Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 17-2604 Renee Basel From:Jonathan O'Boyle <jonathanroboyle@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, November 16, 2017 12:03 PM To:Trey Nazzaro; Rita Taylor; Renee Basel; Jonathan O'Boyle; Jonathan O'Boyle Subject:Public Records Request Attachments:Stop Dirty Government Records Request 11.16.17.docx; Request Exhibits.pdf; Landscape Correspondence Ganger.pdf Dear Records Custodian, on behalf of Stopdirtygovernment, LLC, I submit the attached public records requests for production ASAP. Enclosed are instructions for the Request and copies of public records of the Town of Gulf Stream which we would like to receive certified copies. I will note, that the attachment containing exhibits are merely demonstrative and for the Town's assistance in identifying the public records requested. As for Exhibit 25, that original public record is in the Ganger Transfer file on the Town's website under the document that I believe is entitled Development Correspondence O'Boyle. I will also note that the requests for electronic records should be readily available since we are asking for copies of requests already transmitted to other requestors (with the exception of the fourth request). The requests are not aggregated and we would like production as soon as the records can be produced since time is at-issue. We do not desire to have the Town complete the entire request first and then transmit everything at once. As for Payment, I will send a courier to the Town to submit payment for the certified copies and any other lawful fees. The Courier will contact the Town later today to touch base and work out the details. Thank you ever so kindly for your prompt attention. If you have any questions please email me back at this address -- Jonathan O’Boyle, Esq., LLM. The O’Boyle Law Firm, P.C. www.oboylelawfirm.com joboyle@oboylelawfirm.com Pennsylvania Office 1001 Broad St. Johnstown, PA 15906 1 Tel: 814-535-5175 Fax: 215-893-3641 New Jersey Office 10 Grove St. Haddonfield, NJ 08033 Tel: 814-535-5175 Fax: 215-893-3641 Florida Office 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Office: 954-570-3533 Fax: 754-212-2444 IRS Circular 230 disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any tax advice contained in this communication, unless expressly stated otherwise, was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding tax-related penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any tax-related matter(s) addressed herein. =========================================================== NOTICE TO RECIPIENT: THIS E-MAIL IS MEANT FOR ONLY THE INTENDED RECIPIENT OF THE TRANSMISSION, AND MAY BE A COMMUNICATION PRIVILEGED BY LAW. IF YOU RECEIVED THIS E- MAIL IN ERROR, ANY REVIEW, USE, DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION, OR COPYING OF THIS E-MAIL IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. PLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY OF THE ERROR BY RETURN E-MAIL AND PLEASE DELETE THIS MESSAGE FROM YOUR SYSTEM. THANK YOU IN ADVANCE FOR YOUR COOPERATION. 2 StopDirtyGovernment, LLC - Public Records Request 11.16.17 for Litigation Resuming on Monday, November 20, 2017. 1.Certified Copies of the Town’s public records reflected in Exhibits 18-23, 25 – that were th admitted into evidence in case 2014CA003721 in the 15 Judicial Circuit styled Stopdirtygovernment, LLC v. Town of Gulf Stream. (Attached Hereto). Specifically for Exhibit 25, we would like a certified color 1 copy that duplicates the document as shown on the Town’s website. 2.Certified copy of an April 23, 2013, letter and enclosures sent by Mr. Thrasher to Ms. Brown with a carbon copy to Mr. Ganger entitled “Re: Landcape Plan for 1465 North Ocean Blvd.” That document is most likely found in the building development file for 1465 North Ocean Blvd. (A copy is attached hereto). 3.A certified copy of Freda Defosse’s resignation letter to the Town of Gulf Stream. 4.Electronic copies of Freda Defosse’s time sheets and/or public records reflecting the amount of time Ms. Defosse worked for the Months of January and February 2014. 5.Electronic Copies of: (1) Town of Gulf Stream Request 587; (2) the initial response given to Request 587 on or about 2/3/2014; (3) any communication from Jones Foster to the O’Boyle Law Firm regarding Request 587 between March 1, 2014 and March 25, 2014 \[particularly from Ashlee Richman\]; (4) the cover page and public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm in March 2014 by Jones Foster in response to Request 587 and/or because of the litigation initiated pursuant to this request \[tip: March 12, 2014 is believed to be the date of transmission\]. 6.Electronic Copies of the request and response to Request 749 which was sent on March 28, 2014. 7.Certified Copies of a Request and Response 1671 made by Asset Enhancement, Inc. in December of 2014 which regarded Sweetapple’s November Billing Records. In addition to certified copies of redacted billings, it is also requested that a certified copy of the unredacted billings be provided as well. 1 The Highlighted requests are very time sensitive and are needed immediately. In addition, if electronic copies of records are sought, please email them to records@commerce-group.com; joboyle@oboylelawfirm.com; wring@oboylelawfirm.com; and moboyle@commerce-group.com TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail November 16, 2017 Jonathan O’Boyle [e-mail to: jonathanroboyle@gmail.com] Re: GS #2604 (Public Records Request for Litigation Resuming on Monday, November 20, 2017 (5)) 5. Electronic Copies of: (1) Town of Gulf Stream Request 587; (2) the initial response given to Request 587 on or about 2/3/2014; (3) any communication from Jones Foster to the O’Boyle Law Firm regarding Request 587 between March 1, 2014 and March 25, 2014 [particularly from Ashlee Richman]; (4) the cover page and public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm in March 2014 by Jones Foster in response to Request 587 and/or because of the litigation initiated pursuant to this request [tip: March 12, 2014 is believed to be the date of transmission]. Dear Jonathan O’Boyle [e-mail to: jonathanroboyle@gmail.com] The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated November 16, 2017. The original public records request can be found at the following link: http://www2.gulf-stream.org/weblink/0/doc/113870/Page1.aspx The Town will use its very best efforts to respond to you in a reasonable amount of time with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Reneé Rowan Basel As requested by Rita Taylor Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. <JOConnor@jonesfoster.com> Sent:Friday, December 8, 2017 3:44 PM To:Jonathan O'Boyle Cc:Renee Basel; Trey Nazzaro; Macfarlane, Mary Subject:Gulf Stream PRR GS 2604 Attachments:1KS9911-oboyle re prr 434.pdf; 20140325134015173.pdf Dear Jonathan – Please allow this and my subsequent emails to respond to your Public Records Request to the Town of Gulf Stream that seeks the following: Electronic Copies of: (1) Town of Gulf Stream Request 587; (2) the initial response given to Request 587 on or about 2/3/2014; (3) any communication from Jones Foster to the O’Boyle Law Firm regarding Request 587 between March 1, 2014 and March 25, 2014 \[particularly from Ashlee Richman\]; (4) the cover page and public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm in March 2014 by Jones Foster in response to Request 587 and/or because of the litigation initiated pursuant to this request \[tip: March 12, 2014 is believed to be the date of transmission\]. Attached to this email are electronic copies of (1) Request 587 and (2) the Town’s initial, 2/3/14 response to that request. (if you seek the cover email that accompanied that 2/3/14 response, please advise). Additional records will follow by subsequent email. Regards, Joane Joanne M. O’Connor Florida Bar Board Certified Business Litigation Attorney Telephone: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 i pa TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail February 3, 2014 Martin E. O'Boyle [FAX: 954-360-0807] Re: Public Records Request #434 — Scott Morgan Communications Provide a copy of all communications and Public Records (as defined in FS Chapter 119) sent by or received by Scott Morgan of the Architectural Review and Planning Board of the Town of Gulf Stream for the period beginning January 1, 2012 through the date of this Request. The above request shall include Text Messages and E -Mails from private accounts. Dear Mr. O'Boyle, This letter is in response to the public records you have requested in your email dated January 24, 2014, that we acknowledged January 24, 2014. There are 5, 8%2 x 11, one-sided documents that are included with this fax cover page. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records The Town's acknowledgement of the above Public Records Request dated January 24 2014 is reproduced in the space below: TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail January 24, 2014 Martin E. O'Boyle [records@commerce-group.com Re: Public Records Request #434 — Scott Morgan Communications Provide a copy of all communications and Public Records (as defined in FS Chapter 119) sent by or received by Scott Morgan of the Architectural Review and Planning Board of the Town of Gulf Stream for the period beginning January 1, 2012 through the date of this Request. The above request shall include Text Messages and E -Mails from private accounts. Dear Mr. O'Boyle [records@commerce-group.com, The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated January 24, 2014. If your request was received in writing, then the first page of that request is attached to this cover letter. If your request was verbal, then the description of your public records request is set forth in the space below. Our staff will review your request within the next three business days, and we will promptly send you the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records Town of Gulf Stream attn. William Thrasher 100 Sea Rd. Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Dear Bill: RECEIVED SCOTT W. MORGAN DEC 16 -21013 1140 N. Ocean Blvd (OM Of GulfstreamF► Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Ph (561) 243-1432 December 13, 2013 Re: Request for Input on Design Manual Changes In response to your request for input on the Design Manual, I read over the Code and, frankly, believe it to be a well written and comprehensive document that has served the Town well for many years. It gives specific guidance to architects, contractors and residents on acceptable design. I would hope a decision is made to keep the existing Manual and modify it only as needed. In particular, I believe that changing the Design Manual to eliminate the specific, itemized Requirements/Prohibitions and instead adding broad, discretion based rules would be a mistake; such rules do not give sufficient guidance and they also open up the Town to allegations of abuse of discretion. That much being said, I suggest consideration be given to modifying the following sections: Article VII, Division 2, Spanish Mediterranean Revival Style Sec. 70-218 Roofs -(d) Prohibited Add the word "metal" Delete the phrase "on the streetside " that follows solar panels Article VII, Division 3, Gulf Stream Bermuda Stvle Sec. 70-238 Roofs -(a) Required After the phrase: slate -like tile, Add "or other dark color tile." -(d) Prohibited Add the word "metal" Add "solar panels" Very truly yours, 1 ott W. org V FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET SCOTT W. MONGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd GULF STRE",, FL 33483 PIS (561)-7S24936 FAX (801)-760-2'777 Date: 7-23-13 To: Town of Gulf Stream Fax: 561-737-0188 From: Scott W. Morgan Re: ,Application for Level 3 approval of Lot 5- Hidden Harbour Estates Number of pages: 3 Memo; Please fired attached my letter in opposition to this application. Would you please make copies of the letter for distribution to tate members of the ARPB? SCOTT W..2 ORGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd YuY!- ream, FL 33483 Ph (561) 243-.1432 July 23, 2013 To: Town of Gulf Stream Architectural .review and :Planning Board Re: Hidden Harbour Estates Lot 5 1224 N. Ocean Blvd. Dear Board Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Architectural/Site Flan Review of 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec, 66-144 (b)(!0)09 The proposed architectural design of this hone violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures_ The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than of an ocean West District home. Because the lot is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale_ The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. Sec. 70-4 (c)(4) and Sec. 70-29 (b)(3) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's prohibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Code's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or duality of the zoning district within which they are located ...."(Art. 'I, Sec. 70-4 (c )(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "bits that are set back great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district." (Art. II, Sec. 70-29 (b)(3)}. The homes of this District have a unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Hidden Harbour Estates—all of which are rectangular, long East to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other life two rows of domino tiles --has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- community sub -division, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Raton and West Delray Beach. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all corner lots and so Were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes on adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. In order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West District character, and to prevent an over -crowding of similar homes inside Hidden. )Harbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review of Lot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re -submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, ott W Marga Bill Thrasher From: Bill Thrasher Sent: Friday, January 24, 2014 5:36 PM To: 'records@commerce-group.com' Subject: Public Records Request #434 — Scott Morgan Communications Attachments: Public Records Request #434 — Scott Morgan Communications_intake.pdf Transmission Report Date/Time 02-03-2014 03:17:11 p.m. Transmit Header Text Local ID 1 5617370188 Local Name 1 Fax This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size : 8.5"x11 " TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail February 3, 2014 Martin E. O'Boyle [FAX: 954-360-0807] Re: Public Records Request #434 — Scott TUorgan Communications Provide a copy grall communications and public Records (as defined in FS Chapter 119) sent by or received by Scott Morgan ofthe Arehitectural Review and Plann ing Board of the Town of GstfSt4reawfor the period beginningJanva y 1, 2012 through the date oflhlsRequest. The above request shall include Text Messages andE-Mails from privote accounts. Dear Mr. O'Boyle, This letter is in response to the public records you have requested in your email dated January 24, 2014, that we acknowledged January 24, 2014. There are 5, B%2 x 11, one-sided documents that are included with this fax cover page, Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records Total Pages Scanned : 8 Total Pages Confirmed : 8 No. Job RemateStation StartTimeDuration Pages Line Mode Job Type Results 001 443 19543600807 03:14:50 p.m.02-03-2014 00:01:46 8/8 1 EC HS CP24000 Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fail G3: Group WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct 5617370188 Fax 03:15.28 p.m. 02-03-2014 118 TowN of GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via &4a" February 3, 2014 Martin E. O'Boyle [FAX: 954-360-0807] Re: Public Records Request #434 — Scott Morgan Communications Provide a copy of all commtmications and Public Records (as defuned in F'S Chapter 119) sent by or received by Scott Morgan of the Architectural Review and Planning Board of ti►e Town of Gulf Stream for the period beginning January 1, 2012 through the date of this Request. The above request shall include Text Messages and E Mails from private accounts. Dear Mr. O'Boyle, This letter is in response to the public records you have requested in your email dated January 24, 2014, that we acknowledged January 24, 2014. There are 5, 8'l2 x 11, one-sided documents that are included with this fax cover page. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records 5617370188 Fax 03:16:07 p.m. 02-03-2014 418 6> -RECEIVED -1 SCOTT W. MORGAN DEC 16 2013 1144 N. Ocean Blvd Town of Gulfstream, FL Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Ph (561) 243-1432 December 13, 2013 Town of Gulf Stream attn. William Thrasher 100 Sea Rd. Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: Request for Input on Design Manual Changes Dear Bill: In response to your request for input on the Design Manual, I read over the Code and, frankly, believe it to be a well written and comprehensive document that has served the Town well for many years. It gives specific guidance to architects, contractors and residents on acceptable design. I would hope a decision is made to keep the existing Manual and modify it only as needed. In particular, I believe that changing the Design Manual to eliminate the specific, itemized RequirementslProhibitions and instead adding broad, discretion based rules would be a mistake; such rules do not give sufficient . guidance and they also open up the Town to allegations of abuse of discretion. That much being said, I suggest consideration be given to modifying the following sections: Article VII, Division 2. Spanish Mediterranean Revival Style Sec. 70-218 Roofs -(d) Prohibited Add the word "metal" Delete the phrase "on the streetside " that follows solar panels Article VII, Division 3, Gulf Stream Bermuda Style Sec. 70-238 Roofs -(a) Required After the phrase: slate -like tile, Add "or other dark color tile." 5617570188 Fax 03:16:23 p.m. 02-03-2014 5/8 -(d) Prohibited Add the word "metal" Add "solarpanew, Very truly yours, jOtt�%Y� W. rg q 5617370188 Fax 03:16:27 pm. 02-03-2014 FA,CSIMII.E TRANSiV MAL STIRET SCOTT W. MORGAN 1140 N. Oaean .81vd GULFSTRE",, FL 33483 PH (36f)-75,21936 FAX (807)-750-2777 Date: 7-23-13 To: Town of Gulf Stream Fax: 561-737-0188 From: Scott W, Morgan Re: Application for Level 3 approval of Lot 5- Hidden Harbour Estates Number of pages: 3 Memo: Please find attached my letter in opposition to this application. Would you please make copies of the letter for distribution to the members ofthe.ARPH? 6!8 . 4 5617370188 Fax 03:16:38 p.m. 02-03-2014 718 SCOTT W. MORGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd GalfS&eany .FL 33483 Ph (S61) 243-1432 July 23, 2013 To. Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Hoard Re: Hidden Harbour Estates Loi S 1224 N. Ocean Blvd. Dear Board Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review of a 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec, 66-144 (b)(100 The proposed architectural design ofthis home violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures. The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than ofan Ocean West District home. Because the lot is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale. The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. Sec. 70-4 (c)(4) and Sec. 70-29 (6)(9) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's probibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Codc's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located... ."(Art. 1, Sec. 70-4 (c )(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "lots that are set back great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district" (Art. U, Seo. 70-29 (b)(3)). The homes ofthis District have a. unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Midden Harbour Estates—all of which are rectangular, long East to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other like two rows of domino tiles—has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- r 5617370188 Fax 03:16:58 p.m. 02-03-2014 818 community sub -division, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Paton and West Delmy Beach. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all Corner lots and so were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes on adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. In order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West Aistriat character, and to prevent an over -crowding of similar homes inside Hidden Harbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review ofLot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re -submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, " ott W Morga Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. <JOConnor@jonesfoster.com> Sent:Friday, December 8, 2017 4:00 PM To:Jonathan O'Boyle Cc:Renee Basel; Trey Nazzaro; Macfarlane, Mary Subject:Gulf Stream PRR GS 2604 Dear Jonathan – Please allow this email to respond in part to your Public Records Request to the Town of Gulf Stream that seeks the following: Electronic Copies of: (1) Town of Gulf Stream Request 587; (2) the initial response given to Request 587 on or about 2/3/2014; (3) any communication from Jones Foster to the O’Boyle Law Firm regarding Request 587 between March 1, 2014 and March 25, 2014 \[particularly from Ashlee Richman\]; (4) the cover page and public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm in March 2014 by Jones Foster in response to Request 587 and/or because of the litigation initiated pursuant to this request \[tip: March 12, 2014 is believed to be the date of transmission\]. Below is a sharefile link to electronic copies of public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm on March 12, 2014 in response to Request 587. Those public records were hand delivered and not accompanied by a cover letter. Their receipt was acknowledged by Attorney Mesa as reflected in the emails that will be produced in response to part (3) of your request. https://jones-foster.sharefile.com/d-s3bde9f85df947c38 Regards, Joanne Joanne M. O’Connor Florida Bar Board Certified Business Litigation Attorney Telephone: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET SCOTT W. MORGAN .1140 N. Ocean P.Ivd GULFSTREAM, FL 33483 PH (S61)-752.1, 936 FAX (801)-760-2777 Date: 7-23-13 '.><'o: Town of Gulf Stream Fax: 561-737-0188 From: Scott W. Morgan Re: Application for revel 3 approval of Lot 5- Hidden Harbour Estates Number of pages: 3 Memo: Please find attached ;my letter in opposition to this application. Would you please make copies of the letter for distribution to the members of the A PB? SCOTT W. MORGAN 1140 N Ocean Blvd Gulf Stre=4 FL 33483 Ph (561) 243-1432 July 23, 2013 To: Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board Re: Hidden Harbovr :Estates Lot 3 1224 N. Ocean Blvd. Dear Board Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Acchitectural/Site Plan Review of a 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec. 66-144 (b)(10){1) The proposed architectural design of this home violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures. The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than of an Ocean West District home. Because the lot is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale. The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. Sec. 70-4 (c)(4) and Sec. 70-29 (b)(3) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's prohibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Code's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located, _.."(Art. L Sec. 70-4 (c )(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "lots that are set back great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district." (Art, II, Sec. 70-29 (b)(3)),, The homes of this District have a unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Midden Harbour Estates—all of which are rectangular, long East to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other like two rows of domino tiles—has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- community sub -division, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Raton and West Delray Beach,. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all corner lots and so were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes on adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. b order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West District character, and to prevent an over -crowding of similar homes inside hidden Barbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 Axchitectural/Site Plan Review of Lot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re -submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, ott W Morga CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley January 19. 2012 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 26, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 12-22-11. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. February 23, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. March 22, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. f. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges Marsh & Associates, as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. Curtiss Roach, the owners of property located at 3560 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, 33483, which is legally described as Lot 3, Block 2, Polo Fields. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS to permit two, one-story additions to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling, each of which would encroach 2.3 feet into the north side setback, and also to permit a single story addition to the same dwelling that would encroach 2.8 feet into the south side setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of three one-story additions, 809 square feet, to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling with two of the additions encroaching 2.3 feet into the north side setback and one addition encroaching 2.8 feet into the south side setback, and to permit the reconfiguration of the driveway. VII. Items Related to Previous Approvals. A. Revision of an approved renovation at 554 Palm Way submitted by Mark Marsh as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. James Davis to permit the elimination of a 2 -story garage with storage/guest room and the addition of a second story above the existing garage for storage/guest room. AGENDA CONTINUED VIII. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Section 70-238, Roofs 2. Section 70-100, Roof & Eave Heights 3. Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures 4. Section 66-367, Swimming Pools 5. Section 66-369, Docks 6. Section 66-1, Definitions 7. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio 8. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements 9. Section 70-4, How To Use This Manual IX. Items by Board Members. X. Public. XI. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, DECEMBER 22, 2011 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:30 A. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Ganger called the Meeting to order at Robert W. Ganger Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Thomas M. Stanley Amanda Jones Paul Lyons, Jr. William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Hassan Tajalli of Ames Architectural Design William Allis Tom Laudani of Seaside Builders Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Alternate Member Alternate Member Board Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent for McCrady 3883 Bermuda Lane 46 Agent for Arscott & Harbor View Estates Town Consultant III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 11-17-11. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of November 17, 2011. There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice -Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes to the Agenda. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. January 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 23, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. March 22, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. f. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. There were no conflicts with meeting schedule. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if any applications have been submitted for the January 26th Public Hearing. Clerk Taylor said there were no applications at this time. Chairman Ganger announced that he would request declarations of ex -parte communication prior to each matter for public hearing. He asked if Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 2 there has been ex -parte communication concerning the application by Hassan Tajalli for Mr. and Mrs. McCrady. Chairman Ganger stated that he only drove by the property. There were no additional declarations of ex -parte communication. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to Hassan Tajalli, William Allis, Tom Laudani and Marty Minor. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Caroline Rudolf or Hassan Tajalli as agent for Mr.& Mrs. William McCrady, owners of the property located at 3883 Bermuda Lane, Apt. 8, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Bermuda Club of Gulf Stream Condo 48, to consider the following: a. VARIANCE to permit the addition of outside emergency stairs attached to the south end of the existing building that will encroach three feet (3') into the required fifteen foot (15') setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of aluminum emergency stairs attached to the south end of the existing building which would encroach approximately 3' into the required setback. Mr. Tajalli introduced himself and stated that he represents Mr. and Mrs. McCrady in this matter. He said the McCradys feel that, in the event of an emergency, they may not be able to safely exit their unit and are requesting a variance to add outside emergency stairs to be bolted to the south end of the existing building. Mr. Tajalli said the emergency stairs will be accessed from their master bedroom through a window which will be converted to a swing -out, lockable door and will match the main entry door. Mr. Tajalli stated that a neighbor reviewed the initial drawings which indicated a protrusion of almost 4' past the edge of the building and he was concerned that the protrusion would impact his privacy and property value. He explained that there was enough space to push the stairs back so that they now clear the corner of the building and the only extension is to the south, which is heavily vegetated and has the least amount of traffic. Mr. Tajalli said the stairs will not be obtrusive to the landscaping; however, they may have to cut out a portion of the sodded area and replace it with concrete pads in order to bolt down the stairs. Mr. Smith asked about the existing storage units. Mr. Tajalli said the shed area will be removed and totally eliminated. Chairman Ganger asked about the construction timeframe, including the construction to convert the window to a door. Mr. Tajalli said it would be about two days. Mr. Tajalli asked that the Board consider the age and health of the occupants and explained that Mrs. McCrady has health issues, she recently had hip surgery and she suffers from anxiety. Vice -Chairman Morgan said this is a variance to the Code and in order to qualify for a variance the applicant must meet all eight (8) hardships. He said the Town Manager Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 3 believes this application does not appear to comply with five (5) code sections. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he believes there are three (3) sections that are not proven and that there is nothing unique or different from others where they are suffering some sort of disadvantage by the original design of the building. Mr. Randolph said that hardship runs with the land and not the individual. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if there were any comments from neighbors. Clerk Taylor said that Mr. Allis, who is present at this hearing, stopped by Town Hall to review the drawings and had some objections. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Tajalli if he thought others in the building would come forward with the same request if this were approved and Mr. Tajalli said it is possible. Mr. Smith asked if the Condo Association had addressed this matter. Mr. Tajalli said Mrs. McCrady gave him a letter of authorization from the Association. Mr. Stanley said if the Town approves this application the Condo Association still has the right to reject it. He asked Mr. Tajalli if they discussed moving the stairs. Mr. Tajalli said they want them in the proposed location because the only window is in the master bedroom. Chairman Ganger asked how they would currently exit their unit in an emergency. Mr. Tajalli explained that the only door exits from the kitchen area onto a catwalk and then down a stair case to the sidewalk. Mr. William Allis introduced himself saying he resides in Unit 46 which is just below the McCradys in Unit 48. He said he just learned of this construction a week ago and it was unacceptable as it was first presented because he felt it would intrude on his privacy and lower his property value. Mr. Allis also stated that he is on the Association Board and he said it was mentioned that this is what the McCradys were asking for, but the Board has not specifically voted on this. He said his concerns have been resolved and he no longer objects, but he was looking for information because he believes there is a pipe in that location which cannot be found. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if there was a survey issue and Clerk Taylor said she asked the architect for a new survey and they had one done just for that corner. Mr. Thrasher stated that his report stands as submitted and that his recommendation is for the Board to recommend denial of the request for a variance in that a hardship has not been proven on items 1, 2, 4, 7 & 8. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to recommend denial of a variance to permit the addition of outside emergency stairs attached to the south end of the existing building that will encroach three feet into the required fifteen foot setback based on the finding that required variance standards 1, 2, 4, 7, and 8 are not met. There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice -Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to recommend denial of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan to permit the addition of aluminum emergency stairs attached to the south end of the existing building which will encroach approximately 3' into the required setback based on the finding that the required variance standards 1, 3, 4, 7 and 8 are not Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 4 met. There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice - Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. Clerk Taylor stated that the Town Commission will hear this application at their Regular Meeting and Public Hearing which is scheduled for Friday, January 13, 2012 at 9:00 A.M. 2. An application submitted by Seaside Builders, Tom Laudani, as agent for John Arscott, owner of property located at 582 Palm Way, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lots 24 and 23A Polo Cove Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. SIGN REVIEW to permit installation of a contractors sign, Seaside Builders, at the above address that shall not exceed 2 square feet in size and be white background with black lettering. Chairman Ganger asked for declaration of ex -parte communication. There were no declarations. Tom Laudani of Seaside Builders introduced himself and explained that he is requesting a standard contractors sign at 582 Palm Way which will be 2 SF in size and will conform to Town Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve a sign permit for erection of a contractors sign based on a finding that the proposed sign meets the requirements of Code Section 66-447, subject to a maximum height of 4' and maximum 2 SF sign size. There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice -Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. 3. An application submitted by Seaside Builders, Tom Laudani, as agent for Harbor View Estates, owner of property located at 1220 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lots 4, 5 & N. 96' of 6, Golf Course Addition, Gulf Stream, Florida a. SIGN REVIEW to permit installation of a contractors sign, Seaside Builders, at the above address that shall not exceed 2 square feet in size and be white background with black lettering. Chairman Ganger asked for declaration of ex -parte communication. There were no declarations. Mr. Laudani explained that he is requesting a standard contractors sign at 1220 N. Ocean Blvd. which will be 2 SF in size and will conform to Town Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if there is any construction going on at this point. Mr. Laudani said the gates are up, they are working to stabilize the site and the property has been seeded. He said road construction is expected to begin within the next six weeks. Mr. Laudani said the sign will identify the site and will indicate Seaside as the exclusive builder. He said the sign will remain through the completion of construction, including the construction of homes. Mr. Laudani said realtors will have individual signs which will be separate from the contractors sign. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that several vehicles have been parked there. Mr. Laudani said he was aware of that, but they are not associated with Seaside Builders. He said no work vehicles will be Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 5 parked there until such time as the hammerhead construction begins. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if the Town has received the drawings and architectural history which was previously requested by the ARPB. Clerk Taylor confirmed that it has been received. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Laudani if they will be doing any irrigation. Mr. Laudani said he realizes there have been complaints about the dusty conditions due to the seed being folded into the top soil and he assured the Board that watering would begin no later than Tuesday, December 27th. Mr. Thrasher said sooner would be best. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve a sign permit for erection of a contractors sign based on a finding that the proposed sign meets the requirements of Code Section 66-447, subject to a maximum height of 4 feet and a maximum 2 SF sign size. There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice -Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. VII. Items by Staff. A. Recommended Comprehensive Plan Amendments 1. Future Land Use Element 2. Transportation Element 3. Housing Element 4. Infrastructure Element a. Sanitary Sewer Sub -Element b. Solid Waste Sub -Element C. Drainage & Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge Sub - Element d. Potable Water Sub -Element 5. Coastal Management Element 6. Conservation Element 7. Recreation & Open Space Element 8. Intergovernmental Coordination Element 9. Capital Improvement Element Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios prepared a Summary of Amendments to the Town of Gulf Stream Comp Plan which was distributed to the ARPB Members in their meeting packet. He said the Town Commission reviewed the proposed amendments to the Comp Plan and Zoning Code at their December meeting and their direction was to move forward and present the proposed amendments to the Architectural Review and Planning Board (ARPB). Mr. Minor explained that the ARPB will make their recommendations to the Local Planning Agency (LPA). The LPA will decide whether to send the amendments to the State and other required agencies, such as the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council and Palm Beach County. The agencies will have 30 days to review the amendments and make comments and then it will come back to the Town. The Town Commission will then make the decision to either adopt or deny the amendments. Mr. Minor said the annexation of 16.6 acres created changing conditions within the Town and, in addition, the State Legislature has made massive changes to their growth management plan. He said the University of Florida (BEER) estimates that 98 permanent residents live within the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 6 annexed area, which includes 102 existing dwelling units, 34 approved but not yet built units, and less than an acre of vacant land. The annexed area currently has a future land use designation of Palm Beach County HR -12 (High Residential -12) which allows 12 units per acre. Mr. Minor said the recommendation is to change that to the Town's current future land use of MF (Multi -Family), which allows 5.7 units per acre and is consistent with other multi -families within the Town. He said no commercial or industrial future land uses exist or are projected for Gulf Stream and that the Town of Gulf Stream is essentially built -out and will experience only minor fluctuations in populations. Mr. Minor said the Level of Service for the provision of recreation facilities, private and public, will be revised from 0.23 acre per person to 0.1 acre per person, noting that the general standard is 5 acres of recreation per 1000 residents. Chairman Ganger asked if the general standard differentiates between recreational areas which are open to the public versus those that are private. Mr. Minor said it does differential and he stated that one of the options provided through growth management legislation is to be able to review and incorporate this information into the Comp Plan. He said someone could convert a recreational facility into something else without affecting the level of service, but if they did so at the present time they would have to amend the Town's Comp Plan to address that type of provision of recreational services. Chairman Ganger said he was not sure that the Comp Plan should contemplate population growth. He said Gulf Stream does not want to grow and the reason the Town decided to annex the 16.6 acres of unincorporated Palm Beach County was to prevent that area from overgrowth. Mr. Minor pointed out some additional items saying that during the summer the State Legislature made concurrency optional. He said none of the local governments took that option, they are still part of the concurrency system and the Town is taking this opportunity to strengthen their concurrency management system within its Comp Plan. With regard to non -conforming densities, Mr. Minor said there are densities ranging from 8 units to 16.5 units per acre within the annexed area and the Town's density is 5.7 units per acre. He said there is a clause in the Comp Plan that if an entire building was destroyed due to a hurricane or an act of God they can rebuild as is. In addition, he said throughout the Comp Plan some of the time frames have been eliminated, such as those associated with certain actions or studies for situations involving historic preservation or the creation of standards for the citing of group homes. The State Law has changed and, although it is still a goal within the State Growth Management Laws, there is no longer an emphasis on immediacy, which allows local governments to decide when they want to move forward with such studies. Chairman Ganger commented that not long after the first Comp Plan a goal was set to have historic preservation as a guide in the decision process in situations such as the Spence Estate. He said there should be something in the Comp Plan concerning historic preservation before the Town loses more of their historic homes. Chairman Ganger also commented that there are issues with group homes and he feels the Town should be Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 7 vigilant with regard to transient rentals, be aware of the situation facing the City of Delray Beach and take action. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked Chairman Ganger what he proposes. Chairman Ganger said he mentioned to Mr. Minor in a telephone conversation that the premise should be consistent with the Town's beliefs and more articulate in putting forth what is important to the Town. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Minor if the Delray Beach group home situation could occur in the Town of Gulf Stream. Chairman Ganger said he has spoken to several attorneys who say it could already be in planning stages without the Town being aware. Mr. Thrasher said the timeframe for these studies has been eliminated, but not the potential to study and make changes in these areas. He asked Mr. Minor to explain the timeframes. Mr. Minor said the timeframe under the older growth management regulations required towns to meet and adopt certain standards, such as group home citings, home-based occupations, rentals less than 3 months and commercial uses, which are all prohibited in the Zoning Code. Timeframes were required for communities without specific regulations which the State wanted to include in all comp plans and rather than making communities adopt regulations immediately the State's focus in review of comp plans is on larger issues of State concern. Mr. Minor said he took the opportunity to eliminate the timeframes, but not the desire to adopt specific regulations. Chairman Ganger said he would like the ARPB to have more time to put their thoughts together and clean up the Comp Plan before making their recommendations to the LPA. He said he would like an opportunity to address fundamental issues to give the LPA substantial goals and planning guidelines. Clerk Taylor said she does not disagree, but understood that when the annexation took place there were some time constraints in bringing the Comp Plan up to reflect the annexation. She said while there are other issues that should be considered, we should move forward now and continue with other issues later. Clerk Taylor said there are no limits on the number of Comp Plans submitted. Mr. Minor said there are some studies to be done and the Board can address some of the other issues under the Zoning Code where those types of regulations occur. He suggested that the Board make their recommendations to the LPA with the proposed amendments they have before them at this time, including any suggested changes. Mr. Randolph said the ARPB has a responsibility to deal with the density issue in a reasonable time and urged the Board to move forward with the proposed amendments now and address other issues later. Both Chairman Ganger and Vice -Chairman Morgan suggested that ARPB members meet to share ideas on some of the issues. Mr. Randolph said the ARPB can hold a workshop, but it would be in violation of the Sunshine Law for members to meet with each other outside of a meeting. Mr. Thrasher said his recommendation is for the ARPB to move forward with the proposed amendments as submitted by Mr. Minor. Chairman Ganger said he would rather hold off on making their recommendations because there are mistakes in the proposed amendments and he would prefer to Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 8 fine tune them before recommending them to the LPA. It was the consensus of the Board and Staff that there would not be enough time to hold a workshop, submit changes to Urban Design and have everything ready to distribute in the Commission meeting packets. Clerk Taylor explained that if the ARPB moves forward in recommending the proposed amendments as submitted, the Commission will have 1st reading of the Ordinance to be able transmit the amendments to the DCA and other required agencies on January 13th. Following the response from the DCA and other agencies which should be within 30 days, the Commission will review and address their comments and have a 2nd reading of the Ordinance for adoption of the Comp Plan Amendments. Chairman Ganger said he is uncomfortable with that timetable. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Minor if elements that do not relate to the annexed area could be put off at this point in order to allow the ARPB to deal with elements that do relate to the annexation, such as future land use and transportation, in order to move forward. Mr. Minor said yes because, generally, future land use is the main focus. He said, however, because of an increase in population, there could be an issue if someone were to ask how the sanitary elements and infrastructure would be impacted. Chairman Ganger said the Town has commercial enterprise which can be converted into a group home with transients who are part owners. Mr. Randolph said the Board could move forward with the proposed amendments with the understanding that there are concerns with certain elements which the ARPB will be addressing to make changes. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of the Summary of Amendments to the Town of Gulf Stream Comprehensive Plan as submitted. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice -Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded a motion to allow the Architectural Review and Planning Board to request authority from the Town Commission to hold a Workshop for the purpose of reviewing additional changes and amendments to the Gulf Stream Comp Plan to submit adjustments to the Commission. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Vice -Chairman Morgan, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed 5 - 0. Mr. Randolph said, if the Board has no objection, Chairman Ganger could bring any mistakes in the proposed amendments to Mr. Minor's attention and, as long as they are not substantive, Mr. Minor can make the changes before the January meeting. The consensus of the Board was that they had no objections. Mr. Thrasher said he would prefer that Chairman Ganger brought the changes to Clerk Taylor to prepare them for Mr. Minor. Mr. Smith suggested having a workshop at the next ARPB Meeting if the Agenda is minimal. Clerk Taylor said she does not favor workshops because no motions can be made. Mr. Randolph suggested calling it a Special Meeting. B. Code Review 1. Section 66-369 Docks (7); Pg. CD66:71 Materials & colors. Materials & colors of docks & ancillary structures shall be considered as part of Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 9 architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. 2. Section 70-51 Minor accessory structures (2); Page CD70:24 In -ground swimming pools and spas 3. Section 70:238. Roofs (a); Page CD70:93 Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval. 4. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights Define preferred, discouraged and prohibited height of entry feature. Mr. Thrasher said these items have been accumulating for review by the ARPB. He said the first step would be recommendations concerning these items from the ARPB to the Commission. Chairman Ganger said that because the roof issue has been a hot subject it should be addressed. He said he would like to discuss the process for a code amendment that would preclude or mitigate subdivision of lots that currently exceed 1 acre into smaller subdivision. Chairman Ganger said the subdivision of the Spence property initiated a lot of talk in the community and he suggested that the subdivision of lots be added to the list of items up for discussion. Mr. Randolph said that the size of a lot is addressed in the Zoning Ordinances which allows subdivision a property as long as it meets existing Code requirements. He said there is case law that says you cannot deny subdivision if it meets your existing Code and, therefore, you will need to modify the Zoning Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he believes the Town Code does allow denial and Section 70, Subsection 4 addresses the matter, but it fell on deaf ears in the application for subdivision of the Spence property. Mr. Randolph said he did not believe the section to be applicable; however, he said it can be added as an item for discussion in the future if the Board would like to tighten it up. Mr. Thrasher said he would like to get the discussion started today on the items listed on the agenda. Chairman Ganger said they will discuss the items listed and he also suggested adding the subdivision item. He added that he would like Staff to have the assignment of identifying property in the Town that could potentially be subdivided. Mr. Thrasher said there are properties that could be subdivided, but he did not know how many. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he would also like to explore whether Section 70, Subsection 4 would allow this Board to limit further subdivision of properties that can be subdivided. He also suggested that FAR Standards be reviewed again. Mr. Stanley clarified that the Board would like to identify properties that can be subdivided and look into whether it is feasible to do an overlay including those properties and change the regulations to a certain point where if someone wanted to redevelop those properties against the code it would be a privately initiated LDR amendment. Mr. Randolph said this matter should be more broadly approached and asked the Board if they want to add this item to the list. Chairman Ganger said he would like it added to the list and he would like the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - December 22, 2011 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 10 roof item to be a priority to prevent another resident from approaching the Board for the slurry -coated tile. Mr. Randolph said that cannot happen due to zoning in progress. Mr. Thrasher said these items are addressed in sections of the Code that have caused many issues in interpretation. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Thrasher to summarize the issues with Section 66-369 Docks and Ancillary Structures in terms of materials and colors. Mr. Thrasher said the Board will discuss the specifics of whether a dock can be concrete or made from real or false wood, acceptable colors of docks, if any, and the extension of 5' from the water line. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he has added FAR and subdivision consideration items. Mr. Smith said that Mr. Thrasher previously informed the Board that they do not have the authority to regulate driveway elevations, but asked whether this matter should be added to the list for discussion. Mr. Thrasher said it is something to discuss, but he will have Marty Minor look into whether the Town can legally regulate driveway elevations. Vice -Chairman Morgan said that all of these items can be fairly involved and suggested taking one item per meeting for discussion. He asked if the ARPB is authorized to direct Mr. Minor to investigate and report on these issues. Mr. Thrasher said we have historically operated that way and are authorized to do so, and he added that some of the items will be controversial and some will not, such as pools and grottos. Clerk Taylor said most of the items on this list have already been discussed and staff has been authorized to do something about them. Chairman Ganger recommended the roof issue be scheduled for the next meeting and asked the Board and Staff to be prepared. Clerk Taylor suggested considering the eave heights for discussion at the next meeting also. VIII. Items by Board Members. There were no items by the Board Members. IX. Public. There were no items by the Public. X. Adjournment. Chairman Ganger adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:30 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-01 Owner: M/M Curtiss Roach Address: 3560 Gulf Stream Rd Agent: Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates Proposed Improvement: Construction of three one-story additions to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling. Approvals Requested: Special Exception: To permit two, one-story additions to the existing one- story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling, each of which would encroach 2.3 feet into the north side setback, and also to permit a single story addition to the dwelling that would encroach 2.8 feet into the south side setback. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of three one-story additions, 809 SF, to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling with two of the additions encroaching 2.3 feet into the north side setback and one addition encroaching 2.8 feet into the south side setback, and to permit the reconfiguration of the driveway. Gross Lot Size: 15,030 SF Effective Lot Area: 15,030 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 3,899 SF Allowable: 4,959 SF Zoning District: RS -C Considered During Review: Height: 15' existing Section 70-75. Special exception setbacks. (c) Additions to structures with existing nonconforming setbacks. (1) Minimum setback. The minimum setback (all setbacks) is the extent of existing minimum setback. Section 70-74 Setbacks. Section 70-100 Roof and eave heir Comments: The standards for approval of special exception appear to be met. Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL ... _...._1....... This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information I.A.I. Project/Owner Name: PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION Mr. & Mrs. Curtiss Roach ARPB File # O!2' /' I.A.2. Project Address: 3560 Gulf Stream Road Gulf Stream I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: Lot 3, Block 2, Polo Fields, according to the plat thereof as recorded in plat book 26, page, 13 public recor s o Pa m Beac oun y, FL I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # ofstories, etc.) Single Story additions on east and west areas of existing residence- interior remodeling. I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: _809 s q . f t . Architectural Style: Gulf Stream Bermuda 1.A.6. Check all that apply: XDArchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) O Demolition of Structures O Non-residential uses O Variance (complete section G) XX Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: B. Owner Information Type of Foundation: _Piling 1.8.1. Owner Address: 3560 Gulf Stream Road LB -2. Owner Phone Number: _ 561-455A731 I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information Fax: I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: M. Mark Marsh. Bridges, arshsoc. R a� I.C.2. Agent Address 18 Via Miz,7ger I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 5 1 . 1.C.4. Agent Siqnature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date _ Decision: alm Reach, F 3 icial Use Only Date: imendation: Date: / �5 ' /-)j es/ J /- Aplilication for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? ps`G III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? JoYes ❑ No Explain. Scale/Style of additions conforms to existing use within the Zonin 1 g district. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? P Yes ❑ No Explain. Fully compatible with future land use. III.A.4. flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? new driveway centered along GulfStream Road. III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage on site b. Sanitary Sewer public c. Potable Water city d. Irrigation Water city e. Electricity f p & 1 f. Telephone at&T g. Gas propane tank h. Cable Television Comcast III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) N/A PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV -A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes L"No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes ©�No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes 6 No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1, Is the proposed use a' permitted special exception use? M Yes ❑ No Code Section:? 0 - 75 c IV.E,2. How is the use designed, located and �1 � � 2 � Pr°posed to be operated so that the Proposed additions to Public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? non conforming setbacks are not visible from -.a public right -Of -way. IV. E.:3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value ofother ro be located? []Yes 1M No P Perty in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. Proposed additions are bel6w required lot and mass ,com covera e Pa with neighborhood. IV.E.4 How will the use be compatible with adjoining development a is to be located? nd the character of the District where it Proposed additions are below required is com q lot coverage patible with neighborhood and mass IV.E,S. What landscaping p g and screening are provided? New I _aJrldscalping existing hedges on property lines will be maintained' aint supplemented. ain ed or IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the 9 District wherein it is to be located? �p Yes ❑ No Explain. All criteria within the Gu manual are met. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units W.F.J. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the to NSA Y are be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their Potential n Properties. naimpacts or, --------------- IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 Page 1 of 1 Rita Taylor From: Bill Thrasher Sent: Tuesday, January 10, 2012 8:56 AM To: Rita Taylor Subject: FW: Roach Residence Attachments: 21133_al-1_area calcs.pdf; 21133_a4-1—area calcs.pdf From: Marty Minor [mailto:MMinor@udkstudios.com] Sent: Tuesday, January 10, 2012 8:48 AM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: Roach Residence Bill, Attached is our analysis of the Roach residence plans with regards to the FAR and the undivided window size and glass percentage on the western elevation. The proposed addition raises the FAR to .26, which is less than than the maximum limit of .33. However, the residence's western elevation contains undivided glass ranging from 18 to 25 square feet in size. Also, glass makes up 51.1% of the western facade, which also exceeds code standards. Attached for your use are the elevations with the calculations. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at any time. marty Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Urban Design Kilday Studios The Offices at City Place North 477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758 561-366-1100 1/10/2012 kI b 7 ƒ |! §k A Lill�| � $■ ¥� . ' |_2 §■ / x � * �\ \ `\ §k2 §§3 ||§E 2 > 7|| z � ; c q 5 m § $ § ilii iis $�- - $ ii b 7 ƒ |! §k A Lill�| � $■ ¥� . ' |_2 §■ / x §k2 ||§E 2 > 7|| � ; q 5 m § § ilii iis $�- - $ ii 2 ® , � 2 i i b 7 ƒ |! §k A Lill�| � $■ ¥� . ' |_2 §■ / x M C- > * -nc o n aOx w O D I D Vl fm NmD O A > \ mRI D r D D ZOo r p Z A A 0p2p g 5Z m f A I—.—�P ,9� OT a�. €b, ( Page 1 of 1 Bill Thrasher From: Marty Minor [MMinor@udkstudios.com] Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2012 11:52 AM To: Bill Thrasher Update on a couple issues: Roach Residence: The cross-section detail of the wall detail was helpful. The clarification of the facade wall height helps us confirm that architect's calculation that the glass area makes up 48% of the west wall facade. Roof Tiles: I have discussed Bermuda white tiles with the owner of Carpenter Roofing, who does roofing for high-end homes and buildings on the island, including in Gulf Stream. He recommends the Entegra Portland white cement, smooth white tile as the preferred the as it is available locally, it is white thru and thru, and he also suggested for slate or gray tile that they be the "un -weatherized or un -fading" type as some of the cheaply -made tiles fade quickly and unattractively. I will include this info in the recommended zoning code language, but I wanted to give you an update in case someone asks. I will see you tomorrow morning for the Town Council/LPA hearing. Thank you, ma rty Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Urban Design Kilday Studios The Offices at City Place North 477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225 West Palm Beach, Florida,. 561-366-1100 1/12/2012 Or Z., ; ti" • � 1 4N W., i r" r_ J i } 3i Or Z., ; ti" • � 1 4N W., i �%.L y kt 'E. li q 0 2 I 1 I ��A W Lu ca H 2 h � OO pij 0 N�r�'q W W ZOi Qti 0 M3� ah � N QY"NNi bf W > N X ti a C) co 1� VVV��j 3 W N OQ ia: 9R1�$ O C) Q o co A ►0 Q c9 03AVd OV08 NV3&IS 37n5 m+ � Lvr+ rcr+ sLr+ z9t+ r7[r+ rf7r+ �rF 2p135 ur+rr� .b019 079N 3Ar6o ' 1St A'JON 6'(rt L.� rr. as« rs+ ora 9 3Af60 1/J0N Lr+ 991 L9+ B9+ 99+ OC+ B9+ 'NOD 2 rltO r9I 9gU O n L+ 99C+ + + ( 7NM ,L 4w =� 6W 991 ts [91 M 69+ -vv6ly OH pI (x[LnM1':11 d IrL IZP- 4 i !Wv N ry Y Omw U a �Stl7l�.f2KJ15! Y � o J � m Z N0078 'F 107 � 0 N .rrr xov / J 691 JKl7 I I J�Vi11� / JWJ 9L'L+ L --_j /[FC+ / 7 0 0 d I / 7XH Dd I bSC+ 09C+ I / �I �.33�+ 8k JOdQCH -- AIMp --__ ao*oa Z N0078 '9 107 e R O iWi-rSNOO lvl5 UCF OIMvi0 OH uOf W U a z LLLV-= 2M R. s MIA2101 3 'IN991 @g, IN.W yy�r5@gg$yy n t o ip C N U W Q DOM� SNO151�3a U- m U) 0 a 3 0 I � I 0 4 R [� a Z w E- E -a z i z4 i < < R 14 q W E- o �, a a====i=m 8 19 cn 0 e halo 8 R .: '�3 z oz�� o U FS ty��] its S g N s MIA2101 3 'IN991 @g, IN.W yy�r5@gg$yy n t o ip C N U W Q DOM� SNO151�3a U- m U) 0 a 3 0 I � I 0 a I / N $ �� 1NV1lfISNOo IV], (13W Sof TWVM ON GO, � Fy7 � iS c+') F I � a al Pu ��g�5h��S 3 dygy s,ffi � r 3� LAPIN die 0 N p� O � O � ��g�5h��S 3 dygy s,ffi ���55gg���dd�kx�a� 3� LAPIN die n X5908 YHE N 3lV�S E"O 'ON -o Md -I II RVO SN0151�3J 2 ME 1 LNV1lf15N0� .�_ 001- 7hAMtlbO ON 90f i 31tl75 Mb0 -)lu7 ON '71.117 IU ,I� ISI F -h Egila5 U A co arip �°��� 288 n 71, NOW WV MUG NOLLIOOV 9 � F- n lug Z a Q-' C a w NOW WV MUG NOLLIOOV .B -,OZ .0-,z b lV O O F d� GMVn38 01 1008 31LL ARM 1Vld ONLLSIX3 i •I � � S .9-,Z .9-.9 H ONUMX3 ZI �Y 3dOlS .a F .0-. Z -.S SLry 3 I I i b S n i I I I I � I I I � I i ONLLS9(3 Z14 UDIS 4O •� ONLLSM i i ZLIY 3d01S � 30 wF N I •I � FF I I 2 2 3 � � Z 3 � < I•,1a 3 I� I dl9 I �-I Zl IYN3dd0IS l II II Y F ~ V I I IIx MVn38 OL 3008 311L 1N3n30 1Vl! ONLLSIX3 H II Li ____ II I •� NOM100V ONILSIX3 lug Z a Q-' C a w ��1, 8 ��s b �� s WW, z pp UU F of 'a yG amp p R ��W " R =�� s ;S z _ ;;�� �� 3Z0 y3��a W3�� W33 F ('��J 3 ��1 w r eor z 0. xwDID OA �� >oW a Q�� Q 70 ��s b �� s WW, z pp UU F of 'a yG amp p R ��W " R =�� s ;S z ;;�� K yy ait livcl ��3a���� a�� ����55��� 3����s3a sNoisin3z 3Yd) 70 ��s U1 WW, pp UU F of 'a yG amp p R ____ __________ ____ FII z d �� 3Z0 y3��a W3�� W33 O ('��J 3 ��1 w a w w x a �� N��N �� b w 3` O F C bU l F o��U QI ��JU Fin 00 X ��3O " Zi 3�� 3�� L.J �� K yy ait livcl ��3a���� a�� ����55��� 3����s3a sNoisin3z 3Yd) 70 U1 WW, pp UU F of 'a yG amp p 4 ��s am C <S a8 w 0 E--1 U1 WW, pp UU yG amp p am C <S a8 O 11 <32 3�� d �� 3Z0 y3��a W3�� W33 ('��J I O w a �� w 3` " I �� A 3> i3 r�� r a f' PAIS �u -2. N < E- "fiatiwmM _- 1C _wiI nSNOD Wj W2 oxw CO Q Q tea Baa C2 W 0 g Q N01 7 a ZOE 015; Z� J E- F w E Z A H W K o m Wr�✓ � � z z K o 0 a 1� w a w In z o S w << v C, < F D IA lWI� ¢ 1.. < o V w G' V In i J p n N o In o a E,0 P M- W N Q N01 7 O ZOE 015; O J 9 III � I I 1 1 wl 7 L O T 4 B L O C K 2 \+ I 4 QV- GNV_�i q oHv MIA MUM M3N ` II u I i � �ff4 w9 Ji ld. �r e ` to EJ Y I CD En W I- g91 CD iZOOCD 1� COU W LZ i 1uj >< N uj ~ 8< IE w XW Ln 1 W 0 Of n I i 1 1 Ia--------- EM 110 IT I + LS3 _ - rs.a 753.89 I IL O T 2, B L O C K 2 1 � � � I I i ISI � atvOs u u vQ� ow "r, 3 I 0 Siva . i 1= A ® ' E Z Z of ZQ i Ao C7 � U U3 Q•' � �� we a�nA HM � < EmV S Z D LL th ry R V W J} 1� U W Z Z of ZQ O I w � II OD t J V) - o in ° v. a U '� LL th ry R V W J} 1� U W Z Z of ZQ z zo w � o Z Q Q J z o a W Z a N W d W a J Q a W U Q x a i a o N U J Z a s 0 J = � �itr�O��O�OO�aO\O�_�_;iwa���-a��oo�o�mo�o�o����0000���oo����0000�o��oo�o�000�oo�o�mo� : p0's�ae�9�s0-oo-Atq� R!(OO'OO'O'0000I Ilk 000000000'O'IBM O000�� ,; � ' `? - [•7 --� Iii- - � _ �><�, ® •\,• SER ;�C•,�� _ �� = � X11 pie����� '� �`���` COWN k•,. go .. �F•1�� Ow gg Ok �.., ► ;�� III, �, ■ I -'�• - , ■Ili ,� - 0000000000�100�0 � • Potential Code Changes; 2012 1. Section 70:238. Roofs (a); Page CD70:93 Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval Recommended Changes: Required. Flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated tile, except that gray, slate or slate -style, may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences, subject to Level II approval. 2. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights Define preferred, discouraged and prohibited height of entry feature. Recommended Changes: Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable or other such element. Height: Preferred, From eight feet to 14 feet. Discouraged, From 14 feet to 16 feet. Prohibited. Greater than 16 feet. 3. Section 70-51 Minor accessory structures (2); Page CD70:24 In -ground swimming pools and spas Recommended Changes: Add "Waterfalls" 4. Section 66-367 Swimming pools Recommended Change: Add (j) No grotto shall be permitted in any zoning district. A grotto shall be considered and artificial structure or excavation made to look like a cave or cavern. (k) Waterfalls, minor accessory structures, shall not exceed 4' in height as measured from the average finished grade of the property and the back side of the structure shall be screened from off -premises view with landscape material. 5. Section 66-369 Docks (7); Page CD66:71 Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. Recommended Changes: No concrete docks are permitted. All docks will be made from natural materials. 6. Section 66-1 Definitions Recommended Change: Basement shall mean that portion of a building which is below the finished floor elevation of the building. A basement is not considered a story with regards to height measurement of a building. The square footage of a basement shall be included in the FAR calculations at 50% and not be usable for living purposes which includes working, sleeping, eating, cooking or recreation, or a combination thereof. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the structure. 7. Section 70-71 Floor Area Ratio Recommended Change: Seeking Input 8. Section 70-68 Lot size and dimensional requirements. Recommended Change: Seeking Input 9. Section 70-4 How to use this Manual Recommended Change: Seeking Input GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-238 (b) Stepbacks. The use of stepbacks is appropriate to reduce excessive bulkiness and provide a transition between first and second stories. A few critical stepbacks on a building are better than several minor stepbacks that only complicate the facade and create busy architecture. (c) Preferred. Balconiesy. Simple rectangular config- urations ti Single story garages Smaller second story con- figurations 4 k Stepbacks to second story (d) Discouraged. Angular walls Complex facade treatment (excessive multi -layer stepbacks) Stepbacks, smaller second story, single story garage, and a balcony help to Sec. 70-238. Roofs. articulate and give appropriate scale to this house (preferred). (a) Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style tile may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval. (b) Preferred. Combination hip/gable roofs Decorative capped chim- ney Exposed rafter tails Flashing, vent stacks, and pipes painted to match ad- jacent building surface Hip roof Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes) Roof overhang (2-2Y2 feet) Simple roof geometry em- phasizing long horizontal lines White flat untextured tile Gulf Stream- Bermuda style white tile roof (required) OC, Corr. CD70:93 § 70-238 (c) Discouraged. Dormers on single story GULF STREAM CODE houses Gable Pyramidal hip (often has too steep of slope) Very low pitched roofs (slope less than 5:12) (d) Prohibited. Barrel tiles -� Front gable except for en- try features - - Gambrel Mansard Monolithic roof design where inadequate mea- sures were taken to re- duce massing and height Roof detail showing exposed rafter tails and decorative capped chimney of roof design (preferred) Pan tiles Shed Shingles Tiles other than white flat untextured tiles or gray slate tiles Unnecessarily complex roof geometry (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 56, 57, 3-10-00) OC, Corr. CD70:94 § 70-99 GULF STREAM CODE Metal roofs (except unpainted copper when used as a decorative accent or on minor accessory structures) Non-earthtone colors (except white), for example: blue, peach, pink, teal or yellow Primary color tiles and shingles Roll tile and similar tile styles in all districts except Place Au Soleil S -Tile in all districts except Place Au Soleil Solar panels on the streetside Unnecessarily complex or monolithic roof design All white tile other than flat cement tile (Ord. No. 00-1, § 36, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-9, § 2, 10-10-03) Sec. 70-100. Roof and eave heights. (a) Generally. (1) The height and number of eave lines and the overall height of a structure play an important role in establishing visual continuity with other structures on the street and maintaining an appropriate residential/human scale. Most structures in the town are characterized by simple roof designs with low to medium eave heights and roof heights. This type of design emphasizes the horizontal dimension of the structure while minimizing the vertical dimension. (2) Roof height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the highest exterior point on the roof. Eave height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the top of the roof beam at the end of the beam (top of flashing). Different eave heights establish different eave lines. Two or more separate roof areas with the same eave height are considered to have the same eave line. (3) Roof features can provide appropriate design articulation to a roof area, but should be used sparingly to avoid unnecessary and undesirable complexity. Roof features include, but are not limited to, chimneys, cupolas, decorative towers, dormers, and small cut-outs and extensions. Two or more dormers are considered to be one roof feature, as are two or more chimneys. (4) Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival to visitors, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches (from eight feet to 12 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Three or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 20 feet or less (24 feet or less for roof features) (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet (between 12 and 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Four Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 20 and 24 feet (between 24 and 28 feet for roof features) OC, Corr. CD70:46 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-100 (3) Prohibited. Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet (greater than 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Five or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side Roof heights: Greater than 24 feet (greater than 28 feet for roof features) (c) Two story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—From eight feet to 12 feet for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 22 feet six inches or less for two-story portions All other districts—From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 21 feet or less for two story portions Eave lines: Four or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 22 feet or less for one-story portions (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Between 12 and 14 feet for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 22 feet six inches and 24 feet six inches for two-story portions All other districts—Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 21 feet and 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Five Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 22 feet and 26 feet for one-story portions (3) Prohibited. Buildings with more than two and one-half stories Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 14 feet for one-story portions Greater than 24 feet six inches for two-story portions. All other districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet six inches for one-story portions Greater than 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Six or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side CD70:47 § 70 -loo GULF STREAM CODE Roof heights: Greater than 26 feet for one-story portions For two-story portions greater than the following for each zoning district: District Height in feet Gulf Stream Core 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Ocean West 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Beach Front 35 (including roof features) North/South 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Place Au Soliel 30 (roof features may extend to 35)" CD70:48 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-101 Preferred ■ Four or less eave lines Prohibited Six or more eave lines Line 3 Line 2 Line 1 Above graphic illustrates eight different eave lines, adding unnecessary complexity to the elevations. (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 26, 37, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-1, § 1, 4-11-03) Sec. 70-101. Windows. (a) Generally. (1) Windows not only provide light and ventilation but add to the aesthetics of a building by creating rhythm, proportion, distinction and articulation. Certain styles of windows correspond to specific CD70:49 + + & ¥ & E \ §@ R C ■ K | | / ■ | § § 4 § ■| �I �§�f| 7� ,.|■,�||wf|)�||||� + + & ¥ & E \ §@ R C & 4t A & b rA, O OR mill k� & 4t A & b rA, HER 1 PEM 01JR!, = -1 "Ill INN", CQ rn rvoiswa LU .fyt, r ,. i a �.: 7 ,' i § 70-49 GULF STREAM CODE (b) These prohibitions shall not extend to telephonic transactions and communications. Sec. 70-50. Private schools. Any private school conducted in any single family residential zoning district may continue to be used as such under the provisions of sections 66-131 et seq. of this Code, provided however, that any private school building, or other structure used in connection with and as a part of and appurtenant in the operation and maintenance of such private school, may be replaced, or another building substituted in place thereof; repaired and maintained from time to time as shall be necessary for the effective operation and maintenance of such private school; and further, any development permits, orders or written agreements granted or executed by the town prior to the adoption of this chapter shall remain in full force and effect. Sec. 70-51. Minor accessory structures. The following structures shall be considered as minor accessory structures in all five single family zoning districts subject to specific setbacks established in this chapter. Any structure which is larger or more intensive shall be subject to the same setbacks as the principal structure. (1) Detached, one-story structures of 300 square feet or less and 18 feet or less in height, including but not limited to: Garages/sheds Gazebos Greenhouses Guest houses Pool cabanas/bathhouses Trellises/arbors (2) Permanent recreation facilities, including but not limited to: Batting cages/backstops Forts and playhouses In -ground swimming pools and spas Paved/special surface areas and accompanying equipment and/or fencing for tennis/squash/ racquetball, basketball, shuffleboard, putting greens/sand traps, etc. Swing sets and other playground equipment (3) Fountains. (4) Mechanical equipment and television antennae/satellite dishes. (5) Decks and patios with elevations greater than eight inches above highest abutting grade. (6) Awnings with leg supports and those otherwise extending more than three feet out from a structure. (7) Docks, boat lifts, and davits. (8) Flagpoles. CD70:24 § 66-351 GULF STREAM CODE tion as a condition precedent to the issuance of a building permit for the proposed use. The unity of title declaration shall apply to all the property necessary for the proposed use, and shall declare that no portion of said property shall be sold or transferred by the owner or successors in interest apart from the whole. (b) If there is a sale or transfer in contraven- tion of a unity of title declaration, no building permit will be issued for any portion of the prop- erty contained in the unity of title declaration. Declaration shall remain in effect until a release of the unity of title declaration is executed by the town. (c) The unity of title declaration shall be filed at the expense of the owner in the public records of the county. Proof of such filing shall precede the issuance of a building permit. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, K), 4-8-83) Sec. 66-352. Nuisances. No use shall be made of any property within any district that shall in any way be offensive or noxious by reason of the emission of any dis- charge, odor, gas, dust, smoke, vibration or noise; nor shall any vehicle be parked or used in any way that would constitute a nuisance; nor shall anything be constructed or maintained that would in any way constitute a nuisance to adjacent property owners, residents or to the community. Each use shall be operated so as to lessen the damage from fire and explosion. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, J), 4-8-83) Cross reference—Nuisances, ch. 22. Secs. 66-353-66-365. Reserved. DIVISION 2. ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND RECREATIONAL FACILITIES Sec. 66-366. Antennas and antenna systems/ structures. (a) Broadcast receiving antennas or communi- cation antennas may be permitted in any zoning district upon site plan review and approval by the town commission and upon issuance of a building permit by the town. (b) Broadcast receiving antennas or communi- cation antennas shall be attached to the main building or structure and shall not extend more than five feet above the highest portion of the roof. (c) Satellite television antenna systems may be permitted in any zoning district upon site plan review and approval by the town commission and the issuance of a building permit by the town. (d) Satellite television antenna systems shall not exceed 12 feet in diameter or width. (e) Satellite television antenna systems shall be considered as accessory structures and shall be subject to the applicable site plan review require- ments and regulations of this chapter. (f) Unless specific approval is granted by the town commission, satellite television antenna sys- tems shall be ground mounted and located in such areas as to be screened or buffered from view from adjacent properties, rights-of-way, the Intracoastal Waterway and/or the Atlantic Ocean. (g) There shall not be more than one satellite television antenna system, broadcast receiving antenna or communication antenna per residen- tial building or condominium association on any platted lot or parcel. (h) Upon receipt of site plan approval and prior to the issuance of a building permit for satellite television antenna, the town commission shall review the installation plans, which plans must be signed and sealed by a professional engineer registered in the state who shall certify that the proposed satellite television antenna system is wind resistant with an ability to with- stand winds up to 140 miles per hour. The calcu- lations and such certification by the engineer shall be submitted along with the plans. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, H), 4-8-83; Ord. No. 84-7, § 2, 12-14-84) Sec. 66-367. Swimming pools. (a) No swimming pool shall be located, de- signed, operated or maintained so as to interfere unduly with the enjoyment of the property rights by owners of property adjoining the swimming pool. ZONING (b) Lights used to illuminate any swimming pool shall be so arranged and shadowed as to reflect away from adjoining premises. (c) A pool may be located within an enclosed courtyard, patio, etc., provided it is to the rear of the required front yard setback line. (d) All enclosed swimming pools shall be in conformity with the setbacks required by the zoning district in which it is located. (e) Unless otherwise specified elsewhere in this Code, unenclosed or open swimming pools in the "RS" single-family residential district shall be located a minimum of 25 feet from front property lines; provided, however, that any swimming pool located on property fronting on SR AlA shall be subject to the established 78 -foot centerline set- back. (f) Swimming pools shall be located on the same lot or parcel of land as that of the main building. In the event of contiguous lots or par- cels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. (g) All pools shall be enclosed by a self-locking, child resistant fence, wall or equivalent barrier at least four feet high, except as provided elsewhere in this Code, and in no event shall a pool be exposed to open view from any public roadway. (h) No aboveground pools of any nature shall be permitted in any zoning district. An aboveground pool shall be considered a pool constructed or assembled of any material and whose top edge exceeds two feet in height above the average finished grade of the lot or site. (i) All pools shall be landscaped so as to pre- vent exposure to off -premises view from any pub- lic roadway, any public or private right-of-way, and the ground level of any adjoining property. However, this subparagraph shall not be con- strued so as to prevent the exposure of pools to open view from public or private waterways. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 1), 4-8-83; Ord. No. 92-5, § 1, 9-28-92; Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 18, 19, 3-10-00) Sec. 66-368. Tennis courts. § 66-369 (a) No tennis court shall be located, designed, operated or maintained so as to interfere unduly with the enjoyment of the property rights by owners of property adjoining the tennis court. (b) No lights shall be used in any manner so as to illuminate any tennis court. (c) All tennis courts shall be in conformity with the setbacks required by the zoning district in which it is located. Any tennis court located on property fronting on SR AIA shall be subject to the established 78 -foot centerline setback. (d) Tennis courts shall be located on the same lot or parcel of land as that of the main building. In the event of contiguous lots or parcels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. (e) All tennis courts shall be enclosed by a fence, open wall or equivalent barrier and in no event shall a tennis court be exposed to open view from any public roadway. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 2), 4-8-83) Sec. 66-369. Docks. In the single-family residential district, one dock per lot of record shall be permitted in accor- dance with the following: Supp. No. 1 CD66:69 (1) Site plan review required. All new docks and significant alterations to existing docks shall require site plan review and ap- proval. (2) Permitted as accessory use. Docks shall be permitted only as an accessory use to single-family dwellings for the exclusive use of the dwelling's occupants (residents and nonresident members of the occupant's family and resident guests at the dwell- ing). Docks shall not be permitted on vacant lots unless the vacant lot is adja- cent to a developed lot under the same ownership and a unity of title has been recorded. . V. A - ,r, ZONING minimum offset from the setback centerlines. For lots with designated water frontage less than 100 feet the docking zone shall have a minimum five-foot offset from each of the set- back centerlines. In the case of cove end lots and lots with a water front- age of 100 feet or less, neither boat nor dock shall exceed a length of 70 feet. For rounded corner lots, water frontage is determined by the mid- point of the arc. For purposes of determining designated water front- age, dock widths, setbacks and max- imum boat lengths for each water- front lot within the Town, the figures contained within Exhibit "B" at- tached hereto and incorporated herein shall apply. [See the end of this sec- tion.] In cases with multiple water frontages, owner must treat each frontage according to the appropri- ate size category. In the case of low profile piling boat lifts, the lift shall be located in the following manner. The first piling shall be placed a minimum of twenty feet (towards center of the lot) from the setback line with the pilings extending into the docking zone no farther than twenty feet from the seawall. For lots with setbacks of more than fifteen feet on either side, the twenty foot mea- surement for the first piling shall be mea- sured from the setback on the side with the largest setback. f. A maximum of one dock box shall be permitted which shall be no higher than 30 inches and no larger than 24 cubic feet. § 66-369 g. Light fixtures shall be installed in a manner that provides safe pedes- trian circulation using low voltage lighting with a maximum fifty watts mounted no higher than three feet above the dock at a minimum spac- ing of ten feet on center. Lights are to be step, path or marine type fix- tures. Fixtures must project down- ward at a minimum 45 -degree angle from the horizontal plan tangent to the top of the light source fixture and allow no light spillage onto ad- jacent properties. No fixture shall be mounted to the seawall. h. Subject to level one site plan ap- proval, a maximum of one floating platform may be permitted in lieu of a boat lift for the purpose of storing small watercrafts. The floating plat- form shall be constructed of nonfer- rous material, be black in color and may not rise more than 12 inches out of the water. No more than two wa- tercrafts of a maximum length of 14 feet shall be stored on the floating platform. The platform dimensions shall not exceed eight feet in width or 16 feet in length. All watercrafts shall be stored parallel to the sea- wall. A floating platform must be removed after three months of dis- use. (7) Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 3),4-8-83; Ord. No. 91-24, § 3, 10-21-91; Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 20, 21, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 04-9, § 2,2-11-05; Ord. No. 05-2, §§ 1-6, 9-9-05; Ord. No. 008-4, § 4, 9-5-08) Supp. No. 1 CD66:71 ZONING ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL Sec. 66-1. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Abutting shall mean having a common border with, or being separated from such common bor- der by, an alley or easement. Access shall mean the principal means of in- gress and egress to property from a publicly dedicated right-of-way. Accessory building, structure or use shall mean a building, structure or use on the same lot with, and of a nature customarily incidental and sub- ordinate to, the principal building, structure or use. Acre, net. See Net acre/net land area. Addition (to an existing building) shall mean any walled and roofed expansion to the perimeter of a building in which the addition is connected by a common load-bearing wall other than a firewall. Any walled and roofed addition which is con- nected by a firewall or is separated by indepen- dent perimeter load-bearing walls is new construc- tion. Adjacent shall mean that which lies near or close to, not widely separated or necessarily touch- ing. Adjoining shall mean that which is joined or united, actually touching. Alley shall mean a dedicated public right-of- way other than a street which provides only a secondary means of access to abutting property, is not over 20 feet in width and is not intended for general traffic circulation. Alterations, as applied to a building or struc- ture, a change or rearrangement in the structural parts of the existing facilities, or an enlargement, whether by extending on a side, or by increasing the height, or the moving from one location or position to another. § 66-1 Antenna shall mean a device for radiating and/or receiving television or radio signals. Antenna structure shall mean an antenna con- sisting of two or more radiating elements, gener- ally similar which are arranged in such a manner as to obtain direction radiation patterns. It in- cludes any structural members which are neces- sary to maintain the proper electrical relation- ships between the radiating elements, including the mast or other structure used to support the array as a whole, but does not include the trans- mission line which supplies energy to or receives energy from the array as a whole. Apartment. See Dwelling, multiple -family. Appeal shall mean a means for obtaining re- view of a decision, determination, order, or failure to act pursuant to the terms of this chapter. Area of shallow flooding shall mean a desig- nated AO or VO Zone on a community's flood insurance rate map (FIRM) with base flood depths from one to three feet where a clearly defined channel does not exist, where the path of flooding is unpredictable and indeterminate, and where velocity flow may be evident. Area of special flood hazard shall mean the land in the floodplain within a community subject to a one percent or greater chance of flooding in any given year. Awning shall mean any movable rooflike struc- ture cantilevered or otherwise entirely supported from a building, so constructed and erected as to permit its being readily moved within a few minutes time to close an opening, or rolled or folded back to a position flat against the building or a cantilevered projection thereof, or which is detachable. Base flood shall mean the flood having a one percent chance of being equalled or exceeded in any given year. Base flood elevation shall mean the height above mean sea level expected to be reached by the 100 -year flood. Basement shall mean that portion of a build- ing, the ceiling which is entirely below grade or less than three feet above grade. A basement is Supp. No. 1 CD66:7 § 66-1 GULF STREAM CODE not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the build- ing. Bedroom shall mean a room other than a kitchen, dining room, living room, bathroom or closet which is marketed, designed or otherwise likely to function primarily for sleeping. Block shall mean a tract of land bounded by streets, or by a combination of streets and public parks, cemeteries, railroad rights-of-way, bulk- head lines, or shorelines of waterways, or corpo- rate boundary lines of the town. Breakaway wall shall mean a wall that is not part of the structural support of the building and is intended through its design and construction to collapse under specific lateral loading forces with- out causing damage to the elevated portion of the building or the supporting foundation system. Breezeway shall mean a roofed, open -sided pas- sageway connecting two separate structures, or two separate portions of the same structure. Broadcast receiving antenna shall mean an outside antenna used for the reception of signals transmitted by stations licensed by the Federal Communications Commission in the radio broad- cast services, including AM, FM and TV. Building area shall mean the portion of a lot remaining after required setbacks have been pro- vided. Building shall mean any structure built for the shelter, support or enclosure of persons, animals, chattels or movable property of any kind; and, when separated by division walls without opening from the ground up, each portion of such struc- ture shall be deemed a separate building, and for the purpose of this chapter, all porches, projec- tions, cornices and eaves shall be deemed and considered a part of a building. The word "build- ing" shall include the word "structure." Building, detached, shall mean a building hav- ing no party walls in common with another build- ing. Building front shall mean that exterior wall of a building which faces a front lot line of the lot. Building height shall mean the vertical dis- tance measured from the point of first floor base flood elevation of the building site to the highest finished roof structure including any rooftop su- perstructure or appurtenance. Building line shall mean a line on a lot, gener- ally parallel to a lot line or road right-of-way line, located a sufficient distance therefrom to provide the minimum yards required by this chapter. The building line delimits the area in which buildings are permitted subject to all applicable provisions of this chapter. Building official shall mean that person who is designated by the town commission and is charged with the responsibility of enforcing and adminis- tering the various land and building regulations of the town. Building permit shall mean the document or certificate issued by the town building official or other designated official which verifies adherence to all applicable development regulations and gives permission to the permit applicant to pro- ceed with the actions for which the permit was requested. Building, principal, shall mean a building in which is conducted, or in which is intended to be conducted, the main or principal use of the lot on which it is located. Building site shall mean a portion or parcel of land considered as a unit, devoted to a certain use or occupied by a building or group of buildings that are united by a common interest or use, and the customary accessories and open spaces belong- ing to the same. Bulk shall mean the term used to describe the size of buildings or other structures, and their relationships to each other and to open areas and lot lines. Carport shall mean a freestanding covered area or a roofed area open on one, two or three sides and attached to a building, either of which is designed for the storage of one or more vehicles or boats. Supp. No. 1 CD66:8 § 70-69 Sec. 70-69. Unity of title. GULF STREAM CODE In the event of contiguous lots or parcels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main residence building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. Sec. 70-70. Floor area calculation. For purposes of computing the floor area ratio, floor area shall be defined as follows. "Floor area" shall mean the gross floor area of a structure as measured from the outside of the exterior walls and shall include or exclude the following: (1) All floor area under a solid roof whether or not the area is enclosed with walls (i.e., porches, balconies, breezeways, etc.) shall be included. (2) Areas under awnings with leg supports or those that extend more than three feet out from a structure shall count as one-half shall be included. (3) Floor area under ceilings which are higher than 15 feet shall count as double. (4) Areas under screen enclosures shall count as 1/2. (5) Areas under eaves or roof extensions of 21/2 feet or less shall not be included. (6) Areas in basements shall not be included. (7) Areas in attics that cannot be used for living area shall not be included if the ceiling height does not exceed 61/2 feet and there are no windows. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 28, 3-10-00) Sec. 70-71. Floor area ratios. (a) Sliding scale floor area ratio (FAR). (1) Floor area ratio (FAR) is the relationship between a building's total floor area and the area of the lot it sits on. If a building is 2,500 square feet and it sits on a lot of 10,000 square feet, its FAR is .25. This direct relationship results in the ability to build bigger homes on bigger lots. While a ratio of total floor area to lot size such as .25 may be appropriate for smaller lots, on larger lots the result can be unnecessarily and inappropriately large homes. This is particularly a problem when two lots are combined and are now twice as large as the lots next door. This section provides a methodology for maintaining a reasonable opportunity to build larger homes on larger lots, while recognizing that the relationship to the scale of an existing neighborhood is an important community character concern. (2) In order to establish a sliding scale which reduces floor area ratio yields on larger lots; the following FAR step down shall be used: Effective Lot Area I Gulf Stream Core Ocean West Beachfront North/South I Place au Soleil Maximum FAR First 20,000 .33 .33 square feet .33 .33 .33 Portions over 20,000 square .20 .20 .20 .20 .20 feet+ Supp. No. 1 Example 1: 45,000 square foot lot in Beachfront District. First 20,000 square feet x .33 = Next 25,000 square feet x .20 = Total 45,000 square feet CD70:28 6,600 square feet 5,000 square feet 11,600 square feet maximum floor area GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-71 Example 2: 30,000 square foot lot in Ocean West District. First 20,000 square feet x .33 = 6,600 square feet Next 10,000 square feet x .20 = 2,000 square feet Total 30,000 square feet 8,600 square feet maximum floor area . Example 3: 18,000 square foot lot in Place au Soleil. First 18,000 square feet x .33 (b) Neighborhood context floor area ratio. 5,940 square feet maximum floor area (1) In order to address the potential problem created when two lots are aggregated in a district of predominantly small lots, the neighborhood context FAR shall be followed. This special FAR calculation will apply only to new lots in excess of 20,000 square feet created in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil Districts after the adoption of this chapter. (2) When dealing with double lots, it is reasonable to allow a larger home than would be allowed on a single lot, but probably not twice as large if abutting lots remain small. An equitable method for determining the maximum FAR for a double lot (or when a vacant lot is split between two existing homes) shall be to use existing abutting lots to create a "neighborhood context FAR" or average FAR yield and then to apply a reasonable factor for floor area expansion. (3) For lots over 20,000 square feet in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil districts created after the adoption of this manual, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the average maximum FAR yield of the two abutting lots with a 50 percent increase allowance. If the neighborhood context FAR is less than the standard FAR, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the maximum allowed. This will restrict new houses or homes with additions to a size that, while large, would not overshadow neighborhood residences. For example: Double lot at 33,000 square feet. Maximum FAR for newly created lots over 20,000 square feet is the smaller of the two FAR calculations (sliding scale FAR and neighborhood context FAR). a. Sliding scale FAR: 20,000 square feet x .33 13,000 square feet x .20 Total 33,000 square feet b. Neighborhood context FAR: Neighbor 1 lot: 13,000 square feet x .33 Neighbor 2 lot: 16,000 square feet x .33 Total 6,600 square feet 2,600 square feet 9,200 square feet maximum floor area 4,290 square feet maximum 5,280 square feet maximum 9,570 square feet max _ 2 = 4,785.0 square feet aver- age x 1.5 7,177.5 square feet maxi- mum floor area Maximum FAR is smaller of the two: 7,177.5 square feet Supp. No. 1 CD70:29 Gulf Stream Core Ocean West Beachfront NorthlSouth Place au Soleil Neighbor- Lots greater than 20,000 Lots greater than 20,000 hood Context square feet created after N/A N/A N/A square feet created after FAR Applica- adoption of this manual adoption of this manual bility (2) When dealing with double lots, it is reasonable to allow a larger home than would be allowed on a single lot, but probably not twice as large if abutting lots remain small. An equitable method for determining the maximum FAR for a double lot (or when a vacant lot is split between two existing homes) shall be to use existing abutting lots to create a "neighborhood context FAR" or average FAR yield and then to apply a reasonable factor for floor area expansion. (3) For lots over 20,000 square feet in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil districts created after the adoption of this manual, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the average maximum FAR yield of the two abutting lots with a 50 percent increase allowance. If the neighborhood context FAR is less than the standard FAR, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the maximum allowed. This will restrict new houses or homes with additions to a size that, while large, would not overshadow neighborhood residences. For example: Double lot at 33,000 square feet. Maximum FAR for newly created lots over 20,000 square feet is the smaller of the two FAR calculations (sliding scale FAR and neighborhood context FAR). a. Sliding scale FAR: 20,000 square feet x .33 13,000 square feet x .20 Total 33,000 square feet b. Neighborhood context FAR: Neighbor 1 lot: 13,000 square feet x .33 Neighbor 2 lot: 16,000 square feet x .33 Total 6,600 square feet 2,600 square feet 9,200 square feet maximum floor area 4,290 square feet maximum 5,280 square feet maximum 9,570 square feet max _ 2 = 4,785.0 square feet aver- age x 1.5 7,177.5 square feet maxi- mum floor area Maximum FAR is smaller of the two: 7,177.5 square feet Supp. No. 1 CD70:29 § 70-71 GULF STREAM CODE (4) For lots subject to neighborhood context FAR, the methodology for identifying abutting lots is as follows: Note: Lots not conforming to outlined examples are subject to approval by the town Planning and Building Administrator in keeping with these guidelines. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 26, 3-10-00) :14 ' `'4 3c .; End Lot 13'1 J� 5 t 12 t t 6 15 •'s.... o t.16 10 g Corner Lot 25 24 .23 22t:21420.18 2627:.'28 :,Yt 31 19 'l J.Y i ✓ L= t—1 ` Interior Lot Combined Lot Types Sec. 70-72. Special exception floor area ratio (FAR). (a) Lots of less than 7,576 square feet. Up to 2,500 square feet of floor area may be permitted on any legally established lot of record of 7,576 square feet or less, subject to the following: (1) Maximum floor area. The maximum floor area is 2,500 square feet. (2) Specific standards for review. Site and structural design elements including, but not limited to: a. Height of the structure relative to neighboring structures; b. The location, number and size of windows, doors, porches, balconies and outdoor lights; Supp. No. 1 CD70:30 Abutting Neighbor #1 Abutting Neighbor #2 For interior lots, abutting lots are: the side lot the other side lot example: if lots 29 and 30 are combined, abut- ting lots are: lot 28 lot 31 For corner lots, abutting lots are: the side lot which faces the same the largest lot directly across the street same street example: if lots 7 and 8 are combined, abutting lots are: lot 6 lot 17 For end lots, abutting lots are: the side lot the next nearest lot on street example: if lots 1 and 2 are combined, abutting lots are: lot 3 lot 4 Note: Lots not conforming to outlined examples are subject to approval by the town Planning and Building Administrator in keeping with these guidelines. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 26, 3-10-00) :14 ' `'4 3c .; End Lot 13'1 J� 5 t 12 t t 6 15 •'s.... o t.16 10 g Corner Lot 25 24 .23 22t:21420.18 2627:.'28 :,Yt 31 19 'l J.Y i ✓ L= t—1 ` Interior Lot Combined Lot Types Sec. 70-72. Special exception floor area ratio (FAR). (a) Lots of less than 7,576 square feet. Up to 2,500 square feet of floor area may be permitted on any legally established lot of record of 7,576 square feet or less, subject to the following: (1) Maximum floor area. The maximum floor area is 2,500 square feet. (2) Specific standards for review. Site and structural design elements including, but not limited to: a. Height of the structure relative to neighboring structures; b. The location, number and size of windows, doors, porches, balconies and outdoor lights; Supp. No. 1 CD70:30 SLI/ GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-68 ARTICLE IV. SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Sec. 70-66. Generally. Typically, zoning regulations affect the size and location of development on individual lots and establish the basic building envelope. The development standards in this article respond to the unique characteristics of the town's five single-family zoning districts and address community concerns regarding the mass of new construction and its impact on neighborhood character. Sec. 70-67. Effective lot area. (a) Because many of the site development regulations contained in this chapter are a function of lot size, the definition of the term "lot size" becomes very important. One of the key goals of this chapter is to maintain a proper proportion and scale between buildings and between buildings and the land. Accordingly, it is necessary to establish an "effective lot area" in order to meet this goal. (b) All references to "lot size" or "lot area" in this chapter shall have the same meaning as "effective lot area" which is defined as follows. "Effective lot area" shall mean the platted/recorded lot area minus the following: (1) Any submerged lands. (2) Any lands east of the Coastal Construction Control Line established in 1978. (3) Any lands separated from the main portion of the lot by public or private roads. (4) Any lands used for private road surfaces including an additional ten feet of area beyond the edge of the pavement of a private road. (5) Any unrecorded public right-of-way which shall be determined by using an average of the recorded right-of-way adjacent to other properties along the same roadway. Sec. 70-68. Lot size and dimensional requirements. The following requirements shall apply only to lots created after the adoption of this chapter. Nonconforming lots which were legally subdivided and recorded in accordance with the regulations in effect at the time of the subdivision, but prior to the adoption of this chapter, shall have all building rights provided under this chapter and chapter 66 provided all other applicable requirements are met. Minimum Lot Size and Gulf Stream North/ Place au Dimensional Requirements Core Ocean West Beachfront South Soleil Effective Lot Area 16,500 30,000 30,000 20,000 15,000 Width Front 100 100 150 100 100 (Rectangular Shaped Lot) Front/Point 40 40 N/A 40 40 (Pie Shaped Lot) Other Lots shall have a All lots shall have a minimum frontage minimum of 150 feet of 100 feet on both of frontage on both AIA and Gulf AIA and the ocean. Stream Road where Land -locked lots are adjacent to both. prohibited. (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 26, 27, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 008-5, § 1, 9-5-08) Supp. No. 1 CD70:27 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-4 (c) In addition to the design standards contained in this chapter, for convenience, the specific mandatory land development regulations are included to facilitate an overall understanding of the review criteria to which new construction is subject. North Ocean Boulevard entering Gulf Stream Sec. 70-4. How to use this manual. (a) Organization. This chapter is organized into nine articles. The user is encouraged to read the chapter in its entirety. This chapter is a full part of the town's land development regulations and has the same force and effect of all other provisions contained therein. (1) Articles III and IV. Article III, Use Regulations, and article IV, Site Development Regulations, contain land development regulations which are mandatory and apply to all of the single-family zoning districts. These are the typical zoning -type regulations found in most other codes. (2) Articles V through VIII. Articles V through VIII provide design standards and establish a basis for review and approval of all new single-family construction or remodeling. Article V, Areawide Standards, applies to all single-family homes in the town. Provisions with respect to Gulf Stream -Bermuda and Mediterranean Revival architecture (see article VII) are not applicable if an alternate architectural design is selected. The reader is encouraged, however, to become familiar with their provisions in that they are the preferred styles in most of the town. (3) Article VL Article VI, District Standards, provides more specific design direction for the five single-family zoning districts established in this chapter. The user should identify the applicable district and should study it carefully to ensure that the unique characteristics of and appropriate design direction for that district are incorporated into any design proposal. (4) Article VIL Article VII, Predominant Architectural Styles, contains design standards for Gulf Stream -Bermuda and Mediterranean Revival styles of architecture. As discussed, these styles are not mandatory but are indicative of the predominant styles within the community. (5) Article VIII. Article VIII, Supplemental Development Regulations, addresses elements such as antennas, that sometimes are tacked on to homes that otherwise display good design character- istics. Standards for these elements are provided in this article. CD70:7 § 70-4 GULF STREAM CODE (6) Article IX. Finally, an appendix is included in article IX. This includes a glossary of architectural terms, an explanation of the development review process, details of the historic survey and single-family development survey, a discussion of color, and a bibliography. These are included as reference materials but are not formally a part of this chapter or chapter 66. (b) Illustrations. The illustrations contained within this chapter address and respond to the oppor- tunities for enhancing and preserving the visual environment of the town. (c) Design standards. The design standards in this chapter provide the town with a methodology and common framework for reviewing submissions for project approvals. The design standards contained herein are either mandatory or discretionary. The terms "required" and "prohibited" are mandatory. The terms "preferred" and "discouraged" are discretionary. These terms are defined below: (1) Required. a. Required items are design elements that are necessary in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. b. Compliance is mandatory for project approval. (2) Preferred. a. Preferred items are design elements that, whenever possible, should be used in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. These items are those typically found in the town and which, in combination with other preferred items, define the existing and desired character of the town and the zoning districts. Preferred items are thought to comply with the 'following goals with respect to desired zoning district character and quality: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. b. Incorporating preferred items into a design increases the probability of, but does not assure, project approval. (3) Discouraged. a. Discouraged items are design elements that should not be used in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. These items are not typically found in the town and detract from the existing and desired character of the town and the zoning districts. Discouraged items are thought to not comply with the following goals with respect to desired zoning district character and quality: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. b. Incorporating discouraged items into a design decreases the probability of project approval and may result in project denial. In order for a discouraged item to be approved, applicants must show, and the town must find, that the proposed item is not inconsistent with the above goals. The use of more than three discouraged items on any property is prohibited. CD70:8 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL (4) Prohibited. § 70-25 a. Prohibited items are design elements that do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located and are not permitted under current codes or regulations. b. The use of more than three discouraged items on a property is prohibited. C. Use of prohibited elements mandates project denial. (d) Additional standards and criteria. Please note that the chapter constitutes only one small subsection of the Land Development Regulations found in this Code. While compliance with the standards found in articles I through VIII of this chapter is essential to final project approval, compliance with several additional standards and criteria also may be necessary before a building permit can be issued. Accordingly, users of this chapter are strongly advised to familiarize themselves with all federal, state and/or town regulations that might apply to a particular type of project. To assist in determining which town regulations may apply, users are encouraged to review the tables and flow chart contained in section 70-297 of this chapter. Users also are encouraged to direct questions to, and share information with, town planning staff as early as possible in the plan development stage. Secs. 70-5-70-25. Reserved. CD70:9 s CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley February 16, 2012 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 23, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. ArWTvTrA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1-26-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. March 22, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Subdivision Review a. Section 66-1, Definitions b. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio C. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements d. Section 70-4, How to Use This Manual 2. Section 70-238, Roofs 3. Section 70-100, Roof & Eave Heights 4. Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures 5. Section 66-367, Swimming Pools 6. Section 66-369, Docks VII. Items by Board Members. VIII. Public. IX. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 26, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:30 A. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Ganger called the meeting to order at Robert W. Ganger Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Paul Lyons, Jr. Thomas M. Stanley Amanda Jones William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Mark Marsh, Architect Bridges, Marsh & Assoc Grant Thornbrough Landscape Arch., A. Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Board Member Alternate Member Alternate Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent for Roach and Davis Agent for Roach Grant Thornbrough & Assoc. Pat Scullen Gulf Stream School III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 12-22-11. Chairman Ganger said he hoped all Board Members had an opportunity to read both the 12/22/11 ARPB Minutes and the Minutes of the January 13, 2012 Commission Meeting. He said the Comp Plan revisions were approved by the LPA in context and some of the changes reflect the views of the ARPB. Chairman Ganger added that there were notations from Clerk Taylor concerning the process of revising the Comp Plan and Zoning Codes. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 12/22/11. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. February 23, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. March 22, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. f. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Mr. Smith asked if there would be a February meeting there will be a February meeting for the purpose of items concerning zoning code changes. There were no meeting schedule. Clerk Taylor said discussing other conflicts in the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 2 VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges Marsh & Associates, as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. Curtiss Roach, the owners of property located at 3560 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, 33483, which is legally described as Lot 3, Block 2, Polo Fields. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS to permit two, one-story additions to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling, each of which would encroach 2.3 feet into the north side setback, and also to permit a single story addition to the same dwelling that would encroach 2.8 feet into the south side setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of three one-story additions, 809 square feet, to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling with two of the additions encroaching 2.3 feet into the north side setback and one addition encroaching 2.8 feet into the south side setback, and to permit the reconfiguration of the driveway. Chairman Ganger asked if there was any ex -parte communication concerning this matter. There were no declarations. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to Mark Marsh, Grant Thornbrough and Patricia Scullen. Mark Marsh introduced himself and stated that Grant Thornbrough, Landscape Architect, was present to review the proposed landscape plan. Mr. Marsh described the existing home as a Gulfstream Bermuda Style of the 1960s, which is not conducive to current lifestyles, and he said the owners are asking for modest renovations, minor expansions and some interior renovation and remodeling. He displayed photos of the existing home as viewed from Gulf Stream Road showing a white tile roof, a nice roof line and simple architectural detail. Mr. Marsh said the home sits on a standard lot, it consists of 3200 SF and the expansions will take it to 3900 SF. Mr. Marsh said they propose an extension of the garage 7' to the east, an addition of a bedroom/office area/ cabana and extend the dining area on the northwest side, and an addition of an office/sitting area off of the master suite. He said the reason for the Special Exception is that these additions are maintaining the existing non -conforming setbacks, which were 12 12 feet many years ago when the house was built and are now 15' under current code. Mr. Marsh said they are in violation by 2.8 feet; however, he said in the past Staff and the ARPB have allowed such expansions that have no impact adjacent properties. Mr. Marsh said the plan modifications include moving the garage to the east to accommodate an interior laundry room, reworking the living room, family room, kitchen and foyer areas, and adding office/sitting areas and a cabana area. He said the courtyard has a very dark and alley -like feel and to capture the use of the courtyard they will reduce the wall Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 3 height and add a scallop and rail detail, create a trellis to serve as a winter porch and introduce an outdoor fireplace. With regard to the fenestration, Mr. Marsh explained that the detail along the east face of the home includes a Bay Window which will be replaced by casements with shutters to create a balance both inside and out. He said the existing sliding glass doors at the rear which face the pool area will be replaced with impact and the arched entryway will be simplified with plaster detail and simple embellishment. Mr. Marsh said the exterior wall color will be beige, the shutters will be a muted green, the projected garage will be an extended hip roof with white roof tile to match the existing. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if there were any objections or comments by neighbors. Mr. Marsh explained that the only comments were from Gulf Stream School concerning the driveway, noise from the air conditioning and a drainage matter. He said the idea is to maintain the buffer and, therefore, they will relocate the driveway with hedging across the front and a small pedestrian entry into the motor court. They plan to replace the air conditioning units, but keeping them in the same location and they will eliminate the roof drainage with a new drainage plan. Pat Scullen of Gulf Stream School said there are no further objections as long as they maintain the hedge, which they have agreed to do. Mr. Marsh said there is a meandering well-established hedge along the north side of the property. He said the owners are environmentalists and appreciate the lush landscaping and they will maintain that hedge. He introduced Grant Thornbrough, the landscape architect, to explain the landscape plan. Mr. Thornbrough said the existing driveway is semi -circular and faces the Gulf Stream School parking lot. He said the proposed driveway will have one entrance and they will create a motor court area. The loose Chattahoochee material will be replaced with pavers, there will be a small seating area and planted areas in the motor court which will be enclosed by a short privacy hedge with piers and there will be a small pedestrian walkway into the motor court. He said there are low catch basins in the road and to avoid interference with the drainage the pedestrian walkway will be three steps up with a small privacy gate. Mr. Thornbrough described the front courtyard which will feature a trellis with vines, a small bench and a platform for decorative potted plants. It will also feature a propane gas log fireplace and the exterior finish on the chimney will match the exterior wall color and finish. He said the exterior finish is currently stucco, which may change slightly. Mr. Thornbrough said there will be a continuous walkway from the front yard to the backyard, new irrigation and not much additional landscaping along the sides of the home; however, he said they will work with the adjoining neighbors in an effort to maintain the meandering hedge and Areca Palms along the north property line for privacy. He said they will use the existing pool and the deck, which will require some pilings underneath, and will be resurfaced using a stamp concrete with sea glass. Mr. Thornbrough said there will be a small patio with a garden off of the office addition which will be Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 4 separate from the pool area, a small garden area around the pool and a Butterfly Garden with flowering plants in the back. Chairman Ganger asked about the road elevation and the house elevation. Mr. Marsh said the road elevation is 4 feet and the house elevation is 8.27 feet. Mr. Lyons asked about the School's concern regarding the drainage. Pat Scullen stated that the former owner of the home put downspouts through the hedge and the school property would get quite wet; however, she said this issue has been addressed. Vice -Chairman Morgan said his only concern was the non -conforming setbacks which will require the involvement of the north and south neighbors to work with the owner on landscaping. He complimented the consultants for maintaining the Old Florida look of the home. With regard to the roof plan, Mr. Smith asked about the Cricket. Mr. Marsh explained that it is elevated in the valley where two sloped roofs come together creating another interior sloped element which is called a cricket, and it diverts the water to the exterior. Chairman Ganger asked for comments from the Staff. Mr. Thrasher asked the consultants to verify the height of the piers in the front and the distance of the piers from the pavement. Mr. Marsh said the piers are 3 1� feet back from the property line and 6' to 8' back from the pavement. Mr. Thrasher said he would like to add the condition that the height of piers and distance from the edge of pavement would conform to Code Section 70-187, subsection 6, which prohibits the top of piers to be greater than 4' tall and the edge of the pier would be at least 7 l� feet from the edge of pavement. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception based on a finding that the proposed two, one- story additions to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling, each of which would encroach 2.3 feet into the north side setback, and the single story addition to the dwelling that would encroach 2.8 feet into the south side setback meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of the Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed construction of three one-story additions, 809 SF, to the existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling with two of the additions encroaching 2.3 feet into the north side setback and one addition encroaching 2.8 feet into the south side setback meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards, with the condition that the height of piers and their location comply with Code Section 70-187, subsection 4. No Discussion. All voted AYE. VII. Items Related to Previous Approvals. A. Revision of an approved renovation at 554 Palm Way submitted by Mark Marsh as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. James Davis to permit the elimination of a 2 -story garage with storage/guest room Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 5 and the addition of a second story above the existing garage for storage/guest room. Mr. Marsh summarized the Davis application to renovate their existing home at 554 Palm Way which was approved last summer. He said construction began about two months ago and the owners have concerns about the proposed 2 -story detached building which would have been a one -car garage with a guest room and exercise area on the second floor. The structure cannot be attached to the house because of a 10 -foot drainage easement which dissects the property; however, he said the owners feel that a detached structure would be too remote from the main house and they would like to maintain that open space as a play area for the children. Mr. Marsh said they would like to eliminate the detached structure and are proposing to expand the existing two -car garage and add a second floor, which would be a full suite consisting of a guest room and bath and an exercise room. He said the entry element of the existing garage currently faces north and they are proposing to expand the garage about 12' to the north with flip garage doors facing east and a half -garage door facing north for bicycles and other recreational equipment. The entry into the second floor of the garage will be from an interior staircase going up to a loft play area and then into the exercise room and guest suite. Mr. Marsh displayed drawings of the new plan showing all views. He said the owners are going with a ventless fireplace and, therefore, propose removing the chimneys. Mr. Marsh displayed the new rendering, saying they have simplified what they refer to as the service area of the home by removing the heavy dramatic piers and creating wing walls instead. He said he would like the Board to support the removal of the piers. Vice -Chairman Morgan pointed out that there appears to be bars over the sidelight windows on the north elevation. Mr. Marsh said it is grillwork. In addition, Mr. Marsh stated that the grey roof tile which was originally presented to the Board may be revised to add mottling to the grey. Chairman Ganger said the Board is in the process of looking at the section of the Code that addresses roof tile and, therefore, the Board will definitely need to review any revisions in that regard. Mr. Marsh said he will come back to the Board with the actual tile, saying that it will be closer to the roof tile used in Ocean Ridge. Mr. Thrasher said, for the record, this went to Urban Design for calculations in two areas. The first was the FAR, and their response indicated that a variance would be required to exceed the FAR. In discussing the matter, Mark Marsh and Marty Minor worked it out and the plan was modified to conform to the FAR. He said the second area was the calculations of percentage of second story to first story, which seemed to be a bit massive with a 26% increase. Mr. Thrasher said Staff was trying to accommodate Mr. Marsh, but if he had more time for review he would have commented that the house as presented appears to be massive and not in context with the neighborhood. In closing, Mr. Thrasher stated that the FAR now conforms and the second story coverage has always conformed. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 6 Mr. Marsh explained that Marty Minor said the square footage and FAR did not correlate with their calculations. He said the ground floor has a brick veneer on concrete block and the owner could not decide whether to keep the brick and stucco over the brick or remove the brick and stucco over standard concrete block. Mr. Marsh said he took calculations to the outside face of the brick, which created the FAR situation. He said the owner has decided to keep the brick and stucco over it. He said with regard to the other issue, the house has water on two sides, it is set back far from the edge of the water, they are 60 feet from the road at any point and they are 57% uncovered. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he had the same impression as Mr. Thrasher when reviewing the plans because there seemed to be massing on the north side when changing this property. He said the previous drawing had symmetry and now, with the ancillary wing and the elevated garage on the northwest side, the elevations caught his attention. Mr. Marsh said his presentations are always in 3D because it shows mass and imbalance. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve the revised renovations of 554 Palm Way to permit the elimination of a 2 -story garage with storage/guest room and to permit the addition of a second - story above the existing garage for a storage/guest room, the elimination of the chimneys, the elimination of piers as submitted, with additional drawings to come, and with submission of the adjustment of the color and texture of roof tile. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. The ARPB Meeting was recessed at 9:30 A.M. to review a letter from Vice - Chairman Morgan addressed to the ARPB regarding changes to Article II of the Gulf Stream Design Manual/Single Family Districts, Art.II, Section 70; and, to review the Memorandum from Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios addressed to William Thrasher regarding subdivision analysis. The Meeting reconvened at 9:40 A.M. VIII. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Section 70-238, Roofs 2. Section 70-100, Roof & Eave Heights 3. Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures 4. Section 66-367, Swimming Pools 5. Section 66-369, Docks 6. Section 66-1, Definitions 7. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio 8. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements 9. Section 70-4, How To Use This Manual Chairman Ganger suggested beginning with items having zoning in progress. Mr. Randolph explained that zoning in progress is in place or any item being considered for change by the Board, such as subdivisions, lot dimensions and any item under study, whether it was discussed at a previous meeting or during this meeting and it is reflected in the Meeting Minutes. Chairman Ganger asked for Mr. Randolph's insight, specifically concerning subdivisions because case law is cited, and Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 7 Vice -Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Randolph to go over the Memorandum from Urban Design while it is still fresh. Chairman Ganger said the Commission is expecting the recommendations from the ARPB and he said when the State and Treasure Coast Regional Planning Counsel comments concerning the amended changes to the Comp Plan are received, there should be one change to the Comp Plan and one change to the Code at the same time. Mr. Randolph said, per the request of the Board, Mr. Minor included a list of lots in his Memorandum which may be subject to subdivision in the future. He said Mr. Minor also took note that the County has a provision regarding Coastal High Hazard Areas which indicates that no increase in density or subdivision should be included in Coastal High Hazard Areas. Mr. Randolph said he sent Mr. Minor a copy of Tequesta's Ordinance in that regard, which may no longer exist, showing that other communities had something in place which was similar to Palm Beach County in that respect. He said Mr. Minor looked at subdivision codes from other municipalities and saw that some are more complete than Gulf Stream Code. Mr. Randolph said the Board is not in a position to finalize anything today; however, he said suggestions, recommendations and proposed criteria included in Mr. Minor's Memorandum are worthy of continued study and consideration. Mr. Randolph said the Board may not implement all of the criteria, but he said one of the most specific proposed criteria provides that a subdivision shall be in character with other lots within 500 feet in any direction of the subdivision. He recommended that the Board ask Mr. Minor to continue with the study and come back with his presentation. Mr. Randolph said Mr. Minor pointed out the Burt Harris Act which was adopted about 15 years ago. He said any regulation in effect prior to the Burt Harris Act is not subject to the Act, but any regulation adopted subsequent to the Act would be subject to it. Mr. Randolph said the Burt Harris Act provides that if persons having reasonable investment -back expectations in a property at the time of purchase and regulations are imposed subsequent to the Act which could diminish their reasonable investment -back expectations and their property is diminished in value, the entity imposing those regulations may be subject to the provisions of the Burt Harris Act and may be responsible to pay the difference incurred as a result of the regulation. He said communities should not fear the Burt Harris Act, but should consider it in their planning process. Mr. Randolph said when the Commission is determining whether to put new regulations in place they should give consideration to how the Act will impact those regulations. Mr. Randolph was asked, if a change had been made by the Board with respect to subdivisions prior to the Spence matter that would have potentially restricted the purchaser to the use of that property, would the next step have been some form of appraisal. Mr. Randolph confirmed that and said it would only relate to the regulations that were imposed subsequent to Burt Harris. He said the reasonable investment -back expectations would have applied to the prior owner of the property and, if they wanted to sell to a developer and regulations were imposed prior Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 8 to their sale they would have had a cause of action and the next step would be to get an appraisal. The appraiser could say that, as a result of the regulations put in place, the property has diminished in value at "X" amount, which would present an opportunity for mediation between the Town and the property owner to come to an agreement. If an agreement is not reached, the property owner could go to court. Mr. Randolph was asked if existing Code predates Burt Harris and he confirmed that saying most of the Code was in place prior to Burt Harris and there have been substantive changes, but none that would invoke the Burt Harris Act. He said if regulations in Section 70-4 allowed the Town to give consideration to the size of surrounding lots when determining whether or not a subdivision could be approved, he believes those regulations were in effect prior to Burt Harris. Mr. Randolph said the concern should be with any future amendments made to the Code that could invoke Burt Harris. Mr. Randolph was asked, what if in five years from now someone wants to subdivide and states they were not aware of the impact on the value of their property five years ago, but they are now. Mr. Randolph said that question went unresolved in the courts for a long time because they questioned whether or not the year runs from the time of the imposition of the code or from the imposition of the regulation on their property. He said he would look into that for clarification. Mr. Randolph was asked if there was anything in the proposed criteria that does not already exist in the Code which could invoke Burt Harris, and if there is a stipulation in the Code with regard to the 500 -foot rule. In response, Mr. Randolph said the 500 -foot rule does not currently exist in the Code, unless we can determine that Section 70-4 is similar, and he said that would have been the one criteria proposal he would have pointed out in Mr. Minor's list that could invoke Burt Harris. Mr. Randolph said the other criteria are very general, almost implying "shall protect the character of the Town." He said, if put into place it would not change the current state of the law as it relates to subdivisions and it would not invoke Burt Harris, but neither does it provide a tool to allow the Town to turn down a subdivision. Mr. Randolph summarized the other criteria saying Bullets 43 and 44 are similar and Bullets 45 through 49 are implied in existing language of the Code. Chairman Ganger asked if the 500 -foot rule is appropriate and has it been tested. Mr. Randolph said he has discussed this with Marty Minor and he needs to do some research in other codes with regard to the 500 - foot rule. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the point of his letter was to show that the 500 -foot rule is already in the Code and, with regard to the Spence Property, the Board may have considered this and felt that the property was not inconsistent with the character of the Town. Mr. Randolph said there are no decisions being made today and he encouraged the Board to not act too quickly in putting new language in place. He said as these matters are being studied, the Town Manager cannot grant building permits until the study is complete. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 9 Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if there are State Laws that may be in conflict with what the Board is trying to accomplish. Mr. Randolph said there is specific case law with regard to subdivisions, one in particular which provides that as long as a subdivision application is in conformity with all of the lot, yard and bulk regulations within a zoning district, the municipality has no discretion as to whether or not they can turn it down. He said he would like to study Chapter 163 which addresses Coastal High Hazard Areas and examine that with regard to the Burt Harris Act. He will look for language putting people purchasing property on notice that if they are in a Coastal High Hazard Area the municipality may have a right to restrict further density and subdivision within that district. Mr. Randolph said that, although the Town may not have that language in effect, if Chapter 163 gives notice to people purchasing property that such restrictions may go into effect in a Coastal High Hazard Area it may be a defense for Burt Harris if the Town is ever in a position to defend itself. Chairman Ganger said the State has removed that policy and the County has chosen to maintain it and, therefore, DCA will not be looking at this, but it may come back. He said we are a municipality within a county that has this policy and we should lean heavily on it. Mr. Randolph said if the Board feels any of Mr. Minor's recommendations are worthy of study, the Board should ask him to continue and come back with his findings. He said there may be an opportunity for the Board to include provisions beyond lot size when giving consideration to subdivision. Mr. Randolph said there is more than lot size included in the current Code, such as road width, easements and lot frontages and, after reviewing Mr. Minor's findings and further case law, the Board may find one or two items that would be helpful or find nothing further to impose. Mr. Randolph said it may be necessary to have a study of what the actual lot sizes are of all homes within a particular district as opposed to what the Zoning Code calls for and we may find that most of the lots are larger than the minimum lot size in the Code. If that is so, it would be justification to increase minimum lot size. If it shows that they are all as set forth in the Code, it would be difficult to select certain areas in a zoning district to increase lot size. When asked if it would invoke Burt Harris if lot size is increased, Mr. Randolph confirmed that, but he said it would depend on how much the lot size was increased. Chairman Ganger used the empty lot recently annexed into Gulf Stream as an example and Mr. Randolph said that different laws may come into play. He said State Law says that the zoning applicable in the County will apply until rezoned by the Town. Chairman Ganger said there are 24 lots that have the potential for subdivision and asked if it is worth the effort to seek opportunities to maintain the scale of the community. He said citizens of the community do not want to see massive subdivisions, which is why we are addressing the matter. Mr. Randolph said Mr. Minor has provided the information requested by the Board and, if the Board feels that the report is dramatic enough to impose further regulations he suggests that Mr. Minor continue a study of the items he proposed from the standpoint of specific regulations and the Coastal High Hazard Areas. Clerk Taylor Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 26, 2012 Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 10 said she has a question concerning the lots Mr. Minor chose and believes it is strictly by lot size. She said the beachfront requires that frontage be 150 feet and she is not sure this was taken into consideration when counting the lots that could be divided. Clerk Taylor said some of the lots include canals and they should not be counted. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Minor to be more specific with lots and land mass and to tighten the language. Mr. Randolph said it seems as though the Board would like the study to continue with regard to lot size and dimensions and with regard to subdivisions, to include the various items discussed today, such as Coastal High Hazard Area and some of the proposed criteria. He recommended that the Board make a motion to authorize the Consultant to move forward with a study of all of the items considered today, specifically those items which were included in the Consultant's January 25, 2012 Memorandum, the Coastal High Hazard Area, lot size and dimensions and subdivision viability. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to authorize Urban Design Kilday Studios to continue their study and subdivision analysis, following up on issues raised in their January 25, 2012 Report and issues discussed at this meeting, specifically looking at lot size and subdivision viability, Coastal High Hazard Area and how it may impact any decision by the Architectural Review and Planning Board and the Town Commission, and other legal ramifications. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. IX. Items by Board Members. Mr. Lyons addressing the transient housing issue. the Town's jurisdiction; however, he said Commission will consider changes in their transient housing as early as February 7, 21, 2012. asked if Gulf Stream would be Chairman Ganger said it is not the City of Delray Beach regulations relating to 2012 or as late as February X. Public. There were no items by the Public. XI. Adjournment. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to adjourn the Meeting. The Meeting was adjourned at 10:35 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant Potential Code Changes; 2012 1. Section 70:238. Roofs (a); Page CD70:93 Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval Recommended Changes: Required. Flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated tile, except that gray, slate or slate -style, may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences, subject to Level II approval. 2. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights Define preferred, discouraged and prohibited height of entry feature. Recommended Changes: Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable or other such element. Height: Preferred, From eight feet to 14 feet. Discouraged, From 14 feet to 16 feet. Prohibited. Greater than 16 feet. 3. Section 70-51 Minor accessory structures (2); Page CD70:24 In -ground swimming pools and spas Recommended Changes: Add "Waterfalls" 4. Section 66-367 Swimming pools Recommended Change: Add (j) No grotto shall be permitted in any zoning district. A grotto shall be considered and artificial structure or excavation made to look like a cave or cavern. (k) Waterfalls, minor accessory structures, shall not exceed 4' in height as measured from the average finished grade of the property and the back side of the structure shall be screened from off -premises view with landscape material. 5. Section 66-369 Docks (7); Page CD66:71 Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. Recommended Changes: No concrete docks are permitted. All docks will be made from natural materials. 6. Section 66-1 Definitions Recommended Change: Basement shall mean that portion of a building which is below the finished floor elevation of the building. A basement is not considered a story with regards to height measurement of a building. The square footage of a basement shall be included in the FAR calculations at 50% and not be usable for living purposes which includes working, sleeping, eating, cooking or recreation, or a combination thereof. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the structure. 7. Section 70-71 Floor Area Ratio Recommended Change: Seeking Input 8. Section 70-68 Lot size and dimensional requirements. Recommended Change: Seeking Input 9. Section 70-4 How to use this Manual Recommended Change: Seeking Input GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-238 (b) Stepbacks. The use of stepbacks is appropriate to reduce excessive bulkiness and provide a transition between first and second stories. A few critical stepbacks on a building are better than several minor stepbacks that only complicate the facade and create busy architecture. (c) Preferred. Balconiesy. Simple rectangular config- urations ti Single story garages Smaller second story con- figurations 4 k Stepbacks to second story (d) Discouraged. Angular walls Complex facade treatment (excessive multi -layer stepbacks) Stepbacks, smaller second story, single story garage, and a balcony help to Sec. 70-238. Roofs. articulate and give appropriate scale to this house (preferred). (a) Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style tile may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval. (b) Preferred. Combination hip/gable roofs Decorative capped chim- ney Exposed rafter tails Flashing, vent stacks, and pipes painted to match ad- jacent building surface Hip roof Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes) Roof overhang (2-2Y2 feet) Simple roof geometry em- phasizing long horizontal lines White flat untextured tile Gulf Stream- Bermuda style white tile roof (required) OC, Corr. CD70:93 § 70-238 (c) Discouraged. Dormers on single story GULF STREAM CODE houses Gable Pyramidal hip (often has too steep of slope) Very low pitched roofs (slope less than 5:12) (d) Prohibited. Barrel tiles -� Front gable except for en- try features - - Gambrel Mansard Monolithic roof design where inadequate mea- sures were taken to re- duce massing and height Roof detail showing exposed rafter tails and decorative capped chimney of roof design (preferred) Pan tiles Shed Shingles Tiles other than white flat untextured tiles or gray slate tiles Unnecessarily complex roof geometry (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 56, 57, 3-10-00) OC, Corr. CD70:94 § 70-99 GULF STREAM CODE Metal roofs (except unpainted copper when used as a decorative accent or on minor accessory structures) Non-earthtone colors (except white), for example: blue, peach, pink, teal or yellow Primary color tiles and shingles Roll tile and similar tile styles in all districts except Place Au Soleil S -Tile in all districts except Place Au Soleil Solar panels on the streetside Unnecessarily complex or monolithic roof design All white tile other than flat cement tile (Ord. No. 00-1, § 36, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-9, § 2, 10-10-03) Sec. 70-100. Roof and eave heights. (a) Generally. (1) The height and number of eave lines and the overall height of a structure play an important role in establishing visual continuity with other structures on the street and maintaining an appropriate residential/human scale. Most structures in the town are characterized by simple roof designs with low to medium eave heights and roof heights. This type of design emphasizes the horizontal dimension of the structure while minimizing the vertical dimension. (2) Roof height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the highest exterior point on the roof. Eave height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the top of the roof beam at the end of the beam (top of flashing). Different eave heights establish different eave lines. Two or more separate roof areas with the same eave height are considered to have the same eave line. (3) Roof features can provide appropriate design articulation to a roof area, but should be used sparingly to avoid unnecessary and undesirable complexity. Roof features include, but are not limited to, chimneys, cupolas, decorative towers, dormers, and small cut-outs and extensions. Two or more dormers are considered to be one roof feature, as are two or more chimneys. (4) Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival to visitors, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches (from eight feet to 12 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Three or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 20 feet or less (24 feet or less for roof features) (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet (between 12 and 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Four Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 20 and 24 feet (between 24 and 28 feet for roof features) OC, Corr. CD70:46 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-100 (3) Prohibited. Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet (greater than 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Five or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side Roof heights: Greater than 24 feet (greater than 28 feet for roof features) (c) Two story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—From eight feet to 12 feet for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 22 feet six inches or less for two-story portions All other districts—From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 21 feet or less for two story portions Eave lines: Four or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 22 feet or less for one-story portions (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Between 12 and 14 feet for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 22 feet six inches and 24 feet six inches for two-story portions All other districts—Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 21 feet and 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Five Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 22 feet and 26 feet for one-story portions (3) Prohibited. Buildings with more than two and one-half stories Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 14 feet for one-story portions Greater than 24 feet six inches for two-story portions. All other districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet six inches for one-story portions Greater than 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Six or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side CD70:47 § 70 -loo GULF STREAM CODE Roof heights: Greater than 26 feet for one-story portions For two-story portions greater than the following for each zoning district: District Height in feet Gulf Stream Core 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Ocean West 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Beach Front 35 (including roof features) North/South 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Place Au Soliel 30 (roof features may extend to 35)" CD70:48 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-101 Preferred ■ Four or less eave lines Prohibited Six or more eave lines Line 3 Line 2 Line 1 Above graphic illustrates eight different eave lines, adding unnecessary complexity to the elevations. (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 26, 37, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-1, § 1, 4-11-03) Sec. 70-101. Windows. (a) Generally. (1) Windows not only provide light and ventilation but add to the aesthetics of a building by creating rhythm, proportion, distinction and articulation. Certain styles of windows correspond to specific CD70:49 + + & ¥ & E \ §@ R C ■ K | | / ■ | § § 4 § ■| �I �§�f| 7� ,.|■,�||wf|)�||||� + + & ¥ & E \ §@ R C & 4t A & b rA, O OR mill k� & 4t A & b rA, HER 1 PEM 01JR!, = -1 "Ill INN", CQ rn rvoiswa LU .fyt, r ,. i a �.: 7 ,' i § 70-49 GULF STREAM CODE (b) These prohibitions shall not extend to telephonic transactions and communications. Sec. 70-50. Private schools. Any private school conducted in any single family residential zoning district may continue to be used as such under the provisions of sections 66-131 et seq. of this Code, provided however, that any private school building, or other structure used in connection with and as a part of and appurtenant in the operation and maintenance of such private school, may be replaced, or another building substituted in place thereof; repaired and maintained from time to time as shall be necessary for the effective operation and maintenance of such private school; and further, any development permits, orders or written agreements granted or executed by the town prior to the adoption of this chapter shall remain in full force and effect. Sec. 70-51. Minor accessory structures. The following structures shall be considered as minor accessory structures in all five single family zoning districts subject to specific setbacks established in this chapter. Any structure which is larger or more intensive shall be subject to the same setbacks as the principal structure. (1) Detached, one-story structures of 300 square feet or less and 18 feet or less in height, including but not limited to: Garages/sheds Gazebos Greenhouses Guest houses Pool cabanas/bathhouses Trellises/arbors (2) Permanent recreation facilities, including but not limited to: Batting cages/backstops Forts and playhouses In -ground swimming pools and spas Paved/special surface areas and accompanying equipment and/or fencing for tennis/squash/ racquetball, basketball, shuffleboard, putting greens/sand traps, etc. Swing sets and other playground equipment (3) Fountains. (4) Mechanical equipment and television antennae/satellite dishes. (5) Decks and patios with elevations greater than eight inches above highest abutting grade. (6) Awnings with leg supports and those otherwise extending more than three feet out from a structure. (7) Docks, boat lifts, and davits. (8) Flagpoles. CD70:24 § 66-351 GULF STREAM CODE tion as a condition precedent to the issuance of a building permit for the proposed use. The unity of title declaration shall apply to all the property necessary for the proposed use, and shall declare that no portion of said property shall be sold or transferred by the owner or successors in interest apart from the whole. (b) If there is a sale or transfer in contraven- tion of a unity of title declaration, no building permit will be issued for any portion of the prop- erty contained in the unity of title declaration. Declaration shall remain in effect until a release of the unity of title declaration is executed by the town. (c) The unity of title declaration shall be filed at the expense of the owner in the public records of the county. Proof of such filing shall precede the issuance of a building permit. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, K), 4-8-83) Sec. 66-352. Nuisances. No use shall be made of any property within any district that shall in any way be offensive or noxious by reason of the emission of any dis- charge, odor, gas, dust, smoke, vibration or noise; nor shall any vehicle be parked or used in any way that would constitute a nuisance; nor shall anything be constructed or maintained that would in any way constitute a nuisance to adjacent property owners, residents or to the community. Each use shall be operated so as to lessen the damage from fire and explosion. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, J), 4-8-83) Cross reference—Nuisances, ch. 22. Secs. 66-353-66-365. Reserved. DIVISION 2. ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND RECREATIONAL FACILITIES Sec. 66-366. Antennas and antenna systems/ structures. (a) Broadcast receiving antennas or communi- cation antennas may be permitted in any zoning district upon site plan review and approval by the town commission and upon issuance of a building permit by the town. (b) Broadcast receiving antennas or communi- cation antennas shall be attached to the main building or structure and shall not extend more than five feet above the highest portion of the roof. (c) Satellite television antenna systems may be permitted in any zoning district upon site plan review and approval by the town commission and the issuance of a building permit by the town. (d) Satellite television antenna systems shall not exceed 12 feet in diameter or width. (e) Satellite television antenna systems shall be considered as accessory structures and shall be subject to the applicable site plan review require- ments and regulations of this chapter. (f) Unless specific approval is granted by the town commission, satellite television antenna sys- tems shall be ground mounted and located in such areas as to be screened or buffered from view from adjacent properties, rights-of-way, the Intracoastal Waterway and/or the Atlantic Ocean. (g) There shall not be more than one satellite television antenna system, broadcast receiving antenna or communication antenna per residen- tial building or condominium association on any platted lot or parcel. (h) Upon receipt of site plan approval and prior to the issuance of a building permit for satellite television antenna, the town commission shall review the installation plans, which plans must be signed and sealed by a professional engineer registered in the state who shall certify that the proposed satellite television antenna system is wind resistant with an ability to with- stand winds up to 140 miles per hour. The calcu- lations and such certification by the engineer shall be submitted along with the plans. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, H), 4-8-83; Ord. No. 84-7, § 2, 12-14-84) Sec. 66-367. Swimming pools. (a) No swimming pool shall be located, de- signed, operated or maintained so as to interfere unduly with the enjoyment of the property rights by owners of property adjoining the swimming pool. ZONING (b) Lights used to illuminate any swimming pool shall be so arranged and shadowed as to reflect away from adjoining premises. (c) A pool may be located within an enclosed courtyard, patio, etc., provided it is to the rear of the required front yard setback line. (d) All enclosed swimming pools shall be in conformity with the setbacks required by the zoning district in which it is located. (e) Unless otherwise specified elsewhere in this Code, unenclosed or open swimming pools in the "RS" single-family residential district shall be located a minimum of 25 feet from front property lines; provided, however, that any swimming pool located on property fronting on SR AlA shall be subject to the established 78 -foot centerline set- back. (f) Swimming pools shall be located on the same lot or parcel of land as that of the main building. In the event of contiguous lots or par- cels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. (g) All pools shall be enclosed by a self-locking, child resistant fence, wall or equivalent barrier at least four feet high, except as provided elsewhere in this Code, and in no event shall a pool be exposed to open view from any public roadway. (h) No aboveground pools of any nature shall be permitted in any zoning district. An aboveground pool shall be considered a pool constructed or assembled of any material and whose top edge exceeds two feet in height above the average finished grade of the lot or site. (i) All pools shall be landscaped so as to pre- vent exposure to off -premises view from any pub- lic roadway, any public or private right-of-way, and the ground level of any adjoining property. However, this subparagraph shall not be con- strued so as to prevent the exposure of pools to open view from public or private waterways. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 1), 4-8-83; Ord. No. 92-5, § 1, 9-28-92; Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 18, 19, 3-10-00) Sec. 66-368. Tennis courts. § 66-369 (a) No tennis court shall be located, designed, operated or maintained so as to interfere unduly with the enjoyment of the property rights by owners of property adjoining the tennis court. (b) No lights shall be used in any manner so as to illuminate any tennis court. (c) All tennis courts shall be in conformity with the setbacks required by the zoning district in which it is located. Any tennis court located on property fronting on SR AIA shall be subject to the established 78 -foot centerline setback. (d) Tennis courts shall be located on the same lot or parcel of land as that of the main building. In the event of contiguous lots or parcels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. (e) All tennis courts shall be enclosed by a fence, open wall or equivalent barrier and in no event shall a tennis court be exposed to open view from any public roadway. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 2), 4-8-83) Sec. 66-369. Docks. In the single-family residential district, one dock per lot of record shall be permitted in accor- dance with the following: Supp. No. 1 CD66:69 (1) Site plan review required. All new docks and significant alterations to existing docks shall require site plan review and ap- proval. (2) Permitted as accessory use. Docks shall be permitted only as an accessory use to single-family dwellings for the exclusive use of the dwelling's occupants (residents and nonresident members of the occupant's family and resident guests at the dwell- ing). Docks shall not be permitted on vacant lots unless the vacant lot is adja- cent to a developed lot under the same ownership and a unity of title has been recorded. . V. A - ,r, ZONING minimum offset from the setback centerlines. For lots with designated water frontage less than 100 feet the docking zone shall have a minimum five-foot offset from each of the set- back centerlines. In the case of cove end lots and lots with a water front- age of 100 feet or less, neither boat nor dock shall exceed a length of 70 feet. For rounded corner lots, water frontage is determined by the mid- point of the arc. For purposes of determining designated water front- age, dock widths, setbacks and max- imum boat lengths for each water- front lot within the Town, the figures contained within Exhibit "B" at- tached hereto and incorporated herein shall apply. [See the end of this sec- tion.] In cases with multiple water frontages, owner must treat each frontage according to the appropri- ate size category. In the case of low profile piling boat lifts, the lift shall be located in the following manner. The first piling shall be placed a minimum of twenty feet (towards center of the lot) from the setback line with the pilings extending into the docking zone no farther than twenty feet from the seawall. For lots with setbacks of more than fifteen feet on either side, the twenty foot mea- surement for the first piling shall be mea- sured from the setback on the side with the largest setback. f. A maximum of one dock box shall be permitted which shall be no higher than 30 inches and no larger than 24 cubic feet. § 66-369 g. Light fixtures shall be installed in a manner that provides safe pedes- trian circulation using low voltage lighting with a maximum fifty watts mounted no higher than three feet above the dock at a minimum spac- ing of ten feet on center. Lights are to be step, path or marine type fix- tures. Fixtures must project down- ward at a minimum 45 -degree angle from the horizontal plan tangent to the top of the light source fixture and allow no light spillage onto ad- jacent properties. No fixture shall be mounted to the seawall. h. Subject to level one site plan ap- proval, a maximum of one floating platform may be permitted in lieu of a boat lift for the purpose of storing small watercrafts. The floating plat- form shall be constructed of nonfer- rous material, be black in color and may not rise more than 12 inches out of the water. No more than two wa- tercrafts of a maximum length of 14 feet shall be stored on the floating platform. The platform dimensions shall not exceed eight feet in width or 16 feet in length. All watercrafts shall be stored parallel to the sea- wall. A floating platform must be removed after three months of dis- use. (7) Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 3),4-8-83; Ord. No. 91-24, § 3, 10-21-91; Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 20, 21, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 04-9, § 2,2-11-05; Ord. No. 05-2, §§ 1-6, 9-9-05; Ord. No. 008-4, § 4, 9-5-08) Supp. No. 1 CD66:71 ZONING ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL Sec. 66-1. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Abutting shall mean having a common border with, or being separated from such common bor- der by, an alley or easement. Access shall mean the principal means of in- gress and egress to property from a publicly dedicated right-of-way. Accessory building, structure or use shall mean a building, structure or use on the same lot with, and of a nature customarily incidental and sub- ordinate to, the principal building, structure or use. Acre, net. See Net acre/net land area. Addition (to an existing building) shall mean any walled and roofed expansion to the perimeter of a building in which the addition is connected by a common load-bearing wall other than a firewall. Any walled and roofed addition which is con- nected by a firewall or is separated by indepen- dent perimeter load-bearing walls is new construc- tion. Adjacent shall mean that which lies near or close to, not widely separated or necessarily touch- ing. Adjoining shall mean that which is joined or united, actually touching. Alley shall mean a dedicated public right-of- way other than a street which provides only a secondary means of access to abutting property, is not over 20 feet in width and is not intended for general traffic circulation. Alterations, as applied to a building or struc- ture, a change or rearrangement in the structural parts of the existing facilities, or an enlargement, whether by extending on a side, or by increasing the height, or the moving from one location or position to another. § 66-1 Antenna shall mean a device for radiating and/or receiving television or radio signals. Antenna structure shall mean an antenna con- sisting of two or more radiating elements, gener- ally similar which are arranged in such a manner as to obtain direction radiation patterns. It in- cludes any structural members which are neces- sary to maintain the proper electrical relation- ships between the radiating elements, including the mast or other structure used to support the array as a whole, but does not include the trans- mission line which supplies energy to or receives energy from the array as a whole. Apartment. See Dwelling, multiple -family. Appeal shall mean a means for obtaining re- view of a decision, determination, order, or failure to act pursuant to the terms of this chapter. Area of shallow flooding shall mean a desig- nated AO or VO Zone on a community's flood insurance rate map (FIRM) with base flood depths from one to three feet where a clearly defined channel does not exist, where the path of flooding is unpredictable and indeterminate, and where velocity flow may be evident. Area of special flood hazard shall mean the land in the floodplain within a community subject to a one percent or greater chance of flooding in any given year. Awning shall mean any movable rooflike struc- ture cantilevered or otherwise entirely supported from a building, so constructed and erected as to permit its being readily moved within a few minutes time to close an opening, or rolled or folded back to a position flat against the building or a cantilevered projection thereof, or which is detachable. Base flood shall mean the flood having a one percent chance of being equalled or exceeded in any given year. Base flood elevation shall mean the height above mean sea level expected to be reached by the 100 -year flood. Basement shall mean that portion of a build- ing, the ceiling which is entirely below grade or less than three feet above grade. A basement is Supp. No. 1 CD66:7 § 66-1 GULF STREAM CODE not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the build- ing. Bedroom shall mean a room other than a kitchen, dining room, living room, bathroom or closet which is marketed, designed or otherwise likely to function primarily for sleeping. Block shall mean a tract of land bounded by streets, or by a combination of streets and public parks, cemeteries, railroad rights-of-way, bulk- head lines, or shorelines of waterways, or corpo- rate boundary lines of the town. Breakaway wall shall mean a wall that is not part of the structural support of the building and is intended through its design and construction to collapse under specific lateral loading forces with- out causing damage to the elevated portion of the building or the supporting foundation system. Breezeway shall mean a roofed, open -sided pas- sageway connecting two separate structures, or two separate portions of the same structure. Broadcast receiving antenna shall mean an outside antenna used for the reception of signals transmitted by stations licensed by the Federal Communications Commission in the radio broad- cast services, including AM, FM and TV. Building area shall mean the portion of a lot remaining after required setbacks have been pro- vided. Building shall mean any structure built for the shelter, support or enclosure of persons, animals, chattels or movable property of any kind; and, when separated by division walls without opening from the ground up, each portion of such struc- ture shall be deemed a separate building, and for the purpose of this chapter, all porches, projec- tions, cornices and eaves shall be deemed and considered a part of a building. The word "build- ing" shall include the word "structure." Building, detached, shall mean a building hav- ing no party walls in common with another build- ing. Building front shall mean that exterior wall of a building which faces a front lot line of the lot. Building height shall mean the vertical dis- tance measured from the point of first floor base flood elevation of the building site to the highest finished roof structure including any rooftop su- perstructure or appurtenance. Building line shall mean a line on a lot, gener- ally parallel to a lot line or road right-of-way line, located a sufficient distance therefrom to provide the minimum yards required by this chapter. The building line delimits the area in which buildings are permitted subject to all applicable provisions of this chapter. Building official shall mean that person who is designated by the town commission and is charged with the responsibility of enforcing and adminis- tering the various land and building regulations of the town. Building permit shall mean the document or certificate issued by the town building official or other designated official which verifies adherence to all applicable development regulations and gives permission to the permit applicant to pro- ceed with the actions for which the permit was requested. Building, principal, shall mean a building in which is conducted, or in which is intended to be conducted, the main or principal use of the lot on which it is located. Building site shall mean a portion or parcel of land considered as a unit, devoted to a certain use or occupied by a building or group of buildings that are united by a common interest or use, and the customary accessories and open spaces belong- ing to the same. Bulk shall mean the term used to describe the size of buildings or other structures, and their relationships to each other and to open areas and lot lines. Carport shall mean a freestanding covered area or a roofed area open on one, two or three sides and attached to a building, either of which is designed for the storage of one or more vehicles or boats. Supp. No. 1 CD66:8 § 70-69 Sec. 70-69. Unity of title. GULF STREAM CODE In the event of contiguous lots or parcels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main residence building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. Sec. 70-70. Floor area calculation. For purposes of computing the floor area ratio, floor area shall be defined as follows. "Floor area" shall mean the gross floor area of a structure as measured from the outside of the exterior walls and shall include or exclude the following: (1) All floor area under a solid roof whether or not the area is enclosed with walls (i.e., porches, balconies, breezeways, etc.) shall be included. (2) Areas under awnings with leg supports or those that extend more than three feet out from a structure shall count as one-half shall be included. (3) Floor area under ceilings which are higher than 15 feet shall count as double. (4) Areas under screen enclosures shall count as 1/2. (5) Areas under eaves or roof extensions of 21/2 feet or less shall not be included. (6) Areas in basements shall not be included. (7) Areas in attics that cannot be used for living area shall not be included if the ceiling height does not exceed 61/2 feet and there are no windows. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 28, 3-10-00) Sec. 70-71. Floor area ratios. (a) Sliding scale floor area ratio (FAR). (1) Floor area ratio (FAR) is the relationship between a building's total floor area and the area of the lot it sits on. If a building is 2,500 square feet and it sits on a lot of 10,000 square feet, its FAR is .25. This direct relationship results in the ability to build bigger homes on bigger lots. While a ratio of total floor area to lot size such as .25 may be appropriate for smaller lots, on larger lots the result can be unnecessarily and inappropriately large homes. This is particularly a problem when two lots are combined and are now twice as large as the lots next door. This section provides a methodology for maintaining a reasonable opportunity to build larger homes on larger lots, while recognizing that the relationship to the scale of an existing neighborhood is an important community character concern. (2) In order to establish a sliding scale which reduces floor area ratio yields on larger lots; the following FAR step down shall be used: Effective Lot Area I Gulf Stream Core Ocean West Beachfront North/South I Place au Soleil Maximum FAR First 20,000 .33 .33 square feet .33 .33 .33 Portions over 20,000 square .20 .20 .20 .20 .20 feet+ Supp. No. 1 Example 1: 45,000 square foot lot in Beachfront District. First 20,000 square feet x .33 = Next 25,000 square feet x .20 = Total 45,000 square feet CD70:28 6,600 square feet 5,000 square feet 11,600 square feet maximum floor area GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-71 Example 2: 30,000 square foot lot in Ocean West District. First 20,000 square feet x .33 = 6,600 square feet Next 10,000 square feet x .20 = 2,000 square feet Total 30,000 square feet 8,600 square feet maximum floor area . Example 3: 18,000 square foot lot in Place au Soleil. First 18,000 square feet x .33 (b) Neighborhood context floor area ratio. 5,940 square feet maximum floor area (1) In order to address the potential problem created when two lots are aggregated in a district of predominantly small lots, the neighborhood context FAR shall be followed. This special FAR calculation will apply only to new lots in excess of 20,000 square feet created in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil Districts after the adoption of this chapter. (2) When dealing with double lots, it is reasonable to allow a larger home than would be allowed on a single lot, but probably not twice as large if abutting lots remain small. An equitable method for determining the maximum FAR for a double lot (or when a vacant lot is split between two existing homes) shall be to use existing abutting lots to create a "neighborhood context FAR" or average FAR yield and then to apply a reasonable factor for floor area expansion. (3) For lots over 20,000 square feet in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil districts created after the adoption of this manual, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the average maximum FAR yield of the two abutting lots with a 50 percent increase allowance. If the neighborhood context FAR is less than the standard FAR, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the maximum allowed. This will restrict new houses or homes with additions to a size that, while large, would not overshadow neighborhood residences. For example: Double lot at 33,000 square feet. Maximum FAR for newly created lots over 20,000 square feet is the smaller of the two FAR calculations (sliding scale FAR and neighborhood context FAR). a. Sliding scale FAR: 20,000 square feet x .33 13,000 square feet x .20 Total 33,000 square feet b. Neighborhood context FAR: Neighbor 1 lot: 13,000 square feet x .33 Neighbor 2 lot: 16,000 square feet x .33 Total 6,600 square feet 2,600 square feet 9,200 square feet maximum floor area 4,290 square feet maximum 5,280 square feet maximum 9,570 square feet max _ 2 = 4,785.0 square feet aver- age x 1.5 7,177.5 square feet maxi- mum floor area Maximum FAR is smaller of the two: 7,177.5 square feet Supp. No. 1 CD70:29 Gulf Stream Core Ocean West Beachfront NorthlSouth Place au Soleil Neighbor- Lots greater than 20,000 Lots greater than 20,000 hood Context square feet created after N/A N/A N/A square feet created after FAR Applica- adoption of this manual adoption of this manual bility (2) When dealing with double lots, it is reasonable to allow a larger home than would be allowed on a single lot, but probably not twice as large if abutting lots remain small. An equitable method for determining the maximum FAR for a double lot (or when a vacant lot is split between two existing homes) shall be to use existing abutting lots to create a "neighborhood context FAR" or average FAR yield and then to apply a reasonable factor for floor area expansion. (3) For lots over 20,000 square feet in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil districts created after the adoption of this manual, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the average maximum FAR yield of the two abutting lots with a 50 percent increase allowance. If the neighborhood context FAR is less than the standard FAR, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the maximum allowed. This will restrict new houses or homes with additions to a size that, while large, would not overshadow neighborhood residences. For example: Double lot at 33,000 square feet. Maximum FAR for newly created lots over 20,000 square feet is the smaller of the two FAR calculations (sliding scale FAR and neighborhood context FAR). a. Sliding scale FAR: 20,000 square feet x .33 13,000 square feet x .20 Total 33,000 square feet b. Neighborhood context FAR: Neighbor 1 lot: 13,000 square feet x .33 Neighbor 2 lot: 16,000 square feet x .33 Total 6,600 square feet 2,600 square feet 9,200 square feet maximum floor area 4,290 square feet maximum 5,280 square feet maximum 9,570 square feet max _ 2 = 4,785.0 square feet aver- age x 1.5 7,177.5 square feet maxi- mum floor area Maximum FAR is smaller of the two: 7,177.5 square feet Supp. No. 1 CD70:29 § 70-71 GULF STREAM CODE (4) For lots subject to neighborhood context FAR, the methodology for identifying abutting lots is as follows: Note: Lots not conforming to outlined examples are subject to approval by the town Planning and Building Administrator in keeping with these guidelines. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 26, 3-10-00) :14 ' `'4 3c .; End Lot 13'1 J� 5 t 12 t t 6 15 •'s.... o t.16 10 g Corner Lot 25 24 .23 22t:21420.18 2627:.'28 :,Yt 31 19 'l J.Y i ✓ L= t—1 ` Interior Lot Combined Lot Types Sec. 70-72. Special exception floor area ratio (FAR). (a) Lots of less than 7,576 square feet. Up to 2,500 square feet of floor area may be permitted on any legally established lot of record of 7,576 square feet or less, subject to the following: (1) Maximum floor area. The maximum floor area is 2,500 square feet. (2) Specific standards for review. Site and structural design elements including, but not limited to: a. Height of the structure relative to neighboring structures; b. The location, number and size of windows, doors, porches, balconies and outdoor lights; Supp. No. 1 CD70:30 Abutting Neighbor #1 Abutting Neighbor #2 For interior lots, abutting lots are: the side lot the other side lot example: if lots 29 and 30 are combined, abut- ting lots are: lot 28 lot 31 For corner lots, abutting lots are: the side lot which faces the same the largest lot directly across the street same street example: if lots 7 and 8 are combined, abutting lots are: lot 6 lot 17 For end lots, abutting lots are: the side lot the next nearest lot on street example: if lots 1 and 2 are combined, abutting lots are: lot 3 lot 4 Note: Lots not conforming to outlined examples are subject to approval by the town Planning and Building Administrator in keeping with these guidelines. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 26, 3-10-00) :14 ' `'4 3c .; End Lot 13'1 J� 5 t 12 t t 6 15 •'s.... o t.16 10 g Corner Lot 25 24 .23 22t:21420.18 2627:.'28 :,Yt 31 19 'l J.Y i ✓ L= t—1 ` Interior Lot Combined Lot Types Sec. 70-72. Special exception floor area ratio (FAR). (a) Lots of less than 7,576 square feet. Up to 2,500 square feet of floor area may be permitted on any legally established lot of record of 7,576 square feet or less, subject to the following: (1) Maximum floor area. The maximum floor area is 2,500 square feet. (2) Specific standards for review. Site and structural design elements including, but not limited to: a. Height of the structure relative to neighboring structures; b. The location, number and size of windows, doors, porches, balconies and outdoor lights; Supp. No. 1 CD70:30 SLI/ GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-68 ARTICLE IV. SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Sec. 70-66. Generally. Typically, zoning regulations affect the size and location of development on individual lots and establish the basic building envelope. The development standards in this article respond to the unique characteristics of the town's five single-family zoning districts and address community concerns regarding the mass of new construction and its impact on neighborhood character. Sec. 70-67. Effective lot area. (a) Because many of the site development regulations contained in this chapter are a function of lot size, the definition of the term "lot size" becomes very important. One of the key goals of this chapter is to maintain a proper proportion and scale between buildings and between buildings and the land. Accordingly, it is necessary to establish an "effective lot area" in order to meet this goal. (b) All references to "lot size" or "lot area" in this chapter shall have the same meaning as "effective lot area" which is defined as follows. "Effective lot area" shall mean the platted/recorded lot area minus the following: (1) Any submerged lands. (2) Any lands east of the Coastal Construction Control Line established in 1978. (3) Any lands separated from the main portion of the lot by public or private roads. (4) Any lands used for private road surfaces including an additional ten feet of area beyond the edge of the pavement of a private road. (5) Any unrecorded public right-of-way which shall be determined by using an average of the recorded right-of-way adjacent to other properties along the same roadway. Sec. 70-68. Lot size and dimensional requirements. The following requirements shall apply only to lots created after the adoption of this chapter. Nonconforming lots which were legally subdivided and recorded in accordance with the regulations in effect at the time of the subdivision, but prior to the adoption of this chapter, shall have all building rights provided under this chapter and chapter 66 provided all other applicable requirements are met. Minimum Lot Size and Gulf Stream North/ Place au Dimensional Requirements Core Ocean West Beachfront South Soleil Effective Lot Area 16,500 30,000 30,000 20,000 15,000 Width Front 100 100 150 100 100 (Rectangular Shaped Lot) Front/Point 40 40 N/A 40 40 (Pie Shaped Lot) Other Lots shall have a All lots shall have a minimum frontage minimum of 150 feet of 100 feet on both of frontage on both AIA and Gulf AIA and the ocean. Stream Road where Land -locked lots are adjacent to both. prohibited. (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 26, 27, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 008-5, § 1, 9-5-08) Supp. No. 1 CD70:27 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-4 (c) In addition to the design standards contained in this chapter, for convenience, the specific mandatory land development regulations are included to facilitate an overall understanding of the review criteria to which new construction is subject. North Ocean Boulevard entering Gulf Stream Sec. 70-4. How to use this manual. (a) Organization. This chapter is organized into nine articles. The user is encouraged to read the chapter in its entirety. This chapter is a full part of the town's land development regulations and has the same force and effect of all other provisions contained therein. (1) Articles III and IV. Article III, Use Regulations, and article IV, Site Development Regulations, contain land development regulations which are mandatory and apply to all of the single-family zoning districts. These are the typical zoning -type regulations found in most other codes. (2) Articles V through VIII. Articles V through VIII provide design standards and establish a basis for review and approval of all new single-family construction or remodeling. Article V, Areawide Standards, applies to all single-family homes in the town. Provisions with respect to Gulf Stream -Bermuda and Mediterranean Revival architecture (see article VII) are not applicable if an alternate architectural design is selected. The reader is encouraged, however, to become familiar with their provisions in that they are the preferred styles in most of the town. (3) Article VL Article VI, District Standards, provides more specific design direction for the five single-family zoning districts established in this chapter. The user should identify the applicable district and should study it carefully to ensure that the unique characteristics of and appropriate design direction for that district are incorporated into any design proposal. (4) Article VIL Article VII, Predominant Architectural Styles, contains design standards for Gulf Stream -Bermuda and Mediterranean Revival styles of architecture. As discussed, these styles are not mandatory but are indicative of the predominant styles within the community. (5) Article VIII. Article VIII, Supplemental Development Regulations, addresses elements such as antennas, that sometimes are tacked on to homes that otherwise display good design character- istics. Standards for these elements are provided in this article. CD70:7 § 70-4 GULF STREAM CODE (6) Article IX. Finally, an appendix is included in article IX. This includes a glossary of architectural terms, an explanation of the development review process, details of the historic survey and single-family development survey, a discussion of color, and a bibliography. These are included as reference materials but are not formally a part of this chapter or chapter 66. (b) Illustrations. The illustrations contained within this chapter address and respond to the oppor- tunities for enhancing and preserving the visual environment of the town. (c) Design standards. The design standards in this chapter provide the town with a methodology and common framework for reviewing submissions for project approvals. The design standards contained herein are either mandatory or discretionary. The terms "required" and "prohibited" are mandatory. The terms "preferred" and "discouraged" are discretionary. These terms are defined below: (1) Required. a. Required items are design elements that are necessary in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. b. Compliance is mandatory for project approval. (2) Preferred. a. Preferred items are design elements that, whenever possible, should be used in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. These items are those typically found in the town and which, in combination with other preferred items, define the existing and desired character of the town and the zoning districts. Preferred items are thought to comply with the 'following goals with respect to desired zoning district character and quality: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. b. Incorporating preferred items into a design increases the probability of, but does not assure, project approval. (3) Discouraged. a. Discouraged items are design elements that should not be used in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. These items are not typically found in the town and detract from the existing and desired character of the town and the zoning districts. Discouraged items are thought to not comply with the following goals with respect to desired zoning district character and quality: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. b. Incorporating discouraged items into a design decreases the probability of project approval and may result in project denial. In order for a discouraged item to be approved, applicants must show, and the town must find, that the proposed item is not inconsistent with the above goals. The use of more than three discouraged items on any property is prohibited. CD70:8 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL (4) Prohibited. § 70-25 a. Prohibited items are design elements that do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located and are not permitted under current codes or regulations. b. The use of more than three discouraged items on a property is prohibited. C. Use of prohibited elements mandates project denial. (d) Additional standards and criteria. Please note that the chapter constitutes only one small subsection of the Land Development Regulations found in this Code. While compliance with the standards found in articles I through VIII of this chapter is essential to final project approval, compliance with several additional standards and criteria also may be necessary before a building permit can be issued. Accordingly, users of this chapter are strongly advised to familiarize themselves with all federal, state and/or town regulations that might apply to a particular type of project. To assist in determining which town regulations may apply, users are encouraged to review the tables and flow chart contained in section 70-297 of this chapter. Users also are encouraged to direct questions to, and share information with, town planning staff as early as possible in the plan development stage. Secs. 70-5-70-25. Reserved. CD70:9 s CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley February 28, 2012 CONTINUATION OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING THAT WAS HELD ON FEBRUARY 23, 2012, IS BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON FRIDAY, MARCH 2, 2012 AT 8:00 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 2-23-12. IV. Items by Staff Continued from 2-23-12. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Subdivision Review a. Section 62-10, Proposed Criteria b. Section 66-1, Definitions C. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio d. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements e. Section 70-4, How to Use This Manual 2. Basement Definition Section 66-1 a. Definitions used in other municipalities V. Items by Board Members. VI. Public. VII. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 23, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:30 A,. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Ganger called the meeting to order at Robert W. Ganger Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley Malcolm Murphy William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Mrs. Cuppy Craft Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting as Board Member Alternate Member Board Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Town Consultant 10 Little Club Rd. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1-26-12. Chairman Ganger thanked Mr. Randolph for preparing the Bert Harris Act information and he thanked the Board for reading the material provided in their packet. He said the Minutes are a bridge to what will be discussed today and he asked if there were any questions or comments concerning the January Meeting Minutes. Mr. Smith moved and Vice - Chairman Morgan seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of January 26, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. March 22, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Ganger asked if there were conflicts with the meeting schedule. Mrs. Jones: May be available May 24th; will not be available June 28th and July 26th. Vice -Chairman Morgan: Will not be available March 22nd Mr. Lyons: May be available June 28 h; will not be available July 26tH Chairman Ganger said it will be necessary to establish a quorum for these discussions and he asked the Board to inform Clerk Taylor of these and any additional conflicts in the meeting schedule well in advance. He said he hopes to have zoning matters resolved by summer and said it Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 2 would be best to submit zoning changes and any tweaking to the Comp Plan at the same time. VI. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes Mr. Thrasher stated that Marty Minor was present to guide the Board through discussions of the zoning items. 1. Subdivision Review a. Section 66-1, Definitions Mr. Thrasher said staff is concerned with the definition of "basements" and thought about what could be changed to prevent a similar situation that exists on County Road. He referred to page 66-7 of the Code and read the current definition of "basement", as follows: "Basement shall mean that portion of a building, the ceiling which is entirely below grade or less than three feet above grade. A basement is not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the building." Chairman Ganger referred to the situation cited on County Rd. and said there is an entrance into the lowest story, which is the garage, and he asked if the floor of the basement is at the same level as the garage floor, and Mr. Thrasher said confirmed that. Chairman Ganger asked if the Code should also prohibit entrances that are visible from the street. Mr. Thrasher read Staff's recommended change to the definition of "basement," as follows: "Basement shall mean that portion of a building which is below the finished floor elevation of the building. A basement is not considered a story with regards to height measurement of a building. The square footage of a basement shall be included in the FAR calculations at 50o and not be usable for living purposes which includes working, sleeping, eating, cooking or recreation, or a combination thereof. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the structure." Mr. Thrasher said the entire area below finished grade in the structure on County Road is livable, and he said the reason for changing the Code to what it is today was that the only concern was the massing of the structure and that anything below the finished floor elevation did not add to the mass of the structure, which is true. He said the definition, in part, has caused some of these issues and Staff feels that if you include a margin of that area as FAR, people may think twice about where they put their allowable FAR. Mr. Smith referred to a new home under construction on N. Ocean Blvd which has a basement that can hold 15 cars and he asked Mr. Thrasher if that project would have been impacted by this proposed language. Mr. Thrasher said it would have been impacted and so would every structure that has a basement that was created after the original date of the Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked how many other properties could be affected. Clerk Taylor said anything on a hill, or dune and Mr. Thrasher added that the DEP offers little support to the Town's Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 3 concerns. He said there are other areas that could potentially create this situation because of elevation, such as a home on Gulf Stream Road that has a basement. Mr. Thrasher said in a previous discussion concerning this matter a comment was made that it is not unusual to control habitable space in a basement and that some percentage is typical. Mr. Minor confirmed that. Mr. Lyons said it is different in the Northeast because an entire basement, all four sides, is below grade. Mr. Thrasher said finished floor grade is determined in the Code by other factors such as the crown of the road and the lowest grade between residences and, after that is determined and depending on the contour of the land, you have the potential of a basement area. Chairman Ganger asked if there is anything in the Code to prevent people from going below grade in flood zones. Mr. Thrasher said livable space is presently controlled by 7.0 finished grade and when you try to renovate more than 500, or a certain percentage, and you have a grade below that flood plain elevation, you must get appraisals on value. He said the key factor may be the percentage of the home that is livable space and basement. Chairman Ganger said if you look at the structure on County Road from the golf course it appears to be three stories, and he said the ARPB recognized this when the project was presented to them, they made their recommendations to the Commission and the Commission did not uphold their recommendations. Mr. Thrasher said they modified the Code. Chairman Ganger said he believes the responsibility of the ARPB is to make appropriate recommendations and stand by their decisions. Mr. Lyons asked if the structure is built in compliance with existing Code and Mr. Thrasher said it was permitable under the current Code. Mr. Lyons asked if the proposed language would have eliminated this structure and Mr. Thrasher said the proposed language would have altered the design of this structure. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the proposed language seems straight forward, it only modifies the use of basements and does not prohibit them, and he asked if there is anything objectionable to the way the proposed language is presented. Mr. Smith said he agrees with the 50% in the proposed language, but he said it may be too restrictive with respect to use of a basement. He said, for example, his home could have a 10 -foot basement where he could have a workshop or a small office rather than just using it for storage. Mr. Thrasher said the language in the previous code was much more restrictive than what he is proposing for discussion. Mr. Randolph asked why language in the Code prohibiting occupancy of basements was taken out. Clerk Taylor said the previous Code provided for the right of inspection from time to time to ensure that the area was not converted to bedrooms and so forth. She said, when going though his approvals, the owner of this particular home expressed violent objection claiming that would intrude on his privacy, and, therefore, the Commission radically changed the language in the Code. Chairman Ganger said he is seriously concerned that people will use basements as bedrooms and putting more people in homes, and maybe renting the space for income. He said the definition of a boarding house includes having a place to eat and sleep and we restrict commercial activity in Gulf Stream. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he agrees with Mr. Smith in that an Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 4 office, workshop or recreational activity is acceptable; however, he said we want to avoid someone using the space for sleeping and cooking. Clerk Taylor said if you count the entire basement area in the FAR, the structure on County Road would be one story less. She said if you count a garage at the side of a house at 100% in the FAR, what would be the difference if you count a garage that is under the house at 100% in the FAR, and she said use of the space would not matter if you did that. Mr. Thrasher suggested that, in the language we use, we articulate in a way that would eliminate the requirement of post -construction inspections or deed restrictions. Mr. Stanley suggested that the percentage counted for FAR be determined by District and Mr. Thrasher said he thought it should be restricted in some way. Mr. Minor said Clerk Taylor's suggestion is very good in that it addresses Chairman Ganger's concern because it makes the homeowner decide where to put their livable space. With regard to defining height of a basement, anything less than 5' or 3' would be considered traditional crawl space and could be allowed without being counted. He said 7' or 8' may be considered storage space, but he said it may be acceptable to some people as living space. Chairman Ganger asked if there is an established height that would discourage habitation. Mr. Minor said maybe 6' within the basement, but he said with respect to height from finished floor grade he would like to keep the height at 3' and that would not be included in the FAR. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Thrasher to refine the proposed language to be consistent with comments and suggestions made by Mr. Minor and Clerk Taylor and Mr. Thrasher said he would put something together. Cuppy Craft asked for permission to comment. Chairman Ganger allowed public comment at this time. Mrs. Craft said she lives at 10 Little Club Road, which is just behind the subject home on County Road. She said neighbors are not concerned with the use of the basement, they are concerned and distressed with the access to the basement, saying that it is offensive, it is below the Coral rock and it is unsafe. Mr. Thrasher said the current language in the Code allows that to happen. He said the owner wanted to maximize the usability of that space and thought they could do that by lowering it, which created the drop-off. Mrs. Craft asked the Board to address the drop-off. Chairman Ganger thanked Mrs. Craft for her comments and said the Board is working on the matter by working on the definition and height of basements. Mr. Lyons said that basements are very common in the Northeast and said he gathers from history that the Town prefers not to have usable basements. Mr. Randolph said basements in the Northeast are generally enclosed on all four sides and not visible from the street and in Gulf Stream we are concerned with appearance. Mr. Thrasher said in every District, with the exception of Ocean West and Beachfront, the Code controls size of a second story, which can be no more than 75% of the first story. He said we carte blanche basements allowing them to be 100% of the first story and it makes no sense to not have some control over the size of a basement. To have that become part of the FAR calculations places the responsibility on homeowners to maximize their Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 5 potential for the sale of their home. Mr. Smith said Clerk Taylor's suggestion of the 100% covers it and he suggested increasing the FAR calculation to 100%, eliminate the reference to use and define a basement as something that is taller in height of more than 5' or 6' from floor to ceiling, or whatever height suggested by the consultant. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Smith if he was suggesting no restriction on use. Mr. Smith confirmed that, saying 100% eliminates the necessity to describe use because owners would have to conform to Code with regard to use and it also eliminates the policing of it. He also suggested leaving in Mr. Minor's recommendation of no more than 3' above grade because it is in the current language. Mr. Thrasher said finished grade must be determined by the crown of the road, average height between homes and existing grade of buildable area of lot. Mr. Randolph said they would look into whether it is necessary to include that. Chairman Ganger said it seems to be the consensus of the Board that Mr. Thrasher fine tune his proposed language regarding the definition of basements, using Clerk Taylor's suggestion of the 100% and Mr. Minor's suggestion of some height limit, and present that language to the Board at their next meeting. Mr. Randolph said a motion will not be necessary if it is a consensus. There was a consensus. b. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio Mr. Thrasher said this item is brought forward for discussion as it relates to controlling subdivisions and size, and he said he and staff feel that the FAR seems to work for us as it is. However, he said if you include FAR in a combination of things to get a better feeling of potential subdivisions, it is worthy of discussion. Mr. Randolph said the FAR has nothing to do with subdivisions and should not be considered in the regulation of subdivisions. He said it should be done in the Subdivision Code and not in the Design Element. Mr. Thrasher said FAR was brought into the discussion at a previous meeting about the size and massing of new homes on Polo. Mr. Lyons remembered that Vice -Chairman Orthwein commented at a previous meeting that while lowering the FAR will address homes being massive in size, should we consider amending the Code that addresses design issues to stop the construction of blocky -looking buildings. Mr. Thrasher said Mr. Morgan also commented on massive homes in that area and thought the FAR may have been incorrectly calculated or the data used in making a decision was wrong. He said, subsequently, the Town started asking Mr. Minor to run through calculations and floor plans to determine whether or not we should do more than rely on an Architect's sealed drawings. Mr. Thrasher said they found some minor changes that were enough to require one person to modify their plans. Mr. Minor said he can request Auto Cad drawings from an architect and run them through his program to calculate FAR, and he said that kind of enforcement will help define some of the issues. He said when looking at FARs, or the equivalent lot coverage of height, up and down the coast, Gulf Stream is not the smallest, but it is at the lower end in relationship to everyone else. However, he said when deciding whether or not to include other design features, such as setback of second stories or length of overhangs, FAR is something to look at to avoid the issue of blockyness and massing. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 6 Chairman Ganger said that architects have software and Cad Cam to assist in calculations and he asked about technology that can assist the Board in their evaluation process. Mr. Randolph said there was an architect the Town used in the past who could show numbers transposed into elevations and asked if he might be willing to do that again. Clerk Taylor said he probably would. Vice -Chairman Morgan suggested drafting additional design language that would assist in restricting the second story so that all buildings will comply with the Code and Design Manual. Mr. Thrasher said that second story coverage at 75% has been an issue in the past and on more than one occasion Staff has asked for assistance from Mr. Minor. He said this has happened several times where, from a visual standpoint, two-dimensional elevations seem to present something that is out balance. Mr. Thrasher said a perfect example of this is on Palm Way where calculations were sent to Mr. Minor for recalculation and it came back acceptable, but it did not look right. He said if it meets the mathematical requirements in the Code there is nothing we can do, and he said maybe the language is too lenient. Mr. Smith said the homes to be constructed on the Spence Property will be two-story and the Board will experience these issues when those plans are presented to them. He said Vice -Mayor Orthwein commented on the lineal straight up from the ground appearance and she is probably looking for some stepback in the front and on the sides. Mr. Thrasher said there are two factors in the Code that address this, one being square footage coverage percentage where, in the Core for example, the second story can be no more than 750 of first story. He said the second has to do with the stepback that the second story must be from first story. Chairman Ganger asked if any communities require three-dimensional presentations. Mr. Randolph confirmed that and said some require a model or a CAD presentation. He said the meeting room would need a screen, a projector and more to accommodate that. Mr. Thrasher said technology is great, but he said this room cannot accommodate the equipment. Chairman Ganger said Vice -Mayor Orthwein has raised a real issue and he feels the Town should request proposals on what is required to use existing technology that would assist in the evaluation process. Mr. Randolph said the first step is to amend the Code to include certain provisions and then have someone like Mark Marsh come in to show us what those provisions will look like before imposing them. He said Gulf Stream's Code is unique to all of Palm Beach County in having the Design Manual. He said if proposals meet the Design Manual the Board has very little discretion, but he said other jurisdictions such as Palm Beach and Jupiter Island have architectural review boards and impact review committees where they allow themselves more discretion. They can look at a house and see if it is in keeping with the character of a neighborhood. Chairman Ganger said it would be helpful in the evaluation process to view Level II and Level III presentations in a more interactive way than on a flip board and we should use all of the tools that are available to us. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 7 Mr. Randolph asked Chairman Ganger if he is looking for an explanation of what we currently have in place in the Code dealing with mass and design issues, along with a suggestion as to what can be done to address these issues in the Code as it exists. Chairman Ganger confirmed that. He said having studies done and asking architects to change the way they do things can be very expensive and, before time and money is spent, he would like to inform the Commission of how the Board is addressing these issues. Chairman Ganger said he would like input from the Commission in hopes that they would encourage the Board to move forward. Clerk Taylor said that when the Code was established these steps were set up. She said the Commission has approved the list of zoning items for the ARPB to work on and, therefore, the Board has Commission approval to study these issues and then make their recommendations to the Commission. Clerk Taylor said the Town Manager knows how much money is available and he will let you know if spending is getting out of line. Mr. Randolph asked about the recommendation of new technology. Mr. Thrasher said he has no idea what that would cost and Clerk Taylor reminded the Board that the Commission did not give that to the Board as an assignment. Chairman Ganger said it would not be costly to find out what other communities are using. Mr. Thrasher said he could inquire and get some estimates and ideas, but he said the Board should decide whether or not they would like to engage Marty Minor and his recommendation is to do SO. Mr. Smith noted that Section 70-70. Floor area calculation. Item (6) reads "Areas in basements shall not be included." He said we need to amend Section 70-70 to eliminate Item (6) if the Board makes the recommendations changes in Section 66-1. Mr. Lyons wanted clarification of what we are asking from Mr. Minor with regard to blocky -looking structures. Chairman Ganger said we are asking for language that is missing from the current Code that will assist us in the evaluation process by helping us understand presentations to recognize whether or not they meet the FARs. In addition, he said we would like to know if there is technology available to help with calculations so that we have looked at something better than a blueprint or architectural drawings before making recommendations to the Commission. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the current Design Manual has allowed excessive mass of a structure and we are asking Mr. Minor to evaluate that and come up with what is causing this and what we can do to reduce mass. Mr. Minor said his understanding of what the Board is asking is where the Code can be modified to avoid some of the bulkier issues. With regard to software, he said it is common for architects to have three-dimensional modeling software and there is a program called "Sketch -Up" which takes two-dimensional and turns it into three- dimensional. The Board recessed from 9:40 A.M. and reconvened at 9:45 A.M. C. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements Mr. Thrasher said comments have been made indicating that lot size and dimensional requirements may need to be changed and he noted that this is found at Section 70-68 in the Code. He said, as an example, we have an effective lot area minimum of 16,500 in the Core, 30,000 in Ocean Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 8 West and Beachfront, 20,000 in North-South and 15,000 in Place Au Soleil, with frontage and things of that nature. Mr. Thrasher said Mr. Minor provided an inventory of those properties that have potential to be subdivided under most of the requirements of the Code. He said it is difficult to do, but he asked Mr. Minor if he looked at how someone might configure a driveway or a roadway. Mr. Minor said the difference in this report compared to the January report is that they looked at effective lot areas, taking out water, and they used a scale map provided by the GIS Consultant so they could estimate how much was water and how much was outside the Coastal Construction Line. He said they looked at minimum lot widths and lot sizes in each zoning district and they did look at possibilities of where a road could go, but did not spend much time on that. Mr. Randolph said Mr. Thrasher is presenting this as a consideration of Section 70-68 regarding lot size and dimensional requirements and he asked Mr. Minor if he is concerned with lot size and dimensional requirements within the Town. He said Mr. Minor prepared a document that seems to deal with lots that have potential to be subdivided as opposed to a document that was prepared as a study to determine whether or not current lot size and dimensional requirements are correct. Mr. Randolph said if you are going to amend 70-68 you will need a thorough study of the lots in the Town and the different districts of the Town to determine how they have been developed. He said if lots have been developed as 125 -foot lots and Code requires that they shall be 100 -foot lots, it would be evidence to assist in revising the Code. If lot sizes throughout the Town are fairly consistent with what exists in the current Code, the study should not relate to 70-68, but rather to the subdivision regulations, which is what he thought was the Board's direction to Staff and the purpose of the preparation of the document. Chairman Ganger said they wanted facts and the map is clear. He said lots developed in the Ocean West District tend to be large and the characteristic of the District, as described in the Design Manual, is larger homes on large wooded lots with water. Chairman Ganger said it appears that the characteristic of that District is large-scale and if you change the characteristics of the Ocean West District by subdividing into smaller lots, you will be making it more like the Core and other districts of the town. Mr. Minor said it would be somewhat smaller than what currently exists in the Ocean West District, but it is still almost double of what exists in the Core. Chairman Ganger said when the Spence property was redeveloped, the concern was that it would change the characteristic of the district. He asked if there is data that suggests subdividing large lots into small lots will go to Bert Harris, and is one large lot worth more than two smaller lots. He asked if it would be better to impose esthetic restrictions rather than financial restrictions. Mr. Minor said he included potential criteria in his January report to assist the Town in determining whether a subdivision is appropriate. He said it provides general guidance that is missing in current subdivision regulations, it provides criteria to be complied with and addresses conformity to surrounding parcels that helps maintain the existing Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 9 character of a neighborhood. Mr. Minor said these criteria are common in more advanced zoning codes and does not create prohibition or sever restriction, but rather provides guidance to the Town in making decisions. He said, for example, we encourage all multi -family areas to become single family and certain provisions in the Code may suggest it would require a subdivision. Mr. Minor said his recommendation is to provide more criteria to address these situations. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Minor if he is suggesting there are ways to modify the Code to protect the desire for subdivisions to fit within the character of a neighborhood. Mr. Minor confirmed that and Mr. Thrasher said it sounds like the direction we should take. Mr. Lyons asked if we could be getting into Bert Harris by crossing the line if we went in Mr. Minor's direction. Mr. Randolph said potentially, but he said you will not know until you deny someone. Chairman Ganger said it is important to let it be known that the Town is trying to preserve the character of one of their neighborhoods that is different from the others. Mr. Randolph said you are not asking for a study to be made of this district to determine whether or not the district regulations should be modified, but rather you are focusing on the subdivision regulations and whether or not we can incorporate the language Mr. Minor is proposing. Mr. Randolph said the Board should determine whether or not this is dramatic enough to do anything and not just focus on the Ocean West District. Chairman Ganger agreed. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the criteria Mr. Minor is proposing flushes out existing general criteria in the Code and provides clarity as a guideline for the Board and Commission as they review these applications. Chairman Ganger said the Board will soon be looking at houses for the six lots on the Spence Property and we will be looking at how to maintain the character of the district. Mr. Randolph said those guidelines currently exist in the Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if the criteria set forth by Mr. Minor place the same discretionary onus on the Board as before, and he asked if the ARPB will have the discretion to deny. Mr. Randolph said yes, but he said Bert Harris may come into play and the ARPB will have the necessary tools to deal any Bert Harris liability. He said, for example, if someone were to say you have placed restrictions on their property where, under the old Code they could have subdivided into two lots and now, using your discretion, you have indicated that only one lot is permissible, they can make a claim and you will have the tools to deal any Bert Harris liability. Mr. Randolph said the potential liability would be if they came in for a building permit and they were denied. He said at that point they would have to come in with an appraisal showing that you have denied their reasonable investment back expectations and you would then have to make the determination as to whether that is true or whether one larger lot is more valuable than two smaller lots. Mr. Randolph said he would not avoid putting tools in force that are beneficial to the Town because you can always negotiate a Bert Harris matter at a later time. Mr. Lyons asked how to handle a one-year claim. Mr. Randolph said, for example, if someone is denied a subdivision of six lots and only gets four lots, their one year could run from the time of denial of their Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 10 building permit or from denial of their subdivision, but to avoid that you give notice to them that you are imposing this regulation and they then have one year to make a claim. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if notice would have to be sent to all affected property owners if a change is made to a Code regulation in the Design Manual. Mr. Randolph said you would not notice all property owners, but he said there would be notice by advertising in a newspaper. Chairman Ganger said the process has been that the ARPB makes recommendations to the Commission, the Commission either objects, modifies or approves, there are new ordinances with two hearings for first and second readings, which will be advertised for public notice. Mr. Randolph said to avoid Bert Harris going on forever, you would only give notice to property owners who are directly affected in Bert Harris and then there is the potential for appraisers coming in. Chairman Ganger asked if it would be enough for someone to make a claim if we said no further subdivisions are permitted in Town, versus providing a new set of guidelines to help the Board give definition to maintaining character and including criteria such as the 500 -foot rule. Mr. Randolph said it is possible and you have to wait and see. Vice -Chair Morgan said there are a number of recommended subdivision criteria in Mr. Minor's January report that could be included. Mr. Minor said he could bring that criteria back in a separate document for further discussion and he can also provide a graphic showing what 500 feet looks like on an aerial. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he likes criteria, but he said he also likes a general statement that sets forth guidance which he believes we already have. He referred to his letter of January 25th wherein he recommends modification of Section 70-27(c) at line 5 to read: . . . proposed projects must incorporate design features that are compatible with, and complimentary to, the preferred elements and overall character of the district, including parcel size, parcel shape, architecture and landscaping. Mr. Thrasher said, it would be helpful if Mr. Minor could take the proposed criteria and overlay it on the Spence Property as a case study, if it is not very difficult or expensive. Mr. Minor agreed to do that. Chairman Ganger said the surrounding neighbors of the Spence Property effectively argued for a public road to serve the new homes rather than using existing roads, which changed the character of the design and took away a substantial amount of acreage that could have been used for other purposes. He said roads take space and have other issues with respect to maintenance, fire and so on and he would like to provide guidelines for contractors to consider before they address a subdivision. Chairman Ganger asked if the proposed criteria to avoid traffic congestion and eliminate conflict between pedestrian and vehicular movement should be included and he asked if there are other criteria that would require addressing access before addressing subdivision. Mr. Minor said the spacing of access points on roadways is very important. He said it is appropriate to have separate driveway access from a local street rather than from an area such as Ocean Boulevard where you should limit access points by congregating them. Mr. Minor said he will look at the general wording for access, but he said he is not sure he can draft something to cover both situations. He said determining access is done on a case-by- Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 11 case basis. Clerk Taylor said there is something in our current Code in the subdivision regulations that says the plat must include access and, therefore, contractors know it is something they have to address. Mr. Smith excused himself from the meeting at 10:20 A.M. Chairman Ganger said we have regulations in place and we have not lost sight of our goal to maintain the character of our neighborhoods, but he said we want to make things clearer in the subdivision regulations. Mr. Thrasher said the current language relating to roads is sufficient. Chairman Ganger said that leafy and meandering driveways and large homes should be addressed and clarified in our Code. Mr. Thrasher suggested consideration of having more than one meeting a month to address these items and maybe set some time limits. He asked the Board to schedule another meeting to take place in the next couple of weeks for the purpose of concentrating on the assignment given to Marty Minor. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Minor if he could have everything prepared by then. Mr. Minor said the FAR information may take a bit longer, but the basement language and the subdivision criteria will be prepared. Clerk Taylor said she would include all three items on the Agenda and Mr. Minor can present what is prepared. Mr. Randolph asked if Clerk Taylor could give the Board a time certain. Clerk Taylor asked for availability on Friday, March 2, 2012 at 8:00 A.M. There were no conflicts. Mr. Lyons moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to defer this meeting to reconvene at a time certain of Friday, March 2, 2012 at 8:00 A.M. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. d. Section 70-4, How to Use This Manual 2. Section 70-238, Roofs 3. Section 70-100, Roof & Eave Heights 4. Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures 5. Section 66-367, Swimming Pools 6. Section 66-369, Docks There was no discussion concerning Item l.d. and Items 2 through 6. These items will remain on the list for a future meeting agenda. VII. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Board Members. VIII. Public. There were no items by the Public IX. Recess. The meeting was recessed at 10:30 A.M. to be reconvened at 8:00 A.M. on Friday, March 2, 2012. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 12 CONTINUATION OF THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 23, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, WHICH WAS RECESSED AND RECONVENED ON FRIDAY, MARCH 2, 2012 AT 8:00 A.M. I. Call to Order: Chairman Ganger called the meeting to order at 8:05 A.M. II. Roll Call: Present and Robert W. Ganger Participating Scott Morgan (8:50 A.M. Thomas Smith Paul Lyons, Jr. Thomas M. Stanley Absent w/Notice Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Also Present and William H. Thrasher Participating Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Sitting as Bd. Member Board Member Alternate Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Town Consultant III. Minutes of The Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 2/23/12. Clerk Taylor asked to let the record show that both Malcolm Murphy and Amanda Jones are absent with notice, and she said Vice -Chairman Morgan has advised that he would be one hour late. Chairman Ganger stated that it would be necessary for him to leave at 9:50 A.M. IV. Items by Staff Continued from 2/23/12. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Subdivision Review a. Section 62-10, Proposed Criteria Clerk Taylor said the Minutes of the February 23, 2012 Regular Meeting were included in the meeting packets; however, she said no action is required until the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing scheduled for March 22, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. She said the minutes will be continued to include the discussions of this meeting. Chairman Ganger said the February 23rd meeting was recessed after presenting Mr. Minor with his assignment concerning FAR, proposed criteria as it relates to subdivisions and the definition of Basements. He asked Mr. Minor if he was prepared to discuss these items at this time and also if he had an opportunity to review the correspondence from Vice -Chairman Morgan dated March 1, 2012. Mr. Minor introduced himself for the record and stated that he reviewed the proposed language provided by Vice -Chairman Morgan and recommended incorporating it into the proposed criteria for subdivisions. Mr. Randolph said he does not understand the language Vice -Chairman Morgan Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 13 proposes to be added to Mr. Minor's Criteria B which deals with design features. He said Vice -Chairman Morgan uses the word "architecture" in the last sentence of Paragraph B in his letter and, he said when looking at subdivisions you deal with the layout of the land and you should not incorporate design features in subdivision regulations. Mr. Randolph said when the Board reviews the proposed design of a house in a subdivision they will have the opportunity to deal with design features under the Design Manual, where there is existing language that talks about maintaining the design of the neighborhood. Chairman Ganger referred to the applicant for the subdivision of the Spence Property and a continuous comment made by their attorney, which was that they were only applying for subdivision of the land at this time and not the architecture of future structures. He said the Board tried to impress upon them that architectural design features was another step in the process, which is something that should be made clear to an applicant proposing a subdivision. They must follow the Design Code and understand that they must maintain the character of the neighborhood with respect to design features, architecture and landscaping. Mr. Randolph said when the developers of the Spence Property made their presentation they made the mistake of showing houses on the property and, he said, he reminded them at that time that their application was strictly for the division of the land and nothing else. He said when plans for a house are presented to the Board they should rely on the strength of the Design Manual at that time. With regard to Vice -Chairman Morgan's proposed language in Paragraph B of his letter, Mr. Lyons suggested striking the word "design" in line 2 and the word "architecture" in line 4, so that Paragraph B reads, "Proposed subdivisions shall protect the character of the Town by incorporating features that are compatible with and complimentary to the preferred elements and overall character of the neighborhood district in which they are located, including but not limited to parcel size, parcel shape and landscaping." Mr. Stanley suggested striking the word "landscaping" and Mr. Thrasher did not agree. Mr. Thrasher said there have been several previous discussions concerning berms and buffers. Mr. Randolph suggested striking the word "landscaping" and replacing it with the word "topography" and Mr. Stanley suggested also adding the words "berms" and "buffers" amending Criteria B to read, "Proposed subdivisions shall protect the character of the Town by incorporating features that are compatible with and complimentary to the preferred elements and overall character of the neighborhood district in which they are located, including but not limited to parcel size, parcel shape, topography, berms and buffers." Mr. Smith inquired about Vice -Chairman Morgan's proposed language in Paragraph A of his letter to amend Mr. Minor's Criteria A. Mr. Minor said Vice -Chairman Morgan added the words . . . which term "surrounding" so that Criteria A would read, "Lots to be created by the proposed subdivision should be consistent with the surrounding neighborhood, which term "surrounding" shall be defined as residential lots within 500 feet of the subject parcel." Mr. Minor referred to the map he provided Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 14 which was done as a case study regarding how Criteria A would apply to a parcel and where the 500 -foot line would go. Chairman Ganger asked if the 500 feet is used by other communities and Mr. Minor confirmed that. Mr. Randolph said he does not see where Vice -Chairman's proposed language in his Paragraph A is that different from Mr. Minor's proposed language in his Criteria A and Mr. Smith said he is trying to emphasize what "surrounding" means, but it is covered in Criteria A. With regard to the overlay map, Mr. Smith said that, looking at the 6 lots superimposed on the map, it appears there was no way to deny the Spence subdivision. He said people are more concerned about six cookie - cutter lots all in a row and access to the lots from A1A. Mr. Thrasher said the neighbors did not want vehicular traffic on the private road and, therefore, there will be two entrances from A1A. One entrance will service one lot and the other entrance will service five lots. Mr. Randolph asked if the word "access" should be included in Criteria B. Mr. Stanley said it is covered in Criteria F which reads, "Proposed subdivisions shall avoid traffic congestion on streets, and eliminate conflicts between pedestrian and vehicular movements." He said when reviewing the overall Spence subdivision, Chairman Ganger asked the applicant several times where the roads would go and he also mentioned that they had to account for improvements, drainage and catch basins. With regard to roads, Mr. Thrasher said hammerheads totally eliminate the meandering roadways and he said there was previous discussion about prohibiting them. Mr. Randolph suggested that the proposed language in Criteria B be amended to read, "Proposed subdivisions shall protect the character of the Town by incorporating features that are compatible with and complimentary to the preferred elements and overall character of the neighborhood district in which they are located, including but not limited to parcel size, parcel shape, access, topography, berms and buffers." He further suggested including a separate statement in the Subdivision Criteria that says, "Hammerheads are prohibited." It was the consensus of the Board to amend the proposed language of Criteria B as recommended to read "Proposed subdivisions shall protect the character of the Town by incorporating features that are compatible with and complimentary to the preferred elements and overall character of the neighborhood district in which they are located, including but not limited to parcel size, parcel shape, access, topography, berms and buffers.". It was also the consensus of the Board to add a statement in the Subdivision Criteria that reads, "Hammerheads are prohibited." Mr. Lyons referred to the overlay on the aerial map and said there is enough there to suggest to a developer that he could develop a subdivision. He said the 500 feet could work against us and suggested eliminating that from Criteria A. Mr. Thrasher agreed and suggested there be no exact distance. Mr. Stanley suggested eliminating a radius and simply say, "the surrounding area." Mr. Randolph said he would prefer to not leave it vague, but he said Criteria A could read, "Lots to be created by the proposed subdivision shall be consistent with the adjacent or immediate property." Clerk Taylor suggested using the design district as the neighborhood because it is already defined. She Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 15 said when they originally designed the design districts through windshield surveys the lots were somewhat the same size and architecture. Mr. Thrasher said there are three districts already identified on this aerial map, which are Ocean West, Beachfront and North/South. It was the consensus of the Board that the proposed language in Criteria A would be amended to read, "Lots to be created by the proposed subdivision should be consistent with the adjacent and immediate properties." Mr. Randolph asked Chairman Ganger to confirm that the Board concurs with all of the changes and that they are ready to make their recommendations to the Commission. Chairman Ganger confirmed that. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Minor to prepare a final draft of the language for review by the Architectural Review and Planning Board before the make their recommendations to the Commission. b. Section 66-1, Definitions Mr. Minor said he reviewed the code provisions from other communities provided by Mr. Randolph and he has incorporated some of that language into proposed language previously discussed. He summarized the proposed language for Sec. 66-1. Definitions which reads, "Basement shall mean that portion of the building which is below the finished floor elevation of the building and is located within the footprint of the first floor. A basement is not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building, unless the ceiling of the basement is greater than three (3) feet above grade. The square footage of a basement shall be included as 100 of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations. Basements shall conform to all setback regulations for structures. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the building." Mr. Smith referred to Exhibit A, Illustration 1 -Basement, which was attached to the Jupiter Island Definitions, if a home has a real basement that is completely under the first floor with nothing more than an emergency exit to the outside, we should not be as punitive. Mr. Minor said if the ceiling of the basement is not more than 3' above grade it would not be counted in the FAR. Mr. Thrasher suggested using 75% in the FAR calculations rather than 100% if the ceiling of a basement is more than three feet above grade. Mr. Lyons said that part of the reason the Board is addressing basements is because of the home on County Road where there is concern over grade and the slope of the driveway and the danger it may cause. He said he is not sure how the proposed definition would avoid the situation and asked if we could define a slope and grade of a driveway. Mr. Randolph said it can be done, but he said it is a different issue. Clerk Taylor said that grade should be controlled under the terms of the Building Code rather than the Zoning Code. She said the Florida Building Code has regulations with regard to Multi -Family, but she said there are no restrictions that apply to Single Family. She asked if there would be a way to include a restriction that would apply without causing an issue. Mr. Randolph suggested incorporating an on -point regulation in the Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 16 Design Manual that would address the grade and slope of driveways. Mr. Thrasher said the Town has asked the City of Delray Beach to examine the situation on County Road and advise whether or not their current code and inspections would prohibit such a driveway. He said their answer was "No" and he said Palm Beach County had the same answer. The consensus of the Board and Staff was that grade and slope of a driveway should be a separate issue. Mr. Lyons agreed that we should not be as punitive if a basement is not visible from the street, not creating mass or impacting the neighbors. Mr. Thrasher said it could still appear as a three-story from the rear. Mr. Randolph said there should be some impediment imposed if a house has a basement where a portion of it can be viewed. Mr. Stanley said it should be controlled by the entrance. He said a basement under the bottom floor, or under the footprint of the house, should only have access from inside the house, and he said if a basement has any external access you would include a percentage of the square footage in the FAR calculations. Mr. Randolph asked the Board if they agree that if a basement is designed in a way that it is habitable space, that space should be counted in the FAR calculations. The Board was in agreement. Mr. Lyons asked if office space or a workout room would be considered habitable space. Mr. Randolph said anything over a six or seven -foot ceiling should be counted as square footage. Mr. Minor asked the Board to confirm that square footage of a basement area having external access and creating a three-story look would be counted 100% in the FAR calculations. Chairman Ganger confirmed that. Mr. Minor asked for clarification concerning a basement completely under the first story with a ceiling that is no greater than 3' above grade with no external access. It was recommended that square footage of a basement completely under the first story with a ceiling that is no greater than 3' above grade and with no external access should be counted as 75% in the FAR calculations. Mr. Smith said a description of non -accessible, with the exception of an emergency escape from such an area, should be included. Mr. Stanley asked Mr. Minor for another sketch similar to Illustration 1 of Exhibit A that would include what has been discussed and agreed upon. Mr. Minor agreed that the sketches are extremely helpful and he would provide a new sketch that would depict the 100% and the 75%. Vice -Chairman Morgan arrived at 8:50 A.M. Chairman Ganger updated Vice - Chairman Morgan on the changes the Board has agreed to so far and he thanked him for the letter to the Board saying that it was very helpful in their thought process and decision making. C. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio Mr. Minor said there have been discussions concerning the current FARs and some feel the FARs may be creating a boxy look to homes. He said we include design features such as covered space with no walls which provides flexibility, but he said we see less of that because if applicants feel they can have indoor space in that same area they will choose the indoor space. Mr. Minor asked the Board if they would prefer more articulation in the buildings or if they would prefer not counting Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 17 as much of the outdoor spaces, such as porticos, overhangs and back porches, as a way of tweaking FAR calculations and how that transfers into design of houses. Clerk Taylor said a special exception is available which provides that you can go 300 SF over and above the maximum allowable FAR if it is a covered, unenclosed space, and she said almost everyone building a new house will take advantage of that special exception. She said the reason they offer the special exception is to encourage balconies. Clerk Taylor said that the space can be used on any side of a house, but she said it is typically used on the first floor as a lanai and the Town would place a deed restriction on that area which restricts the area from ever being enclosed. Chairman Ganger asked if we have asked guidance from architects on how to achieve the amount of living space their client desires while being able to avoid mass or a boxy look. Mr. Smith said the 75% rule is not the problem, he said it is the 25% that must be taken off of the second story that needs to be defined. Mr. Stanley referred to the Delray Beach Code and said that Mr. Minor did the BPOA overlay for the North Beach. He said we are talking about flush walls and a lot of those issues are addressed in the Delray Beach Code and he asked Mr. Minor if there is anything in the Gulf Stream Code that addresses flush wall breaks or that provides incentives for breaking up a side of a building. Mr. Minor said there are standards for that within the Delray Beach Code, but he said there is nothing like that in the Gulf Stream Code. Mr. Stanley said Delray's issues are similar and he said Mr. Minor may have input from architects like Gary Eliopoulos and others that have projects in Gulf Stream. He said Delray has incentives, but you must have height plains coming from the street and flush wall breaks every so many feet on the house. Mr. Lyons asked Mr. Stanley to describe a flush wall break. Mr. Stanley said if you come in on three sides on the second story, there must be a break in the flush wall on the fourth side every 50 feet. He said the alternative is to have an additional architectural element on the street side to break up the flush wall. Mr. Stanley said other towns offer incentives that Gulf Stream may not be ready to offer at this time. Mr. Thrasher asked if Delray regulations talk to different architectural styles. Mr. Stanley said the regulations are shorter and simpler and leave room for interpretation, but he said they define four different architectural styles, including photos, as does Gulf Stream. He said the regulations are very similar and they could serve a model for Gulf Stream. He recommended providing more sketches and requiring flush wall breaks, and he said incentives could be considered down the road. Vice - Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Minor for his input. Mr. Minor said one of the things Delray was looking at was buildings as they relate to their neighbors to avoid creating canyons of buildings that are straight up. He said they want to create a preferred living environment with some building sections set back creating light in those areas. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Minor if the implementation of height plane would help in this regard. Mr. Minor said it would be helpful. Mr. Randolph requested Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 18 another sketch from Mr. Minor showing the apparent height from the street. Mr. Thrasher said many previous applications introduced different architectural elements and setbacks on both the front and rear of a structure, and he said the differences we see in large walls seem to appear on the sides. He said height plane seems to be something you would look at from a front elevation only and, therefore, we should concentrate more on 75% second story coverage and/or some kind of setback break on more sides of a second story. Mr. Randolph said, due to height plane regulations, you cannot bring a side wall all the way to the front of a house and, therefore, you are dealing with the sides when looking at height plane from the front. Mr. Stanley said that Gulf Stream should include a separate section that addresses building height plane for corner lots, which is not addressed in the BPOA regulations. Mr. Thrasher said our setbacks are different for lots located on one, two or three streets, and he said you will typically see additional architectural elements on the street sides for that reason. Mr. Thrasher said, from a two dimensional drawing, it consistently appears that the 75% rule is not sufficient and it disputes the first impression of mass. He said when we send two-dimensional drawings to our consultants for recalculation they come back okay and, therefore, it appears that the 75% rule is lacking something. Chairman Ganger suggested that maybe the 75% rule should require all four elevations to contribute to the 750. Mr. Thrasher said that type of restriction would limit creativity of a good architect and there are many architectural elements that can be used to create a break without creating a boxy look. He said the incentive concept is good if we can incorporate something similar to the Delray Beach, and he said the incentives would have to be tailored to the two predominant architectural styles in Gulf Stream. Mr. Thrasher said we encourage architects to be more creative with the introduction of architectural elements and there may be common terminology that will create incentives to increase the use of those elements. He asked Mr. Minor to provide some information. Mr. Minor said it would be an excellent addition to the Code to address this issue. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Stanley about other architects who contributed to the Delray Beach Code. Mr. Stanley said Bob Curry, Jeff Sowers and William Wietsma contributed their ideas and he said Gary Eliopoulos sat on the Delray Beach Commission when they were reviewing the Code. Vice - Chairman Morgan asked how long it has been in place and if it is working. Mr. Stanley said it is now on the Delray Beach website, but he said it has been in place for five or six years and it works primarily because of the FAR. He said the setbacks are better, structures have to be smaller and are limited to 6,000 SF on an average lot. Chairman Ganger said the Board would like to go in this direction to address mass and the boxy look. Mr. Minor said he has a very good idea of what the Board is looking for and he will come back with his recommendation. Mr. Thrasher asked why Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 19 we do not have second story requirements in the Beachfront and Ocean West Districts. Clerk Taylor said it is because of the larger lots. Mr. Stanley said if you have a larger lot with a 30' or 40' setback from your property line, general design standards allow you to go up, and he said it should be based on actual lot size and not district specific. He said the idea is the larger the setback, the bigger the buffer, the more you can do. Mr. Thrasher said it really shows up when we are dealing with a stand-alone garage with a second story apartment. Clerk Taylor referred to the existing special exception which allows an additional 300 feet of covered, unenclosed space and asked if it would help to increase the additional allowable area. Mr. Thrasher said he likes the elements they have to produce in those areas. Chairman Ganger said it could be used as an incentive in that if you are under the 750 you will receive a credit on the 300'. He said it is logical because those elements create breaks and it would be the rewarding of good design. d. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements Chairman Ganger asked if there is a formula that would preserve some larger lots where large lots exist. Mr. Randolph said the Board is attempting to do this in the subdivision regulations, and he said you must keep in mind that with lot size requirements you are dealing with regulations within an entire district and you could create a problem if you try to change lot size. Mr. Thrasher asked if a reward system could be applied with regard to larger lots that would allow a larger FAR. He said, for example, for the first 20,000 square feet of lot the FAR is 330, thereafter it is 200 of the remaining square footage, and somehow you would correlate that 20o upward in relation to the size of the lot to encourage future subdivision to be larger lots. Mr. Thrasher asked if that would work to help us maintain larger lot sizes. Mr. Minor said you may want to limit that to a large size of a certain threshold as a way of encouraging preservation of larger lots. Chairman Ganger said Ocean West is where we are focused and we are talking about how to maintain the economic value of the entire community by having a sprinkling of beautiful estates as part of our inventory of homes. He said it is a concept worth pursuing and it should be done in terms of acre as opposed to lot, and he said we should say that the reason for doing this is to maintain a few large lots. Mr. Stanley said he believes we need to move forward, but he said some of these things will have to be tested over a period of time to see results. Mr. Minor said he will come back with several options and he will also provide a three- dimensional sketch -up with regard to that point. e. Section 70-4, How to Use This Manual There was no discussion concerning this item. 2. Section 70-28, Roofs Mr. Thrasher said Staff has issued four reroof permit applications in the last few weeks where contractors are using the white cement tile thou and thou which is a flat material with no slurry coating. He said this tile has been used forever and he said its purpose was to mirror the original design of the Bermuda Style homes. Mr. Thrasher said there has been more discussion recently concerning white roof tile material, specifically the white cement thou and thou with a slurry coating and a slight glaze. He said there are pros and cons concerning both roof materials, but he said Staff's recommendation is to maintain our Code in Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 20 the manner in which we have administered it for several years, and that is the use of the white flat cement thou and thou, untextured, unpainted and with no slurry coating. Mr. Thrasher said there have been reports that this tile is no longer available, but he said Staff has found that to be false. He asked the Board if they want to allow the white slurry - coated tile to be placed on Gulf Stream Bermuda Style homes. Mr. Thrasher said there has been additional discussion as to what the Board would like to do with grey slate -like roof tile. He said the Board has allowed a solid grey tile, which does not appear to be slate - like, and a light green, which was approved for the Sargeant home. He said the discussion between slate and slate -like allows distortion and he said architects feel that limiting them to white or grey tile handicaps their ability to create a desirable look. Mr. Minor said he spoke with a carpenter/roofer friend who does work up and down the Island, and he said his friend confirmed that the non - slurry -coated white flat cement tile thou and thou by Entegra is readily available. Mr. Randolph asked what there is in the Code that precludes a slurry -coated tile. Mr. Thrasher said that when he sought guidance from the ARPB several years ago, the Board directed him to approve the white flat cement thou and thou. He said there were discussions in the past about consistency in the Bermuda styling and he said there is also some language in the Code that discourages shiny -surfaced roof tile and specific tile material in certain districts, or in the Core. Clerk Taylor said there is an additional word in the description of roof tile under "Required" which reads, . . . white flat untextured tile. Chairman Ganger said the ARPB and the Commission cannot be oblivious to new technology or a new product, but he said there has to be some benefit to using it such as, it has the same look or that it is better than what has been used in the past. He said the functionality of each tile may be similar, but he said we are trying to maintain a certain look. Mr. Randolph said those who presented the slurry -coated tile say they are advised that it holds up better, it avoids mold and it is not harmed when pressure cleaned. Mr. Thrasher said there are contractors that believe the non -slurry -coated tile is the better product and Mr. Minor agreed saying that professionals claim the non -slurry -coated tile holds up better and is preferred. Chairman Ganger pointed out that the slurry -coated tile is a larger tile. Mr. Thrasher said the size of the tile is what alerted Staff to the slurry -coating, but he said there is nothing in the Code that defines size. Mr. Lyons said the slurry -coated tile is too big and suggested adding something in the Code that defines size. Mr. Stanley pointed out that the slurry -coated tile could probably be custom-made tc any size. Mr. Smith said roofers are selling the larger slurry -coated tile because it is easier to install and it is cheaper to maintain. Mr. Lyons commented that the larger roof tile will give the appearance of mass. Mr. Thrasher said with regard to requesting a variance, money cannot be a hardship. Mr. Smith said that Peter Bennett is the resident who has a Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 23, 2012 Page 21 slurry -coated roof tile and suggested driving by the property to see what it looks like. He said he supports not going to multi -color tile on Bermuda Style homes. Vice -Chairman Morgan said color is covered under Section 70-238, but he said the slurry -coated tile is not covered and it would be subject to interpretation. Mr. Thrasher explained that Mr. Bennett's permit application for the slurry -coated tile was denied at the administrative level and he appealed the administrative decision. He said his appeal came before the Board of Adjustment and they approved the slurry -coated tile, then directed there be Zoning in Progress. Vice -Chairman Morgan said that, because of the way the Code Section is written, the Board of Adjustment could not preclude the slurry -coated tile. Chairman Ganger agreed saying the word "untextured" can be interpreted in different ways. Chairman Ganger excused himself from the meeting at 9:50 A.M. In closing, Mr. Thrasher said Mr. Bennett, in Place Au Soleil, has the slurry -coated tile roof and two houses south of Mr. Bennett has the white flat cement thou and thou. He said if you drive by you may be able to see the difference, and he said try to picture the slurry -coated tile in the Core. Mr. Thrasher said there is a variety of architectural styles and roofs in Place Au Soleil, but he said it is mostly Bermuda Style in the Core Area, and he said once a decision is made you can affect the character of the Town. He said roofs are a very important element in the architectural styling of Gulf Stream and there are no tools in place as guidance to make these decisions. Mr. Randolph said the Code is vague, Mr. Thrasher's interpretation of the Code was challenged and the Board of Adjustment granted it, but then held zoning in progress, giving the ARPB an opportunity to look at it and decide whether a change is appropriate. Mr. Randolph suggested looking at some of the roofs that have the slurry -coated tile, ask Mark Marsh for his opinion and make your decision based on that information. VII. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Board Members. VIII. Public. There were no items by the Public IX. Adjournment. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to adjourn the meeting. The meeting was adjourned at 9:55 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant Potential Code Changes; 2012 1. Section 70:238. Roofs (a); Page CD70:93 Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval Recommended Changes: Required. Flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated tile, except that gray, slate or slate -style, may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences, subject to Level II approval. 2. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights Define preferred, discouraged and prohibited height of entry feature. Recommended Changes: Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable or other such element. Height: Preferred, From eight feet to 14 feet. Discouraged, From 14 feet to 16 feet. Prohibited. Greater than 16 feet. 3. Section 70-51 Minor accessory structures (2); Page CD70:24 In -ground swimming pools and spas Recommended Changes: Add "Waterfalls" 4. Section 66-367 Swimming pools Recommended Change: Add (j) No grotto shall be permitted in any zoning district. A grotto shall be considered and artificial structure or excavation made to look like a cave or cavern. (k) Waterfalls, minor accessory structures, shall not exceed 4' in height as measured from the average finished grade of the property and the back side of the structure shall be screened from off -premises view with landscape material. 5. Section 66-369 Docks (7); Page CD66:71 Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. Recommended Changes: No concrete docks are permitted. All docks will be made from natural materials. 6. Section 66-1 Definitions Recommended Change: Basement shall mean that portion of a building which is below the finished floor elevation of the building. A basement is not considered a story with regards to height measurement of a building. The square footage of a basement shall be included in the FAR calculations at 50% and not be usable for living purposes which includes working, sleeping, eating, cooking or recreation, or a combination thereof. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the structure. 7. Section 70-71 Floor Area Ratio Recommended Change: Seeking Input 8. Section 70-68 Lot size and dimensional requirements. Recommended Change: Seeking Input 9. Section 70-4 How to use this Manual Recommended Change: Seeking Input GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-238 (b) Stepbacks. The use of stepbacks is appropriate to reduce excessive bulkiness and provide a transition between first and second stories. A few critical stepbacks on a building are better than several minor stepbacks that only complicate the facade and create busy architecture. (c) Preferred. Balconiesy. Simple rectangular config- urations ti Single story garages Smaller second story con- figurations 4 k Stepbacks to second story (d) Discouraged. Angular walls Complex facade treatment (excessive multi -layer stepbacks) Stepbacks, smaller second story, single story garage, and a balcony help to Sec. 70-238. Roofs. articulate and give appropriate scale to this house (preferred). (a) Required. White flat untextured tile, except that gray slate or slate -style tile may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences subject to Level II approval. (b) Preferred. Combination hip/gable roofs Decorative capped chim- ney Exposed rafter tails Flashing, vent stacks, and pipes painted to match ad- jacent building surface Hip roof Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes) Roof overhang (2-2Y2 feet) Simple roof geometry em- phasizing long horizontal lines White flat untextured tile Gulf Stream- Bermuda style white tile roof (required) OC, Corr. CD70:93 § 70-238 (c) Discouraged. Dormers on single story GULF STREAM CODE houses Gable Pyramidal hip (often has too steep of slope) Very low pitched roofs (slope less than 5:12) (d) Prohibited. Barrel tiles -� Front gable except for en- try features - - Gambrel Mansard Monolithic roof design where inadequate mea- sures were taken to re- duce massing and height Roof detail showing exposed rafter tails and decorative capped chimney of roof design (preferred) Pan tiles Shed Shingles Tiles other than white flat untextured tiles or gray slate tiles Unnecessarily complex roof geometry (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 56, 57, 3-10-00) OC, Corr. CD70:94 § 70-99 GULF STREAM CODE Metal roofs (except unpainted copper when used as a decorative accent or on minor accessory structures) Non-earthtone colors (except white), for example: blue, peach, pink, teal or yellow Primary color tiles and shingles Roll tile and similar tile styles in all districts except Place Au Soleil S -Tile in all districts except Place Au Soleil Solar panels on the streetside Unnecessarily complex or monolithic roof design All white tile other than flat cement tile (Ord. No. 00-1, § 36, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-9, § 2, 10-10-03) Sec. 70-100. Roof and eave heights. (a) Generally. (1) The height and number of eave lines and the overall height of a structure play an important role in establishing visual continuity with other structures on the street and maintaining an appropriate residential/human scale. Most structures in the town are characterized by simple roof designs with low to medium eave heights and roof heights. This type of design emphasizes the horizontal dimension of the structure while minimizing the vertical dimension. (2) Roof height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the highest exterior point on the roof. Eave height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the top of the roof beam at the end of the beam (top of flashing). Different eave heights establish different eave lines. Two or more separate roof areas with the same eave height are considered to have the same eave line. (3) Roof features can provide appropriate design articulation to a roof area, but should be used sparingly to avoid unnecessary and undesirable complexity. Roof features include, but are not limited to, chimneys, cupolas, decorative towers, dormers, and small cut-outs and extensions. Two or more dormers are considered to be one roof feature, as are two or more chimneys. (4) Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival to visitors, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches (from eight feet to 12 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Three or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 20 feet or less (24 feet or less for roof features) (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet (between 12 and 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Four Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 20 and 24 feet (between 24 and 28 feet for roof features) OC, Corr. CD70:46 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-100 (3) Prohibited. Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet (greater than 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Five or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side Roof heights: Greater than 24 feet (greater than 28 feet for roof features) (c) Two story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—From eight feet to 12 feet for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 22 feet six inches or less for two-story portions All other districts—From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 21 feet or less for two story portions Eave lines: Four or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 22 feet or less for one-story portions (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Between 12 and 14 feet for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 22 feet six inches and 24 feet six inches for two-story portions All other districts—Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 21 feet and 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Five Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 22 feet and 26 feet for one-story portions (3) Prohibited. Buildings with more than two and one-half stories Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 14 feet for one-story portions Greater than 24 feet six inches for two-story portions. All other districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet six inches for one-story portions Greater than 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Six or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side CD70:47 § 70 -loo GULF STREAM CODE Roof heights: Greater than 26 feet for one-story portions For two-story portions greater than the following for each zoning district: District Height in feet Gulf Stream Core 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Ocean West 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Beach Front 35 (including roof features) North/South 30 (roof features may extend to 35) Place Au Soliel 30 (roof features may extend to 35)" CD70:48 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-101 Preferred ■ Four or less eave lines Prohibited Six or more eave lines Line 3 Line 2 Line 1 Above graphic illustrates eight different eave lines, adding unnecessary complexity to the elevations. (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 26, 37, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-1, § 1, 4-11-03) Sec. 70-101. Windows. (a) Generally. (1) Windows not only provide light and ventilation but add to the aesthetics of a building by creating rhythm, proportion, distinction and articulation. Certain styles of windows correspond to specific CD70:49 + + & ¥ & E \ §@ R C ■ K | | / ■ | § § 4 § ■| �I �§�f| 7� ,.|■,�||wf|)�||||� + + & ¥ & E \ §@ R C & 4t A & b rA, O OR mill k� & 4t A & b rA, HER 1 PEM 01JR!, = -1 "Ill INN", CQ rn rvoiswa LU .fyt, r ,. i a �.: 7 ,' i § 70-49 GULF STREAM CODE (b) These prohibitions shall not extend to telephonic transactions and communications. Sec. 70-50. Private schools. Any private school conducted in any single family residential zoning district may continue to be used as such under the provisions of sections 66-131 et seq. of this Code, provided however, that any private school building, or other structure used in connection with and as a part of and appurtenant in the operation and maintenance of such private school, may be replaced, or another building substituted in place thereof; repaired and maintained from time to time as shall be necessary for the effective operation and maintenance of such private school; and further, any development permits, orders or written agreements granted or executed by the town prior to the adoption of this chapter shall remain in full force and effect. Sec. 70-51. Minor accessory structures. The following structures shall be considered as minor accessory structures in all five single family zoning districts subject to specific setbacks established in this chapter. Any structure which is larger or more intensive shall be subject to the same setbacks as the principal structure. (1) Detached, one-story structures of 300 square feet or less and 18 feet or less in height, including but not limited to: Garages/sheds Gazebos Greenhouses Guest houses Pool cabanas/bathhouses Trellises/arbors (2) Permanent recreation facilities, including but not limited to: Batting cages/backstops Forts and playhouses In -ground swimming pools and spas Paved/special surface areas and accompanying equipment and/or fencing for tennis/squash/ racquetball, basketball, shuffleboard, putting greens/sand traps, etc. Swing sets and other playground equipment (3) Fountains. (4) Mechanical equipment and television antennae/satellite dishes. (5) Decks and patios with elevations greater than eight inches above highest abutting grade. (6) Awnings with leg supports and those otherwise extending more than three feet out from a structure. (7) Docks, boat lifts, and davits. (8) Flagpoles. CD70:24 § 66-351 GULF STREAM CODE tion as a condition precedent to the issuance of a building permit for the proposed use. The unity of title declaration shall apply to all the property necessary for the proposed use, and shall declare that no portion of said property shall be sold or transferred by the owner or successors in interest apart from the whole. (b) If there is a sale or transfer in contraven- tion of a unity of title declaration, no building permit will be issued for any portion of the prop- erty contained in the unity of title declaration. Declaration shall remain in effect until a release of the unity of title declaration is executed by the town. (c) The unity of title declaration shall be filed at the expense of the owner in the public records of the county. Proof of such filing shall precede the issuance of a building permit. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, K), 4-8-83) Sec. 66-352. Nuisances. No use shall be made of any property within any district that shall in any way be offensive or noxious by reason of the emission of any dis- charge, odor, gas, dust, smoke, vibration or noise; nor shall any vehicle be parked or used in any way that would constitute a nuisance; nor shall anything be constructed or maintained that would in any way constitute a nuisance to adjacent property owners, residents or to the community. Each use shall be operated so as to lessen the damage from fire and explosion. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, J), 4-8-83) Cross reference—Nuisances, ch. 22. Secs. 66-353-66-365. Reserved. DIVISION 2. ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND RECREATIONAL FACILITIES Sec. 66-366. Antennas and antenna systems/ structures. (a) Broadcast receiving antennas or communi- cation antennas may be permitted in any zoning district upon site plan review and approval by the town commission and upon issuance of a building permit by the town. (b) Broadcast receiving antennas or communi- cation antennas shall be attached to the main building or structure and shall not extend more than five feet above the highest portion of the roof. (c) Satellite television antenna systems may be permitted in any zoning district upon site plan review and approval by the town commission and the issuance of a building permit by the town. (d) Satellite television antenna systems shall not exceed 12 feet in diameter or width. (e) Satellite television antenna systems shall be considered as accessory structures and shall be subject to the applicable site plan review require- ments and regulations of this chapter. (f) Unless specific approval is granted by the town commission, satellite television antenna sys- tems shall be ground mounted and located in such areas as to be screened or buffered from view from adjacent properties, rights-of-way, the Intracoastal Waterway and/or the Atlantic Ocean. (g) There shall not be more than one satellite television antenna system, broadcast receiving antenna or communication antenna per residen- tial building or condominium association on any platted lot or parcel. (h) Upon receipt of site plan approval and prior to the issuance of a building permit for satellite television antenna, the town commission shall review the installation plans, which plans must be signed and sealed by a professional engineer registered in the state who shall certify that the proposed satellite television antenna system is wind resistant with an ability to with- stand winds up to 140 miles per hour. The calcu- lations and such certification by the engineer shall be submitted along with the plans. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, H), 4-8-83; Ord. No. 84-7, § 2, 12-14-84) Sec. 66-367. Swimming pools. (a) No swimming pool shall be located, de- signed, operated or maintained so as to interfere unduly with the enjoyment of the property rights by owners of property adjoining the swimming pool. ZONING (b) Lights used to illuminate any swimming pool shall be so arranged and shadowed as to reflect away from adjoining premises. (c) A pool may be located within an enclosed courtyard, patio, etc., provided it is to the rear of the required front yard setback line. (d) All enclosed swimming pools shall be in conformity with the setbacks required by the zoning district in which it is located. (e) Unless otherwise specified elsewhere in this Code, unenclosed or open swimming pools in the "RS" single-family residential district shall be located a minimum of 25 feet from front property lines; provided, however, that any swimming pool located on property fronting on SR AlA shall be subject to the established 78 -foot centerline set- back. (f) Swimming pools shall be located on the same lot or parcel of land as that of the main building. In the event of contiguous lots or par- cels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. (g) All pools shall be enclosed by a self-locking, child resistant fence, wall or equivalent barrier at least four feet high, except as provided elsewhere in this Code, and in no event shall a pool be exposed to open view from any public roadway. (h) No aboveground pools of any nature shall be permitted in any zoning district. An aboveground pool shall be considered a pool constructed or assembled of any material and whose top edge exceeds two feet in height above the average finished grade of the lot or site. (i) All pools shall be landscaped so as to pre- vent exposure to off -premises view from any pub- lic roadway, any public or private right-of-way, and the ground level of any adjoining property. However, this subparagraph shall not be con- strued so as to prevent the exposure of pools to open view from public or private waterways. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 1), 4-8-83; Ord. No. 92-5, § 1, 9-28-92; Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 18, 19, 3-10-00) Sec. 66-368. Tennis courts. § 66-369 (a) No tennis court shall be located, designed, operated or maintained so as to interfere unduly with the enjoyment of the property rights by owners of property adjoining the tennis court. (b) No lights shall be used in any manner so as to illuminate any tennis court. (c) All tennis courts shall be in conformity with the setbacks required by the zoning district in which it is located. Any tennis court located on property fronting on SR AIA shall be subject to the established 78 -foot centerline setback. (d) Tennis courts shall be located on the same lot or parcel of land as that of the main building. In the event of contiguous lots or parcels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. (e) All tennis courts shall be enclosed by a fence, open wall or equivalent barrier and in no event shall a tennis court be exposed to open view from any public roadway. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 2), 4-8-83) Sec. 66-369. Docks. In the single-family residential district, one dock per lot of record shall be permitted in accor- dance with the following: Supp. No. 1 CD66:69 (1) Site plan review required. All new docks and significant alterations to existing docks shall require site plan review and ap- proval. (2) Permitted as accessory use. Docks shall be permitted only as an accessory use to single-family dwellings for the exclusive use of the dwelling's occupants (residents and nonresident members of the occupant's family and resident guests at the dwell- ing). Docks shall not be permitted on vacant lots unless the vacant lot is adja- cent to a developed lot under the same ownership and a unity of title has been recorded. . V. A - ,r, ZONING minimum offset from the setback centerlines. For lots with designated water frontage less than 100 feet the docking zone shall have a minimum five-foot offset from each of the set- back centerlines. In the case of cove end lots and lots with a water front- age of 100 feet or less, neither boat nor dock shall exceed a length of 70 feet. For rounded corner lots, water frontage is determined by the mid- point of the arc. For purposes of determining designated water front- age, dock widths, setbacks and max- imum boat lengths for each water- front lot within the Town, the figures contained within Exhibit "B" at- tached hereto and incorporated herein shall apply. [See the end of this sec- tion.] In cases with multiple water frontages, owner must treat each frontage according to the appropri- ate size category. In the case of low profile piling boat lifts, the lift shall be located in the following manner. The first piling shall be placed a minimum of twenty feet (towards center of the lot) from the setback line with the pilings extending into the docking zone no farther than twenty feet from the seawall. For lots with setbacks of more than fifteen feet on either side, the twenty foot mea- surement for the first piling shall be mea- sured from the setback on the side with the largest setback. f. A maximum of one dock box shall be permitted which shall be no higher than 30 inches and no larger than 24 cubic feet. § 66-369 g. Light fixtures shall be installed in a manner that provides safe pedes- trian circulation using low voltage lighting with a maximum fifty watts mounted no higher than three feet above the dock at a minimum spac- ing of ten feet on center. Lights are to be step, path or marine type fix- tures. Fixtures must project down- ward at a minimum 45 -degree angle from the horizontal plan tangent to the top of the light source fixture and allow no light spillage onto ad- jacent properties. No fixture shall be mounted to the seawall. h. Subject to level one site plan ap- proval, a maximum of one floating platform may be permitted in lieu of a boat lift for the purpose of storing small watercrafts. The floating plat- form shall be constructed of nonfer- rous material, be black in color and may not rise more than 12 inches out of the water. No more than two wa- tercrafts of a maximum length of 14 feet shall be stored on the floating platform. The platform dimensions shall not exceed eight feet in width or 16 feet in length. All watercrafts shall be stored parallel to the sea- wall. A floating platform must be removed after three months of dis- use. (7) Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. (Ord. No. 83-1, § 2(X, I, 3),4-8-83; Ord. No. 91-24, § 3, 10-21-91; Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 20, 21, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 04-9, § 2,2-11-05; Ord. No. 05-2, §§ 1-6, 9-9-05; Ord. No. 008-4, § 4, 9-5-08) Supp. No. 1 CD66:71 ZONING ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL Sec. 66-1. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Abutting shall mean having a common border with, or being separated from such common bor- der by, an alley or easement. Access shall mean the principal means of in- gress and egress to property from a publicly dedicated right-of-way. Accessory building, structure or use shall mean a building, structure or use on the same lot with, and of a nature customarily incidental and sub- ordinate to, the principal building, structure or use. Acre, net. See Net acre/net land area. Addition (to an existing building) shall mean any walled and roofed expansion to the perimeter of a building in which the addition is connected by a common load-bearing wall other than a firewall. Any walled and roofed addition which is con- nected by a firewall or is separated by indepen- dent perimeter load-bearing walls is new construc- tion. Adjacent shall mean that which lies near or close to, not widely separated or necessarily touch- ing. Adjoining shall mean that which is joined or united, actually touching. Alley shall mean a dedicated public right-of- way other than a street which provides only a secondary means of access to abutting property, is not over 20 feet in width and is not intended for general traffic circulation. Alterations, as applied to a building or struc- ture, a change or rearrangement in the structural parts of the existing facilities, or an enlargement, whether by extending on a side, or by increasing the height, or the moving from one location or position to another. § 66-1 Antenna shall mean a device for radiating and/or receiving television or radio signals. Antenna structure shall mean an antenna con- sisting of two or more radiating elements, gener- ally similar which are arranged in such a manner as to obtain direction radiation patterns. It in- cludes any structural members which are neces- sary to maintain the proper electrical relation- ships between the radiating elements, including the mast or other structure used to support the array as a whole, but does not include the trans- mission line which supplies energy to or receives energy from the array as a whole. Apartment. See Dwelling, multiple -family. Appeal shall mean a means for obtaining re- view of a decision, determination, order, or failure to act pursuant to the terms of this chapter. Area of shallow flooding shall mean a desig- nated AO or VO Zone on a community's flood insurance rate map (FIRM) with base flood depths from one to three feet where a clearly defined channel does not exist, where the path of flooding is unpredictable and indeterminate, and where velocity flow may be evident. Area of special flood hazard shall mean the land in the floodplain within a community subject to a one percent or greater chance of flooding in any given year. Awning shall mean any movable rooflike struc- ture cantilevered or otherwise entirely supported from a building, so constructed and erected as to permit its being readily moved within a few minutes time to close an opening, or rolled or folded back to a position flat against the building or a cantilevered projection thereof, or which is detachable. Base flood shall mean the flood having a one percent chance of being equalled or exceeded in any given year. Base flood elevation shall mean the height above mean sea level expected to be reached by the 100 -year flood. Basement shall mean that portion of a build- ing, the ceiling which is entirely below grade or less than three feet above grade. A basement is Supp. No. 1 CD66:7 § 66-1 GULF STREAM CODE not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the build- ing. Bedroom shall mean a room other than a kitchen, dining room, living room, bathroom or closet which is marketed, designed or otherwise likely to function primarily for sleeping. Block shall mean a tract of land bounded by streets, or by a combination of streets and public parks, cemeteries, railroad rights-of-way, bulk- head lines, or shorelines of waterways, or corpo- rate boundary lines of the town. Breakaway wall shall mean a wall that is not part of the structural support of the building and is intended through its design and construction to collapse under specific lateral loading forces with- out causing damage to the elevated portion of the building or the supporting foundation system. Breezeway shall mean a roofed, open -sided pas- sageway connecting two separate structures, or two separate portions of the same structure. Broadcast receiving antenna shall mean an outside antenna used for the reception of signals transmitted by stations licensed by the Federal Communications Commission in the radio broad- cast services, including AM, FM and TV. Building area shall mean the portion of a lot remaining after required setbacks have been pro- vided. Building shall mean any structure built for the shelter, support or enclosure of persons, animals, chattels or movable property of any kind; and, when separated by division walls without opening from the ground up, each portion of such struc- ture shall be deemed a separate building, and for the purpose of this chapter, all porches, projec- tions, cornices and eaves shall be deemed and considered a part of a building. The word "build- ing" shall include the word "structure." Building, detached, shall mean a building hav- ing no party walls in common with another build- ing. Building front shall mean that exterior wall of a building which faces a front lot line of the lot. Building height shall mean the vertical dis- tance measured from the point of first floor base flood elevation of the building site to the highest finished roof structure including any rooftop su- perstructure or appurtenance. Building line shall mean a line on a lot, gener- ally parallel to a lot line or road right-of-way line, located a sufficient distance therefrom to provide the minimum yards required by this chapter. The building line delimits the area in which buildings are permitted subject to all applicable provisions of this chapter. Building official shall mean that person who is designated by the town commission and is charged with the responsibility of enforcing and adminis- tering the various land and building regulations of the town. Building permit shall mean the document or certificate issued by the town building official or other designated official which verifies adherence to all applicable development regulations and gives permission to the permit applicant to pro- ceed with the actions for which the permit was requested. Building, principal, shall mean a building in which is conducted, or in which is intended to be conducted, the main or principal use of the lot on which it is located. Building site shall mean a portion or parcel of land considered as a unit, devoted to a certain use or occupied by a building or group of buildings that are united by a common interest or use, and the customary accessories and open spaces belong- ing to the same. Bulk shall mean the term used to describe the size of buildings or other structures, and their relationships to each other and to open areas and lot lines. Carport shall mean a freestanding covered area or a roofed area open on one, two or three sides and attached to a building, either of which is designed for the storage of one or more vehicles or boats. Supp. No. 1 CD66:8 § 70-69 Sec. 70-69. Unity of title. GULF STREAM CODE In the event of contiguous lots or parcels, a unity of title shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit for either a main residence building or an accessory structure which would cross lot lines. Sec. 70-70. Floor area calculation. For purposes of computing the floor area ratio, floor area shall be defined as follows. "Floor area" shall mean the gross floor area of a structure as measured from the outside of the exterior walls and shall include or exclude the following: (1) All floor area under a solid roof whether or not the area is enclosed with walls (i.e., porches, balconies, breezeways, etc.) shall be included. (2) Areas under awnings with leg supports or those that extend more than three feet out from a structure shall count as one-half shall be included. (3) Floor area under ceilings which are higher than 15 feet shall count as double. (4) Areas under screen enclosures shall count as 1/2. (5) Areas under eaves or roof extensions of 21/2 feet or less shall not be included. (6) Areas in basements shall not be included. (7) Areas in attics that cannot be used for living area shall not be included if the ceiling height does not exceed 61/2 feet and there are no windows. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 28, 3-10-00) Sec. 70-71. Floor area ratios. (a) Sliding scale floor area ratio (FAR). (1) Floor area ratio (FAR) is the relationship between a building's total floor area and the area of the lot it sits on. If a building is 2,500 square feet and it sits on a lot of 10,000 square feet, its FAR is .25. This direct relationship results in the ability to build bigger homes on bigger lots. While a ratio of total floor area to lot size such as .25 may be appropriate for smaller lots, on larger lots the result can be unnecessarily and inappropriately large homes. This is particularly a problem when two lots are combined and are now twice as large as the lots next door. This section provides a methodology for maintaining a reasonable opportunity to build larger homes on larger lots, while recognizing that the relationship to the scale of an existing neighborhood is an important community character concern. (2) In order to establish a sliding scale which reduces floor area ratio yields on larger lots; the following FAR step down shall be used: Effective Lot Area I Gulf Stream Core Ocean West Beachfront North/South I Place au Soleil Maximum FAR First 20,000 .33 .33 square feet .33 .33 .33 Portions over 20,000 square .20 .20 .20 .20 .20 feet+ Supp. No. 1 Example 1: 45,000 square foot lot in Beachfront District. First 20,000 square feet x .33 = Next 25,000 square feet x .20 = Total 45,000 square feet CD70:28 6,600 square feet 5,000 square feet 11,600 square feet maximum floor area GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-71 Example 2: 30,000 square foot lot in Ocean West District. First 20,000 square feet x .33 = 6,600 square feet Next 10,000 square feet x .20 = 2,000 square feet Total 30,000 square feet 8,600 square feet maximum floor area . Example 3: 18,000 square foot lot in Place au Soleil. First 18,000 square feet x .33 (b) Neighborhood context floor area ratio. 5,940 square feet maximum floor area (1) In order to address the potential problem created when two lots are aggregated in a district of predominantly small lots, the neighborhood context FAR shall be followed. This special FAR calculation will apply only to new lots in excess of 20,000 square feet created in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil Districts after the adoption of this chapter. (2) When dealing with double lots, it is reasonable to allow a larger home than would be allowed on a single lot, but probably not twice as large if abutting lots remain small. An equitable method for determining the maximum FAR for a double lot (or when a vacant lot is split between two existing homes) shall be to use existing abutting lots to create a "neighborhood context FAR" or average FAR yield and then to apply a reasonable factor for floor area expansion. (3) For lots over 20,000 square feet in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil districts created after the adoption of this manual, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the average maximum FAR yield of the two abutting lots with a 50 percent increase allowance. If the neighborhood context FAR is less than the standard FAR, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the maximum allowed. This will restrict new houses or homes with additions to a size that, while large, would not overshadow neighborhood residences. For example: Double lot at 33,000 square feet. Maximum FAR for newly created lots over 20,000 square feet is the smaller of the two FAR calculations (sliding scale FAR and neighborhood context FAR). a. Sliding scale FAR: 20,000 square feet x .33 13,000 square feet x .20 Total 33,000 square feet b. Neighborhood context FAR: Neighbor 1 lot: 13,000 square feet x .33 Neighbor 2 lot: 16,000 square feet x .33 Total 6,600 square feet 2,600 square feet 9,200 square feet maximum floor area 4,290 square feet maximum 5,280 square feet maximum 9,570 square feet max _ 2 = 4,785.0 square feet aver- age x 1.5 7,177.5 square feet maxi- mum floor area Maximum FAR is smaller of the two: 7,177.5 square feet Supp. No. 1 CD70:29 Gulf Stream Core Ocean West Beachfront NorthlSouth Place au Soleil Neighbor- Lots greater than 20,000 Lots greater than 20,000 hood Context square feet created after N/A N/A N/A square feet created after FAR Applica- adoption of this manual adoption of this manual bility (2) When dealing with double lots, it is reasonable to allow a larger home than would be allowed on a single lot, but probably not twice as large if abutting lots remain small. An equitable method for determining the maximum FAR for a double lot (or when a vacant lot is split between two existing homes) shall be to use existing abutting lots to create a "neighborhood context FAR" or average FAR yield and then to apply a reasonable factor for floor area expansion. (3) For lots over 20,000 square feet in the Gulf Stream Core or Place au Soleil districts created after the adoption of this manual, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the average maximum FAR yield of the two abutting lots with a 50 percent increase allowance. If the neighborhood context FAR is less than the standard FAR, the neighborhood context FAR shall be the maximum allowed. This will restrict new houses or homes with additions to a size that, while large, would not overshadow neighborhood residences. For example: Double lot at 33,000 square feet. Maximum FAR for newly created lots over 20,000 square feet is the smaller of the two FAR calculations (sliding scale FAR and neighborhood context FAR). a. Sliding scale FAR: 20,000 square feet x .33 13,000 square feet x .20 Total 33,000 square feet b. Neighborhood context FAR: Neighbor 1 lot: 13,000 square feet x .33 Neighbor 2 lot: 16,000 square feet x .33 Total 6,600 square feet 2,600 square feet 9,200 square feet maximum floor area 4,290 square feet maximum 5,280 square feet maximum 9,570 square feet max _ 2 = 4,785.0 square feet aver- age x 1.5 7,177.5 square feet maxi- mum floor area Maximum FAR is smaller of the two: 7,177.5 square feet Supp. No. 1 CD70:29 § 70-71 GULF STREAM CODE (4) For lots subject to neighborhood context FAR, the methodology for identifying abutting lots is as follows: Note: Lots not conforming to outlined examples are subject to approval by the town Planning and Building Administrator in keeping with these guidelines. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 26, 3-10-00) :14 ' `'4 3c .; End Lot 13'1 J� 5 t 12 t t 6 15 •'s.... o t.16 10 g Corner Lot 25 24 .23 22t:21420.18 2627:.'28 :,Yt 31 19 'l J.Y i ✓ L= t—1 ` Interior Lot Combined Lot Types Sec. 70-72. Special exception floor area ratio (FAR). (a) Lots of less than 7,576 square feet. Up to 2,500 square feet of floor area may be permitted on any legally established lot of record of 7,576 square feet or less, subject to the following: (1) Maximum floor area. The maximum floor area is 2,500 square feet. (2) Specific standards for review. Site and structural design elements including, but not limited to: a. Height of the structure relative to neighboring structures; b. The location, number and size of windows, doors, porches, balconies and outdoor lights; Supp. No. 1 CD70:30 Abutting Neighbor #1 Abutting Neighbor #2 For interior lots, abutting lots are: the side lot the other side lot example: if lots 29 and 30 are combined, abut- ting lots are: lot 28 lot 31 For corner lots, abutting lots are: the side lot which faces the same the largest lot directly across the street same street example: if lots 7 and 8 are combined, abutting lots are: lot 6 lot 17 For end lots, abutting lots are: the side lot the next nearest lot on street example: if lots 1 and 2 are combined, abutting lots are: lot 3 lot 4 Note: Lots not conforming to outlined examples are subject to approval by the town Planning and Building Administrator in keeping with these guidelines. (Ord. No. 00-1, § 26, 3-10-00) :14 ' `'4 3c .; End Lot 13'1 J� 5 t 12 t t 6 15 •'s.... o t.16 10 g Corner Lot 25 24 .23 22t:21420.18 2627:.'28 :,Yt 31 19 'l J.Y i ✓ L= t—1 ` Interior Lot Combined Lot Types Sec. 70-72. Special exception floor area ratio (FAR). (a) Lots of less than 7,576 square feet. Up to 2,500 square feet of floor area may be permitted on any legally established lot of record of 7,576 square feet or less, subject to the following: (1) Maximum floor area. The maximum floor area is 2,500 square feet. (2) Specific standards for review. Site and structural design elements including, but not limited to: a. Height of the structure relative to neighboring structures; b. The location, number and size of windows, doors, porches, balconies and outdoor lights; Supp. No. 1 CD70:30 SLI/ GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-68 ARTICLE IV. SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Sec. 70-66. Generally. Typically, zoning regulations affect the size and location of development on individual lots and establish the basic building envelope. The development standards in this article respond to the unique characteristics of the town's five single-family zoning districts and address community concerns regarding the mass of new construction and its impact on neighborhood character. Sec. 70-67. Effective lot area. (a) Because many of the site development regulations contained in this chapter are a function of lot size, the definition of the term "lot size" becomes very important. One of the key goals of this chapter is to maintain a proper proportion and scale between buildings and between buildings and the land. Accordingly, it is necessary to establish an "effective lot area" in order to meet this goal. (b) All references to "lot size" or "lot area" in this chapter shall have the same meaning as "effective lot area" which is defined as follows. "Effective lot area" shall mean the platted/recorded lot area minus the following: (1) Any submerged lands. (2) Any lands east of the Coastal Construction Control Line established in 1978. (3) Any lands separated from the main portion of the lot by public or private roads. (4) Any lands used for private road surfaces including an additional ten feet of area beyond the edge of the pavement of a private road. (5) Any unrecorded public right-of-way which shall be determined by using an average of the recorded right-of-way adjacent to other properties along the same roadway. Sec. 70-68. Lot size and dimensional requirements. The following requirements shall apply only to lots created after the adoption of this chapter. Nonconforming lots which were legally subdivided and recorded in accordance with the regulations in effect at the time of the subdivision, but prior to the adoption of this chapter, shall have all building rights provided under this chapter and chapter 66 provided all other applicable requirements are met. Minimum Lot Size and Gulf Stream North/ Place au Dimensional Requirements Core Ocean West Beachfront South Soleil Effective Lot Area 16,500 30,000 30,000 20,000 15,000 Width Front 100 100 150 100 100 (Rectangular Shaped Lot) Front/Point 40 40 N/A 40 40 (Pie Shaped Lot) Other Lots shall have a All lots shall have a minimum frontage minimum of 150 feet of 100 feet on both of frontage on both AIA and Gulf AIA and the ocean. Stream Road where Land -locked lots are adjacent to both. prohibited. (Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 26, 27, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 008-5, § 1, 9-5-08) Supp. No. 1 CD70:27 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-4 (c) In addition to the design standards contained in this chapter, for convenience, the specific mandatory land development regulations are included to facilitate an overall understanding of the review criteria to which new construction is subject. North Ocean Boulevard entering Gulf Stream Sec. 70-4. How to use this manual. (a) Organization. This chapter is organized into nine articles. The user is encouraged to read the chapter in its entirety. This chapter is a full part of the town's land development regulations and has the same force and effect of all other provisions contained therein. (1) Articles III and IV. Article III, Use Regulations, and article IV, Site Development Regulations, contain land development regulations which are mandatory and apply to all of the single-family zoning districts. These are the typical zoning -type regulations found in most other codes. (2) Articles V through VIII. Articles V through VIII provide design standards and establish a basis for review and approval of all new single-family construction or remodeling. Article V, Areawide Standards, applies to all single-family homes in the town. Provisions with respect to Gulf Stream -Bermuda and Mediterranean Revival architecture (see article VII) are not applicable if an alternate architectural design is selected. The reader is encouraged, however, to become familiar with their provisions in that they are the preferred styles in most of the town. (3) Article VL Article VI, District Standards, provides more specific design direction for the five single-family zoning districts established in this chapter. The user should identify the applicable district and should study it carefully to ensure that the unique characteristics of and appropriate design direction for that district are incorporated into any design proposal. (4) Article VIL Article VII, Predominant Architectural Styles, contains design standards for Gulf Stream -Bermuda and Mediterranean Revival styles of architecture. As discussed, these styles are not mandatory but are indicative of the predominant styles within the community. (5) Article VIII. Article VIII, Supplemental Development Regulations, addresses elements such as antennas, that sometimes are tacked on to homes that otherwise display good design character- istics. Standards for these elements are provided in this article. CD70:7 § 70-4 GULF STREAM CODE (6) Article IX. Finally, an appendix is included in article IX. This includes a glossary of architectural terms, an explanation of the development review process, details of the historic survey and single-family development survey, a discussion of color, and a bibliography. These are included as reference materials but are not formally a part of this chapter or chapter 66. (b) Illustrations. The illustrations contained within this chapter address and respond to the oppor- tunities for enhancing and preserving the visual environment of the town. (c) Design standards. The design standards in this chapter provide the town with a methodology and common framework for reviewing submissions for project approvals. The design standards contained herein are either mandatory or discretionary. The terms "required" and "prohibited" are mandatory. The terms "preferred" and "discouraged" are discretionary. These terms are defined below: (1) Required. a. Required items are design elements that are necessary in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. b. Compliance is mandatory for project approval. (2) Preferred. a. Preferred items are design elements that, whenever possible, should be used in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. These items are those typically found in the town and which, in combination with other preferred items, define the existing and desired character of the town and the zoning districts. Preferred items are thought to comply with the 'following goals with respect to desired zoning district character and quality: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. b. Incorporating preferred items into a design increases the probability of, but does not assure, project approval. (3) Discouraged. a. Discouraged items are design elements that should not be used in order to maintain the desired character and quality of the zoning district within which they are located. These items are not typically found in the town and detract from the existing and desired character of the town and the zoning districts. Discouraged items are thought to not comply with the following goals with respect to desired zoning district character and quality: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. b. Incorporating discouraged items into a design decreases the probability of project approval and may result in project denial. In order for a discouraged item to be approved, applicants must show, and the town must find, that the proposed item is not inconsistent with the above goals. The use of more than three discouraged items on any property is prohibited. CD70:8 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL (4) Prohibited. § 70-25 a. Prohibited items are design elements that do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located and are not permitted under current codes or regulations. b. The use of more than three discouraged items on a property is prohibited. C. Use of prohibited elements mandates project denial. (d) Additional standards and criteria. Please note that the chapter constitutes only one small subsection of the Land Development Regulations found in this Code. While compliance with the standards found in articles I through VIII of this chapter is essential to final project approval, compliance with several additional standards and criteria also may be necessary before a building permit can be issued. Accordingly, users of this chapter are strongly advised to familiarize themselves with all federal, state and/or town regulations that might apply to a particular type of project. To assist in determining which town regulations may apply, users are encouraged to review the tables and flow chart contained in section 70-297 of this chapter. Users also are encouraged to direct questions to, and share information with, town planning staff as early as possible in the plan development stage. Secs. 70-5-70-25. Reserved. CD70:9 s March 18, 2012 CHAIRMAN: Robert Ganger VICE CHAIRMAN: Scott Morgan BOARD MEMBER: Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy ALTERNATE MEMBER: Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, MARCH 22, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes: Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 2-23-12 & 3-2-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Subdivision Review a. Section 66-1, Definitions b. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio C. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements d. Section 70-4, How to Use This Manual 2. Section 70-238, Roofs 3. Section 70-100, Roof & Eave Heights 4. Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures 5. Section 66-367, Swimming Pools 6. Section 66-369, Docks VII. Items by Board Members. VIII. Public. IX. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. N o-' : ih c � ", M C) � I W z 7� c� N CD CD 0 CD O p 0 ,.. �,, o o o' ro ° ao v4 n p CD 0 CD oCD CD o o o a, CD O CD 0 �. �• CCD n ' (gyp —P r�T CCD � G � p `C � � r~-� v ' CL n CD o oCD n 0. o a cn O p+ G. `C '�U' n .S CD cn cn �. CCDM � CD CD p � n `L7 G CD O Y A' C ,� N a C O C•� C `C (rq o p A CD 0 (D "— O o p O CP, r -Z O 3 ID Ln CD -t ° a ° CD rn S c. (D Gn CD 'Cl CCDD b CD p (� r -h CL ri .°� r+ O O yr r .°�unCD CD tz RD p 0 CD (DCD CD ACD CD --h 00 cn `C �O 0 Oa C CD ❑FD (CLD O � `C 0 CD O qq O (D p O f6D CD -h ;S :.D O CD P �QyO CODCD OCD cncn Yl O CD O O Un "-hO UQ o 'Y CL O CD 1;0 .o CD w 1;0 w p N N N N ZD e -r• L� I,< �• � p- o CD � U] �G o' CD a cn �o U C n 0 0 0c p t p 2 CO)� (i o 0 0 IQLnp o ~, n Q\ cn' cr p N N CD C ti CD 00 00 O CL ^ rn CD Cl. 0 0 rn w .p w z 0 N o-' : ih c � ", M C) � I W z 7� c� N CD CD 0 CD O p 0 ,.. �,, o o o' ro ° ao v4 n p CD 0 CD oCD CD o o o a, CD O CD 0 �. �• CCD n ' (gyp —P r�T CCD � G � p `C � � r~-� v ' CL n CD o oCD n 0. o a cn O p+ G. `C '�U' n .S CD cn cn �. CCDM � CD CD p � n `L7 G CD O Y A' C ,� N a C O C•� C `C (rq o p A CD 0 (D "— O o p O CP, r -Z O 3 ID Ln CD -t ° a ° CD rn S c. (D Gn CD 'Cl CCDD b CD p (� r -h CL ri .°� r+ O O yr r .°�unCD CD tz RD p 0 CD (DCD CD ACD CD --h 00 cn `C �O 0 Oa C CD ❑FD (CLD O � `C 0 CD O qq O (D p O f6D CD -h ;S :.D O CD P �QyO CODCD OCD cncn Yl O CD O O Un "-hO UQ o 'Y CL O CD 1;0 .o CD w 1;0 w p N N N N ZD e -r• L� I,< �• � p- o CD � � o• �G o' CD a cn �o U C o' 0 0 0c p t p 2 CO)� (i o 0 0 IQLnp o ~, n cn' cr p CD C ti CD �. CL •J CD Cl. N o-' : ih c � ", M C) � I W z 7� c� N CD CD 0 CD O p 0 ,.. �,, o o o' ro ° ao v4 n p CD 0 CD oCD CD o o o a, CD O CD 0 �. �• CCD n ' (gyp —P r�T CCD � G � p `C � � r~-� v ' CL n CD o oCD n 0. o a cn O p+ G. `C '�U' n .S CD cn cn �. CCDM � CD CD p � n `L7 G CD O Y A' C ,� N a C O C•� C `C (rq o p A CD 0 (D "— O o p O CP, r -Z O 3 ID Ln CD -t ° a ° CD rn S c. (D Gn CD 'Cl CCDD b CD p (� r -h CL ri .°� r+ O O yr r .°�unCD CD tz RD p 0 CD (DCD CD ACD CD --h 00 cn `C �O 0 Oa C CD ❑FD (CLD O � `C 0 CD O qq O (D p O f6D CD -h ;S :.D O CD P �QyO CODCD OCD cncn Yl O CD O O Un "-hO UQ o 'Y CL O CD 1;0 .o CD w 1;0 w p N N N N ZD e -r• L� I,< 0 o\ O O C)I\ � �-+ pp r- d y '7 rn rn rn 0 0 01) rn 061 N �l W W a. 0 O 01 C� a� CD a o a CD CD o O O C)I\ � �-+ pp r- d y '7 o �4qz o y Ei' CD o Y a. 0 a- a' ° D uro 5: CD 0 CD 0 �' a a� CD a o a CD CD o ° r* CD o o CD ru a. cD W. CD r° ara r+= � -1 � � 0 0 CD CD ° 0 CD CD CD 00 �. R- as o b ° oo A. as o' a o rD a. -ciy 0 �4qz o y Ei' CD o Y a. 0 a- a' ° D uro 5: CD 0 CD 0 �' a a� CD a En o Cl,a P'. •• CD a. 0 o o CD a. cD 0 UQa✓ a' r° ara r+= � -1 � � � ° � 0 0 CD ° 0 CD CD CD 00 �. R- as o b ° oo A. as o' a o N 0 CD CD 11 CD pCD ° Z) � �Z' o ("Do o' W �. ° cD ° c m o ... ° ° " r- ° ro SCD° (aD CD ° N n' -' " N (� (D R CD O P), cn - CD CD �. 5 � � dG CD S=0 p � O R- � Uq (DCD (aD m 0 (gyp (D CD, n O ° Ca. CDCD p. CD a ::r G o � N G R n " (D r. ° a ° a a m oCD �' o a �, ID R �.o CD p ro moo °aa CD CMI O (D (D h0 -n W � W N N N N N ~ N N N N N fD �yr'. � w M ° n • w ° O CD ° R �n o-.• �G : n 0 . i w o CD �* Ot R rL C P CD Q Grr O CD O -t Cp O N p, < R I Nn CD CD C w C. ° CDD m i w� o' y' v CD G yiO .� (� O i p a O O cn ?rCD o 0C COP <. M G p G co Oi fD f7 p CD o o C N CD O C �' y �j A" w ^ O N N fn rt G' ra. N K M .CD o w w CD FD rL t:r CPG o o�^ �Tl m t) n to a bs „ Y ro�'� 5 b r O o "'o P•�p a� ° ° D O O O Cr O o CD rO(p C', -e N n w Na D � gA. v P. �CD IQ w — rL �rL ° G � dG. - n, EAO rn �N n           7 0 a+ a+ ar a�� f5�� x��Jill, F z m P. - CD � E 0 cn 2 � tz CD ƒ 0 0 « 1$1+ 9 + _§|■ �)� ,|f�!!�||§, ��|' |� ■! ( \ ■ � | ■ | & | l � L! U LJ r� r°� a �� aao �� a iT �G �®�pp � _ • �P � V• E 7�� � ' �� s 3 � � ;����- Y4 �� R$ g 8 - 9 g e .�q2 � z" �z83� _•�i RB 3 '�� � 4 - F� q4 �' zp 5�� �. �{ �� � � S � o �__ 3 � ` - - -- -- _�_ l S a e Em &YT- 'q_ _Z' (-e- WA 2- § 70-99 GULF STREAM CODE Metal roofs (except unpainted copper when used as a decorative accent or on minor accessory structures) Non-earthtone colors (except white), for example: blue, peach, pink, teal or yellow Primary color tiles and shingles Roll tile and similar tile styles in all districts except Place Au Soleil S=Tile in all districts except Place Au Soleil Solar panels on the streetside Unnecessarily complex or monolithic roof design All white tile other than flat cement tile (Ord. No. 00-1, § $6, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 03-9, § 2, 10-10-03) Sec. 70-100. Roof and eave heights. (a) Generally. (1) The height and number of eave. lines and the overall height of a structure play an important role in establishing visual continuity with other structures on the street and maintaining an appropriate residential/human scale. Most structures in the town are characterized by simple roof designs with low to medium eave heights and roof heights. This type of design emphasizes the horizontal dimension of the structure while minimizing the vertical dimension. (2) Roof height is measured from the top of the first finished floorto the highest exterior point on the roof. Eave height is measured from the top of the first finished floor to the top of the roof beam at the end of the beam (top of flashing). Different eave heights establish different eave lines. Two or more separate roof areas with the same eave height are considered to have the same eave line. (3) Roof features can provide appropriate design articulation to a roof area, but should be used sparingly to avoid unnecessary and undesirable complexity. Roof features include, but. are not limited to, chimneys, cupolas, decorative towers, dormers, and. small cut-outs and extensions. Two or more dormers are considered to be one roof feature, as are two or more chimneys. (4) Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival to visitors, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches (from eight feet to 12 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Three or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 20 feet or less (24 feet or less for roof features). (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet (between 12 and 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Four Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 20 and 24 feet (between 24 and 28 feet for roof features) OC, Corr. CD70:46 GULF STREAM DESIGN MANUAL § 70-100 (3) Prohibited. Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet (greater than 14 feet for entry features) Eave lines: Five or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side Roof heights: Greater than 24 feet (greater than 28 feet for roof features) (c) Two story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—From eight feet to 12 feet for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 22 feet six inches or less for two-story portions All other districts—From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions (from eight feet to 14 feet for entry features) 21 feet or less for two story portions Eave lines: Four or less Roof features: Three or less visible per building side Roof heights: 22 feet or less for one-story portions (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Between 12 and 14 feet for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 22 feet six inches and 24 feet six inches for two-story portions All other districts—Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one-story portions (between 14 and 16 feet for entry features) Between 21 feet and 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Five Roof features: Four visible per building side Roof heights: Between 22 feet and 26 feet for one-story portions (3) Prohibited. Buildings with more than two and one-half stories Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 14 feet for one-story portions Greater than 24 feet six inches for two-story portions. All other districts—Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet six inches for one-story portions Greater than 23 feet for two-story portions Eave lines: Six or more Roof features: Five or more visible per building side CD70:47 $ T ----y - ra -'r Section 66-1. Definitions. Basement shall mean that portion of a building the ,- eili g whieh is eat ebelevvgrade of less than -twee feet above gfade, which is below the finished floor elevation of the building and is located within the footprint of the first floor. A basement is not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building, unless the ceilingof f the basement is greater than three (3) feet above grade The area of the basement completely under the first floor footprint and having no outside entrance shall be included as 75% of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations. The area of the basement with an outside entrance shall be included as 100% of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations Basements shall conform to all setback regulations for structures. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the building. CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley April 20, 2012 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, APRIL 26, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. ArFNTIA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 3-22-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. No meeting in August e. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. Reorganization of ARPB. A. Swearing in of re -appointed members B. Election of Chairman C. Election of Vice Chairman VII. Items Related to Previous Approvals. A. Change of roof tile at 554 Palm Way submitted by Mark Marsh as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. James Davis. VIII. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio 2. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements IX. Items by Board Members. X. Public. XI. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, MARCH 22, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:35 A.M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Ganger called the meeting to order at Robert W. Ganger Scott Morgan Paul Lyons, Jr. Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley Thomas Smith John Randolph William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting as Board Member Alternate Member Board Member Town Attorney Town Manager Town Clerk Town Consultant III. Minutes: Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 2-23-12 & 3-2-12. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of February 23, 2012 and March 2, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. April 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Mr. Lyons reminded Clerk Taylor that he would not be available for the July 26, 2012 meeting. There were no additional conflicts. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if there were any applications for public hearing for the April meeting. Clerk Taylor said there were no applications at this time. She said there have been pre -application meetings, however, she said those applicants have not yet applied for a hearing by the Board. VI. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios introduced himself for the record. He prepared a Memorandum and a draft ordinance concerning "Zoning Code Amendments Regarding Subdivision Review, Criteria and Basement Definition" for review by Staff and the Architectural Review and Planning Board (ARPB). Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 2 1. Subdivision Review Mr. Minor summarized the recommended changes to the Criteria for Subdivision Review saying that in Criteria A, the proposed language that read . . . "within 500 feet of the subject parcel" has been eliminated. He said proposed Criteria A now reads, "Lots to be created by the proposed subdivision should be consistent with the immediate and adjacent surrounding neighborhood." Mr. Minor read amended proposed Criteria B which language now reads, "Proposed subdivisions shall protect the character of the Town by incorporating features that are compatible with, and complementary to, the preferred elements and overall character of the neighborhood district in which they are located, including but not limited to parcel size, parcel shape, access, topography, berms and buffers, and encourage the orderly and aesthetic development of the Town." Mr. Minor said the 500 -foot language was eliminated and language was added to provide clarification on what the Town is looking for when reviewing future subdivision applications. He said this type of criteria does not exist in the current Code and he is proposing the addition of the criteria to provide a basis for decisions to be made by the Town. Mr. Minor commented on proposed Criteria G, which addresses hammerheads, and reads, "Streets and vehicular use easements shall provide safe and efficient access for municipal services, such as fire, police and solid waste removal. As such, dead-end streets and easements ending in a "T" or "Y" turnaround shall not be permitted." Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Minor if other municipalities have similar language in their code. Mr. Minor confirmed that, and he said it is tied to municipal services for the safe and efficient provision of those services. He said there is a chain of logic between the Code and the Comprehensive Plan, and he said that goal is restated in the Comprehensive Plan. With regard to proposed Criteria D, Mr. Lyons asked Mr. Minor to explain the words . . . "and minimize conflicts among uses of land and buildings." Mr. Minor said if you are creating a subdivision and dividing land with existing structures on site, creating a non- conforming structure in that subdivision would be a conflict and could impact your neighbor with regard to where structures can be within that subdivision. Mr. Murphy said he noted that subdivision is a separate issue from building structures in subdivisions and he asked Mr. Minor if there is language that provides guidance when looking at the design of buildings in subdivisions. Mr. Minor said the current Code defines that you have to come back for the building of structures in a subdivision. All Members of the Board stated that they were comfortable with the proposed Criteria and amended language in the proposed Criteria as it relates to subdivisions. a. Section 66-1, Definitions Mr. Minor said there was a very interesting discussion at the previous meeting concerning basements which provided great input. He summarized the amended portion of the definition of basements which reads, "The square footage area of a basement completely under the first floor Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 3 footprint and having no outside entrance shall be included as 750 of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations. The area of a basement with an outside entrance shall be included as 1000 of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations." Mr. Minor noted that two graphics have been added which better reflect what the Code is asking for when there is a change in grade. With regard to Section 70-70, Floor Area Calculation, Mr. Minor noted that subsection (6) is amended to read, "Areas in basements shall be included as 75% when it is located completely under the first floor footprint and has no outside entrance. Areas in basements with an outside entrance shall be included at 1000." He said this is a limited situation within the Town of Gulf Stream, but he said there are cases of this and by including this language in the FAR calculations you reduce the size of the above -ground structure. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Minor if he proposes use of the graphics in the Code. Mr. Minor confirmed that and he said the Code does an excellent job of incorporating graphics to explain complicated concepts. With regard to Section 70-27, District Descriptions, subsection (c), Mr. Minor said Vice -Chairman Morgan suggested including the phrase . . . "including parcel size, parcel shape, architecture and landscaping." He said it further defines the overall character of the district and that proposed projects must incorporate design features that are compatible with that type of character. Mr. Minor said the word "character" will always be subjective when rendering a decision. All Members of the Board stated that they were comfortable with the proposed language for Section 70-70, Floor Area Calculation, and Section 70-27, District Descriptions, subsection (c) as recommended. Chairman Ganger thanked Vice -Chairman Morgan for his contributions and he thanked Marty Minor and Clerk Taylor for a great job and for providing this information saying that it was very helpful to see the language in ordinance form. He asked Clerk Taylor when this might be presented to the Commission for first reading. Clerk Taylor said if there is a motion to recommend the amendments to Code it may be presented to the Commission at their next meeting. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend that the Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream be amended as discussed, particularly at: Section 62-10, Criteria for Subdivision Review; Section 66-1, Definitions; Section 70-27, District Descriptions; and, 70-70, Floor Area Calculation. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. Chairman Ganger said he will present a short progress report at the Annual Meeting of the Civic Association which is scheduled for April 2nd to let their members know that the Town is taking action on these issues and it is a work in process. Clerk Taylor said the Commission will have an opportunity to review the minutes of this meeting and they will know where the Board is in the process. She pointed out that there Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 4 is currently zoning in progress and suggested waiting on adopting the ordinance until the process is complete and zoning in progress can be removed. b. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio This matter will be discussed at a future meeting. C. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements This matter will be discussed at a future meeting d. Section 70-4, How to Use This Manual This matter was covered in the discussion of Section 62-10 and 70-27. No further discussion or action is required. 2. Section 70-238, Roofs Mr. Thrasher said Mark Marsh is not present, but he said he invited Mr. Marsh to give his professional opinion concerning this matter at today's meeting. Mr. Lyons said he drove around Gulf Stream Rd., Polo Dr. and through Place Au Soleil where he saw some roofs with the slurry -coated tile and he said it was difficult to see a difference. He said he spoke to John Mulavey of RoofTec and found that you will not save money on maintenance with the slurry -coated tile because it requires yearly cleaning to maintain the whiteness, but he said the cost of the slurry - coated tile is about 400 less than the white flat cement thou and thou. Mr. Lyons said Mr. Mulavey stated that the manufacturing process is more expensive with the thou and thou and that there may come a time in the future when the only option will be to have the thou and thou custom made, which will make it very expensive. He said Mr. Mulavey also noted that, over time, the glossy finish flattens out due to the elements. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Murphy if he received negative comments concerning the slurry -coated tile roof in Place Au Soleil. Mr. Murphy said he has had no feedback. Chairman Ganger said that, as a Board, they have to acknowledge new technology that may bring new products and if they are similar to what is currently preferred it would be a bad idea to enforce the more expensive product. However, he said if there is a substantial difference in quality, the Board will have the authority to deny it. Chairman Ganger asked if the Code language can be drafted in such a way where the applicant must demonstrate that a different product is the same as the preferred product as far as appearance, durability, safety or any other pertinent criteria. Mr. Lyons said there are two issues, one being the appearance with respect to a flat or glossy finish, and another being the width of the tile. He said it is difficult to distinguish between the flat finish and the slurry -coated tile, except for the width, and he said the fit is different where the narrow flat finish tiles are deeper with flat sides and the larger slurry -coated tiles are more tongue in groove. Mr. Minor said the Town demands a certain quality of building materials to be used on all its projects, and that should include roof tiles. He said Staff proposes that the white flat cement thou and thou is preferable, but he said they need some direction from the Board as to what is an acceptable roof tile. Mr. Minor said both arguments have been heard and now the Board must determine the level of quality that is acceptable in the Town of Gulf Stream. Mr. Thrasher asked to go on Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 5 record saying it is true that the larger tile gives the appearance of a tongue in groove and he said if you look at it from a 45 degree angle you see a 45 degree run in that tongue in groove, which is counterproductive and conflicts with the linear concept in Gulf Stream Bermuda. He said, in his opinion, it looks a bit fake, and he said his recommendation would be to maintain the untextured, unpainted and unfinished flat thou and thou. Mr. Thrasher displayed a drawing showing the smooth lines of the Bermuda Style and said the smaller tile aligns better than the larger tile with the smooth and flowing line. Mr. Murphy asked about the possibility of the thou and thou no longer being available. Mr. Thrasher said the Board will deal with that if it happens, but he said it is available now and we have permitted three homes in the last month that are using the product. Chairman Ganger said the Town does demand quality and if there is a perception that another material appears to be of a lesser quality it would affect the judgment of the Board. He said if there is another product that is indistinguishable from what is preferred at this time, there would be no reason to deny it. Clerk Taylor commented that while the Board is discussing the type of roof tiles they will also need to discuss color. She said existing Code says either white untextured, gray slate or slate -like. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved to retain Section 70-238 on Roofs and not change the color and texture of the roof tile as described in that section. Mr. Thrasher said the Board must discuss slate -like and other coloring of tiles as a part of this recommendation. He said there is proposed language which was discussed at a previous meeting that may amend this Section of the Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan struck his motion. Mrs. Jones suggested retaining white or slate and eliminating "slate - style." Chairman Ganger said the Board will soon be looking at proposals for six new homes which will be situated in one area, and he said we must establish quality standards. Mr. Murphy moved and Vice - Chairman Morgan seconded to recommend that Section 70-238, Roofs, (a) Required, at Page CD70:93 be amended to read as follows: Required. Flat, white thou and thou, smooth, un -coated tile, except that gray slate, may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences, subject to Level II approval. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. The meeting was recessed at 9:25 A.M. and reconvened at 9:30 A.M. 3. Section 70-100, Roof & Eave Heights Mr. Thrasher said he feels the language is insufficient in this Section of the Code in defining preferred, discouraged and prohibited height of the entry feature. He said when defining "Preferred" it is not clear as to what the phrase in parenthesis . . . "(from 8 feet to 14 feet for entry feature)" specifically refers to. Mr. Thrasher said this concept was introduced to try to maintain a low profile front feature and to avoid a Boca look. He referred to the example drawing saying this was an application brought to the Town, and he said it was argued that it Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 6 meets Code and that the eave height of entry feature was at an acceptable or discouraged level. Mr. Thrasher said the first thing you notice about this house is the entry feature and the height of that roof. He said the overall height of the entry feature should be controlled by the heights in the parenthesis, not just the eave height. In previous applications the Town was successful in requiring that the overall height of that entry feature was from the finished floor to the very top elevation of whatever element was up there, and he said if this language concentrates only on eave heights an application could potentially be approved and end up with the look of this south elevation example, which we do not want in entry features. Mr. Thrasher said this looked wrong to Staff and we tried to convince the applicant to consider changing it to see what it would look like and they refused. He said it was sent to Mr. Minor for his assistance and with his interpretation of the Code it could not be prohibited, however, he said the applicant did not come back. Mr. Thrasher said if we want to control the entry height from finished floor to the very peak of what is up there the language must be changed to address that. Chairman Ganger said the proposed changes are consistent with the information and background provided by Staff and he asked the Board if they are comfortable with what is recommended. Mr. Thrasher said he has been successful interpreting the Code because the entry feature is controlled by the heights in parenthesis. Mr. Minor said it needs clarification and the recommended change clarifies this as looking at the entire feature and not just the eave height. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend changes to Section 70-100, Roof and eave heights as follows: Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable or other such elements. Height: Preferred, from eight feet to 14 feet; Discouraged, from 14 feet to 16 feet; Prohibited, greater than 16 feet. Clerk Taylor asked if the same issue should be addressed with regard tc two-story structures. Mr. Minor said the same text in parenthesis appears where the Code addresses two-story structures. Mr. Thrasher asked for confirmation from either Mr. Minor or Clerk Taylor that the same language appears for both single -story and two-story structures when addressing the entry feature. Mr. Minor said breaking it out and pulling the language out of the eave height category shown in parenthesis for both one and two-story structures will provide clarification. Chairman Ganger noted that the motion pluralized "elements" and asked if there are other elements that would add height. Mr. Minor said he could not think of anything else. Staff and Members of the Board agreed that "elements" will remain plural and that the language in parenthesis addressing entry features under eave heights shall be removed. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. 4. Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures Mr. Thrasher said the recommendation is that the only addition to Section 70-51, Minor Accessory Structures, is the word "Waterfalls." Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 7 Mr. Murphy moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to recommend amending Section 70-51, Minor accessory structures (2) at Page CD70:24, In -ground swimming pools and spas to read: "In -ground swimming pools, spas and waterfalls." There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 5. Section 66-367, Swimming Pools Chairman Ganger asked if there are a lot of requests for grottos and Mr. Thrasher said no. He said they are very nice and a great thing for kids, but they do not fit in with Gulf Stream standards. Chairman Ganger asked if the 4 -foot height limit on waterfalls is a safety issue or an aesthetic issue. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he agrees with the 4 - foot height limit, but he said he was not sure about screening. Mr. Thrasher said the main focus is on height. Mr. Lyons asked if the sound from a waterfall would be a concern. Clerk Taylor said there is a section in the Code relating to fountains requiring they be turned off by a certain time and Mr. Thrasher said the minor accessory setbacks should be sufficient. With regard to paragraph (k), Chairman Ganger suggested that screening will be eliminated and there will be a period after the word "property." Mr. Stanley asked if a height is required on a grotto. Mr. Thrasher asked Clerk Taylor if a grotto is described in definitions and Clerk Taylor said it is not. Mr. Thrasher said the Code defines a structure as that which requires assembly, and he said a grotto would be a formation of rocks which would require assembly and would be prohibited. Mr. Minor said this would fall under minor accessory structures. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend amending Section 66-367, Swimming Pools by adding the following paragraphs: (j) No grotto shall be permitted in any zoning district. A grotto shall be considered an artificial structure or excavation made to look like a cave or cavern; and, (k) Waterfalls, minor accessory structures, shall not exceed 4' in height as measured from the average finished grade of the property. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 6. Section 66-369, Docks Mr. Thrasher said concrete docks have been allowed because it was not clear if the language in the Code prohibited them. He asked Mr. Minor if other municipalities control type of docks. Mr. Minor said the material is not typically controlled, but he said fake wood is usually prohibited. Mr. Stanley asked about concrete spun piles, which are concrete piles. He said spun pilings are not as warm -looking as wood pilings and they do not have the texture, but they are more durable. Mr. Thrasher said concrete docks look terrible when they are deteriorating and it is more expensive to remove them, and he said that wood docks and pilings should be required. Mrs. Jones asked about floating docks. Clerk Taylor said there is a State Law which prohibits the Town from not allowing them. Vice -Chairman Morgan said as pilings and dolphins deteriorate they are sheathed with concrete below the waterline to preserve them and he said the proposed language would prohibit that. However, he said you would not see the sheathing and it probably would not be applied for. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend amending Section 66-369, Docks (7) Materials and colors, at Page CD66:71 to read: "All docks and pilings will be made from wood." There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - March 22, 2012 Page 8 VII. Items by Board Members. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Minor to update the Board on the changes to the Comp Plan. Mr. Minor said the changes were submitted to the the State and to the Treasure Coast Advisory Board and the comments have come back. He said there was one minor comment from South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) and, as they requested, he has made the changes to the water supply plan, which is a part of the Comp Plan. Mr. Minor explained that since Boynton Beach supplies the water to the annexed area, SFWMD wanted Boynton Beach to be better referenced in the water supply plan. He said he has supplied revised copies of the Comp Plan to Staff for the Commission to take up at their meeting. Chairman Ganger asked when the Comp Plan will go into effect if the Commission has no objections. Mr. Minor said if there are no objecttions there will be a 45 -day period and then the Comp Plan could go into effect either by late Spring or early Summer. Clerk Taylor distributed material to the Board which was submitted by Mr. Minor and will be on the Agenda for their next ARPB Meeting. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Minor to explain what their assignment is. Mr. Minor said that, based on the Code, his office has provided a visual look of what is permitted and what the existing FAR regulations provide for in both one and two-story structures in each of the single family zoning districts. He said the Board should look at possible alternatives and he will create a visual so that we can begin discussing whether or not they are appropriate for Gulf Stream. Mr. Minor said there are items on the cover of his material which were previously discussed that could provide revisions and encouragements for good design, such as where the Delray Beach Property Owners' Association allows an additional area of lot coverage if a second story is brought back 5 feet. Clerk Taylor said the purpose of this information is for the Board to determine whether or not our FAR is sufficient as it stands to address the issue of boxyness, and she said Mr. Minor has provided alternatives that the Board may want to consider. Mr. Minor said if the Board eventually recommends changes they will be able to show what is currently allowed and what is proposed, and he said it is easier to grasp when you provide a visual. Mr. Minor suggested that the Board study the material and decide whether they find the alternatives acceptable, too restrictive or not restrictive enough. Chairman Ganger said he would like to have Tom Smith in attendance when this matter is discussed because he suggested addressing boxyness in our FAR. VIII. Public. There were no items by the Public. IX. Adjournment. Chairman Ganger adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:20 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF THURSDAY, MAY 24, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA May 17, 2012 HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 4-26-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. No meeting in August d. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. f. November to be determined g. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by James F. & Pamela Landquist, owners of the property located at 800 Tangerine Way, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 16, Place Au Soleil Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit a 155 sq. ft. garage addition to the existing 396 sq. ft. garage that encroaches 7.8 ft. into the required 20 ft. rear setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit a 155 sq. ft. garage addition to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda Style single family dwelling. 2. An application submitted by John & Elisabeth Woolley, owners of property located at 935 Orchid Lane, legally described as Lot 88, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream Florida. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the replacement of existing broken, awning type windows in all existing openings visible from the street with triple horizontal sliders. The sliders will have impact glass set in white frames. B. Ordinances 1. No. 12/2; AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH, COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE TOWN'S ZONING MAP TO REZONE 12 PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING APPROXIMATELY 16.6 ACRES, MORE OR LESS, IN SIZE; SUCH REAL PROPERTY IS LOCATED GENERALLY EAST AND WEST OF STATE ROAD AlA, SOUTH OF LITTLE CLUB ROAD AND NORTH OF SEA ROAD; FROM THE PALM BEACH COUNMTY DESIGNATION AGENDA CONTINUED OF RM -MULTIPLE -FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (MEDIUM DENSITY) TO THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM ZONING DESIGNATION OF "RM" (MULTIPLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT); PROVIDING THAT THE TOWN ZONING DISTRICT MAP BE REVISED ACCORDINGLY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT HEREOF; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. 2. NO. 12/3; AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE TOWN'S CODE OF ORDINANCES, AT SECTION 71-1, TO INCLUDE NEWLY -ANNEXED PROPERTIES UNDER THE RM -EAST AND RM -WEST ZONING DESIGNATIONS; AMENDING, AT SECTION 66-131, THE NON- CONFORMING USE REGULATIONS TO ADDRESS STRUCTURES WITH A NON -CONFORMING DENSITY; ADDING SECTION 71-8, ADDITIONS AND REHABILITATIONS, TO INCLUDE REFERENCE TO STANDARDS FOR ADDITIONS AND REHABILITATION OF MULTI -FAMILY BUILDINGS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. VII. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio (continued from 4-26-12) VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, APRIL 26, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I II Call to Order. Chairman Ganger called to order at 8:30 A.M. Roll Call. Present and Robert W. Ganger Participating Scott Morgan Paul Lyons, Jr. Malcolm Murphy Tom Smith Thomas M. Stanley Absent w/Notice Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Also Present and William H. Thrasher Participating Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Mark Marsh, Bridges, & Assoc. Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting as Board Member Board Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent/Davis Town Consultant III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 3-22-12. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of March 23, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. May 24, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. No meeting in August e. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Ganger asked the Board Members if there were any conflicts in the meeting schedule. Vice -Chairman Morgan stated that he would not be available for the May 24th meeting. Mr. Lyons stated that he would not be available for the July 26th meeting. Chairman Ganger said he is hoping that, at the end of this meeting, the Board will have concluded the re -writing of the ordinances and that it will go to the Commission for 1st reading at their May 11th meeting. Clerk Taylor said the ARPB recommendations will go to the Commission, but they will not be in ordinance form. She said one ordinance is prepared and is sufficient; however, she said it was decided to hold the ordinance until the process is complete. Chairman Ganger said he will assume that 1st and 2nd readings will have been done by the Fall. Chairman Ganger said the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - April 26, 2012 Page 2 public is very interested in what the ARPB is doing to make changes in the Code and they feel it has taken a long time. Clerk Taylor said the public will have to understand that these things take time. Chairman Ganger said it would be to the public's benefit to attend the meetings. VI. Reorganization of ARPB. A. Swearing in of re -appointed members Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to Robert W. Tom Smith who were re -appointed to the ARPB for B. Election of Chairman Mr. Morgan moved and Mr. Lyons seconded t Chairman. There was no discussion. All C. Election of Vice Chairman Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to Chairman. There was no discussion. All Ganger, Scott Morgan and another 3 -year term. o nominate Robert W. Ganger as voted AYE. nominate Scott Morgan as Vice - voted AYE. VII. Items Related to Previous Approvals. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to Mark Marsh, Agent for Davis, and to James Davis, property owner. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor to go through the timeline concerning this matter. Clerk Taylor said this project was first presented to the ARPB one year ago this month and, at that time, the ARPB recommended approval with the condition of a "grey roof." She said the project and ARPB recommendations were presented to the Commission in May of 2011 and the Commission approved the ARPB recommendations, with the exception of the roof tile. Clerk Taylor said the Commission asked to see a roof tile sample and then Mr. Marsh distributed photos of similar roofs, including a photo of the Ocean Ridge Town Hall. She said the Commission approved the roof tile with the condition that they see a sample of the roof tile material, but she said nothing happened until recently. Clerk Taylor said Mr. Marsh came back to the ARPB on January 26th with changes to the design of the house, there was no discussion with regard to the roof material, but she said the commitment was made that the ARPB would need to review any revisions. Mark Marsh said he would come back to ARPB with an actual roof tile sample which he said would be closer to the Ocean Ridge Town Hall roof tile. Clerk Taylor said the ARPB's Motion stipulated that the adjustment of color and texture of the roof tile was to come back to the ARPB for approval, which is what Mr. Marsh will present today. However, Clerk Taylor said, as result of the Commission asking to see the tile one year ago, the ARPB will be able to make their recommendations today for the Commission to consider at the May 11th meeting. Chairman Ganger asked if there has been any ex -parte communication. He said he drove by the Davis property this morning. There were no other declarations of ex -parte communication. A. Change of roof tile at 554 Palm Way submitted by Mark Marsh as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. James Davis. Mark Marsh said he initially presented a tile that had a bit of a glaze and he is now proposing a smaller tile with a matt finish. He said the architectural style of the home is Cape Dutch which typically features a white exterior with a dark grey roof. Mr. Marsh displayed the smaller Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - April 26, 2012 Page 3 tile with a matt finish, the color of which is called natural slate and he said it is equal or superior to the other white tile. He said you will not see much of the roof because of the pitch. Mr. Marsh said the tile on Ocean Ridge Town Hall is a blend of black, grey and white and the Entegra tile he is proposing is a solid color. He said he would like to encourage diversity and the architectural style merits contrast. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Marsh about the color of the shutters. Mr. Marsh said they will be gun metal grey. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that he likes the roof tile and agrees that the architectural style warrants contrast. Mr. Smith also commented that he likes the roof tile more than the previous tile proposed. Chairman Ganger reminded the Board Members that at the last meeting the Board made the decision that roof tile must be white or slate, not slate -like. He said the minutes from that meeting state that roof tile shall be flat, white thou and thou, smooth, un -coated tile, except that gray slate may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences. The Town Clerk advised that this provision was only applied to Section 70-238. It was suggested to revisit the Code changes and possibly build the Cape Dutch architectural style into the Code. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the gray roof should be limited to this architectural style with the white exterior. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend approval of the proposed solid through and through dark cement tile. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. VIII. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio Mr. Minor reminded that there has been a concern with houses appearing to be more "box -like". He further reminded that in discussions of FAR Calculations, attention had been given to adding more visual interest to the design. In so doing, porches, balconies, etc. that were roofed but not enclosed were included in the FAR calculation. In addition, this would limit the size of homes. The result has been that this interest and the required 25% reduction of the size of the 2nd floor as compared to the size of the lst floor, for the most part, is being concentrated in one area, often the rear, which adds to a box -like appearance. He then explained 4 options to possibly improve the design. These are: Eliminate porches, patios, balconies and arcades from the FAR calculations up to 400 square feet. Allow additional FAR for the lot if the second story of the home is set back a minimum of 10 feet from the front setback line. We have provided three options for the increase in FAR for this second story setback for the ARPB's consideration. Limit the second floor area of homes to be .75 of the first floor area in all single family zoning districts. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - April 26, 2012 Page 4 Allow front porches and balconies to extend within front setback. With regard to Option 1, there was no vote but it was thought that the current provision which allows an additional 300 square feet through a Special Exception better fits with regard to open porches etc. due to the accompanying deed restriction that prevents the open, roofed areas from being enclosed. It was unanimously voted to provide the suggested incentive FAR in Option 2 by adding 5% allowable FAR to the portion of square footage of the lot over the first 20,000 sq. ft provided the 2nd floor was setback an additional 10' from the front property line. The motion was made by Mr. Lyons and seconded by Mr. Morgan. It was felt this may help to reduce the box -like appearance of the structure. With regard to Option 3, it was moved by Mr. Morgan and seconded by Mr. Lyons that the current 75% reduction of the 2nd floor be further reduced to 700 of the 1st floor area in all single family districts to also address the problem of a box -like appearance. No vote was taken but the discussion indicated the members favored this change. There was very little discussion on Option 4 and it is expected this along with all of the other options will be further discussed at the next meeting. Chairman Ganger observed that most of the options are incentive driven which may not solve the box -like appearance. He ask Mr. Minor if he could offer any additional solutions for consideration after hearing this discussion. He added that he did not believe the Town is interested in adding strict mandatory provisions. Mr. Minor replied that he may be able to offer a few more suggestions for consideration at the next meeting. 2. Section 70-68, Lot Size & Dimensional Requirements There were no recommendations to change this section. IX. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Board Members. X. Public. There were no items by the Public. XI. Adjournment. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to adjourn the meeting. There was no discussion. The meeting was adjourned at approximately 10:25 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-04 Address: 800 Tangerine Way Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: James F & Pamela Landquist Agent: Self Garage addition Special Exception: To permit a 155 SF garage addition to the existing 396 SF garage that encroaches 7.8 feet into the required 20 feet required setback. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Gross Lot size: 14,375 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 3,336 SF Zoning District: RS -P Finished Floor: N/A Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks To permit a 155 SF garage addition to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling. Effective Lot Area: 14,375 SF Allowable: 4,744 Height: 13.5' Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks (c) Additions to structures with existing nonconforming setbacks. Note: Application appears to meet the standards for approval. Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Motion to recommend approval for a Special Exception to permit a 155 SF garage addition to the existing 396 SF garage that encroaches 7.8 feet into the required 20 feet required setback. Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed 155 SF garage addition to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: May 24, 2012 Action: Special Exception: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested (4-0) TC Date: June 8, 2012 Action: Special Exception Approved as requested & recommended. (4-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as requested and recommended including proposed landscaping. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM o,RECE Vr, D,4o APP 16 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # ) — To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: kAkE9 4:-1 L ISN 00 U t S'T i-(V/� P1kECA Lt} N/JQJI ST I.A.2. Project Address: 800 TfIi+V It,/ IF WA y 61)t r�Tz 33il 83 I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: L d % J6, pttfcE 4u SOLE / I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.). ADD ,.q f X 19 14" •-M n 05� I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: ISS ,SGL J::�f Architectural Style: &*'TTN F-- KI mo t— 1.A.6. Check all that apply:'( Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) W Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: B. Owner Information Type of Foundation: S) -AP OH 60,•Dl, I.B.1. Owner Address: 906 T -+N6 t< 1111: - jv/7 / 6 U L jst::�- _g QfV 33 3 1.B.2. Owner Phone Number: -5-b l 76(o -776x-? Fax: ql S -97-A4-0014 1.B.3. Owner Signature: N. C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: se I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) cell Fax 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: 3 5 Y3 'A Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the a question number for each response. Please and complete A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? nil P 5 _ 10 III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? VYes ❑ No Explain. Co III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? ;'Yes ❑ No Explain, III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? i1?�e A) ]:)j.AUt� III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage Alk - b. Sanitary Sewer _XiS"Tin1W c. Potable Water d. Irrigation Water e. Electricity 1E,-1 111p N61 f. Telephone Ko t g. Gas h. Cable Television rx/S`1"/ III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the projecti volve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes 1VNo (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes N(No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes 9,'No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. D es the project require approval of a Special Exception? ;'Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the prof ct at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes XNo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1, Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? �6e1 ❑ No Code Section: --5 c IV.E,2. How is the use designed, located and 7 proposed to be operated so that the Public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? IV.E,3. Will the use cause subst ntial in'u be located? ❑ Yes k o rY to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. '"LAAi LL- 11J C 1 'J _ Ali �A !7 IV.E.4. J-fU,, How will the use be com � Off% is to be located? Patible with adjoining development and thecharacter of the Dis whet d- 0'�S —� � ItJ 11-i JAL �FPu�r cv��EsT�c� �nA :7 A.i 2 (d a ------------ IV.E.5. What landscaping P g and screening are provided? 5 E LA-Woscrd N6 PLA -KA � P2clt bib IV.E.6, Does the u applicable regulations governing located? j(YeS 1:1 No conform with all the District wherein it is to be Explain. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the i I AY are to be maintained. IV.F,2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their Potential acts properties. enial im p on surrounding NIA_ ------------- IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: NJ� Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 991J ppn, WN - in Dr�*Izzcnc�—F con 0z F� ---1�j0F�` 0mma`"vr� %zrOzmmOcno=r-c)oinz=zcmwilo,rnTWTA,=Z :U��'D �Dwl ZD�-O Z0mr-(n Zmo -0�N r�* `� m O = 41 cn 1m Y)OM0z-00 r—tT, z0-1r'm �Om•o= M zooz0 Z -<mm OODn�'D90O�5�=� '�UFo2=moinmm 0 00M �7 mcnzn�MOOmmz-d �mo�Azoo>�Q z<Z��mmcmCO --, NmX M o0z" (7)>- Rozo_M-+ m -Ommmrr a�vm �on �Ln 0Nomommrnnmmo jr�r7<KM-2A*IA-M> .ZO7 Z D D r0T1 m'1 o riT o o0 z< ZrnyN XrZl AL otm*laa'm=z6 mW22r5* MRFrAr MOD cn<, ,z=m0IO- rrz m200 X(mnz.MMCm OFZoD.-jmxOW Am000momzZO nao_onm zm Zj�zo T-Tcr$1Aom �ZoD momm w moNFa-T nzOzm mz vlm' n;D Z -i -O--{{ zw wOm MDzrel --i{ M o )o Nm0 z -N1;. O n n o �7 V1 � Zm>m mnm o'l o -F z -0D z F � o z Nco= j rn rn z m A rT-u N M c DCO C � �n 0 O 2 0 0 —1 r r rTl z E!2222 Smm Z) 0 �oozMS r-�>Dc>mzz NDm�00 <��° s UluMoo o D � Jl r,in z m +■e�� 0 ri+t r o�>r� �GYt1a�- D ul Q IAb �4 :M to v7 'pt. UlC- ti. S N ti x' D in ti o n,X Sru KS rn .r. zL)0m"P vJIQ x oOco 4 Qo <m r� Mlmmi c m o o ; D I I I I I I I to I I I I I I I I I I, I I I I d I I III AVENUE AU SOLEIL "!1 �DOrr�--0r Fn coxfT71 �w rain � n.Z�lm ov'*i Ooo-p O ;u �rnazP) r 1 "•� a P o rc' m i it Q m EON?1 m�mDtT�1 z0 0 00�a �o>om mm ti mcrnoZrn o � ::i a m � _M(n K �4"mCC7 o, a -u0M �� G m.i> O r7C _u 3-1N rlO �'I r*+C_7 Q N O O � Z oa mm f Z -: � cn fOTI Z �o�N� m o W- v Z Z { m m z -- t00 D mD Z i m > Oo C4 C T O < MP41 r-C)mD MO O m Z _. r c m C4 D A� M o o C y N m z' O z �% z Z �� Z()5�8 0 0 m C7 0 Z m jo c Z 6 m O N y -1 mHA b C C/) --i o C TT J D zr-Q •' , Z � m a�Ccco y U r vm 111 C) h z y D y - —� a 9 ° ~� ma a ul a o OD 00 m !�2000 le l'j ,I N III AVENUE AU SOLEIL "!1 �DOrr�--0r Fn coxfT71 �w rain � n.Z�lm ov'*i Ooo-p O ;u �rnazP) r D :l7 --NI_a: m— "•� a P o rc' m i it Q m EON?1 m�mDtT�1 z0 LnDI--'{l 00�a �o>om mm ti I to Dr>-=C,D� _M(n K �4"mCC7 o, a -u0M �� G m.i> O r7C _u 3-1N rlO �'I r*+C_7 Q N O O � �_ f Z -: � cn fOTI Z �o�N� m o W- o M W 0 -- t00 D mD Z i m > Oo C4 MP41 r-C)mD MO O m Z _. r cO m C4 �jT`p C y N z' O z �% r O En n Z A Z()5�8 0 0 m C7 0 Z m jo c 6 mon a O N y -1 mHA O Z o D zr-Q \ m a�Ccco y C h mO z 0 y D y D�Do =�0Z ° ~� ma a a o OD r* -j �z G) m Tu Z m ti 7� Mp--u Q � hr W� 6 C, h D O � x r m Cn m O m O 0 00 D D m m a N N M rn O m 00 QSS�"o OOA QQQ� A Q Q O o SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) FL STATE REG " 33138 0 SOO TANGERINE WAY A19D CERTIFIED PROFESSONAL ®U'LER DNG DESIGN CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR 13938 CRANBERRY COURT WELLINGTON, FLORIDA FD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA IOWNER f"A N N N N N ZZb0NDr0-4ZZZm N 1> y Z�pZG�G�G� N r_- m D Up ODmuTTj uo 000 iN m M N z< A D G% D<< U<AmG�A D AA pA<A0 X0xM F- 1 mm 0D< U n Dm0D m }�irtl m*DA< m -0 -0 v m b n Lo EA D °° z D r O ,` IV D N (� z D -4 b D o E m O o N z z W w U O O r D N A tw 7AC N Am O�� Ld N 0 DD O N D p t� N N N �^Dp D° pDD� Y ° mN Apa O snN O 68 6C ....._1. N1. -----� r -- ------- — ---- I 0 9 v k' m _ Is I I z I �: I I \ Zt \ �:m -. M Ir � XYZ r� f� O U A O G% (p Z Z N d f V 71 r D X �n O A0 t 7DpN e mz O m Z z f _. i — 4 "i1 O oo 0 tv m �s ,:y j 3 r w N r � V/ O � x r m Cn m O m O 0 00 D D m m a N N M rn O m D z < m us r o SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) FL STATE REG " 33138 0 PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: JAMES LANDQUIST 4 PRECISION DRAFTING AND DESIGN INC 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOTNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33476 STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: NORTH COUNTY ( 861 ) 733-0669 W. ERIK GENZ PAMELA LANDQUIST SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) FL STATE REG " 33138 SOO TANGERINE WAY A19D CERTIFIED PROFESSONAL ®U'LER DNG DESIGN CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR 13938 CRANBERRY COURT WELLINGTON, FLORIDA FD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA IOWNER NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING / DESIGNER B. DAVID FRANK o 0 X m (< I i A#'j ___. r=, � ro 1 ?�ti �E R, ti C a OY Niii yr{s (561) 772619 1� MARK J. HENEGAN ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT A71 ROYAL IALM exACR 6L�D • F. lALM �AC99 •FLORIDA 11111 I►'�a4v,�L�iu gpany R' -4; 9 irml 19" $ �'I aacz � 3� 77�RRtl $gig s a^9� }ilr� €�fa Ij(g ' 3�0 , ss �7 A € d �m ld.�� jla(s�' a 59 �ge 6 = � Yx fig ;��giHIM a 'd. =I�a�fl a s gaz9 a i g�9 `a 8 s _3 8 f.lEe� �• It I �� a F�= �� �� � ��a���P•- i� anti �� � ii�� s;� ��� @RF �,•; � a 9 € 3 � � ➢� T9R 3Pfi��& � ¢�^ � � 2 a<.. A g9i �2 •s 5 tl�$ 33 _ a L QR R 8 E§� g xs i��" ; z E 3x�g� � ;� 3� � �•• 9� s a i � � II g ��itA E €x f €� F � € a@��� 93 �3 '€• = F �. A f � �33� 5 5�9�8 �€ A' jj z i- z xaxs�l B a �e s �a 9 �r f 5.i 3d F 90o T�+r'�+iKwe 1 r O ye• TA -4 .r 4UJQ Favi LAW• R c�aeh V.Aft PLM4 n SCALE REVISION NORTH OC) o n rn N o � r ev Co) f I►'�a4v,�L�iu gpany R' -4; 9 irml 19" $ �'I aacz � 3� 77�RRtl $gig s a^9� }ilr� €�fa Ij(g ' 3�0 , ss �7 A € d �m ld.�� jla(s�' a 59 �ge 6 = � Yx fig ;��giHIM a 'd. =I�a�fl a s gaz9 a i g�9 `a 8 s _3 8 f.lEe� �• It I �� a F�= �� �� � ��a���P•- i� anti �� � ii�� s;� ��� @RF �,•; � a 9 € 3 � � ➢� T9R 3Pfi��& � ¢�^ � � 2 a<.. A g9i �2 •s 5 tl�$ 33 _ a L QR R 8 E§� g xs i��" ; z E 3x�g� � ;� 3� � �•• 9� s a i � � II g ��itA E €x f €� F � € a@��� 93 �3 '€• = F �. A f � �33� 5 5�9�8 �€ A' jj z i- z xaxs�l B a �e s �a 9 �r f 5.i 3d F 90o T�+r'�+iKwe 1 r O ye• TA -4 .r 4UJQ Favi LAW• R c�aeh V.Aft PLM4 n SCALE REVISION NORTH MIN t5l z.F �;,N g w m f r sZ ,d — W- — — A ! Al QRS I� r - i, 7. i[3 E( ■es �i� � � R✓3�FY�Y. ygk ^ g3 38 G 4 r y k ._l s qIM EE asz IRMULUT� a E.,1, F ;$ �� SM 11��Z ��z 9a s a R� g� " � •3�g AFrt ��xa cp^� g -� p� 3"� �j FRS gA� � ,�� 3 € WIM3 :?z€ H aF $4a A y^Hill P ifg ai= BE �a a .�g �a� By; 3. fit. x 2• =x 5 � c@ g' � ,�. �. i AmLs O o �a (561) 796-2618 OWNT &Dj W.W- v x -tom r 4AXPRRMI -gzvejph a ?� SCALE N MARK J. HENEGAN • ECT � LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 11W,14ATOt4 PL� r lV OM..'Al 1. BEAC1{ BLVD • W. PALM BEAC11 = RARIDA 11117 REVISION NOIa'Tl-1 ? � 9 tpq� a ! Al QRS I� r - i, 7. i[3 E( ■es �i� � � R✓3�FY�Y. ygk ^ g3 38 G 4 r y k ._l s qIM EE asz IRMULUT� a E.,1, F ;$ �� SM 11��Z ��z 9a s a R� g� " � •3�g AFrt ��xa cp^� g -� p� 3"� �j FRS gA� � ,�� 3 € WIM3 :?z€ H aF $4a A y^Hill P ifg ai= BE �a a .�g �a� By; 3. fit. x 2• =x 5 � c@ g' � ,�. �. i AmLs O o �a (561) 796-2618 OWNT &Dj W.W- v x -tom r 4AXPRRMI -gzvejph a ?� SCALE N MARK J. HENEGAN • ECT � LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 11W,14ATOt4 PL� r lV OM..'Al 1. BEAC1{ BLVD • W. PALM BEAC11 = RARIDA 11117 REVISION NOIa'Tl-1 ORDINANCE NO. 12/2 AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE TOWN'S ZONING MAP TO REZONE 12 PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING APPROXIMATELY 16.6 ACRES, MORE OR LESS, IN SIZE; SUCH REAL PROPERTY BEING LOCATED GENERALLY EAST AND WEST OF STATE ROAD AIA, SOUTH OF LITTLE CLUB ROAD AND NORTH OF SEA ROAD AS IDENTIFIED ON ATTACHED EXHIBIT "A"; FROM THE PALM BEACH COUNTY DESIGNATION OF RM -MULTIPLE -FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (MEDIUM DENSITY) TO THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM ZONING DESIGNATION OF "RM" (MULTIPLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT); PROVIDING THAT THE TOWN ZONING DISTRICT MAP BE REVISED ACCORDINGLY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT HEREOF; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Town, through referendum, annexed 12 properties consisting of 16.6 acres, more or less, generally located south of Little Club Road, north of Sea Road and east and west of State Road A1A, on March 15, 2011. WHEREAS, the subject 16.6 acres currently has a Palm Beach County zoning designation of RM - Multiple -Family Residential (Medium Density). WHEREAS, the subject property has a Town future land use plan designation of of MF (Multi - Family). WHEREAS, the Town desires to amend its Zoning Map to designate the subject property as RM (Multiple Family Residential District), which is consistent with its future land use designation. WHEREAS, the Town Commission, upon recommendation from the Architectural Review and Planning Board, recommends amendment of the Town's Zoning District Map to reflect the rezoning. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Incorporation of Recitals. The above recitals are incorporated as fully set forth herein. Section 2. Findings. The proposed rezoning of the 12 parcels, legally -described in Exhibit "A" attached, has been determined by the Architectural Review and Planning Board and the Town Commission to be consistent with the properties' MF (Multi -Family) future land use designation. It has also been determined that the rezoning is in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations and is compatible with the intensity and density of the surrounding, existing and future land uses. Section 3. Rezoning. The 12 properties of real property located within the corporate limits of the Town of Gulf Stream, consisting of approximately 16.6 acres, more or less, in size located generally located south of Little Club Road, north of Sea Road and east and west of State Road A1A, and currently zoned Palm Beach County designation of RM -Multiple -Family Residential (Medium Density) is hereby rezoned to RM (Multiple Family Residential District). Section 4. Amendment to the Zoning Map. The Town of Gulf Stream Zoning Map is hereby amended to conform to this Ordinance, and the Town Manager is hereby authorized and directed to make appropriate changes to the zoning district map of the Town. Section 5. Severability. If any provision of this Ordinance or the application thereof is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect the other provisions or applications of this Ordinance which can be given effect without the invalid provisions or applications, and to this end the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby declared severable. Section 6. Codification. This Ordinance shall be codified and made a part of the official Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream. Section 7. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon its passage and approval, as provided by law. PASSED AND ADOPTED in a regular, adjourned session on first reading this 8th day of June , 2012, and for a second and final reading on this 13th day of July 2012. Vic Ma r �j Commissioner Comniiissioner Commissioner ATT, P—,& Town Clerk EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTION: A tract of land lying within Government Lot 2 of Section 34 Township 45 South Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida, more particularly described as follows: Beginning at the Southwest corner of said Government Lot 2, thence run northerly along the West line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 370 feet more or less to a point lying at the intersection of the West line of Government Lot 2 and a line parallel to and 2219 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2, being measured perpendicular to said North line; thence run easterly along said line parallel to and 2219 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2 a distance of 110 feet more or less to a point, said point being the Southeast corner of the parcel as described in Schedule "A" as recorded in ORB 7236, PG 1193, official records of Palm Beach County, Florida; thence run northerly along a line parallel to the West line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 300 feet more or less to a point, said point being on a line parallel to and 1919 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2, being measured perpendicular to said North line, and said point being the Northeast corner of the parcel as described in the General Warranty Deed as recorded in OR BOOK 15065, PG 1967, official records of Palm Beach County, Florida; thence run westerly along said parallel line 1919 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2 a distance of 110 feet more or less to a point on the West line of said Government Lot 2, thence run northerly along the West line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 667 feet more or less to a point of intersection with the North line of Lot 17, Benson Bros. Subdivision as recorded in PB 5, PG 27, public records of Palm Beach County, Florida; thence run easterly along the easterly projection of the North Line of said Lot 17 to the centerline of State Road A -1-A, thence run southeasterly along the centerline of State Road A -1-A a distance of 325 feet more or less to a point, said point being on a line parallel to and 1569.0 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2, being measured perpendicular to said North line; thence run easterly along said line parallel to and 1569.0 feet south of the North line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 510 feet more or less to the waters of the Atlantic Ocean; thence run southerly along the waters of the Atlantic Ocean a distance of 1010 feet more or less to the point of intersection of said waters and the South line of Government Lot 2, thence run westerly along the South line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 605 feet more or less to the point of beginning. ORDINANCE NO. 12/2 AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE TOWN'S ZONING MAP TO REZONE 12 PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING APPROXIMATELY 16.6 ACRES, MORE OR LESS, IN SIZE; SUCH REAL PROPERTY BEING LOCATED GENERALLY EAST AND WEST OF STATE ROAD AIA, SOUTH OF LITTLE CLUB ROAD AND NORTH OF SEA ROAD AS IDENTIFIED ON ATTACHED EXHIBIT "A"; FROM THE PALM BEACH COUNTY DESIGNATION OF RM -MULTIPLE -FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (MEDIUM DENSITY) TO THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM ZONING DESIGNATION OF "RM" (MULTIPLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT); PROVIDING THAT THE TOWN ZONING DISTRICT MAP BE REVISED ACCORDINGLY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT HEREOF; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Town, through referendum, annexed 12 properties consisting of 16.6 acres, more or less, generally located south of Little Club Road, north of Sea Road and east and west of State Road A1A, on March 15, 2011. WHEREAS, the subject 16.6 acres currently has a Palm Beach County zoning designation of RM - Multiple -Family Residential (Medium Density). WHEREAS, the subject property has a Town future land use plan designation of of MF (Multi - Family). WHEREAS, the Town desires to amend its Zoning Map to designate the subject property as RM (Multiple Family Residential District), which is consistent with its future land use designation. WHEREAS, the Town Commission, upon recommendation from the Architectural Review and Planning Board, recommends amendment of the Town's Zoning District Map to reflect the rezoning. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Incorporation of Recitals. The above recitals are incorporated as fully set forth herein. Section 2. Findings. The proposed rezoning of the 12 parcels, legally -described in Exhibit "A" attached, has been determined by the Architectural Review and Planning Board and the Town Commission to be consistent with the properties' MF (Multi -Family) future land use designation. It has also been determined that the rezoning is in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations and is compatible with the intensity and density of the surrounding, existing and future land uses. Section 3. Rezoning. The 12 properties of real property located within the corporate limits of the Town of Gulf Stream, consisting of approximately 16.6 acres, more or less, in size located generally located south of Little Club Road, north of Sea Road and east and west of State Road A1A, and currently zoned Palm Beach County designation of RM -Multiple -Family Residential (Medium Density) is hereby rezoned to RM (Multiple Family Residential District). Section 4. Amendment to the Zoning Map. The Town of Gulf Stream Zoning Map is hereby amended to conform to this Ordinance, and the Town Manager is hereby authorized and directed to make appropriate changes to the zoning district map of the Town. Section 5. Severability. If any provision of this Ordinance or the application thereof is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect the other provisions or applications of this Ordinance which can be given effect without the invalid provisions or applications, and to this end the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby declared severable. Section 6. Codification. This Ordinance shall be codified and made a part of the official Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream. Section 7. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon its passage and approval, as provided by law. PASSED AND ADOPTED in a regular, adjourned session on first reading this 8th day of June , 2012, and for a second and final reading on this 13th day of July 2012. Vic Ma r �j Commissioner Comniiissioner Commissioner ATT, P—,& Town Clerk EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTION: A tract of land lying within Government Lot 2 of Section 34 Township 45 South Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida, more particularly described as follows: Beginning at the Southwest corner of said Government Lot 2, thence run northerly along the West line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 370 feet more or less to a point lying at the intersection of the West line of Government Lot 2 and a line parallel to and 2219 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2, being measured perpendicular to said North line; thence run easterly along said line parallel to and 2219 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2 a distance of 110 feet more or less to a point, said point being the Southeast corner of the parcel as described in Schedule "A" as recorded in ORB 7236, PG 1193, official records of Palm Beach County, Florida; thence run northerly along a line parallel to the West line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 300 feet more or less to a point, said point being on a line parallel to and 1919 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2, being measured perpendicular to said North line, and said point being the Northeast corner of the parcel as described in the General Warranty Deed as recorded in OR BOOK 15065, PG 1967, official records of Palm Beach County, Florida; thence run westerly along said parallel line 1919 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2 a distance of 110 feet more or less to a point on the West line of said Government Lot 2, thence run northerly along the West line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 667 feet more or less to a point of intersection with the North line of Lot 17, Benson Bros. Subdivision as recorded in PB 5, PG 27, public records of Palm Beach County, Florida; thence run easterly along the easterly projection of the North Line of said Lot 17 to the centerline of State Road A -1-A, thence run southeasterly along the centerline of State Road A -1-A a distance of 325 feet more or less to a point, said point being on a line parallel to and 1569.0 feet south of the North line of said Government Lot 2, being measured perpendicular to said North line; thence run easterly along said line parallel to and 1569.0 feet south of the North line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 510 feet more or less to the waters of the Atlantic Ocean; thence run southerly along the waters of the Atlantic Ocean a distance of 1010 feet more or less to the point of intersection of said waters and the South line of Government Lot 2, thence run westerly along the South line of Government Lot 2 a distance of 605 feet more or less to the point of beginning. CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF THURSDAY, JUNE 28, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA June 22, 2012 BY THE ARCHITECTURAL STREAM, FLORIDA ON TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 5-24-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. No meeting in August C. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. November to be determined f. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Roy Simon as agent for Mr. & Mrs. Paul Lyons, Jr., owners of property located at 2945 Polo Drive, legally described as Lot 12, Gulf Stream Properties Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. VARIANCE to permit the replacement of an existing semi -circular flat roof over the dining area with a roof of a complex geometrical configuration consisting of 5 sections. b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 feet into the north side setback for a bedroom addition of 272 square feet. C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a bedroom and an enlargement of the dining area which includes a roof of complex geometrical configuration, a total of 323.9 square feet, to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, 1 - story single family dwelling. 2. An application submitted by Roy M. Simon, Architect as agent for Mr. & Mrs. Peter A. Lyons owners of property located at 3550 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, legally described as Lot 2, Block 2, Plat No. 1 Polo Fields, Gulf Stream, Florida, for the following: a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 feet into the north side setback for a bathroom addition of 277 square feet. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a bathroom and reconstruction of the AGENDA CONTINUED front entry porch that includes a Dutch gable, a total addition of 488.7 square feet, to existing Colonial West Indies style 1 -story single family dwelling; the removal of existing pool and construction of a new pool; and the removal of the circular driveway to accommodate a front lawn enclosed with a 4' high fence. The driveway into the garage will be Chicago brick and a back -out space will be included. VII. Items Related to Previous Approvals. A. Landscaping revision related to approved renovations and improvements at 1314 N. Ocean Blvd. submitted by Krent Wieland Design, Inc. VIII. Items by Staff. A. Additional Review of Proposed Amendment to Section 70-238, Roofs, as Written in Proposed Ord. 12\4. IX. Items by Board Members. X. Public. XI. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, MAY 24, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:25 A. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Ganger called the meeting to order at Robert W. Ganger Paul Lyons, Jr. Malcolm Murphy Thomas M. Stanley Scott Morgan Tom Smith Amanda Jones William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John Randolph James Landquist John Woolley Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting as Board Member Vice -Chairman Board Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Applicant / 800 Tangerine Way Applicant / 935 Orchid Lane Town Consultant III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 4-26-12. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to approve the Minutes of April 26, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. June 28, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. No meeting in August d. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. f. November to be determined g. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Ganger asked if there will be a quorum for the next two meetings. Clerk Taylor said it looks like there will be a quorum. There were no conflicts with the meeting schedule. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. Chairman Ganger asked for declarations of ex -parte communication concerning the applications for public hearing. Mr. Murphy stated that Mr. and Mrs. Landquist are his neighbors and he advised them of the application and approval process. Mr. Lyons stated that he drove by the Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 2 property. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to James Landquist, John Woolley and Marty Minor. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by James F. & Pamela Landquist, owners of the property located at 800 Tangerine Way, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 16, Place Au Soleil Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit a 155 sq. ft. garage addition to the existing 396 sq. ft. garage that encroaches 7.8 ft. into the required 20 ft. rear setback. Mr. James Landquist of 800 Tangerine Way introduced himself and presented his application to the ARPB. He said he is proposing the addition to his one -car garage to make it a two -car garage, which will also increase the size of their driveway. Mr. Landquist saidhis house was built in 1962 and they were informed that the addition is too close to the 20' setbacks, and he said because of the angle at the back of the lot they had to design the additional garage to be much shorter than the existing. He said, in doing this, they are planning to redo the landscaping, which landscape plan is included. Mr. Landquist said his rear fence borders the new Hyundai Property where trees have been removed. He said they would like to plant in that area to screen Hyundai's 6' fencing. Mr. Landquist said one side of their home is mostly sand where they would like a grassy area and more plantings, and they will remove some of the pathways. Mr. Murphy asked about the timeline for construction and Mr. Landquist said it will be done over the summer. Mr. Stanley asked how the front of the garage will look from the street. Mr. Landquist said it looks like a standard two -car garage from the front elevation, it will have the same roof line as the existing, they will remove the roof from the existing garage and it will be uniform. Chairman Ganger asked if their existing driveway is pavers. Mr. Landquist said they currently have gray pavers and they will redo the entire driveway with coral -colored pavers. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if there were any comments concerning this matter from neighboring residents. Clerk Taylor said Ingrid Kennemer commented that she was in favor. There were no comments from Staff. Mr. Stanley moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend approval for a Special Exception to permit a 155 SF garage addition to the existing 396 SF garage that encroaches 7.8 feet into the required 20 feet required setback. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit a 15E sq. ft. garage addition to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda Style single family dwelling. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Stanley seconded to recommend approval of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed 155 SF garage addition to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style single family dwelling meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 3 2. An application submitted by John & Elisabeth Woolley, owners of property located at 935 Orchid Lane, legally described as Lot 88, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream Florida. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the replacement of existing broken, awning type windows in all existing openings visible from the street with triple horizontal sliders. The sliders will have impact glass set in white frames. Mr. Woolley introduced himself and presented his application to the ARPB. He said he would like to replace their 40 -year old, poorly functioning, awning type windows with horizontal, high impact sliders. Mr. Woolley said they chose horizontal sliders to avoid having them open onto the porch. They look almost identical to casement except that they move from side to side. He said Plantation shutters are throughout the house and sliders are easier than casement to open and maneuver. He said they would like to do the window replacement in two phases due to cost and his wife's asthma issue. Mr. Woolley said doing this in a 40 - year old house can create a lot of dust and release materials from the walls and, therefore, they plan to section off the house and do the work in two phases. Mr. Woolley stated that all windows will duplicate the existing with regard to size and number. Mr. Lyons said he viewed the property and commented that the window Mr. Woolley is proposing in the patio area will not look different from the street. With regard to the other windows, he asked Mr. Woolley why he would not use casement. Mr. Woolley said he thought the ARPB would prefer one style throughout to be consistent. Mr. Murphy asked about the discouraged element and Mr. Thrasher said roller -style sliders are clearly discouraged. Mr. Stanley noted that there are no muttins on the proposed windows and Mr. Woolley said if muttins are preferred they would do that. Mr. Thrasher said the total glass has been measured and muttins will not be required by Code, but he said if the existing blinds remain, there will be some busyness in appearance, which may not be relevant. He said, as presented, they meet the Code with regard to opening size, but he added that they could accomplish the look they are going for with another type of window that does not go against the Code. Mr. Stanley asked if any other ranch -style homes in Place Au Soleil have had window replacement with a similar style. Mr. Thrasher indicated that, to date, he has not received any permit applications to replace dated windows. Chairman Ganger said there are certain safety standards for bedroom windows. Mr. Woolley said they are replacing bedroom windows, but he said sliders are not a safety issue and, in fact, are easier to climb through. Mr. Lyons asked Mr. Thrasher for his view of having a slider in the porch area and casement throughout the remainder of the house. Mr. Thrasher said it should be consistent. Chairman Ganger said he does not like to approve discouraged elements, but he said he would be willing to Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 4 approve this application because they will look like the existing windows from the street and they will be consistent throughout. Mr. Randolph said this application stands on its own merit and does not necessarily set a precedent in the event another property owner requests the same. Mr. Stanley asked Mr. Woolley if he had a strong objection to replacing all windows at once for reasons other than cost. Mr. Woolley said it is mainly because of his wife's asthma. He said, if the approval depends on replacing all windows at the same time, they may have to spend the summer in Maine. Mr. Thrasher commented that regardless of screening, the fine dust will travel throughout, and he said he would prefer that all replacement is done at the same time. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if there have been any comments from neighbors. Clerk Taylor said there have been no comments. There were no further comments from Staff. Mr. Stanley moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve Level II Architectural/Site Plan for the replacement of all windows on all elevations to a roller -style window as proposed on the spec sheet, with the following condition: The replacement of all windows on all elevations to roller -style will be done in completion, not in phases. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons suggested that Mr. Woolley have his contractor install a heavy duty filter and change it frequently during the window replacement, which will help keep the air clean. Chairman Ganger updated the ARPB Members on the Special Commission Meeting saying that there was a lively discussion with regard to the ARPB recommendations that have been set forth to date. He said the recommendations will go before the Commission in ordinance form for first reading at their June 8th meeting. Chairman Ganger said there were some changes and some additions, such as no clear cutting of lots when coming in with a subdivision. He said, in general, the recommendations were endorsed. Chairman Ganger thanked Mr. Lyons for joining him at the Commission Meeting and he said there were a few residents that also attended. He thanked the Commission and commented that the Commission took the ARPB recommendations very seriously and asked great questions. Chairman Ganger asked if any recommendations made today would go into the ordinance for first reading. Clerk Taylor and Mr. Randolph confirmed that. B. Ordinances. Mr. Minor briefly summarized the Ordinances for a recommendation of approval to the Commission. He said the first ordinance concerns rezoning of the annexed area. The Town Commission has adopted the land use portion of that area as multi -family, which change has been reviewed by the State Land Planning Agency (formerly DCA) and other appropriate State agencies, all of whom have signed off on it. Concurrently, it will be rezoned so that the rezoning has the Town's designation of Residential Medium (RM) to match the land use applied to that area. The first ordinance concerns the rezoning of this property from the County designation of RM to the Town designation of RM. Mr. Minor said the Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 5 County allowed 12 units per acre and the Town will allow 5.7 units per acre. Mr. Minor said the second ordinance includes a provision regarding reconstruction of loss in the event of an emergency such as a hurricane or fire, which states they can reconstruct as is, but no larger. It amends the multi -family section of the Zoning Code, listing the projects in RM West and RM East, with an additional provision addressing rehab and additions to existing structures in that area, which states that it must be consistent with Town Code. There is also a reference to the Special Exception process. Chairman Ganger asked about the one commercial property in that area that operates as a time share. He asked if it could be sold for the same use. Mr. Minor said time share is not allowed by Code and, therefore, it is a non -conforming use. Mr. Randolph said these are purely zoning regulations that run with the land and they have the right to sell it for the same use; however, he said if it is abandoned, the property would have to conform. 1. No. 12/2; AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH, COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE TOWN'S ZONING MAP TO REZONE 12 PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING APPROXIMATELY 16.6 ACRES, MORE OR LESS, IN SIZE; SUCH REAL PROPERTY IS LOCATED GENERALLY EAST AND WEST OF STATE ROAD A1A, SOUTH OF LITTLE CLUB ROAD AND NORTH OF SEA ROAD; FROM THE PALM BEACH COUNMTY DESIGNATION OF RM -MULTIPLE -FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (MEDIUM DENSITY) TO THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM ZONING DESIGNATION OF "RM" (MULTIPLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT); PROVIDING THAT THE TOWN ZONING DISTRICT MAP BE REVISED ACCORDINGLY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT HEREOF; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Mr. Stanley read the title of Ordinance No. 12/2. Mr. Stanley moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of Ordinance 12/2 to the Town Commission of the Town of Gulf Stream Town, FL for 1st reading at their June 8, 2012 Meeting. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 2. NO. 12/3; AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE TOWN'S CODE OF ORDINANCES, AT SECTION 71-1, TO INCLUDE NEWLY -ANNEXED PROPERTIES UNDER THE RM -EAST AND RM -WEST ZONING DESIGNATIONS; AMENDING, AT SECTION 66-131, THE NON- CONFORMING USE REGULATIONS TO ADDRESS STRUCTURES WITH A NON -CONFORMING DENSITY; ADDING SECTION 71-8, ADDITIONS AND REHABILITATIONS, TO INCLUDE REFERENCE TO STANDARDS FOR ADDITIONS AND REHABILITATION OF MULTI -FAMILY BUILDINGS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Mr. Murphy read the title of Ordinance No. 12/3. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Stanley seconded to recommend approval of Ordinance 12/3 to the Town Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 6 Commission of the Town of Gulf Stream Town, FL for 1st reading at their June 8, 2012 Meeting. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons asked Mr. Minor why RM West and RM East are divided. Mr. Minor said it was an established breakdown because East of A1A has slightly different regulations than West of A1A which reflect current conditions. Chairman Ganger asked whether there have been any proposals from the Seahorse for construction on the West side of A1A. Mr. Minor said single family structures are encouraged in RM West, the minimum lot size is 20,000 SF and there is room for two single family structures. Mr. Thrasher said Staff has reviewed some conceptual designs, all of which are multi -family. No applications have been submitted for that property. VII. Items by Staff. A. Proposed Zoning Code Changes 1. Section 70-71, Floor Area Ratio (continued from 4-26-12) Mr. Minor said Floor Area Ratio was discussed at the last meeting and the Commission looked at two recommendations. One was the additional FAR incentive and moving the second story back 10 feet and the other was making the maximum second floor area .7 of the first floor area for all districts. At the end of the discussion, the ARPB requested additional mandatory measures to ensure further variations rather than the cookie cutter facade. He said a new paragraph is proposed under 70-73. Two - Story Structures, where an applicant must incorporate one of four features within the front facade of any new two-story structure: (1) A second -story setback of 5 feet; (2) a front porch with a minimum of an 8' depth; (3) a balcony of a minimum of 24 SF; or (4) an arcade, each of which would provide a level of visual interest. In addition, a waiver is included which provides that the Town Commission may waive this requirement if the applicant can demonstrate that these features are inconsistent with the homes architectural style and that the visual variation is provided through other measures. Mr. Lyons said the use of the word "front" does not work with corner lots with one very long wall that faces the streets. Mr. Minor suggested "incorporated within the front facade or facades facing roadways. Mr. Lyons said he prefers that wording. Chairman Ganger asked how he would respond to these suggestions if he was an architect. Mr. Minor said he has had this conversation with several architects and they like the waiver and they like everything spelled out to better understand their parameters and to provide options to the applicant. Mr. Stanley suggested using ". . . facades facing public or private roadways." Mr. Minor clarified that he would be making a change to the second sentence of Section 70-73(b) to read, "One or more of the following features shall be incorporated within facades facing public or private roadways on any two-story single family home in all zoning districts." Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend approval of the proposed language, as amended, to the Town Commission. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 7 Mr. Lyons noted that the ARPB approved a slate roof on Palm Way and he said at a previous meeting it was suggested to include the Cape Dutch architectural style in the Code. Chairman Ganger said that gray tile is now an approved color. Mr. Randolph clarified saying the Commission decided to leave the strict language of the Code as it relates to white thou and thou, non -coated tiles and gray slate tiles, eliminating slate - like, with a provision to allow the discretion for a modification to that if good cause is shown. Further, he said any modification to that would be subject to the ARPB approval process. Mr. Randolph said this only relates to the predominant architectural style of Gulf Stream Bermuda. Clerk Taylor said Cape Dutch does not fall into the predominant styles, but it can fall into the overall section, which everyone must comply with. Mr. Minor said the Board would like to clean up the section of the Code that addresses metal roofs. He said metal roofs are listed under "prohibited" with a note which states, "Certain metal roofs determined by the Town to be appropriate to the structure and to the neighborhood may be approved only in instances of re -roofing of existing structures based upon an engineer's certification that the existing structure will not support a tile roof." Mr. Randolph said a recent applicant did provide an engineer's certification stating that his structure cannot support a tile roof and when the Commission wanted the Town's engineer to test that certification, the applicant refused to allow that. He said the recommended language, which reads, "This certification shall be reviewed and confirmed by the Town and its engineer prior to approval of the roof material" will provide clarification of the note in this section. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Stanley seconded to recommend approval of inserting this language into the note to clarify this section of the Code. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. With regard to slope of driveways, Mr. Thrasher said Mr. Minor had communication with an engineer who indicated that an existing slope of driveway of a newly -constructed single family home in Gulf Stream has a 1 in 10 slope. Mr. Thrasher said he walked this slope and it is reasonable, compared to the driveway slope on the Coon property, which is 1 in 5. He asked Mr. Minor if he was at a point where simple language could be comprised to include, "no slope would exceed the 1 in 10 degree." Mr. Minor said he is waiting to hear from another engineer before providing this language. Mr. Randolph said the Board can approve the concept that they want language incorporated into the ordinance which allows for a reasonable slope approaching garages or driveways, and he said if the Board is comfortable considering this without figuring out the slope it can go directly to the Commission from here. Mr. Stanley moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to approve the recommendation of language addressing the slope of driveways to be further reviewed by Staff and submitted to the Town Commission. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. With regard to Section 70-238, Roofs, Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Minor if Cape Dutch could be included in the phrase, " . . . predominantly Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - May 24, 2012 Page 8 Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences." Mr. Minor said he is not as familiar with Cape Dutch, but he said he would talk to Mark Marsh to provide an answer. Mr. Randolph said as a result of the Commission Meeting we now have a no clear cutting provision in the subdivision Code. He said the Commission directed Staff for a landscaping provision to address single family lots which would regulate the manner in which people treat their landscaping. They asked for language from many standpoints such as leaving existing landscaping along the lot perimeter during construction, or requiring that new landscaping must stay and an approval process would be required if taken out. Mr. Randolph said there are no language details, but he said this can be handled in the same fashion as slope of driveways. Mr. Thrasher said he would also like to add a description of a Level II Architectural/Site Plan that includes landscaping. He said currently there are not provisions in the Code that address changing out, moving, modifying or adding landscaping. Mr. Randolph said Jupiter Island has a provision that screening is required to protect the neighborhood from viewing construction. Mr. Stanley said Delray handles this matter administratively. He said construction screening cannot be left up indefinitely, the contractor must put in landscaping such as a hedge, and certain trees could be tagged that must remain. Mr. Lyons said Vice -Mayor Orthwein suggested phases where a hedge could be removed to allow entry of equipment, but the hedge must be replaced at the close of construction. Chairman Ganger suggested informing the Commission that the ARPB is addressing the removal of historic trees and hedging during construction, but that additional information and further guidance is required to put this language in ordinance form. Chairman Ganger mentioned painted should require a Level I review, only, not seawalls. He said this VIII. Items by Board Members. bulkheads. Mr. Thrasher said this which currently addresses structures should be addressed. IX. Public. There were no items by the Public. X. Adjournment. Mr. Stanley moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to adjourn the meeting. The meeting was adjourned at 11:00 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-05 Address: 2945 Polo Drive Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/M Paul Lyons, Jr. Agent: Roy Simon Enlargement of dining area and addition of Variance: To permit the replacement of an existing se; flat roof over the dining area with a roof of geometrical configuration consisting of 5 se, Special Exception: To permit the extension of the existing nort] single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 ii north side setback for a bedroom addition c Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Gross Lot Area: 16,715 Permitted Floor Area: 5,516 Zoning District: RS -C To permit the addition of a bedroom and ar enlargement of the dining area which incluc complex geometrical configuration, a total c the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, 1-s family dwelling. Effective Lot Area: 16,715 Proposed Total Floor Area: 3,854 Adjacent Residences Style: Mostly Gulf Str( Bermuda Note: This application was sent to Mr. Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday StudioE review. His memorandum is attached to this report for your review and considerat' Considered During Review: Division III. Variances Section 66-154 Standards The determination to recommend approval of this variance is to be based upon whet eight (8) standards, as defined in Section 66-154 of the Code, have been met. Section 70-74 Setbacks The structure has non -conforming side setbacks. Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks. NOTE: This application does meet all standards which would allow for this special c specially: Section 70-99 Roof design, slope and materials (3) Prohibited. Unnecessarily complex roof design. Lyons 2945 Polo Drive ARPB File #012-05 ARPB June 28; TC July 13, 2012 Page 2 NOTE: This application has a complex roof design Section 70-101. Windows. (b) Preferred. (2) Use of muntins to divide glass into unified section of four square feet (: (c) Discouraged. (1) Windows as dominant element (2) Bay windows as a prominent element (4) Between 25 percent and 50 percent of total window opening area on aG composed of undivided panes larger than eight square feet. Staff Recommendations: Variance Motion to Recommend Approval of variance based on the finding that the replacers existing semi -circular flat roof over the dining area with a roof of a complex geometr configuration consisting of 5 sections meets the minimum intent of the Design Manu applicable review standards. Special Exception Motion to Recommend Approval of Special Exception of the extension of the existii wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 into the north side setback for a t addition of 272 SF. Level III Architectural/Site Plan Motion to Recommend Approval of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on the fi the proposed addition of a bedroom and an enlargement of the dining area which in( roof of complex geometrical configuration, a total of 324 SF, to the existing Gulf Strea Bermuda style, 1 -story single family dwelling meet the minimum intent of the Desig] and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: June 28, 2012 Action: Variance: Recommend Approval as requested. (4-0) Special Exception: Recommend Approval as requested. (4-0) Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Town Commission Date: July 13, 2012 Action: Variance: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Special Exception: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ,�•. n'S 6'iTS� APR Tc,r:rl 01 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its considerai To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File 1,4 I.A.1. Project/owner Name: MR. AND MRS. PAUL A. LYONS, JR. I.A.2. Project Address: 2945 POLO DRIVE I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: LOT 12, REPLAT OF PART .OF GULF STREAM PROPERTIES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT B+ PGE 8, BL S F I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) . SEE ATTACHED I.A.S. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: NET ADDED AREA = 322.6 S. F. / Architectural Style: GULF STREAM BERMUDA 395.9 S.F. NEW 73.3 S.F. DE 1.A.6. Check all that apply: M Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocea Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses I (complete section G) EX Special Exception (complete section Z) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: + 8.02 FEET Type of Foundation: PILING B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 2945 POLO DR GULF STREAM FL 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number: 1.6.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information •� 33483-7331 r I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: ROY M. SIMON, ROY M. SIMON, A. I .A. , ARCHII I.C.2. Agent Address: 140 N.E. 4TH AVE. STE. A DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number) 278-1914 cell Fax 27E 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: ' Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: OREC! MAY 2 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL — 2945 Polo Drive Tool` PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION G. Projects Requiring a Variance IV.G.1. THE GEOMETRICAL CONFIGURATION OF THE EXISTING ROOF AND ITS D VALLEYS, TOGETHER WITH THE LOCATION AND CONFIGURATION OF THE E DINING AREA ARE UNIQUE TO THIS BUILDING, BUILT IN 1977. OTHER PRC IN THIS ZONING DISTRICT MAY HAVE SIMILAR CONTRAINTS. IV.G.3. THE PROPOSED ADDITIONS AND THEIR RESPECTIVE LOCATIONS ARE UN THIS PROPERTY, AND ARE INTENDED TO MAINTAIN THE ARCHITE INTEGRITY OF THIS EXISTING RESIDENCE. THIS IS UNDERSTOOD TO INTENT OF THE ZONING CODE; THEREFORE, IN THAT RESPECT, GRANTI VARIANCE REQUEST DOES NOT CONFER ANY SPECIAL PRIVELEGES APPLICANT. IV.G.4. THE ORDINANCE SUGGESTS THAT THE EXTERIOR DESIGN OF THE AD[ SHOULD REPRESENT A LOGICAL EXTENSION OF THE EXISTING STRUCTL THAT IT BE CONSISTENT WITH APPLICABLE DESIGN STANDARDS. EVERY E IS UNIQUE, REQUIRING UNIQUE SOLUTIONS. TO FOLLOW THE INTERPRETA' PRESENTED, WOULD REQUIRE THE RESTRUCTURING OF THE EXISTIN, CONFIGURATION TO RECEIVE THE ADDITIONS TO AVOID OTHER "PRO' DESIGNS, SUCH AS MANSARD OR FLAT ROOFS. AS DESIGNED, THE PL/ THE PROPOSED ROOF ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE EXISTING MAIN ROOF 1 ROOF OF THE GARAGE. THE PROPOSED ADDITION AND THE DINING REPLACEMENT PROVIDE THE LEAST DISTURBANCE TO THE SITE A ADJACENT OUTDOOR AREAS. THE PROPOSED STRUCTURES TIE-IN TO THE EXISTING BUILDING AT LOCATIONS STRUCTURALLY, AND REPRESENT THE PROPER EXTENSION FLOOR PLAN. THE EXISTING DINING ROOM PROJECTS FROM TF STRUCTURE AS A SEMI -CIRCULAR FLAT ROOF STRUCTURE, WITH FULL AWNING WINDOWS FILLING THE CIRCUMFRENCE. IT HAS BECOME NECES; REMOVE AND REPLACE THE DINING ROOM PROJECTION BECAI DETERIORATION TO THE STRUCTURE. IV.G.5. THE ROOF AS DESIGNED IS IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE PLANES OF EXIS- ROOFS AND RETAIN THE EXISTING VALLEY CONFIGURATION. IT REPRESE SIMPLEST AND LEAST OFFENSIVE SOLUTION. THE DINING ADDITION RE THE EXISTING FLAT ROOF OF ALL GLASS SEMI -CIRCULAR DINING ALTERNATIVE SOLUTIONS WOULD INCLUDE THE REDESIGN AND REBUIL THE EXISTING ROOF SYSTEM OR CONSTRUCT THE ADDITION WITH A M ROOF, WHICH IS PROHIBITED. I.V.G.8. WE FEEL THAT THE ROOF DESIGN IS NOT UNNESSARILY COMPLEX, BUT I; PROPER DESIGN PARAMETERS OF RETAINING THE ARCHITECTURAL INTEL: THE EXISTING STRUCTURE AND IS IN HARMONY WITH IT. BY APPLYING I SOLUTIONS TO THE PLACEMENT OF THE ADDITIONS AND THEIR RELATION THE EXISTING BUILDING AND ITS FLOOR PLAN, THE PROPOSED AC SATISFY THE INTENT OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE WITHOUT DISTURBING 1 OR ITS NEIGHBORS, NOR ARE THEY INJURIOUS TO THE PUBLIC WELFARE. AP PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. PROJECT INFORMATION 1.A.4. PROJECT INCLUDES REMOVING DINING ALCOVE OF THIS ONE S1 RESIDENCE; ADDITIONS INCLUDE A DINING ROOM AND A GUEST BEDROOM WITH CLOSET, ALL ONE STORY; PROJECT PROPOSES EXTEND THE EXISTING NON -CONFORMING NORTH WALL TO FOR ADDITION AND TO CONTINUE PATTERN OF THE EXISTING ROOF. - �---...,. • •., ••, �, ��.� dui i i i iUJt UC VVI I IIJICLE3O.� IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or I fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes [3u No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? 1�4 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes IXI No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or ad extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships arr landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or pl that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard 0% Yes No Explain: _ IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possik and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? DURING THE COURSE OF CONS IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? LATE SUMMER 2012 IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? THE AREA TO BE DI THE DINING ROOM EXTENSION IS A HALF CIRCLE SPACE OF 73.3 S.F. ON SIDE OF THE RESIDENCE. D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Oce; Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and presery land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page February 2002 ��ucdlll E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E.1. Is theo ro sed use a p p permitted special exception use? M Yes Q' No Code Sectic IV -E-2. How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the public welfare, and morals will be protected? THE EXISTING STRUCTURE AND THE PROPOSED ADDITION SATISFIES USE OF SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING. THE IV.E,3, Will the use cause substantialinjury to the value ofother ro be located? 11 Yes M No p petty in the neighborhoo Explain. THE USE DOES NOT CHANGE THE CURRENT STATUS OF T OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. l' PROP IV,EA. How will the use be compatible withd adjoining development is to be located? and the character of the D ALL NEIGHBORING PROPERTIES ARE EXISTING SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS. IV.E.5. What landscaping p g and screening are provided? NO CHANGE TO EXISTING WHICH_ SUBSTANTIAL. EXISTING FOUNDATION PLANTING WILL BE REI ELOCATED AND SUPPLEMENTED. IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein located? M Yes Q' No Explain. THE EXCEPTION DEALS WITH SIDE INTERIOR SETBACKS. SETBACK IS 15 FEET WHILE THE EXISTING SETBACKS OF THE RE��UIR ARE 12.2 FEET AND 12.6 FEET MINIMUM. ORIGINAL Bi F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the to Y are be malnt IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on properties. IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32.000 Tbwn'of Gulf Stream ®RE( MAY G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) ?own of IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? SECTION 70-238(d), ROOFS PROHIBITED: "UNNECESSARILY COMPLEX GEO IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? HIP ROOF WITH WHITE FLAT UNTEXTURED TILE IV.G.3. What is proposed? HIP ROOF WITH WHITE FLAT UNTEXTURED TILE IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? ROOF GEOMETRY IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addre additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, struct involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in tht district? SEE ATTACHED (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant.any special privilege that is denied I; Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: SEE ATTACHED (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the san ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? SEE ATTACH (5) Is the Variance request a minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable u building or structure? Yes No Explain: SEE ATTACHED (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: (7) Is the requested variance consistent wit goals, policies, and objectives of the future of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordina be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes Explain: SEE ATTACHED Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page February 2002 OREC MAY APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL — 2945 Polo Drive!iB► (' PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION G. Projects Requiring a Variance IV.G.1. THE GEOMETRICAL CONFIGURATION OF THE EXISTING ROOF AND ITS VALLEYS, TOGETHER WITH THE LOCATION AND CONFIGURATION OF THE DINING AREA ARE UNIQUE TO THIS BUILDING, BUILT IN 1977. OTHER PR IN THIS ZONING DISTRICT MAY HAVE SIMILAR CONTRAINTS. IV.G.3. THE PROPOSED ADDITIONS AND THEIR RESPECTIVE LOCATIONS ARE L THIS PROPERTY, AND ARE INTENDED TO MAINTAIN THE ARCHI' INTEGRITY OF THIS EXISTING RESIDENCE. THIS IS UNDERSTOOD T( INTENT OF THE ZONING CODE; THEREFORE, IN THAT RESPECT, GRAN VARIANCE REQUEST DOES NOT CONFER ANY SPECIAL PRIVELEGE; APPLICANT. IV.G.4. THE ORDINANCE SUGGESTS THAT THE EXTERIOR DESIGN OF THE A[ SHOULD REPRESENT A LOGICAL EXTENSION OF THE EXISTING STRUC' THAT IT BE CONSISTENT WITH APPLICABLE DESIGN STANDARDS. EVERY IS UNIQUE, REQUIRING UNIQUE SOLUTIONS. TO FOLLOW THE INTERPRET PRESENTED, WOULD REQUIRE THE RESTRUCTURING OF THE EXISTI CONFIGURATION TO RECEIVE THE ADDITIONS TO AVOID OTHER "PR DESIGNS, SUCH AS MANSARD OR FLAT ROOFS. AS DESIGNED, THE P THE PROPOSED ROOF ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE EXISTING MAIN ROOF ROOF OF THE GARAGE. THE PROPOSED ADDITION AND THE DINII REPLACEMENT PROVIDE THE LEAST DISTURBANCE TO THE SITE ADJACENT OUTDOOR AREAS. THE PROPOSED STRUCTURES TIE-IN TO THE EXISTING BUILDING AT LOCATIONS STRUCTURALLY, AND REPRESENT THE PROPER EXTENSIO FLOOR PLAN. THE EXISTING DINING ROOM PROJECTS FROM l STRUCTURE AS A SEMI -CIRCULAR FLAT ROOF STRUCTURE, WITH FUL AWNING WINDOWS FILLING THE CIRCUMFRENCE. IT HAS BECOME NECE:: REMOVE AND REPLACE THE DINING ROOM PROJECTION BECF DETERIORATION TO THE STRUCTURE. IV.G.5. THE ROOF AS DESIGNED IS IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE PLANES OF EXI ROOFS AND RETAIN THE EXISTING VALLEY CONFIGURATION. IT REPRESI SIMPLEST AND LEAST OFFENSIVE SOLUTION. THE DINING ADDITION F THE EXISTING FLAT ROOF OF ALL GLASS SEMI -CIRCULAR DININ( ALTERNATIVE SOLUTIONS WOULD INCLUDE THE REDESIGN AND REBUI THE EXISTING ROOF SYSTEM OR CONSTRUCT THE ADDITION WITH A a ROOF, WHICH IS PROHIBITED. I.V.G.8. WE FEEL THAT THE ROOF DESIGN IS NOT UNNESSARILY COMPLEX, BUT PROPER DESIGN PARAMETERS OF RETAINING THE ARCHITECTURAL INTE THE EXISTING STRUCTURE AND IS IN HARMONY WITH IT. BY APPLYING SOLUTIONS TO THE PLACEMENT OF THE ADDITIONS AND THEIR RELATIC THE EXISTING BUILDING AND ITS FLOOR PLAN, THE PROPOSED P SATISFY THE INTENT OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE WITHOUT DISTURBING OR ITS NEIGHBORS, NOR ARE THEY INJURIOUS TO THE PUBLIC WELFARE. uwrl or uulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.1-1.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Zoning Code text change, Future Land Us Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, please describE justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this fc the other materials submitted with the application. THIS PROJECT PROPOSES TO ADD TO THIS RESIDENCE A NET AREA OF 323.c FEET. THE ADDITIONS CONSIST OF A GUEST BEDROOM AND CLOSET (272 S AND A DINING ROOM (141 SQUARE FEET). THE DINING ROOM ADDITION THE SEMICIRCULAR DINING ALCOVE (73.35 SQUARE FEET AND WIL ITS FLAT R0 SCHEDULED FOR DEMOLITION. THIS EXISTING BERMUDA ROOF DESIGN AND ITS FRAMING PATTERN OF H SUGGESTS THAT THE ADDITIONS FOLLOW THAT PATTERN TO RETAIN IRS i THE PROPOSED BEDROOM EXTENDS THE HIPPED ROOF OF THE THE DRAIN DINING ROOM ROOF FORMS ANOTHER HIP FOLLOWING THE GARAGE WING, AN PATTERN OF THE MAI BETWEEN THE TWO NEW HIP ROOFS A CRICKET IS FORMED OVER THE CLOSET, I THE CURRENT ROOF DRAINAGE SYSTEM. Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Qoy M. Simon • A.I.A. * Architect architects and planners 1 V YY 11 VJ. V fill LJ U* C"L11 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 Re: Plan Review: 2945 Polo Drive Owner — Mr. and Mrs. Paul Lyons Dear Mr. Thrasher: oRECEI@T6"J,-.0ac1 May 2 2 ^2012 As requested, I have attached for your review and Variance consideration the completed Section G with attachments. In response to the Review Comments by Urban Design Kilday Studios, dated May 9, 2012, UDKS Project #94-012.019, I submit for your consideration the following, corresponding with the items noted in the referenced report, together with the attached revised Drawings No. land No. 2 and the added No. 3. Side Setback: Approval of the Special Exception Application to permit the proposed addition to extend the existing 12'5" side setback is requested. Eave Height: Subsequent to the report, a measurement was taken at the Lyons residence of the floor-to-eave height and was found to be 8 feet. The attached drawing has been revised to reflect that dimension. The original dimension of T-11" was measured from the scale drawing. Windows: On Drawing No. 1 the glass area has been recalculated. The east window in the Proposed Guest Room has been deleted. Please be advised that the French Doors, both existing and proposed, were included in the original and in the revised calculations. With regard to the use of muntins in the windows, the drawings continue the concept of the existing building in which there are no muntins in any glazed opening. The existing Dining Room is a semi -circular structure with a flat roof and full -height awning windows filling the room's perimeter. The structure has been found to be deteriorating and is scheduled to be removed. In its stead the Owner wishes to maintain the character of the original floor plan with slight modification. This new shape reduces the glass area, retains the alcove design of the original home, eliminates the flat roof, and follows the roof line of the existing hip roof. The concept allows the Owners and guests to retain the panoramic vista of the rear yard and its landscape that they currently enjoy. 140 northeast fourth avenue • suite a 9 delray beach, florida 33483 a (%1) 278-1914 Mr. William Thrasher May 21, 2012 Page 2 I trust that the information provided will clarify your concerns and be acceptable. If additional information is required, please advise. Sincerely, 4 Roy M. i on, A.I.A. AR#25 RMS/blp Enclosure cc: Mr. and Mrs. Paul Lyons memorandum UDKS PROJECT #: 94-012.019 urban design Ir 1 1040MI 1 Urban Design Kilday Studios has reviewed the Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan application for construction of an addition to an existing single family home located at 2945 Polo Drive in Gulf Stream, including the revised plans submitted on May 21, 2012. Please see our comments below. Project Details • Existing zoning: Gulf Stream Core • Proposed project: 322.6 SF addition to rear of SFH consisting of guest bedroom and dining area Side Setback The proposed addition encroaches the side (minimum 15' required/12'-5" provided). This Special Exception Setbacks, because the side setback and therefore is non -conforming permittable, per Code Section 70-75(c), setback to the existing home is also non- conforming. The proposed addition is in line with the existing home and will not encroach any further into the side setback than the existing home. As such, the addition represents a logical extension of the existing floor plan. Windows The proposed bay window in the dining area of the addition falls under the "discouraged" category, per Code Section 70-239(c), because it appears as a prominent feature. Bay windows are expressly "discouraged" by the Town's Design Manual. The applicant's architect has indicated that existing dining room, which features a curvilinear wall, includes full-length awning windows which look out onto the back yard of the home. The 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 Required Proposed Minimum lot size 16,500 SF 16,715 SF FAR 0.33 (1st 20K SF)/5,515.95 SF 0.23/3,853.7 SF Side setback > or = 15' (12.5' existing) 12'-5" Rear setback 20' 62'-9" Landscaping 40% 57.4% Side Setback The proposed addition encroaches the side (minimum 15' required/12'-5" provided). This Special Exception Setbacks, because the side setback and therefore is non -conforming permittable, per Code Section 70-75(c), setback to the existing home is also non- conforming. The proposed addition is in line with the existing home and will not encroach any further into the side setback than the existing home. As such, the addition represents a logical extension of the existing floor plan. Windows The proposed bay window in the dining area of the addition falls under the "discouraged" category, per Code Section 70-239(c), because it appears as a prominent feature. Bay windows are expressly "discouraged" by the Town's Design Manual. The applicant's architect has indicated that existing dining room, which features a curvilinear wall, includes full-length awning windows which look out onto the back yard of the home. The 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 project architect indicates the home owner wishes to maintain the "panoramic vista" of the rear yard from the dining room. The proposed dining room addition uses less glass area than what Roofs Per Code Section 70-238, unnecessarily complex roof geometry is prohibited. Generally, the Gulf Stream -Bermuda architectural style places an emphasis on simple, straightforward design. The proposed roof over the dining addition is cone-shaped and features five different planes. The applicant's architect has indicated that the existing dining room features a curvilinear wall with a flat roof. The proposed roof for the dining room expansion ties into the existing and proposed roofs. The height and slope of the proposed dining room roof is consistent with the height and slope of the existing and proposed roof of the home. Recommendation The existing curvilinear wall on the home's dining room and its proposed addition creates possible conflicts with the Town's Design Manual as discussed above. However, the curvilinear nature of the dining room and its expansion creates a unique feature for the home that should be considered in this individual case. In its review, the Architectural Review and Planning Board should consider, in accordance with Section 70-4(c), whether the proposed addition is consistent with the following items: • Neighborhood character; • Architectural style; • Building form and mass; • Materials and colors, and • Location of elements. In reviewing these criteria, the proposed addition is consistent with the neighborhood character as there are several distinctive roof types within close proximity of the subject home. The proposed addition is consistent with the materials, building forms and architectural style of Gulf Stream -Bermuda homes within the Town. The proposed addition is located on the rear of the house and will not be seen from the adjacent street. As a result, we recommend approval of this request. 0 0 ti 0 F;3 0 z O Z NCH MARK OF / NAI WAShER IN OUT ELEVA77GYV +6.40 —^ POLO DRIVE _ �i PA VED 100.00' BENCHMARK TOP OF NAIL & WASI-ER IN CUT OUT ELEVA77ON +6.30 — FOM IRR, 2.0' WEST (WITAESS CORAER) 1 127, WALL 77LE 122• 19.4' �ANTERp 21.4' n FS o T I L E j o GARAGE +7.43 f1 g 34.3' FLOOR +8.02 1 STORY RESIDENCE O # g p�j FLOOR +8.00 � 20.6'13.7' 214' 124' +7.55 x� + i -s •s obi CAN0PY� 0 12.5' 4.6', ti 4.6' CONC. + + s J, cn �n � t� o � rn z C NG'k��8 x� 3�+ z s s pp � 0 P p �. ,jrONC/ y n 0.5' F CHAIN LIMO FENCE �� —j ❑ F ` p +6.9 100.00, + . +7.4 7.4 ALLEY RIGHT OF WAY TREE -j ON COR LIAMPROVED Pi �mo kaon OOC)O Rl r C� nl A (T� v, i a cn rnQj Do a O � W '`aZo m�mi~j v ��c m O n�l Zi 00\I� ? ca 60 _ rri �� t—► Z nm O �I �Z U �v tii C�� v �o� ���z ��=O X� r �N 7' rr ^^ maw a�n� ��� 'e1 ® ® �� ���n vJ y�Ze C�� e"*a O y I (� cv, cam,) O Co � 2 In Z I? "J o �p Vmir�n rtl �Rl C.7 O IIc,Z Zt 000 �' "a4 M N a m y f r n fill a dSy 'j Nis aali ti N n n Ip x s� �o f O Z �y I v 0. a y .ted s ' z Mo�, z 0 177 �zz _ II II f� r �r4 N Q b m;z W�� r)' o 0 -0 W t7 p H r oULr 70, � IN � � � � n l • � � � N 1 � s n;i v -i �I "a4 M N a m y f r n fill a dSy 'j aali ti N n n Ip x s� �o f O Z �y I v 0. a y .ted s ' z Mo�, z 0 177 �zz _ NO f� o-� Mj-4 �r4 N Q ,,, m;z W�� r)' o 0 -0 W t7 p H "a4 M N a m y f r r A3 fit it t�il! x zo r ` ro Mc Od n o C'' r�� .r y O I �OC-) o sx i r ` � n o C'' rrl I - ne oww ��s �� .. ti��'�� .. 3 ., :,��; } ���� 1s �� i J . I : !! =�� �� ar r��> �� _ a' 1��- f ''. 1 \ y 1 �� \�� -400OF ;JJ sT jdMIk rl 11 1 ... ...... Ir Ile -400OF ;JJ sT jdMIk All. n�� 'yam ^}-� i� l+r,, �r ' �� ` •! �� A10 0 lon . I �4 MOM, 0 TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-07 Address: 3550 Gulf Stream Road Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/M Peter A. Lyons Agent: Roy M. Simon Addition of a bathroom, reconstruction of the front entry porch, removal and replacement of a pool and modifications to the driveway. Special Exception: To permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 into the north side setback for a bathroom addition of 277 SF. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the addition of a bathroom and reconstruction of the front entry porch that includes a Dutch gable, a total addition of 489 SF, to an existing Colonial West Indies style 1 -story single family dwelling; the removal of the existing pool and construction of a new pool; and the removal of the circular driveway to accommodate a front lawn enclosed with a 4' high fence. The driveway into the garage will be Chicago brick and a back -out space will be included. Gross Lot Area: 15,670 Effective Lot Area: 15,670 Permitted Floor Area: 5,171 Proposed Total Floor Area: 4,629 Zoning District: RS -C Adjacent Residences Style: Mostly Gulf Stream Bermuda Considered During Review: Section 70-74 Setbacks The structure has non -conforming side setbacks. Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks. NOTE: This application does meet all standards which would allow for this special exception, specially: Section 70-99 Roof design, slope and materials Section 70-101. Windows. Lyons 3550 Gulf Stream Road ARPB File #012-07 ARPB June 28; TC July 13, 2012 Page 2 Staff Recommendations: Special Exception Motion to Recommend Approval of a Special Exception to permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 into the north side setback for a bathroom addition of 277 SF. Level III Architectural/Site Plan Motion to Recommend Approval of Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on the finding that the proposed addition of a bathroom and reconstruction of the front entry porch that includes a Dutch gable, a total addition of 489 SF, to existing Colonial West Indies style 1 -story single family dwelling; the removal of existing pool and construction of a new pool; the removal of the circular driveway to accommodate a front lawn enclosed with a 4' high fence; modifications to the driveway into the garage that includes Chicago brick and a back -out space meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the condition that a drivezvay permit and a maintenance & removal Agreement are executed. ARPB Date: June 28, 2012 Action: Special Exception: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested with the condition that a driveway permit and a maintenance & removal agreement are executed. (4-0) Town Commission Date: July 13, 2012 Action: Special Exception: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Approved as recommended with the condition that a driveway permit and a maintenance & removal agreement are executed. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream / 1 TOWN OF GULF STREAM MAY 3 0 2012 100 far , �45 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File #_ !,$ — % I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: MR. AND MRS. PETER A. LYONS I.A.2. Project Address: 3550 GULFSTREAM ROAD I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: LOT 2, BLOCK 2, PLAT NO. 1 POLO FIELDS ACCORDING TO THE MAP OR PLAT THEREOF, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 26, PAGE 13 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNIL. I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) SEE ATTACHED I.A.5 1.A.6 1.A.7 Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: NEW STRUCTURE: 277 S. F. ; EXISTING Architectural Style: COLONIAL WEST INDIES NV RTED: 372.9 S.F. Check all that apply: M Architectural/Site Plan Review 0 Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) IN Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) DO Special Exception (complete section) (a) Proposed F.F.E.: + 6.15 FEET Type of Foundation: AUGERED PILING B. Owner Information GRADE BEAMS I.B.1. Owner Address: 4h I.13.2. Owner Phone Number: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: ROY M. SIMON ROY M. SIMON A. I .A I.C.2. Agent Address: 140 N.E. 4TH AVE., STE.A, DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 278-1914 cell Fax 278-9907 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: r Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL — 3550 Gulfstream Road PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.4. Project Description 1. MODIFY EXISTING ENTRANCE PORCH, REMOVE EXISTING CIRCULAR PORTION OF DRIVEWAY, RETAIN THE DRIVEWAY TO THE GARAGE AND ADD BACK -OUT SPACE. 2. CONSTRUCT 277 SQ. FT. BATHROOM ADDITION ADJACENT TO THE EXISTING MASTER BEDROOM AND MODIFY INTERIOR LIVING AREA. 3. REPLACE EXISTING WINDOWS AND EXTERIOR GLASS DOORS WITH HURRICANE AND IMPACT RESISTANT UNITS. 4. ENCLOSE EXISTING SCREENED PORCH ON WEST PATIO AND MODIFY TO CONDITIONED LIVING AREA AND INCORPORATE SPACE INTO CONDITIONED LIVING AREA. 5. REMOVE EXISITING SWIMMING POOL AND CONSTRUCT NEW POOL WEST OF EXISTNG RESIDENCE. 6. MODIFY LANDSCAPING AND PATIO AND ADD FENCE IN FRONT YARD. APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL — 3550 Gulfstream Road PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.4. Project Description 1. MODIFY EXISTING ENTRANCE PORCH, REMOVE EXISTING CIRCULAR PORTION OF DRIVEWAY, RETAIN THE DRIVEWAY TO THE GARAGE AND ADD BACK -OUT SPACE. 2. CONSTRUCT 277 SQ. FT. BATHROOM ADDITION ADJACENT TO THE EXISTING MASTER BEDROOM AND MODIFY INTERIOR LIVING AREA. 3. REPLACE EXISTING WINDOWS AND EXTERIOR GLASS DOORS WITH HURRICANE AND IMPACT RESISTANT UNITS. 4. ENCLOSE EXISTING SCREENED PORCH ON WEST PATIO AND MODIFY TO CONDITIONED LIVING AREA AND INCORPORATE SPACE INTO CONDITIONED LIVING AREA. 5. REMOVE EXISITING SWIMMING POOL AND CONSTRUCT NEW POOL WEST OF EXISTNG RESIDENCE. 6. MODIFY LANDSCAPING AND PATIO AND ADD FENCE IN FRONT YARD. Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.I. In what zoning district is the project site located? GULF STREAM CORE DISTRICT (RS -C III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? IKI Yes ❑ No Explain. THE PROPOSED ADDITIONS TO THIS SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE ARE COMPATIBLE WITH THE INTENT OF THE ZONING DISTRICT AND THE CODE. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? In Yes ❑ No Explain. THE PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS TO THE BUILDING AND THE SITE RETAIN THE USE AND ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE OBJECTIVES AND GOALS OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? THE EXISTING DRIVEWAY SYSTEM WILL BE MODIFIED, ELIMINATING THE CIRCULAR DRIVE WHILE RETAINING THE DRIVEWAY TO THE GARAGE, ADDING BACKOUT SPACE. III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage EXISTING RETENTION SYSTEM UPGRADED. b. Sanitary Sewer MUNICIPAL SEWER SYSTEM EXISTING. c. Potable Water MUNICIPAL WATER SYSTEM EXISTING. d. Irrigation Water MUNICIPAL WATER .SYSTEM EXISTI G e. Electricity EXISTING UNDERGROUND SERVICE. f. Telephone EXISTING UNDERGROUND SERVICE. g. Gas PROPOSED UNDERGROUND PROPANE GAS TANK. h. Cable Television EXISTING UNDERGROUND SERVICE. III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) A PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes M No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? M Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes IN No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? I%1 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes W(No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town bf Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit W.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? W.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the A1A Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit W.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? SWIMMING POOL AND ENTRY PORCH ROOF IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? FALL 2012 IV -C-3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? EXISTING POOL WHILE USEABLE IS IN UNDESIRABLE LOCATION TO BE REPLACED WITH VEGATATION AND PATIO. ENTRY FLAT ROOF TO BE REMOVED AND REPLACED WITH GABLE ROOF. D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1, Is the proposed use a Permitted special exception use? PXYes []No Code Section: 70_47 AND IV•E.2. How is the use designed, located and 0 75 (�) welfare, and morals will be protected? proposed to be operated so that the THE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE IS THE Public health, safety, E ACCEPTED USE PER 70-47; THE PROPOSED ADDITION EXTENDS LOGICALLY THE EXISTING STRUCTURE IV. E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of other be located? 11 Yes 00 No property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. THE USE REMAINS CONSISTENT WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT; THE Mp RHOOD AND THE ZONING NEIGHBORHOOD. C E V LUE AND CHARACTER OF THE IV.EA- How will the use be compatible with adjoining develop is to be located? pment and the character of the District where it THE EXISTING RESIDENTIAL USE IS THIS SINGLE FAMILY THAT CHARACTER AND IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE DISTRICT. NEIGHBORHO D IV.E.S, What landsca in landscaping and screening are provided? NEW HEDGING MATERIAL WILL REPLACE THE EXISTING ALONG THE FRON AND SIDE PROPERTY LINES PROPOSED THROUGHOUT; THE CIRCULAR DRIVE IS TO BE NEW TREES ARE REPLACED WITH A NEW LAWN IV.E.E. Does the use conform with all applicable re ulati . 9 ons governing the District wherein it is to be located? M Yes []No Explain. THE USE DOES NOT CHANGE; THE EXCEPTION DEALS WITH CONFORMING SIDE SET -BACK OF 121_611 + _ H THE _ / AND THE PROPOSED EXTENSION OF THE EXISTING EXTERIOR WALLS AND ROOF. --- F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units W.F.I. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the to Y are be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their Potential enal impacts on surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provi-------------- ded and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 1 uvv" or gulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV. H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, hange Comprehensive Plan text change, oroany combinat oning Codetnc hereof, pleas e Land cribe the need and d Use Map change, justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for al/ applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this form or on any of the other materials submitted with the application. 4 d, to provide any THE PROPOSED PROJECT INCLUDES THE STRUCTURAL EXTENSION OF THE WING AND RECONSTRUCTION OF THE ENTRY PORCH. THE EXISTING NORTH BEDROOM TO BE ENCLOSED TO BECOME PART OF THE LIVING AREA SCREENED PORCH IS FOR GLASS DOORS. ALL EXTERIOR GLAZED WINDOWS AND BY REPLACING SCREEN PANEL BOORS WITH IMPACT/HURRICANE RESISTANT UNITS. ARE TO BE REPLACED TO PROVIDE MORE PASSIVE AND BETTER USE OF PATIO AREA THE EXISTING POOL IS TO BE REMOVED AND REPLACED BETWEEN THE BUILDING WINGS, AND OTHER VEGETATION. THE NEW POOL WILL BE WITH HAVERED PATIO, LAWN TREES CONSTRUCTED IN THE REAR YARD BEYOND THE BUILDING FOR A MORE ENJOYABLE RELAXING ATMOSPHERE_ THE FRONT YARD WILL BECOME A PASSIVF TERRACE AND ENTRANCE WALKWAY. Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/6/00 FAMILY AREA W Page 7 Qoy M. cSimon • A.I.A. • Architect architects and planners •RECEIVEDO JUN 11209 Town of Guy Stream, FL June 11, 2012 Mr. William Thrasher Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: Mr. and Mrs. Peter A. Lyons 3550 Gulfstream Road Dear Mr. Thrasher: Attached is a copy of the revised Site Plan, Architectural Drawing No. 1, to be attached to our submittal of the Application for Development Approval of the residence at 3550 Gulfstream Road, replacing Drawing No. 1, previously submitted. The changes made to the drawing increases the side and rear setbacks for the pool equipment to 12 feet (side) and 15 feet (rear). Please contact me if you have any questions. Sincerely, Roy imon, A.I.A. AR#2 5 RMS/blp Enclosure cc: Mr. and Mrs. Peter A. Lyons au't-4 tl 140 northeast fourth avenue 9 suite a 9 delray beach, Florida 33483 • (%1) 27&1914 Qoy M. cSimon • A.I.A. • Architect architects and planners June 7, 2012 Noy p 2012 J• Mr. William Thrasher Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: Mr. and Mrs. Peter A. Lyons 3550 Gulfstream Road Dear Mr. Thrasher: Attached are revised Architectural Drawings to be attached to our submittal of the Application for Development Approval of the residence at 3550 Gulfstream Road, replacing the Architectural Drawings previously submitted. No changes have been made to the landscaping plan nor the drainage plan. In reviewing the drawings after submittal we noticed that there was a slight discrepancy between the Architectural Plan and the Landscape Plan in the outdoor shower .in the northwest corner of the yard and the chain link fence in the hedges along Gulf Stream Road. In the interim the owners elected to enlarge the awning to encompass the west patio which increased the awning by roughly 83.4 sq.ft. The F.A.R changed from .29 to .295. The muntin configuration was altered as indicated, on the French doors on the front elevation at the owner's request. Sincerely, Roy M. ion, A.I.A. AR#2595 RMS/blp Enclosure cc: Mr. and Mrs. Peter A. Lyons 140 northeast fourth avenue 9 suite a • delray beach, Florida 33483 9 (561) 278-1914 Qoy M. Simon • A.I.A. • Architect arehitect,5 and planners July 9, 2012 VIA: email Ms. Rita Taylor Town Clerk Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: 3550 Gulf Stream Road Dear Ms. Taylor: As you are aware, Mr. and Mrs. Peter Lyons are proposing to remodel and add to their home at 3550 Gulf Stream Road, with construction expected to begin within the next 2-3 weeks. They have advised that all appliances, cabinetry and plumbing fixtures are to be removed and replaced with new ones. Mr. and Mrs. Lyons have graciously offered certain items to members of my family for use in their respective homes. Attached is a copy of the email from Heidi Lyons granting permission to remove items from her home. This letter is written to advise that we anticipate removing these items on Saturday, July 14 and Saturday, July 21, 2012, to avoid any problems that may arise from this activity. Respectfully, Roy M. ' on, A.I.A. AR#25 Enclosure cc: Mr. and Mrs. Peter Lyons 140 northeast fourth avenue • suite a • defray beach. florida 33483 • (561) 278-1914 Page 1 of 2 Roy M. Simon Architect From: <HKSLyons@aol.com> To: <rmsimonarch itect@bel lsouth.net> Sent: Friday, June 22, 2012 4:46 PM Subject: Re: 3550 Gulf Stream Rd. Roy, it's all his, I glad someone can use them, they all seem in good condition, I've used the washer/dryer, and they work fine. If you think of someone who would like the range and microwave, that would be great. Heidi In a message dated 6/22/2012 11:20:38 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, rmsimonarch itect@bel lsouth_net writes: Hi. Well, next Thursday is the big day. I have a color presentation to prepare and get my arguments together, but I guess we'll make it. During our meeting last week, you were kind enough to grant me permission to bring my "kids" to see if they could use any items that are scheduled for removal or demolition. As I stated, one is buying a house built in the 50's that has minimal up -dating, but is a good house in a good neighborhood, so, much of his wish list will help. The other two are in need of replacing appliances. Following is a "wish list" of items they saw that would help them: 1. Appliances - washing machine, dryer, dish -washer, refrigerator 2. Plumbing fixtures - two lavatories and faucets ( Powder Room and Dressing area of Bedroom 3 ); two white toilets ( Bath 1 and Bath 3); kitchen sink; 3. Metal storm shutter panels - son Mike would like the panels for the sliding glass doors of the house he is purchasing. 4. Cabinets - the tall pantry cabinet and the base/wall cabinet in the Kitchen where we will we plan the banquette; The list is submitted for your review and consideration. The items approved will be removed in coordination with Raimo's schedule. Thank you, Roy Roy M. Simon, A.I.A., Architect 140 N.E. 4th Avenue, Suite A Delray Beach, FL 33483 Fla. Registration No. AR#2595 7/6/20 L? o°w a Z� W QW �Qo Q o � w ���(o ew W Q ��a 4 Ze z y ;: �- y NU. U > r•.o ' O f� Q � C'3 Zw 0LLJ 0 M U W O O 'v -�1 ���'o ix _j OCO L� w o � o�z� Q ALO z� �O tfi W cn W ^) g J oW Zm OU� �C Q �Q�o ZW OQ 00 ZQ �� Q QzoPz z zU ►�o Q� U0, ��QW w o �Z � Oji � 91 Q�� � N U W ov0,"� v,O�r �� �N cnW wo 0 z� �`O Qm m� �z�¢ m� �� m ~9 c) �WjO w Z W Z J O 2rn� W �U� W� �� Wti w Q W Q it O^� Lo ��� Q~ �Z WU Q�zm W m QRZ Q W� VLULI W` WL O i ZS c) Z Z Cr- II WQU mQN �m mW OQ �WW� SOW Z �5O �� �O O W co IIQm N Z �Waj W� �COj >Z Q ALO W U U II II II II o�j W UWP WW U" Ocn mov C� II cd p m rjWj O QQ QW Q� WO — I'< WOQ� >cn WWZ WQ WQ �O adoa Nd_S -j7ng _ 10'P+ - G3 Vd Ob'•£'+ XLLVi1.3"13 N1SV8 NOlVO d0 o WIN >21Vn HON39 O N 00 ONOO BO N U NN �U 00 J m .� Zl lood 11 & d03 7000i add *--Wl? 13S 10N 8-:P tOO J 1 h c 5c loot 3AIa4 Cii rm&iO 919+ &0073 055£'# 30N30/S3Y A(VO1S l ss 9+ HJWd 03V33(YJS £ s's+ �� c+ m zs's+ b o N � U ° W Z O zt U� W QQ J Q oQ � � � o+ NN �U 00 J m .� Zl lood 11 & d03 7000i add *--Wl? 13S 10N 8-:P tOO J 1 h c 5c loot 3AIa4 Cii rm&iO 919+ &0073 055£'# 30N30/S3Y A(VO1S l ss 9+ HJWd 03V33(YJS £ s's+ �� c+ m zs's+ b o N � U ° W Z O zt U� W QQ J z oQ � � � JPC g PC J �OO�W W U �W=U� cr) o=mQ Nca ��� N OmpN � DO Ld Wc oC�� N + C)- � O 3ON3d 7V x o�LX) ^ 1N313SV3 .01 30 coo 001 • I l'S+ 6'k+ 8'k+ Z �f00 7a `L 10 7 LO h L p ~WO Cj ONW zY� O Q�U � Q WWO ZQ� I\OUO W �WCk� U N~m 0 o�w U NOO a C) o N � � U ° W Z O zt U� W QQ J z oQ � � � JPC g PC �OO�W W U �W=U� cr) o=mQ Nca ��� N OmpN � Wc oC�� N OrCO Q3 LQ U C)- � O L p ~WO Cj ONW zY� O Q�U � Q WWO ZQ� I\OUO W �WCk� U N~m 0 o�w U NOO a C) o N � � W Z O zt U� W QQ J z oQ � � � JPC g PC �OO�W W U �W=U� cr) o=mQ Nca ��� OmpN � Wc oC�� N OrCO Q3 LQ U C)- NN o�LX) ^ IN C))CN o � L p ~WO Cj ONW zY� O Q�U � Q WWO ZQ� I\OUO W �WCk� U N~m 0 o�w U NOO a C) Q. U �O J w J W U� W QQ J ZOU �OO�W W U �W=U� St z r WLi. waiifaav t Ll! CV J Lig o< w O '—' 3:1— IX __j o ca CL —' n Q I #w4,t8 �o� -. < o_' u °10 N• Ngo U n V ; Q 0 S� O € W am ro- Ig w �y �o v 'yLLN LL n� y 5 o 4 ig pe a ' 158$ Z ?9i�>°a $_ ?g a `� k i6 o rc g 4 is jai FqVII r I W' t il9 L i .>I ,11 011� a zm Y D 2� I S `, & Q q - .. _ _ '._ SII,' ,4a•6sl _ -- - I I I 14 ►i z� U: U aq i U1 L4 LIO v `l z� U: U aq o; o�w Mat m o st I y Co z Oa > `� zW I! 0 Owl a CL a � - I Iz �i FF 1 - . I ul U. N UJ coa OCC -�, > C) Q. ,� c -a x 171 �i a smot Ip r.Ij I 'L� J U. I R+ t{ Sze s r_•) p� T A ■id C.,_4 0 c' uj E E a 5 ..5 S E E d d S d 5 d bo h y d• d d y d o•"• ¢° 6 a cS •A} $ 8 Tic°5�-'" �n$°�° dlo _ �Y Jid` 07} j a PE 4�0, a L6 h�ag,�c � E Eii�� �d E��.� syy 7•�'� ��=up da°.iV iR uK^,E'b .. ay5 di I 62t 52 �8�od 6�" ES! �i g'1 a 6m �c E 5 =-2Q E" tj �: R R �S R6n6� R R r�S�v�� i ?^ o§� � oa b 's $A A r 8 � " s - - r. - A P p tl p A P q = z z R z W V7 J V W Z W a W [if W Lj Q a W � W' � Z Q Z W O UO J [mg z Ny^c 'L� J U. I R+ t{ Sze s r_•) p� T A ■id C.,_4 0 c' uj E E a 5 ..5 S E E d d S d 5 d bo h y d• d d y d o•"• ¢° 6 a cS •A} $ 8 Tic°5�-'" �n$°�° dlo _ �Y Jid` 07} j a PE 4�0, a L6 h�ag,�c � E Eii�� �d E��.� syy 7•�'� ��=up da°.iV iR uK^,E'b .. ay5 di I 62t 52 �8�od 6�" ES! �i g'1 a 6m �c E 5 =-2Q E" tj �: R R �S R6n6� R R r�S�v�� i ?^ o§� � oa b 's $A A r 8 � " s - - r. - A P p tl p A P q = z z R z W V7 J V W Z W a W [if W Lj Q a W � W' � Z Q Z W O UO J ail I lie, Ili 1,1 mb 41 511 N N • A d n d d d .. ail I lie, Ili 1,1 mb 41 Q 20 L QZ O W D Q Z �l t I o Q Z� OO M Lf � W O O ' -�! ticLLJ ��o ceJ OLL U O W�Z� O oo U� �L ~ WuWN g C) J W QZm OU� C-) ZO� N ZQ Z Q Q2p~ �O W O i �Z �� �CNN U W Q(f) I coQ� O0 Co> jU o (n m WC-)( Z� Qm O ca U W Z Cf! Z J O :z -0) W OVU W� O� W� ~��j L Q W Q II O^� �� O~ �Z WU Q z� Z Q m QjZ Q W� V�vil W� W� 0 SHL Z v II WQZ 4' mQN �m �W UQ �W�U JD w ��"� �0 Q �?o�> U Z Q W W �o Z II i U II Qm N Z JWaj W� JO QZ ri"I W U U II II II II O� j (O W UL�� l�lV U� Ocr� W�2 J �cn0 �� �L cl � U II ZO cd p m MjWj O QQ Q� Q� WO WOQ� �>cn N ovoa wd_S -j7n� _ 1o'.k+ - —— — --- — Osf'+ NOLLVA373 a 3 A V d ,9'Z! w o� p NIS V8 HO1V0 --D pyla -mvn H--w3a Zf O IV 0 0 U �� 0 N 0 0 90 wM ' 06's+ 5l'OOl . ZQWx J �l m lob� >.- b J �g cri U moo( Q Lo + Q Q) � ���� N N U N 2 U 0 I U ,9'Z! w o� J j Zf f\ U �� Q �+ N LO N U LLJ �r- 96'9+ 96'9+ "J" a3V33WS O w o� J j Zf DO J � £'6'9+ C�4 P6's+ ' 06's+ Q ZQWx J �l m J >.- b J C) Qj U moo( Q Lo + Q Q) � ���� N J ~�LQ COO Lo INjrw dNO-4 o� 700 700d 2103 ckz + + Odd 0/WO `Px 135 10N Lo !'S+ 3 A L 8 4 0 37LL 032L3400 0 Z7 Sl'9+ 2'0073 095f# 30N30/S3Y A&01S l .6 f'£' LO N 0 LLJ �r- 96'9+ 96'9+ "J" a3V33WS o LO Q Q J j Zf CQ J CN + £'6'9+ C�4 P6's+ ' 06's+ ^V ZQWx O=m Q >.- NJcr-� J C) Qj U moo( Q Lo + Q Q) � ���� N J ~�LQ COO Lo �Pz o� + ckz + + UZQ^ + d'a Q ti �� 30N33 7V13"6't•+ �p a x O 1N3'V3SV3 .01 .j0 ,nn nnL 6'�,+ 9*k+ z X10079 `L 107 n 9**+ p CO OO LO N 0 LLJ �r- J J J � U o LO Q Q J j Zf CQ J g L C�4 I ^V ZQWx O=m Q >.- NJcr-� J C) Qj U moo( Q Lo W N Q) � ���� N J ~�LQ COO Lo �Pz o� m ckz + + UZQ^ + Q ti �� X03 �p a O e� n 9**+ p CO OO �i Lu Q ~�O ONS ZY� 0 p�U � � U J V aZm LZ C) —j O Q CC TWO ^� ZQ� UO OW W �WU N ►— m Y�Z5 Q O a mom? NOO o C) LO N LLJ �r- J J J � U LO Q Q J j Zf CQ J g L C�4 I ^V ZQWx O=m Q >.- NJcr-� C) Qj cl: CO moo( Q Lo W SQ � ���� N J ~�LQ COO Lo �Pz ckz .� UZQ^ Q ti X03 �p a e� C:� O W �i Lu Q ~�O ONS ZY� 0 p�U � � U J V aZm LZ C) —j O Q CC TWO ^� ZQ� UO OW W �WU N ►— m Y�Z5 Q O a mom? NOO o C) 0 i" U U J J J � U LO Q Q J j SOU p ~ U U L'i J ZJJI 0 r i � N may m I �� No111O�J✓J c C, w r LU p�1Yh1t Rorv� �� V 4 u S � to r , u] "F 5 cDAT*e"WE, �' Q Fjp1s E- Jibes+_. p u IL� H v '"o uj N .J IL cm ul `� o a CY3 iu O '�� j oIL ir CL ---D n a °O 00- U o w g roo z a Q Ito o�¢ n w' O .na OQ y w i LL O 2 §S O oa QV V Q V A.; gv 2.5 Zr H is .. w z. ego:3 :3 A il- I i I� - l T - T �0 al i i, rl It .Y'I) .fill "f it ) I8� i I �� No111O�J✓J ,r�.j C, LU u to u] "F - ' H O a ZC Z I I qi p ff 0 k I I ,VEI »o ;4 IpWpS A A il- I i I� - l T - T �0 al i i, rl It .Y'I) .fill "f it ) I8� r 4Z'6S r i I u u] "F H a Z I I Q p 0 k ,VEI »o ;4 IpWpS A w Lil 0 W r 4Z'6S r i I gig �b e � � o 5 5 g�Es 3g EgE�o6aoJbd_3°s�dS°d gJJ �8a°d? f;6 EE gb E6 �Hd'R `as^'E� :�����Z��•.g'z Pg'2a �E23��52g � 2 i��2 a �Pa-"�QSP'YPEZFT��°gig P�PFg�;�� PE�s136yPE—E� k9S __ g _E Esc Rsi FF•EP c;i Ei '$ eetc'6c ii �c 5` 3 �{ fic 6c nw@�gn G 7v `coc°c� R6n6�cR6R �� = iR_ti og�In I _mY4 AAS v9 m6 5R m i ^ R _ S q q q q z z q VANC.5 Ox U hgi � � � n n � O Nm$$ 5 'J uj Q gig �b e � � o 5 5 g�Es 3g EgE�o6aoJbd_3°s�dS°d gJJ �8a°d? f;6 EE gb E6 �Hd'R `as^'E� :�����Z��•.g'z Pg'2a �E23��52g � 2 i��2 a �Pa-"�QSP'YPEZFT��°gig P�PFg�;�� PE�s136yPE—E� k9S __ g _E Esc Rsi FF•EP c;i Ei '$ eetc'6c ii �c 5` 3 �{ fic 6c nw@�gn G 7v `coc°c� R6n6�cR6R �� = iR_ti og�In I _mY4 AAS v9 m6 5R m i ^ R _ S q q q q z z q i i R• ORDINANCE NO. 12/4 AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE TOWN'S CODE OF ORDINANCES, TO CREATE SECTION 62-10, TO PROVIDE FOR REVIEW CRITERIA FOR THE CREATION OF SUBDIVISIONS IN THE TOWN, AT SECTION 66-1, DEFINITIONS, TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF BASEMENT, AT SECTION 70-27, DISTRICT DESCRIPTIONS, TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL CRITERIA FOR DISTRICT ELEMENTS, AT SECTION 70-70, FLOOR AREA CALCULATION, TO REVISE CALCULATIONS FOR BASEMENTS, AT SECTION 70-100, ROOF AND EAVE HEIGHT, TO CLARIFY ENTRY FEATURE EAVE HEIGHTS, AT SECTION 70-238, ROOFS, TO CLARIFY PERMITTED ROOF TILE STYLES, AT SECTION 70-51, MINOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURES, TO ALLOW WATERWALLS, AT SECTION 66- 367, SWIMMING POOLS, TO RESTRICT WATERFALL HEIGHTS, AT SECTION 66-369, DOCKS, TO CLARIFY PERMITTED BUILDING MATERIALS, AT SECTION 70-71, FLOOR AREA RATIOS, TO ADD INCENTIVES FOR SECOND - STORY SETBACKS, AT SECTION 70-73, SECOND FLOOR AREA, TO MODIFY REQUIREMENTS FOR SECOND STORIES FOR SINGLE FAMILY HOMES, AT SECTION 70-187, TABLE OF DISTRICT STANDARDS, ROOFS, TO CLARIFY REVIEW PROCEDURES FOR REQUESTED METAL ROOFS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 62, Subdivisions, to add a new Section 66-10, Criteria for Subdivision Review, to read as follows: Section 62-10. Criteria for Subdivision Review Any person seeking to subdivide property within the limits of the Town shall comply with the following criteria. The Architectural Review and Planning Board and Town Commission shall assure compliance with these criteria in determining whether the proposed subdivision is permissible. A. Lots to be created by the proposed subdivision shall be consistent with the character of lots and parcels immediate and adjacent to the proposed ci ihilk/kinn B. Proposed subdivisions shall protect the character of the Town by incorporating features that are compatible with and complementary to the preferred elements and overall character of the neighborhood district in which thev are located including, but not limited to parcel size parcel shape access topography, berms and buffers and landscaping and encourage the orderly and aesthetic development of the Town. C. Proposed subdivisions shall not create any non -conforming structures or lots without specific approval from the Town Commission. D. Proposed subdivisions shall protect and conserve the value of land buildings and improvements, and minimize conflicts among uses of land and buildings. E. Applicants for proposed subdivisions shall ensure the adequate and efficient provision of public facilities, such as transportation potable water supply, wastewater collection and treatment, drainage surface water management solid waste, parks and recreation, are available concurrent with impacts of development. F. Proposed subdivisions shall avoid traffic congestion on streets and eliminate conflicts between pedestrian and vehicular movements. G. Streets and vehicular use easements shall provide safe and efficient access for municipal services, such as fire, police and solid waste removal. As such dead- end streets and easement ending in a "T" or "Y" turnaround shall not be permitted. H. Proposed subdivisions shall establish reasonable standards of design and procedures for subdivisions and resubdivisions in order to further the orderly layout and use of land, and to ensure proper legal descriptions of subdivided land. Proposed subdivisions shall ensure that new development will be required to bear its fair share of the cost of providing the public facilities and services needed at the time of development. Proposed subdivisions shall prevent the pollution of air and water resources; ensure the adequacy of surface water management facilities• safeguard the groundwater resources; and encourage the conservation protection and management of natural resources. K. Clear -cutting of parcels shall not be permitted. A landscaping plan shall be provided so as to assure the preservation of landscaping and screening to the fullest extent possible and to provide a mitigation plan for any landscaping which is removed. Section 2. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 66, Zoning, Article I, Section 66-1, Definitions, to read as follows: Section 66-1. Definitions. Basement shall mean that portion of the building which is below the finished floor elevation of the building and is located within the footprint of the first floor. A basement is not considered a story with regards to the height measurement of a building, unless the ceiling of the basement is greater than three (3) feet above grade. The squ@Fe feetag-e area of a basement completely under the first floor footprint and having no outside entrance shall be included as !99°4 75% of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations. The area of a basement with an outside entrance shall be included as 100% of the building's Floor Area Ratio calculations. Basements shall conform to all setback regulations for structures. There shall be no entrances to such basement on the street side and the exterior appearance of such basement shall conform to the general architecture of the building. 'TAW Section 3. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article II, Single -Family Districts, Section 70-27, District Descriptions, to read as follows: Sec. 70-27. District descriptions. (c) The character of each district, and the town as a whole, is further defined by the design elements and features listed as "preferred" in other articles of the chapter. From the surveys, these elements and features were found to represent the existing and desired qualities that the town wishes to have reflected in new homes and renovations of existing homes. While the use of specific preferred design elements is not mandated for new homes or rehabilitation projects, proposed projects must incorporate design features that are compatible with, and complimentary to, the preferred elements and overall character of the district, including parcel size, parcel shape architecture and landscaping. Users of this chapter are therefore advised to closely study the character descriptions in this article as well as all of the preferred elements found in other articles prior to initiating project designs. Section 70-298 and 70-299 also should be consulted for a further description of existing development in the town and each district. Section 4. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article IV, Site Development Regulations, Section 70-70, Floor Area Calculation, to read as follows: Section 70-70. Floor Area Calculation (6) Areas in basements shall fGt be included as 75% when it is located completely under the first floor footprint and has no outside entrance. Areas in basements with an outside entrance shall be included as 100%. Section 5. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article V, Areawide Standards, Section 70-100, Roof and Eave Height, to read as follows: Section 70-100. Roof and eave height (a) (4) Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings Dutch gable or other such elements. Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches (4em eight feet to 12 fer- eRtFy (2) Discouraged Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet (bet eeR 12 and 14 feet fer ept-F" feat Fes) (3) Prohibited Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet (gFeat„r +hag 14 f.,.,+ fer entre feat s) (c) Two-story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights:: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — From eight feet to 12 feet for one- story portions (4em ^h+ f,,.,+ +., 14 feet f eRtFy f + ) All other districts — From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions (499, eight f^^+ to 14 f^^+ f entFy f ) (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — Between 12 and 14 feet for one- story portions (bet eeR 14 ,^d- ,-Ce feet ff + r � All other districts — Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one-story portions (-between IA ,^d feet f entFy f Section 6. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article VII, Predominant Revival Style, Division 3, Gulf Stream -Bermuda Style, Section 70-238, Roofs, to read as follows: Section 70-238. Roofs. (a) Required. White flat WRte .+ a + i Flat, white thru and thru smooth un- coated tile and ,&�� gray slate er slate style the may be permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences. subje^+ to Level 11 a Flat, gray thru and thru un -coated tile or slate -like tile may be permitted at the discretion of Architectural Review and Planning Board and Town Commission through the Level III review process subiect to the Architectural Review and Planning Board and the Town Commission making a determination that such alternatives are appropriate for the neighborhood. Section 7. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article III, Use Regulations, Section 70-51, Minor accessory structures, to read as follows: Section 70-51. Minor accessory structures. The following structures shall be considered as minor accessory structures in all five single family zoning districts subject to specific setbacks established in this chapter. Any structure which is larger or more intensive shall be subject to the same setbacks as the principal structure. (2) Permanent recreation facilities, including but not limited to: In -ground swimming pools and spas, including waterfalls, which shall not to exceed four feet in height. Section 8. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 66, Zoning, Article VIII, Supplemental District Regulations, Division 2, Accessory Structures and Recreational Facilities, Section 66-367, Swimming Pools, to read as follows: Section 66-367. Swimming pools. (i) Waterfalls, minor accessory structures shall not exceed 4 feet in height as measured from average finished grade of property. (k) No grotto shall be permitted within any zoning district A grotto shall be considered an artificial structure or excavation made to look like a cave or cavern. Section 9. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 66, Zoning, Article VIII, Supplemental District Regulations, Division 2, Accessory Structures and Recreational Facilities, Section 66-369, Docks, to read as follows: Section 66-369. Docks. (7) Materials and colors. Materials and colors of docks and ancillary structures shall be considered as part of architectural review and planning board consideration and shall be maintained as approved. All docks shall be made of wood. No concrete docks are permitted. Section 10. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article IV, Site Development Regulations, Section 70-71, Floor area ratios, to read as follows: Section 70-71. Floor area ratios. (c) Incentive floor area ratio 1. For new structures in all districts, FAR may be increased to 0.33 for first 20,000 square feet of lot area plus .25 for portions above that if a minimum ten (10) foot setback is provided on any multi -story portion of the structure The ten (10) foot setback is in addition to the minimum required front setback. The structure must conform to all applicable setbacks. so' 2. For alterations to existing structures in all districts FAR may be increased to 0.33 for first 20,000 square feet of lot area plus 25 for portions above that if architectural features are added to the structure. The features may take the form of a porch or balcony, but must be located on the front side of the structure and must occupy a minimum of 150 SF. Section 11. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article IV, Site Development Regulations, Section 70-73, Second floor areas, to read as follows: Section 70-73. Two-story structures ll In order to limit the construction of bulkier homes with full second stories in districts with small to medium lot sizes, the following restrictions shall be used: (b) The use of architectural design features to provide variation among two-story single family homes is required. One or more of the following features shall be incorporated within facades facing public or private roadways on any new two- story, single family home in all zoning districts • Second -story setback (minimum 5' setback in addition to ground level front setback 0 Front porch (minimum 8' depth) Gulf Stream Ocean Beachfront North/South Place au Core West Soleil Maximum -.7-5 .70 x first I xf+rst ' Prgt f'^^- .70 x first X5.70 x Second floor area fiA9F;;rea area floor area first floor Floor Area .70 x first .70 x first area floor area floor area (b) The use of architectural design features to provide variation among two-story single family homes is required. One or more of the following features shall be incorporated within facades facing public or private roadways on any new two- story, single family home in all zoning districts • Second -story setback (minimum 5' setback in addition to ground level front setback 0 Front porch (minimum 8' depth) " Balcony (minimum 24 SF) " Arcade The Town Commission may waive this requirement within subsection (b) if the applicant can demonstrate that these features are inconsistent with the home's architectural style and that the desired visual variation is provided through other measures. Section 12. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby amended at Chapter 70, Gulf Stream Design Manual, Article VI, District Standards, Section 70-187, Table of district standards, to read as follows: Sec. 70-187. Table of district standards. 2. Roofs 1. Certain metal roofs determined by the town to be appropriate to the structure and to the neighborhood may be approved only in instances of re -roofing of existing structures based upe subject to receipt by the town of an engineer's certification that the existing structure will not support a tile roof, said certification to append the engineer's study(ies) and report(s) supporting said certification and subject further to an engineer appointed by the town confirming said engineer's certification Additionally, unpainted copper may be used either as a decorative accent or on minor accessory structures. Section 13. Severability. If any provision of this Ordinance or the application thereof is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect the other provisions or applications of this Ordinance which can be given effect without the invalid provisions or applications, and to this end the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby declared severable. Section 14. Repeal of Ordinances in Conflict. All other ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida, or parts thereof which conflict with this or any part of this Ordinance are hereby repealed. Section 15. Codification. This Ordinance shall be codified and made a part of the official Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream. Section 16. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon its passage and approval, as provided by law. I PASSED AND ADOPTED in a regular, adjourned session on first reading this 8th day of June , 2012, and for a second and final reading on thisl3th day of July , 2012. Mayor, Commissioner Commissi ner Commissioner ATTEST: (x Clerk CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Robert Ganger Scott Morgan Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Thomas M. Stanley REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF THURSDAY, JULY 26, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA July 19, 2012 BY THE ARCHITECTURAL STREAM, FLORIDA ON TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 6-28-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. No meeting in August b. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. November to be determined e. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Roger Cope, as Agent for the owners, Thomas & Kirsten Stanley, of property located at 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 57, Gulf Stream Properties No. 2 together with that portion of the South half of the right- of-way known as Pandanus Rd. lying North of adjacent Lot 57, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit air conditioning equipment to encroach approximately 2' into the South side setback. b. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove a portion of existing West wing and the existing one car garage. C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/ SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit demolition of a portion of the West wing and existing one car garage, the addition of a two car garage and expansion of the West wing, a total of 1,492 sq. ft. to the existing 1 -story, single family historic Polo Cottage, and to permit an encroachment of approximately 2' into the South side setback to accommodate air conditioning equipment. 2. An application submitted by James Boyce as agent for ON Seahorse, LLLP, owners of the property located at 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. on the West side of State Road AlA, legally described in metes and bounds. a. The construction of two buildings, one of Georgian and one of Anglo Caribbean architectural style, containing a total of five 2 -story villas. AGENDA CONTINUED VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, JUNE 28, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:30 A. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Ganger called the meeting to order at Robert W. Ganger Scott Morgan Paul Lyons, Jr. Tom Smith Thomas M. Stanley Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Roy M. Simon, Architect Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting as Board Member Board Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent for Paul Lyons And Peter Lyons Town Consultant III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 5-24-12. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of May 24, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. July 26, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. No meeting in August C. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. e. November to be determined f. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Ganger noted that there will not be an August meeting, and he said the ARPB will schedule their November meeting after the Commission schedules their November meeting. Clerk Taylor said no applications have been submitted and, therefore, there may not be a July meeting. Chairman Ganger noted that 2nd reading of the Ordinances changing the Code and Comp Plan is scheduled for the July 13th Commission Meeting and, if adopted, Code changes will be effective as of that date. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - June 28, 2012 Page 2 Chairman Ganger asked for declarations of ex -parte communication concerning the matters scheduled for public hearing. Chairman Ganger stated that he drove by the Binnie property at 1314 N. Ocean Blvd. Mr. Stanley stated that he is a neighbor of Peter Lyons of 3550 Gulf Stream Rd. Mr. Smith stated that he drove by the Binnie property and that he is familiar with the properties located at 2945 Polo Dr. and 3550 Gulf Stream Rd. ARPB Member Paul Lyons recused himself from the hearing of both development applications as he is the owner/applicant for the property at 2945 Polo Drive, and Peter Lyons, applicant for the property at 3550 Gulf Stream Rd., is his brother. Mr. Lyons left the room and stated he would return to listen to the hearing for 3550 Gulf Stream Rd. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to Roy Simon of Roy M. Simon, Architect, and Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios. 1. An application submitted by Roy Simon as agent for Mr. & Mrs. Paul Lyons, Jr., owners of property located at 2945 Polo Drive, legally described as Lot 12, Gulf Stream Properties Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. VARIANCE to permit the replacement of an existing semi -circular flat roof over the dining area with a roof of a complex geometrical configuration consisting of 5 sections. b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 feet into the north side setback for a bedroom addition of 272 square feet. C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a bedroom and an enlargement of the dining area which includes a roof of complex geometrical configuration, a total of 323.9 square feet, to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, 1 - story single family dwelling. Roy Simon introduced himself and stated that he represents Mr. and Mrs. Paul Lyons, Jr. He said the original house was built in 1977 according to the setbacks existing at that time and, therefore, the applicant is asking that it be accepted as non -conforming because of those setbacks. Mr. Simon said the dining alcove, which is beginning to deteriorate, is located in the existing flat -roof, semi -circular addition and the applicant would like to enlarge the dining area and add a guest bedroom. He said they tried to simplify by following the planes of the existing roof to avoid drainage problems and tearing up the house. However, he said they created what seems to be a complex configuration. Mr. Simon explained the roof drainage, he said there is a lot of foliage in the rear of the home which will be maintained, and he said the original windows do not have muttins and the applicant does not want them on the new windows. He said the Bermuda Style architecture typically has open windows to provide panoramic views. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that the Code uses the word "complex" to provide discretion. He said it does not appear complex to him. Chairman Ganger asked Clerk Taylor if there were any comments concerning Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - June 28, 2012 Page 3 the design from the neighbors. Clerk Taylor said there were no comments from neighbors. There was no further comment from Staff. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of variance based on the finding that the replacement of an existing semi -circular flat roof over the dining area with a roof of a complex geometrical configuration consisting of 5 sections meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards, as defined by Code Section 66.154. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Vice - Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Stanley seconded to recommend approval of Special Exception of the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 feet into the north side setback for a bedroom addition of 272 SF, as defined by Code Section 70- 74. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on the finding that the proposed addition of a bedroom and an enlargement of the dining area which includes a roof of complex geometrical configuration, a total of 324 SF, to the existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, 1 -story single family dwelling meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 2. An application submitted by Roy M. Simon, Architect as agent for Mr. & Mrs. Peter A. Lyons owners of property located at 3550 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, legally described as Lot 2, Block 2, Plat No. 1 Polo Fields, Gulf Stream, Florida, for the following: a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 feet into the north side setback for a bathroom addition of 277 square feet. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a bathroom and reconstruction of the front entry porch that includes a Dutch gable, a total addition of 488.7 square feet, to existing Colonial West Indies style 1 -story single family dwelling; the removal of existing pool and construction of a new pool; and the removal of the circular driveway to accommodate a front lawn enclosed with a 4' high fence. The driveway into the garage will be Chicago brick and a back -out space will be included. Roy Simon stated that he represents Mr. and Mrs. Peter A. Lyons. He said the home is a U-shaped, Colonial style with a swimming pool in the middle, a flat -roofed screened porch and semi -circular entrance. Mr. Simon said they propose to alter the exterior facade, build a bedroom/bathroom addition on the rear of the home, remove the existing pool and concrete patio and install a new pool in the back yard, remove the circular driveway to provide a larger front yard, and enclose the flat -roofed screened porch to provide additional living area, which will have a gable roof and will follow the existing roof lines. He said the front facade will change by removing the two windows and converting them Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - June 28, 2012 Page 4 to French doors, which will open onto a small, covered, unenclosed sitting patio. Mr. Simon said the aluminum awning windows in the rear of the home will be changed to impact resistant casement with muttins that provide a simple horizontal separation. He said everything meets current Code except for the side setbacks, and he said the applicant is requesting a special exception because the Code has changed since the home was built and the setbacks are different today. Chairman Ganger asked if the roof over the enclosed porch area will match the rest of the roof and Mr. Simon confirmed that. Chairman Ganger asked Mr. Simon if the Dutch feature at the entrance of the home meets Code and Mr. Simon confirmed that. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that the changes maintain the classic proportion of the structure. Chairman Ganger asked about additional landscaping in the front. Mr. Simon said they submitted a landscape plan with their application, along with a drainage plan. He said there will be a tall hedge across the front with a chain link fence behind it as part of the hedging, which continues around the property. Mr. Thrasher recommended a condition of approval to the Level III Architectural/Site Plan that the applicant shall complete a Gulf Stream Driveway Permit Application and a Driveway Maintenance and Removal Agreement. Chairman Ganger asked about the proposed underground propane gas and Mr. Simon explained that they are changing their cooking range from electric to gas, they have a fire place where they would like to use a gas log, they will use a tankless water heater for the addition, and they would like to establish a barbeque area. He said the underground tank will probably be located on the side yard. Mr. Thrasher reminded Mr. Simon of the minor accessory setback of 12 feet on the side, and he said the underground tank is fine, but any equipment such as a generator or barbeque grill that is 8 inches above ground must conform to the side setbacks. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Stanley seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception to permit the extension of the existing north wall of a single family dwelling that encroaches 2.5 feet into the north side setback for a bathroom addition of 277 SF, pursuant to Code Section 70-74. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Vice Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on the finding that the proposed addition of a bathroom and reconstruction of the front entry porch that includes a Dutch gable, a total addition of 489 SF, to existing Colonial West Indies style 1 -story single family dwelling; the removal of existing pool and construction of a new pool; the removal of the circular driveway to accommodate a front lawn enclosed with a 4' high fence; modifications to the driveway into the garage that includes Chicago brick and a back -out space meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards, with the following condition: 1. The applicant shall complete a Gulf Stream Driveway Permit and a Driveway Maintenance and Removal Agreement. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - June 28, 2012 Page 5 VII. Items Related to Previous Approvals. A. Landscaping revision related to approved renovations and improvements at 1314 N. Ocean Blvd. submitted by Krent Wieland Design, Inc. There was no representation from Krent Wieland Design, Inc. to present the application for the landscape revisions. Mr. Thrasher stated that there were no odd species proposed in the revision and the plan looked okay to Staff. He said he is authorized to approve minor changes only and the changes to this landscape plan are major, which is why this has been brought back to the ARPB for approval. Chairman Ganger commented on the roof of this home saying that he drove by during daylight hours and it is a beautiful roof and very appropriate for the design of the home. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve the revisions to the landscape plan. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. VIII. Items by Staff. A. Additional Review of Proposed Amendment to Section 70-238, Roofs, as Written in Proposed Ord. 12\4. Mr. Thrasher stated that Marty Minor was present to discuss additional review of proposed Section 70-238, Roofs, as provided in Ordinance 12/4. Chairman Ganger commended Mr. Randolph for his recommendations, and he said the Commission was open-minded, they reacted to specific proposals and made suggestions, and there was a general feeling that the changes were constructive. Mr. Randolph said the specific issue before the ARPB with regard to roofs is whether or not it is necessary to better define the shade of gray and whether or not the language should be more specific than "appropriate for the neighborhood." He said so many shades of gray are brought before the Board and the ARPB tried to make it broad enough to allow for discretion to make a decision as to whether a certain shade of gray is appropriate for the neighborhood. Mr. Lyons said the ARPB suggested deleting "slate -like" and the Commission felt that would be too rigid. Clerk Taylor clarified that the Commission stuck with real gray slate for Bermuda style architecture only. She said if a structure is not Bermuda style, the roof tile can be considered under another Code section where nothing specific is required. Mr. Minor said the Commission considered eliminating specific shades of gray and they wanted input from the ARPB concerning "appropriate for the neighborhood." Chairman Ganger noted that the issue of "appropriate for the neighborhood" was brought up by Commissioner Anderson who lives in Place Au Soleil, which is a very eclectic neighborhood. Vice -Chairman Morgan said that the eclectic nature of Place Au Soleil argues in favor of even more discretion, and he said he believes the phrase should be maintained. Mr. Thrasher noted the proposed language in Section 70-238 (a) and he said it is not necessary to define shades of gray because the flexibility for the Board to evaluate a home is provided in the underlying section. Clerk Taylor said when you look at different Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - June 28, 2012 Page 6 architectural styles, another shade of gray may be more appropriate. She said, for example, the new home at 1314 N. Ocean may not be as attractive with a very dark shade of gray. However, she said the home at 554 Palm Way, which is a different architectural style, called for the dark contrast. Chairman Ganger pointed out that roof tile looks different in daylight and suggested reviewing a proposed roof tile outside to get a better idea of the actual color. Mr. Minor said the exterior color of the home should be considered. Mr. Stanley said it is helpful to consider the rhythm of the street. Mr. Thrasher said, on a Level I, he will only approve flat white thou and thou smooth uncoated tile or gray slate. He said anything other than that would go through the Level III process. Mr. Randolph said the ARPB must send their recommendation back to the Commission concerning the issue of gray roof tile and the phase "appropriate for the neighborhood." He said a unanimous consensus of the Board that the recommended language is appropriate will be sufficient. Clerk Taylor stated that Commissioner Anderson has strong feelings about the phrase "appropriate for the neighborhood" due to certain projects that were approved in Place Au Soleil. She said the detached 2 -story garage that was approved in Place Au Soleil is a type of structure which is far removed from that area. Clerk Taylor said when considering amendments to the Subdivision Code and how widespread a neighborhood should be, the ARPB scaled it back. Mr. Randolph said the Code language provides discretion and he does not believe it should be changed. Chairman Ganger noted that the primary issue with the 2 -story garage was privacy and what was appropriate for the neighborhood was secondary. He said the home was the first built in Place Au Soleil, it is a very eclectic home, and neighborhood design was not paramount. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the ARPB did not recommend approval of that application, the Commission approved it. It was the unanimous consensus of the Architectural Review and Planning Board that the recommended language in Section 70-238, Roofs, (a) concerning gray roof tile, and the phrase, "appropriate for the neighborhood" is appropriate and there are no further recommended changes. Chairman Ganger noted that Mr. Randolph recommended Criteria K in Section 62-10, Criteria for Subdivision Review, which provides for no clear cutting of parcels, and he said the Commission approved the recommended language. It was the unanimous consensus of the Architectural Review and Planning Board that the language in Criteria K is appropriate. IX. Items by Board Members. Chairman Ganger mentioned that he attended a Town of Manalapan Commission Meeting where they discussed the issue of term limits. He said their Planning Board and Architectural Board are separate and their Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - June 28, 2012 Page 7 members have term limits, and he said the Town of Manalapan will have a referendum for term limits for Commissioners. Chairman Ganger said when he addressed their Commission he suggested merging the two Boards. He extended an invitation to Commissioner Gottlieb to attend a Gulf Stream ARPB meeting. Mr. Stanley said there is a possibility of an application being filed in time to be included on the July 26th ARPB Meeting Agenda. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Stanley if he will have to recuse himself from the proceedings on July 26th and Mr. Stanley confirmed that. Mr. Smith noted that the hammerhead at 1220 N. Ocean Blvd. is under construction. Chairman Ganger said he heard there was a contingent as to whether the developer has fulfilled his obligation to the parties of the Neighborhood Agreement with respect to drainage. Mr. Thrasher said the Town has been advised that the drainage plan has been installed. He said the developer was required by South Florida Water Management District to acquire their permit. Mr. Thrasher said Neighborhood Agreement requires maintenance on the pipe because it can frequently clog which will cause flooding on either end of the pipe. He said the Town's approval process required that they apply for, and receive, appropriate regulatory permits. X. Public. There were no public comments. XI. Adjournment. Mr. Smith moved and Vice -Chairman Morgan seconded to adjourn the meeting. The meeting was adjourned at 9:40 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-08 Owner: Thomas & Kirsten Stanley Address: 3524 Oleander Way Agent: Roger Cope, Cope Architects Proposed Improvement: Partial demolition and additions to an existing 1 -story single family historic Polo Cottage. Approvals Requested: Special Exception: To permit air conditioning equipment to encroach approximately 2' into the South side setback. Demolition: To remove a portion of existing West wing and the existing one car garage. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit demolition of a portion of the West wing and existing one car garage, the addition of a two car garage and expansion of the West wing, a total of 1,492 SF to the existing 1 -story, single family historic Polo Cottage, and to permit an encroachment of approximately 2' into the South side setback to accommodate air conditioning equipment. Gross Lot Size: 18,816 SF Effective Lot Area: 18,816 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 3,015 SF Allowable: 6,209 SF Zoning District: RS -C Considered During Review: Section 70-74 Setbacks. Height: 14' Section 70-75 Special Exception setbacks. Section 70-77 First floor elevation. Section 70-99 Roof design, slope and materials. Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights. Section 70-187 Table of District Standards. Substantial Improvement Review. The existing home is below the 7' elevation required by the Flood Insurance Rate Map for this area. As such, the home may not be improved in excess of 50% of the existing home's value. The property owner has submitted documentation indicating that the threshold has not been exceeded. Recommendations: Motion to recommend approval of a special exception to permit air conditiong equipment to encroach approximately 2' into South side setback. Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 2 ARPB File #012-08 July 26,2012; TC August 10, 2012 Motion to recommend approval of a demolition permit to remove a portion of an existing West wing and the existing one car garage. Motion to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed demolition of a portion of the West wing and existing one car garage, the addition of a two car garage and expansion of the West wing, a total of 1,492 SF to the existing 1 -story, single family historic Polo Cottage, and to permit an encroachment of approximately 2' into the South side setback to accommodate air conditioning equipment meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: July 26, 2012 Action: Special Exception: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action: Demolition (Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action: Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Town Commission Date: August 10, 2012 Action: Special Exception: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Action: Special Exception: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Action: Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review: Approved as recommended. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM oltECEIVEDe JUL 0 9 2012 %,a t otW1 Stream, FL TIONFORDEVELOPMENT APPROVALy This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 1,2 " To be completed by all applicants. PART 11. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.I. Project/Owner Name: Historic Polo Cottage/Thomas M. Stanley and Kirsten B. Stanley I.A.2. Project Address: 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, FL I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: _ Lot 57, Gulf Stream Properties No. 2, Plat Book 18, Page 42, together with that portion of the .South half of the right-of-way known as Pandanus Road, lying North of adjacent lot 57. I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stones, etc.) New single story west wing - 795 sq/ft (consisting of kitchen, laundry room, third bedroom and bath; New single story detached garage - 697 sq/ft I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: See above. Architectural Style: — Cape Cod -cottage 1.A.6. Check all that apply: 0 Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing 0 North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) A Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses o Variance (complete section G) X Special Exception (complete section) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: 6.5' auger pilings Type of Foundation: _ B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address- 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, FL 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number: 561 276-6363 ext 102; fax - 561 -276-8881; email: tom(cDmacmillanstanie .com 1.B.3. Owner Sianature- C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: ope Architects I.C.2. Agent Address: 114'/ NE 4"' Avenue, Delray Beach, FL 33444 I.C,3. Agent Phone Number: (o)_561-789-3791 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: — Com Date: _ Decision: cell Fax Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC bate: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART ill. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question. number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? RS - Gulf Stream Core - Polo Cottages III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? -Yes ❑ No Explain._This is a renovation in keeping with the historic architectural style, size and scale of the existing polo cottage to create a single family residence that may be used by a- ---`family with children. III.A.3. Is the prolecc consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? P Yes ❑ No Explain,— This is a renovation to preserve the polo cottage as a single family residence now and into the future. The project is not contrary to FLUM and the comprehensive plan. iII.A.4. How are Ingress and egress to the property to be provided? The ingress and egress to the property shall remain the same as currently exists.' However, the rear drive to the new detached garage will be wider to accommodate the two car garage (whereas currently there is a one car garage). `— III.A.5. How are the following utilliies to be provided to th%property? a. Stormwater Drainage b. Sanitary Sewer C. Potable Water d. irrigation Water e. Electricity f. Telephone g. Gas h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) The proposed detached garage complies with Section 66-144. It is the same as the existing garage except that the proposed garage is a two car garage instead of a one car garage. The materials and elevations mimic the existing structures. PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A Is to be completed by al/ applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes"to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV -A.1. Does the project Involve land area within fifty feet (501) of the AIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes Pf No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? S Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3, Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes m No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Q Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) 1V.A.6. is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes allo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? The architectural features will remain the same as the existing home. The detached two -garage will be larger than the existing one car garage. The landscape features will remain similar from the street except for the addition of Clusia trees to soften the rear elevations from Gulf Stream Road. The ficus hedge along west boundary of property and Gulf Stream Road will remain. IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: The existing one car garage floods and has exceeded its useful life. The new construction of the West Wing is to make the house functional for a family with a third bedroom, bath, and laundry room contiguous to the existing main house. IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or Impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.6.5. What.mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a- Demolition Permit W.C.I. When are the existing structures to be demolished? As part of the construction project _ Fall - 2012 — IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? Immediately after the demolition - T Fall 2012 IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? The structures are not land marked. D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E• Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1 • Is the Proposed use a ' p permitted special exception use? IV.E,2, How fs the use � Yes F-1No Code Section: 70-75 designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the welfare, and morals will be protected? public hearth, safety, .This special exception is the locate the HVAC (mechanical equipment) in the South Setback (on the south side of new proposed garage. The equipment should be located away from the outdoor patio areas of the home. IV.E,3, Will the use cause substantial injury to the v be located? ❑ Yes p No alue of other property in the neighborhoo d where it is to Explain. No, the location of the HVAC unit will not insure other property in the neighborhood. The neighbor to the south has HVAC equipment next to the property line in the setback as well. IV.E.4, Now will the use be compatible with adjoining development Is to be located? and the character of the District where it The use is singly family residential. The HVAC unit will conform to the standards in Section 70-75. IV•E•5• What landscaping and screening are provided? There is existing landscaping along the south boundary line - including Eureka Palms. Per the landscape plan, a Clusia hedge will be added as well to create a buffer. IV -E-6- Does the use conform with all applicable located? regulations governing the District wherein it is to be Explain._ special exception is necessary to keep the patio and open space of the home functional and to accommodate the design of the detached `---'—garage (which is in keeping with the historic character of the home). F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the to y are be maintained. IV -F-2- if recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them Properties, and their potential impacts on surrounding IV,F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 'tiw"gulf Stream N. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.I-{.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? JV -H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, ' zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, Please describe the need and justification for the request, PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on firs fo pplicants are encouraged, ,but not required, to provide any This entire Part is optional for all applicants. ,q the other materials submitted with the application. nn or on any of —The proposed project includes the demolition of the existing west wing containing the existing kitchen, laundry room and third bedroom and bath. This addition was completed well after the 1927 construction of the main house. The construction is substandard and in need of an upgrade. The ` purpose of this construction is to update this portion of the home and create a fully functional three _ bedroom and three bath home for family use. It is further designed to incorporate the existing pool —into the home. The existing one car garage is small and in disrepair. The new garage will provide adequate room —for cars, storage, and additional laundry facilities. The garage remains detached to be in keeping with the historic architectural style of the home. The garage and addition will have hurricane impact windows and doors. The siding will be —The siding to withstand the elements. The roof will be gray asphalt shingle - which is what currently exists. The new roof will have more _ dimension than the existing shingle roof. Samples will be provided for staff review and approval. Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 200() revised 618/00 Page 7 r1 0 WAL � SET NA,'L LB 353 15.04' w Wl7TESS CORi1ER� / ^/ ,/ +3.83 _ CU F S ��FjL� �� SET NAIL & Ll'SfC _ R�_ �s3 15.04' w I (` Tn�ss Ca�j /' A V E D — —_ POLE ON �H MAR!(• TOYS — 3.5+` CORNER CA TCH ® NAIL ADD Gg BASIN R/y1 57< +335 ELEVA 170N .1-389 L 3.5' 142.,35-' 60?, 21.50' J ZNO J. g 18.3' U F m 28.3' uj -um to 0.7' h n Z a oo �rf)ti `ON) N 7.5 o0i=Z W. M.0 ti � 2Z BENCH MARK- TOP NAIL ADD WASTER ELEVAT70N +3.82 4. 17.4' FLOOR p +584 12.1' cq 18.2' CONC. PA 770 4.4f v POOL CONC. PA 770 4.45 5.0' P.E.-" ] 4.6 P.E. �1 a 18.8' 1 STORY RESIDENCE\ #3524 FLOOR +6.45 FLOOR 6.3' +6.27 e= 62+ l� U 213' COVERED J CONC.. CONC. I t WALK U R o �c, :.5 �� LIFT ( ,r) STA TION `--� Rlbl +5.36 FCfj'IrL7?ED CGV�L. CONC. S7EP 37.8' /TL VV / \I PA VEO -OLEANDER WA Y - 5 '''i2 a002Z �- - - - -T O Zoo ZoI R OrqC) Orq�y� azo O�Z ����v un zE Z�2�� O ~tom a c�nc1cn IT O��I O� ad In Lo 2vni CZ rl�_ � �(z•r.�oo �� tir�0� �a� �& c Lo co Zy Z�nti �j "Z Q) sz)� yrs �r r-ri O %� Q) I rnZa� I 0.7' h n Z r II oo �rf)ti 7.5 vr�: r Q II n n Z p a k00aZ Na a� rn=�U TT y _rr-rt, ao � jv II` 4 � N Q� Z n O Zoo r W. M.0 ti � 2Z BENCH MARK- TOP NAIL ADD WASTER ELEVAT70N +3.82 4. 17.4' FLOOR p +584 12.1' cq 18.2' CONC. PA 770 4.4f v POOL CONC. PA 770 4.45 5.0' P.E.-" ] 4.6 P.E. �1 a 18.8' 1 STORY RESIDENCE\ #3524 FLOOR +6.45 FLOOR 6.3' +6.27 e= 62+ l� U 213' COVERED J CONC.. CONC. I t WALK U R o �c, :.5 �� LIFT ( ,r) STA TION `--� Rlbl +5.36 FCfj'IrL7?ED CGV�L. CONC. S7EP 37.8' /TL VV / \I PA VEO -OLEANDER WA Y - 5 '''i2 a002Z �- - - - -T O Zoo ZoI R OrqC) Orq�y� azo O�Z ����v un zE Z�2�� O ~tom a c�nc1cn IT O��I O� ad In Lo 2vni CZ rl�_ � �(z•r.�oo �� tir�0� �a� �& c Lo co Zy Z�nti �j "Z Q) sz)� yrs �r r-ri O %� Q) I 1. �s 'tst 22.54' +5 =OLW IR. 22.54' (WllIHSS CORDER, :-o C) > Q I+r I 0.7' h n Z r II oo �rf)ti 7.5 II 1. �s 'tst 22.54' +5 =OLW IR. 22.54' (WllIHSS CORDER, :-o C) > Q l� I I n n Z r II oo �rf)ti II II II II n n Z p Z Z y _rr-rt, r� I Z77 Z n r Zoo r II n:zE II OOrjj Il O 11 y O O R1 <p� r O M � O ZeQ Z�O Z O Or r Z rtl z -ri �5 Z n c cra cu COe 4 pig PA P A H 89� R9 gp CW c ph iE— a m� a M 300 m tu — 0 M tpQ4Q ® ca r• D m i rLrLrL 'ri r4 iy r �i mm nil gA To m m � v oam m Ln a . r ca 2a IS T — • ~ m 0 t t t t tTNI� t t tt t CO) �Q a g� ■■ Z 9 E A t�t m D Q ; K y 9 Z � q Z s m r rp�p �_ D m A - al a 0 z a - h_ O�nIn D -�u Oa Om 6) WOW [ Ni�qo p§opo 3eRy 0102r1a pulp; gomgNy4 HFRIM ;TpYp (n OC 53 0 c o �-1 C _ • • �• •- s ��SPSF �"""""�ipF" � '���S��S F $� � " R �.i la � � 9 $8R P ;�� � ��.`. ,. �- �� _ ..ti f-7 00 11 rig 11111w 1111 NAM 3i ! 55 Ai o o (n 90 oz D Z5 No 'noall i D= D Nz co �o c r F v:s ..1 W a• w D Y ic dab r 0 s� a ^ 'O C V• LN 0 C=rn o v ° � o -C , seal m�s���E HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE o o =� =Zam O524 OLEANDER WAY, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA � FloridaFlnnda License Na. AROO13 2 No. REVISIONS Data -Dimnpi 2'. LO 11E y n .y-y'-� IZp -tl0 Dm I .., ,,nn 111 N „�N) nl-�� j> kr 7=n117 €j );;pp _(-I 0-1 EF' '�7=(lA L(�0 -IOz� N(�, rZDj-r 1 r0 1 nnye-1 -n D°Tn,l� r^ DNI ll 1111 W-YZ-1 t -y yn' y I -'S nlll ()pp pltl 41 n1 111 l {�1l DtnT 0 Np C1O n 0 L III -n r1i p L L �1 �I ` l°,), m I T ll Ol�j O Y� h� 1_Ozi' I_ til �fll -I '7r3m (�I�t�i u, ri �I�i l�i Zm;(I 0(n�b° a!➢3 m -p In pl°t�inmR �j �'��i Ir z�00 p' R y D r.- '-C7 Ili2L ylllj-n1 '1r0 '--A $p n u'D A(1 'z 1N -1Wt (nz' Aill p A�In N). TO E N. yy L1 y rN..8 I li rl= D. D 2 g _ �(1 ,�I 3 U IlI 11 I I! 1 I m n �t Azr rA^ r llr {91 pp�h W cm ;(pIA (" i U �I y O (1 ay t -{t n WA m �1c (S�n� qO�l' n z (7 �` l m !G O("nq m-+ Illy tiDp < 1`i y W. -+-I :ig"', [10®m`7 � ? Z() � DyOW we 6 -f (� 0(1 �Z _AT(S () m_y-r-(�.�ril �. D,1�1 � -Di lt13 .LnZ ttIA '�p ,'�°Ip �,�p� mm�:r "'� Uri ° 1AAyI p 1D�1, U'� D 0O1-INO In -1;'{-11 Wi D ;(I' (O1 InD �,.9 rn �j A�-I �t IT1i-1 (j ;lZyl �(y1 ;-(II m(1Wy (�'A RI=' If ll(0(L1 U. ZDD G"� ADm III ,�21 UL tln l°r117 (�G \I =l� 0(1 1 7_� Ltlir j' O -'A l'1 � ^^i y t -1 u'O ). O -I ujD °� In g" t -_A _nZD by Z-- x 111 p r� � 1rt° Ns) �.. b -Ie ILn U,r-' R 0 r4 nip_ -j0 p iu �- ) ^-tl Aj0�3A An Am (1 A ,1 0 Z N() ()h WEpm D Z3A-��O11 iS;-AjOnwD Np�prr- '"m-+Lz W r O I�i _(lu� z _ zypz0 OAS �' �..y A rzi"liy tmm ymcYTlNO Cly O m A°m) °�O� �-izn j FrAO (n 11 Aizn.p OU. ( Q-1 rinb-I°nl O i' -I@-'(1 (1 D;�11�Il A �tu� LO A _4. A° AN zOz�y r_--1 m. A - 1n1 < '�cgD,y-i lilAO 00 °1ntet ]I 1A (°g ®r w0 gOnynl nD� 6G.(9n� Zrr`" m -I m�pOl M In V (�6j 1. �y7_ m° 11ij, -r°W IN -I ImW F an r3$z0 y <�UA, D() OADN l,(i�l �➢ z1D-flp AIL°r-(nA�1I(Ai, ,(IA (21 -1y(P h yLmin D2 yP()t,A Ort �ryn Oio°i 7!ANI 3m� A mN /M� X ltl y b O b - 3 c In L i 111 - nI L Z In -p In O I L iE. =1 Z L �' Irl �I III (� A ;b( 'U -. m 71 T- (n ;;Qp U'�,' ,U << 'iTtt W (l In W��, In n� n1 = ((n Gini=1D tl Ip 1) iY to UI11=g� I�iTa W` D 0z�ii nl,i .j. llm (1 VA OD O'"Oz Ey zZb(n lfl lr-A NW �Iz..D n 7n�tn 74.1 _Ir m�l}I 7_D.LD' �IXI1 nN� L �L mO "n1my 4� 1Ur ISI CV1p �m W' Id'((I m 2nlr ll0 X_I[ rn m O<r Ar QAOxp nlr n_<WA (Dl 7ImDOr (yj)> iil r N rypp O-IA(1- �O y Anlr l(rllA W r nm III. G LP L9br r cpm r 11 -(�'_ E y_ U D- r A�Q 1-I_ _n (1 I'I A 3y-tlEL Z -B nl� (n W1 n(�-1� ;TI -I n- r n- -1-13 (n n Nm ' Lrl�-'l l- iD03 I 9.Q u'p3E1 In _0 Zm-I mll nI Alll° }O"l1 G'nI intoIm ;° z R C�Zn IAAL ' Irl �'m gni win Iln c'" A O�j'wfl (n� O nt ni ii -II Wtg }_�n3A A- _n (i Om0 t=(���}I my In S�Lp�L y� Y r�j Apl InR 1� AiOO .�AA c� zz m A yA OG -+ z cin ' z n2 tN 1° '� III r A..aay 11 ,tl In -i r r N OIMm �l7Xyl!IS iI"c w=UO ZOz �" a� �ht zF ylrip 1W �.�1° mAzyn-m(,A- �m mplmr, �"O �'�1 ni fB cnc77 is b��0 OAO (n In°O �I<(n0�°m�-Yz(Zpil,� ➢Gm -LI°lw- n'. Uu, �- _m -Ip m))���'n y it L)z L in 'mi .E D-11n-�i0'_T LO 3zOpz,h m(ri -rmc0 Nm n�a-' r Q.,g pmlr7p V� W _ mT. I1 (1n' EDS! (1 �'' Iryn T'. n- N, -( O m Ili Cl '- D- D ,Up" m �c-c�1 r_.T_ 10-Ih p"Aln lM(� (121° =Fw•1-A my m °(u 1O [r 011F r-1>ARO D3 _ Onl ml'm yOb1' A zr O ni-'IDp NO� ELT=1 i0 ml'At P, p-'"_ 7 i ig03 Nx n �1 cn�( O L ImY N Z y -A1 ='n -1 r_n L r= 'LL Oni. .. NOT1 m A ZO (u; -1 f Ili 99 't m u m A 11 ,I -11"U <z ONIn- OAIDAA tnp0'<Da Dtn- A-- z 1yy D Nm En 7.NI I I i ➢ In In >Ip_ rT rD Put 9 01 -IN l° Nz� -j j jND. r� A6T mN 71A' A_ G<_ N L-rllII� N L _ Aq g-_ A R_- InfryrO& InRm O' ° m In O -mi -Aiw O i DD n T-( �f ni IN O b' n A ) N aI ,tI Irl A y . �{ �lpl lr y (n nl In !" rn m < y rr. _ n Z T ,0 p in _ N 'tl Z ° al- DA- LbF A rZ- 8 (o �j A�p O(1 P N, AD1° m tlL r �O O 3yDmn mlll I.i-r 32- np -rI n1 �i (1 yL zz (..A O_ yyyQ➢ �.,,. by.q nO Im �i� nw0 n m yA AAnA_n _I� W u, A -I n' p y I-4„ 4mA7Q I v,- mOnlZ z 111Ar G ° 7("7( 2- ) ,1 N Sim Ol�l b _ �' QIn m_ - -n �yz � izily0 In a inz Eto u; l� l� Q L W Ir N S 1 Al N nIn$ i Z hl C IGuI U' W 1117 In /t ()- II -r 0 �,��,Il z rODDpp Z = D.� I -I �_ -1'11 O WD IG -IWC- -1 r' z n c i' l) Z A r z 0. - O I�I r r' A m' -1 0 E in 0- 10-1 li "' pD QIO z(PA ,n� GIIN. N- n< m_(I, i A, ,A I Z WD In m c. O y ._�n Oen Um ry Nei -1 UAQ�AT r..17L. Ip 1n'-An1� pD AD yA f. � 1"�ix A Allr yr°mG_I A m_�pr N � yy €Z-O�' Si ^I �I�b_p ^�Er rl�n)Ain Nz f 1= _ 111 y T_ (n - D (n ll r W A ._ 'B (� (� U �1II �l [, A ]' ( -/ E fA^r 1. c u, l;; lr- 2-Ofn3 yn W mnl 7: �'110b bE In'"1. 'F ��II CN U �p -1�> L ,�I_7N It m �n�l1By_ 1"�1 U ay. j A �r-1r IUW yRAW r� pub �p tllyNy a T nl= l♦i; =(1� (w I'ITmmm �.. i�°Z�n°D^ x(� p y z m- m, A �� 11D rnn -� m x y 3 .■�{! n In <j �Oz g rp =1pi�l c1 O -( yl" y.0 r nlryP •1`1 T O 0 30 3�n °DOm wDz<"' _Z� nib " N On -'b 1.1^m Or �1 m o yo 4 ^' OLFA� �A. oT L N r $�<o �� < Dn A- A Y o• c� Ar0 Pm yy QD '(- NO 33N' (u o y A y < Ill ll ;lI N G D� D z E y X 9�n Am y -1 t y < nt_ m A° m �m €ml"- Dy b m Iz 1-�1- a 41 A-t-�_iriz� (dA S� Gln nizW�A 0( D prL Lr 3-1y <D 1n n in �il A y m R (I1N m Zp r m41 bT� Itly-p rh m n Zbd W -(�A = r7 Z z m m i� Dy (1 r r0 m,"_nC y A -(-- -+ E (1�7 n' h Q S� n� -( FF 111 N _1 m O m -1-11 m 0 z 7AI n =1 D o c n -I 1 llp I a -AR -Ino �r02 O(�TO '"Gm 11L 7 D cA oLz�cAm O DE AL�n AI_.N n4, n�r �XW yr yp 1. ylnppp A A a I p(cCiy Ey- m u;'"S ° G"( m i OD A-r(S pm0%Ilm w rLb� ZZ yx '� Rm O U� y sym ➢ll1 ;0 (11n lnpy!n (n 7( OW.n "' mn'nl x A- I" nIN-I Nin OA c �n o~ n Yq p 41 --N I-- an- I'1 4 O _ _YZb ® zm �- r O' -1 Vy A g z- z N O. i" r� A m �. I- '° 1- O In < _ , z ZZ W y ® O N D y 9 nl - �1 n _ -1 y_ir nl�z'-nrya %>LL �_ A (O n1 OG1 ' O 4� 'yam A-<? � ,¶T p!^ VI �znz "] r� r4' _A y- Z -i+ rl� O � O ng r" mi i-7 laq AI In In f ff��()z-- -(y Ill�n_ D1> A- T=Z filNpy'-1 @ZL 1 (1 E I xrl'i O A O N �n ltl Zrmm Wn,� �� m(D1�y mz� O-wi n-IOZ ni -ltlp p - AO' ➢m' zpGr m y 1-(mn-' n y5 y in0 nA t 41 y ro (1 Iii- U m O( rD� pO A-IDj(T-i, N () T. y 41' A �z . m 8 D' R m _-1 fill c gr O -p1 m A-- 3 mm AF a �(1'i -1 n IU m -1- D ry u, -1 i z. 11:1 Zy u' r `' ..1!" II RI rnO -nr rmOjj 1 I(1 y- A °n �z� S ° ,oU -I () 1- Fllnl r. m m n p nl m O Q n '0 A In Z 0, In m L r. Z N U, n N A nl J U A nl 20 D� �- G y -, 435 A m A (zl. A in . _ B ° D (�-p nn EE DD -tt1 ;(vlrn� in m�nlni nrf.._ rDznO E�w D2<in (((���A, r-n.p A I -TM 23 (ny0 OX i°mm3 r-Dn' zyOm ZDII Li �l n. ya-0 77z-tl �EEn (n lrj �InDa (l3"tl D I -r y O y z r'�A In gr" r 43A L�y D ynjmm3(n E a X D.IIZ R-( y 71m L-EiO ,�I Ax c Wx O A. til -_ n rll➢ �I 7�' DF(^ QcROi A_ �gy z rZIR N X -1 <y;;1ttIb it O(�O nzm -IORN' ('i l� �tCpy rel �. U -+ 1813 ,1 m O y rQ MON (n Dtn3 1�'T= c (� O�{ ]�Za m0 n� r AlIn O Om N Wm" 1 it III IIIA D y �7p b m In"rL mQD ='ntPy `- 1 O_D DQ '"zyAcS -IOr ®m r A- °' 1,,'x(1 mm QiO ate 0 $ G TOD () r �7p1y� In -, _ W Iti• �1 7C Din W y 'n XU"2°- r F °rmm Dr7 mW DT,i m -r '- a A z W D i?O VA_Iy$ -1 n tl, i nl IQ. Q L ni ° -' lj I Q -1 r -1 z' Q Cn A 2 mea y �1 -I 1"- r n DD m3 .. -1 a 3 a C D^ ryry (prp1 z ;(l Z y ➢ W D D ;(l n D Q n, AI m� c� Z -N ll QL nD A D O mp Om -n _ -0 4�m O Ac @4)A3 ,L:II,I�< Jr,y,7l -I�z3 (OnD3 0"1�='AO Q_ �mnp7C1 ➢1-O �n-I IIIA pnlO OT - In m •ij2� rc Ti -r '( mU ;1I (p� ;p EIS (1p ma4.' c -+E SIX -,p `�P'r(�1 �1 aY' �Iil€ a(n -I("�' Q_ n 2y -1 xI n $ -"-'4-1 p htn A �Amln Oy rn -1 Cr- �O D z�A 2'r11� L7`1t�n haDm T(lU �-1 (P 111 ll 1h Dllla_ Q- ~ ImC(� r,ply L y F E E nm Wmttd A AO r ° OAt. r�'�O �ip0'n °z Z n zD brZ-Iyy pN m''O Q_.Ini z g' $n3�yAa� n m n 2z -1j n. W O ;l(Q'ImA ry O ZEA �1 A mm ➢m m ;(I y m i -1y A_(` A�L�AInz (1ym O� a (1 l<I -t AYI -° Oe AQ�,O rIII Oi i 17i tiles z E � tm�t uR �z y to arm pX p g fl L1�A0 8y it, I M EEA 3H 0 �-1 O®2 6 YR n�x.N TiyiP lfiObOli-::i1 Pm '"b Nm < 7�1q. O m y m m' T�N�^ Z u' r N E -( N F OD min i -a ND A -1 n m m n r b -'- 1 O- L.. a Z qq Q �_ A_ W Lm- N O� z �lbA 1 N (� l7pl aa11 ° A m 41rr i E° mm��1 0Nln ®cm DO a1 mu' r E nA➢Az.z A�ia- y Ap ASO^ N -(O-1 ;(l W �(' InZr 7tl pO -In ➢yz ay f� WnR� r� ti y, pA A= ZO m Ap LS ynl�l zoz r ', In -( 300 rn 3 z_° y maT p 7C _ �O(I' py r .(y p p 9R - -,a vn Znl1'tlA $ Z n m�W �z t- - W N2,InW y o p R _ L1 -1 ➢m m r E 11 r Ly" r =1 ➢ J.. �Ip m,., yap ym<mllA u; (I ni �ID-of� -n 70 ( O D ( r�I QZ�II m _�l z z0 OJn [n uylw y-(l.j3in D Gn y'- z-(m'bil "In� 3.1 O ;U-IDD°'7yl z E n- x NX ➢ (" Will (� y EjT" y"'g z 21P 4` OA Op m N r p IP nII1D .°D i, T O �yr x 0 -1 °(10 y zlnZ ma (1 i inU y OU(lr WniNA 1> myCl N N D r -1m N W I'a AM,, D W r;(I "Ll yQ � ym X L r =I<Dz -tl-((m < nG) yp�Q�A Ng O;(In O. p y3tnn0-A D(Xn n�3 U !,An '-'o ry0 tl�a�L ApAU D�WTA z=_ r�i �Ziiiiii111lllrp zp r a�1t p� �I m0 ,Ao Vz nOn A°Oa�.-a Q'( ;;1111y3m.oZ nWrP O~ Iyr ACOm �A�I N -1 1 rm zmm O m w3 D3 At y y Ifl Z r_1! Rn p- Am -IIIL 9O9n .� DO 0-nnl�$ In (l� �A3.OL E ifii R aI� b r -� h EL y O W flb y �➢ 7l y zD D I i [w=U € °<m�C'_ m -( m -I ° LD y I r ym b D QTn 9 D- 6 'D �_Ir- w0 r =zy�D;( n W O n1 AmUniD w' E m A L iAi, 7 I i l gn- n_ �n L `z' I�i (ny yyW x 3� _L Z nS A nI ha D i, A, 1, ® ,1 nm O 3 z pr 3r i r 3 z O ®y• �:(I A �-� r °D X �z �x E_m (Dl, t`�aD -1 gtirDDcnU ➢ E $p 'T I P m o r r z W_ In o ® my(@ a- 6` n x -- 1 nl iii D S £ 0 A In y 7 O ,4G O r m € Z m AZ - r mAA OR -IO I-1i�5 mmrD. -1 E �- mU y OmA A-1IDm m_y m- Dr (v (� 11i0 O O ZQ r�A R n OAA IA fAii® Ay ((�1-Iin j3F€ H r y m_A mmit� m ay i71D-(= Z D W cyD 6) L r �, y O Z 771ID-tl N 11 m E y' 3 rrii T �- y-I�niL n a m r -1 -1 y AA W 'nn uQ Dy. y� i mnlr nIA -°i2 p� 1 In y pO O OA-Di9 T WFj-a Em 1ym GnDDw mw Ilt I -°i D A �A °OnO Zti m000 A(1 mOh w -<P �A nicm_i A° �-DI O i llc� -I r!" -I p �A A my zY nm m -I QO-�(I y((1131�i tnm ,p m I A A-- 7b1 Iii Z O �� p �np A(zPDDy in O y-pWNR aZ- QI=@ O NS�iFI Lc U Ir13EE QcY-1-iXA-nDz L z Z- 11 D ,�;1Il I Z (�D y Ny a_D ,1 p- W,��II 4' ,N L) �n�n(P-1 ° V ��_ 3p rrymy E bot) < 0-1 m�l�$,�p=llPm A�3yD 11° �iQ 2(� N_ y,U OE F IIInIDTe R1z ;➢ y U,Ym-I 1y11 ?yD rm-p ZA m11I y R n -12 r(P nD �. C NR O_ -( II () W �Iw -i ,Q1 y yn1 D L ( 3 D �_ II aA1 O Iii lSl AO h yy ,�Ir q II n15 A� 'In'" �O ;1I) p nl 1 1Q° A m ti(wn,n O'(1 n x Ifl m -I m_-I�rU O DDg BOO �iO1n I ina A m IQ1S� < °A-. r A�j_ $y (lQ -tl T -F �^�^ ,���I1 z A x I�i -p '�O w ry0� �i-I lm�z za l�G�q ni -I=m,°Iwrili_m A A �j.wi-_ �rmw7/> x14'I. W'{ bLC=( ( 07(� °O -,II y 13n pp �_ Zrxn_tl 0'- •l)O �7r (jp�I E<i Z� -( �IIIpn6R1 -+ , ODZp=1�p A m ° Dr�i I Z A(3' w pDm�l� (1 "'�I N.ZE 1U0 in MT y mQ EyA�) (lpOy r m_ r LC r m r- mll Z L N L m r N nn nt m A,I Tln yr zm�-( aA A UD;;(Cll zb 'r�z A ?'0 {l i� D -O r IT -Qn �m �Dp-1 �P W y A m Z D 711 Oy W n N DN Yi (I rj € m LO300y _�i, DV IIP A nli r71 r L O m D m r- O + �u Ly til wGN nC- r®-° p� r m3DUy}(1,� m 1r-'' 111 -InA E UU,N AEAD () AIn zAm-(L LW "l U' x1n N l: rn171r1 �j ()< pm N in nl�y t�0 rD m Z C -'71a_ w m Oo m_ mx D =10 y y -1u h Mnm Y Z ry OE A Dz�1 1°- m I l7 ll ryry W y7--(^ N r Om p N 0 1" -( � r l7 D (^ m m y 7i 1, a m n -1 C Zn �- r` n mi- n m€ r. 2 - m DD n$ r p $ F m nn �Oby D rh F- r m, r z-1 `NO a A�GZ rm m y �O D ;(1 y O m n3 A�,II 2,O 1 i�Q nt S yn yyE 3 til Rmy�) 1y y �t11 2hDLWI` �IllyyO ty n,.niy r� ,�l I11 -( ®E y n a -11 77cc(1 -{ rtl 1 W (� 1 (� L i, n Al Z ((E�1i -I A -, --(1 71 i- n O -- fll 3 ni A°z LI' yt myl- QA` D Zii r-_ Of�ln ll ?�iUm Zm nzm <�j mm'tlzz- 3 D 2" Om g lam pal in Dwnl ADo '° � 7D1 m A® m (o -D-1° n r�iilD .D A -(E yuOin � EZ @E��OG) A,Id off' w 7c° ;Uy III rN m qOqO l�n In 3D A o y 3 wyz -1 rn �i -IAr O(J 000,'°�1� nl U. ° din to II z n b w m n O Q«tllllll I�A m m� (j tiji-I w m T i A �i E A A i • N z © tD W 4` U• A !" - r➢ W J 0 to t. z 41( °i -0 nnn n � o o -n i$n mn °� ) r = m p,� °^yL 3l1 i n 3 vE ° DI -c- 4 - { z n n y fl �r��z r < b § n W _3 g- ZZ{ypW y3 in sz nv x((���// -°- D In AI p mLDltl wm 3 3A A m x a 1n;1t Nb -(z -(�i, p0 - b _ p + Xr YD�iA um -In Z =rte m� nN D BJP z in �R-��1 �i n Ng x(riw0 mNA tlL n�Dyn ®� ii I 'A it°70 y0 -1 y." Om 1>3,ily j Ily- my t�D to llo �O w0_ S-np I�r -I r °Ct LS-. Iris r r- y r �> n�Ew Dp Z �1 n nln t^, ]0 in Till py .z D- �n zNzo�E ( ( m mA (PZ m y r 1a Z r =iOD° n r r r b_ b0 1l G N rw r ym :4 ty O, y Z. (11 DE u,V „➢ '7y1 O,tMT �glUz Oyr r i.n In -1 m nm I -it 3 AE r�n,i D. �_ DO -tlr37 c c3 y D = y� cl\ O in y pm c -° IrILD z -R ZD EA- °y E In alt OD. �1W 000 A- h M CI a mm�'� lflzz-� tn-➢ �I3 ZU I� p m O N -(y W$_ my -i iy Nm O A- iU ttl i 3 U _ rll Q _yA yb<n N g;0 r D;(1 rn- tr g 'OV m{ pN-o AW m 1 m N �A =1N- m nl Om In O A A y r N Im a41n g- 1 ZO 0 Oa1u pz Zm Oy ° �Q�II Om1 z q (Lid« AXn V OCJ V pR�Z- Z Ni ,r O D I:. of Om c3 n=I N Ny Ly� gOD TA., n= NT nffc ll m An Dm u, --1 ;C1 0 ^ z -IrD 1- Y W c 0 i._. W DIII n to Y r1 G_ i O (^® ZL r2 y fC'Da 3t1 �1 r �Ana N L mE m "Ig A �' r3 n <rs II m D mlfl Ir y-( '- Uzn rw 0 p�0 s7.lhl0 irnly> (!' i A 1° rll m DI. —i m A ° (Py a'r-1- W Am- "'n mmc SS�W n z o p '9 1 1>Ur- t, Y It1 m ON._ -n 3 A O Oit �m ny Zng �� ® �i.Op Zu'6- °Ayn' __ Z ,ill m- w y A y C zr qqp. Y A�1 p M °° v c�E QA n < 4��;;((1I r c� -,(n;p Wmm� (°�,� "n ��I AR �ppn gnlpp pr- -0 E< A m"A Art 3 -rlm p Ori R m n0 1> D r 9417[ �p 1> 1 N le o'7C 87 (lg 3 r_ ➢ rl'Ny O �I r-()� fll u m'� Oi (n =I �I 3y D ° r z 41n 7RCy p Sc111 A Z A.. i m I m b mD N i 'flb ern �W fli U+I IIIA F A- p m u. 1 mn .t4 (��CI 1 1 C-1 L1vL O ® n t. D xT in y Z r or 7_r lij (-UrI z x m m B zRIU fr�"' nt r9 m y fn r0 a,2 z-1 W{ -am -( n' D 0 O� nl W ll. o(1 L � 7 o -'I fP n EA rn W ;A(l nr n ��II --(( y O < A yy -I Illi yp Y n'z O n'All (nl _.,m L j3 (1 (nA E c1 D r � fpm N"I'n0 TA lyz D_ IFI InA zy y n1 if DIP o_ E mW m� -I Ny O Lb1 wUT Uf1 On m �I O-1 m A nl Q yE. 5^ (o z0A ll 0 "7 �D D OE yi A V• 2 EN it 1 E-wpr 1_yFn� c�wi °-B b X~ n Ifi0 L —f �1 r-� M i() O �C4-' N_ ° N y �' DQ c1 D r Tn n 1 D 1' O-' x Q-1 DFd mD ,n oI n u 1 N z nv C �m r ° v� �m i yr Rm n Nr I �3g am i. r M <_ go A11 m�j t;1z 3 M r yI r➢ hD,l O -e C1 c7 r W 1 c� r „7c m ADV nD A m ,lI In O E 1 _p r Af nl Lln p'S' Zr n0 2� g3 m� Z 'z- r 1�1r Vii �A ('(1y �(- y 1nVN nz N p,tl-1 I -ii _(�, N z0 Fnm.t NA �ib mD-,p NA _A XD 011 -°w T' A- mn rli m 0 y 11 m y y O DA"0 o, Ito � mZ y7l �tl M n Erli '11 O z r D w IID D-z�- w #� ° m ;UFIG p c nln m_ y y41 p Np �- 77Iw In r m pA -IA N1'.-( yAA D In y A p I �'(ptl NT Nr Z X A NU,_ LIII' O. Zj f N- Tj Vy ;(I E n h-1 U, y NQ A min 3 yv 0 �ty u IB 3 �' y -nDD t>D ° p € o- ' N �m y 1- <° i Z -� 3 U ll a -Z 'tl- g A- TUI -' I Zy nlr- 1 b r r zW Um )swe;(1 TZ- U % A� az A ° z- W O r-_ O r z I� nE Z 7a DX L "1 Az ..2- 7C Om �I O O u c� , y0 A r in 'U Lab A =1 h z ("'Qi N °III j"ly O nin �� yy if gR y z Ly Ul as A Am�,-,U� DDi L1 Am r -I a oo EA pant pa N< I_r0 4 11i �°1� (ny L. z� in gill IIn O E i my gid j Ami§ Tm Dc az, -° F➢ r ° s� �U c �. °5 Z -z it �p mm p ET a�1 nm g �_ 2� x� € A lnDpA nv zz w q 013if -' iE0 �nl A�G1 C. y34 3N mA n, nes 3m O (l I= A 3�;A Ar p m�rri n m D� i'-tl 3 ill WO SA mw o m N-� px"�, yp Oz yes_ InyV g .w A yn r- o vi i W 2 n W 2-l° wG� ° �" i ��" l' s °c 1 y� n _ 3i r -(_ O n a D y rn ;;1111 y z r S�IIL _ 11yyppQ- r ,�;(II i��ull y t�A _( p -tlA A� n L Im3 m0 p O- EEy tP m. nIM j -n fn 171 Ojc yyza OU®-� DE 1=m '- in c °ai NO ^Z UII rm-WA a m yAl- F€ A ill•- z�n a ?i'i Oal G °, u. In nT r�n� n m A 0 y i mpyp p 1:in�+ o� poll y6 4p in A 2° �A �W° 'W° �I C)�r m N ZJ(1 yl OZ .,qq°° AI°_ U,m N y rnO M yes'n ga b _y Lr m I -° p ➢ Ay O mpA 6 Lc ,1 a O ,n C1 O o3 0Q C2ni� R3 L O F3 _1 (1 ll r� Q I In ={ r l -I yTlt' r®0 m"' ay z<" L ,lZ z nE 1"� N L "'mltl ,n "I Da�IIz j p y n N ➢r -n y� y Z ]6yj D A "zly0 ;;((1InA ® DI'X" -Xi 1 1 '"-D' OD R- O ®fn -' g n 'CI ° 7 nm a m I -h n F^ 11 O r 0 Y y 0 In O 10 A D f. n r (1 c D '1 ° In _ a T ill T�1 t m Oil 00 ll c 'n' g y� n n nt u, m A n N In r b -r T Z -n n m m j�I 0 1 q I Irl 7 y 711P 6 A- "� S -° CCpt111 A .. A zA Y In �l D r` n '^ 2 YY Irl n i O •'- Cl i(nl O C 6) y -" i (1 11 ° R- Dw nc3 C�Imr( k`jOn 11111Di11o�l17� �O m CF N gn p m y� V 07( Ovw-, -1 �® i. qo1� 'Au in � 7T, � n111 -i �yII III ?^ Jb 1 1> O 1) nG L G1 o y A np wn Lyr It n F�I 11 0- n� y wraW N p [) Z, Z _ AA- A IlI % Z AA G1 (l in _I (n L in -1 y A /l y - ' ^ A nt m z n 3 41 by 33 1� c1 W N Ur y W m011 OAWGrX iti-, NT U= ((11 cT�Om u2, Ir 7 IZ' TU rL -UZ -Dib n'Irm �� O z�-0n D DTyOz rE 3O n7 —F GZ E tl in -n (1) y OmL I rom A §I�Ar ym O� Xm G1 in WI c M -. OW rz rizj�OU D 0c� O O zz to N E-A 111 00` V D D r m Dy mr�0 yu,m ➢ 1- p -I mF A r m"n 1y -r z y i7i z 1nW pN a rQ inq-n �n tln 7111111 rQN E nIo n r p1110 c -ll ti D b;�7 i -y IN mlii y yQ q (Py -11y ( A-1 rN 1fir y� <'1 (wj, gin EG(cj, i- mtv 7-j� SI'_r-JJ rA yA 41m r L13 111 rm y n' A Ayr G��,IIaG ly r�i b7( y7,'y Jr -r r flr 1t, -°l5 ND 'pill- r / Y I., ZOEcy fll E A rcl Rr L m y q7�1 yn p_ 3 b r r (r r r OnR-(A L1] 7t ill n A Z Zr- mn Oy Nyr Cn1i IT A yR r yDE ;�(n Ny-1 p mTyZW (1 IN A41� N q;;;(((pIII 1- M yPl1 R x715 yr I < myzyyz U}�1 r_ -'lppl N IdE 620, °� 2° E(-1 �1' f7 nA 'r mZ (mj i- (mj U, Dr�l pn0 yNOy41 �nI Obi AywO rD �rnt Iny ny r, -°y < 41" OD nlm 2 7D�ng O�A r °TIII AAI nIUZ r N D _(yr - 111 -1 yyZ-L1 n' T -I Zm y �r P. rG Aym Zpmrn ypmOaF{,N mF U AA -j� �1� m E n=' rX pp/iii G1 �-➢il I�r �,l In r AI U' E nZ t br T-yy T N Z nI U' y 7-I -1 Z m A Z- Q F -n r b 111 D N 11�nI €1 1 I In -1 3 '� G UN, << Z m r {,1 -1 41 11 n _I Z G N In - n y_ n, _I y EDW 0 a 7 nE AI ylc (p1S NItG 7T., r �'= mu. iii n Z m gn m7 "hOL_D-IbnnnD45 ;ua r z A L yn D m N1 b �nz Zj._ Ci LO➢ R i"1 YIL IJ g R ,(Ol -Im E '" D b mm r� �Zm y-�mzz mrm j()Ft7. (tm O cnln (iPI Zy Dg n ➢1 (1 c1 1O-� in0 �/ 1z "• 411a� Ty�NI O I i(zF(1r '1lr �jy(1 OW I"N� D11, i '- Y(1 nm r itInN m( 'n 41 m� =i rW Dp n( mD� Zy apt �z Z yFn yt) --°p Ql Fr4 -( O r' m�l 7_� S-1 n Anl Oni �O$ �� i� yEEyn -1 tilt OT -ni NQ <� w� minz (lmu'® LIInn<<�I (1D r' ) �Inn D �y nD In° a nDEAL °�i z" - TW r afl Au, - 1'(l pm Wpx �' inm �;A m ➢c ➢p zm(, Ryz lyn "° ()R M O'O I.L Oz r Orn D Om Ll° �A cyj' 'lI D _ z m ill l7��ii1l m �[ O r G y A O AAAI N x rr A Ayg 2 tlW-1 N b j h(P AZA my to IN in -i G- ➢ ➢➢ "y' wC mil �X 11+U;ll °E, A1Ff1 n I�A_i_ly`°T l70 -p (2n =av Ai r' zo l° W b. mr 1� Lill ,(11 <�I IrI L_�IIr NnI h N 11 U111 D➢ nU,➢ c Oy 12j, -1 Xr yy 111 my I ;(1yQQpIlfl OQ-iA ill- hin �I << f- A� (° ID - n p{C n iQ m 1 n i1 1 my �T (ur = oO ��Oy °`•` pp Wj �ti0 u, b° m Ln rD np Al (9m In r A yD 1-vA znl " t`I-_ aa7�II-p (i10 III AI nDA � D O ay mm Z D ,mi E �ZT 2Z 1) ��• �. 3 Om -t in� - O E� m �N z In 41a <Sm? O 11' p' -'InA �- w °r E� m W y z AW m ji fG1 =1- nmm p ill m m ;� T ,f yr z g Z li _a N m yA Q m Arm ` —i n E Di 3' OIn "z� "�°iuD Il ay T"y o<= _� Q� ��,11�� �o oD o X D� ro A oyDLo ° �i" 4 y rD roes tt'' Oy0 -1 y nD r D W An -A y C -1 -IN m U ,r�- r II�iIll A -(b N ND T_In O m ➢, L 2A I mx O m U;2llm A Y I'l7"y 6' E � ADA �y �O in �r� � in0 r�r� Nr Y- Dyr n IItZ z y ➢ III N m 7(r p x m -y \ OT °r L n A y y ➢I- O' r_ i �11 r pZ N WO Oy 7' Z m u' (1w y nG Xii=+�b1A� ?put at ;D1m ,�I u11n =1E r O r SIL �yi m n AI -In i��D,II DF' -A41 7 r 13 Z 'tl- m-1 (u M1j G1 t�lm w Zr- �(n AI A m(lO= 'D 'i ()= M O mi' r cc j f„ y ,gmU Dp © I b75G b 6) I'd mm .wnA� n A n(�0 m my n' -Li °. n pR I i0_n to Oxp-I 3D OL -0 r E nr D gi z I°A' i in 7I n u m "� }Il m zA z00-ZO Omn g r SS R W n 3bC Zai �.. ORN rll O fo W -U zF m n TD 0(1 a (n in n nn In __I Z i h� O➢�I my Y myc III/I mt- $1 y(I, AIp ll p([pp[ 7 -� D O ➢ 3 () ill -+.. O fll 1'I Z 1�1 m n °1 Cl r Gql ll A L n 1'- n1 �,1 n lel p p r fIl ,71 O y () n R$ N r 3 RZ'nr O mU j 7iU7 Oy 7I nD E_ P (1- ➢ �U UG -lu'g � [;-+DD D D➢ -t i' m U 'jom Igl- ➢-Qipttl t, yr 0 z7 -° -0 G1. ,1 T- Orl1� A bNlll I Ai. A yy I I r P,7�1 y In O O zN W- Oc (6 to Ni, G r Ab-/ 2 33 u, z L O U -Ir0 m X I� g E flllll i) D Z Q 3 L Q O Gn. (� QO Z D 0 -pc G'n 41 III r t m(P 1: {n -() Q m Z m rly w m- Aw r D1 A r 011 D 1 ( r`-1 'n n O tltl gEg r %d 3V fD< Eln m r -r W pL 1° 1 z �' ym X N� n �'r Ay_. r Am lZ ill A mZ 1_ qX� D4171 y000 1 '"' L (°nX riri L m c1 A ( a rni tY O' m pp -(a rW WOQm x m v AA 3 in I- rnA nb (J- ti c h0 ylI r h D O 2 ii, L m r fB a € 0 ill r_ n ir7 Ain .., lln m O 1W z AI>may T �n± rE -1 r r m b a m r wD m A D- r_ -.I ,! On Nu' �' D tii %C �� Q nl r 'tln -(in, N ( n NFri 1" Oj r" Z .701 �,JUa�Y ",,IIO DI <� ° n_I .7A_I .--� A 0 U z. N mN 'll O° r� �n n2 _ °, z Y r I p(n A0 1 U III - on SEG n-rl "- � � n � nn � �, UI it] ( U `' -( . 111t1I All Znl _I W 'm zL �. NI, n On -n 77:- �-1:I, r ➢ Axz NAl,rLz n Alrt <nF� D�11- 111 4n1 0 11 n. O➢ riiG O (R .In 3 (1O rZlz r^D r (lyC A O O Z I (z� lr �tl -I �I In D N_ �I D n r' `- 111 L b z (j, f' r` In �1 E '" F f- f- y y -p°lj Ffl 7- N 1- n N m In _ �. IU r _ E a Oal °).> .° L �-i D y U y °ill Z-_ 11'ODp ill 111b -g Dm N� A 11 Nlp D IIn ''ptl ), 6 ll `l L Z LL 'U In i- n,n 1 r A n Z 'L c' `r• _i N L I u N 1-I/I n -IA 'tl In illZ O® AI In b 111 3 ylrl _Z �r �Am��n1I (1 11 (11 y In FO .O�'r o ul Dp nill�m 11 t� nlz 80 r mA D '-f ym c_ A }I a y°4t' fIN, I� 0 007 I O m�., C S n inA x ry r' tlW ,11'41 a. A U n._A In r�1 m x- -( :..i 1m In_ r n a 1 Z L I n r Irl -"i D L � U,w p pYr.'L n my p 111 In DLLT, ", O1 G X(n in to Z 1 Z D U M 0 G(ry (n I" g Z 1;;(UnnI 1� - O EE ID n AS�,Il 47 r y O n < . F 1,11 2 G y llhr iPL L Ey X O Z O y-� y l_ a�t A .LA y r y y zy z m n y'7r1 '"tl -' Z 'r- m 1 L n" m n O rcl n�q�pma m -Z' NIn ,t m inm m a ��L 0r..r D 41�D®A(6 C p :� ■i D to u: -1 L W fil pp H r r q, m ill i "' w 4I r r= A hl 'ter A (,Q 9�� In `in 0 / f ag�as$ HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE 31 fu e T " C� II . p N� o 3524 OLEANDER WAY, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA AR001 I52 Na. 7J20073552 .wI M , � r.t �t c_.� No. REVISIONS M M G III ''MA V+ O SET NAIL & LYSK LB 353 15.04 W. WITA�SS CORA�/�) — — CU STREAM RO 'ET3N5AlL &DISK -I-3.83 — —� l7 _ _ /`i Q 3 15.04' W I —o ; P A V E D _ —TA SS CORNER) POLE ON �h MARK. TOP - J. CORNER CA TCH ® NAIL Alm DISK BASIN MM +335 ELEVA770N +3.89 c;, WALL 35' 142.35' -�, 21.50' NOT CORER W.M.❑ 18.3' l rn t1.0' 2 Z 2� cn� u, y ?L 0' ~ O CoA . STEPS, 28.3' BEACH MARK.• TOP NAIL AAD WA9-ER ELEVAT70N +3.82 FLOOR o +5.84 c., 182' c , 6�. OC' ? 0�A G CW. PA 770 4•y POOL CONC. PA T70 1 STORY RESIDENCE---, #3524 FLOOR +6.45 FLOOR r 63' +6.27 T ,rte-i62,�� 213' CONC. WALK r � o �C O v O cn o rz y a� DRQ O�Zyv O D O 0 4.3 37.8' � LIFT ( ) STATION 2RlM +5.36 COVERED CONC. STEP 4.8 37.8' rn CONC. �v 2 0.7' s Fj 22.54' _ PAVED OLEANDER WAY 5 09+ FOLD I.R. 22.54' S' o z y �C O v O rz T O�Zyv O OIC a � O II II II a Q 1.4' Z c) -I O r Z Z 7.5' n Z p r-riy a 0 �o2cn z sus_. N��Q� COQ 22.54' _ PAVED OLEANDER WAY 5 09+ FOLD I.R. 22.54' S' -0660 O rz I O�Zyv Q)II OIC ��lv QO II II II Q �c 63 W c) -I O �-moo-� Z Z II n Z p r-riy � �o2cn N��Q� COQ nye amZ� �zco C QZ nO�Q� yr-;2:j� cv=� w�uj S�nr,m oo� � -0660 O I � O Q)II ��lv QO II II II Q Z Z II n Z p r-riy � n nye Z �pci) w�uj r Z�O �Q n Do Z n � r U C) W r Z �W -•• r M ±l�f}w , n o o� D�„ Ir q D,Lm l,�-� _ -io ° Z �cw CmIT! r,�if�7oSba(�rtl m? 7J�,fTI O? � Vi Tr Li O C� )-W a>o C' r- ; I-- a �; yR'��r�i5,:z -i��oa�l"rl� �1 `� dt"� M _-1 003 i1c� rnm�' Z -,y�Q- —7-1 mss, A 3 A o- -{ m ZtnQ�r�s c• x: .Z 3 c- s i a 70� m rn-'rDM3' oic„azn o r- D- 7o Cn m,-) a c z A 2 rzA D �p =1 an c rnrnz'�na Z L6�� it j if III I �� i� i fid' t l i z� - Y 1.11E 142.35' �m >a A � k, ir ' h UI I m 3 an � A 2 � I > 8 1 ((� rn n O f1TfII -� �I 1 x O y z -� N ?O>I� oo Q7 D o nlI ' ti in D�an aIn A r �n< (oma Z z CP 1151 m � r 1. D A CD :z czi -OC n o DZ-pnm Z Cf' L Tf C) rn z A ii a n --z Z C ? r�T->3 ���p3 �an �� rT, rrl °� oZ�z QmG) � Lzl 0 -I= o m 1— m o I 1' m =zbxx Z�S �� om D �c o �T mDV'�o z Z oz �=D� >rm- on A _jz A� man Drawing elle SITE PLAN rr,0z an D O o3 Ii mzz1 JO3 �- Lrl �3 or�m1 �' z r*n p ` r r � I I I I rn y I '� x o� D�„ Ir q D,Lm l,�-� _ -io ° Z �cw CmIT! r,�if�7oSba(�rtl m? 7J�,fTI O? � Vi Tr Li O C� )-W a>o C' r- ; I-- a �; yR'��r�i5,:z -i��oa�l"rl� �1 `� dt"� M _-1 003 i1c� rnm�' Z -,y�Q- —7-1 mss, A 3 A o- -{ m ZtnQ�r�s c• x: .Z 3 c- s i a 70� m rn-'rDM3' oic„azn o r- D- 7o Cn m,-) a c z A 2 rzA D �p =1 an c rnrnz'�na Z L6�� it j if III I �� i� i fid' t l i z� - Y 1.11E 142.35' �m >a A � k, ir ' h UI I m 3 an � A 2 � I > 8 1 ((� z y I b Z� �I 1 y z -� N ?O>I� S ? an I a o nlI ' ti - A an O A mx .. n u, COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. a � I A 3 D Z /• I I z z n o / z Z 845 NE 71 5T ST. / o o 0 —0------ � ' m z • j 1n o m 1— m o I 1' / % A o o I o 3 I I I g Drawing elle SITE PLAN I I I g �' z � I I I I rn y I Uy PROPERTY LINE 142.00' X D (PAVED) j i z an x Z - D NI z i o A A x an 3 rn -� aqz i- o z co R1 �° G o D _ N 0 0 I \ \ 8 1 Z I n \ A 3 y z S ? an z o z x , n I - A an O A mx .. n u, COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. THE STANLEY RESIDENCE � I A 3 D Z /• I I z z o / z c z 845 NE 71 5T ST. / I o 0 —0------ � ' D (PAVED) j i z an x Z - D NI z i o A A x an 3 rn -� aqz i- o z co R1 �° G o D N°. I REVISIONS I Date ° �_ o v+3 �� Y"» - - - CER LANDSCAPTI�T�- COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. THE STANLEY RESIDENCE C°n-t°nl Seal o z zo 845 NE 71 5T ST. IS 114 1/2 , FLORIDA33 DELRAY BEACH, LORIDA 33444-3713 3524 OLEANDER WAY Iia u ° 1n MCA R TON —1—"E--NN,N°-„rE",°u TOWN OF GULFSTREAM, FLORIDA Drawing elle SITE PLAN 334e7 N°. I REVISIONS I Date U m \ ^ o lis I\ y O m D / '� 4 a � 0 < m s o ^m o _ III A S m Z z L=) nD R� N m c p �v o III rnIV j I I III I I 2 C_ � � Om •+ A •+. i N N O' 4l n IA I I I I I I A Q I i � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I / ptiy,1 I m 1 (PAVED) tn AT Z N mb(P ^ o lis (P _z y O m D / '� 4 a � 0 < m s o ^m o _ n o Pn 3 A S m Z z L=) nD R� N m c p �v o �o / ptiy,1 I m 1 (PAVED) tn AT Z N mb(P ^ o n 0 £ A m D y O 3 °1 O N m a � 0 < m s o ^m o X n p 0 n o Pn 3 A S m Z z L=) nD cl c� z gI OZ x G) o c p �v o �o I mN / ptiy,1 I m 1 (PAVED) tn AT Z N mb(P ^ o 'TU I I�m�i'. I IA I U$, Ulm �A o3 � I_ I I I I I z I I I I I 71-0 I -D, FED VE I I I I 41 . I I / 20'-0_RE � z rz � P sg I I 2 C_ � � I I I / ptiy,1 I m 1 (PAVED) tn AT Z N mb(P ^ o 'TU I I�m�i'. I IA I U$, Ulm �A o3 � I't ffr z m �0o i_ n0 � SITE PLAN � z rz � P PROPERTY UNE 14L00' o rn �X ^ o I �DO�(n � � SITE PLAN � z rz � P I I 2 C_ � � I I I IA I I I IG I� • I I I � � Q I 0 p O 0 O O D a op _ '►`�y O O 090.0 D 5.?_ �1 COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. THE STANLEY RESIDENCE `°""'"°°` �°°i = s 114 1/2 NE 15T AVENUE p DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444-3713 3524 OLEANDER WAY _,,.o,,,z�,,,,,�_,,,„,,,,`_,„,tuo„� TOWN OF GULFSTREAM, FLORIDA O Drawing Titk FlAR00,75�54"� No. RLYISIONS SITE PLAN RLYISIONS z o ��I , mfg STREAM ROAD �Ap a � AES P A V E D —- - s---------_ _„_- _ 21.50' -, I J"" Y I j a i ( C 1' J s----_- wo I p \ o z y y CONC. Pn710 root p a CONC. PATIO • \ x Y$ 1 D 1 m n ,n y eM n- I 0 z m 4 �rycmi `\ J I I 2 D PEEJy C 5 c J a.s I N A A oN �s n o I p J O B I I mo R I 2 D I I 1s \o\ � la.a '.� vm• I � 4 0 I jI Ow COK T 9g I j I I ca• I I a 211 CONC WALK I x�e j1e': I G A I .OII I I iI rel I I i I I -11 4 c V E 9 �z c If�l I 1 i I m 8 'G• / 1 I I f D .•� // I 1 22.m. .Dal 1 14200' — —PAVED OLEANDER WAY I J� 1 �yy� No �O ti+ 6 oaaooav000a000 I F soo<000eoaaoaao a x NE ` ^ M w L7 O n �Rt L7 31 i — MCI z:8p' m f �Q B z D 0 0 RROFIOSLO SITE PL4L RIR: SCH I DRANING 12089517E MARIE REWS GATE ULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. STANLEY RESIDENCE SITE PLAN W W.P.S. CML & S7RUMIRAL ENGINEERING - LAND PLANNING - ENW RONMENTAL PERMIMNG °R DRANK M.A.N. ,Dz 3524 OLE,DER WAY CERTIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION NO.: 00008668 K CHECKED W.P.S. GOLFSIREIM, FL 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD., SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 scar I' -ID' TEL 7721770-9622 FAX 7721770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com ""`- DATE 6/22/11 a = 9.21 m s W W M F W T N m V C 9� $SWW o ry O D 0 0 RROFIOSLO SITE PL4L RIR: SCH I DRANING 12089517E MARIE REWS GATE ULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. STANLEY RESIDENCE SITE PLAN W W.P.S. CML & S7RUMIRAL ENGINEERING - LAND PLANNING - ENW RONMENTAL PERMIMNG °R DRANK M.A.N. ,Dz 3524 OLE,DER WAY CERTIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION NO.: 00008668 K CHECKED W.P.S. GOLFSIREIM, FL 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD., SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 scar I' -ID' TEL 7721770-9622 FAX 7721770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com ""`- DATE 6/22/11 r 0 OCG 00 WX m� 0 Dp Xr no =n -�o mj CG) �rn r -n r- 0 0 0 T Z 4) a 161 0 x M rno 0 pco ,�°� N g m 3 y �v f y COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE co'"" Seal i L o o mJ8 A 30 7 � P 114 1/2 NE IST AVENUE s 5 f� o W rA� 00 0 � O C A 3524 OLEANDER WAY O O 2 4) a 161 0 x M rno 0 pco ,�°� N aS-1 COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE co'"" Seal O 114 1/2 NE IST AVENUE o W 00 0 � m DELRAYeCBEA BEACH, FLp OryRIrDA'3444-3713 3524 OLEANDER WAY 2 p • g GULF STREAM, FLORIDA • N z � eNo set s1/-e)oe pAat set a�w-6�o7 orawiag me Florida °'° No. PROPOSED FLOOR PLAN(S) r AR0013552 M001 ! ._ No. REVISIONS Gate P __ (AM i D s. , h �� `J c4 ��J �Yw��, • ,� \ V rteR zy� II rn�I�I.� / - 0 O f f HT1 f• - Gi � 3 O T m 9 2 1 N �H m s o > ;an r rn "o > o 9 r a m rn r- c v r c�i \ ` m zv o<0 o g H0 01 ^^D G) a - - rn €Diu a o _ 1 .. m 3 S oo < A R12 T X H ti I rn � -�"� -- I IIIIIIII III IMI VIII __ a 'c•V CI O - III IIIIII I III VIII OH _— II IIII IIII III - — IIII III I I IIIIII / _ n 11111 IIIIII IIII IIII IIII ull�l II III I IIIIII ,. mt __- ,II I IIIIIIIIIIII" r-O Iulll. --- rnr _ I>QIII - -- - <0 -- - �r,Illlll��l 11 IIIIII' ►" IIII ��, _ �I � IIIIIIII IIII D — 4 III I"" IIII VIII (IIII III H O u IaIiIIl In Ii I III n; II_IIIII I I I IIIIIIII; IIII I III II '\ O, , .. IIII11111. IIII 111111. II' I (IIII VIII .�-/-71 - II ' II +III I„ IIII (IIII; rnr� II II 4 � y IIIIIIII 9 o I 20 11. 3 g 'D 0 ~ D i� �O O ® $ o �m E •��� p� � � py v {' O v any N m v U! rIi A O Z A D A Seel D e � �, COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. HISTORIC POLO COTTA Co Itunt Sml af� D p O 114 1/2 NE IST AVENUE O z Z u u m D DELRAYEA cBCH, FfO A` 3444-3713 3524 OLEANDER WAY • g "" GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Drawing nIe F 001 AR0073552 LC - Na. EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS n it, ,7 [:� m -„ r No. REVISIONS Date M3:> rn -� 0 HT off ;on I- D r m O �=D H ;00 H;0 OH ;on rn-0 r0 Mr - <0 r<0 D -�n HO 0 z D 6) rn •jig ODSr���paI p AZTo— 404 � O- �; e� � N 30 � iu ODSr���paI p f. 30 � iu COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE ^ ° v ' D Z o d o p m PJ114 1/2 NE IST AVENUE FLORIDA 33444-3713 DELAY BEACH, '" " w< ODSr���paI p f. COPE ARCHITECTS, INC. HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE ^ ° v ' D Z o d o p m PJ114 1/2 NE IST AVENUE FLORIDA 33444-3713 DELAY BEACH, '" " 3524 OLEANDER WAY N = GULF STREAM, FLORIDA • N � ✓110 sbl x>w 6>ob Pw�c 56• z>w 6>0> D�awmy N. 0 no 52 "° EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS AR013 AROO1J552 No. REVISIONS Dote D H 0) rn-i ;00 H 0" ;on rn-0 r0 rnr <0 'D in 0 01 z D m iz z = F F n n 0 0 m � x a � o z Y r m A O zz z z z p i F F F m ZZ 3 T 1 T 1 D 3 X Lrj ❑ m A � 2 O ;00 2 P HLal Vl 0� g ;on Wo r0 Mr < 0 — D �r I Iliu�l n �a ��I I�! ,►I �' IIIA! III III I II' LI it 0 0 Z 0 � � I,I VIII I'll'lll I� I II!�I IIT I III III �I�I Illlli, D I III I !I ! Ilii II, II I II IIS I IIII '' rn S, --- -- Iy� l� rill' ll' ►IIILINI��liI,lIIl,lSIIlIlI� III�, I I I!Illil - -I ta, V r V� n No�PO 'C�J ' l m nO 30 s gq �o o go 06 o—iag mla EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS _ 15 A �z o_ �a ■■ 3- N Y r m A O zz z z z p i F F F m ZZ 3 T 1 T 1 D 3 X Lrj ❑ m A � 2 O ;00 2 P HLal Vl 0� g ;on Wo r0 Mr < 0 — D �r I Iliu�l n �a ��I I�! ,►I �' IIIA! III III I II' LI it 0 0 Z 0 � � I,I VIII I'll'lll I� I II!�I IIT I III III �I�I Illlli, D I III I !I ! Ilii II, II I II IIS I IIII '' rn S, --- -- Iy� l� rill' ll' ►IIILINI��liI,lIIl,lSIIlIlI� III�, I I I!Illil - -I ta, V r V� n No�PO 'C�J ' l m nO L o �„ O .A 3� ► X10 06 o—iag mla EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS _ 15 A �z o_ N°. REWSIONS Data ■■ 3- N ■ 0 ' N n No�PO 'C�J ' l m dl°, m L o �„ O .A s 06 o—iag mla EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS _ 15 A �z o_ N°. REWSIONS Data ■■ 3- N ■ 0 ' N n , z ° No�PO 'C�J ' l m Seal Florida L`°°°° NO. AR0013552 COPE ARCHITECTS INC. - 114 1/2 NE IST AVENUE DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 3334444-3713 ""`" K "° ""' a ° v"o 5ei z��-a�oa r.�a sna zz"-bz°z HISTORIC POLO COTTAGE 3524 OLEANDER WAY GULF STREAM, FLORIDA o—iag mla EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS _ N°. REWSIONS Data Carol MacMillan Stanley* Thomas M. Stanley *Board Certified by Florida Bar In Wills, Trusts and Estates. Real Estate Law Offices MacMillan & Stanley, PLLC 29 Northeast Fourth Avenue Delray Beach, Florida 33483 Telephone (561) 276-6363 Facsimile (561) 276-8881 macmillanstanley.com July 9, 2012 Neil E. MacMillan (1918 - 1996) oRECEIVEDo Town of Gulf Stream JUL 0 9.2 Att: Town Manager ; - �; 'U!! 8,; z�;;�, , t 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: Stanley Project - 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, FL Special Exception and Driveway Removal/Repair Agreement Dear Mr. Thrasher: This project includes a special exception request to locate mechanical equipment in the side setback area (on the south side of the property next to the new proposed detached garage). The applicant will provide existing site pictures for the special exception upon request. The neighbor to the south side of the applicant's property has mechanical equipment located on or near the property line as well. The applicant's mechanical equipment is located away from the neighboring property's pool/patio area. In regard to this application, the applicant will be installing a new rear driveway (which will be wider) to accommodate the proposed detached two car garage. The driveway apron will extend to Gulf Stream Road. The driveway will consist of a base and then pea gravel. Applicant agrees that any apron installed to contain pea gravel driveway will be removed and/or repaired due to any public works project in the right-of-way per agreement with the Town. TMS/smt Yours very truly, MacMillan & Stanley, PLLC Serving Delray Since 1946 1pt *00 1 �lw' 0 Ww Wf- )**NM Oki 1,11011" :..4, N. 1 A - ,� a d .�.' \ ` MA f --m � \ � z� 4 + # ■ « � �� �� � f1mo 0 -WT :•. k ' h omw rr,nom,.i I (a1 Y a t ti. f� Y p� t ��•� r'c . it i y• s E A 7 j 1 a t ti. f� Y p� t ��•� r'c . it i y• s E A 7 1 t ias JUL 2012 . rL 3524 Oleander Way Gulfstream Drainage Design June 28, 2012 Schulke, Bittle, & Stoddard L.L.C. 1717 Indian River Boulevard Suite 201 Vero Beach, Florida 32960 Date: W iam Stoddard Ph.D., P.E. FL Reg. No. 57605 F j SCHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. X06 CIVIL 8 STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITTING TEL 772 / 770-9622 www.sbsengineers.com Fax 772 / 770-9496 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD., SUITE 201 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 SHEET NO. OF— CALCULATED F_CALCULATED BY DATE CHECKED BY SCALE (Nlf J�>7um, �L Get 5 bf �uI f fU�, �r-�r�c5 , �,�8,►`d, P9/� Z — 35 Z4 0 N V)u� — -- i+ rmwu�e Y' /�1�� P�nPn CvlouWi'om5 df Arm, = /0l797 SF �C5 r -o - LA) =/ 4 g s F bY'aiAage Ateo% = /7i -?3? s = 0,407 40-1 - GciNd �ovcv- C�i lo I « 4)'ao 5 �_mo-e>ry ivu5 4v -fa) �uEAn(Af PMA5e IcAc4nje ZjZ70 7�,n 33 Lrivc wa i5 11 d 34 )12 3 I POO ( �C K /�(Ai-,"a5 )) 5 0 I /14/+7 All -S I (A ed- wu1i 5, 0 C, 235 24.0 (3 6, cl '�0� Opro 4�re4 7 S 3/1 070J Curvr /vuw hfr 2713 Ilyne o-( _ ,ons 115 j,4 5 m 1, Vl v1= D►z4 (drw5c 3rg5s) L = 3 5/S S = (4►Z - 3, 5/3S,5 ) 3 8CHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. CIVIL & STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITTING TEL 772 / 770-9622 www.sbsengineers.com FAx 772 / 770-9496 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD., SUITE 201 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 JOB SHEET NO. OF CALCULATED BY DATE CHECKED BY SCALE �a recd �� TYe - 55� vi✓�u�► f��aiYo,lo�y -�►� Sr�4/� Gt�rrE1c1r shed 5 Gh�l a �ti� -So l s ryv ✓-f by 1�"►Y1 � N9/ h CPV'S � '�� F �U�t✓►'�-)� I �'e+cy►�10l1 q-�{-fV' rq oo;� ) C5ws i ht9'r e, ocdcu l cord as , V713 —1 = //9-S �� �aucv' o �P� G✓'eu Vol uv� e =(//,is "Ilz (//)/F7 S = 1352 cF 0,4cAjA ) I oveY i ✓h�ItVViuu S q�eU ir► �I�u�JvSPC� 5wu(e5 yQe u i rc� ' va (4me = (1 "�Iz� �55I sl�� = S 4� C/= C jai uo l w M I _ (z,-7 'r -/F+) (?-5S e -F) 6 <2q c r - See 14cU e4 Aod ye- f 6 Cvvc. ry Anu l y51. -(o Y- d Yu �dacvh 5 wa le rc e v ve-v-y Nutting e Engineers of Florida Inc. I Established 1967 Your Project is Our Commitment 1310 Neptune Drive Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 561-736-4900 Toll Free: 877 -NUTTING (658-84641 Fax: 561-737-9975 Broward 954 941-8700 St. Lucie 772-408-1050 Miami -Dade 345 557-3083 svww.r<tre:iragen�irr es rs.<_>:;, r June 13, 2012 ° Mr. Tom Stanley L ;3 29 NE 4th Avenue Delray Beach; Florida 33483 i~ Subject: Report of Exfiltration Test c Stanley Residence `l 3524 Oleander Way 0 Gulfstream, Florida Y t,1 Dear Mr. Stanley: s. ,a Nutting Engineers of Florida, Inc. has performed two exfiltration tests and two infiltration tests for the proposed drainage improvements at the above referenced location. This report presents a brief " description of the field procedures, and the results of the exfiltration tests and infiltration tests, t va 4s E..... Two exfiltration tests were performed to a depth of six feet below existing grade in accordance with South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) criteria for 'Usual Open -Hole' conditions. Prior r, to starting each test, a 6 -inch diameter hole was augered to the test depth to determine the depth to L groundwater and to examine subgrade soils. After establishing the above parameters, the hole was stabilized by a full-length perforated PVC pipe in accordance with South Florida Water Management "' District specifications. Water was then pumped into the hole maintaining a constant water level at the ground surface. The stabilized flow rates were recorded in one minute intervals for a total of 10 minutes. The exfiltration tests revealed the hydraulic conductivity ('K' -value) of the soils ranged from 4-86 x 10-5 to 7.66 x 10-5 cubic feet per second per square foot per foot of head. Soil descriptions and flow rates for the tests are shown on the attached exfiltration summary sheet. We note that the water table was encountered at a depth of approximately 3.5 feet below the existing ground surface. Along with the exfiltration tests our office was requested to perform two Double Ring Infiltration Tests (ASTM D-3385-88). Discussions with Mr. Bill Stoddard, P.E., the project civil engineer, indicated that the retention pond bottom would be located approximately existing grades; therefore the tests r areas were performed within the upper one foot of the soil profile. The tests were performed for a v period of three hours until steady-state was achieved. G 2.� c.J 0 F F I C E 5 Palm Beach Miami -Dade St Lucie 1 The results of the Double Ring Infiltrometer Test reveals that within the upper one foot below the ground surface a steady state unsaturated vertical infiltration rate (K,„) of 8.17 inches per hour (16.34 ft/day) was attained at test location 1 and a steady state unsaturated vertical infiltration rate (K,,,,) of 20.42 inches per hour (40.84 ft/day) was attained at test location 1. Detailed flow rates and soil descriptions are presented in the appendix. We note that these values pertain to the depth location at which the exfiltration tests and double ring infiltrometer tests were performed. We also note that the hydraulic conductivity values may vary along the banks of the retention pond where differing soils may be present. The project civil engineer should use appropriate factors of safety during design to account for the noted site conditions. We appreciate the opportunity to provide these services for you. Should you have any questions, or if we can be of further assistance, please feel free to contact us. Respectfully Submitted: NUTTING E GIPVE OF FIL RID,4,1 Cori; p r E. Gw :.k, P.E. #69947 Senior fingineer 1-647.: Tom Stanlev infil and e:rP.l Itr Nutting Engineers of Florida Inc.. Established 1967 I c LL 7 7 \ U- C ( ( p>—e B = o @ a # a & « 7 k 7 Le) 0 .. Geotechnical & Construction Materials Eng>neering, Testing: K Inspection �n Environmental Services EngineersOffices throughout the state of Florida of Florda IInc.I Established 1962 vr�vw,nuttingengireers corn infolDnuttingengineers com Your Project is Our Commit+nea t DOUBLE RING INFILTROMETER TEST - ASTM D3385 CLIENT: Tom Stanley TEST NO.: 1 TEST DATE: 6i 1212012 WEATHER: Sunny 86 Deg F PROJECT: Stanley Residence DRILLER_ D Tyson 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Strearn, Florida SOIL DESCRIPTION: 0 1' Dark Gray Quartz Fine SAND, Slight Trace Organics NOTE: TEST PERFORMED AT 6 INCHES BELOW EXISTING GRADE. GROUNDWATER DEPTH: 3 5 feet USING 12" & 24" DIAMETER RINGS AREA: INNER RING: 113.1 IN` (729.7 C(t1'�) ANNULAR RING: 339.3 IN2 (2189.2 CNII) Testing was performed according to proceudres specified in ASTIti1 D3385-09. Liquid used consisted of water with an approxiiTiate pH of 7.0. As ASTIR procedure recoil! rnerids, data frorn inner ring was ii=;ed to determine infiltration rate ELAPSED QUANTITY RATE QUANTITY RATE TIME OF WATER INNER OF WATER ANNULAR (HR) INNER(in') (IN,HR) ANNULAR(irl') (INIH R) 025 231 8.17 520 6.13 00.5 231 8.17 520 6.13 0.75 231 8.17 520 6.13 1 231 8.17 520 6.13 1.5 462 8.17 520 3.07 2 462 8.17 520 3.07 3 924 8.17 1040 3.07 STEADY STATE INFILTRATION RATE - _ 8.17 INCH/HOUR Inner Ring infiltration Rate 2o.00 16,00 14.00 12.00 10.00 to 8.00 fi:0p i °2.00 u` 0.00 Elapsed Time (hr) 'f v A— As noted In Sec. 11 t Precision and Bias of ASTL-1 D3385 09 the recorded infiltration rate should be considered on.r as an irdox Christopher E. Gworek, P.E. #69947 INFIL TOM STANLEY TEST 1 CEG Senior Geotechnical Engineer 1310 Neptune Drive .µ Boynton Beach, Florida 33426 (561) 736-4900 Fax (561) 737-9975 Broward (954) 941-8700 0 Port St. Lucie: (772) 408 1050 Miami Dade (305) 824-0060 r Geotechnical & Cnnsinsriion Materials ��� Enoneering,Testing & lnspeciion Envirorimental Services EngineersOffices throughout the state of Flor.da otFlorida mc.I stabl:shed 196i MWW.,i ill 1nge lglneers.com info r—L)r.uttingengineers.com Your Projeet ft Our [ommlrmrn r DOUBLE RING INFILTROMETER TEST - ASTM D3385 CLIENT: Tom Stanley TEST NO.: 2 TEST DATE: 6!12/2012 WEATHER: Sunny 88 Deg F PROJECT-. Stanley Residence DRILLER: D Tyson 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, Florida SOIL DESCRIPTION. 0-1' Dark Gray Quartz Fine SAND. Slight Trace Organics NOTE: TEST PERFORMED AT 6 INCHES BELOW EXISTING GRADE. GROUNDWATER DEPTH: 3.5 feet USING 12" & 24" DIAIv1ETER RINGS AREA: INNER RING' 113.1 IN` (729 7 CM ) ANNULAR RING: 339.3 iW (2189.2 CM`) Testing was performed according to proceudres specified in A3TK1 D3385-09. Liquid used consisted of water with an approximate pH of 7 0. As ASTM procedure recommends, data from inner ring VJ@S Used to determine infiltration rate. ELAPSED QUANTITY RATE QUANTITY RATE TIME OF WATER INNER OF WATER ANNULAR (HR) INNER(in") (IN/HR) ANNULAR(tn`) (IN/HR) 0.25 578 20,42 1271 14.98 0.5 578 20,42 1271 14.98 0.75 578 20.42 1271 14.98 1 578 20.42 1271 14.98 1.5 1155 20.42 2310 13.62 2 1155 20.42 2310 13.62 3 2310 20.42 4620 1362 STEADY STATE INFILTRATION RATE = 2D.42 INCHIHOUR* Inner Ring Infiltration Rate 22 00 _._._.._. 21 00 20.00 19.00 - --Se-esi i4 1t},00 3 ? 7.00 o i6A0 t 15.00 0 i 2 3 Elapsed Time (hr) As noted in Sec. 11.1 Precision and Bias of .AS t N1 D3385-09 the recorded infil'ra:ion rate should he considered only as an index INFIL TON", STANLEY TES"2 CEG J Christopher E. Gworek, P.E. #69947 Senior Geotechnical Engineer 1310 Neptune Chive ,w: Boynton Beach, Florida 33426c,(561)736-4900 Fax(561)737-9975 Broward (954) 941-8700 0 Port St. Lucie (772) 408-1050 1? Miami Dade (305) 824-0060 NUUing is. E g1,131er of Florida Inc.Establivied 1967 Your Project is Our Commitment Client: Project: Location: Test: Surface Elevation Geotechnical & Construction Materials Engineerin, ' es:ing, & Inspection Privironmemal Services Offices throughout the state of Florida www nuttingengineers.corn inroPnuttingengineers.com Report of Exfiltration Test Tom Stanley Order No Stanley Residence _ _R _ Report No 3524 Oleander Wa,Gulfstream, Florida Date.- Usual ate:Usual Open Hole Exfiltration Test Water table from ground Approx. Q Road Crown surface: Casing Diameter: 6" Tube Depth: 6' EXFIL NO. 1 Sample Location: Approx. 25'W, and 10' N. of SEpropertyy corner �_�._._....,. Material 04' 4"-2- 2'-4' 4'-6' K = 4.86 x 10-5 cfs/ftzft.head Dk. gray quartz fine sandy TOPSOIL Brown medium to coarse grain beach SAND Brown fibrous PEAT Dk. gray quartz fine SAND and root fibers v 6"'JU U �. 16400.1 1- 6/11112 3 5' One Pump Rate Minute in Gal/Min Increme 3 5 0.5 _ 6 _ 0.5 7 8 0.6 0.5 0.5 10 0.5 1310 NEPTUNE DRIVE , BOYNTON BEACH, F1.ORlDA, 33426 •561-736-4900 • FAX 561-737-9975 Treasure Coast 772-408-1050 Brow;ird 954-941-8700 Miami Dade 305-$24-0066 Geotechnical & Construclion Materials Nulling Engineering, Testing, & Inspection Engineering Services 'Enr Offices throughout the state of Florida of Floiida Inc.I Established 196 www.nuttingengineers.com intoC@nL;ttingenjneers.com Your Project is Our Commitment Report of Exfiltration Test Client: Tom Stanle�r __._._ _..._..-_._._.�_.. Order No 16400.1 _. . . Project: Stanlel Residence Report No _ 2 Location: 3524 Oleander Wa Gulfstream, Florida Date: 6/11112 Test: Usual Open Hole Exfiltrati_on Test Surface _ _ Water table from ground Elevation: Approx. itu Road Crown _ surface: 3.5' Casing Diameter: 6" Tube Depth: 6' EXFIL No. 2 Sample Location: Approx. OLS, 10' E. of NW ar pe'ty corner Material: 0-1` T-1.5' 1.5'-3' 3'-6' K = 7.66 x 10-s cfs/ft�ft.head Dk. gray quartz fine sandy TOPSOIL Brown quartz medium silty SAND Dk. brown fibrous PEAT Dk. gray quartz fine SAND and root fibers Wci One pump Rate Minute in Gal/Min Increme O 1 5 1 0.8 1310 NEPTUNE DRIVE - BOVNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 -561-736-4900 - FAX 561-737-9975 Treasure Coast 772-408-1050 Brovvard 954-941-8700 Miami rade 305-824.0060 I: 1310 NEPTUNE DRIVE - BOVNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 -561-736-4900 - FAX 561-737-9975 Treasure Coast 772-408-1050 Brovvard 954-941-8700 Miami rade 305-824.0060 LIMI'E':S.`['IONS OF LI. -k.81,114 WARRANTY We warranty that the services performed by Nutting Engineers of Florida, Inc. are conducted in a manner consistent with that level of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of the profession in uur area currently practicing under similar conditions at the time our services were performed. No other warranties, expressed or implied, are made. Whife the services of Nutting Engineers of Florida, Inc. are a valuable and integral part of the design and construction learns, we do not warrant, guarantee or insure the quality, completeness; or satisfactory performance of designs, construction plans, specifications we have not prepared, nor the ultimate performance of building site materials or asserfi3l y/construction. SUBSURFACE EXPLORATION Subsurface exploration is nurrnally accomplishod by test borings; test pits are sometimes employed. The method of determining the boring location and the surface elevation at the boring is rotod in the report. This information is represented in the soil boring logs andlor a d(awing. The location and elevation of the borings should be considered acmrafe only to the degree inherent with the method used and may be approximate. The soil boring log includes sampling information, description of the materials recovered, approximate depths of boundaries between soil and rock strata as encountered and immediate depth to water data. The log represents conditions recorded specifically at the location where and when the boring was made. Site conditions may v9f%j through time as will suhsurfaci: conditions. l he boundaries between different soil strata as encountered are indicated at specific depths; however, those depths are in fact approximate and dependent upon the frequency of sampling, nature and consistency of the respective strata. Substantial variation between soil borings may commonly exist in subsurface conditions. Water level readings are made at the lime and under conditions stated on the boring logs. Water levels change with time, precipitation, canal level, local well drawdown and other factors. Water level data pmvided on soil bo ng logs shall not be relied upon for groundwater based design or construction considerations. LABORATORY AND FIELD TESTS Tests are performed in general accordance with specific ASTM Standards unless otherwise indicated. All criteria included in a given ASTM Standard are not always required and performed. Each test boring report indica_e.s the measurements and data developed at each specific test locaVon. 31ing neers Ydur?njzci �s f1;� Cnmmt;mr't :t TNAL.YSIS ;1ND REC:OMINIFNnATIONS The geotechnical report is prepared primari.y to aid in the design of site work and structural foundations. Although the information in the report is expected to be sufficient for these p:.rposes, it shall not be utilizod to determine the Cost of crnsfruction nor to stand alone as a constructior) specification. Contractors shall verify subsurface conditions as may be appropriate prior to undertaking subsurface work. Report recommendations are based primarily on data from test borings made at he locations shown on tae test boring reports. Soil variations ccmnmor,ly exist between boring locations. Such variations may nct become evident un'il construction. Test pits sometimes provide valuable supplemental information that derived from soil borings. If variations are then noted, the geotechnical engineer shall be contacted in writing immediately so that field conditions can be examined and recommendations revised if necessary The geotechnical report states our understanding as to the location, dimensions and structural features proposed for the site. Any significant changes of the site improvements or site conditions must be communicated in writing to the geotechnical engineer immediately so that the geotechnical analysis, conclusions, and recommendations can be reviewed and appropriately adjusted as necessary. CONSTRUCTION OUSLRVATION Constructiori observation and testing is an important element of geotechnical services. The geotechnical engineer's field representative (G.E.F.R.) is the `owner's representative" observing the work of the contractor, porform.ing tests and reporting data from such tests and observations. Tire geotechnical engineer's field representative does not direct the contractor`s construction means, methods, operations or personnel. The G.E.F.R does not interfere with the relatiorsh'p between the owner and the contractor and, except as an observer, does not become a substitute owner on site. the G.E.F.R, is responsible for his/hrr safety, but has no responsibility for the safety of other personnel at the site. The G.E.F.R. is an important member of a team whose responsibility is to observe and test [tie work being done and report to the owner whether that work is being carried out in general conformance with time plans and specifications. The enclosed report may be relied upon solely by the named client. G SOIL AND ROCK CL.ASS1FicA'nON CRITERIA SAINUSILT CI.AY"S1 LTY CLAY .N -VALUE RELATIVE N-VAIXE UNCONFINED COMP. DEISSTTY STRENGTH (tsf) CONSISTENCY .. .. ......... -Y Lmm 4 %lei c e2 0,25 v Soft 5-10 2 4 0.25-0.50 Sa: 11 29 0 5) - I or) Medium 7 .. ..... .. . .. . ..... ... ... . . ........... . .10-49 I Deuc 9 15 1.00 2.0171 Soft Very ctnse 16- 31) 2.00 - 4.00 Stili 00, R t. i a1 Hard RUCK V -VAI UE RELATIVE HARDNESS ROCK CHARACTERISTICS !--N> 101' Haffl -D v. hal td Local rack rcrittafilons vary in !ta-.dness frum soft to very hard rithin 3hollerti- 2.1!; N <I GO hard to hard Cal ,I -,.d holizont'll distances and after, contain vertical solution holes of 3 to 36 --y:iig de-pil-is and horzowal scUion thrires. Rock may be Ss N 5 Soft To inedium'.w.3 b; nit io spl*'.t spoo impact, bat more resi5iant to excavation. L. ..... .. PARTICLE S17E DESCRIPTION MODIFIERS . .Boulder >12 in. 0 JO/Z Slight l'act: Cobb],.- 1 to I! in 6 - 10% Traco Grave[ :1.76 invii to i in. I i :0,1- Little salid 0.074 rim io 4,76 win 11 351, Some Silt 0.01`15 rim to 0.074 mi-ri >331", And Clay U.005 nim Group Major Divisions Symbols Typical names Laboratory classffiral:on criteria -W W.11 Q-d�d 9-61 (D 11 C', -Pngreater1lrm4.C,- berlwtnlzuid3�, rwwrm �.vi, w P- lir-, D, D,%D,0 . . .. . ....... 7. Z d r,— Title o, re N.: -ilhq gmdc, 1w req.4mMongs 40, GW -6, Silly w -k a _-kc- t n u AJJ.rh"G.,-, b.1- "A' cry lime ., P r1m. 4 Ae- 'A" ll,e .ri,h F L . bl— 4 .1d 7 .1. hcrdra jL T. G.l.yC. V 7 A a.k,k D (DJ! e! 415.! 5w 'e - I'll. r {;,b, C� gre3:eT dian 6; C, befiveEn t and 5 D ,vD,4 u 0 a17 P-11 r SP 6.s -2 A., -linq .11 $W —d -,O .W, lkli's b,ln- "JV' 'Ph Ni. b.i-n .1 and 7 rnn -a It, <r r 1. 1�" t., d -WHH4 Asa Arts b.w lktal. i-, A "I i;h P.J. M.'. MW 7 dolls Mutt Eng Reers AL d: CL g, 7 ,Jy. A 3 01. Otg— 11,. and.,g.,k Vly cloys of k- 1,xiz^, n -din -- Mit is .......... CH a- tith f& eat 7.0 Jil; VJ "a U 110 pics'le!Y, nag":c PT P-1 —1 A— 1.1VU7 aysr is W. Plasticity Chart Mutt Eng Reers ksun ro 0 4.1 $ rl U 4J 0 O v 3 m o u E- LW W X roo xsmi roow 4-I 4 U C H i 0 f4 -H -1 .G E 4 G X H ro z W (0 N ua i) �uw m r.0 x ro ro v aJ +-) M w � ro O Ea x ro � 0) 4J G to w •,I ro G 4� u m ro X N J-1 ro Mw ro ri 04 0 01-1io0o0o00 m r- N 0 0 0 0 0 0 [- N 0 0 0 o O O O MMr)000000 N C 1` 0 0 0 0 0 0 mw 1-00000o 1n C; C,O000 NO NOr to mm m ko r-NmrN N m O m O N r N O m 0 n O1- 01`')1)17 o rlo O H O N Cr r- O -4 O 0 0 0 r 7 m r` O O O rnrnrn000000 �mm v�cc OOornrnrnmmm OOOOOOOOO ,41-1 H 0 00000 oO000O0o0 OOOOOOOOO ooOOOOOOO ooOOOocoo 000000OOO N 1 Ll Ll L' 1; N L�L" N N N N N N N N N o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000000000 000ooOOOO r114r 1 1r 1�14r7M N N N N N N N N N O 1--1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00000000O ur, 1r, n 1n Lr 1n r Ln 14 rI rI H -4 1 aaaaaaaaa NNx�NxNax N N a' N N v 1 N N� as aaNaa` ra�arraNa�a .-1 Nr) rIN r7 rl Nr) W W W W W W W W W m m m m m m m m m mmmmmmmmm rl H H N N N N>1 N zzznmmQgQ zzzzzz mmw]QCQ EEEEW W W mmmaaa 00owa,a, a, a, a, MODRET SUMMARY OF UNSATURATED & SATURATED INPUT PARAMETERS PROJECT NAME: SOUTHEAST SWALE POLLUTION VOLUME RUNOFF DATA USED UNSATURATED ANALYSIS INCLUDED Pond Bottom Area Pond Volume between Bottom & DHWL Pond Length to Width Ratio (L/W) Elevation of Effective Aquifer Base Elevation of Seasonal High Groundwater Table Elevation of Starting Water Level Elevation of Pond Bottom Design High Water Level Elevation Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Unsaturated Analysis Unsaturated Vertical Hydraulic Conductivity Factor of Safety Saturated Horizontal Hydraulic Conductivity Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Saturated Analysis Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Pond/ Exfi ltration Trench Hydraulic Control Features: Groundwater Control Features - Y/N Distance to Edge of Pond Elevation of Water Level Impervious Barrier - Y/N Elevation of Barrier Bottom Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 0.00 ftz 190.00 ft3 11.90 -0.50 ft 2.00 ft 3.30 ft 3.30 ft 3.80 ft 0.15 16.34 ft/d 2.00 10.88 ft/d 0.20 1.00 Top Bottom Left Right N N N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 N N N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 MODRET TIME - RUNOFF INPUT DATA PROJECT NAME: SOUTHEAST SWALE STRESS PERIOD NUMBER INCREMENT OF TIME (hrs) VOLUME OF RUNOFF (ft3) Unsat 0.57 0.00 1 1.00 190.00 2 1.81 0.00 3 1.81 0.00 4 1.81 0.00 5 1.81 0.00 6 1.81 0.00 7 1.81 0.00 8 1.81 0.00 9 1.81 0.00 10 1.81 0.00 11 1.81 0.00 12 1.81 0.00 13 1.81 0.00 14 1.81 0.00 15 1.81 0.00 16 1.81 0.00 17 1.81 0.00 18 1.81 0.00 19 1.81 0.00 20 1.81 0.00 21 1.81 0.00 22 1.81 0.00 23 1.81 0.00 24 1.81 0.00 25 1.81 0.00 26 1.81 0.00 27 1.81 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 28 1.81 0.00 1. 29 1 1.81 1 0.00 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME : SOUTHEAST SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER ELEVATION (feet) INSTANTANEOUS INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (ds) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 00.00-0.00 2.000 0.000 0.00000 0.00 2.000 0.02024 0.01734 1.57 3.542 0.01445 0.00 0.01113 3.38 3.351 0.00902 0.00 0.00691 4.16 3.300 0.00599 0.00 0.00507 6.99 3.146 0.00455 0.00 0.00402 8.80 3.077 0.00368 0.00 0.00333 10.60 3.020 0.00309 0.00 0.00284 12.41 2.972 0.00266 0.00 0.00247 14.21 2.929 0.00233 0.00 0.00219 16.02 2.892 0.00207 0.00 0.00196 17.83 2.859 0.00186 0.00 0.00177 19.63 2.828 0.00169 0.00 0.00161 21.44 2.801 0.00154 0.00 0.00148 23.24 2.775 0.00142 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME : SOUTHEAST SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER ELEVATION (feet) INSTANTANEOUS INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (ds) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 0.00136 25.05 2.752 0.00131 0.00 0.00126 26.85 2.731 0.00122 0.00 0.00118 28.66 2.710 0.00114 0.00 0.00110 30.47 2.692 0.00106 0.00 0.00103 32.27 2.674 0.00100 0.00 0.00097 34.08 2.658 0.00094 0.00 0.00091 35.88 2.642 0.00088 0.00 0.00086 37.69 2.627 0.00084 0.00 0.00081 39.50 2.613 0.00079 0.00 0.00077 41.30 2.600 0.00075 0.00 0.00073 43.11 2.588 0.00072 0.00 0.00070 44.91 2.576 0.00068 0.00 0.00067 46.72 2.564 0.00065 0.00 0.00064 48.52 2.553 0.00062 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: SOUTHEAST SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER ELEVATION (feet) INSTANTANEOUS INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (ds) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 0.00061 50.33 2.543 0.00060 0.00 0.00058 52.14 2.533 0.00057 0.00 0.00056 53.94 2.523 0.00055 0.00 0.00054 55.75 2.514 0.00053 0.00 0.00052 57.55 2.505 0.00051 0.00 0.00050 59.36 2.497 0.00049 0.00 0.00048 61.17 2.489 0.00047 0.00 0.00046 62.97 2.481 0.00045 0.00 0.00045 64.78 2.473 0.00044 0.00 0.00043 66.58 2.466 0.00042 0.00 0.00042 68.39 2.459 0.00041 0.00 0.00040 70.19 2.452 0.00040 0.00 0.00039 72.00 2.445 0.00 Maximum Water Elevation: 3.542 feet @ 1.57 hours Recovery @ 4.160 hours * Time increment when there is no runoff Maximum Infiltration Rate: 3.943 ft/day Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF UNSATURATED & SATURATED INPUT PARAMETERS PROJECT NAME: NORTHEAST SWALE POLLUTION VOLUME RUNOFF DATA USED UNSATURATED ANALYSIS INCLUDED Pond Bottom Area Pond Volume between Bottom & DHWL Pond Length to Width Ratio (L/W) Elevation of Effective Aquifer Base Elevation of Seasonal High Groundwater Table Elevation of Starting Water Level Elevation of Pond Bottom Design High Water Level Elevation Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Unsaturated Analysis Unsaturated Vertical Hydraulic Conductivity Factor of Safety Saturated Horizontal Hydraulic Conductivity Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Saturated Analysis Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Pond/ Exfi ltration Trench Hydraulic Control Features: Groundwater Control Features - Y/N Distance to Edge of Pond Elevation of Water Level Impervious Barrier - Y/N Elevation of Barrier Bottom Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 0.00 ftz 350.00 ft3 21.90 -0.50 ft 2.00 ft 3.30 ft 3.30 ft 3.80 ft 0.15 40.80 ft/d 2.00 27.20 ft/d 0.20 1.00 Top Bottom Left Right N N N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 N N N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 MODRET TIME - RUNOFF INPUT DATA PROJECT NAME: NORTHEAST SWALE STRESS PERIOD NUMBER INCREMENT OF TIME (hrs) VOLUME OF RUNOFF (ft3) Unsat 0.23 0.00 1 1.00 350.00 2 1.81 0.00 3 1.81 0.00 4 1.81 0.00 5 1.81 0.00 6 1.81 0.00 7 1.81 0.00 8 1.81 0.00 9 1.81 0.00 10 1.81 0.00 11 1.81 0.00 12 1.81 0.00 13 1.81 0.00 14 1.81 0.00 15 1.81 0.00 16 1.81 0.00 17 1.81 0.00 18 1.81 0.00 19 1.81 0.00 20 1.81 0.00 21 1.81 0.00 22 1.81 0.00 23 1.81 0.00 24 1.81 0.00 25 1.81 0.00 26 1.81 0.00 27 1.81 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 2g 1.81 0.00 29 1 1.81 1 0.00 f A � MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER INSTANTANEOUS ELEVATION INFILTRATION (feet) RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 00.00-0.00 2.000 0.000 0.00000 0.00 2.000 0.07581 0.06133 1.23 3.412 0.04684 0.00 0.02546 2.09 3.300 0.02004 0.00 0.01462 4.86 3.038 0.01239 0.00 0.01015 6.67 2.943 0.00893 0.00 0.00771 8.49 2.872 0.00694 0.00 0.00617 10.30 2.814 0.00565 0.00 0.00512 12.12 2.766 0.00474 0.00 0.00435 13.93 2.726 0.00406 0.00 0.00377 15.75 2.690 0.00354 0.00 0.00331 17.56 2.659 0.00313 0.00 0.00294 19.38 2.632 0.00279 0.00 0.00264 21.19 2.607 0.00251 0.00 0.00239 23.00 2.585 0.00228 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER ELEVATION (feet) INSTANTANEOUS INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) AVERAGE CUMULATIVE INFILTRATION OVERFLOW RATE (ds) (ft3) 0.00218 24.82 2.565 0.00209 0.00 0.00200 26.63 2.546 0.00192 0.00 0.00184 28.45 2.529 0.00177 0.00 0.00171 30.26 2.513 0.00165 0.00 0.00159 32.08 2.498 0.00153 0.00 0.00148 33.89 2.484 0.00143 0.00 0.00139 35.71 2.471 0.00134 0.00 0.00130 37.52 2.459 0.00126 0.00 0.00122 39.34 2.448 0.00118 0.00 0.00115 41.15 2.437 0.00112 0.00 0.00109 42.97 2.427 0.00106 0.00 0.00103 44.78 2.417 0.00100 0.00 0.00098 46.60 2.408 0.00095 0.00 0.00093 48.41 2.400 0.00091 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE L1 CUMULATIVE WATER TIME ELEVATION (hrs) (feet) INSTANTANEOUS INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 0.00088 50.22 2.391 0.00086 0.00 0.00084 52.04 2.384 0.00082 0.00 0.00080 53.85 2.376 0.00079 0.00 0.00077 55.67 2.369 0.00075 0.00 0.00074 57.48 2.362 0.00072 0.00 0.00071 59.30 2.355 0.00069 0.00 0.00068 61.11 2.349 0.00066 0.00 0.00065 62.93 2.343 0.00064 0.00 0.00062 64.74 2.337 0.00061 0.00 0.00060 66.56 2.332 0.00059 0.00 0.00058 68.37 2.326 0.00057 0.00 0.00056 70.19 2.321 0.00055 0.00 0.00054 72.00 2.316 0.00 Maximum Water Elevation: 3.412 feet @ 1.23 hours Recovery @ 2.087 hours * Time increment when there is no runoff Maximum Infiltration Rate: 7.569 ft/day Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF UNSATURATED & SATURATED INPUT PARAMETERS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE POLLUTION VOLUME RUNOFF DATA USED UNSATURATED ANALYSIS INCLUDED Pond Bottom Area Pond Volume between Bottom & DHWL Pond Length to Width Ratio (L/W) Elevation of Effective Aquifer Base Elevation of Seasonal High Groundwater Table Elevation of Starting Water Level Elevation of Pond Bottom Design High Water Level Elevation Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Unsaturated Analysis Unsaturated Vertical Hydraulic Conductivity Factor of Safety Saturated Horizontal Hydraulic Conductivity Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Saturated Analysis Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Pond/ Exfi ltration Trench Hydraulic Control Features: Groundwater Control Features - Y/N Distance to Edge of Pond Elevation of Water Level Impervious Barrier - Y/N Elevation of Barrier Bottom Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 0.00 ftz 830.00 ft3 30.00 -0.50 ft 2.00 ft 4.30 ft 4.30 ft 5.30 ft 0.15 40.80 ft/d 2.00 27.20 ft/d 0.20 1.00 Top Bottom Left Right N N N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 N N N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2C MODRET TIME - RUNOFF INPUT DATA PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER INSTANTANEOUS ELEVATION INFILTRATION (feet) RATE (ds) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (ds) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 00.00-0.00 2.000 0.000 0.00000 0.00 2.000 0.16639 0.13335 1.41 4.487 0.10031 0.00 0.05778 2.15 4.300 0.04481 0.00 0.03184 5.03 3.783 0.02669 0.00 0.02153 6.84 3.614 0.01879 0.00 0.01606 8.65 3.488 0.01438 0.00 0.01269 10.46 3.388 0.01155 0.00 0.01041 12.27 3.307 0.00959 0.00 0.00877 14.08 3.238 0.00816 0.00 0.00755 15.89 3.179 0.00707 0.00 0.00660 17.70 3.127 0.00622 0.00 0.00584 19.51 3.081 0.00554 0.00 0.00523 21.32 3.040 0.00498 0.00 0.00473 23.13 3.003 0.00452 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER INSTANTANEOUS ELEVATION INFILTRATION (feet) RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 0.00431 24.94 2.969 0.00413 0.00 0.00394 26.75 2.938 0.00379 0.00 0.00363 28.56 2.909 0.00350 0.00 0.00336 30.37 2.883 0.00324 0.00 0.00312 32.18 2.859 0.00301 0.00 0.00291 33.99 2.836 0.00281 0.00 0.00272 35.80 2.814 0.00263 0.00 0.00255 37.61 2.794 0.00247 0.00 0.00239 39.42 2.776 0.00232 0.00 0.00225 41.23 2.758 0.00219 0.00 0.00212 43.04 2.741 0.00207 0.00 0.00201 44.85 2.726 0.00196 0.00 0.00190 46.66 2.711 0.00186 0.00 0.00181 48.47 2.696 0.00177 0.00 Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PROJECT NAME: NORTH SWALE CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER INSTANTANEOUS ELEVATION INFILTRATION (feet) RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 0.00172 50.28 2.683 0.00168 0.00 0.00164 52.09 2.670 0.00160 0.00 0.00157 53.90 2.658 0.00153 0.00 0.00150 55.71 2.646 0.00146 0.00 0.00143 57.52 2.635 0.00140 0.00 0.00137 59.33 2.624 0.00135 0.00 0.00132 61.14 2.614 0.00129 0.00 0.00127 62.95 2.604 0.00124 0.00 0.00122 64.76 2.594 0.00120 0.00 0.00117 66.57 2.585 0.00115 0.00 0.00113 68.38 2.576 0.00111 0.00 0.00109 70.19 2.567 0.00107 0.00 0.00105 72.00 2.559 0.00 Maximum Water Elevation: 4.487 feet @ 1.41 hours Recovery @ 2.151 hours * Time increment when there is no runoff Maximum Infiltration Rate: 13.882 ft/day Analysis Date: 6/19/2012 1 Town of Gulf Stream APPLICATION FOR Substantial Improvement REVIEW Tax Appraisers Folio #: 20-43-46-03-06-000-0570 Property Address: 3524 Oleander Way City and Zip Code: Gulf Stream, FL 33438 Owner's Name: Thomas Stanley Co -Owner's Name: Kirsten Stanley Owner's Mailing Address: 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Owner Phone #: (561)262-4111 FIRM Panel: ��� j ! Flood Zone: BFE: Lowest Floor Elevation: I am attaching an appraisal report of my property, or I am not submitting an appraisal report of my property I accept Gulf Stream Estimated Market Value, or I accept Gulf Stream Estimated Replacement Cost Initials / , Initials Initials Initials I accept the attached estimated cost of construction as a fair and total cost of the improvements proposed for my home. Initials -s SIGNATURES: Owner: Dat Co -Owner: Dat JUL o 9 2W Town of Gulf Stream, FL_ Substantial Improvement ITEMS To BE INCL UDED All strzrctural e1 emen is including: Spread or continuous foundat_on footings and pi_;nas Monolithic or other types of concrete slabs Bearing walls, tie beams and trusses Wood or reinforced concrete decking or roofing doors and ceilings Attached decks and porches Interior partition walls Exterior wall finishes (eg. brick, stucco, or siding) includi_^_c painting and decorative moldings Windows and doors Reshingling or retilina a roof Hardware All interior finish e3ements, including: Tiling, linoleum, stone, or carpet over subfloorina Bathroom tiling and fixtures Wall finishes, eg. drywal', painting, stucco, plaster, pare-=;na, marble, or other decorative finishes. Kischen, utility and bathroom cabinets Built-in bookcases, cabinets, and furniture Hardware All utility and service equipment, including: HVAC eauipment Repair or reconstruction of plumbing and Alectriz 1 services Light fixtures and ceiling fans security systems Built-in kitchen appliances Central vacuum systems Water f_'-tration, conditioning or rec_rcuiation systems Also: Gabor and other costs associated with removing or alter=na undaL--naged building ccmrcnents to accommodate 'mproverne::ts or additions - f r' Substantial improvement ITE'�I�IS TO BE' XCL UDF'D Plans and speci=ications Survey costs PerMit fens Coss to demolish storm -damaged bui Debris removal ldi=c co:nPone_^.cs Itsms not considered real properCy such: as: row ,uzs {C;_`^_--_ Over �in'.S}ISr1' �IOOrS) furniture, re__i,7ar=cOrs, SLJvS= not Oucside improvements, inc'_udina: Landscaping Sidewalks Fences Yard lights Swimming pools Screened pool enclosures Shads Gazebos De.aehnd st_sctures (including garages; Landscape {r =nation systerns CONTRACTOR COST OF IMPROVEMENTS AFFIDAVIT Folio #; 20-43-46-03-06-000-0570 Contractor Name: } Qtr u 455 h, Address: ,� . t.. License : CrGC_ 03 Property Address: 3524 Oleander Wav, Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Phone: \ ^ Z LZ-7_'1(,�_'� I hereby attest to the fact that I, or a member of my staff, personally inspected the above mentioned property and produced the attached itemized list of improvements which is hereby submitted for a Substantial Improvement Review, These improvements are all OF THE IMPROVEMENTS proposed for this structure. I understand that I am subject to enforcement and penalties and violation action and/or fines if the Inspection of the property reveals that I have made improvements NOT INCLUDED ON THE ATTACHER LIST OF IMPROVEMENTS to THIS STRUCTURE. I understand that any permit issued by Culf Stream pursuant to this affidavit does not authorize the reconstruction, repair or maintenance of any illegal additions, fences, sheds or non -conforming uses or structures on the subject property- . See Attached Itemized List V0/Z0 39Vd ONI S31VI30SSV mno" 988E99ZT99 Z17:171 Zi0Zf80//_0 ESTIMATED COST OF IMPROVEMENT Folio #: 20-43-46,03.06-000-0570 Address: 3524 Ctleander Way, Gulf Stream, PL 33483 The CCst Estimates of Improvement must be prepared and signed by a licensed General Contractor ITEMS COST Materials Labor Official Use Concrete, Form, ETC Carpentry Material (rough) Carpentry Labor (rough)"' c.) Cr Roofing ocz Insulation & Weather Strip 1 Exterior Finish (stucco) Doors, Windows & Shutters =' Lumber Finish Carpenter Labor (finish) y^ Hardware (finish) Y a °" Hardware (rough)Cabinets (built-in)Floor covering (tile/rug) p Plumbing UbeQcf) Cr Shower/Tub/Toilet Electrical �1t Light Fixtures!�e Built-in Appliances] (�CnD HAVC Paint 3 C=am. c -� ,fi,�, 1 Total Contractor Name: Mi -i_&W s c�c� �� �C'�,,� CGC License #: C� C_ C - Address: phone #:(,,,— Signature: KJL ' Date: VO/60 39Gd SNI S31VI00SSV Allow 98BC99ZT95 Tb:bT ZTOZ/80/L0 Total Labor & Materials Overhead & Profit Total Cost STATE Or Florida COUNTY OF Palm Beach Affidavit Before me this day personally appeared RJAVd Mok Uj who, being duly sworn deposes and says that he has read, understands and agrees to comply with all of the aforementioned conditions Date: 1 2�- Contractor's Signature Sworn to and subscribed before me this � r day of QA.D., ?01 My commission expires: f a l 5— (votary Public State of Florida VO/VO 39Vd 0NI S31VI00SSV Allow 988CS93T99 TV:17T ZT07,180120 OWNER COST OF IMPROVEMENTS AFFIDAVIT Folio # 20-43-46-03-06-000-0570 Contractor Name: Owner Name: Thomas and Kirsten Stanley License # : Property Address: 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Phone: (561) 262-4111 I hereby attest to the fact that the costs of improvements submitted for the Substantial Improvement Review by my contractor are ALL OF THE IMPROVEMENTS proposed for this structure. No other contractor will be making any improvements not included in the attached list. I understand that I am subject to enforcement action and/or fines if the inspection of the property reveals that I have made improvements NOT INCLUDED ON THE ATTACHED LIST OF IMPROVEMENTS to MY BUILDING. I understand that any permit issued by Gulf Stream pursuant to this affidavit does not authorize the reconstruction, repair or maintenance of any illegal additions, fences, sheds or non- conforming uses or structures on the subject property. STATE OF Florida COUNTY OF Palm Beach Before me this day personally appearedI who, being duly sworn deposes and says that he has read, understands and agrees to comply with II of the aforementioned conditions ature Owner Co -Owner Q /vl Sworn to and subscribed before me this ( day of - A. D., 2U:2 Utary Publi ate of Florida My commission expires: ; ti; � "r a4 : JOAN 0, SASSO PAY COMMISSION # EE 090219 EXPIRES: July 16, 2015 Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY ELEVATION CERTIFICATE OMB No. 1660-0008 Federal Emergency Management Agency Expires March 31, 2012 National Flood Insurance Program Important: Read the instructions on pages 1-9. SECTION A - PROPERTY INFORMATION For Insurance Company Use: Al. Building Owner's Name Policy Number A2. Building Street Address (including Apt., Unit, Suite, and/or Bldg. No.) or P.O. Route and Box No. Company NAIC Number 3524 OLEANDER WAY City GULF STREAM State FL ZIP Code 33483 A3. Property Description (Lot and Block Numbers, Tax Parcel Number, Legal Description, etc.) LOT 57, GULF STREAM PROPERTIES NO. 2 (PLAT BOOK 18, PAGE 42) A4. Building Use (e.g., Residential, Non -Residential, Addition, Accessory, etc.) RESIDENTIAL A5. Latitude/LongRude: Lat. 26029'52"N Long. 80003'16'W Horizontal Datum: ❑ NAD 1927 ® NAD 1983 A6. Attach at least 2 photographs of the building if the Certificate is being used to obtain flood insurance. A7. Building Diagram Number 1 A8. For a building with a crawlspace or enclosure(s): A9. For a building with an attached garage: a) Square footage of crawlspace or enclosure(s) N/A sq ft a) Square footage of attached garage WA sq ft b) No. of permanent flood openings in the crawlspace or b) No. of permanent flood openings in the attached garage enclosure(s) within 1.0 foot above adjacent grade N/A within 1.0 foot above adjacent grade WA c) Total net area of flood openings in A8.b N/A sq in c) Total net area of flood openings in A9.b N/A sq in d) Engineered flood openings? ❑ Yes ® No d) Engineered flood openings? ❑ Yes ® No SECTION B - FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAP (FIRM) INFORMATION B1. NFIP Community Name & Community Number B2. County Name B3. State TOWN OF GULF STREAM 125109 1 PALM BEACH I FLORIDA B11. B12. Indicate the source of the Base Flood Elevation (BFE) data or base flood depth entered in Item B9. ❑ FIS Profile ® FIRM ❑ Community Determined ❑ Other (Describe) Indicate elevation datum used for BFE in Item 139: ® NGVD 1929 ❑ NAVD 1988 ❑ Other (Describe) Is the building located in a Coastal Barrier Resources System (CBRS) area or Otherwise Protected Area (OPA)? Designation Date ❑ CBRS ❑ OPA AO, use base flood depth) 7 ❑ Yes ® No SECTION C - BUILDING ELEVATION INFORMATION (SURVEY REQUIRED) Cl. Building elevations are based on: ❑ Construction Drawings' ❑ Building Under Construction` ® Finished Construction 'A new Elevation Certificate will be required when construction of the building is complete. C2. Elevations—Zones Ai -A30, AE, AH, A (with BFE), VE, V1 -V30, V (with BFE), AR, ARIA, ARAE, AR/Al-A30, AR/AH, AR/AO. Complete Items C2.a-h below according to the building diagram specified in Item AT Use the same datum as the BFE. Benchmark Utilized PALM BEACH COUNTY Vertical Datum 1929 Conversion/Comments WA Check the measurement used. a) Top of bottom floor (including basement, crawlspace, or enclosure floor) 5.1 ® feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) b) Top of the next higher floor 6.2 ® feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) c) Bottom of the lowest horizontal structural member (V Zones only) N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) d) Attached garage (top of slab) N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) e) Lowest elevation of machinery or equipment servicing the building NA. ❑ feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) (Describe type of equipment and location in Comments) 0 Lowest adjacent (finished) grade next to building (LAG) 4.0 ® feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) g) Highest adjacent (finished) grade next to building (HAG) 4.7 ® feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) h) Lowest adjacent grade at lowest elevation of deck or stairs, including N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters (Puerto Rico only) structural support SECTION D - SURVEYOR, ENGINEER, OR ARCHITECT CERTIFICATION This certification is to be signed and sealed by a land surveyor, engineer, or architect authorized by law to certify elevation information. I certify that the information on this Certificate represents my best efforts to interpret the data available. I understand that any false statement may be punishable by fine or imprisonment under 18 U -S. Code, Section 1001_ [DATE: 06/30/10 ❑ Check here if comments are provided on back of form_ Were latitude and longitude in Section A provided by a licensed land surveyor? ® Yes ❑ No Certifier's Name PAUL D. ENGLE License Number 5708 Title SURVEYOR & MAPPER Company Name O'BRIEN, SUITER O'BRIEN, INC. Address 955 N.W. 17TH AVENUE City DELRAY BEACH State FL ZIP Code 33445 FEMA Form 81-31, Mar 09 06/30/1 561 See reverse side for continuation. PAUL. D. ENGL SURVEYOR & PER #5108 Replaces all previous editions IMPORTANT: In theses Building Street Address (incli 3524 OLEANDER WA :es, copy the c_ .esponding information from Section A. IFor Insurance Company Use: Apt, Unit, Suite, and/or Bldg No.) or P.O. Route and Box No. Policy Number City GULF STREAM State FL ZIP Code 33483 1 Company NAIC Number SECTION D - SURVEYOR, ENGINEER, OR ARCHITECT CERTIFICATION (CONTINUED) Copy both sides of this Elevation Certificate for (1) community official, (2) insurance agent/company, and (3) building owner. Comments DETACHED GARAGE FLOOR ELEVATION IS +4.0 FEET WITH A LOWEST ADJACENT IS +3.8 FEET AND A HIGHEST ADJACENT GRADE OF +4.2 FEET. MAIN RESIDENCE HAS OPENINGS BELOW EXISTING FLOOR. OPENINGS APPEAR TO BE AIR VENTS AND NOT FLOOD OPENINGS. THE -S SCE UIJDkR EXISTING FLOOR IS NOT ACCESSIBLE, I.E. NOT A CRAWL SPACE. Signature — 1 -- Date 06/30/10 1 El Check here if attachments SECTION E - BUILDING ELEVATION INFORMATION (SURVEY NOT REQUIRED) FOR ZONE AO AND ZONE A (WITHOUT BFE) For Zones AO and A (without BFE), complete Items E1 -E5. If the Certificate is intended to support a LOMA or LOMR-F request, complete Sections A, B, and C. For Items E1 -E4, use natural grade, if available. Check the measurement used. In Puerto Rico only, enter meters. E1. Provide elevation information for the following and check the appropriate boxes to show whether the elevation is above or below the highest adjacent grade (HAG) and the lowest adjacent grade (LAG). a) Top of bottom floor (including basement, crawlspace, or enclosure) is N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters ❑ above or ❑ below the HAG. b) Top of bottom floor (including basement, crawlspace, or enclosure) is N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters ❑ above or ❑ below the LAG. E2. For Building Diagrams 6-9 with permanent flood openings provided in Section A Items 8 and/or 9 (see pages 8-9 of Instructions), the next higher floor (elevation C2.b in the diagrams) of the building is NIA. ❑ feet ❑ meters ❑ above or ❑ below the HAG. E3. Attached garage (top of slab) is N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters ❑ above or ❑ below the HAG. E4. Top of platform of machinery and/or equipment servicing the building is N/A. ❑ feet ❑ meters ❑ above or ❑ below the HAG. E5. Zone AO only: If no flood depth number is available, is the top of the bottom floor elevated in accordance with the community's floodplain management ordinance? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Unknown. The local official must certify this information in Section G. SECTION F - PROPERTY OWNER (OR OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE) CERTIFICATION The property owner or owner's authorized representative who completes Sections A, B, and E for Zone A (without a FEMA -issued or community -issued BFE) or Zone AO must sign here. The statements in Sections A, 8, and E are correct to the best of my knowledge. Property Owner's or Owners Authorized Representative's Name Address City State ZIP Code Signature Date Telephone Comments ❑ Check here if attachments SECTION G - COMMUNITY INFORMATION (OPTIONAL) The local official who is authorized by law or ordinance to administer the community's floodplain management ordinance can complete Sections A, B, C (or E), and G of this Elevation Certificate. Complete the applicable Rem(s) and sign below. Check the measurement used in Items G8 and G9. G1. ❑ The information in Section C was taken from other documentation that has been signed and sealed by a licensed surveyor, engineer, or architect who is authorized by law to certify elevation information. (Indicate the source and date of the elevation data in the Comments area below.) G2. ❑ A community official completed Section E for a building located in Zone A (without a FEMA -issued or community -issued BFE) or Zone AO. G3. ❑ The following information (Items G4 -G9) is provided for community floodplain management purposes. G4. Permit Number I G5. Date Permit Issued I G6. Date Certificate Of Compliance/Occupancy Issued G7. This permit has been issued for: ❑ New Construction ❑ Substantial Improvement G8. Elevation of as -built lowest floor (including basement) of the building: ❑ feet ❑ meters (PR) Datum G9. BFE or (in Zone AO) depth of flooding at the building site: ❑ feet ❑ meters (PR) Datum G10. Community's design flood elevation ❑ feet ❑ meters (PR) Datum Local Official's Name Title Community Name Telephone Signature Date Comments ❑ Check -here if attachments FEMA Form 81-31, Mar 09 Replaces all previous editions Building Photographs See Instructions for Item A6. For Insurance Company Use: Building Street Address (including Apt, Unit, Suite, and/or Bldg. No.) or P.O. Route and Box No. Policy Number 3524 OLEANDER WAY (MAIN RESIDENCE) City GULF STREAM State FL ZIP Code 33483 Company NAIC Number If using the Elevation Certificate to obtain NFIP flood insurance, affix at least two building photographs below according to the instructions for Item A6. Identify all photographs with: date taken; "Front View" and "Rear View"; and, if required, "Right Side View" and `Left Side View." If submitting more photographs than will fit on this page, use the Continuation Page on the reverse. FRONT VIEW REAR VIEW Building Photographs Continuation Page For Insurance Company Use: Building Street Address (including Apt, Unit, Suite, and/or Bldg. No.) or P_O. Route and Box No. Policy Number 3524 OLEANDER WAY (GARAGE) City GULF STREAM State FL ZIP Code 33483 Company NAIC Number If submitting more photographs than will fit on the preceding page, affix the additional photographs below. Identify all photographs with: date taken-, "Front View" and "Rear View",- and, if required, "Right Side View" and "Left Side View." AGE FRONT VIEW REAR VIEW IL • � iF�i4w_ �. j !+ � .ems �•v.. COUNTY OF PALM BEACH: h� fICE OF AD VALOREM TAXES AND NON -ALJ VALOREM ASSESSMENTS PROPERTY CONTROL NUMBER YEAR CMC COLLECTOR NO. 20-43-46-03-06-000-0570 2011 98 101419480 D 5 - 167383 STANLEY THOMAS M & STANLEY KIRSTEN B 3524 OLEANDER WAY DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7422 III Jill I1I1111111III11I11111111III1I1111111I11II'1III1III1'I11111 READ REVERSE SIDE BEFORE CALLING TAXING AUTHORITY COUNTY COUNTY DEBT TOWN OF GULF STREAM CHILDRENS SERVICES COUNCIL F.I.N.D. PBC HEALTH CARE DISTRICT SCHOOLLOCAL SCHOOL STATE SFWMD EVERGLADES CONST PROJECT SO FLA WATER MANAGEMENT DIST. SO FLA WATER MGMT - OKEE BASIN EXEMPTIONS APPLIED Homestead SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR MORE INFORMATION LEGAL DESCRIPTION '& S 1/2 OF PANDANUS RD LYG N OF ADJTHERETO ANNE M. GANNON, CONSTITUTIONAL TAX COLLECTOR SERVING PALM BEACH COUNTY PAY ONLINE: Go to our secure website at www.taxcollectorpbc.com. The website has easy instructions to follow and allows you to print your receipt. AD_ VALOREM TAXES. MILLAGE TELEPHONE ASSESSSED EXEMPTION 561-355-3996 805,362 50,000 561-355-3996 805,362 50,000 561-276-5116 805,362 50,000 561-740-7000 805,362 50,000 561-627-3386 805,362 50,000 561-659-1270 805,362 50,000 561-434-8837 805,362 25,000 561-434-8837 805,362 25,000 561-686-8800 805,362 50,000 561-686-8800 805,362 50,000 561-686-8800 805,362 50,000 READ REVERSE SIDE BEFORE CALLING TAXABLE MILLAGE TAX AMOUNT 755,362 4.7815 3,611.76 755,362 0.2110 159.38 755,362 2.9265 2,210.57 755,362 0.7475 564.63 755,362 0.0345 26.06 755,362 1.1250 849.78 780,362 2.4980 1,949.34 780,362 5.6820 4,434.02 755,362 0.0624 47.13 755,362 0.1785 134.83 755,362 0.1954 147.60 TOTAL AD VALOREM 14,135.10 READ REVERSE SIDE BEFORE CALLING NON -AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS LEVYING AUTHORITY TELEPHONE RATE AMOUNT SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY 561-697-2700 174.00 174.00 TOTAL NON -AD VALOREM 174.00 TOTAL AD VALOREM AND NON -AD VALOREM COMBINED 14,309.10 **** INFORMATIONAL NOTICE **** A TAX NOTICE WAS SENT TO YOUR ESCROW AGENT FOR PAYMENT: CHASE HOME FINANCE DETACH HERE **SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR INSTRUCTIONS AND INFORMATION" DETACH HERE COUNTY OF PALM BEACH: NOTICE OF AD VALOREM TAXES AND NON -AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS PROPERTY CONTROL NUMBER I YEAR I MTG I COLLECTOR NO. 20-43-46-03-06-000-0570 12011 188880 1 101419480 STANLEY THOMAS M & STANLEY KIRSTEN B 3524 OLEANDER WAY DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-7422 LEGAL DESCRIPTION PL SHOWING GULF STREAM PROP 2 LT 57 & S 1/2 OF PANDANUS RD LYG N OF & ADJ THERETO P.O. BOX 3353 WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33402-3353 2011101,419480001,4309102 MAKE CHECKS PAYABLE TO: Tax Collector, Palm Beach County INFORMATIONAL NOTICE PLEASE READ THE REVERSE SIDE AMOUNT DUE WHEN RECEIVED BY Nov 30, 2011 Jan 3, 2012 Jan 31, 2012 Feb 29, 2012 Apr 2, 2012 TAXES ARE $13,736.73 $13,879.82 $14,022.92 $14,166.01 $14,309.10I DELINQUENT APRIL 3 **SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR INSTRUCTIONS AND INFORMATION** RETAIN THIS TOP PORTION FOR YOUR RECORDS RETAIN THIS TOP PORTION FOR YOUR RECORDS INFORMATIONAL NOTICES - IMPORTANT INSTRUCTIONS This NOTICE provides information about your Ad Valorem Taxes and Non -Ad Valorem Assessments for the 2011 calendar year. A TAX NOTICE WAS SENT TO YOUR ESCROW AGENT FOR PAYMENT. Please review and verify the description of the property on this notice. Report any errors to the Office of the Property Appraiser immediately at 561-355-2866. If you've sold the property on the notice, please forward this notice to the new owner or mark this notice "SOLD" and return it to the Constitutional Tax Collector's Office. PAYMENT INFORMATION (if you do not have an escrow agent or your lender is not responsible for payment of your taxes) Discount amounts are shown on the front of this notice. Additional discount information: • December Payments, if mailed, must be postmarked by DECEMBER 31st or paid in our offices by January 3rd to receive your discount. • March Payments, if mailed, must be postmarked by MARCH 3151 or paid in our offices by April 2nd to avoid additional fees. Your Payment Options • E -CHECK (ON-LINE Only) www.taxcollectorpbc.com NO ADDITIONAL FEE (Payment confirmation e-mail provided) • CREDIT CARD (ON-LINE Only) www.taxcollectorpbc.com A CONVENIENCE FEE WILL APPLY (Payment confirmation e-mail provided) • WIRE TRANSFER(bank confirmation serves as receipt) • MAIL (canceled check will serve as receipt) • IN PERSON at one of our Service Centers from 8:15 AM to 5:00 PM, Monday through Friday (receipt provided at counter) • BANK On -Line CHECK - Property owner's bank/bill pay service (bill pay service canceled check will serve as receipt) Pay by E -Check OR Credit Card: Available 24/7 at the Tax Collector's website, www.taxcollectorpbc.com. See enclosed publication for complete instructions. Pay by Mail: Please detach the bottom return portion. DO NOT FOLD, STAPLE, WRITE ON, OR MARK. Make payment payable to Anne Gannon, Constitutional Tax Collector. Please use the enclosed return envelope, making sure the Constitutional Tax Collector's address shows in the return envelope WINDOW. DELINQUENT TAX INFORMATION Ad Valorem Taxes and Non -Ad Valorem Assessments become delinquent after APRIL 2, 2012. • Interest will be charged at a rate of 18% Per Year (1.5 % Per Month) with a minimum charge of 3% Interest shall be collected; • Interest, costs, and associated charges for delinquent taxes are determined by the date payment is received by the Tax Collector; • Payments received after APRIL 2 are delinquent. Mailed payments must be postmarked by MARCH 31;. • Payment AFTER THE DATE OF DELINQUENCY must be by cash, bank draft, wire transfer, certified check, money order, US Postal Order, or cashier's check. FLORIDA STATUTE 197.432 Tax Sale Certificates will be sold on all unpaid properties 60 days after the date of delinquency. CONTACTS FOR QUESTIONS OR PROBLEMS Constitutional Tax Collector: Prepares and mails TAX NOTICES from Tax Roll data certified by the PBC Property Appraiser and Non -Ad Valorem assessments provided by Levying Authorities. (561) 355-2266. Property Appraiser: Prepares the Ad Valorem Tax Roll (assessed value, exemptions, taxable value, assessed owner's name, address, and legal description). (561) 355-2866. Taxing Authorities: Set the Ad Valorem millage rates. See list on reverse side with telephone numbers for questions about Tax Rate and services provided. Levying Authorities: Determines the Non -Ad Valorem assessments. See list on reverse side with telephone numbers for questions about assessment amount and the services provided. DETACH HERE DETACH HERE PLEASE INCLUDE THIS BOTTOM PORTION WITH YOUR PAYMENT TO THE TAX COLLECTOR ANNE M. GANNON, Constitutional Tax Collector Palm Beach County DETACH HERE DO NOT FOLD, STAPLE, WRITE, OR MARK ON THIS PAYMENT STUB Make payment payable to: Anne Gannon, Constitutional Tax Collector. Place this return portion and your payment in the enclosed return envelope. Make sure the Constitutional Tax Collector's address shows in the return envelope window. C Residential Appraisal Report File No. 12-0842 The purpose of this appraisal report is to provide the client with a credible opinion of the defined value of the subject property, given the intended use of the appraisal. Client Name/Intended User MR. THOMAS STANLEY E-mail tom@macmillanstanley.com Client Address 29 NE 4 AVENUE City DELRAY BEACH State FL Zip 33483 Additional Intended Users N/A Intended Use THE INTENDED USE OF THE REPORT IS TO ESTIMATE THE REPLACEMENT VALUE OF THE IMPROVEMENTS FOR ASSISTING THE CLIENT IN OBTAINING BUILDING PERMITS FOR A PROPOSED RENOVATION. Property Address 3524 OLEANDER WAY City GULFSTREAM State FL Zip 33483-7422 Owner of Public Record STANLEY County PALM BEACH Legal Description See Attached Addendum " Assessor's Parcel # 20-43-46-03-06-000-0570 Tax Year 2011 R.E. Taxes S 14 135.10 Neighborhood Name GULFSTREAM Map Reference 43-46-03 Census Tract 0054.11 Propertv RicilitsA raised W Fee Simple El Leasehold Other describe M research Wdid Lj did not reveal any prior sales or transfers of the su 'ect property for the three years prior to the effective date of this appraisal. PriorSalarfransfer: Date 7/9/10 Price $902,500 Sources COUNTY RECORDS PAPA Analysis DfpdDr sale ortransfer history ofthe subject property (arid comparable sales, ifaipplicable) THE APPRAISER HAS RESEARCHED THE SUBJECTS SALES HISTORY INFORMATION FOR THE PRECEDING THREE YEAR PERIOD, IN COMPLIANCE WITH USPAP STANDARD RULE 1-5. Offerings, options and contracts as of the effective date of the appraisal THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS NOT CURRENTLY UNDER CONTRACT, NOR HAS IT BEEN OFFERED FOR SALE IN THE PAST YEAR. Nei hborhood Characteristics One -Unit Housing Trends One -Unit Housing Present Land Use% Location Urban Suburban Rural Pro Values Increasin Stable DecliningPRICE AGE One -Unit 50% Built -U Over 75% W125 -75%W Under 25% 1 Demand/Supply W Shortage In Balance Lj Over Su $000(yrs) 2-4 Unit % Growth URapid X Stable USlow IMarketimiTime Under3mths 3-6mths WOver6mths 800 Low 0 Muld-Family20% Neighborhood Boundaries See Attached Addendum 25,000 High 90 Commercial % 1,500 Pred. 45 Other Vacant 30% Neighborhood Description See Attached Addendum Market Conditions (including support for the above conclusions) THERE ARE INDICATIONS OF STABILIZING VALUES AFTER A FEW YEARS OF DECLINE THAT FOLLOWED RAPIDLY APPRECIATING PRICES OF THE 2000-2006 ERA. CASH OR CONVENTIONAL FINANCING PREVALENT IN THE SUBJECT MARKET WITH NO EVIDENCE OF SELLER FINANCING. Dimensions SEE ATTACHED SURVEY Area 18,817 SF Shape IRREGULAR View RESIDENTIAL SpecificZon Classification RS Zoni Descri tion SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ZoO Co lance L al Le I Noncortormi Grandfathered Use No Zorwn III al describe Is the highest and best use of the subject property as improved (or as proposed per plans and specifications) the present use? WYes ONo If No, describe. THE HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS AS RESIDENTIAL. Utilities Public Other describe Public Other(describe) Off-site Improvements—Type Public Private Elect' ' Water Street ASPHALT X Gas w Li Sanitary Sewer 1XI Li Alley NONE Li Site Comments EASEMENTS ARE THOSE OF PUBLIC RECORD. NO ADVERSE CONDITIONS OR ENCROACHMENTS NOTED AT THE TIME OF INSPECTION. GENERAL DESCRIPTION FOUNDATION EXTERIOR DESCRIPTION materials INTERIOR materials Units X One OnewlAcc. unit Concrete Slab X Crawl S ace Foundation Walls STEM WALL Floors WOOD, TILE # of Stories ONE Lj Full Baseme U Partial Basement Exterior Walls FRAME Walls PANEL T Det. Att. WS-Det./EndUnit Basement Area 0 sq. ft. Roof Surface COMP.SHINGLE Tmiffinish WOOD X Existin Pro sed UUnderConst, Basement Finish N/A % Gutters &Downspouts NONE Bath Floor TILE Design le COTTAGE OutsideE /Ext LJSumpPump WinclowType CASEMENT Bath Wainscot TILE Year Built 1927 StormSashlinsulated SHUTTERS car storage None Effective A(Yrs) 10-15 Screens YES X I Driveway # of Cars 4 Attic W None Heating FWAIWHW JURacliant Amenities I WoodStove s # Driveway Surface PEBBLE Drop Stair U Stairs Other I Fuel ELEC Fir ac s # 1 X Fence WOOD Gara a #of Cars 1 Floor Scuttle Colin Ce ral Air Conditionin Patio/Deck OPEN Porch Car # of Cars Finished Heated Individual Other Pool OPEN Other Att. X Det. I jBullt-in kpipliances P Ref' afar X Ra Oven X Dishwasher LXJDisposal LjMicrDwave P Washer/ er I 10ther(describe) Finished area above grade contains: 6 Rooms 3 Bedrooms 3 BaNs) 2,043 Square Feet of Gross Living Area Above Grade Additional Features THE IMPROVEMENTS BEING EVALUATED ARE THE SINGLE FAMILY HOME AND DETACHED GARAGE. THE STRUCTURES ARE OF WOOD FRAME CONSTRUCTION WITH VINYL SIDING AND A COMPOSITION SHINGLE ROOF. THE IMPROVEMENTS ARE IN GOOD CONDITION FOR THEIR AGE AND HAVE BEEN WELL MAINTAINED. PLANS ARE TO RENOVATE THE STRUCTURES IN THE NEAR FUTURE. Comments on the Improvements THE SUBJECT IMPROVEMENTS ARE IN GOOD CONDITION AND HAVE BEEN WELL MAINTAINED OVER THE YEARS LOWERING THE EFFECTIVE AGE. THE ROOF IS APPROXIMATELY SIX YEARS OLD, TWO OF THE BATHS HAVE BEEN RENOVATED IN THE PAST SIX YEARS, THE KITCHEN IS TWO YEARS OLD, A/C AND MECHANICAL SYSTEMS HAVE BEEN UPDATED OVER THE YEARS, ETC. V ery"vr�. -.pU� Gewa'l Purpose Appraisal Re��a OLIa10 GPAHIOM 1005262010 9m W,xs Residential Appraisal Report He No. 12-0842 FEATURE I SUBJECT COMPARABLE SALE No.1 COMPARABLE SALE NO.2 COMPARABLE SALE NO. 3 3524 OLEANDER WAY Address GULFSTREAM Proximity to Su 'ect Sale Price $ N/A Is Is S Sale Price/Gross Liv. Area $ 0.00 Sq, ft. S sq. ft, $ sq. ft. $ sq. ft Data Sources INSPECTION Verification Source(s) VALUE ADJUSTMENTS DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION .b)$ I DESCRIPTION l-)$ 1 DESCRIPTION ()s Sale or Financing Concessions Date of Sale/Time N/A Location GULFSTREAM Leasehold/Fee Soliple FEE SIMPLE Site 18,817 SF View RESIDENTIAL Design COTTAGE Quality of Construction GOOD • Actual Age 1930 Condition AVERAGE Above Grade Tma I Bd-1 Bann Taal Bdrms Baths m l norm aams Topa lBd.,F Baths Room Count 6 3 3 Gross Living Area 2,043 sq. ft. sq. ft. sq. ft. sq ft. • Basement & Finished NONE • Rooms Below Grade Functional Utility AVERAGE Heating/CoolingHeating/Cooling CENTRAL Energy Efficient Items NONE Garage/CarportGarage/Carport 1 CAR GARAGE Porch/Pado/Deck NONE Pod, etc. OPEN POOL Fireplace ONE Net Adjustment Taal $ $ + $ Adjusted Sale Price NetAdj % of Com arables Gross Ad. % Net Adj. % $ Gross % NetAdj. % $ Gross Ad. % $ Summary of Sales Comparison Approach THE SALES COMPARISON APPROACH IS NOT APPLICABLE FOR THIS ASSIGNMENT. COST APPROACH TO VALUE Site Value Comments THE SITE VALUE IS NOT DERIVED IN THE COST APPROACH, AS IT IS NOT APPLICABLE TO THIS ASSIGNMENT. THE ASSIGNMENT IS TO ESTIMATE THE VALUE OF THE IMPROVEMENTS TO THE SITE. . ESTIMATED LJ REPRODUCTION OR LXJ REPLACEMENT COST NEW OPINION OF SITE VALUE ................................ ..... _ $ N/A Source of cost data AppralserBASE - BLUEBOOK INTERNATIONAL Dwelling 2,043 Sq. Ft. 0 $ 257.00.... .. .. _ $ 525,051 Quality rating from cost service GOOD Effective date of cost data 7/12 NONE Sq. Ft. @ $ ......... $ 0 Comments on Cost Approach(gross living area calculations, depreciation, etc. PATIO POOL 28,600 SEE THE ATTACHED SKETCH SHOWING THE FLOOR PLAN AND GaragetCarpoft Garage/Ca226 Sq. FL @ $ 85.00.......... . _ $ 19,210 LIVING AREA CALCULATIONS FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY. Total Estimate of Cost -New ............ _ $ 572,861 Less 75 Physical Functional External Depreciation $95,500 = s 95,500) Depreciated Cost of Improvements ............................. .. = $ 477,361 "As -is" Value of Site Improvements ................ . ......... . _ $ 5,000 INDICATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH..(Improvements). _ $ 482,400 INCOME APPROACH TO VALUE Estimated Monthly Markel Rent $ N/A X Gross Rent Multiplier N/A = $ N/A Indicated Value by IncDmeApproach • Summary of Income Approach (including support for markarent and GRM) THE INCOME APPROACH IS NOT APPLICABLE IN THIS APPRAISAL ASSIGNMENT. Indicated Valueb : Sales Comparison Aoach$ Cost Approach ifdevelo ed S 482,400 IncomeApproach If develo ed $ COST DATA IS SUPPLIED BY APPRAISERBASE - BLUEBOOK INTERNATIONAL, AN ONLINE SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE AND IS CONSIDERED TO ACCURATELY REFLECT THE SUBJECT IMPROVEMENTS. This appraisal is made X "as is," LJ subject to completion per plans and specifications on the basis of a hypothetical condition that the improvements have been completed, ❑subject to the fallowing repairs or alterations on the basis of a hypothetical condition that the repairs or alterations have been completed ❑subject to the following: REPLACEMENT VALUE IS ESTIMATED AT $525,051 FOR THE HOUSE AND $19.210 FOR THE DETACHED GARAGE TOTALING $544,261, ROUNDED TO $545,000 Based on the scope ofwork, assumptions, limiting conditions and appraiser's certification, my (our) opinion of the defined value of the real property thatis the subjectofthis report is$ 545,000 as of JUNE 20, 2012 which is the effective date of this appraisal. par Produred —g Aa ft—e. 800 234 8727 xvi J. — THS ram Ow }502005.2010 ACI Dlmsan of ISO Claims Savkm, k[.. AN RigHS Rmarved. Page 2 d 4 (yPARTM) General Purpose Appraisal R1 10Reoat 05/200 GPA vr*�+RPait Aucamp, Dellenback & Whitney 05262011 0 Residential Appraisal Report File No. 1243842 Scope of Work, Assumptions and Limiting Conditions Scope of work is defined in the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice as " the type and extent of research and analyses in an assignment." In short, scope ofwork is simply what the appraiser did and did not do during the course of the assignment. It includes, but is not limitedto: the extent towhich the property isidentified and inspected, the type and extent of data researched, the type and extentofanalyses applied to arrive at opinions or conclusions. The scope of this appraisal and ensuing discussion in this report are specific to the needs of the client, other identified intended users and to the intended use of the report. This report was prepared for the sole and exclusive use of the client and other identified intended users for the identified intended use and its use by any other parties is prohibited. The appraiser is not responsible for unauthorized use of the report. The appraiser's certification appearing in this appraisal report is subject to the following conditions and to such other specific conditions as are set forth by the appraiser in the report. All extraordinary assumptions and hypothetical conditions are stated in the report and might have affected the assignment results. 1. The appraiser assumes no responsibility for matters of a legal nature affecting the property appraised or title thereto, nor does the appraiser render any opinion as to the title, which is assumed to be good and marketable. The property is appraised as though under responsible ownership. 2. Any sketch in this report may show approximate dimensions and is included only to assist the reader in visualizing the property. The appraiser has made no survey of the property. 3. The appraiser is not required to give testimony or appear in court because of having made the appraisal with reference to the property in question, unless arrangements have been previously made thereto. 4. Neither all, nor any part of the content of this report. copy or other media thereof (including conclusions as to the property value, the identity of the appraiser, professional designations, or the firm with which the appraiser is connected), shall be used for any purposes by anyone but the client and other intended users as identified in this report, nor shall it be conveyed by anyone to the public through] advertising, public relations, news, sales, or other media, wfthout the written consent of the appraiser. 5. The appraiser will not disclose the contents of this appraisal report unless required by applicable law or as specified in the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice. 6. Information, estimates, and opinions fur fished to the appraiser, and contained in the report, were obtained from sources considered reliable and believed to be true and correct. However, no responsibility for accuracy of such items furnished to the appraiser is assumed by the appraiser. 7. The appraiser assumes that there are no hidden or unapparent conditions of the property, subsoil, or structures, which woukf render it more or less valuable. The appraiser assumes no responsibility for such conditions, or for engineering or testing, which might be required to discover such factors. This appraisal is not an environmental assessment of the property and should not be considered as such. 8. The appraiser specializes in the valuation of real property and is not a home inspector, building contractor, structural engineer, or similar expert, unless otherwise noted. The appraiser did not conduct the intensive type of field observations of the kind intended to seek and discover property defects. The viewing of the property and any improvements is for purposes of developing an opinion of the defined value of the property, given the intended use of this assignment. Statements regarding condition are based on surface observations only. The appraiser claims no special expertise regarding issues including, but not limited to: foundation settlement, basement moisture problems, wood destroying (or other) insects, pest infestation, radon gas, lead based paint, moll or envkonmental issues. Unless otherwise indicated, mechanical systems were not activated or tested. This appraisal report should not be used to disclose the condition of the property as it relates to the presence/absence of defects. The client is invited and encouraged to employ qualified experts to inspect and address areas of concern. If negative conditions are discovered, the opinion of value may be affected. Unless otherwise noted, the appraiser assumes the components that constitute the subject property improvement(s) are fundamentally sound and in working order. Any viewing of the property by de appraiser was limited to read8y observable areas. Unless otherwise noted, attics and crawl space areas were not accessed. The appraiser did not move furniture, floor coverings or other items that may restrict the viewing of the property. 9. Appraisals involving hypothetical conditions related to completion of new construction, repairs or alteration are based on the assumption that such completion, alteration or repairs will be competently performed. 10. Unless the intended use of this appraisal specifically includes issues of property insurance coverage, this appraisal should not be used for such purposes. Reproduction or Replacement cost figures used in the cost approach are for valuation purposes only, given the intended use of the assignment. The Definition of Value used in this assignment is unlikely to be consistent with the definition of Insurable Value for property insurance coverage/use. 11. The ACI General Purpose Appraisal Report (GPAR—) is not intended for use in transactions that require a Fannie Mae 1004/Freddie Mac 70 form, also known as the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (U RAR). Additional Comments Related To Scope Of Work, Assumptions and Limiting Conditions Scope of Work: As part of this assignment, the appraiser has: 1. performed a complete visual Inspection of the interior and exterior areas of the subject property, 2. inspected the subject neighborhood, 3. researched, verified, and analyzed the data from reliable public and/or private sources, 4. reported the analysis, conclusions, and opinions in this appraisal report. ry RaA[d using Ac suit— 800134.8727 �Acifgb— This rmn Cap" o 201y.2010 ACI Oiuisan d ISO CWSm—Inc, All Rgfts R.—d. ■ ■ m Page 3 of 4 @PAR-) General Purpose Appraisal Repos 0512010 .4 a Residential Appraisal Report FCeNo 12-0842 Appraiser's Certification The appraiser(s) certifies that, to the best of the appraiser's knowledge and belief: 1. The statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct. 2. The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions and are the appraiser's personal, impartial, and unbiased professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions. 3. Unless otherwise stated, the appraiser has no present or prospective interest in the property that is the sultject of this report and has no personal interest with respect to the parties involved. 4. The appraiser has no bias with respect to the property that is the subject of this report or to the parties involved with this assignment. 5. The appraiser's engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or reporting predetermined results, 6. The appraiser's compensation for completing this assignment is not condngent upon the development or reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favors the cause of the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the intended use of this appraisal. 7. The appraisers analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice 8. Unless otherwise noted, the appraiser has made a personal inspection of the property that is the subject of this report. 9. Unless noted below, no one provided significant real property appraisal assistance to the appraiser signing this certification. Significant real property appraisal assistance provided by Additional Certifications: As of the effective dale of the appraisal, David Aucamp, SRP, has mel the continuing education requirements of the Appraisal Institute. Definition of Value: ❑Market Value ®Other Value: REPLACEMENTCOST Source of Definition: Appraisal Institute, The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal,_ Fourth Edition, Chicago, 2002, Page 147 The estimated cost to construct, at current prices as of the effective dale of the appraisal, a building with utility equivalent to the building being appraised using modern materials and current standards, design, and layout. ADDRESS OF THE PROPERTY APPRAISED: 3524 OLEANDER WAY GULFSTREAM, FL 33483-7422 EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE APPRAISAL: JUNE 20, 2012 APPRAISED VALUE OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY $ 545.000 APPRAISER SUPERVISORY APPRAISER Signature: Signature: Name: DAVID AP P, SRA Name: Stale Certificadon R Cert Res RD366 State Certificatlon 8 or License 8 or License k or Other (describe): State M: Stale: State: FL Expiration Date of Certification or License: Expiration Date of Certification or License: 11/30/2012 Date of Signature: Date of Signature and Report: JULY 3, 2012 Date of Property Viewing: Date of Property Viewing: JUNE 20, 2012 Degree of property viewing: Degree of property viewing: ❑ Interior and Exterior ❑ Exterior Only ❑ Did not personally view © Interior and Exterior ❑ Exterior Only ❑ Did not personally view R.&A ,g ACI aoft <e 800234 errr w.w.a<M,&— rnls k. C." o 2005.2010 ACI D'—d 150 Claim: S-.,, l- A ages R��m Page 4d 4 @PAR-) General Purpose AppraisaGPAR1 10l Renoir 051201 05252010 Aucamp, Dellenback &Whitney ADDENDUM Client: MR. THOMAS STANLEY File No.: 12-0842 Property Address: 3524 OLEANDER WAY Case No.: City: GULFSTREAM State: FL Zip: 33483-7422 Legal Description LOT 57, GULF STREAM PROPERTIES NO. 2, PB 18, P 42, TOGETHER WITH THAT PORTION OF THE SOUTH HALF OF THE RIGHT OF WAY OF PANDANUS ROAD LYING NORTH OF AND ADJACENT TO LOT 57, TOGETHER WITH ALL OF THE GRANTOR'S INTEREST, IF ANY, IN EASEMENTS OF ACCESS IN COMMON WITH SIMILARLY SITUATED TO THE ATLANTIC OCEAN AS CREATED AND GRANTED IN DEED BOOK 662, PAGE 396 AND DEED BOOK 884, PAGE 539. Neighborhood Boundaries THE SUBJECT NEIGHBORHOOD LIES NORTH OF GEORGE BUSH BLVD, SOUTH OF WOOLBRIGHT ROAD, EAST OF THE INTRACOASTAL WATERWAY AND WEST OF THE ATLANTIC OCEAN. Neighborhood Description THE SUBJECT IS LOCATED IN THE SMALL OCEAN FRONT TOWN OF GULFSTREAM, WHICH IS SITUATED JUST NORTH OF DELRAY BEACH. THE PROXIMITY TO THE OCEAN AND THE FACT THAT THERE IS NO COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE TOWN MAKE IT APPEALING. HOMES ALONG THE OCEAN ARE ALL REQUIRED TO BE IN A MEDITERRANEAN DESIGN, WHILE HOMES ON THE WEST SIDE OF HIGHWAY A1A ARE NOW REQUIRED TO BE BERMUDA STYLE. THERE IS A TOWN APPEARANCE BOARD THAT REGULATES WHAT CAN BE BUILT IN THE TOWN, KEEPING ITS CHARACTER UNIQUE. LOCAL SHOPPING AND SERVICES ARE ALL LOCATED WITHIN CONVENIENT DRIVING DISTANCE TO THE SOUTH IN DELRAY BEACH OR TO THE NORTH IN BOYNTON BEACH. Appraiser: Supervisory Appraiser: Name: DAVID A CAMP. SRA Name: Addendum Page 1 of 1 'JBJECT PROPERTY PHOTO ADDENDUM 1 � .RY •wig d 0 � �.._ ■ �; ,, .�. ■l Cl ! FRONTVIEW OF SUBJECT PROPERTY Appraised Date: June 20,2012 Appraised Value: $ sas,000 REAR VIEW OF SUBJECT PROPERTY STREETSCENE Uient: MR. THOMAS STANLEY \ File No.: 1� Properly Address: 3524 OLEANDER WAY Case No.: 4 o CITY: GULFSTREAM State: FL Zip: 33483-7422 F9 wi P,W.,d icing ACI mfiw- 800 234 6727 wnw..-b wm PHT12 1. SITE PLAN Client: MR. THOMAS STANLEY File No.: 12-0842 Property Address: 3524 OLEANDER WAY Case No.: CitY: GULFSTREAM State: FL ZiP: 33483-7422 t .vm �F3QNv3 30 - - a 3998 FAU BLVD, SUITE 300, BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33431 PH: 561-998-9326/ FAX: 561-241-4759 SURVEY MAP OF 8MMARY SONEY CZ "M2 -M * P, X 09t' k SWER dr OMU . 3998 FAU BLVD, SUITE 300, BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33431 PH: 561-998-9326/ FAX, 561-241-4759 e C FLOOD MAP C 'Ilefll:MR. THOMAS STANLEY File No.: 1z 0642 property Address: 3524 OLEANDER WAY Case No.: IIy: GULFSTREAM State: FL Zip: 33483-7422 :E in n v _T FloodMap Legend Flood Zones Areas mwndated try 504year flooding Areas outside of the 100 and 500 -year nocdp!ans Areas ekaMalsd by 100•yeaf flooding Afoot in r"ed by 100•yow flooding With voloCly hazard _ Ftoodway areas _ Floodnay Meas -h velocity hazard Areas of undetermined but possDla flood hazards Areas flat nWptd on Mry puhishad FIRM Flood Information Community: 125109 - GULF STREAM, TOWN OF Property is in a FEMA special flood hazard area. Property is Within 250 feet of a FEMA special flood hazard area. Map Number: 1251090001 D Map Date- 09/3011982 Panel- 0001 D FIPS: 12099 Zone: A5 Neiaier TfansawwWa Flood Hazard Ceillf"tion (TFHC) nor ACI make any representations or warranties to any party concerning the content, accuracy or completeness of this flood report. Including any warranty of merchantability or Mness for a particular purpom. Neither TF HC not ACI nor lha seller of this flood report shall have any Mablity 10 any third parry for any use or misuse of this flood report 3998 FAU BLVD, SUITE 300, BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33431 PH: 561-998-9326 /FAX: 561-241-4759 LOCATION MAP Client: MR. THOMAS STANLEY File No.: 12-0842 Property Address: 3524 OLEANDER WAY Case No.: CitY: GULFSTREAM State: FL ZiP: 33483-7422 L Dock Dr m CDCD - Ruthmary Ave N r Bay Dr m Cedar Dr ?3rd Ave Cardinal Dr Briny Breezes BW 0 Seaview Ave alaj Surf Rd a Be] Air Ut i Saint Andrews Club -0 Jaycee Park Gutfstrram Paris U m Little Club Rd N � S� a 3 o` I Circle u x v a c p . o ,l, n U o The Little Club Z ora a o Sea Rd > i � m Bzn,bootn a � n3 y 41 �almeRj c Oldander Way EDelray ach, FL 33483 A1A Chukker Rd B.rnyan Rd s? O o a°' Turner Rd a° a a a O ro p R a, c�7 Palm Way ti Roberts Rd Middle Rd Golfview Dr I Orchid L. h Indigo pt D Ln 3 c m c o 2. 0.4 rnie I ' 3998 FAU BLVD, SUITE 300, BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33431 PH: 561-998-9326/ FAX: 561-241-4759 Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM oftrc e l lfr'. n �., JUL 13 r r f r of C. Stt3',ra, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration, ARPB File #12-7 To be completed by all applicants. PART II, GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.I. Project/Owner Name: C c cr_ns" E.w�yfi.. 'V �.STy 4AHcRS` �L; I.A.2. Project Address: _ 4OU\ �. LA -3. Project Property Legal Description: -SE-� �� - I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # Of stories, etc.) 2�- GoNOr�Mta\J}1 �rz�� S+�A25„p Gohro.J T I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: -G�,-s Stas A*,% I.A.6. Check all that apply: I 9 Arch itectural/Site Plan Review 11Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) I.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: _ --C".� I Type of Foundation: B. Owner Information ! I.B.1. Owner Address: I.B.2. Owner Phone Number:.�j I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Numb r: (o) 56\ ,L 4Sop� cell_(5���3b6-SSSS FaxcS E -L-\650 1.C.4. Aoent Sinnat. pro V V umciai use only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date; App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? c III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? ® Yes ❑ No Explain. /1-1., 9. 9-:112 �u/�Z,�,� 11 S III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? t"Yes ❑ No Explain. �� Q%r) r____ .- `\ III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Qe-9-- zu& �� oT e o.a.-PeQL.co.z.oa z-t-r� 4a -z III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage b. Sanitary Sewer U c. Potable Water d. Irrigation Water f►ia.-� � tom[ �� Tl�lt� S e. Electricity f. Telephone )S,7 Gas Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) RA w CcaS�SZ2.e� �r�'J 11A2r.o.J � of v �T� SvOn.cw,�� � G ��.� Sz2,r�,►, o�s,e.� . PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does theyroject involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ® Yes ❑ No (if "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes © No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existin fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? g vacant lot or more than ❑Yes No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the P%ect require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes 9 No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes R"No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Strearn B. Projects requiring North Ocean, Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? ( I 7 \`S c Eft Tc� �T`� J FiQC� �cAz� a �Ac.WaC�� �� E.�i.Cs 1►-�� \ ��SA ��' L- . IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbanceiaddition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? YesNo . Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:. �� FEl1_ 7p �j yrL �a,J AeP v.c.a.-goJ �Ac.�tac�t, �,ai.�'zS lr-b' � ,s,sl� `--C•2, C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit W.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, f=orm ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 �� - ��ucc91IB E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1, Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? Oyes �No Code Section: _ IV -E-2. How is the use designed, located and welfare, and morals will be protected? proposed to be o Aerated so that the public health, safety, IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of be located? Q'yes Q' No other proper{ y in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. IV.E,4, How will the use be compatible with adjoining development is to be located? and the character of the District where ' It IV -E.5. /hat landscaping and screening are provided? W.E.G. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations over located? �yes �N� governing the District wherein it is to be Explain. F. Non-Residentlai Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 IV.F,1, If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and ho Units w they are to be maintained. JIF t`;.Q- L'.nr n IV -F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: --70 SA` mall Car Parking Spaces: F S4l��c.��.i Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA,32000 Page 5 I :S q C) Q � LAJ ! � ca C5 ► � 16- (o � �L cq oc,Q� v � Q- O a oz��o W WZ�� ® (n t �En LJ O LJ % W �u o R� W JQ�V� F�Wev 1 � W� v QQ�OU Z �Q ^ry CS U UQZQ e O � m � jQ � :S q C) Q � LAJ ! � ca C5 ► � 16- (o � �L cq oc,Q� v � Q- O a oz��o W WZ�� ® (n t �En LJ O LJ % W �u o R� W JQ�V� F�Wev STIPULATION This Stipulation is entered into between counsel for OK Seahorse, LLLP and the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida this [I of July, 2012. WHEREAS, OK Seahorse, LLLP ("the Owner") are owners of a 3.49 +/- acre parcel in Palm Beach County, Florida located at 4001 North Ocean Boulevard ("the Property"); and WHEREAS, on March 15, 2011, the Property was annexed from Palm Beach County ("County") into the Town of Gulf Stream ("Gulf Stream"); and WHEREAS, it is the Owner's position that it has vested entitlements from the County to develop seven units on the Property as of the time of annexation; and WHEREAS, counsel for Gulf Stream and Owner have been in discussions over several months in an effort to avoid litigation with respect to development of the West Parcel that would serve as a compromise; and WHEREAS, counsel, together with representatives of their respective clients, have met to discuss possible ways to amicably resolve the dispute concerning Owner's claim of vested development rights on the West Parcel and Gulf Stream's desire to implement new development regulations on the West Parcel; and WHEREAS, as a result of those meetings and discussions, Owner has prepared proposed revised plans for consideration by Gulf Stream that Owner states comply with either the County's land use regulations as of the date of annexation or the land use regulations planned for the West Parcel by Gulf Stream; NOW, THEREFORE undersigned counsel for the parties hereto stipulate as follows: 1. The above recitals are incorporated herein. 2. As a result of settlement discussions, Owner has prepared a set of revised plans for development of the West Parcel which seek to incorporate many of Gulf Stream's regulations planned for the West Parcel. These plans are attached as Exhibit "A." Owner agrees that the plans attached as Exhibit "A" will be submitted to the Town and considered by the Town Commission, at a duly noticed public hearing, for review, and if acceptable to the Town Commission, approval by the Town Commission in connection with a pre -suit settlement. 4. This matter will be presented to the Town Commission at the duly noticed August 10, 2012 public hearing, prior to which time there will be review by the Architectural Review and Planning Board at their July 19, 2012 meeting. Owner is submitting the attached plans and related documents to Gulf Stream in aid of compromise and settlement of a disputed claim and is doing so without waiving any of its rights, claims or defenses in the event that the Town Commission does not approve the attached plans after public hearing and a vote. Likewise, by considering and voting on the attached plans, the Town is not waiving any rights, claims or defenses to contest Owner's assertion of vested rights as to the West Parcel. In the event the Town Commission does not approve the attached plans, the preparation, submittal, consideration and vote on the attached plans, as well as the forbearance of Owner in not submitting an application for development under the County's land use regulations, may not be used adversely against either party in any subsequent proceedings. John C. Randolph, Esq. Attorney for the Town of Gulfstream Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. 505 South Flagle Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm BvZch, BloridaY401 IN /Z WPB ACTIVE 5117171.1 FA John W. Little, III Attorney for OK, Seahorse, LLLP Gunster, Yoakley and Stewart, P.A. 777 South Flager Drive, Suite 500E West Palm Beate 33401 By: 1wkrtw.z Date: "I ( V% / i l - Page 1 of 6 Rita Taylor From: ronped [ronped@bellsouth.net] Sent: Wednesday, August 08, 2012 3:56 PM To: Rita Taylor Cc: Brent G.; Glenn; Bunny; David Nuttall; Bob Donhauser; CandyGrover@me.com; PBCK@aol.com; Sandra Nuttall; Betsy Subject: Fw: 9 AM August 10 commision meeting / PDF copies of plans from town hall Ms. Taylor: On behalf of the Polo Ridge Home Owners Association (3960 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, FL) we respectfully request this letter be read during the August 10 Commission Meeting. First Point: While this plot is zoned for multi -family and the Gulf Stream rules permit five (5) residences, we respectfully urge the commission to be cognizant of reasonable space should be provided to protect Polo Ridge residence privacy. Hence, the Polo Ridge Home Owners respectfully propose this project be approved for four (4) residences. The proposed project only allows 16' of space between properties. The consequence of the five unit proposal will literally eliminate the privacy of our four northern residences. This will dramatically impact the privacy Polo Ridge residents deserve while bathing, sleeping and pool area entertainment and relaxation. The Polo Ridge Homeowner's Association formally opposes the site plan for the so-called West Side Villas on the basis that it consumes far too much space on a small lot and is too close to the northern property line of our Town House complex. Polo Ridge homeowners will be exposed to almost wall-to-wall viewing into private swimming pools, bedrooms, and other areas which deserve privacy. From our point of view, the West Side Villa proposal is flawed and inconsistent with the existing character of Gulf Stream. We specifically prefer additional space beyond the 16' to include landscaping between neighboring residences. This proposal will be easily achieved with two duplexes and four residential units versus the proposed five residences. We respectfully request the commission to carefully address this extremely serious request. Ron Pedersen President Polo Ridge Home Owners Association From: ronped <ronped@bellsouth.net> To: rwganger < rwganger@bellsouth. net> V7. A; I /n I -A, n Page 2 of 6 Cc: Glenn <gweber@weberassoc.com>; Brent G. <brentgrover@me.com>; Bunny <ahbii@crosslink.net>; Bob Donhauser <rfdonhauser@gmail.com>; David Nuttall <davidnuttall@sympatico.ca>; John Alper <john@apictures.ty> Sent: Tue, August 7, 2012 6:16:17 PM Subject: 9 AM August 10 commision meeting / PDF copies of plans from town hall Bob: We respect your position and appreciate your insightful comments below. When a plan is approved which includes four individual homes, everyone was supportive. Today, we are looking at a newly revised plan which is 16' from the northern Polo Ridge property line and the existing Polo Ridge occupants will be exposed to almost wall-to-wall viewing into private swimming pools, bedrooms and other areas which deserve privacy. From our view, this proposal is flawed and certainly is not consistant with the existing character within the Town of Gulf Stream. Please bring this to the attention of the planning commission. Respectfully, Ron Pedersen (on behalf of the Polo Ridge Home Owners Association) From: rwganger <rwganger@bellsouth.net> To: ronped <ronped@bellsouth.net> Sent: Tue, August 7, 2012 9:30:13 AM Subject: Re: 9 AM August 10 commision meeting / PDF copies of plans from town hall Ron, No one said this was going to be easy. Given the shape of the property (narrower on the north than south) I suspect that flipping the two buildings as currently designed is an impractical solution, but there is no reason not to suggest it. I was unable to decifer some of the handwritten notes on the pdf, but I understand that you feel the southern building is too close to your property line. Given my unique circumstance of being a reviewer, recommender, and possibly approver of this project, I hope that you and other affected neighbors understand that I must keep an open mind and deal only with the facts. The ARPB was most concerned with lot coverage, which in turn relates to setbacks, massing, open space and the like. The developer heard our concerns and hopefully will adjust his current plan accordingly, before presenting to the Commission. We'll know in three days. I remind you that the ARPB was presented with a Stipulation Agreement prior to reviewing the plans which state that the Owner believes that the site plan complies with "either the County's land use regulations as of the date of annexation or the land use regulations planned for the West Parcel by Gulf Stream". The former is undeniable, as the County would have allowed more mass and density. The latter can only be achieved through compromise, as there are elements of the proposed plan that are both outside and within the Multi Family zoning codes pertaining to the Annexed area. The developer believes (apparently) that minor physical differences can be mitigated by lush landscaping, privacy walls and the like. It is up to him to prove his case. It took almost two hours to hear and discuss the developer's presentation, and we had all the drawings and blueprints in front of us. The neighbors are at a clear disadvantage in trying to understand how their privacy, quality of life, and property value might be affected by this development. I think it is wonderful that you can be hooked into the Commission meeting via telephone, but it would be a lot better if we had camera capability in the Chambers. But that's another matter. :•E oioinn1� Page 3 of 6 From: ronped <ronped@bellsouth.net> To: Bob G. < rwganger@ bellsouth. net> Cc: Brent G. <brentgrover@me.com>; Glenn <gweber@weberassoc.com> Sent: Mon, August 6, 2012 11:03:26 PM Subject: 9 AM August 10 commision meeting / PDF copies of plans from town hall Bob: Check out these changes. Polo Ridge specifically requests the southern building be placed on the northern end of the Sea Horse property and the 16" space be extended to 24'. Ron Pedersen The meeting takes place at 9am EST on Friday the tenth. I'd be happy to call you and put you on speaker so you could participate via phone. Mrs. Taylor indicated that the current plans place the larger structure (of the two, with three of the five units) adjacent to us. The larger structure she said is the taller structure, and will be 35'8" tall (30'8" excluding roof.) Both these numbers exclude any dirt mound that will be underneath as it's by the ocean. They are requesting to place the structure at at least some point sixteen feet closer to the property line than the law would otherwise allow. The structures have 6% more roofed area than the zoning allows. The structures are "two stories" with the roof of course expect it to be a three story view blockage. In addition to the two car garage each unit will have, they will additionally be placing four outdoor parking spots, two of which will be readily visible from the street (almost on it). The five units the developer is building will have access to the pool facilities of the seahorse across the street. Father you asked if I think we should be alarmed, maybe. As there is little to nothing we can probably do about it maybe we could settle with their zoning variances in exchange for otherwise unpaid deeded access to their pool and beach facilities. (It's not like it would cost him anything and we're probably the only real potential impediment to his plans approval.) P.S. Mrs. Taylor (Gulfstream town hall) says that for deeded easements, like the Ballantine Easement (North side of seahorse complex?), Florida law doesn't allow for the public to use it. She also said that Polo Ridge has deeded access already to the Ballantine easement. On 4Aug, 2012, at 3:36 PM, Brent R. Grover wrote: Is That would be great. I have a phone meeting with Ron Pedersen and Glenn Weber late Monday afternoon. Let me know what you think about the plans, if we should be alarmed. Dad Brent R. Grover Adjunct Professor, Case Western Reserve University Weatherhead School of Management EVERGREENCONSULTING, LLC 29525 Chagrin Boulevard, Suite 214 Cleveland, OH 44122-4601 oroinnIn Page 4 of 6 T (216) 360-4600 x101 F (877) 827-1469 C (216) 973-0007 E brent@evergreen-consulting.com W www.everareen-consultng.com <Brent R. Grover.vcf> PLEASE NOTE: This email, including attachments, is the CONFIDENTIAL information and property of Evergreen Consulting, LLC ("Evergreen"). The information is intended for use solely by the addressee(s) or entity(s) named in the message. If you are not an intended recipient or you received this in error, any review, printing, copying, or distribution of any such information is prohibited. Please notify the sender immediately by return email, then remove this information completely from your system. Evergreen accepts no liability for the content of this email, or for the consequences of any actions taken on the basis of the information provided. Finally, although Evergreen takes reasonable precautions to ensure this email is virus -free, you/your system should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. Evergreen accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. Thank you for your cooperation. On Aug 4, 2012, at 8:23 AM, Robert Grover wrote: I'll attempt to get copies from the townhall Monday and take them to staples and scan them, then email to everyone I agree he is trying to pull another one across, this person has already violated laws and I wish we could make him tear it down and rebuild it to comply with town standards as opposed to being in spirit with them On 3Aug, 2012, at 8:39 PM, Brent R. Grover wrote: W Don't think it will block our view but it may infringe on our privacy. Could you go to village hall and look through the plans, maybe attend the meeting? How tall? How close to lot line? Parking? Brent Brent R. Grover Adjunct Professor, Case Western Reserve University Weatherhead School of Management EVERGREENCONSULTING, LLC 29525 Chagrin Boulevard, Suite 214 Cleveland, OH 44122-4601 T (216) 360-4600 x101 F (877) 827-1469 C (216) 973-0007 E brent@evergreen-consultina.com W www.everQreen-consulting.com <Brent R. Grover.vcf> PLEASE NOTE: This email, including attachments, is the CONFIDENTIAL information and property of Evergreen Consulting, LLC ("Evergreen"). The information is intended for use solely by the addressee(s) or entity(s) named in the message. If you are not an intended recipient or you received this in error, any review, printing, copying, or distribution of any such information is prohibited. Please notify the sender immediately by return email, then remove this information completely from your system. Evergreen accepts no liability for the content of this email, or for the consequences of any actions taken on the basis of the information provided. Finally, although Evergreen takes reasonable precautions to ensure this email is virus -free, you/your system should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. Evergreen accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. Thank you for your cooperation. On Aug 3, 2012, at 5:13 PM, Robert Grover wrote: n in in n 1 n Page 5 of 6 I think anything other than two single family homes is unacceptable. As I understand it he is already in breach of the codes across the way as his design is larger than it was supposed to be. It's time some endangered animal was found there! (Did Ron talk to you about this? I think this looks like a significant blow to the property value as it will almost certainly block all of what's left of the view. Do we have some type of airrights that we could defend here? Rob On 3Aug, 2012, at 5:03 PM, Brent R. Grover wrote: 0 I need your help with this. Let's discuss. Dad Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Gulf Stream Civic Association <cscal956@amail.com> Date: August 3, 2012 1:40:18 PM PDT To: brent@evergreen-consulting.com Subject: IMPORTANT August 10 Commission Meeting Reply -To: gscal956@gmail.com August 10 Town Commission Meeting 9am at Town Hall, 100 Sea Road Dear Gulf Stream Civic Association Member: Once again, important issues will be discussed/resolved during the historically quiet August Commission Meeting. We recognize that most of our residents cannot attend, but if anyone has strong feelings on a particular subject, they are encouraged to contact the Town prior to the meeting. Commission Appointments: In accordance with the Town Charter, the three remaining Commissioners will appoint replacements for the seats vacated by the late Mayor Bill Koch, and recently resigned Vice Mayor, Fritz Devitt. Mayor Joan Orthwein has written a letter to all residents asking for input on this process. Two candidates, Bob Ganger and Tom Stanley, remain available for the seats, and both have received broad community support. Unless advised otherwise by the Town Attorney/ Parliamentarian, new candidates who receive at least two votes will be sworn in and seated on the Dias. It is unclear whether or how the appointment of a new Vice Mayor will be handled at this meeting. As a reminder, these appointments are to serve out existing 010Inni n Page 6 of 6 Commission terms until March, 2014. Anyone wishing to run against interim -appointed Commissioners will have the opportunity to seek an election in March, 2013. Architectural Review & Planning Board Recommendations: Two site plans will be reviewed by the Commission, (1) a routine application asking for permits to renovate the historic home of Tom and Kirsten Stanley, and (2) an application for five residential units -- described as five 2 -story villas (a duplex and a triplex), to occupy the grounds of the former Sea Horse tennis courts. The latter application began its life several years ago, when the property was located in the Unincorporated County Pocket. After Annexation, the Town has worked with the developer to provide site plans more in keeping with the Gulf Stream Design Manual, and with relevant codes and ordinances. The ARPB was not unanimous in its recommendation to approve the site plan, and the Developer accepted the challenge of trying to conform with the letter and spirit of Town design codes. This is the last empty lot zoned for Multi Family use in Gulf Stream. As always the public is invited to attend the meeting and comment. Please contact the Civic Association, 274-6491, for more details. Forward email VSafe C tCOr1W' This email was sent to brentCd)evergreen-consulting.com by gsca19560gmail.com Undate Profile/Email Address I Instant removal with SafeUnsubscribe'" I Privacy Policy. Gulf Stream Civic Association 1 777 East Atlantic Avenue, Suite C2 I PMB 309 1 Delray Beach I FL 1 33483 0/0PInill SAIVOI-I 11,1 _lox SV IIIA MIS MAN La > w W LLIN LLJ o 0 ® .-4 3 0L �� e Lij , nr. • In EL Ln OLU p Q Z r------------- w 1 O Q i p Q Lu. •+ •'� Q. Z i LU O Q LL, ui O �Y w I Oa f- 5 O,U,., U U .` j r• . Y CL p w W Z e a v► al" p w Z O j N I mo. w d ~° Q {` -s W Z O li J a O U I p it.: Q} OW I W d ° �F- I ��■ 1 n p W O f c LU LU F�LLJ d U Z U CL: 1 W Q Z O W }Y L Ln LL O a zU OO \ LU EU �� V Q O CL Qi--------. Z ` ::)LU Y OW LL O i �a Op WZO i.. �. LU J OU , z0O W a p ZI 0 N d W -1W _ a: LU 0� O LU Z Lu W Z: > Q Q 0 � I a Q- U_ Z -� OLL O l U ogmg r o N d d a U U N U CL0Z0 OCZQZ wg LCLU LU _LU Q aZ)a W d Ww z0O O F- 0 N d W -1W _ N Q LL W Z3 LU Z Lu W Q Q J �r Q 0 H O Z O Q- U_ Z I ' Z U ogmg N d d a U U N U CL0Z0 OCZQZ wg LCLU LU _LU LLli ZEn :5 coL z cn CL En 1 I - S .a LSI o I -I 211.E 11 o x SVIIIA IQis JSaM WWSll31hONVWNWV SMOSC199 VAI Vf N ¢ a , • p L96££ -U Uaea X09 - 9 alM - MN *f^M PMOS U -10J9 0019 gNg NI W C%q Ln C V o 1 :3 � a � o o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- v'i i�Il VAI Vf N co p m C gNg NI W C%q Ln C V o 1 :3 � a � o r z gz Q bee << M Q s o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- v'i i�Il VAI Vf N N 0 C gNg NI tR Q 2 Ln C V 1 :3 „a < u S r z gz Q bee << M 969 s o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- v'i i�Il VAI Vf N N 0 N gNg NI z4�� � MU V 1 � H u ' r z gz Q ties << M 969 LP o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- v'i i�Il VAI Vf N N 0 N gNg NI z4�� MU a 1 Z c u ' r z go Q ties << � '1 u �I .I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,1 o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- v'i i�Il VAI Vf N N 0 N gNg NI z4�� N V 1 z as u >b r z 8o a s bag lbs P � '1 u �I .I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,1 o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- 0 1 z4�� z V 1 J 8 u Ys r z e-8 o � 1 9 � '1 u �I .I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,1 o 21 ■ ,r J R� II 23 I ■ 21 I MOMM, loIIm lid I 1 1 I I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,I 111 �I ,1 .1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I 'I I 1 �I �I �1 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I • ` II Sm 11 11 I ■ r�e _..._ ..'ill■ ILM 1 IN • ■ ■IIm Moil �lilj MEN y 1 -1- 0 1 z4�� 1 Eli a 0 J 11 r z o � 1 9 � '1 u �I .I ,1 ,1 ,1 ,1 I I I------- ----------- i ---------- Z IOS-8[P 19S :mi . IOSB-BLPI%.auo4�la1 6060E 11'gMa0 WIo,l ISOM.011 aIInS'auq Oigwnlo0 ooy uoi}o}iodsuoil I saoinJaS Ioluauauonnu3 aanpaj!LpjV adoospuo-I I 6uiuuold Hinos NOISIG aNV I ❑ LU Cn F N 2> w Q. J, < w t��1nl1��J411�oQLL QW 5= ¢SmdZ o.np< W -Ns wN mal Z JK n W Q rn 2 q d o 0 N Z K� U � N mW n.mc?�o 0 Wa,Z0Z Wo zo"o �a uwm VF 0 hZi m <F�Z O oZFI== a 1J10 �z viz N Z Cl > w M W m J Z .DWOMWOW 01,1 Y W W m SS a»mozo �o�a WOZOZ2Z QQIgQ �ZaZZQ2U2WI-I-ZI- Z5NSNNa000W00 Ou zoo zo°,, `d412lO1J 'Wb'3211S jlf1J �O NMOl Q-ag��o'ao - b3110�1 b0� a32PddTdd o a Z; w zb��EZ�iG z a 1S3M - '3AV NV3DO H1210N Y �o� -OF—' 3 4 W H Q w Ir OW 3 F QQW qW O U J w W w J~ aQ m W Q J F Q 0 KF.07 H mU II NNyD W II,U <0 n °. U o m3LL w r -;<i Kat V1 WnWUU Y 55 K m0 Q a U K Z 0 K 7 O D W 7 f0 W ZKZIII J'+-IZ-� 0 OJOUOC7�OUN W W WJ LL W F R Z <U< K KUW LIIO W ZOZW< Q UL II.m g a O m u< 4 U m n a u n 0- K J ir U 1 Q Q U O o m n - O. mm mo u U a 2 qO aZ La- -C�s. a I- U C9 Z Z O N LU ~ �pAq 10/ C j Z Z LU ® ®W a a� � � 2 lri vi O oco Z it ®. Q Q oe N d d –� i 1 • 00 >- w 1- Q F- Z w W Cd elf lri vi O W L I W V1 h N d d • in ❑ W U In U7 H 0 7 ZteIiH' m N Y V) U vi WOE ❑WU Q Nu U r-4 Q N u Q V W U) W U` ❑ W vi 0 � Q�Q l t� O � � En N O 1 Q% w 0 D Vl U Z a IIa 7w i0 O O II 'L ceu QQ m 1 1 Em d Li in � J �- U 1 m dN N Z Q O I Q w0 1 W o �� N n 0 00 >- w 1- Q F- Z I U Ou,Z) I �_ LL dui N Q � L I J_ Q � H W w m N Y V) U vi WOE ❑WU Q Nu U Li]En u Q V W U) Z IOS-9LV-I9S :-J . IOMSLV-19S :auWdalal 6OVEE 11'40°a9 Ua1°d IsaM. 011 eIpIS'-!J0 °pwnpZ) 006 C C , uollopodsuoil saowaSIo}uawualnu3 �r Y=9 4 S o ajn}oa}14ajy adoos' uol I buluuold g6!f& Z - E _ 6 I ` G1'dOl3 'W`d3211S Sino 30 NMO-L 2��uv 5 E Hinoss b3110)1 210 a32lb'd3�ld NOIS�Q 1.S3M - -3AV N`d3DO H-LNdON tm I Q Y= W J ��, V o W o XCINVI and:ted g o o¢ o a 0 z � U. U. g LU LU 26 S J mill E u o FAIL a 2I -1M uNfl3 r 600 =t; 5o ��UN 6�0 3t ag t9 �uL- Z. �u wmgWocF°� oyW�g Za RIM � o z==uaw$� �E73i°o��a7€z 2ot�u_ ESQ = s�gpo��Z��Z��a m n° n E FW Z10S-9LI-199:x°j. IOSB-BLY-19S:—oydqj 60/CC ll'4P009 +Mod 1*oM. Oil o11�5'aMKJ °!QwnWJ 00Y uoi}o}jodsuojl I saoimGS lo}ual.uu0JInu3 ajnjoajiyojy adoospuo� I 6UIUUDId �Hlnos NJIS9a C1 N VI V(INO13 'WV3211S mo JO NMOL 213110)I 2d OJ a32IWIdd 1S3M - '3AV NV3DO HIdON z w gz= ° j u io co cmw6nu =goo-� ,z � a� Lu c%j U. ° � s O Zu lff Io 02 10— AL 'o<Cm (� � w Z m Z �k g o RRRR� O d a$ �Rw9i;�c�ra°`uc6 �u �5 d"�aou p oM,-P,-i.v o of d' Ica w ` 12 <y�u z�m'�7uw2 °`�QM $g uE��3���Z�o��a7�zdm���gg�gg�LL i��iie�u zz ibu� W obig Rx0d.1p LL s z z 5� u I NEE mmm NUMUM • __ @IIII11111111 it W W 2 cV J Z IoS-oLY-19S :x❑i . IOMj V -19S :°UWdolol 60YCC 1J'4°°oo LLM❑d ISDM. 011 °IMS'°M:O ❑fC�unpD O0Y uoi}o}iodsuoil I SGOIAJGS Io}uaWuainu3 ain}oa}iyojy adoospuoluiuuold x `~ VGNOl3 `WV3'l1S jinn 3O NMOL i I n 1 O J Y '0110)I �o 4 b0� a3'dVd3bd N S� Q XH lo�oi- o S - '3AV N`d3DO H1210N CINVI 8 � 8 W z rtZ* •� $$<W Sz 3 - ~z x E 2 moo Ed°� aa� v-08 Hw<uL�° u LL �� xm <===a= ataaOa 0000. O UUU*4tu o` U a 8E mu ° _@ o_ FF^ rya P v p.� _ 0.52 E E ` �.v-� € Ev e c� >C �oE� a`�' o `w `w a UUU p&.- uu<UaaS -Ll aa� 2ZZS�� �2-Z� guaua0uz„„ Hg u6 E$' €€ €a<P 09 z z �U,ddpuUUULiLi OOO 0.000000 ry nnn!T-°O n Z.%Nry WWuuF tt U, U, u 0 uFjv° o 'u k a '” u` = o o -5-. � 6tixa6a =Ju C�OLLXO❑x uu( Zj ur zg� z Z P Z 000000000 U t.16 b n b„ b '. b H m Li Li Li Li Li Li. U. 0 000000 mom��mt°m 6 HLLHHHHHT �a o.o o o oo`oo #u--uu*uu C E 4 6 o 9 = 9G _ Zg It 5 Ev t `° go < o E aa B' C -`a` $ E o o L $ ` s a Eu` >>SS.< 6,00d��z O amImm—a x `~ vi Z z> F4 <5 0� �o 4 y S u �8g� Yxz 0� — 8 � 8 W z rtZ* •� $$<W Sz 3 - z z �U,ddpuUUULiLi OOO 0.000000 ry nnn!T-°O n Z.%Nry WWuuF tt U, U, u 0 uFjv° o 'u k a '” u` = o o -5-. � 6tixa6a =Ju C�OLLXO❑x uu( Zj ur zg� z Z P Z 000000000 U t.16 b n b„ b '. b H m Li Li Li Li Li Li. U. 0 000000 mom��mt°m 6 HLLHHHHHT �a o.o o o oo`oo #u--uu*uu C E 4 6 o 9 = 9G _ Zg It 5 Ev t `° go < o E aa B' C -`a` $ E o o L $ ` s a Eu` >>SS.< 6,00d��z O amImm—a vi z vi Z <5 FqG 9 § 5959 Z3 �8g� Yxz 0� — 03j �3 3� - o33'of P42 �z ;W � o � >I- W� y�j�z ria 'Q n W J W z`�'zo ¢� ,, { M -21 m � z a S S lwy- vi z vi Z <5 FqG 9 § 5959 Z3 0� 03j �3 3� - o33'of P42 �z ;W a Z 4 G �'z to s s aP DE W y �1oo x ; rt� 8 8 �W3 7 x�m� S= tSr SSE rta Srt. €rtLL �� y �rt� € 3;€� ��; 8 x°u xg°d olo SSW �x�o= 2 uz -� iig � �5° y o _wst, '�E o �r3 4� o R. j? x o s� =rte o � °�= b zZ 9 o 7u�� I Bug �° 2 E� 5 y� Y �e8 08 y8 3° 3isg e� 8� J gi Vz ° z $mss 9' a �< 8 �i x HHg aye �� � o SSG z109 -90-199:=J. 10SB'8 "9S:a a1 60KE 1A V--0 -4-d 11-M. 011-lPS'aMR] o"�Mo 00V uoi}o}jodsuoil I saoinIaS lo}uauau0Jinu3 ajn}oajiyojy adoospuol 16uiuuold !hMMHinos ;mN01S:1C1 o a N b1 12! a a M ev �d41�O13 ,wv32us j�no 30 NMOL i$uvw C73 Mgyo ! > C� Z < cv n.2F 2J31�0)1 2103 (1TdVd3dd a °�s •�•. g c tL LLI _j -1 1AA - '3nb' N`d3DO H1'*dON MUM. 0 ^ � � � W Ei N = J uFZM�j. ii C.0000@ms s _ �z �j 3 _ .i� L � EE>� � � � � � obi b $��$� i �b�e � � �a � 11�9� � �� ro� •; aill ��b � � �E E� bF• �b i � � � E b��16� � �• ��� �b�ljL �� r� Lro E�! i F,� ji =� �� ���,� i b�! Nfit#�s� gi 6yyr eII b�,� �� rpa �' � �� � ro $ � � L6E� -g� � � E�� � � E �`�����e�• ��.� � ��E � � b�! II � �■tf� � ��a ��� �� ��� ��� IIIILi ro L� n[!Ea N,Eoo L7 6 g B b ! L �Lb baII i1858ei II E E r YC �+ b b�g ���� �� 3t �� '8Q� �{i■�l� �II� b � �� � 3 �� ' �5 �� �� II� II� � � �� � g� t�,73� E�■C 8 � � � b�t e � � � i ���b6 F. E' EDi�= • � � �a� yE�i - �t,a �� �+� L �� y �b a 6� b bs � �B � �a3�� �Dyi �r� ��b ���i IRQ � r� ybDi $ ���6� �e� �E�� �� � •�� 111;,W] � ��3910� f,p �a �D �$� t ■�i ! E�' ��ddi�4 !a� gtPro � ��- �� ��E E b � � � � b�b �' r a��� fill �r II�it7ELDr ���Ero� p 5b E'�`i�b $8�� �E�FP� Q�i 9 b �` .k� � E�E �� i� j�� Eb� b ro�a �A � .k �g �• 1 b �ro Pg 6 � � i � Py� �� ���� i� �;�� �� ;i� a � aIL:! ■i ya a` r Aiyj ��p11$� a`11 ��� �� ass � a i 'jpj 71 3e� F�d� 67 �Z�� ,A N�dJ d� ddd ZZZtdddWLL 4 6 4 t d d W ,i t«< d d d W W d d d ova ue :noudoocaa ON M 33M ,� �; 3Naa NV300 FuaON LOOti �NOW � o .WOW W MOM 3WKDZ* p, 11V0.01V, �, �„ z O an w :a W a Ond".OI.W, aoov.0 a�®n vacu gsunmvwm l 3rw V3 aoro rc (sw) -[3t WK-WL (m) xve :HOA mi1vdMd V ') soca vanes arami l t33ws GKQ WN LVW w QQ �'•� SHOA3M21(1S • S213NNVld - SH33NION3 A3nanS AUVaNn09 ALa3d0ad 1S3M 0 O zvzA 'ONI 'SMVIOOSSV (INV NOSdWOHI- N3AV80 Aa: w Amuns d0 FI'Jpms cn C Qj1+ > (ZD zw #� o' U. fill .j HCV) i` 'lob -an `g Ltd s i b �@ • �� Z x a ril SIX � �@ 7 �i p �s 8still �@ � 141 `�a ,6a •.�1�� °• a� ir3fRb d t � l "i •v6 di •psi .4 .�� 24 1 ;# y ,I M _ ��i � ����� � � �G� a xh Who ji 1 9 IV fit IV W Vzus WW >a j o�c y4 v 3NYW "K►i ME Yo rr Ura 1-s] 6woWz-w wyoai sos\a'v\3mm W35— coo-,W\Woa\a 3M 335 #43ov4d 73LVG �a = . = .= 3Nd0 NV300 HIUON Mir 310N 3E :,�. �, o ,UGM o.. 3Mrd=MW 3FM M1 0:M V�W z and ;A. USO 1Q 11 O.. Sm" . oww". ,..YOO Mfl mL Smumve o O V3 :u Mayo OOK-arc Ow -m aro- cw.) an. •ao3 mavd3Nd V SO= VaaOU 3TVQW3GM laA3Ad na 'J3 m awg 'M'N EVW u �W •� 3TMx aiok3Aaf)S • SUEINNMd • SH33NIJN3AD nS �vvy aN, M rye lS 0 W avNc ULva r ONI 'S3IVIOOSSV (INV NOSdWOHl• N3AV'dO A3mns �0 HOms a O U) ®O > O i lu II y r��� k alit Wi i ®i `a .+. B® -0x lie 113.1 ;y s®• I I I 014,NVZe k, mv Gov -4 q --------- -----. __ _ — — _ . / i Cr) dmva .f-i+anc ari[RN ACW dYJvrb►'A9 6.i[ umm ASW v s roiaala�vnrr�e murr�_7- ' "g �'m,, mr�-� , -491111=11. -�-1033 6L61 ' ome ONOO AHO1S L I Loci � 3S!YJH Sdt91'i)3� � b 'V � 1 � I io armr 3 g b h 1 •Ifs• 3,DyLGb N 1 � 1 JJO71A9a1ap10D AMWIOr3J�7 — — _ —� 3KWW UM►7 CM 4'O Ir USM S -Sl a•oroba-ad 31VQd1 906\AW\W OH V3L--LLa4-00\aaas\a VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Paul Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Amanda Jones Ann Aker George Delafieled September 19, 2012 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 27, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 7-26-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. November 15, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. C. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. January 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC, as agent for Harbor View Estates, LLC owners of property located at 1224 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat II, Replat of Golf Course Addn. Its 4, 5 & N 92' of It 6, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics and some native trees providing for a 13' clear zone from edge of roadway. 2. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1220 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 4, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, a replat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 15, Pages 173 & 174, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial two-story Bermuda style single family dwelling, 3 car garage with bonus room above, 8,603 square feet, and a swimming pool. 3. An application submitted by Seaside Builders as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1230 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, AGENDA CONTINUED legally described as Lot 6, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, being a re -plat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BLVD. OVERLAY PRMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and installation of a 6'high aluminum rail fence 12' west of the east property line that will be screened with landscape material. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of an 8,857 square foot Colonial West Indies style partial two-story, single family dwelling, attached 2 car garage with 6' high walls and fences screened with landscape material around the property, and a swimming pool. 4. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1222 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 3 Hidden Harbor Estates Plat Two, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 15, Pages 173 and 174, Public Records of Palm Beach County. a. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest suite, a detached outdoor seating area, a total of 9,229 square feet, and a swimming pool. Reorganization A. Election of B. Election of Items by Staff. of ARPB. a Chairman a Vice Chairman Items by Board Members. Public. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, JULY 26, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M. IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. 8:30 II Call to Order. Chairman Ganger called the Meeting to order at A.M. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Robert W. Ganger Scott Morgan Tom Smith Malcolm Murphy Thomas M. Stanley Paul Lyons Amanda Jones William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John Randolph Roger Cope, Architect Cope Architects Benjamin Shrier, Arch Affinity Architects Jeff Brophy of Land Design South Robert Vale, Koller Jim Boyce, Kast Const Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting as Board Member Board Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent/Tom Stanley Agent/4001 N. Ocean W. Agent/4001 N. Ocean W. Rep. 4001 N. Ocean W. Rep. 4001 N. Ocean W. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 6-28-12. Vice -Chairman Morgan moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of June 28, 1012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. No meeting in August b. September 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. November to be determined e. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. Clerk Taylor said the Town Commission will not be changing their November Meeting Date and she suggested that the ARPB act today on scheduling their November Meeting. Mr. Smith suggested Thursday, November 15, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. There was no further discussion. All agreed. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 2 VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval Chairman Ganger asked for declarations of ex -parte communication concerning either of the applications being heard. Chairman Ganger stated that he was involved in discussions at the beginning of the development of 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. East, which was over a year ago, and he said it would not pertain to this matter. There were no other declarations of ex -parte communication. Tom Stanley, ARPB Alternate sitting in as Board Member, stated that he is the owner of the property located at 3524 Oleander Way, he recused himself from that portion of the hearing and left the room. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to: Roger Cope of Cope Architects, Agent for Stanley; Ben Shrier of Affinity Architects and Jeff Brophy of Land Design South, Agents for 4001 N. Ocean West; Bob Vale of Koller Homes; and, Serge Della Ville, Gulf Stream Resident. 1. An application submitted by Roger Cope, as Agent for the owners, Thomas & Kirsten Stanley, of property located at 3524 Oleander Way, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 57, Gulf Stream Properties No. 2 together with that portion of the South half of the right- of-way known as Pandanus Rd. lying North of adjacent Lot 57, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit air conditioning equipment to encroach approximately 2' into the South side setback. b. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove a portion of existing West wing and the existing one car garage. C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/ SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit demolition of a portion of the West wing and existing one car garage, the addition of a two car garage and expansion of the West wing, a total of 1,492 sq. ft. to the existing 1 -story, single family historic Polo Cottage, and to permit an encroachment of approximately 2' into the South side setback to accommodate air conditioning equipment. Roger Cope of Cope Architects introduced himself and stated that he is representing Mr. and Mrs. Stanley in the renovation of their home. He said it is a sprawling, very linear home with a swimming pool in the rear. Mr. Cope said they are proposing a modest renovation of the historic Polo Cottage which is just south of Gulf Stream School. Mr. Cope said Gulf Stream Rd. runs along the rear of the property where most of the proposed improvements will take place. He said the existing 1 - car garage will be expanded to a 2 -car garage, and the existing rear wing, which includes a bedroom, bathroom, a laundry facility and a breezeway, will be deconstructed to make it about 4' wider and slightly longer, and the breezeway will cut through from the new garage to the swimming pool. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked where the bulk of the additional square footage will be going. Mr. Cope said the garage is doubling in size, so the bulk of the additional square footage is the garage and the strip Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 3 that will be added to the West wing. Mr. Smith asked if they will be replacing the roof. Mr. Cope said the existing asphalt shingle roof is too low and will be coming down, but he said they will match the existing material. He said the windows in the new wing and garage will match the esthetic look of the existing single -hung aluminum windows, and the existing exterior color of the house, which is white, will not change. The breezeway will be open-air, but covered, and there will be French doors going into the kitchen area of the wing. Mr. Cope said they are asking approval to allow the A/C equipment to sit outside of the garage and encroach 2' into the south side setback; however, he said there will be no infringement on the neighbors. Members of the Board agreed that the proposed improvements will preserve and enhance the property. Chairman Ganger said this home may have once been used as living quarters for the polo groomsmen and it is one of the 10 oldest homes in Gulfstream. There were no further comments from the Board, Staff or the public. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of a special exception to permit air conditioning equipment to encroach approximately 2' into South side setback. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of a demolition permit to remove a portion of an existing West wing and the existing one -car garage. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed demolition of a portion of the West wing and existing one -car garage, the addition of a two -car garage and expansion of the West wing, a total of 1,492 SF to the existing 1 -story, single family historic Polo Cottage, and to permit an encroachment of approximately 2' into the South side setback to accommodate air conditioning equipment meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Stanley returned to the Dias. 2. An application submitted by James Boyce as agent for OK Seahorse, LLLP, owners of the property located at 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. on the West side of State Road A1A, legally described in metes and bounds. a. The construction of two buildings, one of Georgian anc one of Anglo Caribbean architectural style, containing a total of five 2 -story villas. Mr. Randolph said the Board has before them the signed Stipulation and the Memorandum from Mr. Thrasher. He explained that the applicant had vested rights under Palm Beach County and now, as a result of the annexation, the Town's Zoning Code applies. Mr. Randolph provided some history saying that the applicant submitted a preliminary plan months ago which was not acceptable. The Mayor and Town Staff met with the applicant, they negotiated with them for several months, and now they are back with a new proposal. He said they were entitled to seven units under Palm Beach County, but only five units under the Town's Code. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 4 Mr. Randolph said they compromised on design and density, the design and density have come a long way and they are now proposing five units. He said to avoid further dispute, this will be presented to the Commission as a compromise settlement, and he said the Board's action today is to review the application and make their recommendations to the Town Commission. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked where they compromised. Mr. Randolph said the compromise was the number of units per acre, the architectural design, and he said the setbacks were greater in the previous design. Chairman Ganger reminded the Board that the 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. project was opposed by the Community prior to the annexation and the developers worked with the Town and made compromises at that time. He said this design has come a long way from the original idea for developing the west side of A1A, which did not come close to compliance with Town Code. Benjamin Shrier of Affinity Architects introduced himself. He said the structure was divided into two masses to appear more like two single family homes, one of Georgian architecture and one Anglo Caribbean. Mr. Shrier said each structure is rectangular in configuration, they will have simple facade treatment, and they reduced the visibility of the garages from the street. He said the 2nd story mass was reduced to 700 of the 1st floor and the height restrictions have been met, with one structure at 30'8" and the other at 32', and he said there is a 2 -story eave height of 22'. Mr. Shrier displayed a drawing showing the height comparison to the neighboring structures which indicated that the two structures are shorter than adjacent structures. Other drawings showed the entire site with the Georgian structure to the north and the Anglo structure to the south, and proposed landscaping along the front of the property which faces A1A. Chairman Ganger said he would like to see a drawing showing what will be behind the structures. Mr. Shrier said the landscape drawings will show what the rear of the structures will look like. Mr. Smith asked if the mass of the structure will fit inside the smallest line of space. Mr. Shrier said the smallest line occurs along the 2 -story portions, and in order to avoid seeing five garage doors directly facing Ocean Blvd., two free standing, one-story garage structures were designed to place one at each end of the property. Mr. Smith asked if the entrances to the property will line up with the entrances to the property on the East side of A1A and Mr. Shrier confirmed that. Chairman Ganger asked if the West side residents will have access to the East side amenities. Mr. Vale stated that they will have beach access and access to the pool and fitness center. He also stated that FDOT permit requires that the entrances on both the East and West sides of A1A are in alignment. Jeff Brophy of Land Design South introduced himself, he displayed the proposed landscape graphic, streetscape and a rendering of the landscape you will see when driving by the property. He displayed a rendering of the interior landscape plan and the front facade of the structures, and he said the formal landscaping will be along A1A and in the front of the property. Plantings at the north and south corners of the property will be very heavy to provide adequate screening of the garages, a line of Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 5 Australian Pines and a 4 -foot Ficus hedge will be planted along ALA, with canopy and flowering trees at the north and south corners. Mr. Brophy said there will be accent palms and plants at all unit entrances, with shorter palms along the structures, Sea Grapes will be planted along the north and south elevations, and lush plantings and flowering trees will be located in the rear of the property, along with a 4 -foot retaining wall to provide screening and privacy. Each unit will have a private patio, a small sod area and a modest pool. Mr. Brophy said the private courtyards have individual gate systems and guest parking, the two accessory garages structures have separate gate systems and guest parking and there is another guest space in the open court. Each garage is a 2 -car garage, except for one interior garage which holds 2 cars and a golf cart. Mr. Brophy said the idea was to create the court, turn the garages in on the project, place the accessory garage structures at the north and south corners and turn them in as well. He displayed a simplified drawing of the setbacks for the units and the accessory garages saying that they met the 78' setback from the center line of ALA, and the 25' rear setback for each unit. Each end unit has a 20' setback from the property line. The accessory structures have a 60' setback to the center line and a 15' side setback to the north and south. Mr. Smith asked if there is living space above the inside garages and Mr. Shrier said there is no living space over the garages. Mr. Smith asked if the two accessory garage structures would have ordinarily been approved. Mr. Thrasher said, due to the size of the accessory garages, they are not minor accessory structures in single family terms, but if they were single family structures the 15' setback would be acceptable. He said the tradeoff is that the garages would not face the street and the architects said they could do that, but there would have to be a give and take on the setbacks. Chairman Ganger commented that Polo Ridge could not get equipment between the structures and the property line when painting their soffits, and he said they asked L'Hermitage if they could bring the equipment on their property. He asked if there would be similar issues with their side setbacks. Mr. Brophy said it is a normal side yard with 15' and 5' of buffer. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that the Developer has made substantial attempts to comply with Town Code, and he asked Mr. Thrasher if there were other inconsistencies besides the garage setbacks. Mr. Thrasher referred to the second sentence of his Memorandum which states that the proposal complies with either the County's land use regulations as of the date of annexation or the land use regulations planned for the West parcel by the Town. He said there were inconsistencies such as front setback of garages, maximum building lengths, maximum facade length without breaks, lot coverage, landscape buffer and percentage of glass on the west elevation. Mr. Smith asked if there were any comments from neighboring properties. Clerk Taylor said 50 notices went out to neighbors and only one neighbor responded, and she said he is present today. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 6 Chairman Ganger asked how many single family homes would Town Code have allowed and Mr. Thrasher said two would have been allowed. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Brophy what density would have been allowed by County Code and Mr. Brophy said seven units would have been allowed and they would have allowed more lot coverage than the Town. Mr. Thrasher said the Town's allowable height restriction 35' and they are proposing between 32' and 33', and he added that the layered and intensive landscape plan, which will include over 120 trees, is a result of discussions with the developers. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked how the design of the buildings would be affected if they brought the lot coverage back to the required 300. Mr. Shrier said they would lose significant portions of the units. Chairman Ganger asked about the size of the units. Mr. Shrier said they range in size from 3,521 SF to 3,912 SF, excluding covered patios and garages. Chairman Ganger asked about the exterior color. Mr. Boyce said it will blend with 4001 N. Ocean East, which is a creamy tan. In closing, Mr. Vale said the developers and architects worked closely with Mayor Koch, Mr. Randolph and Town Staff and they have complied in every possible way. He thanked everyone for their assistance and cooperation in allowing them to get to this point. Serge Delaville of 425 N. County, located just behind the subject property, said as long as the Town is going to do what is best for Gulf Stream, he is not against this project. However, he said neighboring residents were inconvenienced during the construction of 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. with noise and heavy dust. Mr. Delaville said it would have been helpful if residents were better informed during that project. He said a temporary fence was installed, but most of the noise came from the construction trailers during the night and early morning. Mr. Delaville said residents were hoping for a smaller project with a more charming look on the west side. He asked that neighboring residents be better informed of what to expect and when during the construction. In closing, Mr. Delaville wished everyone good luck with the project. Chairman Ganger said, during the construction of 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. East, Bellamar and Ballentrae were in constant contact with the Koller Group and they had Koller attend HOA meetings so that they were aware of everything that was going on. He requested that, as best as possible, construction schedules be made available to residents. Mr. Thrasher said the Town will do whatever they can to give proper notice. Mr. Delaville asked who owned the path to the beach. Tom Hill, Property Manager of Ballentrae, stated that it is their property and it is not a public right-of-way. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he was not aware of the lengthy conversations between Mayor Koch, Town Staff, Town Attorney and the developer of the property, and he said it strikes him that this comes to the ARPB as a late July submittal. He said the issue is whether the applicant received vested development rights when they purchased the property, and whether or not the vested development rights continue on through an annexed property like Gulf Stream. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he would think those rights would not apply to annexed property in a new town, Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 7 that is the Town did not change the Code, but the property was brought in by popular vote into the new Town and, therefore, should be covered by that Town's legitimate Code. He said the key to our land development Code is lot coverage and he views this as another congested property being placed within the Town. Vice -Chairman Morgan said it needs to comply with our Code in every way. He said the design is good, the landscaping is well done, but he said it is the mass that bothers him. Mr. Randolph said the annexation statute provides that, after a property is annexed, the regulations of the entity of which they were in prior to annexation travel with the land until the Town makes their decision otherwise in its Code. He said the applicant submitted their application prior to the final reading of the changes to the Code. Mr. Randolph said, with regard to lot coverage, some of the discrepancies already existed in our Code when they came in under annexation. Mr. Smith commented that neighbors will be impacted by this construction and finished project, and he said he would have preferred to have heard from more residents before making a decision. He referred to the Spence property where feedback from residents came in after the fact because everyone was gone for the summer. Mr. Smith asked the developer when he would like to start the project if this is approved within the next couple of months. Mr. Vale said they wanted to start the project while they had personnel on site and hoped the project would be complete by this time next year. He said this was not intentional timing, it just took a while to get to this point. Mr. Stanley said a 3 -unit building is not as appealing as a single family home and mass is somewhat questionable, but he said the height is good and there is adequate parking with the garages. Mr. Murphy commented that this is a unique situation and it seems there has been a lot of bending to accommodate. Chairman Ganger asked the developer if they could provide something in their presentation to the Commission that will offer a better understanding of what the project will look like. Mr. Vale said they will use today's feedback and will provide additional graphics. Mr. Stanley moved to recommend approval of the construction of two buildings, one of Georgian architecture and one of Anglo -Caribbean architecture, consisting of a total of five 2 -story units, at 4001 N. Ocean Boulevard West (West side of A1A). Mr. Randolph said that Mr. Thrasher wanted the stipulation to be approved, but he said all that was needed is the way the motion was stated. Mr. Stanley amended his motion as follows: Mr. Stanley moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of the proposed architectural design and site development plan after the stipulation agreement has been signed and recorded, in regard to the construction of two buildings, one of Georgian architectural style and one of Anglo -Caribbean architectural style, consisting of a total of five 2 -story units, at 4001 N. Ocean Boulevard West (West side of A1A). There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Stanley, AYE; Mr. Morgan, NO; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; Chairman Ganger, AYE. The motion passed by a vote of 4 - 1. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Town Commission - July 26, 2012 Page 8 Chairman Ganger asked the Developer to provide more information in their presentation to the Town Commission on August 10th to give them a better idea of what the finished product will look like. VII. Items by Staff. There were no items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Board Members. IX. Public. There were no items by the Public. X. Adjournment. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to adjourn. The Meeting was adjourned at 10:25 P.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-10 Address: 1230 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Seaside Builders, LLC Construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and the installation of a 6' high aluminum rail fence 12' west of the east property line that will be screened with landscape material. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family 8,857 Colonial West Indies style dwelling, attached 2 car garage, with 6' walls and fences, screened with landscape material around the property and a swimming pool. Gross Lot size: 36,402 SF Effective Lot Area: 36,402 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 8,857 SF Allowable: 9,880 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Height: 28'4" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Finished Floor: 12.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday was asked to provide a report on the architectural style. This report is attached. Note: Although Mr. Minor recommends approval, page 3 of his report suggests something different, "Architecture ... Although a half moon window is not common within the Colonial West Indies architecture, the architect and independent research has confirmed that half-moon windows are used within the style as special feature." Because it is not common and could be considered a special feature, the half moon windows should be replaced with other type windows as demonstrated on the single story portion of the proposed structure. Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File -#012-10 ARPB September 27, 2012; TC October 12, 2012 Page 3 any hedges to be maintained at a height of no less than 6', and further provided that a 6' temporary construction fence with screening material attached be installed inside the buffer area. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ► RECEIVED q AUG 15 2w t TpW ,.,. n of Gulfstream, FL, APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner N PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File ## )- 1-0 1-J(2' LA.2. Project Address: /\J si vo I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: 9 a- 04-h I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) 0 I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: _6181f-7 Architectural Style: _in�6�) � aA wes-- Im S 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section .E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: 1 9 . ao Type of Foundation:il�l.�C B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address:_+N Qr'hfj- V i 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number. 2-� 2 - � Fax: � - 44 ----�/ 1.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I . Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) o�-�� "T-15Cj cell7%� . �� U"N+ Fax aR 1.C.4. Agent Signature: A jyyjyY�f�_ Pre -App Date: App Date: — Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Legal Description LOT 6, HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES PLAT TWO BEING A REPLAT LOTS 4,5 AND 6, GOLF COURSE ADDITION, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 10, PAGE 75 (P.B.C.P.R.) AND TRACT A, HIDDEN HARBOR ESTATES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE 110 (P.B.C.P.R.) ALL BEING IN SECTION 9, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGE 43 EAST, TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA APRIL 2011. Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and comple question number for each response. te A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? �a 2 west III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning districtX-Y es ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan ?yYes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? (,L` A�t n 1.- \ a SII /- n C' _t .) _ I, .-, I I - III.A.5. a. b. e f. 9 h How are the following utilities to be provided to the orooerty? Stoi San Poti Irrig Elec Tele Gas Cab III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 9Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes ®'No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an exist �?Novacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes Y"No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the projet at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be-tffstnrtTeZl or added and to what extent? Q lum. t'�1t I I'LG Gno� 1,tSWI CX4ens.rz- IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the dLgIu4aawe/addition: CA -P I <zz n, 0 -,- r �-P d f 0 S" d'e- 0-C-0- IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? YesE) Explain: n-Qw %Auy Id -eAn t} PLS " Q ql IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? rxvi dk qoe IV.6.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least imnar-+ the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: a& Fvi reiyoto a-- Ao'S g n ee e,*v a -h s 4- v -a h i r rr�,eo - d n c-hv s-PQC-.-I \P-5 C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? /VJ A IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: '50 VI Q -2�Ci S ilY`ar (`C''1., (� PQ J c IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: 433 - )oyz e- IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: �� j�i1f 't7 ti feQu� , Yl ©� RA%e r e)cte.n 51,.o Vl c`4'i v� 1-�l�n-I-rin� IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? X12 �_ _ � r- , - _ n IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES LOT -6 1J � r o soft fern acadia white WALLS TRIM N 1P\ RECEIVED AUG 2 3 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL ailllllll='" �� LL��- LL F w 0 C/) U- C'1 Cy C/)0 �� F- ��'- LLLL Cf O LL z N C/) d- U) O U) C1 U) r r- ti 00 O C ��t N O �� O C6 F- WU) CY L~L C�� C�� L~L L~L U) U' Ci L~L C�� U, F-- LL L~L C�� U) F LL U) Z N o (n  U) U) L o cD U) 00 cn U' U) i (1 d ti coo L` co ti O m ti L ti coo ao o o`oo 00 O L~L L~L L~L U- LLL~L L~L L~L LL LL LLL O w d��U' C��'1 d ��U' ��U' o O O O O O O O O O V1 w w �� Q L~L L -L LLL LL LL LLLL. LL C1 Cl z LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL d 0 (14 N U) U Cj U' d d U' U' d d d �� N �� CV) O O O w U) U) 0 U) O U) U) U) U) U) U) U) O co O NM O 00 ti M N (D (D O O O O O O O M Ch O Ch O N d' VI- ~ ti O W Q CC Q J Z) LaLI Z O ? = (/) Z O O p Z U CV ��_ [C Oui 2i W F- W w Z N Z W O w W W Q m o A U) X w w LL O a Q 0-10- Q O D C) (7 ZQ w �� �� W �� 1�L W Q w Q w W �� Z 0 ��-' Z (D w C) UY 2 �� �� o O Q w W W W U U O z Lo Z ~ > W > Z F- Q < M N m Q Q o C) F- F-> > w O> O �Q X X Q�� Zo Z W U > O _ O w- W O n�� O o o Q X J w ��< J> F- J p O CD Q O w Ow 0 2 O (nom C7 U) w w J J LL- N J Q 2 w w N J Q z -i w �� Z O N < < O LL- LL �� Q F- U) w 0 O Z O F- (n O 0 Z Z X Q O F- F- p��> W O O Ci F- w O F- Q U a U W LL U N N Q W U (D 0 F- LL 0 F- F- �� Q U) Bill Thrasher From: Marty Minor <MMinor@udkstudios.com> Sent: Friday, September 28, 2012 2:16 PM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: 1230 North Ocean - Two -Story visual variation Attachments: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd 2story memo.doc Bill, A memo for your review and use. Thank you, Marty Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Urban Design Kilday Studios The Offices at City Place North 477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758 561-366-1100 MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM DATE: RE Marty R.A. Minor, AICP SEPTEMBER 28, 2012 urban design kilday Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics 1230 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD LOT 6 OF HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES (HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES PLAT TWO) ■ TWO-STORY VARIATION MEMORANDUM With the recent amendment to the Town's Zoning Code, Section 70-73(b) was adopted to help create visual interest in the two-story elevations for single family homes. This visual interest could be created through variations in the elevations. These variations could include: porches, arcades, balconies or additional second -story setbacks. This code section also allows for the Town Commission to waive this provision if: • The prescribed features are inconsistent with the home's architectural style • or, the desired visual variation is provided through other measures. With regards to the proposed Colonial West Indies home at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard, the desired visual variation is provided through changes in texture and color between the first and second stories. The second -floor exterior walls will be smooth stucco lap siding painted Benjamin Moore Soft Fern. The first story walls will be smooth stucco painted Benjamin Moore Acadia White. This variation of color and texture, in concert with the home's other architectural features, provides the desired visual variation for the home and its two-story elements. As such, I can recommend approval of the waiver referenced in Section 70-73(b) for the proposed home at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream -94-012\1 230 N. Ocean Blvd\1230 N. Ocean Blvd 2story memo.doc MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager :a ,I DATE: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP August 30, 2012 urban design kilday Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics 1230 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD LOT 6 OF HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES (HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES PLAT TWO) ■ REVIEW MEMORANDUM The following is an analysis of the proposed new house at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard. Request The applicant is seeking Level 3 Architectural Site Plan Approval for a 8,857 -square foot, Colonial West Indies home on 36,402 square feet (0.83 acres) on Lot 6 of Hidden Harbour Estates, Plat Two (a.k.a. Harbour View Estates). Background On November 10, 2011, the Town Commission approved the subdivision, site plan, demolition permit, land clearing and North Ocean Boulevard permits for the 6.03 -acre Harbour View Estates project. The subdivision created six, new, single family lots west of North Ocean Boulevard and north of Hidden Harbour Drive. In January of this year, demolition, land clearing and drainage permits were granted. Construction of the site has continued until then. Land Use & Zoning EXISTING USE, ZONING AND LAND USE DESIGNATIONS EXISTING USE ZONING FUTURE LAND USE Subiect Site RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Lot 6, Harbour View Estates North RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Private Roadway and Single Family Home (1304 N. Ocean Boulevard) East RS -Beachfront SF (Single Family) North Ocean Boulevard and Single Family Home (1275 N. Ocean Boulevard) H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream -94-012\1 230 N. Ocean Blvd\1230 N. Ocean Blvd review memo.doc nue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 Mr. William Thrasher 1230 N Ocean Blvd. Review August 30, 2012 Page 2 South RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Private Access Road to Consistent? Floor Area Ratio Harbour View Estates and 8,857 square feet of Yes Lot 5 (Vacant) square feet of lot house West RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Private Access Drive and Lot 1 (Vacant) Proiect Details The following is an analysis on how the proposed house addresses the Town's development standards. 1230 N. Ocean Boulevard Town Regulation Proposed Plan Consistent? Floor Area Ratio 0.33 for first 20,000 8,857 square feet of Yes square feet of lot house + 0.20 for portion of lot over 20,000 square feet = 9,880 square feet of house allowed Building Height 30 feet 29 feet, 1 inch Yes Maximum Stories 2 stories 2 stories Yes Lot Size 30,000 square feet 36,402 square feet Yes Lot Width 100 feet 114 feet Yes Maximum Second .70 of first floor 2,964 square feet Yes Floor Area area 5,721 square feet of first floor area = 4,004 square feet allowed on second floor Setbacks Front 78 feet from 114 feet from Yes centerline of North centerline of North Ocean Boulevard, Ocean Boulevard, 50 feet from lot line 86 feet, 11 inches from lot line Side Street 30 feet 30 feet and 35 feet Yes Rear 30 feet 59 feet, 11 inches Yes Parking 2 spaces in garage, 4 spaces Yes 2 spaces outside Mr. William Thrasher 1230 N- O-cean Blvd. Review August 30, 2012 Page 3 Access Access to the lot will be through a 30 -foot access easement, which runs from North Ocean Boulevard to the six lots within the Harbour View Estates subdivision. The home, which is proposed to be surrounded by a wall and fence, will be accessed through gated driveway into the lot. Landscaping should be incorporated with the fence and wall design. Elevations of the proposed vehicular gates and surrounding wall will need to be provided for the Architectural Review and Planning Board and Town Commission review. Architecture The proposed 8,857 square foot home features a Colonial West Indies architectural style, which is a preferred architectural style for the Town. The Town -preferred hip and gable roofs feature a flat gray blend concrete tile. The eave heights are consistent with preferred elements of the Town Code. The building walls will be a smooth stucco finish with the second floor exterior walls treated as simulated lap siding. The proposed building colors are: • First Floor: Benjamin Moore Acadia White #AC -41 • Second Floor: Benjamin Moore Soft Fern (2144-40) As preferred by the Town Code, muntins have been indicated for all windows in the proposed house. The windows are rectangular with the exception of the second -story, half-moon, windows on the north and south elevations of the home's great room. Although a half moon window is not common within the Colonial West Indies architecture, the architect and independent research has confirmed that half-moon windows are used within the style as a special feature. As such, the half-moon windows are compliant with the Town Code. Recommendation As described above, the proposed Colonial West Indies style home, as provided by Richard Jones Architecture, at 1230 North Ocean is consistent with the Town Code and Design Manual requirements. As such, the proposed house is recommended for approval. Page 1 of 1 Rita Tayror From: Bill Thrasher Sent: Monday, July 16, 2012 5:03 PM To: Rita Taylor Subject: FW: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc Attachments: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc Progress report on 1220/1230 NOB. I forwarded to the architect and Tom. From: Marty Minor [mailto:MMinor@udkstudios.com] Sent: Monday, July 16, 2012 4:53 PM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc Bill, Attached for your review and use is the sufficiency letter for the Epstein residence at 1230 N. Ocean Boulevard. These items should be provided so a full evaluation regarding its compliance with the Town code can be made. Thank you, marty 7/17/2012 MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP DATE: July 16, 2012 RE: 1230 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD ■ LEVEL 3 REVIEW SUFFICIENCY MEMORANDUM urban deign iI Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics Consistent with Section 66-145(c)(6) of the Town's Code of Ordinances, please accept this memorandum as the sufficiency determination for the proposed plans for a single- family home at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard. The following is a list of items, plans and information that are required prior to an evaluation of the Level 3 Architectural review: 1. Correct the FAR calculations on Site Plan, Sheet SP -1, Site Data table. The correct ratio is .033 FAR for the first 20,000 s.f. of lot size. 2. Provide lot dimensions on the site plan. 3. Provide calculations that confirm compliance with the 40% lot landscaped open space requirement. These calculations should include information regarding lot coverage, pervious/impervious areas, and landscaped open space area. 4. Provide dimensions of the proposed driveway, motor court and walkways on the revised site plan. 5. Provide dimensions regarding the length and width of the proposed building on the revised site plan. 6. Provide a landscape plan for the site. Particular care should be used in designing the buffer between the proposed house and the subdivision roadway to the south. Existing and proposed landscape should be identified. 7. On the Floor Plans, Sheet A-1, provide dimensions to the length and width of the building. 8. Please indicate building colors on the elevations, Sheet A-2. 9. Provide dimensions for windows, wall heights and other architectural features and treatments. 10. Please note that a higher percentage of window area than wall area on an elevation is prohibited in the Town Code (Section 70-101(d)(6)). Provide calculations indicating conformance with this Town standard. 11. The large "half moon" window on the second floor of the north and south elevations appear to be inconsistent with size and shape of the other proposed windows and the H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream_94-012\Epstein Residence\1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 Mr. William Thrasher July 16, 2012 1130 N. Ocean Blvd. Residence Review Page 2 architectural style. Consider replacing these windows with windows more consistent with the architectural style. 12. Provide an elevation of the entry door. 13. Provide a digital copy in the .DWG format. Once this information is provided, the application will be complete and an evaluation and recommendation can be made regarding this request. If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to contact me at any time. Richard Jones ARCHITECTURE AA26001617 1 IB26001056 10 S.E. FIRST AVE DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA 33444 15612749186 1 www.rjarchitecture.com Please see attached responses to comments for Hidden Harbour Estates Lot -6. 1. Correct the FAR calculations on Site Plan, Sheet SP -1, Site Data table. The correct ratio is .033 FAR for the first 20,000 s.f. of lot size. The FAR calculations have been provided determined on effective lot area and are shown on sheet SP -1. 2. Provide lot dimensions on the site plan. Lot dimensions have been provided on the site plan sheet SP -1. 3. Provide calculations that confirm compliance with the 40% lot landscaped open space requirement. These calculations should include information regarding lot coverage, pervious/impervious areas, and landscaped open space area. Full calculations have been provided on SP -1 4. Provide dimensions of the proposed driveway, motor court and walkways on the revised site plan. Dimensions have been provided on sheet SP -1. 5. Provide dimensions regarding the length and width of the proposed building on the revised site plan. Dimensions have been provided on sheet SP -1. Richard Jones ARCHITECTURE AA26001617 1 IB26001056 10 S.E. FIRST AVE DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA 33444 15612749186 1 www.rjarchitecture.com 6. Provide a landscape plan for the site. Particular care should be used in designing the buffer between the proposed house and the subdivision roadway to the south. Existing and proposed landscape should be identified. Refer to landscape plans prepared by Dave Bodker. 7. On the Floor Plans, Sheet A-1, provide dimensions to the length and width of the building. Dimensions have been provided on sheet a1 -a2. 8. Please indicate building colors on the elevations, Sheet A-2. Building colors have been listed on the elevation sheets and color chips have been provided. 9. Provide dimensions for windows, wall heights and other architectural features and treatments. dave bodker landscape architecture/planning inc. 601 n congress avenue, suite 105 a delray beach, florida 33445 561 .276.631 1- (fax) 561 .276.3869 August 28, 2012 Bill Thrasher Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Delray Beach, FL 33483 RE: Epstein Residence 1230 N. Ocean Blvd (Lot 6, Hidden Harbor Estates) RECEIVED ., AUG302012 TOwn Of Gulfstream, FL We have revised the hardscape and planting plans for this residence. The overall height of walls, columns and railings, including any lights and wall or column caps, will be 6'. Any chain link fence on the plan will be black vinyl coated and will be screened from off site view by hedge or vine plant material. 6812 8-28-12 let LL- o f8vEE VUMO'l3 `HOVaa nVx�laa o H w z<�= 1701nanNanvx1179nt9810 a— c sxaa llna salsvas W uL x= vGrHO-13 `kWHd.LS 31nJ .. w � l ■ ■ F an la Hvaoo H lzloH ofzl s G ° o V d ¢ o p x � 910rl- SUVISFI'dflOEMVH NF1UalH � a � o � 5 E O U. J 0 of� o ` o ° w W U rc1'• n n ..1. € 0 sI o yWU $ 2 O Z W O❑ p g N 6 O LL F cc cW R Q G a z c ❑<< 3 e z O W F p w Sp 2 N a Woo�oz=� LL a w w a Z aw w ❑s. .2g wg OO VJ (nix 9z mm w D W oaw Z o iO y q FmF O � 2 a g z mww H p wzr Az pm � io ❑ wa w 'u'S rc $ z y�y n ° �� •� o ¢6i ,7, ° F 3 of o0 o Q=wyos .< ° 9 w w yam �o z gm ] o W < m O 2 O Zrw gj a W0 O m S n� O0. HE G> O!j y ZZ o 6 ° Zl s �� w oppm z p mz i c50 0 6Ra10 3 o� iW 11g 9 rc zp g ¢0. "z p gZO 9 °LLm " <W u° rc J ZWWO °F wi ww W w ¢ LL �,'rn' H. p =i '�' LL'O O - '.0 or<n o f p¢, ZO IL 00 p g ° U WZ3 ~�y r. W�� ~° .w o r a ? UWz o * �� `�' d rc Y not 5 o Io eon F 0 ZO oIz d -MiZu1 -ZpW � > °rG 3 �� U �� �F °° oJoF°a�i-m o 8 ° iO$zYu HN m FN IQw wi § § k W�Oupp 0 f Wgw u ¢ qU- i,i p�F=ao<ui iz0°om9w9 O U0 z _ °° a<Z o wo r3o a ? Uau�sbn7oa4 1 �1zmo- c .04 5 rcU9zmQ�o zdw ii m i u w a �� Y S u SQw pm w wm 3Wo r w=rte ww Aja m ° ZZ q� w� ,°o o of w,ri y �° cparcf ao 5 Zoz xm 4a� ah -Z Qa m o ° < 2 zp Zmk 9 Z >Y� Z-. jp¢(((pJJJ . rcw �u <FF bVQU < �O aF0 Z`� Z� LL WO Z. Q�_ m Uw O7� UW n] p2 Ow~ W H z w Z =e_n YY S p W-. rc °w °° iwp F. YLL o4¢wpe oaym a wo,p < J o z�°. o Is. r��u z m °o � zaTu rp w � oj2< p Fm °ajy < si moo 3°moFo z� Z <rcr� Z .,w ¢� i< w w FOF¢ o' z Vow z i rz--- w 0 3� rizswF �m<W D �p OK W O p mUN WO Z O Fao < < °Q< Z Om p2W m pm j Up Z O mZ Z O H i Z W Upw o YF °w § �3 z rc a o Z. m oTii 'eimc°i °3z o'grc�' fp 7%wmz� �m �/� Zfs m w i¢'o aW ° ° =m p oz3w � o Z. m egw -�W " � �Op wF ° � Sy1rc wo V FLL¢m o o pw 'o Wi fm -.0 W., oW u z �yp ¢ S<ui °E~ w o'W www �o m�Op j>p iw olio F 30 4a�w rci moo i W r °m m�< m� z< -i - a I iouoF a 0.0 zci m'm-°m wu aooi�zd o° mm°m px< < aw F orc u�°� z� m i foo w �YLL >g ww qm <LL oz iw °apa ZOti Z OZ ] F> u m WALL '-0',- JU a� UrV W WOV Iw-¢Ua QQp ° 4NR p ipNW�OU OF pw2fw O �U pmY OW °6FU O O� N 2 m°Z OUp m iQ 2 nQ� X�-Q °� 5m �° mom¢ Om O m pUw NS W O wa ° J ax �W OZ KKK NOF o - 7m gw 3 o �W ¢� w izo °uo xi r6 3x mom °° LLW�o ° �ui mp i s o Wi < �f m s �z < � i -0 <i a oow o mz-LL p gm <¢ o o F owe m �, °d rc mpw oim oz LLoo ¢ 9 Jz p wifou� °mo� o oLL oo�a oW o o mY� s oar e�iw o0 ou 'd °W�' p U 1- 9 p0 �zo¢ Fa o o o p o O a�� �8a H 3 1 8 HI �"� wF w� p�� <� zm �a oz Zm Z. zw i� i '''� Z,,L im z i Yg<3 m < fwp �o poF iv rc� aY< ogo— °N z<x u� 3x� oz_ v uFao uw v v 3�a oo mos uwTo is z< cOM U. 3 J3°Uy< w ix-iLL oi3 i¢'u>w ,xi,< xz w '7m xiw¢ w w w �¢ GxG¢rc injO� S grc ° z0 �_F3 �p¢JZ ° � F-- FZF W 1-j HW F Ix -W F hOO Fx-j W w Ix-Ww Ei W -1 .0'. Fw f W JY�� fy 8"' Sam o1O $ �- n� 8o yg oY ��s'o No m rcm ,e0 x F rc- oz.0 a, p< U' a mea uB oo Tu um upm� o,n o` o `oa< o� c�m0 umia w Z V 2Z 7 a = m W N O �O mm < n uo = (fl UHVd''Zar LLY m U0 n w MOrn 1h— � Df- HmW W =W mN U <w D LL u �WiI zErw _ wZ:E< <wUV L5C� LU O< LL�� zamZ� 00 0 LL w 0 Q LL0w � Z J NU) m a Q LLI W Q W Utn�U~ w _ ao LL w t a w z U b O U) LLQ 0 Z_ Q M Np Y 11 Z F- C', ¢ U u W O U J 7 0 m<m W LL Er p� w � W w 0 J it N W W < z R OD E0 (D LL N N F- W O U O LLa' U) O C, Q1 Tk U) < {� = ■ Z N Z Ow W - W LO mw < W w W v; J w ui ❑�QZO O a 0 U w 2 z O , m U m ryj U fn 'P w <Wma O LL t= w o � W Z U� w O F z EL O W O M w z aZ O � 0 0 z z 7 H j w Ir C07 F U m zz > a w N a I --y LL- -a r.-Z L--al.-I O EI ZDT'**Z3 o £St££ VQRI013 `HOV3H AVN I3Q o a a S 0 1701# FIfIN9AV H117 aN 981s C> � r� o■■ p j2! 2s H SHFIGlIf1H 3QISV3S a e x m a x e! VQRIOI3 Y�[V3iILS3Ifl'J = o a Um^''O aa "�Z�` ko o© O a. QA !H NVflDO H L2ION 0£Z! a zF-- a ¢ o 3 9101- SHIVIS3?IflonvH N9QQU. [I r----------� a ru m Z ® N , p lu 7 r O � urOj G� r,ri d a Z 0 0 Q r----------� a ru m Z O m' p w p rO arai N O O � urOj � �aa vpj r,ri d 9 o 0 0 Q w X o m m LLQ F Q d N VOj W m N [ra`7 m aLa O m n O m 2 O v N r 6 N o m n n '� m m o m e Q o ❑r❑iri�oi m N O arai N O �i o W O w O Owl O r,ri d 9 o 0 0 w l<L<o LLQ F Q d a Z rd rL orzp aLa L<�aa O O ra o� O O d o m �, m W O N N O W f71 fll o m m oo �rX 19 Am m Ol W N T A 0-1 (Q y 2 q D ffi w n = 0 LL m w Z O 7 O W u1 K K y a w w w o W Q o j _ w Z rc w oO K nw p� O z o X�i o N g< 6 0 5<� WWW o? ow OLL y U r�90° Jg i o% ww 15 J� LL U �a m w LL z OK yg z ZO 3i rc m 5 0 RE K r OF r O aU ._. N Q W p r U FU LL' Q m FCJ r r W mr 3 U n 6 a Ag d c z O c° m m n � Q y W O _ po O mV O LL Z o m p Go A rr Wow w ¢ U F J m U U r K R Q i W O WO d LL o: 0 2 ze z O Q U a I o a j Z mQo pLLJ W LL' pZ0 W �,n0 �O=R'^WLL o �d33 0 �U� m X...y U2y aaTFO �aQ�OmU< O W K p (W7 a W U ZpZW VC74=m O r a K Y? LL Op OW �Qr�K -'�a°15Zm W CD l o<WZo OmC7 1 1 -O LL Qoom`�902 oomopo r WU on ma���mr°d Q. Ad6 vJ 3 W srat-..zor _ " = Q w £8V££ V(IMO'13 `HDV3E AVd-I3(l 1701 # E[nNHAV HIV HN 981 SHFIC111fis 3QISVHS 0 s a A 4 a a - = Wcca > N a z 1 VQRIO'I3 UvaulS 3 -Ing^- QA1fl NV330 H L2ION 0£Z 1uj ■ ■ m § a ` o 5 ¢ ° z ° W cj O O U o 9101- S3.LVIS9 ZIfIOgHVH N3G C%j o o a w 00 Q. Ad6 vJ 3 W a x z W o u � N 3 U 00 O a< A o�uuuv 3 < < u a O• X � X ryo- W o 000 K¢K aaa ¢rcrc u E E u u aaa 333 000 3 A[ 0 I--44 U = �� o r << W O a« Z. p F�XF--f-�F 7 Z Z 3 2 E 2� 3 3 U U Z S U Z 3 S 2 a F Z Q = D Qxxxxx .I `vI e I U _ e X O < 2 F Z OJ Q O I OE z Y Y r Q O I I I Y zs r Y zs eel o o �-i4 <1 z:-,> PEE .z 11-4 s PET o r-- Q�H z-,> ]-["**a 401# Hf1NHAd H.Lh EIN S8I ry ® -� w �R F3®�Co S'd3ulIIlfl aGISVFIS m LU ' x a e < v■■�r� a. VQRIO"Id `Y�IvamlS A ICIrJ QA IBNVE1JOHLAONO£Zl = a s on v a 42 p 0 = ¢ o a 3 9 lO'l- S9IVIS1 W1O"VH N3UGIH < 0 ° (n!� o o n � � WLU °a 7. COW O 6 M; AC C% Qd RLVLS v ,` 9°`o Yp on� ° + Q Qi E0"I m r _ 0 W+, yl �` 0 n g n� O O o� o o a� a o U P 0 '" t o I �L co i P p JI U �L� N A A 3fr9 E ��0cv a lxvd vg—ty r. I W W cn zi I 3 I I I a I � I 0 W rn z oWc I I 7 v 3y I o a � I N I UU >�- - - - i 2 >W ' Into N I � 1 I ® I i CJ J I 3 � I' I O I N I I � I - F _ -1 I I I II m I I I I I_ I I I s II a / I I I W —— I f oIP� a6PWwQ 1 I I I 'U VI^ CV 13 O ul S a � Q t r ° a'e'aI'o aaol a..ifi� `• �'jii �g s i4 a S Fid S, e'°SSSSSSsa a E1 E3 3 lya It ps d rt?5�1 i PiEE aFl 3 B E11 3-1 1 S�i7 E F lilt l?" diSiab aJS Pa S111 jib gg S. Eta ff !C Sa E a 3 3 P 1 °@fit a='Fi a§! t; E 339 IT ! § g;` ;�'ff•ff 776"; M 1;1jr ! a@ 1 a : 193 i sE3 Ee stiff; $ ,gEj !fit Js gsi Ey ��$ a E'�fm }� � 3'! a�• i tai a I it Hd* ffi9;Ea 3EFsl 114 # i �i da" -t -` 3 4-6till ?3 a 112 #its F a d d U ;��'�; siti t fill. 1piS ltsg is Il; S?�i3 dl a[? ;SSE g�: �gi! Nil IM It 11 M ! ` _ a is � gill! ?���� E h1� alt Pal; EE _�,P 8�4y� da;r;i lg 1 ,sr a si; IN a y; ' EaFa ;lam all plqy# s f3pil Em 5-"'$' ;:� �ag?a tiff tIii i $ '�3;FaE ! t$4ta4 131 ! y3i ?a 3F =t} 3 1' F 1ax-R.�_l s 1:p1 H'i ?-E64 :?gypp F3 AlEES �?3 F3E` g?i �'E i a 3 ]liltll -#. t dP 5 Wit Ill � �� E;56a��E�i3�E+g➢ �aff c a gjlii ;g9 ; g� si���zBe=ja;•��F a;�#it 4 t_z- !3 1�c3:�ff?i'i$Pt� fie,€a1 %ES1i ; _� ' 1�t 9�g1F a?3a is EL SF11 Yl�a�BEp;gf a 3 S a i 3 ¢� E� iF 5E 41$12, ;+��-Faat�jma33 8 S!2 F!i §�1Ei51 �a3 pP tat?af+g Eigi ff . S $s3 :P i s E JON ti, g$:y fit fid= °es=;y a 1 i� 7ay#$ t ft3� 9,SS 2 ; E '� -37 ; ail-iE a 1 O bal iF �F ! it d 1 i E n 1al' a4F •F #li #Y8 tE y;� df�li8�14 E Et On aa7a 3 a it 72E 3 Eo6�n I :i• It!'? SE a 112Pz Iq?jjE=$ Fo•i!I°E' isl E9911a a hill j3 3 3SE' 41" tI d.6t F �.?:1 a p;� ioi?1 t�l� §gSSgatii#s3 F y8: F 33?b JFEF 11iEB 7t t.7 F ?_ 1g =§3s t-siaa§Ease&a3a:Z € ?-'�?i FU!' F O d a U 0) 0) " N° Y '19 p 41 C 9° c ~�9 O Q j u 0 a O `° i9!k L +y C U mTrjbi p p'" m U u o iJ. W N RQ 0 07°o I., u 9142 �rAa u3 jCo 3p of WRift �flt R'- E Ell $ I VIM Ap Ili 11M ig -6 fill }4a o �t3.5 sa 5� X8 1 9 $ �$ !$ l SUP ° d : ° e d e to E a� ����° 1 4 i� 9y 4 a z 1,) 9 15 Fc all 9 I tit s j_?- !� 3 ► z 3� �F p 2ylj siF i a=�n�E EE ;'3; 16 7����6�9#t� �7�3 �,!�� till �i tait10'1��?1111�51�'_;;, s3 ; i 8p�.= jea��i9S i P; ai'ff 9EE;# ;?3ai +�y; of it,=aEiE• d� ;�i�'E-� � �•�; `�a FE-°� bia y ?IEE., a _ •E�3; aji"Y �`,; fflu d U d etch it itaIN-1 —1; Ills!;i1• a9E9Ejt s'tE3 !a ¢ flfl 5gt.3 i$E'a :$ rE $ 3 a 9-1: E yl� $ Y53• P5E ;:: $; It dP ll � S�aF ;p d at7 ;SRS; 3'?s jl� e' . E`� 5 ;1§5i$ r i3#a •j c3 � 1g+3�g ,!§ �,E a jE tj; fl 3i,2jn3 ��il4a F•rij E7P1 m7a • flIL Ffi4ji 1 ���1 sslilE,ri;pEs Fbt lF t 2i8i Y#;4 a . i�a ;gig?3E;pS& S-3 3 sFai g5 � � ; � E F' ?i ;Ef E3g;%.�a ; ;2@3g.�fe�� Ski tall a I E is Is lgFa� E?� i Pati 4 Is E1 j4F6 Im1i t2. °t N1131 _ °�$ � 1 5 �,;g2 1-1;;41 g e ? , 1 �? is F k' Fp !11 .ar gg ? & Efi S 1.��4 i77E. 'fid yl' F - E`1 E` F ?IMI : UrIz?$F trig Fa ji d w i d a � 1 Fa;l6 rl 7F;i ?? ss F f E a till phi .;E i_Etj•3- 1;mayy t 4E EaS a H??i:s § lE1§ I;ES+ Y �E7 6 � ts• � 1 3� ;�d F7'� jiiilli M1 gl1gy; �E '�3 p$¢pp f�, t y 9��&rg�c��a �3 r �lils=3t I FsF?2c J D W . O'N d d U •a as F ? 3_ z a wE€! t ,Sa 13 sy s 1 ; - 4� I� 1 J' 3� &N, y I Il' F�S� lit? i` � sla $i- €� a#3Lad 3E.a tt33 ;E3 d ?•4 zt 1:?111;lE g dE7 t-; F tic bPt g �� ;fid¢•' ! ! a? P P$ S� " S' 'S e E $'y # - islg : E E"--' E aE Bia @8 t!! 4' a a .E y•aas^ 3t5 Q l a? ;d?3 §S aFs.Sy+ ?tie°• fi �Y IFS a$ t E:7 g3 E$ s Y n z y s'.E 6yaa9s g Fg 25:n Stg �2a sESE� Ett E Eg 4 S -w: s IN -11h a=;#?E d` gi d EI�• r tE.F �a �' rt .a as3; s. 31 kT. -! $ f = E ? i : : € tic, ;dl`a j ?? it $ i i tF la; EAIgt Y §m a=$ a ag.; F .b ala �_ E 3 ?Fta?y % y8e a a a'F. Y ? 1 1F _ 'Et _ .IaE F a&°e Sa F p .°5 L a g PpE_3= j= p! iia a'2 3 E n ;;ol!rESE # ?€E a Y s'�L8EE8 $;Fa§�F 3p tH i•: s 4 Es{{it 80 {�{iE> =EE3E , 5;n8 s s a sac# y k3 - t3S=E p lE§ "9F2. §o, E$ ;� R2 U11 = ;;$; S E Yy1D'_) aE;�l4'1 F �i a 8S E6R3at�sy g 5$3S? ;i it •? a Eiy �E3e y a #3 Fol gol Ea ?"� E 8 43 :g8 a58�E; FeF i�� S�FF iFS aiF - r i iay 7 '? rt ? tt•� "Ti Tim t .� d 1s76=„ _�`;u t -1 p$ D4 $E_ 3 Rini 7. P :air ; 6 z31?'!€l a3= ii. �a _3 i3 t t a��1i t F ua8 y" ; s Fi e_?i_- aoa$•75 ?�i= = °➢.5 ER '4 6 3� Ei r• F ff PEy E&§?S 9 s m. a3cs3t y ?aF$ $ °� 5: § ?;� g E ! S•= a 4 " ? a F - ?; u § 3 r gel �i 1� � a s 1 ' F1a1==�F $p = y; F aF.E=E� 4 E y e !FI $$� n .li d_ E d7§�aPE F :§33 # F3 c Y73 ��;y31§$F _5's IN U d d !j ff S n FgFa ! ;E !6 Fay' 3 E 5 F ; :.:::: t6i F= s€ 33:= i i ip S s y!a a t. y Z Ea E3'• l ? �'o'ouauna v.. Ea @® 3_13 i ,s Ea.e �'S 1. J. ?E ti? E' $: � Wi aEo i # I�,..aF_§ 7° S �3 0 4 S E SaE•i� r•d ` $ff:: !i as a 3zF ?t yi Ea ESQ E 'iia 23§ i ; a "$'ir ° a�aasaasaas, p F p E, a3�&.= as =. iE3 s, ?t ?fl• a".:.;.::4�3 i �� 3$7�. ;833? $ 5�F E 5a 'zEa a c 7 sg7§ a 3 . ; ay$?$! E Fki_-E 3 a a sat• pr i I — $ a�'•"� ;- �t4-5 1�' •ppE-g a ? : a?'!i�?=3s a' a i E' E 7a?5fi E13k 9 a8'S F' '• ,1; It-; �i �ES E'E E. x e ' # s §� �. ?s°4i {i F.E 43- y E E s sa ;. a �Y d d 4 3 11ff ?s'i E? 3 by' E-61 = 1g ia, Sa# 3 1 E $a -z,e z`Ea ?= E E Et n y :l ; y 3F ;iya:: g.is$P � s��a�a�• 33E 5F ; 1a333a '" •; �a? � !ee fi t i Si F'In l EO a; d ?E m=3# i ,?;•E; F,.� 3?a E a s ' t 3 a2 E E -'7 ° E•EE�° 6 g - ;�sa t a3 i y t 4i a? i t 9 t P i_ •Y 5 t "d �° a aS l#-. 'Hi Ea Ili;!.!] Aax_ ES= a - Y - z i=s # Y s �- i m E i�EF s4. =3 ; i §§_ ; g yFe "; :j a=5 E: F•3 t 7'a ;; 3 E 38 3 9 �3 3'3aF9 ?i _;D '.' a3= $l $ •s $ iEE E S.g t Eas Eff� �7 �• a� �" ink F'€ �yr� ffF�•a a `1 �? �' �y:ES$�F§ �• g F�3 �� F� E��1P' ' $;i ?lst�•1 a ;s�sy � a �4P- d a,•e^§ g� 1E 78.3 E�5;b�5 ti ff $i F ;� n t i.l! ;$P i ;," •••n+ i ii 2i Ean l=E �o� l 9: � n _ D a W Cj ^ � O O •{•d p 0. Z� O CV °� Qf O u J; SO N o� (0 W F- 1 Q r A\ W Q m LU LLj Cn ® �o 3 a it 72E 3 Eo6�n I :i• It!'? SE a 112Pz Iq?jjE=$ Fo•i!I°E' isl E9911a a hill j3 3 3SE' 41" tI d.6t F �.?:1 a p;� ioi?1 t�l� §gSSgatii#s3 F y8: F 33?b JFEF 11iEB 7t t.7 F ?_ 1g =§3s t-siaa§Ease&a3a:Z € ?-'�?i FU!' F O d a U 0) 0) " N° Y '19 p 41 C 9° c ~�9 O Q j u 0 a O `° i9!k L +y C U mTrjbi p p'" m U u o iJ. W N RQ 0 07°o I., u 9142 �rAa u3 jCo 3p of WRift �flt R'- E Ell $ I VIM Ap Ili 11M ig -6 fill }4a o �t3.5 sa 5� X8 1 9 $ �$ !$ l SUP ° d : ° e d e to E a� ����° 1 4 i� 9y 4 a z 1,) 9 15 Fc all 9 I tit s j_?- !� 3 ► z 3� �F p 2ylj siF i a=�n�E EE ;'3; 16 7����6�9#t� �7�3 �,!�� till �i tait10'1��?1111�51�'_;;, s3 ; i 8p�.= jea��i9S i P; ai'ff 9EE;# ;?3ai +�y; of it,=aEiE• d� ;�i�'E-� � �•�; `�a FE-°� bia y ?IEE., a _ •E�3; aji"Y �`,; fflu d U d etch it itaIN-1 —1; Ills!;i1• a9E9Ejt s'tE3 !a ¢ flfl 5gt.3 i$E'a :$ rE $ 3 a 9-1: E yl� $ Y53• P5E ;:: $; It dP ll � S�aF ;p d at7 ;SRS; 3'?s jl� e' . E`� 5 ;1§5i$ r i3#a •j c3 � 1g+3�g ,!§ �,E a jE tj; fl 3i,2jn3 ��il4a F•rij E7P1 m7a • flIL Ffi4ji 1 ���1 sslilE,ri;pEs Fbt lF t 2i8i Y#;4 a . i�a ;gig?3E;pS& S-3 3 sFai g5 � � ; � E F' ?i ;Ef E3g;%.�a ; ;2@3g.�fe�� Ski tall a I E is Is lgFa� E?� i Pati 4 Is E1 j4F6 Im1i t2. °t N1131 _ °�$ � 1 5 �,;g2 1-1;;41 g e ? , 1 �? is F k' Fp !11 .ar gg ? & Efi S 1.��4 i77E. 'fid yl' F - E`1 E` F ?IMI : UrIz?$F trig Fa ji d w i d a � 1 Fa;l6 rl 7F;i ?? ss F f E a till phi .;E i_Etj•3- 1;mayy t 4E EaS a H??i:s § lE1§ I;ES+ Y �E7 6 � ts• � 1 3� ;�d F7'� jiiilli M1 gl1gy; �E '�3 p$¢pp f�, t y 9��&rg�c��a �3 r �lils=3t I FsF?2c J D W . O'N d d U •a as F ? 3_ z a wE€! t ,Sa 13 sy s 1 ; - 4� I� 1 J' 3� &N, y I Il' F�S� lit? i` � sla $i- €� a#3Lad 3E.a tt33 ;E3 d ?•4 zt 1:?111;lE g dE7 t-; F tic bPt g �� ;fid¢•' ! ! a? P P$ S� " S' 'S e E $'y # - islg : E E"--' E aE Bia @8 t!! 4' a a .E y•aas^ 3t5 Q l a? ;d?3 §S aFs.Sy+ ?tie°• fi �Y IFS a$ t E:7 g3 E$ s Y n z y s'.E 6yaa9s g Fg 25:n Stg �2a sESE� Ett E Eg 4 S -w: s IN -11h a=;#?E d` gi d EI�• r tE.F �a �' rt .a as3; s. 31 kT. -! $ f = E ? i : : € tic, ;dl`a j ?? it $ i i tF la; EAIgt Y §m a=$ a ag.; F .b ala �_ E 3 ?Fta?y % y8e a a a'F. Y ? 1 1F _ 'Et _ .IaE F a&°e Sa F p .°5 L a g PpE_3= j= p! iia a'2 3 E n ;;ol!rESE # ?€E a Y s'�L8EE8 $;Fa§�F 3p tH i•: s 4 Es{{it 80 {�{iE> =EE3E , 5;n8 s s a sac# y k3 - t3S=E p lE§ "9F2. §o, E$ ;� R2 U11 = ;;$; S E Yy1D'_) aE;�l4'1 F �i a 8S E6R3at�sy g 5$3S? ;i it •? a Eiy �E3e y a #3 Fol gol Ea ?"� E 8 43 :g8 a58�E; FeF i�� S�FF iFS aiF - r i iay 7 '? rt ? tt•� "Ti Tim t .� d 1s76=„ _�`;u t -1 p$ D4 $E_ 3 Rini 7. P :air ; 6 z31?'!€l a3= ii. �a _3 i3 t t a��1i t F ua8 y" ; s Fi e_?i_- aoa$•75 ?�i= = °➢.5 ER '4 6 3� Ei r• F ff PEy E&§?S 9 s m. a3cs3t y ?aF$ $ °� 5: § ?;� g E ! S•= a 4 " ? a F - ?; u § 3 r gel �i 1� � a s 1 ' F1a1==�F $p = y; F aF.E=E� 4 E y e !FI $$� n .li d_ E d7§�aPE F :§33 # F3 c Y73 ��;y31§$F _5's IN U d d !j ff S n FgFa ! ;E !6 Fay' 3 E 5 F ; :.:::: t6i F= s€ 33:= i i ip S s y!a a t. y Z Ea E3'• l ? �'o'ouauna v.. Ea @® 3_13 i ,s Ea.e �'S 1. J. ?E ti? E' $: � Wi aEo i # I�,..aF_§ 7° S �3 0 4 S E SaE•i� r•d ` $ff:: !i as a 3zF ?t yi Ea ESQ E 'iia 23§ i ; a "$'ir ° a�aasaasaas, p F p E, a3�&.= as =. iE3 s, ?t ?fl• a".:.;.::4�3 i �� 3$7�. ;833? $ 5�F E 5a 'zEa a c 7 sg7§ a 3 . ; ay$?$! E Fki_-E 3 a a sat• pr i I — $ a�'•"� ;- �t4-5 1�' •ppE-g a ? : a?'!i�?=3s a' a i E' E 7a?5fi E13k 9 a8'S F' '• ,1; It-; �i �ES E'E E. x e ' # s §� �. ?s°4i {i F.E 43- y E E s sa ;. a �Y d d 4 3 11ff ?s'i E? 3 by' E-61 = 1g ia, Sa# 3 1 E $a -z,e z`Ea ?= E E Et n y :l ; y 3F ;iya:: g.is$P � s��a�a�• 33E 5F ; 1a333a '" •; �a? � !ee fi t i Si F'In l EO a; d ?E m=3# i ,?;•E; F,.� 3?a E a s ' t 3 a2 E E -'7 ° E•EE�° 6 g - ;�sa t a3 i y t 4i a? i t 9 t P i_ •Y 5 t "d �° a aS l#-. 'Hi Ea Ili;!.!] Aax_ ES= a - Y - z i=s # Y s �- i m E i�EF s4. =3 ; i §§_ ; g yFe "; :j a=5 E: F•3 t 7'a ;; 3 E 38 3 9 �3 3'3aF9 ?i _;D '.' a3= $l $ •s $ iEE E S.g t Eas Eff� �7 �• a� �" ink F'€ �yr� ffF�•a a `1 �? �' �y:ES$�F§ �• g F�3 �� F� E��1P' ' $;i ?lst�•1 a ;s�sy � a �4P- d a,•e^§ g� 1E 78.3 E�5;b�5 ti ff $i F ;� n t i.l! ;$P i ;," •••n+ i ii 2i Ean l=E �o� l 9: � n _ 0 W J LL31z Q q�4dW Q zz� 0 Q�m� Q oQ��cs O '' 1 �CipQZ oKUzo J5 SLU NC, 0 Q5 m oz��z M ^W LO QiZZ� o�Zz Z WOOS `Z Opo Z Zce-Um O � Q Q W b e 'MV On IN J++ty` Q � PDX 4 o 'gK iS onGMOM K a x Q R� w �1��3W 01 "G�1 C) I cam' ATE �PNF °40'1�N, n n Ei a3�� 0.13°o'S 3,IW ARC = 5122' -CA. = 27.57170" RAMS = X7500' M4NAGE EASEACN (RA 7- B" 3G PAGE 1X1) ARC= 3298' -CA = 6.2"24V7 - RAMS = 3L20' 290' I °I l2.0' t5L TL —ARC = 4192' LI P) I� �n ffi db" � �eI IMd --o I� m CD �O o � m �ti a CD ao �q I I a � ~ b I I " I N � a T \f a o N LO �# s A I) I �PiL,9TF J I IT_ 27181 NF3r3i�_ LZO'PRVAIE 1t7A0AICD PAG fASgEN� (PLAT 60pC 3$ PACE' IV __ 3H38_NP3f3T` Al � r a o p l2.0' t5L TL —ARC = 4192' LI P) CA = 89'38'52' RAQt.6 = 26.7.9' k '�' -07"v ffi db" � �eI IMd --o I� LO �# s A I) I �PiL,9TF J I IT_ 27181 NF3r3i�_ LZO'PRVAIE 1t7A0AICD PAG fASgEN� (PLAT 60pC 3$ PACE' IV __ 3H38_NP3f3T` Al � r a o p TTL-------------...... N LI P) �O mZ m CD �O o � m �ti � CD ® 5.1'5240"W. �l 8aoo' o g g TRA mCvxcarol 5152'40"'W. TRA�C"q S I I� I 30 00' 143.42' OI 29.0' 1 PG XJ1.00' S 152'40'W S 1°52'40"Waor 4).12.42' Pc 55.58' : ' 30. ti 20&5'N 4J'05 'W. 2 85,58' $.1524 "W. IV XP WA MR EA.STEM 6NN 1f N15240E �I SP I Iz I u$ r—fi- I I I.CO eg I I� MrfM Iw I I� FTT Ll t o �w w a a s o0 0 Ln �I I Iti Ln b I loll I .� cn=WA RE 7.48' S V 48' 40 W. 140. �� '10224' VE Lzae'ERLor S 10o - _�AtAr 484p"!4! 93.38 p.0 � sL'rPRM 30.11' � Z�� 237.49'65320"1 /114.Or - EAST (y1E-LOTS 4_B�FYArXi PALE'75J YV. - _ STA iE ROAD r _A -1--A _ N�LAr L014 �N X1 Pq-4 1 =3 D c rn 0-%__ OC G7 _.................................... N_..... TTL-------------...... �," .._P__...0 mZ m CD c >O o v CD ® -4 LOT 1 LOT 1 Lp�sv�rf c4swff OBIfMGF FASL747pfr J DWM4EfAMWNro M77 fm 1RACT A' — ` (� f7J C g I I } * HIJ 6 fQD ,no s w 2z r O y +v f.2 Cb fQD ,no s w 2z i 0 m ci c a' o nD.v c c m o s o o m vD z O o o m g 00 MQ O J N ° 3 0 7 b(D m K n 3 < c �• m m m m z d n m ID M OrtID :1 O u-i m O N m p rt O O N -s v n C -i w -0 N ie wm° 3 h a' fl s o N a m O rn o O v 0 Z m Z CL CL cl IDL U; iD n 0 °' m m O m a p0—t N C a' a+ c m w m p D= 70 w m' -0 CL x ° p'�, N< n- < m rt rtt m o 0`„0 3 m 03 < C (p rt pl n Va Q to Q °< 0 f) (� O N _ O 0 ''� N psi S m ID ID ;a Z D O < °- 1^ 3 a 0 3 -I p < o N A o o, o° s E o° , aq m o ° y �c Z e m a m S "' o N m O d 0 m �, Z ,m D n ° m o s m a a m Q 3 c09 Q 3 S 3 N a v f+ ' v pa O _ n m s L o r i D x g (D Li s� o ° °c 33 p'–� i� a Z o o a m m c w m m vm v o m y S S O m to C m m m m N .y p 0 4c n m Z n w ,,, r-+ m o< u x a 0 ,�'+ tl 3 W m m< as d a o D ' Lnp7 ;T° 'L O �^ m �^ O O 07 n N 2 ID or S o° m O rt rt C N ° A 1n to W 0 C O d OG 50m N .-Sr .0 N -i w H w ru a 4 s X o< :+ m< umi H I ^ `� o° m m e `" c '" °' m o D m e w. v O '� < a s m c y 3 fn , H 3 � gz.+m `N" O v o 3 v � m �° ID S 3 a 3 " 0 3 .°irt a' K O 'O c -0 fl-wm w m '+ O?° m H m r oC ? ' m A'.m 0C O C*a 3cp 0aC cA C2 4 : r- mgY�O W o V x � � w l LC D r y � r y I y i o I � ' i , I O � l –�—i. Q ° o HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES -LOT 6 t7' 1230 NORTH OCEAN BLVD. a �e� �■■ j� CD C= z � GULF STREAM, FLORIDA z SEASIDE BUILDERS T - c 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104 e " ®■ o DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 l�IC HA1�D ,J O NE S -A,.- -1 --U U. NU PA " IMXL PLANS, DESIGNS, UR INFORMATION NAY BE REPRODUCED, COPIED LN UTILIZED 6RAPHILALLY IN ANY FORM VHATSOVER WIrADUT THE EXPRESS VATUEN CONSENT OF RICHARD JONES ARCHITECTURE IAVORPURATER a; N rt 9 CD c -r CD C rt O Z; G -i p f: n o co m C= _o 4� co O ®N O C--) M V-� m CCDO rnC m N A o� N o� rt buo 77 otlP R y>U tl< d 3 Q V/ G -i p f: n o co m C= _o 4� co   �� ZGI��ATE ROAD A_I_e I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I �� I I I I I I I I I I I I I ��g I m a ' o C,0 m2 �� �� C pp �� $ gg SO Laz I G) O a ti A v N 'w m : z m z ��N3y3JJL �� m �� �� O . D $ ��cn F--' N V :* ^' 1 r CD C= rn 3 N v g r ��g I m a ' o C,0 m2 �� �� C pp �� $ gg SO 9 vl O y O gg I G) O a ti A v N 'w m o g3E Na 8508 OF AUIHaimy Beach, Way Delroy 9laoh. Florida 33444 F.. 581 274-9558 ��g I m " � �� 1 fr �� �� `l C pp �� $ gg SO 9 vl O y O gg I G) O a ti 9��g czi$ o g3E Na 8508 OF AUIHaimy Beach, Way Delroy 9laoh. Florida 33444 F.. 581 274-9558 m z �� D m T ~Nf 2M.Nve 2 ��  +KNeM.. i x N. FedmfHwy �� rx: rro tiro ." v I�� NMew��Me y O "tl o p ' N o + rb N x I O m > zv \ N b ed td m ENGINEERS EnviroDesign n-xx Asociates sen" ��devgn com RONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR: LOT 6  HARBOR VIEW ESTATES 1230 N. OCEAN BOULEVARD GULFSTREAM, FLORIDA IT VAS JDYlH A. MIS. �%.L R REO / 426" �ATE "��""101a sr: FLORIDA 298 C Grow PineoA 1. Grow Phone: 581 274-8500 Na 8508 OF AUIHaimy Beach, Way Delroy 9laoh. Florida 33444 F.. 581 274-9558 00 > labo > A 9?� Alz m .5 60V Fn is.*� z 8 p >8 2 --q 31 C0 > m z ;u m Fn 1+ gem —r J Jim p WN. Z47' 4e*.11r ap l 0 z gig . . . . . . . . . . IM I Z mak a, 11 > IK jig 1.50- 00 EYI F 0 I R >m log, g 41 1 5 0 2 z No OTTBig Zr. .!w OTT 0 EIE > > Lu > ze3 28 X .50 ;u > > o z m ig X Ell , 4 ZI 0 K) iS F31m F--, r cn CD C=D rn 0 7 (�JE AIr.D..11!, vmw.emtlesign mm ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PAVING & DRAIANGE DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 6 - 1230 N OCEAN BLVD STREAM, FLORIDA 1 �� JOSM A. PIKE. P.L Fl. M f 42"G �. "M NEVOMM FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTI�YM N. 8505 Ir, altr lie G� Way Doi FloridaFlorlcla 33444 298 Pb7LF Ph (55 ) 7"5DO I= (581) 274-0558 I Pm Cfn= Z OEM < Z o (< ZC j e z' EOe Ftj`J \ > MAP l �O CmG z i W A Z7 5�x� 4Qoo$ �ZP N z Se m npti3 \ (7 D Q, z o I II=11 V) _ i rn I X —II I S m r r m 0> N �o< I II—III U Z = siP 'P>� z w m j z ®® gay 1 1 m y 1 —� I I—I 1 P z ; 4 �?TN yn N Z <> s T mc� o° co P. i p 4 I IF9 I T III PPPP o Tm zOz I (- 00 Z m —1 pp�e � � L Z g ' 2• YeL $E \P31 N =11 I P 11111111 Ilala P -11_ 111 P m � o Z 0 0 c') O ;� a M cz C o M 0 C e_ 3 m and . N o � ► SEPTIC SYSTEM DETAILS FOR: NUT YAW No DAM REM1013:E,lo.lmlti ,� .y: o m EnviroDesign p w N x\ •• b m f Assoaietes ,„� HARBOR VIEW ESTATES ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS LOT 6 — 1230 N OCEAN BLVD FLDRIUA cennFlcATE or AuniamzAna+ NAd6 GULF STREAM FLORIDA 298 Phsopple Grow Way Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Ja3ElB A. MM P.E.Phone: 581 274-8500 F= � R RED / 4RlM 581 274-8558 v D L33 �>Z m o�a Z Im 96 101 \ m 11M �M z z m v $ m D r °� � 24 wn 4 ro'J�J�� n n m h 0 o g \ <� h Z n n 0 Q\ h n �{ u'1 p yT a o en x 1 O N \ N 7 4 N F de M1il Hwy POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN FOR:�T LOT 6 —HARBOR VIEW ESTATES 1230 N. OCEAN BOULEVARD GULFSTREAM FLORIDA � m 010�'� Q•, JOSH A. PKL ►.L R KQ 0 42w! MM an '�� If. p FLDRM)A cmnFlCAIE 29B PI,;)wWe Gmw Phone 961 274-8500 (v wI"rla"U'p" N. °'°° Way Ddray Booch• Florldo 33444 Fore 561 274 -OW 17 v , L__ cn O " o A o en x 1 O N \ N ENGINEERS EnviroDesign Associates n . waw.em:aev9n.mm NMENTAL CONSULTANTS POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN FOR:�T LOT 6 —HARBOR VIEW ESTATES 1230 N. OCEAN BOULEVARD GULFSTREAM FLORIDA � m 010�'� Q•, JOSH A. PKL ►.L R KQ 0 42w! MM an '�� If. p FLDRM)A cmnFlCAIE 29B PI,;)wWe Gmw Phone 961 274-8500 (v wI"rla"U'p" N. °'°° Way Ddray Booch• Florldo 33444 Fore 561 274 -OW TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-11 Address: 1222 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Seaside Builders, LLC Construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest suite, a detached outdoor seating area, a total of 9,229 SF, and a swimming pool. Gross Lot size: 54,102 SF Effective Lot Area: 39,911 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 9,229 SF Allowable: 10,582 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Height: 28' 10" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Finished Floor: 16.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest suite, a detached outdoor seating area, a total of 9,229 SF, and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. The roof shall be white (through and through) un -textured uncoated flat cement tile. 3. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 4. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 5. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #012-11 ARPB September 27, 2012; TC October 12, 2012 ARPB Date: September 27, 2012 Action: Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: conditions listed above (4-0). TC Date: October 12, 2012 Action: Page 2 Recommended approval as requested and submitted w/the 5 Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Approved as requested and recommended with the 5 Conditions listed above. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL RECEIVED AU(11 - . • 2612 Town of Gulfstream Fl This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information LA -1. Project/Owner Name: PART 11. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File #_ Z _ f /_ I.A.2. Project Address: I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: P -�-�- �GAO J _Ab?'3 klidden rb fl.�T'-TL' I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: - !� Z ; _ 9 Architectural Style: e Y WA L) q� I.A.6. Check all that apply:XA"rchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) O Special Exception (complete section) I.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: _j0 400 Type of Foundation: B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 1 '53� "-S LB.2. Owner Phone Number: ��Z • 9 qrFax: f...) 1.B.3. Owner Signature:����,,,��� C. Agent Information I.C.I . Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I�� W 9 14 / t, I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) cella'((-WQ 1 OM Fax o�%2 O '7Z I.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but question brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete . number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? n t71� Ccea l7 III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? Kes ❑ No kJ eS Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent wi the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan?,es ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? \/ t C` f(z III.A.6 0 How are the -following utilities to be provided to the ornnPrtAt? Stoi San PotE Irrig Elec Telel Gas Cab If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the w,(Jj`ect inv ve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 'es o (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes IO (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV -A-3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vPeant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes `kXo (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does thepro�j ct require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes AVO (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project a ariance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes o (if "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Legal Description eav� EsT /aT : BEING A REPLAT LOTS 4, 5 AND 6, GOLF COURSE ADDITION, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 10, PAGE 75 (P.B.C.P.R.) AND TRACT A, HIDDEN HARBOR ESTATES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE 110 (P.B.C.P.R.) ALL BEING IN SECTION 9, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGE 43 EAST, TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA APRIL 2011. I.A.4 Project Description: Lot 3: The project will consist of a two story residence with Bermuda style influences. It will have a detached 3 -car garage with guest suite above. At the rear of the properly there will be a small outdoor seating structure,will storage below. -,0)  A tsrof Q  _. ��Dr�� oo ��R2a a LJ m ��2 �� < W1 W hni!CD o �% 0��4��RaISVFIS V.` `nW W Qo z Q > ` _- �% �% HU a "Id Nida2l I,S 3 If1J'UA Ig l��t`d930"rr��ZZ[ Q �� �� �� �� �� �� i ��i" O ZR aCV � )'1-SHIV.I.SH?1f1OUHVH NEIGUIHU > W (�� W CQ � w 2 ��.I.j 035- d1.- ���� ,1 a � ml 0 (A a o�� ��0 w r a $Q'w ������ o Q R Q' r O p w g Z n LL W$ U O Q' W3 m z_ _ �� i�� r J > a o o w o o Q a a � U s Q' W Z 82 a Q' �� wg5u u �� m O 'f& t U) 6 � p p < K Z W �� < J ^ W S.. ru Z Q' O O Hm w t0u Up C ZI K Z O O O ZQ p O 2 OaW z ��I dw O K Z O F Po0 2- m m 2 W U O OS S � h 1f 'W��1 11����1/��1 � ZZ Q' p Q' �� 6 LLO m O 3oR wio ���m Y L F m z> aQ'x ���� oz o o4 F > om ow F w Q'3�� � owl ��z g Q' z'��� orz�� w�� ���� iq 9 a u `o' 9 Ego o <Q � g zp W N W=Ne ����= o_ =gym oar zo o ��- � � u u � w'u'� >3 ��mwoo u o ��m F w Hi �� o��,O o 3w oo C�� F V o?�� rc `�� ozo g wj aa io { 3 W L h~H a f mmmm zU SFSa - Z< F 8 y - jw fru 5p Fp ?O ��S`U p F�WS Of z��O Oo� pz 6 <5 o w U w ��mu��U m� 2's T4a To < cF 02��. ��wE W �� ��i-z Yg�� ����Zp l l ��R J ���� � .��u ��p zw rp��J $ �''`�� ��1 t��7 $im ��5 ��Ff > O LLw OTU o�� ^u W��Q' ��� j5 wZS Q' qg w o 2 j j�� 3 O .��q 0J O ��Z u o go f Zz.e f z R,3 ����.11 z ��3 oa o6 �- iw Fm -gz `� ��o F ' S o rz�g gcS W,W6". u a o�� -�� of g�- w FUu Ogg9 OF o5 ww fr FO j SO Smu��l ulj ii�Un Z O z�� u3 i ��g 'ay Q' w� -.Z;! m ,� H w�� woo wuwo "w -w d � �3w i <z o z Z�dz 'd m ��� o m����< ��rc O rcZ,o o 'o$ w��$ ��o ��oai � ��o owo 6z ii ME FI w. a"'��wz ou�i Z �� Z - x wi zo T. >��w zo w oma w j y m Z= Fo �I F F�� ao �gFp< 65 F==UO F i�� OZF F> u Rz0 Z O w'g < ww g Win� � ��-Q' ��j3 F z< w m Z w m A <S H r-yX-'F UU x 6U ] OUaO -opp a � e omW��FF w `�� ��o SWU> =O ulOm��< $' � Z Uz Q'x Wm> 3�O F W_Ix-Fb Uw �oo o $�� W".ism Q'n�� q��q gv y ��w Q'a�f z- 5�� oz rc2 ur WLL xzZW" 'd r'o nr= i irc ��o oJo ? 3 >o1 m W-0 1. 4'o -F u iW ��wu 3k pga2O�� �� o. W m <~ m -< W KN W � =-F z�W yw g oaf� >�d ico ��'z mmQ' orx m5 <�� rc3� Z< oz a� � F�� QF 3�m� ��Z F0 O� Z�� O ZOZW ��131 Om �O Y O ��aME �� 0-, pJJa�� rw �m W�� �ww ���� 2mF��<F (iif�� W pOwm WOj� 52 z <y C O�� w� a 2 ZUF O �b5U O�� U w0 USF ��0 ��14w N22Q F� pis z ���� 3 0 .�� a� �zgc��i o � o pw5 m pQ' z"w u aF o� w o�`��Fgw ��i 'n xw w Wo FW - 0 3- o J_�� V FLLwm o g zQ'v a3 � a ��gw<��f tw zo oa Wwo zo mNo$o E. -z 5 1.0. < ua ���� > m Op NF���� ww i a m m F$d .i � � ma �Q'z �U mmm ��J i9 <zad' m o 'dF w Q'_�m ��F au- m o���U ���� woo '��' <'m of a Q'LL "0. -- w�� zm z<, 8. n$'a u Op <gl-�� o op ��'swR om Op LL zaw$ -'$ W,- --Z ��o w F "��� xQow aga zQ'moa" ox �SpQ' Z�� O(OJR 7w WM1� K ?O �� WdU� p�m S QRm LL 2>N w���w a2 im O �W�� O�� ON4��a��U z l-��- m u w20 ��'' sa� ow i> m F m `�� s o<�� z ���� wig w w <w wm �m z o9 ooU � Q'r t'm orca f iio ��o 3r mu�iZ ��6 ozm er so ori z1= mk o ii w i'�� i i Iwx-z rc <Q' i � Z. S" o4w o mzx��. � u zgm a� -�� o uw mo - 'ini ow `��i m m a mQ'w m�ga��u �3 �o mp .,a < N44iw�off QoQ m��m E. p UD <aW V<�� =oz 2 UU �O 000p UT U U z32 W U0 ozp< Op W� n 0. O< wSiox�� F J q��� a Q'0m ��ga < rc g�� m rim a��m_Zo ��F ��i c�� Gu��iri '��c7 W.iml-xbi oa to O U mUZ �m X F ��J �� r ��w 1�- .o i < fw f0Ri ozri0 Z OD ~ ��w Z-+ Q'f0 2W 2 z KZ(wJ m =��_ ��1-w0 U9 U�� z0 K�< � OW Vyor K O_- U- Zm_ SW UFS Q'> 00. Ow OtWw U O O U O < O< � S w 3 m p uz. um aQ' u u i 'd ��� W, p v v Fz 4 6 FO f23 J= x< z wm ~ w �K F <� jOw 8a d`�� 0 z2w � <�z> 3 �3 g w o��u ��� w <��o rg ugiw ��iww ��� ��o ��c�iv"' ���� .1F.qui 0`4x�3 ' F Sq�M4 '8w gy ��- �� 9 'o rx$ �� e h�$ mo X03 moopip ��� Rw ��� Riiia R�� �o`��o Rw $_ O $ OQ'< O� ��< m oSm�01< pK o00 Omz< Om mw ja W. O< 0- 3: 0� s-�� M wN (V W C) �� �� ��wvwm � 11 11 W ? 'ItA O L Y � LL OZ m Q H U M n Q��j PF 9F-1 wmWm W ��w����N�� �w www Z3f<= zo O<WW T �wUU`nN O z�p u ��rnUn i Z Q W< wz HEE Q0 o V O��rQr��i V a. 00 a It Q w Z W Qwa �� F_ N�� m a Qwwpw � Z w c���� w z I- 0 U����UF- O O LL w 0 U) U. < J o - b 1 fl W d Y w Z 0 Z Z Q fn Y II ferry 11 Z�� Z J O UYUY a 0Z t1 H w m<W < W t m 0 l<i 2 o O 7 w 7 S fW w Fm- Z ZUw. Z ���� Nw W qZ Z OD g gZ F_ W z0�� Oo in tl U o U O<000 I�� O wpQ� W -1 zO mLLN N F- W U O IEi Er U) to O M v 0 0 p O Q IJo 2z�a W W z�� ����os a Z ��Z2. L) rnz��� W mQ���� mr EEEEI F WLij-j ��pF J < in ��UzZ�� U��tWi. C7 w 0 = z < J p��UQZ ��lxg<0 vavv F � O W Z" � w U QWwO u ILu u z a v x in w 2 WUmLLa�� 000 L) (L w z O 0 W W O O wZ>-W U) Z O W 0 �� O W �� LO J V���� J w w w w 0 O ix Ir ��� Z y U' It CC) w >d��wco >WWwW z N a w z W�� o p� z vaiaiv=i= gSS w > w a -Z �� LL C7 H �U m w N E I 'I' H 'I' O I I� IIII I � I I -----J I I IL ----------------- I----------------- I _____j r -----------------i' _._._._.—.—_- _ I I ------------------------------ I I , I I, I i I I jII I I I I I II I I I j II I II I ii I � I I II I ;I I II I ;I I ;I I it I II I Z ;I I II I ;I I ;I I II ;I I {I I ;I I I I r'1 ;I I II I ;I I II ;I I .I I ;I I ;I I II - - ---- ' ,I I I I I I ------------- --- ------------ ---1--J----- ------------'�1_ I I , I I hell �vd 'sc Hxa lr� �rrav�3 ` A.IIIJfl &W 6VO'd 31VMdA M end a 0 0 w w n s. C>Pa.i. r H �:D **tl -N4v--z- s "Atl-z o r cr"�ff-NV-H o ■ w ® £8V££ dQR10 II `H3d9g Ad2i IgQ 401# HfINHAd H.Lb gN 581 S-dR(I ilflg MIMS a a N ® IL p O Q P. u a § ON W � ca�1E O w '"IJ NIVMUS JIM 'QA'IS KVH30 'I Mz I o > LO I- SH Ld LSg 2If10g2IdH NgQQIH o S N •*-- W w a 0 0 w w tIOZ gnv s�.a,.eo�.,,...,o,,..,�.,,,.,o� ��,.,,, „o.,,.,,a �� 1,.»,.,,, ,.�...o„ ���oo.,� .,.,..,,.,,,., , o�„���.,,,, ,.o�� .,.. ,., � , ,,.,,,,o�a� .�, „�„ o� •„oma., .��„u�oo� � �.,, ,.�.�..,.�,,.,,., a„ ,,.�.��..,,.. ,o ���,,. �„ 1� ,. ��„o���o ,,r �.o ,,. ,.�..o�oa,�,., �o„�s�,,,,o� ,�,.,,, �o.,,,.o �a �,.� ��.o„„a,,, , dN' ®, + 4Y 1FIal31 3nV3 c n .1 - w w A- E o-.rc Ali I � g 7 �� J.11-l11f1 4NV QVO24 91VAI?Jd OZ [L00 u� 0 L00 L � / > � O U �y�/ O r1 o� y Ty oa �iL 0 H s r S G� Il t! 6yt d iyl•3i L Slit IRE fi `3 � �F��a:•�o6 o$I$I€ �� �� &fid c �= a ! z;m§;��}ia 776"; ija Ge�6e q 6l S; j§ ae66I eIna a d tl J d d 2 d d J tt § (L 6yk l $ !$;§$yyx r�§' "➢yfifi6E fib{ to iAlj ➢� ?Ejjfll l; ;' 4 16 95E 2 { to b = $ � - � 8 ° � ➢ $ k it �{ ? d d d d l i EF; $ sill, of n s$I hi IL I ;a ?' ieya 3i{ 11b a66 y aj!1PE All IPA 3➢$y $,{9 js! $, $1& d_yE 193 Ft-�I"s a. U It a99.E6d 41,t I, i c d d 3 y a 9 $ y a ig ; yjp silig 1i$,yi tl •�, s i=1 IN y fit j ,➢➢ 37 �tE§tas°t l� t➢ �,t � ➢ :�3•. �$: $' viii E {'Lrt'3=•� �� k � 6l��,. lit 3 §� ,t•I���tx$ l3�? fill IM I ! If t�•a �� st 45 €all tjg IN It > l Et ib $ �3�y• +I iy$ Rni$� &fy t=l holy. T �D°y � t$ §yy• 793 3° �34�1� °= a r=-�6yE E'�•d P y P �$ji �!➢ $ g �a1- k8i �i_8 ��_ ➢%Djy$a=�=. i$E, t E i ° • ; ➢-1 1, u1116 }i!3 # tt tl Ali $ ➢e E6� Ey ill! t 5 N"III ; 2�y l$3°1 'y� lI� ial ix4 ;lri�n ] arty 9 $EiStI .tIk All E� :1mYa$�taD y 3 3 YS �jD �y i°'d IE ��1Y6 fi43I i 6 l�5 2Y �${i 33E �a at ;°!-$ `v` -`i i• E YY i J 8 �- 4�y11 ill 3� °$ I'D -i, 7 d d tl wa ! Is a ! 6 ➢$Z gly yl,t�gsyyy8�;$'a tljE� �$ ��� jdga ��'�€ $j))§§§§ '•8 rgya°66a+jlr{! litl� ta$ ;9ja �� �� � � �? �b �;y� g � _��y� �t•� 9,19 IIii ° till l�3yi{t;b■Earl ;P•. il$!y3 6 i i a? ! y i83II :Edi�lsl � # 4111 ! y biH Rei{ $ �$ •t� � f �! $ € � a ! �! a���D 3•a a ° ?l=psE til 3j147 fal;yj; 1ls.l-yi ; s{ ijl if d J eb ! a13: ,l 6 ; 11111 ;,5€ 6°} ; � 1 61 11$� ]-i � ���$f d §$ °� $ il° III Gl n i g . i ss,yb lIII.I,t !l1y'' I] i ii,I if r b;;agglip g� If d J o J Dl j1119 lot F -I lit%;P jE ¢+ E e_; j$3 �•�D � § �;: �si�� Y�� 311,1 t $ Fy eI Ogg. m ifl, 11 lilt lit, 11, Ind$! 8 A 13i4 11 4�I Ea {a{ !&§ : gg $ Alii', 1111: � 7$s d d e d e i� a � ®., 1,2M a LU N a 11111iliai m WQ a 0 � a 1 �, �;ya� n 0 u,� a �-' a.0 W ! Is a ! 6 ➢$Z gly yl,t�gsyyy8�;$'a tljE� �$ ��� jdga ��'�€ $j))§§§§ '•8 rgya°66a+jlr{! litl� ta$ ;9ja �� �� � � �? �b �;y� g � _��y� �t•� 9,19 IIii ° till l�3yi{t;b■Earl ;P•. il$!y3 6 i i a? ! y i83II :Edi�lsl � # 4111 ! y biH Rei{ $ �$ •t� � f �! $ € � a ! �! a���D 3•a a ° ?l=psE til 3j147 fal;yj; 1ls.l-yi ; s{ ijl if d J eb ! a13: ,l 6 ; 11111 ;,5€ 6°} ; � 1 61 11$� ]-i � ���$f d §$ °� $ il° III Gl n i g . i ss,yb lIII.I,t !l1y'' I] i ii,I if r b;;agglip g� If d J o J Dl j1119 lot F -I lit%;P jE ¢+ E e_; j$3 �•�D � § �;: �si�� Y�� 311,1 t $ Fy eI Ogg. m ifl, 11 lilt lit, 11, Ind$! 8 A 13i4 11 4�I Ea {a{ !&§ : gg $ Alii', 1111: � 7$s d d e d e i� a � ®., 1,2M a LU N a 11111iliai lilA 11ivi lkp 5 3 ;➢fi 3 FO dddddd � ®., 0 ithl2i1411ttlttl, LU N a W VCDD W p co CM Q CO A 3 FO y �tEl3 5: ja[ y ty �g111Ali I HMW E � i �§ It �� }� !y;$;•g � g ,I� �a�3;� F i y yE,! 'k �����a�'y➢e' ?fiiy��.;g' 6e�$I�� ��� ��� � y-at��g� ��;� ? a ° d d e ° yl § i l '�• �S � L fi �� 4'F �i15 ip ltilt, f t'� it 9f fl=if I � S ea5 e e ! $g l3iS °;�� ��5j Dr E y El 1 e - 'a i t Y lilt ]L'� y it', [IS 613 t! Q ➢ 6 d $t iI=I 51� ;e3 6 l e I zlglil eye l abD $ $ y U11i, e3Mlilj if ➢ jj3 D D n, '' b - 3 e ll 41316 i f # i �i 3 5 es6 21 e1;;t9° a E - as: $t i 5€f jl4 l yP; hr �m9t�t{s� k s 6lF Ell fi; Olt�_ ��• ll 3y�-°8 is y- a � to=$ $ ����#i i=$!i� - � �� {y d�B•§3 yyg §�� � ja ���PB� €°, � { $fE y$d:]{ �jd,e�`8E el� 1 �•° §{� 6ay�P ����� a�l`� i{4�°� e➢ � i{1 i5A Fi § 3 i$ sy;6 ➢ b��yi l $° �r ��° � 5i:i`II�lfy lli. l $ g �3 y fit, g6 l §§ t ia$g• �_ � ! � �q Mild � 143 �!Y�IES � �8�:119�➢E �{d�b�s 36 t d � d L d� 2 d tl J d • � d d R d tl d d tYy yjg ➢� 12 •E Elit !11011111111111:111111 it �;a{�gl a� Ulf 1y_�!1 i� •3gya i a y; '➢be8$l°%n9;§d g 4 3 rFYeyyE4t/l k E' SS:e5Sbb5'a� lilt ;aa {6� ms*umi;N !I lyaF y} Ei ll;Q` j ��� y� i•3� ExE 9 lit ithl2i1411ttlttl, al t y �tEl3 5: ja[ y ty �g111Ali I HMW E � i �§ It �� }� !y;$;•g � g ,I� �a�3;� F i y yE,! 'k �����a�'y➢e' ?fiiy��.;g' 6e�$I�� ��� ��� � y-at��g� ��;� ? a ° d d e ° yl § i l '�• �S � L fi �� 4'F �i15 ip ltilt, f t'� it 9f fl=if I � S ea5 e e ! $g l3iS °;�� ��5j Dr E y El 1 e - 'a i t Y lilt ]L'� y it', [IS 613 t! Q ➢ 6 d $t iI=I 51� ;e3 6 l e I zlglil eye l abD $ $ y U11i, e3Mlilj if ➢ jj3 D D n, '' b - 3 e ll 41316 i f # i �i 3 5 es6 21 e1;;t9° a E - as: $t i 5€f jl4 l yP; hr �m9t�t{s� k s 6lF Ell fi; Olt�_ ��• ll 3y�-°8 is y- a � to=$ $ ����#i i=$!i� - � �� {y d�B•§3 yyg §�� � ja ���PB� €°, � { $fE y$d:]{ �jd,e�`8E el� 1 �•° §{� 6ay�P ����� a�l`� i{4�°� e➢ � i{1 i5A Fi § 3 i$ sy;6 ➢ b��yi l $° �r ��° � 5i:i`II�lfy lli. l $ g �3 y fit, g6 l §§ t ia$g• �_ � ! � �q Mild � 143 �!Y�IES � �8�:119�➢E �{d�b�s 36 t d � d L d� 2 d tl J d • � d d R d tl d d tYy yjg ➢� 12 •E Elit !11011111111111:111111 it �;a{�gl a� Ulf 1y_�!1 i� •3gya i a y; '➢be8$l°%n9;§d g 4 3 rFYeyyE4t/l k E' SS:e5Sbb5'a� lilt ;aa {6� ms*umi;N !I lyaF y} Ei ll;Q` j ��� y� i•3� ExE 9 lit Z B-IBLIJ C14 I'a, , Big �� N N LL. Q Q 99 � ;ill �4 C� W �2�h LL 7 d &4 Z 0 0 0 m a 54' o ® N � 6 T!, �r3�nYeon oez I (wa�vnwY1 r � I rh we+ ue. u uuear3 �rnep rrs+ an+ Jr. mtw s shN YTM zw 3mast�sun��rpwan � LL IJ.I Co o cyD I a A QLU LO o I ® t -o I I � I � I I I I I � • 4 0 o o I D V I � N I R I o W 2 u c 3 rn `� �[kamn�xnao r[+ A O [Kxav3 �rnwa n r[ rte+ MUWLw v sun + + ow Q I (au gnu arxnv�rtu [fl�Y3.U77f/1 3 A aKN'3lYAW \ 0 A Y d N �0 I A \ \'�� lau �v sr xxae 1nD �Ya�rivm I �� wssDON ,07 �I 10, 531V1� I A � I �d19 0 I �Q cc J�cdW J W yew Z=�O W a Q - O v, W�WZtiN.� LL- �Q Lr) o ti �m2� WO ci U Z��W �Qvm i LO I Z to H ;l �C�56cNG���g LZ SQye amu` �O�fwgWQl t 14 cs 4 LU CO) c LL Q N ami c%i u. 0 WLU N a ~' o O I� ul H ;l �C�56cNG���g LZ SQye amu` �O�fwgWQl t 14 cs 4 I �I 1,r � 1Fp �I I �b J M,OZ�So9S V' LLB�. II w 0 N ca M,OvB� _ 11%)aVdankv U. W 0w I a I 31„06,8Y as ,G*z O 11 ui 04 0 h C7 0 raj � F $P CD _--_ _.. - ©-. �..... `C......- 3 �. a. I �- I �I 1,r � 1Fp �I I �b ti M,OZ�So9S Ih `6�,/F7�15V3 II w v ti 11 Df W2ld 135 8F' £6— M,OvB� _ 11%)aVdankv I I I�c %%lq'l[L98N;EOF I a I 31„06,8Y as ,G*z O 11 .4 h ¢ $P I �I I �I I �b ti �� � Ih �n II w v ti O I co I l'S ,8S'S8 ,esss Jd (�✓/Lvngy v) 'Db2I1 11 s %tLOb.ZSdS ,Zb'99� I IAI II I �I �I �I "� AI ~� I II r II I A�I II L OOZP M.Ob.ZSdS 3.f£JfdN ,8F'L'F .wSiJ.o'Li (ai �vd sf Iva) 1N31�V3 All7ll7 OJV OVOH 3l VACH qZ� 3FI7fdN J91LZ �IL — � R �I �I I I` SSV �� � Ih �n �� Nb Nh NN O O I co I I�c %%lq'l[L98N;EOF I ,R .fiCSZ = 9ll7VL .Z5.8f,6g = Y'J O 11 .4 ¢ $P I �- I rn� 31 I �✓� IIry 0 1 Q y¢ e� N� lbtosv3a3tvm.a m z ALOF:Sq.f6 N.SV'LL� _� ,Z%ZL m Ot"O ['s(b �„or,zs(s.00za lov Jd zorki xory. MDt"zsas (NPL✓MtlJ , �,0io� O ^� �� ,OOSBZ %tLOb.ZSdS ,Zb'99� I IAI II I �I �I �I "� AI ~� I II r II I A�I II L OOZP M.Ob.ZSdS 3.f£JfdN ,8F'L'F .wSiJ.o'Li (ai �vd sf Iva) 1N31�V3 All7ll7 OJV OVOH 3l VACH qZ� 3FI7fdN J91LZ �IL — � R AZ7f = 6i%v✓a .ZarZ,Z9 - YJ-� (a! 39Vd W )COS 1V"U) 1"-3sv33JVNVlp — .cnsa = a�s�avaf .LS,LZ = YJ .ZZ7S - .Y/V lvDy,�ZI YY ¢ WQ �I �I I I I I� I4 �� � Ih �� to I,cc Lr a I I�c %%lq'l[L98N;EOF I ,R .fiCSZ = 9ll7VL .Z5.8f,6g = Y'J AZ7f = 6i%v✓a .ZarZ,Z9 - YJ-� (a! 39Vd W )COS 1V"U) 1"-3sv33JVNVlp — .cnsa = a�s�avaf .LS,LZ = YJ .ZZ7S - .Y/V lvDy,�ZI YY ¢ WQ 40 IL iAltA � ; �� -- � � _ �, �. mr mmw_v A } .R ti P I l �µ �. 1 �-�,11Md S q s - .•[ jam-' �k-•- i �1 i Sot 1 4 ;tome UN'. - Ilk - r' � HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES LOT -3 32 SW 6217 Topsail WALLS TRIM SHUTTERS APPROVED SET OCT 12 2012 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL ► RECEIVED t AUG 2 3 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES LOT -3 32 SW 6217 Topsail WALLS APPROVED SET OCT 12 2012 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL TRIM SHUTTERS ►RECEIVED,4 AU6 ,? 3 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL Page 1 of 1 Rita Taylor From: NTouhey@aol.com Sent: Wednesday, September 26, 2012 3:21 PM To: Rita Taylor Subject: (no subject) To The Gulf Stream Town Commissioners and the ARPB: As was the case a year ago when unfortunate decisions were made regarding subdivision of the Spence Property, I am unable to attend upcoming Public Hearings on plans for building new homes on the site. Unfortunately, I was a innocent victim of the developer's failure to live up to agreements that supported the Town's decision to approve subdivision --most important, the stipulation that the arbor canopy not be destroyed for the convenience of the builder. Had the Town even tried to stop the developer from cutting down a magnificent banyan tree directly across from my driveway, I might have been more supportive of the eventual outcome of this project. am hereby requesting that any approved plans for the six residences that will eventually be built in Hidden Estates include a stipulation that the Town frequently inspect the project --on a daily basis, if necessary to assure that the builders are actually abiding by the terms approved by the Board of Commissioners. I do not wish to place undue burden on the Town Staff, but the neighbors cannot be watchdogs, and we do not wish to be subjected to unpleasant surprises that affect the value of our properties and the quality of our lives. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Nancy Touhey 9/26/2012 dave bodker landscape architecture/planning inc. 601 n congress avenue, suite 105 a delray beach, Florida 33x45 561 .276.631 1 • (fax) 561 .276.3869 August 28, 2012 Bill Thrasher Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Delray Beach, FL 33483 RE: Lot 3, Hidden Harbor Estates 1222 N. Ocean Blvd APPROW"", '"'T OCT 12 2,11 TOWN v g GULF STREAM, FL We have revised the hardscape and planting plans for this residence. The overall height of walls, columns and railings, including any lights and wall or column caps, will be 6'. Any chain link fence on the plan will be black vinyl coated and will be screened from off site view by hedge or vine plant material. 8412_8-28-12_let RECEIVED AUG 302012 lawn of Gulfstream, FL TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-12 Address: 1220 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Seaside Builders, LLC Construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with a bonus room above, a total of 8,603 SF, and a swimming pool. Gross Lot size: 54,102 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 8,603 SF Zoning District: RS -O Finished Floor: 16.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Effective Lot Area: 39,911 SF Allowable: 10,582 SF Height: 28' 10" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval to allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics and providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #012-12 ARPB September 27, 2012; TC October 12, 2012 Page 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with a bonus room, a total of 8,603 SF, and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. The roof shall be white (through and through) un -textured uncoated flat cement tile. 3. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 4. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 5. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view ARPB Date: October 25, 2012 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Recommend approval as submitted on drawings with the exception of the 13' clear zone and further recommended that there be binding documents and provisions that hold the HOA responsible for maintaining the prescribed landscaping in the buffer area. It was also recommended that the site screen as detailed in the plans be provided by the Developer to the best of his ability. (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend Approval as submitted with the five conditions listed above, along with binding documents and provisions that hold the HOA responsible for maintaining the prescribed landscaping in the buffer area. Also recommended that the site screen as detailed in the plans and agreed to by the Developer be provided by the Developer to the best of his ability. (5-0) TC Date: November 9, 2012 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as submitted on drawings with the exception of the 13 ft clear zone. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Approved as submitted with the 5 conditions listed above and provided a deed restriction is placed on the property making the HOA responsible for maintaining the landscape material in the buffer area on the private property as shown on the exhibit attached to the deed restriction, with the hedge to be maintained at a height of no less than 6', and further provided that a 6' temporary construction fence with screening material attached be installed inside the buffer area. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPR0I CU7 uh i►.,_ This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File 11 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name:440d% J — Fsk�"e 11 -IL -C I.A.2. Project Address: _ �^ �l I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: �5e2 I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, includin^ 11 of cf^rioc nf, I -see I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: &0 Architectural Style: �q� r YY1 U OL 1.A.6. Check all that apply.�-Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures 0 Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: ' l L4 , dD Type of Foundation: STEMW tRt.a B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address:Q I.13.2. Owner Phone Number., • la• q Fax: _C�i L I.B.3. Owner Signature:_ C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date:_ App Date: Com Date: Decision: IcPe�sIr 1-12- - cel U1 '�� � Fax Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: U 2; i 5,4 t ►,114 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 I.A.4 Project Description: Lot 4: The project will consist of a two story residence with Bermuda style influences. It will have a detached 3 -car garage with Bonus Room above. It will be a courtyard style house with pool and motor court. Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question. number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? Yes ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan?>0yes ❑ No Explain. IILA.4. flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? i C t_ How are the following utilities to be provided to Stormwater Drainage 1 Cal Sanitary Sewer Potable Water s-� ,�" �Ad ffickwj_ Irrigation Water Elec`-'- Telel Gas Cab 111 III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the pMject involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 19 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes 18'No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV -A-3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑Yes o (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV -A-5. Does the pr ' ct require approval of a Special Exception? El Yes No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the projec t variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes UrNo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be -di ---t ct or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Descriuc uie need and justification for the-fttmtrmee/addition: WE IV.13.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes 0 I n Explain: _fin � A- Z V l U(aA Q`:�3-1 L,--)1,`411 `-W� IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? pvY i &X- O pq�n ��aS �v a-llai,� �u�r -� `�"bw►r1s �-�- #•{-fie (�`c�.�-�1'�G� - IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the yeast impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District.(-- are retwoo-t p•� f'\v r 'aA R CAZ —X' -fit `f Ee/A CLC�P-m-en+ w Mn V1aJ i d"C SIgecie) C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? / IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? 2Q IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? LN) D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: sah IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: _aC) "-NL CL'{ -(0^,.- w � � Af PJ, h Nae'( &Xkhc J -e to Q t, +;� 'LAI i 110—a"i'C ", IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? cC.(0&. Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 1220 N Ocean Blvd. B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit IV.B.1 What significant landscape features are to be added and to what extent? Addition of native plants in most areas of the 50'corridor, and provide an area for the Town's street tree program. Also a 6' wall or railing 39' at its closest point to the property line. a "wTn 01 Vulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Code Comprehensive Plan text change, orany Zoning combination otnc haereof, plea a Land Use Map change, justification for the request. describe the need and PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants, Applicants additional relevant information regarding the projethatwas not covered elsewhere on thisged, but not f to provide any the other materials submitted with the application. s form or on any of /4 r PQ 1- %j V1 0 1- C--� Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 0 I► � •ate �e c , v r i .1� �J r  Ll X J1 Ad OS:bS:Z Z[N/Sl/8 `bmP'ONg SVNl\mG1A aogaoH V S s}oI SVNIVIN O uj C* C14 J LL W N L g $ > Otu F F: = o < DAF fig ' ON CSL Jg i1�� _ -F i 0. p I  rp / 03Y V 3" J 'DIY Y M1EOf Nauu` a'miv^N10WH Y LLiQO 1��R ��7l Y r1QWS ��1111�� ( IH NYHOO lei OZZI  t ,LO'I S 511US H MBIA 2IO aZIVH :2103 iVId S,LNaNaA02IdNI HLUS UMO BSSB YLZ pt x4- YYi�� -ptotmw Kine o a BOBS 'oN NOLLVZIHOHLOY d0 3LY��IiLLL37 OOSB iLZ L9S ,, o m old Ru B6Z VOBgIi q w ����9 ��i \ N q c pzq p 1 x'� Q N ��' p A -H lm -P -AN SixvsznsxoO WJNHNxo wm-ucrsaF��.uaMwn Se OJI U61S8(jQO-1!nU3 �% / J SuaHxiAJxH �� a ru MHOMIAW taro uj C* C14 J LL W N L g $ > Otu F F: = o < DAF fig ' ON CSL Jg i1�� _ -F i 0. p I cn . WV WI bI ` A -H lm -P -AN u s - uj C* C14 J LL W N L g $ > Otu F F: = o < DAF fig ' ON CSL Jg i1�� _ -F i 0. p I -I F -1 F . _ E o �� UJ E 3 - gill O N caN Ips J w�� II _ < W r " m I CD �� ��0 00Lu u rj O -I F -1 F  Ll X ,Jl `Ad 65:L5:Z 2106/5l/8 `6MP'11a b101 S Nl\b 101\M@IA aogJDH V �� S4O] gtNl\Z N\:0 ti � N �� CKI y r N ua AL ct o U CD a t) ,�� �� 2W �� aao�� a3 Q n < Pool 0 o  os x u H f9 z H Z �� II i Z 9162 z ��w :oo c4H i i 00 D m 3wa ail a q�� ��.s ;" ri:i �� >  �� : c nim . f zl- a n 4 d d r mo 8 mo Z dj 9 WF $ 1tiz-- _'raln wag 19 �� ��z J RE d Z F Q rc i F1 I lJ<, mi ee lag �� -4s _ J ti 00 ��" ��` f ���"  ��aI2i0'I3 `I��'��2I,LS ,3'In��J ���� .cz ass xo�� Dose �%cz ins ������ 7Y 'DIW Y H13COf Yfti�f oPVbLi '4-9 AdMO ��(oM ��vJ ��Id��4d BBZ ONO ^��N NOLLVZINOfLLlIV ��0 3LVOLiLLfm VUINOl! aAZH i��'Ha0 DI OzzT  fi ,LO'I ssxvsznsxo�� zv,tNaRxoxituta " s��taHxrOxa N �� z .�� s HsVss H Mein xo gxVx ��-,z,=; �� ��1 ��" ��,O '� ,�� u :xo3 sm��saa HOt��xa V LL- O rtinva ���� o ON cv ��B��Saao��l ��3 ��/>  LL X jL 'Md `bmFlla-- 1iM SbOZL\b 10-I\M@IA aogaoH S4o1 s'vOn\nMO \:0 N Ef Q �� > N `�� UJ0 Q�� O?�� W Q$ z�� o R �� a of z z ��I I I r II II �� U z S�� -L C _ dart' _Li I n 3��S aav  r ,S'B 1- ap U El MOO Ire s1rCo p�� b �� �� F SII x�� 4 I �IA �� a w��  oz ai F o, od lV W��W\ Z`1 W _ (73 <ri 1111 II I o z��5 W x =^ o0 - -I I 1 � W L � 5r, it y o _  11  Woao ��$ id �� p oil W rYSb K�� o= i o d��zoz' Q da J �� CNG w�� zn 0 z o zc pt xa z 3zo L ibD s��5 J �'" ��' f ��QI2I0'I,3 `NI����2i,LS 3'In`J else-r`z ass =-A Dose-rcz ass --4d 7'd '371Y 'tl HLSOf YYYf� OPWLi '43oag .(WIPO AWA avJ old��4d 86Z BOSO '��N NOLLVZIlIOHl(IV d0 31VOIiIlY�� YQINOlA QA'IH I��IVHOO Is OzzT  �� ,LO'I ssxvsznsxoO " rv,rxaNxoxinxa " su����xtOxH N A z �� c'��rr���� TT t-7 T r7 r77 ZT ��7��T��-77i wW ����sa��,.��a..��, 0 S��1iL Y ��L����R ARIA Q��QQ Y it u6Is0 6 o��nu�� �� �� �� �� lu :> ��w �� �� �� ��xo4 s��rvsaQ NHssxs 3isaas aaG PCI ��i " , a m �� -"  L[ X "LL `Wd 90 : bS :Z Z LOZ/S L/8 `bmP" ON3 SVN L\m31A aogaoH s401 -9 N L\Z N\ :0 > a a�� a U fi si N R! CD s m g ��HH W1 1 9 � N �� Es 07 ad ��.O k a W +a ��@, now ELM ��w ��Ln i 0 11 U a cj -. z- " " �v .Cwwa a' AI Ir�� f 6 10 O���� I +l (I I��'' 1 4. W HI M, ����c g 1 G P �� < 8 ���� En < ��2 gig��j ( c o 7t���� IT ��! E���� ����M ����a is I ��ss b asc s x.a x z ..ti cl d r d d n N ti v CO e�� I U)o 00 W caa J �� 3 w co lug w $ Ib w ZNil 52 z Oz LM oil, w . O z<��� m 1 N I I I ; rn I s s W in z -N z ' U Z I I II r-1 r, r, WRQ I WWI ZO 04 o 01 aw Q z $ a ��g s L d I a �� M11 g cn xb 1%���� >d�� X111 x ��, -��" :"'�� + �� ���" dQI2i0'I�� `I��1i��'��2I.LS 3'I11�� Esse rLz ABs ���� oosBiLZ LBS ���4d ..F tiYi�C oPlnLi '4��B L��+PO LoM o+aU' ��Id��4d 88Z G V DOBB " tt1 NOLinOHm L 'r" �� ,nN QAZH 1��id��00 Is OZ��i  �� ,LO'I s��s��ss�� ����in xos����x ��2I0,3 I1��+'Id AIOI,LI��I'.��IA'��2id I��IOI,LR'I'IOd YZBgHLm !0 3Lv��ua�� raluo�� �� o �� ���� x ,, �� �� s,txvsznsxo�� zv.LxaRx uB(seQo��(nu3 su��axi��x�� " �� > a a�� a U fi si N R! CD s m g ��HH W1 1 9 � N �� Es 07 ad ��.O k a W +a ��@, now ELM ��w ��Ln i 0 11 U a cj -. z- " " �v .Cwwa a' AI Ir�� f 6 10 O���� I +l (I I��'' 1 4. W HI M, ����c g 1 G P �� < 8 ���� En < ��2 gig��j ( c o 7t���� IT ��! E���� ����M ����a is I ��ss b asc s x.a x z ..ti cl d r d d n N ti v CO e�� I U)o 00 W caa J �� 3 w co lug w $ Ib w ZNil 52 z Oz LM oil, w . O z<��� m 1 N I I I ; rn I s s W in z -N z ' U Z I I II r-1 r, r, WRQ I WWI ZO 04 o 01 aw Q z $ a ��g s L d I a �� M11 g cn xb 1%���� >d�� X111 x ��, -��" :"'�� + �� ���" dQI2i0'I�� `I��1i��'��2I.LS 3'I11�� Esse rLz ABs ���� oosBiLZ LBS ���4d ..F tiYi�C oPlnLi '4��B L��+PO LoM o+aU' ��Id��4d 88Z G V DOBB " tt1 NOLinOHm L tu g �Sb£QRIO I `H3V38 AdN I3Q C w o a a w z $ {QI "'�3I1N�Ad H Lb flt1 S8 [ N -g ■ ■ W ® N3j.-1g 3QISd3SLo a ■ ■ v¢� a 7 S d Qi IS Xd330 'POZZI 5 > O RClUlH o4 —,j .. O20itd` QQ o of LU w a_ V W 0 W O J LLJZ /w V O 0 Z U U o�� I a=¢ i Boom �mO O ¢S..pmF l pqg w'F: MW O U F I a?p� O FF u i _2W >umm SymjpW I U � W oza <U i z�s<' m>O 1 oil❑: o� O_ mz ¢¢ULL ",, i Fa.0 oFia a ; s w w U3 O W O F m LJ Oz ° fq g o a ppg zU ¢o j5 �¢ €o v Fa <<_ j. ❑a ¢ �o❑ Ox Z Z � °< u zem �S i< o m FaZW �Z �❑ m❑ ❑ OW -w � 0 a i1 1 ❑W o3 r U 9 Z IW p w o OO w Z i5W 29 t03 On jm Oa OUW mF Wa0 ❑my � <U r W� J<oi w m Jkw 2Um ¢O m m of4w < x am aLL �z xa6 Wmx urs �z3 �¢ 1S$ m� ¢¢ OOW � O z appp•p•• N�� o vo i ❑ F� o o`d'o o ¢urc 00 ° is <��wNallo F � auw Y Hoa O U U o =Z. = zam =¢ Fp-¢ F*� -$¢p} Yp1 wjZ a2 Z p SZ Z F =Nm� F w Ww - g m K O «2 FF FF F � UZ, $ w Z zil Z.pZ ~ <� ❑ �O �w mlZ< ULLf U ON � ON O m KZ<F Zazo n "9f a F � wo 3 ga p �y�0 � k z o rz j SwF ❑ <� QVin c',❑, <o Zo ° �pp J� o pJ=aO < 2 << S O Z<2 UUu. pbp ¢� g¢OZ OR. <rx OwOZ¢ < 'w cif � °Z e y� �F �z � w� _�� �o o� ' rz� m ❑o❑ o �s �x5F <rc as rc x �Fo -m omLL� } xwaw < $'jaWUy a ooS aW �w? ° �� Zm ❑ f awp ap FF s F ¢ m 6 Www im 3 5�❑ ¢ UrcW� ❑� a❑ ¢4w pWU �x gamg❑ ❑ i 5 we Ru o3 o im o<LL�gg o f J> vo. o, j°m<aui �UF rca W i <�� ❑ o= o <ZJ~aio QQ Ow Z �2 < Oooww¢ ¢ So ze zwUF r<p ❑m �m, g U LL� U wwk0 i a 6�oe m ggW ��i haoLLLL� o`d¢a ww�p p w vpiarc rc 3Q r�i a<z? 0 0 waw 0 w mS 2 ¢¢< 1z' F� w "w �O FpS ° Nu �<Z�mmm � °J w p2¢ LL y m Z R..0 OZWp ! M1UZ U 2 OU W WOV FSS ww y❑ Zw Oa ❑a 2 fZ wFrWO ¢app ¢7 W F WjU j O Wm0❑U p Jz om oxo z_ �a wmm o3x �° ¢'< g9 �< �a rci 3 0<�<° waU? Up m O«d¢b 'u53zw a2 3m Q° mw om s2ia ¢Q9 m paa ;-Z, 'Z. .,¢cpim .? -Z. m = f Z O W rxO � Ix -z< w2. p<pw -,o go pw pK Np � yp Ft�pF� i m< U O g wU oo0a OF o o mpg o jF ¢KZw Op OU u. ¢�<'x �ym oa Z. -0 o° uom< Fw wF o¢ °vi uxi ova w�ao o g< m F;m 11 z .w so Fi Foo i� 6-'= g1 x� owW off' a o gg0. m uo o1.0 z- N p 2�R0- UL--- `� U�aW uui um UL -- a urrz ° 3 xi❑� 4 noo 6� .S Fwrx-cpi u� �w mow❑ w J , ¢ �a: i oowrc `o .Un o o anaU o� o-uA owi� u ow oa O Q LL O LL Z W w a Q z Z w ❑ U) J LL Q wLL J Z) 00 z ir U) C7 Q ❑ 0 LL IUi O aw LL O^ Z Z N Op W LL o U N U) J ao LL � LL Q za OZ ~ z W o O H o❑ N w 0 Mo LL N ❑ w C, w Y z_ Er EL z w a N 1- n TF a T U 0 O U Y W mQWU W H W m zU' z cn�w oQww LLI O LLn'v)m Z W J V w N � O w9 w A O O H U) M ULL-J, Cwl NO) Q w 0_ ULO N Uj 1 3 �- ® (A W �L--`j �y "' o P��j £Sb££ VQRIO 13 `HJV17 AViI IHQ v n d Z z < N■ b01 # 311N3At� H117 3AI S8 l = SI w SHACI ling flQISV3S $ _ '"L3 WVJI.I.S 3'IfID 'QA'Ig NVFIOO 'N OZZ I s "z S3.I.VIS3 HfIODUVH KACIGIH o A o a 4 V 1 LL- cli N E ® oU. W �- (v O ui — og > "' ` 1 3 �- ® (A W �L--`j O ~J W v oCD d Z u RNVW)n O O J I I a M Pi .Z5 .f5 \ 3 —�— ,-- ---------------------- I I I it -------------------------J I I iI I I I i� I I I I I i I I I i 'I I M s. ZDpa Ji r s pa1**--z o -F� Cl tf e o £8V££ VQRIO'13 `HDVafi AV -S -13a a x - O a 170t# anN3AV H.LV aN S8I I 'g - 00 ■ ■ x SdFluIHnElaQISVEIS q = w Q w 2S! _ z m F. 1 u ■ ■ a I3 Y�IVHN.I.S I(1�J *CIAIH I�Id33O 'A[ OZZl R � k o o O m' o t, 101- Sa.LVISa xnosxVH HaaalH �� © w o N -i w o a > Z W ® ° 3I -Wo o °LL. a z Q ® I I I WCaN E >o N U Lij vo C:) C: 4 8 £84££ VQRIO'IA `HOVHg A 1�Q o a �33e coo z ■ v < � g roe# anr>anv Heti art 1! Q ° N LL SiI�Q IInH 3QISVH a O m m UJ E 1 ■ ■ a` "13 Y4IV3N.I.S IfI9'QA Ifl M)MO nzz& 1.1.1 U a w a a a V ,LO'T- SaLvlsa xnowdvuluG�W o f A Q a 91 o C) le ?' It It 1' 51 0 0 N W W Cd w N� x0 11 1111, o z I I I I S 0 0 0 0 k1l I 0 0 1111 11111' C) WO � 5 ca 7 It It It 1. ?' It It 1' 51 0 0 N W W Cd w N� x0 11 1111, o z I I I I S 0 0 0 0 k1l I 0 0 1111 11111' 0 ani W 0 cn I �Ft SF 4 It p 1,4 C-' J It 0 ani W 0 cn I �Ft SF 4 It p 1,4 C-' J uJi vauoou✓n� Maui✓�ttn✓ov �✓rrur uavn✓�a ✓u irv.r,anu✓ n�iira.v »>ao_v svi t�runun a✓i�u�i vnn nau� nnv rvi n r rv✓rnovar u.�_� uirr au u.uai✓ u�✓r ruuaa�a x nvn rruai vnou�rv� au �nJv»u �rvv ro »mi �u Iavo tnv u.vrr¢a��o r �v ✓in✓ra r ry u�i vauaau✓rrr �rn ri✓�i�n✓av »rvur uavn✓ra na trot �t�a. inuu✓ p -A 4an .i. C> -AIL r s pates o r cr a o £8b££ VQRIO'13 `HOVHG AVd-MU < - VOW HfINHAV HlV HN 981 ■■ "r S-dFlu IIf18 HaISV9s O N a O00> H 1 ■ ■ a -V s 3�no Qn tg I1Va�o ozz < xr�$ a Qr� v�_ g °� 0a� a ¢ o> V .1.07- mvises 2InOH-dVH NHGUIH o O o E 09 4U a W oco LU 0 OU WIt LU egI t# 9 4-4 0 0 J � $e s < 0 z ; z 0 o 0 0 . rl W 0 Ml 0 dpi Q M Es L GVON HIVARid I QVO I - - T� _ J , J_ cA 3 W w� Uw Z LL CL ZIL J Z Zw q =Q U� �Q w U� J � }z zw >w Y� U14 N 0cn IQ L Asti �C ������ _o �Fl a Ila 4-d �L� m CO W 1 N c 1 W CO) je Cb W N !L2 z� lu o oco z U. CL a L Asti II . �11)) o �Fl a Ila > m CO c 1 41 ` J U v 0 L T N P N 1 � A A . !1X cl W o ca N C) .40 c CD 0 '1Q (nC)�� Q �oaoW Wcl� cn r^ 0 w� a cl � Q �zQw� L'i CC LJJ Id OQz O�vly Q� cn O �Ox- CzLno'�� cnI4rn Q z Qoo� Z�LZ Rzz Q C5 LLj z z3,m Q � Q Q I y �W t"A g 4�g 6 Q o, vi 4��QtV,� 3 "y�jq U L ONiti� 2 LO (n z y W z e .w� qq �� LU W^ 2 3 a 0 0 ClQ ® Cj ISLU 05 4 Qr, 2: 3F. ui �eL Ij no e .w� qq �� W^ 2 3 a � p 164, k>€� �eL Ij Q 0 Z ®LL _E - wCo C14 CD LLQ CD W = Q ®W }5 S Qf It Co Q�� T;I HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES LOT -4 N c7 Soothing White > h J � > 3 m WALLS TRIM SHUTTERS ► RECEIVED, AUG 2 3 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL G i►Q1 — •v fyl - r 4 .I y {{ a I I AN 014i IL 40 It 1% lk tA Alk NO .71 4i ._..,,.�..........„...r..........,.,..,a—..�:.,.v_'--�.�.o. � ....�.....,.,.._,..-•••.rat="^—'--"----..,. .r-.__..+`ea"7F ...�...•ls 1.+- +"•a...- � •».+. a d. ' - ,►,�91�" r..,� ,ys11�y, ; � r-ey�'s' � .• � .� ij,it �ii��.� ,afiP ibe • rt y ' X R" H �J. .- ._ �.. .W+fA.: , •.t �k • .Irk/' (� t . i ,,Cs i •••e,.�r �b �-:f 4 ^ y: �l - 1 L Ike� a • ow col . t7_ *il Fd t ^!:.• a _„ a v 4! , ,�t ..►' 4 a. . js ,� '� -a• . , 9 ;� ., � ,ice., .' , _ .� �`� 7 � ��� y,• a,, � - �+ r . / .• -arm .? r 4 ��iiiexw►• 1 ! .{ Ri....'"WL f o � `a tiw � � _ b+r. ,ar .. ..,, 1• t Y �'`-� �+ { F ..111 � � l A .. • 0011, AV v 1• ��t�t is �"', =��1as •rr,a �, M4 vv 121,4 •t A • {r Y ii! ,�y 4 ` ' � s .:.,.moi lk r^ �. �;> ..]111iFFR_^.•• Ir♦ff ��p ♦ .�71� 12 .. r ., A SIA � �' "� 3g,�~x•~'`11,. 1. `; '' � i � '►`�0 4yyy. •� .; i �w , • . , ,� L•� 1 i' r r� r`1� � �' -• i. \ ..,til Ma :•� - r � .Ilan"•Ali- 1 ' h �• ���� w . ,....1s.: Y . ` m , Wiia QA AD Js r Jii N V�/ i S� • I .y ,i Y + r ... 7R :•.� qI• t OF ' ,r •',�,k � � ` �, a �; a►� �r, �a "f! �a ! '� If , a ,e. - '^/ � •�. ,. � ' � 4+11 nI f.�1`,� °\�. -If :. � ,,,, fit; � f � �, • •, , 4 f 1TI t 3 y 7 - Y +� 'tet w �"•Si � fit.`.. , •. .. t,... _ � � *. .. • e+ �► • a � ..,. ' y � � "f.''� W'lay,,i�•"'�. 'X•�rw• _ �+�....yra_ryyr..,.,..a<+r..yR �+-M.:.-�wrt.+'+ .i rvCi.sa J •��, ` �.. ' ! t r< it •!� � 6 � S•� �L'--�1#fr• �, Ax �' .._}/�, A �° � ".< M, f =� �•� r °.A rid S Y ,�F �\ � � R �Ye. art '�'.♦, '.� J K� ; Y' • r wpm • z �� �• � �� w `� �� , �.:, 4 � � �; .N 1 , ' � � irk e` .-' r "•.si.{R` fi' - w �✓ti.1L�„. - _ a✓ r•�re, ,� - S 77 46. w -mow .. i IF• iTr T7, 1't 'PR ♦ a� - - Y1i aN. 44 =1 •.. l rrr;�/ s 'i�� ,.dam �..1i •� �•. �..♦ !•A .Y 10 . 'Irk 7^' TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-12 Address: 1224 North Ocean Blvd Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Richard Jones Architect Construction of a partial two story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit: To permit the installation of landscaping and easterly part of a privacy wall within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling, a 3 car attached garage, pool and cabana, a total of 8,726 SF. Gross Lot size: 30,962 SF Effective Lot Area: 30,962 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 8,790 SF Allowable: 8,792 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Finished Floor: 14.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Height: 30' (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlav District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval of a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit based on a finding that the landscaping and easterly portion of a privacy wall meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling, a 3 car attached garage, pool and cabana, a total of 8,726 SF meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB*File #013-12 ARPB July 25, 2013; TC August 9, 2013 Page 2 1. The entry feature, measured from FFE to top of railings, shall be <_ 14'. 2. The electric service lines shall be buried. 3. A sample of the gray color roof file to be provided for approval. 4. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 5. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 6. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view ARPB Date: July 25, 2013 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Recommend approval as requested (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested with the above 6 conditions. (5-0) TC Date: August 9, 2013 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as recommended with the above 6 conditions. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM 14,�. . ® RECEIVE " .1. JUN 17 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File I# =: -. J To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name:f/�/Yl VU V I.A.2. Project Address: I�V, "f . o v I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: fho JfArho r I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) I tv /je � lv I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: Ci ' 1.A.6. Check all that apply:Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete sec ion B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.:no am1wi— B. Type of Foundation: Owner Information Q I.B.1. Owner Address: O 0 t �J y aw 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number: T(J5 6/e ? ��_ Fax: J5 7" 1.B.3. Owner Signature:/�-0—fe - C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: %© I I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: 7Y` 7N. 4 cell -Z7 Fax 1. C.4. Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: 4 4)7.J- 1217 k -7 -z4 -i.3 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located?��%� III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? P(Yes ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? XYes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? J - K -03S I ew, e. f. Howta)re' the foll Stormwater D Sanitary SeWE Potable Water Irrigation WatE Electricity Telephone Gas Cable Television ow/ g is'Co 1 e r vide' d t( the loertv? III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART MIV: FZSRMAT* K Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 4 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV -A-2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes No (if "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes )Q No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes .K No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes 0t\1 No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Strearn B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? vo, nim IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the Al Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What.mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the IeasTirfipacf possible to The visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? I V A IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? 841 A D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: A# ft IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? A // ,,,, IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E: Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E.1. Is the proposed use a Permitted special exception use? []Yes IV -E.2. How is the use �No Code Section: designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the welfare, and morals will be protected? A (I public health, safety, IV,E,3. Will the use cause substantial in'u other Property be located? [I Yes 1 rY to the value of /n❑ No yin the neighborhood where it is to Explain. IN I I A-- IV.E,4• How will the use be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where ' g f � it IV.E.5,—�- What landscaping and screening are provided? h 1I A IV -E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations overni 9 ng the District wherein it is to be located? []Yes El No Explain. A V I A- F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the N( 14 y are to be maintained. IV -F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts o Properties. K 1 1 in n surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading Spaces: Standard ParkingSpaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 Town, of Gulf Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? I IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV -G.3. What is proposed? IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? IV -G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the Ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? A / 1 (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or struqture? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No I / .; Explain: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 OT c;ulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site?` IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, please describe the need and justification for the request, IN I I A PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants, q ouragedbut Applicants are enc, not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere o the other materials submitted with the application. n this form or on any of Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 L kn w C� Of W SW L V U) W 0 U � �-d N $g❑ u z z � ¢ u ❑ O ❑w ¢.6 cP ¢ i QQ EE i El�, p 0 O QQ UUU N � o w p o p w, z U O uUZI U p LL ❑ o wUp w ° ¢ a m ❑ ❑ N g g ' n- 0 w w F a oazw w w I ❑ o a,o ❑ _Z e ¢a ❑ a ¢u F 3 az w� F o o zi �wi w _i 2w - o u LL �a� 3 og N m< W W q jQm ? 'Z p z Q Z Z F<F O QWm ❑ %o o❑ T. ozo 20 zZiww �� ❑ a p ¢ w �' g O u OZgo �' zO0 U W W c fa0i Nw ¢ ¢ � i`. t.; a� Z Umfl ¢ F -N U Fa < O<i ¢ U o i u 10 FS HI o $ �Y g� 8 g3 ¢ $ 0 o o� dos= o w L o o, csi o aw joz f� oQ z WO o Zr w �5" o .N F eU � p o- �oc¢ii uwz o oho Na ww S o i a a.-,6Nk x °mow❑ �W�saW, W ❑ oQw ara z� z< LL o o �N , oaa�rc w '¢a �o�u >� g❑ u� aa�° mz wF� 3a m w$ w ao¢ ❑ oawm o w0. ow erc NW z o <�< ❑W F ^"Z. ° 3� Sa a & u i Z. o rcww -i eoo wi Z ow .F�w ww ❑ ❑ro ~� _� �a r o� o�o� ii w �wz1 j r. za- .-m 20 wp F. ? -Z' W O zr<m m �u Wym �� w<❑ 4 ow N z> m i� woWi o we omwu;❑ 4�^W o rc .0 i i a^ Jkw �i � ow"� a� ¢o w �¢ m U= O N ¢O ¢F ¢ r ¢2 w 1 -ow o z $ ou o ow oo�0 iaw~ o <9 'z ix m e0.�4 w 1. F. v ow v ga ❑� , ~02 m0 oxg b yWW F -. Q-¢ ¢JFK Z O° Za O �� O(7 O Um Ow¢� p> U j OQOn g °K p. UW. =w OZ U w UFtc d❑ UW ap w o p�p� o z x¢ rW �i�¢ �w r i o?x3 s TUF $Su- '$'w $ �- ^� 80 ❑x 'mug° 0 1O No 0 3❑c of o� oo `oma oo N� oN o i W 2 W F U Al O v O N U y� mw tea± W m0 UW �O Y UV�NF Pe W�3 0 _2I -. n� wy 1F€ �y¢o� °u oW dor H oP wr; u'1 X14 p Jo 0 y Fa Sf w m° � �� ���w� Z ❑ g o. o wo k o 0 2 at" �° am az o ip❑E$ i WW Gm ¢lo` o�QQ"� o o W U< ° UL 412 F¢ t_O U N5~ ~~ zWg� 1 a� Zo °wOwo 42<W w0 a Is _z ugh ^ pQ 0o o yF wx5 cF a riw �a a¢.au <m ¢om w� Fw nzLL _rcaw4°i of m w z- 5' r 3°0 ���`g q❑ awes > o W w ¢w x o _; Opo m rcs mW JU oz JU 30 �xi 3 w�¢ 5 LLgamd o � ❑ �m a� u �w pip Z 3 ¢m p ° w'S OFw �0 fzwuari�3 !i oho 0 b s u' -0 °O= ZwF zf <� U p j O Z❑ a2 Z mwK ¢H O<ja OZ Of -W+m� j0 waQQZ Fap-m ww �¢ p - Z b 6¢ Z w 0 aoo w wo$ wo-Q ww xo -10 oqg 90 zom'oo om a n; t,.: 10 ai !0 1- Z rcarc ¢off o�fgi you f �� ��u� �i xa 3� mem u� oLLswi=m mya rc � '-Z ow oa f aag a F wu-.0 H. A uW,>;!-2= i ozo< .° .Y 0-- � W a� m x j3 y �w �o ,' w400 �s 101, 1 02z °� 00 UwFOF V� U° ip0 Vy¢r Ur OW2N�� 700 �� �F¢ �=❑oa oa ro ioow i � fw� � N¢ eu mini w� w �o uua w o F� o'a< �0 o°o 6.. o.i ow on G��a 0 us< 'du z w 0 rn W lY LL it � o 00 Z m (7 0 w LY w J Y Z a z z 1 w ELH 0 W W CL OJ 0 z W Q ❑ D w U) x O �J U o Z W N �m x � U Y x Y W � W m ,n w La O W 9 O LL lY U7 m 0 0 O m a ~ 0 £8h££ ti I3 `LU J70 # HA_H��,d38 J�V2I I3Q irn m ne st+ Q Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W Q■■ b Wg A'-- el73WH3NLS3IlQrlbZZl o�®�Rg " God o J Y QQIH ❑> � � S u 4❑ a r- N > z U 00 L kn w C� Of W SW L V U) W 0 U � �-d N $g❑ u z z � ¢ u ❑ O ❑w ¢.6 cP ¢ i QQ EE i El�, p 0 O QQ UUU N � o w p o p w, z U O uUZI U p LL ❑ o wUp w ° ¢ a m ❑ ❑ N g g ' n- 0 w w F a oazw w w I ❑ o a,o ❑ _Z e ¢a ❑ a ¢u F 3 az w� F o o zi �wi w _i 2w - o u LL �a� 3 og N m< W W q jQm ? 'Z p z Q Z Z F<F O QWm ❑ %o o❑ T. ozo 20 zZiww �� ❑ a p ¢ w �' g O u OZgo �' zO0 U W W c fa0i Nw ¢ ¢ � i`. t.; a� Z Umfl ¢ F -N U Fa < O<i ¢ U o i u 10 FS HI o $ �Y g� 8 g3 ¢ $ 0 o o� dos= o w L o o, csi o aw joz f� oQ z WO o Zr w �5" o .N F eU � p o- �oc¢ii uwz o oho Na ww S o i a a.-,6Nk x °mow❑ �W�saW, W ❑ oQw ara z� z< LL o o �N , oaa�rc w '¢a �o�u >� g❑ u� aa�° mz wF� 3a m w$ w ao¢ ❑ oawm o w0. ow erc NW z o <�< ❑W F ^"Z. ° 3� Sa a & u i Z. o rcww -i eoo wi Z ow .F�w ww ❑ ❑ro ~� _� �a r o� o�o� ii w �wz1 j r. za- .-m 20 wp F. ? -Z' W O zr<m m �u Wym �� w<❑ 4 ow N z> m i� woWi o we omwu;❑ 4�^W o rc .0 i i a^ Jkw �i � ow"� a� ¢o w �¢ m U= O N ¢O ¢F ¢ r ¢2 w 1 -ow o z $ ou o ow oo�0 iaw~ o <9 'z ix m e0.�4 w 1. F. v ow v ga ❑� , ~02 m0 oxg b yWW F -. Q-¢ ¢JFK Z O° Za O �� O(7 O Um Ow¢� p> U j OQOn g °K p. UW. =w OZ U w UFtc d❑ UW ap w o p�p� o z x¢ rW �i�¢ �w r i o?x3 s TUF $Su- '$'w $ �- ^� 80 ❑x 'mug° 0 1O No 0 3❑c of o� oo `oma oo N� oN o i W 2 W F U Al O v O N U y� mw tea± W m0 UW �O Y UV�NF Pe W�3 0 _2I -. n� wy 1F€ �y¢o� °u oW dor H oP wr; u'1 X14 p Jo 0 y Fa Sf w m° � �� ���w� Z ❑ g o. o wo k o 0 2 at" �° am az o ip❑E$ i WW Gm ¢lo` o�QQ"� o o W U< ° UL 412 F¢ t_O U N5~ ~~ zWg� 1 a� Zo °wOwo 42<W w0 a Is _z ugh ^ pQ 0o o yF wx5 cF a riw �a a¢.au <m ¢om w� Fw nzLL _rcaw4°i of m w z- 5' r 3°0 ���`g q❑ awes > o W w ¢w x o _; Opo m rcs mW JU oz JU 30 �xi 3 w�¢ 5 LLgamd o � ❑ �m a� u �w pip Z 3 ¢m p ° w'S OFw �0 fzwuari�3 !i oho 0 b s u' -0 °O= ZwF zf <� U p j O Z❑ a2 Z mwK ¢H O<ja OZ Of -W+m� j0 waQQZ Fap-m ww �¢ p - Z b 6¢ Z w 0 aoo w wo$ wo-Q ww xo -10 oqg 90 zom'oo om a n; t,.: 10 ai !0 1- Z rcarc ¢off o�fgi you f �� ��u� �i xa 3� mem u� oLLswi=m mya rc � '-Z ow oa f aag a F wu-.0 H. A uW,>;!-2= i ozo< .° .Y 0-- � W a� m x j3 y �w �o ,' w400 �s 101, 1 02z °� 00 UwFOF V� U° ip0 Vy¢r Ur OW2N�� 700 �� �F¢ �=❑oa oa ro ioow i � fw� � N¢ eu mini w� w �o uua w o F� o'a< �0 o°o 6.. o.i ow on G��a 0 us< 'du z w 0 rn W lY LL it � o 00 Z m (7 0 w LY w J Y Z a z z 1 w ELH 0 W W CL OJ 0 z W Q ❑ D w U) x O �J U o Z W N �m x � U Y x Y W � W m ,n w La O W 9 O LL lY U7 m 0 0 O m a ~ 3:vW(" Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W H wLM)- OJQF—w D Ta m Q z J Y �= UN 050 F- U m 00 W Z (7 U 2 O in m W a W Z O j 0 W (ii rn 0 U) 0z g 0 go) ❑ a w z W w 0 0 O Z J w a (07 } F U m w W O w N Ir W 0.0 Vw W Z2 V �a 74 U z W LO =Z) v U W M M W Q O 6 O Q w L Q r p Z D~Z c gU)0 m 0cr O �-1 Z W m a- J F- W o W L 0 W 3:vW(" Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W Z wLM)- OJQF—w W Ta m Q z J wWr0a- Z Q EL J U ap W W UN 050 F- Z W J V W N O d.W,' U�.tOz W M Q m U)M W _i 0 N W =Z) 3 2f d. Q Z = i 0 N W U wQwFYZ20 of LLJN JLL 2 W C,6OUQF- U R O Cl) O_ (M7 CP of � 0 N W W — 1� � J w C� W J caLO O H QZ O tY' LLI w Wm a COz>-W OD LU �JF- W 0 �% � o g �817�� HQMO ` HII, Av Ilt1, H.Lb HN S8 81 l e b0 [ # HH S �� 4 a a Ef W Q+, ca c c L W N C5 W 4Y Q. L. "M WVAHIS JIM9 'Q QS ORD bZZi -j- SHIVISH NH s a �% �% x r $ a`. < i - z z o S LO ��ooa Do�� w a _ -0 Ef W Q+, ca c l �� L W N C5 W z o 3 pa",*an 'I. �:DFa'IL T H �:5`4a -wvr s pat --z O t� Q-�I�H Z:)I�I g Q ■ ■ cy � x,� ® £817££ dQRO'13 `HDd98 Ad2C13Q bol# af d FIN 98 Si3Qlifl8 3UISVHS a teP..m a v OO ■ ■ m i `a. $ " k` o C �-^^ z a' O a "Id WVMUS . TID 'QAlEl WFIDO N bZZI a S91VISFI -dAOfl2IdH N3C[CIIH o ? V• w U 0 60 0 cd a O O w ,-O O v N Vl a , e LU ai o 0 60 0 cd a O O w ,-O O v N Vl a , e L a 0 U 0 oo W -1 E RMZ d d N � N o a 0 U 0 oo W -1 u�u vauoou�rv� �oru�.ra.n�ov Amur uavn�.o �v urru�rvu� rv�u.o.� »>oon> >..i i.runa.n o�.�u�i vnn nou.� nnv na + . rv��nava� u�_. uan or u�. our u»nuuoa�o �a nvry .vu.a vnoumr au �n�.��u �.ry ra »>ni �u lovo un u�i�oa»o . ry �an�ro ..v u�i vauoou�nr �o.u��lrn�ov �urvu. uovn��o na crcc Maio. vnau� O � an'IL Z,>pa.L T H �::is PET t.,z0-r Q-�I�H �I�I „ ■ ■ u £84££ VaINO `HOt Hg 98 bOl# 3f1N�FI .Lb AV H3NN S81 N � ^ g v a oLn � ua S w ® S-dHo'IIf]H flQISVHS ® '"L3 YWHILLS d'IfIJ 'QA'Ifl NVHDO 'N bZZ l -1- ■ ■ ¢ m a a o 'j' w > S JO SMLV.LSH 2IfIOUNVH NHQQIH uc❑a r� lL 9 a 4-40 0 60 0. 0 Q� r-� W W Cd Cd a ti O 00'009: L aleDS -- Ml 6E.'E0 -- ClOe 190 -- PX69107 tEO-06WXcOlOOVO 7Vd73N301 S6upliVJG O m J votes, O w7 lu cc Aw m J votes, O w7 LL - UJ cu > ® VD C-4 VD co Lu LU A Vol o L C 7-0 V O J / /_ bIb CTbO� 31b1S .0.0 a N N N V• Z�sOcn 5� uuu�uu��9 .pY .Y �Utl rivYry ppQm3Q6n9m0m'I oo®smoammmm� Vt Q EE € _ tlf U'0mU0-UU an a-- na- as Su m4u�mAumw in mpaO aOwmUmamm ��m�Rgg�NyNN ��L=CC�mmmmmm l � A 0 -• JI � jr tl 41 L U U 41 L a 9 Uva m p L u�u` ®44444 V U- W CYa E > o Ca Cel u. cu -CD °O ~- O LU —� o ® f -- m k g a k k= 4 g° : B s ¢u j a9 k „n a2 nn aI 2 a g^ 9r 9 m to ° a8a.s?p;P� 9LL 6p g_ 3gbe� y�5��q�s�! Y bi a`k S� 34 a g3 on ¢5 3a C Ao 1v aS Lua°8 ;-,f. N„ . I „ Y Y Q - I . m „ . m tl „ , ° s „ Q „ 4 4= 4$ e 4 s u° m- -a° ad QR kit Is J a c X35 $a • v "� Xi v v U V! Y 9 °2)" l 0 o 41 D 0 o m °�N # s o� V• Z�sOcn 5� uuu�uu��9 .pY .Y �Utl rivYry ppQm3Q6n9m0m'I oo®smoammmm� Vt Q EE € _ tlf U'0mU0-UU an a-- na- as Su m4u�mAumw in mpaO aOwmUmamm ��m�Rgg�NyNN ��L=CC�mmmmmm l � A 0 -• JI � jr tl 41 L U U 41 L a 9 Uva m p L u�u` ®44444 V U- W CYa E > o Ca Cel u. cu -CD °O ~- O LU —� o ® f -- m k g a k k= 4 g° : B s ¢u j a9 k „n a2 nn aI 2 a g^ 9r 9 m to ° a8a.s?p;P� 9LL 6p g_ 3gbe� y�5��q�s�! Y bi a`k S� 34 a g3 on ¢5 3a C Ao 1v aS Lua°8 ;-,f. N„ . I „ Y Y Q - I . m „ . m tl „ , ° s „ Q „ 4 4= 4$ e 4 s u° m- -a° ad QR kit Is J a c X35 $a \EIM §E!,\}o 1. §§}±. - f g \� :c¥ . `2 ]§ \\ ■ $ 20 ` m C la | - t *kms ----- ------}----2 LCo § | L-- /� , � ---- \EIM §E!,\}o 1. §§}±. - f g \� :c¥ . `2 ]§ \\ ■ $ 20 ` m C la | - t LCo § , ® L , � 3 � 0. � d � � }�{ }i � t|! { ! f ! f � -4 m LL 0() W\ IE h 9 LU N 9L0 0 W +ice II uan O O u^ m r_ I s a� O+.' O 11 L v w > a m _ 1 � a o° i o L u, t N W NAA 19U0U 444444 `� �c ® ®y to, C-1 SON ER va W M L CO r/ U E 0 L 7 ' 13 u U 0 W 0 p h' t La L co .0 0 p ¢ �Phil �:�4#ay1raipL u !1!€ -1 21' SFS tra 1, € p pP -FSBagrtE,$�Eaga8;ad���o y9 eDwa fi$§si33$a a 1pgW F 4{§ .@� �'-�� �z s 6a s � yy° �hg5�1� 19 $BF4 a. .? E $ 93� §4 EF.. a F isda io Va;3 �eyE spy pg =ac lafi6$4?Pgs §85s ;Ei ;�a89 a$� lase a:�$aaYa$a a$ !P$� SI > °q;a 3F: 6° 2Eg a' �aaJS Fk $appp I I a., 9"a g yafE' 1 t5 si �a9` p'_e:a °�AB1 aF �ka8 ss �o?$.s sm9:�n9 a§a -$fig= P papa s l"$ as s`z 3'• Y Y sy 4. sF3F of X783 �13 u.38Pa 53 �55 it �•[� ;_ u d Y n �S Ij' $— e�f fib $$ i?Efi 3 g'$$y 2g ;ytry s� }9a 6 ' �= a s P s sa E ;baa s Ya t ys ?a $ �6�y ° aa_. g_ �yy ?3a R aim �� gr 9 � ` off an 5 la 9; �� t���� fi.�E�E;s � � Ea�E a�g �€�S � °� y� � a ea$ i =a 4 a �;; 132 ;?k aE .4 b i' li gi i° _� € a E 6p, �j8!$1 i1�y E d � Ni.]. %3Sy E 7 �!1 �Gg61 a : mB • 1` ���fi Sig 89 `oo e ro : 3a 3•II. A & $ 8s5, a=E s ,$A;P k 5y E$ i Y g E4F 911 a k 1 fib ° �.a a ye a3a o $i 9§s` s sBa=g kro °o 31291 .3i _� Y k s - i s=t Bfi5�e b s By 1- $�9.. fid' �'° s § : S � ,. �i',� 8 $ $3 P 'Y Q � .e 13 3E`y� a $ $•: i3 zBt�yA i FBF ai a�;5� Y as s'I baa n E a s° ➢j� 9u P=A3e _ Y 3Y "a gala. to tr =$ro ds oaf d� a 4%3 rt _ _ zs3AN $®!� 6 d 6 U d W i 4 d U d u MM$�3�� B Y,tahvi„a $ $?a';i a a$= E gy a�,:=`E E'. a= 5 •B 3mBF3tr $ l a sg i fie SF =yg$ II i `,p S PB=$;pq as Y a Y 3e $ it 3; i ,I 8 a a a 4 , R e5i1 •6 gE �2rtp°4_' g'3 63 d �5 c$ a$ z•a - C H Boy mm $6 ° $__ ,➢?3 "bill- s 8 eap Y $a g 1's ;aa - 5 3` .ay3 - s 3la;zs. E=gz4€s• °$ Y: 3w. E d aay3 1'Egl S t o 8 i�95 w A 1 i a.i ILME lea �8s , 4 1saa; ySP6.j 8 i= 6 .455 a 211� ?:;A ,.E w �:_ � 8 8� `s :3�� - ;5•$s8 P: 3 g u n E-. �� �� d8a .3���, 3� n8 gt8 fro -�'� � � e �h 3 $_ $3.� §� �!! §. ,�8� 6 8a• S� ;-;-, P 8 P �' ,P,.T ; P=E 8 r i 9� e8 a E sgpal B a3'$ s 39�� 3 �- € E �EB� � 4 3�p#`WB$B��:Bs`. i•F F P E � sS tys, � � 8l m -!aa R i B ?- �a a $8s ga ayi a. Rnak�PB B? rt�243a ?a �d1 #a ' a& Alt 8a 3• �E ! gs i d f 4 d d U seB$'s 3B = 33 !-` 9131 �$ �aaa 6•'�1 ;a tY88 a a Jilt .i!ol 298 :a :§ Ffi P S n _aE• _ y a� a9h E •�s 41 of pp6• 15 §a §§ii B 19:y y a9Eiaa3 �gy�� �2Y m:l°3aan a$S 4 3EL� P All,E y• Ey ' Es yi y=y e$ $;j 63 ! jd•; b Mpi y82B ji9!$ t a°y asp �Ee a;5 a�5�agg=9g3�ay $5�a=1r i3y€$;ki" P B P =Ys -t Jr pa;3rt 3-a=B is F Ep�SUpn"Pa. E=71a9 Cog& &� S ae s 8a d �� !gB�.yI 63i,sp 7B7 s �! _� 9�3J 3 tr x�63Ea$,p8; 3�P�ns €65a4��6��3i k3 trn•: k 8-i'� � n^"; :1•i���i ,_8� �: v 3 B'8 =n8° apQa F'S ao$§ �$ na§`karo=t� a ;d y�Em'3 !S'3•l;y 8saa g;Ee�E -121E F ai_. - NIP. - d'§gki3' 6 Rg�6�yq�trj•a�'FyF��5i §�3Yk $PliE$ �� F 64 e1�ro 3� 4L;.�$$$a 1 . sai¢6 S� �s-§Bcay3d S Eh. � 3�� fi °8J�; � g ��• zh I?a96�QsgAMU ��$� ��Ea$ � 1 it HA �a g� at rtA a s3'-_ E -yyF 1i 8�2 1$� s B 4 3 a5S M 112 • ; 4b 53aE�9EY 3a9� ' �� p - § 8a --P1 9i3. jEva 1$ 9191P11 -B j! Y ail E 21 i¢ his J11i lid ie3 ;p a1$-Iik- >ss 3 Ra�¢4 l y8 4aa$l3 3 a$ E ,y ass fi9s 3 jjli3 3.,36 ail 3E S 3 ChZR9 $09a2�aS 3` $Asa 8 - _ $ _ E •�S7ni3 $a aaB1 aa6�, -trot u d A d d d U d W k 34h �Etr3 a3zE �: _U B1Pgfx lE IES _ i-6 P3; . � 8 i ' II F' iAb °et� Bc8` 3't n� s 111HP All ,$i1s,d� � ��aa 3 B&ay3$ 6,tr 83 n 9$' P-15 F i8 l Hit 5i1 5 ? � .2 5Y2a a%af E_§ 3 = 1111 �7:a�m l9sa AM �flffl<F 5 �Tj7 3 z d d U 0 3 d gill @11RI - $VISE - qyl -$ IUDnD NO 8 'a• �au 21,912 ? k§ E a m m h B $ � yy B pa r s B $a; ,IRI 3a maB 3a fir: p§ 31�a E :ld8 y5�Wit � 9F� _1 j� EE! ;�ir�, k ;i¢i', 214ap" til a � 5 ••� 2•E�all Ea � E rt gal W-111 1,01-11'a It f 4 y�n $ ? HIM,, �� �yro as A M d �'�5� 3a d15_S d�= Ca?Pa, a3 a �d- 'i3y o.Y M. ±°Itr_ d w � Pt - ��i� P a9`o! 5 y MIN? B ; g ds8 �.J§•' -�k� qtr: 3 � $:� Ss� �8 a PaE $ § a $ � 111, 93;a lZ3sgg�s jilt 5 3 HUM g 1 p��r aIDjfin$$$idW�a$i &�p2ailYas§_kA? e B 5 $$ 6E °E 9 tr E 3jd 3 -�vip a $s- g$ J� N 3 `�a i2 -g #s €t Y 4B a Baa tr $s;� dgB E a �& a aE.sf §6Ea 1 39 :• $ as 3Em $Fa i n§ �_3 d $!- pa 6 s°• a 2= BELIr sy= �t$��i ll JUL?a: :, a § ! Eag.01 �.$ c ➢oma i�ia� 848' y eaa3 fie! 3 a 3 PbT ��tr 9 B' a I .Er" P. 8 yra, 875 X98`' � §§fi2: $.- 8 4 95 trniB5 Sn1 P sE�$ aa��3pe�� � �n a4 ��� �.� Eat �-"��$$� ���'a=$ a�z�; Y$ '$' '$ '� ��➢ � EE'g�y$=g�8��' EP s��•�aAq ¢°�$�-p�d� F E IIs'= a 1 B§B'4_ ig F! e'2 E i rt �a § �i8o 8 8� fi 8'"�r It kid I 93-g� E1:uf, Es 5 $ y 3� n$ ET $1 13 Q a_. ,'$s$. 5P aFgla'�' --'fi Ey =a f iE a $�93^. a$. ' i a3=�. as as =1 sd�'=,a y $$$$ 3E{fi' E3 io a E $ Ee 'g8; 8T1 �➢ 5;aaA- a�oa ;� a= _� :�..�3 �3� �a� &Bsi; & §'x� -P Ez sn roma i a P^'i1 AII YP_E3-•E$ fig` !B 3 F1 a �3 y dE §'y E : 1- i y1� Bs35 �_" i 9 R° i s1 1a �6y §_ a• fiaEL 5�g:,.a fir• § 6't Y75 fi !3F a 2 a8�ada! �iaa�� , u s 3u4,� �� i roEf'tA adi aEEE < $ L tlx: =tr: m$ 3 z$�B�E 3't 8a $33 d9 Y$& g ��I1�--.�68 M _�$8!a$s� k u a d d u 4 0 8 14 !$ p3 I TIM aBp aro$ $`off- Bila:aP!�'a' W y R $ l a § B 1 =!:$a$: g f' 1p$ a Eby aeuaaaaass9 fis F 3 a¢' s1i1 tr kEs 9 r $��•$ta a o°i h �� $= BEaa a 3 $ °asaaaaaaa a-, F p Ii p6Ya d!a° :g a s 3 ! @ro;p B ➢ :!3 r Pi g?pa fie_�..jg�n1 E; l� f aiv-i:S� a m$ 1'��'E3$ $Ea a dz Ei" ase -9]11113t $`�a '§ y 2$5!1h a F a¢e as ! 13 a aG :$y:� ares_=E � 4�6: $$ p $kEga $8S4 s fi•pfi 6 116 N! pp 9§ 3g8ero' ro -E 9 �_P$� 7•a ss �;6s' 3 as � 1 e�� ,c � yE g8d � $� Bfie s_� E�P3'S EP�3,E_;. $vaF� $ •sa �=1pB d a 4 k $9�}a�ya �� ! i� �wJ 8 y' a �pl,9 ipp g '.3 p 8aAa i 9v i rt ya 88 5 $' � d: $• ,° s� 3 ai P i 3a8' 6�!'-n$ �2:�31, �- s !�_`� � Y �s5 4�ss B° bad H 4E �. x a•... a { ••� ��� ��� tr`E- ��a G�9 � �E 1� P rt` $��` �;$������ �aE. �' - �� ��' E �� ��s-jj r p$E�n A z. F. { Z Y 4 s a = �..F�.,,Rax4 E8= s' t it % as E;z$ $p'$�p�IIaa !g B yy3Ea i ��yp 8 a F`8$ a?$a �zgdsa�= &_s$EYyy�ta 91'ag E�®a$iyy$�2p¢�i�$� '�� $ja °a =a3y aaE� F t63R � da3Eaa H8891a aE IMI 8311, H 8t i�]pM iii:.°E' i� g36g rt°��g $�3D��ss 8giY9s-fEo�st nH � g#�� ��r �� �E �fi S�B6'3 ro a .4 d d d w . d _ 6Ea 2�g :� y y 11$18111`0 :433=i3 :8 2: a 32. _h� �A:.n" a°8 al 3 zsB8 53s Y F < J� �§ lit M, �� gB a�'B 6 P%�a lilap 4g F�'_ aE =$Y g ay$ EF j ¢ iff"91 ilk 191 a it; Bl .3 ga 'a° 5 aS $3 F 1e, am.a:. y4 4-26a did Alii z d d U d pp C d seB$'s 3B = 33 !-` 9131 �$ �aaa 6•'�1 ;a tY88 a a Jilt .i!ol 298 :a :§ Ffi P S n _aE• _ y a� a9h E •�s 41 of pp6• 15 §a §§ii B 19:y y a9Eiaa3 �gy�� �2Y m:l°3aan a$S 4 3EL� P All,E y• Ey ' Es yi y=y e$ $;j 63 ! jd•; b Mpi y82B ji9!$ t a°y asp �Ee a;5 a�5�agg=9g3�ay $5�a=1r i3y€$;ki" P B P =Ys -t Jr pa;3rt 3-a=B is F Ep�SUpn"Pa. E=71a9 Cog& &� S ae s 8a d �� !gB�.yI 63i,sp 7B7 s �! _� 9�3J 3 tr x�63Ea$,p8; 3�P�ns €65a4��6��3i k3 trn•: k 8-i'� � n^"; :1•i���i ,_8� �: v 3 B'8 =n8° apQa F'S ao$§ �$ na§`karo=t� a ;d y�Em'3 !S'3•l;y 8saa g;Ee�E -121E F ai_. - NIP. - d'§gki3' 6 Rg�6�yq�trj•a�'FyF��5i §�3Yk $PliE$ �� F 64 e1�ro 3� 4L;.�$$$a 1 . sai¢6 S� �s-§Bcay3d S Eh. � 3�� fi °8J�; � g ��• zh I?a96�QsgAMU ��$� ��Ea$ � 1 it HA �a g� at rtA a s3'-_ E -yyF 1i 8�2 1$� s B 4 3 a5S M 112 • ; 4b 53aE�9EY 3a9� ' �� p - § 8a --P1 9i3. jEva 1$ 9191P11 -B j! Y ail E 21 i¢ his J11i lid ie3 ;p a1$-Iik- >ss 3 Ra�¢4 l y8 4aa$l3 3 a$ E ,y ass fi9s 3 jjli3 3.,36 ail 3E S 3 ChZR9 $09a2�aS 3` $Asa 8 - _ $ _ E •�S7ni3 $a aaB1 aa6�, -trot u d A d d d U d W k 34h �Etr3 a3zE �: _U B1Pgfx lE IES _ i-6 P3; . � 8 i ' II F' iAb °et� Bc8` 3't n� s 111HP All ,$i1s,d� � ��aa 3 B&ay3$ 6,tr 83 n 9$' P-15 F i8 l Hit 5i1 5 ? � .2 5Y2a a%af E_§ 3 = 1111 �7:a�m l9sa AM �flffl<F 5 �Tj7 3 z d d U 0 3 d gill @11RI - $VISE - qyl -$ IUDnD NO 8 'a• �au 21,912 ? k§ E a m m h B $ � yy B pa r s B $a; ,IRI 3a maB 3a fir: p§ 31�a E :ld8 y5�Wit � 9F� _1 j� EE! ;�ir�, k ;i¢i', 214ap" til a � 5 ••� 2•E�all Ea � E rt gal W-111 1,01-11'a It f 4 y�n $ ? HIM,, �� �yro as A M d �'�5� 3a d15_S d�= Ca?Pa, a3 a �d- 'i3y o.Y M. ±°Itr_ d w � Pt - ��i� P a9`o! 5 y MIN? B ; g ds8 �.J§•' -�k� qtr: 3 � $:� Ss� �8 a PaE $ § a $ � 111, 93;a lZ3sgg�s jilt 5 3 HUM g 1 p��r aIDjfin$$$idW�a$i &�p2ailYas§_kA? e B 5 $$ 6E °E 9 tr E 3jd 3 -�vip a $s- g$ J� N 3 `�a i2 -g #s €t Y 4B a Baa tr $s;� dgB E a �& a aE.sf §6Ea 1 39 :• $ as 3Em $Fa i n§ �_3 d $!- pa 6 s°• a 2= BELIr sy= �t$��i ll JUL?a: :, a § ! Eag.01 �.$ c ➢oma i�ia� 848' y eaa3 fie! 3 a 3 PbT ��tr 9 B' a I .Er" P. 8 yra, 875 X98`' � §§fi2: $.- 8 4 95 trniB5 Sn1 P sE�$ aa��3pe�� � �n a4 ��� �.� Eat �-"��$$� ���'a=$ a�z�; Y$ '$' '$ '� ��➢ � EE'g�y$=g�8��' EP s��•�aAq ¢°�$�-p�d� F E IIs'= a 1 B§B'4_ ig F! e'2 E i rt �a § �i8o 8 8� fi 8'"�r It kid I 93-g� E1:uf, Es 5 $ y 3� n$ ET $1 13 Q a_. ,'$s$. 5P aFgla'�' --'fi Ey =a f iE a $�93^. a$. ' i a3=�. as as =1 sd�'=,a y $$$$ 3E{fi' E3 io a E $ Ee 'g8; 8T1 �➢ 5;aaA- a�oa ;� a= _� :�..�3 �3� �a� &Bsi; & §'x� -P Ez sn roma i a P^'i1 AII YP_E3-•E$ fig` !B 3 F1 a �3 y dE §'y E : 1- i y1� Bs35 �_" i 9 R° i s1 1a �6y §_ a• fiaEL 5�g:,.a fir• § 6't Y75 fi !3F a 2 a8�ada! �iaa�� , u s 3u4,� �� i roEf'tA adi aEEE < $ L tlx: =tr: m$ 3 z$�B�E 3't 8a $33 d9 Y$& g ��I1�--.�68 M _�$8!a$s� k u a d d u 4 0 8 14 !$ p3 I TIM aBp aro$ $`off- Bila:aP!�'a' W y R $ l a § B 1 =!:$a$: g f' 1p$ a Eby aeuaaaaass9 fis F 3 a¢' s1i1 tr kEs 9 r $��•$ta a o°i h �� $= BEaa a 3 $ °asaaaaaaa a-, F p Ii p6Ya d!a° :g a s 3 ! @ro;p B ➢ :!3 r Pi g?pa fie_�..jg�n1 E; l� f aiv-i:S� a m$ 1'��'E3$ $Ea a dz Ei" ase -9]11113t $`�a '§ y 2$5!1h a F a¢e as ! 13 a aG :$y:� ares_=E � 4�6: $$ p $kEga $8S4 s fi•pfi 6 116 N! pp 9§ 3g8ero' ro -E 9 �_P$� 7•a ss �;6s' 3 as � 1 e�� ,c � yE g8d � $� Bfie s_� E�P3'S EP�3,E_;. $vaF� $ •sa �=1pB d a 4 k $9�}a�ya �� ! i� �wJ 8 y' a �pl,9 ipp g '.3 p 8aAa i 9v i rt ya 88 5 $' � d: $• ,° s� 3 ai P i 3a8' 6�!'-n$ �2:�31, �- s !�_`� � Y �s5 4�ss B° bad H 4E �. x a•... a { ••� ��� ��� tr`E- ��a G�9 � �E 1� P rt` $��` �;$������ �aE. �' - �� ��' E �� ��s-jj r p$E�n A z. F. { Z Y 4 s a = �..F�.,,Rax4 E8= s' t it % as E;z$ $p'$�p�IIaa !g B yy3Ea i ��yp 8 a F`8$ a?$a �zgdsa�= &_s$EYyy�ta 91'ag E�®a$iyy$�2p¢�i�$� '�� $ja °a =a3y aaE� F t63R � da3Eaa H8891a aE IMI 8311, H 8t i�]pM iii:.°E' i� g36g rt°��g $�3D��ss 8giY9s-fEo�st nH � g#�� ��r �� �E �fi S�B6'3 ro a .4 d d d w . d _ 6Ea 2�g :� y y 11$18111`0 :433=i3 :8 2: a 32. _h� �A:.n" a°8 al 3 zsB8 53s Y F < J� FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET SCOTT W MORGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd GULF STREAM, FL 33483 PH (561)-752.,1936 FAX (80.1)-760-2777 Date: 7-23-13 To: Town of Gulf Stream Fax: 561-737-0188 From: Scott W. Morgan Re: Application for Level 3 approval of Lot 5- Hidden Harbour Estates Number of pages: 3 Memo: Please find attached my letter in opposition to this application. Would you please make copies of the letter for distribution to the members of the ARPl3? SCOTT W. MORGAN 1.140 N. Ocean ,Blvd GW Stream, Fl, 33483 Ph (561) 243-1432 July 23, 2013 To: Town of Gulf Stream Architectural .Review and :planning Board Re: Hidden Harbour F'slates Lot 5 1224 N. (Ocean Blvd. Dear Board Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review of a 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec. 66-144 (b)(1009 The proposed architectural design of this home violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures. The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than of an Ocean West District home. Because the lot is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale. The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. Sec. 70-4 (c) (4) and Sec. 70-29 (b) (3) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's prohibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Code's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located _"(Art, I, Sec. 70-4 (c )(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "lots that are set back. great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district." (Art. U, Sec. 70-29 (b)(3)). The homes of this District have a unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Hidden Harbour Estates—all of which are rectangular, long Bast to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other life two rows of domino tiles has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- community sub -division, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Raton and West Delray Beach. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all corner lots and so were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes on adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. In order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West District character, and to prevent an over -crowding of similar homes inside Hidden. )Harbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 ArchitecturaVSite Plan Review of Lot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re -submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, ott W Morga I t. rn 00'0-19: R alcog -- lNd 60.EO -- El0-1/EdFJO -- PX5'9107 h-1-1-06IPXOIOOVO 7Vt13N39195U1AivJO:O 2z�� p 5yy � C Gj� o Co Ad q Q. u J_ J v GI ^ o LijLo *—r � � g � ��� Q ti 111 ................ Yd �3LYlS �� � (bQ CCM SN7l707 CC+ All o �W a IQ y � s t X � O s •e @ b co 0 0 5 -4r I a a I � e Ii � I I rNLH 31 YAW Y) Xtfo ) ZLW igl+ ,Y, 10YXL vomw rl.Ysmv33arr. v Lonnrrr c-} + ix�mv33Tnneo n of Z 107 107 Z 00'0019: ! ale -91, --kM 60:00 -- ElOZlr{/90 -- PX6'S1O7 POO-06IPXOI00VO 7Vd3N3JIs6u1Ai-Qj:0 -�3A Yd �P7 �y oa - �kr • .r7I7 w4r., I AIN 4: ilk t O W c 0 tl 4 Uxi � �ryV ul O O J J sr I W I I Dar r 1M 21 YAW Y) Ksr lex a JA013M yW~ rax mudZtNvw ° uer ace+ ,Y. 10N2[L � tnamy3 Mnneo �� R ��amn�roaa—1 Z 107 �I 107 CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Ann Kasten Aker George Delafield, Jr. October 17, 2012 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, OCTOBER 25, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 9-27-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. November 15, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. b. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. January 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application, deferred from Public Hearing held September 27, 2012, that was submitted by Seaside Builders LLC, as agent for Harbor View Estates, LLC owners of property located at 1224 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat II, Replat of Golf Course Addn. Its 4, 5 & N 92' of It 6, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics and some native trees providing for a 13' clear zone from edge of roadway. 2. An application, deferred from Public Hearing held September 27, 2012, submitted by Seaside Builders LLC as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1220 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 4, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, a replat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 15, Pages 173 & 174, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial two-story Bermuda style single family dwelling, 3 car garage with AGENDA CONTINUED bonus room above, 8,603 square feet, and a swimming pool. 3. An application, deferred from Public Hearing of September 27, 2012, submitted by Seaside Builders as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1230 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 6, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, being a re -plat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BLVD. OVERLAY PRMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and installation of a 6'high aluminum rail fence 12' west of the east property line that will be screened with landscape material. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of an 8,857 square foot Colonial West Indies style partial two-story, single family dwelling, attached 2 car garage with 6' high walls and fences screened with landscape material around the property, and a swimming pool. 4. An application submitted by Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects, as Agent for Doris J. Gillman, the owner of property located at 3333 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Part of Lot 5, Gulf Stream Ocean Tracts, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to remove existing landscape material and driveway, install new driveway and landscaping and construct5 foot perimeter wall with entry gate within the North Ocean Boulevard Corridor. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to relocate/clear existing landscaping material for relocation of driveway, preparation of building site and property beautification. C. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a 9,036 square foot Colonial West Indies style partial 2-stor single family dwelling, 3 car attached garage and a swimming pool. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 27, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order. The meeting was called to order by Vice -Chairman Morgan at 8:35 A.M. II. Roll Call. Present and Scott Morgan Vice -Chairman Participating Tom Smith Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member Amanda Jones Board Member Absent w/Notice Paul Lyons Board Member Ann Aker Alt. Member Beau Delafield Alt. Member Also Present and William Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita Taylor Town Clerk John Randolph Town Attorney Martin O'Boyle, Resident Hidden Harbour Est. Representing Tom Laudani Developer Richard Jones of Architect Jones Architects Dave Bodker of Landscape Arch. Dave Bodker Landscape & Architecture Mark Grant, Esq. Atty. For Seaside Vice -Chairman Morgan welcomed the return of Amanda Jones, who has moved from Alternate Member to Member of the Architectural Review and Planning Board. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 7-26-12. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of July 26, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. Mr. Thrasher requested that Item VI.A.4 be heard first and Item VI.A.1 will replace Item VI.A.4. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. October 25, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. b. November 15, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. C. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. d. January 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if there will be applications for public hearing for the October meeting. Clerk Taylor said there will be one application, possibly two. There were no conflicts declared. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 2 VI. PUBLIC HEARING. There were no declarations of ex -parte communication. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to Robert Jones, Dave Bodker, Mark Grant, Martin O'Boyle and Tom Laudani. Clerk Taylor stated that she received an email addressed to the Town Commission and Architectural Review and Planning Board from Mrs. Nancy Touhey of 1200 N. Ocean Blvd. The letter was read into the record. In her letter, Mrs. Touhey said she is unable to attend public hearings concerning applications for new homes in the subdivision. She said she believes the developer failed to live up to the agreements that supported the Town's approval of the subdivision, specifically the stipulation that the arbor canopy would not be destroyed. Mrs. Touhey said she might have been more supportive of the project if the Banyan tree across from her driveway had not been cut down. She requested that any approved plans and construction of the six homes be frequently inspected by the Town to be sure the builder is abiding by conditions of approval. The letter will be filed with the Official Records of the Town of Gulf Stream. Mr. Thrasher responded to Mrs. Touhey's comments saying that he has been watching the property very closely, he has done daily inspections during business hours, after hours and on weekends. He said he also inspected the property at 2:00 A.M. during Tropical Storm Isaac. Mr. Thrasher said he has observed nothing that was not approved or permitted. A. Applications for Development Approval (In order of Agenda rearrangement). 4. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1222 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 3 Hidden Harbor Estates Plat Two, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 15, Pages 173 and 174, Public Records of Palm Beach County. a. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest suite, a detached outdoor seating area, a total of 9,229 square feet, and a swimming pool. Richard Jones of Richard Jones Architects introduced himself and noted his team members, including Tom Laudani, the Developer, Mark Grant, Esq., and Dave Bodker, the Landscape Architectect. He said the six lots are ready for development and each are similar in their narrow width and depth, which has created challenges with regard to buffers, setbacks and rights-of-way. He said they looked at similar communities and found ways to minimize mass and size and capture courtyards and create outdoor living space. Mr. Jones described Lot 3 as situated in the southwest corner of the subdivision with a unique view of Hidden Harbour. The proposed 2 -story Bermuda Style structure is long and narrow with an east/west orientation. It is broken up into various masses, including a detached carriage home connected by an exterior breezeway, a pool deck terrace and loggia connected to a boat house featuring a small pavilion above with views of the harbor and storage below, and balconies on the Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 3 front and rear of the home. Mr. Jones said the materials are common, including smooth stucco and a mitered hip roof. Mr. Smith asked about the proposed storage area under the boat house. Mr. Jones said there is 6.5' of headroom under the sitting pavilion for miscellaneous boating storage. Mr. Smith asked about a meandering wall on the south side of property. Mr. Jones said it is an existing retaining wall which was required for subdivision approval. Mr. Smith asked where Mrs. Touhey's property entrance ties into this property. Mr. Bodker said it is near Lot 4 at the southeast corner of the property. He said the tree in question was not within the 15' buffer, it was a rotted Ficus tree with a lot of vines and it will be replaced with six native trees which will block views of the property. Vice -Chairman Morgan asked if there are additional walls planned for this property. Mr. Jones said there will be 3' entry walls at the front driveway, 3'4" welcome walls near the front of the home, and terrace walls at the pool deck that will be 2' at the base with 42" of railing above, and the piers are 6' tall, but he said 3.5' of that is decorative railing. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that the three proposed homes will be similar, but he said this design is the most attractive because it is better balanced. Mr. Smith said the landscaping is the biggest concern for the neighbors. Mr. Bodker said there are 11 existing trees on the south side, two that are 40' in height and spread. They will supplement the existing with 12' high Buttonwood and Fishtail palms on the south side and they will supplement the landscaping on the west side with hedging and trees. He said there will be layering and overlapping of vegetation for additional screening around the pool area. Vice -Chairman Morgan opened the hearing to public comment. Martin O'Boyle of 23 Hidden Harbour Drive asked Mr. Randolph if the Applicant's statements made under oath are binding. Mr. Randolph said the ARPB and the Commission make decisions based on statements made under oath and if something is done that was not approved it can be revisited and additional conditions can be imposed. Mr. O'Boyle said he believes the developer is not abiding by the Agreement between the developer and the neighbors. He said the canopy was damaged and nothing has been done, and he said he requested different material for the meandering wall because it has a commercial look and is not fitting for the Hidden Harbour Development. Mr. O'Boyle was also concerned with the drainage saying there has already been flooding on the Himmelrich property. He said there were modifications to the drainage, it ties into Hidden Harbour and any drainage modification or tie-in to that community is subject to a majority vote of its residents. Mr. O'Boyle said there is no positive drainage, meaning there is no place for the water to go, it uses Hidden Harbour facilities and their covenants do not allow that. Another concern is the Interlocal Agreement with Delray Beach. Mr. O'Boyle said that Delray should have no say in the removal or installation of trees on the property. He said he has spoken to Mr. Thrasher and he wrote a letter to Mark Grant, Attorney for the Applicant concerning these matters. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 4 Mark Grant said he disagrees with Mr. O'Boyle concerning a majority vote requirement; however, he said these are private matters and not the subject before the Board at this time. He explained the flooding issue on the Himmelrich property saying that a temporary cover was in place over the drain to avoid blockage and when the cover was removed the water was gone within an hour. Mr. Grant also said the one tree that was removed was outside of the 15' landscape buffer and it was rotted and dangerous, but he said it will be replaced. Mr. Laudani introduced himself, he said he has made great strides with the property improvements and would like to address these matters with Mr. O'Boyle privately. Mr. Laudani said he spoke with Mr. Himmelrich about the flooding weeks ago and since the drain was uncovered there has been no further water accumulation, even after Tropical Storm Isaac. He said Mr. Himmelrich called him to thank him and to say there are no issues. Mr. Laudani said everything has been approved by South Florida Water Management District and other appropriate authorities and both systems are working perfectly. He described the stucco meandering retaining wall as small and low, 24" above grade with aluminum rail above, and he said there will be lush vegetation and landscaping masking the wall. Mr. O'Boyle distributed some documents to the Commissioners for their information concerning changes to the Hidden Harbour Declaration and how the changes pertain to the required signatures for approval. Vice - Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Randolph if there are legal issues beyond the ARPB that would call for a legal halting of the subdivision and does it mute what the ARPB is doing today. Mr. Randolph said the Commission gave final approval of the project and they will make that decision. He said the ARPB is only required to make a decision based on the application before them today and not to hear concerns relating to violations of the subdivision agreement or the agreement with the neighbors. Mr. Randolph said Staff has looked at many of these issues, particularly the canopy and drainage, but he said they do not relate to the architectural review. If the ARPB recommends approval of this application, he said the Commission will determine if there have been violations and they will deal with that. Mr. Randolph said the issue of the western wall may relate to this application, and he said he is reviewing the agreement between the neighbors and Harbour Estates. He said where it talks about the retaining wall it states that it requires the approval of the neighbors. He said documents such as this may come before you, but the Town does not have the jurisdiction to enforce covenants. Vice -Chairman Morgan said he agrees; however, he said the subject agreement was made a part of the subdivision approval by the ARPB and Commission. Mr. Randolph commented on Vice -Chairman Morgan's statement that the ARPB and Commission asked for an agreement between the developer and the neighbors. He said the request specifically concerned the 15' landscape buffer, the canopy and drainage, but the agreement also talks about the western wall and the neighbors having an opportunity to approve it. Mr. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 5 Randolph said the ARPB and Commission may or may not have commented on these matters, but he said he believes it is beyond the authority of the Town Commission to enforce an agreement that never came before them. However, he said the Commission does have the authority to speak out if they believe the agreement has been breached. Mr. Smith asked Clerk Taylor if the neighbors and Mrs. Touhey were notified of the applications before the ARPB. Clerk Taylor confirmed that. She explained what the Code requires concerning notification and stated that she went beyond Code requirements to cover a larger area. Clerk Taylor said that Mrs. Touhey received a notice and responded. Mr. Smith moved and Mrs. Jones seconded to recommend approval of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two-story single family Bermuda Style dwelling, a 3 -car garage with guest suite, a detached outdoor sitting area, a total of 9,229 SF, and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: (1) The electric service lines shall be buried; (2) The roof shall be white (through and through) un -textured, un -coated flat cement tile; (3) Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval, and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval prior to commencement of landscaping; (4) Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached; and (5) All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbors' view. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 2. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1220 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 4, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, a replat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 15, Pages 173 & 174, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Vice -Chairman Morgan stated that he would rather not address the Overlay Permit at this time and just concentrate on the house. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. (THIS ITEM DEFERRED TO THE OCTOBER 25, 2012 MEETING.) b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial two-story Bermuda style single family dwelling, 3 car garage with bonus room above, 8,603 square feet, and a swimming pool. Robert Jones said Lot 4 is similar to Lot 3 in width and depth, but he said it is the only lot with a direct access driveway onto A1A. He said there is a formal entry driveway through the motor court, detached structures connected by covered breezeways, multiple outdoor sitting Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 6 areas, and the house wraps around the pool area. This is a four-bedroom home with the potential for a fifth bedroom above the garage, which is a detached structure with a carriage house above. Mr. Jones said Lots 3 & 4 are spec homes and will have some flexibility. He said this application meets all of the Gulf Stream Code criteria. Vice -Chairman Morgan said the north and south walls go straight up and he asked if there is any jogging back between the first and second floors of the main house. Mr. Jones said the north and south end walls are continuous, but he said there is a balcony feature extending 4' from the wall with columns and a shed roof above. Vice -Chairman Morgan said there are other walls that go straight up without deviation which gives a massy and unbalance appearance, and he said the garage is also box - shaped. Mr. Jones said the H -shape of the plan provides stepping and there are three balconies that offset. He said there is a stairway on the courtyard side of the garage leading up to the carriage house and there are small architectural details that wrap around the structure and break down mass. Mr. Bodker said there will be a tremendous amount of trees reaching 50' in height which will block the view of the house. In his review, Mr. Thrasher said he concentrated on second story coverage in comparison to first story, but did not apply the newer portion of the Code. He said there have been recent Code changes and there is a requirement upon the applicant to incorporate certain architectural features in the design. Mr. Thrasher read from Code Sec. 70-73, Two -Story Structures (a) In order to limit the construction of bulkier homes in districts with full second stories with small to medium lot sizes, the following restrictions shall be used: Ocean West - .70 of first floor area, (b) The use of architectural design features to provide variation among two-story single family homes is required. One or more of the following features shall be incorporated within facades facing public or private roadways on any new two-story, single family home in all zoning districts: Second -story setback (minimum 5' setback, in addition to round level front setback); Front porch (minimum 8' depth; Balcony (minimum 24 SF); Arcade. The Town Commission may waive this requirement within subsection (b) if the applicant can demonstrate that these features are inconsistent with the home's architectural style and that the desired visual variation is provided through other measures. Mr. Thrasher said one of these elements must be incorporated in the design and if not, you must demonstrate why. He said a front porch with a depth of 8 feet, or a balcony of 24 SF, qualify as a necessary element. Mr. Jones said there is an entry portico that is 5 feet deep and could be 8 feet, and he said there are balconies on the east and west facades, but not on the north and south facades. Mr. Smith said the homes are too close to each other without incorporating some design features and he suggested they do more work with the walls and come back to the ARPB for review. Mr. Thrasher said one option is that the second story would be set back 5 feet from the first story. Vice -Chairman Morgan agreed that this application should be withdrawn and revisited. Mr. Jones said he can incorporate some stepback on the north side. Mr. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 7 Randolph said an appropriate motion would be to defer to a time certain to eliminate the need to advertise, and to have the applicant return with some of the recommended changes. He suggested the architect meet with the Town Manager to be sure they are in compliance with the Code. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to defer this application and have the applicant return to the ARPB with the recommended changes at a time certain of Thursday, October 25, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Jones asked if the Board wished to discuss the Overlay Permit portion of this application. Vice -Chairman Morgan stated that two of the Board Members will be leaving at 10:50 A.M., which would result in the lack of a quorum. Mr. Laudani asked the Board to take a quick look at Lot 6. 3. An application submitted by Seaside Builders as agent for Harbour View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1230 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally Described as Lot 6, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, being a re -plat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BLVD. OVERLAY PRMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and installation of a 6'high aluminum rail fence 12' west of the east property line that will be screened with landscape material. (THIS ITEM DEFERRED TO THE OCTOBER 25, 2012 MEETING.) b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of an 8,857 square foot Colonial West Indies style partial two-story, single family dwelling, attached 2 car garage with 6' high walls and fences screened with landscape material around the property, and a swimming pool. Mr. Jones said there are similarities to Lots 3 and 4, such as a detached garage with a carriage house above, loggia connections, entry wall features and lush landscaping. He said there is a homeowner involved with this lot and, therefore, this will be a custom home of Colonial West Indies architecture, there will be different window articulation and different roof lines, and he said the roof material will be gray slate -like tile. Mr. Smith said the north elevation has great setbacks and features and he asked if the north elevation has straight up walls. Mr. Jones confirmed that, but he said that can be adjusted. He said Marty Minor reviewed this design and found it to be in compliance with Code. Mr. Morgan asked if they were changing the half-moon window. Mr. Jones said Mr. Minor found this window to be inconsistent with Gulf Stream Architecture, but he said they feel it works well with the architectural style. Vice -Chairman Morgan commented that the garage doors open to the streets, Code requires that they be blocked, and he asked how they will accomplish that. Mr. Jones said there will be gates. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - September 27, 2012 Page 8 Mr. Murphy asked that the roof material be referenced when the application comes back to the ARPB for vote. Mr. Thrasher said there will be a sample to view. Mrs. Jones asked the applicant to submit a second drawing showing an alternative to the half-moon windows on that particular facade. The applicant agreed. Mr. Randolph suggested that before this Meeting is adjourned a motion be made to defer the remainder of these items to the October 25th Meeting. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Smith seconded to defer this application and the remaining applications to the October 25, 2012 Meeting. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 1. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC, as agent for Harbor View Estates, LLC, owners of property located at 1224 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat II, re - plat of Golf Course Addition Lots 4, 5 & N 92' of Lot 6, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics and some native trees providing for a 13' clear zone from edge of roadway. (THIS ITEM DEFERRED TO THE OCTOBER 25, 2012 MEETING.) VII. Reorganization of ARPB. A. Election of a Chairman Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded Chairman of the Architectural Review an discussion. All voted AYE. B. Election of a Vice Chairman Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded Chairman of the Architectural Review an discussion. All voted AYE. to elect Scott Morgan as Planning Board. There was no to elect Amanda Jones as Vice - Planning Board. There was no VIII. Items by Staff. There were no items by Staff. IX. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Members of the Board. X. Public. There were no public comments. XI. Adjournment. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to adjourn the meeting. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. Chairman Morgan adjourned the Meeting at 10:50 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-10 Address: 1230 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Seaside Builders, LLC Construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and the installation of a 6' high aluminum rail fence 12' west of the east property line that will be screened with landscape material. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family 8,857 Colonial West Indies style dwelling, attached 2 car garage, with 6' walls and fences, screened with landscape material around the property and a swimming pool. Gross Lot size: 36,402 SF Effective Lot Area: 36,402 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 8,857 SF Allowable: 9,880 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Height: 28'4" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Finished Floor: 12.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday was asked to provide a report on the architectural style. This report is attached. Note: Although Mr. Minor recommends approval, page 3 of his report suggests something different, "Architecture ... Although a half moon window is not common within the Colonial West Indies architecture, the architect and independent research has confirmed that half-moon windows are used within the style as special feature." Because it is not common and could be considered a special feature, the half moon windows should be replaced with other type windows as demonstrated on the single story portion of the proposed structure. Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File -#012-10 ARPB September 27, 2012; TC October 12, 2012 Page 3 any hedges to be maintained at a height of no less than 6', and further provided that a 6' temporary construction fence with screening material attached be installed inside the buffer area. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ► RECEIVED q AUG 15 2w t TpW ,.,. n of Gulfstream, FL, APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner N PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File ## )- 1-0 1-J(2' LA.2. Project Address: /\J si vo I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: 9 a- 04-h I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) 0 I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: _6181f-7 Architectural Style: _in�6�) � aA wes-- Im S 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section .E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: 1 9 . ao Type of Foundation:il�l.�C B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address:_+N Qr'hfj- V i 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number. 2-� 2 - � Fax: � - 44 ----�/ 1.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I . Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) o�-�� "T-15Cj cell7%� . �� U"N+ Fax aR 1.C.4. Agent Signature: A jyyjyY�f�_ Pre -App Date: App Date: — Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Legal Description LOT 6, HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES PLAT TWO BEING A REPLAT LOTS 4,5 AND 6, GOLF COURSE ADDITION, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 10, PAGE 75 (P.B.C.P.R.) AND TRACT A, HIDDEN HARBOR ESTATES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE 110 (P.B.C.P.R.) ALL BEING IN SECTION 9, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGE 43 EAST, TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA APRIL 2011. Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and comple question number for each response. te A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? �a 2 west III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning districtX-Y es ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan ?yYes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? (,L` A�t n 1.- \ a SII /- n C' _t .) _ I, .-, I I - III.A.5. a. b. e f. 9 h How are the following utilities to be provided to the orooerty? Stoi San Poti Irrig Elec Tele Gas Cab III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 9Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes ®'No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an exist �?Novacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes Y"No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the projet at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be-tffstnrtTeZl or added and to what extent? Q lum. t'�1t I I'LG Gno� 1,tSWI CX4ens.rz- IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the dLgIu4aawe/addition: CA -P I <zz n, 0 -,- r �-P d f 0 S" d'e- 0-C-0- IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? YesE) Explain: n-Qw %Auy Id -eAn t} PLS " Q ql IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? rxvi dk qoe IV.6.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least imnar-+ the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: a& Fvi reiyoto a-- Ao'S g n ee e,*v a -h s 4- v -a h i r rr�,eo - d n c-hv s-PQC-.-I \P-5 C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? /VJ A IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: '50 VI Q -2�Ci S ilY`ar (`C''1., (� PQ J c IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: 433 - )oyz e- IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: �� j�i1f 't7 ti feQu� , Yl ©� RA%e r e)cte.n 51,.o Vl c`4'i v� 1-�l�n-I-rin� IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? X12 �_ _ � r- , - _ n IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES LOT -6 1J � r o soft fern acadia white WALLS TRIM N 1P\ RECEIVED AUG 2 3 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL ailllllll='" �� LL��- LL F w 0 C/) U- C'1 Cy C/)0 �� F- ��'- LLLL Cf O LL z N C/) d- U) O U) C1 U) r r- ti 00 O C ��t N O �� O C6 F- WU) CY L~L C�� C�� L~L L~L U) U' Ci L~L C�� U, F-- LL L~L C�� U) F LL U) Z N o (n  U) U) L o cD U) 00 cn U' U) i (1 d ti coo L` co ti O m ti L ti coo ao o o`oo 00 O L~L L~L L~L U- LLL~L L~L L~L LL LL LLL O w d��U' C��'1 d ��U' ��U' o O O O O O O O O O V1 w w �� Q L~L L -L LLL LL LL LLLL. LL C1 Cl z LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL d 0 (14 N U) U Cj U' d d U' U' d d d �� N �� CV) O O O w U) U) 0 U) O U) U) U) U) U) U) U) O co O NM O 00 ti M N (D (D O O O O O O O M Ch O Ch O N d' VI- ~ ti O W Q CC Q J Z) LaLI Z O ? = (/) Z O O p Z U CV ��_ [C Oui 2i W F- W w Z N Z W O w W W Q m o A U) X w w LL O a Q 0-10- Q O D C) (7 ZQ w �� �� W �� 1�L W Q w Q w W �� Z 0 ��-' Z (D w C) UY 2 �� �� o O Q w W W W U U O z Lo Z ~ > W > Z F- Q < M N m Q Q o C) F- F-> > w O> O �Q X X Q�� Zo Z W U > O _ O w- W O n�� O o o Q X J w ��< J> F- J p O CD Q O w Ow 0 2 O (nom C7 U) w w J J LL- N J Q 2 w w N J Q z -i w �� Z O N < < O LL- LL �� Q F- U) w 0 O Z O F- (n O 0 Z Z X Q O F- F- p��> W O O Ci F- w O F- Q U a U W LL U N N Q W U (D 0 F- LL 0 F- F- �� Q U) Bill Thrasher From: Marty Minor <MMinor@udkstudios.com> Sent: Friday, September 28, 2012 2:16 PM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: 1230 North Ocean - Two -Story visual variation Attachments: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd 2story memo.doc Bill, A memo for your review and use. Thank you, Marty Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Urban Design Kilday Studios The Offices at City Place North 477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758 561-366-1100 MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM DATE: RE Marty R.A. Minor, AICP SEPTEMBER 28, 2012 urban design kilday Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics 1230 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD LOT 6 OF HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES (HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES PLAT TWO) ■ TWO-STORY VARIATION MEMORANDUM With the recent amendment to the Town's Zoning Code, Section 70-73(b) was adopted to help create visual interest in the two-story elevations for single family homes. This visual interest could be created through variations in the elevations. These variations could include: porches, arcades, balconies or additional second -story setbacks. This code section also allows for the Town Commission to waive this provision if: • The prescribed features are inconsistent with the home's architectural style • or, the desired visual variation is provided through other measures. With regards to the proposed Colonial West Indies home at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard, the desired visual variation is provided through changes in texture and color between the first and second stories. The second -floor exterior walls will be smooth stucco lap siding painted Benjamin Moore Soft Fern. The first story walls will be smooth stucco painted Benjamin Moore Acadia White. This variation of color and texture, in concert with the home's other architectural features, provides the desired visual variation for the home and its two-story elements. As such, I can recommend approval of the waiver referenced in Section 70-73(b) for the proposed home at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream -94-012\1 230 N. Ocean Blvd\1230 N. Ocean Blvd 2story memo.doc MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager :a ,I DATE: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP August 30, 2012 urban design kilday Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics 1230 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD LOT 6 OF HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES (HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES PLAT TWO) ■ REVIEW MEMORANDUM The following is an analysis of the proposed new house at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard. Request The applicant is seeking Level 3 Architectural Site Plan Approval for a 8,857 -square foot, Colonial West Indies home on 36,402 square feet (0.83 acres) on Lot 6 of Hidden Harbour Estates, Plat Two (a.k.a. Harbour View Estates). Background On November 10, 2011, the Town Commission approved the subdivision, site plan, demolition permit, land clearing and North Ocean Boulevard permits for the 6.03 -acre Harbour View Estates project. The subdivision created six, new, single family lots west of North Ocean Boulevard and north of Hidden Harbour Drive. In January of this year, demolition, land clearing and drainage permits were granted. Construction of the site has continued until then. Land Use & Zoning EXISTING USE, ZONING AND LAND USE DESIGNATIONS EXISTING USE ZONING FUTURE LAND USE Subiect Site RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Lot 6, Harbour View Estates North RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Private Roadway and Single Family Home (1304 N. Ocean Boulevard) East RS -Beachfront SF (Single Family) North Ocean Boulevard and Single Family Home (1275 N. Ocean Boulevard) H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream -94-012\1 230 N. Ocean Blvd\1230 N. Ocean Blvd review memo.doc nue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 Mr. William Thrasher 1230 N Ocean Blvd. Review August 30, 2012 Page 2 South RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Private Access Road to Consistent? Floor Area Ratio Harbour View Estates and 8,857 square feet of Yes Lot 5 (Vacant) square feet of lot house West RS -Ocean West SF (Single Family) Private Access Drive and Lot 1 (Vacant) Proiect Details The following is an analysis on how the proposed house addresses the Town's development standards. 1230 N. Ocean Boulevard Town Regulation Proposed Plan Consistent? Floor Area Ratio 0.33 for first 20,000 8,857 square feet of Yes square feet of lot house + 0.20 for portion of lot over 20,000 square feet = 9,880 square feet of house allowed Building Height 30 feet 29 feet, 1 inch Yes Maximum Stories 2 stories 2 stories Yes Lot Size 30,000 square feet 36,402 square feet Yes Lot Width 100 feet 114 feet Yes Maximum Second .70 of first floor 2,964 square feet Yes Floor Area area 5,721 square feet of first floor area = 4,004 square feet allowed on second floor Setbacks Front 78 feet from 114 feet from Yes centerline of North centerline of North Ocean Boulevard, Ocean Boulevard, 50 feet from lot line 86 feet, 11 inches from lot line Side Street 30 feet 30 feet and 35 feet Yes Rear 30 feet 59 feet, 11 inches Yes Parking 2 spaces in garage, 4 spaces Yes 2 spaces outside Mr. William Thrasher 1230 N- O-cean Blvd. Review August 30, 2012 Page 3 Access Access to the lot will be through a 30 -foot access easement, which runs from North Ocean Boulevard to the six lots within the Harbour View Estates subdivision. The home, which is proposed to be surrounded by a wall and fence, will be accessed through gated driveway into the lot. Landscaping should be incorporated with the fence and wall design. Elevations of the proposed vehicular gates and surrounding wall will need to be provided for the Architectural Review and Planning Board and Town Commission review. Architecture The proposed 8,857 square foot home features a Colonial West Indies architectural style, which is a preferred architectural style for the Town. The Town -preferred hip and gable roofs feature a flat gray blend concrete tile. The eave heights are consistent with preferred elements of the Town Code. The building walls will be a smooth stucco finish with the second floor exterior walls treated as simulated lap siding. The proposed building colors are: • First Floor: Benjamin Moore Acadia White #AC -41 • Second Floor: Benjamin Moore Soft Fern (2144-40) As preferred by the Town Code, muntins have been indicated for all windows in the proposed house. The windows are rectangular with the exception of the second -story, half-moon, windows on the north and south elevations of the home's great room. Although a half moon window is not common within the Colonial West Indies architecture, the architect and independent research has confirmed that half-moon windows are used within the style as a special feature. As such, the half-moon windows are compliant with the Town Code. Recommendation As described above, the proposed Colonial West Indies style home, as provided by Richard Jones Architecture, at 1230 North Ocean is consistent with the Town Code and Design Manual requirements. As such, the proposed house is recommended for approval. Page 1 of 1 Rita Tayror From: Bill Thrasher Sent: Monday, July 16, 2012 5:03 PM To: Rita Taylor Subject: FW: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc Attachments: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc Progress report on 1220/1230 NOB. I forwarded to the architect and Tom. From: Marty Minor [mailto:MMinor@udkstudios.com] Sent: Monday, July 16, 2012 4:53 PM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: 1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc Bill, Attached for your review and use is the sufficiency letter for the Epstein residence at 1230 N. Ocean Boulevard. These items should be provided so a full evaluation regarding its compliance with the Town code can be made. Thank you, marty 7/17/2012 MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP DATE: July 16, 2012 RE: 1230 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD ■ LEVEL 3 REVIEW SUFFICIENCY MEMORANDUM urban deign iI Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics Consistent with Section 66-145(c)(6) of the Town's Code of Ordinances, please accept this memorandum as the sufficiency determination for the proposed plans for a single- family home at 1230 North Ocean Boulevard. The following is a list of items, plans and information that are required prior to an evaluation of the Level 3 Architectural review: 1. Correct the FAR calculations on Site Plan, Sheet SP -1, Site Data table. The correct ratio is .033 FAR for the first 20,000 s.f. of lot size. 2. Provide lot dimensions on the site plan. 3. Provide calculations that confirm compliance with the 40% lot landscaped open space requirement. These calculations should include information regarding lot coverage, pervious/impervious areas, and landscaped open space area. 4. Provide dimensions of the proposed driveway, motor court and walkways on the revised site plan. 5. Provide dimensions regarding the length and width of the proposed building on the revised site plan. 6. Provide a landscape plan for the site. Particular care should be used in designing the buffer between the proposed house and the subdivision roadway to the south. Existing and proposed landscape should be identified. 7. On the Floor Plans, Sheet A-1, provide dimensions to the length and width of the building. 8. Please indicate building colors on the elevations, Sheet A-2. 9. Provide dimensions for windows, wall heights and other architectural features and treatments. 10. Please note that a higher percentage of window area than wall area on an elevation is prohibited in the Town Code (Section 70-101(d)(6)). Provide calculations indicating conformance with this Town standard. 11. The large "half moon" window on the second floor of the north and south elevations appear to be inconsistent with size and shape of the other proposed windows and the H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream_94-012\Epstein Residence\1230 N. Ocean Blvd House review sufficiency memo.doc 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 Mr. William Thrasher July 16, 2012 1130 N. Ocean Blvd. Residence Review Page 2 architectural style. Consider replacing these windows with windows more consistent with the architectural style. 12. Provide an elevation of the entry door. 13. Provide a digital copy in the .DWG format. Once this information is provided, the application will be complete and an evaluation and recommendation can be made regarding this request. If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to contact me at any time. Richard Jones ARCHITECTURE AA26001617 1 IB26001056 10 S.E. FIRST AVE DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA 33444 15612749186 1 www.rjarchitecture.com Please see attached responses to comments for Hidden Harbour Estates Lot -6. 1. Correct the FAR calculations on Site Plan, Sheet SP -1, Site Data table. The correct ratio is .033 FAR for the first 20,000 s.f. of lot size. The FAR calculations have been provided determined on effective lot area and are shown on sheet SP -1. 2. Provide lot dimensions on the site plan. Lot dimensions have been provided on the site plan sheet SP -1. 3. Provide calculations that confirm compliance with the 40% lot landscaped open space requirement. These calculations should include information regarding lot coverage, pervious/impervious areas, and landscaped open space area. Full calculations have been provided on SP -1 4. Provide dimensions of the proposed driveway, motor court and walkways on the revised site plan. Dimensions have been provided on sheet SP -1. 5. Provide dimensions regarding the length and width of the proposed building on the revised site plan. Dimensions have been provided on sheet SP -1. Richard Jones ARCHITECTURE AA26001617 1 IB26001056 10 S.E. FIRST AVE DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA 33444 15612749186 1 www.rjarchitecture.com 6. Provide a landscape plan for the site. Particular care should be used in designing the buffer between the proposed house and the subdivision roadway to the south. Existing and proposed landscape should be identified. Refer to landscape plans prepared by Dave Bodker. 7. On the Floor Plans, Sheet A-1, provide dimensions to the length and width of the building. Dimensions have been provided on sheet a1 -a2. 8. Please indicate building colors on the elevations, Sheet A-2. Building colors have been listed on the elevation sheets and color chips have been provided. 9. Provide dimensions for windows, wall heights and other architectural features and treatments. dave bodker landscape architecture/planning inc. 601 n congress avenue, suite 105 a delray beach, florida 33445 561 .276.631 1- (fax) 561 .276.3869 August 28, 2012 Bill Thrasher Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Delray Beach, FL 33483 RE: Epstein Residence 1230 N. Ocean Blvd (Lot 6, Hidden Harbor Estates) RECEIVED ., AUG302012 TOwn Of Gulfstream, FL We have revised the hardscape and planting plans for this residence. The overall height of walls, columns and railings, including any lights and wall or column caps, will be 6'. Any chain link fence on the plan will be black vinyl coated and will be screened from off site view by hedge or vine plant material. 6812 8-28-12 let LL- o f8vEE VUMO'l3 `HOVaa nVx�laa o H w z<�= 1701nanNanvx1179nt9810 a— c sxaa llna salsvas W uL x= vGrHO-13 `kWHd.LS 31nJ .. w � l ■ ■ F an la Hvaoo H lzloH ofzl s G ° o V d ¢ o p x � 910rl- SUVISFI'dflOEMVH NF1UalH � a � o � 5 E O U. J 0 of� o ` o ° w W U rc1'• n n ..1. € 0 sI o yWU $ 2 O Z W O❑ p g N 6 O LL F cc cW R Q G a z c ❑<< 3 e z O W F p w Sp 2 N a Woo�oz=� LL a w w a Z aw w ❑s. .2g wg OO VJ (nix 9z mm w D W oaw Z o iO y q FmF O � 2 a g z mww H p wzr Az pm � io ❑ wa w 'u'S rc $ z y�y n ° �� •� o ¢6i ,7, ° F 3 of o0 o Q=wyos .< ° 9 w w yam �o z gm ] o W < m O 2 O Zrw gj a W0 O m S n� O0. HE G> O!j y ZZ o 6 ° Zl s �� w oppm z p mz i c50 0 6Ra10 3 o� iW 11g 9 rc zp g ¢0. "z p gZO 9 °LLm " <W u° rc J ZWWO °F wi ww W w ¢ LL �,'rn' H. p =i '�' LL'O O - '.0 or<n o f p¢, ZO IL 00 p g ° U WZ3 ~�y r. W�� ~° .w o r a ? UWz o * �� `�' d rc Y not 5 o Io eon F 0 ZO pIz d -MiZu1 -ZpW � > °rG 3 �� U �� �F °° oJ -m o 8 ° iO$zYu HN m FN IQw wi § § k W�Oupp 0 f Wgw u ¢ qU- i,i p�F=ao<ui iz0°om9w9 O U0 z _ °° a<Z o wo r3o a ? Uau�sbn7oa4 1 �1zmO- c .04 5 rcU9zmQ�o zdw ii m i u w a �� Y S u SQw pm w wm 3Wo r w=rte ww Aja m ° ZZ q� w� ,°o o of w,ri y �° cparcf ao 5 Zoz xm 4a� ah -Z Qa m o ° < 2 zp Zmk 9 Z >Y� Z-. jp¢(((pJJJ . rcw �u <FF bVQU < �O aF0 Z`� Z� LL WO Z. Q�_ m Uw O7� UW n] p2 Ow~ W H z w Z =e_n YY S p W-. rc °w °° iwp F. YLL o4¢wpe oaym a wo,p < J o z�°. o Is. r��u z m °o � zaTu rp w � oj2< p Fm °ajy < si moo pr 3°moFo z� Z <rcr� Z .,w ¢� i< w w FOF¢ o' z Vow z i rz--- w 0 3� rizswF �m<W D �p OK W O p mUN WO Z O Fao < < °Q< Z Om p2W m pm j Up Z O mZ Z O H i Z W Upw o YF °w § �3 z rc a o Z. m oTii 'eimc°i °3z o'grc�' fp 7%wmz� �m �/� Zfs m w i¢'o aW ° ° =m p oz3w � o Z. m egw -�W " � �Op wF ° � Sy1rc wo V FLL¢m o o pw 'o Wi fm -.0 W., oW u z �yp ¢ S<ui °E~ w o'W www �o m�Op j>p iw olio F 30 4a�w rci moo i W r °m m�< m� z< -i - a I iouoF a 0.0 zci m'm-°m wu aooi�zd o° mm°m px< < aw F orc u�°� z� m i foo w �YLL >g ww qm <LL oz iw °apa ZOti Z OZ ] F> u m WALL '-0',- JU a� UrV W WOV Iw-¢Ua QQp ° 4NR p ipNW�OU OF pw2fw O �U pmY OW °6FU O O� N 2 m°Z OUp m iQ 2 nQ� X�-Q °� 5m �° mom¢ Om O m pUw NS W O wa ° J ax �W OZ KKK NOF o - 7m gw 3 o �W ¢� w izo °uo xi r6 3x mom °° LLW�o ° �ui mp i s o Wi < �f m s �z < � i -0 <i a oow o mz-LL p gm <¢ o o F owe m �, °d rc mpw oim oz LLoo ¢ 9 Jz p wifou� °mo� o oLL oo�a oW o o mY� s oar e�iw o0 ou 'd °W�' p U 1- 9 p0 �zo¢ Fa o o o p p O a�� �8a H 3 1 8 HI �"� wF w� p�� <� zm �a oz Zm Z. zw i� i '''� Z,,L im z i Yg<3 m < fwp �o poF iv rc� aY< ogo— °N z<x u� 3x� oz_ v uFao uw v v 3�a oo mos uwTo is z< cOM U. 3 J3°Uy< w ix-iLL oi3 i¢'u>w ,xi,< xz w '7m xiw¢ w w w �¢ GxG¢rc injO� S grc ° z0 �_F3 �p¢JZ ° � F-- FZF W 1-j HW F Ix -W F hOO Fx-j W w Ix-Ww Ei W -1 .0'. Fw f W JY�� fy 8"' Sam o1O $ �- n� 8o yg oY ��s'o No m rcm ,e0 x F rc- oz.0 a, p< U' a mea uB oo Tu um upm� o,n o` o `oa< o� c�m0 umia w Z V 2Z 7 a = m W N O �O mm < n uo = (fl UHVd''Zar LLY m U0 n w MOrn 1h— � Df- HmW W =W mN U <w D LL u �WiI zErw _ wZ:E< <wUV L5C� LU O< LL�� zamZ� 00 0 LL w 0 Q LL0w � Z J NU) m a Q LLI W Q W Utn�U~ w _ ao LL w t a w z U b O U) LLQ 0 Z_ Q M Np Y 11 Z F- C', ¢ U u W O U J 7 0 m<m W LL Er p� w � W w 0 J it N W W < z R OD E0 (D LL N N F- W O U O LLa' U) O C, Q1 Tk U) < {� = ■ Z N Z Ow W - W LO mw < W w W v; J w ui ❑�QZO O a 0 U w 2 z O , m U m ryj U fn 'P w <Wma O LL t= w o � W Z U� w O F z EL O W O M w z aZ O � 0 0 z z 7 H j w Ir C07 F U m zz > a w N a I --y LL- -a r.-Z L--al.-I O EI ZDT'**Z3 o £St££ VQRI013 `HOV3H AVN I3Q o a a S 0 1701# FIfIN9AV H117 aN 981s C> � r� o■■ p j2! 2s H SHFIGlIf1H 3QISV3S a e x m a x e! VQRIOI3 Y�[V3iILS3Ifl'J = o a Um^''O aa "�Z�` ko o© O a. QA !H NVflDO H L2ION 0£Z! a zF-- a ¢ o 3 9101- SHIVIS3?IflonvH N9QQU. [I r----------� a ru m Z ® N , p lu 7 r O � urOj G� r,ri d a Z 0 0 Q r----------� a ru m Z O m' p w p rO arai N O O � urOj � �aa vpj r,ri d 9 o 0 0 Q w X o m m LLQ F Q d N VOj W m N [ra`7 m aLa O m n O m 2 O v N r 6 N o m n n '� m m o m e Q o ❑r❑iri�oi m N O arai N O �i o W O w O Owl O r,ri d 9 o 0 0 w l<L<o LLQ F Q d a Z rd rL orzp aLa L<�aa O O ra o� O O d o m �, m W O N N O W f71 fll o m m oo �rX 19 Am m Ol W N T A 0-1 (Q y 2 q D ffi w n = 0 LL m w Z O 7 O W u1 K K y a w w w o W Q o j _ w Z rc w oO K nw p� O z o X�i o N g< 6 0 5<� WWW o? ow OLL y U r�90° Jg i o% ww 15 J� LL U �a m w LL z OK yg z ZO 3i rc m 5 0 RE K r OF r O aU ._. N Q W p r U FU LL' Q m FCJ r r W mr 3 U n 6 a Ag d c z O c° m m n � Q y W O _ po O mV O LL Z o m p Go A rr Wow w ¢ U F J m U U r K R Q i W O WO d LL o: 0 2 ze z O Q U a I o a j Z mQo pLLJ W LL' pZ0 W �,n0 �O=R'^WLL o �d33 0 �U� m X...y U2y aaTFO �aQ�OmU< O W K p (W7 a W U ZpZW VC74=m O r a K Y? LL Op OW �Qr�K -'�a°15Zm W CD l o<WZo OmC7 1 1 -O LL Qoom`�902 oomopo r WU on ma���mr°d Q. Ad6 vJ 3 W srat-..zor _ " = Q w £8V££ V(IMO'13 `HDV3E AVd-I3(l 1701 # E[nNHAV HIV HN 981 SHFIC111fis 3QISVHS 0 s a A 4 a a - = Wcca > N a z 1 VQRIO'I3 UvaulS 3 -Ing^- QA1fl NV330 H L2ION 0£Z 1uj ■ ■ m § a ` o 5 ¢ ° z ° W cj O O U o 9101- S3.LVIS9 ZIfIOgHVH N3G C%j o o a w 00 Q. Ad6 vJ 3 W a x z W o u � N 3 U 00 O a< A o�uuuv 3 < < u a O• X � X ryo- W o 000 K¢K aaa ¢rcrc u E E u u aaa 333 000 3 A[ 0 I--44 U = �� o r << W O a« Z. p F�XF--f-�F 7 Z Z 3 2 E 2� 3 3 U U Z S U Z 3 S 2 a F Z Q = D Qxxxxx .I `vI e I U _ e X O < 2 F Z OJ Q O I OE z Y Y r Q O I I I Y zs r Y zs eel o o �-i4 <1 z:-,> PEE .z 11-4 s PET o r-- Q�H z-,> ]-["**a 401# Hf1NHAd H.Lh EIN S8I ry ® -� w �R F3®�Co S'd3ulIIlfl aGISVFIS m LU ' x a e < v■■�r� a. VQRIO"Id `Y�IvamlS A ICIrJ QA IBNVE1JOHLAONO£Zl = a s on v a 42 p 0 = ¢ o a 3 9 lO'l- S9IVIS1 W1O"VH N3UGIH < 0 ° (n!� o o n � � WLU °a 7. COW O 6 M; AC C% Qd RLVLS v ,` 9°`o Yp on� ° + Q Qi E0"I m r _ 0 W+, yl �` 0 n g n� O O o� o o a� a o U P 0 '" t o I �L co i P p JI U �L� N A A 3fr9 E ��0cv a lxvd vg—ty r. I W W cn zi I 3 I I I a I � I 0 W rn z oWc I I 7 v 3y I o a � I N I UU >�- - - - i 2 >W ' Into N I � 1 I ® I i CJ J I 3 � I' I O I N I I � I - F _ -1 I I I II m I I I I I_ I I I s II a / I I I W —— I f oIP� a6PWwQ 1 I I I 'U VI^ CV 13 O ul S a � Q t r ° a'e'aI'o aaol a..ifi� `• �'jii �g s i4 a S Fid S, e'°SSSSSSsa a E1 E3 3 lya It ps d rt?5�1 i PiEE aFl 3 B E11 3-1 1 S�i7 E F lilt l?" diSiab aJS Pa S111 jib gg S. Eta ff !C Sa E a 3 3 P 1 °@fit a='Fi a§! t; E 339 IT ! § g;` ;�'ff•ff 776"; M 1;1jr ! a@ 1 a : 193 i sE3 Ee stiff; $ ,gEj !fit Js gsi Ey ��$ a E'�fm }� � 3'! a�• i tai a I it Hd* ffi9;Ea 3EFsl 114 # i �i da" -t -` 3 4-6till ?3 a 112 #its F a d d U ;��'�; siti t fill. 1piS ltsg is Il; S?�i3 dl a[? ;SSE g�: �gi! Nil IM It 11 M ! ` _ a is � gill! ?���� E h1� alt Pal; EE _�,P 8�4y� da;r;i lg 1 ,sr a si; IN a y; ' EaFa ;lam all plqy# s f3pil Em 5-"'$' ;:� �ag?a tiff tIii i $ '�3;FaE ! t$4ta4 131 ! y3i ?a 3F =t} 3 1' F 1ax-R.�_l s 1:p1 H'i ?-E64 :?gypp F3 AlEES �?3 F3E` g?i �'E i a 3 ]liltll -#. t dP 5 Wit Ill � �� E;56a��E�i3�E+g➢ �aff c a gjlii ;g9 ; g� si���zBe=ja;•��F a;�#it 4 t_z- !3 1�c3:�ff?i'i$Pt� fie,€a1 %ES1i ; _� ' 1�t 9�g1F a?3a is EL SF11 Yl�a�BEp;gf a 3 S a i 3 ¢� E� iF 5E 41$12, ;+��-Faat�jma33 8 S!2 F!i §�1Ei51 �a3 pP tat?af+g Eigi ff . S $s3 :P i s E JON ti, g$:y fit fid= °es=;y a 1 i� 7ay#$ t ft3� 9,SS 2 ; E '� -37 ; ail-iE a 1 O bal iF �F ! it d 1 i E n 1al' a4F •F #li #Y8 tE y;� df�li8�14 E Et On aa7a 3 a it 72E 3 Eo6�n I :i• It!'? SE a 112Pz Iq?jjE=$ Fo•i!I°E' isl E9911a a hill j3 3 3SE' 41" tI d.6t F �.?:1 a p;� ioi?1 t�l� §gSSgatii#s3 F y8: F 33?b JFEF 11iEB 7t t.7 F ?_ 1g =§3s t-siaa§Ease&a3a:Z € ?-'�?i FU!' F O d a U 0) 0) " N° Y '19 p 41 C 9° c ~�9 O Q j u 0 a O `° i9!k L +y C U mTrjbi p p'" m U u o iJ. W N RQ 0 07°o I., u 9142 �rAa u3 jCo 3p of WRift �flt R'- E Ell $ I VIM Ap Ili 11M ig -6 fill }4a o �t3.5 sa 5� X8 1 9 $ �$ !$ l SUP ° d : ° e d e to E a� ����° 1 4 i� 9y 4 a z 1,) 9 15 Fc all 9 I tit s j_?- !� 3 ► z 3� �F p 2ylj siF i a=�n�E EE ;'3; 16 7����6�9#t� �7�3 �,!�� till �i tait10'1��?1111�51�'_;;, s3 ; i 8p�.= jea��i9S i P; ai'ff 9EE;# ;?3ai +�y; of it,=aEiE• d� ;�i�'E-� � �•�; `�a FE-°� bia y ?IEE., a _ •E�3; aji"Y �`,; fflu d U d etch it itaIN-1 —1; Ills!;i1• a9E9Ejt s'tE3 !a ¢ flfl 5gt.3 i$E'a :$ rE $ 3 a 9-1: E yl� $ Y53• P5E ;:: $; It dP ll � S�aF ;p d at7 ;SRS; 3'?s jl� e' . E`� 5 ;1§5i$ r i3#a •j c3 � 1g+3�g ,!§ �,E a jE tj; fl 3i,2jn3 ��il4a F•rij E7P1 m7a • flIL Ffi4ji 1 ���1 sslilE,ri;pEs Fbt lF t 2i8i Y#;4 a . i�a ;gig?3E;pS& S-3 3 sFai g5 � � ; � E F' ?i ;Ef E3g;%.�a ; ;2@3g.�fe�� Ski tall a I E is Is lgFa� E?� i Pati 4 Is E1 j4F6 Im1i t2. °t N1131 _ °�$ � 1 5 �,;g2 1-1;;41 g e ? , 1 �? is F k' Fp !11 .ar gg ? & Efi S 1.��4 i77E. 'fid yl' F - E`1 E` F ?IMI : UrIz?$F trig Fa ji d w i d a � 1 Fa;l6 rl 7F;i ?? ss F f E a till phi .;E i_Etj•3- 1;mayy t 4E EaS a H??i:s § lE1§ I;ES+ Y �E7 6 � ts• � 1 3� ;�d F7'� jiiilli M1 gl1gy; �E °�3 p$¢pp f�, t y 9��&rg�c��a �3 r �lils=3t I FsF?2c J D W . O'N d d U •a as F ? 3_ z a wE€! t ,Sa 13 sy s 1 ; - 4� I� 1 J' 3� &N, y I Il' F�S� lit? i` � sla $i- €� a#3Lad 3E.a tt33 ;E3 d ?•4 zt 1:?111;lE g dE7 t-; F tic bPt g �� ;fid¢•' ! ! a? P P$ S� " S' 'S e E $'y # - islg : E E"--' E aE Bia @8 t!! 4' a a .E y•aas^ 3t5 Q l a? ;d?3 §S aFs.Sy+ ?tie°• fi �Y IFS a$ t E:7 g3 E$ s Y n z y s'.E 6yaa9s g Fg 25:n Stg �2a sESE� Ett E Eg 4 S -w: s IN -11h a=;#?E d` gi d EI�• r tE.F �a �' rt .a as3; s. 31 kT. -! $ f = E ? i : : € tic, ;dl`a j ?? it $ i i tF la; EAIgt Y §m a=$ a ag.; F .b ala �_ E 3 ?Fta?y % y8e a a a'F. Y ? 1 1F _ 'Et _ .IaE F a&°e Sa F p .°5 L a g PpE_3= j= p! iia a'2 3 E n ;;ol!rESE # ?€E a Y s'�L8EE8 $;Fa§�F 3p tH i•: s 4 Es{{it 80 {�{iE> =EE3E , 5;n8 s s a sac# y k3 - t3S=E p lE§ "9F2. §o, E$ ;� R2 U11 = ;;$; S E Yy1D'_) aE;�l4'1 F �i a 8S E6R3at�sy g 5$3S? ;i it •? a Eiy �E3e y a #3 Fol gol Ea ?"� E 8 43 :g8 a58�E; FeF i�� S�FF iFS aiF - r i iay 7 '? rt ? tt•� "Ti Tim t .� d 1s76=„ _�`;u t -1 p$ D4 $E_ 3 Rini 7. P :air ; 6 z31?'!€l a3= ii. �a _3 i3 t t a��1i t F ua8 y" ; s Fi e_?i_- aoa$•75 ?�i= = °➢.5 ER '4 6 3� Ei r• F ff PEy E&§?S 9 s m. a3cs3t y ?aF$ $ °� 5: § ?;� g E ! S•= a 4 " ? a F - ?; u § 3 r gel �i 1� � a s 1 ' F1a1==�F $p = y; F aF.E=E� 4 E y e !FI $$� n .li d_ E d7§�aPE F :§33 # F3 c Y73 ��;y31§$F _5's IN U d d !j ff S n FgFa ! ;E !6 Fay' 3 E 5 F ; :.:::: t6i F= s€ 33:= i i ip S s y!a a t. y Z Ea E3'• l ? �'o'ouauna v.. Ea @® 3_13 i ,s Ea.e �'S 1. J. ?E ti? E' $: � Wi aEo i # I�,..aF_§ 7° S �3 0 4 S E SaE•i� r•d ` $ff:: !i as a 3zF ?t yi Ea ESQ E 'iia 23§ i ; a "$'ir ° a�aasaasaas, p F p E, a3�&.= as =. iE3 s, ?t ?fl• a".:.;.::4�3 i �� 3$7�. ;833? $ 5�F E 5a 'zEa a c 7 sg7§ a 3 . ; ay$?$! E Fki_-E 3 a a sat• pr i I — $ a�'•"� ;- �t4-5 1�' •ppE-g a ? : a?'!i�?=3s a' a i E' E 7a?5fi E13k 9 a8'S F' '• ,1; It-; �i �ES E'E E. x e ' # s §� �. ?s°4i {i F.E 43- y E E s sa ;. a �Y d d 4 3 11ff ?s'i E? 3 by' E-61 = 1g ia, Sa# 3 1 E $a -z,e z`Ea ?= E E Et n y :l ; y 3F ;iya:: g.is$P � s��a�a�• 33E 5F ; 1a333a '" •; �a? � !ee fi t i Si F'In l EO a; d ?E m=3# i ,?;•E; F,.� 3?a E a s ' t 3 a2 E E -'7 ° E•EE�° 6 g - ;�sa t a3 i y t 4i a? i t 9 t P i_ •Y 5 t "d �° a aS l#-. 'Hi Ea Ili;!.!] Aax_ ES= a - Y - z i=s # Y s �- i m E i�EF s4. =3 ; i §§_ ; g yFe "; :j a=5 E: F•3 t 7'a ;; 3 E 38 3 9 �3 3'3aF9 ?i _;D '.' a3= $l $ •s $ iEE E S.g t Eas Eff� �7 �• a� �" ink F'€ �yr� ffF�•a a `1 �? �' �y:ES$�F§ �• g F�3 �� F� E��1P' ' $;i ?lst�•1 a ;s�sy � a �4P- d a,•e^§ g� 1E 78.3 E�5;b�5 ti ff $i F ;� n t fy ipas iii : i'g dp � _=F F fEo s= dE:S. 5 a -E! 3a° i ..n+ i ii Ci Ean l=E �o� l 9: � n _ D a W Cj ^ � O O •{•d p 0. Z� O CV °� Qf O u J; SO N o� (0 W F- 1 Q r A\ W Q m LU LLj Cn ® �o 3 a it 72E 3 Eo6�n I :i• It!'? SE a 112Pz Iq?jjE=$ Fo•i!I°E' isl E9911a a hill j3 3 3SE' 41" tI d.6t F �.?:1 a p;� ioi?1 t�l� §gSSgatii#s3 F y8: F 33?b JFEF 11iEB 7t t.7 F ?_ 1g =§3s t-siaa§Ease&a3a:Z € ?-'�?i FU!' F O d a U 0) 0) " N° Y '19 p 41 C 9° c ~�9 O Q j u 0 a O `° i9!k L +y C U mTrjbi p p'" m U u o iJ. W N RQ 0 07°o I., u 9142 �rAa u3 jCo 3p of WRift �flt R'- E Ell $ I VIM Ap Ili 11M ig -6 fill }4a o �t3.5 sa 5� X8 1 9 $ �$ !$ l SUP ° d : ° e d e to E a� ����° 1 4 i� 9y 4 a z 1,) 9 15 Fc all 9 I tit s j_?- !� 3 ► z 3� �F p 2ylj siF i a=�n�E EE ;'3; 16 7����6�9#t� �7�3 �,!�� till �i tait10'1��?1111�51�'_;;, s3 ; i 8p�.= jea��i9S i P; ai'ff 9EE;# ;?3ai +�y; of it,=aEiE• d� ;�i�'E-� � �•�; `�a FE-°� bia y ?IEE., a _ •E�3; aji"Y �`,; fflu d U d etch it itaIN-1 —1; Ills!;i1• a9E9Ejt s'tE3 !a ¢ flfl 5gt.3 i$E'a :$ rE $ 3 a 9-1: E yl� $ Y53• P5E ;:: $; It dP ll � S�aF ;p d at7 ;SRS; 3'?s jl� e' . E`� 5 ;1§5i$ r i3#a •j c3 � 1g+3�g ,!§ �,E a jE tj; fl 3i,2jn3 ��il4a F•rij E7P1 m7a • flIL Ffi4ji 1 ���1 sslilE,ri;pEs Fbt lF t 2i8i Y#;4 a . i�a ;gig?3E;pS& S-3 3 sFai g5 � � ; � E F' ?i ;Ef E3g;%.�a ; ;2@3g.�fe�� Ski tall a I E is Is lgFa� E?� i Pati 4 Is E1 j4F6 Im1i t2. °t N1131 _ °�$ � 1 5 �,;g2 1-1;;41 g e ? , 1 �? is F k' Fp !11 .ar gg ? & Efi S 1.��4 i77E. 'fid yl' F - E`1 E` F ?IMI : UrIz?$F trig Fa ji d w i d a � 1 Fa;l6 rl 7F;i ?? ss F f E a till phi .;E i_Etj•3- 1;mayy t 4E EaS a H??i:s § lE1§ I;ES+ Y �E7 6 � ts• � 1 3� ;�d F7'� jiiilli M1 gl1gy; �E °�3 p$¢pp f�, t y 9��&rg�c��a �3 r �lils=3t I FsF?2c J D W . O'N d d U •a as F ? 3_ z a wE€! t ,Sa 13 sy s 1 ; - 4� I� 1 J' 3� &N, y I Il' F�S� lit? i` � sla $i- €� a#3Lad 3E.a tt33 ;E3 d ?•4 zt 1:?111;lE g dE7 t-; F tic bPt g �� ;fid¢•' ! ! a? P P$ S� " S' 'S e E $'y # - islg : E E"--' E aE Bia @8 t!! 4' a a .E y•aas^ 3t5 Q l a? ;d?3 §S aFs.Sy+ ?tie°• fi �Y IFS a$ t E:7 g3 E$ s Y n z y s'.E 6yaa9s g Fg 25:n Stg �2a sESE� Ett E Eg 4 S -w: s IN -11h a=;#?E d` gi d EI�• r tE.F �a �' rt .a as3; s. 31 kT. -! $ f = E ? i : : € tic, ;dl`a j ?? it $ i i tF la; EAIgt Y §m a=$ a ag.; F .b ala �_ E 3 ?Fta?y % y8e a a a'F. Y ? 1 1F _ 'Et _ .IaE F a&°e Sa F p .°5 L a g PpE_3= j= p! iia a'2 3 E n ;;ol!rESE # ?€E a Y s'�L8EE8 $;Fa§�F 3p tH i•: s 4 Es{{it 80 {�{iE> =EE3E , 5;n8 s s a sac# y k3 - t3S=E p lE§ "9F2. §o, E$ ;� R2 U11 = ;;$; S E Yy1D'_) aE;�l4'1 F �i a 8S E6R3at�sy g 5$3S? ;i it •? a Eiy �E3e y a #3 Fol gol Ea ?"� E 8 43 :g8 a58�E; FeF i�� S�FF iFS aiF - r i iay 7 '? rt ? tt•� "Ti Tim t .� d 1s76=„ _�`;u t -1 p$ D4 $E_ 3 Rini 7. P :air ; 6 z31?'!€l a3= ii. �a _3 i3 t t a��1i t F ua8 y" ; s Fi e_?i_- aoa$•75 ?�i= = °➢.5 ER '4 6 3� Ei r• F ff PEy E&§?S 9 s m. a3cs3t y ?aF$ $ °� 5: § ?;� g E ! S•= a 4 " ? a F - ?; u § 3 r gel �i 1� � a s 1 ' F1a1==�F $p = y; F aF.E=E� 4 E y e !FI $$� n .li d_ E d7§�aPE F :§33 # F3 c Y73 ��;y31§$F _5's IN U d d !j ff S n FgFa ! ;E !6 Fay' 3 E 5 F ; :.:::: t6i F= s€ 33:= i i ip S s y!a a t. y Z Ea E3'• l ? �'o'ouauna v.. Ea @® 3_13 i ,s Ea.e �'S 1. J. ?E ti? E' $: � Wi aEo i # I�,..aF_§ 7° S �3 0 4 S E SaE•i� r•d ` $ff:: !i as a 3zF ?t yi Ea ESQ E 'iia 23§ i ; a "$'ir ° a�aasaasaas, p F p E, a3�&.= as =. iE3 s, ?t ?fl• a".:.;.::4�3 i �� 3$7�. ;833? $ 5�F E 5a 'zEa a c 7 sg7§ a 3 . ; ay$?$! E Fki_-E 3 a a sat• pr i I — $ a�'•"� ;- �t4-5 1�' •ppE-g a ? : a?'!i�?=3s a' a i E' E 7a?5fi E13k 9 a8'S F' '• ,1; It-; �i �ES E'E E. x e ' # s §� �. ?s°4i {i F.E 43- y E E s sa ;. a �Y d d 4 3 11ff ?s'i E? 3 by' E-61 = 1g ia, Sa# 3 1 E $a -z,e z`Ea ?= E E Et n y :l ; y 3F ;iya:: g.is$P � s��a�a�• 33E 5F ; 1a333a '" •; �a? � !ee fi t i Si F'In l EO a; d ?E m=3# i ,?;•E; F,.� 3?a E a s ' t 3 a2 E E -'7 ° E•EE�° 6 g - ;�sa t a3 i y t 4i a? i t 9 t P i_ •Y 5 t "d �° a aS l#-. 'Hi Ea Ili;!.!] Aax_ ES= a - Y - z i=s # Y s �- i m E i�EF s4. =3 ; i §§_ ; g yFe "; :j a=5 E: F•3 t 7'a ;; 3 E 38 3 9 �3 3'3aF9 ?i _;D '.' a3= $l $ •s $ iEE E S.g t Eas Eff� �7 �• a� �" ink F'€ �yr� ffF�•a a `1 �? �' �y:ES$�F§ �• g F�3 �� F� E��1P' ' $;i ?lst�•1 a ;s�sy � a �4P- d a,•e^§ g� 1E 78.3 E�5;b�5 ti ff $i F ;� n t fy ipas iii : i'g dp � _=F F fEo s= dE:S. 5 a -E! 3a° i ..n+ i ii Ci Ean l=E �o� l 9: � n _ 0 W J LL31z Q q�4dW Q zz� 0 Q�m� Q oQ��cs O '' 1 �CipQZ oKUzo J5 SLU NC, 0 Q5 m oz��z M ^W LO QiZZ� o�Zz Z WOOS `Z Opo Z Zce-Um O � Q Q W b e 'MV On IN J++ty` Q � PDX 4 o 'gK iS onGMOM K a x Q R� w �1��3W 01 "G�1 C) I cam' ATE �PNF °40'1�N, n n Ei a3�� 0.13°o'S 3,IW ARC = 5122' -CA. = 27.57170" RAMS = X7500' M4NAGE EASEACN (RA 7- B" 3G PAGE 1X1) ARC= 3298' -CA = 6.2"24V7 - RAMS = 3L20' 290' I °I l2.0' t5L TL —ARC = 4192' LI P) I� �n ffi db" � �eI IMd --o I� m CD �O o � m �ti a CD ao �q I I a � ~ b I I " I N � a T \f a o N LO �# s A I) I �PiL,9TF J I IT_ 27181 NF3r3i�_ LZO'PRVAIE 1t7A0AICD PAG fASgEN� (PLAT 60pC 3$ PACE' IV __ 3H38_NP3f3T` Al � r a o p l2.0' t5L TL —ARC = 4192' LI P) CA = 89'38'52' RAQt.6 = 26.7.9' k '�' -07"v ffi db" � �eI IMd --o I� LO �# s A I) I �PiL,9TF J I IT_ 27181 NF3r3i�_ LZO'PRVAIE 1t7A0AICD PAG fASgEN� (PLAT 60pC 3$ PACE' IV __ 3H38_NP3f3T` Al � r a o p TTL-------------...... N LI P) �O mZ m CD �O o � m �ti � CD ® 5.1'5240"W. �l 8aoo' o g g TRA mCvxcarol 5152'40"'W. TRA�C"q S I I� I 30 00' 143.42' OI 29.0' 1 PG XJ1.00' S 152'40'W S 1°52'40"Waor 4).12.42' Pc 55.58' : ' 30. ti 20&5'N 4J'05 'W. 2 85,58' $.1524 "W. IV XP WA MR EA.STEM 6NN 1f N15240E �I SP I Iz I u$ r—fi- I I I.CO eg I I� MrfM Iw I I� FTT Ll t o �w w a a s o0 0 Ln �I I Iti Ln b I loll I .� cn=WA RE 7.48' S V 48' 40 W. 140. �� '10224' VE Lzae'ERLor S 10o - _�AtAr 484p"!4! 93.38 p.0 � sL'rPRM 30.11' � Z�� 237.49'65320"1 /114.Or - EAST (y1E-LOTS 4_B�FYArXi PALE'75J YV. - _ STA iE ROAD r _A -1--A _ N�LAr L014 �N X1 Pq-4 1 =3 D c rn 0-%__ OC G7 _.................................... N_..... TTL-------------...... �," .._P__...0 mZ m CD c >O o v CD ® -4 LOT 1 LOT 1 Lp�sv�rf c4swff OBIfMGF FASL747pfr J DWM4EfAMWNro M77 fm 1RACT A' — ` (� f7J C g I I } * HIJ 6 fQD ,no s w 2z r O y +v f.2 Cb fQD ,no s w 2z i 0 m ci c a' o nD.v c c m o s o o m vD z O o o m g 00 MQ O J N ° 3 0 7 b(D m K n 3 < c �• m m m m z d n m ID M OrtID :1 O u-i m O N m p rt O O N -s v n C -i w -0 N ie wm° 3 h a' fl s o N a m O rn o O v 0 Z m Z CL CL cl IDL U; iD n 0 °' m m O m a p0—t N C a' a+ c m w m p D= 70 w m' -0 CL x ° p'�, N< n- < m rt rtt m o 0`„0 3 m 03 < C (p rt pl n Va Q to Q °< 0 f) (� O N _ O 0 ''� N psi S m ID ID ;a Z D O < °- 1^ 3 a 0 3 -I p < o N A o o, o° s E o° , aq m o ° y �c Z e m a m S "' o N m O d 0 m �, Z ,m D n ° m o s m a a m Q 3 c09 Q 3 S 3 N a v f+ ' v pa O _ n m s L o r i D x g (D Li s� o ° °c 33 p'–� i� a Z o o a m m c w m m vm v o m y S S O m to C m m m m N .y p 0 4c n m Z n w ,,, r-+ m o< u x a 0 ,�'+ tl 3 W m m< as d a o D ' Lnp7 ;T° 'L O �^ m �^ O O 07 n N 2 ID or S o° m O rt rt C N ° A 1n to W 0 C O d OG 50m N .-Sr .0 N -i w H w ru a 4 s X o< :+ m< umi H I ^ `� o° m m e `" c '" °' m o D m e w. v O '� < a s m c y 3 fn , H 3 � gz.+m `N" O v o 3 v � m �° ID S 3 a 3 " 0 3 .°irt a' K O 'O c -0 fl-wm w m '+ O?° m H m r oC ? ' m A'.m 0C O C*a 3cp 0aC cA C2 4 : r- mgY�O W o V x � � w l LC D r y � r y I y i o I � ' i , I O � l –�—i. Q ° o HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES -LOT 6 t7' 1230 NORTH OCEAN BLVD. a �e� �■■ j� CD C= z � GULF STREAM, FLORIDA z SEASIDE BUILDERS T - c 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104 e " ®■ o DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 l�IC HA1�D ,J O NE S -A,.- -1 --U U. NU PA " IMXL PLANS, DESIGNS, UR INFORMATION NAY BE REPRODUCED, COPIED LN UTILIZED 6RAPHILALLY IN ANY FORM VHATSOVER WIrADUT THE EXPRESS VATUEN CONSENT OF RICHARD JONES ARCHITECTURE IAVORPURATER a; N rt 9 CD c -r CD C rt O Z; G -i p f: n o co m C= _o 4� co O ®N O C--) M V-� m CCDO rnC m N A o� N o� rt buo 77 otlP R y>U tl< d 3 Q V/ G -i p f: n o co m C= _o 4� co   �� ZGI��ATE ROAD A_I_e I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I �� I I I I I I I I I I I I I ��g I m a ' o C,0 m2 �� �� C pp �� $ gg SO Laz I G) O a ti A v N 'w m : z m z ��N3y3JJL �� m �� �� O . D $ ��cn F--' N V :* ^' 1 r CD C= rn 3 N v g r ��g I m a ' o C,0 m2 �� �� C pp �� $ gg SO 9 vl O y O gg I G) O a ti A v N 'w m o g3E Na 8508 OF AUIHaimy Beach, Way Delroy 9laoh. Florida 33444 F.. 581 274-9558 ��g I m " � �� 1 fr �� �� `l C pp �� $ gg SO 9 vl O y O gg I G) O a ti 9��g czi$ o g3E Na 8508 OF AUIHaimy Beach, Way Delroy 9laoh. Florida 33444 F.. 581 274-9558 m z �� D m T ~Nf 2M.Nve 2 ��  +KNeM.. i x N. FedmfHwy �� rx: rro tiro ." v I�� NMew��Me y O "tl o p ' N o + rb N x I O m > zv \ N b ed td m ENGINEERS EnviroDesign n-xx Asociates sen" ��devgn com RONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR: LOT 6  HARBOR VIEW ESTATES 1230 N. OCEAN BOULEVARD GULFSTREAM, FLORIDA IT VAS JDYlH A. MIS. �%.L R REO / 426" �ATE "��""101a sr: FLORIDA 298 C Grow PineoA 1. Grow Phone: 581 274-8500 Na 8508 OF AUIHaimy Beach, Way Delroy 9laoh. Florida 33444 F.. 581 274-9558 00 > labo > A 9?� Alz m .5 60V Fn is.*� z 8 p >8 2 --q 31 C0 > m z ;u m Fn 1+ gem —r J Jim p WN. Z47' 4e*.11r ap l 0 z gig . . . . . . . . . . IM I Z mak a, 11 > IK jig 1.50- 00 EYI F 0 I R >m log, g 41 1 5 0 2 z No OTTBig Zr. .!w OTT 0 EIE > > Lu > ze3 28 X .50 ;u > > o z m ig X Ell , 4 ZI 0 K) iS F31m F--, r cn CD C=D rn 0 7 (�JE AIr.D..11!, vmw.emtlesign mm ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PAVING & DRAIANGE DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 6 - 1230 N OCEAN BLVD STREAM, FLORIDA 1 �� JOSM A. PIKE. P.L Fl. M f 42"G �. "M NEVOMM FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTI�YM N. 8505 Ir, altr lie G� Way Doi FloridaFlorlcla 33444 298 Pb7LF Ph (55 ) 7"5DO I= (581) 274-0558 I Pm Cfn= Z OEM < Z o (< ZC j e z' EOe Ftj`J \ > MAP l �O CmG z i W A Z7 5�x� 4Qoo$ �ZP N z Se m npti3 \ (7 D Q, z o I II=11 V) _ i rn I X —II I S m r r m 0> N �o< I II—III U Z = siP 'P>� z w m j z ®® gay 1 1 m y 1 —� I I—I 1 P z ; 4 �?TN yn N Z <> s T mc� o° co P. i p 4 I IF9 I T III PPPP o Tm zOz I (- 00 Z m —1 pp�e � � L Z g ' 2• YeL $E \P31 N =11 I P 11111111 Ilala P -11_ 111 P m � o Z 0 0 c') O ;� a M cz C o M 0 C e_ 3 m and . N o � ► SEPTIC SYSTEM DETAILS FOR: NUT YAW No DAM REM1013:E,lo.lmlti ,� .y: o m EnviroDesign p w N x\ •• b m f Assoaietes ,„� HARBOR VIEW ESTATES ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS LOT 6 — 1230 N OCEAN BLVD FLDRIUA cennFlcATE or AuniamzAna+ NAd6 GULF STREAM FLORIDA 298 Phsopple Grow Way Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Ja3ElB A. MM P.E.Phone: 581 274-8500 F= � R RED / 4RlM 581 274-8558 v D L33 �>Z m o�a Z Im 96 101 \ m 11M �M z z m v $ m D r °� � 24 wn 4 ro'J�J�� n n m h 0 o g \ <� h Z n n 0 Q\ h n �{ u'1 p yT a o en x 1 O N \ N 7 4 N F de M1il Hwy POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN FOR:�T LOT 6 —HARBOR VIEW ESTATES 1230 N. OCEAN BOULEVARD GULFSTREAM FLORIDA � m 010�'� Q•, JOSH A. PKL ►.L R KQ 0 42w! MM an '�� If. p FLDRM)A cmnFlCAIE 29B PI,;)wWe Gmw Phone 961 274-8500 (v wI"rla"U'p" N. °'°° Way Ddray Booch• Florldo 33444 Fore 561 274 -OW 17 v , L__ cn O " o A o en x 1 O N \ N ENGINEERS EnviroDesign Associates n . waw.em:aev9n.mm NMENTAL CONSULTANTS POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN FOR:�T LOT 6 —HARBOR VIEW ESTATES 1230 N. OCEAN BOULEVARD GULFSTREAM FLORIDA � m 010�'� Q•, JOSH A. PKL ►.L R KQ 0 42w! MM an '�� If. p FLDRM)A cmnFlCAIE 29B PI,;)wWe Gmw Phone 961 274-8500 (v wI"rla"U'p" N. °'°° Way Ddray Booch• Florldo 33444 Fore 561 274 -OW TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-12 Address: 1220 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Seaside Builders, LLC Construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with a bonus room above, a total of 8,603 SF, and a swimming pool. Gross Lot size: 54,102 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 8,603 SF Zoning District: RS -O Finished Floor: 16.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Effective Lot Area: 39,911 SF Allowable: 10,582 SF Height: 28' 10" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval to allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics and providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #012-12 ARPB September 27, 2012; TC October 12, 2012 Page 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, a 3 car garage with a bonus room, a total of 8,603 SF, and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. The roof shall be white (through and through) un -textured uncoated flat cement tile. 3. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 4. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 5. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view ARPB Date: October 25, 2012 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Recommend approval as submitted on drawings with the exception of the 13' clear zone and further recommended that there be binding documents and provisions that hold the HOA responsible for maintaining the prescribed landscaping in the buffer area. It was also recommended that the site screen as detailed in the plans be provided by the Developer to the best of his ability. (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend Approval as submitted with the five conditions listed above, along with binding documents and provisions that hold the HOA responsible for maintaining the prescribed landscaping in the buffer area. Also recommended that the site screen as detailed in the plans and agreed to by the Developer be provided by the Developer to the best of his ability. (5-0) TC Date: November 9, 2012 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as submitted on drawings with the exception of the 13 ft clear zone. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Approved as submitted with the 5 conditions listed above and provided a deed restriction is placed on the property making the HOA responsible for maintaining the landscape material in the buffer area on the private property as shown on the exhibit attached to the deed restriction, with the hedge to be maintained at a height of no less than 6', and further provided that a 6' temporary construction fence with screening material attached be installed inside the buffer area. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPR0I CU7 uh i►.,_ This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File 11 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name:440d% J — Fsk�"e 11 -IL -C I.A.2. Project Address: _ �^ �l I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: �5e2 I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, includin^ 11 of cf^rioc nf, I -see I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: &0 Architectural Style: �q� r YY1 U OL 1.A.6. Check all that apply.�-Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures 0 Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: ' l L4 , dD Type of Foundation: STEMW tRt.a B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address:Q I.13.2. Owner Phone Number., • la• q Fax: _C�i L I.B.3. Owner Signature:_ C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date:_ App Date: Com Date: Decision: IcPe�sIr 1-12- - cel U1 '�� � Fax Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: U 2; i 5,4 t ►,114 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 I.A.4 Project Description: Lot 4: The project will consist of a two story residence with Bermuda style influences. It will have a detached 3 -car garage with Bonus Room above. It will be a courtyard style house with pool and motor court. Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question. number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? Yes ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan?>0yes ❑ No Explain. IILA.4. flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? i C t_ How are the following utilities to be provided to Stormwater Drainage 1 Cal Sanitary Sewer Potable Water s-� ,�" �Ad ffickwj_ Irrigation Water Elec`-'- Telel Gas Cab 111 III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the pMject involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 19 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes 18'No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV -A-3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑Yes o (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV -A-5. Does the pr ' ct require approval of a Special Exception? El Yes No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the projec t variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes UrNo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be -di ---t ct or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Descriuc uie need and justification for the-fttmtrmee/addition: WE IV.13.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes 0 I n Explain: _fin � A- Z V l U(aA Q`:�3-1 L,--)1,`411 `-W� IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? pvY i &X- O pq�n ��aS �v a-llai,� �u�r -� `�"bw►r1s �-�- #•{-fie (�`c�.�-�1'�G� - IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the yeast impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District.(-- are retwoo-t p•� f'\v r 'aA R CAZ —X' -fit `f Ee/A CLC�P-m-en+ w Mn V1aJ i d"C SIgecie) C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? / IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? 2Q IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? LN) D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: sah IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: _aC) "-NL CL'{ -(0^,.- w � � Af PJ, h Nae'( &Xkhc J -e to Q t, +;� 'LAI i 110—a"i'C ", IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? cC.(0&. Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 1220 N Ocean Blvd. B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit IV.B.1 What significant landscape features are to be added and to what extent? Addition of native plants in most areas of the 50'corridor, and provide an area for the Town's street tree program. Also a 6' wall or railing 39' at its closest point to the property line. a "wTn 01 Vulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Code Comprehensive Plan text change, orany Zoning combination otnc haereof, plea a Land Use Map change, justification for the request. describe the need and PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants, Applicants additional relevant information regarding the projethatwas not covered elsewhere on thisged, but not f to provide any the other materials submitted with the application. s form or on any of /4 r PQ 1- %j V1 0 1- C--� Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 0 I► � •ate �e c , v r i .1� �J r  Ll X J1 Ad OS:bS:Z Z[N/Sl/8 `bmP'ONg SVNl\mG1A aogaoH V S s}oI SVNIVIN O uj C* C14 J LL W N L g $ > Otu F F: = o < DAF fig ' ON CSL Jg i1�� _ -F i 0. p I  rp / 03Y V 3" J 'DIY Y M1EOf Nauu` a'miv^N10WH Y LLiQO 1��R ��7l Y r1QWS ��1111�� ( IH NYHOO lei OZZI  t ,LO'I S 511US H MBIA 2IO aZIVH :2103 iVId S,LNaNaA02IdNI HLUS UMO BSSB YLZ pt x4- YYi�� -ptotmw Kine o a BOBS 'oN NOLLVZIHOHLOY d0 3LY��IiLLL37 OOSB iLZ L9S ,, o m old Ru B6Z VOBgIi q w ����9 ��i \ N q c pzq p 1 x'� Q N ��' p A -H lm -P -AN SixvsznsxoO WJNHNxo wm-ucrsaF��.uaMwn Se OJI U61S8(jQO-1!nU3 �% / J SuaHxiAJxH �� a ru MHOMIAW taro uj C* C14 J LL W N L g $ > Otu F F: = o < DAF fig ' ON CSL Jg i1�� _ -F i 0. p I cn . WV WI bI ` A -H lm -P -AN u s - uj C* C14 J LL W N L g $ > Otu F F: = o < DAF fig ' ON CSL Jg i1�� _ -F i 0. p I -I F -1 F . _ E o �� UJ E 3 - gill O N caN Ips J w�� II _ < W r " m I CD �� ��0 00Lu u rj O -I F -1 F  Ll X ,Jl `Ad 65:L5:Z 2106/5l/8 `6MP'11a b101 S Nl\b 101\M@IA aogJDH V �� S4O] gtNl\Z N\:0 ti � N �� CKI y r N ua AL ct o U CD a t) ,�� �� 2W �� aao�� a3 Q n < Pool 0 o  os x u H f9 z H Z �� II i Z 9162 z ��w :oo c4H i i 00 D m 3wa ail a q�� ��.s ;" ri:i �� >  �� : c nim . f zl- a n 4 d d r mo 8 mo Z dj 9 WF $ 1tiz-- _'raln wag 19 �� ��z J RE d Z F Q rc i F1 I lJ<, mi ee lag �� -4s _ J ti 00 ��" ��` f ���"  ��aI2i0'I3 `I��'��2I,LS ,3'In��J ���� .cz ass xo�� Dose �%cz ins ������ 7Y 'DIW Y H13COf Yfti�f oPVbLi '4-9 AdMO ��(oM ��vJ ��Id��4d BBZ ONO ^��N NOLLVZINOfLLlIV ��0 3LVOLiLLfm VUINOl! aAZH i��'Ha0 DI OzzT  fi ,LO'I ssxvsznsxo�� zv,tNaRxoxituta " s��taHxrOxa N �� z .�� s HsVss H Mein xo gxVx ��-,z,=; �� ��1 ��" ��,O '� ,�� u :xo3 sm��saa HOt��xa V LL- O rtinva ���� o ON cv ��B��Saao��l ��3 ��/>  LL X jL 'Md `bmFlla-- 1iM SbOZL\b 10-I\M@IA aogaoH S4o1 s'vOn\nMO \:0 N Ef Q �� > N `�� UJ0 Q�� O?�� W Q$ z�� o R �� a of z z ��I I I r II II �� U z S�� -L C _ dart' _Li I n 3��S aav  r ,S'B 1- ap U El MOO Ire s1rCo p�� b �� �� F SII x�� 4 I �IA �� a w��  oz ai F o, od lV W��W\ Z`1 W _ (73 <ri 1111 II I o z��5 W x =^ o0 - -I I 1 � W L � 5r, it y o _  11  Woao ��$ id �� p oil W rYSb K�� o= i o d��zoz' Q da J �� CNG w�� zn 0 z o zc pt xa z 3zo L ibD s��5 J �'" ��' f ��QI2I0'I,3 `NI����2i,LS 3'In`J else-r`z ass =-A Dose-rcz ass --4d 7'd '371Y 'tl HLSOf YYYf� OPWLi '43oag .(WIPO AWA avJ old��4d 86Z BOSO '��N NOLLVZIlIOHl(IV d0 31VOIiIlY�� YQINOlA QA'IH I��IVHOO Is OzzT  �� ,LO'I ssxvsznsxoO " rv,rxaNxoxinxa " su����xtOxH N A z �� c'��rr���� TT t-7 T r7 r77 ZT ��7��T��-77i wW ����sa��,.��a..��, 0 S��1iL Y ��L����R ARIA Q��QQ Y it u6Is0 6 o��nu�� �� �� �� �� lu :> ��w �� �� �� ��xo4 s��rvsaQ NHssxs 3isaas aaG PCI ��i " , a m �� -"  L[ X "LL `Wd 90 : bS :Z Z LOZ/S L/8 `bmP" ON3 SVN L\m31A aogaoH s401 -9 N L\Z N\ :0 > a a�� a U fi si N R! CD s m g ��HH W1 1 9 � N �� Es 07 ad ��.O k a W +a ��@, now ELM ��w ��Ln i 0 11 U a cj -. z- " " �v .Cwwa a' AI Ir�� f 6 10 O���� I +l (I I��'' 1 4. W HI M, ����c g 1 G P �� < 8 ���� En < ��2 j ( c o s; g�� s y n aFo W �� i�����3��3 i L 7t���� IT ��! E���� ����M ����a is I ��ss b asc s x.a x z ..ti cl d r d d n N ti v CO e�� I U)o 00 W caa J �� 3 w co lug w $ Ib w ZNil 52 z Oz LM oil, w . O z<��� m 1 N I I I ; rn I s s W in z -N z ' U Z I I II r-1 r, r, WRQ I WWI ZO 04 o 01 aw Q z $ a ��g s L d I a �� M11 g cn xb 1%���� >d�� X111 x ��, -��" :"'�� + �� ���" dQI2i0'I�� `I��1i��'��2I.LS 3'I11�� Esse rLz ABs ���� oosBiLZ LBS ���4d ..F tiYi�C oPlnLi '4��B L��+PO LoM o+aU' ��Id��4d 88Z G V DOBB " tt1 NOLinOHm L 'r" �� ,nN QAZH 1��id��00 Is OZ��i  �� ,LO'I s��s��ss�� ����in xos����x ��2I0,3 I1��+'Id AIOI,LI��I'.��IA'��2id I��IOI,LR'I'IOd YZBgHLm !0 3Lv��ua�� raluo�� �� o �� ���� x ,, �� �� s,txvsznsxo�� zv.LxaRx uB(seQo��(nu3 su��axi��x�� " �� > a a�� a U fi si N R! CD s m g ��HH W1 1 9 � N �� Es 07 ad ��.O k a W +a ��@, now ELM ��w ��Ln i 0 11 U a cj -. z- " " �v .Cwwa a' AI Ir�� f 6 10 O���� I +l (I I��'' 1 4. W HI M, ����c g 1 G P �� < 8 ���� En < ��2 j ( c o s; g�� s y n aFo W �� i�����3��3 i L 7t���� IT ��! E���� ����M ����a is I ��ss b asc s x.a x z ..ti cl d r d d n N ti v CO e�� I U)o 00 W caa J �� 3 w co lug w $ Ib w ZNil 52 z Oz LM oil, w . O z<��� m 1 N I I I ; rn I s s W in z -N z ' U Z I I II r-1 r, r, WRQ I WWI ZO 04 o 01 aw Q z $ a ��g s L d I a �� M11 g cn xb 1%���� >d�� X111 x ��, -��" :"'�� + �� ���" dQI2i0'I�� `I��1i��'��2I.LS 3'I11�� Esse rLz ABs ���� oosBiLZ LBS ���4d ..F tiYi�C oPlnLi '4��B L��+PO LoM o+aU' ��Id��4d 88Z G V DOBB " tt1 NOLinOHm L tu g �Sb£QRIO I `H3V38 AdN I3Q C w o a a w z $ {QI "'�3I1N�Ad H Lb flt1 S8 [ N -g ■ ■ W ® N3j.-1g 3QISd3SLo a ■ ■ v¢� a 7 S d Qi IS Xd330 'POZZI 5 > O RClUlH o4 —,j .. O20itd` QQ o of LU w a_ V W 0 W O J LLJZ /w V O 0 Z U U o�� I a=¢ i Boom �mO O ¢S..pmF l pqg w'F: MW O U F I a?p� O FF u i _2W >umm SymjpW I U � W oza <U i z�s<' m>O 1 oil❑: o� O_ mz ¢¢ULL ",, i Fa.0 oFia a ; s w w U3 O W O F m LJ Oz ° fq g o a ppg zU ¢o j5 �¢ €o v Fa <<_ j. ❑a ¢ �o❑ Ox Z Z � °< u zem �S i< o m FaZW �Z �❑ m❑ ❑ OW -w � 0 a i1 1 ❑W o3 r U 9 Z IW p w o OO w Z i5W 29 t03 On jm Oa OUW mF Wa0 ❑my � <U r W� J<oi w m Jkw 2Um ¢O m m of4w < x am aLL �z xa6 Wmx urs �z3 �¢ 1S$ m� ¢¢ OOW � O z appp•p•• N�� o vo i ❑ F� o o`d'o o ¢urc 00 ° is <��wNallo F � auw Y Hoa O U U o =Z. = zam =¢ Fp-¢ F*� -$¢p} Yp1 wjZ a2 Z p SZ Z F =Nm� F w Ww - g m K O «2 FF FF F � UZ, $ w Z zil Z.pZ ~ <� ❑ �O �w mlZ< ULLf U ON � ON O m KZ<F Zazo n "9f a F � wo 3 ga p �y�0 � k z o rz j SwF ❑ <� QVin c',❑, <o Zo ° �pp J� o pJ=aO < 2 << S O Z<2 UUu. pbp ¢� g¢OZ OR. <rx OwOZ¢ < 'w cif � °Z e y� �F �z � w� _�� �o o� ' rz� m ❑o❑ o �s �x5F <rc as rc x �Fo -m omLL� } xwaw < $'jaWUy a ooS aW �w? ° �� Zm ❑ f awp ap FF s F ¢ m 6 Www im 3 5�❑ ¢ UrcW� ❑� a❑ ¢4w pWU �x gamg❑ ❑ i 5 we Ru o3 o im o<LL�gg o f J> vo. o, j°m<aui �UF rca W i <�� ❑ o= o <ZJ~aio QQ Ow Z �2 < Oooww¢ ¢ So ze zwUF r<p ❑m �m, g U LL� U wwk0 i a 6�oe m ggW ��i haoLLLL� o`d¢a ww�p p w vpiarc rc 3Q r�i a<z? 0 0 waw 0 w mS 2 ¢¢< 1z' F� w "w �O FpS ° Nu �<Z�mmm � °J w p2¢ LL y m Z R..0 OZWp ! M1UZ U 2 OU W WOV FSS ww y❑ Zw Oa ❑a 2 fZ wFrWO ¢app ¢7 W F WjU j O Wm0❑U p Jz om oxo z_ �a wmm o3x �° ¢'< g9 �< �a rci 3 0<�<° waU? Up m O«d¢b 'u53zw a2 3m Q° mw om s2ia ¢Q9 m paa ;-Z, 'Z. .,¢cpim .? -Z. m = f Z O W rxO � Ix -z< w2. p<pw -,o go pw pK Np � yp Ft�pF� i m< U O g wU oo0a OF o o mpg o jF ¢KZw Op OU u. ¢�<'x �ym oa Z. -0 o° uom< Fw wF o¢ °vi uxi ova w�ao o g< m F;m 11 z .w so Fi Foo i� 6-'= g1 x� owW off' a o gg0. m uo o1.0 z- N p 2�R0- UL--- `� U�aW uui um UL -- a urrz ° 3 xi❑� 4 noo 6� .S Fwrx-cpi u� �w mow❑ w J , ¢ �a: i oowrc `o .Un o o anaU o� o-uA owi� u ow oa O Q LL O LL Z W w a Q z Z w ❑ U) J LL Q wLL J Z) 00 z ir U) C7 Q ❑ 0 LL IUi O aw LL O^ Z Z N Op W LL o U N U) J ao LL � LL Q za OZ ~ z W o O H o❑ N w 0 Mo LL N ❑ w C, w Y z_ Er EL z w a N 1- n TF a T U 0 O U Y W mQWU W H W m zU' z cn�w oQww LLI O LLn'v)m Z W J V w N � O w9 w A O O H U) M ULL-J, Cwl NO) Q w 0_ ULO N Uj 1 3 �- ® (A W �L--`j �y "' o P��j £Sb££ VQRIO 13 `HJV17 AViI IHQ v n d Z z < N■ b01 # 311N3At� H117 3AI S8 l = SI w SHACI ling flQISV3S $ _ '"L3 WVJI.I.S 3'IfID 'QA'Ig NVFIOO 'N OZZ I s "z S3.I.VIS3 HfIODUVH KACIGIH o A o a 4 V 1 LL- cli N E ® oU. W �- (v O ui — og > "' ` 1 3 �- ® (A W �L--`j O ~J W v oCD d Z u RNVW)n O O J I I a M Pi .Z5 .f5 \ 3 —�— ,-- ---------------------- I I I it -------------------------J I I iI I I I i� I I I I I i I I I i 'I I M s. ZDpa Ji r s pa1**--z o -F� Cl tf e o £8V££ VQRIO'13 `HDVafi AV -S -13a a x - O a 170t# anN3AV H.LV aN S8I I 'g - 00 ■ ■ x SdFluIHnElaQISVEIS q = w Q w 2S! _ z m F. 1 u ■ ■ a I3 Y�IVHN.I.S I(1�J *CIAIH I�Id33O 'A[ OZZl R � k o o O m' o t, 101- Sa.LVISa xnosxVH HaaalH �� © w o N -i w o a > Z W ® ° 3I -Wo o °LL. a z Q ® I I I WCaN E >o N U Lij vo C:) C: 4 8 £84££ VQRIO'IA `HOVHg A 1�Q o a �33e coo z ■ v < � g roe# anr>anv Heti art 1! Q ° N LL SiI�Q IInH 3QISVH a O m m UJ E 1 ■ ■ a` "13 Y4IV3N.I.S IfI9'QA Ifl M)MO nzz& 1.1.1 U a w a a a V ,LO'T- SaLvlsa xnowdvuluG�W o f A Q a 91 o C) le ?' It It 1' 51 0 0 N W W Cd w N� x0 11 1111, o z I I I I S 0 0 0 0 k1l I 0 0 1111 11111' C) WO � 5 ca 7 It It It 1. ?' It It 1' 51 0 0 N W W Cd w N� x0 11 1111, o z I I I I S 0 0 0 0 k1l I 0 0 1111 11111' 0 ani W 0 cn I �Ft SF 4 It p 1,4 C-' J It 0 ani W 0 cn I �Ft SF 4 It p 1,4 C-' J uJi vauoou✓n� Maui✓�ttn✓ov �✓rrur uavn✓�a ✓u irv.r,anu✓ n�iira.v »>ao_v svi t�runun a✓i�u�i vnn nau� nnv rvi n r rv✓rnovar u.�_� uirr au u.uai✓ u�✓r ruuaa�a x nvn rruai vnou�rv� au �nJv»u �rvv ro »mi �u Iavo tnv u.vrr¢a��o r �v ✓in✓ra r ry u�i vauaau✓rrr �rn ri✓�i�n✓av »rvur uavn✓ra na trot �t�a. inuu✓ p -A 4an .i. C> -AIL r s pates o r cr a o £8b££ VQRIO'13 `HOVHG AVd-MU < - VOW HfINHAV HlV HN 981 ■■ "r S-dFlu IIf18 HaISV9s O N a O00> H 1 ■ ■ a -V s 3�no Qn tg I1Va�o ozz < xr�$ a Qr� v�_ g °� 0a� a ¢ o> V .1.07- mvises 2InOH-dVH NHGUIH o O o E 09 4U a W oco LU 0 OU WIt LU egI t# 9 4-4 0 0 J � $e s < 0 z ; z 0 o 0 0 . rl W 0 Ml 0 dpi Q M Es L GVON HIVARid I QVO I - - T� _ J , J_ cA 3 W w� Uw Z LL CL ZIL J Z Zw q =Q U� �Q w U� J � }z zw >w Y� U14 N 0cn IQ L Asti �C ������ _o �Fl a Ila 4-d �L� m CO W 1 N c 1 W CO) je Cb W N !L2 z� lu o oco z U. CL a L Asti II . �11)) o �Fl a Ila > m CO c 1 41 ` J U v 0 L T N P N 1 � A A . !1X cl W o ca N C) .40 c CD 0 '1Q (nC)�� Q �oaoW Wcl� cn r^ 0 w� a cl � Q �zQw� L'i CC LJJ Id OQz O�vly Q� cn O �Ox- CzLno'�� cnI4rn Q z Qoo� Z�LZ Rzz Q C5 LLj z z3,m Q � Q Q I y �W t"A g 4�g 6 Q o, vi 4��QtV,� 3 "y�jq U L ONiti� 2 LO (n z y W z e .w� qq �� LU W^ 2 3 a 0 0 ClQ ® Cj ISLU 05 4 Qr, 2: 3F. ui �eL Ij no e .w� qq �� W^ 2 3 a � p 164, k>€� �eL Ij Q 0 Z ®LL _E - wCo C14 CD LLQ CD W = Q ®W }5 S Qf It Co Q�� T;I HIDDEN HARBOUR ESTATES LOT -4 N c7 Soothing White > h J � > 3 m WALLS TRIM SHUTTERS ► RECEIVED, AUG 2 3 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL G i►Q1 — •v fyl - r 4 .I y {{ a I I AN 014i IL 40 It 1% lk tA Alk NO .71 4i ._..,,.�..........„...r..........,.,..,a—..�:.,.v_'--�.�.o. � ....�.....,.,.._,..-•••.rat="^—'--"----..,. .r-.__..+`ea"7F ...�...•ls 1.+- +"•a...- � •».+. a d. ' - ,►,�91�" r..,� ,ys11�y, ; � r-ey�'s' � .• � .� ij,it �ii��.� ,afiP ibe • rt y ' X R" H �J. .- ._ �.. .W+fA.: , •.t �k • .Irk/' (� t . i ,,Cs i •••e,.�r �b �-:f 4 ^ y: �l - 1 L Ike� a • ow col . t7_ *il Fd t ^!:.• a _„ a v 4! , ,�t ..►' 4 a. . js ,� '� -a• . , 9 ;� ., � ,ice., .' , _ .� �`� 7 � ��� y,• a,, � - �+ r . / .• -arm .? r 4 ��iiiexw►• 1 ! .{ Ri....'"WL f o � `a tiw � � _ b+r. ,ar .. ..,, 1• t Y �'`-� �+ { F ..111 � � l A .. • 0011, AV v 1• ��t�t is �"', =��1as •rr,a �, M4 vv 121,4 •t A • {r Y ii! ,�y 4 ` ' � s .:.,.moi lk r^ �. �;> ..]111iFFR_^.•• Ir♦ff ��p ♦ .�71� 12 .. r ., A SIA � �' "� 3g,�~x•~'`11,. 1. `; '' � i � '►`�0 4yyy. •� .; i �w , • . , ,� L•� 1 i' r r� r`1� � �' -• i. \ ..,til Ma :•� - r � .Ilan"•Ali- 1 ' h �• ���� w . ,....1s.: Y . ` m , Wiia QA AD Js r Jii N V�/ i S� • I .y ,i Y + r ... 7R :•.� qI• t OF ' ,r •',�,k � � ` �, a �; a►� �r, �a "f! �a ! '� If , a ,e. - '^/ � •�. ,. � ' � 4+11 nI f.�1`,� °\�. -If :. � ,,,, fit; � f � �, • •, , 4 f 1TI t 3 y 7 - Y +� 'tet w �"•Si � fit.`.. , •. .. t,... _ � � *. .. • e+ �► • a � ..,. ' y � � "f.''� W'lay,,i�•"'�. 'X•�rw• _ �+�....yra_ryyr..,.,..a<+r..yR �+-M.:.-�wrt.+'+ .i rvCi.sa J •��, ` �.. ' ! t r< it •!� � 6 � S•� �L'--�1#fr• �, Ax �' .._}/�, A �° � ".< M, f =� �•� r °.A rid S Y ,�F �\ � � R �Ye. art '�'.♦, '.� J K� ; Y' • r wpm • z �� �• � �� w `� �� , �.:, 4 � � �; .N 1 , ' � � irk e` .-' r "•.si.{R` fi' - w �✓ti.1L�„. - _ a✓ r•�re, ,� - S 77 46. w -mow .. i IF• iTr T7, 1't 'PR ♦ a� - - Y1i aN. 44 =1 •.. l rrr;�/ s 'i�� ,.dam �..1i •� �•. �..♦ !•A .Y 10 . 'Irk 7^' TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-14 Address: 3333 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Doris J. Gillman Agent: Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects Construction of a partial 2 -story single family dwelling. N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To allow the removal of existing landscape material and driveway, install new driveway and landscaping and construct 5 foot perimeter wall with entry gate within the North Ocean Boulevard Corridor. Land Clearing Permit To relocate/clear existing landscaping material for relocation of driveway, preparation of building site and property beautification. Demolition Permit To remove existing structures. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a 9,036 SF Colonial West Indies style partial 2 -story single family dwelling, 3 car attached garage and a swimming pool. Gross Lot size: 57,086 SF Effective Lot Area: 30,057 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 9,036 SF Allowable: 9,114 SF (25% Rule Front SB = +10') Zoning District: RS -B Height: 34' 10" (roof height <_ 35' Preferred) Finished Floor: 17.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Motion to recommend approval of North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to allow the removal of existing landscape material and driveway, install new driveway and landscaping and construct 5 foot perimeter wall with entry gate within the North Ocean Boulevard Corridor. Motion to recommend approval of Land Clearing Permit to relocate/clear existing landscaping material for relocation of driveway, preparation of building site and property beautification. Motion to recommend approval of Demolition Permit to remove existing structures. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #012-14 ARPB October 25, 2012; TC November 9, 2012 Page 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed construction of a 9,036 SF Colonial West Indies style partial 2 -story single family dwelling, 3 car attached garage and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 3. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 4. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. 5. The landscape plan will protect existing Australian pine trees and provide a 13' clear zone where possible allowing for the planting by the Town of two Australian pine trees on the north of the existing driveway entrance and up to eight on the north side of the existing driveway. 6. Change the proposed gate design to the alternate gate design that is less ornate. The agent has shown several gates along SR A1A several of which are fronting homes classified with Mediterranean style architecture. 7. The property ozvuer shall give the neighbor to the south 30 days notice prior to commencement of collstructlou. ARPB Date: October 25, 2012 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Recommend approval to allow the removal of existing landscape material & driveway, install new driveway and landscaping and construct 5' perimeter wall with entry gate within N. Ocean Blvd. Corridor. (5-0) Land Clearing: Recommend approval to relocate/clear existing landscaping material for relocation of driveway, preparation of building site and property beautification. (5-0) Demolition: Recommend approval to remove existing structures. (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval as submitted with the 7 conditions listed above. (5-0) TC Date: November 9, 2012 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as recommended by ARPB. (5-0) Land Clearing: Approved as presented and recommended by ARPB. (5-0) Demolition: Approved as recommended by ARPB to remove all existing structures. (5-0) Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Approved as recommended by ARPB with the 7 conditions listed in the record. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM SEP 2 0 2012 Towit of Guif Stream, i L APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File # x I.A.1. Project/Owner Name:_ Dorz15 • kIL' GI"IA 4 I.A.2. Project Address: 3335 N. oc.EAN 'S1,%lD• G-TV;F S -C m I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: CVL -'F ST1&eAH ?TLS iJ 125 P:T of S 225 F -T e' L? S I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.)_ NEW Z 5-t>� pe, ME SII T+1 3 cFtrL ('rAT*'&M AND FCo�- I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: `l, 03 0 Architectural Style: Cot.oN IAL W es -r 1.A.6. Check all that apply: eArchitectural/Site Plan Review B"'Land Clearing C/North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) V Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: Izj•o NcTV U Type of Foundation: PI L! til CTS B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 3t5 5e :?--rfi metjyE v8!X� 5-CACHI Fu, 3-S-113:1 I.13.2. Owner Phone Numbed 5(. - ��� -n-f4e( I.B.3. Owner Signature C. Agent Information Fax: Al • A I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: 5etJJhM114 scHl I�fz, P� FlN I�1 f'rtL�titt -fi5 I.C.2. Agent Address: W00 i3R.olc.eO 500015 ylmzl- t4WI SoI-re 8 -Spcpk rAI041 P- "S�S-f I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 5t: 1-750-04+5 5 cell 1.C.4. Agent Signature:���� Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: �l (tln e , x.11) 17 n Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: _ TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Fax Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the a question number for each response. ppropriate and complete A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? SI N 6rX -rWI 75c�LtfPt�r�t" III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? Yes ❑ No Explain. pyslero wgroMmt 10 T}.I-5 t -^NG I�eyEi,opwtCN-r �c-t.����ous o , tow oF- oL4- SitMop " . III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? Eryes ❑ No Explain. DISI (:T A uvtitr-o Fjc. 7-o THE Ukl4p P VeLPPrlEP-t. ryq -)LkttoAl i of :MHC Towm oI: rvL't= �1 M III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? TH 7WO " Exls-I t >� j �-o r \4 I DC L01M cLn III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage o N s l -re V 1 A � �4I8 w -t o' PF*04,11- � 15ASINt b. Sanitary Sewer , pI I EXFI �i-I�11�rt.7Tz�Ilcii�s rk '66"o c. Potable Water _ �� � W�rER P xe-WATMDi d. Irrigation Water D�PP.�-rNr.1Ff c -I til Dc�.iZPrjPrL� YlAtt� rxpa e. Electricity .�.�� urMc�r-� f. Telephone g. Gas bUL UTILiTKS h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) T+IF Si � EMIL`% TSSI t N 1s 114 C0NT0r-i14 ALV 1 -to -tHe u4ND P�t�tnPM6Nt V;e(TuLAfiloNS ot` C it. s-ttzckM PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? Ca'�'es ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? O'Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV -A-3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? 4'4'es ❑ No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes WNo (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes dNo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? I`yl ► til C� (-PSN V Sc PAY£ t�l�'C iZt P�. w l L u 13e rte►-loJ�p I jd orper -to pt AI -6 h 4EM NF-i\14eWk'd AWD HOW LA N DScA? 1 N 6y-4eE L# -N Dsr#pL pL Ah0 IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IFg!o 1pe Neo SITS wAu-, q 14E\I L#,PVI-c K WILL ir_ye It�S-rA�-uc-p � �H�il�tUct1oF� 't"P D 'tn e-zek- e r-JZ4\1-hLq 'FTL*t IV -B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes to Explain: OV,6X,o�Oc, vtE,a/S ofL VISTAS \4I(,L. 7 A,IfJ T}I-e SAS, p S G�lzf Tt'I t-`� tic l S-tS o tFTrc IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? 15t�6 LANDScA T-- PL'N0 - IV.B.S. What.mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: S -M ►.pN1DS44,M 'Ft.AIII C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? L)POM r-CA1-PT ot= IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? WHcfJ PEr*irf IS tss.VP, cmNs-.TXU -IoIJ �StiM,�.ttb 1.ar-- A PexApb O� f►rl wla�t IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? 009 e D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IXA 6p.Ps -rreeeS, e�lyi-►146r M,6,Ix7I 1-tl441W clxorm-� elws IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: fotC gELoCA-HCNI CFF DZz1-4.swaj AMD J5E5•vTIT-IL#-JJoJ c%F Pp::SMF `i ,its 11evJep :FrmM x_Av IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: 'MUW LANDc cATi-t t4#,- FtP-u wlu, RE INS-r,6.uE�b. -.s45 Lmt)sc'b�'Pe - LAO IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? TeMP'�Fi 11z>zlC��lIoi1 WILL INE I?,ISrALGTb >417i+ sitX scrTzzeII -to SEPh7-P�fi'E V46 �kyoa -FMV 1 NS-MoLmaJ IV.D.S. What replacement materials are proposed? 4FE t.ANDSLATIS '1Af4 Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 Drawing Index 3333 North Ocean Blvd. Gulf Stream, FL Affiniti Architects Perspective Drawing A1.0- Site Plan, Location Map, Site Calcs., Streetscape A3.0- 1" Floor Plan A3.1- 2nd Floor Plan A5.0- West & South Elevation, Wall & Entry Gate @ Road A5.1- East & North Elevation, Alternate Entry Gate @ Road A7.0- Lower Roof Plan A8.0- Upper Roof Plan Neighboring Gate Images Peterson Design_ Professionals L1- Existing Tree Removal L2- Landscape Plan L3- Landscape details/ specifications L4- Front Elevation L5- Street Elevation Meridian Land Surveyors Sheet 1 of 2- survey of subject property Sheet 2 of 2- survey of adjacent properties Schulke, Bittle & Stoddard, LLC ''G Cl- Demolition plan �GD c SJ``V GD C2- Site Plan ® lb LzS�L C3- Cross Sections C4- Lighting Plan �n �u�fistCeam.� C5- Cut & Fill C6- FDOT Details Samples Driveway Pavers-Belgard-Oak Run -Old Castle Colonial Roof Tile -Hanson Southern Shake, Color Moccasin Pool Deck -Dominican Coral Paint Color: Benjamin Moore #879, Exterior Shutters, Stucco Siding, Metal railing, Wall and entry gate at road T Yy Z� n MEAN HIGH WATER AS LOCATED ON 05/03/12 9J -----9R Z..,". ----- - NORTEf ❑ =� ------------ D � AAAI Ef 3 � a a z i off' 9 2 g A X c O z rp i ii D r � F a v A URI Q s Ta rYRSSR " az 1co 114 �JWi n �V $Q gIN g S2 ioz*n IV 0 s O ©. � N i I f N wxr2oi uNE ac' 1 tBm ��DD �J L g —i T M 0 to N b a L � �i mAn CD s m "Vs N v Y iF T Z Te. 9J -----9R Z..,". ----- - NORTEf ❑ =� ------------ D � AAAI Ef 3 � a a z g off' 9 2 g A X c O z 11 r 1 l'N 1 t a r c b i t e c GILLMAN RESIDENCE 3333 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream, Florida g 9 2 g A rp D URI Q s Ta rYRSSR " az 114 �JWi n �V $Q gIN g S2 m O tBm ��DD �J T 0 o b a GILLMAN RESIDENCE 3333 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream, Florida 91 0 4z CT; ;:5 --% m .- - 4d Ip' t5 TA A rn r— -1 ---- ------- .... ----- ---------- ........... + 7. ------ -r-TiYQLRMIBPIB ------ ------ c - ID) Ell Cp T) 114 1 ------ ti ----------------- i 990 rA ----- - -------------- - -------------- ------ II ------------------ Ail00 00 C—) CJ fig 0 ®a t) ( I� � � , ���51 i O r'n�'1y � 19 q T T T. Fri) For:i ---------- ----------____I -L ------ -- P-�)]I icy z9i t A- < I-____ -----_____t_____ FF I - - - - - - - - - Do ---------- -E ---------- ----------- C: ME; G') hTA Sq T 5a 2rd rd' 9oQ POG OA � CT; ;:5 --% m .- - i� t5 TA A rn r— GILLMAN RESIDENCE a.r C h i t C C t s 3333 North Ocean Boulevard 6100 Broken Sound Pkwy. NW - Suite 8 - Boca Raw R. - 33487Gulfstream, Florida � I to rr � 19 q T T T. GILLMAN RESIDENCE a.r C h i t C C t s 3333 North Ocean Boulevard 6100 Broken Sound Pkwy. NW - Suite 8 - Boca Raw R. - 33487Gulfstream, Florida � I X Qa a a ------- -- --- ------- --- --- 7 4 4agm � a g -- ----- a ,all r 'p 14 C-9 s I P V- wVgn N Gll __________ _____—_—_—_ _ -.I._ _—_ _—__ _—_ _ _ $ - - I I I I � , a � � 4 I _____—_ __— ___ Tz": n c � ao ---- -- a s a 64 c r I" m nI L'. •'rl _ �i fJRR�ft O O CO) 16100 Brol en -%xW Pkwy. NW - sik 8 - Boca Raton FL - Ba7l I y O A � A I Q Dr CD z C^i I C--) � � A � A I Q CD C^i o C--) m a ; g G zip Gulfstream, Florida R n _-Cn ..� b 2A O m N � 0 r— GILLMAN RESIDENCE C^i 3333 North Ocean Boulevard 6100 Broken Sound Pkwy. NW - Suite 8 - Boca Raton FL - 33457 g G zip Gulfstream, Florida R 561.75DA"S AifTNMRQRRi1Sn M N ` = o 10 CD N v T . IMM qS ► � N ` = o 10 CD N v T . IMM y _o g I� NI plts _ V S " N v T . N Ir CO) m I �� �� g +rssr r mrcoc�� I ,am- LLyy SYE��# T I r ran :q:A t pp I F yy Sin r - ----_ '" 3 _ T I 'P>�� O m z zir wK5 o -'1NE O mJN AAAA c S -i- ��N t ZAp ,,,t g, 0.?/f2 ��) 3 O - A7LAN-POCEAN 'j m _ m CD C= n; ILIO .' "'��oX" Y' -< rz NU ran 8 oasrAt cays7xuc7rcv m ��tavrwL Ute' // ' A',L`.Y:�� %1LY>G(S rJ>_:.5( F" arp. ����'a-r raylNy.7 or.,lr YY - m ��>a b V N ' `70 COASTAL gyySMjC71pV Ca+RgC LNJ� r m.%>w,lcrs .ar-,n:: vtec4. :q:A pp I F yy Sin r - ----_ '" 3 w o -'1NE >" �� s Ta. IR 'kggs .. ��' 12500' i����m " " t ZAp ,,,t g, 0.?/f2 ��) 3 O 8 oasrAt cays7xuc7rcv m ��tavrwL Ute' // ' A',L`.Y:�� %1LY>G(S rJ>_:.5( F" arp. ����'a-r raylNy.7 or.,lr YY - m ��>a b V N ' `70 COASTAL gyySMjC71pV Ca+RgC LNJ� r m.%>w,lcrs .ar-,n:: vtec4. a a"1"hcc,l�� Ai7' '7K' CS4,V r - ----_ '" 3 w o -'1NE `t .. ��' 12500' .= AS L0CA7FDWAk7��fL. 0.44 (NA �� t ,,,t g, 0.?/f2 ��) 3 O A7LAN-POCEAN 'j m _ m CD C= �� . NU r a a"1"hcc,l�� Ai7' '7K' CS4,V ��1 1:E MZ 3o A^ sw a m m GILLMAN RESIDENCE 3333 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream, Florida Peterson Design Professionals _ chili L -6c mA ph C> n P6ow(561)702-0136  ice v{ 151S.W.7WT Pa (561)33835/3 .Bon RWk FW&33186 j.pft-200 @hM-0. rn CD N C CD s rn Y =ice II m flU m y G �Y.�a�s"��vtc s„;SSS Sym R2 6; 9. �o�ottx�e��NsaMW---tiN�Nms W IN fiq g5yMm'li 2`.j'�e 31W mn�� *9 �s P r a b � will 1182 1 -n—a � � a� wo 1A s .fir 11; €� �> � MM8 -4 @ C w g m?qy> °F �� � � w�� E ;I 4 9 _lj�jg 8 Egg y ® X77 F �� H UR '11 8 A g as ss� �9 �� N mss; PIN a� > GILLMAN RESIDENCE 3333 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream, Florida ®Peterson Design Professionals Is0yuR ARyIIp4y Pluem Ph—(561)702-0136 ISl S.W.7ih TYuee Fu (561)338-3543 Bou RMm FWWO3486 J.Peldson2008$hdm ai a UN -1 C �.� o -4*° ao m jCIn N c 0 N ca m i W - o o �-► - mPeterson_ GILLMAN RESIDENCE _ �Design G) t—'tnProfessionals C) ® 3333 North Ocean Boulevard L A—wA W .,.... N ® Gulfstream, Florida „ Phone (761)7@-0136 e.77o6 , Fn l61p7bhl Mi;ZFWr— 4 co T _ a c � r z -v „-a o (0°� MZ T© m jc" o r,' CO) m q --- GILLMAN RESIDENCE-. 3333 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream, Florida ®Peterson Design Professionals L-A—" A hfl . Pi— Pb—(561)703-0136 I51 S. W. 7th rn« P.a (361pNd3U B— Pum. Plmih 334P6 J.pwr,m200Pe6a,.aitam� �1 r 7� fn E t --- GILLMAN RESIDENCE-. 3333 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream, Florida ®Peterson Design Professionals L-A—" A hfl . Pi— Pb—(561)703-0136 I51 S. W. 7th rn« P.a (361pNd3U B— Pum. Plmih 334P6 J.pwr,m200Pe6a,.aitam� �1 3 n'•'.�a nROm a hf�Fri�prz n6C'N rrll illllliilirll li rll ij II rr Ill rlrirlir lltlr Nps r 01 I'D. O �$k7 �y 4� U— ITATLANTIC OCEAN � �m mid m ^m <'U m zp rmp m S finl m mgt f,m Q� rpt D Syi pe �pA $ t �amZ ppgm g yp= Y�f1 rr7l�mnrt1N x � X. C p Qm m gAp Q- ~ 2,a p Z RR � m m g $ o I ' � I O x :y � ® C C o C--) M 0O a rn MZ m0 6 ce 3� N Of ra 1� m �m mid m ^m <'U m zp rmp m S finl m mgt f,m Q� rpt D Syi pe �pA $ t �amZ ppgm g yp= Y�f1 rr7l�mnrt1N x � X. C p Qm m gAp Q- ~ 2,a p Z RR � m m g $ o I ' � I x :y GRAPHIC SCALE SCALE MoT 70,5c.414 ra nUa M1g�1 f ^� eu ct. �.atwrw•q-� Q �PRfll PR Yr0 IN *9 rn. arrive Nco c olio 03 uaa cnc a 1 X68! >rsm'twinr� sale, IW, — 10, S PR AIO r 1 I �o rn a - ..... PR t' PR S rF=PffDi(RAPH RfF7=RlA4T POINT film - Li LC- mrF c 01 PR xten _.. PLA T OF S_URVEY FOR: cl)No ", p c n Pr 1XWNDARYR T OPOGRAPAK 3333 NORTH OCEAN B�,Vll. Q"o c DATF.,W12 P.R. 175Pa..44 ftp;. Kit F02l GCLLMAN RESIDENCE w^ 0 CI IA ORAnNRY:MTJP rm,)W. reran srtrs :� CHECKED BY, f.B N ;...,_J en ALF 1.90 OF MERIDIAN THIS SURVEY IS NOT VALID 141MIOUT T11F, SIGNATURE. AND THE ORI NAL RAISE1) SEAL OF THE FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR LAND SURVEYORS A apr' w DFLOW. Fin.Ai- iNthX+1t¢yei7ra+M�.svi \l NO. D47E DMVPMN By 0L4RLF_S tf QLANCH Apj) P $.A.f #57SS 4 PR AIO r 1 I �o rn a - ..... PR t' PR S rF=PffDi(RAPH RfF7=RlA4T POINT film - Li LC- mrF c 01 PR xten _.. PLA T OF S_URVEY FOR: cl)No ", p c n Pr 1XWNDARYR T OPOGRAPAK 3333 NORTH OCEAN B�,Vll. Q"o c DATF.,W12 P.R. 175Pa..44 ftp;. Kit F02l GCLLMAN RESIDENCE w^ 0 CI IA ORAnNRY:MTJP rm,)W. reran srtrs :� CHECKED BY, f.B N ;...,_J en ALF 1.90 OF MERIDIAN THIS SURVEY IS NOT VALID 141MIOUT T11F, SIGNATURE. AND THE ORI NAL RAISE1) SEAL OF THE FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR LAND SURVEYORS A apr' w DFLOW. Fin.Ai- iNthX+1t¢yei7ra+M�.svi \l NO. D47E DMVPMN By 0L4RLF_S tf QLANCH Apj) P $.A.f #57SS °a. as ". oa onF I a m _ / m 4 =--onF SNF h h 00 A \ m .vrp — L lily 1_ o m oa asa mlS 275.00' OF LOt 5 g n a $` f s s s� N600E i 7�>�?�Ls1v1H a l� s1s1>,s ?SZSZs1s s1S1S1S1SZs1� '� ' � 111?11??111 111111 R� '��; ssssssssssssssssss �LZ� ����11111 11111 o i . ;S S,S,S Zs1s1s1sLs1S _ 244 4 3S3S 4 Z4 J6' • ZI I i I �F'j �= Irr �. III m^ 90�I � 4� LI I� 4 rTr a, _J j � I m � I � � � �•• J rrraV I -/�----LSCA CHAPES —1 r----- SEA GRAPES - --- 1 IaI � a I� T 0O • qc 7FIE I I Ai 27300•[075 C R �"'• est y0 mZ r a G ca 4:a _•. ti ('� m U / IT► hF l.F F[3 '4r04r RCSwJ[NCE n WlN 19J Z D oa asa mlS 275.00' OF LOt 5 g n a $` f s s s� N600E i 7�>�?�Ls1v1H a l� s1s1>,s ?SZSZs1s s1S1S1S1SZs1� '� ' � 111?11??111 111111 R� '��; ssssssssssssssssss �LZ� ����11111 11111 o i . ;S S,S,S Zs1s1s1sLs1S _ 244 4 3S3S 4 Z4 J6' • ZI I i I �F'j �= Irr �. III m^ 90�I � 4� LI I� 4 rTr a, _J j � I m � I � � � �•• J rrraV I -/�----LSCA CHAPES —1 r----- SEA GRAPES - --- 1 IaI � a I� T 0O • qc 7FIE I I Ai 27300•[075 PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: fl: ip DORIS J. GIUMAN DEMOLITION PLAN aA 3333 NORM OCEAN BOULEVARD �[ ' GULF STREAM. FLORIDA aoa ti N®O (5,37, n � ATLANTIC OCEAN ra \go �o �a 1m�o 3� g� Q R �"'• est O 4:a _•. —� ('� m U / �► hF l.F F[3 '4r04r RCSwJ[NCE n WlN 19J Z D yo0px 124J (NA K) 6BJ O ^t0 D m CD o rn Ea v —n r— PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: fl: ip DORIS J. GIUMAN DEMOLITION PLAN aA 3333 NORM OCEAN BOULEVARD �[ ' GULF STREAM. FLORIDA aoa ti N®O (5,37, n � ATLANTIC OCEAN ra \go �o �a 1m�o 3� g� Q a 9 0 4 x n I rv� 6> SCHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. a9AWNG 12149 -SPI �"* NEN90N 0.1/E acsc>,ro wrs CIVIL B STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (AND PUNNING ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITTING MANN WAC CERTIFICATION Of AUTHORIZATION NO. 00008666 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD. SUITE 201 VERO BEACH FLORIDA 72960 TEL 772,770-9622 FAX 772 / 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsen9ineers.com ""` oAff 10/16/I2 R �"'• est 4 b 9� =m -y1 tNn=pCm n,� �.vna hF l.F F[3 '4r04r RCSwJ[NCE n WlN 19J mE yo0px 124J (NA K) 6BJ O ^t0 *D�y < nnnN a 9 0 4 x n I rv� 6> SCHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. a9AWNG 12149 -SPI �"* NEN90N 0.1/E acsc>,ro wrs CIVIL B STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (AND PUNNING ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITTING MANN WAC CERTIFICATION Of AUTHORIZATION NO. 00008666 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD. SUITE 201 VERO BEACH FLORIDA 72960 TEL 772,770-9622 FAX 772 / 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsen9ineers.com ""` oAff 10/16/I2 ovcaEo nrs scnaE •-20' as a R a m w GL, L"ntVrJl'_ Ne 3 m uz 00 ■ g a, w '4. O A> A 4 O \ e\ 00.1 DS fi 11 • a A k cn F+ ga I' 19 I J xN s�n,ENRrrn e � F yam. !! r lgi1.164 r RCLOCNCCm J I) (N b N6/ i F 4 G p Li 4 AlF = =M,� 27 it 3f 3E�tnn I �� �'.0> ai yopp= r, 1-00, 0 RCAOCNY m0 mzpnpG 12 +j �ro`.�LO 29/ °, �� Cly R DtiZul ���R la •�I aM O Ji Dns, �+ / .. � � e• Aas R -I2 z�F a> F7w2cma V _ DECK I O �3g aha^ f r--- i . a � el tJ B —�l L —Da., q P_ X rr� I L—� Ef� ci PQ` L I ­• I _ O ` an CJ lei gI JJ JA 411 ?a 5 175 00' CYC or 5 O O O i}} €B }1.�4Q }�€E =Fizz fi 5; fi X11 L21 G>tg� 0 0 PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE. ra n ~ APA DORIS J. GILLMAN ♦ ay agA 3333 NORM OCEAN BOULEVARD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Z D 0 m ^pop o^po p^omi �O nCD !JM >c! op O�g OOS aR AOLANTIC E} yy LEAN I N N^ Nz N3 timz Mi 1250>HE O' C 07 S I I o D ' - 7 53eraD ;u i's���•Ys '- -€ami' n 4� r � 445 y� o 1 c c G')~ �Z f 0 0 PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE. ra n ~ APA DORIS J. GILLMAN ♦ ay agA 3333 NORM OCEAN BOULEVARD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Z D 0 m SITE PLAN ^pop o^po p^omi �O nCD >c! op O�g OOS aR AOLANTIC 90 ? ig ga LEAN I N N^ Nz N3 timz 1250>HE O' C 07 S I I o D ' - 7 53eraD L - i's���•Ys '- -€ami' o rn � o 1 c c G')~ �Z f fn m a o o^ 4 SITE PLAN [WAAIND 12119 -SPI PARK R www OA rE DE-GNED wp[ arccxFn W, 1•-20' vas DA Ir ID/15/12 ^pop o^po p^omi �O nCD >c! op O�g OOS AOLANTIC 90 ? ig ga LEAN N^ Nz N3 timz C r- o o rn � o coo C O G')~ �Z f fn m a o m cn CD N Sd,FR'JLim, BITTLE & STODDARD, ( " CML h sIRUC1US ENGINEERING LAND PUNNING ENVIRONMENTAL PER64TI RTIFICATION OF A0MOR12ATION N0. 00008668 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD.. SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 TEL 772 / 770-9622 FAX 772 / 770-9496 EMAIL inlo0sbsen°ineers.con [WAAIND 12119 -SPI PARK R www OA rE DE-GNED wp[ arccxFn W, 1•-20' vas DA Ir ID/15/12 P. a Cooa6000m":oaa600000�e §j [s] NOIRII PROpm UK O Ill • .07PAW BEACH COUNT' COASTAL CONSTRUCTION CONTRA. UNE. AS RECORDED ON AUGUST 22. 11197, IN PUT BOOR W. PAGES 137-155. :40. a y 4 FA ll� y P I I It I I I I I I I I I I I floo"[ N9_CLEY IG SEASONAL WATER UNE EIEV.-1.4a' .1. 'm [s] NOIRII PROpm UK O Ill • .07PAW BEACH COUNT' COASTAL CONSTRUCTION CONTRA. UNE. AS RECORDED ON AUGUST 22. 11197, IN PUT BOOR W. PAGES 137-155. I}I-- 0.00 CONTOUR UNE NGw '2B MEANNICN WATER UNE ELEV -014' NAV '. —0.00' CONTOUR UNE NAw 'RR 1.59' CONTOUR UME Nf '29 �A ATLANTIC OCEAN +� Cca j � T o � a0 N ;ozm m r 30 p v % O O OIUMNC 12149–SP1 YANG RCN9Pv OA 1E r r PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: SCHULKE, BITA-E $ T ARD, L.L.C. in " " DORIS J. CILLMAN CML & STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING LAND PUN RONMENiAL PERMIT(ING xP5 =1 CROSS SECTIONS w DRAW "AC I+p xO W 3333 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD CERTIFICATION OF AUTHOWATION NO. DODOa669 w CNECREO NPS AF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD., SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 WALE As NOTED TEL 7721770-9622 FAX 772 / 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com ""' DAs to/15/tx 4 FA P I I It I I I I I I I I I I I floo"[ N9_CLEY IG SEASONAL WATER UNE EIEV.-1.4a' .1. 'm I}I-- 0.00 CONTOUR UNE NGw '2B MEANNICN WATER UNE ELEV -014' NAV '. —0.00' CONTOUR UNE NAw 'RR 1.59' CONTOUR UME Nf '29 �A ATLANTIC OCEAN +� Cca j � T o � a0 N ;ozm m r 30 p v % O O OIUMNC 12149–SP1 YANG RCN9Pv OA 1E r r PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: SCHULKE, BITA-E $ T ARD, L.L.C. in " " DORIS J. CILLMAN CML & STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING LAND PUN RONMENiAL PERMIT(ING xP5 =1 CROSS SECTIONS w DRAW "AC I+p xO W 3333 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD CERTIFICATION OF AUTHOWATION NO. DODOa669 w CNECREO NPS AF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD., SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 WALE As NOTED TEL 7721770-9622 FAX 772 / 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com ""' DAs to/15/tx r I a gill0 Q :17LC T wC I I I: 01 lIi PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: LWAWW 12149 -SPI YARIt RfN90N DA 7F CHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. J—H.DE�wPS DORIS J. GILLMAN C/NL & STNDCTURAL ENGINEERING - [AND PUNNING ENNRONMENTAL PERMITTING'" cwAw w•c A FDOT DETAILS CERTIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION NO OOODB66B N OYCIXED wP9 ,o c ]JD3 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD u., w GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD.. SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 S0ILE AS NOTED TEL 772 1.770-962V FAX 7721 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com DAM 10/11/12 PAVEMENT SECTION (SEE DETNLS THIS SHEET) „F oou �iO( 1 NONE a o" 01 lIi PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: LWAWW 12149 -SPI YARIt RfN90N DA 7F CHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. J—H.DE�wPS DORIS J. GILLMAN C/NL & STNDCTURAL ENGINEERING - [AND PUNNING ENNRONMENTAL PERMITTING'" cwAw w•c A FDOT DETAILS CERTIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION NO OOODB66B N OYCIXED wP9 ,o c ]JD3 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD u., w GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD.. SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 S0ILE AS NOTED TEL 772 1.770-962V FAX 7721 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com DAM 10/11/12 PAVEMENT SECTION (SEE DETNLS THIS SHEET) „F oou �iO( 1 C L9" a o" 2� z o S X AN .,B (l1 n x3 f"1 H o m = � g » m orn p z -• m n Z,- � z Y a 8 g `F am 01 lIi PROPOSED SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE: LWAWW 12149 -SPI YARIt RfN90N DA 7F CHULKE, BITTLE & STODDARD, L.L.C. J—H.DE�wPS DORIS J. GILLMAN C/NL & STNDCTURAL ENGINEERING - [AND PUNNING ENNRONMENTAL PERMITTING'" cwAw w•c A FDOT DETAILS CERTIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION NO OOODB66B N OYCIXED wP9 ,o c ]JD3 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD u., w GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 1717 INDIAN RIVER BLVD.. SUITE 201 VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 S0ILE AS NOTED TEL 772 1.770-962V FAX 7721 770-9496 EMAIL info@sbsengineers.com DAM 10/11/12 3333 N Ocean Blvd Gillman Residence Driveway: Belgard-Oak Run -Old Castle Colonial from Mega Bergerac Collection 3333 N Ocean Blvd Gillman Residence Roof Tile: Hanson Southern Shake Color: Moccasin 3333 N Ocean Blvd Gillman Residence Pool Deck: Dominican Coral 'r ' � r Y r n . e k - y 3333 N Ocean Blvd Gillman Residence Paint color: Benjamin Moore #879 White Opulence Areas of use: Exterior of house Wood shutters Stucco siding Metal railing Wall & entry gate at the road TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-12 Address: 1224 North Ocean Blvd Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Richard Jones Architect Construction of a partial two story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit: To permit the installation of landscaping and easterly part of a privacy wall within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling, a 3 car attached garage, pool and cabana, a total of 8,726 SF. Gross Lot size: 30,962 SF Effective Lot Area: 30,962 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 8,790 SF Allowable: 8,792 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Finished Floor: 14.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Height: 30' (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlav District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval of a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit based on a finding that the landscaping and easterly portion of a privacy wall meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling, a 3 car attached garage, pool and cabana, a total of 8,726 SF meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB*File #013-12 ARPB July 25, 2013; TC August 9, 2013 Page 2 1. The entry feature, measured from FFE to top of railings, shall be <_ 14'. 2. The electric service lines shall be buried. 3. A sample of the gray color roof file to be provided for approval. 4. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 5. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 6. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view ARPB Date: July 25, 2013 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Recommend approval as requested (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested with the above 6 conditions. (5-0) TC Date: August 9, 2013 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as recommended with the above 6 conditions. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM 14,�. . ® RECEIVE " .1. JUN 17 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File I# =: -. J To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name:f/�/Yl VU V I.A.2. Project Address: I�V, "f . o v I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: fho JfArho r I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) I tv /je � lv I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: Ci ' 1.A.6. Check all that apply:Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete sec ion B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.:no am1wi— B. Type of Foundation: Owner Information Q I.B.1. Owner Address: O 0 t �J y aw 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number: T(J5 6/e ? ��_ Fax: J5 7" 1.B.3. Owner Signature:/�-0—fe - C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: %© I I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: 7Y` 7N. 4 cell -Z7 Fax 1. C.4. Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: 4 4)7.J- 1217 k -7 -z4 -i.3 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located?��%� III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? P(Yes ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? XYes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? J - K -03S I ew, e. f. Howta)re' the foll Stormwater D Sanitary SeWE Potable Water Irrigation WatE Electricity Telephone Gas Cable Television ow/ g is'Co 1 e r vide' d t( the loertv? III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART MIV: FZSRMAT* K Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? 4 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV -A-2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes No (if "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes )Q No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes .K No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes 0t\1 No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Strearn B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? vo, nim IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the Al Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What.mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the IeasTirfipacf possible to The visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? I V A IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? 841 A D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: A# ft IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? A // ,,,, IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E: Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E.1. Is the proposed use a Permitted special exception use? []Yes IV -E.2. How is the use �No Code Section: designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the welfare, and morals will be protected? A (I public health, safety, IV,E,3. Will the use cause substantial in'u other Property be located? [I Yes 1 rY to the value of /n❑ No yin the neighborhood where it is to Explain. IN I I A-- IV.E,4• How will the use be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where ' g f � it IV.E.5,—�- What landscaping and screening are provided? h 1I A IV -E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations overni 9 ng the District wherein it is to be located? []Yes El No Explain. A V I A- F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the N( 14 y are to be maintained. IV -F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts o Properties. K 1 1 in n surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading Spaces: Standard ParkingSpaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 Town, of Gulf Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? I IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV -G.3. What is proposed? IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? IV -G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the Ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? A / 1 (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or struqture? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No I / .; Explain: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 OT c;ulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site?` IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, please describe the need and justification for the request, IN I I A PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants, q ouragedbut Applicants are enc, not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere o the other materials submitted with the application. n this form or on any of Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 L kn w C� Of W SW L V U) W 0 U � �-d N $g❑ u z z � ¢ u ❑ O ❑w ¢.6 cP ¢ i QQ EE i El�, p 0 O QQ UUU N � o w p o p w, z U O uUZI U p LL ❑ o wUp w ° ¢ a m ❑ ❑ N g g ' n- 0 w w F a oazw w w I ❑ o a,o ❑ _Z e ¢a ❑ a ¢u F 3 az w� F o o zi �wi w _i 2w - o u LL �a� 3 og N m< W W q jQm ? 'Z p z Q Z Z F<F O QWm ❑ %o o❑ T. ozo 20 zZiww �� ❑ a p ¢ w �' g O u OZgo �' zO0 U W W c fa0i Nw ¢ ¢ � i`. t.; a� Z Umfl ¢ F -N U Fa < O<i ¢ U o i u 10 FS HI o $ �Y g� 8 g3 ¢ $ 0 o o� dos= o w L o o, csi o aw joz f� oQ z WO o Zr w �5" o .N F eU � p o- �oc¢ii uwz o oho Na ww S o i a a.-,6Nk x °mow❑ �W�saW, W ❑ oQw ara z� z< LL o o �N , oaa�rc w '¢a �o�u >� g❑ u� aa�° mz wF� 3a m w$ w ao¢ ❑ oawm o w0. ow erc NW z o <�< ❑W F ^"Z. ° 3� Sa a & u i Z. o rcww -i eoo wi Z ow .F�w ww ❑ ❑ro ~� _� �a r o� o�o� ii w �wz1 j r. za- .-m 20 wp F. ? -Z' W O zr<m m �u Wym �� w<❑ 4 ow N z> m i� woWi o we omwu;❑ 4�^W o rc .0 i i a^ Jkw �i � ow"� a� ¢o w �¢ m U= O N ¢O ¢F ¢ r ¢2 w 1 -ow o z $ ou o ow oo�0 iaw~ o <9 'z ix m e0.�4 w 1. F. v ow v ga ❑� , ~02 m0 oxg b yWW F -. Q-¢ ¢JFK Z O° Za O �� O(7 O Um Ow¢� p> U j OQOn g °K p. UW. =w OZ U w UFtc d❑ UW ap w o p�p� o z x¢ rW �i�¢ �w r i o?x3 s TUF $Su- '$'w $ �- ^� 80 ❑x 'mug° 0 1O No 0 3❑c of o� oo `oma oo N� oN o i W 2 W F U Al O v O N U y� mw tea± W m0 UW �O Y UV�NF Pe W�3 0 _2I -. n� wy 1F€ �y¢o� °u oW dor H oP wr; u'1 X14 p Jo 0 y Fa Sf w m° � �� ���w� Z ❑ g o. o wo k o 0 2 at" �° am az o ip❑E$ i WW Gm ¢lo` o�QQ"� o o W U< ° UL 412 F¢ t_O U N5~ ~~ zWg� 1 a� Zo °wOwo 42<W w0 a Is _z ugh ^ pQ 0o o yF wx5 cF a riw �a a¢.au <m ¢om w� Fw nzLL _rcaw4°i of m w z- 5' r 3°0 ���`g q❑ awes > o W w ¢w x o _; Opo m rcs mW JU oz JU 30 �xi 3 w�¢ 5 LLgamd o � ❑ �m a� u �w pip Z 3 ¢m p ° w'S OFw �0 fzwuari�3 !i oho 0 b s u' -0 °O= ZwF zf <� U p j O Z❑ a2 Z mwK ¢H O<ja OZ Of -W+m� j0 waQQZ Fap-m ww �¢ p - Z b 6¢ Z w 0 aoo w wo$ wo-Q ww xo -10 oqg 90 zom'oo om a n; t,.: 10 ai !0 1- Z rcarc ¢off o�fgi you f �� ��u� �i xa 3� mem u� oLLswi=m mya rc � '-Z ow oa f aag a F wu-.0 H. A uW,>;!-2= i ozo< .° .Y 0-- � W a� m x j3 y �w �o ,' w400 �s 101, 1 02z °� 00 UwFOF V� U° ip0 Vy¢r Ur OW2N�� 700 �� �F¢ �=❑oa oa ro ioow i � fw� � N¢ eu mini w� w �o uua w o F� o'a< �0 o°o 6.. o.i ow on G��a 0 us< 'du z w 0 rn W lY LL it � o 00 Z m (7 0 w LY w J Y Z a z z 1 w ELH 0 W W CL OJ 0 z W Q ❑ D w U) x O �J U o Z W N �m x � U Y x Y W � W m ,n w La O W 9 O LL lY U7 m 0 0 O m a ~ 0 £8h££ ti I3 `LU J70 # HA_H��,d38 J�V2I I3Q irn m ne st+ Q Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W Q■■ b Wg A'-- el73WH3NLS3IlQrlbZZl o�®�Rg " God o J Y QQIH ❑> � � S u 4❑ a r- N > z U 00 L kn w C� Of W SW L V U) W 0 U � �-d N $g❑ u z z � ¢ u ❑ O ❑w ¢.6 cP ¢ i QQ EE i El�, p 0 O QQ UUU N � o w p o p w, z U O uUZI U p LL ❑ o wUp w ° ¢ a m ❑ ❑ N g g ' n- 0 w w F a oazw w w I ❑ o a,o ❑ _Z e ¢a ❑ a ¢u F 3 az w� F o o zi �wi w _i 2w - o u LL �a� 3 og N m< W W q jQm ? 'Z p z Q Z Z F<F O QWm ❑ %o o❑ T. ozo 20 zZiww �� ❑ a p ¢ w �' g O u OZgo �' zO0 U W W c fa0i Nw ¢ ¢ � i`. t.; a� Z Umfl ¢ F -N U Fa < O<i ¢ U o i u 10 FS HI o $ �Y g� 8 g3 ¢ $ 0 o o� dos= o w L o o, csi o aw joz f� oQ z WO o Zr w �5" o .N F eU � p o- �oc¢ii uwz o oho Na ww S o i a a.-,6Nk x °mow❑ �W�saW, W ❑ oQw ara z� z< LL o o �N , oaa�rc w '¢a �o�u >� g❑ u� aa�° mz wF� 3a m w$ w ao¢ ❑ oawm o w0. ow erc NW z o <�< ❑W F ^"Z. ° 3� Sa a & u i Z. o rcww -i eoo wi Z ow .F�w ww ❑ ❑ro ~� _� �a r o� o�o� ii w �wz1 j r. za- .-m 20 wp F. ? -Z' W O zr<m m �u Wym �� w<❑ 4 ow N z> m i� woWi o we omwu;❑ 4�^W o rc .0 i i a^ Jkw �i � ow"� a� ¢o w �¢ m U= O N ¢O ¢F ¢ r ¢2 w 1 -ow o z $ ou o ow oo�0 iaw~ o <9 'z ix m e0.�4 w 1. F. v ow v ga ❑� , ~02 m0 oxg b yWW F -. Q-¢ ¢JFK Z O° Za O �� O(7 O Um Ow¢� p> U j OQOn g °K p. UW. =w OZ U w UFtc d❑ UW ap w o p�p� o z x¢ rW �i�¢ �w r i o?x3 s TUF $Su- '$'w $ �- ^� 80 ❑x 'mug° 0 1O No 0 3❑c of o� oo `oma oo N� oN o i W 2 W F U Al O v O N U y� mw tea± W m0 UW �O Y UV�NF Pe W�3 0 _2I -. n� wy 1F€ �y¢o� °u oW dor H oP wr; u'1 X14 p Jo 0 y Fa Sf w m° � �� ���w� Z ❑ g o. o wo k o 0 2 at" �° am az o ip❑E$ i WW Gm ¢lo` o�QQ"� o o W U< ° UL 412 F¢ t_O U N5~ ~~ zWg� 1 a� Zo °wOwo 42<W w0 a Is _z ugh ^ pQ 0o o yF wx5 cF a riw �a a¢.au <m ¢om w� Fw nzLL _rcaw4°i of m w z- 5' r 3°0 ���`g q❑ awes > o W w ¢w x o _; Opo m rcs mW JU oz JU 30 �xi 3 w�¢ 5 LLgamd o � ❑ �m a� u �w pip Z 3 ¢m p ° w'S OFw �0 fzwuari�3 !i oho 0 b s u' -0 °O= ZwF zf <� U p j O Z❑ a2 Z mwK ¢H O<ja OZ Of -W+m� j0 waQQZ Fap-m ww �¢ p - Z b 6¢ Z w 0 aoo w wo$ wo-Q ww xo -10 oqg 90 zom'oo om a n; t,.: 10 ai !0 1- Z rcarc ¢off o�fgi you f �� ��u� �i xa 3� mem u� oLLswi=m mya rc � '-Z ow oa f aag a F wu-.0 H. A uW,>;!-2= i ozo< .° .Y 0-- � W a� m x j3 y �w �o ,' w400 �s 101, 1 02z °� 00 UwFOF V� U° ip0 Vy¢r Ur OW2N�� 700 �� �F¢ �=❑oa oa ro ioow i � fw� � N¢ eu mini w� w �o uua w o F� o'a< �0 o°o 6.. o.i ow on G��a 0 us< 'du z w 0 rn W lY LL it � o 00 Z m (7 0 w LY w J Y Z a z z 1 w ELH 0 W W CL OJ 0 z W Q ❑ D w U) x O �J U o Z W N �m x � U Y x Y W � W m ,n w La O W 9 O LL lY U7 m 0 0 O m a ~ 3:vW(" Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W H wLM)- OJQF—w D Ta m Q z J Y �= UN 050 F- U m 00 W Z (7 U 2 O in m W a W Z O j 0 W (ii rn 0 U) 0z g 0 go) ❑ a w z W w 0 0 O Z J w a (07 } F U m w W O w N Ir W 0.0 Vw W Z2 V �a 74 U z W LO =Z) v U W M M W Q O 6 O Q w L Q r p Z D~Z c gU)0 m 0cr O �-1 Z W m a- J F- W o W L 0 W 3:vW(" Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W Z wLM)- OJQF—w W Ta m Q z J wWr0a- Z Q EL J U ap W W UN 050 F- Z W J V W N O d.W,' U�.tOz W M Q m U)M W _i 0 N W =Z) 3 2f d. Q Z = i 0 N W U wQwFYZ20 of LLJN JLL 2 W C,6OUQF- U R O Cl) O_ (M7 CP of � 0 N W W — 1� � J w C� W J caLO O H QZ O tY' LLI w Wm a COz>-W OD LU �JF- W 0 �% � o g �817�� HQMO ` HII, Av Ilt1, H.Lb HN S8 81 l e b0 [ # HH S �� 4 a a Ef W Q+, ca c c L W N C5 W 4Y Q. L. "M WVAHIS JIM9 'Q QS ORD bZZi -j- SHIVISH NH s a �% �% x r $ a`. < i - z z o S LO ��ooa Do�� w a _ -0 Ef W Q+, ca c l �� L W N C5 W z o 3 pa",*an 'I. �:DFa'IL T H �:5`4a -wvr s pat --z O t� Q-�I�H Z:)I�I g Q ■ ■ cy � x,� ® £817££ dQRO'13 `HDd98 Ad2C13Q bol# af d FIN 98 Si3Qlifl8 3UISVHS a teP..m a v OO ■ ■ m i `a. $ " k` o C �-^^ z a' O a "Id WVMUS . TID 'QAlEl WFIDO N bZZI a S91VISFI -dAOfl2IdH N3C[CIIH o ? V• w U 0 60 0 cd a O O w ,-O O v N Vl a , e LU ai o 0 60 0 cd a O O w ,-O O v N Vl a , e L a 0 U 0 oo W -1 E RMZ d d N � N o a 0 U 0 oo W -1 u�u vauoou�rv� �oru�.ra.n�ov Amur uavn�.o �v urru�rvu� rv�u.o.� »>oon> >..i i.runa.n o�.�u�i vnn nou.� nnv na + . rv��nava� u�_. uan or u�. our u»nuuoa�o �a nvry .vu.a vnoumr au �n�.��u �.ry ra »>ni �u lovo un u�i�oa»o . ry �an�ro ..v u�i vauoou�nr �o.u��lrn�ov �urvu. uovn��o na crcc Maio. vnau� O � an'IL Z,>pa.L T H �::is PET t.,z0-r Q-�I�H �I�I „ ■ ■ u £84££ VaINO `HOt Hg 98 bOl# 3f1N�FI .Lb AV H3NN S81 N � ^ g v a oLn � ua S w ® S-dHo'IIf]H flQISVHS ® '"L3 YWHILLS d'IfIJ 'QA'Ifl NVHDO 'N bZZ l -1- ■ ■ ¢ m a a o 'j' w > S JO SMLV.LSH 2IfIOUNVH NHQQIH uc❑a r� lL 9 a 4-40 0 60 0. 0 Q� r-� W W Cd Cd a ti O 00'009: L aleDS -- Ml 6E.'E0 -- ClOe 190 -- PX69107 tEO-06WXcOlOOVO 7Vd73N301 S6upliVJG O m J votes, O w7 lu cc Aw m J votes, O w7 LL - UJ cu > ® VD C-4 VD co Lu LU A Vol o L C 7-0 V O J / /_ bIb CTbO� 31b1S .0.0 a N N N V• Z�sOcn 5� uuu�uu��9 .pY .Y �Utl rivYry ppQm3Q6n9m0m'I oo®smoammmm� Vt Q EE € _ tlf U'0mU0-UU an a-- na- as Su m4u�mAumw in mpaO aOwmUmamm ��m�Rgg�NyNN ��L=CC�mmmmmm l � A 0 -• JI � jr tl 41 L U U 41 L a 9 Uva m p L u�u` ®44444 V U- W CYa E > o Ca Cel u. cu -CD °O ~- O LU —� o ® f -- m k g a k k= 4 g° : B s ¢u j a9 k „n a2 nn aI 2 a g^ 9r 9 m to ° a8a.s?p;P� 9LL 6p g_ 3gbe� y�5��q�s�! Y bi a`k S� 34 a g3 on ¢5 3a C Ao 1v aS Lua°8 ;-,f. N„ . I „ Y Y Q - I . m „ . m tl „ , ° s „ Q „ 4 4= 4$ e 4 s u° m- -a° ad QR kit Is J a c X35 $a • v "� Xi v v U V! Y 9 °2)" l 0 o 41 D 0 o m °�N # s o� V• Z�sOcn 5� uuu�uu��9 .pY .Y �Utl rivYry ppQm3Q6n9m0m'I oo®smoammmm� Vt Q EE € _ tlf U'0mU0-UU an a-- na- as Su m4u�mAumw in mpaO aOwmUmamm ��m�Rgg�NyNN ��L=CC�mmmmmm l � A 0 -• JI � jr tl 41 L U U 41 L a 9 Uva m p L u�u` ®44444 V U- W CYa E > o Ca Cel u. cu -CD °O ~- O LU —� o ® f -- m k g a k k= 4 g° : B s ¢u j a9 k „n a2 nn aI 2 a g^ 9r 9 m to ° a8a.s?p;P� 9LL 6p g_ 3gbe� y�5��q�s�! Y bi a`k S� 34 a g3 on ¢5 3a C Ao 1v aS Lua°8 ;-,f. N„ . I „ Y Y Q - I . m „ . m tl „ , ° s „ Q „ 4 4= 4$ e 4 s u° m- -a° ad QR kit Is J a c X35 $a \EIM §E!,\}o 1. §§}±. - f g \� :c¥ . `2 ]§ \\ ■ $ 20 ` m C la | - t *kms ----- ------}----2 LCo § | L-- /� , � ---- \EIM §E!,\}o 1. §§}±. - f g \� :c¥ . `2 ]§ \\ ■ $ 20 ` m C la | - t LCo § , ® L , � 3 � 0. � d � � }�{ }i � t|! { ! f ! f � -4 m LL 0() W\ IE h 9 LU N 9L0 0 W +ice II uan O O u^ m r_ I s a� O+.' O 11 L v w > a m _ 1 � a o° i o L u, t N W NAA 19U0U 444444 `� �c ® ®y to, C-1 SON ER va W M L CO r/ U E 0 L 7 ' 13 u U 0 W 0 p h' t La L co .0 0 p ¢ �Phil �:�4#ay1raipL u !1!€ -1 21' SFS tra 1, € p pP -FSBagrtE,$�Eaga8;ad���o y9 eDwa fi$§si33$a a 1pgW F 4{§ .@� �'-�� �z s 6a s � yy° �hg5�1� 19 $BF4 a. .? E $ 93� §4 EF.. a F isda io Va;3 �eyE spy pg =ac lafi6$4?Pgs §85s ;Ei ;�a89 a$� lase a:�$aaYa$a a$ !P$� SI > °q;a 3F: 6° 2Eg a' �aaJS Fk $appp I I a., 9"a g yafE' 1 t5 si �a9` p'_e:a °�AB1 aF �ka8 ss �o?$.s sm9:�n9 a§a -$fig= P papa s l"$ as s`z 3'• Y Y sy 4. sF3F of X783 �13 u.38Pa 53 �55 it �•[� ;_ u d Y n �S Ij' $— e�f fib $$ i?Efi 3 g'$$y 2g ;ytry s� }9a 6 ' �= a s P s sa E ;baa s Ya t ys ?a $ �6�y ° aa_. g_ �yy ?3a R aim �� gr 9 � ` off an 5 la 9; �� t���� fi.�E�E;s � � Ea�E a�g �€�S � °� y� � a ea$ i =a 4 a �;; 132 ;?k aE .4 b i' li gi i° _� € a E 6p, �j8!$1 i1�y E d � Ni.]. %3Sy E 7 �!1 �Gg61 a : mB • 1` ���fi Sig 89 `oo e ro : 3a 3•II. A & $ 8s5, a=E s ,$A;P k 5y E$ i Y g E4F 911 a k 1 fib ° �.a a ye a3a o $i 9§s` s sBa=g kro °o 31291 .3i _� Y k s - i s=t Bfi5�e b s By 1- $�9.. fid' �'° s § : S � ,. �i',� 8 $ $3 P 'Y Q � .e 13 3E`y� a $ $•: i3 zBt�yA i FBF ai a�;5� Y as s'I baa n E a s° ➢j� 9u P=A3e _ Y 3Y "a gala. to tr =$ro ds oaf d� a 4%3 rt _ _ zs3AN $®!� 6 d 6 U d W i 4 d U d u MM$�3�� B Y,tahvi„a $ $?a';i a a$= E gy a�,:=`E E'. a= 5 •B 3mBF3tr $ l a sg i fie SF =yg$ II i `,p S PB=$;pq as Y a Y 3e $ it 3; i ,I 8 a a a 4 , R e5i1 •6 gE �2rtp°4_' g'3 63 d �5 c$ a$ z•a - C H Boy mm $6 ° $__ ,➢?3 "bill- s 8 eap Y $a g 1's ;aa - 5 3` .ay3 - s 3la;zs. E=gz4€s• °$ Y: 3w. E d aay3 1'Egl S t o 8 i�95 w A 1 i a.i ILME lea �8s , 4 1saa; ySP6.j 8 i= 6 .455 a 211� ?:;A ,.E w �:_ � 8 8� `s :3�� - ;5•$s8 P: 3 g u n E-. �� �� d8a .3���, 3� n8 gt8 fro -�'� � � e �h 3 $_ $3.� §� �!! §. ,�8� 6 8a• S� ;-;-, P 8 P �' ,P,.T ; P=E 8 r i 9� e8 a E sgpal B a3'$ s 39�� 3 �- € E �EB� � 4 3�p#`WB$B��:Bs`. i•F F P E � sS tys, � � 8l m -!aa R i B ?- �a a $8s ga ayi a. Rnak�PB B? rt�243a ?a �d1 #a ' a& Alt 8a 3• �E ! gs i d f 4 d d U seB$'s 3B = 33 !-` 9131 �$ �aaa 6•'�1 ;a tY88 a a Jilt .i!ol 298 :a :§ Ffi P S n _aE• _ y a� a9h E •�s 41 of pp6• 15 §a §§ii B 19:y y a9Eiaa3 �gy�� �2Y m:l°3aan a$S 4 3EL� P All,E y• Ey ' Es yi y=y e$ $;j 63 ! jd•; b Mpi y82B ji9!$ t a°y asp �Ee a;5 a�5�agg=9g3�ay $5�a=1r i3y€$;ki" P B P =Ys -t Jr pa;3rt 3-a=B is F Ep�SUpn"Pa. E=71a9 Cog& &� S ae s 8a d �� !gB�.yI 63i,sp 7B7 s �! _� 9�3J 3 tr x�63Ea$,p8; 3�P�ns €65a4��6��3i k3 trn•: k 8-i'� � n^"; :1•i���i ,_8� �: v 3 B'8 =n8° apQa F'S ao$§ �$ na§`karo=t� a ;d y�Em'3 !S'3•l;y 8saa g;Ee�E -121E F ai_. - NIP. - d'§gki3' 6 Rg�6�yq�trj•a�'FyF��5i §�3Yk $PliE$ �� F 64 e1�ro 3� 4L;.�$$$a 1 . sai¢6 S� �s-§Bcay3d S Eh. � 3�� fi °8J�; � g ��• zh I?a96�QsgAMU ��$� ��Ea$ � 1 it HA �a g� at rtA a s3'-_ E -yyF 1i 8�2 1$� s B 4 3 a5S M 112 • ; 4b 53aE�9EY 3a9� ' �� p - § 8a --P1 9i3. jEva 1$ 9191P11 -B j! Y ail E 21 i¢ his J11i lid ie3 ;p a1$-Iik- >ss 3 Ra�¢4 l y8 4aa$l3 3 a$ E ,y ass fi9s 3 jjli3 3.,36 ail 3E S 3 ChZR9 $09a2�aS 3` $Asa 8 - _ $ _ E •�S7ni3 $a aaB1 aa6�, -trot u d A d d d U d W k 34h �Etr3 a3zE �: _U B1Pgfx lE IES _ i-6 P3; . � 8 i ' II F' iAb °et� Bc8` 3't n� s 111HP All ,$i1s,d� � ��aa 3 B&ay3$ 6,tr 83 n 9$' P-15 F i8 l Hit 5i1 5 ? � .2 5Y2a a%af E_§ 3 = 1111 �7:a�m l9sa AM �flffl<F 5 �Tj7 3 z d d U 0 3 d gill @11RI - $VISE - qyl -$ IUDnD NO 8 'a• �au 21,912 ? k§ E a m m h B $ � yy B pa r s B $a; ,IRI 3a maB 3a fir: p§ 31�a E :ld8 y5�Wit � 9F� _1 j� EE! ;�ir�, k ;i¢i', 214ap" til a � 5 ••� 2•E�all Ea � E rt gal W-111 1,01-11'a It f 4 y�n $ ? HIM,, �� �yro as A M d �'�5� 3a d15_S d�= Ca?Pa, a3 a �d- 'i3y o.Y M. ±°Itr_ d w � Pt - ��i� P a9`o! 5 y MIN? B ; g ds8 �.J§•' -�k� qtr: 3 � $:� Ss� �8 a PaE $ § a $ � 111, 93;a lZ3sgg�s jilt 5 3 HUM g 1 p��r aIDjfin$$$idW�a$i &�p2ailYas§_kA? e B 5 $$ 6E °E 9 tr E 3jd 3 -�vip a $s- g$ J� N 3 `�a i2 -g #s €t Y 4B a Baa tr $s;� dgB E a �& a aE.sf §6Ea 1 39 :• $ as 3Em $Fa i n§ �_3 d $!- pa 6 s°• a 2= BELIr sy= �t$��i ll JUL?a: :, a § ! Eag.01 �.$ c ➢oma i�ia� 848' y eaa3 fie! 3 a 3 PbT ��tr 9 B' a I .Er" P. 8 yra, 875 X98`' � §§fi2: $.- 8 4 95 trniB5 Sn1 P sE�$ aa��3pe�� � �n a4 ��� �.� Eat �-"��$$� ���'a=$ a�z�; Y$ '$' '$ '� ��➢ � EE'g�y$=g�8��' EP s��•�aAq ¢°�$�-p�d� F E IIs'= a 1 B§B'4_ ig F! e'2 E i rt �a § �i8o 8 8� fi 8'"�r It kid I 93-g� E1:uf, Es 5 $ y 3� n$ ET $1 13 Q a_. ,'$s$. 5P aFgla'�' --'fi Ey =a f iE a $�93^. a$. ' i a3=�. as as =1 sd�'=,a y $$$$ 3E{fi' E3 io a E $ Ee 'g8; 8T1 �➢ 5;aaA- a�oa ;� a= _� :�..�3 �3� �a� &Bsi; & §'x� -P Ez sn roma i a P^'i1 AII YP_E3-•E$ fig` !B 3 F1 a �3 y dE §'y E : 1- i y1� Bs35 �_" i 9 R° i s1 1a �6y §_ a• fiaEL 5�g:,.a fir• § 6't Y75 fi !3F a 2 a8�ada! �iaa�� , u s 3u4,� �� i roEf'tA adi aEEE < $ L tlx: =tr: m$ 3 z$�B�E 3't 8a $33 d9 Y$& g ��I1�--.�68 M _�$8!a$s� k u a d d u 4 0 8 14 !$ p3 I TIM aBp aro$ $`off- Bila:aP!�'a' W y R $ l a § B 1 =!:$a$: g f' 1p$ a Eby aeuaaaaass9 fis F 3 a¢' s1i1 tr kEs 9 r $��•$ta a o°i h �� $= BEaa a 3 $ °asaaaaaaa a-, F p Ii p6Ya d!a° :g a s 3 ! @ro;p B ➢ :!3 r Pi g?pa fie_�..jg�n1 E; l� f aiv-i:S� a m$ 1'��'E3$ $Ea a dz Ei" ase -9]11113t $`�a '§ y 2$5!1h a F a¢e as ! 13 a aG :$y:� ares_=E � 4�6: $$ p $kEga $8S4 s fi•pfi 6 116 N! pp 9§ 3g8ero' ro -E 9 �_P$� 7•a ss �;6s' 3 as � 1 e�� ,c � yE g8d � $� Bfie s_� E�P3'S EP�3,E_;. $vaF� $ •sa �=1pB d a 4 k $9�}a�ya �� ! i� �wJ 8 y' a �pl,9 ipp g '.3 p 8aAa i 9v i rt ya 88 5 $' � d: $• ,° s� 3 ai P i 3a8' 6�!'-n$ �2:�31, �- s !�_`� � Y �s5 4�ss B° bad H 4E �. x a•... a { ••� ��� ��� tr`E- ��a G�9 � �E 1� P rt` $��` �;$������ �aE. �' - �� ��' E �� ��s-jj r p$E�n A z. F. { Z Y 4 s a = �..F�.,,Rax4 E8= s' t it % as E;z$ $p'$�p�IIaa !g B yy3Ea i ��yp 8 a F`8$ a?$a �zgdsa�= &_s$EYyy�ta 91'ag E�®a$iyy$�2p¢�i�$� '�� $ja °a =a3y aaE� F t63R � da3Eaa H8891a aE IMI 8311, H 8t i�]pM iii:.°E' i� g36g rt°��g $�3D��ss 8giY9s-fEo�st nH � g#�� ��r �� �E �fi S�B6'3 ro a .4 d d d w . d _ 6Ea 2�g :� y y 11$18111`0 :433=i3 :8 2: a 32. _h� �A:.n" a°8 al 3 zsB8 53s Y F < J� �§ lit M, �� gB a�'B 6 P%�a lilap 4g F�'_ aE =$Y g ay$ EF j ¢ iff"91 ilk 191 a it; Bl .3 ga 'a° 5 aS $3 F 1e, am.a:. y4 4-26a did Alii z d d U d pp C d seB$'s 3B = 33 !-` 9131 �$ �aaa 6•'�1 ;a tY88 a a Jilt .i!ol 298 :a :§ Ffi P S n _aE• _ y a� a9h E •�s 41 of pp6• 15 §a §§ii B 19:y y a9Eiaa3 �gy�� �2Y m:l°3aan a$S 4 3EL� P All,E y• Ey ' Es yi y=y e$ $;j 63 ! jd•; b Mpi y82B ji9!$ t a°y asp �Ee a;5 a�5�agg=9g3�ay $5�a=1r i3y€$;ki" P B P =Ys -t Jr pa;3rt 3-a=B is F Ep�SUpn"Pa. E=71a9 Cog& &� S ae s 8a d �� !gB�.yI 63i,sp 7B7 s �! _� 9�3J 3 tr x�63Ea$,p8; 3�P�ns €65a4��6��3i k3 trn•: k 8-i'� � n^"; :1•i���i ,_8� �: v 3 B'8 =n8° apQa F'S ao$§ �$ na§`karo=t� a ;d y�Em'3 !S'3•l;y 8saa g;Ee�E -121E F ai_. - NIP. - d'§gki3' 6 Rg�6�yq�trj•a�'FyF��5i §�3Yk $PliE$ �� F 64 e1�ro 3� 4L;.�$$$a 1 . sai¢6 S� �s-§Bcay3d S Eh. � 3�� fi °8J�; � g ��• zh I?a96�QsgAMU ��$� ��Ea$ � 1 it HA �a g� at rtA a s3'-_ E -yyF 1i 8�2 1$� s B 4 3 a5S M 112 • ; 4b 53aE�9EY 3a9� ' �� p - § 8a --P1 9i3. jEva 1$ 9191P11 -B j! Y ail E 21 i¢ his J11i lid ie3 ;p a1$-Iik- >ss 3 Ra�¢4 l y8 4aa$l3 3 a$ E ,y ass fi9s 3 jjli3 3.,36 ail 3E S 3 ChZR9 $09a2�aS 3` $Asa 8 - _ $ _ E •�S7ni3 $a aaB1 aa6�, -trot u d A d d d U d W k 34h �Etr3 a3zE �: _U B1Pgfx lE IES _ i-6 P3; . � 8 i ' II F' iAb °et� Bc8` 3't n� s 111HP All ,$i1s,d� � ��aa 3 B&ay3$ 6,tr 83 n 9$' P-15 F i8 l Hit 5i1 5 ? � .2 5Y2a a%af E_§ 3 = 1111 �7:a�m l9sa AM �flffl<F 5 �Tj7 3 z d d U 0 3 d gill @11RI - $VISE - qyl -$ IUDnD NO 8 'a• �au 21,912 ? k§ E a m m h B $ � yy B pa r s B $a; ,IRI 3a maB 3a fir: p§ 31�a E :ld8 y5�Wit � 9F� _1 j� EE! ;�ir�, k ;i¢i', 214ap" til a � 5 ••� 2•E�all Ea � E rt gal W-111 1,01-11'a It f 4 y�n $ ? HIM,, �� �yro as A M d �'�5� 3a d15_S d�= Ca?Pa, a3 a �d- 'i3y o.Y M. ±°Itr_ d w � Pt - ��i� P a9`o! 5 y MIN? B ; g ds8 �.J§•' -�k� qtr: 3 � $:� Ss� �8 a PaE $ § a $ � 111, 93;a lZ3sgg�s jilt 5 3 HUM g 1 p��r aIDjfin$$$idW�a$i &�p2ailYas§_kA? e B 5 $$ 6E °E 9 tr E 3jd 3 -�vip a $s- g$ J� N 3 `�a i2 -g #s €t Y 4B a Baa tr $s;� dgB E a �& a aE.sf §6Ea 1 39 :• $ as 3Em $Fa i n§ �_3 d $!- pa 6 s°• a 2= BELIr sy= �t$��i ll JUL?a: :, a § ! Eag.01 �.$ c ➢oma i�ia� 848' y eaa3 fie! 3 a 3 PbT ��tr 9 B' a I .Er" P. 8 yra, 875 X98`' � §§fi2: $.- 8 4 95 trniB5 Sn1 P sE�$ aa��3pe�� � �n a4 ��� �.� Eat �-"��$$� ���'a=$ a�z�; Y$ '$' '$ '� ��➢ � EE'g�y$=g�8��' EP s��•�aAq ¢°�$�-p�d� F E IIs'= a 1 B§B'4_ ig F! e'2 E i rt �a § �i8o 8 8� fi 8'"�r It kid I 93-g� E1:uf, Es 5 $ y 3� n$ ET $1 13 Q a_. ,'$s$. 5P aFgla'�' --'fi Ey =a f iE a $�93^. a$. ' i a3=�. as as =1 sd�'=,a y $$$$ 3E{fi' E3 io a E $ Ee 'g8; 8T1 �➢ 5;aaA- a�oa ;� a= _� :�..�3 �3� �a� &Bsi; & §'x� -P Ez sn roma i a P^'i1 AII YP_E3-•E$ fig` !B 3 F1 a �3 y dE §'y E : 1- i y1� Bs35 �_" i 9 R° i s1 1a �6y §_ a• fiaEL 5�g:,.a fir• § 6't Y75 fi !3F a 2 a8�ada! �iaa�� , u s 3u4,� �� i roEf'tA adi aEEE < $ L tlx: =tr: m$ 3 z$�B�E 3't 8a $33 d9 Y$& g ��I1�--.�68 M _�$8!a$s� k u a d d u 4 0 8 14 !$ p3 I TIM aBp aro$ $`off- Bila:aP!�'a' W y R $ l a § B 1 =!:$a$: g f' 1p$ a Eby aeuaaaaass9 fis F 3 a¢' s1i1 tr kEs 9 r $��•$ta a o°i h �� $= BEaa a 3 $ °asaaaaaaa a-, F p Ii p6Ya d!a° :g a s 3 ! @ro;p B ➢ :!3 r Pi g?pa fie_�..jg�n1 E; l� f aiv-i:S� a m$ 1'��'E3$ $Ea a dz Ei" ase -9]11113t $`�a '§ y 2$5!1h a F a¢e as ! 13 a aG :$y:� ares_=E � 4�6: $$ p $kEga $8S4 s fi•pfi 6 116 N! pp 9§ 3g8ero' ro -E 9 �_P$� 7•a ss �;6s' 3 as � 1 e�� ,c � yE g8d � $� Bfie s_� E�P3'S EP�3,E_;. $vaF� $ •sa �=1pB d a 4 k $9�}a�ya �� ! i� �wJ 8 y' a �pl,9 ipp g '.3 p 8aAa i 9v i rt ya 88 5 $' � d: $• ,° s� 3 ai P i 3a8' 6�!'-n$ �2:�31, �- s !�_`� � Y �s5 4�ss B° bad H 4E �. x a•... a { ••� ��� ��� tr`E- ��a G�9 � �E 1� P rt` $��` �;$������ �aE. �' - �� ��' E �� ��s-jj r p$E�n A z. F. { Z Y 4 s a = �..F�.,,Rax4 E8= s' t it % as E;z$ $p'$�p�IIaa !g B yy3Ea i ��yp 8 a F`8$ a?$a �zgdsa�= &_s$EYyy�ta 91'ag E�®a$iyy$�2p¢�i�$� '�� $ja °a =a3y aaE� F t63R � da3Eaa H8891a aE IMI 8311, H 8t i�]pM iii:.°E' i� g36g rt°��g $�3D��ss 8giY9s-fEo�st nH � g#�� ��r �� �E �fi S�B6'3 ro a .4 d d d w . d _ 6Ea 2�g :� y y 11$18111`0 :433=i3 :8 2: a 32. _h� �A:.n" a°8 al 3 zsB8 53s Y F < J� FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET SCOTT W MORGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd GULF STREAM, FL 33483 PH (561)-752.,1936 FAX (80.1)-760-2777 Date: 7-23-13 To: Town of Gulf Stream Fax: 561-737-0188 From: Scott W. Morgan Re: Application for Level 3 approval of Lot 5- Hidden Harbour Estates Number of pages: 3 Memo: Please find attached my letter in opposition to this application. Would you please make copies of the letter for distribution to the members of the ARPl3? SCOTT W. MORGAN 1.140 N. Ocean ,Blvd GW Stream, Fl, 33483 Ph (561) 243-1432 July 23, 2013 To: Town of Gulf Stream Architectural .Review and :planning Board Re: Hidden Harbour F'slates Lot 5 1224 N. (Ocean Blvd. Dear Board Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review of a 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec. 66-144 (b)(1009 The proposed architectural design of this home violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures. The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than of an Ocean West District home. Because the lot is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale. The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. Sec. 70-4 (c) (4) and Sec. 70-29 (b) (3) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's prohibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Code's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located _"(Art, I, Sec. 70-4 (c )(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "lots that are set back. great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district." (Art. U, Sec. 70-29 (b)(3)). The homes of this District have a unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Hidden Harbour Estates—all of which are rectangular, long Bast to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other life two rows of domino tiles has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- community sub -division, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Raton and West Delray Beach. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all corner lots and so were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes on adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. In order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West District character, and to prevent an over -crowding of similar homes inside Hidden. )Harbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 ArchitecturaVSite Plan Review of Lot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re -submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, ott W Morga I t. rn 00'0-19: R alcog -- lNd 60.EO -- El0-1/EdFJO -- PX5'9107 h-1-1-06IPXOIOOVO 7Vt13N39195U1AivJO:O 2z�� p 5yy � C Gj� o Co Ad q Q. u J_ J v GI ^ o LijLo *—r � � g � ��� Q ti 111 ................ Yd �3LYlS �� � (bQ CCM SN7l707 CC+ All o �W a IQ y � s t X � O s •e @ b co 0 0 5 -4r I a a I � e Ii � I I rNLH 31 YAW Y) Xtfo ) ZLW igl+ ,Y, 10YXL vomw rl.Ysmv33arr. v Lonnrrr c-} + ix�mv33Tnneo n of Z 107 107 Z 00'0019: ! ale -91, --kM 60:00 -- ElOZlr{/90 -- PX6'S1O7 POO-06IPXOI00VO 7Vd3N3JIs6u1Ai-Qj:0 -�3A Yd �P7 �y oa - �kr • .r7I7 w4r., I AIN 4: ilk t O W c 0 tl 4 Uxi � �ryV ul O O J J sr I W I I Dar r 1M 21 YAW Y) Ksr lex a JA013M yW~ rax mudZtNvw ° uer ace+ ,Y. 10N2[L � tnamy3 Mnneo �� R ��amn�roaa—1 Z 107 �I 107 CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Ann Kasten Aker George Delafieled, Jr. REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF THURSDAY, DECEMBER 27, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes. A. Regular Meeting & B. Joint Meeting with December 20, 2012 BY THE ARCHITECTURAL STREAM, FLORIDA ON THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA Public Hearing of 10-25-12. Twn. Commission of 12-14-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. January 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Quinn Miklos, Miklos & Asssoc. as Agent for Gerald & Sharon Clippinger, the owners of property located at 2538 Avenue Au Soleil, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 48 Place Au Soleil Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the extension of an existing non -conforming wall that encroaches 4.2 feet into the required 15 foot south side setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit additions consisting of bathroom, covered entry and additional living area, a net total of 716.6 square feet, to the existing one-story single family dwelling and an exterior renovation to smooth stucco with the addition of quoins on the corners. A new brick driveway will also be a part of the renovations. 2. An Application submitted by Rene Tercilla, Tercilla Courtemanche Architects, Inc. as agent for The Gulf Stream School Foundation, Inc., owners of property located at 3600 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as a parcel of land lying in Section 3, Township 46 South, Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida. a. VARIANCE #1 to allow an increase in total floor area that will exceed the 61,737 square feet allowed in the existing Developer's Agreement by 1,617 square feet. AGENDA CONTINUED b. VARIANCE #2 to permit an increase of 11,765 square feet over the 6,000 square feet permitted for the second floor area in the existing Developer's Agreement. C. DEMOLITION to demolish the existing one story pavilion consisting of 1,681 square feet. d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to replace and enlarge the first floor pavilion and add three second floor classrooms, an interior corridor and an exterior covered walkway and stairs, a total of 4,1875 square feet. 3. An application submitted by Peter Carney as agent for James and Beverly Kolea, owners of property located at 960 Orchid Lane, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 83, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to construct a rear portico and a new front entrance to the existing one-story, single family Bermuda/British Colonial style dwelling, additions of 403 square feet. 4. An application submitted by James Boyce of OK Seahorse LLLP as agent for OK Seahorse LLLP, owners of the property located at 4001 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Sec. 34, Township 45 South, Range 43 East in Palm Beach County. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish the existing southern most dune crossover. b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the relocation and reconstruction of the existing southern most dune crossover to a location that is 15 feet north of the south property line at the above address C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to rebuild the southern most dune crossover in a new location that is 15 feet north of the south property line of 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. That will be the same size as the existing structure. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, OCTOBER 25, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:35 A,. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Morgan called the Meeting to order at Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy Paul Lyons Beau Delafield Tom Smith Ann Aker William Thrasher Rita Taylor John Randolph Hope Calhoun, Esq. of Greenspoon, Marten Tom Laudani of Seaside Builders Richard Jones of Jones Architects Dave Bodker of Dave Bodker Landscape & Architecture Joe Pike of EnviroDesign Martin O'Boyle, Res. George Elmore, Res. Bill Himmelrich, Res. Lisa Morgan, Res. Ben Schrier of Affinity Architects Joe Peterson of Peterson Design Pro Guy Flora of Mark Timothy Tom Murphy, Esq Audrey Schwartz f Chairman Vice -Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting As Board Member Board Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Rep. Applic./Developer Tom Laudani Applic./Developer Architect/Harbour View Landscape Architect/ Harbour View Engineer/Harbour View 2300 N. Hidden Harbour Dr. 1320 N. Ocean Blvd. N. Ocean Blvd. 1140 N. Ocean Blvd. Arch./3333 N. Ocean Landscape Architect/ 3333 N. Ocean GC/3333 N. Ocean Construction Rep. Res. 3265 Audrey Schwartz N. Ocean Blvd. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 9-27-12. Mr. Murphy moved and Vice -Chairman Jones seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of September 27, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. Mr. Thrasher requested to re -arrange the Public Hearing Agenda to be heard as follows: Item VI.A.2.b., VI.A.3.b., VI.A.l.a., 2.a., 3.a., Item VI.4.a.,b.,c.,d. There were no objections. Chairman Morgan noted Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 2 that Tom Murphy, Esq., is involved in Item VI.4 and has to be in court this morning. He said, depending on how the meeting goes, Mr. Murphy may be taken out of turn to make his presentation. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. November 15, 2012 at 8:30 A.M. b. December 27, 2012 @ 8:30 A.M. C. January 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Morgan noted that the November Meeting will be held early in the month and asked if anyone had a conflict. There were no conflicts with the Meeting Dates. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. Chairman Morgan asked if there was Ex -parte communication concerning any of the items being heard today. Mr. Morgan stated that he spoke with Mr. Laudani last week regarding some of the matters discussed at the previous meeting explaining why items were deferred to this meeting. There were no further declarations of Ex -parte communication. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to the following individuals who were planning to testify during this Public Hearing: Hope Calhoun, Esq., Tom Laudani, Richard Jones, Dave Bodker, Joe Pike, Bill Himmelrich, George Elmore, Martin O'Boyle, Tom Murphy, Esq., Audrey Schwartz, Lisa Morgan, Ben Schrier, Joe Peterson and Guy Flora. Hope Calhoun, Esq., introduced herself and said she is present on behalf of the Applicant. She thanked the ARPB for their consideration and said they have gone through many drafts working with Town Staff and they believe the application has satisfied all architectural requirements. Ms. Calhoun stated that, due to possible time constraints, all testimony should be focused primarily on architectural review and then the overlay. She said issues of the plat were heard previously and are not necessarily relevant today. Ms. Calhoun requested the opportunity to re -address the Board following the presentation to respond to any questions or comments. A. Applications for Development Approval 2. An application, deferred from Public Hearing held September 27, 2012, submitted by Seaside Builders LLC as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1220 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 4, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, a replat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 15, Pages 173 & 174, Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow the removal of existing nuisance exotics and extensive Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 3 planting of native species and the installation of an entrance wall and gates, a portion of which is within the 50' corridor. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial two-story Bermuda style single family dwelling, 3 car garage with bonus room above, 8,603 square feet, and a swimming pool. Richard Jones introduced himself and thanked the Board for recommending approval of Lot 3 and said it did go through the Commission and received approval. He said they received good comments from the ARPB at the last meeting relating to the Town's new ordinance addressing two-story mass and the appropriate methods of addressing the issue. Mr. Jones said the proposed 2 -story Bermuda Style structure will sit on the southeast lot. He said they addressed the issue of mass by breaking down the house into various portions interconnected by covered roofs, and they created courtyards to capture outdoor space. He said the color scheme is the traditional off-white with black shutters and white mitered roof. To address mass on the second floor, two balconies were added on the south elevation facing the private road and one on the north elevation facing another lot, all of which are a minimum of 24 SF and consistent with the two proposed balconies on the east elevation. In addition, they did overlays of the existing landscape and Mr. Jones said Dave Bodker created elevations showing the existing 15' no -cut zone landscaping as well as the proposed new landscaping, which will screen the entire south elevation of the home and provide ample screening on the north, east and west elevations as well. Mr. Jones said that Dave Bodker will review the proposed landscaping, Joe Pike will address any drainage questions, and the Developer, Tom Laudani, will any questions. Chairman Morgan asked what the distance will be from A1A to the gate and then to the house. Mr. Jones said it will be 50 feet to the gate and 98'9" feet to the house. Chairman Morgan asked if the additional balconies are identical and asked for their depth. Mr. Jones said they are identical and they are 4' deep by 6' wide, 24 SF. Chairman Morgan asked if the addition of the balconies meets Code. Mr. Thrasher confirmed that saying Section 70-73, Two- story, provides four options that can be used to break massing of the facade and one option is the use of balconies that are a minimum of 24 SF. Dave Bodker introduced himself. He said they depicted the proposed and existing vegetation to show how all elevations will be seen from different property lines. Mr. Bodker said there are 19 existing trees along the south property line which will remain and any gaps will be filled in with Buttonwood trees or Fishtail palms, and a series of under plantings with various hedging. On the north elevation which faces the interior, they will plant tall Sable palms at higher elevations of the house and smaller trees throughout. The west elevation will also be seen from the interior and shade trees will be planted in several locations to break up the garage. The east elevation will be seen from A1A, there are a large number of existing trees along the east elevation Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 4 that will be filled in with additional plantings and there will be additional vegetation on the north side of the entrance gate to provide sufficient screening. With regard to the wall on the south elevation as you drive down Hidden Harbour Road, Mr. Lyons asked if existing vegetation will block the wall on the south elevation. Mr. Bodker said they have already planted a 5' high Buttonwood hedge along the wall which will eventually block the wall, and he said there is also hedging on the top of the wall and along the interior of the wall. George Elmore introduced himself and questioned the Minutes of the 9/27/12 ARPB Meeting where on Page 4, Paragraph 2, it says Mr. Himmelrich is happy with the drainage and there are no issues. Mr. Elmore the drainage system works, but he said there are issues if it is not properly maintained everyone in the 1300s will be flooded and it must be resolved. He said Mr. Laudani is working on it and informed him that documents were sent to his attorney, but they have not been received. Chairman Morgan noted that this was covered in the last meeting and the conclusion was that it should be brought to the Commission for further pursuit. He said Staff will make record of Mr. Elmore's comments in the Minutes of this meeting. Ms. Calhoun confirmed that documents were sent to Mr. Elmore's attorney about two weeks ago. Lisa Morgan introduced herself and said she would like to address landscape issues exclusively and asked if the Board would hear her presentation at this time or wait until after the building has been addressed. Chairman Morgan said they will address the buildings and the immediate landscape designs first. He said there is a separate application for the overlay permit with the Australian Pines, which will be addressed separately at the conclusion of the building. Mr. Thrasher said there are two actions to be taken, one of which is on Level III and the other is a portion of this property abutting N. Ocean Blvd. where there is request for the creation of a clear zone on the east side. Chairman Morgan recommended addressing all questions on building and then move into the Overlay Permit. Vice -Chairman Jones commented that she really liked the addition of the balconies, which improves all facades of the building. Martin O'Boyle introduced himself and asked if there is a requirement under the Code for positive Drainage. Mr. Thrasher said the requirement is for the individual lots and properties to retain the first 1" of runoff on their site by either positive outfall or exfiltration trenches, or a combination of both. He said Delray Engineering will be verifying that, but he said the requirement is not restrictive to just positive outfall. Mr. O'Boyle agreed saying there are two alternatives, positive outfall and retention, and asked if runoff will be retained on site. Mr. Laudani asked Mr. Pike to answer the question and Ms. Calhoun stated that Mr. Pike can answer the question generally because drainage is not before the Board today. She said drainage issues were handled with respect to the plat during a previous hearing. Chairman Morgan said much of this was covered at the last meeting, but he said it involves our Code, which relates to ARPB activity. He asked Mr. O'Boyle to make Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 5 his points so they are of record and then Mr. Pike may give a brief response; however, he said it may or may not impact the Board's decision today. Mr. O'Boyle asked Mr. Pike if the drainage required under the Code is positive or retained on site. Further, Mr. O'Boyle said there is no positive drainage, the drainage system installed is hooked into the drainage of Hidden Harbour Estates, and he said there is a declaration of record prohibiting any modification without agreement of the property owners. He expressed concern for the new homeowners who may later find out they have no rights, and he said, after what Mr. Elmore and Mr. Himmelrich experienced, he does not believe there is positive drainage and they should take a closer look. Mr. O'Boyle said the ARPB is obligated to protect homeowners and he asked if anyone present could show they have positive drainage. Mr. O'Boyle mentioned three large signs on the property between his home and the property previously owned by Mr. Wheeler property that were erected by the Developer and are prohibited. Chairman Morgan said the issue of signs should be brought to the Town Manager. He said the point raised with regard to drainage is legitimate and it should be brought before the Town Commission. Mr. Randolph said it is relevant to the ARPB that the first 1" of rainfall is retained on the property because it deals with individual lots, and he said Mr. Pike may want to address that. Mr. Pike introduced himself and said that legal positive outfall and outside retention meet the requirements of the City of Delray Beach, South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), the Town of Gulf Stream's Engineering Consultant and two independent drainage engineers hired by the neighbors. He said there is a series of on-site collection inlets and two positive outfall pipes to the Intracoastal, which is State water. Mr. Pike said Hidden Harbour has a drainage easement, but they tied directly into the waters of the State. He said they are working on a maintenance and inspection schedule and have covered everything required by law and then some. Mr. Himmelrich introduced himself and stated that he did tell Mr. Laudani the system is working, but he said his concern is whether it will continue to work. He said there is an agreement between the neighbors and the Developer and he is concerned about the Developer honoring the agreement with regard to drainage, landscaping or any other issue. Mr. Himmelrich said he discussed this with the Town Manager and the general response is that it is not a matter of the Town, but rather a civil matter. He said he would like to go on record saying that if the Town approves any changes in the buffer it would specifically contradict the agreement the neighbors have with the Developer because the buffer is outlined with measurements. Mr. Himmelrich said he disagrees with Mr. Pike in that the drainage they installed was not set forth to the neighbors prior to installation. He said they are satisfied the system is currently working, but it was not approved as it was supposed to have been done according to the agreement. He said it may be seen as a civil matter and not a matter of the ARPB or the Commission, but it is important to know that the agreement between the neighbors and the Developer is in place. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 6 Tom Laudani introduced himself and said he would like to address Mr. Himmelrich's comments. He said his attorneys supplied Mr. Elmore's and Mr. Himmelrich's attorney with a draft of the drainage agreement for maintenance two weeks ago. He said he signed a private maintenance agreement with Centerline Utilities for semi-annual maintenance of the system due to concerns of drains clogging with leaves, etc., and he said he will continue to work with Mr. Himmelrich and Mr. Elmore to satisfy their concerns of drainage system maintenance. In addition, Mr. Laudani said the signs that are in place were approved by the Town in terms of location prior to their installation. Chairman Morgan suggested moving on with the architectural review of Lot 4, and he said the next point in the application is the Town's requirement of planting Australian Pines. Mr. Thrasher asked that the Board take action on the Level III at this point due to some concerns regarding the clear zone. To clarify, Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Thrasher if he is suggesting all matters relating to the clear zone come at the end of the Agenda and that the Board vote on the Level III first. Mr. Thrasher confirmed that. Chairman Morgan said the Level III relates strictly to the architectural plan before the Board and the immediate landscaping of the structure. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Bermuda Style dwelling, a 3 -car garage with a bonus room, a total of 8,603 SF, and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. The roof shall be white (through and through) un -textured, uncoated flat cement tile. 3. Any minor modification in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 4. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 5. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 3. An application, deferred from Public Hearing of September 27, 2012, submitted by Seaside Builders as agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, owners of property located at 1230 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 6, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two, being a re -plat of Lots 4, 5 & 6, Golf Course Addition, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BLVD. OVERLAY PRMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics providing for a 13' clear zone from the edge of roadway and extensive planting of native species and installation of a Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 7 6'high aluminum rail fence 12' west of the east property line that will be screened with landscape material. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of an 8,857 square foot Colonial West Indies style partial two-story, single family dwelling, attached 2 car garage with 6' high walls and fences screened with landscape material around the property, and a swimming pool. Ms. Calhoun said their Architect will present the architectural features of this home and reminded the Board that all non -related issues should be considered, but that the focus remains on what is before them. She requested time to re -address the Board at the conclusion of this presentation to respond to any questions or comments. Mr. Jones said this particular home is under contract, and he described the proposed structure as a long and narrow Colonial West Indies Style, changing mass from one-story to two-story with a garage connected by a loggia and a carriage house above. He said they contacted Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios and Mr. Minor corresponded by letter with his interpretation of the Code regarding two-story mass. Mr. Jones said the Code provides options to address second -story mass, one of which allows the applicant to propose an alternative in the event the other options are not consistent with the architectural style. He said they are proposing an alternative that is consistent with the Colonial West Indies style. Mr. Jones explained that the second story will be a different color and will have a clapboard -look siding, and the roof will be a gray flat slate -look tile with mitered ridges. Mr. Jones said at the last meeting Vice -Chairman Jones commented on the half-moon window and felt it was not consistent with the architectural style, and he said they are now proposing an alternative half-moon window with a flatter arch. Mr. Jones summarized the landscape overlay saying they presented the existing 15' no -cut zone landscaping with the proposed additional landscaping. He said you will barely see the home on the north elevation, the south elevation is internal to the community and you will see a mix of landscape and architecture, and the east and west elevations are the same. Chairman Morgan said the wall along the north elevation appears to be uneven. Mr. Bodker said it is existing vegetation which is up to 18 feet high, and he said there is a gap where the drainage Swale to the catch basin goes through where they are proposing new trees of about 20 feet high to plank the Swale and to block the house. Mr. Lyons asked if the gap along the north elevation will be closed. Mr. Bodker said there is an easement there, but he said the proposed additional plantings will eventually close the gap. Chairman Morgan asked if the Board Members had questions or comments. Vice -Chairman Jones said she likes the flatter -arched design of the half-moon window. Mr. Lyons expressed concern about possible loss of existing vegetation and vegetation put in place to screen architecture in both the buffer zone and throughout individual lots. He said he would like to have something put in place to enforce replacement to Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 8 maintain the approved landscape plan. Mr. Himmelrich stated that he lives very close to the property and expressed similar concerns with regard to open spaces and gaps in the landscaping. Mr. Laudani and Mr. Bodker assured the Board and Mr. Himmelrich that there will be sufficient landscaping for screening and it will be maintained in the future. Mrs. Morgan requested that the ARPB make a specific recommendation to the Commission concerning maintenance of the buffer around the entire development. During this discussion concerning the protection and maintenance of existing and new vegetation both in the buffer area and throughout the property, it was suggested that a landscape agreement could be put in place or deed restrictions applied to individual lots. Mr. Randolph said he would work with the Applicant's attorney, Mark Grant, to put documentation together. Mr. Murphy moved to recommend approval of Level 222 Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two-story single family 8,857 SF Colonial West Indies style dwelling, attached 2 -car garage, with 6' walls and fences, screened with landscape material around the property and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. Replace the two half-moon windows as shown on the north and south elevations with the proposed alternative design as presented. 2. The electric service lines shall be buried; 3. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping; 4. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached; 5. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view; and, 6. A recommendation to the Town Commission to set a condition through documents and provisions that the landscaping in the buffer areas as prescribed in the landscape plan is maintained. Mr. Randolph asked the Board if they are satisfied with the landscape plan as presented and that it provides the necessary buffer. Chairman Morgan and Mr. Thrasher said they are not satisfied. Chairman Morgan suggested including a recommendation of a deed restriction to the lots, to be incorporated in both the homeowners' association agreement and also in the individual property deeds, that the buffer property as defined in the landscape plan be maintained at the homeowners expense, that the lot foliage abounding each individual lot be maintained at that individual homeowners expense, and that it be subject to approval and supervision by the Town. Ms. Calhoun asked if the recommendation could be for appropriate documentation determined by Attorneys Randolph and Grant as opposed to a deed restriction. Mr. Randolph asked the Board if they are saying they approve the landscaping and want it to be maintained in the future and, if so, is the Board satisfied that the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board — October 25, 2012 Page 9 landscaping as shown does create a screen along the road to the abutting properties. Chairman Morgan said he does not see that on the plan, but he said there is a representation that it will create the buffer and he will accept the representation and turn it over to the Town to enforce it. Mr. Randolph explained that the deed restriction would apply to the properties themselves and provide a restriction so that the purchaser would be aware of their obligation to maintain a site screen along the boundary of their property in perpetuity. Chairman Morgan said this recommendation to the Commission should apply to all the properties and all applicable landscaping and buffer zonings, not just Lot 6, and it would be the entire responsibility of the homeowners' association. Mr. Murphy asked if the ARPB could make a recommendation that the condition to maintain the landscaping is by way of documents and provisions to be determined in discussion between Attorneys Randolph and Grant. Mr. Randolph said it requires a strong recommendation to the Commission saying that their approval is subject to there being binding provisions in place that will assure the buffer will be maintained into the future. Mr. Himmelrich commented that the site screen language is important because they have already agreed to the buffer, but he said it is important that they agree to maintain what the Board is approving from the drawings, which is a full screening of 800 of the structure. Chairman Morgan asked how they could make the recommendation apply to all of the lots, since two of the lots have already been approved without it. Mr. Randolph said he would discuss the matter with Mr. Grant. Mr. Murphy amended Condition 6 to read as follows: 6. A recommendation to the Commission to set a condition by way of binding documents and provisions that the prescribed landscaping in the landscape plan be maintained in a way to be determined through Attorney Grant and the Town Attorney. Mr. Randolph said he would recommend adding the Applicant's promise that there will be a site screen of hedging or plantings that would fully screen the property. Mr. Murphy added Condition 7, as follows: 7. The site screen as detailed in the plans which were presented to the ARPB will be provided by the Developer to the best of his ability. Mr. Lyons seconded the motion. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. Chairman Morgan asked for a motion to incorporate the conditions made on Lot 6 to all of the lots in the subdivision. Mr. Delafield moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend to the Commission that the conditions imposed on Lot 6 in terms of site screening and illustrations of the landscaping will be consistent with all of the lots in the subdivision, including Lot 3, which has already been approved by the Commission, and Lot 4, of which the ARPB has recommended approval to the Commission, by way of binding documentation and restrictions imposed by the Town Commission. Mr. Randolph said the Board can make this recommendation to the Commission, but he said he does not know how enforceable it will be based on the fact that there Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 10 has already been an approval by the Commission of one of the lots. Chairman Morgan said it would be an advisory to the Commission. Mr. Randolph stated that he will be working with Mr. Grant to come up with a provision that holds the homeowners' association responsible for maintaining the buffer. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. Chairman Morgan asked Attorney Tom Murphy to make his presentation to the Board. Mr. Murphy introduced himself and stated that he represents Audrey Schwartz who resides at 3265 N. Ocean Blvd. He said Mrs. Schwartz is looking forward to meeting her new neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. Gillman, who have purchased the property at 3333 N. Ocean Blvd. Mr. Murphy said Mrs. Schwartz has no objection to the proposed improvements on the Gillman property; however, he said it is important to her that her trees are protected during construction. He said Mrs. Schwartz would like to have her representative present when they begin removing trees and she is requesting a 30 -day notice of commencement of construction. Mr. Peterson of Peterson Design Professionals, who is the landscape architect for 3333 N. Ocean Blvd., stated that he would be happy to provide Mrs. Schwartz with 30 days notice. Chairman Morgan called for a short break at 10:15 A.M. The Public Hearing continued at 10:25 A.M. Chairman Morgan recused from this portion of the hearing because Mrs. Morgan would be making a presentation to the Board with regard to the existing canopy and buffer area of the subdivision. He turned the meeting over to Vice -Chairman Jones. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Thrasher to give his presentation before discussion. 1. An application, deferred from Public Hearing held September 27, 2012, that was submitted by Seaside Builders LLC, as agent for Harbor View Estates, LLC owners of property located at 1224 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat II, Replat of Golf Course Addn. Lts 4, 5 & N 92' of Lt 6, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to allow removal of existing nuisance exotics and some native trees providing for a 13' clear zone from edge of roadway. There was no application for a Level 3 Architectural Site Plan Review at this time, only consideration of the clear zone. Town Manager Thrasher explained that the Florida Department of Transportation right-of-way west of the pavement on A1A is included as a part of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District and as such he would like to address this area in relation to all three lots, numbers 4, 5 and 6. Mr. Thrasher displayed a survey of the entire plat and one of just the area along A1A and pointed out that the proposed 13' from the edge of pavement was shaded in red pencil. He further called attention to the fact that the west line of the 13' is almost the same as the easterly property line of the three lots. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 11 Mr. Thrasher advised that he had asked the developer if he would be willing to clear this area of existing plant material, some of which is nuisance exotic growth, sod and install irrigation in the 13'so the Town could plant Australian Pine trees in this area. He explained that the Town had been successful in having the State declare A1A a historic and scenic highway because of the Pine canopy and a Special Act of the State Legislature had given Gulf Stream the authority to restore and extend the canopy along both sides of A1A on the right-of-way, provided they were planted beyond the clear zone. Mr. Thrasher stated that the Town has planted over 90 additional trees since the Special Acts were enacted. He pointed out that the clearing would not encroach into the landscape buffer area that the developer had provided on the private property. Lisa Morgan, the property owner south of the development, made a presentation with regard to the importance of the preservation of the natural hammock and canopy along A1A, the existing vegetation at the entrance of the subdivision and the buffer area. She said she has lived in Gulf Stream since 1996 and she supports the Australian Pines; however, she said not every project can be approved before considering the properties to be affected by removing nuisance and non-native vegetation and planting Australian Pines. Mrs. Morgan provided photos of what exists and was particularly concerned that there is very little existing vegetation to the south of the entrance of the subdivision and in the buffer area. She said taking down any of the native landscaping to make room for the Australian Pines would be a mistake. Mrs. Morgan said if it is possible to maintain the 15' buffer and plant Australian Pines in front of it, she would be all for it. She said she would hope that the ARPB would recommend to the Commission that this is not the right location to do this. Mr. Thrasher said they are not suggesting the removal of some of the large trees. He said at the request of the Town, the Developer's plan is to mitigate the trees that were native and accidentally removed. He said the DOT requirements were not as strict years ago as they are today and he said we are obligated to the 11' clear zone. Mr. Thrasher said it is true that a lot of the vegetation behind the hammock was removed, but he said there will be new plantings and screenings behind that. He said the Australian Pines do give the Town some protection with regard to the widening of the road, adding bike lanes and/or sidewalks, since they are somewhat protected by the Special Acts. Mr. O'Boyle asked if there was a requirement that none of the foliage along A1A be touched. Mr. Bodker said there is a 10' buffer. Mr. O'Boyle said Mr. Thrasher pointed out that the DOT has control over their property and he asked Mr. Thrasher why the DOT would come in now. Mr. Thrasher said there is nothing preventing them from doing what they want with property in their jurisdiction, but he said he is not implying that they are going to do that now. Several neighbors of the subdivision and Board Members expressed their concern over disturbing the vegetation along A1A in this location. Mr. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 12 Lyons said if the community does not want this he would suggest not recommending approval. Mr. Thrasher said if this is not approved the Developer would move on. Mr. Laudani said he is more than happy to comply with the wishes of the neighbors, the Town and its residents. Clerk Taylor said that it is her understanding that a motion will be required to approve the N. Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit with the exception of the 13' clear zone, due to the fact the Overlay District extends an additional 50' onto the private property. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend approval of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit excluding the 13' clear zone with regard to Lots 4, 5 and 6. Mrs. Morgan asked about a fence 12' in from the property along Hidden Harbour Rd. Clerk Taylor said the Code mandates that any walls or fences in that zoning district facing AlA must be 12 feet back, whereas along the Beachfront District walls and fences can be along the property line, but she said it meets Code. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. Vice Chairman Jones returned the gavel to Chairman Morgan. 4. An application submitted by Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects, as Agent for Doris J. Gillman, the owner of property located at 3333 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Part of Lot 5, Gulf Stream Ocean Tracts, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to remove existing landscape material and driveway, install new driveway and landscaping and construct5 foot perimeter wall with entry gate within the North Ocean Boulevard Corridor. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to relocate/clear existing landscaping material for relocation of driveway, preparation of building site and property beautification. C. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a 9,036 square foot Colonial West Indies style partial 2-stor single family dwelling, 3 car attached garage and a swimming pool. Ben Schrier introduced himself and briefly presented the project proposed for 3333 N. Ocean Blvd. He said the new structure will be 9,036 SF, it is a Colonial West Indies Style home with clapboard style siding, a gray slate tile roof and brown windows. Mr. Schrier asked for consideration of the front entry gate which was originally proposed with an elliptical element in the center and Staff was not happy with that. He said they are proposing an alternative design which is horizontal at the top, but he said that Mr. and Mrs. Gillman would still like the Board to consider the original design. Chairman Morgan asked about shutters. Mr. Schrier said there will be some white Bahama shutters. Chairman Morgan asked about the doorway on Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 13 the balcony above the entrance and asked if there was a purpose for the clumping of windows. Mr. Schrier said it will bring light into the interior. Mr. Lyons asked what the view would be from the street. Mr. Schrier said you would only see the structure as you enter through the driveway, but he said you would not see much from the street. Joe Peterson, the Landscape Architect, said there will be a 6' high privacy wall in front with trees and plantings along the wall, throughout the interior and against the home. He said there will be layers of shrubs in front and along the walkway, hedging along the sides and in the back and Coconut Palms around the pool and deck. Mr. Peterson said the existing Ficus hedge on the north elevation will be removed and replaced with a new Ficus, and he said the existing Sea Grapes will remain with additional plantings around them. Mr. Peterson said that very tall Sea Grapes will be planted along the side property lines for additional screening. He said there are some very overgrown Sea Grapes that will be removed and replaced with much denser Sea Grapes. Mrs. Schwartz mentioned the privacy wall they are proposing along N. Ocean Blvd. and was concerned about the column on her property line. She asked if the wall would meet her column and Mr. Peterson it would be about 4' from her column. Mr. Lyons was concerned with protecting the neighbors to the north and south during demolition and construction and he asked Mr. Peterson if they were going to remove all of their vegetation immediately. Mr. Peterson said they are only removing the cluster of Sea Grapes to the south and the existing Ficus hedge to the north. He said the neighbors to the north have a 6' high screen wall on their property. Mr. Peterson said there may be some period of time when there would be openings. Guy Flora of Mark Timothy Construction stated that he would be responsible for the property during construction. He said the Australian Pines will be removed immediately and they will install a screened privacy fence, and they will put up the privacy wall in the front as soon as possible. Chairman Morgan said Mrs. Schwartz asked for a 30 -day notice before commencement of construction and he asked Mr. Flora if he can do that. Mr. Flora said he can do that. Chairman Morgan asked Mrs. Schwartz if she had any other comments. Mrs. Schwartz said she would like them to do the screening to protect her property and her vegetation. Mr. Flora said they would install a chain link fence with a green shade for protection. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Thrasher for Staff's analysis of the roof tile. Mr. Thrasher said it is consistent with the architectural style. Clerk Taylor noted that the neighbor to the north was by Town Hall to look at the plans and there were no objections. Mr. Lyons moved and Vice -Chairman Jones seconded to recommend approval of each of the following: Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board - October 25, 2012 Page 14 North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to allow the removal of existing landscape material and driveway, install new driveway and landscaping and construct a 5 foot perimeter wall with entry gate within the North Ocean Boulevard Corridor. Land Clearing Permit to relocate/ clear existing landscaping material for relocation of driveway, preparation of building site and property beautification. Demolition Permit to remove existing structures. Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed construction of a 9,036 SF Colonial West Indies Style partial 20story single family dwelling, 3 -car attached garage and a swimming pool meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards, with the following conditions: 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. Any minor modification in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 3. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 4. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. 5. The landscape plan will protect existing Australian pine trees and provide a 13' clear zone where possible allowing for the planting by the Town of two Australian pine trees on the north of the existing driveway entrance and up to eight on the north side of the existing driveway. 6. Change the proposed gate design to the alternate gate design that is less ornate. The agent has shown several gates along SR A1A, several of which are fronting homes classified with Mediterranean style architecture. 7. The property owner will give the neighbor to the south 30 days notice prior to commencement of construction. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. VII. Items by Staff. There were no items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Board Members IX. Public. There were no items by the Public. X. Adjournment. Chairman Morgan adjourned the meeting at 11:45 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-06 Owner: Gulf Stream School Address: 3600 GS Road Agent: Rene Tercilla, Tercilla Courtemanche Arch. Proposed Improvement: To replace and enlarge the first floor pavilion and add three second floor classrooms. Approvals Requested: Variances (1): To allow an increase in total floor area that will exceed the 61,737 SF allowed in the existing Developer's Agreement by 1,617 SF. Variance (2): To permit an increase of 1,765 SF over the 6,000 SF permitted for the second floor area in the existing Developer's Agreement. Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan: To replace and enlarge the first floor pavilion and add three second floor classrooms, an interior corridor and an exterior covered walkway and stairs, a total of 4,875 SF. Gross Lot size: 239,995 S.F. Proposed Total Floor Area: 63,354 SY Zoning District: RS -C (Core) Finished Floor Elevation: Effective Lot Area: 239,995 S.F. Total Allowed: 61,737 SF Proposed Height: 30' maximum 7.97 NGVD existing' Proposed Architectural Style: G.S. Bermuda Adjacent Residences: Bermuda, one-story -adjacent and across the street Issues Considered During Review: 1. Developers agreement restrictions 2. Variance criteria 3. Impacts on surrounding residential areas 4. Impacts on services provided. Recommendation: If the Board finds that the 8 mandatory variance criteria are met and the proposed additions are approved, the following conditions are recommended for the site plan approval (three separate motions to recommend approval or denial are required, one for each of the approvals requested). 1. The student enrollment shall be permanently capped at 250, as limited by the existing developers agreement. A yearly certification of the enrollment shall be provided the Town. 2. No additional after-hours functions shall be held at the School other than those allowed by the existing developers agreement. 3. The private school campus shall not be expanded onto existing single-family lots, as dictated by RS -C and RS -0 zoning district use regulations. 4. A Construction Traffic Management Plan shall be submitted prior to the issuance of a building permit application. This plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Police Chief. 5. The School shall reimburse the Town for all advertising and Town legal fees associated with this application. ARP1312-16 December 27, 2023 Page 2 of 2 6. The school is respectfully requested to dedicate a 9' utility easement across the entire frontage of A1A, to be used exclusively for future under -grounding of power, phone and utility lines. (A long-term Town goal) ARPB Date: December 27, 2012 Action: Variance (1): Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action: Variance (2): Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action: Demolition; Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action: Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review: Recommend approval as requested with with the 6. conditions listed above and a provision added to #5 that the reimbursement for legal fees not exceed $5,000 plus the addition of a condition, number 7, that the conditions and figures set forth in the application and the motions recommending approval shall be incorporated into a Revised Developer's Agreement. (4-0) TC Date: January 11, 2012 Action: Variance (1): Approved as recommended. (5-0) Action: Variance (2): Approved as recommended. (5-0) Action: Demolition: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Action: Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review: Approved as recommended including all conditions recommended by ARPB. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL lru`� s LM -dawn OS GO Stream. Fl ... ...... ....:.:.,,..:.....,.. ,.:,,:...: This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Strea., m Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.I. Project/Owner Name: Gulf Stream School, Inc. (successor in interest to Gulf Stream Schoo oun at�on, nc. I.A.2. Project Address: 3600 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See Exhibit "A". I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) Demolition of a 1 -story pavilion and construction of a new 2 -story pavilion and classroom building. I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: _4,875 square feet Architectural Style: Gulf Stream Bermuda 1.A.6. Check all that apply: Ill Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) M Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses M Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: 7.97 feet NGVD B. Owner Information Type of Foundation: Continuous Spread Footing- s Wildman I.B.I. Owner Address: West PalmdBeach, Floridae33401 , 525 Attention: Gregory Boulevard, E. YounSuite 1600, I.B.2. Owner Phone Nu I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: Rene Tercilla, AIA Tercilla Courtemancl-e Architects, Inc. I.C.2. Agent Address: 2047 Vista Parkway, Suite 100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33411 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 561-478-4457 cell 561-310-9877 Fax 561-478-4102 1.C.4. Agent Signature: `�"" I— Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: C Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 TOWN OF GULF STREAM w _ .APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB Fite # To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/bwner Name: Gulf Stream School, Inc. (successor in interest to Gulf Stream c o0 oun a ion , tic C. 1.A.2. Project Address: 3600 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See Exhibit "A". I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, Including # ofstories, etc. ition of a I -s -tory pavilion and construction of a new 2 -story pavilion and classroom building. I.A.S. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: 4 2 875 square feet Architectural Style: Gulf Stream Bermuda I.A.G. Check all that apply: X) Archltectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ 'North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) )0 Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses M Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: 7.97 feet NGVD Type of Foundation: Continuous Spread Footing B. Owner Information I.B_1. I.B.2. C/O Edwards Wildman Palmer LLP, 525 Okeechobee Boulevard, Suite 9.600, Owner Address: West Palm Beach Florida 33401 Attention: Gregory E. Youn Owner Phone Number I.B.3. Owner Signa C. Agent Inform,'; o„ I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: Rene Tercilla, ATA Tercilla Courtemanct-e Architects, Inc. I.C.2. Agent Address: 2047 Vista Parkway, Suite 100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33411 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number. ) 61-4 8--4457 cell 561-310-9877 Fax 561-478-4102 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC gate: Decision: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? Ocean West III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? )l Yes ❑ No Explain. The new buildin 's design and location on the project property are in with the spirit of the zoning district. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? Iff Yes ❑ No Explain. The new building and project are also compatible with the future planning of the Town of Gulf Stream. III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Ing and egress to the property wilL remain as desi ned with an existin entrance and exit along Gulf Stream Road and -a secondaryentrance exit on SR A -1-A. III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage Catch basin and French drain b. Sanitary Sewer _ Sanitary sewer entral sys ctem) site) c. Potable Water Public d. Irrigation Water Well water and Public e. Electricity FPL f. Telephone AT&T g. Gas N A h. Cable Television Comcast III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) sea improvements meet all criteria in Code Sectinn hh_U1, PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes Lf No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? 1�l Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes EJ No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes IN No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? 1] Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Strea B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit extent? N/A' IV.6.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair v* al relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incomp ' e landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas wi the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.13.4. How is the design consiste ith the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitiEoilll�is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual an quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit MCA. When are the existing structures to be demolished? March/April 2013 IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? Tmmediately following demolition of existing structure. W.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? None - N/A; the structure to be demolished is a 1 -story pavilion. D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit N/A Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to itigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated etative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activiAT and thereafter? IV.D.5. What cement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. N/A -H Ljwl IV -E-2. How is the use designed, located and welfare, and morals will be protected? proposed to be operated so that the public health, ty, IV.E,3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of of be located? El Yes ❑ No her property y in the ghborhoo d where it is to Explain. IV.E•4. How will the use be compatible with adjoining deve is to be located? ment and the character of the District where it IV.E.5. What landscaping and scre g are provided? IV.E.g. Does th se conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be locate 0 Yes 1:1 No F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the are e to be maintained. N/A, all as existing - no change proposed. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts properties. on surrounding V-A; all as existing no chane proposed. IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number Loading Spaces: See provided and their dimensions. below. Standard Parking Spaces: See Small car Parking Spaces: below. See Handicapped Parking SpacesSee belol-7. Driveways/Aisles: below. See below. all as existin - no chane proposed.. Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 Town of Gulf Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? Code Sections 70-50 "Private Schools", Code Division 4 "Non Conforming Uses" (Section 66-131.) and the "Developer's Agreement" (herein, as defined in the Justification Statement attached hereto. IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? Single family residential use. IV.G.3. What is proposed? Addition to an existing (permitted) private school IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? See Rider 6-A. IV.G.S. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? Expansion of a non -conforming use to include additional second story area above the replacement of an existing structure to allow a 2 -story pavilion and classroom buiicling, ali wit.m the a owance agreed se_ ac s. (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes M (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes M Explain: We are an existing private education institution an(A present an allowed non -conforming use un er the Zoning Code ot Urdin�:::::::n'es or eam. (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the Ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? The expansion of the non -conforming use incorporates the development standards set out in the Zoning Code of Ordinances_ The existing criteria ratio requires removal of existing square footage to add new is unreasonable when other development criteria are met in full (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure? XW6 No Explain: This request involves an area previously designated for expansion by agreement and fulfills the most optima an reasona e use o e an.. e increased square footage will not impact any infrastructure needs or use (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? No Explain: The entire 2 -story structure proposed maintains the architectural character and. scale of the site and imposes no impact to neighboring property owners. Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page February 2002 Rider 6-A The total variances requested are: 1. An increase by 1,617 square feet of total floor area allowed at the property, per the Developer's Agreement (as defined in the Justification Statement attached hereto) and taking into consideration the area of the corresponding structures to be demolished — to wit: a. The existing total floor area is 60,160 square feet; b. The allowed total floor area is 61,737 square feet; and c. The requested total floor area (inclusive of the proposed project) is 63,354 square feet. The entirety of the increased total floor area requested by this application is located within Envelope 1(A)(as defined in the Developer's Agreement). 2. An increase by 1,765 square feet of second floor area allowed at the property, per the existing Developer's Agreement and taking into consideration the area of the corresponding structures to be demolished — to wit: a. The existing second floor area is 5,742 square feet; b. The allowed second floor area is 6,000 square feet; and c. The requested second floor area (inclusive of the proposed project) is 7,765 square feet. The entirety of the increased second floor area requested by this application is located within Envelope 1(A). ANI 17603099.1 Rider 6-A The total variances requested are: 1. An increase by 1,617 square feet of total floor area allowed at the property, per the Developer's Agreement (as defined in the Justification Statement attached hereto) and taking into consideration the area of the corresponding structures to be demolished — to wit: a. The existing total floor area is 60,160 square feet; b. The allowed total floor area is 61,737 square feet; and c. The requested total floor area (inclusive of the proposed project) is 63,354 square feet. The entirety of the increased total floor area requested by this application is located within Envelope 1(A)(as defined in the Developer's Agreement). 2. An increase by 1,765 square feet of second floor area allowed at the property, per the existing Developer's Agreement and taking into consideration the area of the corresponding structures to be demolished — to wit: a. The existing second floor area is 5,742 square feet; b. The allowed second floor area is 6,000 square feet; and c. The requested second floor area (inclusive of the proposed project) is 7,765 square feet. The entirety of the increased second floor area requested by this application is located within Envelope 1(A). AM 17603099.1 Liulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning N/A IV.H,2. If the project involves a rezoning, Comprehensive Plan text chan Zoning Code text change, Fu justification for the request. g ' °r any combination therec AoMnd Use Map change, se describe the need and PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on the other materials submitted with the application. this form or on any of ification Statement. Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 i fi�ti _ ��EM M DEDELOPER'S AGREffiEgT This Developer's Agreement is entered into as of tUs L:E4 g of c�rrx-e_ , 1994 by and between THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, Hereinafter referred to as ".Town" and THE GULF STREAM SCHOOL FOUNDATION, INC., a Florida not -far -profit corporation, hereinafter referred to as "School". WHEREAS, the Gulf Stream School located at 3600 Gulf Stream rl- Ln Road, Gulf Stream, Florida is situated on a parcel of real property N(the "Premises") of approximately 5.51 acres and legally described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto, and 0 WHEREAS, the School has requested that the Town approve the construction on the Premises of a multipurpose fieldhouse and a C14,4 covered wa.Ucwayt the renovation of the existing auditorium •and the 0 w demolition of the existing maintenance building in -order to better a 'c provide for the needs of the students of the School, and Z U M W WHEREAS, the Town has approved two variances to the School in al LZ M connection with said construction, specifically, a variance with respect to adding a building that does not replace an existing structure and a variance with respect to the front yard setback, mm w and -p M WHEREAS, the Town has granted other approvals to the School as follows: a) a Demolition Permit to demolish an existing " maintenance and storage building, b) a vegetation Disturbance L•0 r Permit to add a row of trees and shrubs along State Road A -1 -A and 44, c) a Site Plan Approval, and o `�' rs x L) ,� WHEREAS, this Agreement and Drawings attached hereto as M Exhibits are a condition of the above -referenced approvals of the Z c o Town D 0p" NOW, THEREFORE is consideration of the ntained herein and for other good and valuable consideration, e heoreceipt 0 of which is hereby acknowledged by each party to the other, and for other good and valuable consideration, the a follows .parties agree as 1. Use of the Premises. The parties agree that the present u use of the Premi ses i.s a nonconforming use ander the Town's present zoning code inasmuch as the same is zoned "RS Single-Fami fu Residential District." The partiely 10 s agree that in the event the Premises cease to be used as a school, as defined is Item A. below, fl in the future that the M same shall conform to the zoning classification then in effect for the Premises and that said a Premises shall not be subject to any other term or condition of this Developer's Agreement. A. Use Requirements. The School agrees to use the a Premises as an independent day school in accordance with the a� accreditation regairements of the Florida Council of L) Independent Schools or similar accreditation entity and in a accordance with the terms of this Agreement. B. a H 3 school shape elimited Parties agree that the use of the Premises as a as follows: The .maximum number of students, both seasonal and fv- -time, that may be said school at one time (250) students. shall not exceed two hundred f f p Said students may be enrolled in grade levels Pre -R through 9. The School will generally be open between the hours of 6:00 B.M. and 6:00 P.M. year round. After school activities will generally not be conducted past the hour of Page 1 I! fir &32 I. Existing Vegetation and Tree Relocation Plan and Proposed Landscape Plan (Sheets I and 2, respectively), prepared by A. Grant Thornbrough and Associates, dated March 3, 1994 and last revised March 9, 1994. [Exhibit I]. J. Building Envelope and Building Setback Plan, prepared by Gator Engineering, Inc., dated February 7, 1994, last revised March 10, 1994 and identified as Job Do. 93-145 [Exhibit J]. 3. Site Building Envelooe. Exhibit "J" reflects broken lines around the proposed one (1) story field house, the existing one (1) story chapel and the existing educational facility (Envelope 1). to buildings shall be erected or expanded outside of this Envelope. Site Building Envelope calculations for the existing building footprint area and for the total building footprint area (new construction included) are reflected for Envelope 1 on Exhibit J. In order to eliminate the need for the School to seek a variance from the Town each time construction (in addition to the fieldhouse and auditorium renovations) is desired in Envelope 1, the parties agree that a variance will not be necessary for such construction provided that (i) the Total Building Area in Envelope 1 is not increased by more than 10,000 square feet over that shown on Exhibits B and J, and (ii) for each square foot of Building Area in excess of 400 square feet that is added, the School removes one square foot of either Building ,Area or Covered Walkway and Covered Open Structure Area. The parties agree that the only variances from which School is being given relief pursuant to this Agreement are those variances concerning: a) setback or locational requirements, b) the size of structures, and c) the expansion of a nonconforming use or the addition of a building which does not replace or substitute an existing structure. Moreover, the School must comply with the architectural and site plan review processes and other requirements of the Town prevailing at the time of the expansion proposal.• Additionally, Envelope 1 contains an inner envelope, identified as Envelope 1(A), to depict a possible future second story area,. It is agreed that Envelope 1(A) shall not utilize more than 6,000 square feet of the permitted 10,000 square feet for the second story. In the event a second story is added, it shall not be closer to any lot line than one -hundred twenty (120) feet. The parties agree that neither the Fieldhouse and/or auditorium renovations shall be constructed, nor shall any other buildings be erected or expanded within the Envelope, unless all of those site improvements described in Exhibits B through G, inclusive, and Exhibit I ("Site Improvements") of this ,Agreement are completed before or simultaneously with said construction. Provided, however, and notwithstanding anything contained in this Agreement to the contrary, the Town agrees that the School may add up to 400 square feet of the permitted 1.0,000 square feet prior to the .construction of the Site Improvements without the requirement Of one square foot removed per square foot added being enforced. Furthermore, nothing in this Agreement shall preclude the erection of new buildings or additions within the Envelope prior to the construction or completion of the fieldhouse and/or auditorium renovations if the Site Improvements are completed before or simultaneously with said erections or additions. Finally, the parties agree that the Traffic Control Plan described in the G shall not go into effect until the Site Improvements are completed. 4. Miscellaneous Provisions. A. Compliance With Legal Requirements. -The Town has reviewed the construction of the proposed facility and Page 3 9311 r"s 6--Z-Ar- H. •3=:H. Building Permit. The parties agree that the School shall have until January 1, 1998 to apply for a building permit for all those site Improvements shown in Exhibits B - I, inclusive. In the event the School has not filed its application with the Town by that date, then this Agreement shall be of no further force and effect. Provided however, the School may construct the fieldhouse and renovate the auditorium, subject to the terms of this Agreement, if an application is made for a 'building permit by January 1, 2000 to construct the fieldhouse andlor renovate the auditorium, if application for the building permit for the Site Improvements has been sought by January 1, 1998 and said improvements have been completed by January 1, 1999. If the School has not made application by January 1, 2000 for a building permit to construct the fieldhomse and/or renovate the auditorium, then the site plan approval granted by the Town, for the fieldhouse and auditorium shall expire. I. Landscaping Specifications. The School agrees that all existing amd proposed landscaping will be maintained in a condition and size equal to or exceeding the specifications indicated on Exhibit I. J. Use of Houses of the Premises. The one (1) story wood residence adjacent to Oleander Way shall be used as a faculty residence or as an ofkice. The remaining two one (1) story structures shall be used only as residences for faculty, employees and their guests. The School agrees to maintain the residential appearance of these structures. Page 5 I Gulf Stream School, Inc. — 3600 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 Justification Statement for Application for Development Approval This Justification Statement appends to the Application for Development Approval and related materials (collectively and including this Justification Statement, the "Application") filed on November 14, 2012 with the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida (the "Town") by Gulf Stream School, Inc., a Florida corporation not-for-profit ("Applicant"), with respect to the real property located at 3600 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Palm Beach County, Florida 33483, designated as Palm Beach County, Florida Parcel Control Number 20-43-46-03-00-001-0020 and described as set forth on Exhibit "A" attached hereto and made a part hereof as if fully set forth (the "Pro e "). Capitalized terms used herein but not defined shall have the same meaning as set forth in the other relevant portions of the Application. I. General Information regarding the Property & Gulf Stream School The Property encompasses 5.51 acres +/- of land area. Bounded by State Road A -1-A on the east and Gulf Stream Road on the west, the Property is located one (1) block south of Town Hall and within the Town's RS -0 (Residential Single -Family Ocean West) Zoning District. Existing at the Property are one- and two-story buildings and related improvements which comprise Gulf Stream School ("GSS"), a pre -kindergarten through 8th grade private, independent school. The Applicant operates GSS through Joe Zaluski, Head of School, and its 18 -member Board of Trustees. GSS is accredited by the Florida Council on Independent Schools and the Florida Kindergarten Council and is also a member of and affiliated with the National Association of Independent Schools ("NAIS") in Washington, DC. GSS was founded in 19381 and shares a significant history with and within the Town. The GSS Mission Statement reads as follows: Gulf Stream School empowers students to succeed, inspires intellectual curiosity, and celebrates both effort and accomplishment. Tile School is distinguished by a sense of family, small size, and respectfor its heritage. GSS achieves its Mission through the defined values of Academic Vigor, Character3 and Participation4. The GSS curriculum and other offerings prepare and develop students well for further academic pursuits and, generally, as good citizens and caring individuals. From a financial perspective, GSS is operated with a balanced budget and without the existence of any debt — one of only a few private, independent schools in Florida with the ability to approach our business in this manner. Over the last 12 to 15 years an endowment fund has established and grown to a level of nearly two times the GSS annual operating budget (a level recommended by NAIS), with plans for further growth firmly in place. As well significant, non - endowed reserve accounts are actively funded and maintained. As such the GSS Board is 1 GSS will celebrate its 75th Anniversary during the 2013/14 school year. 2 Gulf Stream School actively engages students and faculty in a challenging educational experience that fosters the skills, habits, and passion for lifelong learning. 3 The Gulf Stream School experience develops moral courage, integrity, kindness, empathy, responsibility, courtesy, and respect for different backgrounds, talents, and interests. 4 Gulf Stream School requires its students to participate in every aspect of school life, encouraging them to learn more about themselves and others, while preparing them for purposeful involvement in the local and global communities. AM 17605389.1 C r particularly focused on extending for decades to come the GSS Mission and the offerings and opportunities provided thereby — to our students, families, faculty/administration and community, while sustaining our culture and enhancing the School experience. II. Historic Zoning Considerations relevant to the Property GSS was located on and in operation at the Property well prior to the adoption and enactment of the Town's current Code of Ordinances (the "Code") or its predecessors. The Property is, given its positioning and otherwise pursuant to the Code, located in the Town's RS -0 (Residential Single -Family — Ocean West) District — within which a single-family residential use is mandated. The resulting non -conforming aspects relevant to the Property and its use as a private, independent school were not created or caused by the Applicant and have not been modified by the Applicant. As such the non -conformities associated with the Property and GSS are and continue to be provided grandfathered status under the Code. By virtue of Section 70-50 of the Code, new construction on the Property is restricted. In essence — pursuant to such provision, adding a new structure on the Property requires the removal of a like amount of existing square footage. According to records on file at the Town, GSS has committed to "serve a maximum of 250 students" since 1982. As an immediate point of clarification, this Application does not seek to expand the maximum number of students that may be enrolled at GSS. A small classroom environment and, relatively, a small school family, each as promoted by GSS, are an essential part of its culture and are important to the educational offerings delivered daily. However, GSS did not have anywhere close to maximum enrollment in 1982.5 Clearly the school buildings and facilities located at the Property in 1982 would not, in that world or today's, be of sufficient scale, design or context to appropriately facilitate GSS operations with a student count of anywhere close to maximum enrollment. In order to reasonably provide for the educational offerings necessitated by an increasingly discriminating school family, it was and is inevitable that GSS would need to enhance its physical campus and offerings — as it has done over the last 30 years and as it requests at present. In connection with an application for development of a multi-purpose fieldhouse and other improvements then in consideration and with an aim to alleviate the impact of Section 70-50, Gulf Stream School Foundation, Inc.6 and the Town entered into a Developer's Agreement on June 10, 1994. That agreement was modified by an Amendment to Developer's Agreement entered into by the Applicant and the Town on April 9, 2001; in connection therewith, the Town subsequently approved on or about May 10, 2002 of, inter alfa, construction of a new, larger, 2 -story library and classroom building as replacement for an existing structure. A copy of the Developer's Agreement and the Amendment to Developer's Agreement are collectively referenced herein as the "Developer's Agreement" and, as recorded in the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida are attached hereto as Exhibit °B". Among other established requirements, the Developer's Agreement created a mechanism for future development at the Property. Building Area "Envelope 1" (herein, as defined in the Developer's Agreement) was established and identified as the area at the Property within which additional construction might occur of 1 -story structures in the future. As amended, the 5 Not until recently, i.e., within the last several years, did the number of students attending GSS approach or achieve maximum enrollment. 6 This is the name of the predecessor -in -interest to the Applicant. A name change amendment was filed in 1994; however, no actual change of interest occurred at an organization level. AM 17605389.1 - 2 - C Developer's Agreement allowed 10,000 square feet of new construction within Envelope 1. Building Area "Envelope 1(A)" (herein, as defined in the Developer's Agreement), an inner core area within Envelope 1 and located behind (to the east of) the 1 -story structures along Gulf Stream Road, was established and identified as the area at the Property within which additional construction might in the future occur of 2 -story structures. As amended, the Developer's Agreement allowed 6,000 square feet (of the allowed 10,000 square feet) for new, second floor construction within Envelope 1(A). The new, 2 -story library and classroom building and facilities that were constructed as a result of the 2002 development application and the Town's May 10, 2002 approvals utilized a good portion (though not all) of both (a) the 10,000 square foot total area permitted for new construction, and (b) the 6,000 square foot second floor area permitted for new construction. At present, there remains in place from those respective allowances (y) 1,577 square feet of total area for new construction, and (z) 258 square feet of second floor area for new construction. Finally, the net expansion of the structures at the Property and increase of additional floor area at each prior occurrence — the 1994 approvals and adoption of the Developer's Agreement and the 2001 Amendment to Developer's Agreement and the subsequent 2002 approvals for additional development — were each undertaken pursuant to an Application for Development Approval (for Demolition Permit, Site Plan Review -Level III and Variance Review) in a manner consistent with this Application and approved by the Town upon the same criteria to that relevant hereto. III. The Variances Requested Herein the Applicant presents this Application in request of two (2) new variances, as follows: 1. An increase by 1,617 square feet of total floor area allowed at the Property, per the Developer's Agreement and taking into consideration the area of the corresponding structures to be demolished — to wit: a. The existing total floor area is 60,160 square feet; b. The allowed total floor area is 61,737 square feet; and c. The requested total floor area (inclusive of the proposed project) is 63,354 square feet. The entirety of the increased total floor area requested by this Application is located within Envelope 1(A). 2. An increase by 1,765 square feet of second floor area allowed at the Property, per the existing Developer's Agreement and taking into consideration the second floor area of the corresponding structures to be demolished — to wit: a. The existing second floor area is 5,742 square feet; b. The allowed second floor area is 6,000 square feet; and c. The requested second floor area (inclusive of the proposed project) is 7,765 square feet. The entirety of the increased second floor area requested by this application is located within Envelope 1(A). IV. The Proposed Pavilion/Classroom Building The proposed Pavilion/Classroom Building presents as a new, 2 -story structure containing 4,875 total square feet, 2,201 square feet of which are located on the second floor. It AM 17605389.1 - 3 - will provide critically needed teaching space for the educational offerings provided by GSS and will be used daily for other purposes essential to GSS operations. But for Section 70-50 and the requirements of the Developer's Agreement, the buildings and improvements at the Property, inclusive of the proposed Pavilion/Classroom Building, meet and satisfy all dimensional and other criteria of the Code. The proposed building is attractively designed in the Gulf Stream Bermuda architectural style and in a manner complementary to the adjacent, 2 -story library and classroom building located in the central core of the Property. Further, the proposed structure is designed to seamlessly connect to the existing, 2 -story library and classroom building so as to provide for efficiencies, e.g., established standards regarding access for ingress and egress (generally and to facilitate and comply with handicap access pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act), fire/safety code requirements, etc. The following provides a review of the interior space provided within the proposed building. A. The first floor contains a Pavilion & Multi -Purpose Space, a Serving/Warming Kitchen Area and interior Mechanical/Electrical and Storage Space, to wit: i. The Pavilion & Multi -Purpose Space replaces, slightly enlarges and substantially upgrades the usefulness of the existing 1 -story, outdoor -only Pavilion? located at the Property. Approximately 2/3 of GSS students and faculty eat lunch daily in the Pavilion. As designed, the students and faculty who use the proposed Pavilion daily will be kept from the elements, e.g., extreme temperatures, rain, etc., while the facility may be kept open in nice weather. Further, the proposed Pavilion will be tremendously more functional, facilitating numerous weekly meetings of faculty, students, parents, trustee committees and others, which today take up space elsewhere — mainly the Library, making that space much less functional for its principal use. ii. The Serving/Warming Kitchen Area provides the same function as an existing Kitchen facility, but relocates the existing Kitchen facility from elsewhere at the Property into the area where it will be best utilized. As well, moving the existing Kitchen into the proposed building will enable the existing location to be turned into a small teaching room for a learning specialist — of strategic importance to GSS. As it stands today, GSS is not able to offer the services of a learning specialist to any students as there is simply no space within which for the need to be met. Recruitment of a learning specialist is an essential component to GSS's Strategic Plan (11/2012) and delivery of the physical space within which for this person to work is the essential first step in achievement of that important aim. iii. The interior Mechanical/Electrical and Storage Space serve to enhance the usefulness and function of the new building and relocates existing storage from elsewhere at the Property into the area where it will be best utilized. B. The second floor contains three (3) new Upper School (Grades 5-8) Classrooms, an interior Corridor and an exterior Covered Walkway and Stairs. i. To provide for the educational deliveries expected of a private, independent school, GSS has a real and immediate need for three (3) additional Upper School classrooms. The ' As it stands today, the 1 -story Pavilion has no walls on any sides and is not climatized. During rain storms and on the coolest of days roll -down canvas partitions, which do not provide any relief from the temperature and do not entirely seal out rain, are utilized. AM 17605389.1 - 4 - request is made on the basis of the following — which is intended to be inclusive but which is by no means exhaustive: a. Current utilization of rooms other than for their intended purposes: the Library is used during 22 periods each week for classes or study halls other than Library classes — this does not consider the use of the Library for other weekly needs, e.g., parent coffees, Trustee meetings, etc.; the Computer Lab is used 6 periods each week for classes on subjects other than Computer; and the Science Labs are used during 5 periods each week for classes on subjects other than Science. As well this means that the needed facilities, e.g., library, computer rooms, etc., are often not available should a teacher want to pursue opportunities, e.g., research, cross - curriculum, etc. b. Floating teachers and shared spaces: doubling up of rooms means that teachers have to teach their classes where they can be scheduled. Teachers often "float" from room to room. This negatively impacts planning and the spontaneity of "teachable moments" given that resources are often elsewhere. Moreover, inefficiencies are caused by technology, particulars for which often must be revised from classroom to classroom, causing daily delays and loss of instruction time. Number and size of children relative to the space provided: many of the Upper School classrooms simply don't comfortably fit the number of students within a section — particularly the 8th Grade Sections. Many classrooms won't hold more than 12 students comfortably, making impossible the need to separate students for quizzes and tests, group work undertakings and classroom management. Generally, the overall lack of classroom space creates a further lack of quiet work space — for teachers, for students and for teachers and students. The three (3) Classrooms requested by this Application are the most essential component of the proposed building and project — they are the reason that this Application is made and they present an absolute and essential need for GSS to deliver its educational offerings at the level expected and required. At a Board of Trustees retreat in May 2012 it was determined an immediate and essential undertaking that GSS must design and obtain the necessary approvals for these classrooms and have them constructed and implemented into use. ii. The interior Corridor and an exterior Covered Walkway and Stairs effectively and attractively tie into and utilize the existing buildings and infrastructure. V. Additional Justification for the Variances Requested The special conditions and circumstances associated with the requests herein made is that the Code precludes any expansion of the GSS facilities. Given the non -conforming use associated with the Property there is not, short of the Town's grant of the relief requested, any ability to meet the baseline needs associated with the educational offerings expected and required by GSS. The stated hardship runs with the land and did not result from the actions of the Applicant. Given the use regulations promulgated by the Code, there are no other private schools in Town which would be denied special privilege should the Town approve of the Application. As such, the granting of the relief requested by this Application will not confer any special or unusual privilege on the Applicant. AM 17605389.1 - 5 - Literal interpretation of the Code would deprive the Applicant of sufficient classroom space and space for other purposes essential daily operations — which will inevitably work to the hardship of the Applicant and will negatively impact on the Property. The requested relief is the minimum variance necessary to permit Applicant to the safe and reasonable use, utilization and enjoyment of the Property as a private, independent school. Moreover, allowing the requested relief and permitting the requested construction and implementation of the proposed Pavilion/Classroom Building, as set forth in the Application, are reasonable and in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Code. Approval of the variance requested by the Application will neither be harmful to the area involved or detrimental to the public welfare. VI. Summary For the foregoing reasons and as set forth in the Application, generally, the Applicant requests that the Town provide such necessary demolition, site plan and variance approvals to permit and facilitate the construction of the proposed Pavilion/Classroom Building. AM 17605389.1 - 6 - C Exhibits and Attachments to the Application for Development Approval and this Justification Statement: Exhibits: Exhibit "A" — Legal Description of the Property Exhibit `B" — Photocopy of the Developer's Agreement (June 10, 1994) and the Amendment to Developer's Agreement (April 9, 2001) Attachments: Application Fee — Check in the amount of $2,515.00 Drawing Index — Cover: Site Data Table/General Location Map Boundary Survey C-1: Grading and Drainage Plan G1.1: Site Plan/Site Demo/Landscape Plan A1.1: First Floor Plan A1.2: Second Floor Plan A2.1: Roof Plan A3.1: Exterior Elevations A3.2: Enlarged Elevations A4.1: Existing Photographs (Pavilion)/Renderings For each: 2 full size sets and 15 reduced sets (11 x 17) provided Proof of Ownership — Trustees' Deed dated January 17, 1972 and recorded on February 2, 1972 in Official Records Book 1976, Page 1684 Trustees' Deed dated January 17, 1972 and recorded on February 2, 1972 in Oficial Records Book 1976, Page 1687 Trustees' Deed dated January 17, 1972 and recorded on February 2, 1972 in Official Records Book 1976, Page 1690 Executors Deed dated December 15, 1972 and recorded on December 19, 1972 in Official Records Book 2095, Page 1377 Executors Deed dated January 15, 1973 and recorded on January 16, 1973 in Official Records Book 2107, Page 917 All references to recordation in Official Records Books are held within the Public Records for Palm Beach County, Florida Agent Affidavit Property Owners Affidavit Map of Property Owners located to within 300' & List of Adjacent Property Owners Stamped addressed envelopes with no return address for property owners within 300' AM 17605389.1 { EXHIBIT "B" C� Photocopy of Developer's Agreement dated June 10, 1994 and Amendment to Developer's Agreement dated April 9, 2001, as recorded in the Public Records for Palm Beach County, Florida (See attached) AM 17605389.1 I wn A. I la Y DESCRIPTIOh- A PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION J. TOWNS14P 46 SOUTH RANGE 43 EAST, PALM BEACH COUNTY; FLORIDA, BEING MORE PARTIQXARLY DESCRIBED AS FOL L OWS- BEGIANNG AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF L 0 T 4, AS SHOWN ON THE PLAT OF BERMUDA FEIGHTZ AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 23. PAGE 200, PUBLIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA; TbENCE SOUTHERL Y ALONG THE WESTERL Y RIGHT OF WA Y LINE OF STA TE ROAD DEPARTMENT A -1-A, AS PRESENTLY LAID OUT AAC IN USE. A DISTANCE OF 116.40 FEET, MORE OR LESS. TO THE POINT OF CLIRVA TUBE OF A CURVE; ThENCE SOUTHERL Y, ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE CONCAVE TO THE WEST HAVING A RADIUS OF 5245.51 FEET AND A CENTRAL ANGLE OF 6"01'36" A DISTANCE OF 551.75 FEET, MORE OR LESS: TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE NORTH LINE OF LOT 55. AS SHOWN ON THE PLAT OF GULF STREAM PROPERTIES NO. 2, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 18, PAGE 42, PLELIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA; THENCE WESTERLY ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID LOT 55 AND ITS WESTERLY EXTENSION. A DISTANCE OF 86.30 FEET TO A POINT IN THE CENTERLINE OF PALM WA Y. THENCE SOUTHERLY AL ONG THE SAID CENTERLINE OF PALM WA Y A DISTANCE OF 2.5 FEET TO THE INTERSECTION WITH THE EASTERLY EXTENSION OF THE SOUTH LINE OF LOT 56 OF SAID PLAT OF CULF STREAM PROPERTIES NO. 2; THENCE WESTERL Y AL ONG THE EASTERL Y EXTENSION ANO THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID L 0 T 56, A DISTANCE OF 122.54 FEET, MORE OR LESS, TO THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SAID L O T 56; THENCE NORTHERL Y AL ONG THE WEST LINE OF SAID L 0 T 56 AND ITS NORTHERL Y EXTENSION, A DISTANCE OF 142.95 FEET, MORE OR LESS: TO THE POINT OF INTERSECTION OF THE CENTERLINE OF PANDANUS ROAD; THENCE WESTERLY ALONG SAID CENTERLINE. A DISTANCE OF 142.38 FEET, MORE OR LESS, ,TO THE EASTERL Y RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF GULF STREAM ROAD; ThENCE NORTHERLY ALONG SAID EASTERLY RIGHT OF WAY LINE A DISTANCE OF 7.52 FEET, MORE OR LESS, TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF SAID PLAT OF GULF STREAM PROPERTIES NO. 2. THENCE NORTHERL Y ALONG 5A10 EASTERL Y RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF GULF STREAM ROAD, MAKING AN ANGLE WITH THE NORTH LINE OF SAID PLAT OF GULF STREAM PROPERTIES NO. 2 (AS ICASURED FROM EAST TO NORTH) OF 92'35'00 , A DISTANCE 0 198.12 FEET, ThENCE CONTINUE ALONG THE SAID EASTERLY RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF GULF STREAM ROAD MAKING AN ANGLE WITH THE PRECEDING COURSE OF 180'07'25; AS MEASURED FROM SOUTH TWOUGH EAST TO NORTH, A DISTANCE OF 16&74 FEET; TWNCE CONTINUE NORTHERLY ALONG THE SAID EAST RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF GULF STREAM ROAD MAKING AN ANGLE WITH THE PRECEDING COLi4SE OF 183°11'32 ` AS MEASURED FROM SOUTH THROUGH WEST TO NORTH. A DISTANCE OF 4,393 FEET; THENCE EASTERL Y MAKING AN ANGLE WITH THE PRECEDING COURSE OF 90°0838 ; AS MEASURED FROM SOUTH TO EAST, A DISTANCE OF 128.21 FEET; THENCE NORTHERLY MAKING AN ANGLE WITH THE PRECEDING COURSE OF 90000'00' AS hCASURED FROM WEST TO NORTH, A DISTANCE OF 78.52 FEET; THENCE EASTERLY MAKING AN ANGLE WITH THE PRECEDING COURSE OF 90000'00", AS MEASURED FROM SOUTH TO EAST, A DISTANCE OF 25.01 FEET TO THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE SAID PLA T OF BERMUDA HEIGHTS; THENCE EASTERL Y ALONG ThE SOUTH LINE OF SAID PL A T OF BERMUDA HEIGHTS: A DISTANCE OF .322.0 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING AFOREDESCRIBED. ORB 8311 Fs 637 tw ' Ki (AA��•�" �14��° D/' `y P MIC A'/rr •tZ 1'f' :� y 1 I r• —)� r hL NO pflfl IF ft w �� i V /�. � �( ti /j-% lt-l'�• v � 4 �'!+•• Y iry � ,le r rlt+wV /w/I'TNrr c �r r �1 Q \ N /If'e1rr• I • r ' I'••f` pd1 y� /E!�',�G .' `e � r��`t� ; • i1 v r1 r. r \ ; 2 M c o i of '�' Irl arr' �•. : ^ � � ` � Ir r',� A, M,• IL IT `.1 � � S � 4 fir, • • ' ; � � \ 1 r''' A v 1 1•r• � r dI'R I+rP+o C a� V M/• pp` •A , ; � � . ,• rice A /w"• � � ` ♦ a•. � Z v vrs",M r. A 2� _ 5'L'rfYOl1� !; G�r•Y/•s/• rI//1 a 1 . rf�,.'w--�..'`,r�:''•'' ° _ � � a • L V l ei, rI Ar( I/.13 i t IN 14 Hit f:f1 � 9 1 • Y � .•' t _ � �� ° ` i ke Q ti ? 7r t ; � � 'ftr• °j � � t_ b Ift k ,� \ I: i • 1' � =• 1 I 1' � //�s• � ? � � ft , lit 11 tilt 1 �j,�tt 'i� C[I /3.e• +s/• � � i �j y � I, � � o �w -� l�l�[!Et ii``r!= t� 'lie'�� S Y t ii i Al \ \ ^� ,.•� � I •; �_ �� If 111!L1I �I Il i7 It R7�i!li:l;Pli � + � V"1 } i � a � r ``�'•!1��1'•i��l�i�lifj�i><lc����i�l��� 16 1 a Bit ♦ � ,♦v _ -•)Ic � •A,r ,r.r•' : , �� �� � :, !� I:�itti-'�: j!!!= t = it ' il. 4 I�Z i �'�V � � rii• � (• • I . � I � + ii :�=1lii�l�li?�i4�ll�1ii! �+ ii`I W I I. �\ I i ii i=i t •'i E_ 'iE E��� ail it16 a t�•' l�ji!- �Edtl=. i�=it�i�`I��Iit ,rrr. a • 7 1 R O _ \ V � e ",�f 1.s�•� ; I l i � i � � •! ������ii���il�i����7il�l���iil� .,= 1 S 49' am ram1.9 :ql'' '� �•rrrrr� i I I! i �; I fr »• 2� ,. ^� (?� � .nr..�.B6:?O ..r.• ? A l�ii � tti 0 � \� � W WA vq .41 9 ot %mq 37® A71 OmIO�lIIW1� u mr,I►ma n� maam 9E�EEi U 'HOdBH NOJMOH LCL-9Hddm 002— i �►�11tI `ASIJ1A YZE 1..... 1 = Ll 0•I Y- O I -- I ---J R U. ,8£'Zti l ! N e fl J H ; 7N 13W4= WCaM- 1 nlrO A WILYl 10LLM 60"G 3a UMKM K1MV= IOLLO AM N MM 1 V3.0011I.o11,A3UMM%336%M MaMmoc Nl11d NO111'lOW3p H R IW !l•--�J xxz gt;j ' WO ul 1 1 o' I 0 - II li I! I I N e ; � I •- I I 1 / r I 'r 1 11 f r� r r 1 I I 11 i rl I j � I rl I I , II � r; r ill ' I 1 I / I I 'I II 1-e Q I, � h J 0- a h o tz n 0 O I;' �� r � 11 f—• < I I/7 v I I l W vl I /IlI l J w 0 II O m ;� m O If 0 O W F- J 1 W 11 If/1 Q cn ,! w ww fl ' Z Z A t 11 II r 7 � I I Orr Y �F aa6r dolao-1� •wd3a19 d�no � a 2 I Od0lf Wd3R119 d1nt7 app<. •ONI 'N01 Nn0� 700NO9 Wd3TJ19 d1nO u.0=1 '10 Co 0N09 Wd31i19 d1nO 3H1 O1 SN1O11d OI -WIDOW 3119 40",W :<3 -IMI -1 M3N LILIDaf Odd O a N W O W a � J d Q 0 U (/7 0 U = O QV w O (1 (` N CO j O J f � .oh 0 LL �- W Il IW !l•--�J xxz gt;j ' WO ul 1 1 o' I 0 - II li I! I I N e ; � I •- I I 1 / r I 'r 1 11 f r� r r 1 I I 11 i rl I j � I rl I I , II � r; r ill ' I 1 I / I I 'I II 1-e Q I, � h J 0- a h o tz n 0 O I;' �� r � 11 f—• < I I/7 v I I l W vl I /IlI l J w 0 II O m ;� m O If 0 O W F- J 1 W 11 If/1 Q cn ,! w ww fl ' Z Z A t 11 II r 7 � I I Orr Y �F X, 0 � �r<a s.l¢flela In,ro � Nou Naunw SS7W00 7LL ,LION,. NOLL17P, 1Ii110 ANV b Q,3S m� 4A04-9EL JO /1'°ly � •01.otw P 7 1a Ol . ION 3tl11 dill N VMKM DNQC , L0�6 � m' was 9E�£E U •HOV8H Noa& oa "au H.Lf1rI); OOZ p ssNis r,,,,, Nb -1d 3Ob Nlb1WC3 n Msls �. volaold •wv3ais ylnp q 3 � �� %1.%�-�'/� j T11 AT r� avow wvaais y�no oovc C � u z 1 ll ,j �(1 I..Jl rj 1� •SNI •NOI1V ONnOd 100M03 Wd Z W � pais ylno ao y d •j�•/% �/T Vf�/ 3N011d0o OWW3113 ONV 33nON O0-13l3af Mid 34d L' V. O� V . a 9 % ? 7 Ii N c � _ i � -._� �',d3 i!i � �- ��i•3�' _- as =a- - - dco U g =w LU i -3';N (� y vF. d -a LL LL I 0 J LL z z zo i�cx i 1 W W ,a �� / a a r Wd0 i zo rn cNi i H n ° '8 o vi1?0 W2U� W� y. 4v1=, ° azoaid d dl_ly7q _••il A zz C'i s ,0E I P � 1 1 1 /I Jh r fl 1 j/ �q 1 1 11 11 , � r 0 1 ' � ; 1 m / 1 < / ,d , ro ,1 / 1 , 1 /1 �1 to V, w p z = oQ C) Cl) I— / %W 11 O_ � r Z< �o Q� �3 +� All � E- X O / wLLI ao /1� J irk 1 ¢m / �¢ z(_ / Z 0 as + ' 3 z o 0 /1 Q m z n .o W m Q O O II F 1 F = 3 Q N j ' z U 0 w> w Z Q w Q J F W LLJm...1 U W W j W W V C7 V' J W Ld W O� Z F W m _ a - AWL N Ij / �O z 7- X W W W z z 7 � 0o UQ o O s w J I— Nb -1d 3Ob Nlb1WC3 n Msls �. volaold •wv3ais ylnp q 3 � �� %1.%�-�'/� j T11 AT r� avow wvaais y�no oovc C � u z 1 ll ,j �(1 I..Jl rj 1� •SNI •NOI1V ONnOd 100M03 Wd Z W � pais ylno ao y d •j�•/% �/T Vf�/ 3N011d0o OWW3113 ONV 33nON O0-13l3af Mid 34d L' V. O� V . a 9 % ? 7 Ii N c � _ i � -._� �',d3 i!i � �- ��i•3�' _- as =a- - - dco U g =w LU i -3';N (� y vF. d -a LL LL I 0 J LL z z zo i�cx i 1 W W ,a �� / a a r Wd0 i zo rn cNi i H n ° '8 o vi1?0 W2U� W� y. 4v1=, ° azoaid d dl_ly7q _••il A zz C'i s ,0E I P � 1 1 1 /I Jh r fl 1 j/ �q 1 1 11 11 , � r 0 1 ' � ; 1 m / 1 < / ,d , ro ,1 / 1 , 1 /1 �1 to V, w p z = oQ C) Cl) I— / %W 11 O_ � r Z< �o Q� �3 +� All � E- X O / wLLI ao /1� J irk 1 ¢m / �¢ z(_ / Z 0 as + ' 3 z o 0 /1 Q m z n .o W m Q O O II F 1 F = 3 Q N j ' z U 0 w> w Z Q w Q J F W LLJm...1 U W W j W W V C7 V' J W Ld W O� Z F W m _ a - AWL N Ij / �O z 7- X W W W z z 7 � 0o UQ o O s w J N N a- rl 6VUd.—HE[, k4U'7J 96'F66 U 'HOYaH NOJMOH '*aH H,Lf M 009 'ONIr `ELYD.TA LILYE D1VJrYL7LY1\II ;)1TLY aOLL VD 'mom '�m�'la UL IibM m L11LL11'3 mMua a�lblla Y AALw3daud -MKIM A 11Ni nnxLSN ww lr " /' I 1 T_m fr � w x7IO�IIJN N W _ � 171 7� llb lnB,ll L bYtJa� Al IMA 1Ta7t t ulm "Mm Mm I �a va1ao-1d wvaals d7 0 a Ln�j ' aVOa YVvga1B d1Plp 6 L N N a- rl 6VUd.—HE[, k4U'7J 96'F66 U 'HOYaH NOJMOH '*aH H,Lf M 009 'ONIr `ELYD.TA LILYE D1VJrYL7LY1\II ;)1TLY aOLL VD 'mom '�m�'la UL IibM m L11LL11'3 mMua a�lblla Y AALw3daud -MKIM A 11Ni nnxLSN ww Nt , /' I 1 cro � w :a... N �UIIL aog �a va1ao-1d wvaals d7 0 a Ln�j ' aVOa YVvga1B d1Plp 6 L ODBC 'ONI 'N011VONflOd-IOOMOB j; d ma N N a- rl 6VUd.—HE[, k4U'7J 96'F66 U 'HOYaH NOJMOH '*aH H,Lf M 009 'ONIr `ELYD.TA LILYE D1VJrYL7LY1\II ;)1TLY aOLL VD 'mom '�m�'la UL IibM m L11LL11'3 mMua a�lblla Y AALw3daud -MKIM A 11Ni nnxLSN ww r , /' I 1 � w NV1d 70 i11N00 Oldddldl �UIIL aog �a va1ao-1d wvaals d7 0 a Ln�j ' aVOa YVvga1B d1Plp 6 L ODBC 'ONI 'N011VONflOd-IOOMOB j; d ma WV3a1B d1f'O aOd 1 I1 100MOB WVHa1B d1 r. 7Ny O1 BNOI1V OIdlOOw 7118 ONV 7BflON C1BId M3N lei o III I ' 1, I J' 1 7 1 , O W It r- Q O U III CIO cn °_ o �T Q LO U W = Oa- F 1 O U7 IN O Q iit IW 11 �� 11 O I< I -� N 0 J �i ' O w I IL -- I 0 c�Z _ �I f� !, i I I a I I 68 d ; In in 1- m a_ o q w U U Z W in a f � o a eelip IAlalA in 9 N It J ` � 5F� O 99 0 1 I ,1 /;f r , /' I 1 3: '" UU 1 A 1 f , f / I 1 ' I a Ln�j 1 I 6 L O01- < w v7 �' W r 1 � 1 I1 III. i / , 1 PI I lei �I I III I ' 1, I J' 1 7 1 , 1 1 l; I III °_ o �T cr- U l� 1 O U7 IN O u '" iit IW 11 �� 11 U I -� LL. - �i � ~ 1 I ,1 /;f I8 0 /' I 1 3: '" UU �3e 1 I ,1 ' 0 * ' I / 1 3: '" UU uw>6 a f / a Ln�j 1 I 6 � 1• O01- < w v7 �' W x 1 I1 lei , kkO & 2 § ■! -`- A k� s § Q U)|, f� � o R � ■! . 22U` 0 (A ©o 2 F � a �wk »« � � 2§{w � � , • R \ ul $$ CA � | � � � � ff k M °§ }� � ! . 22U` 0 (A ©o 2 F ■ �wk »« 2§{w , • . )| ul $$ § ■ 6 e z,,. \�!• ~�� ,.sae: ' ': � � ff I I w In 11, go _0'm 'HOi+3H �0()? �" `glw¢a CNIm1oN7 YOIro ,[I KLL10n 57yyp DLL 3W Aft IULLO 41/V NI •�IOOM�1 30 Ol lON T11I UII� 7M1 mYdOG DNO[ A laaoua BEtiEE 'i.� HOLN,kOH "(JU 7,ns 3uv IN,as ,o tarn sN r'M H.9LEF DI Nbf1d NJV913S �Nldllf"19 � � !' ONd 3dOl31�N3 p1V1a11fl FJ CCnn CO{{ N JJVI `ELY0Il'1 �3S' . volao�d •wv3als y�no %%lily%rf L:[11C 14./1 �(Lj ovoa wvaats y�no. oowe "SNI •NOI1d ONflOy IOOHpS yyv3alS TO T ^ 1J•1•/ Ll/J I�JJ zI1nn 700H08 Wy3a lg 31np 3N1 O1 8NOI1d 0131OOW 3115 ONv 33f104,1 t 0.131y M3N -J,Da 'O�Id s CN d W d :<U Oo V)a s k= 0 'j, It 1 a- Q W Q 0 af i - ti [RsN1 �• yy i N yy pp CD LL D fn 11, go rs 0 C �0 L7 ¢ U Z a :w O a o :c ] ]! ! C c 3j in in .q J a U N ;►-A Vluas. i 1 r 119 I 1 1 /\ 1 -A VIA a9v■no* 4:• a. ■ • t 117VIS A& r a 1111 F1111 IMMUNE CICop F ::::. JIC�l1:::� 111,11111gri, _:CIIEC:: mom '1 Sal it 101 :-• t O 1 -'1YH O I1lO'aY= 162ON11117�= I N o t 1a s 41i55f • . a3-nvd."2v 09999 (d o s f ' - s,11Ylsdn `l ;t 59 O9S017(la 1 INNS. �.... .1111 INNS■ uON uIN� 0 11\YT 09doi5 _ �.MF ..s n 'I -1v s o �.MF mffjz�w� ►'I:I EL' vpl co .g G1; ml CCt qq1 fti , 7 1 3- u ER. 602-1, W y { o J Z 7. F�c°1S Md WKS 'Ld 'HOtlaH NOJAKOH "aH H.Lfm OOz `EYDIAUZE 1 DNI LW ENI D C L1 POLL/ V;9 . t I � V � 'd' Y Z 17 tz' M—A 1 Nd1d W31SJ13 NO11(1912i1S1O m� I a Mf L13M3S ilMvllNvs ONb' 2i31dM YL •�V i109/>Q�N kLn IA a=T"U JIM MUATIU �LL 1LL1W - 108 17{1 ital>m 1imulz 1 Q ►'I:I EL' vpl co .g G1; ml CCt qq1 fti , 7 1 3- u ER. 602-1, W y { o J Z 7. F�c°1S Md WKS 'Ld 'HOtlaH NOJAKOH "aH H.Lfm OOz `EYDIAUZE 1 DNI LW ENI D C L1 POLL/ V;9 . t I � V � 'd' Y Z 17 tz' M—A Nd1d W31SJ13 NO11(1912i1S1O � I a 11 �J as -W 'El]V4M CIPWAG INDIG nln M IOLLttY MMM S31JO 3% 111OMA Pmv= %3110 xw N miff Y '40.00 'm7nCMdM 31 OL LOM 31V A7LL 7 4 '00—M 010[mvIQ ,�I I 0 0 i I J- J is c ,Its I CV I' b o 1 N In W ' I i L sliftKe If � . m H L r _ I I Z- o•�z z0E �wJ Qoi JI � 1 � Y LLJ < X ' o i II� Z ' LLJ LL. F CY o O a 1 > ¢ 17 411--. to" Z 06 I O I Io tnlv•o Q Z W �•�•— � z , I� 111 (r)o (n o � ALL ❑ o Z D 003 a 00 � o / r, W 0 z / I Q V -1-M F-w W y1y F O �W >�2 E / 1 I Z 3tt� yy' Wlr� C)0CL X / I I aOCL • � b t � O .\\\ 3 W w CL � LiJ Z W —_—••___ s z z O C3 a- LLI En J Z L uGs6 U Q Ld J J U O Z w O U- Q Z J ¢ Ln Qm LLJ 3: ci 16 o ___ _ CD I I I I I 10 i x'98 J N (� � I I I I Nd1d W31SJ13 NO11(1912i1S1O � t� � � L13M3S ilMvllNvs ONb' 2i31dM kLn �LL 1LL1W Q 1 IL i 1 volaOld •WVSa 19 �1n0 Od0!! WV32l15 d1nO OOOC K C SjC" 'ON/ •NOIlvO Nn Od 100H05 Wv3211S d1flO LOd 1O. 100H03 Wi/3 tl1S d1nO 3H1 01. SNOIly OIy IOOW 3113 ONv 35nOH O131d 111%3N N Y i0aroxa as O 0 LL W 0r�U] N d a Z W W r - J ¢ oo J d a C. �tNF'o �-' Q Wd o Mz ooZo a0 U zQ w°Dox � U p0 I �HLU _ 0 XZ 0 LLJ Z¢ �w00UW Q W W 3 O o M: ZZ JZOJ (.D H ' m� -0��z y o U- t7 LL.i ; E Iw- > FW- J U F- ~ 00 Z x OU .i (7 (9 z U D z w I i�Tc LL t� ,�I I 0 0 i I J- J is c ,Its I CV I' b o 1 N In W ' I i L sliftKe If � . m H L r _ I I Z- o•�z z0E �wJ Qoi JI � 1 � Y LLJ < X ' o i II� Z ' LLJ LL. F CY o O a 1 > ¢ 17 411--. to" Z 06 I O I Io tnlv•o Q Z W �•�•— � z , I� 111 (r)o (n o � ALL ❑ o Z D 003 a 00 � o / r, W 0 z / I Q V -1-M F-w W y1y F O �W >�2 E / 1 I Z 3tt� yy' Wlr� C)0CL X / I I aOCL • � b t � O .\\\ 3 W w CL � LiJ Z W —_—••___ s z z O C3 a- LLI En J Z L uGs6 U Q Ld J J U O Z w O U- Q Z J ¢ Ln Qm LLJ 3: ci 16 o ___ _ CD I I I I I 10 i x'98 J N (� � I I I I 'i inn= III L O1v1 •/ad 1781 m Ni.11 Ig • ICUIM SS3ri00 3ML inowA MOLLv= NiLLOO AIIV N mitt I 'U3XXMV.M 30 OL AOM 31n A31LL 'M ITMM 91a01OM7 AMM3LS 3 L 3W '3]A S1M3M SV S7MAVM 'HOV51H NOJKLOH "CIE H.Lfm OOZ ry Nd1d �NI/�dd '►��II `E,701A ,7E WOlaO1d 'Wd3a1S dlno LL Z ovOa ",Wm'Uls dlno oaac u, m •oN1 'NOI1VONnOd IOOHOS WV3a1S d1flO a0a1 dd li ; 1LJi. LLiL V. LLLiLL 100H09 Wwmw-La din0 3H1 Ol y B 1 TO T ZJ� 9NOI1d O1d1OOW 3118 ONd 35n OH -13 . LNl lJ/./ V=i��r.o�a a tltls I N a s 0O W d d co U o = w Q �t Q O N y N U' IL LL ggpp J J 23 j O C7 C7 a I LL LL Ave 0 rl = Cal / W Q' a a IL / J II r � I^ I I a , I I -� I I 0 N � rl A .A W1 FRI W '.Jg l 0 r� I • LtOL-9£4 (LO -P 9M£ U 'HOVaH NOMU09 "Qzi HJd Mi 00 `�1�I�LhT1�1�II�11� l , �. tyaL Vf I _*@ IMrj= e�la 7016 a @MVM NIu7r »Ystl 3a uou>• MILL l H71aa xM N cm In •Ita� •a3mcavi 1 3s CLL UN 3w L7LL 7M mwNs '.J�mG so 'MrMAWN a &Il(fvts4F1 5v �vrs N V1d ails � aqa s11L �" m< S 1 volao�d •wv3als d�no � u � 1 s d OV/Oa wv3a1S d�no 0000 •cl"q ANO/1•�•ONIYOy 100"09 wW3l1 LS �-In0 a0i1 y('c1 l00"OS w_M%A .9 d"In0 3"1 OJ. ■ 19N011VC71a100w 3119 ONS/ 3sn 0" 0131 M3N -,L0aroxa s N h '^ i ;}s s Q =S"I W 9� i e3 i b is = " a a i i d li ; = x rQNy w w N�� l.L -rA ydC. H~ 33 LL. e ss <L � � 45 LO*L-K , .ate L. L. 3 3 1 a ' 0 0 Z ' ac • � a a a ` � ' y co M co 0 Id 3g Id 1 I 1 , Q I 0 I 0 0 i 1 v� ar �Ztigd � �` zw'cl OF; Booms � 'ld1 WOU` �� W d tYLU _ �� a 8 aA� .3 is Y + nl � ". s's • 'e 0 R - O �li•� \ b 6 .0c.! T L W W mIL d n IL flog a 1�� m �1 I Elm 1 QU rQ I W U W, Qj II a_ W -_m ,� t �07 Z t, ° I�� Mn—vI o I I U Wmtn x pp I, I U<% U 8 ► 1II , ¢ <20 a U WU..1�1- < I � gall z a fiI n 1 I l O U7 W < I I: ti�j N co U '� 11 �0 intn s til /c''—i a ;1 ck, a ' w c a UO aa'� x o [' _ / z w^ �1^a 1 lit . < Em � A ' ' 1 8 U3 to o01 tr 29 7v Mw3W l / _=_ W I CJ7 c=i CS) p6 3 o kk Ux /— m� o< Cn II; I OILIL 'I I Q aos° o I o, o , Wino4 N I Y N Y � � a O (n a•►1 L / Z pW 3 r ye yyo f � F•- w p' U I Q- =O a Q W 1! i, o2a tL U_ cn QOO c) o J 0 M t0 i to =Nr -Z z r I I I I I 1 06 t fi G t / t. iaWlQJaI :: W lIIWll Lt® 174 3M Era L as►mi 9OM n M' IIZQ 1771 1n77m lm'O I I pad I • LtOL-9£4 (LO -P 9M£ U 'HOVaH NOMU09 "Qzi HJd Mi 00 `�1�I�LhT1�1�II�11� l , �. tyaL Vf I _*@ IMrj= e�la 7016 a @MVM NIu7r »Ystl 3a uou>• MILL l H71aa xM N cm In •Ita� •a3mcavi 1 3s CLL UN 3w L7LL 7M mwNs '.J�mG so 'MrMAWN a &Il(fvts4F1 5v �vrs N V1d ails � aqa s11L �" m< S 1 volao�d •wv3als d�no � u � 1 s d OV/Oa wv3a1S d�no 0000 •cl"q ANO/1•�•ONIYOy 100"09 wW3l1 LS �-In0 a0i1 y('c1 l00"OS w_M%A .9 d"In0 3"1 OJ. ■ 19N011VC71a100w 3119 ONS/ 3sn 0" 0131 M3N -,L0aroxa s N h '^ i ;}s s Q =S"I W 9� i e3 i b is = " a a i i d li ; = x rQNy w w N�� l.L -rA ydC. H~ 33 LL. e ss <L � � 45 LO*L-K , .ate L. L. 3 3 1 a ' 0 0 Z ' ac • � a a a ` � ' y co M co 0 Id 3g Id 1 I 1 , Q I 0 I 0 0 i 1 v� ar �Ztigd � �` zw'cl OF; Booms � 'ld1 WOU` �� W d tYLU _ �� a 8 aA� .3 is Y + nl � ". s's • 'e 0 R - O �li•� \ b 6 .0c.! T L W W mIL d n IL flog a 1�� m �1 I Elm 1 QU rQ I W U W, Qj II a_ W -_m ,� t �07 Z t, ° I�� Mn—vI o I I U Wmtn x pp I, I U<% U 8 ► 1II , ¢ <20 a U WU..1�1- < I � gall z a fiI n 1 I l O U7 W < I I: ti�j N co U '� 11 �0 intn s til /c''—i a ;1 ck, a ' w c a UO aa'� x o [' _ / z w^ �1^a 1 lit . < Em � A ' ' 1 8 U3 to o01 tr 29 7v Mw3W l / _=_ W I CJ7 c=i CS) p6 3 o kk Ux /— m� o< Cn II; I OILIL 'I I Q aos° o I o, o , Wino4 N I Y N Y � � a O (n a•►1 L / Z pW 3 r ye yyo f � F•- w p' U I Q- =O a Q W 1! i, o2a tL U_ cn QOO c) o J 0 M t0 i to =Nr -Z z r I I I I I 1 06 t fi G ��j F .. .. . . " . , JOHN C. R.ANDOLPH, Esquire Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Post Office Box 3475 West Palm Beach, Florida 33402-3475 Fpr-- A01 04:E5ve 01 i4-:3202 ORB 1 a -4 -EM Pa_ $ Si,a 1111111 III 11111 II 1111111111 ill 1111111111 if 10 11Ill1 In AMENDMENT TO DEVELOPER'S AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT is entered into on the date shown below between the TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, and GULF STREAM SCHOOL, INC., hereinafter referred to as "parties," WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, the parties hereto entered into a Developer's Agreement, dated June 10, 1994, and recorded in Official Record Book 8311, Page 630, public records of Palm Beach County, Florida; and WHEREAS, the parties wish to amend said Agreement to provide for the abolishment of the requirement that certain covered walkways be removed when certain construction is performed; and WHEREAS, ii is in the best interests of the children of the Gulf Stream School that said walkways remain in place, despite the new construction that is planned at the School; and WHEREAS, the School agrees to continue to use the Premises as an independent day school in accordance with the accreditation requirements of the Florida Council of Independent Schools or similar accreditation entity and in accordance with the terms of this Agreement; and WHEREAS, the agreement that the maximum number of students, both seasonal and full- time, that may be enrolled in said school at one time shall not exceed two hundred fifty (250) students is affirmed. It is additionally affirmed that the Premises will not be used for any activity other than for School and community events involving the residents of the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida, the students attending the Gulf Stream School, and the families and friends of those students. The remainder of the Developer's Agreement is affirmed, except to the extent of the amendments included herein: and WHEREAS, the Gulf Stream School, in recognition of the extraordinary services provided it by the Town of Gulf Stream, voluntarily agrees to pay to the Town annually on October 1st of each year the sum of Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000.00) as long as said extraordinary services continue to be provided by the Town. This contribution shall be tied to the terms of the Consumer Price Index and shall be subiect to amendment upon approval of the School and the Town Commission. Or I;R-4z5 F RQ 1 SIEZ5 in this Agreement shall preclude the erection of new buildings or additions within the _ Envelope prior to the construction or completion of the fieldhouse and/or auditorium renovations if the Site Improvements are completed before or simultaneously with said erections or additions. Finally, the parties agree that the Traffic Control Plan described in Exhibit G shall not go into effect until the Site Improvements are completed. 3B. The Gulf Stream School, in recognition of the extraordinary services provided it by the Town of Gulf Stream, voluntarily agrees to pay to the Town annually on October 1 st of each year the sum of Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000.001 begjnning October 1, 2001, as long as said extraordinary services continue to be provided by the Town. This contribution shall remain fixed for a period of three years. Beginning October 1, 2004, this contribution shall be tied to the Consumer Price Index and shall be subject to amendment upon approval of the School and the Town Commission. Increases in the annual contribution shall be in proportion to yearly increases in the Consumer Price Index as reported by the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau ofLabor Statistics, "All Items" for "All Urban Consumers." The Base CPI shall be the twelve month average for the calendar year 2004. The Adjusted CPI shall be the twelve month average for the calendar year preceding each annual adjustment. The annual contribution beginning October 1, 2004, and every year thereafter shall be computed under the following formula: "New Contribution" _ $10,000.00 x Adjusted CPI Base CPI" 2. All other provisions of the Developer's Agreement shall remain in full force and effect. 3. The parties agree that this Amendment to Developer's Agreement shall be recorded in the public records ofPalm Beach County, Florida, withinfourteen days of execution by all parties. GO Pg I t5r='7 JGRIJ 4. WILKEN, CLERK Pi -b C9J.."t , FL. STATE OF FLORIDA f— COUNTY OF PALM BEACH The foregoing:", ent was acknowledged before me this day of 2001, by h0—,,1xu of Gulf Stream Schoo c., who is personally know to me or who has produced _ as iden ' cation No Public _�Sl.W- , Joan A Posey X... MY COMMISSION # CC9909 EXPIRES May 21, 2005 MRF.BONDED THRU TROY FAIN INSURANCE INC N:UC'R\13147-01\GS School Amendment Red wpd 1. My Commission expires: 3:\212041.01\plot\COVER.dwg, 11/12/2012 1:32:53 PM, pkorf DDDDDD0 wwwN�7- 0 < m X mmmxwMWOMM Xr-�O0CC5m�Cm O -=�.ZXX Z���ZO0 G)m0r-0rD0D-, �>-nOz ;0>��mZrO—D-<� mmr gxtnzU)D i m< 7 r- m 0 x W 0y� �Dpz<m — r Z m Dm r Dp0 Z �z�0 M C/) 0 0 D U) D m � Z-0 O m oy z o nZ D m� u m z m COi) D z N 0 X E. WODLBRIGHT RD L c➢yiyo C D C 0y ➢➢ y0 yco D m C)P N m mM'mm�n, Z o' z z o z z G Tc) y yD sm oo o m� w X> 80m oo o C) o< m RA om�INm S YZD QD m O0 m� 0, Ao zoo O O D O Z m m T G) O P0 r g T cf) m > NNT Z7 -y-1 � i$ N N N D ,>> T T, - D T z Gf Vf f/. Ln � D T ➢ T D D T T z> D n vX m z D <nzz T ➢ D T w�nz T gz T� ➢ m ps T D T D D T T T D O �! a 0 L•9 7 O F F* �O Z 7� cn0 G rnzr' �O n r w m O �! a 0 L•9 7 O F F* q� E mwa E GedG -iPi, Z ��'� �R � R ry '4-M O Z p N Zb 70 b rLL S 3/ 1 d 3 d 0 cy-/008 L b7d'� R m a m n N CO po �3�l Qg OLy 3� p, I Inl gg 3 `� 1 S d 7 pe4 Z imm v � 2 � � '„ � / )r .°rbr•rE 9r t°) � I ibi �{ �� a I I yp; ° 8J ® I I o4A' boHayr .o. N a bl owlo,- / / / I R I �\ .rr/ .96f ^� O A3ndY1L BZJS.LB < I , A3AMIr BLAS. L'B , oA /a." x .9'rl r sun ^ r lN'b3 yy�I'! .r w n I b 1 J 'M'N '9H H sLa A3AWS b°If.r6 yy, .9xc !V D tr-b •rSasr.rs l J A y d I R ° J/Y (OIC I y p / / s 1) av, .°rr HLMI 'r)YM ~ b3M3�5��15 I ChR 19 / I _.or Ob'02/ SnI bVG 'd J n l / � V � � �— � � � �� � �_ "J. \ ,L'ZC NMo . ZZ •O Y� YIMO SB°II]Ny Na 1\ n In dlo I / l •LlB I SA I ® ° 3 A Y d / / M]YM " .rH M)yM 'JApJ o3A'3Ap,] .sLf_—� ,d.,e n R JM1OJ I� •Bor ° r b31 r�,yj� �YOV ° .f'6(14 �t�HlEl n a DN/07a7B .12Lp15 ! .arl n 8( X15 I Y I .L°z e A� •lar • � Ab .r)YM J°JA° ry M J1Yl] 03b3A°J I WzioJ T � .L Br I m k N I t If I a I e Ir 17 LTLL I I tfDr Y I 1q 4 IIW.ol%Y- .yu r>, I LLl g c+L a a ? \ R Shclr 6'r A .JWJ 4 c la' uJ5 � Or I in r'v I o bye >.oTo : gLL •fYf •S'ZC Q Y a fi \ � L ♦I y B � •rrL y'W J• .f'B ly�ls ` I 3T .r° QL 2HG N 3 A I b a\ (B33jBldYW ON) M J ° b \�oiselJoJ I � / 9 A3AL)S .[o.6o.CBJ .oBrDo 4oB /'+ r3dld fav) I. •A k o `" ..s n .zn `6. OV 107 r- rn —4 .00zzr L/+ .Md J.nd A : � N R"G i� nNyuj� 3XJd 5 ,:l Qil~" O . ; ^ v h I ,�,�- � t 2N F-k� 1 ih 4g'�L^Fn��i�i~gig. {js1 a gg ysIHJl3H F .v 1r W I'I I'�j~~. ,° , bMktlJ 'M5 ~ .91~ P� a' Rxn.'-r a �a -9107 It 1077 HNa^'~Rq� ITi�n i R ^ OF` R Rxi RgG~'<„ Nip;"Nn RRa R~ d,~ :�� N hNR"�"fig=~� R^�>6^^rsN'~ 00' 30bd 'FZVOOG 1 b7d Ni."£ A 3 H d 0 n {N 2/ 3 8 ~ °aRsnPg'~a�R�'���^��5 �; R na~nR CO CO M Z ER Din N ii7 ','L �r'R,R R Ng�ER a eN�R r- rn —4 I I, I II , ' I I �o T� y 1 .>.--, r: ovoasnNVONVd 1) � Ali I I I I ovoa 100 -Hos 3- 0 L---- v Z D O m 0 D r 0 C r D O Z (� o N 00 N \ N m o �Iz zolz FLO CIsrRATTION NO. 556042 MIKE GUINAU NC ENGINEERING, 6021 180th Avenue North LoxohotcEmail: 33470 mikeguinoughpbellsouth.net Phone: 561 —248-5577 Florida C.A. License No. 28574 PAVING, GRADING 8c DRAINAGE GULF STREAM SCHOOL 3600 GULF STREAM ROAD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 33483 a �. No DATE REVISION DESCRIPTION ]:\212041.01\plot\G1.l.dwg, 11/12/2012 1:27:15 PM, pkorf 0 L C G.� L coo 5 Y Z % I M ~' S D o �' BTB CM ® r w CA I M III off` % UI IN m� �F" III'-- — gg . •s� `_' x O :g IIII5 9 41 0 ivy;; p € PP"? �^ ANN --I /i�_ -- 1 r, c w' tz C, ti r �n x G VJ L coo K Z I M ~' D o �' BTB CM ® r w CA I M ivy;; p € PP"? �^ ANN --I /i�_ -- 1 r, c w' tz C, ti r �n -j---- - — _-- — 0 � Uri I N li I 3 C= ra Proposed Addition for: p=�� d Gulf Stream School tercilla cou emanche t.: archilects 9 1,1000311[ 3600 Gulf Stream Road 2017 ,isc, perkway, swlr 100 resl palm brach, Ilolida 33111 ph:.561.-178.11:57 I'm .561.178.1102 Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 x G L K � III III H IHI A€�" oSIIJII �c in t II Iu � II m I CJ "�' LT �c3, III off` % UI IN m� �F" III'-- — gg . •s� `_' x O :g IIII5 9 41 C4 ilB g �iA o� IM, r�— -j---- - — _-- — 0 � Uri I N li I 3 C= ra Proposed Addition for: p=�� d Gulf Stream School tercilla cou emanche t.: archilects 9 1,1000311[ 3600 Gulf Stream Road 2017 ,isc, perkway, swlr 100 resl palm brach, Ilolida 33111 ph:.561.-178.11:57 I'm .561.178.1102 Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 J:\212041.01\Pl0tW.1.dw9, 11/12/2012 1:24:06 PM, pkorf EXISTING BUILDING \\ EXISTING COVERED WALK \\ 38'-8" -->�---- �— -----� ---C\— -- ---I — -- �I--- - I M I I -71 m II cn � II I I O El G � l 25'-6" a I - w I I ! I J --I O A C NO 0 I I X Cn 14'-6" j z G] 0 I I I I a M p O II � Ff O II II -iW---_� � \ I \ II II IIS � I I C= g O Cn -0 I I I I -m 34'-2" I I I I I C-) O a m M O M X Cn 14'-6" j z G] 0 I -----'Qj�----- M p O II � I M . O II II II II II I I\ � \ I \ II II IIS \II I -- I � 1 I I I \ ` G Proposed Addition for: JM, DDDDDDDD Gulf Stream School tercilla cou emanche architects AA 000311-1 3600 Gulf Stream Road 2017 vista parkn:rv, suite 100 o tacst palm beach, 11mida 33111 pb: J61A78.11.i7 1x: 561.178A101 Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 J:\zizogi.oi\piotWi.z.dwg, 11/12/2012 1:25:27 P,, pkorf 0 m y 38'-8" G Proposed Addition for: a>>>>>>DD-r= Gulf Stream School tercilla cou emanche _ architeas � AA 000311 4 ti 3600 Gulf Stream Road 2017 cisl;r, in Way, suite loo t�Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 west pall;' Bead), °o6da 33111 1. 178.11.37 1x::3(;1.178.1102 l:\212041.01\pkk\p2.1.dwg, 11/12/2012 1:25:51 PM, pkorf 3:\212041.01\p1aty\3.1.dwg, 11/12/2012 1:26:20 PM, pkorf C/] 0 0 z Z)L W96-- + PIR gs'aQU T Hvj!° M~' M a 0v 3� o CL a o w o Proposed Addition for: DDDDDDDD a Gulf Stream School 3600 Gulf Stream Road �—' Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 o y m C _ y M W96-- + PIR gs'aQU T Hvj!° M~' M a 0v 3� o CL a o w o Proposed Addition for: DDDDDDDD a Gulf Stream School 3600 Gulf Stream Road �—' Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 1 0 0 ®10�I;• Q Ili_ I � oema 1■ ml emaall �a®� ■'■m•a `�,� � �m�;•off= � ■� ��� mm®m m m , , • �.� m•Im•m Imi ml -- M=M=i oil a a ;�;�►m� 1 0 0 J;\212D4I.OI\pIot\A3.2.dwg, 11/12/2012 1:26:47 PM, pkDrf C> NO 000aoao RZ > M SR S!s rD C, M 4 M i�'PW 9j iRaA kd t1r, 0 )> 0 M M >0 r,�3 C=) n w M Proposed Addition for: Gulf Stream School 3600 Gulf Stream Road Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 OA C) Fs it, -4 terci cou emanche architects AA0003414 2047 vista Ixtrkway, suite 100 %vest palm heach, florida 33-111 11: 561.478.4157 N:561.478.4102 (7) a Er""y NO C -A- C) C) s.. � - '� Iti 'i Proposed Addition for: D ns > > > > > Cco C"' C Gulf Stream Scho,,,. terci u e COU Manche architects ro Tn 3600 Gulf Stream R a 0 C= AA M414 2047 vista parkmay, suite 100 Q-stpaimberach, 11olida 33411 -3 ill Gulf Stream, Florida 33 -.& ph:56t.478.4457 R:561.a4l, on C.^3 CI) r rn TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT January 20, 2011 Application #: 012-18 Amended Owner: OK Seahorse, LLLP Address: 4001 North Ocean Blvd. Agent: James Boyce Proposed Improvement: Construct dune crossover Approvals Requested: Demolition Permit: To demolish existing southernmost dune crossover. Special Exception: To permit construction of a dune crossover east of the Costal Construction Control Line 1978 and 15 feet north of the south property line at the above address. Level III Architectural/Site Plan Zoning District: RM -E, Multiple Family Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks To permit construction of a dune crossover structure seaward of the Coastal Construction Line 1978 and 15 feet north of the south property line at the 4001 North Ocean Blvd. (g) Minor accessory structures east of the Coastal Construction Control Line established in 1978 Recommendations: Motion to Recommend Approval of Demolition Permit. Motion to Recommend Approval of Special Exception to permit construction of a dune crossover east of the Costal Construction Control Line 1978 based on the finding that the dune crossover meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. Motion to Recommend Approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan to permit construction of a dune crossover structure seaward of the Coastal Construction Line 1978 based on the finding the dune crossover meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: December 27, 2012 Action. Demolition: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action. Special Exception: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action. Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Architectural Review anu elanning Board ARPB File #012-18 ARPB December 27, 2012 TC January 11, 2013 Page 2 Town Commission Date: January 11, 2013 Action. Demolition: Approved as requested and recommended. (5-0) Action. Special Exception: Approved as requested and recommended. (5-0) Action. Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as requested and recommended. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream 17Ez, - 3 `n1? TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 1;2 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information LA. 1. Project/Owner Name: f`i. DG E A n1_ lOk LLI-P I.A.2. Project Address: yod t 1.1 ocp NN i&L\111, CULF 57MMAM FL 33483 I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: Sf 6I185-H'r N EJChF t BIT — AFc/}L bE-6C PTic'�*'% I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) (Lr--%UIL'M NoR IA Duac— _C(Z0SS aVM-rL 1 -A# -P AND Jty_Lau4T1= Tit£ r.-f1J'r)WN SouTH pular- CRo55o1(IE1L I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing 0 North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) 0 Demolition of Structures 0 Non-residential uses 0 Variance (complete section G) 0 Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: -r.%p Type of Foundation: NIA B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address: S- t_� t �rtu� Sunt 10#4,�,�;� gctl I.B.2. Owner Phone N b r: S -Q 7- - 5do Fax: 861 - 697-- loses I.13.3. Owner Signatur : C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: 3'gine,S i3o�c� I.C.2. Agent Address: 7pt r,_ r, 1%l w .uv= d... I.C.3. Agent PhoneAumber: joy 1616-1) 6 Sz — I.C.4. Agent Signa Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: l 's4a cell_&Qb 3&6 SI56' Fax i 6gZ _ to5 Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: f* J, g/ _z_r1 42 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification I II.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? PSC — N R -1t CutF STIZgr. Rwt ^51 III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? 5?"'Y'es ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent L�yth the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? 13Yes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided?_�I III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage b. Sanitary Sewer c. Potable Water d. Irrigation Water N D. e. Electricity f. Telephone g. Gas h. Cable Television N III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) Nl PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes Q No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? LST Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an exist!n�g.vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes L9"No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. DDo�s the project require approval of a Special Exception? B Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the proje t at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes M No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.13.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: Ja.K1STItJ/, hk 2Tt4 Dr"41r-- GROSScvrlL Arlo iZ.ELoc4r'L-- V1S7-ir,(& Souri.l >DuWAS c.Rpss0V#E2 IV.13.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.6.4. How is the design consistent with the Al Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:_ iJ 1 k C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit MCA. When are the existing structures to be demolished? 11.1013 IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? I I A 13 IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? SOUTH bUtA -- C-R,DSS 6VF—(Z D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 vuGglll E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV -E,1. Is the proposed use a Permitted special exception use? &,es p No Code Section: -40- IV -E-2. How is the use designed, located and �S�' proposed to be operated so that the Public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? C GLOSS oyrn-a- 0 3r 2EL0CATr (!J AtAb REBU►LT - IV -E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury be located? ❑ Yes eNo ry to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. OMLLe >,.---- - _rrxu 2E$(J1Lb t^k, %}/E I�lo27p{ �uNE ca'osSo�(Lr2. How l the Ll IV.E. s to be I cilated? se be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where it A�f-IC GRoyg ov R2:S �12� �jtISTA�If. _ --------------- IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? No _ HF W.E.B. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing located? Q'Yes ❑ No g the District wherein it is to be Explain. f= .0c'4 %%=b �v�'E- �Rr�SSoVr2 �tLL OFrsr=T 1'ecaUR�r._'_,.... F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units W.F.I. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their Potential n properties. naimpacts or, IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 P LO N �y�'100w ZOy�00 a��n�o Rl 0 cOjan�jan�j � Z � �yti�a o� z r y a�o�n `D O ,A C nOn^1� �!N�°o o Zril o nZ�n-a y � C y J C: \2006\060077\awq\SOS SPEC PURPOSE dl q (S-17 Dec 13, 2007 8: 12am OOAVIE OONNw°iNgUegV�t°„°al°,N�$�div�VaN" 4 N q Ob � V �"i�4�4N--$bv'� N �=l_ 1Nw O°.N waw°:�NNzoz o.iOoOa`w`wV,b24.`v OOOOw_i `s:N `w VN4�u .vVes`w n �iONpaaaaa p^p^^Oai��"2 ^^atts��°yaasi»> • =salla>aia>aD ;-M: R<saaaln maysasiaaiaaaAtiisaaasaiaa$a u�,4misaa2<2Y2Yna>a>NOO�asaiasiii��Naisaaa�iaa�i � ^'�'� s�mccc£°:ascEc£�;nm000sFi£EcccFNN;FscF£££ccc�c -----e- n tl x m m m x tl x N m i i i x tl x u u tl m _ i tl n tl °�a,NMryyyyjOmOaN��n�?USUVaUUNttippi2gNmwAbb;a i O�O mMNN jmayM 2 01 NIOm�RiUOb �i SN Y4NOegU�4N= 0 b Qg5No 4 N Z$$$$ i HORig RV r2`C CCC CC CiC Ci CC �nn iiiiqiiaNNNNNNH"ul "°i ilnN v�1�. NN���NLaLxT ;;c^n^a ii^a ^a "°,��°°Im^=� mmmmim� mm �mm{j� mm iiiYtl2 i4i ±; Ii O�mMa44��bmVaM��V�Mw44-ObmVaNwN.,N �m NCO N-mmmN ties n\o 000m�^$�'�'$�'i'2L2=Sii2iiii2iiiiix�"ti000�vmONN�,000 ^^^ ^^^nmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm$mmm^^L^^^:'^>: L"aii gg�gggggaa�apa�aa��aaa�aa�a��a���aagg;g€aeeeeeeo aaaaaaa'NNNNN NNNNNNNNN � N�NNNawiasiiiiiici np � p oNp 3 0 � N?eo?w�" 3io�xtio.ouua_gU tltl �' y3,q 4'a.° R i ail $"c m Yrl "nx to " n I ^ m _ h m oRxm 9w 3N� mo�.h ?� 3m�•a ^mam boa g.E H mom: gs; ti a, �';ga m"EE�!o am 3R" mm aN 3. ¢ I. RN SSR" C z� graLd Vsm2.N m a 3a g;5$�$$. :' 3 aR �.sa o ¢a wta $o$ p;'p; z 8833Ae a 3 n �gmr3B44a 3 3 a '"£ o�Ek$ � �g •� $� cJ��+ c^�+ g s :R g i" ^to ian RNZ ry'm�� = N= �RRo a t0^03 sad.' a @ 3V7M ,7 ^n°a '� Ria i R xg 3°at uv !�"edym g ^ a A. aZI o �maX�3"� € o A. - mmoR�m R as""ca a a due nye =� 3 g.�a T N m< ME: i]] _ O° n r?v An ' ,ir �$�mr �$ A^ ^� n an'< $ zga €34 o 4ga^dt 33 ^1;�X x e3"" i a S °� udo �n� dPs ��o' n N° a.c a � MRV ,��$e" Eg R t- �� �a° I �N �ci�aail n� £i u,NNZ 3� �..ti a.t Q^4ii$ a,". a_ "3 R� r aka °, "R o` n S a• mr'dm g<N cm:^'i� $4 io 2z°3 n R �. ,v8° } oa 6m n� N g A mag �°' Rmp . Z a� '.a1 �£xn- n �,°i� n <� c m < n �'1'1 r 8onx II c 'Fo �a< i a^gan• ca'£' £�n�la N" an �3 R p �, o.°°. >Im., ° a ♦ o'l n"o $ `o v3 rn i'i Zi' aN '1ti a a" a 3 3 o R ag gryc�,i„°,vm >£• > e �eRau y8 R= s a �° °§ 3� 3 n$ ��p �°'' `r r3 n3a n Ca �c�� m M k 'S �`., �a � .n. &9 8 _$ z N r nos R 8omg2ati a<i" 2' n�', 3`m`si " 8 M Qtm ° MB a ° n� C flv $ P agmy� �o :� £��m p° a.r�iia 5* o t '� s° giN w k oA p� a 33. �'al$' �.°, v 4 3 CID RT LIT SKETCH OF SURVEY CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. oarE: a/Ifi/ofi T O A ENGINEERS • PLANNERS • SURVEYORS 7 UPDATE LOCATIONS k ELEV'S ON AIA DMO 12/12/07 SCALE. 1'=30' ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY `—, 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIOA 333°9 6. ADD UNDERGROUND UTILITIES OMD 10/24/0 I� ``^^ m 5. REVISE LEGAL TO MArCN RILE COM. DMO 6121107 DRAWN BY: EA V/ FAX: (954) 739-fi 109 TEL- (954) 739-6100 t n PREPARED FOR: 1. UPDATE SURVEY REV. CER nnca rE OMO 4/5/07 CHECKED BY: DMD J O 1 RORpA A UCENO D LINEDMNC, SARVE11N0 ! MAPPING S N1. CI N°. 071 p THE JFP GROUP, LLC RaRIOA UCEn5E0 LAx05C/PE ARtw NEC VIRE &151K55 xo. [000111 3. A00 19]9 CCCL LINE OMO 1/11/0] OZ 2. REVISE TO ALTA/ACSM SURVEY ONO 10/34/06 FIELD BOOK: SEE NOTE SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB � •._�•� A� GGGL DATA A BDG TIES EA I°/I6/°° A PAGE(S): SEE NOTE n� DESCRIP TON: BY: I DATE. APPROVED SET JAN 112013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL l�J n �� vt, IaoT gga�a a 00011 p e, m9-�a mge c' � 8 nJJSR o\�;aca8aMoni8°$� >O iN01 ee mmNt.,NN 3ga�e'oo N'\. cT`�B aJ9. C) V­JCm �N04aNm � Nu <appo° ori$ �� N a° r7l V12- s Qg.+v11- � b �g 8z t`' 3vG RRR i�g 3 H mom: gs; ti a, �';ga m"EE�!o am 3R" mm aN 3. ¢ I. RN SSR" C z� graLd Vsm2.N m a 3a g;5$�$$. :' 3 aR �.sa o ¢a wta $o$ p;'p; z 8833Ae a 3 n �gmr3B44a 3 3 a '"£ o�Ek$ � �g •� $� cJ��+ c^�+ g s :R g i" ^to ian RNZ ry'm�� = N= �RRo a t0^03 sad.' a @ 3V7M ,7 ^n°a '� Ria i R xg 3°at uv !�"edym g ^ a A. aZI o �maX�3"� € o A. - mmoR�m R as""ca a a due nye =� 3 g.�a T N m< ME: i]] _ O° n r?v An ' ,ir �$�mr �$ A^ ^� n an'< $ zga €34 o 4ga^dt 33 ^1;�X x e3"" i a S °� udo �n� dPs ��o' n N° a.c a � MRV ,��$e" Eg R t- �� �a° I �N �ci�aail n� £i u,NNZ 3� �..ti a.t Q^4ii$ a,". a_ "3 R� r aka °, "R o` n S a• mr'dm g<N cm:^'i� $4 io 2z°3 n R �. ,v8° } oa 6m n� N g A mag �°' Rmp . Z a� '.a1 �£xn- n �,°i� n <� c m < n �'1'1 r 8onx II c 'Fo �a< i a^gan• ca'£' £�n�la N" an �3 R p �, o.°°. >Im., ° a ♦ o'l n"o $ `o v3 rn i'i Zi' aN '1ti a a" a 3 3 o R ag gryc�,i„°,vm >£• > e �eRau y8 R= s a �° °§ 3� 3 n$ ��p �°'' `r r3 n3a n Ca �c�� m M k 'S �`., �a � .n. &9 8 _$ z N r nos R 8omg2ati a<i" 2' n�', 3`m`si " 8 M Qtm ° MB a ° n� C flv $ P agmy� �o :� £��m p° a.r�iia 5* o t '� s° giN w k oA p� a 33. �'al$' �.°, v 4 3 CID RT LIT SKETCH OF SURVEY CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. oarE: a/Ifi/ofi T O A ENGINEERS • PLANNERS • SURVEYORS 7 UPDATE LOCATIONS k ELEV'S ON AIA DMO 12/12/07 SCALE. 1'=30' ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY `—, 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIOA 333°9 6. ADD UNDERGROUND UTILITIES OMD 10/24/0 I� ``^^ m 5. REVISE LEGAL TO MArCN RILE COM. DMO 6121107 DRAWN BY: EA V/ FAX: (954) 739-fi 109 TEL- (954) 739-6100 t n PREPARED FOR: 1. UPDATE SURVEY REV. CER nnca rE OMO 4/5/07 CHECKED BY: DMD J O 1 RORpA A UCENO D LINEDMNC, SARVE11N0 ! MAPPING S N1. CI N°. 071 p THE JFP GROUP, LLC RaRIOA UCEn5E0 LAx05C/PE ARtw NEC VIRE &151K55 xo. [000111 3. A00 19]9 CCCL LINE OMO 1/11/0] OZ 2. REVISE TO ALTA/ACSM SURVEY ONO 10/34/06 FIELD BOOK: SEE NOTE SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB � •._�•� A� GGGL DATA A BDG TIES EA I°/I6/°° A PAGE(S): SEE NOTE n� DESCRIP TON: BY: I DATE. APPROVED SET JAN 112013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL G.\2006\060077\ewg\SOS SPEC PURPOSE. dwg (S-21 Dec 13. 1007 B: IJam ODA WE I I I I I I I I I I I —Y_ _ NEST BOUNDARY GOVERNMENT LOT 2 is P 'e N F F EX/5liNC R/pl7-OF-WAY�L/NC COUNTY ROAD (20' RK11r-0F-WAY arY uM/r row OF GULF5IREAM (Is 7, PC REPLAT OF BLOCK Z PALM BEACH SHORES (P.B IB PC 19 P.B.CR.) 2209 300' N 01:77'16" E JOpJ1' CALC. z N opo N 01:77'40" E J..J6' C" a N 4� 11 1X1' PRM-! '. O[WN 015E '-� d-75557- A- S`^ Utl EAST LINE REPEAT OF BLOCK Z PALM BEACH SHORES 2 �o� P (P.B. IB. PC 19).,a 7 a -1i ,mss-.-✓- `( S 045916" W 10.41' .f'�i'r�r-r`L\ -� 175 11 1X1' PRM-! '. O[WN 015E '-� d-75557- A- S`^ Utl EAST LINE REPEAT OF BLOCK Z PALM BEACH SHORES 2 �o� P (P.B. IB. PC 19).,a R-1546.64' FNO NAILb ''� !A � A-165.59' W/ LB J9J5 N 'v F O NA& o, 6 cur & SEC J4. THP 455. RNG 4JE -, - �,,,, PALM BEACH SHORE ACRES,}��gA...� r y N N P.B. 7• PG 15 P.B.CR. mRZU mn DDAZ� o Im P m z o Am y•Yo�i O I I s ROAD �n m •�^ N 0651'51' E 127794' �g LSiC�19N 9MMD_2510 Z"1] a s11 61 4 w N m N o 2I . s 0 Z �a R ..'� .. OLD6OCEAN BOULEVARD o' �n m � H — �— _UIQ I I� 'I BELLAMAR HOUS J J N'•ANO 1 #3951 PJ-7BWA �'992AC p OLM BEAOUNr REO BY 'AC OCr 7, I982 I 7 STORY CONC- BLD I ti VSRNC Rm r-LY-wA "' 1J l\•!7 CENiERUNE Utl EAST LINE REPEAT OF BLOCK Z PALM BEACH SHORES 2 �o� P (P.B. IB. PC 19).,a ,� a u � ® GOVERNMENT LOT 2 H a o & SEC J4. THP 455. RNG 4JE -, - �,,,, PALM BEACH SHORE ACRES,}��gA...� v s (OCEAN BL ESTA TES)•..-"""'- q Y N N P.B. 7• PG 15 P.B.CR. mRZU mn DDAZ� 'J4" LFT A:.101 51' CALC. —��,- o-06y6'S7. abs ��� 0= 632' =2546.64' Am y•Yo�i O N 075706' 117117' _� s ROAD 57 �57� 06.46* •�^ SOT 5 We H �g LSiC�19N 9MMD_2510 Z"1] a s11 61 4 w 2219' I 4' NAIL B T B O '41"' (ND W/ LB 3 35 CALL. A 1.21' CFL. A, — O o 4 s 3' NI :,bti hp '���I F4Ti =15.61 G � C y I 4 e MEN !M .. D4-- - -------{ pm I Zj T`�E 1979 COASTAL PER PLAT 707 IS E CENiERUNE I SKETCH OF SURVEY ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY �o� �•+' 4 'a ' O m =a0 _ Or THE 17 1997 L/NE SHO NW OB 0 N ILOROA UCEN9 D EN(N4EENNG, S7RWYNG & MAPPING BUSNIESS No. 211 RORWA UCEN%D LANDSCAPE ARCNHECT &1SNE% Na. COD0114 SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB 0 N � N N O mRZU mn DDAZ� abs ��� n1T Am y•Yo�i O N 075706' 117117' _� � stiRo� •�^ SOT 5 We H � N o 2I . s 0 Z �a R ..'� .. OLD6OCEAN BOULEVARD o' �n DE 1016.26' H I 4' NAIL B T B O '41"' (ND W/ LB 3 35 CALL. A 1.21' CFL. A, — O o 4 s 3' NI :,bti hp '���I F4Ti =15.61 G � C y I 4 e MEN !M .. D4-- - -------{ pm I Zj T`�E 1979 COASTAL PER PLAT 707 IS E m m(p -{ /4� CD CENiERUNE SKETCH OF SURVEY ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. ENGINEERS PLANNERS SURVEYORS `���/// 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 37709 FAX: (954) 739-6409 TEL.: (954) 739-6400 �•+' 4 'a ' ." m IN N _ Or THE 17 1997 L/NE SHO NW OB s a ILOROA UCEN9 D EN(N4EENNG, S7RWYNG & MAPPING BUSNIESS No. 211 RORWA UCEN%D LANDSCAPE ARCNHECT &1SNE% Na. COD0114 SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB 0 N � N N O N, l V 1 N 075706' 117117' f � •�^ SOT 5 We H � N o 2I . s 0 r x rl rl ..'� .. OLD6OCEAN BOULEVARD o' w �o DE 1016.26' — �— _UIQ 4, Y j PER AL/CNMEN MAP PREP TOE J J N'•ANO m m(p -{ /4� CD -H/SIOR/IAREFERENCE ONLY HERS HAS BEEN SU'NCE DEO '`"�r0 SKETCH OF SURVEY ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. ENGINEERS PLANNERS SURVEYORS `���/// 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 37709 FAX: (954) 739-6409 TEL.: (954) 739-6400 �•+' 4 'a ' ." 4. UPDATE LOCATIONS & ELEVS ON AIA DUD 12/11/07 CHECKED BY: DMD J. ADD UNOERGROIINO UINJNES ORD 10/14/0 1. UPDATE SUR VEY REV. CERTIFICATE DMO 4 5/07 FIELD BOOK: SEE NOTE IN N _ Or THE 17 1997 L/NE SHO NW OB ILOROA UCEN9 D EN(N4EENNG, S7RWYNG & MAPPING BUSNIESS No. 211 RORWA UCEN%D LANDSCAPE ARCNHECT &1SNE% Na. COD0114 SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB / Q— nw �• ��� N N O 101 I. ADD 1979 CCCL UNE DMD 1/11/07 PAGE(S): SEE NOTE DESCRIPTION: BY: DATE: S 0570:75` IV -lOE •�^ SOT 5 We H 0B �"cFT T0E-T0B 2I . s 0 ..'� .. OLD6OCEAN BOULEVARD o' 701.85 CALC. @ T DE 1016.26' — �— _UIQ 4, Y j PER AL/CNMEN MAP PREP TOE J N'•ANO . PJ-7BWA �'992AC p OLM BEAOUNr REO BY 'AC OCr 7, I982 •' b o.( 1 J ' PALM A'EVA QBE ACRES PCAT M447=7 I= �1�e • r (SEASONAL 98B L/NE 15 PBCR). M — .- N05• . 22-- �� _- • e��_ u� -"'n I =i 1r H/C WA ,RF A /N/ERPpLA IED FRO# FELDLOAEq I _ SEC. JO YERNMENr Lor 2 IRP 45S 707 BS' _ O _ RNG. 4 -TE PAW BEACH SHOR (OCEAN BL VD E . a •' C 6 o ��` AES) P.B. 7, PC. 15 P.RC.R. — N 06515:71 ` E - PRLWE/(7Y CD'TNERS NOT SET p/y A ^ ' ar H Z RT/S ,.16-144- TO BA INERS N' - ✓L"E ' en PER MEAN via L/Nf 79 OB' _— H/GH WR BY s DA IED UAPR/(ATE�g OGK �Y o _ 'a 61 �Qoi; Peia}�'A „�n '�R ^ Sga�\tlq pX£ 2 .„ la'pp•,,, 'v� 6b N>FRPOLAI1 FROMN RUNE DATA ' MEAN j1H I TLAx:lNT/C OCEAN A n ' GH W TER JO /NIE988 4 RPgAH n QBQ, € o 5 F Y4 i 3 o s a N O FONIOUR C$✓E4 ROM OA IA 0 mea n A ZZI II s o e�aa � R m m(p -{ /4� CD o =j' I F11 SKETCH OF SURVEY ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. ENGINEERS PLANNERS SURVEYORS `���/// 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 37709 FAX: (954) 739-6409 TEL.: (954) 739-6400 DATE: 6/I6/06 SCALE: =]D' DRAYM BY: EA PREPARED FOR: THE JFP GROUP, LLC 4. UPDATE LOCATIONS & ELEVS ON AIA DUD 12/11/07 CHECKED BY: DMD J. ADD UNOERGROIINO UINJNES ORD 10/14/0 1. UPDATE SUR VEY REV. CERTIFICATE DMO 4 5/07 FIELD BOOK: SEE NOTE IN N vy O n Z ILOROA UCEN9 D EN(N4EENNG, S7RWYNG & MAPPING BUSNIESS No. 211 RORWA UCEN%D LANDSCAPE ARCNHECT &1SNE% Na. COD0114 SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB / Q— nw �• ��� IA O I. ADD 1979 CCCL UNE DMD 1/11/07 PAGE(S): SEE NOTE DESCRIPTION: BY: DATE: APPROVED SET JAN 112013 GULFOWN OF S REAM, FL C: \2006\060077\dwg\ADJACENT-BUILDINC-EXHIB17dwg (VICINITY EXHIBIT) D- 13, 1007 8.190 DOAVE C 1 mso o m J IS SgtBs R 4�c Ua�y,y O ♦R I 4; 1 I 1 RM00391 90 181LI 11 3AkSSIN ON 6SYN9 N319 fN3NNNON U30 BNO OW T IA 1 II I I _ 1 A70d •0f 09/-----. 1 I'Tti / 1 I I 3.8094fBS-- ZVON HH1HON - — — — — — an g aa an'13 ,Hurl 1 ----------------- L ^Nr sip1 ' y�VQ j I 3PoBQ(aiS - JAgJ Ad1]r5 1\�JO7B I � 1 - .i rs 5•gres---- --�' 3078 - 3Atl3 aao�s r I 1 1` 1 vou V.1 Y0 - — - - I , 1 r' _-- a �-3enstires �j ti P°�9 apn I I B3l3NYb' ^i rJAYA] Q3N3d0 O I I L-� 3a7e -��eares--- L4 7AV3 A8Qr9 Z (O o V ! I I Oy I Vr� ��Bares-/1 P I } 2 5 v I o� 1 y I 4 ,00101 Z56SBB N_ 3 I 7Y3W.1373 3AY13 ANOfs l� .r9 B6 384BQfeS ,99 fi r 3 77,06 N ,SS B6 M "r£L1Q6 S 79- I BD.BQn, � 2 Iq a m�2n ti I aNQAA, r'YY�i V Q F I� a^o o m RRYxa N� IoaR i = spa �pn�g _ 700d a re ?q' - � o ma 10 LL- www I 1 I I I I I I I `n I 1 I I I I I 1 I I I I f a I 1 I I I / I 1 I I I a 1 mso o m J IS SgtBs R 4�c Ua�y,y mea RST ♦R I 4; 41 u �n IA 1 II f�r. Z 107 1N3NN713AC _ 1 I,6B 911 3 ,81, 1 / 1 I 1 ¢¢c" 14Y I a 1 mso o m J IS SgtBs R 4�c Ua�y,y U O m Z O I 41 u �n IA 1 II ng _ 1 I,6B 911 3 ,81, I ani T _ J 1 I � J IS SgtBs I xN2 n Z O I 2 �n a 1 K.a. .awba laK Ka..:.a o.v tea.. waa.a4.4 »wK ..: ng Ip � I ani / 1 1 1 I �o ¢¢c" 14Y ZVON HH1HON - — — — — — an g aa an'13 ,Hurl 1 ----------------- L ^Nr sip1 ' y�VQ DI - .i rs 5•gres---- --�' 3078 - 3Atl3 aao�s r I 1 1` 1 ---� ..........� I - I ' I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I , � I I I I I 'II ' I 1 I I I 1 I I I I I II iB 5 I I 1 I 1 QmQ of x I IT I Is � I I I' lyl t o I I k .orrRR 0 I 98 N I I I 1 I ' I 1 I 1 I I 1 I Ilt I 1 I ' I I I I ' I I ' I I I I 1 I I I i 1 I 1 I II I I I 1 I I I I I I Imo_ 1 I I I 1 I I I i I I 1 I O o m O O -I 10, EXHIBIT 1 1 I 2 F!� � Z I o v� 1 cri V K.a. .awba laK Ka..:.a o.v tea.. waa.a4.4 »wK ..: .nn .ala rrrr rrr ,O N I O! v ¢¢c" 14Y ZVON HH1HON - — — — — — — — - aa an'13 ,Hurl �+ 3-f1.OLB85_ I ----------------- ---� ..........� I - I ' I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I , � I I I I I 'II ' I 1 I I I 1 I I I I I II iB 5 I I 1 I 1 QmQ of x I IT I Is � I I I' lyl t o I I k .orrRR 0 I 98 N I I I 1 I ' I 1 I 1 I I 1 I Ilt I 1 I ' I I I I ' I I ' I I I I 1 I I I i 1 I 1 I II I I I 1 I I I I I I Imo_ 1 I I I 1 I I I i I I 1 I `^VICINITY m -I + Vv p I_01 O o m O O -I 10, EXHIBIT CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. ENGINEERS • PLANNERS • SURVEYORS ff 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE. FLORIDA 33309 N.W. (954) 739-6409 TEL. (954) 739-6400 namoA uaHsm crronamnc, sinlcmm a u.rrmc eusras: Ka. 2 ROgOA LK£Kg0 LAKOSC AR010ECRIAE Bu5wE55 Ko. C.Z..71 ©, Bpi PREPARED FOR: THE JFP GROUP: LLC F!� � Z QCA DA"rU O TCAIAIIQ /%111 K.a. .awba laK Ka..:.a o.v tea.. waa.a4.4 »wK ..: .nn .ala rrrr rrr , ¢¢c" 14Y `^VICINITY m -I + Vv p I_01 O o m O O -I EXHIBIT CRAVEN •THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. ENGINEERS • PLANNERS • SURVEYORS ff 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE. FLORIDA 33309 N.W. (954) 739-6409 TEL. (954) 739-6400 namoA uaHsm crronamnc, sinlcmm a u.rrmc eusras: Ka. 2 ROgOA LK£Kg0 LAKOSC AR010ECRIAE Bu5wE55 Ko. C.Z..71 PREPARED FOR: THE JFP GROUP: LLC QCA DA"rU O TCAIAIIQ /%111 K.a. .awba laK Ka..:.a o.v tea.. waa.a4.4 »wK ..: .nn .ala rrrr rrr APPROVED SET JAN 112013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FI. nun1Inr— 110/18/06 SCALE. 1"-50' ORAWN BY: EA CHECKED BY: DMO FIELD BOOK: 1 2210 G:\2006\060077\-9\SOS SPEC PURPOSE -g jS-4 UDL] Dec Q. 2007 8'14— DD—E APPROVED SET JAN 112013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL ® r a® o 0 Q om:m fe Fgv:nA Z n I I I I C Z Z D C Z D C D f— A Z UI A m Fn I.7 ,h )j$)t bI¢IQ $ > � 0 C, p 0 a m C7 P1 rT \ IIyII� `ILII' #oA II Z c Z rr�* < m m m m m ,7� u1 fIj v N m p zz LL�� y9� pp Z C1 Z Z N) i ) � F T A SKETCH OF SURVEY CRAVEN • THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC. DATE: 10/24/07 O m O UTILITY LOCATIONS ` ENGINEERS PLANNERS SURVEYORS SCALE. =20' CD qt fTl 3563 N.W. 53RD STREET, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33309 DRAWN BY: EA A V Cl PREPARED FOR: FAY: (954) 739-6409 TEL.: (954) 739-6400 iLO6OR CHECKED O THE JFP GROUP, LLC A UCE" D """SCA 9U6YEITNG b YR—E 604NEC 11 ])1 flOfiOA UCEN]E0 LANOSCRPE MCnItE0N6E 6u5N1E55 rva. C000114 BY: DMD A I 0 SEA HORSE BATH AND TENNIS CLUB a ., m FIELD BOOK: 2288 Duo 12112107 PAGE(S): 1. UPDATE LOCATIONS 8 ELEVS ON AIA ^�^�10>® DESCRIPTION: BY: 49-54 DATE. APPROVED SET JAN 112013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL -i < m m ppp T D { * m Z -< v=D= O,m A ; CZ O O-nj -Oji 0ccm 0 31 ;um (n r `_Z �zzm cO G)< O Z Z m FD Z:a;OO �o o� as 8 1- Volug 4001 No cean Blvd. g on KaIter CoenmunWm APPROVE® SE, GUN Stre8M, F107ida JAN 112013 TOWN OF GULP STREAM, ar w9 j p Imm QIPzz S �N�3 N Z O mU5 -uz m D Co m cn �z G) a 00 =� �y o< rno o� mC z0 z D m m v o C D 0,T1 `2N 0 20Scn ZO X�7777 m 07 -DI .'U• C G1 �0 cn O =N=ZO n �r cn 20 o G) 0 m E�� om�m � M 2 ti r=n� M 0 Z Z7� rm- z m M sn N se II FM mn o co 70 m n m 40 z z' D D = A r u m N Z z m b x b N m m = m 0 C m -I z m N cn m 0 coZ cn z c z m O CR-a—I -Djv-G UCimzc MM or- ��a-ummzrr'� mm mcg M mmgm�o-.oMcn M \�00 r_ m-ISpDZZ2-� T zxRE W04m >228 D Ocnz <u ZJ2 -0z cn �GoSmffO?Z> cn mm-m=lo� 0oO� l Cn O cn O� Z n O Im O z M M C M In zao� -g0co> cn �+ c o m -0 C1 aa> -I r m0 O mom mTONcn�m DC)N r T CD M4 2 :* 22 O cn M fn M X_k D m v X -0 a; OOPU, p -owl 0=m -o�vw� Cn cn m ��.37 0 , /^ 'i 0 N r X nFcn cn N y c J cn m m C C7 u u cn P D �0 � N m Cl) C A -i a p m m W V m Cl) D o G)�nv m -a-I D mr=m 2 fn n Z cn --j o 2 _� N � �--�N-at- � v D m�G) r U) � x cn � cn r- w �n = m 0 II II z � m y z Cl) �a2cn F�1 In zX Z o sz N Q�O�� �'I 0 nca �2�-0 0aA P -��7 0 -I =mom'�Pm �a� m o zmzDO . O . C. Mcn Vx�m 2r�Sm m TT o W .Zm] C7 �7 -I >m (Tj N m MID Av N=om o m cn at SMnm tiT y n rn ;ux�N -0ci. 'oo OD0OD Ao � �i vMp-q U).r-m mWP 7,' 0 r A =mzzmWo C= m 0 o y „ g W� rTl m Rmz tC! �n0ODr o N 0 yC:-on O mrZX _ oC� �m D �0y>o m �M �z�m� mm o mA -n r N IN I Pg m3 y= m3� 3 o 0 z [n ZO y-Im m0� Z•im° mM. 229 M X00 S A u' �zc -�'gm M'.. DESIGN -4 xon om atom = o m a IN I Pg m3 y= m3� 3 o 0 z [n ZO y-Im m0� Z•im° mM. 229 M X00 S A u' �zc D DESIGN -4 xon 10 atom = o m a t�ia A o ��SO[ JTH PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ~: ' '- $ 4D Planning I Landscape Architecture Environmental Services I Transportation Tin l � y MKm T ba CNC or"= 0 M N IN I Pg m3 y= m3� 3 o 0 z m A ~ O C a -�+ ° m g mG �19n Yn' m — ,y9YLSZdl C � alvo,tcwc .5j� KgA•a m ��` opp yy� � p,QymmOm A�1oO��rDLOyc1{[iOpo222py3i b���wyy-1�om-aixlD�zOp-m�iQ�nToyy�a cz'0io0my ry<,p �C<ZmDOy�� O� aAp<p.2D�Te.AnoNO ZOZZO_0m °O omm O =r\ 00 Z m.p oa� mR.�o 8 az n�smQso Za Zy 60-1 m o < - Z o Ai 9O 0. T'� 64189, B� Zv g0-Z011n-y. z . 1 'Cm ."-o,-mac F '".�' m zT m- zz in?Ay .> "'a I,nn m- M Ag9,Zp > �. SC9m0 m- H. ©gy 9,'o D9D0 ]Iyo�>2D2O.00�.0 m.0 Q 0mnm-n mOn� rn Z D Oy Oyp�y•y0100 �3C002 m ca£m qqlI pp�yyo lcn�'Zc{�' 73 �" �m$xT'-�(�o�f5 pqp�l, -1 yyo -i prp y�y�" "y°$$ a ���c-yl aAay6<99cy V 2p °rte OTO.y cO' �Dm mym O 0�0miN°Al�� y5 -9,r m.y m OOZZ mO Zr mA 1'fl m. M �X V M!pFsf is CAO ml�t� <0>60z.0 m( -m y N - ��� < o'oyp S' -i 9:y''yO OC1. 2D y.Zm9,y Or�m � y = 00 vD �00p 02°Ov A NL Ggy9C.2 m.�i mm. n.5~oim"-1mZ-I m�Mr.p Z_O ym y-yL�'r O .V� bTm�� m Oy 9O22m Ll A. C. °{ r 00>OO m yJCO -C��. C~Co �OI'm.cm z l)9, OZ�a Zyp00 me 999 cyoC =o z°. g m�>�nmpaa.yAm S p. a a z ` poc N.- c �=3 O�yA[C[�a lli��D'�ZOpzpl!y 2 C!n �C O OT.o- -110, _I �IF-�2'.O�O m�('�C� _Z O.y�.mo ZZ O m~,Oyez 02 . YO 5. �i O T dye Fa m y �Fu -.CiZyN� 4p Z NN1 $ ?mSmzZ �`c'O oy =l P+is m. ti Or- M. �mNZTn�O �-1 T ?00 m O� m LZiOm�CDmG�)y OSS. o�ooc 6y�v,,lm��m $m V{ icaiG.�'<-my,m $ OA°`^9�aAm ccm O OpO .0 Z' p--'mm.Omm C Z s y pN' z`c' AOO lay-" va m Av«m�v25 Om 2 .0 o�m oc z O _ az <c 0Ov Ori m`_' -�61"A �p yiI czi�o tynmm - �9L m1° O O- �°y m -p 410y R -'D 31 � zm CS't1 111. -:1< O Gy IAn 61 CC� mZl' �9ZCZtC- �r O ymtJ �m� C O �C C° H -Z-1.a> -� .!2 Z Z Z n 2-St� O g�n O y < m 0 0 C Z m D y m �o Ommo ..0T,�l 90T .Z -m N m -1y 49,-y1 ym'y m m O 0mmla O A OpD'm 'aA O y<Oy yam. yOm1~_�Z. A 00m -CyyA V D f�a `• O°0022y 80 Am Gllnn m �"'�' -LI. Ny zN 9 Gl ••offa � -yi �in it�p�� Pp n m M A� y ��CO �m O< 0��r D-1 �j° 8D O'O O r2 o'u Z'n 'b n V >y >> ta q y a ymym�S�c O ti =q0 O Om Aym 0 b y Fx Q .Q. p"m+y_Do my AO 3�3D c z tam o¢ m°� a 0p�pyym Coz mmczi �' �. lnv o`v+yc py m�o-a g o ��m0-P DST G1 v..L0 '2yf� "nn'D��'� q°IDZ S5$$�OAWIR!O OD m �ODti 9,90 rC. Ami 'C m 3 pm.�Olnmmym_o m_pxe N y�yZ -I OiI°iz co �y9m N m �O,° _1Zn� D T- N 3mAAm �Z20OC m° O IM E>g opLLyo,� C -Z z O Zy3lf� 9 C-1 -C RF '.2Oym„S° �T 2 2gyZ 42= ADZE < 9 Z ?I A � _-� ° - u vm-rO -GYMCC ]Al� -'d' a .��c�c c, 0-C D-1 AK Z OZnQ fil O m A m yy yy m.Dy"�yD $y9,yOZA 9r bm'1 y0y T Z �r vm .< A 9�V 99 V02'lX ra yyn mFTOa Y'M O [" om- Z O O m y C" z �0 y0m 05',�AO ZOZ-p OZ [n ZO y-Im m0� Z•im° mM. 229 M X00 S A u' �zc D DESIGN -4 xon 10 atom = o m a t�ia o m A ~ O C a -�+ ° m g mG �19n Yn' m — ,y9YLSZdl C � alvo,tcwc .5j� KgA•a m ��` opp yy� � p,QymmOm A�1oO��rDLOyc1{[iOpo222py3i b���wyy-1�om-aixlD�zOp-m�iQ�nToyy�a cz'0io0my ry<,p �C<ZmDOy�� O� aAp<p.2D�Te.AnoNO ZOZZO_0m °O omm O =r\ 00 Z m.p oa� mR.�o 8 az n�smQso Za Zy 60-1 m o < - Z o Ai 9O 0. T'� 64189, B� Zv g0-Z011n-y. z . 1 'Cm ."-o,-mac F '".�' m zT m- zz in?Ay .> "'a I,nn m- M Ag9,Zp > �. SC9m0 m- H. ©gy 9,'o D9D0 ]Iyo�>2D2O.00�.0 m.0 Q 0mnm-n mOn� rn Z D Oy Oyp�y•y0100 �3C002 m ca£m qqlI pp�yyo lcn�'Zc{�' 73 �" �m$xT'-�(�o�f5 pqp�l, -1 yyo -i prp y�y�" "y°$$ a ���c-yl aAay6<99cy V 2p °rte OTO.y cO' �Dm mym O 0�0miN°Al�� y5 -9,r m.y m OOZZ mO Zr mA 1'fl m. M �X V M!pFsf is CAO ml�t� <0>60z.0 m( -m y N - ��� < o'oyp S' -i 9:y''yO OC1. 2D y.Zm9,y Or�m � y = 00 vD �00p 02°Ov A NL Ggy9C.2 m.�i mm. n.5~oim"-1mZ-I m�Mr.p Z_O ym y-yL�'r O .V� bTm�� m Oy 9O22m Ll A. C. °{ r 00>OO m yJCO -C��. C~Co �OI'm.cm z l)9, OZ�a Zyp00 me 999 cyoC =o z°. g m�>�nmpaa.yAm S p. a a z ` poc N.- c �=3 O�yA[C[�a lli��D'�ZOpzpl!y 2 C!n �C O OT.o- -110, _I �IF-�2'.O�O m�('�C� _Z O.y�.mo ZZ O m~,Oyez 02 . YO 5. �i O T dye Fa m y �Fu -.CiZyN� 4p Z NN1 $ ?mSmzZ �`c'O oy =l P+is m. ti Or- M. �mNZTn�O �-1 T ?00 m O� m LZiOm�CDmG�)y OSS. o�ooc 6y�v,,lm��m $m V{ icaiG.�'<-my,m $ OA°`^9�aAm ccm O OpO .0 Z' p--'mm.Omm C Z s y pN' z`c' AOO lay-" va m Av«m�v25 Om 2 .0 o�m oc z O _ az <c 0Ov Ori m`_' -�61"A �p yiI czi�o tynmm - �9L m1° O O- �°y m -p 410y R -'D 31 � zm CS't1 111. -:1< O Gy IAn 61 CC� mZl' �9ZCZtC- �r O ymtJ �m� C O �C C° H -Z-1.a> -� .!2 Z Z Z n 2-St� O g�n O y < m 0 0 C Z m D y m �o Ommo ..0T,�l 90T .Z -m N m -1y 49,-y1 ym'y m m O 0mmla O A OpD'm 'aA O y<Oy yam. yOm1~_�Z. A 00m -CyyA V D f�a `• O°0022y 80 Am Gllnn m �"'�' -LI. Ny zN 9 Gl ••offa � -yi �in it�p�� Pp n m M A� y ��CO �m O< 0��r D-1 �j° 8D O'O O r2 o'u Z'n 'b n V >y >> ta q y a ymym�S�c O ti =q0 O Om Aym 0 b y Fx Q .Q. p"m+y_Do my AO 3�3D c z tam o¢ m°� a 0p�pyym Coz mmczi �' �. lnv o`v+yc py m�o-a g o ��m0-P DST G1 v..L0 '2yf� "nn'D��'� q°IDZ S5$$�OAWIR!O OD m �ODti 9,90 rC. Ami 'C m 3 pm.�Olnmmym_o m_pxe N y�yZ -I OiI°iz co �y9m N m �O,° _1Zn� D T- N 3mAAm �Z20OC m° O IM E>g opLLyo,� C -Z z O Zy3lf� 9 C-1 -C RF '.2Oym„S° �T 2 2gyZ 42= ADZE < 9 Z ?I A � _-� ° - u vm-rO -GYMCC ]Al� -'d' a .��c�c c, 0-C D-1 AK Z OZnQ fil O m A m yy yy m.Dy"�yD $y9,yOZA 9r bm'1 y0y T Z �r vm .< A 9�V 99 V02'lX ra yyn mFTOa Y'M O [" om- Z O O m y C" z �0 y0m 05',�AO ZOZ-p OZ [n ZO y-Im m0� Z•im° mM. 229 M �Ro !y moma ANALmyy �zc D DESIGN -4 xon 10 n Azo Z Z °m z C ti m m A c s 2 m v T-12 � Tx z "® LAND 4001 N. OCEAN BLV - W� DESIGN -4 _ PREPARED FOR KOLTER - ��SO[ JTH PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ~: ' '- $ 4D Planning I Landscape Architecture Environmental Services I Transportation Tin ' C 1 I m z 11-A �g ma 31ni � 6m�" 1ny z� ooh m£Ocii m N 0��4x'E 300.38'CFfN01.3i'ix'E 3D0.31 -CAL iymc ���^I � cmmc Dmm� m f!1D Oy N�r bvy� .9 S88ui�J�����8� m DSOZv 002:0 ziov = •f�i/ / / A Zy�=� <Dv rm �4O�b = 9 m�Tl 6f v19 >9 '�iN^�e / `I 'i 4.1 S fn M �c c� g f @9 M AE mm c 1 m g! M? o7�c ' MIN O 0 N mr M.w �D I oma I m z 11-A �g ma 31ni � 6m�" 1ny z� ooh m£Ocii m N 0��4x'E 300.38'CFfN01.3i'ix'E 3D0.31 -CAL iymc ���^I � cmmc Dmm� m f!1D Oy N�r bvy� .9 i m DSOZv 002:0 ziov = •f�i/ / / A Zy�=� <Dv rm �4O�b = { ©y�filz f ` m / ^F, m T h O > �c c� g f , m mm c m g! M? o7�c ' z ii O 0 N mr E5 I m z 11-A �g ma 31ni � 6m�" 1ny z� ooh m£Ocii m N 0��4x'E 300.38'CFfN01.3i'ix'E 3D0.31 -CAL -- — -I P9 g ca n=s•a�'arcFr - m c p R-,579.64'-8'AT4T DT4-C. r mm iymc ���^I � cmmc Dmm� m f!1D Oy N�r bvy� .9 mF: r 6 ci m DSOZv 002:0 ziov = •f�i/ / / A Zy�=� <Dv rm �4O�b = { ©y�filz a Z C ^F, m T h O > �c c� g ma nyc mm mm m - _ — ,a9'cLsva 'OT10 LS'LOE i30..4GZ9.9 ' i rl.cv'wc 'D'M•I.tZ75.9=v 1233.&' -- — -I P9 g ca n=s•a�'arcFr - m c p R-,579.64'-8'AT4T DT4-C. r mm Oy \ zm P� \\\ m lA/1 y y as c in 0 tAiiy Cm < c l?m�I A, I " �776geg a �nY � 111111.1 �m`gg -xi :: X. ���^I � (CA T Dmm� m f!1D Oy N�r — � mF: r 6 ci m DSOZv 002:0 4001 N. OCEAN BLVD. •f�i/ / / A Zy�=� !IuuzPpZ { m 3 a Z C ^F, m T h �1nI, V Ll c� g nm `? - _ NOd•5132•E ' 1233.&' E5 �D I Oy \ zm P� \\\ m lA/1 y y as c in 0 tAiiy Cm < c l?m�I A, I " �776geg a �nY � 111111.1 �m`gg -xi :: I :2� I ���^I � I I I N�r — � —I I No7dav I� d➢25g t�t{{��� IYo 2� k'i 4001 N. OCEAN BLVD. - LDj s 0 GG { 7 � 1 ^F, m T h �1nI, V Ll - `? PRFPARFI7 FOR KCI TFR c E5 I m o I I l � I I I I m � I i m� 1�• m I 5 .I L1:zm �Or - �z 0y gni T-1 bo �$ O - i v o 111111111 S05 J,., 301.85' CALC. d CFf. - �m A m Z I� OLD OCEAN BOLILEVA}7D m '¢ PER AIJGNA1EwJ./T�WAY P.- LL'WPPREPAREDNY 0 0 NO.3-7 CN1' 8�492ALDA7E0 OC77, � 1082 $ ym' N05'2035• E a _ m A m3 p mgo�"moq 0-1 32 oo� Viz, 0 a�^y 00 AD A�IC_.T � C'>x D .11.<0 r� y>A�L rD Zm DD y�pm �0_I n�2C A ��x/ °RK '-Kai O vc�p� 1z; > �Z m 4 pmfZ/1DDN1311 Z f°OOp�T mTm 111Gx1A p -z 9<fZ ? mx C y�-Om0 -2- 1-� T OC fl A, D Ofnf1 �, ofOm° o m'�m °� o�on pp� o Z. .F `� m ga h (� �•. VI �'�_OiC m3 A:N r�a° N. TO C9m v mn'.CO °nn o oA m � y x�nE:>y L�1 �Aaz� zap �� oo_ x O i cc o Az 5 Z Sm Oy�p� oCm0Or0.1 °Zp _y Om 2y Z Z mp 7L. 0�ofrmn m-Oyv -miy z�� zy.Z ❑� �omi DZ ca V•^'L� 1�f� V3 -i<23 x >AA ZR'O 00 A2pD i g O m a L m- mm'T mT m�N 0, oz 'o -mA< o p�m 8$ �c~� D " 5", ti ' Z n�vmo orvoa i mQm�yyA z zaA x DP'a< ymyzza�zoD so P. I m'`n Am xI OODS O� iyCyX A'nc2m nm A��I.�o Oy[°)' O �•x m" m�aZn y.l - 0- Oy0 OAZ�1O ax zfx T( 9.2j - O [lnn°?03o?I. h1.Drrrlxll Emil W 80Z WVo m. -1o' •� oyA a yj ylll$aoC as ZIT" my o, -� cy 0.8 $'mxmzi_v Fmk ,oz yO rrO rtoo°I T.00m�Ne _AZ Z= ry0 D °y �,341NAy� ZCa9 Z-11 ((�y7ny RR4Z]II C_yn z 1 C pA.D 'tlOm u�OZ A� T� ZIM plpt�j r Azrl3 OOIllmp Z,- 2! U; yOGYZn Am Tp�TmA mmc 1C my A C00o Om- m mD_DO al 0 m- mz N Om��Acm 3mC vzy �- po yyz{R Z Z SZmQ�m tinZp-xop.OD �3A O-nl1Dmyy 'P9N.O m.ID'1��01 'n ~ z�0 Zm Z pNOy47 mD �Imil��mm ...K ZRi ta'I to �Ra1�0©A m_xy$O xy� C m� m OA ��yLy7 X17 !� �OOm 'opZm n. T m_ OAOy 9.01 - .ay" Oy.�'ZOmT C Z O C9 1yy.� e-1 Ai'�-i � � O-°_IiZ031mn y mv9n 9x 2 N.D�O np0 �2mA Om. m h' X D vn9<,-� hoz -y1� A N-zx ciT zm°< zv a z mz�p c -c p imc1T A9T r a m m -ICO y rlOCO ��i�v°r zm H Tv ° c'1 mix�o m� v m O�Z Z ��n3mm OO mmm Om 'OA myon=1 -a I^ollim c� p OC)NTcPim?]Av O va. O mmmn 3A°jO •DqI Ai�nn g �"r m -iy a �ry in "o�jf O OOOzxA Oyc03 ym O< m 002Dr. y0 O' g°.9 2 m0 m uja�a�--mii zp�-rnyno A o x9m�.o< m v D� rF-A �mmin y y y OA O. Axl ° aDOSO�AmO Z mm2ymzn �yy?c mr'�n1 po 06^ A ADmN �oz I�i m-�'xzi = '" r��C!3A�1�' �1 xDv�-mi PICA 'n •,GAr'�Op r AZOC yfm ZOcg1m�yyO O D` -y OD Tm Tr.O IT ZL.pnl°ily Qm OLn .nO m Iz >0 OOC yOO c -m1 3 v�pnmm A(] - N myztiy gam, oAy'� °D ➢v ' �"/ a-- `V. !• - vmCAOZroxA .Z.p xx �O PyoDC m zO Oi v OCmyD .�•O o�� o m O p : LNJ mzDramAO�o -_ yD mFazm. oK CY ° y Zy¢ m oZm0m D Am < m Z A Y T O O p O 0 I T yyy yyyy2mm AOy �O y'"Ij OmyC 9m M. yZ'x0 Cl) = 00.0 OOOO CCA mmO -�S� C OOm OmOs-aA0 m yyy Dyy LyL °m DDyDyL yy;I- OOZY = 1 r Oym ZOZ p;0 m Z D 1'I"'I"Cyy I-l-I-rimll°<Cm-1 Dv�N,S+, _�S >ti p� NP mm�'' fn mygD m2'mAACApmm<O. Wm <�I° �Ri 3 I.N. mzC01 syn O _ y0y '+xmr 00^� mDy x A Om 0 - 1O'3OjA�S6ym:�`<mrm--�t0'IS<2 < vny AOyO <Cm > Z D> p AO ZDID Z'y 09OmZ Yx YY<•• D O yy Niq �tlm� D Z 99AZ9Ayyyn��TmC yAy y T y _x.D.yz OTO m p :s- 1mA A m m n my y z Gj Z A m a 0 Z A C m �1nn n Lmx z y m �A°p �Ovp� CDe Dy $ ZA D � A OD z1z AO00 mmy Ili m m O OC Ny pC GIGO yy- C m0 0. zzD 'x ° o 0 m m A O O O 3 0 74Q¢ S o 0 m - a mz m z N 1. No m N Qe .or m x'q�',m� R - mS�N a z"� uzSp ym� minm D mDe mgr�m�� � c vv-pO nam aD_ 3a'I�S x�..om LAND DESIGN C` r11 1T1 1 m Z 4001 N. OCEAN BLVD. ^F, `? PRFPARFI7 FOR KCI TFR E5 C DE, - ?2.012 �- 5setback lige App r to location of new dune ' sover. New crossoF to meet the minimu' ' 15' offset �.` requirement and shall not disturb the existing Seagrape line. *stairs shown are not to scale and do not depict actual layout. i �- 5setback lige 30NMIS3�J �13E)NlddllO M N r WC,--) U. r © �2 > ®N a LU z oc ou a ul zul OG Q J IL 0 J W �O Ul M C> Q Z_ 0 w U O Z Lt_ I J W I Z J 0� i � w«a•i�ci cn 0o I W m I Z N _l � I Q I w w U) 't 0 i Q� U p °° N Do Lu JLOW ti= Z`OW U-0 Q~o U 0 CV —iI rn Y I m CD �LO Z w— ' NO=W i H Nacn� m Z I O I o a 1 Q oc o Z J r l 0 LL K 0 0 e <cl ONE* z OC �R J� °JLJ � QLij W V a W W z W a U)j ,a00CL w C -C cc- OW W LA. D=> t1 LL H pt- - 7c 1Ozw f(D LL W W OC J G ap N ti V N I O O O < \ Q 1. Nto�•9itrn sov>av :mss QutA I1IOJ'3$11.I.7�.irsr�2[V60'DIDAI®08QII :•IIYN[ +i i9Y9-"L (19G) •XV3 Z9L9K6E (19G) •IId leve£'I.d'klc)mvu VolOH'LTl mlins'•QA'IH AIo.LVZT VrboH •M•2S e9ZZ 4132i -x ax/ �A:.LIx-ll wczluo-B=m •wvaa�ia,a�no 79a1oa nw onNaA\I --w SON30183H U30NIddP10 I 0%0V'7ad MMJL■Q 71LLofMOUVAIMMIIWUMW �iOW F Z6/b l lVAOVdd\I,LN3Wd073A3a U- c z ir ` ®-1 IE W 0 W Z o d 8 Z J 0 Q W J W H o m $ a 2 9 3 N N Jr W 8 Z J W Y. H 2 {p � Jr L F H Q zLL 2 Yl a= f m Q c ul vi W N W F v z N � LLA a 0 W In Bill h LL LL N o d J Z ID a 01Qy O Wul .. Q + i N 3 _o �_ Q tz u Z . >i <$4g a O; pO O g��" !- fX W w r2 w imp m t° -I- $ =�z oe ' O immomi g --ft l. Elm U wOJ'—.C)W.>•_rrr-fgVSOyK,E :HEIS HWM I1IOU•'.+*n r -w r rv-��.SO.��O�HI i.��� S9��SL iT9G) •XY8 Z9L9-Z6E iT9s) •Hd TEPEE 78 '1�IO.LV�I V�OH `tTT '7.r.TnB '-QAZg HO.LV2i VOOH •AA"i�i £9ZZ -1121-law nv anN;anv as�z 3ON3a1S3H V3DNlddll� Nr,r�a saoo-��a i 3 mu U-NMVAOM T roumm oao�ow W u. U/P&I 1VAOVddV .LN3WdOl3A30 u. Q r--1 ® W I Z \` 1 pp I = i z 5 CL cc O O :` � I 01 ggaa ¢9¢ _ ��■y m I CS Wo I z Q Jim o e� O I I 1 W � d33� Vy1A @ g 3 11i>#.ge. I � �� �� W z 1211111 1 1111 p 1. 1 �' 1--a �� I I I 3 iral�Z >c u 1 f 3 I 0 1 U , � A o &MOQlMA JQWI o N A z rs rs rsF9sn I r 1 f o j ti p I >5 I. rx u I •urs I ti l rzc .. .a a 1 I� rs rti 0 I yp O _ Im �" R _: ------- cc 5 �.WNEll rr ru rz rz a s � >s ------- o w o 4 S� 0RZ 0 yg� t B ��� w oSo Co w OW rx . j r rs rs - rse F 3 u : ieuu,aon oil - r-- --------- zim a -- wwoeiesorwaa3awn — --------i p poi zy I I I 1 •u m g� 1 uaause:xvxomi•:sxsl I wm3av/ovoop•raool ee�areaarrimn�n I Z \` 1 pp I = i z 5 CL cc O O :` ggaa ¢9¢ R��1 z Q Jim o e� 1' zz 1 W d33� Vy1A @ g 3 11i>#.ge. �� �� W z 1211111 1 1111 p 1. 1 �' 1--a �� f 3 - U , � A 01000 &MOQlMA JQWI N A zgo31zxnr3ajAHa1ivso113mM Maus WHAA .40 ;fe //q iiroY� I1I0�'HNn r_^fzJXEn-dvso Dcmgoo3HI ,,xrvw a s9YY-OGL u9s)'XY3 z9L9 z6E (xw)'Hd a iW �yCGGQ�rf=8�9 31 �77�y� ievse -LA •uoLvx v�os •zii wzxr.sis xorvar v�os m u e9zz Yep S2Z�l�l�I�'-Id/Q.Ir_ LIHa2Z`ivT sozxi J N nv snNanv assz 3JN3amv V39NIddI73 SHoLivna-/a ow�avna ;��:/� `/�uoawoureo//rr/ow//rm�row ZW8/0 I"Oaddd 1N3WdOl3A30 WC=) ` a cli W �� him � � J � Q 3 �( 6 I I p�� p I g I I I I I I a I I I I I I E I I � I I I I I I I I P I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I F0 Q N I I=mw J W W Z O W W � i '^ WO,'Xxn--3=JM;3UV6O'T]IINT :MT.T6 H$AA ti f i lip Y T1I013.* f r-iM,M-13117 O'DIIT1IOOaTHI 'IIYW 3 i9►Y-OGL (T9L)'XY3 Z9L9K66 (19S)'Hd a ,11 00eg if �5 �•TEOE£ -LeT `isO.L.r�T VOOH `ZTT ar.rrng •.QAZH 1�IO.LVlI V�OH'AA')�T E9ZZ L -J. i ■■g s2x I Z -N �'ZaJss.3�.X-IX-7:6z�-�-a s�s��oss� sozxunt M p 7t®70tQ nd =nNiAr 9SHZ V �e; AfZ i��� 3JN301S3M �l3�OM& I7J >allo�i�rn��� on�avne ��e i%!�eo1 =anrolWourw*xougaraamu J U/8/ft I"OaddV 1NMdoimm us c N u) M a> W w ® N W o 7-A 7. cc O I I p� I I I I I I � 4 4 I I I flit I EEJ Ito I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � I I I EB I W -tel' I I y I I i9 I I I I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � I I I I I � I I I I � I o I z I C W J I I W I W LU I C 1, C ul A g I I � I W lu Qs s ll �, Vl r^nr-,xvso'D)�TI e�.T.Ts aZAA 0 ., r r : �� 9Y Ni07 "�Nn r_ rsr iZIY60Z7IIIN®03HI c IItlNi H G9fr OGL (T94)'XY8 Z9L9 Z6E (19L)'Hd ,. � I h�, !� TEr£E -ra `uO.r.Vx V�OTT `ZTT a*Tn8 "an -Ts xOZVZI V�Os'AA'l�i E9ZZ 8 1 1 [ r S2i ►�l�l��- Ia�S s. � ►�.I.X-X r.. $$ � �•a s�s.��oss� 2SI sozxuW C E varao��r •wrraa a>acm-2no -ua-�o a nv �nNanv scsz e 33N3GI83H H38NIddl r e� U � � ➢6� illi 01 Nivd �oo OLLlAOrrY l r01Jlr0! d7tOi0W Lu L ul IL JTJ--------T----—�-----� I...r- - LJ LJ ---- I I I I I I I I I I I I I F p I I I -r----�--Z-- - I 'I I I -------------- I I - I - I I I � n r=' ----------- jL== _— II \ i II I II , II II II II �I II 13 II II II 58 j 1 ZWVM� IvnoaddV JLN3wdol3n30 Ods e"� - - - � f v ZWVM� IvnoaddV JLN3wdol3n30 .----- T,_____-__- i II I II II II II II I I I I ___________________ II IL � I I � r== I I I II II P L jl II I � I I II I II it jl II I II h II n II r LL_ L________ J 1 ---------- ---------- I I I I I I I I I I I II III I I I I r -I I I , jt I I JI y I lole ' n IL_____ -1 L______ L_____�I Lr-----,� -----� II I I II II F -I II n II II n II r II II 11 II II II II II II r---------------- IL_____JL-----JII II II I 1 I I II II I I I II I II II I i I II II II II i, I U II II II I 1 I '11;� II II II I I II II Ods e"� BSV cc r 3 M .----- T,_____-__- i II I II II II II II I I I I ___________________ II IL � I I � r== I I I II II P L jl II I � I I II I II it jl II I II h II n II r LL_ L________ J 1 ---------- ---------- I I I I I I I I I I I II III I I I I r -I I I , jt I I JI y I lole ' n IL_____ -1 L______ L_____�I Lr-----,� -----� II I I II II F -I II n II II n II r II II 11 II II II II II II r---------------- IL_____JL-----JII II II I 1 I I II II I I I II I II II I i I II II II II i, I U II II II I 1 I '11;� II II II I I II II "  >. " vaaul$JJ-1 na .tu u.u�fl IFk tifl" w " '1.\INIJ JII ��.I ��i'��'1' " aur .uEE �� Hwjj.s..jquuX��ry1-:��,ai l)ormu F5 F 8 e 0 F EPIlO��'WCallirp(J paps w anua.\y Buz aauaptsag ja��?utddlID ��d ��Id umisfS atidas :g SlupeJo aus lenluaauoD S !WUj F5 F 8 e 0 F S !WUj S Wo' J F z U Z �� ! I I F5 F 8 e SI S 58ga���� SIN �� ��I��@@� n��prp �� ���� yip yy�� a ��3 ',p���'q��_��a 0 bg AE�� +���� ��6����" " 6 q 9$`e 3rL�� e��g��. ��qg ig�� Y9 `. 3 b+C�� g its i 9 Obi. n������f��" $ e�� ��a xsX96 ��, A 'i fi a. ���' $ E !' d Y$�� R ��.��6�� via Fp C his pfl .. 9 �� ��'�� y 9 e yQb �� @ I�� �� �� " �� �� .5 A & ��������&� i ��`�� b i ��k X2,47 �% Q 9'te' �� �� S �� `' �� E" 3�� a b9 ax �� lA�� b �� AllJa��s�� 11 �� �� a3bx��b c �� ��gg5�� a9.E������ I I91ASI `H Ie! 5 SUM]' aIH111to�� �1.11 41 fill X111 ��1A 01 it I Al 4 1 M1 it4M 1iIIv �� IIII I 2 11 uul'11 11 41!1 0 F S S II > E x x 8 & b a SI S 58ga���� SIN �� ��I��@@� n��prp �� ���� yip yy�� a ��3 ',p���'q��_��a 0 bg AE�� +���� ��6����" " 6 q 9$`e 3rL�� e��g��. ��qg ig�� Y9 `. 3 b+C�� g its i 9 Obi. n������f��" $ e�� ��a xsX96 ��, A 'i fi a. ���' $ E !' d Y$�� R ��.��6�� via Fp C his pfl .. 9 �� ��'�� y 9 e yQb �� @ I�� �� �� " �� �� .5 A & ��������&� i ��`�� b i ��k X2,47 �% Q 9'te' �� �� S �� `' �� E" 3�� a b9 ax �� lA�� b �� AllJa��s�� 11 �� �� a3bx��b c �� ��gg5�� a9.E������ I I91ASI `H Ie! 5 SUM]' aIH111to�� �1.11 41 fill X111 ��1A 01 it I Al 4 1 M1 it4M 1iIIv �� IIII I 2 11 uul'11 11 41!1 FS _ a,� s _ o . CD Cd �V 0.� If log -f3 II 11 tl d O D u �u t' �n ��iI ad a C3 Lu m� E ii i w u fi0 03 .6 n is r ua. rte` �" :y a a• It '$ "' 1 AddE'm� � 6-109 lip a z x " o ci o oc o e a O 3 o. LA a. C : u; d l! OL a t a ` o m u}�fS ait �J_v If o.= If Q 11 °iS m LL CL LA 4W O aILs x 4 W o s E oy 3� ,q V 7L CL I' 11 q II O ��c �m it �E�"� sail � ��} �� €�E ` "• E �q �x 1u Q S�p1 II 11 Il '� a g A t exp oKR�CIA U C II u r a 11 106 a W .R .r— Lu z CL N .R �tL A.*6'691 N _.� (v , _ fes.•, � N��cY,S f ,�9� O,Ly,.. • .".Fk- 0 �'• .,. "'• .sir . it .r— Lu J CL N u; di Z 4 c jp n' � N Y� 0 0 O � C m � � Z u �tL A.*6'691 N _.� (v , _ fes.•, � N��cY,S f ,�9� O,Ly,.. • .".Fk- 0 �'• .,. "'• .sir . it .r— Lu J CL TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-15 Address: 2538 Avenue Au Soleil Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Gerald & Sharon Clippinger Agent: Quinn Miklos, Miklos & Associates Addition to an existing one-story single family dwelling with exterior renovations and brick driveway Special Exception (1): To permit the extension of an existing non -conforming wall that encroaches 4.2' into the required 15 foot south side setback. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit additions consisting of bathroom, covered entry and additional living area, a total net of 716.6 SF, to the existing one-story single family dwelling and an exterior renovation to smooth stucco with the addition Gross Lot size: 22,274 SF of quoins on the corners. A new brick driveway will also be a part of the renovations. Effective Lot Area: 22,274 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 5254.5 SF Allowable: 7,054.8 Zoning District: RS -P Height: 17.2'; Preferred <_ 20' Finished Floor: 8.21 Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks (c) Additions to structures zvith existing nonconforming setbacks. Note: Application appears to meet the standards for approval. Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Motion to recommend approval for a Special Exception to permit the extension of an existing non -conforming wall that encroaches 4.2' into the required 15' south side setback. Motion to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition consisting of 776.4 SF, bathroom, covered entry and additional living area patio to the existing one-story single family dwelling and an exterior renovation to smooth stucco with the addition of quoins on the corners and a new brick driveway meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: December 27, 2012 Action: Special Exception: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File # 12-15 ARPB November 15, 2012; TC December 14, 2012 TC Date: January 11, 2013 Action: Special Exception: Approved as recommended. ( 5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as recommended with condition that if any changes in color or material for the roof are being considered, they must be reviewed by staff. ( 5-0) I Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ® RECEIVED OCT -8 2012 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 1.2-1� To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information f I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: 3EMN( 44D 5"NZ00 C t PP1a(qEVZ, I.A.2. Project Address: a5Sb >&WJEtA13$ AV SpW1 I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: Lo -r FD PLA(S AQ SOIC—tL I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) T} UP AN ROSM()t4E R.+Es IM = . 'T;G WIU�. R c�'-1�1�, NEw Ex'�'�Eti►oQ. EIEv.�T�o+�.S ►Z ��Ns ors-STOLY I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: 774-1/ Architectural Style: 4ULF �-tWZUA ..t �MV� 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: CH Type of Foundation: l� ICAL PIG-o- �CIST! C7, B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 6111L�12�yE, lJfc�i �%i �j34$3 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number: fQI . ZS �_ S Fax: 7 e-✓ — Q g 0d 1.B.3. Owner Signature: r C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: (eywwmmu--& 1` mLbS �. ► P -PA. I.C.2. Agent Address: Nt�,�} V--1q'rc-*A I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o). ?j • (pli ell Sol 3c, �19(0GFax S(a ISO846S 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: IZ Com Date: Decision: 'Official Use Only ARPB Date: - —/ Z Recommendation: TC Date: 3�31Cr. /e-. rZ-. Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff.concise but Please be brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question. number for each response. ue A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? C' P L U III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? X Yes O No Explain. 1"►eg_-{'S l,'�� tt�1'T�N'Y }O III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? AYes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? ��t�-��y �r!LN21yFwLng III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage_(nPy SI'T'E b. Sanitary Sewer 5 G. Potable Water d. Irrigation Water CST e. Electricity FAL f. Telephone Grp, Co g. Gas A h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional she'e't if necessary.) N 1P. PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes OkNo (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes X No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) b01hTi clan atop. w�� s w tu_ lb6 IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacantlott ormorethan fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes RNo (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? A'Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes XrNo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 E. Projects Requiring a special Exception. IV.E.1. Is thero osed use a P P permitted special exception use? IV.E.2. Hoy, is the use designed, located and f�iYes ❑ No Code Section: Q..'j � proposed to be operated so that the Public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? Po-.___ IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of of be located? [3 Yes !o her property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. PCO �T IV.E.4, How will the use be compatible with adjoining develo is to be located? pment and the character of the District where it �Zo IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? eyes []No Explain. C IZ�(,-� lS ,d. ncc ►..—_ F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potacts Properties, Potential impacts on surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 ?J"'>> of Uulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezonin n e ' Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Ma g ' °r any combination thereof, please describe the P need change, a Comprehensve Plan text ez d justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. At additional relevant information regarding the Project Applicants not covered elsewhere on required, form or on any of red, to provide any the other materials submitted with the application. p -FHE P R o \Nk"T-P f- D. ,L ► -�-, ANT t 1M0' eL cK A, ENc� IS ,4 Lcnm�. Avv) D Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 012-17 Owner: James & Beverly Kolea Address: 900 Orchid Lane Agent: Peter Carney Proposed Improvement: Construct a rear portico and a new front entrance. Approvals Requested: Level II Architectural/Site Plan: To construct a rear portico and a new front entrance to the existing one-story, single family Bermuda/British Colonial style dwelling, net additions of 403 SF Gross Lot size: 39,984 SF (Unity of Title) Effective Lot Area: 39,984 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 6,634 SF Zoning District: RS -P Architectural Style: G/S Bermuda Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Allowable: 8,230 SF Height: 17.0' (roof height <_ 20' Preferred) Neighborhood: Mixed Section 70-99 Roof design, slope and materials Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-239 Windows Recommendation: Motion to approve Level II Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed rear portico and a new front entrance to the existing one- story, single family Bermuda/British Colonial style dwelling, net additions of 403 SF meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. If the proposed site plan is altered because of the requirements of the Health Department a revised site plan will require ARPB approval. Action: ARPB Level II Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as requested W/ condition as recommended above. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL 1 CIV NOV a 2912 This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 1 .2 "t 7 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: �J-a rr C_s *- P -e ve w in 1<0 I -e- o I.A2. Project Address: 7 G 0 O re_ L, I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: Ly IFfl ij o ce AJ TO. Ry"' ! 14�- 2D -43- LIG 1 0 'k —Zz -0va -0k3a I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.)_ 'Cy IS �i r• q 5'rM y! �QLe ��w.e „ (�a1,o e,0 114(> IXC r.troVs�� I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: ra,2 ev � r c r eir r 1^oar pe vj�e, a Architectural Style: l�j,QrW� ✓ J a .S 1.¢ % $ r c �-, s (o (o . I A.6. Check all that apply: 5�Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: P v 0 o'X 1 S z Type of Foundation: Qu' S 7 -i r 1.B.2. Owner Phone Number: 6" Lf -2- ° 3r5 2— I.B.3. Owner Signature: k,'e-IV-'e , PR 1 CjoJc-7 ax: ( 1 a moi'! 515-1 C. Agent Information V I.C.I . Agent Name and Firm Name:Lam,, ceLV K It -Y I,C.2. Agent Address:13b 5'E �'�/�,/2- ,T T. toy 00 -tx 33yF-3 LC.3. Agent Phone Number (o) S /- 7/f- 3o S' cell Fax 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: of It Official W*R Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: _ TC Date: 7J- l,o/�- /)- Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification (� III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? g (� — P III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ? O No Explain: III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? � No Explain: III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? r i Q woy III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage -2,A i 14- b. Sanitary Sewer _ p r. - , c. Potable water d. Irrigation Water I r e. Electricity P f. Telephone Go Yti e- A -J 7-- g. Gas WA h. Cable Television t-- a y.,.` Azi �- III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements W.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes (° (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? YesNo (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is theprogt at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page February 2002 0 £817££ UPROIA `uluaa�sjjn0 LL LL au'url pIWJO 096 aa 01 suoi�.91311V ?ysuoi�TppV pasodoij F ca0 Q ZL-9L-60 NHOM H11M ONI0390ONd 38Od39 S31ONVd3HOSIO ANV d0 G31AIlON 31VO I 30 ism 13311HOHV ONV HOlOVH1NOO A9 C131JI83A 39 15f1W SNOISN3WIO llV o, Nl AB NMV2l0 0£6Z-LZS-OL9 2SNOISIA3H OL06L Vd'NMVA NA219 '3AV IX1113 % SOEZZL oN .ON 'WWOO JDHIIHDUV TJH3N3O T 03 ION SV vuv'vry C1u.LL az Q Q.7 j SNOISIABU 3lVOS 0 £817££ UPROIA `uluaa�sjjn0 LL LL au'url pIWJO 096 aa 01 suoi�.91311V ?ysuoi�TppV pasodoij F ca0 Q 4l0 Oil 11 r � _4p l `� y o, 0t z O 7 C oN O - Q 4l0 Oil 11 r � _4p l `� W -3 N Il� 11-9l-60 31VO NHOM H11M ONI0330OHd 3HOd3B S310NVd3U3SlO ANV d0 0313110N 301SOW1031lHOHVONVHOIOVH1NOOAeO31dIH3A3915OWSNOISN3W10l1V — — — — _ - - l7 �4i�££ gpi,[oI3 `uIL'aa�.s,�in0 auL"I PITMO 096 • 01 suoi�igaal.iV ay suoijippV pasodo.id -6 Z � W a w _ 00 LL � _ 0 — — — — — AB NMVNO NI 0£6Z-LZ5-Ol9 O1066Vd'21MVWNAH9 '3nV1L01113fi1 r � H rv1 V i1.7.LL1.7G Q (IHHL4 / SOEZZL 'ON ANOO ZI-CO-6 SNOISIA3H 1"3N39p310N SV 3lVpS SNOISIA3M W -3 N Il� — — — — 0 N N — — — — _ — — � W W — — — — — — — — — — — — — I IO m�2 Y=i :::i =i m` � W U O � .� � � � �'r � � �' m � "^\• x <X� .ten .ten ,a�Di xxx x xxx xxx Q Cls z I i o rr r p0 D D O p p C� = — — — — 0 — — — — — — — — _ — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — I � I Q 1� I I i = - –JI� I w ti+ , „ I, U „ LU � . I J LL I ~ I J -- j I =I L_—"—___— ID 1 i }f I ______________ a r^ Z L'B L'60 NHOM HIIMON103300Nd 3HO199 SMONVdMIOS10 ANVd0031AION u' 31VO 39150W 10311H0tlV ONV H010Vi11N00 A9 031dIH3/. 3B 150W SNOISN3WIO lltl N1066Z-LZS-M9 ® L� J AB NMVa❑ OL06L Vd 'i1MVW NAN9 '3AV ll01113 6L SOEZZL ON ANOO JDHIIHD2IV ZtSORfi SNOISIAM ltltl3N300310N SV V u V , V 1 V Llu LLia2 •Q (laud i SNOISIn3H 31V0S r^ £8t�££ lumioi3 �tuLa.ljsjln f) o augZ PigaJO 096 = - -- 010 ° Co Q Qof suopunliv 75) suoi�ippV pasodoij W' C, - u' C::) Qa �i Or ® L� J � 0 � £8t�££ lumioi3 �tuLa.ljsjln f) o augZ PigaJO 096 = - -- 010 ° Co Q Qof suopunliv 75) suoi�ippV pasodoij W' ZL'Q L'GO)W0M 31VO H11M ONI03330dd 3210330 S310NVd3H0S10 ANV 30 0313110N 30150W 10311HOdV ONtl-01:)-.N00 A00313I-A 301501V SNOISN31YIO llV (����[� 17 n7 7Or,T viii»'l i�[�T7Yl� L L C9 lrl M L';),I SJl 1 1 Lr) LL Nl A0ocM oesz MoLs M06L Vd'UMVW NAi18 3AV 11011136L r la 1 a uurl pj ;)1Q 096 .0 0 Q 0 Lo ON VONOO JDHIIHDdV vuv'vIV 'QHLLLI.1L Q Qauj / off. suollicialiv T suoij!ppV pasodo.id _z H, LU w Q ZL-M SNOISIA3HlVd3N30 Q O310NSV SNOISIA311 31VOS AiM31 4Hu 30 411! - 444?3 R• Cli c , Ul UA h _ = X au yo-! .9 LLL c 'oM .h 9.Y ou .SfY•2 y� L7 AZ .9-.9 1H39 W3 444X3 33 dol I— CLLI ,r,9 §§ Q c z Lauo W r— 3 LU I Z w �� a� Q z O 1� ti o� qq l W qj ti CO) C14 �;'s CQ c 'J Ld b 0 t N ZI ._ CL ,c y .E O U V ,b ao�a Its %) w if II U 2 L II p II ] b � ts o � �v 2 3 ti N � LIN v b4 Q' r O i a� UL1 N -C) ca aci�ir O ? Eiv d`c • > U Q)75 Z Z me � °� o m a o E (C1 O -? '� O U N U .o C _ If II c0 -a) II u u II II O O �— C7 ¢ II II o (nm (Ei V ueal0 a_a_000wUm p Weals ►� `? o/no cc 3O�0 d m jo �� %�R 1 iiE 2: IMFa �': _c = = c o E o ca Lu 5 CL 3 rn Q ssW FJ- �''n N II II �a `� �Ua.le cc a anE II n ta U�UQ O.. D_a II JJ u Os)ald� � m i� CLIP cr -i o< a: a p as wled o E0 LL — . CL w nV Onuan' l clm a'm leulpaeo ,Z a' D v_, E w Y 3 CD m Cu a) c o v mac-; 0 O i a� UL1 N -C) ca aci�ir O ? Eiv d`c • > U Q)75 Z Z me � °� o m a o E (C1 O -? '� O U N U .o C _ If II c0 -a) II u u II II O O �— C7 ¢ II II o (nm (Ei V ueal0 a_a_000wUm p Weals ►� `? o/no cc 3O�0 d m jo �� %�R 1 iiE 2: IMFa �': _c = = c o E o ca Lu 5 CL 3 rn Q ssW FJ- �''n N II II �a `� �Ua.le cc a anE II n ta U�UQ O.. D_a II JJ u Os)ald� � m i� CLIP cr -i o< a: a p as wled o E0 LL — . CL w nV Onuan' CD (I)IiapS � aci c clm a'm leulpaeo ,Z a' D v_, E w Y 3 CD m Cu a) c o v J. W ._ CL ,c y .E dJ o �,wM�`'' w if II U 2 L II p II ] U 2 3 2511 CL If I rL = w J J N � LIN v N a: F- LL ` w to Z 3S = W ti l�a6l �- 0 N =� Q 1S Z 3S �o sp a� a y 0> a V a!:. �o t0 3 E a� U c �i ai a O N (n U 0 cc E_ Q: c cu m � 2- E acsou H J WQ O o a) o =-o W O c UW� 2 c: v it 0_ 3 U O X20 U. �O � otS a cU II a CU WOW WO OO .a co a- oar F-LLUaa:CL LU Q cc LLI CA cn W W� cc 3WcL Wp W cl ca �2 a cZi¢(n Qcc z � �Q �, a) c E 2 QWO OVO �I/l�' _ _— E ' (>D'$ WQ O viOS2OS2 WSW l0W-W Y 0� o m nZ y 03 O S Y =o o cU �c �O 2 fah z(i v U a». E c E E a �O O W 3�v) Gly n E o E'5) E m ja W2 3W WOrr Lu ja= 0 m 0.0 �� 0 0 cc =y OVca O yWW 0:W iu 2 0 m 0 o Op aH vu, In wo 0z v c c € c.c 2_� o 2= HQ QcLF• Z J 392 o v �o Q. v E'n Q ty 2� co r, ;t OQQ II II II II II If II II II ao�rL °Co Qty ��Lu may ¢cdC_j 0 uM�c�n �+[2 OOa OCUaaaa-LUQa Q40 m� �ZaOu� W20 24 0 m :2 -=, <et,r4/k M~ N Cl) � N (/) CY) USA °? LL Q C9 r (D j,a T Li N -Rr a) CA r N CD co vt co co (D w per') m NNI,- h Ic F LL E E W a d o,�y� a. LL m t� c N CL CL Z p1 obi o m 26 la: C w O W) i L C7 U_ C �p OC « O a Cj � L f'- U L c c - O NL•V O U) Q O c n -•� Q •gyp c m CO � O C H � ca n Y U to W L w in `a.�t m = .c zi E .. c C z�,.� � r E o c) mQ Z N 0Ln ,E .` c N o a — E u_ Cn cc U) IN 72 V Q% fll. Q� dJ o p N � 2 3 CS N � LIN v r Cn cc U) IN 72 V I 1 I 11 v 4-4. Ida v E 0 C11:11 T7� E 0 C11:11 r� ■ AL k TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA COMMISSIONERS WILLIAM F. KOCH, JR. Mayor JOAN K. ORTHWEIN, Vice Mayor FRED B. DEVITT III CHRIS D. WHEELER MURIEL J. ANDERSON STATE OF FLORIDA ) COUNTY OF PALM BEACH ) TOWN OF GULF STREAM ) AGENT AFFIDAVIT tlosi15 i �f7 BEFORE ME THIS DAY PERSONALLY APPEARED (Owner) J S U e'-� , WHO BEING DULY SWORN, DEPOSES AND SAYS: Telephone (561) 276-5116 Fax (561) 737-0188 Town Manager WILLIAM H. THRASHER Town Clerk RITA L. TAYLOR THAT THE PERSON(S) OR COMPANY OR FIRM LISTED BELOW HAVE THE CONSENT OF THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY LISTED BELOW TO REPRESENT THE OWNER OF SAID PROPERTY AS AGENT FOR SITE PLAN REVIEW WITHIN THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM. THE SUB CT PROPERTY IS LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: AGENT'S(S) NAME: COMPANY OR FIRM NAME: N �- AGENT'S RESS: � � Ar AGENT'S PHONE: FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. (Owner Signature) SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS DAY OF %D-1� , 201)-- (NOTARY 01)-- (NOTARY P SHIRLEY COHN MY COMMISSION EXPIRES: i Notary Public - State of Florida • e My Comm. Expires Jun 1, 2016 a*e' Commission # EE 200669 � i•" Bonded Through National Notary Assn. 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 33483 low R � 4 14 ƒ �� § \� �§ � � Act --jr R � 4 14 Irb-!f CIN oil MY -1 Aa CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Ann Kasten Aker George Delafieled, Jr. January 17, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 24, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 12-27-12. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. July 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC, as Agent for 1275 N. Ocean LLC, the owners of property located at 1275 N. Ocean Blvd, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 7 and 50' of Lot 6, Revised Plat of Elks. D&E of Palm Beach Shores Estates. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to clear building site and re- arrange/remove existing landscape material. C. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to supplement existing landscaping and install rail fence and entrance gate. d. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to allow 300 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum floor area permitted. e. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit construction of a dune crossover. f. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of 11,566 square foot Bermuda style, single family, partial 2 -story dwelling with guest quarters, attached 3 car garage, outdoor pavilion and swimming pool and dune crossover. 2. An application submitted by George Brewer as agent for Ross and Katherine Jones, owners of property located at 450 Banyan Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 4, Elk. 1, Plat No. 1 Polo Fields Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to completely remove the existing AGENDA CONTINUED second story of existing structure. AGENDA CONTINUED b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a bedroom wing and covered loggia on the south east corner and an addition to existing bedroom on the south west corner, along with a new entry feature, a total of 1,431 square feet, to the existing Bermuda style single family dwelling and new landscaping and driveway. 3. An application submitted by George Brewer as agent for Richard Paul-Hus, owner of the property located at 3500 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Part of Lot 55, lying west of westerly right-of-way line of State Road A -1-A, plus the east 1- of Palm Way, lying west of and adjacent to said Lot, Gulf Stream Properties No. 2, as in Plat Book 18, Page 42, Public Records of Palm Beach County Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BLVD. OVERLAY PERMIT to allow the reconfiguration of existing driveway, construction of a fireplace and enhanced landscaping within the North Ocean Blvd. Corridor. b. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL\SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition of 32 square feet and renovation of an existing partial two story, single family dwelling of Monterey Vernacular style and the addition of an outside fireplace, reconfiguration of existing driveway and enhancement of existing landscaping. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, DECEMBER 27, 2012 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:33 A. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating III. Minutes. Chairman Morgan called the Meeting to order at Scott Morgan Malcolm Murphy Paul Lyons George Delafield Tom Smith Amanda Jones Ann Aker William Thrasher Rita Taylor John Randolph Quinn Miklos of Miklos & Associates Greg Young Rene Tercilla of Tercilla Courtemanche Peter Carney James Boyce Chairman Board Member Board Member Alt. Member sitting As Board Member Board Member Board Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent/Clippinger G.S. School Agent/G.S. School Arch. Agent/Kolea Agent/4001 N. Ocean ON Seahorse LLLC A. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing of 10-25-12. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of October 25, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. B. Joint Meeting with Town Commission of 12-14-12. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to approve the Minutes of the Joint Meeting with the Town Commission of December 14, 2012. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. January 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. Mr. Murphy asked if applications have been submitted for the January Meeting. Clerk Taylor said there will be two, possibly three Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 2 applications on the January Agenda. There were no conflicts in the Meeting Schedule. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval Chairman Morgan asked for declarations of Ex -parte communication with regard to any of the applications being heard. Chairman Morgan said he had a telephone communications with Greg Young, who will speak on behalf of Gulf Stream School, with regard to the attendance at this meeting and to set forth the itinerary of their presentation. There were no other declarations of Ex -parte communication. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to the following individuals: Quinn Miklos, Architect representing Clippinger; Greg Young representing Gulf Stream School; Joe Zelewski, Principal of Gulf Stream School; Rene Tercilla, Architect representing Gulf Stream School; Charles Frankel, former resident present on behalf of Gulf Stream School; Peter Carney, Agent for Kolea; and, James Boyce representing OK Seahorse LLLC, 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. 1. An application submitted by Quinn Miklos, Miklos & Asssoc. as Agent for Gerald & Sharon Clippinger, the owners of property located at 2538 Avenue Au Soleil, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 48 Place Au Soleil Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the extension of an existing non -conforming wall that encroaches 4.2 feet into the required 15 foot south side setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit additions consisting of bathroom, covered entry and additional living area, a net total of 716.6 square feet, to the existing one-story single family dwelling and an exterior renovation to smooth stucco with the addition of quoins on the corners. A new brick driveway will also be a part of the renovations. Quinn Miklos of Miklos & Associates introduced himself and stated that the existing structure is a brick Ranch style home consisting of 2,700 SF. He said they are proposing an addition of 1,716 SF to the existing structure and updating the style of the home to a Gulf Stream Berumda. Mr. Miklos displayed a drawing of the existing floor plan indicating the addition of square footage in both the front and rear of the home. He said the existing portion of the home was dominated by a large roof and a flying beam with the house tucked in. Mr. Miklos said in keeping with the Gulf Stream Bermuda style architecture they have created a clear center and a clearer front entry, the windows have a more symmetrical pattern and the roof will be appropriate to the neighborhood. Chairman Morgan asked if the windows will be changed. Mr. Miklos said they will be changed to a clear muttin pattern. Mr. Murphy asked if there has been feedback from neighbors. Clerk Taylor said Mr. and Mrs. Adams were in recently and had no objections and she said there has been Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 3 no other feedback. Mr. Miklos said he is a neighbor and has no objection. He said the neighbors are excited when there is any improvement to properties. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Miklos to address the requested Special Exception. Mr. Miklos said the Special Exception is for the addition of square footage which will extend an existing non- conforming wall to accommodate a new master bath. Mr. Lyons commented that it is a positive change. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend approval for a Special Exception to permit the extension of an existing non -conforming wall that encroaches 4.2' into the required 15' south side setback. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition consisting of 776.4 SF, bathroom, covered entry and additional living area patio to the existing one-story single family dwelling and an exterior renovation to smooth stucco with the addition of quoins on the corners and a new brick driveway meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 2. An Application submitted by Rene Tercilla, Tercilla Courtemanche Architects, Inc. as agent for The Gulf Stream School Foundation, Inc., owners of property located at 3600 Gulf Stream Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as a parcel of land lying in Section 3, Township 46 South, Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida. a. VARIANCE #1 to allow an increase in total floor area that will exceed the 61,737 square feet allowed in the existing Developer's Agreement by 1,617 square feet. b. VARIANCE #2 to permit an increase of 1,765 square feet over the 6,000 square feet permitted for the second floor area in the existing Developer's Agreement. C. DEMOLITION to demolish the existing one story pavilion consisting of 1,681 square feet. d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to replace and enlarge the first floor pavilion and add three second floor classrooms, an interior corridor and an exterior covered walkway and stairs, a total of 4,1875 square feet. Clerk Taylor corrected an error in the Variance 42 description on the Agenda. She said rather than an increase of 11,765 SF, it is an increase of 1,765 SF. Greg Young, representing Gulf Stream School, asked Mr. Randolph if the error occurred on information distributed for Public Notice or if it is incorrect on the Agenda only. Mr. Randolph said it did not go out in the Public Notice. Clerk Taylor said the error is on the Agenda only and not on the Staff Report. Greg Young, an Attorney with the Law Firm of Edwards, Robin and Palmer, introduced himself saying he represents Gulf Stream School. Mr. Young said he is President and Board Chairman for Gulf Stream School and a Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 4 parent of five children who have attended, or are attending, Gulf Stream School. He introduced Joe Zelewski, the head of Gulf Stream School, Rene Trecilla, a principal of Trecilla Courtemanche Architects, and Charles Frankel, a former Gulf Stream resident and former member of the ARPB. Mr. Young said Gulf Stream School, who will celebrate their 75th Anniversary next year, is a member of the National Association of Independent Schools in Washington, DC and accredited by the Florida Council of Independent Schools and Florida Kindergarten Council. He said the School operates on a No Debt Policy, they will not begin construction before paying for it, and they look forward to fundraising around it. Mr. Young said 29 families in Gulf Stream have children that attend Gulf Stream School, his family included, and they are in favor of the application before the Board. Mr. Young said the land use and zoning considerations start with the fact that the school is grandfathered non -conforming within the Town based on its location in the RS -0 district, which is residential. He said Section 70-50 of the Town's Code requires approvals for new construction, and he said there is a Developer's Agreement in place which caps the student head count at 250 and includes one-story and two- story building envelopes. He said they are not asking for an increase in enrollment and do not seek to alter the building envelopes. Mr. Young said the School approached their maximum enrollment number capped by the Town in the last seven years, but he said there is a dire need for three additional classrooms because they have had to double up in some classes in each grade level due to inadequate space. Teachers are switching classrooms and teaching in the Library and other inadequate teaching environments. Mr. Young said he is confident their application meets all variance criteria and Town Code, and he said their Architect, Rene Tercilla, will discuss their proposal and answer any questions. Rene Tercilla of Tercilla Courtemanche Architects introduced himself. He said they have done over $1 billion in educational work over the past ten years and he said in the last five to seven years teaching has become more individualized in K-12 schools. Teachers are covering the same subject at different grade levels and it creates the need for more classrooms and teaching space. Mr. Tercilla displayed a drawing of the current site, pointing out the current 1 -story open pavilion which is adjacent to the 2 -story Media Center where the Library is located, and referred to a line along the Pavilion area. He said the second level of the Developer's Agreement refers to that area and states that a second story addition is only allowed 120 feet from every property line, and he said the plans as submitted are within the Developer's Agreement area. Mr. Tercilla said what they are proposing is to take down the current pavilion, replace it with a slightly larger open-air pavilion and add a second story with an open balcony to accommodate three additional classrooms. He said the stair tower in the existing two-story Media Center will come down to be able to push the pavilion to the Media Center and the stair tower will be replaced at the end of the building. Mr. Tercilla displayed various elevations indicating the little bit of the new addition that can be seen from the front of the School property. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 5 He displayed the west elevation where the second -story addition will be visible and pointed out that the roof is lower and the massing is less than the existing two-story structure. Mr. Tercilla noted that during construction, all work vehicles will be parked on site. Mr. Lyons asked about feedback from the neighbors who may be impacted by the addition. Mr. Young said they met with Tom Stanley who lives on Oleander directly to the south, and he said the School owns the property across from Mr. Stanley. He said he has not spoken to the O'Briens, who are adjacent to the School, and they have not spoken to the family on Banyan who is from Connecticut, but he said there have been no objections from the surrounding neighbors. Mr. Delafield asked about the timing of the construction and how the School will address it from a safety perspective. Mr. Tercilla said 650 of his projects are on active campuses, but he said there is never a good time for construction on a school property. He said their intention is to begin at the start of Spring Break and the entire construction area will be fenced off so that students will not be exposed to that area when they return to class. Mr. Young said there will be no activity on the playing field during construction. In addition, he said that not only will the contractors be required to register with the Town, the School will also require vendors to certify their workers. Mr. Lyons inquired about the School's No Debt Policy and asked if the School will have capital committed prior to commencement of construction. Mr. Young explained that the School has no debt, they have cash on hand that will pay for about 500 of the structure, a healthy endowment for Pre -K through 8th Grade of $8 million and, although they do not want to draw on it, they have $2 million in reserves. He said pledges will add to their funds and they will fundraise in a fairly aggressive manner around this project. Mr. Lyons commented that he thinks this improvement will be great for the community. Chairman Morgan said the Developer's Agreement establishes the legal issue and sets forth a total allowable floor area and a total allowable 2nd floor area. He said the 2nd floor area seems to be a fairly significant increase over the Developer's Agreement of about 290, but he said it is only a couple percent over the total allowable 2nd floor square footage. Mr. Tercilla explained that the total increase is reduced by taking down the pavilion which is a first floor issue, and he is taking down a stair tower at the Media Center which is a first and second floor issue of the current building. Chairman Morgan said in keeping with the Developer's Agreement to provide for the better needs of the students, it seems the School currently has some safety issues with children moving from class to class, teachers having to relocate from class to class and in using rooms such as the Library for teaching purposes rather than Library purposes. Mr. Young said the Library is also used for 24 class instructions and study halls per week, Auxiliary Meetings, Parent Coffees, Teachers' Meetings and Board of Trustees Meetings. He said Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 6 computer labs and science labs are also being used for other class instruction. Mr. Young said there is great need for additional classroom space and also for a Learning Specialist, and he said by relocating the kitchen facility to the first floor of the new pavilion, it will create space to accommodate a learning specialist. Chairman Morgan commented that the School is taking a very reasonable approach to their needs. Chairman Morgan asked if the recommended conditions of approval are currently included in the Developer's Agreement. Mr. Thrasher said the 2nd sentence of Condition 1, which requires a yearly certification of enrollment be provided to the Town, and Conditions 4 and 5 are not included, Condition 6 was included in the 2002 Amendment to the Developer's Agreement, and he recommended adding Condition 7 requiring that the Developer's Agreement be amended to incorporate these conditions. He asked Mr. Young about the plan to require certification of construction workers. Mr. Young said there is no formal policy in place, but they want all workers entering campus to be certified that they are not on a sex offender list or any other alert list. Mr. Tercilla said he would recommend that the School follow the State of Florida and require the Jessica Lundsford Act reviews of all workers, which is a Level III background check of every worker entering the campus. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Young if he wanted to comment on the conditions of approval set forth in the Staff Report. Mr. Young said he had no comments concerning the six conditions listed in the Staff Report; however, he asked about the 7th condition which was recommended by the Town Manager. Mr. Randolph said it is just saying that the six conditions and terms of approval be incorporated within an amended Developer's Agreement. Mr. Young had no objection to Condition 7. There were no comments by the Public. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend approval of a Variance to allow an increase in total floor area that will exceed the 61,737 SF allowed in the existing Developer's Agreement by 1,617 SF. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend approval of a Variance to permit an increase of 1,765 SF over the 6,000 SF permitted for the second floor area in the existing Developer's Agreement. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend approval of demolition of the existing one-story pavilion consisting of 1.681 SF. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan to replace and enlarge the first floor pavilion and add three second floor classrooms, an interior corridor and an exterior covered walkway and stairs, a total of 4,875 SF, with the following conditions: Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 7 1. The student enrollment shall be permanently capped at 250, as limited by the existing Developer's Agreement. A yearly certification of the enrollment shall be provided the Town; 2. No additional after-hours functions shall be held at the School other than those allowed by the existing Developer's Agreement; 3. The private school campus shall not be expanded onto existing single-family lots, as dictated by RS -C and RS -O zoning district use regulations; 4. A Construction Traffic Management Plan shall be submitted prior to the issuance of a building permit application. This plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Police Chief; 5. The School shall reimburse the Town for all Town legal fees and Town advertising associated with this application; 6. The School is respectfully requested to dedicate a 9' utility easement across the entire frontage of A1A to be used exclusively for future undergrounding of power, phone and utility lines. (A long-term Town goal.); and, 7. The above -listed Conditions and figures set forth in the Variance approvals shall be incorporated into an Amended Developer's Agreement. Mr. Young asked Mr. Thrasher if the amount of legal fees have been established. Mr. Thrasher said he does not have an estimate on legal fees, but he recommended that they are not to exceed $5,000. Mr. Young had no objection. Condition #5 was amended to read: 5. The School shall reimburse the Town for all Town legal fees associated with this application, in an amount not to exceed $5,000, and for all Town advertising costs associated with this application. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. 3. An application submitted by Peter Carney as agent for James and Beverly Kolea, owners of property located at 960 Orchid Lane, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 83, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to construct a rear portico and a new front entrance to the existing one-story, single family Bermuda/British Colonial style dwelling, additions of 403 square feet. Peter Carney of Carney, Stanton in Delray Beach, Florida, introduced himself as Agent for James and Beverly Kolea. He said there have been two previous constructions on this home, one in 1963 and the last in 1985. Mr. Carney said most of the proposed work will be interior and they are proposing the addition of a rear portico to protect from direct sun and the addition of a new front entrance to their home. Mr. Lyons asked about the recommended condition of approval concerning Health Department requirements. Mr. Thrasher said sometimes the Health Department requires additional sizing on the septic tank and drain field, which at times can only be met by modifying the site plan. Mr. Carney said they are not adding a kitchen or bathroom and it is doubtful there will be an issue since they are only providing shade. Mr. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 8 Thrasher agreed. Chairman Morgan asked if they will be changing windows. Mr. Carney said they will not change them, only replace with impact. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to approve a Level II Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed rear portico and a new front entrance to the existing one-story, single- family Bermuda/British Colonial style dwelling, net additions of 403 SF meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. If the proposed site plan is altered because of the requirements of the Health Department a revised site plan will require ARPB approval. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 4. An application submitted by James Boyce of OK Seahorse LLLP as agent for OK Seahorse LLLP, owners of the property located at 4001 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Sec. 34, Township 45 South, Range 43 East in Palm Beach County. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish the existing southern most dune crossover. b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the relocation and reconstruction of the existing southern most dune crossover to a location that is 15 feet north of the south property line at the above address C. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to rebuild the southern most dune crossover in a new location that is 15 feet north of the south property line of 4001 N. Ocean Blvd. that will be the same size as the existing structure. James Boyce, representing the owner of OK Seahorse, LLLP at 4001 N. Ocean Boulevard, introduced himself. He said there are two existing beach access crossover ramps on the property, both in need of repair, and he said they are proposing to move the existing southern ramp about 28 feet to the south. Mr. Boyce explained that the purpose of doing this is because of the five new villas that will be located across the street from 4001 N. Ocean that will be allowed beach access and this will make access easier for those residents. He said this has already been approved by the Department of Environmental Protection, they want to maintain the existing Sea Grapes and the will be able to do so with this relocation of the dune crossover. Mr. Boyce said it will look similar to the crossover to be demolished, it will be taken away from the site line and hidden by the Sea Grapes and it will be done before turtle nesting season. Mr. Delafield moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend approval of a Demolition Permit. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Delafield moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception to permit construction of a dune crossover east of the Coastal Construction Control Line 1978 based on the finding that the dune crossover meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Delafield moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend approval of a Regular Meeting and Public Hearing Architectural Review and Planning Board December 27, 2012 Page 9 Level III Architectural/Site Plan to permit construction of a dune crossover structure seaward of the Coastal Construction Control Line 1978 based on the finding that the dune crossover meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. VII. Items by Staff. There were no items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. There were no items by Members of the Board. IX. Public. Martin O'Boyle of 23 Hidden Harbour Drive introduced himself, his son Jonathan and Brien Whitmore, an employee in his office. He said he has some questions concerning the Code because is upgrading his home and wants to do it right. Mr. Whitmore referred to Section 66-131(4) dealing with setbacks and requirements to extend or enlarge a non- conforming structure and asked what would qualify as an extension of a non -conforming structure. For example, he asked if it would be considered an extension if you build under an awning or roofed area. Mr. Randolph said this portion of the Meeting is for Public comment with regard to the Meeting. He said the Town Manager is the Official who is authorized to review pre -application proposals and interpret the Code. Chairman Morgan said the ARPB would be presented with applications for approval that have been previously reviewed by the Town Manager. Mr. O'Boyle said he has already addressed this with Mr. Thrasher and does not believe he can answer his questions. Chairman Morgan suggested that he meet with Mr. Thrasher to go over his proposal, and he said if Mr. Thrasher has difficulty answering your questions he will seek guidance from the Town's Consultant. Mr. O'Boyle explained that he cannot get hurricane insurance and they are trying to install hurricane impact windows prior to Hurricane Season. He said if he cannot get this done in time and incurs any damage to his home due to a storm, he will hold this Board responsible. Mr. Randolph stated that Mr. O'Boyle has a meeting scheduled with Mr. Thrasher at 2:00 P.M. this date. Mr. O'Boyle confirmed that, but he said there is a process which can take months and Hurricane Season is quickly approaching. X. Adjournment. Chairman Morgan adjourned the Meeting at 9:45 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-01 Owner: Richard G. Paul-Hus Address: 3500 N Ocean Blvd. Agent: George Brewer, Brewer Architecture, Inc. Proposed Improvement: 32 SF one-story additions to the existing partial two- story Monterey Vernacular style single family dwelling. Approvals Requested: N Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit: To allow the reconfiguration of an existing driveway, construction of a fireplace and enhanced landscaping within the North Ocean Blvd Overlay Zone. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit an addition of 32 SF and renovation of an existing partial two story, single family dwelling of Monterey Vernacular style and the addition of an outside fireplace, reconfiguration of an existing driveway that includes enhancement of existing landscape. Gross Lot Size: 10,189 SF Effective Lot Area: 10,189 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 3,301SF Allowable: 3,362 SF Zoning District: RS -C Height: 23' 10"' existing; <_ 30' Considered During Review: Section 70-74 Setbacks. Section 70-75. Special exception setbacks. Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of District Standards, (5) Entrance Gates Recommendations: Motion to approve North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit based on a finding that the proposed reconfiguration of an existing driveway, construction of a fireplace and enhanced landscaping within the North Ocean Blvd Overlay zone meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. Motion to approve Level II Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition of 32 SF and renovation of an existing partial two story, single family dwelling of Monterey Vernacular style and the addition of an outside fireplace, reconfiguration of an existing driveway that includes enhancement of existing landscape meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: January 24, 2013 Action: North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Permit: Approved as requested. (4-0) Action: Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review: Approved as requested. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ► RECEIVED q •> • ` � DEC 2 6 2012 'Y Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File #-13-1 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name::iz\ I.A.2. Project Address-. QC_U ex I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: ��I-, OF [.p l� 5 L `�i� � SEs � D l— -4o L) S %y 0 ��LA X04-1 Jac a I° 4z I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) f-&_ WV '4 i (fes' C t 4—) I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition:77- Architectural ZArchitectural Style: 1.A.6. Check all that apply: B�Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing R"'North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) 0 Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: Type of Foundation:CISI� B. Owner Information �p I.B.1. Owner Address: 21 c'( N J z> I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: n(p� —��'-i�(o% Fax: I.B.3. Owner Signature:__ C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: �c Dl��j� ��t,���� 9,c�J_,�� L, _ Q_c I.C.2. Agent Address; C/h �j. L �'� ��L �%� 3�- �L CJ I.C.3. Agent Phone Numbe : ) 26: j• 2TZ • ZOO 1 cell .5C (- 70& Fax �C9( 27L- 37z Z 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: I Z -'5 • Zp1Z App Date: Com Date: � Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: 1- 2.,q -1a_ Recommendation: .N-1s- Recommendation: TC Date: 'f 20-0 4-4 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ? (5) No Explain: mp 4r5N) el C?g III.A.3. Is the project consistent w' the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? es No Explain: No C•I-R-iJgc� III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? 6A )4 �jlto& -Jo-1 r A-►19- III.A.5. a. b. e. f. 9. h. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? Stormwater Drainage C1S I Sanitary Sewer _ 6kt S i . Potable wE Irrigation V Electricity Telephone Gas Cable Television��i�rj ��% L) Z-1X01.7ki� III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project in a land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes No (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) (�F IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an exist' vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the proms at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes (Nq/ (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page February 2002 76.vn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? P&-"7 I M aFl� IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: ► 1► ►LR ► 3C�L� o� IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes (�9) Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? /`!t IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? ��Zp IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? IV/ D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 561-737-0188 Line Tdwn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: _ — lV.13.3_ Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the Al A Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What.mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least Impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:. 'C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit MCA. When are the existing structures to be demolished? I v I Pr IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? 312-01-3 IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? r-4 1 A— D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit .IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:� i IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removallrelocation: N IA IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: P IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land.clearhg and constriction activities and thereafter? (f IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 0 4 Goo olc earth �% all ................... F3 ���� f�� ���� �% .- ��` I I •l IIIc ••. ......__... Iry \' y�. iii • • y ` ___- _ � � � ' ` ,7 � `'� .. .,� _ .. ________ ____ •,` ` Y \' +\_fie ���_. .S.S _ _��•�.: i .K __ - / • I' M Imo.• I I +i I', 1 I' 7� I_ N OO `21' SS” W 141.27' PALM WAYS -� ■ Mae � ii Ma ��E, I 20, 7 _ .1 ,W I - r \/ Z40 4 1,9,2 18.2 ITS \. M yj o � r cA = oo' CD to 93— n s 3 3 m z y s m <m iD g in' n CD A — -a -u -a CL 05 9 * * n n —I m vn o rn n N0, a c 1]1 i m 11 w o- CL O o a a CD w > U) v m 1 = <'Qi " � 3 � (D 0.=dc41 =1`=m <=o-0 0 CD r c >dc m 0 (D m p R- O 00� <� f N (D O Z z m o ,i 0 r �. V m � m m o` m 0 0 < p I< cl'Ii II „ 11 (p (OD II II II 'rm F. n N o O o CD 0 m 0 0 0 CL --4��mmr.S2 SU 'r e su m _ � o w 3 ch, U CD.c m m O O cn m v 2 CL o O d m N N y m Iz Q0s 0 ami w (D 3 3 is c -n Ln rnImrn �cco((DA °aoo iaP<o i =om vm,oa 3�ao Z-44 or-OO� sy mtZn irzn� mmy °�y yi °o amo �o y:0 yA� moa mo= cp yF-° mnZ -ts m -Cid �'-� omm tom i ��a Baa o mmo m m ��m c ern to oa y a �cm F- :v OC) rh2 amok sm �r"'� m oy m� 3y y�usi � ma ay mZ mo c � s S � or v7Oc�r�mtQ-o 370 II � -� 11 II 11 ■ II _'S m II II 3 n o m II s II 7 (D 4• w �cn 3= $ (D ° m (° n m r (D �. �w3 1 � !"0mc)Ov7D-w NW 3 7 (- 11 II � n 3 m o 3 0' o II 11 ° CL w ° II — II II O m n, -•� O A A)O (D y c m 0 � fD n w 3 m 3 r j W y (n 7 CD en W r — -a -u -a �D 9 * * n n —I m vn o 'r v T1 7 - I I II ci 11 fA . II It o 0 II i m 11 w o- A n o o m 0.— SOP - CD w > m 1 = <'Qi " � 3 � ?5D =1`=m <=o-0 0 CD r c m 0 (D m p R- O wm <� $s Z m 0 � r n v mTmi� 1 u ao p I< cl'Ii II „ 11 (p (OD II II II 'rm F. n N N CD =r 3mwa(a'v� �' oto N 1v m 6 w _0) o w -m d Oa CL --4��mmr.S2 SU 'r e su o w 3 ch, U CD.c m m °aoo iaP<o i =om vm,oa 3�ao Z-44 or-OO� sy mtZn irzn� mmy °�y yi °o amo �o y:0 yA� moa mo= cp yF-° mnZ -ts m -Cid �'-� omm tom i ��a Baa o mmo m m ��m c ern to oa y a �cm F- :v OC) rh2 amok sm �r"'� m oy m� 3y y�usi � ma ay mZ mo c � s S � or v7Oc�r�mtQ-o 370 II � -� 11 II 11 ■ II _'S m II II 3 n o m II s II 7 (D 4• w �cn 3= $ (D ° m (° n m r (D �. �w3 1 � !"0mc)Ov7D-w NW 3 7 (- 11 II � n 3 m o 3 0' o II 11 ° CL w ° II — II II O m n, -•� O A A)O (D y c m 0 � fD n w 3 m 3 r j W y (n 7 CD en W 1► 0 z m o 0 m ro C= s m 0 ;a X -4 a° IC O mgr aw c is N � � rr WzZ _r00 n rn(A� 0-4-4 000 a°,a_ ovAa $> ca m WMr;- �z� =O5 4 0a Zoo rn 40. Oce —mi Ln z �CAm D � rn 3a Urn Om m0 1v to -L Z;6 0-0 Zm r m r m X z C4 0 Z 0 Er 2. n N m 1► 0 z m o 0 m ro C= s m 0 ;a X -4 a° IC O mgr aw c is N � � rr WzZ _r00 n rn(A� 0-4-4 000 a°,a_ ovAa $> ca m WMr;- �z� =O5 4 0a Zoo rn 40. Oce —mi Ln z �CAm D � rn 3a Urn Om m0 1v to -L Z;6 0-0 Zm r m r m X z z 0 0 N In I<n G -P N J T a mN � xo A■ PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE FDm nm RESIDENTIAL REMODEL � • m 3500 N OCEAN BLVD " N N r n V Wm C GULF STREAM, FL ;No wm rAi® C i.. z � v fA O ,C m C m C �% `0 N o CD z 0 0 N In I<n G -P N J T a mN � xo A■ PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE FDm nm RESIDENTIAL REMODEL � • m 3500 N OCEAN BLVD " N N r n V Wm C GULF STREAM, FL ;No wm rAi® MA zl N "T7 / i i 1 1 l 20'RAV ti 1 �xzzz ~>1 V� ti712�t. 11 A a '„=r� a O � t R t � 7 d v Ot DD n D j'Yp- EH Itxun. 4 yRl l� < <O< En t11 tit N Ii O OODD AE p� Otho 0 ti D 1ji>' < RI mDT c Y tt7A / M / it z m I / r z v n A y on o � / o / O / / K YS / O I 0 / Z I / m D W / 0 / .Nn m / ;101 I / 7 n 0 /1 r / m N N N N N N N N N I 0 r / mLn / I Ln / / I I / / 1 / � MZ z IV ® �_ r w CO) m —1 MA zl N "T7 / i i 1 1 l 20'RAV ti 1 A� EAT ° 3 wfvN nt-Di f YRMI El r rZ DtiZO M r D r A�1Em A_ OppA, rn m�r N V N Lei O m s o m Q N n z y O 11 oa �o °o '— —7— I � S8`► 23'25" E 86.63 �xzzz ~>1 V� ti712�t. 11 A a '„=r� ti yyy � ti ti wr n t R t � 7 d v Ot DD n D j'Yp- EH Itxun. 4 yRl l� < <O< En t11 tit N Ii O OODD A� EAT ° 3 wfvN nt-Di f YRMI El r rZ DtiZO M r D r A�1Em A_ OppA, rn m�r N V N Lei O m s o m Q N n z y O 11 oa �o °o '— —7— I � S8`► 23'25" E 86.63 P J !F!P ►JON MUM V Vno�Tyg4R�'��ihHnfiA� .Wy; PMHEPIWAP J gyp giL /sg mmy g� (1O ��7 Qy, 6 7J1L gil�Pg E�ji PRO TP T D am- i6 j< zz4 19 (1'.3.30° �AD ~1D Z Rae6 Q 9 M1M1 ffli _m2 a�I- Sl m D j1 Aim g ° ° a m Lgg � nR� 'd y m' �OygA��n����$��g�p�m}�iA�m AA iiiiiKK----- 33333 22 p @4@4 a N j o g €� � DIlipM m9ReR�� ATMP°" 301i ii pi � v 0R9 ¢Q17(lymi�€i §p= 8 4� a n Ami Oj Q kO� �'y ZP;°yw ITj A iiTT11�Aj1 fii tltlri g i �0? W4 R P 8 9_R �Pn U NR Ail€ 2�i�gy O°ZZ 'd'tU yl z M F- r Z O m T �xzzz ~>1 V� ° 11 A x=z PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE� RESIDENTIAL REMODEL 0� 3500 N OCEAN BLVD m .. r' wm c GULF STREAM. FL o N 2 "c A °N� wm m ti yyy � ti ti � C d v Ot DD n D zOS v D < <O< En t11 tit N Ii O OODD AE p� Otho 0 ti D 1ji>' < RI mDT Y tt7A O PDD N it z m z v n A y on K YS 0 m D W .Nn 0 N N N N N N N N N N N N P J !F!P ►JON MUM V Vno�Tyg4R�'��ihHnfiA� .Wy; PMHEPIWAP J gyp giL /sg mmy g� (1O ��7 Qy, 6 7J1L gil�Pg E�ji PRO TP T D am- i6 j< zz4 19 (1'.3.30° �AD ~1D Z Rae6 Q 9 M1M1 ffli _m2 a�I- Sl m D j1 Aim g ° ° a m Lgg � nR� 'd y m' �OygA��n����$��g�p�m}�iA�m AA iiiiiKK----- 33333 22 p @4@4 a N j o g €� � DIlipM m9ReR�� ATMP°" 301i ii pi � v 0R9 ¢Q17(lymi�€i §p= 8 4� a n Ami Oj Q kO� �'y ZP;°yw ITj A iiTT11�Aj1 fii tltlri g i �0? W4 R P 8 9_R �Pn U NR Ail€ 2�i�gy O°ZZ 'd'tU yl z M F- r Z O m T X 2 ° 11 A x=z PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE� RESIDENTIAL REMODEL 0� 3500 N OCEAN BLVD m .. r' wm c GULF STREAM. FL o N 2 "c A °N� wm m n r I r -x FD o m� N ® ® a o PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE Dx= Km =�� RESIDENTIAL REMODEL ITT - ISI ■ 3500 N OCEAN BLVD N N L m GULF STREAM, FL ^Nw A= A® .N2 wm m m-----------� B Z J � C IV, aOo I A O IE ON m m D oma I _ LA FD o m� N ® ® a o PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE Dx= Km =�� RESIDENTIAL REMODEL ITT - ISI ■ 3500 N OCEAN BLVD N N L m GULF STREAM, FL ^Nw A= A® .N2 wm m m-----------� N D C IV, I O r -x n p� m Z 2 � IE ON m m D oma I _ FD o m� N ® ® a a Lo PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE Dx= Km =�� RESIDENTIAL REMODEL ITT - ISI ■ 3500 N OCEAN BLVD N N L m GULF STREAM, FL ^Nw A= A® .N2 wm m INu m r X r X r X m X m X -� ~ Fp mp 0� W y J -A u y B Z B Q~ W Z h Q w O Z \ 'h O m mm O O IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII CIIO IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII M\ rXrX V I I I I!!!! I I I I! I! I I I! I "m rZX 'ooO Z e' -I" 6'-6'• = A ip op 3Zr j 0 y 0 B o Ax Cu -1 I� IIIIIIIIIIIIIilillllllllll D 3 T Av � 1119111111111 mm, r 0 Om IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII CI_I� IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 1 1 N X 3mN COCNS m�p0 M\ rXrX N3 r 0 B 8 B'-0" MITI mm rX III "m rZX 'ooO Z e' -I" 6'-6'• = A ip op 3Zr j 0 y 0 B o Ax Cu -1 O pNNI D 3 T Av v - mm, r 0 Om r 00 v ? 0 A 3 A 8 (�18mOA Vo ITT A I �1 Illlllllilllllll I I I I�III CSI � I I Iilllllillllllll I �I I I I oI I I I I I Tam �mX QAN -q Fffll � mr RM yn m zmA / � mm m n n N X 3mN COCNS m�p0 M\ rXrX N3 r 0 B 8 B'-0" MITI mm rX III "m rZX 'ooO Z e' -I" 6'-6'• = A ip op 3Zr j 0 y 0 B o Ax Cu -1 O pNNI D 3 T Av v - mm, r 0 Om r 00 v ? 0 A 3 A 8 (�18mOA Vo ITT A I Z, OLX UO_ O (n w y m 'q O v ,'0 c�, m 0 C rn N � 1 „ (D O � N E —r1 A ND m N N3 r 0 B 8 mm A ao 'ooO Z e' -I" 6'-6'• = A rX III-zx 3Zr j 0 y 0 B o Ax Cu -1 0 X74 pNNI �m Z, OLX UO_ O (n w y m 'q O v ,'0 c�, m 0 C rn N � 1 „ (D O � N E —r1 A ND I N3 Amm B 8 mm A 'ooO Z e' -I" 6'-6'• = vl rX III-zx y j 0 y 0 B T 0 -4 Z Cu -1 0 X74 3 1 W 1 �m FL ;Ns wm m - r 00 v T A ` ITT III I �1 y I I I I I I I I I �I I I I oI I I I I I Tam �mX QAN -q Fffll � mr RM yn m zmA m�0 mm m n mX mm X -Di z m _ B O0 ul A Z, OLX UO_ O (n w y m 'q O v ,'0 c�, m 0 C rn N � 1 „ (D O � N E —r1 A ND I N3 m B 8 mm 8'-e" X 'ooO Z e' -I" 6'-6'• r ONS -�1rX D m <m n a RESIDENTIAL REMODEL = U m == m • ■ rX III-zx rx�m III rX j 0 y 0 B T 0 -4 Z Cu -1 0 X74 3 1 W 1 �m FL ;Ns wm m - r 00 v T A ` ITT III �1 O� I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I V o I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I N3 m B 8 xo rN A■V' PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE 'ooO Z N ul D m <m n a RESIDENTIAL REMODEL = U m == m • ■ a .. 3500 N OCEAN BLVD NN w< I GULF STREAM, 0 w >_ FL ;Ns wm m M11111110 0 C 'r zCOO 70 nO m c n O a C5 CO) m q mm r X G)Om (P 0rp z _I G n o m➢G-) a p . A I I I I 4G I I I I I 6 PR I I 1 rm I 610 I 1 0' I m I I I � I m I ' I I I AX I®' 0 n 4 m 111 III � 111 111 zN II LLQ--------- m X O 111 x nA mzo N N o + az W m .r 0< 0< OZ0� p 3 Gl c WZ w w O m Ln AO AX I®' 0 n 4 m 111 III � 111 111 zN II LLQ--------- 111 x nA mzo N o + O 9 v c> n n � � C= m k `' zN F m Ax= PAUL-HUS RESIDENCE m RESIDENTIAL REMODEL A m 101 Ty m 3500 N OCEAN BLVD n GULF STREAM, FL m® 1 I� �I II II II II II II II II II II I I II II I� II II I II II I� II II II II II I II II I� II II II II II II II I II II II I II II II II II I� II II I II II II II II I� II II II I I I III II ------11 L- II II II II it II II II II II II II II II II II II II II II II II I� II Q C'I1�1 m()'UD -0�o mo�3D COO Nmo �L "® m z�0 AXEZ �® m AZZO gT ® ® OW� w � p00 mDN AZ NAD zn'�ZKT,yD3A an "= -E mNOiONmD AmOOp=x Uti<zNmm8 AAaA®m,-i0 EtAADOO c'TI:A NTZD�AAA ti AZmn>�0 oOMD() NA mr �O.UG•n0 N NEOml v oo � 0 ` , rn C � N m x �gp3A8vmlu a� rail L�mZ DmDf 6()F DA mmm m (P 1> yy Am D � 1 oz 3 PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE A➢ Km ' �° O 3 m T v Axz N n■ L. N RESIDENTIAL REMODEL = _U �_ _� • N 3500 N OCEAN BLVD A N N wm X GULF STREAM, FL o "�H� ' >_ wm m ENz 0z (A - E (P ti A my �bam flu -13 uj =�Oz -0, O p F— m X r X r X r X r X �. T W .-NI l➢ ti � N W N O z 0 0 w z A O 0 r \ ` z \ \ O m mmD A O Em zjj E -fK 4 3 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII' .M w ■;■ Gam' IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII uuumnum IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII. c Is I m m N ~ X� m 0 T 6z r0 �� N A1XE 0D IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII! IIIIIIIAillllll'. IIIIIIIIillll 1111111111111 1111111111111 1111111111111 'r fn�. 1 1 1 nn r monm E 3 0mmm A (000 N �NnN (1 0 FF D m A RE OD n 3 O =Z m� mr O Z!Z m —., G G-) c N CD w ,L0 l Vm cn P -o C O m 41. a 00 m 03 D_ Z OD 7d o y� �I z z r 0 >m 3 D_ OZ Z o m AOO nn �mm O m-nim X O00 M �~ r c m m 0 A Z3 DmE O A xjZA -(3mD LN OA�O y�Or DNr= rA�y 2;m c Is I m m N ~ X� m 0 T 6z r0 �� N A1XE 0D F: } T77 ! ( A yZ O N 'r fn�. m >0 1-0-nW nn r I V, m 4 q, o z cmE n nZE O6zz NNO AN D_ 0Z g=X Om(P aDn' Em v E E3 ND ym m X A 0 i F mE3z ME XjZA -(3mD om�m A (P 00, z 0 N jNnN E y14M TFrX DNDa no,n'2 O O n n�nAz m y m_Dr= � m i�oyyo ti 'm0 Aim zCCD X� m mAmm r0 y 0 N A1XE 0D F: } T77 ! ( A yZ O N 'r RESIDENTIAL REMODEL =o m m == m ' nm m nn Lz I O�O M Xz! GULF STREAM, FL N o m= m® A �Dm N �m N Ny= OD TFrX DNDa no,n'2 O O n n�nAz m y m_Dr= � m i�oyyo ti 'm0 Aim n� o rX rX riX rX r0 y 0 N N_N J N ~ W F: } T77 ! rz A N 'r RESIDENTIAL REMODEL =o m m == m ' m my n� o 0 a PAUL—HUS RESIDENCE £ n m� 0 mxz rm ;n s ' m F: } T77 ! O N A RESIDENTIAL REMODEL =o m m == m ' r 3500 N OCEAN BLVD ANN w< c GULF STREAM, FL N o m= m® 0 z n n D T wo 0 m 0 m x O A y PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE � 0 z -0� K -4z m 41. O coo Z !� m bmn ON 3500 N OCEAN BLVD m w V Z :L � o m i z n Do 9 T @ � C-) 0 D o O D T cl) m �1 CD ov o 03 =3' v 0 z n n D T wo 0 m 0 m x O A y PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE � 0 z -0� K -4z m 41. O 3�c m-Oo m bmn ON 3500 N OCEAN BLVD m w V z :L � o m i z n =rb0 @ � ��I11 (P (P 0 D O D T 0 m 0 m x O A y PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE � 0 K 41. RESIDENTIAL REMODEL m m =� m• _ m ON 3500 N OCEAN BLVD m w V wm c: GULF STREAM, FL w <= A® RNs w� m x H o 5d o �p r oA PROJECT: PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DATE -2BY12 REtR0toNt�: MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT D I > " DRAWN M. FAY D 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. p rn C O Fn OULFSTREM, FLORIDA x� D 420 N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 HE DY: x 0 ~ D OF CAD �° r a rnOo to (n A a m om Jm-p J OD T -•JN Nm� W A'�N / F� - RCgD > m F. � 2 � �_ � A g A g �� c - z > z z c ry iv - px� F, 0 54 \ D mN Z NO y m y mn w C �m fz�l O m F vq N 15 Mn 2 -0 2 0 -0 _ r �-0O o 2 m rm G) Vl N C-) D Z (Dl m S Z x C{] O D Z m ,< O c C -O( O C O A "Z7 < �� x w p m AC Z (n N m m x � r 1* dx z z x 2 O O m + v s z ➢Z So ➢ N > c 0 mrmr0 DOmm 31 F.< p 0 .SAAn 00 GJ�x0-0 m0> r D m DAM A s 12 Cm1 K>m p + V N f+�1 O D C D O A m D m n IZTI O -1 .Z-7 Dc m m D M C fm"' N z C o TI C m m D n z L O z D > r -+ -i O Cn x r + N D A mm Z] c nlnD T. O N D' �r n m O2� Z m G D � D m r Z D m D (n O In D z C _ D D C 0 X mZ> (n 0 No..D-i1n m D o N 0 0 s �In s J Z D D O C m O D O N / t D L + A m xM ➢ ' m u0. p9 I C m A m m O I O Mx m g� N o I K D D - % - m 0 O M N 00 r z ' xm�ti 0 p O m ;a O D m r Z Z -xi D G7 m0 �D D o> >> m m Dm coo{3 0 >0>m -I MO !n z D C Z D V Tl Z m 0 Mx D `r c m m � C 5D i n D m z O o m M 2O N 22 m v D x c 0 r— z�mm 1— C DDDD w W WJ �W� (n -' (T r� x Z (n f r r r p W G7 G7 O O O 0 m lr,l O m N D W p DDD r f- t- n a r D 0 D I O r - D: r r x 1O cn> v I m . I • I I D m m A M OON I O 00 rn N,r J M p N ADDD O?U (n O DD O V1 V m k N -Np O D D p ? m m D N m m r m m D + o ul r _ � 0 Z Z Z{ Z{ Z Z Z Z Z{ Z Z Z Z Z Z G O O N O N 0 0 0 0 O N O O O O O < M x H o 5d o r oA PROJECT: PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DATE -2BY12 REtR0toNt�: MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT D I > " DRAWN M. FAY 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. T> p Fn OULFSTREM, FLORIDA x� D 420 N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 HE DY: x 0 ~ PH. 561-306-4003 OF CAD �° im m a LANDSCAPE PLAN z a m om / F� - RCgD > m F. � �_ � A g A g �� c - z > z z c ry iv - px� F, 54 \ D mN i O NO y m y s x g� RD z - - Z maz alta A > s � m. D> suziz I >- A _> ~ Z 7) o y C C A ➢ O / I> m yy A > 2 O O > + v s z ➢Z So ➢ ➢ !� I > s + O A s 12 D + V + z A I� m a I I 1 p I I + i I I 1I C + G D � 2 m A _ 0 0 s I C m� s J m O D O N / t D L + A m xM ➢ ' m u0. p9 I C m A m m � � n I I 1 1 m g� N I D D - % - ' r z ' xm�ti 0 m N O Fs a 8 + m> - m - D O + OA p� 86.63 �R �F F- c: WO 2 D L7 N- r r>- -0 NDCO O�G�(nD D r0> =�m02 D-Drlr �mZmOm�rn Z{zZ,X0 >F6z:w-u><D' z P„ Z OmrpZDZ1 �� ZON DZNO m-iw�ZmZ DND Vl Nm��lO-I=-IZO-O d N"m0 2 D m O< D r S- OC)� 0;C1m �]�' rG�D�ONZDr N p> z C O m D m m m D r N m O A- D n r UO Z O -n-I r m O Z �N Om 7CD r ZN-ICOM DDL�UI-I n -*, VD10 �N Dm �m 2=�Z m�?OI {r �i �JOZM --A �— 0�m��DOD OCA-K:ol moo ���NNrITip ON�Oxn 000=C �A Frl 0* ?n00:::i M i�� v�im ���{O m�tn�<m c- M I -A F-1 -C) <N-(nD 0O� fn-��' �rrrl X10 r - Do z0 -MMMN OD Nm0O�V<, AN{ mW00(n 0 mL" IS*, SAO r�CAXrfO*lz m'Orz-iz-NIDD ➢�= mS0 rr-C�Dm LCl�zO mZm=NZDm <��m�Ozpr 0 z DCmo -Imrm :Or VIZ O rDNG) r M_ ;u >O' i"<�,N m D 0{r V)N--2DD�n rr DNS DO,vlm Om r �(�orZ�O{ �Oz{>-Mj�OZ Zm C�m ��-D-Im� {D N �0.1mW 002 OmO�1Nr,= N�.ZOJ Ko Crim �m�m� z -i �A �� 2m2 -nm D = n p m -I �,� -I- (n O m D<2�7 cn Drr mA r f'Im02. CS OZr 22';D mm 0>N { m D Z0m1 Zm "ZI-mr Zm0 22 mN - NU/ 0m > Acm �r (nZ 1- mcm rr mfr*, -UO (n z z r0 x �Z �O Z 02 N DI,=j m nn , m �mF 0 o n x O TIU1 X0 (n T1 D Nm-{ Opc) -0Da � 00 -C n O O Cil D m D 0 AIIFAY, A.�.L.A. RED. N0, 640 DATE: PROJECT: PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DATE -2BY12 REtR0toNt�: MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT LANDSCAPE ARdHTTEdT:dHADL DRAWN M. FAY 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. REG.# 540 OULFSTREM, FLORIDA 420 N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 HE DY: x 0 ~ PH. 561-306-4003 CAD �° LANDSCAPE PLAN AIIFAY, A.�.L.A. RED. N0, 640 DATE: R � ��� NMI �ssAq� P»g $ � >?i' iiM5,; c v yyyb>^ y i aMHtjFj M<'OM� _ 9 G� o� s� s Fp ti a all 'I �x� ;mom€p` M94 ^�g g �- - g � >26- ; g � -N-. �g, 0 .4 Rd, W �� � m pig 1g P. gg $"4R p22 gig ' m4 $n�a�^ mo �-8F $�>-Li�'x=R g- $_� mMad Elul A; .12 g?� U F AOx^� �_�� gp=F�g�sQ� mm .p� y see�PO�F= V.&_ > y�=$ $��>m ka' �aR MgpYI>`F F $� wA� $m }om O 4— tn4N� > 3rin vac " i, �2>r� _� oo4s�' $ F om gm�� b ;N,»qs� 9. sg3 d� oo fY$ R $;� Y69 $m 9$ €z 9y OWN mgt >��i xGy� s N o � � rn H. > F ��" i� x �a -� n� oo� o� m �i oS�m >A m m� > o'^ ' y i9-RgFjvft=loi m-Aoq C.?.gmm-22 mm<Fg mi a z22>.9"4 1 >y q �S"� �mxFp�om' r �"gS�°c�e 4m 'off (R� �yaF4�FAgym m��_� N.A� Fn _$ > m g�€ LF gg A; > v7 1-Vgu y €' > 7s�"' >$ y q&."��m yiT• ted F _F�GgQBo�� o$ � ick >�PS N4 .�Fg'm^mF�gF gm$=`�-$ �y2�$ o$M y �' " s g> 4'' y�4z'm"gn �. oxo 0,9o>%�. "s ��m A �g s� aQmg mm -�� _t Rl lip A m8TA��; $ �m y�cnn dci b�_ �"= K �L ����> S S ��8� L9-�C1m �i g Amo �� �� m �mT g9�=y; �i��x>y^g�9��m Q Y65 K ' sm > ulgx $ > > 126Am A- W-,lt"-I' o "m�Riffin qm�op<' S'�y m�F 2 59 R 9T FA=mss�` gmmE �mg gF K " F s ;$F o A id c w _ PROJECT: TI DA'T'E: MOONS: 12-24-12 Lp�D OdAPE ARcx�r C^P �- MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT MldaAM FAY, a q iA, PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DRA s BY: Rte• No, 640 REG.# 540 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. M. FAY DAM 420 $ O y n ml $U, FLORIDA dBEOM BY: N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 o ny PH. 561-306-4003 KFS. > O " �a o" = m$ i > XI m oP >7K=m G1 rg �CC7 ; o ig �0 rR o I$sm a� 9$ � tiM S 5 yy m y O € >l ; ASS ig Eli 0 O G7 c N CD PROJECT: TI DA'T'E: MOONS: 12-24-12 Lp�D OdAPE ARcx�r C^P �- MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT MldaAM FAY, a q iA, PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DRA s BY: Rte• No, 640 REG.# 540 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. M. FAY DAM 420 $ x0 FLORIDA dBEOM BY: N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 o ny PH. 561-306-4003 > O " O G7 c N CD C7 m fid I� to C= rArA Q C r0 �Z m0 3n Fm m F_ D Z -_I Z c� 0 m D r ^_ >00- @off_ ;; x Offjj7 g� F F � � oaF A �F� Egg nflm 3o<vai a'as $No o ti zo i �y El VA -11008p "$ $ ayo=o>VgRUI<or�oEa> HOC"! 0=lRARA W-% omgF >n = g�1 Lem Ul > � g;�_ y2 2lip Qykg=AE P��ofQ N u=i -ly ink, �myi�z ggm�i m�aa "'d>Pno.'4 rmocs ggxm�4yos���"P$ocgF' m �qm AM T ' F�T� 99^22g "Hin"ll U,WgIN !14, o-�ogot %gh- MTH ale gg'oAg Flso= m9�� �Rg� � o�n�"=' ��yN � � �28F§imm 9di-n� F� ,y 9F ;F> [�6m € »gS3r2S F,�m LTA OyS I`I�FJ �ICOOC m F2 F M Mn mFF c D ��€F o 128 0 D o mgr r g N ;q ging �� pp = P-1�A rii aM So Z i, �' O T 4a - m p Fg9 z1Nm cn N AM < a3i- In T Ai Nm mg SEP izF � z� u RNA AOL 0 EirR R. �55 D z D D 0 m O I -T1 C� PROJECT: TI DA'T'E: MOONS: 12-24-12 Lp�D OdAPE ARcx�r C^P �- MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT MldaAM FAY, a q iA, PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DRA s BY: Rte• No, 640 REG.# 540 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. M. FAY DAM 420 $ x0 FLORIDA dBEOM BY: N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 o ny PH. 561-306-4003 C7 m fid I� to C= rArA Q C r0 �Z m0 3n Fm m F_ D Z -_I Z c� 0 m D r ^_ >00- @off_ ;; x Offjj7 g� F F � � oaF A �F� Egg nflm 3o<vai a'as $No o ti zo i �y El VA -11008p "$ $ ayo=o>VgRUI<or�oEa> HOC"! 0=lRARA W-% omgF >n = g�1 Lem Ul > � g;�_ y2 2lip Qykg=AE P��ofQ N u=i -ly ink, �myi�z ggm�i m�aa "'d>Pno.'4 rmocs ggxm�4yos���"P$ocgF' m �qm AM T ' F�T� 99^22g "Hin"ll U,WgIN !14, o-�ogot %gh- MTH ale gg'oAg Flso= m9�� �Rg� � o�n�"=' ��yN � � �28F§imm 9di-n� F� ,y 9F ;F> [�6m € »gS3r2S F,�m LTA OyS I`I�FJ �ICOOC m F2 F M Mn mFF c D ��€F o 128 0 D o mgr r g N ;q ging �� pp = P-1�A rii aM So Z i, �' O T 4a - m p Fg9 z1Nm cn N AM < a3i- In T Ai Nm mg SEP izF � z� u RNA AOL 0 EirR R. �55 D z D D 0 m O I -T1 C� PROJECT: TI DA'T'E: MOONS: 12-24-12 Lp�D OdAPE ARcx�r C^P �- MICHAEL FAY: LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT MldaAM FAY, a q iA, PAUL -HUS RESIDENCE DRA s BY: Rte• No, 640 REG.# 540 3500 N. OCEAN BLVD. M. FAY DAM 420 NGULFSTREM, FLORIDA dBEOM BY: N.W. 7th ST., DELRAY BCH., FL., 33444 o PH. 561-306-4003 LANDSCAPE DETAILS AND SPECS. FM - TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-02 Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Address: 1275 North Ocean Blvd. Agent: Seaside Builders, LLC Proposed Improvement: Construction of a partial two story single family Bermuda style dwelling, dune crossover, outdoor pavilion and swimming pool. Approvals Requested: Demolition Permit: To remove existing structure. Land Clearing Permit: To clear building site and re-arrange/remove existing landscape materials. N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To supplement existing landscaping and install rail fence and entrance gate. Special Exception (1): To allow 300 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum floor area permitted. Special Exception (2): To permit construction of a dune crossover. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of 11,566 SF Bermuda style, single family, partial 2 -story dwelling with guest quarters, attached 3 car garage, outdoor pavilion and swimming pool and dune crossover. Gross Lot size: 76,672 SF Effective Lot Area: 43,331 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 11,266 SF Allowable: 11,566 SF (With Special Exception) Zoning District: RS -B Height: 33' 7" (roof height <_ 35' Preferred) Finished Floor: 18.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-02 ARPB January 24, 2013; TC February 8, 2013 Page 2 Motion to recommend approval of demolition permit to remove existing structure. Motion to recommend approval of land clearing permit to clear building site and re- arrange/remove existing landscape materials. Motion to recommend approval of a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to supplement existing landscaping and install a rail fence and entrance gate. Motion to recommend approval of a Special Exception to allow 300 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum floor area permitted. Motion to recommend approval of a Special Exception to permit construction of a dune crossover. Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed construction of 11,566 SF Bermuda style, single family, partial 2 -story dwelling with guest quarters, attached 3 car garage, outdoor pavilion and swimming pool and dune crossover meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions 1. The electric service lines shall be buried. 2. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 3. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 4. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. 5. The landscape plan will protect existing Australian pine trees and provide a 13' clear zone from white travel line where possible allowing for the planting by the Town of two - ten Australian pine trees. ARPB Date: January 24, 2013 Action: Demolition Permit: Recommend approval. (4-0) Land Clearing Permit: Recommend approval. (4-0) North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Recommend approval. (4-0) Special Exception (1): Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Special Exception (2): Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval with the 5 above conditions and provided the two chimney heights will each be lowered by 16" and a construction parking plan will be coordinated with the Town of Gulf Stream and the Gulf Stream Police Department. (4-0) TC Date: February 8, 2013 Action: Demolition Permit: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Land Clearing Permit: Approved as recommended. (5-0) North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Special Exception (1): Approved as recommended. (5-0) Special Exception (2): Approved as recommended. (5-0) Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Approved with the 6 recommended conditions with the exception of the portion related to a parking plan inasmuch as this was already worked out. (5-0) O 0 0 M —lrs -U� m�cn zm — r co =mD m ^ pcn Z `/ =m r D po = m I OZF Nil mm Z C Ji Z mD�c�n \ v ? A m 00 CA) XlI O 0 0 TDrm O C -U� '-" 1 ❑ tummy — r mr55❑ T chb 0 M cmn Z v,0M = m x rn (JIM c: C Ji Z A CA Cn :::i \ cowCM (.0 m CF) A m c XlI m .71 K) m M z 0 TDrm O C -U� Xmr`N°❑ U�ODM — r znU7 0U3c0 /� 0 rn_OWmG) o NmDzz Z �_❑� D = m C31-- n rn rn (JIM c: (A � C > Z iv1Dcnmz M cn�mm cj' m ^Z^ XlI D rr O < �' rl -U� O X z O znU7 0U3c0 /� 0 Z o 0m C M mD1.nzMM D O W = m z v0, 0 rn (JIM c: m o ^ `>+ iv1Dcnmz M (� 6 w < w D0 0 n n 1 is m- M .71 M m O -o m m M fn z-+ Z1 m ;uD 0000 mm m C �A CnD AZO c mrncommcnm Z OO mm -1m 0 11 u3 En Cncn nD mm � x0 N 4m ==mco 11 nn ZCi u, v, o R ;K cn N o N m � _ In mz2�;am -0 AOOc cmOoDOO ==0 (n --I M v_)v_nmLnmcnm m m m n D m v mm "7'c') �m m D co Z n it 11 "o oom ry 11t U1 W N N O O X n mo C O< O O X z O o 0 Zm -n m 0m C M z X OT = m z v0, 0 o m m o c m = z m 0 (� Q 0 Q z 1 O X 0 0 .71 0 z M O -o m m y - o' <g m w o O i t X �n as m ; O O m 2 M o z n -0 0 =m c 0 1 M z Z U) 0 w om 0O M N 00 5m O Z!2 Z -v m T oC) C1 r N In C) O 11 00 22= DO Z 0 Z O T OD Om Z O O X D O L M Z n icry D 0 Z 0 CA og n» gD 9=mD �N mo mD az��nn_o oDc� 9D o o D iN 9wm�o0 0 oom i$ y�QQ 9 gDo mD ov of--z„o �`y0 0m ci A' tri �C mmm� z?� Om pu a u _ crp+ o 9y 3r 3a 9, 2 O. OyA m 1n Cm yxy - _ T (3 Mo 2>2 rym m2p2m 0m AO O AOCm 9>n 5 DAF m m cm 9omm M -0m m zx >= mrm 9 zo3 02 0 90>0 =r0inm0 .S >DnZ ZZ n� <S Omy2 �AS zmO Z 0 G2 pam2 m2 2 -z- 0. om0 izy� >S . 0>0 -Z �Y <m'z ->y my 2v m9 >ima m y >z p y vy ;vy my Dpy < mmm x y _ Z' xy®O OAAFj 1yn >nl -im =m Omn> m2y9 lyn$S D D rD -> '> > n �> Y X9 wD Om C> OmAm 0- cmgm wo mx10 90 0>ti m-1 A02 001 ydm O On xD �OOp r0 p fti0 0pD y0 tuna �y Z iD>c Omr� Z �99 9 Z Zz O D 9 9 L mf 09 C- On a m=2m tun n3Dm Ow OS p0 O S=0S -0p >2= w w m Ai Ow mm Om_ m o9m 9> xS0 0. T m y�0� O 9 v ox Zm2 x x 2 p y2 mZT3� a o� s� �= a" mnaF ozx ,�9m 9yy> ®g > =ii xv ,Dr-o-ai m o �-ni0o s> nm=r $ oZvapzo ano mmmm�x 'x"y MW 55 'm" mz:E( ccz, z b90 0 oo :10, mo c mgm 9M -IF oam mr Dmv c2 c mvz=z O-pmx`G- oma mm mm �> HM >pO aDE.0oo =$aO 0 m �}1 -1 m wo 2CQm m� 3 ZD03i aC O C��yZO S0=mOm OZ O O Oy ox y mOy >>p'a; 2vy T SO� 2 2- O2f10 a� y m9w D ��m CO nCm yrt0i 41 mm0< omZgm z8z > fm cm AOoi Cvy o syn c a +MMma�W mo m oow zy vpa m Dym m� mmm o0 2n cmm nam s - '_"- v m> oz > Pm 0. 'o D0 m a n Z 2�_ _c9N� 11 rm oz ;m -yTi v m w o mrmm 9 =oma n mzF 3$61 >p y i mymy�O sm a�F ra wp Z' >z m?�m w A m 0O2 5 a 00 !'. So mm v nm p 09�n Zz 090 on 0 gtf- O�Kwn �2 yy Z DDn ; n�0y Ox _ sm A yszp Z m z :E Ay 0w D Fo00D 1 Zwmm m'_ 2; mxa wy ym it w �y� z 4 m m gpo mrz iz ACw - m - 1 �Da F >y ;; T >Dom 9 m0M>0 i2moman-' ZDm3 nm w Z� O Z Yy 2 !o > wn m0 > 1F Tw m j ZmOm� 'o D1T Zx O 2 90- 0 m Zz CF yyOy r Olyn% Nooivo xx p0i vmg cTR '>ro ap m -om ci io K o �c m o nm zom s1 m �Zz $g$F 5H X- mA >>< gUSE tun 6 n�z �_ _ = om n2 Qy� ' g M2�r- • 0Oyy My M= Z -Z miin 00 z Cm�� Z Fiw ?-1 g0 y C ym �S mmm m0 O��D '. � 9y Z� m- < OZ Z9wZO w m2Dp > ypmy 30 2 mr 20 D �0 020 Z� m m 0r ] .>n m myoZi Sm r0. mC mm yt -2 m Oy O r9 r9 0Z� M. O '-m 0 y0 9S ZAT Dm 0 �9T0 >>a2 m $$ w= 9n m.'a y m- $ -� _ ap c a=� y D z 95 � :_ O.9- S d>z 31^ C a� f D d x Mo 2-2 m a n «�F -mim O= > (mi2(.-yi n02A9 9- ��= m 0m �y m�Cm = C - y - y O nymm 9K a '_. y 3zz o o cy o z- ±m o Dnzm i z �s om �� y zT Sz m o w z o z D0 z2a 0 z `o omnmP 9z� y i omy ° o i® So OF o oo-$ S�yz ov Nmm zmo 00 in z �m� z o o m z yw �` 4 oo9n �cZZ m > C$,'� n yb H pm o 1�S �a Q Zan O On;� �>D = A %n 5y5c0i mm9 0 0 1pn 0 5a5 c= oZZ Cn n �CyP i) NOa� SS 2Z2 �S m� ZOm yOrR Am (. p0 O m a z� A my A '.; iO ; >yZm tl y000Fi y -.aA :E NT zm o m c o azqg o z oc'm oTm o' S'6ao yo mz z v z�m p5 w pm sy zz fro oAz A �� - n m riS ; � % oM g oody FMx O 3QQQ zyF s€�'- v� °imo $ 9 0 '% - rzOyo c c oo z zai 1 -0 2. Fi R yo Ni3i m� �" v w g € >oN $ yy m o 00 o D om;. �17r i V000 $ a Z. = ? n z o �0- m' S n p m3 m� o A> n gi m' z 'f�' qvq _z 2�0 �y1 M mW -n1� SDi� m� Tn D nS nZ ZS m Am C in y m O m2 m� O ,c n �}m2 cMM a A �o� 9 tun m zw o �2 v z po°1�+� pi' ms M -� n 0$ m o im m o Am^� n 3 v A y. o a o btu S v Al 90� o s q� mz I r�mo x�<z m 'G' z2 'SK�3 o S �"o o zmwom F `�' —Z C °A' m €€SS mz 3 ?02 2 yo 0 moS z� oa n G mD o �m mjo ❑ o Z9 0 C=7_ n mo O O m0 n A 'H. �IEMMMIENEMA r Z. . o aj DTO O O 2 Q T n 0 o s� y - o' <g m w o E i t 9 �n as m ; o o>> 2 - ;.-- s 2- 06 7 > OP y ZZ O m 2y0 O 9 0 X y O C s Z Zm� DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 is F Yn o n m IMy ryC�' D v m "yy m z9 6 mmo O 0 o O - y r m m � 9 O m A o m D on s _ ohmo 66- o om g a 0 0 � � D m o El 0 Z c 8 n A n m o n s $m y n A o a a 2 .-, O 9 q O� m N � (t y ?O O � o 9 C m m z o O n D q o m v wn > S m z"; _ l M m m m a m It m r o It C=7_ C) m D r O M co) m G) M m V I m SEEM '�IIIII' Io �illll�' CD r n mo D i o n ig � T N o s 11 D o CUSTOM RESIDENCE 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. �IEMMMIENEMA IMMUM e ll LMEMO ■■■■M - I..■■. 0111 O ,3=— 1,--- I �n w c . - ;.-- ® x � 7tri � MM 06 y - N is. C) m D r O M co) m G) M m V I m SEEM '�IIIII' Io �illll�' CD r n mo D i o n ig � T N o s 11 D o CUSTOM RESIDENCE 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. e y s ■ ■ e �y E w c SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 ® x � 7tri � MM y - � s x DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 is l�IC HADD O NE S Al C H I T .EC T U1�E wzzm wOm � w ti Oy D ti O m Oy y D X O 0 cam. m 0 p0 w pppp ml Z Opy r ATI- A msp� N O r O m Z fyA m T m p T p n pO IOIIC O Ng p w 3 xoxo w O m w w� O g 2� w 11 om�5 r m m § o o a A m o 0 z OmodT h7 c S D� O gw m`n Do tO Ib' to y M00c ~� -i dHg S§�3 m [Tl Om o og A $ z Oom00T T� p a n `= mo c O Q O m y A T 9 m '" Z o m n Z m �sM: pmyT g C T p�0;p y k bron OG o �_ n+ w 0 i V ^�] O G) 0 O p P ;g:I a� 0 W T m, pMO w O W y M0800 T 7 m nl y D xmp m ------------ OOCLL RFrION CONTROL I�u� mD TO pA pm (a 5; ti Oy D ti O m Oy y D X O 0 cam. m 0 p0 w pppp ml Z Opy r 0^6 A01 N O r O m Z fyA m T m p T p n IOIIC — Ng c w m oz wGf O x pp O w § o Oz a A m,D�,, o 0 mm<$ M p c S D� O gw m`n Do tO Ib' to y "'I2 $p m N fn < off' og A $ T� a n `= mo c m m$ m y A T 9 m '" Z o m Z g Hy a� �p W tri w w W 40 0 p 0 0 0 0 0w 0 top w 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 D o O m O [n {meq T T m 1z O X �p w tp OD W yy y�� op V w I2 fn O D ~ O D O P (p O 2 A O C) + w T y J Q m O w w P T y 41 m ON 41 m N O N w a 0 O w W w 2m -1 �I y L p I L _J Q rnnvi.iorTr nn�n ov nrrunnn xrnKr noruirrr nuoc nrrnoonon ncn ni r omurc ni � occro�irn �m nnar nr rurcr n� nuc nrcrur nn rurnain rna� unv or oroonmrrn cno�rn rtn nrn r�rn ronourrni r v ni nuv cnou vun rcn�ico iirtavx�r rur rvoorcc vnrrrrn� rnnicrur nr orrunnn xrurc nnruircrri inr rnrrnoonon rrn qN-�rnoz �r 7c�-3 @-nrna�v a o K=p AN CUSTOM RESIDENCE 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. y E � o K Y o F w > yy�xE p m n x .+ SEASIDE BUILDERS z t" Nr rn x ■ ■ o ~, O ti 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 0 W i tc SN"� a £ 1444%. 11C 1-1A1sED ,1 O N E S C] G3G X11 R§< N J N- caaa�oaxcn bgQdadad C7 Po i wil 97-8" I I I � I I w ® � �0 `n99 H by b k :ti p I o O O o n Ioe s0 ---- i_ ----- 'til I � I I I I a i p I � I , m O ❑�❑ 00 ME= o sp � e v e O 8 I I o - \ x ' I NI I AfAI I' kO L------- _____ -------- -�------__ ow> _�` g BOLTER PANTRY� v I I I I II I II I I --- T G� j I I I I I II II I I I I I I - - ------ ------ --- --_-----_- --- ; ; t ---- - - q co ---- ®CD T_ n T --- --- n®; VJ yy LAS I o I - - JA • 4 >< I — I I '� I �r - ` I I � II II I I , II II II I N I II II I T II I II I 0 1 1 I I I I I I I I I L ------ _-_ai I I 0 I I I I--------'--� y /1 I 11 m II I �f 4 Ce Go X888 00 ookoo 888 (EG. Y lN,Tj Cf es , to x �o ;A ; (Fe -§ ------- --- ( O 00 O ee 617 Gs O o� �g O a-- - --- p 'xo o pop b> y0 9 „1* FU r�i p m Z 0 z 30 Irri c I --- ------- ----------- r � lod-4'" '4 o CUSTOM RESIDENCE 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. y E � K Y o F w > p m n x .+ SEASIDE BUILDERS z t" Nr rn x ■ ■ o ~, O ti 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 0 W i tc DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 a £ 1444%. 11C 1-1A1sED ,1 O N E S ASC H-1 T E C T U1� 4 , VA - Puy 0!� e+w xa F.7 -n ,V 1 C com CS v w co) m q nD z rot? s �e z o z o § CUSTOM RESIDENCE`° 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. m y § n ■ ■ x g� au ® N r $ n - SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 a M 9 = e>5 ■ ■ 4 DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ; s JZIC HAlZD `T O NE S ASC H 11 TEC T UlZE CD CD r-+ CD m ,_. CD C O M' TY LITE PRO'ERTY LME PR6PERTY LIFE mo CD m C v w C#) m 4 ,VI — -- — — o �.,«,,,o� .., ��,��,., .— ." --". —.-- --,., n«.,.,, — — -- --.-1111,.—. , , ..,.."— —11—.11,,.,,11,. 1-11 —11,.11 o...—11­N.,r,­ I1 i 711 02 ii 0 MEMO I I .I a F' oI I q I � 711 02 ii 0 MEMO -rn-6 t17 `"3 Z �`■o■ q I monoI 1 >a� O»> >y>pp FFfiyy Dfifi y> /y�ya � zz .. SG7� 44, Z Cn 7K _ y.�y _ SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 z ■ ■ H � � 2 a DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 i a 's FDIC HAl:;k,]D O NES A1C H I T EC T U1�E ■■■■■ III. Q■d■ W■E■ ■ ■ F �T F-qp � F o 333 i� o v 0 1iT6 Q r 00 o 54 � n NUJ ow Z N 711 02 ii 0 — •' o..... ,n.,« MEMO -rn-6 t17 `"3 Z �`■o■ q I monoI 1 >a� �..z VIII I .. y ®x 44, Z Cn _ _ SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 z ■ ■ H � � 2 a DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 i a 's FDIC HAl:;k,]D O NES A1C H I T EC T U1�E ■■■■■ III. Q■d■ W■E■ ■ ■ i� o v 0 — •' o..... ,n.,« -rn-6 t17 `"3 Z q CUSTOM RESIDENCE 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. g ■ ■ x >a� �..z ® y ®x 44, Z Cn _ _ SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 z ■ ■ H � � 2 a DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 i a 's FDIC HAl:;k,]D O NES A1C H I T EC T U1�E — •' o..... ,n.,« PAW 0 m 6 Q" im h7 z o `n > o > Q ° ?9 n<- 'n m a _ g eNn 1* yCCl "-1 h7 x Z °O o E x a0 m �o Cv w co) r t7 ■ ■ h7 z o `n > o > Q ° ?9 n<- o CUSTOM RESIDENCE15 1275 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM FL. a _ g eNn yCCl "-1 h7 x 0 rot o E x ® P �■■;rou J s m SEASIDE BUILDERS II AA V I w r t7 ■ ■ — b p 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 a l�IC HA1�D j O NE S A1RC H I TEC T LJl�E T r'- I 1'NATCH LINE SEE SHEET L-2 DDDDDD aon v o 7 nnrt p N �� r+- CD N l 117 `I n n3 �- m 0 0 ] N n rt CAU GGG �7nC 1'NATCH LINE SEE SHEET L-2 C Jab yo r w y 0 v 7 �~ p N �� r+- CD N l 117 `I n n3 �- C Jab yo r w y MATCH LINE 5EE 5HEET Lm I`.,� I 1 �E: .r•b=oc .. ��.�:� .;It 7i r IS• lkAl2 ,��o O7U z "' DDDDDD tltlrt Ston � P 0 N n I � rt C A o 0 0 0 .41' V P��ERTY LINE 60 8 ' �z 151 O m N m 60.03 — PREVIOUS C — C ONSTRUC (D,,,,,— — MEAN HIGH �LEVATIONW+0 WATER N -� a TION RECORDED IROS LINE (PLAT s= BOOK 36 A`�P .II e nN n 0 0rn cn PAGEg 104) e l ��n 0 1.6'o CONC. CAP ON EXISTING 7 n # a o D N CD REACH BUI_KHEAp H DUNE rt m r O > D co N 8 PAU* N TI r F 0 D (10 Z O D OD = N I C > D p X'2U o = U1 rno� U = FIE' .70 rn� Dr SMI z1 �i u�i n � n ) 0 cn �1 Nm c) c ;u> -uO� J� =rTl Z oy z �� n -7-1z mz r rI� co p — O N m cD ;uo c o D� z o N N 0 Ao Zm D Z� 0, N —I TJ W 0� coJ > Z p I UI� Cn � D/y/TS O F o D rn t eG frAT/O/V G) M co ` Np J �o SEAS — ONAL HIGH WATER I ,��o O7U z "' DDDDDD tltlrt Ston � P 0 N n I � rt C A o 0 0 0 CC) D C) S p z m rn D M z F1I W, .41' V P��ERTY LINE 60 8 ' �z 1 O m ti m 60.03 A T L q N MEAN HIGH �LEVATIONW+0 WATER W I 1 O � A`�P .II e nN n 0 0rn cn l ��n 0 7 n # a A � 1 V U °,n N CD rt m g Wwo AN Io w /�?� "� a �L �* 3 N co N TI r CC) D C) S p z m rn D M z F1I W, V �z 1 O m ti m W 4 I I r VI ����_g�eF�g' ?; ��� " •"'� � ^ifBa? kge :�:sg � '���-;:� �'���g�;r�c� a•$ � � f ` as , ' � �, s$ q n 44v•.U4ui 6d s 6 t g n, a q s"daf n Q=- bdq g, ga f. tea. it ig" °f ff $a kgs f f m t -8v 8x Yo fl: ° `%� eS s; `f`s•: e$a yc.s E7�F-w@s P: gY` z' 4q °3 '_'_°^ f l" :€ $ sF F imp i Ra c g �3e g^ 1 3 Peo=P }: ° fzg:=-Rea�•s .n� >4 :'7< �aeo��•t� fl cif;- �_ ��A= g�=f R g3 ;d g'a= G• , a i f s�spp f g£w. t: 3 §a $ Ea g 6€ € SaC'�5 , g a• fgf'- y Ad •! g ga '€ f.4 z •Rr a! 4 g•4 i !'der !C 9$ 3•.-c 'Sf 3f9$ a6g c$ t :i f d iiirfl--, gg�gsp �< S-s'aa spy n gg - qn ad= € g f c =° }a° f di s! n� a °f -•e, # a 2 tiE a•E`si8 A; ?; ii ;S a=?'fag f %v_sa of a d�R.iScF: $ $is ..g4• S1yyafl rai 6 e _ % f ff p �� [ _ $E R $R #, •� oA p a a aE t`!Efl flR� c om<c f Y o5R fs�$= 3 w_- , "Him, S- , Y Ill -e: ff a s fl R s .s Y c=?gg-iy Sa n F$c?6f9g$s a $'$ °:" $R; : g}� " f,9�s •$fl if `i9fA i�3�f�g.�a4 a'c£ p �. �3°� a f So r 9ya As o wit Ya B �Bi = $'S#?� FzY.i°�-�n$Ff A4 c'9R cj °a !'g fc;f ,� iv a aaia9 :Ldpa' a 6fl ig� iE _ ._ -z a' gfl:agg b.' 9- ° a -� et' '_a f;d a_a,-•°-. �- c5�- do e° a .s �,'} `__ AYS%g g o6 !7; $=.$a 8¢'f� f� �s = �- -8 gA i a E • g �' E i° g_ $ f 4 8m -�y_ $9 g i vf'i_i,SS• t 8-s6^g ? 8$.° 111' fs 9` 3 P f G 9 ago• a g C S=f fl'=f-' F•-�y..: .� R ad 4' F JE.. A , , fl fl Y tq3+,�4g-o gBo�E ste,$ p.i $ao 9•'V as i ta_o lit a' 1� E fg. i 6 v kc a o f yr 'm$ag cd s & s %`'so '3t i i = a_ f %- oma Y - a"k'-- sY f$b Hai- 1flg `t4 8 R° n a c is d g pa aR d= 5� €• 5 2A i A w $ �€ f'ag�f$,$;= _ >c i9E `4448.°-c,°crcc o Ya :a d• a aa$ T; � i°�}�'9.E�o'3� xgE E ��e c � 6$�;.E $ �v ria 4g'ia g;aao g aP is as 9 f :i� � ff3 �ia"[ I1 �' aEal] -�P " f�' gre YeY �Ea a m P P P > 1 " ' �gb¢d 9999>ii �gg c! �� qq� 9 ag. a,gf$'£ s' �d E , g a g $ o='acd:' & ;f 'w�$c�it 'd'� ig P L YQ $i I F�a�e:ca f 4 f aa'!g ug �a.•�f� Rn !$n $aP9 § 3 =$ df S•S'Q A° i5 t F' sCa 2ta e i �J, do Fit a' `$ Rd3 '° G'f f �- f°4 g aEaaq� a r ;,� is a= °> �S == a`- i ? _ c ne !Y is $A Y E � 'yl g $ 8f -. s' ,si°��i=?k�E _ °>n €'flaQF•Ss;•g`€, :iA_ yi�a �d�y Ell f s sg e�fi• s s -da A e4€ 9y a w -°•ea^ =d. a a: if o e�ae a s. a isfli ff;, iP s ,d ie fl f tf ae sc r as�a e' i a§ -:ire fa: p2 Yf Sf 3$ERg x c c a , cg4,$ y g g iEl _ v. iFi c S Y °Y E 9 �xY°• $ $f s •f� o..? c '�► "k� 1y kgs _ a i $ f 4- a 22 Ro' !d E $b fl ra°4<t '?3 .a '�° g $S - �aC t= 9 8 d $ s n g i n '�-='9 a$ •g! a f � _ °',R F- 9s flgP�3v€ iR a� �k g t°aa xz za gds ,,y_die .k f�6 fs'3 a=kga�zst a f.o g A � f• Edi_° S f R3,$fi Fd,� 6 PR,A nREB � 9$e. f° % �ti e 4 '$=�flg gen 9Q � .96 gCIla!'� ACJ i�oi 9� r f 4 $ AAa c CL -S i �a_ Fn:= 04 FE EB fg f €#age__- F" o s! 'i �csr. g$8as3s! o$ikikP�fa S`' s%1g] ;j 3fla=R aiS @ g �3r� i35ayyg� iy f:$ oYSi 4;at€FfgAggd'� $ $psEaa spQa�gR bi a It i fg - 9 +F` ,2 R 4 g=8 - € :s?� gtR , C• fs $ a sib°' °A9id P o 6a s�p gm a P }'7: --g`` i9j jj i$,82 dE 6 9$ -a8 9: gd flda� ;csAlf °g8'dn�? �3 ga 7 5 3A He $ fr Nis•o f•o ,aar6 Hal ff' ita?84P^�g9 g�Ra gs $cfl� k� $ 5 p7 _ o k b s iPg= = •n' €� 45A°g�Pd �Laa CROg$d`$ 4 f Rat $ !n �3 �g� r f5 sa4f °s�cne� N°nla a P ^ m p t A �g g �QFs°sgg S. t - "._ ;i� ai�� � = j'9$ R�$fca$a fi� ERg c9'ys%ot 5d yig p�! �'$�@sFsA� .R-Sa�'$� gg � 'sF=gfgpgp #ggi� °8 411 Pow f$f ff?I `fR23 EF��� $ E 3 €•q S �'gosaae 6•e�% a aeigz dgis - yR� `of9ai $�4 ¢$R YQ i�Csiy A���37ic ggda!}f m g ffwo��k ads k �= g;=6a �aasA:g d aha• a id a 4 s - 5 3a A = € 0 aoYs 9°iR�f 'as'� iieax y.=_= ��e:• - 3Y§ 'fig E' -i f e z P e a ,lit ! s:z€$}gp atd8-: �g egg$pgz6_{� iifg i; af`-s.f r tee•; n gs� YYA` F� f244Q ss ipe�?�� Nii 11. egi `$ 3 z= �� Fc o° 3a� fig¢; fgf ��Rfl q spa RS! u g ci $ $ fl a� R y 5f a5 si flaap Fa°sf $ f d� $A: afe� a A A%y-i °a=a• :BsS I%QwY,S °- : f• f5i ERV g :ffli a�w �+s'k'°°$ = a€ g! . ?s.as;x a E 9Q alm , tg° °: c7�. �$< A1. ` aRie f si f 4 F a �,4�aa 'gf ��4; sfq '. a c_f= 8pp @6- M an ff s a 6Rp 9 �a 9a,C i�de $Y ff'�g R2i $ S ,S;:bP €° } a enty R fHi' C �fl� _ «� g. 8•fBfBg 5�.9 • 3 A :ae 3wse =i f eRo sg? �a ifot �ilF $gypp sa f� 441 68! ' q FflaP a �''�` IY��$?- ' :6°#gc �[.g gSg•a4 � �ta ':° "f, d [a°a'sa.S ;-_ ;e:y .�� •ga=� �s,flf�g- .a� ggY Q.; 3-i ;cga= 49r s®cysr ai E$ f 3 fig: g3 g -w fRg mi, Qe �^ Y• oai P=•t R !.6• g� i f- ai S i €4=F_fe6' p i IF f tali t r- �- >i aa� _ a ! i-cas -4 aa• -p Red._ 4=. m�8a i. E : [c.d= �. elf f� ��'e_ 9b�°f �a yfa•. 5sg°$=-ya :• €='•Aa € RL'a�og=}} sg � fl g wg; �$y a �_ a$- ag 9�Uil a�E O 24-a�^5'9 ��'S AC�Cf�R ,�� i,� °54d ,�,�A Y$ S f jf: f - ?g �� :$= 8$ - 8 = td db€ gFaFg Y •F fl;df faC9Y kis $g. t a4 oP� d ASR f t= og $•�Y fid; P �g� ° e S 'i � 8t '!t'B "a fs'at A.. �I'i yFa6lc Pwg�f 4S'a oR 4 R?f,fEf 2 RA Fo a6 C =o oac5 sf 'Y 3a•aa ify �g" 'g sF "'i k YS - .�flv p lfa ii -i aff$ ;,e ggf$• R_ [g�Sn a==a F �➢ 9 93?;6 fl.i` § }C ,� } n_i3-$2 CF,Cm Af$$f A4g$6E cC:n gf?,gi(=g �'-f.$= i�' @ r9dd 9; �gafld _ sSS'f ga#43a ; ay3 g_. ,IM, g$ 9 :$G96:�g If f Hi Pi �Q �s Si o f sii iE[gs a;at� ti 95s6N �p4id:Rii rti gia i- 08 •r - 6fl' f L 4�sa¢E fa§ fls a€9 'Rx! gEa3�ff�i° itit gg4s f $��i pi asEi e< qtr n €aR L f es-' 9 H co EWl G.6 6 ?k § g�ogso�°ds3 qy fEoCi ,`- E sl. gp aha ?i€Ri o trig 11 It P P P o n P r a_s 1a< wyg a3 ea° € i�@� s F. ? g - 8 "�'gn g = si a syz• •e;ggms $�f6Fet - g iRifl.� s���° •:$;€a �Jf H ilR sa`!11qgi g M _5 i c gi= �. a Gg= - �- '0- $s C .. i •a V� YF R f trza• .-a c I&lk a `i Y55�9g :5=4 �': +�° f"'$Ce � s $:9 � $'i• $a f. `$4. 5, it �'ai �'� 0 6$ ,9' a g ' Win m $ $' d tIi' S P ka• a.o �1OA s t1 4 i a' 'ic' i�f �f a 6•• 4 I E 4 epi °i S! ;8Rf;8� € €=ggs $? €.�gRe# 3 �9gs R S.g'ie $ gPs'eU� ? ;aa a:R $c? f TO a��85s i �S4` g3 SRhai���ia 3an` iz4gg a`� eg if Eq �d9 of 4f 8 � 8;a 1W HIS a'a;atff gr`=Ae$ l9:g:sc-o #•' nfas E,gt g= ZF-0: ale R,a•= -1R1 ;g'f fs-n fl -R d :I g a°a -fl 3 €�5 red '4 ia•i ei.. L9�a -f dm 9a fg 9Ea.?y �?sa �g��ft� s} 5ss ::gas ani 8 a'b�¢R°s9� f sgr.w �nf fosi pp �tt yP�sa �4 4.� =a, g.c aR;=-a firg$° 6_ sit 9 a E $gsg fgsi 3f `Fc ;g is4ayo:.i_ $a$ao �$;6�% psis S �s fg m �; 8,yg3 k•„ i-- wtua:i !k dd c d`�fa: -= i $€fl! gq•• i dr:`f nE 6fs co' i $a $:;�dc g g,f a 2• ° dEgo }R} s -9• a §la a;k 4 € '§r;sgg•s ¢ 9s wFk,s R � atu p i !jig 'si 6 § 38 3 i.� d°3 "y's3 ao adY :iq::. y[ML-s`f�f i? fCf$ g ��& � ?�i'€;� :�"� �§ a aCb�gAt? $ aF K,. Hig f is ! F� g� S sba�'iffcg%F 5 E •ax gg a9 c }Af- ?€S; 'Qsse.i•gagfi :4ai ° !& ga�yhg �9 09 F $i4sf'`, a 3aP gE fa % fa $i4 g��a: gi> 34°sai�aig $s fc 65i �_•_= i ciR c���s ya - ig98€ _qf i gg °'g S€� f$p=d, §: a Did efw c e99ia ?f s ii E_ HF 6R 44f•• E� P �•_ asu'C s;± �g� i �• f-. d € �_ �C� 3lsn`%-A 8a$ as a•�a4g � v' 4 �fR�3k P �• Rki6 :�� °��°>°a21f2 i Y rtg ids ^-e a s gg Rip, a F� s ie=Epfs R�$$� =f'; 8f -fl�kg ��f� a �A: Sa � m i xd si of - f,.p s �- a-. o _ - fsQ 8a 80 �g s f`a� tf a •P f - d f E } s d� n f gn a_a,g' fs. =c!Y a =,a $; g. .. gas $.o q •d d+f A a'8s 9Q °aO 'F:: rq=gda 6Y :• E•$ S'F flA9 n t c S=§� C -g r $ € S R1 u f 1! a $e $ddf :lis B�If'4� 3E} 6 i�a�RCin 9 t = 9 0 S N$ S b�° �$ 4$ a c P p m y s AOgga• F �•-c WE a u d 4s v M as oa, a � A N 8 pa? . F" : Z 'o goF F 8 - d � - °ff 8 sFwAB $�a a g $ 7� 8 a° 4 s- �€ p` ° � 11I P5 s i ? iR° Ei :yf�sf i€"gs gg a3 to g I8'a( 9 aces Ea �; g� Fl '• og - 6 �7 'a, - 0 -Fp: U E r �� P !a as a�i$9 �} 8 i � 6 �• � 9 � 6 p � A° as 7 0 � a� 4 �6 �y•Y :a € � € � � gk� � °ka�R � � a ° � a• ' a m _ y 9a1 1 JL5 F t G g 'L•3paS� 5 ii Y` kx qq¢ f9� 5-'$}6,7 <fs'_ i 7 W a6 � kg �� g� � .S R ;g ��R 8 i � a "o�d Raa' $ '� m a_aa '$�'��iPt Y8'C � on; i95�. 'e6 a• t F5 & F fla- ES d °gddd @ a a6 R a a a � �?i ge g lam. � €Apaa °SgAg � f fkd39H gPai AY cFi k gs a €_ 6s g gD €Yg is (( ; ;:E _�yyad=sfk f gi f33"s 5F #C 6€g $"k'E4 a 'q5. �- F i'=-'bA.s-,s. bI , s g - i £ $ Xm F ?a b �6 f'o Q €es' Ut , a— %' F•F °6Y} u R ,.R� s 5 a Ag �.. c_ •E A urs ug 1 : a C Y$ ! r,f$E a 38 s Nil sa y� 8 o as 3 gc. a H, QS�•'d ►:p q U'fddafIl fad ,$ .a,� ak c P zEEk s alb $ IN gS B. 9gC• � ge 2 '. yyf€= gyp_ a g AIAC o �- If t bdY Aafi 6o'a A:4: a?•S ,�a:3 ia$' Ec6 aw ij '� =o ai 4 9 �� S� �;' f €$t eg i� € n�•�a= iI!' yY �i� 2 m° � }� $ a2 8 $a•g� ni4 n3ifc;� g7'f=i.63gg�6,�•• Fzs s! s Es CageEsE A� A�{kR f6 6 f a- •_ g° $ sq o � CD coi s N 6r 8 v m U -g m It o (D 7 rt N'� fn N 0 n 3 P m ➢ 3 m m P P a g €�twF ill's IF ? _ 3 i $fi ik" 95 °e .._ ,si ..gni$$ s# s figA BS e }� 5[a�t Mac's A3 $6�' yjUf RR I�4Y 4a �b ! ;Pa'B S 6c= Sg ggE.R.' s f fA aft ggar� ?2 sFga3 i.in, gld 4$ : a H f;a F IQ q a MIit R ro Rft c�eg- :a ; e ���o°fl�fl s6F 2 waif g�Eg - 9 'a aikge 6rt kiya8x�gf'3k �g as Rfci?s •6° Q ys€ f 93gfa$a° a R fl .a eg i aR M f s aP m W B 00 N D c m 4 " JD k Q el vt l �aa" srtc��x:snv " sNYt710N36N1AL CONSUMAN78 - rn.�� en aseoo .,rte n4 -ems-.. PAVING &DRAINAGE PLAN FOR: SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE 1275 N OCEAN BOULEVARD . ��'W a .m tao ���� ZE O F-1 N A S r L A N i C 0 C E CD cn 5D x 11") t - �aa" srtc��x:snv " sNYt710N36N1AL CONSUMAN78 - rn.�� en aseoo .,rte n4 -ems-.. PAVING &DRAINAGE PLAN FOR: SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE 1275 N OCEAN BOULEVARD . ��'W a .m tao 5D x 11") 4 i y S EnNmDeslgn ���m,� ,.= XMINnzas • tNVIIWN=NTA. MMMLr,wrs PAVING & DRUMGE DEPARS FOR HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 9 — 1224 N OCEAN BLVD GULF S'lREA1[, FLORIDA '!�i+ •:•' t.'; iy,yii rsa v R oar rro� w K X i" �1� F 1 wz w N NI N EnNmDeslgn ���m,� ,.= XMINnzas • tNVIIWN=NTA. MMMLr,wrs PAVING & DRUMGE DEPARS FOR HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 9 — 1224 N OCEAN BLVD GULF S'lREA1[, FLORIDA '!�i+ — a o. iy,yii rsa v R oar rro� w C wz w � m co �-n P%,j V co o M m o 0 < m i 3 � A. NI N 5" x 11") EnNmDeslgn ���m,� ,.= XMINnzas • tNVIIWN=NTA. MMMLr,wrs PAVING & DRUMGE DEPARS FOR HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 9 — 1224 N OCEAN BLVD GULF S'lREA1[, FLORIDA '!�i+ — a o. iy,yii rsa v R oar rro� w 5" x 11") OCEAN ROU��EARD STATE I 1 I I LOT 6 0 v•nr _ I I I e»s*xuc ii N I rs w E.d- E9"ICE787 }I I ;s L O T 6 , I 1 LO C K I p I gr _t � I I ; G I I epA"�e. n,� EwE I � �° 1 ,•�o �s erxcnu I 1 • _q' _°� cnos's cur °G I v •el elb.. � I ' r mX I I � al y7. h I = Dm0 x �a 1 � �—• 1�1 3�+ I 1 1 Q Meral N^Y Jill .^ S� • F i N A T L A N T I C O C E A LI © N I< V x m ca 71 f r } e (n SSPnC SYSTEM PLN FOR: SINGLE LNCINZZRS • INVIRONIQMAL CONSULTANTS FAIELY RESIDENCE 1275 N OCEAN BOULEVARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORMA .. .._ ..._ ,, � �^ .. I< V x m ca 71 f 5" x 11 ") cootruns LOT 3 — 1224 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STRSAI[, FLORIDA r— � oma"' "...:: � •••� "�« 9P Ig 11 QQ TA r - >ap ■ � � �> I I '.sem Jif Ea pip l�� \ 1 p lima R i T N o � ir4 cl t 19 t It q. IL } S 5� Ir �$ g }� Ii �n n a P 3c FcZi 1 n " oc, C o CcoOdNo mPo co SEPTIC SYSfBY DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES � � seroixsens • exvtnaxUxrAr, tts U `t J V L 1 U U`t I . L V `t. J. J I, l C \U 5" x 11 ") cootruns LOT 3 — 1224 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STRSAI[, FLORIDA � oma"' "...:: � •••� "�« 5" x 11 ") O�FaN B0u1EAR 2�TA?E RS=OD oil z�MY I � a _ JUI -1I=1C I I I All, - I � Hill H ,ryi I Ng lipILI ii kil Q.� 1E +� rn0 b. x o, a I—+ eILI ofCf Q Ut \GV G \ LVU`r L / J IV LCUI I V \ LVU`r L_ VV. Wl�, Z LV� LV G J. JU. z r- VI, CllCr ( .J x 11") �Envimooslgn ns�mtos .: ,��„ LNCINLLR9 • LNVi%IN{RM'AL IX)NSOLTAHT9 POLLIITION PRHVENTION PLAN FOR: RESIDENCE )QO( DELRAY BEACH FLORIDA ti �rz o xnacq i .. nom, x 11") Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM RIE DEC 212012 sown of Gulfstream, R APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 13 —.2 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: 12 -14:) Al. 0'1qjGC1 I.A.2. Project Address: I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) a. } T-1, tI J I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) I.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: ?'00 J Type of Foundation: B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address: JV S LJ 1-k A1h0 qlv i Ai I.B.2. Owner Phone Number:, /?I - 1.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: Agent Address: N�Sllw Agent Phone Number: (od�12�j�ell Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation. Com Date: TC Date: Decision: a Application for Development Approval F6rffl DA.2000V'p% revised 6/13/00 12-.2 6-/2— - 7 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? 6V*',7,C2�, —� III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? yYes ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consisteXyes ith the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Via a l�t�ln, -19- - - . . . III.A.5. a. b. C. d. e. f. 9• h. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? Stormwater Drainage pYl S j .� moo, „ �• „�„ Sanitary Sewer Potable Water Irrigation Water07 , to Electricity ` Telephone Gas Cable Television 0 III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way?%R<es ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures?XYes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of a existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? -Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? �'es U No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the proj'ept at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes I�Wo (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: 4 Matio OVI S -f-'CJIt jr C. ko I 14) ��bt'JI.�.rY1P_r'1- ( , add -QJ IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? RfeD r 6w�fic�ee�- IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: PA SA— CLQ (R Idsbho A­M�S \/11 �►,\ _e t.y�-�it i�l1(-� �,� -�p remain shr G ac arae Gwex- At I C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? T IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetativematerialsof 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard lel Overlay District: I R_ IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? 0( a -A (W _ kz M'P,r IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? 5 WRV )_+MWOO 6q Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 , -..•,uaGlll �� E• Projects Requiring a Special Exception. W.E.I. Is the proposed use a p permitted ti special exception use? p p Kyes ❑ No Code Section: _ IV.E.2, How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the Public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? C:'r\rw., (—\ .. IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of other property be located? O Yes p perty in the neighborhood where it is to �No Explain. IV.E.4• How will the use be compatible with adjoining development a is to be located? nd the character of the District where it 10 111 a. r flr� IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? MEA Does the use onform with all applicable regulations governing t located? � 11 No g he District wherein it Is to be Explain. C F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how the to A I ,� Y are be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their Potential acts Properties. enal im p on surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the numbdimensi number provided and their ons. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-03 Owner: M/M Ross Jones Address: 450 Banyan Road Agent: George Brewer, Brewer Architecture, Inc Proposed Improvement: Construct addition and new entry feature to an existing Bermuda style single family dwelling. Approvals Requested: Demolition Permit: To remove entire second story of existing structure. Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the addition of a bedroom wing and covered loggia on the south east corner and an addition to existing bedroom on the south west corner, along with a new entry feature, a total of 1,431 SF, to the existing Bermuda style single family dwelling and new landscaping and driveway. Gross Lot Size: 18,027 SF Effective Lot Area: 18,027 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 5,106 SF Allowable: 5,950 SF Zoning District: RS -C FFE: 6.0' NGVD Considered During Review: Height: 177'; R/F 21'8" (Preferred <_ 20", R/F <_ 24') Chapter 48 Flood Prevention and Protection Note: FFE of existing structure is below the Flood Zone 100 -year storm event of 7.0' FFE. Section 70-74 Setbacks. Section 70-75. Special exception setbacks. Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Comments: Substantial Improvement Valuation and exclusion justification is required. Architectural Review and Planning Board Page 2 ARPB File #013-03 January 24, 2013; TC February 8, 2013 Recommendations: Motion to recommend approval of Demolition Permit to remove the entire second story. Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition of a bedroom wing and covered loggia on the south east corner and an addition to existing bedroom on the south west corner, along with a new entry feature, a total of 1,431 SF, to the existing Bermuda style single family dwelling and new landscaping and driveway meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following condition: Prior to permitting, applicant's agent shall demonstrate and verify that the proposed additions and improvements do not exceed 50% of the market value of the structures before "start of construction". ARPB Date: January 24, 2013 Action: Demolition Permit: Recommend approval as requested. (4-0) Action: Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review: Recommend approval as requested with the Condition listed above. (4-0) Town Commission Date: February 8, 2013 Action: Demolition Permit: Approved as recommended, remove entire 2nd story. (5-0) Action: Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review: Approved as recommended with the condition recommended and stated above. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM .: ►R ECLCIVEp DEC 2 81011 TOwn of Gulfstream FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File #_/3-47 To be completed by all applicants. PART H. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: I.A.2. Project Address: 4"60 f3.4^D I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: _ �..p� G�- i3LK JL &y �I ��� ��.� ►► ► 7,crl t�� �� t � , ���h �3� Com �' 1 I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) l�uw r J �q ` \ �l� A� S VCi1��Q I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: ,� 3 Architectural Style: T�> 1.A.6. Check all that apply: architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) 'K Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ,K Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: I GP -050 Type of Foundation: IA4yz,!% 13bq'klSl,Pit�s B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address:_ -1 f::;' &4A��� I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I . Agent Name and Firm Name: 9• Fax: LJ&\- �c yr x -y—. I.C.2. Agent Address: j�jk2 �j• L , ��GI4 44. I.C.3. Agent Phone Num" -: (o) i f90 • Z7Z ;,ni cell_�?(�r�• 70(9 •2j4& Fax QP • 27Z• 57Z Z I.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: Decision: 1 T'j; '1l,1/4 - Official U' a Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? K Yes ❑ No Explain. lj{,�-� ,� _ A,/tl►!�Y III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? it6,Yes ❑ No Explain.��-/�►t-- O�l, III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? �D,� t Lit S III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage p,0 S 3 C- b. Sanitary Sewer 4OA.X5t 10 c. Potable Water_I� d. Irrigation Water &KIST, ,�-�� e. Electricityf. S a g 6 , Telephone &1S ti g. Gas h. Cable Television �.. . III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) c[. c,� ,I '/'v PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes "o (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? KYes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes J%No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ,(,Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes j"o (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town M Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or ad d and Ztowhat extent? kyp `IZx9 oiL j�� t.p 1 cG IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: LC.J4—)11 y 't, 56L, I N6 -0 pL1AD61�•5 IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or s landscape features and open space, or introdu that destroys or impairs significant views o is Yes No Explai OMC '' 7,C (w ie se impair visual relationships among buildings, incompatible landscape features or plant material tas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? il,00A.3 IV.6.4. How is the design con ' tent with the Al Landscape Enhancement Project?WA vINW ry OF IV.B.S. What mitigyon is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least)glpact possible to the visual and 9sthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: W14 C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? ?Q IZj IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? ��'i1►1 �-O)zc'o 2p)-S IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? /L'K)L D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit .IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: _ IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 vu cql I I E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1, Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? KYes ❑ No Code Section: IV.E,2, How is the useg desi ned, located and proposed to be operated so that the Ifare, and morals will be protected? n- n public h h, safety, Oo�L C_, _ L� v 1 1 IM n IV.E.3. Will the use cause sub �tOZ� IMal 1io� be located? ntial injury to the value of other Property y i he neighborhood where it is to Explain. A^� 1 L / 5b1 -UGC �c. 50A, oil t�ctS6, IV.E.4. How will the use be compatible with adjoining veto men is to be located? p t and the character of the District where it �La*iL S IV.E.5. What landscaping and scr Hing are provided? L� S W.E.B. Does the u conform with all applicable regulations governing the District herein it is to be located? Yes 0 No Expla' j"L, v6 � � F. on -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV-F.I. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potacts properties. potential impacts on surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number pro---------------- vided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 v J W N 3 (IVO2J NV),Nb9OSt7 !' ■ F lao NH(Ils!a I�mQ > N a a c" r O H1210N vm_ l �La Q V 1J 1 Q W co v U Q 00 LL- _ Ca mo aim 3ONwismm S3NOf W I 1UQQ 0az -- ----- — — —— A P2 An ( mod W I-- W N O Lu W ®� N OJ CUB LL- _ Ca r I co I ,LL SZ I .— LoU O -j J Cc ,59'98 I I I -- ----- — — —— I I I I I 1 I I � w� �► zl Ibo z t I I I I w I L _ 'x o — — — — — — --- — — - - n I I ►-� Icon I I w� 1 1 b--- ,LL SZ I .— LoU O -j J Cc WZ♦ qM N O Q "q ij'wd3,dls�nnp o U. r zO s <4 N �i �7 T�T!��CIVOO'dNV),,NVOO!SS • 41 am c � � m lowgx -MINE[ �L1S�1Q I W o c > N W 0 q� N p n H12iON xx O W ou) � 0- LL' c�a m r 4 rc c, oa� I I I I I N I I Z ' I I a= a m mm r �j Z U uZWi �q>QQW �S3U� ZYp� � w � - J1��m+1 Jp Yj yZ�� �2 ®IL2 OF rv_52r ai rxr yyR�I ZZ ZZ (7�j yLL� �.1 kir�a Wes!-, Qfj OT OW 6 Z '62. i S ::iz $ - �¢ ° m Z O Z W U L Iu Ug JLL}m19 .:� 3F ai mK LLg 1S{J W ry m m d = WJJ ZZ )�� m W U z S k nO �no �gOzr o �� � IGC U � tOt Wµl wwwQ n °1,@ m J a� ��;�ax s p pF G OU 9Rr9OLL v'.; ���Z CIE J UQ'p� mp KU mX fru -O�Q -W wu a$o W O RLI m 4? dQaG gUl r EW{r WW�a� �_m ��Jm u6� u� mm�jj �� 4 yI �yG7 0 i x ° ly U z OQ �dl �7u5'T 0w h�'� V - '•' q Y ,• '• r eD •1 0 AI W 0 U. r zO s d WE 0W 9� IL xx O W ou) � 0- LL' c�a m r 4 rc c, ,,,,,,,,,,,— I L LLI.LLI. L.LLL LLLL LLLL 1. m � W. IQ w � aa�g� 5 d IL as I I I I N I I Z ' I I a= a m mm r �j Z U uZWi �q>QQW �S3U� ZYp� � w � - J1��m+1 Jp Yj yZ�� �2 ®IL2 OF rv_52r ai rxr yyR�I ZZ ZZ (7�j yLL� �.1 kir�a Wes!-, Qfj OT OW 6 Z '62. i S ::iz $ - �¢ ° m Z O Z W U L Iu Ug JLL}m19 .:� 3F ai mK LLg 1S{J W ry m m d = WJJ ZZ )�� m W U z S k nO �no �gOzr o �� � IGC U � tOt Wµl wwwQ n °1,@ m J a� ��;�ax s p pF G OU 9Rr9OLL v'.; ���Z CIE J UQ'p� mp KU mX fru -O�Q -W wu a$o W O RLI m 4? dQaG gUl r EW{r WW�a� �_m ��Jm u6� u� mm�jj �� 4 yI �yG7 0 i x ° ly U z OQ �dl �7u5'T 0w h�'� V - '•' q Y ,• '• r eD •1 0 AI W 0 U. zO s d WE 0W 9� IL oq ° O W ou) � 0- LL' c�a I I I I N I I Z ' I I a= a m mm r �j Z U uZWi �q>QQW �S3U� ZYp� � w � - J1��m+1 Jp Yj yZ�� �2 ®IL2 OF rv_52r ai rxr yyR�I ZZ ZZ (7�j yLL� �.1 kir�a Wes!-, Qfj OT OW 6 Z '62. i S ::iz $ - �¢ ° m Z O Z W U L Iu Ug JLL}m19 .:� 3F ai mK LLg 1S{J W ry m m d = WJJ ZZ )�� m W U z S k nO �no �gOzr o �� � IGC U � tOt Wµl wwwQ n °1,@ m J a� ��;�ax s p pF G OU 9Rr9OLL v'.; ���Z CIE J UQ'p� mp KU mX fru -O�Q -W wu a$o W O RLI m 4? dQaG gUl r EW{r WW�a� �_m ��Jm u6� u� mm�jj �� 4 yI �yG7 0 i x ° ly U z OQ �dl �7u5'T 0w h�'� V - '•' q Y ,• '• r eD •1 0 AI W U. U. 0 N 0W 00 3 O W ou) � 0- LL' c�a IAMG MOd ;----.'..; ,� ,:�i�i�i�%i •moi I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I,I�I� �■. , , \ � , , , , , , , 1��������������\��h�����\�������\�\�\ lid■1 ���Y'�C���\ �I�I��\�������\ I�Ib��b�����I�I�I��b�Ib�Ibb�1���1 II %�_� m■1 %%Gv ��� �I������������� ���\������I�I��\�\�\����I�I�I�I�I�I�I�I�r 111■I �•i ��\���\ .\�\I������\���� I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I� I l■. I-I,I,I��\ ,1,1,1,1,1\ISI\ ';•'�'�'�:�:�s:�:�:�:>iti�%%%i�i�iv� c . _'_ �i', t ieii i.1.1.•, Li.LLLi L. I.I.I.I. 1�1�1�1••I,: I �1�1�1.1�1�1�1�1. III I III 'III /III I III I•� ♦ ♦ \ ♦ ♦ ♦ \ \ I / I I II / I III II.I.� 1� 1,1,1,1,1,1 I,I ..��,��,,,� I�I�I�I�I�I�I.� �= �I�ISm;I�I\jai\��i _ I%I�I�I�I�I�I e � II I � - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l 1 I I(Q OI C( -'I Q IZ Q I I I 1 I I I I I I 1 I I I I I �am> i �a. y 1 rc c, ,,,,,,,,,,,— I L LLI.LLI. L.LLL LLLL LLLL 1. e � II I � - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l 1 I I(Q OI C( -'I Q IZ Q I I I 1 I I I I I I 1 I I I I I �am> �a. y 1 W adO2l NV),NVB 05t, C] o -r T�7 -T�1T T 1.7 704 RR".1 u H1 aory • ■ a m `�Q�y �L' 1 v 1.1�1�1 `�Q1S' 00 w N N _ ------ W ■Q o �>< 3ON3ais3a S3Nor ow oV- g \v L I L------ j i i LJ1 U ZW IIl n a n Q IL �L1wm�r Len a iZl7� a---IFT�l Q - $\-- Zo----------�I I II Pq �nO V)oLL�8o wu X LU �� XOf �X 0 I I I 3 I iJIU 'L I I n J �'n Z� I L1��� II �� I --------ter -- II o / ),VAAIIVH 9NUSIX3 / I I 6__�, ----- == ==- -�--- --� --- ---- -- I 1 / L --I-- I III Iyjl i I I I IIII ISI U>- IIII I �Z I / III LU j`- -------------------- I H I nl I I I d II � I 8q II Opu I1 0 I QU III ♦- O II Zd I I I o I U II I (t��o I om 111 } Zo II I ILn LDZ I Q H�> IOU Z y W2---- ii a r ' ms I oa I ul I o�� ..w I I II J J o J Iu I p11 I I 0 7d I H2. ~NJ I w 0 I I --- ------- ---- li I I uq I I � J-------------------1--T--r---- IIII l7g IIIII XaI I I IIII Zw I _ I w I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I--�--1--L- I I I I I I I I I I r--I--+--F-J I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I -r I I I I T I ly \ II I II-- \ �\y I1 +1I I �f r -,-- I I IV I I I I 0 v W` / cC'4 O CSE W 00 W w cmA 1t 1 111 1 111 1 �1 I (Q 0 12 I mgL) O�J °u X w �Kup� w J � Me mma L4 0 Iw �sz -- _ ------ \v L I L------ j i i LJ1 U ZW IIl 6 j in 1= I I I �- IIII I I I I I X LU L L - I ; I , I L I \ II I II-- \ �\y I1 +1I I �f r -,-- I I IV I I I I 0 v W` / cC'4 O CSE W 00 W w cmA 1t 1 111 1 111 1 �1 I (Q 0 12 I mgL) O�J °u X w �Kup� w J � Me mma LL-' 0 � W o n \mow/ F all 11,16,111, ALU V) C" LL W `0 QO o4 Oz w ° 0 °" °� CLLLJ Q ywv32Lsj�np <" OVOi NW N` O OSS - 00 cit a Z B C4 N W =4 ^ W 'I�QOY�I�2I "I�'I.LI�I�QIS�2I ■= vm vuiOiu ui w 1 W 0 8 0 X w p J N W� =, Ln O mo a 3:)N3ais3a SMor m Q OEM■Q Q- o n \mow/ F all 11,16,111, ALU V) C" LL W `0 QO o4 Oz w ° 0 °" °� CLLLJ Q F =o N %puw L O n Z B O N LU 1 W 0 8 0 X w p J N W� Q3mOC O 1 � o oQ 11 l7 J iy w p Nm N2yEE1�� �1 W l W LL C W F =o N %puw L O n Z B N N 0 w w X w W <; c abO2J NV.Mg 09b o m 'I�QOY�i�2i "I�'I,LI�I�QIS�2i Lu� _ e 1� aim ��N�aIS�21 S�NO� r � Q g �o W a Q0 W o, a C� 1 W U F n Z a LL ' N Q N W W X W mQQ�WRw ~ W f 30� F— ui ® cz c CNJ 0 LLJ ca co a � oLL a V W WCM Q: �e m� ge �q�m LL OJ �W W � F LL N W� W� L Ou 1� W W o, a o� � hal �m V H �e W� V W WCM Q: �e m� ge �q�m LL OJ �W W � F LL N W� W� L (7� r) 3 Lel >M N V K a`d02i NbJ.Nb'8 OSb • ■� <m NNU ���LOI tll tl ��Wl`�\II AJ LI\1 � 00 A. C,3 HI'dON _ 3ON3ais3a S3Nor Q N 9 ' o a O >Zic 00 mW aim ✓ 3- CW 0 J (7� r) 3 Lel 1� CA' C,3 es ui 04 >Zic 00 O " 3- CW 0 J CL u - ad0'd NV),NVO OSV ■ am igao p a W a H12fON z �IaQ 1 V 1�L,NgaisJaQ Q �o =4m 33N3alS3a S3No > C� 1 w Q O b zz W o a C" � 9 — m 3 I z -------- @A q rt1 I I �i I W 0 N ------ — ------- --13NI9V� 9 -� N3NI-1 I > „e -- — ---- --- „4 „4 a I I w q I I° '^ m I-- ..0-:£ p w z I I I o O o a J � J H d) p Y d m F I J d m 90 3 r4 I z U Z a = N Q 0 w Z z Z X W ut d) J - u ° m O 9 wq a UW ww ��- �m ---- - p w I I Nd I I I o O ffte ? d) �d m zJ I m v r4 I a = u ° m I I 9 wq a UW ww ��- ---- - 9 Z J BOOEl ffo,"F_ ----- ---� 0 co m „ml -.L „ml n Cf f--- y qw a° m$ r D wW q IIuu w 3> a zd � w� am ----------- - = 0 .o m •_ W e -- -- ro me a m v a r - - -� - �' r ' I l l l p g l I I 3do�s cl� r 2 _ q d w I I Nel I z I I QQ a w l I w s I zq vq ----- -- IC-------- -71 r;7-- ----- - -------� 9 \-------- I I I F I I Ila IIII I I I I T L3 II II ILi I� ❑ I ° I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I a I I m sell, I I I IIII I x1 w I I - I I H i l l I I aa I I z I I I I z I I I I I I � 0 O CL I I I I I p I I z� s I I —z I III I ma m >> w LLw II I Z _I IIII II n 1 I w z n I � 91 IIII 9 z LLI I z X I ❑ ❑ i i°�I w L ------I J N — D I I-- U��--L�_ 1—_m— _ I i ------ B Ul z _ - w�wIL IL (L �_ m d= aLu a o , Zi W d 0 Y 3 Y -- -------- I z a3 In ,OLZ ZR� I— I m I I I I I N 9 i0 w0 p r a v a HI d Lu Q H d z J u _ - m x x u V o O"m m Ne I Ne 00 _j _ v - H H m ,oz O L a -- z T m — X I Al - ® I I I O O Dm ---- 10 I v-- 0--------� I _ I I -O m I I I I I „b N ,.Z-.5 F__ a „0 .£Z a O I — z = J Al y I m l7 9 I I a 9 O I I zz w I a O I 0 O I aI J n m� 9 I z0w I I r N Qj T uw I I O n l 9 8 — _----- — I I a� I I wd I ( Ul n/ „ lu a � — .9_.L „9-.I �- �wgwza w „O -.9E IIIIIIIIIIIIII illll'IIIIIIII I . I � SO m IIIIIIIIIIIIII .I�IIIIIIIIIII - I� I� IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIII 111111111111111�IIIIIIIIIII .. I IIIIIIII :1111111 ® . ;, I IIIIIIII Illiiii I ■■ ■� mom . IIIIIIII IIIIIIII (I'll I Uu 11ill I Ilil 1"1 Iliil�l (III. �r lI I I I I o J � J 0 Q Oiv NUN � I I I I I I I I I I I m r � EEEE rc N � Z X m LL �r�i r WJW— = ZWr O U awF} 1-. i �cx Dc 3 QN z- w O oz ad0� NV),N`d9 OSi 0 ao E � I 'IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII p I w 1111 I�IOLLVVAONUH (INV NOLLICI N � _ r~ _ �q�a mo =4m _ 33N3a1S321 SM r a, ® a m U- ZZ Q -0-1- I 111 J t J IIIIIIII IIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIII illll'IIIIIIII I . I � SO m IIIIIIIIIIIIII .I�IIIIIIIIIII - I� I� IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIII 111111111111111�IIIIIIIIIII .. I IIIIIIII :1111111 ® . ;, I IIIIIIII Illiiii I ■■ ■� mom . IIIIIIII IIIIIIII (I'll I Uu 11ill I Ilil 1"1 Iliil�l (III. �r lI I I I I o J � J 0 Q Oiv NUN � I I I I I I I I I I I m r � EEEE rc N � Z X m LL �r�i r WJW— = ZWr O U awF} 1-. i �cx Dc 3 QN z- w O oz Q� Q 0 131110'11 R'm Q Q 3X - Ww LL W Z=�w 'IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII p I w 1111 'IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII - ' IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ® Q'ra ■■ -0-1- I 111 J t J IIIIIIII IIIIIIII r�W I ZZ� W3� IIIIIIII IIIIIIII ® I • TWO IIIIIIII IIIIIIII zas r J ND_W • w0'r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Q U F d d d) O W O W O W X, w w B 0 w W m oLu W (L ry lu rLL 3I III W I � Wz� " U00 W J 7 Z J � NSW XW� WRRr 3 I o J � J 0 Q Oiv NUN I1� r � EEEE rc N � Z X m LL �r�i r WJW— = ZWr O U awF} 1-. i �cx Dc 3 QN z- w O oW Q� Q 0 131110'11 R'm Q Q 3X - Ww LL W Z=�w 'IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII p 1111 W m oLu W (L ry lu rLL 3I III W I � Wz� " U00 W J 7 Z J � NSW XW� WRRr 3 I I � Oiv �Qzjr- I1� SOF EEEE rc Qz`�1' Z X m LL �r�i r WJW— = ZWr O U awF} 1-. i �cx Dc 3 QN z- w �R'Q oW Q� Q — W m oLu W (L ry lu rLL 3I III W I � Wz� " U00 W J 7 Z J � NSW XW� WRRr 3 lig �_il■ r (J I � Oiv �Qzjr- I1� SOF EEEE rc Qz`�1' Z X m LL �r�i r WJW— = ZWr O U awF} 1-. i �cx Dc 3 QN z- w �R'Q O Um aWdi 33u OR' 131110'11 R'm Q Q ZN3 - lig �_il■ r (J I � Oiv �Qzjr- I1� N EEEE - X m LL �r�i r WJW— = ZWr O U awF} 1-. i �cx Dc 3 QN z- w ! I i I I I zF lig �_il■ LL Oiv z0 N N � W W X W I 'IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII p 'IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII - ' IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ® ■■ -0-1- IIIIIIII IIIIIIII IIIIIIII IIIIIIII ® I • IIIIIIII IIIIIIII IIIIIIII IIIIIIII ® • \ LL Oiv z0 N N � W W X W ®F i■ ■� Q r M v i < J �m N� =x 3 mo aia.. rc GVO�J Nb,INVO OSS 'INQONAN TvilRadisavN 33N3aI9321 SMor LLJ W Q z � Q, Q Oz o 0t; a p W I a N ba W w 00 z � o NUQN 0t; a u _ a oUK I a O m w J� J � �0. NUQN ILW U3 r oUK LL ' LLO �Nd W ZU 3xN- ZWLLW �W Z (= SOW u Q I a � m O \ LL LL ' W W N X W ��j'wb32iisjinp W M n M U N L.- I3�� > M N N 2 ab02i NbJ.NbB OSS W o Cc e N '= W00 �% �� <m �� �� �� "I��QOY��I��2I "IVIZI��I��QIS��2I �� " g % cc W ��V CD W 0 W cc w C:a a a o�� ��1 . L.- I3�� " W o Cc e N '= W00 > N N cA % cc W ��V CD W 0 W cc w C:a o c 4 ��M ab021 NV),NVO OSS �%F N H W am ladowaQ 0 E \eCo N ut a H1NON �� 1 V 1��Ll��LgaisaQ O�� 2 l< Q IK w --�� L oo w o ? e 3!R. Fal W ad02f NV,. Nd9 OSS in e4�-- e %a LL E Z;U ��'j{l/�1 T/.��IT F'j�]jT /�1 {�/�1 T1 �TI ,%�1 T C 1''�%T� • ■{� Ym Ny1U -igao1 111 t1 1 ♦ 1jmcllsay . 1�i � ll N co •., Y� �a mo=4 33Maism SMo W 7 F � JU 11 a W U, LL, LL. �a W m Ztm�.j �m NU i i W, W W W I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I n� S LL LL Q� c V i 10 Z W W W W W F � JU 11 a W U, LL, LL. �a W m Ztm�.j �m NU i i W, W W W I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I n� S LL :5nu avo £00V-90£-199 'Hd '; Oji p w6.I N` ld HdVDSQNVII o � Z `'ZS 4;L 'M'N OZb :AG 3x� 'W O f`� r BPS W�Ue531aJ o r us S OSb l N Nttla 069 'ON:. OEM Qbs #'`� AVS 8 vaa � '�" aaUa Isa p• x o Sauo a r tl"Iav 'Atli 7Qvxalyi lDaIiHDHVgdVDSQNV'i % LZ03mHpxv 3dVPOUNtl•I •)Ld3'IHVHDIW :ONOIOIA38 21-92-21 Y' '..f02id m o a :31tla JUL— > ® LL izzzz zzzzz zzzzz zzizzzz ok z'zzz zzz �pp m U mz in W ♦ 4 o E o U x a �V C14 W pv F F W a ¢ Y z � � NelUod • ¢ d U m � w .d Igi vai Q'voa :ino¢dad dJ, w a oc¢i m�' W V LU v— O m�sm I- zo Ja o`i Di Di uain ¢cj o. z w 0 (n X �m0 Y F M nH N yniD mNY Hip mN 0 Jc d0�ia a dddmQ dad da _ :�a aha^ .Q :a! U U> c> o dm o v o 0 o 0 < p<000aaao is as oIn c� coca o 0 0 0 o Qm n`+ mmm Din 1p m1O 1Om n �r n'Onnn� rn� Mn -'H w O_ 'o � W ¢ J p LL o o wo W ¢ d U x � U J O Z g� YO 1 O 9 JK < �" w in o ,,, 4 C� II W a z a ¢ Z an O o m <W �U Y p ZZ - x J FAWN 60 a O N- ¢ 3 z V) N �U O O wwF O K K U < > F K a x i� OO w w i - a z ¢ a w s m o m o 0 Y o _ m > o Q < a x In w z r w a p> o< ¢ g z w r U mu'¢-¢^ �aI a n a ¢ a •vprw N rc a_" O -. OJ V I¢ W Z O m I~/1 O i na rca p p z p V I - U w Q¢¢ Q Q m m a>w ¢N ¢ O ¢� U m J In o o ¢a ¢ '�c=.1 U a ^ \II Z /\laa Q�0 4�o aN¢a w O F¢ W gg¢a 0== W ¢¢a ¢ wz vi ¢ iwc�i¢arc rc�ia� ¢ H Z uai p W w Q Q W Z I- ¢ n > 1- ¢ h 0 0 0 O Z tan W a n m U¢ Z< a «o aw Q Q ��a 'J'i uzc¢iu aua4m �Sa�cmiu¢,maomaaam�coa - N a O Z O Q W � o < J o ~ a 2 Q F o r \ p z o ,59. 99 ~ O a W W z Y NO_ �Jw a' N/ - - a Q n N V) O J dU w ` O�OZ ¢ w V)QO QU J F- H U J W m V)!. 0 w J m \� J Z V) w G S J W J V) D Q. J O W Z J/ J Y O O W D_' U O Q O_ )- J F- � J� U) Z} W J m=om N x W Q m /� = O W J O OOw VI of> 0 O O O O/K-- . Q 0_ W V) N i F YN O N Q Z 1- �O � > WU O W J � w0 0. O UD a K W ZJ = Q J H m0�� F-OWo Z Hm O SQw W J m M:20� dwI�'IU) Q OOw aVj O'T� >pU z0 V)J- m J jF-J own D./� J Q O M O iV KW J O d� Q0= } O Jw� J U' ~OQO OHOmQ UUQ 2W OOJ N Q x U o I T _ I Q Z � w O_ O o �vU y1»~�m a 3�0<1 �0 0<0 ~mUZ� mz=w QUO=V) J I w ^ �.- �j V)� ,Q � A, O W m Y- JW V) m Li H T4 I O UO�U K/ W�' T m U 'C �O J Z :wZOW OOO�� �'l� �Q JN���Z�'m2 F \ IICC„JJ '- \ O _�a rn00 J Li MN > �a<F dU��LLJ��O�O Q< N _ O a L, I N O xw Q z N O��QV) JOOWW QZWH�mz Of -0) Iw- QU W� \ ¢ Q� U J O Q t� O J �Z00RMTw 0 wQJamwd<Wuom<� V) QQ W Q�2 Q w / < En W OJ ♦-a� Z w ¢ o JO �O 0_ t0 w m 1 w ZJ O ww a m I z J Zuo w� Q O_ Q N wwwwd Jl~i¢SOD!Jr N O 0 x Q Q Q a M U O_ Q O M W U a a N + d -_______= V) Q Q Y Nm ~ I 0 Q In t0 I� t>0 m 4J > Q '- O_ I O Fn I I t I > M I J ” Q z Z m O W O F' H U U N + �' N O T I J w Q <1 O I •V~7 oW IY J< a +I + I Z I w0 Q a Z U o g J = V) = Z o s� W o a w Of + 2 rc W p D U m U m'. Q w Z I + I I aj¢m O a p ° '^o m _ J Q Q O w o �o X o m N ++ I UO �j N z w N U =QUo z 3� zW Or w t LN ~OW N W g > 0 n '-� O J ZI� O J I _z 2 _____ U z0 O ZQJ W JZO W z W Z O Q + I _____ O Q W D' N Q In IL Q + I Q a W I. I o�x J Amo -O` mo � ofrv,=mo 000 w + m � ii ii I' .- ¢ zoo-m<}-OpO Flo Q I N H m c.r0 iI II Ib m I c/ \QQQ JF-� JV)V) + U N I I O z -~ (/7 JOZaJm Uoj mQU JZQOQV)O�w v) z Z N w U O Z (^' �/ O O =_--- ____-- w N W ~ 0 Q �-Z zZ _0 zwJ V=) o U Q 0> V)LL, m o S 4pQ�FLi �WO �a2 y pj 0- -,IJ m O a O¢ '- 0 w W V7 )n O O_ O_ � W �w V)�J W �FN`LW O OOu2�H � �- 1 � IIJ OO W ii O li '-1 / O QOM—v'=-Q �wQ ~� �m� X� Q O U W i Z U a M m i Q )- V7 Q Q —08 F m �� W I IIQ CJ J ^ O a F D_ ' Z lid W ii 0 U O' p z 0_ J~ Z� Qd'Z WJ(.!�Q JQ O JQ- V)O<<=J x m w O O ¢ ~ V) F H O Z Z U Q II O_ W ~ 1- I V) Q Q 0_ D z = 0_ z Z z 1- 1n F- W O N Z Q 1 0 MH Im l 2 J w a N U UH ii U a 0 0 O V In N Y Z JQ�QO_ ZOJZ 00_ aNC7d�~OSQIQF UU IN U O O¢ II I N �cVO ii V) O W Q Q N M . - O J x Q g O_ Y i i Z W S .� �-.,. Z O W Q U Q X < OQ a FRO ITO Q w Q ~ a w al-- wQo M o n� 0 J Vl UZ J m j Of O_ U p L<) V) J Q I + Q O y X U Q a w 0 __Ul_ H¢ I __L_ Q Q U m O w3 + J jM 3:Q Q N O Q v) o: + Q ¢ M Ln I w z J O_ Q Wm + W V) I N �J Z I W w N W Z d w °0 Q U 0_ JOO + Id W o ofa 00 I N W x N Q c Q I-LLJ Of O = I -yr------ d ----- n Q L) U w� WU + I U I•I____________I ____________I• Hx M z Q o ?o I W N + av I w 0 /O O o I Q F II i•i i � I aw J r 00 W U O U i IM + 0 m J o ' I I + U O Z I N O ~ 00 O N lfi h Q O - _______ J N _V) d w a w r II = 0 o Of I •____________r n: _____ -- r --i Q O < Q O_ Q r' WU w ONO J 0- o O IL O_ U W F -U '�� u u � u V) W Q -' J ILLJ r 0 azn II J P g II o U�Z w I o ( I wox w ii w �0 Q ¢mom J a I N ¢' iI I' Sa Ow O V Vii~aQ I x H oC14 Ln I I m I i i U I Q 17 �En N m d' m cr 0 U x Q I W V) _ Q U N I OIC WNW I I U O m \ V) \ J 1 - - - - - - -- -- -- -- - - 1 )10019 9 10l :37iA aro 78 S'IIV.L3Q ddVDSQNV'I £00V-90£-I99'Hd = trbh££ `'O `'H39 AV2PIEQ `',LS u;L 'M'N OZb 3N EpPold'�ansila�J N xB z 1 N o S.LYa 0179 # o� AVS 'W Pa�souojf7o�qq�j�L 069 'ON 'pSa �1 �1c. t,,+ V :A8 YN aauappag UO3nHpu, 3dYPS6 NaYWI •J'•7'�•IH✓�'3d�'.J•7Q�d�IAV��I�V.7 'ONOIOLM 3.LYa oud d cu W p , N00 gi <� maw Q WT• �<-F o ♦.7 cn tr7 m < 8� i U' �v� O V _ V-s' W V O W y LLJ rF s Z2i Q 33cr- 3Sax N m (L LLJ Lli LLJ 1 > 0 Z ^ a / I Q z 8 42 � r „Y<ULLJ n nn NNWVI<� '� �1 Q r p• Z m ry U qq o� NaQ Sn i F YS W� i 2! w m�i6 r GF as m 1yy F iFC m 2 qq F�`3< =< is F J S-4 � b >- m m€3 wb J 32 m•= 3 m <- wag t3 Z m _� 93 $ qui w ✓ bafi!'� r i zzN S8 B g� O rcRg (rc ma=`wno Z F Q g2 g(gx m.vg eoR=: Eo £� a VSs �_ a Q �a ��m=& J S di g g a J �`< 'Un m��j�O xF 06 DQ$ry�Q�� Z it ei w� g gs h kl [ g ME =1BZ gG <��< Ini '§x �5 =.-.3 O nwR zl<� F¢ R O F �� 2 O B Z 6 < yo k V�1 \ F o w�3 F Z 8� -51 6 0 < F Fo g&Zzi _ fN g W� LLJ-g� ` $, \ g.s Zg g o�g ;_ gym € �6 �- c < \ W 6WgX S�Fg�SaFJ ��o m�< „gm �` �MM I wMb� 1S Z J IRA N`` o �• �i �G JiajCW9�F B is Ji '9 g? f21. w� o m= A� i—z _ wmi ws S z 12,o � oG Xv <<m m �aa 61 grcgFg `r W tj WG F IA- `UIAR« j x 6 ZWOW GyF<9 y �xs-m 6 <0 �aKn F $�g8 E b 4 = S €� ���oc�WIU�!!m/��]�C�irS �S j G m i-"�icp5��`Nm� �a rc I^aCi��SWb�g�;&wi¢z QQ--II m �m �~Uwl%jF.r:1Iio1¢Wzr mwi FF 7✓i���i���J qOm �uw g Z �"(�jsw�j�R WlL<ii` E< �F�O �i p�Nlniz gFF�a�e � i i ���< l 9-S." �O-6 B Smo v��iYa� Bs � 2�, �o e � masm g<�a �' s�� � _8 � k > �� ` � o= `S�gmia F �� 5 - 3ZZ? ��y' Di L=" FN< px �s g ��� g m<>�oNN� `� gym � o _ g�WW - m5Em w o? ai �i'mu�= ;45 NogG E�ag�?$�€egg w`abl ���$� �`�.��c�j�z<��w ��i���<:m� B`n S �?Wg _ ,� g �w`g 3 k��s sm8P;.-El- cS� _<�mugmF �F�uINNicm,5`-0�� d�a����$ 6u K'm �g�����eg,�g.-°-F.rc �m gz�c ga ��bK.'$�=ioui5tl o g�,�moomWii�a< Elg� =tlmE€ E< Im8� N -<� i i �o�= i 'o` �`m �� x ma�o�;;�a<e � QV... rwo1- dig=atHeN'a womrc�=In h«g3< � g<?uogus�x°�m�eirc 8 x=A b =�a�F<i � € wIB`pb (� R al 0 g �g W 2� ag So a'3 j m 12 Bgo= $ g 1' w€ p twj~�U�ow� �'rmw� � ���po� � ��1 8 �Na � S gF Smw31 i F ���` � 3F4gl`i SM g� g 8 "- n��S < F a" m � � � � �<w ��N���` � < wgg 2 11m B � � SF � <�� $ �$ m w � iz �� �m �m ~ 3�= <wgYwW R (l�wRpp <Nz 3a � Z 22�=m �Za�l¢¢ � $w 2 � � 2 F=<� 4o m¢ZV z ¢&y FiF�u`~i<<2m�m U li X g<e @ s�w�� Y �m �R^���<_= 3 ��~ s���ax"� ' a=a �` F F t2 g` K' ��s i r�ama 0 _� � b a �wogw=s�<� � � ��o `� 3 Kia= ��� ff Q� �F8� m � get 'qq �m owwg� €�on�n o g � m g � gn 3 ��� �o � mZ�WB p Foam Z aiz� Zrc '6 o °<p g` <n mg�ao� g ow m w �z i Ei?� `� � M. �o< 3F g �E=EW �� N. � s 5� • �im� q _ � o� w8 Ste+? $ox 3 cS`�m9 = z`< F W `��ww8g�� ,S&,<�S i �€�R m'��g i� & `SSS' Ega � WRER- i � P 8�8�w 12 �qq � g.9 �- w y 12—n-i �� L° c6m a�� <m�m g Zm�n �Ew � ��<Wb NE5 woydRmR 3ii� sok' R^ n4 i gS `off �3`ww ,..� 4=`< �� �s o€ m �_ `%� F� � <-a2 Sa �3gomwx �`o Eww $ `IO`�< ,,.�{µp. ]�� ? €iM� O mRM. f'�<'<a -0 dYfg" .� .. .Sa FF g ((S5FS a` ��g�� ` 7� ¢�gg��Wm�,g=R ��� `�F`�iN�G `. -Uf a Ft �y w S ��w8 g gg�=a ��?I�Iw =m ,,g-p7dmmu<'� K. SINE Ng m� ?OZ <�5 i��ui�2 � g � <ac� o <�Z& 'w� i�� G � 8 E o €3 17 $i�w F gmygGo Pdt qq IT!^ ymj<w�w�g�� z2 iw�uw� zO=�ggznwa ` § z2< b6i1. n= -� Sgt <w �mo� 3�`� � K =in3 �$ w tdr< m < S � S �S� g. <m in�m�no �g�� F Z yJ �wU Z < _ wB Q ��` F n— � ar3d <<�=ma �g � F=o6Bn WN a B ��e"a w yUFF F FF o� B = ��M� �m7 I-m (�J F jF-zUBA 0^iswrm� n 8�5C nzm m, m� <n� 0 .a :saip< ��< R.5252 Q d m w Ir L j " � c Zjl m = o�om g � W � ON W ~ W �I m Q p W �I-W QQm Q Q 'S SOU W C) � J Z ti II II II Q Q U ti v W II II W U op � II = Q Z Wvp II tiQ O N W U Li p II II II N�� O .0 SY Q) N C, c� I Qi� Z 214) Qp0= LO � V Vi• V,� � cn � \ r� I J U', zi O O QZ� Z'ncno W�Q� o�oN tip � QW-- Q� CO QTY^ LL- OQQW�LO Z CU O voi=�z U: I—p—� m �W2)�� al ?ticn� OQ � it]§lull J� y�� Q:�N _R5 Q�Z� WW2 �Z�� Z—o4i time W QZLo N s Lrl fB ��o ^ O OJOO �~�zi > 0= �� x I—~LLJj Z� O (oLo � W W o LQ o � m ,� Cd O OJ O-- pO —"K zti� o /Jo 76 S1O7 '9 �13 (o .0 ys7 Q J ry O Z K- � Q I) Q) Q W 'or O Q �h N 0 v IP N ~ .or � o � 'o. ,F£ m �gy N WSW- O 03/1 yo, —Z — - .97 u CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy Ann Kasten Aker George Delafield, Jr. February 20, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 28, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1-24-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. July 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. August 2013 -No Meeting VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Bernard and Stephanie Molyneux, owners of the property located at 915 Emerald Row, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 64, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida a. VARIANCE to allow a roof replacement on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling, of a color and material that do not conform to the provisions of Sections 70-107 and 70-238 of the Gulf Stream Zoning Code. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the installation of a brown, flat cement tile roof, replacing the existing wood shake roof, on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling 2. An application submitted by William Ring, Commerce Group, Inc. as agent for Martin O'Boyle, owner of property located at 23 Hidden Harbour Dr., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. VARIANCE #1 to allow a net addition 109 square feet to the front entry feature of the existing non- conforming two-story single family dwelling that currently exceeds the maximum permitted floor area ratio by 2,589 square feet. b. VARIANCE #2 to permit the first -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 12.5 feet by 2.5 feet to the architectural element. AGENDA CONTINUED C. VARIANCE #3 to permit the second -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 23 feet by 2 feet. d. VARIANCE #4 to permit an additional 2 foot encroachment beyond the existing 9 foot 8 inch front setback encroachment. e. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove 229 square feet of gross floor area. f. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition for a cumulative increase of 109 square feet to an existing 8,001 square foot, non -conforming, Spanish Mediterranean Revival, two-story single family dwelling. 3. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates, Inc. as agent for Mr.& Mrs. Robert Julian, owners of property located at 1601 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described in metes and bounds in Government Lot 1, Section 10, Township 46 South, Range 43 East. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition of 392 square feet to the south east corner of the existing Spanish Mediterranean Revival style single family dwelling, to enclose an existing breezeway on the north side of the dwelling and to install a roof over the existing trellis connection to the existing guest house. 4. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates, Inc., as agent for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, Jr., owners of the property located at 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 21 and part of Lot 20 in Gulf Steam Cove Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to permit the extension of the non -conforming south wall of the existing structure, that encroaches a maximum of 1 foot into the south side setback, to add a master bedroom of approximately 302 square feet to be located on the first floor. b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit the addition of the proposed 302 square foot master bedroom to extend 20 feet into the 50 foot rear setback. C. DEMOLITION PERMIT to allow small portion of existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 car garage. d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a master bedroom, a small addition to the kitchen, a realignment of the 2 car garage and a new front entry, a net increase of 540 square feet on the first floor of an existing partial two story Neo - French Eclectic single family dwelling. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. AGENDA CONTINUED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 24, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. 8:35 II Call to Order. Chairman Morgan called the meeting to order at A.M. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Scott Morgan Tom Smith Paul Lyons Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy George Delafield Ann Aker William Thrasher Rita Taylor John Randolph Tom Laudani of Seaside Builders Richard Jones of Jones Architects Dave Bodker of Dave Bodker Landscape & Architecture Joe Pike of EnviroDesign George Brewer of Brewer Architecture, Inc. Mr. and Mrs. Ross Jones William Himmelrich Chairman Board Member Board Member Board Member Board Member Alt. Member Alt. Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Agent/1275 N. Ocean LLC Architect/1275 N. Ocean LLC Landscape Architect/ 1275 N. Ocean LLC Engineer/1275 N. Ocean LLC Agent/Jones Applicant/450 Banyan 1304 N. Ocean Blvd. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 12-27-12. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve the Minutes of the December 27, 2012 Regular Meeting and Public Hearing. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes to the Agenda. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. February 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. July 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Morgan noted the Meeting Schedule. There were no conflicts with the February meeting date. Mr. Lyons stated that he would not be present for the March meeting. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 2 VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval Chairman Morgan asked for declarations of Ex -parte communication concerning any of the applications being heard today. Mr. Lyons stated that he met with William Thrasher concerning the condition for approval for 450 Banyan. Chairman Morgan stated that he spoke with Mr. Paul-Hus of 3500 N. Ocean Blvd. who asked for some concerning design matters. Mr. Randolph noted that full Board membership is not present, and he said Code provides that for an application to be approved, a motion requires three-fifths vote or greater in favor to pass. He said there are four Board Members present and three members would have to vote in favor to pass a motion. Further, he said the Code provides applicants the option to either make their presentation to less than a full Board or to come back and make their presentation to a full Board. Tom Laudani of Seaside Builders said his application for 1275 N. Ocean Blvd. is a Level III, the ARPB will make a recommendation only to the Commission, and, he said he would prefer to have his presentation heard at this time. Clerk Taylor said one of the two applications being presented by Mr. Brewer is a Level II and this Board will have final approval on that. Mr. Brewer said he would prefer to have both applications heard today. 1. An application submitted by Seaside Builders LLC, as Agent for 1275 N. Ocean LLC, the owners of property located at 1275 N. Ocean Blvd, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 7 and 50' of Lot 6, Revised Plat of Elks. D&E of Palm Beach Shores Estates. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to clear building site and re- arrange/remove existing landscape material. C. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to supplement existing landscaping and install rail fence and entrance gate. d. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to allow 300 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum floor area permitted. e. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit construction of a dune crossover. f. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of 11,566 square foot Bermuda style, single family, partial 2 -story dwelling with guest quarters, attached 3 car garage, outdoor pavilion and swimming pool and dune crossover. Richard Jones of Jones Architects introduced himself. He said this property is located across from Harbor View Estates and they want to be somewhat consistent with the architectural style of the subdivision, but he said this property will be unique in its own right. Mr. Jones said the home will be a partial two-story traditional Bermuda style with an attached 3 -car garage and guest quarters above. There will be a front Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 3 motor court and a pool courtyard to the east with an outdoor pavilion overlooking the ocean. Mr. Jones said the property is very secluded and cannot be seen from A1A when driving by, and he said they want to maintain the estate -like feel. He said much of what you see when you enter the property will remain, but with the addition of several upgrades. Further, he said access to the property will not change, there will be entry gates and piers along the street, and the defining feature of the house, common to the Bermuda style, will be the parapets on the front elevation. The structure will feature overhangs with traditional cypress wood out -lookers, wood carriage garage doors, shutters and decorative railings, with landscape walls and gates on the interior of the property. The covered loggia will feature a two-sided fireplace, Bermuda grass will extend to the pool edge to maintain the natural environment, and six large Bending Coconut Palms will also extend to the pool edge. Mr. Jones said the exterior will be white stucco with a white mitered roof and Sherwood Green shutters, rails and overhangs. Chairman Morgan asked if the peak of the roof is the highest point. Mr. Jones said the peak of the roof is 33.7' and the chimney pots are just below 35', a foot higher than the ridge of the house, but he said the pots are a decorative feature and can be dropped in height if made a condition of approval. Mr. Lyons asked why shutters are not shown on all windows. Mr. Jones said shutters will be used on the majority of windows that are in view, and Bahama shutters will be used on some of other windows. Mr. Lyons asked if the front Ficus and Sea Grapes will remain. Dave Bodker, the Landscape Architect, confirmed that, and he said as much of the existing front vegetation as possible will remain. Mr. Lyons asked about the planting of Australian Pines. Mr. Thrasher said the clear zone is yet to be determined, but Australian Pines will be planted where possible. Mr. Smith asked about the wall on the south side which frames the right-of-way. Mr. Jones said it will be a stepped masonry wall, it will follow the same profile as the existing wall on the south side of the right-of-way and it will be painted the same color as the existing wall. Chairman Morgan referred to the streetscape elevation and said the home appears to be connected to a wall on the north side that runs to the property line. Mr. Jones said it is part of the design feature. Chairman Morgan said it may be permissible, but there is a 15' setback. Mr. Jones said it is a garden wall and could be set back a few feet. Mr. Randolph said when it is attached to the structure it is deemed to be a part of the structure. Mr. Jones said it appears seamless, but it is not physically attached and falls under the Code as a perimeter wall. Clerk Taylor said this wall acts as a barrier for the swimming pool and most houses have something to connect to the property line such as a wall or a chain link fence. Mr. Thrasher said there is no real restriction on such a wall and he would not argue against it. Dave Bodker of Dave Bodker Landscape & Architecture introduced himself and addressed the vegetation along N. Ocean Blvd. saying north of the Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 4 driveway is a huge existing Strangler Fig and south of the driveway there are a number of existing trees including Tropical Almond, Gumbo Limbo and Sea Grapes with multiple trunks. Day Palms under -planted with Coolers and various annuals will be planted along the radius walls on the west elevation. Mr. Bodker said they propose 5' high columns or piers along A1A with a 4' railing between them, and a railing -type entrance gate that will match the railing between piers. In the interior, Day Palms under -planted with shrubs will flank the motor court, and a series of Sea Grapes separating public access from the home on the south elevation will be filled in with Green Buttonwoods and Sabal Palms. Toward the back they propose Silver Buttonwods with Coconut Palms on either side, and plantings on the north elevation will be similar. Mrs. Jones said she finds the parapets to be very sharp in design, much like pagoda architecture, and she asked if they considered rounding them out. Mr. Jones said they are consistent with the Bermuda style and minimize mass. Mr. Morgan commented that the parapets are a prominent feature. Mr. Thrasher said he likes the uniqueness of the parapets and the Board tries to encourage creativity. He said he likes the look, but they do seem to be prominent. Mr. Jones said they can lower the parapets about one foot and drop the chimneys down about 16 inches. Mr. Laudani agreed to that. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Jones to address the front setback required distance and what is being proposed. Mr. Jones said the required front setback is 50' and they are at 78.2' to the garage and roughly 130' to the main structure, which provides a very large setback. William Himmelrich of 1304 N. Ocean Blvd. introduced himself and said he was present at the request of Mr. George Elmore who could not attend and wanted his concerns brought forward. He said the neighbors are aware of the project and they think it is terrific. He said the first concern is for the existing vegetation along A1A and that it not be disrupted, and he said the other concern is with parking along A1A. Mr. Himmelrich said construction can generate a lot of work vehicles and they are hoping contractors will be considerate. In closing, Mr. Himmelrich asked to see a drawing of the south elevation if available. He was able to view the south elevation. Mr. Laudani said he spoke with Mr. Elmore and addressed the parking concerns. He said there will be no construction parking along A1A and that the staging areas and all construction parking for 1275 N. Ocean Blvd. will be along the hammerhead in the subdivision directly across the street. Mr. Laudani added that he will work with Chief Ward to develop the traffic management plan before this application goes to the Town Commission. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a demolition permit to remove the existing structure. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a land clearing permit to clear the building site and re-arrange/remove existing landscape materials. There was no Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 5 discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to supplement existing landscaping and install a rail fence and entrance gate. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception to allow 300 SF of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum floor area permitted. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception to permit construction of a dune crossover. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed construction of 11,566 SF Bermuda style, single family, partial 1 -story dwelling with guest quarters, attached 3 -car garage, outdoor pavilion and swimming pool and dune crossover meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. The electric service lines shall be buried; 2. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping; 3. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached; 4. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view; 5. The landscape plan will protect existing Australian pine trees and provide a 13' clear zone from white travel line where possible allowing for the planting by the Town of two to ten Australian pine trees; 6. The two chimney heights will each be lowered by 16"; and 7. A construction parking plan will be coordinated with the Town of Gulf Stream and the Gulf Stream Police Department. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 2. An application submitted by George Brewer as agent for Ross and Katherine Jones, owners of property located at 450 Banyan Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 4, Elk. 1, Plat No. 1 Polo Fields Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to completely remove the existing second story of existing structure. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a bedroom wing and covered loggia on the south east corner and an addition to existing bedroom on the south west corner, along with a new entry feature, a total of 1,431 square feet, to the existing Bermuda style single family dwelling and new landscaping and driveway. George Brewer of Brewer Architecture, Inc., Agent for Mr. and Mrs. Jones, introduced himself and described the existing home, located on the corner of Banyan and Polo, as a classic Florida Ranch. He said the goal is to beautify the home by removing the wood -framed second story addition, change it to a Bermuda style and bring it to Code. Mr. Brewer Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 6 said the home has never been renovated, except for an outdoor porch which was enclosed and air-conditioned. They will improve the interior, add a new wing to the house, create a backyard courtyard and outdoor loggia, replace the landscaping, modify the pool deck and add a spa. They will extend the existing master bedroom to add a bathroom, remove all aluminum awnings, replace all windows and add shutters and they will redo the driveway, replacing asphalt with pavers. There will be a new entry feature, crown molding along the soffits and they will add a chimney for the new interior fireplace. Mr. Brewer said the exterior will be painted Creme Fleece, the shutters will be a grayish blue and the trim and roof will be a flat white. Mr. Lyons asked about the condition of approval. Mr. Thrasher said the finished floor elevation is 6.3' and the flood elevation required in that zone is 7'. He said the existing home is below the flood elevation and to maintain our CSR Rating and Certification FEMA requires that the Town have the applicant/owner go through an analysis evaluation to prove, state and certify that the additions and changes are not greater than 500 of the value of the structure. He said the Town is required to ask for this certification and to retain in their records. The owner retained an appraiser and the Town has provided forms to be completed. Mrs. Ross stated that she is not exactly sure of the colors and they may change. Mr. Thrasher said any changes in color must be approved by the Town Manager. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Demolition Permit to remove the entire second story. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition of a bedroom wing and covered loggia on the south east corner and an addition to existing bedroom on the south west corner, along with a new entry feature, a total of 1,431 SF, to the existing Bermuda style single family dwelling and new landscaping and driveway meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following condition: (1) Prior to permitting, applicant's agent shall demonstrate and verify that the proposed additions and improvements do not exceed 500 of the market value of the structures before "start of construction". There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 3. An application submitted by George Brewer as agent for Richard Paul-Hus, owner of the property located at 3500 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Part of Lot 55, lying west of westerly right-of-way line of State Road A -1-A, plus the east 1- of Palm Way, lying west of and adjacent to said Lot, Gulf Stream Properties No. 2, as in Plat Book 18, Page 42, Public Records of Palm Beach County Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BLVD. OVERLAY PERMIT to allow the reconfiguration of existing driveway, construction of a fireplace and enhanced landscaping within the North Ocean Blvd. Corridor. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 7 b. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL\SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition of 32 square feet and renovation of an existing partial two story, single family dwelling of Monterey Vernacular style and the addition of an outside fireplace, reconfiguration of existing driveway and enhancement of existing landscaping. Mr. Brewer, Architect and Agent for Mr. Paul-Hus, said a large family with four children and one on the way will be moving into this very modest Monterey style home. He said the modifications to this home are mostly interior and he summarized the proposed improvements, as follows: There are two bedrooms on the 2nd floor, one of which will be divided into two bedrooms, the kitchen will be relocated, they will create an outdoor environment, a new front courtyard entry, a new side entry for the children and the laundry room will be moved to the garage. The exterior of the ground level is stucco, the second story is board and batting with a tile roof and they will add a small chimney. All windows will be single -hung hurricane impact with shutters, there will be a new garage door and the second floor will be re -strapped to bring it up to Code. Mr. Brewer said the existing driveway entrance from A1A is a disaster and very difficult to maneuver in and out. He said the driveway will be reconfigured to allow safe exit onto A1A. Mr. Smith referred to the additional right-of-way piece and asked if it could be used for turning. Mr. Thrasher said the application was examined based on the property they own and it was concluded that the additional right-of-way was not on their property and cannot be used. Mr. Brewer said they also wanted to install a gate for security for the children, but he said he was told that gates are not permitted in the central Core. Mr. Thrasher said the plan showed a gate and he asked that it be removed. He said gates in the Core area are prohibited and he provided the Agent with the option of the owner applying for a variance, which would be a Level III, where the Board would be the recommending body and the final decision would rest with the Commission. Mr. Thrasher referred to Page 70-78 of the Code, Section 70-187(5), Gulf Stream Core, where it talks about entrance gates and provides that all gates are prohibited. Mr. Brewer said he heard it is rare for the Commission to grant a variance. Mr. Randolph said variances have been granted; however, he said the criteria in the Code are strict. You must show hardships that are unique to the property and not common to other area properties. You must apply so that surrounding neighbors will be noticed, and he said you should not be discouraged to apply. Mr. Smith said the owner should consider applying for a variance to install a gate for the security of the children. Chairman Morgan asked if the second right-of-way was unique to this property. Mr. Thrasher said he was not sure what that right-of-way piece is and cannot answer the question. Mrs. Jones asked the height of the wall surrounding the pool area, which includes the fireplace. Mr. Brewer said it is an existing wall with a picket fence detail along the top, it is 4' to 4.5' high and it will not be altered. He said there is a courtyard type Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - January 24, 2013 Page 8 entrance with a gate and they will correct that space to provide a sense of direction. Mr. Lyons asked about the regulations for outdoor showers. Mr. Thrasher said they are not prohibited, but he said they must be attached to the wall with no overhang, it must be greater than 2.5' and it cannot encroach on the FAR. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit based on a finding that the proposed reconfiguration of an existing driveway, construction of a fireplace and enhanced landscaping within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay zone meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve a Level II Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition of 32 SF and renovation of an existing partial two-story, single family dwelling of Monterey Vernacular style, the addition of an outside fireplace and the reconfiguration of an existing driveway that includes enhancement of existing landscape, meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. VII. Items by Staff. There were no items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. Mr. Smith asked about items coming up on the February Agenda. Clerk Taylor said there are three applications for February, and Mr. Thrasher said there is a variance request on one application. Clerk Taylor said Mark Marsh brought in two applications, one of which is for a remodel of Mrs. Jones' former home and the other is an application for 1601 N. Ocean, which includes two small additions and the conversion of a trellised walkway to a roof -covered walkway. She said the variance request is by Mr. Molyneux in Place Au Soleil for a re -roof replacing cedar shake with a flat cement tile, but he does not want to use white tile and the color is the issue. Mr. Smith noted that Seaside Builders should work with the Police Department with regard to traffic management and parking for the 1275 N. Ocean project. Mr. Thrasher said the construction traffic for this project should not be an issue due to their easy access to the hammerhead in the subdivision across the street. IX. Public. There were no items by the Public X. Adjournment. Being no further business to come before the Board, Chairman Morgan adjourned the meeting at 9:55 A.M. Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-4 Address: 915 Emerald Row Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Bernard & Stephanie Molyneux Agent: Self Roof Material Variance: To allow a roof replacement on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling, of a color and material that do not conform to the provisions of Sections 70-107 and 70-238 of the Gulf Stream Zoning Code Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the installation of a brown, flat cement tile roof, replacing the existing wood shake roof, on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling. Architectural Style: G/S Bermuda Neighborhood: Mixed Issues Considered During Review: Section 66-154 Standards (For Granting Variances) see page CD66:46 and CD66:47 There are eight (8) standards to be reviewed in granting a variance. All eight standards must be met in order to allow a variance. For example, if seven (7) standards are met and only one was not met, the variance should be denied. Section 70-107 Additions and rehabiliations, and replacement of existing features. (e) Prohibited. Use of prohibited design elements not present on the existing structure. Section 70-238 Roofs. (d) Prohibited. Tiles other than zvhite flat untextured tiles or gray slate tiles. NOTE. The owner is proposing an entire re -roofing with a brown/tan concrete tile material that is prohibited. The applicant has provided certification that the roof can accommodate the additional loads imposed on by replacing the existing shingles with concrete tile. Recommendation: Motion to recommend denial of a variance based on a finding that the proposed brown/tan concrete roof material is prohibited by Gulf Stream Zoning Code Sections 70-107 and 70-238. Additionally, none of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met as defined in Section 66-154. Motion to recommend denial of Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on the finding that the proposed brown/tan concrete roof material is prohibited by Gulf Stream Zoning Code Sections 70-107 and 70-238, and none of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met as defined in Section 66-154. Architectural'Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-04 ARPB February 28, 2013 TC March 15, 2013 ARPB Date: February 28, 2013 Action: Variance: Recommended denial for above reasons. (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend denial for above reasons. (5-0) TC Date: March 15, 2013 Action: Page 2 Variance: Installation of Brown tile was denied but Grey slate like tile was approved (5-0) Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved with gray slate like tile. (5-0) NOTE: Several days after this hearing, Mr. Molyneux advised staff that he would be using the white thru and thru, 9" tiles that conform to the Code provisions. Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ► RECEIVED,, JAN 112013 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by theTownof+Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: e i a i 6W 5 fG 6 ant c /V f 0I ll eL I.A.2. Project Address: // 5 Jrmefa Id ROW I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: T latce A4 So I -e; / L D _r G I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.)_ 12ro I6V 40 o -F 6 le- I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: /V //4 Architectural Style: "gti l 1.A.6. Check all that apply: VArchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: Type of Foundation: B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: q/5 F moiot!d1 ?o w I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: 0 7 LB.3. Owner Signature: 13� ,��� _ C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: �/ Q(,�JnQr Into 0/P SG/!�i g yyt fe/ I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) cell Fax 1C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include tTo be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but question number for each response. he appropriate and complete A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? S III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? )V"7es ❑ No Explain. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? �s ❑ No Explain. "' III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage b. Sanitary Sewer c. Potable Water d. Irrigation Water e. Electricity f. Telephone g. Gas h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes k1_0 (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yesto (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes k No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does thepr ject require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes WNo (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6.I_ sAhe project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? AYes ❑ No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town'of Gulf Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? 10 ^ /U 7 aeY IV -G-2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? %tJhP/CyC/ pySSI'ble' �'Yis�'n5 o��sroura s ��✓ �►� fro%;6;k� ��s,'y.-�-C/<.Yr��� Shams l� rem 0✓rd 'e all4leklil IV.G.3. What is proposed? t (ela(e/yfelr� r IV.G.4. What is the total variance req ested? k rfsu /ed W ccs IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance additional sheet if necessary.) / a E e X; 9 wuoa(slt Q lCP roo ,./- 4 4/ /A dark. �s4- 7o n o� be C la u 14> - loh; k o✓ 514 gs from Section 66-154, must b addressed: /(f - (Attach (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? fit{ 2x�.sh'.�y rood �ilC is �' da/ll waa�l Shti lCP rood wh,'c� was �< c';/ed ►�� ��s�. aw��� w A (2) Did the special condition and circumstances result trom the act ons of the applicant? Yes (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is de ni by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? /Yes o Explain: �1,( pro 19OSeG( %00� alise �4 101146116 W 7110 as ;f has f)(rsk-d dor ' o✓e( o?O vears. (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant?{ Gi / (e(et4 (cika r -ed gr �°/ �C u n /►1 Tb /1 Sfa �)�Cru/y a 4kcsG6., av pe D� -'A-e -e%ec- �;on (5) Is the Variance requese minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land building or structure? es No / Explain: %Gt/tA'ly -A,.5 1!G/r G R �{ j tVlll /iO7 A -�kC-�- QA V Su it ow? off ; •, proged y owAor.s A-ec A u fe A�e Sm-�e c f- a. (r> / 5 CGt r/Ln :�(q V VV (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent wn goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoninance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental tothepublic welfare? Ye No Explain: V6j r16i n Y' GU/ /tO 7 /J P a'e-& eit 1-ci % //! G'n c✓ lNQy• P/vlpOs-ew fe0 l< Gc/i��� Sinn'e�V s h g YD /P ae/ya, S �7OGS Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 11 ui iJult Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV -H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Comprehensive Plan text change, o Zoning ar g Code text change, justification for the request. y mbination thereof, Future Land Use Map change, Please describe the need and PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants, q additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere Applicants are encouraged, but not required, to provide any the other materials submitted with fhe application. on flus form or on any of n= . a - (Sr !� 5am� 0J IrA 4k, Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/0/00 �014LJ L_ r'o p� c_,e , 4- 16r-a��. /cl—� Page 7 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.6.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.8.4. How is the design consistent with the Al Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E• Projects Re gtuiring a Special Exception. IV.E,1, Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? 0 Yes ❑ No Code Section: IV.E,2. How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? IV.E.3, Will the use cause substantial injury be located? p Yes ❑ No ry to the value of other Property in the neighborhoo d where it is to Explain. IV.E,4. Hoy, will the use be compatible with adjoining development I is to be located? pment and the character of the District where' t IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? [I Yes El No Explain. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units W.F.I. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F,2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential im acts Properties. P on surrounding IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 February, 23, 2013 Rita L. Taylor, Town Clerk Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 ► RECEIVED q FEB 2 6 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL Re: Public Hearings on Thursday, February 28, 2013 at 8:30am and Friday, March 15, 2013 at 11:00am at which the following will be considered: Application submitted by Bernard and Stephanie Molyneux, owners of the property located at 915 Emerald Row, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legaly described as Lot 64, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida for the following: Variance to allow a roof replacement on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, one story dwelling, of a color and material that do not conform to the provisions of Sections 70-107 and 70-238 of the Gulf Stream Zoning Code. Level 3 Architectural/site plan review to permit the installation of a brown, flat cement tile roof, replacing the existing wood shake roof, on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling. Dear Ms. Taylor, Unfortunately, We are unable to attend either of the hearings cited above, but wish to advise all parties concerned that, as neighbors (directly across the street at 2700 Place An Soleil), we have no objections to the granting of the above requested proposals by Bernard and Stephanie Molyneux, and therefor encourage the appropriate boards to approve the requests. We believe their proposals will enhance and further beautify our lovely neighborhood. Cordially, Thomas Kubricky and Terri Kubricky, owners 2700 Place Au Soleil Gulf Stream, Florida c: hand delivered to Bernard and Stephanie Molyneux LUIS F ORTEGA, PE Civil/Structural Engineer November 28, 2012 Royal Palm Roofing Palm Bch County, Florida Re: STRUCTURAL INVESTIGATION OF EXTSTTNG ROOF SYSTEM TO REPLACE SHINGLES WITH TILES Single Family Home 9l' Etrlerilld Row Delray Bch, Florida Gentlemen, An inspection was conducted on November 26, 2012 per your request to verify the actual structural condition of the existing roof at above referenced residence, and its adequacy to accommodate the additional loads imposed on by replacing the existing shingles with tiles. By visual observation and structural analysis it was verified that the existing roof system including the wood deck, the trusses and their metal plates, the rafters and the ridge beams, is in good condition and it is adequate to receive the Additional loaUs of the new tiles. However, the roof to wall connection of the rafters could not be verified at the time of this inspection. Therefore, this has to be verified before the work, and it needs to be done with metal connectors fastened to the tie beam. Additionally, the weight of the new tiles shall not exceed 12 PSF to be verified per the NOA of the tile manufacturer. If you have any questions or concerns in regards to the above matter, please do not hesitate to contact our JJ.��.,,., 94AN n^} -7 ono Thant,, VIIiVV at (94 /J/�LTU4. Lhant,, YOU.. Ti Li Reg. 61145 1 OF 1 116 HIDDEN CT ROAD, HOLLYWOOD, FLORIDA 33023 TEL: 954.937.2484 FAX: 954.962.1801 l r F. AbAL TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT February 28, 2013 Application #: 013-05 Owner: Martin O'Boyle Address: 23 Hidden Harbour Dr. Agent: Bill Ring, Commerce Group, Inc. Proposed Improvement: Addition with alterations to an existing Spanish Mediterranean Revival single family dwelling totaling 109 SF. Approvals Requested Variance (1) : To allow a net addition of 109 SF to the front entry feature of the existing non -conforming two-story single family dwelling that currently exceeds the maximum permitted floor area ratio by 2,589 SF. Variance (2): To permit the first -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 12.5 feet by 2.5 feet to the architectural element. Variance (3): To permit the second -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 23 feet by 2 feet. Variance (4): Demolition: Level III Architectural/Site Plan Proposed Floor Area: 8,110 SF Zoning District: N/S Background: To permit an additional 2 foot encroachment beyond the existing 9 foot 8 inch front setback encroachment. To remove 229 SF of gross floor area. To permit an addition of a cumulative increase of 109 SF to an existing 8,001 SF, non -conforming, Spanish Mediterranean Revival, two-story single family dwelling. Allowable: 5,521 SF At the request of the Town, Mr. Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday Studios was asked to evaluate and provide his findings of the proposed application. That report is provided as backup to the staff's report. Both Mr. Minor and staff are in agreement and consistent with their findings and that there are four variance created by the proposed application. Issues Considered During Review: Division 3. Variances Section 70-71 Floor area ratios. Section 70-74 Setbacks. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-05 ARPB Thursday February 28, 2013; TC March 15, 2013 Page 2 Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks. Section 70-77. First floor elevation. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights. Section 70-101. Windows. Recommendations Motion to Recommend Denial of a variance to allow a net addition of 109 SF to the front entry feature of the existing non -conforming two-story single family dwelling that currently exceeds the maximum permitted floor area ratio by 2,589 SF based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. Motion to Recommend Denial of a variance to permit the first -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 12.5 feet by 2.5 feet to the architectural element based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. Motion to Recommend Denial of a variance to permit the second -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 23 feet by 2 feet of the architectural element based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. Motion to Recommend Denial of a variance to permit an additional 2 foot encroachment beyond the existing 9 foot 8 inch front setback encroachment based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. Motion to Recommend Denial to remove 229 SF of gross floor area as the proposed alterations to not meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. Motion to Recommend Denial Level III Architectural/Site Plan to permit a cumulative increase of 109 SF to the existing 8,001 SF, non -conforming, Spanish Mediterranean Revival, two-story single family dwelling does not meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB: February 28, 2013 Action: Variance (1): Recommended denial for reasons listed above. (5-0) Action: Variance (2): (5-0) Action: Variance (3): (5-0) Action: Variance (4): (5-0) Action: Demolition: (4-1) Action: Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Recommended denial for reasons listed above. (5-0) Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-05 ARPB Thursday February 28, 2013; TC March 15, 2013 Page 3 Town Commission Date: March 15, 2013 Action: Variance (1): Granted. (3-2) Action: Variance (2): Denied. (3-2) Action: Variance (3): Denied. (3-2) Action: Variance (4): Denied. (4-1) Action: Demolition: Denied. (4-1) Action: Level III Architectural/Site Plan: Denied. (5-0) NOTE: At this same meeting the Town Commission, sitting as the Board of Adjustment, heard an APPEAL, filed by Mr. O'Boyle, of Mr. Thrasher's decision that variances would be needed to modify this structure as is being requested. The Board of Adjustment sustained Mr. Thrasher's decision that all four of the variances would be necessary. (See File # 13-8) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ,..,. . w _-, �._ APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL JAN 15 20,13 To%vn of Gu;f ^ yrt, ;rL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Revlew and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information PART II, GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File #___1_3 -C-- I.A.I. Project/OwnerName: _-MAON 6 S YLP I.A.2. ProJectAddress; I.A.3, Project Property Legal Description: LbT 6 , (Dppkj WIVeM C6TAT6� RIAA&A... 1A _ n ,....v, i i eu K INN r K its 0 CALM $W uNty t ko?-10A , I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detaA, including # of stories, etc,) w EN TUt '-D`` mftm�. WI r� NEW NT12 t 5t [ L.16NT5 . I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: bITI Architectural style: _SCA14 9 lagAXW WYIVAL _ I.A.6. Check all that apply: �Archileclural/Site Plan Review D Land Clearing 0 -North 0 n out and Overlay (complete sect n B) X Demolition of Structures 0 Non-residential u s Vari ce k (complete secti6n G) ZSpeclal Exception (complete section.F) I,A.7. (a) Proposed F,F.E.: NO CNAN6� 1.98 Type of Foundation: j pp WTI N6 B. Owner Information ^� I.B.I . Owner Address: MAK TIM b ' 6 l LE I.B.2. Owner Phone NumberASH - 560 AT s Fax: 5 - 0 - 0001 I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information M ', I L F'�#� ¢ �IFLOP�t I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: _WILLIAM AN6lblmmft 6ftQ v . I.C.2. Agent Address: 1.C.3. Agent Phone Number: c Fax !% LCA. Agent Signature: I n Pre -App Date; App Date: Com Dale: Decision: ARPB Date: Recommendallon: TC Date: kb .41/'O Application for Development Approval form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Guif Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM En APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the To.vn of Gulf Stream .Architec(ural Review and Planning Board, Board of AdWlmenl, and)'or Town Comm!ssfon. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gull Stream lnstrucUon Manual forApp,',rcation for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form property will delay Its consideration. ARPB File # PART IL GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed bya;lappa+cauls. A. Project Information n �r I.A1. Fro;ecUbwnerName: MAIZnN U`F)v1l.L I.A.2. Project Address;_ 2J HaN I.A.3. Protect Property Legal Description: j MW RAMK G'j'A'[ 6 hW6 D tHT `►1 b� �S 12 ►H P }T EW 116, W Ik(, Fmo)5 of Pace 66WO ODUNty t �=>A. I.A,4. Project Descripllon (describe in detarl, including # ofstories, etc,) AWTION Df- ANT iy , ?p' -o" � f F WI rg MEW ENTq bDN t s,be l,tt3NT5 . I.A.5. Square Footage of NewStruclureorAddiJon:IiaZ�A.�T -UN N41TjONAL Architectural Style:—,—'AgrPy mfbjTfgAt,)uwpnvAL 1.A-6. Check a!I that.ppiy:YArch"lecturaVS3e Plan Revl Av 0 Land Clearing 0 North 0 out and Overlay (complete serY n B) IxDemollEon of Structures 0 Non-residential u s Vari ca (complete Becton GJ Zpeclal Exception (complete seclionFJ 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F•F.E.: NO NHN9*41 1 Type of Foundation: & B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address:. MWIR b"6KE I.B.2. Owner Phone N ber: Fax:q- aO� �Uy� 1.8.3, Owner S!gnature: C. Agent Information ,, I ''/,=z(f F'Y�qE't I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: _1V ILiinwh�AN6 r1E�fl+tPt� I.C.2, Agent Address: I"�QYKv,,fl�rGrIblc7 r.GfV `R I,��{,.jz Jtj I.C,3. Agent Phone Number: {oT p'J i �� V' (p, i �J7 Fell% NVQ b�D� 1.C.4, Agent Signature: Or ici s_ n. Pre -App Dale: ARP3 Dale; App Date: Recommendation; Com Date: TC Dale: Dec'is!on: Application for Development Approval Form ADA2000 revised 6113100 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference -with Town Staff. please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question. number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? WTH III,A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? 16s []No Explain. T44P AIRAI MtV-r. AKI 2✓7,. I i _ ., _ . , III.A.3. Is the project"cnnsisrmv''— the Future Comprehensive Plan? 0 Yes []No Explain, WWI Lana use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the T III.A.4. How are Ingress and egress to the property to be provided? III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage_ b. Sanitary Sewer n c. Potable Water 14 r d. Irrigation Water e. Electricity_ NDq f. Telephone Np N g. Gas 00 h. Cable Televisinn ►►n ��,A. . III.A,6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria In Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) UM1% D 4W SVILOINElt MA1*5 r- m1% I I v. Huui i IUNAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff, Answering "Yes"to anyquestlon in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements N.A.I. Does the project i valve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right -of. way? 0 Yes VNO (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed,) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures?Yes 0 No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an exii vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? 0 Yes VNo (If "Yes", section D of tills part must be completed.) IV -A-5. D s the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes []No (If "Yes", 'section E of this part must be completed.) IV,A.6.fe project at variance with any regulations contained In the Zoning Code? es C] No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: . IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: MBA How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What.mitigation Is proposed so that the disturbance/additlon has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:, 'C. Projects Requiring a, Demolition Permit' N.C.I. When are the existing structures to be demolished? LkINER I0ERMIT K D16TA INED IV.C.2. When are the proposed. structures to be constructed? W0 PERMIT IS WOWED IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? Mtge D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit .IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. 'How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IVDA How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 I 1b ZSR'31 � fge, IOW). E• Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV,E,t, Is the proposed use a' permitted special exception use? �YeS p No Cade Section: IV -E-2, How is the use designed, located and welfare and morals will be protected? proposed to be operated so that the }�A A public health, safety, N!/IMC- A n IV,E,3. Will the use cause substantial injury be located? ❑ Yes ' try to the value of other property in the ne(ghborhnn i �x,h a No Explain. IV,E,4, How will the use be compatible with djoining development (s to be located? aand the character of the District where it I�rN U N I�RoPf� � �T� �11I G19� �iqt� 1V,E,5, What landsca in p g and screening are provided? NOT APPLI NCW LpNb5 '4 ND IV,E,6, DOeS the use co orm with all applica�regnullaa�llionssvernin thelocated? ❑Yes(Nog District wherein It is to be Explain. 7 H7_ Nhl rgC71/VEIW17'H I5171`lE7 tQDOFIIV .i --- F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater th �V i D r� �G. f tr! Q1 1 2 Units IV.F.1, If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV,F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surroundin properties, 9 IV.F,3, For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading space Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA,32000 Page 5 eiV,X -ffTWK-, E• Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,f, is the proposed use a Permitted special exception use? �ye5 .❑ No Code Section: 2 IV -E-2- How is the use designed, located and lO / 3I welfare, and morals will be protected? proposed to be operated so that the N public health, safety, N F FF t - BUT CNH rt� Tir'S ANCE� S16N IV -E.3. Will the use cause substantial in'u be located? ❑yes )(No J ry to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. (� 1 ALLbw API IN P, ENHA CEb INOLDIN WITH NfI6�4 IV,E.47HowwIll the use be compatible with adjoining iocated? development and the character of the District where it (� �S w 1 LL LLOIN 5l0 V A NMNTON w�icN s l���e T �>��R C� Im ) IV.E•5• What landscaping and screening are provided? ND F�pN� W.E.B. Does the use confo m with all a located? Ei yes ZNo PplicaZegulaa­iti�onnssgoverning the pistrict wherein it is to be Explain. OLD r -r F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Protects of Greater than 2 Units SII W.F.J.If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be . mamtainec Dl5 . IV,F.2, If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surroundin . properties, 9 IVY -3. For each of the following, Ilsf Loading spaces: the number provided and their dimensions, Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Drlveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA,32000 Page 6 1 n k . , Tbwn'of Gulf Stream VK AN 61 Ge r 6wy, G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Sectibn 66-150 through 157) ' IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested?—AD —t D ` I q 5H'Isgf , IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? FkNT %1-6AC (, W' NE4ECTA` wT UNE THE (IFFDVE" DoT ONE 46 WANG ED EVEN TftO H ft5E AND ROAD AEE _rtHE 5prnE IV.G.3. What Is proposed? %iF REVERSE 'SIDE OF TH 15 PAGE. IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? &LWE V ENCKDPOMW WITH 2, T. IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Seclion 66-154, must be adddre�ss d Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, .or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or bulldings in the same zoning district? THE tM M5 CLkANC1M AIAb A NON CM99MIV was TEb. (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant.any special privilege 'that is degied�by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or slrvclures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: WREN C-ETWK kAN606E Wlb CRR ED AU. --�DQ%�1�1� ��12Ly LOCA-rr=D woui� I rcO1S �dNF�1 1 �1�(�. (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the Ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? TA M51Mt&TffeK 6 A0.1_FE�T UM Ek THE DLD =E. NEW ft-VI51 DR MftM VT WK A6 Ill 8"1 EVEN TROM ,OPH181CA01 6', (5) Is the Variance requeslpd a minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure? No Explain: U09 OLD PDE ���VL LOT UNE,TN15 (060 WOULD URN -a` 56M MINIM, MEN !KeF, 15 AND MINT _ (6) Will granting the variance permit any -prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes (7) Is the requested variance consistent witlythe,goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Y No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning O,�dtPf�nce and not be Injurious to the area Involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? a No Explain: IT WILL ENRAWE APPEARANCE AND E bMPfT16V WiTN TIDE NEOR6*00D. Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002  ZN11 FLMK G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) W.G.I. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? ID - 10() IF EAVE 15 ble Lowf1<, rr W000 PH151CALLJ NFLICT WITH N6 &OFT U55. IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? THE PI2 A-5Fb FN NCIL' T AI.I,DWAmi, UrrHf EAVE WOVbD NOM -iv t_ -1,44 -ra obrvI y. IV.G.3. What Is proposed? LkA ��t " . g�� " I,(, ����I'����'�� I��j DK. r IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested?A!i MAEFAM IV,G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-15,+, must oe addressed--- Atlach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, .or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, slructdres, or buildings in the same zoning district? EXISI'INC BUILD t ftF UNE BwLT MOW PkVibUS CODE (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes S (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant.any special privilege'that is de ' by the Zoning Code to -other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain:TRE NElrl-{T fiMFlC1UIZ��TIbN OF 1��f15DNI I UNIW e. (4) Hove would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? TNl5 HOUT b 51CN Is UNINUE t9 IT cANIBE W%KTICAM ENHANCED WITHOWT MATING POTEMIAL LEA -06(f A0 M11HC5 THE APVtArAsdE V -me flout. (5) Is. the Variance requ a minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure Ye No Explain:MINIMOM VARIAWCE 11 ESRAW8 THE A?P MW -E T? WtI4E U��W1K it rtttE NE14 H WARD. (6) Will granting the variance permit any -prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes 0 (7) Is the requested variance consistent wit oafs, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning nce and not be Injurious to the area Involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No Explain; It ENIANCG6 "4NF APFEE1+94& SND ItAC96#5G6i TN IS AN Nl��2OPr' ��Rty NIA LM5. Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 I THERE 6 AN �EXISTINCS AT121 uM THAT EXTE Ib5 FKDM THE ft NT PYX OF TRE- HD05E, -THAI W I LL 9E PEMUO AN b KED OCED M AN "NCE- t1 WF..I\ft TO -r CXMN ( 6 OHLI V FkM Tif FgDN1' FACF-D�- 144E �D(KiF. MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP DATE: January 25, 2013 RE: 23 NORTH HIDDEN HARBOR DRIVE ■ LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW MEMORANDUM urban kilda y Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics The following is an analysis of the proposed addition to the existing home at 23 North Hidden Harbor Drive. This analysis is based on the plans prepared by Currie Sowards Aguila Architects. Request The applicant is seeking Level 3 Architectural Site Plan Approval for an addition to the existing 8,001 -square foot, Spanish Mediterranean Revival home on 39,243 square feet (0.9 acres) on Lot 5 of the Hidden Harbour Estates plat. The effective lot area, not including submerged lands and areas associated with the private road, is 16,733 square feet (0.38 acres). According to the submitted documents, the applicant is requesting to demolish 229 square feet of gross floor area and replace it with 338 square feet of area for a cumulative increase of 109 square feet. The addition includes a larger entry feature for the building and minor revisions to the rear elevation. Background The Hidden Harbor Estates subdivision, consisting of eight single-family lots, was platted in 1978. The subject home was constructed in 1983, according to Palm Beach County Property Appraiser records. The house is located directly adjacent to the private canal created as part of the Hidden Harbor Estates subdivision. Access to the site is from Hidden Harbor Drive. Land Use & Zoning EXISTING USE. ZONING AND LAND USE DESIGNATIONS EXISTING USE ZONING FUTURE LAND USE Subject Site RS-North/South SF (Single Family) Single Family Home at 23 (Residential Single Family) North Hidden Harbor Drive H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream -94-012\23 North Hidden Harbor Drive\23 N. Hidden Harbor Drive Review Memorandum.doc 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 Mr. William Thrasher 23 N. Hidden Harbor Drive Review January 25, 2013 Page 3 Analysis As indicated in the Project Details section above, the subject home is not consistent with several of the requirements and standards of the Gulf Stream Design Manual. These non -conforming sections are: the building Floor Area Ratio (FAR); first -story eave height for the new entry feature; the second -story eave height for the entry feature; effective lot area; front setback; and, rear setback. As such, the home is considered a non -conforming structure in relationship to the Town's Zoning Code and Design Manual. Section 66-131 of the Town Code addresses non -conforming structures. The applicable code section is as follows: Section 66-131. Required conditions for continuance (4) Buildings or structures or uses of land which are nonconforming shall not be extended or enlarged, Prohibited — Greater than 23 feet Effective Lot Area 30,000 square feet 16,733 square feet No Minimum Lot 100 feet 337 feet Yes Width Maximum Second .70 of first floor 2,434 square feet Yes Floor Area area 5,407 square feet of first floor area = 3,784 square feet allowed on second floor Setbacks Front 30 feet from the 9 feet No effective lot line (11 feet, 8 inches existing front setback) Side Total of both side 32 feet on west side Yes setbacks shall be a 30 feet on east side minimum of 30% of the lot width and each side setback shall be 15 feet or larger. Rear 20 feet 10 feet No Parking 2 spaces in garage, 6 spaces Yes 2 spaces outside Analysis As indicated in the Project Details section above, the subject home is not consistent with several of the requirements and standards of the Gulf Stream Design Manual. These non -conforming sections are: the building Floor Area Ratio (FAR); first -story eave height for the new entry feature; the second -story eave height for the entry feature; effective lot area; front setback; and, rear setback. As such, the home is considered a non -conforming structure in relationship to the Town's Zoning Code and Design Manual. Section 66-131 of the Town Code addresses non -conforming structures. The applicable code section is as follows: Section 66-131. Required conditions for continuance (4) Buildings or structures or uses of land which are nonconforming shall not be extended or enlarged, Mr. William Thrasher January 25, 2013 23 N. Hidden Harbor Drive Review Page 4 however, a special exception may be allowed for additions to structures with existing nonconforming setbacks pursuant to the provisions of chapter 70, section 70-75(c) of this Code. The referenced Section 70-75(c) does allow for additions for homes with existing non- conforming setbacks only if the proposed expansion does not impact the existing non- conforming setback. With regards to the subject site, the Town Code would allow an expansion to the house as long as the addition maintained the existing 11 -foot, 8 -inch front setback. However, the application for the expansion does not maintain the existing, nonconforming, front setback. The proposed addition of the entry features encroaches approximately two (2) feet into the established non -conforming setback. This encroachment is not permitted by Section 66-131 (4) of the Town Code. As a result, the applicant will need to seek a variance for this encroachment into the existing, non- conforming, setback. As indicated above, Section 66-131(4) does not allow for the enlargement or expansion of the home. The subject request proposed an expansion of 109 square feet. Although the expanded area is not large, the existing house already exceeds the Town's FAR (Floor Area Ratio) limitation and a further expansion is not permitted by the Town Code. As such, the applicant will need to seek a second variance for this expansion of a nonconforming structure. The proposed entry feature creates a tower feature at the center of the house's northern elevation. This tower feature raised the home's highest roof height by more than six (6) feet. The proposed entry feature is inconsistent with the preferred roof eave heights for the first and second stories found in the Town Code. Section 70-100 (a)(4) of the Town Code directly addresses entry features and states: "Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provides door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable or other such elements. Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house." Currently, the home's entry feature provides for a varied elevation which is approximately two (2) feet higher than the second -story roof. This existing entry Mr. William Thrasher 23 N. Hidden Harbor Drive Review January 25, 2013 Page 5 feature is in a consistent scale and proportion with the rest of the home while allowing it to become a focal point for the elevation. The proposed entry feature extends more than eight (8) feet above the second -story roofline, which challenges whether the tower is of a consistent scale and proportion with the remainder of the house. Also, the second -story roof eave proposed for the entry feature is approximately 25 feet in height. Section 70-100 of the Town Code states that second -story eave heights 23 feet or higher are prohibited. The preferred second story eave height is 21 feet or less and the discouraged eave height is between 21 and 23 feet. The first floor entry feature also exceeds the Town standards. The applicant is proposing 15 feet to the first floor element banding. This exceeds the Town's preferred height of 8 to 10 feet, six inches and the discouraged eave height between 10 feet, six inches and 12 feet, six inches. As a result, the applicant will need to seek variances for first and second -story eave height as proposed. Review Process As indicated above, the applicant will need to request four (4) variances from the Town's Zoning Code and Design Manual in order to achieve the presented design. The Town Code defines a variance as "deviations from the terms of (the) Code that would not be contrary to the public interest when owning to special circumstances or conditions, or when the literal enforcement of the provisions of this Code would result in undue and unnecessary hardship." The Town's Board of Adjustment (Town Commission) will make the final determination on whether to approve, approve with conditions or deny each variance request after considering recommendations from the Town Staff and the Architectural Review and Planning Board. This process can run concurrently with the Town's Level 3 Architectural Review process. In making its decision, the Board of Adjustment will have to determine that each requested variance conforms to each standard below. If each standard cannot be complied with, then the variance cannot be approved. VARIANCE STANDARDS Sec. 66-154. Standards. When recommending or taking final action on applications for variances, the review authority must find that: (1) Special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district. Mr. William Thrasher 23 N. Hidden Harbor Drive Review (2) The special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the applicant. (3) Granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by this Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district. (4) Literal interpretation of the provisions of this Code would deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the terms of this Code and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant. (5) The variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use ofthe land, building or structure. (6) Granting the variance would not permit to be established or re-established any use prohibited in that zoning district. (7) Granting the variance is consistent with the goals, objectives and policies and future land use map of the adopted comprehensive plan. (8) Granting the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this Code and that such variance will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. January 25, 2013 Page 6 Recommendation The proposed entry feature exceeds the preferred and discouraged eave heights outlined in the Section 70-100 of the Town Code. The first story entry feature height is 15 feet, which is in excess of the 12 feet, six inches which is prohibited by the Code. The proposed second -story eave height of 25 feet exceeds the "prohibited" eave height of 23 feet or higher. As such, the proposed entry feature is out of scale with the rest of the existing structure and is not compliant with the Town's Code. It is recommended that the applicant revise the entry feature to reduce its height to be in conformance with the Town's Code. Until then, a recommendation for approval cannot be provided for this request. MIF --w go " I. , fxJ��;" 111 4 , ' t sit, o �� r,ll ��7��1-I - 1'I��I���� " ti ',. 1 7 WPM- - N" .. 4 .j , .fit :�- ",,►�-i/ mi Iwo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... _ THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OE CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED. ANY POSSESSION, REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC., IS PROHIBITED. 1/1>/2013 2:59:08 PM c ? I I I I I :.5 DA114A-;E EASE hJEIJ (FLAT BOCK 115, FA—. 173 A4, \ O - I I I I I .I I' I _ n I a �, Z m R' -e D08TW. SEMACK I I I I I n El M CDC < m o m a w 0 g A DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL SET 1-15-2013 o F _ N m m VI § m OOpw€n nOti nOAymm dor€ 0. ul rn �,g4F�"QomyNm m 0-2� gym o F—LW � 88gp�p�g�1oom�T O n pilmmg Z yrp Vm40 AT310w ON ni yypppowy0 � 2y�2 ym�m O�Z]Imi~ ..tt011pOO y>m IR Zm O w :.5 DA114A-;E EASE hJEIJ (FLAT BOCK 115, FA—. 173 A4, \ I I I I I I .I I' I _ IL I a w=e n D O n R' -e D08TW. SEMACK I I I I I :.5 DA114A-;E EASE hJEIJ (FLAT BOCK 115, FA—. 173 A4, \ z rn W --I V) y w o 354 D =_ '� Ln �N Inv pZ a w=e n D O n a rn 3 xa rn z g �X p pX ap rn 11i u1 V I c m 3 THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED. ANY POSSESSION, REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT. WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC., IS PROHIBITED. 1/15/2013 1:51:00 PM 11, ,or it DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL SET 1-15-2013 F - L. X o � m m D z n CA CD co C= m m N Go v rn 3n m an r C3 m PA A r C o D o i u S^ I--1 DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL SET 1-15-2013 F - N m m a � � F � m 20�-D000-�pOp Din O�OyOZ22�2n~Aril <�op>9yw4aoiyymN D ON m N (n O ; A=c�$op=moon p2 z. -AT yCZOtiypmA N w rn 3n m an r C3 m PA O C o D o i u S^ I--1 � o9'L'Aocgaammom $ DF TOmmM20D�myC O c O 3 p�pmm" o�<v AZT p X om` ppm nu z _ nDoI m=�o-- zm r m �r z T m z m oNtiaa m �u�za o.R 2 Gi C o �+ p 2 3n m an r C3 m PA C o D o i u S^ I--1 p DC) p rn $ m c 3 THIS DOCUMENT 15 THE PROPERTY OR CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED. ANY POSSESSION, REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC., IS PROHIBITED. 1/1S/2013 2:23:37 PM T m m z 0 m x z G) O z rn � �o Im -i En O Z m p Z { o rn 3 rn Z A a _ ryy_ CTS > 0(') m, i ~' m CD o m CAD v $ m DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL SET 1-15-201y3 o O rn gi z<�=5'2y w O N Y Z w��w'G°LHy Hm 011 S g w z rn � �o Im -i En O A p Z { o rn 3 rn Z A a _ ryy_ CTS > 0(') m, i z D 50 rn R: B /r opw p z 90 rn $ m G 6 m THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF CURRIE SOWARDS AOURA ARCHITECTS INC. ALL RIOHTS ARE RESERVED. ANY POSSESSION, REPROOUCITON OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT, WRTHOUT THE WRaTEN CONSENT OF°CURRIE SOWARDS AGURA ARCHITECTS INC., IS PROHIBITED. X Z d � m 9 m r D O z _tj o zm Z Qe O O1 p 2 C a 8SS+b "999E fL^ a all { o m g A �� _ �- (D C z m m =� DSIII n 0r) ®® N m N C CD m o m 3 `Q v o DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL SET 1/15/2013 NS m X � o� gF- g81 qM D W N o m Ln < m D Z Gi O� 0` Nogo' o y wO O Z Ln o _tj o zm Z Qe O O1 p 2 C a 8SS+b "999E fL^ a D I� Vi { o m g A �� _ (D C m m =� DSIII n 0r) THIS. DOCUMENT IS THE PROP ERN OF CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED. ANY POSSESSION, REPRODUCTION OR OTHER USE OF THIS DOCUMENT. WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF CURRIE SOWARDS AGUILA ARCHITECTS INC., IS PROHIBITED, 1/15/2013 11:52:45 AM ' ` % IF P DZ 6'o 0 o z1 NIg �I0 o m DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL SET 1-15-2013 ;O�O TOyQ$a�ZC�ZZm8 I D iO 0.aMp W O C�'Ii�gy fpn>l~gyPvA>�� Ty� Ln rnmFS�mg���?ow z � 0��$`�4ocm���mi� v c� v O a03mr=9�"�ommya n z =aooy�oa�pv�Am og �z ppm mem o mm v all - c s, v m Z 0 N m CD C=2 m Go v T . 7IIT AFF. FAYf4d AF.f. RI)GE311-54AFF, 1.0 AFF... 3�$4( r.� z 1AVE1 E'4 314' AF.F. �Z rn m z "' IG) a > n m rn �S1 �m a° Nlr-• o V �lO 3�$4( r.� z ul O �Z rn m z "' 9 a > n m rn --i w A C o m 00 m n � rn � rn 3�$4( r.� D =>0C ®m�oq 3 � rn He Y �m ONAIN60E EASEMENT I , I GLA, RMT Ar W) I �T R! N pi IEAOIO AN] MRIIY -- (PlATa�]jPl¢W) 1 PA VEO L OI T 13 L O T 2 L 0 T 1 HIDDEN HARBOUR PLAT TWO —I ( LA T BOOK 115= PAGES 17 & 174) Q - o a o a NE pji co Rig 2 X re s p Y u m V v m z c� 0 N m CD C= m � v IT I� . Q - o a o a NE pji co Rig 2 X re s p Y u m �I i v mwN¢ etgsavr tRAravr nG Aaas os r rx)11I 1 2 1 I �I i v mwN¢ etgsavr tRAravr nG Aaas os r rx)11I 1 2 1 TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-06 Owner: M/M Robert Julien Address: 1601 North Ocean Blvd. Agent: Mark Marsh, Digby Bridges, Marsh & Assoc. Proposed Improvement: Construct a 392 SF addition to an existing Spanish Mediterranean Revival style single family dwelling. Approvals Requested: Level II Architectural/Site Plan To permit an addition of 392 SF to the south east corner of the existing Spanish Mediterranean Revival style single family dwelling, to enclose an existing breezeway on the north side of the dwelling and to install a roof over the existing trellis connection to the existing guest house. Gross Lot size: 112,258 SF Effective Lot Area: 84,506 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 19,322 SF Allowable: 19,501 SF Zoning District: RS -B, Beach Height: 16'6", (roof height <_20' Preferred) Proposed Architectural Style: Mediterranean, matching existing structure Adjacent Residences: Mediterranean Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-70 Floor area calculation Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-187 Table of district standards Section 70-100 Roof and eave height Recommendation: Motion to approve level II Architectural/ Site Plan, based on a finding that the proposed addition of 392 SF to the south east corner of the existing Spanish Mediterranean Revival style single family dwelling, to enclose an existing breezeway on the north side of the swelling and to install a roof over the existing trellis connection to the existing guest house meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: February 28, 2013 Action: Level II Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as submitted. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream ------------- TOWN OF GULF STREAM fro, � .. C, L JEgtT� �S JAN 2 t 2013 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File #13= -OL To be completed by all applicants. PART II.GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.I. Project/OwnerName: Mr. & Mrs. Robert Julien I.A.2. Project Address: 1601 N. Ocean Blvd, Gulf Stream I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See attached I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) Addition to S . E corner (ground floor) main house, enclose an existing breezeway on north side and install a roof over existing trellis connection I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: _ to quest house Architectural Style: Medit rranean Reyi va I.A.6. Check all that apply: ,Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: B. Owner Information Type of Foundation: Pili I.B.1. Owner Address: 1601 . Ocean Blvd. , Gulf Stream, FL 33435 I.B.2, Owner Phone Number: 561 8 9500 Fax: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information M. Mark Marsh I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: Bridges, Marsh & Associates Inc. I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 Via MizpAr $alm B.Aach,_ FL 33480 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 832- 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: A06B D, App Date: Recomm Com Date: TC Date: Decision: qi;37 04&tom 13 at Va Onli Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 ation: Fax Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? Beach Front l , 5 L8 III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? X Yes No Explain: Meets or exceeds all zoning criteria III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? XYes No Explain: Meets or exceeds all zoning criteria III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? existing drivewa III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage on site b. Sanitary Sewer _ septic c. Potable water _ city d. Irrigation Water city e. Electricity FP & L f. Telephone AT&T g. Gas Florida Public i i 1; t i P h. Cable Television Comcast III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) N/A PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes XNo (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes No X (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes (?N)o (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes No XX (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes XXIO (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 1-G.Vn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? N/A IV.6.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: N/A IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: N/A IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? N/A IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: N/A C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? N/A b. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: N/A IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 . vucdlll E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. ME -1. Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? ❑ Yes ❑ No Code Section: IV.E.2. How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? N/A IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to be located? ❑ Yes ❑ No Explain. MEA. How will the use be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where it is to be located? IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? ❑ Yes ❑ No Explain. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surrounding properties. IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 of Gulf Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? N/A IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV.G.3. What is proposed? IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure,.or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant.any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No Explain: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 um, or gulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV -H-1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? N/A IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Zoning Code text change, ,Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, please describe the need and justification for the request. ' PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this form or on any of the other materials submitted with the application. Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 7 DFSCRIPTION: P FGINNING AT A POINT ON. THF C FNTFRI INF OF OC FAN P OUI FVARD, AS NOW .I AID OUT AND FSTAP I ISHFD, 268 FFFT NORTH OF, MFASURFD AT .RIGHT ANGI FS TO THF SOUTH I INF OF I OT ONF (1), SFCTIO.N 10, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGF 43 FAST; RUN THF. F FAST ON A I INF PARAI I FI TO THF SOUTH I INF OF SAID I OT ONF (1), SFCTIO.N 10, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGF 43 FAST, TO THF WATFRS OF THF ATI ANTIC OC FAN; RUN THFNC F NORTHFRI Y AI ONG THF WATFRS OF THF ATI ANTIC OCEAN TO A POINT 468 FFFT .NORTH OF MFASURFD AT RIGHT ANGI FS TO THF SAID SOUTH I INF OF I OT ONF (1) SECTION ' 10, SAID TOWNSHIP AND RANGF; RUN THFNC F WFST ON A I INF 468 FFFT NORTH. OF AND PARAI I FI TO THF SAID SOUTH I INF OF I OT ONF (1), SFCTION 10, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGF 43 FAST, TO THF CFNTFRI INF OF THF OCEAN POUI FVARD, AS NOW IAID OUT AND FSTAPI ISHFD; RUN THFNCF SOUTHFRI Y AI ONG THF C FNTFRI INF OF SAID OC FAN POUI FV;APD TO THF POINT OF P FGINNING, I FSS THF WFST 30.0 FFFT. THFRFOF; TbCFTHFR WITH 'AI I I.ITTORAI RIGHTS THFRFUNTO PFI ONGING OR IN ANYWISE , APPFRTAINING, SAID I AND P FINE THF SOUTH 200 FFFT OF THF NORTH 400 FFFT OF THF' SOUTH 668 FFFT OF I OT ONF (1), SECTION 10, TOWNSHIP 46' SOUTH, RANGF 43 FAST, IPING FAST OF OCEAN ROUT FVARD. 0 `- BRIDGES, MARSH & ASSOC. JAN r r �.'� 21 January 2013 JAN2- t cu13 ,...._ Mr. William Thrasher Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33482 RE: ADDITIONS TO EXISTING RESIDENCE 1601 N. Ocean Blvd. Dear Mr. Thrasher, You had previously requested a landscape plan be submitted with the attached ARPB Level I submission. However, on behalf of the Owner, we would like to be exempt from this request as the area of proposed addition affects minimal landscape change. The area (S.E. corner of residence) affected has some existing foundation material and some coconut palms, these will be reinstated or supplemented after completion of the construction. The area immediately to south is densely landscaped and will provide ample screening from the neighbor to the South. Your cooperation in this matter is greatly appreciated. Kind regards Yours sincerely, TES, INC. BRIDGES, MARSH & Assoc., INC. chartered architects EIGHTEEN VIA MIZNER • PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33480 • 561 832 1533 • FAx: 561 832 1520 DCB-# AR 0008738 MM-#AR0009030 GV-#AR92276 r �% ��a a ��wriw��ww�%r.��^.��. '111 ; �� _ N /Jr7i r- A r i� 0 z� 90 Rt mp � a -c ATLAAtric OCEAN 1&2STQPYWSVDCE 201 41 N.B'13'4` 130.18' Q"Io Hk M ai mq NA OF OCEAN BOULEVARD (COUNTY ROAD A.K.A. S.R. AIA) 1 ®• C.C.C.L. N.7'21'56"E. 201.41' OLD C.C.C.L. N.8'13'45"E. 130.18' - APPROXIMATE M.H.W.L. EL. -0.34' NAVD m�mT101 m vAi vi O y O ti O� 000N�� I�m> N'z O ^� D --- —0.0' NAVD------ .2-,.Z. ADo A�� j c G a ATLANTIC OCEAN CSF � ��n • rC, a A a N p A y fig Q O Z gz < v$ Do LIMITS OF BEACH DUNE_ - -_1 APPROXIMATE S.H.W.L. EL -4.47' NAVD - APPROXIMATE M.H.W.L. EL. -0.34' NAVD m�mT101 m vAi vi O y O ti O� 000N�� I�m> N'z O ^� D --- —0.0' NAVD------ .2-,.Z. ADo A�� j Dm2 Aaz < G a ATLANTIC OCEAN z mom rC, a A a N p A y fig Q O Z m ^ Do a 3" ^, on aNn r w CIO r DATE OV,G. NO CHK. RNY z O m�mT101 m vAi vi O y O ti O� 000N�� I�m> N'z O ^� D O m .2-,.Z. ADo A�� j Dm2 Aaz < z mom z m mo a A a N p A y D D D O Z m ^ p a ooAoa o on aNn - a a w =m z ti NN noo 00 o O m ss O r n C o - N H M _ n - Ou OiNO D � -- V 0 0 J22 mm Z. Z. 22 0 Z. M, M, 9 O N IIII NIIIN N V1 uIIBd z S O 0 I� !N Qoean 4 3 n Tr co zo �a JOB 140. DRAMNG � JOB lo SEAL CONSULTANT CONSULTANT $ h n / ��y I I o I I �� I DATE DV.G, NO. CHK. RWY / II II II II II II II II ��n�� II II II II II II II II 02 SII III II II i �� II II II II II o oz II II o o II II ``-n I a I II II z II II II , ; II II II II II II i _ I _ Y= I II II II Im I ��x rn ,o: 'A2 I --�� n n I O  II III- - - J- II II I II I II II ��" �� IV II 'Il II II II II II II II II II II II I��Ij I I II III II V I I I II II I I ��y I I o I I �� I DATE DV.G, NO. CHK. RWY / �� m ��n�� m I 0=' 02 I 3n i �� II G � n / A \ 11 o .i." IR -} m ax mx mrn �� ��y vY ZZ =2 an n " X ��1i. -I -x _ E:;; j - I a�� I 3 �� I I I I --------------J II a p Imm ��x Jor z -I I2. II _ -x rn m Ax ��n�� m I 0=' 02 I 3n II <l�� II � n / A \ II _ -x rn m Ax ��n�� m I 0=' 02 I 3n <n II r �Y z t^ a�� <n I II II II II II II II ��m II I I � m 'I afx mm 00 FFW 0V���� REVISION ��' S ggta y $ w; a��= NUDRAWN����o n =C -I > 9 : m Ix1 a d~to > JOB SEAL CONSULTANT CONSULTANT S r nSCALE JOB NO. I. I' I I I �— I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I ------------------------ 'A op — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — --- -------------- ------------ ------------- ------------— — — — — — — – – – – – – – 1- -- II I I - - - II I I II I – II I alp ---------- II I – I II' II I I I'I I I I I -II II I I II II I I o II II I I � II II I II II I I II II I I II II 11 II I I II II IIII ------- II I I I I I II I ------- – ,IIIILIIIILIIIIII .,'''IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII '' IILIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 1,IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII – --- ------------------------------ ------ T– – – lIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I I. C r �.►� I<f ----- -..6F �e — — — — -- — — --- — ------------ is a C.L� pniE IYa o OY;G. NO. CHK. RN'1 SCALE <kh: �0� t94$> g n4 C - �111��11 I —�I I I \ I y � v6r JON NO. NR.—G >� J0� SEAL CONSULTANT CONSULTANT I —�I I I \ I y � v6r JON NO. NR.—G >� J0� SEAL CONSULTANT CONSULTANT WI J Nl �, FIN IM cel Ic) 0 I I I I I ' YIA 9NIJSN© ' � I I II II II II II G V -n -4 m 0 Tv y�0 � I II I ', 11 ,, II ,, II ., II REVISIOIJS 2ANIpilim nj Rign �^4 a z _, }T OAiL IIY E_ UH � 5"�-1, l v I• � �:n�R��3 FLFF.i LRI �� O�'i0110CHK SCALE C_ a iV M n �C-4 flu vp JOB 140. ORAN�NC JOB <__AL CONSULTANTCONSULTANT rn r� O Z3 �7 w TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-07 Owner: M/M Nelson Grumney Address: 2960 Polo Drive Agent: Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates Proposed Improvement: Construct 540 SF single story additions to an existing two story Neo -French eclectic style dwelling. Approvals Requested: Special Exception (1) To permit the extension of the non -conforming south wall of the existing structure that encroaches a maximum of 1 foot into the south side setback, to add a master bedroom of approximately 302 SF to be located on the first floor. Special Exception (2) To permit the addition of the proposed 302 SF master bedroom to extend 20 feet into the 50 foot rear setback. Demolition Permit To allow small portion of the existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 car garage. Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan To permit the addition of a master bedroom, a small addition to the kitchen, a realignment of the 2 car garage and a new front entry, a net increase of 540 SF on the first floor of an existing partial two story Neo - French Eclectic single family dwelling. Gross Lot size: 18,519 SF Effective Lot Area: 17,996 SF Permitted Floor Area: 5,939 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 5,425 SF Zoning District: RS -C: GS Core Proposed Height: Match existing Finished Floor Elevation: 9.33' Base Flood Elevation: 7.0' Adjacent Residences: Gulf Stream -Bermuda Considered During Review: Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks Note: Standards of approval for both special exceptions are met. Section 70-80 Landscaped open space Section 70-100 Roof and Eave Heights; Section 70-107 Additions and rehabilitations, and replacement of existing features Arc�.itectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-07 February 28, 2013 Page 2 Staff Recommendation: Motion to Recommend Approval of a Special Exception to permit the extension of the non- conforming south wall of the existing structure that encroaches a maximum of 1 foot into the south side setback, to add a master bedroom of approximately 302 SF to be located on the first floor. Motion to Recommend Approval of a Special Exception to permit the addition of the proposed 302 SF master bedroom to extend 20 feet into the 50 foot rear setback. Motion to Recommend Approval of a demolition permit to allow small portion of the existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 car garage. Motion to Recommend Approval of a Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit the addition of a master bedroom, a small addition to the kitchen, a realignment of the 2 car garage and a new front entry, a net increase of 540 SF on the first floor of an existing partial two story Neo -French Eclectic single family dwelling based on a finding that the proposed construction meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: February 28, 2013 Action: Special Exception (1): Recommend approval as requested. (5-0) Special Exception (2): Recommend approval as requested. (5-0) Demolition Permit: Recommend approval as requested with final approval of any additional demolition of the garage being subject to staff review and approval. (5-0) Level 3 Architectural /Site Plan Review: Recommend approval as requested and as staff recommendation. (5-0) Town Commission: March 15, 2013 Action: Special Exception (1): Approved as recommended. (5-0) Special Exception (2): Approved as recommended. (5-0) Demolition Permit: Approved as recommended including the additional demolition of garage & kitchen wing. (5-0) Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all ,development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 15,0 PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information [.A. 1. Project/Owner Name: Mr -9 Mrs- Nelson Gr„mney, Jr I.A.2. Project Address: 2960 Polo Dr , r„1 f Stream I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See attached I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) Proposed master bedroom addition, kitchen expansion and realignment of 2 car garage. I.A.5. Square' Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: Neo—French F 1 t i r 1.A.6. Check all that apply: CXArchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section 8) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) N Special Exception (complete section) lE 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: �* '5�T'3"• Type of Foundation: Piling B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address: 2960 Polo Dr, Gulf Stream, FL I.B.2. Owner PhonE I.B.3. Owner Signa C. Agent Informatio.. I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: Bridges, Marsh & Associates, Inc. I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 Via Mizner, Palm Beach, FL 33480 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 8 3 —1 ^ 3 3 II Fax 22 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Offi al Use LTnly 'B ate: mendation: TC w (2, 3t5-- /- Application for development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 �: � •� �� � 2013 L ' J ' APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all ,development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 15,0 PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information [.A. 1. Project/Owner Name: Mr -9 Mrs- Nelson Gr„mney, Jr I.A.2. Project Address: 2960 Polo Dr , r„1 f Stream I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See attached I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) Proposed master bedroom addition, kitchen expansion and realignment of 2 car garage. I.A.5. Square' Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: Neo—French F 1 t i r 1.A.6. Check all that apply: CXArchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section 8) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) N Special Exception (complete section) lE 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: �* '5�T'3"• Type of Foundation: Piling B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address: 2960 Polo Dr, Gulf Stream, FL I.B.2. Owner PhonE I.B.3. Owner Signa C. Agent Informatio.. I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: Bridges, Marsh & Associates, Inc. I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 Via Mizner, Palm Beach, FL 33480 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 8 3 —1 ^ 3 3 II Fax 22 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Offi al Use LTnly 'B ate: mendation: TC w (2, 3t5-- /- Application for development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? Gulf Stream Code -Rs —C III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? [XYes ❑ No Explain. Proposed additions /expansions, are compatible in scale/mass of the zoning district. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? 6a Yes ❑ No Explain. Proposed modifications comply with all future requirements and are consistent with the future land use. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Existing driveways III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage on site . b. Sanitary Sewer sanitary system c. Potable Water city d. Irrigation Water city e. Electricity FP&L f. Telephone ATT g. Gas Florida Public Utilities h. Cable Television Comcast III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) NO PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes X[N No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes 9RNo (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ARYes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes IX No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Strearn B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? N/A IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: N/A IV.13.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: _ N/A IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? N/A IV.B.5. What.mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: N/A C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? Portions of the existing garage IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? Summer 2013 IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? _ No D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: NTA IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: N/A IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: N/A IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? N/A IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? N/A Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 .... vucdlll E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. 70-75(c)(1)(2) IV.E.1. Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? ElYes ❑ No Code Section: 70-75 (j) ( 1 ) ( 2 ) IV.E.2. How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? The proposed additions are located at the rear of the property and do not impact any R.O.W. exposures. IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to be located? ❑ Yes Flo Explain. The scale and design compliment the existing residence with no adverse impact to the neighborhood. IV.E.4. How will the use be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where it is to be located? same as above IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? All existing landscaping will be preserved at property lines, therefore all existing privacy buffering will remain. IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? ❑ Yes [XNo Explain. This residential use conforms to the District Regulations except that the proposed SW wing of the residence extends an existing non conforming sideyard setback and requires the use of a minimum rear setback for a waterfront lot in core district. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units 1, IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. N/A IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surrounding properties. N/A IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: N/A Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page c f Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? N/A IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV.G.3. What is proposed? - IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, .or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant.any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the , ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No Explain: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 uwn or uulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, please describe the need and justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this form or on any of the other materials submitted with the application. Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8100 Page 7 SOUTH COVE 0 0 0 ` DOLPHIN PILE -- 72GN/q N05'45'00'E i00.00' A-/, V. 3' G � 19.40' 11 rl y I C I f CD I oI -� 'D M) f•-6.2 r \N a L .= I n:' c a I / / / ----------- ---- 2.7' SEAWALL CAP 6V ary 1' J J rel � 1.20' 12.40' 3, •�^ 'STEPm ``;�• �j�/. 60'@. 50' 4.50`• t I •'' .i,.fi` .` y�J; ' Il 55' v COVEAEOI' .31.30' / � I 3.6p° - � r • ' C,' Z STORY RESIDENCE m N 12. N 70' 12.70' I L1. r G3 N s. 70' N e� I .r . !B 65' 7 &' •V� ,A • 18. fib I � � O I I I x o o x I gli $ In 6=0mzmo D i°'z mr- C N N m m n m m T ° U;�j= y- J mcl90 �mN � MU. N n $ s-m� g>0O Zm -DI O czvm_omz °zZ go - x=DZOZ N� 56� a n o�z9" a W;� m o u,a�zZ 'CziS Oms��� m c �d 99 a m Z y .m � 0=p��a �O m Z. Z E d OZyCy< m` Z>'?!lb m c tv �a�'czi��' zm 4 4 I cA>zmm Az oolnl, Z° o�o,.... in I m11 �^G7m{�, y y -O� ZQ Ocl n 'J.m N z9 mp"'' c-1 Q1 !171T C i : >zvEi m9 o \ h� >^ W r ��' _or�a-7mv MM o -17 V yDOD9P N�INrI Q 0 Om m9a ' oozm< D �'ew, m3_ C7 ;1 _q 9 m ry�� ° ��i} p C , m O O�N09�p9� C N Or p Z Z > z p Gi O O v.mm' a �$ Z F -n rn C r -G�zo� � O� 111 Q n Gr O m m Qmmmz-n 1hj v r OO -i• z- o l71 N M>Z (v m$ N C u°c°l�x F"m O S z TI. moo=rs-�Omm 2 •Z1m9cZGly. r4 77.29 7 r 22. 7:1' u M> � r' pr EL- m m > o s o 0 506'36'00'N 177.30' o --— O 0 -I�O : om CT"' m D 0 rp y "o 0 177.30' m — _ _ o N N06' 36' 00' E -- y " -' r 0 �' y o POLO DRIVE N C.. Z m .DOApiz° D O — —— -- o d 3 m .zozz-�-II'z���.G -+ -I rti 'Z.� - ? o0boi„ rm °.�D S¢l O�j rL 'C gy• m O'rr0D co �9 II. 8;v o b p z �. O �y'r .Orr y � WyrT.-1-:D°Imn9T NDmm D m a c r< w m w � a r d w M a s r pNOOW Oo °Sm_ O D cinrn pz ° nr m-im°Ac p 61 I ar:A -D 3 'c $ In 6=0mzmo D i°'z mr- C N N m m n m m T ° U;�j= y- J mcl90 �mN � MU. N n $ s-m� g>0O Zm -DI O czvm_omz °zZ go - x=DZOZ N� 56� a n o�z9" a W;� m o u,a�zZ 'CziS Oms��� m c �d 99 a m Z y .m � 0=p��a �O m Z. Z E d OZyCy< m` Z>'?!lb m c tv �a�'czi��' zm 4 4 I cA>zmm Az oolnl, Z° o�o,.... in I m11 �^G7m{�, y y -O� ZQ Ocl n 'J.m N z9 mp"'' c-1 Q1 !171T C i : >zvEi m9 o \ h� >^ W r ��' _or�a-7mv MM o -17 V yDOD9P N�INrI Q 0 Om m9a ' oozm< D �'ew, m3_ C7 ;1 _q 9 m ry�� ° ��i} p C , m O O�N09�p9� C N Or p Z Z > z p Gi O O v.mm' a �$ Z F -n rn C r -G�zo� � O� 111 Q n Gr O m m Qmmmz-n 1hj v r OO -i• z- o l71 N M>Z (v m$ N C u°c°l�x F"m O S z TI. moo=rs-�Omm 2 •Z1m9cZGly. waO86 mcp-4 mW ^i M> � r' pr EL- m m > o s Z. No�mG12 z- 'myc����'ai mm�7 i +. z c > n 2 Z'y •'•r=rr .C.KD NIOii W Gl c m � m o, ° rm_r m .DOApiz° D z d 3 m .zozz-�-II'z���.G -+ -I rti 'Z.� - ? p O lto `� °.�D S¢l O�j rL 'C gy• m O'rr0D co �9 II. S i �. O �y'r .Orr y � WyrT.-1-:D°Imn9T rT" n �F.n1. • T D m a mr-mii .O.I tUO°-IA O yl'r p pOl >•" m m1�1 yzm r d w M a s r pNOOW Oo °Sm_ O D cinrn pz ° nr m-im°Ac p 61 I ar:A -D 3 'c m 'mrj p No.<°r �o oo? i o0 m m "=yo°n°m K'DRkmr mo 0gr s0m W pZ in m cy m'ly Oi. -00'm Ta ?: °r mo •fl lar 1 W m O >Lrr �, W T m °G) -1 0 °x6 F.0 . �crr y rri rNC O!+ O2 y rOriD - 'm0 ON-r�°�° "Iv'rn o� N ` m O) -m T io•' m MA Q ry ft z m G t� n m ^3 < `° m CD s rn - ---------------------------------------------------- POLO DRIVE O C) n m z n m CD N o m w T 0 mZ ~ 3� m o w cn 4 REVISIONS DATE MHNW G. NO. Glltt DRW SLALE Y �I to �rA fi f] 00 o� i P� 9 m � N i D5• p}� x :4 u N 8 y + P� zz yz z z �� H d � >>� > o H a a s O C) n m z n m CD N o m w T 0 mZ ~ 3� m o w cn 4 REVISIONS DATE MHNW G. NO. Glltt DRW SLALE Y �I to �rA fi f] ��I Ell I .". I S e 1. 1" -a' 9 p O II ----------------- I I > I I -- II II II II II II I II U- II`�� II Il��rll Il jj Il III �� I II II II II II II II II VI\ II II II II II II II II ' II \ II II I II II II I IL 14 !k  tr--tl--I��--U--rr �� II In II n\ u u u II II y u �� II a II II II I u II \ II II II II II J i 1 I 1 s i II mix I 7CZ A Z I �� a / II RB ,4 oU II II O l II t1 I IJ L:T J I 7T"  N" 49" -1' q K 9 p O II ----------------- I I > I I -- II II II II II II I II U- II`�� II Il��rll Il jj Il III �� I II II II II II II II II VI\ II II II II II II II II ' II \ II II I II II II I IL 14 !k  tr--tl--I��--U--rr �� II In II n\ u u u II II y u �� II a II II II I u II \ II II II II II J i 1 I 1 s i II mix I 7CZ A Z I �� a / II RB ,4 oU II II O l II t1 I IJ L:T J I 7T"  N" 49" -1' q K \ REVISIONS-tz 4agd ��g��R ca m ttj In vATE I. R kk2@ i9pz 9 I--�� 0 t [ J - GYIR vR14'f SGALF J09 t:0 yr^.A',; :G V] SEAL GONSULIANT rn m_ 0 ��z M frn T NT s o r - \ REVISIONS-tz 4agd ��g��R ca m ttj In vATE I. R kk2@ i9pz 9 I--�� 0 t [ J - GYIR vR14'f SGALF J09 t:0 yr^.A',; :G V] SEAL GONSULIANT z 0 T -i mZ n® 3 n a REVISIONS 4sFgS�3q bgEb �. b to rpp '� 9a gp4�°" 0 668 ��� � �°O � � � tij • < vATE II pvi � NEI! -Al I II y I... � > C� y E A,la 9 Kul G 9 A �FgIIAN C O� R DWG. 110. GIiK DRYri S;plC J09 tin DFAY:',i;r. ^� cn b m tz Gil LL 0 m v c� a REVISIONS 4sFgS�3q bgEb �. b to rpp '� 9a gp4�°" 0 668 ��� � �°O � � � tij • < vATE II pvi � NEI! -Al I II y I... � > C� y E A,la 9 Kul G 9 A �FgIIAN C O� R DWG. 110. GIiK DRYri S;plC J09 tin DFAY:',i;r. ^� cn b m tz Gil LL N REVI510N5 E7 m .. HII W PATE "Ing K � yC � o ao scar !09 r;o o�ax.r,c 57h C/] sEa_ ccu_.ur.wrr _^ n SAS CD O Grn � 3 0 N REVI510N5 E7 m .. HII W PATE "Ing K � yC � o ao scar !09 r;o o�ax.r,c 57h C/] sEa_ ccu_.ur.wrr _^ n i 70 d R o v n i W ONE �WWG 1�1 70 v n r m m . ME1■■L__ . IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII� • llllllllllllllllllllllllf]-- ��1■CJI 1111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIL] . !I W ONE �WWG 1�1 III 11111111 1111111 • II II I II _ 111111 z IL� 7B w 0) IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 111wollI I F REVISIONSto once II E F446 ��3, ��.. s p C�i t�-i • g -r B e "'� Qt'JG- �:Q. GIiK DK1'F `_-GALE JOB IJ9 o�A1`:^:v Cn SEAI. GON5UL7ANT " m n C] C 70 v n r m m III 11111111 1111111 • II II I II _ 111111 z IL� 7B w 0) IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 111wollI I F REVISIONSto once II E F446 ��3, ��.. s p C�i t�-i • g -r B e "'� Qt'JG- �:Q. GIiK DK1'F `_-GALE JOB IJ9 o�A1`:^:v Cn SEAI. GON5UL7ANT " m n C] C F g iin o REV15ION5 ►F1 DATE II 564=y�pg g ap q9q9R ggp fa Oo H ^3 Y33R�y z� psi DWG. NO. Ni N SCALE JOp f:0 DRA1`;'; r. to N s coi�sui Ta�IT �22 �" o A ml y� Lt r f1)i __ N � 1111'lll'111�1'111.1,. M11.11111 H • �11111�1�111 1�1�1 t 'j'jHum. '.' p�'111'1', k 1111 _1 �^ 1+ REVISIONS 1}� DATE ry P. O DWG. NO. GNK DRW' SCALE i IC Cr'F of I; mFYE ppF tF �J �Q�Fp —1 �n $}$�F LLLp > y�i�> 'Elm Ro € o P 70 Av g o " i a m IIND-V CD� C= m ; T �^ 1+ REVISIONS 1}� DATE ry P. O DWG. NO. GNK DRW' SCALE i IC Cr'F of I; mFYE ppF tF �J �Q�Fp �n $}$�F LLLp > y�i�> 'Elm Ro € P Av g " i a tz to JOB NO DRAWPiG CA SEAL CONSULTANT q?R 4 s gg -9'c g99�� 518 tlz O €@ s•m $R—q'.5 SgR� X! ii y3.' Fm g'�ya48 mman��o o�g-^q'g IRA Jai �gr. 5F R4 ROSE ^ � 'oaa �oow gn s "9-1 x POLO DRIVE R g z 0 Lo Dx �gaUg9_:':xti53 �•aa 6� e3x3 $ n 2O D —I I� I i \\ (7 1 I n Cl s as i O _I_ ' s � D v �s. m �O p�2 a' n 'p O z 0 Lo Dx �gaUg9_:':xti53 �•aa 6� e3x3 $ n 2O D r9 C D 3 O ((D�'� Z z n Cl s as i O = Sao 02 D oZ m �O p�2 D n 'p O y vi Z [ a " a 2 O fA 'O C Z s > a Z n z = > a � yny z v n ; C 3 w S WN thtN A O'd � i 3: O f7 A m N Z A fel -C X O N U N U O U N AO U N = O m VI " o N O + U N A a m m O (il m; D 'z m o Z D 3 ZD o r y Z m TI r A C m z g n y m I I I I I I I I I I W m N O --------------- — °J "gym 3-'- $ gig'""", m `i BE 35L n s S$ Sa ��° rm– C=' �` s s� a D s as i O ££ Sao 02 o •Rg' �$ oc nc 3111,T �O 1 x �J n O maµ m } Z n3R =aR " a 2 O D 2 8s' Z n z = --------------- — — — --- — — 3° C=' v ` o z m 3 „o �o n Sao 02 o D 3° C=' v w CO) • cN� a x �J o� 0 2 D maµ m } o v m D Crag Z n z = � yny C 3 w D C � p t o D m r, T r- " o m o m m m O (il m o Z D 3 ZD o r y Z m TI r A C m z g n y m I D 3° C=' v w CO) • cN� a x �J o� 0 2 D maµ m } o v m D 1; m I iu � Z n z = � yny s SOUTH COVE P'ax 100.00' N. 05' 45' 00" E. --- ----- ---- la O ob 1 � 0 9 $gym t I x \— $8 tie01 = Rg $€ E4sl184 j-- �o Q -- ------ ❑ ❑ Cn o o f CDEl n � n "7' S Fri (!I X i ?1 Z Z +O uYtiN d Fr 3 ° I fv O —1 CD m o 1 y a� z j kal x � o c o 's �g z " x ------------------------------ \. 2 x 177.30' N. 06' 36' 00" W. — ------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- POLO DRIVE m z � z y x pc BEb�AA pa � r�Y i� AAA q. '•" F E cn m �� CD o M ��' o 0) c� ® .n cd arn TI T" iv > b g o r�� r � o ado DRA1'��tiG W JOB G7 SLAL VA1 111114 p $8 tie01 = Rg $€ E4sl184 c xjaj�a iv > b g o r�� r � o ado DRA1'��tiG W JOB G7 SLAL "7' S i0 YFJ +O uYtiN d Fr 3 ° u Ksrc^!k0 d --I EgCL 1 y a� tr1 c o c o w 'b"Y �g 3 a PNB ueO*N 0 Y Y A 3 sy1 '0!L..a..9.25F Soo _ P _,¢c' W p ^S°:xn= nSSqoq^;a;ix�o $ T.<om�3n�nXjSa�'na�oo^n on aRN -W_ ��'.a.: w @ Rx a"»tSha �s 39� a�= �X` xso� 03� oo�z�$a�TAR4 v3a8'� x�iaq�u X$"° _ g n- 41 �a=�' s rt a anna ' ^ °fin "° ° ^ in 0 < a$; 9,388; 4�`"'^^X�nS s� $ RSR;"R»,ax "�> A?� a Q r' ��DXi�^''^ `c 4. iu m _a "t��PNit°="i�. ^a. ^.n ;om �Rn 9 4n saga .° Baa �ax;o�aa$"°� "» xnn a;� ""° , »; =a .'W o�A a �� �< a: �?N a� oar $'p p q s&° Aon ^d�=_5a - _ a^x Xa ' - 4 ;s � n - ax" _,� s x ^req _ - I x x _ ^ Sno -a 9 gig - 12F VISIONS I� DATA O Ono DY�G. N0. Ev D'n 1'.."•i: Al. ����lul 214 11H;61.9 � � S All I All 91 F�y�$ r $_>198� " z_�� 2 s ��a r;n Denw:rc "nano M$S ; "4;gQ ^35:"°s Via,,; j°x�3Tino-i7°u^ Rvi i; Yn ^Sn^ ^ [� ^° ^ i 99 ^Xaa' ^9^ asap asA oao�. io�"g igxFx-W ono°in In "T°" 3j An g gCnNnn SEEK -i $Qo ' S 41, a� °bT� ^n m$^ i �nRn» n ' g=°$x� ��i "nna= a" So 9„= R x^ sNa°o F�si^u - z � ^ RP�� 8n3,2^ mi�A ai$n ^a$�'n FMO Y"a- rt; $p ganNN "aq= �,+� oa..^ 'sno T3N�a'� _;~�w ^zqA = as 3i 2�2 3x8^Q -°. p S I i.d° � '�S” » 5 3,^ �' ^gx•` °n�s. � =a��-sq boa =�"a�= 1 $a» sad n�� spa a�gR�on1 11 ar°R� J ° " ; o���s 3» - R ORMIyyNE�IMUM STONpEE CANLDL 4* ALTERNATE Fa MACHINE INVERT EXCAVATION AND OVER EXCAVATION UMIT FOR 4 F—MACHINE Z am> i�"i as s vi ii�oy I EXCA �A •.. �.�< O zn 09 mF m iDo'QQ'li yQ> / S Mon Z 4v im �> F zigF z�cao o> v s�v CO FAD of (�(�,m+�1 �2 If ma 0 11z n InDZ a� JC aI ppA>�l -UII 9 N F D o O n 9 r C tmnm .lm UC 2 1YniA� NmFm 11 Om ON 2 D m F>n�8 �yAoo �mm� I�/�! •pr f mpo m mf°1 Pz zzm-Tz8c E= A ' go Dr p mz Mr�D O "o F gmo D m K K: CD TI m41 m � ➢� z y CD Z (I O CD Z O Cn � C7 Zr All m mn ggs a �u� m s z q, ie dG X90 �r'g IV zod ° D m K K: CD TI m41 m � ➢� z y CD Z (I O CD Z O Cn � C7 Zr All m mn ggs a �u� m s z q, ie dG N -P G C-) rn CD z a 9 tS �R m ° N M 0 m �� c ® ;u Z F --i —n D -n -n v 4 N -P G C-) rn CD z a 9 tS �R m ° N N -P G C-) rn CD z a CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy George Delafieled, Jr. March 21, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, MARCH 28, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 2-28-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. July 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. August 2013 -No Meeting VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects, as Agent for 3211 N. Ocean Boulevard, LLC, Mark T. Pulte Member, the owners of property located at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as the North 4.5 ft of lot 3 & the S 108 ft. of lot 4 Gulf Stream Ocean Tracts in Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to prepare for some new landscape materials and adjust the grade to accommodate the new structures and improvements. C. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVAD OVRLAY PERMIT to install entry gate and piers and supplement existing landscaping within the corridor. d. VARIANCE to permit a terra cotta slate style roof to be installed on the proposed Georgian style home. e. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a 10,408 square foot partial 2 -story, single family, Georgian style dwelling with a 4 car garage and swimming pool. 2. An application submitted by William Wietsma as agent for Ralph MacDonald, owner of the property located at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds as Lots 1, 1-A and 2, McLouth Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. SUBDIVISION to divide one, 4,733 acre, parcel of land into 3 lots. b. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove and- existing driveway, a garage and shed. AGENDA CONTINUED c. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to remove existing driveway from proposed Lot "C". d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the division of one parcel of land containing 4.733 acres into 3 lots with the existing structures on proposed Lot "B" to remain. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 28, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order 8:30 A. M. II. Roll Call. Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Morgan called the Meeting to order at Scott Morgan Tom Smith Paul Lyons Malcolm Murphy George Delafiel Amanda Jones Ann Aker William Thrasher Rita Taylor John Randolph Bernard and Stephanie Molyneux Hilel Presser of 2745 Ave Au Soleil Chairman Board Member Board Member Board Member Alternate Member Vice -Chairman Alternate Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Attorney Applicant/915 Emerald For Molyneux Martin O'Boyle1Applic/23 Hidden Harbour Dr. Charles Siemon, Esq. Rep. Martin O'Boyle Siemon & Larson P.A. Robert Currie, Arch. Currie, Sowards & Aguila Architects Bill Ring, Esq., of Commerce Group, Inc. Mark Marsh of Digby, Bridges, Marsh & Assoc Rep. Martin O'Boyle Agent/O'Boyle Agent/Julien & Grumney III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1-24-13. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to approve the Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1/24/13. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. There were no changes. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & a. March 28, 2013 b. April 25, 2013 C. May 23, 2013 @ d. June 27, 2013 e. July 25, 2013 f. August 2013 -No Public Hearing @ 8:30 A. M. @ 8:30 A. M. 8:30 A. M. @ 8:30 A. M. @ 8:30 A. M. Meeting Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 2 Chairman Morgan noted the Meeting Schedule and asked if there were any conflicts. Mr. Lyons stated that he would not be available for the March 28th Regular Meeting and Public Hearing. There were no other conflicts. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval Chairman Morgan asked for declarations of Ex -parte communication for any of the applications being heard. There were none. Clerk Taylor administered the Oath to the following: Bernard Molyneux, Stephanie Molyneux, Hilel Presser, Martin O'Boyle, William Ring, Esq., Charles Siemon, Esq., Robert Currie, Arch., Mark Marsh, Arch. 1. An application submitted by Bernard and Stephanie Molyneux, owners of the property located at 915 Emerald Row, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 64, Place Au Soleil Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida a. VARIANCE to allow a roof replacement on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling, of a color and material that do not conform to the provisions of Sections 70-107 and 70-238 of the Gulf Stream Zoning Code. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the installation of a brown, flat cement tile roof, replacing the existing wood shake roof, on an existing Gulf Stream Bermuda style, single family, one story dwelling Bernard Molyneux of 915 Emerald Row stated that he would like to change his roof from shaker to flat cement tile and is asking for a variance to allow a brown tile which is similar in color to the existing shaker. He said the original home had a brown shaker roof, it was later replaced with brown shaker, and now he would like a flat cement tile of a similar brown color, which is characteristic to the style of the home. The Board Members were shown a tile sample. Chairman Morgan said the Town worked very hard on Code changes relating to roof material and color. He said he personally likes the idea of the shake look, but brown cement tile is directly prohibited. Chairman Morgan said the ultimate decision is with the Commission, and he suggested that maybe the approach should be that the shake -look of the brown tile is an integral design element to the structure. Mr. Smith asked if any precedent was set in the past allowing the original roof color to remain if replaced with another material. Mr. Thrasher said to his knowledge there is no precedent. Mr. Lyons asked if the applicant could replace his roof with a shake roof. Mr. Thrasher confirmed that. Mr. Molyneux said there is nothing wrong with his roof, but it is difficult to get insurance on a wood shake roof. He said he had three estimates and they have either refused coverage or quoted a very high rate. Mr. Molyneux said he changed his windows and garage door to hurricane resistant as suggested by insurance carriers, but he cannot get insurance without improving the roof. He said he would like to replace the roof with a similar -colored cement tile. Mr. Molyneux said Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 3 another reason for replacing the roof is that it is 15 years old, and he said he has an engineer's report stating that cement tile will hold up better in a storm. Hilel Presser of 2745 Avenue Au Soleil, a neighbor of Mr. Molyneux, was present to lend his support and to encourage the Board to approve the request. Mr. Molyneux said his neighbors have no objections and may send letters of support to the Town. Chairman Morgan said the Kubrickys, who are adjacent to Mr. Molyneux, sent a letter in his support. Clerk Taylor said there have been no objections from neighbors and no other letters have been received. Mr. Lyons asked about other wood shake roofs in the neighborhood. Mr. Molyneux said there are three or four others. Mr. Thrasher said he likes the roof tile, but believes a variance is required, and he said at least one of the eight standards have not been met. He said in Standard 42 it states "The special conditions and circumstances do not result from the action of the applicant," but he said based on what we have heard, they do result from the applicant. In addition, he said Standard 43 states "Granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by this Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district." Chairman Morgan said he also reviewed the Standards and was trying to find a basis on which to recommend approval. Mr. Lyons asked if a refusal of insurance would be considered a hardship. Mr. Thrasher said the Code is more strict with white cement thou and thou groove, non -textured, non- coated being added, but he said white thou and thou was always preferred and required. He said the applicant can purchase a concrete roof material of a color that meets Code and he would be able to get insurance and, therefore, as it relates to insurance it is not considered a hardship. Mr. Molyneux said there are two roofs across the canal from him that are brown and were done recently. Mr. Thrasher said if the architectural style of a home is determined to be something other than Bermuda, there is more flexibility relating to color in our Code. Mediterranean and Other Various styles would have more flexibility with color. Chairman Morgan said the Board is sympathetic with their position, but their hands are tied. He said he would encourage them present their position to the Commission. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend denial of a variance based on a finding that the proposed brown/tan concrete roof material is prohibited by Gulf Stream Zoning Code Sections 70-107 and 70-238. Additionally, none of the required eight (8) Standards for granting a variance have been met as defined in Section 66-154. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Smith moved and Mr. Lyons seconded to recommend denial of Level III Architectural/Site Plan based on the finding that the proposed brown/tan roof material is prohibited by Gulf Stream Zoning Code Sections 70-107 and 70-238, and none of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met as defined in Section 66-154. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 4 Mr. Randolph asked if there was any sympathy on the part of the Board to recommending that the Town Commission look at an amendment to the Code to create an exception where a roof color that has been in existence would be allowed to remain if replaced with a tile roof. Chairman Morgan, Mr. Smith, Mr. Murphy, Mr. Lyons and Mr. Delafield were in agreement and sympathetic to what the Molyneuxs are going through, particularly with the hardship they face on the insurance issue. Chairman Morgan said the color of the tile is attractive and appropriate to their home, and he said because it is a design element of the existing structure, Code Section 70-107 may allow the Commission to approve an exception under these limited circumstances. Mr. Randolph asked if the Board would like to move the recommendation to the Commission. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Murphy seconded to recommend that the Commission look at an amendment to the Code, or approve an exception, where a certain roof color, which has been in existence, can remain if replaced with a tile roof of the same color. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 2. An application submitted by William Ring, Commerce Group, Inc. as agent for Martin O'Boyle, owner of property located at 23 Hidden Harbour Dr., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. VARIANCE #1 to allow a net addition 109 square feet to the front entry feature of the existing non- conforming two-story single family dwelling that currently exceeds the maximum permitted floor area ratio by 2,589 square feet. b. VARIANCE #2 to permit the first -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 12.5 feet by 2.5 feet to the architectural element. C. VARIANCE #3 to permit the second -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 23 feet by 2 feet. d. VARIANCE #4 to permit an additional 2 foot encroachment beyond the existing 9 foot 8 inch front setback encroachment. e. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove 229 square feet of gross floor area. f. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition for a cumulative increase of 109 square feet to an existing 8,001 square foot, non -conforming, Spanish Mediterranean Revival, two-story single family dwelling. Charles Siemon of Siemon & Larsen, P.A. in Boca Raton, introduced himself and stated that he is a Land Use Planner and Land Use Attorney. He said some expert testimony is appropriate for this matter and he offered his resume into the record. Mr. Siemon's resume will be filed in the Official Records of the Town of Gulf Stream. Mr. Siemon said he will present the applicant's position, but he said it is a difficult and complex set of facts, and he said whether his Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 5 applicant qualifies for a variance, or if a variance is even necessary, requires the interpretation of the Town Code. He said the issues are judged by legal principles and architectural design. Mr. Siemon said the Board has been given a recommendation that draws conclusions or interpretations of the Code that are not consistent with legal principals or architectural design. He added that Staff analysis is also devoid of the principles that guide the interpretation of the Code. Mr. Siemon said the purpose and intent of the Town's variance provision includes two separate concepts that are separated by the word "or," which is alternative. He said he believes the proper reading of the Code is: "Variance are deviations from the terms of this Code that would not be contrary to the public interest when owing to special circumstances or conditions, or when the literal enforcement of the provisions would result in an undue hardship." Mr. Siemon said he believes the law requires that it be read disjunctively, that there are two circumstances under which variances are authorized by this Code. Mr. Siemon said the following: There are numerous cases in the State of Florida where the State has interpreted the word "or" to mean that they are disjunctive. That leads to analyzing each of the set standards and the eight standards do not apply to every variance application. Two of them are about uses and have nothing to do with this matter. This is a non -conforming structure made non -conforming by the adoption of the Gulf Stream Design Manual in 1995 through no fault of the owner. Mr. O'Boyle built the house in 1983 and complied with all requirements and it is a lawfully non -conforming structure that he can maintain as is, but it has lived out its usefulness as a design in the community and their attempts to upgrade are being frustrated by an inaccurate interpretation of the Code. Chairman Morgan asked for the citation of the variance section. Mr. Siemon said the purpose and intent is in 66-150. A series of standards are in 66-154, and he said the special circumstances would apply here. He said the home is significantly non -conforming and, with the changes in setbacks, if this property did not have a home on it you could not build on it. Mr. Siemon said he understands that the Town made a decision to set up guidelines to control future development in the community, but he said when there is a major change you look for ways to deal with existing structures that are not consistent with new regulations and recommend a provision allowing improvement by complying with the maximum extent practical with the requirements of the new design regulations. Mr. Siemon said the area of improvement is the facade of the home facing the private lane. It has a very ordinary character unique to the community and they would like to upgrade from the long horizontal look and create architectural interest by building a tower at the entrance and replace all windows and redo the building. He said he believes a variance is not required for the entry feature and that staff has applied the wrong provision of the Code. If it does apply, a variance is supposed to allow deviations from the Code that is in the spirit and intent of the regulations which are non -conforming as long as they are Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 6 harmonious. Mr. Siemon said this is not a hardship created by the applicant, it comes from the Code and everything is non -conforming. This is a special circumstance where they are applying for a minimum amount of change. He said the real issue is the tower, which is intended to mitigate the horizontal character of the design, and leaving the existing condition rather than improving it in a modest way is not consistent with the Design Manual. Granting the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Code and not detrimental to the public welfare. The property owner, his neighbors and the Town will benefit. Mr. Siemon referred to a drawing of the proposed entry feature and he said Staff believes the feature violates the eave height provisions of the design manual, but he said the overall height of the structure, which is 30 feet, meets Code. He said the structure is covered, but there is no floor, it is clear from the top of the step to the top of the structure inside, and there are no windows, just arches. It is an entryway that provides vertical character to the horizontal look of the home. Mr. Siemon referred to a drawing of a tower with a flat roof, no second - story eave, saying that particular design is permitted by Code, which he indicated was on Page A2.01 of their presentation documents. He said this is where an architect's expertise should be included in evaluating what is an eave and what violates Code. Mr. Siemon said an eave is part of a roof, and the area of the structure staff calls a first story roof is not a roof, it is a cornice line, or a decorative treatment. Without the cornice line it is not consistent with the intent of the overall design of the design manual. He said the proposed entry feature does not have a second story and it complies with the height limit. Mr. Siemon said if you look at the definition of "story" and the definition of "floor" in the Code, what the applicant is proposing is not a second story, it is an entry feature and both the height of the entry feature, which is 30', and the eave height, satisfies the Code. He said it is not a second story because you cannot get to the top, there are no stairs, only air, and he said there is a provision in the Code addressing that. Mr. Siemon said the design manual uses FAR as a surrogate for regulating the volume of the building. The Code says if you have a covered space that exceeds 15', you have to double in calculating the floor area. He said the entry feature is outside of the building and it is not a porch area and, therefore, you do not have to calculate floor area. Mr. Siemon said there is an entry feature provision in Subsection 70- 100. Roof and eave heights. (a) Generally.(4), which is difficult to understand and apply. He said, "I think it is understood that it is a different kind of feature from a one-story portion of the residence and a two-story portion of the residence, which are these lines right here and right here." Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Siemon to clarify and said, "could you tell me again, you made the statement that variance is required because of square footage, and only because of this thing. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 7 What is this thing?" Mr. Sieman said it is the entry feature which replaces the existing entrance. Mr. Siemon said there is a provision in the Code addressing modifications of existing structures and provides that the height from the base building can vary to the extent necessary to identify the entranceway to make it more monumental. Mr. Siemon displayed a photo of the Gulf Stream Town Hall, which he said reflects the architectural principle they are trying to achieve with the proposed tower, or entry feature. He said it will be an improvement over the existing condition, the applicant built the home himself, he built it to Code, it is his principal residence, and it is a lawful non -conforming structure. Mr. Siemon said he did not care whether or not a variance is required, or granted to make this clear, but he does care about the recognition that the intent of the design manual is met here. Mr. Siemon displayed a survey of the property and said there is a provision in the design code that excludes certain portions of a property in calculating the floor area, and that includes any property separated by a public or private road. He pointed out the private road indicated in green at the top of survey, which is dated November 21, 1994. Mr. Siemon offered the survey into the record. The survey will be filed in the Official Records of the Town of Gulf Stream. Mr. Siemon said, I am now talking about this small deviation of adding space, if you interpret this as floor area, and I believe there is a reason not to, the double counting of what is not floor area because it is more than 16' under this area, that goes away, and then the fact that more than 500 of this property is not counted in the effective floor area -land area, this lot is 39,000 plus feet, the water is excluded, the road is excluded, the 10' buffer is excluded and this is what is left. This lot and its unique configuration was not considered in the Code interpretation. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Siemon if his analysis is leading up to addressing the setback change. Mr. Siemon said he is only addressing the application of the Code and that Mr. Currie and Mr. Ring will address the setback issue. Mr. Siemon said in Section 70-100, the sub -categories of height are one story homes and two story homes, and he said all of the eave height regulations apply only to the two story portions and the only one that doesn't is the 30' height limit which is found in the negative in the prohibited section and what it says is that for two story portions greater than the following, the north south district, 30', you can't go beyond that, that's what the prohibited says, and by definition that means 30' is this and I believe Staff has acknowledged that this part of it is conforming and it is only this eave and while that eave is a part of a roof I would submit to you that it is not a two story portion of the building. He said he believes it is consistent with the intent and purpose and language of the Code. Robert Currie of Currie, Sowards, Aguila Architects, Project Architect, introduced himself and said in his 44 years as an architect he designed a number of homes in Gulf Stream that have won architectural awards. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing — February 28, 2013 Page 8 Mr. Currie said, as Mr. Siemon explained, they are trying to apply a vertical element in the horizontal scheme of this home to make it more characteristic of Gulf Stream and to make the entry feature more appropriate than the existing entry. He explained that they will cut the lanai area back into the setback and add only a couple of feet in the front to capture the two roofs that come out on the side, which is almost equal to what they will cut away. Mr. Currie said the Code provides that when you take something off you can only count half and when you add you have to count the full amount. He said they are not adding more physical space and they are reducing the physical setback. Mr. Thrasher asked Mr. Currie to display the lanai area. Mr. Currie said it is on Page A3.01 of their presentation documents. With regard to the tower, Mr. Currie said the height is in compliance with Code, but he said if they brought the eave down to the 22' where it would comply, it would have a smashed appearance. He said an eave is the underside of a roof overhang, but he said this is a cornice, it is a much better design and it improves the look of the home. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Currie to confirm that the drawing he is referring to is on Page A2.01. Mr. Currie confirmed that. Mr. Smith referred to the new 8' open air area and asked if it just went up like a shaft and if there were any windows on the inside of the home located behind that area. Mr. Currie said there are windows now, but they will be closed off and there will be no access from the physical structure to the tower. Mr. Lyons said it does look like a tower and he likes the other version better because it is more subtle. He asked if there was another design that did not stick out as much. Mr. Currie said the graphic is deceiving because of the coloring. Chairman Morgan said it could be the mass of the feature, and he asked if they could design a smaller and more diminutive feature that would not raise the potential for variance issues. Mr. Currie said the problem with bringing down the height is how it intersects with the existing roof and it would look like a mistake. He brought the drawing to the dais in front of Chairman Morgan to explain. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Currie about the setback. Mr. Currie said the setback is a consequence of the changes in the Code, and then a road was put in after the fact, and then the Code imposes a 10' buffer. He said the current setback only allows for a couple of feet of building. Mr. Currie said the other setback issue is the lanai that sticks out, they are getting rid of it and pulling the new feature out two feet. Mr. Lyons asked if there has been any feedback from the neighbors. Clerk Taylor said there has been no feedback. William Ring, Agent for the applicant and a Florida Attorney, introduced himself, and to assist him in answering questions about the setback issue, he distributed some photos and referred to Sheet A1.01 in the packet, which shows the site plan, the lanai area and the dimension of 6'6". He said you can see that the existing location of the lanai area extends further into the setback area than the proposed entry feature. Further, he pointed out that the actual Variance 44 states that they are asking for an additional 2' encroachment beyond the existing 9'8" setback. Mr. Ring said the 9'8" that is referenced is measured from the Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 9 planter, maybe because that is where the roof overhangs, but he said the new entry feature comes out to about the edge of the planter and the encroachment is not 2'. He said there may be some amount that is further than the roof edge to give it a bit of reveal, but he said the 9'8" is measured from the edge of the planter to the 10' buffer from the edge of the paved area. Mr. Ring referred to Sheet A1.01 where it says line of effective lot area, and he said if you follow the line where there is a 10' measurement (buffer area), the next line is 11'8" existing building setback. He said whomever drew this plan measured the setback from the actual building. Mr. Smith asked if the face of this feature will be flush with the roof on the west side. Mr. Ring said it will be consistent with the roof, but not with the wall. Chairman Morgan asked if any portion of the feature is livable space. Mr. Ring said there is no livable space with this feature. Mr. Currie said it is all open space. Mr. Ring said Variance 41 is the request for a 109 SF net addition, and he said Mr. Siemon explained that this is not an addition. He said there is no additional floor area being added, there is one entry feature to be demolished and one being constructed that is covered, but with no additional floor area. Mr. Ring said he does not believe a variance is required for that, but if it is required it should be approved because it is a fictional measurement. Mr. Ring said Mr. Siemon and Mr. Currie spoke to Variance 42 which was the requirement that the first floor eave height was exceeded because what the Town calls the first floor eave is 15'. Mr. Ring pointed out Marty Minor's report of 1/25/13, Table 2, where Mr. Minor called this an architectural element, not an eave. He said it is a tiled ridge or a cornice, an architectural element, and he said they do not need a variance to exceed the first floor eave height because it is not an eave, but if it is required the Board should approve because it is not an eave. Mr. Ring said Mr. Siemon spoke to the effects of the Code on the gross and net lot area of the property and showed an old survey. He said one of the requests was for a Level III/Architectural Site Plan Review for the addition to a non -conforming use where the square footage of the home exceeds what is allowable. If you ran the Code's percentages to the real lot area this home would not exceed any allowable floor area ratios, it is only when you apply the Code ratios to the fictional net lot area that you come to this non -conforming calculation. For those reasons, that variance should be granted. Mr. Siemon referred to the last two sentences in Section 70-100 (a) Generally. (4), which read: "Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house." He said it is ironic that we are in a building using that same architectural design to create an identity of where the entrance of Town Hall is. The Code requirement Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing — February 28, 2013 Page 10 is will it be in harmony, will it make it more consistent with the intent of the design manual. The applicant, Martin O'Boyle of 23 Hidden Harbour Drive, introduced himself, he stated that he is a Real Estate Developer with 43 years or experience in development, building and design. Mr. O'Boyle thanked Mr. Currie, Mr. Siemon and Mr. Ring for making a presentation on his behalf and he said they did a wonderful job and they were very diplomatic. He said he is somewhat outraged and explained that he bought the lot in the 70s, he built the home between 1981 and 1983 in keeping with the style of the time, but he said it is not the style of today. Mr. O'Boyle said he has worked with Mr. Currie and Mr. Ring for probably a thousand hours on a multitude of designs to come up with one that functions, bring the home into the new millennium and will improve the neighborhood. He said there are six homes in Hidden Harbour, he built his home and the home next to him, and he said he is in the process of rebuilding 16 South Hidden Harbour. Mr. O'Boyle said he believes everyone on the Board and those who drafted the Code has good intentions. He said this will be a big improvement to his home and he disagrees with Mr. Thrasher's analysis of the project. Mr. O'Boyle said he has millions of dollars invested in this home which he has lived in for 30 years and believes a bit of deference should be given to him and that nobody should impose their taste upon his assets. With regard to the setback issue, he said he considered taking down the home and rebuilding, but the property has been zoned to oblivion and he said he could not build a dog house on it. Mr. O'Boyle said he believes his property is worth between $2.6 million and $3.6 million to build a dog house on it, and he said if you want an ugly building, he will oblige. In closing he said he hopes the Board will accommodate their request, he has millions of dollars invested, he has neighbors and there are no objections, and he said he hopes the Board will allow he and his wife to do what they want with their asset. Mr. Lyons asked Mr. O'Boyle if he knows of any other home in Gulf Stream with this type of entryway. Mr. O'Boyle said he has not viewed any other of the homes in Gulf Stream in that way, but he has in Palm Beach and he said he is impressed with the Town Hall building. Mr. Lyons asked to have the picture of Town Hall put up against the picture of what they are proposing. Mr. Currie said that one is a one story structure and the other is a two story structure. Mr. O'Boyle asked if anyone on the Board found the design distasteful. Mr. Lyons said he did not feel it was particularly appealing and asked if it could be wider and more proportionate. Mr. Currie agrees that it should have been shown in one color so that it didn't appear as prominent. Mr. O'Boyle said taste should not be considered here. Chairman Morgan said a lot has been heard about the primary issues of setback and the interpretation of eave height and whether or not this is a variance from Code or a design application. Mr. Randolph said the issue before the Board today is limited to substantiating the variance that is requested. There is an opportunity in the Code to challenge the decision of the Administrative Official, and if they challenge the decision of the Administrative Official it should be applied for and advertised. When Mr. Siemon made his comments, he indicated that he did Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing — February 28, 2013 Page 11 not care if the Board agreed with him as to whether or not a variance is required, and that he was only laying the background for the fact that if you were to grant a variance today it would not do an injustice to the Code the way he interprets it. Mr. Randolph said, because this was not advertised as a challenge of the decision of the Administrative Official, he is not prepared to advise the Board Members on whether or not the Administrative Official is correct in his interpretation, and he said that is not the decision the Board has to make today. He said if the challenge was going to be made to his opinion it should have been applied for and advertised so that you would know what you were dealing with. Chairman Morgan said it is a good point, but he assumed that the opposition to Staff's determination would be to challenge any aspect of that decision and whether it is in support of a variance or whether it undermines the determination of a variance, and he said he assumed that it would be a part of the application. He said if it is not, it will change the direction this Board will take. Mr. Thrasher said that, on more than one occasion with Rita Taylor in his presence, he offered Mr. O'Boyle information which provided his options; one option was a variance application, and the other was the opportunity to challenge his administrative decision. He said the options were on the table from the beginning, and conversations with Mr. Ring indicated to him that they would not challenge the administrative decision, but would apply for variances as it relates to that specific issue. Chairman Morgan said by challenging the determination of variance they are recognizing that the Code sections to which they argued did not apply, which seemed to be the entire crux of the argument. He said they were not disputing Staff's decision that the applicant did not meet the eight requirements for variance, they were saying a variance did not apply at all. Mr. Randolph said they were saying that, but as background for why the Board should grant the variance and why criteria for variance have been met. He said the Board is not here today to determine whether or not they need a variance, but to determine whether or not the variances applied for meet the criteria, and he said the Board can consider the background and the arguments made. Chairman Morgan said it becomes very easy. Mr. Murphy asked Mr. Randolph for clarification on one of the arguments of what is an eave and what is not an eave. Mr. Randolph said he is not prepared to discuss whether or not the ordinance as drafted would consider this an eave or not, but the issue before the Board is based upon the application as made for a variance regarding eave height. Mr. Siemon asked Mr. Randolph if he is talking about an appeal under Division 5. Appeals. Mr. Randolph confirmed that. Mr. Siemon asked if the appeal would be of the administrative decision that a variance is required, and he asked if there is a development order or something that makes that an appealable issue. Mr. Randolph said the Code does provide for an appeal of the decision of the Administrative Official in regard to his interpretation of the Code, and he said it was discussed with the applicant as an option. Mr. Siemon asked if the appeal goes to the Board of Adjustment. Mr. Randolph confirmed that. Chairman Morgan asked Mr. Siemon if he would like an opportunity to consult with his Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 12 client. Mr. Siemon said he would like to consult with his client. Mr. Randolph suggested they leave the room for privacy and the discussion would resume following the next items. Mr. Currie read the definition of "Save" from Code as follows: "Save shall mean projected overhang of the lower edge of a roof." Item VI.A.2 was recessed at this point to allow Mr. Siemon to consult with the applicant. Mr. Randolph asked Chairman Morgan to move on to Item VI.A.3 and 4 at this time. 3. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates, Inc. as agent for Mr.& Mrs. Robert Julien, owners of property located at 1601 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described in metes and bounds in Government Lot 1, Section 10, Township 46 South, Range 43 East. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition of 392 square feet to the south east corner of the existing Spanish Mediterranean Revival style single family dwelling, to enclose an existing breezeway on the north side of the dwelling and to install a roof over the existing trellis connection to the existing guest house. Mark Marsh, of Digby Bridges, Marsh & Assoc, Agent for Julien, introduced himself, he said there are three areas covered in this application; the first is a one-story addition on the south east corner of the existing structure, the second is the enclosure of the existing breezeway and the third is to roof what is now an open trellised walkway linking the guest house to the main house. He said displayed renderings of elevations showing the proposed improvements, and he said it is all compatible with the existing structure, the materials are the same and there are no issues with FAR coverage. Chairman Morgan asked if there have been any objections from neighbors. Clerk Taylor said there have been no objections. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to approve Level II Architectural/Site Plan, based on a finding that the proposed addition of 392 SF to the south east corner of the existing Spanish Mediterranean style single family dwelling, enclosure of an existing breezeway on the north side of the dwelling and installation of a roof over the existing trellis connection to the existing guest house meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. 4. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates, Inc., as agent for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, Jr., owners of the property located at 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 21 and part of Lot 20 in Gulf Steam Cove Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to permit the extension of the non -conforming south wall of the existing structure, that encroaches a maximum of 1 foot into the south side setback, to add a master bedroom of approximately 302 square feet to be located on the first floor. Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 13 b. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit the addition of the proposed 302 square foot master bedroom to extend 20 feet into the 50 foot rear setback. C. DEMOLITION PERMIT to allow small portion of existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 car garage. d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the addition of a master bedroom, a small addition to the kitchen, a realignment of the 2 car garage and a new front entry, a net increase of 540 square feet on the first floor of an existing partial two story Neo - French Eclectic single family dwelling. Mr. Marsh introduced himself as Agent for Mr. and Mrs. Grumney. He said the home is a Neo -Classical French Eclectic style home, previously owned by Mr. and Mrs. David Jones, and he said there have been a couple of renovations over the years. Mr. Marsh said when the Grumneys purchased the home they identified some areas that are not compatible with their lifestyle, and he said they are applying for two special exceptions to allow them to extend the non -conforming south wall for the addition of a Master Bedroom. He said under the special exception criteria in Section 70-75, they meet the justification for the side yard setback and they are allowed to encroach 20' into the required 50' setback. Mr. Marsh said they will create a new entry feature, expand the kitchen to the west and realign the garage to be parallel with the road and more compatible with the neighborhood. Mr. Marsh displayed renderings showing the expansion of the kitchen area, which he said created some difficulty in complying with setbacks because of the strange angle. He referred to the following on the renderings: (1) The new entry portico, which is in keeping with the scale of the structure; (2) the new garage wing, which will mimic the existing brick and the existing slate roof; (3) the expansion of the master wing; and, (4) the reconfiguration of the kitchen area. Mr. Marsh said they will match the fenestration across the west face, groom the overgrown landscaping, replace hedging and create some foundation planting. He said one area that was not addressed was as part of the improvements is the driveway. Mr. Marsh said they would like to replace the gravel with a paved driveway to make it a hard surface. Chairman Morgan stated that the south side setback is a continuation of the non -conforming use and the west side falls under Sec. 70-75 allowing the encroachment. Mr. Lyons asked if the neighbor to the south who will be most impacted by the improvements has commented. Mr. Marsh said they may not notice the improvements because there is a huge buffer between the properties. Mr. Lyons said he lives across the street from the subject property and he said the existing driveway to the garage is brick. He asked Mr. Marsh if they will make the material consistent. Mr. Marsh said it will be similar, but they want a hard driveway. Mr. Lyons asked about lighting across the front of the property. Mr. Marsh said there may be two wall sconces within the portico, and he said the center of the house is recessed with a couple of magnolia trees that Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 14 flank the front door. He added that the entry will have a stucco element as a contrast to the brick. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception to permit the extension of the non -conforming south wall of the existing structure that encroaches a maximum of 1 foot into the south side setback, to add a master bedroom of approximately 302 SF to be located on the first floor. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Special Exception to permit the addition of the proposed 302 SF master bedroom to extend 20 feet into the 50 -foot rear setback. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a demolition permit to allow a small portion of the existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 -car garage. Mr. Marsh said the garage is on a pile structure and during their research they discovered that it may be necessary to demolish more than indicated in order to properly realign the garage. He said he did not know how much more at this time, but the end result would be the same. Mr. Lyons amended the motion and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a demolition permit to allow a portion of the existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 -car garage. Clerk Taylor asked how much of the existing roof will be removed. Mr. Marsh said it may affect the whole wing, but it will not change the heights or the form. Mr. Randolph suggested that the Board ask the applicant to come back to the Town Manager for approval of any additional demolition of the garage. Mr. Lyons amended the motion and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a demolition permit to allow a portion of the existing garage to be removed in order to realign the 2 -car garage, and final approval of any additional demolition of the garage is subject to Staff review and approval. There was no further discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Lyons moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend approval of a Level III Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit the addition of a master bedroom, a small addition to the kitchen, a realignment of the 2 -car garage and a new front entry, a net increase of 540 SF on the first floor of an existing partial two-story Neo -French Eclectic single family dwelling based on a finding that the proposed construction meets the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. The Public Hearing for Item VI.A.2., Continued. Mr. Siemon said he has consulted with the Town Attorney, and he said this renovation involves an insurance problem and there are time constraints. He said Mr. O'Boyle cannot obtain hurricane insurance at this point and hoped for an approval in time to redo the windows prior to the peak of hurricane season. Mr. Siemon said Mr. O'Boyle would like to move forward and they are going to apply for an appeal from the determination as to whether a variance is required. He asked that the Board go forward with the merits, he asked that the appeal go before the Board of Adjustment at the next Meeting, and he said hopefully they will look at the appeal first, before the Commission hears the request for variance. In Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing — February 28, 2013 Page 15 addition, he said they will remedy the esthetic focus on the entry feature prior to that meeting. Mr. Siemon said one thing the Code says is that granting a variance will not do any violence to the Code and its purposes, and the fact that a variance may not be required goes directly to that point. He asked the Board to consider his remarks with regard to that in that context. Mr. Randolph stated that the ARPB recommendation will go to the Commission on March 15th. He said their appeal would have to be submitted to the Town of Gulf Stream this date in order to be heard by the Board of Adjustment at the March 15th Meeting. Mr. Siemon said they will file the appeal today. Mr. Randolph noted that the applicant hopes that the Board of Adjustment will hear the appeal first. Mr. Lyons asked about the window replacement. Mr. Siemer said the applicant is not willing to commit to replacing the windows if this design is not approved, but he said it is not relevant to the decision, it is only to explain why time is of the essence. Chairman Morgan asked what level of review applies to a front entryway. Mr. Thrasher said if determined that it meets Code it is a Level I, but he said if it requires a variance it is a Level III. He said, for the record, Mr. O'Boyle has submitted a permit application for window replacement, it was approved and was forwarded to Delray for approval. Mr. Thrasher said the front entry feature elements will be different, but he said other portions of the home are unchanged and he could proceed with the window replacement for that part of it. Mr. O'Boyle said Mr. Thrasher is correct, they did apply for a window replacement permit and it was approved, but he said the windows were designed in conjunction with this facade and if this facade is not approved those windows will not be appropriate. Mr. Morgan noted that in proceeding with this application we are being asked to interpret the application in conjunction with the issues that resulted in its denial, including eave heights and setbacks, which are the issues to which they are seeking variance, rather than disputing the application of variance as a decision by Staff. He said he is sympathetic to the applicant's position, but he said he cannot advise on how to proceed. Mr. Thrasher asked if he could comment. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Thrasher that he not comment in regard to the issue as to whether or not they need a variance. Mr. Thrasher said we are hearing these variance applications and he said he is asking for time to address comments made by the agent of record or the expert witnesses. He said he would like to question things that have been stated as fact. Mr. Randolph asked Mr. Thrasher if there is something he heard that would change his recommendation, or does he simply want to support his recommendation. Mr. Thrasher said he would like to support his recommendation. Mr. Randolph asked Chairman Morgan if the Board needed to hear anything more. Chairman Morgan said the Code has been spelled out, we have been provided with Mr. Minor's report and we have the applicant's admission as to where their heights and setbacks fall. He said the applicant is Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 16 challenging the Administrative Official's decision in a separate application and, therefore, we must proceed with what we have. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend denial of a variance to allow a net addition of 109 SF to the front entry feature of the existing non -conforming two-story single family dwelling that currently exceeds the maximum permitted floor area ration by 2,589 SF based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend denial of a variance to permit the first -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 12.5 feet by 2.5 feet to the architectural element based on the finding that not all of the eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend denial of a variance to permit the second -story eave height of the proposed entry feature to exceed the maximum discouraged height of 23 feet by 2 feet of the architectural element based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend denial of a variance to permit an additional 2 -foot encroachment beyond the existing 9 -foot 8 -inch front setback encroachment based on the finding that not all of the required eight (8) standards for granting a variance have been met. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Delafield seconded to recommend denial to remove 229 SF of gross floor area as the proposed alterations do not meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. Roll Call: Mr. Lyons, AYE; Mr. Smith, AYE; Mr. Delafield, AYE; Mr. Murphy, AYE; and, Chairman Morgan, NO. The motion passed by a vote of 4 - 1. Mr. Murphy moved and Mr. Smith seconded to recommend denial of Level III Architectural/Site Plan to permit a cumulative increase of 109 SF to the existing 8,001 SF non -conforming, Spanish Mediterranean Revival style two-story single family dwelling based on a finding that it does not meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. There was no discussion. All voted AYE. VII. Items by Staff. There were no items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. Mr. Lyons asked if the ARPB would be involved in making the decision concerning the new street lighting. Mr. Randolph said the Town Commission will make that decision, but he said the Commission may ask the ARPB for their input. Chairman Morgan announced that Amanda Jones, Vice -Chairman of the ARPB, has requested a six-month leave from her Board duties due to a personal matter and that she may need to resign as a Member and come back as an Alternate Member. He suggested that Mr. Smith be nominated as Vice- Architectural Review and Planning Board Regular Meeting and Public Hearing - February 28, 2013 Page 17 Chairman. Mr. Randolph asked if there is a rule for Members who miss a certain number of meetings. Clerk Taylor said there is a rule for missing meetings without being excused, but she said the Commission could grant a six-month leave. Mr. Randolph asked the Board if there is a nomination for Vice -Chairman. Mr. Lyons nominated Mr. Smith as Vice - Chairman, all voted AYE. IX. Public. No Public Comment. X. Adjournment. Chairman Morgan adjourned the Meeting at 10:45 A.M Gail C. Abbale Administrative Assistant sa�og dinxnZ duaouitl xaEy� waosnauorinrr s»aosc�9s I.j � �-` p � L9M -'U UOM � - 9 2WvS - MN'kmU PuaS �6 =9 EPPOIJ 'm8aiasjIn� •pejg u�a3p 'j1aoN I V ii9E ZP V' M LL r � W� oa z� N - ----- --- N O LL ZP s a 004 0 b 1t oo� Y yylµ ¢ m 25 UPo Op � i to Q b p 8 F F� � 8 V' M LL r � W� oa z� N - ----- --- N O LL sauioH Ainxn-I AgloiniL jiLW Eptaoi� 'mEaals31nf)> woo'sDUB-ouvunM swaasc'tvs ® r �— V J O C14 � 41) I., ca l l . a a up LRKE - -U �I FX9 - 8 MPS - MN'R-W P��S �9 0019 P°ig u'ea:)p 111-10M I iU IL ® 4— LLX LU CV 04 Z W 1— a L.V a Q I a 8 a I I k i I I k II II I II H ------------------ -------------------------- --------------- II II II II I c II II II II it 11 II II 8 ' II II i II II II II :ik=zzz:::::====zzzzzz:z:zz:y¢zz I II II 11 11 I: 11 zzzzzzz==:z=z= I i c II 11 I k z II II 11 II I I k i k I I I I I a I I I I I se A+ �y r as — 8 k k � N a a k 2 } II k— — ■ — — — — — — — — — — — j --- I 3 th --- --------------- t • • II - N I i i I, x•, e r I I II I II I _= II I: •..: ' I I �X _____---------- --------------- ------------ T _________ 1 k k II I I I II I � ' 1 k 9 I 6 .Ch 6 II II II NR ! II y II S II I II T_________________ II T— II I1 3 II II II I II I I OCIOOOCI OO�OO� 1 I k ❑ p! ❑❑❑❑❑❑❑i ❑❑_FT -1❑❑ >a Ni M ' ' ❑°❑❑❑4❑ ❑❑ 1 .. ` ❑ ❑❑❑ E a t jj ll I I +i i ❑❑❑❑ ❑$L]LILLIE] ❑I II I❑❑❑❑ i ' o 1111111 I ❑❑❑❑ ❑❑❑❑❑❑❑❑ I 1�- ' %• k ------------ -- ❑❑❑❑❑❑❑❑ ----------'--- I Y kY A+ A+ + Y yyl+ by+� yn+ Y F IL ® 4— LLX LU CV 04 Z W 1— a L.V a Q I a 8 a I I k i I I k II II I II H ------------------ -------------------------- --------------- II II II II I c II II II II it 11 II II 8 ' II II i II II II II :ik=zzz:::::====zzzzzz:z:zz:y¢zz I II II 11 11 I: 11 zzzzzzz==:z=z= I i c II 11 I k z II II 11 II I I k i k I I I I I a I I I I I se A+ �y r as — 8 k k � N a a k 2 } II k— — ■ — — — — — — — — — — — j --- I 3 th --- --------------- t • • II - N I i i I, x•, e r I I II I II I _= II I: •..: ' I I �X _____---------- --------------- ------------ T _________ 1 k k II I I I II I � ' 1 k 9 I 6 .Ch 6 II II II NR ! II y II S II I II T_________________ II T— II I1 3 II II II I II I I OCIOOOCI OO�OO� 1 I k ❑ p! ❑❑❑❑❑❑❑i ❑❑_FT -1❑❑ >a Ni M ' ' ❑°❑❑❑4❑ ❑❑ 1 .. ` ❑ ❑❑❑ E a t jj ll I I +i i ❑❑❑❑ ❑$L]LILLIE] ❑I II I❑❑❑❑ i ' o 1111111 I ❑❑❑❑ ❑❑❑❑❑❑❑❑ I 1�- ' %• k ------------ -- ❑❑❑❑❑❑❑❑ ----------'--- I Y kY A+ A+ + Y yyl+ by+� yn+ Y saaiog Ainxn l dgaotni L -4ieW EplaolA 'mEaaislinf) •pnig u72330 ulaoN iig8 M NIOD'SD31FMUMV SVPO d.*I% 9 i3 C/31 ,a �2 5 o Lav% -'U UM" F"a-e;vms-MN*&-W�ro�aoa9 o o� ui aN °a z o o o� I LL- s;)uaoH Ainxnj At[louiijL )jjEW VPPOIA Itule;)ilsjlnf) vjo3srRl*ovvur4wv CD ME, L9M —U UWV TXQ - 8 WIS - MN *AW *pAlq U*eDJO 'ql-ION THE .— LU M C3, U— C= Rl. 114 ME, r-) • I•--- - noun 11 is Maine.. � I I I I M— I I NO Ion t A 04 V C) sguc[OH Ainxnj Stpotail -3prN YVCDSD3l*DTiUR4WV S"OWL195 C-�A C:D ,eppojj lumeaijsjjnf) �6 � 7 0 ce- *PAJU U1030 0 qljox 1199 w m Z 0 W 00 E 0 mom IMEN wommomm El-mmommm- mmm I III C:D , d; �:�t �6 � 7 0 ce- 0 mom IMEN wommomm El-mmommm- mmm I III / WO7'SUillFDNVWMI3V S"ffNL'195 - ml I , dinn ,(ij O iII i S E sao x'I mH LSKE -'H UMPS POO9 - 9 a11nS - MN 'fkl PunOS -W39 0019 � �— . o • Ep►aoi,� 'meai;sjinf r AN�--1 •pnjg UE330 gljoN iig8 � � � • § LLI vo C= �� C14 04 UJ �n w 0 v _i LA- © '.., r 1 sauiog 6inxnj dq;omil -4aEy� EpPold °LuEaaIsJinf) wmsuUMuvunasav sseoosctgs U3 F Ll � a �u am-1HuomT-9-amm-MN 'P"ig uEaJp TIIJO i size O UG.d— _ �IL9�J CDe E►. rNFj©a O UG.d— J AL �Y. M W E_ ® J LL F_ M r E RS N rHVA /`V L L � A 1 i� w CD 3 U � o ® s� rSIMON w z�r x :y a l W tin NOMMEN r OJ a 1 l 1 I rrlss Sammons �ssss -- =220s 2:ss ass L3aEmYl� ;Mui 1 I L -19,i L.. 2 1 777= = ® J LL F_ M r E RS N rHVA /`V L L � A 1 i� w CD 3 U � o ® ,) w z�r x :y a l W tin cc OJ a F_ Q x U � o T1s w z�r x :y CLUI /zo pro uim steaul6uesgs@olul IIVYV3 9646-OLL I ZLL XV3 ZZ96-0LL I ZLL 131 tl019071 'Kv3iLS �In� •�_-: 3rwas 096Z£ VOR10-W H3V39 0m3A L0Z 31!ns 'OA1B 213NN NVIdNI LLLL 09VA31f108 NV300 H1LON LtZC Li. AYNG08990 0. 9NI NOLLrZiGW - N N 3NIOlMl:!iS? Wd N01111OW34 077 `QHVA97fl09 2Nxrao m ON1LUWb3d 7YLN3WNObNN3 • 9NINNV7d ONV7 • 90103301903 7YURL�!lHLS � 71N� � U�NNVHJ0 HLHON TTZS'MAVOGOIS V 311118`3>rinH0S3tNaois3a A�urre meows a3soaoad ® cts L Lu ! �' L J m C7 U) �' a Wo 0 N p LL c U Z owC or - 00 �.e " C7zim \ R! `N 3Q� 322 ,�,•' �=N Z:16 O� 2 ° O o Nb m� II 11373-g,{ -7NOZ Zoe e 011 AI b l l b � * 0007 W :y i3' $ �' :n e s-8ii 3NOZr7ppLi Cu C Is "Z� y �' f15LA1.1jt4.'LVS 9 � -� `g 9!ffiIMAI.IC � � 8 R � a h@ - O! 11373-g,{ _A000007L o S .9 3NOZOOp7� _ $ .x N � e I I I I I ! I ! ! 1 m a 14.{ ON U3 Z NO N« NO x o 2 a ..x ci, N % 3 N m ! I---- I ! OV --7 O I~i, U X _ I � x� .A O`y IOONN•Ol!�l� �ON a d00�. XON N N Ix/ e x' W NO,'O�_-``---�-�-- C - � I t I i I I F ! � I I 1 i I I ! �9,e3zssl I � 1 I l 1 1 r- I { I I O 1 I 90 �n I I I _—•—--_�_—__ ! I amN $ X10 N V rz I I 1 ---_—.____ -77 "t"" G I J. I m ! I"III m rx g a %a it N N 1 I L -fir ?zR.-. L W c'.•J a I'1 - II h (- t.`�' 'x I i N o F..uti a�a {I L- I:I it. W m W n g X te_-9-- a OR ee m� p hx oW I 1 If h!11 N oe l " tIf h W Jao �� o II m -� �� _I '� N m 11• I ° o VZ 61 itIx - 2°N w�zm e L"d 4 Ve o 'ate I= o !{^ ?wcoiw io�`i`I hl �vQ"�I� hoo A W wo I\ -- 00 11 Wu • Qo I �3 '$II Bahl \ h\,; I I � _ �a zl I� 4w mfr k w A< _ j _ -rzl a 3v �°, I. I' I � 1,,.' 1, z 'moo W 4 9 oQ.N I W.. q IMP= � q �_<� �oq'� III ry � j L a.. _JIo L'=o>�-:r_z�aq j1 o Y �1' �., s���o�a� �$ s a o <� v�o �aW II _ o a -g o ° 1 2 0� u_1 _ o .i.>3®®Btse�B%BaeP19i��E711 a®L��3� OO ® m g t' � �, N m -a ek II c mo W 3 II I .e m I ffi II HNN=�<�`o�kkanspn4 a4 0 0 XI -c ti -a y,�`•. I � .�, x I _ x .sem owmmaaaaoo€ow w �I x z x k\ I lb x Ix m ob - 1 •Ismr3gtx�.zgy� - - W m �oo� * It 11 1 I If ^ ith IR „x W x w W J S 4X � ry � I I I I I ! I ! ! 1 m a 14.{ I ! a tioiW Wei II 3� 1 I t I i I I F ! � I I 1 i I I ! �9,e3zssl I � 1 I l 1 1 r- I { I I ( I I I I I L-- 1 I I I I I cioz/so/zo acro uloo•sleaul 9s�10!'IIVW3 96116-OLL / ZLL XVA ZZ96-OLL / ZLL IM tl0R1013 'Wv3itLS 3100 •�'•i anss 0967E VOIUOI� HOV39 ON NO LOZ mm A 'O ivi mio M/IONI LGLI 0lNA3N109 NV300 RMN IIZE P13 89990000ON NOLLtlZIa0lilOr j0 NOI1tl01J11N3J ^ srlWM83d 7rLN3rvNo'&W - DAWWWld GW • OAN&UM90 714MUYw/s f 7zv� Ndid 311S j7I 'a�immoa Csax 3o 11d3Jo HdtIOM TTZS�'•'`3 1118 `�>i�f1H S '30N3OSM ADMA 31OMS 03S0dO8d° _ol %1373-B43No2g00Zl B 3NOZo06- _ ---_ w T._._____—______� N oupr.,,," 4• m Q N q / I I _ z II I i3 �L ;1 -?Z7 -9A 3HOZ of — Gbo1i A 2 ` �" 0 11 N 1, � O $ 1 b 373-g^ 1 _ol %1373-B43No2g00Zl B 3NOZo06- _ ---_ w T._._____—______� <c A x II z q / I I _ z II I i3 x a IppplI 1 Ii. • r' Z" l°i L-7 w :. ' �• I � l i ter,-_� t.• -� I I �s I 1 I I I. I r i evsearss ----- �- r r I j I r / L I t I L' -_ I I 1 L ° s e I 3V I � B� Vd� 2 3C Vv�iwm "i w!2z I� B ^� ry"I Ua<c�i gllitF Px V I _ — — — — ?----it all 1 It 2 W lit ax 1 n II v L- LL- D E s N L- Lc� � C -D V w o 0 m Ixl IW I Xi 2 va U 2 % $ 1 x� •ip � ii `••■ ,Iii LU U) fn - x I x °3 w ma $ 1-1A �v � w U . gx w€8 A 8X _e yn A x II z q / I I _ z II I i3 x a IppplI $ X 1 Z" l°i L-7 w lit ax 1 n II v L- LL- D E s N L- Lc� � C -D V w o 0 m Ixl IW I Xi 2 va U 2 % $ 1 x� •ip � ii `••■ ,Iii LU U) fn - x I x °3 w ma $ 1-1A �v � x LII I x Ilk' dal 1 t# Ys1 so, II . gx w€8 A 8X _e yn A x II z q / I w ° _ z II I i3 g 10 $ X 1 lit ax 1 n II v L- LL- D E s N L- Lc� � C -D V w o 0 m Ixl IW I Xi 2 va U 2 % $ 1 x� •ip � ii `••■ ,Iii LU U) fn - x I x °3 w ma $ 1-1A �v � x LII I x Ilk' dal 1 t# Ys1 so, II . gx w€8 A 8X _e yn A x II t I I 7 1 1 I q / I Q n z II I i3 10 I oW 93 fl It h i x a g xlua; g", oo _ 2 Nm — I 1 : I t I I 7 1 1 I q / I Q n L 10 Z" l°i L-7 w :. I I I: f r I i 1 I I Iq It I 1 I I I. I r i evsearss ----- �- r r I j I r / L I t I L' -_ I I L_- 11VW3 96i6-OLL I UL XV3 ZZ96-OLL I ZLL 191 096ZE V011f013 'HOV39 OHM lO 3j -ins "0A19 H3A111 NVIONI LILL 999RMOO ON NOi1VZINOH1nv JO NOI1V01.!I1N30 9NW/WN3d 7V1N3VN02IW13 • 9N'NNVJd ONr - 0NIX33N9N3 7YXfu & -T 7 vJ S N O 1103 S S S O N 0 O'1--1 `(DAVOOOIS -Q 3-LL18 '3N-inHOR NVaDO OLLNV'IJV I D, ------------ 99, CAVN Mn af101N00 .00.0 An a31vM H091 w3m I I — 3N11 L13LVM N`JIH -"DS 3S 8 a Of -TAW 1 3N177g001{ tlW .d N I i� 3Nn l0aLN00 NOa0f9115N00 T'15V00 0'10 4iQ s3Lf1Lv1 VOM -H OLZ'Vf-OZ9 a31dVH0 aid 3Nn 11Na3d 1Va3N30 IRS s I I I W w �I L6/ZZ/B fD0lp03a -- s0ao339 ALN= 1OV313 NIVd '951-L41 S30Vd •09 / I "0 1300 aid An '1'0.0'0 1 i � I al I`1 -- In° I �I 3Nn AaEkKwd s3M ao3 I v -1-r ro's /"wle NY300 HIaON , Vowo-u 'v 3ws dlno y §$g 09VA31n09 NV300 HIMON LLZ£ R FC^ C IOZ/wO . MV0 Q310N SV 37YJS 077 Nv,�0o HIHO1 Hof: Sd f13X13Vf0 �m :30N301S38 OYM AMIVYO d Qd id lu s- O3MJ53O 3LVO AVNSN3a JINNI Ids-Z91Z1 DMNIVNa r 11VW3 96i6-OLL I UL XV3 ZZ96-OLL I ZLL 191 096ZE V011f013 'HOV39 OHM lO 3j -ins "0A19 H3A111 NVIONI LILL 999RMOO ON NOi1VZINOH1nv JO NOI1V01.!I1N30 9NW/WN3d 7V1N3VN02IW13 • 9N'NNVJd ONr - 0NIX33N9N3 7YXfu & -T 7 vJ S N O 1103 S S S O N 0 O'1--1 `(DAVOOOIS -Q 3-LL18 '3N-inHOR NVaDO OLLNV'IJV I D, ------------ 99, CAVN Mn af101N00 .00.0 An a31vM H091 w3m I I — 3N11 L13LVM N`JIH -"DS 3S 8 a Of -TAW 1 3N177g001{ tlW .d N I i� 3Nn l0aLN00 NOa0f9115N00 T'15V00 0'10 4iQ s3Lf1Lv1 VOM -H OLZ'Vf-OZ9 a31dVH0 aid 3Nn 11Na3d 1Va3N30 IRS s I I I W w �I L6/ZZ/B fD0lp03a -- s0ao339 ALN= 1OV313 NIVd '951-L41 S30Vd •09 / I "0 1300 aid An '1'0.0'0 1 i � I al I`1 -- In° I �I 3Nn AaEkKwd s3M ao3 I v -1-r ro's /"wle NY300 HIaON , Vowo-u 'v 3ws dlno y §$g 09VA31n09 NV300 HIMON LLZ£ R FC^ 'aavna7nori in 077 Nv,�0o HIHO1 Hof: NOW 40 �m :30N301S38 d Qd id lu kllrfVJ TONIS 03SOd0ad ❑ ❑ ❑ LL - @ LU �� tvC= "' U.75 a •-- ":mr ui"e > w � �P c '-'- 3:a a M1 ddwMN HN�_9dd 9d LLW_ I I I I I I I I I'll 1144H,, I I I I I,, I V-1 IV uwn•slaaw6u2sgs�qul lIVW3 9666-OLL l ZLL XV3 ZZ96-OU / ZLL -131 O96ZE VOIaOl3 HO`d39 M19A M 91MS "OAl9 N3AI8 NVIONI LILT• VOlao-u Wfisis dln0xxs- B999O O ON NOI_VZ8OHMV JO NOIiV2IJ11!]O om3womo NV3o0 H1NON ££££ q-9_9ami • .s9/JLllWa3d 7dLN3WNOX6W3 9NlNNYId ONV7 9Nk133N13A13 MnL�/kILS W 7W,7 N V� d J N U H J 1l NVW'I7I D •1' SI?IOa mt� 3 o U �t N vv d � yl `d�b'OQOlS '8 3 1118 dMav/1 `�n1nH.7s '30N3o� AIINY! TIONtS 0350d08 10110.1 zl/sl/OI arrad�l LL "•I a'+✓u y }7 ��p�,pll�pl L aaM]ai0 ,'.AY tl�•�•� pip NIO •"MIN��� sm Tww A Ids-6YIZI aN vua '' I �r U e LL y }7 ��p�,pll�pl L u ,'.AY C'rf pip NIO •"MIN��� xi A W -� m m'1 i ee� cn = 0-1 � �� 3�2 V O j" 2� U22, Zpi6 '' I �r Elk LL ,'.AY C'rf CO U) cn �— a. � G cn = 0-1 � �� =3Z �A 3~ � m a o CO AL a a Elk 9e9 � gn gi R3 §g � O mO U� L]p ,s3aaul6�Q^@(9u! lIVW3 9666-OLL l ILL XV3 ZZ96-OLL I ILL l31 VOIaO1i 'WV3a15 dlnO 96ZE tlORiOIJ H�tl38 0213A lOZ 31ins 'OATH 2i3AliJ NtlIONI LILL OaVA31nOB NV3O0 HIaON llif�y89990000 ON NOIIVZi8O113fIV f0 NOI1VOI-11'C?�`ILIIVY3d 7V1N3VNOX61N3 - 91VINNV7d ONV7 - 9NIH33NION3 7VY(U 7XLS -V 7W� 077 `GHVAH7l108�i to�-11J _ (INV inn AIV.700 HLLHON ITOC ����"U I•I `Q2i` OG IS V 3JL j `3N�f )S :3ON3O153a A11KV3 31ONIS O3SOdOad ❑ ❑ ❑ Lm cloz/eo/za .�3 ra J •�-•I 3z�s 3 N OJ � Q �• n . 33ra NOaN3a wnn Ids-MZL DWvxa '^ 494 polioL Y � LL_ © M LrJ O a) > c14 N U W o LL- � e j U W m J h 3 N OJ � Q LL_ © M LrJ O a) > c14 N U W o LL- � e j U W N C11) 04 N OJ � Q �• n LL_ © M LrJ O a) > c14 N U W o LL- � e j U W  z/zl/z xval ai0=3 aul6uasgs@(4ul -IINW3 9646-OLL I ZLL XV3 ZZ96-OLL 1 ZLL l31 �-" ��'��/�� - 09626 VORfOId 'HOV38 ON3A LOZ 31lnS "OAl9 N3AM NVIONI LLU -S dm QiA03Ft] 09990000 ON NOI1VZiMOluOV A0 NOIIVJI!!iN30 9. "Yaa 9NLUIWN3d 7V1N3YYN0N14N3 " WNNY7d ONVI " W&UNION3 7YNIlLX&S f 71413 " SdM �y 3LVaa .��.��.�� `azi`daQOls '8 3 1118 `��Ji��f1H��S Y0 Ip6N3N MYYM OLLd3SZBlLI DA MIYbT/ 7 ?suis I AY-;qRt 14 Cf figs � ' lit] 1 2 YOWOl3 'RaB nm ONYATM NY330 HIM IIZC t NVId 32 nixie ?suis I AY-;qRt 14 Cf figs � ' lit] 1 2 YOWOl3 'RaB nm ONYATM NY330 HIM IIZC t NVId 32 nixie 'QiIVn3InoH !9-.9 9 i N VUiSAS 0I1d3S SII uvaoo rr��uou rrze - .4 T; _ �� �" ��m "�� NQJ NOIS30 rMSlS OMS O3SOdOHd �� Q' Q' Q' ?suis I AY-;qRt 14 Cf figs � ' lit] 1 2 t cm Co fv ala Crry���% W O A LU U) ev..) U. r � N ��L y �� Oa j zw OC p ca Ii cl ~ J a a a Q t a =9� noZ/ZVZ Xro vow -u YN31u5 sm ONVA NY330 H NON IIN oz Eln rn -m¢ � aU g S w ii . § ' '9'J'M 03)L]3xq 1 ms's g g '9'W'N tmvw m z i '1%I w 9 3 �3 'S'd'M ap p 31V0 NoismjH NHYIx MdMZ91Z1 JNNIVNO a =9� I n o%v1 (INV SNoav�no-ido W31SAS �I1d3S vow -u YN31u5 sm ONVA NY330 H NON IIN oz Eln rn -m¢ � aU g S w ii . § ' E$ 1 ms's g g LL o z i '1%I w 9 3 �3 W 4U LLS N H RS •N -P _- so s W U='Slaau!F)U-'Sqs@(lu! lIVW3 9606-OLL I ZLL XVI ZZ96-OLL / ZLL 131 096ZE V6IHOl3 HOV39 OM3A mi auras "OA -9 N3AI8 NVIONI LLLL 00 H99900 ON NOIiVZid0111 OV JO NOI LVOT+IiN]O ONLGWN3d 7t+LN3WNP71WV3 • WNNY7d ONt'7- 9N/L733N/9N3 7I4U1L7/WS Y 7W� I n o%v1 (INV SNoav�no-ido W31SAS �I1d3S vow -u YN31u5 sm ONVA NY330 H NON IIN oz Eln rho � N OTI 'aUVA3'IaOHNV330 HJAON ME•O-T� :, N�� `MIVOOOl '8 3 UI S e `3��nHOS d• a Q LL z i '1%I w 9 3 �3 W 4U LLS N H RS so s W U='Slaau!F)U-'Sqs@(lu! lIVW3 9606-OLL I ZLL XVI ZZ96-OLL / ZLL 131 096ZE V6IHOl3 HOV39 OM3A mi auras "OA -9 N3AI8 NVIONI LLLL 00 H99900 ON NOIiVZid0111 OV JO NOI LVOT+IiN]O ONLGWN3d 7t+LN3WNP71WV3 • WNNY7d ONt'7- 9N/L733N/9N3 7I4U1L7/WS Y 7W� I n o%v1 (INV SNoav�no-ido W31SAS �I1d3S vow -u YN31u5 sm ONVA NY330 H NON IIN oz Eln rho � N OTI 'aUVA3'IaOHNV330 HJAON ME•O-T� :, N�� `MIVOOOl '8 3 UI S e `3��nHOS d• a Q Q J g i s b S ILL 3 - U='Slaau!F)U-'Sqs@(lu! lIVW3 9606-OLL I ZLL XVI ZZ96-OLL / ZLL 131 096ZE V6IHOl3 HOV39 OM3A mi auras "OA -9 N3AI8 NVIONI LLLL 00 H99900 ON NOIiVZid0111 OV JO NOI LVOT+IiN]O ONLGWN3d 7t+LN3WNP71WV3 • WNNY7d ONt'7- 9N/L733N/9N3 7I4U1L7/WS Y 7W� I n o%v1 (INV SNoav�no-ido W31SAS �I1d3S vow -u YN31u5 sm ONVA NY330 H NON IIN oz Eln rho � N OTI 'aUVA3'IaOHNV330 HJAON ME•O-T� :, N�� `MIVOOOl '8 3 UI S e `3��nHOS wg U N C3 NUJ U. O rho 30G a o� d• a Q F x F a 0 W r C" LL i� ■� W o u pct 4N 1111111111111111IIIllll rV� I I I O U p! ���_ � O p.u�r+wZZ6F»�Cirt1i f ®��J O® e w__ g i5 0 = ij .ps'Y M•tgpZfs C `1 •9! k OY #>----------- •-_ w______�____--_-----_-------w.--- x_ occe M y 6 � ', I �$�[9r...�[i•�O��t�.�a 4J 711�c b1�C i -� _ Ty--��� __ _'-- i do z 10 0Q �O N A 3N7 Xl&/off H N Z po ZZ ZE W W E ZQ goo 9 w 5 O¢Z uiz m U m O O m 0 ow q� o z ��� �o W^ < zz U Q S H o f i O a O o 0 = m a Q O Qz a> LLvwiOa Nm ZwwF m °° ¢. ¢ Z ¢ =Vm p03 m<2� 2 z Z E W O a w z w a �2 O> r FO tiles > w w - E Om= z Oa00 z3 mo$w O� 0 a i w w¢ S H<5 0 0 w W o maw m0 _ �F 0= d¢ a1- a r mp Z-0 ¢wm m0 Q �¢3 Z o zo `r30LL oN o z Owm.I ¢,6-- =i QLL W >p �� 2<�� mini ",2, ¢Z ¢w cwiw ¢a N �S ¢ N a < wmma m u x0� zFON ¢w mm 30,CQ plw-m 00 ¢m O O m w z DO>w Z X Qo m0 ¢00¢ Ohm 0 � m w z O O K mw w Z moor LL? Z¢ w W m �Ow> OOO O?N O w > f uxi Oi u = �¢a m ¢$z ¢w 0�w Zw >¢a ¢w o a� w o �0zz Iy >° uo<0 �az �7 p0 HZ yrw O N a w3 Z¢ ¢ Ow¢ mw D ow2 mm 2 i3 r wF w V X02 03 a LLQ¢ Q W o a w w _ Fzw zmo z O<�O>Ea :, V .699i9 zzg64fvv 0 U z a r, 81 — zgo w~ aw¢ S x O 2 m w¢ m m Z LLzpwr r7w1-1w- Z OZ m r¢ m¢ Qmm1a., Q H Om c20Ur-Ow 2zm R o3 IT nu w muo Z0<O ID IT 2¢ a - x " 0 a w r F r¢ a � a o OLL 6 w U m r Z a LL O w ¢ of Q Z a�1 00 z¢ 0 a¢ a w O z m a zwm LL�a m z I a O¢ c = wam w=�00 m z w w0 >ww 3rz mz zz c07va pVwt�m awUes X60 a M w¢ > w 0¢� p w r 2 O Zz? j V a W Z u Z O w r a i 1-W� F a r w LL O zz~a wELL�za00u0 m O g z r¢ O O F w W O 2 a oeo a. -1200x- <¢ ?+ U Oaf o¢�w ¢0gwz2�^ w0 m Na OSr UwmK a a ink Q rr 0 m Z� Z r 0¢ w LL w wFOJ OOLLw a 1zo t7LL mQ �9 tt ca7a w mmOra3 a�wz° rpr Jx O �I�I olelCl� po ZZ ZE D z 199 goo 9 w 5 F<, - � .. '=ou c 7 �w m z >m oao o � z LL W am <wa "' zue esu a z�>m a wAtt OF V�V�� ..Do Qq w -MUD iQu. U y¢j wU 17=x' 0 LL � �m¢m Z �� h Z m¢ O O z waa m O -How Z N Z F W V 0 2 wa a oN mo �� Z Ow m�zF y z P< w ¢ Ow N �O ¢ugwm ug yy=oaf 4a z ]�'m Jz U U O Oz = vl wFj aNza ? 6 m S K a �aLLac¢io K O Z W F 11z o zuz w�U'¢o mm 3 mR a R �'"�mo J ^_ z la- = 0"o ¢ oLL U z0 m Ii mVa tq0 ¢¢ ¢ 0 0mn p w � ¢gym 0 a u z o g o ¢ ¢ u0-iw 3 FOpm O¢ > O > Q OOO j>i vi=Z-- ¢ W Jwm ¢ w¢" _ mw oz w o ¢ m ¢ x Q U m w m ¢ ti¢ O F LL y¢ O 0 0 aw� z �Z¢wz > w Z tt w ¢ m w a= w LL wZ <O a0" Quz a z w F m m 0 .01M (n -> g« o x U�¢Fuz w m z i m "ria zm0n mFZ-. O 0¢ om h es wu> gFz o w o p w w=Qo1 u ¢ 00 0 u w i�� m= j W J ott- WmZw J 0 a i w w¢ S H<5 0 0 = V w z w w� I- E�> a UI -r m?c7m z-i w F 2< Q r1= wa�m?> mw :, V .699i9 zzg64fvv 0 U z a r, 81 — zgo w~ aw¢ S x O 2 m w¢ m m Z LLzpwr r7w1-1w- Z OZ m r¢ m¢ Qmm1a., Q H Om c20Ur-Ow 2zm R o3 IT nu w muo Z0<O ID IT 2¢ a - x " 0 a w r F r¢ a � a o OLL 6 w U m r Z a LL O w ¢ of Q Z a�1 00 z¢ 0 a¢ a w O z m a zwm LL�a m z I a O¢ c = wam w=�00 m z w w0 >ww 3rz mz zz c07va pVwt�m awUes X60 a M w¢ > w 0¢� p w r 2 O Zz? j V a W Z u Z O w r a i 1-W� F a r w LL O zz~a wELL�za00u0 m O g z r¢ O O F w W O 2 a oeo a. -1200x- <¢ ?+ U Oaf o¢�w ¢0gwz2�^ w0 m Na OSr UwmK a a ink Q rr 0 m Z� Z r 0¢ w LL w wFOJ OOLLw a 1zo t7LL mQ �9 tt ca7a w mmOra3 a�wz° rpr Jx O �I�I olelCl� W ZLLj V)n gyp@ �a C QOw'mnu�,o ® C 9 ® N LL. Oa_ t u M F X _ 7 tom- � o � f/d O� N C7 Q L Q. a `5 L9 °° Q e L ZLLj V)n gyp@ �a QOw'mnu�,o ® C 9 >�Z,70 a t u M F X D '^K u Z S ++ ilii 0 2, a w C7 L ZLLj V)n QOw'mnu�,o ® C 9 >�Z,70 a t u M F X D '^K u Z S ++ ilii 0 2, a w C7 soozi ver[cwNwi'.�x�a CKE•BEEi19f))>"3 »ev+141L'M'S ISI sElo-zochxl cwt a siBuoissa3oid uSisaQ uosialad — saazog Sinxnj AgiowiJ 41eN eppo13 'uieai7s3i°-q •pnjg ul!a3p 111ION i HE 1— W Cl) C= Lu�io<w zo �+. C3— r tr a Q ry a��aaaaaaaas Soo 000�u4�5 Baa€�a........... sas�aaaaas ssaaasa�aa�� ......................... Q�aaa�aa�aa�aaaa?���Qaaaaa�aaa�a� ddz�r'09 0 1�0F 9 d;99d9mdd9a0saa91r99 I NN1I1 i qq� log � ! S z i �m qq EKE-KE09"I-1ML'M'sIsl sawoH A]nxnZ ALj oLIIIZ ]IJrW c� 9EIRYOL(19s) •b W sisaoissojord r p ►1 o i 3' w r, a g s j I n d CIA B��aa® •pnig ura�p gIaoN .IIz9 ocl �u M �-- C N r a _ C"C.8,019G) n3 —191! 'M S ISI 9110-2 L(195)". --,9d --m-y sieuotssa3ord nSTsa(, uosia;ad satuog Aanxnl Aq;omiZ 3faEn EpIdo13 'uIEaiasjinf) •pnig uEa:)p uIsoN I T U LU S� 4 >�N 5 9 � LU co >�N QIP WL^^E°�°a'1 99KE VPUGIJ• "" FKE-8E I9S1><.a 1W'Ws Is Klo-za. 19s) -9a a SIRUOTSSa30Jd r'I4 z' '� III SII i a� r` •. Usisa(I � ' uos"Jad I C soutog Ajnxn�j ,igaou TI 3[11!N uppol3 'tup;)J}sjln f) PAJU u'10330 ujsON II7g �r I IIS I m-, r'I4 z' '� III SII i a� r` •. I � ' i. I �II I I � �� I I � � I I I � � EKE-SIC090.3 9CIo-m(19s)-9d —1 WL M'S IST —1d n-nvv S[SQOTS j IIIS� s!sa UCK12 CI saurog Ainxnq A(jourrZ 3[itW Epiao13 1utEaljsJln9 •pnjg UE300 TION II9C WR H 45 H a€im Hj�� a GYM °acC BF1 mIM9 H Ig ONE 11MI Ego Mm � <4a O�q ° $ m Up 7 �y 101 41, R.1 ,� m a g Baa F g pig r y oyy mW < REo qyyq4x zpa Momoml moll 0 LU ems L, uj `1' © a �w W OPLL a � d C� - ,i �0o�`5 912MIb �R Y HU ill I in m �S gAl A19. . 19 1 1 0 v �! i 0 t 1 90DE—d'f 99KE 4IAId'�11•-G EKE-1W190nd—IWL'/A'S ISI 9ETO-CKc19s»^4d .ted SRUOISSa Odd US!SOG uosianad samog Ainxn7 dgaotui,y igxeW Ep!.IOjd 'uiEasls3ino •pejg UE330 gljoN i t 7g - pm LU CO) cINIC� in C= LLI ®a pm 4 A p q z � 2 c 11111111111111111111111 1, 1 o O! 3""W � S � �,p.o.«.>gze�•�..erf®���o ®� e w e� ^�_� ____----- O • W ; Y $ '1 ---_-me---__ _ -- --_-__---,.I,_=_ ■ ■!Ir01? as :�^ _____„�,___ m - • I 3At7 .Q -------- " 9 11111111111111111111y.�11 � � � � e� --- � ----w. ���e....5�@p•.o..e��� d'Q'+ btu.. .'-„_wo,_-�_�____ 3=�_� ON annh �h ❑ RO Nie_ I y� Ciry10}�pJ Ww ------------ X, --_____ cfage'••• `�.' f w .v,,. ZU vii w - z f9 m m Ctr .. tr�. d it aya� °� < o? tm 'ra i , ''�G •�: f,JO �a O N �x= mw 8w0> am ti U a ; o '` �:.`..'.• . z O¢w N, Z❑LL�. =z¢ >0 40ou-7((��� wo zIz WW W m W O ¢ O m° Z3 VI°oJ �m f� O I ^ ^ •:.C.�•••'M":.:, ° O¢ ¢ oumij w� -Z New mO uq o°o.z� =p !i I • ' •' LL °ZmWi ❑°z_n ¢QQo � I •.'�.. •. 1�.�; ti. d O K W H W m LLF a410 L* w 3 ° o zmm zow21 a�LL O m1w- o F .0- -ri i o w ¢m �; o❑ x s w a 1w- i ,��' '� I ^M v '•••'�•``., v'. ¢w Oa ur ¢a < !!> wz Z'-°ri Uw ,Uu❑ ¢ h u) u xO W ¢v1 Oi1_¢ m�3 �w z a °” 2=o z-zzo S�WT' oaz °OO z¢ W =¢ z�= O y2a 'U �6F n•.:.: 0 x W Z z iui ¢ w OFA¢ wQ OZF❑ z m 64 wOm �m W UQ u x ¢• ¢w mu Oz�w Q <1b �? `'` �0Q Rw ° am W O j�wi >° UOQO ^-'S-❑, �� • �i �f ? T y¢a hz yx ° y '�'uso oa °d 0¢w Oda 2 . mW❑V ?O F ww w w¢zy wN °'amu¢ xQfm(99 Ix-❑ W z z ❑a W ❑ F> i¢ 1=-1x- 1x -6m5 FNZ - _ - \ m ••'\. �i 1 h ---- - fh N= wZ. q I '' `' .^ .f y...':'r • • S31/tl VIS YOlbYJ-& -SZ9 &21dWhOyp Yl j¢m❑U aam vQ❑ WO ° y QFQ W QU' W W U Z> m a W f Z U - x w a 4 ' I ;3 :'-i'' `�' �•� tl3d 3N7 J1MGd 7:V 3 1 Y17,99'ILOI ALZlrOY.ZQS ,SZT lF`V L1►,0>rLOS f m b yo b w o O N W O m O w z 'U°'JJWz oQ.Qw1- u = w _ H X W W ¢- W Q O ll W E m 7 N ¢ h m Q ¢ z �mJz az = Nw�u ¢mza u1 W �¢ O Si w n aluo m a m W W Z ¢W¢ ❑o as x 3a'o r�°zo > J H b ��x1-° V O N tY LLU¢ mpFO 0 b U1 p❑ w n O w i'n_¢ � O n u z OWZ Q Q W 3 vi0 ZU' Ix -Op m pO��j W a D Fx-Z.Q pj1¢..w m w¢ m ¢ x Q u o> m OZ�E m h C- a z 0 w ❑> O a U > 2 ¢ ¢ m °Hu ¢> W z z¢ y OWJ amo a j0� HZO 01111�- Z cxi O 2 W �¢F m < w m z n ❑a rw pl ?w❑j `p a am N w a�>gw¢ � LI 0 w~ z<w W¢QQ O° w W �?O 4 [r¢ W SQ o�5 O w= w w ¢ 2 i w w -W 1 S > ❑ ❑¢LL 0Z0<Wt/� W O w w° Z CLd UHH¢z OM > mw 2 x m a W¢1- z>Ix-¢mLL hh6 ••''••'•.•.•. EO m I ' w 4l'i b�1�5 I 3 Si h 14 N h I � C❑� � yy 1 b I I = F � �:Ci�E3:;i EiEE;E:' E:E:i:E::ii; EE:EEEEEEEE:i :.:::'iiisiii atf4b Ww ------------ X, --_____ cfage'••• `�.' f w .v,,. ZU vii w - z f9 m m Ctr .. tr�. d it aya� °� < o? tm 'ra i , ''�G •�: f,JO �a O N �x= mw 8w0> am ti U a ; o '` �:.`..'.• . z O¢w N, Z❑LL�. =z¢ >0 40ou-7((��� wo zIz WW W m W O ¢ O m° Z3 VI°oJ �m f� O I ^ ^ •:.C.�•••'M":.:, ° O¢ ¢ oumij w� -Z New mO uq o°o.z� =p !i I • ' •' LL °ZmWi ❑°z_n ¢QQo � I •.'�.. •. 1�.�; ti. d O K W H W m LLF a410 L* w 3 ° o zmm zow21 a�LL O m1w- o F .0- -ri i o w ¢m �; o❑ x s w a 1w- i ,��' '� I ^M v '•••'�•``., v'. ¢w Oa ur ¢a < !!> wz Z'-°ri Uw ,Uu❑ ¢ h u) u xO W ¢v1 Oi1_¢ m�3 �w z a °” 2=o z-zzo S�WT' oaz °OO z¢ W =¢ z�= O y2a 'U �6F n•.:.: 0 x W Z z iui ¢ w OFA¢ wQ OZF❑ z m 64 wOm �m W UQ u x ¢• ¢w mu Oz�w Q <1b �? `'` �0Q Rw ° am W O j�wi >° UOQO ^-'S-❑, �� • �i �f ? T y¢a hz yx ° y '�'uso oa °d 0¢w Oda 2 . mW❑V ?O F ww w w¢zy wN °'amu¢ xQfm(99 Ix-❑ W z z ❑a W ❑ F> i¢ 1=-1x- 1x -6m5 FNZ - _ - \ m ••'\. �i 1 h I 1 1 1 I� �2 "Y' °a ZZ '4 fh N= wZ. q _ Yl j¢m❑U aam vQ❑ WO ° y QFQ W QU' W W U Z> m a W f Z U - x w a 4 x w0¢ux Oa W Ftur°i1aW m z > O Fzmam z�m H LL W Z F Q V o Z z N¢ O m Z w¢¢ m a _xzo� w o O N W O m O w z 'U°'JJWz oQ.Qw1- u = w _ H X W W ¢- W Q O ll W E m 7 N ¢ h m Q ¢ z �mJz az = Nw�u ¢mza u1 W �¢ O Si w n aluo m a m W W Z ¢W¢ ❑o as x 3a'o r�°zo > J H b ��x1-° V O N tY LLU¢ mpFO 0 b U1 p❑ w n O w i'n_¢ � O n u z OWZ Q Q W 3 vi0 ZU' Ix -Op m pO��j W a D Fx-Z.Q pj1¢..w m w¢ m ¢ x Q u o> m OZ�E m h C- a z 0 w ❑> O a U > 2 ¢ ¢ m °Hu ¢> W z z¢ y OWJ amo a j0� HZO 01111�- Z cxi O 2 W �¢F m < w m z n ❑a rw pl ?w❑j `p a am N w a�>gw¢ � LI 0 w~ z<w W¢QQ O° w W �?O 4 [r¢ W SQ o�5 O w= w w ¢ 2 i w w -W 1 S > ❑ ❑¢LL 0Z0<Wt/� W O w w° Z CLd UHH¢z OM > mw 2 x m a W¢1- z>Ix-¢mLL I 1 1 1 I� �2 "Y' Ljr fh N= w LL— , y N i 3Nl7 70N[APOO SNOO 7Y1SYC NI .699*9 3.LS,6LroN 1� '9wl b jg° xw❑ Qa ro 1- W W > ❑ � > ¢ W Olx--H mllu¢jm Zz LL 2U Ing`1x-°Uv'o.'?: n ¢ ❑ z� Ea cvUa' Q��awror�j a OIW o JU�w;'z w a - ZEE JQ 1a/1Q� W¢rOm N ❑ ❑77 w O z Q MIT -m <M<� 6z0¢pmw x > < O -w Ja¢ui1QQ-$Y ooamrOBZ3W �z¢OUY1O z0w�Y ¢❑wUo -< e< WW �xjrizw oo< zgx¢ 5z¢G H Q W� u Z❑ r a � W¢❑> J Z 2 Z 3 x ❑F ¢ �� U1wF-F Q1-Qti j Z O Q w O Z Q W O m Z -0-0. .oma¢ Ow< Im x a O a p O w c=7 F w w¢¢ 3 ¢Npam ❑¢ Oa Z°p a4Uz' w¢� wY ' W¢ O 0¢ox-w�¢LL O rww¢ z a�m°oa7wa 0 1Woz �t w T ?� coCO Wo A I 6P Q og - ®L 0 U z W OoQLL = a ZM1 w COMMISSIONERS JOAN K. ORTHWEIN, Mayor THOMAS M. STANLEY, Vice Mayor MURIEL J. ANDERSON W. GARRETT DERING ROBERT W. GANGER May 12, 2013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA 3211 North Ocean Boulevard, LLC Attn: Mark T. Pulte, Member 3211 N. Ocean Blvd. Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 Dear Mr. Pulte: Telephone (561) 276-5116 Fax (561) 737-0188 Town Manager WILLIAM H. THRASHER Town Clerk RITA L. TAYLOR This is to confirm that at the Public Hearings held by the Town Commission on April 12, 2013 and May 10, 2013, your application for a Demolition Permit to remove existing structures, a Land Clearing Permit to prepare for some new landscape materials and adjust the grade to accommodate new structures & improvements, a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to install entry gate and piers along with additional landscaping in the corridor, a Variance to permit a terra cotta slate style roof to be installed on the proposed Georgian style dwelling and a.Leval 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit the construction of a 10,410 square foot partial 2 -story, single family, Georgian style h-ome with a 4 car garage and swimming pool was considered. The application was approved conditioned upon the following: 1) The electric service lines shall be buried; 2) Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping; 3) Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached; 4) All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view; S) The landscape plan will protect existing Australian pine trees and provide a 13' clear zone where possible allowing for the planting by the Town of additional Australian pine tree(s); 6) Change the proposed terra cotta roof to that allowed by the Town Code, your second choice, a dark grey slate like tile. 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 33483 Mark T. Pulte 3211 N. Ocean Blvd. Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 page 2 This approval shall expire Application, including the been applied for. Very truly yours, 4 7� Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk CC: Benjamin Schreier Affiniti Architects on May 10, 2014 if a Building Permit aforementioned improvements, has not INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK Rita L. Taylor TO: Mayor & Commissioners DATE: May 3, 2013 RE: North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Dist. Set -Back At the last Commission Meeting, action was deferred with regard to the installation of gates and piers within the N. Ocean Blvd. Overlay District at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd. The Town has always permitted walls, gates and fences to be constructed in the Overlay District. As the result of a question that was asked at the last meeting with regard to the setback for the gates being 78' from the centerline of AlA, a review of the Code was conducted. Section 66-431 addresses the 78' but ends with "unless specified otherwise in the Code". In Chapter 66, Article VI. District Regulations, the regulations for each district are listed. Please note that in Sec. 66-191, Single Family Residential it directs you to Chapter 70 for ALL regulations which includes setbacks. In Chapter 70, Section 70-187 9. Front Yards it states that compliance with the North Ocean Blvd. Overlay District is required. In Sec. 66-322 it lists the things in North Ocean Overlay that need to have a permit. One of those is gates, and also columns, fences, walls etc. Section 66-141(2)f. covers projects requiring a Level 2 review specifically names "new entrance gates" within the 50' Overlay Dist. All of this considered, the proposed location of the gates and piers conforms to the Code. Also, I believe gates & piers would be included where fences and walls are addressed in Sec. 70-74(b)(4)"No setback requir- ed provided wall or fence is located on the property & at least 5' from edge of the pavement. V7.A. t. A. Date/Time 05-06-2013 05:02:16 p.m. Local ID 1 561-737-0188 t ransmission Report Transmit Header Text Local Name 1 town of gulf stream This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size: 8.5 "x11 " PO*Wr Fax Note 7671 °°b a't. ro _ �. ttto �Mt tY coIFUI isu rmn4 a r� � 176-fi/ INTEROFFICE ME TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK Rita L_ Taylor TO: Mayor & Commissioners DATE: May 3, 2013 RE: North Ocean Blvd, Overlay Dist. Set -Back At the last Commission Meeting, action was deferred with regard to the installation of gates and piers within the N. Ocean Blvd. Overlay District at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd. The Town has always permitted walls, gates and fences to be constructed in the Overlay District. As the result of a question that was asked at the last meeting with regard to the setback for the gates being 78' from the centerline of AlA, a review of tbte Code was conducted. Section 66-431 addresses the 78' but ends with "unless specified otherwise in the Code". In Chapter 66, Article VI. District Re lations, the regulations for each district are Listed. P ease note tat in Sec. 66-191,'Siinn la Family Residential it directs you to Chapter 70 for ALL regulations whicTi - inc'—Tulles setbacks. In Chapter 70, Section 70-187 9. Front Yards it states that compliance with the North Ocean Blvd, Overlay Dietr�ctIs required. In Sec. 66-322 it lists the things in North Ocean Overlay that need to have a permit. One of those is gates, and also columns, fences, walls etc, Section 66-141(2)f. covers projects requiring a Level 2 review specifically names "new entrance gates" within the 50' Overlay Dist. All of this considered, the proposed location of the gates and piers conforms to the Code. Also, I believe gates & piers would be included where fences and walls are addressed in Sec. 70-74(b)(4)"No setback requir- ed provided wall or fence is located on the property & at least 5' from edge of the pavement. Total Pages Scanned : 1 Total Pages Confirmed : 1 No. I Job I Remote Station Start Time I Duration Pages Line Mode I Job Type Results 001 1328 115617507872 05:01:23 p.m. 05-06-2013 100:00:20 1/1 11 JEC IHS ICP26400 Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct Date/Tlme 05-06-2013 05:00:00 P.M. Local ID 1 561-737-0188 ransmission Report Transmit Header Text Local Name 1 This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size : 8.5"x11" INTER -OFFICE ME town of gulf stream Poet-fN' Fak More _ 7671 yam,► r'f�{Arl le_ cif gee PhOie R p,p,eY Z7 `—b'f Fu X Fex Y TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK Rita L. Taylor T0: Mayor & Commissioners DATE: May 3, 2013 RE: North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Dist. Set -Back At the Last Commission Meeting, action was deferred with regard to the installation of gates and piers within the N. Ocean Blvd. Overlay District at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd. The Town has always permitted walls, gates and fences to be constructed in the Overlay District. As the result of a question that was asked at the last meeting with regard to the setback for the gates being 78' from the centerline of AlA, a review of the Code was conducted. Section 66-431 addresses the 78' but ends with "unless specified otherwise in the Code". In Chapter 66, Article VI. District Regulations the regulations for each district are listed. Please note t at in ec. 66-191, Simon lee Family Residential it directs you to Chapter 70 for ALL regulations 2j% 11 ncT c luUees setbacks. In Chapter 70, Section 70-187 9. Front Yards it states that compliance with the North Ocean Blvd. Overlay District is required. In Sec. 66-322 it lists the things in North Ocean Overlay that need to have a permit. One of those is gates, and also columns, fences, walls etc. Section 66-141(2)f. covers projects requiring a Level 2 review specifically names "new entrance gates" within the 50' Overlay Dist. All of this considered, the proposed location of the gates and piers conforms to the Code. Also, I believe gates & piers would be included where fences and walls are addressed in Sec. 70-74(b)(4)"No setback requir- ed provided wall or fence is located on the property & at least 5' from edge of the pavement. Total Pages Scanned : 1 Total Pages Confirmed : 1 No. Job I Remote Station Start Time Duration Pages Line Mode I Job Type Results 001 1326 15612725571 04:58:52 p.m. 05-06-2013 00:00:37 1/1 11 JEC IHS ICP14400 Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct Transmission Report Date/Time 03-23-2013 12:17:57 p.m. Transmit Header Text Local ID 1 561-737-0188 Local Name 1 town of gulf stream Total Scanned : 4 This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size: 8.5"x14" P-0-tr N.Note 7671 tare ra � (evfT�L o> CHAIRMAN: Scott Morgan _..._____— VICE CSlAIRM4N: Amanda Jones BOARD MEMBER: Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy ALTERNATE MEMBER: George Delafieled, Jr. REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD By THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANKING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, MARCH 28, 3013 AT 8, 30 A.Y., IN THE T(AWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FL)RIDA. AGtNDA. I. Call to Order, II. Roll Call. III. Minutes Of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 2-28-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements, A. Heating Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a'March 2.8, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. h. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A..M. c. May 23, 2013 8 8:30 A M. d. June 27, 2013 @ 9:30 A.M. e. July 25, 207.3 @ 8:30 A.M. f. August 2013 -No .*tearing VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval. 1. An application submitted by Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects, as Agent for 3211 N. Ocean Boulevard, Li,C, Mark T. Pulte Member, the owners of property located at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as the North 4.5 ft of lot 3 s the S 108 ft. of lot 4 Gulf Stream Ocean Tracts in Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DESDLM'ION PERMIT to remove existing structures. b. LAND CLEARING PRW¢T to prepare for some new landscape materials and adjust the grade to accommodate the new structures and improvements. c. NORTB OCEAN HODLEYAD OVRLXY P to install entry gate and piers and supplement existing landscaping within the corridor, d. VARIANCE to permit a terra Cotta slate style roaf to be Installed on the proposed Georgian style home. e. LEVEL 3 MC L/B2TE PLAN RRVIM to permit the construction of a 10,408 aquare foot partial 2 -story, single family. Georgian style dwelling with a 4 car garage Lind swimming pool. 2. An application submitted by William wietsma as agent for Ralph MacDonald, owner of the property located at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds as Lots 1, 1-A and 2, McLouth Subdivision, Ga1E Stream, Florida. a. FURDIVISiOR to divide one, 4,733 acre, parcel of land into 3 Tote. h. IMMLITIOB PERMIT to remove and- existing driveway, a garage and shed. Total Pages Confirmed Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system H R: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct i ransmission Report Date/Time 03-23-2013 12:22:39 p.m. Transmit Header Text Local ID 1 561-737-0188 Local Name 1 town of gulf stream This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size : 8.5"x14" Paw4.r Fez Nnaw _7871 . . a4nNic�Tt1v 4.�' f f—'jr� ' MMa1 Roney j+ CfiAIRK7W: Scott Morgan ----_.--- VICE CHAIRMAN; Amanda Jones BOARD MEMBER: Paul A. Lyons, Jr'. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy ALTERNATE MEMBER: George Dela£ieled, Jr. REGULAR VFETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OP GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, KARCE 20, 2013 AT 900 A.K., IN THE TCW HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. 11. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing 2-28-3.3. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda iters. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting 4 Public Hearing a. March 28, 2013 8 8:30 A.M. b. April 25, 2013 0 8:30 A.M. C. May 23, 2D13 g 8:30 A.M, d. June 27, 2013 0 8:30 A.M. e. July 25, 2013 P 8:30 A.M. f. August 2013 -No Meeting VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Developtnen.t Approval 1. An application submitted by Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects, as Agent for 3211 N. Ocean Boulevard, LLC, Mark T. Pulte Member, the owners of property located at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as the North 4.5 Et of lot 3 L the S 108 ft. Of lot 4 Gulf Stream Ocean Tracts in Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DRNOLITION PRRKIT to remove exiscinq structures. b. LAND CLEARING PBRKiT to prepare for some new landscape materials and adjust the grade to accommodate the new structures and improvements. C. NORTE OCEAN EOIIILVAD OVVI" PRRKIT to install entry gate and piers and supplement existing landscaping within the corridor. d. VARIANCL to permit a terra cotta Elate style roof to be installed on the proposed Georgian style home. e. LLVLL 3 ARCEITBCTURAL/SITE PLAN RLVIEK to permit the construction of a 10,408 square foot partial 2-stury, single falnily, Georgian style dwelling with a 4 car garage and swimming pool. 2. An application submitted by William Wietsmw as agent for Ralph MacDonald, owner of the property located at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream. Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds as Lots 1, 1-A and 2, McLout_b Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. BVRDIVIRIOE to divide one, 4,733 acre, parcel of land into 3 lots. b. r=QLITIONp"NIT to remove and- existing driveway, a garage and bed. Total Pages Scanned : 4 Total Pages Confirmed : 4 No. Job Remote Station Start Time I Duration Pages Line Mode I Job Type Results 001 1974 15612725571 12:20:00 p.m. 03-23-2013 00:01:47 4/4 11 JEC IHS ICP14400 Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA; Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct ransmission Report Date/Time 04-06-2013 01:00:27 p.m. Transmit Header Text Local ID 1 561-737-0188 Local Name 1 town of gulf stream This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size: 8.5"x14" Pact -W fay No% 7471 cnean. o MAYOR: Joan R. Orthwein VICE MAYOR: Thomas M. Stanley COMMISSIONER: Muriel J. Anderson — W. Garrett Dering Robert W. Ganger. REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE '1gWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GUIX STREAM ON FAZMAY, APRIL 12, 2013 AT 900 A.N. IN THE C014MISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA Call to Order. II. Pledge of Allegiance. III. Roll Call. IV. Minutes. A. Regular Meeting, Town Commission s Bd. of Adjustment, 3-15-13 B. Certification of Election Retures, 3-15-13 V. .Additions, withdrawals, defarrals, arrangemant of agenda items, Vl. Announcaments. A. Regular Meetings and Public Hearings 1. May 10, 2013 @ 9:00 A.M. 2. June 14, 2013 B 9:00 A.M. 3. July 12, 2013 0 9:00 A.M. 4.August 9, 2013 B 9:00 A.M. 5. September 13, 2013 8 9:00 A.M. 5. October 11, 2013 R 9:00 A.M. B. Mayor's Proclamations 1. Water Reuse Week -May 19 thru May 25, 2013 2_ National Missing Children's Day -May 25, 2013 VII. PUBLIC HEARING, A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application suhuutted by Benjamin Schreier, Affiniti Architects, as Agent for 3211 N. Ocean Boulevard, LLC, Mark T. Pulte -Member, the owners of property located at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd., Galf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as the North 4.5 ft of lot 3 6 the S 108 ft:. of lot 4 Guli Stream Ocean Tracts in Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DTMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. h. LARD CLYARIHD PERMIT to prepare for some new landscape materials and adjust the grade to accommodate the new structures and improvements. c. NOX= OCEAM DODLEVAn MRLAY PERMIT to install entry gate and piers and supplement existing landscaping within the corridor. d. PARIANCL to permit a terra cut" slate style roof to be installed on the proposed Georgian style home. e. LEM 3 ARCBITK'rURAL/RITE PLAM REVIL'W to permit the construction of a 10,408 square foot partial 2 -story, single family, Georgian style dwelling with a 4 car garage and swimming pool. 2. An application submitted by William Wietsma as agent for Ralph MacDonald, cromer of the propsxty located at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds as Lots I, 1-A and 2, McLeuth Subdivision, Gulf Stream, Florida. a. BOBDIVIBION to divide one, 4.733 acre, parcel of land into 3 lots. Total Pages Scanned : 4 Total Pages Confirmed : 4 No. Job I Remote Station Start Time Duration Pages Line Mode I Job Type Results 001 1093 115617507872 12:58:11 p.m. 04-06-2013 00:01:35 4/4 11 JEC IHS ICP24000 Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR; Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK Rita L. Taylor TO: Mayor & Commissioners DATE: May 3, 2013 RE: North Ocean Blvd. Overlay Dist. Set -Back At the last Commission Meeting, action was deferred with regard to the installation of gates and piers within the N. Ocean Blvd. Overlay District at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd. The Town has always permitted walls, gates and fences to be constructed in the Overlay District. As the result of a question that was asked at the last meeting with regard to the setback for the gates being 78' from the centerline of AlA, a review of the Code was conducted. Section 66-431 addresses the 78' but ends with "unless specified otherwise in the Code". In Chapter 66, Article VI. District Regulations, the regulations for each district are listed. Please note that in Sec. 66-191, Single Family Residential it directs you to Chapter 70 for ALL regulations which includes setbacks. In Chapter 70, Section 70-187 9. Front Yards it states that compliance with the North Ocean Blvd. Overlay District is required. In Sec. 66-322 it lists the things in North Ocean Overlay that need to have a permit. One of those is gates, and also columns, fences, walls etc. Section 66-141(2)f. covers projects requiring a Level 2 review specifically names "new entrance gates" within the 50' Overlay Dist. All of this considered, the proposed location of the gates and piers conforms to the Code. Also, I believe gates & piers would be included where fences and walls are addressed in Sec. 70-74(b)(4)"No setback requir- ed provided wall or fence is located on the property & at least 5' from edge of the pavement. Bill Thrasher From: Marty Minor <MMinor@udkstudios.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2013 3:29 PM To: Bill Thrasher Subject: RE: Yes, I will be there. With regards to the terra cotta roof color for 3211 N. Ocean, as we discussed, the color is not consistent with code and that's why there if an application for a variance. As Benjamin Schierer has shown, there is some architectural precedent of Georgian homes with a terra cotta slate -type roof. However, I am not aware of terra cotta slate -like on a Georgian home in the Town. The ARPB should consider whether the roof meets this criteria: 1. Consistency of neighborhood character. 2. Consistency of architectural style. 3. Consistency of building form and mass. 4. Consistency of materials and colors. 5. Consistency of location of elements. I don't have a strong opinion on the appropriateness of the color. The roof color has been used on other Georgian homes, just not here. The ARPB will need to determine whether the color is appropriate for the district and the community for this one house. Being in the Beachfront District, there is a wider variety of architectural styles than in other districts, which is also another factor to be considered by the ARPB. See you in the morning. ma rty Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Urban Design Kilday Studios The Offices at City Place North 477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758 561-366-1100 urban The Offices at CityPlace North ph. (5 61) 366.1100 477 S. Rosemary Avenue. Suite 225 f. (5611 366.1 1 1 1 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 www.udkstudios.com kid S T U D I O S Urban Planning and Design J landscape Architecture J Communication Graphics From: Bill Thrasher[ma iIto: bthrasherCabqulf-stream.orq] Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2013 3:08 PM To: Marty Minor Subject: Marty, confirming you will be here tomorrow at the ARPB for the subdivision update? BT William H. Thrasher, ICMA-CM, CGFO, CGFM Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Office 561.276.5116 1 Fax 561.737.0188 Direct e-mail: bthrasher@qulf-stream.org Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manualfor Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File #. To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.I . Project/Owner Name: UL4�A I.A.2. Project Address: 14.%0 J,1CQ_JJA bC&0j_) I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: _ hma-5 i, '6DJWbS. _ ,Z — I-A-4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.)\�� p I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: N 1A Architectural Style: ti'l A I 1.A.6. Check all that apply: VArchitectur I/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing tY North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) O Special Exception (complete section.E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: Type of Foundation: B. Owner Information 1.B.1. Owner Address: X4-10 jam'N —) I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information &l ' Ma I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: V.11La..t pM 1�� I.C.2. Agent Address: 010 -Slt,� �� I ICIA .� I.C.3. Agent Phone Num 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: -.!k1-)3 A3121�- Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 •$2:76 Fax L'I Z -66•S IS Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III -A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? IRS- O Ch�a, ,� W�zST �IS1hclr) 111./A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? 9yes ❑ No Explain. SU501U1C>)1j& ni`e W11_L p, Lt-QI.•� �tZ (-3) III.A.3. Is the project consistent }'pith the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? C�1 Yes ❑ No Explain. F;yT[yt2.& U'A LPA&Afl III.A.4. Flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? F.ZC1S1 W(- 2J)D-p TO -1' o- P00 -1.4-A III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage (!PO- S iTV b. Sanitary Sewer C)0_,5 ITV_ c✓��1 c. Potable Water TQ OV- 6t)LP 1 I C d. Irrigation Water e. Electricity f. Telephone TT g. Gas . Pi les 0Ll1 41 h. Cable TelevisionLa� III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) hl L_ 'D& L Qltd I TH Nv. ) OF &0L.9 s ti c oM PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? Wr Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? 2 Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existin vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes ONo (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does theeNo(If ect require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the prof t at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe . N 0 IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? YesNo Explain: �.9fl �`a1�z f!�QDlT1Y�. f�V'6t}t�-ice T30t1.3'>I&>G OP- #-V-w WT'5 %i ALL, i4oWL% OvRiA9d.— uh. • Sc.A ZmT-02S a wc> i IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? AgS IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:. V314 C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? 1`�-C17.9Co 71iilQ 1 l S'CORSQ b IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? VCPi , D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 t` vucd111 E• Projects Requiring a Special Exception. 14 a IV.E.1, Is thero P posed use a permitted special exception use? IV.E.2. How is the use designed, located and ❑Yes ❑ No Code Section: proposed to be operated so that the Public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? IV. E.3. Will the use cause substantial in'u be located? ❑ Yes ❑ No 1 ry to the value of other Property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. IV,E.4, How will the use be compatible with adjoining develo is to be located? pment and the character of the District where it IV.E,S. What landscaping p g and screening are provided? W.E.B. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing located? 13 Yes ❑ No g the District wherein it is to be Explain. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units ``' IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and h`'`l a ow they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their Potential Properties. enal impacts or, IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 Tbwn°of Gulf Stream G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV.G.3. What is proposed? IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the Ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No Explain: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 4w211 or Vulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning H 1� IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, Zoning any combination tcthereof, Future Land Use Ma justification for the request.please describe the P need an Comprehensive Plan text change, ord PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Pari is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this the other materials submitted with the application. , to provide any form or on any of Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/0/00 Page 7 Robert W. Ganger 1443 North Ocean Blvd Gulf Stream, FL 33483 To the Architectural Review and Planning Board Re: Application for Development Approval MacDonald Property Sub Division This application is scheduled for your review on March 28. As neighbors across the street from the project, my wife and I have no reason to oppose sub -division into three lots, nor any other specific permits or plans you will be reviewing. However, while the landscaping plan is very preliminary, we would hope that Mr. MacDonald's lush tree and privacy hedge border on A1A and along the private road at the northern end of the property, be retained as a condition of approval. Ideally, there will be an opportunity for select planting of Australian Pines along the state road, consistent with the former Spence property to the south. Sincerely, Robert Ganger Anneli Ganger Page 1 of 1 Rita Taylor From: rwganger [rwganger@bellsouth.net] Sent: Monday, March 25, 2013 2:17 PM To: Rita Taylor Attachments: ARPB-McDonald..doc Rita, Attached is a letter regarding the upcoming ARPB review on the MacDonald property development application. I ask that it be entered into the record as an affected neighbor. I will drop off a signed hard copy as soon as possible. Bob Ganger 3/26/2013 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 Parcel ID: 20-43-46-09-03-000-0010 Property Address: 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Project: Proposed Subdivision of MacDonald Property Architect: William Wietsma Architect, PA Date:02/12/2013 Below are the responses (in blue italics) to the review comments: Reviewer: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Subdivision Re -Plat Process 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. Ok. ► RECEIVED A FEB 14 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested subdivision and designation of agent. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 3. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the property. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 4. Aerial Location Map with the appropriate zoning and future land use information for the site and surrounding properties. See Aerial/Zoning Map on sheet A-01 5. A certified boundary survey by a surveyor registered in the state of Florida at a scale of not less than one inch equals 200 feet containing the following information: a. An accurate legal description of the property; b. A computation off the total acreage of the parcel to the nearest tenth of an acre; c. Topographical data; d. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within 100 feet of the outside boundaries of the site; e. Location and width of all existing driveways, streets (named), intersections, easements and utility locations (underground and overhead) adjacent to and across the subject site. Refer to Boundary Survey for items a - e. 6. Plat Plan, compliant with Section 177 of Florida State Statutes, indicating the proposed subdivision. The plat plan should indicate all existing and future easements, restrictions and common -owned property, if any. Refer to submitted Plat Plan. 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 7. A written narrative describing the request and indicate how the following services will be provided to the site: a. Potable water; b. Sanitary sewer; c. Drainage; d. Access/Traffic Circulation; e. Solid Waste disposal. See attached response to comments from civil engineer. Concurrency Certification 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. Ok. 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested subdivision and designation of agent. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 3. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the property. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 4. A certified boundary survey by a surveyor registered in the state of Florida. Boundary survey has been submitted for review under this submittal. A traffic impact statement, prepare by a traffic engineer, indicating how the proposed increase in the number of dwelling units on the site will comply the Town's Level of Service standard as described within the Town's Comprehensive Plan and the applicable traffic circulation standards in Chapter 44 of the Code of Ordinances. The applicant will also provide to the Town a copy of Concurrency Certification from Palm Beach County Department of Engineering. See attached traffic statement. Provide a statement from a qualified professional regarding the provision of sanitary sewer service for the proposed subdivision. The plan for sanitary sewer service shall comply with the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Section 44-102 of the Code of Ordinances. See attached response to comments from civil engineer. Provide a statement from the City of Delray Beach that potable water service can be provided for the additional dwelling units proposed. Also, the applicant should provide a statement on how the proposed subdivision would comply with the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Section 44-59 of the Code of Ordinances. See attached response to comments from civil engineer and letters from City of Delray Beach water/sewer network manager. 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 8. Provide a statement from a registered civil engineer addressing how storm water drainage will be addressed on site. The statement should include how the subdivision's storm water drainage plan will comply with the Level of Service standard as described in the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Code of Ordinances. See attached response to comments from civil engineer. 9. Provide a statement on how solid waste will be collected and disposed for the subdivision's homes. Provide a copy of the annual capacity letter from the Solid Waste Authority of Palm Beach County. Solid Waste shall be collected by the Waste Management of Palm Beach County. Attached is the requested copy of the annual capacity letter from the Solid Waste Authority of Palm Beach County. 10. Provide a statement addressing how the additional dwelling units within the proposed subdivision addresses the Recreation and Open Space Level of Service found in the Town's Comprehensive Plan. Level 3 Site Plan Review 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. Ok. 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested subdivision and designation of agent. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 3. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the property. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 4. A certified boundary survey by a surveyor registered in the state of Florida at a scale of not less than one inch equals 200 feet containing the following information: a. An accurate legal description of the property; b. A computation off the total acreage of the parcel to the nearest tenth of an acre; c. Topographical data; d. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within 100 feet of the outside boundaries of the site; e. Location and width of all existing driveways, streets (named), intersections, easements and utility locations (underground and overhead) adjacent to and across the subject site. Refer to Boundary Survey for items a - e. 5. Aerial Location Map with the appropriate zoning and future land use information for the site and surrounding properties. See Aerial/Zoning Map on sheet A-01 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 6. Site Plan depicting the entire site. The Site Plan shall include the following information: L Location of wooded areas existing or proposed water bodies, and other environmentally -sensitive lands. ii. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within one hundred (100) feet of the outside boundaries of the site. iii. The use and approximate dimensions and location of all proposed buildings and other structures. iv. The number of dwelling units by type and gross floor area of nonresidential structures proposed, if any. v. All existing and proposed means of vehicular access to and from the site, and the location and width of proposed streets, walkways, and off-street parking facilities for the various buildings and uses vi. Centerline and ultimate rights-of-way dimensions for roads and canals (note if existing, proposed, dedicated, reserved, etc.) vii. The location and width of proposed and existing driveways, streets (named), intersections, easements and utility locations to and across the subject site. viii. Evidence of compliance with all applicable environmental ordinances. ix. The location and size of open space and recreation areas, including docks and common structures, and the form of organization proposed to own land and maintain said areas. x. Proposed location, size and type of permanent outdoor signs, if a ny. xi. Indication of all exterior lighting, location, height, type, foot candles, including cut sheets. xii. Zoning category of the site and all parcels within 150'. xiii. Land use of the site and all parcels within 150'. xiv. Site Data information providing the following: 1. North arrow (north up when possible) 2. Scale (graphic and written) 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 3. Name of development and project name 4. Range/Township/Section 5. Date Plans prepared and subsequent revisions 6. Total acreage of site 7. Boundary dimensions 8. Lot coverage 9. Open space calculations 10. Parking Spaces (required/proposed/dimensions/Handicap/loading (as applicable) 11. Building setback and/or separations 12. Building height. See site plan, sheet A-01, for all relevant information. 7. Landscape Plan indicating compliance with Sections 66-396 through 66-402, 70- 146 and Section 66-144(b) of the Code of Ordinances. The Landscape Plan shall indicate all existing and proposed landscaping including the location of landscape buffers or screening walls along roadways, with landscape plans for entrance features, subdivision streets, buffers and common areas. Landscape Plans shall include safe sight triangles. Landscape drawings have been submitted for review under this submittal. 8. Preliminary Drainage and Utilities Plans indicating proposed easements, structures, retention areas, etc. Civil drawings has been submitted for review under this submittal. 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 January 7, 2013 Mark Hammond Executive Director Solid Waste Authority 7501 N. Jog Road West Palm Beach, FL 33412 YOUR PARTNER FOR SOLID WASTE SOLUTIONS Subject: Availability of Solid Waste Disposal Capacity Dear Mr. Hammond: The Solid Waste Authority of Palm. Beach County hereby provides certification that the Authority has disposal capacity available to accommodate the solid waste generation for the municipalities and unincorporated county for the coming year of 2013. This letter also constitutes notification of sufficient capacity for concurrency management and comprehensive planning purposes. Capacity is available for both the coming year, and the five and ten year planning periods specified in 9J-5.005(4). As of September 30, 2012, the Authority's North County Landfills had an estimated 30,355,863 cubic yards of landfill capacity remaining. In addition, the Authority has contracted for the construction of a second Waste -to -Energy facility, projected to begin operations in 2015. This will significantly extend the useful life of the landfill. Based upon the existing Palm Beach County population, the most recently available population growth rates published by the University of Florida Bureau of Economic and Business and Research (BEBR), medium projection, and projected rates of solid waste generation, waste reduction and recycling, the Solid Waste Authority forecasts that capacity will be available at the existing landfill through approximately the year 2046. The Authority continues to pursue options to increase the life of its existing facilities and to provide for all of the County's current and future disposal and recycling needs. As part of its responsibility, the Authority will provide an annual statement of disposal capacity, using the most current BEBR projections available. Please provide copies of this letter to your plan review and concurrency management staff. If you have any questions or I can be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me. Very truly yours, Marc C. Bruner, Ph.D. Chief Administrative Officer 7501 North Jog Road, West Palm Beach, Florida 33412 (561) 640-4000 FAX (561) 640-3400 1 q 8. DELRAY BEACH All-America City January 14, 2013 Mr. Joseph Pike, P.E. President, Engineer 298 Pineapple Grove Delray Beach, FL 33444 RE: Proposed Development MacDonald Three -Lot Subdivision Water Availability Town of Gulf Stream, Florida Dear Joe: Potable water is provided to the Town of Gulf Stream by the City of Delray Beach, thru 2 metered locations. Adequate treatment capacity for water is available to serve the subject project without any plant or piping upgrades. Per the agreement with the City of Delray Beach and the Town of Gulf Stream the City is to provide the Town with up to 800,000 gallons of water per day. A twelve (12) month average was calculated and present usage is approximately 535,500 gallons per day. Exact connections and other improvement requirements will be identified once a preliminary plan is submitted for review. If you have any questions or require any additional information please do not hesitate to contact me at (561) 243-7309. Sincerely, J 12 Scott W. Solomon Water/Sewer Network Manager City of Delray Beach UAFORMSIWaterAvail MacDonald Propoerty.doc wtjuv;iiv �r �M4l�Ot i EnviroDesig Associates gin.. 298 Pineapple Grove Way - Delray Beach, FL 33444 Florida Certificate of Authorization #6506 TRAFFIC STATEMENT FOR 1410 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM, FL FEBRUARY 8, 2013 Tables 4, 5 and 6 show the daily, A.M. peak hour, and P.M. peak hour traffic generation for the proposed development, respectively. The proposed redevelopment entails the subdivision of a large single-family home site into three single-family home sites. This will result in a net increase of two single-family dwelling units, for a total of three single-family homes. The associated traffic generation may be summarized as follows: Daily Traffic Generation = 30 tpd A.M. Peak Hour Traffic Generation = 2 pht P.M. Peak Hour Traffic Generation = 3 pht The net difference in traffic generation as a result of the proposed redevelopment may be summarized as follows: DAILY A.M. PEAK HOUR P.M. PEAK HOUR 20 daily trip increase = 1 peak hour trip increase 2 peak hour trip increase CONCLUSION An analysis of the traffic impacts associated with the proposed development was performed in accordance with Palm Beach County's Article, Traffic Performance Standards. The proposed redevelopment has been estimated to generate the following, an increase of 20 daily trips, an increase of AM peak hour trips and an increase of 2 PM peak hour trips at a build -out in 2016. The results of this analysis indicates, that the proposed redevelopment will have an insignificant impact on the surrounding roadway network, meeting the requirement of Palm Beach County's Traffic Performance Standards Certified By: EnviroDesign Associates, Inc. Certificate of Authorization_ 0„6506 x Jo,�egl!i A. Pike, P.E., President Ft` egistration No. 42696 1 11",& 1 iL4,1L*Y i �� Associates, Inc. 1410 North Ocean Blvd. Town of Gulf Stream, FL February 8, 2013 Page 2 of 6 O I O ,go I-.' o O CF' O q a V) r O U Q mCDO U) L a t L u � w o � m t Q O L a CD LU J m Q MEMORANDUM TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP DATE: December 18, 2012 RE: PROPOSED SUBDIVISION OF MACDONALD PROPERTY Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics The proposed subdivision and re -plat of the MacDonald Property at 1410 North Ocean Boulevard (Property Control Number #20-43-46-09-03-000-0010), as outlined in the November 10, 2012 plan prepared by EnviroDesign Associates, Inc., for a total of three lots will require three concurrent review processes. Those processes are: Subdivision Re -Plat Process, consistent with Chapter 62, Subdivision, of the Town's Code of Ordinances. Concurrency Certification, consistent with the rules and standards of Chapter 44, Concurrency Management System, of the Town's Code of Ordinances. This process will confirm that there are sufficient municipal services for the two additional lots/houses proposed. • Level 3 Site Plan Review, consistent with Section 66-140, Architectural/Site Plan Review — Levels 1, 2 and 3, of the Town's Code of Ordinances. All three processes will require review by Town Staff, the Architectural Review and Planning Board and the Town Commission. Along with the standard application requirements required by the Town, the applicant will need to address each of the subdivision criteria outlined in Section 62-10. The three identified development review processes above require the submittal of plans and documents to the Town to demonstrate compliance with the Town's Comprehensive Plan, Code of Ordinances, state regulations and all applicable rules and standards. Below is a listing of such plans and documents: Subdivision Re -Plat Process 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested subdivision and designation of agent. 3. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the 477 S. Rosemary Avenue property. Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDKstudios.com LCC35 H:\JOBS\Gulf Stream_94-012\MacDonald Subdivision\Subdivision Process Memorandum 121812.doc Mr. William Thrasher December 18, 2012 Proposed MacDonald Subdivision Page 3 7. Provide a statement from the City of Delray Beach that potable water service can be provided for the additional dwelling units proposed. Also, the applicant should provide a statement on how the proposed subdivision would comply with the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Section 44-59 of the Code of Ordinances. 8. Provide a statement from a registered civil engineer addressing how stormwater drainage will be addressed on site. The statement should include how the subdivision's stormwater drainage plan will comply with the Level of Service standard as described in the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Code of Ordinances. 9. Provide a statement on how solid waste will be collected and disposed for the subdivision's homes. Provide a copy of the annual capacity letter from the Solid Waste Authority of Palm Beach County. 10. Provide a statement addressing how the additional dwelling units within the proposed subdivision addresses the Recreation and Open Space Level of Service found in the Town's Comprehensive Plan. Level 3 Site Plan Review 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested Level 3 Site Plan Review and designation of agent. 3. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the property. 4. A certified boundary survey by a surveyor registered in the state of Florida at a scale of not less than one inch equals 200 feet containing the following information: a. An accurate legal description of the property; b. A computation off the total acreage of the parcel to the nearest tenth of an acre; c. Topographical data; d. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within 100 feet of the outside boundaries of the site; e. Location and width of all existing driveways, streets (named), intersections, easements and utility locations (underground and overhead) adjacent to and across the subject site. Aerial Location Map with the appropriate zoning and future land use information for the site and surrounding properties. 6. Site Plan depicting the entire site. The Site Plan shall include the following information: Location of wooded areas existing or proposed water bodies, and other environmentally -sensitive lands. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within one hundred (100) feet of the outside boundaries of the site. Mr. William Thrasher December 18, 2012 Proposed MacDonald Subdivision Page 5 features, subdivision streets, buffers and common areas. Landscape Plans shall include safe sight triangles. 8. Preliminary Drainage and Utilities Plans indicating proposed easements, structures, retention areas, etc. C Page 1 of 1 Rita Taylor From: Marty Minor [MMinor@udkstudios.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 20, 2013 1:36 PM To: Bill Thrasher Cc: Rita Taylor Subject: RE: Yes, we can send the "what we do" letter as the staff report for ARPB. I have no problem with that. Wantman has provided with a list of questions/additional info they would like to see that I will include with my comments. However, Brian LaMotte and I both do not see any initial concerns with the application and have no problem with this moving forward. Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Urban Design Kilday Studios The Offices at City Place North 477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758 561-366-1100 urban The Offices at CityPloce North ph. (561) 366.1100 477 S. Rosemary Avenue. Suite 225 f. (561) 366.1111 d� West Psalm Beach, Florida 33401 www.udkstudios.com kl I ditty S T U D 10 S Urban Planning and Design I landscape Architecture j Communication Graphics From: Bill Thrasher [mailto:bthrasher@gulf-stream.org] Sent: Wednesday, March 20, 2013 12:01 PM To: Marty Minor Cc: Rita Taylor Subject: Bill Wietsma wants to know if there will be some additional report for the subdivision. We were thinking that the "what to do" letter was sufficient for the up -coming ARPB meeting. They are on the agenda. Please let Rita know what to expect. Do we sent your "what to do" out as the "staff" report? William H. Thrasher, ICMA-CM, CGFO, CGFM Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Office 561.276.5116 1 Fax 561.737.0188 Direct e-mail: bthrasherCoD-gulf-stream.org 3/26/2013 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 Parcel ID: 20-43-46-09-03-000-0010 Property Address: 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Project: Proposed Subdivision of MacDonald Property Architect: William Wietsma Architect, PA Date: 02/12/2013 Below are the responses (in blue italics) to the review comments: Reviewer: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP Subdivision Re -Plat Process 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. Ok. 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested subdivision and designation of agent. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 3. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the property. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 4. Aerial Location Map with the appropriate zoning and future land use information for the site and surrounding properties. See Aerial/Zoning Map on sheet A-01 5. A certified boundary survey by a surveyor registered in the state of Florida at a scale of not less than one inch equals 200 feet containing the following information: a. An accurate legal description of the property; b. A computation off the total acreage of the parcel to the nearest tenth of an acre; c. Topographical data; d. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within 100 feet of the outside boundaries of the site; e. Location and width of all existing driveways, streets (named), intersections, easements and utility locations (underground and overhead) adjacent to and across the subject site. Refer to Boundary Survey for items a - e. Plat Plan, compliant with Section 177 of Florida State Statutes, indicating the proposed subdivision. The plat plan should indicate all existing and future easements, restrictions and common -owned property, if any. Refer to submitted Plat Plan. 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 ` William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 Provide a statement from a registered civil engineer addressing how storm water drainage will be addressed on site. The statement should include how the subdivision's storm water drainage plan will comply with the Level of Service standard as described in the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Code of Ordinances. See attached response to comments from civil engineer. 9. Provide a statement on how solid waste will be collected and disposed for the subdivision's homes. Provide a copy of the annual capacity letter from the Solid Waste Authority of Palm Beach County. Solid Waste shall be collected by the Waste Management of Palm Beach County. Attached is the requested copy of the annual capacity letter from the Solid Waste Authority of Palm Beach County. 10. Provide a statement addressing how the additional dwelling units within the proposed subdivision addresses the Recreation and Open Space Level of Service found in the Town's Comprehensive Plan. Level 3 Site Plan Review 1. Application Fee to be determined by the Town. Ok. 2. Written and notarized consent of the owner for the requested subdivision and designation of agent. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. Warranty Deed of the property and copies of all easement and plat documents on or adjacent to the property or serves the property. The requested document has been submitted as part of this application. 4. A certified boundary survey by a surveyor registered in the state of Florida at a scale of not less than one inch equals 200 feet containing the following information: a. An accurate legal description of the property; b. A computation off the total acreage of the parcel to the nearest tenth of an acre; c. Topographical data; d. The location of all existing structures on the site, as well as those on adjacent properties within 100 feet of the outside boundaries of the site; e. Location and width of all existing driveways, streets (named), intersections, easements and utility locations (underground and overhead) adjacent to and across the subject site. Refer to Boundary Survey for items a - e. 5. Aerial Location Map with the appropriate zoning and future land use information for the site and surrounding properties. See Aerial/Zoning Map on sheet A-01 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 William Wietsma Architect, PA Florida License Number AR -0014766 3. Name of development and project name 4. Range/Township/Section 5. Date Plans prepared and subsequent revisions 6. Total acreage of site 7. Boundary dimensions 8. Lot coverage 9. Open space calculations 10. Parking Spaces (required/proposed/dimensions/Handicap/loading (as applicable) 11. Building setback and/or separations 12. Building height. See site plan, sheet A-01, for all relevant information. Landscape Plan indicating compliance with Sections 66-396 through 66-402, 70- 146 and Section 66-144(b) of the Code of Ordinances. The Landscape Plan shall indicate all existing and proposed landscaping including the location of landscape buffers or screening walls along roadways, with landscape plans for entrance features, subdivision streets, buffers and common areas. Landscape Plans shall include safe sight triangles. Landscape drawings have been submitted for review under this submittal. 8. Preliminary Drainage and Utilities Plans indicating proposed easements, structures, retention areas, etc. Civil drawings has been submitted for review under this submittal. 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 y" 2 y G, m 3 3 FF�Z7-Fi 3^ 3 3 3 3 O - 8 y-�0 G7 c 0 o~C �rpmAE App�Am ny °<IOI gmyy T 4` yAq A<o mg w y " TZ mAE �N" <DE I p AD"�y^'p° Oi yy\ �T °'O _g �L V I z \ N n y A U z J � \ \ Pm I m D - fl 01 D B (n D N_ z O gpy I A ��mss�loo \ nW� a N o� A o x 6 . Apr_ � AmmZ Wy. yy�, pppm' "zn0 > L x L o y % x »ya a� N�xm x mFg4 A'rn m A o m m y" 2 y G, Fn m "§ % " - 8 y-�0 G7 c 0 o~C �rpmAE ny °<IOI gmyy T ru 6KD A<o mg w fu1 " mMynmO2 mAE �N" <DE I m iR Oi yy\ �T °'O _g �L V I z \ Am n y A U rrL) J \ \ Pm I m D - fl 01 D B (n D N_ z O gpy I A ��mss�loo \ a N o� �® o x Apr_ nU "zn0 > L x L y % x »ya a� N�xm x mFg4 A o m \ N O�j xAn I �m No — `IOw —, — — r�r-� Ay ON zx 50 mom° Imn�L N r y.. QN a ID = P O 0 D M r r N Z Z G� N M -T D a RIM \ p T ZE m N IM G7 c 0 f�m1B'II 1 gmyy � ru 0 I OZ �qp°OFFF Coo w fu1 " A ym��pp 0333 I R3. m 6 x m nn Oi Di Oi V I z \ Am �n3n y BRICK)EXIBTCORAL 5TONE PATIO (TO REMAIN) I i O 70 ODm UDS 6 < % / / 3 DO / / Om3Au z / mO0 E7b1 Q Z➢,f�CN / ni Q°j p" Ian m OA D N SE yA M A Q tis I s I° �mr" A� Qmp lnm Dx �DX � 770gN b p� Yj lAmamn pp� +j mny0O 0 �3Z x, m m J \ /O➢ m A6 ^ DA v � A :npD g1�p;1�nnlI U3 1-- D -, a Z i. p--m A� r—ElO o OgmDX z0�` f 33• _ Z O " m q m y i1m 1 1 V USI^NN m -1 x Z ipo �- I� nm Am vAl it -dm •D$o �i zz._ ��N Dmllae T ZE v IM G7 c 0 f�m1B'II 1 � ru 0 I OZ �qp°OFFF Coo w fu1 r'�nn g I R3. m 6 x N 1 TI� W< V I z \ ry �n3n BRICK)EXIBTCORAL 5TONE PATIO (TO REMAIN) I rrL) J \ \ Pm I m D - Z O 70 ODm UDS 6 < % / / 3 DO / / Om3Au z / mO0 E7b1 Q Z➢,f�CN / ni Q°j p" Ian m OA D N SE yA M A Q tis I s I° �mr" A� Qmp lnm Dx �DX � 770gN b p� Yj lAmamn pp� +j mny0O 0 �3Z x, m m J \ /O➢ m A6 ^ DA v � A :npD g1�p;1�nnlI U3 1-- D -, a Z i. p--m A� r—ElO o OgmDX z0�` f 33• _ Z O " m q m y i1m 1 1 V USI^NN m -1 x Z ipo �- I� nm Am vAl it -dm •D$o �i zz._ ��N Dmllae T ZE v G7 c 0 f�m1B'II 1 � ru 0 I C '00 w fu1 Q I 1YI N 1 TI� W< V I z \ ry BRICK)EXIBTCORAL 5TONE PATIO (TO REMAIN) I rrL) J \ \ Pm I gpy I ��mss�loo \ a N o� AA� % o x Apr_ "zn0 L % x »ya a� N�xm x A o m \ N O�j xAn I �m No — `IOw —, — — r�r-� Ay ON zx Imn�L ID = a, ZE v G7 c 0 6 1 � ru C:) C w fu1 1 yam d �8 I Im"nm%11 m m��� D P�s'� Z m OZ 2EQ 04O0 mN Q mI 0ID ov - _U I < AOL m mnmo m Irn nm ma I n *mnR l //�o�o � p - U � y Z mo°o$ Z z ,„Z I i ®®Eim`$`-° z Np A mg m �a" "A Goff z r � * owojT AL\ n13 {°C 2 to y_ z- i ItlmD A Aq ON °oa¢N z ASD I mNn z"° I Im zr I ggnmD% r g<<pn£�o O DgN° — — — — — L PROPERTT LINE 210.43' — — _ Q m pO °Don "o � A yi° STATE ROAD 4-1-A (OCEAN BOULEVAFRD)LDm (EXISTING IIID' PAVED) Z O g " PROPOSED SUBDIVISION OF MACDONALD PROPERTY u a g Y 1410 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD 'ILLIAM WIETSMA Architect, PA ^^^ Florida License Number AR -0014766 0 0 o m � \Rrr ( 10 am �1 o �- -A m2 � " j, m EG (()" T m Y o"2x 1W g c Z rn Dn4, "fin A° i i rm an I 1 Oi-X I 1 I I Uy N Jti 4� I A I-, ~� ~O L, Lew EDzzp_zz I 1 rTI I I ® 3(mj RI' °\� Z� I mrn X rn \ / I I i Ohm I I m I nix I \ • ODg°�-iX 6x In x ° o �N A D °Z� I A EX p'4i �33' m � r OX '-w N£xip I I CD �v V . m p I3 — PROPERTY LINE 21043' -- - — — — $ E Z ~ 3m v °n x on i� u pOXDX z ONN m z pi A E i �1 X L I A I O N O o m o-.mx m 0 z ZmZ g.. p _ rb o N 71 -i N 7 -.°Z° x m m.Z I q / X y� m/770,�� I A m o ON z IN � IuSyl °�z I m oaa• rn ��p$ r o V �" b I IA T�T2d° W — m EXISTING 13RICK/COR4L �I I V 1 STCNE PATIO (TO 1 d° REMAIN) I INx I I Ey �$ �m�m NmoX £ IT! I pp ^Po 1 I I I F Aod-A oo m m=0(I) L--- J I " = U Sx- x mAa I m E m I-Vp � - zA 10 D I m -p o I I At0 ,6 6 D_Om _ I E A m dl� Ap m3R fy I I p Aa e a rn'I M xZ I, UM �y0 I A r STATE A-1 -A (OCEAN BOULEVAfvDJt-" (EXISTING 22ff PAVED) Y O~ $ D = = PROPOSED SUBDIVISION OF MACDONALD PROPERTY WILLIAM WIETSMA Architect, PA Hill -1410 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD 4 'nen Florida Number AR -0014766 OX ��f•�X CD �v V . m p I3 — PROPERTY LINE 21043' -- - — — — STATE A-1 -A (OCEAN BOULEVAfvDJt-" (EXISTING 22ff PAVED) Y O~ $ D = = PROPOSED SUBDIVISION OF MACDONALD PROPERTY WILLIAM WIETSMA Architect, PA Hill -1410 NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD 4 'nen Florida Number AR -0014766 r SOT gi5y O74 ;gg�qj� 11� 1aggRe ��a� fi ro O 9q W= DOM '-CMC ALMEAD I s I _ � p + b4 R • pry Pi 4 + + f 4 h l I r OCAC All MAD v I ' � _ �9 UR Au + + A c e + + tly �j� Y Y �":'�' �$ I i r1l ar LQ Ve g Iti 9 I • NO o � I + Oil i a + i r;,T Cr Wwvu�E me Few J%r +22&+2M STAAT ROW A-1—A (AN M BIOL[EVAI�q +n° r +IILJ 17 MNC +CTf +II61 �0 77 r /NTRACOASTAL WATERWAY ,L qkQ 1q �,�'ia �. STATE ROAD ..YY 19 TO ' z .lar NOT9" � q L —1 e Oar zoa i '� I ��r rn O St ��Z �y CD o Z pZOy Z I� $m a � � o 2tW $� N rn cz rn e a. n til c cn Z ®®A e3 O I 22 4 RNr SS�f'Rp, Y � S �T��+nlaa; UYOIIY' goer MME IE /SID ranoV.� N/clwgir .Isrwarrorwrue raroro / k51 WD— had \ ��/ ) > —2D tT'I 4o z y v t4t., I > rTI / colic, u�=.ne�cna u a � A e = a c-) frI to mA /� III � '7itO �MA•+� z t�i IiQ�f \ LCC J I bd ' I N I I tj I rn yo I F r I I �N� O I I ty I I rn C' -i d W �m I I I �00 rpAwo n ba`� I I C C I Ix I tl [ I I Gb by b� I I m I I O trd I �yt7 O o `I z � � in I I o�" t•3 •dam I I c �z �� � g O $ I o � C-3�zo n j. 3 I - �z r NIu _ o t sI 4 I I "2 t o� I m � 1 1 I � Z m L4 f� J aiw10-1 { oil �30.6M}0.60 oil Z r � y o "e o C11 ' o omm o x I o a d = ► M o •• N -W b W dCIVIL Assoociateciates Envgn ww«.6mc66b . ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR: MACDONALD SUBDIVISION 1410 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA - YAtlb Mmttour eH6wmc5 eul S H PIKE. .peETH A. ►IKC. RL P �• °A7Fi WI M*w= r= ° FLORIDA 1. Gr. CAW OF .I7y BI—h. Ha es6e 298 PORIDA C WIC Way DAUTH BZAch• Fl N.6 33444 Phone: 561 274-8500 Fay 581 274-0558 D ' ;u�g IZ g, � � q P� �0 171 0 85 0 if,111111"i 9� cU ITT 24' H El z Xrq 2$�� g g F i y iI�iY i:''IL P �7 > -> �P R �$ >• 7 45 To J c�� �■F ��� pm'2 i N� Mgr a El A1 � a� i:2 � � m F �IN � � ji g e. pi o A� mss r a z F1 w Ln — �m m 0 r 4 z z { z � El z ` xg �7 DOR 1 11 ZR w 6' 1 01F -'n o CTI o oxo ydy L-' - N nu m d m EnviroDesign Associates _ ENGINEERS • ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENT DETAILS FOR: MACDONALD SUBDIVISION 1410 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM FLORIDA 1 Nm yALE, wDHouT EfgWEE71'S SFwL JOSEPH A. PIKE. P.E. FL REO / 42190 �• DATE REYogNS n: m 4/0/11 ADD TIENCH REPAW/BACKrlL DETAILS no m 6/50/11 ADD CONTROL S1RXIME L BLEEDER PLATE DETAIL .AB m I/1�/11 REWE EASE -WEST SECIIUN PER SITE PIAN CHANGES .A9 ® 11/2/11 ADD PAVEMENT J0*9 DETAIL .A9 FLORIDA CERDFlCATE OF AUTHDRIUTION Na 6508 298 Plneapple Grow Way Delroy Beach• Florida 33444 Phone: 581 274-8500 Fax: 581 274-8558 ® 12/21/11 ADD BLEED DOWN AND MANATEE GRATE DETAILS 2/9/12 ADD TYPICAL D""AY DETAIL .Ap Yom® o -u " m ty CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENT DETAILS FOR: NOT vAuO wm+oNo. u"TE: REvelow: " Rr: o DD � EN°wEn+'s 'E"Eur Ey EnviroDesign m +/ze/+z ADD DRIVEWAY CRCROSSSECTIDH Mp M �� ',.� o x o •. p AssociatEjsln_ MACDONALD SUBDIVISION m 2/0/+2 ADD TYPICAL SECTIONS D t E FOR TRACT A .Ae � o ro ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 1410 N OCEAN BLVD � %%l FLIXiIOPPCEFtTIFlCATE OF AUTHORIZATION Na DSDD 295 PlneO le Grove Way Ddu Beach, Florida 33444, I + GULP STREAM FLORIDA 1 � JOaFTN A. PIKE, ►.E. R RED / 42eYe Phone: 581 274-8500 Felt 587 274-850 M�� z e 0 PI � e �x Ai � I SOLID BRICK ��p� e• uR ro a' DEEP z cDIIRSEs wµ 10. 6' ro 10' DEEP 4 COURSES MAX 12' DVER 10' DEEP NOT TO IXC® tY � r, � F VARIES 24• YIN. ,• YIN. ,M MAX e• �5�� MI qr bb fN I I N .• c r i� •g $v m�(�� ,moo KP 24• MN. �y¢5j yy P MAX J'jJP YRlRRAI DEP+FI 4'-a• o p 6 DFPTN TD INVERT IS GREATER THAN a' -D• USE STANDARD YAW{q,E D P'� CUI m 2� q O ��I� IR PR mu ' (�� � z'� z'YA>< F i 30'V♦I q 14nnn lr l,,,,n uun 0p 1IIVOId IpI ��� i � II 1,1 Itltltl VlllW, qIJ u m _ �+ loinnnna:l pi � i I Z �� frr m ORO at H! rq ir M nnn UVUUni:nii�li�liU . . m r 111 IIII � JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ it it it �l �I �I it it it it it �l �I it it �l '� Sya � ri Z ¢^i§@w r � q q --I � � z e• FA m e• m M, � � -I r0. � -It?• o � � v �; n� � m e•: w TO e• DEEP � K +> at x +o•: a' ro +o' DEEP o p +z•: OVER +o' DEEP 1 � JOaFTN A. PIKE, ►.E. R RED / 42eYe Phone: 581 274-8500 Felt 587 274-850 ��oyxmomB����i`z��$o'" n��"��"����m����~o��Fv����g i p : CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENT DETAILS FOR: --1D M7,FIOUf NOT ENDwEra's ,.L No.DATE: REWRN4 n: O��o ^i moiy$c�� , ->0>u����zcve'_y ��z+$ovz>9: ��xv$vmp��'m�� $$ir��ISo��-��-c y��N��yZ��CnCN'v��SS��'����:i v��Ag?i������fm4)KaNi km-4ppdT>��c��D��i ��v��tm����1KmiAp"^p�� 'j gyyS��C1xFm���� ����mv-_Z����Z.i�� ����--=>>tCn�����A���%gn11 $��o��mNAA��>��$AnV����>�� gt��B~+��m��o4su��m��rR : i i4omZBgmm ��A��N >nWm_��m? � cOc^i ����������' on=����c$��-F���� m��.O`pp����4����=2gyn ��:mz9��z��$9����F$;>mn��np O J��>��((g��zo'��yC�����'<��C''))4��rim��zm>m������ovd�� ��" x> ��>v Um��m��ai (t��n��������'��$'l ��v��m >��4Av-��m$_��zmr������c��g �������� nm ����$ ��F��������imryx����N��F""] A ��m y $��m m ��1Y����� ��ppZ �� -'A��;" m�� -��_^��i$m��_>l����c��$��r����4��-a'' n0 yyi��z$������o��' ����'��o����$��o��n�g.n" p��Z ���� ��r��Ar��m1ym��Bni A��m~=����$e5F��4��r>L��, to'"cg!��r��ojD ,. o". > rn ey P. �� CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENT DETAILS FOR: --1D M7,FIOUf NOT ENDwEra's ,.L No.DATE: REWRN4 n: N��nr��:��iyO`iI����Z$��m FL REO~/ 4R2a00.E. ,. o". > rn ey P. �� CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENT DETAILS FOR: --1D M7,FIOUf NOT ENDwEra's ,.L No.DATE: REWRN4 n: 01 c% 72 F N1P 0 m • 0 En 00 : p M ul m M sill AMIX is 0 N W 0 Al, 0 F z iq INIgg 0 oll -oil F_ MR z 'vo h 0 IN ;7, m Ln 4 111 1 0 19 0 pig I — — — — — — — — — — 10-11 L L p P. -4 P. P Ln Elf ol A M ig m En 'zn A AE R iml r>- fl4 —o 5 — — — — — — — — — — - J_ o z Epp m 9 Rom &ORA STATE ROAD A -I -A (OCEAN BOULEVARD) 0* Q)4� tr �; > (n �tL —i . o CA 0 m cp W 0 0: >Z all 0 z =mI m o cr) it rT1 ovi > m ZI n C) _j n L4m m m gig > r P > R 0 01 o 0 0 -0 w wot2: w td Envir Design SOCiateS - ENGINEERS - ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN FOR: MACDONALD SUBDIVISION 1410 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA NUT VALID JOS"" A. PIKE* FL REG 1 4259FS' NO. DATA REMIOM: I FLORIDA CER flFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION Na 05M Pheapple Grove Way Delray 13-1h, Florida 33444 pLou" F.w. (581) 274-B 55B b e>e�GNYW r5�m* 'HHHHHHH * HFIFFIFFFF aGt: :GGC 939999�399�$9�$$�9'�93y99 ri rihririri - - 'ri hriririri ririri (i riri � ri n riri 39399.3-933 ��93�33�F��GF�G��C�C3���3a�,��3 ��ySt�:N�s:d:—v'6mNa�li 6ta.v�m��'xom�cCw=dad FFFFFF�FFFF�F�FFFFFFF���F�F�QF�FF�F��F�F a�p�ap:ww�x�a��UaWp�a���x�rW ��eaa�aeW -339983 a3333°3�38399, g9§ 's:v _rF9aa:-��� FFF�F�FF � FFFFFF� r r rrr °I F F g; e g�x�j9xxWs��a�ssetepp iM ri spa 3F F.cg ° ggg3QNmR^t3g3,'�d �ua� HE 3� I y r. 1 H aq ss44Qg4 g" gg B'" 19 Ir �;���3553339,39339��::l�5.�,go4 �gagqqpqa�aqa�a �� ,�sa�a FFFFFFFFFFFFFF ����� '77 w n u C #� O _p _ Macdonald Property Subdivision 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Gulfstream Florida Peterson Design Professionals Landscape Archiftm Planners Phone (561)702-0136 151 S.W. 7th Terrace Fax(56l)339-3543 Boca Raton, Florida 33496 j.peleraon2008®hormail.com CA CV 5 77/4 -r —5 - Macdonald Property Subdivision Peterson Design Professionals 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Lan&upc ArchiWU Phme (561)702-0136 41— 151 S.W. 7th Tcff� Fax (56 1 )338-3543 Gulfstream, Florida B� Resm Fknide 33496 j.petmDn20D8@hotmaiI.cm R I _ V. °O ISO) CD Cm q Ar - Macdonald Property Subdivision Peterson Design 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Professionals Landscape Architects Flam1aa Ffiooe (561)702AI36 Gulfstream Florida 151 S.W. 7th Terrace Fax(561)338-3543 Boca Raton, Florida 33486 j•peterson2008QhotmU.com lit r V C 0�� T- • LA a m I��Rh 1-,,6,- t >_ J Macdonald Property Subdivision Peterson Design Professionals © 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Landicape Amh;tecb P,,,, 4— Phone (361)702-0136 Gulfstream, Florida 151 S. W. ri433486 ;.p—wnPm (s6P).i36-3543 M@homniP.— ti z yy 0 _ Ma zy n �y c� <�,oOti o4 4 m r z AQ m d '° x�'e 'eoE7a� rn o m v oa0 Z �op WHIR y��°p��oow � �Q ~ E � p° � 8� o �x�� � B•�§ •��� ° � P� K- �'"�m�Oo�0x5S°o°° °z'oroCC` b� c 4 `o'ccb� g� d�`° g•>"> t" m°N 44 'd '9 >y3 3� n�mE 1a a r v y tl m m a pq� MIR yxP,�i°a� ��yymoym�p yO ii�j�>zO4z 000 op�ropy Qd Sr O�g�z ym o '�1 a e in ygq�,,OZ0wZ p 5� y M [rl ?1 tci 'vy lxl 81Z pz ' Sg tr1 C 7n 7yQ a y0 OFoi H n o, C nn --p11 X666 w S t. a�an zm y trz� by�w��� a� xo��blw e. �yg0yg yy0� t�+�i t�a�tmu E� �uCf��p.~.7 � � � O yz mo a~ n < X� �Yp CCtlSS4 > 90°p vy�i y❑app ,.a -„]I QO yjn5 �[.�pj7i�p7�. �CO m C (9i�o �:. � gfA] o RIOaE y � °"p> p 4 ^`�RmI �i9� n o ° � 21 p IIa ° 4 � � � y >d 'i jn 7c pb p� N �T rd w N O o m ° z '! ° �J [y'� r y ? 8 � O uee twnN 0 = • 1 O W �- ci i- 1-s Peterson r =-3 w Macdonald Property Subdivision -n Design 1410 North Ocean Boulevard Professionals 1 �[.nndlcepe A+chilects Plrnneta one (561)702-0136 Gulfstream Florida 151 S.W. 7th Terrace Phow Boca Raton, Florida 33486 j.1etaeon2006®Iworoil.cam 9£9L-t,LZ (199) XUA £98t,-tLZ (19S) 031330 d4IHO-id ` vDuiS d-n!D � a amu £8b££ EpT10i,.1 `TT3EOg AL'110Q `QATSQ uTSEg O£OI w U d' U O 99Li7100-'dV .TaquznH osuaolZ EPT3Oi3 a�lb'�8-in08 NVE100 HiHON 0[K cu c w••=hh WQ m �„ 3oMIN U g� Vd `P-J.fI,PJ T VjVSjjjM JjVj77jM uH3dOHd Q_1VN040dW d0 NOISIAI48f1S a=-ISOdOHd Jf, 's Q LU W O bFi yq w Qu�u�lryryW111 U Q�WW QWWWN>>ZZ� w� a �oWQ�- z�dwi� 4akOw a °oT� °a6rc aU� m i�O L ioa w3 - w tl�l,1>a ii W "aF m Odi 00§O t0 �WBi_ 8 O amQwLL "R3u w °� N � JUO a0 N W.— U1tLL L1i§a Z3 IIIQ 111��5 .�I 1 X. ,„ Z a�� �z Q N aWm� �z W h a 4 / W O u Ca�b/�3-11108 Nb ��OJ�D -�i� slQ7O� �lb1S — — __ _E4'Oii 3NIl— �= IL 1 i Q 3� a0 a ��a I i mQURI mjE I QQ€a� MWi° 6°01 O�Z New D" I I I If1L/oA W2 x I I W tt 1 I dao i a '` �z 0. 3 1 zw I IJUU W ry W /p� RHO LL�I i v :3 dl k v WW 1v LLM,° I # , k 'o- 'WL I w WmL m��tt "�I ORO I fi iL — J I it i© da I w �w �o I" W s \ d O \ I � \ o ul I = rrmvuaa ou p \ ouvd ar+ois _ Q �mnr las 'JNI151X3 > � � o pll1 r'Idm Bwaa � Up: N O II ��oW � �I I In t wwR w" Aj0 , I IL m N°�om I WdWrta r w 0 a° W z 2 �L II I O�z 3a W 1 w"� 'I Iim �r ----- .EE `UOQ % WHO - - - - - " w p Xa ?� JWwWTm DID W°� ~9a w x • 3 ¢ �II4Rm� a W� a }cru w OE F0�` r � a a " Y ��� "\ w°voC�f N — — --- •ni am ° w X6a.LLNd� Wm^ Wla'1�`l O \\ w I Iw a I w= ' os e wo \ a ° ° 1,w i ° N 0°°° / a Wo O a `,� : I T J TA TA ms _ _ �Qz N f- 0 M f- 0 / / M Z S7 ¢� N �3 h P Qk U k°u > Q Q VL Ca 0 �J Bt SE/� 1b\ J � a amu nU N U d' U MwZ N cu w••=hh WQ m �„ 3oMIN U g� a = o Jf, LU W O bFi yq d000� 1-. � k'�O��� N f- 0 M f- 0 / / M Z S7 ¢� N �3 h P Qk U k°u > Q Q VL Ca 0 �J Bt SE/� 1b\ J � a amu a = o Jf, bFi yq d000� 1-. � k'�O��� W 3d'�4n LL' Om�7O au u uuuw���41� aad� _� Wigw W 9 a U U U vm- U U mam" °a 9£9L-VLZ (199) X83 £98b-VLZ (199) ao?330 vcinjo—u 'INv3uiS =nno — —' N £8•b££ t1ppola 'g3uOq AuiloQ `oAISQ uisvq O£0I 99LVI00-2IV saquinH asuooi-I -uplSol_q OUVAD noa NbDoo H1HON o[V[ L4 O �'d `��a1rTTar �rT,IT T T,1TT r '1 � Y �' 1(,SlJIAl i' 1( Y I77IM ),iUl dOHJ a-ItfNOQOb'W -40 NOISIAI(lons aDSOdO�id �V La Q A 9 f i WB�CQ�b'��-InO9 (JHAOtt �HjjslQb'O� 31b'1S — IW L 2w_ Q 3Z a1) � ~ �a NwL 73 �Qa WG Wi I�Q r_-- _-- _-- a° I a l Zw O I ly - %�O�atopz = If zj o wz I ' i> " aq� apo w� d .L w o " "z w mm mp w= y wl w w� wL w°� F w wa >>°o I I �aW`g �Q = o I I I, W 3 I o° (NIVL.GRJ ol) OI1Vd 3No1S w Q waoolae IVNILSIXa I-) [(� I QQ I oma 0hz- - to a I �o I i° oQ, wq w a W I IL af 8 w mI o x(�tg OW W d)( `g w" o N 0 I 0 o ii LL X � I z ,n9_U W U� 2 XQXa J WLLWLL W qq�� l'1Q aQ a a Na > I Ef 95. w3 � ODUUy ° Xvla� X� ,Iii I ?^ W Wa ---J- ---J "� — W � o Mvr 94 €a€ Z zO WW17 z� wa ��°Faw NQEW \ \ K •`WjQ — — — d— I ° I j do I I' I j IfIg # i 1 I j d-1� I W 61 w i. I zw I eE,`eoac 0�Z>vo ~ > �3 a n/ IL , ; m�W�d WLL J o - ------ -------------- p it / zmo I I z oa a z 1� N R° yup a w } U W�ORR" j W3❑ i- ~ -Q l-�aL Z >UN°a wo —QQaUQ F- 2m m z � p 440 N 0 — —' ca /O C - j L4 j �V La A 9 f N 0 ISOOO[8: t Gle S --lNd 6Z.'lO -- EFOZ/! l20 --PXB,Q9-S61Px`JIOOVO WLOMN 10115Uia1e�01:0 C C= � 25 HP � 14 Ogg OPT cl �o� z co b Quo OAU ,Qm jVQ $8 V• ,� eta Ul a qqr J �1 Z e CO J �vI ~gip iGocp tiQ r -"b a opo 4 RN ail I -0 R ROSH,, i ail- tz E �.� � " � WO MIA 6 W �Q Q �-i QAC 411 47 r1 Qao k Y -I -Y OY O f� ? L� � Q r 1y 1S Qj� ..(r� .p �L j�1� Cf o� Cly '� ml`i Pit R��Qc fig, I 1 1 %1,462,'!ZN�DW mai- �! Q Im Rm � lu'j � (YM2/31 YM 7YISYOOYtJ1N/ J 1500'019: 1 GIRDS --WV6t 04--0t0e1t120--Px6g9-S61PxEJ100VO 1b'N3N3�JIsfiurnne�pl:p 2n AM X LOM invA N (GWAy7//1�{I NV3 �R( l I-iI a/�NV �I � �Mlfl i101.L�3S �pp�S5I W �y Jq( M I Z �� ,(i5Y �M�JTr llICMK ���AM7 l 1,4 o N .6�Z ti D J� I it 4 O o Q IAstnavNZz� z � I � rn;M N � N O a� Um 3oamON - Whav n vJ Q �QW O II try AM" Lu d 104 Q I � J W pY`� MIT Qzt ZW 0 0 W C N e r -/-r oro ,Q+p qr 3 W Al �YMH3I VM 7VlSY00Vd�IN/ O % J �  L1 X  11 'Ad L5 0�� ��IOVLLI/Z `6mp,gN��-08011\uoisinipgnS jol �� wc)@jjsjln0-08011\LlOZ\:0 31 TW 'v H1nW HmHN ��7/��TT����TT r�� i ������.7r����LT 7 C+ ��r7 1�� v Q1Qo d ' Y alm's M -D (ma Nvaoo N OTti NOIS��QgnS a'IVN0(13VW :HOd KV7d S1KaNdA02IdW1 HUS UAIO 9959 w L99 and 0099 YLZ L99 MIw4d tfY�� oPWLi '4aoa0 A -mi ADM --j odd-lqd 96Z 9099 " N NOLLyzIuOHLOY d0 3LyoutL93oyao-w a , �� C7 o I .3 z P, o oo _U217 m OG 6h6 Rif& simviinsxoo zviNamouinxs " suamma w� ��aKavRZ RwV jq��4 u6ssepo��nu3l �� l ?' t Q v =N cI01C1A3Y aa��vIa3Lva ( wMinoa Nv3003 v -I -v avow iTbjsPA19 _U217 m OG 6h6 Rif& O S �� l ?' t Q TOd " I c ��.��.._ I"ae O +��QfNpi7 MHO  MFIO_ MHO-ri'Oi'��71 Af93d0p  10 MHO MHO � 0��'a   u.wns ms..Ru ,s N R TMJ= s � ]JO 'A.pO,G tii'S �� I " I, I I �� I I II LyJ m ���� W I L �� .ti ���� Q$ 00 < 6t ti I op q " *6 r a I 03 I�� 1 0ADN ,0'T'T = la ad 1 z I 0 NE 90, M. m yZg�� i I' IW.��l1 px����j 3 I Q I  LL X j `Ad 21:Lt, :�� ��IOZ/1[/Z bMp-]la-08011\uoisinipgnS Ion �� wooa1slInO-08011\L10Z\:0 en 1Ir13a ArM3Naa lrauAi aaY z./ah IF aaaLr / wa V8999 YLZ '3.9 3MId " Y HdUOr IY32 %yWMMM3 1fi0LILM OfnYA ION VGRIolid i NVHZIyS ATM) (��7 (GArI9 NVa tO�� N(j O��TTVT7 NOISIAIMMS QrI v MO (13 Y N :HOdI S 11 Y WLLQ W1V I MI AOUdlll UZIS UAID Lbs --A 0099 LZ YLos :.Uo4d YYYCC aPl-U '4.0�8 A -pa A.M onoxd cjddoaeld 86L wy.9 " t4 HOLLYZIHOHLnY !a 31ra11I1833 r0IH071 a ��: aLO z a ��, o z O N 9 i IMM 31Yaa 331YHYR ONY HMOs a3319 Cay ll/lz/zl NV an 1n130 1MDf 03MAYd aav L l/z/l L � Saxes f1SNO3 'IVJNa��exour��n/x/a�� su3Jxi��xa Sebe Ossd 1 . y u6lsapo��lnu�� VV // M �aNYlia HYId 3LG aid N00a3t lL3M-1cr3 3OA3a ll/Ll/a aYa 7Y13a 31Y 71 a a lHOH3Wi aaY ll/aC/a en sin139 lilfllaYa/uraaa HOH3Y1 am It/e/r lYI30 3VG/ V. :alaaA3a r11ra 'oH � g1ho CIIJ n tr3Aoa " eat .ac " o Imo. a . 3 >o �� s L ga s 4�� ��V J sE$u i SF U mtCCi% g�� Z d rf i 0 d o d u d 5��5 `�� 8 104 liIHOWfa o mil Y � LS �� lY fi` p GoS gg �� N Z N a d o -p- I f�� mg, - �� ,; d g: p ��L. JE > < ka ����ir!d ��>G' `a5 w ��3 �� a e 8 �� r���� a 25K kgs a8 O n�� -, HPI W m m J}a J PrP 6122 �� L1p�� a&a E I A-. a r �� 8 8�� S� a #q r�� 0  z1 X "LL `Ad S�� : L- r 7 bmp,j1a-0801 L\uoisinipgnS jol ��7 LUD@Jjs jlnS-080 L L\ L LOZ\ :0 GeOLY / qs N ��1 6p Fl d��_ ? zo jq d33a ,aAt mno :.zl Y d33a u A al yy W d33a .0 OL dNK,�� < A SMVA j m b Il N ��y'6'rd ����i��;F Q I- �� W m Fi V IP - O Ld Z b 7a U) b$ U LT W {a�� I W.2 A m V ,0 Z� EL ��y�� fii vii U l-.YII- II��jj A����}F ti 1" , ZONA rri F x # 0 m;Fi YOIS Z ��.2 I, , I, I;III, I, I;ill, 1; I,I;I gal J y 111111'Ili 1111 III, II VIII i ( III 11111 1��11i1 Ju u61,u 6J L uLJ pop r, ,rr, w �� ili4 i ilili ill ili i ilili�� E��, o LL d � Ir 8' w �� 2 i �� �� �� '�� nnnnnrlrlrlrinnnnnnrl ,(p��ql ������ �� ? ��\ n r I I I II I II I I III I ii" ��''JJy1����' YI .: N���� W /���� �� I ��\ �� i$` �� it nnnnnnnnnln+nnnnn Ik%y+lll IC �� �� _, �� n �� ��JJiill IlltIJJUIIUJ U d ��8 xvnz S a $ (V < s A�� r zg19 uj z�� Oa% IFj o < N UI Oil ��zb ��m �� 3iwmrn GH CWIs 3sn .a -.v 12$ �� > rl i N o ri fi u d NYH N3.9 -J, Ld3G N d o r MVWM F��"1: N�� IN ��9x��y1 O N)n .tL i S4j J d+ S m cl grlr cl ����JS CS (s5 Sx LV 65 gi + - - - fid kJ i Sm b 6 �� 3a cr -17 In e g a mg" rin.r Nn .YLs3larA Q'Q'> > ��ilnu m O 4.. K3 al ION d33a ,ax O HI,o .zl O SS F < t�� i3 'WI S3sHfL d33a A Wpga V �� dfl GI Z N r! f Hl ti Z 4 4 )CNHB Of105 ^I 03'u 7'J '3MW 'Y HJ3Saf lY3i C,iR33N1aN3 11NHWM onVA MN i V LL1Qo id NV a��7 uuwiflo QAZS NVaoo N oTtT NOISIAIQHIIS C1r1VM0CfJVW r�� ��1TTo1 QS'IIV Lia LI��I3Itl��noxajYI ILIB ,,AID HSSH-vLz m ..-4009"/Z M :..a4d ri4�� -PP-Li V-8 A-1-0 400 wax, aIdd-lid 96Z BOSS ' N NOILVZIHONLNV JO 31VOIiLLH3O VOIHO-U a {pqy N p7 [ti \ a F o z m pa o e, ow����elsa����.��aMv.� ��yY `-+ saxvsznsxoo ivLLNayiNouiAma " sxasxIjxa �Is3��eiapssy l U61S2QOJIAU�� ��/ J aYe Y 17Yi1 Ya3 3: a RIQlaUa3G,YaMaaV LI/e/L el'e Ha3S Siatla AYM3N71a aQV Zl/SL/I �� �u '001OAM ,Uva " (N qs N ��1 6p Fl d��_ ? zo jq d33a ,aAt mno :.zl Y d33a u A al yy W d33a .0 OL dNK,�� < A SMVA j m b Il N ��y'6'rd ����i��;F Q I- �� W m Fi V IP - O Ld Z b 7a U) b$ U LT W {a�� I W.2 A m V ,0 Z� EL ��y�� fii vii U l-.YII- II��jj A����}F ti 1" , ZONA rri F x # 0 m;Fi YOIS Z ��.2 I, , I, I;III, I, I;ill, 1; I,I;I gal J y 111111'Ili 1111 III, II VIII i ( III 11111 1��11i1 Ju u61,u 6J L uLJ pop r, ,rr, w �� ili4 i ilili ill ili i ilili�� E��, o LL d � Ir 8' w �� 2 i �� �� �� '�� nnnnnrlrlrlrinnnnnnrl ,(p��ql ������ �� ? ��\ n r I I I II I II I I III I ii" ��''JJy1����' YI .: N���� W /���� �� I ��\ �� i$` �� it nnnnnnnnnln+nnnnn Ik%y+lll IC �� �� _, �� n �� ��JJiill IlltIJJUIIUJ U d ��8 xvnz S a $ (V < s A�� r zg19 uj z�� Oa% IFj o < N UI Oil ��zb ��m �� 3iwmrn GH CWIs 3sn .a -.v 12$ �� > rl i N o ri fi u d NYH N3.9 -J, Ld3G N d o r MVWM F��"1: N�� IN ��9x��y1 O N)n .tL i S4j J d+ S m cl grlr cl ����JS CS (s5 Sx LV 65 gi + - - - fid kJ i Sm b 6 �� 3a cr -17 In e g a mg" rin.r Nn .YLs3larA Q'Q'> > ��ilnu m O 4.. K3 al ION d33a ,ax O HI,o .zl O SS F < t�� i3 'WI S3sHfL d33a A Wpga V �� dfl GI Z N r! f Hl ti Z 4 4 )CNHB Of105 ^I  L 1 X  L L `Wd 9S : L-�� L/Z `bMp*��10-0801 L\uoisinipgnS Io -I �� woaaI sIIn0-0801 L\ L l0Z\ :0 ctr IU CD w r o SW W IJ mq p ��Us �� zw m oc'i�� iTh o22 t`Ur- WpO_ 1;�� I y��. ��<< ��< mr32 y�� 24��WUje�� pO4O1M mg��Or qIL ? W Ub ��8< �� xW<yt r3=q zSwSsSi <w ao ���� <aS Z. a<�� zo _ ��oW �� jg<�� ?����$< W. < O4c 6 WU< zq<ie o����o������ 13W=cpi c��3 y��y,,����i pq 1(+' <�� �� p��r L�YS��N 4e yy<_����;U�� ��� ��T<��zm W rOm��N_< <O ��mW ���� N���� W��<j= O�� F'������g 0038� gr��$zg 1- ����F ��3c ������5 ��ZZ ��rc 3f.a�� UR RS= LIN,1 LTm ��botg <�� F$xF UZ ��� <aa ���� <���a ��L9ia rn H Q4m OI N Z J rc m W oW < 1����� �� Z wF 05-��1�� �� <_ < �� (.�� ij��3bs Eoa6F La <2. i&Z�� ewm {ry��R as 9�� <��oC ��rc����jZ��iX ��$3 9mo z��< z� W�� din 6 O�� $ 3 ��^ � rc��RZ��ZWr< ���Zp��Zp��ZZ rc r W 0 ��0= W o W{�� O�� F�� U W ;E �� O= v=W Z�� $ b=ZpZ<g �� g F3KW��W Fpp��O y= TUB $�� ,g��U�� < 3��0g�� ����NZU NU> 1-Ir/1 UW 0�� g3 U00 ��IJ���� Z 2 z��O09 qg0 Zr W r ��o=$�� m��eaV< '��` ��E Fq��-+�ate m�� ��yUjNrO m8wo�� M=S aiJ< >-��" X00 a3 Z3 Ig7i����F ra��471z ��FiF4mg (5aLa O gp,U�� c3F ��j =m=��a 6. 3 ,a������O ppn ==��J U WSF=., W��C O0W=< W�� 8�� ��F�� gUUFO ZU< mZ��F��N m��p 'M- T o ��K- mFr- mF mg0 ��������o�� ?O N a��] <$�������� ��OcFi err rci'�� ��iUm ��a��z0, da ��o;j g0fl ����il L�� ����g��am ��o FrjO Irh3E I����YbSFg gg ���� ion ��<iS ��mYS��oq ����Fz���� ��L��Spg<i U�� Ub��ihUFZ u v F 6��U<4Tig =LT1 Z3 U. z<���� yWaV��1 00 el jWF p Z �Z<�a< �Z<�8 ac��Owa P. ��O����O�� ��4JgOZ FW�� ��W�� ��Jm���� ��Eb 00�� 00 ��WO J������<9 ��W U 3 8 KSU U az2z 3 U ��O `w �� KX U Z U z U zF z < U U% a U 4c: oeaz�% o3n v 7Y 'DIY Y H,aiaf ,no��LLui'anVkU3A IIM VUR10Z3 `NVHZI,LS Allia-D (u,IH Nva00 N OTtT ��7 ��v '��y7 KOiS��QgnS Q -  K0(1JVW :HOa SMV1HQ .LN.HWHnoMNI HUS r AID esse-rtz 199 xa�� oosj -jd tl d :auo4d = aPWU 'Uj Rwlaa ICo/,�� waw alddoauld B6L 9099 ��N NOLLYZImmownV .4o 3Lywtw3o YaiWIA �� q M h Cj ca pp H Hpq�mIsHc Q 0 C m "" o [ppFzrpq o F1 .110 rco�� 2���� V��w3<m0<=001 smvsznsxoo lvmamouinxs " sussxioxa w;el'Jossd ��/��/ U61SSapo��!AU3 `y/ / ������ ��F��g aw Mnd NMUL3Yl3 CRY D111L7n= 1OWNW 39AM 1{/U/91 �� M 'InL30 awuD(wls'Iaalloo amu aNv slmrt3a aav 11/a/zl mm MLra row ctr IU CD w r o SW W IJ mq p ��Us �� zw m oc'i�� iTh o22 t`Ur- WpO_ 1;�� I y��. ��<< ��< mr32 y�� 24��WUje�� pO4O1M mg��Or qIL ? W Ub ��8< �� xW<yt r3=q zSwSsSi <w ao ���� <aS Z. a<�� zo _ ��oW �� jg<�� ?����$< W. < O4c 6 WU< zq<ie o����o������ 13W=cpi c��3 y��y,,����i pq 1(+' <�� �� p��r L�YS��N 4e yy<_����;U�� ��� ��T<��zm W rOm��N_< <O ��mW ���� N���� W��<j= O�� F'������g 0038� gr��$zg 1- ����F ��3c ������5 ��ZZ ��rc 3f.a�� UR RS= LIN,1 LTm ��botg <�� F$xF UZ ��� <aa ���� <���a ��L9ia rn H Q4m OI N Z J rc m W oW < 1����� �� Z wF 05-��1�� �� <_ < �� (.�� ij��3bs Eoa6F La <2. i&Z�� ewm {ry��R as 9�� <��oC ��rc����jZ��iX ��$3 9mo z��< z� W�� din 6 O�� $ 3 ��^ � rc��RZ��ZWr< ���Zp��Zp��ZZ rc r W 0 ��0= W o W{�� O�� F�� U W ;E �� O= v=W Z�� $ b=ZpZ<g �� g F3KW��W Fpp��O y= TUB $�� ,g��U�� < 3��0g�� ����NZU NU> 1-Ir/1 UW 0�� g3 U00 ��IJ���� Z 2 z��O09 qg0 Zr W r ��o=$�� m��eaV< '��` ��E Fq��-+�ate m�� ��yUjNrO m8wo�� M=S aiJ< >-��" X00 a3 Z3 Ig7i����F ra��471z ��FiF4mg (5aLa O gp,U�� c3F ��j =m=��a 6. 3 ,a������O ppn ==��J U WSF=., W��C O0W=< W�� 8�� ��F�� gUUFO ZU< mZ��F��N m��p 'M- T o ��K- mFr- mF mg0 ��������o�� ?O N a��] <$�������� ��OcFi err rci'�� ��iUm ��a��z0, da ��o;j g0fl ����il L�� ����g��am ��o FrjO Irh3E I����YbSFg gg ���� ion ��<iS ��mYS��oq ����Fz���� ��L��Spg<i U�� Ub��ihUFZ u v F 6��U<4Tig =LT1 Z3 U. z<���� yWaV��1 00 el jWF p Z �Z<�a< �Z<�8 ac��Owa P. ��O����O�� ��4JgOZ FW�� ��W�� ��Jm���� ��Eb 00�� 00 ��WO J������<9 ��W U 3 8 KSU U az2z 3 U ��O `w �� KX U Z U z U zF z < U U% a U 4c: muircw��F,F W � rco�� 2���� V��w3<m0<=001 ������ ��F��g �� ��w8w< a2= X 0 ��O w v� wo z����Nn F m��i-n�� �Ur' ��zF�� ��N ui��m�� ��,��.i1 bio mVal< w w����m��gi~ 3Fp��m -m-{{��a 3c4i o25n Z w9 ��cr5- 2,0259 $oz ��F����F_ �� �� x�Ji��B �� wo_a% �� ��Z��= oz�� M o ����o Mb c����Tyl�� YLFYg9 ��z���� ��i.< < no ��,aw =1 81 m <os�� Fgo w ��i ��- 7`=����r IJS��= p �� o GI �� m <<�� vI W m� �� W����3 U Uo< z��ieo <8<I -U c�� m< Ex! in ��o<(��.7 5=1= Z����S i m ����oZ wW ��.I ,��i Iy.F�� $3a��{������+ 3 ���� o ��n��5��<���� S��ril ��$a <ZF��q 0 �� 1��,, O ��S ���� < < aUii���� a w �� W��tF w 3��< o �� aW EMS z< oma��m c < � p 0<�� ��^<i$r r������ W<Giqq laJ <��U Ott Fo ��nFp<EgU -RR <OI-- zw U<< ��O�� �� 3��jj �� 8 F < W-EzZo wvlW �� oo.. s-dx m��WU ou77 �� rcw��< $��m��a ���� 8th ����o ��D:w�� �� aFp. u��i uri O��<��o�� ��o x ���� I pom q a= ���� G7 a e �'�� H. w ��m m = a��0�� �� 8 payZj�� Z EAR6 pry $rca �� �� Boo ����<aW zUo v ��6,r�� <��� ��jwz LJ (7 31��Lf��= �� c7 �� ����$3 OFma = ���� = g = c U S U = _mom N =JUO < = ��yqj UMmm ��O Z ����Q������$rmo��F q yj m�� O US O O < o o U��g���� <U ��muaiF ��� < da��vZa ����yz grc��= Q��ufU<6�� a��zUm UW<�� m �� e��U=��+ u��0�� �� Fz0 v ��w �� g��< ��` m��$mo��iio<�� '3<a F3 F�� ��o a < < S���-�� z ����a��� O��o ����<0 ,z'7-��.i$em�� aowtJtS< ��<%3 ������o p <����xF�� <UUSJa ac��rco?��a ai uT34x =USS< chi c���i �� a: a: aia�� U<GS ����Jll ��9 wgFI������ az8fa��i xF c'i��U aUW� Z Q 4 ' b ^ ai A N H N N N In } <�� = Q p�� ��O-WW } 1y � F�� p =}Zp S Z O < � Z<< Z 1-O�� Q Z Oa�� <UI W. -O m0 S1��1yy SWSmO ��h ��aC��Ep ~G'�� ><W<_ ����?N r> w<��c m<�� �� W��mm ZNQ O��`I-O'< 03 U 7 <O�� �� naa���� ozrc I am0< ��Fmg a d 56������ Q��>m omW��((77.��r! �� z�� L=��rcWz chi i��G��w��ix z< m o�uf 3tml1m0��"�� z cyi��b j zUL��'l�� $$e> Sep�� dv' mw ��Gq Gia�wm��<- <o< $ ��< zz ��- Li ��8��,'j Z m2��I��Z4pp{ mR p<��pU<O� 158<JmJ��< ����UO<S[m3 SR -MR 60R.- 66SVF��xp8 UIu Zz ��rVZ��IW < '����m����������� (��1mp����0����((U=l��O���� <~O ����YO $U=����W�� 1W ��m yyU����m<<(<'J Y1 $��-'�� a w=2 M29 ��ZO��<=��3 MaF��p<p������ IWW33J��w Or Z<0����0������(' Ff���� �Q <O$,=�� =OOm ��mN<a��N K UI #bVVWIIg .OqBr 8 aJ Z ��*wg7=r< F��-J <V O yf��m��Qm�� mL'��<<��������y-��Z������ ��az��om����tn =��F<���� O� =<���� � �� ����F��3p8 yd~< <Op������U ��r.��Fy-,IC��I�� U J��mF O��jj��m���� ��s ��1 ;�o+��a aal'y,7i�� pmWO "O��jW2��my <mSKN y����U����O 6e UUUUU"''= ��SW = �� < �� f9aN/wl��maU1N-��BY �� O ��� w ��31_z 3F- q S ] ������W�� 4��11 eOUOU'}t- ��i �� d ���� W N Om0 m8 U m < ��SwUw��O��< <��Wi��y=m������ T����NII/<IZZIi M. 1��2 ��gyWWJ IK��i17����KW< O e< i��lfo 05 mp O'L 0<8. S 4 . ? o 3VyNl W WmW aU3W�� t0.'IW=�� a<�� a < �� B F 2Wr- 3��<�� �� ��f c3 Lsl ����d 1`4T��1<IJ>nmz0 'wfd 2pZp<R<�Z_W WW~��iE <1U 1/I��ZSZ ��p K 4Zm��W r< ����=<F OW 3Z< ��UOIJ �������� m08< < W rW O IU�� U ~ ��z U'. 41 EO���� 4yl W'b��BWa m w0 rmY IW/I OO OU Op oBiF�� < WaOU 00 zF �FNO W C �� 6} m��pg ��lBK��� a q F I F cF.������a��a������b$pp3be o5 yn p w mg 5"*86-geo�W( Yz��gZ< pS nQ��mi � g0 � iWuW IF��ZO�� $<or<}vai a U����O�� a0W ��U<o<3 i�� ffiFOW<W jt V1 ����<oe< O��<����<<������W ��o��Jac��i��m$��ii5m$cii viii<tFo�� UW<�������� 1Fu2i5bbu_ g�� F3a ��tSi u< x= ������Scr<��< chi 43as a��U ���Om y`L=��iro�� <W <C ro:��<} '�� Y! 6 o) ri Y vi m n ad of �� muircw��F,F W � rco�� 2���� V��w3<m0<=001 ������ ��F��g �� ��w8w< a2= X 0 ��O w v� wo z����Nn F m��i-n�� �Ur' ��zF�� ��N ui��m�� ��,��.i1 bio mVal< w w����m��gi~ 3Fp��m -m-{{��a 3c4i o25n Z w9 ��cr5- 2,0259 $oz ��F����F_ �� �� x�Ji��B �� wo_a% �� ��Z��= oz�� M o ����o Mb c����Tyl�� YLFYg9 ��z���� ��i.< < no ��,aw =1 81 m <os�� Fgo w ��i ��- 7`=����r IJS��= p �� o GI �� m <<�� vI W m� �� W����3 U Uo< z��ieo <8<I -U c�� m< Ex! in ��o<(��.7 5=1= Z����S i m ����oZ wW ��.I ,��i Iy.F�� $3a��{������+ 3 ���� o ��n��5��<���� S��ril ��$a <ZF��q 0 �� 1��,, O ��S ���� < < aUii���� a w �� W��tF w 3��< o �� aW EMS z< oma��m c < � p 0<�� ��^<i$r r������ W<Giqq laJ <��U Ott Fo ��nFp<EgU -RR <OI-- zw U<< ��O�� �� 3��jj �� 8 F < W-EzZo wvlW �� oo.. s-dx m��WU ou77 �� rcw��< $��m��a ���� 8th ����o ��D:w�� �� aFp. u��i uri O��<��o�� ��o x ���� I pom q a= ���� G7 a e �'�� H. w ��m m = a��0�� �� 8 payZj�� Z EAR6 pry $rca �� �� Boo ����<aW zUo v ��6,r�� <��� ��jwz LJ (7 31��Lf��= �� c7 �� ����$3 OFma = ���� = g = c U S U = _mom N =JUO < = ��yqj UMmm ��O Z ����Q������$rmo��F q yj m�� O US O O < o o U��g���� <U ��muaiF ��� < da��vZa ����yz grc��= Q��ufU<6�� a��zUm UW<�� m �� e��U=��+ u��0�� �� Fz0 v ��w �� g��< ��` m��$mo��iio<�� '3<a F3 F�� ��o a < < S���-�� z ����a��� O��o ����<0 ,z'7-��.i$em�� aowtJtS< ��<%3 ������o p <����xF�� <UUSJa ac��rco?��a ai uT34x =USS< chi c���i �� a: a: aia�� U<GS ����Jll ��9 wgFI������ az8fa��i xF c'i��U aUW� Z Q 4 ' b ^ ai A N H N N N In } <�� = Q p�� ��O-WW } 1y � F�� p =}Zp S Z O < � Z<< Z 1-O�� Q Z Oa�� <UI W. -O m0 S1��1yy SWSmO ��h ��aC��Ep ~G'�� ><W<_ ����?N r> w<��c m<�� �� W��mm ZNQ O��`I-O'< 03 U 7 <O�� �� naa���� ozrc I am0< ��Fmg a d 56������ Q��>m omW��((77.��r! �� z�� L=��rcWz chi i��G��w��ix z< m o�uf 3tml1m0��"�� z cyi��b j zUL��'l�� $$e> Sep�� dv' mw ��Gq Gia�wm��<- <o< $ ��< zz ��- Li ��8��,'j Z m2��I��Z4pp{ mR p<��pU<O� 158<JmJ��< ����UO<S[m3 SR -MR 60R.- 66SVF��xp8 UIu Zz ��rVZ��IW < '����m����������� (��1mp����0����((U=l��O���� <~O ����YO $U=����W�� 1W ��m yyU����m<<(<'J Y1 $��-'�� a w=2 M29 ��ZO��<=��3 MaF��p<p������ IWW33J��w Or Z<0����0������(' Ff���� �Q <O$,=�� =OOm ��mN<a��N K UI #bVVWIIg .OqBr 8 aJ Z ��*wg7=r< F��-J <V O yf��m��Qm�� mL'��<<��������y-��Z������ ��az��om����tn =��F<���� O� =<���� � �� ����F��3p8 yd~< <Op������U ��r.��Fy-,IC��I�� U J��mF O��jj��m���� ��s ��1 ;�o+��a aal'y,7i�� pmWO "O��jW2��my <mSKN y����U����O 6e UUUUU"''= ��SW = �� < �� f9aN/wl��maU1N-��BY �� O ��� w ��31_z 3F- q S ] ������W�� 4��11 eOUOU'}t- ��i �� d ���� W N Om0 m8 U m < ��SwUw��O��< <��Wi��y=m������ T����NII/<IZZIi M. 1��2 ��gyWWJ IK��i17����KW< O e< i��lfo 05 mp O'L 0<8. S 4 . ? o 3VyNl W WmW aU3W�� t0.'IW=�� a<�� a < �� B F 2Wr- 3��<�� �� ��f c3 Lsl ����d 1`4T��1<IJ>nmz0 'wfd 2pZp<R<�Z_W WW~��iE <1U 1/I��ZSZ ��p K 4Zm��W r< ����=<F OW 3Z< ��UOIJ �������� m08< < W rW O IU�� U ~ ��z U'. 41 EO���� 4yl W'b��BWa m w0 rmY IW/I OO OU Op oBiF�� < WaOU 00 zF �FNO W C �� 6} m��pg ��lBK��� a q F I F cF.������a��a������b$pp3be o5 yn p w mg 5"*86-geo�W( Yz��gZ< pS nQ��mi � g0 � iWuW IF��ZO�� $<or<}vai a U����O�� a0W ��U<o<3 i�� ffiFOW<W jt V1 ����<oe< O��<����<<������W ��o��Jac��i��m$��ii5m$cii viii<tFo�� UW<�������� 1Fu2i5bbu_ g�� F3a ��tSi u< x= ������Scr<��< chi 43as a��U ���Om y`L=��iro�� <W <C ro:��<} '�� Y! 6  L L X J1 'Md �� LOVL L/Z `bmp,ON]-080 L L\uoisinipgnS jol �� wo@i4s11n0-08011\ L LOZ\ :0 o of w � 3^ 8 o12 o ��N IIs DO �� $ 8 a ;HUEiji $I S���� Q N t Z i�� i Y z�� 9 a bw \ o ll z z \ m w 3 'o S  u) \ 7 n o m 91 H m �� s (fl oU Y ` � jag pQ (OLVA3inoo NV700) V -i -V OVOa 31V15 AW2 ��y����pyyypyjjj!,! WW o o r W�� im I��FY L` m-MIIO-M!%1-Miq -Mlq-- _- MHO-I)yllJ��-MIY)- Fni QIY �� �� S8 L<, zo ��t a lb d d PIN la o yl 313 w t o P 10 GD d d n d o 3 I ---------- l II r  ----------SII I I I I am cl I I I I I w I r �� e w v) W1 I W�� g zP b�� 0 i I o �� PIN, 191 a'!I ���� �� h H 41, 1 Ld r " 9 I n' I CJ z , J �� I Ld e z MA$ z I' i i 969LY } 03tl V '3Y 'INW 'V Hd3SOr LIOIWM Omf A1DN ��1'TT����77 rf J. ��TrT (�� i�� ��T��T��7ri��T His ��Q1Q0 1��:L w Y LLQWl7 LL 111 ��I (WHI NVUO N OT -VT NO��TISIAIQ��SITITS��T ��������(I,��rIVN��TOCIDVN '2I�� 3 Ni��Id NDILN 1L1 lud N��IZII l loa 05913-YLZ L99 :x93 Oo913-YLZ l93 -11d fiY�� opl-U " y��9aEl �� -1.0 .(9M uoxd c��ddn 1"d 96Z qK9 ' N NOLLVZItlOHLf1V d0 3LVOl3(LM VOlw-u A U ti NO �� A ^ Ur z �� o ti ~ (n Z z 4 {[p����gQ7 u�� VJ simvi7nsxoo ivixamouuma " suaaxima SeIopossv i6jsaQ'o,! ����� 1 / o �u 41gGA3Y 31V0 OH o of w � 3^ 8 o12 o ��N IIs DO �� $ 8 a ;HUEiji $I S���� Q N t Z i�� i Y z�� 9 a bw \ o ll z z \ m w 3 'o S  u) \ 7 n o m 91 H m �� s (fl oU Y ` � jag pQ (OLVA3inoo NV700) V -i -V OVOa 31V15 AW2 ��y����pyyypyjjj!,! WW o o r W�� im I��FY L` m-MIIO-M!%1-Miq -Mlq-- _- MHO-I)yllJ��-MIY)- Fni QIY �� �� S8 L<, zo ��t a lb d d PIN la o yl 313 w t o P 10 GD d d n d o 3 I ---------- l II r  ----------SII I I I I am cl I I I I I w I r �� e w v) W1 I W�� g zP b�� 0 i I o �� PIN, 191 a'!I ���� �� h H 41, 1 Ld r " 9 I n' I CJ z , J �� I Ld e z MA$ z I' i i n �'I1 4�sooz l�'f 9WEwuou'umes 00 �pj.zQl� `uz�a.T�sJInJ EKE-M(19S) -A �Z41L'dA'S TSI 9E1O-ZOW90 —9d p gxmmd q�lyary �9 siEuotssajoid prenalnog uLa30 a oN 0 It I 1 usisaQ ® U01SIAipans filiadord PIRUOPOEW I--1 uosialad -�y _ L'd F11'JFI�FIFIF1fJppgFlp�a X 3i 3i 3i aa�aaa a � a a3 a: a _ seas a.Y aaaaa���� � Boa gg pp g�I g "� 22'B 2 g J E oBa$"�f����Raggraa _• g (is' .madla4 999aaaa99a9t8 • s � „�4F19"_N a���ea _�� 3 �6 z J J J J J J J J J J J I t J J J u j J J J u J J.J t j J j j d j J u ��='rE°�R=r3rRm=�Y9r==m°:=�rnF1AC�nF1��� ash. mw•L-WmF9@pR—jNad•f "KE RNNWd' WM o"s EVSE-KE09s)-d �141L'IWS 151 tPuotd LUL'a.T�S�in� - 9E10-zOL(195)-9d slom!q-v o& -purl d P.renatnog uu3o0 ul1ON 0 t t, i ` V SjEIIOiSSa30Id u�isaQ uoisini n �Zadoi quo ou S d PI P LSI uos�a�ad .P • �� -� i mE r" cB _ .� - � civ • =3 • p W LL C FO SFr, C LIPPold gwuojlsjlng quo -Wigs) -ow PJBAOlnog uv000 qljoN 0 It, I sliguo!ssojom USISOCI UOlSlAlpqnS Xlj;Ddoil pluuopouW u0sialo'l 0 LL- CV111 E A� 10 r;Ll CD .0 U- 41 A mma -3*vvu4oq@800v—jaw,f 99KE wWOI-4'u("vA —9 EI'SE-SEEO 9s) -.4 �al EPL *MS ISI UpPoll 'tut'a-usilng 9oo-ZOL0900-m !qmV od—p-I sluuOlssajoi'l PJBAOlnoEl uu000 quoM o It, I als3cl uosj3locl U01SIAipqnS Auodoij pluuopouW LL - o ca CNJ t \r\ CD V -P a tT n 717 IA rr n K 717 K CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Thomas Smith Malcolm Murphy George Delafield, Jr. REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF THURSDAY, MAY 23, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AC-,Fmnpl May 16, 2013 HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 3-28-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. July 25, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. August 2013 -No Meeting d. September 26, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. e. October 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. f. November to be determined g. December 26, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by William Wietsma, as Agent for the owner of the property located at 3122 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described as Lot 36 less the S. 50 ft. thereof and the S. 47.94 ft. of Lot 35, Gulf Stream Properties Subdivision. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove the existing outside stairway on the garage/guest quarters. b. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit an addition of 888 SF to the west side of the existing one-story, single family, Gulf Stream Bermuda style dwelling, an enclosure of 65 SF on the second story of the garage/guest quarters, the removal of the existing outside stairs and the construction of new interior stairs in the garage to the guest quarters, re- location of the existing garage door from the north side to the west side of the garage to provide an entrance off Gulf Stream Road and a new paver brick driveway off Gulf Stream Road. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM AGENDA CONTINUED RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, MARCH 28, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. Call to Order: Chairman, Scott Morgan called the Meeting to order at 8:30 a.m. Present: Chairman, Scott Morgan, Vice Chairman Amanda Jones, Board Member: Thomas Smith, Malcolm Murphy Alternate Member: George Delafield, Jr. Town Manager: William Thrasher Town Clerk: Rita Taylor Absent were: John Randolph, Esq. (with notice) Recording Secretary: Susan Cooper IL Roll Call Present and Scott Morgan Chairman Participating Thomas Smith Vice Chairman Malcolm Murphy Board Member Amanda Jones Board Member George Delafield Alternate Member Absent w/Notice Paul Lyons Board Member John Randolph Town Attorney Also Present & William Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita Taylor Town Clerk Mark Pulte Property Owner Benjamin Schreier Architect for Pulte Joe Peterson Landscape Arch. -Pulte William Wietsma Architect -MacDonald Marty Minor Town Consultant Randy Ely Town Resident III. Minutes of the Previous Meeting(s) Mr. Smith moved to accept the minutes of the Meeting of February 28, 2013 with no correction, Mr. Murphy seconded the Motion. Motion carried unanimously. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. None V. Announcements. None A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing a. March 28, 2013 @ 8:30 a.m. b. April 25, 2013 @ 8:30 a.m. c. May 23, 2013 @ 8:30 a.m. d. June 27, 2013 @ 8:30 a.m. e. July 25, 2013 @ 8:30 a.m. ARPB — Regular Meeting and Public Hearing March 28, 2013 Minutes f. August, 2013 — No meeting All stated they would be attending all meetings listed on agenda No ex parte communications prior to the public hearing. VL PUBLIC HEARING. Ms. Taylor swore in all who planned to speak at public hearing. Those sworn in: Mark Pulte, Property Owner; Benjamin Schreier, Architect for Mr. Pulte, Joe Peterson, Landscape Architect for Mr. Pulte. William Wietsma, Architect for property owner Ralph MacDonald, Paul Engle, Surveyor for Mr. MacDonald, Mr. Becker, Engineer for Mr. MacDonald. Marty Minor, Town Consultant and Town Resident Randy Ely A. Applications for Development Approval. 1. Application submitted for construction to property of owned by Mark T. Pulte located at 3211 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, FL. Legal description of North 4.5 ft. of Lot 3 and the S 108 ft. of Lot 4, Gulf Stream Ocean Tracts in Gulf Stream, Florida. a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove existing structures. Mr. Benjamin Schreier, Architect for Mr. Pulte requested demolition of existing structures as well as approval of the construction of a 10,408 square foot home on the site. Mr. Schreier stated that their intent was to clear the site and begin construction of the new home immediately rather than waiting for the permit for the new home to be issued before demolition occurs. • Thomas Smith moved to approve the demolition permit to remove the existing structures. Amanda Jones seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to prepare for new landscape materials and to adjust the grade to accommodate the new structures and improvements. Presentation by Joe Peterson, Landscape Architect for Mr. Pulte demonstrating via sketches, the proposed landscape to include 220 trees along Al including placement of the cabbage palms, coconut palms and existing Australian Pines. The existing sea grapes will be re -located along the existing driveway to form a canopy as you drive into the site. Along the front of the property the sea grapes will be removed and put into a staging area in order to raise the grade. The sea grapes will then be re -planted at the conclusion of the landscape project. • Thomas Smith made a motion to approve the Land Clearing Permit to prepare for new landscape materials and to adjust the grade to accommodate the new structures and improvements. Amanda Jones seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. ARPB — Regular Meeting and Public Hearing March 28, 2013 Minutes c. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to install entry gate and piers and supplement existing landscaping within the corridor. • Thomas Smith further moved to approve the NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to install entry gate and piers and supplement existing landscaping within the corridor. Malcolm Murphy seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. d. VARIANCE to permit a terra cotta slate style roof to be installed on the proposed Georgian style home. Upon Mr. Morgan's request for explanation of the new home, Mr. Schreier stated they are proposing a 10,408 square foot Georgian style home with a dark green shutters and terra cotta colored slate roof. Variance was requested as town code calls for terra cotta roofs on Mediterranean -style structures, and either a gray slate or "slate -like" or white thru and thru concrete flat tile roof for the Georgian style homes. Presentation by Mr. Schreier with sketches of the home, actual samples of proposed roofing tiles as well as a choice of gray slate tiles as suggested in the Town Code. Discussion was had as to roofing materials. Mr. Schreier argued that the beachfront homes in Gulf Stream are unique and individual in style in contrast to the white on white Bermuda -style in the more general areas of the town. Mr. Schreier also stated that the home will be surrounded by a variety of palm trees and the roof of the home will in no way be visible from the road. Mr. Morgan suggested the roof be discussed with the Town Commission. Mr. Pulte advised that his "alternate choice" was the darker gray "slate -like" tile recommended in the Code, as the lighter gray tile would fade to almost white from the Florida sun within a very short time. Mr. Thrasher advised "Section 70.238—Roofs. Flat, white through and through, smooth and gray slate tile may be permitted on predominantly Georgian or British -colonial influences. Flat, gray through and through, uncoated tile or slate -like tile may be permitted at the discretion of the Architectural Review and Planning Board and Town Commission thru level 3 review process. ...Section D — Prohibited. Tiles other than white flat untextured tiles or grey slate tiles." Ms. Jones felt the lighter tile would be more appropriate. • Thomas Smith further moved to recommend DENIAL of a VARIANCE to permit a terra cotta slate style roof to be installed on the proposed Georgian style home based on the Tmdings that not all of the 8 standards to allow for variance have been met. Amanda Jones seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. ARPB — Regular Meeting and Public Hearing March 28, 2013 Minutes e. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a 10,408 square foot partial 2 -story, single family Georgian style dwelling with a 4 car garage and swimming pool. • Thomas Smith moved to recommend Approval of a LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction based on the findings that the proposed construction of a 10,408 square foot partial 2 -story, single family Georgian style dwelling with a 4 car garage and swimming pool meet minimum intent of the design manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: a) electrical service lines shall be buried; b) any minor modifications of the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for approval prior to the commencement of landscaping; c) Wall and fences shall be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 8 feet including any lighting fixtures that might be attached; d) all chain link fences will be screened from neighbor's view; e) the landscape plan will protect existing Australian pine trees and provide a 13' clear zone where possible for the planting of Australian pine trees and f) to change the proposed terra cotta roof to that of the town code, to wit: the gray -slate -like tile. Amanda Jones seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. Ms. Taylor informed Mr. Pulte and Mr. Schreier that their next hearing will be at 9:00 a.m. on Friday, April 12, 2013. 2. Application submitted by William Wietsma as agent for Ralph MacDonald, owner of property at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida legally described in metes and bounds as Lots 1, 1-A and 2, McLouth Subdivision, Gulf Stream Florida. a. SUBDIVISION to divide one, 4.733 acre parcel of land into 3 lots. Mr. Wietsma presented proposal to subdivide nearly 5 acres into 3 lots. Essentially Lot A would be 40,000 square feet, Middle lot would be 80,000 square feet preserving the house and the third lot about 80,000 square feet. They are proposing to keep the existing grading, existing landscaping and preserving the house in the middle. Theye are not changing the character and structure of the neighborhood. The private yacht basin will be part of the deed to property A. A buffer of landscaping will be provided to eliminate line of sight from the water and road. Mr. Morgan expressed concern with the driveway access from Al and its visibility from the road. His concern is that the driveway will require removal of a considerable amount of foliage from the property south and north of the driveway. Mr. Wietsma stated that the access will remain where it is now and therefore the foliage will not need to be removed as the same cut for the drive will remain intact, the entrance will remain the same, it will just be enhanced. E, ARPB — Regular Meeting and Public Hearing March 28, 2013 Minutes Mr. Wietsma advised that all the neighbors had been notified and polled, the only letter received was from Mr. Ganger stating that it is his hope that the lush foliage at the northern end of the property be retained as a part of the condition of approval for subdivision. Mr. Wietsma stated that it is their intent to retain that area in its current condition. Mr. Smith questioned the chance that the DOT would disallow future entrance onto North Road from AlA to Lot C. Mr. Wietsma advised that there was not a chance due to the location of the curve. Mr. Morgan stated we all like to see the old properties remain the same and that he liked the idea of this proposal. Malcohn Murphy moved for APPROVAL of a SUBDIVISION at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida and to divide one, 4.733 acre parcel of land into 3 lots. George Delafield seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. b. DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove an existing driveway, shed and garage. • Malcohn Murphy further moved for APPROVAL of a DEMOLITION PERMIT to remove an existing driveway, shed and garage at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida and to divide one, 4.733 acre parcel of land into 3 lots. George Delafield secondd the motion. Motion unanimously carried. c. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to remove existing driveway from proposed Lot "C". Malcohn Murphy moved for APPROVAL of a NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to remove existing driveway from proposed Lot "C" at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida. George Delafield seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. Discussion was had regarding the exact request of the removal of the driveway and while possibly retaining the curb cut for an option of keeping it to feed proposed Lot "C" at a later date. Malcolm Murphy moved to RESCIND his prior motion to Approve. George Delafield seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. Malcohn Murphy then moved for APPROVAL of a NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT including the authority to remove existing driveway from proposed Lot "C" and retaining the curb cut as shown on sketch A-01 . George Delafield seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. ARPB — Regular Meeting and Public Hearing March 28, 2013 Minutes d. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the division of one parcel of land containing 4.733 acres into 3 lots with the existing structures on proposed Lot `B" to remain. • Malcohn Murphy further moved for APPROVAL of a LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the division of one parcel of land containing 4.733 acres into 3 lots with the existing structures on proposed Lot `B" to remain at 1410 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream Florida and to divide one, 4.733 acre parcel of land into 3 lots with the condition that the lot and foliage on the West side of AlA and the North side of the property be retained. George Delafield seconded the motion. Motion unanimously carried. VII. Items by Staff None VIII. Items by Board Members None IX. Public: None X. Adiournment At 9:35 a.m. Mr. Morgan adjourned the meeting of the Architectural Review and Planning Board. Susan Cooper Recording Secretary 6 TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-11 Owner: Charles L. White, III Address: 3122 North Ocean Blvd Agent: William Wietsma, Wm. Wietsma Arch. Proposed Improvement: Addition and renovation to existing one-story Gulf Stream Bermuda style dwelling Approvals Requested: Demolition Permit: To remove the existing outside stairway on the garage/guest quarters Level II Architectural/Site Plan: To permit an addition of 888 SF to the west side of the existing one-story, single family, Gulf Stream Bermuda style dwelling, an enclosure of 65 SF on the second story of the garage/guest quarters, the removal of the existing outside stairs and the construction of new interior stairs in the garage to the guest quarters, re- location of the existing garage door from the north side to the west side of the garage to provide an entrance off Gulf Stream Road and a new paver brick driveway off Gulf Stream Road. Gross Lot size: 27,927 SF Effective Lot Area: 27,927 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 5,500 SF Allowable: 8,500 SF Zoning District: RS -O Height: 12' 7" (roof height <_ 20' Preferred) Finished Floor: 18.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Motion to approve demolition permit to remove existing outside stairway. Motion to recommend approval Level II Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed addition of 888 SF to the west side of the existing one-story, single family, Gulf Stream Bermuda style dwelling, an enclosure of 65 SF on the second story of the garage/guest quarters, the removal of the existing outside stairs and the construction of an interior stairs in the garage to the guest quarters, re -location of the existing garage door from the east side to the west side of the garage to provide an entrance off Gulf Stream Road and a new paver brick driveway off Gulf Stream Road meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-11 ARPB May 23,2013; ARPB Date: May 23, 2013 Action: Demolition Permit Approved as requested. (4-0) Page 2 Level II Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as requested and recommended by staff. (4-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM -0. RECEIVED APR 15 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FI - APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information PART It. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File # LA -1. Project/Owner Name: I.A.2. Project Address: ;-,51 /?.'L �j p �}� DC►t N t�LV a t-�t �� p t --FG SS 't}}� sc�31'i•E � I`f. '[! le1�Ow, ,A-foj b -t�'� I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: Sck-TiA 41ter- c:;)w I-oT , �,c.l ,rte , , ���,eaT,q S A l l V 1 S1 Di�1 Gv= C +�c�S b S i N Tii ttivi ! o `F C4_) -L1_ , PLO1e_e>)aV) JN1 G -T o TN's e -re e6e-V iA Tii1� OfflCre OF THe GLr gI 4 of 'ITi'C U r -W_1 T --CUW-i- t 4.4NU )F01-- Vin I.A.4. Project Descri tion (describe in detail, includin # of stories e.) T . < t) s I► u� X _'I�lue sultTt s? : �� SPL �n � f iQ � ' �c Su iTE extrc G U t NTr"- ua S -t- t9-1(2 r-�si� } _ I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: [� . Architectural Style: ( y (,F 1.A.6. Check all that apply: [Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) W' Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: 9 A(U Type of Foundation: 'e'HN 4-CLAJ B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address:_ 3122 f4OIRTIA 1.B.2. Owner Phone Number: AQ -r LI 0 Voo -d Fax: 1.B.3. Owner Siqnature: _O I/ C. Agent Information I.C.1. I.C.2. I.C.3. 1.C.4 Agent Name and Firm Name: VniU-0pwn V\A T&WIA1 V\)1LU\PA- n wl A A)QL1-AI-vk0 Agent Address: '2-,,1 00 V.W. 12:3'Z 2 -7 �( Agent Phone Numb r: (o)ayJ-. - 2,. Agept Signature: ) Pfe-App Dat o2' App Date. Com Date: Decision: 4942) cell_ 5(o I -44 h M_4LP Fax 7>7 y26/)Dfficial Use Only A PB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the a question number for each response. ppropriate and complete A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? Yes ❑ No Explain.,&D- 101J. uL)(tLA C Ga "-tl k) -u Ic Io C N ` •� w � t' P �'`�rc I u 'Pi�.T - c7 t f U �.l III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objective Comprehensive Plan? ,Yes ❑ No s and policies of the Explain. {,\mow , b171fi I O tJ S)+ j - 1 C 11f1�- L)S (G 6�G T f EYP VvE III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? -gym 1pntk4 III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage q4 SI-j-ir, IIE�Tg iJ Z p b. Sanitary Sewer ��� t (, 5� �_M d) -A 4ORDIP C. Potable Water 01- rat , d. Irrigation Water hi G-V-� e. Electricity O LC', I>t~� e. -f �xl5-TI L2 g. Gasf. Telephone_ /mac F X1 STt f-1 ) g_ t-..3i.� � h. Cable Television nf;Y t-,Iq C /'r -.i, K(M III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) ��S rS_�N.-�aDr�rclurl )E ckw Nyev 'To s-1 ►�S ►'D�>J �� \S�I1J PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project 'olve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the projectinvolvethe demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existin vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes ` ." (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) / IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? KYes � No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the prFo 't at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 r�yy or Uulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV -H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, ZoningCode text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or an combination thereof, lease describe the need and justification for the request, PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for al/ applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere the other materials submitted with the application. rrn or on any of N Ye X ofA h, >� n A4 P,,VL s-r)N� w rte} Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/0/00 Page 7 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I e I m I I I I � 3 N Iw k� 0 ,IIIII/IIIIIIIIIII,:-' �I, I �II/IIIII/IIII II�I�I�I�II�I�I�III�I�II�I�!{iII�II�I�II�I�II�III�'II�I III/IIIIIIIIIIIII;CIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII whk I I II II II II ----------- ----- -4-11--1 -14-- ------- I II IIS II II � I II Ilg�ll II ��� I II Ilrell II D 4'-0' WIDE I I I I m l l I IIEV .L.1 I II II II II I II II I� _ _ IS - -I LL—jI I I I - I I IWWU I - , I AI D 1 W I I - I I I I I I I I I I I 3• -Ir e•-IIm I I L---------------------------------------- II NO n I I I I � I I 11 �r I A II el I r ------------- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I� N L D m mN £ap R m I � o I I I z � E I --J � I r 1 I i 1 o , 1 r �il i 1 III•. _.s / of / 0 ,IIIII/IIIIIIIIIII,:-' �I, I �II/IIIII/IIII II�I�I�I�II�I�I�III�I�II�I�!{iII�II�I�II�I�II�III�'II�I III/IIIIIIIIIIIII;CIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII whk I I II II II II ----------- ----- -4-11--1 -14-- ------- I II IIS II II � I II Ilg�ll II ��� I II Ilrell II D 4'-0' WIDE I I I I m l l I IIEV .L.1 I II II II II I II II I� _ _ IS - -I LL—jI I I I - I I IWWU I - , I AI D 1 W I I - I I I I I I I I I I I 3• -Ir e•-IIm I I L---------------------------------------- II NO n I I I I � I I 11 �r I A II el I r ------------- I I I I I I I I I I I I I IB' PEEP I I I I I _J L N L D m mN £ap R m I � o I I I z � E I --J � I r 1 I i IB' PEEP I I I I I _J L WHITE RESIDENCE WILLIAM WIETSMA Architect, PA W ®Florida License Number AR -0014766 31ZZ NORTH OCEAN BLVD. O 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, Florida 33483 N GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 L I � o I I I z � E I --J � I r 1 I i o WHITE RESIDENCE WILLIAM WIETSMA Architect, PA W ®Florida License Number AR -0014766 31ZZ NORTH OCEAN BLVD. O 1030 Basin Drive, Delray Beach, Florida 33483 N GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Office (561) 274-4863 Fax (561) 266-5915 m � \ §� �K ; 2 �■ � k! E mom= MEMO §§ � )§ )7 2 3; 9 6 - ;2 2§2� z �/ �k } / � | � §2§ � � ----� _ §`®�} ---- 222lm ■! , = (k o § BM �§§ ] 0 -!m o 2%. � rn _�/ -- rE t � r� 2 Eg A � WHITE RESIDENCE WILLIAM WIETSMA Ambitect PA 3]22 NORTH OCEAN BLVD. �oma��neKum�:*k�o��6 m30 Basin ow_, Delray Beach, Florida 483 GULF STREAM, FLORIDA� �Of f ie (5S) 274-4863 Fax mA> 266-5915 Page 1 of 2 FL0903<1 052 Roundary Survev SURVEY # FL0903.1052 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3122 N OCEAN BOULEVARD DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 LEGAL DESCRIPTION: ^--- Lot 36, less the South 50 Peet thereof, and the South 47.94 Peet of Lot 35, GULF STREAM PROPERTIES, a subdivision of lands In the Town of Gulf Stream, Florldo, according to the plat thereof on file and of record In the office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court In and for Palm Beach County, Florida, In Plat Book 18 at Page 27. ,R.M. Date: 09/30/82 n Work: 3/23/2009Completed: 3/24/2009 15. LU FND PK NAI -1 Cof Q oo m LLJ r~-- U m 0 1.3 LS: 7337 �:'S'"CTAFL N. CERTIFIED TCS: _ _ CHARLES WHITE; SUNBELT TITLE AGENCY; FIRST AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY; ; GRAVEL ,. { For Surveyors Notes and LegeR-T,`-seerp ._2 -- /RN55°00'54"W IB26E-G t'D, {( . . Assumed; 2F;6 -38' D, { FND IR 112" 5�C a { Ci-) f_ E;a "12 5TORYBLDG. - AREA A/C(2) jq, TAI , tt - -cu {� O - POOL POOL I c } ._„ DECK j s.� CONC PORCH FENCExFci ` d ' { O { o d `r' { L-- - —_ — - 50 0 25 50 GRAPHIC SCALE (In Feet) 1 inch = 50' ft, r-"734 ss. i t D/w t i L. P. ._ r � F G �' ^ r �Y aPOLE ;B WALL -/.. "'7qi� CONG 5fi`' m 1\18700723"V✓ 2h7.0 C.P.P { { { ---------------------- I hereby 15 a true ar�ccsurvey mmy1�i�efR3 vnand the minial 5tandard5 set Board Ot L,�id Survey472,02k& � faled <Adm rni5te. Furth r, this dSigned aPCu►`h5ect Florida 5 apter [G-1 State of 1MN 7 t of the hereon representation of a Ofd survey meets by the Florida 5uant to 5ection I G- 17-G Florida t is electronically 2.027 of the )025 of the Florida .w,& Mapp,• Lc -^vee No. 65 7) Project: Addition to White Residence 3122 North Ocean Blvd, Town of Gulf Stream, FL Architect: William Wietsma Architect, PA Photos of Existing Residence ®RECEiVE®, APR 15 2013 Town of Gulfstream, Ft Existing Photos Key Plan (not to scale) A) Southwest View of Existing Main Residence and Detached Garage/ Guest Suite B) Southeast View of Existing Main Residence Project: Addition to White Residence 3122 North Ocean Blvd, Town of Gulf Stream, FL Architect: William Wietsma Architect, PA C) North View of Existing Detached Garage/Guest Suite D) East View of Existing Main Residence E) West View of Existing Main Residence ® RECEIVED I APR 15 2013 %wn of Gulfstream, F! CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy George Delafield, Jr. REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF THURSDAY, JULY 25, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA July 18, 2013 BY THE ARCHITECTURAL STREAM, FLORIDA ON TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 5-25-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. August 2013 -No Meeting b. September 26, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. October 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. November to be determined e. December 26, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Richard Jones, as Agent for Harbor View Estates LLC, the owners of property located at 1224 N. Ocean Blvd, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat 2. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit the installation of landscaping and the easterly portions of privacy walls within the North Oceana Boulevard Overlay District. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of an 8,726 square foot, partial two-story, Colonial West Indies single family dwelling with 3 car attached garage, pool and cabana. VII. Items by Staff and Attorney. A. Proposed amendments to the Town's Zoning Code, including Design Guidelines. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. AGENDA CONTINUED IFAXCover Sheet TO: Tom Laudani Phone: Fax Phone: REMARKS: 272-8941 Date: 7-24-13 Number of pages including cover sheet.- FROM: heet: FROM: Rita Taylor Phone: 561-276-5116 Fax Phone: 561-737-0] 88 o As Requested ❑ Urgent ❑ FYI ❑ For Your Review o Reply ASAP See attached. Originals to Follow by Mail_ Yes CC: Fax Phone: No P91JOD JOJJ3 03 Jasn Aq pal, ,JJa-L :f11 pJeMJOj Xej : jj dAes xogl1eA :SW puss 6ullleM :SM £dnoig :£9 Ilej :yj jjodaa :da aloulaJ pallod :2fd OA103al IsOH :NH ulals/Ls1sq paleululJal :Sl palalduloD :d:) lul3d xoglleW :dW leJOl pallod :Id puas IsOH :SH Fax Phone: 272-8941 -x188 :suollelnadggy OOOVUD SHI D3 L I S/S LV:00:00 £L0Z-VZ-L0'w'e917:8b:01 LV68ZLZL95 SLE L00 sllnsaa I adAi qorl apovy I auI I I sa6ed uolleJna IaullilJezS I uollelS aloulaa I qor 'oN S : PBUTA}uoD sa6ed lelol S : pauue:)S s96ed leloi L"CoverSheet Date: 7-24-13 IN,rnbm orpages including cover sheet: -S— TO: Tun Inudaol LF2XP40ne. Phone: -5116 Fax Phone: 272-8941 -x188 REIT ARKS: o As Requested n Urgent o FYI ❑ For Your Review o Reply ASAP See attacbed, Originals to Follow by Mail: Yes No CC: Fax Phone: „,Lx„S•8 : azis }uawmod (molaq sjiejap pue aldwes pa:)npaa) pawaiPoD : }uawmop siyl xej L aLueN le30l 88LOL£LOS L (11 le)ol TXalJapeaHllLusueJl W'eso: 0s:0L £LOZ-VZ-LO awll/aled jaodaH uoissmsueji IFAXCovet Sheet TO: Tom Laudani Phone: Fax Phone: 272-8941 Date: 7-23-13 Number of pages including cover sheet. FROM: Rita Taylor, Town Clerk Phone: 561-276-5116 Fax Phone: 561-737-0188 3 IREMARKS: ❑ As Requested ❑ Urgent ❑ FYI ❑ For Your Review ❑ Reply ASAP I received the enclosed letter from Mr. 11organ this morning. He will not be present for the meeting on Thrusday. I will be presenting this as a part of the record at the meeting. Jriginals to Follow by Mail_ Yes CC: Fax Phone. No X i Transmission Report Date/Time 07-23-2013 03:45:03 p.m. Transmit Header Text Local ID 1 5617370188 Local Name 1 Fax This document: Confirmed (reduced sample and details below) Document size : 8.5 "x11 " FAXCover Sheet Date: 7-23-13 Number ofp.ge. including cover sheet 3 TO: LPhone: Tom Laudani lor, Town Clerk Phone: ]-276-5116 Fax Phone: 272_8941 1-737-0188 LARKS: o As Requested ❑ Urgent ❑ FYI ❑ Far Your Review ❑ RrpIy ASAP I received the enclosed letter from Mr. Morgan this morning. He will not be present for the meeting on Thrusday. I will be presenting this as a part of the record at the meeting. Originals to Follow by Mail: Yes No Y j CC: fFax Ph one: Total Pages Scanned : 3 Total Pages Confirmed : 3 No. Job I Remote Station I Start Time I Duration Pages Line Mode I Job Type Results 001 1305 15612728941 03:44:08 p.m. 07-23-2013 00:00:28 3/3 11 JEC IHS ICP24000 Abbreviations: HS: Host send PL: Polled local MP: Mailbox print CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct Transmission Report Date/Time 07-23-2013 04:23:26 p.m. Transmit Header Text Local ID 1 5617370188 Local Name 1 Fax This document: Failed (reduced sample and details below) Document size : 8.5 "x11 " IF"Cover Sheet Date: 7-23-13 Number ofpages including cover sheet: 3 TO: +FROM: IRichard Jones Rita Taylor, Town Clerk Phone: Phone: 561 -276 -SJ J 6 Fax Phone: 274-9196 Fax Phone: 56]-737-0788 REMARKS: o As Requested o Urgent ❑ FYI ❑ For Your Review o Reply ASAP I received the enclosed letter from Mr. Morgan this morning. He will not be present for the meeting on Thursday. I will be presenting this as a part of the record at the meeting. Originals to Follow by Mail: Yes No x CC: Fox Phone: Total Pages Scanned : 3 Total Pages Confirmed : 0 No. Jo I Remote Station Start Time IDuration Pages Line Mode Job Type Results 001 30 12749196 03:46:05 p.m. 07-23-2013 00:00:00 0/3 1 -- IHS I FA Abbreviations: HS: Hostsend PL: Polled local MP: Mallboxprint CP: Completed TS: Terminated by system HR: Host receive PR: Polled remote RP: Report FA: Fall G3: Group 3 WS: Waiting send MS: Mailbox save FF: Fax Forward TU: Terminated by user EC: Error Correct 1FAXCover Sheet TO: Richard Jones Date: 7-23-13 Number of pages including cover sheet: 3 FROM: Rita Taylor, Town Clerk Phone: Phone: 561-276-5116 Fax Phone: 274-9196 Fax Phone: 561-737-0188 (REMARKS: ❑ As Requested ❑ Urgent ❑ FYI ❑ For Your Review ❑ Reply ASAP I received the enclosed letter from Mr. Morgan this morning. He will not be present for the meeting on Thursday. I will be presenting this as a part of the record at the meeting. Driginals to Follow by Mail: Yes CC: Fax Phone: No x L kn w C� Of W SW L V U) W 0 U � �-d N $g❑ u z z � ¢ u ❑ O ❑w ¢.6 cP ¢ i QQ EE i El�, p 0 O QQ UUU N � o w p o p w, z U O uUZI U p LL ❑ o wUp w ° ¢ a m ❑ ❑ N g g ' n- 0 w w F a oazw w w I ❑ o a,o ❑ _Z e ¢a ❑ a ¢u F 3 az w� F o o zi �wi w _i 2w - o u LL �a� 3 og N m< W W q jQm ? 'Z p z Q Z Z F<F O QWm ❑ %o o❑ T. ozo 20 zZiww �� ❑ a p ¢ w �' g O u OZgo �' zO0 U W W c fa0i Nw ¢ ¢ � i`. t.; a� Z Umfl ¢ F -N U Fa < O<i ¢ U o i u 10 FS HI o $ �Y g� 8 g3 ¢ $ 0 o o� dos= o w L o o, csi o aw joz f� oQ z WO o Zr w �5" o .N F eU � p o- �oc¢ii uwz o oho Na ww S o i a a.-,6Nk x °mow❑ �W�saW, W ❑ oQw ara z� z< LL o o �N , oaa�rc w '¢a �o�u >� g❑ u� aa�° mz wF� 3a m w$ w ao¢ ❑ oawm o w0. ow erc NW z o <�< ❑W F ^"Z. ° 3� Sa a & u i Z. o rcww -i eoo wi Z ow .F�w ww ❑ ❑ro ~� _� �a r o� o�o� ii w �wz1 j r. za- .-m 20 wp F. ? -Z' W O zr<m m �u Wym �� w<❑ 4 ow N z> m i� woWi o we omwu;❑ 4�^W o rc .0 i i a^ Jkw �i � ow"� a� ¢o w �¢ m U= O N ¢O ¢F ¢ r ¢2 w 1 -ow o z $ ou o ow oo�0 iaw~ o <9 'z ix m e0.�4 w 1. F. v ow v ga ❑� , ~02 m0 oxg b yWW F -. Q-¢ ¢JFK Z O° Za O �� O(7 O Um Ow¢� p> U j OQOn g °K p. UW. =w OZ U w UFtc d❑ UW ap w o p�p� o z x¢ rW �i�¢ �w r i o?x3 s TUF $Su- '$'w $ �- ^� 80 ❑x 'mug° 0 1O No 0 3❑c of o� oo `oma oo N� oN o i W 2 W F U Al O v O N U y� mw tea± W m0 UW �O Y UV�NF Pe W�3 0 _2I -. n� wy 1F€ �y¢o� °u oW dor H oP wr; u'1 X14 p Jo 0 y Fa Sf w m° � �� ���w� Z ❑ g o. o wo k o 0 2 at" �° am az o ip❑E$ i WW Gm ¢lo` o�QQ"� o o W U< ° UL 412 F¢ t_O U N5~ ~~ zWg� 1 a� Zo °wOwo 42<W w0 a Is _z ugh ^ pQ 0o o yF wx5 cF a riw �a a¢.au <m ¢om w� Fw nzLL _rcaw4°i of m w z- 5' r 3°0 ���`g q❑ awes > o W w ¢w x o _; Opo m rcs mW JU oz JU 30 �xi 3 w�¢ 5 LLgamd o � ❑ �m a� u �w pip Z 3 ¢m p ° w'S OFw �0 fzwuari�3 !i oho 0 b s u' -0 °O= ZwF zf <� U p j O Z❑ a2 Z mwK ¢H O<ja OZ Of -W+m� j0 waQQZ Fap-m ww �¢ p - Z b 6¢ Z w 0 aoo w wo$ wo-Q ww xo -10 oqg 90 zom'oo om a n; t,.: 10 ai !0 1- Z rcarc ¢off o�fgi you f �� ��u� �i xa 3� mem u� oLLswi=m mya rc � '-Z ow oa f aag a F wu-.0 H. A uW,>;!-2= i ozo< .° .Y 0-- � W a� m x j3 y �w �o ,' w400 �s 101, 1 02z °� 00 UwFOF V� U° ip0 Vy¢r Ur OW2N�� 700 �� �F¢ �=❑oa oa ro ioow i � fw� � N¢ eu mini w� w �o uua w o F� o'a< �0 o°o 6.. o.i ow on G��a 0 us< 'du z w 0 rn W lY LL it � o 00 Z m (7 0 w LY w J Y Z a z z 1 w ELH 0 W W CL OJ 0 z W Q ❑ D w U) x O �J U o Z W N �m x � U Y x Y W � W m ,n w La O W 9 O LL lY U7 m 0 0 O m a ~ 0 £8h££ ti I3 `LU J70 # HA_H��,d38 J�V2I I3Q irn m ne st+ Q Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W Q■■ b Wg A'-- el73WH3NLS3IlQrlbZZl o�®�Rg " God o J Y QQIH ❑> � � S u 4❑ a r- N > z U 00 L kn w C� Of W SW L V U) W 0 U � �-d N $g❑ u z z � ¢ u ❑ O ❑w ¢.6 cP ¢ i QQ EE i El�, p 0 O QQ UUU N � o w p o p w, z U O uUZI U p LL ❑ o wUp w ° ¢ a m ❑ ❑ N g g ' n- 0 w w F a oazw w w I ❑ o a,o ❑ _Z e ¢a ❑ a ¢u F 3 az w� F o o zi �wi w _i 2w - o u LL �a� 3 og N m< W W q jQm ? 'Z p z Q Z Z F<F O QWm ❑ %o o❑ T. ozo 20 zZiww �� ❑ a p ¢ w �' g O u OZgo �' zO0 U W W c fa0i Nw ¢ ¢ � i`. t.; a� Z Umfl ¢ F -N U Fa < O<i ¢ U o i u 10 FS HI o $ �Y g� 8 g3 ¢ $ 0 o o� dos= o w L o o, csi o aw joz f� oQ z WO o Zr w �5" o .N F eU � p o- �oc¢ii uwz o oho Na ww S o i a a.-,6Nk x °mow❑ �W�saW, W ❑ oQw ara z� z< LL o o �N , oaa�rc w '¢a �o�u >� g❑ u� aa�° mz wF� 3a m w$ w ao¢ ❑ oawm o w0. ow erc NW z o <�< ❑W F ^"Z. ° 3� Sa a & u i Z. o rcww -i eoo wi Z ow .F�w ww ❑ ❑ro ~� _� �a r o� o�o� ii w �wz1 j r. za- .-m 20 wp F. ? -Z' W O zr<m m �u Wym �� w<❑ 4 ow N z> m i� woWi o we omwu;❑ 4�^W o rc .0 i i a^ Jkw �i � ow"� a� ¢o w �¢ m U= O N ¢O ¢F ¢ r ¢2 w 1 -ow o z $ ou o ow oo�0 iaw~ o <9 'z ix m e0.�4 w 1. F. v ow v ga ❑� , ~02 m0 oxg b yWW F -. Q-¢ ¢JFK Z O° Za O �� O(7 O Um Ow¢� p> U j OQOn g °K p. UW. =w OZ U w UFtc d❑ UW ap w o p�p� o z x¢ rW �i�¢ �w r i o?x3 s TUF $Su- '$'w $ �- ^� 80 ❑x 'mug° 0 1O No 0 3❑c of o� oo `oma oo N� oN o i W 2 W F U Al O v O N U y� mw tea± W m0 UW �O Y UV�NF Pe W�3 0 _2I -. n� wy 1F€ �y¢o� °u oW dor H oP wr; u'1 X14 p Jo 0 y Fa Sf w m° � �� ���w� Z ❑ g o. o wo k o 0 2 at" �° am az o ip❑E$ i WW Gm ¢lo` o�QQ"� o o W U< ° UL 412 F¢ t_O U N5~ ~~ zWg� 1 a� Zo °wOwo 42<W w0 a Is _z ugh ^ pQ 0o o yF wx5 cF a riw �a a¢.au <m ¢om w� Fw nzLL _rcaw4°i of m w z- 5' r 3°0 ���`g q❑ awes > o W w ¢w x o _; Opo m rcs mW JU oz JU 30 �xi 3 w�¢ 5 LLgamd o � ❑ �m a� u �w pip Z 3 ¢m p ° w'S OFw �0 fzwuari�3 !i oho 0 b s u' -0 °O= ZwF zf <� U p j O Z❑ a2 Z mwK ¢H O<ja OZ Of -W+m� j0 waQQZ Fap-m ww �¢ p - Z b 6¢ Z w 0 aoo w wo$ wo-Q ww xo -10 oqg 90 zom'oo om a n; t,.: 10 ai !0 1- Z rcarc ¢off o�fgi you f �� ��u� �i xa 3� mem u� oLLswi=m mya rc � '-Z ow oa f aag a F wu-.0 H. A uW,>;!-2= i ozo< .° .Y 0-- � W a� m x j3 y �w �o ,' w400 �s 101, 1 02z °� 00 UwFOF V� U° ip0 Vy¢r Ur OW2N�� 700 �� �F¢ �=❑oa oa ro ioow i � fw� � N¢ eu mini w� w �o uua w o F� o'a< �0 o°o 6.. o.i ow on G��a 0 us< 'du z w 0 rn W lY LL it � o 00 Z m (7 0 w LY w J Y Z a z z 1 w ELH 0 W W CL OJ 0 z W Q ❑ D w U) x O �J U o Z W N �m x � U Y x Y W � W m ,n w La O W 9 O LL lY U7 m 0 0 O m a ~ 3:vW(" Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W H wLM)- OJQF—w D Ta m Q z J Y �= UN 050 F- U m 00 W Z (7 U 2 O in m W a W Z O j 0 W (ii rn 0 U) 0z g 0 go) ❑ a w z W w 0 0 O Z J w a (07 } F U m w W O w N Ir W 0.0 Vw W Z2 V �a 74 U z W LO =Z) v U W M M W Q O 6 O Q w L Q r p Z D~Z c gU)0 m 0cr O �-1 Z W m a- J F- W o W L 0 W 3:vW(" Z Z>MY (.9OJaN u-W V Fn � W Z wLM)- OJQF—w W Ta m Q z J wWr0a- Z Q EL J U ap W W UN 050 F- Z W J V W N O d.W,' U�.tOz W M Q m U)M W _i 0 N W =Z) 3 2f d. Q Z = i 0 N W U wQwFYZ20 of LLJN JLL 2 W C,6OUQF- U R O Cl) O_ (M7 CP of � 0 N W W — 1� � J w C� W J caLO O H QZ O tY' LLI w Wm a COz>-W OD LU �JF- W 0 �% � o g �817�� HQMO ` HII, Av Ilt1, H.Lb HN S8 81 l e b0 [ # HH S �� 4 a a Ef W Q+, ca c c L W N C5 W 4Y Q. L. "M WVAHIS JIM9 'Q QS ORD bZZi -j- SHIVISH NH s a �% �% x r $ a`. < i - z z o S LO ��ooa Do�� w a _ -0 Ef W Q+, ca c l �� L W N C5 W z o 3 pa",*an 'I. �:DFa'IL T H �:5`4a -wvr s pat --z O t� Q-�I�H Z:)I�I g Q ■ ■ cy � x,� ® £817££ dQRO'13 `HDd98 Ad2C13Q bol# af d FIN 98 Si3Qlifl8 3UISVHS a teP..m a v OO ■ ■ m i `a. $ " k` o C �-^^ z a' O a "Id WVMUS . TID 'QAlEl WFIDO N bZZI a S91VISFI -dAOfl2IdH N3C[CIIH o ? V• w U 0 60 0 cd a O O w ,-O O v N Vl a , e LU ai o 0 60 0 cd a O O w ,-O O v N Vl a , e L a 0 U 0 oo W -1 E RMZ d d N � N o a 0 U 0 oo W -1 u�u vauoou�rv� �oru�.ra.n�ov Amur uavn�.o �v urru�rvu� rv�u.o.� »>oon> >..i i.runa.n o�.�u�i vnn nou.� nnv na + . rv��nava� u�_. uan or u�. our u»nuuoa�o �a nvry .vu.a vnoumr au �n�.��u �.ry ra »>ni �u lovo un u�i�oa»o . ry �an�ro ..v u�i vauoou�nr �o.u��lrn�ov �urvu. uovn��o na crcc Maio. vnau� O � an'IL Z,>pa.L T H �::is PET t.,z0-r Q-�I�H �I�I „ ■ ■ u £84££ VaINO `HOt Hg 98 bOl# 3f1N�FI .Lb AV H3NN S81 N � ^ g v a oLn � ua S w ® S-dHo'IIf]H flQISVHS ® '"L3 YWHILLS d'IfIJ 'QA'Ifl NVHDO 'N bZZ l -1- ■ ■ ¢ m a a o 'j' w > S JO SMLV.LSH 2IfIOUNVH NHQQIH uc❑a r� lL 9 a 4-40 0 60 0. 0 Q� r-� W W Cd Cd a ti O 00'009: L aleDS -- Ml 6E.'E0 -- ClOe 190 -- PX69107 tEO-06WXcOlOOVO 7Vd73N301 S6upliVJG O m J votes, O w7 lu cc Aw m J votes, O w7 LL - UJ cu > ® VD C-4 VD co Lu LU A Vol o L C 7-0 V O J / /_ bIb CTbO� 31b1S .0.0 a N N N V• Z�sOcn 5� uuu�uu��9 .pY .Y �Utl rivYry ppQm3Q6n9m0m'I oo®smoammmm� Vt Q EE € _ tlf U'0mU0-UU an a-- na- as Su m4u�mAumw in mpaO aOwmUmamm ��m�Rgg�NyNN ��L=CC�mmmmmm l � A 0 -• JI � jr tl 41 L U U 41 L a 9 Uva m p L u�u` ®44444 V U- W CYa E > o Ca Cel u. cu -CD °O ~- O LU —� o ® f -- m k g a k k= 4 g° : B s ¢u j a9 k „n a2 nn aI 2 a g^ 9r 9 m to ° a8a.s?p;P� 9LL 6p g_ 3gbe� y�5��q�s�! Y bi a`k S� 34 a g3 on ¢5 3a C Ao 1v aS Lua°8 ;-,f. N„ . I „ Y Y Q - I . m „ . m tl „ , ° s „ Q „ 4 4= 4$ e 4 s u° m- -a° ad QR kit Is J a c X35 $a • v "� Xi v v U V! Y 9 °2)" l 0 o 41 D 0 o m °�N # s o� V• Z�sOcn 5� uuu�uu��9 .pY .Y �Utl rivYry ppQm3Q6n9m0m'I oo®smoammmm� Vt Q EE € _ tlf U'0mU0-UU an a-- na- as Su m4u�mAumw in mpaO aOwmUmamm ��m�Rgg�NyNN ��L=CC�mmmmmm l � A 0 -• JI � jr tl 41 L U U 41 L a 9 Uva m p L u�u` ®44444 V U- W CYa E > o Ca Cel u. cu -CD °O ~- O LU —� o ® f -- m k g a k k= 4 g° : B s ¢u j a9 k „n a2 nn aI 2 a g^ 9r 9 m to ° a8a.s?p;P� 9LL 6p g_ 3gbe� y�5��q�s�! Y bi a`k S� 34 a g3 on ¢5 3a C Ao 1v aS Lua°8 ;-,f. N„ . I „ Y Y Q - I . m „ . m tl „ , ° s „ Q „ 4 4= 4$ e 4 s u° m- -a° ad QR kit Is J a c X35 $a \EIM §E!,\}o 1. §§}±. - f g \� :c¥ . `2 ]§ \\ ■ $ 20 ` m C la | - t *kms ----- ------}----2 LCo § | L-- /� , � ---- \EIM §E!,\}o 1. §§}±. - f g \� :c¥ . `2 ]§ \\ ■ $ 20 ` m C la | - t LCo § , ® L , � 3 � 0. � d � � }�{ }i � t|! { ! f ! f � -4 m LL 0() W\ IE h 9 LU N 9L0 0 W +ice II uan O O u^ m r_ I s a� O+.' O 11 L v w > a m _ 1 � a o° i o L u, t N W NAA 19U0U 444444 `� �c ® ®y to, C-1 SON ER va W M L CO r/ U E 0 L 7 ' 13 u U 0 W 0 p h' t La L co .0 0 p ¢ �Phil �:�4#ay1raipL u !1!€ -1 21' SFS tra 1, € p pP -FSBagrtE,$�Eaga8;ad���o y9 eDwa fi$§si33$a a 1pgW F 4{§ .@� �'-�� �z s 6a s � yy° �hg5�1� 19 $BF4 a. .? E $ 93� §4 EF.. a F isda io Va;3 �eyE spy pg =ac lafi6$4?Pgs §85s ;Ei ;�a89 a$� lase a:�$aaYa$a a$ !P$� SI > °q;a 3F: 6° 2Eg a' �aaJS Fk $appp I I a., 9"a g yafE' 1 t5 si �a9` p'_e:a °�AB1 aF �ka8 ss �o?$.s sm9:�n9 a§a -$fig= P papa s l"$ as s`z 3'• Y Y sy 4. sF3F of X783 �13 u.38Pa 53 �55 it �•[� ;_ u d Y n �S Ij' $— e�f fib $$ i?Efi 3 g'$$y 2g ;ytry s� }9a 6 ' �= a s P s sa E ;baa s Ya t ys ?a $ �6�y ° aa_. g_ �yy ?3a R aim �� gr 9 � ` off an 5 la 9; �� t���� fi.�E�E;s � � Ea�E a�g �€�S � °� y� � a ea$ i =a 4 a �;; 132 ;?k aE .4 b i' li gi i° _� € a E 6p, �j8!$1 i1�y E d � Ni.]. %3Sy E 7 �!1 �Gg61 a : mB • 1` ���fi Sig 89 `oo e ro : 3a 3•II. A & $ 8s5, a=E s ,$A;P k 5y E$ i Y g E4F 911 a k 1 fib ° �.a a ye a3a o $i 9§s` s sBa=g kro °o 31291 .3i _� Y k s - i s=t Bfi5�e b s By 1- $�9.. fid' �'° s § : S � ,. �i',� 8 $ $3 P 'Y Q � .e 13 3E`y� a $ $•: i3 zBt�yA i FBF ai a�;5� Y as s'I baa n E a s° ➢j� 9u P=A3e _ Y 3Y "a gala. to tr =$ro ds oaf d� a 4%3 rt _ _ zs3AN $®!� 6 d 6 U d W i 4 d U d u MM$�3�� B Y,tahvi„a $ $?a';i a a$= E gy a�,:=`E E'. a= 5 •B 3mBF3tr $ l a sg i fie SF =yg$ II i `,p S PB=$;pq as Y a Y 3e $ it 3; i ,I 8 a a a 4 , R e5i1 •6 gE �2rtp°4_' g'3 63 d �5 c$ a$ z•a - C H Boy mm $6 ° $__ ,➢?3 "bill- s 8 eap Y $a g 1's ;aa - 5 3` .ay3 - s 3la;zs. E=gz4€s• °$ Y: 3w. E d aay3 1'Egl S t o 8 i�95 w A 1 i a.i ILME lea �8s , 4 1saa; ySP6.j 8 i= 6 .455 a 211� ?:;A ,.E w �:_ � 8 8� `s :3�� - ;5•$s8 P: 3 g u n E-. �� �� d8a .3���, 3� n8 gt8 fro -�'� � � e �h 3 $_ $3.� §� �!! §. ,�8� 6 8a• S� ;-;-, P 8 P �' ,P,.T ; P=E 8 r i 9� e8 a E sgpal B a3'$ s 39�� 3 �- € E �EB� � 4 3�p#`WB$B��:Bs`. i•F F P E � sS tys, � � 8l m -!aa R i B ?- �a a $8s ga ayi a. Rnak�PB B? rt�243a ?a �d1 #a ' a& Alt 8a 3• �E ! gs i d f 4 d d U seB$'s 3B = 33 !-` 9131 �$ �aaa 6•'�1 ;a tY88 a a Jilt .i!ol 298 :a :§ Ffi P S n _aE• _ y a� a9h E •�s 41 of pp6• 15 §a §§ii B 19:y y a9Eiaa3 �gy�� �2Y m:l°3aan a$S 4 3EL� P All,E y• Ey ' Es yi y=y e$ $;j 63 ! jd•; b Mpi y82B ji9!$ t a°y asp �Ee a;5 a�5�agg=9g3�ay $5�a=1r i3y€$;ki" P B P =Ys -t Jr pa;3rt 3-a=B is F Ep�SUpn"Pa. E=71a9 Cog& &� S ae s 8a d �� !gB�.yI 63i,sp 7B7 s �! _� 9�3J 3 tr x�63Ea$,p8; 3�P�ns €65a4��6��3i k3 trn•: k 8-i'� � n^"; :1•i���i ,_8� �: v 3 B'8 =n8° apQa F'S ao$§ �$ na§`karo=t� a ;d y�Em'3 !S'3•l;y 8saa g;Ee�E -121E F ai_. - NIP. - d'§gki3' 6 Rg�6�yq�trj•a�'FyF��5i §�3Yk $PliE$ �� F 64 e1�ro 3� 4L;.�$$$a 1 . sai¢6 S� �s-§Bcay3d S Eh. � 3�� fi °8J�; � g ��• zh I?a96�QsgAMU ��$� ��Ea$ � 1 it HA �a g� at rtA a s3'-_ E -yyF 1i 8�2 1$� s B 4 3 a5S M 112 • ; 4b 53aE�9EY 3a9� ' �� p - § 8a --P1 9i3. jEva 1$ 9191P11 -B j! Y ail E 21 i¢ his J11i lid ie3 ;p a1$-Iik- >ss 3 Ra�¢4 l y8 4aa$l3 3 a$ E ,y ass fi9s 3 jjli3 3.,36 ail 3E S 3 ChZR9 $09a2�aS 3` $Asa 8 - _ $ _ E •�S7ni3 $a aaB1 aa6�, -trot u d A d d d U d W k 34h �Etr3 a3zE �: _U B1Pgfx lE IES _ i-6 P3; . � 8 i ' II F' iAb °et� Bc8` 3't n� s 111HP All ,$i1s,d� � ��aa 3 B&ay3$ 6,tr 83 n 9$' P-15 F i8 l Hit 5i1 5 ? � .2 5Y2a a%af E_§ 3 = 1111 �7:a�m l9sa AM �flffl<F 5 �Tj7 3 z d d U 0 3 d gill @11RI - $VISE - qyl -$ IUDnD NO 8 'a• �au 21,912 ? k§ E a m m h B $ � yy B pa r s B $a; ,IRI 3a maB 3a fir: p§ 31�a E :ld8 y5�Wit � 9F� _1 j� EE! ;�ir�, k ;i¢i', 214ap" til a � 5 ••� 2•E�all Ea � E rt gal W-111 1,01-11'a It f 4 y�n $ ? HIM,, �� �yro as A M d �'�5� 3a d15_S d�= Ca?Pa, a3 a �d- 'i3y o.Y M. ±°Itr_ d w � Pt - ��i� P a9`o! 5 y MIN? B ; g ds8 �.J§•' -�k� qtr: 3 � $:� Ss� �8 a PaE $ § a $ � 111, 93;a lZ3sgg�s jilt 5 3 HUM g 1 p��r aIDjfin$$$idW�a$i &�p2ailYas§_kA? e B 5 $$ 6E °E 9 tr E 3jd 3 -�vip a $s- g$ J� N 3 `�a i2 -g #s €t Y 4B a Baa tr $s;� dgB E a �& a aE.sf §6Ea 1 39 :• $ as 3Em $Fa i n§ �_3 d $!- pa 6 s°• a 2= BELIr sy= �t$��i ll JUL?a: :, a § ! Eag.01 �.$ c ➢oma i�ia� 848' y eaa3 fie! 3 a 3 PbT ��tr 9 B' a I .Er" P. 8 yra, 875 X98`' � §§fi2: $.- 8 4 95 trniB5 Sn1 P sE�$ aa��3pe�� � �n a4 ��� �.� Eat �-"��$$� ���'a=$ a�z�; Y$ '$' '$ '� ��➢ � EE'g�y$=g�8��' EP s��•�aAq ¢°�$�-p�d� F E IIs'= a 1 B§B'4_ ig F! e'2 E i rt �a § �i8o 8 8� fi 8'"�r It kid I 93-g� E1:uf, Es 5 $ y 3� n$ ET $1 13 Q a_. ,'$s$. 5P aFgla'�' --'fi Ey =a f iE a $�93^. a$. ' i a3=�. as as =1 sd�'=,a y $$$$ 3E{fi' E3 io a E $ Ee 'g8; 8T1 �➢ 5;aaA- a�oa ;� a= _� :�..�3 �3� �a� &Bsi; & §'x� -P Ez sn roma i a P^'i1 AII YP_E3-•E$ fig` !B 3 F1 a �3 y dE §'y E : 1- i y1� Bs35 �_" i 9 R° i s1 1a �6y §_ a• fiaEL 5�g:,.a fir• § 6't Y75 fi !3F a 2 a8�ada! �iaa�� , u s 3u4,� �� i roEf'tA adi aEEE < $ L tlx: =tr: m$ 3 z$�B�E 3't 8a $33 d9 Y$& g ��I1�--.�68 M _�$8!a$s� k u a d d u 4 0 8 14 !$ p3 I TIM aBp aro$ $`off- Bila:aP!�'a' W y R $ l a § B 1 =!:$a$: g f' 1p$ a Eby aeuaaaaass9 fis F 3 a¢' s1i1 tr kEs 9 r $��•$ta a o°i h �� $= BEaa a 3 $ °asaaaaaaa a-, F p Ii p6Ya d!a° :g a s 3 ! @ro;p B ➢ :!3 r Pi g?pa fie_�..jg�n1 E; l� f aiv-i:S� a m$ 1'��'E3$ $Ea a dz Ei" ase -9]11113t $`�a '§ y 2$5!1h a F a¢e as ! 13 a aG :$y:� ares_=E � 4�6: $$ p $kEga $8S4 s fi•pfi 6 116 N! pp 9§ 3g8ero' ro -E 9 �_P$� 7•a ss �;6s' 3 as � 1 e�� ,c � yE g8d � $� Bfie s_� E�P3'S EP�3,E_;. $vaF� $ •sa �=1pB d a 4 k $9�}a�ya �� ! i� �wJ 8 y' a �pl,9 ipp g '.3 p 8aAa i 9v i rt ya 88 5 $' � d: $• ,° s� 3 ai P i 3a8' 6�!'-n$ �2:�31, �- s !�_`� � Y �s5 4�ss B° bad H 4E �. x a•... a { ••� ��� ��� tr`E- ��a G�9 � �E 1� P rt` $��` �;$������ �aE. �' - �� ��' E �� ��s-jj r p$E�n A z. F. { Z Y 4 s a = �..F�.,,Rax4 E8= s' t it % as E;z$ $p'$�p�IIaa !g B yy3Ea i ��yp 8 a F`8$ a?$a �zgdsa�= &_s$EYyy�ta 91'ag E�®a$iyy$�2p¢�i�$� '�� $ja °a =a3y aaE� F t63R � da3Eaa H8891a aE IMI 8311, H 8t i�]pM iii:.°E' i� g36g rt°��g $�3D��ss 8giY9s-fEo�st nH � g#�� ��r �� �E �fi S�B6'3 ro a .4 d d d w . d _ 6Ea 2�g :� y y 11$18111`0 :433=i3 :8 2: a 32. _h� �A:.n" a°8 al 3 zsB8 53s Y F < J� �§ lit M, �� gB a�'B 6 P%�a lilap 4g F�'_ aE =$Y g ay$ EF j ¢ iff"91 ilk 191 a it; Bl .3 ga 'a° 5 aS $3 F 1e, am.a:. y4 4-26a did Alii z d d U d pp C d seB$'s 3B = 33 !-` 9131 �$ �aaa 6•'�1 ;a tY88 a a Jilt .i!ol 298 :a :§ Ffi P S n _aE• _ y a� a9h E •�s 41 of pp6• 15 §a §§ii B 19:y y a9Eiaa3 �gy�� �2Y m:l°3aan a$S 4 3EL� P All,E y• Ey ' Es yi y=y e$ $;j 63 ! jd•; b Mpi y82B ji9!$ t a°y asp �Ee a;5 a�5�agg=9g3�ay $5�a=1r i3y€$;ki" P B P =Ys -t Jr pa;3rt 3-a=B is F Ep�SUpn"Pa. E=71a9 Cog& &� S ae s 8a d �� !gB�.yI 63i,sp 7B7 s �! _� 9�3J 3 tr x�63Ea$,p8; 3�P�ns €65a4��6��3i k3 trn•: k 8-i'� � n^"; :1•i���i ,_8� �: v 3 B'8 =n8° apQa F'S ao$§ �$ na§`karo=t� a ;d y�Em'3 !S'3•l;y 8saa g;Ee�E -121E F ai_. - NIP. - d'§gki3' 6 Rg�6�yq�trj•a�'FyF��5i §�3Yk $PliE$ �� F 64 e1�ro 3� 4L;.�$$$a 1 . sai¢6 S� �s-§Bcay3d S Eh. � 3�� fi °8J�; � g ��• zh I?a96�QsgAMU ��$� ��Ea$ � 1 it HA �a g� at rtA a s3'-_ E -yyF 1i 8�2 1$� s B 4 3 a5S M 112 • ; 4b 53aE�9EY 3a9� ' �� p - § 8a --P1 9i3. jEva 1$ 9191P11 -B j! Y ail E 21 i¢ his J11i lid ie3 ;p a1$-Iik- >ss 3 Ra�¢4 l y8 4aa$l3 3 a$ E ,y ass fi9s 3 jjli3 3.,36 ail 3E S 3 ChZR9 $09a2�aS 3` $Asa 8 - _ $ _ E •�S7ni3 $a aaB1 aa6�, -trot u d A d d d U d W k 34h �Etr3 a3zE �: _U B1Pgfx lE IES _ i-6 P3; . � 8 i ' II F' iAb °et� Bc8` 3't n� s 111HP All ,$i1s,d� � ��aa 3 B&ay3$ 6,tr 83 n 9$' P-15 F i8 l Hit 5i1 5 ? � .2 5Y2a a%af E_§ 3 = 1111 �7:a�m l9sa AM �flffl<F 5 �Tj7 3 z d d U 0 3 d gill @11RI - $VISE - qyl -$ IUDnD NO 8 'a• �au 21,912 ? k§ E a m m h B $ � yy B pa r s B $a; ,IRI 3a maB 3a fir: p§ 31�a E :ld8 y5�Wit � 9F� _1 j� EE! ;�ir�, k ;i¢i', 214ap" til a � 5 ••� 2•E�all Ea � E rt gal W-111 1,01-11'a It f 4 y�n $ ? HIM,, �� �yro as A M d �'�5� 3a d15_S d�= Ca?Pa, a3 a �d- 'i3y o.Y M. ±°Itr_ d w � Pt - ��i� P a9`o! 5 y MIN? B ; g ds8 �.J§•' -�k� qtr: 3 � $:� Ss� �8 a PaE $ § a $ � 111, 93;a lZ3sgg�s jilt 5 3 HUM g 1 p��r aIDjfin$$$idW�a$i &�p2ailYas§_kA? e B 5 $$ 6E °E 9 tr E 3jd 3 -�vip a $s- g$ J� N 3 `�a i2 -g #s €t Y 4B a Baa tr $s;� dgB E a �& a aE.sf §6Ea 1 39 :• $ as 3Em $Fa i n§ �_3 d $!- pa 6 s°• a 2= BELIr sy= �t$��i ll JUL?a: :, a § ! Eag.01 �.$ c ➢oma i�ia� 848' y eaa3 fie! 3 a 3 PbT ��tr 9 B' a I .Er" P. 8 yra, 875 X98`' � §§fi2: $.- 8 4 95 trniB5 Sn1 P sE�$ aa��3pe�� � �n a4 ��� �.� Eat �-"��$$� ���'a=$ a�z�; Y$ '$' '$ '� ��➢ � EE'g�y$=g�8��' EP s��•�aAq ¢°�$�-p�d� F E IIs'= a 1 B§B'4_ ig F! e'2 E i rt �a § �i8o 8 8� fi 8'"�r It kid I 93-g� E1:uf, Es 5 $ y 3� n$ ET $1 13 Q a_. ,'$s$. 5P aFgla'�' --'fi Ey =a f iE a $�93^. a$. ' i a3=�. as as =1 sd�'=,a y $$$$ 3E{fi' E3 io a E $ Ee 'g8; 8T1 �➢ 5;aaA- a�oa ;� a= _� :�..�3 �3� �a� &Bsi; & §'x� -P Ez sn roma i a P^'i1 AII YP_E3-•E$ fig` !B 3 F1 a �3 y dE §'y E : 1- i y1� Bs35 �_" i 9 R° i s1 1a �6y §_ a• fiaEL 5�g:,.a fir• § 6't Y75 fi !3F a 2 a8�ada! �iaa�� , u s 3u4,� �� i roEf'tA adi aEEE < $ L tlx: =tr: m$ 3 z$�B�E 3't 8a $33 d9 Y$& g ��I1�--.�68 M _�$8!a$s� k u a d d u 4 0 8 14 !$ p3 I TIM aBp aro$ $`off- Bila:aP!�'a' W y R $ l a § B 1 =!:$a$: g f' 1p$ a Eby aeuaaaaass9 fis F 3 a¢' s1i1 tr kEs 9 r $��•$ta a o°i h �� $= BEaa a 3 $ °asaaaaaaa a-, F p Ii p6Ya d!a° :g a s 3 ! @ro;p B ➢ :!3 r Pi g?pa fie_�..jg�n1 E; l� f aiv-i:S� a m$ 1'��'E3$ $Ea a dz Ei" ase -9]11113t $`�a '§ y 2$5!1h a F a¢e as ! 13 a aG :$y:� ares_=E � 4�6: $$ p $kEga $8S4 s fi•pfi 6 116 N! pp 9§ 3g8ero' ro -E 9 �_P$� 7•a ss �;6s' 3 as � 1 e�� ,c � yE g8d � $� Bfie s_� E�P3'S EP�3,E_;. $vaF� $ •sa �=1pB d a 4 k $9�}a�ya �� ! i� �wJ 8 y' a �pl,9 ipp g '.3 p 8aAa i 9v i rt ya 88 5 $' � d: $• ,° s� 3 ai P i 3a8' 6�!'-n$ �2:�31, �- s !�_`� � Y �s5 4�ss B° bad H 4E �. x a•... a { ••� ��� ��� tr`E- ��a G�9 � �E 1� P rt` $��` �;$������ �aE. �' - �� ��' E �� ��s-jj r p$E�n A z. F. { Z Y 4 s a = �..F�.,,Rax4 E8= s' t it % as E;z$ $p'$�p�IIaa !g B yy3Ea i ��yp 8 a F`8$ a?$a �zgdsa�= &_s$EYyy�ta 91'ag E�®a$iyy$�2p¢�i�$� '�� $ja °a =a3y aaE� F t63R � da3Eaa H8891a aE IMI 8311, H 8t i�]pM iii:.°E' i� g36g rt°��g $�3D��ss 8giY9s-fEo�st nH � g#�� ��r �� �E �fi S�B6'3 ro a .4 d d d w . d _ 6Ea 2�g :� y y 11$18111`0 :433=i3 :8 2: a 32. _h� �A:.n" a°8 al 3 zsB8 53s Y F < J� I t. rn 00'0-19: R alcog -- lNd 60.EO -- El0-1/EdFJO -- PX5'9107 h-1-1-06IPXOIOOVO 7Vt13N39195U1AivJO:O 2z�� p 5yy � C Gj� o Co Ad q Q. u J_ J v GI ^ o LijLo *—r � � g � ��� Q ti 111 ................ Yd �3LYlS �� � (bQ CCM SN7l707 CC+ All o �W a IQ y � s t X � O s •e @ b co 0 0 5 -4r I a a I � e Ii � I I rNLH 31 YAW Y) Xtfo ) ZLW igl+ ,Y, 10YXL vomw rl.Ysmv33arr. v Lonnrrr c-} + ix�mv33Tnneo n of Z 107 107 Z 00'0019: ! ale -91, --kM 60:00 -- ElOZlr{/90 -- PX6'S1O7 POO-06IPXOI00VO 7Vd3N3JIs6u1Ai-Qj:0 -�3A Yd �P7 �y oa - �kr • .r7I7 w4r., I AIN 4: ilk t O W c 0 tl 4 Uxi � �ryV ul O O J J sr I W I I Dar r 1M 21 YAW Y) Ksr lex a JA013M yW~ rax mudZtNvw ° uer ace+ ,Y. 10N2[L � tnamy3 Mnneo �� R ��amn�roaa—1 Z 107 �I 107 CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy George Delafield, Jr. September 19, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 26, 2013 at 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular A. May 23, 2013 B. July 25, 2013 AGENDA Meetings and Public Hearings. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. October 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. November to be determined C. December 26, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. f. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Dave Bodker, Landscape Architect as agent for 1275 North Ocean Blvd. LLC, owners of property located at 1275 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Palm Beach Shore Acres Rev. It. Elks. D & E, S 50 ft. of Lt 6 & Lt 7 Blk. D a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to install privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping at the existing beach access. b. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the installation of a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping to an existing beach access. 2. An application submitted by Randall Stofft Architects as agent for Kevin & Michelle Clark owners of property located at 3250 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 13 and part of Lot 14, Polo Cove Subdivision for the following: a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish existing structures. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to clear site for new construction. C. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to allow 236 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum Floor Area Ratio. d. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit rear waterfront setback of 30'. e. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a Bermuda style, partial 2 story, AGENDA CONTINUED single-family dwelling with attached garage, pool and pavilion, a total of 7,552 square feet. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, JULY 25, 2013, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: Vice -Chairman Smith called the meeting to order at 8:30 A.M. II. Roll Call: Present and Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Participating Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Board Member Amanda Jones Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member George Delafield Alternate Member Absent: Scott Morgan Chairman Also Present and William H. Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk John "Skip" Randolph Town Counsel Martin O'Boyle Resident Richard Jones Architect Mark Grant Owners' Attorney Thomas Laudani Developer David Bodker Landscape Architect III. Minutes: Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on May 23, 2013 Vice -Chairman Smith suggested the May 23, 2013 minutes be deferred until the next ARPB Meeting, as they were not in the Board Members' packets. All agreed. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: Vice -Chairman Smith asked for any changes to the agenda. There were none. He also confirmed that each member received a copy of Chairman Morgan's letter, in addition to their meeting packet. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates Vice -Chairman Smith announced the upcoming Regular Meetings and Public Hearings. 1. August 2013 — No Meeting 2. September 26, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. 3. October 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. 5. November 2013 - TBD 6. December 2013 - TBD Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the re -scheduling of the ARPB meeting dates during the holiday season. He also reminded Board Members to contact Town Clerk Taylor when they will be unable to attend any ARPB meetings. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam July 25, 2013 — Page 2 Town Clerk Taylor responded there has been no decision made, as yet, on any date changes, and suggested that those be determined at the September 2013 hearing. Vice -Chairman Smith asked for ex -parte communication relative to the items this day. There were none. Town Clerk Taylor swore in all persons who planned to speak at this meeting: Martin O'Boyle, Richard Jones, Mark Grant, Thomas Laudani and David Bodker. VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Richard Jones, as Agent for Harbour View Estates LLC, the owners of property located at 1224 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 5, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat 2. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit the installation of landscaping and the easterly portions of privacy walls within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of an 8,726 square foot, partial two-story, Colonial West Indies single family dwelling with a 3 -car attached garage, pool and cabana. Mr. Jones introduced himself and stated he represented Seaside Builders, as well as, Mr. Bodker and Mr. Grant. He discussed and displayed the renderings of the three (3) houses well under construction in Harbour View Estates. Mr. Jones continued that two (2) of the three (3) under construction have been sold, and one of the remaining lots has also been sold. He further reported that out of the six (6) lot subdivision, three (3) have been spoken for. Mr. Jones continued that Lot 5 is a very important lot, due to the fact that it is directly adjacent to the entry of Harbour View Estates, and it sets the tone for the entire community. He recapped that Lot 3, Lot 4 and Lot 6 have been approved and that they all have their own unique appearance; two (2) of the homes are designed in a classic Bermuda style, and Lot 6 is a Colonial West Indies style. Mr. Jones continued that all three homes meet the Town's codes for setbacks, ratio and diversity to its neighbors. He described the differences with Lot 5's site orientation by displaying its landscape plan. He reported another difference of the three (3) approved homes is their second floor carriage homes above the garage with full courtyards on each lot. On Lot 5's home, the carriage home was brought down to ground level and attached to the home. Mr. Jones continued that another difference is that it implies classic symmetries with the two (2) projected wings. He reported on historical homes that have this type of classic design. Mr. Jones further detailed how the unique characteristics will blend together. He displayed the floor plans and the colors and feels that this home will be the nicest house in the community. Board Member Lyons inquired regarding the elevations. He also asked Mr. Jones to address some of Chairman Morgan's concerns that were listed in his letter. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam July 25, 2013 — Page 3 Mr. Jones detailed the north, south and east elevations of the home. He continued that he appreciated Chairman Morgan's opinion, and stated that the house contradicts itself due to the wings. Mr. Jones further discussed its charm and character with the design. He repeated that Lot 5 is different and that the developer achieved their style quite nicely. Board Member Lyons commended the developer. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the two (2) story mass between the two (2) homes from scale photographs to confirm that the bedrooms were not visible from one to the other. Mr. Jones displayed and discussed the second floor layouts where there were no overlaps with the houses. He reported that his client has a lot of money at stake, and his architectural designs are the best Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the height and if the artificial fireplace on the east side of the home was for symmetry. He was concerned the smoke would enter the 2vd floor windows. Mr. Jones responded that it is a functioning fireplace, but it is approximately 15 feet away and does meet codes for clearance. Board Member Jones inquired regarding the distance between main house and garage. Mr. Jones stated approximately 27 feet or one dozen (12) steps. Vice -Chairman Smith asked if any thought was given to bringing in either one of the wings a little. Mr. Jones answered one (1) or two (2) feet would employ classic symmetries. Mr. Laudani discussed how he takes pride in his work. He continued that he took exception to Chairman Morgan's comments in his letter and his absence from this meeting. Mr. Laudani stated that after the home is built it will be a signature property as he is an expert developer. He requested that the design be left as drawn. Board Member Lyons discussed his impression of the wings eventually being all blended in on the home. Mr. Laudani gave an overall review of the structure and the development. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the building on the east side being a guest house. Mr. Laudani responded that it could be a guest house or a gym. Mr. Bodker completely detailed the landscape with photographs and descriptions of the plantings. He also discussed his plans on the other adjacent properties in the community. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam July 25, 2013 — Page 4 Town Manager Thrasher requested the PDF of the drawings for Lots 3, 4 and 6. He also asked for the Condition of Approval. Town Clerk Taylor responded that she wasn't sure regarding their roof sample being received in Town Hall. Mr. Jones displayed a sample of the gray slate -like tile. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if the Board could, in the future, see all six (6) masses on the eventual site, so they can see where all were positioned on the property. Mr. Laudani stated that he would do a massive study for Board Members' viewing. Vice -Chairman Smith asked for any comments from the audience. Mr. O'Boyle stated that if the Board Members heard ample testimony and feel they could make a favorable recommendation, he felt he did not have to speak at all. He addressed the letter from Chairman Morgan whom he favored very much, but questioned its contents. Town Counsel Randolph stated that it was not in violation to be distributed to Board Members. He continued that if there were comments back, that would be in violation of the Sunshine Law. Town Counsel Randolph responded that he always encourages communications like this to come to the public meeting, as opposed to appearing before the meeting. He repeated the Sunshine Law stating that no two (2) or more members of a board may communicate in regard to something. Vice -Chairman Smith asked the Board Members if any two (2) or more members communicated with anyone regarding Chairman Morgan's letter. They all responded "No". Mr. O'Boyle discussed Mr. Laudani's project in the Town, and their "roller coaster" relationship. He continued that he finds the home acceptable from his experience and what the markets say. Mr. O'Boyle suggested that the Board Members have to yield to Mr. Laudani's discretion, his taste and his experience. He commented negatively on Board Chairman Morgan's letter. Mr. O'Boyle highly recommended Mr. Laudani's knowledge and experience in building homes. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if all neighbors were notified and if there were any other comments received. Town Clerk Taylor responded that all were notified and Chairman Morgan's letter was the only one received. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam July 25, 2013 — Page 5 Board Member Murphy moved and Board Member Lyons seconded that approval of a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit based on a finding that the landscaping and easterly portion of a privacy wall, meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards be recommended. All voted AYE. Board Member Murphy moved and Board Member Lyons seconded recommendation of Level 111 Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two-story single family Colonial West Indies style dwelling, a 3 -car attached garage, pool and cabana, a total of 8,726 SF meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. The entry feature, measured from FFE to top of railings, shall be <14'. 2. The electric service lines shall be buried. 3. A sample of the gray color roof tile to be provided for approval. 4. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval, and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 5. Wall and /or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 6. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. All voted AYE. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF AND ATTORNEY: A. Proposed amendments to the Town's Zoning Code, including Design Guidelines. Mayor Orthwein thanked everyone serving on the ARPB for all their hard work. She discussed how the Town should rethink the codes and expand changes to them. Mayor Orthwein stated that the world is changing and how we have to also. She also mentioned flexibility and going forward in regards to the building codes. Mayor Orthwein commented how she liked the new homes in Town. Vice -Chairman Smith agreed and stated that he would like to see other residents on the ARPB, as alternates, to get their ideas. Mayor Orthwein responded that the search for more ARPB members has been on the Town's website for a long time with no responses. She continued that any interested party has to write a letter to the Town or attend a Commission Meeting and show their interest in becoming an alternate ARPB member. VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: Alternate Board Member Delafield inquired regarding a power point presentation for better audience viewing of visuals with regard to site plan approvals, at a Commission or Board Meeting. Board Member Lyons commended the idea of having a committee to update codes and he suggested possibly a developer being on the committee which may have the process work even better. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam July 25, 2013 — Page 6 Mayor Orthwein agreed with the developer being involved as they have helped the Town's property values go up, and put their investment in the Town. Town Counsel Randolph stated if the Board Members agree with Mayor Orthwein, they should make a recommendation to the Commission that they appoint a committee to look into the issues that she has raised, e.g., how the codes can become more user friendly, try to prevent a "cookie cutter" look in the Town, and to make more versatility in Town also. He admitted its going to be a big job for a committee to take on because they would have to start from scratch, e.g., is a design manual the way to go which was utilized in the past, and which did not allow flexibility and versatility. He reminded Board Members how there were problems that came up these past couple of years with regard to colors, metal roofs, etc. Mayor Orthwein stated she would take suggestions and would consider Mr. Laudani and other developers. Board Member Lyons moved and Alternate Board Member Delafield seconded to recommend the Town Commission appoint a special committee to review comprehensively the codes and regulations to provide a little more flexibility to meet today's concerns. All voted AYE. Town Counsel Randolph stated that motion will take care of the substantive portion of it. He suggested also that the Board pass on to the Commission to add three (3) words to real estate signs "and political signs". Vice -Chairman Smith commented on the importance of uniformity of exterior wall colors on all structures on a property. Board Member Lyons inquired on accent colors and trims. Town Counsel Randolph explained that both the color codes and sign codes can be looked at also by this new committee, and if need be, the color codes may even be done away with completely. Vice -Chairman Smith asked if these changes are intended to be recommended for adoption in the meantime and the answer was, yes. He then asked for feedback from the Board members. Board Member Murphy commented on the black and white colors on the signs at the present time. Board Member Delafield asked the status of the new traffic signs and was advised that an order would soon be placed. Town Clerk Taylor inquired if these new issues needed to be read into the record. Town Counsel Randolph responded "No" and that it should just be recommended that the Commission give consideration to them and to include ordinance amendments to adopt them. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam July 25, 2013 — Page 7 In response to Vice -Chairman Smith's request for public comment on these issues, Mr. O'Boyle stated he emphatically concurs with Mayor Orthwein and Town Counsel Randolph's statements. He also wanted confirmation that political signs no longer require review. Town Counsel Randolph stated there is no review required for political signs. Board Member Murphy moved and Board Member Lyons seconded that it be recommended to the Town Commission that in the interim, consideration, and possibly amendments, be made to the sign code and the section of the code relating to "color" as suggested by Attorney Randolph in his letter to the ARPB. All voted AYE. IX. PUBLIC: Mr. O'Boyle discussed his home's rear elevation issues. Town Counsel Randolph stated that these are an attempt at a clarification of what was intended by the code, "having uniformity of the colors". He continued that by doing this he was not trying to usurp the work of this committee, which could look at what Mr. O'Boyle suggested. Town Counsel Randolph stated that it was done to clarify the code at present and have uniformity of color on all walls. He continued that maybe this new committee can come up with a suggestion for Mr. O'Boyle. Mr. O'Boyle stated that there are a lot of conflicts in the code. He related his efforts with metal roofs. A discussion ensued regarding the colors of the home discussed earlier at this meeting. X. ADJOURNMENT: Vice -Chairman Smith adjourned the meeting at 9:40 A.M. Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-14 Address: 1275 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: 1275 NOB, LLC Agent: Dave Bodker, Landscape Architect Install privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscape. N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To permit the installation of a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscape to an existing beach access. Level II Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the installation of a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscape to an existing beach access. Issues Considered During Review: Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Motion to approve a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to install a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping at the existing beach access. Motion to recommend approval Level II Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping at the existing beach access meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: September 26, 2013 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as requested. (4-0) Level II Architectural/ Site Plan: Approved as Requested. (4-0) ,, ►':n 7 2013 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. PART If. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information ARPB File # /'Y — / t' LA -1. Project/Owner Name: 1275 N- Ocean Blvd / 1275 N Ocean Blvd LLC I.A.2. Project Address.. 1275 N. Ocean Blvd. Gulf Stream, FL I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: PALM BEACH SHORE ACRES REV PL BLKS D & E S 50 FT OF LT 6 & LT 7 BLK D I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) of imn walls and gates for beach access I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: N/A Architectural Style: will match approved architecture for the home being constructed at 1275 N.Ocean 1.A.6. Check all that apply: Gil Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing IX North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section 8) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: N/A Type of Foundation: ro_ nc:reteRpread footer B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 185 NE 4th Ave. #104 Delray Beach, FL 33483 I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: -561-272-9958 Fax: 561-272-8941 I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: Dave Bodker Landscape Architect I.C.2. Agent Address fin LCL (;nnnrPss.Arra-%qi iitP 1fly A r)alrav Raarh P► '41AA I.C.3. Agent Phone Nu 1.C.4. Agent Signature - Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date - Decision: ..P.�n/► nn �� A,Q,.j •�nP.11/ _ .ilii _ cell 561-704-0443 Fax 561-276-3869 Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 PART Iii. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFIC..-,rION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? RS -13 III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? x Yes No Explain: Replacing existing wood fence and gate with new aluminum gate and masonry columns and wall III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? x Yes No Explain: see above III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? pedestrian III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? to adjacent residence: a. Stormwater Drainage on-site exfiltration trenches and site grading b. Sanitary Sewer an -site septic system (performance-based ystem) c. Potable water municipal water - Gulf Stream d. Irrigation Water —same e. Electricity FpI f. Telephone g. Gas h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) The gates, walls and columns will match the previously approved architecture at the adjacent residence. PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? xYes No (if "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? x Yes No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes x No (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes x No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes x No (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 B. Projects Requiring North I- -an Boulevard Overlay Permit • • IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? None - removal of old wood fence and gate; replace with aluminum fence and masonry columns IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: decrepit condition of existing fence and oate IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes x No Explain: The design is compatible with the adjacent residence to the North IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? It does not affect the IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: Proposed ntingsoften. the C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit MCA. When are the existing structures to be demolished? N/A IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? immediately upon approval IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? N/A D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: None IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: _N/A IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: N/A IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? N/A IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL 7 2013 This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information ARPB File # I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: 1275 N Ocean Blvd 11275 N Ocean Blvd LLC I.A.2. Project Address: _1275 N. Ocean Blvd. Gulf Stream, FL I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: PALM BEACH SHORE ACRES REV PL BILKS D & ES50FTOFLT6&LT7BLKD I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # ofstories, etc.) columns walls and gates for beach access I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: N/A Architectural Style: will match approved architecture for the home being constructed at 1275 N.Ocean 1.A.6. Check all that apply: 6d Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing B North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: N/A Type of Foundation: ronr.�et - spread footer B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 185 NE 4th Ave. #104 Delray Beach FL 33483 1.6.2. Owner Phone Number: -561-272-9958 Fax: 561-272-8941 I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: Dave Bodker Landscape Architect I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Nuber: (o) 561 76-631 c 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use O Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: 561-704-0443 Fax 561-276-3869 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? RS -B III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? x Yes No Explain: EpplacIng existing wood fence and gate with new aluminum gate and masonry columns III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? x Yes No Explain: see above III.A.4. How are Ingress and egress to the property to be provided? pedestrian III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? to adjacent residence: a. Stormwater Drainage on-site exfiltration trenches and site grading b. Sanitary Sewer nn -Sita sPptjr system (performance-based system) c. Potable water municipal water - Gulf Stream d. Irrigation Water sAMP e. Electricity FPI f. Telephone g. Gas h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) The gates, walls and columns will match the previously approved architecture at the adjacent residence. PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? xYes No (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? x Yes No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes x No (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes x No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes x No (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? None - removal of old wood fence and gate; replace with aluminum fence and masonry columns IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: decrepit condition of existing fence and pate IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes x No Explain: The design is compatible with the adjacent residence to the North IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? It does not affect the IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: Proposed planting softens the C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? N/A IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? jmmediatplyJ. upon apprnval IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? N/A D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: None IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: N/A IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: N/A IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? N/A IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? N/A Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 1E 2 cn A m omg��0� m�xpmm0 Q A -i Om 0 y0 ti -1 O TI 0< p -1 m N -1 0 p 2 A T o0 z mi D N z 0 p^ -� <�(n m�'a 2 n p 2 mS1A,aOOO O m a z 71 yy P In a T v C3 N NC A 1 m c m, 00 oz C? O O C N m OOyx y �m o ami m O >y A D m Z 5 5 j mpZ1gi r �z z �Amn D Nyp dRp i A m0 omg�m .A L$ m D O o•n D ^ m j m F•-1 Z AOCm� 0�00 oOiO0;'o,b o o H m Dom v z T�owo d o m a f° z n m m pzm0m ;v�a�pi trl o m v (� x �" X N C m m H H mSDmo gm� ' cn C� p? DD ZA yt3ly—�� oO$om�;y� )O.? y o�oNmf3 p �VD•' � oS• 'r'' y> o ymC-1+ v O�mo C- O V0� H OO ro m Gm _ Zmmz =O Ml G] �Ce'r4jpN O OOz`3Hy OA m 1 YOOm� Ix v A _ __ u� Va- - -"AVROAD A -1—A a PED b-� VANE PRLPFl2TY UhE CONC p w FORS 3 T T. b d I 5p F 6 ONi SETBACK (MAIN STRUI f N URE) N m y U - D I CONSTRUCTION CCONTROL LLINE (PLATg�K RDED 8/22,97 $mRPAGE 152) & 2 STORY RESIDENCE N UNDERGROUND GARAGI m n Q A -i Om 0 y0 ti -1 O TI 0< p -1 m N -1 0 p .0 m O$ p z mi D N z 0 p^ -� <�(n m�'a N Z o O m a z 71 yy P In a T v N NC A 1 c m, O m oz r O g P !I 'W 2 S T O R YJ R E S I h E N C L 0 T 8 _ 11c L 0 C K A 0 o L • m P 25-' REAR xio• > C (MAIN S _ OCT ORE) SETRACK CON PSTRREUCVIOUS OA r TION ��-� CCCL RECO DED TROL LINE PLAT BOPAGE 104) OK J 1979 ------------ 1 6' CONC n aGCM �' � IXiSTNO BUIN�,E D �l OHNE ml Fi + to D m0 a Q A -i Om 0 y0 ti -1 O TI 0< p -1 m N -1 0 p .0 m O$ p z mi D N z 0 p^ -� <�(n m�'a N Z o O m y 71 yy P In a T v mg NC A w~ gg C O m oz r O g S=O , p g O O E� y0 m O-5 o O by x x� m o 0 m 8 A mm D D zv O �m0 v O N < m Z 5 5 j r0 y �n �Amn D Nyp dRp nlm/IN A m0 D .A O Z D — ?N D ^ m j m O _ Om N� C Dom v z v v o f° z n m m nz N C lJ-�,yJ m� W DD ZA i9 �L m Ml G] �Ce'r4jpN O OOz`3Hy J ir' 'm iSH-1 1 Ir __ b7 0 O � WrJ� O O O D O O NN O W O fyn O D; U z En0 21p T m I I i') r� r V 0 L3141' Z Q ffi O VW m O fn O D rp tp D 41 V y m m0 m A T L g N TeLvl"1 Cw;o O O m O� m O C g {. O p N o 21 E 21 21 Z Zi o o o 1 4 ��a.•�..o,ra- ��,� o.• o,�.,�o� ,n.,w „or•..,>r,-.,,� ,.,�„oo„o�.�� �, , o,,.,.r.• �, , opo.-o�.�� .,,, o�or „� .,.«< o, ,..,.- „r�,�.,� „a ,.,�.:o.,�.,,,., ..�. o� o�oo„�„��o �,.n,�� na ,�T„ ,-�„ �a�a...�,,, , � ,,, �,.,� �„o.. �.��.o��.�o �..,,..,,,,, >•.,< <, �o«� �..o,T.�.� .•,,.,��.,r „� o,r•,.�o� ,.,.,« �o�..,r�.•>„oma ..,�„oo„o�,�� -Z I F ZO mmm mom O� Nyp nlm/IN 1 w — ?N D ^ AZO m O _ N� _ g� Dom 010 n nz N C lJ-�,yJ m� W DD ZA i9 �L m Ml G] �Ce'r4jpN J ir' 'm 1 Ir __ O � I I V 0 L3141' -' 60 60.03_ A T L g N TeLvl"1 Cw;o m O C E A N {. 1 4 ��a.•�..o,ra- ��,� o.• o,�.,�o� ,n.,w „or•..,>r,-.,,� ,.,�„oo„o�.�� �, , o,,.,.r.• �, , opo.-o�.�� .,,, o�or „� .,.«< o, ,..,.- „r�,�.,� „a ,.,�.:o.,�.,,,., ..�. o� o�oo„�„��o �,.n,�� na ,�T„ ,-�„ �a�a...�,,, , � ,,, �,.,� �„o.. �.��.o��.�o �..,,..,,,,, >•.,< <, �o«� �..o,T.�.� .•,,.,��.,r „� o,r•,.�o� ,.,.,« �o�..,r�.•>„oma ..,�„oo„o�,�� I W i CTI . 3 1 14 m (a . 3 1 r-6 ro nNa y m — �nd rn �.J m T> _; am tl d M N No Y Tl .T� � N z n - -- P�m N0� � U d m 0 N d { iY Y 2 O p O n /PAF a d C 0 CL X W I MATCH LINE SEE ABOVE P s D�7fzT 70 n rn « Q 70 0 � N FTI �D 7 zr FTI = D � z u �e sp n� �R MATGN LINE SEE BE—OL:. y C v; rn �.J m T> _; am _I No Y Tl .T� ®// N z ° - -- P�m N0� � u �e sp n� �R MATGN LINE SEE BE—OL:. y C or AN °°W eve dm am '® No m ®// N z ° - -- P�m N0� � U d m 0 A d { n gn - I s� u �e sp n� �R MATGN LINE SEE BE—OL:. y C dm am '® No m ®// N z ° - o � U d m s d { - am �c �n u o � - G nQ 3 em a+m o$ ' ns 0 0 b >Nm om8 s o a. p E S t - m �m g9' s pD 3� 0 u �e sp n� �R MATGN LINE SEE BE—OL:. C C C/) '® No m ®// N z ° o 'fl 61a m m+r PA YEO MLtD i N OLr 4 s� � �QIiP M "'£ MRH � l44 SIA L� �WGVVMTCRPAD 6T LIP LIE OO > n y � o Mg p 10 AI' e +a — a EA OF WOOD LA173 ar Faw �� I Y go 11 lip a lig PIP � aMI �> ! Q "1 � t igi fill ° d"At rq 1 STORY RESIDENOE f 1P75 R Y ur � CO NC. A� T � as � - a n p WTSa MRD G Fid +q fUW r1R PRL bq �t� PUOSIVE PAM) PAsOpraorr awyyM C � A �p1' SC,rpgSy, + O! Cfhc Cv ar � ml > py ° T � { C 6 i A TLAmrtc OCEAN c� nm -4 * z' M J":)< Z a ® (:7)X77 G � w m ra a t, -i I '' I .. - Sk ft -RIM flow f r ;h Irk tip •yl -ell Mir 71, ,64 MW Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL 11110- RECEIVED -4 AUG 2 3 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream - Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this"form properly will delay its consideration. PART ll. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information ARPB File # KEVIN AND MICHELLE CLARK/ CLARK RESIDENCE I.A.I. Project/Owner Name: I.A.2. Project Address: 3250 POLO DRIVE, GULF STREAM, FL 33483 I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: LOT 13 & TOT 14 T,ESS rn 14 OF POLO COVE, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF ON FILE IN THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT IN & FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA,RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 24, PG. 73, SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING & BEING IN PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA. I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) DEMOLISH EXISTING SINGLE FAMILY HOME & BUILD NEW TWO STORY, nSIjNGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE +&, I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: 6,088 SF Gva- ►-c �-'Ce �; y ter"✓' 2 Architectural Style: BERMUDA STYLE ARCHITECTURE 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ZI Architectural/Site Plan Review a Land Clearing O North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ® Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) 0 Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: +8.0' NGVD B. Owner Information I.B.I . Owner Address: Type of Foundation.- GRADE oundation: I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: 203 834 3015/ 203 984 9883 Fax: 1.6.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information GRADE BEAMS AND PILES I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: RANDALL STOFFT/ RANDALL, STOFFT ARCHITECTS I.C.2. Agent Address: 42 N. SWINTON AVE. DELRAY BEACH. FL 33444 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) (561) 243-°799 cell Fax (561) 243-0299 1.C.4. Agent Signature: 5 e -i- �( Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: 2g0 6,�t 20'2, 34 5- 9 ,3 e> Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 F, Q w i LL E caN CrJ CD C O Q � !6i w to m `a n �Ea Ac C O 'O j rrN LL rs Y a C w E ¢ C a O u ❑ v v v y5�v v~ 3 p E: � m F_ a C7 � m❑m � E _ � yy v m ❑ o A Y N G LL W W a 9.� m Z mN �8 a` n. D a o •o e a UE j y ,❑ a Q N f7 8 9 v� o o N z -- Cj Lq E u o v Z � c mj6Z C C d N 10 a ¢ a € z a of IL 33 10 3 m O o t-: O ry' of a U N v a Trwn of Gulf Stream PART Ill. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? GULF STREAM CORE DISTRICT (RS -C) III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? ® Yes 0 No Explain, THE PROPOSED TWO STORY RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE FITS WITHIN ALL THE SITE SETBACKS,- ARCHITECTURAL ETBACKS,ARCHITECTURAL STYLE, MASSING, MATERIALS USED AND LUSH LANDSCAPE SET FORTH BY THE GULF STREAM CORE DISTRICT GUIDELINES. III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? M Yes ❑ No Explain. THE PROPOSED HOME IS CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND USE AS IT COMPLIMENTS THE RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD. III.A.4, flow are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? A 16' WIDE BRICK DRIVEWAY WILL EXTEND FROM POLO DRIVE TO MOTORCOURT INTO PROPOSED GARAGES. III.A.5. How are the following utilifies to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage ON SITE RETENTION/ DETENTION (SEE DRAINAGE PLANS) b, Sanitary Sewer CONNECTION TO NEW PROPOSED TOWN SEWER SYSTEM c, Potable Water CONNECTION TO TOWN WATER SYSTEM d. irrigation Water CONNECTION TO TOWN WATER SYSTEM e. Electricity CONNECTION TO FP&L f. Telephone CONNECTION TO PRIVATE COMPANY(AT&T OR EQUAL) g. Gas CONNECTION TO PROPANE TANK (WILL SUBMIT FOR PERMIT) h. Cable Television CONNECTION TO PRIVATE COMPANY(DIRECT TV OR EQUAL) IIi.A,6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria In Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) THE PROPOSED STRUCTURES ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE CRITERIA OF LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/ SITE PLAN REVIEW AS IT MEETS THE CRITERIA OF ITEMS 1-12 UNDER SECTION 66-144. PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements 1V.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the AIA (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes ZI No (if "Yes", section 6 of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project Involve the demolition of one or more structures? El Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? EI Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ® Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? 0 Yes ® No (1f "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit iV.B.1.hat significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what exte IV.B.2. Describe the need justification for the disturbance/addition: _ W.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition de oy or - seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or roduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or v as within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with theA1A Landscape EnhancemeM,,Project? IV.8.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impacossible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay C. Projects Requiring a -Demolition Permit W.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? AFTER COMMISSION APPROVAL W.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? AFTER BUILDING PERMIT HAS BEEN AWARDED W.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? NONE D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit W.D.I. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard PAUMOTIS PLAMS, FRAGAPANI, FICUS, SEAGRAPE TREES, QUEEN PALMS, ROEBELENII PALMS Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: ALL THE ABOVE TREES ARE CONSIDERED IN DECLINE FROM YEARS OF LACK OF PROPER CARE INCLUDING FURTILIZATION AND PRUNING. IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: MANY NEW PALMS AND TREES WILL BE REPLACING OLD AND TIRED MATERIAL, IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? ONLY MATERIAL ON THE PROPOERTY LINES ARE TO REMAIN AND WILL BE PROTECTED. IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? SYLVESTRIS, ROYAL, SABAL AND COCONUT PALMS. PIGEONPLUM & CRAPE MYRTLE TREES WILL BE USED IN PRPT ArRMF rr Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 ..•• .,uoQlll E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E.1. Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? ® Yes ❑ No Code Section: 70 -71(c)/70 -72(b) IV.E.2. How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? THE 300SF EXCESS F.A.R. ALLOWED IS STRUCTURE SAFE IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to be located? ❑ Yes ® No Explain. THE 300SF EXCESS IS PART OF A COVERED OUTDOOR SPACE THAT HELPS THE FUNCTION OF THE ARCHITECTURE BUT HAS NO IMPACT ON THE PROPERTY VALUE MEA. How will the use be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where it is to be located? IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? PLEASE SEE LANDSCAPE PLANS. IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? 0 Yes ❑ No Explain. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units .1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. if recreation facilities are be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surrounding properties. IV.F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 W IV 150.00'(P) 150.330'(M T FT— C C m ° N Z wo N O z v mmz 9vmc1 pgME y�T. a>�niC WOOD DOJ K 0 0 T13 2' CONC. SEAWALL 1' EACH SIDE OF _ BULKHEAD LINE I I�K------- ---0 ------ — -------- I Ir v Iio co 0 i I i w n T1 D 7 I *r A ■I tea'',. . a`' ■ ■I :1 is III, �N Mi �N :mow■w i 6.7 Im � 12'-0*ACC SORY T SIDE S CK 6.8! fin. 1_ SIDE SETBACK I 150.00(P P"O 02'(M ) '`n9 POLO _DR_ I VE -� ---------------------- (=FNTFRI INS------------- ----- - �1------- 30' R/W 18' ASPHALT_ `r SURVEY BASELINE-------------- ---- g---------- —� '--' C=D E�2 CT �l O8 "�1 MA y T<"V� .11u ]nyJ Tr -----_. g o r >> oc C D N�O� zv' > C�i +ri"a A2 �� pp �17T12 -N1 yAOT O 9~ a mZ NAOO vAmZ p ~ ru T p m O 1 O �oN o$ ioO m N N o z O Ao z< Ngoo ��**Il C 1 �A O T 0 0 OA{Ji zN pog 5 C i ;A N T o T r � v c S T o m 'Nil T V T o T 'Nil Q O 70' ° TNI ° H O N N � C=D E�2 CT �l O8 "�1 MA y T<"V� y ]nyJ Tr of 88 g o r >> oc C D N�O� zv' r <a m� 5 V N y O 7 n Y N z at m N N N TT 6` 0 0 PXdPil A,.161[UF-WR!Hili:et G6RWGYSP16Bi It{ Iff!!Nl J bJR(Ipq �AEE4� Ix'f_JE F,1iyq i A-VN^tT.'xH Y!A;; 1!'. KKQ5[+Lfti 3.":fvE4FMM�"5RlE9Nl3 Y F.R_Y:9: �:.1 R6y FF �Jl?Flt1W A' °A301Y1{iiN'i MN'!tM1UJ VG! F: F IW?'SfA W7Y}tWIE? {Y3Mld SJI W Po O $ o C �i aao pp ` ��i All IRp O 5� < m N ; D Pip m0 CA m o A n�SDO H N CUT m y0 yg m C C) � tDn C` y Z D J �' - O Dm r0- m tiOD m D 0m0 CC m Z A r O -D-I m O g M, &' NZ rTrrr rr r41 TTr . � N 1 O= D Z� {, z SITE PLAN R VIEW SU MISN : 8- 116:.JRJCU'.941 {ql lgiF•Jp(gf kF{l mmsl mroea "E tp i4SJRI'tNHCfF.J.I vW'OEi4'{ [IfU' lbK SIOir :MJN%Y9'1 m D_ Z G7 m -D r D z I m 0 m m [-ULU UrN►VC -M--- - ----------------4 SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSI( lC'.L;FIk pSXJE131gAfi ICYl�Li&iEzl�9tb AWG 4;PH:nIt{IgtEP!Qf�tPQ LF S�JTv E/AP91TA_'Qt�'fR5 P'IM 1NE'GI'AH WJC'Gi!'KK15fi QE 7if5 YSMci155u..1E 5:7!HhflL4�77.7iiC P1 tIR'9'�R, ilU WR k^P50.5Tffrd ""F,dIF R'F£6vOERT RAm4E ""M"651P;E'M:9 {l1li'i/1i BN Q5Bi'F: V tiF(i:F, I I I I I I I 1111411 R.ANDALL STOFFT .ARCHITECTS distinctive. inspirational. architecture. a? N SWITMW AVF, DFA.MY BFACH. FL 33149 U6I1 241-0199 . NAR FR FI. !7191 7h 76n • w — — SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 08-22-13 eauralweaxnrt�e�w:�+ia9axelrauwesm �malaea�[m�nwumrtc�a.�rruoewnKwexrs wmaa�aw et�wrw7awutsae®u[rurecfennpww¢a+a+WAmw:x®wwlmyumeanw7u CLARK RESIDENCE I - 3250 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM, FL YA RESIDENTIAL1130401 813 -CLARK RESIDENCE%Sh..IFHes�CLARK_A201 Awg• 8/2012013 1:08:38 PM 0 0 0m NN z°o O m c7ym m';o0-,0 8 ZZZ QQYJy� �� p � ;U M >mp m R . 0 8 D ;U A A y o m A D O o DZ n �m n �C) m � m ICr— �D py 0 D �+ Sk &Pn� D 9 ePn MIRA I &�Z xirrynK'i�n �rii% �n�yn� �TynT 1111411 R.ANDALL STOFFT .ARCHITECTS distinctive. inspirational. architecture. a? N SWITMW AVF, DFA.MY BFACH. FL 33149 U6I1 241-0199 . NAR FR FI. !7191 7h 76n • w — — SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 08-22-13 eauralweaxnrt�e�w:�+ia9axelrauwesm �malaea�[m�nwumrtc�a.�rruoewnKwexrs wmaa�aw et�wrw7awutsae®u[rurecfennpww¢a+a+WAmw:x®wwlmyumeanw7u CLARK RESIDENCE I - 3250 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM, FL YA RESIDENTIAL1130401 813 -CLARK RESIDENCE%Sh..IFHes�CLARK_A201 Awg• 8/2012013 1:08:38 PM A L II III L ------ 11: ----------------- T— SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSIO mcn C) 0 0 'RESIDENCE z -n I 111 RANDALL STOFFT CLARK 0 3250 POLO DRIVE 0 diSLInobve, inspiratiowd urchitocture GULF STREAM, FL i I FL Z u slwwr I "I. AVL ll Ra -Iii. Ilk, AW -4 CW .14Iom. - MAU, 11, f -0 0 n kIiKkND::ALL STOFFT u Z difiLlnot Iva limpirational architecture 14-' N S'%lNPk^ _Atli, DfIRAY IVAOL MD -4 fy'k Nklfr!;, SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION CLARK RESIDENCE 3250 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM, Fl, Y VRESIDENTIAW304018D-CLARK RESIDENCE,SNWFW,CLARK A20: O z m r m D O z m D Cn —I o � rawruaeeanre[aum o n m 0 M � N cp © 03T m SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 08-22-13 sn xeauxenar¢ei � rawruaeeanre[aum taws �a�veraoEa�xmreraa�xmmxcenuaeausmoa wxeeesaaxxnua�n a� v+n neoUw�.a:a6.xa+aurxwxss�rArw �wei�xasucuc�rt.w�.aurnaeroaaxevwrew:wrt�.a�xwuavmsuxvmsnu� �areueazxnuuevxvnmea�m�xea¢iwaxn¢vMrwiwarxa�aeme.romaAsean rhxmwdxrm�esv4mx[ruiwKxvx�pusmuramwmo4w�wruaruaaresx� Cmm ANDALL STOFFTARK RESIDENCE R D A RCHITECTS FSWUTM 3250 POLO DRIVE FL i o R ostinctive. inspirational. architecture. GULF STREAM, FL Z$ ELRA7' iIPAC'H, FL33494 (5611 24]-0'79♦ • N.APLES. FL (239) 262-7677 • WNWSIOF'FI'.COM V:\IRESIDENTIAL\13040150-CLARK RESIDENCE\SheetFks\CLARK_A301.dwg, 8120/2013 1:53:52 PM r/; 0 m r m D 0 U) 0 I > II RANDALL STOFFT dirst:inctive. mspirational arkliitecturti "i SMNit^ nV" T*"MY {k'M`FL F7, :Od41 ('4V 1t1 N5S+ fWtF9.FS k9. GJl� ^.A:�$'T x S:M1i1Y.titt p'r. . a -- 00000 00000 00000 000eo 000 � 0000a 00000 oeae© _ FTI❑� i 0000 5. 5' 0' I I I > C �7 C cn c sJ SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 0$-22-' venuwn�awowua.�awne imtmeaum�oea¢swam®a.�wwe!�n�[um�womooesaniaawxrmivaamururea�m�mvaewxw,maiwrc�cwr�cwae�ni i CLARK RESIDENCE to 3250 POLO DRIVE m GULF STREAM, FL " 9 11 - 14-6 1- WASI I"% ml SHEET 2 OF 2 0 m Y6.1' Ln RIGHT-OF-WAY - LLl LP LIGHT POLE J U � � � o M Z w m U M tl LL CONCRETE Z o< ¢w. Q `- co <L CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE POB a POC POINT OF COMMENCEMENT OU j U W = RECORD F CV Cl) M O L2 0 0 0 FOUND "X"CUT OFFSET5'EAST - 4'CLF 30.9' Y6.1' U—JN RIGHT-OF-WAY (D CATCHBASIN LP LIGHT POLE WPP WOOD POWER POLE o -=! LU Z CLF Z w m o p U LL CONCRETE Z COVERED WM O U 7• ABBREVIATIONS CENTERLINE RAV RIGHT-OF-WAY CB CATCHBASIN LP LIGHT POLE WPP WOOD POWER POLE CAN CABLE TV CLF CHAIN LINK FENCE WF WOOD FENCE CONC CONCRETE COV COVERED WM WATER METER CBS CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE POB POINT OF BEGINNING POC POINT OF COMMENCEMENT R RECORD F FIELD Boundary Survey a9 1 LOT 12 FOUND SMALL 10'DRAINAGE TREE DIRECTLY EASEMENT ON CORNER 157.46'(P) 158.72'(M) — — i as 89'22U "(M) VA LVE ;•'v' • . • • F • I 34.1' al CONCRETE* U GARAGE N , PATIO ELEV = 6.21' • • 7.0' 7.0' • -� • _ ONE STORY ¢ • ` . • •. , • • RESIDENCE LU c d 1.3' 4.3' > I c +• FF ELEV = 7.05' I •Q p •p Cl • o • w z LU e� • w.• =1W ac �I c • a � .oUo w U .m op c e• r •o• I • LOT LINE 1 • 8.3' 4.3'I SITE • I• NAIL r, 16 , • ELEI - 15.3' I o M 23.7' 38.7' I Z. I N I I - I 90°00'00"(P) N x I p 90°25'06"(M) I 90°44'53"(M) I 5• a' CLF 155.68(P) 155.67'(M) WPP FOUND X"CUT OFFSET5'EAST REMAINDER LOT 13 TOTAL AND EFFECTIVE LOT AREAS: TOTAL LOT AREA= 23,485 sq.R. EFFECTIVE (DRYLOT) AREA= 22,885 sq./t. SURVEYORS'NOTES: 1.1 HEREBY CERTIFY this survey meets Minimum Technical Standards pursuant to Section 472.027, Florida Statutes. 2. The survey map and report and the copies thereof are not valid without the signature and the original raised seal of a Florida licensed surveyor and mapper. 3. Underground orobscured improvements were not located. 4. Dimensions are record and field unless otherwise noted. 5. Stated dimensions take precedence overscaled dimensions. 6. This firm's Certificate of Authorization Numberis LB 6788. 7. Additions or deletions to survey maps or reports by other than the signing party or parties is prohibited without written consent of the signing party orparties. 8. Survey subject to reservations, restrictions, easements and rights-of-way of record. (This survey has been completed in the absence of a title insurance policy). 9. Location map is gleaned hum online mapping sites and and is only approximate. 10. Elevations refer to NGVD '29 Datum. Originating benchmark is 0-315, a Palm Beach County benchmark. Elevation =15.60' 0 z O FOUND 2"X2" CONCRETE p MONUMENT I z I p m FOUND 04-02-13 /7 rti DATE 7- ..Ii41.i I a•..i ��. r:L c p 0 a PM S(Jf� DYING 4546 CAMBRIDGE STREET WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415 OFFICE 561-478-7764 FAX 561-478-1094 Please visit us on the web @ www.pmsurveying.net 3 q S'. &R. � oHIMm m \ o o gg� R� � I 3aa o<S�<ma�OASo Q$ zo�1 �iT mn m�nm�mmmmpm m J1 1 p y 43-r z<�- ai59Mm�nm 5���yy ��11 poip�p n gt i ig ~ - � € d a €€ STS m g O mA D9L�C yrSOm O—C <m rn �Sg x Z 2 Ria R�r� € R3 l�Yr J< �` ; 6'��a�49�`m W�,W��,mmmEmmmmn N s S RAS' a Ila El 1 RA QN; cn cn play / 014F 11 11, 4€4 !"gIN q�@ r R j 15119 IT&II E 9 ��rRR r9 T [^a£ Nu:o �'7�43 �7 '➢Woy��3m �jS. q tis_ ■F qpu 4 Faq■p■p a gG S B r9 ■p aag 33� 3; 3 -; ; F' ; r;� 3� 4S 3 S O g f�g� A lit �R �f � 5,, y N<N< mm mm (a mmfn N�Nm mm N 4i W � mm m INTRACOASTAL WATERWAY '"1 N � � 3aa o<S�<ma�OASo Q$ zo�1 �iT mn m�nm�mmmmpm m J1 1 p y 43-r z<�- ai59Mm�nm 5���yy ��11 poip�p n gt i ig ~ - � € d a €€ STS m g O mA D9L�C yrSOm O—C <m rn �Sg x Z 2 Ria R�r� € R3 l�Yr J< �` ; 6'��a�49�`m W�,W��,mmmEmmmmn N s S RAS' a Ila El 1 RA QN; cn cn play / 014F 11 11, 4€4 !"gIN q�@ r R j 15119 IT&II E 9 ��rRR r9 T [^a£ Nu:o �'7�43 �7 '➢Woy��3m �jS. q tis_ ■F qpu 4 Faq■p■p a gG S B r9 ■p aag 33� 3; 3 -; ; F' ; r;� 3� 4S 3 S O g f�g� A lit �R �f � 5,, y N<N< mm mm (a mmfn N�Nm mm N 4i W � mm m INTRACOASTAL WATERWAY '"1 PM S U RVEY1 N G 4546 Cambridge Street ., West Palm Beach, FL 33415 September 20, 2013 The Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: 3250 Polo Drive To Whom It May Concern: We had previously completed a boundary survey on this property. There was an error on that survey, in that the rear boundary line was incorrectly marked as being on the seawall. We have revised our boundary survey (see attached) to show the rear property corners as being in the water, 4 feet west of the west edge of the seawall. As a result of the revision, we certify the following: Total area of the property: 23,485 SF Effective area of the property: 22,885 SF Should you have any questions or require additional information, please feel free to contact meat (561) 478-7764. Sincerely, a�45z Mark, 4� a't� r�/�-�'°'�•,� ` Pro.ft'. � i ej ,r aid Mapper Fly Certifi -giL :. d 9OO PM Surveying U 4546 Cambridge Street U West Palm Beach, FIL 3:1415 Bus: (561) 478-7764 13 Fax: (561) 478.1094 0 Email: phession@pmsurveying.net SHEET 1 OF 2 Boundary Survey PROPERTYADDRESS: 3250 POLO DRIVE DELRAYBEACH, FLORIDA 33483 FLOOD ZONE: "AY BASE FLOOD ELEVATION 7 Panel No: 125109 0001D Date: 01-05-89 CERTIFIED TO: 1. KEVIN CLARK AND MICHELLE CLARK 2. LOUIS J. CARBONE, P.A. 3. DEVITT, THISTLE & DEVITT P.A. 4. OLD REPUBLIC NATIONAL TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY LEGAL DESCRIPTION: ALL OF LOT 13, AND ALL OF LOT 14, LESS THE SOUTH 50 FEET OF LOT 14, OF POLO COVE, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF ON FILE IN THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 24, PAGE 73, SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING AND BEING IN PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA. FIELD DATE., 04-02-13 LO0 OSCAN pP i ltay�tr� 10% OFF POOL -FENCE -ADDITION ANYFUTURE SURVEYING SERVICES ON THIS PROPERTY LFORABOVE NAMED CLIENT PM SURVEYING 4546 CAMBRIDGE STP,EET S13030216 MOVED SEAWALL JH MOL 09-20-13 ( WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415 S13030216 ADDED ELEV FD MDL 06.04.13 OFFICE 561.478.7764 513030216 ADDED TOPOFD MDL 04-15-13 FAX 561-478.1044 513030216 BOUNDARYSURVEY FD CD 04.02-13 JOB# PURPOSE FIELD DRAFT DATE Please visit us on the web @ www, pmsllrveyilig.net SHEET 2 OF 2 t RIGHT-OF-WAY co LU LU r LP LIGHTPOLE U W o M CATV CABLE TV it CHAIN LINK FENCE �U � J 9 Q C COVERED WM WATERMETER CRS CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE POB tV ca 0 POFVT OF COMMENCEMENT R RECORD F Y U i0'25'06'(M) Please visit Us on the Web etl www.ptnst1Nayitig.net O ❑ � f i 0 ':: ' ' ❑' � Lu 0 3 ABBREVIATIONS CENTERLMIE RAY RIGHT-OF-WAY co CATCHRASIN LP LIGHTPOLE WPP WOOD POWER POLE CATV CABLE TV CLF CHAIN LINK FENCE WF WOOD FENCE CONC CONCRETE COV COVERED WM WATERMETER CRS CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE POB POMITOFSEGMM/MIG POC POFVT OF COMMENCEMENT R RECORD F FIELD Boundary Survey I LOT 12 FOUND SMALL 04-02-13 FOUND X' CUT 10 DRAINAGE TREE DIRECTLY OFFSET5'E4ST -6 4'CLF EASEMENT ON CORNER ' —x — x -- -- 1 PROFt R iF�^ ' 157.46(P) 158.721(m)I FL 4. Dimensions are record and field unless otherwise noted. 69'22'52'(M) I 20 6. This firm's Certificate alAuthorization Numberis LB 6786.�� — , VALVEI 7. Additions ordeletions to survey maps orreports byotherfhan the signing 30.9' 10°00'00"(P) - OFFICE 561-478.7764 90'44'531(M) �. • •+ ,• 4- i0'25'06'(M) Please visit Us on the Web etl www.ptnst1Nayitig.net W 3 � � � f i ! ':: ' ' ❑' � Lu • • FOUND? Ielo0 w W o 2 �j "� j W U m •• I � U LL MONUMENT REMAINDER W 8.0' p U 34.1' • I LOT 13 , 34.1' W I 30 .7' y . `� R CONCRETE: } ;°' GARAGE N PATIO ELEV= 6.21' 7.0' g9 ?•:.:�,, ONE STORY •'- . j.,.5 .� ' RESIDENCE ; • w 4.3' , + FF ELEV = 7.05' �: I Lu. .' . U :.�; 'CL A. o. f.,.. .. \ ,. •. ' I L LOT LINE 8.3' 4.3' ;�., • SITE BENC- MA M SURVEYORS' NOTES:' M15.3' n 23.7' 04-02-13 I '•'• ELEV -4 .62 38.7' PROFt R iF�^ 3. Underground or obscured improvements were not located. FL 4. Dimensions are record and field unless otherwise noted. 5. Stated dimensions take precedence over scaled dimensions. PM 1. I N G 6. This firm's Certificate alAuthorization Numberis LB 6786.�� 1 N I 7. Additions ordeletions to survey maps orreports byotherfhan the signing WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415 10°00'00"(P) - OFFICE 561-478.7764 90'44'531(M) .f.CW. (INS sutveyhas been completed in the absence ofa title Insurance policy). FAX 561478-1094 i0'25'06'(M) Please visit Us on the Web etl www.ptnst1Nayitig.net 10. Elevations refer to NGVD 79 Datum. Originating benchmark is 0.315, a Palle Beach County benchmark. Elevation =15.60' ! ':: ' ' - 4' CLF 155.68(P) 155.67(M) WPP �• \ FOUND X' CUT FOUND? Ielo0 OFFSET5'EAST CONCRETE MONUMENT REMAINDER I o LOT 13 TOTAL AND EFFECTIVE LOT AREAS: `� o TOTAL LOT AREA= 23,485 sq.lt. EFFECTIVE (DRY L07) AREA= 22,885 sq.rt. SURVEYORS' NOTES:' 1.1 HEREBY CERTIFYM surveymeets Minimum Technical Standards 04-02-13 pursuant to Section 472.027, Florida Statutes. 2. The survey map and report and the copies thereof ars not valid without the DATE 9l y hX+ L �� signature and the original raised seal of a Florida licensed surveyor and mapper, PROFt R iF�^ 3. Underground or obscured improvements were not located. FL 4. Dimensions are record and field unless otherwise noted. 5. Stated dimensions take precedence over scaled dimensions. PM 1. I N G 6. This firm's Certificate alAuthorization Numberis LB 6786.�� 4546 CAMBRIDGE STREET 7. Additions ordeletions to survey maps orreports byotherfhan the signing WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415 parfyorparties is prohibited without written consent of the signing party orpadies. - OFFICE 561-478.7764 8. Surveysub)ecf to reservations, restrictions, easements and rights-ol-way .f.CW. (INS sutveyhas been completed in the absence ofa title Insurance policy). FAX 561478-1094 9. Location map Is gleaned from online mapping sties and ands only approximate. Please visit Us on the Web etl www.ptnst1Nayitig.net 10. Elevations refer to NGVD 79 Datum. Originating benchmark is 0.315, a Palle Beach County benchmark. Elevation =15.60' j \p 150.00'(P) 150.33(M) -, --- --- - ---- 1 2' CONC. SEAWALL 8.3'. _ _ - _-- 0.9'i "BUL.KHE ,lo I LINE k To y O ------- y r-� ®------ __ ® L ------ -------------------- Ea 18.7' WL IL ---------_ I° I • CA J I i I 11 I - - - r -- -, � -- I 1 -a 00 cri ' LqV X0 i i - --- 1_. -------- -, a 5'rn 51 l ffi 0 a o�vz 4 Vzz z HEAD —�4 ❑ C m NAIL SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 08-22-13 CLARK RESIDENCE 3250 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM, FL a . (POLO W "' m DRIVE cr a a 30 c7------ —� - cr 18'ASPHALT o m n \ z >< y jcn §m 0 z a m z �tI kkRANDALESTOFFT O ARCHITECTS N r € distinctive. inspirationalarchitecture. NAIL SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 08-22-13 CLARK RESIDENCE 3250 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM, FL a . a 00 0 r v Cl) O N O O 1T 3 Q m STUCCO WALLS FRONT DOOR/ GATES W silver satin (benjamin moore oc-26) stain Y U %l Cn c .3 cLa U) ca ED /w z snowfall white OC-118 0 W _ Y OUTRIGGERS/ TRIMS/ RAILINGS snowfall white (benjamin moore oc-118) o FLAT ROOF TILE co o It O M i U) Q J Q U `r-ti s Y U �)vemnq dove 2128-30 + l W / SHUTTERS DRIVEWAY PAVERS evening dove (benjamin moore 2128-30) diMhRAND CLARK RESIDENCE A Ft C H H I T E C T S ECT S distlnctive. Insplretbnal. art;FrHedure 3250 POLO DRIVE Delray Beach, Naples, The Cardbean GULFSTEAM, FLORIDA 10-10-2013 PM S U RVEYI N G (CNA) G 4546 Cambridge Street 14 ., West Palm Beach, FL 33415 September 20, 2013 The Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Re: 3250 Polo Drive To Whom It May Concern: We had previously completed a boundary survey on this property. There was an error on that survey, in that the rear boundary line was incorrectly marked as being on the seawall. We have revised our boundary survey (see attached) to show the rear property corners as being in the water, 4 feet west of the west edge of the seawall. As a result of the revision, we certify the following: Total area of the property: 23,485 SF Effective area of the property: 22,885 SF Should you have any questions or require additional information, please feel free to contact meat (561) 478-7764. Sincerely, Ma&VO .. a'x� lARI-,;, 4c4 6. /� Proch`i86.r�ad Mapper PM Surveying U 4546 Cambridge Street U West Palm Heach, FL 334115 Bus: (561) 478-7764 0 Fax: (561) 478-1094 0 Email: phession@pmsurveying.net JT I OF2 undary Survey PROPERTYADDRESS: 3250 POLO DRIVE DELRAYBEACH, FLORIDA 33483 FLOOD ZONE.• "A5" BASE FLOOD ELEVATION 7 Panel NO: 125109 0001 D Date: 01-05-89 CERTIFIED TO; '• KEVIN CLARKAND MICHELLE CLARK 2. LOUIS J. CARBONE, P.A. 3. DEVITT THISTLE & DEVITT,, P.A. 4• OLD REPUBLIC NATIONAL TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY LEGAL DESCRIPTION: ALL OFLOT 13, AND ALL OFLOT 14, LESS THE 50 FEET SOUTH OFLOT 14, OFPOLO COVE, ACCORDING TO THSOUTE PLA H THEREOF ON FILE IN THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 24, PAGE 73, SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING AND BEING IN PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA. FIELD DA TE., 04-02-13 —1057,,—OFF— I POOL-FENCE-ADD/770N ANYFUTURE I SURVEYING I SERVICES I ON THIS PROPER 7Y LFORABOVE NAMED CLIENT- I -k 513030216 M Mo SEE 1.yAL1 PM SURVEYING S730J0216 i 13030216 ADDED ADDED EL ✓H FD M� B9 -2B-13 , / 4546 CAMBRIDGE STREET 13030716 ADDED TOPp BOUNDARY 3URVEY Po MDL MDL 06-04.13 04-15-13 WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415 OBI1 PURPOSE CD 04-07-13 OFFICE 561-478.7764 FIELD DRAFT DATE FAX 561-478.1094 Please visit us On the web @ wwwpmsurveying.net -k SHEET 2 OF 2 � .n - FOUND 3CCUT10ORAINAGE —OFFSET YEAST ,�0 4'CLF - — — — -, Lor 12 — — 157.46(P) 158.72'—M I I FOUND SMALL TREEDIRECTLY I EASEMENT ON CORNER 4 t B9°22'52'0 Pi 90'25'06"( M) ' J��(M)— r scaled 5. Slated dimensions take precedence over scaled dime $ m —I— — — _:s.' —• n I ,' -- VALVE 7. Additions or deletions to survey maps orrepods by other than the signing 9 U O FOUND 'X' CUT 30.9' 26.1' FOUND 2'X2' ;. f I FAX 561.478-1094 9. Location map is gleaned from online mapping sites and and is only approximate. ( I OFFSETS'EAST 10. Elevations refer to NGVD'29 Datum. Originating benchmark is D-315, a Palm Beach County benchmark. Eleval ar = 15.60' CONCRETE RrW • • 4 •� c � 3LUI W � z II o �LU a N U �!+ � � I MONUMENT 111. LP UM 2 d m W U I I zo WPP `^ �� cT3 TY �C LL p W 8.0, Z. :. '. CAN CABLE TV J' j I U 34.1' .6 _.._ .. ' I ~ U m KUM FENCE 34.1' W I t" •.,' .,,�. CONC CONCRETE W `' •. LUi f % o EFFECTIVE (DRY LOT)AREA= 22,885sq.8. z ~o '� 'CONCRETE •� ;'� a o N GARAGE I PATIOa CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE ELEV = 6.21' POB POWT OF BEGINNING t �'ONE • POC POINT OF COMMENCEMENT o 'r' STORY r ,e 9 RECORD W .,.5• , o 3 +' •1 RESIDENCE ; J. W. NAIL + i.• ; . FF ELEV - 7.05' r • a: • Q 3 4'oiu;.. � :oI ..LU 9� v OI Lr -' -L LOTTIWE.;.I. 4 ��• 8.3'� 4.3' ', i•: '. ';�• SITEBENC.. p0 WAIL II�PA M ELEV - 4.62 0 o .1 Z. 9 23.T "I •. 38.T / z O 11 z 0 Boundary Survey SURVEYORS'NOTES: 90"00'00"(P) 04-02-13 ' 90'44'53"(M) DATE signature and the odgmal raised seal of a Florida licensed surveyor and mapper. 3. Underground or obscured improvements were not located. Pi 90'25'06"( M) r scaled 5. Slated dimensions take precedence over scaled dime . ABBREVIATIONS o 4'cLF 155.68'(P) 155.67'(M) WPP 7. Additions or deletions to survey maps orrepods by other than the signing ?�N rk CENTE7LME FOUND 'X' CUT FOUND 2'X2' I of record. jThis survey has been completed in the absence of a title insurance policy). FAX 561.478-1094 9. Location map is gleaned from online mapping sites and and is only approximate. ( I OFFSETS'EAST 10. Elevations refer to NGVD'29 Datum. Originating benchmark is D-315, a Palm Beach County benchmark. Eleval ar = 15.60' CONCRETE RrW RIGHT-OF-WAY I a CB CATCHBASW MONUMENT LP LIGHTPOLE I REMAINDER I I zo WPP WOOD POWER POLE LOT 13 9� CAN CABLE TV CLF CHAIN LOW FENCE WF KUM FENCE TOTAL AND EFFECTIVELOTAREAS: CONC CONCRETE TOTAL LOT AREA= 23,485 sq.2 COVERED EFFECTIVE (DRY LOT)AREA= 22,885sq.8. WM WM WATER METER CBS CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE POB POWT OF BEGINNING POC POINT OF COMMENCEMENT R RECORD FOUND F FIELD NAIL Boundary Survey SURVEYORS'NOTES: 1. I HEREBY CERTIFY this survey meats Minimum Technical Standards 04-02-13 ' pursuant to Section 472.027, Florida Statutes. 2. The surveymapandrepod and the copies thereo/are not valid wiOlout the DATE signature and the odgmal raised seal of a Florida licensed surveyor and mapper. 3. Underground or obscured improvements were not located. 4. Dimensions are record and Geld unless noted. r scaled 5. Slated dimensions take precedence over scaled dime � P G LB 678ions. 6. This firm's Certificate of Authodzafion Numberis LB 6788, 4596 (-AMBRIDGE STREET 7. Additions or deletions to survey maps orrepods by other than the signing WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415 parlyorparties is prohibited without written consent ofthe signing party orparties, S. Survey subject to reservations, restrictions, easements anddghts-ol--way OFFICE 561-478.7764 of record. jThis survey has been completed in the absence of a title insurance policy). FAX 561.478-1094 9. Location map is gleaned from online mapping sites and and is only approximate. Please VISIT Us On the well @ www.pmsiirNeyiiig.net 10. Elevations refer to NGVD'29 Datum. Originating benchmark is D-315, a Palm Beach County benchmark. Eleval ar = 15.60' j J \ 150.00'(P) 150.33(M) ____ _________T 2'CONC. SEawau 0.9' 5' BULKHE c 22 o LIfJE x o ~�IS 8:1 IFl — I - Il ------ --------- ---- p I------- .-n I I I I I I '— ___—_____�—__ ________________ _ 1;5.T o �e E ----------- y, vel _ 4_____-.'u� ___{ ___— L cn � I ao - I ---i I------- 1A, I j I 1llu�_` J7I . u ' I opo w ; -E RD I Xo I I , I I r ! _'� I Ca L--- -- -�- --- ----- I rn n rn 5' 51i—icn I q I X cii r _ " 1 O—Icii - W A_ !J' 4 `� I = 1 D DIY(P)1WOZ(M) o mzy -- r -M Z POLO DRIVE l 18'ASPHALT—C— — y —fOUND-- AW—L eq F ce ,�a §m 0 z D m v z SITE PLAN REVIEW SUBMISSION 08-22-13 Om� NI,R iCLRK RESIDENCE EN CE 1.11 ARCHITECTS3250POLO DRIVE I QR �R � N distinctive. inspirational. architecture. GULF STREAK FL STUCCO WALLS silver satin (benjamin moore oc-26) 0 snowfall white OC -118 OUTRIGGERS/ TRIMS/ RAILINGS snowfall white (benjamin moore oc-118) SHUTTERS evening dove (benjamin moore 2128-30) CLARK RESIDENCE 3250 POLO DRIVE GULFSTEAM, FLORIDA FRONT DOOR/ GATES stain FLAT ROOF TILE DRIVEWAY PAVERS 111WR.ANDALL STOFFT A R C H I T E C T S distlnclive. Insplretlonal. architecture Delray Beach, Naples, The Carribean 10-10-2013 i� TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-15 Owner: Kevin & Michelle Clark Address: 3250 Polo Drive Agent: Randall Stofft Architects Proposed Improvement: Construct a Bermuda style, partial 2 story, single family dwelling. Approvals Requested: Demolition Permit: To demolish existing structures. Land Clearing Permit: To clear site for construction. Special Exception (1): To allow 236 SF of covered unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum Floor Area Ratio. Special Exception (2): To permit rear waterfront setback of 30' Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a Bermuda style, partial 2 story, single-family dwelling with attached garage, pool and pavilion, a total of 7,552 SF. Gross Lot Size: 23,485 SF Effective Lot Area: 22,885 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 7,552 SF Allowable: 7,321 SF; + Special Exception 236 SF = 7,557 Zoning District: RS -C FFE: 7.5' NGVD Considered During Review: Height: 30.0' (Preferred 530',15t Story 5 22.0') Chapter 48 Flood Prevention and Protection Note: FFE of existing structure is below the Flood Zone 100 -year storm event of 7.0' FFE. Rules could be changing in the near future to approximately 7.50. NGVD. Application is at 7.5' NGVD. Section 70-67. Effective lot area. Section 70-71. Floor area ratios. (c) Incentive floor area ratio. (1) For new structures in all districts, FAR may be increased to .33 for first 20,000 SF of lot area plus .25 for portions above that if a minimum ten foot setback is provided on any multi -story front setback in addition to the minimum required front setback. Note: Application is compliant. Section 70-72 Special exception floor area ratio (FAR) (b) Roof projections. Up to 300 SF of roof projections (covered, unenclosed floor areas) may exceed the maximum permissible FAR... Note: Application is compliant. Section 70-74. Setbacks. Section 70-75. Special exception setbacks (j). The minimum setback for water front lots in the Core District may be reduced to ... 30'. CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy George Delafield, Jr. Robert Dockerty October 17, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, OCTOBER 24, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 9-26-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. November 21, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. December 19, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. C. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Jose Gonzalez, Gonzalez Architects as agent for Dennis & Lanore McDonagh owners of property located at 530 Middle Rd., Gulf Stream, Florida legally described as Lt. 18 and 50 Ft. of Lt. 17, Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision for the following: DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish existing pool, screen enclosure and all windows. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a new pool, glass patio canopy, new front entry porch, and installation of impact resistant windows to the existing one-story single family home, and with some new landscaping being included. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 26, 2013, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: Chairman Morgan called the meeting to order at 8:35 A.M II. Roll Call: Present and Scott Morgan Chairman Participating Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member Absent w/Notice Amanda Jones Board Member Absent w/Notice George Delafield Alternate Member Also Present and William H. Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk John C. Randolph Town Counsel Richard Jones Architect Thomas Laudani Developer David Bodker Landscape Architect Billy Himmelrich Resident Carlos Linares Architect Maureen Smith Landscape Architect Katareyna Meleda Property Representative III. Minutes: A. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on May 23, 2013 B. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on July 25, 2013 Chairperson Morgan reported that at both meetings Board Member Murphy and Alternate Member Delafield were absent with notice. Board Member Murphy moved and Board Member Lyons seconded the approval of the amended minutes of May 23, 2013 and July 25, 2013. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: There were none. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Chairman Morgan held a discussion amongst the Board Members regarding the holiday season meeting dates. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream September 26, 2013 — Page 2 Chairman Morgan announced the following approved ARPB meeting dates: a. October 24, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. November 21, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. c. December 19, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. d. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. f March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Morgan asked for ex -parte and there was none. He also asked for any persons speaking at this meeting to be sworn in. Town Clerk Taylor swore in David Bodker, Billy Himmelrich, Carlos Linares, Maureen Smith and Katareyna Meleda. VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Dave Bodker, Landscape Architect as agent for 1275 North Ocean Blvd., LLC, owners of property located at 1275 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Palm Beach Shore Acres Rev. Pl. Blks. D & E, S 50 ft. of Lt. 6 & Lt. 7 Blk. D a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to install privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping at the existing beach access. b. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the installation of a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping to an existing beach access. Mr. Bodker introduced himself and stated he was representing Seaside Builders, with regard to the beach access easement at 1275 North Ocean Blvd. He described the existing conditions and displayed, while discussing, the design that he was presenting. Mr. Bodker reported in detail the landscaping features with the two (2) 3 -foot aluminum gates that would be installed. He continued that the path would be sand, as it is at present. Mr. Bodker stated that he has been in contact with the next door neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. Knobel, conveyed the plans to them, did a walk through with them, and there were no problems with them. He discussed and displayed the colors being used for the columns and walls. Mr. Bodker reported that the property is 25-26 feet from the edge of A1A. Chairman Morgan stated he liked the idea of both gates. Board Member Lyons inquired regarding the beach access. Mr. Bodker stated that there were fifteen (15) homes that had access to this area. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream September 26, 2013 — Page 3 Mr. Himmelrich, a resident at 1304 North Ocean Boulevard for fifteen (15) years introduced himself. He reported that he has a copy of the deed and stated that everyone in that area should have a recorded deed. Mr. Himmelrich continued that anyone that does not have a recorded deed should not be able to use the beach access. Mr. Himmelrich stated that he has paid landscapers over the years to maintain the beach access area. He offered his help with any beach access issues, and that he is in favor of this project. Chairman Morgan stated that this project will be an improvement to the area. Board Member Murphy moved and Vice -Chairman Smith seconded to approve the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit for the installation of a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping at the existing beach access. All vote AYE. Board Member Murphy moved and Vice -Chairman Smith seconded to approve the Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit the installation of a privacy gate, columns, walls, aluminum picket fencing and landscaping of the existing beach access which meets the minimum intent of the design manual. All vote AYE. 2. An Application submitted by Randall Stofft Architects as agent for Kevin & Michelle Clark owners of property located at 3250 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 13 and part of Lot 14, Polo Cove Subdivision for the following: a. DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish existing structures. b. LAND CLEARING PERMIT to clear site for new construction. c. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to allow 236 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum Floor Area Ratio. d. SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit rear waterfront setback of 30'. e. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a Bermuda style, partial 2 -story, single-family dwelling with attached garage, pool and pavilion, a total of 7,552 square feet. Mr. Linares, Randall Stofft Architects, introduced himself and described and displayed the rendering of the partial 2 -story Bermuda Style home. He stated that the home has the proper setbacks. Mr. Linares reported that the home has 6,000 square feet under A/C, and a total of 7,552 square feet. He continued that the height limitations were met. Maureen Smith, Landscape Architect Delray Beach described the buffering from the neighbors of the home. She continued that she utilized a great deal of native materials. Ms. Smith highlighted in detail the landscaping from the renderings. She discussed the privacy hedge which is very maintainable, and the other manicured and clipped vegetation. Ms. Smith reported that it will be a very nice Palm Beach, Florida landscape. Chairman Morgan inquired if there were any comments received from the neighbors and Town Clerk Taylor advised there had been no comments. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream September 26, 2013 — Page 4 Board Member Lyons stated that the neighbors were not in Town, and questioned the procedure of informing them of this project Town Clerk Taylor responded that there was a mailing sent to the neighbors at their address listed on their tax bill. Katareyna Meleda stated she represents the neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. Hagen, at 3232 Polo Drive, and their concern is regarding the privacy on the south side of their property. She continued that Mr. and Mrs. Hagen will be returning to Town the beginning of November, and spend only 3-4 months in Town. Ms. Meleda also inquired regarding when construction will begin and how long it would take to complete. Ms. Smith reported that no privacy would be taken away from what is there now. Chairman Morgan discussed the importance of privacy and how all property owners request that. Board Member Lyons inquired about outdoor lighting plans for this home. Mr. Linares responded that at this time there are no outdoor -landscape lighting plans, but that he will make a proposal at a later date. He continued that there are two (2) sconces at the front entry of the house, and on the each side of the garage. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the location of the pool pavilion bathrooms stating he had two (2) different site -plans. Mr. Linares reported that the #A101 is the correct one, and that #A102 is not valid any longer. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the air -flow of the pavilion. Mr. Linares stated that the pavilion will be connected to a small trellis, not a large feature, but rather a garden feature to create a bridge effect between the house and the pavilion, and the structure is open to allow the free flow of the air. Chairman Morgan inquired if the color of the home would be white. Mr. Linares responded that it would be a very light color, possibly on a white tone. Chairman Morgan also asked the type of roof. Mr. Linares replied that it will be a flat -tile roof, probably grey, and when he is able to obtain roof samples, he will present his proposal to the Town. Chairman Morgan asked for any further comments or questions. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream September 26, 2013 — Page 5 Town Manager Thrasher pointed out that there was a typo under Level 3 on the Staff Report stating "a total of 7,557 square feet". He continued that it should read 7,552 square feet. and also stated that all landscaping must be located on private property. Chairman Morgan stated that when Mr. Linares comes before Staff, they would handle those things and have everything spelled out. Town Manager Thrasher repeated that he was concerned that all the plantings and landscaping (not grass), in the front of the home, were on private property, not in the right of way. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the setbacks. Town Manager Thrasher reported in the core district, Code Section 70-75 allows for a special exception to reduce the rear waterfront setback from 50 ft. to 30 ft. He stated that in his review all code standards have been met. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if there is a similar structure there at the present time. Mr. Linares stated there were two (2) one-story detached homes on the location. Chairman Morgan asked for any further questions. There were none. Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Murphy seconded to approve a DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish the existing structures. All voted AYE. Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Murphy seconded to approve a LAND CLEARING PERMIT to clear the site for new construction. All voted AYE. Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Murphy seconded to approve SPECIAL EXCEPTION #1 to allow 236 square feet of covered, unenclosed area that exceeds the maximum Floor Area Ratio. All voted AYE. Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Murphy seconded to approve SPECIAL EXCEPTION #2 to permit rear waterfront setback of 30 ft. All voted AYE. Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Murphy seconded to approve a LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a Bermuda style, partial 2 -story, single-family dwelling with attached garage, pool and pavilion, a total of 7,552 square feet with the following conditions: (1) All boat lift ancillary fixtures shall conform to Section 66-369 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code (2) Utilities shall be underground (3) Outdoor lighting color selections and roof materials shall be presented for approval prior to completion of the approval process and (4) Landscaping in front shall all be installed on private property, not in the right of way. All voted AYE. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream September 26, 2013 — Page 6 VII. ITEMS BY STAFF: Town Manager Thrasher updated the progress of the Town's undergrounding project. He advised surveying the locations for the transformers and the staking of the sites is starting. Town Manager Thrasher reported that Place An Soleil is being included in upgrading of the street signs. He reported that the custom lighting on AIA has been eliminated in favor of replacing the existing poles with smaller poles with the Cobra fixtures in place of the Viper fixtures. This change resulted in a savings of $300,000. He continued that there will be no overhead lines once the project has been completed. Board Member Lyons inquired when the ground breaking will take place at the south end of Town. Town Manager Thrasher reported optimistically the surveyors will be putting in at least one (1) stake on September 30'". Board Member Lyons questioned if there would be any increase costs in this project with further delays. Town Manager Thrasher stated he did not expect that to be the case. VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: Vice -Chairman Smith inquired when restrictions on building activities are in effect. Town Manager Thrasher stated certain construction activities are restricted beginning on December 1, 2013 but that temporary exemptions for certain activities can be given. Chairman Morgan inquired where the restricted activities information was listed in the Town's Code. Town Manager Thrasher responded either in Section 22 or 41. Town Clerk Taylor stated "In the Nuisance Section". Chairman Morgan asked what action has been taken with regard to Code clarification and modification. Town Counsel Randolph reported that there were no changes made at this time. He continued that at the next Commission Meeting there will be a finalization of appointments for the Ad Hoc Committee. Town Counsel Randolph stated then this Committee will begin studying the code, prior to making their suggestions, which could take some time, possibly months, or longer. IX. PUBLIC: There were none. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream September 26, 2013 — Page 7 X. ADJOURNMENT: Chairman Morgan adjourned the meeting at 9:15 A.M. Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-16 Owner: Dennis & Lanore McDonagh Address: 530 Middle Road Agent: Jose Gonzalez, Gonzalez Architects Proposed Improvement: Demolition of existing pool, screen enclosure and all windows, construction of a new pool, glass patio canopy, new front entry porch and installation of impact resistant windows. Approvals Requested: Demolition Permit: To demolish existing pool, screen enclosure and all windows. Level II Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a new pool, glass patio canopy, new front entry porch, and installation of impact resistant windows to the existing one-story single family home, and with some new landscaping being included. Gross Lot size: 23250 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 6,646 SF Zoning District: RS -C Finished Floor: 8.21" NGVD Main Issues Considered During Review: Section 66-369 Docks Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-101 Windows Effective Lot Area: 22,500 SF Allowable: 7,100 SF Height: Existing 18.2', New Entry 12' 11 1/" Note: Some window opening sizes on south elevation are discouraged. Section 70-187 Table of district standards Motion to approve of the demolition permit to remove existing pool, screen enclosure and all windows. Motion to approve Level II Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed demolition and construction of a new pool, glass patio canopy, new front entry porch, and installation of impact resistant windows to the existing on -story single family home, with some new landscaping being included meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the follozving conditions: 1. Service line shall be buried if they are not already. 2. Any work on the seawall, seawall cap, existing boat lift and existing dock shall conform to Section 66-369 Docks. 3. Driveway removal agreement shall be signed for recording prior to permitting. Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM b- RECEIVED OCT 08 2013 Town cif Gulfstream, R APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File #13-16 PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information I.A.I. Project/Owner Name: MC1c>y -Si# R€S�cg 0(s L4M-Q'- k�&r I.A.2. Project Address I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: 1>cA r c>C- L_IULFcST�IN i eve: 5c:'Pr c�F ice' 17 !S I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) J)zno(,'S(a fix" Sri SC.�E�1� EN(.Ia�sR� XW %ANbcxl . %T* i w ot_t (qc.AsS c04 t.N o n D+ticfi- cN rw�,�S� kD� N FW art IZ S mE7 t M p{1,oJ-- HEATS AS Uvc:�W f4 t >M T4 -e 5 1 "rIE _ I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style:/C�r h� /�j m4cf-)S S3N t9f 1.A.6. Check all that apply: Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) S( Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: f Type of Foundation:/Ar . B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: -5,30 l'c, 344f L f I.B2. Owner Phone Number: Fax: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: *>RZALEZ I.C.2. Agent Address: .-; , j b� �'v i`I r M('tNN 1PL. 33132. I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) c��LJ5t3_'L{Zjfo cell 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: Official Use Only ARPB Date: Recommendation: TC Date: If 4' e 4615,- lo -4-13 Application for Development Approval Form ADA2000 revised 6/13/00 Fax Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? ��j—(.IV SiI t31At. St &L6 fplr of , III.A.2. Is the project compactible with the intent of the zoning district ? (2e0 No Explain:—C'i�- -C (l�({`sC�t' 15 t��1i�111 �1,d W t'T III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? Ee� No Explain: ��� �i14��- I i �►Ni�. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? kiSsiNi;j D9iVCWk1*? T6 Ch1lkitl lks SfbVid c.HT c�Si P�," III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided, ,to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage �xiS`c Nt1�cci b. Sanitary Sewer ( r�Na 4`lprt' c. Potable water l , -t—;L-, d. Irrigation Water EDtc'S To e. Electricity EKt��N b, T-6 f. Telephone E�rvm o A -t g. Gas ( 'N h. Cable Television rK i C W u& cry, V _QW A4 �v III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes (E)(If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? IS) No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes No (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the pro' ct at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes No (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 6.vn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.13.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: _ IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? �' M `6(- T- t' IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? JKVJIEti:A'�.L`I IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 lr(D Ln ri 0-D- 5-0" 150'-0- Ilct knpih for ft—. bt Deal 3 CL 0 LD Li C) as ---------- ft-t 1 J IT ----- .. . . . . - Qac 4' 17 0 .3 7 E o :F .1 .1 0 7 TomoLl 11 AU A MM -532. p R� Gl �­aS�As a 0 C -j fs I Z is Ln ri 0-D- 3 CL 0 LD Li C) D m nc G) O my 3 m z D O D r C -i m G') n o ao mCD - m o m r - v � 41 m m `° m =3 w v r- r -v ® O m o L.3 m �cnw co o, w N p�j CD N 7 C o D1 CO 0 G� 00 D r w cn V, rr 0 N N ■M -W rn 70 O O O CT(D > N O c w XX EBD 9f�001-Q 00000>, ft:Ei FF ccg tiv�.-,0 u, yuy,mmy aaa� p app pap ppppa^yp opQooz zz;;i�gr^ TT pm mmm m opo° °p°pnpn a J21 i?: in amooFA? :z mr �.vm� aaoo3-L�nppmm_-7iAi'C?-� a°„ oo��immap i�"=°mm��;oos6vxm�' -+3m nm �;Dpm nF� $a zn zaayya ZZ mma tE'* S£m Lm t��iig5p���''ii my mm mmaaAAA Za� >a>av v v va yvsy Qo o aZZy'i' �ixrr;�x-- minimz rmr�x xQ}'xi�xinn= n� xZmx �isa> <a�m�oTzo �mA2 y O�ZD Oymsp�rmxy�a-IOOOmaymmmaO Ao�Cs;m NOZmp'p SmpmA<y ��°A$2 ovmo{�ijCQ=�Zbxynm 8 is �j)i m a m �nm 89W. mix T � £$ $TT $$^ $ m ; m oT $g a $ mg mgm roT^TT r;� HIM? pz 'o°°m°a� aFm 3�°ya°m Zio°ig^ mgs �Z y -aim° So �A��moii nO en a ' a S mm T _ m ' a V �� iC �i �F ~ �a mu,O�ng oo c�a 0V u; mx y�z�"� c.�� � a°� � � n ° "$ m�smp> > MV �m m mi" z o m aZo�px FZmo= iiia z� �Ao> ! m TA m a zC �i°� m �$oyi A am$ m > H".00,20 xm mrd 1" x'� moms n M I R°m e m z I I I 155.00' � =m m� 0 ^° ;l a'! 11 N� O REMAINING WEST 50' OF LOT 17 rc nlnr a agar nr �M c- 'ORIGINAL WEST LINE OF POLO ORNE' y1� 0.2t1 N a 0 POLO DRIVE u Z6Z€ 0 N I I I 155.00' � =m m� 0 ^° ;l a'! 11 N� O REMAINING WEST 50' OF LOT 17 rc nlnr a agar nr �M c- 'a! x� �� � ai y$ 'ORIGINAL WEST LINE OF POLO ORNE' AS LABELED ON PUT OF GULF 51REAM� COVE (P.B. 24, PG. 185) - — POLO DRIVE u T mNo Nao 0 N m_ t 2 O _, � N + r r O b en V m m i F i N +� yar- au'o H� FpmFt��'3F�F a� mo?. ga ZI m A g! a C 3 �_ mu,- ° '-�.o m a � F m� +1p. let. i -I tt �BF�.�a;Q 'a; -. no a' a m rn ° en.N puu aN 4 yZy B ji 8 Ln Co 'a! x� �� � ai y$ 1- G) rnZ a m N 0 o W z h 'ORIGINAL WEST LINE OF POLO ORNE' AS LABELED ON PUT OF GULF 51REAM� COVE (P.B. 24, PG. 185) - — POLO DRIVE u T mNo Nao N t 2 $m yar- au'o H� a� ga ZI m A g! a C 3 ° � m no a m rn ° en.N puu aN yZy Ln Co 1- G) rnZ a m N 0 o W z h 0 c n 0 m O' 0 S.° �0 CD a CD ° U z - v ®om No ° m m oO /SPS 3 nt I f ya' i Nil 3 CD ICD ?Z HO CD (D p7Q N (n 3 7 30 �•'N fD D ❑ 7 a s ❑ 7 O IJ O p 3 ❑ O U C lT (D 0 (1 (D N 0 7 Gi ° w T O T .L N T Om0a-N((fir �a NtiD � N �N NO y000 X70-Oc O N W f 7 S c 7 Q o n n a n O O 3 O j .zO o n 0 N -. 7 z D. D 7 m w� 7 7 n t�j j a (D ❑ ❑ ❑ D c N a ,n O v o (S N 0 D) ° ~ n z O < fl (D ❑. 7 . O O O d P N p o — a m 7 7 n C a C D m o m ❑ N W p n"� ❑ N !D (DD O N N O X D �^ p S < y Or D N Q 3 S C C =• Z O p C. p • U 7 a 0 U N N x '(w, O ❑ n ❑ p c 7 (p O o o D m�i II II (D A °. ° D N❑ O v "� y n �... D .. ? 004 ° (D a W <�7. 11 0 m 7 D o £ a T 0 7o 'o m �3 m w .. p (p W m �' a < c p(N(t� N a�fp(Dom N C3.D 3 3 6 _b o o m m a o n n m m o T v WIN �4:�.- y ��. `1 `.;ea.'re'rfgj,u'� -. *� O O 7 30 ° � D m w 3 � 0 Q ❑ 3 -°p CD 07 � ((^^N{, O AO N ,p N -. N O l.! Nt O 0 CD P -_« n CD N (n O -� n N G C m_n x?$$ ° P 3 w °p 4f S. F'derallYnrlr C'lo N $ U $ x o 3 i CD cl >, CD 0 N M CD _...0 9 NOcexu tkvd:` :T.,, cn 30 A -61] A O w c G 0 w� v < N r a z N and A z p A ° P :EI A a D $ m On � $ m m 4 Vpp O~ C, o Pp P T A O W N p n o U n -PN o° ® `✓ OVl Nil 3 CD ICD a�. TI c O• COL^1 t U 0£ _ Z O O O O V 0 0 O rn N O o O n 71 D D - N n W n < C RD O o C❑ O O v O 9 t0 p C n N A D N I# A va ° Q n z ❑ \ m 3 0 < ' ❑ 3 m oJ m `V ❑ o ° F m o n o p o x m p D o n❑ o m0 -a. m O m ° V 0 n O o <o x 0 ❑ m n O Q O ❑ f O A o ° Y �G ❑ O Y> N C c H A ° v G o nn N 0 0 2 2 c m' c ry O n N 0 Z ❑ ❑ ❑ J ❑ 3 n n o 0 0 0 j `m ❑ o o ° - n m a a m n n o o m 3 n o _ n m a n m ? C)° 3 o N C. o 10 n m o 0 N 0 CD o o m 3a o o J 3 o J Q ° ° n 3 n ° n n n m° z n z z O c o 0 3 3 3 cD ❑ N N� \ n 3 n n ° m 3 3 3 3 c 3 ° 3 3 o 03 J oJ N a J Q J J o n 3 v 3 3 n N c D N o ° n 3 � 3 o n m o 0 0 o 0 A 3 3 3 3 o O ID CL J a a S CD a OD. m m > J ❑❑ n n p D oa o m a n na o ❑ ❑ _ N o m A p W O O p n n p p n 0£ n O _ O V 0 0 0 rn N .D o n Q m a D N n W n < C, RD O o C❑ O O v O 9 t0 p C n N A D N I# A va ° Q n z ❑ 0£ n O _ O V 0 0 0 rn N .D o n m a no N n W n < C, RD O o C❑ O O v m J _ 0 t0 p C n N A D J ° A va ° Q n z ❑ \ m 3 0 < ' ❑ 3 m oJ om, ID o ° F m o n o p o (D p D o n❑ o m0 -a. m 0 n o 3 3 o J 0 0 ❑' o <o x 0 ❑ m n i a o ° f ❑ 0 ° v v o nn N c ry O n N 0 Z ❑ ❑ ❑ J o 0 0 0 j ❑ o o ° - n o m n o m 3 o _ n m a m ? C)° 3 o o n o 0 0 o = 3a o J 3 o Q ° o 3 0 A n 00_ _ t0 O QCD m cD o 00 N t0 O 3 ❑ J % 1.L rn G o n m a no N n W n '" C, RD O o N m O v m J _ 0 C n N A D J ° A va ° n z ❑ \ ' ❑ 3 m om, ID o ° F m o n o p o p D o n❑ o m0 -a. m 0 n o 3 3 o J a 0 ° ❑ ❑ m 3 0 W n ��^••••�� !! % 1.L 3Q G W n '" 0 00 S..L CIE � D S / \ Ilufrp I 1 r � m A r' 7 r ❑ I / I m ° ® I I 1\ r I � g N ® (D 42) ♦vr L_ I > \) IE :1 r- - I L-- 00 O ❑.... ❑ O L_J L_J O O O O ❑ El El DD om 000 m O O f —1 O \J Z m to O I I I II O I o> I I os I II N mi II F fO o I I I I II 1 O L ------J I----------- i O 0 ml a� Q ® < 3 TO � Q ro oril u, B w ® �� -, A — w ��. E i " N ` cp O ��o GMl aa 3 r cri N rn CD C7 Da CD�� N 3Q Q o w (D n � vT-3 w O CD Q MAI /V AZ � m 3T V �4E3� r—.� ��3 ] V P fn A W N Z Z m Z Z T T Z U0 !H:Eg ��ff.>> o D O C �O 0�_0 - N crn O O OCD m 11 a CCD O -370 p (J1 0 0Q' p n Q m. � m �3n.33CD < 3 m o _ 0 o a O J O > p p= CD o'o m N N�� p l 0 p -o p p a o CL o �o 5 p ' m m Dm as O D n no 1. IR 1 W I I?/% 45, HHa �� � 00%i aY ��(DE3 DoL" E3 F{: Q T C=3 ss�� ��Q lI�� 5 � 00%i ��(DE3 DoL" NCD F{: O T C=3 0 ��Q r 9��0 I�� c+��N� r' p , PR`_�_ `O�� tJ T r, ?I G) U Tli --- 0 of ��(DE3 DoL" 3Q O T ��Q Q(Q CC) a u 1 0 z =� f m m m m m o 0 0 � s CL m CIL 0 'm 0 4 3 S 1-0 ul Fo p c o o, v� LCD — n ® 3a O (D 3 W 70 Q CQ (D QL CO g oil ?® m �--i G) n m m DD o N m m �' w � O'CD 0 a ssa 1-0 ul Fo p c o o, v� LCD — n ® 3a O (D 3 W 70 Q CQ (D QL CO T_6' O 0 a a A P N P T -U' A U U FIo U to Ut P P A A A N � � p O Cn • > II m m 0 O m �o m D \ Q � N 0 N O O Q N o m o ;o N T N Q n Q Q N A C, O m a m o_ O O U O m m N Q N Qc W Jm V \Q N. J U N ro' �o u Q cn N A N W O m p b A N a a � d T -U' A U U FIo U to Ut P P U 0 Cn U �O V OL`i. Qj� A NN ENDENO V a b m 0 O m �o m 0 O 0 Up N O O O Q N by N N. j � N T N Q n Q Q N A C, O m a m A A Ut U U P P 5-7' 6'-0" w a O a a w V m A A O b ••No V ;o A Cn U �O V �O A U � -• A 3Q N � A V A 'O r o V D A N 5-7' m Q b A N O A a 1W1 W — 4 m a a U T_6' A O C (DI I� T -o" Z � e S( W Cn � \/ 3Q @ Q OD (A) �� :F I IAA -Mao 2 11% /P. lkft Al: c 2 A. , ;77 c 2 Fn co El 3 Q- NJ CD C= (D o (c< H3 W = T ^� W m r1 O � moo. <a 6s'. ® 00 a � (Q a I ON - W, firiftoz- -- 2 CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy Robert Dockerty E. Hewlett Kent November 14, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 10-24-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. December 19, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. C. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. f. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Seaside Builders, as Agent for Harbor View Estates, LLC, the owners of property located at 1228 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 1 Hidden Harbour Estates Plat 2. a. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a Georgian style partial two-story, single family dwelling, 3 car garage with guest quarters above, a total of 10,222 square feet, and a swimming pool. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, OCTOBER 24, 2013, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: II. Roll Call: Present and Participating Absent w/Notice Absent w/Notice Absent W/o Notice Absent W/o Notice Also Present and Participating Chairman Morgan called the meeting to order at 8:30 A.M Scott Morgan Chairman George Delafield Alternate Board Member Robert Dockerty Alternate Board Member Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Amanda Jones Paul A. Lyons Malcolm Murphy William H. Thrasher Rita L. Taylor John C. Randolph Jose Gonzalez Christopher O'Hare Board Member Board Member Board Member Town Manager Town Clerk Town Counsel Gonzalez Architects Resident Chairmen Morgan welcomed Robert Dockerty, as the newest Alternate Board Member. III. Minutes: A. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on September 26, 2013 Alternate Board Member Delafield moved and Alternative Board Member Dockerty seconded to approve the September 26, 2013 Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held by the Architectural Review Board. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: There were none. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Dates Chairman Morgan announced the following approved ARPB meeting dates: a. November 21, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. b. December 19, 2013 @ 8:30 A.M. c. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Morgan asked for any ex -parte communications, and there were none. He also requested that any persons speaking at this meeting be sworn in. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream October 24, 2013 — Page 2 Town Clerk Taylor swore in Jose Gonzalez and Christopher O'Hare. VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Jose Gonzalez, Gonzalez Architects as agent for Dennis & Lanore McDonagh owners of property located at 530 Middle Rd., Gulf Stream, Florida legally described as Lt. 18 and 50 Ft. of Lt. 17, Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision for the following: DEMOLITION PERMIT to demolish existing pool, screen enclosure and all windows. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a new pool, glass patio canopy, new front entry porch, and installation of impact resistant windows to the existing one-story single family home, and with some new landscaping being included. Mr. Gonzalez introduced himself stating he was representing Dennis and Lanore McDonagh owners of 530 Middle Rd., Gulf Stream, Florida. He displayed photographs and reported that the house is relatively a non- descript home built in the early 1960's. Mr. Gonzalez described the roof as a Bermuda -style roof with a combination of stucco and board and batten siding on it. He stated that the house was somewhat of a paradox, designed with a ranch style in the front and the back with a more modern bunch of angles. Mr. Gonzalez continued describing the cornered windows of the home which is actual glass. He discussed the bizarre screen enclosure around the kidney -shaped pool which is on the end of the canal. Mr. Gonzalez stated that he wanted to modernize the house and enhance the great views in the rear of the home. He continued that the owners wanted to give the home more presence and curb appeal. Mr. Gonzalez presented the new renderings and plans. He compared the openness of the new home compared to the older rendition. Mr. Gonzalez discussed the present "mishmash Grandma's" front garden, and presented the noble appeal he was going to give it with the circular driveway behind it. He continued stating that the original bizarre detail of the home would be removed, by making it all stucco. Mr. Gonzalez further reported that the entrance would be a lot clearer, and more appropriate with the style of the home. He discussed and presented renderings of the complete openness of the back of the house. Mr. Gonzalez continued that he utilized all the original openings of the house, adding the muntins to complying with the Town's Code. He again discussed the importance of the wonderful view from the rear of the home. Mr. Gonzalez explained the benefit of the loggia with regard with both shade and sunlight. He also stated that all the windows comply with the Town's Code. He pointed out that the canopy over the patio is glass with the middle layer being treated so as to block some of the sun's rays but not the light. Chairman Morgan stated that this is a vast improvement and a very nice rendition of the house. He also inquired if there were any inquiries from the neighbors. Town Clerk Taylor responded "None". Alternate Board Member Delafield inquired regarding the distance of the loggia glass. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream October 24, 7013 — Page 3 Mr. Gonzalez demonstrated the distance of the loggia on his renderings. He pointed out that that it is all open and no screening. Mr. Gonzalez stated that there will be no plantings at all. He also commented that this home was almost a "schizophrenic" kind of home, due to the use of the stucco and board and batten. Alternate Board Member Delafield inquired whether the bricks on the house are to be removed. Mr. Gonzalez responded "Yes" referring to his renderings stating "The brick work was a silly accent". He continued that the previous architect was having a different day in the front of the house than in the back. Mr. Gonzalez did state that the driveway bricks will remain. Chairman Morgan commended Mr. Gonzalez on his presentation. He stated it was very well done, and that it was why there were few questions. Alternate Board Member Delafield moved and Alternate Board Member Dockerty seconded to approve the Demolition Permit to remove existing pool, screen enclosure and all windows. All voted AYE. Alternate Board Member Delafield moved and Alternate Board Member Dockerty seconded to approve Level II Architectural/Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed demolition and construction of a new pool, glass patio canopy, new front entry porch, and installation of impact resistant windows to the existing one-story single family home, with some new landscaping being included meeting the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. Service line shall be buried if they are not already. 2. Any work on the seawall, seawall cap, existing boat lift and existing dock shall conform to Section 66-369 Docks. 3. Driveway removal agreement shall be signed for recording prior to permitting All vote AYE. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF: Town Manager Thrasher reported that the street signs' installation has been postponed until Tuesday, October 29`". VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: There were none. IX. PUBLIC: Mr. O'Hare stated that he had enjoyed and had been happy living in the above-named house. X. ADJOURNMENT: Chairman Morgan adjourned the meeting at 8:49 A.M. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream October 24, 7013 — Page 4 Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-17 Address: 1228 North Ocean Blvd Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Harbor View Estates, LLC Agent: Richard Jones Architect Construction of a partial two story single family Georgian style dwelling Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Georgian style dwelling, a 3 car attached garage with guest quarters above and pool, a total of 10,222 SF. Gross Lot size: 45,317 SF Effective Lot Area: 38,222 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 10,222 SF Allowable: 10,244 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Finished Floor: 16.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Height: 30' (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Georgian style dwelling, a 3 car attached garage with guest quarters above and pool, a total of 10,222 SF meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. The entry feature, measured from FFE to top of railings, shall be <_ 14'. 2. The electric service lines shall be buried. 3. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 4. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 5. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. 6. Any work on the seawall, seawall cap and existing dock shall conform to Section 66-369 Docks. 7. Subject to confirmation by Toznn Manager Thrasher that the plants included in the landscaping plans are not prohibited under the Toum's Code, zt7ith the understanding that if they are prohibited, they mill be substituted with plants that are allort7ed in the Code. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #013-17 ARPB November 21, 2013; TC December 13, 2013 Page 2 ARPB Date: November 21, 2013 Action: Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Recommend approval with the 7 conditions listed above. (5-0) TC Date: December 13, 2013 Action: Level III Architectural/ Site Plan Town of Gulf Stream _ 1 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 4.^ RECE!",9ED t V- OCT 15,-13 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information ARPB File #_13 - � 17 I.A.1. Project/Owner Name:T( t/ i JJ11 I V 1 VJtA) ( ► (A �_ Xa,��� I.A.2. Project Address: I 15 �Ocpori61 y of 10 4rL 4f- I I I:A.3. Project Property Legal Description: �/� 40f b01AZY_ F STQ'4A_Ra_tf Ilk 16 I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) r(0���, I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural style: C� ri I aY) I.A.6. Check all that apply: Architectural/Site Plan Review✓North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) Demolition of Structures (complete section C) Land Clearing (complete section D) Special Exception (complete section E) Variance (complete section G) Non-residential uses (complete Section F) I.A.7. Proposed F.F.E: I (P. D 0 Type of Foundation: l7TL�w Ll a I B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: J3 5 %JE 411, AV e_ ':*10L1 Joy l i -al l ch fi I t �1�T0 1.B.2. Owner Phone Number: Rol `dio-1 - 69 Fax: 6(J/'_ 1.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: �I/.!4ff_JZ r 1 C,[i( f . I.C.2. Agent Address: io" 411/ /x I.C.3. Agent Phone Number (0) 5bl_�J� _L*?J5;25 Cell Fax J(f)/-o?7d- b / 4l I.C.4. Agent Signature: /�01 ­7"��`" Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 2 September 2004 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification VU l VIX / j.III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? OU_ow �1 Lil III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ? 6PNo Explain: III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan?es No Explain: III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Farms a" - I I I.A.S. a. b. C. d. e. f. 9• h. How are the following utilities being provided to the p Stormwater Drainage Via f1A.t D.O ►'/h i &.p r4 Sanitary Sewer (W gif-P i G S Potable water /Y)"i G jpa it k0a t -f 4 Irrigation Water _SaJgS,GAS 61iWVei Electricity Telephone (?aG Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) ADDITIONAL4u a4Dan-edv2iie PART IV. • ' • Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes No (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) �--� IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the prod o f variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes Q , If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 September 2004 Town of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? . , IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: / I1 IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the Al A Landscape Enhancement Project? All R IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: —N I /� C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit JQ, IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? 1 IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? �1 I IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? N D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: �I IrT IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? N11 PC E. Projects Requiring Special Exceptions Level III Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 September 2004 Town of Gulf Stream IV.E.1. Is the proposed use a permitted Special Exception use? Yes No ode Section: IV.E.2. How is the use designed, located and proposed to be operated so that the public health, safety, welfare, and morals will be protected? IV.E.3. Will the use cause substantial injury to the value of other property in the neighborhood where it is to be located? Yes No Explain: IV.E.4. How will the use be compatible with adjoining development and the character of the District where it is to be located? IV.E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? AJ I /—f IV.E.6. Does the use conform with all applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? Yes No Explain: F. Non -Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained: IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on surrounding Properties. IV.17.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions: Loading Spaces: I Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) Level III Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 5 September 2004 Town of Gulf Stream IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? Nr7 J 1/0- IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV.G.3. What is proposed? NJ IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? _IrV ar 1 IV.G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? A )A - f I rT (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the. land, building or structure? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No Explain: H. Projects requiring Rezoning Level III Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 September 2004 Town of Gulf Stream IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? A/ IV.H.2. If the project involves a Rezoning, Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, or any combination thereof, please describe the need and justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required, to provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this form or on any of the other materials submitted with the application. Level III Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 7 September 2004 fo)n+( 4ir3 15 SW 6098 Pacer White <— Tr -)corn bla.cL APPROVED SET DEC 13 2013 TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FL ► RECEIVED A OCT 15 2013 Town of Gulfstream, R w w NO C:) G') f 0 EE- 1- C=D M m _rl r-� � it j� jy� j5 �T :�,�'+�� ��.� i '.�" i ;,• s'_I \. ,p h.• ���t,1�y�ti ;yMr��♦. w,l'•A J,�,`• �S i4`]ctI" JI.- 41.11� n•�-.�:�;,:�t�' ;fit �r � ..� s�'�'1;, � �i �. ,r w�i :� � �, •a' =r' � :�r I �',►s -!ITL.} , � � ~' 1 , «.'� F {`. � _ . F Yom' ♦; J • , J'' .; Er 4.1 « L r •r., 4. , APO �`�i � - ti,, " ► +rtiP L yam. i� ` r -� •+' Y +t ` •t _,.. a. • � � � � � ••0.r 01 f •moi ;w 'Y � � '` JJ"�ry rpt v �- ' •i� �t � ;• , r ♦til ? +e,`',�d'� „ � � 71 J ' i i , 1� Y Y./« j` + •) � � f t r I•ill. l �Y •,' . Yi �' :I ; + �' � � f �if � r � '^awl '1`y�r� e.�, � , ,f �' 4•''�'�" j: �• t1,,, `J •• ' VJ i ,''\• 1 ' •� " lC.. (1' „ �fJd .. is ,� ar be 1 17 r-� � it j� jy� j5 �T :�,�'+�� ��.� i '.�" i ;,• s'_I \. ,p h.• ���t,1�y�ti ;yMr��♦. w,l'•A J,�,`• �S i4`]ctI" JI.- 41.11� n•�-.�:�;,:�t�' ;fit �r � ..� s�'�'1;, � �i �. ,r w�i :� � �, •a' =r' � :�r I �',►s -!ITL.} , � � ~' 1 , «.'� F {`. � _ . F Yom' ♦; J • , J'' .; Er 4.1 « L r •r., 4. , APO �`�i � - ti,, " ► +rtiP L yam. i� ` r -� •+' Y +t ` •t _,.. a. • � � � � � ••0.r 01 f •moi ;w 'Y � � '` JJ"�ry rpt v �- ' •i� �t � ;• , r ♦til ? +e,`',�d'� „ � � 71 J ' i i , 1� Y Y./« j` + •) � � f t r I•ill. l �Y •,' . Yi �' :I ; + �' � � f �if � r � IL 14 Al 4 1 " OOOF' e.0000, - sv W. 4 . 7 BE it (Art, It , lk I A -Stk t Al 4 1 " OOOF' e.0000, - sv W. 4 . 7 BE it (Art, It , lk I A -Stk " + ,, k�� ,, " ,, .," " tit �� ,�� .. ��#��' .. ` 1 , " �� " x!11 s IF y I -�% y��T'tr �� 1" . ��' t "1 yjt�� t ,r\_7.4 ���� ��t ��' t,{ ��T Esq Yom," 1. ..�� �� -., �� _ �� - - ;. " ' -la f&fir '��" �� I` . f '" _ t f& �� Y ` _ _ ` ,..w" t a .J tk1.1'r . 1 ," .yt t ti`s'+. {:;.'+ T - i + i " �� �� -�� - V41 SMT M,�� _i�� �� t7 ��jt ''Ir+. . _. _ " t �� ., ��' ��.`" rr �� ' -������. ,t �� " _��,.  }. ��_ ,�� . s. t Vit- ,�� ,�� _,i .. '1 '�� �� I��,'f`��'1' Mt :^t' A ��'a' 'ip y : ''��, ��'' ' ''i �� , �� ��'t', trrt�% -. '% - ya.S��" ., w i_,ySr'��. �� - �� - r r r i����1 1 ' , " �� ��' 1v1- ���� + 1 `n A-11 's" S����t '; " 1 t �� ' a ��1 ����` _. `M �� i���� 1(a ; ��.{y�� w' q r ' i ��' rl `tk. , t ri - ` �<fff t rl' �� �� ��[Pi��'����" ��lky+lrii S f& I��" li' ,_ r It ry f& 1{' Y P Q31VYO"-'RV/ .7YN1331 /IC7ryV .S7hY1/" 08V031ry .✓L"/.UCiS1H73 /1.71LNM 5'.S7rYd,Y.7 .]!II 1001/1 /M 1Y3NOSI VIUt HMLI AIN /if A77VXHdVY9 Q3Z17/1 n 80 a3ldlIJ '032790dd3Y 38 AVH NOILVW809A YO 'SN9lS3V 'SNV7d 3S]Hl dO 1NVd nN '93AAM3Y 77V SUVDRY 77V !/31 f1WdYO:Ma/ 380133111d7YV S_7N7Y aAWI 1Y A£ £102 1H9fYAaU n -A J. T H �_�i� S l�I O r Q-4IH 0 Esta, Van l0-l:l `H3VHB AV21'13Q [^ z■; „E~� - b01#3nN 3nVlILt 9N 981 w w S23Q 7lffl lQISVlS _u ; cn 'QAIEIRVaDO N■■>r IYVV12iiS TMD 1 <L c3 N > ¢ i LOI s�iVisam3lnxnosxVH o N x O Li C -i 54 LU CO 3� 0 a I `' ❑ n Z _ O OW Al U H U n a O Z O 2 Z ° z Z 1. d ¢1. A '�11 U N @ ❑ 3 � W C) �--� LL. LU z o w a WN W a o C c ' t r flu -1 O C C� R a z Q- w Wj > > a Z , n J w w � z z `zi O r Q W N a $ ° W a $ w n 'y ❑x ❑x o >u z' w a i o Q Z 1t of ow U :. n oU_ ° . J 0r1 \ LJ N❑ w❑ J 4 LUw O Q 2 u o? m Rio al as $ z< t 00 $ a Z wzw ❑ w� o K ❑ � 4E yo Ii El� oZ0 J w � W y O ❑ � a W r Q QJ � o naw au � w ❑ 3 :' Nzz xz Vz5 W o N >Qm 4"' ❑ g u ❑ � ❑a ° z �Ou 0 o r7 7 ,q T /� z z a Sri c❑i� X 'a o o o c3a¢N U W m m m>N am n Q Zi K N K f Z �2 J? F'a ° W �« � p - a LL r Lo U O ❑m �❑ z zzm z W F- �N '°-'u=i ow< H w4 a wa x N s r m N > o i iw� z>� Ng= W m ? �w<uu=i = I -- N w w ❑ m> m z ww u� z rc 9 4Lr r a wLL a °$ �n w z- xN ❑z rc > g a O u a° ❑ a u z ❑ z foo w ca z ❑ o�Y O wa¢ ❑ �Y� u W <w ° F ❑¢ u a g ❑ rcu Q �rcw'n� z zti Inu ❑ u W C) Z:) c of U) W co Q A Y O W o W�ZW T 22 NC Q h2 N K a R UyQ uW FgN gw m ° �= Um Z Z OaW O�O zn� ,� Y U�aQW O a W ih (fl N �n2-z °' ww z o ❑ �- u 4- F`w w z`zw' s w a a p o u z z a s awz N w� x o Fm QW wu o"� o wN oft2 wgag� ¢ uWNT u -{ Qm�4 o Q w> O Q Q LL m (V 00 Nu u"i� w o as v T� > iipp ❑r z p O U i m v mi- z Lt* ~ a a t i Q F z mx FiN xb & m o❑z w rcW �O °=w s PO -z P0 -z x OF ZNaW U (� U) W C7 = CO (n > xtiw0 U 04 6 FT a f� io U _a w M. ¢ ~ ❑ T F < o� K JUT'. - U O <w p. xm Z F QiW 1Q- S ww U Wui__ O t9FQ z T yo i�u Q �� zwp 9 �R QN TNW soi �❑ _ w wYg��d 3 §zi �+ U� p Q W U Q r Q 0 w N j� M W TO rW z a Fo u < F rcig f �z z4 x or w >N°a m tai Cx z- a u ° oo� z o ❑ a w Tf,a z w u 8 as w Na a um m w N oa u. ❑ Ou Fw ❑w w aw N ozw >T z wWzxJTpQ z=N m� ❑ rc a5 w� ❑ aw sN W ..L. min Q Z m I— Q CO F 3'� rca ynw w� - ❑a i� j i5' F W W NY m n �wza n a w: m ON aEJ ❑ ma o v oz uje Q o a ��w LL zd❑ o w NazN'8 u oz wore rc Z U �' } S W Q V! U) ❑wo<$ �° w'� sg a z0 u T ❑y iTz z �w Rp " 0� ott�❑Q a4 c°Tia o ❑wvi o ° ax o -0.o y p prc w < >z rc n o w 'du 3 T LL°m T ac<i _N w❑ NW u_ az u uT u'd am imw �� o iw p ❑y ❑mN ai z uW Q H Lou Y = J Z J 0 I— W Q W LL w4Z�¢` O �>> N pO O pp T U< ZO T z Bw U 'kauu u W,a �s� �Q w o a T p a -O o rc �T Oo 0. H i o w <<i 2N < U' ❑aD U l7 (�W Z 2 UZ 2 a Z Z a S oz o z j -O m a m0 rc a a= ui w3 -z- uLz rc Y a� �a m i �d�Tj O¢ ,io Zc N O 0K Q> u o zaz UN °k' TgL$ w O a 0. �¢� °° Sa�2LL iz � �ah� a Zp o °W'd �u T T o �x�wWz o0 m 0 O U W Z > Z o z Wiz ❑❑ i Z�Zz 4 m� Oz LL' ii W E O n Wa 8 T z. aT u o �o� = m ¢ ao a Z-' Saa2� u� nLL ?w fZg - a� irc a s U �QC w4 an zic=�a a (Op TU<u K Ta w� o� a LL� w uui mz° W ¢° waw oo a w .m N K� ~LLF W� i❑ °gm zw °� T. a� giWg = pOunU aw " aw�w. "o uzw ¢C >1,66 oo °o a wW� o wz z °T w a obi Fk rc z zap s qp w ° Zg °awm az od xw Z � rc ,b�S ru it� t W�� � U u u < 0S aF- 20 a, z¢ < z wu Ta LL N >na wow pa wo z aa4 <m FF 4 3 5 yrcp oTa zm> WN DDz N On ❑a as z °"u iE uw uw ❑ w W Vim¢ w �Ww zi�T 8z ail ;5 rc ❑°. 'z 3 < o a Yx m. - Z O UJ T' Jj .�❑ W 7 aLL aTF z uo ❑ w Fp oja ❑ �> v ❑ o w'0 3 z V' O . wo m o TWF iQ �rc� mz � a� HP o w ❑ ❑rc m� w z yu T ?orc T� w a � N pa J Taw oo a z ❑a o �T Fm aWua a yz ❑ ❑z �z aw wuo z of of i w wN ¢Ww a wm a k W jgE:, �3 j�uai" z� g �2NFIg i�� LLJW W T W V W CO W m w�§z ° On, 8 zT N�> mw �3 o �w zw z 3 aw rcT z aw v aw �FgW zQ � � iwg �w x m $Q wZHw °mom �� �o uQ� -i= 4a� ala ��¢ a�w��❑Y Cw wa �� Z Q � c7 Y � Z 00 } .. '.'. (N7¢o w �grcw i(J Wx QQ ¢ o w W QQ< z uZZ ❑ oT ¢ w wT �6w� a o L °� im nw T uxop U > Tn J maw °Z gx 1O i�- m J Zw az J� SAN o°� ❑w zo nQn ¢ T < w� J Fgrc N¢o"�❑ FN o W z aw �° rc❑T J I� U W (V > LL W LC) • z NT ° Q JV QKW aU o mW N y ° I. F� m°T Z N <� ❑TW Z❑ JU a WT < ZF> a¢ F zOm -2 �w Qi �y W _ TQx FF W m K2w ❑ ZZ O1 -w <¢ � OTU'T a1 T f FaJ wwp f oSZ 3 m BOC NJ WS °U NNm °� ❑a L Z° T Q Z 2 >❑Q 1-p Q L jm VKO N ❑ a z❑ Fw µ1Q Jl�❑s N O� y Oy1 > Q❑ WUO ¢p Q _ co Q 0 C ....k 1r6 tl �fyl� l�. W- ¢¢ W ZO=i ❑Z T., .1 Um adTm �K .1¢ 009 O OW❑m UR ZUn NW Td0 y 0°> °a0 a u auzyy z° == z 000 ZW 1- �N w�pu ❑❑ W < �NU H Q- o,� _ _ TZ❑W WOTa 'W 1'K QZZQU pNp W �OU W6U< ¢_� KW N LL °ZiS a❑ °-o �1: ��� �w 1UY ZW °wTFWO OF ❑❑ 2WNp❑U.px Z gx01-a2 �0 "QE 0 U Q Z N z C14 w W CV U '4p J...' m Zu �T O J - m fw= �v %� oW N i> mn%T uW m m O9a �F �m �i u nti p <4U mw z dQN s x3 iN 3F mOF gm o <� u� 9u�uo u=iF C� W CO Q O CO ' Oum o roT ti s mO u�a iF -'fin ° m�xLL rc u ogx a m -o w o°_ �n j j w� viz u=i yw =Tzw m0 m = �za o F Now $ a �rcN ¢ mza❑ v=iowz Tx TQ aE aaz ❑w ..mo oz o� y° ° is »Z001 00 �asuT� ""' Z } {— = LO Z W ..t`" X d ,c. '13F ❑�rcF =N � i Naai TZ NJN izw ¢� aQw uw .n �K o o n o'¢=w F o wpb 3 E2 p (,1 uw "a° u� i a z v Qh Q Q QR Q �� �3LL om a U orc 0 1 w rc�z uowa �i uT�TJw" ZW QUN❑ 1� Nm og w�a � F u$u Txx Z N 2� OJ 0 W N� 0 Q LL O W Ci ,� s, TT Fm FF Y6W H ozp a p9WW ° FR R R� F Fn J i m- > YAW 0 6T < 2 nT 2 �OOj N �wgz io �w TT- u�w�4a� �, i 0'31 VNOdNOJN1 38nJJ3J/HJNV S3HOl 01WOM _0.11GS10.7 1131.I/NM SS38dX3 3HI JNOHJIA N3/,OSJ VHN 1✓NOJ AUV NI A 77VJIHdVN9 03.7711/1 NO 937dOJ 'Q3J(AT9,Yd3N 3.9 A VIJ 1/1.7/1 VWNOJII/ NO 'SN9IS-7J -SNV7d 3S3Hi _i71NVd ON '03AN-7S3N 77V S.1H9/N 77V /131 VNOdNOJNI 38O1.731 /HJNV SMO/' 17N'VHJIN A8 £100 IH9/NAdOJ u = £8h££ V41�101A `HDV39 kVdIHGLu - z ■ZD= a t,01ft anN3nV HIV FIN 581 L S�Efcllln8 311SV3S O n Fes- wVa�Ls s ins an �a I�Va�o Wszz> = N - i LO I SILVIS3 main dnof -dVH r < < -> z ir c� m o ~ I I I ui I ® r w 9 1 0 W 1 p I I Lo �• I I I I � e� , k •ma!1 aanvd v a a II U0�3--------------- H Q d a fn Ul — A O NCY I g o (a✓oa d1vnRJd v) Cal .Ur r� �vdd ® 0 Z N m m o m m m No 0 I Y.I qcn .,— — 74211 JK — — 3 NIDI — OI'� Ar m I IiaQ�l ——-------- 1 rJSI i �n,u� M tL LL 00 LL LL o ti r— ------ m o m m ° m 88 �4Jarxvaa 3 m m m o m.wz'�rsI w n m m I I -- 3V IY2Y1 —1 m ^ o o m I o I I w I I < I I env os p Z d o a a 0 o d o o a F a o m m m m d I I -__ ------cn w o 0 0 0 0 0 0 F d d z tl CL fL LL d o' d o 1.7 ¢ m m~ m m m m n m N N m m m m m m m m m m o y oy N o m ryory �. N N p 2 v2 N m ` O N w 0 w a V7 I� ii 3' II m m °� w = O °' w ¢ O O oo m a ¢ m w w o wzw ae Q 0 O0 w K w ❑$ K m a O O O a w j a o g m wo ? Lop 'ou W 0 Z 0 0 3 13 gQ I I �' w ¢> m ¢ m n m o 8 of m w O m i Oi O (7m w LL o 0 0 0¢ x wIn 5 rW.! �Q 0 U iy LL 1 U y. J m m F m Q W _1V O w Q J J J0 z Zo a4 O m w 0 O, �¢ u~i w z mo z 3z Q m O o m> o o wo Ua oy 1.7 w LL U N d QW o 7 o F LL o H H w2 Qm P -46d �' m o Z OU ° w a y 1.7 o a o W a W w m n O ® ❑❑ Q 3 0 o U O 0 m�rM a.Jrx i I I \ ❑ ❑ T $ �W7o .r? O W W W N N O% Ln o X I cM" AW H! W 0 [� 0 Lb O I I I O I ¢ bb mN o e n J W z Y U r1 S �S BJ Q 0 0 < L) m w = w > > n -------- — — - — — — � 1 1N3YdSv3 �JvrNvaa I ! 1rr�^r�v3 �xrnvaa ,Ez ' `------------------•------ I (all a3✓d 'x x9PA 1v ;,p o 1NW:19Y3 ul3fln 6W QdOaJ 31 niTJd a a n v d t a / (all 3344 '9c. )ba4 1YU Z 1N2N.,Y3 3=JONWNO 5 I � � I I lit W I r� xo Wo Q� e✓ H 0 0 03IVN1ldNOJNI 3rYOJ3.711H3HN .SJ•f0/' O "W71d' dO 1H3S//OJ /01,1INPI SS7NdX3 3H1 J/IOHJIA N347S1 wm HMO./ ANN /ll A77VJIHdVN9 03Z77J10 d0 731dGJ '07JOOONd32. 39 AVH HOII MNOSO d•O 'SI/DIS-711 SIIV7d 3S3Hl 301MVd ON 93AV-?S38 77V SIH918 77V 03IVH7dH6JNI ]NO13311N38V S3NO/' ONVHJIH AB VOR JH9I8Ad03 0 U 1 $ 8ggg8 ' ® ii --b____ ee o 1 (Y1 W I II _____I7 O i� i I II r O M lJ:l ll m S I I I 1 I I I ___ - II I I 1 1 I I� yyI--yyI I ii yh I I I 5 x 1 ' 1 C� it -- ---- I I I � o ` '= I I 1 00 O � O o� 6 'QY' u7 A CO Ri O 02) - 8ggg8 0 ®$ 0 000 0 �I s� �c b ox � U; Q g 8---- U. a £8t££ VGl'dO-1J `H3d3fl AN2i•124 - O O N O w z 3 ■ <�_ = a t01# EmN3AV H.Lt 9N S81 LU c� f C-3 p aO 4 K 52134 llflfl flQ1SF/l5 = ♦ e C� d w x V f z � 1�1 0 p y Id Ww3Nis j-mD •QAl9 Nd3D0 *X 8lli u■■� z_ s31dis3 m31n �no£1�H _ � � = < z 3 � ' _ > Gs) `` w V1 _ CIO w U 1 $ 8ggg8 ' ® ii --b____ ee o 1 (Y1 W I II _____I7 O i� i I II r O M lJ:l ll m S I I I 1 I I I ___ - II I I 1 1 I I� yyI--yyI I ii yh I I I 5 x 1 ' 1 C� it -- ---- I I I � o ` '= I I 1 00 O � O o� 6 'QY' u7 A CO Ri O 02) - 8ggg8 0 ®$ 0 000 0 �I s� �c b ox � U; Q g 8---- U. O O N O w LU c� W. C-3 aO 4� I O L---- Q C� C V � 1�1 0 y r� Gs) V1 w 1 10 I I U 1 $ 8ggg8 ' ® ii --b____ ee o 1 (Y1 W I II _____I7 O i� i I II r O M lJ:l ll m S I I I 1 I I I ___ - II I I 1 1 I I� yyI--yyI I ii yh I I I 5 x 1 ' 1 C� it -- ---- I I I � o ` '= I I 1 00 O � O o� 6 'QY' u7 A CO Ri O 02) - 8ggg8 0 ®$ 0 000 0 �I s� �c b ox � U; Q LY4, I I I l O "uoa�eg osleg I I T�7 0 88 o I I I I I I 1 I 1 I 1 I --_ 1 I O I I I 1 I I I I I I I I 1 i i 3 !i OD x i i y I 1 I I I I 1 I i • I i 1 i I I ® 1 I 1 1 I I I O -------- 0. �x � � I •� I I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � — I — - I I I I I I I I i I 0 Q I o /'\ I � I � a I o � I � � I o > N�� U O , U Z -------------- I ._i 2 R m 3 6 rte» email - O - 0 �SgS Q <a< U W U U U U U U U' Z I Z Z Z w r 3LL�LLir ¢yrcrc¢ y o m q a o g q o o x x X x x x x x x N 0 80 ca C-3 r U� VV C V c) I I I I I 1 O U I I N LY4, I I I l O "uoa�eg osleg I I T�7 0 88 o I I I I I I 1 I 1 I 1 I --_ 1 I O I I I 1 I I I I I I I I 1 i i 3 !i OD x i i y I 1 I I I I 1 I i • I i 1 i I I ® 1 I 1 1 I I I O -------- 0. �x � � I •� I I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � — I — - I I I I I I I I i I 0 Q I o /'\ I � I � a I o � I � � I o > N�� U O , U Z -------------- I ._i 2 R m 3 6 rte» email - O - 0 �SgS Q <a< U W U U U U U U U' Z I Z Z Z w r 3LL�LLir ¢yrcrc¢ y o m q a o g q o o x x X x x x x x x N 0 80 931VdV,NG31V13d971,7311HJ8V .V3M7- 08VHJ78 A71N3SAl7J H31178A SS38dX3 3H1 InDHIIA Y3A9SJVHA IVAUJ MV NI A 77V31HdVX9 03Z17110 NH O3/d03 '03MaONd7N 39 A VH NOIl VNNOJN/ d0 'SN9IS39 '.MV7d 3S3H1 3012fVd ON 'U13Ad7S M 77V S!H91H 77V O31 V&GdNONI/ 3dR13311HJNV "NLY QNVHJIN A9 EIOR IH9/dAdOJ p -,Ill JL C>pa .1. 111-1 S - 1-,,z O r Q-�-gsvrH �:D w a £817££ VQ1-dO'1J `HOV38 AV d 13a z - 1701# 3nN3AV H1f 3N 581 sx3a11Ins 3a1sV3s z *� z ■ ■� <� s t2- ~ = z B w Z w O a "I3 WV32TLS IIf1C)'aA'lfl KV1JO8ZZr1 > g 3 I LO -1- SHIVIS3 M31A ?JCIOM1VH g o _ F— LLI U) c*'f LL ® N ui LLQ c� Z w LLI o. o 0 I I I I " W > o N a I d• 2- I .� I I f 1 V W V C) _ I r r CD o _ I A& CCS O O 7711/.Y, ,/,,Y0,7/l! 3N/?.I J3llH7.YV 53.7/' ILVVH7TY /7 1 N3SNV3 N3111NM SS3d'dX3 341 IMNI M 6f3MOSIVH I NNOd ANV NI A77VJIHdVM9 a3717f1N Jll 031 7 '03JVA70Md3N 3B AVN M7f1VN2II Wl d'O 'SN91S37 'SNV7d 3S3H1 JO I &MON 103i183SAY 77V S1H91N 77V R31 VAUdWJN13NNIJ3lIHJd'V S31K7/' QUVHJIY AB E7021H IIA. I 4—j ct B Irl 0 ji LL - M E LLJCIO N (:�o LLJ t--� W v o ® 1� w - `_ = 'arcs; vai1io�d 'x�dag wu�aa o s � ■ 1701# 3nNSAd HIV aN s8I i � � s�r�crnng aaisdas v m -IJ 'aA'RI 'N ■ WVH-8 LS d'MD NVHDO 8ZZT I 1 07' S91V SH M31A UnOg-d H < o o U 1— W to LL I't it lit aR h it P, .. a W n ' CO o< W O`XZ 1 OL!J U. a o < u V D W 1L L 0 Y J i Z'Z 00 M 4—j ct B Irl 0 ji LL - M E LLJCIO N (:�o LLJ t--� W v o ® 1� (:) < o o U Ztn9 w� w� .. < u V D W 1L L H Y J i Z'Z R M ` 'O31VNOdNOJNl 3dV]1J31/H7NV S3NDf ONVH7IN JO IN3SN93 N3117NM SS3NdX3 3H1 1JXA41J14 N3AVSIWA HNOJ MVNI (77VJIHdVN9 O3Z7711D NO O3IdOJ 'O37/MIDNd3N 38 AVN AYLIVNND3NI NO 'SH9IS39 'SNV7d 3S3HI 3O 1 NVd ON '93A M3N 77V SIHDIN 776' Q31 VNOdNO7N/ 3NDS7317H7NV S3ND7!' ONVH778 A9 EIOd IH9JNAdO7 ERRE VQRIo'I3 `H3dHg .IV -d IHQ z o ^ 1701# aflNg" HIV 3K SSI SIM(FIMS HQISHHS ■ ■ m -IJ WVMUS JIM 'QA'IS NdFIDO 'ISI SZZI I ZO'I' SHIVISH MHIA W109WH uj q� ; ®< LIJ `o co c U. 0 a O _= `"I' U. LV CO w ® '� 3:1-- ar W OCO D � � Q 03 \I V ct Q� 0 II 00 Z q� ; ®< `o ® 0 a O Oil > Q z o poll Q �3> a s�>a z w V ct Q� 0 II 00 Z q� ; ®< `o ® 0 a O Oil > poll Q ��o 00 ���� ��_y ��n'�� 0 cop O L E O 1 L ����' =anN O N > '�� I .Q,5+, �� Il u ` ��- J a W M LL/ U L N J �� �� ��UUUUU p p JI O Vi A ^ca^ 41 O 1J. �� di U QQQQQQ -+ had VIRN zzzzzzz��z zzzzzzz����zzzzzzzzzzz��zzz �� ���� aadaaaaaa aQa'aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aY ...�� "" dX h_v9 W xxxxxXx Xx XXXxXXXXXx% x xx%xxxX- ����ii W $e�����3�����s'oaaare9aaa-Q'vQa$mQ �� m PH zzzzzzzzz zq Lll HHS w1aQ��������s w ��+ ��0�� 0 f Y � fo fo fo fo fo f fo fo fo f�� {�� f�� ��� fo fo fo {-q fo fu �� m i n ��1 ^gLL 33 3LLo s�� 43IL 8 ILLas is $5 3�� wni f va f f f o $o f B n m 0 z �� -- ���� fin it W VT $ IO 0 a LU cr 0T ?v �� 7 --i LU O J W U CL C � c a 3 Q ��o 00 ���� ��_y ��n'�� 0 cop O L E O 1 L ����' =anN O N > '�� I .Q,5+, �� Il u ` ��- J a W M LL/ U L N J �� �� ��UUUUU p p JI O Vi A ^ca^ 41 O 1J. �� di U QQQQQQ -+ had VIRN zzzzzzz��z zzzzzzz����zzzzzzzzzzz��zzz �� ���� aadaaaaaa aQa'aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aY ...�� "" dX h_v9 W xxxxxXx Xx XXXxXXXXXx% x xx%xxxX- ����ii W $e�����3�����s'oaaare9aaa-Q'vQa$mQ �� m PH zzzzzzzzz zq Lll HHS w1aQ��������s w ��+ ��0�� 0 f Y � fo fo fo fo fo f fo fo fo f�� {�� f�� ��� fo fo fo {-q fo fu �� m i n ��1 ^gLL 33 3LLo s�� 43IL 8 ILLas is $5 3�� wni f va f f f o $o f B n m 0 z �� -- ���� fin it L3a� 0000 ----------------------------------------- L_________________ _____ _ d tQ11'�> W e e 0 e I ■ 0 0 co U) W V) M i WCYJ ° w O 3~ U 0% CD Q,. G CL /w/ 90 � � U � L V � U L T d 9 UmU 444444 "� F- oZ l.L W co O w .._. W v o �/ Q c L W ,� !; A3 E m �Y �� w ��n b u Y o�°? �'C m 0A � a. y ■ I 0 dJ \ o ..co ,2 w, # p Co C P D W L/ m p°11 ry ' u> a ^ U �� Q Q = 1ST W ` V P� L i 0 IX C.j Orin �" a 0 4,11 03 LCJ ® J a ` 66 •�E ! 8 �. 01! F �$ RFnFs a =�� 3:• s 5,3 �9Sa�� �_ �fi � � �� a � �°� aK.�.�agsgaasEEgggS Eg3_e i 3°sib 3 aid; -a xFa !!s Ea s'? c ¢ Sts e a $ 6r@ -1• P p bCag E B5 d $ is g aC 51 W0 g ! ai18 .E•� 5lF !i ilES93i�, �•g 3a-�° y�i�• tls°9 jR 11 l -E __ 3- ; s` am _ $a a a � ' € MIL .j 5 c$� !- c3 s F s# �, r Yom$ 7 §p..t 3.�.s3 s gg n 5 rt :a3 rt1sa�z !➢ g �p Ydy ss M . i� ,3 'EF -'ya •s a s9� $ t t(a a. a E!°a E >B F- E 5 88���j6a�! rPE �gg� ��6� aaaa a� 3 �a °haw #ay9! a!S111,!14, r �$= Ab $ @ g� "d`3 �t ......x p5°pan g °s-% 3i a 3 S� gab $=�r3E P ;' E 9; Y 9 St r= 3 : 3& sp �`�a ,� � i.� a a sa E 8 L•rE $5r 1�! $ 111 =e £; Pti�$� �F3; =,8 s 8; 33 3�a33EF g!g °! F: 3 � 1 lis 1j'e 31 39 a` gas 3 #sins !$�'P=3='°° t P °`a E ' ° g$ i �P8&� �. s rt �; a•� 3��r• .`. ,? rEr sS a aG P g g =' d- 'E? � F �°° 11 Hit, � °18a�s d P a ::m$ w x ! 83§ os 3a a$353r $ =$..p 2_1? -I$ d ° d z d d t. �- _ - s=�6 �i� ; gE ➢ ; e� ; Fa ! e_ -r1 di 8p 1j LAI 1 m a $: !° 1 $ $ ¢ Sa1�� 138 a 3 i$ a 91 3r a ! g a ° i ;1 1— �: gg o s 1 3 �' �r x1129 8$3 11 E 5 �&° mbps=!� �s�3��:3 R gg�$ggsg $ $ , � ;�2E9y� c�E ia31� i'�'aa E�l� � -�= ! a!? •p � 1y � ! �9 E�z 111 L 2t3yg��C ,� , 4 1 F `009 9i _ W Y�b bQ ° Ski$ im 3°pan ; Er a § a.-$°:sy # E1``l s�yIa$aq s4 " 1.. 51 ga: - isF�bag 1 °$a$3 A b i- 5 a s4e a s 3 8a E$ 3 s ` a ° 1 i F . a a i$c 3 d J b t d &§ �'S J. d aY >'A 5: . f . a d e s �! o f d d d w L d d d C L' - 6 d b 961! ➢ l1tg h4l p 3� Bre'%5 a� oak E13 S� '1TLle$ PS S Mi9 imp It ia'3�� Q;4 pgs19 d p Still I I All �8L 33 3i3ic's8 Pa�*iLi3$e y a gkt 3 S d i d d d d x d a d �y�1E '��y a' �9 '�= y•a1� 3E!' s y1B£ p°g•. 4 a.. g aE�3� ; 3g 3 of s9 � i as. :lit � i. 8'o- eE i a g•� 1x8 a�'3= 3 a $ m1 s ly y rtE?Sg-� i ' s; l■ut 3`g p� pE& X13 aEgS5 1 $1E2s$3 =a w.aa. F_PP3 a'�t sp �3: 2 'c ^ �y6.:• a 2 d d d d d d d d tit I°y 1 ;illi all s if a� �I3 it lit gk c ° pb 3l5 8a1�a i3kdg3, $� �a x9!11 ,Ig�$a 3-g3 p,3 $ n E10 �a �i@�a �' IN fl ; d saw 3 �8 E 'a �olilia� sQ $ ° Pp ! g •l E� y F ; 3 i 7,x4 9P gal § pE f 1-1e:pE =5 yss s_= s#a e� igE Ei syg's p °-73 1h eeE IP 91°- �!P ° 3_ sI33 ila j$i sus>l� �3 30 a3E art!°bias tra p E�i sa _ ° :®• a$R31 d13�'9a���ii rs-$ !Ea a$8 "1rt�11� lEi 15,x3 3�r.3F1: 33=1 4 � § da l�=api 8¢¢x.4ggpp51 �si� g� 2 eNail- ti m l Ea 83��s�9E-°yiR!$6aF� �3 ay ��1Y 3e y '3 3¢3 E3 $ 13 4•pr'.E �� 89 6E b- oP II °a"aa$`9§l33a3 as a�3LF P•6 -° a ° la 1! Sia=S i _a Er iay qi'3 1i W; !1 a a m1 lr : 3,aul W1915- $Ec�7E�s 5N �an Ef ia33� ; 'y ? � `y3yI iE a3 I FES at $ � 1�i 1; �• �° 3� u, zPl eF2 $ Q E; a aE 3g c d d a �ta�s a3s� s • s° s �°' S $ s3 e Ing ; 3 aPsm p � 1a� 3� 8y1 e• $ r� 1 5 qj.1 �3rt ;y31 Ear =9p -H Ohl'° - ;�aEry g sa Saar s$as J °� 1^pa1a:E!-n T1s: E'83 �3a; sada; 53a� 61�?a°as3�{�a,i�ie 3 3:13 9e8 �$a# �iE E3 i Egi d$ 3° a� $835E• 33$a3i .. p�3o ® s- s rr 8s 3�-, E' HIMe i 3 3'- # - 3p a �.> 0;3 os�• €1lE1Eie gds R3a39 9�8€! n l! ¢ ! m mP1 y -a3• 1a a33� ;i a aa£, aa' 1y93y a�� Z yyisyV�$ a3 � a MM A'3!'a Lia •_$.'411H E93 iEaY 79 2' ? -y 31:i3 r3 d d d W d lLfl 31544 s � a i sQo a E ea It 1 al a!r°.3 HP, ay g air $y➢ a¢ oal �a s. !�= 'Arl �1F rt3 a ! sa 1 -�d3 1a `�FO . aQ3m �e 1 Ep5 3 rbu !3 °E agl:3 �ao8') •xa' a?a�t gad9$pa��d =aB� ��- r�6-EIi s a1i s� 3. s3 Fa s ��5 464 41E 4M $i4s�aa��k5 �Q 3- r ��� �& slg, a y � �a$1 �aa•ay 1'P rriIFg� a g e r 1T111.1 sl, yds 1t8l j°b=a B <3 s9 tlE83d gds � 41°s?3a aipf's� $� i &;; g 3 9pp8 aEE a1� d w W d a Jil a b: l i s 1 r $ 3 iia�� ldS FI,,'Erb g! g 1i i s a1 1& bay` 1!1 y�aa1 s S � fi a l �' sd3'3B` p 3im mgba 111 P 6� 3� E3 p p6 E��INN a r$9 I rases 'aa lb. 9a°$3 11111a sai#-111: =9t i rt r§ s 3 a d 3paE 88 g ?gP �,I..hI JIM asQa31 d u W a d d d F=9ytr 1 f 3 B3 9 as ��m, u � �. 1= 3� lag i� 3rP e ]'r. spa E §3a €! a ��� 3 as g 3;^?s3� 3-• �1�'P 9 �`!;�!85 5`WS a o5' saBpaa c' baa#ay9 ¢$=iyp3 a- 3 a �a. a P' °a s ' EE S Fa 3, a 3 �•$1p�g g ° m b 3 anE35 E'ai s i a a !•'Si 3! g eaaFj item3$fig�� n 3, a�r€ 3afi� Ea4� : spa 9 �p li 'o�pg °8 s a, bill s ip � a ;51 �3p1°° !a ; iE=� s �a �" ° N U "MIN, l a� a s�3 $3p �6 ��` 1�f� ��a?�E �j s1� !� ,, ���� � �&�3 s �Fa�3��o dp a1 ���' Sad-� �1 E33 1 a8i1r yea 1 !nE= aPy ,1 1!a g <z 1 s gr a? fi= 4 °yga �aig€�a a$g& a 2 Ys- ➢ s 1 3 g 1' 3-1- ; &3•w °E5bigi 1' n 3i �fi� PE a qr 3°! i$ is a 8 5�� �aia�j = s a=� yyip y 1 SEB l9�yy 181 Sa! 3 3° 9! m p s4na __ § ° �$ - bra 33 38- SE d' 1 S a v!$g 8p F a pa; pig r 1 E° pE4E1- 8" as g 1��,Pg , 1 !l a1nl �1; 1 �3�5?a• ea d s°a 5 $ 3t :leg_ _a 01 argil=a:1Fryg 5"ag.l e p a: gas 1P- a°� �a a'F`3a sE <aia 88 3 baa a a 3 tE !, gg .1,6 1 P x 9 �- 15 6 ! FaS= 5- e P ,• °a 3s1 j naglb � i 8 g '� 3 Y1� ss $ C! �i� Pgy P - a � - �b§e s° _• s 9.�r-sd !� _�• 2�� 33�a #�me `a$$1i � asPj�9 HUSH. g 13 � � 83.E � a P�f 'J' 2 'C a3:E , § i�� 3�: a 9 e: =•8 g b SH g g �E s � '-i g•'`_ Y$" 3$'= �3 qq $ aa�rB:E �3t8<E$3� ! 1xs tp3a3 .a�S�g.��., m$ LLg�1,�s�;45 t33d� p ra ! � �a1aa'adea s3� $a = ya '�_1P a mY $a1 13�1�s3a =1 9 1 j t- a y �; a 3 F `r ��a s ;3sa {#i s a ;1 _ ?ai_ 5='.'p r Ebj: Bis 5 3E�es P� 8?$; _ 1• � sg ala g Fi• a ° :a I. a. = oaasasaaaa a g8 .1...1p_6�; a. �4=` 6y a3 $ 3 F.- Fp1 sad,§a1E;3`a a:� s3� 1�^:a��6S as ani �g 3 - 3.3 ' _!_ gig g ,yE a -E` a;6aP 3e E� ! as° ��a a :g s L �•. ?3 .��$G��.�a;y � t=E� �s� sa- a 8.p $� g •trF �6F s 5Pf g a $ a3 3° 1'A=3-� n 4 ! s g8 E#,6 is sl1ar �1 aEa3; n r$5.�Ea sib E�nsbB1E€�' Ez�p,E_;a 1 13;x3 &rtg3y! �g�m 3b°9 5'A 3a=aa s as d3 - 6 �aa F 3• $3=sraEt'F" �aB�L Ea 33g3;`€ i� smi��fi3 8 �az�E'� g 13p1s x31¢ 3� r 3 1 ;R, X33 9 jaj j� as4 pa�m g 1a gEgg B�?x51 �3J35• E °� 6£ a as a y3 � 0 BBQ;gra 1 ;5� i-1a'aY 1 1 $- ° s°°rsdi3 3 3 rs E� g ! 8....•.. _ 3s $1= - P 5x1 �� a3 11.i=s .4 pr $3g�°•3� g3 i44 sfig ° _ FsE a:�� 35Ags 3 $ s pa19.1 P ➢43" �g ;= rt = s' g3� g4 9y e98� ' !a _ a g ab s $ � l��� $jILM]i ` ; Y L - _ E a�� �EEa� 9F =wa �53will! �a3?a� 13°13 1E31m 13 �a fiE l8 $ a z ! 3 3 5 E° s� - °:a t $ 1� Pa .�:n _- _ { a d d d t d ° aiba3aa� a3n9 �a:3 ��1iE;x333;_:age13ge s�R��m:9na a3 21y e$�!o$ W d •. p 33 y _9� Ea3E!53_ Y 4 d " ` F-, v- . . .. 1 . /.-Ij-.I '.,.I. Y .. , . \„r, w. i -1 . I- a If r/ '1\ .,-\-.. .. PAIS UVQ30-N _.9 anV sm� 'm Poll hrynN ? m d a 5 aAV 416 9N `� $ a -V In 3N u OAV 1114 3N XMH;leaapaj _ S w > -AV L[ S I Q) E41 :v I l I I I I I I I I 999zr i 938 a •3'd 3MId 'Y Hd3SOf 1Y3S S•833N19N3 10OH11M 011VA ION �-7 '�i �7 'T a Y QIQO idl y�L y aQ.1.S .7 ill QA'IH KVH30 N KaT — i ,LOZ SHZVLLSH ATRIA ZIOgZIVH 'T ��TT3��f T T I,Trf T.�T �f �T ��T �f T T rf ^ •HOA M Y 1d S1NJH 21A0UdW1 HIIS MAID 8999-bLZ (L9S) :'<oJ OOS9-bLZ L99:auo4d bH, 2 P!101j 'yooag 6oJ1a0 ,(oM ano3o alddoawd 96Z 9099 'ON NOLLyz180H10tl JO 31tl0ULL830 YOINO3J .: 1 E; O :2i a caw a L) 0 �z7o [� O �y w o I Q0 C z w [r a G.1 T F � SiNVI'InsxOD 'IVLNsYiN0-dIANa • s -da IiNg .6-p�aa.. �Isa3eloossd10 U61S240JLAU� �/ z 3 o o n5 :19 :SNOISIA38 :31YO *ON .. PAIS UVQ30-N _.9 anV sm� 'm Poll hrynN ? m d a 5 aAV 416 9N `� $ a -V In 3N u OAV 1114 3N XMH;leaapaj _ S w > -AV L[ S I Q) E41 :v I l I I I I I I I I c _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - e�e+ tc•e+ -Lova V) OL 111311 Y3 39NO .01 1-V211 1N3NSY3 39YNwa9 ,91----------------- _-1 L_L W cn E r CU >c C14 a' U W CA ) A < ♦/W� v+ J cw-, C. F � °W a z 3 o o n5 1wy z w<> �6 w 1y a .< U ¢� ?�a < Z ao 3 z �� a <o w F> I o� tea' ° m m a C:3co I -Q o ow UWH o Z J a z o. w N ox g o° 1F I 1Ti bs F c _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - e�e+ tc•e+ -Lova V) OL 111311 Y3 39NO .01 1-V211 1N3NSY3 39YNwa9 ,91----------------- _-1 L_L W cn E r CU >c C14 a' U W CA ) A < I I I I I J � s C. F m z O f!] ¢ z 3 o o n5 1wy z w<> �6 w 1y a .< U ¢� ?�a < Z ao 3 z LJ..I Z ° cFWi W z W <o w F> I o� tea' ° m m ¢ w W N d o F z I -Q o ow UWH o Z J a z o. w N ox g o° 1F I 1Ti bs F Of 5-C oa a as v�irc3 a w I R m 1 a U z _ $ I M-0 I 1 I Z�„ I I I I c _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - e�e+ tc•e+ -Lova V) OL 111311 Y3 39NO .01 1-V211 1N3NSY3 39YNwa9 ,91----------------- _-1 L_L W cn E r CU >c C14 a' U W CA ) A S,Z! rol6; , �YNnJ �►A,. I �� z 0 ` � s C. L) z O f!] ¢ Go I II°�S I iFFO� N wLU W a OWWFWz z>gdWW Rims 1 o F N RR a v~i x )0 a �7 r] bs F m -W I v U o d C a U z R2 Z�„ � �a OI 3 0 o > m� .O O d Iq a 3 10 �U S,Z! rol6; , �YNnJ �►A,. I FOzUdd¢ ¢owo�c L) z O f!] ¢ U W W O W q i1 SFO I iFFO� W a OWWFWz z>gdWW S,Z! rol6; , �YNnJ �►A,. I '1-I'l,-Y 'IV" C. It :P" 7L-4/" /,-I 'hMP'II rn/Ii>.\°Ahr\ma in. r1 , I- a.n=paa. .a Y --/ ,-I\- -\ , o� J LU04 fa tp N U. v WC6-.a co oN w� gem W 1–J � cis pp qtr �I o F {.i 0 W � o� a U Q w i-- o L M. _m 8 lip z S �g Z_I Sa z w wJ� QJ< x z aU OJI— U� O w . cm CL `^ ir'� a a m -\Up 1. ". z\%/\%/` z a3noo NIA NIW ,£ .9 tL / • I > Z �u \ J WnW1NMW a 5 e \ Z O Q z6� \ Z y W z d o M5 g cl `nON e13NNVH :HLyA S31VA•Hld3j /� m P, Z o x mW Jt Q m W5W N eta 94� >' Za N 17 g� w > Yp OS' X 9Z £9' ZpI- a 0_ a Z e w x W6 �m d // Lit < < / - V � � zzo _--+_ m < z� o 58<mIIfn1IIII M 0 zrcw. Z S.2 a><r� 3s U V/ �o�m<II W I Kme I ui= I a 9 m I IVI. / m pI c�iZzi 0 ar— UgLml°I �� m m ouw k'.9 0 yll;; N$ �Ft v tTl NO CV \\ O VO zz� ORo0 0 L� rc$dm0(5 Bo 6 ao UmmoS� Ma« Co m6 SFS.* o M. i mZ O!!JJyy UZO� 0p Z F m x�l/1ZZ~ZWWp U� 2 1� a0i 2gw; C-)1 I zmK 0���`O ggV aww s rLg <zo W>< ZH., all il I] �� t�imarc� ~ 1 : MoG«z o Z < ocT5 Dw e az=w �w ^U Yrc O < > x 2 91-,4 m ,L4'Z 'NIW b a M -809 a � T qq &gym z aBoU J W EV, ' b N Aix it 1 1-15 WEld <W <� W a o- Y "ru+x+m Q Iy F N w�ppee a zt m 4 » Nirc W -6- R. `1�or om a£ z W�" s mWmuix �s w Z Fc3 Q? �wainwrcw = Y p 12 �J� �SgNz dz A H 00 – 959L/ 4 939 V -3'a 391d 'tl Nd350f 1Y39 5,anvA N3 1f10H11M OIIYA lON '7 tTAT�.7rf1TTC� ,TAT �1 vaiaou w Y azii s �7 lflo QA'M I VH30 Iii BEET — T 101 rI'�7'Yt T�-7T C� t7T� SL1LL V LJH MBIA 2IDHZI�H :'HOA S'IIVJ.dQ a0NVIVZlG �? DMIAVd 9959-4LZ 199 :x -j 0099-4LZ 199 :a..4d 444££ opuo[j '4...e ,(.ilea A.m anax3 aIdd... Id 96Z 90S9 'oN NOLLYZI90NlnY !o myouLL930 Yal9old E� a m w°� y o Q 2 a z o �o 2 2 z o E- w N SINV,L'InSNOD 'IVINZANGUANH • S-daaNIf)Na .71 el uIllsooss \ U61sQojlnU�l' ]�1 t// ' 0 A9 :SNOISIA39 '31tl0 'ON o� J LU04 fa tp N U. v WC6-.a co oN w� gem W 1–J � cis pp qtr �I o F {.i 0 W � o� a U Q w i-- o L M. _m 8 lip z S �g Z_I Sa z w wJ� QJ< x z aU OJI— U� O w . cm CL `^ ir'� a a m -\Up 1. ". z\%/\%/` z a3noo NIA NIW ,£ .9 tL / • I > Z �u \ J WnW1NMW a 5 e \ Z O Q z6� \ Z y W z d o M5 g cl `nON e13NNVH :HLyA S31VA•Hld3j /� m P, Z o x mW Jt Q m W5W N eta 94� >' Za N 17 g� w > Yp OS' X 9Z £9' ZpI- a 0_ a Z e w x W6 �m d // Lit < < / - V � � zzo _--+_ m < z� o 58<mIIfn1IIII M 0 zrcw. Z S.2 a><r� 3s U V/ �o�m<II W I Kme I ui= I a 9 m I IVI. / m pI c�iZzi 0 ar— UgLml°I �� m m ouw k'.9 0 yll;; N$ �Ft v tTl NO CV \\ O VO zz� ORo0 0 L� rc$dm0(5 Bo 6 ao UmmoS� Ma« Co m6 SFS.* o M. i mZ O!!JJyy UZO� 0p Z F m x�l/1ZZ~ZWWp U� 2 1� a0i 2gw; C-)1 I zmK 0���`O ggV aww s rLg <zo W>< ZH., all il I] �� t�imarc� ~ 1 : MoG«z o Z < ocT5 Dw e az=w �w ^U Yrc O < > x 2 91-,4 m ,L4'Z 'NIW b a M -809 a � T qq &gym z aBoU J W EV, ' b N Aix it 1 1-15 WEld <W <� W a o- Y "ru+x+m Q Iy F N w�ppee a zt m 4 » Nirc W -6- R. `1�or om a£ z W�" s mWmuix �s w Z Fc3 Q? �wainwrcw = Y p 12 �J� �SgNz dz A H 00 – I 'IYa A. ,7 11 tl - 1C l/�[ 'h"•P TSV- n/0$'.\`VAC\ma -'--i , 10- .a v r*Lt O u� ZW u s r• ;� I,1•�,o r•, o n r- W ® (� oN. I ��jj N o �N II$�R �� r a• onyaMa 1y J lid um �� w 'i ogms U) a W od a N0 bs ~03 L) o mN F p W c� o- Q , a 6i3sN� a m I b T O z •i a $1 -AV 446 IN P O I i NQISiY OIS !IO STI3Y ON / any 1AA IN Q -V 111L 3N 4MH#J0PaJ ( I � T 'o I ---------------- RAV W[ I I I , ra+ a9'a+ Z ee+ >-ce+ ( �. ,.V l.) 01 1N3W35V3 3*L 6+ 1N3N9v3 30YNWNo ,01 I-------=-----------------�-- I 8 � I ' I cre+ ec•s+ sre+ ac•e+ r" I I is I ry I sTi8 IC 1N115v 30VNNW �r I� L - - - - - --- -^ --- ---] ------ I I I la I I I III I r- + / WN, wo F '6 I I i j �_ o_CD F w > i I I I$Y IR -1- m 0 = o >m Z g w elI I � ME zo zw zv`;x I I 1 N i I* e N , Y I I—,sr g I W I I I a ! a m n l R I • °° e y c r $ I cx� boa:o .-. c T o mQ ea�°"3om d�� ra'o mm�m __-- 9------ z y :" ; d m �a f" ° c F o y o m � I + + I IT � � zmS 6 `aa w C no am�P:i Fri<�F I 969Zt M 93tl 33 '3'd '3NId 'V Hd35of 1V35 S, O11VA N3 lfiOH11M OIItlA !ON ' 1'1L W d �QI�O�� IYr Y �RQWS T�nr� GYM MVHDO K 8ZET - T ,LOrI SHJ,VJ,SH MUTA ZIORZIVH �T ��TT��r� TAT r,� T T T T r,�[. •Q0d 1V V ld WHISAS DIJA S BSSB-bLZ l9S :'4 OOS9-bjd 199:auo4d • UVZ18 HIM 0 3 anal a�ddoalnd B6Z `ri'b££ 9 'ON 9059 'aN NOLLtlZINOHIOV �0 31tl01l1LN30 tl09H01d ad e.' Q ^� ra :C w °' r�i d U "+ 0 C O A "'� ty z w z a z O •••i "'� o z w E Vl w ov — SINV,L'IfISNOD 'IV,LNaYiNO2IIANa • SIdgaNIJNT _ vgooss,vn ,utse e�Os Ill u6(sapOJIAu3 • ON 'A9 �SNOISIA3tl �31tl0 'ON r*Lt O u� ZW u s r• ;� I,1•�,o r•, o n r- W ® (� oN. I ��jj N o �N II$�R �� r a• onyaMa 1y J lid um �� w 'i ogms U) a W od a N0 bs ~03 L) o mN F p W c� o- Q , a 6i3sN� a m I b T O z •i a $1 -AV 446 IN P O I i NQISiY OIS !IO STI3Y ON / any 1AA IN Q -V 111L 3N 4MH#J0PaJ ( I � T 'o I ---------------- RAV W[ I I I , ra+ a9'a+ Z ee+ >-ce+ ( �. ,.V l.) 01 1N3W35V3 3*L 6+ 1N3N9v3 30YNWNo ,01 I-------=-----------------�-- I 8 � I ' I cre+ ec•s+ sre+ ac•e+ r" I I is I ry I sTi8 IC 1N115v 30VNNW �r I� L - - - - - --- -^ --- ---] ------ I I I la I I I III I r- + / WN, wo F '6 I I i j �_ o_CD F w > i I I I$Y IR -1- m 0 = o >m Z g w elI I � ME zo zw zv`;x I I 1 N i I* e N , Y I I—,sr g I W I I I a ! a m n l R I • °° e y c r $ I cx� boa:o .-. c T o mQ ea�°"3om d�� ra'o mm�m __-- 9------ z y :" ; d m �a f" ° c F o y o m � I + + I IT � � zmS 6 `aa w C no am�P:i Fri<�F I I I I .ri a I I I�I I IIS I ov W oLu . cr.) U. ® N �Q W CDCQ " '' ++ a W coLU ul V �• O IIS�S ® V ®� © G1 08m3 ® !— CL Cl- M E 9 �b J yyY OY 0 U Z Q o 0 w r z J ¢Lq N aft \ g 8gd` mw'a N m FSIz o�uj �'bz'd �Jii Z7�m6 Q N I-00 I<- g y� Ju z`x p a w 4gr z� z U Z \ O tl v 0. o N • • 1O— L 3'EO♦ oU Y o l eo as € / 11E 1'E qua w ' �� S �°✓. � Cox �$ �F�--o g � � � w � N I —.. .. �. 2.,f o� �� s�� ° "p��� wffg dao 6z a ; ID lo AP 02,LY wWb�iQa K_xd wOld W flail F�w^ 129e a 14 H a� �z ww E- 4. �o $e 9 W W IY € ?$g 3 b z ------------ e q 1 o I ❑ ❑ 12 ,ia �a 69 -a Ivy 0 - N H ♦ d e n d d A N ' � ! � a � I [ I L) , I E- �� I - I ��❑ ❑ ❑ cr 9 "L) E 0 E- X D El El E- CT' El 0 BPI z T / o Who 501--I— F- � o Y Y Hex Z NORtN ' 8 I PzP Pi N'40 2 v << yam 969it / 038 v '3'd d 'V Nd3SOf 3tl35 9,N33NI0 1f0N11M ION 3-7 L7T�o�.T �TAT��'�T �+ •T�n� V ai d W .L .7 QArM MV2130 N gaaT - T III :d03 VVId AOL�HAHUd N0LLnllI0d xOj BSSB-bLZ TZ '4. DOJO bLZ (l9S) 15e VO 9£ 9 '0Nd 'yooag Hinv0 Ao/A ano[0 ald ONJOI 86Z 9059 'aN NOLLVZItlOHLOtl 10 3Ntl01lLLN30 tlON10lj E-•wE •L fa x ) O� � z w z wo o z w E.SHIVI5���ln��g�VH w ul SLNVJ.'IfISN00 'Id,LNHWN0-d1ANa - S1daSNI-JNa 'SIH S8 u6lsee!lssl�` doJIAU 0 Afi 6NOISIA3N 31tl0 'ON W oLu . cr.) U. ® N �Q W CDCQ " '' ++ a W coLU ul V �• O IIS�S ® V ®� © G1 08m3 ® !— CL Cl- M E 9 �b J yyY OY 0 U Z Q o 0 w r z J ¢Lq N aft \ g 8gd` mw'a N m FSIz o�uj �'bz'd �Jii Z7�m6 Q N I-00 I<- g y� Ju z`x p a w 4gr z� z U Z \ O tl v 0. o N • • 1O— L 3'EO♦ oU Y o l eo as € / 11E 1'E qua w ' �� S �°✓. � Cox �$ �F�--o g � � � w � N I —.. .. �. 2.,f o� �� s�� ° "p��� wffg dao 6z a ; ID lo AP 02,LY wWb�iQa K_xd wOld W flail F�w^ 129e a 14 H a� �z ww E- 4. �o $e 9 W W IY € ?$g 3 b z ------------ e q 1 o I ❑ ❑ 12 ,ia �a 69 -a Ivy 0 - N H ♦ d e n d d A N ' � ! � a � I [ I L) , I E- �� I - I ��❑ ❑ ❑ cr 9 "L) E 0 E- X D El El E- CT' El 0 BPI z T / o Who 501--I— F- � o Y Y Hex Z NORtN ' 8 I PzP Pi N'40 2 v << yam Z o; v W M E � o N � CU LQ (DLQ r -t S NY300 Old NY71 Y W U Q 1N CD aMVd R h S y O a w na io v � uocv33»rmo —_ [e+ ■ o i•p�' yl7AS1S a, cra i717LS�Stln 3lNKYhy —� ® Q W N W F - NN 1� ) LL. al ge AYd S[Aq7 Vitra tel' 151127 g� J ib tt� A Vdd,,' II 0 0 g Z30�� a < < K �ct: Q: � 4 4�2 KN IRS, aha x a a4aaa R h S y O a w na io v � 031VL'Odt/O.7N/ 3rriLJ31/N,7t7V S3AYX' (1.YV1'/JIrY .11/ 1N3S/X7J //7L1I,YM SS7,YdX.7 31/1 1/111//1 /ArY7npS1Vf'✓1 HY/ l A//V III A77V3/NdVd"J Q3Z1 un `JO 03rdw n3VN/ONd3N 3f! AVN NOIIVNNOJN/ W 'SAVIS30 'SNV7d 3S -7N1 _171NVd ON 'Q3i1N_7S3N 77V SJW)IV 71V 031VYNd80.7N/ ]Nnl J-717HMV SW7r CW4-)Iv an rw --A *an JL ZDD-A .i. r --r=x -r%-z o -r T"'a o ^ 1 h01 # EIANFIAv HIf 3N 581 eat - o w ■ " sxaa-iinq aaisv---is - x U 3a x �1 wv t��:s t trt� anZ�[ �tv��o t o m x 5 T- > 1 J-0, s3.Lv.LS3MMAxnogxaH < z o� w o o.. x U LLI ul O d) 0 m w m w ~ z vJ z3 'y W a.Fa tFn0 W o � O C ❑< o w o w u > a J Zc � mm r ° a � � � w ElLL <a w i U a m � � � g O a H wwa� LL o :s Z 'o 0 C�//�� V1 W s� a .g x ° 3 w o 0 �+ � w w w� m _ a ° ° my w g w w w� � w O W 0 o �^ o r m haw p m y U= m�E orl Ga 4 y w xm ~ a u R n w m ww z 1TWu _ ow Jm aaw r� w new P. w o h W 1�'1 aEl aw 1/- TSI' w pj1 a O i iz v F- z u oarc� g i 6- 1� b x LL Wl w m _ u� o i o v odo i w rc S ry p< a U y O a o u �i ^ m z z I OU W w2 m m , miw O LL Q Zg v01 K S e 3 o� O 1 U o f a0 W m Q w IN p O J x m Z2m j U w m W O aox > Z Ui yuu wa o wm o owQ dao w4 a wa w r or a$u� m J i ? awe - z O o z>S2 a waw w 000a z °wa,w-�y I- _ U r N m �= ww < z w>o p qzy ow a ma zoo iy �° 'zi Z. w> <F� O zo g g u aQ oo$ as z Qaq d o° 9 �LL� a a� w 'm ww yww o£ w�i arc z��u° Umama W A IL' Un V Y M Q M N .H m a z oa u w 4' o zk w wz� mz uy 10 < ui w rc rc m >a O z oz D �i zym o z �w eo f zu uNa u aw uw u3w � by x x °'d'°a �o rc �wwm u � am �� � �oa VIS � W M ❑ > O � Q LL Cb (V (O u kw w P. fw o z i <� u a m< �,z ° ya x �� _ y a 0-' i riw '°"o rc xFm U3o p pp Oxl'W3 \\\ Q DO W W M Uo = (� C o D w iy wo m mw� € o z¢- a u �y s� Fo u a y a O< rc �iuy zq v o 0 aw ¢ WW 2w w yu4 z F Sx xRu chi OyQ 3 o Flu pr zm§,-r F zm wx 3 Un fn > � CO ❑ W U Q I� a afro' a iw .z z oy � i0 u a a m z� a u � Qzw m i o a I�yy ooa �rc s oa �uiLL ° �� _" i�m� ° oDu Fw'mw .J aw -7 qa g���- ° aS rc�owo ' Vi Z � Q ❑ W (� W Q Z �x i z x ma 3 i w u S as w w mx b w °ow N m Wi i k z wwz r ow ma aN i o 'dsw rcw° i2'z-oa LLw N,zzao o % Z m H M >- U O to U _ m'3'q gg >�mo ri'w pa S izSJ o o o �� xo u w of a of haw aq a ua o owoi o m ax o of rcz iia U I-- rc�a na oa is pam wo > v rwny oOJ z§ g�-owW¢o¢ � mazm u oz p �{�( WOQ�zwoa Y = W Qai q �� > rc rc 3 z V m w� og z am ofaQor�u YA °u MH m W❑ W LL urcDo o Oul- u un z �� y_ u u wa i u Zw < g jaG Z U U' rut m z uz a zz oz w < z �° �S'r g� w� �Fm OaS zQi < cyim �� Oa w o a zg j� �'awy za QO �Oug �rc I- �'d a O U f W Z O Z pzO� o o< p�� gD zt 7 z z¢ W I- 00 y 4 ¢ z aF= vi ma Q F m az O �� 3 Q uu p�z < -3 XLL m i u¢ a1. Q woz po �o'a Q O wfzuo wr aux LLi it ° jw a �o uuyi! JS _aE u o O� = rc o0 ui w mzz w i <m 0 w sZS �F z� a ai tLL�h w� fu yuoa,rc �a ar 'oz pOua� a ❑ CO J rc g rca wrc irc u v >�Ny u wu °0 5 ��§ t w rc� iw a ym wtimz u� m ° o uo �zzw >m ww o wg aF wm �w D w~ wp oam m Juoo o Qa uiuzi rc= z Off 6' rcif o� x j i �o aro ona. za w w mzo aJ 3 uF o'Si vi mk i ziw ya 'z wm� 10 a4 z F ou oarc� uz of wmoo h z5 -'� i6 rcw xw z- uw uw ua rz sz�c�i� wLL Frc�uyau ,u ILL" i� rcawa0 ii U Z W uau z w w r� w z z� J u oaim and rola >z p w uwwa z F' -F �D z w, ?am y z Oxm z4 �+ o ora p a zm> �Vm z z wo o r zrcw o oa ¢ �- Owu ww zrcw w umiw z y �z au q y rc o oa'a' om > u xo w x" pp¢mmam i 30_ t wm 1- z, W O (n O Z rami m o m o- as Doom q uo <zz °o a. z. i op�J D zF nW ; u 2< z a� yam mo z O aaoz aw yW wa ¢ Fm wa Nz u0- p oz xz aw wLo a 0= oa�o ~� om w� ziw om ¢h�u °¢ ua zo inti zw 3 �zin� g � ¢ wm�� tw W V W W V W CO ~ ❑ Y �� o wy rc xw u�o �LLmm o ziw o� g arc zuy w o w� M Aq § owe w �� �a a u > ?aw m qqm J?jw u� w a_ rc y o mrgw 3 oz ¢ 3aF10� a�zy� zm �� ow� ao°y'zo am v o� w Q Z d' U W N (t) to •.: '�+"Jnri5d s -zz z Qaz <° -.04P. rc rc ml- o m ¢w ¢z° WD <� OHW 2p ZF g F o mica �z o wy a� om - w wF ¢K uii w0 Zp Qi N O�wp ¢tt 6 U iV Z <Y �o p2 ua mJOW rc yz x ww y ma uS oZ _ m im 1;�Aa°QQ a zo K j S QLL ziZn q J(7Zpi m Ei w opwpo W>o u$ rrc ON aw gwF=Ow /w V O > W I O U) Q = O (p Lo da ?W 2. w., Om oiao m z� o�w rm°nF Wazo g aUZy VOO �w s ao rcz °m i i-o�' J ow w o<. o rc >u "'a w ¢< ggoJ ¢< rcmrc " O� rci oxwoaz uu ❑ U 7 (V Q Z W I W u wma �-�w Oy wm uq $ < of �> azo u E o a °¢a ° I -m 3m o ww - a��a a z zdm 'uaf w w ;w m g� -as{{z �� H mOp W Z N U U' W m Z O 0wa apQ a°yi 7Fw� w ?IIZL Nu Oya ay mk0 ° p moo zjy o ¢y a as ¢¢FFw ap a < viz rxi! ww rxW vxl� N b �z< rx� w izo O� �< 'i- ow yuwo ow op y0 y�za po a�Fu a LLw�g m ¢F FQjo� Oy z xwuu u� J LO f/% Z Z = W M Q i< _^ �Zpw Jzw $a m o 'a -ay o aaw uw w uui x �9axa iwsoraw o4 0'6E '¢gym of ow maw uv o I- o y'' z F a� a °�- J zw y rcw aaa as y�aowm rca u uo4z °Q ga'0'2 oyN om Qa�¢rn� yu m y rczz>w �� o� °aoom (A O w ❑ N J U J Q O LL - ya�y rcrc a Fw ¢my F� rc o o ottLL zw $lQlQ�� o J z� z LL i��� zr" i gpqaw S a uO wz °i u� auN uii�x3; = i a z ai �� Sm uaa g " ti_m �i&a w �o �w FI -y? zQ pp �m„ya xa ayZ u� w q,4 z'Oy-' W (Y ❑ W > ~ ¢ ww W1-� �g w Wlx-aW w w j�o oaw o �d ~ y r=� f= �iwQ r=s zF hrco jtz�'o wul 0oy O� o �Z�Zw m=wz s�� ou4� Fw fwpa fz W ' QUlm t41 4U� TUO< TU¢ Q l4Jf m lc c4i TU C'1� (70mc O¢ U' U l7 viii U' W �'a�i9'� �Q QI°J �' 6 Yxi UR' V' 0 C? C? 0 - -' o W N O U1 'd' (O z ¢ Z � W � O "� 'n r 0 I I I I co H W V W o0 U~ V Z _ �a a z cLL>Z I acY7Yll / U W M C� ❑ O F— cnM�vrn ` MW •: Z W❑ W U3 Z O ¢ — U LL O O H m Q Q W wmmw W U W (� O 2i w z LL� ZaYww ¢ W U LO CV ' x �Qd00>LU <wIW- a z Z �_ Z¢ 0<00 LLCrin�n _ U Un>Q W Q W z —❑tq CD ¢a I W UJ� L D❑ ❑ U O m �— O X w U) Z— — �-i w (7000 �:U) EL z HD Q ❑O ❑ �IJi ❑ > Q U a- Q ❑ U- .., �Q Uarn<nLL W W O CL Q U z❑>(� g Q W a Q = w OU o_ NU) cn o Q L� W —1 z —1 Q W W O W Z J cV iii a ui a- 2 w (n ��// LL Z w U .- ❑ ❑ w Z _ fn ❑ U ~ U .. '^ ~ = U to F- F' 2 2 to fn f- 2 2 (n UJ QZ J r J N 0» J J J O ❑ W Il o LL U.� Y w U N2 O Z z 0. Z LL ❑ z F- �z F 101 U1 Y II O ❑ UYYm z LL (L 1- ¢UU Q W O O Z ❑ -' X11 ~- m m w w LL (Y 0= 0 ❑ N w > 0 d 5 m W w z H U❑ U Q z Y M - Q LU (D 0}}W tq (7 cn N O co - 0O zz 0 LL c07 F- W U O (� to [}' ❑N Q Ww (L ~ �z0`T U- �� W m¢� F- w w w w w � J o=Qz . -�izo¢z❑ nazi¢¢ O a O w z C9 U x O to U m w U (q tet' W O Q W to _ � Uww1-LL~~ �¢ a ❑ w c7 LL U 0 w di U)i U Z W ❑ W Z>- W CO >wUn0�tY FOU 0 O l� [r ❑ K 0E- m O w (n Q J ror � W x (ntLQ (wz a- O N w z W EQ ❑ ❑ O z > Q Z � z a Z O J I— W w> �Nn]Y d }a (07 FOU m w ON w ❑ Q UtnQQQQ 'V31VNOdNC7.7,J1 3N1?JJ3JIH.7NV S.7H17f O."MO N 3011I39JJOJ toz.i A S93NdX3 31.1 JnOH11A 83A17SJ VPA HNOJ AHV NI A77VJIHdVN9 03Z1711n NO 031d07 'Q3J/7CLIN'd38 3.9 AVIV MII1 VR'NOJNI NO •SIl'J1S30 •S1IV7d 3S -7H1 7O I 811 ON 'U3/1N7S3N 77V SIHIN 77V 1I.7/VNndNn7HI 7NnI 771I97NV C7WIr nNllun)v In rnv Iunrvl �n� c w £O££ VCMIO I3 HOV�1H AV2i 73QLQ z n = b01# TIN�IAV H.Lb HN 581 Q _ S2JRGIIMG 3QISVHSLU INVHWIS TIAD VALE NVH,)O W SZZI <- k < S91VIS3 MHIA TIOnVH r < z F '� ,< 110 > - _ _ x •—� z ix 04 3 I I I O I I IN f ; - ebb l„ aanvd O I I I A013 -------------- __ _ ___ gI 2,o (Wd 31vM U v) �q Ata^osv3 AGYMY,ld ® a s. „— 1JH?ll 1N3' — 3�tlrMVild PI I I I SISI I _ �_ _______________________ 'I YA Amy 8s"C v3 vad A ----------- --- ----- I I < I I I I -- I P-1 I u Q M I I o z� O �4 ❑' ❑ I mty I 1.4 U i 0 I :-------------- �-----'-- ' pI -------------� ---- ---------I------- I I '94 SOA lYkfl (OII Mufl I I .D m lt�`f35V3 I.®•!V dY021 31 M2Jd PL d 3 AlV d -------------- --- --- I j % (all 99yd �n J o W ` n �• P. Q 1171VNOdN17N1 3NI1331 /H.7NV S31,Or 178VH7IN 717 1/1391107 1171.11NM SS.7NHA'.7 3H1 111H11A N3119I WA H201 AIV III A77V.71HdVN'9 03217111 NO 031d17 'O.77100Nd3N 79 A P1011 VHNOJNI NO 'SN91S.70 SIIV7d 3S3H1 JO 1NVd ON '03A&3S78 77V S1H91d 77V 1131 V8OdNOJN1 3NN133llHOVV 57N171' O8VH7IN A9 VOP I NOMdMl p .rrrr Sift t_Z o £8b££ VUl-dO-W `HDV]9 ,kV'dl3Q - - - z ■ j t,01# 3AN3AV H Lh 3N 981 - y u s2ma-iinq 3Q1Sv3S ■ ■ z I LO I s3.Ld.Ls3 m31A 2inOQ-JVH w a x Q x U 3 0 Q /d/ '17:71 Vd•7d807,V1 3NOLZ7f/H7NV .S3/9/" 08VH.7M-701113SNOJ I1.31178M .SS'3NdX3 3H.1 108H1IA 2V3AOSI VH/I WN173 AIV //I A77VJIHd V89 034!X10 NO 031403 '0_3JOOONd38 39 AVH 1011 VWN03N1 80 'SNOIS30 'SUV7d 3S3H1 3O 1NVd ON '03A83S38 77V SIH9I8 77V 031 VNOdNO.7Nl 3NOf9B1IH3NV S -7N7/' 08VHJI8 AA E102 1H91NAd03 ct O O v: ul g MIH VQIW IJ `HDV39 AVd 130- N 5 z ■ bOl # 3f1N3AV HJ f, 311 SS I - o Z o w s2I3a'IIA8 3QISV3s = (� ■ ■ 'x Q V 7 a v O -IJ VVV3?I LS 1111 'QA"1Il RV 1D0 'ISI 8Z xO 4 " g 3 1 LLOZ- SFUVIS3 M3IA WlOMIVH o 'z v < 3 m 5> > CC .,r W M LL N LLCeD Q W a --I zlu �----- LL O (� IX 0N F J --i-----1-- I o 0 CY CL0 ' I I II - W O Ik, I it N N I I � LU I ® n° ct O O 9.71 C'Nnd87.]; (f 78/1[331lH78V 51, 'r a.YVHWY.in i!1>i/:07 07/i 1rM �,V,,A3 .71, i ,OH/(,11 r-ACi:: :.H7 14d17I l`V n7 A-. IH�✓rn:7 7%71n h17 1771d,171 'a'JR,XYa7r _n.7 AV,l UoL/t'. ddn rn :q;9lr34 c,:V ]i 7i #I P •r'<>!1 / -: n)'S 7+ , SSti9'h' , u i.r ,:11'n 1 :, .d'n,'v„H” ., �' - i.. ... ir. ni" Ur :,IA, AA £!Od 1Hn!?IAd77 n �-",4* 1. T H ::�Y*'a -,,,vr s -At--z O r0i# RI7NRAd H.Lr HN S8I W U M Q w o w c SHICI f1fI3QISd3S �� U w/ LALcm ■ ■ , n = RZ N x i _ D � w w —IJ WVRXJ S TDO 'QAlff NVHDO 'N 8ZZI I I O I- SJIVISR /ARIA-If1OgHVH J o ' _ r-- _ J ° w _ 719_ <� >>> M W M LL G `.' LL W oa w/ LALcm W ® J D O I I 0o M O O N >>> '931VhV.W Nl3d%IIJ31IN3NV S3NLY' 9,YVN71& JO 1N7SfmJ N311IJ'A SS3dtdX33N1 IfMJIA aGARS1VNA NL'OJ ANV NI A77VJINdVd9 9371711n 1Y107tdrt7 '//'iYMln) - m �vw unci eum ui� �xr •cun���r. •�u..v x�.., .., ,.,... __.. _..._... __.. __....._ ...__.._ _.._. __ _ _ o r-1% Qrr v 14 Z a w Z ■ o ~ £817££ VQRIO'I3 `HDVIU AVN IFIQ fi0I# 3inN:IAV Hlt7 3N 98l O N s ° - = M Z Z o LL SIdla-lIf18 HQISVflS m v S a u x ■ ■ v p y� a x 3 > "I3 WVaUJS TMD *GA'IEI NV900 'N 8ZZI o 3 I ZO'I- SRIVIS9 MMA-IflOUVH ° N N y N �1 I :\ W _= LL W N oa Qco 3W � a o 0� J a a �i KT air nt # 4 # #-0� $ 0 ct 0 ct W O CF II R z ° N N y N �1 a < U W lD L H Y J 21 Z W M LL >co z ix d ) o; w aa,. cm � a i v L - WO CD W o i • 9 0, �AnUU 9c Y.0 9in U2 9m�0n a 0 KUMO.U.-d�� W xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx x'TN M xx@' iiii�xi i�i�i �i `xiri ri �s riu�x= qui LLI $°�°B�°oao ��°3��sssea�aQeoc�a�a3�°Q z = LLPLL LL o 4aa��awi poow�opo WHIM1ZEE 5- 1, i"N.H."HIM11fliho w999 -U -CH Qan�nnnnn��-2-A'-A��*AEA�9VV- Q 0 w LL] g v 0 9m Qr At .4c nn .° rry c9 9S Ar 01 € S �d dmd y�.Yiv '•$ -yam ou �N 8 m 0 e m p' a a 3 � � s_ a •e a � Y y � - �e Z �6 �a �6 ua orm �nm filo 5r� �$ A 1u>t �S n� 8� �€ J 8 v o o 06 L ` O y a on"s o ~- oo + (d '3 L L 4.1°^ �f A{ y II N '� a w 9 #Cd U W u N N • 9 0, �AnUU 9c Y.0 9in U2 9m�0n a 0 KUMO.U.-d�� W xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx x'TN M xx@' iiii�xi i�i�i �i `xiri ri �s riu�x= qui LLI $°�°B�°oao ��°3��sssea�aQeoc�a�a3�°Q z = LLPLL LL o 4aa��awi poow�opo WHIM1ZEE 5- 1, i"N.H."HIM11fliho w999 -U -CH Qan�nnnnn��-2-A'-A��*AEA�9VV- Q 0 w LL] g v 0 9m Qr At .4c nn .° rry c9 9S Ar 01 € S �d dmd y�.Yiv '•$ -yam ou �N 8 m 0 e m p' a a 3 � � s_ a •e a � Y y � - �e Z �6 �a �6 ua orm �nm filo 5r� �$ A 1u>t �S n� 8� �€ J 8 003 ----------------------------------------- a -Q,- 46 N l 0 7 W O C�2 O co O C/) ui M LL ® N LL-COa > � zIx 03:1.- U QN LLI acm 0 u cd 9 0 G U s E R GIm t 1L C U 41 L U u U L L T a � N A A U m U dddddd ''� H Q Z vCl11 W` CSS C= as �A L_ -r� 3 w C o s O u W L rs-- W ui ° to Co � L �" `o x c g 0 0 IL LL N L� # U� W ziraoco o m +r o ' r Al 1 m O u W L rs-- m ui ° to v O 00L � L �" `o x a 21 g 0 0 _ aL> # U� o m +r r Al 1 m W N �` 09 W W e*rs o m > cV W CD W o C 3 o II A ro u 4J L V � L L j IL � `o 13 II0� aaaaaa O 4- 0 W O cn coW CS 7Q c) Q 00) i �-vaaaja5 d]j•'�5 Mewaaaaagagpap9 s��g � Rumomai�E34��a tFh� d u_ d L ;F U 9L /d °a a N ul dJ .r E4�a g s ;in s3 - 'E�• &` 3 F$i' t 5 E s�•8 :pp�aE 84 a YrtEY s -Bm: u Y �=at - j' •i � 9 !$j� 3.a.gy3ijt! � t v- p3rt�spy IN ani art's s�E::; t' : 47'�P 6.F P p i g• u' 9 i'il= E" i �t5a's Flo E5 � �g En E�yi!��. 5g ie i��n g-�• _� 5{.583 �is>u i �' 8 $a���7Y� �" P��;� �a F �s;., -MOMa E `; �•'� ;. 9 � ?' P 6 �`n° n 32aa3 gat5gg��� &4 igw 5 �9 �� zs ��a� aill;iAB�g3t�$"g 3� _- yk�°�g.g r d Y hip agJ AllBL i�yga �Ea E ;y agy;�F ;g�afd�� � , �➢� �8�y3�°. �}i A. '9 g j F� ayyyy¢¢ ;� ° gSSF"�� ,>E a 89 its IL aFg§ s=g �$ 3Og Fwi5 8 9 g.. mgjFatr iit ° $ ! •� � 6" at ff ffEY i � �31 �ee�8�9� 343 e_ E�1�] Ali 229111,1 ! i dig X33 gas as ge 3a � �a;8g rt - _ Min 3 i g P ; `s$fig $ 8; �83� al p- 3 � g gg s g•& z sl EE aiF�zg s�ii {a �w'� 4• w �d ag t $ _ t=�h 6322 � $ feE wiaIJ bi ilp Fi B ago; P � P111 g s.fi15a s a"? FIgEg E�PaEY si i psis E� !a F B 3imw of $ jji yy$ sgr 3� '-�� EPF€ "3 m83y im$ Eaiag' g8 3€� a 5= a 41; 'rta&ap8g or4;e?E - d d J u 8 d d J H 3 SatcE "j j� 5 90 g $ ie 125 g§F LL� t] €i:.1 d ➢E 9 3 c°.n JR it E 3g1F4$ p���'ggE1ig8°Ey° I 3 E„°'Eg5s .g4)=$g i� i1$11FFIF 11 Flht.E 9 -] 3`a:a°g-�,:�§}"3?3�i �g a � �3a� E•y` ss � a� - ha t Esa5;i➢F;�a$ .g8 ag am,gj V11 94 f8 c• � 8: d J g E;!}.8 F F g aPswp° gae'8' a3' 9 a9 $g yy �• i� $ig• � Ertk �. s°I IL P?it;a�`° tB3i;PY E�agi . g a; 8 a§ a°Ee g� 558` ag a 2:g Sh=at a'�:F• fida� $ i E S3 0 8 �� s .�OEyy ig 8a�fi ? MI! X1$8 ��$'' � �Eg ij#�, a 2€i;5 g B�iAgp3 i�E3: big m$e,:aEga�E' $4ia 9 F ,alga;3 3 gage $sg a;9"she g� ,it P. tt i�a� i � : a � 5 $ 3 S d - •�}sg � �Efi7Ys �ts56 3' d d u w € d . 8 ] : �� 5 i 5=i ff%y 3 f $ s_ gi•i fr�_s �5E fi;s. � $t9 � � '8�ti �➢y � �` ��5�8r-xs�i���8aah `����'��a ��p�gg^�,Y;3 58��8 e��E� s�s� s� � �� m%;ga•s�'� ,rg=.; B�a:F�;ia. ssE _�=Faay• iia 3- �'&8a$ §$ t F�P$$ gg8 g B j8'$a;,�$�$ g;�p 335��; s� g8s s gfa ae%8 e g g F E' A s Eat 9j➢ �� ' .gz�� sag g 9a ?!rrt�s"�.is � g� s=erg �t €1�S�g a8$gt dF.ess aag� a i ti`g = � '� � � ; � t3 �BP�:��B s�g �� � a�el s'p n'•g- 5€s � 4 E' ods ei'= + t �° g• ����%� a ��EB �a�'' � ss a99�ama�__`>��%;�g E 4;! ,,g s�.i•.]BP�p�� 3g]ffa Fa�tE'� a g Eff ,ear sa >$ €a fi �•. $ a a"° ]:g ab a j9EF ,j i- E E4 gj m ga.fi 9�3'��F--$ Eg 5-g ➢�8.4�:F'B E Fal: Sr �� � 8'ogp o�= Pa�n59`6S !'-r$Pip58Y$2$ p1gi u3'g �a aii till]-=gm'35ig"3 MIR i��pe g � i iiw Ig E 33- 1'311�e�isa �3 g3 $ii �lta:tans9� g $Ea$ ba a E5 $ a F$ $ •rt a 8yE •;$ sts 9 g Igag iE a lglp• p_s>° i ge ;� e g=a8MAIfi-• � 3'•2E ;sYae: g ggi•h �•. F z E !" a €8 � �'' F5 ag S: .gT in•'P-c e a3g 1, a �,8y 8uj8ya4� �sg tYa a88 Faii< Jill i!�,5a�a�Fy 6sg �gh�F i t t, = h�a�a�agr ;� s $a 8 ge9'g� °gs a rtae4$a3 39 BiP�'$��a= ;E,€ g aay`5 hks Pull $ QeggE d $°h3 pi 2 a $}98 k ps gym; fE :y3� 8a' != gra g Ei �s _EY 4t_ff ? F- F6 g �Ea 5gE b t5rtg8ag g�F 8'a 8 227E3g;g°P� Q'lf Eg E6� F 3 `8 a,, ass 3gig3 a= s; -a 5 9 FFA ���.,3 ha-a9°3°s•. " a.�Y F F�_�� asg gs a =aEa �a}8nE°= ad a s a h g SQA§gffan-=8 _ s= 8aa�i�igg 5eii}� 1 cea 8�a 5a=s j5' gas h 5' ,3 Fg8 Y 18 a s -j" ®§ 1 t o F�� b z 8 z g.�g9s33 � i EB aaaai- _E W$ }9:Ega�a92 g g a :a y! pq g§3E S d d d d J d W j d d J 0 3 d t 3411 ON !s HU, 1, jpaE.ff iF oa _: !t4s U FY 1a E_ d•5 91.0b�gg gf3Di Wvi ! EBrgS' i•8g� i56s # 3gHi Ings 19 i-- 1�i�lll(t�i•#Ei iii O E 0 0 H O a N O Q 6s,■ 1 m � t) g . �a 1L coo - 01 b°Y it fa h �4=4 g,� m p �g p9_Eb�F 4;a. E$ s$ E9! E?'a $.8 °!g p� �E 4 aE1 o;; aaEj as pSg'g Fay 6i� ° ss all Y h '3a , 4 4= §g Ea BEea ��3 j 3 -�a9 1 t `as IL $ F� �3'� 5$}gF dFg'aF ?38e ��at i8ff �g8 p i' i;t:P ,ail No d W a J hL n52�g F e § a e}aFaa 3y3- s !8i Y 'ii1 8 r ff 4arlfi iy -0 p; $ #��§�. lli ffl k$ E s P P� �_ aF�B=� Fgg� E jE�FA•' 9• a°�8g� s'gb 9y _y h 1� �g•;�i��� `•;5� 5 g: g p.°§ k .@ a i s s:n i Sk iINA, -101 JIM41 as8i�a�� J d W LL• �a3 d d J g ;F! 4 i �a g g8 zs 8aI' nay; =aa as g$sFfig�ga 8a_Ea ff ��- 8a8Eg5�a$ $ ,auE_ °gE`Ea tm bAq j ��._7 d x_36§3 q $a. gFo a45� a""ig gga gag �_F a`s3ap'4gF4��`d t.3 ' a g� a- g�.g 844, fi ii $ia e gs 9 n a aLLa� 5= 3' fig a 3 as r r= 8',a•a �i} a g:g rta a§ a$ ,gg] 98 s ff a s_ E3 § �g j3 a,§ha Y 3' ;E= 9 g8•� t $g gsk P3F@ g ' s g s, gp GP SFa g $E 3 3 i !if e ai �Egs� € �� � �t an#_� �1a."� �3 Lm� � � ���, g ���g�! i�;�g; 4E om3� Fk°i ; F'S fi-p$` Fz 3°.3539'`2 B E� iz EE g��"8 i- �i s� b 9s$ 1111j,g $_;i�_B�8 5 ,§§alai gj #kE�S� )� 155 g3 ➢y1+�fi�a'• 8F c; a� iE a 3 F" �,�P }'.p E;Sg8 ff8 as s Y g 3 ; Cs 5, g i g 111E E a��t5g§boa h �, a !� 9a ;_, ik; _a a � ° B qE ainaF kffs $a _ Qn6;a 8 5� Ufa 8 _ 6 uj p 's r a Fagg e E :E � i § 9��1­11 $ A] � = g' e5$ ag'112ii ag saF EE= 8�='F 6➢8 a $.w'j �• g�- �a g- i §�' "a��F & F'ri $�° la •a a gr ff$' �_ 3" `�Y-"5. 8 Y! e i 5,•3 g8�°5$ �Eg3 a3.s ksi 5 3$�SiBe fBa!$ F as]'zs$�i8ig�l 118=11H 9x9'd 9' Sa •FS 3 ii?�gnF §9_p39 d d J e € d E=sc d d s d d J d Wg Hill. 118=11 � i J c ;;ig 9! H �g pp f d d t d d d d ?g"g 8 TIM E6 yy E E: 38gj s sa { s Y $ az8 : F€ G�;• i D41 E B $@j i Bra €9"• _ !. 6= ar$6 �oi'- Will;gg: i ° 2 8 EE'y3'a ag 4P F F`vaaaaasaa'..8b €� $ 811,5 33Y�aFi ] ° "� _ �= �, f' p k , E' ] Ypmg d " . h E- t gn. t i a° ae ;8a ��__° gi;a i iljiji �` jg = `�� aaaaaaaaaa9 a y�-1a li'€ gs ;§ h�" s 3j•' 19 1 _ �� Ea ]3 8P�` ffa 5,'� 11,ga it, 86.e E":55856 �i s a$t 8�ad_3 a :4 3 $te i g g F $ $; 18"8 Fd�`-E; ,g a k fid:"."uuu""l�k: g: y$ E lyazEF�t a E a a h s •g :4t g a 5 aFaf3 i`dP= "� 8�9 E E# g t•� ° § All E . E� YF sn 'g `aa - .g 8 -9n. a E ' a 1 € }gff G 98s3 95 ga ; $' ga $•F =a 3E 8% E�4y` as YSaF _E g_ r § �a!E a i8=E€� EEt}a S, ;-dia .-:a= nyF 9 $ -e. sa 2 3}a ' ��9 $=Si $= g aEgg� `°5yk _ 3n`.S�ni�•EESi'=5 t.=$.€a E g g MirF:i$�3 ,BiaE •p �lS �. 37 a h �� � 8a -.2 -}i Fa iggb d_YE se pE i gMd ' . aa= `°a a-� @ g E E a`Q ;'E§ �- ;Dg$ pp FE - Eg #5 E ss °L 2 E.s - $ 8- Y3F F $ s a as Qa a g iy� U_ >$ }F gj� i Fa Eis` ;$�?g`� sg g YnE: Ya3 s ! � ��` i c 's°az��iax5a Eg= �- s _a8E§ § fag 82 so n�S p astu,3 ? a>I n SA �'y' ,. § �'EF �i z!= ! - g➢g i` c § 3 g > fi sh Fgi E E a g- 5� -�� =" oa 8 '`� : YE=a y ;:y� $F g i g•€i 34yg �t 54;7 sq!t Fa'i• 3�x ' p -a E�§_ $' 8.3z �;Q3�3� ` ?;� s F t5"'�a_ a3 �g_- ��" ����F�9' ��'8a-4 " -•� -SUM • mi €$TIM �ig?iIa 1g"i3 121mi? Ilea ea �� s_.=i=�a$ � 3 $ a � it �� � g�� a pa a t ISE�- a ° ve i'ae E C ha = g= Fhygg a Eod a9:P: Fag a �P�gg �''~ H <i s iza�.E SggP i-- 1�i�lll(t�i•#Ei iii ® { d 6s,■ 1 Z g> t) g 01 b°Y it fa h �4=4 g,� m p �g p9_Eb�F 4;a. E$ s$ E9! E?'a $.8 °!g p� �E 4 aE1 o;; aaEj as pSg'g Fay 6i� ° ss all Y h '3a , 4 4= §g Ea BEea ��3 j 3 -�a9 1 t `as IL $ F� �3'� 5$}gF dFg'aF ?38e ��at i8ff �g8 p i' i;t:P ,ail No d W a J hL n52�g F e § a e}aFaa 3y3- s !8i Y 'ii1 8 r ff 4arlfi iy -0 p; $ #��§�. lli ffl k$ E s P P� �_ aF�B=� Fgg� E jE�FA•' 9• a°�8g� s'gb 9y _y h 1� �g•;�i��� `•;5� 5 g: g p.°§ k .@ a i s s:n i Sk iINA, -101 JIM41 as8i�a�� J d W LL• �a3 d d J g ;F! 4 i �a g g8 zs 8aI' nay; =aa as g$sFfig�ga 8a_Ea ff ��- 8a8Eg5�a$ $ ,auE_ °gE`Ea tm bAq j ��._7 d x_36§3 q $a. gFo a45� a""ig gga gag �_F a`s3ap'4gF4��`d t.3 ' a g� a- g�.g 844, fi ii $ia e gs 9 n a aLLa� 5= 3' fig a 3 as r r= 8',a•a �i} a g:g rta a§ a$ ,gg] 98 s ff a s_ E3 § �g j3 a,§ha Y 3' ;E= 9 g8•� t $g gsk P3F@ g ' s g s, gp GP SFa g $E 3 3 i !if e ai �Egs� € �� � �t an#_� �1a."� �3 Lm� � � ���, g ���g�! i�;�g; 4E om3� Fk°i ; F'S fi-p$` Fz 3°.3539'`2 B E� iz EE g��"8 i- �i s� b 9s$ 1111j,g $_;i�_B�8 5 ,§§alai gj #kE�S� )� 155 g3 ➢y1+�fi�a'• 8F c; a� iE a 3 F" �,�P }'.p E;Sg8 ff8 as s Y g 3 ; Cs 5, g i g 111E E a��t5g§boa h �, a !� 9a ;_, ik; _a a � ° B qE ainaF kffs $a _ Qn6;a 8 5� Ufa 8 _ 6 uj p 's r a Fagg e E :E � i § 9��1­11 $ A] � = g' e5$ ag'112ii ag saF EE= 8�='F 6➢8 a $.w'j �• g�- �a g- i §�' "a��F & F'ri $�° la •a a gr ff$' �_ 3" `�Y-"5. 8 Y! e i 5,•3 g8�°5$ �Eg3 a3.s ksi 5 3$�SiBe fBa!$ F as]'zs$�i8ig�l 118=11H 9x9'd 9' Sa •FS 3 ii?�gnF §9_p39 d d J e € d E=sc d d s d d J d Wg Hill. 118=11 � i J c ;;ig 9! H �g pp f d d t d d d d ?g"g 8 TIM E6 yy E E: 38gj s sa { s Y $ az8 : F€ G�;• i D41 E B $@j i Bra €9"• _ !. 6= ar$6 �oi'- Will;gg: i ° 2 8 EE'y3'a ag 4P F F`vaaaaasaa'..8b €� $ 811,5 33Y�aFi ] ° "� _ �= �, f' p k , E' ] Ypmg d " . h E- t gn. t i a° ae ;8a ��__° gi;a i iljiji �` jg = `�� aaaaaaaaaa9 a y�-1a li'€ gs ;§ h�" s 3j•' 19 1 _ �� Ea ]3 8P�` ffa 5,'� 11,ga it, 86.e E":55856 �i s a$t 8�ad_3 a :4 3 $te i g g F $ $; 18"8 Fd�`-E; ,g a k fid:"."uuu""l�k: g: y$ E lyazEF�t a E a a h s •g :4t g a 5 aFaf3 i`dP= "� 8�9 E E# g t•� ° § All E . E� YF sn 'g `aa - .g 8 -9n. a E ' a 1 € }gff G 98s3 95 ga ; $' ga $•F =a 3E 8% E�4y` as YSaF _E g_ r § �a!E a i8=E€� EEt}a S, ;-dia .-:a= nyF 9 $ -e. sa 2 3}a ' ��9 $=Si $= g aEgg� `°5yk _ 3n`.S�ni�•EESi'=5 t.=$.€a E g g MirF:i$�3 ,BiaE •p �lS �. 37 a h �� � 8a -.2 -}i Fa iggb d_YE se pE i gMd ' . aa= `°a a-� @ g E E a`Q ;'E§ �- ;Dg$ pp FE - Eg #5 E ss °L 2 E.s - $ 8- Y3F F $ s a as Qa a g iy� U_ >$ }F gj� i Fa Eis` ;$�?g`� sg g YnE: Ya3 s ! � ��` i c 's°az��iax5a Eg= �- s _a8E§ § fag 82 so n�S p astu,3 ? a>I n SA �'y' ,. § �'EF �i z!= ! - g➢g i` c § 3 g > fi sh Fgi E E a g- 5� -�� =" oa 8 '`� : YE=a y ;:y� $F g i g•€i 34yg �t 54;7 sq!t Fa'i• 3�x ' p -a E�§_ $' 8.3z �;Q3�3� ` ?;� s F t5"'�a_ a3 �g_- ��" ����F�9' ��'8a-4 " -•� -SUM • mi €$TIM �ig?iIa 1g"i3 121mi? Ilea ea �� s_.=i=�a$ � 3 $ a � it �� � g�� a pa a t ISE�- a ° ve i'ae E C ha = g= Fhygg a Eod a9:P: Fag a �P�gg �''~ H <i s iza�.E SggP r)AIE1 UCa)O N _ 9b9ZVI / 03a lJ '3'd '3NId 'Y Hd3wr lV3S 0 100H11M OIlVA10N Wilziolid INvEl lils dri lD V LLl �R YV ! W 1 11 ✓ Q[LZS NVE1100 N 822i - i EDT U0JVVldSWVyW�AOUdIllHSrD 9SS,ttg (L9S) Ixod OOS9-6Id L99:auo4d bbbff op'ON •yooag 6o31a0 O 3 anolg aldd0awd 96Z 9059 '0N NOOVZINOHlf1Y j0 3Ltl01jLLN30 tl01801j z7.F d F:�" w xW a U M � F a z o i' Z.we m o 22eul o z o . WSHZVLSHMHIA2IOgIVHr M 10 a a S aAV 446 3N SLNVLII1SN00 S2IRNNIDW- seooss 30 „7- a„ aAV lP9 3N Q _ -. aAV I)IL 3N :AO :SNOISIA38 :31V0 'O r)AIE1 UCa)O N _ o o N rt o ana snw ® - a m a a S aAV 446 3N Y 3 $ Z aAV lP9 3N Q _ -. aAV I)IL 3N =a dap. 4MH'leaap0j s rOAV w! I O � I I I I I I I I iu o o I I I I w � o a ® m 4. O ¢ F I` 00 U I O Z O O w Z Z Z w > ILI O w p I� a5 a wa U oW =a dap. 3� > oa a .1 O Z1= a � n a o oa a �w as Ina- a w a w I a - UI o� o a o o I I I I w � o a Z O 3 za m ¢ O ¢ F I` 00 U I O Z O O w Z Z Z w > ILI O w p I� a5 a wa U �¢ wzFa = o ao Z2> 3 a = =a dap. 3� > oa ILI oZO .1 O Z1= a ox a n a o a a o o oa a �w as Ina- a w a w I a - UI o� o I I I s z 8 1l Oa 3lYAlad Y) 01 1N3NM35V3 V3 30VNIV�V0 1�W21L ----- lN3rvsv3 3�Ylxvaa ,o 1 -L- W 10 o iI o_m xQ a o I I IVLL - A �wq0 ANQFZ W ..F �.. •� U zw isi Z •`-s F Oz z d awo �6 260' O U .. F f� � 0 o a u�4 WZ UlC o«. =a dap. 3� FFaUAz > o 9i o UWO dW N F a U ^-1 LL�w Rgmg UI F a P. P. 9 O W W F W z o a iQ Z. m ~_ 00 I a U ' N < a w �2oB z o z z A dl v d� .fl rte-. Y1 0) A � 3 fC oU Y A �wq0 ANQFZ W ..F �.. •� zw o U W OC.hFZzF U d •`-s F Oz z d awo �6 260' O U .. F f� � u�4 WZ UlC o«. 0 FFaUAz > o oz�n 9i UWO dW 9r ro W A F F F 0 F a P. P. 9 O W W F W z L > l w S�4 (of, 4 , \ / 1S3 dln�a 'a_�bn,,. 1 a r4,4 -,q O .=. Qi --I v1aU'wq x WE -0 ul F Z U A W A W z W EE d� F x d C) F W E. W Uzfs O UA F�dzda o lx 0 W I -Il?tl 'IV•• r._ 11-4' j. -I lmp'1I. n/IIS,\'eL' \.:.. i... - -i o� LU �.wy °8 Y I CD LL. ® N LL. W04 v zlx p R r � !;I- c'r'y E S ®G w > ""� cl" -t= bg� d. o n V Ry �. W U o CD -1- 3SIRE? Z I- 3 =, Y m� ooa 8� ado z N$ o Ja3Ao0 NW1 o m� \�� ��j z¢-8 NIYI ,£ .9 I.,_ a.5 Z uw ¢ <oir N o MR J \ z W VVI psi 6 g aON43NNVH0 HLIy 531�VA N1d3Q /� H = YAR w;ar ¢ ?N� apo ymymyy$$ a m�vm Ha- > oC OS' % BZ f5' z z H n a z ¢ u LIA W z LO EL `gvz <ooa�S gn r �a �♦ I mach '�'I'��Ihlgr-:Xoxo 2MRLn Q<�zum.a p N � 6 a 64 a ��mo 00 Ln Baca W a .- z. a Egg o N 3 z8 m Rg, Y mz z O.. 6', U z m a I imu E]][ oW -i W. Q z<Zo. 00 g6F �U �"� F w< m V4�IZ<~ZWW N9Y =�0 �'' <� Y� m J FOm� NO g u Q yyif _ � ui Uiw< rnz UY ~ o~wzod wO Esti b= H u z m z � z oN Xm=1 mm < o0, o 4 m v ab ?i N9 md J_ 3i �6 d � iao15 w <crs u a Z 2 1P i KININ Q , ^ wJ 4 i�7ii .zI -7 S ) w Vif, y~jQ of 3 S c 4 z �� Of �l < �� 03 PPOf m < N o mj z o<m how Wig. W Z La a.�0`z alwill.�ca W F ` �n��o -< ��� m� Sm > Q uoo yob<mle=mm b z m d � oa 5 Vii$ i za` 969Zr 4 93a v d Did 'v Hd3sor 1nOH11M 031VA0ION �Q1Q0 1.7 �y,����ys .T�n� 1Q �7 x1 11 QA'IG NVH30 N 8221 — i 10.1 IT 7 V7 T H 11 11 A 1T C717�.-JH ��TTS��L, TV{'ALTT S((���7 rr��111V1��T��1JT111TT//��Q1��CY�L �CTLT V{i�1T •Q0L4 S'II V WAU HON V NULL '0 ✓MIA V d 9998-4LZ PI :N. OOjg LZ l89 :2u04d 444££ 9 *ON •yooa8 .Hing 0 3 anaLL aIddoauid 96Z 9059 *ON NOLLVZI80H1nV !0 31tl01iLLa30 tl01a01d Z ¢ E: ate+ [a "^ a lull x O F� «7 F a z a In y z m E" w N ssxvs�nsxo� �vix� xoxinri� • sx��tsiox� s8 8poss U51s2Oo�i AUA / y \y// AB :SNOISIA3a '31V0 'ON o� LU �.wy °8 Y I CD LL. ® N LL. W04 v zlx p R r � !;I- c'r'y E S ®G w > ""� cl" -t= bg� d. o n V Ry �. W U o CD -1- 3SIRE? Z I- 3 =, Y m� ooa 8� ado z N$ o Ja3Ao0 NW1 o m� \�� ��j z¢-8 NIYI ,£ .9 I.,_ a.5 Z uw ¢ <oir N o MR J \ z W VVI psi 6 g aON43NNVH0 HLIy 531�VA N1d3Q /� H = YAR w;ar ¢ ?N� apo ymymyy$$ a m�vm Ha- > oC OS' % BZ f5' z z H n a z ¢ u LIA W z LO EL `gvz <ooa�S gn r �a �♦ I mach '�'I'��Ihlgr-:Xoxo 2MRLn Q<�zum.a p N � 6 a 64 a ��mo 00 Ln Baca W a .- z. a Egg o N 3 z8 m Rg, Y mz z O.. 6', U z m a I imu E]][ oW -i W. Q z<Zo. 00 g6F �U �"� F w< m V4�IZ<~ZWW N9Y =�0 �'' <� Y� m J FOm� NO g u Q yyif _ � ui Uiw< rnz UY ~ o~wzod wO Esti b= H u z m z � z oN Xm=1 mm < o0, o 4 m v ab ?i N9 md J_ 3i �6 d � iao15 w <crs u a Z 2 1P i KININ Q , ^ wJ 4 i�7ii .zI -7 S ) w Vif, y~jQ of 3 S c 4 z �� Of �l < �� 03 PPOf m < N o mj z o<m how Wig. W Z La a.�0`z alwill.�ca W F ` �n��o -< ��� m� Sm > Q uoo yob<mle=mm b z m d � oa 5 Vii$ i za` H ;, 11 ;1,-/'I/;I "`„F "I- erns VVAr\• "' ' -I �Y 1I 1•"f'' I 6 o I—p E 2 /—I W crJ W I o .-- Co O N N W 04 11 A O 00 W r3 _ T zaz Sgaz a< 3 aAVN)63NA.LHU0 J.sva do ,o0t sdl u 'g I I I I u� N[HZiY 01Zd HO STIM ON 1 g 7 anV 4M 3N t0 O I =' .w $ l Z N m J 1 OAV 4)13N a 4 I $ I= M <, MH e�apaj I ; I -T�.------------- / I I �A.a.z I I —--------------- \ « I ------- $ t \$ Ire r•9+ 99'9+ (OvVON lV 2l1) �011N3�i i 3 41- N N3NSv3 3avWHO Al l Wa+ 9c_9+— �----- 1 I $ I I 918 >. 1N3NSY 39Y amu° e I� L I I I I I$ I r— IIv� Ja m l \a I �_ v W p F W O LI -1 w > 1 1 1 +, m x o F J o II\ I+ Z. o I z I ^ 0w 0 o Z 0z i( Imr zc, zfn ais I 3f I I $ 1 I+ m 8 I w I I I I N 1 O R � nor.; a ~ I 19I*e I I I I o a z m R �w ['�"� m 0 O I Wa I I I I WICp 91 r------------ D I ?ryl I r r +sm W I I\ I n ❑❑ v + I m� 07L4�F N ` m �z I >i� I ' I F .0'Z W W� F�Q.� U a� II I I I ❑❑ !/� R ,j z Q. y( I pp< .Fm II I[II i xT a o I F Irl I �..' F ,ri 5 c /'1 I p, oa Kcr o xof�i. Z2 l m 0 I jlll I ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ }Q E u I ❑ El❑ and I _ I l YEMEN � 8i} 8+ ZO I X l I \ J. 1NN3N335YrvHeO S z s•c sc+ ON�. < I a3-- 0. s'4+ — Iri Y I I I I 09+ c'91 r'S+ O i m C I I g 0 \ o f I L-------------- - -ZZ'W I ! I /Ire+\� lou 30vd .yc NOOB 1Yld) 61'9+ o 611+ �%N3K3SY3 urmn div avoa 3ivnrod M a mw u I III � 5 p Na1v�J 6r �callooe end) 1N3ff3SV3 MVWHa m + I I ` le I N6R1'H I I 3NCI A.LHHdOHd J.SHM d0,OOI I I I NIHZIY OLLd3S HO STIHY ON J d� III I K{Wj fym I m° �` `,`�•� erg =MOi le =< ' I � III I ov II S3=bO<< )b, Y_ 9992r M 038 a '3'd '3NId 'Y Hd350f 9Y3S S,N33N19N3 1nOH11M OIIYA ION f7,�({.7r7�,TT ,Tr7 y QIQO 1�'1 N V 'aa Ls LL lnD GYM NVH00 N 8ZZT — T 101 SHIVISH MHIA ZIOUZIVH ��TT '�TT �T�.�rf T T.,Tr� T [� T T T !� •HOJ, NI lU Y'L \'1 LS kS DILTAHS 9559—ti1Z l9S .KOj 0059—i1Z 199 :9u011d bbb££ DpPmj •4...a (-,i-a ,(oM --j elddae N!d 86Z 9059 'ON NOLLYZINOH��IY 30 uVOLiLLH30 YONIOId Z ddW C E-; R'I Wq ^.4 �a SSI d dam' � d o [9 W p rnl �o p z w F p W M IL' SLNVLInSNOD IVINUxONiANZ • SUHRNION3 u&seenue Awn, u61sa OJIAu J 31se Oss�10 _ :AB :SNOISIA38 :31YO 'ON �Y 1I 1•"f'' I 6 o I—p E 2 /—I W crJ W I o .-- Co O N N W 04 11 A O 00 W r3 _ T zaz Sgaz a< 3 aAVN)63NA.LHU0 J.sva do ,o0t sdl u 'g I I I I u� N[HZiY 01Zd HO STIM ON 1 g 7 anV 4M 3N t0 O I =' .w $ l Z N m J 1 OAV 4)13N a 4 I $ I= M <, MH e�apaj I ; I -T�.------------- / I I �A.a.z I I —--------------- \ « I ------- $ t \$ Ire r•9+ 99'9+ (OvVON lV 2l1) �011N3�i i 3 41- N N3NSv3 3avWHO Al l Wa+ 9c_9+— �----- 1 I $ I I 918 >. 1N3NSY 39Y amu° e I� L I I I I I$ I r— IIv� Ja m l \a I �_ v W p F W O LI -1 w > 1 1 1 +, m x o F J o II\ I+ Z. o I z I ^ 0w 0 o Z 0z i( Imr zc, zfn ais I 3f I I $ 1 I+ m 8 I w I I I I N 1 O R � nor.; a ~ I 19I*e I I I I o a z m R �w ['�"� m 0 O I Wa I I I I WICp 91 r------------ D I ?ryl I r r +sm W I I\ I n ❑❑ v + I m� 07L4�F N ` m �z I >i� I ' I F .0'Z W W� F�Q.� U a� II I I I ❑❑ !/� R ,j z Q. y( I pp< .Fm II I[II i xT a o I F Irl I �..' F ,ri 5 c /'1 I p, oa Kcr o xof�i. Z2 l m 0 I jlll I ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ }Q E u I ❑ El❑ and I _ I l YEMEN � 8i} 8+ ZO I X l I \ J. 1NN3N335YrvHeO S z s•c sc+ ON�. < I a3-- 0. s'4+ — Iri Y I I I I 09+ c'91 r'S+ O i m C I I g 0 \ o f I L-------------- - -ZZ'W I ! I /Ire+\� lou 30vd .yc NOOB 1Yld) 61'9+ o 611+ �%N3K3SY3 urmn div avoa 3ivnrod M a mw u I III � 5 p Na1v�J 6r �callooe end) 1N3ff3SV3 MVWHa m + I I ` le I N6R1'H I I 3NCI A.LHHdOHd J.SHM d0,OOI I I I NIHZIY OLLd3S HO STIHY ON J d� III I K{Wj fym I m° �` `,`�•� erg =MOi le =< ' I � III I ov II S3=bO<< )b, Y_ ® L u! 9oZ 0 4-V 'Ntl c1M :6 C16Z/Sl/Ot '6MP'116-1OOH-6LOC1\JMO\Ma1A coq, -H ! Io-!-aouaprsaa ­!A-6LDCt\CtOZ\'C dg 9■9zt / o3Yilt' 3'd '3N1d 'Y Ni3S01' I1 ,r3S 5 C":S1�ZS� LION111A 0(TIA 1 �7 1T �f .T c y QIQO lu1 1'1L y ,�Q,LS �1 In ,,J QA'IR NVHD0 lei BZZT — T Z0I 1 -• MBIA 2i0g2i�H ��TT '�TT r� T r�/� TAT r,� �v T �+ r�T T r�[. 1,r`j - •QOa S 1��LLLLL /lv1�JAr7 ✓1WdLLJ 9559^1LZ 19S :j DJ D059-tLZ l9S :a�yd 4fi1Y opuoU •yaoag .(o�pD ADM ano�� a!ddDOu!d 96Z 9059 'aN NDLLYZI9DHiny !O 31tlOLiLL93J VD!907! E: q '^�' •'• W C x U "'• C F 6 0 q - F+ 0 o 1A o C r� -+ o z o E- IV WjJ d� Y�. a sixvsznsxo� �vsx� xoxinx� • sxa�xiax� �a1 SB 81003 �a I �� UBIS9 OJ AU3 �w p�uf,Fl, o '1B :SHOt " 31Y0 "ON dg m I I x �o 0 v�Q r � .0 G d� Y�. a o �w p�uf,Fl, <awrc FO'F z w 6:0 ?' PU I w�5 �zmuu d� alow = w aoG ogb q 6 zzpn81<a -N3ii R.6, 3V p. oa Z. 7d cFiF I aa?oo v� < S o <mo zap &< € m>Jwmm� o �9Wm 6�z m< "'.� ¢�w�0' cmioi<a 1_OZ< mjEa � <FJaa <a<= Y<� m. mis<Fam O s ?p WOW ii^08 Rma<3�i� <-Q{{i< <2 ,mwa'6F�Wp uo�awo� <mxu i�-M. I mo q- M O rcrcg �F a�ilim�s< < Wwm <w"m' ¢�-b 6�N� �i9 i7iry �� Wm U aU g<z Will <zw �g waz6Zix[g�-u <F Wa m 696 mwzF3a&$ ?M<< Wis Bo <w3 a6im R�F_w<W 8 F pZp!6zo� Ug<aW VI wm¢Z P�Z`J3F w1.1bF ��,5 b1JF = <20 �a < UVWa 2692 KKz b< 6U1w�mV c5;T < <U vl oZ� <�<7l hag mw�� ww55 iF i�OC x S � ' N Si fi U 3 01� Z r. al <j Z WW �iJ 'o mQ QQY IZFAZ rcY Cd<< 00 I &imZ Up s s n wa pWpqa us �^<�icoi , .�'z -m!SoSi x<xZ Y<o2 �i Qs i»�"� Mm mz mZmZ>1a1 ~mVoVl Q 01W m Z1Oj1_111zw < _ w�F� FOO�SaVi� f�¢�¢i ;W <3 �O? ziSFo 2 �m �UZ OZjLLU <V mpi �S10tOO 01 01 1__'NIW sz 2=F pTQx 2�5 J 5S�==1-xxw aa <dd �x SN <ZUUO poopO,, �LLh<w Q1/�WJmKI OW !yN! O ^ FI<4 V1U m ^ Fam.i. N N N N Z W Z cm R� F <w- �z�a oow� v<� arch g o� m a<. <mg we w < _m vi � z w` rc vi a� i a ww � o uj C� iio ¢W<ZoZrc mpa <w wF <�Zzm1<Jw m Ww a'�iai s" NZZZZOp 1,0�x �6x wYo�2 �N wl¢¢-O W1ZF WEE C -i t)Z F15, LLZ¢9F< ad, U IIpI�Ww 33ibU V O 3 W�Z j1<-1 ZU m(O'J ZZyWj &JO•U� r. < m S j M6WZ m w< oF_b66`8' osg U j w RL -O O N Z oo< K~ am (��5'N d j vm 0Fm q 6 mgou<i ffipp . aSV < o JW FJ <m m acro yl< ,aF mwS qs�m O ! m V ^� § d"$a 2w O-_< m mI- M �f m y-� <� V., moZwk�¢�� q �^ z z wm� OZio<w z 5 s =00. = ZZ V Nzpp1.biw8W Zm R = ^W< OF i umsmo�w 60 ipp7,i St OFF zOO ZpC �F �wOOw FdOW2 NjZ<w Z' ZZgw1i W O o. Z¢ Z Nw W 7 '� V1=w yJ6�UU" O W F > S h fUt ��adW O °� W m 0.ai o mzoFA15 md< mho biz UZ i��"€<O mz� WR <Um JFb mF a mmip cU S< m FF <Z `WZ J ?fmb'a OoVV1n 1¢<�1gw�F SOF 1<�iH biz m=Z<Figo�� o 42 JioUvoo Vi¢vi�u�1 �F- p§pjF0 zoo <1w�'tior_' 1`aW�o ZY�Y111Zpm7�z� ¢� t¢F0.12U CKOFj�V <OWOT� ¢Ub �a3 UFo ¢e o< OJOJF �i Ow�� ¢V¢ F»d�O ¢U¢=F?<K I-Fb��VI tY U2 FwN W<l�<Q aWW FQ< 1..0 ZOU�Ua =6 "E-9 Za pw F¢ aO ZW o om'I''6o U 3 K i U ox�zoi �Xo U W a< Z 7 U N n ��� o�'�' a b a—, x " H b h ad Fi < i�8fa m <. wu<iuxi?alii _ dg I a� I I 0 z U d� 1212 �s a d� �iE.x F I i`oo£z Zl-9 HR Of ?< 92 O z Nay o¢� q a O W3 EH W z w z a =1 S x S � ' N Si fi E"'1 U 9 1 l Up s s n a E- m F�q�zm m= w F w mo�M�bU < ams+ o< ?<� x?�M'ozzz I a rcN i. iEFz aQR�zOomg,13 l. Qti < D k1 m z 08 N 1<i0 O W oLLF w a_ °✓' ". m 3<10 w�z< W1��c> aQ a0ix ��m rci0 H m i o �aoo�m " z Mm W °�� < W (Wj Z < �� _ $ Sm �iS 3WQwai�ot'i Z� O� emsk� Z � < N = F m0 4 m O =� D� U Z O .< < U U W W J w C7 wV B F ?vi i w pb �i �'< < m �z wz�o W >: W F Z W O v< Z m<1<-<jNW?Z mmY• YO] �N iF0 .6ZOQ F F J< w o1•�c<iR"� ui �z< vlcz a`F-'uw H X50 O KKm = W?NmUWUN� F pm Rc1 ZU m_w w < br-`im Y Nw WIJ OZzp �=2m ¢¢ {4� � m,� <QV 171 VZpI ,a< DW m m 02 WZ m1j\-�W�ZI<i N KX Oyy;�� <U Uo tK a g� u>U Z = 3zo Qzoi Vaso z �J<1- MUMS CL a< m g z ]mowwFlmlo< xz zo g FS32 mw w W c.11^ 1n< mY w < rc a�zNmmIM N 9� <R i 'a u w $ Zi6rca<myo ane �4 �.2 v��o > �o Io J m- m xzz °13 =rFG Zo UmmJ60w w< <Kv oao ` Uo=� F NF� o� \�1Z ��#Jawz. U� Wa1N 1.C�x<t xW U WQ IJ .. �m 1z z zz = U 1�a <W l}SUV a1O�W31A Z1<JJ UK gW �mOn U <WF OF <>m� Z <K Zy1 UVl VF U IA R� K� pyFbjZ .Z<WWK< UZ `USW W 8J� WszW < 6z wWY `Fa yaWh yaWo yaJ J oi� t� iw�6 o�$aw � g venni? I W U< N m3 Na NJ In < <x <x wmawwl-w a1.m aU x <1na �F1nm <.�iz W yJ a x� z m�NSziE M, W LL J W W ob$ p iiiaa�V1 mZ wz. w� i�a�am Mzma"< ��IV_ Iz. sJ N�icw4 iWi_-O ooiym< <�oxm < z < �eo�$ W. M? z�mzF z}aaw a F Di. < z .6 0 vj 0 9q ■ ^ H b!y■ m Wr7 arW jig mme �Yi: o o o gQa W = (n < s om � f t ■ C U Z r W �7i9 2 �gin"tl a$g r�T7, H FTy z m ! `v a • • 4€ = C6 ov ca 0 z U 1212 �s m F�q�zm m= w F w mo�M�bU < ams+ o< ?<� x?�M'ozzz I a rcN i. iEFz aQR�zOomg,13 l. Qti < D k1 m z 08 N 1<i0 O W oLLF w a_ °✓' ". m 3<10 w�z< W1��c> aQ a0ix ��m rci0 H m i o �aoo�m " z Mm W °�� < W (Wj Z < �� _ $ Sm �iS 3WQwai�ot'i Z� O� emsk� Z � < N = F m0 4 m O =� D� U Z O .< < U U W W J w C7 wV B F ?vi i w pb �i �'< < m �z wz�o W >: W F Z W O v< Z m<1<-<jNW?Z mmY• YO] �N iF0 .6ZOQ F F J< w o1•�c<iR"� ui �z< vlcz a`F-'uw H X50 O KKm = W?NmUWUN� F pm Rc1 ZU m_w w < br-`im Y Nw WIJ OZzp �=2m ¢¢ {4� � m,� <QV 171 VZpI ,a< DW m m 02 WZ m1j\-�W�ZI<i N KX Oyy;�� <U Uo tK a g� u>U Z = 3zo Qzoi Vaso z �J<1- MUMS CL a< m g z ]mowwFlmlo< xz zo g FS32 mw w W c.11^ 1n< mY w < rc a�zNmmIM N 9� <R i 'a u w $ Zi6rca<myo ane �4 �.2 v��o > �o Io J m- m xzz °13 =rFG Zo UmmJ60w w< <Kv oao ` Uo=� F NF� o� \�1Z ��#Jawz. U� Wa1N 1.C�x<t xW U WQ IJ .. �m 1z z zz = U 1�a <W l}SUV a1O�W31A Z1<JJ UK gW �mOn U <WF OF <>m� Z <K Zy1 UVl VF U IA R� K� pyFbjZ .Z<WWK< UZ `USW W 8J� WszW < 6z wWY `Fa yaWh yaWo yaJ J oi� t� iw�6 o�$aw � g venni? I W U< N m3 Na NJ In < <x <x wmawwl-w a1.m aU x <1na �F1nm <.�iz W yJ a x� z m�NSziE M, W LL J W W ob$ p iiiaa�V1 mZ wz. w� i�a�am Mzma"< ��IV_ Iz. sJ N�icw4 iWi_-O ooiym< <�oxm < z < �eo�$ W. M? z�mzF z}aaw a F Di. < z .6 0 vj 0 9q ■ ^ H b!y■ m Wr7 arW jig mme �Yi: o o o gQa W = (n < s om � f t ■ C U Z r W �7i9 2 �gin"tl a$g r�T7, H FTy z m ! `v a • • 4€ = C6 ov L) �s a d� Icy n d Zl-9 o� q a O W3 W z w z a c z U o a E- 01 01 1__'NIW R'1 n ��q q e 1 0 7 /\ a a os+ 7: rt���� n a i i q cx+ +r' t ca NY3�� O/1NY71 Y i Q ��o c " N 2ti TTm lo i`�� U. 3W ��0: akzzll b1'  10-,)) 7Y15YY{7 ����; NR 0 J A0 m HE Uj m Z Za: x q ROLwaas In U NY370 Yiffinaw Q tam "2 awJZ[YIS o amvd ��' (OYCY 31YAW Y) ��a L(��Y3 ,V 1��Y��LL uoav3a WV+ MLOA815 _ i uj V/ Cr.) 3MILt��D Sl1./3/MipFLy ��a LULI a a os+ 7: rt���� n a i i q cx+ +r' t ca NY3�� O/1NY71 Y i Q ��o c " N 2ti TTm lo i`�� U. 3W ��0: akzzll b1'  10-,)) 7Y15YY{7 ����; NR 0 J A0 m HE Uj m Z Za: x q ROLwaas In U NY370 Yiffinaw Q tam "2 awJZ[YIS o F,pV 'IYb 6,'g7:15 -L',-/11/.,1 -1-r `N= 6/1W.\`YAC\—.• n,..,: i . lo- «i94 LU o Yfio ® N u. Q UJr-1 CQ <€ CD UJ co Lu U ®gm= i w � V a „ bes F f €3.b 9 �b 4Os� r b or1 O1 O z Q S ai9 s N w O o O y tom' Qd' g ghJl`N`= o`er z 04 J I SaUP aQm w aiicL65 ¢ 03 =rq 0 3t o Ic O N o F rc F- I z C. .X -.X <I-' j y�i3 F O o '� w VIp - Wm�f ¢ y \@� U CN a z zg$s Y r \ '�� S x In o W \ Z— .5 z z \ O g � \ w J \ J O i, a— N m y m N w m � a 3 t6 oS.V Y g s iK= U w K 2, q. u w" N _ vg N R Ho.g H J � ft g g ^' " IN, kra<' 61dim., iF nn = 8 „R- li U) �s» R 1212 F- FBI F�aw� o a _ c4 Ho— ww E- 4, i N� a g 1u 2 pim a I - z V�� �4z a o I ❑ ❑ 9h5RI!j Igo ��� � g� �� �H q9g 414 A - N H ♦ d a n d d E N I � � ! I � ' II11 I I V I cn ~ E ❑ ❑ ❑ P4 U- w�ql� I p< U E] 0 11 w w E w z ;4z a < <�a ago o; Z e orcoma J �\ E f•Tl is a SG`p NORTH ' t 3� mM. �\ I 969ZY / 734 v '3'd 'Did 'r Hd35Of IVIS S,833NION3 1NOHIIM OfIYA ION V 111 �7 Yr �L �7 V LL1Qo id `WvazuS iflo GYM NVHDO N BZZT — I WrI SElI1�ZSH MBIA 2IOg2IF�H SATO .T �TtlR T TOT T �Tnn�AT T TOT T nrfrfo T Q �R N Y 1CL N UNH Ud N IL 11 Q 9999 -VIZ V"u (195 :xo.1 OOSi Id l95 :auo4d bbb££ -PP-1A 'y.oag doIlad O anal a�ddo18O1 86Z 9059 'oN NOLLVZINOHLfItl !0 3Ltl011LLtl30 tlOINOIj Z .; C F O a ¢ U "'+ � o E . d Ll "'� �y z o � z p3 o O 2 o W w o w in 5 UI SINn,CIfISNOD 'Id,LN2WN02IIANa - SUUNIDNa IIeI+anA�a,� ¢�/^-���[[ \\ . saleloossy u6lsaQo�lnu�l��J ////// U6 :SNOISIA38 31Y0 'ON «i94 LU o Yfio ® N u. Q UJr-1 CQ <€ CD UJ co Lu U ®gm= i w � V a „ bes F f €3.b 9 �b 4Os� r b or1 O1 O z Q S ai9 s N w O o O y tom' Qd' g ghJl`N`= o`er z 04 J I SaUP aQm w aiicL65 ¢ 03 =rq 0 3t o Ic O N o F rc F- I z C. .X -.X <I-' j y�i3 F O o '� w VIp - Wm�f ¢ y \@� U CN a z zg$s Y r \ '�� S x In o W \ Z— .5 z z \ O g � \ w J \ J O i, a— N m y m N w m � a 3 t6 oS.V Y g s iK= U w K 2, q. u w" N _ vg N R Ho.g H J � ft g g ^' " IN, kra<' 61dim., iF nn = 8 „R- li U) �s» R 1212 F- FBI F�aw� o a _ c4 Ho— ww E- 4, i N� a g 1u 2 pim a I - z V�� �4z a o I ❑ ❑ 9h5RI!j Igo ��� � g� �� �H q9g 414 A - N H ♦ d a n d d E N I � � ! I � ' II11 I I V I cn ~ E ❑ ❑ ❑ P4 U- w�ql� I p< U E] 0 11 w w E w z ;4z a < <�a ago o; Z e orcoma J �\ E f•Tl is a SG`p NORTH ' t 3� mM. �\ I WI%L LL Ri.SERVLD. ra, -W i mLu q_Aris. DLsirta. rip i - l -1-1 1. I'll, 1-1- 1-11.1-11 1 11 1., 1--l... I....._ I - - 0 �a N M .5 w 0:� E� G) M 0 X 0 _u M 0 M x < ;u > x C) M r- - M �a 00 F: z rn > < c 0 0 z M A G)0 C -n 0 _u 0 0 0 0 X:� 0 a: M r- > M Z M M z M G) (Z 0 M M 0 c) 0 z c/) -n G) c/) M X c 0 w --1 M < -0 M x 0 =00M> __4 M M w =! M 0 --1 22 0 M 0 x > > zz>ozm> > I— z - > w M cf) C) 0 z , z > --i G) 0 D 0 00zw * M M M M r III M 1-1 . . > M 0 0 cn 0 0 z 7 Crl < Cy) -n - I F z M M , � M 0 0 rQ M M < > 0 0 ;u yh 41 cn (n �u -n 0 0 M W K) M 0 W 0 0 Z z > ig�l *7 W 0 Lo M "1 0 z 0 a, ;Q - Z, c - z 0 V Co M M!� Z� 0 0c) M cf) C/) -0 0 M 0 X LO cn --i z M < 0- T (1) 0 ;u --I M CO c :� 0 M M z -0 M ;u -n > 0 'M M> 0 M --A 0 > 03 ct) i U) O OD C-) > 2 Cad ;l 0 0 z > X - 0 o n -n M I- M > 0 M -n 0 7u _u M cn z mcncn T cn cn a: M :Z! 0 -4 C-) U) M 0 M M > -A z M C) -0 cl) " M z _j ;u M mmol :E > 0 E/) 0 M P w M r M 0 z 4 r-zr-, ;0 0 c) 0 0 M < M > 0 > 'u 0 M M 5 air, at ICE a > > > 55 X r- 0 0 00 0z>0 J C -i () G) U-) 4 >< c) _< C/) 0 0 0 M 0 U) 5 M -0 0 z cr) Co -< cn cd --A M z Cy) z M > M M > < M Cri 0 M cn U) x M 0z MM>0 -n 0 z z cn > I— Z > z -0 M M < M -4 --1 M M KK > -u > 0 < 1 1 04; _�_O i llrj 4 (y) 2: z > U) cn Cn M M -A Z MI G) M c: --I M M U) > --I Z> > MD (b r�, X -n M C-) cn :zi M W I M M > C > 0 -n 0 > Z C) z 0- z I cn M M I z > i cn , 0) -�l c- (1) COO M 0 C) -n (,) 11 T. r- 0 --I > z cn _J_ AZA C-) M M cy) 4�1 cn c: C, 0 __4 c? 6 M > z MM > L mo O�M�K�0. 92 111-10 IQ -C) .0 -.0 0�0 �o >,q N2 -I t� �_; 8 - , � 0_. Sze _. 5; �� % � _9 �q �s Nq 9 R s -,R 'R 0 C.) mmffi'N mw 0� I K o 1, 0 0 - '0 2 M z 0 I Pl �l o. o❑ v I m in F F km m, 7 Fl I ��2 o' 6' moov m, w P it 9 . in n ffi o m I Ri mo I m� z xm >- om x moc F z z" 0 o 10 P z. 0, z� . Az j >z z .o mm §, IAn f " ,$°2° 0 A -j M M -p 81 .1 s o -mo z, m-103- 0 -m .0 NH -0 p � o* rnom oz 'z z 0 K z 1" -Zi z Imm z�z I > o. >, zo 0z 02 �� z "o ­,x=ioo _,Jn 0-m g I J z m> zI •m _n> mz. 1 -,o > F > I 'mo ­ aipw n ommm 'm m C-) r- r, 0 (0 0 F -z �5oO -5-1 > 01 A> 0 -, z. c<, z 0, Q, 2 > m, Al > > G o m -'I > F '. F, -m >, 2 .0 �> C', Ozo T >om z z > > �o 1 02 OR m� SO mc 20 20 20 Q .0 Cm, mw mo Ox m.2.1 x nc) > OD M CTI Z 0) 0 > M M >. z poo m >< I, z,x 0 x m 0 1 0 0 x 'T 0I -. �, , 9 E > 0, 1 o -m 0. K zqo. zz, OF" 1, z t, - > 'T I z >1 o zo om >, mo o nm 0� w >, , 1, 1 a A :9 0 s mom- 0- P F' 0, 1> T. C, P 0 1. > I �, , P > 'o 2 '0 0< , I, , 9 1 Z c M r\.) z M -i > z Z z> >- Uzi 8 m - I '.-I ­- -o m -2 1-Im. -8,0 1, z' z, Am mo E P. , 1 T � A z I ox zc2m I z> 'm > m � , , I zo �Io o E o 01 E. �oz P 9 I I z." '�- > Ul 0 0 cn 0 �r > C/) G) o M, Ax -, I >,Azio I I ng> �z .1 .!z2 =>i in 2 g �<O, 0, �>. F zO Im 0 U, I > Aa > 0 v 1 0 Tm 4'; 2 0, 2 o" >' o > G)Izo > ,m -omz'.I �z :Em m z , 9 mm mw x m c, >z mx P T mm , UI M -n < 0 Lrl 00 111 Li Z z mE5 go 7� K0 x� 0 > 1 0 0 z z9 > �, 62 > I P. r P 2 - z.. �l �' c� > o o' K I -m I �w I o > m, m" oz P > > oz --j > 'm -I " .0 z z >1 w P� om m� n I > m, "o 0. z. -z 'o z. n I > ATO o om zM oz cm: m 0 1 wc Cin ow < 'm A R J, M.- > om m�­� �z 0 m z zm 'm o T -P x �i 0 5 0 0 OTOT 0, o n om 'o x > 3 z� G) c') > 6) w c: s; �l j - > . - - �, o.- 0, lz -P, o Q O� 20 om�� 'm 0 x 2 4 I, I > S­� 5 - :,i q . mA I po in - z o mm � M >� 0 5 (m) z < > 6 z mz Iz <0 w, o' o' z :E > I �O . =i z 0 1��oo z w oz xzm 0 nm c m Lrl M M ■M >' �z > 0 > 24 > 2 Ax x �m , O- g I, . z Cz P 0� z z 0->- =i o '0 2T . > >- 0 mz o. > 0 m o m o o P zm n 'm z z o -v > >' M p .1 P 0 ml Im w m .02 Z 0 cn 0 M P �m <g >m >��>� o -m 1. .1 T -o I �l .1 > 7 R Q 0 1 1 �� p - -m 1 8, m,-> > 0 :s , I - - 0 P . '. <.2 > , �E 0 z, �0 z. -1 -,1, �< .0. > 'm 1 -0 M Z 0 5� ;� _0 oz o'. o� o 0 11 To zi m- om a' z 1 z oz:� o cK >- 5 < I g V oz 1, r z I > z, z w " .1 oz , Tm > >z > - -'m -0 z r. 'm t 0 m m -> > mo om �w mm z wm � < �7 �o o m1 m >a�m4w mffi q O:OE i P mm 2, wz Q mz I, > , m- >,❑ 0 Rj I I g F G 2 o m �M m. 2A2❑ -m P 1. Im 1. > o� $> > m. >z 5: m 8"- Lz, A 0. z 'o > p 01 �15 > �K I'm > 8 c . . . I I . �z P wx - z - I A . v m. z. ol- ol 2 TO 0 0 �n . C, . 6, p I zo >1 2 p zmz m ..0 om �z m� mo >� no z on 0) (D > < z � - -;5 - m 1 5�- �0 . z > Mm m K � � >, � >o � _-jz, �z > .o �z > IT >1 �- zV vi I o 1, z =j K � 0z wo 0 cz) �' FF z =1 0 > I 'm 5'i o. �m z. z I 2 In I z m > m o IT . > I < > < c) z z o� z I Tm z �l C) 1) 1. 2 1z) 0 E� >�zp z 0 Z M 0 A � � c- 22 x z I -z >, oz �� zo oo m, 'ws 0, 0 Om zo 2 cm, o > I> >I, 2- 1 1. .1 . o > :E > . 1. >q - -z .,. � 0 .>2 o. -> zo z> p T x, > 2 0z A> oz 'o >z oc a' >, 2. T , I 'm On x� m 0 A 'n om n g n o �fi . z> o> mm 0- o� 0, 2 .0 x 9 0 0 �a 0 M > -n P 0 M --1 0 D -z o 2 > cl I I �z F .01 , I , I o 0 mo 'n 0 >, mz >, Oz 2 P G., s 0 A g 0 z I > go 6 7 Ho .1 -1 go" o < " .1 - 5,0, >m , - o mz 0, M cn M M > > �l 85 o % 0 > ',z- z > 0 z �l . 0 K> MA .0 z o 1 A 0 o on 0 CTI 0 C-) 0 0? z z o >­' o�> z T, I > z -m E5 z- m- 8 zo 0 ffi o> 0- o M': > 'o 'm 1 0 o z z o > . . �l I A m , , Z, , , I 'm - F 'o I I 0 o,2 n o 0 �o so z R m I I _- qmomm M o *m z. .0 1 1 10 .1 =1 1 M) M) 110.0.1 M M Cl > �O Z - > M c() > m, F:E -z w III iTi T, z >0 -,:E:E Mm -m o i 0 M�OF 1 0 6 1 2 n< P F� �m zz Q =j' 0 G1 I , m< z q Or'o 00 K 0. >z m>� Q n z oz -z -m .0 .1 K I =i 0-'. P cn In < U) cl) 0 z -0, 1 - m 1 0 of. m, z m . > .1 m .1 6,9 m H �0 A zz) M C/) C-) C)c) 00 > > M cy) (b 0 < 0 > m- >T 'o . 'm F w. z4 mm wo m-7 �x xm z �l om czi m. A o> 0 z �0 nm za 2 v 8. w cm >� 2 0, > > P z mc mmm Ml T m n w, a 8 r I 0 Im w 0 m, 0 IT mm G) M 0 M > o :4 o 0 1 K EO. DO 01 z, I 'T 0. Im m >1 -0 'D oo 'm I, z> 5; m, :j , 0 m p 1. '. (�) W M C31 cz In M o z o I 0 z m. 'm z z 0 > �l > z z z I z. mz 90 mm o 0. 6' K .,z I I I m m,p (7� 2 z . Z o o 5i m- ,z �l I > < G) 0 F c I Q) > > 0 1nD I .0 - -K M __j M I E Q z z K 0 z❑ z . o v .. > z I o z >. z o 0, A Q o 'm > '�z 0 aim o rum 0- > T T F0 1 - -I!in - - u , 0 F '0 O q! T q 8 6 �z '0 >* v 0z 0z T �O �' z �z m, <m F, o > > . T I m� 5, > o 0, > a 0z 6 CAO " z 1 0 S? '62 zlv 0 o I =1 y OZ > z� z 0 om > z <Tm M lz El .:< o 0 G) o _j > 6 jjjm . mT 6 c) I 0� > z K�-, g D?l g;� 'm C�) K > it I I I m x I z 6 z6 0 ij I I z p >1 iz 2 M M cl) z I, P �02❑ oI o o. z 1 -�o o - Q? I - 0 :< o� . �; o E az 0 0� A❑ o 0 > q Im 8 'T z T� To F, 0z > >, 0 > n z 0. a^kE5 0 C] ml 0 .4 0. i ab '=7_t 0 U) W' OWl > M T 0 oz 0 > .1 z v o 0 Im z 1 0 z i. z- z 1. A 01 z z 'm P10 0 t-: z z -n 7 !-+o ...... . ..... t.x M o R7 3> O -4 Z > > 0 7. E;: M �2. > C -a > HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I 1221hL OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM F 10 , r1l. § ILI rn ?� z > SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104 m DELRAY M. BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 O N19, S AIDC H x -r _u, C -r u LL Ri.SERVLD. ra, -W i mLu q_Aris. DLsirta. rip i - l -1-1 1. I'll, 1-1- 1-11.1-11 1 11 1., 1--l... I....._ I - - 0 0 N O W O A 0 0 cn n N O -------;--------------------- I � I ` I � • CRAB �, GRAKWLE EASEEI+IFFNf I -------------- EA INAL-.E EA�EA%E I� - - - - TRACT ••A•• ------_ G ® _----------j----(A PRIVATE ROAD) PAVED r 0 H I I n uM i L 0 T 6 L] MI co I I , Mig N Z £ HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I > Z = . N. 1228 NOCEAN BLVDGULF STREAM I.L. y - _ > <C,> 1 Y 5 5 S _ SEASIDE BUILDS q� 185 NE 4TH AVENUE 104 x - - - _x DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 = - 1=ZI O S _A'_ H I T .E C T U --P,]F, 00 0 I I I I I I I I I I I I O I D x I � I � � m �Ti I d: t;gbmd:bbinA�bL,'b O 00 OOy`^O O I I bion — ¢, "'�' O �xxxxxxxxxo N 0666161 0 oabl o m G')_ m �^ m C-" O cn _ 661b6661 O 0.1 (t3il wDppZNDz - X300 ROME -� �. Dpp O p Z-1ZZi O O KtitiKKK 0 Oi y KZ O O � m3 Zi iZ 2Z 02 22 O K 3 C 4100 3 K a C Ll 6100000 3 9 C l7 3 K C C 3 ly yy C G[]G1 3 C ONL]G1 S C 3� C G) C � C ;;; l C y s ygy C K ,�yy �J Nrn.s.�Ntsil.Nl5i1F/l�tsi.I r I....... >S ➢ r O NN NNN NN NN N NNN (Nil O O Pd M 33 K ry 3K3��N3�3ii�� ry rye r7� � �� r�-ry �� �; 33 r ; cn m /C/I/� m W y A yy A A\`G O o O m lid m'O ' mwn 3 p0 D N r'I r<�m iF1r 30 3 m cl �y Il,..,' h7 g�>mm A� v N N m0 < N o m D <o o O 3 Z O 0 a 00 0 I I I I I I I I I o I p I I a E I I I I I I O i I I i l I I I I I I I I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I 0 gg 0 I I False Balcony I O 0 I I I ------- L I I I I I I O I I � I � � m �Ti I I O 00 OOy`^O O I I IF -------, r--------- -------- I I o I p I I a E I I I I I I O i I I i l I I I I I I I I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I 0 gg 0 I I False Balcony I O 0 I I I ------- L I foo 0 00 AM IR m, 00 0o II It■■� 0 w k8 ---------- ----- --------I I II II I II I NO O _4* G Z 3�" No v "n mJ HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I r Z C/2r ` ' "r 1228 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULP STREAM I L.. T ■ ■ yby -> _ F� Z z ~ SEASIDE BUILDERS o O d = = {!ss ? 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 `' z r DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ^ $ m I�IC HAlZD � O NQS Al�C H I T EC T Ul�.E CUPYR/GHT 2L'I7 BY RICHARD JUNES ARCH! rEC'TURL- PXORPURATED ALL RTU.4TS ALL RESERVED. HU PART TIF rF — 1-1 ntcri 1 nR inirneun rine un v — ----- --- CD I I O I I ¢, O G')_ C-" O cn CD � O 03 "' 0 -� �. foo 0 00 AM IR m, 00 0o II It■■� 0 w k8 ----- --------I I II II I II I NO O _4* G Z 3�" No v "n mJ HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I r Z C/2r ` ' "r 1228 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULP STREAM I L.. T ■ ■ yby -> _ F� Z z ~ SEASIDE BUILDERS o O d = = {!ss ? 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 `' z r DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ^ $ m I�IC HAlZD � O NQS Al�C H I T EC T Ul�.E CUPYR/GHT 2L'I7 BY RICHARD JUNES ARCH! rEC'TURL- PXORPURATED ALL RTU.4TS ALL RESERVED. HU PART TIF rF — 1-1 ntcri 1 nR inirneun rine un v — ----- --- NO O _4* G Z 3�" No v "n mJ HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I r Z C/2r ` ' "r 1228 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULP STREAM I L.. T ■ ■ yby -> _ F� Z z ~ SEASIDE BUILDERS o O d = = {!ss ? 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 `' z r DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ^ $ m I�IC HAlZD � O NQS Al�C H I T EC T Ul�.E CUPYR/GHT 2L'I7 BY RICHARD JUNES ARCH! rEC'TURL- PXORPURATED ALL RTU.4TS ALL RESERVED. HU PART TIF rF — 1-1 ntcri 1 nR inirneun rine un v — ----- --- HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I r Z C/2r ` ' "r 1228 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULP STREAM I L.. T ■ ■ yby -> _ F� Z z ~ SEASIDE BUILDERS o O d = = {!ss ? 185 NE 4TH AVENUE #104 `' z r DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ^ $ m I�IC HAlZD � O NQS Al�C H I T EC T Ul�.E CUPYR/GHT 2L'I7 BY RICHARD JUNES ARCH! rEC'TURL- PXORPURATED ALL RTU.4TS ALL RESERVED. HU PART TIF rF — 1-1 ntcri 1 nR inirneun rine un v — ----- --- --------------- --- ------ I I I , I I I I I I I ,I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � � I I I I I I I � I --------------- I I tib as I I I I I - I I I I I I I I I I ----------------- � � I I I I R� , r � , I I I I I kvGE I I I I I I a I I I I I L JI , I I I I I I I Ile I I- - ----------F I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I A I srFn I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O I I I I O I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ,yA as I I I I I I I o n rn =., c n as ti� 47 '� o m b r m -v 7v -- ---- too n m CAD my c° o ca Ca cop) m o x HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I N. OCEAN BLVD. GULP STREAM PL. = ^ N m � �"=s n z ■ ■ - r N D �� 16.aSEASIDE c o BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104 „> = z ■ . - - DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA33483 = w -� xis m 1Z1 C H A 1�D �T O N S A l�C H I T E C T U 1ZE i -o EASE FEleff F., m r If I y A � f� V1 1 n J 1 SAVE O 3 Ire v>= rEibrlr 00 - IFEW EAVES 115511T #I -.yy 1.... _..I rTl FAV D F z D Sx ' O' E N — t7i A F1 a A �' O • � 1 -- �, C=)7 op C) C-.)�o m o SAVE rE brTr #1oo II 1Q! it . . m a" �';00 a� zf µ' p t , 4.50 * o 0 Ro �-� m CA' if w (n IM OC D^ _ y HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT 1 5 M z c. _ _ - _ n y r � C > �y v _ 1228 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM I'I_. x z ■ ■ z a n SEASIDE BUILDERS a 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104_ Y ■ z DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ti l�IC HADD O N� S ASC H I T EC T UI-�E V Vj Y z V i -o EASE FEleff F., m r If I y A � f� V1 1 n J 1 SAVE O 3 Ire v>= rEibrlr 00 - IFEW EAVES 115511T #I -.yy 1.... _..I rTl FAV D F z D Sx ' O' E N — t7i A F1 a A �' O • � 1 -- �, C=)7 op C) C-.)�o m o SAVE rE brTr #1oo II 1Q! it . . m a" �';00 a� zf µ' p t , 4.50 * o 0 Ro �-� m CA' if w (n IM OC D^ _ y HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT 1 5 M z c. _ _ - _ n y r � C > �y v _ 1228 N. OCEAN BLVD. GULF STREAM I'I_. x z ■ ■ z a n SEASIDE BUILDERS a 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104_ Y ■ z DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 ti l�IC HADD O N� S ASC H I T EC T UI-�E 0 00 ri 0 m o A a 00 u 0 a r-+ s e �—, m m z C co J m 3>0 CS r w co) m ^i A � O Z KI-1-1-11 -1...... . gD i f HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I > z m x p 1228 N.00EANB LVD. GULF S'IRGAM Fl... m Y_ z■■y G Z N co r O� SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104 - p w p 7 n N yy V N 0 00 ri 0 m o A a 00 u 0 a r-+ s e �—, m m z C co J m 3>0 CS r w co) m ^i c z gD i f HARBOUR VIEW ESTATES -LOT I > z m x p 1228 N.00EANB LVD. GULF S'IRGAM Fl... m Y_ z■■y G Z N co r S -� m p s P 0 SEASIDE BUILDERS 185 NE 4TH AVENUE # 104 - p w DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33483 7 n N 1ZIC HADD O NE S ASC H I T EC T U1ZE 8 k 3Dc $ o m$ r 41� ir Q 6 o- �o C s A x a iso a' So ®g 2 �A OP cup mG up an a°, sP Sm p6 OG OAR aA °� si '�'-_6 as 1d b� 0 A r— wyupw v NwN gg�-ry aeap-� Frl Fri x Z YD V DDD DAD '-°DDD '°A An p3 u O z �s$oa?��se�sNe"s_eeoo$"s_ oo�ssos`_$ m xxxxAxG,x xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxkcx! xx ads"s_o"_----$ sss�� m°asa°s$s 1:F0 P gPOO;PGT6��;S0�� ()fl w�O °.�Pmro PH OW:z nn nnnnnnnnAnnnnnnnnnnnn nnnnn nnn z zz3zzYz'z zz32zzz3zzzzzY3 z223zzzzz C) �ry C) � o c —« cit co—" N C tC d M ty �t A N >>>>>> ao a anrt inn � rr N n < 0 " C rt W N � U o AO nn nnnnnnnnAnnnnnnnnnnnn nnnnn nnn z zz3zzYz'z zz32zzz3zzzzzY3 z223zzzzz C) �ry C) � o c —« cit co—" N C tC d M ty �t A N Ill O N C) n � � E—' N < CD c= w v 0 O�z I 0� � DDDDDD °"a ,nn nnrt inn 0 N � n n rt n " 0 o 3, n r s 0 6 W m v °'p C-) m Co 3° o w CO) co co 0 n [c-- F+ r N C _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ rA5-T0 s MOM I I 9- m Q Cf) I m Q O D ' CD aUa inn r h-� rn 2 o co .� O)o m C'7 Hart CD :3 C= w rril n c C': e m Q Cf) I m Q O D ' DDDDDD aUa inn r 2 o O O)o m C'7 Hart M Z „ n c C': e � W 7 y �i 0 X�� 0 urk i r -�-� O O)o m C'7 1C' M Z I.— n c C': � W m y i RR'YS�:f�a i� �,➢ g� �"C'C�eaGG &� o_Sgg" ypg$➢_ � :dsCB § iYRA @-�$s�'$R I S� W 63 p nrn.Rv _ fgBS�g�si $% 9 y�° ag,� a dyes } 11iMs?s di Ilk ti 6 KE W Sfi Ci $ gIJg S,24 e$S �s$rijvK:�gF 8� F€ g cR66 Id6�C 9pE } 9 e "6MYaIii ..... �MN }•9$° "q� 6�•4 4 a,7 nngn_nnnnn F o arP A4��d :- S DG �4F •P PP!P!!!P! p � �i P 4_ Win g N Uk-.E 6 i$ 12 i aya Qee���%Qg :8 'k-1 a} 1 ar w W F, n arc �n $° g N, i 14 AgS �4 f'8 � $ 1, fit �•rti�fi �R n F •* y ym P n y ;9 gl $ yc� Rife Eitig jj 9D amA 5 �C i$ finz ; ¢g ego,! j it R g�� $" 4 ���6a � ��g$f a��ix�2� aalaf a ;s �a egg a of l ka`a., wi �f p_ g §a ? y$ i. ggat 6$191- MIRj; jJ2 if c a= a P r P a o P ➢° nc °C F - 1 m P n P A P r€ P 4 n ➢ ¢ �?- a }3n s a�� k �? � _ 1•$x;4 - 's ?Q Uf $9 ' a 4 i �e•q's➢ s v f W a �g gi1Kly 1 uE $qfi`--$ - - y I .i cacti € ag?� a" s" �p $y� 9 iL i S� •: i4Sec.ainsg s ;8 ay =ia aye 4. q° a5 dos _- s;a a'a e' i i �a s €'xi_ C� s: c� _- $ � a eaai i i £° i �� _i'sR. € 3.5 a a AA- Ea>_� -5a e 9 =� sE g a �c8�aa, - c igxQ Fz S -A 11 €1 a a g ? € a A a �= ni 4. aiAiac g= _= asE ss § e9 i 3q.f� i-:?$ i d ` $ ai iFaa' " dl_ ?#$ %-a$i$8 9 Fyy3= n ''gyy�fisgi, ai a $;°8.d g 9a as a:•3=dYi f� & a$y ?ii 9 �� y Y '_ Sf=4= F g r ;$Sf� fi•= R'i 4 yds f I M 9s �a�gy qua a, s� a s agna i�9 a a iy gs 9 i R°� a. $ a s d a� i ,y A s s°i °�`�m° �- a �•�4- .YYyidBg Py% igx N. ��E �$4" s •: s� 9 $38`� 9�Cii$ S IgG° � s� �c�=-=-a9Es ?�z ,A I I Es��Cs'� RJR- F$ P' a 9 i i- �3 9 € a "$ x9i 4_ .figg s i fs y J � ^'�o.� s a_ $ F $ $ �` 5e 9 B'S• s. ? s �� ; 6 -•3 3��im8a �:s:$q �c a ° i:•i nLg F 9�a 4° fP=8aes9 3ami a,"ddR_S .j $$€o r "F @ g v §.Y u�san ,a&g � i Hi � Jq " � � g �• �i% � K•' g Aat IJ9a� 6 s is o' ?4 �• - �� € a R 9iyza � s A n P Am m p n aCa� aJ�ijf» 9- ea " ?a ay ni fg xz nao $ Oe a'$y a �V�, E.°° %E�ktq a� 3 § � �4d � �p C'o y� •� �a4 } _ ggCp tri a y"Aa �i 4 l4fi?dag� p 9' 9 ax_ # y34 •gz Hip ��€4a mar y3•?g%q �s a jig' $`s�l S boa$ a9 8 i J F ^ m p " lq � eg �Xn a I s Ra s ➢=n aa$ o f aTin $��t to MfgMfg17 ggaag�t it i'Wi Bis i3 T �' DDDDDD Nr , n : < � N V t f+ N __ T i� -,� i ei 2 � � s_a,� a fix IMP6. 9�ft§pil s� q_ �•s 9 '�a °a'a'.' 3s A1°igr ag S p IFit,— a 0, lip 11 8 m I=�:iga fiA a4•�d4� 6 6 ifiyl6-a4_ C $ € a E$ � s A i� ? ��a� it'$•s$€�@ gr1e ssa9 oa r :'. 111m,411 HI?e € eis �fi Yy!!6 sF '$i Ea' --�4i gzt za�d _!iR zyq=s`RAa g��=�ay� aY4 :g���F ig�id gi�Ei �J$ae $;g��g,= ` mrag tR H a $ n�syyyy 'e �f Pi �e�� d g In - Oil A4 i2 zc 4-•�Ea if9 rp sgm 9i•:3�_€� A€`��4� g a.ig gg - iji $r !€gi�egg: $�2 isQy 6�aC§� de Y 4" gr A MIN -i}nilit Fa4`t•itl'o� r� =� € ;; H R o r r m P P P i It i y e €Rza$ g 8fi§1a 1fiffayy9� sgg� -14 'gE a.a 4;g�c I4 Af�by_ eggY�e°s g}i•iy'sd F'Y�SyE 84y�g% €: z�,a8 zgiq%'Sg 9g9 ��P9 ciag iS: �$I'gCN a aRR �_ R' -s 9 S a iF=4 @ �i°fi�c'9•€i e 41, A01 �Iaf`- n��` a i'•Ag7°*'SCi aa' Q?Ee as:y`P. sise�96a pis Yd I8if ai� a F� Sf �i �.� �� � � � Jaz ��c�aas 9g€ ° �i•i�&F°4a iy6 6igqgg�� i9 $ l 'sa�. i s i's �#yogis{�It of �§ �€ 4a ?i ggi Yaaisc $seii€"g'�aBydi§�g�f i m p n P. r RPp y ➢ y H.zz UN IgtIO, `iii y cqg yL o -gFra €41! H 8' �$9•�$1 g�R al Fwilt! Y gsg ysf 'I9g �% d d 8¢IQ;NJ 41 aa ag=og gg%e E� a 9 ? it SH f?r;MIMS et8G ;a tae Fi. oil Y- s$at H YQaa:��R ai�S $gma & 2`fi B� i a�4gg g9 r � ` €L=4at4NJ II �it12F .4 E$�� 8=�� s 3 -f$a$ g$ }god' a tip:Ia9!�i.lia = z� Ezz,a A a9 SF �"i'!A €g�� 19q , •f G q =e8 agng.ig xyg i� 15 n P P P p n P A A� C �g5�� : " g - -.It it �an yAa&i� -gR �36 il}lC - is R S�,'� 6R R'ei iS�tr i� $ ai -. not R a� qdS $a l fisP i6� g f d ega�.� kilgl 9 c 1 srif1igi °d e e- a Pi s a9 =`ag R a �y$i$ tic- i °� i$A i� '�$ $E •i Oji; A - m p ? n P D c m P n P P p �Aeea a �� ° € aF; ' �Q g: x" ffa =i�a1s 94Y 4d n 9 9g F Hit 5 '�- €$ & ti e- $ e st$ og o Ig <g4 w9, 1 gs i 9 9c ag�gf 2 ay -s 3'Ae a e66s a.• 1a� y_y$ : pp gfg �i�atf i ` $ �. yd .8 a' !• ,9_z Ea y i P .g �' P i 5 6c= F° AB �9_• i9 i i Y 31 3 i 1i 1 � - c ! �[4e� . gya, s €@ r P $ RSV R _gfi 4 Y s_ 8• t= ! €' f $' g c i' a- a �` f E aB aaia�R tie$ $ $g g�� �;�° Aa[�� s z Cagi $ $ °Q iff 9 1 g a i. �i S YS $- %gg s a a R � ii yss � n S•�s � � ° � � S � � � c 9 � � � _° g- = n � �• i F0� � gg ��� ��� pSe ��� 2 � ��+ 3g R'd i�`t ;% �6c ? 9 g 8�gs��a $ $ R$ $ q J z ��a 3 f_ M" H eI $r gilt ; g ` � �i4 ?Iis=a a Ia$li MI [�g�a Nei, � � ��9q ���'� ez�a�'•c Y •ai,� � rt��, g �? �° a� � c• Q iuoL.�a:�� $ " � � $ g a� �Bt � �a$ f� � � Eg_ aei�=��;�s F save$ �•s 4a�fse Ina�'C� ; $�i4 a 9 a It s -i- -ate jai 9: s� Ifa� $ql &�q����a��e:���� �=�i 77 e R i s i. p89•s- F.• s- �� s ` $=8F�' �E=s��F 8 �_ A���Q �aE�-��i�€gs g"Fa _ ��g �,9y n9 p� a as S. R r Y$" ay%� F�`aF - id§•�c iq%iii eix i Aa i4, s .°°4?8 f�; 814e q'pn f m' A. = sada �i i y @�; �g 'a t y c a sa '_: : Rag gg a a Rp ¢¢ i Rt n aa- ;Rgz `, a ia, F�$4 m : $g rya &� mp §s s 9 ] R $ gg # 6 g AI N A' d� i. fi a a 8R a �s bks i��€ g y ai�d•�'$s�°�,gasI8 i•�i$� � i•y gS*4''y sfl �4a� �� � y � �� C� ££$ �� � ���' $�$ '�se- Y $�li2 $ ��. �s $� € ii? yE �• a A S= c f 3 a ge. g v a$=Ila aaR jq an. b' EF� 3gau �� i9A figf'$ -i5S n n59ai»»:: a: �p. Q"o 66 P y' e!`d acs S 4y g R��' G i s S°4444448444 �x CR asaea asa� Jill co CO Cc ® .� ..0 03 rn CD �_ CO) 0 2It "u W] fA fA� $ mudWQ �y n Z c QY Z l a }EA t t",041lt�ii�� t8°ia"fit —� 111 6_ T �' DDDDDD Nr , n : < � N V t f+ N __ T i� -,� i ei 2 � � s_a,� a fix IMP6. 9�ft§pil s� q_ �•s 9 '�a °a'a'.' 3s A1°igr ag S p IFit,— a 0, lip 11 8 m I=�:iga fiA a4•�d4� 6 6 ifiyl6-a4_ C $ € a E$ � s A i� ? ��a� it'$•s$€�@ gr1e ssa9 oa r :'. 111m,411 HI?e € eis �fi Yy!!6 sF '$i Ea' --�4i gzt za�d _!iR zyq=s`RAa g��=�ay� aY4 :g���F ig�id gi�Ei �J$ae $;g��g,= ` mrag tR H a $ n�syyyy 'e �f Pi �e�� d g In - Oil A4 i2 zc 4-•�Ea if9 rp sgm 9i•:3�_€� A€`��4� g a.ig gg - iji $r !€gi�egg: $�2 isQy 6�aC§� de Y 4" gr A MIN -i}nilit Fa4`t•itl'o� r� =� € ;; H R o r r m P P P i It i y e €Rza$ g 8fi§1a 1fiffayy9� sgg� -14 'gE a.a 4;g�c I4 Af�by_ eggY�e°s g}i•iy'sd F'Y�SyE 84y�g% €: z�,a8 zgiq%'Sg 9g9 ��P9 ciag iS: �$I'gCN a aRR �_ R' -s 9 S a iF=4 @ �i°fi�c'9•€i e 41, A01 �Iaf`- n��` a i'•Ag7°*'SCi aa' Q?Ee as:y`P. sise�96a pis Yd I8if ai� a F� Sf �i �.� �� � � � Jaz ��c�aas 9g€ ° �i•i�&F°4a iy6 6igqgg�� i9 $ l 'sa�. i s i's �#yogis{�It of �§ �€ 4a ?i ggi Yaaisc $seii€"g'�aBydi§�g�f i m p n P. r RPp y ➢ y H.zz UN IgtIO, `iii y cqg yL o -gFra €41! H 8' �$9•�$1 g�R al Fwilt! Y gsg ysf 'I9g �% d d 8¢IQ;NJ 41 aa ag=og gg%e E� a 9 ? it SH f?r;MIMS et8G ;a tae Fi. oil Y- s$at H YQaa:��R ai�S $gma & 2`fi B� i a�4gg g9 r � ` €L=4at4NJ II �it12F .4 E$�� 8=�� s 3 -f$a$ g$ }god' a tip:Ia9!�i.lia = z� Ezz,a A a9 SF �"i'!A €g�� 19q , •f G q =e8 agng.ig xyg i� 15 n P P P p n P A A� C �g5�� : " g - -.It it �an yAa&i� -gR �36 il}lC - is R S�,'� 6R R'ei iS�tr i� $ ai -. not R a� qdS $a l fisP i6� g f d ega�.� kilgl 9 c 1 srif1igi °d e e- a Pi s a9 =`ag R a �y$i$ tic- i °� i$A i� '�$ $E •i Oji; A - m p ? n P D c m P n P P p �Aeea a �� ° € aF; ' �Q g: x" ffa =i�a1s 94Y 4d n 9 9g F Hit 5 '�- €$ & ti e- $ e st$ og o Ig <g4 w9, 1 gs i 9 9c ag�gf 2 ay -s 3'Ae a e66s a.• 1a� y_y$ : pp gfg �i�atf i ` $ �. yd .8 a' !• ,9_z Ea y i P .g �' P i 5 6c= F° AB �9_• i9 i i Y 31 3 i 1i 1 � - c ! �[4e� . gya, s €@ r P $ RSV R _gfi 4 Y s_ 8• t= ! €' f $' g c i' a- a �` f E aB aaia�R tie$ $ $g g�� �;�° Aa[�� s z Cagi $ $ °Q iff 9 1 g a i. �i S YS $- %gg s a a R � ii yss � n S•�s � � ° � � S � � � c 9 � � � _° g- = n � �• i F0� � gg ��� ��� pSe ��� 2 � ��+ 3g R'd i�`t ;% �6c ? 9 g 8�gs��a $ $ R$ $ q J z ��a 3 f_ M" H eI $r gilt ; g ` � �i4 ?Iis=a a Ia$li MI [�g�a Nei, � � ��9q ���'� ez�a�'•c Y •ai,� � rt��, g �? �° a� � c• Q iuoL.�a:�� $ " � � $ g a� �Bt � �a$ f� � � Eg_ aei�=��;�s F save$ �•s 4a�fse Ina�'C� ; $�i4 a 9 a It s -i- -ate jai 9: s� Ifa� $ql &�q����a��e:���� �=�i 77 e R i s i. p89•s- F.• s- �� s ` $=8F�' �E=s��F 8 �_ A���Q �aE�-��i�€gs g"Fa _ ��g �,9y n9 p� a as S. R r Y$" ay%� F�`aF - id§•�c iq%iii eix i Aa i4, s .°°4?8 f�; 814e q'pn f m' A. = sada �i i y @�; �g 'a t y c a sa '_: : Rag gg a a Rp ¢¢ i Rt n aa- ;Rgz `, a ia, F�$4 m : $g rya &� mp §s s 9 ] R $ gg # 6 g AI N A' d� i. fi a a 8R a �s bks i��€ g y ai�d•�'$s�°�,gasI8 i•�i$� � i•y gS*4''y sfl �4a� �� � y � �� C� ££$ �� � ���' $�$ '�se- Y $�li2 $ ��. �s $� € ii? yE �• a A S= c f 3 a ge. g v a$=Ila aaR jq an. b' EF� 3gau �� i9A figf'$ -i5S n n59ai»»:: a: �p. Q"o 66 P y' e!`d acs S 4y g R��' G i s S°4444448444 �x CR asaea asa� Jill co CO Cc ® .� ..0 03 rn CD �_ CO) 0 2It "u W] fA fA� $ mudWQ �y R. w OWldo raza�y C7�Oz�rJ iV 3 m::!Z z 0 9 x H l7 d nZ �3 0 Cn U] x tJ xd rt7 <mw C7 CJ 'zl in r tJroaccz ztJHtJMC) �ro rozH o�d-x13, H O Cn 0 J 0 4�G"yaf']y zd0rH9 a En ] Cn ]d I3 O H O In H yzy4z]Z0 �Cn ��m n`3Z4 oe� d CgNgt�',J �g /I 0 W O o m z o t4 a "$2 == y S�tl F s• � Ptn. (n I 'r �Q- p FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NB. 6606 296 Pineapple Grove Way Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Phone: 561 274-6500 Fax: (561) 274-8558 0 \ -( LIR'DRABlAGE EASMENTRACT ORABIAGE EASEMENT 100 (A PPoVATE ® N W O o m z o t4 z " rT rL' ? ra == y S�tl EnviroDesi n Associates Inc I- I�Be 9 vJBA�n.�,I ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS II c I � �J . v N 6 -1 0 p FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NB. 6606 296 Pineapple Grove Way Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Phone: 561 274-6500 Fax: (561) 274-8558 m I 5 1 $N aI y bey u Z C-:3 3 480 (n m O L—) m I =pas4 o a MO� ( s G) I X A l y$ n I Nm X A =o N m 0 A z O m o I ,A a m n —'' =D s 0 F<T Z m 179 Z s. gQz Z F .r_ Nm g m No _ C D m vz $ m g T C♦ Myg I I _ I I I II $ -PD m !y -3 e► m 4n0 A: O Rog„ IN) �� c X99= o a0 m _C I n W O o m z o t4 = O a � y ,P W " rT rL' ? ra == y S�tl EnviroDesi n Associates Inc I- I�Be 9 vJBA�n.�,I ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS II c I � NOT VALID WITHOUT ENGINEER'S SEAL JOSEPH A. PIKE, P.E. FL REG 4 42696 NO. DATE: REVISIONS: gy; 0 I � I FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NB. 6606 296 Pineapple Grove Way Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Phone: 561 274-6500 Fax: (561) 274-8558 m I 5 I 0 I r z I O I u m I I N I I m I m I I I I I I I 0--m I d S; 0 ( I t I I X A l y$ Z1 -1N Arc mA A L,$ $ Nm X A =o N m 0 A z O m =1 y IT A a m n F9 G7 =D s 0 F<T Z m 179 Z Z Zx L,p im I m m D m vz $ m g y m vmG, I I _ I I I o o fIl I I I I I I I I vJ "a' s Y M ira Ave a ut � i Federal Hwy NE711,AvD _- -Z Ci NE 6th AvR E 0 NEW, Ave 190 F'Jrnt rfal a e%vS Ave CD �- N.00eanBlvd rn 0 o N W O o m z o t4 = O a � y ,P W " rT rL' ? ra == y S�tl EnviroDesi n Associates Inc I- I�Be 9 vJBA�n.�,I ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 1 - 1228 N OCEAN BLVD (�7T 7� �,F 7�T GULF STREAM, FLORIDA NOT VALID WITHOUT ENGINEER'S SEAL JOSEPH A. PIKE, P.E. FL REG 4 42696 NO. DATE: REVISIONS: gy; 0 FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NB. 6606 296 Pineapple Grove Way Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Phone: 561 274-6500 Fax: (561) 274-8558 .. \_ ��1 i�Js li e• tesid,nx _cl ' h_I o�n .'ew\JYA,\'3U /9 aNli.Uwy, IV/1d/_�. 1� 9:1.. -1 L W Z. �ml vrD. H'- a� vy D m >� mP woNm� t 'D Ff.i Ng CI.z �p z y m> v�K m o NC0 zm Do 5m ; D mKK �F z G' z L a �� K b ? N 12' D 2 IrxNu n o m D —i f <>s F T� 6" 00m a' 4 MIN. 2.47' x6 " m go 0 R x< ma o W_- S D �rm1� tim Fsx o xzE £'mr F v N Z gzaay.$s "� zm m$ e> m a4 0� 0 o9A �g� I @gui mI �g 1 � T g�msc.s -C day >•y F m Baa 'o . is r mmo>z �� =F �p N1n i 6. Y mm2 N $ yiyfa MIN. F- I zioz mF� 0 w> a2 C7 Fia� o� �t4i m�> O MIN. z. m ro'n g' 3 Bio yN o g9 ". = D t. a M �-6m -6 m Cb v'v>aQ —omF;z 8F IH;? ,;I zo$9 y mA�,`cu �svaro; y y \\9� $ $ O >=A. I a FlmmSt n�� DNvS� �r I zoatF I � $F ti o�l� / o N>>InNN �� xgg Z g M mZ� �x�B ��. > m ----I--- p0 SnTi n \ D o \ i �— < N ,Zml � •_a• a rn I I ze x. .63 So 0 -z a u I ig ��iY'i � $ < �gmg� Kee A A 0 j F _ m Ipp� r t ^2 z 4 zm� �Z�1 Fb7'�Y' F O SIF ,v,1 ��!/ j O m ..�o�o v goO~D za�Do S� 15EPTN V41ES MTH CHANNEL NO. m g m E F$ z m w /� D �$ i's Z rn n F Ooi s ; SAH 0 O % Z �' Sim Ste aklmmuM ,4% m Z <_ // M m R$c •«•.: ov > MINCOVER D z v i i N mi ZO Krl•1 m Za' T �D m� f l — 9 y 08 $ o >: 3 Z T (� D �$A �_ U=�� cc s 6 =3 C� U99 o �q$ m 0 o: m o -� �m04-may -e —i rn COO 0-9 ;0z :JD a Do m r n a c,s _ m P w o N m o 1 y r 8 y `� w Y b� cc' g :-i sVa oci tSgNn JE ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PAVING & DRAIANGE DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 1 — 1228 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA NENGINEER'S JOSEPH A. PIKE, P.E. FL REG @ 42696 NO. DATE: REVISIONS: BY. 0 -IL- FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION No. 6506 298 Pineapple Grove Woy Delray Beach, Florida 33444 Phone: 561 274-6500 Fax: 561 274-8558 ,.:\ .;'.$\15'./_ h e --j- --_. _'_L F ,,, e,Aj'/F,\"--�TI/v-:li-d— I 1, .�l. 41. '-, 41_ A�,.f I. r—, PA V£0 5 Ir "o> P r COM +1! BRNArI +s. +7S 4 7+ P A V F O +ao ary���.T,K, 0 �o goo S, ® � o€ �p N. o C -)m y ATLANT/C CEA c F--� 0 p m roo To�, �_'m - / L O T B c T n -CO)) C CO m m y ® O —� A-FWCAMrrunsffSW&Z. �CO) 9.01M.se�ava�A 1 A o +a7 p�gyy�Vr EASWWT�� IR4CT A' FAWD goo S, ® � o€ �p N. o C -)m y ATLANT/C CEA c F--� 0 p m roo To�, �_'m - / L O T B CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy Hewlett Kent Robert Dockerty December 12, 2013 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2013 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 11-21-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. c. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh of Bridges, Marsh & Associates as agent for Mr. & Mrs. John Smith, owners of the property located at 555 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 2, H. V. Pope Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 square feet, to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway and reopen a previously existing driveway at the south east corner of the property. 2. An application submitted by Mark Marsh & Keith Williams as agents for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, owners of the property located at 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 21 & Part of Lot 20, Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to slightly modify both driveways, add paver bricks, and revise previously approved landscape design and materials at the above address. 3. An application submitted by Mark Marsh as agent for Mr.& Mrs. Steven Silverman, owners of the property located at 1465 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Section 10, Township 46 South, Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit installation of new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate at the above address. AGENDA CONTINUED 4. An application submitted by Maria T. Bonilla & Joaquin Grillo, owners of the property located at 335 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described as Lot 6, H. V. Pope Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 square foot garage and 668 square feet of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 square foot lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single family dwelling being 1,329 square feet, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added. VII. Items by Staff. A. Update -Ad Hoc Committee VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2013, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: Chairman Morgan called the meeting to order at 8:31 A.M. II. Roll Call: Present and Scott Morgan Chairman Participating Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Amanda Jones Board Member Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member Robert Dockerty Alternate Board Member Hewlett Kent Alternate Board Member Also Present and William H. Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk Absent w/notice John C. Randolph Town Counsel Mark Marsh Architect Hollis Tidwell Architect Keith Williams Landscape Architect Joaquin Grillo Resident David Frank Precision Drafting & Design III. Minutes: A. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on November 21, 2013 Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Jones seconded to approve the November 21, 2013 Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held by the Architectural Review Board. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: There were none. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Dates Chairman Morgan announced the following approved ARPB meeting dates: a. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. c. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Morgan asked for any conflicts with the next meeting date and any ex -parte communications, and there were none. He also requested that any persons speaking at this Public Hearing be sworn in. Town Clerk Taylor swore in Mark Marsh, Keith Williams and Joaquin Grillo. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 2013 —Page 2 VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh of Bridges, Marsh & Associates, as agent for Mr. & Mrs. John Smith, owners of the property located at 555 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 2, H.V. Pope Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 square feet, to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway, and reopen a previously existing driveway at the south east corner of the property. Mr. Marsh introduced himself, Keith Williams, Landscape Architect and Hollis Tidwell, who was technically savvy with the power point and sketch -up computer presentation for the massing he was presenting this day. Mr. Marsh continued that it was an auto cad program. He reported this program has been received well from all levels, and that it is simplistic but the elements and proportions are real. Mr. Tidwell described and demonstrated in detail the new computer program. Board Member Lyons inquired regarding encouraging this program being utilized when building a new single-family home. Mr. Marsh responded that it was not substantial for some homes, as size and financial costs are the criteria. As an example, he recommended this great tool for beach front homes, due to the massing of the homes. Chairman Morgan inquired regarding the preservation of this computerized tool for record keeping. Mr. Tidwell reported that it was saved in a PDF file folder, as with photographs. Mr. Marsh stated that he would be leaving a thumb drive for the staff to review. Board Member Jones inquired if it could be printed out, to which Mr. Tidwell answered "Yes". Mr. Marsh continued describing the above-named interesting reversed residence which faces the golf course in the back and Old School Road in the front. He reported that the residents were trying to create an entry feature to replicate a covered porch and loggia over an existing tattered awning. Mr. Marsh identified the exact placement and discussed the color of light white brick, the coin work, which will contrast with a shadow line. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the distance of the awning with regard to the eaves. Mr. Marsh stated that the "silly" wall will come out. He continued that the portico element will anchor the element to the floor. Mr. Marsh also reported that the loggia will be wider than the front door, and will ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 3 now give a sense of entry and arrival to the house. He commented that the house is on line with a Georgian style but with more elements. Mr. Marsh stated that the roof is flat and dramatic. Mr. Williams described and demonstrated the landscaping improvements with photographs. He reported that the entrance will be adjusted with the driveway. Mr. Williams continued and discussed the motor court with canopy trees. He stated that coral and cast stone will be used on the driveway, and gardens will flank the entrance. Mr. Williams also stated that this will create better circulation in the driveway. He commented that the present Ficus hedges will be replaced with more white fly tolerant hedges being put in, and that the pool will remain, with the removal of quite a bit of paving, and will incorporate the cast stone for the pool furniture area. Mr. Williams also reported that there will be a feeling of expanse with the elevations. Mr. Marsh continued that the new driveway will still be on the west side of the house making it easier to get to the garage. Vice -Chairman Smith stated that he presently loved the house, and that with these new proposed additions, it will be excellent Chairman Morgan asked for any further comments. There were none. Board Member Murphy moved and Vice -Chairman Smith seconded to approve Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 square feet to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway and reopen a previously existing driveway at the south east corner of the property. All vote AYE. 2. An application submitted by Mark Marsh & Keith Williams, as agents for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, owners of the property located 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described s Lot 21 & Part of Lot 20, Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to slightly modify both driveways, add paver bricks, and revise previously approved landscape design and materials at the above address. Mr. Marsh stated that the residents have asked Mr. Williams to revisit the previously approved elements. Mr. Williams reported that the residents requested to incorporate a spa which would water into the remaining pool, with a new emerald green finish. He continued that the cast stone paving will remain. Mr. Williams also stated there will be no change in the landscaping in the back. Mr. Williams stated that all equipment will be out of the setback and will be walled in. He stated that off the breakfast room there will be a garden, which would have a walk through leading out to a little terrace with an urn or sculpture. Mr. Williams discussed and further demonstrated on the computer the driveways and the remaining Ficus trees. He stated that the gardens will be all freshened up throughout the property. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 4 Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the hedge in front of the driveway. Mr. Williams responded that it will be replanted out of the right of way and onto the property. Board Member Jones inquired if the plantings would survive that transition, including the citrus trees. Mr. Williams commented that there is a 75% chance. Chairman Morgan asked for any comments. There were none. Board Member Lyons moved and Vice -Chairman Smith seconded to approve the Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to slightly modify both driveways, add paver bricks, and revise previously approved landscape design and materials, which meet the intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards at the above address. All voted AYE. 3. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, as agent for Mr. and Mrs. Steven Silverman, owners of the property located at 1465 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Section 10, Township 46 South, Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit installation of new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate at the above address. Mr. Marsh reported that this property will be one of the sterling properties in Town, due to the outstanding work done, and the monies invested on this project. He continued that they are requesting a new gate and gate post on A1A. Mr. Marsh described and discussed the sketch of what is being proposed. He further reported that the gate post has no encroachment is very pricey, antique, and is a very classic element to the property. Mr. Marsh continued that the compositions were rot iron and bronze, eighty (80) years old, and is from France. He reported that there has been a great deal of unfair conflict from some neighbors regarding this property. Mr. Marsh continued that the owners have been very patient with the situation. Town Manager Thrasher stated that he passed through the above-named property and was very impressed with what he saw, and commented that there was no conflict with the approval documents. Mr. Marsh reported that the owners planted very substantial landscaping on their property, at a cost of $500,000, with respect to their neighbors. Vice -Chairman Smith questioned the heights of the gates with regard to the codes. Mr. Marsh stated that the restrictions are between 7 and 8 feet and those were met Board Member Lyons stated that he liked it because it was not a wall, and the entrance looked great Chairman Morgan commended Mr. Marsh for the remarkable job. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 5 Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Lyons seconded to approve the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to permit installation of new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate at the above address. All voted AYE. 4. An application submitted by Maria T. Bonilla and Joaquin Grillo, owners of the property located 335 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described as Lot 6, H.V. Pope Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 square foot garage and 668 square feet of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 square foot lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single-family dwelling being 1,329 square feet, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added. Mr. Grillo introduced himself and stated that he and his wife are the owners of the above-named home for the past two (2) years. He stated his wife fell in love with the house, as soon as she saw it. Mr. Grillo continued that his three (3) children attend school in Town, and discussed the comparison of their small home to their neighbors' larger ones. He commented on how he wanted to "grow" the house towards the east for more space for his family. Mr. Grillo discussed and referred in detail to the floor plan handout. He wishes to convert the current garage into a guest room, another garage, a mud room and a new bedroom in the northeast corner. Mr. Grillo discussed an entry bathroom which would convert to a cabana bathroom leading out to the pool area, and a lanai as transparent as possible, which would not interfere with the view of the grounds. He discussed in detail the lanai's views from the extreme east and that the existing neighbors cannot be seen. Mr. Grillo commented that there will be a small barbeque structure with drawers on the lanai. Chairman Morgan inquired regarding the driveway. Mr. Grillo responded that there will be two (2) driveways; one goes around the house in the front and will not be touched. He continued that the shorter driveway will be 23 feet east from the property. Mr. Grillo stated that one tree will have to be replaced. Board Member Lyons questioned replacing the roof as it looks old. Mr. Grillo responded "No", and that some pipes have to be amended but the roof will have to be painted to appear as one new roof. Chairman Morgan inquired regarding the landscaping off the addition of the bedroom. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 6 Mr. Grillo stated that the vegetation will move closer to the property line. He continued he will look to the ARPB for suggestions for new vegetation. Mr. Grillo stated that there will be a fence inside the new calusa vegetation, which is the same vegetation as is planted two (2) houses to the south of his house. Vice -Chairman Smith discussed the short driveway and the issues of a car backing out of the driveway. Mr. Grillo responded that the Ficus hedge will disappear which would help. He continued that he realizes it is too tall. Board Member Jones inquired regarding the roof line, which seems a lot higher, and if it could be made all one height. Town Clerk Taylor swore in David Frank, of Precisions Drafting and Design who reported that they are working with the some plane and therefore, they cannot lower it. Board Member Lyons inquired as to the new height of the roof. Mr. Frank responded approximately 3 to 4 feet higher. He continued that the only way to lower the roof would be to flatten it out, and that it would not be seen from the ground level. Board Member Lyons questioned the monotonous roof line which would not make it desirable. Chairman Morgan discussed the windows on the north side, which are all vertical, and takes your eyes straight up to the roof. He continued that all structural issues are permissible under Code. Mr. Grillo reported on the large amount of landscaping, and that the roof will only be seen from the golf course, and that there was no major impact on the house. Board Member Murphy inquired if there was any feedback from the neighbors. Town Clerk Taylor replied "No". Chairman Morgan stated that if s a nice improvement and change to the house. Town Manager Thrasher added that he did ask for help from Urban Design Associates, and there were no violations. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 7 Board Member Murphy moved and Board Member Lyons seconded to approve Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit the conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 square foot garage and 668 square feet of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 square foot lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single-family dwelling being 1,329 square feet, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added from the Design Manual. All voted AYE. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF: A. Update—Ad Hoc Committee Town Manager Thrasher reported that the Ad Hoc Committee has been completed and is full. The Chairman is William (Bill) Boardman, and the members are: Benjamin Scheier, Richard Mouw, David Bodker, and Patricia (Patsy) Randolph. Town Manager Thrasher requested receiving suggestions or comments from the ARPB for changing the qualifications of the code. He stated that the ground work would take a minimum of ninety (90) days. Town Clerk Taylor stated she hoped an Organizational Meeting would take place right after the holidays, and be totally completed by May 2014. She continued that the Committee was not expected to review the entire code just certain issues brought before the Committee. Town Manager Thrasher reported that Chapter 70 can be addressed, which has caused difficulty in the past. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the amount of cars in front of the Silverman house. Town Manager Thrasher agreed that its a nuisance, and that it has nothing to do with the Spence house. He continued these are all related to the Silverman construction. VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: There were none. IX. PUBLIC: There were none. X. ADJOURNMENT: Chairman Morgan adjourned the meeting at 9:29 A.M. Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-18 Address: 555 Old School Road Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Level II Architectural/Site Plan Gross Lot size: 28,547 SF Zoning District: RS -C: GS Core Adjacent Residences: G/S-Bermuda Considered During Review: Section 70-71. Floor area ratios. Section 70-74. Setbacks. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights. Staff Recommendation: Owners: M/ M John Smith Agent: Mark Marsh of Digby, Bridges, Marsh & Associates. Construct new entry portico, covered loggia and relocation and modifications to existing driveway To permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 SF, to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway and reopen a previously existing driving at the south east corner of the property. Effective Lot Area: 25,367 SF Proposed Height: Existing Motion to Recommend Approval of a Level II Architectural/ Site Plan Review based on a finding that the proposed permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 SF, to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway and reopen a previously existing driving at the south east corner of the property meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: December 19, 2013 Action: Level II Architectural /Site Plan Review: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ® RECEIV"''- Nov 15 2013 Town of Gulfstream, R APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # "' l 13, To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name I.A.2. Project Address: PART H. GENERAL INFORMATION & MRS. JOHN SMITH 555 OLD SCHOOL ROAD I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: SEE ATTACHED I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) ADDITION OF A NEW ENTRY PORTICO (NORTH) AND COVERED LOGGIA OVER EXISTING OPEN PATIO (SOUTH) ALONG WITH LANDSCAPE AND IIARDSCAPE MODIFICATION, I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: N/A Type of Foundation: PILING B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 555 OLD SCHOOL ROAD I.B.2. Owner Phone Nu I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name; BRIDGES, MARSH & ASS01.NIE VERA WIT T TAM I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 5 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: Decision: = Use Only ate: ~ v 4 1,vS- N- I5-) 3 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13100 Fax l7 ^lam Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? GULF STREAM CORE 95-C) III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ?Yes No Explain:PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS DO NOT REQUIRE VARIANCES OR SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS BEING COMPATIBLE WITH ZONING DISTRICT III.A.3. Is the project consistent witla the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? Yes No Explain: NO IMPACT III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? RELOCATING EXISTING WEST DRIVEWAY AND REOPENING A NEW DRIVEWAY AT SOUTH EAST CORNER OF PROPERTY WHERE ONE EXISTED PREVIOUSLY III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage ON SITE b. Sanitary Sewer _ PUBLIC W R c. Potable water C'TTV d. Irrigation Water CITY e. Electricity FP&L f. Telephone ATT g. Gas FPT h. Cable Television (1r)mr•A cm III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PROPOSED ADDITIONS ENHANCE THE ARCHITECTURE AND FUNCTION OF THE EXISTING STRUCTURE PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes No (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an exist' vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes No (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes 0 (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 146,.vn of Gulf Stre B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? N/A IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: N/A IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? N/A IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IM&A C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? N/A IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? N/A IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? N D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: N/A IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 memorandum TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP DATE: December 10, 2013 PROJECT NAME: 555 Old School Road UDKS PROJECT #: 94-012.019 urban design kilda STUD I OSY Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics Urban Design Kilday Studios has reviewed the proposed addition of 597 square feet to the existing, one-story, single family home at 555 Old School Road. The proposed improvements include a new front entry to the home and a new loggia at the rear of the home. The brick home is also proposed to be painted white. Please see our review comments below. Project Details • Existing zoning: Gulf Stream Core • Proposed project: 597 SF addition to existing single family home The proposed new entry includes two cast concrete columns, a stucco cornice and a decorative aluminum railing. The height of the feature is 14 feet to the top of the proposed railing. The proposed loggia at the rear of the building is similar in style to the front entry addition as it features four cast concrete columns, stucco cornice and an aluminum railing. The entry feature and rear loggia both use flat roofs with slight slopes for drainage purposes. Discussion The height and massing of entry features for homes is specifically addressed within the Town's originally -approved Design Manual. Entries of appropriate scale and proportion are encouraged while "over -elegant" and larger entries are discouraged. The original Design Manual set limits to the entry heights in relationship with the home's roof eave height. For example, an 8 to 12 foot height entry was preferred for a one-story home with an eave of 8 feet to 10 feet, six Inches In height. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 2.2.5 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 In 2012, several amendments to the Town's Code of 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax Ordinances were adopted to address several building -related www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 Required Proposed Effective Lot Area 16,500 SF 25,367 SF FAR 0.33 (1st20k SF) & 0.20 (> 20k) /7,673 SF 5,547 SF Front setback 30 feet 47 feet Rear setback 20 feet 46 feet The proposed new entry includes two cast concrete columns, a stucco cornice and a decorative aluminum railing. The height of the feature is 14 feet to the top of the proposed railing. The proposed loggia at the rear of the building is similar in style to the front entry addition as it features four cast concrete columns, stucco cornice and an aluminum railing. The entry feature and rear loggia both use flat roofs with slight slopes for drainage purposes. Discussion The height and massing of entry features for homes is specifically addressed within the Town's originally -approved Design Manual. Entries of appropriate scale and proportion are encouraged while "over -elegant" and larger entries are discouraged. The original Design Manual set limits to the entry heights in relationship with the home's roof eave height. For example, an 8 to 12 foot height entry was preferred for a one-story home with an eave of 8 feet to 10 feet, six Inches In height. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 2.2.5 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 In 2012, several amendments to the Town's Code of 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax Ordinances were adopted to address several building -related www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 issues. One of the issues addressed was the height of entry features for single family homes. The concern was that the existing code at the time allowed for entries which were out of scale with the home and the character of the neighborhood. The 2012 code changes were (new sections underlined while deleted sections were ;+rte: Section 70-100. Roof and eave height (a)... (4) Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable or other such elements. Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches (49FR eight f.,.,t t„ 12 f„r e„tr„ featw,-,,4 (2) Discouraged Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet (bet,.,eeR 12 and 14 feet f9F eRtr., (3) Prohibited Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet (gFeat„r than 14 feet f.,. ,,.,t.,, (c) Two-story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights:: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — From eight feet to 12 feet for one-story portions All other districts — From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions 4r-e� (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — Between 12 and 14 feet for one-story portions All other districts — Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one-story portions (bet eeR 14 and 16 feet f.). eRtFy fee .& The 2012 amended code does not adequately address the height of new entry features as intended. As a result, the proposed entry feature does not have a specific height limitation and is limited to being consistent with the scale and proportion of the rest of the house. With regards to the flat roof proposed for the entry and loggia, flat roofs are not permitted by Section 70-187(6). However, within the description of Gulf Stream Core district (Section 70- 28, (b)(3)), lanais are described as being used extensively throughout the district in the backyards of lots. Many of these existing lanais and loggias feature flat roofs or roofs with a very low slope. The proposed flat roof is consistent with the standards of the existing neighborhood district and, therefore, consistent with the requirements of Section 70-107 Recommendation The proposed new entry feature and rear loggia meet all the City standards with regards to Floor Area Ratio and setbacks. As stated above, the current Town Code does not place a specific height limit on the entry feature. The proposed entry stands 14 feet in height to the top of the railing as compared to the 21.5 feet high roof ridge. Under the current code, the proposed improvements are consistent with scale and proportion of the existing house. As such, we can recommend approval of the request. It is also recommended that the Town Design Manual be amended to place specific height limitations for entry features. Below is a suggested revision to Section 70-100 with the additions underlined and the deletions stricken. The suggested entry feature heights are generally what was approved within the original Design Manual, however, the definition of entry feature has been expanded to incorporate additional architectural features. Suggested Code Amendment Section 70-100. Roof and eave height (a) (4) Entry features are the front portion of the structure which provide door entrance to the dwelling. The height of the entry feature is measured from the finish floor elevation to the upper portion of any balcony railings, Dutch gable, eaves, architectural banding or other architectural elements. Entry features, if used, should provide a sense of arrival, yet should not overpower them or the remainder of the structure. The scale and proportion of entry features should be consistent with the rest of the structure, varying just enough to provide a focal point to the front of the house. (b) One story homes (1) Preferred. Eave heights: From eight feet to ten feet six inches Entry feature heights: From eight feet to 12 feet (2) Discouraged Eave heights: Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet Entry feature heights: Between 12 and 14 feet (3) Prohibited Eave heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet Entry feature heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 14 feet (c) Two-story homes. (1) Preferred. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — From eight feet to 12 feet for one-story portions 22 feet six inches or less for two-story portions All other districts — From eight feet to ten feet six inches for one-story portions 21 feet or less for two-story portions Entry Feature heights: All districts - From eight feet to 14 feet (2) Discouraged. Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — Between 12 and 14 feet for one-story portions Between 22 feet six inches and 24 feet six inches for two-story portions All other districts — Between ten feet six inches and 12 feet six inches for one- story portions Between 21 feet and 23 feet for two-story portions Entry feature heights: All districts — Between 14 and 16 feet (3) Prohibited. Buildings more than two and one-half stories Eave heights: Beachfront and Ocean West Districts — Less than eight feet or greater than 14 feet for one-story portions Greater than 24 feet six inches for two-story portions All other districts — Less than eight feet or greater than 12 feet six inches for one-story portions Greater than 23 feet for two-story portions Entry feature heights: Less than eight feet or greater than 16 feet These suggested heights will provided the needed limitation on entry features, while allowing for sufficient flexibility for quality architectural design features. The Architectural Review and Planning Board is encouraged to review the proposed amendment to ensure that the entry feature heights are consistent with the Town's architectural history and character. ��-6u�� / ( >Czuimm y ����x x v y m O Lin CJ to to l7 cn 'o x ��C ��o Noro�� t 0 o,m,> n_m C.) C> (�� <Omm " D� =n 7z7om��n _ 03 q FSH>o9 rtrt y ��ao�zczim�Da= W A J ��-6u�� / TmDo' pD" ��p9m >Czuimm y ����x x v 92Dma 0 m - m DDm a mo zo omamrmDitz mm ox ��C Z4 1358a o,m,> n_m C.) C> (�� <Omm " D� =n 7z7om��n _ 03 q FSH>o9 rtrt y ��ao�zczim�Da= w N 6\ N v \ ������  // b -d' OO E h Y - o im MGz7 Cr�� tie 75 C) > `L mpmzC"51 o=0 a(4 TmDo' pD" ��p9m >Czuimm y ����x x v 92Dma 0 m - m DDm a mo zo omamrmDitz mm ox ��C Z4 1358a o,m,> n_m C.) C> (�� <Omm " D� =n 7z7om��n _ MM C��tm7 31rmmC-i'1 q FSH>o9 rtrt y ��ao�zczim�Da= w ��mC00 r C 9�� -zON��N Cp D> Z N��f=il m im MGz7 Cr�� -1 m0 mm T T �� D O ,aOm��O 10 FP. ��. H o . P1 z D����N< ' r��y ZoC Dmmx-+ oOmmm �� Zg. z F O--1540 /25 J . A " ����oma [mime Orman 3 C Om-IO9 ysznv�� z-ggoa mz��m.ma o m K omrO lr mms zm9 'BOm:G MM Dm<xmm c ��m3s��z o Om or00 �] N `' -<0Zi mm r��*1 OC>" OD 9 < `\����l m in 1T m�� `; V cgmOT a��En mD3Z C-+ZO rn Z Om Dm Z D3am i 0 \ m mm C D z 9zm N m - T nCmo omD000 zrrme lD I .o o '17" so aODo p n m 9 G OOamm N? .`NrFO Z d jas rIA to 14S" 1 I So 40 0�' S. Zo 8> wa 0 U04 t 5.5 ��. 11ll fV Ute+ w +" a 11 3. + av " p C 0 ry ` ^ 14 x.80 S .. + " +, v �� 20.5 a" .e ,Z i.S rLt q �� �� p " . , n ��. 0 1.76 S IS tl.3 4 tiCoo ��" 00, n w oin o p Ecs��m er> >= JIJi 0 " > `L mpmzC"51 o=0 O D �� TmDo' pD" ��p9m >Czuimm y ����x x v 92Dma 0 m - m DDm a mo zo omamrmDitz mm ox 0 M,zo .0, zzfA D> 2zmma0 o,m,> n_m C.) C> (�� <Omm " D� =n 7z7om��n MM C��tm7 31rmmC-i'1 q FSH>o9 rtrt ��o < ��ao�zczim�Da= Tm'OO��p 5 myN ��mC00 r C 9�� -zON��N Cp D> Z N��f=il m im MGz7 Cr�� -1 m0 mm T T �� D O ,aOm��O Ommp�� H o . P1 z D����N< D � m OT pD r��y ZoC Dmmx-+ oOmmm cmcwm��r�� Opi��rw- Zg. z F m��mnmT mm mzo 00 M2 ��CZ��O D=O <Zfoc, ��ZammD09D'-���� ����oma [mime Orman Om-IO9 ysznv�� z-ggoa mz��m.ma o m K omrO lr mms zm9 'BOm:G MM Dm<xmm c ��m3s��z o Om or00 �] -<0Zi mm r��*1 OC>" OD 9 < `\����l m in 1T m�� `; V cgmOT a��En mD3Z C-+ZO rn Z Om Dm Z D3am i 0 \ m mm C D z 9zm N m - T nCmo omD000 zrrme aDCOr- aD=lo VI Z r aODo p n m 9 G OOamm N? .`NrFO Z C v "v T O C"7 M ' ' < 3� o v r /�� -n W V/ r_ ml O C:) O m N cn m CSD r�� C=) m rr J�� A ' 9 P P t 00 o O cl 0 0 e pq � C r o ° En >> N r Q it t�i rT $ B tT > > > > > > > O a x > >>x > a > -P > ==a = Z g > 1.1 -i w7je�*Qlq REVISIONS �..� DATE �� NC OWG. NO. GMK W SCALE 0 C Co cnc CV w E3 r 0 M c 0 F -j rn M C,> L wT, - Gft.-Ad & ri N SOA.-. W,y . <a„y M Bdp o 7 f.. I R 3 SEAL GONSLILTANi r 0 0 b z REVISIONS Y � DATE I 0 a DWG. NO. ;HK RW SCALE DRAY;iNG gig oo C V cpn �ti1 r � � x SEAL CONSULTANT R oo C V cpn �ti1 0 0CID 0- rn 0 m M v I M REVISIONS > U]Y DATE 11 0 DWG. NO. GHK RW SCALE jig S$b JOB NO. DRAWPJG SEAL I CONSULTANT P �Yp w [syn wn vB � �Eb CA o m zJILP x rpy C � JOB SEAL I CONSULTANT P �Yp „ n wn vB � �Eb CA o m C O y x a y O A REVISIONS r u DATES o Dwc. No. cnrc �R�n GALE C l m `-) F� < CO X17 3" o cf) m ii F igi 666 6 $$ V y z x ii SEAL CONSULTANT Q CJa Fry g g V y z x ?� SEAL CONSULTANT ii a G) M o� ;.I m o O 73 Z m M> cl Ca REVISIONS a�^u � T DATE IY lV 3 O 151 I D„�c. No. cnrc oewr scA�e RM11511pi dl dom�y IN Z ® m C m o m tt r tid C a y O ii 3 rt I f vo- 11L...1511-11INT _j LE-A J09 tt r tid C a y O ii 3 rt I f vo- 11L...1511-11INT _j LE-A rn"n Off/ ULo I D N En O I \ W CD m r :3> O Z7 L Z O O S O O Z r co O C� >.o 0 C 0 0 m WRIGHT WAY 9 N 0' 00' 00" E 175.00' 82 _ _ it i HIM 1101 fla _ mi'm , M� � 1 N I � b µ P � � r� • 7 e, m G, yc� pct AA ��p9q > m Z Q NN ��pNbo++ p n PP RaN psp� pZC pL>{ � g SS� "11��� 0 too -01"o C=) -� rn P P C c Y��. qqo �I n N — 0 0 .+ ;u Z r m D O CO m C= ® -n y tr1 FEASION5 �8� I O t�rJz �7fip rn CIO 41 Y JOB 110 aagl R 'iiv:- R2r.€ 34P� .lrlo. I.?.. � M-41119 -9 e ° 'so.Enacs9 ag6R�°g^g"gas€ 8;a es§'eg3'go$3 Sen °s= �$s;?'� s� • 3�s$j3 ;a a R•9ge�R g R g Rg9g SoyAoRo°�g%3 3361 � 3'g �v "�ao :se-.�• 9 $.•gig �' �. $�a R 5 '°; S r PIP tl�gi���uUrlpl��il c � r m C-' u, op. x * 7o Z CfJ I�j y0 0 N z O = O © © m �Z C). C rn o V` F� �" z CD ©My x - �. 1 N N o a r PIP tl�gi���uUrlpl��il II PIP tl�gi���uUrlpl��il II F6eY,N i t° � sa s• s�.=3 m .� asp `^�� �n3 a s3a3m`� Rsaa s g �a sava a �s gaR vat RR SO RB sB. §1 t$ji%�.s� JOHN h a2��se eQe$ a R gm�4a oBaR Y$a a R�R€Q33 3R 0R''s ��°3Ras3 Eg $4pOa $"Q Rq y ogg g�a'3R g%2% g% �� eR�4 Raa $39�� "F`. g ���acSQe30$g.Re�s. 4oasg SI3a 3Q=Q g e aS�o ,R �3�°@ 833Y RR3aeS.�ve s°"baa bso 3 ss� $ iE R -F R-�$^ B ?ate �9.Z xa°q'T;a9 3 8�gg 32' R3 ° es•Q $R 113 sR3 s� oo oe' g�32�3a34 �Am * �i nas78e 13�.eg3"g' q=Rd -%G SIB g 'n ; o.T 3 m ^� Rs02 9 a a^yg .'-•� r&n d' 3g$°� ;uS °3 o 3� N:_! SRR baa `� %•3 s R�$3 � $ aRF 3 aaa '""" � •� eR gdgS#$ s4 ;s� $$3's� � �jl-SO ^4R °a9 ;g^g.R_-a� q$ R•a:$a' Qg 93va Q 9 �$@-•e '39 R�g9 eR e•%' �.� 8R �9e$3• x'30 $;4 $g.e °�,q� 9�s� Sgg3eg'a3 �•°§°,§$�Y ga33�'3 �3 °� aBn r°- �� - a � °�•g 3R'e p ��._ m °"gSo3a 5.'R. _�R. �z V MINIMUM SAND, 4, 0Rgy�STgOAN�EI(FA7NLLO ALTERNATE FOR MACHINE INVERT EXCAVATION AND OVER EXCAVATION OMIT FOR 4 MACHNE I pp (111CAVA'n ���z q $$RI^s 08. �ZZ 20C� 5 > �F 4� MIR vel !F Om 8OD� 62 1,mnnZ gg o �gz zv� F$m my4 e on m� ill H' m� 9 9 —KIY AA s aor I.zs 0 m CD if G-) ri v � 177 — '? FF C p� ap [zA - CJ O :IL '4:I' n r II op. x * A F X N X N N N X �c = N z O = O v ' x 2 M$ r �m + pmm5 v Fi 4T c z o _ O m m x A x m g MINIMUM SAND, 4, 0Rgy�STgOAN�EI(FA7NLLO ALTERNATE FOR MACHINE INVERT EXCAVATION AND OVER EXCAVATION OMIT FOR 4 MACHNE I pp (111CAVA'n ���z q $$RI^s 08. �ZZ 20C� 5 > �F 4� MIR vel !F Om 8OD� 62 1,mnnZ gg o �gz zv� F$m my4 e on m� ill H' m� 9 9 —KIY AA s aor I.zs 0 m CD if G-) ri v � 177 — '? FF C p� ap [zA - CJ O :IL '4:I' n R R�4 'n 00 �I m v N O � n -I m ob.t c �3 a��i nc� � VIS O Xo A 'o i ` xN xm ap dd 7 .- — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — _ _ I I i LI o0o EI I = t= -p l w o n 7D mZ C po m w ca �I V • a < aw ■ 0 � O � � 0 oaF-1r] ❑oao❑ Joao ❑aaY-1 ❑ F 4 El -A o�o�o❑o�o�o�r�❑o�o�o� LI11DDDDDU1100110n0n0110000 0 00 �I m v N O � n -I oaF-1r] ❑oao❑ Joao ❑aaY-1 ❑ F 4 El -A o�o�o❑o�o�o�r�❑o�o�o� LI11DDDDDU1100110n0n0110000 0 V O m cn (D z mn Z Ern - - 13 NOVEMBER 2013 -� 0 ❑oo Sao I -Ing❑ -1nr� nn -Au❑ _=u _uw❑ DL o nnn 3 OVERALL SITE PLAN p SMITH RESIDENCE &�>n = 555 OLD SCHOOL RD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA - m SCALE: D 1- PLANTING -- — — — — — — — — — — — —— k+ - rN PLANTING III � I I +i I EI ��n R � I I ❑000❑ J� O=O o Lil I , F L I W -e I L I b. 00 —� 000 _ �= ' 0=1=0 I oO 000 � T,o PUNTING 1 CJ00 ° 00 r ! YY 00° oj 11 10011[[El[° °°°° °°�°�°°°°°°°° ------- --- - - - -- - - - —� -v © ) m v 0 17 1 r� mz C -�CAP, CX D 0 CD o _ b I ro — 4A.2r Z s---', m E. m 3 N Z ..me�qq PROPOSED HARDSCAPE AND '710UT PLAN N Tn'ump .1 n SMITH RESIDENCE n o D 5i5 OLD SCHOOL RD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA $ is NOVEMBER ams SCALE: d' -1-0- i i g yr E PLANTIHc e --- -- ------ g yr E PLANTIHc e --- -- ------ ER13 NOVETI A]013 T SCALE: 1--1W F--"- PROPOSED PLANTIING PLAN N SMITH RESIDENCE 5550LD SCHOOL RD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ER13 NOVETI A]013 T SCALE: 1--1W TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-19 Address: 2960 Polo Drive Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Level II Architectural/Site Plan Gross Lot size: 18,519 SF Zoning District: RS -C: GS Core Adjacent Residences: G/S-Bermuda Considered During Review: Owner: M/ M Nelson Grumney Agent: Mark Marsh and Keith Williams Modifications to landscape and hardscape. To permit a slight modification to both driveways, add paver bricks, and revise previously approved landscape design and materials. Effective Lot Area: 17,996 SF Proposed Height: N/ A Division 3. General Landscape Standards Staff Recommendation: Motion to Recommend Approval of a Level II Architectural/ Site Plan Review based on a finding that the proposed modification to both driveways, addition of paver bricks, and revisions to a previously approved landscape design meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: December 19, 2013 Action: Level II Architectural /Site Plan Review: Approved as requested. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information PART H. GENERAL INFORMATION ARPB File #_f " I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: MR. & MRS. NELSON GRUMNEY I.A.2. Project Address: 2960 POLO DRIVE, GULF STREAM I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: t e, / 2 / - %� 1,�, ! 2 O &V4 S�'J eg (Ov I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) REVISIONS TO APPROVED LANDSCAPE AND HARDSCAPE DESIGN I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: N/A Architectural Style: N/A 1.A.6. Check all that apply: XMArchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: N/A Type of Foundation: N/A B. Owner Information I.B.I . Owner Address: 2960 POLO DRIVE, GULF STREAM, FL I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: __314-7997)7700 Fax: J /q �-� I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: BRIDGES, MARSH & ASSOC. /NIEVERA WILLIAMS I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 VI I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o 1.C.4. Agent Signature: PALM BEACH, FL. 33480 // I/(/ - kOfficial Use Only Pre -App Date: PB Date: App Date: 7ecommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: Fax 832-1520 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? GULF STREAM CORE Ps -� III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ? Yom, No Explain: III.A.3. Is the project consistent witV e Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? aNo Explain: III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? EXISTING DRIVEWAYS III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage ON SITE b. Sanitary Sewer PUBLIC SEWER G. Potable water CITY T'Y d. Irrigation Water CCTV e. Electricity FP&L f. Telephone ATT g. Gas Fp h. Cable Television COMCAST III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) N/A PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes -(�(If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yeses (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes 90) (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 TG .vn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.6.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: _ IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 r z�i '� 0 cx C7 g m o�yo zo y �^ Rt aczi°»�''^ m m m03 oIN° N MOM slop^ 'II 09 50,z N D a� �y"D'zo= 0. >0 m2 \ yy X N mOZZ', fnD F2m�O O m CNo>zm „ =mDOZm m a oN g 0 Z F)Z D0 p w" 0{ omSm°C> c y m m 3N iii czizm vA. m C ZL1a�Nm cis ,EHT: Om N �m=N < ZD b D r- $g�«� o° N 0 m�OZ �Zm '-... DO N zDm C3 Im -qC -a nZ N. V7 9\h Q .T� ZmOcaIO�C x T;a Oo�mmZp�< 9 ,q••• Sma b N >,' z .. �i, Io C CVA D o oo9�aD `\�: z z mn v F jmo n o mm o C11 N 4saZo'" ' mo m N o 'og OI co D ii jog p SOUTH COVE 0 0 0 O Dc,czc'mT ON y j vaim�0 Tom v ��ON -yl� fmd Z-��iisyyO�ZyGIz�.��.[�� o.p-ai m�n��Z '�O lq �' M, n T m 4 w�tmZD pOo�O1 < rm m 0 o D m O O mm OOtm: ar", .. �ZO stliroq NDOrm y A. y > D O < V to A _ C 0 m Ro < " 0 m�yA;uS ,Oz m a My . m r z�i '� 0 cx C7 g m o�yo zo y �^ Rt aczi°»�''^ m m m03 oIN° N MOM slop^ 'II 09 50,z N D a� �y"D'zo= 0. >0 m2 \ yy X N mOZZ', fnD F2m�O O m CNo>zm „ =mDOZm m a oN g 0 Z F)Z D0 p w" 0{ omSm°C> c y m m 3N iii czizm vA. m C ZL1a�Nm cis ,EHT: Om N �m=N < ZD b D r- $g�«� o° N 0 m�OZ �Zm '-... DO N zDm C3 Im -qC -a nZ N. V7 9\h Q .T� ZmOcaIO�C x T;a Oo�mmZp�< 9 ,q••• Sma b N >,' z .. �i, Io C CVA D o oo9�aD `\�: z z mn v F jmo n o mm o C11 N 4saZo'" ' mo m N o 'og OI co D ii jog p SOUTH COVE 0 0 0 /NTRAGOA STA �A L T. O0 moo�w�m Gl' .am�CZGI.. mcoo mW< a m H �. Z-��iisyyO�ZyGIz�.��.[�� o.p-ai m Sa _ a, M, n T m Z.�y '0='2�r�ry '��oo amn N in n m O O mm OOtm: ar", .. �ZO stliroq N O:;u y A. y > .!0 ..=5 _ C 0 m Ro < " 0 m�yA;uS ,Oz m 0100a -, q My . m 61 a 9 mtm -•mm p 1m o"'o - no a29 5 aO xd nc <-o.wm-,+ o yar c 3 K a -060woo gx"MCH OOma 50. c.. m m —PEM ZO= . o cH>0>0m m� v 3 °,049089 0�� o 0 m B a A y Zo �t .p 'OOZo'Or1� 0��-y O.Z.{{ - iswma�'v -i Ol''Op_O ! .0 �mW yOm Nm T m;!oN Z�o U OAC F.0 0 9-rii-l�m..> 'i -orifi m oma, X0-,5 °o�Q o> r gA m mi R opg C3 m CD ED �G� fn /NTRAGOA STA �A L m 2 '� SOUTH COVE a $� 100.00'$ N. 05' 45' 00" E. x xl -pS x x� x 161 0 All • 0 1 '' ���� �•c��l� it 11 6m v v o-- - ------------------- " mc, ----- --------- ------------------------------------ -------------------- ------- ------ ---------- g POLO DRIVE o g x ■ P � � N �P Z i g 6 b �iPWW 2 tl 080 qq Q j y Sq9. a q q g1 now PP q q � Q3 Sid p �p p C) C m G Q _ ma � RE•!!SIUd3 n DAT[ I f f CHKCOME] . DR ro U1 5 P.. �� o _ o n� cn 62 I LL Z� o Q` o m N �T m CCD ®C= =� m Go e d a T y N A � � � A O LANDSCAPE PLAN p�p Ia � Oen G F me i4D Y Z� o Q` o m N �T m CCD ®C= =� m Go N e d a T y N v i m o � A O LANDSCAPE PLAN A m b D n D D a.gmo6; D o O a wowd y O a h O a96o POLO DRIVE. GULF STREAM, FLORIDA m m a E 3 O 14 NOVEMBER 2013 SCALE:,/B'•1'-0' y FS Qr Nwk co N I LANDSCAPE PLAN c D —I a.gmo6; Z GRUMNEY RESIDENCE o m wowd WgUD h O a96o POLO DRIVE. GULF STREAM, FLORIDA m m 3 O 14 NOVEMBER 2013 SCALE:,/B'•1'-0' y i Q Z a a" m LANDSCAPE PLAN A c^ p �` M 0 ° m g° z �- Z S4CS i4 o u uD3, 2960 POLO DRIVE, GULF STPEAM. FLOPIDA z s ti� En 0 ® <,n A cry +P Z a a" m LANDSCAPE PLAN A c^ p �` -o; GRUMNEY RESIDENCE ° z w g° z �- Z o u uD3, 2960 POLO DRIVE, GULF STPEAM. FLOPIDA z s S o 14 NOVEMBEP 2013p SCALE: 1/e'. Y -o' y 1 � f 3 D Do M Z pz < m SCALE, 1/8'. Y•0' y m 93 LANDSCAPE PLAN oIx as ° s i E C:�Z GRUMNEY RESIDENCE R m mac' -�. CSt Y �� a CD r'3 o_ u�► , p _ Z— 3 CJ4 14 N0VEMBER 2013 T 7— �w F 3 D Do M Z pz < m SCALE, 1/8'. Y•0' y m 93 LANDSCAPE PLAN oIx as ° s i E C:�Z GRUMNEY RESIDENCE � m—1. Cl u u n Y 296° POLO DRIVE. GULF STREAM, FLORIDA O 3 k 3 14 N0VEMBER 2013 3 D Do M Z pz < m SCALE, 1/8'. Y•0' y TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-20 Address: 1465 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/ M Steven Silverman Agent: Bridges, Marsh & Associates/Mark Marsh Install driveway pillars and entry gate N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To permit the installation of new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate. Issues Considered During Review: Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Motion to approve a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to install new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate. ARPB Date: December 19, 2013 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as requested. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM ® RECEIVE[ v j. NOV 2 2 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # 3 To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information [.A. 1. Project/Owner Name: Mr R Mrc St -Allo„ Silverman I.A.2. Project Address:. 1491; NT Ocean 21_Vd ' Gulf Stream Fr 31483-- I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See a a h d I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) New driveway Ailars & iron enfry gate I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: n/a Architectural Style: n/a 1.A.6. Check all that apply: XMrchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures 0 Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: n/a Type of Foundation: Stem Wall B. Owner Information I.B.1, Owner Address: 1465 No. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, FL 3348 I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: 561-241-16 I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information ax: I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: Bridges, Marsh & As socia tes / Mark March I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 Viaklizner, Palm Beach FL 33480 LC.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) 5 '1 . 3 2. 1 3 (c**el�56 .5 7 3 .9 Fax ~ F32 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: .11(6-A- , LA ) Icial Use Only Date: emendation: —1)zs=)_3 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? Beach Front District /l. c�_ r III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ? Yes No Explain: Meets all applicable criteria III.A.3. Is the project consistentth the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? Yes No Explain: Consistent with land use requirements III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Existing driveway III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage on site b. Sanitary Sewer septic c. Potable water City d. Irrigation Water C', ty e. Electricity P PR,r f. Telephone TRT g. Gas T: PTT h. Cable Television III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) n/a PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? � No (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? YesNo (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? YesNo (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes No (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 6--vn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? None IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: Revising existing driveway and replicating original qate pillars. IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AIA Landscape Enhancement Project? n IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 ® RECEIVEI"=: NOV 2 2 Z Town of Gulfstream;; bESCRIPTIOM JA PARCEL OF LAND IN SEC770N 10, TOWNSMP 46 SOU77i RANGE 43 EAST, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, MORE PAR77CLKARL Y DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS BEGINMNG AT A POINT IN TI -E WEST UNE OF LOT 4 BLOCK D, REVISED PLAT OF BLOCKS D AND E, PALM BEACH SHORE ACRES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 7, PAGE 38, PUBLIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, A T A DISTANCE OF 82 FEET SOUTHERL Y (WASHED A T RIGHT ANGLES) FROM THE NORTH UNE OF SAID LOT x THENCE SOUTHERL Y ALONG T E WEST LINE OF SAID LOT 1 AND LOT 2 OF SAID BLOCK D, A DISTANCE OF 6801 FEET, MORE OR LESS: TO A POINT IN A LINE PARALLEL TO, AND 150 FEET SOUTIE (MEASURED AT RIGHT ANGLES) FROM THE NORTH LII\E OF SAID LOT t TF7al E EASTERLY PARALLEL TO 77-E NORT LINE OF SAID LOT I A DISTANCE OF 208.55 FEET TO A CONCRE_ TE M MAf7VT SET IN THE GROUND; 71E CE NORTI AT RIGHT ANGLES ,TO '77Ef PRECEDING COURSE; A DISTANCE OF 1249 FEET TO THE CENTER OF THE WEST END OF MASONRY WALL, THENCE EASTERLY PARALLEL TO THE NORTH UNE OF SAID LOT 1 -AND ALONG THE CENTER UNE I SAID WALL AND ALONG AID TROUGH THE PARTY WALL OF A BULDM CONSTRUCTED NORTH AND SOUTH OF SAID LINE, A DISTANCE OF 165.38 FEET TO A CONMETE MOV"ENT; THENCE CONTINUE ALONG THE SAME COURSE, A DISTANCE OF 64 FEET, MORE OR LESS, TO 77-E WATERS OF 77-E A77 -ANTIC OCEAN,• THENCE NORTHERLY ALONG 7T WATERS OF THE ATLANTIC OCEAN TO A POINT IN SAID UNE; PARALLEL TO AND 82 FEET SOUTH OF THE NORTH L OF SAID LOT 1; Th ENL • WESTERL Y ALONG SAID PARALLEL UNE, A DISTANCE OF 70 FEET, MORE OR LESS, TO A CONCRETE MOM 0VT; TH9,CE- CON77AVE ALONG THE SAME COL RSE WESTERL Y, A DISTANCE OF 170.38 FEET TO,, CONCRETE MOMA ENT,- THENCE :CCNTIMIE ALONG 77-E SAME COURSE WESTD1 Y, A DISTANCE OF 20225 FEET TO POINT OF BEGINMNG. BELINMNG AT A POINT ON 77E WEST FACE OF TSE FOOTINGS OF A MASONRY WALL IN A UNE PARALLEL TO, AND FEET SOUTH OF, MEASL#?ED AT RIGHT ANGLES, TO Tl -E NORTH LIFE OF LOT 4 BLOCK D, REVISED PLAT OF BLOCK.` ALD E, PALM BEA CH 94ORE ACRES ACCORDING TO 77-E PLA T 77-ER60F, RECORDED IN PLA T BOOK 7, PAGE 38, Pb RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID POINT BEING 199.65 FEET, MEASURED ALONG SAID PARALLEL & EASTERLY OF THE WEST UNE OF LOT 2 OF SAID BLOCK D, THSINCE CONTAUNG EASTERLY ALONG SAID PARALLEL 8.9 FEET, MORE OR LESS, TO A CONCRETE MOMANENT,- 77ENCE NOR7IE:1Y, AT RIGHT ANGLES, TO THE LAST DES COL#?SE, 1249 FEET TO THE 09RERLM OF A MASONRY WALL; REYCE' WESTERL Y, ALONG 77-6 CENTERUAE OF E MASONRY WALL, 89 FEET, MORE OR LESS TO 77-E WEST FACE OF 77-,E FOOTINGS OF A MASONRY WALL, THENCE SOUTHERLY, ALONG THE WEST FACE OF 77-E F0077NGS OF SAID MASONRY WALL, 1249. -FEET TO THE POINT OF BL c 4� ;az 3° v m c� 0 W <ENzRR��y �'Fe R> R, R f8 �€mA6 A.'PIv A Qm m�vr 4 3 C17 'T1 C� 0 Y/ m �l�l�ll I� I �I a�- ml � it A Z e� P.6 i ® M i m G') n Dm I Nd co �o P CD w w m I gR [L R $ � I --�__-,t t Tt VA q LINE_ --�-_� _0 A T L A N T I C O C E A N ._ C Z Z z c o d H >y m f a s H Z � _ 0 Y/ m 516N. R tv JuE r;n. [-tAWFNG Jog SEAL G]i:SN.TAt1T n �l�l�ll I� I �I a�- ml � I Z e� P.6 i ® M i m G') n Dm I co �o i CD w w m I gR i I � I --�__-,t t Tt VA q LINE_ --�-_� A T L A N T I C O C E A N 516N. R tv JuE r;n. [-tAWFNG Jog SEAL G]i:SN.TAt1T n �l�l�ll 516N. R tv JuE r;n. [-tAWFNG Jog SEAL G]i:SN.TAt1T n E i �t ^ UENI REVISIONS DWGNOSCALE FE 1 SEAL CONSULTANT i: 3 m11111-4 GG fir ! tt� �a100K6� ,1zi 6 R 1T�� E ILL -- o m SEAL CONSULTANT m11111-4 -v o m CD m N o m -4 SEAL CONSULTANT s LFLF rZ MUM 88Nps�qi 50 o . m m CD C:) m ry A ATLANTIC OCEAN y Loy Ln g l c Z b IN � m MUM 88Nps�qi 50 o . m m CD C:) m ry A ATLANTIC OCEAN y Robert W. Ganger 1443 North Ocean Blvd Gulf Stream, FL 33483 December 17, 2013 TO THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW & PLANNING BOARD Re: Gate at 1465 North Ocean Boulevard This is in response to notification that Dr. and Mrs. Silverman will be presenting photographs or drawings of the antique gate they propose to install at the entrance to their restored home next door to our house on North Ocean Boulevard. I have seen a photo of the gate, and as long as it is within design and dimension codes for a Gulf Stream entrance feature, my wife and I believe it will make an impressive statement as one enters a beautifully restored and lushly landscaped property. Hopefully, Dr. Silverman or his agent will provide information on the provenance of the gate, which we understand was discovered in Europe. As the original homes in Gulf Stream are restored, the ARPB should be sensitive to the authenticity of design and materials. A "before and after" on the Silverman property would be a welcome contribution to the Town's historical records. Since2nneli Bob ager TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-21 Owner: Maria T Bonilla/Joaquin Grillo Address: 335 Old School Road Agent: Self Proposed Improvement: Convert existing garage to living space and two new additions consisting of 487 SF garage and 668 SF new living space and a 174 SF lanai. Approvals Requested: Level II Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 SF garage and 668 SF of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 SF lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single family dwelling being 1,329 SF, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added. Gross Lot Size: 24,895 SF Effective Lot Area: 24,895 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 4,492 SF Allowable: 7,565 SF Zoning District: RS -C FFE: 7.5' NGVD Considered During Review: Height: Existing Note: This application was sent to Urban Design Kilday Studios for review. A copy of their findings is attached. Section 70-67. Effective lot area. Section 70-71. Floor area ratios. Section 70-74. Setbacks. Section 70-100. Roof and eave heights. Section 70-187. Table of District Standards Recommendations: Motion to approve Level II Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 SF garage and 668 SF of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 SF lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single family dwelling being 1,329 SF, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: December 19, 2013 Action: Level II Architectural/ Site Plan Review: Approved as recommended. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM too- RECEIVED t NOV 19 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: �'� Gro I.A.2. Project Address: � � C b I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: LdT CO GM. V IS1 t.0L �.�°tiGfl .v I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) -IVIhJjy -� �IVII�G I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: 1321 Architectural Style: _ fm"y Vt4 1.A.6. Check all that apply: 6'Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: -7.6' Type of Foundation: MONuLIV)L, B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: _3_'3�5 (D 1.1711-11) -SZ� CU I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: _ S� I-- -(-1- 9,9 0109 Fax: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: I.C.2. Agent Address: I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o 1_C.4. Agent Signature: cell Fax Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ? es No Explain: %sst-A- I4W_atALS -fo 66 ttS�D WIGL JKA-2}a Iztol)o— D fS% b.J III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? es No Explain: III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? J14 -ad/ 1 p -a aX15 101-- 0 P 0 ILL -P-F-_AAv 3 90 -j Ar III.A.5. How are the following utilities being provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage_ CIVIL- 'Pj A)J WILL W plyd V FOO b. Sanitary Sewer _ CK i 5Tlo (,, c. Potable water EXI,yr,iJlr d. Irrigation Water CX 1 S77N E e. Electricity Ex I ,;rr'in! [r f. Telephonexibi��.l Lr g. Gas h. Cable Television Exi5�7n?h III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) 6N EiEf PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve I d area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes @ (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? YesNo (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes No (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes No (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page February 2002 PRECISION DRAFTING & DESIGN lu 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOMON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 Phone: Office (561) 733-0669 Cell (561) 936-9236 FAX: (561) 733-0673 November 18, 2013 Re: Bonilla / Grillo residence 335 Old School RD Gulf Stream, FL 111. A. 6. The primary addition, which includes the new AC/living area and the new garage, will blend seamlessly with the existing home. Roof material, roof pitch, stucco finish, and paint will match the existing. When the addition is completed it will appear as though it was built at the time of the original construction. The secondary structure (lanai) will implement the design of the existing flat roofed breakfast room. All materials used will match including fascia size, stucco finish, and paint. Both structures will be constructed of concrete block and tie beam. DECEIVED NOV 19 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FI. PRECISION DRAFTING & DESIGN 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 Phone: office (561) 733-0669 Cell (561) 436-9236 FAX: (561) 733-0673 November 18, 2013 Re: Bonilla / Grillo residence 335 Old School RD Gulf Stream, FL 111. A. 6. The primary addition, which includes the new AC/living area and the new garage, will blend seamlessly with the existing home. Roof material, roof pitch, stucco finish, and paint will match the existing. When the addition is completed it will appear as though it was built at the time of the original construction. The secondary structure (lanai) will implement the design of the existing flat roofed breakfast room. All materials used will match including fascia size, stucco finish, and paint. Both structures will be constructed of concrete block and tie beam. ls�- RECEIVED, NOV 19 2013 Town of Gulfstream, R memorandum TO: William Thrasher Town Manager FROM: Marty R.A. Minor, AICP DATE: November 25, 2013 PROJECT NAME: 335 Old School Road UDKS PROJECT #: 94-012.019 urban design ki I dad Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics Urban Design Kilday Studios has reviewed the proposed addition of an approximately 1,783 square feet (SF) to the existing single family home located at 335 Old School Road for the relocation of the garage, the creation of two bedrooms, one mudroom and a lanai. After providing initial comments in our October 29, 2013 memorandum on the proposed request, the applicant has revised the building elevations to address the previous comments. In the previous memorandum, the location of the rear lanai was determined to be inconsistent with the "simple rectilinear form" of Gulf Stream Bermuda style homes. This determination was made because the proposed lanai was 4 feet, 4 inches offset from the adjacent house wall location. In the latest architectural plans provided to the Town, the proposed lanai in the backyard of the lot has been reduced in size and has been aligned the house's western wall. As such, the proposed lanai is now consistent with the characteristics of the Gulf Stream Bermuda architectural style. Recommendation With the revised building plans submitted to the Town, we can recommend approval for the proposed change. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 1119 ,r �p 00"5l o 0 r O � N 00°0000" E �tl I60.00' m D m z i a t r P ,_ 0. K r'l D, a: z z� n i^'m<F n t z <• �i n 9 m KPWo Dr Jtrtg n Cl ❑ Ox r_ > okand tR 1; . a Z NN c nmT RU rD M O�r� vd w i N �Q 45.2' o a 1119 ,r �p 00"5l o 0 r O � N 00°0000" E �tl I60.00' m D m z WELLINGTON, FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION • W6 PH, 561-153.3431 FAX, 5641933438 ee B� R o z z� n i^'m<F n Z. rtrty N t �i n 9 m TI ni tr] Cl ❑ Ox r_ 14f1 A.-Wol39 3419 ,gl•LL GEIP 3NI-1 >DV'9139 3418 ,5'YL rD M O�r� I> rZ m j N �Q 45.2' o voo bD $ $ n ID ,L•4Y O'91 D $\ N _ dill -y 0'91 52.5' �A mp my m O mE T< ,,: LI A ------------- "� I- 0 LO 0 d D rim U3 z A LO Qt NmN %d N _+ O 0 NOS r N O z r b z bm vm — A O m u z m ax p E 6'LI o®`,' §°y D - D i m odor p 13 c $$ o W - -, 7O 10.5' CD cm PTS 40.0' O 'C UM M Qp/v D m O U yQ� iii iii � C'' Bap n� nu O Z m (p\ pD/O N/ p�aD YP `i 41 zOD lD z r z � 71 O (l m m N m 0 •p ,r �p o 0 v 40.1' CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING OWNER / DE51GNER B. DAVID FRANK WELLINGTON, FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION • W6 PH, 561-153.3431 FAX, 5641933438 ,5'64/ NXI N '„lll,r� cml i^'m<F T�.to t TI ni tr] Cl ❑ Ox r_ 14f1 A.-Wol39 3419 ,gl•LL rD M O�r� I> rZ m z N �Q o voo bD n ID =� _ dill cA M �A mp m O mE T< T "� I- LO D O z y03 Tb' o®`,' odor c o - -, 7O CD cm PTS 0 -4 z O 'C —;; MO m �R CT p 'til e� L'-' 0 o 0 v GULF STREAM, FLORIDA CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING OWNER / DE51GNER B. DAVID FRANK WELLINGTON, FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION • W6 PH, 561-153.3431 FAX, 5641933438 '- m cml i^'m<F T�.to m z N o n ID AD BD PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: BONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD PRECISION DRAFTING AND DESIGN INC 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 AIBD CERTIFIED PROFESSIONAL BUILDING DESIGNER STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: W. ERIK GENZ (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) FL STATE REG' 33138 13938 CRANBERRY COURT GULF STREAM, FLORIDA CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING OWNER / DE51GNER B. DAVID FRANK WELLINGTON, FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION • W6 PH, 561-153.3431 FAX, 5641933438 AD BD g3 "e cl Z$ � D 0 Ia ND eQ ul �W 8 A O O 3 O X O � n O �J z� <Q z _ cZ Z N A D Z 3 3 8 -------- ---- �sQ aQ i r� D � z i - � n s " W 01 0 W A � W 30 Ki 70 uz a 'u �m i L I 0A 8$ b EQ pp w _P NNii � RI T��B W c .W y 3 g' 3'�" 3'.4' Z 3•-y' Oy b I-'• 3 y - 21 S 19 u u y. y. 6' L - b'-loh• �nily y"g 11 4 " s mm 38 s 38 o v �n F ----------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------- 10-0" -045' G 15-2" o may;• D y' OL O ; I 16 A $$$ m Of co-waG CD C= < � m A U BD N v 0 v 34 VISTA DFL RIO, 50YNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33476 W. ERIK GENZ BONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD cu z 0`o r m m > o m z` X � Eo W m F' A U1 = m - F-� O to igil-ni A U BD PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: PRECISION DRAFTING AND DESIGN INC STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: 34 VISTA DFL RIO, 50YNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33476 W. ERIK GENZ BONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD SOUTH COUNTY (561) 218-3038 AMD CERiIFim PROFESSIONAL WILDING OEDKaNER STATE REG • 33138 13 13938 CRANBERRY COURT GULF STREAM FLORIDA CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING WELLINGTON, FLORIDA CPHTIFICATE OF AUTNORIW-153 •]6154 OWNER / DESIGNER B. DAVID FRANK PH, %1-15}3431 FA%, %I-i5}343D A U BD I I 1� 1� i IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII II' IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII SSSS I iii■ _ SSSS �► SSSS SSSS■■ ■■■..■ ��_�■ SSSS ������ . � ������ .IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII i IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I - I ee�e1 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII .IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ��e■� NONE Iii ■MEMEME MEMO■ ■E■■ ■ ■■■E ■ eeeel ecce NEES NEMS eeeel ecce ■NN■ ■ SEEN IN ■■E■ ■_ NEON IN ME ii NNE iMOM ...... IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII .SSSS■ .....■ I I SSSS■. SSSS■. - ■I�����aii ■I����i�7i • I I I m■■■■ I■n I el■■■■Nei er- =_ —] (-_ _] 11���� 1■11 11���� ■11 11■■■■!'All 11■■■■�■11 1111;■�� ����■11■�� 0 SSSS ■III ■'■■ ■II N■■■• NEON, • =_—__� J 11ENEW 11■i■i�� Ili�e■i�ll �■_■_ . I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 911111111111111111111111111 • ■11 IN mom ■■■■� SSSS mei el���e■ Nei ■�-M LT_-_=-■oei ��--==1�ei SSSS SSSS lel ie�� IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII SSSS■■ i SSSS■■ ..IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 'IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII SSSS■■ _ SSSS■■ � ■�■� SSSS SSSS SSSS■■ ■ SSSS■■ SSSS ■■�■ MINNIE SSSS■■ ■ -SSSS■■ _■■■■ SSSS_ SSSS■■ ■ SSSS■■ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII SSSS■■ ■ ■■■■■■ SSSS■■ SSSS■■ I � SSSS■■ SSSS■■ I SSSS■■ SSSS■■', SSSS■■ SSSS■■ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII SSSS■■ SSSS■■, - - — - SSSS■■ SSSS■■ ■■■� ■■■M SSSS■■ SSSS■■ IM■ NIM ■■ ■m SSSS■■ SSSS■■ , i ,IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII r ecce■ ecce■ a • ° u r u u 0 0v PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: o v o W. ERIK GENZ SONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 a Fnm 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD m 0 a z GULF STREAM FLORIDA om WELLINGTON, FLORIDA GPHOF 41tN • 26184 OWNER / DESIGNER B. DAVID FRANK PN.. %1•Ti 561 -TE }343'1 F ' 5ATION A%%I-l5}3438 n o m m A N !n N m w ��U77I AJU BD PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: PRECISION DRAFTING AND DESIGN INC STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 W. ERIK GENZ SONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 FL STATE REG • 33138 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD 416D CERTIFIED PROFESSIONAL BUILDING DESIGNER 13938 CRANBERRY COURT GULF STREAM FLORIDA CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING WELLINGTON, FLORIDA GPHOF 41tN • 26184 OWNER / DESIGNER B. DAVID FRANK PN.. %1•Ti 561 -TE }343'1 F ' 5ATION A%%I-l5}3438 AJU BD Mid N m b z N' ."A I LJ 0 - T m m m r FEEI � - b z LL o 7 r� N Ell IF rnC) m N m 0 10 rn CD o w ®v C PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: SONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE PRECISION DRAFTING AND DESIGN INC 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 ASO CERTIFIED PROFESSIONAL BUILDING DESIGNER FL STATE REG • 33138 13938 CRANBERRY COURT GULF STREAM, FLORIDA CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING OWNER / DESIGNER B. DAVID FRANK D n m D n Fm7;-o,'L. m z m< to ol PROPOSED ADDITION FOR: SONILLA/GRILLO RESIDENCE PRECISION DRAFTING AND DESIGN INC 34 VISTA DEL RIO, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33426 NORTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 133-0669 STRUCTURAL ENGINEER - W. ERIK GENZ (GENZ ENGINEERING INC.) 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD SOUTH COUNTY ( 561 ) 218-3038 ASO CERTIFIED PROFESSIONAL BUILDING DESIGNER FL STATE REG • 33138 13938 CRANBERRY COURT GULF STREAM, FLORIDA CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR NEW HOMES - ADDITIONS - REMODELING OWNER / DESIGNER B. DAVID FRANK WELLINGTON, FLORIDA CVtTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION • 2654 PH, 561-153.3431 FAX, 86H'®3-3490 AD BD i rn r rn W w 000o mo$ ;o 0 m ,00'S L J m m 45.2' m r m I cn N 00'00'00" E 160.00' r m m Fn N � � C4 tzj < X II b C4 y � O D Z W �� mn O C O n p O 2 � z r- m m Ci < M P o x m m r- �� t < w < O N m r m n � cn in \ ,£•t L r m N � � C4 tzj < X II b C4 y � O ' Zm ,6'L L ` 1 r M N W Ul 40.0' m m N Ln N m O m N OD r n 0�n m Z 70.6 70.5' v W rn I m m x m < I W N W x m m < X II Z h O X O n p O m x z r- m m Ci < m P o x m m r- �� t < w < O N W& p I � J !A rn 0 m I I v z m J Fo A m OD Xl= 1 �� 1 �x n vrn(AM N -Di -i (fA Na o00 m20 z= / < b C '� I ` < t O � m D m Nz - - / --�- m W D m ,��- D < rr--� u _�- inm= w W � I h � ` - - (j� tT Tr0 S com y ( _ D.Z� m D �v _{� C 1 �- gym s �Y� rl G7 In � � � � min D x:00 m m 2E �Z� mDY �D DITI _nrnmo b� D�z NN � bbn��a�'v oPg D m Qo-r1 r MZ_ r — O inmyy, D<n 1 ;n 000 DN �rC� N N �N N II N II N II II N 11 N 11 N 11 II N II N II N mmo Cm _9 O a 'u4QTozz2A v�vfv*1 222 rnmx r_ Fri �0D V z Z vozz�i�zm<zm>ORO <r- M O -u -'ON P,9 ammoD-�yoozorr�vv >9'�A�i�c� mM �•If*I N00 C v "®i -a�irl +imm 3E£�m mC= r� v II Z o m Q No O o C)nm�0 rn II cND> Q O D Z ��2 I_' z j �Zg Z� > m � o cn �I Z d cn ® C "1 D ZO cD m z a m m rn O NCal � �'R NO ^ z 1900 m y y to v O ITB wCOP) ? z 0 0 `� w CID N<m m m 2 � v T �➢ 2 O m 00* 2-00 v < m < < Z x 1*1 N ;u > m vr- I 00* 2-00 v m < < Z x 0 mvv II {- ^? �Z.1�a m z �m z i m o w ,00.91 N 00'00'00" E 160.00' �L—_ / I m r m r M m „ rm- h mz I m M C N O N <z w m ? y� r� cn w o0 �� I �!oIci z gM =1-1 m to z-0 Na0 -r FO— I- cnm � o 3NIl HUV813S SUIS ,S— -- I 45.2• r I I I Fl v h I< ,0'8l 52.5• F I I I iA i.. a >F ' I nXZ o I = a z'�O O O I - I' m I � I S I O O z 1 '' CA o ��' o IA z o C1 j tdI o I LTJ r I r- n I m _ C) I I o m m If m DC7 C1 I NI m / I c I o„ I m II i M I 6'L , l i Fn I w N D N 10 ml N \ II" < u (0Fn I a, W ,S 6ti 70.5' A I 40.0• D . ID 0 O -0 I m Fn I N a 0 N < I I 0 0�„\ I zv w n 0 ( 0 W /1 N z w I \ 40.1' ,S'fi4 a, I � CD :\\ o � ` � — ---- S 3U15 g � tl m m cg c'' Vn j I — 3Ni1 c,, (n o FnM a n a PIC , o0 m w m ao 0 F1 II om ;0;0 < zn n cr .60 I m v % 'Va3 I cwiiZ _�'` _� � r, m M *1 ro uD w , it _ EA�z °Q cnm= N M. < I p w _ �� � n '� u!Fn0 cY C co ' v n r� c ) w 05E o IC .meq m D m v m C ' — 0_a rr1. 4 iue Z r r Z Ij MEW N ??AZ cC n m D ; n D in ma -I <m o DDZ ;m Ornm gfrn*1, M> < 0Z� Zmq k' �1 e mD2 y Dm m ._L1 n00 mAvvvzzz- m ors000> G7 C) �1�p �Z3� ;SII ob0 i>a�D�omg b=m rmp D� DpZ c7 ", Mx nmvin i<n -i in O rl r riZ- 071y �—. o 00� DN ��� I, r� i'" ��- nnm�illuana"nnnnnnpOnNuen� 0 mO�O CDS �-q cn' 4 �' 00 >QQTozziq-n0p0�znS�c�$a r r ti^ z zz �� rnm �rn OD Z ( i �v�icziln S a-iyarr-mmzooDMc�22o <rr'irn �m N �p �` C i?� mmiFi� 1 �^��,mU1��`�m �1�n^il=>,,MR x rm+ z r it II ;° z �. c) m j �--� ? P g a r. i ' Z � _ � �> 0 O D 1V C -< mz n m o Ocn CD G "� /�� zz� an m� z N 'o m R r - r ''- ] y . ''' z 0 0 rnco -zi � C�o�+ LA m rri p O O =1 Oo (� N v CL OD < CO LU St°z r*Im o M 00� D� na)Zm� o 2>-n OOM Z -p R�ZD M� AMO zrm M><m D� -mom m� 00ZW DO rn �nED<e -o-0Om rno W� 5�zz �O Sjrr(n o �Z D om mi 0 FI C: oo� 0 O z0. C)m m D2C ZO -oZZX-riO0 Z .Oo�� o`" 22cp3p m> OC D� �Zo KZ Lr) ZM mor �d 0m In � O N ro C:2 fl' w T r- oo> M OX DO IV 70m m E m W = O mr-0. Om OZDfJ::J COMD -U. T- z -< � (1) 0 ccs 10ZF N m � O D D r �c zjm- r O�0-uD D C D D D � Z Fl D O m. Z D c D D z C)m m U) D O m O D Z z r � r D D m N r 0 C7 0 z D Z N 00 (a Gn In O c D m m m O (n D C) m V) 0 X m O r m N m�0 -u O r O gym= m0< mZ. D Dm 0-'(n cmc ZOco 00 < r- W Z X -p - 0 D > DfOrin n c -,O W O Z 00 �O cM mm rr nD �I n� xx � 0 ooMOO- o 2m2Nm CLO �Mm2x zoOD ?n�m0 m � mD r-�-jo C Z�p i -i Z� D m O -n U) q� >0 Ln K>0 U) �m DXOjj-j ms 00 (A K_ ori z �O� 0 c j� ZX0(LOf*1 f�1 0 --�� mm MM D0Zr�1� �LI)o tm OD ��mrn� mCDO m Ln mo -D Z I Tt"c T 0:'z-;U:� m�;;gym O J E�D;u j� 0 Booz m IN DR ESTgCI- fill�� n n fN m a o m n �• (iJ M XC X OJ W 'rvm� n � m p N 00'00'00" E w 11 w _ N I O I CJl m O m O m I11 ;uvv {. I O cn m /I r+ ,OO'S L m p N 00'00'00" E 160.00' m "-3 CJl m m rrl D A m m r r m ' u r- < < II n < II vi in mz2 n N Z N y II A m m Z rn D z zm y w =1 -f m w w bo x W OA / ,OO'S L N 00'00'00" E 160.00' r m m m m r r m ' I I < II n < II vi < II ( _ II D I o rn D z w y w =1 -f m r to z 0 w bo x W OA r w� I cc! z F-4 t'- D0 cnm /N tp m O \ '— a 3NIl NOV813S MIS ,S'*Z �—fir — — --— — — — — — — — — - 45.2' I .09L I y m - ,Z'bb to F9 J I ,0.9L 52.5' I I rn m I� I I ( w " T 1 m I n Z m C) I nI o C) I < I O I I\ hj I o r x I O O n Z I cn� o b o O I Z I c �7 c0 c y r r m( _ cn O r I O c m I ZI CZ7 O �' I '^ < " m �' , i < 0� Zd ,, I" Cl o II �+ _ cn I _ �m� / rC�7 I O m j v I {� m I a I R .6-L Lm m rrt I I O I r� n < I N \ C z m I Im I� I R I< N I I 1 w 0o I 70.5' I 40.0' I I` n T oO � m v; I� w v m g w `, I o< I Iom\ " 11 z� m w o \ I � 40.1' I ' S'6b _ a:p_ - - L' lZ �_ m =� i m o a) D j _ `3N11 KOdel3S 3415 ,9 `_ h �- y _ _ w n Ln o0 I m L--- N \mZX 'ern z r n om CA i " _ I F- < w mmn M mnn < w in r7 y m z z a 2 rs X <ZC) II 1 r�* w L4 - `--- O \ M> 1 O/ z�� �' O I rm �o \_-- 'tl03 �z m u � _ r' _�--- _!- II �� z m r rn < rn rn m <z p r - - _ _ �r7 `��+7��L�7 (� L4 cn MM cn r o < m cUl Ya N C O m mm O D 0 > Z -p zxrm oz� nz mD - -mow..---- rrT�i Z� a m aim � rZ n Zw N O � = mLO �7-u WD> A X cn OJ C) m =� 0 WOTI <m mr p m= O Om LnXz M > U) �m --I < m O z a7 >m cm z ;l -uzzz S _9mm > ODS n�O --Im -ice C)Ov SII xW'OT--girl OOn ��.p9 9 ore r7a 0n ==m O r O -1 jo n ao 'v to D< n yi in m Qo0 Dcn �>-� c, p Im'0.ZOI C> >�Z c') > ADg9T9zzpgR DyZ2Cm nr�*I�()�OD OZ mm <F �m OD Az *1zZ-I10pZZ; MCOO A-p0O���-I�j,*'n fOSrZ77�7 -m ,r -I II << O -u 112 X -` ON N O Ul Z C r 2000 i�nr r -i* ZOrr I r^rn nm fig@ '� m m mC=mrd* zr II II N D (D -1p 2 r�m�O�Ex y�r�rno mZN = Fjionm C)> '2 co O D Z y �z j n m m o (Ji J 0 ZD O m CO D® z 2� a moo m En O O N y `"' CA mr. O 0 m m I C) N v N 00'00'00" E 160.00' off., y M� BA911 f `- --- rr r O n I T-1 0n O XCD z O �m I o Oz x D T< X p z I m fTl �1 m Zm O o p D I ? z o m m ti Z o AA zr ci A m m m < f �m etivl o / \ D ID O o 0 o ( ( ) \\\ll zm z m o ZD � alb BASIN R003 J I � m AQ--- - D b t -y u J N SCALE AS SHOWN JOB If 13-3106 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD SITE DRAINAGE PLAN GULF STREAM, FLORIDA m°^ O A 9Q z m s og""� �ZODm 0= m gR4 � m y 0, ��e ADA"m D O O L7 sgy n O N2F i�,h�a y 2 5q St � 9 4 4 go � r r qq VJ C7 _ C O � COO J z> 8 ;u zi ic� O V v/ 1 u J N SCALE AS SHOWN JOB If 13-3106 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD SITE DRAINAGE PLAN GULF STREAM, FLORIDA m°^ O A 9Q z m s og""� �ZODm 0= m gR4 � m y 0, ��e ADA"m D O O L7 sgy n O N2F i�,h�a y 2 5q St � go � r r I °agz C7 _ z> 8 D v_ 3 xcte_ _ N 3 3 ATLANTIC OCEAN u J N SCALE AS SHOWN JOB If 13-3106 335 OLD SCHOOL ROAD SITE DRAINAGE PLAN GULF STREAM, FLORIDA m°^ O A 9Q z m s og""� �ZODm 0= m gR4 � m y 0, ��e ADA"m D O O L7 sgy n O N2F i�,h�a CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy Hewlett Kent Robert Dockerty January 17, 2014 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 23, 2014 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 12-19-13. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. C. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. f. June 26, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Dave Bodker, Dave Bodker Landscape Arachitecture/Planning, Inc as Agent for Robert Julien, the owner of property located at 1601 Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Section 10, Township south, range 43 east. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit installation of paver bricks over existing concrete driveway. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. IX. Public. X. Adjournment. N. 46 SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2013, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: Chairman Morgan called the meeting to order at 8:31 A.M. II. Roll Call: Present and Scott Morgan Chairman Participating Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Amanda Jones Board Member Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member Robert Dockerty Alternate Board Member Hewlett Kent Alternate Board Member Also Present and William H. Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk Absent w/notice John C. Randolph Town Counsel Mark Marsh Architect Hollis Tidwell Architect Keith Williams Landscape Architect Joaquin Grillo Resident David Frank Precision Drafting & Design III. Minutes: A. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on November 21, 2013 Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Jones seconded to approve the November 21, 2013 Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held by the Architectural Review Board. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: There were none. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Dates Chairman Morgan announced the following approved ARPB meeting dates: a. January 23, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. c. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. Chairman Morgan asked for any conflicts with the next meeting date and any ex -parte communications, and there were none. He also requested that any persons speaking at this Public Hearing be sworn in. Town Clerk Taylor swore in Mark Marsh, Keith Williams and Joaquin Grillo. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 2013 —Page 2 VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh of Bridges, Marsh & Associates, as agent for Mr. & Mrs. John Smith, owners of the property located at 555 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 2, H.V. Pope Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 square feet, to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway, and reopen a previously existing driveway at the south east corner of the property. Mr. Marsh introduced himself, Keith Williams, Landscape Architect and Hollis Tidwell, who was technically savvy with the power point and sketch -up computer presentation for the massing he was presenting this day. Mr. Marsh continued that it was an auto cad program. He reported this program has been received well from all levels, and that it is simplistic but the elements and proportions are real. Mr. Tidwell described and demonstrated in detail the new computer program. Board Member Lyons inquired regarding encouraging this program being utilized when building a new single-family home. Mr. Marsh responded that it was not substantial for some homes, as size and financial costs are the criteria. As an example, he recommended this great tool for beach front homes, due to the massing of the homes. Chairman Morgan inquired regarding the preservation of this computerized tool for record keeping. Mr. Tidwell reported that it was saved in a PDF file folder, as with photographs. Mr. Marsh stated that he would be leaving a thumb drive for the staff to review. Board Member Jones inquired if it could be printed out, to which Mr. Tidwell answered "Yes". Mr. Marsh continued describing the above-named interesting reversed residence which faces the golf course in the back and Old School Road in the front. He reported that the residents were trying to create an entry feature to replicate a covered porch and loggia over an existing tattered awning. Mr. Marsh identified the exact placement and discussed the color of light white brick, the coin work, which will contrast with a shadow line. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the distance of the awning with regard to the eaves. Mr. Marsh stated that the "silly" wall will come out. He continued that the portico element will anchor the element to the floor. Mr. Marsh also reported that the loggia will be wider than the front door, and will ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 3 now give a sense of entry and arrival to the house. He commented that the house is on line with a Georgian style but with more elements. Mr. Marsh stated that the roof is flat and dramatic. Mr. Williams described and demonstrated the landscaping improvements with photographs. He reported that the entrance will be adjusted with the driveway. Mr. Williams continued and discussed the motor court with canopy trees. He stated that coral and cast stone will be used on the driveway, and gardens will flank the entrance. Mr. Williams also stated that this will create better circulation in the driveway. He commented that the present Ficus hedges will be replaced with more white fly tolerant hedges being put in, and that the pool will remain, with the removal of quite a bit of paving, and will incorporate the cast stone for the pool furniture area. Mr. Williams also reported that there will be a feeling of expanse with the elevations. Mr. Marsh continued that the new driveway will still be on the west side of the house making it easier to get to the garage. Vice -Chairman Smith stated that he presently loved the house, and that with these new proposed additions, it will be excellent Chairman Morgan asked for any further comments. There were none. Board Member Murphy moved and Vice -Chairman Smith seconded to approve Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit construction of a new entry portico and covered loggia over an existing open patio, a total addition of 597 square feet to the existing one-story, single family dwelling, relocate existing west driveway and reopen a previously existing driveway at the south east corner of the property. All vote AYE. 2. An application submitted by Mark Marsh & Keith Williams, as agents for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, owners of the property located 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described s Lot 21 & Part of Lot 20, Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to slightly modify both driveways, add paver bricks, and revise previously approved landscape design and materials at the above address. Mr. Marsh stated that the residents have asked Mr. Williams to revisit the previously approved elements. Mr. Williams reported that the residents requested to incorporate a spa which would water into the remaining pool, with a new emerald green finish. He continued that the cast stone paving will remain. Mr. Williams also stated there will be no change in the landscaping in the back. Mr. Williams stated that all equipment will be out of the setback and will be walled in. He stated that off the breakfast room there will be a garden, which would have a walk through leading out to a little terrace with an urn or sculpture. Mr. Williams discussed and further demonstrated on the computer the driveways and the remaining Ficus trees. He stated that the gardens will be all freshened up throughout the property. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 4 Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the hedge in front of the driveway. Mr. Williams responded that it will be replanted out of the right of way and onto the property. Board Member Jones inquired if the plantings would survive that transition, including the citrus trees. Mr. Williams commented that there is a 75% chance. Chairman Morgan asked for any comments. There were none. Board Member Lyons moved and Vice -Chairman Smith seconded to approve the Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to slightly modify both driveways, add paver bricks, and revise previously approved landscape design and materials, which meet the intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards at the above address. All voted AYE. 3. An application submitted by Mark Marsh, as agent for Mr. and Mrs. Steven Silverman, owners of the property located at 1465 North Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Section 10, Township 46 South, Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit installation of new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate at the above address. Mr. Marsh reported that this property will be one of the sterling properties in Town, due to the outstanding work done, and the monies invested on this project. He continued that they are requesting a new gate and gate post on A1A. Mr. Marsh described and discussed the sketch of what is being proposed. He further reported that the gate post has no encroachment is very pricey, antique, and is a very classic element to the property. Mr. Marsh continued that the compositions were rot iron and bronze, eighty (80) years old, and is from France. He reported that there has been a great deal of unfair conflict from some neighbors regarding this property. Mr. Marsh continued that the owners have been very patient with the situation. Town Manager Thrasher stated that he passed through the above-named property and was very impressed with what he saw, and commented that there was no conflict with the approval documents. Mr. Marsh reported that the owners planted very substantial landscaping on their property, at a cost of $500,000, with respect to their neighbors. Vice -Chairman Smith questioned the heights of the gates with regard to the codes. Mr. Marsh stated that the restrictions are between 7 and 8 feet and those were met Board Member Lyons stated that he liked it because it was not a wall, and the entrance looked great Chairman Morgan commended Mr. Marsh for the remarkable job. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 5 Vice -Chairman Smith moved and Board Member Lyons seconded to approve the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to permit installation of new driveway pillars and an iron entry gate at the above address. All voted AYE. 4. An application submitted by Maria T. Bonilla and Joaquin Grillo, owners of the property located 335 Old School Road, Gulf Stream, Florida 33483, which is legally described as Lot 6, H.V. Pope Subdivision. a. LEVEL 2 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 square foot garage and 668 square feet of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 square foot lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single-family dwelling being 1,329 square feet, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added. Mr. Grillo introduced himself and stated that he and his wife are the owners of the above-named home for the past two (2) years. He stated his wife fell in love with the house, as soon as she saw it. Mr. Grillo continued that his three (3) children attend school in Town, and discussed the comparison of their small home to their neighbors' larger ones. He commented on how he wanted to "grow" the house towards the east for more space for his family. Mr. Grillo discussed and referred in detail to the floor plan handout. He wishes to convert the current garage into a guest room, another garage, a mud room and a new bedroom in the northeast corner. Mr. Grillo discussed an entry bathroom which would convert to a cabana bathroom leading out to the pool area, and a lanai as transparent as possible, which would not interfere with the view of the grounds. He discussed in detail the lanai's views from the extreme east and that the existing neighbors cannot be seen. Mr. Grillo commented that there will be a small barbeque structure with drawers on the lanai. Chairman Morgan inquired regarding the driveway. Mr. Grillo responded that there will be two (2) driveways; one goes around the house in the front and will not be touched. He continued that the shorter driveway will be 23 feet east from the property. Mr. Grillo stated that one tree will have to be replaced. Board Member Lyons questioned replacing the roof as it looks old. Mr. Grillo responded "No", and that some pipes have to be amended but the roof will have to be painted to appear as one new roof. Chairman Morgan inquired regarding the landscaping off the addition of the bedroom. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 6 Mr. Grillo stated that the vegetation will move closer to the property line. He continued he will look to the ARPB for suggestions for new vegetation. Mr. Grillo stated that there will be a fence inside the new calusa vegetation, which is the same vegetation as is planted two (2) houses to the south of his house. Vice -Chairman Smith discussed the short driveway and the issues of a car backing out of the driveway. Mr. Grillo responded that the Ficus hedge will disappear which would help. He continued that he realizes it is too tall. Board Member Jones inquired regarding the roof line, which seems a lot higher, and if it could be made all one height. Town Clerk Taylor swore in David Frank, of Precisions Drafting and Design who reported that they are working with the some plane and therefore, they cannot lower it. Board Member Lyons inquired as to the new height of the roof. Mr. Frank responded approximately 3 to 4 feet higher. He continued that the only way to lower the roof would be to flatten it out, and that it would not be seen from the ground level. Board Member Lyons questioned the monotonous roof line which would not make it desirable. Chairman Morgan discussed the windows on the north side, which are all vertical, and takes your eyes straight up to the roof. He continued that all structural issues are permissible under Code. Mr. Grillo reported on the large amount of landscaping, and that the roof will only be seen from the golf course, and that there was no major impact on the house. Board Member Murphy inquired if there was any feedback from the neighbors. Town Clerk Taylor replied "No". Chairman Morgan stated that if s a nice improvement and change to the house. Town Manager Thrasher added that he did ask for help from Urban Design Associates, and there were no violations. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream December 19, 7013 —Page 7 Board Member Murphy moved and Board Member Lyons seconded to approve Level 2 Architectural/Site Plan Review to permit the conversion of the existing garage to living space, the construction of two new additions consisting of a 487 square foot garage and 668 square feet of new living space on the east side of the existing structure, a 174 square foot lanai on the northwest corner of the existing structure, with total additions to the one-story Bermuda style, single-family dwelling being 1,329 square feet, and adjustments to the existing landscaping with some new plantings added from the Design Manual. All voted AYE. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF: A. Update—Ad Hoc Committee Town Manager Thrasher reported that the Ad Hoc Committee has been completed and is full. The Chairman is William (Bill) Boardman, and the members are: Benjamin Scheier, Richard Mouw, David Bodker, and Patricia (Patsy) Randolph. Town Manager Thrasher requested receiving suggestions or comments from the ARPB for changing the qualifications of the code. He stated that the ground work would take a minimum of ninety (90) days. Town Clerk Taylor stated she hoped an Organizational Meeting would take place right after the holidays, and be totally completed by May 2014. She continued that the Committee was not expected to review the entire code just certain issues brought before the Committee. Town Manager Thrasher reported that Chapter 70 can be addressed, which has caused difficulty in the past. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired regarding the amount of cars in front of the Silverman house. Town Manager Thrasher agreed that its a nuisance, and that it has nothing to do with the Spence house. He continued these are all related to the Silverman construction. VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: There were none. IX. PUBLIC: There were none. X. ADJOURNMENT: Chairman Morgan adjourned the meeting at 9:29 A.M. Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 014-01 Address: 1601 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: Robert Julien Agent: Dave Bodker, Landscape Architect Install paver bricks in the driveway and the driveway approach. N. Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: To replace the existing concrete driveway and driveway approach with paver brick. Issues Considered During Review: Article VII. North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District Motion to approve a North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to install paver bricks in the driveway and driveway approach. ARPB Date: January 23, 2014 Action: North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit: Approved as requested including the concrete pad adjacent to driveway on north side. (5-0) Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM �r.RECEIVED t. 1::yapDEC 2 3 2013 Town of Gulistream. APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. PART It. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. ARPB File # 141 - I A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: 0-b ekc I.A.2. Project Address l 0 p N\, C_ ate �)(�y Iac t I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) C\- rN �e t.'.)CJZ k4 T, 0 � ca e kyy,..t` ti l Q, i 4-e- i, i ►'v -v\ I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: i� 1 Architectural Style: 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: r� C� Type of Foundation: B. Owner Information I.B.I . Owner Address: I L2� I.B.2. Owner Phone Numbe 1.B.3. Owner Signature• C. Agent Information I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: Fax: " Z049 r'f 0,A-1 b. , rc-r:1n, i;( -P c�-uc r'_ % � ►a i1 �'1 c �'kd � � � I.C.2. Agent Address: �� �y�,n�t ('e�� I e ude- I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o), !��i_. _�2 11 cell 'SSI Fax J(` 1 ` 3 t1'cl 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: 23) fz)h= 12-13 Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6113100 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream �l TOWN OF GULF STREAM lb- RECEIVE® r p DEC 2 3 2013 APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL Town of Gulfstream, F! This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File # PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION To be completed by all applicants. A. Project Information I.A.1. ProjecVOwner Name: I.A.2. Project Address ` 0 n I��. L� Qt7 JL7Zi1��CL I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: �} ra E « �1--i�li'Y� xy LAA. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) C\ fn Pp i �)iiC' lz- n -n - D\u fes_ •�i+�TCC%d- A5,6 by 1 C' -y' I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: U i` Architectural Style: 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing [North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section F) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: iS\1 iv Type of Foundation: V\ B. Owner Information I.B.I . Owner I.B.2. Owner Phone N I.B.3. Owner Ice) C. Agent Information( / I.C.I. Agent Name and Firm Name: i�LLV �. �JL�G, �L2GGt"�llLi [ 2�tiCC ` nP►Ct,cli1�Alcs �d1C I.C.2. Agent Address: (p r✓7 [ '�Y1Cx C e `f7 I Ic 5 J'vt _' ©� " t''c `rte �c`�7 ) �' _ _ 33�i�15 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o) �ittli- 3� b, ,, tl j cell —J(rl' q J;q- ()LJ4' 2) Fax S - 9 � � ` I.C.4. Agent Signature: Official Use Only Pre -App Date: ARPB Date: App Date: Recommendation: Com Date: TC Date: Decision: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6113100 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART 111. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff Please be concise but brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include the appropriate and complete question number for each response. A. Project Description and Justification * RECEIVES; III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? � _SDEC 2 3 2013 III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district ?Yes No Town of Gulfstream. r, Explain: l� III.A.3. Is the project consistent he Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? Ye j No Explain: III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided?til C�' �' C� V e III.A.5. How are the following L a. Stormwater Drainage _ b. Sanitary Sewer c. Potable water d. Irrigation Water e. Electricity f. Telephone g. Gas h. Cable Television provided to the property? 111.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) \i1\ PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project i1 a land area within fifty feet (50') of the Al (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of-way? Yes No (If "Yes", Section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? Yes No (If "Yes", Section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or the filling of any portion of an existin vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscape area of a developed lot? Yes l 0 (If "Yes", Section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.4. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? Yes (If "Yes", Section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Is the proje �t variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? Yes � (If "Yes", Section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 3 February 2002 16-:vn of Gulf Stream B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit PFC 2 q finwn of Gulfstream, A IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? i7 () IV.6.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? IV.6.4. How is the design consistent with the Al Landscape Enhancement Project?�E' IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District:v (t,' C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 4 44c -Q-,, h Im e,,M A �Q LQ Q�W �gp�Jt� �Jp� VZZtiZ��tl����`Q `=OZ��~Or� ��pJ--W ic �J ZW 22�ti Q u5 Ci ��t~i�VOc�o�O=zQ~�Om z J W QWU�t-U �L� �p1:5L tp��Q�O�titi``v�iScWi • .QcaQ ) OOW�J Q 210�~W �Q 10 UWp Q �0. z � UO4v� J=oW�li oW Z �~QtiW���Qti� Q. p,��i'j �oUi�e�-�ti0 J,� z Qa WLcz aSW�SOzn:�C�Q�cW��nO�L�uO� f?ECEI VE p q OEC 26 2013 Town of Gulfstream, FL m I TA p N 3p � b � i m 3 �Q, D70 a i i " a Qon `D D 0 I I g N Q I N dnrt fn0 n, m it o o I qfi n o 0 c �S�fi p1 o "Ir J m I TA p N 3p � b � i m 3 �Q, D70 a i i " DDDDDD Qon o — dnrt fn0 n, m o n o 0 N n c n _ �Q a CD w m 5 ,�MZ o70 o s o n �Q a CD w m 411V IN ,4� 4 -STA ROAD A -F -A -OCEAN Q� HAM� ta+� - �gA CO�Z :+ "' K �PATC 20`IS Ns�J/Z ?- O :e 3 rmai OUT QA""DN4/G I PAX $G) PA VEO 2W.V /AL FIXM 4'X+"CLNC 2 ��11 �i� nw• w n, 'n a4S SER 0 W21 WwT/7�EVSSN J)� y N 02 I V9 W A 169' I a a � L b aim � C\ Yai i v COM EO L1Y.0 S� i < WALL M LAE � o i �Ste,'n a � (T)ACQi i T o y 0 O y I VEW" Oq O AVEL y O AY m a � o x 0 o � MAO Y n +6fl5 \/FOfMAN flT wa b a n � a �,�e_J• � r � m F — _ ftu " c' � .5m\\ �n�a � \ AWeT °�'� N(�.L mlvEo cows14LNS' - < ca �� <--- _Sasso• --- WALK t z218 cow nOOR rafl� r / • /Lan IMM O =G • (,TRN. srOAE igp]1 COW SMW FORM / STEP IN, ST E P +>rJ `y 1 & 2 STORY ffSngE CF CORAL STONE _ - y _ gW 01A7 -T4 PA - aG — *a>e i cn`STK'm" u :', LAOS LY ZZ z 7 ^wit SQ�� N � yQ, ° nl n (l q�lf]dD LAITs qe-�E b N� Aim it n b m o ti !k2 a G qv$ E i tiaLai l 2 LIES rQVWAI7 141 ggk��cn ga Dov m TV? L ., mama p R �O r= 5-0 �' m k A2 im N co tti'O" CD YCCD G i' a A T[ A N TIC O C E g N m a v Aj v m A N N A, ��C/ ��` (`T ^ ' V v �� rrhh�� v � � Q 3 Rine 1495, FAC. STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION e50.040-15 DRIVEWAY/CONNECTION APPLICATION svSTEMSPLANWNG oaras FOR ALL CATEGORIES 496-0 1-01 Papa 1 ef3 Instructions — To Applicant • Contact the Department of Transportation to determine what plans and other documents you are required to submit with your application. o Complete this form (some questions may not apply to you) and attach all necessary documents and submit it to the Department of Transportation. • For help with this form contact your local Maintenance or District Office. e Or visit our website at www.dot.state.fl.us/onestoppermitting for the contact person and phone number in your area. You may also email — driveways(a�dot.state.fl.us o Or call your District or local Florida Department of Transportation Office and ask for Driveway Permits. Planca nrint nr hme APPLICANT: Creck one: Owner Lessee ❑ ' Contralrt to Purchase Name: (jo0- t Au `1i e-�Jr) Responsible Officer or Person: If the Applicant is a Company or Organization, Name: Address: � �L V L � � V C � _i`�� �Gi.i, e.l1 CUGd City, State: � L) 5 I'Y\T Zip: ? M7 Phone: 5 (� g oL - q 5 D(Q` Fax: Cl • Email: LAND OWNER: (If not applicant) Name: If the Applicant is a Company or Organization, Name: Address: City, State: Zip: Phone: Fax: Email: Op, REG h1vt .:_ DEC 232013 a3_,q _yq,. 0/01 Town of Gulfstream, FL OFFICE USE ONLY nn K V er Application Number: Received By: 4 Date: 7ojV III PRINT) j I'7 / `7 ®" Category: ��--11- " 13 O �' b t1 "JJ .b State Road: % A Section/Mile Post: Section/Mile Post: State Road: Instructions — To Applicant • Contact the Department of Transportation to determine what plans and other documents you are required to submit with your application. o Complete this form (some questions may not apply to you) and attach all necessary documents and submit it to the Department of Transportation. • For help with this form contact your local Maintenance or District Office. e Or visit our website at www.dot.state.fl.us/onestoppermitting for the contact person and phone number in your area. You may also email — driveways(a�dot.state.fl.us o Or call your District or local Florida Department of Transportation Office and ask for Driveway Permits. Planca nrint nr hme APPLICANT: Creck one: Owner Lessee ❑ ' Contralrt to Purchase Name: (jo0- t Au `1i e-�Jr) Responsible Officer or Person: If the Applicant is a Company or Organization, Name: Address: � �L V L � � V C � _i`�� �Gi.i, e.l1 CUGd City, State: � L) 5 I'Y\T Zip: ? M7 Phone: 5 (� g oL - q 5 D(Q` Fax: Cl • Email: LAND OWNER: (If not applicant) Name: If the Applicant is a Company or Organization, Name: Address: City, State: Zip: Phone: Fax: Email: Op, REG h1vt .:_ DEC 232013 a3_,q _yq,. 0/01 Town of Gulfstream, FL Ru;e 1495, FAC. STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION SSO-040-15 DRIVEWAY/CONNECTION APPLICATION sYSTErasP�+N04N0 FOR ALL CATEGORIES Pa9o2 of AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE: If specified by Applicant to handle, represent, sign, and file the application — NOTE: A notarized letter of authorization must be provided with the Application. Name: Company Name: Address: City, State: Zip: Phone: Fax: Email: Address of property to be served by permit (if known): I Le 01 N . b !Qx'Z In If address is not known, provide distance from nearest intersecting public street (such as, 500 feet south of Main St.) Check here if you are requesting a ❑ new driveway ❑ temporary driveway modification to existing driveway ❑ safety upgrade Does the property owner own or have any interests in any adjacent property? '$ No ❑ Yes, if yes — please describe: Are there other existing or dedicated public streets, roads, highways or access easements bordering or within the property? _*o ❑ Yes, if yes —list them on our plans and indicate the proposed and existing access points. Local Government Development Review or Approval Informiation: Local Government Contact A -6`u -=I1 of �V1_ sk—feCLVV-� Name: if V `' aim 1 � w a �� � Apr" � C31-L"� iA[�,1� g4'e= Government Agency: -TrNLe3'rN 1A (T U Phone#: 5U,\- .2`lLe 5I lAk Rule 14-96, FAC. STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION a50-040.15 DRIVEWAY/CONNECTION APPLICATION SYSTEMS PLANNING 04105 FOR ALL CATEGORIES Page 3of3 If you are requesting commercial or industrial access, please indicate the types and number of businesses and provide the floor area square footage of each. Use additional sheets if ecessary. Business (Name and Type) Square Footage Business (Name and Type) Square Footage 1. 3. Note: No plans larger than 24!'x 36" will be accepted 2. 4. a) Highway and driveway plan profile If you are requesting a residential development access, what is the type (single family, apartment townhouse and number of units? Type Number of Units i Provide an estimate of the daily traffic volume anticipated for the entire property at build out. (An individual single family home, duplex, or quad-plex is not required to complete this section). Daily Traffic Estimate = Use the latest Institute of Transportation Engineers ITE Trip Generation Re ort) If you used the ITE Trip Generation Report, rovide the land use code, independent variable, and reference page number. ITE Land Use Code I independent Variable I ITE Report page number reference Check with the Florida DOT Office where you will return this form to determine which of the following documents are required to complete the review of your application. Plans should be 11" x 17" (scale 1" x 50') Note: No plans larger than 24!'x 36" will be accepted f) Proposed access design a) Highway and driveway plan profile g) Parcel and ownership maps including easements (Boundary b) Drainage plan showing impact to the highway Survey) right-of-way h) Signing and striping plans c) Map and letters detailing utility locations before and i) Traffic Control/Maintenance of Traffic plan after Development in and along the right of way j) Proof of liability insurance d) Subdivision, zoning, or development plans k) Traffic Impact Study e) Property map indicating other access, bordering roads 1) Cross section of roadway every 100' if exclusive tum lanes and streets are required Important Notices to Applicant Before Signing Application The Department Reserves The Right To Change Traffic Features And Devices In Right Of Way At Any Time Proposed traffic control features and devices in the right of way, such as median openings and other traffic control devices, are not part of the connection(s) to be authorized by a connection permit The Department reserves the right to change these features and devices in the future in order to promote safety in the right of way or efficient traffic operations on the highway. Expenditure by the applicant of monies for installation or maintenance of such features or devices shall not create any interest in the maintenance of such features or devices. Significant Changes In Property Use Must Undergo Further Review If an access permit is issued to you it will state the terms and conditions for its use. Significant changes in the use as defined in Section 335.182(3), Florida Statutes, of the permitted access not consistent with the terms and conditions listed on the permit may be considered a violation of the permit. All Information I Give Is Accue I certify that I am familiar with t � information contained in this application and that to the best of my knowledge and belief, such information is true, comp) a and accurate. Starting Work On The Drivewa onnection After I Get My Permit Means I Accept All the Conditions In My Permit I will not begin work on the co ction until I receive my Permit and I understand all the conditions of the Permit When I begin work on the connection accepting all conditions listed in my Permit. Applicant Name (Printed): ym F7 7 - Applicant's signature: /- Date i Ruls 7455, FAC. STATE OF FLORIDAOEPAR40 TMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 85D-0.18 DRIVEWAYICONNECTION PERMIT SYSTEMSPLANoNING m FOR ALL CATEGORIES P.S. Application Number: Permit Category: PART 1: PERMIT INFORMATION I Access Classification: VPrS Project: q[1iaik�1L����l1lLr1[11►tieZi+Jt=�iR�•iSa7��� a�aaaw•==��� air. �_---- Section/Mile Post: State Road: PART 2: PERMITTEE INFORMATION Permittee Name: o tae aaxxc` Permittee Mailing Address: City, State, Zip: V W 1\ S N I r 1. ,V__ Telephone: S U' I - I D 93� 91 - c) r)— Engineer/Consultantlor Project Manager: 1)c.Jvt � % mix- 1-11` `M Engineer responsible for construction inspection: Df�•J� �' ���� t""A���` NAME n 1--P�r 4- � P 5 - A Mailing Address: (pDL (-'DOC (2 �j A-" City, State, yip: 1�-P `t'U'''..d e "1 Jird, -- ?J � A Telephone: 5 �' a (o - 3 0 Mobile Phone: S l o t- y d `� PART 3: PERMIT APPROVAL The above application has been reviewed and is hereby approved subject to all Provisions as attached. Permit Number. Signature: Department Representative's Temporary Permit: ❑ YES U (If temporary, this permit is only valid for 6 months) Special provisions attached: YE ❑ NO f Date of Issuance: I If this is a normal (non -temporary) permit it authorizes construc 'on for one year from the date of issuance. This can only be extended by the Department as specific in 14-96.007(6). 4aa fnnnwina naaes for General and Special Provisions 13-p_gg6- C)jop g306 0 Ruic %-sa, F.A.G. STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION &56.040.18 DRIVEWAYICONNECTION PERMIT SYS7-tMSPLANN FOR ALL CATEGORIES Pago2aM I PART 4: GENERAL PROVISIONS 1. Notify the Department of Transportation Maintenance Office at least 48 hours in advance of starting proposed work. Phone: Sof' q Q 61 Attention: 6 - l - DI -0 Li + 2. A copy of the approved permit must be displayed in a prominent location in the immediate vicinity of the connection of construction. 3. Comply with Rule 14-96.008(1), F.A.C., Disruption of Traffic. 4. Comply with Rule 14-96.008(7), F.A.C., on Utility Notification Requirements. 5. All work performed in the Department's right of way shall be done in accordance with the most current Department standards, specifications and the permit provisions. 6. The permittee shall not commence use of the connection prior to a final inspection and acceptance by the Department 7. Comply with Rule 14-96.003(3)(a), F.A.C., Cost of Construction. 8. If a Significant Change of the permittee's land use, as defined in Section 335.182, Florida Statutes, occurs, the Permittee must contact the Department 9. Medians may be added and median openings may be changed by the Department as part of a Construction Project or Safety Project. The provision for a median might change the operation of the connection to be for right turns only. 10. All conditions in NOTICE OF INTENT WILL APPLY unless specifically changed by the Department. 11. All approved connection(s) and turning movements are subject to the Department's continuing authority to modify such connection(s) or turning movements in order to protect safety and traffic operations on the state highway or State Highway System_ 12. Transportation Control Features and Devices in the State Right of Way. Transportation control features and devices in the Department's right of way, including, but not limited to, traffic signals, medians, median openings, or any other transportation control features or devices in the state right of way, are operational and safety characteristics of the State Highway and are not means of access. The Department may install, remove or modify any present or future transportation control feature or device in the state right of way to make changes to promote safety in the right of way or efficient traffic operations on the highway. 13. The Permittee for him/herself, his/her heirs, his/her assigns and successors in interest, binds and is bound and obligated to save and hold the State of Florida, and the Department, its agents and employees harmless from any and all damages, claims, expense, or injuries arising out of any act, neglect, or omission by the applicant, his/her heirs, assigns and successors in interest that may occur by reason of this facility design, construction, maintenance, or continuing existence of the connection facility, except that the applicant shall not be liable under this provision for damages arising from the sole negligence of the Department 14. The Permittee shall be responsible for determining and notify all other users of the right of way. 15. Starting work on the State Right of Way means that I am accepting all conditions on the Permit Rule 14-56, FAC. STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION as0-040.1 e DRIVEWAYICONNECTION PERMIT SYSTENSPLANNW6 06106 FOR ALL CATEGORIES Pago3W3 I PARTS: SPECIAL PROVISIONS I NON -CONFORMING CONNECTIONS: ❑ YES ❑ NO If this is a non -conforming connection permit, as defined in Rule Chapters 14-96 and 14-97, then the following shall be a part of this permit. 1. The non -conforming connection(s) described in this permit is (are) not permitted for traffic volumes exceeding the Permit Category on page 1 of this permit, or as specified In "Other Special Provisions" below. 2_ All non -conforming connections will be subject to closure or relocation when reasonable access becomes available in the future_ OTHER SPECIAL PROVISIONS: SEE ATTACHMENT "A' PART 6: APPEAL PROCEDURES I You may petition for an administrative hearing pursuant to sections 120.559 and 120.57, Florida Statutes. If you dispute the facts stated in the foregoing Notice of Intended Department Action (hereinafter Notice), you may petition for a formal administrative hearing pursuant to section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes_ If you agree with the facts stated in the Notice, you may petition for an informal administrative hearing pursuant to section 120.57(2), Florida Statutes. You must file the petition with: Clerk of Agency Proceedings Department of Transportation Haydon Bums Building 605 Suwannee Street, M.S. 58 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0458 The petition for an administrative hearing must conform to the requirements of Rule 28-106.201(2) or Rule 28-106.301(2), Florida Administrative Code, and be filed with the Clerk of Agency Proceedings by 5:00 p.m. no later than 21 days after you received the Notice. The petition must include a copy of the Notice, be legible, on 8 1/2 by 11 inch while paper, and contain: 1. Your name, address, telephone number, any Department of Transportation identifying number on the Notice, if known, the name and identification number of each agency affected, if known, and the name, address, and telephone number of your representative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes during the course of the proceeding. 2. An explanation of how your substantial interests will be affected by the action described in the Notice; 3. A statement of when and how you received the Notice; 4. A statement of all disputed issues of material fact If then: are none, you must so indicate; 5_ A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts you contend warrant reversal or modification of the agency's proposed action, as well as an explanation of how the alleged facts relate to the specific rules and statutes you contend require reversal or modification of the agency's proposed action; 6. A statement of the relief sought, stating precisely the desired action you wish the agency to take in respect to the agency's proposed action. If there are disputed issues of material fact a formal hearing will be held, where you may present evidence and argument on all issues involved and conduct cross-examination. If there are no disputed issues of material fact an informal hearing will be held, where you may present evidence or a written statement for consideration by the Department. Mediation, pursuant to section 120.573, Florida Statutes, may be available if agreed to by all parties, and on such terms as may be agreed upon by all parties. The right to an administrative hearing is not affected when mediation does not result in a settlement Your petition for an administrative hearing shall be dismissed if it is not in substantial compliance with the above requirements of Rule 28-106.201(2) or Rule 28-106.301(2), Florida Administrative Code. If you fail to timely file your petition in accordance with the above requirements, you will have waived your right to have the intended action reviewed pursuant to chapter 120, Florida Statutes, and the action set forth in the Notice shall be conclusive and final. SPEC/AL PRO VIS/ONS/CONDITIONS ROADWA Y ACCESS PERM/TS ATTACHMENT f°A" Sodded areas will hg in ar_ orrfaru:t. with Permittee will provide the necessary Standard Index 105 and Sections 162, 575, 981, 982, Department's current edition of the densities accordance with the 983 s of the Department'Standard Specifications . Standard Specifications for Road & (latest editions). All disturbed areas will be sodded Bridge Construction prior to final within one (1) week of installation of said permitted acceptance by the Department. work. It is the Permittee's responsibility to obtain final acceptance of permitted work (completed) and the restoration of the Right of Way from the Department prior to usage. All maintenance of traffic (MOT) will be in accordance with the Department's current edition of the Design Standards, (600 series). The Operations Engineer or his designee reserves the right to direct the removal/relocation/modification of any traffic device(s) at the Permittee's sole expense. Restricted hours of operation will be from 9:00 am to 3:30 pm, (Monday thru Friday), unless otherwise approved by the Operations Engineer, or designee. Ownership of all suitable excavated materials, as determined by the Department, shall remain in the Department until a final acceptance of the permitted project is fulfilled. Excavated materials shall be hauled by the Permittee, at their cost & expense from the site to the PB Operations Center or stockpiled in those areas as directed by the Department, including asphalt millings. Permittee will restore the Right of Way as a minimum, to its original condition or better in accordance w/FDOT's Standard Specifications for Road & Bridge Construction or as directed by the Resident Operations Engineer. Permittee shall use the current editions of the Department's Design Standards, Standard Specifications for Road and Bridge Construction and applicable manuals, policies and procedures. Permittee will construct the first five (5') feet of the driveway connection adjacent to E.O.P. from the travel lane consisting of 15"- limerock based on compacted subsoil) and 3" of Type S-1 asphalt. Grade from E.O.P. will be at 6% to the center of swale. Permittee shah coordinate all work with David Moore of Transfield Services u@ 954-317-8044 or email: mooreda@transfieldservices.com Permittee will construct the first five (5') feet of the driveway connection adjacent to E.O.P. tfo i -n ille tlavei iaiie curisisillig UI 15"- lif ieruck base (on compacted subsoil) and 3" of Type S-1 asphalt. Grade from E.O.P. will be at 6% to the center of swale. Permittee will restore swale area adjacent to property/proiect limits (4:1 or flatter) as directed by the Department's Operation Engineer or their designee. O R), C) s�- 1\:) c - CD CM2 CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER: Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy Hewlett Kent Robert Dockerty February 21, 2014 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2014 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. FATIMBIr►UD"A I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1-23-14. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. C. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. June 26, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. July 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. f. There is no meeting in August VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh of Bridges & Marsh, as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, the owners of property located at 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 21 Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the addition of a spa, that will encroach 4.34 ft. into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 ft. into the west setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL SITE PLAN REVIEW to allow the construction of a spa which will encroach 4.34 ft. into the west setback and will be attached to and become a part of the existing pool that encroaches 6.42 ft. into the west setback. 2. An application submitted by Mark Marsh and Nievera Williams as agents for Mr. & Mrs. Bryan Cook, owners of property located at 1226 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 2, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two. a. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial 2 story, Anglo Carribbean style single family dwelling with guest quarters and a three car garage, a total of 9,403 sq. feet, and a swimming pool. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. AGENDA CONTINUED IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 23, 2014, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: Vice -Chairman Smith called the meeting to order at 8:32 A.M. II. Roll Call: Present and Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Participating Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Board Member Amanda Jones Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member Robert Dockerty Alternate Board Member Hewlett Kent Alternate Board Member Absent w/Notice Scott Morgan Chairman Also Present and William H. Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk John C. Randolph Town Counsel David Bodker Landscape Architect Christopher O'Hare Resident III. Minutes: A. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on December 19, 2013 Board Member Lyons moved and Board Member Jones seconded to approve the December 19, 2013 Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held by the Architectural Review Board. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: There were none. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Dates Chairman Morgan announced the following approved upcoming ARPB meeting dates and asked for any conflicts. a. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. c. Ap:6124, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. June 26, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. Alternate Board Member Kent reported that he cannot attend the February 27`' ARPB Meeting. Board Member Jones also reported that she may be unable to attend the February 27`' ARPB Meeting, and will contact Town Clerk Taylor if that is the case. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream January 23, 2014 — Page 2 Town Clerk Taylor swore in David Bodker, and asked if there was any ex -parte communication, and there was none. VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by David Bodker, David Bodker Landscape Architecture/Planning, Inc. as Agent for Robert Julien, the owner of property located at 1601 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Section 10, Township 46 South, range 43 east. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit installation of paver bricks over existing concrete driveway. Mr. Bodker introduced himself and stated that this application is for the repaving of the gravel driveway at 1601 N. Ocean Blvd. He reported that that he will be utilizing a red Dominican brick which he displayed and distributed samples amongst the ARPB Members for their review. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if the brick was new or recycled. Mr. Bodker responded that he did not know the answer, but stated that the same type of brick was utilized on the driveway 3 or 4 driveways south of this residence. He also stated that he received a Department of Transportation Permit for the portion of the driveway which is in the public right of way. Mr. Bodker further commented that the new brick will be installed on top of the existing concrete after removing the gravel. He described and displayed his photographs of the brick border along the perimeter of the driveway, and described and displayed the area where the owners requested the concrete auxiliary area. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if that area would be unfinished concrete. Mr. Bodker responded that it will be a light broom finish. He continued that it will be for auxiliary parking. He stated that according to DOT requirements, there has to be 3' of asphalt past the driveway. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if the driveway will have the exact same configuration as it has at present. Mr. Bodker responded "Yes". Alternate Board Member Kent stated that it looks a lot better with the brick paver rather than the concrete. He continued that there will be no weeds or pesticide used to kill the weeds with concrete under the bricks. Mr. Bodker also stated that this property is heavily screened with landscape material. Town Clerk Taylor swore in Christopher O'Hare. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream January 23, 2014 — Page 3 Mr. O'Hare commended Mr. Bodker on a job well done. He commented on the number of Board Members present just to approve a brick paver on an existing driveway. Mr. O'Hare pointed out that the code states that brick pavers are preferred because they are pervious and better for drainage. He inquired why the concrete is being kept on this project, and the pavers being installed over it. Alternate Board Member Kent replied it depends on the size of the lot, and the ratio of the pervious area as to whether the concrete is acceptable. Mr. Bodker stated that this was already a paved driveway, and the pervious area that is required has been exceeded. Mr. O'Hare stated that he had no problems with the merits of Mr. Bodker's application, but was questioning the members of the body about what was preferred and not preferred. Alternate Board Member Kent stated that there had to be ten (10) persons here for approval of this application because the property is along A1A, a State road, requiring a North Ocean Blvd. approval. Mr. O'Hare also stated he had an issue regarding last month's minutes referring to Town Manager Thrasher's comment with regard to a new policy with plants listed in Section 70-150. He inquired why he was prosecuted by the Town in 2013 for having certain plants, on his property and wondered if that policy was changed. Town Manager Thrasher responded that neither the code or policy has changed in that regard. Board Member Murphy moved and Alternate Board Member Kent seconded to approve the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to replace the existing concrete and gravel driveway and driveway approach with paver brick. All vote AYE. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF: There were none. VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: There were none. IX. PUBLIC: There were no additional comments from the public. X. ADJOURNMENT: Vice -Chairman Smith adjourned the meeting at 8:45 A.M. ARPB Rcgular Mccting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Stream January 23, 2014 — Page 4 4AALA�-,- J Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-07 Address: 2960 Polo Drive Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/ M Nelson Grumney Agent: Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates Construct and attach spa to existing pool. Special Exception To permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback. Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan To permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback. Gross Lot size: 18,519 SF Zoning District: RS -C: GS Core Considered During Review: Effective Lot Area: 17,996 SF Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks Note: Standards of approval for both special exceptions are met. Staff Recommendation: Motion to Recommend Approval of a Special Exception to permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback. Motion to Recommend Approval of a Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review to permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback based on a finding that the proposed construction meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: February 27, 2014 Action: Special Exception (1): Level 3 Architectural /Site Plan Review: Town Commission: March 14, 2014 Action: Special Exception: Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review: Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM � RECEIVED - JAN 1_ (� 2014 hta'0 1111 (,,l.11fstream. rl APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Fa -m. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File JI / 4k Z To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.I . ProjecVOwner Name: I.A.2. Project Address: 2960 POLO DRIVE, GULF STREAM I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including It of stories, etc.) I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: Architectural Style: I.A.G. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Sile Plan Review O Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section 8) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) I.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: N/A Type of Foundation: nTT,TNC, B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 2960 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM FL 1.8.2. Owner Phone Numh --,31 4 Ap9zq0 n Fax: 314-567-3940 I.B.3. Owner Signature C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: BRTGES MARSH R Assn /NTFVFRA WIT T TAM4 I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 VIA MIZN$R, PALM BEACH, FL 33480 I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o)5_6 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Dale: App Dale: Com Dale: Decision: S cell Off cial Use On ARJJJm Date: Reendafion: TC ate: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13100 Fax 832-1520 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream PART Ili. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town SfeM ff a question, number for each response.6 1'rrsae but e sure to includeth brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be appropriate and complete A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? CORE III .A.4. is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? ® Yes ❑ No Explain, ALLOWED UNDER ACCESSORY USE III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? ❑ Yes ❑ No Explain. III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? N/A III.A.5. Flow are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. Stormwater Drainage b. Sanitary Sewer c. Potable Water d. Irrigation Water e. Electricity f. Telephone g. Gas 1. Uduiu 1 uievision - III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes 0 No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes XXNo (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3, Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes x® No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? M Yes ❑ No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes 0 No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA,32000 page 3 All) y� �, D l Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E,•I, Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? I`)wrt 0 Gill ;;`Team R. IV.E.2. How is the use �� � Yes ❑ No dost Code Section: 70 75 � c welfare, and t geed, located and propo5ed to be o Morals will be protected? perated so that the Public health, safety, ---TILIi PRnDr,.,,,_ WHICH WILL HAVE ALL IV,E,3. REQUIRED PROTECTION FOR Will the use cause substantial injury SAFETY be located? ❑ YOS 11 No rY to the value of otherro y p pert Explain. in the neighborhood where it is to n., � _ WILL BE NO - JuvtCs STRUCTUR IMPACT TO VALUE P H Rp IV, E,4 How OR NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTY will the use be compatible with adjo(n(ng development and the character or the District where it THE PROPOSED SPA ADDITIONS REFLECTS SIMILAR POOL SPA STRUCTURES FOUND ON PROPERTIES WITHIN IV,E,S, THE SURROUNDING What THE and screening are provided? THE PROPOSED ADDITION HEDGES WILL BE SCREENED Ey NEW, Does the use confirm with all applicable pplicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be located? ❑Yes Explain, rDTT— __ EXISTING POOL STRUCTURE WITHIN SETBACK vided, describe them and how theF. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 U IV.f .•I, If common area facilities are to be profts y are to be maintained. N/A IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided,e describe them and their potntiaimpacts mpacts 01-1 s properties.w rounding IV1.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 ' uw►r or (3ulf Stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.I-I.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? 2014 IV,H,2. If the project involves a rezoning, , Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, any combination thereof, please describe the need and Justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not required to Provide any additional relevant information regarding the project that p was not covered elsew/sere on this form or on the other materials submitted with the application. any of OF A NEW ELEVATED SPA TO BE ADDED TO THEEXISTINGPOOL, CENTERED IN THE N/W SIDp nn Mun ---- --- LOCATED WITHIN THE EXISTING POOL AREA AND HAS A GREATER SETBACK THAN THE EXISTING NON—CONFORMING WEST EDGE OF POOL THE PROPOSED REQUEST IS Tn P PnTTr1L1 MT1- 15.66' IN LIEU OF 20.0' EXISTING POOL SETBACK IS 13.58' Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 614100 Page 7 SOUTH COVE a _ 0 m M. 'a N nZz`('i,mm m 'mm ,Z1 ol^ mPI z N m n O9 DIin- 0f^o< Oy92mm= =1 --mi�,�tOZm �-al 0 oDCj m= ME _ 9SSQZoOmz, N xZm Q Z00 m m OR-.ODtzmm - _ m a Z. o _ m $_ ="' m Oo o:G> c_ J� 2901-�6N m pgo m mm�GZ)Z� i0 y. �v v C1Cym ➢ W p z�C r=m'c H to o c y 1,� �mZmm DZ ` r 0 m�Nm�Do 000016° 3 ° -rt 'm I A1I N ?Amp as m W <mf�' $ ,D 03 i �' vlpma�� -. 'h ~m " 0 � m�ODmO m 1 2 0 � 0 o�ozva 9 �` mo Mo O N rn� v�.o�v c t 000 C n 0 ocm8mm 0c.: Z .� /S�� Z >ZT m. 9mm� Q 7c �c r� p0 -n Cmimm7�. o Z ?O,t ooM Y r m m 0 nm2Zo m t o _ 0111 N 4Dovm my N p moaEo 0p m HE U E n 0 13 3 m m m CDC cD m moo�r�,4�m mcoo W> ��m�czci.. �W<-! WF o,�mcNi'z z�Pt� _Lr Z-r7°�!"al 13 mIn Qz zy pxZH3 RL4 �I"ivla 0�O00106 a sk ZO-CI; CZ?m r0�•p OZ 6' m a tS�NtI '-�. Q - -1 'p 60 22yTiY_Omf 3�0T a� Mr,i-OCTa wSO Y� FFFFFFD �. m W y fn m T m Z C 0 N a gopEg9�a6a5{ ,Mm �Fa m 6_00<�C oo p0 •°it O 6'1002 '� m mg -P D[7^ Rww m ;uz �m .0.,;0T mZC mf7 ,�ntt .ffvOZo'OiIY U00 -i A_...m1.am6 a5� y 1"T -I O66.Q 0,O, TO po °" z1 rtam 001 C Q A Cr 9 'ril m o a -1 �p 'II N pN+Ia OT=C o>M T �Ooi�4o_, '°it m,� b' m =1 OP 3 �q^ 0 0 0 �66LPHIN PILE .Szc, ,n/a ✓/ N05' 45' 00' E 100.00' / sev.8.a o... u.66• / 1s. 46 / lz 35' - ao 2.7' SEAWALL CAP E /or. S-tV \ rZ P1 ,J r -5 Q riU J14. 6B' 3.20' 1246' 3.60 'STEP�`^ '�^ 4.60' 12.60' 4.50' I! 65' I $ COVENED r I , ^o ?3.60'- N�l�` 34.36' / I ' ip S r w r. 5.2 w 2 STORY I s � Vvm �R RESIDENCE ti 12.76' 1z.76• Nr I I ' ,�L ^" s. 76'6 , • 16.55' NI 14.66'16 r' r t •.`t 1 S .56' 'V� V Jyp _ N •1 lt2O �t�o I I 77. Z9 PP. 7z' 0606' 36' 00' N 177. 30' + o 00Z-�T Dccmr � N C y o — — � o . J — — — . — — M m y o N m _ _ _ _ _ N06'36'00'E 177.30' o- -- ;u�flXoo -10 c o POLO DRIVE o yy,, '{�l mDN�Z o �., 00000000-1[Dit om a ooDm a! ND zmr rm- < O D O W a _ 0 m M. 'a N nZz`('i,mm m 'mm ,Z1 ol^ mPI z N m n O9 DIin- 0f^o< Oy92mm= =1 --mi�,�tOZm �-al 0 oDCj m= ME _ 9SSQZoOmz, N xZm Q Z00 m m OR-.ODtzmm - _ m a Z. o _ m $_ ="' m Oo o:G> c_ J� 2901-�6N m pgo m mm�GZ)Z� i0 y. �v v C1Cym ➢ W p z�C r=m'c H to o c y 1,� �mZmm DZ ` r 0 m�Nm�Do 000016° 3 ° -rt 'm I A1I N ?Amp as m W <mf�' $ ,D 03 i �' vlpma�� -. 'h ~m " 0 � m�ODmO m 1 2 0 � 0 o�ozva 9 �` mo Mo O N rn� v�.o�v c t 000 C n 0 ocm8mm 0c.: Z .� /S�� Z >ZT m. 9mm� Q 7c �c r� p0 -n Cmimm7�. o Z ?O,t ooM Y r m m 0 nm2Zo m t o _ 0111 N 4Dovm my N p moaEo 0p m HE U E n 0 13 3 m m m CDC cD m moo�r�,4�m mcoo W> ��m�czci.. �W<-! WF o,�mcNi'z z�Pt� _Lr Z-r7°�!"al 13 mIn Qz zy pxZH3 RL4 �I"ivla 0�O00106 a sk ZO-CI; CZ?m r0�•p OZ 6' m a tS�NtI '-�. Q - -1 'p 60 22yTiY_Omf 3�0T a� Mr,i-OCTa wSO Y� FFFFFFD �. m W y fn m T m Z C 0 N a gopEg9�a6a5{ ,Mm �Fa m 6_00<�C oo p0 •°it O 6'1002 '� m mg -P D[7^ Rww m ;uz �m .0.,;0T mZC mf7 ,�ntt .ffvOZo'OiIY U00 -i A_...m1.am6 a5� y 1"T -I O66.Q 0,O, TO po °" z1 rtam 001 C Q A Cr 9 'ril m o a -1 �p 'II N pN+Ia OT=C o>M T �Ooi�4o_, '°it m,� b' m =1 OP 3 �q^ FFaiij> t7 9 cn -3 zo Amm m OO ME 5 y n• E z 0 g UP 100W_ �� N.05' 4500' E y — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — ro I I - �g r z �y 20' ACCESSORY STRUCTURE SETBACK I N n gmm y >F N Ali 4, xP E > Q a g P r A 1�1 NON O 0 N D .."66 b `z' ym"NNyy A 4 _ 8 in m D G] '`�yl O T7 � m -H P xxpx x uit > > z z i i i Q $ a >>N a a 9 $ a REVISIONS a j..� GATE C I r a DWG. NO. GNtt RW SCALE ,� KY qqpp�S^ 33oR$"F, R �F�P�.44�53'? Ali 4, xP a g Foil m o A6 I, 4 Qv� z I � I to r I Q]1• I _�RESi�)ES 39 Fn y AQ cOL C � ,rW -- -- AN BOLCEARD 37� A75A--TIA---- g I PAVED I I A,b. ntiw I z y y S HI'JISS'J: as I .04' a �w Gl0/919J W) a� ki GIfl1 M6 -aa ARI a H � b � g a y rq ��SZ SZ WN S-01 paP 'V v �^ npi s I pip (� g ATLANTIC OCEAN S "fit-,q�EsTq �i FE� ZZ Qv� WOW AQ GSEFEJVr RiAPAIE Gl0/919J W) /dIH.1D GIfl1 M6 �q� -- +SJJ syU P A V f 0 ti' FRVA,f ACwD Aururor m 15s + P r u u tM>S SWALE//✓E7F]Vlpy A/d-A 4 W�D D PJ D'IAILICFG31OJr M wL &45UINT I L�I I + I + '6 II + a Z qq Z b V 74) II + I 0 e I e O I� x ,l I o IM A{A A(E fiLm ¢lRArwirc�eAsl,E„r - AiRiRUN If LDG IR)V � SWALf G4AOLr1 Ifl/ mmm,FT�� L"noc /dN79] --- Ltl ✓81 J wrm .DPA1W - -- -- -- CAS P --12 mg} � DPAlMLf LAg1k71r p D _-.- TRACT (A P Aif NCD) �i FE� ZZ z x I to 3gi �� 6 B8 '6�tf 1 I I I I I I 1 1 I. 0 0 -1 0 , 0< O T C 1 O 0 O r 0 m D N Q S I' N ? ✓� -` " -n D m rii -n '-O 1-3 P r ti- 1 p yZ Op N a r N A > op p A m - O� z m I ro GZ � A >m� m U n N m = D o 0 o o o o y O m m r- p n p z V D m voi V. p 2 o p-1Dp m z 2 mo 0 g> In A rO MA - z .mal �=oo D Z mm�m n n O l o aim n�A= o z o A A mz oz Mo " C p a p�....I D A m D .�1 A A '� m D m O m p p m J mO D A D D a m D m D m D O O z a a ^ x �„ z A m IA TI a M D W N N ® o J 'J N m r z z z z z z z X N N O rD a D D D D D (n o N N N O O m o cf) g W g p z D z D z D z D z D z D z D I-4 ,y JO W J W 0 O o d N z y m N A� >>m o w y N a a y m zz m N to m O a N D D m a m N m L J o o CJS Imp d =1 ZOm �m C D ,o�oA by LJ r m m , uzi m �^ r ✓� CDDry cn m D T m ti- 1 p yZ Op N 0-4 �mzz V op p A m - O� y D D O an ,00 GZ O A >m� M0-0 A^c ov A y O m m n p z V D D � p-1Dp m z 2 mo 00D �x>n !nom~O MA - z .mal �=oo D Z mm�m n n O l n�A= F mz oz Mo " vz mL! m Imp d �m C JOB � � m , < CDDry m s m UPCl)_(� mL! m Imp d �m a z JOB � � SEAL MI SILTANT mL! m �m '=J a Z 0 I A Icn trJ 1 4 REVISIONS y N DATE II u � CHK.RW SC ALC �Agjpjpp p §Mv. Fm,4 3nE pq g5 6yS6 T F y p -- - -- �, W fl'@ H F-- �`a 9 CD �Agjpjpp p §Mv. Fm,4 3nE pq g5 6yS6 T F y p Z O 2 II I Y 3 ci \ / HIM ci \ / \ / \ I I I I F I � I 0 II I a I L—__ -----J I IT I II II II II II I II II II II II II I ;< f----1T-----CI---rtl--- I�_� ® H II III II II I L Ix I II II II II II x REF FRZ I II II II II II �. C] U1 — — !.ZZ3 Cb m t" Hcon �7 � -- 0— t m \ / \ / I 't�7. N1111111111111111111 11111111 / \ x — r� II II'' o HStlM AHO 1 I m ji i" W-0" Cy,' tr 12'-10" 2' 2" 14'-0' 2' 2" 12'-10" Cl a Ci d a � UP 10'-0" yHy Lr u REVISIONS v OAT I II iV = u o I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I L ------------J O g555555 �ssss � �� E w m I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I L ------------J O w m CID, n aaalll J 013 f:� DFnt'; I;:G J03 � � _ CONSULTANT � � n APA v REwsious gga @ � �R"� ��b,: _7 �+ ��W tz ry s � � GSa^ 94 5S paP2�,3R C ^ O DY,'G. �: D. CHK RYiI _'GALE JGB IJO. DRAI'��I:G 10B SCAB C011 ��- $.°j A REVISIONS DIMN I f1l n L I (� DATE II o D\'; v. NO CH K. Oid9F SCALL O O DRA1':'il!G T w m 0 m CDC1 _� o m CONSNLTANT z 7- � >o i Z i 3E MP of - cousu�rnur gggj gjppq RAW fl, Fa F �g pyqgg 44 R d � >o i Z i 3E MP of - cousu�rnur 4 ����� 1►'IIII�I I,•I �m ail ■■■ REVISIONS nA1� 2 Dl':C. f:0 CHK. Rltit SCAi� ill �4sq€1. 8 a�Ynr'� r• D- D oo� -� OEM I I �IIII' II I I io • to I- rn I r t� ae T1 I'I r t� I-3 O is 4 ����� 1►'IIII�I I,•I �m ail ■■■ REVISIONS nA1� 2 Dl':C. f:0 CHK. Rltit SCAi� �N jr ill �4sq€1. 8 a�Ynr'� r• l88' a� 5 5Ea -� OEM �N jr Y • r• -� OEM �IIII' II m ® • to I- rn I r t� ae T1 I'I -� OEM w m ® 0 to -� r w m ® 0 to I- rn I r t� ae T1 -� r m 0 to I- rn � ae T1 2�\ D p0 < O D 7z� m (N n D D D G- r m ANT_ R=C 045 TAL WATERWAV ATLANTIC OCEAN V ' 0 JAI DRAINAGE EASEMENT (PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE no) -20' PRIVATE ROAD & UTILITY EASEMENT P A V E D (PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE n0) Acn ---- ------------------------------------------------------------ --------- 1 z r n 0 3 in 3 z 3 zr a SITE PLAN v 6� Cm O�Z' In COOK RESIDENCE 3 n N TD �n� __z X -^�-^m N sic a �xm�3 TO °DO m i L r CULF STREAM, FLORIDA NInD -��a D ' s� A D •� p1i -"'i x A L� o• LT m o T c N o m Z •T C O. n� D xz"- n c. �Z N �� y g" o $> g6 a r m vj c .-6 "O Q Q S °� 4 a ° n N�Nm pm T�z 0 11 r n p ON 0 g z z O V ' 0 JAI DRAINAGE EASEMENT (PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE no) -20' PRIVATE ROAD & UTILITY EASEMENT P A V E D (PLAT BOOK 36, PAGE n0) Acn ---- ------------------------------------------------------------ --------- 1 z r n 0 3 3 z 3 SITE PLAN v 6� ZW COOK RESIDENCE CULF STREAM, FLORIDA z 3 v In U o 15 JANUARY 2014 SCALE: D I I --t-------{-------------7l---------------------------------------}--------- I -------- ------------------ ---------------------------------- I � I I � ° L-- _-- =1--_-- —��__ I —i-- — T STM — STAI — S7M � STM — STM I TM — STM — — — — — a F — — — — — — — — I — — — — STM — STM — STM — STM — STM --------T— —--------R�--- -------------------- -----------�-------- _ I I r—r—I� k o I — _ m g° -- m n � m � -------------------------------------- c I I! zm s II � M� I � �R � PF N i b I ! n I a E. a �',• ! b I i i; 2 ill IT— C, ------ll----- II =92 I s i i I u I .3u a i < 3 Z ICA)O q n P m m NARDSCAPE PLAN .j m D "i x A D {{IPi T NT .NNi o %— COOK RESIDENCEoDn m n TI z N ptisN D �4& o n r GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ® _ G RI z �, o w W i 21 FEBRUARY 20/4 3 m 3 " 15 JANUARY 2014 T 3o DECEMBER 2ot3 SCALE, 3' • t -o' D 1 — --- -- a Zm A � o m'� I �E I =Q I I a, R nuc p I N v as =1 I I D I- – – – – – – – – – – – – – –– I P C.B. C.B. mo 5„� —sTM— STU _ saeq — — � — — — Li — — — — — I I ---------'-J m �` a i ze i^ I ow '^ B L"3 n S4 <1—N Z_p rn ® m R m HARDSCAPE PLAN H p 71 3 N mho; COOK RESIDENCE _c n a a vDi n FEBRUARY 2014 GULF STREAM, FLORIDA u v 3O J" 15 JANUARY 7014 CA rt'I 3 0 3o DECEMBER 2013 SCALE'•t-o' '�— D n_ Ti D C �a I �E I =Q I I a, R nuc p I N v as =1 I I D I- – – – – – – – – – – – – – –– I P C.B. C.B. mo 5„� —sTM— STU _ saeq — — � — — — Li — — — — — I I ---------'-J m �` a i ze i^ I ow '^ B L"3 n S4 <1—N Z_p rn ® m R m HARDSCAPE PLAN H p 71 3 N mho; COOK RESIDENCE _c n a a vDi n FEBRUARY 2014 GULF STREAM, FLORIDA u v 3O J" 15 JANUARY 7014 CA rt'I 3 0 3o DECEMBER 2013 SCALE'•t-o' '�— D n_ _ _ _ _ --------- D I �E I =Q I I a, R nuc p I N v as =1 I I D I- – – – – – – – – – – – – – –– I P C.B. C.B. mo 5„� —sTM— STU _ saeq — — � — — — Li — — — — — I I ---------'-J m �` a i ze i^ I ow '^ B L"3 n S4 <1—N Z_p rn ® m R m HARDSCAPE PLAN H p 71 3 N mho; COOK RESIDENCE _c n a a vDi n FEBRUARY 2014 GULF STREAM, FLORIDA u v 3O J" 15 JANUARY 7014 CA rt'I 3 0 3o DECEMBER 2013 SCALE'•t-o' '�— D --f------- --- -- ------ -------------------------------- --� —--------- \ I I I ° —1 / � Is q I PoV. I I L I I JjI I — I ° -- — 1 ° g `✓ ® 1-49 m y a 3 D LANDSCAPEPLANfV xr as A �. ° cm L Pdq GULF STREAM, FLORIDA - z r a m < /� m SCALE, > STM STM — STM — STM S .I TM— I STM — STM — STM — STM STM i n -- ----------------- -------- --- — ---- --� -- --R= =_------ o— �— ni FOO 3 93 z m I g s Q 13; m 0 9c g x N_________________"_____________ ---------------- z 25 IIe„ nn ,mm /FF=- ---1 I o h fzU P c r s nes esr a- R ui 'n I� , `3> man - k �A HE E '���ck 3 _ n Fry 1 • w" n i , z o a.S .4 Umz Y rE �� E _E - ar as 10 '6mm l 0�-E _° e f o , U O z m m A D L, Z D n FEBRUARY 2014 15 JANUARY 2014 3o DECEMBER 2°13 ® \ I I 9 —1 Is q PoV. I I L $ O n I JjI 1 g `✓ ® rev m y a 3 D LANDSCAPEPLANfV xr as A COOK RESIDENCE cm L Pdq GULF STREAM, FLORIDA - z r a m < /� m SCALE, > " I -- --- -- -- n n � LIJ --  --------- � m m Tip sus � ��p m N �� A AE � a �s o I P o 1._ _ a m3 G__ 10 z ems 4 -Z r 2m I I= Ijj E �� xY r im ��, I I I 77 r A T'm�� k R3 I I= n I N3U z4, cr �� z  _ w IL i��- m = II 4,;= N g �r� I= I c o 23 -- I C.B. Sim- -      cu------ I F wm a.0 ��' sz ��u � I^DT Ll�� 6,u w n 6��1 oSv 1= rv, 'x4 t'1 fff m * N a I n~ 0          - v p Iv w i R a(n���� Z- r CID r m (��! P Cn Z �� � I ���� n m LANDSCAPE PLAN D p D==s ��F Z COOK RESIDENCE N _mao�� �� oDa z N n O wN a n FEBRUARY 2014 15 JANUARY]otq GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ' z ^ a < m 3 0 3o DECEMBER]�13 SCALE:,J'. T" o' D r�zadcz �ro`3b�y �yoa•��e� o�x~< a 0 ' oo � z av zc�r> Cm cn 13 ?� �ac�zo� yz4 0z0 zCn �M 0 0* v* —� •. ° m A N O tT / \ i rTj ACE]EASEMENT if 1 SPT %)-m. f\ 1 I I ism I I � I I I ORII I- I I J I+ d 1 \ -5 t IIMVAIE RO h UMITY EASEMENT 20' g , 1 \ I -s -� I ( T BOOK 36. PA 00)- N O O =1 I -----I -- ---------- ---------1 _=1 1 I ---I o o O m w z m z \ '3 11glEnvropesgnHARBOR .T 4 > I I IIP. - I f-- slu�slu AssociatesInc. ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM FLORIDA ON D -1 —,ry—sti sn, 2/20/14 REVISE GARAGE LAYOUT PER ARCH PLANSMTJ N --t-- J I CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION No. 6506 298 PO FLORIDAIDA Grove Way Delroy Beach, n .. 6 33444 Phone: (561 274-6500 Fox: (561) 274-8558 ^t N I EASSEEMAENNT p I Imp w Nm I I � I I I I I I I A I+ I 1 I =1z I I i IT I r w N A z I I I Ia I I I P m E I I I I 1/I I N Ng 0 Bap Irt m F I � I yy�I I I I N I '.l = N CD o o O m w z m z \ '3 11glEnvropesgnHARBOR .T 4 > '3 9 AssociatesInc. ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM FLORIDA NGT VALID VNTNOUT ENGINEER'S SEAL JOSEPH A. PIKE, P.E. FL REG N 42696 N0. DATE: REVISIONS: BY: 2/20/14 REVISE GARAGE LAYOUT PER ARCH PLANSMTJ --t-- J I CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION No. 6506 298 PO FLORIDAIDA Grove Way Delroy Beach, n .. 6 33444 Phone: (561 274-6500 Fox: (561) 274-8558 ^t EASSEEMAENNT U99 N �o z E 0 Bap Cn m F yy�I N I X. S 'A i -D-11 f*I 0 � Oc �p 0 I _ N g `'� Sy S� W! y WfTI m I I F IQHUI !;L m y O m D@ v`2 � � W ♦mom gN N < 2 C � N � O m A 0 $ gg tI Z C CD m © �J T �I..I I m� no N 4 Nm `I I I'd Ave a N iL Federal' Hwy pQI h NE 7th Ave = x G1 NE 8th Ave S! u� NE 9th Avc f y TRACT •A- (A PRIVATE ROAD) _ a T xo D= r C/)m vmZ:' 0 m > m C >, m D ^1 z p m z c M L� x D ND j m m m A D O D o m i z'I- s g D m r.-- - N OEean BIVd r x O m rn o o o O m w z m z \ '3 11glEnvropesgnHARBOR .T 4 > '3 9 AssociatesInc. ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS CIVIL SITE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN FOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM FLORIDA NGT VALID VNTNOUT ENGINEER'S SEAL JOSEPH A. PIKE, P.E. FL REG N 42696 N0. DATE: REVISIONS: BY: 2/20/14 REVISE GARAGE LAYOUT PER ARCH PLANSMTJ CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION No. 6506 298 PO FLORIDAIDA Grove Way Delroy Beach, n .. 6 33444 Phone: (561 274-6500 Fox: (561) 274-8558 P N t Y N z @P f C #g r roDesignHARBOR Associates ice. vmw.emeedpn.mm ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS a� v M r� 99>�R gg @ g !gig N FLORIDA wp (ER2IFICA2E OF almyAUTHORIZATION "Ft Na Osoe 2H0 561) 27a 0ro>a Way DMray Bwah, Flarlda 33444 Phonx 501 274-8500 Fac 581 274-8558 P N t Y N z om I O 41 i; Nil� Fig Aja K d y roDesignHARBOR Associates ice. vmw.emeedpn.mm ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS a� v M r� 99>�R gg @ g !gig N FLORIDA wp (ER2IFICA2E OF almyAUTHORIZATION "Ft Na Osoe 2H0 561) 27a 0ro>a Way DMray Bwah, Flarlda 33444 Phonx 501 274-8500 Fac 581 274-8558 77 ISS bj �c P p vP P ��• W N'� c om I O 41 i; Nil� Fig Aja K d y roDesignHARBOR Associates ice. vmw.emeedpn.mm ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS F O D r m 5 n m 0 O z z m 0 0 z � 9 1109 c rp P, .1 m p + f+ N -(Tmv mo§gm $a4i Fc 21 �Qi pg �-5!n- ;=v-m�,mg ��mo'4� ��2n�F �Fv gati ^' Sgg-'i InA m c�gF mx >>jCmd� afli>OgQE Mo"p F $nyly oz pv z=m�� y�>-Ic g imz l n�n�ai B zmvoTz 25 ynj -1228 5z=n ~TAiQ >m4>m �m 2� �,r,% 2954 >a� > �m~i p c>��'Nm QiB�oepEn'* ymey<m�im d�� TzA$ziz Tv� Ap c F dz s > v $> o >� m ��g� <e� go �N >>83F$��^ oon t-'814 >^m>SoggZBggg7i� <e�z �g�1gF �g S ti �� yz li��A� IQQ AW �, ogmni� mcziwotl�F�r�i���� 14.5 WAS- > m C v$ rmm� z+l �F =mF m�4� ym <�� Bzpav mqs �>ix�iZ i d��g >�>dA-� nz goio g -z 229E�"" NOR. g8np�g�F €� 1'=$-�m>�361:^ m<, m > SqPR 'K i *o FF�x m�"x pnFi�o > � �iz+ii�^ �^��yxi��c �►4 �F yi�ax omoGiigg M. i� zTz _m�>vgv�� �gp�og s m�`��m Sm>S Ao928 i� �s �i 02212 3 � m� �.����� Z���Lc �m��QiS�C 8F.2" �8N'�19l�,>>- �Fqn g. ; �pd'� �� I;ImoA Amo m F� ti=1�m-0 PEON N N;gU>0£n d mi `� m � $12T> mvio msE qat �2 R F; � AF>Bm� 1� g Z ;� �eo4� �g�` �dS oa vmm>> Hvzcm om � yF ROME m�z ��p �z �� $mm�1 QGORM�g�i� �>'spao�> '2m'ggR„2ujao�amJZm� gg'W mgs '(m; Foo n t S� �mx Sp -;o yS^mm� s ;�i R5jo �F>m yx0 2=�. NZ Q��Zm Z Q Li F = > N 5Sn pa4vag >TiF n� mmc8�m�>n2 �>v �Fm mi'iz 6 a� o i0.2 la (>ytz �Fv m?�p 8m'R'0nmv�n" s Ott � MR W $ �oom �� 8� yi'�4�� 5��=�m g=>4$��>� V�' I�,�pg��89 F�SFg c� z� xal eo TOK g vm oNo�9 $ �o� Z»og $Km mm� ogm" D mm $ m Tz yiz y Fz g m ov v < m m y z Z O �+' Fr' ,-N• o m p'o :: m ,u': t u N Z m' N61. s=ags ms�> $A> >SQ�F o .�E.((z1a� l -:3o i �mm g Nv . �=Jmo c m nQ A F a H mmom zp2mQ z y��.8 np8= �=n�n � GC> rn21=0 m N � � n>m4 -1�$pq in i � ��n MQ ox$' mmo m Q&0m@ 0WO 0 T �gpids 31AEq 4o M� �Fgg >u2 z inicd ,i 8 o ..% ,„ gm>zz > N y gg- mxn x N o D z EI �, 4zt ->" $g A g Zi pm ->r p z� yy!�� O Midi > i�czi,m„ � >pi nZ�nm o a n>,x 44E22` n�g�n i� 1; �m�ii m -E�E2 p> is �g nm d%; mgW I Z mo$Cl i-+. >Z� �� �B �' Z Sl - �^ �g p >4o$i AA21 9 � mg ggv ox8a---m 9 ns � �F2 v> qm BFB > 49 892m 8ti� 2 0 ''Imm orz3 > B 8 �i F mz o v 2io �yy�� Ai m> m � �� d 'z<m .I ?O z g'i f ndoA� Vl o m �� i mFm �$ Af'+>,� v �z�j >50 g$�p p' �i{y� giKo 2io �M E; "f-,P,m my mo n �2m p. 2T 1>p`J r'2 �v-I �Rm ;�3 �g >$ A�YI ,C��r{m�m 4mTz �Z� 5.--m m Y+ �C >mrc 1410 M nys �z y r icy >�2 �O;z; �L Qmp� SZ�L mi x� v 2m.. FO1j 8z '8'kl ogFBF m �L400 z BI�Sm^o F�q c�j QF vA�OpC �s $ aL �0� N„ m m; nRiE .02> m 02 andQ =. �m Ngal i i 3Fc>>m u� >om ' $ g � mv� a'i g`�iy2 �gi Fly '�Z y�= �m omd> pmpm 4�V it .2o om �o mlm� o [�' g gF n� �; o>� .11 m^ m m dy o� I�IAym m n .z O O2 m ? �di tii n g M n d n -Ag T4s > >>> 8 � 4� 4�dn� zai v cg Z KZgd y�SJ $ z z In'7i gg mgmzm "vTia MET 8-`dh� Dq8gp1n. 4�S:2ff ONE $fflF gcnpFz�0 g p�F HQ oY�mo ll p;m�N pv! p �m �M§ 4 Fi mg W $�� �a1� o�R 9 Fr $djf F1 296sv -Ho -8 F8 AG 5 � t48 Fob 500, SSI g� > cn �- $nQ M bn> on n d g z ``� �zmmc 19 ..5 mC �x Am= � $ �n Ti m D oh g= m gQ -TE ffl g4 g� u�fQ zzA ty'i im v.n nr..`.dm=_a� mv> ��o� o���z F! Y i ?�z� oz bQA �m m Z'< LID Mg�gB p� p�� y F m �p 8 Nim �F2�> > mp z z K mA KmF m D O y 5!D1.�T= zm d C cn g= {da oo etc Cs�z j�jF tin p MIN IT L is$ o A �= m� MF oi��� Z" o 2tCy Ca mQQQtQ IJ 1 Q�>�p Qja -S@12 @>8z m H. mO u�i mr1 �Q 'T s� �1�u� g �F ti4 y v v ~i��-vgoo w �'vm tai > gc>i mx� om 529 mmo z. 149 pw 48 T pF�mTLv �r'1. ym �p Ai $ y m N O "a o N ' om I O 41 e ••:ti�91E .7" F K d y roDesignHARBOR Associates ice. vmw.emeedpn.mm ENGINEERS ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PAVING & DRAIANGE DETAILS FOR: VIEW ESTATESeaa�oa5> LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDAFl Ndf �� W W LA. MN[. 6 JOSEPH �4„ No. DATE, �°�' �: FLORIDA wp (ER2IFICA2E OF almyAUTHORIZATION "Ft Na Osoe 2H0 561) 27a 0ro>a Way DMray Bwah, Flarlda 33444 Phonx 501 274-8500 Fac 581 274-8558 0:\2013\13096—Cook Residence—Lot 2 HV—Bridges Marsh\DWG\13096—DTL.dwg, 1/15/2014 8:39:53 AM, 11" x 17" +4.89 �\ +5.J"! 1+5.33 IIrWATE • � p I \ 45.1 a; I % Lj_ I I IU $�A{,i-� — H _ a 1— R.52 ppMIA FA4i �N1 I r-----43.1"ra' €'3afi—" 1� +� d SEPRC sYSTEIA I j pbd lax To PROP1 I u+� WATER SERVICE I I' I ' I I' 1 , I I` I is I ' I I I I P4 4 I I ly I I' I I' I C1 I I I l I I I II � I of * I �T Er tr I � o I I o I a I I I --LST - 9.5] S9•%N.ti 6a9� 1a/1g. o \ Ird Ava a - Envirolesign ILSs ��ts �. ENGINEERS • ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PederaiH.Y H.Y. Rm VALID wmlour FN0NED1"�"i M07E►R A. nla, r.c S REO ICE. F N 1 Z z R Ali E n NO WXL 9 0E 6EPYiC 11IPM 2 Q :per loo' or ❑E6'r PROPEE77 LINE c T O v@ :l 4 S` '= C 71 \ �• n� am L4 � Nm er z^,p� i S R E§ 'o y oi 4.g ' q Q �a D m 1� k � Joh / ��g VZ,1 m f� UU ❑ ❑v m z r, ON 2yc n +4.89 �\ +5.J"! 1+5.33 IIrWATE • � p I \ 45.1 a; I % Lj_ I I IU $�A{,i-� — H _ a 1— R.52 ppMIA FA4i �N1 I r-----43.1"ra' €'3afi—" 1� +� d SEPRC sYSTEIA I j pbd lax To PROP1 I u+� WATER SERVICE I I' I ' I I' 1 , I I` I is I ' I I I I P4 4 I I ly I I' I I' I C1 I I I l I I I II � I of * I �T Er tr I � o I I o I a I I I --LST - 9.5] HIM 0 a o 4.4 r W ar\ 0 flIM+4.]J +1.6 :1.M +4,59 1+5.22 +5.19 lod c.9. -- +9.61 a M+9.5] 'C' MARK) a a a NOTNO.L9 OE SKMC ■MOR I G PNVAIE 100' Or EmPROPERW LMN a a �a ua a x = a � � n an°T npp Gi. S 3� u� 3xm iS a 0 gnN 33 V ^�N 3a6 '°O daon°� d � RH A��d a v_ n6 Oo- Sn $.�$Q a•z a 33 seCzC 3 3o- ox`�e. a. y O O N 3 g y 3 y o �$ gI a 3� 34 �> da 'a �r3�� 3s o-'3 a sAmv G. aE �agm' a4 m, ffRR'msoo �go-m;SS S as a 9.xv gg d°uvsm Cl 3 °� Bu P,a 33 n Aa QON�6. o -•c a'G '° 3a���mm! Rhi x m[ y0 m u �'°mi+t a my r •aygyj I I ao, o m 4.8' TO rPROPERTY LINE +k Beo RQg � j d � o ��83� CCC x 1004 Br myg � e 6.8' �xry io 9.1' TO msT sEPIIC sysim m- NAI m b° W o o \ Ird Ava a - Envirolesign ILSs ��ts �. ENGINEERS • ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PederaiH.Y H.Y. Rm VALID wmlour FN0NED1"�"i M07E►R A. nla, r.c S REO ICE. F N 1 Z z R Ali E n o� 2 Q :per � c T O v@ :l 4 S` '= C 71 g o3 m L4 �• n� r L4 � Nm er z^,p� i S R E§ 'o y oi 4.g ' q Q �a D m 1� k � Joh / ��g wg� m f� UU ❑ ❑v m z e Q K n I HIM 0 a o 4.4 r W ar\ 0 flIM+4.]J +1.6 :1.M +4,59 1+5.22 +5.19 lod c.9. -- +9.61 a M+9.5] 'C' MARK) a a a NOTNO.L9 OE SKMC ■MOR I G PNVAIE 100' Or EmPROPERW LMN a a �a ua a x = a � � n an°T npp Gi. S 3� u� 3xm iS a 0 gnN 33 V ^�N 3a6 '°O daon°� d � RH A��d a v_ n6 Oo- Sn $.�$Q a•z a 33 seCzC 3 3o- ox`�e. a. y O O N 3 g y 3 y o �$ gI a 3� 34 �> da 'a �r3�� 3s o-'3 a sAmv G. aE �agm' a4 m, ffRR'msoo �go-m;SS S as a 9.xv gg d°uvsm Cl 3 °� Bu P,a 33 n Aa QON�6. o -•c a'G '° 3a���mm! Rhi x m[ y0 m u �'°mi+t a my r •aygyj I I ao, o m 4.8' TO rPROPERTY LINE +k Beo RQg � j d � o ��83� CCC x 1004 Br myg � e 6.8' �xry io 9.1' TO msT sEPIIC sysim m- NAI 0 m 0 m b° W o o \ Ird Ava a - Envirolesign ILSs ��ts �. ENGINEERS • ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PederaiH.Y H.Y. Rm VALID wmlour FN0NED1"�"i M07E►R A. nla, r.c S REO ICE. F �• "ATS ItivetoRs tn: .. - R 8�yO g E n G F 2 Q :per a c T O v@ :l 4 S` '= C 71 •G' �• p4 (D m� w0 J N er z^,p� i S R E§ 'o y oi 4.g ' q 4 2 � 220 M Z 'a � $ / ��g wg� m SSy v ❑ ❑v m > e s °egg° s GIN IL ASF zm� > o� irr o ; zRE s i s 0 m 0 W o "tl o t31 'a m b° W o o \ Ird Ava a - Envirolesign ILSs ��ts �. ENGINEERS • ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS PederaiH.Y H.Y. Rm VALID wmlour FN0NED1"�"i M07E►R A. nla, r.c S REO ICE. F �• "ATS ItivetoRs tn: NE 7th Ave - -- -Z I1 L1 NE Rih Avc D E n G F NE 9th Avc : m �. IS4n Trail m a = Y r n V CWS Ave (D m� W o "tl o t31 'a m b° W o o \ ey � Envirolesign ILSs ��ts �. ENGINEERS • ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS SEPTIC SYSTEM PLAN FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Rm VALID wmlour FN0NED1"�"i M07E►R A. nla, r.c S REO ICE. F �• "ATS ItivetoRs tn: FLORIDAle (;row E OF wmy Beach Na eSOR 298 OPinmIDA C Grave Way AUIH RIZAT Fltxlda 35444 Phony. 581 274-8500 Fo>c 581 274-6558 0:\2013\13096—Cook Residence—Lot 2 HV—Bridges Marsh\DWG\13096—ENG.dwg, 1/15/2014 8:40:16 AM, 11" x 17" n i s O;E o O c � BHN Ii r �a m m T q, o 5 1201 bti A-0 I ;:l, 4 oz sa Izm uM 44 z IaS S z HIM - C r IIF RAI r(��ANI r$rg'� Cv ON a7 ;V O C J ffWE 'I Z5. A '1:0 m� A 3 ;yon_ � m N WIN F p>ga n 1-1 �g ®® �� z1 O ia- HUR $ p m 0 x C o g K n yz �i BHN Ii r �a m m T 941 p. mm rcr�jQ >ym� t r e A 510n H TSO P��4� >_05 86. qE UN RIP pal12g -1 Z q, o 5 1201 bti A-0 I ;:l, t oz sa Izm uM � �j>$i�j$$�j�gjj gS < 0 IaS 9S IqSLIA HIM - C r IIF RAI r(��ANI r$rg'� Cv TNM > S ;V E�A J ffWE 'I Z5. R %M cSE PUH rm �I m� A 3 ;yon_ � x WIN 9 m ggn S>d� QL FQ n 1-1 �g Z �� z1 O ia- HUR 8i'y� Fri cziQiA� gZ, E 0 x C �s x yz �i �a � A x0 �� y yi51 iiig555'JzISM m ig$m y 0 >u.;. ami 3mo N'A" �i{m{(��� n mo TL o104$>g O z � 4g, v�Q HmT 1SA 7EMr NOT ' > �v g d 4$ Amg v-18 (4E PUH FOR 9iE R �� Q °z AND mumu z �k N >ayx PH e $�j i'���i-ii H mom mm � ��� u J ii o ar 10E jn x�z up 15z$F + 4 q cx Q� ��m 3E y x jQ _> 1g ��� PH zn��x y� xsiB� g< n � 4 'm"> g pm S i �, TzQ xqg Fm�C��F L v 04mQ c$ y�Tz t 941 p. mm rcr�jQ >ym� t r e A 510n H TSO P��4� >_05 86. qE UN RIP pal12g -1 Z q, o 5 1201 bti A-0 I ;:l, t oz sa Izm uM � �j>$i�j$$�j�gjj gS < 0 IaS 9S IqSLIA HIM - C Q IIF RAI r(��ANI r$rg'� Cv NITF a y 5� g gQ y ciQ ;V , J ffWE 'I Z5. R 4 �SQ� of O�$iUI a�F, m� A 3 ;yon_ � 5$; -W, tog WIN 9 m ggn S>d� QL FQ n 1-1 �g Z (�n>Cvz H �c n n z1 O ia- HUR 8i'y� Fri cziQiA� gZ, E m z >4{ Ill x yz �i x � A 5j �'i mZS �� y yi51 iiig555'JzISM m ig$m iQ'i m -a }� �mFFi >u.;. ami 3mo N'A" �i{m{(��� n mo TL o104$>g o� � 4g, v�Q ' > �v g 4$ Amg v-18 R �� T�*1 n °z �k N >ayx PH Qcm PIP Q �;J $�j i'���i-ii H mom mm � ��� u J ii o ar 10E jn x�z up 15z$F + 4 q cx Q� ��m 3E y x jQ _> 1g ��� PH zn��x y� xsiB� g< n � 4 'm"> g pm S i �, TzQ xqg Fm�C��F L v 04mQ c$ y�Tz t �g L i�mZ4� p 941 p. mm rcr�jQ >ym� t r e A 510n H TSO P��4� >_05 86. qE UN RIP pal12g -1 Z q, o 5 1201 bti A-0 I ;:l, t oz sa Izm uM � �j>$i�j$$�j�gjj gS < ���<g�9JJJf��p�oo<<gCC�� fps { g6. y pIr, ill IqSLIA HIM am C Q IIF RAI r(��ANI r$rg'� Cv NITF a y 5� g gQ y ciQ ;V , J ffWE 'I Z5. R 4 �SQ� of O�$iUI a�F, m� A 3 ;yon_ � 5$; -W, tog O N 0 m O it rd O __ 7 b q, o 5 1201 bti A-0 I ;:l, t oz sa Izm uM � �j>$i�j$$�j�gjj gS < ���<g�9JJJf��p�oo<<gCC�� fps { g6. y pIr, ill IqSLIA HIM am Z Rho Agog �g IIF RAI r(��ANI r$rg'� p.T N 011 $ra� $�fl' NITF a y 5� g gQ y ciQ v 4" Cz J ffWE 'I Z5. R 4 �SQ� of O�$iUI a�F, m� A 3 NN >-N Fis�@ s@qA 5$; -W, tog WIN 9 m ggn S>d� QL FQ }iy :� 5 C5 vlgp�0[[}x�G� oyq�gi 1-1 �g Z (�n>Cvz H �c n n z1 O ia- P P f P r Z y 11; N m'm 11'r ” Jill JF y A� I 16 q, o 5 1201 bti A-0 I ;:l, SEPTIC SYSTEM DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA nill sip uM � �j>$i�j$$�j�gjj gS < ���<g�9JJJf��p�oo<<gCC�� fps { g6. o 'tl o N ' q, o 5 \•. bti EnviroDestgn Ics� ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS SEPTIC SYSTEM DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA — — wmroor tl10MEEe5 XAI' JDFL R A. AIDE. 1.L s 9D9 / m P � O DAM "�°I Yr: � �j>$i�j$$�j�gjj gS < ���<g�9JJJf��p�oo<<gCC�� fps { g6. >R>yp ps 4 o y pIr, ill IqSLIA HIM "llffl Z Rho Agog �g IIF RAI r(��ANI r$rg'� p.T N 011 $ra� $�fl' NITF a y 5� g gQ y ciQ v 4" om �ajLa �Hil m LQ m z g 4 �SQ� of O�$iUI a�F, j� � � jig 'zig �� m�m NN >-N Fis�@ s@qA 5$; -W, tog WIN � N'� NKS m ggn S>d� QL FQ }iy :� 5 C5 vlgp�0[[}x�G� oyq�gi 1-1 �g m o ��Q (�n>Cvz H �c n n z1 O ia- HUR 8i'y� Fri cziQiA� gZ, E m z >4{ e e_ I; -a � QQ Q �Z yz �i ��g�IS-J -ly RRnnii O mF�ng 5j �'i mZS �� ����,,m��,{({{((� g 'y�n=p yi51 iiig555'JzISM OQbQ52 �~ ig$m iQ'i m -a }� �mFFi >u.;. ami 3mo N'A" �i{m{(��� Q=Tz Ov mo TL o104$>g o� � 4g, v�Q $ m m > �v g 4$ Amg v-18 R �� T�*1 n r� •N' cm m >$�z5 v Kmz 5 N >ayx PH Qcm PIP Q �;J $�j i'���i-ii H mom mm � ��� u J ii o ar 10E jn x�z up 15z$F + 4 q cx Q� ��m 3E y 0 rr*t fn jQ _> 1g ��� PH zn��x y� xsiB� g< n � 4 'm"> g pm i �, TzQ xqg Fm�C��F L v 04mQ c$ y�Tz t �g L i�mZ4� p u m mcx n'^ -Rl gg icziFm F� FT=C n L - - 'MR 9F/yz v $6 Qa� $ORR gz iv n$> LL AFI y� �25 H � pgp�j �z $ SRI X2, mm� y�mNivmL In ��l^$ m Q� �ii�g $v z � > v A> vii �y m<g �m Y m v o 'tl o N ' q, o 5 \•. bti EnviroDestgn Ics� ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS SEPTIC SYSTEM DETAILS FOR: HARBOR VIEW ESTATES LOT 2 — 1226 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM, FLORIDA — — wmroor tl10MEEe5 XAI' JDFL R A. AIDE. 1.L s 9D9 / m P � O DAM "�°I Yr: p FlJDRIDAin—p 1. G.CAlE y gmy B1ZATIONwcL Na E90E 298 561) 2 4 65M Way Ddmy Beach, Florida 33444 PhoaY:(Set 274-BS00 Fme 561 274-6556 0:\2013\13096—Cook Residence—Lot 2 HV—Bridges Marsh\DWG\13096—HOOT—DTL.dwg, 1/15/2014 8:50:55 AM, 11" x 17" n � / / Ar D W000 EASOOff I I I I I TMWA I I RAW I Ii I I ------------ ---. I 0 ---;------------------P---� y S R I I I Fn I I ---�iA> I I D2NAlM E0PARMIX EIS --------- I --------------------------- D awl co �� d-; �f P � - I l a I I I I I I N ' i I Nlp ; 99 1 ❑ ❑ i I I 1 1 PPS P P P Y N Y Ipq U m pp S -11 R, JAI ------ ---L ELF----------- --- —= -- ----- — o 0 C. rl 61 f 1C DIWIALE __J—_____—__—_ N + u is d • I&ANA.EE �1r4 I — �----------- — m $ 6 s � ig �e��� Ig --- — 1 £c o Y loll € 1 , La Pq F o� = g o� �: N 'L4 M _o v� \ m v_ 0 Z \ m v = m qp in [L� \ 3 �kQ r Z a oz gji� Alm' A �� l Dry m�88 o n - m gig011 " D EIIOY NO. POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN FOR: I=VAM DATE: IIEWp47: m: Li0 10 t om EnviroDeslgn HARBOR VIEW ESTATES � W x WIER Associates ice. "tl o 9 - ENGINEERS •ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS LOT 2 - 1226 N OCEAN BLVD FiORIOA cmnFlCATE OF Autrfam7arror+ N. 05M GULF STREAM, FLORIDA FL RED �,��„ 298 Pheoppls Grove Way DNray Beech, Florida 33444 J031" A. PIKE. 0:\2013\13096 -Cook Residence -Lot 2 HV -Bridges ►.E. Phone: 581 274-8500 Fa>c 581 274-8558 Marsh\DWG\13096-ENG.dwg, 1/15/2014 8:40:51 AM, 11" x 17" TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 014-03 Address: 1226 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/ M Bryan Cook Agent: Mark Marsh/ Nievera William Construction of a partial two story single family Angelo Carribbean style dwelling Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Angelo Carribbean style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest quarters and pool, a total of 9,403 SF. Gross Lot size: 48,509 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 9,403 SF Zoning District: RS -O Finished Floor: 16.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Effective Lot Area: 34,110 SF Allowable: 9,422 SF Height: 28' 4" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Angelo Carribbean style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest quarters and pool, a total of 9,403 SFmeet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 2. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 3. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. 4. Any work on the seawall, seawall cap and existing dock shall conform to Section 66-369 Docks. Architectural Review and Planning Board ARPB File #014-02 ARPB February 27, 2014; TC March 14, 2014 ARPB Date: February 27, 2014 Action: Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: TC Date: March 14, 2014 Action: Level III Architectural/ Site Plan: Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM I- RECEIVED t JAN 15 2014 Town of Gulfstream, R APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL .........� This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File #j_y To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: Mr . & Mrs. Bryan Cook I.A.2. Project Address: 1226 N Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See attached I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) New Two Story Residence I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: 4'O�3 sq. f t Architectural Style: Anglo Carribbean 1.A.6. Check all that apply: KX4rchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: +16.01 Type of Foundation: stem wall B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 7707 Forsyth Blvd., St.Louis, MO 63105 I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: 314-746-4600 I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information Fax: I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: M. Mark Marsh/Bridges, Marsh & Assor- I.C.2. Agent Address: 1 R v; A/ M, --_—, — , _ _ I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o)1 ./1�42 - A? 3 3 1_C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: KOfficial Use Only PB Date: 30mmendation: Date: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Fax 561.832. 1520 Page 2 Town of Gulf Stream k,- RECEIVED 44 PART III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION - AN 15 id+i ,ewn of To be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town Staff. Please be�11� F� concise brief. Attach additional sheets only when necessary and be sure to include thea nclse but question number for each response. appropriate and complete A. Project Description and Justification III.A.1. In what zoning district is the project site located? Ocean West III.A.2. Is the project compatible with the intent of the zoning district? IR Yes ❑ No Explain. Meets all the criteria recru.ired for t he 7"Wincl t III.A.3. Is the project consistent with the Future Land Use Map and goals, objectives and policies of the Comprehensive Plan? p Yes ❑ No Explain. Proposed residenti of the future land use III.A.4. How are ingress and egress to the property to be provided? Prive driveways from private roadway. III.A.5. How are the following utilities to be provided to the property? a. StormwaterDrainage_ on Gto i b. Sanitary Sewer septic c. Potable Water cit d. Irrigation Water cit e. Electricity FP&L f. Telephone AT&T g. Gas FPU h. Cable Television Comcast III.A.6. If the project involves the erection of one or more structures, please describe how the structures are consistent with the criteria in Section 66-144 of the Town of Gulf Stream Code. (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) N PART IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Section A is to be completed by all applicants after pre -application conference with Town staff. Answering "Yes" to any question in Section A requires the completion of additional Sections as indicated. A. Additional Approvals/Requirements IV.A.1. Does the project involve land area within fifty feet (50') of the A1A (North Ocean Boulevard) right-of- way? ❑ Yes 1;No (If "Yes", section B of this part must be completed.) IV.A.2. Does the project involve the demolition of one or more structures? ❑ Yes 0 No (If "Yes", section C of this part must be completed.) IV.A.3. Does the project involve the clearing or filling of any portion of an existing vacant lot or more than fifty percent (50%) of the landscaped area of a developed lot? ❑ Yes IR No (If "Yes", section D of this part must be completed.) IV.A.5. Does the project require approval of a Special Exception? ❑ Yes 0 No (If "Yes", section E of this part must be completed.) IV.A.6. Is the project at variance with any regulations contained in the Zoning Code? ❑ Yes IR No (If "Yes", section G of this part must be completed.) Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 3 s "A -n or uulf stream H. Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.H.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? N/A IV -H.2. If the project involves a rezoning, , Zoning Code text change, Future Land Use g please d °r any combination thereof, Map change, Comprehensive Plan text change, the need and justification for the request. PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. Applicants are encouraged, but not re additional relevant information regarding the project that was not covered elsewhere on this form or on any of the other materials submitted with the application. required, to provide any Proposed new 2_ story residence within a 6 unit subdivision The Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8100 Page 7 CHAIRMAN: VICE CHAIRMAN: BOARD MEMBER: ALTERNATE MEMBER Scott Morgan Thomas Smith Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Amanda Jones Malcolm Murphy Hewlett Kent Robert Dockerty February 21, 2014 REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING BEING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA ON THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2014 AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS OF THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. AGENDA I. Call to Order. II. Roll Call. III. Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing of 1-23-14. IV. Additions, withdrawals, deferrals, arrangement of agenda items. V. Announcements. A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing a. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. C. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. June 26, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. July 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. f. There is no meeting in August VI. PUBLIC HEARING. A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by Mark Marsh of Bridges & Marsh, as Agent for Mr. & Mrs. Nelson Grumney, the owners of property located at 2960 Polo Drive, Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described as Lot 21 Gulf Stream Cove Subdivision. a. SPECIAL EXCEPTION to permit the addition of a spa, that will encroach 4.34 ft. into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 ft. into the west setback. b. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL SITE PLAN REVIEW to allow the construction of a spa which will encroach 4.34 ft. into the west setback and will be attached to and become a part of the existing pool that encroaches 6.42 ft. into the west setback. 2. An application submitted by Mark Marsh and Nievera Williams as agents for Mr. & Mrs. Bryan Cook, owners of property located at 1226 North Ocean Boulevard, Gulf Stream, Florida, legally described as Lot 2, Hidden Harbour Estates Plat Two. a. LEVEL 3 ARCHITECTURAL/SITE PLAN REVIEW to permit the construction of a partial 2 story, Anglo Carribbean style single family dwelling with guest quarters and a three car garage, a total of 9,403 sq. feet, and a swimming pool. VII. Items by Staff. VIII. Items by Board Members. AGENDA CONTINUED IX. Public. X. Adjournment. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, SAID PARTY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, MAY NEED TO INSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 286.0105, F.S.S. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING HELD BY THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING BOARD OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ON THURSDAY, JANUARY 23, 2014, AT 8:30 A.M., IN THE TOWN HALL, 100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA. I. Call to Order: Vice -Chairman Smith called the meeting to order at 8:32 A.M II. Roll Call: Present and Thomas Smith Vice -Chairman Participating Paul A. Lyons, Jr. Board Member Amanda Jones Board Member Malcolm Murphy Board Member Robert Dockerty Alternate Board Member Hewlett Kent Alternate Board Member Absent w/Notice Scott Morgan Chairman Also Present and William H. Thrasher Town Manager Participating Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk John C. Randolph Town Counsel David Bodker Landscape Architect Christopher O'Hare Resident III. Minutes: A. Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held on December 19, 2013 Board Member Lyons moved and Board Member Jones seconded to approve the December 19, 2013 Minutes of the Regular Meeting and Public Hearing held by the Architectural Review Board. All voted AYE. IV. Additions, Withdrawals, Deferrals, Arrangement of Agenda Items: There were none. V. Announcements: A. Meeting Dates 1. Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Dates Chairman Morgan announced the following approved upcoming ARPB meeting dates and asked for any conflicts. a. February 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. b. March 27, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. c. April 24, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. d. May 22, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. e. June 26, 2014 @ 8:30 A.M. Alternate Board Member Kent reported that he cannot attend the February 27' ARPB Meeting. Board Member Jones also reported that she may be unable to attend the February 27`" ARPB Meeting, and will contact Town Clerk Taylor if that is the case. ARPB - Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam January 23, 2014 — Page 2 Town Clerk Taylor swore in David Bodker, and asked if there was any ex -parte communication, and there was none. VI. PUBLIC HEARING: A. Applications for Development Approval 1. An application submitted by David Bodker, David Bodker Landscape Architecture/Planning, Inc. as Agent for Robert Julien, the owner of property located at 1601 N. Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream, Florida, which is legally described in metes and bounds in Section 10, Township 46 South, range 43 east. a. NORTH OCEAN BOULEVARD OVERLAY PERMIT to permit installation of paver bricks over existing concrete driveway. Mr. Bodker introduced himself and stated that this application is for the repaving of the gravel driveway at 1601 N. Ocean Blvd. He reported that that he will be utilizing a red Dominican brick which he displayed and distributed samples amongst the ARPB Members for their review. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if the brick was new or recycled. Mr. Bodker responded that he did not know the answer, but stated that the some type of brick was utilized on the driveway 3 or 4 driveways south of this residence. He also stated that he received a Department of Transportation Permit for the portion of the driveway which is in the public right of way. Mr. Bodker further commented that the new brick will be installed on top of the existing concrete after removing the gravel. He described and displayed his photographs of the brick border along the perimeter of the driveway, and described and displayed the area where the owners requested the concrete auxiliary area. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if that area would be unfinished concrete. Mr. Bodker responded that it will be a light broom finish. He continued that it will be for auxiliary parking. He stated that according to DOT requirements, there has to be 3' of asphalt past the driveway. Vice -Chairman Smith inquired if the driveway will have the exact same configuration as it has at present. Mr. Bodker responded "Yes". Alternate Board Member Kent stated that it looks a lot better with the brick paver rather than the concrete. He continued that there will be no weeds or pesticide used to kill the weeds with concrete under the bricks. Mr. Bodker also stated that this property is heavily screened with landscape material. Town Clerk Taylor swore in Christopher O'Hare. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam January 23, 7014 — Page 3 Mr. O'Hare commended Mr. Bodker on a job well done. He commented on the number of Board Members present just to approve a brick paver on an existing driveway. Mr. O'Hare pointed out that the code states that brick pavers are preferred because they are pervious and better for drainage. He inquired why the concrete is being kept on this project, and the pavers being installed over it. Alternate Board Member Kent replied it depends on the size of the lot and the ratio of the pervious area as to whether the concrete is acceptable. Mr. Bodker stated that this was already a paved driveway, and the pervious area that is required has been exceeded. Mr. O'Hare stated that he had no problems with the merits of Mr. Bodker's application, but was questioning the members of the body about what was preferred and not preferred. Alternate Board Member Kent stated that there had to be ten (10) persons here for approval of this application because the property is along A1A, a State road, requiring a North Ocean Blvd. approval. Mr. O'Hare also stated he had an issue regarding last month's minutes referring to Town Manager Thrasher's comment with regard to a new policy with plants listed in Section 70-150. He inquired why he was prosecuted by the Town in 2013 for having certain plants, on his property and wondered if that policy was changed. Town Manager Thrasher responded that neither the code or policy has changed in that regard. Board Member Murphy moved and Alternate Board Member Kent seconded to approve the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit to replace the existing concrete and gravel driveway and driveway approach with paver brick. All vote AYE. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF: There were none. VIII. ITEMS BY BOARD MEMBERS: There were none. IX. PUBLIC: There were no additional comments from the public. X. ADJOURNMENT: Vice -Chairman Smith adjourned the meeting at 8:45 A.M. ARPB Regular Meeting & Public Hearing Town of Gulf Sueam January 23, 7014 — Page 4 Sandra Fein Recording Secretary TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 013-07 Address: 2960 Polo Drive Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/ M Nelson Grumney Agent: Mark Marsh, Bridges, Marsh & Associates Construct and attach spa to existing pool. Special Exception To permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback. Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan To permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback. Gross Lot size: 18,519 SF Zoning District: RS -C: GS Core Considered During Review: Effective Lot Area: 17,996 SF Section 70-75 Special exception setbacks Note: Standards of approval for both special exceptions are met. Staff Recommendation: Motion to Recommend Approval of a Special Exception to permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback. Motion to Recommend Approval of a Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review to permit the addition of a spa that will encroach 4.34 feet into the west setback, which will be attached to and become a part of the existing swimming pool that encroaches 6.42 feet into the west setback based on a finding that the proposed construction meet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards. ARPB Date: February 27, 2014 Action: Special Exception (1): Level 3 Architectural /Site Plan Review: Town Commission: March 14, 2014 Action: Special Exception: Level 3 Architectural/ Site Plan Review: Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM RECEIVED JAN I('1 014 !�ta�,�rr �;� t�tllfstrrarll. rl APPLICATION FO1. R 1. DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File J/ To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. ProjecVOwner Name: I.A.2. Project Address: 2960 POLO DRIVE, GULF STREAM I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including 11 of stories, etc.) AD1�T_ TION OF A SPA Tn EXTSTTNG poo I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structure or Addition: N/A Architectural Style: n, i„ 1.A.6. Check all that apply: ❑ Architectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) 1.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: N/A Type of Foundation: pTT,TNG B. Owner Information I.B.1. Owner Address: 2960 POLO DRIVE GULF STREAM FL I.B.2. Owner Phone Num X31 47 n Fax: 314-567-3940 I.B.3. Owner Signa C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name:..BIRIDGE., MARSH & ASSnI /NIEVERA WIT T TAMC I.C.2. Agent Address: 18 VIA MIZNFR, P,4LM BEACH I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o)5_61 1.C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Dale: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: I cell ial Use Onl ARP Date: Rec iimendation: TC ate: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6113/00 Fax 832-1520 Page 2 Projects Requiring a Special Exception.pp JJ Is the proposed use a permitted special exception use? ,, i•(1Wri c1'i i.II,I�i:�ifi�,adi1I, IV.0 2 How Is the use Yes ❑ No designed, Code Section: 70_ �5 c�" welfare, and gned, located and Proposed to be o morals will be protected? perated so that the Public health, safety, --THE- PRnn.,-,-._ uvrill:ii WILL HAVE ALL REQUIRED PROTECTION FOR IV, E,3 Will the use cause substantial injury SAFETY be located? ❑ YeS ( No rY to the value of other Property in the neighborhoo d where it is to Explain. D�, � WILL BE- L�ovtcY STRUCTURE NO IMPACT TO VALUE P H OR NEIGHBORHOOD IV,E•4 I -low will the use be co PROPERTY is to be located? compatible with adjoining development and the character THE PRnnno,�.. __ of the District where it STRUCTURESFOUNy" L�L1'S SIMILAR POOL SPA D ON PROPERTIES WITHIN THE SURROUNDING IV.E•5, What landscaping and screening are provided? THE PROPOSED ADDITION WILL BE SCREENED EY _NE HEDGES EXISTING iV•E.� Does the use conform with all a located? ❑ Yes ❑ No pplicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be Explain. I EXISTING POOL -Q_&N i TC'un n'CF�T� STRUCTURE WITHIN AN SETBACK EXIS _r'ni\Tv,r F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.•1. If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them vv and ho they are to be maintained. N/A IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their potential impacts on properties, surrounding IV,F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions, Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 VMIROZOTI DO a am. o =LLaph O} man SFO JFinaO. p ONJ .-ZF,yO� O JO p 0 0 F O N m ti LL O- =ULL WOh O.o03c1,F0�1- ,F IL r zm mgo aLLN,50a. W. m !9 m ww''O uj N. LU w�LL Nam. W 200a' Q} zW3 li YF��OmO[w.f IY Wmooaz 0 =00 2� 3 0W R =. N =1U m � O�m OFm O zK awqa t°.1. °mzt. -ZZOJaa IL ul 0❑ J...I� W6O.FO}W �+• a O LL 'UtrLL h�6 O N aWLL soao xw .a H Z uj N J0: 2. 0?0.0 0 2 U3 LU �z as ac�woOPig .hU Ng', za � mF uz Ja¢ SS 2 a JW OOmw ww OWWWSOOW am JU0.m mmm W Fz0ca 3A I Ha 010d v CiL LU C=� M c W Q o � 3 GC'LLI 3.00,9E.90N o— — — — — — — — — — — — — — AE'LLi N.00,9C.90S J d s Nig `•� `, I I o Ns ❑' Wa v �3e0= pm w0oaw N 11'1 zco 0 N =W m OOw LLul O W r I o� 4z a z in -0 0°s w N = 0 a Om ¢ aawUea8 0n CO dLL2dN LL O U 4�n�NNZz ,�S J CO a. Lu a�bo¢z N 0 ~ ¢¢1 m. m .Ka FpOz m OOw C i1 1 ON vwz�oo o°z Q���0 wmam jw� iL \ cc Z N mmRUZO b v J ) wz uzol anE°€O m =o �aWS ¢ F y > W. m N F OaU� gg zw?¢DY a`S h rc7LLT5I N1 U-066¢ Z �00 O¢d�w�di z¢ma� U F�1N °x 0.� Aly=y wz m3€¢w.. b w y xO=Za o 0 maZ, N w az 3 U =o o acwuii3� � � I N � o � I � m m cm N� �- ,B9'If� o Z- C:) r, o 5f ZI 1000 000 .0Y'61 ,00'001 3.00,9b.90N 311d NIHdl00 0 0-�� 0 3Aoo H1noS N m �1 N M n �l � M Q �W p O WQOQM",, O Lu aZrnOM o �v O W IrS �� zin6w, 00 U) aLL w 00 a�U-W; OWZU' I� OL '21 O \ 30N30I S38 s. I I �moga AHo1S Z C:) �� � � � 1,05'f I �I J ,5e •Yf ` 0 $ a ` 9c:9' .55 11 'o y . 9,V .09'1 �MUM •� d319, ` 09'f .00-6 `��, ,� • I � �� �, - X66) cJ J o_ ,00'91 € -` I — — — — (�>$'9 •20� (.v- dY0 llYNY36 ,L 2_ Ns ❑' Wa v �3e0= pm w0oaw N 11'1 zco 0 N =W m OOw LLul O W r I o� 4z a z in -0 0°s w N = 0 a Om ¢ aawUea8 0n CO dLL2dN LL O U 4�n�NNZz ,�S J CO a. Lu a�bo¢z N 0 ~ ¢¢1 m. m .Ka FpOz m OOw C i1 1 ON vwz�oo o°z Q���0 wmam jw� iL \ cc Z N mmRUZO b v J ) wz uzol anE°€O m =o �aWS ¢ F y > W. m N F OaU� gg zw?¢DY a`S h rc7LLT5I N1 U-066¢ Z �00 O¢d�w�di z¢ma� U F�1N °x 0.� Aly=y wz m3€¢w.. b w y xO=Za o 0 maZ, N w az 3 U =o o acwuii3� � � I N � o � I � m m cm N� �- ,B9'If� o Z- C:) r, o 5f ZI 1000 000 .0Y'61 ,00'001 3.00,9b.90N 311d NIHdl00 0 0-�� 0 3Aoo H1noS N �1 N M n �l � M Q �W p O WQOQM",, O Lu aZrnOM o �v O W IrS �� zin6w, 00 U) aLL w 00 a�U-W; OWZU' I� Q C4 C9 O \ " -.9 lr��vlinsr:o�� N�� ��Z m�� R7 F3 P-1 d z 0 N W E- M M OT a Jh'',MtlbO OH 99Oi L CQ LL 5 s �� �� 8 _ o A -.-9a csm .4 ~s�e= 3 a��g<3�� xis � 31VOS NMXG U140 ON '7 Ma ,may 31Vn ��"I SNOISIAMI a Y gagC s b �� SFo3���������� pax�slip yf��a������ r 6x 5 s �� �� 8 _ o A -.-9a csm .4 ~s�e= 3 a��g<3�� xis � 31VOS NMXG U140 ON '7 Ma ,may 31Vn ��"I SNOISIAMI a H O w ��S rn W maanoo 0 7771 El 0 0 o f o j H /o.�� i Z1<a WU]Q I Z q$A YY Y < < mmi N m 7 I     ----- n --  E -r F�� I movam aamonas xaossaove ,oz = S n I s  3 ,00 ,G , SON Fr RN 8 1 ,00.001 A �� a GGG]]] O �� E = �� `: i x 8 e OO 10 U �� uj H O w ��S rn W maanoo 0 7771 El 0 0 o f o j /o.�� Z1<a WU]Q I I I     ----- --  F�� I movam aamonas xaossaove ,oz �� S n I    3 ,00 ,G , SON Fr RN 8 1 ,00.001 v a ����e is gag. Big dna ��owJ��9 �� a 0 80 oSm ������g��nr X90 <'Sm o��H ��m ic��im TOWN OF GULF STREAM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW AND PLANNING REPORT Application #: 014-03 Address: 1226 North Ocean Blvd. Proposed Improvement: Approvals Requested: Owner: M/ M Bryan Cook Agent: Mark Marsh/ Nievera William Construction of a partial two story single family Angelo Carribbean style dwelling Level III Architectural/Site Plan: To permit the construction of a partial two story single family Angelo Carribbean style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest quarters and pool, a total of 9,403 SF. Gross Lot size: 48,509 SF Effective Lot Area: 34,110 SF Proposed Total Floor Area: 9,403 SF Allowable: 9,422 SF Zoning District: RS -0 Height: 28' 4" (roof height <_ 30' Preferred) Finished Floor: 16.0' NGVD Issues Considered During Review: Section 70-67 Effective lot area Section 70-70 Floor area calculations Section 70-74 Setbacks Section 70-100 Roof and eave heights Section 70-187 Table of district standards Plat 2 Motion to recommend approval Level III Architectural/ Site Plan based on a finding that the proposed partial two story single family Angelo Carribbean style dwelling, a 3 car garage with guest quarters and pool, a total of 9,403 SFmeet the minimum intent of the Design Manual and applicable review standards with the following conditions: 1. Any minor modifications in the landscape plan shall be submitted to the Town Manager for review and approval and any major modifications shall be brought back to the ARPB for review and approval, prior to commencement of landscaping. 2. Wall and/or fences will be measured from the lowest abutting grade with a maximum height of 6' including any lighting fixtures that may be attached. 3. All chain link fencing will be screened from neighbor's view. 4. Any work on the seawall, seawall cap and existing dock shall conform to Section 66-369 Docks. ` 'Town of Gulf Stream TOWN OF GULF STREAM RECEIVED -4 SAN -t 5 2014 "()wn of Gulfstream, FI. APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL _.......,... _.,........_,..........,. _ .,,,:,...�..� ............. ,.,:......,..,:.. . This form is to be used for all development review applications to be heard by the Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board, Board of Adjustment, and/or Town Commission. To complete the form properly, please review the accompanying Town of Gulf Stream Instruction Manual for Application for Development Review Form. Failure to complete this form properly will delay its consideration. ARPB File Ili -I To be completed by all applicants. PART II. GENERAL INFORMATION A. Project Information I.A.1. Project/Owner Name: M.- & Mrs. Bryan Cook I.A.2. Project Address: 1226 N Ocean Blvd., Gulf Stream I.A.3. Project Property Legal Description: See attached I.A.4. Project Description (describe in detail, including # of stories, etc.) New Two Story Residence I.A.5. Square Footage of New Structureor Addition: 439 sq , f t Architectural Style: An to Carribbean I.A.6. Check all that apply: j4X4rchitectural/Site Plan Review ❑ Land Clearing ❑ North Ocean Boulevard Overlay (complete section B) ❑ Demolition of Structures ❑ Non-residential uses ❑ Variance (complete section G) ❑ Special Exception (complete section E) I.A.7. (a) Proposed F.F.E.: +16.01 B. Owner Information I.B.I. Owner Address: 7707 Fors Type of Foundation: stem wall Blvd., St.Louis, MO 63105 I.B.2. Owner Phone Number: 314-746-4600 Fax: I.B.3. Owner Signature: C. Agent Information I.C.1. Agent Name and Firm Name: M. Mark Marsh/Bridges, Marsh & ASSQc I.C.2. Agent Address: 1 R v; z M; --­ — , _ - I.C.3. Agent Phone Number: (o I_C.4. Agent Signature: Pre -App Date: App Date: Com Date: _ Decision: �fficial Use Only PB Date: ecommendation: Date: ��fj-- 1'/l—/ Application for Development Approval Form ADA.2000 revised 6/13/00 Fax 561 .832. 1 520 Page 2 ''U�Of (31-111' Stream �A H• Projects Requiring Rezoning IV.I-1.1. What is the Future Land Use designation of the project site? IV.H,2. If the project involves a rezoning, Comprehensive Plan text ezchange, , Zoning Code text change, justification for the request. °r any combination thereof, Future Land Use Map change, Please describe the need and PART V. OPTIONAL INFORMATION This entire Part is optional for all applicants. q additional relevant information regarding the Project thatts are encouraged, was not covered elsewheretnot re the other materials submitted with the application. required, to provide any on this form or on any of Proposed new 2—story residence within a 6 unit t subdivision The Architect, --i Application for Development Approval Form ADA. 2000 revised 6/8/00 Page 7 Town of Gulf Stream Ol- REUAr. ED ,SAN i J & B. Projects Requiring North Ocean Boulevard Overlay Permit Town of Gulfstream, FI, IV.B.1. What significant landscape features or architectural features are to be disturbed or added and to what extent? N/A IV.B.2. Describe the need and justification for the disturbance/addition: IV.B.3. Will the disturbance/addition destroy or seriously impair visual relationships among buildings, landscape features and open space, or introduce incompatible landscape features or plant material that destroys or impairs significant views or vistas within the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District? Yes No Explain: IV.B.4. How is the design consistent with the AM Landscape Enhancement Project? IV.B.5. What mitigation is proposed so that the disturbance/addition has the least impact possible to the visual and aesthetic quality of the North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: C. Projects Requiring a Demolition Permit IV.C.1. When are the existing structures to be demolished? N/A IV.C.2. When are the proposed structures to be constructed? IV.C.3. What is the landmark status of the structures to be demolished? D. Projects Requiring a Land Clearing Permit IV.D.1. Describe those vegetative materials of 8 inches in diameter and greater to be North Ocean Boulevard Overlay District: IV.D.2. Describe the need and justification for the removal/relocation: IV.D.3. How is the removal from the project site of vegetation to be mitigated: IV.D.4. How are the remaining and relocated vegetative materials to be protected and preserved during the land clearing and constriction activities and thereafter? IV.D.5. What replacement materials are proposed? Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 4 February 2002 E. Projects Requiring a Special Exception. IV.E.1. Is the proJAN ° 26 posed use a permitted special exception use? ❑ Yes ❑ No IV.E,2. How is the use Code Section; 'yam=_ designed, located and proposed to be operated so th welfare, and morals will be protected? at the public health, safety, — N/A IV.E,3. Will the use cause substantial in'u be located? 13Yes El No 1 ry to the value of other Property in the neighborhood where it is to Explain. IV,E,4, How will the use be compatible with adjoining development is to be located? 9 and the character of the District where it IV -E.5. What landscaping and screening are provided? IV•E•g. Does the use conform with all located? ❑ Yes El No applicable regulations governing the District wherein it is to be Explain. F. Non -Residential Projects and Residential Projects of Greater than 2 Units IV.F.1, If common area facilities are to be provided, describe them and how they are to be maintained. IV.F.2. If recreation facilities are to be provided, describe them and their ' Properties. r potential Impacts on surrounding ----------------- IV,F.3. For each of the following, list the number provided and their dimensions. Loading Spaces: Standard Parking Spaces: Small Car Parking Spaces: Handicapped Parking Spaces: Driveways/Aisles: Application for Development Approval Form ADA.32000 Page 5 of Gulf S G. Projects Requiring a Variance (code Section 66-150 through 157) IV.G.1. From what specific Zoning Code regulation is a variance requested? n/a IV.G.2. What does the Zoning Code require for this specific site? IV -G.3- What is proposed? IV.G.4. What is the total variance requested? PEIVED t JAN 15 2014 Town of Gulfstream, R IV -G.5. The following 8 mandatory variance findings from Section 66-154, must be addressed: (Attach additional sheet if necessary.) (1) What specific conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures, or buildings in the same zoning district? (2) Did the special conditions and circumstances result from the actions of the applicant? Yes No (3) Will granting the variance confer upon the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the Zoning Code to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes No Explain: (4) How would a literal interpretation of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the same terms of the ordinance and work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant? (5) Is the Variance requested the minimum variance that makes possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure? Yes No Explain: (6) Will granting the variance permit any prohibited use to be established or re-established: Yes No (7) Is the requested variance consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the future Land Use Map of the adopted Comprehensive Plan? Yes No (8) Will the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes No Explain: Application for Development Approval, Form ADA.32000 Page 6 February 2002 f lI(�C3y]f V, 0 u �romya 9dn v 10'1 L, 0 , W� N Z o 51 Z �x NV300 0/1 NV71 d 6 Q m-7— go ggae LL_ -1 Rpq R� q a� Vq./ v 4 3 ti,N tiN 1_N tiQQV�' 7b'1Sy�pJ S q M. ti n Q �E Q 1-2 Dw NV3 MNYl1Y Y.W 1N343SY3 SS3.�0YlpY� — Y�-y py�I',P �J e� U_ > N Cc 1C3 Z CO O u �romya 9dn v 10'1 L, 0 , W� N Z o 51 Z �x NV300 0/1 NV71 d 6 Q m-7— go ggae LL_ -1 Rpq R� q a� Vq./ v 4 3 ti,N tiN 1_N tiQQV�' 7b'1Sy�pJ S q M. ti n Q �E Q 1-2 Dw NV3 MNYl1Y Y.W 1N343SY3 SS3.�0YlpY� — Y�-y py�I',P �J e� �m O� Co I wil iNvnnSNOO was =o z N W li ¢vim Wa�Z � � U �OlL2 O U Q w=a3 w -a po�a o_ p=aa zQaw pUn Om0 U G Q < O �JZ oma a azo w U _ Ulm p� W VI V N U M Q Ow -- -z- Odom z E O w ¢ a z -- ¢ Y W J ral .p !N M F Cl)V aJ< V1 F J a a w aW of w - m p Z m Oz mo Zoo. m¢¢�n s 7,,Tv ON eor a,,vos :'aa NNS orl ;,�a 9 3 F a 5 t g u �� �Sg„�g •- •II �3ea5d�€u SNOISIA IH "^ EEEE�� Ili. o� I � I I 1 I I I I I I s i r-- --L ----1 - } -- romilaillip—M! 1 IJ I 0 Z AN h co co I I I I I r cP • eA � 6 c a c m c n W Z Y N Z Z MW I�+N L� N N N p< E Z Z z Om O lV n II A o w vwi W E z z z z z z z o d O �mm o n o cl rn t` On m o Ir Q Q' Q y Q W ~ pQ O a a ¢ a ¢ O S N N m 2 Z 2 Z Z Z Z -j O N Oi E� W Q V1 � LLI V/Z a o a Z Q w w m wLd W o w a F o w w w ¢ ¢ < a¢ m a a v O a s m Z Z ~U 5 3 vUi z _jN a p 0 o U U p o $$ N$ a= m n Q K z 0 w Z3 a Q r a a < a E C7 W li N N a (y U O O O O O =o z N W li ¢vim Wa�Z � � U �OlL2 O U Q w=a3 w -a po�a o_ p=aa zQaw pUn Om0 U G Q < O �JZ oma a azo w U _ Ulm p� W VI V N U M Q Ow -- -z- Odom z E O w ¢ a z -- ¢ Y W J ral .p !N M F Cl)V aJ< V1 F J a a w aW of w - m p Z m Oz mo Zoo. m¢¢�n s 7,,Tv ON eor a,,vos :'aa NNS orl ;,�a 9 3 F a 5 t g u �� �Sg„�g •- •II �3ea5d�€u SNOISIA IH "^ EEEE�� Ili. o� I � I I 1 I I I I I I s i r-- --L ----1 - } -- romilaillip—M! 1 IJ I 0 Z AN h co co I I I I I r cP • eA � 6 31d - J.'4J NH7 Ot! J�.10 O � ® II Aida SNOISIA 21 e � Y e$tl��q��� cea#Rg°�gpa� 31d - J.'4J NH7 Ot! J�.10 O � ® II Aida SNOISIA 21 ME 1NviinSN0O D'_i '�1; :'.1VL+�7 ON Ellp D -, o W � 0. U a s� 31V75 lwb 'NHS ON '9'AO m n 0 V Z MOOD n sNOISIA38 _—__. _._ --— ❑ ❑cn F \ / w n - .01-,Zl ,Z ,Z w I I I w w � W x x 13 \ / \ / aHill N \ / x F a W ao t .Q a a lip co U U 3 — — � , II II II II II I zap — J3a I � II II II II II I E. I I I---I-r-----11-----I-—rtl----II x-� I II II I II I 11 I3 11 I I F �® --IT---1 F----71---� I I II II II II II II I I II II II II II I o •o (�° I r----- � I � I I I I � I � I I � I L--------- I I \ / II � Z .L—,Y z €gQgg YL YY ;g�2 Lgtla�p b�8 e�C�Be§�§p�p%�� 31V75 lwb 'NHS ON '9'AO m n 0 V Z MOOD n sNOISIA38 _—__. _._ --— ❑ ❑cn F \ / w n - .01-,Zl ,Z ,Z w I I I w w � W x x 13 \ / \ / aHill N \ / x F a W ao t .Q a a lip co U U 3 — — � , II II II II II I zap — J3a I � II II II II II I E. I I I---I-r-----11-----I-—rtl----II x-� I II II I II I 11 I3 11 I I F �® --IT---1 F----71---� I I II II II II II II I I II II II II II I o •o (�° I r----- � I � I I I I � I � I I � I L--------- I I \ / II � Z .L—,Y z 7U 1NV11N5N00 w Ot:'..".1 �'EO '"N EOi' 31VO5 !,'1L� NHJ ON 'O:AO _ p.mr�K, pi y �$ 3co 9 �y n siva V'Y/ Cw.7 o u m O V] cue w ` z isg�yJ` �eE��� Sfi w FgQg q�q qp �sl€ g c b 111d n pq 'w a �+ iYi s biv F� 6 =fie € §w S � ��a srioOA]d 0: z z ID �/a m 1NviinsNOJ lvtl s N n vi N q W U C u W �a Li LLEcoT 1.NJ NH7 0.l '0:.10 co sNoisinaa Z a a y p RIP gy Rgg^ 3$ LLEcoT 1.NJ NH7 0.l '0:.10 co sNoisinaa Z a a 2 § \ka 2 § § R § J V51 ON 91MC) \ - ��� . 9 a ' (' � |Mm !§ P J V51 ON 91MC) \ - ��� . 9 a P P2) !§ P \H LSE 11N EDP z z W J o i 6°�6 5$�eEy�,FF 2 c �e��YEi f)m��8388�4 d SMEN ON III i moOM m MOM MOM I I I \H LSE 11N EDP z z W J o 3�V�5 !l.1d 'NHS O �J "J lAd z z El SNOISIAM Gail �9i�3� 6°�6 5$�eEy�,FF 2 c �e��YEi f)m��8388�4 d 3�V�5 !l.1d 'NHS O �J "J lAd z z El SNOISIAM Q w .o -,I • ,r 9lv�s K- AbvnNvr sl F o n f O V W � r z LL a_q O N9- vdltlO7j'Wv3tl15 j,n9 30N341S3t1 N00D Z 3� aw n m M v c `��� s � J a NVId 311S > maLL > F Z E m w Z ---------r---------------------------------------------------------r------ W - - , az L— cca Q o IV d 100918 IV] I I / \ 1Nd JSVI / Od JiVAIdd ,oz I I F—I0 � 00 - - -QD \ 00 00 00 \ 00 EJ 9� A009 1V]d) 1NdN3SV3 39VNIVda �.n I i � a Z 5 aLLJ P1-0 �� C a Za -� �^ °ow oo �q°g� od oaN� niO M -: 'puu -� a U ° �/ry W•• a�>0 oz aN0 QO �l7 J. 176 J U FF Y 0 V CO CV Q ¢ c �a = Oen iw »No Nn z�wo w n H mww _^Ln / �. Q N w J N u U Z" m a0 CL Q J O H2 N d Nb3000I1NVl1V Nb30o N1tlON O � O AbMtl31b M 7b15bOObtl1 9/ ` NI 1 Q £tot d3awaom of .0 f c stoc AtivnNVf St .n U r i w� vatimi'Hums jinn d1OL AtlVfltl83j ti a J o" >o a LL a 30NaIS3i MOOD3: J ohm a a N'dld 3dVOS4tIdH F Z E m a w Z t t 1 L----- - Jr� ef _ I - g iM o u d ws= Gt I a a g y �sllI G I I I I I " I---------- �i R 9 tI x EI W t; I I o d o I N I �r �i Mo. 0 s I I r I I o Mt I " In I --- — — — — — — — — — — — — — --- — — — — — —� — I — II— _ I WLS — W15 — W15 — WLS — W15 I - - W15 — W1 II W15 — "IS —} W15 — W15 — ms � I I r I ------------------------------------�— I I — — — — � I ---------fi--------------------------------------- /----------- -- I Q .o-,i•,g9lVJ5 EloLtl3HW3J3aOE o i ix .. Vlo[AtivnNvr SL '^ w M O LU _ r z VOItlOIl'WV3tl15 j1f19 rios AtlVf1tl93j is G w n Z ua o� 3�N�aIS3ti >1000 3� a v Q w C r ^ O W P ✓1 � m N N ¢ a NVId 3dt/OSaNt/l w �q m o: LL Z E w Z 6 _ I I r, ° I a u 3Ll ae.�.° = � e s s I ££ ° S^ 21 21 V 5 _ •I I a� �� 3y 3" 21 ° •p _°�3 w W _ L _ Y _ u� 1 8 ii I 3 =_ 0 A s _ I R:g ° w I 3i °rr' 26 `a c's" -n ; - 9 ^w} u 11 nb3 .-s 3 , m n� mJ O 3 � II __ _ ^- --- --------------- ? z g W c I I " - z $ P — o — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — m — — N — — -- — — — — — — — - a NS ° W1S — It15 — W15 — Nis. _ - - al — S W15 - W1S — W1S — W15 3 — W15 — Nil 12 3v a� ° I I I I I � ° I ------ -- --- ------ --- ----- --- ----_ / --- -- _ _ _ _ — — — — — — III Q .°-d-,g 9lVOS £toe tl3BW3J3a of m [x .. >toc AtivnNvr St b1OZ w O w -z Z LL AtltlfltlB3tl It Vdltloltl'WV3tl15 ling ° N 3JNQIJU/O�Jo 3a Q NVId 3dVOS4tiVH w m a z Q .0-.L* g'31vos £tot n9wom o£ m° E C w l- Atl Mian a Y�oL AtlVfltlB3j is x f p > s z vamoi�'wv3ais tlin� a ° M Z LLa LL o� 3ON3GIS3b >1000 Q F NVId 3d'VOSONVI w Z m a LL E w w n Z PAi9 u¢"30 N v s [ 3AV &M.1 G � C ci V m Ilz•1 Nand -AV 4116 IN a a aAV 449 3N VQ Z_ - JAY 41L 3N AMH leaapa j L > "AV pal 9s9Zr 9 03a l! '3'd 9ZV 'tl Hd350f 1V35 5,933NION3 1NOH11M OIItlA ION {.,� �T �7 �T �7n V QIQO IA jAjVHZI,LS 111f) (1A'I9 NVHDO N 9Z2T — Z 10.1 v SHI V ISH AUIn UODUVH �i �T '^3o,T NT1d STN HINHAIDUdW1 TTS �TnT� Q �7 1�1 W1V YV YYl Wl MAID 9SS9-4LZ l9S :xDA 0099-4LZ (M) :auo4d 444££ DPIJDId '4DDag ADJlaO ,CDM aAojD alddoauld 96Z 9099 % NDLLVZI80H1HV JO myoiz um VONLOIJ Z .; ,� E Q W �a W d V ti \ W o [.. \ q o z o 1 Rr. 00 O 0 2 o z O W M SINVE IISNOO 'IVINSKNOUTAN3 • SUSaNIONa uNayslsepnue rnmrn Isa�eloossy 16 U61S2QOJIAU3 yy��'S az f1N SNtlld HDHV HU IDOAVI 30VHVD 3SIA39 rl/OZ/Z ® AB :SNOISIA3N :31Y0 'ON PAi9 u¢"30 N v s [ 3AV &M.1 G � C ci V m Ilz•1 Nand -AV 4116 IN a a aAV 449 3N VQ Z_ - JAY 41L 3N AMH leaapa j L > "AV pal a �.��.IM-� m m .a o N d 1 s i R oV Y I I Upy ^ lull I I I I I w Z Q yy��'S az w J IIe pa W a 6. z�aa I Z Q 3 O2 M I I M O ^ o oho I I F- p W �-------- -----� ?i l,t C\2 N W w o w ��I s wm a a ; v. vs—va— P H o w a�j N Naas n !ZD, - I --ril I I ------------ — — Ljj1a1 W W Da. toN VI o U w p F m a ~Y N O 0 Z m = I— U .--1 W —M. Q S Q�+ a W a a o o V w U om $ w 0 w ¢ SLL vi Foo d o ~ Uo� g w 0w (OY09 3LYAINd Y) I r' Q m In 0 = I W �2 N W .Y. 10YNL 2 rc N FU N ww c _ -R\ rn 'v 1J113N'l MVH(3 ® 0 o. a �.��.IM-� m m .a o N d 1 s i R oV Y 1 \ 1 - l B-1ONfimsY3d Ainun Na 1 Otl'3LYA" .OZ rR- -__ �,mo ---- ------------ L I I I I \ (Bu DYd I I I 'B[ N 1Vid I I I I'$ 1N3N35V3 3OY ( - I IJ I v'V+ I X I i d � U ED*\ ra Z Ln "A O co - A N F z �u1E"zw ] vi Oz��zH FF��d�v ¢aW0 O O z 55 U W O W� W F O FIxP, a.9 OwwFwz zaa¢xw I I lull I I I I I w I IIe m I M I I M I I I �-------- -----� � I I N ��I a�IN USN v. vs—va— P H ]YNIVNO vua .[mo Z — v.-I I, I --I I z f m w o— !ZD, - I --ril I I ------------ — — — — — — — — -- I I �1 -15- 1 \ 1 - l B-1ONfimsY3d Ainun Na 1 Otl'3LYA" .OZ rR- -__ �,mo ---- ------------ L I I I I \ (Bu DYd I I I 'B[ N 1Vid I I I I'$ 1N3N35V3 3OY ( - I IJ I v'V+ I X I i d � U ED*\ ra Z Ln "A O co - A N F z �u1E"zw ] vi Oz��zH FF��d�v ¢aW0 O O z 55 U W O W� W F O FIxP, a.9 OwwFwz zaa¢xw  Ll X  ll `VW ��7S:6��7:8 t1N/S1/l `6n^P" j1a-960 l\qM0\uSJDW Sa6pia8 AH Z 10�� GOUGMSa��J f000-960 LVLOZVO o m F r- o i�� z < s ��< O ��. a '}n" o wF wi r��} z1+" we ��O��r1 mgmm�� o$ ��< b_ "$ iQojb zox mui o So w a ��s bS Wold az1 BY 0��m IN �� o��1ZS BE%0z M.'. 3 9910 Ei5 cSmw o "1�� a�� F[E p gurm zQm_ 3 �� <z SF_ <��< m�� 0 u��03 a 8 i m <�� w i - 0Gv ��2g ]ziW. xxo m��V z 98 ��fil. cry <= ii����wgg��1 qq< Sm�� x1,7-1 $e '9<coi�� gw��<5 w0<y ���� fm <M E$F g�� o�� <;c��i 1 z oz ��b��o 31010 34 ' ��is F-X�� a ��soo drcg3 S��8ai r rz m 6 d y1 J �� �� 9 4 u" S$ W O m Z 1�� F $361S a g a��<LLI Bd 8 ani iz < ������ 1-po f:lFag ZmW WVI< ZY" WF O 0�� W <m��' O 5��rr1 O<= <�� � Z ��j 0 0 =ggyypg,,RZZO g��m Qod ��appJ�� �j i IpCCzk' M2Z g ;0 8a its a >V 3Z��$ Z�� "yS p9.6 C'IF�� ��O ad ppy��..��SW pO, g9?:o ��WO}g6 0��oa b$ ��,]F����72v C1�� CJo o mo�< WWF Ei $BiSJ ����p5o rca <an ��a< wx< ����. wp z w o 0 KZN& m�� ��- ,n m$�� m$Z ��rco m mF me3p ���� m ��W 34 a ga C��Fzi$ Rg6 RSF �� �� X �� o i z ja ��0S��0rn ��FnM 1z`doF`�� <IChe��rc a <�� ��u RxQ ea��ws a ri w ui ui n o of 0 fly �� ����z ZZ os b�� UOW3 a a ��W�� S ��Fz w > ww z����" ��`''(((1</������1 ��eF��Oo'm JJ z F_ mpa7����'�� i =��wm P96 Ew H o �� iW4W 102 zp5P `��09a�� $�� x0imn yP. _ uaz�� ����Q w, Y SOF vU g��<1 V15pW bz TLi ng Z ��j��F ��O�� x�� W 4gyy<Zllff..,5��,' doa V 9 N E p����jj Tqi aci��ac<i ������ Njb (n AGOQ(y�� NpZZa N��yw..Z o1+ Ig�1 z< � ��5 � <S�� Nr'c��m $gyp Rn ~ KW < $d��Oeq NO <a ��_~ ����<U a <<y a FAQ W ��W b O ���� Q ���� ��RTj 4al z tF���� Ioom i ��7 aY��e<�� aFP ��j 5 $za g Mo W E05" ��aWr F a a��;U w<b�� ��fjco rc w EDP a �� ��5ANXr m8v=Sm1��i1 ���� � U��o z���� F <���� o 06ur�� ��<w $w I Q Fm$mgq $uS_��p��1��3��b��-$13xi1 Eon W Haza HS p W6 gas<< 08<. iHtH. ?��i55?k $ $ s ����Sib�� ��i<<<�� s�� s a0 ni ^ 6 1G ^ w 6 d N 0205 W p N 1" w��'' " �� W c�� ��1-��W��W < z < Z Zai U, mZ <xF yy.�� wSSm$ W��?�� ����3mlyy!j��'gpWppWma 8 baP. a<�� NPymmy11 Q`��2mSga��$=JJw ��<< o�$im�������� p~ Z$ ' 3w 2 < Z��OKO KKI <~O�=S(Y0 HPwWihp b Q 3��<apa ������mWpo$1��$��aw 1�� z$m��ZiHa -UPHI L 1= 0 < m 0 O F F� m m U b 0 m< W W J z s F < m 1S 1~ fQZg�� M W<F it X0 < Y I KZ zpe Pun ZO ��-z_ 1 B=OO oN m h<- 0IW1~V q����OeWN00U����4.�� m ��FZFmY M U P W 5 8a�� U Ue��gmdbgwm>��em< me e$pJ Mo P= M. o { < a ��< oo�uSa chi lrli��s hMaw 4'FiS urs iii ��il3m 0093 71 U 's- 0x3 Q LU 11 3J'vw T H � ��aI2i073 `I��'��xss ��'In�� GATT KVH30 N 9ZZT - Z 101 S HZVZS H MBIA ZI O ffHVH :Hod srnVaHa HaNVrvxa Ol��nva a"Kc 49s) -CA '4aa9 A -lea (0.N -wa o�� dao 98Z 4d 9099 ' N Nomwwow.ny do 31y3Uaymyowo U ,; a �� �� �� 0a A o z m "-,1 C; 9a N v�� <g SINVIrIIISN00 'IVSNTIQNOHIMH " SHaHNII9NIS ��I S G flossy I ��s,saaa,,,��3 $ Gi azo tae ��O � o m F r- o i�� z < s ��< O ��. a '}n" o wF wi r��} z1+" we ��O��r1 mgmm�� o$ ��< b_ "$ iQojb zox mui o So w a ��s bS Wold az1 BY 0��m IN �� o��1ZS BE%0z M.'. 3 9910 Ei5 cSmw o "1�� a�� F[E p gurm zQm_ 3 �� <z SF_ <��< m�� 0 u��03 a 8 i m <�� w i - 0Gv ��2g ]ziW. xxo m��V z 98 ��fil. cry <= ii����wgg��1 qq< Sm�� x1,7-1 $e '9<coi�� gw��<5 w0<y ���� fm <M E$F g�� o�� <;c��i 1 z oz ��b��o 31010 34 ' ��is F-X�� a ��soo drcg3 S��8ai r rz m 6 d y1 J �� �� 9 4 u" S$ W O m Z 1�� F $361S a g a��<LLI Bd 8 ani iz < ������ 1-po f:lFag ZmW WVI< ZY" WF O 0�� W <m��' O 5��rr1 O<= <�� � Z ��j 0 0 =ggyypg,,RZZO g��m Qod ��appJ�� �j i IpCCzk' M2Z g ;0 8a its a >V 3Z��$ Z�� "yS p9.6 C'IF�� ��O ad ppy��..��SW pO, g9?:o ��WO}g6 0��oa b$ ��,]F����72v C1�� CJo o mo�< WWF Ei $BiSJ ����p5o rca <an ��a< wx< ����. wp z w o 0 KZN& m�� ��- ,n m$�� m$Z ��rco m mF me3p ���� m ��W 34 a ga C��Fzi$ Rg6 RSF �� �� X �� o i z ja ��0S��0rn ��FnM 1z`doF`�� <IChe��rc a <�� ��u RxQ ea��ws a ri w ui ui n o of 0 fly �� ����z ZZ os b�� UOW3 a a ��W�� S ��Fz w > ww z����" ��`''(((1</������1 ��eF��Oo'm JJ z F_ mpa7����'�� i =��wm P96 Ew H o �� iW4W 102 zp5P `��09a�� $�� x0imn yP. _ uaz�� ����Q w, Y SOF vU g��<1 V15pW bz TLi ng Z ��j��F ��O�� x�� W 4gyy<Zllff..,5��,' doa V 9 N E p����jj Tqi aci��ac<i ������ Njb (n AGOQ(y�� NpZZa N��yw..Z o1+ Ig�1 z< � ��5 � <S�� Nr'c��m $gyp Rn ~ KW < $d��Oeq NO <a ��_~ ����<U a <<y a FAQ W ��W b O ���� Q ���� ��RTj 4al z tF���� Ioom i ��7 aY��e<�� aFP ��j 5 $za g Mo W E05" ��aWr F a a��;U w<b�� ��fjco rc w EDP a �� ��5ANXr m8v=Sm1��i1 ���� � U��o z���� F <���� o 06ur�� ��<w $w I Q Fm$mgq $uS_��p��1��3��b��-$13xi1 Eon W Haza HS p W6 gas<< 08<. iHtH. ?��i55?k $ $ s ����Sib�� ��i<<<�� s�� s a0 ni ^ 6 1G ^ w 6 d N 0205 W p N 1" w��'' " �� W c�� ��1-��W��W < z < Z Zai U, mZ <xF yy.�� wSSm$ W��?�� ����3mlyy!j��'gpWppWma 8 baP. a<�� NPymmy11 Q`��2mSga��$=JJw ��<< o�$im�������� p~ Z$ ' 3w 2 < Z��OKO KKI <~O�=S(Y0 HPwWihp b Q 3��<apa ������mWpo$1��$��aw 1�� z$m��ZiHa -UPHI L 1= 0 < m 0 O F F� m m U b 0 m< W W J z s F < m 1S 1~ fQZg�� M W<F it X0 < Y I KZ zpe Pun ZO ��-z_ 1 B=OO oN m h<- 0IW1~V q����OeWN00U����4.�� m ��FZFmY M U P W 5 8a�� U Ue��gmdbgwm>��em< me e$pJ Mo P= M. o { < a ��< oo�uSa chi lrli��s hMaw 4'FiS urs iii ��il3m 0093 71 U 's- 0x3 Q LU 11 j W��K 3d v 3t�� o oNul dHN _" wOOg 10'1 wg 1 - H - rc ��i w��OQ< Xi$ygW SV'1F��1�� NNE 3<��ao��Sbi MM s�� urmx FZoo<iO <11^0m 1F < K < <d wx N ��0w6 XQ8-X.- NEE0e O<Za O mg is8<< Q3 <�� e �� A9fl4$1 ��jQg m��gjz< N H 4 ui 16 r-: 1d m a S m OIz 3 CL z 0 C) U W Z Z 0 U w U S x w Q U r! AwI e m v�� <g @P_ @~�� Yy $ Gi azo tae WN tNq 6. F1����{ a 0 c W. C�y1 Z��r 31tl{19��=2 $l m 2Z iN F Ann 2 x�� K$< p��mo F7'��d< Z.: d 1.1 f d d ��I< (z< iSSS gBaU Fj��== $��yo LL�� ;WE 1U10io N N j W��K 3d v 3t�� o oNul dHN _" wOOg 10'1 wg 1 - H - rc ��i w��OQ< Xi$ygW SV'1F��1�� NNE 3<��ao��Sbi MM s�� urmx FZoo<iO <11^0m 1F < K < <d wx N ��0w6 XQ8-X.- NEE0e O<Za O mg is8<< Q3 <�� e �� A9fl4$1 ��jQg m��gjz< N H 4 ui 16 r-: 1d m a S m OIz 3 CL z 0 C) U W Z Z 0 U w U S x w Q U r! AwI e IDU l <g @P_ @~�� Yy I g I 2EF! g��g��n � S g in N a 31tl{19��=2 $l m 2Z iN F Z.: d 1.1 f d d llAA Pis WR U J H w 0 W o- F - z LU a ,,Z[ X j[ 'Wd 9 L :Ob :8 V LOZ/S L/[ '6MP*ON3-960 ' L\OMC]\LIsaOW sa6Pia 8 AH Z 40�—@OUGPisa�j X00 0-960 V LOZ\ O Pn�p "030 N 1, -"W 'V HHd3.W 1 D�rn"e°N1nH F7�TT�7 rT 'i TATF7rT�TTCr �7ri /1 r aiao id tN Y alas A lalf) QA'Ig I\I���O Iii 9ZZT — Z ,LOZ SHIVISH MBIA ZIOE[ HVH :HOA NVri(I IKHLLS)Ls DI,Laas BSsO—YaZ LOS : _1 OOS9—YLZ L99 auc4d YYY££ cPP.0 14cca8 A -1-a ADM -On j add -4d 96Z 9099 '°N NOILyzIHONlfy 30 31VOI3amo V019033 .; tj A �a L1 pg o �° � Z. o � o n !. z M a a > a sLNVL'IfISNOO 'IVLNHNNo2IIAMa • suaHNIONs selejoossyl u6lsado�lnu3 9^V 410 3N t7 --. -, -- ° �• :nH MMM f31ra Pn�p "030 N 9211 BB'Y+ 1'14 CC'Y+W�9 0 -V �rrn \T a VJ I�m01' m �ieil ruYCd � m a a > a � 9^V 410 3N t7 --. -, -- any (11L 3N I 1 xma Ilelapa� _ y gay Pal O Q,. n Y131SAS OELIM 'moi I >_S9a M .Ve I I Ch i AND) �p�jJ] O yO �v O 07� VlA 4 a j aL V 3NIl UH3dOHd Yi Ol ,9'y Coq �iqA �ra c�78W 8 Ngo w S 0 �M Own$ z g & y �gn'°'�i�• y' e�$�$`9�x�anea va�aaag eye �° b° -A Fs°9 Tmo a®EES �Fo iA °1a aw�wSaC5 N .�'�.�, wW°o vim$ eR o v mho i•PooB as vo eg cnwmw g�bmor= of'°m_BBSm m"'� c4pi tg E a�? eEa�° o a iCC�ea�E �EE ap�^1,y g8 ioE .. o ° zF ZFoL 8 °• P E. LL._Ea E'¢ N � W ag1TN tN Fba�Vl 99gS �Q Oj i ,�� qpPSO p c a°Pn a° eeq g'qeq Ew° E E'8 E zrs a e E 5 _'na�' w8 9'•eE P 1i m L, EaE F'r r b6A m ��� o �gzm g= "Num �' ��$t t « o i p qac p a p P E EU -62 tr U e 3➢ ° N E F E F ow off• a oNLL `g 8 r E _ 0 £ $pa 9 r" L� 1 �7 q- .11, 1L'9+ ZZ'91 wt. 99'�+� 9211 BB'Y+ 1'14 CC'Y+W�9 0 I i I I \T Z I � .1(otuoe 1ald 1HiH5Y3 0 O a a ❑ g a � O � o I 1 F— z Y •• 2.2 I .N < Un o V W H oV II I I i I I II R I 1 I I 1-� I I ... m Lal n o H r� Jill soCC 00 �d2� F XEN $ rn Ifi I I ' a a m m 1 R B P � v�', s � 6o C) T I 1 1 "A6 'zAll 19' I 1 , I I I , 1 1 I I ww RIM 0 oR��m Y131SAS OELIM 'moi I >_S9a M .Ve I I Ch i AND) �p�jJ] O yO �v O 07� VlA 4 a j aL V 3NIl UH3dOHd Yi Ol ,9'y Coq �iqA �ra c�78W 8 Ngo w S 0 �M Own$ z g & y �gn'°'�i�• y' e�$�$`9�x�anea va�aaag eye �° b° -A Fs°9 Tmo a®EES �Fo iA °1a aw�wSaC5 N .�'�.�, wW°o vim$ eR o v mho i•PooB as vo eg cnwmw g�bmor= of'°m_BBSm m"'� c4pi tg E a�? eEa�° o a iCC�ea�E �EE ap�^1,y g8 ioE .. o ° zF ZFoL 8 °• P E. LL._Ea E'¢ N � W ag1TN tN Fba�Vl 99gS �Q Oj i ,�� qpPSO p c a°Pn a° eeq g'qeq Ew° E E'8 E zrs a e E 5 _'na�' w8 9'•eE P 1i m L, EaE F'r r b6A m ��� o �gzm g= "Num �' ��$t t « o i p qac p a p P E EU -62 tr U e 3➢ ° N E F E F ow off• a oNLL `g 8 r E _ 0 £ $pa 9 r" L� 1 �7 q- .11, 1L'9+ ZZ'91 wt. 99'�+� 9211 BB'Y+ 1'14 CC'Y+W�9 0 I i I I \T Z I � .1(otuoe 1ald 1HiH5Y3 0 O a a ❑ g a I 1N3R3Y3 t6+ L96+ �'L,I l'9+ a `'' -1 L VIUSAS OLLd3S I i I I L_ SUq 0l"}t-----J Z I � 0 O a a ❑ g a � O � o I 1 F— z Y •• 2.2 I .N < Un '+ oV II I I i I _3 I II R I 1 I I 1-� I I ... m Lal n o H O �x O r� Jill I [I ' I 00 I� $ rn Ifi I I ' a I O zE O I 1N3R3Y3 t6+ L96+ �'L,I l'9+ a `'' -1 L VIUSAS OLLd3S I i I I L_ SUq 0l"}t-----J dY 'v 3 I � 0 O a � � o I 1 F— z Y •• 2.2 I .N < Un '+ oV II I I i I Y I 1 I I 1-� I I ... I � „+ I I 1 1 I �' I [I ' I \� I� $ Ifi I I ' a I O zE I 1 1 19' I 1 , I I I , 1 1 I I 1 I----__-___ __ I I^ I + 3g11113S 1131VM �a3SdOk QL ,1.'OL a `'' -1 L VIUSAS OLLd3S Alli L_ SUq 0l"}t-----J +� Eb -51 I s n t mlow)atvn,A �z-, CC's,! LC \ \ U j. \ F— z Y .N < Un /i \ ... Y)II'! 1J.HYdONd JS9Y l0 OOT ,� N®.TIY OlZdIS 80 6TRY ON \ �' \� 9`gBZ` Mj �Y6Cg� L b�  LL X  LL `WV ss:05:8 LOZ/5L/L 'bmp,lla l0OH-960 L\OMa\gSJOW sa6pu8 AH Z 101 GOUapisa��J X000-960 LVLOZ\ O r � > in m O v o a < u�5 = g rc ��0I in B w < e<81��o ��a S =a ��83c ��1  gf $ S .64 PP�� 8 3 e2w5 u Mg Um W Ci u m d 4 w m 3sb b ���� Kq O F f5 03 Mal. >< I-- m < gmg ty rc��7FF ��W F a$ aO as JI F 3 5 3 U _pGl J rc Z Z -< �� ����<��W,jQ 9 IL ��= Za BECK < -Z2 Z OF i;l o B W���� ��a ���� z �:< <J 6��w ��ww }J aE G7 do B }y �� zL4 i �� 6 ��b ���� < ��'m ���� S �� ������' <�� B�� W Fp s < '1 "� ���� 8q W Z= < 5 - 1 b ��i}{ tFS4 y��W 9_ W ��m ��b� q a wee' ism ��ei M 02 W k' g m�� Sx 8 ��B (/)W B g U3<����0.5���� a ��Bn ���� < ����j�t ���� ��g�� Qm gmg (/�� obi ��ZZ ',$N����Jaam��'OB ZpbaB��y ���� yap pp�� opg jai<F bmr3 1- F F r O;F��FJm(.1ZZ ��y ` r r�� r p�� r i Ng BB W 8 $ {y��B FBII���� i a coat c��F o i�� 34 3 B " o = t iJ ma d iE 1p X18 W. g g 0 0. ���� �� �� ���� t. mL'a K���� ���� s�� ���� �������� � ��az -ma���� tJ ri f ui m n ed m c d ri v A w Ln vi C13 2: a v7 cr, a. U ul JINX11 Nil f12 'a ZI N d i d d Z o �� � a 3�� ��eyg J < " 4��S c<i n Sans � {, E " 8 L O yy ai *"���� f 6 �� W ,t B��` Z m4 z >E ' a -z--���% mm d z zp�� R z � 5 0 M. F z F � N U x �� 3 =o ���� �� ���� Q ��- 1�� J QQ���� ��p oR�RH95R���e������' " " =.mo ��1 3 () �� '21 9 $ e �� z �� o U Ey Cum aw 3M HU WW 3Z) Uaeo��r p / ��1`s �� g Ems" '" U Er! x F; O O z I F (na �oi Ud e g a �m 3uaa "rs Q �� A ��7/��T��T r�� ��T 6SS6-YLZ lB5 and 00S8iLZ LtiS 4d 7'J���YI'Y ��� Y LL1Q0 1LL `rnr����xss ��tn�� ��t oPWLi 'yao�9 '��cip4 R0.N wnp BOCO 'oN N0Ltj ix 31 LVZIL0F11f1V d0 3LVJIiLLN3�� V��INO"L�� QAZg l��t��'����0 I`S 9ZZT  Z ,LO'I s,r��xvsznsxoo zvax��Rxoainxs " sx����xt��x�� ��r'-f�� T7�� ��-7 T [����T ARIA �� ; ,��, �� ��,�� A ��T (T��T��7TT'z S��R.L V ��1,.7��7 ��I1��71L�� Q��QQ V II ��2Io3 s'IIV,L��a ����ssxs ��Isa��s �� ��aZZS cri a Zal N�� W Wtl�� p��a ya��z�� �� 'L! u6��sedw��n 3 �������� ����Zc 0 t�� tmaionmi ���� ��� r � > in m O v o a < u�5 = g rc ��0I in B w < e<81��o ��a S =a ��83c ��1  gf $ S .64 PP�� 8 3 e2w5 u Mg Um W Ci u m d 4 w m 3sb b ���� Kq O F f5 03 Mal. >< I-- m < gmg ty rc��7FF ��W F a$ aO as JI F 3 5 3 U _pGl J rc Z Z -< �� ����<��W,jQ 9 IL ��= Za BECK < -Z2 Z OF i;l o B W���� ��a ���� z �:< <J 6��w ��ww }J aE G7 do B }y �� zL4 i �� 6 ��b ���� < ��'m ���� S �� ������' <�� B�� W Fp s < '1 "� ���� 8q W Z= < 5 - 1 b ��i}{ tFS4 y��W 9_ W ��m ��b� q a wee' ism ��ei M 02 W k' g m�� Sx 8 ��B (/)W B g U3<����0.5���� a ��Bn ���� < ����j�t ���� ��g�� Qm gmg (/�� obi ��ZZ ',$N����Jaam��'OB ZpbaB��y ���� yap pp�� opg jai<F bmr3 1- F F r O;F��FJm(.1ZZ ��y ` r r�� r p�� r i Ng BB W 8 $ {y��B FBII���� i a coat c��F o i�� 34 3 B " o = t iJ ma d iE 1p X18 W. g g 0 0. ���� �� �� ���� t. mL'a K���� ���� s�� ���� �������� � ��az -ma���� tJ ri f ui m n ed m c d ri v A w Ln vi C13 2: a v7 cr, a. U ul JINX11 Nil f12 'a ZI N d i d d Z o �� � a 3�� ��eyg J < " 4��S c<i n Sans � {, E " 8 L O yy ai *"���� f 6 �� W ,t B��` Z m4 z >E ' a -z--���% mm d z zp�� R z � 5 0 M. F z F � N U x �� 3 =o ���� �� ���� Q ��- 1�� J QQ���� ��p oR�RH95R���e������' " " =.mo ��1 3 () �� '21 9 $ e �� z �� o U Ey Cum aw 3M HU WW 3Z) Uaeo��r p / ��1`s �� g Ems" '" U Er! x F; O O z I F (na �oi Ud e g a �m 3uaa "rs Q �� A ��7/��T��T r�� ��T 6SS6-YLZ lB5 and 00S8iLZ LtiS 4d 7'J���YI'Y ��� Y LL1Q0 1LL `rnr����xss ��tn�� ��t oPWLi 'yao�9 '��cip4 R0.N wnp BOCO 'oN N0Ltj ix 31 LVZIL0F11f1V d0 3LVJIiLLN3�� V��INO"L�� QAZg l��t��'����0 I`S 9ZZT  Z ,LO'I s,r��xvsznsxoo zvax��Rxoainxs " sx����xt��x�� ��r'-f�� T7�� ��-7 T [����T ARIA rchi ��rcrc���� (����`��'����,I ,��18 �� i:i��3<ZiN ��aZZS cri Zal N�� W Wtl�� p��a ya��z�� �� 'L! �������� ����Zc ZO F��p�� FQU}U <[jU�� ��WJ� t��ryrJ1 "iWZOW�� ssss < ����\ m���� �� 8��z Om=wO �� ZO<Zc]f .1Z` <���� 3��N�� p��`zy ��FmZS< ��Fw���� e � 8_�� ����=m ���� ���������� ����yZ����awO�� ��WL1��tJU��Z����U{ Y114JJIF<��_���� O�� ��' i �� ��y�� ��"YZ-�� �������� ������J�� dm��Z ��(IJm��O��F ��55m1- x�� o- Pin s��i����{Frca ����zS��Fj$��a������a ��O< � ��g=`mam���� <W W�� <3���� `v<�� z<3 r -m ������j���� W i��������'��<4 ��1��8f <i ������ ��a<�� ����a��0 <��'J`m�� rc��iig�� o Z 1'I .-. v{ ' r �� Oi �� H N N N Z 2W KKg w 1-Ugg�� C7 is<����j ����jj b����i5z p�� ����m!s ��y LLW ���� ��'z�� ��B k'aq'$ ��miK�� g���� 1. Lzl u��< ar WE wE a pW �� N2 N kt�� o=�� �� W �� m�������� g ��F_ �� ��< = otic zo c M�� z������s�� ��zW��c�i ��a hag W�� �� ENO F22 ������< 1-'-t ��Zg ��a �� v ����g Q��j�� �� ��7i �� N����.J ? mtZ��Zy����U��ZFZ m�� iU'��Z��`yW�� 4'S00R J ��pp,5�� i�� o�� 99h. p, OWKSX Y aB y��p2< W1 m F m ���� WF< GI m CW ��_ ��1- WF m W2 m 1= W, r3 m p UW J Oo��t��j ��i ����FU 5i" 0 666 rSam��������� ���� TLS���������� ��'�� ��W��WutJ ��<�� �� j��j7;'�� ��=F2=�� g��+�� c, `��N7��rc ������ g��g��++"F F"��<>u��j k����o ����CI ����_��z�� za6 c+E�� ij����j������ j��l w��g<�� {y��{ �� ��3�� `�� QF��1 w3 ��S��<z7 ����o ����Gl���� w ��zF gib <S�� ��z�� �� ��z <��S ��S�� ��cmiuBlo<.cmi �� -��I�� S��ji<S��g b LT7��� ia=Fi Z� b ��z d �� ��  L[ X  LL `Wd LS:O-b:B bLOZ/5L/L `bmP*9N]-96NL\OMa\LIs.IQW sa6pua nH z ��01 a:)UaplsaN '000-960TLVLOZ\ O ��3 P GGG3R��R �� o J s ��sa��a W z w OI F,<B��sR1tl g0 z lid fij��Rfi tz gag el d f d d n d 11 0 J 1 W 0 En 0 z J 0 z 8__.. z 0 V) 0 W 00 in J H W 0 LLJ z C ------------- U 0 J H W 0 W U z z W z 0 U z z O U 0 N m F- U) r--- I O L--- ____ _____T__ I I I I I I I I I I i; I I ��$ I aM. i ii I I V I I I I �� II 11I I I II; 1i NJI i �� T T' I �� I I �� I  I ---------- I 77---- ---1--- ----1---L--  -----------------r-----r--t -J------------------Q'-- , , I DR I I I Y(Olt d 'K )WO IV14 --o ---------------J--- 13�� I WI I mom I 1 I L j I I S I " " " 3` W Q3 d3S 7'J '3)IY 'V NJ7LOf 3 �aMA ION VQIZI0'I3 'IVH2LLS �� M -D (UIH NVHOO N 922T  Z ,LO'I SHZVZSH MBIA 2i0H2I��'II :xOd tMd HOLLNMUd xotsnTIod asse--rcz gas MDA LP ones-rcz 1�� Z 1Y4i oPWLi 'ynwg taipO .(oM wo.p a��ddw,- BBZ 80:9 VN NOLLVZU*tLnV 30 3LVOULLN30 V01NO13 ,; F \ i` ���� A O o I z o ��,o . LO x O LO,���� Ssxvsznsxoa zVINHNNOUTAMa " SUMIDNa wm��epeawaew,., se a moss  s,Seaa,, �� � :��OMLAN rava ��3 P GGG3R��R �� o J s ��sa��a W z w OI F,<B��sR1tl g0 z lid fij��Rfi tz gag el d f d d n d 11 0 J 1 W 0 En 0 z J 0 z 8__.. z 0 V) 0 W 00 in J H W 0 LLJ z C ------------- U 0 J H W 0 W U z z W z 0 U z z O U 0 N m F- U) r--- I O L--- ____ _____T__ I I I I I I I I I I i; I I ��$ I aM. i ii I I V I I I I �� II 11I I I II; 1i NJI i �� T T' I �� I I �� I  I ---------- I 77---- ---1--- ----1---L--  -----------------r-----r--t -J------------------Q'-- , , I DR I I I Y(Olt d 'K )WO IV14 --o ---------------J--- 13�� I WI I mom I 1 I L j I I S I FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET SCOTT W MORGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd GULF STREAM, FL 33483 PH (561)-752.,1936 FAX (80.1)-760-2777 Date: 7-23-13 To: Town of Gulf Stream Fax: 561-737-0188 From: Scott W. Morgan Re: Application for Level 3 approval of Lot 5- Hidden Harbour Estates Number of pages: 3 Memo: Please find attached my letter in opposition to this application. Would you please make copies of the letter for distribution to the members of the ARPl3? SCOTT W. MORGAN 1.140 N. Ocean ,Blvd GW Stream, Fl, 33483 Ph (561) 243-1432 July 23, 2013 To: Town of Gulf Stream Architectural .Review and :planning Board Re: Hidden Harbour F'slates Lot 5 1224 N. (Ocean Blvd. Dear Board Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review of a 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec. 66-144 (b)(1009 The proposed architectural design of this home violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures. The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than of an Ocean West District home. Because the lot is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale. The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. Sec. 70-4 (c) (4) and Sec. 70-29 (b) (3) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's prohibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Code's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located _"(Art, I, Sec. 70-4 (c )(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "lots that are set back. great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district." (Art. U, Sec. 70-29 (b)(3)). The homes of this District have a unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Hidden Harbour Estates—all of which are rectangular, long Bast to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other life two rows of domino tiles has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- community sub -division, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Raton and West Delray Beach. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all corner lots and so were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes on adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. In order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West District character, and to prevent an over -crowding of similar homes inside Hidden. )Harbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 ArchitecturaVSite Plan Review of Lot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re -submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, ott W Morga From: scottmoraan75(nlamail.com To: Bill Thrasher Subject: Public Records Request 10/15/13 Date: Friday, October 18, 2013 8:54:36 AM Hello Bill, You sent me a copy of an e-mail from Mr. J. O'Boyle, which purports, rather informally, to be a Public Records request. The highlighted Request (5) of the e-mail makes no sense, as it requests "Email's sent from Scott Morgan's (sic) for the Month of September 2013". 1 assume that is the request you wish me to answer but since Mr. O'Boyle's request is vague, I am unable in good faith to respond to it. Should you have any further questions, do not hesitate to contact me. Scott W. Morgan w-561-752-1936 c-561-573-6006 Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. <JOConnor@jonesfoster.com> Sent:Friday, December 8, 2017 4:44 PM To:Jonathan O'Boyle Cc:Macfarlane, Mary; Trey Nazzaro; Renee Basel Subject:Gulf STream PRR GS 2604 Dear Jonathan – Please allow this email to respond in part to your Public Records Request to the Town of Gulf Stream that seeks the following: Electronic Copies of: (1) Town of Gulf Stream Request 587; (2) the initial response given to Request 587 on or about 2/3/2014; (3) any communication from Jones Foster to the O’Boyle Law Firm regarding Request 587 between March 1, 2014 and March 25, 2014 \[particularly from Ashlee Richman\]; (4) the cover page and public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm in March 2014 by Jones Foster in response to Request 587 and/or because of the litigation initiated pursuant to this request \[tip: March 12, 2014 is believed to be the date of transmission\]. Below is a sharefile link to electronic copies of the communications you sought by subpart (3) of your request. These communications do not include any electronically served copies of pleadings that may have been served or filed in the suit related to this request during this particular time period as we do not understand such communications to be responsive to your request. https://jones-foster.sharefile.com/d-s62eff389665403f8 Regards, Joanne Joanne M. O’Connor Florida Bar Board Certified Business Litigation Attorney Telephone: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. <JOConnor@jonesfoster.com> Sent:Friday, December 8, 2017 4:44 PM To:Jonathan O'Boyle Cc:Renee Basel; Trey Nazzaro; Macfarlane, Mary Subject:RE: Gulf Stream PRR GS 2604 Jonathan – Correction, the link below is to the public records sought by subpart (4) of your request below. Joanne M. O’Connor Florida Bar Board Certified Business Litigation Attorney Telephone: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: OConnor, Joanne M. Sent: Friday, December 08, 2017 4:00 PM To: 'Jonathan O'Boyle' <joboyle@oboylelawfirm.com> Cc: 'Renee Basel' <RBasel@gulf-stream.org>; 'TNAZZARO@GULF-STREAM.ORG' <TNAZZARO@GULF-STREAM.ORG>; Macfarlane, Mary <MMacfarlane@jonesfoster.com> Subject: Gulf Stream PRR GS 2604 Dear Jonathan – Please allow this email to respond in part to your Public Records Request to the Town of Gulf Stream that seeks the following: Electronic Copies of: (1) Town of Gulf Stream Request 587; (2) the initial response given to Request 587 on or about 2/3/2014; (3) any communication from Jones Foster to the O’Boyle Law Firm regarding Request 587 between March 1, 2014 and March 25, 2014 \[particularly from Ashlee Richman\]; (4) the cover page and public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm in March 2014 by Jones Foster in response to Request 587 and/or because of the litigation initiated pursuant to this request \[tip: March 12, 2014 is believed to be the date of transmission\]. Below is a sharefile link to electronic copies of public records transmitted to the O’Boyle Law Firm on March 12, 2014 in response to Request 587. Those public records were hand delivered and not accompanied by a cover letter. Their receipt was acknowledged by Attorney Mesa as reflected in the emails that will be produced in response to part (3) of your request. 1 https://jones-foster.sharefile.com/d-s3bde9f85df947c38 Regards, Joanne Joanne M. O’Connor Florida Bar Board Certified Business Litigation Attorney Telephone: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 2 Renee Basel From:Kieta, Marge Sent:Tuesday, March 18, 2014 9:47 AM To:gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com; mhanna@oboylelawfirm.com; rwitmer@oboylelawfirm.com Cc:Richman, Ashlee A. (ARichman@jonesfoster.com); Gardner, Kelly A.; OConnor, Joanne M.; Randolph, John C. Subject:13147.51; 13147.52; 13147.53 Attachments:20140318093555350.pdf Please see attached letter to Judge McCarthy with attachments. Margaret L. Kieta Secretary to Sidney A. Stubbs, Roberto M. Vargas, and Ashlee A. Richman Direct Dial: 561.650.0408 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | mkieta@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. -----Original Message----- From: Margaret L. Kieta \[mailto:mkieta@jonesfoster.com\] Sent: Tuesday, March 18, 2014 9:36 AM To: Kieta, Marge Subject: Message from "RNP00267343ACDC" This E-mail was sent from "RNP00267343ACDC" (Aficio MP 7502). Scan Date: 03.18.2014 09:35:55 (-0400) 1 JONESFOSTER JOHNSTON He STUBBS, P.A. Ashlee A. Richman Attorney 561-650-0467 Fax: 561-650-5300 arichman@jonesfoster.com March 18, 2014 Honorable Timothy McCarthy Palm Beach County Courthouse 205 North Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, FL 33401 Re: O'Boyle v. Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 50 2014 CA 001572 XXXX MB AJ O'Hare v. Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 50 2014 CA 001776 XXXX MB AJ O'Hare v. Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 50 2014 CA 001833 XXXX MB AJ (HEARING SCHEDULED FOR MARCH 20, 2014 AT 8:45 A.M.) Dear Judge McCarthy: Enclosed please find an Agreed Order for each of the above -styled cases which cancels the hearings on our Motions to Consolidate set for March 20, 2014 at 8:45 a.m. before Your Honor. Opposing counsel have agreed to the form of the orders. If the orders meet with your approval, please sign and forward to counsel of record in the enclosed stamped envelopes. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sincerely, JONES„ FOSTER, JOHNSTON & STUBBS, P.A. In Ashlee X Richman AAR:mlk Enclosures cc: Giovani Mesa, Esquire (q mesa CcD-oboylelawfirm. com) Marrett W. Hanna, Esquire (mhanna(aoboylelawfirm.com) Ryan Witmer, Esquire (rwitmer joboylelawfirm.com) p:\docs\13147\00051 \Itr\1 ij8105.docx Since 1924 j West Palm Beach 1 Jupiter r F,`agler Center PCt ,ver 505 Satith F1agler Drive, Suite 1100 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 w ww' jo nesfoster'C011a IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO: 502014CA001572XXXXMBAJ MARTIN E. O'BOYLE, Plaintiff, V. TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Defendant. AGREED ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE WITHOUT PREJUDICE THIS CAUSE came before the Court on Defendant's Motion to Consolidate dated March 12, 2014, and the Court having been informed of the agreement of the parties and otherwise duly advised in the premises, it is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that: Defendant's Motion to Consolidate is hereby denied without prejudice. DONE AND ORDERED in West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, Florida, this day of March, 2014. Circuit Court Judge Copies furnished: Giovani Mesa, Esquire The O'Boyle Law Firm, P.C. 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442 gmesa(aoboylelawfirm.com oboylecourtdocs(a�oboylelawfirm.com John C. Randolph, Esquire Joanne M. O'Connor, Esquire Ashlee A. Richman, Esquire Kelly A. Gardner, Esquire Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 irandolph(a-),jonesfoster.com ioconnor(cD-jonesfoster.com a rich man (a-)-ionesfoster. com kgardner(ccD--ionesfoster.com p:\docs\13147\00051 \pld\1 ii7334.docx 2 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO: 502014CA001776XXXXMB AJ CHRISTOPHER F. O'HARE, Plaintiff, vs. TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Defendant. AGREED ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE THIS CAUSE having come before the Court on Defendant's Motion to Consolidate dated March 12, 2014, and the Court having been informed of the agreement of the parties and otherwise duly advised in the premises, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Defendant's Motion to Consolidate is GRANTED, in part, and denied, in part. The case styled Christopher F. O'Hare v. The Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 502014CA001776XXXXMBAJ, is hereby consolidated for discovery and trial with the case styled Christopher F. O'Hare v. The Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 502014CA001833XXXXMBAJ, in the Circuit Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach County, Florida. The Clerk of the Court shall transfer and consolidate Case No. 502014CA001833XXXXMBAJ under Case No. 502014CA001776XXXXMBAJ. All pleadings, motions and other filings shall hereinafter be filed in, and bear, Case No. 502014 CA001776XXXXM BAJ . IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, pursuant to an agreement by the parties, the case styled Martin E. O'Boyle v. The Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 502014CA001572XXXXMBAJ, will not be consolidated at this time, but that the denial of an agreement not to consolidate this matter with the two other actions to be consolidated at this time is without prejudice. DONE AND ORDERED in Palm Beach County, Florida, this day of March, 2014. Copies furnished: Marrett W. Hanna, Esquire The O'Boyle Law Firm, P.C. 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442 mhanna .oboylelawfirm.com oboylecourtdocsCaD-oboylelawfirm.com John C. Randolph, Esquire Joanne M. O'Connor, Esquire Ashlee A. Richman, Esquire Kelly A. Gardner, Esquire Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 jrand olph(c�jonesfoster.com joconnor(a-)jonesfoster.com arichman(a-)-jonesfoster.com kgardner(a-).jonesfoster.com pAdocs\13147\00052\pld\1 H7416.docx CIRCUIT JUDGE 2 CHRISTOPHER F. O'HARE, Petitioner, V. TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Respondent. IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO. 50 2014 CA 001833 XXXX MB AJ AGREED ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE THIS CAUSE having come before the Court on Defendant's Motion to Consolidate dated March 12, 2014, and the Court having been informed of the agreement of the parties and otherwise duly advised in the premises, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Defendant's Motion to Consolidate is GRANTED, in part, and denied, in part. The case styled Christopher F. O'Hare v. The Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 502014CA001776XXXXMBAJ, is hereby consolidated for discovery and trial with the case styled Christopher F. O'Hare v. The Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 502014CA001833XXXXMBAJ, in the Circuit Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach County, Florida. The Clerk of the Court shall transfer and consolidate Case No. 502014CA001833XXXXMBAJ under Case No. 502014CA001776XXXXMBAJ. All pleadings, motions and other filings shall hereinafter be filed in, and bear, Case No. 502014CA001776XXXXMBAJ. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, pursuant to an agreement by the parties, the case styled Martin E. O'Boyle v. The Town of Gulf Stream, Case No. 502014CA001572XXXXMBAJ, will not be consolidated at this time, but that the denial of, and the agreement, not to consolidate this matter with the two other actions to be consolidated at this time is without prejudice. DONE AND ORDERED in Palm Beach County, Florida, this day of March, 2014. CIRCUIT JUDGE Copies furnished: Giovani Mesa, Esquire Ryan Witmer, Esquire The O'Boyle Law Firm, P.C. 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442 gmesa oboylelawfirm.com oboylecourtdocs(c�oboylelawfirm.com John C. Randolph, Esquire Joanne M. O'Connor, Esquire Ashlee A. Richman, Esquire Kelly A. Gardner, Esquire Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 jrandolph(a-)-jonesfoster.com joconnorCa)-ionesfoster.com arichman(a)-jonesfoster.com kgardner jonesfoster.com pAdocs\13147\00053\pld\1 ii7556.docx Renee Basel From:Richman, Ashlee A. Sent:Wednesday, March 12, 2014 11:01 AM To:gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Subject:Documents (O'Boyle) It looks like it would take about 300 emails to get all of these documents to you. I don’t want to overburden you with that many emails. We are trying to get someone from the office to drive it to you (so there is no added expense, and no extra burden for you). Also, a CD would have an index of everything you’re receiving, which will make review easier. Would this be alright with you? If so, what is the address that you would like me to send to (assuming we have someone who can get them there today)? Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | arichman@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 Renee Basel From:Richman, Ashlee A. Sent:Wednesday, March 12, 2014 11:01 AM To:gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Subject:Documents (O'Boyle) It looks like it would take about 300 emails to get all of these documents to you. I don’t want to overburden you with that many emails. We are trying to get someone from the office to drive it to you (so there is no added expense, and no extra burden for you). Also, a CD would have an index of everything you’re receiving, which will make review easier. Would this be alright with you? If so, what is the address that you would like me to send to (assuming we have someone who can get them there today)? Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | arichman@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 Renee Basel From: Richman, Ashlee A. <ARichman@jonesfoster.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 11:01 AM To: gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Subject: Documents (O'Boyle) It looks like it would take about 300 emails to get all of these documents to you. I don't want to overburden you with that many emails. We are trying to get someone from the office to drive it to you (so there is no added expense, and no extra burden for you). Also, a CD would have an index of everything you're receiving, which will make review easier. Would this be alright with you? If so, what is the address that you would like me to send to (assuming we have someone who can get them there today)? JONESFOSTER _._._.__..—...__, MMbn,. n s n ear, r e Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 ,iricliman(@,jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, \\ est Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.ionesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. 'Ibis email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. Renee Basel From: Richman, Ashlee A. <ARichman@jonesfoster.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:08 PM To: gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Subject: FW: documents See below for the index of what you will be receiving. Keri is the department assistant who will be dropping off the CD later today JONESFOSTER hill, rA_ Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichmanOjonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Hagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming etnails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Boudreau, Keri U. Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:03 PM To: Richman, Ashlee A. Subject: RE: documents Pages 1-5 consist of the email and attachments that you gave to me to scan. Pages 6-799 consist of 2012 documents. Pages 800-1322 consist of 2013 documents. Pages 1323-1418 consist of 2014 documents. Pages 1419-1421 consist of the facsimile transmittal sheet from Morgan to Town of Gulf Stream attaching the letter in opposition to the application. Page 1422 consist of an email from Morgan to Thrasher re: Public Records Request 10/15/13. These were the main folders on the flash drive. The individual documents are all bookmarked. JONESFOSTER Keri U. Boudreau Litigation Department Assistant Direct Dial: 561.650.5320 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 kboudreauQ4onesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, kx'est Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Richman, Ashlee A. Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 9:42 AM To: Boudreau, Keri U. Subject: documents Can you make a list of all that will be produced and sent to Giovani, so he and I can both confirm that he receives everything that was on that drive and in the email (with attachments) that I printed and gave you? Thanks! JONESFOSTER Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichmanoionesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.ionesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emads are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. Renee Basel From: Richman, Ashlee A. <ARichman@jonesfoster.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:18 PM To: Giovani Mesa Subject: RE: documents She is leaving the office now with the documents. Thanks, Ashlee JONESFOSTER POMM rtesruNA.M. Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichman(,,jonesfosteccom Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 wwwJonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may lie imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. '11iis email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not die intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Giovani Mesa[mailto:gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:07 PM To: Richman, Ashlee A. Subject: RE: documents Ok, thank you. Giovani Mesa, Esq. The O'Boyle Law Firm P.C. 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Direct Dial #954-834-2201 Fax #954-360-0807 Email: gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com From: Richman, Ashlee A.[mailto:ARichman(cDionesfoster.coml Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:08 PM To: Giovani Mesa Subject: FW: documents See below for the index of what you will be receiving. Keri is the department assistant who will be dropping off the CD later today JONESFOSTER xnear+wresrueu,tu. Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 ariclhman(ajonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. FLlgler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, Crest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by die Internal Revenue Service. Incoming entails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Boudreau, Keri U. Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:03 PM To: Richman, Ashlee A. Subject: RE: documents Pages 1-5 consist of the email and attachments that you gave to me to scan. Pages 6-799 consist of 2012 documents. Pages 800-1322 consist of 2013 documents. Pages 1323-1418 consist of 2014 documents. Pages 1419-1421 consist of the facsimile transmittal sheet from Morgan to Town of Gulf Stream attaching the letter in opposition to the application. Page 1422 consist of an email from Morgan to Thrasher re: Public Records Request 10/15/13. These were the main folders on the flash drive The individual documents are all bookmarked. JONESFOSTER -ppbAMann uLUY,CA KeriU. Boudreau Litigation Department Assistant DireetDial: 561.650.5320 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 kboudreau@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Richman, Ashlee A. Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 9:42 AM To: Boudreau, Keri U. Subject: documents Can you make a list of all that will be produced and sent to Giovani, so he and I can both confirm that he receives everything that was on that drive and in the email (with attachments) that I printed and gave you? Thanks! JONESFOSTER Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichmaneionesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.ionesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. Renee Basel From: Richman, Ashlee A. <ARichman@jonesfoster.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 1:50 PM To: Giovani Mesa Subject: Re: documents Great, glad to hear it. Let me know if anything appears to be missing from that index. Should all be there Sent from my iphone On Mar 12, 2014, at 1:21 PM, "Giovani Mesa" <gmesa(@obovlelawfirm.com> wrote: I am in receipt of the records. Thank you . Giovani Mesa, Esq. The O'Boyle Law Firm P.C. 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Direct Dial #954-834-2201 Fax #954-360-0807 Email: gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com From: Richman, Ashlee A.[mailto:ARichman(a)ionesfoster.coml Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:18 PM To: Giovani Mesa Subject: RE: documents She is leaving the office now with the documents. Thanks, Ashlee <image0ol.jpg> Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichmant7a ionesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flakler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by die Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Giovani Mesa [mailto:gmesa(&obovlelawfirm.coml Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:07 PM To: Richman, Ashlee A. Subject: RE: documents Ok, thank you. Giovani Mesa, Esq. The O'Boyle Law Firm P.C. 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Direct Dial #954-834-2201 Fax #954-360-0807 Email: gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com From: Richman, Ashlee A. [mailto:ARichman(&ionesfoster.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:08 PM To: Giovani Mesa Subject: FW: documents See below for the index of what you will be receiving. Keri is the department assistant who will be dropping off the CD later today <image001.jpg> Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichman jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.ionesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that -written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any rei iew, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Boudreau, Keri U. Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 12:03 PM To: Richman, Ashlee A. Subject: RE: documents Pages 1-5 consist of the email and attachments that you gave to me to scan. Pages 6-799 consist of 2012 documents. Pages 800-1322 consist of 2013 documents. Pages 1323-1418 consist of 2014 documents. Pages 1419-1421 consist of the facsimile transmittal sheet from Morgan to Town of Gulf Stream attaching the letter in opposition to the application. Page 1422 consist of an email from Morgan to Thrasher re: Public Records Request 10/15/13. These were the main folders on the flash drive. The individual documents are all bookmarked. <image002.jpg> KeriU. Boudreau Litigation Department Assistant Direct Dial: 561.650.5320 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 kboudreau@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, Pak. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Richman, Ashlee A. Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 9:42 AM To: Boudreau, Keri U. Subject: documents Can you make a list of all that will be produced and sent to Giovani, so he and I can both confirm that he receives everything that was on that drive and in the email (with attachments) that I printed and gave you? Thanks! <image001.jpg> Ashlee A. Richman Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0467 1 Fax: 561.650.5300 1 arichman(a�,,jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 1 www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury= Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties dint may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. 'This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. Sent:Friday, March 7, 2014 3:32 PM To:gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Cc:Matias, Sally; Macfarlane, Mary Subject:FW: O'Boyle vs Gulf Stream 13147.51 Attachments:1IG5605-notice hearing march 14 2014.PDF Mr. Mesa – As you know we have filed a notice of unavailability in this case for all of next week as I am in trial and Skip is out of the country. Since one of us will be handling the ultimate hearing, we need to be available to set it. thth I am available any day the week of March 17, with the exception of Thursday March 20. I am not sure why it is noticed for hearing at 3:30 pm on a Friday as I was not aware Judge McCarthy had motion calendar at that time. I see no reason why we can’t go over at motion calendar one morning to obtain a date. We will also be filing a motion to consolidate this case with Case. No. 001776, filed by Mr. O’Hare, that relates to similar records of Scott Morgan. Please advise whether you oppose consolidation. We will attempt to set it at the same time. Please confirm you will reset next Friday’s hearing and not set any other hearings next week. Thanks, Joanne Joanne M. O’Connor Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. From: Matias, Sally Sent: Friday, March 07, 2014 3:22 PM To: OConnor, Joanne M. Cc: Macfarlane, Mary Subject: O'Boyle vs Gulf Stream 13147.51 1 See attached notice of hearing. Please advise if you can attend. Sally Matias Secretary to John C. Randolph and H. Michael Easley Direct Dial: 561.650.0458 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | smatias@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 2 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15th JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA MARTIN E. O’BOYLE, Plaintiff, CASE NO.: 2014CA001572 v. THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Defendant. ______________________________________/ NOTICE OF HEARING YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that the undersigned as counsel for the Plaintiff shall call up for hearing before the Honorable Timothy P. McCarthy, in Courtroom 10.2214, Palm Beach County Courthouse, 205 North Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida, on March 14, 2014, at 3:30 p.m. or as soon thereafter as may be heard the following: MOTION FOR IMMEDIATE HEARING PURSUANT TO FLORIDA'S PUBLIC RECORDS ACT PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons in need of special accommodation to participate in this proceeding, shall, within a reasonable time prior to any proceeding, contact the Administrative Office of the Court, 205 N. Dixie Highway, Room 10.2214, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, telephone (561) 355-4380; 1-800-955-8771 (TDD); or 1-800-955-8770 (V), via Florida Relay Service. PLAINTIFF’S ATTORNEY CERTIFIES that a copy of the foregoing document was furnished via email to Defendant’s attorney, Jones, Foster, Johnson & Stubbs, P.A. at JRandolph@jonesfoster.com. and SMatias@jonesfoster.com on March 7, 2014. In accordance with Fla.R.Civ.P. 1.080 and Fla.R.Jud.Admin. 2516 email is the only method of serving this document. A paper copy has not been mailed to this party. THE O’BOYLE LAW FIRM, P.C. Attorneys for Plaintiff 1286 West Newport Center Drive Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 Telephone: (954) 834-2201 Facsimile: (954) 360-0807 oboylecourtdocs@oboylelawfirm.com gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com By: /s/ Giovani Mesa Giovani Mesa, Esq.- Florida Bar #0086798 Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. Sent:Tuesday, March 4, 2014 9:36 AM To:gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Cc:Matias, Sally; Macfarlane, Mary Subject:GulfStream - Morgan depostion Mr. Mesa – Mr. Morgan did not realize that spring break is approaching. He is unavailable for deposition March 14 through March 24. Thanks. Joanne M. O’Connor Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 Renee Basel From:OConnor, Joanne M. Sent:Tuesday, March 25, 2014 1:50 PM To:mhanna@oboylelawfirm.com; gmesa@oboylelawfirm.com Cc:Richman, Ashlee A.; Matias, Sally; Macfarlane, Mary Subject:Scott Morgan documents Attachments:Public Records Request 10/15/13 Gentlemen – th Attached is an October 15 email to Mr. Thrasher from Scott Morgan, which email was referenced in the additional documents produced to you approximately 2 weeks ago but may not have been included (I have not confirmed that by looking through all 1500 pages). I provide it here in an abundance of caution. Thanks, Joanne Joanne M. O’Connor Attorney Direct Dial: 561.650.0498 | Fax: 561.650.5300 | joconnor@jonesfoster.com Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. Flagler Center Tower, 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-659-3000 | www.jonesfoster.com U.S. Treasury Regulation Circular 230 requires us to advise you that written communications issued by us are not intended to be and cannot be relied upon to avoid penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. Incoming emails are filtered which may delay receipt. This email is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this email is prohibited. Please immediately notify us by email and delete the original message. 1 Renee Basel From:scottmorgan75@gmail.com Sent:Friday, October 18, 2013 8:37 AM To:Bill Thrasher Subject:Public Records Request 10/15/13 Hello Bill, You sent me a copy of an e-mail from Mr. J. O’Boyle, which purports, rather informally, to be a Public Records request. The highlighted Request (5) of the e-mail makes no sense, as it requests “Email’s sent from Scott Morgan’s (sic) for the Month of September 2013”. I assume that is the request you wish me to answer but since Mr. O’Boyle’s request is vague, I am unable in good faith to respond to it. Should you have any further questions, do not hesitate to contact me. Scott W. Morgan w-561-752-1936 c-561-573-6006 1