Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout20.286 457 BlakelyEXHIBIT 3 CASE # 20-286 457 BLAKELY TUESDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2021 a BUILDING OFFICIAL STRUCTURAL DETERMINATI0llk' CHAPTER 38.65 IMPROVED PROPERTY STANDARDS 457 BLAKELY a D DATE ADDRESS-L=TM0FVKXATM O (a) FOUNDATION >�m) STAIRS O (b) WOOD SUPPORTS x(n) ROOFS O (c) METAL SUPPORTS O (0) GUTTERS AND DOWNSPOUTS O (d) SKIRTING O (p) CHIMNEYS, FLUES, AND VENT ATTACHMENTS (0) EXTERIOR WALLS O (q) OVERHANG EXTENSIONS >rif) WINDOWS O (r) INSECT SCREENS O (g) SHUTTERS O (s) ACCESSORY STRUCTURES (h) EXTERIOR DOORS O (t) SWIMMING POOLS (1) EXTERIOR DOOR FRAMES AND STOREFRONTS O (u) RODENT HARBORAGE 0) EXTERIOR SURFACE TREATMENT X(v) EXTERIOR LIGHTING ,0-,(k) STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS O (w) FENCES AND WALLS 54 (1) PORCHES AND BALCONIES O OTHER: COMMENTS/CORRECTIVE ACTION(S): f Azor-,-. romm-q' rr c ` o' I vc on L'n `•mac r v �o� b i dcrior DATE EXHIBIT # � - ... -' ,.".. � _-. t - ...f, '.• 'ice' .a. OW rya- . . - - - , .- • -'�,,. � - .. - - - 16. y . _ `?L r ry. yx Jyti .- r P,�,i. _ lljj $'- wL• iN it, • tom• .�7[- L - _ > . Crestview, Florida, United States 457 Blakely Ave, Crestview, FL 32536, USA Blakely ' ` Lat N 30° 44' 51.7272" Long W -86° 34' 14.3724" Go gle 26/05/21 11:04 AM AW _ _ fix.. _ • . , Crestview, Florida, United States 457 Blakely Ave, Crestview, FL 32536, USA Lat N 30" 44' 51.6624" Long W -86" 34' 14.4588" ■ ■ - 18/06/21 09:22 AM -tom _ . .. • ��` -r p�r Y.., -.: � •►�y•"T �- .ice :. • � �y , � ..-- .�� 1, — - _ -mac-r':Y.• r 1 is .�• aTf. • ~ r - ti. 's' .._ �.y3. r�-kGPs M., Camera Crestview, Florida, United States 457 Blakely Ave. Crestview, FL 32536, USA BlakeVIYAve Lat 30.7477460 Emerald j Long-86.5706530 30/06/21 07:35 AM ' -� .: yap, •' _ �,, WIWI= '!f y{,. .• ..--�i'M'��'r "•t�'• R��"• � GPS MaN Camera Crestview, Florida, United States 457 Blakely Ave, Crestview, FL 32536, USA BlakelfyAve Lat 30.747746' Long-•86.570684' 30/06/21 07:35 AM r ' - l _ et- - /' � f, ;"�� r may'-'.•v= Y��1 .- '� •� I.1. r •. :. �hv fir.; .. ii •rf,v�'..i�' ri�_��`� _ � l��5- ^i� 'T �• [ �i':e- \ J ':� 1C' �..Gi_r, s'.+ . h-.j "'�.•.:r�,]I�� _ T'f� .� Jx'�' ,`�.�, r?`.{ 1-�,�'jN±.,'.e�'s r !- �r Jx rc. ,ry. - w .iC ►�!� sl _ -fir • s.'•- ���� T � rr� .-jr�•� . f ��j...,� 14{�; .:,� - . - u`•;W..,F�y�•�. '4 R i, Mr -le; �• . w. �ti y .�' - �ix,\ i. yl � 1 r • .. r • �,_.�r r• r�}� e •�. 1 _'�� r.` -'L�•r £.:arc... _ - f � ti•'� `*. — ...,—.. s.. 'R, . �. �'��, r =� �i =�c' Cr''. T'� r 5• i•'? C': •i�� fisc� ''. R•--:'f :Y.t� -•=yl++•:- ern Lik. - ,r"-"�: - -�•.. - play- -Sfs' .}, . .• _`1• :;t.�•{' J• :Cis%' '•' ^� . =.'�rty-1� .. •r �',r•�.� �r �- .����� .-�' K [ -• ',�:`^ '�' 'ac. R 'Fr a,7�' �i,. r�.T.r }��y-4., ey " �"' a •! I I... Q�; 1 �• �� , 4 �. � �F� : t-4: `M1:. y� . , y •" , y��a y N'~ k r s- fig: :+4� • °- ';� y F ' ►ems -tip, r `i :-�`' . : ter• � r ;,:', �'s, •,� ��••n.,. .r 'raj �'• , 1` -�1'rr `: `�'� , � s ; .,jf !' , `�,}_ r ,��� �.~•- - �•• �. �- '.ram * i _k.�. ^�.r •r 7 14r.rI.+ roe • y - - .. ` � : >� ' .•zJ'.a' �� .. ]! • :,� _ �'" . � =�'� �'�;,� ' "`,a, : . CITY OF CRESTVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Code Enforcement Division P.O. Drawer 1209, Crestview, Florida 32536 Phone (850) 683-0896 Date: May 27, 2021 Case #: 20-MO286 KENNETH & CALVIN SILER 497 S WILSON ST CRESTVIEW, FL 32536 Dear Property Owner, This letter is being sent to advise you that a parcel of property belonging to you, which is in the City of Crestview, is currently in violation of City Codes. The following information is provided to you concerning these violations: Location of Violation: 457 BLAKELY AVE Tax Identification Number: 20-3N-23-2390-0012-0050 Legal: SULLIVANS ADD LOTS 5 & 6 BLK, 12, If the violation(s) noted in the attached Statement of Violation (Violation Detail), are not corrected by June 10, 2021, this case may be scheduled for a public hearing before the City of Crestview's Special Magistrate. The Special Magistrate has the authority to impose fines of up to $250.00 per day for the first offense and $500.00 per day for repeat offenses and other penalties as a measure to enforce the codes and ordinances of the City of Crestview in cases where violations continue to exist. If you have any questions concerning this matter, you may call me at (850) 683-0896. Sincerely, Florina Alcobia City of Crestview Code Compliance Officer 850-306-3699 (office) 850-612-5872 (cell) alcobiaf@cityofcrestview.org EXHIBIT # VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 1 CASE NUMBER 20-00000286 PROPERTY ADDRESS 457 BLAKELY AVE -------------------------------------------------------------- VIOLATION: CH 38 SEC 18 (d) QUANTITY: 1 DESCRIPTION: DEMOLITION OF STRUCTURE DATE: 5/25/21 LOCATION: ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION : 38.19 - Duty of Property Owner. It shall be the duty of the owners, or other persons in control of property within the City to maintain their lot, tract or parcel and the abutting right-of-way but not including that area which is paved as roadway consistent with the standards set forth. Nuisance Conditions - 38 - 18 (d) Any building or structure which does not meet the requirements of the Code and is in such a dilapidated condition that it is unfit for human habitation or kept in such a structurally unsafe or unsanitary condition that is a menace to the health of people residing in the vicinity thereof or presents a fire hazard to the vicinity in which it is located. 38.70 - UNSIGHTLY CONDITIONS. The following conditions are hereby deemed to be unsightly conditions and are prohibited. The following conditions are prohibited on any premises in the City: (a) Structures that are: (1) Partially destroyed; or (2) Left in a state of disrepair; or (3) Left in a state of partial construction beyond the valid timeframe of the permit. (c) Building exteriors in a condition of deterioration or disrepair such that the condition causes measurable diminution of surrounding property values. (e) Prior to issuance of a demolition permit for a building where commercial activity is a permitted use, performance bond or equivalent security shall be filed with the City, or a letter of credit may be submitted to the City Manager for approval, in the amount defined below. (1) Total demolition: The amount to demolish the building, and remove all debris from the site, and disposal cost for the debris and grading the lot in compliance with the Land Development Code; or (2) Partial demolition: The amount to demolish the building, and remove all debris from the site, and disposal cost for the debris, grading the lot and the cost of additional construction or reconstruction so the exterior of any partially demolished building or building abutting an adjacent building that results in repair or reconstruction complies with this chapter and the Florida Building Code, as amended. CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED : EXHIBIT # VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 2 CASE NUMBER 20-00000286 PROPERTY ADDRESS 457 BLAKELY AVE CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED : You may abate the violation(s) by obtaining a demolition building permit and removing the structure. Prior to commencing permit, or approval Failure to obtain a Statute 553. work to correct a violation , from the Building Official is building permit is punishable a building required. by Florida For further information, please contact the Permitting Division @ 850-689-1618 ext 254 or 261. -------------------------------------------------------------- VIOLATION: CH 38 SEC 18 (k) QUANTITY: 1 DESCRIPTION: VEGETATION -WEEDS DATE: 5/27/21 LOCATION: ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION : 38.19 - Duty of Property Owner. It shall be the duty of the owners, or other persons in control of property within the City to maintain their lot, tract or parcel and the abutting right-of-way but not including that area which is paved as roadway consistent with the standards set forth. Nuisance Conditions - 38 - 18 (k) Grass, weeds, and uncultivated vegetation: All grasses or weeds, and uncultivated vegetation, shall not exceed twelve (12) inches in height on improved property, including the area between the edge of the pavement in the street and the lot line. CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED : You may abate the violation by removing the vegetation, or weeds from the property. EXHIBIT # 3 I ni c < an ©ROM Refit(eWct ) s O ®C lwl d ma %WtO ed DO'11n a 0 (jA*A9WAt—R" rod s I ©,du[t Skr& re nowakA 0 O.W.,y a n . postage tr 5 cFS-, ru 0 r- Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. w Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 1. Article Addressed to: 11111111111111111111111111 Hill I III I III 9580 9402 5522 92499957 39 2. Articte,NumhpY.n -' ^Clfl0�u 5682 21'06 7 i12fl_ 12�� Ps Form 3811, duly 2015 PSN 75M-02-000-9053 U % © Agent d Address Receive (PrJnfed Na ) C.-Pate of Delivt Is delivery address different from item 1? 13 Yes If YES, enter delivery address below: p No Nult ervice Type ❑ Priority Mail Express@ ult Signature ❑ Registered MalrrtA Signature Restricted Delivery ❑ Registered Mail Restri ❑ certified Mail® Delivery ❑ CertifiPtl Mail Restricted Delivery Ci Return Receipt for on Delivery Merchandise on Delivery Restricted Delivery ❑ Signature Conffrmatioi =irWred Mail 13 Signature Confirmatioi ❑ Insured Mail Restricted Delivery Restricted Delivery Domestic Return Recei EXHIBIT # 3 CITY OF CRESTVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Code Enforcement Division P.O. Drawer 1209, Crestview, Florida 32536 Phone (850) 683-0896 Date: June 22, 2021 Case #: 20-00000286 KENNETH & CALVIN SILER 497 S WILSON ST CRESTVIEW, FL 32536 Dear KENNETH & CALVIN SH ER, This letter is being sent to advise you that a parcel of property belonging to you, which is in the City of Crestview, is currently in violation of City Codes. The following information is provided to you concerning these violations: Location of Violation: 457 BLAKELY AVE Tax Identification Number: 20-3N-23-2390-0012-0050 Legal: SULLIVANS ADD LOTS 5 & 6 BLK, 12, If the violation(s) noted in the attached Statement of Violation (Violation Detail), are not corrected by July 08, 2021, this case may be scheduled for a public hearing before the City of Crestview's Special Magistrate. The Special Magistrate has the authority to impose fines of up to $250.00 per day for the first offense and $500.00 per day for repeat offenses and other penalties as a measure to enforce the codes and ordinances of the City of Crestview in cases where violations continue to exist. If you have any questions concerning this matter, you may call me at (850) 683-0896. Sincerely, Florina Alcobia City of Crestview Code Compliance Officer 850-306-3699 (office) 850-612-5872 (cell) alcoblaf@cityofcrestview.org EXHIBIT # -2D VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 1 CASE NOMBER 20-00000286 PROPERTY ADDRESS 457 BLAKELY AVE -------------------------------------------------------------- VIOLATION: CH 38 SEC 18 (d) QUANTITY: 1 DESCRIPTION: DEMOLITION OF STRUCTURE DATE: 5/25/21 LOCATION: ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION : 38.19 - Duty of Property Owner. It shall be the duty of the owners, or other persons in control of property within the City to maintain their lot, tract or parcel and the abutting right-of-way but not including that area which is paved as roadway consistent with the standards set forth. Nuisance Conditions - 38 - 18 (d) Any building or structure which does not meet the requirements of the Code and is in such a dilapidated condition that it is unfit for human habitation or kept in such a structurally unsafe or unsanitary condition that is a menace to the health of people residing in the vicinity thereof or presents a fire hazard to the vicinity in which it is located. 38.70 - UNSIGHTLY CONDITIONS. The following conditions are hereby deemed to be unsightly conditions and are prohibited. The following conditions are prohibited on any premises in the City: (a) Structures that are: (1) Partially destroyed; or (2) Left in a state of disrepair; or (3) Left in a state of partial construction beyond the valid timeframe of the permit. (c) Building exteriors in a condition of deterioration or disrepair such that the condition causes measurable diminution of surrounding property values. (e) Prior to issuance of a demolition permit for a building where commercial activity is a permitted use, performance bond or equivalent security shall be filed with the City, or a letter of credit may be submitted to the City Manager for approval, in the amount defined below. (1) Total demolition: The amount to demolish the building, and remove all debris from the site, and disposal cost for the debris and grading the lot in compliance with the Land Development Code; or (2) Partial demolition: The amount to demolish the building, and remove all debris from the site, and disposal cost for the debris, grading the lot and the cost of additional construction or reconstruction so the exterior of any partially demolished building or building abutting an adjacent building that results in repair or reconstruction complies with this chapter and the Florida Building Code, as amended. CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED : EXHIBIT # .3 VIOLATION DETAIL PAGE 2 CASE NUMBER 20-00000286 PROPERTY ADDRESS 457 BLAKELY AVE CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED : You may abate the violation(s) by obtaining a demolition building permit and removing the structure. Prior to commencing work to correct a violation , a building permit, or approval from the Building Official is required. Failure to obtain a building permit is punishable by Florida Statute 553. For further information, please contact the Permitting Division @ 850-689-1618 ext 254 or 261. -------------------------------------------------------------- VIOLATION: CH 38 SEC 18 (k) QUANTITY: 1 DESCRIPTION: VEGETATION -WEEDS DATE: 5/27/21 LOCATION: ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION : 38.19 - Duty of Property Owner. It shall be the duty of the owners, or other persons in control of property within the City to maintain their lot, tract or parcel and the abutting right-of-way but not including that area which is paved as roadway consistent with the standards set forth. Nuisance Conditions - 38 - 18 (k) Grass, weeds, and uncultivated vegetation: All grasses or weeds, and uncultivated vegetation, shall not exceed twelve (12) inches in height on improved property, including the area between the edge of the pavement in the street and the lot line. CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED : You may abate the violation by removing the vegetation, or weeds from the property. EXHIBIT # yr ru ' Er r1 v ru v 0 Complete item 1, 2, and & -- 7 I A. ■ Prfrrt your name and address on the reverse x so that we can return the card to you. * Attach this card th the hack of the mallplece. B. or on the front ff space permits. 1. Artic le Addressed to ry W'l LGOR s, e ed by f+*fed Name) C. Date of Delivery vtq delivery address dffmd front ides 1? 0 Yes ff YES, enter delivery address bekw. © No 111 flllll loll l�llllll i 1111111111I1111811111N a a �,y,W t re o Registered r�aTM vase Rwbic d Ddk&y naafi ResVtcted; 0 cenea 9590 9402 6373 03031373 76 0 coma mom Reafrtcw 0ftnahnCote"''°- _ 0 Cosed on Dgwy, 0 swistum Coriflmia*m 2. Wft—ie Number (/iarww from semoe bw 0 Collect on Delivery ReetriC%d De" R05VW ed Delivery _ O preraed man 7i120 1�`'c�9 0 0001 5 6 8 2 2373 .4 RaaWcW Ddivery FS F dM 3t 71". Ju O F%N fro-a2=b Dorrrestic Retum Receipt 3 EXHIBIT # 3 CITY OF CRESTVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT _ �° CODE COMPLIANCE DIVISION 198 Wilson Street North Crestufew, FL 32536 (85o) 683-o896 NOTICE OF PUBLICHF.ARINO DATE: 9/7/2021 Kenneth & Calvin Siler 497 S Wilson Street Crestview, FL 32536 RE: CASE# 20-286 Dear Property Owner. You are hereby formally notified that on October 19, 2021, at 5:30 P.M., there will be a Public Hearing at City Hall, located at 198 Wilson Street North, Crestview, Florida 32536 in the Council Chambers. This meeting is being held concerning violations that continue to exist on a parcel of property belonging to you located at 457 Blakely Avenue, Crestview, FL 32536 more particularly described as: PIN# 20-3N-23-2390-0012-0050 LEGAL DESCRIPTION: SULLIVANS ADD LOTS 5 & 6 BLK 12 The Special Magistrate has the power to levy fines up to $250 per day for a first violation, and up to $500 per day for a repeat violation. If the Special Magistrate finds the violation to be irreparable or irreversible in nature, a fine, not to exceed $5,000 per violation, may be imposed. If a violation, or the condition causing the violation, presents a serious threat to the public health, safety, and welfare, or if the violation is irreparable or irreversible in nature, the Special Magistrate will notify the local governing body, which may make all reasonable repairs required to bring the property into compliance, and charge the violator with the reasonable cost of the repairs along with the fine imposed. If the City prevails in prosecuting a case before the Special Magistrate, it shall be entitled to recover all costs incurred in prosecuting the case before the Special Magistrate, and such costs may be included in the lien authorized under FS 162.09(3). End: Notice of Violation EXHIBIT # 3 A certified copy of an Order imposing a fine, or a fine plus repair costs, will be recorded in the Okaloosa County Public Records, and thereafter shall constitute a lien against the land on which the violation exists and upon any other real or personal property owned by the violator. You have the right to obtain an attorney, at your own expense, to represent you before the Special Magistrate. If you desire a verbatim transcript of the proceedings for appeal purposes, you should arrange for a court reporter to attend the hearing. The Crestview Special Magistrate was created pursuant to Florida Statue 162. ar istrate is to. facilitate the enforcement of local and state laws. I 850.305.3 702/850.612.9714 Farm 53A ANMdh 8 Reviod M1 The purpose of the Special EXHIBIT # S 20-286 457 Blakely Ave STATEMENT OF VIOLATION Code of Ordinance Violated: Chapter 38 Section 18 (d) Demolition of Structure Any building or structure which does not meet the requirements of the Code and is in such a dilapidated condition that it is unfit for human habitation or kept in such a structurally unsafe or unsanitary condition that is a menace to the health of people residing in the vicinity thereof or presents a fire hazard to the vicinity in which it is located. Corrective Action Required: Obtain a demolition permit and demolish the structure. Remove all demolition debris from the property. Code of Ordinance Violated: Chapter 38 Section 18 (k) Vegetation- Weeds Grass, weeds, and uncultivated vegetation: All grasses or weeds, and uncultivated vegetation, shall not exceed twelve (12) inches in height on improved property, including the area between the edge of the pavement in the street and the lot line. Corrective Action Required: Remove the vegetation or weeds from the property. EXHIBIT # 3 ome our website at www.usps,com*, For delivery information i visit 1 w Complete sterns It 2, and 3 A: - - Print your name and.address on the reverse x ' r 13 Aeent so that we can return the card to you. O Addressee Attach this card to the beck of the mailpiec e, B OVnted Aft") of Deitvery or an the front N apace permits. t t t f L „ q 1. Article Addressed to: '� i� Slt f — D. Is de my address dif arerd from item 1? O Yea If Y, eta deRmy address Ww. O No ��� a , -+N owe � 1MI11111111111111111111�IIII1N11111 113 �ts � o o 9590 9402 6373 03031228 22 nlapAeehrktedD*-Y a cor OnTM ❑ Colrect on Dd9 w 0 Resbkftd D o see cor ► R&Ae4 ad Dellvay 2. Aft4e Number (ardor from swvke &W 7011 3500 0000 9133 8595 ,anPmbtatedDonvery Ps Form 3811, duty 2020 PSN 7&w-m4ma-so53 - - - Domestic Retum Receipt a EXHIBIT # BUILDING OFFICIAL STRUCTURAL DETERMINATION CHAPTER 38.65 IMPROVED PROPERTY STANDARDS oA� O (a) FOUNDATION O (b) WOOD SUPPORTS O (c) METAL SUPPORTS O (d) SKIRTING (9) EXTERIOR WALLS Do WINDOWS O (g) SHUTTERS (h) EXTERIOR DOORS (I) EXTERIOR DOOR FRAMES AND STOREFRONTS xQ) EXTERIOR SURFACE TREATMENT �(k) STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS (1) PORCHES AND BALCONIES 457 BLAKELY )(m) STAIRS X(n) ROOFS O (o) GUTTERS AND DOWNSPOUTS O (p) CHIMNEYS, FLUES, AND VENT ATTACHMENTS O (q) OVERHANG EXTENSIONS O (r) INSECT SCREENS O (s) ACCESSORY STRUCTURES O (t) SWIMMING POOLS O (u) RODENT HARBORAGE AV) EXTERIOR LIGHTING O (w) FENCES AND WALLS O OTHER: COMMENTS/CORRECTIVE ACTION(S): UlSrj�; 5k,. , &or."O e� / -ernovf 1 P s"-. _ - a ,r^ov ^v d ri f F i rc . G.;^clow5 oba rs 4✓S a/ C4 0 DATE EXHIBIT # oo lit 14t - V-, .�� .fir. rr � •. � � �` f r•>t ' w �. fit y - •�' �".7��i • qr l �� 1 �r-� �" _ •t ` "L• ..� - ... -i K>�-ems INC - �•~ . _ _ • ���� • . r _µ �_ �_ � w as-->` �r_� ���,y �'.++�11t ' �L.: - ,'� ~• ,� ••• Y �'" - •- . � _ .. -1;"�� -•4 fir' ` - _ ' C . ' • f i � �g7r, ' • ' _ Ir�i' ' : + + `• �. ram:: t AM&"fl; 1 74 BUILDING OFFICIAL STRUCTURAL DFTERMINATION CHAPTER 38.65 IMPROVED PROPERTY STANDARDS DATE O (a) FOUNDATION O (b) WOOD SUPPORTS O (c) METAL SUPPORTS O (d) SKIRTING (e) EXTERIOR WALLS r` (( WINDOWS O (9)SHUTTERS (h) EXTERIOR DOORS (1) EXTERIOR DOOR FRAMES AND STOREFRONTS x- 0) EXTERIOR SURFACE TREATMENT �(k) STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS x(1) PORCHES AND BALCONIES 457 BLAKELY y(n,) STAIRS X(n) ROOFS O (o) GUTTERS AND DOWNSPOUTS O (p) CHIMNEYS, FLUES, AND VENT ATTACHMENTS O (q) OVERHANG EXTENSIONS O (o INSECT SCREENS O (s) ACCESSORY STRUCTURES O (t) SWIMMING POOLS O (u) RODENT HARBORAGE O (v) EXTERIOR LIGHTING O (w) FENCES AND WALLS O OTHER: COMMENTS/CORRECTIVE ACTION(S): 4Smcf Skv Aor-e�e� removf 1 Q _z1' DATE EXHIBIT # -•war•. �•�� �, i:. �_ ��: -,.ice _ ��_� - •`.'�. � �: -�.f . -j'j� •4 ter_ A/. ro -{�`� ...` ��7�s ���� >.. �•�f� whir �':.r �� •. . - ..'� ~'�[_ co- ti "�T "��i "-�.� ' `•�^ #_ l' �' -� .. •`�;= T•'r��; : �i. dc ti IL VA 1 • Z. :-. .;� .`% T - ry • `Y�• '�' ` • ��J-'i ' Cam- � . ` ._ :.-•- ► _ � ' = i �;•. r= *°� ATV.+S` �r .:_ ••ram ._� � .'�": r-��'� 3 'i~ • J _ Case# 21-286 457 Blakely 0 W S JL 41- EXHIBIT # a �a, a i Y 1