HomeMy Public PortalAbout20050000.pdf Ludington Project
July 1993
DLH Photos by Marge Beaver
Nov. 1984
Photo by DLHolmberg
Ludington Project
July 1986
July 2005
19 Years Later
Photos by DLHolmberg
Ludington Project
Nov.1985
July 2005
20 Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Ludington Project
Nov. 1985
July 1992
Seven Years later Photos by
DLHolmberg
Ludington Project
Nov.1984
Funded by Harold Cabe
July 2000
16 Years Later DLH Photoss by Marge Beaver
Ludington Project
June 1983
July 2005
22 Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Montague Project
Nov. 1985
Owners Harold Decker & Muskegon County
June 2003
18 Years Later Deckers & Mienert Park Photos by
DLHolmberg
Montague Project
Nov. 1986
Decker & Lost Valley Association
June 2003
17 Years Later Photos by
DLHolmberg
Whitehall Project
1983
Funded by Sylvan Beach & Murray Beach Associations
1985 7-2000
2 Yrs. Later DLH Photoss by Marge Beaver
17 Years Later
Whitehall Project
1984
^ South
June 2003
19 Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Whitehall Project
1984
^ North
June 2003
19 Years Later Photos by
DLHolmberg
Duck Lake Project
1985
DLH Photo by Marge Beaver
State Funded 1985 June 2003
Photo by DLHolmberg
18 Years Later Photo by DLHolmberg
Michigan Academician, Winter 2004
Shore Protection and Coastal Change on the Lake Michigan Shore: Duck
Lake, Orchard Beach State Park, and Onekama, Michigan
David Barnes Michael S. Kovacich Santos Limesz
Western Michigan University GEORANS, Ann Arbor Consultant, St. Joseph
ABSTRACT
A high-resolution beach profile change-monitoring program was conducted during generally high water in the
1990s at three sites along the eastern shore of Lake Michigan in a variety of coastal geological settings to
evaluate an experimental shore protection technology called the Undercurrent Stabilizer System™. Shore
protection structures at all three sites produced minimal negative impact at and immediately adjacent to the
study sites and generally resulted in significant net accretion of near-shore sediment in and around the
structures during the study period compared to control sites. Local complexities and variations in coastal
processes and conditions (especially local long shore transport, coastal substrates and geological setting, and
other existent engineered structures) play a critical role in the specific performance characteristics of these
small (property owner) scale shore protection structures in the Great Lakes region. A fundamental factor in the
evaluation of coastal change associated with shore protection on eastern Lake Michigan (as well as many other
areas of the Great Lakes) is that net transport of sand is offshore, especially during periods of prolonged high
water levels. Maintenance of long-term sediment budgets through input of beach-grade sand is dependent on
the erosion of upland (bluff dune materials) or nourishment. The use of coastal monitoring results for coastal
planning, development, and permitting decisions requires careful consideration of several factors: the intent of
the monitoring project in terms of spatial scale and time frame of influence of the structures that are monitored
and the appropriateness of extrapolating monitoring results to other areas with substantially different coastal
setting. Although the overall results of the study indicate that no substantial negative impact occurs within the
experimental structure study sites compared to control sites, we believe that the isolation and protection of
back-shore coastal sediments from wave action through the use of any shore protection technology will
ultimately result in increasing offshore loss of near-shore sand throughout the eastern Lake Michigan coastal
system.
INTRODUCTION AND PURPOSE
Hard shore protection is considered with increasing skepticism by coastal management community in the U.S. Permits for shore
protection are very critically reviewed by state and federal coastal managers in Michigan, especially shore-perpendicular
structures projecting on to "state owned bottom land." Much of lower Michigan Great Lakes shoreline comprise erodible coastal
substrates. Periodically high water levels in the recent past have resulted in accelerated bluff/dune recession rates, and future
high water level periods will undoubtedly result in a public outcry for "protection."
This paper presents the final results of coastal change monitoring studies of small scale experimental shore protection
technology marketed as the Undercurrent Stabilizer System™. The studies were conducted in three study areas along the
eastern Lake Michigan shore: near Duck Lake State Park north of Muskegon, near Orchard Beach State Park north of
Manistee, and North of Onekama, MI (Figure 1). Coastal change monitoring was conducted from 1991 through 1998 (see time
line, Table 1). The purpose of these studies is to document the overall impact of the experimental shore protection structures
and assess the effectiveness of this approach to Great Lakes coastal engineering practices relative to other shore protection
alternatives, including no action.
A complete discussion of general study background is presented in Duck Lake Outlet Demonstration Project Undercurrent
Stabilizer System™ Shore -Stabilization/Accretion Program Find Report of 1991-1996 Surveys (Barnes 1998; available from the
author, see references).
Duck Lake Project
Nov. 1982
State Funded
6-3-2003
21 Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Duck Lake Project
June 1991
State Funded
6-3-2003
12 Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Duck Lake Project
Oct. 1985
State Funded
June 2005
20 Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Norton Shores Project
May 1997 June 2000
Funded by Jim Westgate & Jim Tyler 3 Years Later DLH Photoss by
Marge Beaver
May 1995
^ Northern Adjacent Shore Start of Project Photo by
DLHolmberg
Norton Shores Project
Aug. 1996
July 2005
Nine Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Norton Shores Project
June 1996
July 2005
Nine Years Later Photos by DLHolmberg
Norton Shores Project
May 1997 June 2000
DLH Photos by Marge Beaver 3 Years Later
May 2005
8 Years Later Photo by DLHolmberg
Grand Haven Project
Jan.1986
Funded By Scott Shapiro Photo by DLHolmberg
Oct. 1987 June 2000
1 Year Later DLH Photos by Marge Beaver 14 Years Later
Grand Haven Project
Oct. 1987
Stickney Ridge
6-30-2000
13 Years Later
DLH Photos by Marge Beaver
Grand Haven Project
1987
June 1992
5 Years Later Photos by
DLHolmberg