HomeMy Public PortalAbout2021.07.08 Public Comments - McCall City Council Wildlife Ordinance ReviewID
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
Start time
6/3/2021 6:10:26 PM
6/3/2021 8:36:09 PM
6/4/2021 12:50:44 PM
6/7/2021 9:08:46 AM
6/7/2021 3:07:15 PM
6/7/2021 5:14:31 PM
6/8/2021 12:37:31 PM
6/8/2021 6:44:19 PM
6/9/2021 6:31:58 AM
6/9/2021 3:28:49 PM
6/9/2021 7:47:57 PM
6/9/2021 7:52:19 PM
6/10/2021 7:45:20 AM
6/10/2021 10:48:30 AM
6/10/2021 11:03:20 AM
6/10/2021 11:56:26 AM
6/10/2021 12:01:20 PM
6/10/2021 12:17:17 PM
6/10/2021 12:43:27 PM
6/10/2021 1:25:23 PM
6/10/2021 2:09:50 PM
6/10/2021 2:14:49 PM
6/10/2021 2:00:54 PM
6/10/2021 2:44:57 PM
6/11/2021 11:24:56 AM
6/13/2021 7:29:30 PM
6/13/2021 8:38:41 PM
6/16/2021 4:25:06 PM
6/16/2021 3:20:05 PM
6/19/2021 2:26:50 PM
6/22/2021 1:50:56 PM
6/22/2021 4:56:09 PM
6/22/2021 9:51:26 PM
6/23/2021 12:35:39 AM
6/23/2021 12:35:03 AM
6/23/2021 12:34:02 AM
6/23/2021 3:46:43 AM
6/23/2021 6:40:53 AM
6/23/2021 7:36:47 AM
6/23/2021 7:20:57 AM
6/23/2021 7:58:48 AM
6/23/2021 8:15:51 AM
6/23/2021 9:55:02 AM
6/23/2021 10:10:06 AM
6/23/2021 10:25:18 AM
6/23/2021 10:33:19 AM
6/23/2021 10:28:01 AM
6/23/2021 11:09:29 AM
6/23/2021 11:38:03 AM
6/23/2021 11:38:45 AM
6/23/2021 1:38:21 PM
6/23/2021 1:57:49 PM
6/23/2021 1:58:49 PM
6/23/2021 1:59:23 PM
6/23/2021 1:57:59 PM
6/23/2021 1:59:48 PM
6/23/2021 2:00:21 PM
6/23/2021 2:00:11 PM
6/23/2021 2:00:43 PM
6/23/2021 2:05:17 PM
6/23/2021 2:09:20 PM
6/23/2021 2:09:11 PM
6/23/2021 2:16:36 PM
6/23/2021 11:16:07 AM
6/23/2021 2:26:36 PM
6/23/2021 2:33:50 PM
6/23/2021 2:42:07 PM
6/23/2021 2:51:42 PM
6/23/2021 2:20:33 PM
6/23/2021 3:10:55 PM
6/23/2021 2:38:45 PM
6/23/2021 3:53:25 PM
6/23/2021 4:14:05 PM
6/23/2021 4:18:38 PM
6/23/2021 4:35:24 PM
6/23/2021 4:31:35 PM
6/23/2021 4:16:55 PM
6/23/2021 4:42:35 PM
6/23/2021 4:49:49 PM
6/23/2021 4:55:32 PM
6/23/2021 4:54:53 PM
6/23/2021 4:58:41 PM
6/23/2021 5:12:46 PM
6/23/2021 5:21:08 PM
6/23/2021 5:26:51 PM
6/23/2021 5:27:07 PM
6/23/2021 5:34:45 PM
6/23/2021 5:38:39 PM
6/23/2021 5:42:12 PM
6/23/2021 5:46:24 PM
6/23/2021 5:45:22 PM
6/23/2021 5:52:31 PM
6/23/2021 5:52:34 PM
6/23/2021 5:54:57 PM
6/23/2021 5:52:01 PM
6/23/2021 5:56:22 PM
6/23/2021 5:56:20 PM
6/23/2021 5:59:45 PM
6/23/2021 6:05:27 PM
6/23/2021 6:07:58 PM
6/23/2021 6:11:20 PM
6/23/2021 6:15:42 PM
6/23/2021 6:16:11 PM
6/23/2021 6:17:44 PM
6/23/2021 6:02:35 PM
6/23/2021 6:20:06 PM
6/23/2021 6:22:47 PM
6/23/2021 6:17:07 PM
6/23/2021 6:25:55 PM
6/23/2021 6:24:27 PM
6/23/2021 6:31:23 PM
6/23/2021 6:27:07 PM
6/23/2021 6:02:47 PM
6/23/2021 6:27:01 PM
6/23/2021 6:43:00 PM
6/23/2021 6:39:08 PM
6/23/2021 6:46:17 PM
6/23/2021 6:44:23 PM
6/23/2021 6:59:09 PM
6/23/2021 7:02:50 PM
6/23/2021 7:26:22 PM
6/23/2021 7:17:49 PM
6/23/2021 7:36:17 PM
6/23/2021 7:42:33 PM
6/23/2021 7:48:57 PM
6/23/2021 7:36:49 PM
6/23/2021 7:52:24 PM
6/23/2021 7:43:27 PM
6/23/2021 7:55:25 PM
6/23/2021 7:53:27 PM
6/23/2021 7:49:43 PM
6/23/2021 7:58:28 PM
6/23/2021 8:11:14 PM
6/23/2021 8:10:56 PM
6/23/2021 8:17:09 PM
6/23/2021 8:17:08 PM
6/23/2021 8:19:56 PM
6/23/2021 8:22:59 PM
6/23/2021 8:23:34 PM
6/23/2021 8:26:35 PM
6/23/2021 8:28:25 PM
6/23/2021 8:35:53 PM
6/23/2021 8:35:57 PM
6/23/2021 8:37:20 PM
6/23/2021 8:37:26 PM
6/23/2021 8:36:20 PM
6/23/2021 8:34:34 PM
6/23/2021 8:50:48 PM
6/23/2021 8:52:27 PM
6/23/2021 8:59:42 PM
6/23/2021 8:56:03 PM
6/23/2021 9:05:36 PM
6/23/2021 9:14:02 PM
6/23/2021 9:23:23 PM
6/23/2021 9:24:40 PM
6/23/2021 9:25:01 PM
6/23/2021 9:30:06 PM
6/23/2021 9:16:04 PM
6/23/2021 9:16:35 PM
6/23/2021 9:43:11 PM
6/23/2021 9:44:18 PM
6/23/2021 9:45:54 PM
6/23/2021 9:49:49 PM
6/23/2021 9:54:39 PM
6/23/2021 9:31:11 PM
6/23/2021 9:57:57 PM
6/23/2021 10:01:32 PM
6/23/2021 9:59:00 PM
6/23/2021 10:11:51 PM
6/23/2021 10:14:27 PM
6/23/2021 10:16:50 PM
6/23/2021 10:20:50 PM
6/23/2021 10:19:35 PM
6/23/2021 10:24:50 PM
6/23/2021 10:30:08 PM
6/23/2021 10:35:26 PM
6/23/2021 10:34:54 PM
6/23/2021 10:43:30 PM
6/23/2021 10:56:54 PM
6/23/2021 11:13:45 PM
6/23/2021 11:16:03 PM
6/23/2021 11:19:34 PM
6/23/2021 11:19:56 PM
6/23/2021 11:25:54 PM
6/23/2021 11:27:17 PM
6/23/2021 11:28:09 PM
6/23/2021 11:06:33 PM
6/23/2021 11:37:31 PM
6/23/2021 11:53:38 PM
6/23/2021 11:54:34 PM
6/24/2021 12:13:56 AM
6/24/2021 12:16:11 AM
6/24/2021 12:42:55 AM
6/24/2021 12:05:36 AM
6/24/2021 2:16:06 AM
6/24/2021 2:13:40 AM
6/24/2021 3:28:24 AM
6/24/2021 5:26:18 AM
6/24/2021 5:32:49 AM
6/24/2021 5:45:52 AM
6/24/2021 6:03:44 AM
6/24/2021 6:04:19 AM
6/24/2021 6:00:58 AM
6/24/2021 6:14:05 AM
6/24/2021 6:17:56 AM
6/24/2021 6:40:20 AM
6/24/2021 6:45:22 AM
6/24/2021 6:54:27 AM
6/24/2021 6:50:42 AM
6/24/2021 6:57:21 AM
6/24/2021 7:03:54 AM
6/24/2021 7:07:39 AM
6/24/2021 7:10:44 AM
6/24/2021 7:15:19 AM
6/24/2021 6:49:35 AM
6/24/2021 7:24:53 AM
6/24/2021 7:25:45 AM
6/24/2021 7:22:22 AM
6/24/2021 7:31:03 AM
6/24/2021 7:35:47 AM
6/24/2021 7:39:43 AM
6/24/2021 7:42:08 AM
6/24/2021 7:45:56 AM
6/24/2021 7:48:39 AM
6/24/2021 7:55:18 AM
6/24/2021 7:57:10 AM
6/24/2021 7:52:45 AM
6/24/2021 8:06:33 AM
6/24/2021 8:08:23 AM
6/24/2021 8:11:27 AM
6/24/2021 8:15:54 AM
6/24/2021 8:16:13 AM
6/24/2021 8:14:37 AM
6/24/2021 8:26:02 AM
6/24/2021 8:23:23 AM
6/24/2021 8:22:31 AM
6/24/2021 8:22:07 AM
6/24/2021 8:40:09 AM
6/24/2021 8:39:20 AM
6/24/2021 8:41:19 AM
6/24/2021 8:43:28 AM
6/24/2021 8:39:47 AM
6/24/2021 8:51:17 AM
6/24/2021 8:57:09 AM
6/24/2021 8:59:46 AM
6/24/2021 9:04:07 AM
6/24/2021 9:09:51 AM
6/24/2021 9:10:03 AM
6/24/2021 9:09:13 AM
6/24/2021 9:18:33 AM
6/24/2021 9:21:38 AM
6/24/2021 9:14:18 AM
6/24/2021 9:23:00 AM
6/24/2021 9:34:39 AM
6/24/2021 9:36:20 AM
6/24/2021 9:35:08 AM
6/24/2021 9:25:17 AM
6/24/2021 9:45:39 AM
6/24/2021 9:51:01 AM
6/24/2021 9:49:56 AM
6/24/2021 9:47:37 AM
6/24/2021 9:59:18 AM
6/24/2021 9:59:48 AM
6/24/2021 10:05:01 AM
6/24/2021 10:15:35 AM
6/24/2021 10:14:23 AM
6/24/2021 9:58:47 AM
6/24/2021 10:16:24 AM
6/24/2021 10:22:19 AM
6/24/2021 10:21:28 AM
6/24/2021 10:09:13 AM
6/24/2021 10:31:19 AM
6/24/2021 10:34:36 AM
6/24/2021 10:41:02 AM
6/24/2021 10:48:47 AM
6/24/2021 10:55:33 AM
6/24/2021 11:00:10 AM
6/24/2021 10:53:03 AM
6/24/2021 10:59:33 AM
6/24/2021 11:02:27 AM
6/24/2021 10:59:15 AM
6/24/2021 11:03:53 AM
6/24/2021 10:44:25 AM
6/24/2021 11:09:10 AM
6/24/2021 11:11:36 AM
6/24/2021 11:16:00 AM
6/24/2021 11:10:50 AM
6/24/2021 11:15:37 AM
6/24/2021 11:24:36 AM
6/24/2021 11:25:12 AM
6/24/2021 11:12:29 AM
6/24/2021 11:29:31 AM
6/24/2021 10:56:24 AM
6/24/2021 11:34:16 AM
6/24/2021 11:28:41 AM
6/24/2021 11:37:58 AM
6/24/2021 11:39:30 AM
6/24/2021 11:41:38 AM
6/24/2021 11:39:21 AM
6/24/2021 11:32:40 AM
6/24/2021 11:45:24 AM
6/24/2021 11:47:32 AM
6/24/2021 11:54:13 AM
6/24/2021 12:01:56 PM
6/24/2021 11:39:56 AM
6/24/2021 12:05:39 PM
6/24/2021 12:12:22 PM
6/24/2021 12:20:15 PM
6/24/2021 11:57:49 AM
6/24/2021 12:29:41 PM
6/24/2021 12:30:53 PM
6/24/2021 12:32:26 PM
6/24/2021 12:33:57 PM
6/24/2021 12:32:52 PM
6/24/2021 12:28:05 PM
6/24/2021 12:33:48 PM
6/24/2021 12:38:55 PM
6/24/2021 12:44:16 PM
6/24/2021 12:51:14 PM
6/24/2021 12:50:59 PM
6/24/2021 12:59:26 PM
6/24/2021 1:02:57 PM
6/24/2021 12:58:33 PM
6/24/2021 1:13:51 PM
6/24/2021 1:16:25 PM
6/24/2021 1:20:42 PM
6/24/2021 12:48:51 PM
6/24/2021 1:29:35 PM
6/24/2021 1:29:31 PM
6/24/2021 1:30:19 PM
6/24/2021 1:36:12 PM
6/24/2021 1:54:02 PM
6/24/2021 1:53:40 PM
6/24/2021 1:48:51 PM
6/24/2021 1:58:29 PM
6/24/2021 1:51:31 PM
6/24/2021 2:10:05 PM
6/24/2021 2:06:03 PM
6/24/2021 2:16:48 PM
6/24/2021 2:28:22 PM
6/24/2021 2:27:41 PM
6/24/2021 2:31:21 PM
6/24/2021 2:30:25 PM
6/24/2021 2:34:08 PM
6/24/2021 2:29:07 PM
6/24/2021 2:36:25 PM
6/24/2021 2:35:43 PM
6/24/2021 2:38:50 PM
6/24/2021 2:46:07 PM
6/24/2021 2:37:33 PM
6/24/2021 2:50:36 PM
6/24/2021 2:55:45 PM
6/25/2021 8:42:09 AM
6/25/2021 9:58:36 AM
6/25/2021 11:15:56 PM
6/28/2021 7:27:16 PM
6/29/2021 7:53:44 PM
6/29/2021 8:18:28 PM
6/29/2021 9:01:11 PM
6/29/2021 9:13:35 PM
6/29/2021 9:17:16 PM
6/29/2021 11:37:36 PM
6/30/2021 8:51:09 AM
6/30/2021 8:56:49 AM
6/30/2021 9:36:26 PM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:28:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:36:33 AM
7/1/2021 7:18:49 AM
7/1/2021 1:06:04 PM
7/1/2021 4:56:27 PM
7/2/2021 9:10:45 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:08 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:08 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:08 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:08 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:08 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:09 AM
7/2/2021 12:21:45 PM
7/2/2021 12:28:13 PM
7/2/2021 10:46:09 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:09 AM
7/2/2021 2:18:34 PM
7/3/2021 7:41:04 AM
7/3/2021 7:45:36 AM
7/3/2021 8:12:32 AM
7/3/2021 9:58:58 AM
7/3/2021 11:51:38 AM
7/2/2021 10:46:10 AM
7/3/2021 12:54:34 PM
7/3/2021 11:56:46 PM
7/4/2021 4:08:52 PM
7/5/2021 7:00:51 AM
7/5/2021 1:31:30 PM
7/5/2021 11:41:05 PM
7/6/2021 7:47:32 AM
7/6/2021 7:52:15 AM
7/6/2021 8:03:41 AM
7/6/2021 8:21:47 AM
7/6/2021 8:25:21 AM
7/6/2021 8:27:01 AM
7/6/2021 8:39:21 AM
7/6/2021 8:41:36 AM
7/6/2021 8:51:46 AM
7/6/2021 8:54:19 AM
7/6/2021 9:00:50 AM
7/6/2021 9:00:11 AM
7/6/2021 9:02:46 AM
7/6/2021 9:10:35 AM
7/6/2021 9:13:41 AM
7/6/2021 9:19:40 AM
7/6/2021 9:27:15 AM
7/6/2021 7:36:27 AM
7/6/2021 9:31:59 AM
7/6/2021 9:33:35 AM
7/6/2021 10:04:05 AM
7/6/2021 10:10:13 AM
7/6/2021 10:48:29 AM
7/6/2021 10:49:40 AM
7/6/2021 11:40:46 AM
7/6/2021 12:25:47 PM
7/6/2021 12:50:18 PM
7/6/2021 1:38:33 PM
7/6/2021 1:44:07 PM
7/6/2021 1:45:20 PM
7/6/2021 1:51:44 PM
7/6/2021 2:05:38 PM
7/6/2021 2:13:03 PM
7/6/2021 2:12:01 PM
7/6/2021 2:24:43 PM
7/6/2021 2:27:44 PM
7/6/2021 3:06:13 PM
7/6/2021 2:54:30 PM
7/6/2021 3:13:02 PM
7/6/2021 3:27:26 PM
7/6/2021 3:51:07 PM
7/6/2021 3:59:46 PM
7/6/2021 4:05:42 PM
7/6/2021 4:11:15 PM
7/6/2021 4:21:36 PM
7/6/2021 4:29:05 PM
7/6/2021 4:34:07 PM
7/6/2021 4:43:43 PM
7/6/2021 4:50:38 PM
7/6/2021 5:02:12 PM
7/6/2021 5:18:20 PM
7/6/2021 5:41:48 PM
7/6/2021 6:13:08 PM
7/6/2021 6:14:05 PM
7/6/2021 6:31:26 PM
7/6/2021 6:19:38 PM
7/6/2021 6:37:13 PM
7/6/2021 6:46:05 PM
7/6/2021 7:08:06 PM
7/6/2021 7:15:16 PM
7/6/2021 7:27:42 PM
7/6/2021 8:07:08 PM
7/6/2021 8:08:51 PM
7/6/2021 8:31:32 PM
7/6/2021 9:09:20 PM
7/6/2021 9:23:35 PM
7/6/2021 9:34:57 PM
7/6/2021 10:05:54 PM
7/6/2021 10:12:19 PM
7/6/2021 10:14:47 PM
7/6/2021 10:15:26 PM
7/6/2021 10:17:35 PM
7/6/2021 10:40:46 PM
7/6/2021 11:03:41 PM
7/6/2021 11:13:56 PM
7/6/2021 11:09:32 PM
7/6/2021 11:31:17 PM
7/6/2021 11:15:24 PM
7/6/2021 11:51:12 PM
7/7/2021 12:24:59 AM
7/7/2021 2:44:29 AM
7/7/2021 5:19:24 AM
7/7/2021 7:28:36 AM
7/7/2021 7:31:59 AM
7/7/2021 8:11:32 AM
7/7/2021 8:13:24 AM
7/7/2021 8:14:27 AM
7/7/2021 8:48:49 AM
7/7/2021 8:58:34 AM
7/7/2021 9:02:02 AM
7/7/2021 9:47:19 AM
7/7/2021 10:35:47 AM
7/7/2021 11:05:32 AM
7/7/2021 11:11:01 AM
7/7/2021 12:18:46 PM
7/7/2021 12:56:00 PM
7/7/2021 1:05:32 PM
7/7/2021 1:42:35 PM
7/7/2021 2:03:41 PM
7/7/2021 2:04:49 PM
7/7/2021 2:28:46 PM
7/7/2021 2:45:38 PM
7/7/2021 2:48:51 PM
7/7/2021 11:00:25 AM
7/7/2021 4:01:40 PM
7/7/2021 4:45:02 PM
7/7/2021 4:37:49 PM
7/7/2021 5:17:28 PM
7/7/2021 5:34:33 PM
7/7/2021 5:56:30 PM
7/7/2021 5:56:44 PM
7/7/2021 7:26:15 PM
7/7/2021 8:14:27 PM
7/7/2021 11:06:14 PM
7/7/2021 11:20:00 PM
7/7/2021 11:26:12 PM
7/8/2021 12:42:24 AM
7/8/2021 1:51:12 AM
7/8/2021 6:04:21 AM
7/8/2021 7:20:34 AM
7/8/2021 7:16:06 AM
7/8/2021 7:22:19 AM
7/8/2021 7:39:54 AM
7/8/2021 7:57:54 AM
7/8/2021 8:02:00 AM
7/8/2021 8:13:21 AM
7/8/2021 8:28:59 AM
7/8/2021 8:52:01 AM
7/8/2021 10:05:09 AM
7/8/2021 10:07:21 AM
7/8/2021 10:11:16 AM
7/8/2021 10:18:19 AM
7/8/2021 10:19:55 AM
7/8/2021 10:47:37 AM
7/8/2021 11:38:19 AM
7/8/2021 12:32:33 PM
7/8/2021 1:00:27 PM
7/8/2021 1:10:20 PM
7/8/2021 1:15:34 PM
7/8/2021 1:25:30 PM
7/8/2021 1:26:19 PM
7/8/2021 1:27:06 PM
7/8/2021 1:27:43 PM
7/8/2021 1:28:41 PM
7/8/2021 1:20:11 PM
7/8/2021 1:38:38 PM
7/8/2021 2:15:39 PM
7/8/2021 2:31:26 PM
7/8/2021 2:31:23 PM
7/8/2021 2:49:55 PM
7/8/2021 2:49:52 PM
7/8/2021 2:56:57 PM
Completion time
6/3/2021 6:29:20 PM
6/3/2021 8:39:26 PM
6/4/2021 1:04:35 PM
6/7/2021 9:34:33 AM
6/7/2021 3:20:52 PM
6/7/2021 5:22:13 PM
6/8/2021 1:11:11 PM
6/8/2021 6:47:31 PM
6/9/2021 6:34:33 AM
6/9/2021 3:45:27 PM
6/9/2021 7:52:14 PM
6/9/2021 8:41:54 PM
6/10/2021 7:46:06 AM
6/10/2021 10:59:14 AM
6/10/2021 11:24:31 AM
6/10/2021 11:58:08 AM
6/10/2021 12:05:04 PM
6/10/2021 12:29:02 PM
6/10/2021 1:04:33 PM
6/10/2021 1:26:20 PM
6/10/2021 2:26:36 PM
6/10/2021 2:31:07 PM
6/10/2021 2:44:39 PM
6/10/2021 2:57:28 PM
6/11/2021 11:27:48 AM
6/13/2021 7:31:59 PM
6/13/2021 8:54:18 PM
6/16/2021 4:37:28 PM
6/16/2021 5:11:32 PM
6/19/2021 2:30:43 PM
6/22/2021 1:52:21 PM
6/22/2021 4:59:17 PM
6/22/2021 10:04:47 PM
6/23/2021 12:39:51 AM
6/23/2021 12:43:28 AM
6/23/2021 12:47:40 AM
6/23/2021 3:53:01 AM
6/23/2021 6:48:17 AM
6/23/2021 7:45:45 AM
6/23/2021 7:46:08 AM
6/23/2021 8:03:02 AM
6/23/2021 8:32:21 AM
6/23/2021 9:59:52 AM
6/23/2021 10:27:55 AM
6/23/2021 10:28:08 AM
6/23/2021 10:38:38 AM
6/23/2021 10:38:44 AM
6/23/2021 11:13:16 AM
6/23/2021 11:44:12 AM
6/23/2021 11:45:45 AM
6/23/2021 1:41:13 PM
6/23/2021 1:58:46 PM
6/23/2021 1:59:22 PM
6/23/2021 1:59:46 PM
6/23/2021 2:00:05 PM
6/23/2021 2:00:20 PM
6/23/2021 2:00:41 PM
6/23/2021 2:01:47 PM
6/23/2021 2:02:01 PM
6/23/2021 2:08:36 PM
6/23/2021 2:15:07 PM
6/23/2021 2:18:23 PM
6/23/2021 2:18:41 PM
6/23/2021 2:30:37 PM
6/23/2021 2:30:46 PM
6/23/2021 2:41:02 PM
6/23/2021 2:44:45 PM
6/23/2021 2:53:28 PM
6/23/2021 3:00:37 PM
6/23/2021 3:13:42 PM
6/23/2021 3:23:40 PM
6/23/2021 3:54:53 PM
6/23/2021 4:21:29 PM
6/23/2021 4:22:19 PM
6/23/2021 4:39:37 PM
6/23/2021 4:42:22 PM
6/23/2021 4:43:35 PM
6/23/2021 4:44:50 PM
6/23/2021 4:55:07 PM
6/23/2021 4:56:42 PM
6/23/2021 4:57:55 PM
6/23/2021 5:01:37 PM
6/23/2021 5:18:24 PM
6/23/2021 5:28:42 PM
6/23/2021 5:31:31 PM
6/23/2021 5:33:19 PM
6/23/2021 5:42:06 PM
6/23/2021 5:42:27 PM
6/23/2021 5:43:16 PM
6/23/2021 5:49:56 PM
6/23/2021 5:50:15 PM
6/23/2021 5:54:27 PM
6/23/2021 5:54:28 PM
6/23/2021 5:56:14 PM
6/23/2021 5:57:45 PM
6/23/2021 5:59:14 PM
6/23/2021 6:01:47 PM
6/23/2021 6:03:07 PM
6/23/2021 6:06:41 PM
6/23/2021 6:11:11 PM
6/23/2021 6:14:01 PM
6/23/2021 6:16:22 PM
6/23/2021 6:17:40 PM
6/23/2021 6:18:35 PM
6/23/2021 6:24:48 PM
6/23/2021 6:25:19 PM
6/23/2021 6:27:20 PM
6/23/2021 6:27:39 PM
6/23/2021 6:27:41 PM
6/23/2021 6:31:29 PM
6/23/2021 6:33:11 PM
6/23/2021 6:33:31 PM
6/23/2021 6:36:40 PM
6/23/2021 6:44:00 PM
6/23/2021 6:44:49 PM
6/23/2021 6:45:59 PM
6/23/2021 6:47:36 PM
6/23/2021 6:53:18 PM
6/23/2021 7:02:44 PM
6/23/2021 7:04:28 PM
6/23/2021 7:29:34 PM
6/23/2021 7:34:13 PM
6/23/2021 7:39:02 PM
6/23/2021 7:46:16 PM
6/23/2021 7:50:30 PM
6/23/2021 7:52:20 PM
6/23/2021 7:55:36 PM
6/23/2021 7:56:10 PM
6/23/2021 7:58:36 PM
6/23/2021 7:58:40 PM
6/23/2021 8:03:55 PM
6/23/2021 8:08:34 PM
6/23/2021 8:12:37 PM
6/23/2021 8:17:43 PM
6/23/2021 8:19:49 PM
6/23/2021 8:20:28 PM
6/23/2021 8:21:13 PM
6/23/2021 8:25:39 PM
6/23/2021 8:29:09 PM
6/23/2021 8:29:22 PM
6/23/2021 8:29:32 PM
6/23/2021 8:36:51 PM
6/23/2021 8:37:17 PM
6/23/2021 8:38:23 PM
6/23/2021 8:39:05 PM
6/23/2021 8:39:52 PM
6/23/2021 8:44:45 PM
6/23/2021 8:52:11 PM
6/23/2021 8:57:20 PM
6/23/2021 9:04:54 PM
6/23/2021 9:05:30 PM
6/23/2021 9:13:15 PM
6/23/2021 9:19:29 PM
6/23/2021 9:24:54 PM
6/23/2021 9:28:14 PM
6/23/2021 9:30:38 PM
6/23/2021 9:32:29 PM
6/23/2021 9:33:09 PM
6/23/2021 9:45:36 PM
6/23/2021 9:47:40 PM
6/23/2021 9:48:32 PM
6/23/2021 9:49:05 PM
6/23/2021 9:52:13 PM
6/23/2021 9:59:20 PM
6/23/2021 9:59:44 PM
6/23/2021 10:00:35 PM
6/23/2021 10:03:28 PM
6/23/2021 10:10:54 PM
6/23/2021 10:14:15 PM
6/23/2021 10:17:04 PM
6/23/2021 10:20:22 PM
6/23/2021 10:21:51 PM
6/23/2021 10:29:49 PM
6/23/2021 10:32:14 PM
6/23/2021 10:33:22 PM
6/23/2021 10:37:02 PM
6/23/2021 10:38:17 PM
6/23/2021 10:44:57 PM
6/23/2021 10:58:00 PM
6/23/2021 11:15:46 PM
6/23/2021 11:16:50 PM
6/23/2021 11:21:01 PM
6/23/2021 11:24:04 PM
6/23/2021 11:28:05 PM
6/23/2021 11:29:29 PM
6/23/2021 11:30:29 PM
6/23/2021 11:36:22 PM
6/23/2021 11:40:02 PM
6/24/2021 12:00:49 AM
6/24/2021 12:01:58 AM
6/24/2021 12:15:36 AM
6/24/2021 12:20:40 AM
6/24/2021 12:44:38 AM
6/24/2021 12:55:27 AM
6/24/2021 2:22:32 AM
6/24/2021 2:22:35 AM
6/24/2021 3:32:09 AM
6/24/2021 5:29:41 AM
6/24/2021 5:35:10 AM
6/24/2021 5:47:10 AM
6/24/2021 6:04:59 AM
6/24/2021 6:11:08 AM
6/24/2021 6:16:55 AM
6/24/2021 6:20:13 AM
6/24/2021 6:26:06 AM
6/24/2021 6:42:16 AM
6/24/2021 6:52:48 AM
6/24/2021 6:56:18 AM
6/24/2021 6:57:20 AM
6/24/2021 7:01:32 AM
6/24/2021 7:08:47 AM
6/24/2021 7:11:27 AM
6/24/2021 7:12:40 AM
6/24/2021 7:16:53 AM
6/24/2021 7:20:04 AM
6/24/2021 7:26:37 AM
6/24/2021 7:29:29 AM
6/24/2021 7:34:16 AM
6/24/2021 7:35:56 AM
6/24/2021 7:38:14 AM
6/24/2021 7:42:02 AM
6/24/2021 7:44:43 AM
6/24/2021 7:49:56 AM
6/24/2021 7:52:39 AM
6/24/2021 7:57:03 AM
6/24/2021 8:06:31 AM
6/24/2021 8:06:32 AM
6/24/2021 8:09:41 AM
6/24/2021 8:10:44 AM
6/24/2021 8:15:42 AM
6/24/2021 8:16:53 AM
6/24/2021 8:19:36 AM
6/24/2021 8:21:44 AM
6/24/2021 8:29:05 AM
6/24/2021 8:30:01 AM
6/24/2021 8:34:02 AM
6/24/2021 8:37:04 AM
6/24/2021 8:41:20 AM
6/24/2021 8:42:39 AM
6/24/2021 8:44:32 AM
6/24/2021 8:47:04 AM
6/24/2021 8:50:16 AM
6/24/2021 8:57:11 AM
6/24/2021 8:58:51 AM
6/24/2021 9:04:44 AM
6/24/2021 9:12:32 AM
6/24/2021 9:13:18 AM
6/24/2021 9:17:40 AM
6/24/2021 9:18:34 AM
6/24/2021 9:21:08 AM
6/24/2021 9:23:02 AM
6/24/2021 9:24:04 AM
6/24/2021 9:26:23 AM
6/24/2021 9:36:06 AM
6/24/2021 9:37:15 AM
6/24/2021 9:39:23 AM
6/24/2021 9:41:21 AM
6/24/2021 9:49:44 AM
6/24/2021 9:51:43 AM
6/24/2021 9:52:48 AM
6/24/2021 9:57:44 AM
6/24/2021 10:01:37 AM
6/24/2021 10:03:53 AM
6/24/2021 10:08:05 AM
6/24/2021 10:16:14 AM
6/24/2021 10:16:36 AM
6/24/2021 10:16:40 AM
6/24/2021 10:19:27 AM
6/24/2021 10:23:08 AM
6/24/2021 10:24:39 AM
6/24/2021 10:28:52 AM
6/24/2021 10:41:53 AM
6/24/2021 10:46:02 AM
6/24/2021 10:46:26 AM
6/24/2021 10:50:25 AM
6/24/2021 10:58:18 AM
6/24/2021 11:02:37 AM
6/24/2021 11:03:28 AM
6/24/2021 11:04:31 AM
6/24/2021 11:04:45 AM
6/24/2021 11:04:58 AM
6/24/2021 11:06:20 AM
6/24/2021 11:07:04 AM
6/24/2021 11:14:07 AM
6/24/2021 11:14:36 AM
6/24/2021 11:18:44 AM
6/24/2021 11:20:28 AM
6/24/2021 11:20:35 AM
6/24/2021 11:27:51 AM
6/24/2021 11:28:16 AM
6/24/2021 11:29:00 AM
6/24/2021 11:31:08 AM
6/24/2021 11:32:18 AM
6/24/2021 11:36:53 AM
6/24/2021 11:37:53 AM
6/24/2021 11:39:19 AM
6/24/2021 11:40:13 AM
6/24/2021 11:42:40 AM
6/24/2021 11:43:48 AM
6/24/2021 11:43:55 AM
6/24/2021 11:47:01 AM
6/24/2021 11:50:44 AM
6/24/2021 11:59:28 AM
6/24/2021 12:04:15 PM
6/24/2021 12:04:18 PM
6/24/2021 12:11:19 PM
6/24/2021 12:20:14 PM
6/24/2021 12:23:43 PM
6/24/2021 12:29:15 PM
6/24/2021 12:30:40 PM
6/24/2021 12:32:25 PM
6/24/2021 12:35:43 PM
6/24/2021 12:35:46 PM
6/24/2021 12:35:57 PM
6/24/2021 12:36:04 PM
6/24/2021 12:44:58 PM
6/24/2021 12:46:29 PM
6/24/2021 12:48:15 PM
6/24/2021 12:51:54 PM
6/24/2021 12:55:52 PM
6/24/2021 1:04:32 PM
6/24/2021 1:07:24 PM
6/24/2021 1:08:17 PM
6/24/2021 1:15:11 PM
6/24/2021 1:18:33 PM
6/24/2021 1:22:15 PM
6/24/2021 1:28:14 PM
6/24/2021 1:30:20 PM
6/24/2021 1:30:32 PM
6/24/2021 1:33:20 PM
6/24/2021 1:40:47 PM
6/24/2021 1:55:03 PM
6/24/2021 1:55:04 PM
6/24/2021 1:59:39 PM
6/24/2021 2:01:15 PM
6/24/2021 2:04:39 PM
6/24/2021 2:11:27 PM
6/24/2021 2:18:29 PM
6/24/2021 2:21:00 PM
6/24/2021 2:30:24 PM
6/24/2021 2:31:45 PM
6/24/2021 2:34:45 PM
6/24/2021 2:37:35 PM
6/24/2021 2:37:37 PM
6/24/2021 2:37:44 PM
6/24/2021 2:38:46 PM
6/24/2021 2:38:57 PM
6/24/2021 2:39:32 PM
6/24/2021 2:52:00 PM
6/24/2021 2:55:42 PM
6/24/2021 2:55:43 PM
6/24/2021 2:56:25 PM
6/25/2021 8:48:41 AM
6/25/2021 10:18:02 AM
6/25/2021 11:18:24 PM
6/28/2021 7:49:42 PM
6/29/2021 7:55:49 PM
6/29/2021 8:20:10 PM
6/29/2021 9:06:29 PM
6/29/2021 9:14:20 PM
6/29/2021 9:20:52 PM
6/29/2021 11:43:10 PM
6/30/2021 8:56:38 AM
6/30/2021 8:59:31 AM
6/30/2021 9:44:34 PM
7/1/2021 6:32:30 AM
7/1/2021 6:32:34 AM
7/1/2021 6:32:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:32:54 AM
7/1/2021 6:33:15 AM
7/1/2021 6:33:16 AM
7/1/2021 6:34:06 AM
7/1/2021 6:34:22 AM
7/1/2021 6:34:41 AM
7/1/2021 6:38:51 AM
7/1/2021 7:22:22 AM
7/1/2021 1:10:15 PM
7/1/2021 5:04:20 PM
7/2/2021 9:13:52 AM
7/2/2021 10:50:59 AM
7/2/2021 10:51:12 AM
7/2/2021 10:53:05 AM
7/2/2021 10:54:16 AM
7/2/2021 10:54:17 AM
7/2/2021 11:04:19 AM
7/2/2021 12:25:35 PM
7/2/2021 12:29:49 PM
7/2/2021 1:16:56 PM
7/2/2021 1:24:14 PM
7/2/2021 2:22:37 PM
7/3/2021 7:44:44 AM
7/3/2021 8:05:30 AM
7/3/2021 8:15:28 AM
7/3/2021 10:22:23 AM
7/3/2021 12:06:38 PM
7/3/2021 12:54:13 PM
7/3/2021 12:55:24 PM
7/3/2021 11:57:25 PM
7/4/2021 4:27:47 PM
7/5/2021 7:02:28 AM
7/5/2021 1:57:56 PM
7/5/2021 11:42:02 PM
7/6/2021 7:49:28 AM
7/6/2021 8:01:41 AM
7/6/2021 8:05:59 AM
7/6/2021 8:23:10 AM
7/6/2021 8:28:56 AM
7/6/2021 8:29:19 AM
7/6/2021 8:49:15 AM
7/6/2021 8:50:37 AM
7/6/2021 8:55:13 AM
7/6/2021 8:56:40 AM
7/6/2021 9:01:54 AM
7/6/2021 9:02:41 AM
7/6/2021 9:06:05 AM
7/6/2021 9:14:39 AM
7/6/2021 9:16:15 AM
7/6/2021 9:28:07 AM
7/6/2021 9:31:01 AM
7/6/2021 9:32:15 AM
7/6/2021 9:33:12 AM
7/6/2021 9:41:51 AM
7/6/2021 10:05:49 AM
7/6/2021 10:17:26 AM
7/6/2021 10:49:28 AM
7/6/2021 10:50:38 AM
7/6/2021 11:42:44 AM
7/6/2021 12:30:28 PM
7/6/2021 12:54:15 PM
7/6/2021 1:45:28 PM
7/6/2021 1:45:44 PM
7/6/2021 1:47:31 PM
7/6/2021 1:54:59 PM
7/6/2021 2:11:03 PM
7/6/2021 2:15:58 PM
7/6/2021 2:18:17 PM
7/6/2021 2:27:38 PM
7/6/2021 2:29:38 PM
7/6/2021 3:09:55 PM
7/6/2021 3:14:11 PM
7/6/2021 3:21:18 PM
7/6/2021 3:29:20 PM
7/6/2021 3:58:45 PM
7/6/2021 4:02:28 PM
7/6/2021 4:07:20 PM
7/6/2021 4:18:25 PM
7/6/2021 4:25:17 PM
7/6/2021 4:31:54 PM
7/6/2021 4:39:12 PM
7/6/2021 4:44:58 PM
7/6/2021 4:53:24 PM
7/6/2021 5:04:50 PM
7/6/2021 5:21:34 PM
7/6/2021 5:43:13 PM
7/6/2021 6:14:03 PM
7/6/2021 6:14:57 PM
7/6/2021 6:33:52 PM
7/6/2021 6:39:07 PM
7/6/2021 6:40:56 PM
7/6/2021 6:46:50 PM
7/6/2021 7:11:00 PM
7/6/2021 7:21:06 PM
7/6/2021 7:28:45 PM
7/6/2021 8:11:11 PM
7/6/2021 8:18:33 PM
7/6/2021 8:34:52 PM
7/6/2021 9:13:04 PM
7/6/2021 9:27:39 PM
7/6/2021 9:39:21 PM
7/6/2021 10:08:31 PM
7/6/2021 10:14:45 PM
7/6/2021 10:15:24 PM
7/6/2021 10:16:03 PM
7/6/2021 10:20:57 PM
7/6/2021 10:43:50 PM
7/6/2021 11:06:25 PM
7/6/2021 11:19:17 PM
7/6/2021 11:24:07 PM
7/6/2021 11:34:37 PM
7/6/2021 11:38:19 PM
7/7/2021 12:10:50 AM
7/7/2021 12:27:21 AM
7/7/2021 2:46:44 AM
7/7/2021 5:24:17 AM
7/7/2021 7:30:47 AM
7/7/2021 8:00:39 AM
7/7/2021 8:12:40 AM
7/7/2021 8:15:39 AM
7/7/2021 8:15:52 AM
7/7/2021 8:51:00 AM
7/7/2021 9:01:58 AM
7/7/2021 9:03:42 AM
7/7/2021 9:50:49 AM
7/7/2021 10:41:32 AM
7/7/2021 11:09:00 AM
7/7/2021 11:12:17 AM
7/7/2021 12:47:03 PM
7/7/2021 12:57:48 PM
7/7/2021 1:08:06 PM
7/7/2021 1:48:53 PM
7/7/2021 2:04:33 PM
7/7/2021 2:06:30 PM
7/7/2021 2:30:04 PM
7/7/2021 2:51:01 PM
7/7/2021 2:52:46 PM
7/7/2021 3:35:27 PM
7/7/2021 4:16:15 PM
7/7/2021 4:49:18 PM
7/7/2021 4:49:22 PM
7/7/2021 5:19:32 PM
7/7/2021 5:35:56 PM
7/7/2021 5:57:55 PM
7/7/2021 5:58:50 PM
7/7/2021 7:29:26 PM
7/7/2021 8:27:59 PM
7/7/2021 11:10:36 PM
7/7/2021 11:21:26 PM
7/7/2021 11:29:12 PM
7/8/2021 12:50:02 AM
7/8/2021 1:59:39 AM
7/8/2021 6:12:39 AM
7/8/2021 7:22:27 AM
7/8/2021 7:25:45 AM
7/8/2021 7:39:52 AM
7/8/2021 7:49:40 AM
7/8/2021 7:59:30 AM
7/8/2021 8:07:21 AM
7/8/2021 8:13:54 AM
7/8/2021 8:37:50 AM
7/8/2021 8:53:28 AM
7/8/2021 10:06:53 AM
7/8/2021 10:08:30 AM
7/8/2021 10:13:13 AM
7/8/2021 10:20:03 AM
7/8/2021 10:22:40 AM
7/8/2021 10:55:11 AM
7/8/2021 11:41:11 AM
7/8/2021 12:35:36 PM
7/8/2021 1:10:09 PM
7/8/2021 1:12:45 PM
7/8/2021 1:16:00 PM
7/8/2021 1:26:17 PM
7/8/2021 1:27:04 PM
7/8/2021 1:27:42 PM
7/8/2021 1:28:38 PM
7/8/2021 1:29:20 PM
7/8/2021 1:37:10 PM
7/8/2021 1:45:00 PM
7/8/2021 2:21:01 PM
7/8/2021 2:38:06 PM
7/8/2021 2:40:01 PM
7/8/2021 2:54:15 PM
7/8/2021 2:58:50 PM
7/8/2021 2:59:23 PM
Email
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
anonymous
Name
Enter First and Last Name - A bona fide name is required in order for public comment to be communicated to council.
David Simmonds
Faye Thompson
Roger gossi
Karen Bouch
Karen Hornfelt
Sharon Tucker
Colleen Bright Ross
Eddie and Danielle Gray
Dean Gard
Debra Staup
Daniel O'Malley
Daniel O'Malley
Simon Ingham
Marilyn Olson
Debra and Jim Staup
Cherise White
pat collins
Jamie Melbo
Dale Allen
Joe Luff
Mark Dooley
Debra and Jim Staup
Julie Conrad
Julie Conrad
Ernest Revello
Shelby Edwards
Darlene Kohout
Larry Hauder
Emily Hart
Benita Shaw Giltzow
Mark Dooley
Doris Eaton
Marsha L Bennett
Sandra Borbonus
Valerie Murray
Danielle Custer
Stephanie Schaff
Kristie Williams
Karen Scott
Nancy Krahn
Veronique Borbonus
Sallie Oberlin
Sandie Schaumburg
Colleen Ross
Sarah Williams
Ian Williams
Lew Ross
Kristiina Spencer
Jeff Martel
Sherri Pedersen
Marta Paulson
Sarah Curtright
Tim Curtright
Judy Curtright
Gail Rankin
Cherie Wick
Connor Wick
Bruce Rankin
Ashton Wick
Wendy Albright
Jessie Farnsworth
Sue Schaffner
Kim Brandt
James and Debra Staup
Brad Bartlett
Kim French
James French
Jeanine Halbesleben
Patty Hickman
Shermayne Young
Pamela Willett
Brian Recher
Sondra McMindes
Zoran Trejos-French
Deborah Smit
Linda Tunis
Donna Hoffman
Jackie Mitchell
John Riggins
Melanie Curry
Marjolein Lolkema
Brenda Jansson
Susan Cottrell
Jennifer Garland
Rod Groff
Eddie and Danielle Gray
Jennifer Leavitt
Patricia Braganza
Harlie Burgess
Kris Cox
Teia McCormick
Kara-Jo A. Cone
Margo Flaherty
Amber Levanger
Chris
Sara Brooks
Mary Fain
Rosie Saenz
No
Omega Taylor
DON'T KILL THE DEER!
Sandy Williamson
Barbara Minton
Kristy Payme
Sarah Reyes
Barbara Harper
Donna Robinson
Marvin Lockwood
Tami Beus
Brandy Jones
No feed ordinance
Amanda Brunmeier
John Henry Mitchell III
Kori Merlino
Judy Pridham
Moriah Riley
Janet Williamson
Ann Taylor
Anna Roy
Michelle Streiff
Corii Williams
Heather Troughton
Charlie Glenn
Katie Gwinn
Mary Beth Resimius
Ginger Riggins
Britny McCoubrey
Meg & Steve Glasgow
Kim Knuth
Tanya Masterson
SUZANNE COFFEY
Sue Switzer
Christi kenley
Lisa Loera-Rhinehart
Elena Weza
Kristi Christensen
Molly Lewellen
Martha subia
Trishanne Beckner
Heather Hamann
Debra WINN
Michelle koenig
Teresa Lynch
Garth Lynch
Alana Duke
Ron Mattox
Sheri Petersen
Hanna Lynch
Bethany Allie
Ginny Ackley
Jan Journey
Frank Journey
Julio Vega
Pat Farrell
ReNae Bradfield
Beverly wise
Melinda Thomson(Carey)
Steve Baker
Connie Ickes
Kriss Steuart
Christi Smith
Tarra owings
Amy Klingler
Brenda Hill
Dan O'Malley
Paula Mannlein
Shannon Riggs
Sherry McTigue
Heather Potts
Patty Stanbrough
Pamela Frazer
Jamey McInally
Jan Beckwith
Stan Kalinovskiy
Dona Jeka
Sara Lee
Christine Cruickshank
Chris Joyal
Barbara Langdon
Susan Evans
Jennifer Stickles
Teresa Wilson
Marilyn Buchholz
David Atkinson
Michelle Arguello
Regan Flanagan
Deborah Wetherell
Candace Sherwin
Michelle Campbell
Joseph S Wasula
Vickie Riss
Karen Roben
Michele Moncure
Becky Thomas
Jett Newell
Donna Trout
Jennifer Poncia Ragsdale
Kathy Dillon
Erin Roland
100 percent against this
Rich Wright
Dwight Peterson
Katie Hudson
Ilene Stittsworth
Doug Huntley
Robert West
Jennifer Smith
Mary Tucker
Leila Kerschensteiner
James Boley
Mary Stevens
Rocky Paulson
Lorraine Hunter
Crystal Deelstra
Kelli Day
Cathy Thayer
Kayla Riggs
Gina Thruston
Jo anne Busch
Aemilia Harper
Joani Labrousse
Patrick Cusick
Carin Gholson
Ann M. Cowher
Penny owens
Melissa Courtright
John Fawcett
Jeremy Courtright
Annette Charles
Christopher Culler
Wendy McClellin
Dreena tabor
Arthur Alyanakian
Julie Warwick
Tessi Lindley
Lisa Schneider
Mark Dooley
Kelly Paananen
Ann Pruitt
Deborah Moreno
Val Olsen
Kristy Enbysk
Mike Sorensen
Stacey Hansen
Margo Wyman
Robin Gerblick
Brittney Jones
Mindy Miller
Helen Timothy
Ryan North
Deanna Thomas
Mary Kolbet
Makeesha boyum
RyAnn Mager
Tyler Mager
Ron and Joni Korthals
Pamela Eskelin Reichel
Malee Thomas
Wendy Loomis
Paul Thomas
Lisa Durning
Helen Powers
Chris Reichert
Angela Shoecraft
Kendall Northcutt
Brenda Jansson
Destiny Platt
Kim Mitchell
Zoe Metcalf
Karen Hancock
Madison Hamilton
Karen and James Bouden
LaDessa Foster
Darla Weekes
Leila Farley
Christy Schill-Newbold
Cathy Jasperson
karen Bouden
Scott Thibodeau
Lannie Davis
Shannon Ochoa
Lynn Wayne
Jenny Fawcett
Vicky Perez
Cathy Mosman
Julie Warwick
Sara Powell
Benita and Alan Giltzow
Lisa Wood
Ashlea Gray
Linda Estes
Barbara Brown
Julie Conrad
Cindy Boyce
Kelcey Gentry
Niky Hoffman
Jennifer Thornfeldt
Tuck Miller
Ardis Hewitt
Meredith Carlson
Christine Reino
Lynne Lawless
Pamela Weathers
Joan Whitacre
Katie Lynn Strode
Shelly Miiller
Shirley duffy
Denise McNamee
Julie Conrad
Jon Umbdenstock
Julie Conrad
Joanne Conrad
Haley Paulsen
Sandra Stern
Marilyn Olson
Ashlyn Bideganeta
Michelle Sanders
Ina Harts
Keynan Fanslow
AnnMarie Halverson
Barbara A Lutz
Renee Baird
Laura Kirk
Deanne Seiler
Cathy Buffington
Diane Sanders
Emily Hart
Amy Kohler
Karissa Tatom
Denice Ruse-Sullivan
Suzette Driscoll
Shannon Reeves
melswfstage@ sbcglobal.net
Teresa Daily
Dianne Ryan
Heidi Baumgartner
Hali James
Jim and Debra Staup
Tracy Hunter
Kaitlin Parsons
Jennifer Wahlquist
Kay Ernst
Julie Hellerman
Thomas Sowers
Nikki Nakan
Heather ODonnell
Nadina Zarkowski
Heather ODonnell
Lori Crogh
Ashlee Enbysk
Melissa Dibbe
Aldana Kay Enbysk
Ramona Hildebran
Cinda Perez
Ann Smith
Patti Komp
Tanya Gaona
Suzette Driscoll
Kristi Christensen
Kristi Christensen
Amy Staufer
Candace Sherwin
Steve Gleason
Judy Gleason
Amy Leaf
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Cindy Maestas
Dallas Young
Jenny Fawcett
Katy Stoll
Marianne Jones
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Jackie Mitchell
ReNae Bradfield
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Susan and Lloyd Bence
Sarah Chambers
Rick & Deb Fereday
Faye Thompson
Edit Szanto
Melissa Kinzer
Jennifer Robnett
Jennifer Robnett
Anna Roy
Gwen Asmussen
Amber Levanger
Donald Bailey
Against
Bryant Forrester
Tracy Breidfjord
Bret Shoulfer
Brenda Jansson
Pamela Eskelin Reichel
Mary Ann Keller
Donella Groseclose
Heidi Kilian
Todd Kohlbecker
Melanie Curry
Lindsey Genenbacher
Jeff Groseclose
Francine smith
Judy Pridham
Sarah Ward
Phillip Custer
Jana Harrison
Rich & Catherine Lynd
Richard Harrison
Alexis Cobb
Mary Beth Resimius
Carrie LaFay
Frank Journey
Jan Journey
Ken Steinhauer
Rosie Saenz
Alec Weinert
Moriah Riley
Sandie Schaumburg
Sebastian Mancari
Angela Becker
Karen strop
Stephanie Schaff
Brad Bartlett
Robert Williams
Corii Williams
Jennifer Smith
Donna Hoffman
Halley Shultz
Barbara Brown
Monica L Hellman
Jason Huntley
Christine Reino
Becky Thomas
Darlene Anderson
Sandra Borbonus
Mary kemnitz
Anna Hoffpauir
Jennifer Ragsdale
April VanDeGrift
Patricia Minor
Jill Gaughan
Cathleen Curtiss
Lee Curtiss
William Douglas Huntley
Michelle Seaton
Debbie Briest
Natalie Stradley
Dana Cook
Stuart Ward
Elizabeth Fulton
Keep the Deer!
Kristi Christensen
Jim Christensen
Joan Whitacre
Lisa Wood
Steve Baker
Catherine Konrath
Teresa Lynch
Garth Lynch
Hanna Lynch
Elena Weza
Michelle Streiff
Deborah Wetherell
Sarah Williams
Adam Rohrig
Veronique Borbonus
Heather Hayes
Meg & Steve Glasgow
Michael Bourke
Teresa Leavitt
Johannah Strobaugh
Rubén Gaona
Cherise White
Frances De Melo
Paula Montgomery
Dan Cole
Jennifer Tunnell
Stephen Gleason
Judy Gleason
Margo Flaherty
Peggy holmes
pat collins
Christy Curtiss
Randy and Patty Hickmab
Angela Kirkland
Kimberly Northway
Cathy Jasperson
Rozlyn Sheridan
Patrick Sheridan
Staci Trenkel
Michelle Samders
Marcia Woodbury
Janet Meckel
Susan Jaussi
Ginny Ackley
Eileen Swigert
Deanna Swigert
NO
Rhonda Vesper
Jeremy Holland
Kara Dougherty
Dan O'Malley
Larry Stokes
Danielle Custer
Ana Woods
Gail Draper
Wayne Sawdy
Dan Reid
Kathy Sawdy
Robert Martin
Julie Conrad
Julie Conrad
Linda J tunis
Jerry Mills
Kayla Adams
Eileen Nelson
Laura Hurst
Stephen Edwards
Audra Edwards
Anna Sheppard-Suumerfield
Chris Clapperton
Kim Batt-Lincoln
John Rainey
Tina Joiner
Jim, Debra, Angela Staup
Kristy Enbysk
Michael Sorensen
Leila Farley
Ashlee Enbysk
Aldana Kay Enbysk
Curtis Cramer
Krista Wilson
Cohner fry
Toni Slaymaker
Debi peterson
Colleen Ross
Pamela Fink
Angela Staup
Kevin Boothe
Shay Tyler
Kitty Boothe
Enter Complete Address
506 Sunset St, PO Box 287, McCall ID 83638
13828 Shadow Ridge, McCall
1200 Aspen ridge ln
704 Reedy Lane, McCall Idaho
4014 Fairway Drive Lewiston ID 83501
1022 Evergreen Dr., McCall, ID 83638
PO Box 510, McCall, ID
705 Reedy lane
1600 Lawrence Dr. McCall, ID 83638
ikaria@mac.com
1535 McCall Avenue
1535 McCall Avenue
1658 Timber Circle McCall ID 83638
P.O. Box 455 (890 Timber Ridge Ct.), McCall, ID, 83638
P.O. Box 1221
1324 Eagle Dr McCall, Idaho 83638
1324 eagle dr mccall idaho 83638
506 Sunset St McCall, ID
914 Chipmunk Lane
414 Floyde St. McCall, ID 83638
258 Ernesto
P.O. Box 1221 McCall, Idaho 83638
1423 Eagle Drive P.O. Box 2755 McCall, ID 83638
1423 Eagle Drive PO Box 2755 McCall ID 83638
pob 518 McCall ID 83638
sjedward@aol.com
917 Fairway Dr 14b
1504 Louisa Ave, McCall, ID
702 1st Street McCall, ID 83638
199 Hazel Place, Donnelly , ID 83615
258 Ernesto
212 N. 3rd Street, Suite D, McCall ID 83638
221 Lake St #9 McCall Id 83638
1746 N. Monterossa Way Eagle Idaho
23121 Freezeout Rd. Caldwell, Idaho 83607
411f Deinhard Lane McCall ID83638
430 Ringel St. Mccall, Id 83638
1102 N. 7th St. Parma, ID. 83660
277 S Cobblestone Way, Eagle, ID 83616
906 Ann Street, McCall
10060 W Roan Meadows dr Boise, ID 83709
POBox 1722, McCall ID
5614 Lakewood Ave Caldwell, ID 83607
PO Box 510, McCall, ID
200 Jacob st. McCall Idaho
317 Mountain Cove Court
PO Box 510, McCall, ID
8016 W Whittaker st Boise Idaho 83714
Jeff@43re.com
431 McGinnis St McCall
624 Ruby Street
4365 W Cherry Lane Meridian, ID 83642
12856 Axel Donnelly, ID 83615
12856 Axel Rd Donnelly, ID 83615
675 Fox Ridge Lane
12856 Axel Donnelly
12856 Axel Donnelly
675 Fox Ridge Lane
12856 Axel
1075 Shady Lane Loop, McCall, ID
1575 West Ryegrass Court
12961 Ponderosa Dr Donnelly Id
10982 W Tioga St, Boise, ID 83709
P.O. Box 1221 McCall, ID
1610 S Loggers Pond Place Apt. 16 Boise Idaho 83706
kkfrench69@gmail.com
jfrenchjr1969@gmail.com
10960 W. Shetland Rd. - Boise, ID 83709
1603 Davis Ave
9931 Hwy 45 Middleton, Id 83644
7350 Gary Lane Boise, Idaho 83714
14005 hogue hollow road. Mccall ID 83638
3308 Shaggy Mane
1425 liberty at unit 5 Boise ID 83704
507 Hemlock st, unit 72, McCall
box 606 McCall
850 Shelia Ln,McCall,Id 83638
300 Mather Rd, McCall ID 83638
662 Koski Dr., McCall, ID 83638 (PO Box 1925)
670 Koski McCall, Id 83638
3 Squirrel Ln, Garden Valley, 83622, ID
8958 W Candleston ct Boise ID 83709 (I lived in McCall for 15 years)
2517 E Ohio Ave Nampa Idaho 83686
1656 Davis Ave.
6316 castle Dr, Boise Idaho
705 Reedy lane
6596 S Jessenia Ave, Boise ID
1201 Roosevelt Avenue, McCall, ID
P. O. Box 4416 McCall Idaho 83638
319 W Hunley, Ave Westport, WA 98520
7700 S Carpenter Ave. Boise, Idaho 83709
331 Mather Road
PO Box 515 Donnelly ID 83615
236 Rio Vista Blvd
Chris@draftcard.com
2730 N Dalton ln
PO Box 1955 McCall
5733 Abby Dr, Corpus Christi TX 78413
12966 Zoon ln, McCall Idaho 83638
1896 W Lake Pointe Ct, Nampa, ID 83651
220 hoffman ave. Pocatello, idaho 8320q
McCall, Idaho
1630 Davis Ave #23
600 S Winterberry Ct Nampa, ID 83687
909 E Jefferson St Boise, ID 83712
156 Pile St, P.O.Box 69, Ramona,Ca 92065
507 Bluewater Hwy , Surfside Tx 77541
117 Gavin’s Place, Yankton, South Dakota. 57078
1412 mill rd Emmett I’d 83617
1241 Herrick St McCall Idaho 83638
1104 n b st Parma idaho 83660
11599 cabin creek st
300 Mather Rd McCall, ID 83638
494 Cammy Drive
2048 Eastside Way
11243 W Silver River Loop
1225 hwy 26
8971 Bowmont Rd. Nampa Id. 83686
1664 Warren Wagon Road
932 Strawberry Lane McCall Idaho
Calgary, AB, Canada
231 NW 10th Street, Ontario Oregon 97914
2619 fruitvale rd, Council Id
1022 Violet Way, McCall Idaho 83638
3315 Whitefield Lane #1569, McCall, ID 83638
662 Koski Dr., PO Box 1925, McCall, ID 83638
10008 W Tanglewood Dr
235 Ernesto Drive, McCall Idaho 83638
16 Bobcat Ct, Garden Valley, Id 83622
2 Sawtooth Ct
2112 W Neilscott Dr. Nampa, ID. 83651
224 Moonridge Dr. PO Box 4164 McCall Idaho 83638
13775 Clearview road mccall Idaho 83638
300 Washington St # 214 McCall ( also P.O. Box 597 83619)
481 155th ave se Bellevue Wa 98007
906 conifer St McCall Idaho 83638
2245 SW 1st Ave, Fruitland
820 w homedale rd
24689 Warren Wagon Rd
409 W 1st St Fruitland, Id
540 Linder Ave. Kuna, ID 83634
mnkoenig@gmail.com
805 Agate St McCall Idaho 83638
805 Agate St McCall Idaho 83638
117 E Butterfield St Weiser Idaho 83672
13650 S. Coquille St. Nampa, Idaho 83651
626 Blue Water Circle, McCall, Idaho 83638
805 Agate St McCall Idaho 83638
12209 W Foxhaven St, Star ID 83669
250 Cold Creek Court McCall
12912 195th Ave Ct E Bonney Lake Wa 98391
12912 195th Ave Ct E Bonney Lake Wa
505 post oak lane Burleson, Texas
14118 Tricia St.
705 Broken Rein Rd, P.O. Box 841, McCall
11428 west Hiawatha dr., Boise ID 83709
18 Chisholm Place Wyndham Vale Victoria Australia
2156 E. Hyper Dr. Meridian Idaho
1915 Bear Basin Road, McCall, Idaho 83638
628 E Woodbury meridian idaho
1855 Jones Road, Weiser, ID. 83672
1369 nw 4th ave Ontario Oregon 97914
Against the matter
1418 Us Hwy 95 Weiser I’d 83672
1535 McCall Ave. McCall, Idaho 83638
2385 E Amity Rd Meridian ID 83642
8097 Waterleaf Ave Nampa ID 83687
1437 E Lewis, Boise, ID 83712
1017 Cee Way Loop, McCall
753 W Tropical Dr Nampa, ID
19493 Red Eagle Way. Caldwell Idaho 83605
End of the Road
5378 Elk Ridge Dr, Eugene, OR 97402
114 East Lake St McCall ID 83638
12604 W Murchison, Boise. Id
8517 HWY 95, Payette, ID 83661
311 Burns Rd, McCall ID 83638
P.O. Box 672 New Meadows Idaho 83654
302 Mather Rd #A22
201 Rio Vista Blvd. McCall, ID 83638
Boise ID 83709
216 Angus Lane. Donnelly, ID
208 Rosemont, San Gabriel, CA
13395 W. Paint St. Boise ID 83713
1918 Cambridge St Caldwell idaho
635 Ruby St McCall Idaho 83638
3550 KP Cove Mccall, ID 83616
4879 W Mystic Cove Way Boise ID 83714
2304 NE 16th St. Fruitland, ID 83619
391 Silver City Drive, Boise
11 Wakerrobin McCall ID
8045 Chancellor Drive Colorado Springs, Co 80920
41741 Switzerland Dr
570 Shelia Lane McCall
70 Atkin Lane Cascade, Idaho 83611
2379 North World Cup Way Eagle Idaho 83616
1010 Bitterroot Dr. McCall, ID. 83616
412 S Voyage Ave Caldwell ID 83605
10502 Galloway rd Middleton Id 83644
1075 club rd
233 Ernesto, McCall
233 Ernesto Dr, McCall, ID 83638
423 Colorado street
4043 N Buckboard Way. Boise Idaho
13764 Clear View Ct.
10227 W. Twisted Vine Drive, Star, ID 83669
304 McBride Unit# 102
447 Allen McCall ID 83638
953 N Etheridge Pl Boise Idaho 83704
53 Jughandle Drive, McCall, Idaho 83638
9434 Grasty Gold Mine Road
624 Ruby St McCall ID 83638
954 Settlement Ave Middleton ID 83644
2832 E Tiber Dr
409 N Samson Trl McCall Idaho
5060 Highway 72 New Plymouth I'd 83655
McCall Idaho 83638
109 E. Kerby, Cascade, ID
2205E. Linden #42, Caldwell, ID 83605
2720 Tanglewood Pl, Nampa ID 83687
13816 Shadow Rdg, McCall, ID 83638
7207 W Swift Ln, Boise, ID 83704
4701 Collister
10332 Utahna Rd. Boise, Id. 83714
1237 6th ave s payette id
2602 College ave caldwell idaho 83605
1340 Ridgeway Lane, McCall, Idaho 83638
2602 college ave caldwell idaho
305 east lake street
53 chase drive McCall, Idaho 83638
Mccwen@gmail.com
2962 w. Mark Dr. Sarasota Florida 34232
1035 Monte Vista Ave. Los Banos, Ca. 93635
107 South 13th Ave, Caldwell, ID 83605
2609 Northside Road Homedale Idaho 83628
2946 Syringa Dr. New Meadows Idaho 83654
258 Ernesto McCall, ID. 83638
2021 N. 16th St. Boise Id 83702
1521 Shadowbrook Drive Keller, texas 76248
829 W Riverstone Ct, Nampa, ID 83686
792 Amy Court Boulder City, NV
904 N. Imperial Way, Boise, Idaho 83704
905 Pennfield Place, Caldwell, Idaho
308 S 230 W Jerome ID 83338
1607 Brooklawn, McCall, Idaho
2010 University Lane Pondersosa Park
6670 S Santa Ana Ave, Boise ID, 83709
404 Virginia blvd
2450 Old Sharlie Lane, McCall, Idaho 83638
249 Moonridge Dr, McCall, ID 83638
4405 West Saint Andrews Boise
10383 W Cory St. Boise. Id
115 s ivy St nampa id 83686
18947 Middleton Rd Nampa Idaho 83687
18947 Middleton Rd Nampa Idaho 83687
90 Ridgeview Road, Donnelly, ID
7905 152nd St. Ct. East, Puyallup, WA 98375
19114 Galloway rd Caldwell I'd. 83607
16 Usher Drive
19114 Galloway rd Caldwell Is. 83607
22753 Zephyr Ct Caldwell, ID 83607
1503 Roosevelt Ave., McCall, ID. 83638
908 Specht Ave CALDWELL idaho 83605
2341 Hill rd Boise, ID 83702
423 Floyde St McCall ID 83638
8958 W Candleston ct boise idaho
12685 Hereford Rd, Donnelly, ID 83615
12650 wild rose lane Nampa id 83686
11515 w Silverview st boise Idaho
1209 E Dewey Ave Nampa, ID 83686
949 E Travel Ln, Kuna Idaho
5895 Ensign Ave.
12681 Hereford
5815 Oak St Nampa ID
902 N. Imperial Way, Boise, Idaho 83704
601 East Ash Street Caldwell Idaho
P O Box 412, McCall, ID
5895 Ensign Ave. Garden City Idaho 83714
626 Syringa a Dr
9850 W. Westview
14183 Hancock Rd. McCall
2068 John Alden
1340 Ridgeway Lane
13496 S Hall Topock, AZ 86436
155 E Lake Fork Rd#1941 McCall ID 8363
107 South 13th Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83605
Floyd St
199 Hazel Place Donnelly, Idaho 83615
PO Box 1836, McCall ID 83638
22 Timberline Drive Donnelly ID 83615
1508 W Colorado Ct Nampa ID 83686
1533 Warren Wagon Rd
1423 Eagle Drive McCall, ID 83638 PO Box 2755 McCall, ID 83638
1531 McCall Ave. McCall, Idaho 83638
711 N 6th St Parma, Idaho 83660
138 N 17th St wheeling we 26003
960 Conifer St, McCall, ID 83638
PO Box 2002 McCall Idaho
7062 E Los Carneros Drive Boise
2119 W Bannock St Boise ID, 83702
129 Stibnite #7, McCall, ID 83638
635 Samson Trail McCall Idaho 83638
16865 Bryant Ave., Dos Palos, CA 93620
3300 Whitefield Ln, McCall, ID 83638
814 Carico CRT.
3286 S. Norfolk, Boise, Id 83706
1100 Burnett 358. Nampa,Idaho
5171 s Yarrow Ave Boise ID 83716
1423 Eagle Drive McCall, ID 83638 PO Box 2755 McCall ID 83638
203 n. Heigho New Meadows, 83654
1423 Eagle Drive McCall, ID 83638 PO Box 2755 McCall, ID 83638
2569E Whitebud Court Meridian, Idaho
24549 Fern Lane Wilder, ID 83676
sandystern208@gmail.com
890 Timber Ridge Ct, McCall, Idaho, 83638
522 E Washakie street Meridian Idaho 83646
1500 S. Harmon Rd. Fallon, NV 89406
2333 W Palouse St
13206 S Pine River Way Nampa 83686
1112 Alpine St, McCall, ID 83638
5208 E Homedale Rd Caldwell idaho 83607
13723 Hockberger Ranch Road, Caldwell, ID 83607
623 Syringa Dr Mccall ID
P.O. Box 3225, McCall
3049 S Terri Way
653 Woodlands Dr
702 1st Street McCall, ID 83638
Daveamykohler@gmail.com
4498 E Thomas Mill Drive Nampa, ID 83686
2921 n 36th st Boise Idaho 83703
1664 S Sportsman Way Meridian Idaho 83642
20 Timberline Dr
Melinda Pereira
22912 Cirrus View Court, Caldwell, ID
601 River Street, McCall, Idaho
heidijbb@yahoo.com
146 Trail Loop Dr #201 Paducah, Kentucky
P.O. Box 1221 McCall, ID 83638
4026 N Newland Loop, Lehi, Utah 84043
325 Valley Springs Road Apt D-206
129 Sue Dr McCall, ID
P O Box 117 Vale OR 97918
212 n 3rd #4
261 Buckcamp Rd, McCall ID
Nikki Nakano I live in town and am a full-time employee of the golf course . I truly feel the deer are a fabric of the McCall environment and do feel they are a true asset, not a nuisance
to our environment.
8480 W. Cory Court, Boise, ID 83704
709 Bridle Path Way, McCall, ID 83638
8480 W. Cory Court, Boise ID 83704
13147 Hill House Loop, Box 634 Donnelly ID 83615
6701 Ashland dr Boise ID 83709
25153 Shirley Ln Middleton, ID 83644
6701 Ashland Dr Boise id 83709
128 S Stephenson Street, Eagle, ID 83616
1033 Bitterroot Dr McCall
2533 N Robie Ave, Meridian, ID
929 Conifer
1031 Potts Drive, McCall, ID. 83638
1664 S Sportsman Way Meridian Idaho 83642
906 conifer street McCall Idaho 83638
906 conifer street McCall Idaho 83638
814 evergreen drive, McCall, ID
4879 W Mystic Cove Way Boise ID 83714
341 Memo Circle, McCall, Idaho 83638
341 Memo Circle. McCall, Idaho 83638
14059 Pioneer Rd., McCall, ID 83638
656 Koski McCall ID
656 Koski McCall ID
656 Koski McCall ID
656 Koski McCall ID
656 Koski McCall ID
656 Koski McCall ID
656 Koski McCall ID 83638
656 Koski McCall ID 83638
656 Koski McCall ID 83638
656 Koski
609 Whipkey St. McCall, ID
PO box 2630
227 Rio Vista Blvd Mccall
925 Chipmunk Ln, 4134
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
200 Mather Rd, McCall ID 83638
705 Broken Rein Rd, P.O. Box 841, McCall, Idaho 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
209 Meadow Lake Court
5356 n troon place Boise Idaho 83713/606 lakeside ave McCall
315 Burns Rd McCall
13828 Shadow Ridge Rd
353 Maki Lane, McCall Idaho and 2105 Summit Place, Twin Falls Idaho
924 Conifer Lane, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
1002 Violet Way, McCall, ID 83638
bodianna@hotmail.com
Box 4081 Mccall Idaho 83638
236 Rio Vista Blvd
10990 Bellflower Place, McCall
P.O. Box 672 new Meadows I’d 83654
325 Forest Street McCall ID 83638
1113 Davis ave mccall ID
1103 Cedar , Lot
8958 W Candleston Ct Boise ID 83709
7905 152nd St. Ct. East, Puyallup, WA. 98375
897 West Roseberry, Donnelly ID
4222 E Ashler Hills Dr, Cave Creek, AZ 85331
10265 W Cultis Bay St, Garden City ID 83714
316 Silverpine McCall, Idaho
670 Koski Dr.
1369 Hearthstone Court
1369 Hearthstone Ct. McCall ID 83638
1019 violet way McCall ID
2048 Eastside Way McCall ID 83638
756 Deerforest dr
691 N. Samson Trail, McCall, ID
1085 Samson Trail
PO Box 4011 McCall, Idaho
1085 Samson Trail
4748 N Date Palm Ave Boise,ID
3315 Whitefield Lane, #1569, McCall, ID. 83638
419 Floyde St. McCall, Idaho
12912 195th Ave Ct E, Bonney Lake, WA 98391
12912 195th Ave Ct E
508 N Cass Ave #104 Westmont IL 60559
5733 Abby, Corpus Christi TX 78413
1235 Meadows Rd
11243 W Silver River loop Nampa Idaho 83686
5614 Lakewood Ave Caldwell Idaho 83607
3359 Woodland Rd. New Meadows,Id
780 Chad Loop McCall, Idaho
109 Idaho St, McCall ID 83638
430 Ringel St. McCall, ID, 83638
1610 S Loggers Creek Pond, Apt. 16 Boise ID 83706
88 Woodlands Est Dr NW, Calgary, AB, Canada
88 Woodlands Est Dr NW, Cgy, AB, Canada
304 McBride Unit 102
850 Shelia Ln, McCall, Id
1658 Timber Circle, McCall, ID 83638
1533 Warren Wagon Rd
1455 Bitterroot Dr
13764 Clear View Ct, McCall,ID 83638
129 Stibnite #7, McCall, ID
570 Shelia Lane Mccall Idaho 83638
319 CeCe Way
1746 N. Monterossa Way Eagle Idaho
13974 Turner Lane. McCall ID 83638
5545 S Zonetailed Way, Boise, ID, 83716
1010 Bitterroot Dr.
1809 West Hazel st Boise ID 83702
307 Mather Rd. McCall, ID
13134 Hawks Bay Rd, Donnelly ID 83615
1575 Dragonfly Loop McCall ID 83638
1575 Dragonfly Loop McCall ID 83638
13764 Clearview Ct., McCall 83638
9 Oneida Dr., McCall, ID 83638
10141 W Wildbranch St, Star ID 83669
273 secesh river road mccall id 83638
965 Pine Haven Place
5126 S 391st St Auburn, Wa 98001
266 Morgan Dr, McCall ID 83639
PO Box 377 Hammond Oregon 97121
906 conifer street McCall Idaho 83638
906 conifer street McCall, Idaho 83638
3300 Whitefield Ln, McCall, ID 83638
432 Rio Vista Blvd, PO BOX 1836 McCall Id
2156 E. Hyper Dr. Meridian Idaho 83642
5241 N Backwater Ave, Boise 83714
805 Agate St McCall ID 83638
805 Agate St McCall ID 83638
805 Agate St McCall ID 83638
481 155th Ave SE Bellevue, WA 98007
932 Strawberry Lane McCall Idaho 83638
3550 KP Cove Rd McCall, ID. 83638
200 Jacob st. McCall, ID
PO Box 496 New Meadows, ID
10060 W roan meadows dr boise id 83709
PO BOX 496 NEW MEADOWS
235 Ernesto Drive, McCall
110 N Park Place, San Manuel AZ 85631
35 Heinrich Ln, McCall, ID 83638
13956 Rustic Rd
1031 Potts Drive, McCall, Idaho 83638
1324 Eagle Dr McCall ID 83638
6056 N Booth Ave, Meridian, ID 83646
2429 Sharlie Lane
1712 S. Marsh Wood Pl. Meridian Idaho 83642
1569 , Warren Wagon Rd
P.O. Box 2698, 341 Memo Circle
P.O. Box 2698, 341 Memo Circle
105 Forest Place Donnelly Idaho 83615 POB 515 Donnelly ID 83615
1209 N Ashland, E Wenatchee, Wa 98802
1324 eagle dr. McCall, Id 83638
6077 N Applebrook Way Boise ID
1603 Davis Ave McCall ID 83638
13861 Farm to Market Rd. McCall ID 83638
2193 Coyote Run #107, Council, ID 83612
P O Box 412, McCall, ID 83638
1075 Swanie Way, McCall, ID 83638
1075 Swanie Way, McCall, ID 83638
1217 Moore Way Ontario OR 97914
1500 S. Harmon Rd. Fallon NV 89406
12104 W Tidewater Dr., Boise ID 83713
13944 GallopingRd. McCall, ID 83638
630 Ellis Road
250 Cold Creek Court McCall
20877 Yukon St NE Aurora, OR 97002
3715 T Cir. Washougal WA 98671
814 Carico Ct A2, McCall, ID 83638
13960 Oasis Rd Caldwell Idaho
7698 W. Morning Ct. Boise ID
4058 Smokey Morel Ct
1535 McCall Avenue, McCall, Idaho 83638
P.O. Box 1052, McCall, I’d.
691N Samson Trail McCall ID 83638
328 Belgian Court, The Woodlands, TX 77382
199 Krahn Lane, McCall, ID
1391 Greystone McCall iD 83638
1005 Violet Way, McCall, Idaho 83638
1391 Greystone /Box 2750
PO Box 23 Council Idaho
1423 Eagle Drive McCall, Idaho 83638
1423 Eagle Drive, McCall Idaho 83638
box 606 McCall Idaho
P.O. Box 676 Council Idaho
5198 Highway 95, New Meadows, ID 83654
294 Bleeker Ave Council Idaho 83612
2468 Highway 95, Council, ID 83612
201 Rio Vista Blvd. McCall, ID 83638
201 Rio Vista Blvd. McCall, Id 83638
201 S. Clarendon St Council Idaho 83612
1035 W. 2nd st
Former McCall resident now living in Panama
501 N. Fairfield
905 W. Lake St.
P.O.Box 1221 McCall
904 N. Imperial Way, Boise, ID 83704
905 Pennfield Place, Caldwell, ID 83605
902 N. Imperial Way, Boise, ID 83704
6701 Ashland boise Id 83709
6701 Ashland dr Boise Id 83709
2960 Columbia rd meridian 83642
2901 n 13 at Tacoma wa 98406
2901 n 13 at Tacoma wa 98406
1635 Lakeridge Drive, McCall, Idaho 83638
2150 old hornet rd.
915 Camas Place, McCall ID, 83638
PO Box 733, 2354 Spring Creek Ln, Council, ID 83612
PO Box 1221 McCall, ID 83638
Adams County
131 Rainbow Road, Pollock
PO Box 301 Council Idaho 83612
What is your stance on this matter?
For
Against
For
For
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
For
Against
Against
Against
For
For
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
For
For
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Neutral
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Neutral
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Neutral
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
For
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
Against
For
Against
Enter Public Comment - All Public Comments are public record
Please prohibit feeding of deer, and work with IDFG to reduce the herds drastically. Overpopulation of deer in our part of town is a serious menace and has had a major financial cost
for us. This spring, a deer being chased by a loose dog in the neighborhood darted out of a side street, struck my stopped vehicle at a full run and caused significant damage. In recent
years as deer herds in town have increased, we have spent hundreds of dollars on deer repellent to save our trees, shrubs and gardens. But it's always temporary and seems they will
soon eat almost everything they can reach, including "deer hardy" plants. Two weeks ago in frustration I spent almost $400 on 7 foot deer netting. Prior to that, we watched deer easily
jump over a 5' wire fence around our vegetable garden. Our yard now has some protection but feels and looks a bit like a prison. This has to end. Thank you.
Leave the deer where they are. Increase education about not feeding. Signs about it in areas where it is known they are being fed. Generations of deer are in town. It is an endearing
feature here and should be left alone. The mountain lion has been around for many years.
Deer have been a problem for years. Feeding them isn’t good for deer or McCall. Tourist love to see them like we do but they need to become wild again. Same for all the furry creatures.
Birds are just fine. Thanks and have been a resident off and on since 1957.
Please vote in support of this proposed ordinance. We support McCall Police Dept. and local Fish and Game in the need to curb the cities deer population. We know first had the destruction
of personal property that is being done. Please drive by and take a look. The City of McCall, should look to other resort communities in the state. It is one of the only in the state
NOT to have an Nuicance ordinance for feeding of wildlife in city limits. Thank you
Just read an article in the Lewiston Tribune that the mayor and city council are discussing the moving of the "town" mule deer. The wildlife is one of the reasons why we love visiting
McCall every year in the spring and fall. McCall is a mountain town, not an urban city. Do your part in helping to maintain this mountain town and it's four legged inhabitants.
Educate people on how not to feed the elk and deer; how not to leave garbage cans open for the bears, fox and raccoons; how not to leave dog and cat food on porches. People choose
to move to McCall because of it's beauty and natural setting. It's not the fault of the animals, it's human err. Wildlife have lived there long before humans. If people want to change
the beauty of this mountain town, then they probably should just stay in the city. McCall is not an urban city. Do not stress-out and move these deer. The McCall wilderness is their
home. Not everyone goes to McCall to eat, drink and be merry. Many go for the serenity and to be with nature.
Thank you for your time.
I’ve seen an adult teaching small children to feed deer from the palm of their hands while the buck is rearing to get to the food! Crazy!!
Dear Council Members, The proposals to move or cull our "town deer" makes me very sad. It is a cruel "solution" to a falsely-framed "problem."
Long before McCall existed as a town, the deer were here. So were the predators (cougar and wolves, even no doubt). Then, we built our town. The problem is not the town deer, but the
town itself. There is no evidence that I am aware of that our mule deer migrated to lower elevations in the winter. It's a tricky, almost impossible journey from our valley floor to
Riggins, Council or the lowest reaches of the North Fork of the Payette River. In all likelihood, our town deer wintered over on our very own valley floor.
And what have we done to their wintering grounds: built houses, roads and fences everywhere. This has limited their food supply, made it very difficult for them to move around the valley
floor so they can browse and feed without getting caught up in fences, hit by cars or worse. The impulse to feed deer is not a widespread issue: a few people in town feed some of the
deer a few months in the depths of winter, when forage is limited or non-existent. There would be much more food for the deer during winter if we hadn't built houses and roads everywhere?!
If it is ok to feed songbirds (another population in decline due to human activity), why not deer, we should be asking ourselves?
Instead of culling the town deer, we should try to live together more peacefully with them: instead of driving 35 mph on roads posted 20 mph, follow the speed limits. Whether to avoid
humans, pets or deer, people should SLOW down while driving in town. The city could and should post more signs reminding motorists that there are pets, wildlife and humans on or next
to roadways? Maybe some signs that just say "watch out for humans and wildlife"?! As for the damage to gardens, and we all love our gardens, people might try putting out deer repellant
or deer resistant plants? Cayenne, commercially available repellant sprays, and fences (where permitted) all work very well for keeping deer out of gardens. Become a better, more "mountain
savvy" gardener.
As for the burden on the police department, we have seen plenty of house pets and occasionally bicyclists hit by cars, as well. Do we want to ban them?
And then there is the alleged lice/mite/ skin infestation problem: those do exist in town, but they also exist outside town. Lice infestations are not unique to the town deer: they happen
to all "herding" deer populations. The reason lice, skin and wasting disease spreads in deer populations is precisely because they are herd animals, not because the herd lives in town.
The Department of Fish and Game ought to be thinking broadly about making our deer, elk and other browsing herds more healthy everywhere, not just killing town deer to appease a small
segment of town dwellers unhappy because they can't leave their gardens unattended at their second homes.
Let's try and have some concern for all of god's creatures, not just ourselves?
We are against transporting or killing town deer, deer do what deer do, and they have been here far longer than we have.
I oppose the plan to transport or kill any of the town deer.
I am against rushing this through. I feel enough research hasn't been done. Please refer to the email letter I sent to each council member and to the City Manager. In my letter, I shared
the results of some of my research and what other places have done. I believe we need to slow down and consider better options. Eradicating the deer either by trapping and relocating
them or killing them is costly and has proven unsuccessful and even inhumane to the deer. Our deer should not be punished for what is a human caused problem. The deer and all our wildlife
were here first. We need to look at and implement better options. Again, please refer to my letter and hopefully we can be proactive instead reactive. Thank you.
Dan O'Malley
The city wants to ban the feeding of all wildlife within city limits, with the exception of wild bird feeding. The local deer can sometimes be a problem due to being fed and eating from
people's yards and gardens. However, I first visited McCall back in 1999, and have lived here since 2002, and there have always been large numbers of deer within city limits. Why is
the city just now choosing to try to resolve a problem that has existed for decades? What is their reasoning behind only allowing wild birds to be fed? If they are going to ban feeding
wildlife in city limits, they shouldn't do a half assed job of it, and should ban the feeding of birds as well. I used to feed the birds all the time, but have not done so for several
years. This is because of the huge problems wild bird feeding can cause. It not only attracts birds, but it also attracts squirrels, skunks, raccoons, deer, and bears. Will the city
propose to eradicate all the wildlife in the future because they sometimes pose problems? How is the city going to enforce the feeding ban when the bird feed attracts wildlife other
than birds? Is the city going to enforce/cite people for attracting and feeding bird food to other wildlife, even if it was not intentional? Do any of the F&G people, police, mayor,
or city council members feed the birds, and are not including feeding them in the ban for their own purposes? I am not trying to be funny with the photos. They show the aftermath of
what can happen when a bear rips down a handmade bird feeder, then climbs a 6 foot fence and tears down two more feeders hung 12 feet up a tree, which attracted even more wildlife.
I was once known as the "Mad McCall Bomber". I designed, built, and experimented with homemade explosives, until I was arrested on 09/02/2011. When I was released on 12/08/2011, I swore
to myself that I would never go back down that long dark roadway, towards self destruction. Instead, I took up the camera that I used to express myself many years prior. My subjects
were the urban wild animals that lived around me, and that I loved photographing.
Unfortunately, back in 2015, I was lied to by Dallas Palmer of the McCall Police Department. He specifically told me that feeding wild animals within city limits was illegal. He emphasized
that if I continued to do so, that I would be cited and my probation violated so that I would end up back in jail. He suggested at that time that if I had questions, I should contact
Idaho Fish & Game for verification. I did exactly that the next day, and was told that there were no (zero) regulations/ordinances prohibiting the feeding of urban wildlife in the McCall
area. I stopped feeding any wildlife at that point, even though I read the entire McCall Civil Code, and also found no mention of the illegality of feeding wildlife within city limits.
I was quite pissed off due to being lied to directly by a member of our local police department, and when my Probation Officer, Mike Truxel, told me he would not enforce a probation
violation (I had him verify my findings with Idaho F&G and McCall City Code), I knew then and there that Dallas was lying about what he told me. Less than two weeks later, former McCall
Police Detective Brian Koch stopped by my house to tell me that he would issue me a citation if I ever fed the wildlife again. He specifically told me that it was in "the books" written
that it was illegal to feed wildlife, and if I couldn't find where that fact was documented, that "that's your own fault".
Just a factual account since April of 2017: I have had several foxes show up at my house in McCall showing signs of mange. I did a lot of research on how to possibly treat these foxes
for their mange conditions. I decided to treat these foxes myself for their mange. I ordered medication online, and carefully followed the directions I found online. (http://www.foxwoodwildliferescu
e.org/2017/01/05/treating-sarcoptic-mange-in-red-foxes/), and through the fox welfare site in England (National Fox Welfare Society). Since 2017, I have been able to successfully treat
9 of 11 foxes that presented themselves to me with varying degrees of mange infestation. If you ban/prohibit the feeding of wildlife within the city of McCall, you will essentially
condemn any fox afflicted with mange to a long, unnecessary, and extremely painful death due to mange. Don't tell me that there are other options available, because our local "animal
welfare" rehabilitation center (Snowdon) is a joke at best. I have contacted them 6 times to come and assist/help afflicted/injured animals, and they have never once helped at all.
It also seems that the only help Id F&G want to provide is a quick bullet to the brain for any wild animal they are called out for.
Great idea - I highly approve
I support an ordinance to prohibit feeding of deer (and other wild animals) in the town of McCall. I have lived in McCall for over 40 years and understand that we have lost a lot of
deer habitat due to the increase in buildings and development. Riggins had a deer problem and culled their deer herd and were able to feed several low income families. Transplanting
deer seems a bad choice, as 50% mortality occurs with excessive cost. Thank you for your time and consideration.
I entered a comment earlier, but Jim and I both felt we needed to strongly clarify we are against the killing and/or trapping and relocating of our town deer. Please refer to my email
sent yesterday to all Council Members and to the City Manager. In it are better and more humane options suggested by wildlife experts in other areas/states. We expect the Council to
slow down, gather more complete and balanced information, and to look at this matter very carefully before making a decision that could cause unnecessary harm. The deer should not
be punished for a human caused problem. Thank you, Debra and Jim Staup
Strongly oppose
I am against the removal of the deer from our community, but would like to see people being educated about not feed the wild animals.
I urge you to adopt this ordinance prohibiting the feeding of wildlife as described in the draft. Wild animals should be respected, observed from a distance, and left alone. Thank you.
Please add the following Whereas or similiar; Intentional feeding of wildlife causes unnatural aggregations during environmentally stressful times and can led to outbreaks of diseases.
I live near Davis and Lick Creek Rd. We are over run with deer in the late summer and fall. We can no longer have any outdoor flowers or plants on our back patio, because deer will mow
them down. all foundation plantings around the house have been destroyed. I have easily up to ten deer in my backyard, on my porch and even laying on the concrete floor of the garage.
This is all because of winter feeding activities of several individuals on Davis Ave.
This ord. is a necessary start but it will be meaningless unless enforced. Also the City must be active in assisting the removal of these deer during early winter when they really gather.
This will require resources to clear snow for trapping, providing City properties for trapping and perhaps manpower. This also will likely take several years to be come effective.
These town deer will not migrate normally, its been too many generations of staying in town during the winter instead of migrating. If feeding is successfully curtailed the deer's condition
will be much reduced, even more damage to citizens landscape plantings will likely occur and there could well be much more deer mortality.
thank you
This should have been implemented years ago.
I know this is a complicated and emotional issues. I would like to remind everyone that people are the ones who moved into the wild lives habitat. We dug and removed their food sources.
We eliminated their natural migration routes and now we deem them the problem. I don’t agree with this.
Trapping and relocating deer is an exercise is futility and a waste of money. Where do you draw the line for trapping? City limits? Area of impact limits? County limits? What’s to
stop the deer on the edge of that limit line to not come over. We learned from the failed wolf introduction decades ago that the wolf doesn’t know to stay where he was put.
In regards to a comment in the paper about a majority of the people are feeding deer inappropriate food. I would like a copy of that report. No one polled me to see if I feed the deer.
No one asked me what I fed them if I did feed the deer.
History proves the deer and elk winter in Donnelly, McCall and New Meadows. The Finnish settlers settled in Donnelly in the winter because the deer and elk where there. New Pearce tribe
used the Zims hot springs area because of the hot springs, fish, deer and elk.
If Fish and Game is going to address feeding they need to address the big picture. Elk in Donnelly are manipulated and moved by the ranchers that provides the sleigh rides. They have
moved that wintering herd from the trees to the fields adjacent 55 by feeding them. Someone will die when hitting an elk on 55 due to their direct efforts to market their business.
No one will die hitting a deer at 25mph in front of Albertsons.
I would argue Lardos is feeding the bears with the uncontrolled vent hoods spewing grease onto carpets and causing the direct dependency of the bears to live in the Rio Vista sub. Aggressive
bears are dangerous.
What will constitute feeding? I feed the birds. Seed falls on the ground and the deer eats the seeds. Do I get a fine? I plant flowers and grow tomatoes. Deer eat those, do I get
a fine. I would rather our law enforcement officers enforce the no alcohol ban on the beach during the fourth then write tickets for feeding the bears.
A major draw and big part of our quality of life is nature. Our past mayors, city councils and planning and zoning commissioners failed our community by not requiring developers to
provide environmental clearance and preservation of migratory routes for wildlife. As a consultant in Boise I did this on every community development I worked on. It’s even required
in downtown Bellevue, WA but not McCall. The Cities past short comings managing development should not be passed to the current citizens and the wildlife that are directly affected
by those decisions.
Thank You
Mark Dooley
208-573-4627
"On May 27, 2021, Council directed staff to continue with preparation of a proposed ordinance prohibiting the feeding of wildlife within the City of McCall." This is quite concerning..
Does the Council want to ban everyone from feeding 'all' wildlife such as birds, humming birds, etc. The language is ambiguous and will cause a firestorm of problems. Clarification
is needed. Again, the Council needs to slow down and rethink what is the real objective here. Reactive thinking will not provide a solution to the problem.
Dear City Council,
First let me clarify my "against" response.
Since this "matter" came up only in the last week, and since it is not ultimately clear as to what this "Wildlife Ordinance" fully entails, here is my clarification statement:
1. I have no problem with there being an ordinance put in place by the City to make it illegal to feed deer and other wildlife within the City limits of McCall. I think that is a good
and necessary first step. Therefore, I am in agreement or "for" that matter ONLY.
2. What I am FULLY AGAINST however, are the other issue(s) being talked about in the same breath by Regan Berkley, Regional Wildlife Manager with Fish and Game and by local Police Chief
Justin Williams to catch/transport/ or euthanize the town deer. Particularly concerning is Ms. Berkley's quote in last weeks Star News: "There is no effective way to rid the deer of
the lice, so infected deer would be humanely killed by Fish and Game to avoid spreading the infestation, she said".
3. It is very unclear as to which issue we are supposedly making our stance on. JUST the proposed ordinance to make it illegal to feed the deer? OR, several other ordinances regarding
trapping, transporting, euthanizing all of the town deer? In speaking with a multitude of friends and acquaintances this week who live here full time, NOT ONE OF THEM KNEW OF THIS
PROPOSED ORDINANCE OR THE TALK OF TRAPPING, TRANSPORTING, EUTHANIZING THE TOWN DEER. That is Extremely concerning to me.
***Regarding deer lice: Multiple studies show that lice in deer are not uncommon. These same studies also show that the lice are NOT harmful to humans nor domestic pets, and that
the lice rarely kill the deer themselves.
"The exotic lice species described above does not affect humans or domestic animals. Deer in captive settings have been successfully cleared of lice infestations with the use of medication.....Medica
tions exist to treat most conditions causing hair loss in deer... Many cases resolve on their own when the deer are in better condition in spring/summer due to increased food resources
or with seasonal environmental changes."" ~Washington Department of Fish and Game~
***Regarding the issues of "traffic hazards": IF the speed limit in the City of McCall was routinely enforced (20mph and 25mph), and the distracted driving issue was enforced, I think
we would find that there would be few car/deer collisions. I spoke by phone this week with the WA State Fish and Game Wildlife Officer, and he stated that "even at 25mph, most deer
survive the collision and do not need to be euthanized".
***Regarding the attraction of predators: I have been coming to McCall since the early 1960's (summers, winters, weekends, holidays) and have enjoyed McCall with my family at our two
cabins (the first in Wagon Wheel Bay off of Warren Wagon Road from 1967 through 1994, and the second in Shady Cove/Pilgrim Cove off of Lick Creek Road from 1994 to 2012. I have been
a full time resident of McCall since 2012 and live on the McCall Golf Course.
I have never once seen a mountain lion or wolf. I have only seen a coyote in town ONCE (on the golf course) in the past 55+ years. I realize there are "sightings" on occasion. Primarily
from juvenile mountain lions without a mother, or perhaps a sick/injured lion. The City of Boise has many more sightings than McCall.
These are fleeting, and in 55+ years I don't believe there are "increased" sightings, but rather an increase in reporting of sightings. Again, these are very rare. I am unaware of
ANY documented killings of deer within our City Limits in 55+ years.
***Regarding the "nuisance" issue: We live in a beautiful Mountain Resort town where deer have been prevalent for decades and longer. We have taken over their habitat. We have paved
over their migration routes and built subdivisions, buildings, parking lots, businesses ON their habitat. Since space is an issue, I will continue with this statement in a 2nd submittal)
Please see first submittal to this page as of 2:44pm June 10th, 2021.
This is the continuation of that statement:
******Regarding the "nuisance" issue: We live in a beautiful Mountain Resort town where deer have been prevalent for decades and longer. We have taken over their habitat. We have
paved over their migration routes and built subdivisions, buildings, parking lots, businesses ON their habitat. I have serious doubts that these town deer have migrated to lower elevations,
but would certainly welcome that information. Were the town deer tagged and monitored in the past? Did our town deer simply move to areas outside of our core such as Spring Mountain
Ranch? The Woodlands? Lick Creek Meadows during the Winter months and remain unseen. But now that those locations are all paved over with houses, the deer have no other choice but
to be "seen" in town?
It is a blessing and privilege to live amongst the deer and other wildlife here in McCall. It is a primary reason I moved here from Boise.
I spent this week talking to Fish and Game Wildlife Officers and Biologists from the States of Washington, Oregon, Utah and Idaho. Our neighboring states have excellent websites and
resources to educate the public on "LIVING WITH WILDLIFE". Not the "transport and euthanizing of wildlife".
It was refreshing to hear of and read their education pieces.
I am curious what percentage of those complaining to the City of McCall/F & G/The Police Department are complaining about the deer "eating their gardens, flowers, trees, shrubs"?
Why are we accommodating their statements when there are ways to mitigate the deer coming on their property and/or eating their gardens?
There are plenty of educational pieces out there. No need to recreate the wheel.
****Finally, I believe that the City has much bigger fish to fry right now:
1. Housing
2. Infrastructure
3. Safe biking paths and sidewalks
4. Making roadways safer
5. Speeding locals and Tourists and Distracted Drivers
6. The huge illegal drug problem Within Our City.
Many of the above will harm or kill far more humans than any town deer will.
I hope you will not make a knee-jerk reaction to a "non-issue" that we can never recover from . Just one cursory look at the history of the wolf in Idaho should tell you that (eradicate
to extinction; re-introduce; and now eradicate to 90%+ extinction). This is a very dangerous situation of trying to "Play God". I hope our City officials take a BIG step back before
it's far to late.
Thank you
Julie Conrad
Please prohibit the feeding of wildlife. It is essential for the safety and health of both people and animals.
We love the "city" deer. They are part of the charm of McCall. Euthanizing or relocating the deer is detrimental to our community and we need to live with our wildlife and not eliminate
them.
As a member of this community for 70+ years. I am appalled that you are considering working with F&G to round up our deer with intent to move and KILL them!!! This is our community and
does not belong to the TOURISTS. If they are bothered by them then maybe they shouldn't come here! Warning signs to slow down might be the answer. Our Fox populations has dwindled to
nothing because of allowance by our state to kill for profit- Furs to other countries still buying pelts. Please consider who pays your salary and ELECTS you!!
I am in favor of the city taking action to regulate the "town deer herd". I see residents feeding them grain, apples, and hay. I see McCall guests stopping to throw fast food remains
out the window for deer to eat, then taking a picture. I have had many many landscape plants and trees destroyed by the herd. I've seen visitors being chased when getting too close
to the deer. In the spring, many deer look diseased and physically distressed as they pass through our yard.
I support a city ordinance banning feeding of wildlife (except songbirds) in McCall city limits and impact zone.
The deer problem is overwhelming at our house in the winter and spring. Up to 15 deer dwell on our property nearly every single day. The amount of feces is astounding, and the impact
to the native shrubs and trees (mountain ash, lilac, currant, aspen, etc.) is significant.
The deer continue to visit throughout the summer and fall, using five game trails to transit the property while browsing. I do not garden at home due to their presence, and instead
grow vegetables in a plot at the Community Garden, which has a deer fence.
I give the deer the widest berth possible when outside, but they have no fear of humans, and I don't trust them around kids. I am frustrated when I see people in my neighborhood leaving
out food for them - I have seen quartered heads of iceberg lettuce, Cheerios cereal, and bales of hay. This is unconscionable human behavior.
I fully support culling the mule deer population if a diagnosis of exotic lice makes transplanting them to the wild impossible. These deer are sickly (yet somehow hyper-fertile - so
many twins and triplets), and it is inhumane to allow them to continue propagating in downtown McCall, which is not their native territory.
They either belong in the wild, or they should be humanely dispatched.
Thank you.
Emily Hart 702 1st Street McCall, ID
I do not agree with the current proposal to trap, remove or euthanize the town deer of McCall. They are a part of the culture and fabric of our mountain town. Educate, not Eradicate".
Will the public be given a chance to review the draft ordinance prior to City Council taking action. Please call at 208-573-4627 or email draft to markdooley67@outlook.com
thanks
"I do not agree with and am fully against the current proposal to trap, remove or euthanize the town deer of McCall. They are a part of the culture and fabric of our mountain town.
Educate, not Eradicate".
Post signs about deer in the city, don’t feed deer signs. There are other things that can be done! This is their home.
I have lived on Lake St for 7 years. The deer are abundant. 3 deer have been killed in front of our residence in the last 5 months. They have eaten a lot of landscape materials down
to the ground. A startled deer on more than one occasion has run through our property. If they had encountered a dog or a person this could have unfortunate consequences.
We hear screeching brakes and see many near miss collisions. Lake St is very busy. I am concerned that sooner or later a serious accident will occur- a collision or a car veering to
miss a deer and hitting a pedestrian or bicyclist. The abundant deer on Lake St are a serious hazard.
I would rather see them removed then slaughtered on Lake St. I am very concerned for a serious accident on Lake St due to their presence causing a person’s injury or death. The danger
and hazard on Lake St is much different than spotting them on the golf course. Allowing the town deer to stay and the population to grow will have severe consequences.
The charm of McCall is seeing and admiring nature and most importantly the wildlife! I am completely against forcing out, killing or relocating the deer 🦌 in McCall! They have more
of a right to be there than we do.
The mountains/forest is where deer should be allowed to roam. It is their natural habitat. The building of new buildings including homes and businesses is taking their habitat away.
Deer should never be considered a nuisance, especially in McCall, Idaho. McCall is a mountain town.
You are taking their habitat away without any consideration there are generations of deer in the area.
Transferring them to another area is unfair to the deer and euthanizing them should not even be a consideration. Deer are basically a harmless creature.
If residents do not want deer wandering through their yards then build higher fences, or move back to a city where deer seldom roam around.
I for one would never take these creatures for granted. They are the innocent bystanders of people who are only complaining to be complaining.
Please vote against this action. The deer do not deserve to be taken out of the only environment they know.
Thank you,
Valerie Murray
23121 Freezeout Rd
Caldwell, idaho 83607
No I do not agree with the side proposal of transport, relocating and euthanizing deer by the Fish and Game.I would like the city to take pause and here from citizens, biologists etc.
as well as consider other resort towns actions in this matter.
I do agree with a city ordinance making it illegal to feed them in city limits.
My husband and I have been full time residents in McCall since 2016. The reason that we love to live here is our proximity to nature and wildlife. These deer are part of what makes McCall
so special and it would be a travesty to lose them.
I am not a resident of McCall, however, my family are regular visitors. One of the things we love about your town is the opportunity to see the wildlife that has made their home there
for so many years. I understand and agree that at times, all animals can be a “nuisance”, but so can a lot of people. Just like in many other areas across our beautiful state, with
the exceptional growth we have experienced, we are slowly taking over all of the land that belonged to our wildlife. I am against your plan to relocate, trap, euthanize these animals
just because they may be a bother to some people. This was their home first and it is our responsibility to learn to live with them and coexist.
With that being said, I am not a resident of your beautiful town and I don’t live with the challenges on a daily basis. But, I would ask that you consider my comments as well as the
many others you are likely receiving.
Thank you for your time.
We have been visiting McCall frequently since 2001. Prior to that it had only been once or twice. The first 15 years we would stay at Worldmark. We absolutely loved when the wildlife
would grace us with a glimpse. The deer were always big hit! The last few years, when we visit, we stay with friends or family, or at their homes when they are away. Even the thought
of "removing ALL deer" from the city is disgusting! These animals have lived there for much longer than we humans! How in the world, as a human, can you even grasp the concept of wiping
out hundred of living creatures? Sure, there will be a problem animal or two, from time to time...but for Heavens sake, these are LIVING ANIMALS! Who are you/we, to decide they shouldn't
be here anymore? All of this because of what? And, is this the publicity you want for your beautiful mountain town...."they killed all of the deer in the town limits because some people
thought they were a nuisance?"
I do not agree with trapping, moving or euthanizing the town herd of deer. People moved into their home not the reverse. I agree that people should be educated about the reasons NOT
to feed any of the wildlife in our town but I don’t think that a City Ordinance is the answer. As with so many other rules in McCall there is no one enforcing them so they are meaningless.
Please leave the town deer where they are and do a “Don’t Feed the Wildlife” campaign to educate our locals and visitors about how to properly interact with our wild neighbors.
The idea that some people believe the deer are a nuisance in McCall is disheartening. When you move to a mountain town/area, you learn to coincide with the animals who have been there
before man.
The deer are intriguing to watch when we come across them in town on our visits.
They come because they feel safe, don’t take that away from them.
I find it difficult to believe the City Council would vote to remove one of McCall’s favorite visitor attractions, to say nothing about the smiles seeing our deer elicit from those of
us who make McCall our home. Perhaps attention needs to be directed to visitors who see a crosswalk and stroll across without making sure there are no cars. Why not fine those who
are seen feeding the deer (and other wildlife), post visible signs addressing fact that feeding wildlife interferes with the natural migration plan and monitor the results before you
cause undue friction.
The deer and wildlife is one of the main reasons why I myself, my family and other people go to McCall.
We always stop and take pictures of the deer in town. We always camp at Ponderosa and love watching them come through the campsites. We watch for them every morning and every evening.
The mommas with their babies are the best.
That was their home way before it was anyone was around. Why in the world would we take them from their home and why in the world would anyone ever want to euthanize them???? Seriously???
IF people can't handle the wildlife in the mountains then they don't need to live there or even go up there.
Please leave the wildlife alone.. They call the place home.
I am heartbroken that this proposed ordinance has gotten this far. Apparently, “the powers that be” have already made a decision, but I think it is a bad one and am completely against
it.
A major reason many of us love living in McCall is our close relationship to nature. Our beautiful lake, Ponderosa Park, the surrounding mountains, and, yes, wildlife, especially the
town deer and foxes. Yes, they occasionally complicate things, but if they could speak I am sure they would say we have done the same for them.
We live on a very busy street with a blind curve that is posted 20 mph, but the average speed driven is much higher. Many drive more than 30 mph. No thought is given the safety of any
person or animal on or adjacent to the street. Last night our peaceful evening was interrupted by a young man driving an SUV who was “forced” to come to a stop because a young fawn
and mother deer were crossing the roadway. The young driver yelled out his window, “F*%k you!” I thought there was an altercation going on, but were no other people or cars out there.
He was yelling an expletive at the deer. I do not understand that mentality, but we see the aggressive driving, the honking and intentional driving “at speed” to scare the deer and
to me it says volumes about our sense of entitlement and our species’ lack of empathy for other life.
So, instead of getting mad at the deer, foxes and other wildlife in town, let’s try to figure out how to live with them: spend money on better traffic signs, give tickets to our perennial
speeders, better educate visitors and residents about how to coexist with wildlife, and generally be grateful for the fact we do have wildlife all around us? That is part of the “magic
of McCall,” after all? We cared enough about wildlife and the “wonder of nature” to enact anti-light pollution ordinance; why can’t we learn to live with nature instead of killing or
“removing” it from town? We might as well all move back to the suburbs at that point?
Since some apparently want to “fast track” this ordinance, the final thing that breaks my heart is that this city council is not giving this issue the public hearing it deserves. This
ordinance is not about helping the deer, but about appeasing a small group of people who seem to have a point of view that I do not think makes sense financially, scientifically, or
morally. Nor is it workable at a practical level - after the deer are "removed", do you think other deer are not going to move back in to town to replace the removed deer? Passing this
ordinance without a thorough public hearing with “live” testimony would leave wounds in the community. To me that would be the most heartbreaking thing of all.
I am against this proposal. This is the saddest thing I’ve heard. Deer are a gem to this community and what makes McCall precious to so many.
I am completely against this ordinance. We love the deer in our area and it would be a major mistake if the city moved to relocate them. They add to the beauty of McCall. Do not pass
this.
I agree with the recent editorial in the Star News: this issue deserves a public hearing with live testimony from both sides. Otherwise, this issue will become a permanent controversy,
one that divides us rather than unites us. Personally, I enjoy seeing wildlife in town and think the degree of the "problem" is overstated. Like the resident geese in public parks nationwide,
my guess is that our town deer are a permanent feature of life in the mountains. Let's be happy we live here and have them.
I think this is ridiculous… what other resort town in the US does this?? If you don’t want wildlife on your property then don’t buy in the middle of a Forrest go purchase your property
in the concrete jungle of the city…
Jeff Martel, 1020 Cedar Lane, McCall.
I am for selective removal of sick or problematic wildlife, but I am against the full removal/euthanize of the “in-town” wildlife without further study. I think taking time and not rushing
to a decision is always prudent.
I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing of the town deer in McCall. The will not survive a Winter out there! I do not feel the deer are a “nuisance”, only those that are
in a hurry and traveling too fast (not 25 mph) and in their way. Also, those dog that are too close to a mama deer and her babies she is only protecting her babies, that is human and
animal instinct.
I find it absurd to move wildlife from their habitat simply because we have built homes there. We are respectful of the animals near and around our home. They are not a nuisance, but
rather a gift of Nature. Leave the animals in Peace.
We visit the mountains to see wildlife
We live in the mountains to see/enjoy wildlife
We live in the mountains to see/enjoy wildlife
Deer are increasingly problematic in McCall, both on the roads and in our yards. As a physician, I am also very concerned that deer are a vector for ticks and will increase how rapidly
we are exposed to Lyme disease and other dangerous infections. Thank you.
I love to see the animals when I travel around
Manage people not animals
There are too many deer in the city doing too much damage.
Deer make me happy
My partner built his home in 1989 and since then we have enjoyed the deer and other wildlife in McCall. We have embraced their presence as part of having a home in a rural town. I
am very much against removing them and am aghast that this matter has even been brought to the council for any type of consideration.
-Wendy Albright
I am against the relocation or euthanasia of any wildlife in McCall. I visit McCall frequently and love seeing all the wildlife that is present. I am a avid hunter and believe relocation
would be to stressful on the animal causing death as well as euthanasia is cruel to do on any animal that is in good health. People moves into the home area of these deer and therefore
the deer shouldn't be punished for something that those people decided. The people that live mccall knew what they were moving into before they purchased their home and or businesses.
The deer presence is what brings some of the business to mccall as well. So not only is it going to cost money to get rid of the deer in general but you also be loosing money from the
tourist who come up just to see the deer.
As a native Idahoan and Donnelly property owner, I vehemently oppose this horrendous idea regarding our native wildlife! The mountains of Idaho belong to all Gods creatures and they
certainty are NOT a nuisance.
I am adamantly opposed to the trapping, relocating or euthanization of the deer population, and any other native wildlife in the McCall area.
We, James and Debra Staup, are against any measure that would result in the ultimate removal, relocation, and eradication of our town deer. There are better and more humane ways to live
with and manage our deer and other wildlife. The City Council may think what F&G does with our deer has no reflection on them, but it greatly does. The Council can definitely influence
a better outcome. A no feeding ordinance is fine as long as it is backed by common sense .. meaning a humane wildlife management plan in place that supports and preserves our town deer
here in their habitat. I sent an email to each of you two weeks ago with some realistic solutions other states and communities do. These solutions were from F&G Wildlife Experts. McCall
Needs to be Proactive not Reactive. Let's stop this wrongful path and work to create a safe, reasonable, and humane path of preservation for our wildlife. .. James and Debra Staup
I am very much against this proposal. My in-laws have owned property off of Samson Trail for over 45 years and the deer have been a great source of enjoyment during that time. My kids
grew up watching the deer and other wildlife roam freely around the property. Please reconsider this proposal as I believe it is a bad one. Thank you.
Humans are the nuisance to wildlife, not the other way around. McCall is surrounded by forests and lakes. What kind of person wouldn’t expect there to be deer or any other wildlife.
I agree the public needs educating on reasons why they should not be feeding the wildlife but relocation and euthanasia are a despicable solution.
Humans are the nuisance to wildlife, not the other way around. McCall is surrounded by forests and lakes. What kind of person wouldn’t expect there to be deer. Educate the public on
why they should not feed wildlife. Relocation and euthanasia are both a despicable option.
I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall. They are part of the reason why my family loves McCall so much.
My husband and my self have lived on this street for 40 years, in that time we have watched the deer migrate on the same route year after year. Once the deer quit leaving in the winter
we watched them use the same paths to move around town. I don’t claim to know why this started but I do for a fact know that their staying had nothing to do with people feeding them.
So now fast forward years later and we have an abundance of deer in town. Yes deer are getting hit by cars but is that really the deer’s fault? No it is not! If the people driving our
city’s roads would drive the speed limit of 25 mph as posted throughout town and pay attention instead of texting or what ever they are doing, they could easily come to a stop and not
hit the deer.
I have taken the time to do some research on stopping distances at various speeds. 25mph: up to 85 ft to stop, 30mph: 109 ft, 35 mph: 136 ft and 60 mph: 305 feet. So my point is that
if the speed limits were enforced in this town the odds of deer getting hit go exponentially down. So that solves problem #1. Mangy looking deer, this is what happens to deer in the
winter no matter where they are, it happens to some dogs too! It isn’t because they are sick or infected with some deer disease or from people feeding them, it is their natural hair
process. I am not saying there aren’t a few sick ones out there but for the most part our town deer are pretty healthy. It isn’t the fault of the people that are feeding the deer that
they are getting hit as relayed to my husband by an uninformed police officer. I can show you pictures from 20-25 years ago that show the deer using the same migratory path and they
still are in spite of all the building across the street.
I am against eradication of all the deer in this town and in favor of educating people and enforcing the speed limits!!!!
I will go so far as to offer any officer to sit I’m my driveway anytime and stop the constant stream of speeding cars on Davis Ave. I would venture a guess that you could pay for an
officer hired for this purpose within a very short period of time.
Let’s try to work together and it will be a win win for all involved, especially the deer 🦌!
Sincerely
Patty Hickman
Mccall
I agree to prohibit feeding the wildlife in question, but do NOT agree to removing the animals from the town.
McCall is NOT McCall without the deer! This has NEVER been an issue until our beautiful state has been inundated with transplants! The deer and the other abundant wildlife, are part
of what makes McCall such a desirable place to live and visit! If you CHOOSE to live in nature, or recreate, then wildlife will be a part of that environment! This is an OUTRAGEOUS
proposal!!! I support respecting wildlife and not feeding them, however, eradicating them from their home is a huge mistake! These are God's creatures, not a "nuisance" as a FEW are
stating. The sweet deer are NOT the problem, too many people are!! I am very angry that this is even being considered! I have proudly lived in this gorgeous state for over 45 years
and McCall is a place I cherish.....don't destroy the magic by removing one of the very things that makes it this way!
I am 100 percent against this proposal. The local wildlife is a benefit to our community and not a nuisance. We are a nuisance to them
It is fine to ban feeding of the deer. But, PLEASE don't kill or relocate them. The wildlife help make McCall the beautiful town that it is.
Euthanizing and relocating animals that have been native to the area before humans were in unethical and wrong. Idaho is beautiful state, doing this is destroying our home. Teach humans
not to feed wildlife, not that it’s okay to kill wildlife when they get in our way.
The deer should be left alone. We have taken over their habitat in a very large number of locations. Why should they be the ones to suffer for our greed? Also, McCall prides itself on
being a paradise for outdoorsmen and being able to see nature up close is becoming more and more rare.
I am 100 % against the trapping and killing of our town herd. Snowden as well as many wild life services know trapping and relocation in almost a death sentence in itself. the backlash
in public opinion,general response to this drastic action I think is very underestimated and will bring much sorrow , and great amounts of anger,hostility and cause more trouble
than the deer.
Please do not remove or euthanize our town deer. It’s a horrific idea. We are living in their habitat. They were here first this is their territory. Humans have decided to live here
among the wild animals. So if you don’t like them, then you go live somewhere else.
I agree with making the feeding of wildlife illegal, and the removal of town deer if needed. I trust my local fish and game officials and the judgement and decisions they will make.
I support banning the feeding of game animals, such as deer and elk (those wildlife species managed as game animals by the Idaho Department of Fish and Game), within the curtrent and
future city limits of the City of McCall. Said feeding ban not to include songbirds and hummingbirds, or non-game wildlife species, such as squirrels.
I am strongly opposed to this.
I am against the trapping, relocating, and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall. This is proposing to just kill all wildlife. First Idaho started with the wolves, now these town deer.
Next? McCall better should invest in eco-tourism, instead of killing or locate them in another part of the state (which basically means, killing them too). This is an idiot proposal.
Like: complaining about trees because in the fall they lose their leaves and that is sooo inconvenient (and this is also a true story).
Don't you DARE KILL or remove our wildlife!!!!! We love them like we love our pets and our family. They are part of our neighborhoods. How would YOU like it someone threw you out of
YOUR home because some asshole (who probably just moved here from another state) wanted you gone???
Wild life is one of the big attractions for enjoying McCall please don't take this away from us.
I absolutely oppose the proposal to remove and eliminate the deer or squirrels. We have reunited their natural habit and are increasingly destroying more habit through our greed and
narcissistic habits and behaviors. Add climate changes and more and more wildlife will attempt to live in our areas where there is accessible water and food. Most of us that have been
visiting or living in the area came here to be able to see, smell, feel and taste the most amazing environment. We are the nuisance, not the wildlife. Educate people on consequences
of feeding the deer, create deer friendly zones on endowment lands rather than planting mansions for the rich, and find ways to open paths for the wildlife to traverse the area safely.
Y’all can do better, be better.
The beauty of McCall is the coexistence of the wildlife.
We are wholeheartedly against transporting or euthanizing our town deer. The deer are not a “nuisance” the deer have been here far longer than we have. Please educate don’t eradicate,
McCall native lived here 58 years, deer have been in town for generations it is what makes McCall a beautiful quaint town full of wildlife . Eddie and Danielle Gray
I am against the trapping and relocation of wild animals in the City of McCall, ID. The idea is absolutely asinine and ridiculous. Humans have invaded our native wildlife's habitat and
need to adapt to their behavior, not the other way around.
To trap and remove the "town herd" is cruel and inhumane. These deer know only this environment and climate. Most will not survive being moved to a totally different environment, plus
have to compete against the deer already there.
Against this happening!
As a regular visitor to McCall since 2000, I am against the killing of any wildlife as that is a big reason why I continue to visit the area. If this were to pass I would be taking my
travel money and spending it elsewhere for sure.
If this passes, things will never be the same. Part of the appeal of McCall is the possibility of seeing wildlife. Removing all the deer and possibly uthanizing them is just wrong and
heartless. And we as humans are better than that. This can't be allowed!
I disagree with the trapping and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall. I disagree with them being a nuisance and love seeing them daily.
I am against trapping removing euthanasia of town wildlife
We love that mccall has local deer. It’s apart of McCall’s charm. We are against this completely. And we live here full time.
I have lived in Idaho for 25 years and have purchased my hunting and fishing license and tags every year. To hear the council wanting to get rid of all deer in Town makes no sense. If
you lived in New York City maybe but we’re here in Idaho which it seems like with everyone moving here from big cities to escape the concrete jungles it’s a shame that we can’t make
room for animals. We keep building more homes eliminating habitat and natural feeding grounds. Funny how watching these out of touch councils and school boards can’t find something
better to do then try to turn our great state into the next Portland!
I do NOT support relocating of wildlife or the euthanization of McCalls deer. They deer were here before us and this is their home as much as ours. We’ve been living with them for as
long as the town has been here and they are a part of it.
I do not agree with killing off the deer because they are a nuisance. I love driving in town seeing the deer. Living in the mountains includes wildlife. If you feel something needs
to be done please relocate them. I do agree people feeding them is not helping the situation. Please to not make a quick decision just to get rid of them.
This is unfathomable! As a visitor to your beautiful town, I took many pictures of the local deer and think of this as a friendly town to animals. They are wonderful creatures that add
to the serenity of your town. To murder them???? What are you thinking??? Shameful.
Vote: No
I am against the removal of the deer population in McCall. This is inhumane and will take away from the natural beauty that brings so much character to the area. Would we continue to
do this in the future as other wildlife population move into the area?
No!
I’m against removing our beautiful town deer. They are truly magnificent to see and watch. They were here first. Leave the deer alone
Although it makes sense to encourage people not to feed wildlife, this should be an educational process not a legal one. Second, I am against moving or euthanizing the town herd of
deer.
We LOVE the wildlife in McCall. It’s one of the things that make it a special place.
Our family LOVES the deer and other wildlife in McCall!!!
My family loves coming to MC Call each year to visit. We always enjoy watching the deer roam around the town. What a sad day when an animal is called a nuisance for just being in it’s
own environment. Who really is the nuisance here?
My Grandparents owned a cabin in McCall many years ago. We would vacation there in the summer. We loved the natural beauty and enjoyed watching the deer. Please do not kill the deer
. They have every right to be there. Thank you for your time .
I live on the edge of Yankton, South Dakota. We have deer that I feed regularly so I can enjoy the wildlife up close. Fun to see how they evolve through the seasons... Viewing fawns
with mom or watching the young bucks grow antlers and eventually grow to majestic bucks. I believe it has been good for my mental health to be closer to all wildlife!!
It was their home long before all these people calling them a nuisance were there I think that’s just wrong and cruel let them live there to have their babies and go back where they
go
With all due respect, I am pleading with you to NOT take our town deer. These town deer are what made me want to live, work and raise my children here in McCall. These beauties are
fascinating and intriguing to watch. I love watching these deer in my yard as well as through my work windows. My children tell family and friends about the deer they live with. This
would be so heartbreaking for many McCall residence as well as our town visitors.
If you want to live in the forest you need to realize you live in "there" home
I understand the nuisances humans cause by feeding wildlife. I also understand the reality of population growth. Removing the wildlife from McCall or Valley county for that matter would
take away from the natural environment of the area!!
Spend your fish and game allocated funds more resourcefully. Educate your visitors post signs, fine those should they be caught feeding animals or leaving food accessible while camping
in a state-city-county park, visited by wildlife, but don't punish the animals and others who know how to behave as decent humans for the few new comers who don't.
I oppose the matter at hand and ask you do not enforce this matter.
#thintheherd!
It doesn't take a wildlife biologist to tell you mule deer migrate! They should not be in mccall during the months of dec thru may. Stop selfishly feeding the deer which prevents them
from migrating (for your own instant gratification) and Let idfg manage the wildlife so we can Get them the hell out of town, duh!!! Long valley is not winter habitat for mule deer
or elk for that matter and if you cant handle that simple fact, move. Stop feeding deer potato chips in the shore lodge parking lot and Go watch them in their natural habitat, anywhere
idfg is going to move them, outside of town.
I do not support this proposal to diminish the population of deer in McCall. The beauty of our wildlife, here in McCall, is one of the reasons we live here as full-time residents. It
breaks my heart to think that there is a possibility of ridding this majestic area of such beautiful wildlife. I support the increased education on the effects of domesticating these
beautiful animals, make fines steep for feeding them if you must, but DON’T take them away!
I agree enforcing not allowing the feeding of the deer and wildlife (other than songbirds) however I DISAGREE with removing the deer from town.
As a gardener I can fully understand the desire to keep wildlife off of my property and away from my prized garden! SO I INSTALLED A FENCE!! Under no circumstances EVER do I feel there
is a need to kill a creature of God!! We all serve a purpose on this earth and we all deserve the life God gave us!! I strongly oppose this ordinance! We have absolutely no right to
take the life of an animal outside of ordinary circumstances like for the purpose of food. “Nuisance” is simply not a respectable reason to end the life of an innocent animal! I strongly
ask you to vote NO on this matter! Thank you
This is a poor substitute for planning for growth. Do your homework! Have the public meetings.
The educational part of this ordinance is fine. People should not be feeding the animals. But the costs associated with catching, transporting and releasing large wild animals does not
make any sense in this economy. Even more troubling is the moral aspect of euthanizing these animals. It seems odd to move to a mountain town and then be bothered by the mountain animals
that drew you to it in the first place. Are they 'inconvenient'? Yes. Educate, don't annihilate.
We absolutely love the deer! It is what makes McCall so special! They are very welcome on our property! Please do not kill these beautiful animals to make McCall more like a city. Killing
these animals will ruin the mountain life that we all enjoy. McCall is a mountain town and not a city. If one does not enjoy the forest animals, then move away. No one is making you
stay!
I do not support moving or killing the deer. I’m okay with an ordinance to prohibit feeding wildlife.
I was just made aware of a few disgruntled individuals in the town of McCall who are wanting to get rid of the local deer because they are a nuisance. We have been visiting McCall on
and off for the past 9 years and my American husband longs to call it home one day for the reason of it's untouched beauty. The wildlife makes McCall what it is. Leave them be. Deal
with the disgruntled people, not the wildlife. They were there first and should be respected as such.
PLEASE do not do this. Idaho is where I am from (where I work and grew up) and McCall is a beautiful place. Please do not take away WHAT IS Idaho. Wildlife is so amazing for young children
to see, even older people who may have never seen anything like this. Why take them from their home, their land, for us humans to “not be bothered by them”. It’s sad. Just sad. What
is happening to McCall? And for Idaho for that matter? If we can’t have/ co-exist with wildlife in the mountains cuz they “annoy” locals (new people moving from out of town), then we
are on a very slippery slop...
HUGE MISTAKE.
Once you start removing the animals you begin a slippery slope of choosing which animal lives. This is their home and they were here first. If residents and visitors are educated not
to feed and fined if non-compliance all in McCall will win
I love our Town deer.
I am for the ban on the feeding of deer in McCall. In past years I have had a summertime neighbor who has routinely fed the deer all summer long. When the couple leaves in the fall the
10-20+ deer sit on their lawn looking for food for days. Then the deer turn to my yard looking for food and destroy my bushes and trees. It's sad to see the deer being fed corn all
summer, which I have been told by the Forest Service is unhealthy for the deer. In the fall during the rut the bucks become very aggressive and it is dangeous for me to even be in my
own yard. Thank you for your willingness to pass a ban on the feeding of deer in McCall.
Its a privilege to live near wilderness and wildlife. Spending tax money on killing wildlife in a place where it's a perk seems nonsensical to me. And many enjoy the wildlife they get
to see. Some moved to McCall abd similar places FOR that privilege.
We are against the trapping, relocating or euthanizing of town deer.
The wildlife in McCall is part of what makes it so special. Instead of destroying these animals, we would prefer to see more effort spent educating residents (and visitors) NOT to feed
the animals and HOW to use safe methods to deter animals from gardens.
I am against the trapping, relocating, and euthanizing of the town deer in McCall. My family frequently spends time in and around McCall and we love the wildlife. Please don’t do this.
We used to have deer when we built 19 years ago in Blackhawk when there were only a few cabins. Now with so many homes we very seldom see any. I so look forward to seeing them in town.
I love when I have to stop because a car is in front of me letting deer cross the highway and the kids in the car ahead are pointing and enjoying our wildlife. Please don’t do away
with them. They are a part of McCalls uniqueness. Enough has already changed.
I have no problem with the Education section.
I do have a problem with relocating or euthanization of any of the deer from inside the City limits or anywhere near the City of McCall.
My sister and brother-in-law owned the mortuary there since I was in my early teens. I practically grew up there on the weekends. At the age of 60 I still get excited to see the deer
grazing in town. I can't even fathom that your taking this into consideration!!!! So many mornings I would wake up to deer in the front yard or back, that was Mountain living!!
Its part of nature that was there first. Those complaining can move - and if its the guy buying the mortuary out (lol), I will gladly go knock him into next week. Got use to the
school being there, but was floored when the subdivision went in.
Again, Im floored that has even been brought up for discussion.
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE do not vote for approval for relocating or Euthanizing the Deer out of McCall City limits.
Respectfully,
Suzanne Coffey
The McCall "herd" has been an asset for the tourist and local community. While they are considered at times to be a nuisance, I believe most of us who live here love seeing them. There
are other mountain towns who have adjusted to deer, moose, bear etc. in there towns and have accommodated them. Not relocated them. People need to be educated on how to help the deer,
and how to cohabitate with them. This is their area, we have taken over their habitat. Where is the compassion for our wildlife??
The fact that people are even considering such a disgusting measure is despicable. We live in the mountains. We live in deer country. Don't like it? Leave.
I feel it is wrong to just move or euthanize an animal because it may visit a certain property regularly. Certainly we have to share the land with those born on it. We have a few deer
that regularly visit our condo property. They’re not hurting anything. They’re not destructive like some of the human visitors can be. It’s ridiculous to try to take the wildlife
out of a mountainous, forested area. Especially just to keep a few humans more comfortable. Thank You for your time on this.
We vacation in McCall every year and one of the things we look forward to is the deer around our timeshare. I am totally against removing them from the area. They are part of the magic
of McCall.
We love the deer visiting our yard. Our guests always get so excited to see deer so close. Such a treat. We've moved in on the deer. They were here before us and we should respect that.
Keep MCCall Idaho! People that move here can learn what it’s about or leave,
What is our world coming to? To disregard and eliminate the nature, which by the way existed before being populated by humans, is a disgrace and I can’t believe the city of McCall would
propose such a measure. The wildlife is one of the prize possessions of McCall. Let them be.
Unfortunately the “some” people more than likely are transplants and do not understand these deer have been coming into town long before they ever thought of living in McCall. And here
we are bending to the “some” people. You live in a mountain community, what did you expect. Next the city will be plowing driveways because it snows too much. Leave the deer. If you
don’t like it sell.
I know I do not live in McCall but I visit frequently and it would be so sad to remove animals from the home that they have had as well. Part of being in the mountains is being a part
of the mountains. And part of that is living with animals and with beauty and the disturbance that it comes with.
I am 100% totally against this!!!
The public need to be educated to not be feeding these wild animals.
I am against the order to thin out the local herd of deer in mccall by any means!
I am against the order to thin out the herd of deer in mccall
This is wrong
We visit the City of McCall two or three times a year. We especially enjoy the deer and we would hate to see them captured, relocated, or destroyed. The deer are a big hit with everyone.
Thanks
My family has been coming to McCall for over 40 years and we have been home owners since 2009 and WE CARE DEEPLY about the deer and wildlife in McCall! We strongly oppose removing deer
in McCall. This is a very bad idea! I do not know anyone that wants the deer removed. It is the mountains.....let the deer be free. Warmly, Sheri Petersen
I am against this proposal to thin out the herd of deer in mccall.
Our family vacations in McCall and Ponderosa State Park multiple times a year. I believe it is a terrible mistake to remove the deer from McCall. They are a large part of why we visit.
They don’t bother us and we don’t bother them. We don’t feed them either. We enjoy watching them. We just visited Glacier National Park and I said to my family how much I prefer Ponderosa
due to all the deer. Please leave the deer alone!
Enough is Enough. Don ‘t you have better things to do than to waste time and money on this. This is part of the charm of McCall and brings tourists back time after time to drive into
town and “I spy the lake” or seeing the deer.
We visit Mccall every year and look forward to seeing the deer 🦌. They are part of the Mccall experience. Please leave let them continue to explore the territory that was once theirs.
It seems certain organizations are attempting to create job security in transporting wildlife. Let nature work as intended; after all, they were roaming the area before the development
of what is known as McCall, Idaho.
Please do not disturb the wildlife in McCall. I have been vacationing there for years. One of the great things about McCall is the wildlife. Teaching my grandchildren and seeing the
excitement in their eyes when they see the animals, is priceless.
Please don't take that away.
Leave the wildlife alone. It's their home too!
I am against removal or destruction of the town deer. They bring joy to myself and my 92 year old mother. I am not against penalizing those people who feed them. Please leave them
alone and keep McCall “wild”.
Absolutely against any trapping, removing, rehoming or euthanasia of any deer in or around McCall. This would be a horrible thing to do for all and should be a crime to even consider
it. Ive lived in the country in Oregon, Washington, and Colorado where deer, elk, bear, cats, raccoons etc were all a part of the joy of living in the country and on acreage. They
should stay. It’s their home too and they matter.
As a former resident of McCall what made it special was the beauty of the wildlife and nature.
I can not believe the City of McCall wants to kill the deer and other wildlife. We are owners in Hearthstone and some of our favorite memories and highlights of our stay is seeing deer
and other wildlife in the area. Family and friends that stay with us absolutely love seeing these beautiful animals. If you allow the killing of this wildlife it kills what make McCall
unique and so special. Please allow these beautiful animals to live and be a part of what makes McCall stand out above other tourist areas. Thank you for your consideration.
Steve Baker
I am very much against the current June 24th, 2021 proposal to trap, move, and potentially euthanize the town herd of deer. There has got to be a more humane way to deal with this issue!!
I urge our community to work together to come up with a plan that includes a vision for the future of wildlife in our community that our children and grandchildren can be proud of.
This is something that can not be undone. Please think it through carefully.
Humans should be smart enough to abide with wildlife. Too bad it appears they are not.
I was born in Idaho 63 years ago and have never lived anywhere else. Growing up, I spent a lot of time in McCall and always have throughout my lifetime. Removing deer from the city
of McCall is a REALLY stupid idea. Seriously, don’t you have bigger things to worry about?!?
The town is a beautiful place and it is known for its nature and wildlife to trap and get rid of the town deer would ruin a huge part of the towns appeal. If they are considered a nuicence
then I feel you are living in the wrong area. Leave the deer bee and co-excist with them
I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall.
I understand culling out the sick and infected. We live in the mountains, in their backyard and it's quite unique having them around and sharing the ecosystem with them. It’s about educating
not eradicating.
We come several times a year to enjoy nature and wildlife in your area. We used to have a mountain home and love this area. I can’t tell you how happy it makes me to see deer wander
the streets and hang out in the trees. We’re familiar with the nuisances animals can be, but the joy outweighs the hassle in most cases. We’re in their home, not them in ours. We need
to respect that.
I am against the proposed wildlife ordinance. I feel that given the opportunity and proper education, locals and visitors alike can be educated regarding the harm that can be done when
wildlife and people interact in negative ways. The deer have been present within city limits (and surrounding areas) nearly year-round for decades. I live in a neighborhood of the city
where there are several large wooded areas. This weekend alone, I counted no fewer than 32 individuals and groups of people travelling on our street, who stopped either to view or photograph
the few deer that were present and grazing on grass near the street.
It was obvious that the deer were not seen as a nuisance, and rather as a type of attraction. Several of the people I saw over the weekend returned two and three times to the area to
view/photograph the deer. I have witnessed these same actions by visitors and locals alike, continually throughout the year, for the 11 years I have lived in my home. I have also witnessed
five negative encounters between people with their dogs and the local deer. In every instance, the deer appeared to be attempting to protect themselves or their young because an irresponsible
dog owner allowed their dog(s) off leash on a public street/area illegally, and the dog(s) either chased after, or physically attacked the deer. In two of those instances, the dog involved
was owned by an acting city council member at the time (Laura Scott).
I believe that education and not eradication is the answer to this proposal, and I do believe that education will potentially be cheaper financially, with much fewer wildlife lives lost
due to eradication efforts.
Wildlife here long before people. People should be happy that they are around. Maybe remove people from wildlife habitats. Which is pretty much everywhere.
I’m against harming the deer/wildlife in McCall.
As a decades-long McCall visitor, and former resident and business owner, I emphatically oppose the proposed Wildlife Ordinance. This is unnecessary, ill-conceived and reprehensible.
McCall without wildlife is like Boise without the Greenbelt. What next - drain the lake because mosquitoes are there?
Please, please deny this proposal. It would be an incalculable loss to the McCall so many, many people love and cherish.
I am against, if it leads to IFG removing and/or euthanizing town deer. It bothers me that Wildlife Management would allow this to happen, they are suppose to protect these animals.
We just spent the weekend in McCall and had a wonderful time. Our favorite part of our visit we to see a couple of wild deer.
Please reject this!! The beauty and wildlife are why we come to the beautiful outdoors in McCall. There is absolutely no reason people and deer can’t live together!!!
"against this happening" a "nuisance" Really are your flowers more important then the wildlife?
As a long time resident of Idaho, and frequent visitor to McCall, I wish to voice my concern for any actions that might lead to removal of the wildlife in and around McCall. The wildlife
are an asset to the community and belong on the land. Is there any other way to prevent artificial (people actively) feeding?
I have a 3 yr old son we love to see the freindly deer walk thru our yard to ponderosa lake every year and its really fun for the kids and adults. That's ridiculous to remove them.
Strongly disagree with the proposed Stance on the matter. what is this... never been in issue and all of a sudden some people move in and want to change McCall to there liking and
its a nuisance? go live somewhere else like the city were you wont see deer!
Keep the deer! They are part of the appeal of McCall
Please let the town deer stay town deer.
Leave the deer alone. It’s part of the charm of McCall and it would be a travesty to harm them.
I am against this
No! I love those deer. It’s one of the highlights of being in McCall. Please do not euthanize them.
Wildlife is critical to the health and happiness of life in McCall. Let them remain and be loved!
Not for this
We are in their territory. Let them stay.
What a cruel and outrageous proposal. These animals have just as much right to live and to live in their current home. You should be ashamed of yourselves.
I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall
No wildlife should be killed because they are a nuacence. That is so wrong!! They have a right to life. They are beautiful living creatures and should stay that way.
I am highly against the trapping, relocating, and euthanization of the deer in McCall.
The McCall City Council needs to table the wildlife ordinance and tell Fish and Game to back off. The residents of McCall need to be included in any discussion/solution regarding the
resident wildlife. Furthermore, in my opinion, McCall has more urgent needs/problems to address. (affordable housing; overburdened infrastructure; growth management coupled with zoning
requirements). Leave the deer alone. Tell Fish and Game to move on. McCall will manage its own resident wildlife. Let's not make national news as the lovely little Idaho mountain town
that wiped out its deer population overnight. Idaho has enough of an image problem right now . . Thank you.
I am against the trapping, relocating and eutanization of the McCall town deer.
Please don’t remove the wildlife from the city of McCall. It is part of what makes McCall so great.
I am against this stupid ordinance. Maybe we should eradicate all the people who are nuisances! There are far less of them than there are of our favorite, quiet, beautiful critters.
Go ahead and pass your do not feed the animals ordinance BUT do NOT let fish and game take this measure as a call to eradicate and eliminate the animals of our beautiful state!
STRONGLY against. This is a horrific measure & degrading to this town.
There is no reason to euthanize. I lived in Boise at a time. I am in Colorado now, we have deer, squirrels and rabbits and I would fight the same thing if the city ever proposes such
an ordinance.
I am absolutely against removing the town deer.
Before any decision can be made I feel the community needs to see concrete data on why these deer have become a “nuisance” now. You have some people on the community all fired up
thinking FG is going to kill ALL of the town deer including Ponderosa Park! I hope this is not true. I think data needs to be collected, shared then a decision revisited? Maybe you
have already collected data and I just have not seen it?
1. Has there been a count taken on “city deer” over the last 10 years? Has their population really increased or are they being pushed into concentrated areas because of our growth
and all of the lots being filled in by housing?
2. How many out of the total population are diseased? Is it 2 or 200?
3. How many man made feeding stations are there around the city?
Thank you for your time. :)
"Relocating" town deer is expensive in a time when local workers cannot even find housing, and this is what you are choosing to concentrate on? Ridiculous. I am against this proposal.
I am against the trapping, relocation & euthanization of the McCall Idaho deer.
Hello, I hope this message finds you well. I am absolutely against the trapping, euthanizing, relocating or any other such measure which could possibly bring harm to our town deer. I
truly believe there is a different way, a better way. I can not imagine looking out my kitchen window and not seeing the mamas, babies and bucks we have seen for 12 years now. I’m honestly
in shock that this is even on the table.
Sincerely,
Jenn R.
I am completely against moving and especially euthanizing these beautiful animals who have done nothing wrong. Why would you want to change what brings beauty and uniqueness in to your
wonderful city of McCall.
I have lived in Idaho my whole life. I travel to McCall to see the wildlife. If it’s taken away why would I come see McCall or bring revenue? Do not get rid of the wildlife. That is
the reason I go to the mountains.
Completely against
I do not support euthanizing city deer.
This is barbaric. The deer in McCall are one of the things that make McCall such a beautiful place. They provide excitement whenever they come along to say high, and to kill them all
is just wrong. I do feel that there should be a law against feeding them, as that is when they could become troublesome. In my years in McCall I have never felt that the deer are a
problem on my property, so I absolutely DO NOT SUPPORT this!!! These gentle creatures shouldn’t have to pay the ultimate price for living their life.
Against euthanization. Instead, measures need to be taken to enforce people to stop feeding the deer, this is attracting large amounts to locations in town where they normally wouldn't
feel comfortable coming. It's all about balance, there are more humans in McCall these days, meaning more traffic and more accidents are prone to happen. An accident involving a deer
in town is highly unlikely to be their fault or caused by them, the speed limits need to be followed and overall awareness of the wildlife we share our home with. Yes, I hate that the
deer eating my plants but this is their home just as much as mine. Like already stated, we have created this problem by feeding and attracting them. It is unnatural and if we set rules
to stop it, they will likely venture out to find food and shelter. It is easy to coexist, let's put in the effort. Control the tourist's actions that are affecting our community. Stop
feeding the town deer and slow down!
Another thought, stop development! Put a cap on development because natural areas are being cleared out forcing animals/wildlife from their homes....
Wildlife was in your area first. It is their home. Due to excessive building and infringement on THEIR territory you should be the nuisance. Leave them alone. Overbuilding overselling
land greed. That about sums it up. It used to be beautiful to drive to McCall. Not anymore wall to wall traffic and housing from Boise to McCall.
I'm 74, live in Lake Fork, but am tied to a downtown business. I've been living close to or visiting McCall my whole life and can't believe how bad the decisions are that are being made
to change McCall the last several years. The issue to eliminate deer from the town is absolutely not in the best interest of anyone who enjoys the local area. Total against this!
We visit McCall often to visit relatives and enjoy nature and wildlife. Removing deer from McCall would be a horrendous mistake and they truly are NOT a nuisance. Please do not pass
this measure.
I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall.
Thank you in advance for taking the time to consider my stance as a long time resident of McCall.
Jennifer Smith
208.315.5571
We all need to slow down and enjoy the wild life. I agree that education is needed how we can live together. But…. They were here first!
I'm a native Idahoan, and I am shocked and horrified that this would even come up as a suggestion for the city of McCall. Stop this travesty now! Seeing deer within the city limits of
McCall is not a nuisance. It's called nature at it's finest and most beautiful form! It's what makes McCall, McCall! You must not pass this ordinance. It will be a sad day for McCall
and the state of Idaho if you do.
I am against the Fish & Game proposal to relocate and/or euthanize the town deer population. It goes against the very nature of our community and why I chose to live in McCall.
Every time humans mess with the balance of nature (lots of coyote because we got rid of wolves) there are always bad results. Discourage people from feeding but leave things alone.
We are in their territory, we need to learn to live with them...
Leave them alone.
KTVB, KBOI well being out to you!
Leave the wildlife alone!! They're a huge part of McCall's charm. Bad idea to remove them...
This is not what Idaho represents.
Please do not get rid of the town deer! I know they can be a nuisance at times but it is something so unique and special about McCall. I have visitors all the time talking about how
cool they are and even myself and my family love them as full time McCall residents. Just yesterday I was out for a run and thought to myself how special and lucky I am to live in a
place that I can regularly pass wildlife on my morning run. The day before that they came up and were "playing" with our cat which was so fun to watch. Our 1 and 3 year old love seeing
them out our windows when they're walking through our yard.
we visit in McCall frequently one of the things we love are seeing the deer by removing killing them,You remove some of the ambience of visiting there. Don't commercialize it anymore
than you already have.
I am against the proposed plan of trapping, transporting, and/ or the killing of the McCall town deer.
I am totally against this proposal! It's one thing to prohibit feeding in the city limits but it's a sad shame that you would want to remove the animals or "KILL" the animals to lesson
the nuisance to the city. For the majority of the people who visit McCall or live in McCall and surrounding areas, they do so because of nature and the wildlife and love to see them
upon their visits to your city of which I'm sure they spend plenty of money doing so. You are taking away a learning experience for the children as well as not many children have a
chance to experience the joy of seeing an animal such as this. I've seen many, many, many pictures from visitors, residents of your City and mine posting the joy of seeing these animals
and how excited their family was that they could experience this during their visit. This is part of living in the Mountains, people have a choice, if they don't like what comes with
Mountain living then either don't visit or sell your home and move to the City!
I agree with the people who want this deer to live, she has visited for short period over many years abd causes no or minimal problems. I do not approve of removing all the deer in McCall.
Removing the deer that live near McCall and come into town would be inhumane at BEST. Please consider letting them stay and live their lives uninterrupted by your need to make McCall
a resort town, instead of the small mountain getaway town it currently is.
We need our wildLIFE in McCall.
Encroaching on deer habitat has caused this problem, along with human-caused climate change. Culling deer isn't the answer. Managing growth and carbon emissions is.
Relocate or euthanize the deer??? HORRIBLE idea!!! I'm VERY much against this!!! We have overtaken their habitat! Let them be!!!
I only wish I was as lucky on a daily basis to see Gods creatures roaming free. And to think mama feels secure enough to have her babies there is fantastic in itself. Leave alone what
God has created and the way He takes care of them.
Do not harm our beautiful wildlife
I am against this happening, leave the wildlife alone to wander and come in town, we come to McCall to see the wildlife absolutely love seeing the deer especially. If people dont like
it they can go move to the city with no wildlife.
I love seeing the deer and they are definitely a tourist attraction and a vital part of our ecosystem. When our family and friends visit they love taking pictures of the deer, foxes,
raccoons and squirrels! We fortunately live in the wilderness. Home for all of us! Why would anyone want to kill them? I have been coming to McCall since About 1950, I am a hunter,
and the deer were living here way before any of us. We have and can coexist.
In the future as wild animals wander in will you kill them too? Who started this insane idea? Vote no.
Sincerely The Fawcett Family!
I am very against this proposal to get deer and other wildlife out of town leave them alone, its nature, mccall is in the middle of nature, stop trying to control the local wildlife.
I think relocation is ok if it can be done with minimal harm to the deer. Not a fan of euthanizing them.
You’re all insane if you think euthanizing deer because they make their way into town is ok!! Where does it stop!? How far would you go!? We’re in the mountains!!! Deer will always be
in town! That is part of why people fall in love with this place!! Quit being so ridiculous!!!
I am against this ordinance
The animals were here first and they are precious. We need to protect them, not destroy them. The world would not be worth living in if the only life was human.
Please consider the deer as a positive tourism attraction that enhances your community. Find a considerate solution to any problems. Thank you.
The new wildlife law you are considering would severely impact the way folks experience McCall and nature. I go to McCall and the surrounding areas often and one of the highlights of
our trips is always seeing nature, and most especially deer, living in harmony with people. McCall is a wild and beautiful place and the deer add to the attraction. Please don't pass
this law to trap, relocate and/or euthanize the deer that are just trying to live where they always have.
I live near the Owyhee Mountains (not next to, but near) and we also get deer in our yard occasionally. We cannot relocate or eliminate all the deer every time they go into someones
yard, not here, in McCall, or anywhere else.. This stands true for other animals as well. I would think people would have learned from past experience that when you remove a part of
a food chain it can have far more serious consequences later (any one remember the "bunny bashing" caused by the coyotes population being almost eliminated in various places?) If they
(the animals) are a danger or pose a health risk, then that is a difference scenario. If people don't want other animals in their yard they need to put up appropriate fences to keep
them out.
We have been coming to this area for years before moving here 5 yrs. Ago. The wildlife is a major part of its charm. I have no problem with the rule of not feeling the wildlife but
killing the deer or removing them because they don't behave the way certain folks think is appropriate seems very harsh. Humans and wildlife have coexisted forever and adaptations from
both sides are often made. Is that such a bad thing? We love our deer and McCall would not be the same without them. So sad to see our area go the way of large population areas where
every inconvenience of nature is removed.
In reading the proposed ordinance and the reference to people having garbage and other to "lure, attract and entice" wildlife. Grease is garbage and I would like to see grease added
to the list of items to attract wildlife, in this case bears. Common practice to use grease to "bait bears" during hunting season and any person or business who has an abundance of
grease disposed of outside their property should be fined until the situation is remedied. This is specifically related to Lardos. They are the only commercial kitchen in town with
such a nasty mess behind their building, not even sure it meets city or health code. This results in the direct correlation of the bear population in Rio Vista. Fish and Game had
to kill an aggressive bear in Rio Vista 2 -3 years ago. That is much more dangerous to people and pets than the deer are and I would like to see that problem addressed in this ordinance.
I don't agree with the term "Habituated.......... Otherwise living within city limits - outside their normally wild habitat". Our city was built within their habitat. McCall failed
the wildlife through the years by allowing developments to take place without providing for habitat preservation and preservation of natural migration patterns. The result of the City
failing to develop in an appropriate manner to work with and preserve nature is to blame the wildlife.
I worked for the Government for 15 years in the planning, annexation and development side and know this has already been decided. You wont change or remove the definition for Habituated
I hope you will address the real issue with Lardos and the grease leading to the direct attraction of bears living in my neighborhood.
Thank you
Mark Dooley
How do you even consider them "city deer" when McCall is in the Forest?
It makes me SICK that I have to take a minute to save the life of a mama deer that is harming NO ONE. If any of you are GREATER THAN THE GOD WHO CREATED HER and gave her the RIGHT TO
LIFE-- then YOU take the life of that deer and YOU take the consequences! God said "Wo unto him that wasteth flesh and hath no need"--- If we can't have compassion on the helpless in
our society, then we are all doomed. Save the deer and MOVE ON to something that REALLY MATTERS in your community!
Against the removal of wildlife in town. It is one of the reasons we enjoy going to the lake and spending time in the area.
The deer are part of McCall's charm. We expect to see them in the mountain communities. Expect tourism to go down. Its not always about the residents.
I am completely against this!!! As an Idahoan, the fact that we have wildlife so close to us is simply a blessing!! For decades, our family has loved seeing these gorgeous creatures
outside our windows and love being able to observe their gentle nature. Whoever decided that this proposal was a good idea needs to move away to somewhere else where everything is
concrete and developments!! Shame on you, City of McCall and Idaho Fish and Game for entertaining this absurd notion!!! You should be embarrassed and apologize to the people who
live here and visit, bringing $$ to McCall. We come to enjoy Idaho and all it has to offer…… including the deer that our grandkids get to watch when we’re there.
Stop this NOW! This is a ridiculous proposal and should have been shut down before it ever even started. The deer in McCall as a big part of what visitors and folks that live in McCall
LOVE about being there. McCall has the perfect blend of everything, including the deer. The person who proposed this should be removed from office - clearly they don’t have the citizens
and visitors that bring money into the city. Boo!
I oppose, this is such a heartless ordinance.
This is the wrong thing to do. Most visiting McCall live the wildlife. We have had a "mama" and her fawns in our back yard for many, many years and they are not a nuisance, to the
contrary, they add to the uniqueness of McCall. Don't change our town....it is a HUGE mistake.
I, and many, many others in McCall are NOT in favor of this ridiculous ordinance.
We are against this proposal for obvious reasons:
1. The research from neighboring States (WA, UT, OR, MT, WY) Fish and Game departments have shown that less than 50% of the deer survive such a "relocation" program, and that the cost
is $600 to $900 PER DEER (in 2014 dollars).
2. We live here for a reason. For the wilderness, which is rapidly disappearing before our eyes. For the wildLIFE. For the absolute privilege and blessing it is to live Among the
Wildlife (deer, bear, fox, coyotes, cougars, moose, squirrels, ground squirrels, Ravens, Steller's Jays). They all have their own unique behavior and language...it is an incredible
blessing to witness daily from my home here inside the Park.
But if the City of McCall and Fish and Game have their way, they will ALL be gone next year. All. It is a drastic, draconian measure we will never be able to recover from.
Can you even imagine coming to McCall, in the Mountains of the Great State of Idaho and NEVER seeing a live, wild deer again? Ever?
Even in Ponderosa STATE PARK?
What a true travesty that would be that our children, grandchildren and visitors were never able to see a wild deer here in our beautiful town.
Once fully eradicated, we cannot come back.
"Removal" of the "town deer" that are *such* a "nuisance" may "sound nice", but what they are talking about is the trapping, transport OR killing of ALL of McCall's "town deer'.
No matter that they live in Ponderosa State Park. No matter that they do the "right thing" and migrate to lower climes at times and come back. No matter what their age. No matter
if they separate Mama from her young.
You get the picture.
It's a travesty and Draconian measure at best.
I am against the proposed wildlife ordinance for many reasons. As an Idaho native I think it is a shame that we build a town in the middle of a forrest and expect wildlife to conform
to our demands. They were there first. McCall is known for its wildlife which is one of the reasons why the town is a state treasure. Please don’t pass the ordinance.
I agree we need to stop feeding the wildlife but do not agree to get rid of them. These animals have been a part of our community for generations and are part of what makes McCall so
special.
Wildlife makes McCall unique and that is why we love having our cabin there. If the deer population was diseased then I could understand it but there is no evidence to that fact. I
guess you could consider bears a nuisance too but there is no proposal to relocate or euthanize them.
I am against trapping, relocating or otherwise removing deer.
If AB-168 were limited to making feeding of wildlife illegal then that would have been an entirely different matter. As it stands, AB-168 reached too far.
Save the wildlife!!
I have been coming to McCall for over 60 years and have seen it grow from the small mountain town with small cabins and friendly people to a small town with oversized houses and out
of staters who just aren’t as friendly it seems.
Anyway, enough of that.
Please, please don’t pass all of this ordinance. I don’t mind the no feeding but please don’t pass the rest of it. The deer, elk, and other wildlife were there long before us humans.
If those who find it a nuisance don’t like the deer on their property let them be moved.
Please please please don’t pass this. I love seeing the wildlife when I come to McCall.
If wildlife is a nuisance then people should not be visiting a wildlife get away, taking innocent animals and relocating them to die to benefit rich yuppies who are moving to our beautiful
state and taking away what we love about it is not ok. And those who proposed this bill with no regard that half of the relocated wildlife would probably die should be ashamed of themselves.
Keep idaho beautiful and keep idaho wild.
I am against this wildlife ordinance I think it will be detrimental to the natural wildlife in and around McCall
I am against this wildlife ordinance
Not allowing wildlife in McCall would be a travesty and just one more reason for people to detest out-of-state newcomers. If we wanted to live in a barren wildlife-less place, we can
move to the big city! Don't mess with what we have!
I am AGAINST the local Fish and Game's agenda/proposal to trap, remove, euthanize ALL of the town deer in McCall, due to them being a "Nuisance". This is a terrible idea! I spent many
summers and winters as a child visiting McCall and was outraged to even hear of such an awful idea! The wildlife are there to be enjoyed and protected. Shame on you for even thinking
of such a horrific plan! Fish and Game promotes their "Project Wild" program to children which encourages the appreciation of wildlife, something you should consider! The deer have
not invaded and are a nuisance, people are!!
You are living in their home . Most people love being close to nature it brings tourists and if you choose to live there it is part of the beauty. The tax payers should not be funding
relocation when we moved into their homes.
I'm against this!
Not something we should be doing to justify a job. Other things are in desperate need of supervision not deer in town, who are a tourist draw card
I am against removing wildlife from McCall city limits. People that are moving into this area need to coexist with local wildlife. This is their home, and the mountains around McCall
have been their home for longer than the existing homes. My husband and I also own property in Cascade, as well as in Caldwell. We bought our property in Valley County knowing full
well we would be sharing it with all of the local wildlife. That means we accept the positive aspects of seeing and enjoying wildlife, along with their natural behaviors, which might
not always be positive. It’s not right to eradicate wildlife just because they are a “nuisance”.
Deer were here first, we are just borrowing the space, feed them if you want or not, not your place to decide who stays and who goes, you are only here for a period of time.
Wildlife have been in and around McCall for YEARS and NOW you want to mess up the natural order of the animals for what?!?!?! They're habitat was crowded into in order for McCall to
even be built in the mountains, but you didn't see them throwing a fit and organizing meetings to have humans removed from their area!!! Dont over take nature if you dont want nature
to be in your backyard!!!! 100000% AGAINST THIS IDIOTIC MOVEMENT!!!!!!!!!!!
The reason people escape to the mountains it to be with wildlife and now they want to kill them because they are an inconvenience? I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing
of the town deer of McCall.
The deer are a magical part of McCall!! It is human error, not the fault of the deer. Please, please, please do not euthanize.
Sorry the deer are such a nuisance to you but WE like them here. And just in case you didn't know, WE are encroaching on THEIR land, NOT the other way around. I'm sure the Native Americans
felt the same way when they were targeted for being a 'Nuisance'.
I am in agreement with not feeding the wildlife. However I am completely against relocating or euthanizing wildlife under the guise of being a nuisance in their own habitat. People who
choose to move to the mountains should fully expect interactions with local wildlife. If they are unhappy with this then they can move to a more populated city that is further away
from wildlife. Alaska does not euthanize or relocate their local wildlife simply for being around humans and within city limits. McCall shouldn't either.
With all new housing, wildlife are being weeded out as it is. Totally against
Please do not remove wildlife
I am incredibly against this happening. Wildlife should be preserved, not eradicated for being a “nuisance.”
“Animals should NOT require our permission to live on earth. Animals were given the right to be here long before we arrived”. - Anthony Douglas Williams
We are against the removal of town deer!!! This is their home! People are the ones that need to make adjustments to our lives to help them!!! Removing, separating families , or killing
them is cruel!!! It is the same thing as removal of people SHAME SHAME SHAME on those thinking of doing this! I was born in Idaho and it is unique and beautiful Which includes getting
to see our wildlife and enjoy it!
I have been coming to our family property in Valley County since the mid 1960s. As humans we have encroached on wildlife habitats. Leave the deer alone. The are not predatory and cause
no harm to humans. There is no reason to euthanize them! They are part of living in the Idaho mountains. Families living in McCall and Valley County for generations love seeing them.
I have observed the joy in others seeing them for the first or hundredth time.
Thank you!
My family vacations up there every year! One of the most enjoyable experiences for the adults and our kids is to watch the deer... I cannot understand why anyone would think this is
okay! If you don't like nature then you should move to the city!!! Please don't do this!!!
What a horrible thing to consider. Stop this nonsense! The deer are one of the amenities that make McCall special. Let’s eradicate the people that came up with this stupid idea!
Against removing the natural wildlife from McCall. One of the most beautiful experiences in our State is being near wildlife especially the deer.
I DO NOT want this ordinance. There are ways to coexist with these beautiful creatures.
I wrote a comment earlier But I forgot to include my city in my address section. And want to be sure you include it and read it. This is a cruel proposal! taking wildlife from their
homes that they have lived in for ever. to relocate them to an area they are not familiar with and to separate families or kill them. Reminds me of the removal of jews!!! We are living
in their home! People are the ones that need to make adjustments to live with the deer. I was born here. We need to keep Idaho unique and beautiful with all of its wildlife! McCall
has been my playground for all of my life! I do not want to see it without Deer!!!
My in-laws. And. I own a vacation home in McCall this will be my wife and I retirement home we love McCall for the wild life. Including the deer this matter will change the mountain
feel of McCall
I am against this this happening.
We’ve been here for 20 years. We enjoy the wildlife. We never complained about the deer and we never hear any complaints. Tourists enjoy seeing the wildlife.
Seeing the deer and wildlife around our homes is an important part of the McCall experience. PLEASE do NOT remove and kill these beautiful deer!
The deer in town have been here for a long time and they will continue to come into town - feeding the wildlife or not. We live in their habitat. Education is important. Killing/transporting
is an outlandish/cruel idea. Someone has taken a very myopic view of what “they” think should be done with the deer. Is this job justification for F&G? Nothing better to do? I am
nearing 70 and I have seen a lot of foolish things “accomplished” by F&G. Many years ago someone with F&G had the brilliant idea to introduce mackinaw into Payette Lake. We no longer
can catch silver sides or trout to levels in the past. Re-introduction of a specific species of wolf? Really? Unless you are out in areas where you can see the damage to elk herds
from wolves one will not understand. There are other towns and cities that have taken a much more realistic approach to dealing with the wildlife in their human inhabited areas. Learn
from them before you make such a harsh decision that will have long term effects on our way of life here. Spray some deer fence on your flowers - don’t kill the deer.
As former owner of property next to the Park I never had any problems with the deer!! As for drivers thats another story!! Slow down, view the wildlfe!!!!
I support the proposal.
I understand that a yes vote on the not feeding wild animals will also result in Fish and Game beginning the gathering and relocation or euthanization of animals. This is completely
unacceptable! Obviously this was the animals home first! We visit McCall often and part of the reason is that we can see so many different beautiful animals in such close proximity
to town. It would be unconscionable to remove them from their homes. Please do not pass the ordinance regarding the feeding of wild animals. Thank you.
I can not believe that you would just euthanize an animal for being in city limits when McCall was and is in a forest area… these animals natural habitats for years.
How many cities do you know that currently do this. Seems very inhuman and a lazy way to “fix” this problem. Perhaps they need relocated further into the forest rather than just put
down.
This is no different than moving next to an established ball park or golf course and complaint about the balls coming in their yard or the noise of cheering fans.
None of this seems like a good solution the animals, but rather your easy fix.
I hope you reconsider this option and perhaps look for a different solution than just euthanasia.
We are against the eradication of town deer and any other animals by the City Council and Fish and Game! Are dogs and cats next?
Please leave our town deer alone. We can co exist with education. I oppose any use of taxpayers $$ to be used in any way eradicate the town deer.
My name is Ashlea Gray and I’m a 3rd generation McCall native. I am against the trapping, relocating, and euthanizing of the town deer. If this goes throw it would be a devastation to
the animals and the people alike.
People travel to McCall not only for the lake and it beauty but to have a chance for a first hand experience of enjoying the wildlife as well. How many children would not have this
opportunity?? Councilmen and women would you deprive you grandchildren of this opportunity? I think not!! My husband and I are not boaters however when we travel up north and see
a deer it becomes a successful trip.
Against this proposal
I voted NO last week and again this week regarding the "No-Feed" Ordinance. After attending the city council meeting in person on June 10th I am vehemently opposed to this ordinance
being voted on and/or passed at today's meeting or in the future.
The City has NOT been transparent with the apparent Fact that a "Yes" Vote on the No-Feed Ordinance is a Death Sentence For All Deer In and Around McCall. Regardless of whether the
deer are in town, in Ponderosa State Park, in Bear Basin, on Brundage Mountain, in Jug Mountain Ranch, in Blackhawk on the River, in RiverRanch, no matter if the deer do the "right
thing" and migrate in/out, up or down from McCall.
What you DID NOT TELL THE PUBLIC is that a "Yes" Vote will start a horrific Train Reaction giving local Fish and Game the "Go-Ahead" to immediately start the process to eradicate all
town deer.
This is a irreprehensible, uneducated and short-sided decision that You UNILATERALLY are making For ALL OF US, that will not only affect those of us who live here and call McCall home
but those generations to come. Including 2nd homeowners, visitors and tourists.
The First step MUST BE for the City Council to TABLE the no-feed ordinance and tell Fish and Game to STAND DOWN.
There are so many more pressing problems and issues in McCall that need the attention of our City "Leaders". The deer by far, are LAST on the list.
Who is so strongly spear-heading this and WHY? And why so suddenly?
Follow the POWER OR THE MONEY and you will typically always find out.
Fish and Game? Local Police? Local City Manager? Local City Mayor?
Which of them grew up here? Which have spent their childhood years into adult years here enjoying all McCall has to offer and the sheer beauty and magic and PRIVILEGE of living among
the deer and other wildlife? Are they really OK with forever altering the beauty and magic of McCall? For EVERYONE? To what end?
Who are they playing to?
I highly doubt any of them will want to brag to their children, grandchildren and future generations that "THEY WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR KILLING ALL OF THE TOWN DEER". Is THAT the legacy
they want to leave? Blood on their hands? And WHY?
Do our City Council Members, City Manager and City Mayor Actually even KNOW that if they pass the no-feed ordinance that Fish and Game will immediately begin the eradication process
(euthanization of ALL TOWN DEER)?? Are they actually OK with that?
If they DON'T Know Or Understand This, then WE need to ask, demand that they ALL STAND DOWN.
McCall has ALWAYS been a sanctuary for humans and wildlife alike. Please do not “City-fi” and pave over and alter forever the last vestiges of this beautiful MOUNTAIN town. We LIVE
in the mountains for the wilderness experience. We live here because we CAN co-exist with the deer and other wildlife. We live here because is NOT Boise or any other large concrete
city. We are going down a very horrid path we can never return from. Once it’s gone, once the deer are gone, this magic, this beauty is GONE FOREVER.
I urge you to DO THE RIGHT THING. Table this ordinance AND vote, and step back to re-evaluate what you are doing.
We NEED to preserve McCall. The deer BELONG TO ALL OF US.
Please stop feeding the animals. Please DO NOT relocate them.
For years my family have visited McCall multiple times a year, with family having cabins in different area's around the lake. We come up to be able to enjoy the mountains and watching
the deer and fox in our yard! Our favorite memories include waking up in the morning to the baby deer and baby fox wondering in the yard, with momma not to far. As we watch them they
always come right up next to the window, as if saying "Good Morning". If our wildlife is removed, we will no longer be able to share this amazing experience with our next generations,
it will no longer be an experience we get to have every year, and a big reason we come back to McCall year after year.
The absurdity of this should be evident. All life is precious, all of it.
For the feeding ban. AGAINST killing them or relocating them
Not Natural, Not Sustainable.
The McCall Mayor got it right when he said the situation with deer in McCall is not natural and not sustainable. The endless crush of humanity that is destroying wildlife habitat is
absolutely not sustainable and is not natural. McCall and Valley County have joined headlong in the destruction of wildlife habitat with development, activities and roads that are
destroying wildlife habitat at an unsustainable rate.
We have a problem with humans not deer. Human development has essentially destroyed all the deer, elk, and antelope wintering habitat in the Treasure Valley. That crush of uncontrolled
humanity is now creeping up the hill in Dry Creek and Avimor and Highways 55 and 95 have become Kill Zones for deer, elk, and any other wildlife that wanders onto the roadways. The
deer and elk migration corridors are threatened by the continued development of every river corridor in our area and now planned developments, mines and roads will take the rest.
The Police Chief mentions the problem of dead and maimed deer in a town with a 25 mph speed limit. Again, it is not deer that are the problem but the crush of reckless drivers in an
armada of vehicles. Oh yes, and dogs at large. Both of these are enforcement issues. As I sit here, watching vehicles running down Lick Creek Road at 50 mph, I wonder where the enforcement
is.
Gigantic, energy inefficient homes and endless development not only destroys habitat locally and displaces wildlife but is the root of habitat loss on a global scale. More dams and
coal mines for electricity have destroyed the rivers of the West and we have lost salmon and so many of the native fish of the West. These river corridors are now just killing fields
for migratory wildlife and gurgle with methylmercury and carp so we can build more houses and more developments.
We have extirpated Sockeye and Chinook Salmon from Payette River and our Lake. Bighorn Sheep and Antelope are long gone around McCall, Columbia Sharptail Grouse, Sage Grouse, Monarch
Butterflies, native Trout, Mountain Quail, Mountain Goats, Grizzly Bears, Pronghorn Antelope—all hang by a thread. We cannot count on the Idaho Department of Fish and Game Department
to make wise choices here. They have been nothing but a Holding Company for Extermination over the years and are politically neutered by the State government. One need only review
the recent wolf actions by the Fish and Game Department and the State to understand how castrated they are in dealing in wildlife issues.
There has been a 68% loss of wildlife worldwide since 1970. Migratory fish species have declined 72% since 1970. Deal with that Idaho Department of Fish and Game and stop nibbling
around the edges and dumping hatchery fish and non-native species into our environment. This is not sustainable and it is not natural.
In a hundred and fifty years, we have lost so many local, iconic species to human development. Now, we think we have a problem with deer in McCall. We have a problem with humans and
their greedy tendencies. They are not natural and they are not sustainable—the Mayor is absolutely correct.
We need to do a better job managing ourselves, not deer.
Tuck Miller
McCall, Idaho
As a former resident for a decade in McCall I’m gobsmacked to learn of this proposal to dispose of the city deer that wander about the community. Are you kidding?? Do not let a minority
of anti-wildlife and conservation new residents and homeowners mess with part of the charm and wildlife of McCall.
As a born and raised Idahoan and frequent visitor to the area, I am greatly against the removal/destruction of our “nuisance” town deer. Being able to live close to and see the wonderful
nature that Idaho has to offer is why we live here.
Another solution should be sought.
I think that it would be more harmful to move the deer. There are other options we can take one being signage about not feeding the wildlife and educating the public rather than moving
the deer. I think it would be detrimental to McCall.
The wildlife is one of the main reasons we maintain a family vacation home in Idaho. Nuisance is one who does damage, intimidates or threatens. To some... anything is a nuisance.
The wildlife was here first...and is one of the most attractive things about Idaho. If wildlife is a nuisance perhaps as ps you've chosen the wrong place to live.
I am against the proposed wildlife ordinance resulting in any interference, intervention, or control of the wildlife population in the City of McCall. I also consider Ponderosa Park
and other State or Federal properties beyond the authority of the City Council of McCall regarding this ordinance.
I grew up here in McCall and the deer have never been so noticeable invasive as they are now and are clearly a Nuisance at restaurant parking lots, and in town blocking the roads a lot
of the time.
Folks also need to stop feeding them.
The deer need to be thinned out or gone. They have no natural thinning process in town and have no Predators from what I have seen.
Most mommas have twins so the amount of deer is over loading the city and are getting out of control of eating folks landscape in their yards.
They have chased my dog and attracted it at my front door.
They have attracted my neighbors dog on the leash when she walked down the street.
They will eventually make their way back but for now they are definitely a Nuisance.
This seems extreme. How about putting signs up and educating people. It’s not like they are killing peoples dogs and cats or farmers sheep!
I like to drive to McCall to see some of the wildlife. It's always a surprise to see deer in people's yards or even in tjown.To take this away from humans is insane. These animals have
been here long before us and to disrupt the would be cruel. That is my opion
Wildlife is a draw for tourism in McCall.
This is a very drastic and sad proposal - totally against
We must educate, not eradicate when it comes to McCall town deer
I attended the June 10, 2021, McCall City Council meeting in person to listen and learn more about two “proposals” the City of McCall is currently considering regarding our town deer.
The first proposal is putting an ordinance in place making it illegal to feed deer and all wildlife in McCall with the exception of song birds.
The second “proposal” of much more concern due to its draconian measures, is giving Idaho Fish and Game the go-ahead to trap, relocate or euthanize all of our town deer. This will happen
if our city council votes on and passes the “illegal to feed wildlife” ordinance.
This will also happen without any public hearing or without any public input by our full-time and part-time residents, taxpayers and visitors/tourists. Unless you speak up now.
I am OK with an ordinance to not feed the deer and wildlife in McCall. I am not OK with the notion of trapping, transporting and/or euthanizing all of the town deer simply due to them
being a “nuisance.”
Just yesterday, Mama Deer (who has been giving birth to her fawns in my side yard for 11 consecutive years) and her day-old twins scampered across the fairway on the McCall Golf Course
where I am a full-time resident. Golfers, one visiting from Arizona, stopped their play and excitedly exclaimed “Aww, look! Baby fawns! Quick, get a photo”! I simply cannot imagine
a McCall without “town deer.” I’ve been enjoying McCall for 58 years with my family and friends at our family cabins over the years, and there have always been town deer.
Can you imagine being a visitor to Ponderosa State Park in the great state of Idaho and never being able to witness the majestic beauty of a wild deer? They are a part of the fabric
of McCall. May as well remove the expensive signage they put throughout the park letting visitors know of the wildlife they are “likely to see” in the park. Or tell them as they enter
the park, “Sorry, but to see a wild deer, you will have to go to a big-city zoo.” What a travesty it would be if our children, grandchildren and visitors were never to see a wild deer
or fawn in McCall ever again.
What in the world are our city officials thinking? And all due to the deer being a “nuisance?”
After doing considerable research by talking with Fish and Game wildlife biologists, wildlife officers, and wildlife conflict specialists in Idaho as well as our neighboring states of
Washington, Utah, and Oregon, we have much to learn. Each had come to the same conclusion, that trapping and relocating deer, known as “translocation,” did not work due to two primary
reasons: 1. Over 50% die during or shortly after the transport, and 2. The exorbitant cost ($600 to $900 per deer). If we allow this to happen in McCall, who will be paying for that?
Certainly not Idaho Fish and Game? Certainly not the City of McCall? The taxpayers? One wildlife officer said to me “Fish and Game shouldn’t be getting involved at all.” He also said
that the “deer belong to all of us” and that one governmental agency should not be allowed to take that from the local residents and visitors.
There are other alternatives that we can consider first before we got down a slippery slope that we can never recover from: 1. If traffic issues are “the most common problem” with our
deer, would it not be much more cost effective to actually enforce the speed limit? 2. In the 58 years I have been spending time in McCall and now living here full-time for 12 years,
I have not once seen a mountain lion. Have there always been occasional sightings during the winter or spring months? Of course. Towns and cities from neighboring states simply post
a general warning about sightings, or capture and re-release the lion vs. eradicating an entire herd of deer.
3. Of course deer sometimes become aggressive toward people and dogs, most often in the spring when they are caring for newborn fawn. Again, why not educate the public on how to live
with
The wildlife is what makes our area special.
(Continued from previous comment submission).
3. Of course deer sometimes become aggressive toward people and dogs, most often in the spring when they are caring for newborn fawn.
All mammals and wildlife are highly protective of their young. Again, why not educate the public on how to live with wildlife as our neighboring states do as well as enforce city off-leash
dog laws?
4. The exotic lice species in deer described by F&G does not affect humans or domestic animals. Deer in captive settings have been successfully cleared of lice infestations with the
use of medication. Many cases resolve on their own when the deer are in better condition in spring/summer due to increased food resources or with seasonal environmental changes
5. Why not put the no-feed ordinance in place then use a fraction of the funds it would take to trap and move, and put that toward a massive education campaign for locals and visitors
alike?
Why are we allowing a handful of people to decide the fate of one of the most endearing traits of McCall by eradicating the local town deer? The deer do indeed belong to All of us.
The city has many more pressing problems that it ought to be working on.
I urge our city leaders and city officials to take a big step back before it’s too late, before we can never recover from a very poor decision. Educate, not eradicate.
(Julie Conrad lives in McCall.)
One of the main reasons I travel to McCall is to see the deer. Please don’t remove them as then there will be no reason to go to McCall.
I grew up in McCall - it is a second home for me and I am COMPLETELY AGAINST this! Please leave the deer alone, they are doing no harm!
My family has been long time property owners, visitors and residents in Valley County and the McCall area. I am against the trapping, relocating, and/or euthanizing of the town deer
in the City of McCall. Please remember McCall and people are impeding on the deers natural habitat not the other way around. McCall is a resort town and a mountain community with many
new “city” residents and vacationers that do not understand wildlife and are fearful of them or feed them. We as a community need to do a better job through partnerships with Fish
and Game and City of McCall’s resources to educate about the deer and other wildlife not eliminate their presence. The deer herds are a beautiful attraction not a distraction. Please
do not eliminate the charm of our beloved mountain escape by making it void of the treasures our Idaho mountain communities offer.
I support educating the public with a wildlife ordinance against feeding wildlife in the city of McCall. I am against the current proposal to trap and remove the town deer. I think
education would be a good place to start and possibly putting more police presence along Davis Street where several deer have been killed due to excessive speed by drivers. Thank you
for your time and consideration.
Hi there, I would like to very seriously vote no on this proposed plan for the deer and wildlife in the city of McCall. As an Idaho native and someone who’s spent many many summers in
the city of McCall, I can say 1st hand that the deer within the city of McCall pose no unnatural threat to campgrounds or public lands when humans act responsibly. Deer live in the
mountains and the mountains were there before the town. As they say in Costa Rica, “don’t be a victim” which in this case, means use your brain when it comes to wildlife. Drivers, pedestrians,
and all people should take personally responsibility for themselves and their safety around McCall wildlife, specifically deer in this case. Please to not violate the home we so joyfully
share with these deer and please do not harm, move or alter the beautiful wildlife, including the deer. in McCall. We do not want restrictions placed on our interactions with these
animals, rather the freedom to use common sense and continue to enjoy the land we share. Thank you and sincerely,
Ashlyn Bideganeta
DO NOT KILL THE DEER!!!! THEY ARE A PART OF THE BEAUTY OF MCCALL !!! I VISIT MCALL OFTEN AND THE FIRST THING MY ENTIRE FAMILY LOOK FOR IS THE BEAUTIFUL DEER. AND FOR THE ONES THAT
ARE COMPLAINING, THEY NEED TO LEAVE THE AREA!!! # ALL WILDLIFE LIVES MATTER
Wildlife needs to always be preserved, the real nuisance is the public who don't want them to be in their natural surroundings. When visiting McCall and other areas it brings us joy
to see deer, elk etc. To take that away then what is the point of coming to McCall!
Do not want to see deer removed from the city!
I have lived here for 8 years, and over the last three years the town deer problem has gotten out of control. It is very obvious (and I am no wildlife expert) that the deer population
is not healthy. The fact that people are feeding the deer is only adding to the problem, and it is frustrating that these folks do not see it as a problem. An excessive deer population
does not belong in town, especially with the increase in tourism and traffic. The deer are becoming a nuisance and the population needs to be controlled. I am in favor of ticketing
people who are found to be feeding the deer.
It is just a shame that you would go so far as kill or remove all the deer or wildlife from the city limits of McCall. You go to the mountains to be with nature see things you cant
see in the city animals are part of that We are taking their land they are just trying to enjoy what was theirs. If the people who dont like animal should just stay in the city where
they do not have to put up with them. Please understand this is the animals land we have taken over it is not their fault why punish them!!!! the people of mccall live there because
they love the mountains, the lake and the wildlife... Thank you for listening
My daughter is in real estate in McCall and we visit there often, Myself, my family and clients that I have sent her way, all appreciate and love seeing the deer in McCall… it brings
a special charm to your town that should never go away, don’t lose one of McCalls biggest asset and charm they bring to all those who visit and live there. Don’t give into the politics
of growing and pushing out the animals that are such a joy to see.
It should be illegal feed all of the wildlife. Just as you cannot do this in state and federal parks. It’s not healthy or sustainable. It attracts more animals than the habitat can
support and creates a nuisance.
It’s so sad what you want to do. I support NOT killing or moving the deer. Please listen to the impassioned pleas of those who care. Thank you
I am adamantly against the euthanasia of wildlife, specifically deer, in the City of McCall. The wildLIFE, among many other things, is what makes the town so wonderful!
I love our town deer, but stop feeding them.
Last night, I was sitting in my yard with a friend, and the most adorable tiny fawn leapt out of the tall grass, practically into our laps. I, too, am completely charmed by occasions
like this, and I love animals. However, I re-iterate everything I said in my previous comment about the town deer.
In reference to this week's Opinion in today's Star-News by Julie Conrad, I dispute her claim that "there have always been town deer." I have lived in McCall for 45 years, and this is
simply not true. Seeing a deer in town was an anomaly, and there most certainly was not a pack of 15 living in my yard all winter. This situation will only get worse. Research the deer
situation in Ashland, Oregon, and get a glimpse of what our future may be if we don't act now.
Keep the animals in their homes!
Euthanizing the town’s deer is a terrible idea. They are a huge part of the appeal of McCall.
I am totally against this, the animals were here 1st , leave them alone!
The City has NOT been transparent with the apparent Fact that a "Yes" Vote on the No-Feed Ordinance is a Death Sentence For All Deer In and Around McCall. Regardless of whether the deer
are in town, in Ponderosa State Park, in Bear Basin, on Brundage Mountain, in Jug Mountain Ranch, in Blackhawk on the River, in RiverRanch, no matter if the deer do the "right thing"
and migrate in/out, up or down from McCall.
A "Yes" Vote will start a horrific Train Reaction giving local Fish and Game the "Go-Ahead" to immediately start the process to eradicate all town deer.
This is a irreprehensible, uneducated and short-sided decision.
The First step MUST BE for the City Council to TABLE the no-feed ordinance and tell Fish and Game to STAND DOWN.
McCall has ALWAYS been a sanctuary for humans and wildlife alike. Please do not “City-fi” and pave over and alter forever the last vestiges of this beautiful MOUNTAIN town. Once it’s
gone, once the deer are gone, this magic, this beauty is GONE FOREVER.
I urge you to VOTE NO today and make the City step back and re-evaluate what they are considering BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE.
We NEED to preserve McCall. The deer BELONG TO ALL OF US.
I am against this decision.
Save the deer and other wildlife in McCall, Idaho.
McCall is situated in the mountains which is the original habitat of wildlife. As we grow we continue to encroach on their habitat and we are now sharing our spaces. How can we terminate
innocent animals because we humans are in their space, if we're going to live in their environment then we need to be prepared to share the space. If you don't want to share the space
then you should go somewhere else, the animals were here first.
Please don't harm the deer... We need to drive slower, and be more tolerant. Thank you.
As an Idaho Native it is absolutely amazing that we are even having to make a stance against issues like this. The McCall area is a place I have always chose to go to for the nature
and beauty and along with that comes the wildlife. This is their home and was their home before the PEOPLE from all over (mostly those coming from outside of Idaho) moved in and are
now pushing for things like the eradication of the deer. And let me say, this is only the beginning.
Leave them alone! We should be pushing to save them not get rid of them. This is IDAHO- let's remind each other of that. Start doing things like this you will only continue to make
people angry, and that is one more thing we DON'T need right now. Have a heart and do the right thing.
HB
I am against the relocating of deer and other wildlife that grace beautiful McCall Idaho. Listen to the voice of the people.
So much of this is wrong.. Time to TABLE the Decision !!! There are more humane options. If you pass the ordinance, you know the Council will take a lot of heat regardless of what
you may think. This issue has not been well thought out; the consequences will bite our community badly. Take the time to do this correctly and humanely. This is a human caused issue;
the deer shouldn't be harmed or killed because of us. Once again, TABLE this decision!!!
Deer do not need to be relocated. THEY WERE HERE BEFORE US. WE INVADED THEIR HOME, NOT THE OTHER WAY AROUND. The deer belong in the forests, McCall, and we the people are the visitors!
The wildlife in McCall is one of the best parts of living here. Destroying that would be a huge disservice to the community
I am for the relocation and management of the local wildlife under the supervision and direction of Idaho’s Fish and Game.
For 18 years our family worked at Camp Pittenger for family work week ends. It was always a treat to see the wildlife in and around McCall. It was THEIR home before we moved in!
I don't get to McCall as often now, but when I do, I expect to see the wildlife. I think it is terrible what is being planned to happen to these beautiful creatures of God. Please
reconsider and allow them for future generations to enjoy. Thank you
I enjoy our town deer and do not feel they are a nuisance . They bring a peace and beauty to our town. Most people enjoy the moments our wildlife brings toMcCall, with wilderness comes
wildlife. Please preserve what our community enjoys. Thank you for all you do for our community.
Please let the deer do what they do. There is no reason for further regulation. The deer are not hurting anyone, if you hit one with your car you were probably driving too fast, texting,
or intoxicated. If people are feeding them, that should be their business. Spend your time reading the Constitution of the United States. Liberty and Freedom.
I love our town deer. With wilderness comes wildlife! Please preserve what all enjoy . Thanks for all that you do for our town!
Are you people crazy? Leave the wildlife alone. Move if they are a nuisance to you.
I support what ever measures it takes to control and decrease the town deer population. I also support the ordinance that forbids the feeding of wildlife.
Are you people crazy? Leave the wildlife alone. Move if they are a nuisance to you.
We live in these mountains to enjoy the beauty and the beasts. To take away one, will leave the other without it's mate. For who are we to decide what is beauty and what is beast?
This is a terrible idea
Our family visit McCall multiple times a year and our favorite part is seeing all the new wildlife, especially the deer. There are many reasons this is wrong but please dont do this.
What makes this town so beautiful is the natural elements. One year we ate at sushi and the deer were 20 feet away grazing. Or we love when they come up to our cabin to say hi and
sleep under the trees at night allowing us to wake up to them just being there. Those memories are a part of the McCall Charm. Don't let anyone take that away. Thank you!
Crazy!
I have been going to McCall since I was 4 years old. I have never been to McCall without having a deer sighting which always delights me. I cannot believe that the City Council is
even CONSIDERING doing what they propose. It's utterly ridiculous and cruel. If anyone there considers the deer and wildlife a problem, they should look inside themselves. If they
don't like seeing road kill, HAVE EVERYONE OBEY THE TRAFFIC LAWS!!!!! I can't tell you how many speeders I see around town, those who run stop signs, etc. Frankly, those scofflaws
are a danger not only to wildlife but anyone on the roads. I do not know of any mountain town anywhere who has tried to rid itself of the wildlife that was there way before the humans.
How dare you? Boise has a ton of repulsive Canadian honkers. They are like rats, they trash out parks, any bit of green grass they can find, yet there's no sane way to get rid of
them and they abound. So, how can you even propose to rid McCall of it's town ambassador? The wildlife? YOu would strip it of all the charm and also put an unsavory stamp on a town
for any and al visitors and those of us who consider McCall our second home. Shame on you.
I moved here in 1971 and the deer would meander through town and would head to the lake for water. Slowly McCall is closing off any access the wildlife used to consider a source. Now
it’s the landscaped flower beds!!!! Perhaps a nursery can instruct homeowners on the names of flowering plants that the deer won’t eat!
Prohibit the feeding of wildlife but please do not relocate them. If the deer are not fed they will relocate themselves back into their natural habitat.
Our family visits McCall, eats lunch, purchases items and spends money in this town. Why do we visit? To enjoy nature and wildlife.
Please!!! Do not let this happen. This would be a travesty! How sad that so many out of state people are moving in, driving up prices of housing/using their property for short term
rentals so that locals can’t find housing in order to work and now they have a voice in the proposal to euthanize our town deer! Gee, it’s too bad they have to stop for deer on the
roads… maybe they should slow down, marvel at the incredible wildlife, what a beautiful place they have invaded and the privilege of living here! This is McCall, a beautiful resort
town that has always had town deer. Unfortunately, it beginning to look and feel less than the community we’ve always known. So sad!!! Please don’t take away our town deer!
I do not want to see the deer trapped and moved. Seeing deer is one of our favorite things about McCall.
I am against this ordinance as it is written! Especially with the lack of transparency the City Council is showing.
I am against making it against the law or anything that would stop the public from feeding the wild animals. The deer need to be left alone and allowed to live in peace in their home
environment that we humans have invaded.
https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/why-deer-killing-programs-dont-solve-conflicts-deer
The McCall deer are a very special and beloved part of the community.
This ordinance would be against EVERYTHING McCall stands for. The amazing wildlife in that area is a lot of why people hold it as a special place in their hearts and memories. How
very sad if that were to go away. I am absolutely against this ordinance as should every resident and visitor to this unique and special area should be.
The eradication of all deer in the McCall area should never happen!! They are part of what makes living here worth while. We totally oppose any suggestion that this could happen.
Our McCall deer are, and always have been part of the charm of our area. This is terribly disturbing to think our City Council would think differently.
Part of the appeal of McCall is the wildlife and killing the existing deer will not stop others from coming to the area.
Deer are a vital part of the ecosystem that we all live in as we are lucky enough to live in the wilderness. Home for all of us! Why would anyone want to kill them? We have and can coexist.
If you want to reduce the number of deer in town, fine the people that feed them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Leave the animals / deer alone. They are not a nuisance but rather integral the the reason why McCall is a special place. It would be asinine and a travesty to remove them.
Do not mess with the deer. They are not a nuisance. How arrogant of this council to propose to kick the deer out of their home. The wildlife makes McCall special. Leave them alone!
I love our town deer.
Removing the current population will only bring more.
As a citizen of Valley County and McCall it is vital that we take a deep breath regarding transport/eradication of our local town deer. Deer don’t know the city limits. Why do we
have to mandate a decision right now when the deer have been here forever? What is the rush for Regan Berkley of Fish and Game, McCall Chief of Police Justin Williams, city council
members Colby Nielsen, Mike Maciaszek, Bob Giles, Cami Callan? What has changed that the deer have to be “taken care of” now?
The fish and game are very good at fear mongering. Mountain Lions, lice and deer being hit by cars. This is what is being promoted as the reasons for transportation, eradication.
Lice on deer. This problem takes care of itself. The lice do not get transmitted to humans or pets. Mountain lions? Really? Where? When? And as far as deer being hit by cars,
that does happen. Wouldn’t it be a better solution to enforce our speed limit laws?
The deer were here first. The deer have been here forever. I remember deer being inside the town of McCall and the surrounding area for my entire lifetime (I am 72). Why is there
such an emergency? Why don’t the people we elect listen to the citizens of McCall and take their time to be educated?
Our local fish and game needs to educate themselves with research conducted by other states and cities that have come up with reasonable rules and regulations.
We exterminate the deer now and other deer will come back in. Natural selection will take care of the few that are sick.
Why do we have a city council that rather than being responsive and responsible to the citizens they choose to listen to two individuals that have, in our opinion, jumped to their
own conclusions without a good thought process. We pay the Fish and Game and our chief of police. Maybe they should pay us back with positive thoughts, good education rather than
inflammatory rhetoric and fear.
Wouldn’t it make a lot more sense to enforce the speed limits, educate the public and take lessons from those cities that have chosen to live with their local wildlife instead of killing
or transporting the local deer?
We urge the city council to listen to their constituency. City Council, do your due diligence before you make a final decision.
At the last city council meeting on June 24, with a cutoff for comment time at 3:00 p.m., more than 350 voted against the proposal of trapping and transport and approximately 18 were
either neutral or for the proposal.
Please contact our city council members and our local fish and game to voice your opinions BEFORE
July 8, 3:00 p.m.
John and Jenny Fawcett
Full-time residents of McCall/Valley County
Tom, if possible, please include contact information for council members and fish and game.
Cami Callan ccallan@mccall.id.us
Bob Giles bgiles@mccall.is.us
Mike Maciaszek mmaciaszek@mcall.id.us
Colby Nielsen cnielsen@mccall.id.us
Melanie Holmes has voted against deer transportation/eradication
Mholmes@mccall.id.us
Regan Berkley, local fish and game 208-634-8137
Please, please, please approve this matter and allow Fish and Game to improve the health of our town herd through any and all means they have recommended. The herd looks worse year-by-year.
Those who suggest it's a normal seasonal molt haven't lived in areas with deer populations with healthy eating and migratory habits. There will still be plenty of healthy deer for
tourists to view without allowing the herd to continue to become the McCall equivalent of a flock of enormous pigeons.
Relocating the deer seems to be the most humane and natural way to care for the herd. It balances public safety with getting the deer back to their natural habitat. Further, when they
migrate through, not allowing them to be fed will keep this balance.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
I trust IDFG to do what is best and necessary - I trust their experience and knowledge on wildlife management vs locals who think they know better and have no experience managing wildlife.
The town deer are not only a nuisance, carry zoonotic diseases, ticks, lice, etc…these deer are dangerous. They have no fear of humans and this will prove to be devastating when more
people and/or pets are attacked. It is not natural for them to not be afraid of us, and this is what locals and visitors are failing to realize.
I am against removal of the “town deer” in the city of McCall. I am not opposed to fining people for feeding the deer. There has been a lot of talk about the deer becoming dependent
on the feeding stations. This is not true from my observations of the deer frequenting my property just off of Thompson/Davis. They graze on the vegetation in my lot all year. They
appear to be healthy and not aggressive. Yes, on occasion they eat my flowers when I forget to apply the deer repellent. At large dogs are a bigger problem in this community. Leave
the deer alone and shut down the feeding stations and let us continue to enjoy the presence of these gentle animals.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? Does this method work in other areas? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
We feel this is a non-productive issue. The town deer are not hurting anyone or anything. They will face predation in the woods that they have never faced in town and probably won't
know how to handle. If the intent is to kill the deer then take them away. They are the town mascots. If you need to limit people feeding them then do that but leave them alone otherwise.
My husband and I very strongly feel this is a horrible idea. We own several parcels in McCall and strongly urge you to vote against this.
I understand peoples attachment to wildlife but the feeding of Deer, Fox and Raccoon has created a problem for City residents and especially for the town deer population.
Deb has lived here her whole life and I have been a permanent resident since 1974. Back then there were no deer in town. Literally none. Starting in the mid to late 90's there were
a few deer. Continue to allow people to feed the wildlife and the problem will continue to get worse.
The sad thing here is that people think that they are helping the deer by feeding them. IDFG staff are spot on with their diagnosis - these deer are suffering and will continue to do
so if there is not a concerted effort to change course and IDFG has a good plan. Will there be some attrition to the deer that are moved? Yes, but that falls on the shoulders of the
people who have kept the deer in town by feeding them. These animals need to follow their natural migration and move to lower ground like they have done for thousands of years.
Sad that humans think that we can alter nature's ways for our own enjoyment and think that there will no consequences.
Eradication is for the protection of the deer? I have lived here all my life. The wildlife is a part of living in the mountains. If you have a problem with the, then maybe this isn’t
the best place for you. Education is far better than removal. LEAVE THE DEER ALONE
To Mayor Bob Giles and members of the McCall City Council:
I urge you to vote against the ordinance proposed by one of your City employees. You cannot bifurcate the vote on the no-feed ordinance and the gruesome aftermath. Thoughtful elected
officials do not make decisions without considering even short-term ramifications, let alone long-term ramifications of their actions. Pretending that this is only a vote on a no-feed
ordinance is disingenuous.
Going down this road, will alienate a lot of people who have loved and supported McCall for decades. The pandemic negatively impacted the town, its businesses, and residents. Why look
for ways to alienate people? Wasn’t the pandemic enough of a hit on the town? Do you really want to wage a war on Bambi now?
One would think that you have more pressing issues to consider than rounding up or trapping deer, intentionally killing some of them, causing the death of others due to stress, and transporting
those that survive to Emmett or other places far from McCall.
The alleged “exotic” lice infestation has not even been confirmed, but there's already talk about killing the deer. Some studies have shown that about half of all deer trapped and relocated
die from capture-related stress or from being hit on highways as they wander extensive distances after release.
Who determined that the guestimate of about 150 deer for a mountain town that has over nine square miles is too many deer? Remember, it was us humans who first invaded the territory
of wild animals. We are the original intruders. We encroached upon their habitat first.
So you eliminate those 150 deer. How about the deer that hang out within the city’s area of impact or in the county but could later wander into town? Do you also plan to take them out?
Do you plan to put a deer fence around the entire town? Or perhaps an annual fun deer roundup event?
If you are concerned about inattentive drivers injuring or killing deer within city limits and causing damage to their vehicles, why not put up some warning signs where deer cross frequently?
Why not enforce speed limits? Why not educate people to slow down and drive more carefully?
Why not place moveable, changeable message boards at accident hotspots to alert drivers, especially during times when fawns are likely to be crossing the road behind their mothers, or
during the fall “rut” when bucks are on the move and likely to be crossing the street in pursuit of does?
In Idaho, people are used to seeing “Deer Crossing” signs and “Open Range” signs along highways where they travel at relatively high speeds. Livestock may roam freely in Idaho, including
on the highway, but deer must be rounded up and killed or moved out because they might cross our streets?
Have you asked the Chief of Police what his department has done to date to improve public safety?
It does not appear that the city has done much to come up with a thoughtful, publicly-acceptable, and sustainable deer conflict management plan, if one is even needed. Why not start
with a comprehensive public education program designed to minimize deer-related conflicts?
Stop the war on Bambi!
Edit Szanto
McCall and Twin Falls
One of the many things we love about McCall is the wildlife. I urge the Council to not ban feeding the deer but rather to educate the public and encourage local stores to sell approved
feed. If you decide to ban feeding the deer there will be some residents who continue to do so, despite your ban. For the deer who call McCall home, please choose to educate the public
how to care for our forest friends and make money on approved deer feed sales. Keep the deer! Please.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? Does this method work in other areas? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
It sickens me that the McCall City Council wants to disrupt/move/destroy/kill the town deer. Several people enjoy the wildlife in McCall and you guys want to take that away. Don't you
have anything better to do with your time? Does this method work in other areas? I'm extremely disappointed. There are better alternatives to consider.
No!!!!
As much of a nuisance as the town deer can be, we are in their habitat! There is no need to place a war on the wildlife as the police chief seems to want to do. There are alternatives
such essentially, wildlife birth control. Here’s a link to such ideas https://spayvac.com/ and Please see article below.
“A private effort to experiment with contraception in British Columbia. The U.S. Humane Society provides this service, contact information and an example proposal. The nonprofit Science
and Conservation Center in Billings, Montana, has many years experience working with horses, deer, and other animals. On July 6, 2017, the EPA approved an application to register
ZonaStat-H, a fertility control vaccine that will provide a humane management tool for managers of deer populations.
News
Esquimalt proceeding with birth control study on deer June 30, 2021 British Columbia, Saanich News
... The research is being done by the University of Victoria Applied Conservation Macro Ecology Lab. This summer, a capture team consisting of a wildlife veterinarian and field technicians
will tag 20 female control deer using darts...
Lesniak Calls on UC to Establish Fertility Control Programs for Deer Management April 13, 2021 New Jersey, InsiderNJ
... Former Senator Raymond Lesniak kicked off the event by breaking the news that the Lesniak Institute will be working with advocates and Union County officials to establish a deer
fertility control program in Union County... In their research, they found that fertility control programs could gradually reduce the deer population in their neighborhood to a sustainable
size without unnecessary lethal force...
An Overview of Wildlife Fertility Control April 13, 2021 Pennsylvania, Botstiber Institute for Wildlife Fertility Control
... The Botstiber Institute for Wildlife Fertility Control is excited to share the new educational film, “An Overview of Wildlife Fertility Control,” on April 20, 2021 at 1:00pm EDT...
This film was created with the intention of educating the public and creating connections between wildlife managers, researchers and advocates...
Town considers deer options, no-feeding ordinance March 19, 2021 Washington, Whidbey News-Times
... the state Department of Fish and Wildlife said there’s nothing currently available [birth control] for the resident ungulates who roam the streets of the town... it hasn’t been used
on blacktail deer... the mayor found trapping and killing to be an “ugly” and “extreme” response to the overpopulation problem...
Head of the Harbor village, Hunters kill tagged deer used in study, researcher says November 16, 2020 New York, Newsday
... "Killing tagged deer is very harmful to the research, since each one provides us with information on how long the contraceptive vaccine lasts and helps us understand how deer move
around the village," Tufts University researcher Allen Rutberg ...
Oak Bay, Deer contraceptive program in Oak Bay deemed successful, but challenges remain October 4, 2020 British Columbia, CHEK
... the project has managed to vaccinate approximately 75 per cent of Oak Bay’s deer population with birth control. “I’d say 70 to 80 per cent of the vaccinated does will be effectively
contracepted so that means only 20 to 30 percent of them will have fawns compared to 95 per cent will have fawns without the vaccine,” [ wildlife veterinarian Adam Hering] ...”
I’ve been chased every season by a momma deer protecting her babies as have many others and their dogs, the fact is we’ve pushed so far into their homes they have no other place to go.
By using science to help control the population rather than slaughtering them, we can help create a manageable population.
Estes Park, CO has a huge problem with the town Elk. Tourist seem to think it’s fun to try to feed them and pet them which only makes them more aggressive especially during mating season
and calving season. Here’s their plan
https://www.nps.gov/romo/learn/management/
The deer are a part of the small charming mountain town feel that mccall is known for. Educate the people don’t punish the deer.
This action by the City started from a complaint that reported that the "town deer" were a "nuisance" and created various "risks"! I (and my wife, Marlene) simply disagree with this
characterization! We have lived in McCall for 25 years and have never seen an instance where the individual deer, or the "herd" fit this description! That is, unless you considered
their apatite for tulips or some of the other tasty plants we've tried. We believe that the "nuisance" label in this case comes from employees of the State Fish and Game department,
as noted by their quick solution to the problem (which is quite ridiculous)! Frankly, having members of the local Mule deer herd visit our property on occasion is quite a treat; they
don't eat very much at any one time, nibble a little here and there, and then move on. We find their visits very enjoyable! We believe that the proposed "solution" is a total waste
of time and resources by the Council and City employees, as well as the costs to "relocate" the herd, and strongly object to our contributions to the City (and State) budget being used
for this totally unnecessary purpose! Perhaps one solution is for our visitors to relax an little more when they visit, slow their driving some, and enjoy what we have in McCall and
our surroundings! Including the occasional visits by our "deer herd"!
Against
This doesn't seem like a good use of our money. Take a moment and see if mountain lions attack anyone downtown first.
There are plenty of other smart things we should be doing with the city of McCall’s revenue. We need bike trail and sidewalks in town. If you look at other towns in other states like
colorado, the people and wildlife Co exist like Estes park the elk there are plentiful and they border a park like we do. Please use the funds for something less insulting and beneficial
to the town.
I am a native Idahoan and am against this 100 percent
I am AGAINST this proposal. How DARE you kill off the wildlife in a MOUNTAIN TOWN???????
NO! To such a crazy idea to eliminate all the deer around McCall!! My father helped to design and create Ponderosa State Park and would be horrified at such a terrible idea!!😒. I went
there for years as a child and the deer are apart of McCall!
Leave the deer alone. Pass an ordinance not to feed them. But please don't eliminate them. Thank you
My family had been visiting McCall for 15 years and bought a townhome several years ago to spend summers in McCall. The local wildlife Is a big part of what makes McCall a special place.
It seems to me everyone enjoys and respects the wildlife. We considered buying a place in northern Arizona closer to our main home, but because of the beautiful wildlife chose McCall.
Please do not destroy the local resident deer! I was born and raised in Boise and have visited McCall and had a second home in Valley County all of my life. One of the highlights is
seeing the deer!! They lived there before we did and they add to the beauty of McCall. Please model after places like Jackson Hole! The wildlife wander all around there and we get
to visit their home, not destroy them! Please vote NO and save the deer!
Please open this topic of “town deer” to the broader community - an open, in-person, public forum ensures the best outcome. I am not in favor of any directives to remove town deer without
further evidence of a comprehensive study and a true vehicle for public input.
I am absolutely against the relocation of the town deer. This is their home and we should put more emphasis on educating the people of McCall, and those who visit on how to coexist with
the wildlife that live here.
.
Don’t change the town. Maybe help homeowners with fencing.
We love the wild deer. If there is disease, I understand we need to help the herb stay healthy. but to destroy all of the animals is not humane.
I don’t agree with killing the deer or even forcibly removing the deer. I strongly agree with enforcing a No Feeding Wildlife policy which only harms the wildlife. I was very surprised
to see that a strong majority of comments agreed with this opinion yet the next day in the Star News it stated that the City Council was in favor of removing the deer. It doesn’t seem
like the city council is listening to the citizens of McCall. Don’t they represent us, not their own personal agendas?
Please do not eradicate the deer. They are just one of the many reasons we enjoy the beautiful city. My children look forward to seeing them in the morning and afternoon as they wonder
so calmly through our neighbourhood.
Relocation of the deer will be a very expensive short term solution. If the city deer herd is truly a problem, there are less expensive longer term solutions.
Don’t ruin the special environment of the town which makes McCall so unique!
The city should not look a gift horse in the mouth, as the State Fish & Game is willing to help take care of the city's liability of problem deer! We have seen this situation played
out in a Montana city we moved from 10yrs ago, where the city police department with only advisement from Fish & Game were removing approximately 500 deer a year, trapping, euthanizing
and giving the meat to the city's foodbank. It astounds us that one weekend feeder can cause so much damage for local, neighborhood residents who live here all year long. Please pass
this much needed ordinance!
The deer make it unique in McCall
I have been going up to McCall since I was a little girl. It was amazing to see the wild life and learning the respect that it comes with. My step mom has a cabin in McCall and we are
still always going up. Voting to remove the wildlife is not the McCall or Idaho that I have grown up in. We love our wild life and have always respected that we co exist with them no
matter what area in Idaho we are in. Just because of population growth is happening doesn’t mean we should change our ways. If people are moving here because they love our way of life
then why change it? Keep Idaho the way we have always loved it and start teaching people the way Idahoans live instead of changing it to fit their needs.
This is just stupid. The deer were here first!
I never get tired of seeing the new baby fawns each year, and observing them grow. Please consider leaving the town deer alone. They add to the charm of McCall. Thank you for your
consideration.
I am against this happening.
I am against this happening.
Save the deer. As a tourist, I found the presence of the wildlife in and around McCall much of the appeal.
As a visitor and guest of McCall, I found the town deer part of the town beauty and culture I found peaceful and beautiful. I have many photos of the deer that I still look at daily.
I don't understand or condone the slaughter of these innocents. They are part of the serenity that surrounds your town, why would you murder what most people embrace? Shameful.
This is not something that should be passed without substantial research. Eradicating all town deer seems like a quick solution, but there is no way it will come without consequence.
I recommend contacting the city of Logan, Utah to see what they have been doing to combat their growing town deer population. They work with local universities to come up with solutions.
Furthermore, come up with a plan, present it to the public and create a public forum. Don't just take the easy way out of this issue. It won't work.
I can’t believe this is still an ongoing consideration. I am vehemently against the eradication of innocent animals because some humans consider them a nuisance! Humans are the nuisance!
Leave the deer alone! They have every right to be there. You live in THEIR backyard! Don’t like it? MOVE!!!!!
Please please leave the deer and all wildlife in the mountains and the surrounding towns.
The deer have been there a lot longer than the people. Keep McCall deer friendly and a little wild.
Allowing intentional human/deer interactions in town are dangerous for both parties. Deer cease to engage in natural foraging behaviors and the feeding of them increases their density,
leading to a higher probability of disease spread.
Should there be some sort of controlled feed of the deer? The deer have been a part of this community for decades. They are a part of McCall’s charm and what keeps a lot of people happy
and bright in the winter months for sure. Have we considered a raise in taxes to offset a controlled feed that could be managed by some of the people who are against this ban? I’m not
sure of the answer but these deer have been here forever and finding a way to preserve their presence for the good and soul of the community sounds like a better solution than starving
them and/or relocating them. On a sidebar, There’s a lot of therapy in Animals and their presence for the betterment of the public, particularly those who struggle with anxiety, depression
and loneliness. Thank you
As a resident of McCall, I think that it would be irresponsible for us to spend funds to relocate or remove the deer from McCall. This is a waste of resources that could be better utilized
to improve our community. I love living in McCall because of the proximity to wildlife and I enjoy the deer in our community. Please don’t do this.
I am against this proposal. My in-laws have owned property in McCall for 45+ years and the deer have never been a problem. I believe this is a few people, most probably new to the
area, who are pushing this through. The comments made by the chief of police and the F&G representative at the last meeting about the deer starving if they weren't trapped and relocated
is overblown. I doubt the majority of people feed the deer in the winter and they have done just fine over the years. At the very least, the council should delay the passage of this
and open the matter up to further public discussion. Especially given the last count reported in the previous meeting of over 300 against the proposal and 18 in support of it.
We have been visiting the McCall area for the past 9 years as it is our favorite place in the world to go to. It breaks our hearts to think that anyone in McCall would want to exterminate
the local deer in any way. McCall is known for it's beauty and wildlife, leave them be! If this is the route McCall council and its residents want to take in removing something that
naturally belongs there, we have no desire to return as McCall is nothing more than any other tourist trap with city life thinking. We go there to escape the craziness, not be engulfed
by it.
Leave the deer alone in McCall. How utterly ridiculous to think they are a nuisance when they do nothing but show the beauty of your city. Shame on those who think otherwise. Move to
the big city if you want the convenience of no nature.
I am against the trapping, relocating and euthanizing of the town deer of McCall.
The deer were here first. We live in a mountain town for Pete sake. This is there home. If you don’t like the deer leave McCall Please do not remove the deer from McCall and the surrounding
area. It’s the dumbest thing the Fish and Game, the Chief of Police and the City Council has ever proposed. I’ve lived here since 1958,The deer must stay.
I support the plan to not allow the feeding of wildlife in town. The deer herds in town are a huge hazard, especially along Davis Street where I know multiple people feed the deer. It
isn't safe for the humans or the deer. People seem worried that the plan would mean that there would be zero deer in town. It seems like there will always be some deer, but this plan
will help to control the herds to limit them getting hit by cars, causing people to be injured in accidents, bringing predators into town, and getting diseases. Thank you!
That's what McCall is all about...Keep the wildlife in town.
Please vote NO/ against. We live here to see the deer and wildlife. The deer eat my flowers every summer, it's a nuisance but we expect it. Keep people from feeding them. That's more
harmful.
Need to post no feeding signs and impose fines not remove the deer. There will be more deer to come in if removed.
I oppose the intent to remove/eradicate our town deer. Please find an alternative for all involved.
With all the growth and other pressing issues of this town it’s hard for me to believe the deer need be a focus.
More research is needed regarding controlling the deer in McCall. Educating the community and visitors about not feeding the deer is a great place to start.
Please leave the deer alone! 🦌 They need to stay and deserve to be there more so than us! Shame on all of you to think that this is ok to kill the wildlife downtown and the surrounding
area.
I am against any vote to remove or relocate the town deer. It is an outlandish proposal that has not worked in other areas nor with other species of wildlife. We build in deer habitat,
we maintain water and food sources for them (without intentionally feeding them), and we have coexisted with them from the beginning. If the current deer population is removed, it
will only be a matter of time before other deer fill in. McCall is a beautiful place to live and deer and humans are here to stay. Please do not approve this proposal.
The wildlife in McCall is part of the communities charm.
I am in shock that this measures is even on the table. We know and love our town deer. For us this is personal. I think to do something so cruel would leave a stain on McCall that I
personally can’t bear. I encourage you to think of ways to put this burden on *the people* and not the animals whose home we have infiltrated. There is a better solution. Murdering
our deer-friends is not it.
Removing all deer from McCall would change it forever. One of the things me and my family love most about McCall and why we visit often is the wild life. Please vote no.
We think this ordinance is NOT the answer!
Please find a solution to the deer problem that does not involve killing the deer.
I am totally against this there has to be a better way
Just ridiculous find a better way
Vehemently against!
The deer in McCall are part of the town's natural beauty and charm. It's a part of the reason people visit McCall, to escape city life and be immersed in nature. McCall is truly a magical
town. The City should be working to do everything in its power to protect that magic.
I am against the killing or relocating the deer. I look forward to watching ALL the wildlife in McCall as a visitor and a former resident.
DO NOT KILL OFF OUR DEER
We live the deer in our neighborhood. We love seeing them in the morning while driving our kids to/from school. This is their home and part of the beauty of living in McCall is seeing
them and respecting the deer.
We have been visiting McCall since we grew up in the Treasure Valley in the 70’s. The local deer are such a welcome sight and are what you expect to see while enjoying all the the area
has to offer. Removing the deer would be a terrible thing to do and would ruin the experience for generations to come. SAVE THE DEER!!!
Keep the deer happy and thriving in McCall!
Keep the Deer! They were here first! We love seeing them when we visit! Don’t kill! If you want them out Tranquilize them and move! Plz don’t kill!! Thank you!
1 - The deer are not a problem. Speed limits are 20 and 25mph in town and just outside of town no more than 35. People are the problem. They need up watch for deer and slow down.
2 - If feeding the deer is what you don't want then start a program to educate people and it will gradually stop. It is not right to punish the deer for something that has been allowed
for years.
3 - We don't feed the deer and we enjoy watching them whenever and wherever we see them. It is a highlight of our day. Our guests are always delighted to see deer in and around town.
Please don't get rid of the deer.
Against any proposal that will end with removing deer from the town of Mccall.
There has not been compelling evidence that a public nuisance exists for deer or other wildlife in the area. Please find other and better ways to spend public money and time of public
servants. Yes—-that includes you, Idaho Fish & Game.
Let’s vote no! Let’s really take some time for more study of what is working in other communities. Let’s not fall to what is the easy answer here. Let’s make a thoughtful and REPRESENTATIVE
vote on this important, emotional and sensitive issue.
Do not remove and kill these deer in McCall. It part of the identity of McCall.
This issue needs further analysis and public input. Don’t rush a vote. Everyone’s voice deserves to be heard.
There should be an ordinance to not feed the deer but removing them from mccall is not right and I'm against it completely. They are a part of this town and part of what makes it so
special.
There should be an ordinance to not feed the deer but removing them from mccall is not right and I'm against it completely. They are a part of this town and part of what makes it so
special.
There should be an ordinance to not feed the deer but removing them from mccall is not right and I'm against it completely. They are a part of this town and part of what makes it so
special.
The deer of McCall are part of the magic of the town
I do not support killing or moving the local deer population. I do support an ordnance to stop people from feeding them.
Do not eradicate the deer from the City of McCall.
I’m against this proposal. I absolutely adore the precious wildlife, aka deer here in beautiful McCall. It’s what makes this town such a precious gem to so many. They are not a nuisance
in any way, they are a gift to me and my family. Such gentle creatures that deserve to be safe and have a refuge here in our small city. Thank you.
Wild animals should not be domesticated. People feeding anything besides birds should receive one warning followed by a fine and a mandatory class educating the public about the multiple
reasons habituation is inhumane.
Leave the deer be!!!
This is the only home they know, do NOT kill these beautiful beings just because we, humans, arent smarter than the deer and still haven’t figured out a way to live with them.
Let’s set a good example for this world, there’s already so much negativity in this world, let’s shed some light and encouragement on this world
I am a biologist and understand the reasoning behind this effort. It is unfortunate that though very kind-hearted, many people would choose to see "their deer" suffer injuries, parasitic
infections, cause accidents and/or potentially starve. In my professional opinion, it is reckless and irresponsible to put these deer in harm's way daily for the sake of what people
deem as "town charm".
I fully support the efforts of trapping and trans-locating the town deer that are deemed by wildlife biologists as having the best potential to make it in the wild. I also support the
humane euthanasia of those in the population that are injured, unhealthy, or deemed unfit to be placed into a wild herd.
Knowing these are tough decisions, it is my hope that those that lead this effort will work together to make the best humane decisions possible with the utmost respect for the deer.
Thank you~
Watching wildlife up close is part of what makes McCall so special. Interacting with the animals is a privilege. Some people don't understand the danger of does with fawns or the harm
in feeding wildlife. The animals shouldn't be punished due to the ignorance of a few.
We firmly oppose the removal or destruction of town deer. We do support community education on safe living among wildlife.
I'm against this measure. People and wildlife can coexist.
Please do not kill local deer population.
The town deer are apart of the community and be should be protected. Eradication would be a gross overstep of our stewardship responsibilities. People need to be held accountable for
feeding the deer, yet the deer themselves should be permitted to live and find shelter to have their young in this community.
Seeing the deer in McCall is something we enjoy.
NO, NO, NO! The City council and the Mayor's job is to serve the town of McCall to the best of its ability. THIS IS NOT IT! Those of us who live here but may not have YET have changed
our residency although we own homes and property and PAY TONS of TAXES that support the town of McCall would like representation as well. We have spoken out against the proposal to
remove the deer and you are not listening. WHY? Why do just a few “in power” think they KNOW what is BEST when the people they represent have made it clear they do not. LISTEN TO AAAALLLLL
OF YOUR PEOPLE AND DO YOUR JOB. LEAVE THE DEER ALONE. Also, seriously you want to make feeding a deer the same criminal offense as a DUI, who decided that punishment fits the crime?
We have never fed the deer ( except when they eat my garden) but a Misdemeanor on a second offense for feeding a deer? THAT IS OUTRAGEOUS!
Please let the deer stay in McCall
This is so sad. The deer have been here forever. They are iconic. Do not do this. It is akin to Nevada rounding up horses and burros. This is wrong!!!!
Do not eradicate the town deer!!! They add to what makes McCall, McCall….
If people quit feeding the deer, the problem will fix itself. I am against relocating the deer. It is part of the charm of McCall. The cost and time it would take to trap & relocate
them is a waste of our dollars.
We had lots of out of town family here over the 4th of July and when told about this proposal they could not believe it! Our deer are part of the charm of McCall. They said they couldn’t
imagine visiting here and not seeing the deer roam our beautiful town.
Absolutely unthinkable!! I hope our City Council, that we voted for, will do the right thing!!
This is unbelievable that this is even proposed.
I can’t believe that people in McCall would be for any of this. The deer are part of the beauty of the Town. It brings such a good feeling to me to see them in town when visiting.
The fish and game should be ashamed and local authority too.
Do not remove the dear, They are part of what make McCall special. We have friends up almost every weekend and they adore the dear.
You shouldn't eradicate the deer or wildlife.
We are writing you again to voice our concerns with the current proposal if the no feeding ordinance and removal of town deer.
This proposal has not been properly researched and studied to make such a rash decision at this time. We have now put in weeks of research, calling Valerie Mathewson who is the Senior
Urban Wildlife Conservation Coordinator for the city of Boulder Colorado. During our conversation she stated that trying to remove deer by trapping rarely is successful. She said that
the city of Boulder has a strictly enforced no feed ordinance. The city of Boulder Colorado has done extensive research on this issue and have learned to coexist with these animals.
Valerie also mentioned that they strictly enforce speed limits in the city of Boulder Colorado as that has been the main issue with deer getting hit in the past. Valerie also said that
she would be glad to speak to our fishing game manager and our chief of police if they would like to call her she can help them with the information they have gathered through research.
Her phone number is area code 303-441-3004.
My husband has a book called heart and blood living with deer in America by author Richard Nelson and it speaks of Different areas in the United States that he has studied that trapping
and trying to relocate these town deer is rarely successful. We would suggest that you borrow our Copy of this book or go online to amazon.com and order one in paperback. It is filled
with much information on the different areas of the US where people have learned how to coexist with the deer.
We are all for a no feed ordinance in the city of Mccall but not an all or nothing at the expense of these beautiful animals. We have moved in and encroached on their land where they
have been for years and years and in spite of all the building and an influx of people these deer have stayed and it’s not because people fed them. We have lived in our home for over
40 years, we have seen the same migration path throughout this town for all these years. Even with the incredible building going on across the street from us, these deer still follow
the same trails as they did 40 years ago. The reason We believe these deer have stayed is that people have moved here and put in beautiful lawns with ornamental bushes shrubs and trees
and lots of yummy flowers that they eat on in the fall and at one point winter came in these deer didn’t leave not knowing there would be no food for them in the winter.
We feel that if the police department received over 40 calls last winter about deer getting hit by cars and killed or injured, it was not because someone fed these deer it was because
the speed limits were not enforced in this town. Davis Avenue is one of the busiest streets in this town and we rarely see any police patrolling it. We will offer once again, any time
the police are welcome to sit in our driveway and ticket the people that speed past our house and probably would make enough money to fund an officer just for this purpose. The only
thing that has slowed the traffic down in this town unfortunately are the deer. So for the chief of police and the fishing game Manager in Mccall to put the Blame totally on residents
that feed deer and not look at the bigger picture is not only unfounded but on research and unsubstantiated.
After researching relocation of dear success rates, it is highly unlikely that this would be a successful way to deal with these deer. Why don’t we put in a no feet ordinance and give
it a year or two and see how many deer survive the winter. It is our honest belief that the intentions of relocating them would be more humane it’s nothing but propaganda to get you’re
under researched plan passed. We feel it is the councils Duty to listen to the voices of the citizens of McCall not just the ones that call and complain because their tulips got eaten
or somebody sped down the street and hit a deer.
I don't want the deers euthanized.
Translocating, or killing the deer population in McCall is a horrible idea. They will just come back anyway. McCall is known for deer roaming the city. Tourists love to see them. They
are not the problem you make them out to be. I am adamantly against this proposal.
Please don’t do this. We moved here because of the friendly people, the deer, the foxes, birds, etc. I don’t like my plants eaten by the deer so I plant other things.If I see a deer
in the street, I slow down. I don’t feed them. Estes Park, Gardiner, MT and West Yellowstone, MT have ELK in the streets and they handle it.
Completely and totally wrong. Are you insane?
So disappointed this is even being considered. The deer are what is so special living here. What is the city thinking?
More research and full plan needs disclosed. Deer are part of McCall. Eradicating them would not be favorable.
Leave the deer alone !!! They are a part of McCall and what me and all of my family looks forward to seeing when we visit McCall very often. To whom they “Nuisance” they are the ones
that need to get the hell out of McCall. #SAVETHEDEER
Please do not endanger or harm or remove the wonderful creatures/deer that roam in the McCall community! Not a good idea! They need to be protected!
I am opposed to the complete eradication of our towns deer population. If they are sick and diseased, is there nothing that can be done to help them? Our feral and lost cats are fed,
protected and veterinary services are rendered. Our canine population is cared for in the same way. Millions and millions of dollars are spent on the education and protection of the
fish species that we share our rivers, lakes and streams with as well as the many animals that live in the forests and mountains surrounding us.
Cats, dogs, fish and the abundance and array of wildlife we cohabit this area with are very much a part of us and we are of them. If the only coexistent management solution was to kill
or simply get rid of our strays, fish or game because they were deemed a nuisance, a pet peeve or of no value, it is the humans who have become the sick and diseased.
Animals have inherent value and worth and merit our respect and acknowledgment. Growing up with a pet has been shown to instill a deeper understanding of responsibility and accountability
in us. The relationship we foster with our companion animals also teaches us compassion for all animals as it forces us to look beyond our needs and imagine those of another who is
vastly different from ourselves.
Our towns deer population has a treasured history, value and worth and thus merits our respect. The valuable life lessons we gained as children when caring for our domesticated pets
are just as important and pertinent today. At the heart of it all is the undeniable fact that our purpose and existence becomes so much healthier, happier and rewarding when we share
our lives and habitats with all creatures great and small.
I am appealing to the sensibilities of our city council to slow down. Please avoid a hurried, reckless or irresponsible decision. Instead, seek a humane, sensible and quality resolution.
After all, these deer are our citizens too. The same respectful and thoughtful process you lend to those with a voice must be compassionately given to those without.
Respectfully submitted,
Janet Meckel
I really hate to see all the deer go. It’s been so fun to have them through the years. If they are thinned out because of sickness maybe okay. However to take all the deer away seems
wrong. What are we teaching the younger generation? Plus euthanizing them is very wrong . We are sending the wrong message about McCall. Wildlife is part of McCall. Please be kind to
wild life. Let’s send the message that wildlife is important to McCall.
I can’t believe our public officials have nothing better to do than try to rid McCall of one of the biggest draws our town has ..the deer.. I imagine we will make national news protesting
this if it passes.
Although I no longer live in Idaho, I am a 3rd generation Idahoan. Our family had a cabin on Payette Lake for 75 years, and I spent my childhood there. When I married & had a family,
we continued to go each year, traveling from Oregon, until we sold the cabin in 2013. Please continue to allow the deer! This is THEIR home - HUMANS moved in! They may eat vegetation
but are otherwise harmless. McCall is in the mountains, in the forest. There will be deer, as well as all sorts of other animals. I don’t believe the majority of people want to see
the deer gone. Please make the right decision. For the deer & the residents.
Abundant wildlife is a major factor of what draws people to this area, this passing would have a large negative impact on this. Please do not allow this to pass.
Please don't remove the deer from town it's one of my favorite things to do is see then out and about. I think you will be doing a huge disservice to the town, it's part of the experience
of McCall
Absolutely outrageous!!
We encroach on their habitat and yet they’re the problem? What a joke! Whoever thought this up is a complete moron!
The deer live with us in town. I know they cause some issues but we have less issues with them than people. I personally like our town deer. Focus on mosquitos?
This proposal is wrong, and will not be a good thing for the city. If carried through, it will put a dark stain on this city's reputation that may never go away. "Welcome to McCall,
the city that kills deer"...
Trapping and relocating deer puts a tremendous amount of stress on the animals. Based on information from other states, a large number die during the relocation process.
A much better program is a city code which allows for code enforcement to issue citations to persons who feed wildlife.
The deer need to stay in McCall City Limits
I think it is a shame you are considering exterminating wildlife from McCall. I’m a tourist and your spectacular natural resources, wildlife included, is one of the main attractions.
I believe the eradication of the deer is wrong. When we owned a home here in McCall, I enjoyed seeing the deer in my yard, even though it meant bringing in my bird feeders every evening
and planting plants they did not like to eat. The deer were here first and we are the ones who invaded their home.
Quit wasting tax payers money. It seems way to much time and money is spent on NON PROBLEMS Stop wasting resources on this issue and solve some real problems We are watching and will
VOTE accordingly
Thanks. WAYNE SAWDY 26 year tax payer and voter
100% against the ordinance and the amendment as proposed. Also 100% against the Idaho Department of Fish and Game plan to capture and relocate the resident deer population. Our Chief
of Police needs to worry about enforcing the existing laws that are REAL problems. Our city government needs to worry about business critical to the City of McCall and LISTEN to the
residents and their constituents. Can you even HEAR the voters?
I am against the ordinance to relocate and euthanize the deer in McCall.
Leave the deer alone. They are a welcome part of McCall for most people. The vocal minority should not be mistaken to represent the majority. Fish and game is always wanting to meddle
in such affairs and they should stay out of it. Let McCall be McCall and not McCalifornia as I understand it is starting to be called these days by many locals. Good grief, there are
far bigger concerns that aren't being addressed but this is so much like the way McCall is going these days. So many influences and attitudes that are forever changing our beloved Idaho
by those that came here from elsewhere.
I am writing to you with an impassioned PLEA to please table these two proposals regarding the town deer of McCall. If you cannot separate the two proposals, then please table them
until further educated studies and clear, critical thinking can take place.
Mayor Giles: You were quoted in last weeks Star News as saying:
"Giles said he would not vote for a feeding ban if the effort to trap and relocate the deer was not tied to it. “That’s not in my moral code of ethics,” Giles said.
Your "moral code of ethics" seems grossly out of place in the above statement.
Your moral code of ethics should not have anything to do with the conjoining of the two proposals. Rather one would think that you have a moral code of ethics to LISTEN TO THE PEOPLE
WHO ELECTED YOU. One would think that you have the moral code of ethics to listen to the 350+++ residents, 2nd homeowners, tourists and visitors who resoundedly voted AGAINST the proposal
of trapping, transporting and euthanizing of our town deer to extinction. You have a moral code of ethics to HELP the wildlife here in our mountain town of McCall Idaho, in which you
reside, not HURT them. Please do the right thing and vote against these two proposals as they stand and go back to the drawing board. There is no need for rush or hurry on something
that will FOREVER change the fabric of McCall for current generations and future generations alike.
Mike Maciaszek, on January 9th, 2020 you wrote the below words on your Facebook page after taking the oath of becoming a McCall city council member:
This town, the lake, mtns, and community we love, take pride in, and that we will fight to preserve and protect, it’s worth it. I am honored and humbled to have taken the oath of office
this evening to serve our community on our city council. McCall is a treasure, we care about this place. We look out for each other. We are passionate about our way of life, have deep
roots and culture and I am proud to be here. Next council meeting is 5:30pm Jan 23 - your voice matters, and there’s an opportunity at every meeting to share your thoughts, concerns,
or maybe just to shed light on something good in our town you value. Thanks!
Specifically you stated: "YOUR VOICE MATTERS".
I hope you uphold this oath and passion today as well as in the future.
I My voice matters...I OUR voice matters, then you will also vote against these two proposals as they stand.
You will table these proposals until further studies can be done and further expertise brought in to make the RIGHT choice for McCall , its residents, its 2nd homeowners, its tourists
and visitors now and into the future for all generations to come.
PLEASE do not move forward with this vote tonight.
PLEASE bring in more experts from the State of Idaho, from our neighboring mountain States who have learned how to LIVE WITH WILDLIFE, NOT ERADICATE IT.
Please let McCall learn from them.
Regan Berkley is but one individual who should NOT be making this decision for the entire town of McCall.
In my opinion she is NOT an expert. I have spent the last 4 weeks talking with and learning from the States of Utah, Wyoming, Montana, Idaho and Oregon's FISH AND GAME WILDLIFE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS, WILDLIFE BIOLOGISTS AND WILLIFE CONFLICT MANAGERS, that this process of trapping, relocating know as "translocation" DOES NOT WORK.
ALL of them states that MORE than 50% of the deer die during this process (not 4% as Regan quoted recently).
That does NOT sound like an "expert".
Why are we allowing Regan to make policy and set precedent in McCall when she is likely passing through and looking for a notch on her belt?
Why is our local police chief involved at all?
More than one Fish and Game Wildlife Officer and Managers made the same statement to me and that was "your local police chief has NO BUSINESS being involved in this . Period. CONTUED
NEXT PAGE.
(continued from prior page 1).
Why are we allowing Justin to set policy and set precedent for our town of McCall when he is likely passing through and will not even live here in a year or two.
PLEASE consider forming a task force of real professionals and experts across the board regarding living with wildlife. Is has been done and is being done NOW in our neighboring states.
These Fish and Game Wildlife EXPERTS from our neighboring state have also said that the deer WILL NOT STARVE AND DIE THIS WINTER OR ANY WINTER if a "no-fee" ordinance is put in place.
Read that again. THE DEER WILL NOT STARVE AND DIE IF A NO FEE ORDINANCE IS PUT IN PLACE.
I heard that resoundedly from ALL experts who I spoke with in our neighboring states.
The few residents who might feed the deer physically and financially cannot feed a herd of 60, let alone the estimated 150+ quoted by Regan a life-sustaining diet.
The deer are finding their natural food sources in and around our town in the middle of winter.
I have 30 photos of deer in my yard, on the golf course and around town to prove this. They stand on their hind legs to reach tree branches and moss. They stand on snow plow piles
to reach food sources.
They eat the crabapple and other fruit trees throughout town. They eat residents spent gardens. They eat pumpkins, they eat dead leaves, sticks and brush.
THEY WILL NOT STARVE. This is not coming from me and my personal opinion, but that of the TRUE EXPERTS from fish and game in our neighboring states. Even our own Nez Perce Tribal Wildlife
Manager stated this.
These are wildlife professionals who area seasoned. Who have been doing this for 20, 30, 40 years. Not just a few years as Regan has.
PLEASE listen to the EXPERTS.
Finally. Begin an Education Campaign to educate residents and visitors on the dangers of feeding deer and all wildlife. Let that campaign be ongoing like all other mountain state surrounding
us do.
Increase signage, brochures and other materials to educate, not eradicate.
PLEASE, City Council and Mayor of McCall: LISTEN TO YOUR CONSTITUENTS. LISTEN TO THOSE WHO TRUSTED YOU WHEN THEY VOTED FOR YOU. LISTEN TO THOSE WHO PAY YOUR SALERIES.
AND PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE LEAVE A LEGACEY OF SMART CONSERVATION, NOT ERADICATION.
Thank you.
I am 100% against any type of interferance with the town deer.
Remember this, the Deer are not invading your property you are invading theirs, you should feel fortunate and blessed that they tolerate your presence , try sitting back and enjoying
the splender of nature and not big city life with traffic and buildings , we have lots of deer around town in Council and they are a joy to see even the Bears that sometimes come through,
I would suggest you should all go back to where you came from and stop trying to change Idaho!
Against
The deer in McCall are part of the charm myself and other people look forward to when visiting (quite frequently since I live so close) McCall. It would be a travesty for you eradicate
them. I can’t agree with your proposal at all. The eradication of all deer and wildlife is a terrible idea. We are bright, intelligent people. I’m sure you can put your efforts into
finding a better solution than destruction.
I vote “NO”!
Let's educate ourselves on how to live with our wildlife rather than destroy it.
Please figure out how to live with our deer!
Leave the deer to roam. If you need to take action, fine the HUMANS for feeding them.
The McCall Deer need to be left alone.
Please tell me this is a bad dream!!! Euthanizing the town deer? Relocating the town deer? I lived in McCall for 11 years and it warmed my heart every time I would see them in town.
They are a tourist attraction! Why on earth would you do this? The only people who would be injured would be the deer molesters.
I could not find the wildlife amendment information. However I heard this amendment was to relocate the deer from McCall and or put them down. I understand the McCall people are liberal
for the most part. Those deer have been there for years without problems so why is it a problem now? What will be your next move McCall council members. Defund the police so you can
be more like your California counter parts? Take care of your wildlife and land stop giving to those part time residence who complain of everything yet we're with silver spoons in hand.
I dont feel like the deer are enough of a problem to justify killing them. If it became illegal to feed them, then the deer would eventually move themselves to where they could naturally
feed.
We are completely against eradicating our town deer. There are better options other states do which is outlined in their F&G Wildlife Management Plans. We do not understand your unwillingness
to take the time to put together a better plan. Your desire to only listen to one or two people underscores your close mindedness and fear. The research and plans are out there, but
yet you refuse to consider a more humane option. We have a chance to make this a win for the town and the deer. Those of you, who through your vote, choose to allow the town deer to
be eradicated, will lose our support and vote in the next election.
Respectfully,
Jim Staup
Debra Staup
Angela Staup
I am completely against this proposal. We have been coming to McCall for many generations and one of the highlights for my children and grandchildren was being able to see deer outside
the house. The wildlife of Idaho are what makes this the greatest place on earth to live. By you folks considering the "eradication", and yes, you can say that it is only the "ban
of feeding the deer" that is proposed, but c'mon, that is just the beginning of what horrific things are to come. If you pass this, you will have given Fish and Game the green light
to "eradicate" what we love about McCall. Clearly, the council is not looking out for the best interests of the people who elect them and reelect them. I firmly believe the police
chief, council, and fish and game are hell bent on pushing this through to what end??? Stop the insanity now, and shelve this ridiculous idea and remember that the wildlife was where
first and who are you as a "council" to think you should mess with nature??
Don't you, as a city council, have more important things to do than to disturb mother nature? Put your time and efforts into fixing things that need fixing. Deer in McCall is not one
of them! Remember, you ARE elected - that can be fixed too.
Leave the deer alone. We don't want them gone. They make McCall special and multiple generations of our family has enjoyed them and would like to continue to do so. Take care of business
that needs tended to - and leave the deer alone.
Horrible
Disgusting
Stupid
Hateful and disgusting that this is being considered
Why is this conversation even taking place!!!??
Dear Council Members,
I think you should dismiss the proposed wildlife ordinance and work with concerned community members to develop effective alternatives to manage this situation; such as diligent traffic
control, passing sensible ordinances that manage or prohibit the feeding of time over time so they don't starve and can return to natural feeding patterns and migration, and most important
- educating our citizenry and our visitors about how to embrace and live among our wildlife.
Thank you for this opportunity to comment on this important issue.
Toni Slaymaker
What has happened to the public, you come to the mountains to enjoy such things as wildlife.I think if you do away with the deer..it would be a sad day for sure...in a lot of mountain
communities , they work with the wildlife...lets say as a example Estes Park, Co.
Use your wonderful deer as a tourist tool....
After all all you infringed on the wildlife..they were here first before you were.
Please do not pass this ordinance. Let the deer continue to live in McCall as they always have.
This is a heartbreak. Enforce the speed limits and add more wildlife crossing signs.
Leave the deer alone. It's one of the better things to see when going to McCall. The population moves into their habitat so now the population needs to get rid of them. If you don't
like the natural surroundings of McCall, go live in the "big" cities. Take your vacations somewhere else. Take your city thinking back to the city. The deer herds are part of what
makes up McCall and great place to visit. They don't bother anyone. They are wild animals and should be left alone.
Greetings,
I appreciate you all reading my letter at the last meeting. I hope you have all taken the time to consider the majority comments you received against the removal of the deer and that
you have each taken some time to research and look at the precedents set by wildlife management agencies across North America.
I, and many others, understand that feeding deer, like all wildlife, is inappropriate. Let’s start with citing and enforcing this to deter the inappropriate behavior of humans. Again,
I would implore for our wildlife managers to communicate and educate the public, locals and tourists alike.
I am against removing the deer, an indigenous species, from our community because of human caused problems. The lack of accountability by humans is disappointing and punishing the victims
of our poor choices is at best unethical.
Let’s take reasonable steps toward deterring poor behavior and educate the public.
Thank you for your time.
I grew up in McCall in the 70s and 80s LEAVE THE DEER ALONE They have more rights to be there then ANY HUMAN
I am in support of a feeding ban. We, as humans, should not interfere with the natural way wildlife are to live and in feeding the deer, people have changed that. I grew up in this region
and work in McCall and until about 10-15 years ago, did not see herds of deer roaming towns. I actually witnessed someone at Riteaid throw feed out for them in front of the store. This
needs to stop. It makes me mad because this is not caring for them and in allowing deer to become accustomed to people and cars is harmful. Please pass the ordinance.
I am against any type of "removal" of ANY wildlife in the city of McCall.