HomeMy Public PortalAbout20061129 - Minutes - Board of Directors (BOD) Meeting 06-28
SPECIAL MEETING
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
November 29, 2006
MINUTES
I. ROLL CALL
President Jed Cyr called the Special Meeting Closed Session to order at 5:31 p.m.
Members Present: Jed Cyr, Mary Davey, K. Nitz, Pete Siemens, Curt Riffle, L.
Hassett, and N. Hanko
Members Absent: None
Staff Present: C. Britton, S. Rice, D. Simmons, M. Williams
6:00 p.m. Special Meeting - Study Session on Draft Sudden Oak Death Management Policy
SPECIAL MEETING
11. J. Cyr called the Special Meeting to order at 7:35p.m. He said there were no reportable
actions from the Closed Session.
Additional Staff Present: R. Jurgensen, J. Maciel, D. Simmons, M. Williams, K.
Lenington, M. Manning, C. Roessler, M. Freeman, S. Hooper, M. Jesperson, Matt
Baldzikowski
111. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS There were none.
IV. ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Motion: P. Siemens moved that the Board adopt the Agenda. L. Hassett seconded
the motion. The motion passed 7 to 0.
V. BOARD BUSINESS
A. Agenda Item No. I —Authorize the General Manager to Negotiate and Execute
an Agreement in an Amount Not To Exceed $60,000 to Fund Three Years of
Research with the USDA Forest Service on Tanoak Resistance to Sudden Oak
Meeting 06-28 Page 1
Death, for Conducting Research on the Sudden Oak Death Pathogen-, Determine
that the Recommended Actions are Categorically Exempt Under the California
Environmental Quality Act as Set Forth in This Report - (Report R-06-130)
C. Roessler reviewed the staff report. There was a ten-year work plan on Sudden
Oak Death and there were two major principles which are to map the oak trees on
District land that appear to be resistant to Sudden Oak Death (SOD) and establish
funding for research of SOD, specifically research that would help the District in
making management decisions.
She said that the proposal before the Board was slightly different than what was
originally thought was going to be proposed. Originally the District was going to:
1) hire a contractor to go into the field and find oak trees that appeared to be
resistant and surviving in areas that are heavily infected in the entire 50,000 acres
managed by the District, 2) map those trees and keep checking them over the
years 3) and if there was a research project going on, then offer those trees for
research purposes.
K. Nitz verified that the District had already had some students look for resistant
oaks. C. Roessler said that they had set up a small scale procedure for doing that,
but not all 50,000 acres were looked at. K. Nitz asked if that work would now be
set aside and not used and C. Roessler said that the proposal before the Board was
a better project, but that she had used the information gathered and had taken it to
workshops and conferences and that it was noticed by the US Forest Service.
At one of these workshops, C. Roessler was approached by the US Forest Service
and told that they were very interested in researching resistant oaks and would like
to do the study on the District's land. The proposal from the US Forest Service
advances the District's plan by five years.
C. Roessler then introduced Susan Frankel of the US Forest Service to describe
what the research proposal is and how the District would be partners with the US
Forest Service and National Park Service. S. Frankel is in charge of the SOD
research at the US Forest Service and she oversees over $1 million dollars in
research dollars.
S. Frankel thanked the Board and commended them on looking for ways to
research SOD. She presented PowerPoint slides with her discussion. She began
her talk stating that this year has been a particularly bad year for SOD and showed
slides of many Northern California counties heavily hit with SOD. C. Riffle
asked if the slides showed tanoak and S. Frankel replied that they were
predominantly tanoak. SOD is a very patchy disease, as not every tree dies.
S. Frankel said the biggest question is what can land managers do to manage SOD
on their lands. She brought up two thoughts, the first is what can be done by
Meeting 06-28 Page 2
genetics and the second is if nothing is done, will the local populations of tanoak
disappear. The study will help them find out if they can locate resistant oaks and
if they can use their genetic properties to save sick trees.
S. Frankel then reviewed the project design. The first part is to gather acorns,
then take the pathogen and inoculate the trees. K. Nitz asked how old the trees
would be and S. Frankel said they would be a year or two old. She continued that
they would plant acorns in the field to see if they respond the same way. There
would also be a common garden study where tests would occur to see if they had a
viable product to inoculate the trees. K. Nitz asked if they would know which
acorns are healthy and which were not. S. Frankel said they would know which is
which.
S. Frankel then reviewed the funding of the proposed project. She said that UC
Berkeley would contribute 25%, that the Point Reyes National Seashore and the
District would share an equal amount and that the balance of the funding would
come from the Forest Service Research Program.
She then reviewed their SOD research program. She said they were fortunate that
there is $2 million funds dedicated to research, but after it is divided up, about $1
million will come to the Forest Service. They have a competitive program, issue a
call for proposals and then have a team that evaluates the proposals and the work.
P. Siemens asked if this money comes from a national office or her office and S.
Frankel said it was national. P. Siemens then said he didn't think it was very
much money. S. Frankel said it wasn't, except for a forest disease, it actually was
a lot of money, but it's true that it does not go very far.
Every three years there is a SOD science symposium and the next one occurs in
March 2007. They have 105 papers submitted and she said there is more
information located at www.suddenoakdeath.orp,. This concluded S. Frankel's
presentation.
C. Riffle asked if this is just a national effort or if there was an international effort
as well. S. Frankel said that it is international and that the European Union has a
risk assessment project and had about $3 million to use in the past three years.
They are most interested in their nursery and agriculture.
P. Siemens asked if they know where SOD came from and if anyone was
researching that aspect. S. Frankel said that there were people researching this,
specifically Clyde Frasier from the United Kingdom. She said that he believes
SOC came from Asia.
L. Hassett asked why a large portion of the research is being done in the Big Sur
area. S. Frankel said the Big Sur area is heavily infested. There are research plots
throughout the state, but the areas in Big Sur have the highest mortality.
Meeting 06-28 Page 3
K. Nitz asked how they knew if the acorns collected were resistant or non-
resistant. S. Frankel replied that they do not, but they had not been infected yet
and the collection was done randomly. It is expected that I% of the population
will be resistant, adding that it is a numbers game. They collected about 12,000
acorns, and they expected a low number of resistant acorns. 3,000 of the acorns
were gathered on District land.
C. Riffle asked how long it would be before they will have information they can
do something with. S. Frankel said the first measurement will be the end of the
summer and that it will be a year before they will have anything to report. It will
be three to four years before there will be publishable material, but they can give
progress reports about every six months. C. Riffle asked if the information the
District gets back would help them in how they treat SOD. S. Frankel said it
would. She said that they would know how the District trees did in the lab tests.
They are trying to develop a whole ecology of the tanoak along with the disease
component.
J. Cyr stated that the previous studies were more hit and miss, but that the
proposed project seems much more focused and useful to more agencies than just
the District.
N. Hanko asked if the problem started in Asia and are there maps showing where
the problem areas are. S. Frankel said the complicating factor is that when the
organisms are in the natural environment they don't do much damage, but when
they are moved to foreign areas, that is when the problems occur. She added that
the origin question is the most important to answer but the hardest to solve.
Motion: L. Hasset moved that the Board authorize the General Manager to
negotiate and execute an agreement in an amount not to exceed
$60,000 to fund three years of research with the USDA Forest
Service on tanoak resistance to Sudden Oak Death, for conducting
research on the Sudden Oak Death pathogen; Determine that the
recommended actions are categorically exempt under the
California Environmental Quality Act as set rorth in this report. P.
Siemens seconded the motion.
Discussion: L. Hassett said he was glad that the District is stepping up to be a
full participant and he thanked C. Roessler and K. Lenington.
P. Siemens said he was excited about the partnership. He added
that it is important to find the origin of the pathogen.
C. Britton said it was their hope that other agencies will see what is
happening and will join in. He added that the SOD task force is
going in the right direction. K. Nitz asked why Marin was not
Meeting 06-28 Page 4
involved and C. Britton said it had to do with lack of funding;
Marin does not have much money to contribute and that Marin is
helping in other ways, including their activity with legislation,
M. Davey asked if the Bay Area Open Space Council was aware of
the project and C. Britton said they were and that a presentation
was made to this group.
Vote: The motion passed 7 to 0.
B. Agenda Item No. 2—Annual Update of Resource Management Program no
formal Board action is required)-(Report(Report R-06-107)
K. Lenington began the staff presentation saying this is the annual update on the
Resource Program for '05 through '06. The first program area he presented was
on the Resource Program Planning and Policy Management Development. He
said that he would be highlighting the main points of the program.
K. Lenington said that there was a Resource Program workshop in March 2006
that involved representatives from five agencies and that the workshop went over
two days. The District's consultant developed a report summarizing the results of
the workshop, District staff developed a table showing ideas generated at the
workshop for consideration in the District's Resource Management program,
which is included in the Board's FYI's this evening.
He said that staff had given several Resource Management Policy presentations to
the Board in the past year highlighting Water Resources and Grazing Policies.
Another emphasis area has been on permitting coordination. He added that
permitting is a complicated and long process requiring a lot of staff time
regardless of whether the project was large or just a basic maintenance project.
K. Lenington reviewed the Resource Inventory project saying that they had
developed a baseline inventory of the flora and fauna. He showed the Board a
vegetation map for the La Honda Creek Open Space Preserve. He said the
District-wide vegetation mapping project had begun in 2000 and that Preserves
and surrounding lands had been added each year, including the San Mateo coast.
The vegetation data is very useful with the current projects, such as Sierra Azul
Bear Creek Redwoods Open Space Preserve Master Planning project.
K. Lenington gave highlights of the water quality protection projects. He said that
the highest profile project was the El Corte de Madera Creek Watershed
Protection Program. To date, the District had expended $500,000 to upgrade the
roads and trails (totaling approximately 30 miles)to reduce sedment delivery from
the Preserve's road and trail system. This year work began on the San Fracisquito
Meeting 06-28 Page 5
Creek Watershed in an effort to protect water quality for steelhead trout. The
District has been awarded grants through their partnerships with other agencies.
Finally, K. Lenington said another large program area was environmental
remediation with the largest projects being resolving the oil leaking at the Pulgas
Ridge Open Space Preserve and characterizing the contamination at Driscoll
Ranch.
C. Roessler updated the threatened rare and endangered species program which
included surveys on red-legged frogs, western pond turtles and marbled murrelet.
There had been several trainings for staff from outside experts.
Under Vegetation Management, staff had used multiple methods to control
vegetation. Quite a bit of work had been done by the Operations staff. District
volunteers had been very helpful in the Spring season. Staff is working towards
getting the weed inventory management system completed. Staff will be able to
put together information sheets to help identify and look out for new invasive
species and use the information to share with other agencies. C. Roessler spoke
about the use of weevils as a bio-control insect and staff is measuring its
effectiveness. She said that slender false brome was found in new locations and
that where found on District land, it is being treated. She reminded the Board that
the slender false brome is a Category A noxious weed and that there is a ten-year
program to eradicate it. C. Roessler said that 3,000 acorns had been collected on
District land. About fifty volunteers had collected the acorns looking for good
oak trees. On ecological restoration, C. Roessler reviewed the Pulgas Ridge Open
Space Preserve planting restoration—planting 300 native shrubs. Staff had
restored four acres at the former Skyline Christmas Tree Farm, but they now need
a permit from San Mateo County to continue. The permit process may take a
year.
C. Roessler reviewed the wildlife management projects including the feral pig
trapping, noting that no pigs had been trapped since March 2006 and that there
were no signs of rooting. Staff rescued a bobcat found in a restroom. They
conducted a survey on mountain lions at Rancho San Antonio and found that
about 91% of those surveyed knew what to do when encountering a mountain
lion.
L. Hassett asked if there was a plan for controlling pampas grass. C. Roessler
replied that staff would be working to evaluate and identify the problem, adding
that pampas grass is not too hard to treat. L. Hassett asked if a plan was in place
for eradicating bullfrogs. C. Roessler said that there were no plans currently, but
did say that where there are red-legged frogs there are no bullfrogs.
L. Hassett asked if there is a report from the consultant on the District's grazing
study. K. Lenington said there was not a District-wide study; however, there was
Meeting 06-28 Page 6
a grazing assessment done about two years ago at Big Dipper Ranch. P. Siemens
asked if there is a plan to have a District-wide grazing study. K. Lenington said
there will be site-specific plans because conditions vary greatly by Preserve.
P. Siemens asked if the work had started on the watershed project that had
received a grant. K. Lenington said work had not started yet, they just received
the grant and they have until 2010 to complete the work.
K. Nitz asked if the Sudden Oak Death 10-year plan had changed. C. Roessler
said that it had not yet, but it will be changed to reflect the approved project (see
Agenda Item 1).
C. Riffle asked if the vegetation mapping of District lands was complete. M.
Freeman replied that most of the mapping of District land is completed. The only
areas left to map are the San Mateo County baylands.
C. Riffle asked if there are a watershed plans for District lands. K. Lenington said
that the District did not have watershed plans. He said that the Master Plan
process looks at watershed areas rather than specific parcels.
J. Cyr asked if staff shared the resource mapping with other agencies and if it was
reciprocal. M. Freeman said that all data sets are shared with other agencies, but
he said some data sets are purchased by the District with the understanding that
the information is not allowed to be shared.
The Board accepted the staff report. No formal Board action was required.
C. Agenda Item No. 3—Implement a Retiree Health Savings Plan, Adopt the
Resolution Implementing a Retiree Health Savings Plan•, Adopt the Resolution
Amending the District's 40 1(a) Plan to Allow Accrued Leave Pre-Tax
Contributions• Adopt the Resolution Amending the District's Personnel Policies
andProcedures Manual to Reflect the Proposed Changes to the Sick Leave
Conversion Language - (Report R-06-145)
S. Rice said that the Resolutions are the last phase to implement this project and
she reviewed the highlights noted in the staff report.
J. Cyr complimented staff on this complicated process.
Motion: M. Davey moved that the Board implement a Retiree Health
Savings Plan; Adopt Resolution No. 06-52 approving the
Vantagecare Retirement Health Savings (RHS) Program; Adopt
Resolution No. 06-5 3 amending the District's 40 1(a) Plan to allow
accrued leave pre-tax contributions; Adopt Resolution No. 06-54
amending the District's Personnel Policies and Procedures Manual
Meeting 06-28 Page 7
to reflect the proposed changes to the sick leave conversion
language. L. Hassett seconded the motion. The motion passed 7 to
0.
VI. INFORMATIONAL/COMPENSABLE MEETING REPORTS
P. Siemens said his compensable meetings included the November 29th Board meeting,
the November 20th Sierra Azul Master Plan meeting, and the November 28th
Administration and Budget Committee meeting.
L. Hassett said his only compensable meeting was this evening's meeting.
C. Riffle included his compensable meetings of this evening's meeting and the November
16th La Honda Master Plan meeting. He said he visited Pulgas Ridge on Thanksgiving
and said it was a great place with a very nice parking lot.
M. Davey said her compensable meetings included tonight's meeting, the November 15th
La Honda Master Plan meeting, and the November 28th Administration and Budget
Committee meeting. She added that the La Honda meeting was marvelous and had good
participation by both the public and District staff.
K. Nitz's compensable meeting included tonight's meeting, the November 8th Good
Neighbor Committee meeting, the November 15th La Honda Master Plan meeting, the
November 20th Sierra Azul Master Plan meeting, and the November 28th Administration
and Budget Committee meeting.
N. Hanko said her only compensable meeting was tonight's meeting.
J. Cyr said his compensable meetings included the November 15th La Honda Master Plan
meeting, the November 20th Sierra Azul Ad Hoc Committee meeting and tonight's
meeting. He said the La Honda meeting was well prepared by staff and noted that the
maps were well received. He said that Google-Earth has tremendous potential to help
with District presentations.
S. Rice handed out a Bay Area Open Space Council booklet and cards from the Land
Trust Alliance to the Board. She pointed out the Resource Management memo in the
FYI's. She announced that the staff holiday party would take place on December 20,
2006.
D. Simmons showed his framed "Indenture"to the Board as a follow up to their exercise
of Financing Authority at the prior meeting.
M. Freeman said that the next day he would be attending a meeting with San Mateo
County to discuss the permitting process between the two agencies and possible ways to
streamline the process.
Meeting 06-28 Page 8
J. Maciel said that on Friday the bum would be completed and he handed out an
information sheet to the Board.
R. Jurgensen remarked on the media file on slender false brome. He said their press
released on the grazing program had been picked up by the Associated Press so that a
newspaper in England had picked up the story.
VII. ADJOURNMENT
The Special meeting of the Board of Directors of the Midpeninsula Regional Open Space
District adjourned at 9:45 p.m.
Lisa Zadek
Recording Secretary
Meeting 06-28 Page 9