Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout20100527ccpacket (2) From: The City of Tybee Island Ethics Commission To: Mayor, Council Members, and City Attorney Re: Advisory Opinion: 05/19/2010 ISSUE: Should the current Ethics Ordinance (21-2008) be revised to include a requirement that if a Council Member receives campaign contributions of $500 (five hundred) dollars or more, that Council Member must recuse themselves from voting on issues that involve the contributor? BASIS OF OPINION: In the state of Georgia we are unaware of any local government that imposes a recusal requirement in connection with campaign contributions based on the amount of the contribution. Also, we are not aware of any case law dealing with this issue in those exact terms. Further, the acceptance of consideration (consideration defined as money, contributions of time or non monetary gifts to a campaign) in exchange for action on the part of a Council Member (such as a vote) constitutes a bribe and this is already addressed by Georgia law and therefore it would be redundant to place a campaign fund based recusal requirement on elected officials. CONCLUSION: After diligent review of past and present recusal requirements related specifically to campaign contributions for the community of Tybee Island, Georgia, the City of Tybee Island Ethics Commission elects not to act on the issue as related to recusal due to campaign contributions. Therefore, we conclude campaign contributions should be disclosed as per Georgia state law and this disclosure, which is a matter of record, can make it possible for the City of Tybee Island Ethics Commission to conduct an investigation [at our initiation or the request of others] if deemed necessary by the Tybee Island Ethics Commission to determine and then offer an opinion to the Tybee Island City Council. This is in the event of allegations of conduct by a City Council Member is believed to be, and evidence may be present to support a recommendation by the City of Tybee Island Ethics commission that a Council Member (s) recuse themselves. This applies only to issues within the scope of the authority established by the By-Laws of the Tybee Island Ethics Commission. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: CCPacket05272010 Page 1 of 89 Since the inception of Ordinance 6-2007 in 2007, one of the many purposes of the Ethics Commission has been to enhance the public's confidence in the integrity of the Tybee Island government. Embracing this purpose and its importance, members within The Commission who have maintained political affiliations with local political support groups have chosen to eliminate their affiliations with these groups in support of their sworn oath to the State of Georgia and the office of the Ethics Commission. The foundation for this action within the Ethics Commission is simple: it is our ardent goal to always strive for an objective opinion about any official’s conduct and we would not wish any decision we make to be misinterpreted as being rendered due to political and/or philosophical differences. We see this as a benefit to not only the city government of Tybee Island but its citizens as well. In closing Mayor Buelterman and Council Members I want to thank you for giving "Budget" consideration to the Ethic Commission's request for the City to have an independent attorney available; in the event the City Attorney cannot advise us. And also for our request for funds so as to provide additional training to the Ethics Commission.. Respectfully submitted, Danny Hill (Chairman) Tyler Marion (Vice-Chairman) The City of Tybee Island Ethics Commission CCPacket05272010 Page 2 of 89 MAYOR Jason Buelterman CITY COUNCIL Shirley Sessions, Mayor Pro Tem Wanda D. Doyle Bill Garbett Frank Schuman, Sr. Kathryn Williams Paul Wolff CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND CITY MANAGER Diane Schleicher CLERK OF COUNCIL Vivian O. Woods CITY ATTORNEY Edward M. Hughes P.O. Box 2749 – 403 Butler Avenue, Tybee Island, Georgia 31328-2749 (866) 786-4573 – FAX (866) 786-5737 www.cityoftybee.org City Council Agenda Item Request Agenda Item Requests must be submitted to the Clerk of Council by 10:00am the Friday prior to the scheduled Council meeting. If this form is received after the deadline, the item will be listed on the next scheduled agenda. Council Meeting Date for Request: May 27, 2010 Item: Monthly Financial Report – River’s End Campground & RV Park Explanation: April Revenues & Expenditures & Projected May Revenues & Expenditures __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ Budget Line Item Number (if applicable): N/A Paper Work: Attached* Already Distributed ______ To Be Handed Out at Council Meeting (by Requester) ______ Audio/Video Presentation** * Thirteen copies for packets must be provided with request. ** Audio/video presentation must be submitted to the IT department at City Hall at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. NOTE: Request will be postponed if necessary information is not provided. Submitted by: Woody Hemphill, Campground Manager – River’s End Campground & RV Park Phone / Email: 912-257-9890; whemphill@cityoftybee.org Comments: ________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ Date given to Clerk of Council 5/21/10 CCPacket05272010 Page 3 of 89 River's End RV Park and Campground Monthly Anticipated Revenues and Expense Report - 2010 April April May River's End Revenues:Anticipated Actuals Anticipated Camping $62,500.00 $59,660.60 $60,000.00 Cabins $6,000.00 $9,200.00 $9,000.00 Monthly/Tents $7,200.00 $8,485.20 $6,800.00 Reservations $18,000.00 $21,954.10 $17,000.00 Store Revenues $4,500.00 $7,274.79 $5,000.00 Misc. Revenues $500.00 $797.30 $500.00 Total Anticipated Revenues:$98,700.00 $111,252.04 $98,300.00 April April May River's End Expenditures:Anticipated Actuals Anticipated Total Personnel 15,000.00$ 18,523.89$ 15,000.00$ Total Services 9,000.00$ 7,582.37$ 9,000.00$ Total Supplies 11,000.00$ 9,544.23$ 11,000.00$ Total Capital Outlay 861.00$ Total Depreciation 861.00$ 861.00$ Total Debt Service Expense 47,200.00$ 47,200.00$ 47,200.00$ Total Anticipated Expenses:83,061.00$ 83,711.49$ 83,061.00$ River's End Guest Survey Time Period: 5.17.09 - 5.17.10 Responses: Rating Range: 1-5 Composite Scores: Average Overall Rating 3.7 B- Average Service Rating 4.3 B+ Average Facility Rating 4.3 B+ Average Site Rating 3.7 B- Average Cabin Rating 5.0 A+ Average Restroom Rating 4.3 B+ Total Rating:4.2 B+CCPacket05272010 Page 4 of 89 River's End Revenues:September September Anticipated Goals Camping 38,500.00$ 45,000.00$ Cabins 6,385.00$ 7,000.00$ Monthly/Tents 4,000.00$ 6,500.00$ Reservations 10,000.00$ 11,000.00$ Store Revenues 4,500.00$ 6,000.00$ Misc. Revenues 650.00$ 750.00$ Total Anticipated Revenues:64,035.00$ 76,250.00$ Total Deficit to Overcome 23,965.00$ 11,750.00$ River's End Revenues:September Goals Add'l Opportunities Goal Translation TOTAL NEEDED CAMPING 21,413.95$ 1,000.00$ 476 Site Nights/30amp; 390 site nights/50amp 498 site nights/30 amp; 408 site nights 50amp CABINS 3,280.00$ 1,000.00$ 44 site nights/$75; 28 site nights/$120 58 site nights/$75; 36 site nights/$120 MONTHLY/TENT 3,509.00$ 2,000.00$ BOOK MONTHLYS!WEEKEND FORECAST:( GROC (Store)706.10$ 500.00$ FIREWOOD!MORE FIREWOOD! ICE 181.21$ 250.00$ 85 bags 203 bags PROPANE 641.31$ -$ RV SUPPLIES 239.35$ 250.00$ RESERVATIONS 4,766.50$ 1,000.00$ ELEC -$ -$ VEND 353.25$ -$ TROLLEY 275.00$ 300.00$ 11 tickets 23 tickets OTHER REV 206.00$ 200.00$ 21 bike rentals 41 bike rentals TOTAL DEPOSIT 34,212.86$ 6,500.00$ $5,250.00 Operating Deficit River's End RV Park and Campground Monthly Anticipated Revenues and Expense Report - 2009 * Add'l Opportunities compiled from distributing remaining $11,750 throughout higher performing trends and components performing well this month to be recognized through remaining days of the month. Store Revenue Goals & Milestones for Month of September Total Park Operating Expenses for Month of September: $88,000 CCPacket05272010 Page 5 of 89 Assessment of September: 1. The first half of the month of September has already seen historical monthly sales totals surpassed within the following sectors: Tents, Grocery, Ice, & RV Supplies. These areas should continue to grow due to the expanded selection. 2. The following areas are areas of developmental need: Camping revenue (in-coming), Cabins, Propane, Reservations. 3.) Poorly performing sectors or areas of growth opportunity within ancillary revenue sectors are Bike Rentals, Vending Revenue, and Trolley Ticket Sales. These areas must be addressed immediately to ensure that revenue goals already maximized or limited by the drop or levelling of seasonal demand does not cause hardship for the park. CCPacket05272010 Page 6 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 7 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 8 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 9 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 10 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 11 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 12 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 13 of 89 ORDINANCE NO. 15-2010 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES SEC. 2-81 PERTAINING TO RULES OF COUNCIL FOR THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND, GEORGIA WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is authorized under Article 9, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the Constitution of the State of Georgia to adopt reasonable ordinances to protect and improve the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Tybee Island, Georgia, and WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is the Mayor and Council thereof, and WHEREAS, the governing authority desires to adopt ordinances under it police, zoning, and home rule powers, and WHEREAS, the City of Tybee Island is authorized by ordinance to establish rules of procedure for council meetings; and WHEREAS, the existing ordinance provides that except as otherwise provided by ordinance, rules shall be as provided in Robert’s Rules of Order; and WHEREAS, council wishes to adopt rules that are less cumbersome and more easier application than Robert’s Rules of Order; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island that Sec. 2-81 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Tybee Island is hereby amended so as to hereinafter provide as follows: Sec. 2-81. Rules of procedure. The mayor and council may, from time to time, adopt rules of procedure which shall govern the conduct of meetings and procedures of the city council. A copy of all such rules shall be maintained by the clerk of council at all times. It is the intention of the governing body, and it is hereby ordained, that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Ordinances, City of Tybee Island, Georgia, and the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered if necessary to accomplish such intention. This Ordinance shall become effective on ________ day of __________________, 2010. CCPacket05272010 Page 14 of 89 2 ADOPTED THIS DAY OF , 2010. _________________________________ MAYOR ATTEST: CLERK OF COUNCIL FIRST READING: SECOND READING: ENACTED: EMH/TYBEE/ORDINANCES/2010/15-2010/Rules of Council 05.19.10 CCPacket05272010 Page 15 of 89 RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the Charter of the City of Tybee Island expressly authorizes the adoption of rules of procedure in Section 2.20 thereof; and WHEREAS, the Charter establishes the procedure for the adoption of ordinances and states when an ordinance is required; and WHEREAS, the Code of Ordinances provides at Section 2.81 that except as otherwise provided by ordinance, the procedure of council shall be governed by Robert’s Rules of Order; and WHEREAS, in order for council to adopt rules inconsistent with Robert’s Rules of Order, an ordinance amending Section 2-81 is appropriate; and WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council believe that the procedures provided in Robert’s Rules of Order are cumbersome and needlessly difficult of interpretation and that the City will be better served by a set of straight forward rules and procedures adapted to the needs of the City. NOW, THEREFORE, the Council, pursuant to the power vested in it, does hereby adopt the following resolution: The City Counsel is amending its Rules of Procedure as described in this Resolution. An Ordinance will be prepared so as to alter the provisions of Section 2-81. Upon amendment of the ordinance, the following set of rules shall be in effect upon the adoption by Council of this Resolution and the ordinance amendment until such time as the Rules are amended or new rules adopted. CCPacket05272010 Page 16 of 89 Sec. 1. General Rules. These rules are intended to supplement and not to replace in any manner the Charter of the City or the ordinances of the City. Many topics frequently addressed in rules are covered by existing ordinances and the Charter and are not necessary to address herein. Sec. 2. Conduct of Meetings. 2.1. Existing Rules. Meetings shall be conducted as prescribed in the ordinances and Charter of the City. 2.2 Chairman. . The mayor shall serve as chairman of all meetings. The mayor or, in the mayor’s absence, the mayor pro tem shall preside at the meetings. In the absence of both the mayor and the mayor pro tem, the council shall elect a chairman to so preside. 2,3 Preservation of Order. The chairman shall preserve order and decorum, prevent attacks on personalities or the inpunging of members’ motives and confine members in debate to the question under discussion. 2.4 Points of Order. The chairman shall determine all points of order subject to the right of any member to appeal to the council. If an appeal is taken, the question shall be “Shall the decision of the chairman be sustained?” CCPacket05272010 Page 17 of 89 2.5 Questions to be Stated. The chairman shall state all questions submitted for a vote and announce the result. A roll call vote shall be taken upon the request of any member. Sec. 3. Order of Business and Agenda. 3.1 Consent Agenda. Council shall meet and consider items that can be placed on a consent agenda for unanimous action during the business portion of the regular meeting. 3.2 Structure. The structure of the agenda shall be as determined by the mayor and council from time to time. Sec. 4 Ordinances, Resolutions and Motions. 4.1. Form and Introduction. Ordinances and resolutions, including amendments to existing ordinances, shall be presented to council only in printed or typewritten form. An ordinance is to be considered introduced when provided to the clerk of council and all council members in attendance at a meeting. Emergency actions and ordinances shall be addressed and adopted as provided in the Charter. 4.2. Funding. All ordinances authorizing expenditure of money shall include the exact source of the funds to be expended. 4.3. Request for Staff Recommendations. Council may request staff to provide written recommendations with regard to any ordinance under consideration. CCPacket05272010 Page 18 of 89 4.4. Ordinances and Amendments under Consideration. A properly introduced ordinance or an amendment to an ordinance shall require a first and second reading for adoption. First and second readings may not be held on the same date an ordinance is introduced but a previously introduced ordinance may be adopted by first and second reading on the same date. In connection with adopting an ordinance, upon its first reading, it is only necessary for the caption thereof to be read aloud unless some member of council requests that the entire ordinance be read or that particular sections be read in their entirety. After the first reading of an ordinance, or the caption thereof, it shall only be necessary at a subsequent meeting concerning the adoption of such ordinance that any changes be referred to unless some member of council requests that the entire ordinance or change be read aloud. Changes of any nature may be made to a proposed ordinance following its first reading and the ordinance may be approved and adopted upon second reading unless a majority of council determines that the changes are of such a degree that additional reading(s) should be required. 4.5. Actions by the Mayor and Council. An affirmative vote of at least a majority of the members of council present shall be necessary to pass an ordinance, resolution, motion, or any other proposition except as otherwise specified in the charter or Georgia law. Unless otherwise specifically required by state law, no action by council shall require more than a majority vote of those members present and entitled to vote thereon participating. CCPacket05272010 Page 19 of 89 4.6. Motions and Seconds. Any motion by any member of council shall require a second before proceeding further. A motion that is not supported by a second ends the matter and the motion fails. Following action on a motion, a new motion on the same subject may be made but is not necessarily required and the failure to pass a motion to approve is the equivalent of a denial of the application. 4.7. Motions to Reconsider. Actions by council, including ordinances, may be reconsidered unless otherwise provided by state law, only in accordance with the following procedure: A member of council who voted in the majority of those voting on the topic, before the adjournment of the meeting at which the vote takes place or the very next meeting, makes a motion to reconsider or to reconsider and “lay on the table.” A motion to reconsider shall be taken up when made and, if seconded, voted upon. When a motion for reconsideration is passed, the topic under consideration is to be addressed at that time and action taken in accordance with the normal procedures. Motions for reconsideration and to lay on the table, if passed, shall require that the matter under consideration be addressed at the next council meeting. Following action on a motion for reconsideration and/or reconsideration to lay on the table, the matter shall be concluded. 4.8. Signing of Ordinances. When passed by council, an ordinance shall be signed by the presiding officer and attested by the clerk of council, and shall be immediately filed and thereafter preserved in the office of the clerk of council. CCPacket05272010 Page 20 of 89 4.9. Public Hearings. A majority of council may, by motion and vote, determine to hold an official public hearing on any ordinance, resolution, motion, or other action of council on any matter on an agenda. Public hearings shall be provided on zoning matters as required by law. 4.10. Abstentions and Recusals. For the purpose of action by the council, an abstention consists of the failure of a qualified council member to vote on a matter before the council. A recusal occurs when a council member is either not authorized to vote or declines to vote based on ethical considerations, such as an interest in the subject matter or a relationship to an interested party. Abstentions are counted as an affirmative vote (see also Sec. 2.21 of the Charter.). Recusals are not counted as a vote. Sec. 5. Creation of Committees, Board Members and Commissions. The council shall create committees, boards and commissions to assist in the conduct of the operation of the city government with such duties as the council may specify not inconsistent with the city charter or the city code of ordinances. 5.1. Membership and Selection. Membership and selection of members shall be as provided by council if not specified by the city charter or the code of ordinances. Any committee, board, or commission so created shall cease to exist upon the accomplishment of the special purpose for which it was created, or when abolished by a majority vote of the council. No committee so appointed shall have powers other than advisory to the council or to the city manager, except as otherwise specified by the charter or code of ordinances. CCPacket05272010 Page 21 of 89 5.2. Ex officio members of council may serve on committees as liasons for the mayor and council but shall be non-voting members of such commissions or boards. City council may seek input from existing committee members or the heads of any existing committee in connection with filling vacancies in the membership of any such committee, commission, or board. The council may remove any member of any board, commission, or authority which it has created by the city charter by a vote of at least a majority of council unless otherwise provided by ordinance. Sec. 6. Citizen’s Rights at Meetings. 6.1. Addressing Council. Any person desiring to address the council by oral communication shall request to be on the agenda as a visitor in accordance with procedures established by the clerk of council. Members of the public shall also be permitted to address council on matters on the council agenda. The time for addressing councils hall be established by council and shall generally be three (3) minutes per speaker, with a maximum of five (5) minutes, unless otherwise directed by council at the commencement of a meeting. 6.2. Manner of Addressing Council. Each person addressing council shall step up to the microphone, give his or her name and address for the record. All remarks shall be addressed to the council as a body, and not to any particular member thereof nor to the public. No person, other than members of council and the person having the floor, shall be permitted to enter into any discussion, either directly or through members of the council. CCPacket05272010 Page 22 of 89 6.3. Personal and Slanderous Remarks. Any person making personal, impertinent, or slanderous remarks, or who shall become boisterous while addressing the council, may be requested to leave the meeting and may be forthwith, by the chair of the meeting, barred from further audience before the council on the matter under discussion. Sec. 7. Suspension and Amendment of these Rules. 7.1.. Suspension of Rules. Any provision of these rules not governed by the city charter or code of ordinances may be temporarily suspended by a vote of a majority of the council. The vote on any such suspension shall be of record on the minutes of the meeting. 7.2. Amendment of Rules. These rules may be amended, or new rules adopted, by a majority vote of all members of council present at any meeting, provided that the proposed amendments or new rules shall have been introduced into the record at a prior council meeting. Optional 4. All motions except the following are subject to debate: a motion to adjourn; a motion to recess; a motion to table with or without a specific time for the return of the item; a motion to limit debate or to call for the question. Although not debatable, each of these motions requires a second and succeeds if passed by a majority of the members present provided a quorum is present. CCPacket05272010 Page 23 of 89 SO RESOLVED, This _______ day of _________________, 2010. ______________________________ Jason Buelterman, Mayor ATTEST ____________________________ Vivian Woods/Clerk of Council EMH/Tybee/14536/Resolutions/Rules and Procedures 05.19.10 10-08 am EMH/Tybee/156-Rules of Council/Resolution –Rules and Procedures 05.19.10 1-48 pm CCPacket05272010 Page 24 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 25 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 26 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 27 of 89 ORDINANCE NO. 15-2010 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES SEC. 2-81 PERTAINING TO RULES OF COUNCIL FOR THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND, GEORGIA WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is authorized under Article 9, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the Constitution of the State of Georgia to adopt reasonable ordinances to protect and improve the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Tybee Island, Georgia, and WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is the Mayor and Council thereof, and WHEREAS, the governing authority desires to adopt ordinances under it police, zoning, and home rule powers, and WHEREAS, the City of Tybee Island is authorized by ordinance to establish rules of procedure for council meetings; and WHEREAS, the existing ordinance provides that except as otherwise provided by ordinance, rules shall be as provided in Robert’s Rules of Order; and WHEREAS, council wishes to adopt rules that are less cumbersome and more easier application than Robert’s Rules of Order; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island that Sec. 2-81 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Tybee Island is hereby amended so as to hereinafter provide as follows: Sec. 2-81. Rules of procedure. The mayor and council may, from time to time, adopt rules of procedure which shall govern the conduct of meetings and procedures of the city council. A copy of all such rules shall be maintained by the clerk of council at all times. It is the intention of the governing body, and it is hereby ordained, that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Ordinances, City of Tybee Island, Georgia, and the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered if necessary to accomplish such intention. This Ordinance shall become effective on ________ day of __________________, 2010. CCPacket05272010 Page 28 of 89 2 ADOPTED THIS DAY OF , 2010. _________________________________ MAYOR ATTEST: CLERK OF COUNCIL FIRST READING: SECOND READING: ENACTED: EMH/TYBEE/ORDINANCES/2010/15-2010/Rules of Council 05.19.10 CCPacket05272010 Page 29 of 89 ORDINANCE NO. 16-2010 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES REGARDING ARTICLE 15, SOIL EROSION AND SEDIMENTATION CONTROL FOR THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND, GEORGIA WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is authorized under Article 9, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the Constitution of the State of Georgia to adopt reasonable ordinances to protect and improve the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Tybee Island, Georgia, and WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is the Mayor and Council thereof, and WHEREAS, the governing authority desires to adopt ordinances under it police, zoning, and home rule powers, WHEREAS, the City of Tybee Island desires to clarify the Ordinance relating to soil erosion and sedimentation control. NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island that the attached Article 15, Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control, be adopted in full as the ordinance of the City and the existing soil erosion and sedimentation control ordinance be and is hereby repealed in its entirety. It is the intention of the governing body, and it is hereby ordained, that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Ordinances, City of Tybee Island, Georgia, and the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered if necessary to accomplish such intention. This Ordinance shall become effective on ________ day of __________________, 2010. CCPacket05272010 Page 30 of 89 ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF ___________________, 2010. ______________________________ MAYOR ATTEST: CLERK OF COUNCIL FIRST READING: _______ SECOND READING: _______ ENACTED: _______ EMH/Tybee/Ordinances/2010/16-2010-soil erosion and sedimentation control 05.19.10 CCPacket05272010 Page 31 of 89 ORDINANCE NO. 07-2010 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE TEXT OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES REGARDING PUDS FOR THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND, GEORGIA WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is authorized under Article 9, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the Constitution of the State of Georgia to adopt reasonable ordinances to protect and improve the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Tybee Island, Georgia, and WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is the Mayor and Council thereof, and WHEREAS, a number of planned unit development districts (PUD’s) are located within the City of Tybee Island, Georgia as reflected in the City’s Land Development Code and the City’s official zoning map, and WHEREAS, the City’s official zoning map identifies Gulick Row as one of the PUD’s located within the City, and WHERAS, the City Council re-zoned Gulick Row from R-1 to PUD at the City Council meeting held on March 10, 1982, and WHEREAS, the text of subsection 04-050(K) of the City’s zoning ordinance lists planned unit development districts existing within the City but, through inadvertence, omits Gulick Row as one of the existing PUD’s within the City, and WHEREAS, as a result of certain litigation, to wit: Civil Action No. CV06-2275- FR, Live Oak Group, LLC v. the City of Tybee Island, et. al. in the Superior Court of the Eastern Judicial Circuit, the court has determined that the property in Gulick Row is in fact a PUD, and WHEREAS, in order to correct the ordinance of the City, the text of the ordinance, 4-050(K) should be amended so as to expressly state that Gulick Row is one of the existing PUD’s. NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island that hereafter subsection 4-050(K) should read as follows: CCPacket05272010 Page 32 of 89 PUD Planned Unit Development Districts. The existing planned unit development districts, at the time of the adoption of the ordinance from which this section is derived, shall remain. No further planned unit development district shall be created. The existing planned unit development districts are Northshore Subdivision, Seaside Colony, Oceanside Dunes, Oceanview Townhomes, and Gulick Row. This Ordinance shall become effective on ________ day of __________________, 2010. ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF ___________________, 2010. ______________________________ ___ MAYOR ATTEST: CLERK OF COUNCIL FIRST READING: _______ SECOND READING: _______ ENACTED: _______ G:/EMH/TYBEE/ORDINANCES/07-2010/PUDTextAmendment 03.11.10 CCPacket05272010 Page 33 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 34 of 89 ORDINANCE NO. 10-2009-B (amended 4/27/10) AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES SECTION 34-3 PERTAINING TO PRIVATE PARKING LOTS FOR THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND, GEORGIA WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is authorized under Article 9, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the Constitution of the State of Georgia to adopt reasonable ordinances to protect and improve the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Tybee Island, Georgia, and WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is the Mayor and Council thereof, and WHEREAS, the governing authority desires to adopt ordinances under its police, zoning, and home rule powers, WHEREAS, it is necessary to amend the Code of Ordinances pertaining to private parking lots so as to expand the times of use permissible for such so that the following changes shall be made in Section 34-3. NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island that Code Section 34-3 regarding private parking lots is amended so as to hereafter provide as follows: Section 34-3 Private Parking Lots Notwithstanding any other ordinance or provision to the contrary, individuals owning property suitable for vehicular parking may apply to the city for a business license so as to authorize them to charge for parking on their property, regardless of the zoning of the property so long as the property abuts a public road, during such times as may be established by the CCPacket05272010 Page 35 of 89 Mayor and Council or authorized City staff. In general those times shall be in connection with special events or holiday weekends or holidays and the heavy tourist season and shall include all dates from St. Patrick’s Day through Labor Day and such license shall authorize the holder thereof to rent out parking spaces solely on the holder’s property between the hours of 08:00 a.m. and 09:00 p.m., or the duration of the event, the weekend or holiday, all as stated on the license. It shall be unlawful to rent spaces in any district without a valid business license issued by the City of Tybee Island. With submittal of the application for business license, each applicant must provide the City with a professional survey of the lot or lot corner demonstration which is to be used along with a site plan of the location showing the parking spaces and structure location that will be rented. In addition, these submittals are required to have a scaled drawing of the parking spaces to be located upon the proposed location. After the submittal of the application, staff shall have the authority to recommend to Council a maximum number of spaces allowed to be utilized at the requested parking lot. Upon submittal of the applications and all pertinent materials, the Mayor and council will hear the request for application at their next regularly scheduled meeting of the City Council. Public comments, if any, will be allowed to be made at these meetings and allow for property notification to adjacent property owners of the application. Council may reject any such application or may approve the application with conditions designed to protect neighboring properties & households including, but not limited to, restricting the number of vehicles allowed to be parked on site, the location of vehicle parking, the type of vehicles permissible for the location, the hours of operation, the requirement of security measures, buffers, noise control methods & any other condition or requirement reasonably designed to lessen the impact of the activity upon other properties or citizens. CCPacket05272010 Page 36 of 89 Each license to operate a private parking lot on Tybee Island will be subject to an annual review for compliance. If compliance is not met, the license may be revoked by City Council upon a hearing that will take place during a regularly scheduled City Council meeting. It is the intention of the governing body, and it is hereby ordained, that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Ordinances, City of Tybee Island, Georgia, and the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered if necessary to accomplish such intention. This ordinance shall be become effective on _______ day of ________, 2010. ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF ______, 2010. ______________________________ MAYOR ATTEST: __________________________ CLERK OF COUNCIL FIRST READING: _____ SECOND READING: _____ ENACTED: _____ CCPacket05272010 Page 37 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 38 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 39 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 40 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 41 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 42 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 43 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 44 of 89 CC P a c k e t 0 5 2 7 2 0 1 0 P a g e 4 5 o f 8 9 CC P a c k e t 0 5 2 7 2 0 1 0 P a g e 4 6 o f 8 9 CC P a c k e t 0 5 2 7 2 0 1 0 P a g e 4 7 o f 8 9 CC P a c k e t 0 5 2 7 2 0 1 0 P a g e 4 8 o f 8 9 CC P a c k e t 0 5 2 7 2 0 1 0 P a g e 4 9 o f 8 9 CCPacket05272010 Page 50 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC Site ID: [site id] Site Address: [site address] [AMEND #] AMENDMENT TO [ORIGINAL LEASE AGREEMENT NAME] THIS [AMEND #] AMENDMENT TO [ORIGINAL LEASE AGREEMENT NAME] (“[Amend #] Amendment”) is entered into as of [papering date], by and between [insert current landlord’s name], [type of entity], as successor in interest to [landlord predecessors] (together with successors and assigns, “Landlord”), and Md7 Capital Three, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (together with successors and assigns, “Tenant”). The effective date of this [Md7 Amend #] Amendment to [original lease agreement name] is [assign CD] (“Effective Date”). RECITALS WHEREAS, Landlord and [original T-Mobile tenant’s name], a [type of entity], [as predecessor in interest to [current T-Mobile tenant name]] (“T-Mobile Tenant”), entered into that certain [original lease agreement name] dated [lease agreement date] as amended [by a(n) name of amendment dated x/x/xx] (collectively, the “Lease”), whereby Landlord leased to T-Mobile Tenant certain premises described therein, together with all other space and access and utility easements utilized by T-Mobile Tenant pursuant to the terms of the Lease (the “Premises”), that are a portion of the property located at [site address] (the “Property”); WHEREAS, on [papering date of Assignment Agreement], T-Mobile Tenant and Tenant entered into a lease assignment agreement, whereby T-Mobile Tenant assigned, and Tenant assumed, all of T- Mobile Tenant’s rights and obligations as the tenant under the Lease and the parties simultaneously entered into a sublease agreement (the “T-Mobile Sublease”) whereby T-Mobile Tenant is subleasing the Premises from Tenant (T-Mobile Tenant, as subtenant under the T-Mobile Sublease, “T-Mobile Subtenant”) and T-Mobile Subtenant has agreed to a rent lock-in period that runs concurrently with the Rent Lock-In Period (defined below); WHEREAS, Tenant desires a reduction in its base rent obligations under the Lease and Landlord is willing to reduce Tenant’s base rent obligations under the Lease, provided Tenant commits to pay base rent to Landlord for the Rent Lock-In Period; WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant desire to extend the term of the Lease and to add additional renewal terms to the Lease; and WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant, in their mutual interest, wish to amend the Lease to accomplish the foregoing on the terms and conditions set forth herein. NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing Recitals which are incorporated herein by this reference, and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, Landlord and Tenant hereby agree: 1. Lease Amendment Provisions. The following provisions hereby modify the Lease: a. Term. The current term of this Lease is amended such that, commencing on [Assign CD] (the “Rent Modification Date”), the term shall continue for twenty-five (25) years, expiring on [new expiration date]. (the “Modified Term”). Rent for any partial month or partial year of the current term prior to the Rent Modification Date shall be prorated. CCPacket05272010 Page 51 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC b. Renewal Terms. Upon the expiration of the Modified Term, the term of this Lease will be automatically renewed for up to [number of renewal terms] additional and successive five (5)-year terms (each a “Renewal Term”) without further action by Tenant on the same terms and conditions of this Lease, unless Tenant provides written notice to Landlord of its intention not to renew this Lease at least thirty (30) days prior to the end of the Modified Term or Renewal Term, as applicable. c. Modification of Rent. Commencing on the Rent Modification Date, the base rent payable under this Lease during the Modified Term and any and all Renewal Terms (“Rent”) shall be made in the amounts and frequency as designated on Schedule II attached hereto and incorporated herein (“Rent Payment Schedule”). d. Rent Lock-In Period. Tenant hereby agrees that Tenant will be obligated to pay the Rent due hereunder for the ten (10) year period immediately following the Rent Modification Date (the “Rent Lock-in Period”), and such obligation will not be subject to offset or abatement by Tenant, or adversely impacted by termination of this Lease by Tenant, except in the event of a termination by Tenant as permitted by this Section 1(d). Notwithstanding the foregoing, or any term or condition to the contrary in this Lease, Tenant shall have the right during the Rent Lock-In Period to immediately terminate the Lease upon written notice to Landlord, if Tenant’s (or any subtenant’s) rights to occupy or use the Premises for Tenant’s (or any subtenant’s) intended telecommunications purposes are impaired at any time due to: (i) any bankruptcy or insolvency proceeding involving Landlord or any affiliate of Landlord; (ii) any uncured default, gross negligence or willful misconduct of Landlord; (iii) any casualty damage; (iv) any taking or condemnation under the power of eminent domain; (v) any tax sale, foreclosure or other similar proceeding; or (vi) any other material interference by Landlord to Tenant’s (or any subtenant’s) use of the Premises]. In the event of any such termination, except for obligations that survive termination under this Lease, Tenant shall have no further duty or obligation under this Lease, including, without limitation, any obligation to pay any Rent that would otherwise have been due for the remainder of the Rent Lock-In Period following the date of termination. Without limiting any other termination right of Tenant, at any time after the Rent Lock-in Period, Tenant may, at any time and for any reason, terminate this Lease upon thirty (30) days written notice to Landlord. e. Quiet Enjoyment. At all times during the Modified Term and any Renewal Terms of this Lease, Landlord covenants and warrants to Tenant that Tenant’s quiet enjoyment of the Premises or any part thereof shall not be disturbed as long as Tenant is not in default beyond any applicable grace or cure period. f. Indemnity. Landlord and Tenant each agree to indemnify and hold harmless the other party from and against any and all claims, damages, costs and expenses, including reasonable attorney fees, to the extent caused by or arising out of: (i) the negligent acts or omissions or willful misconduct in the operations or activities on the Premises by the indemnifying party or the employees, agents, contractors, licensees, tenants and/or subtenants of the indemnifying party or (ii) a breach of any obligation, representation or warranty of the indemnifying party under this Lease. The indemnifying party’s obligations under this section are contingent upon its receiving prompt written notice of any event giving rise to an obligation to indemnify the other party and the indemnified party’s granting it the right to control the defense and settlement of the same. This indemnity provision shall survive the expiration or early termination of this Lease. g. Recognition Agreement. Landlord agrees to execute, acknowledge and deliver to Tenant for the benefit of T-Mobile Subtenant a recognition agreement in the form of Exhibit A attached hereto CCPacket05272010 Page 52 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC and incorporated herein, which instrument may be recorded by Tenant or its subtenant in the land records for the recording jurisdiction in which the Property is located (“Recognition Agreement”). h. T-Mobile Sublease. Landlord acknowledges that, simultaneously with the execution of this [Amend #] Amendment, Tenant is entering into the T-Mobile Sublease with T-Mobile Subtenant and that Landlord shall enter into a Recognition Agreement with T-Mobile Subtenant. Landlord agrees that, notwithstanding any provision of this Lease to the contrary, no sublease rents or other additional rent payments shall be due to Landlord from either Tenant or T-Mobile Subtenant in connection with the T- Mobile Sublease. i. Notices. All notices under this Lease shall be in writing and shall be deemed effective, even if refused or returned undelivered, if the same is given by first class, certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, or sent by a nationally recognized overnight courier, postage prepaid and addressed to the party to whom notice is to be given, at the address indicated herein (“Notice”). Either party may change its address for Notice, or provide additional addresses for Notice by ten (10) days prior written Notice to the other as provided herein: Landlord’s Address: [landlord’s name and address] Send Rent Schedule Payments to: [payee name and address] Tenant’s Address: Md7 Capital Three, LLC 3721 Valley Centre Drive Suite 303 San Diego, CA 92130 Attn: Legal Department T-Mobile Subtenant’s Address: [TMO name and notice address] With a copy to: [TMO copy to name and address] During the term of the T-Mobile Sublease, for ordinary course, day-to-day, operational issues relating to the use, occupancy, maintenance and repair of the Premises, Landlord shall communicate directly with T- Mobile Subtenant in the manner set forth in this Lease as though T-Mobile Subtenant were the tenant under this Lease and in accordance with applicable operating rules and regulations and local custom. Landlord shall provide Tenant with copies of all correspondence to and from T-Mobile Subtenant. In addition, T-Mobile Subtenant shall be copied, pursuant to the notice instructions above, on any delinquent rent notices or termination notices at the same time such notice is delivered to or by the Landlord or Tenant, as applicable, under this Lease. j. Equitable Remedies. In addition to the remedies available to Tenant under this Lease, Tenant also shall have the right to enforce this Lease by specific performance, injunction, appointment of a receiver and any other equitable rights and remedies available to Tenant under the law, it being acknowledged by Landlord that money damages may not be an adequate remedy for the harm caused to Tenant by a breach or default by Landlord under this Lease. k. Landlord Assignment; Successors and Assigns. Landlord shall have the right to assign or otherwise transfer this Lease upon written notice to Tenant in the event, and only in the event, of a sale of the entire Property to a third party. In all other circumstances, the prior written consent of Tenant (and any subtenant of the entire Premises) shall be required for any other assignment or transfer by Landlord of this Lease; for purposes of clarity and without limitation upon the foregoing, Landlord shall not have the right to: (i) assign or transfer this Lease or any rents or other income associated with this Lease or (ii) CCPacket05272010 Page 53 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC grant any easement rights in or over all or any part of the Premises separate and distinct from a transfer of Landlord’s entire right, title and interest in the Property, in either case without the prior written consent of Tenant (and any subtenant of the entire Premises), which consent may be withheld in the sole discretion of Tenant (and any subtenant of the entire Premises). Subject to the foregoing, this Lease shall run with the land, and shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the parties, their respective successors, personal representatives and assigns. 2. Landlord Required Consents. Landlord represents and warrants that Landlord has obtained all required consents in connection with entering into this [Amend #] Amendment (including, without limitation, all master landlord, lender and secured party consents, if applicable). 3. Other Terms and Conditions Remain. The Lease is amended to incorporate all the provisions set forth on Schedule I attached hereto and incorporated herein, if applicable. In the event of any inconsistencies between the Lease and this [Amend #] Amendment, the terms of this [Amend #] Amendment shall govern and control. Except as expressly set forth in this [Amend #] Amendment, the Lease is otherwise unmodified and remains in full force and effect. 4. General Provisions. a. Landlord acknowledges that Landlord has read and understands this [Amend#] Amendment and the underlying Lease. b. This [Amend #] Amendment may be executed in multiple counterparts and signatures sent by facsimile or email may be treated as original signatures. c. The parties agree to cooperate with each other to sign, within ten (10) business days following the written request of the other party, a Short Form/Memorandum/Notice of [original agreement name]/ Short Form/Memorandum/Notice of Amendment to [original agreement name] in the form of [Exhibit B and C] attached hereto and incorporated herein. [SIGNATURES APPEAR ON THE FOLLOWING PAGE] CCPacket05272010 Page 54 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused their properly authorized representatives to execute and deliver this [Amend #] Amendment effective as of the date set forth above. LANDLORD: [Landlord Name] By: Print Name: Title: TENANT: Md7 Capital Three, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Print Name: Title: CCPacket05272010 Page 55 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC Schedule I Additional Lease Terms and Conditions The following provisions shall amend the Lease: 1. Expansion of Permitted Use. Landlord hereby agrees that Tenant shall have the right, without the requirement of obtaining Landlord’s consent, to modify, supplement, replace, upgrade, expand or refurbish the equipment related to Tenant’s communications facility (“Communications Facility”), increase the number of antennas thereon, modify its operating frequencies or relocate the Communications Facility within the Premises at any time during the term of this Lease or any Renewal Term. Landlord shall cooperate with Tenant in all respects in connection with the foregoing. If Landlord does not comply with the terms of this section, Tenant may exercise all of its rights and remedies under law or equity, including, without limitation, terminating this Lease and, upon such termination, shall have no further liability to Landlord. 2. Expansion of Premises. Landlord grants Tenant the right, on a space available basis, to enlarge the Premises (the “Additional Premises”), so that Tenant may implement any necessary modifications, supplements, replacements, refurbishments or expansions to the Communications Facility or to any equipment related thereto, as determined by Tenant in its sole discretion. In the event Tenant requires Additional Premises for such purposes, the monthly Rent payable for such Additional Premises shall be the lesser of the then current monthly per square foot rent or [One Dollar and Fifty Cents ($1.50)] per square foot (the “Additional Premises Rent”). The Additional Premises Rent shall be compensation for space utilized by the expansion of Tenant’s room/cabinet/ground area and for expansion of the antenna area(s) beyond the Premises, but Tenant’s addition of coaxial cables, raceways, conduits and other ancillary equipment and such related space usage, shall not require or result in Additional Premises Rent or any other compensation to Landlord. The Additional Premises Rent shall be payable to Landlord at the times and in the manner set forth in this Lease for payment of Rent and shall be subject to adjustment (if applicable) from time to time in the same manner and percentage set forth in this Lease for adjustments to Rent, if any. Landlord agree to take such actions and enter into and deliver to Tenant such documents as Tenant reasonably requests in order to affect and memorialize the lease of the Additional Premises to Tenant. Landlord and Tenant agree that each and every reference in this Lease to the “Premises” shall also include the “Additional Premises” (if any). 3. Access. Without limiting the generality of any other right available to Tenant under this Lease, Landlord hereby grants and confirms unto Tenant, and to any public or private utility serving the Premises and/or the Communications Facility or related equipment, access to the Premises and over the Property, twenty-four hours per day, seven days per week (24/7), including, without limitation, access to and from an accessible, open and maintained public road to the Premises, for the installation, maintenance, repair, modification, alteration, or refurbishment of the Communications Facility or any equipment or service related to such Communications Facility as such access is deemed necessary by Tenant, in its reasonable discretion, without the requirement of notice by Tenant to Landlord. In the event that any public or private utility serving the Communications Facility is unable to use the access provided by Landlord, then Landlord hereby agrees to grant additional access to Tenant or to such public or private utility, for the benefit of Tenant, at no cost to Tenant and pursuant to the same terms and conditions as noted above. 4. Reasonableness. If any consent, authorization or approval of either party is required or requested by the other party under or in connection with this Lease, such approval, consent or authorization shall not be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed. CCPacket05272010 Page 56 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC 5. Assignment and Subleasing. a. Tenant shall have the right to assign or otherwise transfer this Lease (including all easements, rights and obligations thereunder) upon written notice to Landlord. Upon assignment, Tenant shall be relieved of all liabilities and obligations under this Lease, and Landlord shall look solely to the assignee for performance of all obligations under this Lease. b. Tenant may sublease the Premises without notice to or consent from Landlord. c. Tenant shall have the right to sublease the Premises and/or assign, sell, pledge or otherwise transfer any and all of its rights, title or interests in, to or under this Lease to any pledgees, mortgagees, holders of security interests, trustees, lenders or other parties providing financing to Tenant (individually, “Secured Party”), without the prior consent of Landlord. Landlord and Tenant agree that any Secured Party shall be a third party beneficiary of all of the rights of Tenant under this Lease and shall be entitled to record a deed of trust or mortgage to secure its interest under this Lease. CCPacket05272010 Page 57 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC Schedule II Rent Schedule Payments RENEWAL TERM/RENT SCHEDULE TABLE HERE CCPacket05272010 Page 58 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC EXHIBIT A Recognition Agreement (attached) CCPacket05272010 Page 59 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC EXHIBIT B Short Form/Memorandum/Notice of [original agreement name]/ (attached) CCPacket05272010 Page 60 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-3 ASL DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC EXHIBIT C Short Form/Memorandum/Notice of Amendment to [original agreement name] (attached) CCPacket05272010 Page 61 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC [INSERT STATE-SPECIFIC HEADER HERE] RECOGNITION AGREEMENT THIS RECOGNITION AGREEMENT (“Agreement”) is entered into as of [papering date], by and among [current landlord’s name], a [type of entity] , as successor in interest to [landlord predecessors] (“Landlord”), whose mailing address for notices is [landlord notice address], [current T- Mobile tenant’s name], a [type of entity], as successor in interest to [insert tenant predecessors] (“T- Mobile Subtenant”), whose mailing address for notices is [T-Mobile notice address], and Md7 Capital Three, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (“Tenant”), whose mailing address for notices is 3721 Valley Centre Drive, Suite 303, San Diego, California 92130. The effective date of this agreement is [assign CD] (“Effective Date”). RECITALS WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant are parties to that certain [title of original lease agreement] dated [original lease agreement date], as [amended by a(n) name of amendment dated x/xx/xx and further] amended by that certain [Amend #] Amendment to [title of original lease agreement] dated [papering date] (as supplemented and amended from time to time, collectively, the “Lease”), which demises certain premises located at [site address] (“Premises”), as more particularly described on Exhibit A attached hereto and incorporated herein; WHEREAS, pursuant to the terms and conditions of the Lease, the “Modified Term” of the Lease expires on [new expiration date] (the “Lease Expiration Date”), and Landlord has agreed to modify the Rent (as defined in the Lease) due under the Lease in exchange for a Rent Lock-In Period (as defined in the Lease); WHEREAS, Tenant is subleasing the Premises to T-Mobile Subtenant pursuant to that certain Site Sublease and Assignment Agreement between such parties (as supplemented and amended from time to time, the “T-Mobile Sublease”); WHEREAS, pursuant to the terms and conditions of the T-Mobile Sublease, T-Mobile Subtenant enjoys all of the rights of Tenant under the Lease during the term of the T-Mobile Sublease and T-Mobile Subtenant has agreed to perform all of the obligations of Tenant under the Lease other than the payment of Rent; and WHEREAS, Landlord, T-Mobile Subtenant and Tenant have agreed to enter into this Agreement on the terms and conditions set forth below. AGREEMENT NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing recitals which are incorporated herein by reference and of the mutual covenants herein contained and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the parties hereto agree as follows: 1. T-Mobile Sublease Permission. Landlord hereby acknowledges and agrees that the T- Mobile Sublease is permitted under the terms and conditions of the Lease. CCPacket05272010 Page 62 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC 2. Recognition; Nondisturbance. Landlord agrees that T-Mobile Subtenant shall be a third party beneficiary under the Lease, and hereby recognizes T-Mobile Subtenant's rights to use, possess and enjoy the Premises pursuant to the T-Mobile Sublease as being valid and enforceable rights. Landlord agrees not to disturb or interfere with any of T-Mobile Subtenant’s rights to use, possess or enjoy the Premises at any time prior to the Lease Expiration Date, for any reason, provided that T-Mobile Subtenant timely cures any T-Mobile Subtenant Default (defined below). Landlord further agrees to recognize and accept: (a) T-Mobile Subtenant’s exercise of all rights and options under the Lease on behalf of Tenant as tenant thereunder (including, without limitation, all tenant remedies and rights to renew the term of the Lease beyond the Lease Expiration Date); (b) T-Mobile Subtenant’s performance of the Tenant’s obligations as tenant under the Lease; and (c) any assignment by Tenant of the tenant’s rights under the Lease to T-Mobile Subtenant. For purposes hereof, the term "T-Mobile Subtenant Default" means any material default under the Lease on account of T-Mobile Subtenant's use of the Premises in a manner prohibited thereby or on account of any failure by T-Mobile Subtenant to pay any monetary obligations (excluding Rent) that are required to be paid or reimbursed under the Lease (if applicable). 3. Additional Rent and Other Payments under Lease. Landlord acknowledges and agrees that T-Mobile Subtenant shall not be required to pay any Rent under the Lease, unless and until T- Mobile Subtenant becomes the “tenant” under a New Lease (defined below) pursuant to Section 5 below; provided, however, the parties agree that T-Mobile Subtenant shall be responsible for, and shall timely pay directly to Landlord: (a) any payments due under the Lease for utilities, insurance, real property taxes and maintenance charges (collectively, “Owner Reserved Payments”), (b) any Additional Premises Rent (as defined in the Lease), [and (c) any Revenue Share Fees (as defined in the Lease)], and Landlord agrees to look only to T-Mobile Subtenant for such payments under the Lease. 4. No Amendment. Landlord agrees that it will not amend or modify the Lease without the consent of T-Mobile Subtenant, which consent T-Mobile Subtenant may withhold in its sole and absolute discretion if (in T-Mobile Subtenant’s reasonable judgment) the amendment or modification would materially or adversely affect T-Mobile Subtenant's rights in and to the Premises, including, without limitation, any and all changes to the Rent and other charges payable under the Lease, any modifications of the term of the Lease and any modifications to the Premises or rights appurtenant to the Premises. If (in T-Mobile Subtenant’s reasonable judgment) the amendment or modification would not materially or adversely affect T-Mobile Subtenant's rights in and to the Premises, then T-Mobile Subtenant may not unreasonably withhold, condition or delay its consent to such amendment or modification. Landlord shall not cause or join in any rescission, rejection or other termination of the Lease prior to the Lease Expiration Date, without the express prior written consent of T-Mobile Subtenant. 5. Direct Lease; Attornment by T-Mobile Subtenant. If, at any time during the term of the T-Mobile Sublease, the Lease is either rescinded, rejected or otherwise terminated (except in connection with an uncured T-Mobile Subtenant Default), then Landlord shall promptly notify T-Mobile Subtenant thereof, and Landlord agrees, upon T-Mobile Subtenant's request, to enter into a direct lease between Landlord, as landlord, and T-Mobile Subtenant, as tenant, for the remainder of the period prior to the Lease Expiration Date, on the same terms and conditions as set forth in the Lease, including, without limitation, all Rent, any remaining portion of the Rent Lock-In Period, and the Renewal Terms (a “New Lease”). From and after the first day of the first full month following the date Landlord and T-Mobile Subtenant enter into a New Lease, if at all, T-Mobile Subtenant shall commence paying Rent directly to Landlord and T-Mobile Subtenant shall not be responsible for any Rent unpaid by Tenant; provided, however, that T-Mobile Subtenant shall continue to be responsible for the payment of all Owner Reserved Payments, Additional Premises Rent and Revenue Share Fees, if applicable. CCPacket05272010 Page 63 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC 6. General Provisions. (a) This Agreement constitutes the final, complete and exclusive statement between the parties to this Agreement, supersedes all prior and contemporaneous understandings or agreements of the parties with regard to the subject matter hereof, and is binding on and inures to the benefit of their respective heirs, representatives, successors and assigns. Any agreement made after the date of this Agreement is ineffective to modify, waive, or terminate this Agreement, in whole or in part, unless that agreement is in writing, is signed by all parties to this Agreement, and specifically states that the agreement modifies this Agreement. (b) This Agreement will be governed by, and construed in accordance with the internal laws of the state where the Premises are located. (c) If any provision of this Agreement is, to any extent, held to be invalid or unenforceable, the remainder of this Agreement will not be affected, and each provision of this Agreement will be valid and be enforced to the fullest extent permitted by law. (d) Landlord shall promptly deliver to T-Mobile Subtenant a copy of any and all notices which Landlord is required to give under the Lease, and any other notice or official communication given by Landlord to Tenant with respect to the Lease. Any notice under this Agreement will be delivered personally, by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by a nationally recognized overnight courier, addressed to the party to whom it is intended. Any notice given to Landlord or T- Mobile Subtenant shall be sent to the respective address set forth below, or to such other address as that party may designate for service of notice by a notice given in accordance with the provisions of this paragraph. A notice sent pursuant to the terms of this paragraph shall be deemed delivered when delivery is attempted, if delivered personally, two (2) business days after deposit into the United States mail, or the day following deposit with a nationally recognized overnight courier. Landlord’s Address: [Landlord name and address] T-Mobile Subtenant: [T-Mobile tenant] c/o T-Mobile USA, Inc. 12920 SE 38th Street Bellevue, Washington 98006 Attention: Legal Department Tenant: Md7 Capital Three, LLC 3721 Valley Centre Drive, Suite 303 San Diego, California 92130 Send Rent Schedule Payments to: [Payee name and address] With a copy to: [Name and copy to address of T- Mobile tenant] (e) If, after the Effective Date of this Agreement, either party commences any litigation or other legal proceeding against the other party arising out of, or in connection with, this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be entitled to recover from the losing party reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs of suit. CCPacket05272010 Page 64 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC (f) Each party to this Agreement will, at its own cost and expense, execute and deliver such further documents and instruments and will take such other actions as may be reasonably required or appropriate to evidence or carry out the intent and purposes of this Agreement. (g) Landlord acknowledges and agrees that T-Mobile Subtenant lacks an adequate remedy at law if Landlord does not honor its obligations under this Agreement, and that Landlord's obligations hereunder shall be enforceable by means of an action for specific performance and other equitable relief. (h) This Agreement runs with the land of which the Premises are a part, and shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. (i) This Agreement may be executed in counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original and all of which together shall constitute one instrument. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have entered into this Agreement as of the day and year first above written. LANDLORD: [Landlord Name] By: Print Name: Title: TENANT: Md7 Capital Three, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Print Name: Title: T-MOBILE SUBTENANT: [Tenant/Carrier name] By: Print Name: Title: CCPacket05272010 Page 65 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC LANDLORD ACKNOWLEDGEMENT STATE OF ) COUNTY OF ) On __________________________________, 20________ before me, [print name of notarial officer here:] ______________________________________________________, Notary Public personally appeared [print name of person whose signature is being acknowledged here:] proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his authorized capacity, and that by his signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature __________________________________ (Seal) My commission expires: TENANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss: COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO ) On _____________________, 20______, before me, __________________________________, a Notary Public, personally appeared , who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his authorized capacity, and that by his signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature: ____________________________________ My commission expires: (Seal) CCPacket05272010 Page 66 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC T-MOBILE SUBTENANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT STATE OF ) COUNTY OF ) On __________________________________, 20________ before me, [print name of notarial officer here:] ______________________________________________________, Notary Public personally appeared [print name of person whose signature is being acknowledged here:] proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his authorized capacity, and that by his signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature __________________________________ (Seal) My commission expires: CCPacket05272010 Page 67 of 89 [Lease ID] MT-2 RA DO NOT DUPLICATE – PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL TO Md7, LLC EXHIBIT A PREMISES DESCRIPTION AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY Street Address: [insert] (Parcel ID Type): [insert] Legal Description: That certain communications facility site (and access and utility easements) on a portion of the real property described as follows: [copy/paste from deed/lease/title report] CCPacket05272010 Page 68 of 89 AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND AND THE GEORGIA MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION, INC. FOR NEGOTIATION OF GROUND LEASE BETWEEN THE CITY AND T-MOBILE WHEREAS, the City of Tybee Island (“City”) has been approached by an agent of a current lessee requesting renegotiation of the terms and conditions of a lease with __________ for attaching cellular equipment to city owned property; WHEREAS, the Georgia Municipal Association (“GMA”) has available a telecommunications management service; and, WHEREAS, the City has a need for such telecommunications management services. THEREFORE, THE CITY AND GMA AGREE AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Services Provided to the City of Tybee Island GMA agrees to provide, either directly or through its agents or subcontractors, the following consulting services, which are not considered legal services. a) Cellular Tower and PCS Tower Site Consultation Services, as more fully described in Section 2 of this agreement; Section 2. Cellular and PCS Tower Site Consultation Services Cellular and PCS and Tower Site Consultation Services shall include: a) Advising Cities on the provisions of tower site agreements for the use of public land. b) Informing Cities concerning federal policies related to siting of wireless technologies. c) Negotiating an agreement between the City and _______ (“Company”) for the use of the city’s property by the Company to erect a tower and antenna for the purposes of providing wireless communications services. Section 3. Effective Date, Renewal and Termination. a) This agreement shall become effective upon the signature by the parties b) This Agreement shall terminate absolutely and without further obligation on the part of the City at the close of the Calendar year in which it was executed and at the close of each succeeding Calendar year. c) Both the City and GMA shall have the right to terminate this agreement by giving written notice of such termination to the other party and specifying the effective date thereof. GMA shall be entitled to payment for services rendered to the City. CCPacket05272010 Page 69 of 89 2 Section 4. Compensation The City agrees to pay GMA the amount of $3,000 for professional fees plus any travel costs. For services described herein, payment shall be made to GMA within 30 days of receipt of the invoice by the City. The GMA invoice will be submitted as follows: 50 percent of total cost --upon execution of the contract. 50 percent of total cost -- upon acceptance of the final agreement between the City and Company or completion of the project if the Company elects not to execute enter into a modified lease agreement. Section 5. Hold Harmless and Indemnification. To the extent permitted by Georgia law, each party shall bear the responsibility for liability for negligence, errors or omissions of its own officers, agents, employees or subcontractors in carrying out this agreement. To the extent permitted by Georgia law, the City holds harmless GMA for liability for the negligence of the City, its officers, agents, employees, or subcontractors arising out of this agreement. GMA holds harmless the City for the negligence of GMA, its officers, agents, employees, or subcontractors arising out of this agreement. In addition, the City designates GMA, its officers, agents, employees, and contractors as agents of the City for purposes of Section 635A of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, and the applicable provisions of the Local Government Antitrust Act of 1984. Section 6. Amendments. This contract may be amended by future written agreements executed on behalf of the City and GMA. Section7. Law Applicable. This agreement shall be construed under the laws of the State of Georgia. EXECUTED ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF ____________ THIS ____ DAY OF ____________, 2010. ATTEST: By____________________ City Clerk (SEAL) Mayor:___________________________ City of Tybee Island EXECUTED ON BEHALF OF THE GEORGIA MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION, INC. By_______________________________ Executive Director CCPacket05272010 Page 70 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 71 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 72 of 89 CCPacket05272010 Page 73 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 1 of 5 Better Hometown Board Meeting Minutes February 16, 2010 Directors Present: Cullen Chambers, Stephen Palmer, Monty Parks, Shirley Sessions, Patricia Miller Wann, John Yarbrough Directors Absent: Judy Malins, Peggy Stone Guests Present: Lindsey Fruchtl, Tybee Island Tourism Council Call to Order: The meeting was called to order at 9:06am. Approval of Minutes: John made a motion to approve the January 19, 2010 Board of Directors minutes. Monty seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous. Board of Directors Update Chantel introduced and welcomed new Board members Monty Parks with All Points Café and Stephen Palmer with Tybee Island Wedding, Inc. Erin Sheldon has moved and is no longer on the Board and therefore no longer Vice Chair. Cullen explained that the Vice Chair runs the Board Meetings in his absence. Monty agreed to take the Vice Chair position and the Board Members approved of this appointment. The Promotions Liaison position is vacant due to Maureen no longer serving on the Board of Directors. Stephen Palmer agreed to be the Promotions Liaison and the Board Members approved this appointment. Chantel said that Peggy Stone is trying to work out her work schedule so that she can attend Board Meetings. Community Visit Darien was the third site visit to see how other Better Hometown communities approach the program. On January 27, Patricia, Cullen, Councilman Bill Garbett, and Chantel met with Frank Fields, Darien’s Director of Community Development. Frank is the Executive Director for the Downtown Development Authority and is in charge of their Historic nonprofit. Darien has designed long term plans and has put a great deal of emphasis on streetscape projects, including boat ramps. A few businesses left downtown and moved to the outlet mall where the Chamber of Commerce is located. There has been some conflict between the Chamber and Downtown. The different groups Frank heads up work in tandem and are now working for façade improvements and on a nature trail and kayak ramps. It is hoped that the nature trail and kayak ramps will pull in more eco-tourists. Frank said they are trying to bridge the differences with the Chamber of Commerce. Cullen noted that the Darien Better Hometown is having a disconnect with the State Historic Preservation group in Atlanta. They have a significant historic building that is falling into ruin. The owner is asking $3 M for the site and it will need a lot of money for restoration. Cullen said it was “demolition by neglect.” CCPacket05272010 Page 74 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 2 of 5 Shirley asked if Frank was working with other entities. Cullen said the group appears to be working well with other groups and seems stable, but he believes that work can be more effective. Cullen also cautioned us in regards to the Darien Chamber leaving downtown. He said we need to be careful and avoid groups parallel duplication of efforts because that can lead to a breakaway among groups instead of working together as evidenced by the divide between the Darien Better Hometown program and the Darien Chamber of Commerce. Main Street Conference The Main Street Conference is March 17 – 19 and 1/3 of the Board must attend. Last year the DCA made an exception for Tybee, but only two out of the three Board Members attended. It was a real setback for Tybee. Stephen has it on his calendar and doesn’t know if he will be staying or driving daily. It is a two hour drive and Stephen offered to drive. Cullen said he will be at the Conference, but not staying overnight. Patricia said she would be going. Patricia expressed a desire to drive back to Tybee on Thursday afternoon for the Third Thursday on Tybee concert. She said she would drive back to St. Mary’s Friday morning for the completion of the Conference. Shirley can go the first day to show the support of Tybee’s City Government. Stephen said we have three days to represent Tybee at the Conference. Lindsey offered to have the Tybee Island Tourism Council help with the set up of the Third Thursday Concert if necessary. John said he will be at the Conference if his business is covered. Cullen asked everyone to please let Chantel know as soon as possible about attending the Conference. Chantel said that it is $100 per person for the Conference. Shirley reiterated that she would attend on Wednesday, but said she would have to be in Savannah on the other days because this is the busiest time for out of state college students who come to work. Cullen said that we have to get over this hurdle. Committee Updates Design – Cullen / Chantel February 4 Committee Meeting update: Parking – Chantel said she has laminated the Parking Paradigm in Paradise information and is distributing to lodging establishments with lobbies. The information was emailed out so companies can post the information on their websites. Cullen said that the accommodations industry has a responsibility in getting this information to their guests. Complaints come from the accommodation industry about their guests getting parking tickets, but it is the responsibility of the hotels and rental property managers to get the word out. Cullen said that Chantel has filled a lot of the “information holes.” Chantel said that every community has parking issues and everyone has to work together. Cullen said that we need to be on the same page and finally we are seeing people working together. He said Councilwoman Wanda Doyle advocates a Parking Committee and noted that this issue has been going on forever. Shirley said that since 2005, over 100 spots have been added for parking, but asked how many have been added since we started meeting. Shirley said that the City is trying to encourage people who want to have people park in their yard. Cullen said that the committee has discussed increasing the fines for people parking in non-designated places. He said renting or purchasing land has also been discussed. We have a core group of dedicated people trying to resolve issues. Cullen said we also need to protect our residents as well as our businesses regarding quality of life. Stephen wanted to know if there is anything in the works for the north end of Butler. Cullen said we are looking at rental/lease possibilities and identifying problem zones. Stephen said that with the Chapel going in parking is needed. CCPacket05272010 Page 75 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 3 of 5 Trash receptacles – Shirley said that people want to hear back on the trashcan and restroom issues. She said we need to keep the public abreast, particularly those heading up the Business Alliance group, of what progress is being made. Chantel spoke at the last Business Alliance meeting and tries to cover this information in the columns she writes. We need to continue making efforts that produce results instead of producing rhetoric. Chantel said she thought we needed to have a public forum. Shirley said we should have media present at the public forum. Cullen said his is working with a local business that is willing to reproduce the trashcans at a lower price. Chantel will resend him the specs. We have received funding for five additional trashcans. Chantel said that we need to spread the cans out more and check on the status of the other cans that had to be returned. Cullen said that we have slides taken in 1994 that show what the area used to look like. John said that back then it was called “the combat zone.“ Chantel has sent Michael Bodine historic photos in hopes that they can rotate on the City’s homepage. She has added pictures to the BHT Initiative webpage. He suggested that we need a motto to reiterate keep the beaches clean and to also include it on trashcans. Cullen said we should use stencils rather than stickers. Stephen suggested “Keep Tybee Tidy.” Smoke out Art -- Councilman Bill Garbett has come up with a Tybee idea to paint the “butts” container like a cigarette. His idea is that it will draw more attention and encourage more use that the black container. It will be more fun and hopefully people will use it more. Cullen asked if we are planning another “clean-up.“ Chantel said Beautification wants to do some pruning for the plants that look dead so they come back nicely this season. She said that TBA wants to get more involved. Cullen noted that some real progress has been made. Door Cover at Tybrisa/Butler -- There is a meeting with Alan Jones to talk about doing it. The Permit is approved and there is a list of materials for DPW to pick up. Shirley asked why DPW was not doing the work. Chantel confirmed they have other projects they are working on. Stephen asked about signage and advertising space. Chantel said we have talked about a kiosk. We need to look at the budget. We could put parking information there. Stephen said that a designated meeting place is a place people could meet and exchange information. Cullen asked if there were any updates on alleyways. John said that there was an update on the Strand. They are looking at re-painting. There is a meeting with the GA Trust Historic Preservation regarding traffic calming on North end and crosswalks, landscaping and traffic flow. Jonathon will be giving a report. Once GTHP gets the specs they can design something. The Sea & Breeze Hotel façade was discussed. Mel & Natalie are now managing the motel and want to change the look. The design team is coming up with ideas for them. Cullen said the Sea & Breeze is no easy fix. It has bad signage. They have come up with some quick fixes, but the building has been a problem building for a long time. Chantel said that hopefully, they will come up with some new ideas sooner rather than later. Christy’s wants to replace their rooftop and GTHP is working on a concept for them. Community Garden -- If the group wants this to be a BHT project, they need to bring it before the Board. They are having a meeting today at 6:30pm. CCPacket05272010 Page 76 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 4 of 5 Economic Restructuring – Judy / Chantel Chantel gave the Committee update in Judy’s absence. The Tybee Business 411 (Resources) Guide has gone to Department Heads for approval. This guide is an overview to help existing businesses and new businesses with effectiveness and efficiency when operating a business on Tybee. The brochure was passed around for board review. Organization – John / Chantel Newsletters – Chantel asked the board for direction on listing events on the BHT Newsletter. Many are asking for their events to be listed under the Happenings section. If they are non-profit she directs them to the City Calendar where items can be posted for free. Cullen said we don’t need to include special events that have not gone through the application process. Patricia said that she didn’t think Chantel needed to add to her already heavy work load. Stephen said that there are many places for listings, like Facebook. Cullen said that Michael provides this service for the City. He said that since the BHT is still in its infancy we need to keep pursuing clarification. We do not need to replicate a service already being provided by the City. We can refine our efforts as we move along. We need to stay on Mission. Shirley said we can’t be all things to all people. Promotions – Chantel 1. Island Wide Sidewalk Sale follow-up -- It rained the day of the Sidewalk Sale. Some people said it was great. It was the last one for the year. 2. Susan Kelleher has done a Shop & Stroll which involved putting coconuts in stores and prize drawings near her store at the end of the day. She wants BHT to take over the event in April & December. Monty said we do not need a bar/alcohol event. Stephen said that someone should sit down with Susan and then meet with us later. Cullen said that we will grow as an organization. Chantel has been pulled in many different directions by individual requests. There has to be a benefit to the Island as a whole, not just to individuals. 3. Chantel said that the City is working to become more bike friendly. Perhaps businesses want to offer something during “Bike to Work Week.” The City is working to pave the Memorial Park bike trail. We need more bike racks on the Northend. Cullen asked if we could get the City to fund it. Stephen said that we need better bike racks at the Lighthouse. Cullen asked what we can do to urge the City to buy more. Chantel said that the Design Committee should be involved. Stephen said this is a way to alleviate some of the parking problems. Cullen suggested that we identify potential locations for bike racks in other areas. Stephen said parking lots and beach crossovers. Cullen said encouraging biking will help with parking problems. We need to be more bike friendly. Stephen said we need more signage. There is a safety problem. Cullen said that we need Stephen to participate in planning. 4. Third Thursdays on Tybee – Patricia commented that the second Third Thurdays on Tybee with Lauren LaPointe at Tybee Oaks was wonderful. Once again, the demographics were diverse and we are looking forward to April 15 with Lacey. 5. Seafood Festival update -- There is a meeting today at 2pm at City Hall. Sandy Major made a presentation to the Board about a Festival. Chatham County is moving forward with this event. Lindsey said that Tourism is waiting to see how this pans out. John said that last week they said there were 12 restaurants committed. Chantel said that she is helping facilitate the meetings. Cullen said that he wanted to see more planning, advertising, etc. CCPacket05272010 Page 77 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 5 of 5 Monty said this is a vendor driven event and that it is refreshing that the businesses are taking ownership. This is a first no charge event. John said there would be more information at the second meeting. He said that what Dean has done in a short time is impressive. Shirley said she really wants to see it work and Chatham County take ownership of it. It is a great idea, but promotion is critical. Monty said the cost of getting involved with Pirate Fest is high and he said if only 20 people come, I’ll make more money with this than with Pirate Fest. Lindsey said that Tourism is supportive, but that things were on the calendar months before this came up. Cullen said this whole thing really came about because of the fake seafood festival in the movie. John said that Coke is really involved. 6. Tybee for the Holidays – We are working to get control of the web domain name and the site updated. Other Business Chantel asked the Board members to add new information to our binders. Stephen thinks BHT Board Members, Tourism and City Council ought to take one day and go out and talk to businesses. He also said we should do a beach walk and talk to people and also talk to residents. Chantel said that was a great idea. She hears from businesses and residents on a daily basis and it is important for others to understand. People are not used to being approached and asked for their ideas. Cullen said he loved that approach. It is about the three legs of our stool -- business, visitors & residents. We may need a survey form. Lindsey asked if we could tape people. Shirley said that some weekends are a different configuration of people. Adjourn Patricia made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 10:30am. Monty seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous. CCPacket05272010 Page 78 of 89 Approved: 4/21/10 Page 1 of 4 Better Hometown Board Meeting Minutes March 16, 2010 Directors Present: Cullen Chambers, Judy, Malins, Stephen Palmer, Shirley Sessions, Patricia Miller Wann, John Yarbrough Directors Absent: Monty Parks, Dick Smith, Peggy Stone, John Yarbrough Guests Present: See below. Call to Order: The meeting was called to order at 9:08am. Welcome Chantel welcomed everyone and reminded everyone about the upcoming Conference in St. Marys. Shirley will ride with Patricia and Stephen will pick up Cullen. Chantel will meet everyone in St. Marys. We need to leave at 5:30am in order to arrive for registration. Chantel explained meeting time conflicts have been expressed by Monty and Peggy due to their careers. Cullen asked if the Board meetings should change to the early evenings. Meeting either on Tuesdays or Wednesdays at 6pm was suggested. Chantel will email the board for input. Dicky Trotter, Trotter Productions Dicky Trotter was scheduled to attend the Board meeting as a guest, but is under the weather and unable to attend. He is very supportive of the Better Hometown Initiative and wants to talk about membership and other ways to get the word out about BHT, specifically through social media. Public Forum / Visioning Workshop Preparation The next Visioning Workshop is scheduled for April 7th from 5 - 7pm in the Auditorium. This workshop is required annually so the Board can determine what BHT will work on within the coming year with regards to the 4 Points. The last workshop was July 27, 2009 and was attended by more than 30 people. DCA was pleased at the turnout. We will lay out what has been worked on and accomplished over the previous year. Cullen said that a lot has been worked on and highlighting these items is crucial and we need to be really prepared. Patricia suggested that we have a rehearsal before the Workshop. Cullen said that we need to have forward movement beyond talking about issues. It was decided that we would have a rehearsal on April 7 and the Workshop will be on the 14 from 5-6pm with a Board workshop from 6-7pm. Cullen said that the number of meetings on Tybee is a big concern. He said that people don’t mind going to meetings if they see outcomes. Everyone’s time is valuable and BHT doesn’t want to waste anyone’s time. Questions need to be anticipated for accurate and meaningful answers. He asked Shirley if anything is going to be done about the restrooms in the foreseeable future. Shirley said that it depends on the SPLOST funding and that she didn’t know if anything could be done soon. CCPacket05272010 Page 79 of 89 Approved: 4/21/10 Page 2 of 4 Restrooms have been an important issue expressed by some businesses and answers need to be given. Chantel mentioned a resident has been in constant contact with the City Manager about issues with the visibility of the South End portable restrooms from his home. Alternate locations have been considered, but the infrastructure is only there. DPW is putting in foliage to block the view. Shirley said that people don’t want the bathrooms in their backyards. Shirley understands the importance of answers and will find out about the bathrooms on the North end. Cullen commented that it is a staffing issue within the City and we keep taking a hit on it. He asked if we have a number posted in the bathrooms is there a person who will respond. Shirley volunteered to be the “bathroom person.” We need to assure people that the bathrooms are on a cleaning schedule with a cleaning schedule posted that is signed off with a phone number to call if they are not clean. Cullen said someone is needed at each bathroom and calls need to be answered. Shirley said we certainly need someone at the Marine Science Center. Chantel added that there is a need at 14th Street too. Stephen asked about the three portable bathrooms at 17th and 18th. Shirley said she would find out if they are rented. Stephen mentioned the bathrooms at the Pavilion and said that Dean takes care of them. Chantel said that Dean is responsible and when the bathrooms are cleaned, they have to be closed for 45 minutes for the floors to dry. Shirley said that people are changing clothes and bathing in those bathrooms and that Dean does a good job. Cullen asked if there was a company that could be hired. Judy said that there are companies that do this. She said she thought it was critical to have a person who was responsible. Cullen asked if the City had looked into that. Shirley said not to her knowledge. She said that the City is looking for a part time attendant, but doesn’t know if the City can afford it. Council knows that this is important. DPW is stressed during the high season and they have problems getting the equipment through the crowds on the beach. Stephen commented that the middle of the Island is also a problem. Memorial Park and Jaycee Park have been improved with SPLOST money. He said the North Beach parking lot is a huge issue. Cullen said that there are FEMA requirements and that the city receives money for beach renourishment, but nothing goes to bathroom maintenance. Shirley asked if we could get a business to sponsor a bathroom. Cullen responded that if he knew the costs, he could look into it and see if the Historical Society might be able to do that. There should be one contact person for bathrooms and one person for trash. Chantel said that Wind Rose has noticed issues with the Atlantic Ave. compactor and has called DPW in the past without response. Wind Rose owners are very diligent in calling her when they see problems and she documents it and lets the City Manager know. Chantel said that we need a phone number on the dumpsters too. Cullen said that we have to have actual follow-up. Shirley said that some people just seem to be destructive. Chantel said that she had sent Diane several e-mails. She said that last season a gentleman was paid to pick up trash on the South End, but didn’t carry a bag to put it in. She is asking if we will have a person this season and if he will have bags. She said she has sent about five e-mails and is waiting for responses. Stephen asked about the 14th Street crossover. He mentioned “Tim’s Beachgear” and said that a big trailer is parked in front of Ocean Plaza. He asked if that was a rented spot. Chantel said that similar issues have come up at the Parking Committee meetings and Jonathon and Diane are CCPacket05272010 Page 80 of 89 Approved: 4/21/10 Page 3 of 4 working on a parking plan. Patricia asked if we could get “before” and “after” pictures to use at the Workshop. Chantel said she had done that with previous presentations. Shirley said that visuals are important. Shirley said that too much detail can be overwhelming. We need to keep it simple. Stephen said that we need to be prepared for anything. He suggested that we brainstorm while we are driving back and forth to St. Marys. Chantel said she would e-mail the work plan to the Board again. Stephen said we could use it to show results since the last Workshop. Cullen said that is what we are talking about. Chantel said there are tangible things we can show. Shirley said that we can show what we have accomplished and have handouts for people. Chantel said that we need to reiterate that these are big issues that the Island has been working on for years and years. She reminded everyone to note April 7 is the rehearsal and April 14 from 5-6pm is the Workshop with a Board meeting from 6-7pm. Stephen said that we can give the audience information and an open floor and that will help residents and businesses get more involved. Design - Cullen Discussions were held within Visioning Workshop presentation discussion. Promotions - Stephen / Chantel Tybee for the Holidays – Stephen updated the Board about the last Committee meeting. He suggested that everything take place on one weekend. He said we need to look at what is disposable. We need a backup plan and know what is important. He suggested that we have Santa Claus and lose the parade if necessary. Keep it all one weekend and have a better tree and better decorations. Cullen said that one packed weekend would be better and could become a signature event. Stephen said that we could have the “WOW” factor by syncing the music and lights. Patricia said the lights could look a lot better. She said that half the lights were out. Chantel said that they had been purchased “used” and that there were different stories about whether that was the problem or if there was a problem with the electric poles. She said we need to make sure that the Christmas tree remains lit throughout the month. One suggestion made at the committee meeting is to have kids come out and help businesses decorate on “Decorating Day” the Saturday after Thanksgiving. She said that TBA has been judging commercial decorations and has asked BHT to get more involved. Cullen asked if the lights had outlived their lifespan. Chantel said that some have. Cullen asked if we had to have them. He suggested that we rethink the decorations and do something nice and simple. Chantel said that would have to go through DPW and that some neighborhood associations had purchased some of the lights. Stephen said he would love to have a snow machine. Chantel commented that the past two years there have been small snow machines which John at Spanky’s paid to rent. Third Thursdays on Tybee – Patricia said that the first concert had been very successful. She reminded everyone that Lauren Lapointe would be singing at the second concert at Tybee Oaks. Stephen said that we should to be prepared for questions because the first concert was held inside the rain location even though the sun was shining. Patricia and Chantel confirmed the Trio had to perform inside due to the low temperature and alternate locations are listed on the posters. Stephen said that “Bike to Work Week” is May 10 – 14 and will be promoted. CCPacket05272010 Page 81 of 89 Approved: 4/21/10 Page 4 of 4 Economic Restructuring Committee - Chantel Connie with SBDC has agreed to present a “Keeping Your Customers” seminar in the Auditorium on March 24 at 8:30am for Island businesses. She said that about ten people had already signed up. We are paying $150 for the seminar and hope to have a good turnout. BHT Budget Chantel said that each City Department had been asked to cut 10%. She said that she has taken out various subscriptions and bumped up Business Training and Opportunities. She said that without contributions, the program will not be a success. This is a show of the public partnership. Cullen said that the BHT Budget was already bare bones and that we cannot afford to keep taking hits from the City. He said the City can’t keep cutting the budget. Shirley said that she thought that the majority of Council will support the Program. Cullen mentioned the Façade Grant and said that with economic situation, this is not the time. He said that there is no more room for grants and that does not think we needed to spend money on a Market Study. Other Business Discussion continued among board members about trash issues, restroom clean up, and code enforcement. Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 11:05. CCPacket05272010 Page 82 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 1 of 2 Better Hometown Board Meeting Minutes April 21, 2010 Directors Present: Cullen Chambers, Stephen Palmer, Dick Smith, Peggy Stone Directors Absent: Judy Malins, Patricia Miller Wann, Monty Parks, Shirley Sessions, John Yarbrough Guests Present: Bill Garbett Call to Order: The meeting was called to order at 6:00pm. Welcome Chantel welcomed everyone. Approval of Minutes Stephen motioned to approve the March 16 minutes. Patricia gave Chantel her verbal approval prior to the meeting which is the second to Stephen’s motion. The vote was unanimous. Approval of the February minutes will take place at the April Board of Directors meeting. Visioning Workshop Review Attendees felt the workshop was well attended. Information provided is being used to update the Committee’s work plans. Cullen opened discussion regarding trash and the shift of resources. Peggy suggested that the sidewalk trash containers have an extra pickup during the day. The sidewalk trash containers fill up by 3pm and when the evening crowd comes in there is nowhere for them to put their trash except on the ground. Chantel reported that DPW is interviewing for a position that would be responsible for picking up trash along the downtown area during the summer. Suggestions were made that this individual have a push cart so the employee could also empty the trash containers efficiently during their shift. Attendees agree that there needs to be more pickup, more enforcement, Police foot patrol, and prioritizing staff is necessary. Peggy feels that the litter issue can be resolved with foot patrol and enforcement. Dick said this has been an ongoing issue for years. Residents and businesses take responsibility and visitors need to be aware they need to not litter. Cullen has written a letter addressing the concerns for code enforcement to the City Manager. Board members have given their approval for Cullen to forward to the City Manager. Stephen Palmer will follow up on getting the amount of citations issued as requested in the letter. The City needs to be committed to helping with these issues and address them immediately. The possibility of have community service workers pick up trash was discussed, but Cullen pointed out that they need too much supervision. CCPacket05272010 Page 83 of 89 Approved: 5/19/10 Page 2 of 2 Work Plan Determination Design - Cullen Chantel emailed the strengths and challenges that were voiced at the Visioning Workshop and the survey feedback she received. Cullen explained he has not seen the notes. Chantel will resend the information. In the meantime, items regarding the need to combat litter and strengthen code enforcement will continue. Parking issues throughout the island are being worked on by the officially formed City Parking Committee. Better Hometown will work to make sure businesses are kept abreast of decisions and or changes that affect them. During the high season, businesses are affected by parking all day and residents are affected by overflow parking in their neighborhoods. The residents’ quality of life must be taken into consideration. There is overflow parking available in the North Beach Parking lot and it needs to be defined. Economic Restructuring – Judy Will be reviewed at a later meeting. Promotions - Stephen Third Thursdays on Tybee has received a tremendous response and the desire to continue the outdoor music was voiced at the Visioning. Chantel explained that Third Thursdays will continue per the request of attendees and the City. The continuation of Tybee for the Holidays, which helps during the off season, is underway by the Promotions Committee. Stephen explained that he sees a need to brand Tybee versus having more events. He described a Tybee Tree which would promote all that Tybee has to offer for living, business and vacations. The branches would represent all aspects such as stores, restaurants, services, outdoor activities, etc. The tree would show that there is something for everybody. More children activities need to be developed BHT Budget Discussion about the BHT budget ensued. Chantel and Cullen have reviewed the budget and cut where we could as requested by the City. There are items that are needed that are not in the budget. Cullen and Chantel will continue to work on this so the program can continue to grow and succeed. Other Business Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 7:35pm. CCPacket05272010 Page 84 of 89 812803-01 Tybee Island Marine Science Center Board of Directors Meeting December 15, 2009 Present: Cathy, Debbie, Shelly, Elizabeth, John, Mike, Judy, Kathryn, Julie, Maria, Dione, Meredith 1. Call to order - 6:15 2. Approval of Agenda Motion to approve - Cathy Second - Shelly Unanimously approved 3. Approval of Minutes Motion to approve - Cathy Second - Shelly Unanimously approved 4. President’s Report a. Virginia Aquarium Visit - Monday, February 8 - all going to Virginia, will post travel plans on blog by Monday, January 4 b. Dicky Mopper is joining Board 5. Treasurer’s Report - Board is aware that Foundation will likely have to take money from account to cover deficit at year end 6. Executive Director's Report a. Maria is working with DNR on Coastal Incentive Grant for an educational program with public schools - Maria is meeting with Mayor tomorrow (12/16) regarding partnership with City (water quality component) - looking into partnering with 4 public schools - would be 2 year grant beginning October 2010 - goal of creating pilot program for city to fund after grant term expires - Maria will meet with school officials on Friday 7. Development Committee a. Met with Dan Roberts - project manager offering services for free - would be volunteer - recommendation of Development Committee to bring him on board as volunteer project manager for new facility (exact role TBD at later date- Board agreed that it is critical to define his role)) Debbie made motion to extend offer to Dan Roberts Second - Shelly All in favor. b. Debbie met with Martin Melaver - he gave name of Michael Singer for green design used by Melaver - he said he would be willing to lead a workshop for board regarding sustainability of building in mid-January (TBD) c. Jeff Jowdy - scheduling meeting with Development Committee Next Board meeting – Wednesday, January 27 CCPacket05272010 Page 85 of 89 812803-01 2 Next Executive Committee meeting – Thursday, January 7 Adjournment – 7:00 p.m. Action Items 1. Dionne will look into hotels for Virginia trip. 2. Maria will look into weblog posting notifications. 3. Maria will look into TAC Education subcommittee as potential source of funding for education project. 4. Maria will send out guidelines (RFP) for CIG proposal to Cathy for review. 5. Debbie will schedule Melaver workshop for mid-January. CCPacket05272010 Page 86 of 89 Tybee Island Marine Science Center Board of Directors Meeting January 27, 2010 Present: Mike, Maria, John, Julie, Elizabeth, Shelly, Debbie, Judy, Kathryn, Meredith 1. Call to order - 7:10 2. Approval of December Minutes Motion to approve - Shelly Second - Kathryn Unanimously approved 3. President’s Report (Dionne not here; Mike filling in as President) a. Virginia Aquarium Visit - any questions or comments for those not going? - Mike would like some history of transition to bigger center - Shelly wants copy of current operational budget - how do they do membership/sponsorships - how big is board and how many did they bring on for project - Board voiced concern that Dionne would not be able to go anymore - if Dionne still wants to go, Elizabeth and John (and maybe Debbie) are still willing to go - please email additional comments or questions for team going to Virginia; John will compile prior to trip 4. Executive Director's Report a. Gallery - update going well - Sea Turtle tank delivered and platform here - Chris and staff have been fantastic - Home Depot has been very helpful - DPW, COT and DNR very enthusiastic - only behind schedule 1 week approximately - Georgia Aquarium will provide jellyfish but can no longer donate tank. Maria is looking into tank prices and Board is discussing small grant options for this need (approximately $4,000). Maria is preparing proposal - Discussion of how to get word about gallery out - Membership and VIP - viewing before release to public - postcards - magazine and newspaper article(s) b. CIG Grants - should hear results mid-April 5. Treasurer’s Report - will be below budget once CIG $ comes in - income up $11,000 from budget - expenses down $15,000 from budget - Board requested designation on financials for money spent on NB Facility - Maria will ask Dean about language of cover letter - 2 record months in gift shop - $100,000 + annually for 2009 - 31,000 + visitors to center in 2009 CCPacket05272010 Page 87 of 89 842162-1 6. Frank Shuman and Kathryn - Council Liaisons to Board - Paul no longer officially liaison - Board hopes he will remain very connected - Should add Frank to emails and will keep Paul on 7. Development Committee a. Working on interviewing potential project team - 10:00, February 13 - meeting with Dan Roberts - all are invited (location TBA) - Met with Martin Melaver - Met with Robin Gold (fundraising) (was recommended by Marjorie Young) - Meeting with another consultant this week - Still looking into fundraisers with capital campaign experience b. SPLOST Meredith and Kathryn will work on finding out: 1. What can funds be used for? 2. When do funds expire? c. Sea Kayak GA has indicated they might not participate in Sea Kayak race this year Date: June 12, 2010 Debbie will have sponsor request forms at February meeting 8. Marketing Committee Sustainable Seafood Festival - Focus on education/nutrition/ecosystem/environment - City of Savannah/Chatham County taking on 2010 Seafood Festival but might be willing to partner with us - need a board member on City's planning committee for event - will be on pier in April (strange month because not shrimp season until end of May/June) - Shelly mentioned that Tina might be able to be our liaison on planning committee 9. Turtle Trot - April 24th - Save the Date 8:50 p.m. Motion to Adjorn - Shelly Second - Debbie Unanimously approved Action Items 1. Shelly will call Shantel with COTI to get seafood festival information. 2. Meredith and Kathryn will look into SPLOST restrictions. 3. Debbie will find new location for Dan Roberts February 13th meeting. 4. All: email comments/questions regarding Virginia aquarium to John, Dionne, Debbie and Elizabeth. CCPacket05272010 Page 88 of 89 848533-01 Tybee Island Marine Science Center Board of Directors Meeting March 24, 2010 Present: Maria, Debbie, Judy, Mike, Dionne, Cathy, Meredith 1. Call to order - 7:15 p.m. 2. Approval of Approve Agenda (with modifications) Motion to approve - Cathy Second - Judy Unanimously approved 3. Officer's Reports A. President’s Report Board Development Activity - 1) to demonstrate that there are things about the TIMSC that we don't know and/or don't do in practice; and 2) to brainstorm roles of Executive Director and Board will be continued at next meeting B. Executive Director's Report 1. Financials - want to keep lower inventory - schools are up; scouts are way up - salaries up because raises and health insurance additions - discovery shop sales down because of cold winter 2. Gallery - $1,500 from Optimist Club for jellyfish tank to be bought from Georgia Aquarium - presentation of Coastal Incentives Sea Turtle Conservation grant deliverables to Board - Maria presenting Sea Turtle Grant update to Council 3/25/10 4. Committee Reports 1. Development Committee reminder of committee assignments/designations emailed to Board on March 8 2. Marketing Flip Flop Fundraiser - Mike will man table; Meredith will speak and accept check on behalf of Center - discussion of issues surrounding event Next meeting: April 28 Executive Committee: TBD Adjournment - 9:30 p.m. Action Items 1. Dionne will type and distribute February minutes 2. All Board seek kayak race sponsors 3. All Board work on Development Committee assignments 4. Maria will send bullet points to Meredith prior to Flip Flop Fundraiser 5. Judy will find out power point capabilities for Flip Flop Fundraiser and contact Dionne CCPacket05272010 Page 89 of 89