HomeMy Public PortalAbout2020.06.30 Special Council Minutes MINUTES
McCall City Council
Special Meeting
McCall City Hall Via Teams
June 30,2020
Call to Order and Roll Call
Work Session
Adjournment
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Mayor Giles called the.special meeting of the McCall City Council to order at 3:00 p.m.
Mayor Giles, Council Member Holmes, Council Member Maciaszek, and Council Member
Nielsen all answered roll call. Council Member Sowers joined the meeting at 3:02 p.m.
City staff members present were Anette Spickard, City Manager; BessieJo Wagner, City Clerk;
Erin Greaves, Communications Manager; Linda Stokes, City Treasurer; Michelle Groenevelt,
Community Development Director; Chris Curtin, Information Systems Manager; Traci Malvich,
Human Resources Manager;Justin Williams,Police Chief;Nathan Stewart,Public Works Director
Also, in attendance was Amber Green, St. Luke's Hospital; Russ Duke, Central District Health;
Lindsay Haskell, Central District Health;
All submitted written comments are included as attachments to the minutes.
WORK.SESSION
Covid-19 Information Update—Awareness of Growing Concerns for the Public's Health
and Safety
Mayor Giles laid out the schedule of the meeting. City Clerk BessieJo Wagner read a letter from
Dr. Gregory Irvine. The letter is attached as part of the permanent record.
Amber Green with St. Luke's Hospital gave an update on happenings at the hospital. There has
been an increase of patients showing symptoms at the clinic and hospital and the amount of testing
has increased as expected. She shared it takes 10-14 days for symptoms to become severe enough
to require hospitalization, so the hospital expects to see an influx of patients over the next two
weeks. St. Luke's staff have spent considerable time in preparation for the virus and one thing that
has been implemented is to treat every patient coming in the door as a possible infected person as
an effort to protect staff and other patients.
Russ Duke from Central District Health(CDH) gave a brief overview. The two main public health
goals are to protect the vulnerable.and prevent the hospital being overrun. Realistically,there is no
stopping the infection from happening but rather to try to provide better management in effective
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page I of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting
treatment and helping the population gain herd immunity. However, it is yet to be determined if
people will acquire a long-term immunity from having had it. He is in discussion with City
Manager Anette Spickard about a multi-agency coordination structure for communication. One
role of the CDH is disease tracking. Community spread does not necessary mean it is widespread.
The CDH has the ability to implement quarantine but it is not at a level at this point in time where
those orders need to be imposed. Commissioner Elt Hasbrouck is the board representative for
Valley County and is a part of the decision-making process. Also, cities have permission to pass
an emergency order as they see fit. He receives many emails from the community from both sides
of the spectrum of whether or not to enforce a mandated shutdown. He reiterated it is not possible
to stop the disease from spreading, only determining what levels are acceptable. He explained an
unacceptable level would be transmission in long-term care facilities,jails where people cannot
escape, and overcrowding at hospitals. The CDH will provide guidance when the time comes and
will support the City as it can in necessary decisions for this community.
Lindsay Haskell,Epidemiologist at Central District Health, explained her role is to follow up with
anyone who tests positive by conducting an interview to determine where they may have picked
up the virus and who they may have exposed. Community transmission means they did not get the
virus by traveling outside the area or from someone they know who tested positive such as a friend,
spouse,family member but by an activity within the community.Another portion of contact tracing
is determining what activities the individual had been involved in while infected and to fmd those
individuals who might have been exposed in order to notify them as an additional effort to help
the community protect itself. She shared the numbers are not reflective of what is really going on
in the community because cases are reported in their primary county of residence and the CDH
staff in each county are responsible for those individuals reported from their county. For example,
if an Ada County resident has a part-time residence in Valley County and get sick while here, the
CDH staff here will contact Ada County and pass the information over to them.
Mayor Giles stated he has spent time talking to multiple people within the community and
including City staff and the overall feedback he received was everyone felt a bit in the dark about
the data that has been shared by St. Luke's and the CDH about the actual numbers in the
community. Three prominent restaurant businesses have closed due to exposure to the virus which
is concerning and there are those who have expressed the fear this is the beginning stage of
something similar to what happened in Blaine County. There are dozens of people contacting the
City every day demanding that actions are being ramped up to protect the community. He asked
for more information to help the City determine the next steps.
At this point, Mayor Giles asked the Council to share their questions and insights.
Council Member Holmes expressed some concerns based on conversation with local businesses.
She did not understand why the City is not being informed about the actual number of infected
identified in Valley County, how many were recovering here, and how many patients at the
hospital. She felt it left the City at a disadvantage and was unfair to the public. She wanted to know
the protocol for the recovery of non-county residents such as if they were sent back to the county
of origin since this county is not equipped to handle large numbers of infected people. She is
hearing from many businesses the desire for the City to provide instruction and leadership on
protocols and she feels the City should provide that assistance. Mr. Duke addressed her questions.
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 2 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting
He explained how the information is passed from the testing centers to the CDH and how it is
determined if a business needs to quarantine. The challenge is the testing centers report to the
county of residence and the CDH does their best to follow up on those cases. The information
provided for Valley County is accurate but agreed it does not show how many cases are actually
here. Ms. Haskell explained it takes a least a week to learn about cases of out of the area visitors,
if she is informed at all and therein lies the challenge.
Council Member Nielsen had questions regarding testing numbers. He felt the City should be able
to get the number of all the cases reported within Valley County regardless of where the individual
is from. Mr. Duke felt the only mechanism that could help with this issue was if the testing centers
were to provide the information as the local CDH is not privy to that data.He stated this is an issue
for each city and county. Ms. Haskell shared that in regard to the aggregate numbers, an infected
person may have to test a several times before allowed back to work and those tests may come
back positive a few different times before they reach a negative status and thus the numbers can
be inflated. Ms. Green pointed that by the time the hospital learns a person has tested positive, it
is unknown how many others have been infected. She does not feel the real-time numbers of
positive tests are not a good indicator of who now has been exposed or has it. If relying on the
tests,the numbers reported of today are already behind the curve in what is happening in real time.
Council Member Nielsen also wanted to know why people were driving to Boise for testing. Ms.
Green was not sure why people were traveling out of the area for testing as the capability to test is
available here. However, she did state that due to the limited number of tests, they cannot test
everyone who feels they may have been exposed and yet have no symptoms. Also, because it is
unknown when a person becomes viral, a test may come back negative until the viral load is high
enough to test positive. Testing too early gives a false sense of security and the person may let
their guard down with protection and hygiene measures exposing others to the virus. She
confirmed there is an adequate amount of supplies available at this time but the hospital has a
conservative approach and prioritizes the list of patients according to need in order to have the
ability to care for those who become critical if suddenly there were a large number cases to arrive
at the hospital. Mayor Giles asked Ms. Green if she could approach the St. Luke's corporation
about increasing the ability for more local testing to help mitigate people traveling to Boise. She
stated she could but shared the entire hospital organization has the same protocols with testing.
She could not, however, speak to what practices of Crush the Curve or any other testing centers
have. Council Member Holmes asked how many cases have tested positive at the local St. Luke's
and Ms. Green stated she does not have those numbers handy and does not monitor those as a daily
practice nor is she personally notified when those tests come back positive.
Ms. Green clarified for Council Member Sowers the number of hospitalizations has been few at
St. Luke's McCall as anyone in critical care are transferred to Boise where there is a better ability
to care for them. Mr. Duke clarified the goal with herd immunity but stated it will take years to
achieve the 65-70%goal and is banking on a vaccine to help the more vulnerable.He also clarified
the numbers are below the peak from a couple months ago and does not anticipate a huge surge
for the hospitals in Boise,however,the challenge is not having adequate critical care units at those
hospitals to care for all the normal incidences and the virus which is an issue everyone is trying to
vet through. Council Member Sowers felt there are other communities (such as Blaine County)
ahead of this community in terms of exposure and cases, and he would like the data to be studied
and shared to assist in modeling what protocols are necessary to be done here.
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 3 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting
Council Member Maciaszek felt the primary question he has heard from the community is
regarding the numbers of cases in the County but in hearing today's information,understands it is
challenging information to provide. From what he has heard, he feels there is a strong public
interest in a resolution with some restrictions for safety but help keep people working so as to not
shut down the town again.
Mayor Giles does not want to become the second county with the nation's highest infection rate
per capita. He feels there is an opportunity to get in front of infection rate with some strong action.
He suggests another special Council meeting tomorrow to discuss a resolution,and hopefully learn
more about the approach of the City of Jackson, Wyoming to assist with developing a plan.
Council Member Maciaszek is in favor of a meeting tomorrow and a resolution with the
requirement of masks for in-door public areas to address health and safety but allowing businesses
to stay open. Council Member Nielsen is in favor as well and would like to hear the advice of the
professionals in attendance. Council Member Holmes is open to a resolution and feels something
needs to be done to stay ahead of the curve. Mr.Duke addressed Council Member Nielsen request.
He feels face covering are the best tool to reduce exposure and spread as well as allowing business
to remain open.It would need to be across the board for all people,not just visitors.He is in support
of face coverings inside buildings and outdoors, if around people outside your inner circle. The
risk of contamination comes not from passing someone on the street but when the time around
others starts to exceed 10-15 minutes.
Council Member Nielsen wants to ensure the City helps the local businesses deal with exposure
issues and navigate the influx of infections. Mr. Duke felt it is very important that people not only
in the workplace but in their personal life do all they can to protect themselves. Ms. Haskell
explained there is a ton of information on the CDH website and to please reach out to their staff.
Ms. Green stated the hospital was able to learn much from their sister hospital in Sun Valley and
therefore implemented a pre-screening trailer for anyone needing to come into their facilities and
required masking of anyone coming into the buildings which has been paramount in protecting
staff and patients. Since these two requirements were put in place, not one employee has reported
sick. It is vital to keep the economy going. Their experience is the majority of people are willing
to comply to the masking. Council Member Nielsen wanted to know what to do when an individual
has been tested positive or exposed where the employer still requires the person to come to work.
Mr. Duke stated this is difficult to manage and problematic to contend with. Ms. Haskell stated
often the CDH will contact the employer to help mitigate the issues. Unfortunately, this is not a
one-size fits all approach but a case by case basis. Employees can contact the CDH with concerns.
Council Member Nielsen is very concerned about employees threatened with firing and wants a
collaborate relationship with the CDH and St. Luke's.
Council Member Maciaszek wanted it to be clear that he is less interested in 100% enforcement
but more support of the businesses in dealing with this issue.
Police Chief Justin Williams gave an update on efforts the City has done to support the community
and education efforts. He wanted to make sure the Council understood the difference of what an
enforcement action is and what is not. He explained an enforcement action is created by an
emergency order whereas a resolution is only a recommendation or strong suggestion and not
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 4 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting
enforceable by law. If the Council chooses to make an emergency order, the mechanism for
enforcement needs to be addressed in the action. This is uncharted waters for a city to create a
mandatory mask requirement and advised the Council to think carefully about making an
emergency order. He stated he only has 6 officers which is only one officer for every 8000 people
when there is a high volume of visitors in town.
Mayor Giles would like staff to prepare a resolution for tomorrow's special meeting and received
no objections from the Council members. City Manager Spickard suggested to put out a travel
advisory to warn visitors of what to expect. She shared West Central Mountains Economic
Advisory Council is also putting out information for the community. Communication Manager
Erin Greaves shared some of the language she will use and asked for anything specific the Council
would like to see put out. Council Member Nielsen suggested something about encouraging
Treasure Valley residents to have staycations rather than traveling here for fun. Mayor Giles
wrapped up by reiterating the meeting on July 1 will be at 5:00 p.m. for the review of resolution.
ADJOURNMENT
Without further business,._1VMyor Giles.adjourned the meeting at 4:34 p.m.
ATTEST: a s��i x�obert S. Giles, Mayor
civ In
BessieJo Wa e , City C r
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 5 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting
Concern at 06/25/2020 8:32 PM
From: Melissa Rood
Describe Your Concern:
Please (!) consider making masks mandatory in all public places in McCall! Things are just now
starting to "heat up", in regards to COVID, here.....follow the science and data, protect our
community, and remove the stigma of mask wearing...by requiring them from everyone. Things
are getting too tense in restaurants and stores here, where locals are wearing masks, but tourists
are not.
Concern at 06/25/2020 10:04 PM
From: Regan Berkley
Describe Your Concern:
I would like the council to consider making mask use mandatory inside all businesses,restaurants,
and other places of business in McCall. Ada and Canyon counties are seeing surges in COVID
cases, and Valley County's cases are also increasing. Mandatory mask use would enable visitors
(many of whom are from the Treasure Valley) to continue to come here, and businesses to stay
open, while still providing security for both residents and visitors. Please consider it now, before
our cases increase dramatically.
Concern at 06/26/2020 12:42 PM
From Michelle Kehm—McCall
Describe Your Concern:
To Mayor Giles, I realize that McCall is a summer recreational destination and I built my
livelihood on that fact,but I ask that you please put the health of the residents of McCall first when
it comes to requiring masks to be work within city limits whenever people are indoors or not able
to properly socially distance. Similar mandates are in effect throughout the country, as you are
likely aware of, and there is resounding proof that mask wearing helps to stop the spread of
COVID. I am honestly.scared every time I go to Ridleys or Albertsons and Father's Place and see
throngs of tourists not wearing masks. They're probably from Boise, which is in the early stages
of an outbreak. Let's be smarter than that, please? Let's nip this in the bud now. The residents of
McCall deserve your wise judgement and protection.Especially during the next few months,when
we'll be visited by thousands of outsiders. McCall is a safe haven. Let's keep it that way! Thank
you.
Concern at 06/27/2020 10:51 AM
From: Sheree Sonfield
Describe Your Concern:
Given that 1)we now have community spread and case#'s skyrocketing (and underreported if the
case identified here lives outside of Valley County) and 2) wearing a mask has been documented
to reduce the spread and 3)pleading with people to wear a mask is not accomplishing the goal to
get more people masked ---- WHY are we not mandating mask wearing inside a public place? Is
this being discussed? If not, why isn't it being discussed? (We wouldn't be the only town/county
to require masks...)
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 6 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
Concern at 06/27/2020 5:56 PM
From: Mary Carter
Describe Your Concern:
I'm sure you are in contact with the Mayor of Sun Valley They have an electron sign north and
south of town WEAR A MASK No one enters a business without one You can make this happen
for the safety of all Please reply to my request
Concern at 06/29/2020 10:43 AM
From: Ginger Riggins
Describe Your Concern:
Please cancel all furture community events especially those that will attact tourist like the planned
4th of July events. Now that we have Community spread shouldn't we be canceling as many
community events as possible?Things are only going to continue to get worse. Do we have to be
like Blaine County before we do anything to protect our community? If you choose not to cancel
things shouldn't you at least require masks? I feel that you are putting your desire for money over
the heath and safety of people in our community. Please do something to stop the spread of
Covid19. Don't invite more people up here. People who are coming have no regard for the people
who live here and seem to refuse to wear any type of face covering or do anything to social
distance. Since they have no respect for us I believe we should do everything we can to deter them
from coming. Please help save us. You as our city are the only ones who can.
Concern at 06/26/2020 11:55 AM
From Ann Brown
Describe Your Concern:
Yes, my name is Ann Brown and I have been a part time resident of McCall for the last 70 years.
I'm very concerned about people up here not wearing masks, most most that that are going into
Albertson's;that is criminal.With the 4th of July coming up,McCall needs to mandate masks. We
do it for everybody else's safety and people here don't seem to be terribly concerned sometimes,
so it needs to be mandated. Thank you
Concern at 06/29/2020 3:18 PM
From: Linda Thompson
Describe Your Concern:
Please implement stricter restrictions for our safety as COVID confirmed cases increase. Require
wearing masks in all businesses,consider closing non-essential businesses again.Close the county
if necessary. Be smarter than the politicians!!!
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 7 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
Concern at 06/28/2020 10:03 AM
From: Pamela McChrystal
Describe Your Concern:
What? The City needs to be responsible and shut down! This is a extremely dangerous game you are
playing with peoples lives! My husband works the sick car clinic and we are terrified with the cases and
people's behavior! If he gets sick it's the City who is responsible! Good luck taking care of yourself!!!
MCCALL CITYCOUNCIL Page 8 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Bob Giles
To: BessieJo Wagner
Subject: FW:COVID community spread etc
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 9:09:48 AM
Attachments: IMG 0921.PNG
IMG 0922.PNG
1MG 0923.PNG
1MG 0924.PNG
For Packet.
Bob
From:Toni Slaymaker<tonislaymaker@frontiernet.net>
Sent: Monday,June 29, 2020 7:07 PM
To: Bob Giles<bgiles@mccall.id.us>
Subject:COVID community spread etc
---This email is from an external sender. Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments if the
sender is unknown.---
Bob
See attached and sharing this from my Facebook feed. Lots of similarities to McCall.
I understand from Sherry Maupin that the Mayor and city council has the power to mandate specific
regulations in this pandemic. I personally don't feel discretionary precautions are adequate to mitigate
the risk of a major outbreak/hotspot in our community.
Bottom line-listen to Dr. Irvine and within your powers at the city council require masks in public and
private venues as you can. At least at this juncture.
Thank you for considering this message.
My best,
Toni Slaymaker
1635 Lakeridge Drive
McCall, ID. 83638
208,315.0846
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 9 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
c3i PM lion Jun 29 utl c�iDD:�_
Alaska News
Seward, at the precipice' of a major
COVED-19 outbreak, cancels.Fourth of
July celebration liaiaWbfe
/.Authar:3az Hollander O Updated;I hour ago M Nblishcd 2 hours a o ka"mast
database ptagramz atNl11T. www.Alaska271.org
t 0 in 3- n* A-
Ar aid spiking co.ronavirus cases in the scenic city on Resurrection Rat Seward
chanther:of rammerce offiicialspn,\landayrtnceled Fourth of July event-.this caming MYALASKATI X
weekend.
King Salmon
on the Y,as4lol
The cancellation includes fiiewarks and vendors in addition to the already canceled »",Juno S. WA.W.
:Mount i<larathon Race.and parade.The eyents'annuallydraw thousands of As.itors 2020
from.a wide part of the state,tripling 5e>vard's 2;750 year round population,
Chong Hot
Springs from
Fairbanks
. i A1onday.:kmr29.
I 202a
airQtYBod_—_______.I
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 10 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
Gi�y p6t jJlon Jler24' --- - '+itl F"+s low`
f1�6tl16tai�;. - ..
ANC110RAGE DAILYNEWS CorrinnATus AlaskaWyis PoIttics •
�'�Qzt?,t�oua�l,tlnratlinn Rare cnneel crt diac,trt C[lt'l!?-1«cun[rrrs f -��
As of.Monday,I9 Seward residents had tested positive,for COVID;I9,[ncluding eightF mi1yC.drp,' .1nc.
nevronSunday,after m ouibreak began there late last%Tek,accorditigto the Alaska
,.
Department of Healthand Social Servrices.CQVID-19 dashboard."Another3 cases were
reported in nonresidents there,including!uri new cases Sunday. yr
The city last week Av[std altyonc who lied•vlsIted the Sewairl Alehouse and Yukon r f
13 readier in.the week they should be tested for the virus A Seward.Alehouse
employee tested positir for COVID I9 and the restaurant posted k would close for
cleaning and to monitor employee health:Hundreds of tests.uvre performed over the
weekend., H
+
Wily restaurants"acid bars`dua otown were closed Dionday and nvmerous'peoplc were
uWt ng to get tested,according to Kai Sorensei a ehanilieispo eswonian.
1
Sorensen said she hoped no one was.planning,any kind ofalternativne activities to
make uir for the loss of the annual festivities:
ILI
jt iNlLtct-$earl
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 11 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
8'39P1.i'hipu�Jurt29 — `�id'c'�IOM:'®•
2 sewvir[,at Uta ureetvlcr uf"'
.'%Ve are at the precipice of our COV1D outbreak,"she said Monday. rEwiorcrnlUat9aac+arak
omh F®uTth orlulg
a9e6rattoif-..
The Seward Chamber of C.ommeree•had originally hoped to proceed=ttiith the holiday a._ ,
b p smother now
events using mitigation n mures such ais soClal di5t8nci face'e6vetings handed but (Xwul-t9acthx- asehigh �s
6me nq rrtiw,lws�italaaations
In participants,hand saniiizerstatians and street closures to give.people more roam uracdihi
to spreadouG.
4.Iiuntrntsr tlskamanhmt
wire w denth.ehaMing
But the chamber,in cotlabdration.-with the city of Seward,state and local healthcare
providers and the chamber-hoard and members decided instead to can given the
Went and dramatic increase in.COVID-19 cases there,-accnrdmg.re a statement 5 71addw'Cov10-19hc , ]
issued Monday.
is hung er the
only; • ADNRecomm.04d's
ail
you hear?
Natlon-World
r Couple dracvguns at
crowd heading to St.
Louis mayor's home
- maim
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 12 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
13APAl.'e Qa' Jure29
AJaska•News
"wre seeing cases across businesses and indifferent sectors,'°Soren"en,said,"At this M I
pninl',if,dur downtown is:closed due to air-nnaviriis wncems,there's nn reason tine Tcvo more Alaslt8t]S
should be inviHngvisitarsidcur fdwn" die Outside txitlt
COVW-1%bi iging
t esident death total
jBecatise of a ltor volnrtie o f comments requirir+g nioderatiorr,we are teinitorarily disab[irtg tQ 14
coinnaerits nn rrmny of our articles so editors cars foals orr the coronti►Rrtrs crisis and other
talcragC.�ti`e"invite)wu to.$♦Tice a litter ro ihc criitor ar reach ow tlkixtly if you'd like tri
coinmrrnicate tirith us tilrukt a partiUrlat artitic'-Tiaartks,f
l�
Today's
Refinance Rate
Our most important stories, in your inbox.
f ;r-A ,'erjwrir th,^o y=s,p'c::olrnn vIiya arm lo-:.ir r:bar.
ever y roc,+- . 53 / 0
26
APR 15 Year fixed
Select Loan Amount
.�oyerCoranuv+n,x �
AtmutthisAuthor $2257000'
,
Zaz Hollander
Sent from my Wad
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 13 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Bob Giles
To: BessieJo Waaner
Subject: FW:COVID Community spread
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 9:11:17 AM
For Packet
Bob
From:tonislaymaker@frontiernet.net<tonislaymaker@frontiernet.net>
Sent:Sunday,June 28, 2020 12:34 PM
To: Bob Giles<bgiles@mccall.id.us>
Subject:COVID Community spread
---This email is from an external sender. Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments
if the sender is unknown. ---
Bob,
I have sent this message to the Valley County Commissioners and urging my sphere to do
the same. Given the major influx of resort area visitors and the community spread reported,
many of my friends and associates are anxious and desire action to protect our citizenry.
At this juncture the only thing I know is what I don't know-the"facts"about this pandemic
and its impact on any age group seem to change daily.
I respectfully and strongly urge you to establish diligent, proactive initiatives to protect our
citizens and our livelihood. Dr. Gregory Irvine's succinct and factual message in the Star
News this last edition relative to masks,face coverings in this unpredictable pandemic Is
something that makes total sense to me. However you have the ability to mandate these
things, I support any regulations that would require wearing masks in public venues and our
private businesses, particularly retail and grocery stores where we see a broad mix of local
and out of area visitors.
I implore you to establish a safe rather than sorry management philosophy in governing our
community through this difficult time.
Thank you for your service over the years and in this challenging assignment.
Toni Slaymaker
1635 Lakeridge Drive
Mccall, Idaho 83638
208.315.0846
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 14 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Bob Giles
To: A PEMBERTON
Cc: Anette Soickard;Bessie]o Wagner
Subject: RE: Face Coverings
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 10:17:18 AM
Thanks Amy. City Council is meeting today w/a number of agencies and experts to share
information about our current status w/Covid 19. Your input is timely and helpful.
Bob Giles.
From:AMY PEMBERTON <>Sent:Tuesday,June
30, 2020 10:13 AM
To: Bob Giles<bgiles@mccall.id.us>
Cc:Steve Millemann<sjm@mpmplaw.com>
Subject: Face Coverings
---This email is from an external sender. Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments
if the sender is unknown. ---
Bob,
I know that you are inundated with a situation you could have never anticipated when you
took office. This COVID-19 issue is difficult by anyone's standards, let alone someone who
is making decisions about how the city will proceed.
I notice that the City's website is asking people to wear face coverings in public. I am writing
to you to request that the city actually impose a requirement for everyone to wear face
coverings in public and practice social distancing. This could be limited to when people are
inside and not seated at a restaurant, and outside if social distancing cannot be practiced. This
could be noticed on banners over the road at the two entry points to town.
I think people are coming to visit McCall and are totally skipping all responsible and
respectful ways to visit McCall and interact with its residents. I just spoke with a Physician's
Assistant yesterday in Boise,who came to McCall last weekend. He said that he thinks people
are careful in their home town, but then come to McCall on vacation and fail to practice social
distancing or wear face coverings. He went to Mountain Java with a mask on, and they said to
him"you must be a local, you have a mask on". This is sad. Everyone should be respecting
McCall and its residents, and do what they can to avoid community spread. I think, given the
very busy weeks ahead, it would be worth imposing face coverings.
Thank you for your consideration of this request, stay well, and have a good day,
Amy
Amy Pemberton
Millemann Pemberton &Holm LLP
The information contained in this transmission may contain privileged and confidential information. It is intended
only for use of the person(s)named above. If you are not the intended recipient:(1)you are hereby notified that any
review,dissemination,distribution or duplication of this communication is strictly prohibited;and,(2)please
contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. Thank you for your cooperation.
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 15 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Rodney Auth
To: BessieJo Wagner
Subject: COVID Concerns-Please forward to city council members.Thanks.
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 11:32:27 AM
---This email is from an external sender. Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments
if the sender is unknown. ---
City Council,
As a full-time resident and business owner, I'm becoming increasingly concerned for the health of
my wife and four daughters. We've been told 25+cases of COVID have gone through our hospital in
the last week with some of those folks being sent to Boise to be hospitalized yet our official counts
only show 11 confirmed eases in Valley County.
I understand visitors who are sick with COVID count only in their hometowns, but if they're
"recovering" here,we need to know. Where can we go to get an accurate report of the COVID risk in
our hometown?
Likewise, we are increasingly unclear as to what establishments are safe to support. For example,
we've been told Mile High Marina and Shore Lodge have had active cases of COVID, but there is no
information posted anywhere to let us know if this is true and, if so,what those organizations have
done to mitigate the risk—so, right or wrong,we are simply staying away. In fact, because this
information doesn't appear to be transparently reported,we have decided to avoid all local
institutions. We don't want to do this, but we have no way of knowing which businesses are safe to
support(other than May's Hardware which has been requiring masks since day 1). Is there a way we
can determine this so we can help our local business owners?
Finally, what steps are being taken to stop the surge in cases? My office is located above Ice Cream
Alley. I've stopped using it because I can't safely navigate the path from my house on Roosevelt
Avenue to my office without passing groups of un-masked, non-social distancing visitors. It seems to
me the best solution for all business owners and residents is to require masks in public. If we do this,
we might have a chance of reversing the surge AND keeping our economy running. It appears to
offer that rare win-win solution. I fear this coming weekend—without masks we're encouraging
super spreader events—which means within 30-days our hospital could be overflowing with cases
and friends and neighbors may be dead.
We've been lucky so far. Now is time to take action. What actions are we taking?
Sincerely,
Rod neyJ.Auth
Publisher
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 16 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Ian Williams
To: Bessie]o Wagner
Subject: On the record for today's meeting
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 2:49:47 PM
---This email is from an external sender.Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments if the sender is
unknown.---
Hi there,
Mike M.Requested that I email you to get on the record for today's meeting at 3pm.
I am deeply concerned about the safety and well-being of our community as I've had multiple business owners reach
out for advice regarding how they should proceed with closures and restrictions.
With the recent influx of positive and confirmed cases in McCall,I call for the immediate shutdown of all
businesses within City Limits,especially those businesses that are tourist based and have a much higher risk. If
anything,all restaurants,bars,retail stores,etc. We have already closed our building to the public to remove our
businesses from this dire situation.
On behalf of our companies and multiple other business owners,please shut down the city effective immediately.
We cannot afford to let this virus destroy our amazing community. We will return,stronger than ever.
Regards,
Ian Williams
President
The Idaho Shirt Company
Five meals to the Idaho Foodbank for every shirt sold.
IdahoShirts.com
208.634.5850
Now conveniently located at 200 Jacob St right on Highway 55 in McCall!
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 17 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Jim Zokan
To: BessieJo Wagner
Subject: City Council Emergency Meeting RE:Mandatory Masks in Public Buildings and Private Establishments
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 11:46:11 AM
---This email is from an external sender. Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments
if the sender is unknown. ---
I am in favor of the city council passing a rule to establish a Mandatory Masks in Public
Buildings and Private Establishments within the city limits of McCall , Idaho.
Thanks
James F. Zokan
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 18 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments
From: Krista Oberlindacher
To: Bessie]o Wagner
Subject: In favor of masks and social distancing
Date: Tuesday,June 30,2020 11:49:48 AM
---This email is from an external sender.Be cautious and DO NOT open links or attachments
if the sender is unknown. ---
Greetings,
I am writing regarding the emergency meeting at 3:00 today. I am in favor of the city council
mandating mask-wearing in the city of McCall.
Thank you for your consideration,
Krista Oberlindacher
McCall, ID
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 19 of 19
June 30, 2020 Special Meeting-Public Comments