Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutMisc. Press Dippings et. al. M.O.B Folder/V Pair: Hasty, petty politics threatened dream home Small-town officials say couple wanted to skirt the rules. ByJane Musgrave Palm Beach Post Staff Writer WEST PALM BEACH — When JOEL ENGELHARDT/ THE PALM BEACH POST 2010 Richard and Marilyn Barfield's home In Jupiter Inlet Colony Is shown during a work stoppage on April 20, 2010, that the couple blamed on retaliation bytown commissioners. The attorney for former MayorJohn Zuccarelll III (left) said that the couple tried to build "on their own time, on their own term'." Marilyn Barfield (right) charged that Zd'ccarelll told the couple that"we would never move Into that house:' months, possibly more than a year, to mend their lives. As a result of what they call widespread corruption and ricanes Francis and Jeanne destroyed. Rather than help the Bar - fields rebuild as they had J torney told a Palm Beach County jury on Tuesday. Then -Mayor John Zuc- carelli III dispatched members of the tiny town's police force to spy on the couple, attor- ney Steven Katzman said. Workers, including roof- ers, drywall hangers and paving contractors, were chased off their property. Day laborers they hired were forced to register at town hall. 800 code violations Before their new house was finally completed in 2011, they had been is- sued more than 800 code violations and more than $100,000 in fines, he said. `Why dick they get all these violations? We believe it's because they ... spoke out: Steven Katzman Attorney for Richard and Marilyn Barfield "Why did they get all these violations?" Katzman asked jurors during opening state- ments in a trial in which he is expected to seek millions in damages. "We believe it's because they stood up and spoke out and were punished for doing so." Attorneys represent- ing Zuccarelli, two town commissioners and Po- lice Chief John Beneven- to disputed the notion that the Barfields were punished because Mari- lyn Barfield used her po- sition as a town commis- sioner as a bully pulpit to criticize long-standing town policies. "This case is not about free speech. It's not about unlawful search- es. It's not about dis- crimination," said at- torney Michael Burke, who represents Commis- sioner Douglas Pierson and current Mayor Dan- iel Comerford III. "The evidence will show they tried to bully and intim- idate folks in the town who were responsible for enforcing the rules of the rnnd whan it rnmcc to chief, also blasted the couple for trying to skirt town rules. The hurri- canes, he said, gave Bar- field, an emergency room doctor, and his wife, who worked as a nurse, an un- expected gift. "The Barfields saw this as an opportuni- ty to build their dream house," Oldehoffsaid of the grand two-story, 10,000 -square -foot home they built to replace their aging 5,000 -square ranch -style house. "They wanted to build their house on their own time, on their own terms." The level of animus be- lies the atmosphere of the neatly manicured 128 -acre community at the tip of Jupiter Island. It seems more likely to embody the character- istics of its most famous resident, the late croon- er Perry Como, who climbed to the top of the charts with such hits as "Some Enchanted Eve. ning." An enchanted life For 10 years, Mari- lyn Barfield testified, life on the island was en- chanted. "It was the most beautiful place I'd ever seen," said Barfield, who was raised in West Vir- ginia. An active town volun- teer, in 2003 she decid- ed to seek office. That was when, she said, she discovered cracks in the town's veneer — cracks she couldn't ignore. She questioned why the town moved its mon- ey into Independent Community Bank, where Zuccarelli was a 9.9 per- cent owner and Pierson owned stock. She pushed fellow commissioners to fix what she said were blocked or undersized drainage pipes, claiming they were contributing to flooding and silk holes. She criticized Pier- son for not putting an en- closure around his pool and Comerford, then a commissioner, for not trimming bushes that obstructed motorists' views. She questioned why the town charged so much for building per- mits. Zuccarelli, she said, told her it was to keep property taxes low. With each complaint, she said, her elected col- leagues got angrier and angrier. When the Bar - fields then needed the and her husband went to visit Zuccarelli to call a truce. "We decided to go and speak to him and tell him we were done complain- ing about the town," she said. "All we want to do is build our house and live in peace." Zuccarelli's response was swift: "He said we would never move into that house and we would never get a certificate of occupancy," she said. Police called vigilant Throughout her tes- timony, Zuccarelli and Pierson shook their heads as Barfield re- counted conversations she said she had with them. Oldehoff said Zucca- relli didn't sic the po- lice on the Barfields. Po- lice watch the 180 hous- es in the community con- stantly. And, he said, that includes being vigilant about code enforcement violations. They were particularly watchful of the Barfields because they appeared to be doing work without permits, he said. Work trucks and construction equipment littered the site and dust billowed from it, in violation of town rules. 'The evidence will show they tried to bully and intimidate folks in the town: Michael Burke Attorney for the mayor and a town commissioner The couple tried to avoid paying extra to ex- tend building permits when they expired, he said. They moved in be- fore construction was completed. They al- so low -balled the cost of the house to reduce the price of permits, which are based on construc- tion costs. Experts estimate they spent as much as $3.5 million to build their house while the Barfields said it cost $400,000, he said. "It really boils down to dntinel SunSentinel.com Sunday, January 27,2013 PC Serving as a Learning Ally BY MARLENE ROBERTS Special Correspondent Name: Lucy Chernow Brown Age: 66 Residence: Ocean Ridge Birthplace: Manhattan, N.Y. Family: Husband, Terry; daughters, Jessica and Alex- andra; granddaughters, Jo- sephine, 3, and Peaks Eve, 7 months Career: Circuit court judge, former trial attorney, assistant state attorney and state parole andprobation of. ficer Cause: Learning Ally, foundedinl948asanonprof. it organization named Re- cording for the Blind. Its ini- tial mission was to enable soldiers blinded in World War II to go to school and re-enter society. The organi- zation's name was changed to Learning Ally (Al -eye) to show its expanded mission in supporting people with a wide range of reading disa- bilities that include blind- ness, visual impairment, dys- lexia and other learning diffi- culties. The Boca Raton facil- ity has studios where volunteers create audio text- books and literature for '12, college and graduate • s, veterans and life- volun- of the sys- tem. I found it very re- warding. When the program moved out of Delray, I Lucy Chernow decided to Brown look at other vol- unteer opportunities. Q: Why did you choose this organization? A: The Lawyers for Liter- acy Committee of the Palm Beach County Bar Associa- tion had an open house for them that I attended. I knew I wanted to volunteer there. My mother gmduafiy lost her vision during her late 80s and early 90s. She was living in a retirement home where volunteers came in to read to the residents. The amount of joy she received by again en- joying the words from a book or a newspaper was tremen- dous. Q: Describe your vohm- teer role. A: I sit in a booth and monitor a computer as I try to read, with clarity and ex- pression, the written materi- al infront of fie.Thismustbe done exactly, without mis- takes. The reason is that what are "inconsequential" mistakes to many are very off-putting to dyslexics fol- lowingwordbyword. Q: How does this differ from your day job? b.AA As a judge: I'm always ing, weighing one Inst another. At things are cut and dry. There is a clear right way and a clear wrong way. Q: What challenges have you faced? A: When I volunteered, I decided to come once a week and work as seriously as I did in my other job. It was ini- tially difficult mastering the technology. Then I took on increasingly difficult materi- als. Explaining illustrations and graphs brought special challenges, even with pre- production workers helping me. Q: What have you ac- complished? A: I have helped make the lives of people like my mother better. Also, for my- self; there is something I find very satisfying, sitting in a booth alone and being able to self -direct myself in this work Q: What does your or- ganization need? A. More people to know that the Learning Ally exists and to use the many resourc- es it has. For more information, can 561-297-4444, email she- drick@LearningAllyorg, or visit www.leamingallyorg/ studio/boca-raton. Ifyou know a Palm Beach County resident who deserves recognition for volunteer work, fax the information to 954-4291207or e-mail to robertsbanet@gmail.com. Nominations should include volunteer's name, city of residence, a contact name and phone number, and a brief description ofwhy this person deserves special recognition. o-XvraCP ,tbPir don B5 REAM JNER'S like d part rotest lints satirical )n side of his Julf Stream. hardt )st Staff Writer M— With "com- iug" emblazoned nx Klan -like hood if his million-dol- rtt home, Marty thrust his dispute n into the pub- vho in 2011 flew r downtown West to proclaim his it with then -State :hael McAuliffe, is its home, valued oses at $1.6 mil- essages aimed at nmission after it request to add a 7feature. - Tued on 135 Here e drove ice said. for - call tive -2160, at 177). :)m lam kthe Is look- dar ex- ig to similar nt to you've ave e their lemic let that vork, nd have lion of i her re - )y ac - 3 has ar for all the 'qe- 1, the ed by :epting ontrac- s $6 mil- have its football roup later !ft. FAU al - elf from a ,or nation- question - nal web - e Sandy vertook n the way t authori- in's news ribed." eom post 200 percent of the fed- eral poverty level. This ssinger@pbpost.com Twitter: @StaceySinger TELCO T GULF dl•' 0. } � a A� ■! : in u. Marty O'Boyle painted this protest message on the side of his Hidden Harbour Drive home that faces the Intracoastal Waterway In Gulf Stream. BILL ENGRAM /THE PALM BEACH POST Decision agitates owner O'Boyle continued from BI The view of his home from the Intracoastal Wa- terway is now dominat- ed by a red banner pro- claiming"Welcome to Gulfstream." Above it is the hood, labeled "This is a satire" and "Stop the oppression." Across the doors of his three -car gd- rage are the colors of the rainbow flag. The mes- sage to be superimposed over the garage doors re- mains a work in progress, O'BoyIB said. O'Boyle said he was making changes to his home because he be- lieves that the town com- mission was imposing its architectural taste on him. The commission voted 3-2 on March 15 to reject three of four vari- ances needed to build the entry tower. "Right now, my house is an.ugly duckling," O'Boyle said. "There are things that I want to say that I would never do on a nice house. I offered the town up a nice house. I said to them, you could have this, or I will do it in a different way according to the laws of the United States of America." Town Manager Wil- liam Thrasher had no comment. Commissioner Robert Ganger, who vot- ed in favor of O'Boyle's proposal, said the home, built in 1983, doesn't con- form to current code, a common problem -in Gulf Stream. "It came down to a close call and he lost." O'Boyle filed suit Mon- day, seeking a judicial panel's review. One is- sue is the height of a fea- ture on the addition. The town calls it an eave and says it is 2.5 fee too high; O'Boyle says itis a cor- nice and does not have to comply with a code limit. Additional issues involve the height of the roof And the entryway's distance from the property line. Mayor Joan Orthwein said at the March 15 hear- ing: "I have a problem with the massiveness of the entryway." She feared approval would set a bad precedent. O'Boyle has filed more than 1,300 public records requests with the state at- torneys in Palm Beach County and the Treasure Coast in the appeal of his daughter's 2011 DUI con- viction. He also has been pursuing public infor- mation in Gulf Stream, the tony south county oceanside town of 786. In February and March, he made about 50 record re- quests. He has received some but is disputing costs sought by the town. In 2011, after failing to secure a ineeting with McAuliffe to discuss his daughter's case, he flew banners and teamed with Dave Aronberg, then a potential state attorney candidate, to stage pro- tests and run advertise- ments critical of McAu- liffe. Aronberg won elec- tion to state attorney in November 2012 after McAuliffe resigned before completing his term to take a private -sector job. lengelhardt@pbpost..com Twitter: @JoelEpbpost co m ti m m� d m ° a a m N a O--� ? = O a �n N �n to In N O ��� 3 i n cr rt y rr 3 G ffi A Sfa a O" -O Ttort Da C tNp Z3 CD ti�Ct) WQ VTNVp�N Ow f a < wO r _ O'aca 5 me m � d Fb an 7.-,= 3'pya CA om nN� -.w..:m 5 0 �m N cc1 OWNm� 'y�j.7 m�mm oO O C -0 C x00,5 �y'�F°c°�m�c (A n CLW p Ob =NC)= AM. S ^ • tidwu�7 `SyyO^aO.Ba' `v 4�n��0 ¢biN - n F _ hyo- Aw<Eon" o. o O ti^ g° G) D d w Oc)=. Sn r'a c -90o c�n0om0 ©mm0l T m wy��n o a3.*F Oa m ony Aa -sj ~ 1 C r7o y' n o, M y o DQ w ,c°,1 T D 9 bo�'� Ooo� W Q b " 3 � M. w ,C 5 a D�a_.00vtro aOm= 0 a m n ��f3w'�Ma+°�3m0C 2 O N m O M ZrN N OO. D m pDi.D�� 1� A ao n n � n .F° 6 o w Z) j° 0 �� c JL.Sa Ortn cr m N Z r m���aam ��°ao� 1 r x 13 Cl M= ° mvm m �. 0 °.N oN �m as '0 '- n x < CL m m o 3 Q I�r • /T 7 CL ^ n i y h� ` Li� u y W e ❑ nri w �ni n O �� y W y 0 f N R O b C n y Aronberg continued from Al Post that documented Aronberg's involvement, including in O'Boyle's hiring of actors to pro- test McAuliffe's decision in a death penalty case, while Aronberg worked as a special prosecutor for the state attorney gen- eral. The ethics commis- sion did not consider and the complaint did not ask whether Aronberg violat- ed office policy or state law by conducting per- sonal business on state time. Viewed as partners While the complaints were submitted by Shawn Hanlon, a Palm Beach Gardens resident with no political background, Aronberg's Republican opponent, Dina Keev- er, insisted she had no in- volvement in them. Philip Claypool, specia advocate for the ethics commission, summed up the relationship between Aronberg and O'Boyle as partners rather than as a donor and beneficiary, describing their actions as a joint venture. ,,is that a gift from on venture to the other, when they have a similar goal?" Claypool wrote. He found no probable cause to support any of the allegations made by Hanlon. O'Boyle, who hired planes to fly banners cr ical of McAuliffe over downtown, told inves- tigators he would have continued his strikes e it- WORLD against McAuliffe even t without Aronberg's help, Claypool wrote. t O'Boyle, who has mounted a series of pub- lic records requests and Aron - lawsuits against berg, took a big step back Wednesday, saying he agreed with Claypool's findings. While he and Aronberg have had their , differences, O'Boyle said, he hopes the two can be 1 friends again. In spelling out details of their relationship in 2012, O'Boyle told The Post that he believed, if elected, Aronberg would have helped make a mis- demeanor DUI convic- tion against his daughter go away. On Wednesday, he said that during their covert campaign against McAuliffe, Aronberg ac- tually counseled caution. The banner -towing planes, for example, might garner sympathy 1 for McAuliffe, O'Boyle said Aronberg told him. "I have a tendency to perhaps punch, where Dave is not a puncher. I think he took a much classier approach than what I would have tak- en," O'Boyle said. McAuliffe announced in January 2012 that he would not be seeking a second term as state at- torney and resigned soon afterward for a private sector job. Aronberg won easily that November. Reached by phone Wednesday, Aronberg said he was glad to put the matter behind him. "This was a frivo- YOUR WORLD X THE PALM BEACH POST REAL NEWS STARTS HER have a endency o perhaps punch, where Dave is not a puncher.' Marty O'Boyle Michael McAuliffe critic ous, politically motivat- ed campaign stunt filed on the eve of the election by my opponent's cam- paign knowing it would be dismissed much lat- er," Aronberg said. "For- tunately,the voters spoke loud and clear that this type of dirty politics would not be tolerated, and now the ethics com- mission, by dismissing the entire complaint in a Jiiatter of seconds last week, essentially said the same thing." Flight reimbursement One question left un- answered is the issue of Aronberg's reimburse. ment to O'Boyle for a private jet ride to Talla- hassee. Aronberg said he sent O'Boyle a check for $550 a month after the trip, as required by state gift laws. O'Boyle told The Post he never received the check. Af- ter the newspaper asked about it in May 2012, Aronberg sent what he said was a second check Claypool said thereat ways will be some dorl6i about the first check because it was never cashed, but there was n evidence that Aronberg never sent it. Claypool added that the evidence showed that throughout most of Aron - berg's interaction with O'Boyle, Aronberg had not yet made a final de- cision as to whether he would run — a finding O'Boyle corroborated. Aronberg's lawyer, Bar- ry Richard, submitted af- fidavits from seven Aron - berg confidants, includ- ing current aide Mike Edmondson and depu- ty Alan Johnson, all say- ing that Aronberg did not make up his mind to run until Jan. 17, the day McAuliffe dropped out. Campaign worker Mi- chael Worley said even when Aronberg asked him to prepare a Face - book ad attacking McAu- liffe, which ran before Jan17, "Mr. Aronberg re- mained undecided as to whether he would run." If he wasn't a candi- date, he couldn't have vi- olated campaign gift law, Claypool found. With the ethics com- plaint dismissed, a con- trite O'Boyle on Wednes- day said he hopes he and Aronberg can reconcile. ,if I had to do it over again I would have done things differently. I sort of blew it by not listen- ing to him," O'Boyle said. "Had I handled things an- other way our relation- ship would be much bet- ter, and I would be very proud to be his friend." Staff writer Joel Engelhardt contributed to this story. dduret@pbpost.com Februar Saturda; 10am-5F Free Adn Located or across Atla Downtown For more in call 561-74 V I L a mn , n'CO�mrCo�7m °�"� 0 O ntd°�»w"9.»n �` y on C. Or^�n a w O 0aOr °n Ow v Q �D tD .Vi En carr- °•O� n07q r°p n� N fdD w'n+��`�?•n o 00z�•w Oro C� O Or C.w.r t,°O 1214O W Sim C° '�7yy. c.. rp ro m.C,� rptiy^co ,a mp ^n°i r^o n'�nyrp oCdOry y dN y by .'7 �•m O m . m w •� y m .;. n^ rp 7C 7^^r"p pE'rnp p� m :ey70050 °.". dAraa� 0.b•dG0~a �O Mf O p ryp M rD W vi ?'O n tCi y 00Cn n ^K `w+•°•nCC�Cmw �, S•P C w � C,� p•n0� JC. `.y i'O a°y rD m .61 to ;n w�omrp °1 y 0o S a0 =n o G.� O m ry y� 0 C O y �• fp y Q, O ?• N O aC aq r6 ti � y'• ... ?_ � O y�'°S��C O] ^w K°www m'd5m=O'm xm w' .tea :rO �a�°gnt°w^ ?•o n°o-tD'n'O� dao wr�o9ryp �manti7a�vO�nNo �ry or"p 7C.m o�p' cn cyan O N07N 707 fw^D a9rw^p rw1 ° CD rCD O:: Cne,rt 009:: 9E �•yn�7 �w^O.Tm Orwnw?'pni� ,Oy G. fyp R C f]D G N 00 1 0 0.0 r<p G w wr ° -I`m' CL n 7Hd n ^ T A m C d wCN to F m^Oy m� ne a a» w c D o aaO c _ ^ n o �. c m@ ryry; rp rp Y�w?df• ld T C .Q Q °.o .G 7 m N N tp O n m°m OCew 07 w d0 w BEACHPOSTR E s 2012 poll 40 percent :s favored �wntown -ed to referen- endered banning 'ed in Ju - he effort the which de- duable :eived. one in ks with •s re- val- Ilion, the de - a Clough ory. com THE PALM BEACH POST REAL NEWS STARTS HERE I SATURDAY, JUNE 14,2014 B5 Banners flying over 41city t attach law firm Developer won't say if he's behind signs against Jones Foster. ByJane Musgrave Palm Beach Post Staff Writer WEST PALM BEACH — Ban- nerman is back. For the last week, air- planes toting signs that blast the Jones Foster law firm have been flying up and down the Intracoast- al Waterway over down- town. The banners are rem- iniscent of a campaign Gulf Stream millionaire Marty O'Boyle launched against then -Palm Beach County state Attorney Michael McAuliffe three years ago. For weeks, after O'Boyle's daughter was convicted of drunken driving, planes flew over the county courthouse trailing banners, calling prosecutors "thugs" and "dishonest" and accusing them of embracing tyr- anny. The signs that have filled the skies in recent days seem to be signature O'Boyle. However, the 62 -year- old commercial real es- tate developer from New Jersey was coy when asked about them on Fri- day. My work is much bet- edule a an item goes on a ballot, t a cost said, "That function is an it more operation of the munici- aold pal clerk." 1 March The municipal clerk, asked by the political es committee, checked slid for with City Attorney Max ag- Lohman and respond- ed: "That responsibility Su- is with the supervisor of re elections." tHl HQ rinhnnst rom An plane above the Intracoastal Waterway off downtown West Palm Beach pulls a sign with comments directed toward a law firm. BRUCE R. SENNETT /THE PALM BEACH POST ter than that," he said when asked whether he was behind the latest sign that read: "Jones Fos- ter Your Bills Make Me Puke." One earlier this week asked: "Has Jones Foster Embraced a Bad Apple"? But, O'Boyle didn't ex- pressly denyinvolve- ment. "If I said to you it was not mine or it was mine, what difference would it make?" Still, in the same con- versation, the unsuccess- ful candidate for town commission questioned the amount the law firm has been paid to repre- sent the tiny, uCale is- land town northeast of Delray Beach. O'Boyle, who has sued Gulf Stream repeatedly and papered it and oth- er government agencies with public records re- quests, said he recent- ly asked the town how much Gulf Stream has paid the firm during the last year. Records, he said, showed the town paid between February 2013 and February 2014 — an amount O'Boyle said is too much. Jones Foster, which traces its roots to 1909 and counts former U.S. Rep. HarryJohnston as a member, replied to ques- tions with a statement: "The perpetrator of the banner humor is not and never has been a client of our firm. "Rather, we have good reason to believe that he is a litigant in several cases we are defending, who, rather than relying on the merits of his case and the judicial system, has elected to harass our firm." Last year, the town set- tled a building code dis- pute with O'Boyle by pay- ing him $180,000 and is- suing a public apology. O'Boyle gained attention after he mocked town of- ficials with murals, in- cluding a Ku Klux Klan - like hooded figure, on the side of his $1.6 million Gulf Stream waterfront home. wtz yk1 3 r z 7 Or m 0 5'`�' S•,� a 5 2d•�'� � gib; b a. a M 0 n a x w 1 x° cnx m C) H z z M 1 0 H ox Sl zm m z C) m m o m cn , V T CIi W W o� C ° a C m 0 dJ L m n -i H z v 0 0 C3 C: n m 7 a T7 7 D 0 0 ) ) -1 di Gras - ""'- •� _ i nival season, which ends di Gras like 'we do." dorprobleieP0 edn0- therth.rna_ /..._ .,T,,�'gave to Aronberg, McAuliffe Pugliese continued from Al haw unction in Osceola County. Pugliese, 65, and Reamer, 54, turned them- selves in to Palm Beach County Sheriff's Of- fice deputies days be- fore Dave Aronberg was elected state attorney. By, then, not only had Pug- liese donated money to Are nberg's campaign but he also once retained as his lawyer Barry Krisch- er - the former state at- torney, a chief Aronberg supporter and a volun- teer adviser to the top prosecutor. Shortly after his elec- tion, Aronberg said he would give Pugliese's donation to charity but keep the case. Last month; however, one of his chief assistants asked Gov. Rick Scott to as- sign another office to the case. Last week, Scott's legal office assigned the case to prosecutors from the 20th Judicial Circuit, afive-countyjurisdic- tion that covers the Tam- pa area. "It is my opinion that it would serve everyone's interests to have anoth- er prosecutor assigned to this case," Chief Assistant State Attorney Brian Fer- nandes wrote in a Janu- ary letter to Scott's office. Fernandes' letter of- fered only a hint of the political power Pugliese held by the time investi- gators brought the charg- es against him. Pugliese was then one of only a handful on non -attorney members of the 15th Cir- cuit's Judicial Nominating Commission, responsible for interviewing candi- dates forjudgeshipsand recommending appoint- ments to the governor. He resigned from that position shortly after his arrest, but it is likely that Scott would have sus- pended him anyway. Campaign finance re- cords show he contribut- ed to local and state polit- ical campaigns, including races for Aronberg and his predecessor, former State Attorney Michael McAuliffe. In 2008 - the same year he supported McAu- liffe for state attorney - Pugliese also donated $500 to Sheriff Ric Brad- shaw's re-election cam- paign, and gave the same to Republicans Adam Hasner and Mike Horner for their state House cam- paigns. Pugliese support- ed former Florida Gov. Charlie Crist and state Rep. Randy Johnson two years earlier. He also con- tributed to former Attor- ney General Bill McCol- lum's 2010 gubernatorial campaign, although Gov. Rick Scott beat McCollum in the GOP primary. Nationally, Pugliese contributed to both of President George W. Bush's campaigns and, more recently, donat- ed $2,500 to Newt Gin- grich's failed quest to se- cure the 2012 Republi- can presidential nomina- tion. Pugliese has donat- ed to the campaigns of Congressmen Allen West, Robert Wexler and Bill Posey, former Sen. Mel Martinez.and others. McAuliffe by last sum- mer had left office for a job in the private sec- tor, but inv@stigators in his. office were looking at whether to arrest Pug- liese, who in 2010 depo- sitions for a related law- suit admitted creating the AIR,DUCT CLEANING Aiming For A Cleaner, Healthier Environment Gelling Sick, Stuffy, Suffer ham Allergies or Asthma? Hoes your Home Have on Odor or is it Dus^�' PRE I F x fictitious companies to si- phon off DeLuca's cash. He said he did it to cre- ate a cash reserve in case DeLuca pulled out of the project. But investigators linked the rerouted cash to Pugliese's own lav- ish expenses, including a mammoth home stereo system and an $11,000 moat chiller to cool the water surrounding his Gulf Stream mansion for the fish swimming in it. DeLuca's lawyers com- plained in the civil case that Pugliese wasn't afraid to show them he had powerful friends when he thought he was in jeopardy of landing in criminal trouble. He came to interviews in the lawsuit last year sur- rounded by a cadre of le- gal heavyweights - in- cluding Krischer and for- mer Attorney General Bob Butterworth. DeLu- ca's lawyers demanded all of them enter formal notices of appearance as his lawyer if they were on his team. When asked about his connection to Pugliese in October, Krischer de- clined to respond, refer- ring all calls to Jack Gold- berger, another membL-r of Pugliese's deep roster of lawyers. Fernandes did not mention Krischer by name but offered as his first reason for withdraw- al that Pugliese "once re- tained for counsel a vol-. unteer for this office who consults on executive is- sues" - an exact descrip- tion of Krischer's involve- ment with Aronberg's ad- ministration. And, accotdin& to Fer- nandes' letter, there was more to Pugliese's fh�1tp- port of Aronberg than the $500 donation. He also served on a host commit- tee for an Aronberg cam- paign fundraiser. Fer- nandes did not speci- fy the fundraiser, but re- cords show that a March event for Aronberg was held at a building Pug- liese leased to a local law office. State attorney's of- fice spokesman Mike Ed- mondson declined Friday to comment on the case beyond the letter's con- tents. "We wouldn't want to say anything that would create any problem" for the new prosecutors, Ed- mondson said. McAuliffe was out of of- fice by the time of Pug- liese's arrest. Gov. Scott appointed Peter Antonac- ci interim state attor- ney. Butterworth was An- tonacci's old boss. Antonacci is now Gov. Scott's general coun- sel. His office handles re- quests like the one Fer- nandes made. Reached by phone last week, An- tonacci confirmed the governor had assigned the case to the Tampa circuit. He said such re- quests from prosecutors' offices around the state are routine. "Usually they cite a conflict of interest, but there are a hundred oth- er reasons," Antonac- ci said. "It's not at all un- common." Pugliese attorney Doug Duncan said Friday he re- spected Aronberg's de- cision and was glad the case had been reassigned so that his team could be- gin receiving evidence prosecutors plan to use and preparing their de- fense. "Mr. Pugliese has en- tered his plea of not guilty and is looking for- ward to having his day in court where ALL the facts and circumstances will be fully presented," Dun- can said in an email. dduret@pbpost.com Erectile Dysfunction Drugs May Be Dangerous To Your Health FREE book by doctor reveals what the Brun rmmnanioc rinn't want vmr to knnwl NEW E) go con - .^ year, on a 2 -year Continued on page 5 e Elie e Funding toP trolleys was provided through a�Florida Jim Knight: BUILDING NEW PATHS By Jamie Solen The Pineapple Staff Writer "Be the elwnge that you wish to see in the worldy." — Mahatma t came of A native of South Florida and raised in Boca Raton, J'Knight age in the decade following the civil rights act. In a time when the country was just beginning to experience the effect of desegregation, Knight not only bared witness to the social struggle for equality, but also was a participant through the infamous'desegregation busing' initiative, landing him at Spady Elementary as one of the only whites in the school. After an early rience d the ria young justiblack atsnrr undedhimnd ostracized aanc local annual fair, Kt e e tb the influence of thate would set the tone for a life long dedication t[ dismantling the color barn er in his beloved South Flor da co1r coon ty. Lucky for Delray Beach, Knight landed here when he started his owl ment commercial real of the elite group of early Delray Beach commin 1991. As Pal e compunity ]eade s�1�r Knight usedbot his vocation in commercial real estate and his devotion to volunteerism t bring him closer to his ultimate dream for the area— the fair and rnulucultur community he knew in Jus heart that Delray Beach was meant to be. As a board member of the Deplan Approval Boar roe the Delray Beach ST COVERAGE PROSECUTION CONFLICT Developer's case moved ti overstate attorney es Fraud trial of politically connected builder goes to Tampa prosecutors. By Daphne Ducat Palm Beach Post Staff Writer A powerful Delray Beach developer once tasked with helping appoint local judg- es also has ties so close to the Palm Beach County State At- torney's Office that it is back- ing away from handling his prosecution for allegedly cheating a sandwich mogul out of more than $i million. Anthony Pugliese and his business manager, Joseph Reamer, are fighting charges Prosecution of developer Anthony Pugliese (left) has been relinquished by the office of state Attorney Dave Aronberg. with Reamer's help, creat- ed fake companies and phony invoices to steal $1.2 million from Subway founder Fred DeLuca. DeLuca at the time was working with Pugliese on fnilprimn million, 9satellites may hamper TO[ e�a, tle- ep- esi- :ray- lor- mg- ten POSTCOVERAGE THE,DESTINY CASE Developer Pugliese charged with fraud Alleged scheme aimed to con Subway founder out of $1.2 million. By Daphne Duret Palm Beach Post Staff Writer For years, big-time Del- ray Beach developer Anthony Pugliese padded his pockets with Subway mogul Fred De. Luca's money, investigators say — creating fake companies and phony invoices to bilk De- Luca out of nearly $1.2 million that was supposed to be going toward a 41,000 -acre "green" community planned south of Orlando. Pugliese, whose empire in 2008 was crumbling with Anthony Pugllese bought land forthe Destiny development In 2005 with Fred DeLuca. the collapse of the real estate market, allegedly used the money to subsidize his lavish tastes — spending $150,000 on a home sound system, and $11,000 on a chilling machine to cool the waters of a moat surrounding his Gulf Stream mansion. On Friday, Pugliese, 65, and his business manager, Pugliese continued on A13 s of anti-Obama billboards ster their disap- he ..., ...I ". .. ­. ------ - - LLIN' ATTHE MOAT tlgators say Anthony Pugliese stole money meant e Destiny project to pay for personal expenses. ,189 for a moat chilling machine — Pugliese and nployee reportedly traded emalls regarding a Invoice from Roman Construction Company Inc. yfor the machine used to cool the waters in noat surrounding his mansion so the fish inside dn't die. 3,524 for a high-end audlo/video system — Pug - paid Auman and Associates owner Kris Au - In three payments between November 2008 ianuary 2009 to Install a high-end system in his e. Auman also received money for work he said d on a piece of defective equipment at Pug- 's office. Auman received a total of $160,211. 3,587 for"Bush Hog" payments — Employees i Green Edge Inc., a landscaping company, said provided lawn services for Pugllese at his home cean Boulevard in Gulf Stream, as well as his erty at the Carnival Flea Market in Delray Beach. ough the Invoices reflected payments for work a with a Bush Hog, a land -clearing rotary cutter I to cut through thick brush, Green Edge employ - said they never owned such a machine. ,100 fora Zen house— Erik Wasko, owner of ko Carpentry, said Pugliese paid him to build the cture at his house. Wasko said he also did work ie home of Pugliese's son, Pugliese's ex-wife Pugliese's storage facility. In total, he. received 571. re: Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office t, was unaware that restment money !ing secreted away. gliese and Ream - aim that they werb 2d in stealing, for trposes of creat- eserve account is ext and not a legal cation for theft," igator Robert Sus wrote in the ar- !port. ording to investiga- ad records from the it surrounding the ly project, Pugliese eLuca met in March through a mutual late. Pugliese need- mey for Destiny, I was supposed to signature project. ca stepped forward rivate investor. >ugust 2005, Pug - and DeLuca bought aehaw Junction arty through the Company of Osceo- inty, a company 'ormed together. the $111 million Re- invested in the proj- ccording to court ds, about $6 million et aside for expens- ated to the prop - years. At one point, in August 2007, according to re- cords from the civil case, DeLuca refused to give Pugliese another dime until he provided budgets to show where the money was going. Pugliese in his deposition said he even- tually complied, albeit at times incredulously. "And in a lot of cas- es we almost had a laugh that someone, you know, in the sandwich business is asking for a 20 -year projection on a land deal," Pugliese said. "It's like, 'What are we doing here?"' DeLuca started pay- ing project expenses in 2008 and continued pay- ing until the partnership fell apart in early 2009. All the while, investiga- tors said, Pugliese was si- phoning off money to ac- counts Reamer creat- ed for fake businesses. A search of some of the en- tities later revealed the addresses were fake, and the primary agent listed on the companies in ma- ny cases was Pugliese's sister, Kim Caruso. ---- A:- -A— rf a fake invoice to sub- . idize an $11,000 moat :hiller for waters sur- •ounding Pugliese's ex- )ansive home. The too - warm waters were caus- ng the fish inside to die., Investigators linked he moat chiller payment :o an invoice created on )ehalf of a construction -ompany linked to Pug- liese, billed for work on the Destiny project that was never performed. Pugliese, in an interview for the lawsuit, admitted making up companies to take DeLuca's money. In one instance he said he picked "ARUP" as the name for a fictitious com- pany because the name resembled the name of a legitimate company that,. had done work on the project. Pugliese also talked about having his son cre- ate a fictitious logo for another fake company, billing for work that was never performed. investigators also in- terviewed employees from several legitimate companies whose invoic- es Pugliese gave to DeLu- ca to pay for project -re- lated expenses. In several cases, the employees told investigators they nev- er worked on the project, and the expenses were related to work they did for Pugliese at his home or at one of his several businesses. Pugliese and Reamer were released from the county jail Friday eve- ning after posting bond amounts of $3,000 to $15,000 for each of the 19 counts on which each man was charged. Pugliese in recent months has been de- scribed as a philanthro- pist, both donating and championing several charitable causes - in- cluding Artworks for Food, an organization he created to combine his love of art with an effort to help needy children. He's also a member of the 15th judicial Circuit's Judicial Nominating Com- mission. Staff writer ane Mus- grave contributed to this ronnrl [taus um vrr�•---. state, most polls show Nelson hasn't lost much of a lead, lately averag- ing 5.5 percentage points. Still, the latest surveys in the Senate race are a week old, a long time in a fluid election season. Mack's campaign said the tide is turning. ,,we feel there will be a great Republican turnout. in Florida," James said. "We are very happy to be just where we are." Appearing the past two weeks with former New York Mayor Rudy Gi- uliani and 2008 presiden- tial contender John Mc- Cain, Mack is relying on a star-studded lineup of GOP endorsers to help make the case that vot- ers should support him as part of a broader GOP. brand. Mack plans to campaign with Romney today in Pensacola and Central Florida. Giving Romney a Re- publican -controlled Sen- ate is key to repealing the Affordable Care Act, con- tinuing the Bush -era tax cuts and achieving a pro- posed 20 -percent across- the-board tax reduction, Mack said. "I'm afraid that under this administration and Sen. Nelson; the Ameri- can dream is a little dim- mer than it was in the past," Mack said in Tam- pa during a fly -around 48 percent or inn ing came from third -par- ty spending organiza- tions - the bulk of them' helping Mack. The nonprofit Cam- paign Finance Institute reported that $13.3 mil- lion has been spent by third -party groups sup- porting Mack, compared with $3.6 million for Nel- son. The Democrat, howev- er, has raised $12.7 mil- lion for his campaign - double that of Mack. The different ap- proaches to financing al- so are shading into Nel- son's stump speech head- ing into the homestretch.. The Democrat said the corporate money flowing to organizations that, in turn, attack him is proof that he has been willing to challenge corporate power in Washington. It also fits the role of the solitary, free -speaker he is portraying in the race's final days. "It's coming from the interests I have stood up to in the Senate, like the oil industry and in some casestheinsurancein- dustry," Nelson said. "I've been on my own. These PACs have been at- tacking me since April. I've had to defend my- self," he added. Jkennedy@pbpost.com ' Is Mobile Marketing • Audience Management • SEM • Retargeting • Social Media f, Call (561) 820-3706 1 ideolob pouerrd by;TheP.thn131:ath Ani o REGULARS II CITY PEOPLE 4) A Visionary With A Heart ANTHONY Vm PUGLIESE ff r LJ BY DIANE FEEN PHOTOS BY MELISSA KORMAN Trying to to put a c describe Anthony )ntent label on the constantly on the move, is al around him (and probably i accomplishment's could fill He started out in the construction business at the age of 17 and hasn't stopped creating things of beau- ty since. The Pugliese Company, headquartered in Pineapple Grove in Delray Beach, owns and manages over 1.5 million -square -feet of industrial, office and self storage facilities in Florida and New Jersey. He is also a real estate entrepreneur; developing commer- cial, industrial and residential properties. But that is not what defines this man of many tal- ents. He may be an enigma to those who see the Pug. liese Way street sign or the peach colored Pugliese Corporate Center, but in the Flesh Pugliese is some- what mystical and magical. He has the macho cha- risma of a movie star, a sense of style like the great masters, an artistic bent that has won him awards for his properties, and a sense of the future that borders on clairvoyance. But to everyone who knows Pugliese, he is the consummate gentleman with the bulldog instinct for heading forward in business. 'Anthony is always on the cutting edge — he has such an intense and ex- pansive view that when you're around him you see the world differently. In the most difficult of times he expresses caring and concern for others and a jovial- ness that helps transcend' problems. Anthony is im- bued with a highly developed intellect, creativity and humanity," said Pugliese's former attorney Henry Fricke. It might be his intellect that leads Pugliese in the direction of infinity, but it is his street smarts that propelled him forward. He created state-of-the-art storage facilities, swimming pools that celebrate na- ture, office buildings that soar with visual aesthetics, and he is now concentrating on a creative passion that burns within him. "1 just completed 103 paint- ings.l wanted to use the medium of painting as a way to attract other artists to donate their work for our a October 2012 1 www.AtlenticAveMagazine.com a V. Pugliese 111 is like trying earth's energy source. He i ways aware of what is gosh nterplanetary as well) and lid stadium. 1, ti new charity called Art Works 4 Food." \ If you haven't heard about this new non-profit ve ture then you should know that Pugliese spearhea ed it as a way to raise funds to provide healthy foo for underprivileged children in Palm Beach Count' "1 started out helping the Big Heart Brigade prepali meals for those in need on Thanksgiving. And then thought to myself, 'what about the rest of the yea There are so many children in Palm Beach Col that don't have enough food to eat, and when the eat it is sugary unhealthyFood. Without proper trition their brains don't work well and they en dropping out of school or in jail. With the increa school age homelessness and the growth of pov in PBC, we need to do something about It:' So that is exactly what he is doing. His org tion provided over 5000 pieces of fruit to the H Fruit Program in conjunction with local chat And a Fundraiser is planned at the Arts Garage tuber 24th to raise awareness and funds for the prb\ gram. Helping people is nothing new on the Pugliese front He once read about a little blind deaf boy who enjoyed swimming so much that he got giddy just smelling chlorine. So Pugliese came to the rescue and had a swimming pool built for him. He also heard about a wan who needed life-saving surgery and he steppe KIP to the plate and helped her. What can you say about a man who has a massive pop art collection, an office that looks like a Roman Palazzo, an adventurous spirit (he wrestled with al- ligators in the Everglades and ran with wild Bulls in Spain) and a heart of gold? 'Anthony is one -of -a - kind. He can be a shrewd businessman and a gentle giant at the same time. He is always giving back to the community and not looking for recognition;' said international businessman David Ross. The seeds of his growth (and development) were planted early on in life. "My father always told me, 'don't ever mistake kindness for weakness and never run from a fight:1 also believe you should treat people as you wish to be treated.' Nice words, but in Pugliese's case it always comes to fruition. To honor his grandson; Anthony V. Pugliese V, he created the Anthony V. Pugliese V Miracle League field, a ball field where handicap children can play sports. He is also a men- tor and friend to many. 'Anthony is so passionate about his entire fam- ily, and when it comes to friends, there is no one better to have on your side. Not only does he go out of his way for charities, but he gives the guy on the street a chance. An- thony is an amazing man - he's sincere, passionate, an amazing artist, a tremendous businessman and savvy in all ways (as a movie producer 'and an actor). Anthony is a very special man in this world," said Mel Urban, luxury custom home builder. It was Pugliese who saw the po- tential of Pineapple Grove in 1999, and it was Pugliese who had the foresight to buy property in Delray Beach in 1978. So it makes sense that this visionary would be busy exploring the next frontier. "Right now we are working on new tech- nologies that have never been ap- plied before. At our upcoming char- ity event you will be able to point your Smartphone at a painting and see the artist talking and painting in 3-D (it's called Augmented Real- ity). Technology is the future of our world:' Technology may indeed be the future of our world, but one thing for sure; i fneans nothing without those around it who have a caring heart. To learn about Art Works 4 Food call 561-454-1616 or check out: www.Artworks4food.org The charity event is October 24 at Max's Harvest in Pineapple Grove. The Pugliese Company is located at 101 Pugliese's Way. n I Cen,em 6e. 1010 m Dncn Hnm x, •00 `G r^o �'°+3 cm Q, y.D u`"i�•oy�9.Co �m o.m N ::0 0,C.m p°o° 7 = m OyC � c2 @,p �wp'GgN to w0"nn,mm� E"'4 A' xm nO Qm ttp6 mw C"?rvs,>o NO n_.. nGNoa+�G.mIIoNO rXm0.m:no'Go'?m,y cn �D OwOLd�cny mrbO wO mA l3C 0. I=w 0 -°c�w•0wa^OOmCL. . w07N^N n�•rp 3 mm3 ;» m� n a s a m WMw m°^� ox.yy^f0,o8owcs °.-"��oom�o o3, �N o"JNO wG �"^�O•_!NC °O O m,4 Om °G°m8�3wmg o0wM"--lc�u° OD�p :3 C t2 " y O. n nc. pr. M y a OO G, p, "M7m ^ppm"--� p°^i '°O 00..b� Rtn C G� O a °' n y'ev; rt� xoom " •m 3'�'^y' ocn'�o an pm�'3mX ,..�, yr' wFO nO v ooccmm�mae m?x0X^.A Gy7f G .n� 0.: m G 0 0 t m Wm M '3NwmC ow 00 R. Ej*- ,2m nomw 00w O'�.tn'^AmBN�'G�m w•000 acm mortem �Onm%�xb GQ, �0o�m�G A� 3 10 0 w C,r MET ':cmw•'o�bOnn-1—Z c'm'o.w7�.m 3QmE�Ow v,o.°:RSaw°•a3 `n P: o,'No °<oo•a o0 n», °'rOnCn�'p.^n m Ao•?'m p - O':; oYgcO 7wm ^»wr:wocnon -- n w 0 ?Cw, .nmm0c❑.-a<0•n Nm mOmGn.+o Ow 0ra0'°O mO=^*"NN k75 "Rmmd004N n ryryy, O'fNO .., N m NC 0�9.m bop'nNO`�P;w .fin N£a° N0p'O°,.-,m 0 7m o M $ y0 m �� � m w,E �aQ opa �mm``N�mw Q. �°A G•o �aCII" G10 O � 717 we Ny mcm a ' Dncn Hnm x, •00 `G r^o �'°+3 cm Q, y.D u`"i�•oy�9.Co �m o.m N ::0 0,C.m p°o° 7 = m OyC � c2 @,p �wp'GgN to w0"nn,mm� E"'4 A' xm nO Qm ttp6 mw C"?rvs,>o NO n_.. nGNoa+�G.mIIoNO rXm0.m:no'Go'?m,y cn �D OwOLd�cny mrbO wO mA l3C 0. I=w 0 -°c�w•0wa^OOmCL. . w07N^N n�•rp 3 mm3 ;» m� n a s a m WMw m°^� ox.yy^f0,o8owcs °.-"��oom�o o3, �N o"JNO wG �"^�O•_!NC °O O m,4 Om °G°m8�3wmg o0wM"--lc�u° OD�p :3 C t2 " y O. n nc. pr. M y a OO G, p, "M7m ^ppm"--� p°^i '°O 00..b� Rtn C G� O a °' n y'ev; rt� xoom " •m 3'�'^y' ocn'�o an pm�'3mX ,..�, yr' wFO nO v ooccmm�mae m?x0X^.A Gy7f G .n� 0.: m G 0 0 t m Wm M '3NwmC ow 00 R. Ej*- ,2m nomw 00w O'�.tn'^AmBN�'G�m w•000 acm mortem �Onm%�xb GQ, �0o�m�G A� 3 10 0 w C,r MET ':cmw•'o�bOnn-1—Z c'm'o.w7�.m 3QmE�Ow v,o.°:RSaw°•a3 `n P: o,'No °<oo•a o0 n», °'rOnCn�'p.^n m Ao•?'m p - O':; oYgcO 7wm ^»wr:wocnon 5og-. 3 00 I ?Cw, .nmm0c❑.-a<0•n Nm mOmGn.+o Ow 0ra0'°O mO=^*"NN k75 "Rmmd004N n ryryy, O'fNO .., N m NC 0�9.m bop'nNO`�P;w .fin N£a° N0p'O°,.-,m wmmmw ywm� no :x33 a= 7m o M $ y0 m �� � m w,E �aQ opa �mm``N�mw Q. �°A G•o �aCII" y' m � 717 we Ny a tr wP•Cd•dt�°i*1A��vMR;mnw., �»'rywc ° F�o03 w^nm�np'sm. 0ntjfmw5,,. 0m mM. fro aV17fH,cr°El ?No�°'fmP:o.no`io'y i@ 7 o Daa"t G; n 0• YG•'•O•m w 0 a� .450 oow nw c o^Nnnoo"om o o. .e .mow o.. '?w "vi •+" .w �^Gc oto 7 rvCC3k NG TSG ^,ma�a0m�' ° ° :5 m nn '�?m, 9om�oGooKm.0 �3 y°5m O'wo.-3P.o o �mwcfmo73 0.m y^rx 00• O, nOw.,N -nw, ,"° moi, omnr"o"n 0: 3m�o 3mmmo'* Fcrn'Mom fl at VIN GO ..G G m �•H m 3 7 o o D ° $ �'0 camm MmoojAtvaaf�ms $`o comp0c-m d 3 .3�mmmo o°�a33<i t°* �0 S N O ...� .-9 o a .. 3 N— rt �u W "" O a O 6N 7 C S-7 p m j�SN 0 •O rt 7 G NO (�j Urti 0 W MN nNN mN Nm m N ut hns •p «, n noS^m07 v Vi r ` • �/}�. C D ' O ' O' m :o3'P, C 3.0 (D QF =0 IF.•.{� l V - m '' � m`•< 'm t n x w m s O mow• I•� 70 3<m m3 � N T S O M O (••i• 0. 0 m w fD �. � tZI M p• q m` �keo597Nmg w m m C. O •-�l Y SSO sr o m�S vi cam. �r"'� m�+w a.o0. CONxdm m rp N 7 w o A 5 o Vim'o ^ S 7 w 5 ::PQ o d �• C =rr. o l V mo'm*3� ?mwNm so �oaa�5wtimxg C.r•� O m.nm�A�C? n3 p O E.I. N R v y 6w N 0 0 0 Boma.00m3;R'wN �.n3o.o`cD O 1•"P '° T1ONCw .^. wny oowmm 7 nw6ay. oN em i `nGw�NC�n £,�7•p,m 0.�tr :4o cm CL r N a y v g o p D 6 O y O C O a �FNOG m O m m T y 'ON F W d m F. m 9 f m n N m m mOwmO so c X M ;:;F,6Fw O n S !I =a EL I ,y�OwEo vm ID -G m w w w m 0o CL M= n w m D m O G,n `C y �yGw W O'N 9.w. ry( n W m nmo�a°oo9�� ^w�°ccDi vq C m ., 0 0 0 •, m ., a m a. -, x a on�.m p•�m Odfm""- R-4 to D o5y :1 an wwn�'O Ortr . m m o .Nowo ,oramt' C7<OO. GNS. <mmmm rt '•f w �� � Q'�'0 rw.. T N �G w O 0. O n m m m L O z Oi O O O D z D m .o C5 4 O Z O r N M m n 2 C) O z Z11 CD7 --a _•^ N _'°mm a'O�pNm aw'-ycC,Op•NOFnywp'S°w.,rD-rYdMEl rp y�m`!O�cSv ix dr•i C��� dya'^�J'}n to .0 n°.awwofD "', r`Domw�mol�"� c.7 55F. d�a0.0.0 ry m_ m o rD d 0 0. m.m N o y r3c mn mpir 5o'�,cpn ^d =S_S. N ^ ry y !°� .d+ iAW'O ('n1• �. .. ..; ,. L." ^. S.. �1wa,S.m O yy S '< O d .J.. N N R ^ to d N .° �0. .e Qq = - - n• iiCC � • n ''c ww O M z o 3.n y ?n cr In y _ dN o' I CL n. Z. :3 C•C `n'w O a.• a - - °. moi _ = .--•• o, o N •J •` 10 _5 n0 ^.n..Iy Cp oa.m wO oQfSmC-N=+O:.S g; __.. 5 a< �ppppNHw, w0 C Dk7' vwmG D dym =MOymow W m'°<d•y mN S fD�N SN.O = C.•...M05 S�°n5.n.m CO.�'m.�'Oi Cn❑'t n.rd� 5. .4J cmn5.5q ° ^^n OW NO"•L3wN5ne'n'y � DndDS�dDmml Nm rtd S�np+Uq 6^uNim -p'�s ^d° "'+Oj< O_7 •-yw drD�d °OroDnwO�ww d: m 0 GJ". wC d:?m J�'00.0.Cn_ ....n5�00 rc X'<^ 5�:�. d.Snw 5: 0 ti j a -O Ig �p Mwnmon ,�N,:?.w�'omao°o�'o5rn^=_-�°nO.•edfD+w�a °mRo�S mo �7�s0 CL'n_ ,'Do=.aBa��c <-aSw�Nm o_omm_roTrl N. mw G5 n,d wmi 09w Mw 0 ==0 �5dM nviX ❑ fDN rD tD CL c �5Fw0du O ~<�NCDCgq07� rnnOO.'0S ds __ N Om D d.G `4� �x.•_.W rDwO;g Q.N.. Co..50f-dC d_05� 7nN�'iG 6,yn., .n.C:.� tdDa P..;55 N Srpm5'b 5•w aeryc `G rDddS 5 dy ��N-rM —cm7 6N rD S `D r0 05ST n <r1 O nN'v tlrtq �0 M.7 y CL N' Y r. ^ rD m 7 y y -..e0 Nx, m rD h '00 ° " �.Ncpx'a"3 cmo;-.wo�ai w n IT s°+� �•m m T•n Tcr wp �.O�zmF Cil ..w Srpn drD �wwg =500- °m55 'O 5'.0 SO L7' w d D °oaoo.Omd�o tj orb �, 53 7y 0. t, t,� CoQ a nM UQ an �wC•dpnRw-ni m �•��d�nm E;omm I c•w 0 w F'=5 =5 C.O and woen 75'm Gm .O w° n m CL d N 09 E O dw 7 O.j-w �Ody OrDr00...n ^f�i n^dNN -•w-• C N S N n o'b ���� a�•5 a.°" -.Om � c ;,m Ten ern ?=Opo°m�ioa _"o�''orNo��;ma•��� �o5-a4Oq �So"°��" o•n.•c Doo My�d�m., Fv, wdw rnDwN4i m=wen �H dd.,..i °• 'y'$ �•�`CNVNi 7'•Oi Mw ^G.� 5�5�. °, I5ml m.d.w 5b c`i CL ? w 5.� CL p.m 5 w as o d o 0 w M$ M' N `a Ewo�E 'edry 0 m 0 vum cr 0 0 3 a N o N :a5 Ct �.dmx'4 0e�n�'ooaOnm' "cw NOO.5?w o�,w—_,m C WNp nCT r+N N y�•�5 i 5 m °= • ° Q"J rD wd0.r� m'i ,tN w' ,yOry dr CL aN�•�rdD WEE °m.,d+mi C ppS•�G1pOn _7'm ��.o Mo'OG^ .w+0'+.5'0 .7y MVJ Mgwwtwgp ::r , °- H n R° m N o^+i O "fix" 7 ^ N n? w 7 w w, flu n C y 'bG N tlC v m '� n O • o' `m'�'S r.LM ui Ty Q•.r 7w'G P l V �o5nx?:7 a:mam _m'n,o rcj tvw�y�p .nm H nm 5Cq`ym gty_w otrNcEd°°°wow o5.od�°p"q .0 0, �oYw aN/"1�i fp°C.Ow?w aaw "a .ww m O fyC Xmm�m NO G C f0]7`G P n•�""N"' O' ""• *�`� ly 1�'F l NCd.'G "�. �.Oy a,TlO O. a.<Ra SEvi 7S�?O Na<pert m tin:3 viJg0.�N X.< .nC^=n CP C.w "end<OMommv Oy .°., dO A.m �,n SKlp mN 000R"'I�o' RO91CMTm vi �. N�CT. w=M0 w EQ P Nm nO wm m.N_.aOO ,C`~< D �+ oww o rnomyr�o c'. 5' c.°.3`•<w w yc.o .r coaCL 5v ,7,0 o_�yo�o mem moXSF mwm .mwm7+qwn tv wm trm I 'gym yts O'^w'o COf`<D "°+,Owq �N �'G �'d�':.O � � 7 �fp °to r wt".n_.w ]'Can N 9 CLm d� y m 0•4ag0 rynOtj Nwo" C`C nw 'o5n w cn �. V'Cny OQ' �Pf W w N »a0 g5wo �w0:'rt�w•0 n'<mw yb y NO'm Ma0a^� W W T° V=`" p 0'n m �'.S y - —w n O4''O::M n•o"o n.0 � q n M.=tr C Jr',q+n wCLd°'m Calm°'` nSiOS`<"n`+E� ra��°O'`.m (IMM It a04�dM p C G. :03 W— O'z yOM7 m o. o.�Mn 0.�.y,N tj O'C.w 70w OWq �v:r :o°Do^'oaJc*?e CyaCM;;,<,d�a��°�, mtr�mns� w,O R ..A y .y=p^°NmG'cp w ptifb M ° �+ d ? ° a m 55' o m"oi bmmn"•M 5`C 7'c ^m rno 7�9,��•dW w• i�a�wd��pa mom• mg, Q•,mxmq r a �r�o ❑ mioc a, rm nnn'a!-q 'oa p'`y°ro'C o� n�000w c.wpMw�,00<cwaPo m ' Ea3.�.m m m m pz; w m< o nm Eno E2.6 m :•dM 05 °4CL0 m'o• a M 4•" ° aS.°Co 2 ssw° m ^ Rao 'V w "J Fwj °° '+ H q m �:�,ryQ 7ow°C.MwwC N",�' Ow�'Nm .nn n.0 m N m .`s' P no C1 w ,w.� C- p•aa n ' m 7. O O= C X7.0 ad:j o' "n�m S.C.,y?�O�`+as G...O �j'� roO O;C �. (n M (n Q m to rY al (p (p Z M n 0 0.< 'J' n a "+w vi ': •.�Tm "^� C T m„yb 'Z' mq w ad a d 1,,, K`< aq 'J` fD :<awn �O.q fwlM w< .O IM0 Ra7A m,=0 � w .„ro•no CL n OC��m� may m PNaw�£M�OS M 0. �. CT° rt wW=", waq MIS "Ci p,ON, :yo ° wo^f•OF "ovww .5. w°•odoy ow 7�tr adPn�gn 4C,0@CMarMoemomf 5mtd O'P o In O w.01] � 7nww dC "wi Q O y Hwy Fro" ,'u n '� O .w".q Owe n CL 0. m a< »,d:r 3NO•CO•=1 rbc=a cN°m<<`<roC.M,<, Qq oan�^o 0 05.`aa n5wtday�' mti •O' --n =MO SC ° m O M G]° m C.= O O CL. w g y C n.y C" M-wi d^n`w3o m'OcO.S •r<o�noo. p d w;G0 :3 m S•SWa�•r"'o Ow° ^O'On .^at aq°e�CCn E vR�in»'gyp °.•,, 'b ,Cyw50'^et"""t d m � Hy7'S'o A On �O7 n d Itnmi ^?mC Q.o” wm— S•=M waam<•p yn �•5Mw^NymNw to .7. °' O •O w ❑ m .y ❑ O C. C 0 ,'O m? O n W"=" Q. -O" �G. rno ow c=maq �am5•�M me 0Km Cdpoo �.rt 20 M no p JI"'tlmq'7 n n f syn 70n'o roOp�m�w 5dmwa7croyo� to 0.,0.,Crywn �-."d 5iryA ' cw w a.' m O'_7 =aa -a :ia. Oytrym�q R o m W O• Ow tv C. �J 'fy y ° ' O •n n•=o ya0Q ay"1N N ~ A $ xn ioaM.onym�mdP'•m=y°=Tmwmmo mwmsomam�z A ao v°-w3cr M c a=ro 3 mn in moim m w a p n mwm� "J �. ^" a^q n0a� 6_w"+ NmX nmV L'!•* ,+ q "n'MO� tw�O�y 0= OmwpmO W<S� N m O.CO W�.w �'.Er wI�N� ►�, O'� Nn O qMN `m X,w Ro^m SLI. ..nOQ".yin Om c Onwn<�: cnc0.�mmm Mw Ttid Ow ^m CJt00�<FmN�• »mmom 6 Rm N°7R-=-C, mSM;^ �7R i "f ay.n7•CR 7 m T C �• w pm"w Xz MOO wow Ro w Oy dqw ""Oytny7 mMI.r' MRw w`<Cw "•Ri0%, ry0 C,o•„:^wao "go m5aq. 0."n Cw<m° e0 ww —.:e M oc `Q5° M 'dm5clr ^ `�.w.q❑°7�^r"•'�.m •0~�mdao<mn =m��roO•�'Oq`<5'm^ .ti?Cmy O•.Pm.' '°OO"C�w pw.P* nONo•c. oa?:`Go^�n d�oww< gm .6.m, . w,�+'❑••'•^m"mt . na"mOm,+: �.mM°°Mwn* •OT'mpoX.m.mn^amnraQy^om a5'w�d y O rOw 0 M0R O 05Or•0O•C°` �nniw p JmwM wM .w?"mn0q e�sOol•• „O�wC} .b0 RM Momo� n r x n m D n x 0 0 M n z 2 x m N z Z D { m rn N 0 w 9+ 0= oo .w--.ombww �•o�omm m��n"'mQn �.�:c3-��*--c arc gm 2 n rD W w w w w m "� O w "• O `n n w m O .� y n -_ G O Cw C..^°'?• 'aTvni ��Gbyc�G-7^i ']p 70� No N 0`G p'O R•w•'�rwDn rl ~' M o'wawom nww�OnC.pin0.n❑ymR<�.�<w��="� w o x�wccm w,. o°••d��(s'n,., .*onmyw3mccro -ni �°°•C=�so5 Nm .0.,KOnN wyn. m fST 1.5 w_x..pnm•,c w •m z�.x�� �'n'-60=1- .n7'9m w �rD � w w xd7 6� � � C n - _ - O n O•-• mm O 'J .O mOGbw 7 nyl `<c•w"nyO�o'7�rgo•wry.a�d5dory°_W.�'O�p]o••.w_.�^=_<_ow •w. O1 rc ii o m m y •.. �.n o K - � 7 �?o w O y0 ymCx n070 Xxf�D"< mrp _O�wO iry n.Oi tAa�wb W'G O`, GwrC 0.m y C6..y I°b n•m m •7 m w n rp m N w Cm^0 v;b� A -va p p�j d.°...C.n..� qO tj w o m 0 vmi�w�C.'L•or an G bnH° fe. m�0 nrxo '=apo CL-=- o oy°•�T��dow-•�� 00 off_. tz -.0 nanW .a 3$ x0 b7 •m..�rpy�Oco mo d,y�00�%o ownn n'5 n'C yam.=0y,lf"hof C'p„w"n. C.':= 'c7y mK7" CQ'.m ^..�..�mn O�irr .n�ani�00���°n�„n,o ro W� cO w 7 m o 0 a ��'e w 9� tD� `"� O z' = .7n n „Ow n. (�D � y -C ° m Ul 0p•'C n m° mwn0. J�wpy�Ya+�m^D -0S� CL- �00°-�9Grt070nmQmm 0= � 0- �m p mxT0(D=sZ cam. xgy°o»a9A:1 omO ny r•b o „w,••n'°_'�Cw y p' a �•c dy. o• �y°'�-•3 �� nww oYw 'nF ny5�mwo F==0 '�.y yRo�x ic= c�aaco .co,o ��?a°��.o�m �omT<c.� °3< °no °�?w]°o 0 I- <m`ac`Lo a` dy N»�7wo g�`o D 7�a o0tr noy T 3mn 3-2 C �'rJ t.+ a < m ca w OOmw •+ `< n wcc. O om m cm Mcr ym w y n c ?' nm = •a d� o'm c m p•.m..� C� _Cnr xof°cmz° °C mf �7 °+�wGo°n� rxoN rnG msso 6.nw°• s 3c^•OWn», m m n O O m C c 0 ww'< m 70 �T0•<n �dO �.ro n o Oy n mp; LOCw �. n WON m..