Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout20210816_PC_PACKET.pdfDernery Bishop Ron Bossick Marie Gooding Susan Hill Elaine T. McGruder David McNaughton I Whitley Reynolds Planning Commission MINUTES July 19, 2021 Commissioner David McNaughton called the July 19, 2021 order. Commissioners present were Marie Gooding, Susan I and J. Whitley Reynolds. Chair Demery Bishop and Vice "t Consideration of Minutes: Commissioner David McNaughton asked made a motion to approve. Elaine T. McGj Disclosures/Recusals: Commissioner David Old Business: TEXT AMEIS George Shaw stated the language that that has been changed and this change that prior language. Is the acknowledg, section? Also in Sec. 7040, who is pen also has the owner and contractor to si George Shaw Island Planning Commission meeting to tine T. McGruder, David McNaughton on Bossick were absent. of the June 21, 2021 meeting minutes. Susan Hill vote to ap-orove was unanimous. if there were any Disclosures or Recusals. There were none. Tree iission was not comfortable with at the last meeting so all the ordinance. Marie Gooding asked if this will help ent of the monitoring requirement duplicative of the other code zed isnot clear to me. George Shaw stated it probably does and this the application. Marie Gooding asked why City staff has to be on site for this. George Shaw stated this was a request from a Council member and I personally don't think it is necessary as long as the trees are identified on the application. Dale Williams who lives at I 10 1 Second Ave. approached the Planning Commission and stated he thinks having someone on site would be best to help enforce the cutting rules. Katherine Williams who lives at 1510 Chatham Ave. approached the Planning Commission and she thinks there needs to be supervision on the site. She also stated pine trees should be on the significant trees list and not Palm Trees, because they are not true trees. Whitley Reynolds stated he is not sure this is ready to go to City Council. Marie Gooding stated she cannot agree with requiring staff to be on site for every removal. She also stated we don't need to alienate our tree contractors. Elaine McGruder made a motion to approve. Susan Will seconded. Voting against were Marie Gooding and Whitley Reynolds. Voting in favor were Susan Hill and Elaine McGruder. David McNaughton voted in favor to make the vote 3-2. Motion to approve passed. New Business: TEXT AMENDMENT: Amendment to Sec. 3-250 Private Parking lots — Charles R. Cole. George Shaw stated Mr. Cole owns a lot between Railwood and Gulick adjacent to North Beach Parking lot entrance. He would like to have a pay to park lot like the seven that already exist. The code does not allow for any additional lots. Bubba Hughes our Attorney stated the only way this could go forward is if it is a text amendment. Patricia Leiby who lives at 812 Butler Avenue approached the Planning Commission and stated she thinks it is a good thing to have more parking but she is worried that if could expand and start a problem with too many parking lots. Charles Cole who lives at 17A Meddin Avenue approached the Planning Commission and stated this lot always has problems with cars blocking the driveway and he thinks it would help Parking on the Island if he could use it as a Parking overflow lot. David McNaughton asked to continue this till all members of the Planning are present. Elaine McGruder made a motion to continuo. Whitley Reynolds seconded. The vote to continue was unanimous. i7X 11d%-XIiL XXIL ♦ lli VT. LU11U "U" I UVVC911% \—I V.lJyycl — / VU "UL1G1 t1{'. U. — -rVVVJ 16VVVV —yUllC 1\-!r —Heath Shelton Habersham Development, LLC. George Shaw stated any crosswalk has to be reviewed by the City before they can get the DNR approval. So far since I have been with the City they have all been approved. Elaine McGruder stated this would not benefit anyone but the owner of the property and if we approve this what's to stop any other private owner from asking for a crossover. George Shaw stated he thinks not many can do them because they are very expensive to build. Patricia Leiby who lives at 812 Butler Ave. approached the Planning Commission and stated she would like to ask the Planning Commission to deny this. Jay Maupin with Maupin Engineering who is the representative for the applicant approached the Planning Commission and stated they would like to install this private crossover using DNR requirements. Currently there are crossovers near this property. The property on the north side is a short walk then a cow path through the dunes. We would not like to create any more issues with the dunes. David McNaughton asked if the applicant talked with the property owner at seventh terrace about using their crossover. Jay Maupin stated that is the one we were just talking about that is through the dunes and we do not want to create any additional damage to the dunes with extra foot traffic. David McNaughton asked is this a precursor of a subdivision application. Jay Maupin stated we had talked to George about building one additional house and renovate the existing house to be put on the Historic registry, also we want to reconfigure the driveway entrance to save trees on the Butler Avenue side. Heath Shelton who lives at 1.6 Izlar Avenue approached the Planning Commission and stated my wife and I would like to create a family compound on the lot and our intentions are to hopefully develop the lot out in accordance to the R-2 zoning for Tybee. Elaine McGruder asked if he will make this an STVR. Heath Shelton stated not at this time, it depends on an economy of scale. David McNaughton asked George Shaw based on the size of this lot how many homes can be built on it. George Shaw stated maybe eight or ten but you would have to land plan it and the dune area drops off significantly. Jay Maupin stated if we built to the current ordinance it would be eight. Whitley Reynolds stated we have gotten off the subject here, we have a plan for a dune crossover and we are talking about subdividing this property that is not a part of this. think we need to address what they have presented. David McNaughton stated we do need to consider the future. Jay Maupin stated Mr. Whitley is correct, all of this is hypothetical. Right now he would like to do what we said build a new home and renovate the existing home, put it on the Historical registry and then hold the property. Whitley Reynolds made a motion to approve. Marie Gooding seconded. Voting in favor were Susan Hill, Whitley Reynolds and Marie Gooding. Voting against was Elaine McGruder. Vote was 3-1. Motion to approve passed. VARIANCE: Rear Addition to residence — 3 Kingry St. — 40019 03006 — Zone R-2 — Anne K. Smith, Architect for Owner (Robin Crain) George Shaw stated that this is a small house and it sits well back on the lot. They would like to add an elevated rear porch. This would encroach 18" into the rear setback. There is room to do a narrower porch and there is no hardship. Staff had to recommend denial. Ann Smith the representative for the applicant approached the Planning Commission and stated this is a very small house and really does not have enough width to be viable or comfortable. Elaine McGruder asked if you build it the end post will be in the setback, wouldn't six feet be enough for a porch. Ann Smith stated after you add in all the exterior walls it makes it very tight. Elaine McGruder made a motion to deny. There was no second. Motion failed. Whitley Reynolds made a motion to approve. Marie Gooding seconded. Voting in favor were Marie Gooding, Whitley Reynolds and Susan Hill. Voting against was Elaine McGruder. Vote was 3-1. Motion to approve was passed. Discussions: Tybee Island 2016-2021 Comprehensive 1 George Shaw stated Cole Mullis a planner from the CRC Comprehensive Plan update. Cole Mullis stated this is an the review process by the Department of Community Affa review process. Cole Mullis stated he will address and inc City Council meeting they will hopefully approve a resolu Community Affairs to review. Then there will be forty day comments. Once the Department of Community Affairs al able to adopt. Adjournm Lisa L. Sct on the screen and will talk about the late and all that is left for this process is along with the simultaneous local Borate comments. Then at the August 12 1 to transmit the draft plan to the Tybee citizens to leave plan then City Council will be 6 1 I wall a a It A a Eel IN F.11 a a a IWAMW41 Mn MOM M WIMMOMM, I APPLICATION: Amendment to Article 3-250. Private parking lots PROPOSAL: To allow residents who own an empty lot adjacent to an existing City parking lot to apply for a private parking lot permit. ANALYSIS: This amendment was requested by a resident with a lot adjacent to the north beach entrance. He would like to charge parking on his lot between Railwood and Gulick. A site plan including layout, trash cans, access, etc. would be required during permit application process. The use of Railwood may be problematic due to the residential nature and narrowness of the road. STAFF FINDING The parking department doesn't see an issue with this particular lot having paid parking. I identified four other lots that meet this criteria. Each would be evaluated on a case by case basis. Staff has no recommendation on this amendment request. This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. ATTACHMENTS 4- A.w.e-t dwe-,(l I V xv W.110 I Biel Did I 019y M Applicant's Telephone Number 0 L142 Applicant's Mailing Address E If within two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the Applicant's application for a zoning action, the Applicant has made campaign contributions aggregating to more than $250 to the Mayor and any member of Council or any member of the Planning Commission, the Applicant and the Attorney representing the Applicant must disclose the following: a. The name of the local government official to whom the campaign contribution or gift was made; b. The dollar amount of each campaign contribution made by the applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action, and the date of each contribution; c. An enumeration and description of each gift having a value of $250 or more made by the Applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action. Disclosure of Campaign Contributions form attachment hereto: Yes Signature of Applicant Date -5ee. 3 rkvoo:-� ro�rk,� (a�s City Official Date Page 1 of 3 " This application must " accompanied i" additional documentation, " " and/or text that include " illustrate the information outlined below. i I I" I I I I" I i IF 11 1 Y 5-020 (E) An amendment to the text of this Land Development Code follows the same process as an amendment to the zoning map. However, a text amendment requires different materials to be included with the application. T 5-040 (E) (1) In the case of a text amendment, the application shall set forth the new text to be added and the existing text to be deleted. 5-110 Section 5-110, Standards for Land Development Code or Zoning Map Amendment Approval, identifies standards and other factors to be considered by the Mayor and Council in making any zoning decision. The Applicant should provide written data addressing each of the below listed standards and factors to assure consideration of applicable information. 5-110 (A) The existing land use pattern; 5-110 (B) The possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts; 5-110 (C) The existing population density pattern and the possible increase or overtaxing of the load on public facilities; 5-110 (D) Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed amendment reasonable; 5-110 (E) Whether the proposed change will adversely influence existing conditions in the neighborhood or the city at large; 5-110 (F) Potential impact on the environment, including but not limited to drainage, soil erosion and sedimentation, flooding, air quality, and water quality and quantity; 5-110 (G) The reasonableness of the costs required of the public in providing, improving, increasing or maintaining public utilities, schools, streets and public safety necessities when considering the proposed changes; 5-110 (H) Whether the proposed change will be detrimental to the value or improvement or development of adjacent or nearby property in accordance with existing requirements; 5-110(l) Whether the proposed change is out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or entire city; 5-110 (J) Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to the individual owner as contrasted with the adjacent or nearby neighborhood or with the general public; and, 5-110 (K) The extent to which the zoning decision is consistent with the current city master plan or other local planning efforts, if any, of the city. The Applicant certifies that he/she has read the requirements for Land Development Code Text Amendments and has provided the required information to the best of his/her ability in a truthful and honest manner. Signature of Applicant Page 2 of 3 III i el kq Have you within the past two (2) years made campaign contributions or gave gifts having an aggregate value of $250.00 or more to a member of the City of Tybee Island Planning Commission, or Mayor and Council or any local government official who will be considering the rezoning application? YES NO NAMEOF CONTRIBUTIONS GIFTS DATE OF GOVERNMENT OF $250.00 OF $250.00 CONTRIBUTION OFFICIAL ORMORE ORMORE L N no- HIM WI•W111 11.101ilii01 U-11116 TraVrIjkm I 'X�WVNA" I Do"T GIFTS IN EXCESS OF $250.00HAVE BEEN MADE TO ANY MEMBER OF THE PLA119KIG COidol SSION 0 Signature Printed Name Date Page 3 of 3 spaces o e located up e e s an Off -511-e dimensions of subsection 3-080(e) including drive aisles widths. All spaces must be sized to accommodate full sized vehicles. If the applicant for a private parking lot is not the property owner, a notarized affidavit authorizing the applicant to operate a private parking lot is required. After the submittal of the application, staff shall have the authority to recommend to council a maximum number of spaces allowed to be utilized at the requested parking lot. Upon submittal of fa the application with all pertinent application materials and following proper notification to adjacent property owners • the application, the mayor and • will consider the request for application at a scheduled meeting of the city council. Public comments, if any, will be allowed to be made at these • Council may reject any such application or may approve the application with conditions designed • to protect neighboring properties and households and customers including, but not limited to, xwoWA�rog rri.-xPjxtA-�m# the type of vehicles permissible for the location, the hours of operation, the requirement of security measures, buffers, noise control methods and any other conditions or requirements reasonably designed to lessen the impact of activity upon other properties or citizens. All private parking lot properties shall be marked with a maximum of one sign not to exceed two #42te1 riaht-of- way and not attached or placed on any sign, utility pole, bench, rock or any form of vegetation. The sign shall contain the name of the contact person or company and a telephone number. Any and all vehicles owned by the property owner(s), the parking lot attendant(s) and by friends or family of the property owner(s) and/or attendants(s) or otherwise parked on the property shall count toward the maximum number of spaces that are to be rented. that had been required with the initial application. Each application for renewal of a license to operate a private parking lot on Tybee Island will be subject to an annual review during the month of January for compliance. Any and all incident reports and citations shall be considered during the annual review. If compliance has not been met the license may be revoked by city council upon a hearing that will take place during a regularly scheduled city council meeting or an application for renewal may •` `• Following • and • the mayor and cooke, suspend, • refuse to renew a license previously granted upon a finding that the license -holder, his agent, representative, or employee has failed to comply with all terms and conditions of the license or has failed to compl with other relevant ordinances of the city or other applicable law(s). I M Me U -111M 01-4m,-11 0 a Mon 'I Efie acitm;�9 licensing. P ii�� INTO ji� 1111's I= 1111 1!, llj��iijpi; 0151 8/4/2021, 1:24:09 PM 1:564 Zoning Property Boundaries (Parcels) D 0 0.01 0-02 m! FIWJIMMr j �#, m AID: 40002 20005 COLE CHARLES R GULICK ST Most urrnOwner Current Owner Co -Owner Care Of Mailing Address COLE CHARLES R PO BOX 1442 TYBEE ISLAND GA 31328-1442 Digest Owner (January 1) Owner Co -Owner Address 1 Address 2 City State Zip COLE CHARLES R PO BOX 1442 TYBEEISLAND GA 31328 Status ACTIVE Parcel ID 40002 20005 Category Code RES - Residential Bill # 3010604 Address GULICK ST Unit # / Suite City TYBEEISLAND Zip Code 31328 - Neighborhood 20270.00 - T270 TYBEE SCREVEN Total Units Zoning -1 Class R3 - Residential Lots Appeal Status ... Legal Description LOTS 17 18 FORT SCREVEN WARD BLO CK 11 Deed Book Deed Page Inspection Date Reviewer ID 04/01/2020 RKRYZAK 03/23/2016 MWTHOMAS 04/23/2009 TLWH ITFI Tax Year Land Building Appraised Total Reason 2021 150,500 0 150,500 2020 150,500 0 150,500 MATOR Shirley Sessions CITY COUNCIL Barry Brown, Mayor Pro Tern John Branigin Jay Burke Nancy DeVetter Michael "Spec" Hosti Monty Parks CITY Of TYBEE ISLAND Anxim"M I K, rm To no 0; nu. t -M The Mayor and Council of the City of Tybee Island will hold a Public Hearing at the Public Safety Building78 Van Horneon Thursd.y, January 28, 2021at 7:00pm. On= i• •'. 215 Lovell Ave.; PIN 4-0004-09-008A; R-2; Marianne Bramble,, petitioner 1001 Butler Ave.; PIN 4-0006-14-013; Zone R-2; Renee Bridges, petitioner 214 Second Ave.; PIN 4-0004-09-007; Zone R-2; Joyce Prescott,, petitioner 20314 th St.; PIN 4-0007-18-001; Zone R-2; lack Rosenbergpetitioner 1511 Butler Ave.; PIN 4-0008-07-005; Zone C-1/SE; Agnes Yao, petitioner 1401 Strand ; PIN 4-0008-02-016; Zone C-1/SE; Brett Loehpetitioner Anyone wishing to speak to this issue may do so. It will be necessary to sign a Disclosure form before the Hearing. The form is available at City Hall. P.O. Box 2749 — 403 Butler Avenue, Tybee Island, Georgia 31328-2749 (912) 786-4573 — FAX (912) 786-5737 MME. city ofLbee.org ___ I n O _ p D F., QPli Wr' r A � N N ul � C m T z A N VI m m N V1 ri LU 00 Q1 'J O ® '... A m LU W N li 00 U7 N '.. N OLO 00 A N Z n W m A O Q z w � I u� - N Q N O m G) m 5 > > D D � 7 W O Gl Gl A Z I -A Ul N ® C m A A ® C O _ p D F., QPli Wr' r A � N N ul � C m T T m N VI (A '. Vf N V1 ri LU 00 Q1 'J O ® '... A l0 N LU W N li 00 U7 N '.. N OLO 00 �Tf O Q O O Q O '.. N N O O . N O N O N Q N O !� IQ Ik-a IN to IQ '.� m m m m m T T m N VI (A '. Vf N V1 tp N '.. N OLO 00 N Z m n A A cn A � Q Z m m m m A >Z N ;oGl Ln n%� -n A Z m G) G) p = ) AA vmi "< A PO Ul) 7K Z 2 z ;v Z Gl G) A Z a� N N �p ® NJ 0 w ti O l^ C 4A r m n = C r m r r f77 � G P 00 ® w 00 Al na 0 0 iv o o r� a rs ry 0 F* na 0 tv 0 T o T No o 0 0 a, 0 ua 0 0kDa w w a anis Ivmi Iv (.m V) Tann m m m m m m m m Ln cn IV) cn cn l0n N w O w 00 " F67k/V3s 3711[ 3La"drW' ONV 772f V AS 5'? 1Tasd'Z7 ��B6 -6Z'f (Zd 61 .����. 39 .(YW IM Sia V3 Amk" 01 1aVi��xdQ3Q NVNNV`r{VS 3rans st LY7d s1N1 MON OVOY i17 061 , gg .977 '9N1,i3/tdns ONV7 SrddVx .93di FF &05/97 135 vlk v05 :.Llu d/n03 'IMA p7 0 4 000006/1 < =1771 s1N3m-m1nO3d ONV SOdVONV1S rvnrvlNlav 09 k 000'OZ/1 < -973IJ ssvd6YdJ =d9 031sn/�OV 3X1 x1/Ri dldiYdd3NOO N! 03171311 ld '.9NV dad .Z=ifOXU3 �WV N338 SVH QNV 0311V7d ONV7 3 3Y/7SO70 30 YOdY3 3x1 30 NOF1 V1N3S3Yd3d 31 VdnJJV NY S/ SIHI A(MVV6��d/��O{ AM H/ j V HI pAJIJ1Lgf3��J/ } j { ;fig ` { 900-01 ,#e0r ��BYY��CI ��fViV Y i��Y Y4 011eolzo 31 VO 03.4-7AlnS c6/Za/Lo :31rrr ,s3nzdns a73r.�� PE'.01.0 f d0 (I1VV7Sl 33SAI 3A V 773/107 913 -Sr NINCIV ! OS7V 6� 11 'd 1L111 90 'f 3131YONQO -aNO3 6 "d Z MOOS dVsY 'Z 3,9M3.9 VN17 NlVHO 370 3V 3NOZ Nf 53i1 %1131011 SFx1 0�1 'd 'd IV7d `d 8313H 8831 VM YVM� �S37N3cY333N 7317 aa��7z7x add7d 77/J3ds 7 3N/7 3ON3-Y NiH1L s3/7 (JY3dOdd C3,(3AY179 3H1 ON1703 IN3M/7NOtY 313dONOO 3/YO 90-94-6 031VO 396Z0J1S0Ft dvx 31Vd 000n 3d1d ,NOXI 3d/ s 33NV8179MI d0d73 3H1 01 3NIGYG,??V =QN3937 Al `0 -'S_76fO V19dO30 `A1Nn00 VHiVH:D 'Cl NTIS1 338A1 ``TVTO H1S `t CNV `V-VZ10'130 ,Qtr N83HinOS 3H1 2' Yd -2Z 10-1 30 iV-1d ,OZ= .. L ^TWDs _ e w�p `d�Z i B9 a 9'+tiag yuvtr 4LLYd' > 0') gaols z p c�� Tc era esz 1�� cac-60-1,000-* # NId JIN 0`9L vVZ .fo , N83Funos ������ry-s .g a �� .esz cn ca a a +,rd �p $ 001 v8vsave C 1q VE d v)p 1Y13lY dl3 z .09'9L tai 000M S 3.00,0�. LLS o r+3 alt 7 ' ' �� 6QQ-6Q b��Qii tr # ui LOVELL AVENUE 6V R/W N 10'20'-a.7"—E 5 AeE z 0 0 Gaul Nm 0.0. ? F m m U OR > 8 '0 0 'n > 00 75 eSa p Rl> �qq AkF z OR rn 0 z vm v r' >z z 1j lw C rnm 0 rn to Z4 in a z 0 OD z BUTLER AVENUE 8V R/W 120.00'_ ff� I I U NQ AkF rn I I p I Q emu i SECOND AVENUE 60 K/W r 00 0 i 1 s e a �I ZI y, ttl p t i Ir i E O'> Y 'iffisf XZ=M lVR ZZU OlUdDS SCO ZT, XWO os -L T Zvi as'a co -wig mm-aw. P'I'l *lq4, "t WIN "a mg zw.w nm—m Tx eMID 10 MXYM UN -i N U2 ly -a -AVL ZZ -66 ON na 5661'9 lkwflum -Uva ,oz - A :R7vDs OZ. Q -3i SLR LLuilawl mmvl.- -DRY -!1 :Uvam Mmsorm 110 Hom Tri-dy MO3aOl -1_.MMRab;K 'asnoR AoRs cL goou'oi aNnr aasUZ9 4944 -M -M -'XVII 4990-Z9e-ZTS :HKORdMR1 901,1P VIDROM 'HYMNAVS 3 SIMS afwa&v mosmaa,321S 9C9 uoln Ms akv-1 SMOKM Xamum -r 7ZK= a0OU Hvzk 001 ami lual sa lori SIEU 96AT/9 =Y(E 7EYFli Ua O.F. ON11T.T000v 99-L AM Vd KI ITfN Q -3i SLR oi;,vc STs S! C/1 Agois Tw zo [j [I o C2 RFL Ir --1 IF - 1-11 99-L AM Vd KI ITfN R/Zl 109 anNalff CIN00as 00/koo d 7961e uouueo M BUTLER AVENUE WRIW N 2-72516' i- – r— — . mss- ® 7;fs-X'" I v so I WE - If 2 Sun S-- 22- 9 9" I v so If 2 S-- 22- I v so 5 @ e'X 18' i 57'-G' > G @ 9' x 18` 64 Sunrise Parkin,3 Lots 29 * 30 sa— - - - ---------- ---------- --- - - R 51te Plan 3@9' 15' 70 UD CA rn F - 2@9'X20' > rn 70 0 > G @ 9' x 18` 64 Sunrise Parkin,3 Lots 29 * 30 sa— - - - ---------- ---------- --- - - R 51te Plan PLANNING COMMISSION Meeting date: July 19, 2021 Project Name/Description: Amendment to Sec. 3-250 Private Parking lots Special Review Subdivision: Site Plan Approval Sketch Plan Approval Conceptual Variance Preliminary Plan Approval Map Amendment Final Plat Approval Text Amendment X Minor Subdivision -Major Subdivision Petitionerhas met all documentation requirements, all external approval requirements, and all code requirements, except for the following: The Planning Commission Motion on Petition: E] Approval ❑ Denial E Continued COMMISSIONER FOR AGAINST COMMENTS Bishop ABSENT Bossick ABSENT Gooding X Hill X McGruder X MOTION McNaughton Reynolds X SECOND Planning Commission Chair: Date: -e-lee, J2 -r J - Date: STAFF REPORT PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING: August 16, 2021 CITY COUNCIL MEETING: September 9, 2021 . . . . . . . . . . LOCATION: 12 10' Place PIN: 40006 17003 APPLICANT: Jeffrey Kole EXISTING USE: Single family dwelling FAVIN11-1214M I OWNER: Jeffrey Kole PROPOSED USE: Single family dwelling APPLICATION: Applicant requests a variance from Sec. 3-090 to build a screen porch that will extend approximately eight feet into the front setback. PROPOSAL: The applicant is requesting to add on to an already nonconforming porch. The surface under the proposed addition is concrete so there would not be any additional impervious surface. ANALYSIS: While the proposed addition would not create additional impervious surface it is an additional encroachment into the setback on a home that already encroaches into the setback. The lot is the same size and shape as those around it and is fully developed. The requested variance does meet the "hardship" test outlined in Land Development Code Section 5-090 (A): (1) That there are unique physical circumstances or conditions beyond that of surrounding properties, including irregularity, narrowness, or shallowness of the lot size or shape, or exceptional topographical or other physical conditions, or considerations related to the environment or the safety, or to historical significance, that is peculiar to the particular property; and, (2) That because of such physical circumstances or conditions, the property cannot be developed in strict conformity with the provisions of this Land Development Code, without undue hardship to the property. (3) A nonconforming use or structure does not constitute a unique physical circumstance, condition, or consideration. The Comprehensive Plan describes the Beachfront Neighborhood District as follows: The Beachfront Neighborhood to the east of Butler Avenue is exclusively R-2 zoning, with single family, multifamily, and duplex housing types. Wide streets with on street parking and old growth trees supplemented by side alleys characterize the area. Public and private beach access are available. Comprehensive Plan — Community Character Area I The Beachfront Neighborhood District Meets Recommended Development Strategies Strategy YIN or NIA 1. THitoric, structures should be, preserved whenever possible y H STAFF FINDING Staff recommends denial. This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. ATTACHMENTS A. Special review application B. SAGIS map (I page) C. Survey showing existing foundation, D. Construction drawing =nhance the pedestrian environment where feasible N/A 3. Preserve old growth trees N/A 4. Preserve and maintain public beach access and enhance when necessary N/A 5. Do not allow intrusion of commercial uses N/A 6. Preserve the low density character of the area N/A 7. Encourage preservation of the large historic beach to Butler Ave. lots N/A 8. N/A STAFF FINDING Staff recommends denial. This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. ATTACHMENTS A. Special review application B. SAGIS map (I page) C. Survey showing existing foundation, D. Construction drawing Fee Commercial $500 Residential $200 CITY OF TYSEE ISLAnD VARIANCE APPLICATION from the Tybee Island Land Development Code Applicant: Telephone #: -Email Address: Mailing Address *Note: If the applicant is not the property owner as listed on the property deed, a letter from the listed owner(s), including a telephone number and address along with any other relevant information, authorizing the applicant to act in their behalf must be included in the application. PROCEDURE Application Reauirements dig jW Drawigs or surveyLw1ill Application Deadline Applications are due by ® p.m. of the last day of the month before the next scheduled Planning Commission meeting. APOlication Submittal Return one copy of this completed application and all supporting documents to: Tybee Island Planning and Zoning, City Hall, 403 Butler Avenue / P.O. Box 2749 City of Tybee Island, GA 31328 ADDlication Public Hearings Applications will be heard at a public hearing before the Planning Commission on the third Monday of each iiijjil at inother public hearing on the second Tue d of th'A go�jjlj Wr Tax Map/Parcel ID#: 4-0006-17-003 Current Zoning: R-2 Existing use of Property: Single- family home ,wroposed use of Property: 9� M16 1111 1,111pi ��� IM# 1. Does the requested variance change the Tybee Island character designation for the property as described in the Master Plan? If so, provide a brief explanation. No. The requested variance does not change the Tybee Island character designation in the ter Plan. 2. Please explain the purpose of the requested variance and the intended development of the subject property if the variance is granted. To enclose the existing ground floor open slab porch, and to extend the second-sto , !7d:1 3. Please explain the specific provision within the Tybee Island Land Development Code from which the variance is requested. 3-090, Minimum Front Yard Setback Distance. A. The need for a variance arises from the condition that is unique and peculiar to the land, structures and buildings involved. The structure is a pre-existing, nonconforming residential structure. The proposed B, The variance is necessary because the particular physical surroundings, the size, shape or topographical condition of the property involved would result in unnecessary hardship for the owner, lessee or occupants as distinguished from a mere inconvenience. applicant is unable to expand the premises in any direction. C. The condition requiring the requested relief is not ordinarily found in properties of the same zon��g district as the subject property. a WOUSIMM11111 D. The condition is created by the regulation in the Tybee Island Land Development Code and not by t action of the property owner or applicant. i of the property owner. Sam' asl 9 a-- low -01 iW—#1H7AMMN7=- slits] 1111jr w 111 111 F. The variance requested is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structures. Yes, the variance request is the minimum variance possible and conforms to the existing -pw:ameters of t -ren+ nr-..mn .he enGrGaGhment by the — -.1— slab POrGh. Aoiacent Pro ert _Owners p _y Please list all current owners of properties located immediately adjacent to or directly across the street from the subject property. This information may be obtained from the Chatham County Tax Assessor's office (912) 652-7271 or by using the website at www. boa. chathamcounty.org The accuracy and completeness of this information shall be the responsibility of the applicant. 1. T bee entals., LLC 2. Richard M. Geriner - ri I ri gait v X40 3., Jeffr l i riv v n 1 11 4. David Matthew and Preston Morrison - 3261 Casteel Road NE Marietta GA 30062 5, Jane and Leon--Slotin - 6401 Habersham Street, Apt, 3A, Savannah, GA 31405 6. Jane Shuman - PO Box 145?, Tybegjsland, GA 3132§ -- 7. Barbara Lubar - PO Box 1937, Tybee Island, GA 31328 8. Michael Gesser - 120 Greenview Circle Tybee Island GA 31328 9. io. Edward Rosenzweig - 122 W Huntingdon Street, Savannah, GA 31401 11. Paul Schenker - 3330 Primavera Street, Pasadena, CA 91107 12. Claude and Camrlyn Royal - PO Box 16.5-7 fbee lsland_,GA 31328 Ty 13. Julia McElrov - PO Box 490, o ansville, GA 30230 14. 15. Howard and Faith Levy - 917 Springdale Road, Atlanta, GA 30306 -d2--LT,--LLC ---3323 Quesada Street NW, Washington DC 20015 16. 17. Tenth Place LLC - 35 Island Drive, Savannah, -GA 31406 18. George and Kelly Calvert - 2985 Rennells Roa!,S Vring-Lake MI 49456 19. ME M NOTE: This application must be accompanied by additional documentation, including drawings that include illustrate the information outlined below. I REFERENCE DESCRIPTION 5-040 (D) (1) Site plan and/or architectural rendering of the proposed development depicting the location of lot restrictions. 5-040 (D) (2) Narrative describing the hardship and the reason for the variance request. (Hardship means the circumstances where special condItzons, which were not self created or created by a pnor owner, affect a particular pro perty and make strict conformity with the restrictions governing rnal standards (such as lot area, w1dth, setbacks, yardrequirement o 5, r building height) unnecessanly burdensome or unreasonable In fight of the purpose of this code. Unnecessary hardship is present only where, in the absence of a variance, no feasible use can be made of the property.) Explain the hardship: Hardship created by the Ordinance; existing encroachments_ unnecessarily burdensome. 5-040 (D) (3) A survey of the property signed and stamped by a State of Georgia certified land surveyor. 5-090 (A) (1) That there are unique physical circumstances or conditions beyond that of surrounding properties, including: — irregularity; narrowness; or, — shallowness of the lot shape; or, —exceptional topographical or other physical circumstances, conditions, or considerations related tothe environment, or the safety, or to historical significance, that is peculiar to the particular property; and; 5-090 (A) (2) Because of such physical circumstances or conditions, the property cannot be developed in strict conformity with the provisions of the Land Development Code, without unduLz hardship to the property. NOTE: Provide attachments illustratinci conditions on surroundinci DroDerties and on the subiect Droi)ertv, indicating uniqueness, etc. 5-090 (B) Height No part of any structure shall project beyond 35 -feet above the average adjacent grade of a property except: (1) See section 2-010 terms and definitions; height of building. (2) The following items that were existing on the date of the adoption of this section; flag poles, television aerials, water towers and tanks, steeples and bell towers, broadcasting and relay towers, transmission line towers, and electric substation structures. The Applicant certifies that he/she has read the requirements for Variances and has provided the required information to the best of his/her ability in a truthful and honest manner. iii SMEMMU=1 M- 5 -090(C) Variance longevity. After a variance has been granted by the mayor and council it shall be valid for a period of 12 months from date of approval. Such approval is based on information provided in the application. Building permits may only be granted for plans consistent with the approved application. Any deviation from the information submitted will require separate approval by the mayor and council. CERTIFICATION AND AUTHORIZATION I hereby certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, the above listed information and all attached supporting documents are complete and accurate. I understand that this application will require public hearings by the Tybee Island Planning Commission and City Council. I have been made aware and I hereby acknowledge the scheduled hearing dates/times and location where this application will be considered. I also understand that review of this application will require a site visit, and I hereby authorize City staff and members of the Planning Commission and City Council to inspect the property which is the subject of this application. Signature of Q�� (� Applicant��—�.) Date If within two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the applicant's application for a zoning action, the applicant has made campaign contributions aggregating more than $250 to the mayor and any member of Council or any member of the Planning Commission, the applicant and the Attorney representing the Applicant must disclose the following: a. The name of the local government official to whom the campaign contribution or gift was made; b. The dollar amount of each campaign contribution made by r• to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action, and the date of each contribution; c. An enumeration and description of each gift having a value of $250 or more made by the Applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action. JIM =* - Yes Date Have you within the past two years madea• i i+ i or ia.'" gifts having an aggregate value of $250.00 or it to. member of the City of e Planning Commission,and Council or any local government official i will be considering is • application YES NO NAME OF GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL CONTRIBUTIONS OF $250.00 OF $250.00 OR MORE OR MORE DATE OF CONTRIBUTION 0- SAGIS Map Viewer 6/28/2021 12:52:08 PM 1:564 0 0 0.01 0.02 mi Property Boundaries (Parcels) ----------- 0 0.01 0.01 0.02 km SAGIS m Chatham County, Georgia Page I of 4 PARID:4000617003 JEFFREY H. KOLE & LEEANN A. KOLE, AS JTW 12 10TH PL Most Current Owner Current Owner Co- Care Mailing Address Owner Of JEFFREY H. KOLE & LEEANN ROS KOLE MANAGEMENT COMPANY 1719 ABERCORN, A. KOLE, AS JTW STREET SAVANNAH GA 31401 Owner Co- Owner Address I Address 2 city State Zip JEFFREY H. KOLE & ROS KOLE 1719 ABERCORN STREET SAVANNAH GA 31401 LEEANN A. KOLE, AS MANAGEMENT JTvv COMPANY Z= - Status ACTIVE Parcel ID 4000617003 Category Code RES - Residential Bill # 2953182 Address 12107 PL Unit # / Suite 04/03/2018 City TYBEEISLAND Zip Code 31328 - Neighborhood 20213.00 - T213 TYBEE BTL BEACH Total Units $500.00 Zoning R-2 Class R3 - Residential Lots Appeal Status Legal Description LT 3 SUB BEACH LT 64 WD 3 TYBEE Deed Book 1880 Deed Page 0766 Permit # Permit Date Status Type Amount 190589 11112/2019 Complete RN - RENOVATIONS $28,000.00 180255-2 04/03/2018 Complete RN - RENOVATIONS $900.00 160374-1 07113/2016 Complete EL - ELECTRIC $500.00 file:IIIC:IlJsersljyelIlAppDatalLocallPackages/ windows—ie—ac—OOIIACITemplQOWL6AJ... 6/28/2021 Chatham County, Georgia Inspection Date Reviewer I 01/29/2020 RKRYZAK 01/10/2019 JEADY 07/22/2016 H S 02/15/2013 AS 07/28/2010 LESTEPH Tax Year Land Building Appraised Total 2021 201,600 318,400 520,000 2020 201,600 318,400 520,000 2019 201,600 318,400 520,000 2018 201,600 288,400 490,000 2017 201,600 288,400 490,000 2016 201,600 288,400 490,000 2015 204,400 259,000 463,400 2014 204,400 263,200 467,600 2013 204,400 262,500 466,900 2012 204,400 114,100 318,500 Reason •� i Page 2 of 4 Sale Sale Book Sale Date Price Validity Instrument Pae ranter Grantee 03/17/2020 0 U GD 1880 - 0271 KOLE JEFFREY H. JEFFREY H. KOLE LEEANN A. KOLE, JTWROS 03/17/2020 0 U WD 1880 - 0766 KOLE JEFFREY H. JEFFREY H. KOLE LEEANN A. KOLE, AS JTW 09/04/2012 550,000 Q WD 380 - 590 JOSPIN OL JEFFREY H JFTTi t Line Number 1 Land Type U - UNIT Land Code 01 - SINGLE FAMILY E Square Feet 0 Acres 0 Influence Factor 1 5 Influence Reason 1 file:///C:/Users/jyell/App at ocal/Paces/wino s ie ac 001/AC/Te p/ 6A3... 6/28/2021 Chatham County, Georgia Influence Factor Influence Reasol Residential Building Card # Actual Year Built Effective Year Built Type Style/Stories Percent Complete Quality Condition Living Area Basement Area Finished Basement Area Bedrooms Full / Half the 1 1948 1990 1 - Single Family Residence 2- TWO STORY 100 400 AV -AVERAGE 2,416 0 V 3 2/0 nit for this Item Area Main Building 1069 Al - 100:100- LIVING SPACE 250 Al 0 - 907:907 -Enclosed Porch (SF), Scree 250 A2 -100:100- LIVING SPACE 28 A3 - 904 -.904 -Slab Porch (SF) with Roof 40 A4 - 907:907 -Enclosed Porch (SF), Scree 85 A5 - 908:908 -Enclosed Porch (SF), Knee 150 . . ........ A6 - 907:907 -Enclosed Porch (SF), Scree 150 Page 3 of 4 file:IlIC:ItJsersljyelllAppDatalLocallPackageslwindows—ie—ac—OOIIACITemplQOWL6AJ... 6/28/2021 Chatham County, Georgh- A8 - 901:901 -Open Slab Porch (SF) 170 - 907:907 -Enclosed Porch (SF), Scree 12 ERROR OF CLOSURE: FIELD: 1/30,446 ANGULAR ERROR OF 2" PER ANGLE POINT AND ADJUSTED BY COMPASS METHOD PLAT CLOSURE 1:INFINITY EQUIPMENT. TOPCON GTS236 TOTAL STATION; SINGLE PRISM ACCORDING TO F.I.R.M. MAP NO. 13051CO326G. EFFECTIVE DATE 8/16/2018, THIS PARCEL SHOWN HEREON LIES IN ZONE X NOT A SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA OTH r r A �-- MKINIUMIq IRF_- ----------®-- S 6°00'00`E 140.00' IE(W)=6.77 IE(S)=6.48 �-- �_—_ �--------�----_ S66°00'00'E 70,00' - IE(W)=8.65 4 IE(S)=8.95 6' GIP ------- ®Q'� �f , PIN: 40006 17003 it boundaries. The recording information of the IIU LOT 3 OF 11 documents, maps, plats, or other instruments which 17„ T3 1 ADDRESS: create this parcel or parcels are stated hereon. PIN# 40003 17003 Surveyed For: 1 0.12 Vincent H lmly 0120, !1 APPROVAL OF ANY LOCAL JURISDICTION, AVAILABILITY SAVANNAH, GEORGIA 31405 tes 85,4' 12 l o OR G SCALE: 1"=20 FT DATE . 211 21 B No. 21-3 OR REQUIREMENTS, OR SUITABILITY FOR ANY USE OR PURPOSE OF THE LAND. Furthermore, the undersigned i O I n 1 1 Q` N 1 1 J NO. 1882 T of the Georgia Board of Registration for Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors and as set forth in ®1® PIN. 40006 17002 0 BTF—BOLT FOUND CONCRETE PAVEMENT O.C.G.A. Section 15-6-67. o v 0 IRF—IRON ROD FOUND BARBARA L LUBAR ETAL I TWO STORY Iv CIRF—CRIMPED IRON ROD FOUND BRICK PAVEMENT L/ -1 CIP CAST IRON PIPE CONC, BLOCK &I a PP POWER POLE VINCENT HELMLY NO. 1882 DATE: OHP FRFF=AME11, SIDENCE R Cu I z SCR. PORCH I STORAGE ADDITION' ' 16-0 1 1 1 11 1 1 " BRI]KEN ASPHALT - & GRAVEL 1 SANITARY SEVERMH o= IE(E)=4.09 IE(W)=6.77 IE(S)=6.48 IECE)=8.77 IE(W)=8.65 4 IE(S)=8.95 6' GIP ------- ®Q'� �f it boundaries. The recording information of the IIU LOT 3 OF 11 This plat is a retracement of an existing parcel or o= IE(E)=4.09 IE(W)=6.77 IE(S)=6.48 parcels of land and does not subdivide or create a _ new parcel or make any changes to any real property U M> ®a boundaries. The recording information of the & TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY LOT 3 OF BEACH LOT 60) WARD 3 documents, maps, plats, or other instruments which CHATHAM COUNTY, GEORGIA ADDRESS: create this parcel or parcels are stated hereon. PIN# 40003 17003 Surveyed For: CAD AN DESIGNS RECORDATION OF THIS PLAT DOES NOT IMPLY Vincent H lmly 0120, 129—A BURTON ROAD APPROVAL OF ANY LOCAL JURISDICTION, AVAILABILITY SAVANNAH, GEORGIA 31405 (912) 429-9395 OF PERMITS, COMPLIANCE WITH LOCAL REGULATIONS OR G SCALE: 1"=20 FT DATE . 211 21 B No. 21-3 OR REQUIREMENTS, OR SUITABILITY FOR ANY USE OR PURPOSE OF THE LAND. Furthermore, the undersigned G\ST�'R land surveyor certifies that this plat complies with the minimum technical standards for property surveys Q` in Georgia as set forth in the rules and regulations NO. 1882 LEGEND of the Georgia Board of Registration for Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors and as set forth in 0 BTF—BOLT FOUND CONCRETE PAVEMENT O.C.G.A. Section 15-6-67. 0 IRF—IRON ROD FOUND CIRF—CRIMPED IRON ROD FOUND BRICK PAVEMENT L/ -1 CIP CAST IRON PIPE NC HEL PP POWER POLE VINCENT HELMLY NO. 1882 DATE: OHP OVERHEAD POWER r - o= IE(E)=4.09 IE(W)=6.77 IE(S)=6.48 188® _ U M> ®a AS -BUILT & TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY LOT 3 OF BEACH LOT 60) WARD 3 TYBEE ISLAND CHATHAM COUNTY, GEORGIA ADDRESS: 12 10TH PLACE PIN# 40003 17003 Surveyed For: CAD AN DESIGNS Vincent H lmly 0120, 129—A BURTON ROAD SAVANNAH, GEORGIA 31405 (912) 429-9395 FIELD SURVEY DATE :212021 SCALE: 1"=20 FT DATE . 211 21 B No. 21-3 REERENCE. 1. DB 3NN, PACE 590 1 PB 1�. PACE 1106 1 PB H, PACE 94 BIW CF CLOSURE ABL 1 445 CF Y PER ANGLE POINT AND ADJUSTED RY COMPASS METHOD FLAT CLOSURE 1:I F99T1' EQUIPMENTlBpCIN f.T51T5W TOTAL STAIIOA SNQE PR SM EFFECDYEACCORDING 0'461% iR,L MAP NO. HL9 PRJif%L SHS HEREON UES N ZONE %NOT A SPEON. FIDW HAZARD AREA Thpm xb�tafMlmdda d not wwil d o, o— u ABOVE Paw a mage aar awn9m m mr aaa aaPaEr boundaUew The 9 Flwmollm mt tlr MINIMUM M1rA Rb p�acPtlw gyp= �aWT NR CONDITIONING Ix' Y APPROVAL, O � 1W5 PUT OQE9 NOT IWAI APPROVAL OF ANY LOCAL JWSOCAL REGULATIONS AtlA OF POLARS, CE MTH LOLL MIRROR DI'MOR MyUSEO OR RFOIIRE4ENTJ. OR SIRABUIT FOR MRY 11a5wE1aORnn,�la OF THELAN. Fa %methemFEa�metmdaN ABOVE FINISHED FLOOR ABOVE MEAN SEA LEVEL N.T.S. OC. NOT TO SCALE ON CENTER PamM ma ruse and rcgMafianadd BASE CABINET BEARING O.H. OV. OVERHANG OVENS BTWN. BETWEEN VI4dC,ENT FRE.LNLk' NO 10R.R�J< LEGEND • BF -RMT POUND LONOIEIE PAVEMENT a W - ROM ROD FOUND • Off -WIPED RO! ROD FOND NOCK PAVEMENT OF GST RON PEE PP POMER POLE OP CWm!m Pam lows rraM LEL G559M 112 AS—BUILT & TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY LOT 3 OF BEACH LOT 60, WARD 3 TYBEE ISLAND CHATHAM COUNTY, GEORGIA ADDRESS: 12 10TH PLACE PIN/ 40003 17003 Surveyed For. CADMAN DESIGNS Vincent He,- y 01 20' YZD--A BdnRTON ROAD SA V'AT'iN.4tt; OE'CiRgA 37405 422 ABBREVIAl10NS ABV. ABOVE MIN. MINIMUM A/C NR CONDITIONING MIR. MIRROR A.F.F. AMA ABOVE FINISHED FLOOR ABOVE MEAN SEA LEVEL N.T.S. OC. NOT TO SCALE ON CENTER B.C. BIG. BASE CABINET BEARING O.H. OV. OVERHANG OVENS BTWN. BETWEEN PAN. a PANT. PANTRY BM. BEAM P.C. PULL CORD CAB. CABINET PK POCKET CAR. CATH. CARPET CATHEDRAL PL PLWD. PUTT PLYWOOD CJ CEIUNG JOIST PSF POUNDS PER SQUARE FOR CLG. CEILING P.T. PRESSURE TREATED CLOSETCID. CI - RETURN AIR CMU C.O. CONCRETE MASONRY UNIT CASED OPENING %A Rd15 REF. or REFG. ROD AND SHELF REFRIGERATOR CONC. CONCRETE RE1NF. RENFIXdCING CL CERAMIC TLE ROOM CTR' COUNTER R.O. ROUGH OPENING D DRYER REQ'D. REQUIRED DBL QJ DOUBLE DOUBLE JOIST S. or SLP. ROOM SLOPE ON. DOWN SF SQUARE FEET OW DISHWASHER SH. SHELF EA. EACH SHIM SHELVES / SHELVING EXT EXIST. EXTERIOR EXISTING SHT. SHW. or SHOW. SHEET SHOWER EW EACH WAY SL SIDE LITE FIND. FJ FOUNDATION FLOOR JOIST SPECS SYP, SPECIFICATIONS SOUTHERN YELLOW PINE FR FRENCH SM SQUARE FTG. FOOTING T TILE F.V. FIELD VERIFY T&GTONGUE & GROOVE GL GLASS TRANS TRANSOM H.B. NGT. HOSE BIBB HEIGHT TPD TB TOILET PAPER DISPENSER TOWEL BAR HEAD. HVAC HEADER HEATS, VENTILATION & A/C UNIT T.P. TR TOP PLATE TOWEL RING JST. JOIST TYP. TYPICAL K.D.A.T. KILZ DRIED AFTER TREATMENT U.N.O. UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE KW KNEE WALL V VINYL LAUN. LAUNDRY VERT. VERTICAL UN. LVL LINEN LAMINATED VENEER LUMBER W W/ WASHER WITH LAT. LATITUDE W.C. WATER CLOSET (TOILET) LONG. LONGITUDE OR WALL CABINET MAX NANUR MAXIMUM MANUFACTURER WD. W.I.C. WOOD WALK IN CLOSET MEL MED. CAB. MARBLE MEDICINE CABINET W.H. WWM WATER HEATER WELDED WIRE MESH MSL MEAN WWF WELDED WIRE FABRIC MECH. MC MECHANIICCALEVEL MEDICINE CABINET W YELLOW PINE MICRO MICROWAVE OVER SHEET C T OF 5 COPYRIGHT@ 2021 �denon Oe1;;pna.yt�� M SCAM 114-61'-W scus 771 UNDERPINNING rte+ '"moi 9. CGNOREM MMOL.DEMOP ZW DID AT 23 DAR FLY AMI IS MOT ALLMIMP N IRE MNXMM NM Z OWAGM REDJ1439MM (S1@ PROOM tM= FWTM OW UNDER MAIN 9M S ML SEMM VAUM 13W ! 4. SIAM CONFORM TO ASM A OSA IN OO. & IM FWIFCROM M N 30 OF SIM.MMM SAT 7. - SAS QO WASE TO B£ S X S 1O/9O WIMO YAb F'1gA WMYFACX2eM MIST Nr EVAF91� RM I7 YA30. F1EER INPNFAS74RLM3 WST iV df SIM O -l" III, NSIIMY. tllll CERIF ND ASM o-1,1fr " i S. MRFY RHO LLOOOTOWAAON 8911 MM 1t/Al R REVAI W ALL FOOF W SMALL 5112 1 SZ MAII FOR M1P FOO, W IDP W iOO 96 SH' F COM SF9A9111E if'ES. h LSE OPOI AM LWA7 IATM ME minsm MAGM 1,. ALL COMOREIC DOME MWL COMFORM TO A= MM REOUIRMIMM if am Al 2OF5 LA0 1/YMD' CSV. 16'aL ST MPA SCAM 1/4%4-r MUM CMULCM - ORION TEAM M A ALL SMALL =I= m LOCAL am nommm LALL MM ATALLM 9MLL ! sammm YALL&N ARM R mm mm mom= a ALL "M OW R RIMER MMIWOCOURE 4 N®. MW MMI ME 0.b SND AMM! Na N MM® L M IRW IME 3404 UP AWN NUM M mm Mm MigmaL L MN9D.1�"E AS1M MRA R N NTI Y 0.1N ltl T. NL MRTIR MNP NSE 2 M1NR MA W a RNI AMM A4 ALL mw E H MI MIAAS a M6 NOM afw Y YNR nSL a NM�vNAnNn AAL Et.}a1 nM 1NSAmf Y a t • tr RJDML OL MA® m AIE 1N1N6 m n�aADnt a AM YL a Al N.11[ Q{ AICM 4's INARME 1L �pNp�R:IN 0 MAS ANI A Y 1 C 1.200a r=00 AMAN' IL NLf-f14Wtl NF/1T IMID YMf N11APR.... A..... OBNNI ! f FEP a IAS MM/ 1�4AA &.1/P c i t/Y ®° l6FL MINS WS'Em LT MR FLM m T! NMAIgi NSM OF 1M . 1�MY A TAYTCMAT TNS NI WPINS MLL10 LIAM YM S a l RAR EIMi MMII IME AT 1[Nf ANAM RIAMNLLY N ID 70 MMINI MMR. TE a SIM M1F8 MRIIMMN awL R lLAR9M. N, MMm MMATMN NWL IN, {R� RASSUM MU YR RAM Sim _inr_:-tee. to Lv/ r 0.1PNa NMI Y MUM w R IMP MTM V MAIM OF SlL. 14 IliTw M 4RA1m MATERIAL NI ML:NAMI LIM 1R NKM.. 7/-r AME A Im. ALL omm MMIL As mm mm AIL�IwMM �R_..� MRGo= ®1. NN MAIM& . V. MM. am M* p.mmmumuN a fA TNN NN w 7= won a OMW 4AMNTD S A TA ALL W MD N OMIM IM RIME E "a"W" AUNUK 1L AAN MALL IME Ps. CRAY "M UNION. a$ MLMUM INM4 Al MM= A4 CAMDM NNS UALL R W MOM a M.LLAUI AMMML SSL MWL. ANN N NTN A-, fL NUNf OMM MM PWME A n ME M.MD W TE W NNEE O ML DISK, WAN$ TNI 3ff NOMURA SKIS AT br a MM OMY ME= ALL CCCUVUN MAAIIA AW ANN N R ON== CMR6 W MUM fa RM FWMM LAMM MAIL E OMM70 WIN WE QUIRM, Ate TRIM OMERLMM W MIKE AM= CHAINS AND UNMWOMM WAS FOR UNT NTT mm mit SAC IAVWP W E OMMM N TAM MANNAMM 8M NNME: CLM l= ' A4 W NMLAZj WM ML MIS UM AE N M NI M LMp13N IM RIM MtL'P WP NP Mia mm. AUNAD M/ 31 LV s low So to WFEW, MICS VER 4A so In No N m IM M iI Vfw RR IMS IR V V TIS I/tm NA$ ME NTE m IM V ARM MM UND T IA IMP IME AM Plod mm .--W MMM AOMMNASWEWa NWWWWW L AWLWNW WOWN= MAIM aA4 ALL %10 a MSL emmman nowmN EGSTM X IRAMarnm Wali MALE 2A FRAMED CALLS mmmoom SCS, FRAMED MALLS IWIM 1. ALL FRAHM@ ID E ?N DOOM Y CMM HENIHIES W E W -W LUM NDIE4 1 CO. W VERVY MECHANICAL W ®!®®® MEN TO CONSMOICWL 4.ALL MINING MAILS WEMCA WHERE AMJCAKE. I L LOUR LEVEL FRAMMIll E PREMIUM TRUIRIL 6 LOOM SEED. FMM W E WA7M RESSIANT FROW' > I � I B M 1. EAASR - f T M • W. TEY AN MR N W xMa ER. MM s � N 1 L WIIM Ta-s.M M/r a -ATA'ARUCK1 i \ a ALL IMACK AST-f.I NMfM FUN IN MANY /WS Orm NORMALLYMR ARV aA L IM As ARE A 1M OF FIRM ME LAMMM 1MNmme mm t: HMO CHUNK ONLIMIX CONNECT ID J 1 \ L ALL It a AaM A ARE I. ■ a IV C C IMES NMI® m=.IM I j L7. CUBIC SPMM 1af.M OwfMCTMG CNE MN�NTS f - f.♦ 1a fcmewT - FZA \ ®®®®10 �...® Z n am. 2,L= aLanL ALL =OF W= MNP E IRRY N ACOMMM NN TM1m ORMWACROM CRUCIAL X W 5%cr. Forch WAS MHM E6Pf R 7A' RN714T r DOW U AT ® LNNL C'jg "I'M M A4 WN&R MIN f - f 14 RAMS AT M R RA CMMT N a RL-f.MNNia ASN WPM All l EML r IAR =ff.-g 2�451416 .1.ALL y 1 1NM MN A W EALe 3O5 mqm 914'-1'-W CONSTRUCTION NOTES ROOF FRAMING Scale: 3/4'=1"—O" 1. ALL HDR ON C13U0 JOISTS OR RAFTERS ARE 2 x 6 O 16' 0. C. UNLESS NOTE OTHERMISE 2 RING SHANK NAILS TO HAVE RND. HEADS. 3 PROVIDE WOW AND PANELS YALL DE 0 7/18' THICK AND INSTALLED AS PER LOCAL REDW2ENENTS SEE DETAI T A5. ARTS A ROOF SHMIGLES :MUST HAVE pAp MN. OF 6.FASTENERS �(IB�C-U22018).. ROCf _ SHEATHING DGES ANDD INTERLR®IM IE FRAMING. FR NENERS 1N BE 4g&V MMI. OR M/fOd RING SHANK NABS & ROM BOARD TO BE NOMINAL 2x. THICKNESS NOT LESS IN DEPTH THAN THE DEPTH CUT OF THE RAFTERS (IBC-2MG). ff _. .GENERAL -STRUCTURAL NOTES _... r""'y 1) AU. WORK TO CONFORM TO THE REMAREMENTS OF Tiff FOUSIM 4) DESIGN CRPIERIA rd SRN THEN Up.. (A) INTERNATIONAL RESIDENTIAL CODE - 2006 ORC-2012) ' (B) STANDARD FOR HURRICANE RESISTANT RESIDENTIAL FLOW LAVE LAD 40 NS CONSTRIICHON 0CG-600, 2000) OR LAVE LOAD EW BALYY■O' U4E LOAD (AREA < IDD FT'2) = 60 PSF BEHIND (VERTICAL SND WAILS (C) WOOD FRAME COISTIMITN MANUAL FOR ONE AND T PSF ACIMC-TIE ADHESIVE PER FAMILY DWSUMCS (2012 SBC HIGH -WIND EDITION) BAUD' LIVE LOAD WU T 106 FI"21 = 100 100 NNS AT 4' HNXBZ 2) WINDOWS. GAS DOORS, 6 SIOUG TS SHALL BE APPROVED AND ROWS HIVE LOAD =ZED PSF BERCI NOT SHORN RIR NSTANIED TO COMPLY WITH BOTH NEGATIVE AND POSITIVE PRESSURES AS REWIRED BY ICC -6011. DOCUMENTATION OF R06 SNOW LOAD MIN UNLESS NOTED OTERIMSE. COMPLIANCE SHALL BE AVAILABLE F ON STE FOR EACH WINDOW. DOOR PSE SPACING AT DCII ED OF =NO RM LOAD M = 0 OR SOUGHT AT THE FRAMING N9'ECTION (OCr6D(X 2008). ® A RAT ROOF SNOW LOAD M 0 Pff O 3) IF APPROVED DOORS, WINDOWS. OR SKYLIGHTS ARE NOT USED, THEN SHOW EM'OS IRE FACTOR EGET = 1.0 n IMPORANW FACTOR D) = 1.0 ® W OO STRUCTURAL PANELS MOIST BE PROVIDED FOR EACH OPENING.SlMW TIETNAL FACTOR O ® O PANELS WILL HAVE A MINIMUM THICKNESS OF 7/16 BdOffS AND A _ o •^' MA MUM SPAN OF 8 FEET. PANELS MST BE PRECUT TO SZE WITH HARDWARE PROVIDED AND NUMBERED SO THAT A WIRD LOADS a ATTACHMENT HOEOVNER WILL BE ABLE TO IDENTIFY THE PROPER LOCATION FOR BASIr WIND 9iID = 130 MINI EACH PANEL. (OC 2012 AND MC -600) 1.0 WINO QMRE = D AS REQUIRED) ,ATEA, PRESSURE IXIEFFiCE1NT (GI5Y1 = 1a.,R COMPONENTS & CL40ONG PRESSURE = 32 PSF TWPICAL EXTERIOR SHEATHING... PANEL (REF. DETAIL. AT FIGHT FOR TYPICAL EXIEHOR WANING NAILING PATTERED SECOND FLOOR JOST FRAMING r""'y 2) SFIP. MTS12 MN rd SRN THEN Up.. 2 ROWS O IOD NAILS AT 4° HORIZONTAL SPACING AT TOP PLATE (REF. DETAf_ FOR NAUNG PATTERN) ' �•HIO VIEDOOR SINGLE NS EMS (12' NN EMBED FOR CMI SIEMWALL FOUNDATION) N SIMPSON BEHIND (VERTICAL SND WAILS rlfff ACIMC-TIE ADHESIVE PER --. ROW FRAMING NOT SHOWN FOR CLARITY. 100 NNS AT 4' HNXBZ MA UFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS BERCI NOT SHORN RIR HEADER OR BEAM PATH SIMPSON H254 MIN UNLESS NOTED OTERIMSE. MIN UNLESS NOTED OTHEOISE SPACING AT DCII ED OF CLAIM -. ABU66 (USF SIMPSON ABU88 W/ (2) s ®ANCHOR 80.T5 FOR 818 W/ (2) rW ANCHOR BOLTS FOR 8X8 EXTERIOR SHEATHING AT PANEL SPLICE (PROVIDE 2X ROOM IT III III III 111 1 111 AS REQUIRED) USE OVER COMIRANCLSECOND FLOOR 94EATHNG FRAM Ji` ITL STAGrAR JOINTS 2 ROWS O IOD NAILS AT 4° HORIZONTAL SPACING AT BUTIOH PLATE (REF. DETAL FOR NALMG PATTERN) NOTE NAILING PATTERN SPECIFIED IS DESIGNED TO TRANSFIX UPLIFT TYPICAL EXIESOR SIEATI•4G INSTALLATION PATTEN FORDS TO FOUNDATION T1POA EXIEF6OR SIFAIMNG NAIUNG PATTERN TYPICAL EXTERIOR SHEATHING NAILING PATTERN 1. DEM PRESSURE (DP) VALUES ARE LISPED IN POUNDS/SQUARE FOOT (PS) 2. h= MEANROOFHOW AND S MEASURED FROM GRADE TO HALMY UP THE ROOF I a = LENGTH OF ZONE (5) LOCATED A THE CORNERS W THE BUILDING A DISTANCE OF THE FOUffMA G CRITERIA A THE SMALLER OF THE FOUDWUD: T. 10% OF THE LEASE HORIZONTAL DIMENSION B. OR 4A B. BUT HOT LESS THAN THE IA1GIX OF E TIER OF THE I. 4X OF THE LEAST HORIZONTAL DIVIENSION it. OR, 3 FLEE 1 WINDOW AND DOOR DESIGN PRESSURE DP RATING M LYS \\` CQBiNE. c )IN ca BEND ADWTJ L STRAP T OVER TDP DR CUT OFF r,.„. I Slnpsan Strong -Tie PA51 RM D `R1rPNCLADS) TYPICAL WALL SECTION. SIMPSON HDU4 OR SIMPSON rW MP, ANCHOR BOLT CORNER HOLUM WITH SNGLE ON STEM WALL NOTE SEE FOUNDATION PLAN FOR ALL CORNER STUD CONNECTED TO TRANSFER SEAR (ALT.: USE ADDITONAL HODOWN) G1 COJYON R O.C. SNPSOd IDU4— aNIN ON Bo OR 9.= HTE22'.. (REF. PLAN MEN) 1GD NAILS AT 4'o.r- SPACING AT EACH END OF SHEATHING AT SPLICES (PROVIDE 2X BLOCKING AS REQUIRED) NOTE: NAILING PATTERN SPECT IS DESIGNED TO TRANSFER UPI FORCES TO FOUNDATION OMO STIR CONNECTED -TO TRANSFER STEN (ALT, USE ADDITIONAL HODOWN) (2) 16d 6' MON DO. SIMPSON FDU4—SDS3 HAAS O OR NP�d HTM �uN NN BOTH 0.C. BOTH SIDES (IFF. RAN VIEW) 51Tvaical Roof Nallinq Pattem RAL CORER SND CONNECTED ;10 TRANSFER SHEAR (ALT: USE ADDITIONAL HOEDOWN) ( 1NM SIMPSON SNON1 E 6' 0.G HPAD22 W/ ON 001H SIDES IOD RAU (REF. PUN VIEW) /WT.S NAILS AT 6•o.t SPACMG EDGE (TYP) /32' OSB PLWD. EATHING, SEE SHT. S4. NAILS AT 6°o.c. ICING AT INTERIOR RAFTER P) DOUBLE 7z MINIMUM FOR HEADER OR BEAM (FEF PIAN FOR SPECIFIC SLE) G JOIST (REF RAN FOR SIZE t AND SPACING) ROD HAUS AT 6' VERTICAL SPACING AT EDGE ") SHEATHING IOD NNS AT 6' VERTICAL SPACING AT INTERIOR SHA) (TIP) • • 1/Y TYPICAL 2 ROW RARING PATTERN ALIENATE ME HOD: INSTAL }' BEAD UQUD NAILS 0 °SUBFL)OR5' ADHESIVE (PRODUCT NUMBERS LN --602 AND UN -902) AT ALL 2 ROW NAILING PATTERN LOCATIONS W/ SHOE ROW 10d COMMON NNS 0 6' MAX HORIZONTAL SPACING (WX BIEED OUT FROM ADHESIVE BEAD MUST BE VISIBLE FOR INSPECTION) DOUBLE 2s MINIMUM FOR HEADER OR BEAM (REF RAN FOR SPECIFIC SIM MIST (REF PLAN FOD SZE AND SPACING) 2) r""'y 2) SFIP. MTS12 MN rd SRN THEN Up.. UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE Era' A307 THREADED ROD W/ V MIN �•HIO VIEDOOR SINGLE NS EMS (12' NN EMBED FOR CMI SIEMWALL FOUNDATION) N SIMPSON Nm rlfff ACIMC-TIE ADHESIVE PER --. ROW FRAMING NOT SHOWN FOR CLARITY. BALM MA UFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS SSW MG -TIE THEN!D MAY BE USD N !P STORY HOO56 OILY /WT.S NAILS AT 6•o.t SPACMG EDGE (TYP) /32' OSB PLWD. EATHING, SEE SHT. S4. NAILS AT 6°o.c. ICING AT INTERIOR RAFTER P) DOUBLE 7z MINIMUM FOR HEADER OR BEAM (FEF PIAN FOR SPECIFIC SLE) G JOIST (REF RAN FOR SIZE t AND SPACING) ROD HAUS AT 6' VERTICAL SPACING AT EDGE ") SHEATHING IOD NNS AT 6' VERTICAL SPACING AT INTERIOR SHA) (TIP) • • 1/Y TYPICAL 2 ROW RARING PATTERN ALIENATE ME HOD: INSTAL }' BEAD UQUD NAILS 0 °SUBFL)OR5' ADHESIVE (PRODUCT NUMBERS LN --602 AND UN -902) AT ALL 2 ROW NAILING PATTERN LOCATIONS W/ SHOE ROW 10d COMMON NNS 0 6' MAX HORIZONTAL SPACING (WX BIEED OUT FROM ADHESIVE BEAD MUST BE VISIBLE FOR INSPECTION) DOUBLE 2s MINIMUM FOR HEADER OR BEAM (REF RAN FOR SPECIFIC SIM MIST (REF PLAN FOD SZE AND SPACING) 2) I i ---rd AND THREADED ROD ./ 6' •$ I I � r® A307 THREADEDROD r/ 6' n MN EMBED INTO FOUNDATION ■/ I(IY,/ MR EMBED INTO FOUNDATION V/ SIMPSON ACRYLIC -TE AOESIVE SIMPSON ACIMC-11E ADHESIVE d FOUNDATION PLANFOUNDATIONPLAN x FOR FOUNDATION TYPE FOR FOUNDATION TYPE (5 CONT. REBAR PFA FOUNDATION RAN SIMPSON REQUIREMENT TYIRCAL WI%D ODLUMN HOIDOWN ANCIHOR TYPICAL WIND CIXllMN HODOWN ANCHOt :�HTLt'kLtt kl� 4 TYPICAL COLUMN HOLDOWN DETAILS d Pi mill SHEET A4 5 of 5 COPRYGHTQ 2021 _Ga4nw Qgwsays_[ I r SIMPSON MTS2 101. 2) SFIP. MTS12 MN UNLESS NOTED OTHERW& UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE 016 P.T. SYP. WOOD CI LNN „r P.T. SYP. WOOD COLUMN 0 8X8 P.T. SYP. WOOD ,.-�''F ( 8X8 P.T. SYP. WOM ) Nm mm, ._... ROOF FRAMING NOT SHAW FOR CLARITY. --. ROW FRAMING NOT SHOWN FOR CLARITY. ..,_,.,. ALL RAFTERS MUST BE ATTACHED TO ......._...,.::x�_._...,_ ALL RAPIERS MUST BE ATTACHED TO HEADER OR BEAM WITIH SIMPSON H25A HEADER OR BEAM PATH SIMPSON H254 MIN UNLESS NOTED OTERIMSE. MIN UNLESS NOTED OTHEOISE JOIST (REF PUN FOR SIZE AND SPACING) VAMM ABU68 (USF SIMPSON ABIJ88 -. ABU66 (USF SIMPSON ABU88 W/ (2) s ®ANCHOR 80.T5 FOR 818 W/ (2) rW ANCHOR BOLTS FOR 8X8 I i ---rd AND THREADED ROD ./ 6' •$ I I � r® A307 THREADEDROD r/ 6' n MN EMBED INTO FOUNDATION ■/ I(IY,/ MR EMBED INTO FOUNDATION V/ SIMPSON ACRYLIC -TE AOESIVE SIMPSON ACIMC-11E ADHESIVE d FOUNDATION PLANFOUNDATIONPLAN x FOR FOUNDATION TYPE FOR FOUNDATION TYPE (5 CONT. REBAR PFA FOUNDATION RAN SIMPSON REQUIREMENT TYIRCAL WI%D ODLUMN HOIDOWN ANCIHOR TYPICAL WIND CIXllMN HODOWN ANCHOt :�HTLt'kLtt kl� 4 TYPICAL COLUMN HOLDOWN DETAILS d Pi mill SHEET A4 5 of 5 COPRYGHTQ 2021 _Ga4nw Qgwsays_[ I r " STAFF REPORT PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING: August 16,2021 CITY COUNCIL MEETING: September 9,2021 APPLICANT: City of Tybee Island EXISTING USE: N/A 3��11116' " �� APPLICATION: Amendment to Appendix A, Land Development Code, Section I I-100 Meetings PROPOSAL: To change the time and location for Planning Commission meetings from 7:00 p.m. at City Hall to 6:30 p.m. at the Public Safety Building. ANALYSIS: This amendment will set the Planning Commission meetings to the same time and location as City Council meetings STAFF FINDING Staff recommends approval q I I all I I U -MV 0 This Staff Report was prepared by George Shaw. Applicant's Name C- R Applicant's Telephone Number ILI=- 117;L -5D31 Applicant's Mailing Address I If within two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the Applicant's application for a zoning action, the Applicant has made campaign contributions aggregating to more than $250 to the Mayor and any member of Council or any member of the Planning Commission, the Applicant and the Attorney representing the Applicant must disclose the following: a. The name of the local government official to whom the campaign contribution or gift was made; b. The dollar amount of each campaign contribution made by the applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action, and the date of each contribution; c. An enumeration and description of each gift having a value of $250 or more made by the Applicant to the local government official during the two (2) years immediately preceding the filing of the application for this zoning action. Disclosure of Campaign Coiltributions form attachment hereto: Yes h Signature Applicant Date NOTE: Other specific data is required for each proposed Text Amendment. City Official Date Pagel of NOTE: This application must be accompanied by additional documentation, including drawings and/or text that include or illustrate the information outlined below. Indicate in the spaces provided whether or not the required information is provided. 5-020 (E) An amendment to the text of this Land Development Code follows the same process as an amendment to the zoning map. However, a text amendment requires different materials to be included with theapplication. 5-040 (E) (1) In the case of a text amendment, the application shall set forth the new text to be added and the existing text to be deleted. 5-110 Section 5-110, Standards for Land Development Code or Zoning Map Amendment Approval, identifies standards and other factors to be considered by the Mayor and Council in making any zoning decision. The Applicant should provide written data addressing each of the below listed standards and factors to assure consideration of applicable information. 5-110 (A) The existing land use pattern; 5-110 (B) The possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts; 5-110 (C) The existing population density pattern and the possible increase or overtaxing of the load on public facilities; _YL 5-110 (D) Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed amendment reasonable; VAA 5-110 (E) Whether the proposed change will adversely influence existing conditions in the neighborhood or the city at large; t4ip( 5-110 (F) Potential impact on the environment, including but not limited to drainage, soil erosion and sedimentation, flooding, air quality, and water quality and quantity; 5-110 (G) The reasonableness of the costs required of the public in providing, improving, increasing or maintaining public utilities, schools, streets and public safety necessities when considering the proposed changes; 5-110 (H) Whether the proposed change will be detrimental to the value or improvement or development of adjacent or nearby property in accordance with existing requirements; Al 5-110(l) Whether the proposed change is out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or entire city; 5-110 (J) Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to the individual owner as contrasted with the adjacent or nearby neighborhood or with the general public; and, 5-110 (K) The extent to which the zoning decision is consistent with the current city master plan or other local planning efforts, if any, of the city. The Applicant certifies that he/she has read the requirements for Land Development Code Text Amendments and has provided the required information to the best of his/her ability in a truthful and honest manner. S ifznattv Yo-f- Applicant Date Page 2 of 3 021 � ' i' ' I • ' ' i ' i i Have you within the past two (2) years made campaign contributions or gave gifts having an aggregate value of $250.00 or more to a member of the City of Tybee Island Planning Commission, or Mayor and Council or any local government official who will be considering the rezoning application? YES NO IIS•AMOR•1tF.`fD[K• u ' •' Lli i • . 1 i NAMEOF CONTRIBUTIONS GIFTS GOVERNMENT OF $250.00 OF $250.00 DATE OFFICIAL O MORE ORMORE CONTRIBUTION Signature Printed Name , Date Page 3 of 3 (A) The planning commission shall meet in a regular session each month no later than 16 days prior to the first scheduled city council meeting of the following month at Gity hall at 7:00 p.m. the oublic safety building at 6,30 p.m. Special meetings may be held as deemed necessary by the chair or a majority of the members or at the request of the mayor or council with 48 -hours -notice to caid members. (B) The planning commission shall conduct its business under rules approved by the mayor and council. It shall keep a record of its proceedings which shall be a public record.