Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My Public Portal
About
20-9767 Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services
Sponsored by: City Manager RESOLUTION NO. 20-9767 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF OPA-LOCKA, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING BID PROPOSALS FOR CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING CONSULTING SERVICES PURSUANT TO RFQ NO. 20-0324200; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO MULTIPLE AGREEMENTS FOR ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING CONSULTING SERVICES AS PROVIDED HEREIN; PROVIDING FOR INCORPORATION OF RECITALS; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, on February 23, 2020, the City of Opa-Locka (the "City") duly issued Request for Qualifications ("RFQ") 20-0324200 for the purpose of establishing a library of Licensed Architects and Engineers to provide Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services for the City, attached hereto as Exhibit "A"; and WHEREAS, a total of 35 firms responded to the RFQ by May 15, 2020, the submittal deadline; and WHEREAS, bid proposals were received by the Office of the City Clerk on May 15, 2020 at 2:00 p.m. The City Clerk's Office opened sealed proposals at 2:05 pm and certified the bids under the provisions of Section 2-320.1 of the City's Code of Ordinance; and WHEREAS, the City Manager assembled an Evaluation Committee to assess the bid proposals. The Evaluation Committee met on June 2, 2020 to review the proposals and rate them; and WHEREAS, based on its review of the Evaluation Committee, the City Manager proposes that the City negotiate and enter into several agreements for Continuing Professional Architectural and Engineering Services; and WHEREAS, the City Manager recommends award of continuing contracts to: 300 Engineering Group, P.A. for Civil Engineering, landscape architectural, structural engineering and traffic engineering services; EAC Consulting, Inc. for Civil Engineering, landscape architectural, structural engineering, traffic engineering, land surveying, construction testing and inspections, utilities engineering services and general consulting engineering services; H.W. Lochner, Inc. for architectural, construction testing and inspections and general consulting engineering services; Civica Resolution No. 20-9767 LLC for mechanical/electrical/plumbing service; BEA Architects, Inc. for architectural services; SSN Engineering, LLC for utilities engineering services and 2 Plus Architects, Inc. for mechanical/electrical/plumbing service, as provided in Composite Exhibit "B" showing the scoring for responses to the RFQ; and WHEREAS, the City Commission supports approval based upon the Evaluation Committee's review, evaluation, scoring and ranking of the proposals submitted; and WHEREAS, the City Commission finds that it is in the best interest of the City and its residents to award various Continuing Professional Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services as set forth herein. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF OPA LOCKA, FLORIDA: Section 1. RECITALS ADOPTED. The recitals to the preamble herein are incorporated by reference. Section 2. AUTHORIZATION The City Commission of the City of Opa-Locka hereby accepts the bid proposals, as provided herein, for Continuing Professional Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services, pursuant to RFQ No. 20-0324200, and as set forth in Composite Exhibit "B" attached hereto. The City Commission further authorizes the City Manager to enter into multiple agreements for Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services in a contract form acceptable to the City Attorney, and as otherwise described in this resolution. SECTION 3. SCRIVENER'S ERRORS. Sections of this Resolution may be renumbered or re -lettered and corrections of typographical errors which do not affect the intent may be authorized by the City Manager, or the City Manager's designee, without need of public hearing, by filing a corrected copy of same with the City Clerk. Section 4. EFFECTIVE DATE. This Resolution shall be effective immediately upon adoption hereof and approval by the Governor of the State of Florida or Governor's designee. PASSED and ADOPTED this 10th day of June, 2020. 2 Resolution No. 20-9767 AT EST: a Flores, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIEN 44;q �'— • Burnadette Norris City Attorney Moved by: COMMISSIONER BASS Seconded by: COMMISSIONER BURKE VOTE: 5-0 Commissioner Bass YES Commissioner Burke YES Commissioner Kelley YES Vice -Mayor Davis YES Mayor Pigatt YES 3 Matthew A. Pigatt, Mayor City of Opa-Locka Agenda Cover Memo Department Director: Acting City Manager: Commission Meeting Date: Fiscal Impact: (Enter X in box) Airia Austin John E. Pate 06.10.2020 Yes No Item Type: (EnterX in box) Ordinance Reading. (Enter X in box) Department Director Signature: CM Signature: Resolution Ord ance st Reading Other 2nd Reading Public Hearing: (Enter X in box) Yes No Yes Funding Source: Account#: Contract/P.O. Required: (Enter X in box) (Enter Fund & Dept) Ex: Advertising Requirement: (Enter X in box) Yes No No X Strategic Plan Related (Enter X in box) Yes No x RFP/RFQ/Bid#: 20-0324200 Sponsor Name Yes No X City Manager Strategic Plan Priority Area: Enhance Organizational in Bus. & Economic Dev 0 Public Safety Quality of Education El Qual. of Life & City Image C] Communication p Department: Strategic Plan Obj./Strategy: (list the specific objective/strategy this item will address) City Manager Short Title: A resolution of the City Commissions of the City of Opa-locks, Florida authorizing the City Manager to accept continuing contracts for Professional Engineering Services Pursuant to RFQ No. 20-0324200. Staff Summary: 0n May 15, 2020 the City of Opa-locka received thrity-five (35) responses to its Request for Qualification (RFQ) No. 20-0324200 for Architectural & Engineering Consulting Services. In accordance with the RFQ , the City of Opa-locka intents to award a contract to the most qualified Proposer (s) who agrees to provide the requisite professional services at a compensation which the City of Opa-locka determines fair, reasonable and competive. After reviewing the bids submitted, the Selection Committee found 300 Engineering, EAC Consulting, H.W. Lochner, BEA Architects, Inc., 2+ Architects, Inc., Civica Architecture, and SSN Engineering, LLC as the most qualified offerors. Proposed Action: Staff is recommending the award to 7 vendors to insure adequate coverage for the City of Opa-locka engineering consulting needs. Financial Impact There is no financial impact associated with the awarding of contract to the seven recommended firms providing professional engineering services. At such time that a future project is to be assigned to one of these firms, staff will return to the Commission to obtain approval, including identifying the financial impact and funding sources. Attachment: 1. Agenda 2. Evaluation Matrix 3. Selection Matrix Office of the City Manager 780 Fisherman Street, 4th Floor Opa-locka, FL 33054 John E. Pate, MS, CM Telephone (786) 338-6598 City Manager Email: jpate@opalockafl.gov To: Mayor Matthew Pigatt Vice Mayor Chris Davis Commissioner Sherelean Bass Commissioner Alvin Burke Commissioner Joseph L. Kelley From: John E. Pate, City Manager Date: June 4, 2020 Re: Resolution: Committee Selection for Architectural & Engineering Consulting Services Request: A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF OPA- LOCKA, FLORIDA, ACCEPTING CONTINUING CONTRACTS FOR PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES PURSUANT TO RFQ NO. 20- 0324200; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO MULTIPLE AGREEMENTS FOR CIVIL ENGINEERING, ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES, STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SERVICES, MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL/PLUMBING SERVICES, UTILITIES ENGINEERING, TRAFFIC ENGINEERING, LAND SURVEYING, CONSTRUCTION TESTING AND INSPECTIONS, AND GENERAL CONSULTING ENGINEERING AS OUTLINED; PROVIDING FOR INCORPORATION OF RECITALS; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Categories: CIVIL ENGINEERING 300 Engineering Group 90.2 EAC Consulting 86.0 ARCHITECTURAL SERVICE H.W. Lochner 85.8 BEA Architects, Inc. 85.6 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES L 300 Engineering Group 90.2 EAC Consulting 86.0 Analysis: STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SERVICES 300 Engineering Group 90.2 EAC Consulting 86.0 MECHANICAL / ELECTRICAL / PLUMBING SERVICE 2+ Architects, Inc. 84.6 Civica Architecture 82.2 UTILITIES ENGINEERING EAC Consulting 86.0 SSN Engineering, LLC 77.2 TRAFFIC ENGINEERING 300 Engineering Group 90.2 EAC Consulting 86.0 LAND SURVEYING 300 Engineering Group 90.2 EAC Consulting 86.0 CONSTRUCTION TESTING AND INSPECTIONS EAC Consulting 86.0 H.W. Lochner 85.8 GENERAL CONSULTING ENGINEERING EAC Consulting 86.0 H.W. Lochner 85.8 Bid proposals were received by the Office of the City Clerk on May 15, 2020 at 2:05 p.m. The City Clerk's Office opened sealed proposals and certified the bids under the provisions of Sec. 2-320.1 of the City's Code of Ordinance. The following thirty-five (35) companies submitted proposals: 2Plus Architects, Inc. Caltran Engineering Group, Inc. Michael Flaugh Landscape Architect Perrin International Services, Inc. SSN Engineering, LLC The Beta Jones Group, Inc. 300 Engineering Group, P.A. 305 Consulting Engineers, LLC BEA Architects, Inc. Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc. C&I Constructions and Design, Inc. Civica Architecture Craven Thompson & Associates, Inc. D.L. Fields Consultants, LLC David Plummer & Associates EA3 Civil Engineering, Inc. EAC Consulting, Inc. Eastern Engineering Group EBS Engineering, Inc. Eco Tech Consulting, LLC H.W. Lochner, Inc. Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. Landshore Enterprises, LLC McMahon Associates, Inc. ME Engineering, Inc. Nova Engineering and Environmental, LLC Nyarko Architectural Group, Inc. Pistorino & Alam Consulting Engineers, Inc. Premiere Design Solutions, Inc. R.E. Chisholm Architects, Inc. Radise International, LC SGM Engineering, Inc. Synalovski Romanik Saye, LLC Tierra South Florida, Inc. Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC The evaluation committee met on June 2, 2020 to review proposals. Members of the evaluation committee included: Corion DeLaine, City Planner Carlos Gonzalez, CIP Project Manager Gerald Lee, Zoning Official Rich Oddman, Sr. Accountant Arshad Viqar, City Engineer Each committee member's review evaluation and scoring of proposals were based on the following criterion and weight system: Criterion Weight Consultant's background, qualification, credentials and in- house expertise, factoring in the proposed Proposer teams' current workload and experience working together on similar category. 35% Staff Experience and resumes of team's personnel, including assigned Project manager's experience in planning, designing and construction administration services. 35% Previous experience working with local regulatory, permitting agencies and governmental clients. 5% Project control tools utilized to maintain schedule, quality and cost controls and construction management activities. 15% Local Business Preference. 5% CBE or SBE Preference. 5% Attached you will find the selection committee evaluations that include scoring of the thirty-five (35) proposals submitted / received. Recommendation(s): Staff recommends approval based upon the committee's review, evaluation, scoring and ranking of the proposals submitted. Therefore, it is the recommendation of the Selection Committee that the City negotiate and enter into several agreements for Continuing Professional Engineering Services. Attachments: Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #20-0324200 Advertisement Bid Certification Committee Evaluation Forms Bid Proposals 1*- 17 EAC Consulting 19 I EBS Engineering 21 H.W. Lochner 4 Perrin International Services 5 SSN Engineering, LLC 6 The Beta Jones Group, Inc. 7 1,300 Engineering Group 8 10 11 12 13 14 78.2 77.2 74.6 305 Consulting Engineers, LLC Biscayne Engineering C&I Construction 90.2: 75.4 80.4 75.4 Civica Architecture Craven Thompson & Assoc. D.L. Fields Consultants 15 David Plummer 82.2 77.2 82.0 16 EA3 Civil Engineering 79.4 66.4 '88-0 80.0 85.8 22 Kimley Horn 29 Premiere Design Solutions 32 SGM Engineering 85.2 84.0 84.6 RFQ - 20-0324200 il 1 Architectural Services Score 84.6 2+ Architects, Inc 9 BEA Architects, Inc. 85.6 12 Civica Architecture 82.2 14 D.L. Fields Consultants 82.0 15 David Plummer 79.4 21 H.W. Lochner 858'.; 25 ME Engineering 74.4 27 Nyarko Architectural Group 76.6 28 Pistorino & Alam Consulting 77.8 30 R.E. Chisholm Architects 84.2 32 SGM Engineering 84.6 33 Synalovski Romanik Saye 84.0 Ili 1 Landscape Architectural Services MEW Score 84.6 2+ Architects, Inc 3 Micheal Faugh Landscape 62.6 6 The Beta Jones Group, Inc. 74.6 7 300 Engineering Group 90.2 12 Civica Architecture 82.2 13 Craven Thompson & Assoc. 77.2 14 D.L. Fields Consultants 82.0 15 David Plummer 79.4 17 EAC Consulting 86;0,: 21 H.W. Lochner 85.8 22 Kimley Horn 85.2 IV Structural Engineering Services Score 5 SSN Engineering, LLC 7 300 Engineering Group 77.2 90.2 8 305 Consulting Engineers, LLC 12 Civica Architecture 14 D.L. Fields Consultants 15 David Plummer 17 EAC Consulting 18 Eastern Engineering Group 21 H.W. Lochner 75.4 82.2 82.0 79.4 86.0 70.2 85.8 22 Kimley Horn 32 SGM Engineering 85.2 84.6 v 1 Mechanical 1 Electrical \ Plumbing Services Score gq;6 2+ Architects, Inc 6 The Beta Jones Group, Inc. 74.6 12 Civica Architecture 812 14 D.L. Fields Consultants 82.0 15 David Plummer 79.4 25 ME Engineering 74.4 27 Nyarko Architectural Group 76.6 Utilities Engineering 5 SSN Engineering, LLC 11 C&I Construction 77.2 17 EAC Consulting 75.4 86.0 RFC, - 20-0324200 Traffic Engineern. Caltran Engineering Group 5 SSN Engineering, LLC 7 300 Engineering Group 8 1305 Consulting Engineers, LLC 12 Civica Architecture 17 EAC Consulting 21 H.W. Lochner 22 Kimley Horn 24 McMahon Assoc. RFQ - 20-0324200 vtu Land Surveying Score 1 2+ Architects, Inc 84.6 4 Perrin International Services 78.2 7 300 Engineering Group 90.2 10 Biscayne Engineering 80.4 12 Civica Architecture 82.2 13 Craven Thompson & Assoc. 77.2 15 David Plummer 79.4 17 EAC Consulting 86.0 21 H.W. Lochner 85.8 22 Kimley Hom 85.2 29 Premiere Design Solutions 84.0 Ix 1 Construction Testing and ;.Inspections Score 2+ Architects, Inc 84.6 4 Perrin International Services 78.2 6 The Beta Jones Group, Inc. 74.6 12 Civica Architecture 82.2 15 David Plummer 79.4 17 EAC Consulting 86.0 19 EBS Engineering 80.0 20 Eco Tech Consulting 70.8 21 H.W. Lochner 85.8 22 Kimley Horn 85.2 26 Nova Engineering\Environmental 72.8 31 Radise International 81.8 34 Tierra South Florida 77.4 35 Universal Engineering Sciences 77.6 X General Consulting' Enaineerina 1 2+ Architects, Inc 13 Craven Thompson & Assoc. Score 84.6 77.2 1 g EA3 Civil Engineering 17 EAC Consulting 19 EBS Engineering 21 H.W. Lochner 22 Kimley Horn 25 ME Engineering 28 Pistorino & Alam Consulting 29 Premiere Design Solutions 66.4 86.0 80.0 85.8 77.8 84.0 RFQ - 20-0324200 - Firm Name: 2+ Architects, Inc RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Civil Corson DeLeine Arshsd Wrier Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Criterion Architectural Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 2 3 4 5 35 5 15 28 28 5 10 35 35 5 15 25 25 5 10 30 5 6 5 Total 100 4 5 80 0 5 95 2 Firm Name: Caltran Engineering Group 5 5 75 30 3 12 4 5 84 31 31 5 13 4 5 89 AVERAGE 84.6 Structural MEP Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro IConsultlng CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Civil Gorton DeLeine Arehad Vlgar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Criterion Point Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 20 35 25 2 3 4 5 6 35 5 15 20 5 10 20 5 1 25 5 10 32 32 5 5 Total 100 4 5 64 0 0 61 3 Firm Name: Micheal Faugh Landscape 4 5 74 5 3 4 5 31 31 5 13 81 4 5 89 AVERAGE 73.8 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro !Consulting CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Civil Coron Delsine Arshad Vigor Rich Oddman Cantos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 18 25 2 20 35 18 10 3 5 4 15 5 6 5 5 3 5 25 5 12 27 27 5 2 0 2 3 12 5 Total 100 0 48 0 38 0 69 3 0 29 30 5 13 72 4 5 86 AVERAGE 62.6 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 4 Firm Name: Perrin International Services Reviewer Name: Criterion Points 1 2 3 4 35 35 5 15 5 6 5 5 Gerald Lee Score 20 20 5 10 4 5 Corson DeLeine Score 30 25 5 10 0 5 Arahad Vigar Score 25 26 5 13 5 5 Rich Oddman Score 33 33 5 3 4 5 Carlos Gonzalez Score 31 32 5 13 4 5 AVERAGE CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Total 100 RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 64 75 79 83 90 78.2 Consulting I RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX s Firm Name: SSN Engineering, LLC CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Clarion DeLeine A�,ad Vigor Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score 1 Score Landscape 35 20 25 2 35 20 25 3 5 5 5 30 29 31 31 31 32 5 4 5 6 15 5 5 Total 100 3 4 5 57 10 0 5 70 12 5 5 86 5 5 12 4 0 83 13 4 5 90 AVERAGE 77.2 Structural Mechanical U8lfifes Traffic Survey Geo / Envlro 'Consulting s Firm Name: The Beta Jones Group, Inc. CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lae Conlon DeLalne Arahad Vigor Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 2 3 4 35 35 5 15 25 25 5 0 20 25 5 10 28 29 5 12 5 5 4 0 5 34 34 5 3 31 32 5 13 6 5 Total 100 0 59 5 65 0 79 4 0 80 4 5 90 AVERAGE 74.6 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro 'Consulting 7 Firm Name: 300 Engineering Group CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Colton DeLeine A►shad Vigor Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural chitectural Criterion Pointe Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 2 3 4 5 6 35 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 30 30 5 12 4 5 86 35 30 5 15 0 5 90 30 30 5 12 5 5 87 35 35 5 15 4 5 99 31 31 5 13 4 5 89 AVERAGE 90.2 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 8 Firm Name: 305 Consulting Engineers, LLC Reviewer Name: Criterion Point Gerald Lee Score Conlon Detain Score Arched ► � Score Ruch Oddman ScOfe Carlos Gonzalez Score 1 35 20 25 26 33 31 2 35 20 20 25 33 31 3 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 15 0 15 12 6 13 5 5 4 0 5 4 4 CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey 5 Total 100 5 54 5 70 RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 5 78 5 86 5 AVERAGE Geo / Enviro 89 75.4 Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 12 Firm Name: Civic�itecture Reviewer Name: Criterion Point CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Udrities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 6 5 5 5 5 5 Total 100 74 90 82 72 5 93 AVERAGE Geo / Enviro 82.2 'Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 13 Firm Name: Craven Thompson & Assoc. CATEGORY Reviewervil Corson DeLeine Name: Gerald Lee Arch Arahad Wear Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Criterion Points Score Architectural Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 2 35 3 4 5 6 20 20 25 20 34 34 33 5 5 5 5 33 15 2 10 14 5 5 Total 100 4 5 56 14 Firm Name: D.L. Fields Consultants 0 0 60 5 5 97 5 5 4 0 33 33 80 5 13 4 5 93 AVERAGE 77.2 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro (Consulting CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Lea Civil Corlon Detains Arehad Vigar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Criterion Point Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 25 29 2 3 4 5 6 35 5 25 5 30 30 5 30 5 27 27 15 5 5 Total 100 8 4 5 72 15 0 5 85 12 5 5 86 3 32 32 10 4 5 5 13 76 15 Firm Name: David Plummer 4 5 91 AVERAGE 82.0 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Colton Del aloe CivMI Arehad Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Scam Landscape 1 2 35 35 25 25 25 30 3 4 5 6 5 5 5 27 28 5 30 30 31 31 15 10 15 10 5 4 0 5 5 Total 100 5 74 5 80 5 80 5 7 4 0 4 13 76 4 4 87 AVERAGE 79.4 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 1s Firm Name: EA3 Civil Engineering Reviewer Name: Criterion Pointe 1 2 3 4 5 35 35 5 15 5 Gerald Lee Score 15 15 5 5 4 Corson DeLaine Score 20 25 5 10 0 Arahad Vigor Score 25 24 5 12 5 Rich Oddman Score 27 29 3 8 4 Carlos Gonzalez Store 29 29 3 11 4 CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 6 5 0 0 Total 100 44 60 5 0 5 76 71 81 AVERAGE Geo / Enviro 66.4 Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 17 Firm Name: EAC Consulting CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson DeLeine Arshad Vlgar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 2 3 4 5 6 35 5 15 20 20 5 10 35 35 5 15 28 27 5 10 34 5 5 Total 100 4 5 64 0 5 95 5 5 80 34 5 15 4 5 97 33 33 5 14 4 5 94 AVERAGE 86.0 Shuchnal Mechanical Udliti� Traffic Survey Geo Enviro (Consulting 1s Firm Name: Eastern Engineering Group CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lea Carlon DeLeine Arshad Vlgar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 2 3 4 5 6 35 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 15 15 5 3 4 5 47 20 25 5 10 0 5 65 25 20 5 10 5 5 70 30 30 3 8 4 5 80 31 31 5 13 4 5 89 AVERAGE 70.2 Shuctural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 1s Firm Name: EBS Engineering CATEGORY Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson DeLasne ArshadCM Vlgar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Points Score Score Score ScoreScore Landscape 1 35 20 2 3 4 5 6 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 20 5 5 4 5 59 30 30 5 10 0 5 80 30 28 5 12 5 5 85 30 30 4 12 4 5 85 32 32 5 13 4 5 91 AVERAGE 80.0 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro 'Consulting 20 Firm Name: Eco Tech Consulting Reviewer Name: Criterion Point 1 2 3 4 5 35 35 5 15 5 6 5 Gerald Lee Score 15 15 3 5 4 5 Conlon DeLaine Score 30 35 5 10 0 0 Arshad Wrier Score 20 20 5 14 4 0 Rich Oddman Score Carlos Gonzalez Score 30 30 4 8 4 0 31 31 5 13 4 4 AVERAGE CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Total 100 47 ( RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 80 63 76 88 70.8 Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 21 Firm Name: H.W. Lochner CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Carlon DeLeine Arshed Vigsr Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 25 2 3 4 5 6 35 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 25 5 10 4 5 74 35 30 5 10 0 5 85 33 34 5 12 5 5 94 31 31 5 7 4 5 83 33 33 5 14 4 4 93 AVERAGE 85.8 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 22 Firm Name: Kimley Horn CATEGORY CM Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Carlon DeLaine Arahad Vlgar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Paints Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 25 2 3 4 5 6 35 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 25 5 10 4 0 69 35 35 5 15 0 0 90 35 35 5 14 5 0 94 32 32 5 10 4 0 83 32 32 5 13 4 4 90 AVERAGE 85.2 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 23 Firm Name: Landshore Enterprises CATEGORY Civil Architectural Reviewer Name: Gerald Les Carton DSLaine Arahad Vigor Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Landscape Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Structural 35 10 25 2 3 35 5 10 2 25 5 20 28 31 15 4 28 4 31 4 5 6 15 5 5 Total 100 2 4 0 28 10 0 0 65 5 4 0 48 9 2 0 71 5 13 4 4 88 AVERAGE 60.0 Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting Erosion Control 24 Firm Name: McMahon Assoc. Reviewer Name: Criterion Point Gerald Lae Score Caron DeLalne Score Arshad Vlgar Score Rich Oddman Score Carlos Gonzalez Score 1 35 20 20 29 31 32 2 35 20 20 30 31 32 3 5 5 5 5 4 5 4 15 10 15 10 9 13 5 5 4 0 5 4 CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 6 5 0 0 0 0 4 AVERAGE Geo / Enviro Total 100 59 60 79 79 90 73.4 Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 25 Firm Name: ME Engineering CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson DeLaine Arched Vigor Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Pointe Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 2 35 23 23 25 25 3 4 5 6 5 15 5 5 Total 100 5 2 4 0 57 5 15 0 0 70 28 30 31 31 31 31 5 10 5 0 78 4 9 4 0 79 5 13 4 4 88 AVERAGE 74.4 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 26 Firm Name: Nova Engineering and Environmental CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Carlon DeLeine Arched Vlger Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 18 1 2 3 4 5 6 35 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 18 5 8 4 0 53 25 30 5 15 0 0 75 21 20 5 10 4 0 60 34 34 5 11 4 0 88 31 31 5 13 4 4 88 AVERAGE 72.8 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 27 Firm Name: Nyarko Architectural Group Criterion CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson DeLaine Arched Vigar Rich Oddmen Carlos Gonzalez Arc hitectural Point Score Score Score Score Score 2 3 4 5 6 35 35 5 15 5 5 Total 100 19 19 5 10 4 5 62 35 30 5 15 0 5 90 20 20 5 10 5 5 65 27 27 3 9 4 5 75 32 32 5 13 4 5 91 AVERAGE 76.6 Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 28 Firm Name: Pistorino & Alam Consulting Reviewer Name: Criterion Points Gerald Lee Score Corion DeLaine Score Arched Viger Score Rich Oddman Score Carlos Gonzalez Score 1 35 23 30 30 30 32 2 35 23 30 30 30 32 3 5 5 5 5 3 5 4 15 10 15 10 8 13 5 5 4 0 4 4 4 CATEGORY Civic Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 6 5 0 0 0 0 4 Total 100 65 80 79 75 90 AVERAGE Geo / Enviro 77.8 Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 29 Firm Name: Premiere Design Solutions CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson DeLeine Arshad Vigar Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 25 35 31 29 32 2 35 25 30 31 29 32 3 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 15 10 15 11 9 14 5 5 4 0 5 4 4 6 5 5 5 0 5 5 AVERAGE Total 100 74 90 83 81 92 84.0 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 30 Firm Name: R.E. Chisholm Architects CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lea Cation DeLeine Arshad Agar Rlch Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 23 35 29 30 32 2 35 23 35 31 30 32 3 5 5 5 5 4 5 4 15 10 15 10 9 13 5 5 4 0 4 4 4 6 5 5 5 5 5 4 AVERAGE Total 100 70 95 84 82 90 84.2 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 31 Firm Name: Radise International Criterion CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson Detains Arshad Vlqar Rlch Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Points Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 1 35 20 35 28 29 31 2 35 20 35 29 29 31 3 5 5 5 5 4 5 4 15 10 15 10 9 13 5 5 4 0 4 4 4 6 5 5 5 5 5 5 AVERAGE Total 100 64 95 81 80 89 81.8 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 32 Firm Name: SGM Engineering Reviewer Name: Criterion Point Gerald Lee Store Cotton DeLeine Score Arshad Wrier Score Rich Oddman Score Carlos Gonzalez Score 1 35 25 35 32 30 32 2 35 25 35 32 30 32 3 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 15 10 15 10 10 13 5 5 4 0 5 4 4 CATEGORY Civil Architectural Landscape Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey 6 5 5 RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 0 5 5 AVERAGE Geo / Enviro Total 100 74 90 89 79 91 84.6 Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX 33 Firm Name: Synalovski Romanik Saye Criterion CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson D*Laine Arahad Vlgar Rich Oddmen Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Point Score Score Score Score Scare Landscape 1 35 2 3 4 5 35 5 15 5 25 25 5 10 4 35 35 5 15 0 32 32 5 12 5 30 30 5 11 4 32 32 5 13 4 6 5 Total 100 0 69 0 90 5 91 0 80 4 90 AVERAGE 84.0 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 34 Firm Name: Tierra South Florida CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Corson Dslaine Arahad Ylger Rich Oddman Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Points Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 35 1 2 3 4 35 5 15 20 20 5 10 25 30 5 10 30 29 5 10 31 31 5 11 31 31 5 13 5 5 4 0 4 4 4 6 5 Total 100 5 64 0 70 5 83 0 82 4 88 AVERAGE 77.4 Structural Mechanical Utllfties Traffic Survey Geo / Enviro Consulting 35 Firm Name: Universal Engineering Sciences CATEGORY Civil Reviewer Name: Gerald Lee Carlon DeLaine Arahad Vigor Rich Oddmen Carlos Gonzalez Architectural Criterion Point Score Score Score Score Score Landscape 35 2 3 4 5 35 5 15 5 18 18 5 8 4 35 30 5 15 0 30 29 5 10 4 32 32 5 10 4 31 32 5 13 4 6 5 0 0 0 0 4 Total 100 53 85 78 83 89 AVERAGE 77.6 Structural Mechanical Utilities Traffic Survey Geo/Enviro Consulting RFQ 20-0324200 EVALUATION MATRIX CITY OF OPA-LOCKA CERTIFICATION REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS ARCHITECTURAL & ENGINEERING CONSULTING SERVICES RFQ NO. 20-0324200 I, Joanna Flores, City Clerk of the City of Opa-locka, Florida, do hereby certify that according to the provisions of Sec. 2-320.1 of the City's Code of Ordinances, sealed proposal(s) were opened at the Office of the City Clerk, 780 Fisherman Street, 4th Floor, Opa-locka, Florida, at 2:05 p.m. this 15th day of May, 2020. UALIFICATIONS) RECEIVED *Please note: The following RFQ's were hand delivered to the City. NAME/ADDRESS 1. 2Plus Architects, Inc. 206 Andalusia Avenue Coral Gables, FL 33134 Contact: Edgardo Macchi, Principal in Charge Tel: 305-619-3277 Email: emacchi(a�2plus_a.chitect. 2. Caltran Engineering Group, Inc. 790 NW 107th Avenue Miami, FL 33172 Contact: Juan Calderon, Principal Tel: 786-456-7700 Email: icalderon(a�caltraneroua corn 3. Michael Flaugh Landscape Architect 2877 SE Ocean BLVD Stuart, FL 34996 Contact: Michael Flaugh, Principal Tel: 772-419-0024 Email: mike(�milteflaueh com 4. Perrin International Services, Inc. 12491 SW 134th Court, Unit 20 Miami, FL 33186 Contact: Gregory Perry, President Tel: 786-251-9291 Email: gpreery errin_Acorn 6 Copies/1 USB 6 Copies/1 USB 6 Copies/1 CD 6 Copies/1 CD 5. SSN Engineering, LLC 13899 Biscayne Blvd, Suite 310 North Miami Beach, FL 33181 Contact: Rubel Siddique, Director of Engineering Tel: 561-951-3864 Email: rsiddinuec ssnengineering.com 6. The Beta Jones Group, Inc. 801 Brickell Avenue, Suite 900 Miami, FL 33131 Contact: Luis Betalleluz Tel: 786-284-8828 Email: contact(&,betaiones.com 6 Copies/1 CD 6 Copies/1 C1) *Please note: The following RFQ's were submitted electronically to the City. 7. 300 Engineering Group, P.A. 3850 Bird Road, Suite 601 Miami, FL 33146 Contact: Franklin Torrealba, Director Tel: 305-602-4602 Email: fatorrealbanu,300engineering.com 8. 305 Consulting Engineers, LLC 13944 SW Bch Street, Suite 211 Miami, FL 33184 Contact: Enrique Zuniga, President Tel: 305-409-5548 Email: ezuniga(a 305consultant.com 9. BEA Architects, Inc. 3075 NW South River Drive Miami, FL 33142 Contact: Bruno -Elias Ramos, Principal -in -Charge Tel: 305-461-2053 Email: beamarketing(a,beai.com 10. Biscayne Engineering Company, Inc. 529 West Flagler Street Miami, FL 33130 Contact: Mike Bartholomew, President Tel: 305-324-7671 Email: mikeb(Oiscayneengineering.com 11. C&I Construction and Design, Inc. 13350 NW 420d Avenue, Suite 15 A Opa-locka, FL 33054 Contact: Carlos Maldonado, President Tel: 786-287-9903 Email: carlosAcicdinc.com 12. Civica Architecture 8323 NW 12th Street, Suite 106 Doral, EL 33126 Contact: Rolando Llanes, President Tel: 305-593-9959 Email: rllanesna,civicasroup.com 13. Craven Thompson & Associates, Inc. 3563 NW 53rd Street Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309 Contact: Patrick Gibney, Vice President Tel: 954-739-6400 Email: pgibney(&,craventhompson.com 14. D.L. Fields Consultants, LLC 1125 NE 125'h Street, Suite 210 North Miami, FL 33161 Contact: Debora Fields, Managing Principal Tel: 305-582-0091 Email: DeboraAdlfcarchitects.com 15. David Plummer & Associates 1750 Ponce de Leon Blvd Coral Gables, FL 33134 Contact: Timothy Plummer, President Tel: 305-447-0900 Email: tim.plummernu,dplummer.com 16. EA3 Civil Engineering, Inc. 1112 N 46th Avenue Hollywood, FL 33021 Contact: Eric Arencibia, President Tel: 754-777-7993 Email: ericarencibiaa0a3civil.com 17. EAC Consulting, Inc. (Also hand delivered) 5959 Blue Lagoon Drive, Ste. 140 Miami, FL 33126 Contact: Michael Adeife Tel: 305-265-5400 Email: madeife(,eacconsult.com 18. Eastern Engineering Group 3401 NW 82" Avenue, Suite 370 Doral, FL 33122 Contact: Raissa Lopez, President Tel: 305-599-8133 Email: raissa(a)easterneg.com 19. EBS Engineering, Inc. 4715 NW 157th Street, Suite 202 Miami, FL 33014 Contact: Benjamin Essien Tel: 305-625-5252 Email: info(a,ebsengineering.com 20. Eco Tech Consulting, LLC 556 NW 53`d Street Boca Raton, FL 33487 Contact: Bala Somasundaram, President Tel: 305-924-2260 Email: balaAecotechfl.com 21. H.W. Lochner, Inc. 8750 NW 36th Street, Suite 360 Miami, FL 33178 Contact: Edwin Mojena, Vice President Tel: 305-503-9873 Email: emoiena(a,hwlochner.com 22. Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 355 Alhambra Circle, Suite 1400 Coral Gables, FL 33134 Contact: Gary Ratay, Vice President Tel: 305-673-2025 Email: gary.ratay(aijkimley-horn.com 23. Landshore Enterprises, LLC 188 Triple Diamond BLVD., Suite A4 North Venice, FL 34275 Contact: Andre van den Berg, President Tel: 941-303-5238 Email: info(i1andshore.com 24. McMahon Associates, Inc. 8333 NW 52rd Street, Suite 450 Doral, FL 33166 Contact: R. Trent Ebersole, Vice President Tel: 305-222-1945 Email: tebersolena mcmahonassociates.com 25. ME Engineering, Inc. 11401 SW 40"' Street, Suite 301 Miami, FL 33165 Contact: Zoila Morales, President Tel: 786-275-4635 Email: zmorales(a)meengineeringc.com a 26. Nova Engineering and Environmental, LLC 4350 Oakes Road, Suite 518 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33314 Contact: Javier Jimenez, Business Unit Manager Tel: 954-424-2520 Email: ijimenez(a,usanova.com 27. Nyarko Architectural Group, Inc. 5931 NW 173rd Drive, Suite 2 Miami, FL 33015 Contact: Charles Nyarko, President Tel: 305-820-3555 Email: cn(u�nyarkoarchitects.com 28. Pistorino & Alam Consulting Engineers, Inc. 7171 SW 62"d Avenue, 46 Floor Miami, FL 33143 Contact: John Pistorino, President Tel: 305-669-2700 Email: jpistorinoApamiami.com 29. Premiere Design Solutions, Inc. 1065 NE 125'h Street, Suite 211B North Miami, FL 33161 Contact: Luis Jarado, President Tel: 954-237-7850 X701 Email: liurado(a,pds-eng.com 30. R.E. Chisholm Architects, Inc. 782 NW 42" Avenue, Suite 650 Miami, FL 33126 Contact: Robert Chisholm, Chairman/CEO Tel: 305-661-2070 Email: bob(&,,chisholmarchitects.com 31. Radise International, LC 10486 NW 31st Terrace Doral, FL 33172 Contact: Gregory Stelmack Tel: 305-989-7895 Email: Gregory.stelmack(a7,radise.net 32. SGM Engineering, Inc. 1 E. Broward Blvd, Suite 1503 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Contact: Tony Shahnami Tel: 954-451-1944 Email: tonyansgmengineering.com 33. SYNALOVSKI ROMANIK SAYE, LLC 1800 Eller Drive, Suite 500 5 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33316 Contact: Manuel Synalovski, Managing Member Tel: 954-961-6806 Email: msynalovskina,synalovski.com 34. Tierra South Florida, Inc. 16250 NW 59'h Avenue, Suite 207 Miami Lakes, FL 33014 Contact: Raj Krishnasmy, President Tel: 305-557-0708 Email: rai(a tsfgeo.com 35. Universal Engineering Sciences, LLC 9960 NW 116th Way, Suite 8 Medley, FL 33178 Contact: Reinaldo Villa, Miami Branch Manager Tel: 305-249-8434 Email: rvilla(uiuniversalengineering.com I further certify that sealed proposal(s) were submitted and properly opened in the presence of the following: Sherine Bulloc , Assistant City Cler ty City of Opa-Iocka City of Opa-locka Sha'mecca Lawson, Executive Secretary City of Opa-Iocka Airia Austin, Public Works Director Joanna Flores, CMC City Clerk Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services - DemandStar Page 1 of 2 Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services Under Evaluation 80 1833 0 7 2 Planholders Broadcasted to Supplemental Suppliers Watchers Post Bid Viewers Bid Details Agency Name City of Opa-locka Bid Writer Airia Austin Bid ID RFQ-20-0324200-0-2020/AA Bid Type Request for Qualifications Broadcast Date 02/23/2020 4:00 AM Eastern Fiscal Year 2020 Due 05/15/2020 2:00 PM Eastern Bid Status Text None Scope of Work To establish a library of Licensed Architects and Engineers to provide Architectural and Engineering Services for the City of Opa- locka. Documents Filename Type Date Modified Status Addendum 05 Addendum 04/27/2020 Complete Addendum•04 Addendum 04/08/2020 Complete Addendum 03 Addendum 03/24/2020 Complete addendum-i)2 Addendum 03/16/2020 Complete Addendum 01 Addendum 03/16/2020 Complete RFQ No 2U-o324200 Bid Document / 02 21 2020 / / Complete Specifications Distribution Info Bid Bond Plan (blueprint) None Electronic plan documents https://www.demandstar.com/beta/buyers/bids/372200/detai is 6/8/2020 Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services - DemandStar Page 2 of 2 E-Bidding No Distributed By DemandStar Distribution Method Download and Mail Distribution Options Uploading electronic plan files (.plt, .dwg, dwf) Project Estimated Budget S0.00 Distribution Notes None Publications Miami Herald - Neighbors Ji fly., Legal Ad Pre -Bid Conference 0 No Pre -Bid Conference Available Statistics Planholders There are 80 Planholders for this bid. Filtered No Broadcast List 1833 Suppliers have been notified Post -Bid Viewers There are 2 Post -Bid viewers Supplemental Suppliers 0 Supplemental Suppliers Commodity Code E<port [002-019-001 AGRICULTURAL CROPS AND GRAINS, INCLUDING FRUITS, MELONS, NUTS, AND VEGETABLES [002-020-001 AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT, IMPLEMENTS, AND ACCESSORIES (SEE CLASS 022 FOR PARTS) [002-022-001 AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND IMPLEMENT PARTS [002-040-O0J ANIMALS, BIRDS, MARINE LIFE, INSECTS AND POULTRY, LIVE, INCLUDING ACCESSORY ITEMS [002-325-001 FEED, BEDDING, VITAMINS AND SUPPLEMENTS FOR ANIMALS (SEE CLASS 875 FOR DRUGS AND PHARMACEUTICALS FOR ANIMALS) https://www.demandstar.com/beta/buyers/bids/372200/details 6/8/2020 EVALUATION FORM RFQ No. 20-0324200 Architectural and Engineering Consulting Services By signing this form as an Evaluator, I certify that 1 have no conflict of interest. Reviewer Name: Signature: Date: a j c5 d,vz-/i (_-G `L a • Z • ZO'�C Firm Name: Q2 Z * / r Criterion Points Max. NOTES: i Consultant's background, qualifications, credentials and in-house expertise, factoring in the proposed Proposer team's current workload and experience working together on similar category. 3 / POlnts 35 2 Staff Experience and resumes of team's personnel, including assigned Project manager's experience in planning, designing and construction administration Services. 35 3 Previous experience working with local regulatory, permitting agencies and govemmental clients. S 5 4 Project control tools utilized to maintain schedule, quality and cost controls and construction management activities. /3 15 5 Local Business Preference 4 5 6 CBE or SBE Preference. 6I• 5 Firm Name:03 `�/'7ar.7 4; Sjrt e-•e,—i7 Criterion Points rGrl,'71G • ,1 e n / Cfv, L.t•., • !r �t� sY t u.--o. /% •• ✓1 d rt Aft • G v r c. ! c a-j- • �Xce• iSa - rpp `T avlor- e N 90>�•y�j (rt, Y%i J/41 /1v%7rtoe<t /a L�fY,7f At rLolrtc►�•+ - S G-. Max. NOTES: 1 Consultant's background, qualifications, credentials and in-house expertise, factoring in the proposed Proposer team's current workload and experience working together on similar category. 3 , r u 35 2 Staff Experience and resumes of team's personnel, including assigned Project manager's experience in planning, designing and construction administration Services. 3'35 3 Previous experience working with local regulatory, permitting agencies and govemmental clients. sr 5 4 Project control tools utilized to maintain schedule, quality and cost controls and construction management activities. 3 15 5 Local Business Preference 4. 5 6 CBE or SBE Preference. S^ 5 Firm Name: CV ,vf+ c _he v/ /4"-- ec-‘,,� # �Q, SGA,D e Criterion Points Max. 1 Consultant's background, qualifications, credentials and in-house expertise, factoring in the proposed Proposer team's current workload and experience working together on similar category. Z7 1,11114) � 35 2 Staff Experience and resumes of team's personnel, including assigned Project manager's experience in planning, designing and construction administration Services. 0 35 3 Previous experience working with local regulatory, permitting agencies and govemmental clients. 5' 5 4 Project control tools utilized to maintain schedule, quality and cost controls and construction management activities. /.3 15 5 Local Business Preference %e 5 6 CBE or SBE Preference. 5- 5 Elvinc/ _ma • 2-01 • e el • `�r-t • 4• frI'✓C.l� �j NOTES: CQ cal ,SGC(,AQE • /-/" ,r w r loot /4 .4.4 aso Jit .t�7,t iN ,S✓✓fit l-i 'i 4/7 0J2 ita-4.ir / / ` j/YJ. ��E V A L U U A T I O N F O R M F i r m N a m e : � �� r r / r J _ r 1 - 7 ` 9 - s . h ��'