HomeMy Public PortalAboutAutomobile Accidentsv
Two youths killed as auto hits tree
east barrow pit for a considerable
distance before striking a large
tree. All three city police officers,
two ambulances and deputy sheriff
Derold Lynskey were called to the
scene.
Funeral services for Mr. Espy,
son of Mr. and Mrs. Robert Espy,
Jr., were conducted yesterday in
Monte Espy
MCCALL —Two young McCall
men, Monte Espy, 20, and Michael
Webb, 21, were killed instantly, a
third, Barry Binning, 17, seriously
injured, and two others, Davis
Stewart, 22, and Juan Hernandez,
20, suffered lesser injuries early
Sunday morning in a single -car
accident on Warren Wagon Road,
about one - fourth mile north of
Hgwy. 55.
Binning, who was taken by
ambulance to St. Alphonsus
Hospital in Boise Sunday, un-
derwent surgery there for ex-
tensive internal injuries and was
reported in "satisfactory" con-
dition Tuesday by attending
physician Dr. Robert Morrell.
Stewart and Hernandez remained
hospitalized, in "satisfactory"
condition, in McCall Tuesday, the
former with niultiple superficiA
injuries and the latter with a
fractured arm and other injuries.
According to police chief Bill
Acker, the southbound 1965
Chevrolet owned and driven by
Webb left the right -of -way at about
1:45 a.m. and traveled along the
Michael Webb
McCall, and will be held this af- Mr. and Mrs. Wayne Webb. (See
ternoon at 2 D.M. for Webb. son of obituaries.)
MCCALL —A collision between this car and tree on Warren Wagon Road claimed the lives of two McCall youths Sunday morning
Gills killed in car. accident r t %1 xP�s
By DICK PIEPER
WENATCHEE, Wash. — Rod Gill
and his wife Pam Kunes Gill, both
former coaches at Mission Ridge here,
were killed in an automobile accident
near Riggins, Idaho, August 12.
Gill, 25, was a coach on the Mission
Ridge racing staff for several years
before taking the position of director
of racing at Mt. Brundage near
McCall, Idaho. His wife, Pam, 23, was
a top -notch racer for Mission Ridge
before retiring from competition after
the 1977 -78 season. With. Rod, she
helped coach the McCall skiers last
winter and developed the Northwest's
championship Buddy Werner squad.
As a racer, Pam Gill came very
close to cracking the national level.
Four times she represented the PNSA
in the U.S. National Alpine Champion -'
ships and was the first member of the
Mission Ridge Academy after it was
formed by Jon Bowerman in 1972.
Both Gills were graduates of
Central Washington University in
Ellensburg, Rod majoring in
recreation management and Pam in
physical education. Both young people
grew up in the Wenatchee area and
Pam earned the distinction of being
the foremost female alpine racer ever
to have come out of North Central
Washington.
Casket bearers at the double
funeral service August 17 were ski
racing coaches who had worked with
the Gills at Mission Ridge. They
included John Travers, now a coach
with the national team; Dick Knowles,
director of racing at Mission Ridge;
Mike Bourton; Randy Houston and
Gordy Bolstad.
The Gills were returning to McCall.
after a visit in Wenatchee, early on
August 12 when their compact car
crossed the center line and collided
head -on with a four -wheel drive
vehicle driven by Martin Cameron of
McCall. Cameron was also killed in
the accident.
'�-k P 5 G +" /alp VY S -- 71111)1-1--Y
Baby sever hurt
0 la I-Me A 0 IL
An infant was killed and 10
people were injured in a series of
highway and boating accidents
that marred Valley County's In-
dependence Day weekend.
Three- month -old Aaron
Michael Coe of Boise died last
'Wednesday of head injuries suf-
fered when he was run over by a
boat and trailer on a stretch of
Cascade Reservoir beach about a
mile south of Cascade City Park,
Lt. Donald Broughton of the
Valley County Sheriff's Depart-
ment said.
Apparently, the boy's parents,
Randy and Patty Coe, and the in-
fant's grandparents had towed
the boat and trailer down onto
the beach about noon to back it
into the water, Broughton said.
He said that while the women
went to a nearby restroom, Ran-
dy Coe placed his son in the
shade under the boat, while he
and the boy's grandfather,
Wayne Coe, discussed how to
back the rig into the water.
Broughton said that Wayne
Coe got into the pickup and
backed it up while Randy Coe
watched the truck's tires to see
how far they would sink into the
sand.
When the elder Coe pulled the
pickup ahead again, Aaron was
ui uvuutty iiueiiupe
run over by the wheels of the
trailer, Broughton said.
Ada County Chief Deputy
Coroner Lynn Bowerman said
Tuesday that he was told that
Randy and Wayne Coe had not
forgotten that Aaron was under
the trailer, but did not move him
because they had only intended to
move the trailer a "couple of
feet."
Bowerman's office gave the
time of Aaron Coe's death as
3:01 p.m. and listed the cause of
death as massive trauma to the
head.
Other mishaps last week in-
cluded:
• A one vehicle rollover on
Lakeshore Drive in Cascade sent
both the driver and a passenger to
Valley County Hospital for treat-
ment of minor injuries.
The driver, Darryl L. Gamel,
21, Boise, was charged with driv-
ing under the influence of
alcohol.
• A speedboat and sailboat col-
lided in Wagon Wheel Bay on
Payette Lake shortly before mid-
night on Thursday, the sheriff's
office reported.
Four people were taken to Mc-
Call Memorial Hospital with
minor injuries as a result, but all
were treated and released. The
operator of the sailboat, Douglas
F. Griffin of Boise, was cited for
failure to have adequate running
lights.
• A collision between a motor-
cycle and car shortly before mid-
night Thursday on Idaho 55 and
Heinrich Road sent the driver
and passenger of the motorcycle
to the McCall hospital.
The driver, DeWayne D.
Elsperman, 17, Boise, was
transferred to St. Alphonsus with
head injuries. After a short stay
in intensive care, he was released
on Sunday. His passenger was
treated and released in McCall.
Elsperman was cited for inat-
tentive driving.
• A 1919 Model T Roadster
rolled over on Warren Wagon
Road around 1:15 a.m. Friday.
A passenger was treated and
released at McCall Memorial and
the driver, Allan G. Getter, 26,
Boise, was kept overnight for
observation and released. No
citation was issued
• A head -on collision with a
parked car around 4:15 a.m. Fri-
day on Warren Wagon. Road
_r`111;1 1_5�17 Y - //P - 0 /aT 2 / f ;�!
Woman killed in U.S 95 wreck
An Emmett woman was killed
and a Moscow man was seriously
injured Thursday night when the
car in which they were occupants
crashed on U.S. 95 about 13
miles south of Riggins, according
to police.
Julie Shaw, 18, of Emmett,
was dead at the scene of the acci-
dent, according to an Idaho State
Police report.
The driver of the car, Marshall
Eng, 20, of Moscow, was listed in
stable condition on Tuesday at
St. Alphonsus Regional Medical
Center in Boise.
Two other occupants escaped
serious injury. Tim Blain, 20, of",
Moscow, received cuts and,:
bruises. Tim Bashau, 20, of„
Moscow, was admitted to McCall
Memorial Hospital with arm in= ;
juries. He was released on Satur -,,e
day, according to a hospital
spokesman.
The car was heading south
when it went off the side of the � `
highway and tumbled end over _
end several times, the state police
report said.
U.S. 95 wreck kills woman,
injures four others
By Tom Grote
The Star -News
A former McCall resident was
killed and four other people in-
jured Sunday in a three - vehicle
accident on U.S. 95 about 12
miles north of New Meadows, ac-
cording to Idaho State Police.
Dead at the scene of the acci-
dent was Lois Kay Rogers, 41, of
Bellevue, Idaho, who was a
passenger in the front seat of a
car that was heading south on the
highway. The car was struck
head -on by an empty cattle truck
heading north on U.S. 95, ISP
Cpl. M.R. Ruska said.
Ruska said the truck, driven by
Daniel A. Dorman, 40, of Moun-
tain Home, slid across the
highway, which was covered with
slick slush, and into the south-
bound lane on a curve about I
p.m. Sunday.
The accident occurred along
the Little Salmon River about a
mile north of the Smokey
Boulder Road turn -off from U.S.
95.
The truck was.,'treling an
estimated 35 miles per hour and
the car was traveling an estimated
30 mph when the collision occur-
red, Ruska said.
The truck and the car in which
Rogers was riding collided head -
on. The Rogers car was pushed
backward into a third car that
also was heading southbound on
the highway, he said.
Rogers, who was not ejected
from the car, died of neck in-
juries and massive head injuries,
Ruska said. A full obituary can
be found on Page A -3.
Ruska said Monday that no
citations had been issued, but
that an investigation was continu-
ing.
Driving the car in which
Rogers was riding was her son,
Daryl I.. Rogers, 17. He was
treated at McCall Memorial
Hospital in McCall and transfer-
red to St. Alphonsus Regional
Medical Center in Boise.
Daryl Rogers was listed in
satisfactory condition on Tues-
day and was expected to be
released today, a nursing super-
visor said.
Also injured was Scott A.
House, 16, of Hailey, who was
riding in the rear of the Rogers
car, and who was thrown from
the car during the accident,
Ruska said.
House was taken to Syringa
General Hospital in Grangevillc,
where he was admitted to the
hospital's intensive -care unit. By
Tuesday, he had been transferred
out of intensive -care and was
listed in stable and improved con-
dition, a nursing supervisor said.
A third passenger in the car,
Heather Ann Linhart, 18, Sun
.Valley, was injured and taken to
St. Joseph's Hospital in
Lewiston, where she was listed in
stable condition.
Daryl Rogers, House and
Linhart all were members of a
high school debating team and
were returning from a competi-
tion at the University of Idaho in'
Moscow when the accident occur-
red, Ruska said.
Dorman, the driver of the
truck, was held overnight at Syr -
inga General and released. The
driver of the third car, Teresa M.
Praest, 20, of Lewiston, was not
injured.
Ambulance crews from New
Meadows, Riggins and Lucile
assisted in treating and transport
ting the iniured. Ruska said.
Body of Cascade man found
The body of Cascade resident
Dan Montgomery was
recovered last Thursday from
the Payette River near
Horseshoe Bend.
An Idaho Department of Fish
and Game officer found the
body of Montgomery, 33, while
patrolling about two miles
north of Horseshoe Bend, Boise
County Coroner Devota Tib-
bets said.
Montgomery had been miss-
ing since the morning of May
14, when the pick -up lie was
driving to work plunged off the
Garden Valley Road and into
the South Fork of the Payette
near Banks.
It took sheriff's deputies and
a wrecker crew working with a
crane two days to retrieve
Montgomery's truck from the
swift current.
During the first day's efforts,
it was thought that Mon-
tgomery's body could be seen
inside the cab, but the vehicle
broke loose and drifted further
downstream. When the pickup
was finally pulled out, there was
no body inside.
Montgomery's body drifted
about 15 miles downstream
from the site of the accident and
into the main Payette River dur-
ing the 23 days that he was miss-
ing.
9J'8'- IV e w 5 A p k i/ 161 1 q8b
PAGE B-- 5 - -THE STAR - NEWS -- WEDNESDAY, APRIL 16, 1986
Crunch!
No one was injured last Wednesday evening
when this logging truck, driven by Gary L.
Ward of Garden Valley, collided with the
Union Pacific Railroad engine in Cascade.
Cascade Police Chief Al Records said Ward
was eastbound with the unloaded truck on
East Cascade Street. The train, piloted by
Dennis G. Washburn of Caldwell, was travel-
ing north. The train consisted of only two
engines and a caboose at the time of the acci-
dent. A line of freight cars parked along a
parallel track prevented Ward from seeing the
oncoming train until he was on the tracks,
Records said. The chief said that Ward at-
tempted to back his truck off the tracks. "If
he'd have been able to back up another foot,
he would have made it," Records said.
Damage to the Peterbilt tractor, owned by
Jensen Trucking of Eagle, was estimated at
$1,750. The Union Pacific train engine was
not damaged.
Donnelly man dies in wreck
A Donnelly man was killed last
week when the pickup he was
driving ran off a road near White
Bird.
The wreckage of the car driven
by Richard E. Campbell, 32, of
Donnelly, was seen by a passing
motorist about 11 a.m. Thurs-
day. The wreck was off a dirt
road one -half mile from Banner
Ridge Road about six miles east
of U.S. 95, an Idaho County
Sheriff's Department report said.
A deputy sheriff responded to
the call and found the pickup 300
yards down a hillside from the
road. Campbell's body was
found halfway down the slope,
the report said.
Campbell apparently was
ejected from the truck as it rolled
down the hill, and he appeared to
have been killed instantly, a
sheriffs office spokesman said.
Campbell was working as a
sawyer for Robinson Logging
Co. of Riggins on a timber sale at
the time of the accident.
The report said he had made a
telephone call from White Bird
about 11 p.m. Wednesday, which
likely put the time of the accident
as soon after that.
The report said that the acci-
dent probably happened due to
Campbell driving too fast for the
road conditions at the time.
Funeral services will be held at
1 p.m. today at Heikkila Funeral
Chapel in McCall. It
Spill trailer
leaves McCall
More than se ven weeks after a
semi -truck dumped hundreds of
gallons of fungicide into the Little
Salmon River, the trailer that car-
ried the poison was moved from
McCall Tuesday afternoon.
The trailer, battered and split
open from the Dec. 19 wreck, was
not a health hazard, according to
McCall officials. But those offi-
cials were frustrated in attempts to
have the wreckage removed and
have incurred the wrath of the
Payette Lakes Water and Sewer
District.
The trailer was collapsed by city
crews operating heavy equipment,
and the rig was last seen being
towed on its wheels toward Boise
about 5 p.m. Tuesday, city admin-
istrator Bud Schmidt said.
The trailer was carrying a load of
fungicide when it careened off U.S.
95 north of New Meadows and
plunged into the Little Salmon
River.
An estimated 500 to 800 gallons
of the materials spilled from con-
tainers and went into the river,
killing fish for several miles
downstream.
U.S. 95 was closed for a day,
the driver of the truck was cited in
the accident and state officials have
vowed to seek repayment from the
truck's owners for the damage in
the river caused by the spill.
The problems for the city of
McCall began when the trailer was
plucked from the Little Salmon and
towed by Acheson Motors to the
wrecker's yard along Idaho 55 in
McCall.
Almost immediately, residents
of homes near the Acheson yard
called city officials expressing
:strong objections, calling the trailer
,a health hazard.
McCall Fire Chief Dale Points
said he would not have allowed the
truck to enter the city if it had not
been made safe. The trailer had been
emptied of the remaining fungicide,
with only some reddish - purple
stains visible from a dye used on
the chemical.
"Millions of gallons of river
water had washed over it," Points
said. "There was not enough mate-
rial spilled in the trailer to be toxic
to anyone."
However, as a precaution, the
city used its emergency police
powers to take control of the
trailer, which was then moved to a
fenced yard at the sewage treatment
plant off Boydstun Street on the
southwest edge of town.
Schmidt said he immediately
began efforts to have the truck re-
moved, but was called by Idaho.
State Police investigators on Dec.
22 and told to hold the trailer for
examination by the state.
The ISP released the trailer back
to the city after its investigation a
week later, just before the New
Year's Day. Schmidt said he spent
the next several days on the tele-
phone tracking down the owner of
the trailer, the owner's insurance
company, the company's adjuster,
and arranging for a towing com-
pany to dispose of the rig.
Then, City Attorney Robert
Remaklus was asked to intervene,
and several more telephone calls
produced a promise to have the
trailer moved by Jan. 18.
That deadline was missed, but a
wrecking crew from Boise came to
McCall last week to tow away the
trailer. However, the crew discov-
ered the trailer was too badly dam-
aged to be hauled safely, and went
away empty - handed.
Finally, on Tuesday, a tow truck
managed to pick up the trailer after
it was collapsed on its chassis and
hauled it away.
Adding to the problem was a
letter sent on Jan. 13 to the city
from the sewer district expressing
concern about storing the truck at
the sewer plant, where district em-
ployees make regular visits.
The district had told its employ-
ees to stay out of the area until the
truck was removed, the letter from
district board chairman Barbara
Knipe said. "The city's conduct in
unilaterally exposing sewer district
employees to a potential health
hazard is unwarranted," Knipe
wrote.
Schmidt called the letter
"overstated," but Ted Whiteman,
coordinator for the district, said that
the letter accurately expressed the
concerns of his board of directors.
,A4 /Z ws Jl,) iV b ,4 « p p -5-1 ll z�Yl
McCall store damaged
by car str ck qyJruck
A truck and tr�i�r
letslammed
into a car and knocked it into a
McCall mall store at noon Satur-
day, causing about $8,000 in dam-
age; no one was injured, McCall
police said.
The truck, driven by Eldon
Davis, 74, Fruitland, was north-
bound on Idaho 55 and was at-
tempting to turn west onto East
Lake Street when it slid into a
parked car, pushing the car 65
feet into the corner store of The
Lake Street Mall, Officer Dave
Denbleyker said.
Denbleyker said that "miracu-
lously," neither pedestrians nor
the 25 horses riding in the trailer
were injured. He attributed the
slide -off to icy roads.
He said the collision wrecked
the car and shifted the Shirt and
Soundworks store from its con-
crete foundation.
According to the store's con-
tractor, damage to the Shirt and
c ^•• ^�•• ^�U ,the corner building
11, was estimated at
100, Denbleyker said.
an investigation was
Youths injured
in auto wreck
Three Valley County residents
were injured Friday night when the
car in which they were riding lost
control and crashed along Lick
Creek Road, the Valley County Sh-
eriff's Office said.
Kristina Varner, 16, of Donnelly,
was the most seriously injured in
the accident, which happened about
10 p.m. Friday on Lick Creek Road
just past its intersection with East -
side Road on the east side of Payette
Lake, Sheriff Lewis Pratt said.
Varner was taken by ambulance
to McCall Memorial Hospital and
taken by Life Flight helicopter to
St. Alphonsus Regional Medical
Center in Boise. Varner was listed
in good condition on Tuesday at St.
Al's, a hospital spokesman said.
The driver of the car, Mark Lari-
more, 20, of Donnelly, was admit-
ted overnight at McCall Memorial
Hospital and was released on Satur-
day, Pratt said. A third occupant,
Patrick Futter, 26, of Lake Fork,
was treated at the hospital and re-
leased.
Larimore told police that he lost
control of the car on a curve. The
car left the roadway and rolled a
short distance down an embank-
ment. All three occupants were not
wearing seat belts and were ejected,
Pratt said. The accident was still un-
der investigation, he said.
J111J,e /�� cis 6 F `l q o
-"
Testimony says
drinking led to
Pyle accident
BY JAMES L. KINCAID
The Star -News
A four- wheeling lark based on al-
cohol led to the death of Daniel
"Dino" Pyle last Halloween night,
according to testimony given in a
court hearing last Thursday.
The testimony was given during
a hearing for Darren S. Coats, 20,
of McCall, who was driving the
pickup at the time of the accident
which killed Pyle, 17, of McCall.
Witnesses for the prosecution
appearing in Valley County Magis-
trate's Court in Cascade uniformly
confirmed the use of alcohol during
the late -night drive on Bear Basin
Road west of McCall.
Defense attorney Thomas Mc-
Cabe questioned claims about Coats'
blood- alcohol content and the speed
"We were four -
wheeling. It was an
accident.
It happens."
— Jeffrey Bateman
of the pickup at the time of the ac-
cident. However, Magistrate Darla
Williamson bound Coats over to
Fourth District Court to face felony
charges of involuntary manslaughter
and felony driving without privi-
leges.
Coats is scheduled to appear for
arraignment in Fourth District
Court on Jan. 28.
Valley County Prosecuting At-
torney Clayton Andersen told
Williamson that the manslaughter
charge was applicable to Coats for,
among other reasons, indications of
driving under the influence of alco-
hol and reckless driving.
A test given to Coats several
hours after the accident showed a
blood - alcohol content, which ex-
ceeds the legal limit percent, Ander-
sen said.
Tests conducted by Idaho State
Police Cpl. Robert Clements, an
accident reconstruction investigator,
showed that Coats' truck was travel-
ing at least 32 miles per hour when
the driver lost control. About 75
feet of skid marks were left on the
snow - covered road before the truck
hit a stump and tipped on its side,
Clements said.
Witness Jeffrey T. Bateman, 18,
of McCall, said he, Pyle, Shawn
Storck and Coats met earlier Hal-
loween eve and decided to "go four -
wheeling." While drinking Yukon
Jack and Canadian Mist, they drove
up Bear Basin road, Bateman said.
Coming down the mountain
about 9:15 p.m., the truck slid
sideways, hit a stump and turned
over on its side, pinning Pyle un-
demeath, Bateman said.
"I could tell by the way he
(Coats) was driving he was kind of
drunk," Bateman said. "Right be-
fore the corner we lost control and
Dino told Darren to slow down.
None of us were upset with the driv-
ing coming down. We were four -
wheeling. It was an accident. It
happens."
After the group jacked up Coats'
truck to free Pyle, Bateman said he
ran to Pyle's truck where the group
had left it earlier, drove into town
and reported the accident.
Storck, 19, of Donnelly, said he
felt Coats was in control of the
truck.
"We weren't that drunk at the
time of the accident, just feeling
good," Storck said. "We started slid-
ing sideways, like in slow motion.
The rig tipped over really slow and
Dino had his head out the window."
Valley County Sheriffs Officer
J.R. Gray said he responded to the
accident about 1 a.m. He placed
Coats under arrest for driving with-
out privileges and escorted him to a
patrol car.
"I noticed the odor of alcohol on
Darren Coats and he had a great deal
of difficulty maintaining his bal-
ance," Gray said. "At one time,
Coats appeared to be falling forward
and I reached out and helped him
remain standing. Coats refused
blood and alcohol tests."
After obtaining a search warrant
about 2 a.m. that morning, Coats
was tested at Valley County District
Hospital in Cascade, Gray said.
r / Q
Truck overturns
in S.F. of Salmon
A 35 -ton dump truck flipped into
the South Fork of the Salmon River
Monday morning, spilling a small
amount of fuel and other fluids.
However, officials believe they cap-
tured most of the fluids before they
flowed downstream.
The accident occurred on the
South Fork Road 16 -1/2 miles
north of its junction with Warm
Lake Road and downstream from
Poverty Flat, a spawning area for
salmon and steelhead.
The truck belongs to the Argee
Construction Co., which hauls ore
for Hecla Mining Co. of Coeur d'
Alene from the Hecla's gold mine at
Stibnite. The empty truck was be-
ing moved from the mine and out of
the area for the winter, Payette Na-
tional Forest spokesman Dave Ol-
son said.
The accident occurred about 4
a.m. Monday on a straight, narrow
stretch of the South Fork Road.
Somehow, the truck ran off th;, road
and overturned into the river. The
driver escaped serious injuries, ac-
cording to reports.
The capsized truck spilled 20 gal-
lons of diesel, 12 gallons of hy-
draulic fluid and four gallons of mo-
tor oil, Olson said.
However, an estimated 95 percent
of the spilled fluids was contained
by booms and other absorbant mate-
rials placed in the river downstream
from the accident site, Olson said.
Those absorbant materials are
stockpiled at Warm Lake and at
Stibnite just for such incidents, Ol-
son said.
Olson also credited Valley
County Sheriffs Deputy Dave Mc-
Clintock with limiting the spill.
McClintock, one of the first persons
on the scene, used plastic bags to
cover the truck's fuel tank until
more help could arrive, Olson said.
There was no report of filsh kills
or other damage as a result of the
accident, Olson said.
A bulldozer was needed to right
the truck about 4 a.m. Tuesday and
pull it to a place where it could get
back onto the road and resume its
journey. Workers then placed rock
"rip -rap" along the bank and planted
grass where the truck had passed.
The dump truck was one of a
dozen ore - hauling trucks operated by
Hecla and Argee that were permitted
to use the South Fork Road under a
special permit issued by the Payette
forest, Olson said.
The South Fork Road was used
rather than the Johnson Creek Road
because of slippery conditions on a
steep section of the Johnson Creek
Road between Landmark and Warm
Lake, he said.
The incident was still under in-
vestigation, and it was unknown
whether more trucks will be allowed
to use the road, Olson said.
Monday's incident was the second
in a week at the same location, Ol-
son said. Another 35 -ton truck fell
off the road last Thursday, but a tree
kept the truck from going into the
river.
Charges filed
in death of
MmD student
BY TOM GROTE
The Star -News
A McCall man has been charged
with vehicular manslaughter and
four other charges following an ac-
cident last week that killed a Mc-
Call- Donnelly High School student.
Darren S. Coats, 20, of McCall,
remained in Valley County Jail this
week on $50,000 bond pending, an-
other_court h ha+dek.':: .
Coats has been charged in the
death of Daniel K. "Dino " Pyle, 17,
of McCall. Pyle was a passenger in
a pickup driven by Coats that slid
off a snowy stretch of Bear Basin
Road, struck a stump and overturned
on the night of Oct. 31.
Pyle died within minutes after
the pickup rolled onto the upper part
of his body, Valley County Coroner
Mary Heikkila said. Pyle was the
son of John and Barbara Pyle of
McCall.
In addition to the manslaughter
charge, a felony, Coats also was
charged with another felony for driv-
ing without privileges due to the
fact that he has been charged twice
before with that offense, Valley
County Prosecuting Attorney Clay-
ton Andersen said.
He also was charged with failure
to provide proof of vehicle insur-
ance, failure to use a safety belt and
obstructing or resisting an officer.
The obstructing charge relates to
Coats' resistance to submit to hav-
ing blood drawn for a blood - alcohol
test, even though a search warrant
had been obtained to compel the
test, Andersen said. Results of the
test were not available on Tuesday.
The incident occurred about 9:30
p.m. on Oct. 31 when Pyle, Coats
and two other area residents decided
to take a drive up Bear Basin Road
west of McCall, Idaho State Police
Cpl. Mitch Ruska said.
The others who came along were
Shawn J. Storck, 19, of Donnelly,
and Jeffrey T. Bateman, 18, of Mc-
Call.
Pyle had driven his car about
three miles up Bear Basin Road, but
decided to leave it when the caravan
encountered snow, Ruska said. The
four youths then decided to proceed
in Coats' pickup on a trip to
Brundage Mountain Lookout and
Daniel 'Dino' Pyle
surrounding roads.
It was on the way down that the
accident happened, Ruska said.
Coats rounded a curve in the road
too fast for the road's grade. He lost
control and slid sideways down the
snow - covered road about six miles
from its junction with Idaho 55.
The pickup hit a stump on the
side of the roadway and rolled onto
its right side. Pyle had been hanging
outside the pickup window and was
pinned when the pickup rolled,
Ruska said. The others used the
pickup's jack ,to raise the cab and
free Pyle, and Bateman ran down to
Pyle's car to drive into McCall and
seek help.
McCall Ambulance Service am-
bulances responded, as did officers
from the McCall Police Depart-
ment, the Valley County Sheriffs
Office and the Adams County Sher-
iffs Office.
Pyle's death sent a wave of shock
through McCall - Donnelly High
School, where he was a well -liked
student, Principal Doug Flaming
said. Pyle was a member of the
school wrestling team and was a
candidate for the student body
president.
"He was the kind of kid that was
accepted by everyone," Flaming
said. "He was a good student and not
a discipline problem. You wouldn't
mind having him as your own son."
St -' P- /\/P- W--5
A/a V 5,J f y�
Pyle's death set into motion the
first use of the school district's Cri-
sis Management Plan, which was
adopted only last spring to deal with
sudden deaths or emergencies in the
school, Flaming said.
Teachers were notified of the
death early Thursday morning and
were called into a meeting to be
briefed on the facts of the incident.
"We gave them a statement of facts
for discussion in each class and told
them to go ahead and let the kids
talk about death and dealing with
loss," he said.
Next, a "grieving room" was set
up in the high school counseling
center to allow students to leave
their classrooms and gather to fur-
ther discuss the death, if they
wished. Professional counselors
from McCall were called in to aid
M -D's staff counselors, as were
counselors from the Meadows Val-
ley School District.
Nearly half of the student body,
or about 80 students, visited the
room during the morning, some
coming back more than once, Flam-
ing said.
A student body assembly was
held at mid - morning, where addi-
tional facts of the incident were read
and students were encouraged to ex-
press their feelings.
"By about 10 a.m. or 10:30, you
could see that something was pass-
ing," Flaming said. "They were not
sobbing uncontrollably, and some
had smiles on their faces again."
School was already scheduled to
be dismissed Thursday afternoon and
Friday for parent- teacher confer-
ences, which provided a welcomed
break. A gathering held Thursday
night at a student's home and Pyle's
funeral on Saturday also provided
needed releases for grief, Flaming
said.
When classes resumed on Mon-
day, a sense of normalcy had re-
turned, although the grieving room
will be left open through next week,
he said.
Flaming said he was pleased with
the way the crisis plan worked,
although he wished the district did
not have to use it so quickly.
The last time an M -D student
was killed was when 17- year -old Ja-
son Place of McCall was killed in a
boating accident on Payette Lake in
July 1988.
A memorial scholarship fund for
Pyle has been set up at West One
Bank in McCall, and all donations
should be sent there, Flaming said.
Guidelines on how the fund will be
distributed will be determined later.
, l,Y' /l (9 Y,/5
4 /�i�;'
Coats
given
prison
A McCall man was sentenced to
prison Friday on charges of vehicu-
lar manslaughter and driving with-
out privileges in the death last Hal-
loween night of a McCall youth.
Darren S. Coats, 20, of McCall
was sentenced to seven years in
prison with two years fixed on the
manslaughter charge for the death of
Daniel "Dino" Pyle, 17. He also
received 20 days in jail, a $500 fine
and suspended driving privileges for
his second charge of driving without
privileges.
"I'm sorry for what happened and
for my actions that led to the acci-
dent," Coats told Fourth District
Court Judge George Carey. "Not a
day goes by that I don't think about
Dino Pyle. I am ready to accept re-
sponsibility for his death."
Carey, who handed down the sen-
tence at the Valley County Court-
house in Cascade, said he felt the
sentence recommended by Valley
County Prosecuting Attorney Clay-
ton Andersen was fair.
"Coats had a prior charge (of
driving while suspended) and drove
his vehicle openly in McCall," An-
dersen said. "He obtained alcohol,
joined his friends and went four -
wheeling to try out his new tires."
Andersen said Coats and his three
passengers were heavily intoxicated
at the time of the accident, which
took place on Bear Basin Road west
of McCall.
The accident occurred on the
night of Oct. 31, 1990, as Coats,
Pyle and two other men were four -
wheeling, according to police re-
ports. The accident occurred about
9:30 p.m. that evening when Coats
lost control of the truck, and it slid
and hit a stump.
Pyle, sitting near the passenger
door, was hanging out the window
and was killed as the truck rolled
onto him. Coats' blood - alcohol
content was tested and found to be
higher than the lega limit lice
reports said. ���� Coats is in jail ni
space in the state penitentiary. He
will first spend time at the North
Idaho Correctional Institution in
Cottonwood, according to Thomas
J. McCabe of Boise, Coats.' defense
attorney. WD
"Darren Coats is accepts g is
punishment and this is a way to get
right with society," McCabe said.
"Getting right with himself will
probably take a lifetime. It is unfor-
tunate that the Coats and Pyle fami-
lies have been unable to heal this
wound."
There is no appeal planned, Mc-
Cabe said.
J_e, _ W_� i 0- 3j_ 1 9 T 1
THE STAR NEWS - THURSDAY, OCTOBER 31, 1991
Coats released
on probation
after jail term
A former McCall resident was
placed on probation last week after
serving 180 days of a seven -year
sentence for vehicular manslaughter.
Darren S. Coats, 20, was sen-
tenced last May for the death of
Daniel "Dino" Pyle, 17, who was
killed in a four - wheeling accident on
Halloween night of 1990.
Coats served his time in the Val-
ley County Jail and at the North
Idaho Correctional Institution in
Cottonwood. Fourth District Court
Judge George Carey on Friday eval-
uated a review of Coats' behavior
during the 180 -day period and
granted probation for the remainder
of the sentence.
Carey also ordered Coats to pay
about $3,000 restitution to the vic-
tim's estate and suspended Coats'
driving privileges for three years.
"I would like to thank the court
for this second chance, and I intend
to carry out my probation success-
fully," Coats told Carey.
Coats will live with his parents
in Clarkston, Wash., and attend the
spring semester at Lewis -Clark
State College in Lewiston, said
Thomas J. McCabe of Boise, Coats'
defense attorney.
The accident occurred on the
night of Oct. 31, 1990, as Coats,
Pyle and two other men were driv-
ing for fun on snow -slick Bear
Basin Road west of McCall, accord-
ing to police reports.
The accident occurred about 9:30
p.m. that evening when Coats lost
control of his pickup and it slid and
hit a stump. Pyle, sitting near the
passenger door, was hanging out the
A Valley County Sheriffs Office
patrol car was destroyed and a Cas-
cade Police Department police car
was damaged when they were
rammed at a roadblock on Idaho 55
just north of Cascade.
The patrol cars were rammed by a
flatbed car carrier stolen earlier that
evening from McCall Tire and Auto
Repair in McCall. Prior to the col-
lision at the roadblock, police had
chased the carrier 25 miles from
McCall down the highway.
window and was killed as the truck
rolled onto him.
Other actions at the Fourth Dis-
trict Court in Cascade on Friday in-
cluded
• Christobal Apodaca pled guilty
to two counts of aggravated assault
and one count of aggravated battery
in connection with the July 2 shoot-
ing of a woman during a camping
trip near Horsethief Reservoir.
The guilty plea, if accepted at a
Nov. 29 sentencing hearing, is
based on a plea bargain, according to
Larry Schoenhut, defense attorney
for Apodaca. Valley County Prose-
cuting Attorney Jamie Shropshire
has agreed she will not ask for more
than a 10 -year prison sentence with
five years fixed. The judge does not
have to accept the plea bargain and
the defense can ask for a reduced sen-
tence, Schoenhut said.
"Mr. Apodaca has no recollection
of the incident," Schoenhut said.
"In his heart, he does not believe he
did these things."
Denise Branson, 28, was shot
with a .45 caliber automatic pistol
while sitting in her car at the camp-
site, according to Valley County
Sheriffs reports. Branson was
found by children and neighboring
campers, who wrestled the gun away
from Apodaca and held him.
The campers then drove to a
home on Warm Lake Road and re-
ported the incident to authorities.
Branson was hospitalized and subse-
quently recovered from the shooting.
Apodaca, whose age was listed as
over 50, remains in custody in the
Valley County Jail in Cascade.
• Joseph K. Tucker, 23, pleaded
not guilty to charges stemming
from an Oct. 7 incident which ended
when a stolen car carrier rammed a
police roadblock near Cascade.
A trial is set for Dec. 4 for
Tucker, who is charged with second -
degree burglary, grand theft, petty
theft, obstructing an officer, mali-
cious injury to property, felony ma-
licious injury to property and aggra-
vated assault.
Donnelly mayor dies
from accident
Donnelly Mayor Don Coski died
in a Spokane, Wash., hospital on
Monday night from injuries he suf-
fered in an automobile accident on
March 21 near Spokane.
Coski, 71, had been in critical
condition in the intensive care unit
at Holy Family Hospital in
Spokane since the accident. He died
with members of his family at his
bedside, said Ken Roberts of
Donnelly, Coski's son -in -law.
Funeral services will be held at 1
p.m. Friday at the Donnelly Bible
Church in Donnelly, with members
of Coski's family conducting the
services. Graveside services will fol-
low at Alpha Cemetery south of
Cascade.
A pot luck dinner will be held at
the Donnelly Bible Church follow-
ing the burial. Those attending
should call Tom or Cathy Penry at
325 -8733 for information on bring-
ing food.
Donnelly City Council President
injuries
Tom Penry will assume Coski's du-
ties until a permanent replacement
can be named, Donnelly City Clerk
Louise Roberts said Tuesday.
Coski was injured about 10 a.m.
on March 21 on Washington State
Highway 2 about two miles north
of Spokane, according to
Washington State Patrol officials.
Coski's car was northbound on
the highway when he tried to make
a U -turn, according to officials. His
1989 Subaru station wagon was hit
broadside on the driver's side by a
Chevrolet Blazer, also northbound,
driven by Richard Myers, 40, of
Colbert, Wash. Myers was not in-
jured.
Coski's wife, Frances, suffered a
broken collar bone in the accident,
but did not require an extensive stay
in the hospital. A second passenger
in Coski's car, Aaron Coski, 13, a
nephew from Spokane, escaped seri-
ous injury.
bhp v
Photo by Tom Grote
19urned hulk is all that remains of roadster that crashed early Friday.
Two die in car crash
Two men were killed early Friday
when the car in which they were rid-
ing missed a curve on Warren
Wagon Road north of McCall and
crashed, Idaho State Police said.
Michael F. Heyrend, 45, of
Boise, and Steven J. Rudy, 42, of
Sandy, Utah, were pronounced dead
at the scene of the accident, which
happened about 3.5 miles north of
Idaho 55 near the J.R. Simplot es-
tate.
The two were occupants of a
1989 model specialty kit car that
Heyrend that purchased on Thursday,
ISP Cpl. Mitch Ruska said.
The car was heading north about
2 a.m. Friday when it approached
the curve at the "Simplot estate at
between 50 and 60 miles per hour,
Ruska said. The car flew off the road
and rolled end - over -end, breaking off
several small trees.
Heyrend and Rudy, who were
brothers -in -law, were thrown from
the car, which burst into flames as
it came to rest off the roadway.
There were no skid marks on the
road, Ruska said.
It was unknown which one of the
victims was driving the car. A care -
taker at the Simplot estate saw the
fire and reported it to police, Ruska
said.
Members of the Valley County
Sheriff's Office, the McCall Police
Department and the McCall
Volunteer Fire Department re-
sponded to the scene. The fire did
not spread beyond the car.
Rollover kills two
Riggins youths
BY TOM GROTE
The Stu -News
Two Riggins youths were killed
Saturday and six other youths were
injured when the car in which they
were riding ran off U.S. 95 and rolled
down an embankment about 17 miles
north of New Meadows, Idaho State
Police said.
The deaths of Lacey Hancock, 8,
and Linda Dealy, 10, stunned the stu-
dents and staff at Riggins Elementary
School who invoked the school's cri-
sis management plan.
The 1973 Jeep Wagoneer was
driven by Amber Travis, 16, of
Riggins, ISP Cpl. John Burke said.
The car was heading south on U.S. 95
about 6:25 p.m. Saturday when it ran
off the shoulder while rounding a
curve.
Travis apparently overcorrected
the steering, slid across the highway
and rolled 20 feet down an embank-
ment toward the Little Salmon River.
The car did not go into the river,
Burke said.
Hancock and Dealy were ejected
from the car during the accident and
were pronounced dead at the scene.
There is no guard rail where the car
went off the highway, he said.
Travis and five other youths in the
car were taken to McCall Memorial
Hospital by ambulances from Riggins,
New Meadows and McCall.
Transported were Melissa Dealy,
10, Riggins; Rick Herman, 17, Pol-
lock; Angela Herman, 14, Pollock;
Bill Arnold, 13, New Meadows; and
Jamie Grant, 16, New Meadows.
Melissa Dealy, Angela Herman and
Arnold were treated at the hospital
and released. Travis, Rick Herman
and Grant were held overnight at the
hospital and released on Sunday, a
hospital spokesman said.
The car apparently was traveling
within the speed limit at the time of
the accident, Burke said. None of the
occupants were wearing seat belts.
An investigation is continuing this
week.
On Sunday, Salmon River High
School Principal Joe Anderson called
a meeting of school staff members to
invoke the school's crisis manage -
mentplan. Hancockwas athird- grader
and Dealy was a fourth - grader.
Counselors, ministers and other
volunteers were called in Monday
morning to talk to the students about
the accident, Anderson said Tuesday.
"We briefly stated the facts and let
the kids talk or express their feelings
by way of drawing pictures or writing
a letter to the parents (of the vic-
tims)," Anderson said.
Those students who needed indi-
vidual counseling were given time to
do so, but Anderson said he stressed
returning to a normal routine as soon
as possible. "We wanted to try to get
right back on task," he said.
The plan worked well, he said.
About 140 students are enrolled in the
elementary school and 140 are en-
rolled in Salmon River High School.
Funerals for the two youths killed
in the accident were held Wednesday
at the school. Scheduled school holi-
days today and Friday also will help
students recover from the shock,
Anderson said.
McCall Memorial Hospital in-
voked its own disaster plan when faced
with six accident victims coming to
the hospital at one time, director of
nursing Lori Wilkes said.
An extra doctor, three extra nurses,
and laboratory and therapy special-
ists were called in. Also, volunteers
from the McCall Memorial Hospital
Auxiliary were called to deal with
family members of the victims and to
control visitor traffic, Wilkes said.
3131_1
Van, bus crash hurts 3
A collision between a 1985 Ford
van and a school bus headed to
Brundage Mountain Ski Area to
pick up high school students last
week injured three people and re-
sulted in extensive damage to both
vehicles. The incident occurred
about 4 p.m. on Feb 23 on Brund-
age Mountain Road as the Ford
van driven by James S. Hennigan,
37, of Louisiana, was unable to ne-
gotiate a curve in the roadway. The
van slammed into the oncoming
bus driven by Mary Beth Farrer,
36, of McCall. Hennigan and two of
Photo by Shari Hambleton
the five other passengers in the van
were injured in the accident.
Hennigan, his mother -in -law, Betty
Coarmouche, 51, and father -in -law
Donald Coarmouche, 57, also of
Louisiana, were treated at the scene
by McCall Ambulance Service
EMTs and transported to McCall
Memorial Hospital where they were
treated and released, police reports
said. None ofthe injured were wear-
ing seat belts. Farrer and her two
children were not injured in the
incident. Hennigan was cited for
driving too fast for conditions.
Woman dies
while driving
A McCall woman died last
Thursday when she apparently
was stricken with a heart attack
while driving her car near the
McCall Golf Course, the McCall
Police Department said.
The auto driven by Barbara J.
Rosenau, 65, of McCall, crashed
and rolled onto its top about 8:15
p.m. last Thursday on Reedy Lane
near where the street bends into
Fairway Drive, a police report
said.
Witnesses said they saw
Rosenau's car heading east on
Reedy Lane moving about 20
miles per hour when the carfailed
to make the turn to the north.
The car ran off the street, hit a
boulder and overturned. There
were no sign of braking or skid
marks, the report said.
Rosenau was unconscious
when rescuers found her, and she
had to be extricated from her car
by volunteers from the McCall
Fire Department.
She was treated for cardiac
arrest and declared dead at McCall
Memorial Hospital, the report
said.
Doctors at the hospital said
Rosenau had been previously
under care for heart problems.
Car wreck kills Boise man;
McCall man dies after mishap
A Boise man was killed early Sat-
urday in a one -car accident on West
Mountain Road five miles south of
Donnelly, the Valley County Sheriff's
Office reported.
Also, a McCall man struck by a
bicycle during the Independence Day
weekend died from his injuries last
week.
In the West Mountain Road acci-
dent, Steve A. Thompson, 46, died
from injuries he suffered when the
1989 Chevrolet pickup he was driv-
ing went off the road and crashed near
Black Bear Drive about 2:30 a.m., a
sheriff s report said.
Two other passengers in the ve-
hicle, Patrick F. McFarland, 40, and
Mark L. Brough, 38, both of Boise,
were taken by Donnelly Volunteer
Fire Department ambulance to Val-
ley County Hospital in Cascade.
McFarland suffered extensive cuts
and bruises to his head, neck and
shoulders. He was held overnight for
observations and released on Sunday
in satisfactory condition. Brough was
treated for cuts and bruises and re-
leased on Saturday.
The sheriff's department was inves-
tigating the accident this week.
In the McCall incident, John W.
Lord, 57, died last Thursday morning at
St. Alphonsus Regional Medical Cen-
ter in Boise from head injuries, an Ada
County Coroner's report said.
Lord was walking westbound on
West Lake Street at about 12:45 a.m.
July 2 when he was struck by a bicycle
traveling eastbound. Lord struck his
head on the pavement during the inci-
dent, according to a McCall Police
Department report.
Lord had been drinking alcohol
shortly before the accident and had a
blood - alcohol level 2 -1/2 times the le-
gal limit, Lt. Carla Donica said.
The bicyclist, JoshuaJ. Cochran, 19,
of McCall, was thrown from his bicycle
from the impact. Cochran was treated at
McCall Memorial Hospital andreleased.
Cochran told police he was tempo-
rarily blinded by the headlights of an
oncoming vehicle when his bicycle col-
lided with Lord.No charges will be filed
against Cochran, McCall City Attorney
Ted Burton said. "It was just an acci-
dent," Burton said.
Lah Vdfle� AdvoCate Al ro199�I
Valley County accident rates are
high amongst state's larger counties
BOISE — Valley County had the third highest rate of fatality and
injury accidents in the state in 1994 among the 34 counties in the state
with populations of 5,000 or more.
Valley County had a rate of 12.1 fatality and injury accidents per
1,000 residents during the year, according to Idaho Transportation
Department figures released last week.
That placed the county third behind Benewah County, which had
a rating of 13.4, and Jerome County, which had a rate of 13.2.
Adams County, which is in the smallest category of counties, under
5,000, of which there are 10 counties, had a rating of 12.4. Other coun-
ties under 5,000 had rates as high as 27.5, but one serious accident
could swing those numbers dramatically.
iThe statistics released also include the the number of alcohol- relat-
cidents per 1,000 population. Valley County's rating in that area
?.8, second highest among the 34 larger counties.
-newah County again led that statistic with a rating of 3.4 acci-
Adams County's rating in that statistic was 2.6 alchol- related
lents per 1,000 population.
n the plus side, compliance with the state's new seatbelt law has
oved by 17.8 percent from 1993 to 1994 for Valley County.
pliance in 1994 was 77.4 percent.
Jams County's compliance improved even more, by 38.3 percent
1993. Compliance in 1994 was 73.6 percent.
7 (/T4r - New'
sl
s Y OG PHILLIPS
The Star-News
A car driven by a Cottonwood
man slammed into the Anderson Oil
gas station in New Meadows Mon-
day, sending the driver and three men
in the store to the hospital.
Joseph Arnzen, 63, was driving a
1996 Chrysler south on U.S. 95 at an
estimated 50 miles per hour when he
missed the corner turning toward
McCall on Idaho 55, according to
Cpl. Jim Eavenson of the Idaho State
Patrol.
Arnzen's car struck the northwest
corner of the building about 12:25
p.m., crashing through it, and hitting
store manager Tim Fausett, then
breaking through a cinder block wall
at the rear of the store. The car de-
stroyed the store's interior and injured
three New Meadows men who were
inside.
All four men were taken to McCall
Memorial Hospital. Arnzen was
treated and released on Monday with
minor injuries.
Fausett suffered a broken leg, an
iajured,ankle, and a fractured toe.
Jim Yoakum received two fractured
ribs, a fractured toe, and various cuts
and scrapes. They were listed in stable
condition Tuesday night, and were
expected to be released soon, accord-
ing to a hospital spokesman.
Monte Matthews was treated for a
minor eye injury and released on
Monday.
Matthews said he and Yoakum
had stopped by the store to pick up
auto parts, and were talking to Fausett
just prior to the accident. Fausett saw
the car coming, and warned the oth-
ers.
"I saw him coming and said,
`We've got to get out of here, he isn't
going to make the corner,' " Fausett
The three men rushed toward the
.ck door with Matthews in the lead,
tiled by Yoakum and Fausett. As
atthews opened the door, the car
me through the building.
"It just blew us out the door,"
atthews said of he and Yoakum.
Fausett was thrown on top of the
r, carried through the store, then
lned by his leg between the car's
mper and the back wall, Fausett
"It happened so fast; he picked me
t and I rode on the hood of the car to
it of the back of the building,"
iusett said.
Despite his injuries, Fausett is con -
lent he will recover from the
cident. "I'm going to make it," he
id. "I feel pretty terrible, but I feel
-ky to be alive."
The car was destroyed in the
-eck. As it entered the building, it
ped out the front counter and
c)ved many items through the back
,�Z/Fj-
ams into NM store)
t
Star -News photo by Rog
Officers examine the damage after a car smashed through Anderson Oil in New Meadows Monday.
wall of the store, creating a jumbled
pile of cinder blocks and snack food
in the back of the building.
"It just destroyed the inside of the
store; it's a mess," Fausett said.
Eavenson reported that Arnzen
claimed to be traveling at about 20
miles per hour when another car
splashed water on his windshield,
impairing his vision.
Arnzen was cited for reckless driv-
ing and carrying a concealed weapon
in his vehicle, both misdemeanors,
Eavenson said.
There were no estimates as to the
cost of damages to the store, but it
will be rebuilt, according to owner
Bud Anderson of Pine Ridge.
"It was tragic. It's a wonder people
didn't get killed," Anderson said. "I'm
kind of in awe right now."
Eavenson commended the fast re-
sponse of the local volunteer
emergency personnel who responded
to the accident and helped remove
and treat the injured men. "I think
everybody did a real good job," he
said.
Meadows Valley Ambulance Ser-
vice President Darlene Loper was
amazed the injuries were not more
serious.
"Miracles are what this season is
about, and that's the only thing that
describes the outcome in this situa-
tion, because this could have been a
real tragedy," Loper said.
05 ca Q - / V x W's
Star -News Photo by Jeanne Heins
Car backs into McCall Drug
This car, owned by Luanna
Phelps, 32, of McCall, crashed
through the south doors of McCall
Drug last Thursday afternoon.
Phelps parked in the store's lot
without setting the car's emer-
gency brake or putting the car in
gear, McCall Police Officer Lance
Rogers said. Phelps was inside the
store shopping when the car slowly
rolled back, breaking the store's
glass doors. No damage estimate
was reported and no citations were
issued.
__21ff / ( 9 Vt-
, 'o
Logmtruc
i!�' Im
#y
aq� Al / off' Z P4, f, ins
tips, s one
4-ar //(, w6 . 4 a z f 2-
the time of the accident.
The logging truck, owned by
Ikola Logging Inc. of McCall and
driven by Leonard Wallace, 55, of
New Meadows, was southbound.
The truck had just turned the corner
when the tongue connecting the log-
ging tractor with the trailer either
cracked or broke, an Idaho State
Police report said.
The break caused the fully loaded
trailer to roll to its left and fall onto
Wiley's vehicle. Logs also fell onto a
second vehicle, a 1986 Jeep Wagoneer,
parked just south of Hotel McCall.
The jeep, owned by Carrie
McMahan, 39, of McCall, was de-
stroyed, but McMahan and her
12 -year -old daughter, Antonia, who
had been sitting in the vehicle, were
not injured.
McMahan was sitting in the
driver's seat, waiting for her 17-
year -old son to return from a store
across Third Street, when logs con-
tained on the trailer started rolling
onto her vehicle. Her daughter was
"They (the logs) all started coming toward us. My daughter crawled out the
window and I crawled out over the shifting lever to get out. " —Carrie McMahan
sitting in the back seat.
"They (the logs) all started com-
ing toward us;" McMahan said. "My
daughter crawled out the window
and I crawled out over the shifting
lever to get out."
McMahan said she didn't realize
until after she escaped the vehicle
that logs had crushed the pickup
between her and the logging truck.
"We're very fortunate . . . "
McMahan said, her voice trailing
off during a telephone interview af-
ter the accident.
Rescue personnel arriving at the
scene determined immediately that
Wiley had been killed instantly af-
ter logs rolled onto his pickup,
McCall Fire Chief Dale Points said.
"We were able to reach in the
vehicle and feel for a pulse, but there
was nothing," Points said.
Wallace was treated and released
for shock at McCall Memorial Hos-
pital. He was not cited.
Personnel from the McCall Fire
Protection Agency, the McCall Am-
bulance Service,, the Donnelly
Volunteer Fire Department, McCall
Police Department, the Valley
County Sheriffs Office and Idaho
State Police worked more than four
hours to control traffic and clear the
scene. They were assisted by a log
loader, front -end loader and equip-
ment from ABT Towing.
"Our number one priority was to
see no one else injured while we were
picking up the logs," Points said.
The cables containing the logs
on the trailer had not broken even
after the trailer overturned, Points
said. Workers had to be careful in
taking logs off the load one at a time.
"We depended heavily on the
expertise of all the logging person-
nel we had there," Points said. A
half dozen different companies from
around the area assisted at the scene.
ISP Cpl. Mitch Ruska praised the
professional conduct of those from
agencies, private companies and
relatives of the victim.
Traffic was rerouted around the
accident for almost four hours,
McCall police officer Mike Babbitt
said. Points said the biggest prob-
lem rescue personnel faced was
crowd control, as more than 100
curious onlookers gathered at the
accident, which happened at
McCall's main intersection.
"We couldn't keep people back,
they just wanted to get closer and
closer," Points said. "That didn't
help us at all."
Trah
accic
rate
in Valley
BY JEANNE SEOL
The Star -News
More motorists are injured or
killed in traffic accidents while driv-
ing in Valley County than in any
other comparably populated county
in the state, Idaho Transportation
Department statistics reveal.
In 1995, Valley County reported
three fatal traffic accidents and 95
injury accidents. Those statistics rank
higher than any of the other nine
Idaho counties with populations be-
tween 5,000 and 10,000 people.
The overall number of traffic ac-
cidents in Valley County has also
increased 30 percent since one year
ago, reports show. In 1995, 251 total
accidents were reported, compared
to 192 accidents in 1994 and 191
accidents in 1993.
Valley County Sheriff Lewis Pratt
said more accidents occur in this
area because more tourists use the
county's backcountry single -lane dirt
roads as a destination spot for recre-
ation.
"A lot of people are driving too
fast on these roads," Pratt said. "Blind
turns and narrow roadways combined
with speeding motorists result in col-
lisions."
Pratt also blamed budget short-
falls for the high number of acci-
dents. "We don't have enough money
to do an adequate job of patrolling to
keep the speeds on those roads
down," he said.
Comparably in Adams County,
the total number of accidents de-
creased by 21 percent from 1994 and
by 7 percent from 1993.
Eighty -five accidents were re-
ported in 1995 in Adams County,
compared to 103 accidents in 1994
and 92 accidents in 1993. Adams
County also had the third lowest rate
of injuries and fatalities when com-
pared to counties with populations
of up to 5,000 people.
In McCall, a total of 66 accidents
were reported during 1995, a 33 per-
cent increase from 44 accidents in
1994.
'�'I/z7
Boise Police Department officers Dan Grouthous and Gary
Compton play "Amazing Grace" on bagpipes at Legacy Park.
in McCall while marine deputies in patrol boats. seen in the
background, place a wreath in memory of Art WileN !w
hayette Lake. i lev,,i
Star -News photo by Jeanne Seol
at the McCall Nazarene Church and at Legacy Park for Wiley,
46, of McCall. Wiley.. a Valley County marine deputy, was
killed June 18 after logs from a tipping logging truck trailer
pinned him i inside his pickup at the corner of Third and Take
,,OF in (!! m '_' kCall.
`'� V
&t4inaw., Tu / / 4,
Y
Boise teen killed in rollover
accident on Mountain Road
An 18- year -old Boise man was
killed early Thursday when his
truck rolled over near Donnelly.
Idaho State Police said Mi-
chael Riley was driving his
truck on Mountain Road when
the vehicle went off the road on
the right, he overcorrected, and
then it went off the left -hand
side and rolled.
No other vehicles were in-
volved in the accident.
Riley was thrown from the
pickup and was pronounced
dead at the scene. Alcohol was
not a factor and Riley was not
using a seat belt, investigators
Said_
Tke Zek9
ISP investigation puts blame for
accident on Deputy Porter
CASCADE — While the anti -lock braking system in his patrol
vehicle was likely a factor in the crash three weeks ago of Valley
County Sheriff's Deputy Dennis Porter, resulting in the destruc-
tion of his 1996 Ford Explorer patrol vehicle, those brakes weren't
the cause, according to Idaho State Police Cpl. Jim Eavenson,
who investigated the accident.
Eavenson said Monday that, as is the case with most one -vehi-
cle accidents, "There's no one else to blame but the driver. That
would apply if it was any citizen or whomever, you have a one
vehicle rollover, and there's no one else to blame."
He said an earlier report quoting Valley County Sheriff Lewis
Pratt as saying that the accident was likely the fault of the ABS
brakes in the vehicle, was probably a misunderstanding resulting
from a conversation he had with Pratt.
Eavenson, an accident reconstruction specialist with ISP, said
ABS braking systems were designed to allow a driver to main-
tain steerability of a vehicle while stomping on the brakes.
But, he said that what can happen when heavily applying the
brakes while attempting an evasive maneuver, which Porter was
doing to avoid colliding with the vehicle of a suspected drunk dri-
ver he was pursuing, is that there isn't enough traction to go around.
That is an overly simplified explanation of the situation, but
Eavenson said there is only so much traction that a vehicle has.
When some of it must be used for steering, the amount available
for braking is reduced, thus making for longer stopping distances.
"The cause of this wreck was not the ABS brakes, the cause
of this wreck was the officer was going too fast," Eavenson said.
"Dennis and I are friends, but the officer was going too fast when
he approached that intersection."
Eavenson said there is some training that needs to go along
with ABS brakes on vehicles used by offi-
cers in pursuit situations, as there are dif-
ferences between the new brakes and the
old, where one could mash on the brakes,
but in doing so, lose control of the vehicle.
When steering is lost with the old brakes,
momentum takes over and a vehicle will
simply skid in the direction it's been trav-
eling, even if the wheels are turned anoth-
er way.
He said he hopes to conduct a training
session soon for VCSO deputies on use of
ABS brakes. The training is intended to
keep such an incident from happening again,.
he said.
In his report to Valley County Prosecuting
Attorney Robert Williams, Eavenson rec-
ommends no action be taken against Porter.
And Valley County Sheriff Lewis Pratt said
he had no plans to take any disciplinary
action against Porter.
�� / ��. ��- / 7 &