HomeMy Public PortalAboutGreen Infrastructure for a Healthier Charles River Presentation - June 21, 2016 (PDF)Green,,.,I.t,
JU
wn Hall,
i
41 4n -lilt
ti lr r
r
a
r�,,
w
ti
A
Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
Rich Claytor, P.E.
Janet Bernardo, P.E.
horsleywitten.com
857-263-8193
Agenda
Introduction & Grant Goals
Stormwater & GI Overview
Grant Work Completed to Date
Discuss Candidate Sites
Select 2 Pilot GI Projects for
Further Consideration
�Of
M'&- all abowt ...this town."
Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
Introduction rant Goals
THE COMMONWEALTH OF MAS&ACHUSF rrs Grant Project Funded through
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF ENERGY &
ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS the 604(b) Program for Water
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION
ONE WINTER STREET, BOSTON. MA
tw
Afl- --
i
Weia all abort ...this tpwn."
Quality Assessment and
Planning
Increase Awareness Stormwater Issues
Educate Stakeholders
Identify Opportunities for Green
Infrastructure
Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
Project Partners
MassDEP
Watertown Department of Public Works
Watertown Department of Community
Development and Planning
Watertown Stormwater Advisory
Committee
Horsley Witten Group, Inc.
�Of
Weia all abw�t ...this tawn."
Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
Stormwater & Green
Infrastructure Overview
ft�
A .-F
Weia all ab- this tawn."
Stormwater Basics
GI Practices
Benefits
Limitations
Costs
Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
Stormwater Basics
precipitation evapotranspiralidn
(10 )
r
.}fir f�
BEFORE
Urbanization results in
increased surface runoff
prec-itatiorr
evap-olransp rafion
(5 ) VIL,
AFTER
Stormwater Basics
At -10% impervious we
begin to see:
Water quality issues
Impacts to biological
communities
Increased flooding
Stream erosion
Loss of recreational uses
Shellfish bed closures
Reduced baseflow and
recharge
Watertown is 49% impervious
Watertown — Street Views
T -7
■.! i � � Tii �
Wat�rr[�vn ceio�r,►,x,rot -
.f�-�"- Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
Weia all abw�t ...this tawn."
Watertown — Stormwater
r1
WWI!,Ffflir-Jk
�rr,►,xlroAF
--
Weis all abmt ... rhls town"
Improvements
0
TOWN OF WATERTOWN
Storm pram Outfafl
ONy storm wader should
flow from this pipe oto the river
If ynu sea
• cloudy or descalorep water.
• ad orl the wader hawing from
the pipe. or
+ water fiowng from the pipe
dwirq dry v031her
Wft
V&CrE3"D"% DEW7t14E.W N'tB IC: M;P= m
617.972,6420
[l} 11 QYI
1A4.
Horsley Witten Group
Sustainable Environmental Solutions
ow4L
1 _
r r - ■i
r
IJ
t
r�
_ 1r
ft
I
a
..
-
� i '
- a.. `• � - �
I
_
If y/ 1�
PIF
Amu .9
lu Al
71
i0v
5eo.
dr
Green Infrastructure Practices
Non -Structural Practices
Bioretention and Green Street
Practices
Permeable/Porous/Pervious
Pavements
Infiltration Practices
Wetland Practices
Water Quality Swales
Rainwater Harvesting
Green and Blue Roofs
Non -Structural Practices
Stormwater "passive"
controls and/or programs
designed to reduce runoff
volume, reduce pollutants,
and/or enhance infiltration.
Practices:
Impervious cover
removal
Open space
preservation
Natural landscaping
Street sweeping
Bioretention and Green Streets
Shallow landscaped
depression designed to
capture stormwater runoff
for treatment and/or
infiltration through natural
processes.
Practice Variants:
Bioretention
Tree Filters
Stormwater Planters
Rain Gardens
A&VAM
AMWAM
1
r yrt.�
r l.:
3. •.s Ati !
r
r�- �l+S } 'r �•Ty'
i
Tree Trenches
LEGEN
1. Sidew
2. Tree p
3. Catch
4. Roadv
5. Pland
6. Inflow
7. Stone
S. Overfl
9. Existir
��MI����
Bioretention and Green Streets
Benefits & Limitations
Benefits
Good runoff reduction & pollutant removal
Good aesthetics — fits in with site landscaping
Natural approach, affecting air quality, temperature, & habitat
Moderate cost
Limitations
Not good on steep slopes — needs flat bottom
Some clogging potential
Limit drainage area to <10 acres
Some maintenance required
Permeable/Porous/Pervious
Pavements
Permeable surface material
that allows rainfall to
percolate through the media
into underlying soils or
drainage collection system.
Practice Variants:
Permeable pavers
Porous asphalt
Pervious concrete
Proprietary materials (pre-
cast pervious slabs,
recycled tires/glass)
Permeable Paver Options
rU?�47�,
y� yr
l ♦ % �:j
��41;
'•i � �_ - �� �'t' ��i?'µv �F_��}:: �::`_ � _" �': +:� �� �wl '. ice?'" :'s��1'CiF.y..` .. �F r � < ti�'i+.'_.
y T y
' ..�'" -' r"� •�` 1. #�r '' Y{' +S4 i ,� -�W .� f 4 -
Jr
Yam._ 'A_
1 �. � r t
4 3 - .A } �r�'' wF � y � .as` y ty F� X
r { 4F f ,r
*4 ;. �`
Permeable/Porous/Pervious
Pavements
Benefits:
Good runoff reduction,
promotes recharge,
excellent pollutant
removal
No additional space
consumption
Reduces need for
sand/salt in winter
Limitations:
Not good on steep slopes
High maintenance (e.g.
vacuuming) to prevent
clogging
Require deeper
groundwater and
permeable soils
Needs careful
construction sequencing
High cost
Cost Considerations
Capital cost ranges - Implementation is site specific and
economy dependent. As designers and contractors become
more familiar with controls, costs decrease.
Design and testing - Green infrastructure typically requires
an engineered design. Design costs may be more costly
than conventional, but implementation costs can be less
expensive.
Land consumption - Most practices can be integrated into
site design.
Maintenance costs - Requires a change in mind -set and
training, some specialized equipment.
M ai'-ntenane,.,',. -.6Ts.nninsiderati
Routine general maintenance and frequency -Practices
� require initial inspection and early maintenance.
Non -routine maintenance - infrequence t may require _
system overhaul. alk %W
Specialized equipment and training -Mostly landscaping
related for such activities as tree pruning, re -mulching, minor
erosion gullying, etc.)
�y Inspections and enforcement -Critical to overall long-term
success.
- Performance impacts -Many practices will still
� may suffer aesthetically; clogging a real threat.
nf-�-
Grant Work Completed to Date
HW met with DPW and CDPD Staff
Utilized MassGIS & Town Mapping
Evaluated Total Phosphorous by Land Use
Reviewed Historical Bacteria Data at Outfalls
Analyzed Soils, Outfalls, Catchment areas
Attended SAC Meeting
Identified 21 Potential Locations, Site Visits
- Focused on Town -owned Property and ROWs
W�t�fflirJiW
A
Weia all ab-4VW7al town.
Horsley Witten Group LIA
Sustainable Environmental Solutions LTY
21 Potential Locations to Install
Green Infrastructure
;�xt
ar
11
6 •I A ,��
Jq - .yam _ , f - x .t # • +- x. _ �� +
16
ram.'-" — _- -_--_ - -... •1 r:- �.1' -;;± - -.�. - _ I �'si
Cr
1 • I I � • I �
71
'L' 1 Wr
4.1 +V = i .•i `��~' wn`i. .r rr+•C� 4�«,. _,
' n i., _ � •far , �_'' I - - - - .
74
tj
_y �'�..r S fi' « .J�;!��7' �`�:, r.•f. '�•?•r f Yf "". �y r,] • rr. `
Ff. • -- ' �, 16'.f "Wf, .• � _ __�- r.�4' 27 ti„h, .'� t _iJ } ' ' 4 - - - - .
• �ti� • fR ''+Y� � ` !. ~�'r � 1 . 1 .lam J � - '.4 .
73
�u - � _ 'y4*` w �..� y, �r ,DTP.. �r'�{, k'•' '- _,�i'r •r- ` �{ r ._r • __ - r"
f-T5 :'. gi J_59.... •fF'slr k�'" 1
qp
162
Iti Y
Soil Types of Catchment Areas
fy�ar�
97
19 z
1�
527C
f 13
11
665
526B
$56
415C
C54
s�64
Am
326 0
� �SSEi
�= s 24d
21
s
,d 712 • - 20b
2� y�
13
3rqcteria Leve
y. �~•. �� - ��,� a �� * ,.
� ■1�'�1Y; ter. . ys M
Ou¢Fa1i i
Tye
Outlafl8 Outf2119
iF Uu9afl36
per Outtro_m,.
4N yy x
fi
�m Ilk
a
a
2ugailf2
1wpt: OutlarU 33 IF. Ui 92HS J4 & 35
OF
y
l {.1.
F * Outfa � r .■ ' fir' "' '1` +T �r ,� r - .1�� d
s .:r r� • y"r*+� v[ moo• �4
■ 'i w ■ ? 74 .. ly'
Ir
o' OUtfaR 39 I At
• Aso is CY ;r
'::F �^:s. -- �: • n3_ . ,�: � i�=■�.rfot sret�? , rl�':Y � ' f, eF,��•.� � `
, Outfaii 14 :. r
it I
l ' r ` ' , 1�s .r 1y '� Outfall 15
iv
i S r� •d ■1 ■ [ lox
12 Candidate Sites
Visibility, Cost, Maintenance
Priority Catchment Areas
Public Improvement Projects
I 2ft. Contours 1 " = 50 Feet I
May i
AdminisL
Buildil
410
1f
f
4(`
i
Watertown `
Library e
V '
Town I
Parking
Town Library Parking Lot
GROUNDCOVERI
GRASSES
ZONE
0'-b" HIGH
CURB
GRADE
Location
Library Parking Lot
Id. No.
'IA
Impervious Area
0.34 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
lies
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Potential
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
CANOPY TREE
N PLANTING BED
25'-0" O.0 MN.
REQUIRED
3'-0' HIGH
SHRUBS
STORMWATER INLETS
SPACED AS APPROPRIATE
38'-0"
TYPICAL INTERIOR LANDSCAPING PLANTING BED
2ft. Contours 1 " = 50 Feet I /
41
Administration
Building
!
-.. t
Wa
Y L
r
PF�
Town Hall — Roof Runoff
r�A
Location
Town Hall
Id. No.
1 B
Impervious Area
0.01 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Low
Priority Watershed
No
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Potential
Potential BMP
Rain Garden
RAIN GARDEN DETNL
CilAl,740�G
IN
11
Main Street Corridor
Location
Main St. betty Waverly
Ave. & Town Hall
Id. No.
2
Impervious Area
0.85 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
No
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Yes
Potential BMP
Tree Trenches and
Bioswales
rvrnre► cdac
�- .
�� "�li�llllllll� Illilll
Porter St. @ Boylston St.
Location
Porter St. at
Boylston St.
Id. No.
6
Impervious Area
0.55 acres
Public Visibility
Low
Cast
High
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Law
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
2ft. Contours 1 50 Feet
Jt
0
100,
''��_
71
A6.
I
Worcester @ Springfield
Location
Worcester St. at
Springfield St.
Id. No.
7
Impervious Area
0.09 acres
Public Visibility
Low
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Fain Garden
t
axw wW mwrw wa - R N GARDEN DETAIL
CiW.TiMG
2ft. Contours 1 " = 50 Feet L
i
i
' Ll
low mom A
0
0
Grove St. @ Kondazian
Location
Grove St. at
Kondazian St.
Id. No.
8
Impervious Area
0.84 aces
Public Visibility
Low
Cast
High
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
VIA
C
I�
r
.: x:'
_fir a .7
!
70,VlftIroexoTa"Op4ove
•ys Si ..i ,f �• ,t. •S,
2ft. Contours 1" = 50 Feet
~` d I
AL
_4
Lowell School
Location
Lowell School
Id. No.
9B
Impervious Area
0.04 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Low
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Rain Barrels
`� r
Beacon Park @ Arsenal St.
Location
Beacon Park at
Arsenal 5t.
Id. No.
10
Impervious Area
0.4 acres
Public Visibility
Medium
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
No
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Yes
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
CANOPYTREE
-IN PLANTING 9E0
Ox mim.
REQUIRED
GROUNDCOVERI 5'-0° HIGH
GRASSES 70"
SHRUBS
ZONE f
r _
t
0'-6" HIGH I
CORE _ '%i.- .F1" ...
GRADE VI
STORMWATER INLETS
SPACED AS APPROPRIATE
38'-0"
TYPICAL INTERIOR LANDSCAPING PLANTING BED
2ft. Contours 1 - 75 Feet,
�.
Common St. @ Spring St.
Location
Common St. at
Spring St.
Id. No.
1 2A
Impervious Area
0.48 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cast
Medium
Priority Watershed
No
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Yes
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
ioom
32 `
N�
IN _ •A
Jl 1
�1 • ■ 17 • \
• 38
t v �` 34 i
Common St. Corridor
Location
Common St. Corridor
Id. No.
12B
Impervious Area
0.45 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
No
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Yes
Potential BMP
Tree Trenches and
Bioswales
irs 1" = 50 Feet _
- 7P
y
p - f . t
r
OR Ask
Common St. @ Orchard St.
Location
Common St. at
Orchard St.
Id. No.
1 2C
Impervious Area
0.07 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
No
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
Yes
Potential Bh�tP
Tree Trenches and
Bioswales
2ft. Contours 1" = 50 Feet
--t
ANINNW,`
,
16 _.
CONCORD ROAD
Hosmer School Entrance
Location
Hosmer School
Entrance
Id. No.
1 5A
Impervious Area
0.14 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
CANOPY TREE
N PLANTING BED
Z5,-0" O.0 MN.
REQUIRED
GROUNDCOVERI 3'-0' HIGH
GRASSES SHRUBS
ZONE
0'-b" HIGH
CURB
GRADE
STORMWATER INLETS
SPACED AS APPROPRIATE
38'-01,
TYPICAL INTERIOR LANDSCAPING PLANTING BED
I 2ft. Contours 1 " = 50 Feet I
mom
o
'�IsomI
Hosmer
Elementary
yOVA
f"
b—qqpAp-�l
r&l
tar
,_, Soft
- A -
-:®
Hosmer School
Location
Hosmer School
Id. No.
15B
Impervious Area
0.23 acres
Public Visibility
Medium
Cost
Medium
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Bioswale
I 2ft. Contours 1 " = 50 Feet I
VON
nj
Middle School Rear Lot
Location
Middle School Fear Lot
Id. No.
17
Impervious Area
0.19 acres
Public Visibility
Medium
Cost
Low
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Bioswale
CANOPY TREE
�IN PLANTING BED
ZS'-0" Ox mim.
REQVIRE❑
GROUNDCOVERI 5�-O° HIGH
GRASSES SHRUBS
ZONE
r _
t
0'-6° HIGH I
CURB
GRADE
STORMWATER INLETS
SPACED AS APPROPRIATE
38'-0"
TYPICAL INTERIOR LANDSCAPING PLANTING BED
I 2ft. Contours 1 " = 50 Feet I
LAW
68
O'Connell Park Lot
Location
O'Connell Park
Parking Lot
Id. No.
20
Impervious Area
0.12 acres
Public Visibility
Medium
Cast
High
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Medium
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Permeable Pavement
2ft. Contours 1" = 50 Feet
Department
of Public
Works
4
L
DPW — Parking Lot
Location
Department of
Public Works
Id. No.
21
Impervious Area
0.46 acres
Public Visibility
High
Cost
Low
Priority Watershed
Yes
Maintenance
Low
PI Design in Process
No
Potential BMP
Bioretention Area
REGUHT"
CANOPY THE
GRWACOYERIGRA$$ES
'
CAR OVERHANG ZONE
GRpuNpCtivFRIGRaSSES
CAR OVERHAK ZONE
'SHRLBS
zae+E -o•r
TCX
RFpuiRED
:,.ONE
S6WIG
GEMX
- A
S' HIGH CURR WI
BE LOw
STGRMWaTER IHLE iS
a
PLANTING
PARKING
SOIL
GRACE
'�—HAAIMUi PONDING LIRE
a-----------------------.
GRAvZL
FABRIC
BASE
PIPE CCNNECTEC TO
6' TO 6' PERFORATED PIPE
ON -BITE STORT"ATER
MmECTED TO GM -SITE
SYSTEM
B'-0' MINIM Iri
STORMWATER SYSTEM
12 Candidate Sites
of ry T f 5 41 17G 6enron Hd r£ o..�M4.�r.,�,� nqr F
Y �
Paris
b i $ In C Lrh 0 w 0.9h 't r
ip� L• F1 p rr 11yrtWJ 7 I.lwrtsLA.
X 4
u.
'ILI
rb i 6 rh Im Uwal I kwa i� 3
b
k
J 4 yQ 11W ; n; 1 PAtAvburn
R?R.
r„¢ D
_
Aiani,yru0d .a� 4 i i 4
P 4 * #i fi�ltl a Fj1QrRa 3 a� Sf ury a s
o' a A.
I i�i N��� 4► trx rro�
,y J 'ice s r3 * am W 91 p,i f S e T : a rrE per+
a +a a
1 gee s� {� O _
e~ q G1h�r��r� a qu
Jr���n RI-.�4' i Armta n 'f a �Ae ira [jcW ,?Y
fp
3.
.51
In
4f lued
�C fi � o �V
4U
(�6L*
Si,$p*#� +# �r�7 h #y} ti p r•cdi4Y/L` 9L4r
� ikrmnlr Fh�raiF, � '�{
'rafiSi` Lfurd El
r.alria`rrn`r# SLS Y I rirl rn Oyu
_ urQrrrh Rd +f r�°�oY +ire x
ti gg }
at St �z °'uryAwn ,..
-� rar 91 3 r r�¢ a in R
uh[SI � r� Falk n,:i�i : i r•
4
'r �
I .k
2 Pilot Projects
Rank Sites Based on:
Project Complexity —Cost
Effectiveness — Impervious Area
Public Education
Constructability — Soils, Slopes
Maintenance
Next Steps
Select 2 Pilot Sites
Develop 30% Design Plans
Develop Green Infrastructure
Tracking System for Watertown
1p
]E�:_a��1Coocrii o00
Watertown Department of Public Works
www.watertownd pw.orq
617-972-6420
Stormwater Advisory Committee
www.watertownstormwater. orq
IFM�
�PI1�11�
IM1�7e ai4� about ...this tower"'
Horsley Witten Group, Inc.
www. horsleywitten.com
Rich Claytor, P.E.
Janet Carter Bernardo, P.E.
857-263-8193
Horsley Witten Group +�
Sustainable Environmental Solutions �N
{� r�r• k. r'.k.
- •'F'•'' r - � -fin of �{r r
' r r t r�� '.�r� �t � • •r_
1�'• � ; _a err:: � - ,''fir• •`
19
S •.•��• v.:� .. _ r _ .1 � �+r 'r a ~, r '',.r�ii ti`• .ti�.
F �.,. �'.f�'. kx� ti - ', ''fir! •• � �F:' i. ', �, ,�'ti •x•
.
;•.�-.. .� .- �,1,... : �•� •rr • •� _ r rftiA • , F �rf • - = �., � i }' +h- ti; '•% -
K'-'Y' _ ti 'fle
' f rJ1� - .'.� }Fr'fr'i'�a•kl-I`{+ _
'm, yam* -:� -•. ,ti y -,r ,, { r � L' a i r' i r} f '�I {
% 1j` ti s' rk F T .� '',r,yy • r � J v• _' •+
'k_� -.•.ems{--}��' r -�i k'� :r '� �...
�~
- . _ �. � ti• rr�
Or
9— W-—.-:�
1jl .ram
- '�' . �' � � L ���-r • r ti
AA