HomeMy Public PortalAbout2020.12.11 Special Council Minutes MINUTES
McCall City Council
Special Meeting
McCall City Hall-- Legion Hall
AND MS TEAMS Virtual
December 11,2020
Call to Order and Roll Call
Work Session
Adjournment
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Mayor Giles called the Special meeting of the McCall City Council to order at 1:07 p.m.
Mayor Giles, Council Member Callan, and Council Member Maciaszek all answered roll
call. Council Member Holmes and Council Member Nielsen were absent.
City staff members present were Anette Spickard, City Manager; BessieJo Wagner, City Clerk;
Shay Tyler,Deputy Clerk;Erin Greaves,Communications Manager;Linda Stokes,City Treasurer;
Rick Stein, Airport Manager; Meg Lojek, Library Director; Chris Curtin, Information Systems
Manager; Traci Malvich, Human Resources Manager; Nathan Stewart, Public Works Director;
Jodi Weaver,Public Works Admin;Amanda Payne, Local Option Tax Admin; Sarah Edson,Front
Desk Receptionist;
Library Board of Trustees members present were Jacki Rubin, Chair; David Gallipoli,Vice Chair;
Dawn Matus, Secretary
Also, in attendance were; Jim McNall, ICRMP Risk Management Specialist; Kelley Packer,
Association of Idaho Cities (AIC) Executive Director; Rob McQuade, AIC General Counsel;
WORK SESSION
Training on Idaho Library Law and Idaho Ethics Law
Jim McNall,Risk Management Specialist at Idaho Counties Risk Management Program(ICRMP),
the City's Liability Insurance Provider, presented the training to the McCall City Council and
McCall Public Library Board of Trustees on the topics of Idaho Library Law and Idaho Ethics
Law.
He went through personal liability of a public officials and the ICRMP policy, and discussed
library claims. He described the roles and responsibilities of the board, the chair, mayor and
council, and the library director. The Library is the only committee called out by Idaho statute that
requires a council member liaison.
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 1 of 3
December 11, 2020 Special Meeting
He explained that for Public Libraries the budget and spending are under the control of the Board,
but the city treasurer is the responsible custodian. The board cannot spend in excess of the monies
appropriated for the library or for anything not for the library. Library staff are employees of the
city but managed by the Board and Library Director. Mr.McNall stated that it is wise to have some
expenditures set up to be paid before Board approval so those do not get waylaid by lack of quorum
or canceled meetings.
In the Board meetings, the chairman is the person who will conduct the meeting; however, the
chairman retains the rights to discuss and vote, controls public input when allowed, keeps the
discussion to the agenda items, and prohibits personal attacks and discussion of items not on the
agenda.Valid decisions are made when the meeting is properly posted with a quorum present,item
is on the agenda,a motion made and affirmed,and recorded in the minutes. Inappropriate decisions
include polling the board outside the meeting, gathering signatures, decisions made on an item
without an agenda topic, and emailing or texting votes.
Personnel policy is the responsibility of the city. It is important to follow a familiar policy as claims
often come from not following those policies. When issues arise, go to the policy manual, contact
the human resource director, and consult the city attorney. Before taking any serious action,know
that it is now required to call ICRMP. With the pandemic, keep abreast of Covid related changes
to personnel. There is still two weeks paid leave even though it will be coming to an end soon,ten
weeks of FMLA partial paid childcare,and flexibility for short notice with school changes.Consult
your attorney for special requests. Mr. McNall quickly went over how supervisors are to properly
oversee employee issues cautioning to be diligent in documentation and avoid problem words that
label the employee. He felt supervisors need extra training on harassment issues and quickly
touched on termination procedures.
The establishment of meeting rules was covered and staff roles. Common open meeting law
violations are late notice postings, discussing topics not on the agenda, improperly adding topics
to agenda, communication between board members outside the meetings, and discussing topics in
executive sessions that must be addressed in a public meeting.
Public records include but is not limited to, any writing containing information relating to the
conduct or administration of the public's business. "Writing" includes every means of recording,
including letters, words, pictures, sounds or symbols. It is advised to keep private and public
records separate. This is done by not using a personal phone, device, or email. Mr. McNall shared
some examples of which records are a public record and available to the public. For example,
employee personnel records can be available to the public with the written authorization from the
employee and texts and emails on personal phones are a public record.
Mr. McNall went through ethics and conflicts of interest. He has a list of ethical breaches covering
harassment, release of public records without authorization; open meeting violations, failure to
follow bid/ public works statutes, inappropriate relationships with employees, inmates, and co-
workers. He gave more details regarding who has authority to release public records and bid/public
works processes. He clarified that in the City of McCall, the city clerk is the designated custodian
and any purchase over$50K is required to go through a bidding process and any building projects
over $50K requires a licensed public works contract. City Manager Anette Spickard shared the
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 2 of 3
December 11, 2020 Special Meeting
procurement policy has been rewritten and is going before Council for approval to be effective
January 2021.This will affect the Library building project. Mr. McNall clarified for Library Board
Member David Gallipoli that gifts and donations for the library are acceptable but stated working
with a contractor prior to going to bid is only acceptable if the contractor will not be bidding on
the project. It would be a conflict of interest otherwise. Some types of projects are complicated
and require the involvement of the city attorney. Additional ethical breaches are failure to disclose
in conflict situations, misuse of public funds such as gas and credit cards, overstatement of
expenses or hours worked, and presenteeism (at work but spend all day doing personal things).
A conflict of interest is any official action, decision or recommendation by a public official
(elected, appointed or staff), which would be to the private financial benefit of the individual or a
member of their household, or a business with which the person or a member of their household
is associated. It is always prudent to ask the city attorney if uncertain. Prohibition of contracts with
appointed officers is any contract made by them in their official capacity, or by anybody or board
of which they are members. This means a city cannot purchase or enter into a contract with a
member of council or staff.
Under the new chapter 6, ballot initiatives or elections cannot use public funds for a candidate or
ballot issue. Any information presented must be unbiased, cannot use city staff or equipment to
make promotional items or video, and employees on duty must avoid discussing ballot/candidate
issues and opinions with patrons. Not listed in the statute but recommended by ICRMP is ballot
initiatives need to have a support group which can have library board members, council members,
and staff so long their activity is outside of the public meetings and off duty. Mr.McNall answered
questions regarding what kind of information can be provided to the public. He expressed caution
on using city funds for promotion.
Last,he discussed bribery and corrupt influence which covers threats and bribes, compensation or
retaliation for past actions, compensation of public servants,buying/selling political endorsement
or influence,using city funds or property for economic benefit without specific authorization from
the city, using or disclosing confidential information for economic benefit, hiring of relatives of
council members within the second degree,and staff accepting gifts over$50 is a crime. However,
large gifts to the library is acceptable so long as it is not personal. Penalties could be a year in jail
and/or a$1000 fine. Neither the Council, Library Board, nor staff had any further questions.
ADJOURNMENT
Without further business, Mayor Giles adjourned the meeting at 2:25 p.m.
%%J1ltttNq,,,I,
��•`�GG Z,tcCA.1.
ATTEST: ? SEA L O Robert S. Gi es, Mayor
BessieJo Wa er, City ,,,,fill 110
MCCALL CITY COUNCIL Page 3 of 3
December 11, 2020 Special Meeting