Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout20050922CCMeeting1 1 1 @ @ITEM 2005 -09 -22 City Council Minutes Mayor Walter Parker called the September 22, 2005 Tybee Island City Council meeting to order at 7:00 PM. Those present, in addition to Mayor Parker, were Council Members Jason Buelterman, Eddie Crone, Mallory Pearce, Shirley Sessions, Paul Wolff, and Jack Youmans. City Attorney Edward Hughes and City Manager Bob Thomson were also present. Tybee resident Henry Levy gave the invocation. The Tybee Island Memorial Color Guard posted the Colors and the Pledge to the Flag was recited. Mayor Parker announced that candidate qualifying was over. He said we had two candidates for Mayor and eight candidates for the six Council seats. He also announced that Jack Youmans would not be running again after eighteen years of sitting on Council. He introduced Jon Brown, candidate for Council. He said Jason Buelterman, currently the Mayor Pro Tem, was running for Mayor and wished him good luck, but not too much. Mayor Parker told everyone he had a very special presentation to make. He asked Lou Off to come forward. Parker said Off was Chairman of the Beach Task Force and had worked tirelessly in this capacity and he also was spearheading the effort for Tybee's beach renourishment. Mayor Parker presented Off with a beautiful hour glass and read the inscription. Off thanked the Mayor and the citizens for the recognition but said his job was not finished until there was new sand on our beach. He said there were twelve other people on the committee with him and they all worked hard and deserved recognition also. Off gave a brief status report on the committee's progress. Mary Engals, representing the Tybee Arts Assn., spoke to Council regarding the "Turtles R Coming" campaign. Engals said the turtles are modeled after the endangered loggerhead. She said Sally Bostwick, local artist, would paint the turtle that was sitting out in front of City Hall. Engals passed around a small, painted model for all to see how the large one would be decorated. She asked the City to sponsor this turtle for $5,000 and said after the promotion was over, the City could, if they wished, auction the turtle and recoup the expenses. Pete Mohlin, a member of the NOAA, gave a brief presentation on Rip Currents. He said rip currents are know as "The Drowning Machine" and are extremely dangerous. Mohlin said you can't always see them or know where they are. He gave everyone a lot of very useful information. Dennis Hutton addressed Council and said he had opened a bed and breakfast at his residence on Butler Avenue and 14th Street about two and half years ago. Hutton said he has had a lot of problems with the bar and restaurant across the street with noise. He said he has called the police, has bought a decibel meter, and has written a letter to the City. 1 of 7 1 1 1 Hutton said so far nothing has worked. Hutton said he had asked the owner to arrange the speakers toward the bar and not at the street. He said the owner won't do that. Hutton said the music is louder in his house than it is in the bar. Hutton said he felt he had three choices. One was for the City to enforce the codes. Second was to get speakers of his own and aim them across the street at the bar and blast him. Hutton said that was juvenile and wouldn't solve anything. The third choice was to take the owner to court. He said that would cost a lot of money and time. Hutton said he thought part of the problem was the police didn't know the code and what decibel levels were legal in each zone. Thomson asked the Chief of Police, Jimmy Price, to address this issue. Sessions asked if the owner had been contacted. The Chief said he leaves a lot up to the discretion of his officers and they do know what the decibel levels are. Mayor Parker said that maybe the Chief could talk to the owner and ask him to direct the speakers away from the street. The Chief agreed. Sessions asked if we addressed this problem when the business license was issued and if not, we should. Paul DeVivo requested an alcohol license for the Pirates Fest on October 7, 8, & 9. He said they would operate an off site location for Joel Solomon owner of the Cafe Loco. He said there would be a beer tent in the south parking lot. Sandy Major, representing the Tybee Neighborhood Assn., along with Roxanne Fleetwood, gave Council a brief report on the activities. She said their main goal is to preserve the quality of life on Tybee. She asked for support and invited everyone to attend their next meeting on October 6th at the Community Center. She said the group would not endorse or support any particular candidate in the upcoming election but would have the candidates' views on their website. She said they will hold a Candidates' Forum on November 3`d at City Hall and invited everyone. Shirley Sessions said Kathryn Williams was unable to attend the meeting tonight and had asked her to make an announcement. Sessions said there will be a Beach Sweep this Saturday, September 24th and asked participants to meet at the pier at 10:00 AM. Lawanna Tsoulos said she was there on behalf of Tybee Island Adopt a Soldier. She said they are partnering with the American Legion and Pat Locklear. Tsoulos said they have an adopted Jason Ball, who grew up on Tybee, and his company. She requested Council approve their placing a donation box at City Hall for this group of soldiers. She said this would be one of three boxes, the others are located at the American Legion and the Fire Station. She said April Moore had a list of items that could be donated. Donald Cowart addressed Council and said he was known around the Island as Tybee Dac. He said he was there as a citizen and was not representing the Marine Rescue Squadron. Cowart gave a lengthy history of the property and activities regarding the land near Lazaretto Creek that the MRS and Michael Scarbrough occupy. Cowart said this dispute has been going on for many years and it was time to settle it. Sessions thanked Cowart and said she had learned a lot from the information Cowart had. Mayor Parker recognized another candidate for City Council, Dick Smith. 2 of 7 1 1 1 Jonathan Brown asked about the campground and what was going to be done about their using City property for the camp sites. He said he wanted to know if the incident that happened over the weekend would be discussed tonight or covered up. Mayor Parker said he didn't think anything would be covered up and he was sure there would be some discussion later. Mayor Parker said there are no public hearings and opened the meeting for business legally presented. Crone motioned to approve the alcohol license for the Pirates Fest, Youmans seconded. Vote was unanimous. Parker asked if everyone agreed with the Adopt a Soldier agreement and it was affirmative. Parker asked Thomson to look into the matter of the decibel meters and the Chief said he would see what we might do regarding the positioning of the speakers in the bar on Butler Avenue. Thomson yes, he would do that tomorrow. Pearce asked what legal options the Council had of this problem persists. Hughes said you could prosecute on the nuisance. Hughes said that is one of the specific grounds that constitute a nuisance under our ordinance He said the penalty could be not renewing the license on the next application. Buelterman motioned to approve the minutes for the September 8, 2005 Tybee Island City Council meeting, Pearce seconded. Vote was unanimous. Pearce said he would like to discuss the exceptions to the weed ordinance again. Pearce said this would protect native plant life, bogs, wetlands, and of course, perpetual green spaces. He said it would also specify that house rats would not be protected as they are now under the heading of rodents. Pearce motioned to approve the text amendment to the weed ordinance, Wolff seconded. Buelterman asked how this would alter the current ordinance. Pearce said it gives us more specifics and more protection for wetlands and dunes. Pearce said this does not mandate that people kill all rodents as the present ordinance does. Sessions asked if these changes were discussed with the Zoning Dept., and Pearce answered no, and that he had talked with some environmentalists that he knew. Sessions said she thought it was important to talk to staff and get their input as to whether it would be easy to enforce or would it be more difficult. Sessions asked about voting on the same amendment that was not approved at the last meeting. Hughes said it was not a zoning amendment so that it did not have the legal requirements. Hughes said it also has the right to be brought up again with a motion and a second. Buelterman asked if he decided to grow wild flowers or let his yard grow, would the City have the right to tell him to cut it down. Pearce said the ordinance states that anything over ten inches would have to be cut. Vote was 4, Wolff, Sessions, Buelterman, and Pearce, in favor, and 2, Youmans and Crone, opposed. Hughes said this would be first reading. 3 of 7 1 1 1 Wolff said that Tony Petrea had offered to donate two lots on unopened Miller Avenue between 7th and 8th Streets to the City. Wolff said the property is valued at $7,000 by the County and the lots are 60' X 110' each, and mostly marsh. He said there is some high ground that could be used for a wildlife viewing area. He said Hughes had drawn up a gift deed with the stipulation that it remain a perpetual green space. Wolff motioned to accept this offer, Pearce seconded. Vote was unanimous. Pearce also said this property was adjacent to the property that was approved for green space at the previous meeting and would be included as an addendum. Crone motioned to adopt the turtle, Sessions seconded. Vote was unanimous. Wolff said that we were working with the MPC, along with other municipalities, to recycle electronics on E -Cycle Day, September 30th and October 1St. He said any electronics, such as TV's, VCR's, cell phones, DVD players, computer monitors to name a few would be accepted at DPW all day on Friday and from 10 AM to 12 PM on Saturday. Wolff urged everyone to participate in this. Hughes said he had a text amendment to the noise ordinance to add an exception for public works construction to be conducted as necessary to get around the time constraints that have been imposed on construction activity. Hughes said this is in anticipation to the water line construction, which is to begin soon, in that the contractors probably won't be able to wait until 10 AM to start work. He said this is a limited exception for public works projects that have been approved by Mayor and Council. Crone motioned to approve, Youmans seconded. Vote was unanimous. Hughes said that representatives of the MRS and Mike Scarbrough have had several meetings and seem to be close to an agreement. Hughes said a lot of the issues that Cowart had pointed out have been settled but the issue of parking has not been addressed yet. Chuck Eaton, representing the MRS, said he had met with Scarbrough this afternoon and said he was pleased to announce that they had reached an agreement to the basic needs. He said he would have to present this to the membership before it could be finalized. City Manager, Bob Thomson, said that he had given them a proposal for fees for yard trimmings to be taken to the DPW by landscaping contractors. Thomson said he recommended an annual permit for $500. Thomson said he would like for Hughes to review the proposal and present a draft at the next meeting for action. Sessions asked if any of the contractors had been included in any of the meetings regarding this. Thomson said yes a few had been included and they wanted the fee lower and it was negotiable. Bill Lovett told Council that he had a request for payment from Collins Construction for $5900.00. for the retainage on the gym construction. He said Thomson had wanted Council to approve the release of that retainage. Lovett said the other item is the change order on the blocks for the gym. He said this was about the third request for payment on this. Lovett said there had been a meeting with the City Manager, City Attorney, and the contractor and decided to divide the cost three ways. He said the contractor agreed to pay 4 of 7 1 1 1 one third, H.G.B. & DeY. would pay one third, and the City would pay one third. Lovett said this would be $1,809 and some change for each. Crone asked about the leftover bricks. Lovett said these belonged to the contractor and not to the City. It was determined that a vote was not necessary to pay the $5,900. Pearce motioned to approve payment of the $1,809., Buelterman seconded. Vote was 4, Wolff, Youmans, Buelterman, and Pearce, in favor, and 2, Sessions and Crone, opposed. Buelterman asked Lovett to give Council an update on the status of the water line project. Lovett said he had the contract from the contractor and was ready for execution by the City. He said they had prepared the change order of $294,000 to reduce the amount of the contract. He said the change order reduces the number of jack and bores to one. He said the trench would only be patched in the parking lane and when the street is resurfaced, it would be from curb to curb. He said they are not going to grind down the asphalt on the streets that run perpendicular, but patch the trench and then the City could put those on the LARP list for DOT. Lovett said the change order has been sent to the contractor. He said the contract would not be brought back to Council as it had already been approved at a previous meeting. He said DOT has verbally approved the project and he is waiting on DOT to return the approved plans. Lovett said work should begin around the first part of October. Buelterman asked how we were going to inform the public as to what was happening and had anything been started on a televised information spot. Thomson said we were waiting to find out where the staging area would be and where the contractor would begin the actual work. Lovett said the large informational sign should be placed on Butler as you come on the Island. Dee Anderson said that he had information that the staging area is to be on the vacant lot across from the DeSoto. Wolff motioned for approval on second reading for the text amendment to Sec. 6 -3 -1 removing the schedule of regulatory fees from the ordinance and having them posted in the Clerk's office, Crone seconded. Hughes said he had cautioned everyone to check the rates and make sure that what was being charged was the same as what they thought was being charged. Vote was unanimous. Buelterman motioned for approval on second reading for the text amendment to Sec. 3 -2- 72 to include a fee for live entertainment separate from any other fees, including the alcohol license fee, Wolff seconded. Vote was unanimous. Wolff motioned for approval on second reading for the text amendment to Sec. 3 -2 -72 to remove the business license fees from the ordinance and have them posted in the Clerk's office, Pearce seconded. Vote was unanimous. Pearce motioned for approval on second reading for the text amendment to the Tree Ordinance, Wolff seconded. Vote was 5, Wolff, Sessions, Buelterman, Crone, and Pearce, in favor, and 1, Youmans, opposed. Parker asked if anyone wanted to discuss any of the action items. Crone asked if there was a report on the fuel use by vehicle. Thomson said yes and he 5 of 7 1 1 would give Council a copy. Buelterman asked about the policy regarding purchasing fuel efficient vehicles. Thomson said he had talked to the department heads. Buelterman said he thought there should be a written policy so that years down the road, people would know what the City's policy was. Thomson said he would get one. Sessions asked where we were on the NorthBeach accessibility. Thomson said that was going out for bids by the end of next few weeks and be completed by the end of year. Thomson said he had been remiss and had not gotten any information on opening the cemetery but would follow it up. Crone asked about the ordinance on rental property. Parker said the Planning Commission was working on that. Wolff said he attended their meeting and the PC had decided not to do anything on that. Hughes said the Planning Commission also voted not to do anything regarding the C -1 density issue. He said it was supposed to be advertised and come before Council in October and asked what Council wanted to do. Wolff said he would like for Council to look at the options, such as setbacks based on number of units, as well as others and not advertise for October. Buelterman asked about the issue of residential use on the streets in C -1, like the Chu project. Wolff said that is a reason to have a minimum lot size in C- 1 and C -2. Crone asked about the stuff that was to be put on the rocks on Solomon Avenue. Thomson said we had received the material in a barrel but no instructions were included. He said that is what we are waiting on and as soon as we get them, we will get the job done. Sessions asked about the increased patrols near the Community Center. Thomson said he would talk to the Chief and make sure the patrols were increased. Hughes said he had checked with the City of Augusta and their policy on parking on private property during Masters weekend. He said they told him that they just let it happen. Hughes said he didn't think that would be a good idea for us. He said we should designate the weekends that we would allow it and require a permit if not a business license. Hughes said we should also think about whether to limit it to a particular area or allow it anywhere. Hughes said he would get something on paper for Council to review. He said he would also have a draft for the setbacks for mixed use in C -1. Sessions asked about checking the police log for complaints. Thomson said they were doing that now. Sessions asked about the speed bumps. Thomson said he and Chief feel that speed bumps wouldn't work. Sessions said she is talking about the slopes and not a real bump. 6 of 7 1 1 1 Thomson said the DOT feels like that wouldn't work either. Sessions asked if we had a letter and Thomson said no but he would get one. Wolff suggested pervious strips as an alternative. Thomson said he would look into the difference in cost of asphalt compared to the pervious material. Thomson said the item about power point had been done and is operational. Youmans motioned to adjourn to executive session to discuss litigation, personnel, and real estate, Pearce seconded. Vote was unanimous. Pearce motioned to reconvene to regular session, Buelterman seconded. Vote was unanimous. As there was no further business, Mayor Parker adjourned the meeting. Diane Sikes Clerk of Council Mayor 7of7 1 1 STATE OF GEORGIA COUNTY OF CHATHAM ) AFFIDAVIT PERSONALLY appeared before the undersigned attesting officer, duly authorized to administer oaths, 1 ; � _�� � who after being duly sworn, deposes and on oath state the following: (1) I was the presiding officer of a meeting of the Tybee Island City Council held on th day of ipte r , 2005. (2) That it is my understanding that O.C.G.A. §50- 13 -3(b) provides as follows: When any meeting of an agency is closed to the public pursuant to subsection (a) of this Code section, the chairperson or other person presiding over such meeting shall execute and file with the official minutes of the meeting a notarized affidavit stating under oath that the subject matter of the meeting or the closed portion thereof was devoted to matters within the exceptions provided by law and identifying the specific relevant exception. (3) The subject matter of the closed meeting or closed portion of the meeting held on the of purpose(s) of , 2005, which was closed for the as allowed by §O.C.G.A., Title 50, Chapter 14, was devoted to matters within those exceptions and as provided by law. (4) Any unrelated matters which were mentioned or attempted to be offered for discussion during the closed portion of the meeting were ruled out of order and not discussed. 1 1 5) This affidavit is being executed for the purpose of complying with the mandate of O.C.G.A. §50- 14 -4(b) that such an affidavit be executed. This day of ,b , 2005. f worn to and su rribed before Me this jam day of , 2005 DIANE J. BIKES Wary Public, Chatham County, GA ly Commission Expires July 8, 2001 /l ∎f yor/Presiding 0 ``cer ORDINANCE NO. , 2005 AN AMENDMENT TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CODE OF ORDINANCES FOR THE CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND, GEORGIA, SO AS TO AMEND THE REGULATORY FEE, TO PROVIDE FOR THE REPEAL OF CONFLICTING ORDINANCES AND TO PROVIDE FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. WHEREAS, the City of Tybee Island is a duly organized municipality under the laws of the State of Georgia; and WHEREAS, amendments to the Code of Ordinances are appropriate with respect to charges and fees for certain services and permits; NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island, Georgia, duly assembled, that the Code of Ordinances is hereby amended so as to amend Section 3 -2 -72 relating to the regulatory fee schedule so as to provide as follows: Any business subject to a regulatory fee operating within the City shall pay a regulatory fee even if such business has paid a business tax in Savannah, the City of Tybee Island or any other jurisdiction and regulatory fees as defined in 3- 2- 54)B)(4) are hereby established for those businesses operating within the corporate limits within the City of Tybee Island according to the schedule approved by the Mayor and Council and maintained by the Clerk of Council in City Hall, Tybee Island, Georgia. Severability. The sections, paragraphs, sentences, clauses and phrases of this ordinance are severable, and if any phrase, clause, sentence, paragraph, or section of this ordinance shall be declared invalid by the valid judgment or decrees of any court of competent jurisdiction, such illegalities shall not effect any of the remaining phrases, clauses, sentences, paragraphs and sections of this ordinance. G../cotm,ton/etnh/14/ 14536 / ordinances / 2005 /n gulatoryfeeordinanceamendment 09.01.05 1 1 Repealer. All ordinances and parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are hereby expressly repealed. Adoption/Effective Date. The adoption date of this ordinance is , 2005, and it shall become effective on that date. FIRST READING SECOND READING 9-0i,u ATTEST: Clerk of Council GJcommon/emh/14 /14536/ ordinances/ 20 05/ regulatoryfeeordinanceamendment 09.01.05 1 1 ORDINANCE NO.4 OV,Ss .15-, 2005 TREE ORDINANCE AMENDMENT CITY OF TYBEE ISLAND IT IS HEREBY ORDAINED by the governing authority of the City of Tybee Island, Title g , Article 7 , Section ® is amended so as to change its terms and to add exceptions thereto as follows: Section 2 -010 Terms and Definitions Tree: Any woody plant that has a diameter of six (6) inches or more or any woody plant with a caliper measure of two (2) inches or more if such tree is part of a previous tree mitigation plan. 7 -020 Purpose (F) To help protect the health and well -being of Tybee Island residents and guests by providing shade and otherwise moderating potential dangerous summer temperatures. Article 7 Tree Removal Regulations Section 7 -030 Applications and Exceptions The requirements of this ordinance shall apply to all parcels and public right -of -ways within the City. No trees shall be removed within the City of Tybee Island except in compliance with this ordinance, with the following exceptions: (A) No permit shall be required for the removal of trees which endanger or obstruct public safety and welfare as determined by the Zoning Administrator or designated city representative. (B) No permit shall be required for the trimming or pruning of trees, provided that such maintenance activity shall not be so extensive as to constitute tree removal as defined above. G:common/emh/14 /14536 /ordmances /2005 /treeordinanceamendment 09.22.05 1 1 (C) This ordinance shall not apply to utility rights -of -way. Section 7 -035 Tree Protection During Plat and Plan Removal During the subdivision plat approval process and also during the site plan approval process, the existing location of all significant trees shall be considered so as to preserve such trees unless no feasible alternative exists in order to make reasonable, beneficial economic use of the property. To be considered are the locations and the anticipated locations of drainage and utility structures, water and sewer lines, streets, sidewalks, driveways, final site contours, building footprints, and other impacts on existing significant trees. When no feasible alternative exists except to remove existing significant trees, their planned removal shall be noted on the plans, as well as the location, size and types of the trees planned to meet mitigation requirements as outlined in Section 7 -080. Section 7 -050 Tree Removal Requirements (A) Under the limits and conditions set forth below, trees may be removed from a lot or parcel provided that a minimum density of three trees per each 4,500 square feet of area is maintained. (B) Except as provided in Section 7 -060 no significant tree shall be removed from any vacant lot, undeveloped parcel, or public right -of -way within the City. (C) (D) No trees shall be removed from the DNR marsh setback line. Trees in the marsh setback may not be counted as "remaining trees" for mitigation purposes. Section 7 -060 Removal of Significant Trees (A) Significant trees may be removed only under the following situations or conditions: G:common/emh/14/ 14536 / ordinances /2005 /treeordinanceamendment 09.22.05 1 1 1 1. Upon showing by the applicant that removal of a siginificant tree is necessary to make reasonable beneficial, economic use of the property; such showing must demonstrate that there is no feasible alternative that would preserve the tree, and must be made for each significant tree the applicant proposes to remove. 2. For improvements, expansion and/or new construction of infrastructure services, including water /sewer systems and streets, but only if no alternatives are available; and 3. Prior to the issuance of a Permit allowing the removal of a significant tree, the Zoning Administrator shall confirm in writing that one (1) or more of the situations enumerated herein exists. (B) The Tree Removal Permit allowing the removal of significant tree shall require the landowner /permittee ro comply with the requirements set forth in Section 7 -070 and 7 -080 and the additional following conditions: 1. Each removed significiant tree shall be replaced with one (1) or more trees of like species having an aggregate DBH at least equal to the DBH of the removed tree, and meeting the requirements of 7 -080; such replacement tree(s) shall be considered to be one (1) tree for the purpose of meeting density requirements established in Section 7 -050 (A); the exception to this ordinance is a dead tree, or a diseased tree that is a danger to or obstructs public safety and welfare or that might infect otherwise healthy trees. G:common /emh /14/1 4536 /ordinances /2005 /heeordinanceamendment 09.22.05 1 1 2. Native trees left remaining on the site may be counted as replacement trees according to the mitigation schedule.- These trees must be noted on the plat and shall be protected as a tree as defined by 2 -010. Section 7 -080 Standards for Tree Planting and Replacement (A) Pursuant to Building Permit. Trees planted or replaced, or left remaining on the site pursuant to a validly issued building permit in accordance with this article shall be botanically compatible with local conditions, healthy, disease and pest free, and may have a minimum size of two (2) inches, caliper measure. The permittee /landowner shall choose the species of replacement trees from the native species list for Tybee Island. At least one (1) replacement tree or remaining tree shall be of the same species as the tree(s) that are planned to be removed. Ideally, planting should be done immediately following construction or in the earliest growing season thereafter. (B) Pursuant to citation of violation. Replacement trees planted pursuant to citation of violation shall be of the same type (species) as the tree being removed and shall be the maximum DBH that is commercially available. The aggregate DBH of trees planted as replacement shall equal the DBH of the tree that was removed in violation of the ordinance. (C) All replanted or replacement trees must survive at least two (2) full calendar years for the permittee /landowner to be considered to be in full compliance with this Article. If the replanted tree becomes unhealthy or dies, it must be removed from the site and replaced as soon as conditions permit. This duration is not to exceed one calendar year. G:common/emh/14 /14536/ ordinances /2005 /treeordinanceamendment 09.22.05 (D) (E) Off-Site Tree Planting Option. If it is not possible to replant trees to the specifications required in these regulations, the applicant may chose to plant the required trees on city property in a location specified by the Zoning Administrator. A donation may be made to the Trees for Tybee fund. All significant trees maybe mitigated at a cost of $50.00 per inch. All replanted, remaining, or replacement trees shall be considered a "tree" as defined in section 2 -010. G:common/emh/l4 /14536/ ordinances /2005 /treeordinanceamendment 09.22.05 Common Name Scientific Name Mitigation equivalent Per one inch Live Oak For new plantings Minimum DBH Required for remaining Trees: Special note: Red Cedar Juniperus virginiana 1:1 4" Live Oak Quercus virginiana 1:1 4" Laurel Oak, Water Oak, etc. Quercus sp. NA 4" Water oaks left only in naturalized area Magnolia grandiflora 1:1 4" Sugarberry Celtis laeirgata 1:1 4" Red Bay Persea borbonia 1:1 4" Sycamore Plantanu occidentalis 1:1 4" Sweetgum Liquidamber syraciflora NA 4" Native Hollies Ilex sp. 1:1 3" Native Maples Acer sp. 1:1 3" Toothache Tree Xanoxylum clava - hercules 1:2 (one inch toothache = 2 inch Live Oak) 3" Eastern Redbud Cercis Canadensis 1:1 3" Devilwood (Wild Olive) Osmanthus americanus NA 3" Carolina Laurelcherry Prunus caroliniana 2:1 4" Carolina Willow Salix caroliniana 1:1 4" Tough Bumelia (Buckthorn) Bumelia tenex 1:2 3" Sparkleberry Vaccinium arboretum 1:2 3" G:common/emh/14/ 14536 /ordinances /2005 /treeordinanceamendment 09.22.05 1 FIRST READING -9 g SECOND READING ATTE T: r Clerk of Council G:common/emh/14/ 14536 / ordinances /2005 /treeordinanceamendment 09.22.05