The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My Public Portal AboutPRR 23-2929 Renee Basel From:Jane Swanko <janeswanko@usa.net> Sent:Friday, February 24, 2023 12:56 PM To:Renee Basel Subject:Records Request \[You don't often get email from janeswanko@usa.net. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification \] \[NOTICE: This message originated outside of the Town of Gulfstream -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe.\] Good afternoon Ms. Basel: This is a records request for the following: 1. Please provide when notice was given for the February 10, 2023 Commission Hearing and by what means? 2. Please provide any and all records in the past 21 years regarding golf cart injuries to a person and/or a dog, as a direct result of a Gulf Stream resident running their dog. 3. Please provide any and all records in the past 21 years regarding a golf cart injury to a person and/or a dog as a direct result of Jane Souaid running her dog. 4. Please provide any and all records in the past three years of complaints involving Peter A. Lyons inclusive of his verbal abuse and assaults on Jane Souaid while she was running her dog on a golf cart. Thank you for your time and attention to this request and have a nice weekend. Janie Souaid 305-333-7979 1 TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail February 28, 2023 Jane Souaid [mail to: janeswanko@usa.net] Re: GS #2929 (Golf cart and dog) This is a records request for the following: 1. Please provide when notice was given for the February 10, 2023 Commission Hearing and by what means? 2. Please provide any and all records in the past 21 years regarding golf cart injuries to a person and/or a dog, as a direct result of a Gulf Stream resident running their dog. 3. Please provide any and all records in the past 21 years regarding a golf cart injury to a person and/or a dog as a direct result of Jane Souaid running her dog. 4. Please provide any and all records in the past three years of complaints involving Peter A. Lyons inclusive of his verbal abuse and assaults on Jane Souaid while she was running her dog on a golf cart. Dear Jane Souaid [mail to: janeswanko@usa.net]: The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated February 24, 2023. You should be able to view your original request at the following link: PRR 23-2929 (laserfiche.com) As to number one of your request, upcoming events are on the Town’s website. The Town Commission typically meets every second Friday of every month. The ARPB typically meets every fourth Thursday of every month except for August. The agenda for the monthly meeting is on the website a week in advance of the meeting and also on the bulletin board at Town Hall. As to numbers two and three, many of these records would have met their retention requirements, and therefore, there are no such records responsive to those requests. And as to number four, you can review the response at the above link. We consider this request closed. Sincerely, Reneé R. Basel, CMC Reneé R Basel, CMC Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 01/04/2023 6:26 PM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230020 CASE •• • ORIGINAL DESCRIPTION JUVENILE? GANG RELATED? USE OF FORCE OLICE SERVICE NO NO NO EXACT TIME? INCIDENT DATE/FROM NCIDENT TIME/FROM INCIDENT DATE TO INCIDENT TIME TO DAY OF WEEK NO 01/04/2023 16:57 01/04/2023 17:08 SUPPLEMENT DATE FROM DATE TIME TO DATE TIME STATUS CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY DATE CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY INACTIVE NOT APPLICABLE OFFENSE KNOWN OFFENSE FDLE CODE CHARGE TYPE CHARGE SEVERITY ORDINANCE # STATE STATUTE STATUTE DESCRIPTION COUNTS INCREASED PENALTY TYPE OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY(up to 3) TYPE OF WEAPON FORCE (UP TO 3) SUSPECTED OF USING ATTEMPTED HATE CRIME BIAS MOTIVATION FOR HATE CRIME CARGO THEFT CHILD PRESENT VEHICLE LOCATION OF OFFENSE LOCATION TYPE AT BUSINESS? COMPANY NAME SCHOOL/COLLEGE YES GULF STREAM SCHOOL STREET # PRE DIRECTION STREET NAME POSE DIRECTION STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3600 GULF STREAM ROAD CITY STATE ZIP AT LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE PASSAGE POINT METHOD OFFENSE STRUCTURES GULF STREAM FL 33483 I ENTERED QUANTITY ZONE 2 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO NONE YES IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX JANE SOUAID ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3860 BERMUDA LANE 5 CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL (305)333-7979 REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 01/04/2023 6:26 PM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230020 Lolo m JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO NONE NO IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX PETER LYONS ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 355 GULF STREAM ROAD CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL (240)372-6965 • •� to, FIRST NAME LAST NAME BADGE # RANK JOHN PASSEGGIATA 748 SERGEANT SIGNATURE METHOD OFFICER SIGNATURE SIGNATURE DATE IGNATURE TIME ELECTRONIC 01/04/2023 18:32 ADMINISTRATIVE ROUTED TO REFERRED TO ASSIGNED TO ASSIGNED BY JAIL # OBTS # SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME, THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY THIS DAY OF , 20 SIGNATURE OF PERSON ADMINISTERING OATH NAME (PRINTED) TITLE 2 of REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT I AGENCY CASE# ORIGINAL 01/04/2023 6:26 PM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT 1 230020 )URING PATROL I WAS FLAGGED DOWN BY GULF STREAM RESIDENT MRS. JANE SOUAID. VIRS SOUAID STATED " I WAS RIDING MY GOLF CART MINDING MY OWN BUSINESS DOWN 3ULF STREAM RD WITH MY DOG AND THAT MAN WITH THE TWO LABS YELLED AT ME AND I -OLD ME "GET OUT OF HERE, GET OUT OF HERE", I FELT THREATENED AND NEVER BEEN 30 EMBARRASSED, THERE IS NO REASON FOR THIS. I WAS JUST RIDING WITH MY DOG %ND MINDING MY OWN BUSINESS. THIS HAS TO STOP, SOMEONE NEEDS TO SAY 30METHING TO HIM". THE MAN WITH THE TWO DOGS IS MR. PETER LYONS. I LOCATED kND INTERVIEWED MR. LYONS IN FRONT OF HIS HOUSE. HE ADMITTED HE YELLED AT ORS. SOUAID, BUT STATED "I TOLD HER TO TURN BECAUSE SHE GET'S MY DOGS CRAZY, kND SOMEONE IS GOING TO GET HURT". I EXPLAINED TO MR. LYONS THAT MRS. SOUAID S NOT VIOLATING ANY LAWS, AND IF THERE IS A PROBLEM TO CALL THE POLICE, ALSO kDVISED TO PLEASE REFRAIN FROM YELLING AT ANYONE. IT COULD BE INTERPRETED AS k VERBAL ASSAULT. NOTHING FURTHER. END. 1 3 of 3 R6'IRTTYPE REPORTDATE REPORTTIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 03/27/2023 3:50 PM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230563 CASE INFORMATION ORIGINAL DESCRIPTION JUVENILE? GANG RELATED? USE OF FORCE NIMAL COMPLAINT/NON TOV NO NO NO EXACT TIME? INCIDENT DATE/FROM NCIDENT TIME/FROM INCIDENT DATE TO INCIDENT TIME TO DAY OF WEEK NO 03/27/2023 15:00 03/27/2023 15:10 SUPPLEMENT DATE FROM DATE TIME TO DATE TIME STATUS CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY DATE CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY INACTIVE NOT APPLICABLE OFFENSE KNOWN OFFENSE FDLE CODE CHARGE TYPE CHARGE SEVERITY ORDINANCE # STATE STATUTE STATUTE DESCRIPTION COUNTS INCREASED PENALTY TYPE OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY(up to 3) TYPE OF WEAPON FORCE (UP TO 3) SUSPECTED OF USING ATTEMPTED HATE CRIME BIAS MOTIVATION FOR HATE CRIME CARGO THEFT CHILD PRESENT I VEHICLE LOCATION OF OFFENSE LOCATION TYPE AT BUSINESS? COMPANY NAME RESIDENCE/HOME NO STREET # PRE DIRECTION STREET NAME POST DIRECTION STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3550 GULF STREAM ROAD CITY STATE ZIP LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE PASSAGE POINT METHOD OFFENSE STRUCTURES GULF STREAM FL �AT 33483 I ENTERED QUANTITY ZONE 2 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO YES IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX PETER LYONS ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3550 GULF STREAM ROAD CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT (240)372-6965 REPORTTYPE REPORTDATE REPORTTIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 03/27/2023 3:50 PM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230563 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO NO IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX JANE SOUAID ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3860 BERMUDA LANE CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT • • • FIRST NAME LAST NAME BADGE # RANK JOHN HASELEY 727 CAPTAIN SIGNATURE METHOD OFFICER SIGNATURE SIGNATURE DATEJIGNA�TURE TIME ELECTRONIC�� X 03/27/2023:54 I ADMINISTRATIVE ROUTED TO REFERRED TO ASSIGNED TO —7ASSIGNED BY JAIL # OBTS # SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME, THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY THIS DAY OF , 20 SIGNATURE OF PERSON ADMINISTERING OATH NAME (PRINTED) TITLE 2 of RE'7RTTYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT AGENCY CASE # ORIGINAL 03/27/2023 3:50 PM GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT 230563 HE FOLLOWING LETTER WAS DROPPED OFF AT THE GULF STREAM POLICE EPARTMENT LOCATED AT 246 SEA RD ON MARCH 27, 2023, AT 1500 HRS. I WAS WALKING MY TWO LABRADORS AT APPROX 8PM HEADING SOUTH ON GULF ,TREAM RD. I OBSERVED A GOLF CART HEADING TOWARDS ME- HEADING NORTH. DUE O THE HEADLIGHTS, I COULD NOT SEE WHO WAS DRIVING UNTIL THEY WERE ON TOP OF IE. IT WAS JANE SOAID. SHE WAS DRIVING VERY FAST WITH HER DOG RUNNING BESIDE HE CART- IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ROAD. SHE MADE NO ATTEMPT TO SLOW DOWN, NOR iID SHE STOP AT THE STOP SIGN- AT LAKEVIEW. I HAD LITTLE TIME TO REACT TO HER UNGING DOG. MS. SOAID MADE ABSOLUTELY NO ATTEMPT TO AVOID THIS ENCOUNTER, O SLOW DOWN, TO PUT HER DOG INTO HER CART OR TRY TO AVOID GOING BY ME. SHE :ONTINUED DOWN THE ROAD, AT HIGH SPEED. MY 8-YEAR-OLD JUST HAD KNEE URGERY AND I WAS NOT ONLY ANGRY WITH HER CONTINUED RUDE BEHAVIOR, BUT ERY WORRIED AND MY 8 YEAR -OLD DOG. A COURSE OF ACTION HAS BEEN PRESCRIBED. BELIEVE IT IS TIME TO TAKE ACTION. I LOOK FORWARD TO HEARING FROM YOU." CASE FILE WAS CREATED IN REFERENCE TO THIS MATTER AND WILL BE LOOKED INTO URTHER. A COPY OF THE LETTER WAS PLACED IN THE CASE FILE. END OF REPORT. 1 3 of 3 REPORT TYPE REPORTDATE REPORTTIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22AM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230777 CASE •• • ORIGINAL DESCRIPTION JUVENILE? GANG RELATED? USE OF FORCE OLICE SERVICE NO NO NO ll I EXACT TIME? INCIDENT DATE/FROM NCIDENT TIME/FROM INCIDENT DATE TO INCIDENT TIME TO DAY OF WEEK NO 04/19/2023 16:25 04/19/2023 16:40 SUPPLEMENT DATE FROM DATE TIME TO DATE TIME STATUS CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY DATE CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY INACTIVE NOT APPLICABLE =0_1 41 G lilliaLf-11 oteUm OFFENSE KNOWN OFFENSE FDLE CODE CHARGE TYPE CHARGE SEVERITY ORDINANCE # STATE STATUTE STATUTE DESCRIPTION COUNTS INCREASED PENALTY TYPE OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY(up to 3) TYPE OF WEAPON FORCE (UP TO 3) SUSPECTED OF USING ATTEMPTED HATE CRIME BIAS MOTIVATION FOR HATE CRIME CARGO THEFT I CHILD PRESENT I VEHICLE LOCATION OF OFFENSE LOCATION TYPE AT BUSINESS? COMPANY NAME GOVERNMENT/PUBLIC BUILDING NO STREET # PRE DIRECTION STREET NAME POST DIRECTION STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 246 I SEA ROAD CITY STATE ZIP LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE PASSAGE POINT METHOD OFFENSE STRUCTURES GULF STREAM FL I IAT 33483 I I ENTERED QUANTITY ZONE 2 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO YES IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX JANE 1 SOUAID 1 ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3860 BERMUDA LANE CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT (305)333-7979 REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22AM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230777 GENDER DATE OF BIRTH I AGE AGE RANGE MIN AGE RANGE MAX AGE MEASURE CODE AGE INDICATOR RACE ETHNICITY ETHNICITY UNKNOWN HEIGHT I HEIGHT RANGE MIN HEIGHT RANGE MAX HEIGHT UNKNOWN I HEIGHT EST WEIGHT I WEIGHT RANGE MIN WEIGHT RANGE MAX WEIGHT UNKNOWN WEIGHT INDICATOR EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR BUILD COMPLEXTION PHYSICAL FEATURE SCARS/MARKS/TATOOS (LOCATION / DESCRIBE) FACIAL HAIR TEETH SPEECH/VOICE CLOTHING (Describe) DRIVER LICENSE # DL STATE DL CLASS I PLACE OF BIRTH COUNTRY OF CITIZENSHIP SOC. SEC. # INS # FBI # JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS NO FCIC/NCIC # BOOKING # SPN # DOC # OTHER ID # • • RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? NO BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION FIRST NAME PETER MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME LYONS SUFFIX ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # 3550 STREET NAME GULF STREAM STREET CATEGORY CODE ROAD APT/UNIT # CITY STATE GULF STREAM FL ZIP CODE 33483 ADDRESS SOURCE PERSON RESIDENCE CODE RESIDENT PHONE # (561)234-3212 E-MAIL GENDER DATE OF BIRTH AGE AGE RANGE MIN AGE RANGE MAX AGE MEASURE CODE AGE INDICATOR RACE ETHNICITY ETHNICITY UNKNOWN HEIGHT I HEIGHT RANGE MIN HEIGHT RANGE MAX HEIGHT UNKNOWN I HEIGHT EST WEIGHT WEIGHT RANGE MIN WEIGHT RANGE MAX WEIGHT UNKNOWN WEIGHT INDICATOR EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR BUILD _F COMPLEXTION PHYSICAL FEATURE SCARS/MARKS/TATOOS (LOCATION / DESCRIBE) FACIAL HAIR TEETH SPEECH/VOICE CLOTHING (Describe) DRIVER LICENSE # DL STATE DL CLASS PLACE OF BIRTH COUNTRY OF CITIZENSHIP SOC. SEC. # I INS # I FBI # FCIC/NCIC # BOOKING # SPN # DOC # OTHER ID # 2 of REPORTTYPE REPORTDATE REPORTTIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22AM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230777 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO NO IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX PAUL LYONS ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 2945 POLO DRIVE CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 I PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT (303) 475-4456 GENDER DATE OF BIRTH AGE AGE RANGE MIN AGE RANGE MAX AGE MEASURE CODE AGE INDICATOR RACE ETHNICITY ETHNICITY UNKNOWN HEIGHT HEIGHT RANGE MIN HEIGHT RANGE MAX HEIGHT UNKNOWN HEIGHT EST WEIGHT WEIGHT RANGE MIN WEIGHT RANGE MAX WEIGHT UNKNOWN WEIGHT INDICATOR EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR BUILD COMPLEXTION PHYSICAL FEATURE SCARS/MARKS/TATOOS(LOCATION / DESCRIBE) FACIAL HAIR TEETH [______SPEECH/VOICE CLOTHING (Describe) DRIVER LICENSE # DL STATE DL CLASS PLACE OF BIRTH COUNTRY OF CITIZENSHIP SOC. SEC. # INS # FBI # FCIC/NCIC # BOOKING # SPN # DOC # OTHER ID # • •' • FIRST NAME LAST NAME BADGE # RANK MICHAEL BALAK 765 OFFICER SIGNATURE METHOD OFFICER SIGNATURE SIGNATURE DATE IGNATURE TIME ELECTRONIC % ;; ?' 04/25/2023 09:32 ADMINISTRATIVE ROUTED TO REFERRED TO ASSIGNED TO ASSIGNED BY JAIL # 7 OBTS # SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME, THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY THIS DAY OF , 20 SIGNATURE OF PERSON ADMINISTERING OATH NAME (PRINTED) TITLE 3 of REPORT TYPE REPORTDATE REPORTTIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22 AM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230777 ON APRIL 19, 2023, AT APPROXIMATELY 1700 HOURS, I MADE CONTACT WITH MRS. JANE SOUAID AT THE GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT IN REFERENCE TO A COMPLAINT INVOLVING FELLOW RESIDENTS. MRS. SOUAID WISHED TO MAKE A COMPLAINT INVOLVING TWO INCIDENTS WHICH OCCURRED ON APRIL 16, 2023 AND APRIL 19, 2023. N APRIL 16, 2023, AT APPROXIMATELY 1600 HOURS, MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE WAS UNNING HER LEASHED DOG WHILE ON HER GOLF CART IN THE AREA OF LAKEVIEW DR ND POLO DR. MRS. SOUAID STATED SHE OBSERVED MR. PAUL LYONS STOP IN FRONT F 201 LAKEVIEW DR AND WATCH HER AS SHE WAS DRIVING HER GOLF CART WITH HER OG RUNNING BESIDE HER. WHEN MRS. SOUAID BELIEVED SHE WAS BEING WATCHED BY R. PAUL LYONS, SHE TURNED IN A DIFFERENT DIRECTION TO AVOID HIM. IT SHOULD BE OTED NO WORDS WERE SAID BETWEEN THE TWO PARTIES. DN APRIL 19, 2023, AT APPROXIMATELY 1625 HOURS, MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE AGAIN NAS RIDING IN HER GOLF CART WITH HER LEASHED DOG RUNNING BESIDE HER IN THE kREA OF BANYAN RD AND POLO DR. MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE WAS COMING TO THE STOP SIGN AND REALIZED THERE WAS A VEHICLE BEHIND HER. MRS. SOUAID STOPPED kT THE STOP SIGN AND TRIED TO WAVE THE VEHICLE AROUND HER. ACCORDING TO MRS. 3OUAID THE VEHICLE, WHICH SHE DESCRIBED AS A BLUE STATION WAGON, CAME CLOSE rO THE SIDE OF HER GOLF CART, STOPPED AND CALLED HER SEVERAL PROFANITIES. ARS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE RECOGNIZED THE DRIVER OF THE VEHICLE AS MR. PETER -YONS, MR. PAUL LYONS BROTHER. MRS. SOUAID ADVISED MR. PETER LYONS CONTINUED TO SCREAM AT HER TELLING HER THAT HE WAS PROTECTING HIS DOG. MRS. 3OUAID ADVISED SHE DID NOT SEE ANY DOG IN THE VEHICLE OR NEAR HIM ON THE ROADWAY. MRS. SOUAID CONTINUED TO TAKE HER PHONE OUT TO RECORD THE NCIDENT AND MR. PETER LYONS TURNED ONTO BANYAN RD FROM POLO DR WHERE 3EVERAL HUNDRED FEET AWAY WERE SEVERAL OTHER DOG WALKERS. MRS. SOUAID STATED THE OTHER WALKERS BEGAN ANTAGONIZING AS SHE DROVE AWAY. MRS. 5OUAID ADVISED SHE CONTINUED HER RIDE AND FEW MINUTES LATER SHE OBSERVED MR. PETER LYONS VEHICLE AGAIN COMING TOWARDS HER. MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE NENT IN ANOTHER DIRECTION TO AVOID FURTHER ISSUES. ACCORDING TO MRS. SOUAID THIS HAS BEEN AN ON GOING ISSUE BETWEEN HER AND OTHER RESIDENTS FROM WITHIN THE TOWN WHO DO NOT LIKE HER RUNNING HER DOG FROM HER GOLF CART. MRS. SOUAID STATED SHE HAS TALKED TO MAYOR SCOTT MORGAN ABOUT THESE ISSUES IN THE PAST AND CLAIMS THE RESOLUTION GIVEN TO HER WAS TO NOT RUN HER DOG DURING PEAK DOG WALKING HOURS OF 5PM-7PM. MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE HAS BEEN FOLLOWING THE RESOLUTION BY RUNNING HER DOG AT APPROXIMATELY 1600 HOURS, BUT IS STILL MET WITH RESISTANCE FROM TOWN RESIDENTS. MRS. SOUAID BELIEVES SHE IS BEING HARASSED AND THREATENED BY TOWN RESIDENTS OVER THE MATTER AND WANTED TO DOCUMENT THE INCIDENTS. MRS. SOUAID WAS MADE AWARE THAT THESE INCIDENTS DO NOT FIT THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE FLORIDA STATUE AS IT RELATES TO HARASSMENT AND ASSAULT. END OF REPORT. 1 4 of 4 REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22AM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT AGENCY CASE # 230777 '01� m JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO NO IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX PETER TMIDDLE LYONS ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 35SO GULF STREAM ROAD CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 I PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT (561)234-3212 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO NO IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX PAUL LYONS ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 2945 POLO DRIVE CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT (303)475-4456 • • • FIRST NAME LAST NAME BADGE # RANK MICHAEL BALAK 765 OFFICER SIGNATURE METHOD OFFICER SIGNATURE SIGNATURE DATE IGNATURE TIME ELECTRONIC 04/25/2023 09:32 ADMINISTRATIVE ROUTED TO REFERRED TO ASSIGNED TO ASSIGNED BY JAIL # OBTS # SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME, THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY THIS DAY OF 20 SIGNATURE OF PERSON ADMINISTERING OATH NAME (PRINTED) TITLE 2 of REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT I AGENCY CASE# ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22 AM GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT 230777 CASE •• • ORIGINAL DESCRIPTION JUVENILE? GANG RELATED? USE OF FORCE OLICE SERVICE NO NO NO I i EXACT TIME? INCIDENT DATE/FROM NCIDENT TIME/FROM INCIDENT DATE TO INCIDENT TIME TO DAY OF WEEK NO 04/19/2023 16:25 04/19/2023 I 16:40 SUPPLEMENT DATE FROM DATE TIME TO DATE TIME STATUS CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY DATE CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY INACTIVE NOT APPLICABLE OFFENSE KNOWN OFFENSE FDLE CODE CHARGE TYPE CHARGE SEVERITY ORDINANCE # STATE STATUTE STATUTE DESCRIPTION COUNTS INCREASED PENALTY TYPE OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY(up to 3) -T TYPE OF WEAPON FORCE (UP TO 3) SUSPECTED OF USING ATTEMPTED HATE CRIME BIAS MOTIVATION FOR HATE CRIME CARGO THEFT CHILD PRESENT VEHICLE LOCATION OF OFFENSE LOCATION TYPE AT BUSINESS? COMPANY NAME GOVERNMENT/PUBLIC BUILDING TNO STREET # PRE DIRECTION STREET NAME POST DIRECTION STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 246 I SEA ROAD I CITY STATE ZIP AT LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE PASSAGE POINT METHOD OFFENSE STRUCTURES GULF STREAM FL 33483 ENTERED QUANTITY ZONE 2 JUVENILE? TYPE OF WITNESS RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT REPORTED BY? NO YES IS BUSINESS OR GOVT? BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAME OCCUPATION NO FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME LAST NAME SUFFIX JANE SOUAID ALIAS / MAIDEN ALT NAME DESC. STREET # STREET NAME STREET CATEGORY CODE APT/UNIT # 3860 BERMUDA LANE CITY STATE ZIP CODE ADDRESS SOURCE GULF STREAM FL 33483 PERSON RESIDENCE CODE PHONE # E-MAIL RESIDENT (305)333-7979 REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT I AGENCY CASE # ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22AM I GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT 1 230777 �N APRIL 19, 2023, AT APPROXIMATELY 1700 HOURS, I MADE CONTACT WITH MRS. JANE OUAID AT THE GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT IN REFERENCE TO A COMPLAINT JVOLVING FELLOW RESIDENTS. MRS. SOUAID WISHED TO DOCUMENT TWO INCIDENTS ICH OCCURRED ON APRIL 16, 2023 AND APRIL 19, 2023. IN APRIL 16, 2023, AT APPROXIMATELY 1600 HOURS, MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE WAS .UNNING HER LEASHED DOG WHILE ON HER GOLF CART IN THE AREA OF LAKEVIEW DR. ,ND POLO DRIVE. MRS. SOUAID STATED SHE OBSERVED MR. PAUL LYONS IN HIS ORSCHE ON LAKEVIEW WATCHING HER. SHE CONTINUED SOUTH ON POLO DRIVE. MRS. OUAID STATED SHE SAW MR. BURNS APPROACHING WITH HIS DOG AND SHE DIVERTED ,S INSTRUCTED BY THE MAYOR. SHE THEN TURNED DOWN LAKEVIEW HEADING EAST ,ND GAZED AT MR. LYONS IN HIS CAR BECAUSE I WANTED HIM TO KNOW I SAW HIM. MR. YONS THEN LEFT WHEN I WAS TURNING SOUTH ON GULF STREAM ROAD. IT SHOULD BE OTED NO WORDS WERE EXCHANGED BETWEEN THE TWO PARTIES. DN APRIL 19, 2023, AT APPROXIMATELY 1616 HOURS, MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE AGAIN NAS RIDING IN HER GOLF CART WITH HER LEASHED DOG RUNNING BESIDE HER IN THE %REA OF BANYAN RD. AND POLO DRIVE. MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE WAS 50 FT. FROM SHE STOP SIGN AND REALIZED THERE WAS A VEHICLE BEHIND HER. MRS. SOUAID BULLED OVER TO THE WEST SIDE OF POLO DR. INTO A DRIVEWAY TO ALLOW ROOM FOR % CAR THAT SHE THOUGHT WANTED TO PASS. AT THIS TIME MRS. SOUAID WAS SPEAKING 3Y PHONE TO HER CPA WHEN SHE TURNED AROUND, WAVED TO THE CAR TO PASS AND SAID "WOULD YOU LIKE TO PASS"? WITH NO RESPONSE FROM THE DRIVER SHE %SSUMED THEY WERE WAITING FOR SOMEONE AND SHE THEN PROCEEDED TO GET BACK N THE SOUTH BOUND LANE HEADING SOUTH. SECONDS LATER THE CAR PULLED UP RIGHT NEXT TO HER; SHE ADVISED SHE COULD HAVE TOUCHED IT FROM HER GOLF CART. ORS. SOUAID AGAIN ASKED, WOULD YOU LIKE TO PASS ? THE DRIVER RESPONDED, " I'M PROTECTING MY DOGS" MRS. SOUAID ADVISED, NOW I REALIZED WHO IT WAS AND FELT THREATENED BECAUSE I HAD NO IDEA IT WAS MR. PETER LYONS AND THERE WERE NO )OGS WITH HIM OR AROUND. MRS. SOUAID TOLD HER CPA ON THE PHONE "I'M GOING TO ✓IDEO THIS", WHEN MR. PETER LYONS SAW I WAS RECORDING, HE MOVED AHEAD AND TURNED EAST ON BANYAN RD. WHERE HE MET UP WITH HIS WIFE AND ANOTHER PERSON. CONTINUED TO RECORD BECAUSE I WANTED TO SHOW HOW FAR AWAY HIS WIFE AND )OGS WERE AND HIS WIFE TAUNTED ME BY SAYING "HELLO AND WAVING". NOTE THE :ILMING STARTED AT 4:21 PM, 5 MINUTES AFTER I LEFT MY HOUSE WITH MY DOG. I NO 300NER LEFT MY HOUSE PASSING BANYAN RD. SOUTH BOUND WHEN I SAW MR. LYONS READING TOWARD ME IN THE NORTH BOUND LANE. I TURNED AWAY TO AVOID HIM. )FFICER BALAK ADVISED THERE WAS AN INORDINATE NUMBER OF DOGS BEING NALKED THAT AFTERNOON WHEN I RAN MY DOG. CONTINUING I WAS JUST SOUTH OF MIDDLE ROAD WHEN A RESIDENT THAT LIVES ON THE WEST SIDE ON THE CORNER OF 3OLFVIEW AND POLO CAME OUT WITH HER DOG AND STARTED SPEWING HATE TOWARDS VIE. PRIOR TO MY DIVERSION I TOLD HER I WAS ASKED BY THE MAYOR TO RUN MY DOG 3EFORE 5:00 PM, SHE WENT OFF ON ME STATING THAT "THAT WASN'T CONVENIENT FOR DER" I AGAIN PROCEEDED DOWN MIDDLE ROAD BUT FOUND MYSELF ONCE AGAIN IN THE VIIDEST OF THE LYONS AND TURNED BACK ONTO MIDDLE ROAD TO AVOID. THE SAME -ADY WHO JUST YELLED AT ME WAS THERE AT THE CORNER. EVERY TIME I TRIED TO )IVERT THERE WAS A RESIDENT WALKING THEIR DOG. FOUR PEOPLE VERBALLY %SSAULTED ME THAT DAY. CORDING TO MRS. SOUAID THIS HAS BEEN AN ON GOING ISSUE BETWEEN HER AND 1 3 of 4 REPORT TYPE REPORT DATE REPORT TIME I OFFENSE -INCIDENT REPORT I AGENCY CASE# ORIGINAL 04/25/2023 9:22AM GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT 230777 OTHER RESIDENTS FROM WITHIN THE TOWN WHO DO NOT LIKE HER RUNNING HER DOG FROM HER GOLF CART. MRS. SOUAID STATED SHE HAS TALKED TO MAYOR SCOTT MORGAN ABOUT THESE ISSUES IN THE PAST AND CLAIMS THE RESOLUTION GIVEN TO HER WAS TO NOT RUN HER DOG DURING PEAK DOG WALKING HOURS AS STATED BY THE POLICE OF 7:00 AM - 9:OOAM AND 5:00 PM - 7:00 PM. MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE HAS BEEN FOLLOWING THE RESOLUTION BY RUNNING HER DOG AT APPROXIMATELY 1600 HOURS, BUT IS STILL MET WITH RESISTANCE FROM TOWN RESIDENTS. MRS. SOUAID BELIEVES SHE IS BEING HARASSED AND THREATENED BY TOWN RESIDENTS OVER THE MATTER AND WANTED TO DOCUMENT THE INCIDENTS. MRS. SOUAID QUESTIONS HOW DID PETER LYONS KNOW THAT I WAS THERE ? LIKE HOW DID HIS BROTHER PAUL LYONS STOP, WAITING ON LAKEVIEW? WHY WAS MRS. LYONS WAITING ON BANYAN ROAD? MRS. SOUAID ADVISED SHE IS DOING WHAT HAS BEEN ASKED OF HER BY THE TOWN, SHE ALSO BELIEVES THESE INCIDENTS ARE ACTS OF AGGRESSION TOWARD HER. MRS. SOUAID WAS MADE AWARE THAT THESE INCIDENTS DO NOT FIT THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE FLORIDA STATUE AS IT RELATES TO HARASSMENT AND ASSAULT, FOR THERE APPEARS TO BE NO CRIMINAL INTENT. END OF REPORT. THIS REPORT IS AT THE REQUEST OF MRS. SOUAID FOR DOCUMENTATION. END. 1 4 of 4