HomeMy Public PortalAbout100_022_Backhoe & Grader BID COMPARISON - RFP #2014-648 RFP #2014-648 BID COMPARISON
1
JCB John Deere 1 Volvo Case
Backhoe: Meets Spec Yes Yes Yes Yes
Grader: Meets Spec No* Yes Yes No
Cost JCB John Deere Volvo Case
Backhoe $66,500 $74,000 $72,117 $75,955
Less Trade In -$25,000 -$18,400 -$17,500 -$20,000
Grader * $128,148 $140,000 $139,280 $181,844
Demo Grader ** $69,970 $112,000 N/A N/A
Total * $169,648 $195,600 $193,897 $237,799
Total W/Demo Grader ** $111,470 $167,600 N/A N/A
*Add $6,205 for Rear Ripper; Bringing Total to $175,853
**No rear Ripper (which was in the specs) or cab, Cab with A/C will improve productivity and
decrease wear on controls from weather
John Deere has proven in the past to have good customer service and quick response time. John Deere
has recessed grease fittings and other features that make maintenance and repairs easier.
JCB has taken over two weeks for many parts other than filters.