HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 23-2943
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
May 18, 2023
Yolanda Nargiello [mail to: nargfamily@gmail.com]
Re: GS #2943 (Police Report)
A verbal request for Police Report #23-0864
Dear Yolanda Nargiello [mail to: nargfamily@gmail.com]:
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your verbal public records request on May 17, 2023. You
should be able to view your response at the following link:
PRR 23-2943 (laserfiche.com)
We consider this request closed.
Sincerely,
Reneé R. Basel, CMC
Reneé R. Basel, CMC
Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records
AGENCY CASE #
230864
REPORT TIME
2:47 PM
REPORT DATE
05/09/2023
REPORT TYPE
ORIGINAL
OFFENSE-INCIDENT REPORT
GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT
DATE CLEARED EXCEPTIONALLYCLEARED EXCEPTIONALLY
NOT APPLICABLE
STATUS
INACTIVE
TIMETO DATETIMEFROM DATESUPPLEMENT DATE
DAY OF WEEKINCIDENT TIME TO
12:42
INCIDENT DATE TO
05/09/2023
INCIDENT TIME/FROM
11:51
INCIDENT DATE/FROM
05/09/2023
EXACT TIME?
NO
USE OF FORCE
NO
GANG RELATED?
NO
JUVENILE?
NO
DESCRIPTION
POLICE SERVICE
ORIGINAL CASE INFORMATION -
ZONE
3
OFFENSE STRUCTURES
ENTERED QUANTITY
PASSAGE POINT METHODAND LONGITUDEAT LATITUDEZIP
33483
STATE
FL
CITY
GULF STREAM
APT/UNIT #
2
STREET CATEGORY CODE
ROAD
POST DIRECTIONSTREET NAME
COUNTY
PRE DIRECTION
NORTH
STREET #
4440
COMPANY NAMEAT BUSINESS?
NO
LOCATION TYPE
RESIDENCE/HOME
VEHICLECHILD PRESENTCARGO THEFTBIAS MOTIVATION FOR HATE CRIMEHATE CRIME
ATTEMPTEDSUSPECTED OF USING
TYPE OF WEAPON FORCE (UP TO 3)TYPE OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY(up to 3)
INCREASED PENALTYCOUNTSSTATUTE DESCRIPTION
STATE STATUTEORDINANCE #CHARGE SEVERITYCHARGE TYPE
OFFENSE FDLE CODEOFFENSE KNOWN
1LOCATION OF OFFENSE
OFFENSE INFORMATION
E-MAILPHONE #
(908) 268-7162
PERSON RESIDENCE CODE
RESIDENT
ADDRESS SOURCE
FL DL
ZIP CODE
33418
STATE
FL
CITY
PALM BEACH GARDENS
APT/UNIT #STREET CATEGORY CODE
CIRCLE
STREET NAME
GARDENS GLEN
STREET #
9040
ALT NAME DESC.ALIAS / MAIDEN
SUFFIXLAST NAME
NARGIELLO
MIDDLE NAME
ALEXANDRA
FIRST NAME
YOLANDA
OCCUPATIONBUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAMEIS BUSINESS OR GOV'T?
NO
REPORTED BY?
YES
RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT
COMPLAINANT
TYPE OF WITNESSJUVENILE?
NO
1OTHER PERSON -
4of1
AGENCY CASE #
230864
REPORT TIME
2:47 PM
REPORT DATE
05/09/2023
REPORT TYPE
ORIGINAL
OFFENSE-INCIDENT REPORT
GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT
OTHER ID #DOC #SPN #BOOKING #FCIC/NCIC #FBI #INS #SOC. SEC. #
COUNTRY OF CITIZENSHIPPLACE OF BIRTHDL CLASS
E
DL STATE
FL
DRIVER LICENSE #
N624961578700
CLOTHING (Describe)
SPEECH/VOICETEETHFACIAL HAIRSCARS/MARKS/TATOOS (LOCATION / DESCRIBE)
PHYSICAL FEATURECOMPLEXTIONBUILD
HAIR COLOREYE COLORWEIGHT INDICATORWEIGHT UNKNOWNWEIGHT RANGE MAXWEIGHT RANGE MINWEIGHT
HEIGHT ESTHEIGHT UNKNOWNHEIGHT RANGE MAXHEIGHT RANGE MINHEIGHT
5'07"
ETHNICITY UNKNOWNETHNICITY
NOT HISPANIC
RACE
W
AGE INDICATORAGE MEASURE CODEAGE RANGE MAXAGE RANGE MINAGE
65
DATE OF BIRTH
10/10/1957
GENDER
F
E-MAILPHONE #
(917) 414-5223
PERSON RESIDENCE CODE
NONRESIDENT
ADDRESS SOURCE
CONNECTICUT DL
ZIP CODE
06010
STATE
CT
CITY
WESTPORT
APT/UNIT #STREET CATEGORY CODE
ROAD
STREET NAME
SPICER
STREET #
35
ALT NAME DESC.ALIAS / MAIDEN
SUFFIXLAST NAME
HEALY
MIDDLE NAME
M
FIRST NAME
CHRISTOPHER
OCCUPATION
UNKNOWN
BUSINESS/GOVERNMENT NAMEIS BUSINESS OR GOV'T?
NO
REPORTED BY?
NO
RELATIONSHIP TO SUBJECT
RENTER
TYPE OF WITNESSJUVENILE?
NO
2OTHER PERSON -
OTHER ID #DOC #SPN #BOOKING #FCIC/NCIC #FBI #INS #SOC. SEC. #
COUNTRY OF CITIZENSHIPPLACE OF BIRTHDL CLASSDL STATEDRIVER LICENSE #
066270215
CLOTHING (Describe)
SPEECH/VOICETEETHFACIAL HAIRSCARS/MARKS/TATOOS (LOCATION / DESCRIBE)
PHYSICAL FEATURECOMPLEXTIONBUILD
HAIR COLOREYE COLORWEIGHT INDICATORWEIGHT UNKNOWNWEIGHT RANGE MAXWEIGHT RANGE MINWEIGHT
HEIGHT ESTHEIGHT UNKNOWNHEIGHT RANGE MAXHEIGHT RANGE MINHEIGHT
6'01"
ETHNICITY UNKNOWNETHNICITYRACE
AGE INDICATORAGE MEASURE CODEAGE RANGE MAXAGE RANGE MINAGE
67
DATE OF BIRTH
6/3/1955
GENDER
M
OFFICER INFORMATION
SIGNATURE TIME
14:57
SIGNATURE DATE
05/09/2023
OFFICER SIGNATURESIGNATURE METHOD
ELECTRONIC
RANK
SERGEANT
BADGE #
751
LAST NAME
O'DONNELL
FIRST NAME
BERNARD
14of2
AGENCY CASE #
230864
REPORT TIME
2:47 PM
REPORT DATE
05/09/2023
REPORT TYPE
ORIGINAL
OFFENSE-INCIDENT REPORT
GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT
ADMINISTRATIVE
OBTS #JAIL #ASSIGNED BYASSIGNED TOREFERRED TOROUTED TO
NAME (PRINTED)
SIGNATURE OF PERSON ADMINISTERING OATH
SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME, THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY THIS _____ DAY OF _______________, 20_____.
TITLE
4of3
AGENCY CASE #
230864
REPORT TIME
2:47 PM
REPORT DATE
05/09/2023
REPORT TYPE
ORIGINAL
OFFENSE-INCIDENT REPORT
GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT
ON MAY 9, 2023 AT APPROXIMATELY 1151 HOURS. I, SERGEANT BERNARD O'DONNELL
WAS DISPATCHED TO 4440 NORTH COUNTY ROAD, UNIT #2 IN REFERENCE TO A POLICE
SERVICE CALL. UPON ARRIVAL AND SUBSEQUENT INVESTIGATION DETERMINED THE
INITIAL COMPLAINT HAS BEEN CLASSIFIED AS A CIVIL ISSUE. A SUMMARY OF THE
COMPLAINT IS AS FOLLOWS. THE INTERVIEW WAS CAPTURED ON MY BODY WORN
CAMERA WITH KNOWLEDGE BY ALL INVOLVED PARTIES.
THE COMPLAINANT WAS IDENTIFIED BY HER FLORIDA DRIVERS LICENSE. MRS YOLANDA
NARGIELLO. MRS NARGIELLO IS THE PROPERTY OWNER OF UNIT #2 AT THE ABOVE
LISTED LOCATION. FROM THE PERIOD OF FEBRUARY 8TH TO MAY 8TH, 2023. MRS
NARGIELLO ENTERED INTO A WRITTEN RENTAL AGREEMENT WITH AN INDIVIDUAL. ON
TODAYS DATE IT WAS EXIT TIME FROM THE UNIT. DURING THIS TIME AND DURING THE
CLEANING PERIOD, SHE BECAME CONCERNED FOR HER SAFETY THAT RESULTED IN OUR
RESPONSE.
THE RENTER WAS IDENTIFIED BY HIS CONNECTICUT DRIVERS LICENSE AS MR CHRIS
HEALY. A PICTURE OF HIS DRIVERS LICENSE WAS PROVIDED BY MRS NARGIELLO AS
PART OF THE RENTAL AGREEMENT PROCESS.
THE SPECIFIC CONCERNS MADE BY MRS NARGIELLO WAS THE DELAY IN HIS RESPONSE
OF RETURNING THE KEY TO THE UNIT. UPON THE RETURN OF THE KEY BY MR HEALY,
MRS NARGIELLO ALLEGES THAT MR HEALY HAD CHANGED THE LOCKS TO THE UNIT.
SHE, BASED THIS ON THAT SHE WAS UNABLE TO UTILIZE THE SAME KEY TO UNLOCK THE
DOOR. MRS NARGIELLO HAD ADDITIONAL KEYS OF HER OWN WITH HER. THE KEYS ALSO
DID NOT WORK ON THE LOCK. ALTHOUGH THERE HAS BEEN NO ISSUES OF PAST
NEGATIVE HISTORY BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM THIS CAUSED HER TO BE IN FEAR FOR
HER SAFETY. I PROVIDED MRS NARGIELLO ADDITIONAL SAFETY MEASURES,
SUGGESTIONS THAT SHE CAN TAKE TO SECURE HER UNIT.
WHILE IN THE PRESENCE OF MRS NARGIELLO I MADE TELEPHONE CONTACT WITH MR
HEALY. I, QUESTIONED HIM WITH REGARDS TO THE CHANGING OF THE LOCKS. MR
HEALY DENIES THE CLAIM. I MADE IT KNOWN TO MR HEALY THAT AT THE REQUEST OF
MRS NARGIELLO HE WAS NO LONGER WELCOME TO THE UNIT OWNED BY MRS
NARGIELLO. I MADE IT KNOWN TO MR HEALY IF ANY ATTEMPTS TO CLAIM ADDITIONAL
PROPERTY OWNED BY HIM THAT WAS LEFT BEHIND, A POLICE ESCORT IS REQUIRED. THE
ELEMENT OF TRESPASS, WAS ALSO EXPLAINED BY ME TO MR HEALY. MR HEALY STATED
THAT THE LOCK IS THE PROBLEM AND NOT KEY.
AT THE CONCLUSION OF MY INTERVIEW I UTILIZED THE KEY THAT MR HEALY HAD
RETURNED IN MY ATTEMPTS TO VERIFY THE KEY DID NOT WORK AS MRS NARGIELLO
CLAIMS. THE LOCK OPENED WITH THE KEY THAT MR HEALY HAD RETURNED. THE SPARE
KEYS THAT MRS NARGIELLO HAD WITH HER ALSO WORKED BY OPENING THE LOCK.
MY INVESTIGATION CONCLUDED. I PROVIDED MRS NARGIELLO WITH MY FINDINGS AND
THE CASE NUMBER. END OF REPORT.
NARRATIVE
4of4