HomeMy Public PortalAbout08-27-1987 BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS AND SAFETY OF THE
CITY OF RICHMOND,INDIANA, AUGUST 27,1987
1 The Board of Public Works and Safety of the City of Richmond, Indiana, met in regular session August 27, 1987
2 at the hour of 9:00 A.M. in the Municipal Building in said City. Ms. Silberstein presided with Mr. Brown and Mr.
3 Willis in attendance. Absent: None. The following business was had to-wit:
4
5 RECEIVE BIDS FOR PAVING OF SOUTH G STREET EASTWARD TO DEADEND
• 6
7 Ms. Silberstein requested Proof of Publication of the paving of South G Street. Having examined the Proof of
8 Publication, the Board found it to be in order. Mr. Willis moved to accept and file the Proof of Publication,
9 seconded by Mr. Brown and on unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
10
11 Ms. Silberstein requested all bids be received. Having received all bids, Mr. Brown moved to close the bidding,
12 seconded by Mr.Willis and on unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
13
14 Purchasing Director, Rita Stout.informed the Board they would like to award the bid at this meeting if there were
15 no unusual circumstances involved and Ms. Silberstein stated the item could be left open on the agenda for later
16 action. The following bids were received:
17
18 1. Stone Valley Paving. The bid was on the proper form, signed, notarized and accompanied by a bid
19 bond. The total bid was in the amount of 46,240.69.
20
21 2. Contractors United, Inc. The bid was on the proper form, signed, notarized and accompanied by a
22 bid bond. The total bid was in the amount of 45,193.09.
23
24 Mr.Willis moved to refer the bids to the Purchasing Director and the Public Works Department for evaluation and
25 recommendation later in the meeting, seconded by Mr. Brown and on unanimous voice vote the motion was
26 carried.
27
28 UNSAFE BUILDING HEARING
111 29
30 414 North 18th Street
31
32 Ms. Silberstein delayed the Unsafe Building Hearing until the end of the Agenda due to the absence of Mr.
33 Bronston.
34
35 APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF AUGUST 13.1987
36
37 Mr. Brown moved to approve the minutes of the previous meeting as prepared, seconded by Mr. Willis and on
38 unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
39
40 APPROVAL OF CLAIMS FOR PAYMENT
41
42 Mr. Brown moved to approve claims for payment in the amount of 600,070.24 seconded by Mr. Willis and on
43 unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
44
45 PUBLIC REQUESTS AND COMMENTS
46
47 Residential Handicapped Parking Request
48
49 1720 North B Street
50
51 The request of Karen Boyd of 1720 North B Street for a residential handicapped parking space was presented to
52 the Board. Ms. Boyd has Permit No.55777 with an expiration date of August, 1991.
53
54 Captain Williams stated the request meets the guidelines.
55
56 Mr. Brown moved to approve the request for a residential handicapped parking space at 1720 North B Street,
57 seconded by Mr.Willis and on unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
58
59 DEPARTMENT REQUESTS AND COMMENTS
60
61 FIRE DEPARTMENT
62
63 Approval of Hiring of Probationary Firefighter-Robert Abner
64
65 The following memo was presented to the Board:
C'
Board of Works Minutes Cont'd
August 27 1987
Page 2
1 It is the recommendation of this office that Robert Abner be hired as a probationary firefighter effective
2 August 27, 1987. Robert has successfully completed the physical agility test as well as all medical and
3 psychological tests as required.
4
5 /s/ Don Atkins, Asst. Chief
6
7 Ms. Silberstein noted the Fire Pension Board has approved Mr.Abner.
8
9 Mr. Willis moved to approve the hiring of Robert Abner as a Probationary Firefighter, effective August 27, 1987,
10 seconded by Mr. Brown and on unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
11
12 Ms. Silberstein welcomed Mr. Abner to the Department and requested his indulgence until Mayor Waltermann
13 could be in attendance to administer the Oath.
14
15 LAW OFFICE
16
17 Revised Agreement between City and Township for Purchase of Fire Equipment
18
19 Mr. Barden explained that he has not yet received a signed copy of the revised agreement from the Township.
20 He said the agreement was only changed to allow for annual modification so as not to legally bind future
21 administrations of the City of Township and this was done per recommendation of the State Board of Accounts.
22
23 Mr. Barden suggested the Board tentatively approve the revised agreement subject to receiving a signed copy
24 from the Township.
25
26 Mr.Brown moved to approve the Agreement between the City and Wayne Township through its Township Trustee
27 as revised and to execute the revised agreement upon receipt of executed copy from the Township, seconded
28 by Mr.Willis and on unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
29
30 Sale of Property on NW 11th Street
31
32 Mr. Barden recommended to the Board that they award the sale to the lone bidder, Mr. Robert Lichtenfels, and
33 accept his offer of 100.00. Mr. Barden said that was probably the value of the property and it would only be of
34 value to an adjacent property owner such as Mr. Lichtenfels.
35
36 Mr. Barden requested the Board to accept the offer and to execute the Quit Claim Deed.
37
38 Ms. Silberstein commented that this was a very small parcel of land to sell, but there was still substantial work
39 involved in the sale on the part of city employees. She said she would like to see the cost of the preparation
40 recouped.
41
42 Mr. Barden stated there was not much preparation cost except the legal advertisements.
43
44 Ms. Silberstein stated there was also labor costs involved for surveying, etc and she would like to see those
45 costs payed up front.
46
47 Mr. Barden said they could possibly include administrative costs in the future.
48
49 Ms. Silberstein commented that in private sales, the purchaser pays preparation costs.
50
51 Mr. Brown moved to accept the offer of Mr. Robert Lichtenfels to purchase property on NW 11th and Indiana
52 Avenue in the amount of$100.00 and to execute the Quit Claim Deed.
53
54 Update on Reeveston Easements
55
56 Mr. Barden informed the Board they were in the process of wrapping up securing the utility easements in the
57 Reeveston Area and have set September 20, 1987 to close out the project. He said some of the residents of the
58 are need to take some initiative and get paper work back or get their questions answered.
59
60 Ms. Silberstein reminded the Board these are general utility easements, not just for the use of cable.
61 She added it was time the project was wrapped up and persons made up their minds.
62
63 ADMINISTER OATH TO ROBERT ABNER
64
65 Mayor Waltermann administered the Oath to Mr. Robert Abner to become a probationary firefighter. Mr.Abner
Board of Works Minutes Cont'd
August 27,1987
Page 3
1 was introduced to the Board and their congratulations were extended.
2
3 BOARD OF WORKS MISCELLANEOUS
4
5 Resolve to Fire Grievances No.4 and 5-1987
6
7 Ms. Silberstein read the following resolves to Grievances No. 4 and 5-1987 as filed by members of Firefighters
8 Local 1408, Inc.
9
10 Grievance No. 4-1987
11
12 The Board of Public Works and Safety received evidence and heard testimony concerning this
13 grievance on August 11, 1987.
14
15 The Board has determined that hiring procedures were initiated and have progressed in good faith in a
16 timely manner. Any delays experienced in completing the procedure have not been been intentional on
17 the art of the City but have be gn due to circumstances inherent in the selection process beyond that
18 City's control. The Board will not lower hiring standards or waive their application in order to meet
19 targeted hiring deadlines, which insure that the hiring process is promptly initiated and actively pursued
20 in good faith.
21
22 Mr. Brown moved to adopt and execute the Resolve to Grievance No. 4-1987, seconded by Mr. Willis and on
23 unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
24
25 Grievance No.5-1987
26
27 The Board of Public Works and Safety received evidence and heard testimony concerning this
28 grievance on August 11, 1987.
29
30 The Board has determined that the sole position of Training Officer should be filled by use of the
31 contractual promotion procedure. This position has been the subject of an evaluation process which
32 was conducted in the absence of an incumbent so that the position itself, rather than an incumbent,
33 would be the focus of the evaluation. This evaluation was undertaken in response to stated concern
34 regarding training programs and opportunities and their implementation on the Department.
35
36 The process has resulted in a revised position description which is to be distributed to interested
37 personnel upon request or upon bid. As part of the ongoing assessment of the need for and utilization f
38 the sole position of Training Officer, the Board will require daily logs to be submitted to the Chief and
39 forwarded to the Board listing the Training Officer's daily activities and time spent on each activity.
40 This log is to be kept and submitted for an initial period of three months, after which a re-evaluation of
41 this requirement will be made by the Chief,the Board and the incumbent.
42
43 Mr. Willis moved to adopt and execute the Resolve to Grievance No. 5-1987, seconded by Mr. Brown and on
44 unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
45
46 Termination of Parking Lot Lease-West End Federal Savings Bank
47
48 Off Street Parking Manager, Mary Merchanthouse reported to the Board that the preliminary plans have been
49 completed for the redesign of the parking lot south of the Elder Beerman store to allow West End to proceed with
50 the termination of the lease with the City of Richmond for a portion of the lot. She said plans include the closing
51 of the curb cut onto the service drive and to make a single entrance and exit on 6th Street to make ingress and
52 egress safer. Ms. Merchanthouse stated that construction would be starting around the middle of September
53 and will be completed by the end of October.
54
55 Ms. Silberstein asked if there were more considerations that should be included in the response to West End and
56 it was decided that the final date for completion would be November 30,1987 and a prorating of fees paid on the
57 lease should be included.
58
59 UNSAFE BUILDING HEARING
60
61 414 North 18th Street
62
63 Ms. Silberstein opened an Unsafe Building Hearing on property located at 414 North 18th Street pursuant to an
64 Order issued on July 29, 1987 to Hudson's Inc. of 412 South 4th Street, Richmond, Indiana. The Order stated
65 the following action would be accomplished within thirty days of receipt of the Order: (1) Securing of unsafe
Board of Works Minutes Cont'd
August 27, 1987
Page 4
1 building within ten days and (2) repair of unsafe building within 30 days.
2
3 Ms. Silberstein requested Proof of Notification of the Hearing and was presented a signed return receipt and a
4 Publisher's Claim for a legal advertisement.
5
6 The Clerk administered the Oath to give testimony to Mr.Dennis Bronston, Code Enforcement Officer.
7
8 Mr. Bronston informed the Board that the building was a two story frame structure , unsecured,a rear stairway in
9 need of repair, interior vandalized and a lack of maintenance. He said the electrical system also needs updated,
10 the plumbing is ripped from the walls and there is an open cistern at the rear of the property along with a weed
11 problem.
12
13 Mr. Bronston showed pictures of the premises to the Board.
14
15 Mr. Bronston stated he has contacted Hudson, Inc. to get the property secured and also talked wit the First
16 National Bank. He said neither party currently claims ownership and there is a hearing set for September 3, 1987
17 regarding mortgage foreclosures on Hudson, Inc. Mr. Bronston added that the nearness to the adjacent
18 property leaves a threat to that property if it remains unsecured.
19
20 Mr.Willis asked how long it has been vacant and Mr. Bronston stated at least one year.
21
22 Ms. Silberstein commented that there is a danger of arson and further vandalism if the building remains
23 unsecured.
24
25 Mr. Brown asked where the Board stood in the court proceedings and Mr. Barden said he was not inclined to
26 delay the proceedings with the foreclosure impending. He recommended if the Board affirmed an order to wreck,
27 he would file it in court and the City can start to demolish the dwelling.
28
29 Ms.Silberstein reminded Mr. Barden the Order was to repair and secure, not wreck the premises.
30
31 Mr. Barden felt they could have a problem with a repair order to get it accomplished prior to foreclosure.
32
33 Mr.Willis indicated the City can certainly control the weed problem.
34
35 Mr. Barden said he can enter the repair order in Court. He said there had been a transfer of the property from
36 Hudson to the First National Bank and back to Hudson and First National and the City have asked the Courts to
37 determine who is responsible for utilities, etc. He-said if all of Hudson's properties are sold, it would only covet
38 one-third of the total debt owed and there are liens filed against the property that are first priority.
39
40 Ms. Silberstein gave opportunity for the owner of record to speak.
41
42 There was no owner of record or other interested party in attendance.
43
44 Mr. Brown asked if a repair schedule had been submitted and Mr. Bronston said no.
45
46 Mr. Barden said if the Board affirms the Order, he can enjoin the order in the court action an let the court decide
47 who has the responsibility to bring the building to code.
48
49 Ms. Silberstein said she would like to see immediate action on securing the premises.
50
51 Mr. Barden said he could file a lien on the securing and argue that the City has priority.
52
53 Mr.Willis inquired as to the leverage on the property without enough equity.
54
55 Mr. Barden said the proceedings would be cleaner if the property would be demolished.
56
57 Mr.Willis commented that there are two parties dodging their responsibilities of clean up and repair.
58
59 Mr.Willis said he felt the financial burden would eventually mandate the demolition.
60
61 Ms. Silberstein asked why the Order was for repair and not wrecking and Mr. Bronston stated it was his opinion
62 that it was economically feasible to repair without the cost of liens taken into consideration. He said his main
63 concern was it was unsecured and allowed opportunity for vandalism.
64
65 Mr.Willis spoke of the need for a low interest loan for repairs and Mr. Bronston said the City has that type of
Board of Works Minutes Cont'd
August 27, 1987
Page 5
1 program available through the Planning Office.
2
3 Ms. Silberstein recommended the Board affirm the Order as stated which will give the City the opportunity to
4 secure the property and file the Order in Court.
5
6 Mr. Willis moved to affirm the Order on Unsafe Premises located at 414 North 18th Street for the securing of the
7 the building within ten days of receipt of the order and for repair of the unsafe building within thirty days of receipt
8 of the Order,seconded by Mr. Brown and on unanimous voice vote the motion was carried.
9
10 Mr. Brown commented he would like to see the premises secured as soon as possible.
11
12 AWARD PAVING BIDS
13
14 Ms. Stout recommended the Board award the bid for the paving of South G Street to Contractors United, Inc. at
15 45,193.09 as the lowest and best bid. She said there was 1,047.60 difference in the two bids received.
16
17 Mr. Willis explained this project would include the removal of existing pavement and reconstruction of an old
18 concrete street. He said they would not pave the cul-de-sac since it would cause the curbs to be filled up.
19
20 Mr. Willis moved to award the bid for the paving of South G Street from South 23rd eastward to the dead end to
21 Contractor's United, Inc. at 45,103.09 as the lowest and best bid, secon"ded by Mr. Brown and on unanimous
22 voice vote the motion was carried.
23
24 ADJOURNMENT
25
26 There being no further business, on a motion duly made, seconded and passed the meeting was adjourned.
27
28
111 29 Susan Silberstein, President
30
31
32
33 ATTEST:
34 Mary Merchanthouse,City Clerk
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65