Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout20210719_PC_PACKET.pdfSTAFF FXPORT PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING: July 19,2021 CITY • MEETING: August 12, 2021 APPLICANT: City of Tybee Island EXISTING USE: N/A APPLICATION: Amendment to Article 7, Tree removal regulations. PROPOSAL: To strengthen penalties for violation of this ordinance and require staff supervision when 5 or more trees are being removed from a site. ANALYSIS: This amendment can cause the inability to receive future tree permits for repeat violations of this article and can cause the inability to receive future building permits for cutting trees without a permit. Additionally requires staff supervision for cutting 3 for more trees on a site, any significant tree or any tree in a City right of way. STAFF FINDING This should help deter violations of this article. ATTACHMENTS A. Amendment H This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. ORDINANCE NO, 2021-17 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND SO AS TO INCLUDE PROVISIONS REGARDING APPLICATINS FOR TREE REMOVAL PERMITS, INSPECTION OF TREE REMOVAL ACTIVITIES, PENALITIES FOR IMPROPER TREE REMOVAL AND TO REPEAL INCONSISTENT OR CONFLICTING ORDINANCES AND TO ESTABLISH AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is authorized under Article 9, Section 2, Paragraph g of the Constitution of the State of Georgia to adopt reasonable ordinance to protect and improve the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Tybee Island, Georgia, and WHEREAS, the duly elected governing authority for the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, is the Mayor and Council thereof; and WHEREAS, the governing authority desires to adopt ordinances under its police and home rule powers; and WHEREAS, it is desirable that the requirements be established for tree removal so as to ensure that sufficient trees and vegetation remain on any developed parcel of land and that those individuals pepm4eymingperforming tree removal do so in a professional and responsible manner and; WHEREAS, it has become iraDortant to ensure that the permitting" f� F. `{ s* 7utatmore pre_ventable- and- I NOW THEREFORE, it is hereby ordained by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island duly assembled as follows: Formatted Font: Bold SECTION I Existing Tybee Code Sections identified as Article VII of Appendix A -Land Development Code "Tree Removal Regulations" Section 7-040 is hereby repeals in its entirety and is replaced with the Code Section hereinafter set forth below: Sec 7-040 - Building permit required. Any person desiring to clear land or remove trees to a density below that required in Sec 7-050 or remove a significant tree pursuant to this article shall apply fora building permit from the City. See Sec 9-03o and Section o o of this Land Development Code for requirements and application procedure. A tree surrey must be submitted before a permit can be issued. All applications for tree removal per °t Uproval must also include the below as well as comely_ °th Sec o -o3- of Article IX - Building Regulations in the Land DevelOrlment Code: (1) ACknOwled ent of the mOnitOrillg reglllre ent Set f0 in eC �®� and t12e®- ormtted List Paragraph, Numbered + Level: 1 + COriSegneriCeS OE failing t0 enSllre SL1Ch mOnitOrin which maY reSnit In the TNurnberingStyle: 1, 2, 3, ... + Start at: 1 +Alignment: eftAligned at: 0.5" +Indent at: 0.75" mabllity to otain�ermit in the Estate; �) A statement that t11e apulicatialt accents responsibili to ensure the tree removal is pursuant to all al}licable code sections and that thea licant has informed the contractor laerfor in the work of the monitoring requirement and the consequences of failing to adhere to the monitoring require ants, ) The application is signed by the contractor as well as theower._ Formatted: Font: Georgia, 12 pt (Ord. No. 12-2-12,4-26-2012) SECTION II Existing Tybee Code Sections identified as Article VII of Appendix A -Land Development Code "Tree Removal Regulations" Sec 7-050 is hereby amended with the addition of Subsection (E) which provides as follows: E In The event an anralication for removal would seek to renao til_ tt i1 111Formatted: Line spacing: 1.5 lines City right®of-av° ani -__ i ifieant tree Or three (�) or more otherwise f, :Formatted: Font: Bold Q210506W ----- --------- ---- -- - .. --- - insi ificant tree no tree shall e removed unless a reuresentative of the City is r nto monitor anti observe the removal to ensure , of the After receiving their tree removal permit an a er must give seventy-two f r2? hours' notice to the i prior to removing any tree to allow the City time to arrange far a City representative to present at the rkmDval (Ord. No. 12-2012,4-26-2012) Existing I)rbee Code Sections identified as Article VII of Appendix A -Land Development Code "Tree Removal Regulations" Sec 7-o90 is hereby amended with the addition of Subsections (D) axed (E) which provides as follows: (D) Ani person who has been ad -judged to have violated tree removal permits two or more times within three permits pursuant to Section-0�0 or env other per it under the land Develap ent Code for three (�) veers and may further be subject to additional restrictions or re uirements far any future permit issued Additional ons or require mencs that may be imposed shall be determined by the permitting official talcin into account the circumstances of the current or-pdin application the nature �and extent of removal requestedat�the location as �well as other relevant factors as determined by fhe perminin official and may include additional monitoring -of the removal -proccss and sped c tree maLrkkinfor clarity of intendedrocess. — (E) Any person who has violated the ordinance by removing trees without a permit for removal either directly ar indirectly mcludin an o er or contractor and in addition to all other penalties fines or sentences imposed shall not be eli 'ble far a building or other permit for a period of o�2) veers from the date of an adverse adaudicatian against thea licant far an un ermined removal. Sec. 7-o90 — Penalties for unlawful tree removal. - ! Formatted: Font: Bold (Ord. No. 12-2012,4-26-2012) All ordinance and parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are expressly repealed. SECTION V It is the intention of the governing body, and it is hereby ordained, that the provisions of this ordinance shall become effective and be made a part of the Code of Ordinance, City of Tybee Island, Georgia, and the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered to accomplished such intention, This Ordinance shall become effective on ATTEST: CLERK OF COUNCIL FIRST READING: SECOND READING: day Of , 2021. 2021. Formatted: Font: Bold ENACTED: Formatted: Font: Bold r` 1 111111 # I I Meeting date: 5/17/2021 IME 1111111 1111131-11 Action Requested: Text Amendment Special Review Subdivision: Site Plan Approval Sketch Plan Approval Conceptual Variance Preliminary Plan Approval Map Amendment Final Plat Approval Text Amendment X :::::i Minor Subdivision ® Major Subdivision Petitioner has met all documentation requirements, all external approval requirements, and all code requirements, except for the following: The Planning Commission Motion on Petition: 0 Approval E] Denial M Continued Action on Motion: 7 Date: - .7- COMMISSIONER FOR AGAINST COMMENTS Biso CHAIR Bossick X VICE. CHAIR Goodin X Hill X me McGruder X SECOND hton X MOTION _MIcNau PR,e nolds X Planning Commission Chair: Planning & Zoning Manager: Date: 7 Date: - .7- @a=! ommumu, Komi Special Review Subdivision: Site Plan Approval Sketch Plan Approval Conceptual Variance Preliminary Plan Approval Map Amendment Final Plat Approval Text Amendment X Minor Subdivision — Major Subdivision Petitioner has met all documentation requirements, all external approval requirements, and all code requirements, except for the following: The Planning Commission Motion on Petition: 0 Approval E] Denial M Continued Action on Motion: COMMISSIONER FOR �AGANST COMMENTSa. ._ Bishop CHAIR Bossick VICE CHAIR -ABSENT Gooding X Hill X McGruder X SECOND McNaughton X MOTION mwm Reynolds X Planning Commission Chair: Planning & Zoning Manager: Date: Date: STAFF REPORT • COMMISSION MEETING: July 19,2021 CITY COUNCIL MEETING: August 12, 2021 APPLICANT: Charlie Cole EXISTING USE: N/A ZONING: N/A USE PERMITTED BY RIGHT: N/A COMMUNITY CHARACTER MAP: N/A APPLICATION: Amendment to Article 3-250. Private parking lots PROPOSAL: To allow residents who own an empty lot adjacent to an existing City parking area to apply for a private parking permit. ANALYSIS: This amendment was requested by a resident with a lot adjacent to the north beach entrance. He would like to charge parking on his lot between Railwood and Gulick. A site plan including layout, trash cans, access, etc. would be required during permit application process. The use of Railwood may be problematic due to the residential nature and narrowness of the road. STAFF FINDING The parking department doesn't see an issue with this particular lot having paid parking. There is the chance that other lots may meet this criteria that may be less desirable for the City. Each would be evaluated on a case by case basis. Staff has no recommendation on this amendment request. This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. ATTACHMENTS A. Amendment I V xv W.110 I Biel Did I 019y M Applicant's Telephone Number 0 L142 Applicant's Mailing Address E If within two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the Applicant's application for a zoning action, the Applicant has made campaign contributions aggregating to more than $250 to the Mayor and any member of Council or any member of the Planning Commission, the Applicant and the Attorney representing the Applicant must disclose the following: a. The name of the local government official to whom the campaign contribution or gift was made; b. The dollar amount of each campaign contribution made by the applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action, and the date of each contribution; c. An enumeration and description of each gift having a value of $250 or more made by the Applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action. Disclosure of Campaign Contributions form attachment hereto: Yes Signature of Applicant Date -5ee. 3 rkvoo:-� ro�rk,� (a�s City Official Date Page 1 of 3 " This application must " accompanied i" additional documentation, " " and/or text that include " illustrate the information outlined below. i I I" I I I I" I i IF 11 1 Y 5-020 (E) An amendment to the text of this Land Development Code follows the same process as an amendment to the zoning map. However, a text amendment requires different materials to be included with the application. T 5-040 (E) (1) In the case of a text amendment, the application shall set forth the new text to be added and the existing text to be deleted. 5-110 Section 5-110, Standards for Land Development Code or Zoning Map Amendment Approval, identifies standards and other factors to be considered by the Mayor and Council in making any zoning decision. The Applicant should provide written data addressing each of the below listed standards and factors to assure consideration of applicable information. 5-110 (A) The existing land use pattern; 5-110 (B) The possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts; 5-110 (C) The existing population density pattern and the possible increase or overtaxing of the load on public facilities; 5-110 (D) Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed amendment reasonable; 5-110 (E) Whether the proposed change will adversely influence existing conditions in the neighborhood or the city at large; 5-110 (F) Potential impact on the environment, including but not limited to drainage, soil erosion and sedimentation, flooding, air quality, and water quality and quantity; 5-110 (G) The reasonableness of the costs required of the public in providing, improving, increasing or maintaining public utilities, schools, streets and public safety necessities when considering the proposed changes; 5-110 (H) Whether the proposed change will be detrimental to the value or improvement or development of adjacent or nearby property in accordance with existing requirements; 5-110(l) Whether the proposed change is out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or entire city; 5-110 (J) Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to the individual owner as contrasted with the adjacent or nearby neighborhood or with the general public; and, 5-110 (K) The extent to which the zoning decision is consistent with the current city master plan or other local planning efforts, if any, of the city. The Applicant certifies that he/she has read the requirements for Land Development Code Text Amendments and has provided the required information to the best of his/her ability in a truthful and honest manner. Signature of Applicant Page 2 of 3 III i el kq Have you within the past two (2) years made campaign contributions or gave gifts having an aggregate value of $250.00 or more to a member of the City of Tybee Island Planning Commission, or Mayor and Council or any local government official who will be considering the rezoning application? YES NO NAMEOF CONTRIBUTIONS GIFTS DATE OF GOVERNMENT OF $250.00 OF $250.00 CONTRIBUTION OFFICIAL ORMORE ORMORE L N no- HIM WI•W111 11.101ilii01 U-11116 TraVrIjkm I 'X�WVNA" I Do"T GIFTS IN EXCESS OF $250.00HAVE BEEN MADE TO ANY MEMBER OF THE PLA119KIG COidol SSION 0 Signature Printed Name Date Page 3 of 3 spaces o e located up e e s an Off -511-e dimensions of subsection 3-080(e) including drive aisles widths. All spaces must be sized to accommodate full sized vehicles. If the applicant for a private parking lot is not the property owner, a notarized affidavit authorizing the applicant to operate a private parking lot is required. After the submittal of the application, staff shall have the authority to recommend to council a maximum number of spaces allowed to be utilized at the requested parking lot. Upon submittal of fa the application with all pertinent application materials and following proper notification to adjacent property owners • the application, the mayor and • will consider the request for application at a scheduled meeting of the city council. Public comments, if any, will be allowed to be made at these • Council may reject any such application or may approve the application with conditions designed • to protect neighboring properties and households and customers including, but not limited to, xwoWA�rog rri.-xPjxtA-�m# the type of vehicles permissible for the location, the hours of operation, the requirement of security measures, buffers, noise control methods and any other conditions or requirements reasonably designed to lessen the impact of activity upon other properties or citizens. All private parking lot properties shall be marked with a maximum of one sign not to exceed two #42te1 riaht-of- way and not attached or placed on any sign, utility pole, bench, rock or any form of vegetation. The sign shall contain the name of the contact person or company and a telephone number. Any and all vehicles owned by the property owner(s), the parking lot attendant(s) and by friends or family of the property owner(s) and/or attendants(s) or otherwise parked on the property shall count toward the maximum number of spaces that are to be rented. that had been required with the initial application. Each application for renewal of a license to operate a private parking lot on Tybee Island will be subject to an annual review during the month of January for compliance. Any and all incident reports and citations shall be considered during the annual review. If compliance has not been met the license may be revoked by city council upon a hearing that will take place during a regularly scheduled city council meeting or an application for renewal may •` `• Following • and • the mayor and cooke, suspend, • refuse to renew a license previously granted upon a finding that the license -holder, his agent, representative, or employee has failed to comply with all terms and conditions of the license or has failed to compl with other relevant ordinances of the city or other applicable law(s). I M Me U -111M 01-4m,-11 0 a Mon 'I Efie acitm;�9 licensing. STAFF REPORT PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING: July 19, 2021 CITY COUNCIL MEETING: August 12, 2021 LOCATION: 708 Butler Ave. PIN: 40005 20006 APPLICANT: Habersharn Development, LLC. EXISTING USE: Single family home ZONING: R-2 review OWNER: KM Meter Farms H, LLC. USE PERMITTED BY RIGHT: After special APPLICATION: Special review Section 3-100 Beach, dune, or vegetation disturbance/crossover maintenance and construction. PROPOSAL: The applicant is requesting to construct a new crossover from the lot to the beach. ANALYSIS: The applicant is considering purchasing the property but would like assurance that a private crossover could be constructed before finalizing the deal. The Comprehensive Plan describes the Beachfront Neighborhood in which it lies as follows: The beachfront neighborhood to the east of Butler Ave. is exclusively R-2 zoning, with single family and multifamily, and duplex housing types. The area is characterized by wide streets with on street parking and old growth trees supplemented by side alleys. Public and private beach access are available. STAFF FINDING Without the addition of this crossover residents of the home would have to walk out to Butler and around to the Eighth St. crossover or walk through the dunes. Staff recommends approval. 1 Comprehensive Plan — Community Character Area Beachfront Neighborhood Recommended Development Strategies Meets Strategy YIN or NIA 1. Historic structures should be preserved whenever possible N/A 2. Enhance the pedestrian environment where feasible Y 3. Preserve old growth trees N/A 4. Preserve and maintain public beach access and enhance when necessary N/A 5. Do not allow the intrusion of commercial uses N/A 6. Preserve the low density character of the area N/A 7. Encourage preservation of the large historic beach to Butler Ave. lots N/A 8. STAFF FINDING Without the addition of this crossover residents of the home would have to walk out to Butler and around to the Eighth St. crossover or walk through the dunes. Staff recommends approval. 1 ATTACHMENTS A. Special Review application (5 pages) B. Description (I page) C. Construction drawings (I page) D. SAGIS map (I page) CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND Fee $500 SPECIAL REVIEW APPLICATION Applicant's Name Habersham Development, LLC - Health Shelton MEMEL= OR �j W M)hone Number 912-441-8190 Applicant's Mailing Address 403 Stewart Street Savannah, GA 31405 trjef description of the land development activity and use of the land thereafter to take place on the property: Boadwalk Crossover Property Owner's Name KM Meter Farms 11, LLC Telephone Number Z Property Owner's Address 310 Commercial Drive, Savannah, GA, 31406 Is Applicant the Property Owner? — Yes x W 11 1 1 ITITI 11111 1 1 11 1 11 !111 riIIIIIII III IIII!III I I EEE= M If Applicant Is other than the Property Owner, a signed affidavit from the Property Owner granting W -- Applicant permission to conduct such land development is attached hereto. — Yes Current Zoning of Property R-2 Current Use I Single Family Residence If within two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the Applicant's application for a zoning action, the Applicant has made campaign contributions aggregating to more than $250 to the Mayor and any member of Council or any member of the Planning Commission, the Applicant and the Attorney representing the Applicant must disclose the folloiMing: a. The name of the local government official to whom the campaign contribution or gift was made; b, The dollar amount of each campaign contribution made by the applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years Imi.medlately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action, and the date of each contribution; c. An enumeration and description of each gift having a value of $250 or more made by the Applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the applicaflon for this zoning action., x AA Si Alt(ant gna ure of bDate t , All NOTE: Other specific data Is required for each type of Special Review. ........... .... . ...... ...................... ............... . . . ............. Fee Amount Check Number Date 110 City Offlcial ��pp��iijiq��pi I iI I I [11,111i'll I I ME=, 11 ig��!I 111!1�� iq��11��111!v 1 101 11, 1 :111 I C-1011 I I C-11 MINI PlAar-41 A ml Mj INUM, ing oirisoiLiLgiitviir��iiLgmi M741.1 11 Signature of Applicant Date One West Park Avenue Savannah, GA 31401 (912) 232-7000 aAI 1 t' MW[Weislam L Is,WIN 3"'JUL'i'mLy 111LU -THEMILL U1 FAMMM AeSOWWS, ALe LALY 01 lynee and Chatham County in c(,--- wiffi future work, permits, licenses and other developmental matters for the property known as 708 Butler Avenue, Tybee Island, Georgia. The Company may, at any tmae, revoke this designation of agency. Otherwise, this designation of agency shall be deemed to be in full force and effect as to all pemns, institutions, and organizations which shall act in reliance thereon. 0' L*rd I I t4i.1489 I I Ky I I M I it 1# 1143 11 a OR 11AL4XIIi$11 ty.11 a I I Its41744 11FA' I It' MUM 111.1 Ir I WrIALY1 I I I W Signed, sealed and delivered in the.,*esenceof 10 Zo no I NLalhryn M&�af *hite 0 ary PU)jiic-- R NOTARY PUeW • Go Have you within the past two (2) years made campaign contributions or gave gifts having an aggregate value of $250.00 or more to a member of the City of Tybee Island Planning Commission, or Mayor and Council or any local government official who will be considering the rezoning application? Signature PIN: 4000520006 Project Address: 708 Butler Ave. Tybee Island, GA N171MUM= llaw�� Property Address Owner Name 0005 20014A 10 7th Terrace McEvoy, Brian F 8 7th Terrace Klugman, Daniel H ,1ii ii 6 ac London, Tracey C 6 7th Terrace —F—­Eddwards, Reoella, Mathew J I iii 4 7th Terrace James Bennett & Cindy Eta[ --- ....................................... 40005 20014D 2 7th Terrace Edwards & Daniel Madge L & Peg 4000520001 Terrace STALTAM ME off off 10 8th Terrace Hendrix Properties at Tybee, L 1i 11' j8th Terrace Levy, Joan L I ---T60� 8th Terrace Levy, " l 40005 20006 r , Most Current Owner Current Owner Co -Owner Care Of Mailing Address MCNEAL INVESTMENTS LLC ET AL* 494 BEAULIEU AVE SAVANNAH GA 31406 Digest Owner (January 1) Owner Owner Address 1 Address City State Zip MCNEAL INVESTMENTS LLC ET AL* CSI Status Parcel ID Category Code Bill # Address Unit / Suite City Zip Code Neighborhood Total Units Zoning Class Appeal Status -.. - . k,eed r -ed Pa < Inspection Date 03/10/2020 03/21/2016 07/21/2010 06/14/2007 494 BEAULIEU AVE SAVANNAH GA 31406 TYBEEILAND 31328- 20204.00 - T204 TYBEE BEACHFRON R-2 R3 - Residential Lots BEACH LOT 46 + 47 WARD 2 TYBEE 378G 548 Reviewer I D RKRYZAK MWTHOMAS LESTEPH AVMARCAN Tax Year Land Building Appraised Total Reason" 2021 3,688,200 98,300 3,786,500 2020 3,901,700 118,500 4,020,200 2019 3,901,700 118,500 4,020,200 2018 2,390,200 117,900 2,508,100 2017 2,390,200 121,800 2,512,000 2016 2,390,200 121,500 2,511,700 2015 2,390,200 125,900 2,516,100 2014 2,390,200 130,200 2,520,400 2013 2,390,200 130,200 2,520,400 2012 3,409,600 133,000 3,542,600 Sales Sale Date Sale Sale Instrument Book - Page Grantor Grantee Price Validity 06/05/2012 0 U QC 378G - 548 MCNEAL INVESTMENTS LLC ET 05/31/2012 0 U QC 12/20/2006 1,747,800 U WD 10/01/2000 0 U NA Residential Building AL* 377Z - 290 MCNEAL MCNEAL INVESTMENTS LLC ET INVESTMENTS LLC ET AL* AL* 319K - 0497 MCNEAL JUNE M ETAL MCNEAL INVESTMENTS LLC ET 217N - 0269 MCNEAL JUNE M ETAL MCNEAL JUNE M ETAL Card # 1 Actual Year Built 1928 Effective Year Built 1980 Type 1 - Single Family Residence Style/Stories 2 - TWO STORY Percent Complete 100 Quality 300 Condition AV - AVERAGE Living Area 2,730 Basement Area 0 Finished Basement Area No Bedrooms 4 Full / Half Baths 2/1 OBY Card # Description Year Built: Grade: Units: Override: Area: 1 907: ENCLOSED PORCH, SCREENED WALLS 1980 D 1 1,235 Item Area Main Building 1365 'AOTENCLDSEDPORCH, SCREENED WALLS 1235 Al - 711:711 -Built-in Garage (SF) 1235 SITE VICINITY MAP GENERAL DEVELOPMENT NOTES: 1. PIN: 40005 20006 ADDRESS: 708 Butler Ave CITY, STATE, ZIP 2. TOTAL LAND ACREAGE TOTAL DISTURBED ACREAGE 3. EXISTING USE OF PROPERTY PROPOSED USE OF PROPERTY PRESENT SITE ZONING PROPOSED LAND DEVELOPMENT = 2.36(±) AC = TBD(±) AC RESIDENTIAL (SINGLE FAMILY) RESIDENTIAL (SINGLE FAMILY) : R-2 : BOARDWALK CROSSOVER 4. THE MAJORITY OF THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN ZONE X, NOT A SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA, WITH A PORTION OF THE PROPERTY ON THE EAST IS LOCATED IN ZONE AE (8FE 9.0), A SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA AS DETERMINED BY FEMA FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAP # 13051CO214G, DATED 8/15/2018 5. REQUIRED ZONING SETBACKS: FRONT BUILDING SETBACK: REAR BUILDING SETBACK: SIDE BUILDING SETBACK: O 645-21-09 W. ^` 20' 10' 10' PREPARED FOR: Heath Shelton EH FORTITUDE 403 Stewart Street Savannah, GA 31405 912.443.1313 EXHIBIT DRWN: AM 6-18-2021 SCALE t':3V 30 ( ZONE AE 3 ` PTC..�..d,. o �00 m z W W I- CO ZONE AE g B B 280.4' a 14 0 t 0/0 OF LOT 3 OF A 2/0 OF BEACH LOT 45 SUBDIV EXISTING HOUSE TO REMAIN APPHOXIdIAATE LOCATETN'm^ 01, FLOOOUNE EASING OM FPANE RES 0 EACH LOT 45 FRAME 'E0E0 406.5' IIIIIIG11fIIiuw. 'I1 II 5'PEDESTR i BOARDWALK'S ACCESS EASE • ,< PEDESTRIAN BOARDWALK CROSSOVER CONCEPT PLAN Butter Ave Homes TERMINATION OF BOARDWALK AT BEACH ZZ 4 Q w vi 0 X W wI U F < -¢3 F - Z qw F F 4 F rn MALJPINtm un „ineening *COPYRIGHT 0021 tdevtn Engineering„ Inc. STAFF REPORT PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING: July 19, 2021 CITY COUNCIL MEETING: August 12, 2021 LOCATION: 3 Kingry St. PIN: 40019 03006 APPLICANT: Anne K. Smith EXISTING USE: Single family dwelling PROPOSED USE: Single-family dwelling COMMUNITY CHARACTER MAP: Marshfiront Neighborhood APPLICATION: Zoning Variance (5-090) from Section 3-090 (Schedule of Development Regulations). PROPOSAL: The applicant is requesting a setback variance to put a sunroom/screen porch 18" into the rear setback. ANALYSIS: The general character of the area surrounding this lot is residential. The size of this sub -standard lot is approximately 4250 square feet. The minimum lot size in the R-2 district is 4500 square feet. The requested variance does not meet the "hardship" test outlined in Land Development Code Section 5-090 (A): (1) That there are unique physical circumstances or conditions beyond that of surrounding properties, including irregularity, narrowness, or shallowness of the lot size or shape, or exceptional topographical or other physical conditions, or considerations related to the environment or the safety, or to historical significance, that is peculiar to the particular property; and, (2) That because of such physical circumstances or conditions, the property cannot be developed in strict conformity with the provisions of this Land Development Code, without undue hardship to the property. The required building setbacks for lots zoned R-2 are 20 -feet front, and 10 -feet rear and sides. The applicant is requesting approval of setback variance to put an enclosed porch on the rear of the building with an 18" setback encroachment. There is room for a porch on the back of the house without the variance. The lot is already developed. The Comprehensive Plan describes the Marshfiront Neighborhood in which it lies as follows: Along the marshftont exist residential uses of various ages, sprinkled with intermittent commercial uses. Zoning classifications area R-1, R -IB, R-2, and E -C. providing natural habitat, scenic views and access o the water via docks and creeks natural resources here require special consideration. Comprehensive Plan — Community Character Area Marsh/ront Neighborhood Meets Recommended Development Strategies Strategy YIN or NIA 1, Permit only uses compatible with area character. Y 2. Permit uses that will not adversely affect/impact the marsh environment' Y 3. Enforce marsh buffer ordinance within the area N/A 4. Prioritize tree preservation to protect the scenic and habitat value of the area N/A 5. 6. 7. 8. STAFF FINDING This lot is fully developed with a small home. There is room on all sides to enlarge the home within the setbacks. Staff recommends denial of the application. EMINIT41,61 10TIAMIJ A. Variance application B. Narrative C. Site Plan D. SAGIS map N This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. Fee "E" Commerdal $500 . . . . . . . Resideriffal $200 CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND VARIANCE APPLICATION from the Tybee Island Land Development Code Applicant: Anne K. Smith, Arch Telephone #: 912-232-5561 Email Address: Ann —.,8 e0lksarchitects.com Mailing Address Post Office Box 1587, Savannah, GA 31402 *Note: If the applicant is not the property owner as listed on the roDeU deed, a letter from J�j. li.,.teg owggsj. ttj"k" f r,7d-M1F1YZ1111j,-LT1C dAIJAM11L 1:0 aC[ in Eneir MRSIT MUSE De incluclea in application, in Oe PROCEDURE ADDlication 9gqgj[gMgn!�i All applications must be complete, including required supporting documents. Drawings or surveys will be 11" X 17" or larger. Incomplete applications will not be accepted and will delay review. A!20i li� Applications are due by 4:00 p.m. aft last day of the month before the next scheduled Planning Commission meeting. Apl2lication Submittal Return one copy of this completed application and all supporting documents to: Tybee Island Planning ant Zoning, City Hall, 404 Butler Avenue / P.O. Box 2749 City of Tybee Island, GA 31328 ADDlication Public Hearings Applications will be heard at a public hearing before the Planning Commission on the third Monday of each month, followed by a final decision by City Council at another public hearing on the second Tuesday of the following month. Each hearing will be held at 7 p.m. at the Public Safety Building, 78 Van Horn Dr. 3 Kingry Street, Tybee Island, GA 31329 WX1141411141 Existing use of Property: Existina Residence EMEMr -�b Proposed use of Property: Residence with rear addition Has the property been denied a variance in the past 12 months? If so, please provide brief details: Wo 1. Does the requested variance change the Tybee Island character designation for the property as described in the Master Plan? If so, provide a brief explanation. in, 2. Please explain the purpose after st variance and the intended development of the subject property if the variance is granted. The requested 18" rear yard setback variance will allow for a sunroom/screen porch to be added to the rear of the existing structure and will be similar to the surrounding development pattern. 3. Please explain the specific provision within the Tybee Island Land Development Code from is the variance is requested. Section 3-090 - Schedule of development standards, minimum rear yard setback, requesting an 18" variance from 10' to V-13". A. The need for a variance arises from the condition that is unique and peculiar to the land, structures and buildings involved. The surrounding structures have been added onto over time, many of them currently encroach the required 10' rear setback and do not conform to current setback requirements. ;�i J 11 1l�� 1111111111 1 1 11 -M I 1111111 11, 11111! i1romill J! 11 - 1.6 111TUVIVAJ-171GAM Mum in unnecessary narasnip Tor the owner, lessee or occupants as distinguished from a mere inctnvenience. the rear setback will take the lot coverage from 20% to 25% while the total allowed buildable area is 39%. C. The condition requiring the requested relief is not ordinarily found in properties of the same zoning district as the subject property. ; 1. , $- -I -- 11 Ili Ili III , M"IM0 14431"M are built over the current setback lines. Requiring the 10'setback will not allow enougV D. The condition is created by the regulation in the Tybee Island Land Development Code and not by the action of the property owner or applicant. This variance request is a result of the development code setback requirements rather than an a E. The granting of the requested variance will not conflict with Sec. 26 -70 -Amendments and modifications to the Fire Prevention Code of the Tybee Island Code of Ordinances or endanger the public. F. The variance requested is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structures. 5 # �-- I W1, CERTIFICATION i• I hereby certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, the above listed information and all attached supporting documents are complete and accurate. I understand that this application will require public hearings by the Tybee Island Planning Commission and City Council. I have been made aware and I hereby acknowledge the scheduled hearing dates/times and location where this application will be considered. I also understand that review of this application will require a site visit, and I herelky authorize City staff and members of the Planning Commission and City Council to inspect the r rrerty which i he suoject of this application. Signature Applicant Date 6-28-2021 If within two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the applicant's application for a zoning action, the applicant has made campaign contributions aggregating more than $250 to the mayor and any member of Council or any member of the Planning Commission, the applicant and the Attorney representing the Applicant must disclose the following: a. The name of the local government official to whom the campaign contribution or gift was made; b. The dollar amount of each campaign contribution made by the applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action, and the date of each contribution; c. An enumeration and description of each gift having a value of $250 or more made by the Applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application fqr this zoning action. C ment hereto: X Yes 6-28-2021 Signature of Ap-plicanV Date STAFF USE ONLY Date received: Received Fee Amount $ c200.06 Cl?ec* Number 4;�Efz Date? Planning Commission City Council — DECISION: (Circle One) Approved Denied Tybee Island Planning & Zoning City Hall, 404 Butler Avenue Post Office Box 2749 City of Tybee Island, GA 31328 Kingry Street Variance Request Agent for Owner This letter will serve as authorization for my architect, Anne K. Smith, to ae.j as my agent to represent me for this variance request. Current Owner: Address: Robin Crain 806-674-1481 3 Kingry Street &bee IsIR M M # • i r � 11 i r i ' . . # ' r i r • , / ii Um ''��i. WMI.iii <tw •�% i 4` w i' *� ; i>W.- Planning Commission, or Mayor and Council or any local government official who will be considering i # application? • • r �, ' r • ,. ,r • r � ' . • r . �. 3 K(k"V-J Adjacent ProReft Owneirs Please list all current owners of properties located immediately adjacent to or directly across the street from the subject property. This information may be obtained from the Chatham County Tax Assessor's office (912) 652-7271 or by using the website at www.boa.chat:han2gqqnbLgM The accuracy and completeness of this information shall be the responsibility of the applicant. 'P'roperty owners name and mailing address= 1. 4 Kingry & 6 KinqrV (empt lot), David Alan lannuzzi, Jr., P.O. Box 173, 2. 5 Kingry, Joshua Thompson, 237 Alexander Farms Road W, Statesboro, GA 30458 3. 112 South Campbell, Karin H 4. 110 South Campbell, Lorena Mitchell, 39 Look Homeward Drive, Burnsville, NC 28714 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 9 NOTE: This application must be accompanied by additional documentation, including drawings that include or illustrate the information outlined WMow. RE—FERENCE DESCRIFFION 5-040 (D) (1) Site plan and/or architectural rendering of the proposed development depicting the location of lot restrictions. 5-040 (D) (2) Narrative describing the hardship and the reason for the variance request. (Hardship means the circumstances where special condItIons, which were not self created or created by a rr owner, affect a palticular property and make strict conforwity with the restrictlons governing d1menslonal standards (SUCh as lot area, wIdth, setbacks, yard requlrements� or building height) unnecessarily burdensome or unreasonable in light of the purpose of this code. Unnecessaty hardship Is present only where, In the absence of a varlance, no feasible use can be made of the property.) Explain the hardship: The 10' rear setback will not allow for the equested addition of a sunroom/screen porch. 5-040 (D) (3) A survey of the property signed and stamped by a State of Georgia certified land surveyor. ® (A) (1) That there are unique physical circumstances or conditions beyond that of surrounding properties, including: X irregularity; — narrowness; or, — shallowness of the Itshape; or, —exceptional topographical or other physical circumstances, conditions, or considerations related tot environment, or the safety, or to historical significance, that is peculiar to the particular property; and; 5-090 (A) (2) Because of such physical circumstances or conditions, the property cannot be developed strict conformity with the provisions of the Land Development Code, without und hardship to the property. NOTE'. Provide attachments illustrating conditions on surroundinQ DroDerties and on the 5-090 is Height No part of any structure shall project beyond 35 -feet above the average adjacem'I grade of a property except: (1) See--sj%ction .2-010 terms and definitions; height of building. (2) The following items that were existing on the date of the adoption of this section; flag poles, television aerials, water towers and tanks, steeples and bell towers, broadcasting and relay towers, transmission line towers, and electric substation structures. The Applicant certifies that he/she has read the requirements for Variances and has provided the required information tat best of his/her ability in a truthful and honest manner. /111 2,1 Signature of Applicant -L= �-— Date I 5-090(C) Vafiance longevity, After a variance has been granted by the mayor and council it shall be valid for a period of 12 months from date of approval. Such approval is based on information provided in the application. Building permits may only be granted for plans consistent with the approved application. Any deviation from the information submitted will require separate approval by the mayor and council. 5 �%, �� �� 1i " 1 11" ^, CRAIN ROBIN 3 KINGRY ST Most Current Owner Current Owner Co -Owner Care Of Mailing Address CRAIN ROBIN PO BOX 210 TYBEE ISLAND GA 31328-0210 r @we Status Parcel ID Category Code Bill # Address Unit # / Suite City Zip Code Neighborhood Total Units Zoning Class Appeal Status Q Co -Owner Address 1 Address 2 City State Zip PO BOX 210 TYBEE ISLAND GA 31328 ACTIVE 40019 03006 RES - Residential 2935511 3 KINGRY ST TYBEEISLAND 31328- 20222.00HORSE �% R-2 R3 - Residential Lots LOT 43 PAMELA TERRACE SUB SAVANNAH BEACH 329X 0694 Permit # Permit Date Status Type Amount 080431-3 10/10/2008 Complete EL - ELECTRIC $2,000.00 060139-2 03/10/2006 Complete RN - RENOVATIONS $9,000.00 060138-1 03/07/2006 Complete RN - RENOVATIONS $800.00 Inspection Date Reviewer ID 03/27/2019 KMMORENO 10/20/2015 MWTHOMAS 06/14/2007 „ GDWHIDDO Appraised Values Tax Year Land Building Appraised Total 2021 96,900 105,200 202,100 2020 87,200 103,700 190,900 2019 87,200 63,300 150,500 2018 87,200 61,900 149,100 2017 87,200 55,000 142,200 2016 87,200 41,800 129,000 2015 85,600 41,600 127,200 2014 85,600 47,200 132,800 2013 85,600 47,200 132,800 2012 139,700 44,100 183,800 Sales Reason Sale Date Sale Sale Instrument Book - Grantor Grantee Price Validity Page 08/03/2007 279,000 Q WD 329X - 0694 CARTER THOMAS L & CRAIN ROBIN ELINOR 03/01/1987 53,000 U - 07/01/19811,500 Q Land Line Number Land Type Land Code Square Feet Acres Influence Factor 1 Influence Reason 1 Influence Factor 2 Influence Reason 2 Residential Building 1 U - UNIT 01 - SINGLE FAMILY RES 0 0 Card # 1 Actual Year Built 1981 Effective Year Built 1995 Type 1 - Single Family Residence Style/Stories 1 - ONE STORY Percent Complete 100 Quality 200 Condition Living Area Basement Area Finished Basement Area Bedrooms 864 REFERENCES i t OCMF CONCRETEMONUMENT FOUND 1. COORDINATESDIRECTIONS + ON GEORGIA it-DD:ZONE. IRS �# -!i SET 2 i'# i i#1 ii `MAP ! a ! is i `i` s it i#i '#^. OIRF IRON ROD FOUND 3- ONLY ABOVEGROUND. READILY VISIBLE STRUCTURES WERE LOCATED FOR THIS SURVEY. THIS SURVEYOR MAKES NO # POWR POLE WARRANTY OR GUARANTEE AS TO THE LOCATION, EASTENCE, OR NONEASTENCE OF ANY BELOW GROUND, NON—VISIBLE OR STRUCTURES. I. HVAC EQUIPMENTSEARCH.R THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE BOUNDARY OF THIS PROPERTY. THEY ARE NOT AND DO NOT CONSTITUTE A TITLE 5. NO SUBSURFACE OR ENVIRONMENTAL INVESTIGATION OR SURVEYS WERE PERFORMED FOR THIS PLAT. THEREFORE THIS PLAT DOES NOT REFLECT THE E)OSTENCE OR NONEyjSTENCE OF WETLANDS, CONTAMINATION, OR OTHER CONDITIONS WHICH MAY AFFECT THIS PROPERTY. LL O X l rl �,� (RAIN RESIDEN(E ADDITION V' i 1INFORMATION IS BASED ON iTAX RECORD CARDS AND FIELD 41 7 1 06/28/21 11 PROPERTY REQUESTING VARIANCE BUILT STRUCTURES L_j NEW ADDITION El TY LINE F J SETBACK LINE J J 1INFORMATION IS BASED ON iTAX RECORD CARDS AND FIELD 41 7 1 06/28/21 11 " r - N 0 114- w IRF TOTAL LOT AREA - 41250 SOFT TOTAL BUILDABLE AREA - 11650 SOFT % OF LOT (OVERAGE - 39% )'-0' SETBACK I N53*55'003'-'E 85.00' IRS 85.00' ALLOWABLE BUILDING AREA (EMPTY LOT WITH SETBARS) A F c b *0 t @ c I s Post Office Box 1587 Sayonnob, Georgia, 31402 (412)232®55 1 cons u outs: wort Oft limmant ism, lossirl-wouluff so rrvks dm"' 0 g ", vocholly fof the pF*d WOW in the No MA ad Fonewils the pm" of bb"i' L;mT'nK*qK@hn/SmllL ft my so be reproduced or wood In wlWo of k porl oe� .4 ed wlew the vefflon m5opf of mm� LomwKit/Womfimift date: date: JUNE 28, 2021 iob number. 2105 drawn by: AKS chocked by: 7 5131 SHEET: I ON AIM wort Oft limmant ism, lossirl-wouluff so rrvks dm"' 0 g ", vocholly fof the pF*d WOW in the No MA ad Fonewils the pm" of bb"i' L;mT'nK*qK@hn/SmllL ft my so be reproduced or wood In wlWo of k porl oe� .4 ed wlew the vefflon m5opf of mm� LomwKit/Womfimift date: date: JUNE 28, 2021 iob number. 2105 drawn by: AKS chocked by: 7 5131 SHEET: I ON 0 PO'—O' SETBACK IRF 53'5 '00" M I E116 TOTAL LOT AREA - 41250 SOFT TOTAL ENUOSED SPUE AREA - 866 SOFT % OF LOT (OVERAGE - 20% rMwo, an EXISTING PPP" I nMIGtrt Post Ofte Box1587 Savannah, Georgia, 31402 (912) 232-556 1 This document is an Instrument of service specifically for the project identified in The title block, and Molar the prep" Of Londood/Kohnom/Smith. It may not be reproduced or copied in whole or in part without the written WSW of lominack/Kolmon/Smith. date: job number: 2105 drawn III : AKS checkedb "112 ,2121 8 SHEET. 2 OF. 3 OF: W '^W v / Z 0 E �w 0 0 w I IRFI 31.29' I 0� — 0 LI 0 to z IRF I I 0 10' 201 TOTAL LOT AREA - t 250 SOFT TOTAL ENICLOSED SPAICE AREA WITH ADDITION - , 066 SOFT NOTE - ADDITION EQUALS 5% 11(OVERAGE 85.00' I R S – — — — I 10'-0" _ SETBACK ° 00 \ NEW SETBACK Ld ;� 17.59'1 0 0 '-" I EXISTING PORCH WALKWAY EXTEND TO REAR PORCH oADDgT10N I I 0 ° u) PORCH I I M 31.57' -N53°55'00"E 0 116 I I I I0 ILO ADDITION -j+I17.38' r 00 LOT 43 N I I N 0.098 ACRES 8' WOOD FENCE S53°55 0- - - - - - (18" VARIANCE) 1'-6" NEW SETBACK 10'-0" ImanuflElff 11111 114111111LOR A@hoot@cts Post Office Box 1587 Savannah, Georgia, 31402 (912)232-5561 consultants: _ Y _ e W a v z 3 KINGRY STREET Uj ° I LL- ° ONE STORY I 0 WOOD FRAME 0 I ° RESIDENCE 1 co I I I I0 ILO ADDITION -j+I17.38' r 00 LOT 43 N I I N 0.098 ACRES 8' WOOD FENCE S53°55 0- - - - - - (18" VARIANCE) 1'-6" NEW SETBACK 10'-0" ImanuflElff 11111 114111111LOR A@hoot@cts Post Office Box 1587 Savannah, Georgia, 31402 (912)232-5561 consultants: _ Y _ e W a This document is an instrument of service specifically for the project identified in the title block, and remains the property of Laminack/Kolman/Smith. It may not he reproduced or copied in whale or in part without the written consent of Lominack/KolmonjSethh. date: JUNE 28, 2021 "ob number: 2105 drawn by: AKS checked by: SHEET: 16 3 OF: >r This document is an instrument of service specifically for the project identified in the title block, and remains the property of Laminack/Kolman/Smith. It may not he reproduced or copied in whale or in part without the written consent of Lominack/KolmonjSethh. date: JUNE 28, 2021 "ob number: 2105 drawn by: AKS checked by: SHEET: 16 3 OF: