Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 20-2812-9TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail October 29, 2020 Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: records@commerce-group.com] Re: GS #2812-9 (Request for Public Records Related to Martin O'Boyle Criminal Case) Request for Public Records Related to Martin O’Boyle Criminal Case 9. All text messages on any phone issued or used by the Town Police dating back to January 1, 2013. The word “phone” as used herein includes without limitation, phones in storage, phones in current use, phones previously used, and includes without limitation, personal phones in current use and previous use. Dear Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: meo@commerce-group.com]: The original request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173216&repo=r-430100cc Subpart nine of your request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173530&repo=r-430100cc The Town now estimates that to fully respond to subpart nine of your request will require 5 hours of administrative support at $48.38 per hour, the labor cost of the personnel providing the service, per Fla. Stat. § 119.07(4)(d). If the costs of producing these documents will exceed your deposit, the Town will provide you with an initial production of responsive records and an estimate for the production of any additional responsive records. If the costs of production are less than the deposit, the Town will provide you with the responsive records and a refund. (5 hours @ 48.38 = 241.90) = Deposit Due: $241.90 in cash or check. Upon receipt of your acknowledgement that you will pay for these records, the Town will use its very best efforts to further respond to your public records request in a reasonable amount of time. If we do not hear back from you within 30 days of this letter, we will consider this closed. Sincerely, Reneé Basel As Requested by Rita Taylor Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records Renee Basel From:Jonathan O'Boyle <joboyle@oboylelawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 10, 2020 3:39 PM To:Renee Basel Cc:Jonathan O'Boyle; Suze Courtney Subject:RE: GS #2812-9 (Request for Public Records Related to Martin O'Boyle Criminal Case) \[NOTICE: This message originated outside of the Town of Gulfstream -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe.\] Rene, I don’t have that I responded to this, lets go ahead and produce. What additional funds do you need from us? From: Renee Basel <rbasel@gulf-stream.org> Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2020 1:16 PM To: Jonathan O'Boyle <joboyle@oboylelawfirm.com> Cc: Suze Courtney <scourtney@commerce-group.com>; records@commerce-group.com Subject: GS #2812-9 (Request for Public Records Related to Martin O'Boyle Criminal Case) Good afternoon, Jonathan: See attached correspondence. Kindest regards, Reneé Basel The linked image cannot be displayed. The file may have been moved, renamed, or deleted. Verify that the link points to the correct file and location. The linked image cannot be displayed. The file may have been moved, renamed, or deleted. Verify that the link points to the correct file and location. Confidentiality Notice: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. Florida has a very broad public records law. Written communications regarding Town of Gulf Stream business are public records available to the public upon request. Your e-mail communications are therefore subject to public 1 disclosure. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing. Confidentiality Notice: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. Florida has a very broad public records law. Written communications regarding Town of Gulf Stream business are public records available to the public upon request. Your e-mail communications are therefore subject to public disclosure. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing. 2 TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail November 13, 2020 Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: meo@commerce-group.com] Re: GS #2812 (Request for Public Records Related to Martin O'Boyle Criminal Case) Dear Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: meo@commerce-group.com]: Thank you for your Facilitation Fee of $250.00 by check #52414 on August 31, 2020 for the public record request described above, received by the Town on August 31, 2020. The Town will apply this to the production of records in accordance with the 2018 Settlement Agreement. The original request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173216&repo=r-430100cc Through your attorney, you agreed to have $27.57 deducted from the $250.00 Facilitation Fee for GS #2812-1 of the request above. That leaves you with a balance of $222.43. On November 10, 2020, your attorney responded to GS #2812-9 and stated “Let’s go ahead and produce. What additional funds do you need from us?” GS #2812-9 required a deposit of $241.90 which would deplete the $222.43 balance of your Facilitation Fee leaving a balance owed of $19.47. Sincerely, Reneé Rowan Basel As requested by Rita Taylor Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail January 13, 2021 Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: records@commerce-group.com] Re: GS #2812-9 (Request for Public Records Related to Martin O'Boyle Criminal Case) Request for Public Records Related to Martin O’Boyle Criminal Case 9. All text messages on any phone issued or used by the Town Police dating back to January 1, 2013. The word “phone” as used herein includes without limitation, phones in storage, phones in current use, phones previously used, and includes without limitation, personal phones in current use and previous use. Dear Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: meo@commerce-group.com]: The original request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173216&repo=r-430100cc A partial production of subpart nine of your request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173530&repo=r-430100cc The Town now estimates that to fully respond to subpart nine of your request will require two additional hours of administrative support at $48.38 per hour, the labor cost of the personnel providing the service, per Fla. Stat. § 119.07(4)(d). (2 hours @ 48.38 = 96.76) = Deposit Due: $96.76 in cash or check. Upon receipt of your payment, the Town will use its very best efforts to further respond to your public records request in a reasonable amount of time. If we do not hear back from you within 30 days of this letter, we will consider this closed. Sincerely, Reneé Basel As Requested by Rita Taylor Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records Q O J v a N Ncr U ° N Q �� c 3 4- c 0 � N Q N > V c O U a U Lf) v Y LO U — Q1 N y C > V LL w O O d N C O N O L — Z (n (A Q Q rj, 1 L J E � 0 a E N N 0 o 0, O O N � av aJ f0 >' (0 O O O m 4-; L- 4 0 N O Q ++ In In f0 m O U-ot-c C � m m� p o N= Y a `t oh y c0 0 p N O U Q fa m t� C rn in �.= fA 00 N L c y �' O U F- c t 0 f0 N �. V Q Y 0 CA E`N p cep >+ O t C L c 0: t. O CE cc p O aN C O � j C7 t 'p m m CD U p ;C m H _ v w � 00 G J J W U a 8= C o€ U In 4-+ O _ Ln LO L N U � r 0 C N 4 � o Y CD V o 0 � co C 01 (/) Q N � oN ��I Y T V C N L � 1+ � Y � U *� v E s `n. z in v Q Q °C � c -C Co C C to O c6 U +' O CL Y U (0 a „ O Q N 3 N C X � vo. a w � t, a' c c � N +� N Cl) ��+ O V O0 O N y C L o C +r o ti0 J -C ` }; N�•EY .0 cD C -C j N N y C 0 4..r U O Y •N �••x i � O Q C N N C^ V CoU (� H— (n CD l'� Fm • f Y L + An U � L �\ N 0 Ea)�2 w O ^ 4- a 0) ca•�+ rn 0 Q O� , ! •p *' U 0 La 0 a 'Inn N �m 1•d y C BCD # L . O O co - g LL Q (cII W C C E cu .Y Im�6 a-+ ti a g 3 Qom+ Y S O O e Y f yTP� •� 0 3 F- a) L C (� �! (/: U U C C � o N c F— .� (p CD > 11 v RI t� q. � w+ ��� �•'�•! ii�• �i�� Tit M� M�.Y Ai. ri• �.�11 � .. 00 ON . to l6 �. n 6i1 n MIO ry of. I' U c c c � � n (0 C C U N p .N c L (� 3 x a d a N c M M Q U O p N y 75 O � p v� t Q �. 3=}; O � O m a)'— c +, ai o) m in- P .L ..., 4� � G L O p C ._� � O Q N� N L 0- O N va an O N >v , 0 0 0 a E ?� N E O O L- co .� O U cvo C 0c jo c p o E o v o o v�� N caNi�CH•ao.Y n o p O O N O EcoE� c9 O C O .� ,c �c�n M N c N Z O O N c E 'cC CO N i 1 '� Q N LL N O C L- F- cn k o �a,>DO.N m ��s� �� - cn N to O Q 3 C � O Q O Q= C+ 00 (y ca cn -0 i �� i� O N N ) •O O E O U +� N E i -p p, °o�a�a o`°o�oc� �a��a+ �cu > (DmZ 3-0 in °, Q o nc'/n 3 Q O o +1 CD E a)c O U E C L t M.>_ U O �- a M N� N C cv � �� >,E 'Fv� +' O H E o O c� > c- (� a 3 E N a X m } a 0 u "O L Q aE 5 CD N o�, }, cn - E N N N c °' c �,� 0)_ p (n "� c 0 2 p 0~ i o N to 00 N O P N m-c a) dj > N .O U O vi 0) Cr) c '� N o Y U "O c O to .� 'O > a L Q -a " O O Q N 00 W c9 cn Q E u N C:) D a J m o v a N � (t. c 0 u I L 4- 4- m �% N 'yU—_ O f O11 2 0 1 0 � 14 4- O Vi L - C 00 _ rn CD iQa to ` Q� E U - ct E a 0 U .c a m U (In F- O co v_- *- U +r Q. t, N ` O t- O` �. 0 0 E N co >CD >%a co O O N w+,U)iQ� O L Uv O 0 u a a� �O a �cc,-- a� ic�a ��c E� ,}'-v <n O c;)L �o a�° cu 0 O O O �o =3 cB =O p a m p °' OO c 0 v v •c can E� O� cn � L N N j +r •V Q c V i *r N a j Q o �c m m o c O m c ' cn -a-- �O co t° ,� '� L5 O �_ N n> CD Co C c C O C }L. O Q m N E EH o~ a� v3iv m° o U a� 3 c L t �.N�,-co`L° �U)C :3 a t°N`O"E'ocoy� +,_ � 3cE70E j 00 0O O N m N Q. 4a d Ct CU C O U U 0 E L "O .E Q O O` c= 0 0 j- 0 0 C (0 N m .� i �O O O L G c c m° u o :° 0 �� o a;a `° o �, �2 > Q 3-0tn >. Q otncn L 3+ ¢ co.�Ct �H �' cD¢ C ((• C O 0 a u LL v c o 0 co 0 ,.a m to a o rn dw N m O co U 41 m N D m CD f0 T N L d > ] E 7 X ID LL° E ! c C N N Q CC f6 C 0 _ O :- U -Z x E Q � G O O ++ E a J o O a ©a N a A CD�' W m O E� o U 0 O a U U G ++ D1 V = Qi .O %• _ O m ♦C ^ N O m W N N O O N o G O v _ t _..,. Z N fn z fA Q Q " - > O vs cu cn C > u- '> C7 ?= c TO O u O ya cc o ui o �� Zj Q) {y tw O. U cA Q N O O_ O Y C�� o 4) 0 O n -- U Q o � o N 30 C C3) C *� O O Y c - (D U C co a r: > C U U C 2 O ca N _ C C O Q L N U V) C: c 0 N CD � N r C c N O ._ L. �c Q U O a U N a U> N Co 0 4> U N O _ c a c- 0 > O tz o c� N c 0 0 0 n a Q, 00 O N d u 0 O O ,s, a 0 M N U) c O N - - AML. no p :F O a Q co O M � N a i(. :i u 4- c U CD CO Co 4 0 O � 0b 41 611 d--+ L_ ❑ ❑ 'n W > i , M Z3 6 L O O 06 m Q — O vi c cn .0 4— LL 0 O Q (n c v) LL m U Q Icn E cn O O c No -O cn U N L O Q > U N x 0 LO 00 Q a N N Q 0 0 cli O I �I C - O C O (. O) o a) .` m O t0 00 d Q d Ln n � N o Ln 00 to m C, N M zi Q t LL C O N N m a� 0 L c a a �p o r N r a N 0 U) 00 a a a a %- 0 4 0 a) a N C O N a) L Fj On V) U ❑o loot VNw. v rw o 0 0 Y ' d LL � t0 •= ++ O U O N m � N C i O 00 U LO 3 CD rn c o � co C 0 Y O O N i N N N LL 2 a E� t N e co0 CU LL 4- . j cu H Q)'— N E c , m 'E — H a N � FD E O cn — O m ' V 2 : _ (fill 111141 � s OF, -M E 0 00 c 0 N N O Ui co t -A N L N N C) L O -C Q Cn � U � C C 00 N C N � O N U c� � � O N F— c �01 R. 0 00 g >, a _d ) U r � r (t. 11 00 0 a � N (CO LO (C. � L L U U -0 L O 4- Q COU Co - c c _� °o _co � W =3 O �— E a m U c E* Rl ❑o y .f N a o N - a Q O L I O !E co cu Q% /- Q O U _V) Q U O U } O V) O ry >O E O1m -0 IOi Le 0 0 00 -O �.- o� o� � 0- . �: 4- � U �-+ M O U E � _E +r t13 i a) CD �( n� O cu X > 00 a) cv 3 +� a o O f, U M> cu +• _0� � 3 0 U- E� E�� O a) a)(,. o (D cu � s � o U 0 m n� L- o� �_ a avi m -C o +- L- E a) V) c � +-� 5 � 5 O E � � � (n LL � c6 U O � � i= O O O N_ ©e�®©®®®�■■■■®®.■ OEM ■■P�®�■®O■®®■■ ®®■■ ®®mmmmm®■■ ©m ® ®®® ■.■m■ ©m mm mmmm� ■ mm� ©®■■ ■-■®®®■ ■■� ®®-■.-■®® ". ■■®® ®® ®® ®®®mmm ■■�■®.■ ®®.®.No Now MIN ©�®®N 1 0 00 a 00 r c 0 N a 0 00 a 00 E E 0 a 73 *' C C Cn m L 0 a O_ C o O O +' 00 Y a O C/) L cn 0 O Q U H '> Y 0cu a) Ni i L U _ J U O C/i O "- O N � C N 0 � Q � a O Ln O CU o L w •C C O 1� • E Q as C- 0 tY) C O 0 L N j LL > O " EC—C p 0 4 L CD O O j a 0 CP a U C t0 a 0 O .*' cB LO O O O Cn L x ca E Cll N C O >O 0 T E E O O L 4- 4- 0 m U- O -0-0 0— cu O O _� O O O L O 0) U U 0 .0 >+ to c C cn y L CU cn U CU �� N 0 y ° C: L Y i Ll 0 3 O -r— O u 0 m L L o i— � E)Z LL -i v 0 ��1 " 1 ' :CC: .y r No OD ��A a :I f - c In f0 N I 1t G y �% 00 M 2 r O N mill t O (C. C O N A"-P n:1 m own mmm In mmm m mm m Mom MMMOMMIMMMM, ommmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmam mmmm Moon mwmmmmmm® m WOMMMOMMMMMMMME MMMMMMMMOMMMMMM mommmmmmmmmmmmm mmommmmmmmmmmom MMMMMMMMMMMMIMM mmomm M L _L 'M INN mm no mmmum, mm mmmum mmm mmmmmmmmm mm M, mm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm mmommmmommmmmmm mmmmmmmm mmmmmommmmmommm MMMMMMMMMMIMMMMM mmmmmmmmmmm,mmmo MOMMOMMIMMMIMMMOM MMOMMOMMMMMOMM mmmm MMMMMMMMS =mom MOM mm,ow m 0 - =no-= oMM mom 0 00 N a ..0 O a- M N W O CD m Ocucn N N O A C C Q C'. O Y O � O O a o O c fu U O C m i O 4- C i �L- O /iron 3. V / O 0 OD L 2 � a `0 N o � m a a c 0 0 0 00 O (� a N U co co U rnM � E O O NN So C Q O Y O a ^ cn O �` a co U_ O� O� z cn Q C O O F N M Y Q N (�. to 0) O O U 4- E O lS � C 0) U � C O c � i O cn O 5,a- E� �r H • • 2 a LO 0 ((. c 0 a) u co ((. c 0 N > EN C Q N O >, O p U i a) 3 U a) *'' C O C '- Cl) i L U .— O .� +. O C C V1 C O fII Q L Q m� A > >+ +• Y C a Q M Q1 E p - 0 +-' N Q N 'C�. Q C 3 U �-' s .� E — a) m O N ° E cn N w cu -a vi M" cu cv m ,-M U CD y- N N '- cv Q U 07 O >, a) Y *' Z; E O c 6� a) m 0 0 >co a) .� O O 3-0 M p0 0- °a c > U N c o c- o- m � O a) a) Q a)> N E a) ,�' `� }, cu N rn N 3 > O 0` a) mN Cn Q � 3 ° U O .� U U O 3 3 N E c m a 0 4- +, co >, +- o O — C 0 0 � -0 vi `� (B .�_ C N O > c >. 0 O cu � >,QC c� +� > p p�0 a) 0 co Q c U -O M a) � +� N Ln o 0 E N a) m-a N ca�Q>�.cE>�o O• a) Y _ a) U C p +- O Q.V ► O m C U a- N CD > a] a) I --a) N �-+ N m � a) j C O U L- a) ca a) m L U_ N i-+ 4- +- 0 0 a 40 x 2 M3 L 0) +� 0LO O N n N (� E p N L O ul 4— Ln V U co p O 0- C O � cz o o> o o o `I-��- .rE �.�ova 0 "V Ln Is c L O O O N M E0) OMB E a� 73 +-� O Q? f� O Y : — cn O = N cn Q +� +' C Y cB V U O O O O C M 4 O 0- C N `~ O L o 0 — x �0.— O M 0 +r O a) C �M O��E���� °' ca C °' o > o o a°v .L aMi E o+S� O v a `l `- syJ' ,yy 0 00 c 0 N 0 OD c ca c 0 N > L O v _ t cp O O 61 M m �- O �--� 2 -� `� U O a o O j 00 0) C p O N �+- �_ O oN O O >� a 0 Y x 0 •� U` c p O o cn C C i-Z LL oo 0 0 0 oNcEf-.o C o� cva >_ o O` O N c O +. O S O 4- m O -0C O tv cu 0 O ou p UUO > � = On5CD Z3 Of m� O M Z �-c , 2 Q N T @ a rn N c -a G V N +O O U a O c� v- N N U m c N m O cn O o o ti m o c c +-• ) a� C) CD C Q ?� O U N C m "O C 4- U O E N y) C CV Co ` cD ,v 4­ 14--- +- +1 Al 0 0 0 ao e 0 o • • ao Lo a • U O _0 OI O O C: cu L 0 r\ 5, L O Q }) Q a) co a > U) i Y c. O � c 0 00 O — — CD � O a aa) o a �C 5�+. LO ? u) Z) O O .0 0c , L a0 0O L- � °CU�o � L °N a00�a�E �_ m co o o aai N `n '� a o L) 4 -' to a�i ) o mON -(n.5L 0 M 0 1 00 c O N > O 00 a tD M o 0 0 O ((. c O N o C'- • (n a C7 Z3 Ln +� • f� v L cv = O L L � ca N > U) • >� _ O a/ - >� 4. U L O Fes- J .c J -0 C a OO Q O O N E E Q to O a O U V) C. m "O U � U L ' iNli � 3 V O U O — +� c C O U N +- aF N N 7+ O O 00 La c 0 0 n 00 a Q o � iD c of o� o 0 a > O3 p X a O +, O O Q Q o Y N O N U 2 a n a CC; c O � 3 -o v (C. c 0 N > rn Z r N U N O N 75 N E N ti — C U OU O to 7 U t4 cn L- � � O :3 O LL O .9 aD U iw 91 o ' 0 00 LO "C: E cu N �. o Y CO a v O +� Y Q of co a) N Q c0 o N i 0) cO U) c� U � O > O o O O P U O z +O W 7 > O CU O >. 0 � LO O U Qm O O 0) N O 0 0 � � � c �>0 O a) Q O a � � OQ .� co >` CV C O O Q V) >' -a Q O a� o cu O o E cuQ U N �- : . > F— (n LO U 0 (n O U(,n> 0 N o L H U co lJ n 00 a (DON c 0 1,11W0 r O c 0 N O c� O .Y O cu E U � E m O L O Q cn =3 O E O - a C ca O � � ' O � O N Iz O — a: -a C C c0 O O a O O U C O J U i Q -�C Q R 0 00 ai � a M 5 a^ C: v • 0 o V fn ! O 0 N O H U) c N c O Q N in CD 0 Co a C ca o M d Oi f6 • — N o0 > N ! o Z +.r N N CO 3 O O N 4Z O O Q co V) ° �� +� > U o V a 00 O Z 7 L N LO N N 0 cv rL d f— N V 0 4� V D > N a Q LL L U =_ c ca Q O O O Z U M N r a Cn m c a) 2 a O A No n 0 aA v hc 0 0 0 O N Q 06 U N n Q n ai M N U N 0 4) CP L C Q 0 ++ `1 U L V% 0 0 0 C > 4- Q CD L 0 O Q 0 0 4 c u ) � Lf a] 6 a �01 00 � d a 00 o 0 0 :el c 0 0 00 v ° °W w cr O � M C co co c0 c—" CD — o U 0 F. > Q U O �O C S_ cu Q Q CU �+ U C cts a) 'S N Ln EoC) " }' U v Q v > v CO O4 �+1 c a c +r ui ' a O .� i a vi cts O c Q) o CY) N U i C O 0) L- 4-j O O o� N ° � Q •co�'c' 0 � °N' E v v (D co a v a) a)+' >=�� a)L� -r— V) E U v -+ � N m v O a) "0 C O� v 0 — i--+ -0 S✓ O 0 U }. O J 4—O v N v O E -o 0 NO 00 7 C 0 N C L •L QO /E V Z Ll. H I lJ 0 w O c > N a Co N cc cco C C a co a co *r O m000 0- n CD - En >1 U rl �2 u _ O c cu U u O(f) cn O U O U o C> O LL �C d to LL .: U 0� m L Q "' O �, c c c O c C O O O L a ° Q O c O O J T, O O U t^ N d ►sluossued MKOWA st:zo -jno pleuev 1NUMOBSV3N ;4 + OVON OIOd Z 3NOZ ION lVd :sUorvv go / m u = C \ a \ # Qcu = 2 7 \ \ ƒ q % co/ \ \ 3 \ \ / -0 \ R � % \ E \ / � % k 0 c G \ yy / \ E cu \ cn � � � . ` 5 cu \. m o / m £ _ \ E v $ ® LO CL — . `\ ma 2 \ a) / \ ƒ \ / \ 0-0 0 c � J O E n e > o- » : $ ,g •@ E E o 0 0 0 / /. m m @ • Q � � O �g N E c m �� `� - 0) \ E/ cu \ U E 2 U 0 E 3 2 � E m E 0 sp 00 2 a 0 r- (t• O co a O U) W U i m� W �. >? m 1 v, '- o O cu CD a COd7 a) -_ C M O a m Q o � a _ _ w— Una J S' ��� M n o a`)0) � � Q a� ; c�cBa � w Q� a� a � � � � OfcB 06 _ � Om -- M U c cn ~� ai.� a � �+�M Uot cn U� E 0 U U O O U Y Q= ? Q O O X (D p � a) O coW CO O L ava :T a o Q � �ui w° a u a o w M� C 0LL c �p L- o C L- w to E 00 2 0- 0 77 (C. O OD 2 0 N r7 r jl (C. c 0 N v 00 0 (C. c 0 N I (D 0 � �% _0 E Lw-- 0 0 Q _U U _j > _U Qt L a)- 0 N N I— E S Q 0 H �01 1 0 00 (t. c 0 N v (C. c 0 N i �01 Rl �01 0 OD a r a- c O N O 00 E �01 0 NO 00 ((. c O N fu U c O N N a) aj a CO CD o v— O a a) a) C V c; E C a) a cn O1 .� 'j O C _ Y U O C C O m L E U w Ln Ln C O U E IQ):�, a) a) OU X LO = U b 0- a M m a v w 'a v H 0 e a n Co (C. Q 00 (t. c O N v H 2 ❑o a F 4y. u r ���� .O ;1�� I \ ,/ ���� ��, ���� .��+ M ''�� ` ��!,! .r �� ����'" ��1 t a, TIT sett. • r _ ob a X 4- X w Q) L cn U O O O 7 (1) O > M O L I (0 p-) I O E cn m Co >. N 1- > E U- O O O � U O � 0 U . Q) 00 ) LL > �t-- U _U O s O X Y >'' O to _ L 0. O > U) N _ p >, (D :E 4- U L cD U O O O N O (n ?>>.�0E���n,� O U N > c L- U U L �y 9 EW O F 6� O O O O G a O U > " O cn m a aELL c O -C O U m �O —LL N — . O U >�. = U QJ o= §2 cn0� 0i NZ OD 2 a M_ e- C 0 N O rl OD 2 a C+9 e- (C. C N N O in N O a ra cn g a� C_- 2 a 00 0 N O N O M C m Z 2 C: f� 1 c 1 1 • Q 1 c M • 01, N a c 0 2 Q i o U + E s �, U C C (n O U C C S C � U C O o _ _N o 00 v fQ • V) Q cu N a Co O oM . • le v O LO o L 4- +. L N - o ('Y) L E E M 0 � N • O - a N +� r 0 (n -le N Q E O Q N _0 O L v }r c� � O C +-, O o U — o OU m n cn ++' E >. > C N� >� E N C) � L � ca Q. '� -o 0) p O a) !E O N 000`�$ of aulo p1e�1,a� yseae 103 ajq!'Aqa aq f,rul Itof. pue jelluapiluoz) tice�ua llun uo�leutio3ux mo, •kLLIM0 SdII-85tr-0048 lt' siaddoaS aVU113IIe:I OA pa-Ase toq�azagnn stag} uo U01A Lzojul g4lm 3iIO&UN.7 A � ' ,yz)eag uolu kog ut meg LgarN uo sem ssaippr umoux jsei call 'spunod of i Inoge sgJflam pur L-lool-S spurls 'saAa uaai�i ' itr.Il umo.ttl srtl ' S q 6 t 'fit AoN LI IoLl sum all,, •Ifl(I fuop-i jo r tto ieaddr of awlirl }o N"Jilui pALtolai Uo pa}aauuon f.�asota zadas aar AC2olo3a aq1 Pule fu'Ouoaa am 'KC unoD ull'Aule-la zo; !�[zletno[}zPd„ 'pies aqs ; azagl }no st }saA1Mj a�yau�e lsns le 1leg1 ` �Eq �q}tE aLl e ;o io}Eatput at}} s �}ELI,j,,, s�eoglalsfo;olln; za}rtn aq1 sari pule EEoa111aEjEdy 01 a'Apixq a111 nano sanup aqs 11 :�;reyst �zrnlsa aq1 1Yg1nIs 1sa�ns atl; -nu i tltnt, attc,»n�. 1 0 to 00 plat;s}irI I .'Tunjo I [CITE anEll note aioLaq Pleoz atll Llmop szEa�i onnl az,nof tta111 Par, `1t olut }a4 01 aeisuadxa os s,1I • �zaLlsL1 aM uI 9110 4lana :IU_I �[yELllird Pazza;aad aLI1 }ou xc `1EI11 }nq astutq asEal lEaol r uo sza1. -SAO pauuEl sr.tl al I 'EuEtsnlo-1 PiIE SEXay LLIo13 aIUUJ IAOU sza}sdo `411LUel s "Tp __ })II110.It' Ifs 01 Ma i{11on4, j,LrstzM 1r 4L,Ejj� ANa3 os �?Lrr;;ay a.Ia, a sang lIOI.;U' St16 r.'.Ioj �LI"ri� SELL pLIP ox Nllia1j At, - sAu plan I)?rs `poowas 1aa1}g Ja -ngzllsip atp 1E `L1sEg 0 co OD C a Ln 77 t(• 0 LD 00 Lo h h t!"J N (D Ln t t .14 F R]y C AWA yo , M.AhL Irk c 0 N 1�1 0 (o 00 + C O N LL d 0 O N M U O Q Q cu i Z) O a O U O Q Q cu 10 4�- a Y•� m o O � O _ N (C) 0 (Q O n r h N CCD (D , C N x 0 NCO N n oa) = r �� 0 Q Q n0 v zr v ((DD D w 3Ul Ul .+ O r-r (D (D O- CD rQ co co X. ZD ( (D V �� 0 C) O (Dm n (D O may., .0 m 019 FAil C4 Aq r* CD n D rf& O CD N 0 I m N O 7 c O 0 —1 O O C O O (D O (D O � > (D -0r+ 0 < ' N O O Q � : -4 c r+ Q�-O (D O � ri+ O cn CD x 0) r-F a 3 v) C' : _ (D —+ C 0 O Q �, (D .74 N O CQ i°n CD o c� 0 m � D FD CD O Q d y cNn V) cNn N N -0 CD tJ CD O CD .90 A r.+ O N W /�� \ J fD 0 ►7 < cD N O D 0 Mawr- ' FCM C-� C� O � N O 7 W G7 n W 0 9 n (n� v ��Q.�< a-�p'�C��r� �� C/) (OD Q O O (D C cD p< CD CDQ7 c� (�D c� �_ r+ (D O CD N r+ (D _ O p _0 v O CD � C (D tD < CD vi CD CD CD CD to W� N (D � (n C Q O � cn � O cD DJ O � � C T� 0-o ' v v��30 v �, o - �, • �o w �� CD (Dr-+ < (D cD ,-+ a) (D 3. (D N � � Q O � cn O O N O (D .+ = ID 3 r(-D+ D v 0 D IV D N O 00 'd Ul v r- O (D a) 0 t r 1 Al, ►i CD N O I CU W CD O fD w o D (D ft a N Km n cD v r-+ O v n zr (D^ l ) O 0 O (D cn (D 0- (D O 3 O C7 O O < O v Ln O N v i' CD CD N. O W O 70 Q cn j n m (D v o 3 0 �, _ < << W G) (D 0 C m VJ w rn D C 0 =3 0-9 09 Z O � O cD O 11 v O r-r O O CD C N• CQ O CL r-, N CD CD CD cp N O 3 0 W V D cD N O 3 w j O W V D e E-f L-) N CD 70 Ul N O 00 c9 0 rn D m N O 0 41 0 W 00 D r fD ZOT (D Zr V) 0 L (D 3 :3 (D N O O M n ' r+ (D O = Q_0 m Q. N O 5 N fD r-► ZW *% a n n V N O 00 0 0 Ol C O Cl) rn N 0 03 0 A t *:E355�-O-N_Q_C-Oo o ID � I I ID �- N O (D 07 (D (D (D �" N n -� -+ w � D ram+ (n (Q cn ZT C -t. O o Q Q CD(�D n � r�-r < C CL O� M n (D O N Q O r-+ fD N aI \ CD 3 -o fD C (D N (--- o N= Q-0 (D Q c o o z Q (D O fD Q _. O - Q m FA, CD N O I 0 w 00 D w O 00 D 14, o �K X O (D O Cy (D C O O r-h fD cD 3 ._. O O • • -'% Z O O N (D O (D 01 N :3 Q X --+' r+ CD N (D ,-+ O O ,{ 3 0 O CD CD i :M • a' (/) (a O ZT v X (D r+ O O (D O r�r -��3� O _. O CCD O N CD F l< n (D u w N (D �G n (D N O 7 w G) O w 00 D w G) 0 co D C] 0, a -< r Do s Hp- 3$:�R�SSym Rai z..= e a S 3 R w $g�ea • • • • • O rF • J J (n V) ., N X 2 CU N CD n CD to CD CD In w G7 0 W 00 D CD N O 7 FI a we C� I 2 gugT of 'm 00 CDv TS n� > M0 ? D �mapp; L. A m N 2 O Z T �A�on�nA2v� M. D OT ADZ am2ma �z �G rr �' m m z m A Z 3 fZll y m m m m z gn py� Nv+�AI y A A.pm m Cmm � o�Oc 3 z m m N O Z > O a C m A s S p a D D O Cc) x Z` m � zoo o O p p 0 p 2 x f - H e Am o v yo 3 m m c p 3 � O Z o m _ 1 m Z J O m o c � N _ m J � m 7 � m � w 6n=S�now n;; oag". P IWO, V Y CD N O 9 2 N CD O co o D C V 0 M 0) o .30-4 � mmONmTtmm"m.•�i;�O m W ozpapQmmAr�Dvmo�'pmxv��� <°q ApxrcO �0 ODmA` mmGlxamDiA O C y N Q y m Z a m r o r omm m o" 0 0 �nN<omm�n m yN -i�� OzrnQm��t Ox y<rnz Q CtxAm 3mn"zm g m nJ m Am001 xo zm��[0io wxe m�TA O A;s0S3-=•i A m x z mi�°'no Q zpu <3� to z�Aa� mz o ° .pZ mMgDm mma r��, V mD'ri m" m z m3.13 <�n = aN N pCO'03 "mc Div Po '40zo Erna m mA rts) No a N� 9= On`f� m 13 AS m < C N p 0 Q ° d 3.z m m o Z;;a a iv a oN rtzi Ma p3m O n m z m p' c o mz mp z m Q a °M 0 mrn u 3 O a_'1'IMIMIM D 4D,�DDCD..O OD am o00, U U U (ma(yy U U�� U U '•'� O fJl .� O� U (il m ()+m 71 mramv2 M... mU7 r mUZ:iAmr NrmpvzmmOOuxvO�Dm��O�D0 mr�Dyp ml..�D a MM mA mmOGlwmZo7cmirp�fROM20 m°Dw rpaa�°vim mp ArOOo cod zmy Z^v'om- TOi �ONZD °off mom mm m��.-m n� pmy:ca+ � -v0 orn N o 7c mm...-{. zmc ulo- 11� 19 �arD Q pp � _e2 >04-1 CA0 i o� o 'wo �0D m xzpfA :>0z m 0z% D� t/lAM1,9 m G zp"p -1 A *>M i m m Q rn m t 6 N M. mp yl r Z A < �Z �u N D C�7l OeQm 9 T 9 Z O n a N i N V m .0 n A m r W m m n -1 D ° N-' m o 0 N amp a a m m 0 Z�o p C p =O m � O J... Oi Z () v ty" M u O x mm = m q O o 0 c o0 O y m e m Q IW- v O co M N O O w G) eyL v O CD :3 :2. No W G) �1 0 W D E� �� t, I k > nzn14=Qj—�=, 71 000�;S\§§£2�°k\q !]Ig2622-2I/a3 6 Vim;;,a,e�r,ecz0) M,mmr am go ¥ a, °«°:rn];m4. m )=G;c/ 22ro=, @J�z— �ea��} \§\§()��� ao2oz,om�22/� 100 2;a2� 56 220 oa 3m'k�� i�j��)((\ k Liz§6 7�G& . �})()—� §,.� �z� mz g § k & § \\ a ( } m m � 9 o m § § § k c N ) . m D < O f M _ m No _ / * 09 m .14P N pi w G) 2 CD a CD w o D CD W I W CD O O o D 3 0 09 ,f v FCM � co O 'v v r-r3 O (n O -t (n 73 `� ) 0( Q ZT � CC _. o 3 v t (D < CD O 0 3���D<� G O (D v 3 _. O O (D �- ._. O cn —+ r+ N m 3 - C cfl 00 � CD '� W lS CD � D V cD N O 7 I 0 W D U CD N O 7 9 1 CD •J CD 3 4=;� 0 m 1 CD C (D 0 3 3 - cQ O w 3 G 0 09 O :7 C (D r+ O c 0�.(D (A �� 3 v nm—O O r+ N v O Q cr M N �3 � (A r+ 00 O i w I O F l< m u CD N O R 0 A D cD N O O ,W O A Pb D log I 09 QO D n O A Ut D CD N O a O Ln D 4% a 09 S I (D O CD n (D -� p +O-Q Q 3 N cD O n ,-► fD rt :3 n (Q 77 N CD n CD CD N O O R N O 7 W 0 Lin " 4-,; low'. Ago Ri Q <, (n 3 Zr (D �c O O C U) O_ZT 0 CD S, O W CO v -41 CD N O 7 W G) A a = N c4 W N (D O (D A OD o D W Ul n %we K W (D M O U CD O C � ID o l(D Im O D 3 w �3 0- CD `G (CD N ,4W Q C CD CD � C CAD N O 1 < — Q Z CD 0 O t cD En .r 6 O -nj b :> (D N 0 7 W CCD N O O w G) " ' V EM # a `G s Km m o_ o (D ��h 0 C N �� O -o 0 (D p O Q fD O o ��- IN n C�� ((DD O :T 0 (p O B. (n p 3 N D (D v ,c 13 v Q -a h (D c C D (D 0- O a- (D (D CD a) N O (D (D rLI W (D (D OIA w 0 D U_ M 0 ��, O (D 019 L- c N O N O O v 0 ro !D N O w v (D O 0) o D tD I O (D N O 7 w G) c = N ai P N N CD O O o D W CD Go .n =3 0 (Dm • v 7 ram+ 0 cD (D ri v (D n 77 CQ O E U) tD .a .71 a (D N 00 V ►4 ON I CD F 1410 (D 0 n 0 rn N O O w D (C N 00 W N CD O O m V O '< co n D (D D V K O M 3f4 I� y ot a r �'- �3 O ci o r+ Q O � r* "0 a) CD • J (D O C) C) Q N O '� h N W O v (D i y Q W CD I O v D cD N O 7 I 09 Co 09 Iw N 70 (D707C3 O N K20,zzX Ul m 0 ao 0 r— CD p O CD� 3 :03) �(7 (D D N N _o Ln L Ct rn Z3 cn (CD m Imo" 0 —0 -0 O co f m 0 z CD O (n 3 (i (D 0-0 (D N O W V) cp �. (� N O CD N O W o �Q (0 N CD N 00 0 A V vN i D O N 7C3 ���� r O -�' u 7C, N m m r O N ® CD �mp x (C) ' QO CU '< �m0 < x M 00 u v pry ; v Or D _ (DN _ �_ : (Dz c O O� O O cD cn (7 m N (n 3 n m N co � n 70 cD � n '0 O '0 `A { CIA m >cUc 0 09 CD CO G A m N O 7 fD N O ti 0 00 D V- o a 09 3�4 v v U -4cm Tuu'3 1608051 DOD Sbbtf ld'9'r A-laV anual%v Tsi AS 001 z -13 0 O 3hc A� r 0 1 *an . Q Q yK r yN s Al" •- �E r r3M W bR ]t .�.► y % V CD N O 3 w M (D ppm (D CD � o O 10 �au•y�noallNnJ' Ia!ucF.t�woyew I1ewg L608)51 DOD `yieag � D 6586•S£9 (195) nj Sbbff 13 Seila�j 9 SRMZ£ MO 11"0 aOuz,.%V yySf AAS 001Z _ WI..VAUOJ Irlm.9 pM jnJ.'D Aauoyew ueQ *DNI `S I�IOI ��I�IOH'E� ICI ^u 09 Q at a 1 tip.rn l$S3 r b t tt~ j t+l r � 0 M I CD N O O w C) � A 00 A 0 v. :fps :�c Ele • k,"W N (D (D C� G m N O M A 0 A 00 D O o rn v OCD C N O D N =* O Q CO C L OC (D (Q O 0 < (/) A X x —� (D o (D O v dm O < n � (D 3 D w G) Q � 0 A N, �-+ O O O r+ fD ED D r+ FAN N O D I (D N O D W G) V � 0 © to j Ul rn T rn O N rn - co O (D N v O • o O _� rn Q U Q v 3 F O �, 00 cu ro CDSU O .0 O v D O ro O O 0) ❑_ N r+ • O o \./ O v, co O- O 0- o r+ O W O O � ro 6� W co Ul 0 CJt m O W H CD a m o - - CD C M o .-+ 2.0 N CD p 0 ID r+ (p v �Q O `C 0 m < v Q 7C C N C CD r-r r-t C CD N O W 0 M CD N O O W G) I� 09 09 C Q -� (D ram+ 0 O 00 c p N A � O O D (D -,% (D ED I O M CL (D O N � to '{ � p o co o w D N n 'O A O (D o Ul (D - �_ (D o a q (Z (: (Z (1) rn 0 Qi O O o rn O o VT rn S) 0 CD 3 � O p N G) � � O A C• � • CSl 0� r-r (/j O a '� 0) (.31 o C�_ C7i G E C w o A v OC: 0O a) DO rf- (n .rl+ � N :D r-+ O0 � - (D Q • • CD N O w G) O v� CD N O 7 w 0 CD O _ r—+ v, ,-+ Ul ui N 0 W v C C 00 cn N i (Q O r-F � O Ul CY � (D O V � A O O � M G cu N O fD j fD � O O fD to A Ul 00 :3 3 0 00 p _ "aD N (D 0- D `p � rF Qi V p (n rn Z O n W CD CD Q (Q r-r r-r I W ' (D 6; D _ r� m °0 o co fD cn � V rt - r+ CU rn O w G7 .. rn IO p Q (D D m o W Di n on cx 3 O O o co o LQ r h at a Mi 2 c, 3. � o Ul O O - o '^ 3 tY ,� ®rn O O O 3 cn O C .� • OT J J N' r-3T 7 `^Y, • � (n W N• � /=3 CD CCI °_° omm 0 o �s m Ul 2, 7 M mm o � � V W G) N � � C7i � I � C V _ m C O co W D IJ • < (D N Q 2 � W G) i i I � � O O co D Ail CD n o O W o n 3 CJ7 rn -t, r+ v W o = C3i N O � � n A C7 n V w OUl 00 7 o� D ti Q(D c3 CD FD A O N r+ O rt o 115 c� �' � rt N 7 �� A ✓� W G7 D C V00 Cn O) loopW 0 0 O N A Q i11 `� rn O � co 3 O cfl D o A O � 0 D M # a Z O r-h 7. A CD (7 � (D Q w c� G CD N O w rn 0 � OC O (3)(A N Op \✓ `G v tnD rr = (D tQ (D O O 1 N V N O• 3 CD O 6-0- ' m o A 3 : r+� m CQ O cn v ? m cn °`� r+ Z- O m otQ 3 o cfl N O co a ° ° o 3 (Q O c� o V) co w © O N O 0 � CCD 0 0 C O 0 C;) 7 ��../ O N r+ Is (Q 0) to o N �" p D C p O m m Oo W ,a r-+ Ri O) 0 (J1 NO A (pzT N to fD fD N (D < -+ CD �_ A `G v r+ fD N r-+ S O cl) W O CD O 3 ;7 CD 0 0 CSi C G m (D W CD N O W d) Q (N (D A W C Co A N cD Ul r_+ N cr (D o W 0) O Q {31 r+ A O CD 1 (D O "a Ln co D Q 00 W Q 0 C O �- Ln O E O Q Q d) 3 zr Q cO fn 0 C oorb O n cn Q • cn cfl CD Q A O NO co 0 �• N D Z N O 0 0 0 { A O +n W 0 CY) N { � S A O O { O O c4 fD � ma OPM 41 rases A C O W x m s N q. o — 0 CA � nni to m .y O m 10 (Sp 0 cQ m 0 0 3 m m m m 3 0 A rn 00 10 0 0 3 3 co W ME Cl) 0 fl. o ,rt c � � m m m 0 N O � 7 m =r m m c c m o � C — m 10, I; 1' Ob 4'J Af U) zr U) (D M Cn l< -01 > R D , Z3 0 w r-j W CD- z3- E� 00 of, 1, X ED O Ln zy- o m 0 UD LO U) 13 0 Z) 0 Z3 cn ��. r LXF at a 09 A• v Ado i n CD N O D R 0 ro N O 7 I 0 M 0 MM 00 r--F 00 W rF 3 CD n zT m Ln n a V N O N M U K O n U) U) 0 � m v Qo • N • • 0 cr 0 (D • caI:- m 0 70 _ p #-+ 0 v (D O cfl I ``� `G 3 W < (D o r-+ O r+ � (D (D O `< n � 0 OL) D Q 0 (D ,--� O � o 3 a) O" cis O 0 C: � to O CQ N � (D -+* 00 u v 0 3 X' < r+ - T. _ _ K v � 0 O O v 4- ot a 1 09 G 170 O O Q 3 ? O Q O < (aO m C n T. o CD 0 <m�.� 0O O O O •J @ O N O O .0 C r+ 3 o m m (D •J I w CD N O R '1 cr O cp. cr c Q 0 O 2 `< l< O 0 (D Q •� O :. (CD Q (D C dt a ♦e 10 K� 09 zr O c O 0 O 'C 5 O cc Q 0-5 3 O CD C :3 N sO W O U1 W W W 1 V CD V CD N O O G. I f < �O 0 =r Q 01, CD h .- O N O n O O 6-3 O CQ �• r ^O N v b 0 w Z fD Q V) G (D N O m � N '� N 0 0 �� _,,� O -_*� O a Q' O n �' `< (D QCD O lD CD N iD A OP � A A TAV 4 < CD N O 7 + co C31 N v � a 00 w N �A v " N O D C O 00 x x O_ S O N N W CU W O N CD A 1 C�� a) l< Cr L 2 2) CD ii 9 0 M w R m N O O - ,O o ! C O O �� 1 iD ._ D trr ! O O CD h l< oo w• v K tc4m V' G) S a) (oD O (DD ° n ` v `:' Q O O CD (D 3 (D r+ � O � (D N O 7 W V. • N O R c *t a O U) (DD 0 a C� � o O •J � O CD < � O • Ql 3 A ^ c Ul cfl � 0 N N v 00 � W ai _I N O 7 I A D a C CD N O 7 I D K dt a N O0 can c� ,{ ET K C� C N O CD M Q O E R N A n N O 0 N Ln D 4 n n Q cu '< r+ c: v O Cn (D n O Q r+ • • 010 F, m N O Q ( � 3 G) Q � = U1 13 C (D N �< f i O C � f cQ D o (C) O A O Q =r Cn O O O Q D (D 0 O _ - r C A N O O d � CD Q � (Q Q. N D C: O Q N i9 m N O w G) 'a D CD K O '-+ O "' (D N CD Q r-F c0 (D rn m : fD (D r+ ClA CD m (D r+ O A v Cl O K O O t ww o 00 (a �, p O n r+ C o • v N (p N — w (D p CT A N O v O O p fD r+ CD r+ (D �O CL N� fD (D `< :7 r-+ p fD O (D =' p (D (D W CD N O R Ln D 09 _ O o O cn Q �70co D O CD o O O =3 W N cr Q dt a 11 CD O (Nn D K CD N O 7 I� 7murk t , _ r O 3�4ci f I � s� Fq 0 :e Tag �. coo nor C) - 5 i a. 196 I T 1* L 0,: vp 14 O 36 4050 Ct! AV 1 N W G) ro I N O 7 W G) N t . N 0 L g O 0C�CAvO O C �CC N0 � CD a 0O O� -p(Dn CD 0 .1 0cO cn 3 O < 07 O n CL (D (D v a)�`< X 'S — F ? O O CD O �' C O O O 0-cr ,{ M N G7 rr != O (D C O v O N O 0- C n r+ N v (n cn � '� Q c� ,{ cD • O Q O (n -t+ (D N O I ('1 " ��4 Aw 3 :3 CD o V r+ Cn ? �� co .3 : a _(a o CD A 0 r+ (Q n (cD C -a o r+ CD o CD -t 0 CL v o 3 �� O r+ m 3 n O r+ m 3 n n 4 CD N 11) (D r+ rt ®� m00v��0o CO CD cr ID ,{ OL)O N=� -� O o K CD ry C) (D fD coy O v `-+ '�• N fD n D a1 O� L7 = N N CD l< CD © O © 4 N ® cn .-+ a) N � 0 v' w r+ rn w � JN w N M 0 O G) r+ N rn o cfl o --., co o O �+ Q o_ w o w O v Ul _ w W N o O N CD f�D iv fD CD rr � O co = N O (p 'a D O O =_ G7 CD < CD CD © 0 c U1 0- < 2 U1 CD 0—. ZT (D : Ln - f C C °J G C� o m ro Ul o (D (DO O Q O (DD N N •J '4 N � AM, (DOJ ^' r CQ 0 r�-r < Q (Q O 8a o h � �+ zr y b (n C CD 1+ 70 O ,N+ O I ^ ^ (D N O I M < (D N O 7 W O 00 D m 'U � ram+ CD (Q (�D 2 0 O � n -h a)� Q CQ ro (D O � m (D O � o N s (D N ,..- �, 0-•�, cn : , : C (D 0 z CDm3 + 3 o �, ��� `D v�cQ �' oCc_o • O cr p CO �-+ O colCD O= (D co r+(o Ln N � -0 O O — .�-r• -O �• D V�i �_ CCD O O O n O r••+ CD � CD Vs r-r � CQ — � rN-+ T1 O O CD ^ O + CQ (D (Q r+ * Q% O ow a (D o N O . C) ZN rn V) U) '� N V) N - CQ O 00 J N �• CV)00 : (O O r-+ 1 O � (D O (D O W O Cfl O �' O OQ O � 0 O • Q. =i4 LT (D O C O O- M (D 0 N 00 CD (D 0 CD Q (D O Q su •.� N O © O • OR ® D rn zt r-r rn 3 D 3 � � CCD 0) n t � Q N T v (D • O Ln 77 rn O N U, 0 0) 0 C ((D < CD C co Q t7 (D (D A 7C" `< jo C)vOMo- m 0 C—) (D x O A .* (D +1 O (7 � � � Camo �- (DD O fA co 00) fn C: ZTUl Cn cQ —. O O O Q O O D 0 CTl CD A a W co to <' O � Q 00 n ( (D (Q 0 CD 0 CD n CD CL M O O v ZT a) CJt A 0 r-+ -_*3 o (D o --. v 5 O 3 C) 7 �oj cD Q O Q 0- v Q (D CD O �e K m N O Z) w W G) 0 v v `G Aw 1 0 a rn zy �...� r+ 7\ w !J N M r+ O ty N 0 0 CDCn 0 ,{ o r+ mCL < cD N 3 n D•O"p m x- O v (D a) n a (D v D. (Q r+ CD r+ O 77 K • w O Ln A c v o N O O D R (D z O °' CD 6i 0) O P; O Lo r o � m r-F cu ci CD N O 7 w CD O wo -0 D tD K (D N O W G) M v� OL a 0 CD �(D X N O � V � au•y'nosllNOlaiucpSauoycw;I!ewy L60WSI DOD v 6S96-90 (19S) xej swi SLZOSZ4(�56) 11'J anua.,yy�5f!)ASoolz • wxnwuo1) 1"im"o MOOD AauoyeW ueQ p *DNI `SAWOR ��I�IOH1dI�t 09 CJ Es 0/ I I M *k a A s at a to I n (D N O 1 w G) O M < (D N O 7 W 10 O G ri n O • OL a *k 0 00 c CD N CD CQ cr o Lz C CQ� O O z OD CL 0 z z (D c0 Q CD (D (D 3 tia 0) L 0 O 3 3 UD CD 0 -a��_ �'10•(zr w r+ M:3a r�-r < 0 C O 7 0) -4� !; M (D • :7 (D n (D a) i= CD .-i -� cc a)CL W Ul Q — CD M � n < Q- a� QCD CD 0 CD ��0CD 3 (D 3N 0 Q= (D(.0 I�COO 0 O (D (D O CD 00 0 3 U 0 M O 70 O O (D -0 OL) S G + - (D -< (D O _ (D (D _ r+ N O • ,-+ N (D p `< ((DD _ n � (D CD O rl 4 le =r= :3 O 3 v o: -0 O D- -- 0 (D o�0 70Cv cn S Q-0 O �- O (D rt n. (D r+ (D a1 CQ Q. -0 53 O c (D (D � (D n �-+ m (D N 3�v�c�D—O�-o� �o O N W LO N V co cD N O D W G) w N D w O w N D -41 at a #a K 70 O CD O 0 h r-F (D O O O CD (Q O CD 3 (D � N :3 I< 5. m N O D w -.A O .-. N U1 •_•• � W w N (D D 1 N N V w O v, 0 * a a O � CD N .-r h 0 m fD fD 9Ni lD 0 Ct R,n. w ��. N O �� CD CD Ij -f W (D (D Ql n �� " p w G) _V O) * �� O X_ X_ (D U) 0, - v v d co IJ  ' w rr ,1- w O O  �� N O iD W c_o 3 O CO W O M �� N v N V �� K K CD O (n (n 3 0 D r v z -4 rn M ro �� N O O C) w O �� 00 O cD w �� Q �� A O fD �� N D .y 0 Z -< 0 O S` a o rn (D a CD? ! CD Ilj K I-j CD - r+ O cn A cn w Q � (Q o 0)N r O rn o � X o V) rn � • • J �lx+c�i S1n41) a o 93 D � 3 L f Cr -s �? H Z 3 no a R r v o� , cil c r. CD 'a um � N W 1 � � 1 1 N •- 1 a -.4 U ( ww(1AC. 223Y C 0 � w Q' P 0 N O Z v 0CD fD 0 w m-C4 o tD '•► G 4 _ro w X; o L7 wm'D a 0 rt nr " k Zii W _ - D CD p O < p - CD ��- cs co Q m m r+- (Q Q 0--a N A O N O m O O' n CD o O N O �� CD c :3 A x _ _ '--F C CD O (D O CD 3 cn  co a LO v (D�� o c cQ CU h Q ic ��� Sc < o CD " (D 01 (D `< N O O A p _ to y o0 " V) N N P O O �� �� O ��< " 0 0 0 o 0) 3' D (D o rn �> O r? 3 rQ w O 6)CD C rah U (D G O (Q U) Q 3 v CD (D N O w 0 R 0 9 rk�� � 1• t i : T • 'I' - :�q I:�c W 0 W co C' -n 0 c ! 0_ Q 0 -coo 00 W W CD ZT �•�, t,`• 00 (D z (n (Q -' N fD yt 3 K� 09 3 ---I � - Q N Q T. a,Q G cu -0 Q C Q (D Zr (D 1C oa cro L Q C (D Zr Q g Q z cn Q Q n V) :3 N 1 Q f-+ m3�� ED C `< Q T. N c_ Q Q Q E :n ZD3 Q (Dr-F � � Q C Q _ N � < (D ZT (D N O O + W G) "n r� cr CD N O V m O N W D N � N W ro N O I �2 # a N O O w G3 # a cD N O W G� 0 O C-4 0 l<o�o0 o 3 ,'< ° �CC' cr � Q o � co� 'GO QO N (� U1 i D m CD En Q N : 0 in @ rF N IJ 1 :3 00 M O 70 � to O o o tQ m U1 0 CL W � V I w V D 0 0 v f(D rn ® O Lo N O CD A Q v M W O 0 O �< N .» • N O 'W (D < C51 o °° N fD .a Q�Q `C coN 0 CD • O m M -� o fD vCD 3 • • • n Fo 6. cD N O I �i 0 N O 1 go, 09 3r4 v l< # a 34 v C� CD n O 3 m 1 r_l cD N O O w 0 < CD N O 7 w Ln 0) 0 09 so • • H co N O 7 I W OD D m N O O W 0 W W D o a 0 (D Q U rn 0) O O W OD W O CSl CD N N CD O O F�1 W W D I 0 O D E' o � F D � � • • die; n a D o w T a N n � C r 3 ti O 3 g P » C O S m° o 9 � � � va m o� 9 0 R 0 09 i,f ■# ƒ} f®f � J -+■ ��- - ff | ƒ J /%7 / !�%�•!!&« !\� {`f({ ci f! � �� { . ;« • . � \$\ � � }\ � !■ � � � O � � $ § :3 R \ » � * / 0 :3 AA � » � � * w r-� Ul 1 00 O Cn al m O 3 m N O 3 1 m D r $ T. Q- W 0 cn p ° n °n o v o 0 o j' Q 3 ^° gt o 3 0 —�, CD o 7 x 3 m (OD (D r% C o n a � T 2 o a n v CD C'7 7 H O m m o - d ° _ O C h - o O O 3o p � � -h 3 N y Zn -� GO m n C a > ... O 0 :E F :my a �F`° _� = s �= N D m 2. < r. * o. 0 o °o oi o I � N 0 N N tD O_ � a A p O 7 y y 7 N O N N N fD rL 0)D CL x N =O N /n O A < cl ? OI to 0 (D CD d � a C 3 0 a m n o o a 0 0 o n m° m •J 7 y O S 0 /�� z^ N �D � r+ 3 m a x c x 3 a n C.n '` S n O N O N a 'r a < ° n a n o m .J x (D m ri m N o C O° I w I s -fi (n (n zr 3 v V o m 0-�`D3 v) � M m e+ QQ � J- � N C CL p "O co v o CQ (D (n (D � fD 0 p M �' N Q 3 cQ N o 0 O 0 C 0 O D 0C m w :3 3 O C4 (Q (D r+ Q C = C: (Q (n N < O � n .+ r+ "I N rt< 0 o o 0- MCD r-r :. M O 0 ,-� D T. (n c M(D (Q Q Q u 00 Ci a)O Q �. 0 M fDCU --h iD (Q r } fn cn � L•. �l .•. O 0) •P i O Ln Ut CD N 0 0 I CD N O w ¢z TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail February 26, 2021 Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: records@commerce-group.com] Re: GS #2812-9 (Request for Public Records Related to Martin O'Boyle Criminal Case) Request for Public Records Related to Martin O’Boyle Criminal Case 9. All text messages on any phone issued or used by the Town Police dating back to January 1, 2013. The word “phone” as used herein includes without limitation, phones in storage, phones in current use, phones previously used, and includes without limitation, personal phones in current use and previous use. Dear Martin E. O’Boyle [e-mail to: meo@commerce-group.com]: The original request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173216&repo=r-430100cc A partial production of subpart nine of your request can be found at the following link: https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/DocView.aspx?id=173530&repo=r-430100cc Thank you for your deposit of $96.76 by check #53426 received by the Town on January 22, 2021 for the public record request described above, seeking all text messages, with no content limitation, from any phone issued or used by the Town Police over an eight year period. Pursuant to your e-mail dated January 26, 2021 regarding GS #2812-6, and by reference all subparts of GS #2812 that seek text message records, the Town understands you seek these text message records in “native electronic format.” Please be advised that producing these records in their native electronic format exceeds the Town’s technological ability and legal responsibility under the Public Records Act. Generally, access to computerized records is provided through the use of programs currently in use by the public official responsible for maintaining the public records. It is not the intent of the Public Records Act to put public officials in the business of compiling charts and preparing documentary evidence. “The intent is rather to make available to the public information, which is a matter of public record, in some meaningful form, not necessarily that which the applicant prefers.” See Seigle v. Barry, 422 S. 2d 63, 66 (Fla. 4th DCA 1982); see also Tampa Television, Inc v. Clay Cty. Sch. Bd., 1993 WL 204090, at *2-3 (Fla. Cir. Ct. Feb. 11, 1993) (applying Seigle and stating that “[w]hile the public records act does not require [an agency] to compile lists or make special reports solely for [a requestor’s] benefit,” public records should be provided where they are “easily available” to the agency and “could have been produced at a minimum of time or expense”). An agency is not required to furnish electronic records in a format other than the format routinely used by the agency. See also Op. Att’y Gen. Fla. 97-39 (1997) (“[A] school district is not required to furnish its electronic public records in an electronic format other than the standard format routinely maintained by the district.”). If you would like these records in the format regularly and customarily provided to you in response to other public records requests during the past eight years, please let us know and we will continue with our production of these records. If this is not sufficient and you would prefer to withdraw your request, please let us know and the Town will refund your deposit. If we do not hear back from you within 30 days, we will refund your deposit and consider your request withdrawn. Sincerely, Reneé Basel As Requested by Rita Taylor Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records