HomeMy Public PortalAboutBox 512 - Memo from Eimers 7-25-98JULY 25, 1998
TO: BRIAN OLSON
FROM: KIRK EIMERS
SUBJECT: QUESTIONS IN PREPARATION FOR SPECIAL J-DITCH MEETING
CC: COUNCIL
BRIAN, COULD YOU PLEASE ADDRESS THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS FOR
DISCUSSION AT OUR UPCOMING J-DITCH SPECIAL MEETING. AS YOU KNOW WE
NEED T❑ MAKE THE DECISION AT THIS MEETING BASED ON TECHNICAL MERIT
RATHER THAN POLITICS SO THE MORE INFORMATION WE HAVE THE BETTER.
1. MR. SEUBERT MAINTAINS HIS ADDITIONAL WORK SOLVED THE WETLANDS
PROBLEM. IS THAT TRUE AND ACCURATE?
2. MR. SEUBERT MAINTAINS HIS ADDITIONAL WORK ALLOWS PLACEMENT ❑F
THE ASPHALT PLANT WITHIN AN ALREADY PERMITTED AREA WHICH WILL
REQUIRE NO ADDITIONAL P@Z CONSIDERATION. IS THAT TRUE AND
ACCURATE?
3. WHAT IS JUB'S GUARANTEED LEVEL OF ACCURACY RESPECTING THEIR
$6.8 MILLION ESTIMATE OF PROJECT COSTS ❑N SEUBERT?
4. CAN WE USE ❑N SITE MATERIALS TO CONSTRUCT ❑N THE SEUBERT SITE?
5. HOW MUCH ❑F THE SEUBERT SITE IS NEEDED, AND WHAT PORTION, FOR
THE CONNECTOR? CAN YOU ESTIMATE A COST?
6. WHAT TECHNICAL INDICATIONS DO WE HAVE THE BAZADAS GROUND WILL
WORK IN TERMS OF WATER TABLE, SUITABILITY OF ON SITE MATERIALS
FOR ABOVE GROUND WALLS, ETC.?
7. COULD YOU PLEASE FILL IN THE ATTACHED MATRIX WITH WHATEVER
STAFF AND TECHNICAL EXPERTS YOU MAY WISH T❑ EMPLOY AND DISCUSS
THOROUGHLY AT THE MEETING?
THANKS BRIAN.
,,(A,(.,-k,
KIRK L. EIMERS
DECISION MATRIX
ELEMENT SEUBERT BAZADAS OTHER
V.E. COST ESTIMATE ($ IN MILLIONS) $6.8 $6.2 $
COST CREEP POTENTIAL
TIME TO APPROVAL
RELATIVE COST
RELATIVE RISK --TECHNICAL
RELATIVE RISK --LEGAL
RELATIVE RISK --PUBLIC
PUBLIC PERCEPTION
UNKNOWNS
OVERALL RATING
WEIGH EACH ELEMENT, APPLY A RATING AND THEN SUMMARIZE