HomeMy Public PortalAboutIdaho History: Daily LivingL-cu Ny -.+c Y I --W ........ r,. —V' . —• --- -- — - - -
Staged photographs depict
Western self- consciousness
By ARTHUR HART
After Idahoans began going
to the movies regularly there
was a new awareness that they
lived in the "wild and woolly
West." This is indicated by a
number of amusing "staged"
photographs in which ordinary
folks pretended to be movie
badmen.
Today's example is a classic
of the type. It was made in
Billy Coltharps's Hagerman sa-
loon early in the century. In it,
everybody is studiously acting
out a part — some with feeling
and some a bit awkwardly.
Ralph Bryant, the central
figure, plays the part of a ram-
paging cowboy,, drinking his
whiskey straight from the bot-
tle. Bartender Butch Gridley
doesn't approve of this kind of
behavior and raises a hatchet
to stop it — whether in earnest
or as a threat is not clear.
Billy Coltharp, proprietor,
has his own problems in the
background. A second cowboy
with a pistol is forcing him to
"stick- em -up." Elmer Cook
and his pistol are silhouetted
against the saloon's front win-
dow, and appear again in the
back bar mirror at left.
Idaho'
Yesterdays ,
Pool player George Lunford
is either unaware of what is
going on behind him, or doesn't
give a hoot and is going to con-
centrate on the shot he wants
to make no matter what hap-
pens.
One of the nicest things about
this photo is the beautiful qual-
ity of the light and the fine de-
tail it brings out. In the origi-
nal, one can almost read the la-
bels on the bottles back of the
bar. It is easy to read the large
framed picture in the center
which advertises the "Pabst
Brewing Co.," and one to the
right which touts "Y -B Havana
Cigars."
The grain of wood in the bar
itself shows up nicely as do the
brass rail, the cuspidor, and a
corner of the cigar counter dis-
play space.
It would be nice to know who
the talented photographer with
the flare for movie melodrama
was — or if he took other posed
pictures like this one.
In any case, it is a document
of the kind of self- conscious-
ness Westerners began to show
about their history arounq the
turn of the century, partly
under the influence of dime no-
vels', the first movie Westerns,
and such classic works as
Owen Wister's 1902 The Virgin-
ian.
Wister's masterpiece, featur-
ing a cowboy hero, a villain,
and a pretty schoolteacher, be-
came the prototype for literally
hundreds of Western novels
and movies.
Idahoans who read these
books or saw these early West-
ern films obviously got into the
spirit of the kind of drama they
portrayed.,
The saloon was a standard
setting for much of the action
in such productions, and from
the photos in the Historical col-
lections, Idaho photographers
couldn't resist their own
chances to further the legend
of the Old West.
Shelton "Doc" Thayer was
the donor of this fine picture.
(Arthur Hart is director of
the Idaho Historical Society.)
Volume 5 White Swan, Washington, July 5, 1970 Number 1
INTERESTING FACTS -IDAHO
This year on July 3, Idaho celebrates its 80th Statehood Anniversary. Many events have
contributed to the making of Idaho, the nation's 43rd state to be admitted to the union.
When Meriwether Lewis and William Clark made their way westward to Idaho in 1805,
they discovered the Nez Perce, Idaho's largest Indian tribe, living along the Clearwater and
Salmon Rivers. They were followed by Henry H. Spalding and his wife, early msisionaries,
who built a home and mission at Spalding, near Lapwai. They became the first white fam-
ily to settle in Idaho. Spalding also established Idaho's first sawmill in the late 1840's.
Following the Spaldings, a group of Mormons settled in eastern Idaho at Fort Lemhit
and began farming in 1855.
In 1860, the cry of "Gold" was heard from the Orofino Creek region causing gold seekers
to pour into the territory. The miners worked out their claims and moved on, leaving way
for farmers, cattlemen, sheep ranchers, and loggers.
Congress organized the Territory of Idaho, which consisted of Montana and Wyoming,
as well as Idaho, on March 3, 1863, wtih Lewiston as its capitol. In 1864, Boise became the
capital of the smaller Idaho territory after Montana and Wyoming had become separate
territories.
Eventually settlers tried to force the Nez Perce Indians to move to the Lapwai Indian
Reservation creating the War of 1877 in Idaho. In 1878, the Bannocks also rebelled because
cattle were destroying an important food crop, camas, which grows abundantly on Idaho's
camas prairie region. However, by 1894 most of Idaho's Indians were established on res-
ervations.
The Territory of Idaho adopted a constitution in 1889 and entered the Union July 3, 1890.
George L. Shoup, a Republican, became the first governor.
The years 1892 through 1907 saw many mining disputes and strikes. One dispute in
1907 brought national fame to young William E. Borah, a lawyer, who later became an out-
standing U. S. Senator for 33 years.
After World War I, Idaho enjoyed good times until the depression in 1929. An important
relief agency to Idaho during the depression was the Civilian Conservation Corps, whose
members did work in the forests, improved public lands, and helped protect wildlife.
Idaho's forest and farm lands became increasingly more important during World War II
as sources of lumber and food. More than 60,000 Idahoans served during World War II with
many more working in factories.
Idaho has recently developed hydroelectric projects to meet the demand of its expand-
ing agricultural and industrial enterprises. Now under construction near Orofino is Dwor-
shak Dam. Named for Henry Dworshak, the dam will be the highest straight axis concrete
gravity dam in the U. S. upon completion in 1972.
THEN AND NOW — The old Idaho State Capitol near the center of the 300 block on C Street
showed the effects of time near the turn of the century. Skelton's now extends from the
corner of Third and C Streets to the old Capitol site.
Page Two
WHITE SWAN LUMBER COMPANY
White Swan, Washington
MUSINGS OF CLEDA
Born in Idaho, untouched by any-
thing but a power saw, and christened
"Cleda" by her makers, she arrived in
White Swan via Bill Turner six years ago
to observe life from her forest bower and
to muse on her observations. Someone
asked her where she had gone on her
vacation and she listlessly replied "No
man's land." But this was all right be-
cause the bigger the summer vacation
the harder the fall! Then the other day
a fellow came into the office and wanted
to know if he could have a day off with
pay. When Mike asked when, he re-
plied, "I want to collect up on the time
I missed for coffee breaks when I was on
vacations." But all in all, vacations are
great levelers. The person who takes
one, returns home just as broke as the
person who stayed home because he
couldn't afford to go away!
MAURICE and KATHLEEN
5, 1970
Sunday, May 21, many people passed
through the portals of the Richard
Hitchcock home to wish the honored
guests of the day, many happy returns.
The occasion was the observance of
the 40th Wedding Anniversary of Maur-
ice and Kathleen Hitchcock. Four of the
five children and their families were
present, the missing one was "Kam" and
she could not be here because of time
and distance as she is attending school
in Beirut, Lebanon.
Many people from many places, came
to visit and it was like old home week
and all of us wish you, Maurice and
Kathleen, many more years of wedded
bliss.
The occasion was commemorated more
by a poem written by Ellwood Hinman
of White Swan.
I know that at a service station
You can get most necessities of life,
But no one but Maurice
Would go there looking for a wife!
I don't know what the station was
Standard, Shell or Esso —
But after Maurice inspected the merch-
andise,
He told the attendant, "I guess so."
Then followed a turbulent courtship
Every evasive tactic he tried
But he woke up one day to find himself
Roper, branded and tied.
Life in Sisters was simple
Maurice was happy with married life.
Then the family started coming
Adding brawling, turmoil, and strife.
The first three he survived
Without too much despair
But you can imagine his dismay
When the next one was really a pair!!!
Faced with this weird situation
As a matter of self preservation
Maurice decided the only salvation
Was to find his tribe a reservation.
He chose to move to White Swan
Where there was plenty of room to ex-
pand
The community still is rocking
From the arrival of this wild -eyed band.
(Continued on page 3)
iamw Yesterday
Photos Provide Keyholes
For Spying Into History
By ARTHUR A. HART
Director,
Idaho Historical Museum
Few things are as fasci-
nating to the photo historian
as discovering a new view of
a familiar scene. Today's ex-
ample will provide a case.
study.
In this view of the corner
of Tenth and Main streets,
donated to the Idaho Histori-
cal Society by Barry Hop-
kins, the towers of the
Idanha Hotel at right domi-
nate the scene. Handsome
red and white candy- stripe
awnings give the building a
festive character closely re-
lated to the big American
flags hanging in the fore-
ground.
Dating a picture like this
is one of the first steps in
completing its identity. The
flags are an immediate clue.
Since these are 46 -star flags,
it is likely the picture was
taken before 1912 when Ari-
zona and New Mexico were
admitted to the Union. It
cannot have been before 1908
since Oklahoma, the 46th
state, was admitted the No-
vember before.
The number of flags sug-
gests a holiday. Which one?
The Fourth of July is the lo-
gical candidate, since the
trees on Tenth Street beyond
the Idanha are a dark shade
suggesting mid - summer fo-
liage rather than the paler
trees of spring green or au-
tumn yellow. Another clue to
summer is the fact that the
woman on the sidewalk at
left is dressed all in white,
and the man beyond her
wears a straw hat. Two oth-
er women at the Idanha cor-
ner carry parasols.
Signs, where visible, usu-
ally provide clues to dating a
photograph also. The Pierce
Building at right has W. E.
Pierce & Company's sign on
it, giving us the chance to
check Boise City Directories
to see during which years
the firm occupied the build-
ing. These indicate that the
building was completed in
1903 and that Pierce moved
his office in 1910. (At the
time of its demolition in 1973
the building was best known
as the Men's Wardrobe).
The Gem Building, on the
Northwest corner, seen just
above the horse and buggy,
was begun in 1902 and also
finished in 1903.
On the left, on the fourth
corner of this turretted inter-
section, is the Merino Build-
ing. It too was finished at
the turn of the century.
When it burned in the
Twenties the Sun Building
was built at the corner from
designs by Wayland & Fen-
nel. Today the Sun Building
has been handsomely reno-
vated into the dark -brick
Continental Life Building.
The only legible sign on
the left side of our photo
reads "Talking Machines —
" an early name for phono-
graphs. Although phono-
graphs had appeared on
Boise streets as a money-
making novelty as early as
1890, they were not priced
within the reach of average
citizens until the turn of the
century.
In the Nineties schools and
churches began to purchase
phonographs. Appreciative
audiences gathered to hear
"gramophone entertain-
ments," staring in fascina-
tion at the wonderful ma-
chine producing the sounds
from wax cylinders. By the
time our picture was taken
scores of Boise homes had
them and several merchants
sold them.
Having enjoyed the game
of "photo detective," using
directories, newspaper ads,
and fire maps, it is always
nice to be able to call the do-
nor of a photo for further in-
formation. In this case we
were told that the picture
was taken sometime after
1906 by Ben Hopkins.
106 THE IDAHO STATESMAN, Boise, Monday, July 21, 1975
A horse -drawn delivery wagon is parked across from the Idanha Hotel as flags fly on Main Street
Idaho Yesterday
Photos Provide Keyholes
For Spying Into History
By ARTHUR A. HART
Director,
Idaho Historical Museum
Few things are as fasci-
nating to the photo historian
as discovering a new view of
a familiar scene. Today's ex-
amn a will nrnvidp a case_
kins, the towers of the
Idanha Hotel at right domi-
nate the scene. Handsome
red and white candy- stripe
awnings give the building a
festive character closely re-
lated to the big American
flans hanQinR in the fore-
flags are an immediate clue.
Since these are 46 -star flags,
it is likely the picture was
taken before 1912 when Ari-
zona and New Mexico were
admitted to the Union. It
cannot have been before 1908
since Oklahoma, the 46th
summer is the fact that the
woman on the sidewalk at
left is dressed all in white,
and the man beyond her
wears a straw hat. Two oth-
er women at the Idanha cor-
ner carry parasols_
Signs, where visible, usu-
By ARTHUR A. HART
Director,
Idaho Historical Museum
The history of photography
in- Idaho is a subject that
needs further research and
eventual publication. Pho-
tography, one of the in-
dispensable tools of the his-
torian and documentarian, is
also an art.
A perusal of the efforts of
pioneer photographers
quickly reveals that they
were as much interested in
securing pleasing aesthetic
effects as they were in
recording a likeness.
Many of the old -time pho-
tographers were vagabonds,
moving from mining camp
to mining camp as the tides
Of fortune shifted. It was
rare indeed in the Sixties for
a photographer in Idaho to
stay in one place more than
a few months.
Law & Miller, for ex-
ample, opened a "photo-
graph gallery" at the corner
of Eighth and Idaho, Boise,
in January, 1865.
By July they were out of
business and the Sutterly
Brothers from Virginia City,
Montana, had moved in
"with a complete photogra-
phic stock and apparatus."
A photographer with the
euphonious name John Junk
Was one of the most success-
ful in Southern Idaho in the
mid- Sixties. In 1865 he oper-
ated a studio in Idaho City,
and achieved a local fame in
1868 by taking the first pho-
tographs of Shoshone Falls.
These were taken on spec-
ulation, and offered at $5 a
set, both in Boise, where lie
had now moved, and in a
branch studio in Silver City.
In lieu of a paid ad, the
pnuwgt apt— k,.
set of the photos to Editor
James Reynolds, who re-
sponded with a plug for the
pictures, pointing out that
"they are an ornament in
any parlor or office."
By the following year,
however; John Junk had
moved on to other fields. In
February, 1869, there is men-
tion of his having settled in
Helena, Montana Territory.
His Shoshone Falls photo-
graphs continued to be prized
in Boise for many years. One
of them, purchased by Cy
Jacobs, a founding father of
the city, was proudly dis-
played in Horace Myers' Art
Store in October, 1892.
In July, 1870, evidently fill-
ing the vacuum created by
Junk's departure, H. E. Les-
lie, "photographic artist,"
moved his gallery to Boise
from Silver City. The States-
man, in an optimistic mood,
said that Leslie would "per-
manently locate in Boise.
This meant a few months, as
it turned out. i
Ike Curry, who had run a
studio in Idaho City, was
doing portraits for five dol-
lars a dozen in rooms across
from the Overland Hotel in
December, 1870, but by Au-
gust had rented his rooms to
Bomar & Bayhouse.
"Being steady young men,
just starting out in business,
we hope to see them receive
liberal and substantial en-
couragement," wrote The
Statesman. Curry's brief
abandonment of photogra-
phy was to last only a
month.
On August 19, the paper
observed that he had given
up merchandising "and fall-
en back on his old avocation
of transferring the line-
aments of the human face
divine to posterity."
This is far from a complete
list of early photographers in
Southern Idaho, even up to
1871, and there were many
famous names to come, such
as Charles S. Kingsley, Ho-
race Myers, and Anton Un-
ternahrer, but it does sug-
gest a fertile field of inquiry
for a researcher.
There are hundreds of fine
old photographs, whose pho-
tographers are virtually un-
known as historical figures,
even though their names are
`imprinted on their work.
Who they were, where
they worked, and when —
these are things to be
worked out in detail. Mean-
while, we shall continue to
seek out the photographs
themselves.
They represent a rich re-
source in Idaho history.
Pioneer photograpners in zuultu mug W, "__J
i
BU
r
q,_
�
Y
>i
tai:
Historic double takes
Idaho photographers trace the steps of tt
By JUDY STEELE
The Idaho Statesman
SUN VALLEY — Mention the Old West
and it conjures up pictures of rough cow-
boys riding herd on red -eyed cattle, crazy
miners leaving home and family for the
fool's dream of gold, and determined pio-
neers huddling in wagon trains as they
fight off Indians.
But the West drew other adventurers as
well, men who recorded the wild land
through the delicate art of photography.
Their photographs, as much as or perhaps
more than diaries and drawings, estab-
lished the West as both a real place and a
land of legends.
Now the sites of some of these early pho-
tographs have been revisited and rephoto-
graphed by two Idaho photographers.
Ellen Manchester and Mark Klett, direc-
tor and assistant director for the Pho-
tography Department of the Sun Valley
Center for the Arts and Humanities, estab-
lished the Rephotographic Survey Project
2 years ago. With a third photographer, Jo
Ann Verburg, they have rephotographed
85 sites in Idaho, Wyoming, Utah, Col-
orado, New Mexico and Arizona.
The project was born in Rochester,
N.Y., when Manchester and Klett were in-
troduced because of their mutual interest
in a survey of old photographic sites.
"It started out casually as an idea we
discussed," Klett said. "It probably
wouldn't have happened if we hadn't, got-
ten together in Rochester."
But the project did happen, in part be-
cause it caught the imagination of other
people asp well as Manchester and Klett.
National Endowment for the Arts and Po-
laroid Corp. have funded the project for
the last 2 years. The field work was spon-
sored by Colorado Mountain College, in
Breckenridge, Colo., and research and ex-
hibition preparation for the photographs is
being sponsored by the Sun Valley Center.
Once money was available for the pro-
ject, the first step was to establish some
limits. Manchester and Klett decided to
concentrate on one photographer — Wil-
liam Henry Jackson — for the first year
and to work with his photographs from
1873. The second year they worked with
other survey photographers, including A.J.
Russell, Timothy O'Sullivan, Alexander
Gardner and Jack Hillers.
The decision to begin with Jackson was
made impart for practical reasons. Klett,
who has a degree in geology, had worked
one summer with the United States Geo-
logical Survey and was able to use
Jackson's photos and diaries from its files.
Because Klett was doing most of the pho-
tography (Manchester handles the admin-
istrative and fundraising end of the pro-
ject), Jackson was a natural choice.
The diaries were used to locate the pho-
tnrtr -o.J� niter... D..+ :F .,,.,.. «e♦ .....r .. ....... !.
Photographers Mark Klett and
Ellen Manchester: They set
strict guidelines for
themselves in order to come
as close as they could to an
exact duplication of the
original photograph. That
meant being at the site the
same time of year, the same
time of day and with the same
weather conditions that the
early photographers had
encountered.
cided to photograph Twin Lakes even
though the wind was up. But Klett and
Manchester had set strict guidelines for
themselves in order to come as close as
they could to an exact duplication of the
original photograph. That meant being at
the site the same time of year, the same
time of day and with the same weather
conditions that Jackson had encountered.
Sometimes the diaries gave them dates.
Often, they had to guess the time of year
and time of day from the picture itself. At
least once, a clue to a Timothy O'Sullivan
photo came from an unexpected source.
"A friend told me that one site we were
going to photograph had graffiti on it that
said Sept. 23 and the name of someone in
the survey team O'Sullivan was with,"
Klett said. "That made it easier since the
lighting had to be just right to get the same
picture he took. There was only a 3- minute
period when the rock stratification showed
up.
The team arm imm Pnlamiri anninmant
understand it," Manchester said.
Klett found that the different surve3
photographers approached a potentia
photograph differently from each other
and differently than he might.
"Jackson was really interested in the
Picturesque. O'Sullivan had a less roman
tic stance involved in his work," he said
"Jackson's photographs seem to fit what
people liked. They seem a little outdated
O'Sullivan made beautiful use of space anc
land. In one photograph, he actua113
slanted the shot. He took it at a better
angle even though it wasn't correct."
Russell's training as a painter in
fluenced his photography, Manchester
said.
"Mark and Jo Ann said as soon as they
walked up to a site they knew which direc•
tion he took," she said.
The team also found that different sur•
vey leaders had different approaches U
the land they were exploring.
"There were a number of both civiliar
and miltary surveys which were lumpec
together under the USGS in 1879," Man•
chester said. "Some were really militarily
oriented. Their approach was that this wa:
uncharted land and the idea was to figure
out where irrigation was possible, where
railroads could go and how to deal with the
`red problem,' which is really what they
called it."
The viewpoint of leaders such as Ferdi-
nand Hayden and Clarence King could
have influenced the photographers, Klett
said.
"King had a theory of catastophic geol-
ogy, really a quasi - religious understanding
of rock. To him, things happened very
quickly. There's a question whether he di-
rected his photographers that way. Hay-
den had a theory more along the lines of
evolution," he said.
"Hayden really understood the power of
photography," Manchester said. "He
hired Jackson to photograph Yellowstone.
When the bill came before Congress in 1862
to make Yellowstone a national park, he
made sure that congressmen saw the pic-
tures. Some people say that he even gave
each congresman his own set of photos. He
realized that the better pictures he got, the
better Yellowstone's chances were."
Even though comparison of the photo-
graphs could lead to a number of different
conclusions, Klett and Manchester did not
set out to make any statement about the
land they were rephotographing, Man-
chester said.
"You could edit out certain pictures and
make any statement you want," she said.
They did have some objectives for the
project, however, including establishing a
methodology for conducting a photo-
graphic survey.
"The point for me would not be to do
Luga- aNaaca a, a,aa,auua,as _.. .
XYLHI�l 5.1 Russell, Timothy O'Sullivan, Alexander
Gardner and Jack Hillers.
The decision to begin with Jackson was
made in.part for practical reasons. Klett,
who has a degree in geology, had worked
one summer with the United States Geo-
logical Survey and was able to use
Jackson's photos and diaries from its files.
Because Klett was doing most of the pho-
tography (Manchester handles the admin-
istrative and fundraising end of the pro-
ject), Jackson was a nataral choice.
The diaries were used to locate the pho-
tograph sites. But it wasn't just a matter
of walking up to a well -known natural
monument and pushing the shutter button.
"I remember the first time we looked
for a photo site," Klett said. "It was Twin
Lakes. It's still there, it still has the same
name. But the picture we had has no fore-
ground and we use foreground to locate
sites."
"We spent all day looking for that site,"
Manchester said. "We were bickering and
I was wondering what we'd gotten into. ".
Two weeks later, they went back out to
the lake and located the spot where Jack-
son had taken the picture. But this time
the wind was up, making waves on the
lake. Jackson's picture shows a glass -flat
lake, mirroring the scene around it. The
team had to scrap another day's work.
"After that we had a meeting and raised
some real questions about the project,
whether it was impossible," Manchester
said.
But the next week, Klett went to the
Garden of the Gods and got good pictures.
They decided to continue their work.
Another survey team might have de-
Often, they had to guess the time of year
and time of day from the picture itself. At
least once, a clue to a Timothy O'Sullivan
photo came from an unexpected source.
"A friend told me that one site we were
going to photograph had graffiti on it that
said Sept. 23 and the name of someone in
the survey team O'Sullivan was with,"
Klett said. "That made it easier since the
lighting had to be just right to get the same
picture he took. There was only a 3- minute
period when the rock stratification showed
up.
The team also used Polaroid equipment
to set up the shot and make sure that they
had precisely the same frame taken by the
original photographer. Being off even by
several inches could have made a differ-
ence in the scene shot, Klett said.
But within the strict perameters of time,
weather and frame, the photographers,al-
lowed themselves some artistic leeway. In
rephotographing a lake scene, a photogra-
pher working with Klett realized that the
change in trees and plant life would
change the focus in his photograph. So he
left in a waterskier and boat to pull the
focus back to the lake.
When Klett took a photograph of a
geyser formation in Yellowstone Park, he
decided to leave out the two men standing
on top of the formation, measuring its
depth with a plumb line. And he decided to
print the photograph he took just as the
geyser went off. The two pictures make a
statement about the view different photog-
raphers have of nature.
"There was a feeling at that time that if
they could document something, they
could know it. They could conquer it and
Even though comparison of the photo-
graphs could lead to a number of different
conclusions, Klett and Manchester did not
set out to make any statement about the
land they were rephotographing, Man•
chester said.
"You could edit out certain pictures anc
make any statement you want," she said.
They did have some objectives for the
project, however, including establishing
methodology for conducting a photo
graphic survey.
"The point for me would not be to 6
more photographs, but to define what hap
pens when we do them, isolate the varia
bles and try to tack down some conclu
sions," Klett said. "Surveys are in vogue
now, but people don't know what they'n
doing."
During the 2 -year project, the photc
graphers have developed a record- keepin;
system to provide information on eacl
photograph taken. The system will be use
by Sun Valley Center students to rephotc
graph pictures taken by longtime resi
dents of Hailey and Bellevue, Mancheste
said.
She and Klett also plan to provide sets c
the photographs to various collections tha
have requested them and to exhibit th
photographs in a variety of settings, h
cluding the Boise Gallery of Art.
One set of prints will be going to th
USGS files with the hope that the photi
graphs and information will be used to n
photograph the sites in 50 to 100 years.
"We're not looking for immortality wit
the project," Manchester said. "I hoI
whoever does it in the future is better tha
we are."
Colorado's Whitehouse Mountain and Elk Lake in 1873 ...
... The 197
takes
SUNDAY, JUNE 3, 1979
race the steps of their Old West counterparts
understand it," Manchester said.
Klett found that the different survey
photographers approached a potential
photograph differently from each other
and differently than he might.
"Jackson was really interested in the
picturesque. O'Sullivan had a less roman-
tic stance involved in his work," he said.
"Jackson's photographs seem to fit what
people liked. They seem a little outdated.
O'Sullivan made beautiful use of space and
land. In one photograph, he actually
slanted the shot. He took it at a better
angle even though it wasn't correct."
Russell's training as a painter in-
fluenced his photography, Manchester
said.
"Mark and Jo Ann said as soon as they
walked up to a site they knew which direc-
tion he took," she said.
The team also found that different sur-
vey leaders had different approaches to
the land they were exploring.
"There were a number of both civilian
and miltary surveys which were lumped
together under the USGS in 1879," Man-
chester said. "Some were really militarily
oriented. Their approach was that this was
uncharted land and the idea was to figure
out where irrigation was possible, where
railroads could go and how to deal with the
`red problem,' which is really what they
called it."
The viewpoint of leaders such as Ferdi-
nand Hayden and Clarence King could
have influenced the photographers, Klett
said.
"King had a theory of catastophic geol-
ogy, really a quasi- religious understanding
of rock. To him, things happened very
quickly. There's a question whether he di-
rected his photographers that way. Hay-
den had a theory more along the lines of
evolution," he said.
"Hayden really understood the power of
photography," Manchester said. "He
hired Jackson to photograph Yellowstone.
When the bill came before Congress in 1862
to make Yellowstone a national park, he
made sure that congressmen saw the pic-
tures. Some people say that he even gave
each congresman his own set of photos. He
realized that the better pictures he got, the
better Yellowstone's chances were."
Even though comparison of the photo-
graphs could lead to a number of different
conclusions, Klett and Manchester did not
set out to make any statement about the
land they were rephotographing, Man-
chester said.
"You could edit out certain pictures and
make any statement you want," she said.
They did have some objectives for the
project, however, including establishing a
methodology for conducting a photo-
graphic survey.
"The point for me would not be to do
mnrn r.hntnnr�nc� 1—t to infirm —hnt hnn
Jackson's view of Pulpit Rock in Utah, 1869 ...
itself. At
graphs could lead to a number of different
'Sullivan
conclusions, Klett and Manchester did not
ource_
set out to make any statement. about the
we were
land they were rephotographing, Man -
on it that
chester said.
meone in
"You could edit out certain pictures and
is with,"
make any statement you want," she said.
since the
They did have some objectives for the
the same
project, however, including establishing a
3- minute
methodology for conducting a photo-
n showed
graphic survey.
"The point for me would not be to do
uat
more photographs, but to define what hap -
that they
they
pens when we do them, isolate the varia-
bles and try to tack down some conclu-
even by
a differ-
sions," Klett said. "Surveys are in vogue
now, but people don't know what they're
of time,
of time,
doing."
During the 2 -year project, the photo-
way. In
graphers have developed a record - keeping
photogra-
system to provide information on each
i that the
Photograph taken. The system will be used
fe ld
would
by Sun Valley Center students to rephoto-
ph. So
graph pictures taken by longtime resi-
p pull the
dents of Hailey and Bellevue, Manchester
said.
She and Klett also plan to provide sets of
iph of a
the photographs to various collections that
Park, he
have requested them and to exhibit the
i standing
photographs in a variety of settings, in-
uring its
cluding the Boise Gallery of Art.
lecided to
One set of prints will be going to the
ist as the
USGS files with the hope that the photo-
�s make a
graphs and information will be used to re-
st photog-
photograph the sites in 50 to 100 years.
"We're not looking for immortality with
.ne that if
the project," Manchester said. "I hope
ng, they
whoever does it in the future is better than
ier it and
we are."
... and the same Echo Canyon site in 1978
... The 1977 view of what is now Snowmass Mountain and Geneva Lake
111'(:11 PAR:\II IU
Bruneau Canyon oeerlook, 800 feet above river. View here is south
Idaho has a deep .surprise
Southwestern Idaho is usually described as
desert country —sage and sand, deficient
in rainfall, remote and sparsely settled. It
is indeed an upland desert, etched with
sharp -edged gorges. Most of the region is
drained by the Bruneau River and its
tributaries through Bruneau Canyon, one
of the deepest and narrowest chasms in
North America. Its very steep, sometimes
nearly vertical walls drop almost 2,000
feet in places; only in a few locations can
a man descend to the bottom.
SAND DUNES
Road travelers have three favorite spots
around Bruneau. The first is the sand dune
country. Turn off U.S. 30 at Hammett
State Park, and drive 12 miles to the west.
This road leads directly to the base of the
dunes near a small lake which offers good
swimming and a variety of fish. Several of
the dunes are more than 400 feet high —
among the world's tallest. Although you'll
see tracks where adventurous drivers have
left the road, it's safer to walk on the
dunes than drive on them. If you get
stuck, help is 10 miles away at Bruneau.
BRUNEAU OVERLOOK
From Bruneau, continue 18 miles south
on the road (half pavement, half gravel)
that parallels the east bank of the river.
Following signs pointing to the overlook,
you will cross a flat lava desert and come
abruptly upon the canyon itself, 800 feet
deep at this point, and no more than 74
mile wide at the top.
It's traditional to try to lob a rock across
the canyon, but this is an increasingly
Mountainw`a 68
tQ_ Homk3,
P� mmet}, .
R,�nnnan �.
BRUNEAU CANYON
x
0 miles 20
_ _ IDAHO
NEVADA
The roads to Bruneau Canyon
poor idea because more and more boaters
are running the river each year. If the
urge proves irresistible, at least check to
make sure no one is below.
INDIAN BATHTUB
On the way back to the town of Bruneau
from the canyon viewpoint, turn left
Bruneau Canyon floor is hard to reach,
but provides hiking, fishing, swimming
Dozen, dozen into
Idaho's Bruneau
Southwestern Idaho's starkly beautiful
Bruneau Canyon, one of the deepest of
gorges, is also one of the most inaccessi-
ble, as Peter Ogden found when he ex-
plored its entire rim in 1826. Ironically
he and his Hudson's Bay Company trap-
pers nearly died of thirst for want of a
trail to the Bruneau River far below.
Modern canyon explorers have an easier
time both descending to the Bruneau's
floor and reaching the desert that it bi-
sects for some 65 miles.
From Mountain Home you drive south
on State Highway 51 for 20 miles to the
town of Bruneau. Continue south onto
the desert on the paved road that stays
east of the river. After 8 miles the road
forks into three secondary roads, all best
traveled by high - clearance vehicles. Take
the middle fork, which follows the can-
yon's east rim, for 10 miles to a high
overlook.
To get to the river itself, continue on the
middle fork road another .2 mile, then
turn right onto another dirt road for 6
miles to the canyon rim. Here locate the
Roberson Trail with the help of a U.S.G.S.
map (Winter Quadrangle).
Autumn is the best time for a Bruneau
Canyon visit. The temperature reaches
70 °, the river is low enough to permit
hiking at the bottom of the steep - walled
gorge, and scattered along the rocky can-
yon walls are oases of gray -blue junipers
and bright yellow willows.
6UNBET
Glenns Ferry railroad yards live again at the Idaho State Museum
Glenns Ferry was bustling railroad center
By ARTHUR HART
Glenns Ferry takes its name from
two brothers of that name who built
and operated a ferry across the
Snake River in 1865, about a mile
east of the present center of town
The growth and later prosperity of
the place was chiefly due to the Ore-
gon Short Line railroad which came
in 1882 -83.
Even earlier, Oregon Trail io-
neers forded the river a few n1iles
west by way of three islands. Three
Island Crossing became a well -
known landmark on the trail, used by
thousands of western-bound emi-
grants after 1840.
It was the only crossing used regu-
larly to go from the south side of
Snake River to the north side and the
route over sagebrush plains to Boise
valley.
The townsite was platted by the
railroad in 1883, and in 1887 Glenns
Ferry was made a division point. Re-
pair shops, stores, a freight yard and
a big roundhouse were built soon
after.
The importance of the railroad to
Idaho
Yesterdays 1
Glenns Ferry would be difficult to
overestimate, since for half a cen-
tury it served as the basis of the
town's economy.
Even after farming and ranching
became important, it was the rail-
road that brought in the supplies and
hauled the local money crops to mar-
ket.
Glenns Ferry's railroad yards
were the scene of much activity in
those great days of the steam loco-
motives.
A second roundhouse, built after
the turn of the century and expanded
later, could accommodate 16 locomo-
tives at once. A steel -truss turntable
shunted the giant engines into their
vacant stalls for servicing and minor
repairs.
And now it is possible to visualize
this bit of Idaho railroad history by a
visit to the Idaho Model Railroad
Club's permanent display in the State
Museum.
This group of railroad buffs has re-
created the Glenns Ferry yard in
miniature with remarkable attention
to detail.
Locomotives, spare wheels, ties
and other equipment are reproduced
at precise scale, distributed as they
might have been on a typical day on
the Oregon Short Line.
. Using photographs like the one
shown today, made sometime before
1916, the club has done an outstand-
ing job of making a bit of Idaho his-
tory come to life.
Best of all, perhaps, is the fact that
the club's efforts are all donated to
the people of Idaho for their enjoy-
ment.
Major showings of the Idaho Model
Railroad are scheduled on the first
Sunday afternoon of each month
from 1 until 5 p.m.
Members operate a number of
trains at one time, recreating actual
conditions on a working railroad.
The public is also invited to view
construction activities on Tuesday
evenings beginning April 7 from 7:30
until 9:30 p.m.
(Arthur Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical SocIety.)
Glenns Ferry railroad yards live again at the Idaho State Museum
Glenns Ferry was bustling railroad center
By ARTHUR HART
Glenns Ferry takes its name
om
two brothers of that name who
it
and operated a ferry across
the
Snake River in 1865, about a
ile
east of the present center of town
The growth and later prosperit
of
the place was chiefly due to the
re-
gon Short Line railroad which c
me
in 1882 -83.
Even earlier, Oregon Trail
pio-
Idaho
Yesterdays
Glenns Ferry would be difficult to
overestimate, since for half a cen-
tury it served as the basis of the
this bit of Idaho railroad history by a
visit to the Idaho Model Railroad
Club's permanent display in the State
Museum.
This group of railroad buffs has re-
created the Glenns Ferry yard in
miniature with remarkable attention
to detail.
Locomotives, spare wheels, ties
and other equipment are reproduced
at precise scale, distributed as they
might have been on a typical day on
Best of all, perhaps, is the fact that
the club's efforts are all donated to
the people of Idaho for their enjoy-
ment.
Major showings of the Idaho Model
Railroad are scheduled on the first
Sunday afternoon of each month
from 1 until 5 p.m.
Members operate a number of
trains at one time, recreating actual
conditions on a working railroad.
The public is also invited to view
.• L• a ri-1-111e 5 DIUe Lakes Ranch was an awesome but favored Idaho site
Idaho Yesterdays
Perrine
Land's
By ARTHUR A. HART
Director, Idaho Historical
Museum
Many a pioneer settled
early on some portion of Ida-
ho's richly endowed terrain
without realizing its ultimate
potential. Even in the case
of those who did, they often
had the luck to be "born too
soon" to capitalize on re-
sources that would only
reach full value many years
later.
A man who knew what he
had, and who clung to a par-
ticularly unique piece of the
Idaho landscape, was 1. B.
Perrine. When Perrine first
saw the land lying in Snake
River Canyon a few miles
below Shoshone Falls which
came to be known as Blue
I. B. PERRINE
.. picked his spot
Recognized
Blessing
Lakes Ranch, he decided
that this was a spot particu-
larly blessed.
When the rest of the arid
Snake River plain of South-
ern Idaho was still blanketed
with snow, this sheltered
part of the great basalt can-
yon of the river was receiv-
ing the winter sunshine and
protected from the cold
winds which swept over-
head.
Wintering robins flew from
one protective clump of na-
tive shrub to another or ran
listening for worms across
open grassy patches among
the giant lava boulders pol-
ished by the ancient flood
when Lake Bonneville
drained out to the Columbia
and the Pacific 20 to 30 thou-
sand years ago.
Ducks by the hundreds
rafted in the river or dab-
bled in the Blue Lakes.
Perrine decided, soon after
establishing his ranch in this
wild and awesome place,
that its protected mini -cli-
mate was suited to the grow-
ing of fruit trees.
Since the Wood River min-
ing country was booming to
the north, and the new rail-
road town of Shoshone was
not far away, Perrine de-
cided to exploit this new
market. Now only did his or-
chards produce fruit — it
was of a quality that encour-
aged him to enter it in inter-
national expositions.
At Paris in 1900, he won a
gold medal for his Rome
Beauty apples. He also won
medals at Buffalo in 1901, at
r
Omaha, 1902, at St. Louis,
1904, and at Portland in 1905.
His Italian prunes won a
gold medal in 1909• at
Seattle's Alaska, Yukon and
Pacific Exposition.
Considering Idaho's re-
moteness and small popu-
lation at that time, these
were notable accom-
plishments. That fruit from
the canyon of one of Amer-
ica's great rivers, so remote
that few people in the whole
country could have located it
on a map, should be ad-
judged best in world and na-
tional competitions was
quite astonishing.
Perrine's experience and
success at Blue Lakes Ranch
gave him unshakable faith
in the future of South Ida-
ho's great sage plains. He
saw that this volcanic soil
could produce miracles if
only water could be brought
from the river canyon 400
feet below to the vast plains
above.
He was one of the chief
promotors of the Twin Falls
project, leading to the build-
ing of Milner Dam and the
location of a city where only
sagebrush and jack rabbits
had known the sun and
winds before.
When the city of Twin
Falls was laid out and built
in 1904, appropriately
enough, its largest building
was I. B. Perrine's hotel.
His name, like the country
he pioneered, will be forever
green, and the Blue Lakes a
favored spot in Nature's
scheme.
C
I. B. Perrine's Blue Lakes Ranch was an awesome but favored Idaho site
WE Idaho Yesterdays
GRI
Br
Perrine Recoornized .
Land's Blessing
Both vi
WE
♦6
CJ A
01,
49
By ARTHUR A. HART
Director, Idaho Historical
Museum
Many a pioneer settled
early on some portion of Ida-
ho's richly endowed terrain
without realizing its ultimate
Potential. Even in the case
of those who did, they often
had the luck to be "born too
soon" to capitalize on re-
sources that would only
reach full value many years
later.
Lakes Ranch, he decided Omaha, 1902, at St. Louis,
that this was a spot particu- 1904, and at Portland in 1905.
larly blessed. His Italian prunes won a
gold medal in 1909 at
When the rest of the arid
Snake River plain of South-
ern Idaho was still blanketed
with snow, this sheltered
part of the great basalt can-
yon of the river was receiv-
ing the winter sunshine and
protected from the cold
winds which swept over-
head.
Seattle's Alaska, Yukon and
Pacific Exposition.
Considering Idaho's re-
moteness and small popu-
lation at that time, these
were notable accom-
plishments. That fruit from
the canyon of one of Amer-
ica's ar at riv— sn r—to
Idaho Historical Society photo
Oregon Short Line train makes a stop in Glenns Ferry in 1889
Glenns Ferry owes its start
to Oregon Short Line Railroad
By ARTHUR HART
"Quite a village has already
grown up at Glenn's Ferry on
Snake River,. the outgrowth of
making that place the end of a di-
vision of the ,O.S.L." This item in
The Idaho Statesman of Jan. 18,
1887, reported. the modest growth
the little railroad town had expe-
rienced in its first five years:
"A number of dwelling houses,
two stores, .and three saloons
have already been completed and
other buildings are in process of
erection in addition to the im-
provements- being put up by the
railroad company."
Glenns Ferry is one of many
southern Idaho towns that got its
start with the building of the Ore-
gon Short Line Railroad in 1882-
1883. Its hisfosy goes back consi-
derably farther, however, to a
ferry boat across Snake River
from which it takes its name.
The Glenn " brothers' ferry
operated not, far from Three Is-
land Crossing on the Oregon
Trail, where `thousands of emi-
grants forded, the river in the
1840s and 1850s. When the railroad
came, the name was retained.
G.P. Glenn was operating a
ferry at King Hill in May of 1875
when The Statesman acknowl-
edged a visit "ti -om him. Ferries
were still a necessity for almost
all of Snake River at that time,
for there were, few places narrow
enough to bridge.
Idaho , ?r
Yesterdays`'
(An exception was Matt Tay-
lor's 1865 toll bridge at Eagle
Rock, later Idaho Falls).
Today's photo of an Oregon
Short Line passenger train at
Glenns Ferry was taken in 1889,
just two years after the descrip-
tion of the town quoted above.
It shows an all -male crowd
standing on the station platform
before a board - and - batten build-
ing labeled "Eating House." The
projecting sign over the door
reads "U.P. Dining Room," and
one beyond it says "Ice Cream
and Sherbert (sic)."
Another, just readable behind
the locomotive headlight, says
"Lunch Counter." In the days be-
fore dining cars were regularly
carried by passenger trains, meal
stops like this one were the rule.
Apparently railroad crews were
fed in the separate U.P. dining
room shown in our photo.
In 1892 Glenns Ferry enter-
tained high hopes of becoming
county seat of Elmore County, es-
tablished in 1889 with the old min-
ing camp of Rocky Bar as seat.
An election in 1891 had passed the
honor to Mountain Home, but
Glenns Ferry still had hopes of
getting it changed.
Although railroading was
Glenns Ferry's leading industry,
it had also become the supply cen-
ter for farms and ranches in the
area. A March 4, 1892, account in
The Statesman noted efforts to in-
crease arable land in the neigh-
borhood by developing irrigation.
"Mr. Elmer Davis has nearly
completed a water wheel with a
capacity of 500 gallons per min-
ute."
These big wooden wheels, pow-
ered by river current, lifted water
more than half the height of their
diameter and dumped it into
flumes and ditches for distribu-
tion to fields along the banks. The
ruins of some of them, 30 or more
feet in diameter, can still be seen
along Snake River.
(A later steel water wheel, now
in C.W. Moore Park, demon-
strates just how these historic
water- lifters did their work.)
Other activities in Glenns Ferry
in 1892 included YMCA meetings,
a visit from the Mountain Home
Dramatic Club, and the forming
of a James A. Garfield Republi-
can Club. Glenns Ferry, just 10
years old a century ago, was
"feeling its oats" and optimistic
about its future.
(Arthur Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical Society.)
John Kensler was last seen alive near this uenns Terry gainenng place
By ARTHUR HART
Murder in 19th century Idaho was
an all too common crime, and it
tended to follow common patterns.
Two men who had been drinking
heavily in a saloon got into an argu-
ment, one struck or pushed the other,
knives or guns came into play and
tragedy resulted.
Many times the underlying reason
for the bad blood between such men
could be traced to earlier disputes
over mineral or water rights, but al-
cohol was immediately responsible
for the fatal action. -
A notorious case which occupied,
the attention of Idahoans in late .1896
and 1897 also involved alcohol, but
was even more sensational for inti-
mations of adultery, conspiracy,
murder by poison, murder by shoot-
ing, a faked accident, and a missing
body.
John Kensler, a well known
rancher on King Hill Creek, east of
Glenns Ferry, was seen in Glenns
Ferry on Oct. 16, 1896, with his hired
man Alfred Freel. Both had spent a
loj of their time that day drinking,
and were pretty far gone when they
left town.
When Kensler turned up missing,
his wife, Josie; offered the following
account of what had happened after
he and Freel came . home from
Idaho tom'
Yesterdays
Glenns Ferry the night of Oct. 16.
She said that both men were drunk
and had a quart of whiskey that they
insisted on finishing. After she had
gone to bed, her husband woke her
up to say he was going back to town
to a Silver Republican rally, armed
with a big roll of money, and still
drunk. She told questioners she
feared he had met with an accident
or foul play.
Neighboring ranch hands found
Kensler's wagon, broken to pieces
and scattered along the road, but
found no trace of the missing man.
The indications were that a runa-
way had taken place, but curiously,
the'tea'm was still tied to part of the
wagon, the reins wrapped around a
wheel hub. Although the ground was
soft, there were no indications of
Kensler having been thrown from the
wagon; neither were there any foot
prigts to suggest that he or anyone
else had been walking in the area.
This, and Mrs. Kensler's reputa-
tion as an adulterous woman,
aroused the suspicions of the ranch
hands. Freel, when questioned as to
the night's events, confirmed that
Kensler had headed for town with
about $1,600 which he invited his
hired man to help him spend.
Freel said he had refused and gone
to bed, and that in the morning Mrs.
Kensler had sent him to town to look
for her husband. The neighbors were
really suspicious when Free] admit-
ted he hadn't thought to look in any of
the saloons — the first place you
would expect him to ask, given the
circumstances. Freel said he "for-
got" to look there.
Volunteers continued the search
for the missing rancher while a citi-
zens' committee met with the dis-
trict attorney. When somebody re-
membered that Alfred Free[ had
bought strychnine at a local drug-
store a few days before the dis-
appearance, a complaint was filed
charging Free[ and Mrs. Kensler
with the murder by poisoning of the
missing man. Without a body and
stronger evidence, however, the case
was still a mystery.
In ,the next article; ,we will con-
clude the remarkable story of a
bungled attempt to get away with
murder.
(- Arthbr Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical Society.)
Illicit romance results in murder
When John Kensler turned up
missing on the morning of Oct. 27,
1896, from his ranch near Glenns
Ferry, suspicion quickly turned to
his wife, Josie, and the hired man,
Alfred Freel. Neighbors who knew
Mrs. Kensler considered her to
have been careless of her marriage
vows in the past, and thought she
and Freel were having an illicit ro-
mance.
There was something strange
about the stories the two told about
the events of Kensler's last night at
the ranch, both claiming that he
had started out for town near mid-
night with a large sum of money
and a skin full of whiskey. When it
was recalled that Freel had
purchasedstrychnine a few days
before at a Glenns Ferry drugstore,
.he and Josie Kensler were charged
with poisoning the missing man.
Search parties combed the coun-
tryside looking for any trail of John
Kensler. When the farm hand who
had discovered the missing man's
wrecked wagon recalled that there
was water overflowing a field
where there should have been none
that got his attention in the first
place, the irrigation ditch which
supplied Kensler's ranch became
the center of the search. There had
been no. water in it the night
Kenslerdisappeared. it was full of
water the next morning.
Using a tong iron rod, deputies
probed the muddy bottom every
few feet until they came to a spot
softer than the rest. When they
struck what felt like "a roll of blan-
kets." they dug. They found the
body of John Kensler, in good con-
dition except for a gunshot wound
in the head. The indictment was
changed from murder by poison to
murder by shooting.
Both Josie Kensler and Alfred
aft
Idaho
Yesterdays
Freel now wrote out "confessions,"
each placing all the blame on the
other. Josie said that Freel had
killed her husband and forced her
at gunpoint to help dispose of the
body. Freel's version was that Josie
and a mysterious "masked man"
had forced him at gunpoint to aid in
concealing the crime. He also
quoted Mrs. Kensler as telling him
she had shot her husband herself.
Witnesses at the trial testified
that both Josie and Freel had been
heard to say that they were in love
and would soon have Kensler's
place to themselves. Freel was con-
victed of murder in the first degree,
Mrs. Kensler of murder in the sec-
ond degree. Due to an error in pro-
cedure the two were granted a ret-
rial. This time both were convicted
of murder in the second degree and
sentenced to life imprisonment at
the Idaho Penitentiary in Boise.
Josie Kensler continued in the
limelight, even at the penitentiary.
In 1902, she signed an affidavit ac-
cusing Warden Charles E. Arney
and prison physician J.K. Dubois
with having forced her to submit to
an illegal abortion. Warrants for
their arrest were issued. Mrs.
Kensser said she was five months
pregnant at the time of the alleged
abortion, but refused to name the
father. A convict known to be in
love with Josie was suspected, but
it turned out he had been in solitary
confinement when the alleged con-
ception took place. Mrs. Kensler re-
Josie Kensler
pudiated this first affidavit, clear-
ing Dubois and Arney, but later said
she did it on the promise of a par-
don. She insisted her first charges
had been true, and then suggested
that her lover had been "a peniten-
tiary official" who had visited her
regularly. She never revealed his
name.
On Christmas Day, 1909, Josie
Kensler was pardoned after serving
12 years of her life sentence. Alfred
Freel was pardoned a few months
later.
(Arthur Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical Society.)
BOISE, IDAHO, TUESDAY, MAY 20, 1975
Yhoto
OLD BRIDGE POST OFFICE AE'
... only one with dirt roof in U.S.
Post Office at Bridge
To Shut Down May 31
BRIDGE (AP) — The 96 -year-
old Bridge Post Office, possibly the
only dirt- roofed post office still in serv-
ice in the United States, is being closed
May 31.
Starting June 1, mail will be deliv-
ered via star route carrier instead of
patrons picking up their mail at the
Bridge Post Office. The office serves 10
families. An open house will be held
Sunday to provide people a final oppor-
tunity to visit in the facilities.
The office is near Idaho 81 about 50
miles southeast of Burley.
Announcement that the building would
close was made last week by Max Han-
sen, customer service director at the
Boise Post Office. Hansen said the de-
cision came after the clerk in charge of
the Bridge facility, Florence Barnes,
advised that commitments at home
u ill not allow her time to operate the
office.
Mrs. Barnes lives in the Standrod
community 14 miles southwest of
Bridge. She said Monday no one else
was interested in being the clerk, lead-
ing to the decision to close the office.
The facility is on land owned by
Frank Olson, who was postmaster at
Bridge until his retirement.
Nonetheless, Bridge has its own zip
code, 83315.
14
d
s
s
Idaho Yesterdays
=� Old Buildings Give
Shoshone Charm
By ARTHUR A. HART
Director, Idaho
Historical Museum
Shoshone's building boom
of 1902 continued for several
years thereafter, leaving a
number of prominent land-
marks which can still be
seen. The character of the
town remains, happily,
slightly old- fashioned and
charming, largely due to
these early buildings.
One result of Shoshone's
frontier Western style was
her designation earlier this
year as an historic district
by the National Register of
Historic Places. Another was
her selection by Disney stu-
dios as the setting for a mov-
ie being filmed right now.
Shoshone is on the verge
of the discovery that historic
architecture has economic
value, and that its preserva-
tion and restoration can be-
come the basis for a viable
future.
In addition to the Episco-
pal Church finished in 1902,
Fred Gooding erected a
handsome new house from
designs of Walter S. Camp-
bell of Boise (architect of
the Idanha), and the Odd
Fellows and Knights of
Pvthias collaborated on a
two-story stone "opera
house."
1903 saw the building of W.
C. Custer's meat market, a
commercial block by the
Gooding brothers, and the
letting of the contract for the
new Lincoln County court-
house. 0. J. Brennan was
the successful bidder at
$17,100 on May 20, 1903.
The courthouse was dedi-
cated on the Fourth of July,
1904, and within a few weeks
the Methodists were stirring
up interest in building a new
stone church nearby.
Shoshone's most con-
spicuous building material,
the black lava rock found ev-
erywhere, was to be used for
most of the building. Upper
walls and the steeple were to
be sheathed in fancy cut
shingles.
The Shoshone Journal sup-
ported the project, saying
that "the old church building
is an unsightly shell at best,
and for that reason alone
Shoshone citizens ought to
stand ready to assist in the
building of a new church."
There is a local legend
about Shoshone's Methodist
Church which repeats al-
most exactly what we have
heard of other places: "The
stone mason worked for a
pint of whisky a day, which
is why the walls are
crooked." Who knows, this
may even be true of some
buildings of which the tale is
told.
By December, 1904, the
church was closed in and
ready for the plasterers. On
August 13, 1905, Dr. T. C. II-
7
iff, secretary of the Method-
ist Episcopal Church "Ex-
tension Society" officiated at
the dedication of what is still
one of Southern Idaho's most
charming and picturesque
small churches.
The Baptist Church also
was upgraded at about the
same time. It received a
baptistry, new interior paint
and paper, and electric
lights.
Meanwhile, the business
blocks fronting the railroad
tracks were undergoing a
number of additions and im-
provements. The Oregon
Short Line Railroad tore
down its old ice house and
built a new one (ice was still
harvested from ponds in
winter and held over until
summer in insulated build-
ings); Keefer and White
built a new warehouse in the
rear of their store; Dr. W.
H. Baugh tore down some
older buildings, moved one,
and commenced a big new
business block (still stand -'
ing); and C. F. Borden built
some carriage sheds and a
storeroom for lumber.
On the north side of the
railroad stood two pictu-
resque hotels which still give
a considerable amount of
style and character to old
Shoshone. They are the
McFall House and the Co-
lumbia (now Shoshone) Ho-
tel.
One is shingled in a pictu-
resque Queen Anne style and
is soon to be restored. The
other is notable for its metal
cornice in imitation of classi-
cal stonework.
Without either of them,
and others like them, Sho-
shone just wouldn't be Sho-
shone.
-4 The Lincoln County Cot
farming, iargery cue to
hese early buildings.
One result of Shoshone's
ontier Western style was
er designation earlier this
rear as an historic district
?y the National Register of
Historic Places. Another was
ter selection by Disney stu-
ios as the setting for a mov-
being filmed right now.
Shoshone is on the verge
of the discovery that historic
architecture has economic
value, and that its preserva-
tion and restoration can be-
come the basis for a viable
future.
' In addition to the Episco-
pal Church finished in 1902,
Fred Gooding erected a
handsome new house from
designs of Walter S. Camp-
bell of Boise (architect of
the Idanha), and the Odd
Fellows and Knights of
Pythias collaborated on a
two-story stone "opera
house."
1903 saw the building of W.
C. Custer's meat market, a
commercial block by the
Gooding brothers, and the
>. s
J Shoshone's most con-
spicuous building material,
the black lava rock found ev-
erywhere, was to be used for
most of the building. Upper
walls and the steeple were to
be sheathed in fancy cut
shingles.
The Shoshone Journal sup-
ported the project, saying
that "the old church building
is an unsightly shell at best,
and for that reason alone
Shoshone citizens ought to
stand ready to assist in the
building of a new church."
There is a local legend
about Shoshone's Methodist
Church which repeats al-
most exactly what we have
heard of other places: "The
stone mason worked for a
pint of whisky a day, which
is why the walls are
crooked." Who knows, this
may even be true of some
buildings of which the tale is
told.
By December, 1904, the
church was closed in and
ready for the plasterers. On
August 13, 1905, Dr. T. C. Il-
Meanwhile, the business
blocks fronting the railroad
tracks were undergoing a
number of additions and im-
provements. The Oregon
Short Line Railroad tore
down its old ice house and
built a new one (ice was still
harvested from ponds in
winter and held over until
summer in insulated build-
ings); Keefer and White
built a new warehouse in the
rear of their store; Dr. W.
H. Baugh tore down some
older buildings, moved one,
and commenced a big new
business block (still stand-
ing); and C. F. Borden built
some carriage sheds and a
storeroom for lumber.
On the north side of the
railroad stood two pictu-
resque hotels which still give
a considerable amount of
style and character to old
Shoshone. They are the
McFall House and the Co-
lumbia (now Shoshone) Ho-
tel.
One is shingled in a pictu-
resque Queen Anne style and
is soon to be restored. The
other is notable for its metal
cornice in imitation of classi-
cal stonework.
Without either of them,
and others like them, Sho•
shone just wouldn't be Sho-
shone.
T Shoshone's 1904 Methodist church is mostly lava rock
The Lincoln County Courthouse
Werdays
t Buildings Give
shone Charm
letting of the contract for the
new Lincoln County court-
house. O. J. Brennan was
the successful bidder at
$17,100 on May 20, 1903.
The courthouse was dedi-
cated on the Fourth of July,
1904, and within a few weeks
the Methodists were stirring
up interest in building a new
stone church nearby.
Shoshone's most con-
spicuous building material,
the black lava rock found ev•
erywhere, was to be used for
most of the building. Upper
walls and the steeple were to
be sheathed in fancy cut
shingles.
The Shoshone Journal sup-
ported the project, saying
that "the old church building
is an unsightly shell at best,
and for that reason alone
Shoshone citizens ought to
stand ready to assist in the
)uilding of a new church.,,
There is a local legend
about Shoshone's Methodist
-hurch which repeats al-
'nost exactly what we have
heard of other places: "The
;tone mason worked for a
)int of whisky a day, which
s why the walls are
:rooked." Who knows, this
nay even be true of some
Buildings of which the tale is
old.
By December, 1904, the
church was closed in and
eady for the plasterers. On
august 13, 1905, Dr. T. C. II-
iff, secretary of the Method.
ist Episcopal Church "Ex.
tension Society" officiated at
the dedication of what is still
one of Southern Idaho's most
charming and picturesque
small churches.
The Baptist Church also
was upgraded at about the
same time. It received a
baptistry, new interior paint
and paper, and electric
lights.
Meanwhile, the business
blocks fronting the railroad
tracks were undergoing a
number of additions and im-
provements. The Oregon
Short Line Railroad tore
down its old ice house and
built a new one (ice was still
harvested from ponds in
winter and held over until
summer in insulated build-
ings); Keefer and White
built a new warehouse in the
rear of their store; Dr. W.
H. Baugh tore down some
older buildings, moved one,
and commenced a big new
business block (still stand-
ing); and C. F. Borden built
some carriage sheds and a
storeroom for lumber.
On the north side of the
railroad stood two pictu.
resque hotels which still give
a considerable amount of
style and character to old
Shoshone. They are the
McFall House and the Co-
lumbia (now Shoshone) Ho.
tel.
One is shingled in a pictu.
resque Queen Anne style and
is soon to be restored. The
other is notable for its metal
cornice in imitation of classi-
cal stonework.
Without either of them,
and others like them, Sho.
The Lincoln County Courthouse in Shoshone was 71 years old on July 4th
New town of Gooding was served by the Idaho Southern Railroad
The story of Gooding forms
remarkable chapter in history
The creation of small towns and
cities in south - central Idaho in the
decade after 1900, where only lone-
some sagebrush plains had existed
before, is a remarkable chapter in
our state's history. As dramatic as
any part of it is the story of Gooding.
On Nov. 1, 1907, Gov. Frank R.
Gooding founded the little town that
bore his name. In partnership with
M. Mattson he opened the Gooding
Merchantile Co., the first store in the
new location; and on February 4,
1909, a first -class brick hotel, known
as the Lincoln Inn was opened for bu-
siness.
Gooding was in Lincoln County
when it was founded, but in January
1913, the Legislature created the new
counties of Gooding, Minidoka,
Franklin, and Power. The town of
Gooding was made county seat of
Gooding County.
In 1907 a state school for the deaf,
mute and blind was established in the
old Central School in Boise. The state
had acquired the building in prepara-
tion for - construction of a new Capitol
in 1905. In 1908 a fire damaged old
Central and a permanent location for
the school was sought. The state
school for the deaf, mute and blind
Idaho
Yesterdays
By Arthur Hart
r
was located in Gooding in 1910.
The new town of Gooding, befitting
its 20th century founding, was
equipped with electric lights and
power, a good water system and rail-
road service from the beginning. By
1910 the population had reached 1,444.
A number of large brick commercial
blocks were built, in addition to the
hotel, and there were soon three
banks, a weekly newspaper, a pack-
ing plant, a hospital, five churches
and a high school.
The Idaho Southern Railroad, an
affiliate of the Oregon Shore Line in
the Union Pacific system, had just
begun running to Gooding when the
picture shown today was made.
Gooding's railway station was only
a tar -paper shack, and the platform
for loading and unloading goods was
without a cover. A combination pas-
senger and baggage car stands on
the siding where a local transfer
wagon has just loaded some barrels.
Gooding's Chamber of Commerce
was proud of the fact that the town
was in the geographical center of a
million acres of irrigated crop land.
Like all such booster groups every-
where, it dreamed of Gooding be-
coming a big city.
Fortunately, perhaps, the growth
was steady rather than spectacular,
and Gooding County today still has
the traditional resources that gave it
birth. The water of Big Wood River
remains the basis for a rich irrigated
agriculture and a thriving livestock
industry.
Gooding also had the distinction of
its own college for nearly a genera-
tion. In 1911 Idaho Methodists de-
cided to start a school of higher edu-
cation. In November, 1917, the first
classes were held at Gooding Col-
lege. Its offerings were suited to
young people who would remain in
an agricultural community, and the
students were able to work to help
operate the college. Gooding College
closed in 1938.
(Arthur Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical Society.)
Emigrants were attacked by Indians near this scene at the City of Rocks
Massacre legend seems overblown
The popular legend that a party
of 300 emigrants passing through
the City of Rocks was massacred
by Indians appears exaggerated,
to say the least. The disaster to
this train of 60 wagons is supposed
to have happened at Almo Creek in
1861, near the present town of
Almo, Idaho.
In order to believe that this hor-
rendous event actually happened,
it is necessary to believe that no-
body at the time thought it worth
reporting to the newspapers. Con-
sidering the great number of news-
paper accounts of Indian "massa-
cres" in the same neighborhood at
Idaho
Yesterdays ;
By Arthur
that time, it is hard to believe this
one was overlooked. The question
is not so much "was there an Almo
massacre ?" but which of several
incidents got blown into the leg-
endary death of 300.
Because Salt Lake City was the
nearest population center to the
area, and because many emigrant
parties passed through there be-
fore or after the City of Rocks part
of their journey, any Indian trou-
bles were reported in some detail
in Salt Lake papers. Here is a sum-
mary from newspaper accounts of
1860 -62:
Deseret News, Oct. 3, 1860: 7
men, 5 women, and "about half a
dozen children," enroute from Il-
linois to California, were shot at in
the night while camped near City
of Rocks. The women and children
tried to walk back to get help from
soldiers near old Fort Hall. The
men tried to protect the wagons
and livestock. In spite of this reck-
less strategy, the women and chil-
dren luckily escaped, but the
wagons were plundered. Except
for hunger, thirst and terror, there
were no casualties to any of the
emigrants or to the soldiers who
eventually came to the rescue. The
emigrants did, however, lose
nearly all of their possessions.
"How many more small strag-
gling companies of emigrants, pas-
sing over that route late in the sea-
son, will be used up before it be-
comes generally known that they
cannot travel safely in that man-
ner, is not known," commented the
Deseret News.
This may have warned emi-
grants in 1861 to be more careful,
because there were no reports of
serious Indian attacks that season.
In August, 1862, however, there
were a series of incidents reported
in papers from Salt Lake City to
Sacramento. There were skir-
mishes reported near Massacre
Rocks, August 9 and 10, and four
Indian attacks at City of Rocks on
August 3, 6, 8, and 9.
The first party lost 50 head of
stock, but suffered only 2 wounded.
The second party, 7 packers from
Willamette Valley who had been to
the Salmon River country, had one
man killed. The third group to be
attacked, as reported by survivor
L. F. Yates, lost 5 men killed out of
40. Yates attributed the death of
the 5 to the cowardice of the others
who refused to go to their aid. The
fourth party, ambushed in August,
1862, was from Iowa. They lost 46
head of stock, but suffered only
two flesh wounds to their people.
A September attack turned out
to have cost the lives of two men,
although first reports to reach Salt
Lake claimed "about half' of 15
were killed, then 6, and finally only
2 confirmed.
By totaling the number of re-
ported deaths in the series of
"Almo massacres" between Sep-
tember, 1860, and September, 1862,
it turns out that only 8 people were
killed. Since all of these reports
were either second -hand or from
survivors who had escaped while
the attacks were still in progress,
it is possible that even 8 is an exag-
geration.
In retaliation for the attacks on
emigrants in the City of Rocks vi-
cinity, a military expedition led by
Major Edward McGarry killed 24
Indians in the area in October,
1862.
(Arthur Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical Society.)
OF
10 &"0 it-40 P4 r wew i F P. M rair• A WA ru 4 1 t R Y01 y OV 9 V M
r
ac
OF
10 &"0 it-40 P4 r wew i F P. M rair• A WA ru 4 1 t R Y01 y OV 9 V M
r
Parking seems to be a problem on a 1920 afternoon in Twin Falls
Pioneer photographer showed
development of Twin Falls
By ARTHUR HART
A selection from the remarka-
ble Bisbee collection of early
Twin Falls photographs was given
national exposure last year
through their publication in
American Heritage magazine.
Clarence E. Bisbee was the pio-
neer photographer of the new
Twin Falls tract, opened to settle-
ment in 1904.
Using a large view camera and
8 -by -10 -inch glass -plate negatives
that he prepared himself, Bisbee
recorded, with a keen eye, fine
pictorial sense and meticulous
craftsmanship, the development
of a town in the midst of a sage-
brush desert.
As Twin Falls grew, the artistic
Bisbee must have been a common
sight to his neighbors.
His camera and tripod were on
hand on every historic occasion,
from the arrival of the electric
railway car (pictured last week)
to cornerstone layings at the new
high school and Methodist church,
to a speech by William Jennings
Bryan at the Perrine Hotel.
Because he had a good eye for
interesting subjects, Clarence
Bisbee recorded, as few other
Idaho photographers ever have,
the life of his times in a signifi-
cant and comprehensive way.
When his shutter clicked, a par-
Idaho tom'
Yesterdays
ticular moment in the history of a
community was captured for all
time to come, in meticulous de-
tail.
Although hundreds of the nearly
2,000 Bisbee negatives in the col-
lection of the Twin Falls County
Historical Society illustrate the
Bisbee gift for capturing the mo-
ment, a few are of such excep-
tional interest that they can be
studied for a long time with profit.
The street scene reproduced
today is such a picture.
From a vantage point about 12
feet above the sidewalk, possibly
from another fire escape balcony
like the one at left, the photo-
grapher shows us a view of the
corner of Shoshone and Main
streets in 1920.
With the aid of a magnifying
glass, much of the minute detail
in the original print is visible, al-
though it may be elusive in a
newspaper reproduction.
The license plates of the cars at
right give us the date of the photo-
graph.
Antique car buffs will recognize
in the row nearest at hand six
Model T Fords, two Buicks, a
Maxwell and a Franklin. Most are
splattered with mud — evidence
of the unpaved roads then preva-
lent in Idaho.
Two women, pushing baby, car-
riages in opposite directions,
pause to speak to each other on
the sidewalk at center. A man
standing by the barber pole
nearby looks toward the corner
where about 20 people are con-
gregated.
At least two other baby car-
riages are being wheeled across
the street at the intersection.
Hunt's jewelry store clock tells us
the time was 3:57 p.m.
Since everyone looks dressed
up, and so many cars crowd the
streets, it may have been a Satur-
day afternoon — the usual shop-
ping day in farm communities
like Twin Falls.
Signs at left advertise a loan
company, the Western Union
Telegraph office, a real estate
broker and two drugstores.
Things were bustling in Twin
Falls that day in 1920. Thanks to a
skilled photographer, we can be
there too, even 62 years later.
Arthur Hart is the director of
the Idaho Historical Society.
The `Silent City of Rocks' awed pioneers bound for California during the 1800s
City of Rocks features ancient twins
Did you know that Idaho has
twin sisters, one of which is more
than 2 billion years older than the
other? Only in the realm of geol-
ogy could such a riddle be posed,
and there is only one place in Idaho
Where the rocks are old enough to
give us the answer.
City of Rocks, in Cassia County,
is the home of Idaho's Twin Sis-
ters. These two granite towers are
over 600 feet tall. The "young" sis-
ter is a mere 25 million years old;
the "old" one is 21/2 billion years
old. There are only a few places in
the United States where Precam-
brian rock is exposed, but one can-
not equal in grandeur and variety
the City of Rocks.
As impressive as the geological
features of the City of Rocks are,
its psychological effect on human
beings is equally notable. Even
professional geologists, writing in
government reports, have been
moved to extravagance in their ad-
jectives. "Awesome," "curious,"
"bizarre" and "quaint" dot their
pages as they seek to do justice to
a marvel of nature.
Comprising an area of roughly 20
Idaho
Yesterdays,,,
By Arthur Hart
square miles, the City of Rocks is
fenced in by higher mountains and
ridges in such a way that it seems
a special hidden place. The north-
east entrance is only 50 yards
wide, the southwest one only 20
yards wide.
Through this strange and re-
markable landscape passed almost
a quarter of a million emigrants on
the California Trail in a little more
than a decade. Between 1849 and
1860 alone, 200,000 made the pas-
sage through what they called
"City of Castles," or "Silent City of
Rocks." Their diaries described
this short part of the way west in
some detail, and they amused
themselves by naming the strange
rock formations' as they slowly
moved through. "Napoleon's
Castle" and "City Hotel" were
even labeled by the emigrants with
letters in tar. Other formations
looked like elephants,. birds,
dragons, toadstools and, as one di-
arist put it, "Anything from the
Capitol at Washington to a lovely
thatched cottage."
In 1852, the peak year of the rush
to California, at least 52,000 people
made the passage through Idaho's
City of Rocks, (even though the
name Idaho hadn't been invented
yet). They had many adventures
and saw thousands of miles of new
country, but if the diaries are an
indication, City of Rocks was a
high point never forgotten.
Inevitably a forklore about C1iy
of Rocks has grown up, one that
historians are unable to either ver-
ify or disprove. One of these deals
with a purported massacre at
Almo Creek in 1861 in which a train
of 60 wagons with 300 people was
wiped out by Bannock Indians led
by Pocatello. A National Park Ser-
vice historian says that although
probably much exaggerated, if this
massacre did take place it would
have been the greatest disaster on
the California Trail for whites and
one of the greatest victories any-
where for the Indians.
Another legend, which is a famil-
iar one in all parts of Idaho, is that
stagecoach robbers buried $90,000
in gold near a place called Treas-
ure Rock in 1888. There are almost
as many legends of buried stage-
coach loot in Idaho as there were
robberies, and there were a lot.
The real treasure, little changed
since 1842 when Joseph B. Chiles
pioneered the route, is the silent
city itself, a wonder of nature.at*d
a landmark on the historic forty -
niners' trail to California.
(Arthur Hart is director of the
Idaho Historical Society.)
The `Silent City of Rocks' awed pioneers bound for California during the 18O0s
City of Rocks feature-s- ancient twins
Did you know that Idaho has
twin sisters, one of which is more
than 2 billion years older than the
other? Only in the realm of geol-
ogy could such a riddle be posed,
and there is only one place in Idaho
where the rocks are old enough to
give us the answer.
City of Rocks, in Cassia County,
is the home of Idaho's Twin Sis-
Idaho
a
Yesterdays
By Arthur Hart t,
i
square miles, the City of Rocks is
fenced in by higher mountains and
letters in tar. Other formations
looked like elephants,. birds,
dragons, toadstools and, as one di-
arist put it, "Anything from the
Capitol at Washington to a lovely
thatched cottage."
In 1852, the peak year of the rush
to California, at least 52,000 people
made the passage through Idaho's
City of Rocks, (even though the
where for the Indians.
Another legend, which is a famil-
iar one in all parts of Idaho, is that
stagecoach robbers buried $90,000
in gold near a place called Treas-
ure Rock in 1888. There are almost
as many legends of buried stage-
coach loot in Idaho as there were
robberies, and there were a lot.
The real treasure, little changed
S h o s h o n e F a l l s c h r o n o l o g y -
T h e f i r s t w h i t e m e n t o s e e i t w e r e a f r a i d o f i t 1 8 1 1 .
T h e f i r s t m a n t o g i v e i t a n a m e s a i d i t w a s "