Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 19-2718 Renee Basel From:Diane.Nixon@hklaw.com Sent:Thursday, May 9, 2019 2:53 PM To:Rita Taylor Cc:john.chapman@hklaw.com; Diane.Nixon@hklaw.com; michelle.arias@hklaw.com Subject:Public Records Request to City of Gulfstream Attachments:2019-05-09 John Chapman letter to City of Gulfstream re Public Records Request_ 67637259_1.PDF Dear Ms. Taylor, Please see attached a Public Records Request to the City of Gulfstream. Please feel free to contact me if you need any additional information or have any questions. Thank you, Diane | Diane Nixon Holland & Knight Paralegal Holland & Knight LLP 222 Lakeview Avenue, Suite 1000 | West Palm Beach, FL 33401 Phone 561.650.8348 | Fax 561.650.8399 Diane.Nixon@hklaw.com | www.hklaw.com NOTE: This e-mail is from a law firm, Holland & Knight LLP (“H&K”), and is intended solely for the use of the individual(s) to whom it is addressed. If you believe you received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender immediately, delete the e-mail from your computer and do not copy or disclose it to anyone else. If you are not an existing client of H&K, do not construe anything in this e-mail to make you a client unless it contains a specific statement to that effect and do not disclose anything to H&K in reply that you expect it to hold in confidence. If you properly received this e-mail as a client, co-counsel or retained expert of H&K, you should maintain its contents in confidence in order to preserve the attorney-client or work product privilege that may be available to protect confidentiality. 1 Rolland & Knight 515 E. Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1200 1 Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301 1 T 954.525.1000 1 F 954.463.2030 Holland & Knight LLP I www.hkiaw.com John R. Chapman III +1954-468-7977 john.chapman@hklaw.com May 9, 2019 Via Email to rtaylora(Uulf-stream,org Rita Taylor Town Clerk 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 (561) 276-5116 Re: FD Destiny, LLC, et al., v. AVP Destiny, LLC., et al, Case No.: 502009 CA 029903XXXXMG AG Consolidated with Case No.: 502009 CA040295XXXXMB AG Public Records Request Dear Ms. Taylor: This is a formal request for records pursuant to the Public Records Act, Florida Statutes, Chapter 119.01, et seq. This firm represents FD Destiny, LLC in the above -captioned matter. Pursuant to the Public Records Act, we request that your office provide us with a copies of the following documents: 1. All documents relating to the fire that occurred at 3145 N. Ocean Boulevard, Gulfstream, FL 33483-7369 on or about October 29, 2018 including police reports, inspection reports, fire marshal' report, insurance reports, dispatch log, dispatch notes, notes, witness statements, transcripts, videos, photographs, etc. 2. All documents relating to any correspondence (including text messages and emails) with City Departments, Insurance Companies, Fire Department, EMTs, Emergency Services, etc. regarding the fire that occurred at 3145 N. Ocean Boulevard, Gulfstream, FL 33483-7369 on or about October 29, 2018. 3. All documents relating to any correspondence (including text messages and emails) with the owners of the property, Anthony V. Pugliese, III and/or Laura K. Pugliese regarding the fire that occurred at 3145 N. Ocean Boulevard, Gulfstream, FL 33483-7369 on or about October 29, 2018. Anchorage I Atlanta I Austin I Boston I Charlotte I Chicago I Dallas I Denver I Fort Lauderdale I Houston I Jacksonville I Lakeland Los Angeles I Miami I New York I Orlando I Portland I San Francisco I Stamford I Tallahassee I Tampa I Tysons Washington, D.C. I West Palm Beach #67590593_vl Town Clerk May 9, 2019 Page 2 If this request for records is denied either in part or in whole, please advise us in writing, as required by section 119.07(2)(a) of the basis for your contention that the record or part of it is exempt from public inspection. In addition, we request that your written statement explain with particularity the reasons for your conclusion that the record is exempt. If the exemption you assert applies to only a portion of the records, we request that you delete the portion you claim is exempt and provide us with photocopies or electronic documents of the remainder as required by section 119.07(2)(a). We will be happy to reimburse your office any fees for duplication and/or certification of the copies that you are authorized by section 119.07(1)(a) to charge. Please advise if there is a charge for searching and copying these records and if the total cost, including copying, will exceed $100.00 prior to providing us with the copies. If possible, we request electronic copies of the documents. Unfortunately, we are under a deadline and would greatly appreciate it if this request could be expedited as soon as possible. Please contact my paralegal, Diane Nixon at 561-650-8348 regarding costs and if you need any additional information. We will be happy to assist you in any way that we can in order to expedite this request. Thank you for your courtesy and attention in this regard. Very truly yours, HOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP s/John R. Chapman John R. Chapman JRC/dmn cc: Richard C. Hutchison, Esq. Diane M. Nixon, Paralegal #67590593_vl TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail May 15, 2019 John Chapman [mail to: Diane.Nixon@hklaw.com] Re: GS #2718 (Pugliese Fire) We request that your office provide us with copies of the following documents: 1. All documents relating to the fire that occurred at 3145 N. Ocean Boulevard, Gulfstream, FL 33483-7369 on or about October 29, 2018 including police reports, inspection reports, fire marshal' report, insurance reports, dispatch log, dispatch notes, notes, witness statements, transcripts, videos, photographs, etc. 2. All documents relating to any correspondence (including text messages and emails) with City Departments, Insurance Companies, Fire Department, EMTs, Emergency Services, etc. regarding the fire that occurred at 3145 N. Ocean Boulevard, Gulfstream, FL 33483-7369 on or about October 29, 2018. 3. All documents relating to any correspondence (including text messages and emails) with the owners of the property, Anthony V. Pugliese, III and/or Laura K. Pugliese regarding the fire that occurred at 3145 N. Ocean Boulevard, Gulfstream, FL 33483-7369 on or about October 29, 2018. Dear John Chapman [mail to: Diane.Nixon@hklaw.com]: The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated May 9, 2018. You should be able to view your original request and response at the following link: http://www2.gulf-stream.org/weblink/0/doc/145084/Page1.aspx After speaking with your paralegal, Diane Nixon, on May 14, 2019, I informed her that the Town of Gulf Stream uses Delray Beach for fire and EMS services. She replied that you had sent the same request to Delray and would wait for a reply from them directly, not needing us to reach out to them, but you would still need anything the Town has in its custody regarding the above request. We have provided everything the Town has regarding the above request. We consider this request closed. Sincerely, Reneé Rowan Basel As requested by Rita Taylor Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records Page 1 of 2 Incident Type: Location of Incident: UCR Code: Type of Premises: Time of Call: Time of Arrival: Officer Injured: Date/Time Reported: Occurred From: Domestic: Juvenile Involved: Reporting Officer: Supervisor: Name: Race: Juvenile: Home Address: Business Name: Name Race: Juvenile: Business Address: Business Name Gulf Stream Police Department 246 Sea Road Gulf Stream, FL 33483 Phone: (561) 278-8611 Fax: (561) 276-2528 NON CRIMINAL OFFENSE REPORT ASSIST OTHER DEPARTMENT 3145 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM FL 33483 X RESIDENCE -SINGLE FAMILY 1753 1754 NO 10/29/2018 17:53 NO NO OFC. RANDALL WILSON LT. JOHN HASELEY ANTHONY PUGGLIESE III WHITE NO 3145 N OCEAN BLVD GULF STREAM FL 33483 (561)866-1100 CHAIM B COLEN MD WHITE NO 1803 S AUSTRALIAN AVE WPB 33409 COLEN INSTITUTE Zone: Processed By: Complaint Number: 18-2312 4 OFC R WILSON Other Units Notified: SGT J PASSEGGIATA, OFC C FAHEY Officer Killed/Assaulted: NO VICTIM Sex: MALE REPORTED BY Sex: MALE Business Phone: (248) 894-7262 INCIDENT SUMMARY ON 10/29/2018, AT APPROXIMATELY 1753 HRS. ALL GULF STREAM POLICE UNITS WERE DISPATCHED TO A RESIDENTIAL FIRE WITH FLAMES SHOWING THROUGH THE ROOF AT 3145 N. OCEAN BLVD. UPON ARRIVAL, ENTRY TO THE PROPERTY WAS MADE VIA THE SERVICE ENTRANCE USING GATE CODES TO OPEN GATE. FIRE WAS VISIBLE IN THE THREE CAR GARAGE AREA AND SPREADING FAST TO THE SECOND STORY ART LOFT. SGT. PASSEGGIATA REQUESTED DISPATCH TO NOTIFY OCEAN RIDGE POLICE TO SHUT DOWN SOUTH BOUND TRAFFIC FROM WOOLBRIGHT. DISPATCH OFFERED DELRAY POLICE UNITS TO ASSIST WITH TRAFFIC, OFFICER FAHEY ALONG WITH THE DELRAY UNITS CONTROLLED TRAFFIC FLOW AND DETORED TRAFFIC THROUGH GULFSTREAM RD. SGT. PASSEGGIATA AND I MADE ATTEMPTS TO CLEAR THE HOME AND EVACUATE ANYONE IF NECESSARY BUT IT WAS DETERMINED NO ONE WAS HOME OR ON THE PROPERTY. DBFD WAS UPDATED REPEATEDLY AS TO THE CONDITION OF THE FIRE AND RESIDENCE PRIOR TO THEIR rage 2 oY 2 Complamt Number: 125-1311 ARRIVAL. ALL GATES TO THE PROPERTY WERE SUBSEQUENTLY OPENED TO ALLOW DELRAY BEACH AND PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE FULL ACCESS TO THE PROPERTY. THEIR RUN NUMBERS WERE DB18013258 AND PBCTY 18113562. DISTRICT CHIEF AMELUNG WAS ON SCENE FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE AND CHIEF SCHAINUCK WAS ON SCENE FROM DELRAY BEACH FIRE. THE HOMEOWNER/VICTIM WAS NOTIFIED AND SUBSEQUENTLY RESPONDED TO HIS RESIDENCE. SEVERAL OF HIS EMPLOYEES THAT WORK AT HIS PROPERTY WERE ALSO SUMMONED TO THE SCENE TO ASSIST FD WITH THEIR KNOWLEDGE OF THIS LARGE PROPERTY. SGT. PASSEGGIATA NOTIFIED CHIEF ALLEN. CHIEF ALLEN ARRIVED A SHORT TIME LATER ALONG WITH LT. HASELEY AND TOOK COMMAND OF ALL POLICE OPERATIONS. GULF STREAM UNITS MAINTAINED SECURITY AND TRAFFIC CONTROL POSTS UNTIL THE FIRE DEPARTMENTS CLEARED THE SCENE. AFTER THE FIRE DEPARTMENT CLEARED, TWO GULF STREAM POLICE UNITS WERE ASSIGNED TO THE PROPERTY/CRIME SCENE FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE NIGHT. THE FIRE MARSHALL ALSO RESPONDED DURING THE FIRE EVENT AND RETURNED THE NEXT MORNING TO CONCLUDE HIS INVESTIGATION. NIP - op \``: �\ /A N f I int j'2a: A+�f+ rr�". ► r. �' t'<• . ' �[� }S 'o * j4 • X00 2 r � r �% i� I _moi✓�1p � �. k= 10 if 4WW y �" 4 r ip F 1 e�9 � Ed* Help F7 w FST F10 F11 {7E1) N OCEAN BLVD IS NOW OPEN [10129/18 23:02:58 BROWNA] Assisted Gulstream PD, by closing northbound A1A, in reference t0 their signal 25 110129118 20:43:09 Unit:C31 ] Hot~ {7E1} A1A WILL REMAIN SHUT DOWN COMPLETELY BTWN GOLFVIEW AND LAKEVIEW ... OCEAN RIDGE PD RELEASED [10129/18 20:42:48 BROWNA] T39 PBCFR ... RADIOS ARE T7, WILL TRY AND RAISE ON PORTABLES 19:48:58 BROWNA] 7A58) ATTEMPTING T25 -- WITH PBDFR UNIT # ['10129/18 57 -- NEED THE OWNER'S KEY RING L1wz911819:45:56 BRITO] (C311 TRAIN DELAY [10129/18 18:52:22 BRITO] {F65} HOMEOWNER IS T97 AREA [10!29/18 18:13:48 {7A58} POSS ANIMALS IN THE MAIN HOUSE -- _, 18:12:29 BRITO] $dpi Ra BRITO] KEYHOLDERS ARE T51 [10129118 T39 WATER PLANT [10/29/18 18:09:26 BROWNA] CFR --- UP THE PRESSURE FOR THE WATER ... [10/29/18 18:07:47 MENDEZM] T39 OCEAN RIDGE PD [10/29/18 18:07:00 BROWNA] {7135} REQ OCEAN RIDGE -- SHUT DOWN S/B TRAFFIC AT WOOLBRIGHT [10/29/18 18:06:11 BRITO] * FIRING RANGE [10/29/18 18:04:20 BRITO] T39 FD [10129118 18:04:09 BROWNA] (7A58) FIRE RANGE UNDERNEATH -- THE RESD -- POSS LIVE AMMUNITION [10129118 18:03:01 BRITO] UDTS: 17A58) FIRE DEPARTMENT ARRIVAL [10/29/18 176*59:49 BRITO] Flip Notes 4 CI _ p _Ose Refresh ... w 39 N-otes fiat Event #201801614'04 r �+fl l lCTS:7A58 FIRE DEPARTIV�I", _ _W r NT ARRIVAL [10/29/1817:59:49 BRITO- gi A58) ALL GATES OPEN110/29/18170u59:47BRITO]] �.. f7D5) REQ GATE CODES T1 8 -- OVER AIR10/29/ � I 18 17.59.19 BRITO] REP RESP UNK T52 ADV T18 DOMI NIDD OR VASQUEZ [10/29/1817.57.56 BROWNJE DOMINICl�C LSD DODGE PICK O ] R WHI VAN __ 2180 DATE CODE MAIN GATE [10/29/18 17 : 57:25 BROWNJ E] *JA58) GARAGE ATTACHED TO THE REED -- FIRE IS SPREADING TO THE HOUSE '710129/18 17:56036 BRITO] (7A58) BLOCK GOLFVIEW, SEA RD [10/29/10 17:55:24 BRITO] {7A58) NEED GOLDFVIEW - GULFSTREAM RD [10/29/1017:54:28 BRITO T9 FCS UPDATE [10/29/18 17:54:10 BROWNJE ] {7A58) GARAGE FULLY ENGULFED -- SEVERAL VEHICLES -- SMALL. EXPLOSIONS ['10/29/18 17:53:33 BRITO] 2ND CALLER 248-894-7262 [10/29/18 17:52:41 PRINCIPEA] {7A58) SERVICE ENTRANCE -- SHOP GARAGE ENTRANCE [10/29/18 17:52:38 BRITO] (7A58) SEE FLAMES FROM THE 3600-BLK -- HEAVY DRK GRY SMOKE ['10129118 17:51:25 BRITO] TOT` D TO P BC FR [10/29118 17:50:44 BROWNJ E] ALARM CO CALLING IN 3145 N OCEAN FIRE ALARM ['10129118 17:50:23 BROWNJE] FLAMES AT LEAST 20 FT HIGH [10/29118 17:50:14 MENDE2M] COMPL ADV'D LOTS OF GRAY SMOKE [10/29118 17:49:44 MENDE2M] Rd NORTH END OF HOUSE IS ON FIRE --- CAN SEE FLAMES'10129118 17:49:25 MENDEZM [ ] COMPL ADV`G HOUSE JSO IS ON FIRE --- [10129118 17:49.02 MENDEZMIT39 OCEAN ka Flip Notes Close Refresh n F4 �'�� __-�---- �� w nun�� � �.�r ur!I"INIl IP II I'tll'I'lll�neryl f7l C4.'pi Illlil� �I�I14P11'VIY,� iI�II@ll! COMPL ADV`G HOUSE JSO IS ON FIRE --- RIDGE PID 110129/1818:07:00 BROWNA ■ {7D5} REQ OCEAN RIDGE -- SHU18:06:11 T DOWN SIB TRAFFIC AT V1fOOLBRIGHT (10129118 BRITO] 'FIRING RANGE �10i291181 � T39 FD [10129 8:04:20 BRITO] /18 18:04:09 BROW NA] (7A58) FIRE RANGE UNDERNEAT RESD -- POSS LIVE AMMUNITION [10/29/18 H `8:03►:01 BRITO] -- THE :47 BRITO] 0/29/18 17:59:19 BRITO] REP RESP UNK T52 ADV T18 DOR VASQUEZ [10/29118 17:57:56 BROWNJE] DOMINICK LSD DODGE PICK OR -- 2180 GATE CODE MAIN GATE [10129/18 UDTS: {7A58} FIRE DEPARTMENT ARRIVAL [10129118 17:59:49 SRITO] {1A58} ALL GATES OPEN [10/29/18 17:59 VER AIR MINICK O WHI VAN 17:5725 BROWNJE] {7D5) REQ GATE CODES T18 -- O [1: {7A58} GARAGE ATTACHED TO THE RES -- FIRE IS SPREADING TO THE HOUSE [10129 {7A58 {7A58 x/18 17:56:36 BRITO] 1 BLOCK GOLFVIEW, SEA RD } NEED GOLDFVIEW T39 FD UPDATE [10129118 1 [1012 FBTREAM 9/18 17:55:24 BRITO] GULRD [10/29/18 17:54:28 BRITO] 7085456 10 BRC► WN,J E] {7A58} GARAGE FULL' ENGULFED --SEVERAL VEHICLES no SMALL EXPLOSIONS [10/29/18 17:53:33 BRITO] dd 2ND CALLER. 248-894-7262 {7A58} SERVICE ENTRANCE X i FlipNotes [10/29118 17:52:41 PRINCIPEA] .. SHOP GARAGE ENTRANCE [10/29/'18 17:52:3 ���%Ti. it 7D5 J s�% L7 D12 9118 17:: A5S} BLOC A5S} NEED 19 1=D UPDA A5S) GABA 0129118 170441 ID CALLER A58) SERVI A5RI SFF rm TQT�� D kLARF LAM I 010#40 I P 40RTI 'M P 5W 0 PE III rt. %m IL n I I Pk%nW TO THE RESD -- FIRE IS SPREADING w.6 BRIT�% ADING T3 THE HOUSE GOLFVIEW, SEA RD10/ [ 2911 8 17:55:24 BRIT ILDFVIEWI' - GULF ] STREAM RD [10/29/1817:54:28 B .E [10/29/1817:54:EROWIVJ E] 10 R1TG] EFULLY ENGULFED -- SEVERAL RAL VEHICLES -- SMALL EXPLOSIONS:33 BRITO] 148-094-7262 [10129/18 174052:41 PRINDIP ;E ENT EA] RANDS -- SHOP GARAGE ENTRANCE I10/29118 17.52.. 3 8 BRITJAMES FROM THE 3000=BLK -- HEAVY DRK GRY SMOKE (1012911$ni 1 JV -U LO- IDOFHC DV'a HrIli J/29118 17: 50:44 BROWNJ E] r IN 3145 N OCEAN FIRE ALARM [10/29/18 17:50:23 BROWNJE 0 FT HIGH [10/29/18 17:50:14 MENDEZM] OF GRAY SMOKE [10/29/18 17:49:44 MENDEZM] 3E IS ON FIRE --- CAN SEE FLAMES [10/29/18 17:49:25 MEND E JSO IS ON FIRE --- x10/29/18 17:49.902 MFNr)F7Mt JI r11��M M �� MrMnnrem+.+rOMwrMrmlrmrnrMr[rn ��nNMrnrnllmnmMrrWrinrrrwenrtnmpnlrvmlrMllmMnnl nMrmlmriamlrlrrmrprrin rMnlr��i nrmr .. .'II nrnnrNrpmriHNrnmrM�� 41' 'Iryl'. '1 91 W.��1 1mmN m, r, 1 4.1''1 ..." . _ _w_-._.._..��' ��a 0 i Ulf 4'7 rym 11 rmnurwmmnmumm�� mmrrmnrrrmingrmnwmmwrmn IMM W ��.����+��e��rywMWrrs��wi�� 0 10/31 Type here to seg, rch I (..I a il��lllp II i  kH+ uunnm.rnnmrnmr: mn l wh rnnrnr mnxmdrmr...wnn r fe " ��a Greg Dunham From: deJesus, Neal <DeJesus@mydelraybeach.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 29, 2019 5:00 PM To: Greg Dunham Subject: Fire Cost Estimate Attachments: Gulf Stream Fire Cost (003).xlsx Good afternoon Mr. Dunham, Per your request, attached please find the cost estimate associated with the structure fire located at 3145 N. Ocean Blvd. This estimate is based on and average of all salaries at each rank, times 5 hours which was the average on -scene time. As an example line 8 lists Engine 112 with an average equipment cost of $78.90/hour, an average fuel rate of $38.65/hour, and an average staff rate of $169.62/hour which represents the total average salaries of all 3 ranks (Captain, Driver Engineer and Firefighter Paramedic) assigned to Engine 112. If you would like to discuss these costs or need further explanation please do not hesitate to contact me on my personal cell at (954) 558-4734. Thank you. Stay safe, Neal de Jesus Fire Chief Delray Beach Fire Rescue delesus@mvdelravbeach.com www.mvdelmvbewh.com (561) 243-7410 - Office ISO Class 1 Fire Department ExceLLewce 'w aLL we do! Delray seam Florida tW 1493.2001+201' �'tJX%%" at:. %C- PUBLIC C PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. City of Dleray Beach Fire Rescue Department Town of Gulf Stream Fire 3145 N Ocean Blvd. Unit Equip/Hour Fuel/Hour Staff/Hour Cost/Hr Cost/Unit E112 $ 78.90 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 287.17 $ 1,435.85 1-111 $ 117.10 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 325.37 $ 1,626.85 L116 $ 117.10 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 325.37 $ 1,626.85 E114 $ 78.90 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 287.17 $ 1,435.85 50115 $ 93.47 $ 38.65 $ 55.44 $ 187.56 $ 937.80 E42 $ 78.90 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 287.17 $ 1,435.85 E41 $ 78.90 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 287.17 $ 1,435.85 TR115 $ 100.00 $ 38.65 $ 169.62 $ 308.27 $ 1,541.35 R112 $ 40.50 $ 38.65 $ 134.46 $ 213.61 $ 1,068.05 R116 $ 40.50 $ 38.65 $ 134.46 $ 213.61 $ 1,068.05 BC11 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 BC57 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 BC91 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 DC42 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 EMS57 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 EMS111 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 Ch113 $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 54.36 $ 112.01 $ 560.05 Fire Inv $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 69.36 $ 127.01 $ 635.05 Fire Inv $ 19.00 $ 38.65 $ 69.36 $ 127.01 $ 635.05 Total Cost Estimate $ 18,802.80