Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My Public Portal
About
Ver. Cmplt To Enforce Pub. Recs Act (O'Boyle)
ZO17££ Id `4oea8 weed lsaM 9017£ XOO 'O'd japoildwo0 ,g Malo 11008 11 NO?IVHS woo•uagmelal oqo uum woo•uugmalal oqo soopunooal oqo L080 -09E (b56) :91!tu!soeq 9889-bL9 (b96) :auogdalay ZPKE LPROU gouag PlagiaaQ anpQ .taluao lsodmarl ISOM 98Z I 3313u1E1d alp io3 MaulouV 'O•d uu13 mel apiog,0 Q41 101'l311S la3LLey3 moo ag33o xlalO :Ag +,tro ` ,ilnr uo Q9.LVQ b 10 bZ 'Inf uollilad io luleldwoo aql m papuswap 3allai alp lo3 luepuajop aql lsuls8e paialua Qq [I!A1 3lnuJap s `os op of slle3 luepuajap a 3I "allsaiagl '(lalalpaurwl io ,(auioue silluleld uo amAlas aio3aq jaglla unoo slgl jo �l.talo aql gltm sasua3ap agl3o pu!I. aql alg of pue IaoWas;o dep ag13o aAlsnloxa 'luspua3ap Imp uo suoununs snp;o ao,Atas IOUB s,Cep (OZ) ,iluaml unptm `zbb££ apuo13'gaea9plagiaaQ `9AlJ ialuoD liodmajgjsaM 98ZI s! ssatppe asogm `iauioue sdllluleld 8u d uml I!M uo uollllad to luleldwoo aql of sosuajap uaunm Qtags of patm6ai si luspua3ap gong £8b££ ePuol3 `umauS 3lno peog Bos 001 wea.4s}1n03o umo.1 :luepua3ap uo 1lns mel slgl ui lun ldwoa aql;o idoa a pus suouauns sap aAias of Qgamvjt wow RNV 1'10A TR- o -WW f,S 9QS:l1 ,; � '...I'�e — L :•ort �sVo NOISIAIQ'IIAIO VMO I9 A.LNIlOO HOV3g Inl'IVd 1109 QNV NI lXflO0 A.LNnoo alll NI :alalS ag33oiPlagS qwa oy VQRI0'I3 30 3.LV LS flll.L •luepua3aQ ` va-aSd'In'J 90 NMo.L A `wumd `H'IAOg,O 9 Nil-dVIAI Pus o'I'I `.LNawN-H9AODA.L-dIQdO.LS Wd LS:OZ30 VIOU£Z/LO Patld .tu3Tuoalaa13 6ILtLZ9I # O�41!3 ++++'RI :NOISIAIQ 6Z98003OtIOZ :ldggWMi gSVD ++++ Filin.- # 16274719 Electronically Filed 07/23/2014 05:20:57 PM IN THE COUNTY COURT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY FLORIDA STOPDIRTYGOVERNMENT, LLC and MARTIN E. O'BOYLE, CIVIL DIVISION Plaintiff, VA TOWN OF GULFSTREAM, Defendant. CASE NO.: VERIFIED COMPLAINT TO ENFORCE FLORIDA'S PUBLIC RECORDS ACT AND FOR DECLARATORY RELIEF The Plaintiff, STOPDIRTYGOVERNMENT, LLC and MARTIN E. O'BOYLE, (the "Plaintiff'), by and through the undersigned counsel, hereby sue TOWN OF GULFSTREAM ("Defendant") and states: 1. This action concerns the Defendant's violation of Plaintiff's civil rights pursuant to Article I, § 24 of the Florida Constitution and Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, (the "Public Records Act"). 2. This action seeks declaratory and equitable relief. 3. Specifically, Plaintiff seeks an order declaring the Defendant to be in breach of its constitutional and statutory duty to permit access to public records, and compelling the Defendant to provide access to the requested public records, and awarding Plaintiff attorney's fees and costs. Additionally, Plaintiff requests this matter be expedited, upon motion by Plaintiff, pursuant to § 119.11 (1), Florida Statutes. Z 6 •solnlulS EPPol3 '611 jaldugO3o suolslAoad oql japun (;Iao•weails;Itt;I'@i aagsE nllq) lE luepua3aQ of I!Ewa VIA lsanb;)N spi000N otlqnd a paAlwgns `al,Cog,O -g uiueyq '33l1uleld b IOZ `6Z XEW lnoge ao uO -I I •solnlelS epuo13 '61 I aaldegO3o suotslAold oql aapun (Vao-wea.ns 31tt;I'yC�i tol,Ceu) le luepuoj*Cl of Itewa VIA isanbag spxooa21 oggnd e palllwgns '•O"1"I .LNfl WN'H9AODAINIOdOIS 33llululd b I OZ '0£ �E W lnoge to uO '01 •salnlElS Epuol3JO 611 aaldegO aapun spaooaa of ssaaae aplAoid of pa.ttnba.t s! '.toua2E agqnd ase 'una.ilS jln f jo umol agl 'luEpuaJaQ .6 S.LNllOO'I'IV O.L LNVA3'I" SIDV1 -paAiem io posnoxo uaaq aneq to paim000 aneq uolloe stgl of luopooaid suoll!puoo IIV '8 -SiunoD goeag wled u, paleool si ssaulsn43o aaeld IEdlouud s,luepua3aQ oql osnEaaq slq$u ltnto s jjyuteld aql jo uollealpulA atll joj onuaA aleudoldde otll st l.moO slgZ -L ')BIS 'eld 11'611 § PuB 'uollnlllsuOD epuo13 agl3o (q)g § 'A aIol1-tV of luensind uoilolpsunf iallew loafgns seq lanoO slgy -q 'ILLS 'Eld `(Z)110'61 1 § u! paugap s! ural letli se ,,KouagE„ ue s! luepua3aQ S •uopnipsuoO epu013 0111Io bZ § 'I •11V pue salnlelS Epuol3 '611 n1degO3o suolslAo.td aql of luensmd spi000 t oggnd jo 5upWoo pue uopoadsui aql of pallqua sEm olaaaq luenalat sawtl IlE le pue luaplsai epuolg E .to 'epuold ut ssaulsnq op of pa.talstgol 'uolleiodtoo epuo13 a st (, gme[d„ se,ClaAllaa11oa)g•IAOBA'gNldVWPueO"II',LNHWNNgAODA.L?IIQdOLS 'b HfINHA QNV NOLLOIQSINflf `Sal L2IVd 12. Both of the Requests advised the Defendant to provide in writing any statutory exemptions, to provide the appropriate citation for any such exemption and to clearly articulate in writing the rationale for asserting such an exemption. 13. The Requests asked for public records as that term is used and defined in Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, including § 119.011(12) Fla. Stat. and Art. I, § 24(a) of the Florida Constitution. 14. Defendant has failed to acknowledge or respond to these requests in a legally sufficient manner. 15. The only responses received are pre -typed standard Town of Gulf Stream letters if stating that the Town will respond in a reasonable amount of time. 16. No further communications regarding these requests have been received from Defendant's to date. COUNT I — UNLAWFUL WITHHOLDING OF PUBLIC RECORDS 17. Plaintiff re -alleges and incorporates by reference the above numbered paragraphs 1 through 16 as if fully alleged herein. 18. Defendant, as an agency defined in § 1 19.011(2), Fla. Stat. owes a duty to allow access to any person to all public records within its control pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 119.01(1) unless specifically exempted by the Florida Constitution. 19. Plaintiff made a public records request, request ID# 569, for "all Public Records which contain any one of the following words: "O'Boyle ", "Boyle ", "Morgan ", "Toohey ", "Drouin ", "Deemer", "Minor", "Randolph ", "Sweetapple ", dated starting August 1, 2013 through the date of this Request" which is attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit A. 3 13 pan!em 10 pasnoxa uaaq `poun000 aneg uo!lou slgl of luapooaad suoil!puoo IV -0£ '(l)I F611 uo!IaaS 'IBIS 'vu aaS •Suuuaq alu!pawun ao3 las aq lsnw jallew s!rly'6Z •Io.quoo sl! u!glpm spioaai oggnd Idwaxa-uou ssaooB ylpmJJllu!BId ayl 2urpmoid apnlou! yo!gm `sa!lnp sl! uuopod Iuupua3aQ IBIBls!su! of 11421P legal iuolo e sBg3J14u!eld '8Z (• infu! aygnd olquiedoni ue solnl!Isuoo paleloln uaaq seg mel oql 1Bgl �julmogs araw agl legl $ulPlog)(OIOZ bOQ Is 'Bld) OOZ `£61 P£'oS I £ •,L !�ysdnaD aaS Crnfu! o Ignd olgendoiui ue salnlllsuoo -IBIS 'Bid `LO'611 uo!IoaSdo uollBloln 'LZ 'spIomA331 ayl a03 Yonas asugBlup ialndwoo oldwrs a gl!m ueds owq hogs u u! palaldwoo Xllu!lued uaaq aneg pinoo Isonba.r ayy '9Z •uuuy ainlry JO pooy!laN!l u smg2ns lonpuoo s,luupua3aQ pue uuug PIcIamdaui ue solnlgsuoo spiooa.r oggnd jo Ie!uop ayy'SZ lad spioaa21 aygnd s,Bpuold Aq palulduialuoo se ssaooe 3o lusrgaa jo Bulplogylrm Injmulun ue alnl!Isuoo spiooar palsonboi aql gulp!noid u! Sulap 2uloguo s,luupua3aQ 'bZ 'spi000i palsonboi agl of olquo!lddu uo!ldwoxo Rolnlels ou pal!:) luupua3a4 ogy'£Z .lob, spiooag oggnd s,Bpuold iapun polduma lou aae palsanbaa},!!lu!uId spiooa.r agy'ZZ meI aseo pags!lqulso-Ilam puu -IBIS etd `(B)(l)LO'6l I§ `uo!lnl!Isuo� epuold agl;o bZ§ `I alo!Lrd3o uo!leloln ul sp.rooaa palsonbai agl3o sa!doo glrm JJ!luleld ap!nold of posrgol 1i uaym Xjnp sl! palBlo!n Iuepua33Q ' I Z '$ I!glgxa aaS •awy3o lunowu algeuosuaa a u! puodsaa II!m umoy aql IBg3 2u!luls t,,OZ `1 aunt palep jallol weazlS 31nD jo umoy p upuels padrll-aid u s! `alep of pan!aoa.l asuodsai kluo oqy •0Z RELIEF REQUESTED WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays this Court: (a) Set an immediate hearing pursuant to § 119.11, Florida Statutes; (b) Declare that the Defendant's failure to provide Plaintiff with access to the requested public records was unconstitutional and unlawful under Article I, § 24 of the Florida Constitution and the Public Records Act; (c) Order the Defendant to allow the inspection, copying and photographing of the requested records; (d) Award Plaintiff its reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and expenses incurred in this action, as provided in § 119.12, Florida Statutes; and (e) Grant such further relief as the Court deems proper. COUNT II — UNLAWFUL WITHHOLDING OF PUBLIC RECORDS 31. Plaintiff re -alleges and incorporates by reference the above numbered paragraphs 1 through 16 as if fully alleged herein. 32. Defendant, as an agency defined in §119.01 1(2), Fla. Stat. owes a duty to allow access to any person to all public records within its control pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 119.01(l) unless specifically exempted by the Florida Constitution. 33. Plaintiff made a public records request, request ID# 574, for "all Public Records which contain any one of the folloxling ivords: ' fdot ", "DOT", " FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (INCLUDING ANY OF THE WORDS WHICH ARE ABBREVIATED IN ANY FASHION) ", " Transfield Services "Brett Drouin (including any other party that is commonly known as FDOT) ", "Morgan ", " Totdtey ", "Boyle ", "O'Boyle ", "Hidden ", 5 '(011-611 uopaaS le,g "eld aag 2uueay a,etpawwt io3 las aq,snut aauew situ "£b •lojluoo sl[ utgltm sploaal at lgnd ldwaxa-uou ss000e 97th+33uuteld ayl 2utptnmd apnlaut gatgm `satlnp slt uuojlad luepugjaQ Imp lstsui of lq'ou legal ieala a seyPluteld "Zb (•fantut oggnd olqumdaitt ue salnlusuoa pa,elotn uaaq seq mel aql ley, &smogs alaw gill legl $utPiotl)(OIOZ VZ)d Is "elA) OOZ 'E61 P£'oS I £ 'U174onlV o iUJj 'n h/sdv D oaS -fantut atlgnd algetedaut ue salnitlsuoa •le1S '919 `LO"61 I uot,aaS 3o uotlelotn • I b •spIomdail aq1 103 yaaeas asegelep nindwoo oldwts a ilitm ueds awtl Ilogs a ut palaldwoa X11sp.ted uaaq aneq pinoo lsonbai ail 1, -op -Limit ain,n33o pooygailq a sis;Mns ,onpuoa s,4uepua3a4 pue uuuq olgeiedaut ue salnitlsuoo spaoaaa oggnd jo letuap aqy "6£ •lay spioaa-1 atlgnd s,epr_co1:j Xq pa,eldwaluoo se ssaaae do lestyatlo fjutploggltm ingmelun ue olnitlsuoo spiooat pa,sanbai aql f?utptnotd w Xulap outoguo s,luepu3p(] -g£ -spt000l palsonbai ay of algeotldde uotldwoxo faoltyels ou paha luepua3aQ oqs "L£ -toy spaoaag atlgnd s,eptxolA spun pa,dwoxa lou On pa,sonboi jjtlutEld spaooa.t agZ "9£ •mel oseo pailsgge,so-Ilam pue •lelS "EIA *0(00-611§ `uotlnlusuoD eppolA all) JO bZ§ `I alatuy3o uoyelotn III SPS0391 palsonbal ag13o satdoo gltm33tluteld aptnoid of poslt}ai,t uaym Xinp sit palelotn luepua3aQ "S£ 'Q 3lglyx3 oas 'awtl jo,unoum olgeumal a ut puodsal lltm umo L oqj legj 2Ittlels `b IOZ V aunt polep laual wea.gS 3lnD 3o umoy paepuels podAl-old a st `a,ep 01 pantaaw osuodsaa Iuo oq j •l,£ 'D itgnlxa se utaiaq pa,etodtoout pue olazaq pagaeue St gonlm ,IuvdjjSflilD J0 11410,E alp fb dvm fo-lll, lm alp Ill SuffIS io1p n sloaigo of da/ba yolynl pun isanbay styl fo olvp alp y8n0J111 f IOZ '! ls11811y 8ulljvls pat0p ',,.moq roN„ 44. All conditions precedent to this action have occurred, been excused or waived. RELIEF REQUESTED WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays this Court: (a) Set an immediate hearing pursuant to § 119.11, Florida Statutes; (b) Declare that the Defendant's failure to provide Plaintiff with access to the requested public records was unconstitutional and unlawful under Article I, § 24 of the Florida Constitution and the Public Records Act; (c) Order the Defendant to allow the inspection, copying and photographing of the requested records. (d) Award Plaintiff its reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and expenses incurred in this action, as provided in § 119.12, Florida Statutes; and (e) Grant such further relief as the Court deems proper. Respectfully submitted, Dated: July 23 .2014 THE O'BOYLE LAW FIRM, P.C. Attorneys for Plaintiff 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Telephone: (954) 570-3510 Facsimile: (954) 360-0807 For Service of Court Documents: 0 0 le urtdocs obo lelawfirm.com By: ie William Ring, Esq. Florida Bar #961759 wringRoboylel awfrrm.com :paonpoid uoileogqu3P13o ad t L :uo)leo9puopl paonpoid g0/ :umoux Xlleuosaad :aleatput aseald ("IVHS) "Zr�if 7� :laud VOI1I019 90 91VIS OIl9fld AIJVION wm'a�u�SAnnoNeP!bId C51P66C ILOH MZ 'n IPdv S3aIdX3 b' 4tZ1B033 q NOISSIWWOO AjN k_ B31HOw u lllr !' 'H upnW Xq fi l OZ ` 3o XeP P'�Z sigl aw aiojaq paquosgns pue 'pouut_ju ol LuomS ( QZIVMO?I$:IO.LINfl00 SS ( VQIUO'I3 10 d.LV.LS al oH�O'g ucuey� :auteN ;agaq pue 'uolleuuojul 'o2palmou,l scq jo mq aql of laa.uoa pus ann si pue 'unq of umou� uolleuuOJul pus splooaa uo paseq sf LN]VrldNOD G31AMA slgl legl sties pue sosodap'uioms pug pagquop! flnp lsig gu)aq `ogm'31409,0 .fl utueyv paleadde,(lleuosiad'L(luoglnu pauS)slapun acll `flyg 3-IOdflfl Q2IVMO'HS LIO A.LtMOZ) VORIO'I3 30 3.LV.LS NOLLVOIAINaA Exhibit A Naoa c i •ZZ'va Uvawd:l •dauaBV aql dq aolsanbag aqq of posodwl slsoo duo to aauunpu ul'((suollluga(j) 10'611 aalduyO'agnlElg EPIa0id ul pougap sE) dauaBV ayl sq palaassE'slsoa 'CUB JO aeoaddu jolsanball aqj layl pa.11nbaa aq 111m lI 'HONVAQV NI .LSanbad SCrdoDaZI Ol'Iflnd SIH.L'1'II3Illd OS (ANv AD SSSOO SSVINIXOZIddV HHS aQIAOZId HSVS'ld AZIHAI'ISQ'HVn-S AH SMHS SH OZ uaSaajjuatj SZIV SSIdOO OINOZISOH'IH I IV Z E 6LO'6lfuall30SHum HONVQZIOOOV NI Q21'119 SE u MORS QNY QSQ/S OMS SS (1'IfIOHS SHMOO SHS SZfiISSOdWl SSH'INflSHSVO I I V+NI :S.LON 'ZISdVd LI X II NO QS'1713'If13 SE.LSHn SZI SQZIOOSZI SIHS IVILL QHSSHn HZI SI SI WHoa OINOILLOH'IH NI H'IRVZIVAV LOM M 'Mod OINOZISOS7S NI OS'1'lldlnd H8 ,EBBW SZI SQZI OSZi SIHS SVHS QSSSHn HZI SI SI - 'AIOLLnSISSNOO VQIuO a HH.L Ni QHQIAOZId ZIOSSHnbHZI HHS d0 S.LHJRI HHS OS SNVf1SNnd HQVLII May SI.LSHflbHZI SIHS '(aiavOPIddV SV `SSHOOV d0 mom AZIOLfl.LVSS ANV `NOLLV'L'W," SfIOH.LIM'ONIQn7ONL1 MONX OS SHJRI AZIOSfUVSS ANV QNV 'SSHOOV ao SHJRI MV'I NOL1fL oa HHS `MONSI OS SHORI MV'I NOIR NO3 HHS ZIHQNfl QHSSSnbHZI OS'IV SI (INV SSS(LLVSS VGIHOIi HHS dO 6II ZISSdVHO `SOV S(rdo3SZI orialid OS LNVnsufia SQVInI SI SSSflbHZI SIHS :SS3n?m ONIQZIvoau NOLLVNRI03NI 7VNOISiQQV sly to atop ay1 y6nojyl E LOZ ' L lsn6nV 6ullinls palop ajddniaams ydlopuoy AoulNl„ ', 'Jawaaa ,' ulnojd„ ' Aaynol„ '„uo6iol�l„ '„aldog 'ado s mm ., 1 90 .., P 6ulmopoq a41Io auo duo uloluoa yalym spAoaay a!19nd Ilo to saldoo apuo�d %SS3nbaH Z6b££ 'I3'yaa2g pfa3raaQ'annQ JaluaO podmaM mm O8ZI :sSWPPV `L080 -09£-b56 :XU3 waa•dnolR-oolawwoa@spioaaj :IloYq-3 :NOISVINZIOM%U JOVSNOO S.Z1O mnbmd aldo8.O -3 u!IioW dols3nb32I woailsiing io umol spioaaa 40 unlpolsn:) :331S3nbmd 699 :#QI lsanba-d s,jolsmba-d b10Z/6Z/S :7sanbag;oaluQ (,.lsanbay„ ayl) .Lmbn SQ-dooa 1 WorkCentre 5230A Transm i ss i on Report 03 ID Local Plame Logo Doc urnent M1ac Uecn sent. Documal[ $i.e 8. 5'I I"SEF Martin E. O'Boyle 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Telephone: 954-570-3505 Telecopy:954-360-0807 hUA(B:R CFPA6ES II•13l/pIPK TpANSAIIi'TAL /A6E 2 fF 15]U JO NOT D(�A11 Pw6F5, PL£ASEG(1 ADSI-5]U-]5(3 x a,y;„rnu,ari nnr Gwa3.5rCrlrry _PadJ.G-ry _Omrr. Da Tci T:me:CBi 1?/2D:y: Jy:3y PM Page: I ILas: Pagel Total Pav'=s $eann9o: 2 coxal Pages 56n2 _ 1�(J. Dac. PcmD is $iaCi[In Star[ Tlnlc D,,,a,,n FS 9es I..IOpE conLell2$ $SdLV6 1 8292 $dt.3T0'IBJ 5-3?: y: 33?M 2$s 2i _ SG3 CP E Rtc: P.: Pescn(I IS: Sentl LCl r.la: ltlOv. BG: Rr1.Jc SeC `AP: MUI2i Polling FN: RCmote $aTvCe PG: Sen A9 R8: P.Clay BrOa[ICaST P_: Avco Sentl TM: Ton Fas Fpr.varU CP: COmVI1[9U $N: Sentl ngaln ESI: En9a9etl a5: 4u to Smu TM; Te rmi na r_tl TELECOPIER TRANSMITTAL PAGE DATE.' TO: -Rom: x.,u L Vt.tY hUA(B:R CFPA6ES II•13l/pIPK TpANSAIIi'TAL /A6E 2 fF 15]U JO NOT D(�A11 Pw6F5, PL£ASEG(1 ADSI-5]U-]5(3 x a,y;„rnu,ari nnr Gwa3.5rCrlrry _PadJ.G-ry _Omrr. Da Tci T:me:CBi 1?/2D:y: Jy:3y PM Page: I ILas: Pagel Total Pav'=s $eann9o: 2 coxal Pages 56n2 _ 1�(J. Dac. PcmD is $iaCi[In Star[ Tlnlc D,,,a,,n FS 9es I..IOpE conLell2$ $SdLV6 1 8292 $dt.3T0'IBJ 5-3?: y: 33?M 2$s 2i _ SG3 CP E Rtc: P.: Pescn(I IS: Sentl LCl r.la: ltlOv. BG: Rr1.Jc SeC `AP: MUI2i Polling FN: RCmote $aTvCe PG: Sen A9 R8: P.Clay BrOa[ICaST P_: Avco Sentl TM: Ton Fas Fpr.varU CP: COmVI1[9U $N: Sentl ngaln ESI: En9a9etl a5: 4u to Smu TM; Te rmi na r_tl g liqTq-xl TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail June 1. 2014 Martin E. O'Boyle [mailto: records@commerce-group.com] Re: PRR #569 Provide copies of all Public Records which contain any of the following words: "O'Boyle", "Boyle", 'Morgan" "Toohey" "Drouin" "Deemer", "Minor", "Randolph", "Sweetapple" dated starting August 1, 2013 through the date of this Request. Dear Martin E. O'Boyle [mailto: records@commerce-group.com], The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated May 29, 2014. If your request was received in writing, then the first page of that request is attached to this cover letter. If your request was verbal, then the description of your public records request is set forth in the space below. The Town of Gulf Stream is currently working on a large number of incoming public records requests. The Town will use its very best efforts to respond to you in a reasonable amount of time with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records /i r Wro aww Yva/dawaq •/aw.y agl AglolssnbaH aql of paawdwl slaw Raa Ja aanupa a11("ORla" l6'6l tJVA :O *nmg appau ul pamJap n) AaPa2V nql Aq Palaism'nm Auo la awadda AolnnbsH aql layl pup1bal aq IPM ll -mNVAQV in lm &" smI003H Onsnd slut "' 19'1O3 O1(ANY jd s1sO3 aly34uIXOHddYaHl 3Ououa alma a LY 1 ILLW N MmInsaa4alookisa n NOLII),I.Llst1Oa VMHO'L'T RILL NI O3alAOHd HO1Sanb3H ma 30 SLHOiH RH.L (aL.T.MVnq)m,; 3cmq Osw Sl jSjtlp3H smi. '(3imrijay sy,ssmoy ao.LHOIH AuolaxY1s ANY'.YOLLYIm"f lnOH1LU sON uma W mD..,m Ol mord ALOlO.LY.ISANV CKV !SMO V 3O JMIH A\V'I NOagA`OJ 3HL A1ONA OL I WIU mV'I NOIgf4Oa 38L Ha@Hla saantl3H OS'IVst O.qv s3=yas vamo*I3 mu so 611 d3lj":) ',zaY $auom Drama oI xNYnszlna 3qm sc.Lsdtlon SISI. :1s3nb3HOMOHVo3HNOLLvvmolm tvNoluaav L1411a aPap 044 4anan11 C IOZ'L I9n0nV Eullrgs palap atddapamS. •�4dlopubau •�wul(ya •.wwaa0� •� ulnaQ.'.�4na1, :uoeloW.:al•1a9. •.alA°&O. npaon� 5uwallad WI da sua Aun ulaluns ganye apaoslH alignd llo as 111dca 1p1nald :lSgnb3V ZttEE'I3'gaa�8 Plo91bQ`>a?Q iam=3 YroduaN laald OBZ( =.wv1LO2nSE-K6 Taj u>oTdrmlEomwuaa(Djsplwas lIaW3 .N(XLVMQ&aiOV1.VO7S.UolsmOn alA^ejO 3 ulynYl--dol53na3H wnallyln., da uwsol aryoaaH }o uoipolsn0 33]S3L1O3H 69S :40 t nbaH s,wmnhoa �IOZ/6Z/S ]ss'�+HJa n7W U-6:rd--P)1S3t1O3H MO33H :molaq Ou s aql ui pa3npol of sl V I U6 6Z AUIN palap lsan a.l Inui uo moA Exhibit C MdOil tlzrro xaaixawaa •Aaua2V aqI Aq.to4sanball aqI o4 posodw! slsw Auelo aauenpe u!'((suoll!u!!aa) 10-611 ,a)du40'alnjvjS uppo13 III paugap se) A3ua2V aqI Ag p24-lass13'slsoa RUE Io ano Iddu Ao4sanball aqI 413111 pa.nnbaa aq 11!A1 II 'aJNVACV NI1Sanbau 5132IOo32I OI'ififld SIH'L'1'H3 Ma 01(ANV dl) S1SOO a1V WIX021ddV 3H.L aalA021d amu 'XIMIAI'I mu-UVN!-3 AU 1N3S AH OZ C21S3f1 a2I a21V SHmoo Mmou13a7a'I'IV Z ° h LO'6I L °01130S H11M aoNVo2IOJOV Nl (13"'119 2911 IfIOHS 13NV 1131315 OMI 311 11'IflOHS Said00 HIi1 3'19155odWI SSa INfI SHSVO 1 iV NI :310N '2ladtld Li X I1 NO C3Tiid'Ifld 391SaR 32I S132IOJa2I SMI IVFLL CH1Safl Hu SI1I WUO.I JINOZItaa'Ia NI a'I Y11VAV ION 91 'WUOd OIN02I10315 NI anqu'Ifld a915af1 a2I SC210Ja2I SLH.L LVFI.L oH1S3fl 321 Si 11 'NOI1f USNOD valuo'11I aH1 NI aaQIAOUd HOISanba21 HH1 d0 S.LHJ121 all.L O.L.LNVflsufld zam OS'IV SI ZSanaail SIIIZ '(3'IffvDrlddV SV'SSa00V 301.HOI2I AZI01111VSS ANV'AIOI.LV.LIWI'1,Lf10H.I1M'ONIQII'IONI) MONII O L 1.H012I A210 LL1.LV,LS ANV CNV !SSHOOV aO 1110rd MV'I NOWWOJ HBI'MON}I OS 1HJI2I MVI NOWWOJ 2H1 HHCN1l Ca1S3naa2l OS IV SI CNV Sa1f11V1S valuo Id 3141 HO 611 2I31dVH0 '1.JV S132IOO a JPIfifld O.L 1NVf1S2Ifld a11V W SI 1SafIaa2I snu :1.531ORNONICrdV0321NOLLVW OIM'IVNOIZICCV •woallslin0lo umol a41 to AoM-IO-14611 ayI u! su6!s 10/puo spa,go ollalal 4214M puo lsan all '!91 J- aloe 0y1 y no141 £LOZ I Isn nV u111n1s palop 1nog1°H„' uaPP!H., '.,alAO9,0„',,alAO9„ Aaynol„', un61oW., '„(load so umou3i AluOUlwOa s! I°qm 10 A11od 1a410 Auo Sulpnl3ui.) u!nolo 11a1g�, ',saa!nlas p!aysuml„ „(NOIHSVd ANV NI (131VIA31199V 311V H:)IHM SGHOM 3H1 JO ANV ONionIDNI) NOI1V18OdSNVHld01N3W1HVd3a VOI21old„'„loo„'„iopl„ :Sp1oM 6UIM01101 6y1 JO auo Auo u!nluoo 43!ym sploaal! a!ignd II° do saidoa aptnold :.Lmb321 Zbb££ 73 `gaeag p!argaaC'QA!101aIua01t°dA%2NlS2M 08ZI :ssalppV !LOSO-09£-b56 :xUd woo•dnw2-2alawwo3@isplo3al :11eW-3 :N011VW210e1N JolvINoosatol53f1b321 MI UMNIMAODAIIII(dO1S '2IO-LMOFH woallslin0 to umol splooall to un!polsn:) :331S3f1U32i VZ5 :#CI Isanball s,lolsonbal! b LOZ/b/9 :Isanbag;o ale13 (,Js2nbaa„a4l),L53LIa3d smdoz d Records From: Records Sent: Tuesday, June 03, 2014 5:29 PM To: rtaylor@gulf-stream.org Subject: Public Records Request #574 Attachments: GS RECORDS REQUEST #574 6.03.14.PDF Please see attached Public Records Request Q lTqiqxl TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail June 4, 2014 Stopdirtygovernment, LLC [mailto: records@commerce-group.com] Re: PRR #574 Provide copies of all Public Records which contain any one ofthe following wards: ' dot", "DOT", "FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (INCLUDING ANY OF THE WORDS WHICH ARE ABBREVIATED IN ANY FASHION)", Transfteld Services", Brett Droitin (including any other party at what is conmronly (mown as FDOT) ", "Morgan". "Touhey", "Boyle", "O'Boyle", "Hidden", "Harbour" dated stating August 1, 2013 through the date of this Request and which refer to objects and/or signs in the right-of-way of the Town of Gulfsuram.. Dear Stopdirtygovemment, LLC [mailto: records@commerce-group.com], The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated June 3, 2014. If your request was received in writing, then the first page of that request is attached to this cover letter. If your request was verbal, then the description of your public records request is set forth in the space below. The Town of Gulf Stream is currently working on a large number of incoming public records requests. The Town will use its very best efforts to respond to you in a reasonable amount of time with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records Mod T1Ti 10 ml'a [` ri •13ua9E aqa .iq>wao6a)J aqa 11 pa:adog ocoa lou Jo a>owpc v1 y(sooapu3a� 1016TT aaldaga blulu5 cpuog m pav3ap :u).6aa7E aqa A pauas:u'-asua lac Jo aawddc aoa:au6sa aqj :..p paaln6aa aq IHas II 33,'F_1QF' -�715ilb7u S(raOJ3H )rIH1d SML TUXLU 01 U.VV AD SISOJ 31k7MOHaaV Mu 3(ILIOXd 3Sk37d '.i'.I3ll73Q 7h7C-3 Sfl li) (9 l S 3H Ol Sit 38 31IF 53IdOJ JL\01iLJ313'Ilk' }JLO'6 I naq»5 113 \7'QH JJk V Q3TH8 3H Q"L10H5 Q.VF Q3Q[S 011130 Q'L2OH5 5 doaSSOOKI 5. L 5 'J T11r Y1310\ 3dF' L \li4 Q 13 Tffi 5 SIILI1k73j Q315i1 3b SI lI'ICa03 JL40U.jJ373 �131Hk-IIl'.kY 10� 3I ' 1801 JLCOHIJ 3H ;531 3'1S OJ k 5 1 SI \OIL+ITI.LSSOJ Ymao- 3 311 u (I3('L101d 101531631; 3ILL 30 simm 3HL Ol jxva5lma 3Qk7C OM SI TMb31 SIHS '(3'I8FJI7ddB SF'S53JJF 30 LH9I1S101!1LFSS .Wv `KOILFIIICfI MON-1 O1IH5ffi.IiIOLq1F.i5 _lKv Q.\�F 1S53JOt 30 SH9I1,11FI \OICI1[OJ 3HI.',110zY 01.IH'JRI,11k'I 40IUCOJ MI ma5LI cru 3il631 OSW SI Q.!'k' S31s11Y15 Fcmu073 Mal 0 6II lII1dt733 'I.JTa SQHOJ31 Jnvd SIH.I -- �j53n2)3vaJh7QH1'0311 NOi1V7\2a0iNI71'NOIIIOQI' wowlsJlM Jo uMoj ay1 Jo Aouyo-14ap ayl uJ suals m/puo s Pa1nP .anagJDH.%.uaPPM..slAn0.0..'IAnH.'.Asgnoj_ •.uosagW...(jGQd so uaaouq Aluounuw sl lny,n In AVad Jaylo AMD BulpnPul) ulMla Haag. >a>j,,SS p1miluwj. '.(NOIHSW ANY M 03LVIA3a22V 31Y HJIHM WHOM 311 i0 ANY OMOnIJNO NOUV1aOdSNVaj i01N3WINYd30 VOlaO14.'..100.'.1opl.:spanan 0upaoll°1 oyl In aue Auo uleluos yvyM spaoaaa >.lgnd Ila J^ said- apinwd °IS3IM3E i:YC£ 73'gscaH P[a3�aaQ'aa+aQ+aavaJ uodnaKra�y 0.gi.l+ppY -LOSO'0pI-}S6 —1 mord'aa na "nnn"'n pmaaa .'nc1<.3 :NOUvA-E03A71JvlN0j S.N015�11D3E J71'1NMMA09A1a10dO1S 301P-na32 u'uaalaJlnO In uanaj spao>aa 1u uolPWsaJ m.L5'anb=-x bL5 :� Ismbag : �ot:anbay bIOZ/E/9 a-'au7+ap Jo as(j C -7-Y a9+) 15'a11?)3L* s0aoJ35 :Mo)aq aaa s ayJ Qi paonpol al s!bIOZ £ aunt palep Jsan a1)ew uolnoA L99b-ZOtr££ epuol,J Veeg wled IS9M L997 X09 'O"d japojjdwoO,R �aa10 >1009'2I NOIJVHS V 91 �'ONHSdO VC[MOT3 `A.LM00 HDVHEI NIZdd -I03 QAIH Aa.LIf102II0 gVIOIQflf RL5I mu A0 .LMOD'UnD2II0 HNI m moo•migmetainogo ioiala moo•mmimalai oqo @ saoplinoaai oqo L080-09£6756) :QrmTsoad 9889-7L9 6796) :auogdalaZ Z77££ aPuoid `goaaH PlagzaaQ anuQ.talua0 lrodmaX IsaM 98Z I d3;lTZIUId aql IOJ s,Samolly •O•d uLgq mal ai,Cou,O etLL .iapuad Eggog aano0 21P JO =pato 7IOZ £T Nflf uo QHLv(j mol ined .to luTeldmoo aql uT papuemopp, O:t agl io3lm;Pua3aP 91P3suTa�a paJalua aq IIIm llnaTap a `os op of site; laepuajap a II •.ta$emogl dlaleipammT io Xamonu s,Uqum d uo aoutas aiopq to pp Imoa stgl;o :pajo aql gltm sasaa3ap agl3o p aIjuo aql aiTl 03 pus aotntas;o Sap oql}o anTsnioxa `luepua3ap IMP uo suomums sTgl3o aotnaas zatla s,fap (OZ) 63uaml tmUTA, `Z76££ apuoid `goaaH piazptaaQ 'anuQ ialua0 liodmapT Mi& 98GT sT ssatppe asognA `,Camollu s jj, Id `iol,Say > 31& uo uo4pd io lululdmoo ail of sasoopp uallum auas of pamibai sT luepua;ap gaaH £S7££ aPT-told `mea4s3lnC) peog u2s 00 meazys3rngjo umo.L atiL wepu032p uo lms mai sTgl m lmaidmoo aql;o (do:) a pua moununs sTgl antas of QHQ1lyyti OD adV fIOA sN 0 ximf,ss :alelS atR3oHUagS Elm 01, VCMO'I:l30 H.L6'.LS an luepua3aQ �j KVHNJ Sd'mo 30 ATMOS HHZ •n loupid "DWA"CIN100 NOI.LISI bov 00 q NIdOZ:0ES0t'IOZlZI/90PRIASReaNWaa[giOL9901#lrugrq +*** Otl'NOISIAIQ EZILOOVOPIOZ Z33GYM HSYJ +s** i 3 tc a r 0 0 0 z PC cu 0 0 n r MI 4 CG ACQUISITION COMPANY, INC., Plaintiff, V. THE TOWN OF GULFSTREAM Defendant IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO.: 2014-CA007123 AG COMPLAINT TO ENFORCE FLORIDA'S PUBLIC RECORDS ACT AND FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF The Plaintiff, CG ACQUISITION COMPANY, INC., ("Plaintiff"), by and through the undersigned counsel, hereby sues, THE TOWN OF GULFSTREAM ("Defendant"), and states: 1. This action concerns the Defendant's violation of Plaintiff's civil rights pursuant to Article I, § 24 of the Florida Constitution and Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, (the "Public Records Act"). 2. This action seeks declaratory and equitable relief. 3. Specifically, Plaintiff seeks an order declaring the Defendant to be in breach of its constitutional and statutory duty to permit access to public records, and compelling the Defendant to provide access to the requested public records, and awarding Plaintiff attorney's fees and costs. Additionally, Plaintiff requests this matter be expedited, upon motion by Plaintiff. pursuant to § 119.1 1(1), Florida Statutes. ;rq!tlxa se pagoe4e sr ,Qouuaa;uTBW 2rtrpling„ se papoo uopoesuen 6IOZ fjenuer 13— saot;o13sueq letouaug it sapoo luepuajgC[oq;;eq; smouy�guMull I T •Saxe; 2ttpajaua2 anuanaj We ,iatj; jatpW „`sIsoD ... ;asl3o SIlura red„ gotgm saa;;ou aje •ola `smatnaj UPId;!s saaueusn q;rm polu!oosse „saa;„ aq;;etp s;oadsns giJUI13Id •01 •uopoe;uaunrjano2 orU!aads mog 2mutmaas „sasoo aq; Iasjjo ,Slruwud„ o; am .(atg jag;ej `anuanaj as!aj o;;ou aas 2u! !mjad garN pa;e!aoss13 sa23 ag; `uopnlosag atg jad „ sosuadxa peagjano pa;slaj pare auM•l;eas MIAO.L3o SISoa atp las-;}o ille.;mcl o; Xnss000u se lanojdds juauidotanap„ jo•I saa3 a p sias uognlosaZl aq;;o I uogoaS (uonnlosag„ atp) L -I IO aot;nlosag passed;uepua3aQ `I I0Z `8 IudV uO '6 S.LNnoD TIv O,I..Lnlvna'Ia2I SZovi •panr13Nx jo posnoxo uaaq an13q io paun000 anaq uor;os s!tll o;;uapaoajd soot;rpuoo [ry '8 •.(lunoO goeag utled ur pa;eool sr ssamsn43o aoeld p:drouud s,iuepua3a(j atg asneoaq s;g2u I!n!o sJILIu!ald olR3o uogaorpmn aql TOJ anuan a;eudojddu arp sr uttoO s!ql •Z 'IBIS •1313 '11'611 § Pue `uoR1414suOD aPuol3 aq;3o (q)S § `A a[alajv o;;uensmd uoyorpsunf jauem;oa fgns suq ImoO s!qy •9 'IBIS 1313 `(Z)I IO'6I I§ ul pamllap st uua; latg se ,,Soua2a„ ue si olajag;uenalaj satin; lip ]e pus A4tprdroTunuj apuo13 a st;uepua3aQ S •uogn4gsuoO13pu01d atll JO 4Z § `I W Puu sa;n;e)S epuor3 '611 ja;dugOdo suotsrnoid atp o; luensmd spjooaj a!lgnd jo 2up0oa pus uopoodsai at{; o; paj;pua sem ojajaq;uenalaj sarin; llu in pug %puol3 u! ssamsnq op o; paja;st2aj Iuoleiodioo BP!101313 sr (, Jj!;ur13ld„) •oul ` mdmoO uop!srnbay rJO ti aMaA C[KV AIOI.LJIQSRIIIf `S3jZIIVd 12. Plaintiff also knows that the Defendant's budget reflects itemized expenses or income using Defendant's financial coding, including expenses expressly related to "Building Maintenance." The Defendant's Balance Sheet & Cash & Budget Report (As of February 28, 2014) demonstrating the Defendant's budget line itemization is attached as Exhibit B. 13. The Town's balance sheets code income from `Building Permits," however the Defendant has ceded all building permitting to the City Delray Beach via inter -local agreement. The inter -local agreement is attached as Exhibit C. Plaintiff was and is unable to identify the precise line item in the Defendant's budget that accounts for income stemming from the Resolution. 14. Plaintiff is attempting to "follow the money" regarding permitting and expenditures because he believes that the cost of permitting is unusually high, miscoded or hidden in the Defendant's budget, and acts as a revenue generator rather than an offset. 15. Plaintiff submitted a series of public record requests to Defendant to investigate this anomaly. The Defendant has not produced a single record regarding the location or movement of funds stemming from the Resolution. Defendant has collected fees pursuant to the Resolution in 2012 and 2013. COUNT I — UNLAWFUL WITHHOLDING OF PUBLIC RECORDS (The First Request) 16. Plaintiff re -alleges and incorporates by reference the above numbered paragraphs 1 through 15 as if fully alleged herein. 17. On May 13, 2014, Plaintiff submitted the following request to Defendant (the "First Request'): Provide all government records which demonstrate where the funds received pursuant to Section 1 ofResolution 011-7 were placed during each of2012 and 2013. yoy spiooag aggnd am pvu uopnlpsvoO epnoi3 ag13o bZ § `I 010-W aapmt lrgmupm Pub luuopnitlsumun sum spaooa.r otlgnd palsanbw aq; o; SSaaae gllm_gpuleld apinoid o; 23n1183 s,luepua3aQ Dip 1ug1 aielaaQ (q) `•saInI87S BPPOT `i 1'6I I § of luunsmd Bmtuaq alutpawrm ue IDS (e) :lmoO slrll s,Cusd ffllumlcj a-d0jaHaHM QmsSanbauaanau •met epuo13 iapun o; Pappua ST aq uopeluauwooP aq1 Bmnlaoar 1ov Xq uueq olquxudaul Buuagns sIgl;weld 'bZ •n+u7 spo=d atlgnd s,epuol3 Xq Palutdwa;uoo sa ssaaae3o p sryai so Bmplogglrm pyMulun ue salnlpsuoo lsanbag 131T3 aq1 so; splooar palsanbai aq;3o satdoa mi i4uasaidai s jpweld apinoid of psn3ai s,;uupualaQ • EZ sprooai palsanbai aq; o; algeatlddu uopdwaxa Szolnlu;s ou palto;uupva;aQ ayy ZZ -loy spioomg oggnd s,uplioTq iapun paldmaxa jou alu palsanbaxppupid spiooai oqL 'IZ 'mill aseo pagsllqulsa-llam pub 'IBIS '813 `(8)(I)LO'61 i § `uOrT 4psuOD epuol3 OLD JO tiZ§ °I alallnd30 uojlelotn ut spzoaai palsanbai aql;o satdoa glrm.grlmeld apinoid of posrgai 1! uogm 14np slt palulorn luepua)jaQ 0G not;nlpsnoO upuoi3 agl,iq pa;dmoxa Xlluogroads ssalun (1)10"611 § 'I81S -Bid of;vunsmd lo>;uoo s1t utgltm splooaz atlgnd 118 of uosaad Gua of ssaaoe motlu ol6lnp u samo •lulS •ula `(Z)I 10'611§ w Paugap A`OBu uu su `;uepua3aQ •61 Q ltgtgxa se pagoellu sl °Isanbai p;ptut aql sapnlam gatgm `asuodsai s,luupua;aQ „ puodsa r of isoo palnunJsa uv -to asuodsa r woudo.rddo aye yltat aunt fo lunowv algDuosnaJ D ut noif of puodsad of spoffa isaq efiaa sJr asn 111,1 untoL ayL„ leq; pub spioaai jo lunowu a2ml 13 Bmtpuuq sum It lugl pastnpe;uupua3aQ aril t,,OZ `St ,Celnl uO '8I i� (c) Order the Defendant to allow the inspection, copying and photographing of the requested records; (d) Enjoin the Defendant from denying access to records which are subject to the Public Records Act: (e) Award Plaintiff his reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and expenses incurred in this action, as provided in § 119.12, Florida Statutes; and (f) Grant such further relief as the Court deems proper. COUNT II — UNLAWFUL WITHHOLDING OF PUBLIC RECORDS (The Second Request) 25. Plaintiff re -alleges and incorporates by reference the above numbered paragraphs 1 through 15 as if fully alleged herein. 26. On May 13, 2014, Plaintiff submitted the following request to Defendant (the "Second Request"): Provide all government records which demonstrate the use of the funds collected pursuant to Section 1 of Resolution 011-7. This request is for each of the Years 2012 and 2013. 27. On May 15, 2014, the Defendant advised that it was handling a large amount of records and that, "The Tows: ivill use its very best efforts to respond to you in a reasonable amount of time with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. " 28. On May 28, 2014, Defendant responded, "Be advised that no such records exist." This response, which includes the request, is attached as Exhibit E. 29. Defendant, as an agency defined in §119.011(2), Fla. Stat. owes a duty to allow access to any person to all public records within its control pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 119.01(1) unless specifically exempted by the Florida Constitution. JadoJd su7aap }moo agl se 3al1aJ Jago g tions luriD (I) puu `.sainitgS uPllol3 `ZI'6T T § Eq papinoid se pon slgl ut paunoui sasuadxa pue `sisoo `sag; s, fatuous algeuosvw snq i311ututd P.TUA'Ld (a) :ioy spJooa21 oggnd agi of loofgns om golgm spJ000i of ssaoou dulduap utoJ; lnnpugja(I agl ulofug (p) `.spzooaJ palsanbaJ otg jo OuglduJOologd pun 2ml(doo togoadsm agi mollu of luupua3aQ alp JgPJO (a) `.iod spJoomd ollgnd aql pue uognigsuo0 nppoi3 agl do bZ § `I olowV Japun pgn elun pun In= nlgsuooun sum spioom ollqnd palsanbai agl of ssaoou qlvmputeld apinotd of amllu3 s,luepuajoG aql lutD aJuloaQ (q) `.Salm IS 12P!1011 '1 I'61T § of luunsmd 2uunag olpipounm ue laS (e) :lmo0 slgl s CuJdtluteld `fl2T03�I3FIM aal isanoma 3a-iriau mal npuo1d Japun of pgpllua sl aq uoquluaumoop agl 5ulnlaoai lou dq uueq olquJudaul 2upogns sl $!7u�Td -17C •mn7 spJooag oilgnd s,epuol,3 Xq paleldmoluoo se ss000e jo lusnjoi Jo 2ulploggilm lnymnpm uu saimpsuoo lsanbag puooaS aql Jo3 sptooaJ palsanbaJ agl jo saldoo angeluasaidaJ sUqululd apinoJd of lusnjoi s,iuupuojo -C£ spJoaaJ palsanbaJ agl of algeogddn uogdmaxo faolnluls ou pallo luupuojo(J agy'ZE qoy spJooag ollgnd s,eppo13 Japun paldmaxa lou aJn palsanbaJglluletd spJooaJ ags T £ •mul aseo pagstlquiso-Ilam pup •lulS TI3 `(u)(I)LO'6I I § `vogn411suo0 npno13 agl3o 4Z§ `I OIDW. 3o uognloln ut spJoaaJ palsanbaJ agldo saldoa tDvAjjiululd apinoid of pasogaJ 11 uagm dlnp sll paluloln luepua3aQ'OE COUNT III — UNLAWFUL WITHHOLDING OF PUBLIC RECORDS (The Third Request) 35. Plaintiff re -alleges and incorporates by reference the above numbered paragraphs 1 through 15 as if fully alleged herein. 36. On May 13, 2014, Plaintiff submitted the following request to Defendant (the "Third Request"): Provide the budget line item wherein [sic] the funds received in connection with Section 1 ofBesolution 011-7 for the Calendar Year 2012 and also Calendar year 2013 were placed. 37. Surprisingly on May 15, 2014, the Defendant responded with a form, "automatic delay" letter once again informing Plaintiff that the Town will respond in a reasonable amount of time. The response, which includes the request, is attached as Exhibit F. 38. The government record(s) requested in Exhibit F were readily accessible and the production may have taken fewer minutes to complete than drafting Exhibit F. 39. Defendant, as an agency defined in §119.011(2), Fla. Stat. owes a duty to allow access to any person to all public records within its control pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 119.01(1) unless specifically exempted by the Florida Constitution. 40. Defendant violated its dutywhen it refused to provide Plaintiff with copies of the requested records in violation of Article I, §24 of the Florida Constitution, §119.07(l)(a), Fla. Stat and well-established case law. 41. The records Plaintiff requested are not exempted under Florida's Public Records Act. 42. The Defendant cited no statutory exemption applicable to the requested records. 43. Defendant's refusal to provide Plaintiffs representative copies of the requested records for the Third Request constitutes an unlawful withholding or refusal of access as contemplated by Florida's Public Records Law. " w a t t a u l l p a l m t 8 l s a p B o v a w o j f p a p u a d x a j u n o z u v a q ; p u v ' w o . r f p a p u a d a a a a a m F I O Z i n a i ( . r o p u a I D D p u n Z I O Z . a n a p . i v p u a l v D a q ; g j o q - i o f Z - I I o u o g n l o s a g f o I u o l i o a g w o l f p a j o a l l o o s p u n f a g l w a a a q t i ( s w a t : a u : l T o ) w a i l a w l i a S p i q a q ; a p l a o i d : ( , j s a n b a g T i n o 3 a t p ) l u s p m p ( j o f l s a n b w B u l m o l l o 3 a q l p a p l w g n s j p u l e i d t 7 I O Z ` � I A W u O ' 9 6 " u l a s a g p o g o l l ' o A I I n 3 3 I s e S I g B n o s g l I s g d t a s m d p a i a q u m u a n o g e a q l a 3 u a 3 a 3 a s C q s a l w o d a o o u l p u s s a B o l l e - 2 i g I l u l e l d ' S t 7 ( I s a n b a g g p n o d a q j ) S Q 2 I O O a u D i r i m I d 3 0 O h I I ( I ' I O H U J J A i , r M A M V r B M A l J A K M O O " s a d o s d s w a a p l m o D a g l s e ; a l l a s s a g i n g q o n s l u m p ( ; ) P U B ` s a l n l e l S s p u o l 3 ` Z I ' 6 I I � u l p a p i n o s d s e ' u o p o s s t i l l T n p a s m o u l s a s u a d x a p u s ' s l s o o ' s a a 3 s , 6 a w o l l a a l g a u o s e a s s . T t l Z ? l u ? B l d p s s m y ( a ) : 1 3 V s p s o o m d o i l g n d o q l o f l o a C g n s a s s g o t g m s p s o o a s o f s s a m e B u i s u a p w o : g l u e p u a ; a Q a q l u t o l u g ( p ) ' . s p s o o a s p o l s o n b o i a q l ; o B u t g d e s B o l o g d p u s B u a d o o ' u o g o a d s u l a q l m o l l s o f l u s p u n j o ( I a q l i a p s O ( o ) ` t o y s p s o o a g o g g n d a q l P u s u o l l n l g s u o D e p r s o l l a g l ; o b Z � ` I o l o n V s a p u n I T g m s p m p u e l e u o l l n l g s u o o u n s e m s p s o o a s o l l g n d p a l s a n b a s a q l o f s s a o o e g l l m g l l u p ; I d a p i n o i d o f a m l p j s , l u s p u a d a Q a q l I m p a s e l o a Q ( q ) ' ' s a l n l e l S B P u o l d ' 1 1 - 6 1 1 � o f l u s n s m d B u u e a q a l s l p a u m n u s l a S ( s ) : l m o o s a l t s i s l d l ; R u l B l d ` a U o j H M - I A 1 a m s a a b a m d a i r i a u " m u l e p l s o 1 l s a p u n o f p a l l g u a s T a q u o l l s l u a u m o o p a q l B u l n l a o w l o u 6 q m s e q a l g e s e d a s n B u p a j j n s s l g q u F l d ' b b 47. On May 15, 2014, the Defendant responded, notifying Plaintiff that the Defendant will respond to the records request in a reasonable amount of time. But on May 28, 2014, the Defendant responded "no such records exist." The final response, which includes the request, is attached as Exhibit G. 48. Defendant, as an agency defined in § 119.011(2), Fla. Stat. owes a duty to allow access to any person to all public records within its control pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 119.01(1) unless specifically exempted by the Florida Constitution. 49. Defendant violated its duty when it refused to provide Plaintiff with copies of the requested records in violation of Article I, §24 of the Florida Constitution, §1 19.07(l)(a), Fla. Stat. and well-established case law. 50. The records Plaintiff requested are not exempted under Florida's Public Records Act. 51. The Defendant cited no statutory exemption applicable to the requested records. 52. Defendant's refusal to provide Plaintiffs representative copies of the requested records for the Fourth Request constitutes an unlawful withholding or refusal of access as contemplated by Florida's Public Records Law. 53. Plaintiff is suffering irreparable harm by not receiving the documentation he is entitled to under Florida law. RELIEF REQUESTED WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays this Court: (a) Set an immediate hearing pursuant to § 119.11, Florida Statutes; (b) Declare that the Defendant's failure to provide Plaintiff with access to the requested public records was unconstitutional and unlawful under Article I, § 24 of the Florida Constitution and the Public Records Act; M m paunout sasuadxa puu `sisoo `saa3 s,,iauxoue olquuoseax sig j pumld piety (q) :;oy sptooma otlqud alp o;;oafgns asa goigt spioaai o; smon 8utivap mo.g;uepuajaQ aq; ulofug (u) :lmoQ sRp s iead33pmgid `32IOdS-daHjA Qgisgfl giI3ai` au •tel;e,Cpamai algnbape ou seggputuld'SS •pamfut Xtge.mdaut uaaq seg33putuld'LS •oluudosdde si3ailal anpoun fun ;utp Bons Am[je anlgnd alp pue 3lpmuld tpoq o; spiooai onlgnd of ssaoou 30 latuop 30 uuo3 alp ui uueq am;n33o poogilasltl u pup. loy spxooat otlgnd aq; g;it aoueildmoauoudo maugd e salugsuomap atlgnd aq; of spiooai 5mptnoid of loadsai glut suopoe s,;uupua3aQ'95 -Iuupua3aQ aql jo lo.guoo pug Apo;sno aql uttpim ate;ugl ;uepna;aQ alp ;o spiooai anlgnd idutaxa-uou ssaaoe o;;g8u jugol xgala u seq_ ltipid'SS 7ajaq p28allu (Iln33t se £S q;lnotgi I sgduaund pasaqumu anoge agl oouaja3at ,fq soluodmoui pus sogalle-a133putald-Vg 3gl'IaH aMIDNIItNI HOa NOIIDV — A .LNIlOO •.tadozd smaap lmo0 alp sogzilaa.tagltn3 qons luujo W pug `sa;tgels upuold `ZI'6I I § ui Papinoid se `uoilag stip m paunoui sasaadxa pug `s;soo `saa3 s,6auioue algguoseat stg l3puteld piety (a) :3o -gr spjooag otlgnd aq; o;;oafgns aig gotgt spiooat of smn Sm fuap tuag;uupuojaQ otp ulofug (p) `spiooaz palsanbai atp3o ImgdeUo;oqd pua IuuCdoa `uopoodsui alp Colla o;;uepua3aQ atp iapio (a) action, as provided in Section 119.12, Florida Statutes; and (c) Grant such further relief as the Court deems just and proper. Respectfully submitted, Dated: June 12, 2014 THE O'BOYLE LAW FIRM, P.C. Attorneys for Plaintiff 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Telephone: (954) 834-2201 Facsimile: (954) 360-0807 For Service of Court Documents: oboylecourtdocs(@obovlelawfirm.com By: /s/NickTavlor Nick Taylor, Esquire Florida Bar 40051629 ntavlor c0oboylelawfu-m.com E1191HX3 :a.LVa qolrrvi.0,L :a.LVa6. C� b :.LRnOY1V :As aanOuaaV 1 1 'As a3.Lsanb3u e s.ttlnoOV �0ax0 'NOI.LMOsaa AOR HO 1I0J NOLLVNV IdXEI :ssauaaV :amH :OIX0ano anssc Cz a uo.i .isanaau :3.Ltla Bill Thrasher From: customerservices@icma.org Sent. Thursday, January 23,2014 1.2:59 PM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: Receipt N 777 N Capitol Street, NE Suite 500 Washington, OC 200024201 Bill To: William Thrasher Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream Phone: (561) 276-5116 Fax: (561) 737- 0188 Email: bthrasher@gulf-stream.org Order# 52981 Order Date 01/23/2014 Customer ID210818 Ship To: William Thrasher Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Rd Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Phone: (561) 276-5116 Fax: (561) 737- 0188 Email: bthrasher@gulf-stream.org Qty SKU Description _ Unit Price Total Price 1 43639 Management Policies in Local Government Finance, 6th Edition $77.00 $77.00 I I I I Mastercand# xxxxxxxxxxxx9638 U09 Shipping Instructions Subtotal 77 Coupon 0 Discount 0 Tax 0 Shipping 13 Order Total 90 p1wZL-uidg AI2pu9na 66'E$ s}rtuop g LOTH nld asn aseald :aas(youe.lg suotT0 .t}saa uotJdmapa.l .10}. woo•s}nuoout�un0 TISIA .re}}o waapaa o} ap0O y}ua 1,!;" "GI eul 18 :apoO U1111PttleA .1001:1 BVEZ-1.090-9E98040886 :apo0 A@Aang •e}sanoua uxisanu ua aedtnt.}.ied a sowe}tnut al 'JIstA .Inofi }noge sn Ita} pue scep E }xau 841. ut aotnap attgow 10 .la}ndwoo unolc uo woo •utiIunp I La}. -mmm o1 og Z39Vf13A38 U39HVI HO HOI03H V 35MHJUnd n0h N]HM IONOO 33HJ V 1NVM ioN,10 01 ptwZL-wdg lcephaana 66'E$ SIMM] LOZ-11- Hld - asn asea l d :aas1t10ue- •suol}3t.1}sa.1 uot}dwapa.l JO} 11103•slnuo0utlun0 }ts'A .iaJ}o waapaa n} i. ; y}!14 1dta3a.i :.apo0 uut}eptIuA 9VOL-L090-9E980-Loll9 :apo0 1t •e}sanwo is i Isanu ua .ledt314.1ed a su[Ue}tnut al .}tstA _mos }noge sn Ila} pue sR }xau ay} ut aotnap attgow n .tali .1nos uo woo•ut�unplia}•MMM of f.1OVI13130 WOW] HO WOI03W V 35MIMIlld 110A N3HM VINU0 3JUJ V K 10V BH 00'OZ$ ZE'O.L$ OZ$ 4Se0 a6ue40 89'6$ 00'0$ aGu 00'0$ IV 101 }unoos10 u I:a�l 00'0$ :121-01 }wioo: '0$ I 89'6n .Ie. 89'6$ : I e I Ol •qn5 01.7IZ 691 66'L� (It»I :14JO3 L 111•300 Zt L b "L s}nuo0 I 1 F:unn t�supl :.ia 1 yseO B86889L :ON bag uea 1 f.:.la�sto0l0 auauiaslaalJ:u; LLEIML :ON bag ue.11 L:.1a: 886 :AagtunN Aapao LL9 : a;agwnN ABI UI Veil UI T-pj WV AL:LZ:9 VIOZ/f,Z/L y}ao1} a;iel `IV a�`J 1111.1 1002 61� 09:20:9 I%I!I�, ut; L SE98OL11 a.l0i�, y}.1o(� biel 'N a%�V 410L 10M Id 9E9AOEH a.io}S s-lnuoj ut�una n} aW03jaM n I .. " 1 . i 1 > E P R r e I I , ��t i c l ' S q r - S { a n r l t o - 1 I x : ��+ L ��l a 1 L [ 1 ! I G i L c [ T J / f i o a m a y . [ [ U S - + �� �� ����" r a j I n n . o ' �� ` L ! " ' 9 . T . 1 . r 1 P . = T : 1 1 . . T . ��* . : 0 . O a 5 t 3 t M E W - 5 - ' A o A A m " 1 . i 1 > E P R r e I I , ��t i c l ' S q r - S { a n r r u x : ��+ L ��l a 1 L [ 1 ! I G i L c [ T J / f i o a m a y . [ [ U S - + �� �� ����" r a j n n . o ' �� ` L ! " ' 9 . T . 1 . r 1 P . = T : 1 1 . . T . ��* . : 0 . O a 5 t 3 t M E W - 5 - ' A o A A m T TIT aJjelHX3 vLOZ `8Z Aienagaj jo sy paiipneun l'I0dMJ lEjJan9 Q HSVO '8 13AHS 3ON`d-IVO WV3111S :1no ,10 NMOi TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION PAGE(S) CashBalance Sheet............................................................................ 1-2 Budget Report, General Fund...................................................................... 3-6 Budget Report, Water Fund............................................................. 7-8 Budget Report, Undergrounding Fund ................................................ 9 I Was ao,lLL'SS Was anuana!l passaJaa 00 -000 -IDEM -10v Was 00'ooCSLs DOTS sparg almau-4!sod20 00-000-OWZZ-10 00406 IM Was algcRcd nuns= W-000.00,10 IOP IZ'SB9'ZOots Was COOS anaas2gpauela0 00.000-l0Ecc-sSi Bolus 00'05 vl161'9S yly9- anlcng pauala0 00•WO-EOEU-10D Was Was 10'Ovs surpanpa0 oaucrospoyo OD-000-90SIE-100 ODDS WWs WOOEiS ajgEScd=.L Vold DO-ODD40LIZ-100 Was Was vZ'06V9S a!gt(rd tuawmpay paway 00.000-E09 [Z•IDD OPTS Was 90'690'OES algtSrd sa6ell, pa=3V 00-000.109!T:1o0 Was DOTS BE'9Ivi655 punj 1219M 01an0 DO-IOhWLOZ-100 OPTS - Was ZE'L95'IS o!gr•Srd stunnrsy W-00o•WZOZ-I00 nq!Ogcl'E aauclue punj pua ra9111ggZ On'190'ISH'95 ISoOVYfiS'Zs Bfi9BH'101'S slush latus. W'OS (00'969'LSS) Was M-j,d!n63-ada(3 palclmunray DO -OW -06L91 -10b 00'05. 00'BLE'l9s W'as aml!mn-q pur wawd!nlrj 00-000.06991-106 aaas (9ELLE'61LS) Was P191 m'00 duq-aasd30•mn»y 00 -000 -06591 -IP Was ZL'IZ6'BS9'Zs 00'Os -aplg ucgLaaglO stuaunnosduq W'00o•061791-lov 0D'OS St'9v5's5 Was .(IDJWAUJ oa-WO-f0551-IOv Was (OV610'IS) Was =1014 sncM Plcdwd 00.ODD-ED951-100 Dons 16-Z91'IS 00'0s u21PO P!cdxd 00.00D•10551 -10r DOW AC91v'iG55 OPTS pund lw=!) ward anO 00.100-001 El -lop 00'OS 00'OGS'9S o0'os aaledl-aaurmnilV:nn7 W -DOD -IOL I HOP Was IS'B Iv'1S Was sauasay-algs•.s!aaay strnaaaV 00-000-EO511.1 OP 0040S 05'6E6'6v5 Was nlcA(- a!gcyaoaa s7una=V OD•000-I0SI 1.100 vPGLO'IS Was Was algcsa!aag laammssy'oa!la0 00-000-EMI-5Si L9'909'100'ES Was Was a!gae!aaay luawssrtsy W030-I09I1•9SI I EZi9'EE9'ZS Was DOTS V3%q l=I=S-WO 0o'Oo0•ZOIot-951 ZG'89L'vIZ`ZS 0040S Was 6u!gaag0- punj tus(d(asd Punod;npufi. OD -000.10101 -SSI Was 00'05 SL'EE9'ZS VHS -s1=10aal 00-00B.10151-100 Was Was EivS'ES saualuasul 00.000•BOIvI-100 W'as (10'05 WEEDIIS e5cglrO- algmpmay slunaaatl a0•WO•i051I.100 Was Was 00'OOZS gwz)Xuad-q-:) 00-000-IOZ01-lo0 00'05 DOM 9L-EZ9'9501IS VIC1N pun -4 lumog lslutunS- qw3 00-000.60101-100 OD'OS Was LZ'E6E'SS lunamy TUd-tlmj 00.OWL0101-100 00'05 W60S 99'SLv'6985 1unna3V sada-gsu0 00-000.90101-100 OD'0S Bolas I6'ENIMS V1,01 Im1.1 MS- Lino 001000-v0101-tW ons 0060S 1B'EB6'E9ZS 00 ryuausylo t(urH- qoo 00.000.E0101-100 DOTS Was E5-SEB'SSZS CMITEEl-1ps7 00-000-20101-100 qs}punjpunos6sepun WOpundueleM "a pund le.leue0 bl0Z fi2nJgaA jaayg 8Oue1e8 uaeejjS lInE) jo umo 1 siassy Town of Gulf Stream ) Balance Sheet February 2014 General Fund 001 Water Fund 401 Underground Fund 155 TamlLUbilides 5638,876.87 581,17631 S'-,002,68531 Fund Balance 001-24702-000-00 Reserve for Dredeing 517,820.00 50.00 50.00 001-27101-000.00 Fund Balance S2,045,190.11 50.00 50.00 155-27101-ooa-00 Fund Balance 50.00 SO.oO 54,848,381.79 40627200.000-00 Retained Earnings - Unreserved 50.00 52,097,491.06 50.00 401-27200.530-10 Retained Earnings-ilesemtd 50.00 (9124,232.84) 50.00 401-27302.000-00 ' RIE Reserved For DIS and R S R $0.00 5537,915.98 50.00 Talal Fund Balance 51,063,010.11 52,511,12430 54,8.18,381.79 Total Liabilities and Fund Balance 51,70(,88698 52,592,40031 56,851,067.00 2 E oartei' s 61yt0'LSI yL'Sr!'ts Krte s ts'u Frowsy frtSrs acl4mmd pvy m'u;'m (srowul scot= am.10:s 97s rcm'a' srLSrs me co1wsmgrrm®0> Mmr:s III=) al MIS MESS CtIr's trim KIM nl�,s9q,a a�>]ra�l mmO[CIS (tI9f99ss1 59910';M tm-IrEi LCOl9S rr'[:9'Ils urru91s ' OCTS DOM was cool MCS DOT[ COTS ggr]•%ai v+.. •j COWES SIDS mMr15 S99Sr IS F= COMICS [69:55 r!J•wiv?g-Ta3 CCI.'; am W05 DSM Dor; DOM to as p+flavfmv5-wi>rmai na mUls (6Lbir131 ;MIKS 9r@r:15 LrfifS CrUVOIS :191.115 "Itq•+ai>giyui 0095 was DOCS met DOM COTS MVS n'N'll acTcSs5 (sea=) COMM 9Z`9tI5 ItTfftsl OVMSS 99;015 S:ll�val>vJ vwwrrloa'1 ac, coni I:4'[9031 C-0D:SS cr1 1 Irrtrsl OTROS 99'got S 1•sc,��vO tva�el waml camWLlls (Cruml St Irr6r; gl'6L0'CK r9-[94'15 6lelr6f murlls acl4mmd pvy COM Orms Cots Cti99S IMIS was army 9anySaim.ty,pfay Mmr:s III=) al MIS MESS CtIr's trim KIM PKCticlmni DSM GOTS roof OPei was ODDS CDC; mawu�Iv of cl eC'LIr;9S rrurK1 SL'i6: SS CVKL.'—S. Im,V)5 frutln Many -I May Val mmmnwp Mal DOM was MOS cons mel was OOHS .vgaivmgV•1gm6 W73 M'[rOS lmofts) or ".'s Ot'LYW 1092951 TO lZrls stur'IS :wysa>vy-di on; DOM DOCS roto 0016 mos Way cy>wmSl] 0095 was DOCS met DOM COTS MVS q�ingw6wp,�vwrnjwd Do as mus MICS calls OUTS coal DUMS S:ll�val>vJ vwwrrloa'1 ww'IIT 1witsSl 593o1'CIS m1LFTii 151015 Frl'J3 19"1 [9`S SSd rlpvi [q�301�7 .Cvvo]7>wt GSTSo'!u EMIRS S!trIlls 6t'96s'LIS lintris) cow.—.r Lt191S OOCCDLS (911tu31 x9916:5 Lrv![S ItF9iKl rrm 6196s cyw P,41 Imnc] ca cti C:s fAv6rW Ir;r[s entrails IL5S6rls) 19999'IS Wiggs v �u;tay. cymmmgloo7 mwmvW>y m OW'O6S mT61'115 Domriys courits (Onml m00ra WrWLS MTMIts 03061'111 DJTCrLLS Wwirs (OUymsl coverts Cowit'LS mvvd lup0ng ' >rund mMl'li L9M5 Ir9SK trim CL'tT15 Wigs Orms CILtS DOTS GO LIS COM mus mm WM vm?ProIM!vWmvjA totally L9MS Irs;K [6"= MITTS L9'16s Ct901S vadpa Ip r wi ro flrfrL:f untru51 57159'96rS M9Ot'[511u (malls) r. 'aIS [tT9rC915 acl4mmd pvy CTM DOTS was mm DOM DOM MCS vgwev]zr/uvtw>ml (mOUr65S) (gITGS'90 In6'sKT651 1:1 ISLMI MEL -a (mpi'951 (tt'9rYrsl 94 PY-vvcnD; d4m3 COTS DOM 0305 DOM MDS 03'M moi mtehg>q-vc1m.S PV COTW'T `Zs (feurIK) SrT61'l[ii :SrSTitf (NTSMSI fillf"IS 4110'1915 vanR9•t>vlmavm,SFV vcl.(avdmi Wpm VIOL vwepeA POPDB A Wpu I -PV cl • Irllill.M.13 tiLOZ'gZtienjgaj jo se pun -j jejauaE) jumajgs auaooul wean;g lInE) jo unno I C; �. Espnditv,n , Ai u & Gin7al Cumnl M9n(h YTD Eaa-.sn.5•„in h-lial Eutlpal Ya6mu Artml Eudg.1 Vatunc, 2059 Evalgal GvtpaG4nbn F,o SI1.3lu5 S16j09.17 sl,49.19 41.1=91 Mtj1531 P221a 51957lam Gaea3e Ca0n16a Fn Sam mm SOL Sa1,P_I13 psfi .66 15',045X51 Sl:accom Dw.i,c•Ad,® SaM Sam Sum SN.Cus 516¢6656 (5;04511) SIAMOLD U,Sir Srnsa Tu 51956.16 5015.17 S76a1 510.496.0 510,Im51 1933211 S233SEm Ua0i7Smire Tsa•9dic SIS,ITi_9 SIZ1llJl $1.315.95 511,21731 561,16665 Dp5o63 SISLaaam Vd9F5nrice Ta -Ta . Sam Som am 5006 Som Sam SOm U,9a3 Sm Ta,-F.t SUU3 Som SUMS 5117aa Sam stj 14 am NaaySmie Tn•Pnpane 524".31 SIJasil 51,413.95 4,31797 SSml.9 IP116S) 314mSO0 Lelil SarCv•Adm 519,66535 S11.041.66 53,55119 SIS,A5.74 570261.30 4,6D -H 519jmm Canm3vuwad Oae:ls,u Sam 515u1 S4539 no S2.3910 sz. IJS 9.100,00 Cawiv,bnl CnYAa,r_ Sam Sam am sam Sam Sam Sam cae,bc3m-Cacr.+:dy 311.04627 Soto 512MS-21 St;a1617 Sam SIAW6_17 Sam AcmuvSalnl Avd®;fan SI;m617 Sam 31;645.31 SIZA16J1 am 512.07627 Sam Fek- Gr.,ca Fed-nlGneu•mhc Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam nas, Palneei57u: arT=.Wan Sam Sum Sam Sam 57,17Sm IDAIM noxam Safra arw,.:m rve5xbn Sam som Som FULL Saw S9om sam Cmlr.kb c.rkasNs O, 9193 Sam SS4.S3 =11 saw S_0M m.m slleaaaern Smdcn Sam Slmaw ISLU,tml 31,516.99 16:lam (51,703.01) sismam CICYa Chuan SFae 569.95 am 56995 595.60 Sam 39550 So.m Pubk Sj.tr-Grtn LT9phe aW Sam Sam am Sam Sam Sam LaS slava.; a,el Clc,b; Sam SRM Som SOLO Sam Sam Sam Sal<afFud Ave,a Sam Som am Sam So 00 SO DO Sam ala¢Se , Fen Sam Sam Sam SOLO - Sam Sao Sam nlSu fau,auul,lpeaartS sam am Sam 5�llo m Sam S_lioea sam OFararnl Tr+vrrt SOLD Saco am Sao Sam mm Sam Opener, Try•%V: F.d Soon son Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Gel, P,w -, Som Sam Sam SOLO Sam Sam Sam SI2193 Slaa.m Ist.lam) Dania 513,7210 IS6,171.701 Sil90100 Te1715naavn 5231V64 955,137.15 (Sl1.Sa0Jll 51,115.14563 D,511,179a (DL13L70) sial.39sm Espnditv,n , Ai u & Gin7al Eaa-.sn.5•„in 59,15705 SlOadm S19dx sSzw1 410100 (Sl.7r_911 SIlrw� Ra5P=+5abrs+-Ads+ SI1.3lu5 S16j09.17 sl,49.19 41.1=91 Mtj1531 P221a 51957lam 0I6ar Liis•rMT. San sum Sam Sam sam SOA] Som Dw.i,c•Ad,® S+119 Sam IS9=X91 55.71X1 Sam (51.71217) Sam F1CATnea 51956.16 5015.17 S76a1 510.496.0 510,Im51 1933211 S233SEm R.C-eTal Cantu 9.1503 53,1703 9937 479994 S27x13 (SWO) 565,611” LI2rd Er.6h L•lvse SljsaS 59,19 .0 Sa61d5` 53,6N19 S^-.11731 (Sjmu) 551joam Rb,3sn'Caapew,ba Sam Sam Sam som MOO Sam =0 V6evP19y,my CavpncSba Som Saw Sam Sam mm MDO sam Lelil SarCv•Adm P9A511 57,T3137 I122Md611 46-46 92931il (51:0x15) s4jm-m LeplSe„ba•P:>miS Bnad Sam 515u1 S4539 no S2.3910 sz. IJS 9.100,00 E.,h.kl Fee Som Som Sam Sam sOm Som som ams Rariav •TH Sly9m 9111.67 (9131) 3961515 511.79311 S3p19.16 vZ'Smm AcmuvSalnl Avd®;fan Sam 5131.(5 SIa4A7 9O.drom 56,27011 156X79.19) 513psom 4 5 03mrs W'IL'S WTLVIS MISS M9CT MS13 W6TIS was (CSIs) was W7615 IM:6151 am WILMS MIKE IrCS I"= OPTS LSIK C9'IK Was onni,; IILTW WIXIS ILT06'IS Ir'tt151 WTLS Emu W'oars (fent."IS) 03T'Ss aT9S'n 1[bm31 W{3S L61995 000093 IK111151 Ira wls la'tfiels imiLlS L"Its !993 oOmrK ultis IfKYIS =TILS LEWIS 04163 ot'Ia1s aPMrn t"Wis lY16r:S IRL[f W rs ItTSK rr613 W -men WROTE WCOOS' WvxlS MOM CONK MOS mmrSST WT91'K MTIarT{s va mss Dan MTS MCS OOPS (Woofs) Was MUSS 11!195 MPT on WOE. MOT COOS 031E MTS Was MIS OOM was Was MOS MTS MLS LOTS OPCS MCS COME on NTT 0315 MTI O(rWrSTIS flravisl Iraf-LSF :iSr995 sa3arK L991rI1S Miris WK6BIS IItb3) SI'tivos 171-cr S MIES LSSPps 6Lm'Tis M'Swm twinSI MMa'92T WWr4T "Un WKrfS sm.ts wiruIs ILr69Sl WOE= is -01-4 9 fm WWS K'135 MmOts 061VTS W'asecs Trails MWIT NT{'S MOS TO Isea3S ISLTen) 01=113 iwlli3 OrNr5S arstelof ar,z'.Js DIMS W9s MM WaS Was NOS 113 CS WLTYo63 M9In IL [.0315 TT9oCsif Cr[3 SL rcY:Ii LT 19PT[s M9W'Is WSr66li P911i )TOS 031K 03'Mf T91S was KMr'JIS MITT MLT trial lr 19;ai NTS LT'IWZn MT31ta65 (worE61 06'lil'M'K LrIt9'L9K Irl Ml'6S) Thi 695 OL'iSTS Mmliti5 6i11rf$ LULL{'t6S aT'19robs arisen 6T3L'9S alln W DDVIS 011'S3f Was M121f ill STIS Mas M CLS firttrsl frur" rr63'9s {PICK LG➢ST olTres MMf :I ffuts 1911PIS xms fro[; ME= Wai WbWb15 tr6frs Oman SET2TIS 6VI-LIT mo]fls ITTCIS 1MbWT9sl (0111)"IS1 IM'a1 IS) COME was Mas Was NOM'" timis Ir3aTS 9rrn Irc93 L9"IK 91739if comrK ITI'"11) ao{4'IS TI'If6'Is MELEE WSLSS NTT M'b10'TIS Ul'Lrf61 antis LOsila (T9'191s) marls 9r691'1S was MTS W -Cs MM COTS M% MPS WmO915 (ri.i93) SYK9'95 WFIV S (91'51 IS) (rTsrlS 6r"rY15 WIN'" (61'TKISI WSS3 6L'ITYK tc1fts OOSt3 9-1{23 W'N 033 COM was MM Wbf will WOE Nos Mas WIDE TOGS WIS W07 mus'ls IOSSIo:TI wmwus cm -"K NM MOS o01S To OWES. miss OO9KTs K'133 (wml W'WLs 99TSLS Mboda3 MTIT'Is IrEWIT Ir Wis (HVX-.Sl 19➢99'IT frr69'S MMISSS ll'ITiIS S9 rst tS t-aiwlS MKS r"Gis Vim Mmrn Inn WTLrIS 65TKIS tilt= MILES S9'6T1" o000rlls TSLfs SOISfIS :ITfOIT U=4 RTl6f M'ns m9ao'n K61i1" DOTECS 99'O6"a M95S NOUS MTS ME` (lri6i3) Was arra MTS OUTS WOE lafma OCi aaa9V9A POPoB IMPV M -PVA POWB IaTsy p17. 4iuW, luun0 Tg�c, imp afW Y=X--m w10.1 pJ-cepe!OMsa7laad WslndmldM{1tr3 va®p "d'"WTIC�.+14+A CIE- 9.smamngllmp09p Od-�13 0Y •aglgaacv9] Cd •u^!O+ad N°p+u1 Od-d5J W =^.1C pd-°rj+LaSiy°T ean'anm°]lawlgdvuup muCTm+°]imWuY rml\bis !y>+avaui aalq{-nalutp Olp aalad-°°}°IrSRtacaY nwRS a+waa3 a;ed awnaarrlV Nrunl+Y'�(IC aj !LL•LOlap 1plda] 111- a+i��l''AN W mIC'9°a9 °°iJJ+S aaLO HL-+a9rp =n1V n Wa] nglp P 1�CuaaYIrOT1 ILL•�!i°OF OcwJ 16L•+aaJuoliJaLb3 aaLO xarauyCGv9a¢5 F19 a°rnggQ unci m ;voar+°v3-amwuat °c°Ydav:a�M1+fT+'67 Algl\ NL-?a°A3 aS:.+Td ILL•m:p+°d Tat l°+°+1 �^TlC bua�a411LJwm+d 0 Svrvu 32,15439134 .5054.11" Sam ST71.19131 SM, Mac ID..3 5115,19190. ReLuW Siluie.smu S4,vm 16 Cvrt.nl6brlh 3337 5:1371.12 ypC SS.70 5330200 Crmivc•stmu Ad l Bud2.1 W.... Ae4vl Bvdpl V.. . 2014 Bud2.t FW 5)47269 5+31111 51311J1 5L9,441L'9 SLT91a65 3.4763fi 555,0)o6L Uf&=L E,4c 347.1! 561250 5161.1: SI,44S01 510.5152 5131659 S73laL0 Hml .Sfcbaslv�x, Trin:�f-PO SS.w 519161 5166.67 SK0.00 565531 5291 I 5+jpppp Cvr..Ovti Edi:cl�•CPE Sam SOA] Saw Sam Soca Sapp Sapp CvpUfthF-PC Sam ST.SQM 3,54130 So an 37,75730 37,T330 3axam Rvn_lulCcu E4pev< 57537531 5115,1334 s2193.96 S6T.,w6�f SGT1,4913p 30,4301 Sl,iil3mm sav ev SOW 3.ol2 51,01)30 SIS.wir 513'a, So (16':5 36,152.00 R<p9W 5ande.3v0dRse Saw Sam 50.0 Saml spm Sam Sum EICATae Som Sam Sam 5000 S an Sam Spill R.C.. C.Mlv.hv Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Saw LUiWHohblvlu v Som saw Sato saw Sam SpA( SOM R'nivl C9mprm'v9 S2w Sam Sam Sam sun sum Saw UOe6'316a71ea[. p.- Sam man Sam Sam Sam 3640 $am pv4hg5C9vca Smhu 31IMS11 511.666.3 U19 P1 5µ901.43 5331111 SIEd911 5140.00100 AI1s.TmhDhpv Sam SUM 51137 Sam 541655 541635 s19m.w Ur6sml C1av0 Sum Saw Sam Som sun Sam Saw hlhc Clta Som Sam Sam SOm Sam Sam Sam 511.`1637 311.730.03 531.17 .04,90123 511.,41.96 313}4143 5141.000.00 Svrvu 32,15439134 .5054.11" Sam ST71.19131 SM, Mac ID..3 5115,19190. ReLuW Siluie.smu S4,vm 16 3,Tflo 3337 5:1371.12 5337150. SS.70 5330200 Crmivc•stmu SOLO saw Saw 5.63.0 Saw ISSpbll saw FICA Tae 513195 SIOX 5`5.11 51,171.27 51,5:661 1$11.6:1 333440 R.*r C.,u*.,ivv sv1ll S999m 51691 55,011.99 3.995.00 135991 511,935.0 LM.MHr hivvamr SP541 51.15133 5105.90 56.4µm 55.6.6665 1s74TA) 313'emm Cv�crv:r.4'v.•Saern r344 541.67 51571 SU640 S21C131 61d21 550040 Elearir •Sheer SI.10116 SLI6661 1513.49) 5!31507 ss,>)1]I 531_4 S14,00sm Rvn_lulCcu E4pev< Saw 5113) 51131 sow 316:7.65 516165 .94000 SI[xc.6ep9v 9,d \L1i12'Lr SOW 3.ol2 51,01)30 SIS.wir 513'a, So (16':5 36,152.00 Mi.- 0i6a-Mes Sam 5525.03 5611.00 53,1410a 9,IJ.w. ISLaltml 57.Sww R'acFmlLaSvrFa Sam Sam Sam Saw Sam Am Sam Cpsrv'vS SuppSa Saw Sam Sam 5499.0: SSm 15499.011 Sam UrilfveysE{vym9d Sam 541.67 S [a7 1329.19 rJ1111 15151.451 SSwm 0.va65Wc4hh 4vi5uppb 51136 3mm SIU4 5.90._ 350000 3:09.73 f19wm CVFhvl Cvd:7-Sown Stamm SL1,6669T 3,114666} SI0;751.17 SI4531131 S4g3114 MuAcaw Colum novo PraPry SOLA Sam Saw Saw Sam Spm saw 53,3537 540,46267 31,17`39 51029735 VmAMA9 55130534 39135140 Tr4:lErya111.rn 325,65017 5I70,13LT4 3531405 3,451,159.95 51431,516_6 54533631 3j/6391m Ker Rn -ave (p4GHll 3.49514 (]631199) SIMMS $LM.93ZAS 5131$3341 (55),75931) slr.3mm BECZ*.NZC MM IL%"NCE 32,15439134 .5054.11" Sam ST71.19131 SM, Mac ID..3 5115,19190. I4FTMFLUSTDMCM 51.496.14 136}1139) 37,017.75 513330LU 33173301 (53,7334) 367.000.00 LVUL1CMTD,UxNM 511;014.45 3;0:5316.15 511,701.77 51941914.11 Aaf5,5H3 (35,75039) 340.19190 6 A8114M F r 'lluuad Allen a Bulploy JO/Pum sol BUTA dde IGl;ua ssaulsnq jaylo jo uogelodioo r- 'Ienpinlpul Aug ue6w pegs ,aapluued„ vial ay; 'uieiay pasn ue4M :aauluua r •Wom uollonjlsuoo Ilue jol ALlO eyl Aq panssl iluuad usaw lleys ,attwad„ uual ay; 'ulejay pasn uayM . ,uuad ;V 10 ay; jo Aoldwe ayl ul jopedsul v Bulpling Aue usaw lleys ppedsul. uual ay; 'ulelaq pasn uayM uoloa sul •laeiay fed a apew yloq :>Rlom to uogoadsui lo; paHieyo aal uogoadsul ayl jo/pue ;luuad 6ulgwnid �o 'lpouloala 'Bulpllnq 'Mahal ueld jo; uolllpuoo a se b peBleyo (s)aal eyl usaw Heys ,sea;. io eaL uue; ey;'ulaiay pasn uayM : s sad s o •yoeag At-JlaCl Jo A$O mpo;1e1o1B0 Bulpling la14O - ay; usaw lleys �lej3B10 Bulplln9,, uual mg 'ulaiay pasn a.iayM :lelo11J0 -!piing `y luawpeda0luawanoidwl 4.unwwoO yoeag Aejle0 )o f110 eyl usaw !lays ,juaw4jede0„ wial mg 'Malay pass uayM .Iuau�e 9—Cj •papuawe se vepoO Bulpiln9 epuold ey; ueew lleys epoO„ twal eyl 'ulajey pasn uayM :apoO a n w :suollluge0 -l, u01 oa3 < d G .d- :smopo; se olajaq se.iped ayl ueem;eq pue Aq peeiBe Ilgalay 51 if 'SNO=13a3H1 MONOR lsaialul s,allgnd ayl;o aouejepi } ay; w jaylo yaea y}lm aleiad000 N w o} sapied enliaadsa� ey; �o suollue;ul ay; seauepine lueweelBV sly; 'SV3N3HM C9 � < p 'Pus :s}lw!I SAMOI I-- Y� a4l u141!m Bu1Al sanyoru;s uppeo Bulloadsul .1110 e41 Aq pen.ias aq lsaq lllm AM � 0 LL Pus NMOL 41oq;o slueplsai eyl to anylem pug Rales 'ylleay ay; 'SV3N3HM n m0 ow :H I R S 9 3 N I I M r v s m re NMO1 ey;, se of paile}ai jayeulajay'uol;ejadioo ledpiunw eppold a 'V0121013 o 'WV321.1.S cn ns 30 NMOL ayl pue ..l.lO eyl„ se of paLalai 104eulalay 'uogeiodjoo 'HOV39 x ledlolunw ePlaold V0121013 AV18130 -10 ALIO ayl uaamlaq Pus Aq BOOZ m 71 3o hep _Q� sly! uo olul pa's;ua J.N3W3B8E)V SIH! i 7 e WV32I1S 31f1J 30 NM013H1 its � = (INV HOV39 AVIM30 30 ALIO 3H1 N33M1391NgUMIJEJV 1VO012i31N1 Wall oil. m419101111111181HE0111 C C Structures: When used herein, the tens "structures' shall mean any and all above -ground, in -ground, and/or underground structures, and any and all construction, mechanical, electrical and/or plumbing work for which a permit must be obtained. Section 2. The CITY and TOWN, in consideration of the mutual promises and benefits hereinafter set forth, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, do hereby agree as follows: A. The purpose of this Agreement is to provide the TOWN with the expertise and assistance of the CITY'S Department for the inspection and permitting of certain construction projects within the TOWN'S limits for compliance with the Florida Building Code. B. The method by which this purpose will be accomplished Is as follows: The TOWN shall adopt an ordinance which: a. incorporates by reference the provisions of the Code as presently in force and effect in the CITY; b. vests the responsibility for reviewing plans for compliance with the Code, issuing permits, and inspecting structures with the TOWN in the CITY'S Department; and C. upon adoption by the CITY of any amendments to said Code, the TOWN shall immediately, upon notice by the CITY amend its ordinance to accurately reflect such changes. 2. a. Plans for construction shall be submitted to the TOWN in triplicate by the applicant and shall be reviewed by TOWN for compliance with TOWN'S Zoning Code and other non - construction compliance. The three (3) plans shall be stamped and submitted to CITY by contractor or owner with the attendant permit applicant and fees. The Department shall review and process all plans, submitted in triplicate, checking the same for compliance with the Code; and determine the subsidiary permits necessary and the amount of fees, For processing and the inspection service, CITY shall receive one hundred percent (100%) of the permit fee. Said fees shall be collected by CITY. After reviewing and processing said construction plans, CITY shall forward one set of said plans to the contractor/owner with the permit and another set to the TOWN with a copy of the permit. CITY shall not forward any plans to TOWN without the attendant permit. " p l e 4 4 l i m e l g e u o s e a m n a q l o u p e g s j e f t u e ; q N s l l l S , A 1 1 O a y } A g l e n o i d d e a y l ' a 6 e J e n o o p u e a l e a y l u a o a o u e u n s u l p l e s p a n o u d d e s e l l j a 6 e u e W N s l a S J L L I O 8 4 1 I q u n l u a w a a j G V s l y ; l a p u n u o g o e S u e a 4 e v a p u n o } p a l e B f j g o l o u s l A l l o a y l " 1 a 6 m u V 4 A s ��l S J ��1 1 O a y } o } / G a } o e ; s p e s e q 1 1 e 4 s a B e t a n o o p u e s a l e o g W a o e a u e m s u ! p 1 e S ' N M O L a y ; u l y } l m s u o p o a d s u l 6 u p l e w l o l p u e u r a o l a y } u l y l l m u o g o r u l s u o o j o ; s u e l d 6 u l m a l m l u a w u e d e O 8 4 1 1 0 l u e r m p a z y m p n e C u e j o l e r o y i 0 B u l p l i n e a y ; H u a A l l o j o } a d a m o o a n u e m s u l I N e s s a o s u a y } I l e B u l o u a p i n a j o g = s o u e i n s u l g , N M o . L a y ; t u o l l e o u a m s u l t o a } e o y l } r a O a y l l m A l l o l i l d d n s A p e n u u e I l e t i s N M O L a 4 1 ' 8 " s s a o a d u o g o a d s u l p u e m a l n a J u e l d m g j o I n o 6 u l s u e ' 4 } e a p j o L t n f u l l e u o s l a d ' a 6 e w e p A p a d m d l o l s w i e l o o ; p a p w i l j o u l n q ' 6 u i p n l o u l a j * n } e u p u e p u l l l i a n a t o s a 6 e w e p J o ; s w l e l o 1 1 1 3 p u e d u s ; s u l e 6 e A l l o 4 . u w a p w p u e M I L W e y p l o y I l e 4 s N M O L 8 4 1 ' B Z ' 8 9 L a i n ; e l S e p u o l S ; o s u o p e H w p a y ; o } } o e f g n s ' L ' N M O L a l B u g u m u l a p e w a q H e y s a t n l o n i l s a p e d s u l o } } o u s u o l l e u l w 1 a l a p 4 o n s I I V ' A 1 J O t o ; s a i a l u l l s a q a q ) w 1 1 w e e p e 4 s l e q p i n o 4 s N M O L u 1 4 I M e m } o n n s A u s l o a d s u l o } a s n l e i o f ; y 6 u a y ; a n e y p e g s J e i o ! ! I O B u l p i i n g a 4 1 ' 9 ' N M O L 8 4 1 4 0 1 4 ! 1 ! g l s u o d s a i a y } e q I l e 4 s S J a y 4 0 I l a p u e ' e n o g e 4 p o l } a s ' s s a = d u o g o a d s u l p u e m a l n s j u e l d a y l B u l w e o u o o s a n n b u l e s o g l A l u o l e l o ��0 6 u l p p n g 9 4 1 0 1 p ��e m i o l H e y s N M O L a 4 1 ' s a l l n b u i j a w n s u o o I l e t o u o l l e j l s l u l w p e a 4 l i o l A 1 I I I g l s u o d s a j a w n s s e H e y s N M O L 8 4 1 9 u i p a 6 e 6 u a s u o l e j o d i o o j o s L w ' s u o s t a d ��S e o N M O L a y } u 1 4 } l m u o g o r u l s u o o ; } q p 0 p i e s t o s u o l s l n a d a y } t o s u o l } e l o l n t o } u a w a o n l u e e l l ; j o l e l g l s u o d s e i / h a l o s a q l l e y s N M O L 8 4 1 ' t + * A L I O a y } o ; A d o o a y l i m ' l o c u e 4 l l u a 6 e p e z u o 4 ; n e j o ' s a ; l u u e d a 4 ; q l a u e d n o o 0 J O e l e o y g j a O a 4 ; a n s s i J I M 4 3 1 4 m N M O L o f l o u e d r = o t o a } e z y i . p a O p i e s p i e n v o l l i p p u e b o u e d n 3 o 0 t o e l e o y g l a O e q I a r e d a i d I l l m l e i o ! g 0 B u i p l i n g e y l ' u o g o a d s w I e u y p u e l o a f o a d m g t o u o g a l d w o o i 0 o } o i 4 s l l e s u o d n " l a a j a t g e l e p a 4 i p u e u o g o a f a i s o l u o s e a j a l o u J I M u o ' l o a l e t p e l e p a 4 l p u e a o u e l d a o o e o f s e l a y l l a p i e o 9 4 1 > u e w 1 1 M u o p o a d s u ! s ! 4 t o u o g a l d w o o a y } u o d n ' a o } o s d s u l a y l p u s s a w g l i p l e e l l s u o g o r u } s u o o e l l ; u o a q p a y s s u e l d p u e p j e o u o g o e d s u i l l u u a d e L L " a l e p p u s a w p u 9 n 1 6 a u o } o a f o j d a l o a d s u l o l ; u a u g t e d a p a t p i s a n b a l x e w l e n p i n l p u l p e z u o y u t e A u v ' N M O L 8 4 1 u l t p l m u o g o n n s u o o j a i s l l u u e d I l e a l e d a i d p u e s s a o o i d H e y s A l l o a y L s u u o l p a n o . i d d e k L J o u o A L I O o f p e A l w g n s a q H e y s s i l u u a d p e j % s u o l i e o l l d d y T C ; C .D U14001IM911- I'D To: Lula Butler, Director of Community Improvement CC: Terrill Pybum, Assistant City Attorney Milena Walinskf, Assistant Finance Director File From; Kimberly Wynn, Executive Assistant/Agenda Coordlnatoro Date. 10/02009 Re: intadocal Agreementrrawn of Gulf Stream/Buiiding Permit and Inspection Services For your record and disbursement, attached please find one (1) fully executed original Interlocal Agreement with the Town of Gulf Stream to provide Building Permit and Inspection services. The agreement was approved at the August 18, 2009 Regular Commission Meeting; Item B.Q. An original agreement will be maintained In the Clerk's office for Its file and a copy sent to Finance and the City Attorney's Office. Please call me at 243-7059 If you have any questions. Thank you. KW1kw Attachments CITY CLERX DEPARTMENT MM Baas eel wo ass � ;uaurgovi v A[/MX •naK DfueiLL cuopsanb Auu aevg no6,il 6SOL-Sh3 av am Wo TYS mail `.8upaaW uormmmoJ avrn809 600Z `SI IdnV aip }v panarddu sam mai! ou •saawas uorinadsur puu inroad Slnppng aprnoad of unrx4g AnE) 10 uMoy mg girnr sivan=&V Ivooraaiul ruuOao (Z) omi puS 2mmId pagaupV naruas uopaadsur puvIturaad StrlplruEr/tuvDAS3rnD jo unlojAualu=gV ruc�°[aaiul -jI I Q1Q(�)b 6 va inx rWau?paooJ upuaSV/iuvis!ssy anrinaaxg `uu6M d[aagm.I meal- ', OL— �Caua°3iV+GrJ7uv7srsN`uanciFd(T?aaa.L �L !I^'W�.�^ Wndtvxoym Section 3. Duration. This Agreement shall be a continuing nature unless cancelled by either party for any reason and without penalty, on not less than sixty (60) days written notice. Any fees paid to CITY where inspection services are not completed shall be prorated In accordance with the percentage of inspection completed and any excess shall be refunded to TOWN. Section 4. Miscellaneous A. This Intedocal Agreement shall be filed pursuant to the requirements of Section 163.01(11) of the Florida Statutes. B. This Agreement shall be governed by and in accordance with the Laws of Florida. The venue for any action arising from this Agreement shall be in Palm Beach County, Florida. C. Neither party shall assign or transfer any rights or interest In this Agreement without the written consent of the other party. D. This Agreement shall not be valid until signed by the Mayor and the City Clerk of each party. IN WITNESS. WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused these presents to be signed by thefrQYJaib ib"dzed officers on the date setforth above. By: Mayor 1 TOWN OF GULF STR , M,v FLORIDA ATTEST: B Mayor By:� City Clerk Approveeas My Attorney ,' ` Eci juiHX3 spsooag oq;;o uulpo;sno 31131D ttmoL 'Sla.TaoulS puodsaT o;;soo papum.Is@ ue zo asuodsw opupdoiddu atp gplm aurp jo;unomu alquuosuai u to no,( o; puodsai o; spojja;saq ,Gan s;l osn Ilan umoL aqL •s;sanbas spT000i ollgnd 2mmoom 3o aagmnu ogni a w 2anlxom ,Cl;uanno ST mea4S 3In'J }o umoL aqL •molaq aouds otp ul gpo3;as sT ;sanbaT spmoaj oggnd moA 3o uoladuosap aq; uagp 'Iugtan sum ;sonbaz inoA 3I •Iaual aanoo slip op paiouun sl;sonbai puq;;o aged psig oq; uag; Tui -A to panlaoai sem;sanbaT mo,i 3I 't IOZ `£I AuN pa;up ;sonbai spsooai oflgnd mo,i panlaaai seq meoAS 3lnD 3o umoL aqL '[moo•dnoa2-2ol2wwoo'vo sp.Toaai:oll!uw] •ouj 'duedmoD uol;isinbay DO JuOG '£(OZ Pu° ZIOZfo tlaoa 2uunp paanld aaam Z-110 uopnlosag fo I uopaag of luonsand panlaoaa spm!/ atp aaatlm aznalsuowap yolyat spaooaa luawuaaao2 11u aPlnoad £IOZ 28 ZTOZ -to3 L-II0 osa-d jo T aas o;;uunsind paoeld aiam panlaoaa span; aaaget spaoaag 'AOf) - g65=,HHd Md [moa•dno12-aoaa=oo@spiooaj:o4llum] •oul'Auudmoo uoptstnboy Do bIOZ `Si ARW Iium-a HU pazanT[aQ VMO -I3 `AJMOD HOVE[a w'Tvd WVgUIS 3lnn 3o rrmoz Your original request. dated May 13, 2014, is reproduced in the space below RECORDS REQUEST (the" Toesn Date orRegaest 5113114 RevmtorsRegcestDY 548 REQursrM. Custodian of Records Town of Gulf Stream REQUESTOR, CG Acquisition Company, Inc. REQUESTOWS CONTACTL*IFORMATION: E -V i1 records@emmerce-group.cum I= 954-360-0907; Addtes:: 13SO West_Nevport CenterDrirne, DezrBetdHeach, FL 33442 REQU-ST: Provide all govemment records which demonstrate where the funds received pursuant to Section 1 of Resolution 011-7 were placed during each of 2012 and 2013. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING REQUEST: THIS REQUEST IS MADE PU'RSL.s.IxT TO PUBLIC RECORDS ACT, CHAPTER 119 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES AI1-D IS.SISO REQUESTED UNDER THE COMUONIAM RIGHT TO MNOW, THE COMNION LAM RIGHT OF ACCESS; AM) AM- STATUTORY RIGHT TO iIOSI` (LICLUDL•`IG, N1 OUT A`1P SIAT)TORY RIGHT OF ACCESS, AS APPLICABLE). THIS REQUEST IS ALSO AJADE PURSUANT TO THE RIGHTS OF THE REQUESIORPROVTDED LN THE FLORIDA IT IS REQUESTED THAT THIS RECORDS REOUEST BE FULFILLED WELECTRONIC RECORDS REQUEST BE FULFILLED ON 11 S 17PAPER.NOTE: WALL CASES (UNLESS ITD?OSSIBLE) THE COPIES SEOULD BE 711°0 SIDED AND SHOULD BE BILLED IN ACCORDANCE 147TH Section 119.07(4) (a) (1) ALL ELECTRONIC COPIES ARE REQUESTED TO BE SENT BY E -b LAM DELII%ERY. PLEASE PROVIDE THE APPRO-MIATE COSTS (IF AD, ) TO Frr.rr L THIS PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST 134 ADVANCE. It Trill be required that the Regnerter approrc of any costs, asserted by the Agents (as defined is Florida Statute, Chapter 119.01 (Definitions)), is adraaee of any costs imposed to the Requester by the Agency. LPiNF'JFti .? 042113 FOEM 11sIHX3 spsooag ogl;o uutpolsn0 x7910 umoy 'Alataouls •posola ialim stgl lapcsuoa am 'noX wog Nouq juoq om ssalu fj 'astxa sploaat gons ou lugl pastmpe ag 'molaq pompoidaj si aouapuodwuoo stgL'biOZ `Si �eNI uo pa�palmoo�lau am lugl `{,TOZ `£j AuNI polep puma moi m palsanbaJ amuq no C spi000i oggnd aql of asuodsas m st jallal stgy [moo dno>$-aatatmuoov0 sp�ooai:olttum] -ouj XuudLuo0 uotltsmbod g0 JuaQ 'E(067Puu ZIOZ Bina l atg jo ryo0a -loJst isanGay sty,L •z -I f0 uopnlosay jo j uoyaas of lummind palaalloo spugf aNJjo asn aq; aiO4suomap 110ly,x spJoaa.t luaututan08l10 apino.td £lOZ 7s ZIOZ S-Ims aoj L-1I0'os3lj;o I as of luunsind spunj jo asn aluaisuomap gatgm sp.toaag - 6PS# IMd :au [moo•dnoig-2312mmoa(0 spIoaas:olltum] •ouj'Auadmo0 uoillsmboy J0 titOZ'SZ XBW Rema ern paaamttaa vcffuo I!I `AjNf10D H0d3g NjZVd W'MZS A -M -D AO NAAIO L 7'ovtoe+=1 rewe� "4i" 132014 is[eOjwid is dmaunee bekl[: *EC6EDS2FM.+�+T{ic'ReweY'] 'Dal CSee�. 'SI11ryi 3MQ�= CWOde11OrRtdrd37O O[GOISdmM MWM1» CG Ac6i idw Cm m" Y. Sicc... 7:E�570L5[O.'fl-ZCQflifi.S77077: P.]64 rvo•SV---.mtuee Fear 9P-7Y.lSJ/: �ik� LN4'd 4.�ICutvRm.Bevhdi Oo�El'37312 7�7;. Pre41de�112ewenneOl iecurds'rhkh dimautinte CN Yp dldltl Nilili'LOII W Yd OW [II]flll0 SOCdw 1 a ResOLdSOrl011.7: Tnh.Requiath(oreuhef IIIc YNnI017 enA7070: T7]13xrQr1L%Tt5mADL7 m%%TTO mum IITCORIKAOT, MOM IV OF=FLO ®ASUTCM A -'ID 15-ALSOS000EMD Il.VOERUM COIOSO%LAI%XGUTIP ZOMIRECOM90,11AIYIIGIR' OFACCES.S;-At.D- x%' sum 0RTRmw ro110wzimLDLVG vniiOVEINIiAT[OV,'my SZITCTM-EGErOFACCESS.ASAMITCAIM TRIS REQVESE IS ALSO WE ,fL7At;L%FTOIBERIGBTS OF77LFREQLTSTOR FMIDED LYM.MILORM 777 SRLQL'EST171=TTIDi 6ECORD57d:OLZST or rni61.CD DiiiETRG%it -I4 W.'i7KQTxl'AIUtLLLs[L7CTiQ\7CFOR\I: T7T4Il*.OI:Lf7EDTIIITTOS tn•0�5ttn1'Cc[r[R'[Fn+^_.OYIIX7>'[.Li[R. NOMMAff.CMMUN[LS5 1\IMCc1+IT KITtIFM[IFc Cndlt b'eFTd'O CInFO S\lf glMn n d[ rtlf LFn fY iSFflIPDI\TF'Amy, .::.11el`41 /d I0 "YAW 7I017DE 122,[o=IAIE CDSTS(ii AK37tOFULML7'NlfMLIC, • '2LC01mSELQ.ZSTLi A05AVCZ;: . • 8+i•Iw.yi-F3iaf IL.LliirF.YN^� •141'nx'an.nJ1[J:iY�1u7.(..4Oad W ILR.Stawly[kpriillL(n.bld.lia�L true. T.��riJifoyiid YiV LliiVNY47 ft-IINC[ fim»82gilo no!polmo F910 Mmol 'ftmooms 'pnods of lsoa palem ra m: S0 asuodsv alcudmddc aql qpm amy;o pmomc alqu=mz e m noL of puods of spaga jwgfnnslz am TMzv .j oql •slsanbaS spzaau oggnd Satmoam )o zagmnn a9mt a no Wuppm flloan0a ss mcaAS 3In'J to u'wl aql •nsolagaacds aql m qpo} las m lsanbu spma a!tgndmol jo uopdpn p mp mgl'pcim sem zsanbu mai31 "Sal»T aeoa soli of pagaslle st lsanbu lcgzdo ;gcd tug aql =p lap! n m pmpa i n.w lsanial moS,ll'tIOZ •£T Scyr pa{9p lsanbaS sp:oaaz aggnd moS paataaaS saq meaAS � 3o n uoL oqL '[moadnar�-assammoa�}sproaS:olL�l "3uI'facdmo0 nogombatlSJO maQ votPau elor=u9,1110llma.rolsrlmnbaxsnLr Y-rr0uoytgom}jforuojq-S of pwnund p9la9poa spool agzlo 9m 0 1 alz4mIU9p gatq% spSm i ltmiuiww2 Ila 9ptww EloI v Zia ssc33 SorL-rlo•asagrolaasoflaaanndspnnrroamaleSlmomapgatgzz spsoaag-6fS HHd ag [moa•dno.ffmrammm n, cNralt! m] mnl'Sncdmoo uog!s!nlnV 0:) vio •SI feNi Ttcm-a nu pug utaQ v=D-u %L riOD Hovaq rrrvd nVVaULS tq-mo tI0 N1,10-1 :motaq MEN aql ul paonpalaaj Si t+4OZ 94 AEV4 pa[ep'tsan ab sploDaa opgnd anoge ag[jo 3uaw5pajmouljDe s,umol agl TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail May 15, 2014 CG Acquisition Company, Inc. [mailto:records@commerce-group.com] Re: PRR# 550- Budget line item where funds were received in connection with sec I of Reso. 011-7 for 2012 & 2013. Provide the budget line item wherin the fitnds received in connection with Section 1 of Resolution 011-7 for the Calendar Year 2012 and also Calendar year 2013 were placed. Dear CG Acquisition Company, Inc. [mailto:records@commerce-group.com], The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated May 13, 2014. If your request was received in writing, then the first page of that request is attached to this cover letter. If your request was verbal, then the description of your public records request is set forth in the space below. The Town of Gulf Stream is currently working on a large number of incoming public records requests. The Town will use its very best efforts to respond to you in a reasonable amount of time with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records EXHIBIT PM1nirro raredn'd7 danalYagl Sq aownbou aql of pa•-odml4ce3Sac jo aavupe m %=,!"qIo-M agdc40 41 W 45 eppoLd V! pam-lap se)1IMSY aql Sq paNawe'slsoa Snc to aamdde aolsanbaa oql mql panaba< aq Ilps lI 3J V-Y:LaFHI 1mb2u sauao3a oriand sIHI. THELCU OS (IVY �m SISOJ 3SF-IwcouddY MT 3(IL.fOad 15 %.- ;IXi1L'II V- .Sfl S\'3S 3H Oi 37i 3aY 531dOJ JLVOal7 T3 TIY ' l0 1o'6li vog»S 30NY@IOJJt V[m"PIIH 3fla '10 O.VY 03ms OdLl. H01ROH5531 OJ Bis 0 SS32 5351 � ON 'li3 L I NO 031 15311 S OJ3a SIHi SYHi SISI h±l \ 3'I3HI flF '.lt SO. ' F 03 JLVOaSJ3'I3. 3H SSiR saaOJ3a SI8L FHZ 03153'1 SISI 'NoUntticl100 vamou an m 03aL1oiIa lI0IS3.ma3H 3HI10 SIHORI mu OI.L1'Y isms aa -H OSIY SI =bHH OU-(TIBYOMMY SV'MZ).3V 10 MOM AHO 11.LY.LS ALTY'KOILVIDN•I.LROH3L£I'JAZ(L07J!n),Jio2MOISHORI.-ffoI). M 3!.-Y @1Y MOJY10 MORIAIT 'I NOMVOO 3HL'AMM OI SHORI A1F'INOI17400 SILL ZLiQlf1 QiTS3RU3iI 05IY SI Q.VF 53SfLLYSS YOia073 3HI.30 6pT H3In c'HJ '.L]Y SQIIOJ3a JlTflad OS L\fi 75a(ld 3QFPI SI353Ila32L SIRS usanbaaolamE alloumquo.4m-LvxoLilaav ,P ao a [a alam LLOZ inaxlCPU ale:) asle pue ZLOz 10 CA Iepuala3 aEll 101 L-{. 1,0 uonnlDSO ll 10 6 u01p0S Ullm u0lloauuDO ul ZttfE'Lq'gac'HPP a a-spanioa0 Pad.-Kl--m oszl :-a--ppv!Loso-Gn-ts6 —3 vsoa-dvas3-aasammmb:paa»t l?c34-3 �NOutllga0aia17VSNOJ S,liOL530D'dTI •oul'Sueowo0 uonlsmhoy g0 --1101 bTa weaASiing)oumolspiooaalouulpolsno 3335V1103a 055 n,sol.'anbaa --fFfeTjT-- 3aobaa3oalca („ mubwY. ail) imbu saaooma :molaq aoe s aql ul poonpoiai s! til OZ £[ XoW palep san a2 le uOlnoA TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail May 28, 2014 CG Acquisition Company, Inc. [mailto:records@commerce-group.com] Re: PRR# 551- Budget line item(s) where funds were collected from sec 1 of Reso 011-7 were expended from, and amount expended from each designated line Provide the budget line item (or line items) wherein thefimds collectedfrom Section I of Resolution 011-7 for both the Calendar Year 2012 and Calendar Year 2013 were expended from; and the amount expended from each designated line item. Dear CG Acquisition Company, Inc.[mailto:rccords(c�).commerce-eroup.coml, This letter is in response to the public records you have requested in your email dated May 13, 2014, that we acknowledged on May 15, 2014. This correspondence is reproduced below. Be advised that no such records exist. Unless we hear back from you, we consider this matter closed. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records EEX7H1Bt:T imams :urerH la�yKa 4-1 ..KA{Hrnarhinulaar.a.aal. r{'0�a!I'ym7Mt^w!V'nw+f R�'tt 9 W WI�Qla'aFMi9 Yli^�a �Nu na }aa�.iaa+aF+ar'+Y�V ia7iY'N'i'1 R•4 'i]7aY.fa},'jllS]]�IYeaiO77Y. 3f11:1 17071'NILtI0i�4.Ya11itOiIIYl�Oi/lY7IIL7RlC'Li3ST17i. it f uZn i u o f w '. t .110 *MM310�:. SIO iL 1111 m A1[270Lsa�nt� aosiu b ciiaiisloi ial'1'iorn sils�oDnt'mri,Y��trcrs��'s�]rimss�na��TM�� . dAY.R:01LY1gII1]lIOHII.11-'aean%xuvy9l�'[ oai7[�i[SYOIDLYIS <tY: Q.a'IS'S773Y3037U'l3AYIAOISSC0�39L'.110ti10tt8:l[::IlY7]�0!aW] 3f D. x3m51, �tSi7L311�o57Y u mY sslanxs Yarxn7t actio at 1aLrfD 'tuiY.+awwwa mut oLnyarivam'mimonffit u1r;na7[nin MY=xIRXxy ob. c� mmanaY 'iwu N!1 PM!fiVW'Poo —4pwvo o �teliPPw,eyl Pur I!PW, W Puwtre uv.tNC k+t!rW)I!]Mw CtK?rlA. 1rP.!I!t!7t414W!I!?11`I tl a?Ilal!'a M t iigW.S weal P�N!IM�Pi!M, ... WI U19mM IguAllo 1 jai Pm oun)mP]O xaoomd, IsM, [ttiL71 toi!,CY!F!M.�9G�]?K+N:>•!.Y./tl.'>rTLT4lIPMC1fi >i wara.a.aada�ri� �.If3'Oa1t17000GI7YIlia7LYaIsi110'7 'ly!AueOwe>wePle►°YD] .�� wwasXIIS m.a'1?Lswo?en30 "p.o +a]. —III— mY" ikS4-"x Gi.werll:'i{O1T.aQiI5ni0Sl� The Town's acknowledgement of the above Public Records Request, dated May 15. 2014, is reproduced In the space below: Town of GULF STREAM PAMBeAcaCglltrn,Rcr mA Delirered ria a -mall Mxy 15. 2014 CGAcTiWtioa Campaay,lnr [mailtoaecotds@c-- nte-group.com] Re: PRRAS51-Budget tine item(s)where fonds were collected from sec 1 of Resp 011-7 were expended from, and amount expended from each desIvuated line Prmide the budget Gne item (or Gne !lams) wherehs the fimdr collected from Section 1 of Rarobrtion 011-7forboth the Cafemdor Yem-2012 and Calendar Yenr2013 wore eaprnded from; and the amount espandedfrom each designated 11ne item. Dear CG Acquisition Company, lac[maslloaecmdV_3%mamerce-group.cam1, The Toon of Golf Stream has received yourpublic records request dated May 13, 2014. If your request was received in nTiting, then the fostpage of that request is attached to this cover letter. If your request was verbal, then the desorption of your public records request is set forth in the space belga•. The Tuan of Gulf Stream is currently working an a large comber of incaauag public records requests. The Tawawill use its very best eBortr to respond to you is a reasonable amount of time with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Togo Clerk Custodian of the Records ` L99b-Z6tiEE -epuou `go28fl wled jsaM L991� xo8 'O,rl aalloajdwo0'8 N1910 }1008 li NOUVHS 90S£-OL9 6796) :auogdajas Ztbb££ upuojd `gouag pjaUiaaQ anuQ ialua0 ljodmoN lsoM 08Z I JJlmujd as o.rd se '01,C09,0 •a ulLi W 1aSNnoo 30 aONd,LSISSV H.LIM (laavda2Id .rapuad utgo-j l.mo0 ag1lo AJOID .aapoa�dwq� ��al� :. �ao� •Ia ni�� vloZ ti bb?fuaaa.Lda uoiljlad so luiujduioa agl ut papumuiap;ajjai agl io3 lumpua{ap lmgl lsuTB& pajowo aq jivA ljne3ap u `os op of sue3 laepua3ap a II • ouvaiagl ,Cjalujpamun io jjtlutmjd UO 03ullas aio3aq iaglta lmoo sr R 30 31iajo agl glrm sasuojap oql ;o [BUISpo agl ajg of puu `aolAIas;o ,Cup aql 3o omsnjoxa yumpuajop vnp uo suoununs sigl Io aou+zas cage s,Cmp OZ unjljm Ztb££ BPPOI3 `gouag PIa7JJaaQ `anuQ 1alua0 jiodmaN isaM 08ZI sj ssoippe asogm aj,Cog,o g ujyrejnj uo uotlpl d io luiujdwoo aql of sasu03ap uaaljaM a,uas of paimbai sc lumpuopp gang £8h££ ZaI `uzuaalS;jn0 PmOH gas OOT :luupuapp uo fins -mei sigl ui lujejduioo agl3o Moo a pue suoununs sjgl avas of (IF1 �IjHOo aav f10A :01uls ag13033PogS gama 01 VGMO'Id 30 a.LVIS alll N � sNornlrnlns } wCO LLJ c 0 ')umpua3aQ J — m= `KVMUS L . o '- A -MD 30 NMOL alu s C= o x� :'ON asvD jjilu!eld a IAO&O 'a M.L-Uvw ow xxxx 9 c o 80 o da Koa 09 it darHO lq ` umnoo xovag W Ivd / I L aoq QIP ILII .LIfloulo Tviolcuu y,SI , ul all L do .L2In00 .LMMII0 alll NI IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15`h JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA MARTIN E. O'BOYLE, Plaintiff, im THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Defendant. THE STATE OF FLORIDA To Each Sheriff of the State: W 502014 CA 0 08 0 7 6 XXXX MB CASE NO.: SUMMONS YOU ARE COMMANDED to serve this summons and a copy of the complaint in this law- suit on defendant: Town of Gulf Strem U' LA- Si reaM 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Each defendant is required to serve written defenses to the complaint or petition on Martin E. O'Boyle, whose address is 1280 West Newport Center Drive, Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442, within 20 days after service of this summons on that defendant, exclusive of the day of service, and to file the original of the defenses with the clerk of this court either before service on plaintiff or immediately thereafter. If a defendant fails to do so, a default will be entered against that defendant for the relief demanded in the complaint or petition. DATED on June 24, 20141 012014 SHARON R. SOCK Clerk& Comptroller Robin Fender By: Clerk of the Court PREPARED WITH ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL Martin E. O'Boyle, as Pro Se Plaintiff 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442 Telephone: (954) 570-3505 Moboyle@commerce-group.com SHARON R. BOCK Clerk & Comptrollsr P.O. Box 4.667 West Palm Beach, Florida 33402-4667 " s e ; n ; g ; S e p u o l d ` ( I ) I I ' 6 I I � o ; ; u e n s m d ` j j p u p i c l X q u o i ; o u i u o d n ` p a ; i p a d x a a q j a i l a u s r s ; s a n b a i i ; m e l d ` X I T e u o i t i p p y s ; s o o p u e s a a 3 s , X a u i O I I g - T ; m e l d S u i p i e r A U p u g ` s p i 0 0 0 i o i l g n d p a ; s o n b o i a g ; o ; s s o o O e a p i n o i d o l ; u e p u a 3 a Q o q ; 2 u l l l o d u i o o p u e ` s p i o o a z o i l g n d o ; s s 0 0 0 g ; i u u a d o ; D n p X i o ; n ; u ; s p u e I g u o p n ; i ; s u o o s ; t } o g o e a a q u i o q o ; ; u e p u a s a a a g ; g u u e l o a p j o p i o u e s N a a s s l p u i e l d ' X u u o U l o o d S ' � 3 a i l a i o l g g ; m b a p u e , u o l m l o o p g o d s u o p o e s i g n ' Z ' 0 3 V s p z O O a N d O t l g n d O T ) ` s a ; n ; g ; S e p u o l d ` 6 I I i o i d L g o p u e u o p n ; p s u o D g p u o i 3 a l p i o b Z � ` I a l O i F / o ; ; u g n s m d s ; g B u l i n i O s d 3 i ; v i g l d 3 o u o i ; g l o i A s , l u g p u a s a ( I a g ; s u i a O u o O u o i ; O e s e g s , " I : s a ; e ; s p u g ( ; u e p u a s a Q ) " m e a g s ; l n D s o u m o s , a q s , s a n s A g a i a g ` l a s u n o o p o u O i s i a p u n a g ; g g n o j q l p u u X q ` ( . d 3 ? l I d ) ` o l X o g , o ' 3 u j M W j j l j u p j a g L a m i a N m Q N V A u o L V 2 I V ' o a a 2 I 0 3 Q N V , L D V S G U O D H H D I ' f f a a S c V Q R I O ' I 3 a D U 0 9 N a 0 1 , L N I V ' I a W O D ( I a l f f I H 1 N O I S I A I G I I A 1 O i 1 ( 1 0 H I 0 H 3 l i O H i d W 0 3 v Y H 3 I 0 ) 1 0 0 8 ' H N O H d H S W o i I - I n r O N P I A K A 0 3 A 1 3 O 3 ��J A d o o : " O N F I S V D l o w x x x x 9 1 O W D M ��1 = V Q R I O ' I d ` A I M O D H O V 3 g W ' I V d 2 I O d � Q N V N I . L I I I D u i o ' N I D I = H I S ' d l L L 3 0 . I . ' m o o . L I ( 1 D u i o a l a N I ; u g p u a s a Q ` W V M U S d - M O 3 0 N M O L H I L L ' A � I I p u l u I d P S O - l d S I ' I A O H , O " $ N I L U V Y 4 PARTIES, JURISDICTION AND VENUE 4. Plaintiff Martin E. O'Boyle is a citizen of Florida who resides in the Town of Gulfstream Florida. 5. Defendant is a Florida municipal government and at all times relevant hereto is an "agency" as that tern is defined in §119.011(2), Fla. Stat. 6. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to Article V, § 5(b) of the Florida Constitution, and §119.11, Fla. Stat. 7. This Court is the appropriate venue for the vindication of the Plaintiffs civil rights because the Defendant is seated in Palm Beach County. 8. All conditions precedent to this action have occurred or have been excused or waived. FACTS RELEVANT TO ALL COUNTS 9. On June 6, 2014, Plaintiff, a real-estate developer, wrote the Defendant's Town Manager William H. Thrasher a letter (the "Sober House Letter") inquiring whether the Defendant required special permitting or approvals before the developing housing for people with disabilities. Specifically, housing for persons afflicted with and recovering from substance abuse disabilities. This type of housing is commonly referred to as Sober Housing or Sober Homes within the Palm Beach County area. This Sober House Letter is attached as Exhibit A. 10. The Defendant was anxious about Mr. O'Boyle's inquiry and on June 13, 2014, the Defendant passed an emergency ordinance regarding Sober Housing, without meaningful advance notice, or any notice at all. The June 13th, 2014 agenda for the Defendant's commission meeting was published on the Town's website on June 61h, 2014, and made no mention of a Sober House ordinance. That document is attached as Exhibit B and the Emergency Ordinance is attached as Exhibit C. 2 M ozlgnd xo3 pa3lse lsanbai sUqun:Td •lsanbw spi000i ollgnd sUquteld of popuodsai luepuo3aQ aql `tiIOZ `6I aun f uO 'jaija7 asnoH iagos aqI sem talpl pagougu aqy , paluuttuassip sem .tallal I pagoene otq gotgm of luensmd `suoRsalununuoo .taglo pue sjzeyq-g 2utpnlaul `spzooa.t otlgnd I[e jo ldoo e apinoid aseal[d]„ `2ugels `uollnlgsuoO epuo13 oglT sainlulS ePuol33o 6l T aaldegO .tapun `luupuajaQ atp of lsanbw spzooat oggnd e opumjj4ululd `tiIOZ `y,LT aunt uO A71 -pop) u lredutuo ieatus a ut talla7 asnoH Lagos snI 2ugeunaassip sem umo.l agl utgl anatlaq of asneo olgegoid uegl mora puq ag panatlaqjpquteld `lutod sigl IV ' £ T •g llglgxa su pagouue st slmuia;o a2uugoxa jjiluleld-ipxm oql, mon sell ut 2untaddeg sero 2unllautos legl [uotleloossy olntO =ogsding oql gtapnloul sqnlo alenud of Ouutada.t] suoqurtueSjo osotp jo saldlouud agl;o ltu lialu Alolulpoutmi p[nom umo I, aql lugl posudtns aq lou pinoqs nox,, `uosiad puooas agl ul jjquteld oql Outssaippu `ponutluoo lgeiX •.qnl ,,,•I!utua piooa.i ollgnd, u XIluomddu sum It se umol oql =4 outeo 11 pias Inq `Ipmo .tag palalap seq ajvn KW,, `poildat l;uzX •.gnl `ul2uo slt acs of Rema mpp Moo u anuq pinoo aq jl pa)jse jIqutuld aqI uogAm •a•I?m sol tuoij aalla'I asnoH .Lagos aql pamonj puq ag Iegl jjgmeld atq papule geiX -iW suogeoumunuoo asoul jo asmoo oql Duun(I •s6ep Iezanas .rano could 31ool oml aql uaamlaq aguegoxa Beata uy •.talla'I osnoH.tagoS oql of ;Iumadat utegu — uteaus3lnO ui 2uisnoH .Lagos 2utp[tnq jo uapi agI tRlm amsealdslp qulssaidxa `jatlaq put: uopmaojut uodn ureazls;InE) jo umo•I• atRjo uazgTo e `UUXX uopioO •3 uu UI04 Rema .taglouu pantaoai JJIlululd aql `t I OZ `t l aunf uO 'ZI 'Q;Iglgxa su pagouue si puma Ingtuug aqj •uaaouoo sr q io; siseq oql sum ialla7 asnoH .Lagos aql lutR puu .tagsLxgl za&uelnl umoy of zonal ,,q aun f s iluteld3o Cdoo a pantaoaz aq Iugl llu!L agl palzale Izetlttteg zlnl tuuazls;IttD 3o umo j aqI }o uozq�o a Izuguzeg Q �tezO utoz3 lteuta ue panlaoaz qute[d agl `bIOZ `ZT aunf uO -11 records as that term is used and defined in Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, including § 119.011(12) Fla. Stat. and Art. I, § 24(a) of the Florida Constitution. The Plaintiff s request and the Defendant's response is attached as Exhibit F. 15. The Defendant alerted the Plaintiff that Town Manager Thrasher hand delivered a memo (the "Sober House Memo") to the Town commissioners and to Defendant's special counsel, Robert Sweetapple, Esq. The Sober House Memo is attached as Exhibit G and the email to Mr. Sweetapple containing the Sober House Memo Exhibit H. 16. The Defendant also advised Plaintiff that 2 unknown persons received copies of the Sober House Letter via verbal public record request. 17. Plaintiff has personal knowledge that the Defendant receives verbal public records requests. Plaintiff finds it suspicious that the Sober House Letter was sent only to Mr. Sweetapple and not to the Town Attorney John C. Randolph of Jones Foster. Plaintiff also finds it suspicious that Mr. Krafft suggested that the Defendant was disseminating the Plaintiffs Sober House Letter, yet the Town has no record of email dissemination to the public except those referenced in Exhibit G and H. COUNT I — UNLAWFUL WITHHOLDING OF PUBLIC RECORDS 18. Plaintiff re -alleges and incorporates by reference the above numbered paragraphs 1 through 17 as if fully alleged herein. 19. Defendant, as an agency defined in §119.011(2), Fla. Stat. owes a duty to allow access to any person to all public records within its control pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 119.01(1) unless specifically exempted by the Florida Constitution. N 9 pus `salnWI$ 13P?101d `ZI'6i i § m papinoid su `uoilos sigl ul pounom sasaodxo pus `sisoo `soaj s,Souious olquuosmi slid3ilutstd Pm^Av (a) :loy spiooag oilgnd ag1 of IoaCgns ass goiq& spiooza of ss000s aui snap uio4 luspuajaQ agl uiorug (p) `.Isanbai spimai oilgnd s,l141isld 01 aeisuodsoi spi000i IIB oonpoid of Iuspua3aQ alp iapzO (o) .joy spi000 d oilgnd oql pus uoilnlilsuoo uppo13 agl jo bZ § `I slop xV iopun Injm-elun pus lsuopr4gsuooun sena Isanbai sd3nuiuld 01 anisuodsaa spzooai oilgnd IIs giiMd3ilsisld apinoid of amliu3 s,luspuajaQ agl lugl azuloaQ (q) salnl'IS spuo13 `I 1'61 I § of luunsmd 3umag alsipaumn up lag (B) :;moo sigl sXsad jiluiuld `aUoaa-daH 1 aaisaaba I aairia I •um q am;n};o poogilailil u s;soBBns lonpuoa s,luapuopCI pus uusq alqutudaui uu saimpsum spi000i oilgnd jo luiuop aq L 'SZ aql lugl sanaiioq _Uilu!eI I aql `papuodsaz ,illuiusd luupua3aQ ag1 q;lnoglly 'tiZ n�s7 spjooag oilgnd s,uppo1g ,Sq papuldwoluoo ss ss000s jo lssn;ai .to $uiploWjm Inj nslun us salnlilsuoo spiooai palsonbai agl3o soidoo amiquasaidai sJPguiBld apinoid of Impi s,luspuajaQ •£Z •spiooai polsonboi oT of algsoildds uoilduzaxo ,isoln;s;s ou palio luupua3aQ agZ 'ZZ •lay spiooag oilgnd s,upuo13 sapun polduioxo lou ase palsonbaigguiuld spi000i aqZ 'IZ vaul.asuo pogsgqslsa-Ilam pus -IBIS -B13 `(u)(I)LO'6I I§ `uoilnlilsuoo spuo13 ag13o yZ§ `I aloilzy jo uoiluloin ul spiooai palsanboi agl3o saidoo lPFA luuisld apinozd of posrga.i It uagnA ,ilnp SI! palBloin IuspuaJZC[ 'OZ (fl Grant such further relief as the Court deems proper. Dated: June 24, 2014 0 Respectfully submitted, PREPARED WITH ASSISTANCE OF. jC0 U N EL T E O'BOYLE, as Pro Se Plaintiff Martin E. O'Boyle 1280 Vest Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Telephone: (954) 570-3505 mobovle commerce-erouo com :paonpozd uollu3iU'IuapI3o adds, :UmotrN Slleuosiad :aluolput aseald 'jalpuugO loop �q VIM —3o Xup — sap aui axosaq paquosgns pus pauugp ol uzomS HDVaff N IV l AO X. MOD ss( V(ElHO'Id AO aly.LS al og,o •g u!amjN :ouwM ,fg gagoq pue `uoiluuuos[n a21pat roux s.q jo Isaq aql of Ioouoo pus an4 sl puu `uinl oI umoux uoquuuosut pug spiooai uo poseq sl T PIIV`IcINOO Qajl3IuaA sng Iugl sties pus sasodap `moons pnu pagpuapl Xlnp lsig gutaq `ogAL `iajpueg0 loop pmaddu ,Slluuosiad `,iluoglne paaljapun ail ,MN g2IOdgg HDVag IN'IVd d0 XJ NnOD HQRIO'Id 30 d.LVILS NOIS.F'OLIMA Exhibit A Zbb£F VMM.4 x q amivt3Q '3nred lm"60 iVO3 N =/A OBZI LOBO'09CK6 WA • rILL'09["K6 m.L uio]'dno32-a]lauiuio3-AvA 1 •s;uauaeoadui sagpo pus uonoru4suoo io} s4TUM;Id_p2nnb2i bua apnioxa pinom sty} asmoo;p i urea.t}s }TnO }o umo 1, aLl; ploq o; pua;ul pinom am `dl;uanbasuoO •uorgsE} p?der B ul. pasmso} aeoui o; uopua;u? mo sT.;t;Eg; nod pu?uaz I ure2V osnoH iagos -eso} urea -4s }TnO uT asnoq le asn 04 falessaoau axe sjeAosdd-eso/pue s;?uuad ;>;gm o; su uopuuuldxa ue -Io !uop-sumiguoo mod;Ieml? dlsn.on= I •osnoH jagos -e }o Lasrt aq; zo} d;lled?o?un'M aq; uios} pomtbaz s;uuiad io spAoxdd-e ou aq pinom aiaq; I-eLp uuguoo o; za}}al s?g; nod a;r_im I 'tl;?mgHo} urei2osd sT }o uopa;uaualduiT ag; ui2aq o; pua;ul I •sasnoH sagos s -e asn io} ureai}s }Ino ul sasnoq o=bos o; dueduoo'e uuo} o; uolsloap -e ap1;Lu aesq I •Ilam nod spur} za}}al sr q; adoq I iagse.ul,L -aW seaQ spuoT L>xea }�?�J `(s)asnoH iagoS-pasodo�d .Q -d aa2>;uep,I nmol,'sags-eigj, •H taL'T PA :u};y £8ti£8 73 `uuea-Rs }TnrJ psox uas OOI =Q -4s jlrLD Jo umo,L 91TS-9LZ-I99# aMOHda'IUL io•tueaz}s- QLTS-e q;q :'IIyIAT-g VIA tIOZ `9 aunt' SOSE-OLS3S6# auoridaiay iscQ aaarQ viwno-ao3atim:o i ogotu d MaO aoua IOo William H. Thrasher, Town Manager June 6, 2014 Page 2 accountable for any damages which we incurred as a result of purposeful delays. Sincerely yours, COMMERCE GROUP, INC. �I -�r�c L Martin E. O'Bl6yle President cc: William F. Ring, Jr., Esquire — E -Mail P/NPR/SOBERHOUSESOULFSTREAM g liqitlxj June 6, 2014 MAYOR: Scott W. Morgan VICE MAYOR: Robert W. Ganger COMMISSIONER: Joan K. Orthwein Thomas M. Stanley Donna S. White REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM ON FRIDAY, JUNE 13, 2014 AT 9:00 A.M. I.N THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Pledge of Allegiance. III. Roll Call. IV. Minutes. A. Regular Meeting of May 9, 2014 B. Workshop.Meeting of May 9, 2014 V. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. VI. Announcements. A. Regular Meetings and Public Hearings 1. July 11, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 2. August 8, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 3. September 12, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 4. October 10, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 5. November 14, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 6_ December 12, 2014 @ 9 A.M. VII. Communications. A. Requests 1. Report on 2014 Legislative Session -Senator Sachs 2. From Residents (5 min. maximum) VIII. PUBLIC HEARING _. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh k Associates, as agent for Robert M. Gardiner owner of property located at 530 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot B, Block 3, Plat No. 1 Polo Fields Subdivision for the following: a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION 1 to permit the addition of a 253 sq. ft. bedroom to an existing home that encroaches approximately 3.5 ft. into the east side setback. b. SPECIAL. EXCEPTION 2 to permit the addition of a 253 \7' sq. ft. bedroom to an existing home that extends approximately 5 ft. into the rear waterfront setback) in the Core Design District. C. LEVEL 3 ARCRITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a 253 sq. ft. bedroom addition to an existing non -conforming Bermuda style, one-story, single family dwelling at the location described herein. IX. Reports. A. Utility Undergrounding-Danny Brannon (Engineer) B. Town Manager SOTO"90Z 'S's•d •asswa 3H OS SI 'IB3ddB 3HI HOIHM Wan 30N30IA3 ONB ANOWIIS3I 3HI S3OO'IONI OH003H HOIHM '3OBW Si 68NI0333OHd 3HI 30 OH003H WIIBSH3A B IBHI 3HOSNI OS 033N AVW '3SOdHOd HJOS H03 ONB 's9NI033OOHd 3HI 30 021033H B O33N MIM xIHBd GIBS '9NII33W SIHI IB 03H3OISNOO Ha"UH ]CNB OI IO3dS3H HIIM NOISSIWWOO NMOL 3HI JCH 30BW NOISI�30 dNB 'IB3daV OI 333S XIHBd 03ISU INI XNB OTBOHS guawuxno�pB •IX SxauorsSTWWOO pug zoAeW Aq swagl •H SdHB uO suoTgTsod 3o guaw;sn CPB 'B •uoTgoB uoTssxwwo0 zo; swagl 6TOZ AeW zo; AgTATgOB •T 98T40 aOTTOd '3 6TOZ 'TE AeW ;o'sg abusn xageM 'Z 6TOZ AeW zo; gzodOH TeTOu2u;3 •T xogOaxTO anueuT3 •O 'W'B OE:B 0 6TOZ 'EZ zagogo0 •a 'W'B 0£:S 0 6IOZ 'SZ xagwagdaS •p gsn6ng uT 6uTgaaw ou sT axagl •O 'N'B OE:8 0 6TOZ '6Z ATnf 'q 'W'B O£=B 0 6IOZ '9Z aunr •e sageO BUTgaaH •T pze03 6utuueTd I naTAeH Texng3aaT40xB , O3ONIINoo VON39B Exhibit*C :smollol se peal ol'sampeomd uonepoww000e algsuoseaa ' (.1-99 uol;oaS 'uogoos mau a apniqul o1 aejauaE) ul 11 a1olPV :6uiuoZ '99 jaldegO;e papuawe 6galaq sl weajlS 1lnJ to umoi aq; to saoueulpio to apoO aql �L uonoag :SMOIIOd SV 'VOIaOId 'AiNnOO HOV38 VdIVd 'WV3211S dlno d0 NMOl 3Hi d0 NOISSIWWOO NM013HI AS 03NIVON011 38 '3W=IHRJ3Hl'MON •6ulllemp a Adue pus asn of A!unlioddo lenba us uosjad palgeslp a piolle of se os swwas pus 'saollomd 'salonod 'salm 'ssoueulpuo s,umol 814; 01 algeolldde aq of sainp000id uonepoww000e algeuoseaj asagl spualul umol aql 'eVgNaHM pus :suollepoww000e algeuoseei anlaoai o1 'mel pus sloe; eql uo paseq a;eudoidde alagm 'pus suonepoww000e e1geu0seai ;sanbei.ol (sallgua 6w6111enb io) slenplAlpul pelgeslp 11uuad nlm Imp saunpeooad uonepoww000e algeuoseaj seoueulpj0 ;o apoO s,umol agl ulgllm ldope of sajlssp 6gejeq umol egi 'SVEMSHM pue :6wsnoq lofue pus a'sn o; 4!unuoddo lenba us uosied qans pjolle of tiessaoau pus elgeuoseei eq lsnw lenplAlpul palgeslP aql /q lg6nos uonepoww000e pasodad aqi -way; o; 'aonoeid ao 'Monod 'elm 'uolslAoJd spo0 offloads a to uopeolldde aq; ul uogaia;le Jo uageoylpow e;senbw ueo 'saln;els peouejejej aql iapun suogepoww000e elgeuoseei jol 6uj4jenb palgeslp eql of saolnias;o Japinwd a jo '(,pelgeslp, iageajaq 'InV sluawpuauiV 6ulsnoH pled 841 io/pue loV s91;111ges10 gl_!m sueopawV a141 10 n ant ul paugap ale suual asogl se) paddeolpueq jo/pue palgeslp sl oqm lenpinlpul ue g014m (q po4law pagsllge;sa Aluolnlels a sl „uonepoww000e algeuoseei. 'SV32l3HM '31V0 3N103dd3 NH JNIOIA021d :NOI1VOIdI000 210-4 EJNIOIAOUd !101ldNO0 NI S30NVNIONO d0 IV3d3N UOd JNIOIAONd Wl18Va3A3S UO=l JNIOIAM]d 'lOV S3111118VS10 H11M SNVORI314V 3Hl d0 11 31111 ONV lOV S1N3WON3WV EJNISnOH NIVd 3H1011NVnsand smn0300W NOIIVOOWW000V 318VNOSV3a UOd ONIOIAONd '14-99 NO1103S 'NO1103S M3N V 30nlONl Ol :IV83N3fJ NI 'I 31011W !eNINOZ '99. N31dVH0 Ol 1N31NON3WV NV `JNIOIAOUd 'VORlOId 'KwnOO HOV38 WIVd 'WV3211S dlno d0 NMOl 3H1 d0 NOISSIWW03 NMO-L 3H1 d0 3ONVNI080 NV 'ON 3ONVN1@i0 "Chapter 66 ZONING ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL Sec. 66-11. Reasonable Accommodation Procedures. (1) This section implements the policy of the Town of Gulf Stream for processing of requests for reasonable accommodation to its ordinances, rules, policies, and procedures for persons with disabilities as provided by the federal Fair Housing Amendments Act (42 U.S.C. 3601, et seq.) ("FHA') and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Section 12131 et seq.) ("ADA"). For purpose's of this section, a "disabled" individual or person is an individual that qualifies as disabled and/or handicapped under the FHA and/or ADA. Any person who is disabled (or qualifying entities) may request a reasonable accommodation with respect to the Town's land use or zoning laws, rules, policies, practices and/or procedures as provided by the FHA and the ADA pursuant to the procedures set out in this section. (2) A request by an applicant for reasonable accommodation under this section shall be made in writing by completion of a reasonable accommodation request form, which form is maintained by (and shall be submitted to) the Town Clerk. The ' reasonable accommodation form shall contain such questions and requests for information as are necessary for processing the reasonable accommodation request. The reasonable accommodation request form shall be substantially in the forth setforth in subsection (10) below. `+%.- tlY�ib (3) Should the information providetl"bry the disabled' individual to the Town include medical information or records, including records indicating the medical condition, diagnosis or medical history of the disabled individual, such individual may, at the time of submitting such medical information, request that the Town, to the extent allowed by law, treat such medical information as confidential information of the disabled individual. The Town shall thereafter endeavor to provide written notice to the disabled individual, and/or their representative, of any request received by the Town for disclosure of the medical information or documentation which the disabled individual has previously requested be treated as confidential by the Town. The Town will cooperate with the disabled individual, to the extent allowed by law, in actions initiaTed by such individual to oppose the disclosure of such medical information or documentation, but E the Town shall have no obrigation to initiate, prosecute or pursue any such action, or to incur any legal or other expenses (whether by retention of outside counsel or allocation of internal resources) in connection therewith, and may comply with any judicial order without prior notice to the disabled individual. (4) The Town Manager, or his/her designee, shall h e the authority o const er and act on requests for reasgnab(e accommodation, after notice and public hearing to receive comments, input and information from the public (provided, however, the Town Manager or designee shall not be required to render their decision at said public hearing). When a orcfl n= No. — Page 2 of 6 9 j E e6ed _ON omn em flgeuoseej Be uoos se uogeuluualep a japuai '6uu eq oilgnd a pue ao46u oilijod Jaye 'pegs oqm ubissiwwoo umol ayi'ol aq pays sleaddy •leadde aLil jol spuna6 ayj jo pejap jusi uns Buiuiejuoo juawalsis a up.4 uoo pegs sleadde py •uoisioap eta leadde few lueoildde yens '/4jed 6ugsanbei ayi of peliew sl jsenbai uollepoww000e algeuoseei a uo uopeuiuuajap 's,aau6lsap Jo 's�86euelnl nmol ay) Jaije sfep OE uILIPM (9) •leadde us jo juana ayl ui uoisslwwoo umol mill fq jo 'aeu6isap io 'jeBeuslN umol ayi fq apew jsanbei uopepoww000e algeuoseai a uodn uoisioap e lol siseq eLp aq pegs (slmoo ay) fq palaidiajui se) 6uio6alol eyl •6uisnoy fofua pue asn of fgun4joddo lenbe suosiod palgesip/paddeofpuBq p104e of fiessaaeu pue aigeuoseei we jgBnos 6uiaq suogepoww000s pasodoid aLijjmg aleAsuowep of aney Minn flied Bugsenbej ay) 'jxaN •jueuuledwi g6ns Guiney se papieft ale fay) ley; (In) Jo juaUmedwi tions Bumall jo pJoow a (f) :saginipa alif Jofew ejow Jo auo sllwp fileyualsgns tiolym luouuiedwl leluaw to leoisfyd e U :mot's )snw lenpugpui palgesip ayj uopoas slyl jo sasodmd jol 'uoileiaidjajui leioipnf of loafgns si fliligesip to uopIuUap ayl y6noylly •yQy �o/pue VHj 941 ul paugap se 'paigesip jo paddeoipuey eje 'juasaidej feyl f1Jed ayi jo 'fay; jeyj 6uge4suowap fq yo jo pue dHj ayl japun pa ad aje ayj jeLij q9fl—quiso of paAn ai eq—pey upsan ayi 'paluap jo peluwB aq pet's jsanbei uogepoww000e algeuosaw ay) jaylaym 6uiulunalep ul (g) •paiinbei aq hays jsenbei uopepoww000e elgeuoseai pies of piuSei yjim umol eLn fq uopoe jayunj ou pue umeapLplm Jo/pue pauopuege paweep eq lleys uopepoww000e elgeuoseei juj jsanbai atil eiolaiayl pue 'uopeuuo;w leuo4lppe ay) ilwgns flewg• of papal peq fled 6ugsenbai aLil jail; 6uisinpe aoljou uajjum a anssi pegs 'aau6lsap jo 'ia6euelnl umol ayj 'pouad fep-g{, pies uiy)fm uogeuuolul leuoi)ippe palsenbei eyl epinoid of spa} flied 6ugsanbaj ayl1l •uogauuolul leuoplppe ay1 jo jdleoau jajje sfep pg ultipm U0413UIWJajap ua}junn e anssi hays '890lsap Jo 'JoBouefy umol ayi pue 'elgeopdde aq jaGuol ou ileys uoijeuiwlajap uaAum is anssi of pouad fep -gy ayi 'apew sl uoileuuojul leuopippe jol jsenbai a juana ayl ul •uoijeuuolui palsanbei eqj opfnoad of uopewjojul leuopippe jol jsenbei ayl jo a)ep ayi Ialje sfep 91 aney pegs feed 6ugsanbaa mill pannbal si uolIeuuolui leym pe)ap juaioyjns ul Buifjioads 'flied Bugsanbal atil woy uogeuuojul leuoylppe jsanbai ' pouad fep-gt pies jo pue ay} of loud 'few 'aau6lsap jo IJaBeuefni umol eLg 'uogepoww000e algeuoseai jol jsanbai ayj uo uogeuluLaiap a tioeai of,Uessaoau flgeuoseaj ji •palsenbai ldieoai wnlaj 'pew peuglao fq (anfjeluesaidai Jay/siy jo lenpiNpui paigesip ayi •a•i) 4ed 6uysanbai ayi of lues aq pays uol)euiuuajep to aopou ayi •leadde of jy6u aql jo aopou an16 pegs suogeuwuejep uajlum pt' •jojejegl spunm6 ayj alels Ileys pue 6ugunn ui aq Heys leivap Lions fuy -mei laiapal yjim souep000e ui ')senbei ayl fuap (o) m :jsenbei eLa jo juelB eyj uodn suoplpuoo asodwi jo/pue 'jsenbei OLD jo uo.qjod a fuap PUB jsanbai ayj jo uoipod a juei6 (q) gsanbei uoppoww000e 941 jue16 (e) :Mei leUapaj tipm aouepv000e ul 'faw PUB uogeoildde pajeldwoo a jo ldiaoaj jo alep ayj jo sfep gq ultipm uopewunajap uajjpm a anssi pegs 'aau6lsap Jo 'JaBoueW umoi mill uogeiaplsuoo pue mama) Joj 'aauBlsap Jo 9a6eueln) nmol aLi1 01 pauejej aq Him p VOID'umol 9y1 of palliwgns pue paieldwoo ueaq say uuol )sonbei uogepoww000e elgeuoseei practicable, but in no event later than 60 days after an appeal has been filed. (7) There shall be no fee imposed by the Town in connection with'a request for reasonable accommodation under this section or an appeal of a determination on such request to the Town Commission, and the Town shall have no obligation to pay a requesting partys (or an appealing party's, as applicable) attorneys' fees or costs in connection with the request, or an appeal. (8) While an application for reasonable accommodation, or appeal of a determination of same, is pending. before the Town, the Town will not enforce the subject zoning ordinance, rules, policies, and procedures against the applicant. (9) The following general provisions shall be applicable: (a) The Town shall display a notice in the Town's public notice bulletin board (and shall maintain copies available for review In the Town Clerk's office), advising the public disabled individuals (and qualifying entities) may request reasonable accommodation as provided herein. (b) A disabled individual may apply for a reasonable accommodation on his/her own behalf or may be represented at all stages of the reasonable accommodation process by a person designated by the disabled Individual. (c) The Town shall provide such assistance and accommodation as is required pursuant to FHA and ADA in connection with a disabled person's request for reasonable accommodation, including, without limitation, assistance with reading application questions, responding to questions, completing the form, filing an appeal, and appearing at a hearing etc. to ensure the process is accessible. (10) Reasonable accommodation request form: 1. • Name of Applicant 2. Telephone Number. 3. Address: 4. Address of housing or other location at which accommodation is requested: 5. Describe qualifying disability or handicap:. 6. Describe the accommodation and the specific regulation(s) and or procedure(s) from which accommodation is sought 7. Reasons the reasonable accommodation may be necessary for the individual with disabilities to use and enjoy the housing or other service: ortLnmm No. — Page 4 of 6 910 9 a6ed --ON MMUIPIO iauolsslwwo0 Jauoissiwwo0 I Jauolsstwwo0 jo{eW eon Jo/eW '1760Z 'aunp l0 6ep yl£ l sly; 6wpea lsig uo uolsses pawnofps 'jeln6ai a ul eoueulpi0 loua6jawo ue se 031dOCIV (INV 03SSVd ,mel 6q papinmd SE 'lenadde pue a6essed sll uodn llelelpawwl loaga a> el pegs aoueulp o styl -9180 ang0a43 g uog0ag -weeilg;ln0lo umol a41 ;o seoueulp o ;o epo0 lep!go ay1 ;o }ied a apew pue pagipo0 aq pays aoueulpi0 s!yl uoge0ylpo0 •y uogoaS •paleadai Agaay eie aoueulplo s141 to lied Ilue to slyl yl_lm lollluoo yolym loaayl shed jo 'epuol3 'weegs;lnO;o umo194110 saoueulpio jaylo IIV •lolguo0 ul saoueup010 leadalj -g uolloaS •algelanas paeloap 6gejay are aoueulpl0 slyl to suolslnad an pua s141 of pue 'suolleolldde jo suolslnwd ppenul ayl ;nayllm 10949 uanl6 aq ue0 yolym eaueulpio s141 }o suogeopdds jo suoislnad jaylo ayl loage lou pegs /llpgenul yons 'pllenw play sl loaayl uogeopdde ayl jo soueulpl0 slyl }o uolslnad lue;I vgplgejaAeS -Z uogoaS :ale0 :A19u3 6wly!lenZ1 io'algedlldde 1!'angeluasejda}d jo lenpinlpul palges1010 ainleu6lS OL :uopeuuo;w JsglO -6 :algeopdde ll angeluesada 10 iagwnu euoydelal pue ssaJppe aweN •g ATTEST: Clerk p:Wo M110147100001 WocllM212.dac Ordmance No. — Pace 6 Of 6 Q liqitl-xq From: Marty O'Boyle Sent: Thursday, June 12, 2014 8:03 PM To: Craig D. Earnhart Subject: Re: PROPOSED SOBER HOUSES- GULF STREAM Craig- kindly call me 561-213-3486 Sent from my HTC -- Reply message -- From: "Craig D. Earnhart" <cdelawCcDbellsouth.net> To: "Marty O'Boyle" <mobovle(a�commerce-erouo com> Subject: PROPOSED SOBER HOUSES- GULF STREAM Date: Thu, Jun 12, 2014 7:05 PM Good evening Mr. O'Boyle: I just received a copy of your June 6, 2094 email to Gulf Stream Town Manager, William Thrasher, advising of your plan to "forthwith" begin acquiring houses in Gulf Stream for use as Sober Houses. I would like for you to know that during your recent campaign for a seat on the Gulf Stream Town Commission I acquired a great deal of admiration and respect for you, spent an evening at your lovely home getting to know you and discussing your goals and vision for improving Gulf Stream, and actively campaigned for you. At that time I was convinced that your motives were all noble, and that you truly wanted to do only good and productive work for our town. Your proposed Sober House plan says otherwise. Certainly you know that opening and operating Sober Houses in the Town of Gulf Stream can do nothing but bring down property values, and would be strongly opposed by not only the city officials, but also virtually all of the residents of our quaint little town. I find it difficult to believe that your motives are purely philanthropic in nature. Since you clearly don't need the money possibly generated from this proposed plan, I can therefore only assume that your motives are purely vindictive and retaliatory in nature. This leads me to question my own naivety in buying into your.campaign promises of Wanting only the best for our town. I only hope that your letter was intended for shock value or an idle threat, perhaps sent out in a fit of rage; or perhaps even meant as a joke. If you are truly sincere in your Sober House plan, I fear that you will swiftly lose the respect and support of those like me who came to believe so strongly in you during the recent campaign. Maybe that doesn't mean much to you, but it seems to me tragic that you would be willing to forfeit your hard-eamed honor in such an act of spite. £8b££'L3'mUZ)48 jlnf) NZ)Jl3 IsuipieD rrLZ lauquana 'a 2I61Z) 61eJO 'AlaJaouis suoisniouoo !ue o} f uiwoo aJolaq sigl uo noA wo4jeaq o} Addeq we Exhibit E :s;uawwoo 6ulmollol ay; aas aseeld 'aplse anoge ayl aopueo ano ( a;eloaadde gonw I •Ilewo ano C jo; no( gluey; — uopio!E) )jenl uopjog Aq weaj;s;Ing - sasnoH aagoS :3b :;oafgnS we W9 Y60Z'L4 unr'anl:;uaS <wo0�ioe uopjo ;ols> 3jejN uopIag :01 <wo0 na-aoJawwoo al ogow>GIAOEI,of4jelnl:woj4 —a6essaW 1eu16110— uerl uopJo0 •4 •;l >luup o; moy p8weel19nau I aplse ue sy •lagwanoN pun epliold ul Noeq aq;ou Illm I'pawaouoo sl eagoo se Je; sy -Alloanp no i o; pasoddo se anssl ay; uo ajow sl snoo; ay;'panlonul 6uleq;o,gplglssod a pa;e01put aney nob 91!4M •Allunwwoo mo o;ul sasnoH jagoS;o uogonpoa;ul ay; I1e;sa101 o; aney;y6lw umo; ay; peoidde hue ;l leym aas o; sem sag ied pa;saia;ul o; Ilewe roof,;o uognglj}slp ay;'p84e01pul I sy •mou eloueied ay; 6uldol9nap aie no! anallaq I do;sly se aweu gay Sluo QM aw 0111 pallewa a;lmAw;eyl sl JayseJyl JlN o;vagal moi(;o Sdoo a aney I uoseai ayl :alAo9.o •jNl }le.iN uopaog Aq weaj;S;Ing - sasnoH aagoS :aa :aoa[gns . alAo9,o ,'4jeW :ol Wd EEZ bIOZ `Li aunt lAepsanl ques wo0•loe uopja ;ols:o;llew yeaA uopiog :woad Whether I decide to participate as a consultant for a Sober House Operator gives no one the right to commence a smear campaign. A Sober House is an enterprise that everyone in Gulf Stream could fight (although I think they will lose — as it is ADA protected). I am an individual. I have no problem with the people bad mouthing Sober Houses, I do have a problem when it oozes over to me and my family. I hope you understand. This situation is no different than a lawyer representing a criminal. Fight the crime — not the lawyer. Gordon, you have my word that I have still not decided to take on the Sober House Assignment. I continue to struggle with it_ Having said that, if I do decide to accept it, I will let you know. Absent hearing from me means I "took a pass". Once again, I appreciate your candor PS: I will make a Public Records Request for your wife's email.- If I get it, great, if I don't, I have to come back to you, If she deleted it, it should be in here deleted box. Alternatively, it is certainly available as metadata. I assume that although she asserts deleting the email that she retained the attachment (as your email below demonstrates). I think if you could come around behind me and look over my shoulder and see what I see, your perspective would change. No one who make a query about a legal matter should be chased by.a posse. I point out that when I woke up this morning, I was in America_ Gordon — your comments are insightful and appreciated (not to mention now received). Are you willing to help me and the 122 others address what needs to be addressed in Gulf Stream? We could sure use your help. I believe that our overall goals are the same. If you get a chance, look at the video's of the Commission Meetings under "Agendas\Minutes" Lastly, is it time for us to have a coffee? I'd enjoy that very much. Let me know an thank you, Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 Cell: 561 213 3486 E-mail: moboyle(a)COmmerce-group com Web Page: WWW.commer-e-group com From: Gordon Kraft fmailto:slotcordon(a)aol coml Sent: Monday, June 16, 2014 8:08 PM To: Marty O'Boyle Subject: Re: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream by Gordon Kraft Mr. O'Boyle: My wife has deleted her email, but said it came from the town as it was apparently a "public record email". By the way she doesn't get emails at Coldwell-Banker. " s n u a a m ) a q A l l e w a j u t j ! a l p u e q l a g j e l p i n o m ! a g e l a V y J l a g l J o ; r i s e P u e J 8 N u e 8 p a m p l e o l o e j u o o e l d o a d l i I n o B A e t l o f j u e m J , u o p A p e a l I ' p u e y j o I n o j a g i j n j s l a b j ! a o l a q G u a m a j y 6 u o ) i s ! o p o f j u e m i 1 ! b ' " I ! P S A I a 0 E U a y s w o y m A p e o ! I ! o a d s w a ; s m o u l l A I 9 N ! i p u e : w a ; J e j l a l 9 L n p a A ! e 0 9 1 a y s ( J e N u e g p a m p l e o J o l e u o s i a d ) j u n 0 0 0 e ! ! e w e g o l g m s m o u ��l a y s A l a j n S l e g u a p p o o j ! d a a ��l I l p ! p u e j o ; 6 w ��l o o l w e ! l e g m s e y a y s m o u s I ' A p e l p e q a I O U s ! a y s l e t l j s ! e s u e s A w I n q ' . i a y J a w J a n a u a n e y ! " a j e d ! 0 ! j j e d o f u a s o g o s e m o q m , p M o j o u l a y j * a u o s e m a I ! m i n o A a w n s s e l " m a 6 p ! m A a g j j o e j u ! * d o l s l , u o m A a t g i 0 ( A l M o ! n b p n q a y j u i p a d d l u ) y j l m I l e a p a q o I a n e y s u f i ! e d w e o j e a w S ' I w j s ! y l l a ! j , u e o ! ' u O p j O E ) " s n y } l m I s e u o q 6 u i a q j o u s e m a o A e W u a y l e q ) ' A ! e j e u n i j o ; u n " s i a L o o p u e ( J a A m e 1 u m o l e q j ) g d l o p u e a d j i S ' ! u e p A e q w o l ' e j o w 1 3 a b j o a E ) A q p a s s a u l l m t o p a n o u d d e j e t J J J n ; p u e u l e m L p o l o A e I A I u s g j A q p a n a d d e s e m u o g o e j o a s i n o o J e y l ' ( p a j e u l L w a j a q p i n o y s N u i g j ! o t l m u e w e ) l e y s e j y l " l W o f j a p a l e q j p u s s p ! p ! ' s a ) , " r a n o s t u 6 l e d w e o a y j ' J a n a m o y ' M O N ' " A e m 1 9 y 1 0 a y ) P e ) i o o l ! ' u 6 l e d w e o a s e m I ! a o u l S " a n 0 w a y J u o S l a m s i o w n i A j s e u e q j p u e I y 6 l s w a ; p e j e a d d e s ! p s u 6 ! s A t u ; o L 9 I , u a y m u 6 l e d w e o a y j 6 u u n p j ! u e e s I " ; o a l g e d e o e i e A s g j s j l o u l 4 ! p a y j p u e s a l s i e d o u m o l s ! y j m o y m 0 u > l I ' u o p j o E ) - n o A % u e y j ! y o l t l m j o l ' s ! s e q A l p u a i 4 J o \ p u e l ! A ! o a u o m o u a l e ( j s e a l l e s i e a d d e j ! ) a m j e g j p e s e e l d y o n w t i a A w e ! w e s ! y l I g u n m o l a q h e w s i n o A S a s I O U p p ! u o p l o E ) j ; e j > I u o p i o E ) A q w e e A S j ! n E ) - s e s n o H j a g o S : M J : l o a ( g n S w e 0 0 : 9 b 6 0 Z ' 9 l , u n r u o l r y : I u a S < w o o - l o e u o p j o l o l s > g e J > l u o p j o O d : o l < w o o n o g - a o j a w w o o a l o g o w > a l A o g , O A u e W : w w 4 a 6 e s s a p q l e u l 6 u o U M A u o p , o E ) " 4 " s s a i p p e o f s p a e u n m o l a y l l e y l s 6 u 1 y j ; o I s l l a y l u m o p A e m a q p i n o y s y o t y m a n s s l u e u o s n o o ; o f a l d o a d s o l o ; A ! a % ! l p i n o m p i e m i o l 6 u t o 6 s o u l s d n A p n p o d d o s l y j s s e d n o A j e y j a d o y p i n o m ! * n o A o f a p e w l e s o d o i d a y l y 8 m p i e m i o ; 6 u l o 6 ; o e e p l e q j y j l m 6 u ! p s a i m p g s a l e n o A j e g j a w o I A l e l e n u d p a j e o l p w a n e y n o A " u m o j s l y l ; o s l u e p i s a i ; o s p u l w a y j u l a n s s ! e n g l s u a s t i a n e o f a j e l e j A a y j s e s j u a w w o o u m o i n o A j o j o e d w l a y j p u o A e q a o e l d 6 u l ��l e j s l 6 w J e e w S A u e a n a l l a q p o p I p 9 u j e o u o 3 s l u 6 l e d w e o j e a w s a s e j e ; s y " e u e j u s ! y l u l 6 u l u e d d e y s e m 6 u ! y l a w o s j e y l s u o l l e z l u e 6 j o e s o y l ; o s a l d l o u u d e q j j o p e p a l e A l e l e l p a w w l p i n o m u m o l a y l j e y l p e s u d j n s a q j o u p i n o y s n o A " y j ! m y p o ; w e i 6 o i d s l y l ; o u o l l e j u a w a l d w l a y j u ! 6 a q o f p u e j u l I " s a s n o H J a g o S s e a s n j o ; w e a j j S d l n E ) u l s a s n o y e i l n b o e o l A u e d w o o a u u o ; o f u o l s l o a p a a p e w a n e y l : 6 u g e l s a a y s e j y l " j l n l o f j a g a l j n o A l u e s n o A u a y M " s j e a A o m l j s e l e q l u ! y o e a g A e l 1 a p u l 6 u u e a d d e p a l i e l s A e g l a o u l s J a n a s a s n o y j e g o s j o e r i s s l e y j 6 u l m o p o ; A l a A l } o e u e a q a n e y . u o l l e n l a s a J d J o ; u o l l ! l e o O a y l p u e ' u o g e l o o s s y o l n l O w e a l S ; ! n o a y l ' u m o l a y l ; e y l m o u N p i n o y s n o p u e y ; o I n o s j a 6 I ! a l o l a q G u a m a j y 6 p o f a n s e p a p u e , u 6 l e d w e o i e e w s 8 0 1 1 9 1 9 1 n o A l l e w a j n o A u l If you would like to have a coffee sometime soon, I would like that. But I reiterate, I must get to the core here. PS: It appears you are from Pittsburg where we own property all over (from South Hills to Monroeville to Greensburg, etc). No Sober houses there or anywhere else. I'll wait to hear from you. Thank you Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 Cell: 561 213 3486 E-mail: moboyle((Dcommerce-orouD.com Web Page: www.commerce-proup.com From. F Gordon Kraft fmailto:slotgordon0aol.coml Sent: Sunday, June 15, 2014 10:55 PM To: Marty O'Boyle Subject: Re: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream by Gordon Kraft Mr. O'Boyle: Thank you for your reply. I appreciate your forthrightness. My wife deleted the copy of the letter, but I can only assume it was sent out by the town or someone in the town leadership. I know this has been a concern of the Civic Association, so I'm certain they are active in any efforts to limit proliferation of sober houses in the town. F. Gordon Kraft Sent from my iPad On Jun 15, 2014, at 6:25 PM, Marty O'Boyle <mobovle c(Dcommerce-arouo.com> wrote: Gordon — I feel no obligation to respond. I am writing to you now voluntarily. I have no intention of putting a sober house in Gulf Stream for reasons, inter alia, I wouldn't have a clue on how to run one. I was however approached by an out of state company that seems set on putting sober houses in Gulf Stream and the surrounding areas (but only on the water in Gulf Stream). For reasons unknown to me, they asked me to lead their charge. They offered to pay me a very handsome sum. I am struggling with their offer (whether to accept it or not). As I.said it is a ton of $$$ and I know if I don't take it someone else will. uogeuwo;ul sly; aJeys o; uogua;ul ou aney noAAguaieddy •poya sly; Bulnsmd ul uol}enl;ow mob jo; noR 6ui> se (ldwls we 1-weans;ino w jaumo awoy Jay;o Sue;o;ey; uuLg luaia;}lp ou /lgegold sl j! 'pawaouoo sl eloue-ied Rw se je; sy '(Oym mouN;,uop I ) wea4s jlno ul auoawos wa; Jlewa ue ut panlaoal a;im AW yolym 'jaysei4l'jlN o; japal jno6;o Rdoo a uey; lay;o nob io; uo.gewio}ui Aue aney;,uop Clleaj I :a1(oe,o 'JW pej>l uopjoo Cq weaj;S;lnO - sesnoH jagoS :9Z1 :joofgnS 910SO Ajievq :01 Nd BE:VVIoz'9L aunrAepuns puss woo•loe uop'o ;ois:olllew pejo{ uopjoo :wojd woo noa-eoTewwoo•nnnnnn :a6ed qaM woo nou-eoaaf-uwoo al ogow :I!ew-3 99fiE £6Z 499 :IIGO L090 -09£-t,96 :Xe=1 505E-0LS-1796 :11214 40811Q Zbt7£E 'Id '40ea8 pla!�taea eAIJC] uajua0 :podMaN •M 09ZL oul 'dnou0 eo.iewwo0 'GIA09,0 •E] ullieW o; 41e; o;,�Sea we I •6uu a aw ani6 'op nog(•;I 'ew wa; uot;euuo;ul gay;o {ue;uem no (;i mous aw;aj pue suoi;ua;ui s, (ddnC);noge mouil aw;aq •aw spues ays;eym leanaj;ou o; uoi;ua;ui Aw aq p1nom11 -op o;;uemIOU Op I yolym 'jai ueg liampleo o; japai uol;eilods ou a puss o; aq pinom GAI;ewa;le ;sed ellnl 'papal uogeilods ou a jay puss pinoo i os pooh aq pinom;eq;'ssa.ippe Plewa Jay aw 9n16 pinom no( j! 'sesn;aj ays;1 'op o; 6uly;;g6u ay; aq pinom (Nuly; I) pue pa;eloajdde aq pinom;ey; y6nojy;;uam;snf I pue no (;eym Alone o; aw moue pue liewe ay; aw pJewol o; jay Nse o; y6noue pui% aq pinom nol;I - Cepo; pue AepJa;sari;i panp GM 'dn 6uwi;s;o elgedeo si;i;ey; sanssi ay; eas no) gewa em paniaoaJ ajvm moA japan ay; jo sisaueB ay; ;no puy;snw i;ey; pue;siapun no( adoy i 'ap!se amoge eyl -epua6e AW uo aiaymou si asnoy jagos a 6ui;ejado jo 6ulumo;eadai I •aney I adoy i pue :asea;e puiw jnol;nd o; pa;uem I aouis ';i PIP I •(aney;ou pinoys AI@N!i i y6noy; uama) 6wy�Uana noR pio; aney I mou 'IIaM •nof, 6uins }o uogua;ui (ue (pey Janau pue);,uop I asneoeq ssal6ulueaw si uoissnosip ay;;nq ';oejjoo;ou si s;lnsmel;noge pies noA;eyM •o; sueld ou aney pue nokens o;;uem;,uop i;eLp pamsse aq '96ed ay; 6uiwn I •asnoy aagos a joj4adoid flay; ;o uoiv.sinboe ay; y;Im uoi;oauuoo ui paiinbui (eogo !w buipnloui) I /es Jana pinoo;ey; weaj;S }InE) ui ouo ou si a.layl I also am not too concerned about a lawsuit I believe that there is still a requirement in this countryfor a basis for bringing a suit Asking a simple question seem to satisfy that hurdle. Don't feel any obligation to reply again. F. Gordon Kraft —Original Message -- From: Marty O'Boyle <mobovle(cDcommerce-orouo.com> To: Gordon Kraft <slotoordonQaol.com> Sent Sun, Jun 15, 2014 12:18 pm Subject: RE: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream by Gordon Kraft Gordon — this "back and forth" is fun, but your paranoia is really quite sad. All I Want is to protect the documents (electronic and otherwise) which you have re me and\or sober houses from spoliation. There is an obvious undertow which you clearly can't see or don't understand. As you have decided to cavy the torch by spreading unfounded allegations, all I ask is to prevent the documents from spoliation, which I feel comfortable you will do. Incidentally, please don't feel sorry for me as I am the happiest guy you don't know. If I had a high desire to sue you, I would have a process server at your home in the am. Having said that, you need not worry, despite your paranoia, I have no present desire to sue you. If that changes, I will call you and try to sit and talk the issue (whatever that may be) out with you in an effort to avoid litigation. This is the normal way that I deal with things. Are you willing to share with me where you got the letter (and the other writings, if any) and the content of any conversations surrounding the issues at hand? I apologize for being brash with you, but your wild assertions are really intolerable. I also remind you about who started these reckless assertions. Why don't you call me and come clean. If you do, I think things will end and I think you will see the light. If you don't and I hear your name as a person spreading rumors about me, this will not end pretty. I leave the decision up to you. Have a good day. Be carefuli Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deertield Beach, Fl. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 -noA o; algellene(sauoyd llao pue sapol!sodai aulluo'swels,Cs 6ul6essaw -aolon's;ue;slsse le;l6!p leuosiad'uope;lwp;nogjIm'6ulpnloul) saolnap pue elpaw Jay;o pue swelsRs Ja;ndwoo jauuo} pue lua;uno uo pajols uol;euuolul ay; sapnlow ly6nos uogeuuolul a41 •uoge6gp ain}n; w tianoos!p o; an!suodsal jo !ejnsolos!p o;loefgns eq /Caw uopeuuolul ayl leyl aledlol;ue pinoys no -oso6 •o•sn 96 japun asngy pue pnejdja;ndwoo jo uo!lewelap�ol swlelo'elleialul'apnlou! Rew swlelo yo!ym („uo!leuuolulw ey;) elAog,o 6q swlelo legualod o; luenalai agSewjos!yolymuogeuuolul'uogellw!l;noy;tm'6u!p low'uogeuuolulpajols 6peoluoiloale pue sluawnoop pue splooai pe 6u!pnlou! 'sleloglO su Jo J96euelnl s;l weaAS;InO to umol ay; Rq 6poanpul jo Clloailp jatgla noA o; papinad (elgl6uelui jo elq!6uel) splooai to sluawnoop Gua 6u!pnloul) s6u!y; e!gl6ue;'sluawnoop pue spooai Ile amesaid noA leyl puewep Malay saop (.91409.0.) elAo9,0 u!lieln! (MO139 o3NId30 SV) N011VWNOdNI d0 NOI1VA8M3ad Nod oNVW3O -eswueylo panics jellaq aje s}sajelul ino C pau!wjalap llluandde aney noA Inq 'Niel slemle pinoo 1 pue noA '6uIN Aewo4v loeluoo lesunoo mo C aney pinoys noA 'lesunoo Aq paluesaidal aje no ( p 'esinoo jo -os op of nog( 96 -In 110 1,9C OLS t796) lesunoo Aw jo aw loeluoo o; ys!M noA 11 •aouelldwoo Inlyllel inoR jo; eouenpe u! noA Mueyl l -molaq aas aseeld}}ejyl JW llej)l uopjo0 !q weans 11nJ - sasnoH jegoS :3N :;oafgnS we 60:9 b 60Z '9l ung 'unS :IueS <woo nor aojawwoo upm> 6ulN welll!M:00 <woo-Ioe uopjo lo!S> IIejN uap100 :01 <woo na-aojawwoo a! ogow> al Cog,o fpe!N :wad —a6essalN leul61j0— IIejA uopJoO -d -uosiad pes fU9n a aq o; waas no ( se 'no( fol (wos laal Allenloe I •6ulyjAJ9na ql!M 6u!leep jo Aem jno i aq of swaas le41-slmsmel ueleejgl o; palnls noA piun aq pinom ll 6uol Moy paiapuom I :81409,0 'JW gejN uopjo0 Aq weeAS lino - sasnoH jagoS :aN :loafgnS aI6o9 0 AIJeW :ol WV 99:6 6 4LOZ 'S l eunr' CepunS :;u9S woo-I0e uop10 lols:oll!ew 6eJN uopjo0 :woad woo nog-aojawwoo•MMM :abed qaM woo noa-aojawwoo al ogow :flew-:� 9W UZ 49S :11010 Information should be afforded the broadest possible definition and includes (byway of example and not as an exclusive list) Information electronically, magneticallyand optically stored as: Digital communications (e.g., e-mail, voice mail, instant messaging); Word processed documents (e.g., Word or WordPerfect documents and drafts); Spreadsheets and.tables (e.g., Excel or Lotus 123 worksheets); Accounting Application Data (e.g.. QuickBooks, Money, Peachtree data files); Image and Facsimile Files (e.g., .PDF, .TIFF, .1 PG, .GIF images); Sound Recordings (e.g., .WAV and .MP3 files); • Video and Animation (e.g...AVI and .MOV files); • Databases (e.g., MySgl, Oracle, Access, MS SQL Server, SAP); • Cellular Telephones, to include storage media (e.g., SD cards and micro SD cards) • Contact and Relationship Management Data (e.g., Outlook, ACT!); • Calendar and Diary Application Data (e.g., Outlook PST, Yahoo, blog tools); • Online Access Data (e.g., Temporary Intemet Files, History, Cookies); • Presentations (e.g., PowerPoint, Corel Presentations) • .Network Access and Server Activity Logs; • Project Management Application Data; • ComputerAided DesignlDrawing Files; and, • Back Up and Archival Files (e.g., Zip, RAR, TAR, GZ, GHO) Information resides not only In areas of electronic, magnetic and optical storage media reasonably accessible to you, but also in areas you may deem not reasonably accessible. You are obliged to preserve evidence from both these sources of Information, even if you do not anticipate producing such Information. The demand that you preserve both accessible and inaccessible Information that is reasonable and necessary. Pursuant to amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure that have been approved by the United States Supreme Court, you must identify all sources of Information you decline to produce and demonstrate to the court why such sources are not reasonably accessible. For good cause shown, the court may then order production of the Information, even if it finds that it is not reasonably accessible. Accordingly, even Information that you deem reasonably inaccessible must bepreserved in the interim so as not to deprive a claimant of its or their right to secure the evidence or the Court of its right to adjudicate the issue. Preservation Requires Immediate Intervention You must act immediately to preserve potentially relevant information Including, without limitation, Information with the eadferof a Created or Last Modified date on or after March 3, 2014: Adequate preservation of Information requires more than simply refraining from efforts to destroy or dispose of such evidence. You must also intervene to prevent loss due to routine operations and employ proper techniques and protocols suited to protection of Information. Be advised that sources of Information are altered and erased by continued use of your computers and other devices. 'ute;go Ala;etpewwt noA ;ey; spew st puewap '(s)anup pjey je;ndwoo .ney; uo uol;oe;ue;sul ay; o; 6ulute> ed uotteuuo;ul aney o;AlaMtj uoslad jay;o Lima se item se 91M'mglaq paweu eqol ay; Bulploy jo AUoedeo ay; u! Buqoe uosiad yoea;o pue molaq paweu suosied eta jo yoee to saotnap a6ejo;s pue sanup pieq ey; o;;oadsai ygM •alg dems ay; pue aoeds Moels'eoeds pa;eoolleun se seame yons ut;slxa Aew Imp e;ep ;ueoglu6le Apeotsuaio; amasaid o; site} pue sang e;ep paMoolun'angoe sam;deo Aluo ;! asneoaq 96ewt pagtlenb Alleotsuajo; e;ou sl anup pjey a;o do Moeq leuoquanuoo e;ey; pastnpe ag •anup ay;;o auola Jo e6ewt weal;s;tq a palleo aq osle Aew a;eolldnp paygenb Apeatsuajo; a yong anup ay;;o sio;oas lie 10 a6ewt pag!lenb Alleotsuajo; e;o uogeoguatgne pue uogeaio ay; Aq st sanup pjey !Pool uo e;ep 6ugstxa;oa;ad o; ALM auo 'sanup prey leool o;;oadsai ygM •(aM!l ay; jo A4dejfioue68;s 'uotssejdwoo uol;dtioua'sanup 6utoeldai to 6ut6ewt-ai'uoge;uaw6e4Gp'suogeolidde 6ul;unniano pue Bu!ppajys slap 6ulsn 'said 6uqumaano Jo 6ugalap Aq se yons) sanup prey leoOl id Muom;au uo aauepina otuou;Data epty jo /!ot}sap 9C�tpow o; 6uptaas wa; santyoje pue swa;sAs'e;ep moA o; ssaooe y;lmauoAue;uanajd o; sda;s angeuutge aMe; pinoys noA 6ut6ewt Aq uol;enrasaJd •eoueLn000 s;! ;sute6e pjen6 pue a;edloque o; pa6ggo aUe lasunoo Aay; pue uogeuuo;ul;o uetpo;sno due;ey; suoga tianooslp oluoAoale ut A4uetn6ei yons ygm sm000 Jey;;uana us Aldwts s,;l •sjaotgo pue seeholdwe moA jo noA o; anblun auo;ou st weouoo slyl •uogeuuo;ul Ao j)sep jo a;elap osle Aew 6ulop os ut 'pue 6wsseuegwa jo lequapguoo'leuosiad se pieBei lay; uogewjo;ul Aoa;sap jo a;alap o; Maas Aew siesn ;ey; a;edtoque pinoys noA 'suol;eolunwwoo leuosieduo ssaooe;awa;ul jo; pasn uaaq aney seulyoewAuedwoo ejegmAllelaads3 suogoe yons;sule6e pien6 Jo;uanajd o;;oe pue uogeuuo;ul ja;le jo Aou;sap 'aply o; Maas Aew s�Mo jo siaalgo 'saaAoldwa inoA;ey; a;edlogue pinoys noA uol;alao ;sute6y pienE) •swetBold uotssaidwoo jo uoge;uaw6ei;ap atg jo anup 6upnoex3 . 'pue :6u166ol W L jo jamas 6ullgastp . !setglgn aaddu;s empe;aw 6utsn . tsauo;lsodam a6a.io;s eutluo 6ut6ind jo 6ulsealab . !uogeja;le e;epe;aw ajesaloym 6ugoaga swei6oud jay;o.to snitngue 6uluuna :elpaw Jo saotnap 'sjaAjes'swa;sAs;o 6utsodslp jo 6ut6ewt-el'6utu6tsse-aa . :elpew do Moeq 6ulpieaslp jo 6utAa;sap 'Butsele '6ugl.wuanp :saotnap jo sagggn uogdKnue jo ainseia'lesodstp '6utdlm etpew jo e;ep 6utsn . !eua;uo jay;o jo A;loedeo We Aq seuo;lsodej llew-a;o s;ua;uoo ay; But6md . :apnlout suagejado pue sam;ea; yons;o saldwex3 •uogeuuo;ul;o ssol ay;asneo o;a;eiado 'uol;e�edo augnoJ ul yey;saotnap pue swa;sAs uogeuuo;ui moA ;o sam;ea; puedsns ao Agpow pue (gquept Ala;elpawwt o; pa;oaAp jayun! aie no,& ,ploy uoge6gg yons yqm aouelldwoo;!pne pue amoas o; y;te; poor) ut pue AquaBillp Joe o; pue ' 'uogeuuo;ul Jo; ploy uoge6gtl a a;eglut Ala;etpawwt o; pe;oaAp aie noA uogonAsaa ougnoa;o uotsuadsng •aouepma;uene;ei AgRilua;odiey;o pue s6uiy; elglBue; '';uewnoop anrasaad o; uoge6gqo;ue unauoo unod ysrww;p o; poo;sjapun eq pinoys uggewjo4utjo uogenreseld uo}puewep siy; u; 6ufy;o;y -uogewo;ul;o uogdnuoo jo ssol;uanajd o;Alglsuodsal PUB Ague6lllp;oe o; emlte; moA wo4llnsei Aew amseia pue uogele;le'Anuenbasuoo aouapin316 uol;etlodg ln;melun atntgsuoo Aew pue sute;uoo;t aauaptna ayt jaNe AlgenatAaut ll!m uogeogdde Aus Bwuum jo s;ua;uoo s;! 6utulwexa 'anup 9 Bugoog authenticate and preserve forensically qualified images of the hard drives in any computer system (including 'swelsAs;o slualuoo ayl etussaid;snw no,C'aoulo ayl wa; leme sluawnoop;uenalaj Allellualod pamalnai m p81e0JO Jo spew-a;uenalaJ Allegualod penlaoal Jo;uas aney saeColdwojoslagwawpjeoq'sjao16o;ey;;ua;xeay;of•elep;uenala.1 Cllenua;od weluoo Aow swelsCs algepod Jo awoq Aue;1 aulw.ialop osle pinoys not'siames PUB suollelqjom eoWo uo elep anuasaid of AIWms;oe plm noA ;et';;oadxa em g6noyl sanuan uol;etwo;ul jay;o pue s;un000y oulluo 'sdo;deq 'swats S awoH -ll ssnoslp o; peo aseald 'lualolgns se;daooe ulm am;ey; auo sl ansind nob poylaw uollemasaid ay; iaylaym uousanb noC;l -LL6Z aulluo aq;snw jo paumop eq ueo 11 iaylaym pue uoueun6uuoo (]Iv2d s;l ''6•a'uodn 6ulpuedap jamas a;o slualuoo ay; enlasaid o; SAM leMnas aye aJaq I -panlasaid aq pinoys;un000e flew a pue aieys �pom;au s, asn yoea;o slualuoo aleldwoo ayl '(„ajeys Miomlau. sdasn a palleo uayo) a6eiols Tom;au Jo (oulwo(3 sn;oq 'a6ueyox3 ?4osojolyq1•6•a) flew oluoAoale a6euew o; pasn asoy; aN II siames o; loadsau yAM 'sPlau 000 pue Oo 'alep panlaoatl ';oafgng ' wool 'oy ay; o; uol;lppe ul 'e;ep luewyoepe papooua {,g aseg pue elep 6ullnou japeay pe sapnloul e;epe;aw'llewolualoala joj uonewjojulaniasaid o; sdalsjadoudwl jo 6ullpuey ssalaieo Cq pa;dnuoo jo uapurvuano agBew e;epelaw ley; paslnpe Be •6ul;uud pue uollealo;o selep pue elep uollnqulslp pue uollejogelloo'/Ge;uawwoo'96en6uel;;ejp';uefuoo pa;alep 6ulpnloul'uasn a ol;uaiedde aq jou hew yolgm;nq salt' oiuoAoela ul pappagws io papnpul lleollewo;ne uoueuuo;ul sl elepelaw uol;eopddy •ssaooe io uolleoulpow ;sel pue uoueajo;o selep pue uol;eool 'uelpo;sno'ezls'aweu s,alu a 6uuoauai slep sapnloul usilo pue al!1oluoiloala un 6ul6euew jo 6uhloen yllm paleloosse Flleold Cl sl uol;euuo;ul slyl'uouewo;ul Jaylo;o Sol SI pue do;sly ay; 6ulgposap uoueuuo;ul sl elepe;aw walslg •;l anjasajd o;loe pue elepe;aw uoueolldde pue wels Is eonpad pue asoloslp of peau ay; a;edlollue jayljn;pinoys nok e;epelelry alglssaooe Alqeuoseal lou uogeuuo;ul vans aNew of sl suouoe yons;o;oage ay;_4 swjo; pue elpew epissaooe ssal of suuo; pue elpaw alglssaooe llgeuoseei wa; uol;euuo;ul ylys;ey; suouoe wog; ule.119i llleuoulppe pinoys nok uol;e6gll ay; w Apualolga uoRewiolul ayl asn to ssaooe of awosuap.mq jo llnolylp ll oNew jo sueaw olualoala Aq uouewlo;ul jnoA gojeas o; Clplge ayl opei6ap io anawal ley; uogewo;ul amasaid of spoq;aw loalas lou pinoys no i pue 'swio; anneu yons ul uogewjo;ul amasaid pinoys no! ' (l6wpj000y •peulelulew Slueupo sl ll yolym ul suuo; to uuo; ay; ul ly6nos aq ptmuol;ewjo;ul uleliao ley; aledlouue pinoys nok uuod and;eN ul uouenia CUd 'uoue�a;le ;noyllm panuasajd aq pinoys a6ewl yons yoea •peule;qo sem ll yolym wok wnlpew pue welsis ay; pue 96ewl ay; 6uulnboe Aplua jo uowed egl'uoulslnboe;o elep ayj Ajuuapl o; palogel aq pinoys abewl palplenb (lleolsualo; yons yoea 'paulelgo souo •lalndwoo yons yoea;o alep pue ewp wels Ss aql 6uuuaseld pue 6ulpjooei se llem se ' Cepo; of t440Z'E yajew ww; pouad ayl 6uunp uosied leylRq pasn (sia;ndwoo ewoy pue algeuod devices and media used for these purposes (including not only potentially relevant data from portable and home computers, but also from portable thumb drives, CD -R disks and the user's PDA, smart phone, voice mailbox or other forms of Information storage.). Similarly, if employees, officers or board members used online or browser- based email accounts or services (such as AOL, Gmail, Yahoo Mail or the like)to send or receive potentially relevant messages and attachments, the contents of these account mailboxes (including Sent, Deleted and Archived Message folders) should be preserved. ay} asolosip fndwad •paniasajd eq o} elpaw to uonenrasajd punos flleolsuajol sol l000lad elgeldsooe ue uodn 99i6e of not ylim 6uiNiom to snojisap aie aM sl000lOJd uo1leruasald salg palelap 6uip104 „'vajsnlo palsoolieun, palleo-os ay} ui 6uipnjoui 'aouap}na 0}ual0ala ayl to sued iie samasaid pue e0uapina elepelaw of sabueyo lsule6e spien6 po4law uoilemasaid punos fpe0isuaJoly'laui6uo ayllo e6ewl llq-jol-llq aleldwoo pue aril a se aleoildnp ayllo uonaoiluaylne poddns pue aouapina 814101 s86ue40 0u a�ew 11341 spoylaw pue slool 6uisn pue fpolsno to ulego jadoid a 6uifoldwe aliym eipaw aouap}na 841 uo pajols elep lie lo'uogenjasajdlo sesodind.rol'uo1leolldnp ueaw am; punosflleoisualol, AS -ssol elep pue uollellods to leejgl lueoglubs s sasod sp0419w yons asn of amlled spoylaw uogamasaid uo1lewlolul punos fneolsualolfoldwa not leyl puewep am'sanljp 94110 sease algssaooefgeolsuajol ul aouapina luen910J to aouesaid ayl pue swals6s ayl to G -low Jo quo to uogeulwexa olsuaaoliol peau ayl aledlollue am sy •aniloage }soo pue luaipadxa sl saoinap pue e1p9w'swalsfs 84110 6ul6ewl punos fpeoisuejol ley} selelolp 'palenildwl swalsfs to jagwnu lsepow a4l 41im paldnoo 'pannbai uogenrasajd to 4lpeajq ayl ley} anapaq am'sa0inep pue elpaw'swelsfsJalsenbas of leol}oeidwi li weep nofluana 941 ul -dais uollumasaid anl10049 }soo pue alelidwdde ue eq few way} 6unoolad pue 6ulialsanbas fpadoid pue amMas wojl saolnap pue eipaw 'swalsAs uollewlolul as0416uinowaU'089 PON pue 969 PoW'L Pout of loadsai yllm'leyllsaMns aM 6ui6ew} punos flleoisuajod ao uollellsanbaS walsfS •aoueildwoo ilaq}amaes of sdals algeuoseaj a�el lsnw not pue 'os op oluone6llgo roof to lualxa lint ay10l uogewaolul yons amasaid o} uogeuuolul }uenalaJ fpenualod to uoissassod w loloe-0uoo ao ueipolsno 'aafoldwa 'fawoge 'luebe lawjol to 1uanno fue flgou lsnw nof'fl6ulpj000y •laluoo jo uoiloailp jnof 61loafgns sl 11341 va410 to fpolsno a4l us uoneuuolul sapnpui pue fpolsno to uoissassod 'oleo jnof us uonewjolul puofaq spualxa uoile6llgo uollenaasaid moA sallied pn41 pue sfawolly'slue6y •suuoj gloq avasaid pinoys nof'suuol laded pue owculoale yloq us slsixe uogeuuolul ll •suoislan pajols (peolu0.goala :lo angejnwno jo uol alnlysgns alenbepe ue lou aie fag; 'elepelaw jo Aj!jjgegojeas oiuoUloala a vasard }ou op saldoo pteq sy alenbapeul sl uogeuuolul to uonenJasaJd jaded •saoinap fjelaudoid jo foe6al Jaylo pue sanup diZ 'vapeai epoo jeq 'sanup ode} sapnioul sly} -parols sl uogeuuolul yoigm uo elpew laidialui jo ss800e 01 papaau g 'anup )islp leogdo anp Jo p3 pMpuels Jo anup Alsip fddon ,g•e piepuels a ue41 jaylo 'ejempje4 pue vamp '6uilgeo fue anlasaid lsnw noA 1S3 ay} ssaooe of pannbal suogeolldde lol sfaN asueoil pue slenuew jesn 'sNslp uogellelsui ay} y}im fiuole'sualeoildde uru jo salg paldrjoue ssaooe of peiinbei voleonuaylne jaylo jo sfaN 'spiomssed fue amesaid lsnw noA •9111 ay} Jo Salsa piomssed PUB dl jasn 'sfell uo.1elnaigge 'suuol f�ua elep 's}aays uononysu} 's>Jeyo moll'swei6eip )llomlau 'slsil eig 'sl000lad 6uiweu 'saoipul 'suogeoy}oads 'slaays laluoo 's6ol 6uipnloul 'uogeuuolul 4aeas jo }aidialul 'ssaooe of pa.nnbal aq few ley} swall algl6uel Jay}o pue sluawnoop anlesaid }snw no k uogenJasaJd fJeglouy preservation protocol you intend to employ. A successful and compliant Information preservation effort requires expertise. If you do not currently have such expertise at your disposal, we urge you to engage the services of an expert in electronic evidence and computer forensics. Do Not Delay Preservation I'm available to discuss reasonable preservation steps; however, you should not defer preservation steps pending such discussions if Information may be lost or corrupted as a consequence of delay. Should your Failure to preserve potentially relevant evidence result In the corruption, loss or delay in production of evidence to which we will be entitled, such Failure would constitute Spoliation of Evidence, and we will not hesitate to seek sanctions. " l a ( l e y l p a w e a l I O U a n e y n o A s s e n 6 I " u o d n p a i l a j a q l o u u e o s j a d e d s m a u w o j l j l o e g p a a d : s d . A j e l u a w w o o p a s y " s s a j p s , a l i m j o s , j @ y l o w s l y p u l y a q 6 u i p i y a u o A q p a m o l i o l s l l o n p u o o y o n s ' l p e n s n " p a m n o g ( a u r a s l l l m ��l u l y l l , u o p I y o l y m ' @ p e w n o t u o l s l o o p l u a j e d d e u y " p o o y l i u e w ; o ( u o i u i d o �� m u l ) N o e l j n o ��t s l l a j 6 a j l l u o A N " p a m n o A y s i m I ' a p i s e a n o g e a y l " s l u a w a l e l s I e u o i s n l e p p u e I e o l y a l w ' l e a l 6 e w . i n o R a j e j o u ' a s u o d s e J 1 0 A y l j o m l o u p u e l e a l s u e s u o u W e M a y a ' s a g i j l e i p j n o ( s e j e l s y " w s A e m y l a q S a n o . A l e y l ' a s j n o o t o ' 6 u u a g w a w a ��I " a l n l i l s u i o f e a 4 a j e n o t a s j n o o t o ' a w a s w e 6 e u o l l o e ; o a s n e o a a n e y A G 4 1 1 9 0 1 a s l e a u o ( u e j o n o ( ; I " ( s m e l v j 7 } o p u e l a p u e ' 9 0 4 a y ; 1 0 p u e l e q l ) e o u a w y u i s e m i 6 u l w o w s l y ; d o a x i o m l u a y m ' j ( I l e l u e p i o u l " w a y l e 5 i l g o o f p u e l u l i p u e : l e y l l d e o o e I " , w n j p u m o A m t o l e a q a y l o f y o j e w o f g a l m o l s a q s e m I l y 6 n o y l h l + ����o ! l o a y l A l l u e j e d d y " u o l l o a l a a y l u l m l o u p i p I ' m o u N n o A s y Z " o u u i s s a n w , Z , p o n y a y l c l o d , , n - o 7 u a y m M s j a l l a l a y ; l e y m n o A p l o l a y s e y l n 8 " j a y s e j y l " j i N o f j a g a l " o u l ' d n o j E ) a o j a w w o o @ y l a n e y A l s n o i n g o n o A " p a w j o l u i s i w u i e w e i n o t : s 6 u l g l l j o y s Z g u J > j - - I N u e i N u o p j o g S q w e a j l S J I n J - s e s n o H j e g o S : 3 a : I o a l g n s , g e l > J u a p j o E ) , : o j . W V Z v L t i 6 o Z ' 9 L a u n � ' A e p u n S : l u a s a l C o g , p ( l j e N : w o j d M 5 5 , 0 5 5 3 6 - G u u u o o " n n n n n n : a b e d q a M w o o n o a - a o j a w w o o a l o g o M : I ! e w - d 9 8 V E c 6 9 9 : 1 1 9 0 L 0 8 0 - 0 9 E - t , 9 6 : X e - J S O S E - O L S - t , 9 6 : l e 1 0 I o a . l ! Q Z t t 7 E E ' I d ` 4 o e a e P l a ! : P a a Q a n ! j p j a l u a 0 } a o d n n a N " M 0 8 2 6 o u l ' d n o . l 0 a o j e w w o 0 ` G I A O 9 . 0 " d u ! l i e n ' l i n p o o d s a a ' 0 9 9 P o u t p u e 9 1 9 P o W ' 4 P o u t p a g p o u a n e y n o A l e y l L w g u o o o s l e a s e a i d - e I O e , p o f l u e n a l a j b p e g u a l o d s l u a w n o o p e l g l 6 u e l p u e u o i l e u j j o } u l a m o s e l d o l j a g a l s i y l u l p a u i l l n o s d a l s a y l u a % e l a n e y n o A l e g l ' y ��O Z ' � l a u n ' r A e p i j d u o " w " d 0 0 : 9 A q u u g u o o a s e a i d a o u e i l d w o o t o u o g e u u } u o C ) Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 Cell: 561 213 3486 E-mail: moboyleecommerce-grouo.com Web Page: www.commerce-grour).com From: Gordon Kraft Imailto:slotgordonrc'Daol.coml Sent: Saturday, June 14, 2014 8:53 PM To: Marty O'Boyle Subject: Re: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream Mr. O'Boyle: I have no interest in talking to you. The "misinformation" you refer to is a copy of your letter to Mr. Thrasher. it appears to be a typical challenge from you for the Town to try and block your efforts to put sober houses In the community. As I understand it, sober houses are protected by federal law, so the town doesn't really have much basis to challenge your efforts. Several groups in Gulf Stream have made it clear that they do not feel they would be beneficial to property values, however, and might bring people with questionable character into our town. Apparently sober houses can generate revenue for the people running them, and I can understand an outside interest moving forward without any regard for the citizens in the target community. When a resident of the town says he is going to do it, particularly one who was supposedly running for mayor to make the town a better place, it seems like vindictiveness and payback more than anything. I don't have to talk to you on the phone to have you explain your motivations. You say I have made allegations. This is really not the case. I am merely asking you why you feel obliged to do something thatthe majority of people in Gulf Stream don't want. If you just need the money, and don't really care what your neighbors think or want, then that is an answer. If you can not express yourself in an email, I'II just wait for feedback from the town and the Coastal Star. As far as that drivel about being a man, I wont bother to address it. F. Gordon Kraft —Original Message— From: Marty O'Boyle <mobovlefa�commerce orouo.com> To: Gordon Kraft <slotaordonraDaol.com> Sent: Sat, Jun 14, 2014 1:52 pm Subject: RE: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream Mr. Kraft — your email was not well received. ue-0I uopjo0 •d '6lejaouls sanlen idol of spo}}a jno C puedxa pinoo noA agRew uagl'no SWnos�ly 10 eem Jew b l 7egl jI •Ja8 agJ uo Allis sl ;I puelslapun I se 'smo! of poop Jxau esnog agl 14Vm peas noA pop lgm suogolppe snOPen gilm paaollde slenpinlpuI 6uidlag ul Jsalalul oysingle ue aneg;snf noA jj ouolaLp u6ledweo luaoa� �no�;o uollolpe�luoo loanp a aq of swags slgl •umol a u1 sanlen Apedoid eonpai of uanad uaaq seg golgm Joneapua ue aouenpe of Maas mou no!'Allunwwoo weeilS ;InE) 941 anoidwl o; w1ogeld a 6ulsnodsa pue aoq}o jolBu( uuni iayy •no! isule6e s6uam panlaaad jo; umol eq; le Noeq Jeb of Jdwaps impous 61aiew s, j! g6nogf se spunos 11 as ' suow age peau noA anallaq l,ueo 1 •slgl 6ulop aje noA Aqm 6uev ou)1 Ul palsaialul we I :aft&o sesnoH jegos :;oafgns 91408.0 ApeW :01 Wd 6Z4 bloZ'tq aunr'Repjnleg :;uas woo•loe uopjo lols:olilew 14e1>{ uopJo0 :woad woo nog-aoaawwoo•Avm :abed qaM woe no.l-ao:lawwoo al ogow :Ilew-3 98VE UZ 699:1100 L080-09CIV96 :xed 905E-OL91796 :Iela ;oanQ zttEE 'I=l 'LloeG9 plal.PaaQ antra Ja}ua0 liodmeN •M 0826 oul 'dnoa0 aojewwo0 'alAo8,O •A olijeW Ileo auogd jno C lleme I ' (l;uenbasuo0 •uew a noA 6ullleo Apodoad we 1 adog 1 ,4noA we golgM •suol;e6alle pelepuelsgnsun aNew pue sllewe pulgaq lno eplg s�sslg •senssl luo4uoo ueN •(IIeH umol eql woo peleuewe ownsse I gotgm) aw;sule6e suoge6911e palelluelsgnsun aNew of pepwied 'aanannog 'lou age no,k •gslm noxi awll Aue le aw gllm ;l ssnoslp pue aw lleo Aew nok •uew a 9411 Joe pue uew a eq noA legl else I og 'noA of Rldde pinom buiAeg;egl '„avoid lsnw aballe ogm asogl„ :slgl aM 6ulglawos luem golgm 6ulAes plo ue aw;g6nel jeglow AW •.ul nog( peNons„ Alln;ssaoons aneq Cagl sieadde;I •molaq JUGS aneg noA se Ilewe ue allonoid of se Bons asodind e•••(u6ledweo jeams leolglALu a;o ped a aq jo gels ol) asodind gilm noA of uanl6 sem uolJewlo;w-slw slgl ewnsse 1 'pawlo;ulslw Almelo ej,no�, Exhibit F spiooag aql;o mpoisnD xla1D nmol `.ilaiaottlg •pasola sallem.sggl Japisuoo am 'noA mog 3Toeq maq am ssolnll '.Cllegian aosiod m apem aiam sasanbaa asagl .tanamoq `iallal aql .go3 paKse imp slnatdiaai nmominn mog s;sanboi spiooai oggnd Z osle aiam aiagy •sianotssmnnOD aql of paiantlap pneq pne (moloq poonpoidw) uopsonb m iapol oql of pagoenu sem omam QuIsanbai mo i of antsnodsai axe legl slaamnoop zip sapnToul gotgm °saTg pagoelle atp nado aseald •oouamoAUoo ano6 io; moloq paonpoidat sl oouapnodsauoo s!%L •bIOZ'Ll annr palep Trema mos mpalsanbai spiooat atTgnd alp jo noponpoid amsuodsw MU alp glVm noX sapinozd legl Rema m: of pogoelle sl lallal sn LL [moo•dnoz3-ooiammoo@spiooai :olltem] aT,fog,o g ngiew ieaQ pa;vulugasslp svat.ga;;al payomm ay; yopym o;;uvns nd 'suopvoluniuwoo.gay;o pun sjp7N-,d2,gpnloul 'sproaar ollgndlly fo fdoo v apinoddamald 06S UUa MU [moo•dnojB-aoiattmtool@vsp.iooai:olltem]alfog,p gntltelnl blOZ `6r aunf Rema CTA pa.ianllaQ vaRIo73 `Aarinoo aovag vs'rvd wvms J7RD do NMOL The Town's acknowledgement of the above Public Records Request dated June 17 2014 is reproduced in the space below: RECORDS REQUEST (the -R gttest,) Dz;eofFtegL---t: 6117144 Rsgae.-:or's RegaestM. 590 REQIIFs=- Custodian of Records Town of Gulf Stream REQ amoR: Martin E. O'Boyle iiEQUrSTOR'S CONL4Cr31\--W-MON F-bfar-' teeatdshLenmm¢aFQoup.eom Far 934-360-0 07;_U&dn USO[4e, ?i *e ,rtCeafv3¢;x DeerfieldBearh,FL 334=2 R=,QUFsT: Please provide a copy of all public records includina E -Mails and other communications pursuant to which the attached letter was disseminated. :DDr.�O>L"� LtieOR_;L:1-i0*IP,.ECz=_,D?iG P.=Q�rST- THDi REQUES TLS hLADE PLBSG:1\T TO PUBLIC RECORDS ACT. CHAPTER 119 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES AND IS ALSO REQUESTED U-NDER ME COMUO TAWRIGHTTOIAOW,TEECOXWOIrL WRIGRTOFACCESS;AM ANYSL4Tu10RFRIGRTTOKNOW (LRCLuDngG,wimouTLrnduATIO\,_Axr STATriTORYRIGRTOFACCESS,ASAPPLICARLE), 1131SREQUEST ISALSO MADE PGRSUA\TTOTEE RIGHTS OFTHE REQUESTORPROYIDEDI TREFLORIDA CO\I M IIO\. 1TISREOUESMMIT THIS RECORDS REQUEST BE FBLFiri n-M;ECTRO\7C FOR117 IFILOii'l arr.ani_F P; CI'c.0_IZCFOML IIISREOLES7'IDTHATTEUS RECORDSREg=BEFGyFILLEDONIIX1-P.PER. VOTE iN�iLLcA&ZSrU_N=SS �OSSIBLE) THE COPIES SHOULD BE TWO SIDED AND SHOULD BEBHT-ED LK ACCORDANCE TS•ITH Seed..119.07(41 rn) r_f ALL= KRONIC COPIFS ARE REQUESTED TO BE S\ -"h"' h"' DEM -ERY PTEdSEPROI71DE THE APPR0-MIATE COSTS (IFANI) TO FUL:cns THIS PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST L� ADVANCE. It mill be required that the Requestor approve oraar cost:,asserted bsihe Asenec(u defiaedm Florida Stntnte, Chapter I19.01(DeSaiti0nc)), in adsance of any rorts imposed to the Requestor be the Ageam. 'pl!��� OTS+sa FOP3r ZbKC vanm:l wavag aiaminad 3nro0 VRiN30 Ivodm3N 1MA\ OBZI LOW09£'656 7cvd • El LL'09E•i56-o1 uloo •dnol2-aoialuw oo•,nMm s;uautanolduiag;o puI2uopanr;suo0 io; s;naiad panrnbai Cue a n axapinom step 'osmoa30 i urEar;S }InrJ }o umoy aTp plodo; pug;in pinoM am `.fpuanbasuo0 'uoTgsE} pldE.r E TAT pzemzo} anour o} uoRua;uT mo sT;T;ETI; `r o,� puttuas I `ure asnoH sagoS a ro} Tusa�4S }Ino uI asnoTl a asn o; kmssaDou Qxe sreAoidd-eso/pu-e s;nuzad ;ETZm o} se uoT;Eu,eldxa uE so !uol}Euuguoo rood;TEmE SIsnoTxuE I asno13 ragoS E }o tasn oql so} dL;.pol3lunur alfa. Iuoi} pasTnbaz sl!=ad so sTeAoiddE ou aq pinom a.iaTl;;Eq; ULTUU03 o; .Ta;;al slip nox a;T.rm I •cl;TmIMo} ureaSosd stip }o uoT;E;uauraldurr aTp ul2aq o; pua;uT I 'sasnoH sagoS sE asn ao} urea4S }Ino TTI sosnOLI a.rinboLa o; AuEduioo E uuo} o; uoLsToap E @p-eTu QA -CTI I Ilam no,f spug za al sTTI} odoTl I -13gsE.ITIL -JN xeaQ Epu01,3 'ureas;S }Ino '(s)asnoH sagoS pasodo.Td :@-a 1a2EueFq umoL'JQlgsEsgy 'H urei Ak :ua3d cs-Kc 73 `ureallS }InD pang EaS OOT urea-pS }Ino }o umoL 9TT9-9LZ-T9S# aMoHda-jal ro•u eal4s- aTIsErTl;q :II�INI-� VlA S05B-0LS-tb96#auogdolayI= ZaanQ 7TOZ'9 aunr moa• no-wlammo T ogom . r dnouo aoxaww0o William H. Thrasher, Town Manager June 6, 2014 Page 2 accountable for any damages which we incurred as a result of purposeful delays. Sincerely yours, COMMERCE GROUP, INC. I LL, -/ G -L ("_ Martin E. O Bbyle President cc: William F. Ring, Jr., Esquire — E -Mail P/NPR/SOBERHOUSESGULFSTREAM wog na-a»awwo� £TLL-09£-bS6# WEVY LOSO-09£-bS6# xej £TSE-OLS-VS64 PIG paa!a ZVbE£ 1d Vea8 Pla!JjaaO aA!Ip Ja;uao :wadmDN ISM OUT 'ou!'dnoag aaaawwo:) a!Aog.O .3 w1jew Jo a:)UJO ;ue;slssV aApmax3 passna'V epuaig larval pagae:ae aas aseald gj'weedsJing'(s)asnoH jagoS pasoftd 2u!Pe69i.1aliaq 91A09,0:43afgns a!AOG,O A!ueiN :Sulu welp!M :aJ -jagseagl 11!9:0.L WV Ob:6 VTOZ'90 aun f'Amij :;uas woo na-aajawwoa !!assnaq:oal!ew passnu epua-ig :wojd .tagsejgl II!e 's4uegl •spioaaj anoA ioJ s!gl SulpieNuoJ we I 'aldde;aamS •alnl Jpd•b1•90.90 iagsejgl we!II!M :sjuawgoeUv 1'weajls Jing'(s)asnoH JagoS pasodoad 6u!pje6aj lapaq alAog,O:Mj :pafgns wornnelaldde;aamspo a!ddelaamsj :ol Wd SS:£ 6TOZ'TT aunf'AepsaupaM :Juas <6aoweajls-Jln6po jagseag;q> iagsejgl II!g :woa j al 08.0eW INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF TBI; TOWN MANAGER WILLIAM H. THRASHER DATE: June 9, 2014 TO: Mayor Morgan and Town Commissioners RE: Recent Commu iications from Mr. O'Boyle To help you stay informed of changing events that could affect the Town, I am attaching gopies of two emails that I have recently received from Mr. O'Boyle. If you have any questions or comments about either of these emails, please call me at your convenience. J liqiq-xl INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF.THE TOWN MANAGER WILLIAM E. THRASEER DATE: June 9, ?014 TO: Mayor Morgan and Town Coramissioners RE: Recent Communications from Mr. O'Boyle To help you stay informed of changing events that could affect the Town, I am attaching copies of two emails that I have recently received from Mr. O'Boyle. If you have any questions or comments about either of these emails, please call me at your convenience. H liqiq-xj From: Bill Thrasher <bthrasher@gulf-stream.org> Sent: Wednesday, June 11, 2014 3:55 PM To: rsweetapple@sweetapplelaw.com Subject: FW: O'Boyle Letter regarding Proposed Sober House(s), Gulf Stream, FL Attachments: William Thrasher06.06.14.pdf Mr. Sweetapple, I am forwarding this for your records. Thanks, Bill Thrasher From: Brenda Russell[mailto:brusseil(@commerce-group.com Sent: Friday, June 06, 2014 9:40 AM To: Bill Thrasher Cc: William Ring; Marty O'Boyle Subject: O'Boyle Letter regarding Proposed Sober House(s), Gulf Stream, FL Please see attached letter. Brenda A. Russell Executive Assistant Office of Martin E. O'Boyle Commerce Group, Inc. 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Direct Dial #954-570-3513 Fax #954-360-0807 Main #954-360-7713 brussell@commerce-arouo com 116E-Z£4EE vatNo7d'No.LV-d vaog'.I3MS mE *H'S OZ *Td'svnvA V WffXH0N$ `Tmjv]3am$ 30 MI"o mv'l avid mu'I al,Sog,O ail `uoTlWodzoa lgoid uSiaTo; upuold u sa `(„ Eu11d mu7 a Aog,o„ aTP iageuTaiat� aul ` O d `nTnd muZ aTl 0P,0 aTP SuualsiSai;o aTuP ail lu `;agaq pT1e uopuuuolETT� uodfl b utuunlAsuuad eTgdlapvlTgd `laailS uopSmlunH 'H 9bIZ se aog;o lediouud sl! Suiuliulo `bTOZ `OI faunlgad uo uogwodloa igoid Opig3 upuold u se paialsiSal •au, •D.d `Tund M11,1al,Cog,O ail Aj ueagpa!S E uoRow ail m passalppu sialluul OT of px0va.T g1Tm saipaulai iaEPo Snnlaas si luupua o(l se aaipnfaid inoEpim umulpTpTm uaaq seq uogbl sigL Z •(„uonolnl„ alp .1a}luuiazaTl) SnueaH ,CiequapTAg nu Io; `aAPucuallV Qtg m ao `rout `•O•d `old mu'l al,Cog,o ail fg!junbsiQ of uopow s,luSpuadau Palg ''V•d `sggniS V uosugof `amod `sauol• pus ' 'I•d 'sgmA v .Ea3laoig 'aldduloamS 'lasunoo sl! iSnoRg `luupua3a(I `bIOZ `OE XIIW u0 ' I :lutg lmo0 ail mops pinom aaoianip spuno.ES se pue `sopoul uoPuS. !I anisnqu puu I . paun `pluoissa;ozdun To; `aiinbsg `BEng mugl6M PuR `OTAog,O usiluuof °luapisazd slt `•auI '•O•d 'uuTd min apCog,o ail `plooag 3o losuno0 'alSoEl,O 'H uilTuyQ jpululcl 1SUMOS suoPaues 3o uoilisodulT ail Eo; lmo0 STEP sanoul `mua4S 3In() 30 umos `luuPUDiou aula sH .9NRI INTVI`l QNVA •luepaa;aQ `THvmus Arm d0 NBAO.L .A `d3?luiuld IJV :NOISIAIQ 9WxxxxbL"00VOi?T0Z05 :•ON HSVO HgAou,o 'H mi.-Ivw VQRIO'Id `A.UMOD HOVHU I^I'Ivd 2IOd QNv NI `ZTI auio 'IVIOIc n r HlSl HIIL d0 .L-JnOD JJnD-IID HH.L NI Martin E. O'Boyle v. Town of Gulfstream CASE NO.502014CA004474XXXXMBAG (PALM BEACH COUNTY) appears to have had no real business presence in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Although it was registered as a Pennsylvania Corporation on November 14, 2013, it further appears that: a. The O'Boyle Law Firm did not own or lease any commercial space there. b. The O'Boyle Law Firm did not have a business telephone line. c. The O'Boyle Law Firm had no employees and paid no salaries. d. The O'Boyle Law Firm did not pay city, state or federal taxes because it had no employees. e. The O'Boyle Law Firm did not obtain an occupational license to conduct business in the City of Philadephia. £ The O'Boyle Law Firm's sole principal, officer and director, Jonathan O'Boyle, used his Florida cell phone number (561-758-1223), as the firm telephone number. g. Jonathan O'Boyle is a member of the Pennsylvania Bar, but not of the Florida Bar. h. Jonathan O'Boyle advised the Pennsylvania Bar that he is an out-of-state attorney with an address in Florida. i. Jonathan O'Boyle advised the Pennsylvania Bar that his address is in the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida at 23 N. Hidden Harbour Drive, his parent's home address. j. At the time of the opening of the O'Boyle Law Firm in Florida, Jonathan O'Boyle resided and was domiciled in Florida. k. When the O'Boyle Law Firm opened in Florida, it was operated out of his father, Martin O'Boyle's, office at West Newport Center Drive, Deerfield Beach, Florida. It is still operated out of this building, which is owned or controlled by Martin O'Boyle. LAW OFFICES OF SWEErAPPLE, BROERER & VARKAs, P.L. 20 S.E. 3fl° STREET, BOCARAToN, FLORIDA 33432-3911 I I6E-ZE6EE Vo,no',3'Notvll vOog'daziaS m,E'3's OZ 'Z'd `svxnvA V 11=08EI'Rlddvd33nS do sdatdap mv3 uorlom sigl pue Sluana asagl 01 pze231 gum sassaultm amooaq Ol lasunga-03 s,lasunoa pou2islapun pasnea suq lonpuoa amoqu agZ flasunoa pau2israpun 2uipnlout `lasunoo 2utlupimnu13o osodmd agl ao3 npum atam sluamaluls asagZ 6 •u113anS 31ngjo umo.L oql lnog2nonll sosnoq iagos undo 01 B11102 sum aq legl palms daglnj atfog,O •g „•dn sdils ags3t aas o1 zalg2nup s,lasunoo g31eA,;, 01 s10113211sanut Will 01 paualea.nll pus snluls luluum `9,zouuo0,0 auueof `lasunoo 2utsoddo 2uipae2aa pannbui alxog,O „auoCue pagonol ianau anuq spueq osggL •uosaad luolotA u uaaq aanau OA,l motel nok„ `21Itlels aaualotA lnotsXgd 3o leanll ltoildmi ue opera oslu alXog,O •uadpligo nagl put losunoa 2utsoddo lsutu2e sdals a3Ml of popualut ol6og,0 `uug mel s,uos S,al,Cog,O is paloattp sem ganlm `uotlow agl3o llnsad e se legl 2uiluls `sleanll ltogdmt onssi of popaaaoid uagl3jnutuld `ianamoll •luamalllas a 1s 2utnt.ue3o asodind otg io3 palluo sem It sn ainieu ui letluapguoo aq pinogs 2ui103m aql paleatput ZIAOg,O L •aauepualle ut lou sum sggnuS -jW •.talso3 sauo f jo sooUjo ag1 ui lam gdloPur2i mlof Puu dowoD,o auuuof 2utd u1elIP.M `01`(09.0 `bIOZ `V aunf u0 •9 •uug mal dalsog sauo f aql jo sggruS LauptS pue gdlopumd 0 ugof JOuUOD,0 'ISI auueof gltm tin oam s polsonboi `2utg uiutlP.M `tasunoa stg P („01Lo9<0„ aaplumonq) aIXog.0 upwW plUpId `,,uoROY�i 0q1„ P0Ii3 luspua3aQ tal3e ilaleipatuml s •.tug ag1 io/pus ymo0 391 gltm s2ullg stg3o Ind se aauopisaz sig paluasaidaxstm seq ajXog,O umpuuof •m •saoumvz)dde aoln any oid (V) mo; lseal le 2uipnlout `sossauisnq s,iagle3 siq puu aaglu3 siq io3 sdallum ln2al 2utlpueq spuol3 3o 0111S aql ui aauasazd luulsuoo u puq seq alAog,0 uegleuof uut3 mel 9l,fog,0 aq1 2utuado aauiS •1 (A,LI`lflOO HOV3H ➢V'IVd) OV8KXXXXVLVV00VOV10Z05'0N 9SVO meailSjlo`J3o umol •A ZIS0a,0 *a mueyy Martin E. O'Boyle v. Town of Gulfstream CASE NO.502014CA004474XXXXMBAG (PALM BEACH COUNTY) 10. Following the meeting, John Randolph wrote a letter to William Ring informing him that the meeting did not involve settlement discussions and therefore it would not be treated as confidential, Exhibit 111". 11. After the meeting, O'Boyle commenced to have airborne banners flown on a daily basis over Palm Beach County. Some of the banners read: DATE TIME ACTFVTTV MWQQAf_P. 06/05/14 @ 2:00 pm Banner Plane "JONES FOSTER CLIENTS, CHECK YOUR BILLS" 06/06/14 @2:00 pm Banner Plane "JF DON'T DRINK & DRIVE — WELL BE WATCHING" 06/10/14 c@i 2:00 pm Banner Plane "HAS JONES FOSTER EMBRACED A BAD APPLET' 06/13/14 @11:10 am Banner Plane "JONES FOSTER — YOUR BILLS MAKE ME PUKE" 06/20/13 @11:00 am Banner Plane "SWEET APPLES ARE ROTTEN APPLES RIGHT JF" 06/24/14 @10:38 am Banner Plane "SWEET APPLES ARE BEST BOILED IN OIL" 12. On June 6, 2014, O'Boyle had his attorney and business associate, William Ring, Esquire, form a Florida limited liability company called "Sweet Apple Sober Houses, LLC", Exhibit "2", an obvious reference to a defense counsel's surname. 13. In addition, on June 13, 2014, O'Boyle appeared before a meeting of the Gulf Stream Town Commission and made false and defamatory allegations against Gulf Stream's co -counsel, Robert Sweetapple, stating that a Judge of the First District Court of Appeal had found that "Mr. Sweetapple consistently misrepresented testimony and failed to acknowledge well-established case law, including Supreme Court precedents " (Exhibit 113") This statement is patently untrue, and was made to undermine the To4vn's confidence in its attorney. 14. The above threats and conduct have occurred with the knowledge, cooperation and complicity of William Ring, Jonathan O'Boyle and the O'Boyle Law Firm. Specifically, this misconduct is being LAW OFFICES OF S WEETAPPLE, BROEKER & VARKAs, P.L. 20 S.E. 3' STREET, BOCA RATON, FLORMA 33432-3911 116E-Z£6EE vwao,3'Notv3 VooEj'L-MalS �£'3's oz ''fd'SVXWA V lMN901!$ `31ddtlJ33mS d0 ssoiddo tAv l i uotlu2tlq antsngt3o l[ell ouo;slq t gal sqg oqm '21-i08,0 103 illanou u;ou st lonpuoo antsngd 0z •ss000ad uotleStltl aLl do llud se losunoo Magi so satlted Sutsoddo llolxo of ldwallu puu u2iluw 'ugndwt louueO `lasunoa 3o aOuMstsse olp gltm'ag jlaswtq jo olotloods t xpuj o; onutluoo of lgfu oLp suq olkos,o Olttlm •61 satltulu; put Duatlo Magl `lasunoa lsutu& slusudol 2utDn;tlsut pue 3uwaluanl; iq uut3 mull al,Cog,p ail; 3o sopg tuoq ogl3o uotltumuolop to not;u2tltl fut asuaO o; DqSnos anuq lasunoa sr q puu 33tlu!uld `aoumsut sntl uI asngt notlugtltl io3 lasunoa Marg puu sail -Md uopouts o; not;Otpstmf luanqut stq unoo luu; oql ltL; palllas Ilam sl ll 8I •aatlsnf;o uotluilsttnwpu oql Sututuuapun ostmaaglo to 's,fawol;u puu sassau;tm 8ui2mudstp wo.g pa;tgigoad aiz pue '11noo oq; jo slaog;o ospt ale ,iagl sisalolul s,luago Maq; luasaldal (Isnolvaz lsnw sSomoDDu altgm puu `goaads Inlglnll o; poplojle st uotloolold ;uql 'gaaads aag 3o lggu f;uotlnipsuoo aq; Aofuo suortlta OlRlm 'Ll X311 aq; ut .to sloolls alp to utgl iogDtz `mui jo sunoo ut solndstp 3o uotlnlosal OLD o; luawltuauoo s, Clatoos saumuapun ;anpuoa gonS •luatlo MOLD o; notDegtlgo puOtgla ,slosunoo asuaJop TIM OlQJtalal of pau9tsap alu put not;eluasaadoi snoltaz puoAoq oq satlaul asogy •asnqu uotltotltl ;o aldtutxa snotOaM9a au sa;nitlsuoo It put p;atglnun 'luuotssa;ozdun st lonpuoostw aqL '9I •luatlo Magl puu lasanoo 2utsoddo Xq sptea Mt put uotluptwilut `luawsseltq 3o loofgns Oql nq lou pinogs DI •mtl of futplooaL panlosO.t oq pinogs ltgl auo st uut3 mt7 mulslalul apg uuoq u st uuid mel alfog,p oql iotpogmdo ansst aq.L SI •uut3 mu -1 alt;sxalul apg tuoq a st wM3 mull al,iog,p oq; aaglagm 3o ansst oLp qutnssnd lou olul lasunoa asuaJop a)tptunDui put amssold of umpliopun (AJ.M 100 HOV39 W'lVd) DVSWXXXXiLb600VDPloZ09'ON E[Sd0 weadls31n0 jo umoy •n al.(o9.0 '3 t!UVW 9 - Martin E. O'Boyle v. Town of Gulfstream CASE NO.502014CA004474XXXXMBAG (PALM BEACH COUNTY) 21. O'Boyle has abused the legal system in several states by overwhelming local municipal governments and a State Attorney's office with the filing of thousands of public records requests and abusive litigation. 22. The case of Martin E. O'Boyle v. Peter Isen, 2014 WL 340104 (N.J.Super.A.D.), issued by the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, on appeal from case no. L-2341-08, is attached hereto as Exhibit "4". The Court noted, From September 2007 through early July 2008, plaintiff and members of his family filed multiple requests pursuant to the Open Public Records Act (OPRA), N.J.S.A. 47:1A-1 to -13. Longport's only clerk worked part-time, and she did not address the requests within the time required by statute. At one point, the clerk went to the emergency room because of the stress she attributed to the flood of OPRA requests. And, in February 2008, the Borough's solicitor notified plaintiff that it would not accept any additional OPRA requests he filed, explaining that the numerous requests were substantially disrupting governmental services. The solicitor claimed that Longport had received 190 requests on October 16 and 17 and thirty filed October 31, 2007. In the Isen case, O'Boyle sued a resident of Longport for claiming O'Boyle was "the enemy of Longport". The suit for defamation was dismissed by summary judgment and affirmed by the appellate court. 23. Similarly, when his daughter was being prosecuted for driving under the influence, O'Boyle inundated the Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office both individually and through companies he controls with over 1,300 requests for public records. (attached hereto as Exhibit "5"). 24. In an interview with the Palm Beach Post discussing his dealings with then candidate Dave Aronberg, O'Boyle stated, My view in life is: Take whatever shots you like at me, because I'm a big boy "d I can handle them. But don't mess with rriy kids, my wife dr my home. Don't do it. Don't. Because I'll come at you with every resource I have. And there's a lot. (attached hereto as Exhibit "WI). LAW OFFICES OF S WEMPPLE, BROEKER & VARXAS, P.L. 20 S.E. 3"0 STREET, BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33432-3911 ! ! 6E-MEE Varomd'No.Lv$ voos `19MtS QE '3-S oz *'I'd'svxavA V M9O-dG'slddvl3am$ do Sao udo Mtl'i aql of tutoipnfaid si legi mel -10 aatlouid atg giim uotloauuoo ui lonpuoo ui 0Mua„ lou ileus aaXmel e) (p)17.8-17 puu '(„leungpj a ldnistp of papualul lonpuoa ut agu8ua lou Bugs aaimel a„) (o)S•£-17 saliu ' 2-a 'aas `( 31aslt aouapcudsunf mel uotuwoo se plo se st ldamoo stq j, AlglooLus suotloutg ootlsnf jo wals,is mo iegl aas of fqtltgtsuodsaz iaq.to siq g0iam4nq zanau uuo luatla a of ilnp s,Aauioiiu uy„ (£66FJID q) 11) 91751 `9£9I PZ -3 L86 `M "OD -1010 P p/nmE -,t vatnvlvlAr aas •mals S lutoipnf agl3o Ouiuoiloutg ogl glim soloinlut io sauiuuopun iugi XOeaonpt, woi3 utus3ax of ,iinp u suq Xamolle uV 'lug upuold agl 9uilulit;ia-d soln-d '17 .iaidug0 `atquteaxd ,'aopsnf 3o Allp'nb oq1 .io3 Xililglsuodsai iuloods 2utnuq uozuto otlgnd t, pue 'wolsXs lnfal a p •io iaogjo ue ••• st iafmul [V]„ ,(itotldwoo jo tutulo u o131oswiq loafgns 'saaue)sumo.ito utmltao iapun'zo luatlo aqi ioiluoo ism fauiollu uV •malsXs iuSol aql sltoldxa,Cpe2allt 10 gltm saia3ialut legl ionpuoo 3u0puo3 Io asinpu 01 iou inlaiva aq isnw lasunoo s,alAog,0 *LZ •smis io uotltolxa 'sleantl 'uotieptuniut•io asn sty io3 vope0gtlsnf lou si pa ivaiiuyo Outaq oin uag mel olelszaiut pa;iollu s,uos stg;o sapff vuoq aqi lugl laui aqi, •linoO to sain'i aql of laafgns on lasunoo sit pueRluteld a iugl OZin20031 01 lie3 lasunoa Stg puu oIXog,0 9Z •(„L„ ltgtgx2j su oloioq pagouiie) (•UU3,L) 9•V•O) OSZOIS£'IM I IN `61717 •xddV•pa,q 9£17 '7v •la 's d2021 'uvwlnys -a alfog, p aas ; olmalol 01 $ullilm lou si lmo0 agi gotgm 'pud siq uo ssausnolBull woggms put, 0oua9tsuuiut 3o ilnsaa aqi si ianpuoa s,atS09,0 lt,gl spug pue sanatlaq lino0 an • ••ssauisnq 3o asmoo ,iep iaana agi anoqu puu aano lino0 stgl jo liol0 aqi uo uopmq awailxa ue paould suq 'aiSog,o 3o luouieiadwol snoleaz aqi Sq paumt,ds uoiIL iii'uoile8titl snolonu33o siea i uanas uegi atoyq„ :iug1 paiou I'm a3 SOUuaZ ayl 8upapxo os ui al fog,0 pauoti0ues tlluuotltppu put, 'sluepua3ap aql of sisoo puu saa; ,iud of aVog,0 paiapio 3mo0 oqL 'QfuSVOm uotlllw 6.8$ un uo poiinujop ai,fog,o aiagm uotiuivasaldaz u;o ino ;iutscle `utni mul u isute;iu wiulo aatlowdlew tubal u uo 8utini luawgpnf ,fiuiuwns asianpu ue pantaaal al6og,o •xyq 'ltnon0 glxtS aql iO3 sivaddy 3o lino0 salols poltun aql aio;aq u011732TIll UI 'SZ (ASNIIOO HOV3g NI'IVd)'JVgINXXXXVLfj ooVO6loZOS'ON 3SVO wea-0sJlnDio UAk0j •A al,Cog,O'3 UJIM N Martin E. O'Boyle v. Town of Gulfstream CASE NO. 502014CA004474XXXXMBAG (PALM BEACH COUNTY) administration of justice, including to knowingly ... disparage ... witnesses ... or other lawyers on any basis......), Rules Regulating The Florida Bar. When professional judgment does not restrain a lawyer's zealous advocacy, however, the courts must act to assure that aggressive advocacy does not frustrate or disrupt the administration of judicial proceedings. See In Re Terry, 128 U.S. 289, 302, 9 S.Ct. 77, 79, 32 L.Ed. 405 (1888); Sandstrom v. State, 309 So.2d 17 (Fla. 4th DCA 1975), cert. dismissed, 336 So.2d 572 (Fla. 1976); see also Louis S. Raveson, Advocacy and Contempt: Constitutional Limitations on the Judicial Contempt Power, Part One: The Conflict Between Advocacy and Contempt, 65 Wash.L.Rev. 477, 53940 (1990). Carnival Corp v. Beverly, 744 So.2d 489 (Fla. l`a DCA 1999) 28. The O'Boyle Law Firm and William Ring have continued to represent O'Boyle in perpetrating these unethical and abusive activities. That conduct should also be sanctioned. WHEREFORE, Defendant prays this Court enter appropriate sanctions for litigation abuse against Plaintiff, Martin E. O'Boyle, his Counsel of Record, the O'Boyle Law Firm, P.C., Inc., Jonathan O'Boyle, President of the O'Boyle Law Firm, and William Ring, Esquire, including striking Plaintiff's pleadings, entering an order prohibiting Plaintiff from exploiting his right to litigate in a manner that impugns and threatens opposing counsel. Defendant also seeks an award of attorneys' fees and costs for bringing the motion. Respectfully sub�rnitted, S WEETAPPLE, BROEKER & VARKAS, PL Co -Counsel for Defendants 20 S.E. 3`s Street Boca Raton, Florida 33432 Telephone: (561)392-1230 E-Mail:pleadings@sweetapplelaw.com ROBERTA. SWEETAPPLE Florida Bar No. 0296988 LAw OFFICES or SWEErAPPLE, BROEKER & VARKAS, P.L. 20 S.E. 3w SraEEr, BocA RATON, FLORIDA33432-3911 IME-ZEKEWIVOIA'HocvTTvoog' anL Sm£'H'SOZ 6 88696ZO '0M lug upuold d'Iddvlaam5 'v .LIIdgMd :Ag '(uoo'dno S-aolalmuoon@Suum:ITMFI'•OISE-OLS-VS6-1 :auogdala.L) KZ£E EPIJOIq `gouag plagaaaQ `anuQ aa;ua0 uodmapl ;saAk 08ZI `'ouI 'dnojo 0012umToD `agnbsg Ting umglT,4& Puu `.(uoo•.Ta;solsouol@uuugoue !uoo'ia;sojsauol@gdlopuulf '.uoo•aa;sojsauo.F@.Touu000f :ITTouE[ '•000E-6S9-I9S-1:0u0gdalal,) SLVE-ZOPEE uPP014 'gosag ulud aM `OOI I a;mg `anuQ 1012si3 WOS SOS "V'd `sggT4S V uo;sugop `.Ta;sod `sauop `annbsg'usunlolg 'V aalgsV puu amTbsg `gdlopueg •O ugop'aimbsg 'iouuo0,o auseo f ,(woo•uuym21alAogo@n alAogo f Toul-d 'S889-tL9-17S6-I:au0gd2laJ) ZtiV££ uPuold `gmoH plaTpaaQ 'anuQ 'I'D uodmapl;saM 98ZI °'O'd `uL'?d ms'I alAog,O aqy ';uopcsaid 'azmbsg 'alAog,O ueTpsuop `.(Tuoo•uugtAulalXogo@niolAu;u 'uoo•uugmelapiogo@nusouTR :Iluu-g f9889-bL9-V56-i:auogdalay) ZVV££ uPuold `gDUag PIQUlQaQ 'anuQ IQIUQD ITodmal.I ;.sa`' w 98ZI O'd ` Id me j a,AogA QU 'agnbsg '101AsZ )PIN 'aimbsg 'esalnl Iuuno10 :o; VIOZ `Alnp 3o AgP P,E SUP Iuuod $Mild -d ag; BTA PaAJos sem fmoSaao; aq;;o Adoo ;oauoo pus ono s Imp AAIII133 &gaHaH I HDIA2['aS AO alVOIMI-da0 W.NnOD HOVflH ITIVd)'JVEMXXXXVL"ooVJV[OZOS "ON 3SVO ueajls3[sOdo UMO.L'A 211(0g.O'21Ut.UHVJ Jotw.SI ON &S1 uunS. P.A. John C. Randolph Atiomey 561-650-0458 Fac: 561-650-5300 jrandolph@jonesfaster com June 4, 2014 VIA EMAIL (wrincl(@commerce-oroup.com) AND REGULAR U.S. MAIL William F. Ring, Jr., Esquire 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 RE: Meeting of June 4, 2014 Dear Mr. Ring: Yesterday you requested a meeting between you and your client, Martin E. O'Boyle, and me and my partner, Joanne O'Connor_ We represent the Town of Gulf Stream. I inquired as to the subject matter of the meeting, but you would not disclose it in advance. At the outset of this afternoon's meeting, your client requested that our communications be treated as privileged settlement communications regarding pending litigation. We agreed that our communications would be treated as such only to the extent that they were, in fact, communications regarding the settlement of pending litigation. We specifically advised you that the privilege would not apply to any discussions relating to future litigation or threats of future action. Please be advised that because none of today's discussions concerned the potential settlement of any pending litigation between our clients, we do not consider them to be privileged settlement discussions under Florida II w_ Sincerely, JONES, FOSTER, JOHNSTON & STUBBS, P.A. By John C. Randol h EXHIBIT JCR-mtm p:ldomlI314T0005111tri1i17190 docx Since 1924 1 West Palm Bench I Jupiter I he -k. t w,r I...ur illi 4xlth 1'130crl)rirc Stam 111111 \CiYI Palm IUA I'Gxi.L, hill) www.lnnesrostcocnm bIOZ/II/9 "'II-ILU/aUTBNlC4lug/Ire;aQ;InsaUIoyeas/qDnOSaol;eaodio0/fa!nbuU`dzo•ziquns•gaieas//:d;;q XD d U to IIeIHX3 dew oy d0d w a6cwl MBI IA ;!I!gell pa;!w!1 epuold — 1760Z/90/90 sa ewl pal!d sNodaa lenuuV ON suo a�uuy ZVV££ ld 'HOV39 Oi31db330 3AIJ0 N31N301210dM3N 1S3M 02Z1 3 NWJVW '311.09,0 2iJW 811!1 ssaJppV 2 aweN l!e;a0 s uosJad pazuoq;nV ZVVEE ld 'HOV39 Oi31d2i330 3N2i0 a31N30IdOdM3N 1SEIM 02Z4 'W'd WVI-111WONIH ssaJppV g aweN;ua V para;s! as ZVVE£ ld 'HOV39 0191d2i330 3AIa0 N31N3O iH0dM3N 1S3M 09ZL ssayppy UMPIN ZVVEE ld'H0V39 O'13I=IH330 3AI80 a31N30 1210dM3N 1S3M 09Z6 ssa.ippV le !3LWd 1740Z/90/90 a;e0 0A!;3a;;3 3AII3V sn;e;S ld a;e3S 1760Z/90/90 papd a;e0 3NON aagwnN NI3/13d 96Z460000V61 jagwnN;uawnoo0 UO! ;ewyo;ul u!l!d Oil 'S3snOH a390S 3lddV 133MS ue wo0!l!ge!l pa;!w!l ep!yold li aWE!N fgRU3 Aq Ilejad Zdo I abed aweN latpug .�q piga Excerpt from the meeting of the Town Cmmission held on 6-13-14 listed on Agenda as Item VII. Caunmications A.2. fran Residents (5 minutes mexinm) Martin O'Boyle: Good morning everyone. I have a few things I would like to go over, but first I just want to give an explaination to the Commission and the public. You will notice that I no longer stand for the flag salute, and the reason (don't know what made it do that .... cell phone signal) and the reason for that is ----when I woke up this morning I was an American. When I walked thru those doors, that did it. This is no longer America and here the flag salute means something and in this chamber it means nothing. I just wanted to make that explanation so that if anybody asks they will have the explanation from the horses mouth.um--the Mayor sent a letter out about litigation and boy it sure is expensive--um--I didn't see Mr. Randolph pull up in a Roles Royce so I know he is not getting all the money although his firm as of Feb. to Feb, billed close to *300,000. um --frankly looking at the bills, and we looked at them, makes me puke. To my knowledge, the Town has never won- a case.since Jan. 13th in a hall of justice. And, by the way, I have no issues with Mr. Randolph, I think he is a good attorney, I think.liis price.is sensational and I think he represents this Commission in the best fashion he knows how and one that this Commission should be very pleased with. Thats my opinion. Then, you brought in Mr. Sweetapple whose clearly the fair haired boy. I don't know why a firm like Jones, Foster isn't enough, but I guess the Mayor doesn't have any buddies at Jones, Foster. Thats the only solution I can come to. ah --- Mr. Sweetapple's clearly a hot shot lawyer--um--th�Mayor gave the Commission and the residents a build up that was, frankly exciting, $500 an hour, charging us $350 an hour and he had experience in public records law. Well, there has been another law suite filed against the Town and the law suite that was filed against the Town was based upon Mr. Swe- etapple's noncompliance with the State Statute Chapter 119 for public records. He redacted portions of his bill and anyone who knows anything about public records knows if you are going to redact, you have to tell under which exception, if thats the right word, under which exception you are redacting. Mr. Ganger could say I am redacting my Social Security number in accordance with this section. That would be proper. Mr. Thrasher has done redaction the same way. Here he didn't, here you got a law suite. Also on his bill he talks about the Sunshine Law, well there's a document called the Sunshine Manual which teaches you how to navigate through the records act. So, where this guy came from, I guess it will always be a secret to me. We--ugh--one of my lawyers was in the court house and learned a little bit about Mr. Sweetapple. He had a case in the 1st Dist. Courtlo£ Appeals before Judge Berton, the Judge found that Mr. Sweetapple consistently misrepresented testimony and failed to acknowledge well established case law including Supreme Court precedence. There was another case in Palm Beach County Circuit Court, the Judge Elizabeth Moss says that Mr. Sweetapple'.s filing was a slander Mayor Nbrgan: I've got 5 minutes Mr. O'Boyle. O'Boyle: Yes, you do don't you. You want to let me --- Mayor: That'concludes your public comment. EXHIBIT O'Boylle: Pardon I 1 1 3 i Mayor: That concludes your public comment. O'Boyle: Well, I know. Do you want to let me finish is my question. Mayor: No, I don't. O'Boyle: I can understand why Mayor. Mayor: You have 5 minutes. Make your point in 5 minutes. Thank you __..—... —.....i. r,.t 1.. ...... _.. -- a.— YU— T..4.'1 :.. q..—..4—... ELle lHX3 S3PaM 'A00 511 '9110 a1 tum 0 ON •sin;nag uoswatLL 41 OZ suopgln2ai utetdpootl;o uopelmn 'uo!;aw•ysa s,VMA ul •sum>etotn Sutuoz otp;o asneoaq aouamsm poog slpluteld Sug2:)ueo lnoge f%waS puelawoHlo luaw -uedaQ aql o1 fonbm On apew aq pug yuawaSguew Soua2Tawo ,lo Jaoujo ale;s pug twapa; atp pagyou TmA jjj4ujuld ;suleSe patnal peq aq saSTego uou -elotn 2utuoz aq1 pansind 3lun3 'LOOZ isnSnV uI •sieaS 02314 ;sed aql To; uoytsod aq1 plaq aq Imp saleotpu! all 03gou itgl ul •spmoq agl wog SunM!s -ai sem aq legl Sutstnpe 'DIOZ 'ZI knonuef vo luawalels oil a panssl;oepua;aQ •ZNg •pound 911311;uen2123 aql Sutmp To,iaw ag1 sem oqm aleptpueo aql To; u2tudweo lwoXinu ag1 uo pa3pom gloq peq luepualap pus aq upliol,.l w pug uodSuo'l gloq Of pap!saT•l;gmeld g2nogllV •Toggg!au sjl!tuteld sam aq s1929 mol inoge To; pue'1TodSuoZlo luaptsw punol-Teat put 2wg-2uo1 a sem aH va OIOZ kninuef Pue LOOZ Annuef uaamlaq spieoq 2utuoz pue 2muueld suod2uoT3o Tagwaw t sem luepuala(j •aauempio 2muoz agl to suotlelom gltm unq Stngmgo oouou e pans[ sum gtluteld 'TagwaaaQ ;eq.L •2po3 gutplwq s,g2noiog oql palt:lotn 'math stq m 'imp sastwwd ag; ,lo IGA21 punm2 aql;o SU01IM2112 panaasgo)penq'aiagl 211glA •f4jadoid sdltluteld lnoqu;uawlmdop atg aq1 Xq panta3oi llso a of papuodsaT 'luaunnclop Smpltnq s;t to 22Aoldwa ue putt ;uawlisdap aig s,uod2uo7 Jo ;atg3 luelstsst aql '31un3 2arag 19002 uI '1X01 -1103 ap!noid;unwalels s,luepualap Smpaowd sluaea oqy •luepualap ,fq apew ;uawalels 912uts a vo SIs21 ucion to asneo s,g!;meld putt 'uod2uo•i;o g2naeog aql;o sluapts2i qloq apt;uepua}ap pus jjgwatd •sn aiolaq Taliew Aluo aq; st;uaw2pnf fainua nslo luw2 agl pue'pwanas pin sem lutpualap Aq uollewalop to wleto stgy I aged •passtwstp aTam sw1e13 sjpupildlo lwanas PUG awtl a Tol siaglo q;!m p2l¢pilosuo3 sem lu!eldwo3 sn0 'aunt o; saaglns ll •leadde uo pastor anssi a p of leua;ew lou St 11 asne32q uno3 JUL aq; ut 29e3 slilplo Ciozstq lumpao -cud paleogdwo3 aql ltalap lou op aM INA PIM •uutl;e am'mopo; legl suose21211 Toa tui vopowulap Sut22pe;meldwoo a uo uasl Talad luupuaj2p to Tonal w ;uaw2pnf knimums to 1ue12 e wog sluadde alSog,o 'H u.,vow BRUPIld T+ 'YVVII no dad 'OSIM30V PUM H0f1VM c -l -D D sa2pn f 210lag •(jauq atp uo 'ut.gnS •Tlnt ,s.Cawo)lu ,vd'palxeM V utalsuoS STaqu!a1S Ta3lonZ) wapuodsaT To; asneo aql p2n2Te uL.uns'M P1All •(lauq atp uo'tuuenot2uog •V op!on l :sfawoue'alf0%o •TNl pue •V•d'auognEl V sgooef) luelladde Tol asneo ag; ponSTe 'aotn 3eq oid pou!tu -pa 'Teg etuenlAutiod aql to 'alS0g,0 •g ueglguo f '80-16£Z-1 'ox la)13oQ'f4itnoO 3tivellV 'lotsln!G me'l 'A2raaf maNlo uno0 TouadnS tuoid leadde u0 't+IOZ 9 E'vef PaptoaQ 'E10Z'I i '30a panSTV •;uapuodsag—lwpua;aQ 'NgSl Ta;ad n `;uelladdV-g!lmt!d'3 T,[Og,O'3 utImW •uotsintQ 2lulloddV 'A2vQf maN;o uno0 Touadns ''JNLLIO 3110M sH'Inu 11MO0 XOHHO'NOIMdO QHHSI'IgndNf1 •algel!ene dllu2Tm3 s<uoge;to mehsaM aql X100 ((•Q•VaadnS'f'N) 60To6£ IM 6TOZ :su a1l0) ('(j'V'TadnS'f'N) VoloPE 7M t lOZ'P£'V tq pauodagION MeJJsaM Not Reported in A.3d, 2014 WL 340104 (N.J.Super.A.D.) (Cite as: 2014 WL 340104 (N.J.Super.A.D.)) would increase flood insurance premiums for the community of Longport. From September 2007 through early July 2008, plaintiff and members of his family filed multiple requests pursuant to the Open Public Records Act (OPRA), N.J.S.A. 47:IA-1 to —13. Longport's only clerk worked part-time, and she did not address the requests within the time required by statute. At one point, the clerk went to the emergency room because of the stress she attributed to the flood of OPRA re- quests. And, in February 2008, the Borough's solicitor notified plaintiff that it would not accept any addi- tional OPRA requests. he fled, explaining that the numerous requests were substantially disrupting gov- ernmental services. The solicitor claimed that Long - port had received 190 requests on October 16 and 17 and thirty filed on October 31, 2007. In April 2008, plaintiff filed a civil complaint to compel Longpores compliance with OPRA. And in June, Longport remind NFC Global, an investigative firm, to uncover any prior difficulties plaintiff may have had with federal and state agencies. The firm completed its report later that month. On July 2, 2008, the Press of Atlantic City reported on the numerous OPRA requests. There is no dispute that Longport incurred significant legal fees in defending against plaintiffs suit. I Plaintiffs OPRA suit was pending hen de- fendam made the allegedly defamatory statement on July 5, 2008. That day, plaintiff was walking and conversing with Leonard Sylk and Fred Kremer, both residents of Longport, near an entrance to the beach by defendant's home. According to plaintiff, defendant said, "what are you guys doing with him, he's the enemy of Longport" Plaintiff further asserts that defendant made the same comment to Willir Simon, when Simon stopped his car to talk to the men. Ac- cording to Simon, defendant, referring to plaintiff, said "he is the enemy of the people of Long- port[,][s]tay away from him." Page 2 *2 Those present had different views of defend- ant's comment. Defendant said he was joking, and Sylk thought the same. According to Sylles testimony, defendant was "sort of laughing" and "sounded like he was joking' when he and Kremer were asked "why [they were] consorting with the enemy." Sylk also noted that plaintiff laughed. In contrast, Simon thought defendant was angry and serious. While insisting that he made the remark about plaintiff being the enemy in jest, defendant admitted that he believed plaintiff was fairly characterized as the enemy of the residents of Longport He based that opinion on plaintiffs conduct, which in his view, led to Longport's unnecessary expenditures for legal fees. In plaintiffs opinion, defendant made the remark intending to have the residents of Longport ostracize and isolate him and succeeded. He based that opinion on subsequent municipal actions singling him and his friends out for unfavorable treatment and affording defendant favorable treatment. In plaintiQ's view, defendant's comment was the cause of his ill-treatment. Plaintiff gave several examples. Days atter de- fendant made the commeat, Longport's mayor called the County Health Department, which subsequently directed plaintiff to remove portable toilets from lits property on the beach. In August, plaintiff filed a complaint against another resident for threatening his life, which the police did not investigate. Moreover, a friend of plaintiffs asserted that in May 2009, a police officer, who had detained him for forty minutes without proper cause, admitted that he had been di- rected to give him a hard time because of his friend- ship with plaintiff, who was an enemy of the people. Plaintiff also had evidence of defendant's favorable treatment. Another police officer admitted that he had not issued defendant a ticket when he saw him violate the law prohibiting use of a cell phone while driving. 0 2014 Thomson Reuters. No Claim to Orig. US Gov. Works. " s J p o l l t " n o 0 S f l " S u p o 1 u n e l o o x " s t a l n m d u o s w o t i j " b I O Z o " , ( m e a d p a s l ! w w o a g a u o a a i e g l u o t u t d o s m l u m a t p j o u o t s s a z d t ( a l i e S m n t o n u t a s e a a ' ( 0 6 6 1 ) 8 1 ' 1 P Z - P . 7 7 1 1 1 ' 9 0 L Z ' 9 6 9 Z 7 3 ' S 0 1 1 ' 6 1 ' 1 ' S ' I I a s , ' " o o l n u m o p W M 0 7 " e g o l e o i l y p u o 6 1 2 3 " { l y u t e l d P ! g l . : a s n g e t e g a a n a a g l o P U B . . . 9 2 p u 1 1 u l n n ' s a p t u a a s g o a n t s i l o g o = 4 u o n e u a e ; a p g s t n u u t l - s t p J s n w s l m o o ' s n g j " P l g l ' 6 1 0 1 e u n g o p s e a l g e u o p - a l l l o u 0 . 1 1 1 6 a g 1 ' a m s u a n o 2 q A e w 2 1 o g j 2 c U q p u l l C g u e j o a d ' S w t t e o - a w e u ' s l l n s w ' s l a g l ! d a g 2 n o g l [ V p l g l ' a a u a S ! I l a s u t o 1 9 e u o s e a z ; o s u o s a a d C q u a n l S o q P 1 n o m s p i o m a g 1 1 a g 1 s u t u e a w t n i M e a p u l l l e j o L p . 1 a p t s a o a s p t t o a y u a w a l a l s l D i p j o J U D I = a g l o z , r o t e o . L ' 6 [ l E T N 0 8 t ' o . 1 d n s ' s l l a S u p a " l u a w a l m s p a t e a t - t e g a D I P J O s x a s u w a q s P E R f 4 j j ! g e g u 2 n a q i y u a J u o o D I P : s a o l a n l a a z g p a a p p u o o s l m o a ' S u i t m o u l t a o l e u r e ; a p ; o 2 1 4 1 1 d e 3 S t l u a w a l e l s u a a g s a g m S u t u t u u a l a p E l l ' ( Z I O Z ) 8 E Z ' 6 Z Z T A t O 1 Z " V ' ( 7 ' n ' V T ' . [ [ " 2 9 1 1 1 ; s t p s s a t u n f a i i j u t e j o p l o u s i P u a w a l e l s V ' ( S O O Z ' n l ( , " d d V ) 0 8 ' E 9 ' " t a d n S T N 6 L E ' - J u l ' " 0 0 F u l p o { L g o o a g n " a B u l S 3 S p w e t d g i r l u u g i a a g l o u o s . 1 a d a o f p a l e o w - n w w o a s e m g o t g m p u l l o s l e j s e m q a ! q m ' j j i . j L q v j d a y l $ w w 9 3 1 1 a 3 l u e p u a j a p 2 1 P , C q s p e w l a E l ; o l u a w a J e l s n j o P ! n s a z 1 1 s e s a S 1 1 w e p p a a a j j n s 2 1 I s a o a q s u E p m o q s J s n w j i p u p l d a ' u o t l u u w p a p g s t l q u i s o o s ' s n U ' ( 9 6 6 1 ) O O L P Z P 9 7 � � [ ' Z S L 7 0 ' S 9 [ [ ' 9 9 0 1 ' S " f l 9 [ S p a l u a p " 1 - 1 2 0 ' ( 5 6 6 1 ) 6 0 t , ' Z 6 E T N 6 E l " d 1 0 J p a o a a y u a g 4 a g n " o u l ' n o d a & r j a m o u i u m o 7 1 i n , 1 " g a u u v f a c q - 1 t u 1 3 j a p p u l l a s t e ; S u u a j j n s l n o g i t m s u o t J e s n d a i a a g s A o f u a a i a a a j a q p i n o g s a l d o a d l e g p s e m i s o o a a 1 1 o P 2 U * ( 1 1 0 6 6 9 8 P Z P 9 7 S L I ' M I 7 3 ' S [ E I ` " S ' f I p a t u a p ' v a o T o m ) m ) Z 1 S ' O O S T y [ 0 z ' - o u l ' " d a D o l p a N X a s r a f I V " n o u o z l o S " 1 2 1 R o u e ; o u o t l e l - n d a a a q l s a i n f u ! I m p I m u l g l e l s 2 s 1 e ; E ; o u o y e a t i g n d u o d n p o s e q p a s o d w t s i u o p e u n i j a p t o j t 1 ! 1 ! g E ! I u o p s a n b 5 U P P a n t o s a t , S p a a u o a ' m a t h m o i n ' a a g 2 g i a g p n f ' ( Z O O Z ) 6 1 1 9 ' Z O 9 T N E L I u o s p u y y ��H f o , & U e - o u l E g u i l d ' " s o a 8 ! l o b " o n o u a p m o t n a i i s n w a m g o ! g m ' ( " O Z ) 6 1 ' i T W 0 8 1 ' 1 1 1 H A s g a S u V a p ' s p n o a D i p a o j m u t j o u o p s a n b a s ! i u U " S u t u e a w C m l e u t � j a p E S u t n e q j o a t g e d e a u t s e m l u a w w o o s , s u e p �� 1 2 j 2 p n k p S u t p n t a - u o a w p a u a 2 2 p n f a t p l a g s s p u a s u o a 3 3 p u l e l d " u o p e w w a a l a p s , a a g g ! H a S p n f w a g p 1 1 p u l l g J t m a a a S e a m p a l l - p u E i s I m p s a t i l d d V " ( 9 6 6 1 ) 0 9 ' O Z S ' T - j V Z P I ' " n t V f o " o f f " s u l a " ( 7 u o l p l 0 1 2 D ' n 1 1 1 1 9 3 j p u l l i l d a o 3 l o t p t a n e a m s a a l o u P 1 n o o s a a u a z a j u t p u l l a 3 1 1 2 p t n 0 0 1 9 e 1 o n e j F I E j o l g o u a q a g l j j i l u t e l d D I P S U I A 1 9 , C m f 1 1 a s n e a a q ' m a t j o J a m w E s e w o u t S p n f o f p a p p u s 6 1 i u e p u a ; - a p a a g l a g m s ! u o p s a n b a t L L " ! . m o a ! e t a s D I P s e p a s - p u l l s a u r e s D i p s 2 g d d e p n o a s t i p y u e p u a j a p j o n o n e ; u t w a w u p n f k n u a t i n s j o s u e t s a S u t m a t n a a u l � r T a e ; a I o u ' u o t t n d o u s s i u o t l d u o s a p p a t a a s s u a q s a s n e a a q ' u o p e w e j a p j o S u t p u y E p o d - d n s ' m u t j o j 2 p i n a a s e y o u u e a s a o d S a o 7 j o s w a u a 2 W s e j ; p u t u t d S u t q , m s a p l a a w a l u l s s , l u e p u a j o p l e g ! p a u t t w a l a p a a g S ! H a S P n f - 1 1 0 2 ' E Z . 1 a g w a l d a S 1 P u 1 1 p a a a s u a s o u s e m u n e t a u o p e w e j a p s g q u t e t d u o l u e p u a ; a p j o a o n r ; l i t w 2 t a p n f A n i n t u n S " a a u e t t d w o a - 1 1 0 1 1 p 2 2 2 1 1 e s g p u t e t d u o p a s e q s a S a e g o a q i p o s s t w s t p f a l p d t a t a n w a i r s g a t g m a a p u n s u a w 2 a a 8 e u s p a g o e a a j j p u l E l d p u l l p o d g u o - I ' 8 0 0 2 l s n S n y u t a a l e t . 1 o n r 3 s j j p u t u l d w p a n l o s a a 2 1 0 M s o o p 1 1 t o t n S u t u o z a g " L " u o p o e J E E P u [ a a p a o 1 1 1 w ; a q l a p n l a u t l o u s a o p p i o n a a D i p p u l l % 2 1 2 1 P p 2 1 e 1 0 1 A p a l d 0 0 0 e p e q 1 1 s i s a n b a a V - d d o 2 g J 3 o u o t l t s o d s t p s p o d g u o 7 l e g J u n e l o s d i p u t e l d ; o s l u a w D I P s s a a p p e l o u p i p u n o a o q J ' a o t s t o a p I m p u l 3 1 p u t e l d w m ; s s s a n b a z y 1 1 d O a a n s n ; i d a o o e o 1 p o d S u o 7 p 2 3 0 2 1 1 p ! m o a D I L L " u o p a e V H d O 2 1 P l i t a n s s t a l i o U O P a t n a u o t s t n I G 1 n e ' i a q s ' . 1 2 1 1 1 1 g l u o w 2 1 1 0 * 9 1 1 1 7 l i p s s e m P u m d w o o V - I d o S t q 2 1 1 1 I M ' 8 0 0 Z ' S [ C l n f a o u 0 p e w 1 1 j a p S u l g a 1 l a l t n s m e t s n p p a l g p l i O u l d ( ( " Q " V a a d n S ' f ' b l ) 6 0 1 0 6 � I M p j 0 Z : s e a i 1 O ) ( ' O " y a a d n S ' f l ) V O I O Y E I M 4 1 0 Z ' P � ' V u i p a l a o d a g B a t y Not Reported in Aad, 2014 WL 340104 (NJ.Super.A.D.) (Cite as: 2014 WL 340104 (N.J.Super.A.D.)) Recognizing that opinions cannot be "false," the Court stressed that there is no "wholesale defamation ex- emption" for any statement that might be labeled an opinion. Id at 18, 110 S.Ct. at 2705, 111 L. Ed2d at 17. The Court explained that if a reasonable fact -finder could conclude that the speaker implied plaintiff committed pedury, then the implied assertion of fact would amount to defamation, if proven false. Id, at 20, 110 S.Ct, at 2706-07, 111 L. Ed2d at 19. *4 The Court's opinion in MAkovich points out the difference between the statement at issue in that case and this one. The Court stated: "unlike a subjective assertion[,] the averred defamatory language [here] is an articulation of an objectively verifiable event," i.e., whether the plaintiff had actually committed perjury. Id at 22, 110 S.Ct. at 2707, 111 L. Ed2d at 20. But in this case, defendant's characterization of plaintiff as the town's enemy, while arguably insulting, does not imply any particular conduct or event that could be verified as true or false. For example, defendant did not refer to the zoning violation or the number of OPRA requests. He simply indicated that plaintiff was an "enemy" of Longport. It is well-settled that a statement is not actionable when it has an imprecise meaning. Buckley v. Littell, 539 F.2d 882, 893 (2d Cir.1976) (holding that the terms "fascist," "fellow traveler" and `radical right" were too imprecise, loose and insusceptible of proof to be considered defamatory). Whets the meaning of an insulting assertion—here the enemy of Longport—is not settled, its truth or falsity cannot be proven. On similar reasoning, this court has held that a statement that could be understood to describe another as one who is not "a decent resident" cannot support a def- amation claim because it does not state or imply something amounting to slander per se, such as criminality. Taurus v. Borough of Pine Hill, 381 N.J.Super. 412,427-28 (App.Div.[2005), ed in part, rev'd in part on other grounds, 189 N.J. 497 (2007); see also Romaine v. Kallinger, 109 N.J. 282, 291 (1988) (discussing slander per se). Page 4 Like a statement implying that one is not "de- cent," a statement that one is an "enemy" of a mu- nicipality does not imply any verifiable fact. Relying on the various contexts in which the phrase public enemy has been used over time, plaintiff argues that defendant's statement could be understood as calling him a traitor, an outlaw, a criminal or a pirate. That may be, but it could just as easily be understood to describe a person who disapproves of the town's leaders, the way they do business or their goals. We reject plaintiffs attempt to equate this state- ment of uncertain meaning to a "false attribution of criminality," which is deemed slanderous as a matter of law. Romaine, supra, 109 N.J. at 291. As previously noted, statements alleged to be defamatory or slan- derous must be assigned the " 'fair and natural meaning' " that would be assigned by "reasonable persons of ordinary intelligence.'" Id. at 290 (quoting Herrmann v. Newark Morning Ledger Co., 48 NJ.Super. 420,431 (App.Div.), ajrdon rehearing, 49 N.J.Super. 551 (App.Div.1958)). So viewed, defend- ant's labeling of plaintiff as an enemy of Longport or its people could not be understood as anything other than name calling. Because defendant's statement did not imply any verifiable conduct or event and simply voiced his OPT ion, it cannot be proven false. Even if every res- ident of Longport other than defendant deemed plain- tiff to be a friend of the municipality, it would not make defendant's opinion false, because he did not imply that his view was universally held or was based on a verifiable event. *5 Our resolution of the case an the ground that this statement is not, as a matter of law, defamatory manes it unnecessary to consider the arpments ad- dressing plaintiffs status as a public figure. Affirmed. 0 2014 Thomson Reuters. No Claim to Orig. US Gov. Works. 'gJOM'A00 Sfl'2110 0l wivio om •slalnag uoswogj 6102 1NEMOOO 30 OM3 ('O'V'aadnS•f-M) 60106£ 'IM 6IOZ `PE'V ui papodag loN uasl •n apCo8,O ' 610Z`O' V'jadnS'f'M ((•O•VvadnS'f'M) 60TO6E m 6IOZ .se a71O) ('(I'V'sadnS'f'N) 60I06£'IM 6loZ `p£'V uc papodag 3oN 9 aged Millionaire deluges state attorney with public records requests after daughter's DUI coni... Page 1 of 1 Government Law Millionaire deluges state attorney with public records requests after daughter's DUI conviction Posted Mar 26, 2013 3:10 PM CDT By Martha Neil Corrected: At one time, Martin E. "Marty" O'Boyle was a political ally of Florida state attorney Dave Arenberg, helping him position himself to get elected. But after Aronberg refused to take a position concerning the 2011 misdemeanor driving -under -the -influence conviction o O'Boyle's daughter, Sara, the two parted ways. They still have regular dealings, however, due to the deluge of public records requests regularly submitted by O'Boyle, whose daughter has performed community service and paid a fine but is also appealing her conviction, reports the Palm Beach Post. Florida has one of the broadest public records laws in the country, allowing citizens to access material such as emails and texts. And Marty O'Boyle, determined to help his daughter reverse her conviction, is seeking to take full advantage c it, according to the newspaper. In a single month, a company he controls submitted 1,328 requests for publicrecords to Aronberg and the office for the prosecutor overseeing Sara O'Boyle's case, after Aronberg recused his own office from doing so. The problem is, the public records requests submitted by O'Boyle's company—which, altogether, are among the most massive in state history—require review and redaction of records before they can be turned over, the newspaper explain: "I have been, and am, a supporter of the public records law; said State Attorney Bruce Colton of the 19th Judicial Circui whose office is now overseeing Sara O'Boyle's case. "But I think the law can be abused. When you look at the number c requests ... these requests could amount to an abuse of the public records law." Related coverage: Palm Beach Post (July 2012): "Dave Arenberg, millionaire ally behind stealth attacks in state attorney's race" Updated on March 27 to correct Aronberg's job title. Copyright 2014 American Bar Association. All rights reserved. EXHIBIT http://vp, v.abajoumal.com/news/article/millionaire_deluged_state_attomeys_with_1328 1 us se pomen aq pinm Biaquojy q4m saeueyaxa slylo auo jalpaym BuplPayP sem led edsmaueyquyl .o plot jollodw ejgp •Ilam se Isod ata uo wlq pinam aKog.O'LlgewRlll Fq uequm 001lnoq e6u n ul— •pmunouue Braquojywgaq ew4 ayi ul siamumilayl 6uquawnoop—Bisquoy Ip p spewelo spaipuny lsod ayL q 6ulsealw'wly ua pewnl eKagp'uaylBSq sy uOwJOW •pgelmlmslw fuaquojy'aylog,0 6ups0ue ul Ing •aKogA wwpllo auou'000'ILbS Pasiw pet' sgluowxls ultplm pue jgel step a 1LI1MCplpum sly pwepap fuaquoy'uOR38la-w yaaslou pinom ay peaunouue—wig purwre Bulplms u5ledweof4seu aylLq'ples ay'ped ul peouangul—a)IllrMW uaym'L1'uepjapego pwadel eKog,O gllm uopwagellm s,8raquory .(ad of aa.(o dwe a ,"geplpum a awmaq I wgaq wu g peau Feyl 4ulgl I.Il l ,spa NOOgmej j q I Kog.O ue po6jn ay'pmunouue ay wgaq stepxlslsnl' lualg s,BwquaN slemai Ilewo ue'mugsul ww auo ul •Buluum qpm pa(g BrequW'In04Sncu4j aueld genud s,aKog,O uo aesseyelleL g epu dpl•punw a pgda=u ay'mu0 •salty a7elslo uoggoy.lequgod e'sjno glom Bupnp6ueEMelg sly waglugslsse s,ey(og,0 g suonangsul pglewa aH •ewpjaledrg uodgeuolsemo'sPoga s,aKog,O popinfi 7gmaswd oplmggs a ugp'wsquojy Imppod Buipnpul'enwnd g sash Ieulwlm�Lp!ym Bulppop ul uommp snouuoue se haw a gels a I 'uo#dnum 4 ell yL'sgo(pgaale luepodwll ow sj(lunoO yPeag wled to auo:arlgs ly 'plp do BulB6lp pue slalsgwd BuKed'guawaslpwpe 6uluum Xlmlposse panow RegL'lenu a ouluuspun g wnsealdslp s,wleuoppw elo aBquenpe glq g,ylugloddo us semll'Braquaq joj •pjmw slgy6nep sly)Io uogalnum 1110 a adlm g lsano ssopugw sly ul ps auo Isnj sem II'aylog,p joj a41 g 6ulsopslp lno411m aKog,O walldlay qog ell os'gepipum a asw 'suopeuop q pqunowe Gley pinom aspuarpa leym Pggnd 11 Iq pwepap tat lou Pell gels jg jauuru luoq ayl mou— Biaquary •/owaas pill ul paxlomAetU •I sod yPeag wled agLRq paulggo guawmop pue smayuqul g Bulpwme'suogoala u1/auwedsueg sin ase g peuBlsep smei epuolj 6ulppls lysnopnm'a)Igr" IsweBe gpepelo u&edweo a jg do Peweq aKog,O pue Biequwy'sypiow jngjaA0 pgs eta Llua semlegL sjope uazoPiley a pwlgs6gegoe JoBue/ylunwwmla Buunodino us se smou6 &ue uo aadw damDgsietil sumopeid/gUed do Paudg ISISsepa wol maewow p4 41 p 1 nq lsgwd a moll s,1ey1 Puy jauueldAued a do paulllugslsse eylog,0 W y6nous ja�gap lou pinoa ay ming -Il g paqug aweu s I dlay q'aKog,OLyep wleuogpw wewlSAnO'Alle pungmou a pgse ay'lljwly wgsalwd IBI lueml,uplp inq jsgwd a pquem'Biaquwy ane0'goj s,glprpulq poluem og4UBwayl esnmaq pled8 pla6 wom6agL *pled Suglae wemhagl esnmaq wayl wam,(egL•afiegnololno wayl l,uwam velsgwd ayllalsow Ing 'Nleuad 1peap arp adeoss pinom'600ZFe0 6uyg6sHuegL ua saAgelwjng PalBq oym'eBlyreyy leeyoyp Inedlusew leyl leap said a paleg06au Isn( pet' apprtyaly vBlaw Cl wlyjg Bul0mdlufiue'mglo 6,9111IR9'M Isewn AGwgR/ algS aplgno Pel Ise] pagwew dnwB pews e'suoolleq mo0a5 Buldsw8 pue su6ls apewpuey 6uheM WQIPM )IBIS Isod gPeag wled pj4uld wept' pue lWawanua laorAe palelou jL:sn 7B IN, %. JI 3j11$ aoea StAOUJOW a;e;S ui S){oe;;e q;jeajs puigaq Alle aaieuoijjiw `5.iaquoay ane(] Zl0Z'ZZFInr'AepunSweC101 'Palsad well suets smau Bunlewg !r. Jrj 1� r: jgslfiay I ul USIS wmjawgsn0 (jaded sAupoL I agposgns 'und OZZI I I,IOZ le AInr UpslnyL uo an moposj attempted bribe, he told the paper that he was "revisiting' the Information he had Provided *b3 confirm Its validilym and that the paper was not authodsd to use the information or to attach his name to It. E)perts later told the paper mat O'Boyle's actions likely did not meet the legal definifion ofatlempled bribery. Arenberg, a Democrat, refused repeated requests for an Interview to discuss his actions, addressing through his campaign manager only four of more than 80 questions asked in writing by The Post. Sent hundreds of pages of his own em ails and asked to verify them. Arenberg didn't respond. Ina one -paragraph statement, he blamed O'Boyle's revelations on one of his opponents: no-pariycandidato Robert Gem hman, a criminal defense attomeywho represents O'Boyle's daughter. 'This is a dishonest political attack waked up bymyopponent Mr. Gershman—full ofmisrepresenlatons and gross ehaggemtions; Arenberg said.'As special prosecutor, I ham always acted according to the leterand spidtofthe laws ofthe stole of Florida and the policies of the Office ofthe ALomey General. I'm proud ofmyrecord ofpromn ethical leadership as an assistant atomeygeneral, special prosecutorand state senator.' The never -before -told storyofwhat happened when Dam Arenberg met M arty0'Boyle, and whytheybroke apart, offers a rare window into how power and moneyinlersectto shape politics —and lives —in Palm Beach County. 'Myviewin life is: Take whatevershots ulikeatme,becauseltnablg bo and l can handle mem. Butdonl mess with myk Ids, my wifeormy home. Dont do It Dun Because 111 came afyouwimeveryresoumelhave.Antl mere'saloL' —Na,lre'6eya, F.AIn. FImMw Itwas March 2011 and In downtown West Palm Beach, a spectacle filled the sky. Dayafter day, a plane circled the courthouse, trailing bannem:'Bewam thug prosecutors."Prosecuiodal perjuryis Vanny."'Dump McAuliffe for prosecutor, vale for Elmer Fudd ; The planes were a remarkable reaction to a common event In 2008 in Delray Beach, a police officer saw a woman driving 5 mph on a residenfiai street at 323 a.m., with halfhercar on the grass. The 19-yearbld told him she had had two cocktalls and a beer. She tailed a bream test and was charged with misdemeanor DUL In Palm Beach County, prosecutors file an average ofnins DUI cases everyday. But mal woman was Marty O'Boyle's daughter, and Marty O'Boyle is an unusual man. The son ale seamstress and a cabby, O'Boyle said he grew up in a tinyrowhouse In Woodland, NJ. At 17, he said, he dropped out ofhigh school. By 18, he was married and had areal estate license. By24, he had four kids and his first million. That million grew Into many more. Starting in the 1970s, he built hundreds ofstores, including construction far the growing Color Tile and Peoria Yislan chains. Now he is 60 and says his businesses —ton from a 14pamon office in Deerfield Beach—include shopping centers and stores in about 25 states, including Florida. Ina light over business Interests, O'Boyle rarely backs down. Ina fight for his family, rarely Dims Into never. The tralfic court case spawned a thick volume full of morons and countermolions, with Gershman arguing the case was tainted bypolice mistakes and faulty breath4est equipment. it led to a three-dayjury trial. Sara O'Boyle was found gulltyin March 2011. She was sentenced to 75 hours ofcommunityseMce, a sl*month loss of herdriver license and a $500 fine. ABerme trial, Marty O'Boyle called the slate attorneys office and asked to speak b MaAulifle about the case. O'Boyle said he laid the woman who answered the phone: "I want to see ill couldjustspend a few moments with him and see if there's anything that could be worked oul.' O'Boyle wanted McAuliffe to drop the OUT charge, even after she served the sentence, to clear her permanent record, he said. j O'Boyle was told that McAuliffe wasn't available. McAuliffe told The Past he didn't know of O'Boyle's request unfit after the banners began to fly. The legal issues in the vase didn't rise to his level. McAuliffe said. But the rejection angered O'Boyle.'Ijust said to myself, "the guy won't give me the courtesy of 15 minutes of his life?" O'Boyle recalled. "Wall, lel me show him what kind of courtesies I can give him.'" O'Boyle had brawled with aumoritybetore. in 2006, a permitting dispute threatened his Longpon, NJ., waterfront home. O'Boyle struck back with lawsuits. Planes trailing banners —one called the mayor a'puppet'—flew over Longpod's beach for months. 'Unfortonatelywhen you're dealing with a body polite, they have a lot of resources; O'Boyle said. "SomeOmes you have too enter m ' e area of unconventional warfare Almost five years later in West Palm Beach, government once again stood in O'Boyle's way. He started a Twitter account Lnder the name 'BannerM4n' and began flying planes. It didn't help with McAuliffe. But the stunt drew attention. South county political operative Marie Horenburger, who salon a charily board with O'Boyle's wife, gave him a call. She asked: Would he like to meet Dave Arenberg? O'Boyle replied: M'ho's Dare Arenberg?' 'Dave—do you wartime to take you—plenty ofroom and no problem? We11 gel you mere by bpm or so. t.1 will be easy and you will be fresh. Advise' —op.:0100 vn OffgM n i aA 1. r".% elayt. pmr. calm. Dave Arenberg, too, faced an obstacle in Michael McAuliffe. In 2002, Arenberg entered polifics as a 31 -year-old rising star—a charismatic, Harvard -educated slate senator. But he left mid -tern to ton for abomeygeneral in 2010 and lost in the Democrafic primary. He found work quickly. Pam Sandi, the Republican who ultimatelywon the altomeygenemi's job, made a spot for him as a $92,000-a-yearspecial prosecutorinvesOgaling pill mills. But Arenberg was eyeing anomerelected job: McAullffe's. Again, he faced a Democratic primary he might not win. True, McAuliffe had angered some influenfial Democrats by prosecuting Democratic County Commissioner Jeff Koons on coruption charges t heymoughtwere weak Local attorneys, both in the criminal defense bar and within his own once, chafed at his style and decisions. Arenberg seemed a logical choice to oppose him: Popular with Democratic voters, he had long-standing political connections and could be a ravenous fundralser. But many prominent Democrats remained pledged to the incumbent McAuliffe. Some urged Arenberg not to ton, hoping to amid a divisive primary. He was warned that'Itwould ,16uN/6squeyL AddeH ""Howe gwedes a ul igwd l aua Wfi n puss Iu "•.y6naueired,:fuequwly ,Indupua6illgul noA anr6lou uea 1 oS -spa sip ul acuwag/p lspa(ew a see IDU op I'we I Jeipingewe Dip 6ulaq—mea,:alfog0 uBlgall 'agljnyopl'u6jsay, pue,ay6ty;y isuieBy alwowaa. Bulpnpui'sueBois sly to Imams pasnAwUjueppa sem puey sly ply •PigsAetp'lupieyyao pus al q sa6essowool IgealB 6ulpuaa Iaswp loiases lsgwd)wg e4g Aq enwp 9H glel sem aouasaid s,Biaquaying q we u sem fila u -uses eq Oma q oiy'seam tpoq ul pty;pauopuaw aq glou sl aweu s,Biaquoy,:llewa us ul oweu s,Biaquaiylnd pe4 oym M110 n a pallewa e9oe,p'pwedwd Rayl sy '0095 iol wcpe xis tillm'pauaddey 1191.AcN uO'Pies aKoS,O'paysnd Biaquoy Ing •ule6e 11 op 01 ieBea l,usem a908,0'Aeuow pug 410M yonw as sem puo lwp MU •ryagiejBM asPa ialfiel j sy1 uo uooleS s/Ielpwe •a'31e /ted yapll u6ledwo s,GgllrW;y aplslno Bull sna—lsalwd pumas a iq payse 6iaquay )ilalelp�wwl lsolury u6lsea Bald s!ull ldmop egllWuyy,:pieoq iplmpues a pue—looyos s1Viy6neP s14—Iwwa pies letp tlm a womlleswly aKogp -vgoe pled is soaAojdwe e9o13,0 iatple wem JIB lsowlV'aoglo s9awoge Vials Big to luoq uj dool e g payleM walsalwd uazop a uetp wgy'euaos eg pwgdm e9oS,0Aq pwly iatdwooepN 0'01, AoN u0 lunms!p DOSS elofi e9og,p as 'Apes gal wgsapwd malt' •wno4 mol iol 00Y' IS qsm sgl,•isViwdAlle=I ul Viedppied q aldoad 01. ig pallppaqumy •sallied s,uwppya smatpiegAuedwm ilawO piumoO e'pueAplej splN P011m ayS 'auoPl1I061urygyea 1!198 um stop no<—spolum io6 s(n6 no pgla6 epo8 a 'Papmw OIAm0,:0uop All op wall am'auo Af,'pww ayilo sem 9H.-f4dwe do awen ay Ing •wet'! pug pinom a4 !ulpgyaa plg 6iaquoy'611eg1ul 'wgsgwd:Bulsslw sem BUM auoAlup •Apew isowle sem lsgwd q41 lsu!eBy genowaO,; u6jsey'ag9rpoly •u&say,: uVilq salppm egpnygy,:6w n ul' !ewa ue u ' e9e>taN1 iol mgsnr.-416upluls wow —pue,agynygq P p I ul pelupdwl sum9eq mollepyfiugiap o q pue walg anew g aa(oldwe allog,owtgoue papw!p 949—pugs nm wgs wd wa m no u '9ddflndow mna. ullim PI Vi 4 1 pug q wa(mel Pqlnsum a9oS,0 pue a4S •sulgunow 6upow ue6aq lupielya0 •mlyo sKawage gels ag ap!slno leap sig In Isgwd a aeueBio of iulinMao peAse Biaquoy avow ILsyS.lseq s a9og,0lo sun sem'luyelyea es!u80 juola!sse Mnplus a9agA; puey auo 4I!M ulgunow e g'le6elwed a se peu!wl •Biaquoy ulllm iliom q siuolslsse s!ylo Duo PauBlsse el yaw lwyAatp igly •/ylugioddo us mss fiiequoid /gleuad geop egg uayi pue le!q a pguemeH y ayol glou s6pnlayi pa6Baq pue jeep ayI paisgap'iaylel s,eKeyery'uoglS w!f Ing luau fiu es ue 'sawPa oywoq lsow sAunoo tpeag wled)a euo q wnsop Buuq pue gp igAeme eBltpgy Ind pjnom Bald eta uVildnj• u I Ip NI H 4liaso—uoPIS eKBMen Plo-jest-9 Bgpnpul— swilelw mg pupil Paul aBIWaW'60OZ ul •eBl4iaiy yllm jeep Bald e q pow6e alp.irrM 4agolop to pua stp y We s,eiaquoylgBnm Aigs smau a•igel syaam mold M'�^N wo IwCu P M 5L euvV}!ad M— ,-su6ls6ulplogmy/oraY11nV-WIDeW"Aewapealeisepleino Pogseldoeduezopaueipwgy apliguospdofa6l4isiyleeyayglned ie1114 woessaw 6uIAl6s4UMU luDsletp loop cold e g uoglsoddo ul 6ulwow Aepsingl eaylo VAGwope alsqu f4unoo gneeg Mad sip ap/sino pelgwane wgsgwd P011mw a9og,p:igy6nepmos q P!PAa ; 6ultp a tons op pinomAoin mollag Lu�alsnfI,,Bulies BiaquoV g le4m Buwmos Ian[ sq,,dn Aem eta uo spew peq ay lulod e q pawgei Ajsnonugum Biequoy'ples e9og,0'y2aglg610 etp u0 ' eddoi uaa 'plea 0908.0 P p q pet' Ige!dwm ag6ym geldca giopwjp uolsslwwm eyl passwd fuaquoy •apgrtyalylsuleee ry!ejdwma dn>pld q mIW3 ua uolsslwwo0 Viols ag paOsy,Aag1 sly aiepap p!noys Biaquayieipaym passms!pAegl•dn4olew Impeylod(y a ul 991194M 6ulpea fila u Aoeplpum I q oy pemoysletg ls9ggoi uolun eglod a Ulm sllnsw 6uplod pamexwAa41 ,sARpaweu;ie6ine 8!6BagA3ldSia-fuaquoy_ayllo aw04— 9u0 p4ldeo s,mwpuyle'Plesa o VieuaLn waquoy Buunp K 8.0'peyounl Aeyl •jq!de0 atp punwe a9og,p tool Maq 6iaquoiy'a9tp am6etp al!4M •agllmlgy 4ilM Bulssew u!Ael1swgul law sIH •ignglqum elgepw a eq pjnomiaiau ingAeuow pe4AnB agl:uolsnpum s,ucgeM 7son6w s,Biaquay le a906,0 do eulzls sem 04 pies uogeM -ing iq 000'OB156u9edinoge w!ygpeylol uoaleM uanuau nsum'wowe '6ulAnq 1,usem aKoe,O•sienoweO/yunoo yoeag wled eupewel wallow abed S 1 Vii 41lo Ino Bisquoy tplm long pies aKcg,0lugjnsum ImyOod a g!miewAatp'Bulwow ;Kau aµ1 ypou met' pue eussao au!BUV-el6uls 8,e9og,0 gul papeol •olapiapnel poj g anwpAw4,E: 120 uWaasseyellal 01 will y1!M dui a a>IVi g e9og,0 peyse Biaquoid .-And a sl aggnvMAay{y Hulti null apwg,uauueq eq mail aueld e'pasiwwd se 7gel sAep oml, asnoH PmO ayl punwe do4S eagoo sdauueg,le,4ounlincAAofue,gdn-spe94o,qdAioa Biaquoyme6e9og,p•agyny,Ksllnogeseuolsgsqup tplMU90 ,o Paioddad Biequoy•s0ewe BuI ugq=opgpgsAe41 •godsloo 4oeag Awlaa e'myg0 aylle tpunliaeoAlnl• Vial g ue6aq aKog.O pue Biaquoy ueamlaq dl4sunm lmp0od 941 'Bl a„Ipaqa9gp pjg uewywa0 •plea uewywa0: uo!yselleApepamejet'pueuwslyiyanslepueuy pguem ay sem ygld s!H.'P!P Biequoyg7041w14gwaae11nq'uwgueldoupeyuewyua0'uatgipue-Aawgeelagsigleus,6iequoymoupue4swopesig4Bneps,aAOG,O'uewywaOglnopayaewBiaquoiy 'agpiyily Bupuauugl! puede q ssou6uppm a uma4s pey'mauueq eyl tp!m'pue—Aouowlof4uajd pgq •g6nutp'o9oe,0 'muweeddeALAely a ul pies Biaquoy; iaweo imp!IodAwio pua atp aq M o ��. L ��n Y U N ��q ��, e y p , i r ' a p y , a , W 1 , W M ��Y n i l t l I e . w u v i u r y b u n u r E v e n a s t h e y p r e p a r e d t h e p r o t e s t s , A m n b e r g w a n t e d O ' B o y l e t o p a y f o r a m o r e t r a d i t i o n a l a t t a c k . O n e t h e m e A r o n b e r g t h o u g h t w o u l d r e s o n a t e : c o n v i c t i o n r a t e s . S t a t e s t a t i s t i c s s h o w e d M c A u l i f f e ' s o f f i c e h a d t h e l o w e s l m t e s i n F l o r i d a . M e r M Y A u l i t e r e s i g n e d , t h o s e r a t e s w o u l d b e d e e m e d s t a t i s t i c a l a b e r r a t i o n s b y h i s r e p l a c e m e n t , P e t e r A n t o n a c c i . M o n t h s e a d i e r , h o w e v e r . t h e I s s u e l o o k e d l i k e c a m p a i g n g o l d . A r o n b e r g a s k e d O ' B o y l e a n d D B M a r n l t o p l a c e a n a d i n t h e J e w i s h J o u r n a l . T h e w e e k l y n e w s p a p e r t a r g e t s a w e a l P a l m B e a c h C o u n t y w f i n g b l o c a n d o n e t h a t ' s p e r s o n a l t o b o t h A r o n b e r g a n d M G W I i f f e , w h o a r e J e w i s h . A m n b e r g p r o v i d e d t h e a d a n d e m a i l e d D e M a r n i c o n t a c t l n f o r m a t i n f o r a J e w i s h J o u r n a l a d e x m l v t v e . I t r a n D e c . 1 4 a n d c o s t O ' B o y l e $ 3 , 4 0 0 . I n b o l d l e t t e r s , i t p r o c l a i m e d : % l i c h a a l M c A u l i f f e I s F l o r i d a ' s L o w e s t R a n k e d S t a t e A t t o r n e y . , A n I m p o s i n g c h a r t c o m p a r e d P a l m B e a c h C o u n l y s c o n v i c t i o n r a t e s w i t h t a p - r a n k e d P i n e l l a s C o u n t y a n d t h e m u c h h i g h e r s t a t e a v e r a g e . A c r o s s t h e b o t t o m . I t s a i d , " W e n e e d a n e w s t a t e a t t o m e y r B e l o w a w n t h a t w a s a t n y l i n e o f l e x : ' P a i d f o r b y F a m i l i e s f o r J u s t i c e L L C . ' T h e c o m p a n y h e d b e e n i n c o r p o r a t e d t w o w e e k s b e f o r e t h e a d r a n . I t s r e g i s t e r e d a g e n t w a s a w i l l i n g O ' B o y l e e m p l o y e e . i t s n a m e w a s p i c k e d b y A r o n b e r g , a f t e r t h e e m p l o y e e r e j e c t e d h i s f i r s l c h o i c e , ' D e m o c r a t s A g a i n s t M c k l i f f e . ' O n e o f A m n b e r g ' s M e n d s g a v e t h e e m p l o y e e a s c r i p t t o r e a d i n c a s e r e p o r t e r s c a l l e d t o a s k w h y s h e h a d f o u n d e d t h e g r o u p : ' A s a m a t h e r o f a c h i l d I n P a l m B e a c h C o u n t y , ] w a s s o d i s t u r b e d b y t h e s l a t e a t t o r n e y s r e c e n t a c t i o n s t h a t i s t a r t e d t h i s g r o u p t o i n f o r m t h e e m m u n i l y t h a t M c h a e l M c A u l i f f e h a s p u t a l l o f o u r s a f e t y a t d s k . T h e a l a r m i n g f a c t s s p e a k f a r t h e m s e l v e s ; N o o n e c a l l e d . T h e a d w a s l e g a l , s e v e r a l l a w y e r s s a i d i n i n t e r v i e w s , b e c a u s e i t d i d n ' t s p e c i f i c a l l y u r g e a c o t e f o r o r a g a i n s l M c A u l i f f e . I f i t h a d , F a m i l i e s f o r J u s t i c e w o u l d h e s e b e e n f a m e d t o r e g i s t e r a s a p o l i t i c a l o r g a n i z a f i o n . I n s i d e M C A u l i f f e ' s c a m p , t h e a t t a c k s w e r e i n f u r i a t i n g . ' M c h a e l w a s l i k e , ' W e n e e d t o r e s p o n d t o t h i s ; ' s a i d M c A d i f f i s c a m p a i g n m a n a g e r , R i c k A s n a n l . ' i w a s l i k e , ' R e s p a n d t o w h o ? W e d o n ' t h a w a t a r g e t t o s h o o t s i t ' I n t e r n a l l y , t h e y s u s p e c t e d A r o n b e r g . P o l i s h a d s u r f a c e d , s h o w i n g A r o n b e r g a s a v i a b l e c a n d i d a t e . D o n o r s t o l d A s n a n i t h a t A m n b e r g h a d c o n t a c t e d t h e m , u r g i n g t h e m n o t I n c o m m i t t o M c A u l i f f e . ' T h e r e w a s a n a n f i - W - A u l i f f e c a m p a i g n b e i n g r u n b e h i n d t h e s c e n e s w h e r e t h e o n l y o n e w h o w o u l d b e n e f i t h o m I t w a s A r a n b e r g ; A s n a n l s a i d . ' H e w a s h i d i n g i n t h e s h a d o w s ' ' I t ' s s o g o o d , i t s h o u l d b e s p r e a d o v e r F a c e b o o k f : ) ' r , ��n a y s h e n o e a 9 . v a a a n , r . , . n A s 2 0 1 2 b e g a n , A r o n b e r g w a s g e t t i n g c l o s e r t o d e c l a r i n g h i s c a n d i d a c y . H e b e g a n p r e p a r i n g a n e w a t t a c k A l m o s t y e a r b e f o r e , o n e o f A r o n b e r g ' s b e n d s , M e l i s s a M c K i n l a y , h a d f i l e d a n e t h i c s c o m p l a i n t a g a i n s t M c A u l i f f e . M c K i n l a y , a n a i d e t o P a l m B e a c h C o u n l y s l e g i s l a t i v e d e l e g a t i o n , a c c u s e d M c A u l i f f e o f f o l l o w i n g h e r o u t o f m e e t i n g a n d t h r e a t e n i n g h e r i n t h e p a r k i n g I o L ' H e t h e n t o l d m e I h a d b e t t e r b e c a r e f u l a b o u t w h o I s p e n t t i m e w i t h : s h e w r o t e . H e h a d s e e n h e r t a l k i n g t o M k s E d m o n d s o n , a f o r m e r M c A u l i f f e a i d e w h o l e t a f t e r a F a l l i n g - o u t . T h e F l o r i d a C o m m i s s i o n o n E t h i c s f o u n d n o m u s e f o r m e c o m p l a i n t - B u t M c K i n l a y t o l d A m n b e r g a b o u t i t a n d i n S e p t e m b e r h e a s k e d h e r f o r a c o p y . S h e d i d n ' t h a v e o n e , s o A r o n b e r g a n d O ' B o y l e p i c k e d u p t h e f i l e d u r i n g t h e i r O c t o b e r t r i p t o T a l l a h a s s e e . L a t e r t h a t m o n t h . M c K i n l e y w a s c a l l e d f o r j u r y d u t y . S h e t o l d P a l m B e a c h C o u n t y C i r c u i t J u d g e J o h n K a s t r e n a k e s s h e c o u l d n o t s e r v e . T h e e x c h a n g e w a s c a p t u r e d o n N d e a . ' 1 w a s t h r e a t e n e d b y t h e s l a t e a l l n m a y ; M c K i n l e y t o a s t u n n e d K o s h o m i l i e s . I n a n I n t e r v i e w w i t h T h e P o s t , M C K i n l a y s a i d s h e d i d n ' t k n o w s h e w a s b e i n g v i d e o t a p e d . B u t s h e s a i d s h e t o l d A r o n b e r g a b o u t t h e e t x h a n g e w i t h K a s t r e n a k e s . E d m o n d s o n , w h o w a s h e l p i n g A r o n b e r g ' s f u r t i v e c a m p a i g n , o b t a i n e d a c o p y o f t h e v i d e o , c o u r t r e c o r d s s h o w . I n J a n u a r y , t h e v i d e o a p p e a r e d o n G o s s i p E w a , a l o c a l w e b s i t e r u n b y e x - P o s t c o l u m n i s t l o s e L e m b i e l A l m o s t i m m e d i a t e l y , A r o n b e r g s e t o u t t o p r o m o t e t h e v i d e o . S l ' s s o g o o d , i t s h o u l d b e s p r e a d o v e r F a c e b o o k ! : r h e w r o t e t o D e M t h r n l . W i t h i n t w o d a y s , w o r k i n g w i t h a ��p a i d e n s u l l o n 4 A r o n b e r g h a d c r e a t e d a F a c e b o o k a d l i n k i n g t o t h e G o s s i p E w a P a s t ' S H O C K I N G V I D E O I S t a t e A t t o r n e y M c h a e l M c A u l i f f e t h r e a t e n e d a W e s t P a l m w o m e n a n d a b u s e d h i s p o w e r . W a t c h t h e v i d e o . . ' A r o n b e r g p e r s o n a l l y d i r e c t e d t h e a d ' s d e s i g n e r , t e l l i n g h i m i n a n a m a l l : ' I l i k e t h e f i r s t o n e . . . . C a n y o u u s e t h e t e r m ' W a t c h t h e v i d e o ' a s t h e f a s t w o r d s o f t h e t e a s e r ! ' F i n a l l y , h e w r o t e a n J a n . 1 3 , ' 1 t h i n k t h e y n e e d t o r u n b e f o r e I b e c o m e a c a n d i d a t e _ . a n d w h i l e t h e s t o r y i s s t i l l f r e s h ' T h e m n s u l t a n r s p r o p o s a l i t s l e d A r o n b e r g a s h i s t a l e n t , b u t O ' B o y l e p a i d t h e $ 5 0 0 b i l l . T h e a d t a r g e t e d F a c e b o o k u s e r s w h o * l i k e * o n e o f s e v e r a l l o c a l D e m o c r o g c p o l i t i c i a n s . I t l a u n c h e d o n J a n . 1 4 , a S a t u r d a y . B y M o n d a y , i t h a d 4 4 0 c l i c k s . B u t b y T u e s d a y , i t n o l o n g e r m o t h e r e d . M c A t i i c e a n n o u n c e d h e w a s d r o p p i n g o u t o f t h e r a c e t o t a k e a j o b w i t h O w o w C a r o n , b i l l i o n a i r e B i l l K o c h ' s e n e r g y c o m p a n y . A r o n b e r g , r e j o i c i n g , t h o u g h t t h e F a c e b o o k a d f a r e d o u t M c A u l i f f e , O ' B o y l e s a i d . T o l d s o b y T h e P o s t M c A u l i f f e c h u c k l e d . T h e a t t a c k s , h e s a i d , d i d n ' t f a r c e h i m o u t B u t t h e ' p r o s p e c t o f a n I n s u r g e n t p r i m a r y e m p a i g n . . . m a d e m e m o m o p e n t o a l t e r a t i v e s . ' W i t h o u t t h e a t t a c k s . ' I r I g h t n e v e r h a v e o p e n e d t h e d o o r ' t o p d w t e o d o r o p p o r t u n i t i e s a t m a t p o i n t h e s a i d . B y T h u r s d a y , A m n b e r g h a d l a u n c h e d h i s c a m p a i g n f o r s t a t e a l l o m e y . ' T h e m o s l i m p o r t a n t t h i n g i s t h a t t h e n e > d s t a t e a t t o r n e y n e e d s t o h a v e a p a s s i o n f o r j u s t c e ; A r e n b e r g t o l d W P T V - C h a n n e l S . ' S o D a v e I g o t m e i m n s W n g o f m y l i f e _ B o t h y o u a n d G e r s h m a n h a v e r e u g h t m e g o o d _ . a n d t h e b a d t h i n g i s t h a t m y d a u g h t e r s u f f e r s . A s a d d a y , w h i c h o n l y A l z h e i m e r s w i i l r e m o v e M a i n m y m e m o r y . I n a n y e v e n t , I c o u l d n t h a v e b e e n m o r e h o n e s t o r b i u n t I o n l y w i s h t h a t y o u s h a r e d m y v l e w s o n h o w h f e n d s h e a t M e n d s . ' - O a e h 4 m o l l t o h w W r y , q M 9 W i t h M c A u l i f f e o u t o f t h e r a m , A m n b e r g ' s w o r k w i t h O ' B o y l e a n d h i s a s s i s t a n t s l o w e d . F o r m o n t h s , D e M a r n i h a d b e e n f i l i n g p u b l i c r e c o r d s r e q u e s t s c r a f t e d a n d e d i t e d b y A m n b e r g , e m a l l s s h o w . T h e r e q u e s t s , s e n t t o p u b l i c a g e n c i e s , a i m e d f o r I n f o r m a t i o n a b o u t M C F W I i f f e . D e M a r n l l i m e d t h e r e s p o n s e s o v e r t o A r e n b e r g . W h e n t h e r e w a s a c h a r g e , O ' B o y l e p a i d t h e b i l l . SMaN ago W Alols arp pauuyuaa yob lead 0yLmaH . Isod'OA!lIV;rMl uaemlaq sllewo payeal filequay . all!Intl-W BuiJaepe luewasPpenPe cloves uo spga0 . Amel eyl Jewq 6ioquwv pill . 96edewoy sepaq . luow pe8a:N9IV&W0 AA0aVHS 'Buplel POPE" PW'Ilea will Pawrgw OH II uaPGdw Isod a woy pea auogd eloB aKoe,p 141%4 %eW ul pil!wAw uilgnop ou s,wagL,-�les ay; palpulms sem l,'Ar6ue peulewel o0og,p '0091 arp pweluG uewyvap'lape uooS'e0o8.0APeW way)140 evou'066'SLZS Bu!sl91 paPodai 04'1udy u!'pepuodsal iwau fuaquary pinw am'p40Imp a ane puts s nu!w ma a uads .IwIM a 6EP88M we I leya wmum ou q ways os lelow e w 9wBe II!m l pue ipeq Weals a u! l! ane) 4 P el ) p q slam no(ll,:pappe a0oe,0'uopevawmnayl BalP+mal uaeq ane)Aew o6o8,0191p was; s,Blaquory al nuwaiw ul piry ;pooB ew 146ne1 ane) uewyvep pue naS tpoS, •eiwm eKog,p; e6lAw)o fiulsna 0)11061. -eseo 1110 9101y6nep sly ul plmluAypBual ayl uo do Lrgm ul Aewone meu an; mpd OLD —Blaqua+d plot ay -0()(),0E% aKo8.0Ism pinom ssol lapel ayL •alaum ay'Aewape us Pug PEEP) a se uewyvep qso! pay 94 Ing •palolpwtl e0oe,0'mm wiluelualou p!nam uew4ve0'11ewe BulLons a Blaquord allum GAGSp APeW -peat' a al own Ile 11 -6 IpdV u0 •aiwm p0euuluy'lnoArid leadde lay Pal p!nam vials a4L.-Bupuem, Sun s,GKuS,p WES ul siuGwnBle le6el a Bu!Bn sepal a aK08.0 Was paevolud •E 1pdv uo ;APogGana ipimlaaw!,'Pie s ay ,Juevea ollgnd a w,1.11411m op of 6ulylou Pay 6ra1u0tp legl lead ayL pial ooeuoluy •BERESw 041 Joel poeualuy vegwnu a papuwd WaquOy •hula Ipg Xawope asno4-ul s,aKo8,0,a1110111ewa0!on 6Z 4lueW a ul pies OEquwy;{ugsisse sly 6n pinoys no( PUS no( pplmiaaw Ipm rmeuoluy aged--asn Ino gyp ssms!p q—Puely plc ue'1o0e11016y—Aawalle alels mau ayl yl!m Bupeaw a do guy e0og,0 pGdle4'8l!4mueaw'Blequary 'poleadde Bwoq sl y0lym'asea !eulwPn Jaq ul isiy6nep s,aKog,O sluosaidw 1149 GH-lsawe Ina Sip w palelal Rims I!nn omi ul e0oe,p Bupuaswdw waq mwpyp!m pinom 04leyl Aluo lueaw 1 n peluloddes!p sem 04 pies uewyvep'asn sla946nep sly dwp el paualeluyi pue'ples 8008.0'6paplq papuodsw uewymoo 'Biaquohrlswa5e mUego 011 Peals et' uewyvep plot GKo8,0'Aawpe alels loj um umo sly 6uuap!sum sem uayl Aq oym'Aawope sdalgSnep S14'uew4vap w peyoedde a0u8.01sanbw S', Bjaquw IV VOLPE gyp Jai ime) OUR pip fuaquoq/ PUS a0oe,p tgoq'6upeow alp laye'ggS "uogngl4um, 000'SZS e41 Pwmpap laeau o0o13,0 'plea e008.0 ala)io Ina BugleB w,I -not peaui,uop I'mouAeuow 1naAlo6 amp 11 pew IAwn aql s,luaH, •pu!l sem 8008,0 'w!m a 6upea. u9aq pay 814%.0146norp Blaquwyleyl GK08.0 1)I01-9008,0 01 Blaquory pnnpogul pay oym uewam aro—lawnquwoH'1ale-1 ,ie(gpooBARE Iseel ly. *piea I. •pallnw a0De.0.101 Bushed alb mus w!y paseyo 1.'wow ayl pep 6laquwv ,; uuddey pinoys le4m appap pinoys ncA:ssoq Gyl w,noAinB.'Ples!. •passald e008,0 Iuelslsse US of lain asap ayl wns Pimm' ay'pep0elo aaam ey)!leyl plus file u A ew *Ass 041loug ane) pinom 0ym'lalmasald 9 eN' II .j'paunwap fuequwM •asn slalyBnep sit'}o 146noip ay le4m 8raquop peyse eKog,p :9!4104!1 luem'smaivelul Iwanas ui uapepan ino4lPm Isod 041 w papinwd'6upaew 1e4p10lunome s!Hnylo yoeae playraap sit' ul wnoy ewylApeau ln) 6laquary 41Pm Pew ay •pies a0og,p'g 140raW up slewyl pen!nw 049JOVE 'paPoda,Isod 041'umop paJOeq lnq'unpgndaa a se But uwpwap!sumpeyweWelsu aB n limn '6iaquop as pexup P f 0'110 plums uaeq pe4Apewle luouoddo auto •sluouoddo lepuelodlagap of wns efiny e panpap of peplum aH'Aoep!pun s!y bupunouue mu!s Psalm pay ayAauow gonw mot' owplvg aylio) asopsip of auppeap wuow-io-pua uel() pwedwd 6laquo+y'yOIeW-p!w ul MON ds141 PIP ay ane a >,un 'pa)ise aKcS,0.1.6u!Ju!rp no( weleym'laig6nep moAlnoge no( of Imil BuKes sKpogawos usym II g I'a1pl�N IWO mouJ noA•op4 wa4lury Buarm oS'S141 PIPAayl mapaq l,un lsnfl oal46nepjncA al slip plpAayl a)a!!oq>.un l,:Bu0esldaJ aneO, 6ulpuepvapun ua pay Braque) pue et' panepaq ay pies 8OoS,0 ine •Pies sAGe.o'dlay of P9slwold peyApplldce imBut fuequord 'pallww 808.0 , ; Bupwyl a;am aqp Buplulyl s! AnS slut leyl was ayew of PEON, l'000'SZS leyloue do Ind! wo)eg,'s)PmAw Is PIER !.'Biaquo v Bu!dle4 000'SZS lueds pay 84 'Pies 0008.0'ua4l A8 -asw 51el4Bnep sit' wall sluewmop wly lugs 04'pealsul •Joayo Gyp Braque) puesl,upip a0o8,0 pue'possed sJeeming 'Aum Guo! a sea6 ASZS Bu!s!91)o)u8uglwwm inM„legl I!ewe 0E'uai• a u! BupPm'pawBeAl!peei Bloquaiv '000'93 6raquary pargyo ay •pealsuj •6110es Palmas aK08,0. anep'Buonsio pu!J sperp'mOM. 'spua!y to saMoldwa•vagwewApwe)'seluedwm s!y')laswiy woy—sJaaya 685409L)o alpunq a Puy el ane) pinom aOoS,p:uovadlad DOSS Is suopeuop sdn mei alelS •Joaya 6lq auo 6uppm lays alowiueaw leyl'aKeS.OlGA -000,(ii Payse waquo)p'ples aKo8,0lwgly -u0pnqulum pepglo us loll s0eS,0 paJss 84'u6ledwn IeplIE us pay eq 1e41 MEN •payl4E aKG8.0 Low di4suopelw s,B)aquoy'yBnagl •ApscVq vanrasgoluapuadapul Aq pGIlPanslp uaaq ane) sawnos pwrgae)nuew pue suogesnme eslq, spaded 9ylleyl 6ugum'vapoddns al paws ue u! wet'! to auo q payup eq,Blequwdlnoge aunt' wluols a u91lsod Sill JOW,uB!edwn s,Bwquoy of lgesn mood pinom s6ugsod qaM ayling'uognq!yum u6!edww a se dley s,lup)elya0 Pwy epapimau 6laquo'aleplpum lepyia us Bulaq al!dsa(3 •ein dlssop Bulpnpul'sallsgem inol ami uo pweadde Aayl ualei EKBPXIS'6Z'gad un fuequwy q spews ail lues!u!pel)ap )o le pin uaemAPeW ewnsse l upellapgww a puesiaAmel a ase) ollu"Aew n0&:Iu!Pelyep W spwm ay'pa(e!apAlnpun uaGq pay lsanbw agllla) fusquop uayM•6raquosy q pay 42l4m'ryeoq leuol!ps slsod e4L LlUm s0umi=a 6ewa s,ag6rr Mi peluem aH •Bulpued lips semlerp lsenblu Eua uo do mops) cl jugleWeO passwd Biaquoly We Recommend • 2 women killed, l In cddcal a0erhit-and-mn(PalmBeachPostcom) • Atlhodties:Amesl'Imminenr In Wellington gas station homicide (PalmeeachPoSLcom) • NC Lottery(PalmBeachPostmm) • Delray Beach woman wins $6 million verdict against tobacco company (Palm BeachPoslcom) • Report 12 -year-old makes up abduction story to amid dentist (PalmBeachPmLcom) • Burger King introduces gay Whopper (palm BeachPostcom) From Around the Web • El Paso Releases Video of Cop Emcuting Handmifed Man—Where's the Anger? (VICE) • Man Who Assaulted Dad Mer Finding Him in Bed With His Wife Gets 08 Easy (Stirring Daily) • Teen Dies an Vacation Mer Drinking Energy Drink (Stirring Daily) • AGraving Father Pulls a Thread That Unravels BNP's glegal Deals [The New York Times) • Life Insurance: what you don't know could hurl you (Black Enterprise) • Woman is Found Hanged in Indian State(The New York Times) P) Comments If you would like to post a comment please Sign In a Register ' Cancel Edit comment 59 Comment(s) Comment(s) 1-20 01`59 neM>last» 'u • Posted byTmiticAvenger This comment has been removed for Notation of the visitor agreement. awvwe • Posted bytealadyat 11:07 a.m. Jul. 22,2012 • Repod Abuse Mr. Amnberg will not have my vote) Indeed, can anyone vote for Mr. Arenberg after reading this? More dirty politics -as -usual. Nonetheless, We The People are not fooled[PACs and Super -PAC's can buy all the ads they want; most voters know the true game now. Whenever we see an 'ad' about an 'issue", we know who's behind It.. and why. NO ONE thinks such ads am impartial; they are disingenuous distortions, half-truths, and outright ties. And we think even LESS of the peoplefcorporatlons who buy these ads. Great scoop. Palm Beach Post writers!! 1.3 Posted by FatCa10711 at 11:28 a.m. Jul, 22, 2012 ReportAbuse I'd still vole for him, and I'm sure onanyothers will.I mean, this is FLORIDA, people actually voted for Rick Stolt f `r • Posted byPBSOTalk at 11:50 a.m. Jul. 22,2012 • Repod Abuse Yes, great scoop. Typical Palm Beach Post not crediting PBSOTalkcom, who provided the start of this story and sent them the information in Apol, complete with laws, to get the ball rolling. Irs amazing thaywill use PBSOTalk.com Information the ownerprovides to them yet they publiclydisamw the site, linking it to disgruntled deputies. There is more documented comption on The Sheri than Shedif Bradshaw's friends at the Postwill everdiscoverorwrite about Thanks Joel! I have to go see a doctor now to see if they can remove the knife from my back. • Posted byTmthWins This comment has been removed for violation of the visitor agreement 1 i t— • Posted byJupiterGuyat 12:06 pm. Jul. 22,2012 • RepartAbuse But tea lady, the big m oney corporations ham been backing the lea party for years. They are bacidng almost awry tea parry candidate running for office this year, as well as the presidential campaign. What happened to the grass roots organiatton that the tea party used to be? aM111snlsl a141'llaswly leulwPa s1 oymAaw ma alegs a me41uea am asnmeq 4ouei gAed •apnegap I(10 wglwg HoogOS ayl 918d Isaoluno Ilea g OSd ul uasled �La�e efun*Aefim I •spas ey1 peau eMgsG Pus dley peau OM e wl)A+aW 6ulpnpulA4unm s141 ul aleaPN!Pa! 1dflMilOO lsow a im no s6ue a d a s, Auepay (Inyemod pus lusnelw wl Hung Bps I Inq uolej pgaNum 4141 1 4 H' 14 paeuolW 4!px'ua4ap 26pnl' avowal g paildsu= GH xweyy 06pn1• pauelew4l aH •Alagpq:Aouow etc loB 04 moy sAeyl pug owuo ayl BuIGundxa q papnlle a4 pus palpuey sem Ina a4l,lgme, moy g pepnile a �ep-lg6oll!:uBledwea Bulwmdn s,a'�ep sol al Agluads semAauow neap aq spaj -mep Appnq sly g aApelal suoge6alle smuss aleBgswui g awn meylou soopinq In(] s!y Inogejwoddns s,Blequay 4almleow pup mo(]jo lsayeq ayl le suapow snolonly aly g awp sey clad moy Auund •mylo leylAq p'ala Blel uaaq meq sa6pnlu!epmAym suleldx3 qua!umuw moH ZAppnq s,Blaquoy sl Imeuguy oS e pOlglaneu sey ay esnmeq mouth Lupinom aH ll!nfila ssausnopsum Ilea am leym sleyl Lpwlm sem al{aS,p ly6noyl oy esnmaq 6ugeew eyo ono uea 6ugeseo snBs!p sl Buaquom osngy Podaa . ZLOZ'ZZ'Inf'w'd4o:Zleea4noyaslle4s4pulAgpalsod . "laawaWSB Jo115h ayllo uogelo.A uq Woww uaaq sey ]aawww s!yL IIII4be0Aq Palsad w I f1es-, laA4poop 'a(gpoop 'aA4poa0 �I'a(gpooB'uo4aslapalmine'BOmwel•BuoloS isnq a!Ignd to uoglsod Aue woy wpw Agueuemad q speau Biequop -qy @Ip 84 014ow'lp •PiaveHle sogee4 llegmeals pawn weal ou p!pAlu!elim OH'wolm Ong s,6laquWV'4N Buuanmunlq lsod 10eaS wled syue4l asngyuodaa . ZLOZ'ZZ'Inf'w'dyq:L1e060E91-OLL6-mg6-S96e-60LLEPLeAgpi4sod . a^-4 ( s 'sgel s,aldoed uaylo do Held gawp g awq woy ydaaxa-- aslo weld(ue ewmlam mu peluem louAlwns wAayL •soup Alunm py] eplsul Ile wa41 doo I'eseald'lnq uayloue auo we sap Ile Aeyl-dn pagp6ABewawa uaaq meq vageq ga4110 awosll ume'ysegjeneq Ile we ways alelndod oym awL L-soull fold pup wapweya Alllenb mol ewes ayllo pas so a sod 'elmouelal SuloBuo us ul slue wllelsul meuAid wla we Aces s!yl ul Ino plel sewelp aMll oL L •pawea LWmeq pus weSep luop Amp auogelndw pus sosnlela 4nq g lel g mey Aey] Aaua W imalegm pan oym ssep ou 10 mollo oldood :(sa)xoqpues elanud lla4l aq q 4ul41A641 ]e4m chis pwapuem sey Osla Apogawas asnmaq/uBue slwq aplp AHu='salsplue a.pu nemnou pue GV!4uelem pegyo uopeulgww elgegwdw!ABew a sl/4unm a4L •43wns OLD ]so] lanou sey Inq--Ina Aem ayl vo(umo sly louAlmn)saugssnopwdewos g uo dsel6 0l pe6euew pug loodssaa umo sly gl4 ul Bal oym lalweos Hioti math a sI altog,p •ap(ogp g Ino pps oBeBuq smouHApogUme oym gpaod(4 awaidns a sl Blaquay sdoya uma j!a4l Buuamio sa!ppngllayl Bupaalwdjayl!a pegsul we ways pop Awn se s6ulyl Bggm eq pno4s oym aldaed •pnmloIno pusAlolmud'we41 wolaq so am Inge sAawoge gtllel (Ielapal pque alels yloq) se6pnl• •segeuuem6pnq pup sgPo0d(4Aq palelndod'(Auep) so!yla mol Anews6ge 4qm 46nwy1 soya we Aayl soAzeals pus amez!q Pus palam se we'eusie 1e6aplepipnl e4] ul ABepodso-sognod yaeaq wled asngdpodaa . ZLOZ'ZZ'inf'w'd ZL:Lleappe-41pauSAgpolsod . luawaaiBe ugrs!1 a4l)o uogeloN uy pmowai uaaq sey luawww s141 ueweelAgpalsod . (y1 quawowBe lgls." eq✓ to uogelole lop pow Wei uaaq sey luawww 5141 HaegsgelOwAgpgsad . e—� s!4luemoymderolowa!d4apimidgaylsla6o9.0'a oS) 41!m uognosse scop s!r'43usa4esnmaglnq luamuls,egsasneeglo'pgelaumalel4Bnap 4waysawmuequojVlnogemouthgpeauno(Bulylluaapue'sl4ewaseya6o9A asngyuodaU . ZLOZ'ZZ-Inf'w'd LZ'•ZLIe LLsewoyLAgpalsad . r-� I can seethe swearing in: Burt. Andre, Fumed, I&Cartyand ewryomermncemus'Political operative' in PBC.Oh, and they will also own Jaime Goodman if he gets elected becausa McCarty is running his campaign. Remember lake back the judiciary McCarty and Rabe= Shelton do. It's all to make sure theymn continue tiefrcriminal behavior and shakedowns w/o an SA who cares. [would like b thank Joel and the Post bemuse this is getfing auention._from authorities who enjoyslapping the cubs on self-pmdaimed'mck slat Dave. You cant get the Aron. burger in jail so enjoy now. Ammnacci—your in over your head. Watch your 6 bemuse I think you would make a great prison true tee • Posted by Douglas3 at226 p.m. Jul. 22,2012 • ReportAbuse Need a connection from Aronberg to Mary McCarty/ Trygoing through her mother Jeanne Raywho recentiyworked as a receptionist forAmnberg. Aronbarg should quit this race. He has prawn himself unfit to serve in any gowmment mpacity. You can't clean up Palm Beach Countybyputting dirt in charge of the bmomi • Posted by Truthshallsetyoufree 21226 pm. Jul. 22,2012 • Report Abuse And to all the lawyers who tum a blind eye to this and continue to treat Dave like royalty bemuse you think Its a given he will be SAand you want to Ingratiate yourselws... getsome morals) We took an oath to uphold the law! Ifyou condone his behavior and that of his'supporters'just dp up your bar card bemuse you are as bad as him. I mnl waitfor the front page photo of him, handcuffed, being led to an awaiting blacked -out SUV. Irs imminenL r) • Posted byRobedBHaigh at2A7 p.m. Jul. 22,2012 • ReportAbuse So, let me get thls straight 'Aronberg and his allies skirt the law on bribery, 'Amnberg and his allies skim the law on blackmail, 'Amnberg and his allies skirt the law on extortion, 'Amnberg and his allies skirt the law on slander, 'Aronberg and his allies skirt the law on defamation. Yep, payor playis alive and well in Palm Beach County. Resign? No, he should be in ajail cell awaiting vial. I knew more then a decade ago that he would do anything — and I mean ANYTHING— to mow his wayup in once. Let me guess, with his eyes next on running for Gommor. Mork mywords: If he gels elected to the position of Stam Attorney, he will can for Governorwilhin ten years and the corruption will be much, much worse. If this doesn'tget the Peds inwlwd (once again) Olen nothing will. I also agree wim the previous poster, teolady. these corporate bigwigs haw been funding the Tea Partymr a long time. Watch how quickly the Tea Partyboil'setles down to a 'simmer' if Romnsyls elected President. (And the ultra -rich orgyol asset transfer from the middle-class to the 1 %will resume at an accelerated pace.) t l Syl • Posted by RegularJoe at 3:46 p.m. Jul. 22.2012 1 • ReportAbuse Can you believe Made did this again? Marie Harenburger has been the campaign manager and consultant for 10 years for suspended Mayor Jose Rodriguez Look atwhata crack he isll!I!I!!I Rodriguez used to be buddybuddywith Mt. ML Marie is BFPs with Anne Gannon who is smarter than DAVE because when she got out of Tally then Marie made Ithappen with Gannon's taxchiefjob as the CONSTITUTIONAL THIEF! • Posted byyoumlldumb at3:48 pm. Jul. 22, 2012 • RepartAbuse You cannot believe a single word putout by the liberal rag known as the Palm Beach Past They haw their own agenda and will spin as tory to fit the outcome theywant Aronberg has a good track record and has served the State of Florida well. He should be judged an past performance and not the attacks of bankrupt newspaper that is so poodymn itis actually printed bythe Sun Sentinel for them. This paper has a specific hatred forAmnberg that has no basis in this mce.The facts are the fads. • Postedbykolal23 at3:52 p.m.Jul.22,2012 • ReportAbuse think this whole article Is a crock of dap. Look m the REAL problems In Palm Beach County, Ms. Marcus and friends. «1991<Rau 69 )a OZ -t (spuawwoD (shuawwoO Og uogoala yiau ag11e1awea aovuas allgnd. siq 6ulddgs Fq iaej 6jq e/qunon eg pus 9a485wagl op Illm walan agl1eg1 NON aweH 'sn io; uma>uom}o aaald f4seulluelnnNed a se ss=e sewn BiaquoV •ql!m wBeq gFjwesun we saggod/qunop goeag wled asngyuodaa . ZtOZ'ZZ'Inf'w,d8Z41eualgregugor,tqua150d . Westlaw. Page 1 436 Fed.Appx. 449, 2011 WL 3510250 (C.A.6 (Tem.)) (Not Selected for publication in the Federal Reporter) (Cite as: 436 Fed.Appx. 449, 2011 WL 3510250 (C.A.6 (Tenn.))) H This case was not selected for publication in the Fed- eral Reporter. Not for Publication in West's Federal Reporter See Fed. Rule of Appellate Procedure 32.1 generally governing citation of judicial decisions issued on or after Jan. t, 2007. See also Sixth Circuit Rule 28. (Find CTA6 Rule 28) United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit. Martin E. O'BOYLE, Individually and as General Partner in New Midland Plaza Associates; Catherine O'Boyle, Individually and as General Partner in New Midland Plaza Associates; New Midland Plaza Asso- ciates; Commerce Partnership No. 1147; Commerce Partnership No. 1171, Plaintiffs—Appellants, V. SHULMAN, ROGERS, GANDAL, PORDY & ECKER, P.A.; Ross D. Cooper; Mark S. Guberman, Defendants—Appellees. No.10 5551. Aug. 11, 2011. Background: Former clients filed legal malpractice action against law firm and attorneys. The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Ten- nessee, 2010 WL 1408444, dismissed complaint, and clients appealed. Holding: The Court of Appeals, Kethledge, Circuit Judge, held that action was untimely. Affirmed. West Headnotes Limitation of Actions 241 C��95(11) 241 Limitation of Actions 24111 Computation of Period of Limitation 241II(F) Ignorance, Mistake, Trust, Fraud, and Concealment or Discovery of Cause of Action 241k95 Ignorance of Cause of Action 24lk95(10) Professional Negligence or Malpractice 241k95(I I) k. Attorneys. Most Cited Cases Under Tennessee law, clients knew or had reason to know of their injury as result of their attorney's alleged legal malpractice during mortgage dispute, at latest, when court dismissed all of clients' claims and ordered them to pay fees to attorneys, and thus legal malpractice suit filed more than one year later was untimely. Wesfs T.C.A. § 28-3-104(a)(2). •449 On Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee. Before: MOORE and KETHLEDGE, Circuit Judges; MARBLEY, District Judge.""' FN* The Honorable Algenon L. MarbleyI United States District Judge for the Southern District of Ohio, sitting by designation. KETHLEDGE, Circuit Judge. **1 Martin O'Boyle, Catherine O'Boyle, and their partnerships (collectively, "O'Boyle") owned a large shopping center in Tennessee. In 1988, O'Boyle mortgaged the shopping center for $8.9 million. Hel defaulted on the mortgage in 1998. The bank that held the mortgage note foreclosed on the center in April 1999. After unsuccessful negotiations to end the EXHIBIT © 2014 Thomson Reuters. No Claim to Orig. US Gov. Works. 'SWoM'Ao'J Sfl'8110 01 uge10 o!y •S121nall uoswogy 6IOZ ajom Aq opooajd salup asagl ,!o ylog •sluepualap alp of SaaJ m uolll!w 9•I$ jaAO ,Sed of unq pajapjo ]moa 24l uagm 'SOOZ jagwaldaS Cq 1311; pa8alle legl mogul 01 uosgaj aloes agl 1111 P4q of iog.0 PuV •a3p0ejdlew pagape s,umd aql ,Cq painful uaaq peg aq Imp moult of unseal peq al tog0 uayl Rq'sngy •swtelo s,a!,Cog,03o pu passtwstp moo aassouuay atp uagm'400Z jogwa3 -a0 u! US113J uanad w2m saouemsse asoq,l, •(3)61 L •1dwo0 ,[•]auto:gno ltyss000ns a u! llnsaj 'Llll!g11 -qmd atgeuosgaj a of 'pinom pug juauiSpnf ,Cteununs Jul uotlow ,Cue Puelsgl!M 6liuegap pinoM sw1e13 [si4] 1ey1 [wn4] postnpe Xlpaleadaj„ peq slugpua}a0 alp Imp alms s8ulpuald uMo s,alkog,0 'oiaH Z.. '(010Z'j!0 419) HL—W,10, P£'d ZZ9 'd77 Bunn,! n 1sui. n •sfs ')ay •sdur,7 •gag oT ..33!l3j 0111 alit ua pinom leyl soo!lu8ape sn, yl!M Iu23s!sUO3 54OV9 jo las on anojd uuo Alpalgnopundl!l -Ulu ld 2y1„ ojogm ungla a aluls of amllej lo; tusstwstp of patluua s[ ssalaglauouluepuaJQP a '(5661'way) 498 '198 PZ'M'S 016 "00 9sa8—N 'A 17aM „'ounwalap of ,Cif ayl loj notzsanb 10g,► a dllensn st„ 98palmowl g9noglry •(8661'W31) ZES '8Z9 PZ'M'S LL6 '8u:m,7 79 ujogAap •n -D'd •o0 T lgox ugor aag •aopotudlew s,,Cawong slq ,Cq painful 911ISMoe sem aq ley, mowl pinogs,Clgeuoseaj jo smotgjjqutgld GED u24m Su!uum sun82q alnlgls aqy •(Zx11)601—£-8Z § •uuy •apoo•way dIlmauag aag •saydde suotlel! -unl jo nnims 1VOA-2uo s,aassauuay jell, aalde sallied 34.L'(01OZ'j!0 419) 819'EI9 P£3 ZZ9 "00 SRWP10H yyltr aj ul aag •,Slawtlun sum 7lns s,alSog,O Imp uotleu -!gualap sljnO3 1Otjzs!p all OAou ap Matnaj OM •pamopol paadde snyy •saopel!w!l jo alnluls leaf-auo saassauuay japun ,tlawtlun se suyelo s,al.fog,O pass!wstp ,moo 1oWs!p ayy sn ajo;all moo auo QIP s1 ase3 jeg,L'60OZ IPdv u! lino:) lejapaj aassauuay m palgaj pug lms alp passtwstp ,Cluajunlon 21,Sog,O WOO lejapal 01 asea aql POAowaj sluepu2la0 ayt• aotloejdlgw pagolle jtagl,lo llnsaj a se 2se3 aassauuay a41 ISO[ peq aq Imp 2t lunel3 '8002 jaquta3aQ In ljno3 2IMS AOSJPf Mal,1 ut sluepua;aQ 241 pans alSog, Z abed •uolsualxa all uSts lou p!p jadoo0 '60OZ Amtugad g5nonp 1! papualxa aldog,O puff sta8og uuwingS lnq 'LOOZljagolo0 III paj!dxa luawaaj8g ally •paneq-2tup awo3aq �Cpea4e pull legs swlula ,Sue an!naj lou pip I! 31141 pains luawaa&u aqy •luawaaj8e aq1 o1,Sljud a lou sem Oguuagn0 •ol,fog,O gllm luawaal& 2utllol a Owl pajalua jadoo0 pug siagog uuwingS '9o0Z jago130 w 'al!gmumapl •lino QED 01 papjgme suopaaus 000'S$ a43 pled al,Cog,O su Suol os 'plume no] .jl!tU—SZ'lS a4l P21e3eA pug Hollow stye PPIUM2 lAm3 ay1 'LOOZ kmnuef ul •japjo suotlmms ayl puaum 01 panow jagualayl alSog,O woo oql of 000'9$ pus sluepualap alp of uotlllw SZ'IS ,Cud o1 al,Cog,O Swapm 'goOZ jagwanoM u! uotlow stye palumS ljnoo aassauuay a4y •goon fmnuef w aptog,O,smear suotloges joj panow sluepualap ,moa-aluls ally •al,Sog,O lsu!u& luaw -dpnf pajalua uagl lmoo atLL •japjo luaut8pnf--Clew -wns I,OoZ JQgw0 aoaslt 9193eA of uotlow alujgdas g pun uotlow legl yloq paluap lmoo ay1'SOOZ jogwaa -OG ul •dap awes lull japjo leg, puawe o1 panow 911fo9,0 •alou 22921jow ayl m uo!stnojd s,Cedaasol a jad'sluepualap oso41 of slsoo pug saa;;o uotlllw 9'1$ jano,Ced of al,fog,0 pwaplo Osla,moo 21D '500Z 'LZ jagwaldaS u0 •swtel3 s,alSog,O,lo gOea uo 2se3 1e41 un slugpuelap oql joj luaw,Cjeu 2pnf tuns paluvA MOO gn3no aassauuay aq1 '1,00Z lagw000G ul •(„ sluepuala0„ so ,Clantl3apo3 ueuuagn0 pug:'jadoo0 'ejagog uuwingS of jajaj am) uguuagn0 3ljeyq pug jadoo0 ssog 'sSoulollu s11 3o om1 C11voyloods pue ,t '(„sja8og uuwingS,) 'V -d j2313a V ,SpjOd 'p±pm:0 'sj28od 'uuwln4s 30 uug Mul aql sem 'sjaglo 8uomm •a1,Cog,O Sutluasajdag 72Jua3 alp ;o lwluoa lnlMelun a)lul of pug dtgsjan -md sty ldnnpmq of p2jidsuo3 peq sluepmpli asagt IMP pawtel3 ,Cllgpuassa all •1.tnoo 21121s aassaway p u! sluapu23ap snougn pans al,fog,O'alndstp a2almw (((•uuay) 9•d'0) MUSE TM I10Z'666 •xddV,pa3 9£ti esu al!0) (japoda)j lwapag aql ul uopeatlgnd tod polaolaS ION) (('uual) 9'd o) OSZOIS£'IM I I0Z'6t 1, ,xddtl'Pa3 9£b 436 Fed.Appx. 449, 2011 WL 3510250 (C.A.6 (Tenn.)) (Not Selected for publication in the Federal Reporter) (Cite as: 436 Fed.Appx. 449, 2011 WL 3510250 (C.A.6 (Tenn.))) than one year the date of the tolling agree- ment—which means that O'Boyle's claims are un- timely. *451 The district court's judgment is affirmed. C.A.6 (Tenn.),2011. O'Boyle v. Shulman, Rogers, Gandal, Pordy & Ecker, P.A. 436 Fed.Appx. 449, 2011 WL 3510250 (C.A.6 (Tenn.)) END OF DOCUMENT ® 2014 Thomson Reuters. No Claim to Orig. US Gov. Works. Page 3 " e p l j o l d ` t l o e a g w l e d I S M L 9 9 v X o 9 ' 0 ' d j a i p i d w o o v X 1 8 1 0 ) i O O S > d N O U V H S 9 0 9 � - O L 9 ( t i 5 6 ) : a u o g d o l o l Z b b � � E P u o 1 3 � g a u a g p l a u l a a Q a n u Q a a l u a 0 i t o d m a N 1 s a M 0 8 Z I J J t l u r e l d a S o a d s e ` a l , ��o 9 , 0 . g u 4 w W I g S N f 1 0 0 . I a p u a d u t g o - d 1 m o 0 a t l l d o 3 p l O J a p o J ; d w o Q V V e l , ��J Q ��' N n i n t h d 0 g O N V I S I S S V H . L L I A Q g 2 I d d M U 0 l a r i b l o z ` 5 l t k n o a g . L d a " u o l l l l a d x o l u t e l d u i o a a i l u t p a p u u w a p d a l i a i a t p m j l u u p u o j o p l u g , l s u l E B u p a T a l u a a q I I ? m l l n e 3 a p E ` o s o p o f s l t E 3 l u u p u a d a p u j i " . T a } l u a . t a g j A l o l u l p o u n u i a o p l u l e l d u o o o p u @ s w o p q . i m p l a l m o o s n p 3 o 3 1 i a l o a g l p m s a s u a j a p a g l I o l e u t 8 u o a g l a j g 0 1 p u u ` a o i A . t a s ; o , f e p a g l 3 o a n t s n i o x o ` l u e p u a ; a p l u g s u o s u o u m m s s t g l j o a [ A l a s i a g u S A 1 9 P O Z u T g l l m Z t i b � � E P ? a o l d ` g a E a g P I Q I F a a Q ` a n u Q I o j u a 0 1 . T o d m a N 1 s a M 0 8 Z I s l s s a a p p e a s o g m O A o g , o g u l ] r e N u o u o p p a d i o 1 u t E i d w o a a g l o f s a s u a ; a p u a u p m a r i a s o f p a . g n b a i s i l u e p u a p p q m g � 8 h � � ' I 3 ` w u a j l S 3 i n 0 p e o n g a s 0 0 1 I , c A a - L } & S A - j c ) q Q w 4 4 w r j p L a 3 o u m o y : l u u p u a j o p u o l m s m u i s a i l u t l u l e i d u m a l l 3 o M o o E p u E s u o w u m s s i g l w a a s o f Q g Q N V W W O D a u v f 1 0 X 0 w J N x r C O z . z ��o > C D m = J C L < i M C o M C - - s c = S N O w w f 1 S : ' O N 3 S V D 8 W X X X X 9 L 0 g o 0 t l 0 K O Z 0 g L r : 0 4 B I S a g 1 3 o 3 P 0 1 1 s g o n g 0 1 V ( I r H O ' I 3 3 0 g I V I S H H I " l u u p u a 3 a Q ` Y V U U . L S A - M D 3 0 N M O L a f f L . A ` j j l l u l e l d ` a - u 0 s ' O ' 3 6 u l d m d Q R I O ' I 3 ` X . L N 1 1 0 0 H O d g g W ' l V d I d O J G W N I I M M I D 5 9 1 a l l l J O , L I O D . M D W I O a I " I . L N I IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15`h JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA MARTIN E. O'BOYLE, Plaintiff, V. THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Defendant. THE STATE OF FLORIDA To Each Sheriff of the State: 502014 CA 008076 XXXXMB CASE NO.: SUMMONS l Y � YOU ARE COMMANDED to serve this summons and a copy of the complaint in this law- suit on defendant: Town of 6a4gtrem GLA-P4r-E M 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Each defendant is required to serve written defenses to the complaint or petition on Martin E. O'Boyle, whose address is 1280 West Newport Center Drive, Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442, within 20 days after service of this summons on that defendant, exclusive of the day of service, and to file the original of the defenses with the clerk of this court either before service on plaintiff or immediately thereafter. If a defendant fails to do so, a default will be entered against that defendant for the relief demanded in the complaint or petition. DATED on June 24, 20149U1 2014 M SHARUN R. SOCK Clerk& Comptroller. Robin Pender Clerk of the Court PREPARED WITH ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL Martin E. O'Boyle, as Pro Se Plaintiff 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442 Telephone: (954) 570-3505 Moboyle@commerce-group.com SHARON R. BOCK Clerk & Comptroller P.O. Box 4667 West Palm Beach, Florida 33402-4667 " s a 1 n 1 n 1 S n P u o l d ` ( 1 ) 1 1 . 6 1 1 � o f l u e n s m d ` d 3 ? l u 1 e l d 4 q u o l l o u r u o d n ` p o l l p a d x a a q i a j j e u r s n D s i s o n b o i j j i l u r t , l d ` 4 I 1 g u 0 i l i p p y " s l s o o p u t , s o a 3 s , , i a r u o l j n j j r j u i e j d ! 3 u t p i e r n e p u n ` s p r o o a i o i l g n d p o l s o n b o i a r i l o f s s a o o u o p l A o i d o f l u e p u a 3 a Q a q l $ u i l l o d u r o o p u e ` s p a o o a z o i l g n d o f s s o o m I ! u u o d o f X j n p A l o l n l e l s p u e l e u o l ) n i t l s u o o s l i l o r l o u a a q u i o q o f l u e p u a 3 a Q a r i l 2 u u p l o a p a a p a o u e s i l a a s g j u i e l d ` X I I e o 3 l a a d S " � ; a t l a s o l q u l m b a p u p f a o j e i e g o a p s 3 l a a s u o t l o p s r L ' Z s p r o o a g o i l g n d a r g ) ` s a j r r j m l S e p u o l d ` 6 1 1 i @ j d u g O P u p u o t l n j i l s u o 0 e p u o l d a r i l t o b Z � ` I a l o ? 7 T t / o f I u u n s m d s l r q i ? u l t A i o s J J t l u r e g d I o u o t l m l o i A s , I v e p u a ; a Q o t p s u r a o u o o u o t l o e s n u " I : s a l o l s p u p ( I u p p u a 3 a ( I ) " m p a 1 4 s l l n 0 " l o u m o 1 , o q y s a n s X g a z a g ` l a s u n o o p o u g i s a a p u n a r i l r l ; I n o r g l P u n X q ` ( , d 3 ? l u q u l d ) o j X o q , O ' f f U ! I m w ` 3 3 1 1 u t u l d a q L a m L O N I U N I ( I N V A 2 I O 1 , F 2 I v ' I O a Q u O A ( I N V , L D V S Q H O Z ) H i O P I $ I I d S & V C I I U O I 3 a D U O J N 2 [ O Z . L N I V ' I d N O D ( I a I M U A N O I S I A I O I I A 1 0 1 1 n 0 d 1 0 8 3 1 1 O H 1 d l N O O V Y I H 3 ��0 ) 1 0 0 8 ' b N O U V H S w o a i - i n r 0 N n i 3 ��1 0 J a 3 n I 3 0 3 2 A A d 0 o : * O N d S V O s w x x x x 9 1 M D " M o s p �� V C r M O ' I d ` , U N R O O H O V 3 H Y Q T v ' d W d o v Q I v M . m a d i 0 ' I H I O I M H 1 S I H I L L d O . L I O D . L I I M E D H L L M " l u m p u a l a Q ` Y \ I V H H L S d - M D d O N M O I a l l l 1 1 ` I 3 R u g e l d (f) Grant such further relief as the Court deems proper. Dated: June 24, 2014 0 Respectfully submitted, PREPARED WITH ASSISTANCE OF. COUN EL tTMEO'BOYLE, as Pro Se Plaintiff l Martin E. O'Boyle 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Telephone: (954) 570-3505 moboyle commerce-aroun com L C2I001 di / uo{sgwwoO- 2103'L idy »ildr3 •wwoa k9 rplJoll to SMS • *M A MJI ATMX M14 vm ('r :paonpoid uopuog!luapllo a&iZ :umou}I ,Jjuuosiad :alsotput asuaid 21g1Id dO alVIS OI Igncl AHV.LON 5-1puug0 taof �q bIOZ 'JO ,fap snp aui oiodaq paquosgns pus 'pauugjL, `ol uaomS ( HOVgg WrWd dO )LINfIOO ss( ( VQRIO'Td dO 211VIS a[ og,0 •g u!ljPW :amuR ga!Iaq puu `uo!lsuuojn a2palmoux sr qjo Isaq aql of loauoo pus an>; s! puu `m q ofumoux uopuuuo3u! pue spiooai uo paseq s! yAIIV IdIAiOO QalI3I2idt1 snll lsgl s,Cus pus sasodop `moms pus pogpuop! ,Clnp Isig Bu!aq `oqm `aaipuug0 loo f paivaddu j(puosiad `,Cluoglnu poug!szapun a p `MN gIOddg HOVHU Fq'IVd 30 A.LNf1O0 VCIMO'Id 30 HMS NOI LVOIJMA Exhibit A ZOKC vammj •xoreg m3uvua •aAmd U�o ivoaWN »ACS MI L090'09CK6 wzl • IILVOW9 5;6 lai. l u0�•d ROli-a�lalllS3lp�•A�MA1 'SIuauIaAOSdui iaq;o pus uopoxu[suoo .xo} s;n=ad.paimbai Eus aprgoxa pjnom sng4 'asmoo;p i =;)-T'S.IInJ Jo umoy aTll ploTl of pualu[ pinom am'dlluonbosuoO •uorgsE} pids.x u Tr[ p.xsmso; anoux of uopualuT mo sell;-mp 'noS puguai I uTLBV @moll xagoS s zo} UMQ14S AnD uT asnO l s asn 04 fmssaoau a.xe slsnoidds .xo/pu-e slluxiad Isom of ss uoz;sn-eldxa nB -To '.uopeUMIJ Too sttod Irem-e ,ilsnoD= I •asnoH zagoS'e }o Toen QTll zo} AT113dlolunUl aql uno-g pasnnba.x slp3ljgd ao sreAoxdds ou aq pinom asaTll }sill =juoo o} iallal slTll no,i alrim I 'TlltanTp:roj uxsa2oTd snp }o u04sluaumaldmi otp u-p@q of pu@;M I •sasnoH sagoS ss asn io} uTsa-.S RnO ul sasnoTl annboe of 1CUeduioo a U.UOJ of uolsloap -e apsTu OA�TI I ,Ilam noS spun} xallal snp adoTl I zagssnly 'XW .xsaQ �pinoi� `tuea�.Fl?�rJ `(s)asr-[oH sagoS-Pasodo-*d=all .102sLreyi umo L 'iatls-eJq , •H uieIMPA :ully esti££ Zd `ureQ1IS JMD pso21 saS OOI =04S 3In JO umo t 9IIS-9L3-I99# aMOHdZ'IZL io Txxsa�s- aTlssxg}q :'Ilyyd-O V A 9096-OLS-bSft auogda[ay IsTQ Taa,IQ woa• no -oo,a o [ ogoui f a • a dnoRo aoU WIOO William H. Thrasher, Town Manager June 6, 2014 Page 2 accountable for any damages which we incurred as a result of purposeful delays. Sincerely yours, COMMERCE RC rE GROUP, INC. I Marlin E. O'B6yle President 1 cc: William F. Ring, Jr., Esquire — E -Mail P/NPR/SOBERHOUSESGULFSTREAM S jiqiqxg June 6, 2014 MAYOR: Scott W. Morgan VICE MAYOR: Robert W. Ganger COMMISSIONER: Joan K. Orthwein Thomas M. Stanley Donna S. White REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM ON FRIDAY, DONE 13, 2014 AT 9:00 A.M_ IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Pledge of Allegiance. III. Roll Call. IV. Minutes. A. Regular Meeting of May 9, 2014 B. Workshop -Meeting of May 9, 2014 V. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. VI. Announcements. A. Regular Meetings and Public Hearings 1. July 11, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 2. August 8, 2014 @ 9 A.M. _ 3. September 12, 2014 @ 9 A.M. 4. October 10, 2D14 @ 9 A.M. S. November 14, 2014 @ 9 A.M_ 6_ December 12, 2014 @ 9 A.M. VII. Communications. A. Requests 1. Report on 2014 Legislative Session -Senator Sachs 2. From Residents (5 min. maximum) VIII. PUBLIC HEARING A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates, as agent for Robert M. Gardiner owner of property located at 530 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 8, Block 3, Plat No. 1 Polo Fields Subdivision for the following: a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION 1 to permit the addition of a 253 sq. ft. bedroom to an existing home that encroaches approximately 3.5 ft. into the east side setback. b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION 2 to permit the addition of a 253 sq. ft. bedroom to an existing home that extends approximately 5 ft. into the rear waterfront setback in the Core Design District. C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITS PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a 253 sq. ft. bedroom addition to an existing non -conforming Bermuda style, one-story, single family dwelling at the location described herein. IX. Reports_ A. Utility Undergrounding-Danny Brannon (Engineer) B. Town Manager SOTO'•98Z 'S'S13 '03sH9 38 OZ SI 'IK3daW 3HZ HOIHM NOdn 33N30IA3 ONH ANOWIS531 3HZ S30n7ONI 0H003H HOIHM 'suww sI S9NI03 oua 3HS 30 Ommu WIxmaA V yHHI 3HOENI OS O33N XVW '3SO"Dd HbnS H03 M 'S9NI0330OUd 3HS 30 mi003H H 033H TIIM muva OIKs '9NIS33W sIHL SK 03H30ISN00 H31LHW ANH 01 XD3dS3a HSIM NOISSIWW O NMOS 3HS AS 30VN NOISI030 XNH 7H3ddN OS M33S X.IdWd 03SS3U3ZNI XNV O'InOHS ;uawuanoCpy 'IX Si9uOT6sTww00 pue 20KEN Aq swa4I '8 9J'dV v0 SuoTITsod ;o wour4snEpy •y •uoT4ny uOTsstww00 i0; swagl 6TOZ AeW 109 A4TAT40V •T g9M aOTTOd '3 PIOZ 'TE AEW Jo -se abesn ia}eM 'Z 6TOZ AeW i0; 42odaa TetnueuT3 •T i04091TO anueuT3 '0 •W'V OE:B 0 6TOZ ''EZ iagoa00 •a •W•H OE=8 8 ETOZ 'sZ =agwagdaS •p gsnbny UT buT4aaw ou GT aiagy •n 'N'V OE;8 B 6TOZ 'bZ ATnr 'q •W'K OE:B 0 6TOZ '9Z aunr •e sa4e0 buT48aw • T p2e09 buTuueTd 5 naTAaH Tean00a4T402y •0 03nNISN00 H0N395t Exhibit C :smollol se peel oI 'samp000ld uollepoww000e algeuoseay ' l L-99 uolloas 'uolloas mau a spnpul of :Iejauag ul 'I a1oIUV :6uluoZ '99 jalde40 Is papuawe lgajag sl weajlS ;Ing to umol eql to saoueulpi0 to apoO a41 �uolloaS :SMO -110d SV 'V(IIUO-Id 'AiNf100 HOV30 WIVd 'WV32i1S dlflo d0 NMOL 3H1 d0 NOISSIWWOO NM013HI AG 03NIVO8011 30 '3HOd3M3H1'MON •6ulllamp a Aofua pus asn of f4lunuoddo lenba us uosiad pelgeslp a pjol;e of se os saawas pus 'saolloeid 'salallod 'salm 'saoueulpio s,umo_I, a4I of algeogdde aq of sainpaowd uogepoww000e algeuoseai asagl spualul umol a4l 'SV3b3HM pue !suollepoww000s algeuoseaj anlaoai oI 'mel pus sloe; eqj uo paseq aleudadde aiagM 'pus suogepoww000e algeuoseaj lsanbaj of (sallque 6u4.lenb io) slenplAlpul palgeslp lluuad lllm Ieig sainp000id uogepoww000e olgeuoseai seoueulPjo to apo0 s,umol ata ulgllm (dope of sailsep Agejeq umol a43 'SVgd3HM pue :6ulsnoq lofue pus asn al,plunpoddo Ienba us uosied Bons piolle of AUessaoau pus algeuoseei eq Ism lenpinlpul palgeslp aql (q Ig6nos uogepoww000e pasodad a41 -wagl of 'aogoeid jo 'Ao11od 'elm 'ummoid apo0 ogpoads a to uolleoildde eq) ul uogeialle Jo uolleoglpow a Isenbal ueo 'salnlels peauejejej aqI japun suogepoww000e elgeuoseaj jol 6ul4lenb palgeslp sqj of saolAMs to 19pinoid a jo '(„ palgeslp, je4eejaq 'loV sluawpuawV 6ulsnoH pled a4I lo/pue IoV sagglgesl0 431m sueouawV a4I to g ag1 ul paugap aie suual asogl se) paddeolpueq jo/pue palgeslp sl oqm lenpinlpul ue gol4M Aq po4law pagsllgelsa Aluolnlels a sl uogepoww000e elgeuoseei.'SV32i3HM '31VO 3AIIO3dd3 NV SNIOIAONd :NOI1VOIdIMOO UOd gN10IA02id !101ldNOO NI S30NVNIM2lO d0 1V3d3M NOd gNI01AOEd - U -II8V213A3S IiOd SNI01A0ad !13V S3111118VS10 HIM SNVOIH31NV 3Hl JO If 31111 0NV lOV S1N3WONEI M gNlsnOH MVd 9HI Ol iwnsufld S321f103002id NOIIVOOWWOOOV 318VNOSV3a clOd ONIOIAOUd '61-99 N01103S 'NO1103S M3N V 30nlONl 01 :IV'dSN3g NI 'I 31311UV !ONINOZ '99 a31dVH0 Ol 1N3WON3WV NV ONIOIAONd 'VORIOId 'A1Nf100 HOV99 WIVd 'W Ams dlflg d0 NMOI 3H1 d0 NOISSIWWOO NMOL 3H1 d0 3ONVNICIUO NV 'ON 3ONVNIOUO "Chapter 66 KNT. OF ARTICLE L IN GENERAL Sec. 66-11. Reasonable Accommodation Procedures. (1) This section implements the policy of the Town of Gulf Stream for processing of requests for reasonable accommodation to its ordinances, rules, policies, and procedures for persons with disabilities as provided by the federal Fair Housing Amendments Act (42 U.S.C. 3601, at seq.) ("FHA') and Tille It of the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Section 12131 at seq.) ("ADA"). For purpose's of this section, a "disabled" individual or person is an individual that qualifies as disabled and/or handicapped under the FHA andlor ADA. Any person who is disabled (or qualifying entities) may request a reasonable accommodation with respect to the Town's land use or zoning laws, rules, policies, practices and/or procedures as provided by the FHA and the ADA pursuant to the procedures set out in this seWan. (2) A request by an applicant for reasonable accommodation under this section shall be made in writing by completion of a reasonable accommodation request form, which form is maintained by (and shall be submitted to) the Town Clerk. The reasonable accommodation form shall contain such questions and requests for information as are necessary for processing the reasonable accommodation request. The reasonable accommodation request form shall be substantially in the form set forth in subsection (10) below. �N - "if (3) Should the information providedly the disabled- individual to the Town include medical information or records, including records Indicating the medical condition, diagnosis or medical history of the disabled individual, such individual may, at the time of submitting such medical information, request that the Town, to the extent allowed by law, treat such medical information as confidential information of the disabled individual. The Town shall thereafter endeavor to provide written notice to the disabled individual, and/or their representative, of any request received by the Town for disclosure of the medical information or documentation which the disabled individual has previously requested be treated as confidential by the Town. The Town will cooperate with the disabled individual, to the extent allowed by law, in actions initiaTed by such individual to oppose the disclosure of such medical information or documentation, but the Town shall have no obligation to initiate, prosecute or pursue any such action, or to incur any legal or other expenses (whether by retention of outside counsel or allocation of internal resources) in connection therewith, and may comply with any judicial order without prior notice to the disabled individual. (4) The Town Manager, or his/her designee, shall �e the authority o const er and act on requests for Rasonahle accommodation, after notice and publtc hearing to receive comments, input and information from the public (provided, however, the Town Manager or designee shall not be required to render their decision at said public hearing). When a Ord==No. _ Page 2 of 6 9 j g 86ed —•au 23LMuiaro /ggeuoseei se uoos as uogeuluualop a lapuej '6uueay oggnd e pub aogou oilgnd iap 'geys oq m uolsslwwoo umol aLp of aq geys sleaddy •leadde ay; jol spunoA ayl to Ilelap lualoglns 6ulule4uoo ;uawalels a ule;uoo geys sleadde ley •uolstoap ayl leadde Am lueolldde yons '4ed 6ugsanbei ayl of pallew sl ;sanbai uogepoww000e algeuoseat a uo uogeuluua;ap 's,aau6lsap Jo 's,136eueW nmol ayl 194e SAep pg ulyu.M (9) •leadde ue lo;uama ay; ul uolsslwWoo umol ay; Aq Jo 'aau6lsap Jo 'Ja6euepy umol ay; Aq apew ;sanbai uogepoww000e algeuoseem a uodn uolsloap e iol slseq ay; aq lleqs (synod ay; Sq pa;aidialul se) 6ulofto; ayl •6ulsnoy Ao(uo pue asn of 4un4joddo lenbe suosied pelgeslp/paddeolpuey ploye o{ kesseoeu pue algeuoseei ale ;y6nos 6ulaq suogepoww000e pasodo.id ayl ley; aleysuawep o; eney ll!m (lied 6u4sanbej ay; ';xaN •;uauuledwl yons 6ulney se papie6aw eme 6ayl ;eyl (iq) jo t;uawnedwl yons 6ulney to pJooai a CI) saglmlloe GMI Jo(ew aiow Jo auo sllwg 6gegue4sgns yolym;uauuledwl le;uaw jo le3isA4d a () snoys;snw lenpinlpw pelgeslp ay; uogoas sly; to sesodmd jol 'uol;e{ajdialul lelolpnl o; }oafgns sl Glggeslp to uoglugap ay; y6noylly VOy jo/pue VHd ay; ul paugap se 'palgeslp jo paddeolpuey cue ';uesaidej /eyl Eyed ay; jo 'Aay; ;ey; 6uge4suowep Aq VgV jo pue HHd ay; japun pa ad aie ay{ ley;sggelsa of pejo w aq-iley ugsan j ay; 'paluap jo pelue16 eq geys ;sanbai uollepoww000e algeuoseai ay; Jay;aym 6ululuualap ul (g) •pajnbai aq lleys;senbei uogepoww000e elgeuoseaj plus o; pieft yllm umol ayl Aq uogoe jayynl ou pue umeapy;lm Jo/pue pauopueqe paweep eq Ileys uollepoww000e elgeuoseei fol;sanbei ayl eiolaiayl pue 'uoWL uo/ul leuon{ppe ayl llwgns llew•q of pallet pey /Geed 6ugsanbei ayl ley; 6ulslnpe aogou uauum a anssl pegs 'aau6lsap jo 'Ja6euevq umol ayl'poped Aep-gl ples mygm uogeuuo;w leuoglppe palsanbai ay; aplmad of sgel Mud 6ugsonbal ayl ll vogetwo/ul leuoglppe ay; to ldlaoai jalle s{sp pg mglm uogeuluualap ua}}um e enssl lleqs '99u6lsap Jo 'JeBeueyy nmol ayl pue 'algeolldde aq J96uol ou lleqs uogeuluualap uapum a anssl o; poped Asp -9y ayl 'apew sl uogeuuo/u{ leuoglppe jol;sanbei a Juana alit ul uol{eujo;ul pa;sanbw alit epinad o; uogeuuolul leuoglppe jol lsenbei ayl to a;ep ay{ 'alle s Cep 91 eney geys Dyed 6ugsanbaj alit •pannbej sl uolleuuolul leym llelap luelogpis ul 6ullfjloads 'dyed Bugsanbw ay; wort uogeuuolul leuoglppe lsanbai'popedAnp-gyplestopue ay}o;joud' aw'aau6lsapio 'ie6euelM umol ay; 'uol;epoww000e algeuoseai iol lsenbai ay; uo uogeuluualap a yoeai o; tiess-wou Algeuosew ll •palsanbei ;dlaoai wnlai 'llew payload 6q (angeluesaidai Jay/sly jo lenplmlpul palgeslp ay{ •a•l) 4ed 6ugsanbaj alit o; lues aq pays uogeulunalap to aogou alit •leadde ol;y6u ayl to aoqou am16 geys suogeuluuelep uagum py •jolajayl spunw6 mg alels Ileys pue 6ugpm ul aq geys lquap yons Auy 'mel leiapa} yqm aouepj000e w 'lsenbai ayl (uap (o) jo :;sanbaj ay; to;uw6 ayl uodn suolllpuoo asodwl jo/pue ';sanbai ay; to uolyod a Guep pue lsanbai ay{ to uolyod a;ueJ6 (q) gsanbai uollepoww000e ayl ;uei6 (e) :Mel lwapal yllm eouspi000e ul '/few pue uogbogdde poleldwoo a to ldlaoaj to alep ay; to s6ep S4 ulygm uogeuluualap ua}}um a anssl lleqs 'aau6lsap Jo 7a6euayy umol ayl •uogejaplsuoo pue malmai jot 'aau6lsap jo 'ja5eueW umo-L ayl of paLalai aq Him q XJGIO.umol ayl of pa;llwgns pue paleldwoo uaeq ssy uuol;sanbei uogepoww000e elgeuoseei practicable, but in no event later than 60 days after an appeal has been filed. (7) There shall be no fee imposed by the Town in connection wfth'a request for reasonable accommodation under this section or an appeal of a determination on such request to the Town Commission, and the Town shall have no obligation to pay a requesting party's (or an appealing partys, as applicable) attorneys' fees or costs in connection with the request, or an appeal. (8) While an application for reasonable accommodation, or appeal of a determination of same, is pending. before the Town, the Town will not enforce the subject zoning ordinance, rules, policies, and procedures against the applicant. (9) The following general provisions shall be applicable: (a) The Town shall display a notice in the Town's public notice bulletin board (and shall maintain copies available for review in the Town Clerk's office), advising the public disabled individuals (and qualifying entities) may request reasonable accommodation as provided herein. (b) A disabled individual may apply for a reasonable accommodation on his/her own behalf or may be represented at all stages of the reasonable accommodation process by a person designated by the disabled individual. (c) The Town shall provide such assistance and accommodation as is required pursuant to FHA and ADA in connection with a disabled person's request for reasonable accommodation, including, without limitation, assistance with reading application questions, responding to questions, completing the form, filing an appeal, and appearing at a hearing etc. to ensure the process is accessible. (10) Reasonable accommodation request form: 1. Nameol'Applicant 2. Telephone Number. 3. Address: 4. Address of housing or other location at which accommodation is requested: 5. Describe qualifying disability or handicap:. 6. Describe the accommodation and the specific regulation(s) and or procedure(s) from which accommodation is sought 7. Reasons the reasonable accommodation may be necessary for the individual with disabilities to use and enjoy the housing or other service: oidmmm No._ Page 4 of 6 9;0 9 a6ed _ON MURUIwo Jauoissiwwo0 iauo[ssiwwa0 Jauoissiwwo0 JoIEW 'bLOZ'ounp;o /ep y;gL siy; 6upeaj;sig uo uoisses pownofps 'jejn6aj a ui eoueup o Coua6iawa ue se 03I d0GV (INV 09SSVd 'mel (q papfnwd SE yenadde pue a6essed sp uodn lla;eipawwi;oaga a%e; geys aoueuipi0 sfyl '9;e0 an403.43 .5 uogOaS weal;SAnO;o nmol ayr;o saoueupi0 ;o apo0 jepg;o an to ;ied a apew pue pagipoo aq jjays aoueupl0 siyl •u014e3g!p00 •q uogaaS •paleadaj 6gaay ae eoueuiplo siy;;o lied Aue jo sfy; y;im;oiguoo yoigm;oaay; sued jo 'epuold 'weags jInO;o umol ay; ;o saoueutpio gay;o IIV '101guo0 a saoueupo;o ieadam E uogaaS •ajgelanas pajeloap 6gajay am eoueupi0 siy;;o suoismad ay; pue siy; o; pue 'suoge0pdde jo suoismad pgenu ay; ;noyann ;oage uani6 aq ueo yoiym aoueupio sfy; }o suogeopdde jo suoismoid jay;o ay;;oepjou pet's R;ippenu yons 'pgenu play si;oaay; uogeoildde ay; 10 aoueup10 sly; ;o u01smad Rue; •iGgigwanaS 'Z uogaaS Aqua 6ui4. en0 jo 'apeogdde ;i 'ani;e;uasajdaa jo lenpmipu palgesf0;o an;eu6!S oL :uogeuuo;w Jay;0 '6 :ajgsoHdde J! ange;uesada ;o jagwnu auoydela; pue ssaippe aweN •g ATTEST: Clerk p:WGM11314TLL DWI Woc11jk8212.drrc ordinance No._ Page 6 Of 6 Q liqitl-xq From: Marty O'Boyle Sent: Thursday, June 12, 2014 8:03 PM To: Craig D. Earnhart Subject: Re: PROPOSED SOBER HOUSES- GULF STREAM Craig - kindly call me 561-213-3486 Sent from my HTC --- Reply message -- From: "Craig D. Earnhart" <cdelawPbellsouth.net> - To: "Marty O'Boyle" <mobovle(a)commerce-grouo com> Subject: PROPOSED SOBER HOUSES- GULF STREAM Date: Thu, Jun 12, 2014 7:05 PM Good evening Mr. O'Boyle: I just received a copy of your June 6, 2014 email to Gulf Stream Town Manager, William Thrasher, advising of your plan to "forthwith" begin acquiring houses in Gulf Stream for use as Sober Houses. I would like for you to know that during your recent campaign for a seat on the Gulf Stream Town Commission 1 acquired a great deal of admiration and respect for you, spent an evening at your lovely home getting to know you and discussing your goals and vision for improving Gulf Stream, and actively campaigned for you. At that time I was convinced that your motives were all noble, and that you truly wanted to do only good and productive work for our town. Your proposed Sober House plan says otherwise. Certainly you know that opening and operating Sober Houses in the Town of Gulf Stream can do nothing but bring down property values, and would be strongly opposed by not only the city officials, but also virtually all of the residents of our quaint little town. I find it difficult to believe that your motives are purely philanthropic in nature. Since you clearly don't need the money possibly generated from this proposed plan, I can therefore only assume that your motives are purely vindictive and retaliatory in nature. This leads me to question my own naivety in buying into your.campaign promises of Wanting only the best for our town. I only hope that your letter was intended for shock value or an idle threat, perhaps sent out in a fit of rage; or perhaps even meant as a joke. If you are truly sincere in your Sober House plan, I fear that you will swiftly lose the respect and support of those like me who came to believe so strongly in you during the recent campaign. Maybe that doesn't mean much to you, but it seems to me tragic that you would be willing to forfeit your hard-eamed honor in such an act of spite. mu Zd `mua4s J(n ) (EIIIp]ED SSLZ Puqu]E`3 'Q 6iejo 'Alojeows suoisniouoo Aue of 6uiwoo ajolaq sigl uo nog( wog} aeaq o} Addey we Exhibit E :sluawwoo 6ulM0110d ayl aas aseald 'apse anoge eq I jopueo moA aleloaidde yonw I 'pews mo! jod no ( Iue43 — uopioE) IIejN uopjog lq weajIS IInE) - sasnoH jagoS :EIH :Ioa(gnS we LV817LOZ'LL unr'an•I•:IuaS <woo=ioe uopJo Iojs> IIeiN uopJoO :01 <woo na-aolawwoo aI ogow> 9jAo8,O (peln! :wwd --06essavq Ieul6li0— I;eIN uopJoO •H •I! Nuup of Moy paweal Janau I aplse ue sy •jagwanaN IIIun eppoid ul %oeq aq Iou plm I 'pawaouoo sl aajjoo se jed sy onu 6u a 'Alloanp no( of posoddo se enssl ayI uo avow si snood ayI'pan I ! ! q do Lflllglssod a paleolpul aney nob aj!gM •lylunwwoo ino olid sasnoH JagoS do uollonpoilul ayI pelsaJod oI aney Iy6lw umol ayl yoeoidde Sue d! leym aas of sem sallied palsaielu! of Ilewe ino C do uolinglnslp aLn'peleolpul I sy •mou eloueied ayl 6uldolanap eie noA ana!laq I • Uolsiy se aweu jay Aluo yllm aw of I! pallewo apmlw Ieyl sl jaysejyl •jyq of japan ono (Io (doo a aney I uoseai 94 :814o8,O •JW :upjN uopog Aq weeilS ding - sasnoH jagoS :aa ::pa[gng . alAo9,o /qjeW :ol Wd EEZ KOZ'LT aunr'Aepsanl quag woo•Ioe uopja Iols:odllew J}enl uopiog :woad Whether I decide to participate as a consultant for a Sober House Operator gives no one the right to commence a smear campaign. A Sober House is an enterprise that everyone in Gulf Stream could fight (although I think they will lose — as it is ADA protected). I am an individual. I have no problem with the people bad mouthing Sober Houses, I do have a problem when it oozes over to me and my family. I hope you understand. This situation is no different than a lawyer representing a criminal. Fight the crime — not the lawyer. 2 Gordon, you have my word that I have still not decided to take on the Sober House Assignment. I continue to struggle with it. Having said that, if I do decide to accept it, I will let you know. Absent hearing from me means I "took a pass". Once again, I appreciate your candor PS: I will make a Public Records Request for your wife's email.. If I get it, great, if I don't, I have to come back to you, If she deleted it, it should be in here deleted box. Alternatively, it is certainly available as metadata. I assume that although she asserts deleting the email that she retained the attachment (as your email below demonstrates). I think if you could come around behind me and look over my shoulder and see what I see, your perspective would change. No one who make a query about a legal matter should be chased by.a posse. I point out that when I woke up this morning, I was in America. Gordon — your comments are insightful and appreciated (not to mention now received). Are you willing to help me and the 122 others address what needs to be addressed in Gulf Stream? We could sure use your help. I believe that our overall goals are the same. If you get a chance, look at the video's of the Commission Meetings under "Agendas\Minutes" Lastly, is it time for us to have a coffee? I'd enjoy that very much. Let me know an thank you, Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 Cell: 561 213 3486 E-mail: moboylelaDCommerce- roup com Web Page: _www.commerce-group com From: Gordon Kraftjmallto:slotoordont7o aoi coml Sent: Monday, June 16, 2014 8:08 PM To: Marty O'Boyle Subject: Re: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream by Gordon Kraft Mr. O'Boyle: My wife has deleted her email, but said it came from the town as it was apparently a "public record email". By the way she doesn't get emails at Caldwell -Banker. " s n u a a m l a q A p e w a l w I ! a i p u e g l a g ) e j p i n o m I " e B e l a l n l J i a g l s o l r i s e p u e J a ��l u e 8 I l a m p l e o I o e l u o o a l d o a d 1 1 I n o a n e y o ; l u e m h o o p A l l e a A 1 ' p u e g t o I n o j a g l J n l s l a b I l a j o l a q 6 u o l m a I g 6 u o ) s 1 o p o f I u e m I p y " I i p a n i a o E M 9 , 4 s w o g m A l l e o U j o a d s w o j l s m o u ��i A 1 a ��l i i p u e : w o g ; J a g a 1 a g I p e n l a o a J a y s ( ' M i u e 8 I l e m p l e o j o l e u o s a a d ) I u n 0 0 0 e l i e w a g o l g m s m o u �� a y s A l a i n s " l e g u a p y u o o 1 1 d a a ��l p w , I p u e j o l 6 u i ��l o o l w e I l e g m s e q a y s m o u s I * A p e l p e q a I O U s l a y s l e g l s l a s u e s A w ; n q ' i a g l a w J a n a u a n e y I " a l e d i o g l e d o f u a s o g o s e m o q m , p m a o u l a g l t o G u o s e m a 3 1 m m o A o w n s s e " m a 6 P i m A a g l I o e ; u l * d o l s I , u o m A a g l J o ( A p i o i n b p n q e q ; u l p a d d l u ) y l i m n e a p a q o I a n e y s u b i e d w e o j e a w s ' I s a a s l g l I a , I , u e o I ' u o p j o E ) " s n g l l m ; s a u o g 6 u i a q I O U s e m a o A e l n l u a y l a y ) ' A l a l e u n l i o ; u n " s j a g ) o p u e ( J e A m e l u m o l e g ; ) g d l o p u e N d i a l s ' l u e p A e - 1 w o l ' a a o w 1 3 9 6 j o a l ) A q P a s s a u l i m 1 0 p e A c u d d e J a 4 j l n ; p u e u i e m g l j o i o f % 2 V q u e g l A g p a n a r d d e s e m u o g o e ) o a s i n o o ; e y l ' ( p a ; e u l w u e l a q p i n o y s ��u i g l I o g m u e w e ) J a g s e J g l " J I n l o f J a R G 1 a g l p u s s p i p I ' s o ) f a n o s l u 6 i e d w e 0 a q ; ' J a n a m o g ' m o N " A e m J a g l o a g I p a l l o o l 1 ' u 6 i e d w e o a s e m I I a o u i s a v o w a q j u o a j a m s i o w n i A l s e u a g l p u e I 1 4 6 i s w o j l p a j e a d d e s i p s u 6 i s A w ) o L g 6 u e g m u 6 i e d w e o a q ) 6 u u n p I i u a a s I t o a l g e d e o a j e A a g l s p o i l A l j i p e g l p u e s a ; e j e d o u m o ; s i g ; m o g m o u N i ' u o p j o o " n o A X u e g l I y o i g m a o l ' s i s e q A l p u a i 4 a o \ P u e I i n i o a u o m o o a i e ( ; s e a l l e s i e e d d e l o ; i ) a m l e q ; p e s e a i d g o n w a n w e 1 * w e s i g l I ! l u n m o l a q l i e w e i n o A e a s I O U p i p I u o p i o o 4 E J M u o p j o E ) A q w e a n s I f n E ) - s a s n o H j a g o s : 3 2 1 : I o a f g n s W E ? 0 0 : 9 b 6 o z ' 9 l u n r u o y u I u a s < w o l o e u a p ��o ) o l s > ; I e j N u o p l o o 3 : o l < w o o n o g - a a a w w o o a l o g o w > 8 l A 0 g , 0 A 4 J e y Q : w o J 3 0 6 e s s a l r y l e u l 6 u o I 1 e J N U O P M E ) " 3 " s s a J p p e o ; s p e a u u m o l a y ) ; e y ) s 6 u i y ) ) o ) s i l e q ; u m o p A e m a q p i n o y s y o l g m a n s s i u e u o s n o o l o ; a l d o e d a w ' o } A l a ��j ! I P i n o m p i e v u o l 6 u 1 o 6 a o u i s d o A ; l u n } r o d d o s l q ; s s e d n o A ) e y I a d o g p i n o m 1 " n o A o ; a p e w l e s o d a d e q j g L m p i e N u o l 6 u i o 6 ; o e a p l a y ; y ) . U n 6 u l g s a i m p i ) s a i e n o A ; e g ) e w o f A 1 8 1 e n u d p a l e o i p w a n e y n o ) , " u m o l s l y l t o s ) u a p l s e j t o s p u t w a y ; u l a n s s i a n l ) l s u e s A j a A e o ; e ) e j e l A a g ) s e s ) u a w w o o u m o i n o A t o ) o e d w l a y ; p u o A a q a o e l d 6 u l ��l e ) s i 6 u u e a w s A u e a n a l l a q l , u o p I ' p e w a o u o o s i u 6 i e d w e o j e e w s a s e j e l s y " e u e j e s i g l u l 6 u i v a d d e y s e m 6 u i y l e w o s l e y l s u o l ) e z l u e 6 j o a s o y ) t o s a i d i o u u d e y ) t o p e u a l e A l a ) e i p a w w I p i n o m u m o l a y ; I B M P a s u d m s a q ; o u p i n o y s n o A y l i m g l i o ; w e i 6 o i d s i g ) t o u o l l e ; u a w a l d w l a y ) u i 6 a q o f p u a l w " s e s n o H j e g o s s e a s n j o ; w e a n s j l n , Z ) u t s a s n o y a n n b o e o f A u e d w o o a u u o l o f u o l s l o s p a s p e w a n e y l : 6 u g e l s j e y s e j 4 l , j n o f j a g a l j n o A l u e s n o A u a g M " d e a f , o m l I s e l a y ; u i g o e a e A e n a d u i b u u e e d d e p a p e l s A a g i e o u i s J a n a s a s n o y j e g o s ; o a r i s s l e g ) 6 u i m o l l o ) A l a n g o e u e e q a n e y . u o l ) e n i a s a J d I o ) u o i l i I e o o a y ; p u e ' u o l ; e l o o s s y o i n l o w e a n s ) o n o a y ) ' u m o 1 a y ) w q ) m o u % p i n o y s n o A " p u e q t o ) n o s l a b ) i a j o l a q 6 u o j m a ) g 6 u o ; a i i s a p a p u e , u 6 i e d w e o j e a w s a o f j e ; a j n o A l i e w a i n o A u l If you would like to have a coffee sometime soon, 1 would like that. But I reiterate, I must get to the core here. PS: It appears you are from Pittsburg where we own property all over (from South Hills to Monroeville to Greensburg, etc). No Sober houses there or anywhere else. I'll wait to hear from you. Thank you Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 Cell: 561 213 3486 E-mail: moboylena.commerce-group com Web Page: www.commerce-clroup.com From: F Gordon Kraft rmailto:slotaordon0aol coml Sent: Sunday, June 15, 2014 10:55 PM To: Marty O'Boyle Subject: Re: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream by Gordon Kraft Mr. O'Boyle: Thank you for your reply. I appreciate your forthrightness My wife deleted the copy of the letter, but t can only assume it was sent out by the town or someone in the town leadership. I know this has been a concern of the Civic Association, so I'm certain they are active in any efforts to limit proliferation of sober houses in the town. F. Gordon Kraft Sent from my Pad On Jun 15, 2014, at 6:25 PM, Marty O'Boyle <mobovleacommerce-croup com> wrote: Gordon — I feel no obligation to respond. I am writing to you now voluntarily. I have no intention of putting a sober house in Gulf Stream for reasons, inter alia, I wouldn't have a clue on how to run one. I was however approached by an out of state company that seems set on putting sober houses in Gulf Stream and the surrounding areas (but only on the water in Gulf Stream). For reasons unknown to me, they asked me to lead their charge. They offered to pay me a very handsome sum. I am struggling with their offer (whether to accept it or not). As I -said it is a ton of $$$ and I know if I don't take it someone else will. " u o g e u u o ; u l S I L O G J e 4 S o } u o n u a ; w o u a n e q n o C C p u a j e d d y " I j o ) ) a s l y ; 6 u l n s m d w u 0 0 e n 1 . j o w j n o C j o ; n o R 6 w > i s e / I d w l s w e 1 - w e e g s ; l n E ) u l j a u m o a w o y J a q ; o A U e ; o ; e g l u e g 4 l u a j a g l p o u C l g e g a d s 1 j l ' p a w a o u w s 1 e l o u e j e d C w s e j e ; s y " ( o q m m o q ; , u o p 1 ) w e a i ; s ; l n 0 w a u o a w o s w o J ; 1 1 e w a u e u l p a n 1 9 0 a . 1 a ) l m C w g o l g m ' j a g s e j g y " r y 4 o ; j a g a l i n o A t o 6 d o o a u e q ; j a g a o n o S 1 o ; u o p e w j o } u l C u e a n e g ; , u o p 6 1 1 1 3 9 . 1 I : a 1 6 o 8 0 A N u e j N u o p j o 0 6 q w e e i l s ; i n 0 - s a s n o H j a g o s : a a ; ; a a l g n g a 1 6 0 8 . 0 6 > J e W : o l W d 9 � : t i V L 0 Z ' 4 L a u n r ' 6 e p u n s q u a s w o o " l o e u o p j o l o l s : o l l l e w g e j > 1 u o p i o 0 : w o r d w o o n o g - e o T e w w o o " n n n n n n : a b e d q a M w o o n a l - a o j a w w o o a ( o g o w : f l e w - 3 9 8 6 E U Z 1 . 9 9 : 1 1 9 0 L 0 9 0 - 0 9 E - t i 9 6 X a a 9 0 5 E - O L 9 1 7 9 6 : l e i G 1 0 0 n a Z b b E E " I : j ' u o e a 8 P l a l J . l a a a a n l J C ] . I a ; u a 3 l u o d m O N " M 0 9 Z L o u l ' d n o a 0 e o j e w w o 0 ` a l A 0 8 . 0 " 3 u l I J e W o ; ) 1 1 e ; o ; A s e a w e I ' 6 u u a a w a n l 6 ' o p n o k ; I e w w o j ; u o g e u u o ; u l j a g ; o 6 u e ; u e m n o ( ; I m o u ��l a w j a i p u e s u o l ; u a ; u l s , ( d d n C ) ; n o g e m o u N a w l e " a w s p u a s a g s ; e g m l e a n a U ; o U o ; u o l ; u a ; u l 6 w a q P 1 n o M ; I " o p o ; ; u e M ; o u O P I g o l g m ' J a ��l u e g p a m p l e 0 o ; j a g a l u o g e 1 1 o d s o u a p u s s o ; a q P 1 n o m a n d ; e w a ; l e ; s e l 6 W v a g a l U 0 1 a [ o u a j a q p u s s p i n o o I o s p o o h a q p i n o m ; e g ; ' s s a i p p e I l e w a J a q a w 9 n 1 6 P 1 n o m n o ( p ' s a s n ; a j a g s 1 1 o p o ; 6 u l q ; ; y 6 u a g ; a q P 1 n o m ( g l u m I ) p u e p a ; e l o a i d d e a q P 1 n o m ; e q ; g 6 n o i q ; ; u a m ; s n f 1 p u e n o 6 ; e g m p l o n e o ; a w M o l l e p u e I l e w e e q ; a w p j e n a i o ; o ; j a q r i s e o ; g 6 n o u a p u i N a q p i n o m n o b ; I - C e p o ; p u e 6 e p i a ; s a 6 ; 1 p a n l l a M ' d n 6 u w t ; s ; o e p e d e o s l ; l ; e g ; s e n s s l a y ; e a s n o k " l l e w a e m P G A 1 9 O G J a j l m m o b j a g a l a q ; ; o s l s a u a b a g ; ; n o p u g ; s n w l ; e q ; p u e ; s i a p u n n o g ( a d o g I ' a p l s e a n o g e a q l " e p u a 6 e A w u o a j a g m o u s l a s n o q j e g o s a 6 u g e j a d o j o 6 u l u m o ; e a d a i I " a n e q I a d o g I p u e : a s e a ; e p u l e s j n o 6 ; n d o ; p a ; u e m I a o u l s ' ; I p i p I ' ( a n e q ; o u p i n o g s 6 1 9 M ! i l g b n o q ; u a n a ) 6 u l g V U a n a n o b P 1 o ; a n e q I M o u ' I I a M - n o b B u m s } o u o g u a ; u l h u e ( p e g J a n a u p u e ) ; , u o p I a s n e o e q s s a l 6 u l u e e w s l u o l s s n o s l p a q ; ; n q ' ; o a l a o o ; o u s l s ; l n s m e l ; n o g e p i e s n o g ( ; e g M " o ; s u e l d o u a n e q p u e n o b a n s o ; ; u e m ; , u o p I ; e q ; p a m s s e a q ' a b e d a g ; 6 u l w n l a s n o q j a g o s e a o } A l i a d o i d s l a g ; ; o u o g l s l n b o e a g ; q ; l m u o l ; o a u u o o u l p a n n b u l ( a o l g o f w b u l p n p u l ) 1 A e s J a n a p i n o o l e q ; w e a l ; g d l n J u l a u o o u s l a a a g l I also am not too concerned about a lawsuit I believe that there is still a requirement in this countryfor a basis for bringing a suit Asking a simple question seem to satisfy that hurdle. Don't feel any obligation to reply again. F. Gordon Kraft —Original Message -- From: Marty O'Boyle <moboyle@commerce-grouo.com> To: Gordon Kraft <slotcordonQ)aol.com> Sent: Sun, Jun 15, 2014 12:18 pm Subject: RE: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream by Gordon Kraft Gordon — this "back and forth" is fun, but your paranoia is really quite sad. All I want is to protect the documents (electronic and otherwise) which you have re me and\or sober houses from spoliation. There is an obvious undertow which you clearly can't see or don't understand. As you have decided to carry the torch by spreading unfounded allegations, all I ask is to prevent the documents from spoliation, which I feel comfortable you will do. Incidentally, please don't feel sorry for me as I am the happiest guy you don't know. If I had a high desire to sue you, I would have a process server at your home in the am. Having said that, you need not worry, despite your paranoia, I have no present desire to sue you. If that changes, I will call you and try to sit and talk the issue (whatever that may be) out with you in an effort to avoid litigation. This is the normal way that I deal with things. Are you willing to share with me where you got the letter (and the other writings, if any) and the content of any conversations surrounding the issues at hand? I apologize for being brash with you, but your wild assertions are really intolerable. I also remind you- about who started these reckless assertions. Why don't you call me and come clean. If you do, I think things will end and I think you will see the light. If you don't and I hear your name as a person spreading rumors about me, this will not end pretty. I leave the decision up to you. Have a good day. Be careful! Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 -noA o; elgellene(sauoyd Ilao pue sauo;lsodaj aulluo'swa;sfs 6ulbess9w -aolon's;ue;slsse le;l6lp leuosiad'uoge;lwll;noy;lm'6ulpnloul) saalnap PUB elpaw Jay;o pue swansAs janndwoo jawlo; pue;uauno uo pejo;s uol;euuo;ul ay; sapnloui IgOnos uopeuuojul ayl •uoge6l;ll ain;n; ul Ajanooslp o; anlsuodsai Jo :amsoloslp on;oafgns eq Auw uopeuuo;ul ay;;ey; a;edp'que pinoys no k 0£04 g 4 japun asngy pue pnejd ja;nd woo jo uol;ewe;all uo; sw, 'o'S'n lelo 'elle ja;ul 'apnloul /yew swlelo y0lym („uoyewlojul. ayn) alAog,o Aq swlelo lei nuanod o;;uenala� aglew ao sl y0lym uogeuuo}ul 'uogglwll ;noynlm'6ulpnloul 'uopeuuo;ul pajons AIleoluoilosla pue s;uawnoop pue spooai lie 6ulpnloul 'slelol;}O sg Jo Ja6eueyq snl 'weaAs dlnJ;o umol ay; Rq 6l}oanpul jo Allowip jay;la nob 0; papinad (elgl6ugul jo algl6uen) spioow to s;uawnoop hue 6ulpnloul) s6ulyn algl6ue;'s;uswnoop PUB spjooaj lie amasaid no C;eyn puewap ulajay saop LBIA09,0.) a1409,0 uleW (MO138 (13NId30 SV) NOIIVWNOdNI d0 NOI1VAa3S3ad NOd ONWOCI •aswuay;o panus laijaq aie s;salap jno paulwia;ap llauajedde aney no (;nq ' lie; sAemle pinoo l pue noA '6uiu eu'joav }oeluoo lesunoo 1noA aney pinoys no,( 'lasunoo Sq pa4uasajdal aje no! p. 'asinoo jo -os op o; nof% affin 1 '(0 49£ OLS 496) lasunoo Cw jo aw noe}uoo o; yslm noR }l •aouelldwoo In;y;le; jno ( jo; aouenpe ul noR gluey; l -molaq aes aseald }}e -IN -IW uejN uopjo0 Aq weans;lno - sasnoH jegoS :3a :;oefgns we 40:9 b 40Z 'S 4 un(• 'ung :;ueS <woo na aojawwoo upm> Gula we1II1M:oo <woo-loe uopjo ;ols> ueiN uopJo0 :01 <woo ncu-aojawwoo al ogow>olAog,pL>,elN:wojd —96essaW leul6u0— jJwN uopJoO -d -uosiad pes /Gan a aq o; weas no! se'no6 jo; fajos laalAllen;oe I -6ulyyGana y;lm 6ulleap jo !em jno C aq o; swaas;eyl -s;lnsmel ue;eajy; o; paygs no(, ilnun aq pinom;I 6uol moy paiapuom I :allo8,0 •JW ueJN uopJoolq weang;in0 - sasnoH jagog :aa :;oafgng slAos O AIJeW :o I INV 9S:44 V40Z'SL aunr'(epunS quag woo•loe uopjo ;ols:o;llew geiN uopJo0 :wojd woo noi-eojawwoo•MMM :abed qaM woo noa-oojawwoo ajogow :view -:q 98tiE £6Z 699:1100 Information should be afforded the broadest possible definition and includes (by way of example and not as an exclusive list) Information electronically, magnetically and optically stored as: Digital communications (e.g., e-mail, voice mail, instant messaging); Word processed documents (e.g., Word or WordPerfect documents and drafts); Spreadsheets and tables (e.g., Excel or Lotus 123 worksheets); Accounting Application Data (e.g., QuickBooks, Money, Peachtree data files); Image and Facsimile Files (e.g., .PDF, .TIFF, .1 PG, .GIF images); Sound Recordings (e.g., .WAV and .MP3 files); • Video and Animation (e.g., .AVI and .MOV files); • Databases (e.g., MySgl, Oracle, Access, MS SQL Server, SAP); • Cellular Telephones, to include storage media (e.g., SD cards and micro SD cards) • Contact and Relationship Management Data (e.g., Outlook, ACT!); • Calendar and Diary Application Data (e.g., Outlook PST, Yahoo, blog tools); • Online Access Data (e.g., Temporary Internet Files, History, Cookies); • Presentations (e.g., PowerPoint, Corel Presentations) • Network Access and Server Activity Logs; • Project Management Application Data; • ComputerAided DesignlDrawing Files; and, • Back Up and Archival Files (e.g., Zip, RAR, TAR, GZ, GHO) Information resides not only In areas of electronic, magnetic and optical storage media reasonably accessible to you, but also in areas you may deem not reasonably accessible. You are obliged to preserve evidence from both these sources of Information, even if you do not anticipate producing such Information. The demand that you preserve both accessible and inaccessible Information that Is reasonable and necessary. Pursuant to amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure that have been approved by the United States Supreme Court, you must identify all sources of Information you decline to produce and demonstrate to the court why such sources are not reasonably accessible. For good cause shown, the court may then order production of the Information, even if it finds that it is not reasonably accessible. Accordingly, even Information that you deem reasonably inaccessible must bepreserved in the interim so as not to deprive a claimant of its or their right to secure the evidence or the Court of its right to adjudicate the issue. Preservation Requires Immediate Intervention You must act immediately to preserve potentially relevant Information Including, without limitation, Information with the earlier of a Created or Last Modified date on or after March 3, 2014: Adequate preservation of Information requires more than simply refraining from efforts to destroy or dispose of such evidence. You must also intervene to prevent loss due to routine operations and employ proper techniques and protocols suited to protection of Information. Be advised that sources of Information are altered and erased by continued use of your computers and other devices. 'ulelgo /Claletpawwt noR }eyl spew st puewap '(s)anup prey jalndwoo neyl uo uogoe luelsul ay} o} 6ututeuad uogeuuo;ul aney o} Ale)lq uosrad Jay)o yoea se pem se motaq paweu eqq go�ay} 6ulp�oy jo /lyoedeo ay} m 6utloe uosiad yoea;o pus motaq paweu suosiad ay} ;o yoea;o saotnap 862Jo}s pue sanup piey ay} o} }oadsai y}tM 'all} dems ay} pus aoeds Xoels 'coeds pa}eoolleun se seaie yons ul lspxa Am ley} elep lueoglu6lsAlleotsuajo; amesaid o} site; pus saiq alep pagoolun'angoe sam}deo Aluo }t esneoaq eBewt pagienb (ieotsuajo; a lou st anup pjey a;o do �loeq leuoguanuoo e }eyl pastnpe ag •anup ay};o auolo ao eBewl weajls ltq a paieo aq osle hew eleotldnp pagtlenb Alleotsuejol a Yong 'anup ay};o sioloas Ile jo a6ewl peyltenb /Cieotsuaio; e;o uogeoqumpne pus uot}eajo ay} Rq st sanup prey teoot uo e}ep Bugstxa }aa}oid O} Gem auo 'sanup pjey leool o} loadsai yttM •("!I ay} jo A4deiBoue6als'uolssaid woo 'uogdfume'sanup 6utoetdai jo 6w6ewt-aj'uoge4u9w6e4ap'suogeoidde 6uquAuQAO pue 6utppaiys elep 6utsn'salq Bugunvano jo 6ul;alep Aq se yons) sanup prey teool io vom}au uo aoueptna otuo43919 epty jo Aoqsep'Aplpow of 6uiNses woj; santyae pup swalsRs 'elep moA o} ssaooe yltm euoRue luanoid o} sdels angeuu!ge a�el ptnoys no k 6ut6ewl Aq uoieniasaJd •aoue.un000 slt lsumBe pien6 pus aledtogue a} pa6ggo eje lesunoo stay} pus uoneuuo;ul;o uelpolsno xue leyl spage tianoosip otuoiloate w /4ueln6aj yons yltm sm000 leyl }uana us Aldwts s,11 sjaa16o pus saa Coldwa moll jo no ( o} anbtun auo lou st weouoo slyl •uogeuuo;ul Aoqsap jo alatap osle Aew '6utop os ul 'pue 6wsseltegwa.to teguspquoo 'leuosiad se pieBei /Cayl uogewto;ut Aculsap jo a}ajap of Maas Am siesn ley} a}edtogue ptnoys noA Isuot}eotunwwoo leuosiad jo ssaooe lawalut jo; pasn uaeq aney saulyoew Auedwoo aiaym AllepaclsEl •suogoe yons lsule6e pten6 Jo luanaid of }oe pus uogewjo;ul jalte jo Xculsap 'apty of Maas Aew spay}o io siaoujo 'saallotdwe jno ( leyl aledtotlue ptnoys no k u099190 lsulebV pienE) •swei6oid uotssaidwoo jo uoge}usw6ei;ap atq jo anup 6ullnoex3 . 'pus :6u166o1 Vd l jo lamas butlgesl(3 . :se!ilgn.tadduls elepelaw 6utsn . :sauollsodaj 96eiols ouguo 6ut6ind io butseal" . :uol}elage elepe}aw alesaloym6wloaga swei6oid jaylo jo snnntlus 6uluun-t . :etpaw 10 saotnap 'sJanies'swa}sAs;o 6utsodstp jo 6ut6ewt-el'6utu6tsse-alt . :etpaw do Koeq Bulpieostp jo 6ul6oalsep 'Butseje 'But)tyvuanp . :saotnap jo satilnn uogdtioue jo amseia gesodstp '6utdtm etpaw jo e}ep Butsn . :eua}uo jaigo jo Altoedeo We Rq seuollsodai pew-a;o slualuoo ay} But6ind . :epnlow suageiado pus sain}ea; yons;o saldwex3 •uogetwo;ut;o ssot aylasneo o}alejado 'uolleiedo eugnoi ul 'leyl saotnap pus swelsRs uogeuuo;ul ino( ;o sainlea; puedsns jo Agpow pueAjquept Rtelelpawwt o) paloailp jayun; aie nok •ploy uoge6g11 yons yim aoueidwoo }ipne pus ainoes of ylte; pooh w pus AlluaBillp toe of pus "uogeuuo;ul ao; ploy uoge6tlg a aleglu! Claletpawwt of pe}oanp are noA uogonAsad augnoa;o uotsuadsng •aouapIna puena;aj Ap)eipualodiaypo pus s6u1y) 9pgr6ue) yuawnoop anjasajd o) uopeBi)go pua unauoo .moA gsygiwip o) poo)slapun aq ppnogs uggeuuoyu) po uoge vaseid lojpuewsp spq; w 6ui141oN uogewio;ut jo uogdwoo jo ssoi }uanaid of Atgtsuodsaj pus Qgua6lip toe of amlle; moA w64llnsai hew ainseia pus uogejelle ' puenbasuoo •83u8pin310 uoge!lods lrymetun a}nitlsuoo Aew pus suteluoo It 03UOPIAO ay} Ja}le 6Igen8tA9Lt itm uogeoidde Aue Butuum jo slusluw s}t Bututwexa 'anup a 6ug00g authenticate and preserve forensically qualified images of the hard drives in any computer system (including 'swels/s to slualuoo eyl anueseud )snw no!'eoy}o an wal Leme sluawnoop luenalai AIleguelod pamalnBJ Jo pelea D Jo spew -a luenalai 6llegua}od penlanaJ Jo }uas aney sae4oldwe jo sjegwaw pjeoq'sjeog}o }ey}}uaWe ay} of •e}ep }uenalaJ 411egua}od uleluoo Aow swelslfs algapod jo awoy Aue ll auluualop osle pinoys noA 'sianias PUB suoge)sliom aoglo uo e}ep aniasejd oll(lylms loe plm noC ley) loadxa em y6noyl sanuan uolleuuolul jey}o pue s}un000y sulluo 'sdo}de-1 'swa}stg awoH q! ssnoslp o} lleo aseald ')uelolllns se ldaooe 11lm am ley} auo sl ans�nd no/f poylaw uogetuesaid ay} jaylaym uogsanb noA;I •Lkke aulluo eq }snw jo paumop eq ueo ll jeylegm pue uogein6yuoo (31" sll '•6•a 'uodn 6ulpuadop jamas a to slualuoo ay} atuesaid o} sFem lejanas aje ejeyl -paniasaid aq pinoys }un000e llew a pue ajeys )pomlau sdasn yoea to s)ualuoo aleldwoo ayl '(„ajeys �pom}au„ s, asn a palleo ueuo) a6eiols Miom)au jo (oulwod snlo-1 'a6ueyoxg 790saollry'•6•a) flew oluanoole 96euew o} pasn asoyl atoll sJanias olloadsai qM siamas ' 'sPlag 00g pue gO 'a}ep penteoeb ')aafgns ' woj j 'ol ay} o} uolllppe ul 'elep }uawyoelle papooue yg ases pue e)ep 6ugna japeay pe sepnloul elepelaw 'pew olucupola jo j -uollewiolul amasaid of sdalsiadoudwl jo 6ullpuey sselaieo Aq paldrwoo jo uagumjano aq lew elepelew leyl paslnpe as •6ulluud pue uo-geajo}o salep pue elep uollnqulslp pue uogejogelloa'Aeluawwoo'a6en6uel geip'lueluoo palalep 6wpnloul'jesn a ol)uajedde aq loulew yolyminq se1g oluopale ul pappegwe jo papnioul Alleogewolne uogeuuolul sl elepelaw uolleapddy •ssaooe jo uogenglpow )sel pue uageaio to salep pue uolleool 'uelpo)sno'azls'aweu s,alg a 6ugoagai elep sapnloul ua}lo pue pill muouloole ue 6ul6euew to 6ul>loeil yum peleloosse Aiieold6l sl uogeuuolul sit] i•uoew1olul �ayo o sogsualoeimp pue olsly a6uquosap euolleuuolul sl elepelow walsds•ll anjsejd ol}oe pue elepelew uogeolldde PUB wals Is aonpoid pue asoloslp of peau ay} aledlollue jay}inl pinoys no k elepe)eyq alglssaooe Algeuoseaj jou uolleuuolul yons eNew of sl suolloe yons to )oaga ay}ll swjol pue elpaw elglssaooe ssal o} swjol pue elpow elglsseooe Illgeuoseei wwl uogeuuolul ulys leyl suogoe wail ulealej Alleuoplppe pinoys no k •uol}e6nll ayl ul AguepIgs uogewjolul ayl esn io ssaooe of awosuepmq jo llnogllp ll eNew jo sueaw olualoolo Cq uogeuuolul jnoA ywees of fllllge eyl epej6ap jo anowej Imp uopewiolul emosaid of spoglew loeles lou pinoys no C pue 'swiol anl)eu yons ul uopewjolul aniasejd pinoys no! 'Rl6wpio3oy •peulelulew Iqueu pyo sl ll yolym ul stwol jo uuol eyl ul }y6nos aq Illm uogewlolul wepao }eyl aledlollue pinoys no k uuoj anlleN ul uogeniasaJd •uoge�a)le }noyllm patuesaid aq pinoys a6ewl yons 4ae3 •peulelgo sem 11 yolym wall wnlpow PUB walsCs ayl pue 96ewl ayl 6ulimboe lggue jo uosied ayl'uoglslnboe to elep ayl Aj.quapl o} palegel aq pinoys a6ewl pagllenb Alleolsuejol yons yoeo'paulelgo aoup •jalndwoo yons yoea to alep pue awg walsls ayl 6uiNesaid pue 6ulpiooai se liam se 'Aepol o1460Z'£ yweyl wool poped ay} 6uunp uosied leyl Aq pasn (sjelndwoo awoy pue algelJod devices and media used for these purposes (including not only potentially relevant data from portable and home computers, but also from portable thumb drives, CD-R disks and the user's PDA, smart phone, voice mailbox or other forms of Information storage.). Similarly, if employees, officers or board members used online or browser- based email accounts or services (such as AOL, Gmall, Yahoo Mail or the like) to send or receive potentially relevant messages and attachments, the contents of these account mailboxes (including Sent, Deleted and Archived Message folders) should be preserved. ay; asoiosip Andwold •panuasaid aq o; eipaw ;o uogenrasaid punos llieoisuajo; 101 1000;ad ajge;deooe ue uodn aaj6e o; no C q;im 6ulNjom;o snonsap aje am sl000;ad uoi;eniesaid •sang pa}alap 6wploy ,'siajsnjo pa}eoopeun, papeo-os ay{ ui 6wpniow 'aouapina oiva}oela aq] 10 sued pe sanrasajd PUB aouapina a;epe;aw o; sa6ueyo }sutefie splen6 poy;aw uogenjasaid punos 1peoisuaJo; y •ieui6uo ay}}o a6ewi;iq-jo}-}iq aleldwoo pue oru} a se a;eaildnp ay;;o uopaoi;uay}ne }ioddns pue aouapina ay} o} se6ueyo ou a�iew;ey; spoq;aw pue sioo; 6uisn pue Apo;sno;o uieyo jadold a 6uiRoidwe eliym eipaw aouapina ay; uo paJo;s e;eplie ;o'uogenrasajd}osesodindjo;'uoi;eoiidnpueaw am „'punosAlleotsuejol, E] •ssol elep pue uogeiiods;o;eajy;}ueayiu6is e sasod spoy;aw yens esn o} oinked •spoy}aw uoi;emaseld uoi}ewjo;ui punos /peoisuejo} Aoldwa no (;ey} puewap am'saniip ay; jo seaie aigissaooe (iieoisuaJo} ui aouapina;uenaiaJ }o aouasaid ay; pue swa;sks aq) 10 ajow ro quo 10 uoi;euiwexa oisuejo;jo; peau ay} a;edioi;us am sy •ani;oaga }soo pue }uaipadxa si saoinap pue eipaw'swelsAs ay;3o 6ui6ewi punos lleoisuejo;;ey; sa;e;oip'pa;eoiidwi swa;sRs ;o jagwnu;sapow ay; y;im paidnoo 'pannbei uoi}enjaseid jo q;peelq ay;;ey; anailaq am'saoinap pue eipaw'swe}sCsia;senbas o; ieoi;oeidwi;i weep not}uana ay; ui da;s uoi;enjasaid ani;oa.4a }soo pue alapdadde ue aq lew way; 6upoeloid pue 6uiia;senbas Ifiiadad pue aoinles wa; saoinap pue eipaw 'swa;s (s uoi;euuo;ul asoy} 6uinowaU'p89 pofN pue gig poVV'L poVj o;;oadsai y}im'}ey;;sa66ns am 6uibewi punos 1peoisuejod to uoi;ej;senbaS wa}s6S •aoueiidwoo liay; amoes o} sda;s aigeuoseal aje;;snw no C pue 'os op o; uoi;e6iigo jnof;o }ua;xo lin} ay} o;uoi;ewjo;ui yons anuasaid o; uoi;ew1o;ui ;uenaiaj Allegualod }o uoissessod uilo;oeuuoojoueipo}sno'a@Aoldwe'A9ujoge';ua6ejawlo;jo}uaiino CueA;i;ou }snw noA'Al5uipj000y •10.4uoo jo uoi;oaiip inoA o; }oefgns si }eq; sjegio;o Rpo;sno ay; ut not;euuo;ui sapniow pue 1po;sno io uoissessod'ejeo jno f ui uoi;ewjo;ui puo6aq spueM uoi;e6ilgo uoi;eruesaid moA sal ped pliyl pue slfawopy's;ua6y •swjo; y;oq anjaseld pinoys nof,'swio} laded pue oiva;oaia y}oq ui s;sixa uogeuuo;ui bi •suolsJan pajo;s.ipeoluoj;oala 4o anpelnwno jo 'joj a;n;psgns a;enbape ue;ou ale.fay; 'e;epe;awjo f;iligeyojeas otuo-qoaja a vasajd;ou op saldoo prey sy a}enbapeui si uogeuuo;ui;o uogenjasajd jaded saoinap Aje;audad jo A02681 1aq;o pue sanup diz 'slapeai apoo ieq 'sanup ade; sapnloui siyl •pajo;s si uogeuuolul yoiym uo eipaw ;aidia;ut jo ssaooe o; papaau;i 'anup �sip jeoi;do ane�o 4� p�eiiue;s �o anup �isip Rddoi; „g•e piepue}s a uey; jay;o 'aJempJey pue sunup 'Builgeo Cue anrasaid }snw noA IS3 ay} ssaooe o} pannbei suoi}eoiidde io; slats asueoii pue sienuew jasn 's�sip uogepe;sui ay; y}im 6uole'suoi pa}dfioue ssooe opejinbaj sioei;uay;neu jay}o io sRaN 'spiomssed Rue amasaid ;snw noA •mill ay} jo sia;sol piomssed PUB aI jasn 's(aN uoi}einalgge 'swjoj Aj;ua a;ep 's;aays uogoru;sw 'speyo mog'sweibeip Niom;au 's;sil a14 'sf000}wd 6uiweu 'saoipw 'suogeoUjoads 's;aays Iafuoo 's601 6uipnpui 'uogeuuo}uiyo�eas Jo ;aidia;ui 'ssaooe o; paiinbei aq Iew ;ey; swa;i aiq!bue; jay;o pue s;uawnoop anresaid ;snw noA uoi;enJasaJd tiepiouy preservation protocol you intend to employ. A successful and compliant Information preservation effort requires expertise. If you do not currently have such expertise at your disposal, we urge you to engage the services of an expert in electronic evidence and computer forensics. Do Not Delay Preservation I'm available to discuss reasonable preservation steps; however, you should not defer preservation steps pending such discussions iflnformation may be lost or corrupted as a consequence of delay. Should your Failure to preserve potentially relevant evidence result in the corruption, loss or delay in production of evidence to which we will be entitled, such Failure would constitute Spoliation of Evidence, and we will not hesitate to seek sanctions. ,]GA IeL4 paweal IOU aney nog( ssan6 I uodn paplai aq louueo siededsmau woj; Noegpead :Sd •AGeluawwoo peg V •ssajp s,a;pm 10 sdeglow sly puigeq 6uipiy auo Aq pamollo; sl p lonpuoo Lions ' Sllensfl •Iiam no! emas ppm �iupyl l,uop I gopLim 'spew nOA uopspoep;ualedde uV •pooyp]uew }o (uo]updo Cw up) Noel mo (sl 19-16al lluo AN -Ilam no! Lispm I 'appse anoge aLi I •sluawalels Ieuopsnlap pue IeopylAw '1e316ew .inol, we jou 'esuodse.i;o Agpom lou pue Ieopsuesuou eje Aey;'saqulepp jnoA se jel sV •„sCem yloq s;no;,;p leLp 'asmoo;o '6upjagwawaa alnlp;sup o; eaj; eje noll asinoo to 'aw ;supe6e uoploe;o esneo a aney Cayl 109; asia euoAus to noA ;I •(smel ;o pue] a pue :Gail ay; ;o puel ayl) eouawV up sem 16upwow slgj do axiom I ueym ' llelueppoul •wayl a6pgo o; pualup I pue :ley; ldeooe I •, wnip umo (w to leaq ayl o; yojew, of l;al l;o;saq sem I lLi6noyl „MoIIo. ayl AlluejeddV umloale ayl upm lou ppp I 'mouN noA sV Z •ou bupsano w, 4„pony ay; dod,, 50A ueym s es japes aq;;eym no plo; ay sey;na •JayseJyl •MVV o; Jalla1 •oul 'dnojE) a0Jawwo0 ay; aney Alsnopngo noA •pawjo;wspw upwai no k :s6u!yl boys Z llej}I JW uejH uopioE) Cq weans 1lnJ - sesnoH jegoS :3U 3oelgnS ,pelN uapJoE), :ql• WV ZI:L ti; OZ'S; Gun(•' CepunS :;uaS al Sog,p (lyelnl :word woo no.l-ao.lawwoo•nnnnnn :abed qaM woo• na-aojawwoo al ogow :I!ew-3 9811£ £6Z L99 :1190 L080-09£Ib96 :xe-I 909E -0L91196 :1210 }oaJIG ZVti££ •I-� `4oea9 Pla!JJaea antra Jejueo }iodnnaN •M 08Z6 oul 'dnojE) eojewwoO 'GIA09.O •A u1�jen 'lpnAoadsaa PUB 919 PoW ' 4 PoW Pallgou aney nob leyl wipluoo osle aseald 81409 ,0 089 Pout o;;uenalaU AIlellualod sluewnoop elgp6uel pue uolleuuolul aniasajd of japan slyl up paupllno sdels ayl uaNel aney noA ley; '6;OZ 'El aunr'Aeppd uo •w•d oo:S Aq wwuuoo aseeld aouelldwoo to uopleuuguoo Martin E. O'Boyle, Commerce Group, Inc 1280 W. Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FI. 33442 Direct Dial: 954-570-3505 Fax: 954-360-0807 Cell: 561 213 3486 E-mail: moboyleta'Dcommerce-groun.com Web Page: www.commerce-cirouo.com From: Gordon Kraft fmailto:slotoordon a7.aol.coml Sent: Saturday, June 14, 2014 8:53 PM To: Marty O'Boyle Subject: Re: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream Mr. O'Boyle: I have no interest in talking to you. The "misinformation" you refer to is a copy of your letter to Mr. Thrasher. It appears to be a typical challenge from you for the Town to try and block your efforts to put sober houses in the community. As I understand it, sober houses are protected by federal law, so the town doesn't really have much basis to challenge your efforts. Several groups in Gulf Stream have made it clear that they do not feel they would be beneficial to property values, however, and might bring people with questionable character into our town. Apparentlysober houses can generate revenue for the people running them, and I can understand an outside interest moving forward without any regard for the citizens in the target community. When a resident of the town says he is going to do it, particularly one who was supposedly running for mayor to make the town a better place, it seems like vindictiveness and payback more than anything. I don't have to talk to you on the phone to have you explain your motivations. You say I have made allegations. This is really not the case. I am merely asking you why you feel obliged to do something thatthe majority of people in Gulf Stream don't want. If you just need the money, and don't really care what your neighbors think or want, then that is an answer. If you can not express yourself in an email, I'll just wait for feedback from the town and the Coastal Star. As far as that drivel about being a man, I wont bother to address it. F. Gordon Kraft —Original Message— From: Marty O'Boyle <mobovle(a�commerce-orouo com> To: Gordon Kraft <slotcordon(o aol.com> Sent: Sat, Jun 14, 2014 1:52 pm Subject: RE: Sober Houses - Gulf Stream Mr. Kraft — your email was not well received. ll2J)4 u0pJo0 •d 'Alaiaoulg umol 841 10 same Jay;o ul sonlen ulm of sliol;a rood puedxa p1noo noA egAew uayl'noA jol lno s�ljom leyl ll •le%jLw. ay; uo III;s sl ll puelsiepun 1 se 'sJnoA o; joop peau asnoy ay; ygm ljels no( l,uop Agm 'suogolppe snopen gllm palolule sienpinipul 6uldlag ui lsaaalul ogsingle ue aney lsnf no! 11 opolagi u6ledweo luaoal inoA to uol;olpej;uoo;oamp a aq o; sweas sl yl •umol a ul sanlen Apadad aonpai o; uanad uaaq sey yolym Joneapua ue aouenpe o; Maas mou noA'Allunwwoo weeilg lint ay; anoidwl o; uuogeld a 6ulsnodsa pue aowo sol 6uluunj jauy •noA;sule6e s6uam pamaoied iol umol ay; le Noeq;a6 of ldwalle jegloue Alajaw sl ll g6nogl se spunos ll os 'Aauow ay; paau noA anallaq;,ueo 1 'sig; 6ulop aie nolf Agm 6ulmouN ul polsajalul we I :alAog,O Jvq sasnOH jagog :;oafgng 9140G.0 Afjefnl :01 Nd 6Z:L YLOZ'VL aunr'Aepjn;eg :;uag woo-Ioe uopjo ;ois:olllew ge1N uopio0 :wojd woo' nog-aoaawwoo,7Fv—m :abed qaM woo no.l-aojawwoo al ogow :Ilew-3 99tic ELZ L99 :Ileo LO90-09S-t,56 :xe-1 905E-OL9-V96 :le1Q loam ZttEc 'I=1 Vea8 PlalPaaa anlaQ jalua0 jlodnnaN 'M 09ZL oul 'dno.l0 ao.iewwo0 `alf%0&0 '3 UIPEN ileo auoyd anoA lieme I 'Aguenbasuoo •uew a noA 6ullleo Apedoid we I adoLl I '4noA aie yotyM •suoge6ape poleguelsgnsun 8%ew pue silewa pulyaq lno eply s Asslg •senssl lualuoo ualnl '(peH uMol ay} wog} paleuewa awnsse I golgM) aw lsu1e6e suolle6alle palelluelsgnsun a%ew of palalwjad 'Janannoy 'lou aje no k •gslm noA owll Aue le aw yllm ll ssnoslp pue aw Ileo Aew noA •uew a a�li 10e pue uew a aq noA ley; 3ise I og 'noA of Aldde pinom bulAeg leyl '„avoid lsnw o6aile oym asoyl„ :slyl "!I 6ulylawos luem yolgm 6ulAes plo ue aw ly6nel jaylow ANl „ul noA peNons„ Alln)ss000ns aney Aayl sieedde 11 •molaq;uas aney noA se Ilewo ue allonoid of se Bons asodmd e•••(u6ledweo jeams leoplAw a jo lied a aq jo Bels ol) asodmd Lillm noA of u9nl6 seM uollewjolul-slw siyl awnsse I 'pawiolulslw Allealo ei,no.A Exhibit F splooag aql jo umpo;sn0 311910 umo1, 'llalaouts -pasolo laupm sag loptsuoo am 'no,� mo -g 31ouq n:aq om ssolufl -A11Eg1an uosiod m oppm glom s;sanbal asazg lanamoq'laual oq;1o; pailse ;uq; s;uacdtaal umoullmi moi s;sanbal splooal oggnd Z oslu wom alaq l slauoTss�mmo0 aq; o; palanzlop pupq pup (moloq paonpoldal) uopsanb m sap;al aq; o; pagoep;u sem omam aqZ ;sanbal mo i o; anisuodsal alp ;eq; s;uamnaop acp sapnlam goigm 'salzg pagouup aq; uado osuala •aauazuanuoo mojC 103 moloq paonpoidai sz aonapnodsomo s!U -tblOZ'Ll aunf pa;up llema moK mpa;sanbal splooal ollgnd aiD jo uoponpoid wasuodsal lln3 alpgp!m noX sopinoid;eq; liumo m o; pagouup sl laual sn [moo•dnoa-oolammoo@n splooal :oplzpm] al,Cog,O •g uplpyq 1uaQ -pazvuzwasszp svnt aa;lal payovuv ayl yozym of luvnsand 'suopvozummoo aazllo pun sl:vH-g Suzpnlouz 'spaooa i oilgnd llv fo `Cdov v apznoad asnald 065 HHJ MU [moo•dnoa-oolau uioo@splooal :o;llum] alAog,0 •g upzelnl blOZ'61 9unf 11pm9 pin palant1aQ VMO-I3'ALNnOD xDvag inlTVd WValU S J'TnD JO NAW L The Town's acknowledgement of the above Public Records Request dated June 17 2014 is reproduced in the space below: RECORDS REQUEST (the `at,q,,e) D<iaofRm---r 6117M4 �rv��ism=aBr_ 590 REQo=�. Custodian of Records Town of Gulf Stream REQr.nolt Martin E. O'Boyle REQD7SfOWS CONT.4CTL\FOPNL5MoX: E?.fac teeoic,nco Roup.com .r=934360.0507;Mir>>-: LSDWesiNatcoortCe=ierDri�Deec{e)dBea:h,FL 33442 R:QDsr: Please provide a copy of all public records including E -Mails and other communications Pursuant to which the attached letter was disseminated. kDDi.Z015"s LOZ�,L=IIO?7 P.EG.=_,D2iGP�.QLcST: THIS REQUES r TS HLIDEPUHSGi%Ir TO PUBLIC RECORDS ACT. CB'_•1PTER 119 OF THE FLORIDA STATUM AND IS ALSO REQLESTE) UNDER THE COMUONLAWRIGFIT TO INNOW1, THE COUMON ILAW RIGHT OF ACCESS; LND i\TSTATUTORFRIGHTTOKNOW (MCLUDMG,WIM0—iSLLAIII3 O-NA\'F STATUTORSrRIGHTOFACCESS,ASAPPLIC-- IBW. TMS REQUEST IS -ALSO AIADE PURSUANTTOTHE RIGHTS OFTHE REQUESTORPROYIDEDIN, THE FLORMA CONSTIFUTION. n'ISREO TS= T$ kI=FECORDSREOLESTBE FrriFnTFi .MCMC FOR3L IFNOTATSTr ART F'LNII.ECTRO�TCFO iLIIIS REOLESTEDTHATTHIS RECORDS REQUEST BE FUIFH-IZD ON 11 S 3 7 PAPER NOTE: LN ALL Ca S (UN=Ss VdPOSSIBLE) THE COPIES SHOULD BE TWO SIDED AND SHOULD BE BILLED LN .ACCORD 1NCE87THS nll967(4)()fD ALL= KRONIC COPIES ARE REQUESTED TO BE SE1I BYE hL1IL DELIIERT PLEASE PROIZDE THE APPROMLITE COSTS (IF AN7) TO Frr.Frr.r. IffiS PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST L\ ADVANCE. It rr$ be required Thar the Requestor approre of any costs, nsreHed by the Agency (w defined is Ftoridn Sainte. Chapter 119.01(Defmitiunc)), in adsance of wT ro;ts imposed to the Requestor by the Attocy. V- r FOPW Zbb££ varcoi3 •x3v3g alMAM3p •3AJV(i HaIMZ) 1Voal tq 153M 09Z LOQO'09C$96 Wa • Cl LL'OW$96 -M I wo3'dnor3•aaxawwoa•m rm . i;)EDO pue uopans;suoa xo; s;iwmd paimbai,Cue a n ata Pin sis;uawanotdun P I om cT; 'asmoa 30 ureaJ'S }InD }o nmol, atl; PIOT•i o; Pualul pinom am 'Al;uanbasuoo uolgse} dex ple Tn pxemxo} aeour o} not;ualul mo sl;, 4,OLP `noA pultuax I 'ute2y asnOH .iagoS a xo} UxBax3S irrio Til asnotl a asn o; Axessaoau axe slenoxdde io/pue s;tuuad ;etlm of se uoi;eueldxa tte -To °TIOP'euuguoo xnoA;Teme Alsnorxua I asno13 xagog a }o tasn atp xo} A;Iledloluntu atl; uioi} pamtbax gpmad xo slenoxdde ou aq pjnonn ax;)g4;egl tuxtdu00 o; xal;al Sup noA a;lxm i •q;lmcT;xo} ureagoxd sire }o uorle;uauraTdtul atp uTBoq o; pua;ul I •sasno13 xagoS se asn xo} uteax;S }Ino uT sosnoq o gnboe o; Auedtuoa a urxo} o; uolsloap a apeur aneq I •Ilam nOX spur; xa;;al sup adotl I xatTsextTZ --IN xeaQ ePPOIrI 'uxeaRS }Ino `(s)asnOH xagoS pasodoxd ;a -d xageuuw umoy'xagsexgL •H TUMMM :TSV £SKS Ila 'ureax;S }InJ PeOU eaS OOT ureax;S •TTno }o umo L 9TIS-9L3-T99# SMUHdH'IS,L x0•tue5x4s- agsexq;q "HVyI-S VIA S0SE-0LS-b96# auogdalay TMQ;oanQ tiOZ'9 aunt' moo' n-ao3ammo I ogom ( LIo io SC)2THm6moo William H. Thrasher, Town Manager June 6, 2014 Page 2 accountable for any damages which we incurred as a result of purposeful delays. Sincerely yours, COMMERCE GROUP{,, INC. Martin E. O'B�byle President cc: William F. Ring, Jr., Esquire — E-mail P/NPR/SOBERHOUSESGULFSTREAM wog na-a»awwo� £LLL-09E-VS61t MEW LOBO-09E-bS6# xej ETSE-OLS-bS6# le!a Pana ZVbE£ lj'yoeag pla!ljaa(3 anua Jaaua0 JjodmaN 3saM OUT •oul'dnoag a:)jawwo:) alAog,O'3 u!ueW 10 a3WO ;uels!ssV anl4max3 0assna •V epuajg J814al payoe:ne aas aseald i j 'weaas;ing'(s)asnoH jagos pasodoad Bu!pJEBaj Ia3391 alhog,0 :aoafgns alAog,O A4jeW :8u!y wegl!M :off jayseayl IN :ol WV Ob:6 VTOZ'90 aunf'Aeppj quaS woo na-aaawwoo I!assnjq:oal!ew passna epuaig:wojj iaysejyl IMI 's-4ueyl •sp.iooaj anoAjol s!ya 8ulpienvoj we I 'aldde;aams -jVM jpd•trT'90.90 jaysejyl we!!I!M :s;uawy3e44V lj 'weajis lln!D '(s)asnoH jagos pasodad 6u!pJe6aj a971al alAog,O :Mj :pafgng warmelaldde;aamspo aldde;aamsi :ol Wd SS:£ 6TOZ'TT aunf'AepsaupaM :Zuas <6jo•weajjs-jln6pujayseay3q> jaysejyl II!g :woaj al O9.0 eW INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE, TOWN MANAGER WILLIAM H. THRASHER DATE: June 9, 2014 TO: Mayor Morgan and Town Commissioners RE: Recent Communications from Mr. O'Boyle To help you stay informed of changing events that could affect the Town, I am attaching copies of two emails that I have recently received from Mr. O'Boyle. If you have any questions or comments about either of these emails, please call me at your convenience. �� l i q i q - x q INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE TOWN MANAGER WILLLAl14 H. THRASHER DATE: June 9, 2014 TO: Mayor Moran and Town Commissioners RE: Recent Communications from Mr. O'Boyle To help you stay informed of changing events that could affect the Town, I am attaching copies of two emails that I have recently received from Mr. O'Boyle. If you have any questions or comments about either of these emails, please call me at your convenience. H �iaiLiX� From: Bill Thrasher <bthrasher@gulf-stream.org> Sent: Wednesday, June 11, 2014 3:55 PM To: rsweetapple@sweetapplelaw.com Subject: FW: O'Boyle Letter regarding Proposed Sober House(s), Gulf Stream, FL Attachments: William Thrasher 06.06.14.pdf Mr. Sweetapple, I am forwarding this for your records. Thanks, Bill Thrasher From: Brenda Russell (mailto:brusselIPcommerce-erouo coml Sent: Friday, June 06, 2014 9:40 AM To: Bill Thrasher Cc: William Ring; Marty O'Boyle Subject: O'Boyle Letter regarding Proposed Sober House(s), Gulf Stream, FL Please see attached letter. .:ca�rget' "a Brenda A. Russell Executive Assistant Office of Martin E. O'Boyle Commerce Group, Inc. 1280 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Direct Dial #954-570-3513 Fax #954-360-0807 Main #954-360-7713 brussel]2commerce-erouo com