Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout2015-11-12 packet NOTICE OF SPECIAL MEETING AND TENTATIVE AGENDA' /411r. iffi.1186\reifiali 1 City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Thursday,November 12, 2015 —5:30 p.m. City Annex, 427 Monroe Street, Jefferson City, Missouri Multipurpose Room AMENDED TENTATIVE AGENDA 1. Call to Order and Roll Call 2. Approval of Agenda(as printed or amended) 3. Approval of Minutes for the September 17, 2015, Special Meeting 4. Old Business a. Historic City of Jefferson Proposed Demolition Ordinance Steve Veile,past president of Historic City of Jefferson Paul Graham, HCJ attorney Cathy Bordner, HCJ member Tammy Boeschen,president of Historic City of Jefferson 5. Demolition Application a. 806 Jefferson St b. 623 —625 W McCarty St c. 1119 Jefferson St 6. HPC Business a. CLG Report b. Adoption of 2016 Calendar c. Election of Officers 7. Dates to Remember a. Next Meeting January 12, 2016 8. Adjournment Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at(573)634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act.Please allow three business days to process the request. Please call 573-634-6410 for information regarding agenda items City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Minutes Thursday, September 17, 2015 Council Chambers — John G. Christy Municipal Building 320 E. McCarty COMMISSION MEMBERS PRESENT ATTENDANCE RECORD Bill Case 8 of 8 Mary Schantz 7 of 8 Kevin Kelly 8 of 8 Terri Rademan 3 of 8 Jane Moore 6 of 8 Art Hernandez 7 of 8 Doug Record 6 of 8 Sarah Hoeller 1 of 8 Commission Members Absent Brent Hemphill 3 of 8 Council Liaison Present Laura Ward Staff Present Jayme Abbott Janice McMillan Guests Michelle Brooks, News Tribune Charlie Brzuchalski Brian Bernskoetter Heath Clarkston Rick Mihalevich Call to Order: Vice Chair Bill Case called the meeting to order at 5:35 pm. Approval of Agenda: Bill Case asked the Commissioners to review the agenda and to recommend any changes needed. Terri Rademan moved the agenda be approved as printed. Art Hernandez seconded the motion. Motion carried. Approval of Minutes: Bill Case asked the Commissioners to review the minutes and offer corrections if needed. Art Hernandez moved the minutes be approved. Kevin Kelly seconded the motion. Motion carried. Section 106 Reviews a. 1128 Madeline — This Code Deficiency project will be funded with Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds. The project is to repair cracks in the basement walls. Bill Case moved that adequate documentation has been provided and there will be no historic properties affected by the current project and the request should be approved by the Commission. Art Hernandez seconded the motion. Motion carried. New Business: a. Missouri State Penitentiary National Register Nomination — Jayme gave the Commissioners an update on the progress of the nomination including the Commissions' initial review and recommendations to the nomination when reviewed the first time. The Commission had recommended that the nomination be expanded to include criterion B, property is associated with the lives of persons significant in our past; and D, property has yielded, or is likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history. The revised nomination does not include these criteria. In addition, the boundary lines were reduced to match what was included in the Redevelopment Master Plan from 2004. Art Hernandez expressed concern that the Commission was hamstrung by only being able to consider criterion A and C. Mary Schantz asked if the additional criterion could be added at some point in the future after the nomination was approved. Jayme Abbott indicated that it could be. Art Hernandez moved the issue be tabled until the October meeting of the Commission. Terri Rademan seconded the motion adding that the Commission appreciated all the work that had been put into the proposal. Motion carried. b. Historic City of Jefferson Proposed Demolition Ordinance — Bill Case asked the Commissioners to turn their attention to the most recent version of the Demolition Ordinance drafted by the Historic City of Jefferson (HCJ). Mary Schantz noted that the version distributed was slightly different that the version sent to the Commission making it difficult to proceed without time to compare or without someone familiar with the proposal there to answer questions. It was noted that no one from HCJ was present. Art Hernandez expressed concern that it would be impossible for the Commission to proceed in discussion without an HCJ representative present. Mary Schantz asked if public hearings will be conducted on the proposed ordinance. Rich Mihalevich, City Councilman from the Ward 2, responded from the audience that if the proposed ordinance is approved by the Commission it will move forward and will be reviewed by the Public Works Department and will be presented at least two times to the full City Council. At those meetings there will be an opportunity for public input. Art Hernandez moved that the proposal be tabled until the October meeting and further that at that meeting a representative of HCJ be in attendance and prepared to discuss the proposal. Mary Schantz seconded the motion. Motion carried. Dates to Remember: a. Next Meeting October 13, 2015 — this may change if a joint regular and special meeting is called to hear the HCJ presentation on the proposed demolition ordinance. b. Historic City of Jefferson, Homes Tours September 20, 2015 c. Missouri Preservation Conference, Cape Girardeau, October 21-23, 2015. Adjournment: Terri Rademan moved the meeting be adjourned at 6:20 pm. Doug Record seconded the motion. Motion carried. ARTICLE III. PROCEDURES FOR THE PROTECTION OF HISTORIC DEMOLITION OR REMOVAL OF BUILDINGS Sec. 8-32. Permit to demolish. A. Purpose 1. The Jefferson City, Missouri, City Council finds and declares that: a. Jefferson City has a rich historic heritage which is reflected in its people, culture, landmarks, downtown areas, riverfront, neighborhoods, cemeteries and historic structures such as buildings, monuments and other physical artifacts; b. The aforementioned historic landmarks, sites, structures and objects that reflect and are a part of the heritage of Jefferson City should be preserved as a living part of our community in order to engender a respect for the past and for who we are now and in order to nurture the cultural and economic life of our City. c. In the natural course of things, the historic landmarks, sites, structures and objects in Jefferson City are being lost or materially altered so as to destroy their historic character, and the Council finds that lack of planning causes or contributes to cause the unnecessary loss of historic landmarks, sites, structures and objects. d. The public interest of Jefferson City will be served by the preservation of its historic landmarks, sites, buildings and other structures and objects in that such preservation will nurture the cultural and economic life of the community. e. The present Jefferson City ordinances are inadequate to enforce the protection of the historic landmarks and buildings of Jefferson City. 2. The purpose of this Article is to provide a mechanism for the safe demolition of buildings and to enforce long-term planning and other mechanisms for the protection of the landmarks and buildings of the City of Jefferson which represent important elements of the city's cultural, social, economic, political and architectural history. B. A, Permit Required. It shall be unlawful to demolish or remove a building or structure without first ' _ . . : : ' . ' • - :' - ' . • _ . Protective Services or his or her designee in writing and obtaining a demolition permit from the Director of Planning and Protective Services in writing. Demolition shall be construed to include an act or process which destroys, in part or in whole, a building or structure or which threatens to destroy a building or structure by failure to maintain it in a condition of good repair and maintenance. A permit to demolish or remove shall not be issued until a release is obtained from the utilities having service connections with the building. The release shall state that service connections and appurtenant equipment, such as meters and regulators, have been removed or sealed and plugged in a safe manner. Any application for demolition or removal shall be subject to a sixty (60) day review period by the CJHPC, except any application made to demolish or remove any building, structure or humanly constructed object built less than fifty (50) years prior to the date of application, which shall have been determined to have no historic or architectural significance by the Department of Planning and Protective Services under the criteria set out in paragraph C. Any recommendation by the CJHPC shall be advisory only. Nothing in this section shall be construed so as to prohibit the building commissioner from acting under any emergency provisions of Chapter 8 of the Code of the City of Jefferson, Missouri. (Ord. No. 12941, §1, 6-21-99; Ord. No. 13106, §1, 9-5-2000) B Review Process. 1. Department. All applications for permission to demolish a building or structure shall be made to the Department of Planning and Protective Services. For any structure that is fifty (50) years old or older, the application must contain the following: 1) photographs, either in hard - - - - - taken within the last ninety (90) days; and 2) a statement from the owner addressing why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored with a and finding that it is in proper form, contains all necessary information, and complies with all applicable provisions of city ordinances, the department shall forward a copy of the application to CJHPC. (Ord. No. 15184, §1, 10 21 2013. 2. CJHPC. The CJHPC may have a sixty (60) day period for review of every application for a demolition permit subject to this section. The CJHPC shall establish procedures to expedite the review of applications for permits to demolish structures. (Ord. No. 12941, §2, 6 21 99) C. Standards of Review for a Permit to Demolish. Review Process. 1. Department of Planning and Protective Services. a. All applications for permission to demolish a building shall be made to the Department of Planning and Protective Services. Subject to all other provisions of law, the Department shall have the authority immediately to issue a permit to demolish a building b. =liktnMof all Buildings Fifty Years Old or Older owned by the City of Jefferson or any private person or business entity: The application must contain the following: 1) photographs, either in hard copy or as digital files, of the building and of all exterior sides, interior rooms, and stairwells, taken within the last ninety (90) days of the building proposed to be demolished; 2) a comprehensive plan for the continued development of the property where the building is located; and 3) a statement with reasons in support of the application for demolition, including an analysis of the costs and hardship of repairing and/or restoring and maintaining the property without demolition; and an analysis of the value of the property with and without demolition. The Department of Planning and Protective Services, after determining that the application is complete and in proper form, shall refer any application to demolish a building which is fifty year old or older which is owned by the City of Jefferson or any private person or business entity to the City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission (CJHPC). 2. City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission a. The CJHPC shall have ninety (90) days from receipt of the application by the CJHPC to review an application demolition _ owned by the City of Jefferson or any private person or business entity. In the event that the application the building has not been denied or granted with conditions within ninety (90) days of receipt, the application shall be deemed granted. b. Upon receipt of the application to coetely demolish or remote the building, the CJHPC shall immediately publish notice of the application by (a) posting a notice prominently and in public view on the property; and (b) publishing the notice in the newspaper on three (3) consecutive Sundays; and (c) mailing the notice by regular first class mail to all adjoining property owners of record; and (d) mailing the notice by regular first class mail to all persons on a registry of persons who shall have requested notice of building demolition. The notice shall invite written comments from any interested person and shall state the address to which such comments may be mailed, state the deadline for the receipt of comments, which shall be the first business day following the last Sunday on which the newspaper notice is filed, and state that only the applicant and persons who have filed comments will receive notice of the decision of the City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission. c. The City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission shall establish and maintain a registry of all persons requesting notice of any application to a building fifty years old or older which comes before the CJHPC. d. The City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission shall either grant the application, or grant the application with conditions, or deny the application. e. The City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission shall immediately mail notice of its decision by certified mail, return receipt, to the applicant and by regular first class mail to all persons who have filed written comments. 3. City Council: Only the applicant a building fifty years older or older shall have a right of appeal from the decision of City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission to the City of Jefferson City Council, and an applicant shall have an appeal right where denied an application to demolish or where granted an application with conditions. An applicant shall file an appeal within thirty (30) days of a denial or of the granting of a conditional application by filing same with the Jefferson City clerk in such form as shall be established by the Jefferson City Clerk. The City Council shall conduct a public hearing on the application de novo and shall grant the application, grant the application with conditions, or deny the application. 4. Circuit Court: Only a private person property owner or a business entity property owner shall have a right of appeal from the decision of the City of Jefferson City Council to the Cole or Callaway County Circuit Court, and an applicant shall have an appeal right where denied an application ro complete a building fifty years old or older or where granted an application with conditions. An applicant shall file an appeal within thirty (30) days of a denial or of the granting of an application with conditions by filing a Petition with the Cole County Circuit Clerk or Callaway County Circuit Clerk (depending upon which county the property is located in). The Circuit Court shall hear the cause de novo. The Circuit Court shall enter judgment granting the application , granting the application with conditions, or denying the application. The Court may deny the application only if the Court finds a) that the Petitioner has the economic means, considering all of the reasonably available resources, to maintain the property without demolition; and b) that the property may be used to its highest and best use without demolition; and c) that the public's interest in protecting the historical character of the property outweighs the Petitioner's interests to be served by the demolition of the property. In any such proceeding before the Circuit Court, the parties shall be the property owner and the City of Jefferson, and the burden of proof shall rest upon the property owner to prove by the preponderance of the evidence that the property owner does not have the economic means, considering all of the reasonably available resources, to maintain the property without complete demolition or removal; and shall be upon the City of Jefferson to prove by the preponderance of the evidence that the property may be used to its highest and best use without complete demolition or removal and that the public's interest in protecting the historical character of the property outweighs the Petitioner's interests to be served by the complete demolition or removal of the building. In determining the public's interest in protecting the historical character of the property, it shall be the City of Jefferson's burden to produce evidence and the court shall consider the said evidence of the historic value of the building by reason of age or association with important figures or events; or by reason of the place of the building in the history of Jefferson City, the State of Missouri or the United States; or by reason of the building's embodiment of the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction; or by reason of the building's representation of the work of an historically notable architect, designer or draftsperson; or by reason of the building's visual and spatial relationship to designated or potential historic landmarks or historical districts. 1. The historic value of the building or structure by reason of age or association with important figures or events; or as evidence of aspects of the history of Jefferson City, the State of Missouri or the United States; or as an embodiment of the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction; or as a representation of the work of an historically notable architect, designer or draftsperson; 2. The visual and spatial relationship of the building or structure to designated or potential historic landmarks or historical districts; 3. The state of deterioration or disrepair or structural unsoundness of the . . . . . - may request the applicant to submit documentation beyond that which is specified in the application in a form specified by the CJHPC or other information necessary to determine whether the property can be rehabilitated or restored with a reasonable economic return to the owner. (Ord. No. 15184, §1, 10 21 2013) D. Approval or disapproval. Within five (5) days after either: 1. the CJHPC's determination: or 2. the expiration of the sixty (60) day review period, whichever occurs first, the director of Planning and Protective Services shall approve or not approve the application. A negative recommendation by the CJHPC shall not be grounds for disapproval of the application. (Ord. No. 14691, §2, 6 21 2010; Ord. No. 9154, § 1, 8 21 78; Ord. No. 10397, § 7, /l 1 85; Ord. No. 11737, § 1, 5 1 92; Ord. No. 12794, §2, 8 17 98) Sec. 8-33. Permit fee. No permit to remove or demolish a building shall be issued until a fee as set out in Appendix Y shall have been paid to the department of Planning and Protective Services or other authorized municipal agency. (Ord. No. 9154, § 3, 8-21-78; Ord. No. 9534, § 1, 10-20-80; Ord. 14272, §5, 10- 15-2007) Sec. 8-34. Maintenance of vacated premises. Whenever a building is demolished or removed, the premises shall be maintained free from all unsafe or hazardous conditions by the proper regulation of the lot, restoration of established grade and the erection of the necessary retaining walls and fences in accordance with the provisions of Article 13 of the city's building code. (Ord. No. 9154, § 4, 8-21-78) Sec. 8-35. Grading of lot. When a building has been demolished or destroyed by fire or other natural causes and no building operation has been projected or approved, the vacant lot shall be filled, graded and maintained to conform on all sides to the existing grades and elevations of the adjacent property. Adjoining walls shall be left in an acceptable condition to prevent the harboring of insects, rodents or pigeons. The lot shall be maintained free from the accumulation of rubbish and all other unsafe or hazardous conditions which endanger the life or health of the public; provisions shall be made to prevent the accumulation of water or damage to any foundations on the premises of the adjoining property. Upon completion of the demolition, the lot shall be left in a state that is aesthetically acceptable to the director of Planning and Protective Services. In the event of a disagreement over the term "aesthetically acceptable," the matter shall be referred to the city council for final determination. (Ord. No. 9154, § 5, 8-21-78) Sec. 8-36. Suspension of permit. Any demolition permit shall become invalid if the authorized work is not commenced within thirty (30) days after the issuance of the permit, or if the authorized work is suspended or abandoned for a period of ten (10) days after the time of commencing the work. All work including grading and lot re-construction must be completed within ninety (90) days after the time of commencing the work unless a written extension of time is issued by the Director of Planning and Protective Services. (Ord. No. 9154, § 6, 8-21-78) Sec. 8-37. Penalties. Any person who shall violate any provision of this article shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of not more than five hundred dollars ($500.00) or by imprisonment not to exceed one hundred eighty (180) days, or both such fine and imprisonment. Each day that a violation continues shall be deemed a separate offense. (Ord. No. 10397, § 8, 4-1-85; Code 1983, § 7-38; Ord. No. 11201, § 4, 4-17-89) Secs. 8-38 8 48. Res.�Zd—Civil Remedy for Unpaid Fines Whenever a property owner shall have been convicted of two or more misdemeanors for violations of any provision of this article with respect to a single property and the unpaid fines and costs for those convictions shall have aggregated to more than $5,000.00, then the City of Jefferson may at its option and at any time until the fines and costs assessed for all of said misdemeanors are wholly paid bring an action in the Circuit Court of the county wherein the property is located to obtain a judgment in the amount of the unpaid fines and costs enforceable pursuant to the provisions of Section 511.350, RSMO. Such an action shall be in rem, and service of process in compliance with the Missouri Supreme Court Rules of Court for in rem actions shall be sufficient. Secs. 8-39 8-48 reserved. to IF I P4 yQE. ,d4d O f' City of Jefferson ,N�„�+01l4 Carrie Tergin, Mayor Department of Planning&Protective Services `° — Janice McMillan,AICP, Director 320 E.McCarty Street Phone:573-634-6410 Jefferson City,MO 65101 i Fax: 573-634-6457 To: City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission From: Jayme Abbott, Neighborhood Services Coordinator Date: November 12, 2015 Re: Demolition Permit Review at 806 Jefferson St The following information regarding an application for demolition is being submitted for your review and comments in accordance with the requirements of the demolition ordinance. DEMOLITION PERMIT REVIEW Property is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to our history. Property is associated with the lives of persons significant in our past. Property embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction, or represents a work of a master, or possesses high artistic values. Property has a visual or spatial relationship to designated or potential landmarks or districts. Property is in disrepair or structurally unsound Property appears to be practical to rehabilitate The Historic Preservation Commission reviewed this property and makes the following recommendation to the Department of Planning and Development: ❑ There will be "no historic properties affected” by the demolition and the permit is approved by this commission. D Demolition will have a "no adverse effect" and the permit is approved by this commission. ❑ Demolition will have an "adverse effect" and the permit is not approved by this commission. By: Date: Historic Preservation Commission Representative Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. RECEIVE HISTORIC PRESERVATION CHECKLIST OCT - 6 2015 Please direct questions to Jayne Abbott,Neighborhood Services Coord nat,'r• Section 8- 32 of the City Code provides the Historic Preservation Commission with 6► da pTE rE SERVICES demolition application(s) affecting structures which are 50 years of age or older. Exterior & interior color photographs and a statement as to why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored are required to be submitted with the demolition permit application. A negative response by the Historic Preservation Commission is not grounds for denying a demolition permit. Application to the Historic Preservation Commission can take place prior to completion of the rest of the Demolition Permit Application. Address: g06 \/e,ger coli 1. Year Built ) 116 2. Is the structure 50 (fifty)years or older? u Yes ❑No 3. Is the structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places? ❑ Yes CdNo (Please see the list of properties at http://www.dnr.mo.gov/shpo/Cole.htm) 4. Is the structure a recipient of a City of Jefferson Landmark Award? ❑ Yes INo (Please see the list of properties at http://www.ieffersoncitymo.gov/pps/LandmarkAwards.html) 5. Historical name of structure Of ally) 6. Historical use s ;d f c fj 7. Most recent use s 1dce�G 8. If answers to Questions 2, 3 or 4 are"Yes,"please provide a statement addressing why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored with a reasonable economic return to the owner(attach additional pages if necessary): Amer/, q doe bd A/11/% > /d/AL /7 4,i %c,,, Ss //iv, y eyes ije �F /fetz 0.-C7GGt iE>icAu1es o�/base inn fl at P r ti ed As ry.kj Dene c - i+ tons u R<sa-Fe ttl 9. Please attach photographs either in hard copy or digital files of all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells.Photographs should have been taken within the last ninety(90)days. ❑Hard copy photographs U< igital files 10. Applicant Contact Name and Phone Number: Name:67-59 ',Lotev— Phone: 573--690 - 2/ 7 44r /raroy,s /LL Print Preview Page 1 of 1 MidMoGIS, MO • :° 0.36 ac `te ` • • • �3 r/ _ • _ [ / }fig# .` r kir 4 11 . lF + .1j . /f 'r *,* ; `G�' -.,i g'.°6 fJ i '*. '• '11'' -."<:: ..5' 44, ..„..Q... , \....... , / re ,.. -,,, . .. ,. . .. ., 'y. -..... . ... .. . . , . . .,..... ..,aa ..... ._. -F Parcel ID 1 1103070003003019 Book-Page Date 658 -779& 10/14/2015 Owner Name — VADNER PROPERTIES L L C Sec/Twn/Rng 7 /44/11 Mailing Address 1105 SCHUMATE CHAPEL RD Square Feet(AboveGrade) 1,302 City State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, MO 55109 Basement Type Full Property Address 805 Jefferson St Finished Bsmnt. Size (Sq° Ft.) Subdivision WA CURRYS OF INLOT 969 TO 976 Year Built 1910 Subdivision Image A' A CURRYS OF INLOT 969 TO 976 Date Certified 1/112015 Comm: 0 Property Description SUBD OF INLOTS 969 TO 976; N 17' Property Values (Land) Ag: $0 OF LOT 5 &S 16" OF LOT 6 Res. $7,000 Comm: $0 Book-Page Date 112-094 05/29/1946 Property Values (Improv.) Ag: $0 Res: $29700 Book-Page Date 350 -550 06/24/1993 Appraised Value $36,700 Disclaimer:Map and parcel data are believed to be accurate, but accuracy is not guaranteed_ This as not a Map Scale legal document and should not be substituted fora title search,appraisai survey, or for zoning verification_ 1 inch = 88 feet 10/28/2015 http://www.midmogis.org/colesl/WebForms/Print.aspx?img=http://www.midmogis.org/ar... 1 0/28/2015 806 Jefferson St Demolition • t • r e• Ilh r e' �fn • f f' EF4 t. - . 1 : r i� ' ,. moi.: h 11. fJf,I t i,,,t 01 I • 1 41. - 0''.le 028 ac w ., A ti - ai<' Property is not listed on the ..,r National Register of Historic 0 ,- - J. 1;, L Places. o f" , Q39ac Yy , °' •.•' :, 3 Property is noted a recipient of ' City Landmark Award. '4rr 4t44 46, , ,, 14 _ Property recently acquired by , / .g. ! owners of River Song to remove ' a4 `. K1 eyesore and potentially add ., ' , x r /,§) , parking. ' � p g• Ali Parcel ID 1103070003003019 L;ok-,=age Date 658 -779& 10/14/2015 Owner Name VADNER PROPERTIES L L C Sec/Twr//Rng 7 /44/11 Mailing Address 1105 SCHUMATE CHAPEL RD Square Feet (Above Grade) 1,302 City State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, M{) 65109 Basement Type Full Property Address 806 Jefferson St Finished Bsmnt. Size (Sq. Ft.) Subdivision W A CURRYS OF INLOT 969 TO 976 Year Built 1910 Subdivision Image W A CURRYS OF INLOT 969 TO 976 Date Certified 1/1/2015 SUSD OF INLOTS 969 TO 976 N 17 Comm: $0 Property Description OF LOT 5 &5 16' OF LOT 6 Property Values (Land) Ag: $0 Res: $7,000 Comm: $0 Book-Page Date 112 -094 05/29/1946 Property Values (Improv.) Ag: $0 Res: $29,700 Book-Page Date 350 -550 06/24/1993 Appraised Value $36,700 806 Jefferson St Demolition l • t . ..,__ , - .4 r� i .10 ' - ilk . , i , ' .e. .r Ill.:- ,------aiiiiip:0114" ? ' I or+ v- - E ..IE..r •. - +c_, 4 806 Jefferson St • DemolitionA r t 4iitt on • .. . . ti IN . 'IP .0 P' . • ' ' .- IL- a. I odt 7 , r. . . t . A .- '., - ..- 1- .1. • .1.AWIIII.111111.11111 — o • •tNEPutv ill •r 1 i II -• , 4111001.111141114 • ,. . - •ilic„,_ •....4,1t- -*- ilk 4'' 7111V-Ctit i .,.# • ' " ' ' • ''' 'n'* '.,-'. .• ...°".'-' - "' r .'' -.,_ '4•7-,..' :7-`,..• •.. f..., , t . 806 Jefferson St Demolition Application ,.. It .. . tlp, . . -- X, rhfs�,,i�j 111\ : 1 s ilk. .414! 1 i • 806 Jefferson St Demolition Application : —• - ,-- -- --•—•- . —,—, —,—,- .. --.,, —,—„- - •, , ;....-- -,--..- .-;•:,-‘,.N ___„_,_ . • _ . ____,;_-• e- 7- r 1 - ... ,. -- i -7_,_. ._•- _ • • - . fli----.'----._TTTTTX illr,10.1 . A. I ' . •• . . = . •k ..10. .. ' .•j ,,, ,. -, , a . .— .. NO. - . •- •-..• . I •41°. , • • • • 9 .• . .. .. of., 806 Jefferson St Demolition Application _. .. _ . _, ar t . _. o . . . i , , / , ,,, _. . . . q , ... .. . ..., ,, idII f I ,, ...,, i G v k . , pit k_, P ,,, ' 4 I i_ i � 1. 1,1.... 1 t - • 4411fi • p 6; A - i 111 -- _ f 11 ., .-mil i , 0 , 4 ,.., , m ,1 im , , , r I� , 1 806 Jefferson St Demolition Application • New property owner did not provide pictures of the basement as he felt unsafe to enter. agiftwitiatte 111 ■ � d to IF I P4 yQE. ,d4d O f' City of Jefferson ,N�„�+01l4 Carrie Tergin, Mayor Department of Planning&Protective Services `° — Janice McMillan,AICP, Director 320 E.McCarty Street Phone:573-634-6410 Jefferson City,MO 65101 i Fax: 573-634-6457 To: City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission From: Jayme Abbott, Neighborhood Services Coordinator Date: November 3, 2015 Re: Demolition Permit Review at 623-625 W. McCarty St The following information regarding an application for demolition is being submitted for your review and comments in accordance with the requirements of the demolition ordinance. DEMOLITION PERMIT REVIEW Property is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to our history. Property is associated with the lives of persons significant in our past. Property embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction, or represents a work of a master, or possesses high artistic values. Property has a visual or spatial relationship to designated or potential landmarks or districts. Property is in disrepair or structurally unsound Property appears to be practical to rehabilitate The Historic Preservation Commission reviewed this property and makes the following recommendation to the Department of Planning and Development: ❑ There will be "no historic properties affected” by the demolition and the permit is approved by this commission. D Demolition will have a "no adverse effect" and the permit is approved by this commission. ❑ Demolition will have an "adverse effect" and the permit is not approved by this commission. By: Date: Historic Preservation Commission Representative Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. HISTORIC PRESERVATION CHECKLIST Please direct questions to Jayme Abbott,Neighborhood Services Coordinator Section 8- 32 of the City Code provides the Historic Preservation Commission with 60 days to review demolition application(s) affecting structures which are 50 years of age or older. Exterior & interior color photographs and a statement as to why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored are required to be submitted with the demolition permit application. A negative response by the Historic Preservation Commission is not grounds for denying a demolition permit. Application to the Historic Preservation Commission can take place prior to completion of the rest of the Demolition Permit Application. Address: 6,23 — la 2.5— W MG Cay4 y 51- . +. Year Built C.j/tdc„ )Q30 — _/0 2. Is the structure 50 (fifty)years or older? L Yes U No 3. Is the structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places? U Yes GINo (Please see the list ofproperties at http://www.dnr.mo.gov/shpo/Cole.htm) 4. Is the structure a recipient of a City of Jefferson Landmark Award? U Yes 0/"No (Please see the list of properties athttp://www.jeffcitymo.org/pps/LandrnarkAwards.html) 5. Historical name of structure(if any) 6. Historical use A, ki'Jntrt-$ 7. Most recent use Vat-44-11A ^ S4OYaga— A pit J-4-YLtenf 8. If answers to Questions 2, 3 or 4 are"Yes,"please provide a statement addressing why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored with a reasonable economic return to the owner(attach additional pages if necessary): ,aes AJ We hdowss Ssdhy) AJY4c) 5>OLOV sr -vdts, 7o vhJail erl, flea-mead Y�fs l ei- A eip t c e e-n4- $ P t b r ecJ . tom(..,44 ol7nrri tatz�G& FeGLst,b1 e 0 9. Please attach photographs either in hard copy or digital files of all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. Photographs should have been taken within the last ninety(90)days. ❑ Hard copy photographs U Digital files 10. Applicant Contact Name,pand Phone Number:r ��p2 c Name:&Pin e / . SCAY1 e) Qy' Phone: ZJ LJ"✓azD 10-26-15 Jayme Abbott City of Jefferson NOV 9 2015 Department of Planning and Protective Services 320 E.McCarty Street p1 rit " `r, R Jefferson City, Mo — Ms.Abbott, After careful thought and consideration concerning the rehabilitation of the property located at 623/625 West McCarty Street, I have concluded that the required investment is not a viable plan. Economic data considered: Estimated cost to replace or improve: $195,000 plus contingencies Siding $33,000 Painting $13,000 Windows $27,000 Gutters $4,000 HVAC $22,000 Roof $11,000 Plumbing $24,000 Electrical $18,000 Floors $16,000 Porches $10,000 Concrete $9,000 Misc. $8,000 Additional subject data and features considered: • Poor rental history • Poor return on previous improvements • Flood plain • Loan repayment is prohibitive • History of vandalism Therefore, I am requesting a demolition permit. Sincerely, Gene P. Schneider,Trustee Print Preview Page 1 of 1 MidMoGIS, MO r, dr ' r - : . r.' 111 • /� lIT g s z�. rrr '7 N. 4e { T px:,,,N., _ ,, r, ,... r # {} + _ i3 /1:''' \ f _ Cid '' • ..o.q ac' - it • t, 'rte S=r ti p� + ` ie.nle rParcel ID ]103070002003005 Book Page Date 391 609 11/12/1897 Owner Name 1103070002003005 GENE PAUL TRUSTEE SeclTwn/Rng 7/44/11 Mailing Address 301 CONSTITUTION DR.. Square Feet(Above Grade) 2,985 • City State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, MO 55103 Basement Type Full Property Address 623 W Mocarty St Finished Bsmnt, Size (Sq, Ft.) Subdivision CITY OF JEFFERSON INLOT Year Built 1900 Subdivision Image CITY OF JEFFERSON INLOT Date Certified 1/1/2015 P.1L543; BEG NW COR IL54.3; SE Comm: $0 Property Description ALONG MCCARTY 53.15'; SW 198.75' Propetr° Values (Land) Ag: $0 TO ALLEY; NW 53.18'; NE 198,75'TO Res:POB $7,000 Comm: $0 Book-Page Date 647 -447 09/25/2014 Property Values (Improv.) Ag: $0 Res; $56,300 Book-Page Date 318 -220& 11/06/1989 Appraised Value $63,300 Disclaimer_ Map.and parcel data are believed to be accurate, but accuracy is;rot guaranteed_ This is raot a Map Scale legal document and should not be substituted for a title sears appraisal survey, or for zoning 1 inch = 158 feet verification. 11/3/2015 http://www.midmogis.org/colesl/WebForms/Print.aspx?img=http://www.midmogis.org/arc... 11/3/2015 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application ! , I i _, __ , . ._ . _ . _ , , __ , 111 IM '",., ...'-- -- -- _ . 1 r.~�*-A 34•- -.:�? -q �K' - +yam- . - - I' r ,,,, li I L ,.,,,,, 7 T _ 214' . :. - '� \ ' , �.. 0 71 ac Property is not listed on the - p Y , , gi* recipient • 4 NationalRegister nor a " ii ~ ',b0 . , 4-k, N`7 ac �f of the City Landmark Award. • „i' ,,....,,,,,..,,,/ - , c!, 411 .-, Ns -,/ . -T, ., 0 , As ,,,,,-(., 0 -it:, -, ,, • r C ° �$ ' 42;* +i .- � g '` Property owner has completedleted a4) 0 ' .. � v '© ' cost analysis (see packet).�0 _.;;,' 13‘ : 4. ;` ' Property owner may salvage . _ �, �r_. ., . items to use in other rental 7* - '-if �` �' properties he owns. _ ~• rs _ 4,,, „it?. s-a'"4' Parcel ID 1103070002003005 Book-Page Date 391 -609 11/12/1997 Owner Name SCHNEIDERr GENE PAUL TRUSTEE Sec,ITwvn/Rng 7/44111 .411. Mai - Mailing Address 301 CONSTITUTION DR Square Feet (Above Grade) 2,985 City State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, MO 65109 Basement Type Full Property Address 623 W Mccarty St Finished Bsrnnt. Size (5q. Ft.) Subdivision CITY OF JEFFERSON INLQT Year Built 1900 Subdivision Image CITY OF JEFFERSON INLOT Date Certified 111/2015 P. IL543; BEG NW COR IL543; SE Comm: Property Description ran ALONG MCCARTY 53.18'; SW 198.75` Property Values (Land) A R Y R TO ALLEY; NW 53,18'; NE 198,75' TO R rtY9e $0 POB Res: $7,030 Comm: $0 Book-Page Date 647 -447 09/25/2014 Property Values (Improv.) Ag: $0 Res: $56,300 Book-Page Date 318 -2.20& 11/06/1989 Appraised Value $63,.300 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application „ .. __ _ i ,1 ., . __ _.,,, _ _ , , 7 .. r ice, _ _ 47 Vg s �j h _ _ _ .,iii_, ,,, , 1 , ,,.. :mei ill.I 151. w 1 "e 111 - l j _Y - -Y1"•- .r.- w: � '. ' _ t, _ -_.-_rte 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application . , ,,... . , \\`‘ \\\s\s4,4 f.: .1:1R C Jli ., iP.' I 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application i , . 041 __ _ ______ _ _ __ _ . . _ • . 1, . __,_ •__ . UM , .4.. , \ ,,.... . . ., __ __ ... .„; ,..., „.. ) ____ ____ , _ _ ___T__ ___ _ _ , . . ti, , ,,,k„ ,„ffi,,, t _.. ,.._,.•• .... \ w , , 1 I i � ���0 A ,�- mi A , , 4, , t, ,, ,it . . y I A / t .. .I.; Ste! 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application •... ,,:: 1 ,, . .._....._ .,. _ . , i,. .,. _, 4N' �-' -,_ A rig S oma�, ! a I !, A ": �' A - -A N 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application . . , A I : bz i P � ti �� it �_ 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application .. amadil 1i -- ......"... .......-0::::: ------___ •••••••••••••• f ----"---- AMMO MI.7: 0•1•4604 k _ _ ;:;_r_. _A _____......iii: ..m, .. ........ 7..—7 _ . 1--- _.---, _., ..._ , - - - i, —I- 1 / , i f ..... ‘HI... ••••••••••••••••• I i. , tailiam...arilnalmsa...M1111.0•••••••••••••••••••••••{0•1110:::''........."..... ' k i ' :::.44.•••11: ..441 \ y filL, , '''\ iiiii:M!!!:MS.A.m.dummum•Enamorn.Vim.•.' ' ' '-" ' 'lin:— i •.••..•••.•......................monsp , 1, 1 ., i to "" I. 1 . '',-, ..'---- I ''. ..... ^ .... -'. . "- --'1"fgm''- Wr"-' \1 , ... ""er. , , \IIIM limilimmik, In (---"--'--------:::. i - _ __ 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application _, ,_,. , ,...., )k',._ _ ...., _____._. .... . . -_____, , 0 , , : - -- .,..-„ , ... _,,,..„ „ I 1. 1 \ ii 1 .4.,:-•-.,..:, .k t attl v 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application , 1, , ... ••, , ,. ,i A •M `! I • it 1 V g *110A iii.4,,,,,._ f , ' 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application .,,.... ,--,,,,,.....-...,_ , • . „.,.7_ , ,t ..,e_ , ..... V �!_ `. :._ �_. , , .. ..„... „,..,--.. illi r :: '' 4% ! L a z 4 ` ' �T. 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application . ., I - AP .'' ' r ;i . . , ... . ._ .. .,,---1.-- , ; . ._ ,,,,x-s . ,. 4/ -. . _______ -- ,___ ____.,_ --t•=1.5----.._-/-7_1,----w-- -- -Te* ' , - !--4111.., ei,..L.,-1.4".°.i.e..ii.::_.......0.tis,,.-1-.1't -'---7'___,t'' _.....,..f..to....:077.:_...ai ri.;r--21 0 m.,,,r. S: 1 1 f . ; '� - "=ms`s Q , .4fie'. t 623 - 625 W DemolitionMcCavApplicationrt St s : :� _ t -=---_-_,-__ 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application 111_, imi a. 31 1 ___ , mw,. 1 i . Ili I la J''' l - J s 623 -625 W McCarty St Demolition Application 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application w , , . , ••164 all . .iiiiL .. s 0 e„, ililir r: . 1i-rr4L- '• . I _ ` _ 0 4 -:i-7.3_4, � t , - s-est 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application . . L. __ .,_ _ i . ...--„, -.,- -„. _...:....,-,„... : ....0 _ ,4J ., L . Iii „ �. Y 623 -625 W McCarty St Demolition Application Copper Piping Stolen 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application 1 0 1 a I 623 -625 W McCarty St Demolition Application 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application . . ,--z--. - __ ' - - --.'. .)",--"1.-. • '''.., ,' 161, ' - '''',- .•"*.-N-,_ ' --.--— - ;:.; ... ',:.:;Pi..... •i..:''''-::\L - ) , . .. . . : .- i ":?-.• ' '..;r1- \ ',.-d ''''''•;',' ' :::'.,Z0--: - ,-..>'' .' . Ili .11 ' .':„,.2..., '•-:.;,4::Y,' ; -;4,...;:. .:.1 , * 1%/'•44t i ..1 ' .V..A. . . *V:. ..., Ili )" ) 1 . , I . li 1 . . .4. I . 623 -625 W McCarty St Demolition Application 623 -625 W McCarty St Demolition Application 623 - 625 W McCarty St Demolition Application _. 7. . ... """. , _ . . . moi. wr�../ y 1'za,,, '1110 ivw ,� "'�,'� �r 1 i. /11( , ' i r 'ti", d . to IF I P4 yQE. ,d4d O f' City of Jefferson ,N�„�+01l4 Carrie Tergin, Mayor Department of Planning&Protective Services `° — Janice McMillan,AICP, Director 320 E.McCarty Street Phone:573-634-6410 Jefferson City,MO 65101 i Fax: 573-634-6457 To: City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission From: Jayme Abbott, Neighborhood Services Coordinator Date: November 4, 2015 Re: Demolition Permit Review at 1119 Jefferson St The following information regarding an application for demolition is being submitted for your review and comments in accordance with the requirements of the demolition ordinance. DEMOLITION PERMIT REVIEW Property is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to our history. Property is associated with the lives of persons significant in our past. Property embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction, or represents a work of a master, or possesses high artistic values. Property has a visual or spatial relationship to designated or potential landmarks or districts. Property is in disrepair or structurally unsound Property appears to be practical to rehabilitate The Historic Preservation Commission reviewed this property and makes the following recommendation to the Department of Planning and Development: ❑ There will be "no historic properties affected” by the demolition and the permit is approved by this commission. D Demolition will have a "no adverse effect" and the permit is approved by this commission. ❑ Demolition will have an "adverse effect" and the permit is not approved by this commission. By: Date: Historic Preservation Commission Representative Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. HISTORIC PRESERVATION CHECKLIST Please direct questions to Jayme Abbott, Neighborhood Services Coordinator Section 8- 32 of the City Code provides the Historic Preservation Commission with 60 days to review demolition application(s) affecting structures which are 50 years of age or older. Exterior & interior color photographs and a statement as to why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored are required to be submitted with the demolition permit application. A negative response by the Historic Preservation Commission is not grounds for denying a demolition permit. Application to the Historic Preservation Commission can take place prior to completion of the rest of the Demolition Permit Application. Address: 1119 Jefferson Street, Jefferson City, MO 65109 1. Year Built 1940 2. Is the structure 50(fifty)years or older? 0Yes O No 3. Is the structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places? °Yes °No (Please see the list of properties at http://www.dnr.mo.gov/shpo/Cole.htm) 4. Is the structure a recipient of a City of Jefferson Landmark Award? 0 Yes ONo (Please see the list of properties at http://www.jeffersoncitymo.gov/pps/LandmarkAwards.html) 5. Historical name of structure(if any) 6. Historical use 7. Most recent use 8. If answers to Questions 2, 3 or 4 are"Yes,"please provide a statement addressing why the property cannot be rehabilitated or restored with a reasonable economic return to the owner(attach additional pages if necessary): OP )j ry i . 1Nc d (le 7�r%,<t.' t � f ri,641-xmezic-4?-1 ` lf; U52 r�� 1') ,t; f ,-44;! jaz1; t c *id has tooti tt (t. I- ,r co' ) , `z s r) )) a t;L nee// % 7 t t p 7 F,'. C t..< ' 9. t lease a c p otdgraphs either m hard copy or digital files of all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. Photographs should have been taken within the last ninety(90)days. ()Hard copy photographs °Digital files 10. Applicant Contact Name and Phone Number: Name:. ., \ \o Phone: S 73 i {p^ f belt,L9 -Gov- 1\V{ 0)fr. " ts- 1�tla t. � Print Preview Page 1 of 1 MidMoGIS, MO 1 11 II ,` T � i.i. .,‘. 4� '4O 01 Idlr; '$. ".. 0/1, .,._..„ .. .. .., .... , . , 0. ! p k�I / .Ilii � I ¢.,i. II�`r F3. 47a ' e 11 ° I c: N 5 iIF ft's T Np‘ {{, ;' tF # pp Parcel ID 1104180002005017 Book-Page Date 357 -181 03/28/1995 MEMORIAL BAPTIST CHURCH OF Owner Name Secliwn/Rng 18/44/11 JEFFERSON CITY Nailing Address 1120 MADISON ST Square Feet(Above Grade) 1,348 City State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, MO 65101 Basement Type Full Property Address 1119 Jefferson St Finished Bsmnt. Size (Sq. Ft.) Subdivision CITY OF JEFFERSON OUTLOT Year Built1940 I _ Subdivision Image CITY OF JEFFERSON OUTLOT Date Certified 1/1/2015 S 50' OF SUB #3 EXC W PART GIVEN Comm: $0 FOR JEFFERSON ST RJ Property Description V� &N 15' Property Values (Land) Ag: $0 OFVAC SPRUCE ST LYING ADJACENT TO ABOVE Res; $7,000 Comm: $0 Book-Page Date 405 -347 12/3111998 Property Values (Improv.) Ag: $0 Res; $70,000 Book-Page Date 450 -635 12/18/2001 Appraised Value $77,000 Disclaimer_Map and parcel data are believed to be accurate, but accuracy is not guaranteed_ This is nota Map Scale legal document and should not be substituted for a title search,apprarsat survey, or for zoning 1 inch = 183 feet verifrcation- 1114171115 http://www.midmogis.org/colesl/WebForms/Print.aspx?img=http://www.midmogis.org/arc... 11/4/2015