The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My Public Portal AboutMorgan Depo Exhibits5617370188 Fax 03:15:51 p.m. 02 -03 -2014 3/8 Your original reauesr dated January 24 2014 is reproduced in the ace below 0t- i4- 1.101: c2Fdli ' ( L• i RED=$ REQtrMr(:Le°R -z n7 nrkc(Regagp Lf1Ah4 Eequeggr'tRegaarl[�• _ 434 EEQOES¢?P: Cu4rodien gi'8�nls lbvm afOglfSUaero R8RUMORi _ MaeneR. nm 4. REQOPSWWS OUNLAa IEPOSMATION: wat txotdte'}O•:n-teiee.ppnF.arp Lze 9Sf-3a8- W071aa�m: IzeBw.rxax'wnocnecA- h'Sne�atd Bcch.ii S3asz MUM. ProVldel oaP9 oTWgbggqlmla [6P1iEIX]AllbfiCRgcMS1 (n9 dffised 1R f6l:beoter l391 aerbv tv dtri 600nNL nc�AmbBeedal Rave .MdF1=b8Hgud ante Town nfGU1F56c1miorOi4neHodbo 7ga1etrl 2aillbrMh ac CLAW ditbi "Uw, TIM lbnya=qu (SUNDecabMw bi:rerceravdY,Mu'D fmmCllYt xlcimSS AlID7 7JDNALPJfQRA {A170NEEGABLV}G7@Qpp57: _ T8 sRxt UEST1SRt =ptmguAATTO1'ODT7CRRCoRDEA=,, CiiAr7Lti 1L90FTIMPLOPM,k LTATUMAliD IS ALSDMEQUEBTgp UNDP,R TEI£ Qnlr4ONL.AW3UG@TO MqU Y.=CQMON LAwRI=WA=SS,.ABD ANYSUTOTDRYRIGNT70 T.7CDwfrNCLUDTKG.Vyn=UTlZ 1TA1TON.ALNV STATMORYRIG TOFAC'CESS,A5AYPrl=LL5. uoREQ77ts1'ISAUOMAgk PIIRSUANTT01EEiM MSOFI=PXQU=MtEROWI ®WTE37LMWA CONS7=TMN, Lf TSAFnt)T'FTAQTTTATTRY RF/ Mns RtXtttAAT• MR M- T8NOT AVATIIASTRTi tStP.Cr72DTTCTORM rrMXFO UW= TFTATTN RE[ORMAtMMSE 1111191T RRDNII X 17 I TMPDCl1nLT1 TFIS(IOVrFBSRDIRU Pr MVO BIDCI ANDWOUITRP BILLED TV w [.C¢]RpANCR w{1RSxHea 119.bTfq (e121 did L'LRC]RDNiCC11ArFF AAF ACDT,Rtii,.n inao FCeTn..•v w.•..............__ PLi: " PRDyIDLTHEAPPRO =M=COSTSpA":O:ULIaLLTN75PUBTSC REOORDSREQUCSTINADYANOE. RASI be rogdr4dtbu thl RIgUNlargyFloyb bf eaYtarb, 93MIld b7 the A5eW EvdorWd-a LkHda 3Mnn4Chaptrr11 201 CWd!Bor4InodvmmArna7 urtrlotpalad tame Rrqullae'by for Aienr). I-WERUR OI.Sa.n1'erx PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT From: "scottmorgan75 @gmail.com" <scottmorgan75 @gmail.com> Subject: Public Records Request 10/15/13 Date: October 18, 2013 8:37:11 AM EDT To: Bill Thrasher <bhrasher @gulf- stream.org> HER =@I You sent me a copy of an e-mail from Mr. J. O'Boyle, which purports, rather informally, to be a Public Records request. The highlighted Request (5) of the e -mail makes no sense, as it requests "Email's sent from Scott Morgan's (sic) for the Month of September 2013 ". 1 assume that is the request you wish me to answer but since Mr. O'Boyle's request is vague, I am unable in good faith to respond to it. Should you have any further questions, do not hesitate to contact me. Scott W. Morgan w- 561 - 752 -1936 c- 561 - 573 -6006 M TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA October 18, 2013 Jonathan O'Boyle jonathanroboyle@gmail.com Re: PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST — 5 (Emails from Morgan Sept. 2013) (5) Entail's sent from Scott Morgans for the Month of September 2013. Dear Mr. Jonathan O'Boyle, The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated October 15, 2013. If your request was received in writing, then the first page of that request is attached to this cover letter. If your request was verbal, then the description of your public records request is set forth in the space below. Our staff will review your request within the next three business days, and we will promptly send you the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond. Sincerely, Town Clerk Custodian of the Records Your original request, dated October 15, 2013, is reproduced in the space below: From: Jonathan O'Boyle [ mailto :ionathanroboyle(dgmail.coml Sent: Tuesday, October 15,2013 12:27 PM To: Rita Taylor Subject: Public Records Request Rita: Pursuant to the Chapter 119 of the Florida Code and the Florida Constitution, I request the following records in electronic form or in paper form only if the electronic form is unavailable: (1) The Registry of Work Permits under Sec 10 -1 of the Town Code for the FY 2014 (starting in October 2013) (2) The Registry of Work Permits under Sec 10 -1 of the Town Code for the FY 2013 (starting in October 2012) (3) The Agendas for commission meetings from August 2004 up to October 9, 2004. (4) Receipts for the advertising of public hearings of Ordinance No. 04 -4 Sec.1 (5) Email's sent from Scott Morgan's for the Month of September 2013. (6) The last 5 emails from W. Thrasher which include the acronym Fema. (7) The last 5 emails from W. Thrasher which include the phrase Flood Insurance. (8) The last 5 emails from Com. Stanley which include the acronym Fema. (9) The last 5 emails from Com. Stanley which include the phrase Flood Insurance. (10) The last 3 Employment applications for the Town of Gulf Stream where the applicant was African American. These requests are all separate and have merely been included together for convenience of record keeping. Note: My contact information is 561- 758 -1223 and Jonathanroboylen email.com I await your prompt response and thank you for your public service. IRS Circular 230 disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, I inform you that any tax advice contained in this communication, unless expressly stated otherwise, was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding tax- related penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any tax- related matter(s) addressed herein. NOTICE TO RECIPIENT: THIS E -MAIL IS MEANT FOR ONLY THE INTENDED RECIPIENT OF THE TRANSMISSION, AND MAY BE A COMMUNICATION PRIVILEGED BY LAW. IF YOU RECEIVED THIS E- MAIL IN ERROR, ANY REVIEW, USE, DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION, OR COPYING OF THIS E -MAIL IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. PLEASE NOTIFY ME IMMEDIATELY OF THE ERROR BY RETURN E -MAIL AND PLEASE DELETE THIS MESSAGE FROM YOUR SYSTEM. THANK YOU IN ADVANCE FOR YOUR COOPERATION. 56173;0188 Fax 03:16:38 p.m. 02 -03 -2014 7/8 SCOTT W. MORGAN 1140 N. Ocean Blvd GuOtreant, FL 33483 Ph (561) 243 -1432 July 23, 2013 To: Town of Gulf Stream Architectural Review and Planning Board Re: Hidden Harbour Fsiates Loi S 1224 N. Ocean Blvd Dear Hoard Members: Please note my objection to this application for Level 3 Architectural/Site Plan Review of a 8,726 sf Colonial West Indies single family dwelling. Sec. 66 -144 (b)(10)(1) The proposed architectural design of this home violates the prohibition against excessive similarity both in regard to neighboring homes and in comparison of its East and West breezeway structures. The latter composition gives an appearance more of the wings of an aircraft than of an Ocean West District home. Because the tat is long and narrow, the applicant has attempted to create useable space by symmetrically loading the farthest East and West sides of the property. The result is a forced balance that gives the appearance of outstretched arms on a measuring scale. The long breezeways, nearly 27' each, only heighten the sense of awkward balance between the two ancillary buildings. 2. See. 70 -4 (c)(4) and Sec. 70 -29 (b)(3) This long, narrow and drawn out house design also conflicts with the Code's prohibition against excessive similarity to neighboring homes, which by definition then conflicts with the Code's prohibition against applications that "do not maintain the desired character or quality of the zoning district within which they are located... "(Art. T, Sec. 70-4 (c)(4)). The Ocean West District is characterized by "lots that are set back great distances from the road ... the homes and landscape features lend a formal, elegant and estate -like feel to the lots in the district." (Art. U, Sec. 70 -29 (b)(3)). The homes ofthis District have a unique, separate character that helps define the Town of Gulf Stream. The similarity of lots inside Hidden Harbour Estates —all of which are rectangular, long East to West, and narrow, and which lay next to each other like two rotes of domino tiles —has from its conception risked the potential of turning into a gated- PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 5617370188 Fax 0a:I aae P.M. .2 -o3-2014 a community subdivision, typical of large home neighborhoods in Boca Raton and West Delray Beach. The previous three Hidden Harbour Estates homes approved by the ARPB were all corner lots and so were evaluated on their own, rather than in juxtaposition to homes an adjacent lots. The current application for Lot 5 is a middle lot, and is sandwiched between two approved homes, each of which employs the now ubiquitous long, narrow, rectangular design. In order to preserve the integrity of the Ocean West District character, and to prevent an over - crowding of similar homes inside Hidden Harbour Estates, I ask that the Level 3 Architecturat/Site Plan Review of Lot 5 be denied, and request that the applicant re- submit a house design consistent with the Gulf Stream Code. Very truly yours, l' Ott W Morga