HomeMy Public PortalAbout08 August 12, 2004 Citizens AdvisoryRECORDS
8761 V
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTA TION COMMISSION
CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMITTEE/
SOCIAL SERVICES TRANSPORTATION ADVISORY COUNCIL
www. rctc. org
AGENDA *
*Actions may be taken on any item listed on the agenda
11:30 A.M.
Thursday, August 12, 2004
COUNTY ADMINISTRATIVE CENTER
4080 Lemon Street, Riverside, CA 92501
Conference Room A, 3rd Floor
In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Government Code Section
54954.2, if you need special assistance to participate in a Commission meeting, please
contact the clerk of the Commission at (951) 787-7141. Notification of at least 48 hours
prior to meeting time will assist staff in assuring that reasonable arrangements can be made
to provide accessibility at the meeting.
PLEASE NOTE: The Chairperson of the CAC/SSTAC kindly
requests that cell phones be turned off during the meeting.
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. ROLL CALL
3. PUBLIC COMMENTS
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
5. ADDITIONS/REVISIONS (The CAC may add an item to the agenda after
making a finding that there is a need to take immediate action on the item
and that the item came to the attention of the CAC subsequent to the
posting of the agenda. An action adding an item to the agenda requires 2/3
vote of the Committee. If there are less than 2/3 of the CAC members
present, adding an item to the agenda requires a unanimous vote. Added
items will be placed for discussion at the end of the agenda.)
Citizens' Advisory Committee/
Social Services Transportation Advisory Council
August 12, 2004
Page 2
6. OVERVIEW OF CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES ON THE 60/91/215
INTERCHANGE
Overview
This item is for the CAC/SSTAC to:
Pg. 1
1) Receive and file the report on the construction activities on the
60/91/215 interchange. Dennis Green, Caltrans' Construction
Liaison, will make a presentation on the construction improvements to
the interchange and segments of each of the freeways that serve it.
7. MEASURE "A" SPECIALIZED TRANSIT TAXI DEMONSTRATION PROGRAM
Pg. 2
Overview
This item is for the CAC/SSTAC to:
1) Receive and file the status report on the Measure "A" Specialized
Transit Taxi Demonstration Program.
8. COMMITTEE MEMBER COMMENTS AND INFORMATION
Overview
This item provides the opportunity for the Committee Members to report on
attended and upcoming meetings/conferences and issues related to
Committee activities.
9. ADJOURNMENT
The next Citizens' Advisory Committee/Social Services Transportation
Advisory Council meeting is scheduled to be held at 11:30 A.M., Thursday,
February 10, 2005, Riverside County Transportation Commission, County
Administrative Center, 4080 Lemon Street, Riverside, CA 92501, 3`d Floor,
Conference Room A.
Proposed meeting dates for 2005 are:
February 10
May 12
August 11
MINUTES
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMITTEE/
SOCIAL SERVICES TRANSPORTATION ADVISORY COUNCIL
Minutes
May 13, 2004
1. CALL TO ORDER
The Citizens' Advisory Committee/Social Services Transportation Advisory
Council was called to order by Judy Nieburger at 11:40 A.M. at the Riverside
County Transportation Commission Offices, 4080 Lemon Street, Riverside,
California 92501.
Members Present
Peter Benavidez, Blindness Support Services
Jim Collins, Include Me, Inc.
Judylynn Gries, RTA (representing Grant
Bradshaw)
Leslie Grosjean, SunLine Transit Agency
Judy Nieburger, Office of Supervisor Ashley
Mike Pistilli, City of Beaumont
Andrea Puga, City of Moreno Valley
Mary Venerable, Office of Supervisor Buster
Members Absent
Cindy Scheirer, Office of
Supervisor Tavaglione
Sherry Thibodeaux, Community
Access Center
Also in Attendance:
Shirley Gooding, RCTC
Tanya Love, RCTC
Chris Millen, City of Banning
Anne Palatino, RTA
Victoria Paz, City of Riverside
Viren Shah, City of Corona
2. PUBLIC COMMENTS
There were no public comments.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
M/S/C (Venerable/Grosjean) to approve the February 5, 2004 Minutes.
4. PALO VERDE VALLEY TRANSIT AGENCY — UNMET NEEDS HEARING
Tanya Love, RCTC, provided a Powerpoint Presentation that described the
requests for services received through the "Unmet Transit Needs Hearing"
process.
Citizens' Advisory Committee/
Social Services Transportation Advisory Council
May 13, 2004
Page 2
M/S/C (Collins/Puga) to approve the finding that there are no unmet transit
needs which can be reasonably met in the Palo Verde Valley.
5. FY 2004/05 FY 2006/07 SHORT RANGE TRANSIT PLAN
Tanya Love summarized the Short Range Transit Plans of the transit agencies
and answered related questions. Some agency representatives gave a brief
overview of activities related to their specific programs.
M/S/C (Collins/Puga) to approve the Short Range Transit Plans in concept
only.
6. RESULTS OF SECTION 5310 LOCAL REVIEW COMMITTEE
Ms. Love indicated that Judylynn Gries, RTA, and Peter Benavides, Blindness
Support, served along with Tanya Love on a Local Review Committee. They
reviewed and scored five (5) applications for Section 5310 funds, which is
Federal Transit Administration financing available through Caltrans, for the
purpose of capital projects.
Peter Benavidez spoke favorably about the review process. Judylynn Gries
acknowledged Tanya Love's time and effort in assisting applicants to gain
maximum points.
7. COMMITTEE MEMBER COMMENTS AND INFORMATION
Jim Collins stated that the Coachella Valley concert was sold out.
Peter Benavidez said that since Measure "A" was a result of voters' choices,
about a year ago he developed a plan in conjunction with the local registrar of
voters to provide training on the accessible electronic voting machines.
Recently, the Secretary of State said that the machines could no longer be
utilized. Mr. Benavidez further stated that he joined in a lawsuit against the
Secretary of State for decertifying the machines in Riverside County.
Citizens' Advisory Committee/
Social Services Transportation Advisory Council
May 13, 2004
Page 3
8. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business for consideration by the Citizens' Advisory
Committee/Social Services Transportation Advisory Council, the meeting
adjourned at 1:30 P.M. The next meeting is scheduled for 11:30 A.M., August
12, 2004 at the Riverside County Transportation Commission, 4080 Lemon
Street, Riverside 92501.
Respectfully submitted,
da'VA, "� f/jtik'-
Tanya Lo
Program Manager
AGENDA ITEM 6
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTA TION COMMISSION
DATE:
August 12, 2004
TO:
Citizens' Advisory Committee/Social Services Transportation
Advisory Council
FROM:
Tanya Love, Program Manager
THROUGH
Cathy Bechtel, Director of Transportation Planning and Policy
Development
SUBJECT:
60/91/215 Interchange
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
This item is for the CAC/SSTAC to:
Receive and file the report on construction activities on the 60/91/215 interchange.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION:
The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), the Riverside County
Transportation Commission (RCTC) and the Federal Highway Administration
(FHWA) are working in partnership to construct improvements to the 60/91/215
interchange and segments of each of the freeways that serve it. This project is
one of the largest and most complex projects in the Inland Empire.
Accelerated growth over the past two decades has resulted in increased commuter
and interregional traffic. Projected growth makes these improvements necessary to
relieve congestion and improve mobility across the region. The scope of the
project includes freeway widening; adding, removing and upgrading local
interchanges; providing new freeway connectors and a truck bypass connector;
and construction of retaining and sound walls and other associated improvements
to reduce congestion and enhance freeway operations and safety. The project area
consists of approximately six miles of 1-215 and shorter segments of state routes
60 and 91 through the cities of Riverside and Moreno Valley.
Funding for the $317M in construction and right-of-way costs for this project will
come from federal, state and local sources. Construction has begun and is
expected to continue through 2007.
Dennis Green, Caltrans' Construction Liaison, will provide a presentation on the
construction project.
1
AGENDA ITEM 7
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTA TION COMMISSION
DATE:
August 12, 2004
TO:
Citizens' Advisory Committee/Social Services Transportation
Advisory Council
FROM:
Tanya Love, Program Manager
THROUGH:
Cathy Bechtel, Director of Transportation Planning and Policy
Development
SUBJECT:
Measure "A" Specialized Transit Taxi Demonstration Program
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
This item is for the CAC/SSTAC to:
1) Receive and file the status report on the Measure "A" Specialized
Transit Taxi Demonstration Program.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION:
In October, 2003, the Commission working in partnership with the Riverside
Transit Agency (RTA) implemented a taxi demonstration program utilizing Measure
"A" Specialized Transit Funds. Since its inception, no senior passengers have been
denied transportation and the need to move equipment (from one city to another)
to handle changing passenger demands has been minimal. Statistics for the first
nine months of the program revealed that the average cost of a taxi trip was
$21.10; in comparison, the average cost of the trip if RTA provided the service
was estimated at $33.50.
Overall, the program is receiving high marks from both passengers and operators
and based on the data available, the program appears to be successful both in
terms of cost effectiveness and increased availability of transportation services for
seniors.
Statistical Data
The attached spreadsheets provide a statistical overview of the taxi demonstration
program including trip type. The following is provided as highlights of the program:
• A total of 21,043 trips have been provided. Of those trips, 9,857
passenger trips were surveyed to determine trip purpose. A large
majority of the trips were for medical (55.16%), followed by shopping
(11.32%) and 10.04% of the trips were to senior centers;
2
• Approximately 1,905 of the 21,043 taxi trips (9.05%) were shared
rides which translate into cost savings as more than one passenger is
being driven to the same location;
• Three taxi providers have signed contracts to provide transportation
services. They consist of:
- AA Inland Empire Taxi
Provides service throughout western Riverside
10 taxi cabs dedicated to the program
- Bell Cab
Provides service throughout western Riverside
25 taxi cabs dedicated to the program
- Southern California Red Top Cab
Serving the Temecula, Murrieta and Sun City area
7 cabs dedicated to the program
Overview of Taxi Program
The following information is provided as background information on the taxi
program:
• The taxi program is available to provide transportation to all areas in
western Riverside County that are currently provided transportation by
RTA, the cities of Banning, Beaumont, Corona and Riverside Special
Services.
• Passengers (residing in the geographical areas that transit providers
currently serve) request a trip by calling the transit service provider. If
it is determined that existing transit providers can not accommodate
the request, RTA refers the trip to Diversified Paratransit Inc. (DPI)
which is responsible for scheduling the trip with contracted taxi
providers.
Transportation provided by taxi service includes:
- Passengers bumped to create space for Americans with
Disabilities (ADA) priority passengers;
- Trips that result in efficiencies for the public transit
agencies; and
3
- Trips that provide better access for passengers (those
with serious illness or need for daily treatments such as
dialysis, therapy, etc.).
• Passengers pay the same fare whether they are transported by taxi or
the traditional dial -a -ride vehicle.
Program Administration and Oversight
The Commission entered into a contract with DPI to provide program administration
and oversight during the taxi demonstration program. While RTA provides
reservation and dispatching functions for the program, DPI provides accounting and
oversight functions including customized data collection and reporting as well as
trip and invoice verification. From inception of the program through the end of
June 2004, $60,950 has been spent to cover administrative costs.
Program Efficiencies
As stated previously, high priority is given to trips that result in inefficiencies for
the public transit agency including trips that require equipment moves to
accommodate demand and cancelled trips due to ADA mandates as these trips can
be provided by taxi companies at a cost savings. Prior to the implementation of
the taxi demonstration program, RTA was bumping passengers and moving
equipment to accommodate trip requests. RTA staff provided the following
statistics (based on a random sampling of September 2003 data) on the daily
average number of passengers bumped and the number of equipment moves to
meet passenger demand:
• "Bumped" 6.72 seniors, 1.54 persons with disabilities and 2.09
general public passengers; and
• On average, 12.57 routes were changed to accommodate the demand
for ADA trips (moved equipment from one run to another location to
handle the fluctuation in passenger load capacity).
Since inception of the taxi program, RTA has not bumped any passengers and has
not moved any equipment (from one city to another) to handle changing passenger
demands.
Attachment: Statistical data and trip type reports (excel)
4
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
MEASURE "A" SPECIALIZED TRANSIT TAXI DEMONSTRATION PROGRA M
SUMMARY: ALL TRIPS/ALL TAXI PROVIDERS
AA INLAND BELL CAB RED TOP
PERIODS
October 6 -17, 2003
O ctober 20 - 31, 2003
November 3 - 14, 2003
November 17 - 30, 2003
December 1 - 15, 2003
December 16 - 31, 2003
January 1 - 15, 2004
January 16 - 31, 2004
February 1 -15, 2004
February 16 - 29, 2004
March 1 - 12, 2004
March 15 - 31, 2004
April 1 -15, 2004
April 16 - 30, 2004
May 1 - 15, 2004
May 17 - 28, 2004
June 1 - 15, 2004
June 16 - 30, 2004
TOTALS
BILLING TRIPS SH ARE TRIPS BILLING TRIPS SHARE TRIPS BILLING TRIPS SHARE TRIPS
$1,044.10 77 1 $3,650.94 257 14 $0.00 0 0
$3,779.60 228 14 $5,994.38 306 5 $0.00 0 0
$5,393.40 296 12 $4,835.76 259 7 $0.00 0 0
$7,098.25 363 27 $6,246.70 295 9 $0.00 0 0
$8,516. 26 530 33 $9,668.13 557 13 $0.00 0 0
$7,264.80 472 37 $10,153.74 572 25 $0.00 0 0
$11,940.00 683 62 $12,119.96 600 46 $0.00 0 0
$12,885. 80 706 79 $13,371.62 689 40 $0.00 0 0
$11,612.40 629 62 $12,253 .69 656 38 $952.96 61 0
$0. 00 0 0 $19,033.86 901 59 $3,760.05 246 0
$0. 00 0 0 $20,916.77 878 70 $3,989.70 210 0
$0. 00 0 0 $26,183.77 1153 95 $4,553 .60 285 0
$4,852. 40 252 11 $23,531.47 1007 95 $4,441 .97 277 0
$9,395.25 433 27 $22,662.54 932 60 $5,646.86 330 0
$8,195.00 367 72 $18,108.60 746 122 $5,310.30 311 6
$8,655. 93 331 82 $16,788.24 645 81 $5,790.70 272 6
$10,533.61 362 166 $23,508.50 862 138 $7,644.86 406 8
$8,407.60 327 87 $25,815.72 896 176 $7,547.00 378 20
$119,574. 40 6,056 772 $274,844. 39 12,211 1,093 $49,638.00 2,776 40
TOTAL FOR ALL COMPANIES $444,056. 79 21,043 1,905
TOTAL COST PER TRIP $21.10
TOTAL % OF SHARE TRIPS 9.05%
8/5/2004
5
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION CO MMISSION
MEASURE "A" SPECIALIZED TRANSIT TAXI DEMONSTRATION PROGRAM
TRIP TYPE
Trips Avg . Trips/Day Medical Pharmacy Grocery Shopping Senior Ctr Recreation Banking Other
TOTALS 10/03 - 12/03 4,212 69.05 976 19 102 338 320 92 25 155
TOTALS 1/04 - 3/04 7,697 118 .42 1,614 31 134 345 240 89 30 251
TOTALS 4/04 - 6/04 9,134 138.39 2,847 129 154 433 430 118 68 917
TOTALS 21,043 109.60 5,437 179 390 1,116 990 299 123 1,323
Of the 21,043 trips provided, 9,857 passenger trips were tracked to determine trip purpose.
Following is a summary:
Medical 55.16%
Shopping 11.32%
Senior Centers 10.04%
Other 13.42%
Grocery 3.96%
Recreation 3. 03%
Pharmacy 1.82%
Banking 1.25%
8/5/2004
6