HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 18-2652
Renee Basel
From:Martin E. O’Boyle <meo@commerce-group.com>
Sent:Monday, July 9, 2018 9:23 AM
To:Rita Taylor; Renee Basel
Cc:Greg Dunham; Michelle Melicia
Subject:The following is a records request made pursuant to chapter 119 of the Florida
statutes regarding: Local Housing Authority - Gulfstream Florida
Dear Mdm. custodian of records and Ms. Basel:
As you can see from the below, I have been asking the town manager, Mr. Greg Dunham, for 6 calendar months to
provide me with information regarding information in connection with a local housing authority for the town of
Gulfstream. His deafening silence now requires me (with reluctance) to have to send a formal records request. Needless
to say, I am saddened by Mr. Dunham's "shunning" a resident and taxpayer of the town; and refusing to even extend the
courtesy of a response. In my opinion, the speaks loudly of his character.
The foregoing the side, my request is as follows:
Please provide all public records related to any housing authority (local or otherwise) that exist with in the town of
Gulfstream or exist by way of an interlocal or similar agreement within the town of Gulfstream. Saying it another way, in
some areas, local housing authorities have different "labels", and they may (as applies to municipalities) be county
agencies, quasi-government agencies or state agencies. Nonetheless, I would assume that if there was a need or
requirement for a a “local housing authority”, such as for government, senior or low income type housing, etc. that they
would be directed to some agency. Please provide all public records which may refer to any such agency or agencies.
Note: This email was prepared using dictation software. As a result, there may be errors in the
content and thus the content may not be relied upon. If you wish clarification, please call or write
requesting the same. Thank you.
Martin E. O'Boyle,
Commerce Group
1280 W. Newport Center Drive
Deerfield Beach, Fl. 33442
Direct Dial: 954-570-3505
Fax: 954-360-0807
Cell: 561-383-1221
E-mail: meo@commerce-group.com
Web Page: www.commerce-group.com
From: Martin E. O’Boyle
Sent: Thursday, February 15, 2018 8:14 AM
To: Greg Dunham <GDunham@gulf-stream.org>
Cc: Brenda Russell <brussell@commerce-group.com>
Subject: Local Housing Authority - Gulfstream Florida
Dear Mr Dunham - would you kindly advise me if Gulfstream has a local housing authority. If not, do they have an interlocal
agreement with another governmental agency wherein they use their local housing authority?
Thank you for your time and I await your kind and prompt response.
1
Thank you! :-)
Martin E. O'Boyle,
Commerce Group
1280 W. Newport Center Drive
Deerfield Beach, Fl. 33442
Direct Dial: 954-570-3505
Fax: 954-360-0807
Cell: 561 213 3486
E-mail: meo@commerce-group.com
Web Page: www.commerce-group.com
2
C13 0
o (4) ti oo o > o
ti
E
'161 c
cn
o a.t3° ;3
° ° cz
GO) Cd
O ° m 3 1 o
cd
o °
FS y
x t3� . .a o o Q. � on o 3
rn
Z o EA
CO
o
46)
con c�j
o „ °
cet �� N ^fl O O +�- N tom. r-: W p �G, p �L.' cz
Cc
to
cd cd
y co
rq
o�° o ti 3 b ° ° o o `� .� c�
N W C7 y Rs 3 3 c;3
°?Q cc
F.
��
\
��
�
��
$ �
\ \
\ ��
��
t ��
$
\ �
0
\ '
&
/ t
u 7
&
5 0
*
0 2
�
% �
o 4 . 1 3
�
� �
*
o
. �
2
.
��
\ o Z
A �
7
b
�
% /
/
k
0
H
Z
LU
W Z
W=) M
QL) w
°a N
F -
Q W J
LL
I 0
LL
Oa
O
0 Z
QW ?'
2 O
O W ~
W m
H
Z
N '� Vi ca ca U ca m -I- a) -C M W e u .O (A O U O ca O m E
c N_ '- c (n a) U a) � � U c — 4-� (a a) cn c 4- L
_ _ _ _ _ a) L to p O
C: c cn W "' o w (a 0 cn
c C) a) 0- m (a O O N E :3_� '- C
M E C 4? p E L O t` a) U a) M U O= �- to c a) ca L c.
L O E ++ _c (n c ,�- +� a) m E m c O a) O +� L > C L to
0 Q �' o C} w Q 0 c cm (DN m �' c 0 O '= `_ Q c Q O o+ N E E
0cu
-p m U) E O fa m Q O. U ('j M +_' C N >, c - a) -O
��� EOaio oc(n ,,off — cn O(n� - 0� > c0a)cv,o
•a. L `+- L fn '_ LL O .� C U �_ U O Q «- W '>= E Q) L m O L ca Q Q
O 0 0 c> L L U o p Q ca +J ¢ L c c0i 0> O U !n m +J N
N U- L o �= _ t6 +� �' �U OC�� � c Qo `� U E a) L6
4- �0 Q� �0 0 L� c nom=. c c �m� po E Q c c cm N�-I-- ca
O a) 4- c ca D o c c in a) p Q c +- V) c m ca � "O o
,-� 'c c o� E� O- c Qp O cU O N O 2 cn o a`�N
o o E 0 ca o a) L= a) r, M M ca U m >_ 0 c
�(n E L 0 ��c ca N m o a O E 4— N 0) `� W�° L �.-
� ) > 0 0.2 a) .� � m a)> U � g) W -a o Q m � � a) E a)
o p c v a) O E c c� c N O' .,-� c� c O 2 p W w
.— 0L cau�i� 0a) o� ca _0 L C) -0
E -o Q E'^CO o� ° U) c O '.-0 a) V E U O _Q O E o c
O ca L C 0 W O c m L� t •� O o 0 U � a) M O c Q (a o U 0 0
c c 0 0 Ems.2 Y E a)—� c o a) EQ Q� a) p a)� �`� O ca
0 o+r� EWO+- �'� �� cn cQ O E� E 00 4= m E c c a)� 0-0
Cl) 4- E _� ujoo4c E.�Q o == ay o �p ��, c�� E >pc`�c
o> o O E � � +�- c D E E C N W' N C o' 0 O (� O Ur . CO U N O m (6
��C� o 0-o� � o+= 0 U- Q a) 0 Q c �'� >,L N C E o L - N� 0)C�O
(n +, 0) Q O �, E 0 0 m L W += ca o "= 0 C O Q Q a W c (A
O +' L N E o p c 70 N ca Z a) _ U) N _Q O >, U O U W O (� O c W
a) rl a) c a) U L c 'O d7 c a) +� a) O � .+- Cfl . "�
a) U C a) a) c " ca a) cn (� O a) c U cLn U 0 cn > +� O c m 0) L
3 CU -0
-Oa) o �Eo .2a)
•�c0 •Ec Q ) cn= o 0 oN�0m
ACL �°oa-cn �a'oai.� �n�0 �o04 Eo oa`n)>" �� coc �o T a� a�m��c_U
(a -p O O D a) fa U U L � O U_ Q _ +. � _) (6 a) O U a) O �O � -c 0- � O • -
.� � fa N U a) o q - O o> a) _ p o U U � a) 2 L Ur to 00 U) N C�jN L p
'F' a) E Q O p +• O cn '6 c) 0 L Q N a) to a) a) c— cn N a)
"O �+ t o U c L L M a) E Q o a) ca fc4 += 0 p) LL c N "O a ca W � C) O ? 4- L Q" 4 -
to O `r "' fL a) p - Co . N O O - � U ~ (� ' to m ca ca `+- M Q c c c O c c
C > " L c cn O L >, c L c >, .- >, o (� L a) m U a) O
E U O N (� c E= O >, ca +_' N 0 U) c c 0 0 0 c 0) U m a) E o} O
p E -0 O +_ Q) -0 W O O. -p c c c c C > a) U O N U
H oU �� 0 0 ca o C0 0 — �•� m o c 0= O v)� o f o> cV 0) a0) ac) 0 �a C) 0
Z ec = C
W m 0 Qo oma°- � � �� 0 �•Q �o ° U rn� U o U o 0 0) O cm E con caM ate)
OD c LL
0 m CO o � � c � -o U E c a) ° c >- a) U a) 0 = 0 � 0 Q LL ca a) � �
W n -� _ o= N U) Q -a p ~ o 0-.— 0 0' -� o a) rn a 'c
o L C: Ma - (n E.QE cm ca �0U c 0�, c � W} Q���,Ec
ca c 0 to o >, a) cn v to O c cn c cn (A Y (n c cn •- (n t- ,- a) •-
Oa. o.�— cn 0 ca c CL Q � a) �"' Q -� an ca Q �� Q ca Qo a) Q Q _-o ��� Q`a
a c� �.�- w o E° w a" w m w m� w �E W W ca E w 0 w L � a) Q N o
a) 0 x U o ca .0 0 L W LU -0 •— m L w E — �-- 42 Ll._ U (n L
cn 0 L 0•c W 0 ��U w Q0 M c E W c E W2i a)— W e 0)a) W o W M W W� �o
L=a) o 2CDo : =200->^o`o =Ej 2OE M/°1) 2_ =joaa)i 2=0- 2_M Oo
f -0 L M= / I..L .^ m I U Q m a) U �! / 1 LL Q I..L I..L / .� I I I �a Z 0
E
C: O a) C
c6 E
O�Z(D
.L � L
N 'O Q
C — U
O p Q
U E
OU p
m a) a) 4`-
C
U' > M "
o >�
C Q m O
O �
L—
M C
U p'-0 m
(n L C E
a) m m
> ?, a)
c aa)) °
Q:boa)
(n 0 M C C
a) _
C C C
>, E
Q 'C Q
>O1 C
C Q
U L n a)
-0 C C O C
O
a)
L
a) a-
-00
� p a)
U
Q a)
-.r- U
+'
C cnC
O a)
p-0
C�
U
U
U
O
>,
a)m—O
m O
U
'C m
a)
M.0
�
) 0
�
0 0 0
(6 '-
a)m ca
70
to (B >
a) C:
a)0
ac
O
C
a)
L O
Q. U 0
0
C a
n
U
Q•�
E�-cmo�
p M
'- 0-
o
C U
(B =
U ;
a) C
a) Q O
0 O U
cB a)
m 75
cn�
O O O Q
C O
C Q
a) U _
a)
"C
�
U Q a)
a)
pFD a) J.--
N
O
U
Q N
_ �
U
(n + +
(II U a)
-E
O1 C
VI
4-
0� tB O— O N -Q� CO 'O O O O O C uj O N >+ p : M (a
_ a_i +r a- U Q C L �' C C O L L C r- U i+ C O �/� f
(B L O O O= p O C LO ,� � _C 4-- O : L; C O a) D
U LL LL = U L+ I L C.r = O C
(0 `� U a) N O Z O "� ° E > cA ° O ca ca cB U "_ L } O E
p +, O O C > (n a) c� :, a) a) L Q m L C C Q C U N O U
0 � � .� � >, � � � � U N � _Q CO � p � � � .0 4? � � O U � U 'a O a) � .Q O U Q 4--
C C C Q L m fB yU_ C L O >+ C (�6 C Q C i- O Q/ E-0 0 a)
> :{-- a) a) M U O U p O Q L -� O C� C/) -= yO.r p +� O V m C = M
U .� U �~ Z Q L n O7 0° L N 0 M! C O -C w C O N c6
a) L p W O a)
O U `� +, C C + O) `� - C f6 E a) � U U a) cn cB Q W
,� 0- M (D C) m o -C U Ld �2iOF- (n 0) 0 c ca : �� °� ° cn
>,0� oma"
t Q) > E o 70 � � � � � W O _ � Q c6 p O � O a) C C O .- ' � v � 0 a) N += C W
Q� c� ° p L o 3 �_ � � �'� o DUB o CL
�.�o� ��Oc-Oa�C m �.� O��EEoC��"- ;ecu a)p�o ca L)—=w.-°=
(n � Q p a) U CL `� ° p => Q E�� co U ni Q CO p N2E 0 a) ° cn
>+ L L � a) C o +r L �_ U •� > ° a) a) Q E o N *- to ° — (n tti
a) (B Q '_ m Q Q L Q C 0) (6 4— 1., "_ Q U= E O O U� U �- L S U ,� � a)
>,•= _
C >, -0 C 4-1 0 — a) Q U Q ..O O m L) ' � (n N _ � c .Q 0) � • � � � M � � � � 32 � � (n
>O �(A•QEwDmm a) cop) �rZ �E0CoC:7501 0-0 Via) a)EC�� 0LN4-M
C OL U a) U U 0-.Q a) E C +� L C ��, C a) W U a) a) � O) Q O �O M—
0- a`+_- C O LQ C N E•C C O a)� +_ C QL CW a) 0 ca O1 a) O Q(Q'' CC7
O O_ tB CB C C a) o "O o } a) (n O �O E 2 O1 B O O O _� N C O Q
0- �' Q >, - O Q (n co U -°� "O m C (6 '' O O m C U) W > O a O E U
Q L cn a) O a) M 4- > }, L O C C U p C +- Z f� (6 ON_
U Q O p m} U 2 Q C C m a) t� O 'D O `� Q) O Q- -0-0 "=C: 76 (� L U C t0 E°
(4 0 C O 4— �' >+ E U m E> LL Q cv O 0 O
V U •� N m C C �_ C-� C U m C L i C� O7 C O U C _ U) C 4-
C:
a) U C cn p U 0 „_ O O O 0 W C Q C p O ai u°i 0 O m t
�-+ �� L p U a 0 0 a)c Q X O LO �O C cn U Q. p m C co C c0 C U E U C ++
U O O O' M L
V � � cn o a� >, "- > >, � �_ W 0 � ° � m a) (D � ca U a) o - F
��+= O �� U rpn� N QmM >W � W a)p > U) 4— E Lu
L } � ��
a) _Q
C+ N U >'U N+� OU U Ui- Cm a) C O O (n
(1) M L�C�(��E c6 ��cna�Cc250� a,`n Q)QE caU�UU� c�a--aU)U)-0
U p (B Q U E a) O' >, >+ O C co Q >+ • C O U Q c N C a) O
C L :f C U >' a) ' C a) a) >, U M m C M U Q- -0 M C >, — a) a) -0 C C C U a) U U C C -a
0° Q�d o °� E Q EQ o f a) a) o o Lo E 0 Eoo o 0�.�0 �� E c°°>
U a) `+_ 0) Q E U c6 E "_' U U *_' C LL *� U ca cn Q L U U (� C U_ a) _ L M U O
a) O Q C � C U O N Q U °U a) -a a) � a) Q C -0 a) O� a) ._� -� Q
U ^0 0 t C C t C� X C C -C a) i (� Q.
O OQ O n'- 0)Q -C
�— Z C 2 U � M M (n F- I-- H �— o 2 cn 1- o o (n co
cli psi co
N
E o 0) o �W o c o �— a) p t��c� c U) -0 Fu E >,c o >, >, cn o o o N O >.cu o
C: �_ o L a) L a) _ c a) o U_ o c c c p U c. U *� a) p p c E
L �- (n vi (n L O c a) 1— n o �_ U ca cc 0 cn 4- c (n U) Cu Q cn Co N N 0> c cB CU
(n O o = a) L ca «� Cn >' o cn to N ° `� c U m (n c- � U o c6 N o
U U a) (6 p L a) F- a) ch ,E - L c U) � O o c O U E c CO O i
U� "O C C �+- Q O O O L r-- V U CB O = p "O to (n o L CV
4_ a) m — (n Cli O >+ +� U c c ° -0 C6 > r ( Q p U O X (� U a) Cu "c _c Q O � -0 � 0-
m
O o L o cn c c o L N_0 �' Q o p >+ .� D Q' U '- U to o U c E c c o Ctf c 0 c I— ., L E p
_ L U Ur o +� ca O o a) ca .. p Q- — U o a) o O + ui U O +_� Cn
O to O U O O >, to (n 0 Cn O a) m E +- t� U C6 Z3 N U� Cu
U j 'C3 Q c `� o
o E >,ow o 4.1 > o or _ U o L m > > c� U� o-0 O �, _0 U
o p = Q a) O U E N c m U O Q o o 4- O U O Q O m CO . L o U _Co
a) 0- p L m c Q—+ O- p 4- } (0 4- Cn Q L o '- -0 O a) o
> c o c L U >, U L O Cn c, } _ O c p (� c +� >. c' (!)
cn > c m p L is o .,... p CU cv O L o a Co _ 4- >, —, c U>, .c L o L o p
o m0 U) o c U �4- c° c� ECo o c �' -a E °4- o cv U° v � p E o c U
> (n (n c o �� �-0 +��� 007Ot'+� E —4O L'a) (B O �.Q� ?� o O Cn 0-0 �,� 4- 0
C.0 O (� N p (� Q = c> "- O Q OU O c� O E ca -c c ca ca U) Q N u c O o c LL
O c U E + f0 t� o> L `+- —_ 4- O o° r Q 0) U= L L �= O c O° U `t °
UE -o `_'�4-."> Qc (n"�� a)E°°°LUpUO(n'c� �L°c �E,� ,�>�*�UE(n��Urn
o f o� o Q° �� " o C) � 0� >,Q �.c � (n c aci o 0 0 �'(n� o f o E o m W a) �.� C)�
C c to Cis U o L O Q Y Q *�' '= c Q — O c O C) + Q +� O `} U o +� >' o L M
O CSf o c "� > L'' Cu a) o� c O LO O L Cu O U C +� c U EE N ui O O o
+ (B (n U +— (� O L c c a L� �-+ c c a=+ L- O .c 4F- c t o X O `' CB += c CL -0 m i
c� �, w�'>�} o 0mm o —_co _cuE�occ6° �(n c c°t�4-°)E O E°(nEc co
c :t-- c U (n Lo L O O c L(D E (0 O E > E— +r .— .� CO cn a) c a) o L O L o — D o o m E O c
(n Q O .N M O to O O Q "=' O Q Q u7 c •� C ° 4 -qt p (On .c to v a) (�
a) cpc a) a) — U O cB U cu cv c >+ O — O (n — ,� c o
a) a) . U 0) _ Q LO -0 E L o U a) 4= N r Q "c Cn> � C i Co(Q -0 E> o U O N c Ca +_ c a) 4--
4? E
cc c E U� m O t� �� ��> 4- U -° o p., c c o c L o o CO c � Q a) v, a) .-� -v o E� O °
(if c' E O p �- o a`) c U coo ° c U 4- o Q' Fm Q- •+-' a) c to E c U. L Cn 4- p °' a) c o
C Q c ,� (B O _ �_ o U c (6 a) N Cu >' U O L o— U N CB c —_ c (n Ca O L L O +r (n
o Q= E o �� o °� X �' U (n Q� �' o O O vQ� a) o o o) U �N� En
070 c E
CL5 0 '- O Q O O O N ,_ c o o C: U) Cnn p c cB cu ca o O (n Q c C U o +� 0 o* -o U_ Q a)
Q (n c E n �n p OO c E ° E F— O.a v-0 E o "_ p+,-0_ C o c o (nN__ O ca U c> 0)
U c ,_, ,_ ;C .— c o D N E O = O i�. -a (n +� c cB c U O — c c o
c o (n c p U E U � 4- 4- o a) ca o C6 , c c E•° O L) >, (/j (n Q
c 4- LL >�co a o 4 - CB a) c -p o `� o (n — - o > a)
(n t� o° U U L O c E U CB o U— c O E° +r Q" c L ° U _r >, -0 (n c U >, c O -c -a- c
t� U E > N +- Q c O O CB o o L o � O p c o +� c O >+ U} — U O
o c -0 c Q >+ 4- C c >, -o (� �- U o— c .� O p U L >+ "O >' c c (%� ' L O U +_ C6 U
-E U) O U N Cif E o E +� c ° o-� U (B c 4= c r +� U t� O c ° U
v c oQ� a cn E Q� cB� L-� �:._ X �o M c Qo c U� ��4_.Q-�
� m L O� CTS Q c 0) 0) M o U)� Q� _Q o u) E O .� o� � o o h c Q cts
c° U c c aci c " o a) o° coi . c 4- `� C U c v `o c—' o cn - -c `-- U (on c° o
cis o U Qui c > d o c c ° O �— rn o o `t c c 0-0-0 _ Q• o c •- ca
c O Q E o c E o c O o= c m c c LO r p C c c o p}o (u O( c6 a) c L
ca V �� E a) E 2(D 0)(D� �'- °� O c- 0 �� c �— o QE �� c m a) 0- o Q� c
o a) Q2 L o U) -0 c Q
o�.N � Loo �� �p 0� o,} o o*=�o �� o a) 0 Cn L o o x m �� cEa o (D C: o� o °o >�
U c cB f—� �wz3 cts I --U �U U oU��r.�Qf—� I—� o� f— o.�� cts (n WUC� ca Qo U U.�� E
O N ch �t
CX) r r r r r
R
r
CO
U'
O
C
O
>+ 0 >
C '_
O
L'
0
a)
a)
Q
f
C
� cB OO
.O
C
�.-
O
O
0
= m
ca L U
m
Z
'D
a) O Q)
O
C
C
N 'L
w
Q
L -
(n Otr-
.r1
C
Z
U)
U)
m
> (!�
r�
O p
U
a)
a) U
O
O
a)
O
O
_0 O
O-
f]0
0
� a)
>:
O
Q
U
O -0
Q
.a
Q
U
o
N N
CO O Q
ECLU
"' • V
F-
m
+•
Q 'C a)
C
U O O
N
Z
c0
>,
m
a) L L'L
E
m
C O
a)0
Q a
p
L
Y
C
-aC
U
O
N
>� N
CUa)O
QU
(1)O
N
N
(13
U
U.
cin C}N-
cis
U
a) O
W
--� cc
c6 U
C
Q
�
o
U
0 0
o
m
>
O m
OU C
o
-a U
m
L
U- m +�+
4-cts
a) a)0
O
O 0. o
O L 0
O
a)
a)
a) U
'
Co
a) -C
`�
(n-
PE'>
()—
4.-
a)
U -0+�
_ O
cB a)
L
U
O C
fly
O
t�
f20
E
C
to
U f6
_0
O
C 't3
}
L C
a) a)
a) L
N
Q)
0 0
+ •C
r.
1O
>0
` L O
O
-r- EDW
^�,
O
-r-
4-
O
E a)
iE
m �
Q
a)
>,
LU
m
o C c
F 0
0
a) L
a)
W:
Z-
J
0 E�
0c
�E
•�
Q
W
a) -
U
_�
U
0
(�
='
Q-
O Q)
� a)
�
CO
Q_
L-
0- -a Q �
cn
O E
-0
Z �
n"
0 L cn
0 C
O ca
>,
C ca
F- a)
U
Z fa
Z U
Q a_
Q sz
Z
U
Z)
(fl
�-
ti
r-
06
T -a)
Z X
2
—
M.
U
C =
O m
;._ m
O
U �
-0 U)
C _U
cn E
EO
L C
a) O
� U
W
04-
O
cn CU c
a) E
> 'C
s- CZ
Q. a)
Q 0
tt II
f
.O
W
Z
0)
"-
Z
U- U
N
Li%
c
Q
O
(n Otr-
.r1
c>3
Z
U)
U)
^a^)`
W
> (!�
r�
C
Q O
O
Q
O
u- .�
U
f]0
0
f
>:
O
Q
U
c
F
cn
O
F-
O
(�
Z
>,
L
I-
O �>
a
D
O
Q�
_
_
U
r<
o
E
QU
(1)O
=
Z
ca Q
LU
m
W
c
0
4-
Q
U
_j
a
m
a°
m
o
U
C =
O m
;._ m
O
U �
-0 U)
C _U
cn E
EO
L C
a) O
� U
W
04-
O
cn CU c
a) E
> 'C
s- CZ
Q. a)
Q 0
I
= Ioa)
U) 0
III
Y U)
aU)
Ea
0
U
NT
tt II
f
W
Z
J
O
Q
U- U
N
W
U)
CL
=E
(n Otr-
c>3
Z
(n 06
^a^)`
W
> (!�
Z)
UJL
Q O
O
Q
Q
U
f]0
ii
I
= Ioa)
U) 0
III
Y U)
aU)
Ea
0
U
NT
cn
0
0
H
-0E-�
m M
cn
�a m
L
L- N m O
�
N M O
� o -2
a�0m
m "c m c U
O OO M
�4-
O m U
4- cri >� c
c 5 w
O w
O 'cn
Q U t6
O
0)
_N m C:
O m D
E
(B O
O Al E
0
C O N
O E +- O
U d m _0
-C (6
U (B (/� —
m
� c
�<-0
0 (n OCN OU
C::!EC
3} N
U 0 a�Y
t: O Q m
0) 0 a�
a) :
0o�m
Q
c6
70
0
4
O
U
U
fI5
ai
m
E
H