Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutBay Property Meeting Packet 08.22.23Town of Brewster 2198 Main St., Brewster, MA 02631 bppc@brewster-ma.gov (508) 896-3701 Bay Property Planning Committee Meeting Agenda 2198 Main Street, Brewster, MA 02631 August 22, 2023 at 4:00 PM This meeting will be conducted in person at the time and location identified above. This means that at least a quorum of the members of the public body will attend the meeting in person and members of the public are welcome to attend in person as well. As a courtesy only, access to the meeting is also being provided via remote means in accordance with applicable law. Please note that while an option for remote attendance and/or participation is being provided as a courtesy to the public, the meeting/hearing will not be suspended or terminated if technological problems interrupt the virtual broadcast or affect remote attendance or participation, unless otherwise required by law. Members of the public with particular interest in any specific item on this agenda, which includes an applicant and its representatives, should make plans for in-person vs. virtual attendance accordingly. Members of the public who wish to access the meeting may do so in the following manner: Please click the link below to join the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84863561303?pwd=bjhQazV3Y0NaN0dESk1LUmxmbGJCdz09 Passcode: 467353 US: +1 312 626 6799 or +1 929 436 2866 Webinar ID: 898 0232 5739 Passcode: 467353 When required by law or allowed by the Chair, persons wishing to provide public comment or otherwise participate in the meeting, may do so by accessing the meeting remotely, as noted above. Additionally, the meeting will be broadcast live, in real time, via Live broadcast (Brewster Government TV Channel 18), Livestream (livestream.brewster-ma.gov), or Video recording (tv.brewster-ma.gov). Please note that the Committee may take official action, including votes, on any item on this agenda. Members: Amanda Bebrin, Chair (Vision Planning Committee) Katie Miller Jacobus, Vice Chair (At Large) Karl Fryzel, Clerk (At Large) Mary Chaffee, Select Board David Whitney, Select Board Patricia Hughes, Natural Resources Commission Peter Johnson, At Large Caroline McCarley, At Large Clare O’Connor- Rice, At Large John Phillips, At Large Tom Wingard, Recreation Commission Town Staff: Peter Lombardi, Town Manager 1.Call to Order 2.Declaration of a Quorum 3.Meeting Participation Statement 4.Recording Statement: As required by the Open Meeting Law we are informing you that the Town will be video and audio taping as well as broadcasting this public meeting. In addition, if anyone else intends to either video or audio tape this meeting they are required to inform the Chair. 5.Public Announcements and Comment: Members of the public may address the Committee on matters not on the meeting’s agenda for a maximum of 3-5 minutes at the Chair’s discretion. The Committee will not reply to statements made or answer questions raised during public comment but may add items presented to a future agenda. 6.Follow-up on the Second Community Forum 7.Discuss Vernal Pool Report 8.Update on Shooting Range Remediation 9.Update on Brewster Community Pool 10.Review Upcoming Approved Interim Uses and Vote on Proposed New Interim Uses 11.Vote on Meeting Minutes: July 25, 2023 12.Discuss Future Meeting Agenda Items 13.Next Meetings: September 19, October 3, and October 17, 2023 14.Matters Not Reasonably Anticipated by the Chair 15.FYIs 16.Adjournment Date Posted:Date Revised:Received by Town Clerk: 08/17/2023 Town of Brewster Cape Cod Sea Camps Planning Date: Saturday, August 5th 2023 Attend one of three sessions: 1pm-2pm, 2pm-3pm or 3pm-4pm Location: Bay Property Dining Hall Welcome to Community forum #2! Community Forum #2 will be an engaging community event that shares preliminary planning scenarios for both the Bay and Pond properties based on resident feedback from Community Forum #1 and the survey. Each session will begin with introductory remarks. The remainder of the meeting will be a community workshop where residents will be invited to learn about the planning scenarios, indicate their preference and share feedback. This event will be the second public community workshop in a series of six that takes place over the course of the planning process. The Council on Aging will be offering rides to and from community forum sessions. Please call the Council on Aging at 508-896-2737 by Thursday August 3rd to arrange for transportation. For more details about the long-term planning process, information on Bay Property and Pond Property Planning Committee meetings and interim activities at both properties, please visit the project page, https://www.brewster-ma.gov/cape-cod-sea-camps-properties. To provide feedback to one of the committees, please email us at bppc@brewster-ma.gov (Bay property) or pppc@brewster-ma.gov (Pond property). The Bay Property will be open to the public to explore by foot anytime between 12pm-5pm Where we are in the process: What to expect: Community Forum Committee Meetings Town Vote Identify your priorities with the planning team Tune in to public meetings where community representatives workshop ideas with the planning team Vote to approve the comprehensive plans at the Spring 2024 Town Meeting Comprehensive Planning Document See the vision for the future of the Sea Camp Properties Previous Context Bay Visioning Committees Table Kid’s Table Bay Site Model Parking/ Community Center/ Housing What We Heard Previous Planning Bay & Pond Site Plan Pond Visioning Potential Partner Organizations (MA Audubon, BCT, & YMCA Cape Cod) Refreshments Long Pond Video Welcome! 25 23 28 82 31 28 ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING FIRST LIGHT BEACH LEGEND BLDG # BLDG NAME 25 HEALTH CENTER 23 OPEN AIR PAVILION 41 BOATHOUSE 57 CABIN 4 CABIN 82 CABIN 31 ARTS CENTER 71 CABIN 43 WESCOTT HOUSE 71 43 0ʼ100ʼ200ʼ 41 The following buildings are open for you to tour! 57 4 DINING HALL BOATHOUSE REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Welcome Station REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Welcome to the second community workshop for the Brewster Sea Camps! Today we will share potential planning scenarios for the future of the Bay and Pond properties and ask for you feedback. These planning scenarios are informed by the community feedback we received at the first community forum in May, and through the follow-up survey. We want your continued input and would like to know which planning scenarios you prefer. Following introductory remarks, we invite you to visit the different stations below and give feedback on the scenarios displayed at the Visioning stations: Welcome! Previous Context Bay Visioning Committees Table Kid’s Table Bay Site Model Parking/ Community Center/ Housing What We Heard Vision and Planning Bay & Pond Site Plan Pond Visioning Potential Partner Organizations (MA Audubon, BCT, & YMCA Cape Cod) Refreshments Long Pond Video Welcome! What we heard We appreciate your thoughts about your priorities for the future of both the Bay and the Pond Property! Thank You for sharing your feedback! 400~1,367Community Forum Attendees Survey Demographics Surveys Completed 72.5% were full time residents of Brewster, 26% were part-time residents 51.8% participants were over the age of 65 51.8% 72.5% 26% REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Create year round and seasonal affordable housing opportunities No housing. Recreation uses and community building only We need housing for summer J-1 employees Re-use of buildings for seasonal housing (workforce and municipal) On Housing On Re-use On Sustainability and Conservation Key Survey Feedback Key Forum Feedback Key Forum FeedbackKey Survey Feedback Key Survey Feedback Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum 31% would like to see seasonal workforce housing in a new building High interest in seasonal workforce housing and affordable Housing Protect natural habitat and water resources was the key opportunity of greatest interest General interest in re-using existing buildings as feasible 74% felt it was important to reuse or adapt buildings currently on the property 82% felt it was important to preserve and maintain the coastal ecosystem 50% would like to see seasonal workforce housing in existing buildings Additional housing opportunities was the Town Vision Plan goal that received the most stickers 75% felt it was important to protect natural habitat and water resources Forum #1 & Survey Feedback Bay Property Protect natural habitat and water resources Concerned about existing beach parking constructed so close to sensitive area Reduce lawn and replace with wildflowers Consider using the boathouse as an event venue or restaurant Minimize asphalt paving Treat invasive species to bring back wildlife Consider renting existing cabins to local businesses Keep the buildings with high re-use potential but remove the others Key Forum Feedback REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Great opportunity for pickleball courts! Need more in Brewster Expand recreation programs for kids Walking trails throughout the property We need a multi-generational community center Creative adult learning, lecture series, and arts center programming. Nature programs which do not interrupt others’ access Add a playground A walking trail with exercise stations to help seniors in town maintain their good health Create studio spaces for resident artists, create gallery space and performance space It is critical that the needs of our senior population be taken into consideration in all planning Support a pedestrian and/or bike path alongside existing roads Seek opportunities to make the property financially self-sustaining to the extent possible Consider revenue opportunities from use by third party organizations – community groups and arts On Recreation On Partnerships Other Key Forum and Survey Feedback On Community Programs Key Survey Feedback Key Survey Feedback Key Survey Feedback Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum 76% want to continue considering a partnership with Mass Audubon 52% would like to see adult and youth education classrooms 53% want to continue considering a partnership with the YMCA 51% would like to see a community center 49% would like to see a children’s day camp Bay Property Key Forum Feedback Key Forum Feedback A community center received the most stickers 92% want to continue considering a partnership with Mass Audubon Residents also expressed strong interest in a playground, beach access, event venue, indoor pool and walking trails 67% want to continue considering a partnership with the YMCA 74% would like to see walking trails 57% would like to see picnic areas 48% would like to see a playground Key Forum Feedback 50% would like to see the Recreation Department moved to the Bay Property Beach access, walking trails, and a playground were the recreational activities of highest interest Forum #1 & Survey Feedback REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA More hiking paths We need more biking and walking paths in Brewster Educational trails for appreciation of ecology and natural habitats ADA parking near pond On Passive Recreation On Access On Partnerships On Sustainability and Conservation Key Survey Feedback Key Forum Feedback Key Forum Feedback Key Forum FeedbackKey Survey Feedback Key Survey Feedback Key Forum Feedback Key Survey Feedback Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum Common suggestions included to improve access but limit parking and asphalt 68% feel it is important to increase accessibility to the pond property and its resources Pond Property Protect wetlands and rare species habitat Minimize asphalt. Gravel parking and roadsPreserve land for future water supply Provide parking at Route 137 for walk-in access only Several smaller parking areas instead of one big one 81% want to continue considering a partnership with Mass Audubon 82% want to continue considering a partnership with the BCT 95% want to continue considering a partnership with Mass Audubon 99% of respondents want to continue considering a partnership with the BCT 60% feel it is important to consider potential future town water supply 76% voted to set conservation areas to protect key habitat & water resources 60% voted to connect the property to the adjacent Long Pond Woodlands Protect key habitat and resources was the key opportunity of highest interest Creating open space and protecting water resources were the Town Vision Plan goals of highest interest 88% are interested in walking trails 56% are interested in bird watching 54% are interested in a picnic area Walking trails received the most stickers of all potential activities Creating open space and protecting water resources were the Town Vision Plan goals of highest interest Forum #1 & Survey Feedback REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Boat storage and boat access It’s in the water recharge district. Do not build anything there Additional moorings Small-scale housing along Rt. 137 with an appropriate buffer to the conservation and recreational areas Access to swimming in the pond Interest in new bathroom, boat house, small snack bar Kayak and boat storage Seasonal housing rental for seasonal employees Kayak/SUP storage for rent like other town beaches Snack bar On Waterfront Activities On New Building On Building Re-Use Key Survey Feedback Key Survey Feedback Key Forum Feedback Key Survey Feedback Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum Example Comments from Survey and Forum 79% are interested in beach access 52% want to see a nature residency in existing buildings 75% are interested in swimming 49% want to see a children’s day camp in existing buildings Pond Property 66% are interested in kayaking/ paddleboards Key Forum Feedback Swimming was the waterfront activity of highest interest 39% do not want to see any new buildings on the property Strong interest in preserving the land with some interest in incorporating affordable housing 34% want to see a new nature center on the property 27% want to see new seasonal workforce 24% want to see new affordable community housing 21% want to see new municipal housing Forum #1 & Survey Feedback REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Key Community Interests Bay Property • Expand opportunities for community use, including a potential community center (education, wellness, meetings, arts and cultural programs) • Provide accessible passive recreation opportunities for all ages and abilities (ADA compliant walking trails, picnic areas, outdoor gat hering areas) • Re-use existing buildings and amenities where feasible • Manage cost (revenue generation and phasing) • Build appropriate partnerships for activation and stewardship • Protect coastal resources and build sustainably (protect buffer zones and ecological resources, limit impermeable paving, restore native ecosystems) • Provide housing options, prioritizing J1 / seasonal workforce • Create experiences for younger generations (day camp, education, pla yground) and older generations (continuing education, programming, accessible resources) REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Key Community Interests Pond Property • Provide community beach access (swimming, kayaking and stand up paddle board) • Increase accessibility to the property and its resources (updat e roads, add ADA compliant walking trails, connection t o Long Pond Woodlands, small parking areas) • Establish conservation areas to protect key habitat and water resources • Re-use existing buildings where feasible (potential for nature cent er, children’s day camp, storage) • Consider a nature center and appropriately scaled af fordable/attainable housing • Build partnerships with BCT and Mass Audubon for activation and stewardship education, programming, accessible resources) Scenarios REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA PA S S I V E AC T I V E PUBLIC SECLUDED PUBLIC, ON MAIN DRIVE SECLUDED AND EASILY ACCESSED FROM DRIVE MOST SECLUDED/ PRIVATE & PASSIVE ZONE PRIVATE/SECLUDED BUT EASILY ACCESSIBLE FROM ROUTE 6A, EASILY SEPARATED FROM REST OF CAMPUS PUBLICLY ACCESSIBLE ON MAIN ROAD CABIN GLADE ARRIVAL FIELDS SECLUDED ZONE POND RESERVE WOODLAND BUFFER COASTAL DUNE BEACH CENTRAL CAMPUS MOST PUBLIC IN VISIBILITY AND ACCESS, MOST SUITABLE FOR ACTIVE RECREATION OVERALL EXISTING FRAMEWORK REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Option 1: Re-use Buildings for Seasonal Workforce Housing Option 2: New Year-round Housing (Affordable or Attainable) LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT Secluded Zone Bay Property LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT RENOVATE + REUSE CABINS AS SEASONAL WORKFORCE HOUSING THROUGH PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP (ADD SHARED BATH/ KITCHEN FACILITIES) MAINTAIN MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS MAINTAIN WOODED BUFFER FOR PRIVACY DEDICATED ACCESS, SEPARATED FROM REST OF CAMPUS (BUT MAINTAIN ABUTTER ACCESS) RENOVATE + REUSE SPRUCE HILL HOUSE AS CARETAKER/STAFF HOUSING ZONE FOR POTENTIAL FUTURE APPROPRIATELY SCALED NEW HOUSING THROUGH PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP (AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING) MAINTAIN MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS MAINTAIN WOODED BUFFER FOR PRIVACY DEDICATED ACCESS, SEPARATED FROM REST OF CAMPUS (BUT MAINTAIN ABUTTER ACCESS) REMOVE SPRUCE HILL & REWILD 0’0’100’100’200’200’ Day Care Center Cape Cod Children’s Place Eastham, MA Picnic Pavilion Camp Canaan New Canaan, CT REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Secluded Zone Bay Property Option 3: Family Zone Outdoor Theater Wolf Trap National Park for the Performing Arts Vienna, VA Artist Residency Providence Dune Shacks Providence, RI Artist Residency Haystack Mountain School of Crats Deer Isle, MA Option 4: Arts/Science/Nature Programs LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PICNIC AREA AND PLAYGROUND - DAY CAMP - AFTER SCHOOL PROGRAMS MAINTAIN MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS MAINTAIN WOODED BUFFER FOR PRIVACY DRIVE REMAINS CONNECTED TO REST OF CAMPUS. ESTABLISH TRAIL CONNECTIONS TO SPRUCE HILL DRIVE REMAINS CONNECTED TO REST OF CAMPUS. ESTABLISH TRAIL CONNECTIONS TO SPRUCE HILL - DAY CARE CENTER - TEEN CENTER (RENOVATE + REUSE SPRUCE HILL HOUSE) RE-USE AMPHITHEATER FOR PERFORMANCES - ARTIST CABINS - RENTALS/RESIDENCIES - POP-UPS MAINTAIN WOODED BUFFER FOR PRIVACY RENOVATE + REUSE SPRUCE HILL HOUSE FOR ART/NATURE CLASSES, RESIDENCY, NATURE CENTER OR MUSEUM SCIENTISTS/EDUCATORS IN RESIDENCE (PARTNERSHIP WITH OUTSIDE ORGANIZATION) MAINTAIN MAINTENANCE FACILITY WITH PUBLIC EDUCATIONAL COMPONENT RELATED TO STEWARDSHIP 0’0’100’100’200’200’ REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Arrival Fields Bay Property Option 1: Community Center & Flexible Outdoor Gathering Option 2: Partial “Re-wild” * THERE ARE OTHER OPTIONS FOR THE COMMUNITY CENTER LOCATION PROPOSED ON THE CENTRAL CAMPUS BOARD Option 3: Recreation Focus LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT INCREASE PARKING CAPACITY INCREASE PARKING CAPACITY COMMUNITY GARDEN MAINTAIN UPPER FIELDS/ USE AS FLEXIBLE EVENT SPACE COMMUNITY ORCHARD OR VINEYARD TRAIL CONNECTIONS POLLINATOR MEADOW ZONE FOR NEW COMMUNITY CENTER (COA & REC) CONVERT UPPER FIELD TO TENNIS/PICKLEBALL/ BASKETBALL COURTS OVERFLOW PARKING MAINTAIN SPORTS FIELD FLEXIBLE OUTDOOR EVENT SPACE AND “TOWN COMMON” MAINTAIN SPORTS FIELD FLEXIBLE OUTDOOR EVENT SPACE AND “TOWN COMMON” ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING 0’0’0’100’100’100’200’200’200’ REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Central Campus Bay Property Option 1: Re-use and Extensively Renovate for Community Campus Option 2: New Community Center Anchors Community Campus Option 3: New Community Center and Expanded Recreation LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT HOUSING AREA LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT RENOVATE & RE-USE DINING HALL AS COA RENOVATE & RE-USE CABINS AS PICNIC PAVILIONS RENOVATE & RE-USE CABINS AS COMMUNITY MEETING SPACE RE-USE AS POOL PAVILION RE-USE AS POOL PAVILION PLAYGROUND SHORT TERM RENTALS RENOVATE & RE-USE CABINS AS RECREATIONAL STORAGE PLAYGROUND RE-USE AS POOL PAVILION RE-USE OUTDOOR POOL RE-USE OUTDOOR POOL RE-USE AS POOL STORAGE RE-USE AS POOL STORAGE RE-USE POOL PARKING EXPAND EXISTING POOL PARKING RE-USE ART CENTER RE-USE ART CENTER ZONE FOR NEW COMMUNITY CENTER (COA & REC) RENOVATE & RE-USE AS COMMUNITY STORAGE EXPANDED GATHERING SPACE FOR RECREATION (WITH BELOW GROUND SEPTIC INFRASTRUCTURE) REMOVE DINING HALL NEW PARKING ZONE FOR NEW COMMUNITY CENTER (COA & REC) FLEXIBLE GATHERING AREA/YOUTH RECREATION (WITH BELOW GROUND SEPTIC INFRASTRUCTURE) PICNIC PAVILION STAFF HOUSING RENOVATE & RE-USE FOR MUNICIPAL HOUSING (FIRE, POLICE, ETC.) PICNIC AND GATHERING (WITH BELOW GROUND SEPTIC INFRASTRUCTURE) EVENT PAVILION PICNIC/ EVENT PAVILION RENOVATE & RE-USE COMMUNITY MEETING SPACE STAFF HOUSING COMMUNITY GARDEN RENOVATE & RE-USE ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING AS REC DEPT. OFFICES RENOVATE & RE-USE ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING FOR B&B RE-USE OUTDOOR POOL RE-USE AS POOL STORAGE EXPAND EXISTING POOL PARKING RE-USE ART CENTER NEW REC COURTS (TENNIS, PICKLEBALL) 0’ 0’ 0’ 100’ 100’ 100’ 200’ 200’ 200’ REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Cabin Glade Bay Property Option 1: Remove Cabins and Restore Woodland and Trails Art and Event Space Cape Cod Museum of Art Dennis, MA Art Studio and Gallery Rental Chatham Art Center Chatham, MA Outdoor Theater Sea Camps Deer Isle, MA Option 2: Re-Use Cabins for Arts and Culture Campus LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT 0’100’200’0’100’200’ RELOCATE EXISTING PARKING & RESTORE COASTAL DUNE NEW BEACH PARKING TO REPLACE EXISTING REMOVE & RELOCATE ALL CABINS RESTORED WOODLAND & TRAILS PICNIC AREA FIRST LIGHT BEACH FIRST LIGHT BEACH DINING HALL REUSE BOATHOUSE FOR EVENTS & BOAT STORAGE REUSE BOATHOUSE FOR EVENTS OUTDOOR SCULPTURE GARDEN PEDESTRIAN WALKING PATH MEDITATIVE WOODLAND GARDEN RE-USE THEATER FOR PERFORMANCES RENOVATE & REUSE CABINS AS ART EVENTS/ MARKETS AND POP-UPS RENOVATE & REUSE CABINS AS ARTIST RESIDENCY/ RENTALS DINING HALL REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Bay Property Option 3: Revenue Generating Short-Term Rentals LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT Option 4: Re-Use Cabins for Seasonal Workforce Housing Cabin Glade LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT 0’0’100’100’200’200’ REUSE BOATHOUSE FOR BAR/RESTAURANT/ SNACK BAR/EVENTS (PARTNERSHIP) RE-USE BOATHOUSE FOR RENTALS/EVENTS REMOVE AND RELOCATE RENOVATE & REUSE EXISTING CABINS AS SEASONAL WORKFORCE HOUSING HAMMOCKS PEDESTRIAN WALKING PATH WITH EXERCISE STATIONS PEDESTRIAN WALKING PATH RENOVATE & REUSE EXISTING CABINS FOR SHORT TERM RENTALS PICNIC & PLAY AREA FIRST LIGHT BEACH FIRST LIGHT BEACH DINING HALL DINING HALL REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Woodland Buffer & Pond Reserve Bay Property Option 1: Expand Trails and Nature Based Education LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT Option 2: Expand Trails LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PRIVATE BENEFIT COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING,MAINTENANCE) REVENUE GENERATION RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES BUILDING RE-USE HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH PUBLIC BENEFIT PUBLIC/PRIVATE BENEFIT 0’100’200’0’100’200’ CONDUCT DUNE ENHANCEMENT ACTIVITIES TO IMPROVE DUNE STABILITY AND COASTAL RESILIENCY IMPROVEMENTS TO EXISTING ERODED TRAILS REMOVE THE REMAINING NORTHERLY TENNIS COURTS AND REPLACE WITH NATURAL VEGETATION TO INCREASE COASTAL RESILIENCY CONTINUE TO PROVIDE BEACH ACCESS FOR RESIDENTS EXISTING DOCK CONSIDERING SHORELINE CHANGE, PLAN FOR FURTHER INLAND BEACH PARKING IN THE LONG TERM TRAILS WITH EDUCATIONAL SIGNAGE ABOUT HISTORY & NATURE PICNIC AREA CONNECT TRAILS TO SPRUCE HILL CONDUCT DUNE ENHANCEMENT ACTIVITIES TO IMPROVE DUNE STABILITY AND COASTAL RESILIENCY IMPROVEMENTS TO EXISTING ERODED TRAILS REMOVE THE REMAINING NORTHERLY TENNIS COURTS AND REPLACE WITH NATURAL VEGETATION TO INCREASE COASTAL RESILIENCY CONTINUE TO PROVIDE BEACH ACCESS FOR RESIDENTS EXISTING DOCK CONSIDERING SHORELINE CHANGE, PLAN FOR FURTHER INLAND BEACH PARKING IN THE LONG TERM NEW NATURE CENTER (POTENTIAL MASS AUDUBON PARTNERSHIP) TRAILS WITH EDUCATIONAL SIGNAGE ABOUT HISTORY & NATURE NATURE RESIDENCY/PROGRAMMING PICNIC AREA FIRST LIGHT BEACH FIRST LIGHT BEACH CONNECT TRAILS TO SPRUCE HILL REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Pond Property Context Zone II Wellhead Protection Pond Property Context LONG POND PARCEL ZONE II DRINKING WATER PROTECTION AREA DRINKING WATER WELLS LEGEND LONG POND PARCEL TOWN OF BREWSTER BREWSTER CONSERVATION TRUST CONSERVATION RESTRICTION EXISTING TRAILS ZONE II WELLHEAD PROTECTION/DCPC MINIMAL ROAD IMPROVEMENTS 100’ WETLAND BUFFER ZONE EDUCATE ACCESS CONSERVE (BCT & MASS AUDUBON) HOUSING HC P POND PROPERTY (66 ACRES) HOUSING ~10 ACRES CONSERVE ~54 ACRES ACCESS ~1 ACRE EDUCATE ~1 ACRE PUBLIC PARKING (PERMEABLE) AND BIKE RACKS FOR TRAIL AND BEACH ACCESS ~0.4 MILES TO PUBLIC BEACH ZONE FOR AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING WITH PARKING LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS (KIDS NATURE CAMP & RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES) PUBLIC BEACH WITH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE ADA ACCESSIBLE PARKING AND DROP-OFF ZONE REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Hybrid Housing/Conservation Option Pond Property LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PUBLIC ACCESS (BEACH PARKING) CONSERVATION AREA REVENUE GENERATION HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING, MAINTENANCE) • AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING ALONG ROUTE 137 • MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMMING AT POND • LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH WITH BOAT STORAGE (~0.4 MILES FROM PUBLIC PARKING AREA) • 1 SMALL PUBLIC PARKING AREA (8 SPOTS) • 1 ADA PARKING (~0.13 MILES FROM BEACH) • 54 ACRES OF PROPERTY CONSERVED (POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP WITH BCT & MASS AUDUBON) KAYAK/SUP STORAGE INCREASED TRAILS NEW ACCESSIBLE WALKING PATH FOR BEACH ACCESS TRAILS LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH AFFORDABLE/ATTAINABLE HOUSING MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS CONSERVATION ZONE WITH NATURE EDUCATION 0’150’300’ 100’ WETLAND BUFFER ZONE EDUCATE ACCESS RESIDENCY HC P P POND PROPERTY (66 ACRES) RESIDENCY ~20 ACRES HOUSING ~10 ACRES CONSERVE ~34 ACRES ACCESS ~1 ACRE EDUCATE ~1 ACRE PUBLIC PARKING (PERMEABLE) AND BIKE RACKS FOR TRAIL AND BEACH ACCESS - ART, SCIENCE OR NATURE RESIDENCY - SHORT TERM RENTAL (POTENTIALLY RELOCATED CABINS FROM BAY PROPERTY) CONSERVE (BCT & MASS AUDUBON) ~0.4 MILES TO PUBLIC BEACH HOUSING ZONE FOR AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING WITH PARKING CONSERVATION ZONE WITH NATURE EDUCATION LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE NEW ACCESSIBLE WALKING PATH FOR BEACH ACCESS INCREASED TRAILS REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Housing, Revenue + Conservation Option Pond Property LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PUBLIC ACCESS (BEACH PARKING) CONSERVATION AREA REVENUE GENERATION HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING, MAINTENANCE) • AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING ALONG ROUTE 137 • ART, SCIENCE OR NATURE RESIDENCY • MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMMING AT POND • LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH WITH BOAT STORAGE (~0.4 MILES FROM PUBLIC PARKING AREA) • 1 SMALL PUBLIC PARKING AREA (8 SPOTS) • 1 ADA PARKING (~0.13 MILES FROM BEACH) • 34 ACRES OF PROPERTY CONSERVED (POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP WITH BCT & MASS AUDUBON) NATURE RESIDENCY LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS (KIDS NATURE CAMP & RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES) PUBLIC BEACH WITH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE ADA ACCESSIBLE PARKING AND DROP-OFF ZONE 0’150’300’ AFFORDABLE/ATTAINABLE HOUSING 100’ WETLAND BUFFER ZONE EDUCATE ACCESS RESERVE HC P P P P RESERVE ~11 ACRES CONSERVE ~53 ACRES ACCESS ~1 ACRE EDUCATE ~1 ACRE POND PROPERTY (66 ACRES) SMALL PARKING AREAS ALONG IMPROVED DRIVE (PERMEABLE PAVING) AND BIKE RACKS WIDEN AND IMPROVE EXISTING ROAD TO ACCOMMODATE INCREASED VEHICULAR ACCESS MANTAIN GRAVEL DRIVE FOR DROP-OFF AND ADA PARKING ONLY POSSIBLE FUTURE MUNICIPAL OR UTILITY INFRASTRUCTURE (WITH 400’ SETBACK ZONE) CONSERVE (BCT & MASS AUDUBON) HIGH-USE PUBLIC BEACH SWIMMING DOCK WITH LIFEGUARD SUPERVISION INCREASED TRAILS NEW ACCESSIBLE WALKING PATH FOR BEACH ACCESS CONSERVATION ZONE WITH NATURE EDUCATION REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PUBLIC ACCESS (BEACH PARKING) CONSERVATION AREA REVENUE GENERATION HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING, MAINTENANCE) • POSSIBLE FUTURE MUNICIPAL USE OR UTILITY INFRASTRUCTURE WITH 400’ SETBACK ZONE • MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMMING AT POND • HIGH-USE PUBLIC BEACH WITH BOAT STORAGE, MOORING, SWIMMING DOCK (~0.4 MILES FROM CLOSEST PARKING AREA) • 4 SMALL DISPERSED PUBLIC PARKING AREA (32 SPOTS) • 1 ADA PARKING (~0.13 MILES FROM BEACH) • 56 ACRES OF PROPERTY CONSERVED (POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP WITH BCT & MASS AUDUBON) MOORING BOAT DOCK SNACK SHACK KAYAK/SUP STORAGE PARKING HIGH-USE PUBLIC BEACH Municipal Use + Conservation + High-Use Public Beach Option (Pond Property) ~0.9 MILES TO PUBLIC BEACH MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS (KIDS NATURE CAMP & RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES) PUBLIC BEACH WITH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE ADA ACCESSIBLE PARKING AND DROP-OFF ZONE 0’150’300’ 100’ WETLAND BUFFER ZONE EDUCATE EDUCATE ACCESS HC P CONSERVE ~53 ACRES ACCESS ~1 ACRE EDUCATE ~12 ACRES SMALL WELCOME/ NATURE CENTER SHARED WITH TOWN FOR COMMUNITY EDUCATION POND PROPERTY (66 ACRES) CONSERVE (BCT & MASS AUDUBON) LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE NEW ACCESSIBLE WALKING PATH FOR BEACH ACCESS MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS (KIDS NATURE CAMP & RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES) PUBLIC BEACH WITH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE ADA ACCESSIBLE PARKING AND DROP-OFF ZONE CONSERVATION ZONE WITH NATURE EDUCATION PARKING AREA (PERMEABLE PAVING). ~0.9 MILES TO PUBLIC BEACH MINIMAL ROAD IMPROVEMENTS INCREASED TRAILS REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Conservation + Education Option Pond Property LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PUBLIC ACCESS (BEACH PARKING) CONSERVATION AREA REVENUE GENERATION HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING, MAINTENANCE) • SMALL WELCOME / NATURE CENTER ALONG ROUTE 137 • MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMMING AT POND • LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH (~0.8 MILES FROM PUBLIC PARKING AREA) • 1 PUBLIC PARKING AREA (12 SPOTS) • 1 ADA PARKING (~0.13 MILES FROM BEACH) • 53 ACRES OF PROPERTY CONSERVED (POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP WITH BCT & MASS AUDUBON) LIMITED-USE PUBLIC BEACH SMALL WELCOME/NATURE CENTER TRAILS MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS 0’150’300’ 100’ WETLAND BUFFER ZONE EDUCATE ACCESS MEDIUM USE PUBLIC BEACH HC P P CONSERVE ~42 ACRES RESERVE ~11 ACRES HOUSING ~11 ACRES ACCESS ~1 ACRE EDUCATE ~1 ACRES POND PROPERTY (66 ACRES) RESERVE PUBLIC PARKING (PERMEABLE) AND BIKE RACKS FOR TRAIL AND BEACH ACCESS (~24 SPOTS). ~0.4 MILES TO PUBLIC BEACH POSSIBLE FUTURE MUNICIPAL OR UTILITY INFRASTRUCTURE (WITH 400’ SETBACK ZONE) CONSERVE (BCT & MASS AUDUBON) HOUSING ZONE FOR AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING WITH PARKING SMALL PARKING AREA FOR TRAIL ACCESS (~8 SPOTS). ~0.8 MILES TO PUBLIC BEACH MINIMAL ROAD IMPROVEMENTS CONSERVATION ZONE WITH NATURE EDUCATION SWIMMING DOCK WITH LIFEGUARD SUPERVISION NEW ACCESSIBLE WALKING PATH FOR BEACH ACCESS KAYAK/SUP STORAGE REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA • AFFORDABLE OR ATTAINABLE HOUSING ALONG ROUTE 137 • POSSIBLE FUTURE MUNICIPAL USE OR UTILITY INFRASTRUCTURE WITH 400’ SETBACK ZONE • MEDIUM-USE PUBLIC BEACH WITH BOAT STORAGE (~0.4 MILES FROM PUBLIC PARKING AREA) • MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMMING AT POND • 2 PUBLIC PARKING AREAS (32 SPOTS) • 1 ADA PARKING (~0.13 MILES FROM BEACH) • 45 ACRES OF PROPERTY CONSERVED (POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP WITH BCT & MASS AUDUBON) Hybrid Housing/Conservation/ Municipal Use Option (Pond Property) LOW LOW LOW LOW LOW PUBLIC ACCESS (BEACH PARKING) CONSERVATION AREA REVENUE GENERATION HOUSING AREA HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH HIGH COST (INFRASTRUCTURE, BUILDING, MAINTENANCE) INCREASED TRAILS MEDIUM USE PUBLIC BEACH PARKING MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS MASS AUDUBON PROGRAMS (KIDS NATURE CAMP & RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES) PUBLIC BEACH WITH KAYAK/SUP STORAGE ADA ACCESSIBLE PARKING AND DROP-OFF ZONE 0’150’300’ AFFORDABLE/ATTAINABLE HOUSING REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Shared Community Parking Bay Property Parking Options Key Considerations USE PERMEABLE MATERIAL INCORPORATE PLANTING/ STORMWATER TREATMENT CONSIDER HEAT ABSORPTION Examples PARKING WITH PLANTING WOODED PARKING GRAVEL PARKINGRELOCATE BEACH PARKING (APROX. 36 PARKING SPACES) EXPANDED POOL PARKING CENTRAL TO RECREATION (APROX. 55 PARKING SPACES) SUPPORTS NEW COMMUNITY CENTER (APROX. 52 PARKING SPACES) EASY TO ACCESS (APROX. 74 PARKING SPACES) REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Dwelling Types Building Area Considerations Parking Demand Occupancy Examples Sites Considered 700 - 1,000 SF -could be realized with more minimal upgrades -requires added kitchen and bathroom facilities LOW access to off-site parking 1UNIT 700 - 1,000 SF -may require significant upgrades for winterization -requires added kitchen and bathroom facilities LOW 1UNIT access to off-site parking High Banks Resort Deer River, MN RE U S E NE W C O N S T R U C T I O N 1,300 - 2,500 SF -may require significant upgrades MEDIUM 1UNIT individual parking Seasonal Cabin Rental Full-Year Cabin Rental One Family Detached Mid-Density Multifamily Multi-Bedroom Congregate DormitoryMultifamily 2,500 - 5,000 SF -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site MEDIUM 2-4 UNITS group dedicated parking 2,000 - 5,000 SF -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site HIGH 5-8 Bedroom with shared facilities group dedicated parking 15,000 SF - 20,000 SF -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site HIGH 20-30 Bedroom with shared facilities group dedicated parking 2,500 SF - 50,000 SF -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site HIGH 4-30 UNITS group dedicated parking Cape Cod Cottage Brewster, MA NYS Cabins and Cottages Wildwood State Park, NY Kimber Woods Housing Barnstable, MA Latham Center Group Housing Orleans, MA Latham Center Dormitory Orleans, MA Affordable Housing Orleans, MA Type Matrix of Dwelling Types 700 - 1,000 SF -could be realized with more minimal upgrades LOW access to off-site parking 1UNIT Dune Shacks Providence, RI Daytime Cabin Rental Cost $$- $$$$$$$$$$$$$-$$$$$-$$$$$$-$$$$$$$$-$$$$$ * $ = approx. 100$/SF Bay Property REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Community Uses Building Area 700 - 1,000 SF 700 - 1,000 SF 2,000 - 10,000 SF 8,000-15,000 SF Picnic Pavilion Seasonal Artist Gallery Small-Scale Nature Center Council on AgingType 5,000 - 10,000 SF Event Venue Considerations Parking Demand Examples -could require demolition and renovation of enclosed structures LOW access to off-site parking Camp Canaan Rock Hill, SC -could be realized with minimal upgrades -could be realized with minimal upgrades -could require significant upgrades -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site LOW - MEDIUM access to off-site parking or dedicated group parking HIGH dedicated group parking or access to off-site parking LOW - MEDIUM dedicated group parking HIGH dedicated group parking Cape Cod Art Center Chatham, MA Flax Pond Lorusso Lodge Yarmouth, MA Green Briar Nature Cen- ter East Sandwich, MA The Center at Sachem Rock East Bridgewater, MA Matrix of Community Uses RE U S E NE W C O N S T R U C T I O N Community Center Community Center with Recreation Nature Center 15,000-24,000 SF12,000 - 15,000 SF 25,000 - 32,000 SF -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site -would need to be appropriately scaled to the site MEDIUM - HIGH dedicated group parking HIGH dedicated group parking HIGH dedicated group parking 30,000 SF 15,000 SF HIGH VISIBILITY RE- PLACS 15,000 SF Harwich Community Center Harwich, MA Council on Aging Chatham, MA Wellfleet Bay Audobon Sanctuary Nature Center Wellfleet, MA Potential Sites for New Community Center Considerations for New Community Center Multi-purpose Room Gym Reception Parking Scale Comparison of 32,000 SF Harwich Community Center on the Arrival Fields of the Bay Property. Harwich Community Center offers a gym, meeting rooms, multi-purpose rooms, and other amenities with a 32,000 SF facility. Cost $$$$$$$$$$-$$$$$$$-$$$$$$$-$$$$$ * $ = approx. 100$/SF $$$-$$$$ Bay Property REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Community Center & COA Bay Property Describe what you would want to see in a community center. What does it include? Tell us with your stickers! Fitness Classroom 1,200 SF Office 130 SF Classroom 1,300 SF Fitness Center 2,000 SF Meeting Room 750 SF Medical Exam Room 130 SF 8-Lane Swimming Pool 6,275 SF Gym 7,600 SF Game Room 450 SF Programming Youth sports After school programs Special events Fitness and exercise classes Educational classes and conferences Camps Adult sports Weekend retreat for all ages Plays/dramatic production Community dance Nature walks/hikes Baking and cooking classes Arts and crafts Senior Day Habilitation Program Senior Culinary Wellness Program Senior Professional Services Senior Social Service Agencies Facilities Fitness Center Fitness classrooms Sport courts Walking track Shared meeting rooms Multi-purpose room Game room Educational and activity rooms Kitchen/Cafeteria Indoor pool Medical exam rooms Offices Workspaces Examples Multi-purpose room 1,300 SF Existing Dining Hall 11,000 SF Vision and Planning REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Our Process Throughout the year-long comprehensive planning process, the Town will undertake an equitable and inclusive planning and decision-making process to create a shared vision for the future of the former Sea Camp’s Properties. Project Phases Community Forum Phase 1: DISCOVERY Build an understanding of existing site conditions and define opportunities and constraints related to built and natural systems. Begin an open conversation with community representatives and potential partners. Learn the community’s priorities and visions for the future of these properties. Define project principles that will guide design proposals in collaboration with the community, town, and committees. Develop preliminary scenarios for each property based on community feedback. Connect ideas and conversations with the community, town, and committees to refine one comprehensive plan for each property. Phase 3: COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING Committee Meetings Town Vote Identify your priorities with the planning team Tune in to public meetings where community representatives workshop ideas with the planning team Vote to approve the comprehensive plans at the Spring 2024 Town Meeting Phase 2: VISIONING Comprehensive Planning Document See the vision for the future of the Sea Camp Properties REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Vote to Purchase By the Numbers... Key considerations when planning for the future of these properties: When Brewster residents voted to approve the town’s purchase of these properties in 2021, the town agreed to consider both properties for a variety of potential uses. Long Pond Property uses to be considered include a public beach, recreation activities, conservation space, appropriately scaled community housing near Route 137, general municipal uses such as a town well, and partnerships with the Brewster Conservation Trust and Mass Audubon Society. Bay Property uses to be considered include a public beach, community center, various recreation facilities and courts, town offices, conservation, coastal resiliency, partnerships to expand services and offerings. • Recreation - Demand for an indoor gymnasium, indoor fitness/exercise space, outdoor (full-size) basketball court, inclusive playground (not located at a school), and additional pickleball/tennis courts exceeds current Town facilities • Open Space - About 1/3 of Brewster’s land is considered protected open space • Housing - 42% of Brewster’s housing stock is used for seasonal use - Between 2010-2018, Brewster experienced a decrease in households with low to moderate incomes - Brewster needs more affordable housing to meet the 10% State minimum goal • Population Age - The median age of Brewster’s population is 56.5 years - 14% of Brewster’s population is under 18; Brewster’s youth population is declining REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Town Vision Plan Community Character Coastal Management Water Resources Local Economy Open Space Governance Housing Community Infrastructure Sustain and foster Brewster’s historic setting, rural nature, small-town feel, and socially inclusive spirit. In the context of coastal change, preserve and protect Brewster‘s coastal resources and expand public access. Protect Brewster’s fresh water system to preserve high quality drinking water and maintain or improve the health of our ponds and marine watersheds. Promote a sustainable economy that builds on Brewster’s natural and human assets, addresses the needs of small businesses, and provides year-round employment for Brewster’s young families. Maintain and expand open space assets to provide public recreation, protect fragile natural habitat, and protect water resources. Create a more open and inclusive town government that encourages participation by all citizens by improving two-way communication, expanding volunteer opportunities, and encouraging customer friendly service. Provide more affordable and accessible rental and ownership housing options at different price points, particularly for single people, young families, and our older population. Maintain and expand town infrastructure in ways that expand opportunities for community interaction, support the development of a “green” economy, expand recreation opportunities, and promote public safety. LEGEND LOW SENSITIVITY HIGH SENSITIVITY REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Regulatory Framework Bay Property Zoning Feasible Areas for Program and Development Utilities Natural Resource Buffers Public use and access within the identified property buffers is limited to pedestrian access. Parking areas and built structures are not allowed. Trees cannot be cleared or removed. The Old Kings Highway Historic District Committee has jurisdiction over new buildings and modifications to existing buildings within the Historic District zone to ensure any changes are in keeping with the aesthetic tradition of Brewster. Natural resource buffers help preserve the function and habitat of wetlands and coastal dunes. Building within these zones is prohibited without a variance. Appropriate maintenance of existing structures is permitted. The lightest green areas at left are outside of zoning and natural resource buffers, making them most feasible for installation of new roads or paths, buildings, parking areas, recreation and sport fields, as well as clearing, planting or changes in landform. The existing water main will likely need to be replaced and relocated because it is aging and does not extend to Route 6A. Existing septic systems are dispersed and will likely need to be replaced by new treatment systems to meet DEP standards. Existing Water Utilities Existing Sewer/ Septic Utilities REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Zoning Natural Resource Buffers Feasible Areas for Program and Development Conservation Restriction Regulatory Framework Pond Property The lightest green areas at left are outside of zoning and natural resource buffers, making them most feasible for installation of new roads, appropriately scaled buildings and parking areas, as well as clearing, planting or changes in landform, if topography allows. A Conservation Restriction (CR) is a future possibility for a portion of the Long Pond property. A CR protects a property in its natural, scenic or open condition while permitting limited land uses in these areas. The adjacent 41-acre Long Pond Woodland is held in perpetual conservation with the Brewster Conservation Trust. LEGEND HIGH SENSITIVITYLOW SENSITIVITY Wetland buffers help preserve the function and habitat of the wetlands and pond. Building within wetlands and their buffer zones is prohibited without a variance. Appropriate maintenance of existing structures is permitted. Approximately 9.7 acres of the property, the area immediately adjacent to the pond, is considered either wetland or wetland buffer area. Any new roads, parking and buildings within the wetland would require a variance, and would not be easily approved. The Old Kings Highway Historic District Committee has jurisdiction over new buildings and modifications to existing buildings within the Historic District zone to ensure any changes are in keeping with the aesthetic tradition of Brewster. Over half of the property sits within the Zone II Wellhead protection area. Small-scale building development is allowed within Zone II areas, but protection of these areas minimizes the potential impact on drinking water quality. In high demand times, the groundwater in Zone II flows toward the town wells. Previous Context REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Topography and Slope Bay Property Topography Slope Drive and Path Slopes Areas Under 4% Slope HIGH POINT +63.0 LOW POINT +0.0 +31.4 +18.0 LEGEND HIGH SENSITIVITY LOW SENSITIVITY The white Administrative Building sits atop the knoll, visible from Route 6A. The knoll, part of a larger ridge that runs along the bay, was clearly manipulated slightly to accommodate the recreation fields south of the building. The existing topography is characterized by steep east-west ridge lines formed by glacial moraines, large upland flat zones, and smaller natural hollows. Overlooks and small natural amphitheaters are notable features. Planning for ADA Accessibility Why slope matters Many portions of the road are quite steep, exceeding what is considered accessible for people with reduced mobility or in wheelchairs. Because the road functions as the main walking path, the steepness of the existing road limits access to the site for disabled visitors. Flat areas, shown in light green here, are more feasible for construction of new roads, parking areas, recreation fields and buildings without implementing expensive and disruptive adjustments to existing grades. NATURAL AMPHITHEATER RIDGE OVERLOOK ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING Slope LEGEND HIGH SENSITIVITY LOW SENSITIVITY REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Topography and Slope Pond Property Topography The Pond Property’s dramatic topography descents over 75’ from a high point at Route 137 to a low point at the pond beach. A relatively flat upland wooded zone leads to a more varied and steep middle zone of the property and, finally, to the low, flat wetlands and small clearings by the pond. Steep slopes on either side of the drive contribute to its minimal width and eroded character. Drive and Path Slopes Areas Under 4% Slope Planning for ADA Accessibility Much of the lower half of the road is quite steep, exceeding what is considered accessible for people with reduced mobility or in wheelchairs. Because the road functions as the main walking path, the steepness of the existing road limits access to the pond site for disabled visitors. Why slope matters Flat areas shown in light green are more feasible for construction of accessible paths, roads, parking areas and potential new building without implementing expensive and disruptive adjustments to existing grades. REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Bay Property Buildings and Access ADMINISTRATION Building Age Building Type The site is characterized by a range of building types, from small cabins/dormitories to communal buildings and older structures. Moved/Original Location Unique Typical BOATHOUSE DINING SHOWERHOUSE STAFF CABIN MAINTENANCE POOLHOUSE DORMITORY COMMUNAL CAMP USES (12) SHOWER HOUSE (6) STAFF CABIN (9) DORMITORY (38) MAINTENANCE (25) ADMINISTRATION (2) SPRUCE HILL HOUSE (1) MOVED FROM ORIGINAL LOCATION (28) ORIGINAL LOCATION (64) 1900 - 1920 (5) 1940 - 1950 (52) 1950 - 1960 (5) 1960 - 1970 (2) 1980 - 1990 (7) 2000 - 2019 (5) 1940 1940 2006 1912 1984 1960 2008 1945 ROUTE 6 A CAPE COD BAY POND BOATHOUSE DINING ADMINISTRATION POOLHOUSE DAY CAMP ROUTE 6 A CAPE COD BAY POND ARTS AND CRAFTS *Spruce Hill House was built before 1860 *not including Spruce Hill House ROUTE 6 A CAPE COD BAY POND BOATHOUSE DINING ADMINISTRATION POOLHOUSE REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Bay Property Buildings and Access WINTERIZED (11 *not including Spruce Hill House) SEASONALLY CONDITIONED (6) NOT CONDITIONED (75) CAPE COD BAY POND Many of the buildings on site are non-winterized cabins with varied interior structural conditions. Several of these buildings have been moved over the years and have structural defects. Non- Winterized Seasonally Conditioned Winterized Winterization ADMINISTRATION ARTS AND CRAFTS BUILDING #40 DINING HALL BUILDING #26 BUILDING #82 DORMITORY BOATHOUSE MAINTENANCE BOATHOUSE DINING ADMINISTRATION POOLHOUSE DAY CAMP ROUTE 6 A ARTS AND CRAFTS REED HILDERBRANDTOWN OF BREWSTER SEA CAMPS, BREWSTER MA Bay Property Buildings and Access HIGH REUSE POTENTIAL (5) MEDIUM REUSE POTENTIAL (16) LOW REUSE POTENTIAL (65) TO BE DEMOLISHED (6) *not including Spruce Hill House **based on initial workshop with Town officials Potential for Reuse 92 Buildings have a range of potential for reuse and rehabilitation. Buildings likely to be demolished have structural concerns. Most winterized structures have the potential to be reused. Removal of all non-winterized structures (excluding the boathouse) would result in a largely open campus. BOATHOUSE ADMINISTRATIONRemaining structures show most immediate potential for reuse: POND CAPE COD BAY ROUTE 6 A ROUTE 6 A CAPE COD BAY POND BOATHOUSE BOATHOUSE DINING DINING ADMINISTRATION ADMINISTRATION POOLHOUSE POOLHOUSE DAY CAMP ARTS AND CRAFTS ARTS AND CRAFTS Site Plan HIGH POINT +63.0 LOW POINT +0.0 +18.0 Bay Property Pond Property LOW POINT +32.0 HIGH POINT +108.0 LEGEND BIOMAP CORE HABITAT BIOMAP CRITICAL NATURAL LANDSCAPE ZONE II WELLHEAD PROTECTION/DCPC TO: Peter Lombardi, Amanda Bebrin FROM: Clare O’Connor Rice RE: Comments from people at the Forum DATE: August 8, 2023 Yesterday staffing the Arts Center I had interesng discussions with the 80 people who came through. They were pleased to see the condion of the building and felt good about its potenal uses. I described the building and asked if they had any ideas for how it should be used. Most of these are interim uses and fee based. Here’s the summary of their suggesons: As a resource for arsts: Possibly use the space for occasional gallery showings, small income producing events for Brewster arsts. Allow arsts space for producon. A few of the people walking through are or know arsts who work out of their homes looking for space where they can paint or produce their work, not sell it. Creang a membership group, with fees, could allow arsts to “rent” space for a period, leaving their materials on site (would require creang some storage units, I assume, in the closets). This is also a possible use of the cabins, again, not for retail sales, but for producon, similar to what Harwich has created at the 204 building, which was reported as “expensive.” The lighng in the Arts Center is great, not sure if that’s a crical issue if you were to “rent ” them the cabins for short periods of me. Have open paint days, inving arsts in to paint as a group, again charging fees.Allow arsts to offer classes in the site for adults, youth, and seniors. Create poery classes, (this was menoned by quite a few people, probably spurred on by my nong that there had been kilns in it as the camp site). It appears that there are some classes in Chatham and Yarmouth and the CCMOA, but they are limited. Two different conversaons around this pointed to classes that would have scheduled out of class me with access to materials/site to connue working on their project. One person talked about what he had experienced elsewhere, a class at noon, with two hour sessions prior to the class that students could come in and use the space. All this is fee based. Rehearsal space, for theater (and using the ampitheater as well) and music. Weekly camps in the summer (and off season for adults) that would include a range of offerings, a different one each week, such as poery, digital art, drawing, painng, music. An interesng idea from one person about having a music camp and using the cabins for rehearsal space for various instruments: trombone in one cabin, drums in another, all connected to a music camp. Yoga and pilates classes on site. Very few places in Brewster parcularly off season to work out in a gym, this site could be used for some light fitness classes. Last, renng out the space for events, such as rehearsal dinners, showers, etc. With the bathrooms and two small rooms that could be used by a caterer to bring in food, it was seen as a good spot to begin to bring people to the property. Reasons for Allowing Tennis players to continue accessing Stony Brook property. This input in response to the Bay Property Planning Committee July 25 Meeting Recap and is in response to this sentence:“Mr.Dermody indicated that both groups support the construction of new dedicated tennis courts at the bay property,allowing the current Stony Brook courts to become a dedicated pickleball facility.” I am a member of the tennis community and moved to Brewster in late 2021.I LOVE Stony Brook Tennis Center and when I am not injured you will find me using the backboard,practicing my serve with a basket of balls,playing with my husband or sons and hopefully in the future with friends I make in the community.I have played tennis since I was young and love the casual laid-back environment that public tennis provides. I do not want to lose access to Stony Brook.Neither do my husband or sons.As a taxpayer I don’t want the town to build anything that excludes tennis or pickleball.Any language or policies that includes “Dedicated Tennis or Dedicated Pickleball”excluding a player is not acceptable to me.The Stony Brook facility was resurfaced In 2019 and was funded by USTA,Community Preservation and Town of Brewster in 2019: https://brewsterma.myrec.com/info/news/details.aspx?NewsID=4516 I am willing to share the facility as is the current practice with tennis courts in Brewster.At no point has the Stony Brook Community Tennis facility been a Dedicated Tennis Facility,as evidenced by the use of the courts by pickleball players.How would the pickleball players have felt if they were not allowed to use Stony Brook courts because they are tennis courts?I hope they understand how I feel at the thought of not being able to access Stony Brook built as a tennis site. If a facility is built at the Bay Property it should serve both Tennis and Pickleball players. We should not be using Brewster taxpayer dollars (or USTA /USA pickleball grants)that exclude one group or another group period. Desirability/Accessibility/Location of the Stony Brook Community Tennis and pickleball site: The 4 tennis courts 4 quickstart youth tennis courts at Stony Brook are desirable for Tennis players and Pickleball players due to its location.It is in an area of Brewster near the Long Pond Property off of RT 137 and Underpass rd.So,it is closer to and serves people in this area.This area does not have much traffic.There are no gates to drive through.The bike path goes by the facility. 1.Close to route 6 off of RT 137 and the Long Pond Property.It is green for people in this area to use this facility less driving and adding to traffic along 6A. 2.Do not need to cross traffic RT 6A to access-Route 6A traffic gets snarled. 3.Right on Bike path. 4.Do not need to go through gates at the Bay property. 5.Can play from sun-up to sun-down.7am -7pm.What would the situation be at the Bay Property?Drive right on in? Use of the courts: Tennis players do use the courts. I heard an argument from someone online who justified moving tennis to Bay Property due to lack of use by tennis players at the Stony Brook facility.My family uses it and we are new,so,it will only get increased use from us and the people we invite going forward and year round!The argument is unsound from a $$standpoint if that argument was true -why the heck would you waste money to build a tennis facility for the non-existent tennis players when a perfectly fine one has already been built at Stony Brook? 1.Every time I play tennis at Stony Brook there are other tennis players playing.I am new to town,I could fill up the courts with tennis players if I started a tennis group. 2.There is a tennis backboard at the facility that allows people like me to practice hitting against it. 3.The Town of Brewster provides tennis lessons through the Parks and Rec at these tennis courts. 4.Pickleball players use the mini tennis quick-start courts for pickleball (and the regular courts when necessary).This means if a person was to come to the facility with their child to learn tennis using low compression tennis balls or an adult wanted to practice mini tennis they would be unable to access those courts.The pickleball players use the courts outside of the window they reserve on the Brewster Rec site.This is fine,it is sharing.I understand people can make online reservations. 5.Online pickleball /tennis groups etc:When I search Tennis and Pickleball Brewster MA via google and through the Brewster gov Park and Rec site,the results I return are about a Brewster Pickleball Group - https://brewsterma.myrec.com/info/activities/program_details.aspx?ProgramID=29949 that is open to pickleball players resident and non-resident.I find no such Brewster Tennis group that allows for online sign-up -senior or otherwise resident/non-resident (I am not yet a senior)that is promoted by the parks and recreation with an online sign-up such as exists for pickleball.Maybe I just have not found it but I am google/search literate. Noise considerations I personally have no issue with the noise of pickleball even when I am playing right next to them. Someone mentioned online that building a pickleball facility at the Bay Property would be “annoying to pool and beach users”.This argument makes no sense -noise is expected at pools and beaches -kids screaming etc.Ocean sounds are like white noise.And Pool and beach use is primarily through the summer months. At the Stony Brook tennis facility,there is a 108 unit apartment complex that backs up near the tennis courts:King’s Landing properties are right across the street from the facility. https://www.kingslanding-apts.com/I did not hear any concern about whether their noises bother those residents. Financial Considerations 1.In 2019 the USTA and the Community Preservation and Town of Brewster provided $$to resurface the courts.I am 100%against losing access as a tennis player. https://brewsterma.myrec.com/info/news/details.aspx?NewsID=4516 2.Tennis courts at the Bay Property were already demolished.If a facility is built,it should be for both pickleball and tennis players to serve more residents. 3.What are the stats regarding pickleball access for non-residents?What percentage of the pickleball groups are non-residents?If lots of non-residents play pickleball on Brewster courts,is that why there is resistance to pickleball facilities at the Bay property? Since,up to this point access to the Bay property has been only for residents to have access?Obviously,I am sure this will be addressed.But,it is not a good reason to bar tennis players from Stony Brook. Thank you for allowing me to give my input/feedback. I will give my input regarding the conceptual designs that have been created for the Bay Property once I have access to them.But,like I mentioned before,I do not want any exclusive use facilities. Thank You, Stephanie Bush-Brown Robert Brown Tyler Brown 54 Beechtree Dr. Archive d: Friday, August 18, 2023 12:31:15 PM From: Amanda Bebrin Se nt: Mon, 7 Aug 2023 13:17:51 To: Rita Stulin Subje ct: Re: Tennis Courts Please Se nsitivity: Normal Rita, T hank y ou for the email! I will include this in an upcoming packet and y es, the committee is now in the process of considering all the potential long-term uses for the Bay Property - tennis courts included! Amanda Bebrin Chair, BPPC On Fri, Aug 4, 2023 at 2:41\u8239 PM Rita Stulin <rstulin@comcast.net> wrote: Hello, I know pickle ball has become very popular, but there are still a good number of us tennis players around. I greatly hope you will include a fair number of tennis courts in the plan for the Bay property, possibly updated to Har-Tru clay courts. Thank you so much for your consideration! Rita Stulin 90 Hillbourne Terrace Brewster -- Amanda Bebrin cell: 860-997-1 563 email: abebrin401 @gmail.com July 21, 2023 Email (elizabeth@reedhilderbrand.com) Ms. Elizabeth Randall Reed Hilderbrand LLC Landscape Architecture 130 Bishop Allen Drive Cambridge, MA 02139 Re: Vernal Pool Assessment Summary Report [LEC File #: ReedHLLC\22-321.01] Former Cape Cod Sea Camps Properties Bay Parcel - 3057 Main Street (Map 101, Lot 45) Pond Parcel - 500 W. H. Besse Cartway (Map 84, Lot 45) Brewster, Massachusetts Dear Ms. Randall: LEC Environmental Consultants, Inc., (LEC) has prepared this Vernal Pool Assessment Summary Report for the above-referenced properties in Brewster, Massachusetts. The Vernal Pool Assessment was conducted on April 28, 2023, specifically focusing within the Bordering Vegetated Wetland (BVW) associated with the unnamed Pond within the northeasterly portion of the Bay Parcel and the BVW/abandoned cranberry bog at the Pond Parcel. The Vernal Pool Assessment was conducted implementing scientifically accepted professional practices and standards in accordance with the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife Guidelines for Certification of Vernal Pool Habitat (March 2009, “NHESP Certification Guidelines”). The following summarizes LEC’s findings. Representative photographs accompany this report in Attachment A. Findings Bay Parcel LEC investigated the perimeter of the unnamed Pond within the northeasterly portion of the 55± acre Property. As reviewed within the Natural Resources Inventory report, prepared by LEC, dated March 30, 2023, swamp loosestrife (Decodon verticillatus) primarily occurs in-water around the Pond perimeter along with intermittent patches of leatherleaf (Chamaedaphne calyculata), while a dense, monoculture stand of invasive common reed (Phragmites australis) dominates the northeasterly edge of the Pond and abutting BVW. Water lilies (Nymphaea & Nuphar sp.) occur within the interior of the shallow Pond. Page 2 of 4 The westerly end of the Pond transitions to overhanging highbush blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum) and winterberry (Ilex verticillata) shrubs and tupelo (Nyssa sylvatica) trees within the terrestrial Forested Wetland. While saturated to the surface at the time of the site visit, no open pockets of standing water were observed within the westerly abutting BVW (Forested Wetland). Therefore, no viable vernal pool habitat is associated with the westerly portion of the BVW abutting the Pond. During the Assessment, LEC (Brian Madden) searched the Pond perimeter and/or abutting seasonally inundated portions of the BVW for the presence or absence of Fairy Shrimp (Obligate Vernal Pool Species) via visual observation and dip-netting, and evidence of Obligate or Facultative Vernal Pool amphibian breeding activity (e.g., spermatophores, chorusing, mated pairs, egg masses, transforming tadpoles/larvae/juveniles, etc.). No signs of Vernal Pool species or breeding activity were observed along the perimeter of the Pond, including a centrally located, narrow finger-like projection of contiguous open water extending to the north. LEC observed multiple painted turtles (Chrysemys picta), a snapping turtle (Chelydra serpentina), green frogs (Lithobates clamitans) within the Pond, indicative of a primarily freshwater system. Unidentified fish were also observed within the Pond, but they could not be captured for identification. LEC did observe Spotted Salamander (Ambystoma maculatum) breeding activity east of the elevated boardwalk extending across the easterly edge of the Pond, parallel to the Property line. Specifically, seven (7) Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed immediately east of the boardwalk (with railings) within the easterly edge of the open water Pond/transitional scrub shrub vegetation, separated from the larger open water Pond by the presence of the boardwalk at the water surface (refer to photos 3 and 4). No fish were observed within this semi-enclosed area that does appear to be located on the abutting Spruce Hill Conservation Area. Additional Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed northeast of the Pond and boardwalk within seasonally inundated portions of the BVW that extend onto the Spruce Hill Conservation Area. A total of six (6) egg masses were observed within standing water amongst tupelo trees and snags, sporadic highbush blueberry and winterberry shrubs, sedges (Carex sp.), cattails (Typha latifolia), and encroaching Phragmites. This seasonally inundated portion of the BVW contains variable hydrology with standing water observed averaging 4-6± inches at the time of the site visit. Based on water marks, the area does hold up to 12-16± inches of standing water. Moderate algal growth was observed within portions of the standing water. Surface waters gently drain towards the Pond, becoming marginally channelized proximate/under the boardwalk. Pond Parcel The BVW/abandoned cranberry bogs were thoroughly investigated to document the presence or absence Obligate or Facultative Vernal Pool species breeding activity as described above. Over one hundred (100+) Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed within the interior of the BVW/abandoned cranberry bogs, primarily associated with remnant ditches that contain deeper pockets of standing water. Westerly and easterly abandoned cranberry bogs are separated by the grassed area/access to the sandy Page 3 of 3 beach at Long Pond. The easterly abandoned bog is larger in size with the southerly portion contiguously inundated during high water conditions. At the time of the site visit, standing water was primarily relegated to the perimeter or interior remnant ditches and abutting areas (6-8± inches average); however saturated conditions continued throughout. Fifty-six (56) Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed within the southerly/southwesterly portion of the easterly abandoned bog, downgradient of BVW flags B41-B47 and coincident with a wider inundated portion of the BVW that holds up to 14-16± inches of standing water (max.) based on water marks (refer to photos 1-3). Five (5) Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed within the interior of a remnant ditch extending in a westerly-easterly direction within the southern portion of the easterly abandoned bog (refer to photo 5). Thirty-seven (37) Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed within and/or abutting a remnant ditch extending in a northerly- southerly direction within the southeasterly portion of the easterly abandoned cranberry bog (refer to Photo 6), downgradient of BVW flags B27-B34. The westerly abandoned cranberry bog is smaller in size with standing water primarily limited to interior, remnant ditches. Only two (2) Spotted Salamander egg masses were observed within a remnant ditch on the west side of the westerly abandoned cranberry bog (refer to photo 12). An overgrown, earthen berm defines the westerly edge of the westerly abandoned bog, located between wetland flags B58 and B59. An irregular-shaped pocket depression greater than 1,000 square feet in size is located immediately west of the berm within the interior of the demarcated BVW (refer to photo 13). This depression was observed holding at least 12± inches of standing water amongst dense winterberry shrubs. Over ten (10+) egg masses were observed within this depression, which appears to be natural and separate from past cranberry bog operations. Summary The following provides a brief summary of the April 28, 2023 Vernal Pool Assessment for the Bay Parcel and Pond Parcel. Bay Parcel On-site portions of the Pond on the Bay Parcel do not function as vernal pool habitat. While no Vernal Pool species breeding activity was documented on-site, the Pond also contains a reproducing fish population. Vernal pool habitat can occur within larger vegetated wetland complexes where sufficient water is contained for at least two months in the spring in most years, but where no reproducing fish populations are present. Vernal Pool habitat was documented immediately abutting and off-site to the east on the Spruce Hill Conservation Area. Based on the location of the breeding activity, it is evident that the Forested Upland on the Spruce Hill Conservation Area provides important terrestrial habitat for the Spotted Salamander (non-breeding/overwintering habitat). Page 4 of 3 Pond Parcel The southerly portion of the easterly abandoned cranberry bog and pocket depression west of the westerly abandoned cranberry bogs within the demarcated BVW qualify as Vernal Pools for certification according to the “NHESP Certification Guidelines.” While standing water is primarily relegated to specific low-lying areas and connected, remnant ditches, the majority of the southerly portion of the easterly abandoned cranberry bog is contiguously inundated during high water conditions. Therefore, LEC would characterize this area as a contiguous Vernal Pool. Based on LEC’s Vernal Pool Assessment, the westerly abandoned cranberry bog does not qualify for Vernal Pool certification as five (5) egg masses (Spotted Salamander) are necessary for documentation per “NHESP Certification Guidelines” unless (Spotted Salamander) larvae are documented. The remnant ditches within the westerly abandoned cranberry bog may not hold standing water long enough to enable successful amphibian development. LEC would recommend confirming the Vernal Pool boundaries through an Abbreviated Notice of Resource Area Delineation (ANRAD) Application with the Brewster Conservation Commission and MassDEP to confirm all Wetland Resource Area boundaries on both properties. Vernal Pool Field Observation Form and requisite materials can be submitted to NHESP via MassWildlife’s Heritage Hub (electronic database) upon request. Please do not hesitate to contact me at bmadden@lecenvironmental.com if you should have any questions or comments. Sincerely, LEC Environmental Consultants, Inc. Brian T. Madden Senior Wildlife/Wetland Scientist Attachment A Bay Parcel Photographs Bay Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photo 1: Westerly edge of Pond and abutting BVW. Photo 2: Centrally located, narrow finger-like projection of contiguous open water Pond extending to the north. Bay Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 3 & 4: Open water Pond/transitional scrub shrub vegetation; observed 7 Spotted Salamander egg masses. Bay Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 5 & 6: Spotted Salamander egg masses found within easterly edge of open water Pond/transitional scrub shrub vegetation. Bay Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 7 & 8: Seasonally inundated portions of BVW northeast of Pond on Spruce Hill Conservation Area containing Spotted Salamander egg masses. Bay Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 9 & 10: Spotted Salamander egg masses within seasonally-inundated portions of BVW northeast of Pond on Spruce Hill Conservation Area. Attachment B Pond Parcel Photographs Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 1 & 2: Southerly/southwesterly portion of easterly abandoned cranberry bog/BVW. Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 3 & 4: Southerly portion of easterly abandoned cranberry bog/BVW. Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photo 5: Remnant ditch within central portion of easterly abandoned bog (5 Spotted Salamander egg masses). Photo 6: Remnant ditches/southeasterly corner of easterly abandoned bog (37 Spotted Salamander egg masses). Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 7 & 8: Southeasterly corner of easterly abandoned bog from W H Besse Cartway/gravel access road. Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 9 & 10: Typical Spotted Salamander egg masses within easterly abandoned bog. Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 11 & 12: Westerly remnant ditch within westerly abandoned cranberry bog containing 2 Spotted Salamander egg masses. Pond Parcel Vernal Pool Assessment (4/28/23) Photos 13 & 14: Vernal Pool located west of westerly abandoned cranberry bog containing 10+ Spotted Salamander egg masses. Town of Brewster BREWSTER, MASSACHUSETTS 02631-1898 (508) 896-3701 FAX (508) 896-8089 .22 Caliber Shooting Range Remediation Minutes August 9, 2023 11 am OFFICE OF: SELECT BOARD TOWN MANAGER 1- Strategic Environmental Services $ 461o, NO 362 Putnam Hill Rd. 1 Sutton MA 01590 REAP NIP Non Collusion - L1 1 ft Bid Bond -'OSHA- t4 Addenda ✓ 2- Global Remediation Services 700 Richmond St. East Taunton MA 02718 3- Brighter Horizons Env. Corp. 201 West Main St. Ayer MA 01432 4- Costello Dismantling Co. 15 Cranberry Highway, Unit #1 West Wareham MA 02576 Town Hall PH II windows Minutes 07.26.23 l lam page 1 $ 3g5;45o REAP - Non Collusion - ✓ Bid Bond- VOSHA- ✓ Addenda ✓ $ N511DL REAP - ✓ Non Collusion - Bid Bond- OSHA- ✓ Addenda ✓ $ 3r1°C,01:?7 REAP - ✓ Non Collusion - ✓ Bid Bond- ✓OSHA - Addenda ✓ 5- Dig It Construction 22 Diamonds Path South Dennis MA 02660 6- NRC 19 National Drive Franklin MA 02038 REAP - J Non Collusion - Y -Bid Bond-0*POSHA- Addenda $ LD1,11q REAP - ✓ Non Collusion - ✓ Bid Bond -✓OSHA- ✓ Addenda v c4 CC_ (ft Donna Kalinick Executive Assistant Procurement Officer Signed under pain of penalty for perjury that the above is true and accurate opening. Town Hall PH II windows Minutes 07.26.23 11am page 2 Griffin Ryder, Director James Jones, Foreman MEMORANDUM TO: Select Board, Town Administration FROM: Griffin Ryder, Department of Public Works Director RE: Fee Waiver Request – Conservation Commission RDA filing fee for Bay Parcel Gun Range Remediation Project DATE: August 17, 2023 The Town of Brewster Department of Public Works (DPW) is working in conjunction with the Town Manager’s Office, the Bay Parcel Facilities Manager and the environmental consultant, River Hawk Environmental LLC, (Project Team) on the remediation of the former gun range at the former Cape Cod Seacamps Bay Parcel (Project). Due to the proximity of the proposed remediation work to nearby wetland resource areas, environmental permitting with the Conservation Commission is required for the Project. In reviewing the project with the Conservation Administrator, it was determined that a Request for Determination of Applicability (RDA) is the appropriate filing for the Project. The DPW, on behalf of the Project Team, is hereby requesting a Conservation Commission Request for Determination filing fee waiver for this project. The RDA filing fee is $75. Thank you for your consideration. Griffin Ryder DPW Director 508-896-3212 Department of Public Works 201 Run Hill Road Brewster, Massachusetts 02631-1898 Tel (508) 896-3212 Wetlands Map ± 3057 Route 6A (Bay Parcel), Brewster, Massachusetts 0 100 20050 Feet LEC Environmental Consultants, Inc. Plymouth, MA 508.746.9491 www.lecenvironmental.com January 18, 2023 2021 Aerial Orthophoto acquired from the Office of Geographic Information (MassGIS) website. Legend Coastal Dune Boundary IVW Boundary BVW Boundary Features Comment basin lot entrance Parking Lot Property Phragmites Pond Mitigation Planting Area Parcel Data Layer A40 A1 A36 A29 CD1 CD24 CD16 CD15 B1-B6 Wetland Resource Area boundaries delineated by LEC on January 11, 2023. Wetland flags and site features located by LEC on January 12, 2023 utilizing a Trimble Geo XH with accuracy ranges betweeen 1-100 cm. Coastal Beach Coastal Dune BVW Forested Wetland Building Removed Pass Type Units Sold Total FAMILY 301 $60,000 INDIVIDUAL 84 $8,400 INDIVIDUAL+1 90 $13,200 SENIOR 91 $6,675 SENIOR +1 123 $15,125 GUEST PASSES 352 $8,800 DROP IN DAYS 183 $915 REPLACEMENTS 20 $0.00 TOTALS 1244 $113,115 Pool Pass Revenues Report Range: 4/10/23- 8/18/23 Cape Cod Sea Camps Summer 2023 Events Brewster Recreation, in partnership with the Bay Property Planning Committee, has been hosting events on the front lawn of the Bay Property on Main Street. There is one event remaining this summer. Events are FREE and family friendly. Touch-A-Truck Friday August 25th Starting at 5:00pm Brewster Recreation, in partnership with the Pond Property Planning Committee, MA Audubon and Brewster Conservation Trust, will offer a guided walking tour at the Pond Property on Long Pond Road. The event is FREE, but registration is required. Visit the Brewster Recreation website for registration details: www.brewsterma.myrec.com (Current Programs & Offerings) Walking Tour September 23rd Time: 9am First Light Beach is open 7 days a week from 7am until 6pm through Labor Day and weekends only from Labor Day through Columbus Day. Brewster Community Pool is open from 7am to 6pm, please check the online schedule for details. Residents without a pool membership may use the pool on Sunday, August 6th for $5 per person, cash only. A resident beach permit is required. The last day to enjoy the pool this summer is August 20th. Pool information is available on our website at www.brewster-ma.gov/cape-cod-sea-camps-properties. At our inaugural Brewster Volunteer Fair, members from board, committees, and commissions will be available to talk to residents about their role in shaping our community. Members will have the opportunity to present the ongoing work their team is responsbile for and the planned initiatives for the upcoming year. Residents will be able to explore opportunities to get involved and learn more about the election and appointment process. Please join us! Saturday September 30, 2023 Dining Hall, Bay Property 10am – 12pm We are requesting each board, committee, and/or commission select 1-3 representatives to host a table at the event. On behalf of the Select Board, Bay Property Planning Committee, and Town Management, we invite you to join us for Brewster’s First Annual Volunteer Fair Immediately following the Volunteer Fair, we invite all members of boards, committees, and commissions to join us for an appreciation luncheon from 12pm – 1pm. Please RSVP to Erika Mawn no later than Sept. 22nd emawn@brewster-ma.gov / (508) 896-3701 x1100 THANK YOU FOR ALL YOU DO! Memo to: Brewster’s Bay Property Planning Committee From: Kyle Hinkle, executive director, Brewster Chamber of Commerce, Inc. Re: Bay Property Use for Brewster in Bloom Fine Arts & Crafts Show 2024 For many, many years, the Juried Fine Arts & Crafts Show, an anchor event for Brewster in Bloom festival was held on the sports fields at the Cape Cod Sea Camps. The event drew more than 90 artisans from Massachusetts and parts of New England for the two-day event, and an estimated 4,000 – 6,000 people attended the show. The show has a reputation for being the first outdoor show of the season on Cape Cod and visitors plan their spring get-a-ways around the weekend. This show, now being held at Drummer Boy Park, has maxed out at 70 artisans due to limited space. But I understand there is now an opportunity to return to the former Sea Camps with our show and welcome this possibility. Event Dates & Times: • For 2024, the show is scheduled for May 4 and 5. Saturday’s show is 10 a.m. – 5 p.m. and Sunday it is 10 a.m. – 4 p.m. • Main tent set-up is usually the Wednesday before the show which allows time for Building, Electrical and Fire inspections. The tent is taken down Monday following the show. Logistics: • A 200’ X 40’ tent is the focal point of the show. This is set up along the front field that abuts Rt. 6A and can accommodate 56 artisans. Electricity is provided in this tent. • An additional 36 artisans use their own pop-up tents in two rows that form in front of the big tent. • Parking is managed in the surrounding fields, with the entrance midway up the main driveway and the exit near the back of the fields. We use ground signs to indicate exits and parking areas and rely on volunteers to help maintain order. • Artisans are asked to set up starting Saturday morning at 7 a.m. • Frazier Disposal provides port-a-potties and trash toters, which they manage for us. • Our electrician is Chip Durant from Bolton. The Building Department is familiar with him! • We hire police details for Saturday and Sunday to manage traffic coming in and out on Rt. 6A. • Local boy scouts and their leaders camp overnight Saturday in the “big tent” to provide security. They work on badges, eat pizza, and play games while they are there. Show Attendance: • Saturday usually attracts the greatest numbers of attendees: 3,000 – 4,000 people. The average visit to the show is about 45 minutes and we estimate that 500+ people visit per hour. There are an average of 300 – 400 cars on the property at one time. • Sunday will have fewer people, particularly while the parade is taking place (12:30 – 3). There may be a total of 1,000 – 2,000 people for the entire day, and an average of 200 cars at one time. If you need further information about this event, please do not hesitate to ask! I am happy to answer any questions you may have. PROJECT PROPOSAL – SECOND MOVEMENT ARTS FAIR What: 2nd Act -- Open Movement Arts Fair -- Diversity, Equity, Inclusion Where: Boathouse & Surrounds, BAY PROPERTIES, Brewster When: September 23, 2023, 1-4 pm Who: Movement Arts Cape Cod and the Brewster Cultural Council What to bring: Water, snacks & lawn or beach chair Contact: Dave Iannitelli, 508-632-3779; diannitelli@movementartscapecod.org PROPOSAL: The Boathouse and environs as the site of a second Open Movement Arts Fair, SEPTEMBER 23rd from 1-4 pm. We will again gather local movement arts professionals of various movement languages to offer free & open mini-workshops sharing the essence of their styles with a diverse inter-generational public from 1-3 in multiple sites centering on the boathouse, followed by an artistic performance from 3 – 4 pm. We are projecting a public of approximately 100 people. As we have gone on promoting these Movement Arts Fairs, (on June 1st in Orleans, July 4th in Hyannis), we have attracted the attention and interest of additional local movement arts practitioners, and we believe it is in the interest of this growing group, as well as of the general local community, to include as many practitioners as possible. We envision this event to be centered in the new boathouse and the lawns and patios surrounding it. However, we would like to request access to additional buildings (the older boathouse, or the dining hall) in the case of rain. All will be welcome to come and sample the wares of people who work in local studios or have open movement arts projects available nearby offering continuity to learn and practice. There will be a chronology of offerings from 1-3 pm., as well as areas where simultaneous workshops of Capoeira, Egyptian, Contemporary, Tai Chi, Yoga, Greek Folk and other modalities will be held. Our final performance will include many of these, as well as invited artists from local studios. There will also be movement areas for toddlers, children & caregivers to play with age-appropriate, DIY movement development equipment, with orientation about phases of developmental movement, non-competitive games and self- directed physical play. Water and simple snacks are also available. The Fair is an initiative to focus on the development and expansion of regional movement arts culture, offering local practitioners and interested public a sustainable and inclusive platform to share these regenerative arts and to begin the process of building community among all people interested in movement arts as art, recreation and healing. This open Fair is part of the pilot project “Dancing by the Bay” of the Brewster Cultural Council with funding from the Mass Cultural Council. Movement Arts of Cape Cod (MACC) Based in Brewster, MA, Movement Arts of Cape Cod is a new non-profit working to bolster public access to and awareness of the benefits of movement arts experiences for all. Through supporting our regional movement arts practitioners in organizing public events, building projects in public institutions, helping with professional networking, development and grant writing, MACC sees a future where all interested local people have opportunities to experience and expand their practical knowledge of movement arts. MACC can be contacted through https://www.facebook.com/MovementArtsCapeCod/ Movement Arts Fair – May 14th – Bay Properties, Brewster Photographer: Filipe Borges, Brewster, 2023 Movement Arts Fair – May 14th – Bay Properties, Brewster Photographer: Filipe Borges, Brewster, 2023 Photo: Antonia Stephens. Photographer: Filipe Borges, Brewster, 2022 Open Movement Arts Fairs BoatHouse – Bay Properties Brewster INTERIM REPORT The First Open Movement Arts Fair happened on May 13th as planned. The event opened inside, with about 50 participants in a circle, with a Sound Harmonization involving everyone, as part of the first moment of the event. Next were the Mini-Workshops with 5 instructors (Tai Chi, Egyptian Dance, Latin Dance, Yoga, and Zumba Dance) from 1:30 to 3 pm. After the two first, simultaneous workshops we decided to move all the workshops to the indoor space due to the heat outdoors. These were conducted in series. A Snack Bar was set up on the porch outside offering clementines, granola bars, and drinks for all participants. Also, we had a book selling table with a book from one of our instructors of the day. There was a literature table for participants to display their class and studio promotional materials. An initiative for parents with children was an outdoor non-competive youth play area, with a basket containing badminton, paddle ball, corn ball, a kid volleyball and football for free use. There is a basketball court next door, which could be an interesting addition for next time. We also set up a caregiver-toddler play area, with a large mat, two different bouncing stages, and a small padded ramp for interactive, self-directed play. These initiatives can be expanded for future fairs as more parents become aware of the intergenerational aspect of the fairs. From 3-4 pm, 6 performances of 10 minutes each were presented on stage, outside the Boathouse with a beautiful view of the beach area. Some of these performances were interactive with the audience. However, all of them were very well received judging from the audience responses to the performances. There was an estimate of 100 participants/attendees, plus 25 instructors with their accompanying artists. The process of defining the space, setting it up, and cleaning it up was smooth, particularly with the help of Ed Barber, of the Town/Bay Properties , who made every aspect of this project pleasant. Our second fair, scheduled for June 3rd, was postponed due to harsh weather. We are approaching the Bay Properties with a proposal for September 23 and also May 2024. We have applied for funding from the Mass Cultural Council (Festivals Grant) and New England Foundation for the Arts (CISJ – micro grant), that latter of which has pledged $500 for the continuance of these fairs. Through the organization and realization of this event, we have to date secured the enthusiastic collaboration of 10 local movement arts professionals & organizations, willing to participate in future fairs and other events yet to be created. We have accepted invitations from Pop-up Performances in Orleans, the Dance Party on July 4th on Main St Hyannis, and the Harwich Farmers Markets with multiple dates. The Pleasant Bay Boating Club has also reached out for a conversation. We intend to grow this group of professionals to include all interested and to make “fairs” of all sizes available to all local venues and events interested throughout the year. We were excited to see the receptivity, engagement and enthusiasm of people present. We continue to believe that cultural production is a unique and highly effective catalyst for contact, exchange and sustainable community-building, and are interested in expanding this model of local practitioners with local public, participatory workshops and exhibitions in public venues, building together an annual calendar of inclusive and accessible cultural opportunities. We are now proposing a Second Movement Arts Fair, this one for Sept 23rd, 2023, with all of the same characteristics, possibly expanding our offerings a bit to include new professionals along with those interested in continuing from the first Fair. Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 1 of 7 MINUTES OF THE BAY PROPERTY PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING DATE: July 25, 2023 TIME: 4:00 PM PLACE: Hybrid Participation – Zoom/2198 Main Street, Brewster, MA PARTICIPANTS: Town Manager Peter Lombardi, Chair Amanda Bebrin, Selectperson Mary Chaffee, Selectperson David Whitney (remote), Karl Fryzel, Katie Jacobus, Caroline McCarley, Thomas Wingard, Patricia Hughes (remote),Peter Johnson, John Phillips, Clare O’Connor-Rice; Liaisons/Representatives: Sharon Tennstedt, Kathleen Walker, Jan Crocker, Gary Christen; Town Staff: Mike Gradone (Recreation Department Director), Elton Cutler (COA Director), Griffin Ryder (DPW Director); Tennis and Pickleball Members: Bill Dermody, Daryl Bladen, Amy Jacobson Call to Order, Declaration of a Quorum, Meeting Participation Statement and Recording Statement: Amanda Bebrin called the meeting to order at 4:03 pm and read the meeting participation and recording statements. Ms. Bebrin announced all members of the committee who were present, a quorum was declared. There were no public announcements or comments. Public Announcements and Comments None Review Updated Presentation Materials and Format for Second Community Forum & Survey Town Manager Peter Lombardi reminded committee members about the upcoming second forum on Saturday August 5. There will be three public engagement sessions held in the Bay Property Dining Hall on the 5th, at 1PM, 2PM and 3PM. The property will be open to the public to explore on foot from 12PM to 5PM that day. There will be a dozen buildings open for residents to explore during the forum. A map will be available before and at the forum so residents can take their own self-guided tour. Representatives from the Town will be at most of the facilities to answer questions from residents. Volunteer docents will be provided with a synopsis of key talking points. Registration was opened up two weeks ago for the forum, and a second announcement was posted on the website to remind residents to sign up in advance. 130 residents have signed up so far, the majority of those for the first session. Depending on the number of residents who sign up, the Town may decide to combine the second and third public engagement sessions. Mike Gradone asked about the Town’s parking plan for the forum. Mr. Lombardi responded that parking will be on the grass lawn area to the right, similar to the last forum. The COA is also offering transportation to the forum for anyone who is interested. The Town is planning on following the forum with a survey, in an effort to get additional feedback. Mr. Lombardi introduced the latest materials prepared by Reed Hilderbrand for the upcoming second forum on Saturday August 5. Reed Hilderbrand has incorporated committee feedback from the last meeting. Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 2 of 7 Potential partner organizations (MA Audobon, BCT & YMCA Cape Cod) will be present at the forum to answer questions about the services and programs they currently provide and may be interested in providing at the Sea Camps. The packet contains the high-level feedback from the first forum and first survey, and the key takeaways for each property. This is a way of easily accessing the data that Reed Hilderbrand has compiled. Mr. Lombardi explained that, before each session, the Chairs of each committee will give a one minute introduction, and Reed Hilderbrand will talk about the goals of each forum – these remarks will take less than 10 minutes. Ms. Bebrin explained that Reed Hilderbrand will be providing instructions to attendees on how they can use stickers on the boards even if another attendee has used one to indicate a similar preference. Mr. Lombardi then displayed the draft boards that the Reed Hilderbrand consultants have put together for the forum. Mr. Fryzel asked about Option 3/Central Campus : this shows a new community center that contains both the Recreation Department and the COA, but the administration building is also listed as the Recreation Department – is this intentional or an error? Selectperson Mary Chaffee said that she believes this is simply intended to convey possible use options. Mr. Fryzel said that the administration building is large, and asked why the only possible use option for it is housing the Recreation Department. Mr. Lombardi responded that, based on the first forum, there wasn’t a lot of support from residents to relocate other existing Town departments there. Mr. Lombardi added that the options outlined are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Clare O’Connor-Rice asked if training would be provided for volunteers working at the table. Mr. Lombardi responded that volunteers will meet at their stations 45 minutes before the forum to discuss the planned approach. Mr. Gradone said it was important to keep buildings open so that residents have a clear idea of what is and isn’t feasible within each structure. Mr. Fryzel asked why a possible newly constructed community center for the Y was not included in these options. Mr. Lombardi responded that the group did not want to include different options for the community center in these display boards. Gary Christen asked what would happen with the plans for a community center if the Eddie School space became available in the next few years. Ms. Bebrin responded that this consideration was not part of the charge of the committee. Mr. Lombardi said that there has been talk about school consolidation and using the Eddie School as a community center for roughly 20 years, but this is not something that is going to happen in the near future, and plans for the bay property shouldn’t be based around these kind of theoretical scenarios. Mr. Lombardi introduced a slide examining shared community parking. The idea here is to consider shared parking areas that may make sense in different scenarios, though they would not all necessarily be needed. The following slide examines dwelling types – the existing buildings that are on the site and the high-level costing for reuse options and new builds. At the bottom of this slide is the Harwich Community Center, included as an example of how a community center of that size would fit into this property. Lastly, Mr. Lombardi noted that a station at the forum would be devoted to asking residents what they would want to see as a community center. Selectperson Chaffee noted that most community conversations have focused on the desire to have a multigenerational community center, and this is important to keep in mind. Mr. Lombardi explained that, in terms of proper nomenclature, what the committee has referred to as “workforce housing” should instead be called “attainable/affordable housing” – this is due to negative Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 3 of 7 connotations associated with the term “workforce housing”. Update on Potential Partnerships (YMCA Cape Cod & Mass Audubon) Mr. Lombardi explained that the YMCA remains interested in partnering with the Town. They recognize that the feedback from the forum and survey was mixed in terms of a potential partnership. This continued interest is why there will be a separate station at the next forum for potential partners, so residents can ask questions. At this point the plan is to revisit what a partnership might look like after the second forum and survey, when we have more feedback from the community. In terms of Mass Audubon, this partnership has been entirely conceptual. A meeting took place with David O’Neill, President of Mass Audubon, and his team, and they remain interested in partnering with the Town on both properties, and providing educational programming, and, if the Town decides, holding a conservation restriction in the northeast corner of the property. They also expressed an interest in having a nature center and office space on the property. In order to maximize their ability to provide programming, they have emphasized that some of the buildings would need to be reused for staff housing. Debrief from Harwich Community Center Site Visit Ms. Bebrin said that the committee visited the Harwich Community Center on Tuesday, July 18. She asked for the feedback of committee members about what had stuck with them from the tour. Caroline McCarley said she was struck by the usage of the building in terms of numbers. Selectperson Chaffee said that if the community in Brewster indicates that it wants to proceed with new construction, there can be many valuable lessons learned from what has happened in Harwich – i.e., a need for a large amount of storage space, and many windows throughout the facility. Another important point to consider, noted Selectperson Chaffee, is that it took Harwich 3 Town Meetings to approve the building of the community center. Mr. Fryzel noted that the key item which had to be dropped from the original plans was the removal of the swimming pool. Ms. Bebrin noted that she found it impressive how every square inch of the building was being used, and the potential of the building was being fulfilled. In addition, the community center has the support and approval of Harwich residents. Mr. Lombardi noted that if Brewster residents decide that they want a community center, this would not be the only site visit – there is a list of 5 or 6 that the committee can visit for research. Discuss Potential Uses of New Athletic Courts – Tennis, Pickleball, etc. Bill Dermody, of 4 Daisy Lane, noted that members of the tennis community and pickleball community would like to share the details of some of their recent conversations. Both groups currently share a facility, and this causes some issues. They share a facility at Stony Brook Elementary School, where there are 4 dedicated pickleball courts and 4 tennis courts – 2 of those tennis courts are shared with pickleball players. Pickleball demand continues to rise – there are currently 200 dues paying members, and it is capped at this amount. There is currently capacity for 32 pickleball players, but demand is in excess of this, and tennis players have first preference to use the shared courts. Mr. Dermody explained that he believes the answer to this is a dedicated tennis facility and a dedicated pickleball facility – he asks the committee to consider making the building of tennis courts part of the masterplan of the Sea Camps properties. Noise from pickleball courts can be considerable, and the current location of Stony Brook is ideal in terms of isolating this noise. The existing Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 4 of 7 tennis courts there could be repurposed as pickleball courts if new tennis courts are built on the bay property. He added that he believes this is also the most efficient use of Town money. Mr. Lombardi commented that new tennis courts are part of two conceptual design options that will be presented at the August 5 public forum. In both scenarios, these will be 4 full sized tennis courts, and 4 junior tennis courts. Peter Johnson asked if Mr. Lombardi’s description of the conceptual tennis court plans on the bay property would be sufficient to satisfy the demand for tennis. Daryl Bladen, of 1186 Stony Brook Road, said that one of her concerns is ensuring that if the public tennis courts are moved, they will still be accessible to the general public year-round and not just Brewster residents. Selectperson Chaffee asked if the current process was first-come-first-served, and if there is no way of registering in advance to avoid people waiting. Mike Gradone, Brewster Recreation Director, said that people can register in advance by calling the Recreation Department. Selectperson Chaffee asked if there was a fee paid to the Town of Brewster for registering in advance. Mr. Gradone responded that it is $5 an hour per court, but that there is no charge for dropping in to play. Mr. Fryzel asked if any of the existing courts on the property would be repurposed in any of the Town’s design options. Mr. Lombardi responded that such courts no longer exist on the property, so any courts would be new constructions. Ms. Jacobus asked if the senior tennis group is comprised of solely Brewster residents, or if anyone can join. Mr. Gradone responded that anyone could join, but that the tennis group is made up of approximately 80% residents, in comparison to roughly 70% in pickleball. Thomas Wingard asked what the plan was for the existing basketball courts on the bay property. Mr. Lombardi responded that decisions need to be made about these courts – they could be used for parking or basketball courts. Mr. Gradone added that no full-size regulation basketball court currently exists in Brewster, and this is something that would be desirable for residents. Amy Jacobson, of 86 Stone Henge Drive, explained that she is a member of both the tennis and pickleball communities. In her experience, the two shared courts are not always used by pickleball players. From what she has witnessed, it is not the case that tennis demand pales in comparison to pickleball. Ms. Jacobson said she would like to see some objective data showing that the current facilities are inadequate for accommodating the demand for pickleball. She added that she would like to know at some point what the cost to residents will be in terms of taxes if new courts are constructed. Mr. Lombardi responded that it is important to convey the cost to residents of all of these potential plans. The planned third forum will include cost estimates for residents’ design preferences in addition to financing options and possible funding opportunities. Mr. Lombardi said that it is important to keep in mind that whether or not the Sea Camps had been purchased, the Town would have been looking for a solution to the increased pickleball demand anyway. Mr. Gradone responded to Ms. Jacobson’s earlier question regarding data, noting that it was currently being collected. Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 5 of 7 Update on Brewster Community Pool Mr. Lombardi explain that the pool temporarily closed for 3 days for unexpected maintenance and sanitation work, but reopened on Monday July 24. Two more test-swim days will occur on July 28 and August 6. Almost 700 season passes have been sold to date, and over 300 guest passes. $111,000 in revenue has been brought in so far, and this is consistent with pool operating expenses. The original pool furniture order was delayed, but Willowbend in Mashpee donated some furniture to the Town as a short-term solution. This furniture will be used for the remainder of this season, and then the Town will reevaluate for next season. Selectperson Chaffee asked if the closing date of the pool could be extended. Mr. Lombardi responded that it could not be extended beyond the current end date of August 20. This is primarily due to staffing availability – most staff are not local, and are visiting family for the summer. Mr. Fryzel asked if the Town had to pay Willowbend for the furniture. Mr. Lombardi responded that Willowbend donated it to the Town, and a letter will be presented to the Select Board in order for the Town to formally accept the donation. Mr. Fryzel asked if anything could be done to prevent the event which caused the pool to close from happening again. Mr. Lombardi responded that there was no specific event, rather an issue that came up during routine testing. However, some of the maintenance protocols have now been changed, and some regulations have been tightened since this incident to try and prevent it from happening again. Mr. Wingard asked Mr. Gradone to discuss the extension of swim lesson programming. Mr. Gradone said that the Recreation Commission has decided that they would like to offer infant swim lessons for an extra week. This would occur at 9am in the swimming pool with an instructor, and parents would be required to be in the water with their infants. Immediately following these lessons, the instructor would be available to provide lessons for residents or non-residents at Long Pond at 10am. Selectperson Chaffee moved to approve an extra week of infant swim lessons at 9am for the week of August 6 at the Brewster Community Pool. Mr. Fryzel second. A vote was taken.Selectperson Chaffee – yes, Clare O’Connor-Rice – yes, Selectperson Whitney – yes, Pat Hughes – yes, Karl Fryzel – yes, Caroline McCarley – yes, Katie Jacobus – yes, Thomas Wingard – yes, Amanda Bebrin – yes, John Phillips – yes, Peter Johnson – yes. Review Upcoming Approved Interim Uses and Vote on Proposed New Interim Uses Mr. Gradone reminded members that the Family Friendly DJ Dance Party is occurring on July 27 at 6pm on the bay property, and the Family Movie Night (Angels in the Outfield) is being held on August 4, beginning at approximately 8.30pm – a sandlot game for kids will be held on the soccer fields beforehand at 7pm. Touch- a-Truck is happening on August 25 at 5pm – an ice cream truck, a food truck, a monster truck, along with other Town vehicles, will be on the property that evening. Mr. Gradone explained that the Recreation Department is requesting usage of the bay property for two of its fall programs – Run Club, which would take place on Wednesday and Fridays from 3-4pm for the month of October, and the Outdoor Club from 3-4pm the second week of November. Selectperson Chaffee moved to approve usage of the property for both the Run Club and the Outdoor Club. Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 6 of 7 Ms. Jacobus second. A vote was taken. Selectperson Chaffee – yes, Clare O’Connor-Rice – yes, Selectperson Whitney – yes, Pat Hughes – yes, Karl Fryzel – yes, Caroline McCarley – yes, Katie Jacobus – yes, Thomas Wingard – yes, Amanda Bebrin – yes, John Phillips – yes, Peter Johnson – yes. Ms. O’Connor-Rice requested the use of the property for the Cultural Council to hold its strategic planning meeting in the Arts Center on Wednesday, August 16, from 4pm to 6pm. Ms. McCarley moved to approve the use of the property for the Cultural Council to hold its strategic planning meeting in the Arts Center on Wednesday, August 16, from 4pm to 6pm. Mr. Fryzel second. A vote was taken. Selectperson Chaffee – yes, Clare O’Connor-Rice – yes, Selectperson Whitney – yes, Pat Hughes – yes, Karl Fryzel – yes, Caroline McCarley – yes, Katie Jacobus – yes, Thomas Wingard – yes, Amanda Bebrin – yes, John Phillips – yes, Peter Johnson – yes. Ms. Jacobus reminded committee members that the “Da Hedge” event is occurring on the morning of Sunday August 6 at the bay property, with a start time of 7am. Vote on Meeting Minutes: July 11, 2023 Ms. McCarley moved to approve meeting minutes from July 11, 2023. Mr. Fryzel second. A vote was taken. Selectperson Chaffee – yes, Clare O’Connor-Rice – yes, Selectperson Whitney – yes, Pat Hughes – yes, Karl Fryzel – yes, Caroline McCarley – yes, Katie Jacobus – yes, Thomas Wingard – yes, Amanda Bebrin – yes, John Phillips – yes, Peter Johnson – yes. Discuss Future Meeting Agenda Items The public forum on August 5 will be the next gathering of committee members. Next Meetings August 22, September 19. Matters Not Reasonably Anticipated by the Chair: None Adjournment Ms. Jacobus moved to adjourn at 5.57pm. Mr. Fryzel second. A vote was taken. Selectperson Chaffee – yes, Clare O’Connor-Rice – yes, Selectperson Whitney – yes, Pat Hughes – yes, Karl Fryzel – yes, Caroline McCarley – yes, Katie Jacobus – yes, Thomas Wingard – yes, Amanda Bebrin – yes, John Phillips – yes, Peter Johnson – yes. Respectfully submitted by Conor Kenny, Project Manager Approved: __________________ Signed: _________________________________________ Town of Brewster 2198 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631-1898 Phone: (508) 896-3701 Fax: (508) 896-8089 BPPC 7.25.2023 www.brewster-ma.gov Page 7 of 7 Accompanying Documents in Packet: Agenda, Flyer for Forum, Forum Draft Boards, Dwelling and Community Use Boards, Harwich Community Center Visit Summary, Cultural Council Request for Use of Arts Center, Recreation Department Request for Use of Bay Property, 7.11.23 Draft Minutes AUTHORIZATION FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES To: Town of Brewster Attn: Peter Lombardi, Town Administrator 2198 Main Street (Route 6A) Brewster, MA 02631 VIA EMAIL: plombardi@brewster-ma.gov Date: 07/25/2023 Project No. C16845.07 Project: Sewage Disposal System Inspections and GWDP 977-0 Renewal T: 508-896-3701 x1134 Location: Cape Cod Sea Camps 3057 Main Street Brewster, MA Assessor’s Map: 8, Parcel: 8 Coastal Engineering Company, Inc. (CEC) will perform the following professional services relating to the referenced project. Fixed Fee: $17,500 SCOPE OF SERVICES: Task 1 - SDS Inspections Fixed Fee: 12,500 • Inspect and file Title 5 reports with the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) Note: 29 system inspections total, including 18 completed and 11 to be inspected. Backhoe is included. Tasks 2 and 3 - Groundwater Monitoring Well Sampling and Quarterly Report; Annual Report See 11/17/2023 Contract Task 4 – Permit Renewal Filing Fixed Fee: 5,000 • File GWDP 977-0 for renewal with the DEP (due by 3/9/2024) Note: Reimbursable expenses such as state and town fees and pumpings are not included. The DEP permit renewal fee is estimated at additional $1,000. JGS/kvp SUBJECT TO TERMS AND CONDITIONS ON NEXT PAGE AUTHORIZED FOR COASTAL ENGINEERING: We are proceeding with service(s) noted as per your direction. Immediate notification in writing is required if you wish to alter this authorization. By: John G. Schnaible, R.S., S.I. Project Manager July 25, 2023 Please execute this agreement authorizing us to proceed. No services will be performed until you return this agreement with authorization in writing. AUTHORIZED BY CLIENT: Signature Date Printed Name and Title This document will become our original agreement. Acceptance of this agreement by signature authorizes COASTAL ENGINEERING to proceed as described. This proposal expires in 90 days if not signed by both parties. PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN ONE COPY D:\PROPOSALS\1HOLD\2023\_CIVIL\Town of Brewster 2023-07-25 APS.doc STANDARD CONDITIONS FOR ENGAGEMENT July 1, 2022 COMPENSATION FOR ENGINEERING SERVICES: Fees for engineering services performed by Coastal Engineering Co., Inc. (CEC) for the CLIENT are based upon the time worked on a given project and are billed according to CEC's current fee schedule or are based upon a fixed fee given for a project. CLIENTS are advised that all fees are subject to increases and can vary due to complexity and staff demand. Fee estimates for professional services are prepared to the best of CEC's ability based on facts available at the time of submission and are subject to revisions from time to time by CEC. CLIENTS are also advised that Additional Services performed beyond the Scope covered by the fixed fee proposal or change orders attached thereto will be based upon the time input according to our current hourly fee rate schedule. TRANSPORTATION: Time and travel expenses incurred, when travel is in the interest of the project, will be charged for in accordance with CEC’s fee schedule. SUBCONTRACT SERVICES: CEC may engage subcontractors and/or other professionals to perform required services such as soil borings, drilling, construction, etc. That subcontractor’s charge plus a service charge will be added to CEC's fee. REIMBURSABLE EXPENSES: Expenses will be billed at CEC's cost plus a service charge. Examples of expenses ordinarily charged to CLIENT are printing and reproduction, special fees, permits, and licenses. PAYMENT: Invoices will be rendered monthly or as work progresses. Invoices are due and payable upon receipt. Amounts over 30 days past due are subject to a service charge of 1.5% per month (18% annually). The CLIENT agrees to pay reasonable attorney’s fees and any collection fees incurred in the collection of any amount owed hereunder and not paid when due. CEC shall have all rights available to it pursuant to M.G.L. Chapter 254 to file a lien on the property for which CEC provided services hereunder. The risk of loss and damage with respect to attempted payments to CEC, including, but not limited to, loss attributable to cyber-theft, shall be and remain with Client until payment is received and accepted by CEC. Said loss shall not relieve Client of its obligation to pay CEC all amounts owed it under this Agreement. CHANGE OF SCOPE: If, during the performance of services under this Agreement, a change in the Scope of Services is requested on the basis of an oral or written order by the CLIENT or CLIENT's Agent, or is required in CEC's sole discretion by circumstances to address contingencies, or CLIENT requests revisions of the plans, CEC will perform such additional services in accordance with its fee schedule. CEC reserves the right, at its discretion, to issue a Change Order to this Agreement. However, a Change Order is not required prior to rendering such services and the CLIENT agrees to pay for such additional services. SUSPENSION OF SERVICES: If the CLIENT fails to make payment of invoices when due, CEC may suspend performance of services under this Agreement. In the event of a suspension of services, CEC shall have no liability to the CLIENT for delay or damage caused by such suspension of services or for any consequential damages. TERMINATION PROVISION: This Agreement may be terminated by either party upon five (5) days written notice in the event of breach of performance of terms and conditions of this Agreement by the other party through no fault of the terminating party. CEC shall be compensated for services performed up to the time of termination. INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR: In the performance of its services hereunder, CEC will be acting as an independent consultant and not as the Client’s agent or fiduciary. No other relationship outside of that contemplated by the terms of this agreement shall be created. Nothing in this agreement shall imply or give rise to an agency or fiduciary relationship between Client and CEC. INSURANCE: CEC is covered by Worker’s Compensation Insurance and Public and Professional Liability Insurance. CEC will furnish certification upon request. CEC will not be responsible for any loss, damage, or liability beyond the amounts, limits, and conditions of such insurance available at the time of claim and/or beyond the limitation of liability established in these General Terms and Conditions. CEC will not be responsible for any loss, damage, or liability arising from Client’s acts, errors, and omissions. RIGHT OF ENTRY: Unless otherwise agreed, the CLIENT furnishes right-of-entry on the land for CEC to make measurements, soil tests, or other required explorations. CEC will take reasonable precautions to minimize damage to the land from the use of equipment, but CEC has not included in its fee the cost of restoration from damage that may result from its operations. If CEC is required to restore the land to its former conditions, the cost of doing so will be added to its fee. OWNERSHIP OF DOCUMENTS: All documents, including original drawings, estimates, specifications, field notes, and data, are and shall remain the sole and exclusive property of CEC as instruments of service and CLIENT shall have no right to such documents. The CLIENT may, at his/her own expense obtain record prints of drawings, which the CLIENT will use solely in connection with the project to which this Agreement applies and not for the purpose of making subsequent extensions or enlargements thereto. All photographic documentation shall remain the property of CEC and may be used in marketing materials (electronic and print) unless otherwise specified by CLIENT. The CLIENT hereby consents to CEC’s use of the CLIENT’S name and general project description in marketing materials (electronic and print) unless otherwise specified by CLIENT. USE OF DOCUMENTS: Services performed and documents prepared by CEC under this agreement shall be for the benefit of CLIENT only and may not be relied upon by any third party(ies) unless specifically agreed to in advance by CEC and CLIENT. Any unauthorized use of the documents prepared by CEC or any use of the documents which is not in strict compliance with the documents shall be at the sole risk of the CLIENT or the unauthorized user and CEC shall have no liability for the misuse or unauthorized use of such documents. The Client may retain copies for information and reference in connection with the occupancy and use of the project. In the event of Client reuse of documents without engaging CEC, Client shall, to the fullest extent permitted by law, hold harmless and indemnify CEC for all claims and/or damages generated by said reuse. STANDARD CONDITIONS FOR ENGAGEMENT July 1, 2022 USE OF STAKES: CLIENT, CLIENT's contractor, or any third party may not use stakes or other markers set at the site by CEC before obtaining verification from CEC that the stakes or other markers were set for the intended purpose and are in place to the accuracy appropriate for the intended use. ELECTRONIC FILES: Electronic files are transmitted for informational purposes only and at the request of the CLIENT or CLIENT’s agent. CEC's official product is limited to its signed and sealed hard copy of plans, specifications, and/or studies. The CLIENT agrees to hold CEC harmless for any damages from inappropriate or illegal uses by third parties from any electronic transfer of information by CEC requested by the CLIENT or CLIENT’s agent. CONSTRUCTION SERVICES: On request, CEC can provide personnel to observe construction in order to ascertain that the construction, in general, is being performed in accordance with CEC's plans and/or specifications. CEC shall under no circumstances be a guarantor of any contractor’s means and methods of work and shall bear no responsibility with respect to the performance of such construction. The CLIENT and CLIENT’s agent will continue to be responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of all construction performed. It is understood that, in accordance with generally accepted construction practices, the contractor shall be solely and completely responsible for working conditions on the job site, including safety of all persons and property, during the performance of the work and compliance with OSHA Regulations, and that these requirements shall apply continuously and not be limited to normal working hours. Any observation of the contractor’s performance conducted by CEC personnel is not intended to include review of the adequacy of the contractor’s safety measures in, on, or near the construction site. INDEMNIFICATION AND LIMITATION OF LIABILITY: CEC agrees to indemnify and hold CLIENT harmless against damages and liability to the extent caused by the negligent acts, errors, or omissions of CEC. The CLIENT agrees to limit CEC's liability, resulting from errors and/or omissions in engineering design information furnished to the CLIENT, to those portions of the design prepared by CEC and in an amount not to exceed CEC's fee. The CLIENT agrees to require a like limitation from any contractor engaged to perform work for which CEC has provided reports, plans, and/or specifications. The CLIENT shall further indemnify and hold CEC harmless from any liability resulting from the acts, errors, or omissions of the CLIENT or CLIENT’s agents, contractors, or assigns from any breach of this Agreement or from any unauthorized use of CEC’s documents or use of CEC’s documents other than as set forth in the Use of Documents section hereof Such indemnification shall include the cost of defense including without limitation attorney’s fees, arising in any way with claims connected with any such liability excepting only such liability as may arise out of CEC's sole negligence in performance of services. CLIENT agrees that any and all damages arising from a negligent act, error, or omission shall be made against CEC directly and shall not be made personally against any of CEC’s directors, officers, agents, or employees. CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES: Notwithstanding any other provision hereof, CEC shall not be liable to the CLIENT for any incidental, indirect, or consequential damages arising out of or connected in any way to the services rendered hereunder, including, but not limited to, loss of use, loss of profit, loss of business, loss of income, or loss of reputation. STANDARD OF CARE: CEC's professional services will be performed consistent with the skill and care ordinarily exercised by similar members of the engineering profession practicing under similar circumstances at the same time and in the same locality. CEC makes no warranties, express or otherwise, in connection with CEC's services hereunder. CLAIMS AND DISPUTE RESOLUTION: Any claim, dispute, or other matter in question arising out of or related to this Agreement shall be subject to mediation. If such matter relates to or is the subject of a lien arising out of CEC’s services, CEC may proceed in accordance with applicable law to comply with the lien notice or filing deadlines prior to resolution of the matter by mediation. The parties shall share the mediator’s fee and any filing fees equally. The mediation shall be held in the place where the Project is located, unless another location is mutually agreed upon. Agreements reached in mediation shall be enforceable as settlement agreements in any court having jurisdiction thereof. MISCELLANEOUS: A. It is recognized that CEC has no control over the cost of labor, materials, or equipment for construction, over any contractor’s methods of determining bid prices, or over competitive bidding, market, or negotiating conditions. Accordingly, CEC cannot, and does not, warrant or represent that bids or negotiated prices will not vary from any cost estimate or evaluation prepared by CEC. B. Should any representative of CEC be requested, required, ordered, or subpoenaed to give any testimony, either at trial, deposition, hearing, or otherwise, concerning services performed under this agreement, or concerning the subject matter of this retainer, then Client shall compensate CEC for all reimbursables and time incurred in connection with the preparation for and giving of such testimony at the rates prevalent at the time of the Service. C. In the event that any part of this Agreement or proposal shall be held invalid, such invalidity shall not invalidate the whole of this Agreement or proposal, and the remaining provisions thereof shall continue to be valid and binding.