Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout2020-03-10 packetNOTICE OF REGULAR MEETING AND TENTATIVE AGENDA` City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Tuesday, March 10, 2020 — 6:00 p.m. John G. Christy Municipal Building, 320 East McCarty Street City Council Chambers TENTATIVE AGENDA 1. Introductions and Roll Call 2. Procedural Matters • Determination of quorum • Call for cases • Receive and review requests for continuance • Receive requests for reordering the agenda • Format of hearing • List of exhibits 3. Adoption of Agenda (as printed or reordered) 4. Approval of February 11, 2020 Regular Meeting Minutes 5. Communications Received 6. Demolition Clearance Public Hearing -Over 100 Years Old a. 418 Case Avenue 7. Demolition Clearance Review -Under 100 Years Old a. 411 Case Avenue b. 407 Union Street 8. Old Business a. Call for Landmark Applications b. Preservation Month Activities 9. New Business a. Gregory Stockard Award b. Landmark Award(s) 10. Other Business a. Dangerous Building Determinations 11. Dates to Remember a. Next Regular Meeting Date, April 14, 2020 b. West Main Survey Public Meeting, April 16, 2020 C. Certified Local Government Forum, April 24, 2020 12. Adjournment Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. Please call 573-634-6410 for information regarding agenda items City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Minutes Regular Meeting — Tuesday, February 11, 2020 Council Chambers — John G. Christy Municipal Building 320 E. McCarty Street Commission Members Present Donna Deetz, Vice Chairperson Steven Hoffman Brad Schaefer Mary Schantz, Chairperson Gail Jones Commission Members Absent Gregory Bemboom Alan Wheat Michael Berendzen Council Liaison Present Laura Ward Staff Present Jayme Abbott, Neighborhood Services Manager Rachel Senzee, Neighborhood Services Specialist Anne Stratman, Neighborhood Services Specialist Bryan Wolford, Associate City Counselor Call to Order Mary Schantz called the meeting to order at 6:06 p.m. Attendance Record 2 of 2 2 of 2 2 of 2 2 of 2 1 of 2 Attendance Record 1 of 2 1 of 2 0 of 2 Adoption of Agenda Ms. Jones moved and Ms. Deetz seconded to adopt the agenda as printed. The motion passed unanimously. Approval of Minutes Ms. Deetz moved and Ms. Jones seconded to approve the minutes from the January 14, 2020 Regular Meeting as written. The motion passed unanimously. Communication Received Ms. Senzee stated that no communications have been received. Demolition Clearance Public Hearing -Over 100 Years Old Ms. Senzee explained that 408 Case Avenue is under consideration for demolition clearance and is owned by the Jefferson City School District. The Historic Southside/Old Munichburg District & Neighborhood Plan identifies this property as future redevelopment land use, presumably for Capital Region Medical Center and Jefferson City High School expansion. In addition, the May 2019 tornado significantly damaged and/or destroyed this property. Any local significance to this working class neighborhood is no longer intact. This property no longer exemplifies the cultural, economic, social or historic heritage of the city. Staff recommendation for this property is demolition. Mr. Frank Underwood, Director of Facilities for Jefferson City Public Schools resides at 220 Partridge Lane, Holts Summit, Missouri. He explained that Jefferson City High School is landlocked and the purpose of acquiring this property is to further expand their sports facilities. Ms. Deetz moved and Ms. Jones seconded to approve the demolition clearance application for 408 Case Avenue. The motion passed unanimously. Demolition Clearance Review -Under 100 Years Old Ms. Senzee explained that the following properties under consideration for demolition review are owned by the Jefferson City School District: 409 Union Street; 417 Oberman Place; and 418 Oberman Place. The Historic Southside/Old Munichburg District & Neighborhood Plan identifies these properties as future redevelopment land use, presumably for Capital Region Medical Center and Jefferson City High School expansion. In addition, the May 2019 tornado significantly damaged and/or destroyed these properties. These properties do not hold stand-alone historical significance in terms of heritage, cultural or architecturally. Staff recommendation for these properties is demolition. Ms. Jones moved and Mr. Hoffman seconded to approve the demolition review application for the aforementioned properties. The motion passed unanimously. Section 106 Reviews A. 98 S. Lincoln Street Ms. Senzee explained that the homeowner has been approved to participate in the CDBG Minor Home Repair Program. The proposed project is repair or replacement of the roof covering. The rear yard appears to have erosion in the northwest corner. It is recommended to consult the Stormwater Engineer for erosion control ideas and possible solutions. The residential structure was constructed in 1970 and is not listed individually on the register or within a historic district. Staff recommends approval of the Section 106 Review as not historic properties are affected. Ms. Deetz moved and Ms. Jones seconded to approve the Section 106 review. The motion passed unanimously. B. 805 Monroe Street Ms. Senzee explained that 805 Monroe Street is undergoing the Section 106 process due to its potential to utilize Community Development Block Grant funds to demolish the structure. It is currently owned by the City of Jefferson and was constructed around 1900. The property has been vacant for several years. Ms. Deetz moved and Ms. Jones seconded to approve the Section 106 review. The motion passed unanimously. Old Business A. Call for Landmark Applications Ms. Senzee explained that applications are due February 28. The Commission will review the applications at their March 10 meeting. The City Council will designate awardees at their March or April meeting. The awards will be presented to property owners during Preservation Month. B. Preservation Month Activities Ms. Deetz reported that she met with Mr. Hoffman and discussed an historic scavenger hunt. Photos will be placed in the News Tribune and participants will have to correctly identify the photos. The participants will submit the form and the correct submissions will be put in a drawing for prizes. Ms. Deetz stated that the Convention and Visitors Bureau will promote this activity on their website. The Commission discussed tabling discussion on additional activities to the March 10, 2020 meeting. Other Business A. Dangerous Building Determinations Ms. Senzee stated that the properties located at 430 E. Dunklin Street and 516 E. Dunklin Street have been determined as dangerous by the Building Official. These properties were impacted by the May 22, 2019 EF-3 tornado. B. Ms. Deetz reported that Habitat for Humanity will be building four homes on Jackson Street. The front of the houses has been re -designed by Doug Record so that the front porch will be historically correct for the neighborhood. Midwest Block and Brick will donate the brick for the front and two sides of the home. This will enable Habitat for Humanity to keep the costs of the homes as lows as possible. C. Ms. Deetz reported on the Main Street Connection Conference held in Jefferson City last week. She explained that as part of the Historic Preservation Plan Main Street Connection recommended as one of the goals to revitalize and assist the historic preservation of the commercial districts. The commercial districts are the downtown area, the east side, Old Munichburg, and Dunklin Street. She stated that Main Street Connection is a nonprofit organization that assists with these activities. Dates to Remember A. Next Regular Meeting Date, March 10, 2020 B. Certified Local Government Forum, April 24, 2020 Ms. Schantz encouraged Commission members to attend. She has attended the CLG Forum in past years and have found it beneficial. Ms. Senzee will send information to Commission members that will include a registration form and a request for topics. Adjournment Ms. Deetz moved and Mr. Hoffman seconded to adjourn the meeting at 6:53 p.m. The motion passed unanimously. DEMOLITION CLEARANCE APPLICATION 418 Case Avenue riistoric Preservation commission Demolition Clearance Application for 418 Case Avenue Meeting Date: March 10, 2020 Motion: Approve the Demolition Clearance Application for 418 Case Avenue Eligible to Vote Aye Nay Abstain Commissioner Present Absent Gregory Bemboom Donna Deetz, Vice Chair Steven Hoffman Gail Jones Brad Schafer Mary Schantz, Chair Alan Wheat Michael Berendzen Tie Votes: Chair Votes I certify the foregoing is a correct record of the Commissioners' presence and votes. Mary Schantz Chairperson Attest Anne Stratman City of Jefferson Department of Planning & Protective Services 320 E. McCarty St Jefferson City, MO 65101 Phone:573-634-6410 icpla nnine@ ieffcitymo.ore www.leffersoncitymo.gov APPLICATION FOR DEMOLITION REVIEW/CLEARANCE TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION in accordance with Section 8-43 of the City Code Property Owner(s): Email Address: Phone Number: Property Address: Jefferson City School District frank. underwood@jcschools. us 573-659-1190 418 Case Ave. Jefferson City MO 65101 Date of Construction: 1920 1. The undersigned hereby request(s): Demolition Review (Application fee $55.00) — For properties that meet the following criteria: • Structure(s) age 50-99 years old; or • Structure(s) listed on the National Register of Historic Places: or • Structure(s) designated as a Local Landmark. ✓ Demolition Clearance (Application fee $108.00) — For properties that meet the following criteria: • Structure(s) age 100+years old; or • Structure located within local historic district. 2. The application is filed for the following described real estate: A. Current address:.418 Case Ave. Jefferson city, Mo 65101 B. In 1969, the City updated their addressing system. Did this property have a different address prior to 1969? Yes ✓ No if so, what was it? C. Number of structures to be demolished: D. Local Historic District E. Landmark Designation Name: F. National Register Name: G. Recent uses: H. Structure Vacant? Yes ✓ No If yes, for how long? 3. Will any architectural features and/or fixtures be preserved, donated or recycled? Yes ✓ No If so, explain: Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. 4. Digital photos are required to be submitted electronically as part of the application. Photos must have been taken within the last 90 days of all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. Photographs must show all areas and characteristics of the structure, not just those areas in disrepair. if multiple structures or addresses, the photos must be labeled to distinguish between structures. Photos submitted via USB Drive CD Dropbox Other Criteria Review: 1. Base on research of the property or to the best of your knowledge, is the property: a. Associated with history of the City of Jefferson, Cole County, State of Missouri or the nation? Yes ✓ I No Explain: b. Associated with persons of significance in the history of City of Jefferson, Cole County, State of Missouri or the nation? Yes ✓ No Explain: c. A representation of particular type, design, period or method of construction (i.e. bungalow, four square, etc.)? Yes No Explain: d. Represents the work of a master designer or architect or possesses high architectural value. Yes ✓ No Unknown e. An example of cultural, political, economic, social or historic heritage of the city? Yes ✓ No Unknown f. Contains elements of design, detail, material or craftsmanship which represent a significant construction innovation. Yes ✓ No Unknown g. It is part of or related to a square, park or other distinctive area that was or should be developed or preserved according to a plan based on a historic or architectural motif. Yes ✓ No Note: Here is an example of architectural motif h. It is an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood or of the entire community. Yes ✓ No Unknown I. It has yielded, or is likely to yield archeological artifacts and/or information. Yes ✓ No 2. Will the demolition be detrimental to: a. The visual or spatial relationships to designated landmarks, National Register Sites, or the streetscape of a local historic district or National Register District. Yes ✓ No Unknown b. The architectural, cultural, historic or contextual character of property designated as a local historic landmark, local historic district, or building or area listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Yes ✓ No Unknown 3. Why can't the property be rehabilitated or restored with reasonable economical return? Attach additional pages if necessary. TOFnade damage. CERTIFICATION: I hereby certify that I am the owner of the named property, or that the requested Demolition Review/Clearance is authorized by the owner of record and I have been authorized by the owner to make this application as his/her agent. Signature: Please check: Property Owner Authorized Agent Licensed Contractor Other DEMOLITION PROCEDURES: Chapter 8, Article IV, Section 8-43 Applications to demolish or remove a structure that meet one or more of the following criteria are subject to application requirements, regulations and review by the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Review: • Structures greater than 50 years old. • Structures designated as a Local Landmark. • Structures listed on the National Register or located within a National Register District. The Building Regulations Division will not issue a demolition permit until the Historic Preservation Commission has approved the Demolition Review Application or the expiration of the 75 day review period, whichever occurs first. The approval of application is valid for one year from date of approval by the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Clearance: • Structure greaterthan 100years old. • Structure located within a Local Historic District. Demolition Clearance applications requires a public hearing in accordance with Section 8-47 of the City Code; which is determined by the date of submittal of completed application. Approximately 10-15 days prior to the public hearing, the property will be posted with sign in the yard notifying the public of the date and time of the public hearing. The Historic Preservation Commission may request information regarding the state of deterioration or disrepair or structural unsoundness of the structure, and the practicability of rehabilitation. In addition, plans for the preservation or salvage of notable historic or architectural features and historic fixtures. Appeal. Demolition Clearance Applications denied by the Historic Preservation Commission may be appealed to the City Council. A written request for appeal to the City Council must be submitted to the Neighborhood Services Division within 30 days of notice to applicant of the Historic Preservation Commission decision. Conditions. The Historic Preservation Commission or City Council may impose conditions on the approval of a Demolition Clearance Application that may include, but not limited to: a. Salvage or preserve notable historic or architectural features or historic fixtures that contributed to the finding of a notable structure. b. Structure found to be a notable structure and approved for demolition clearance is properly documented for posterity. c. Partial demolition of a structure found to be notable structure does not result in establishment of an exterior finish that is out of character with the structure. d. Other conditions that the Historic Preservation Commission or City Council may deem appropriate to reduce the impact of the demolition with respect to the applicable review criteria. The Building Regulations Division will not issue a demolition permit until the Historic Preservation Commission has approved the Demolition Clearance Application. The approval of application is valid for one year from date of approval by the Historic Preservation Commission or by City Council, as applicable. Demolition Application Tips: 1. Photos —Digital photos are required to be submitted as part of the application. Photos must have been taken within the past 90 days at the time of the application. a. Photos must include all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. b. Photos must show all areas and characteristics of the structure, not just those areas in disrepair. c. If multiple structures or addresses, the photos must be labeled to distinguish between structures. 2. Research —Simple check of the following websites and documents will aid answering questions within the demolition application regarding the structure. a. National Register Listings - https://dnr.mo.gov/shi3o/cole.htm b. Landmark Designation Listings - www.leffersoncitymo.gov/live play/history heritage/landmark awards -phi) c. Land and property records —original abstracts for the property holds information on construction date, designer or architect, who originally owned the property, profession, and associated information. If the original abstract is not available a simple deed or title search can tell you who previously owned the property. d. Look up local census data —Census records can provide information about the lives of the previous owners, like the number of children, cost of home, and more. e. City Directory — A precursor to the modern phone book, offers more details on previous occupants. Missouri River Regional Library has City Directories for Jefferson City in the Genealogy Section. f. Sanborn Map —The Sanborn Map Company was a publisher of detailed maps of US cities. Maps were originally created for fire insurance companies. https•//dl mospace umsystem edu/mu/isiandora/object/mu%3A138834 3. Attendance - It's strongly encouraged to attend the Historic Preservation Commission meeting for when the demolition application is reviewed. The Commission may have questions regarding the application. A staff report will be presented based on Review Criteria as outlined in Section 8-43 (F) of City Code. 4. Public Hearing —As part of a Demolition Clearance Application process includes a public hearing before the Historic Preservation Commission. The format of the hearing is as follows: • After introduction of the application (request) by city staff, the applicant or their consultants will provide information on the request. The opening presentation by the applicant is limited to 10 minutes unless additional time is granted by the Commission. • The Commission will then ask to hear from supporters of the request. • The Commission will then ask to hear from opponents of the request. • The Commission will then ask to hear from anyone else who wishes to speak on the request. • Testimony is limited to 3 minutes each unless additional time is granted by the Commission. • City staff will then make their recommendations on the request. In order to reduce the time necessary to hear an application, reference to printed material, including staff reports and applicable findings, is not be read into the record unless directed by the Commission. • The Commission will close testimony from the floor. • The Commission will then discuss the proposal, and then publicly make its determination with reasons. Print Preview Page 1 of 1 Owner Name Mailing Address City State ZIP Property Address Subdivision Subdivision Image MidMoGIS, MO 1104180002009025 Book -Page Date JEFFERSON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT See/Twrk/Rng 315 E DLINKLIN 5T Square Feet (Above Grade) JEFFERSON CITY, MO 65101 Basement Type 418 Case Ave Finished Bsmnt, Size (Sq. Ft.) MORRIS Year Built MORRIS Property Description LOT 101 - PT OL86.: Gate Certified Property Values (Land) 235-224 2/10/1975 18/44/11 912 Full 1920 1/1/2019 Comm: $0 Ag: $0 Res: $7,000 Comm: 0 Book -Page Date 706-531 1/31/2020 Property Values (Irnprov.) Ag: $0 Res: $35,000 Book -Page Date 582-854 9/1/2009 Appraised Value $42,000 D sdairner. Map .and parcel data are believed to be accurate, but accuracy is not guaranteed. This is not a Map Scale legal docunnent and should not be substituted fora title sear h appraisal, survey, or for zoning verilecation_ 1 inch = 23 feet 3/6/2020 http://www.midmogis. org/colesI/WebForms/Print. aspx?img=http://www.midmogis. org/arcg... 3 /6/2020 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION — CITY OF JEFFERSON, MISSOURI March 10, 2020 Nature of Request The purpose of the request is to demolish a single family residential structure located at 418 Case Avenue. This property is owned by the Jefferson City School District and the adopted Historic Southside/Old Munichburg; District & Neighborhood Plan identifies the redeveloped land use for these areas as institutional. This property was likely constructed in 1920, with this block of Case Street receiving sewer service in 1916 and curb and gutter in 1927; making the structure around 100 years old. In accordance with Section 8-47(A)(1)(a) the property was posted with a public hearing sign on February 19, 2020. Exterior and interior photos, MIDMOGIS Map, and other documentation are attached. Staff Analysis Section: Notable YES NO Its association with an event or events that significantly X 418 Case Avenue, with the surrounding contributed to the broad patterns of the history or architectural neighborhood, contributes to the historical heritage of the city, county, state or nation; narrative of Jefferson City through the role of providing homes to generations of working class families. The property housed numerous families. Occupations of owners included: trucker, salesman, shoemaker. Its association with the life or lives of a person or persons X The property had several owners, including: Roy Significant in the history of the city, county, state or nation; Jones (1916), Louis Brunner (1927), and Thomas Howard (1952-53), Eugene Clark (1955), WP Neely Jr. (1957) Its embodiment of distinctive characteristics of a type, X This property is a one story bungalow influence design, period or method of construction with a front gabled roof and a full -width porch supported by floor to ceiling scrolled iron supports. Modern siding covers the fagade. It represents the work of a master designer or architect or X The architect for this property is unknown. possesses high architectural value; It exemplifies the cultural, political, economic, social or historic X 418 Case Avenue does not exemplify the cultural, heritage of the city economic, social or historic heritage of the city. It contains elements of design, detail, material or craftsmanship X which represent a significant construction innovation; It is part of or related to a square, park or other distinctive area X The Historic Southside/Old Munichburg District & that was or should be developed or preserved according to a plan Neighborhood Plan has identified this area as based on a historic or architectural motif, future redevelopment land use. It is an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood X or of the entire community; It has yielded, or is likely to yield archeological artifacts and/or X information. Sections Notable i i to: The visual or spatial relationship of the structure to designated X The property is not listed or designated as a local landmarks, national register sites, or the streetscape of a local landmark, local historic district, or building or area historic district or national register district; listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The architectural, cultural, historic or contextual character of X The property is not listed or designated as a local property designated as a local historic landmark, local historic landmark, local historic district, or building or area district, or building or area listed on the National Register of listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Historic Places. Section:4Notable g shall be considered: The state of deterioration, disrepair or structural unsoundness of X the structure, and the practicability of rehabilitation. The historic preservation commission may request the applicant to submit documentation or other information necessary to determine whether the property can be rehabilitated or restored with a reasonable economic return to the owner. Whether the property is located within an area identified for X This property is within the bounds of the redevelopment within the adopted comprehensive plan, and the Historic Southside Old Munichburg District & Demolition Application — 418 Case Avenue Historic Preservation Commission Page 2 nature of the intended redevelopment. Neighborhood Plan. The nature of the surrounding area and the compatibility of the X The lot that this structure stands is level and is structure to existing adjacent structures and land uses. within the Morris Subdivision. The neighborhood is isolated between a highway, public school, and a hospital/medical facility. The number of similar structures that exist within the City of X Common architecture Jefferson. Plans for the preservation or salvage of notable historic or X architectural features and historic fixtures that contributed to the finding of a notable structure. Condition That Historic Preservation Commission or City Council May Impose In accordance to Section 8-43(1), The Commission or Council may impose conditions on the approval of a Historic Preservation Demolition Clearance in order to ensure that the demolition complies with any applicable requirements of this section that include, but are not limited to, the following: 1. To ensure that notable historic or architectural features or historic fixtures that contributed to the finding of a notable structure are being salvaged or preserved. 2. To ensure that a structure found to be a notable structure and approved for demolition clearance is properly documented for posterity. 3. To ensure that partial demolition of a structure found to be a notable structure does not result in establishment of an exterior finish that is out of character with the structure. 4. Other conditions that the Commission or City Council may deem appropriate to reduce the impact of the demolition with respect to the applicable review criteria. Conditions imposed by the Historic Preservation Commission may be appealed to the City Council in the manner provided for in Section 8-43(H) Staff Recommendation In reviewing Section 8-43(F), Review Criteria (as outlined above), 418 Case Avenue does not appear to hold significant historic value as it is not individually listed on the National Register of Historic Places or Local Landmark nor does it appear to meet the National Register criteria of eligibility. In addition, the May 2019 tornado significantly damaged/destroyed most of the Morris Subdivision. Any local historical significance to this working class neighborhood is no longer intact. At the time of completing this staff report, no comments have been received in response to the public hearing sign. Based on this information, staff recommends that this application for demolition be approved. Recommended Form of Motion Move that the demolition clearance application for 418 Case Avenue is approved by this Commission. Supporting Documentation Landmark Properties/National Register Sites/National Register Districts Map Demolition Application — 418 Case Avenue Historic Preservation Commission Layers = x Filter Layers.., Q Filter — joi Woodland -Old City Cemetery ;- Cemetery > Civilian * Veteran — WI Longview Cemetery z ❑ Lots > U Graves > [ M Unavailable > — Li Historic5ites Li Landmark properties > arr ■ National Regisler5ites > J� 13 National Register Districts > Erj 2015 Imagery c Horn- v L yers Page 3 418 Case rAW rr •r �w vw IV K'.' 418 Case I DEMOLITION REVIEW APPLICATION y �:- r� ,\ �� � � _ I'i P � P� ..� 1' i � � ` 1 x + f A■: se , I � - - �- �_ 'n� „�`L� ` � i� l 1 � : 1st I�, ' � s'_ �. - r Historic Preservation Commission Demolition Review Application for 407 Union Street Meeting Date: March 10, 2020 Motion: Approve the Demolition Review Application for 407 Union Street Eligible to Vote Aye Nay Abstain Commissioner Present Absent Gregory Bemboom Donna Deetz, Vice Chair Steven Hoffman Gail Jones Brad Schafer Mary Schantz, Chair Alan Wheat Michael Berendzen Tie Votes: Chair Votes I certify the foregoing is a correct record of the Commissioners' presence and votes. Mary Schantz Chairperson Attest Anne Stratman City of Jefferson Department of Planning & Protective Services 320 E. McCarty St Jefferson City, MO 65101 Phone: 573-634-6410 icplanning@ieffcitymo.org www. ieffersoncitymo.gov APPLICATION FOR DEMOLITION REVIEW/CLEARANCE TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION In accordance with Section 8-43 of the City Code Property Owner(s): Jefferson City School District Email Address: frank. underwood@jcschools.us Phone Number: 573-659-1190 Property Address: 407 Union St. Jefferson City MO 65101 Date of Construction: 1946 1. The undersigned hereby request(s): ✓ Demolition Review (Application fee $55.00) — For properties that meet the following criteria: Structure(s) age 50 — 99 years old; or Structure(s) listed on the National Register of Historic Places; or Structure(s) designated as a Local Landmark. Demolition Clearance (Application fee $108.00) — For properties that meet the following criteria: Structure(s) age 100+years old; or Structure located within local historic district. 2. The application is filed for the following described real estate: A. Current address: 407 union St. Jefferson city, MO 65101 [a C. In 1969, the City updated their addressing system. Did this property have a different address prior to 1969? Yes ✓ No If so, what was it? Number of structures to be demolished: 1 D. Local Historic District Name: E. Landmark Designation Name: F. National Register Name: G. Recent uses: housing H. Structure Vacant? Yes ✓ No If yes, for how long? 3. Will any architectural features and/or fixtures be preserved, donated or recycled? Yes ✓ No If so, explain: Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. 4. Digital photos are required to be submitted electronically as part of the application. Photos must have been taken within the last 90 days of all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. Photographs must show all areas and characteristics of the structure, not just those areas in disrepair. If multiple structures or addresses, the photos must be labeled to distinguish between structures. Photos submitted via USB Drive CD Dropbox Other Criteria Review: 1. Base on research of the property or to the best of your knowledge, is the property: a. Associated with history of the City of Jefferson, Cole County, State of Missouri or the nation? Yes ✓ I No Explain: b. Associated with persons of significance in the history of City of Jefferson, Cole County, State of Missouri or the nation? Yes ✓ No Explain: c. A representation of particular type, design, period or method of construction (i.e. bungalow, four square, etc.)? Yes No Explain: d. Represents the work of a master designer or architect or possesses high architectural value. Yes ✓ No Unknown e. An example of cultural, political, economic, social or historic heritage of the city? Yes ✓ No Unknown f. Contains elements of design, detail, material or craftsmanship which represent a significant construction innovation. Yes ✓ No Unknown g. It is part of or related to a square, park or other distinctive area that was or should be developed or preserved according to a plan based on a historic or architectural motif. Yes ✓ No Note: Here is an example of architectural motif i h. It is an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood or of the entire community. Yes ✓ No Unknown i. It has yielded, or is likely to yield archeological artifacts and/or information. Yes ✓ No 2. Will the demolition be detrimental to: a. The visual or spatial relationships to designated landmarks, National Register Sites, or the streetscape of a local historic district or National Register District. Yes ✓ No Unknown b. The architectural, cultural, historic or contextual character of property designated as a local historic landmark, local historic district, or building or area listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Yes ✓ No Unknown 3. Why can't the property be rehabilitated or restored with reasonable economical return? Attach additional pages if necessary. Ter a damage. CERTIFICATION: I hereby certify that I am the owner of the named property, or that the requested Demolition Review/Clearance is authorized by the owner of record and I have been authorized by the owner to make this application as his/her agent. Signature: Date: Please check: Property Owner Authorized Agent Licensed Contractor Other DEMOLITION PROCEDURES: Chapter 8, Article IV, Section 8-43 Applications to demolish or remove a structure that meet one or more of the following criteria are subject to application requirements, regulations and review by the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Review: Structures greater than 50 years old. Structures designated as a Local Landmark. Structures listed on the National Register or located within a National Register District. The Building Regulations Division will not issue a demolition permit until the Historic Preservation Commission has approved the Demolition Review Application or the expiration of the 75 day review period, whichever occurs first. The approval of application is valid for one year from date of approval by the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Clearance: Structure greater than 100 years old. Structure located within a Local Historic District. Demolition Clearance applications requires a public hearing in accordance with Section 8-47 of the City Code; which is determined by the date of submittal of completed application. Approximately 10-15 days prior to the public hearing, the property will be posted with sign in the yard notifying the public of the date and time of the public hearing. The Historic Preservation Commission may request information regarding the state of deterioration or disrepair or structural unsoundness of the structure, and the practicability of rehabilitation. In addition, plans for the preservation or salvage of notable historic or architectural features and historic fixtures. Appeal. Demolition Clearance Applications denied by the Historic Preservation Commission may be appealed to the City Council. A written request for appeal to the City Council must be submitted to the Neighborhood Services Division within 30 days of notice to applicant of the Historic Preservation Commission decision. Conditions. The Historic Preservation Commission or City Council may impose conditions on the approval of a Demolition Clearance Application that may include, but not limited to: a. Salvage or preserve notable historic or architectural features or historic fixtures that contributed to the finding of a notable structure. b. Structure found to be a notable structure and approved for demolition clearance is properly documented for posterity. c. Partial demolition of a structure found to be notable structure does not result in establishment of an exterior finish that is out of character with the structure. d. Other conditions that the Historic Preservation Commission or City Council may deem appropriate to reduce the impact of the demolition with respect to the applicable review criteria. The Building Regulations Division will not issue a demolition permit until the Historic Preservation Commission has approved the Demolition Clearance Application. The approval of application is valid for one year from date of approval by the Historic Preservation Commission or by City Council, as applicable. Demolition Application Tips: 1. Photos — Digital photos are required to be submitted as part of the application. Photos must have been taken within the past 90 days at the time of the application. a. Photos must include all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. b. Photos must show all areas and characteristics of the structure, not just those areas in disrepair. c. If multiple structures or addresses, the photos must be labeled to distinguish between structures. 2. Research —Simple check of the following websites and documents will aid answering questions within the demolition application regarding the structure. a. National Register Listings - https://dnr.mo.gov/shpo/cole.htm b. Landmark Designation Listings - www.leffersoncitymo.gov/live play/history heritage/landmark awards.php c. Land and property records — original abstracts for the property holds information on construction date, designer or architect, who originally owned the property, profession, and associated information. If the original abstract is not available a simple deed or title search can tell you who previously owned the property. d. Lookup local census data —Census records can provide information about the lives of the previous owners, like the number of children, cost of home, and more. e. City Directory — A precursor to the modern phone book, offers more details on previous occupants. Missouri River Regional Library has City Directories for Jefferson City in the Genealogy Section. f. Sanborn Map — The Sanborn Map Company was a publisher of detailed maps of US cities. Maps were originally created for fire insurance companies. https:Hdl.mospace.umsystem.edu/mu/islandora/object/mu/`3A138834 3. Attendance - It's strongly encouraged to attend the Historic Preservation Commission meeting for when the demolition application is reviewed. The Commission may have questions regarding the application. A staff report will be presented based on Review Criteria as outlined in Section 8-43 (F) of City Code. 4. Public Hearing — As part of a Demolition Clearance Application process includes a public hearing before the Historic Preservation Commission. The format of the hearing is as follows: After introduction of the application (request) by city staff, the applicant or their consultants will provide information on the request. The opening presentation by the applicant is limited to 10 minutes unless additional time is granted by the Commission. The Commission will then ask to hear from supporters of the request. The Commission will then ask to hear from opponents of the request. The Commission will then ask to hear from anyone else who wishes to speak on the request. Testimony is limited to 3 minutes each unless additional time is granted by the Commission. City staff will then make their recommendations on the request. In order to reduce the time necessary to hear an application, reference to printed material, including staff reports and applicable findings, is not be read into the record unless directed by the Commission. The Commission will close testimony from the floor. The Commission will then discuss the proposal, and then publicly make its determination with reasons. Print Preview Page 1 of 1 MidMOGIS, MO Parcel ID 1104180002010017 Book -Page Date 539-877& 9{8{2006 Owner dame JEFF!ERSON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT Sec/Twn{Rng 18/44{11 Mailing Address 315 E DUNKLIN 5T Square Feet (Above Grade) 694 City State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, MO 65101 Basement Type Full Property Address 407 Union St Finished Bsmnt, Size (Sq. Ft.) 207 Subdivision WOODCRESTADDN Year Built 1946 Subdivision Image WOODCRESTADDN Gate Certified 1{1{2019 PT OL 79; PT LOT 106 & 107, BEG Comm: $0 Property Description 115' Vd OF SE COR LOT 107 W 50'r N Property Valves (Land) Ag: $0 100'; E 50'; S 100' Res: $7a000 Comm: $0 Book Page Date 706-757 2/10/2020 Property Values (Improv.) Ag: 0 Res: $33,,300 Book -Page Date 697-15S 4/1012019 Appraised Value $45,300 Disclaimer. Map .and parcel data are believed to beaccurate, but accuracy is notguaranteed. This is r7ota Map Scale legal docurnent and should not be substituted fora title sear h appraisal, survey, or for zoning 1 inch = 153 feet vevii5c a tiorp. 3{6{2020 http://www.midmogis. org/colesI/WebForms/Print. aspx?img=http://www.midmogis. org/arcg... 3 /6/2020 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION — CITY OF JEFFERSON, MISSOURI March 10, 2020 Demolition Application. Application for demolition of one residential structure located at 407 Union Street NATURE OF REQUEST The purpose of the request is to demolish a single family residential structure located at 407 Union Street. According to MdMOGIS the structure located at 407 Union Street was constructed in 1946. This property is owned by the Jefferson City School District. The Historic Southside/Old Munichburg District & Neighborhood Plan identifies this are to be redeveloped as institutional land use. STAFF ANALYSIS Hstoric Preservation Review Yes No Comments Property listed on the National Register? X See reap on pg. 2 of this document. Property awarded landmark Designation? X Is the property character, interest, or value as part of the X These properties are not individually listed on the development, heritage or cultural characteristics of the community, National Register, local landmark or local historic county, state or nation? district. Is the property location a site of a significant local, county, state or X No known significant events have transpired on the national event? properties. Is the property identification with a person or persons who X significantly contributed to the development of the cormunity, county, state or nation? Is the property embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style valuable for the study of a period, type, method of X Reconnaissance or intensive level of survey has not been corrpleted for this area of town. construction or use of indigenous materials? Is the property identified as a work of a master builder, designer, X Information on designer or architect is unknwai. architect, or landscape architect whose individual work has influenced the development of the community, county, state or nation? Is the property embodiment of elements of design, detailing, X These properties are not architecturally significant. materials, or craftsrrenship that render it architecturally significant? Is the property unique location or singular physical characteristics X that make it an established or farriliar visual feature? Is the property character as a particularly fine or unique example of X a utilitarian structure, including, but not linited to, farrnhouses, gas stations, or other corrrnerclal structures, with a high level of integrity or architectural significance? In reviewing Section 844 C, Criteria for Nomination (as outlined above), the structure does not appear to hold sufficient historical significance in temis of heritage, cultural or architecturally. 407 Union Street was constructed in 1946 and utilized as a residential strudure. FORM OF MOTION Nbtion that the Demolition Review Application for 407 Union Street is reconTrended for approval by this corrrnission. Demolition Application — 403 Union Street Historic Preservation Commission Layers = x Filter Layers..+ civilian * Veteran ❑ Longview Cemetery Lots ® Graves © Unavailable ® Historic Sites ® Landmark Properties . National Register Sites ® National Register Districts Filter Page 2 a� s 1 r Mt.! —77 � S s i 0 m I il 1 7 , , *01ft- 1 41- - 0 - , - -I,- IF 40 D 411 Case Avenue Historic Preservation Commission Demolition Review Application for 411 Case Avenue Meeting Date: March 10, 2020 Motion: Approve the Demolition Review Application for 411 Case Avenue Eligible to Vote Aye Nay Abstain Commissioner Present Absent Gregory Bemboom Donna Deetz, Vice Chair Steven Hoffman Gail Jones Brad Schafer Mary Schantz, Chair Alan Wheat Michael Berendzen Tie Votes: Chair Votes I certify the foregoing is a correct record of the Commissioners' presence and votes. Mary Schantz Chairperson Attest Anne Stratman City of Jefferson Department of Planning & Protective Services 320 E. McCarty St Jefferson City, MO 65101 Phone:573-634-6410 lcylanning@ieffcltvmo.org www.leffersoncitymo.gov APPLICATION FOR DEMOLITION REVIEW/CLEARANCE TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION in accordance with Section B-43 of the City Code Property Owner(s): Jefferson City School District Email Address: frank. underwood@jcschools.us Phone Number: 573-659-1190 Property Address: 411 Case Ave. Jefferson City MO 65101 Date of Construction: 1945 1. The undersigned hereby request(s): ✓ Demolition Review (Application fee $55.00) — For properties that meet the following criteria: • Structure(s) age 50 —99 years old; or • Structure(s) listed on the National Register of Historic Places; or • Structure(s) designated as a Local Landmark. Demolition Clearance (Application fee $108.00) — For properties that meet the following criteria: • Structure(s) age 100+years old; or • Structure located within local historic district. 2. The application is filed for the following described real estate: A. Current address: 4t1 case Ave. Jefferson city, MO 65101 B. In 1969, the City updated their addressing system. Did this property have a different address prior to 1969? Yes ✓ No If so, what was it? C. Number of structures to be demolished: 1 D. Local Historic District E. Landmark Designation Name: F. National Register Name: G. Recent uses: housing H. Structure Vacant? Yes ✓ No If yes, for how long? 3. Will any architectural features and/or fixtures be preserved, donated or recycled? Yes ✓ No If so, explain: Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573) 634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. 4. Digital photos are required to be submitted electronically as part of the application. Photos must have been taken within the last 90 days of all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. Photographs must show all areas and characteristics of the structure, not just those areas in disrepair. If multiple structures or addresses, the photos must be labeled to distinguish between structures. Photos submitted via USB Drive CD Dropbox Other Criteria Review: 1. Base on research of the property or to the best of your knowledge, is the property: a. Associated with history of the City of Jefferson, Cole County, State of Missouri or the nation? Yes ✓ I No Explain: b. Associated with persons of significance in the history of City of Jefferson, Cole County, State of Missouri or the nation? Yes ✓ No Explain: c. A representation of particular type, design, period or method of construction (i.e. bungalow, four square, etc.)? Yes No Explain: d. Represents the work of a master designer or architect or possesses high architectural value. Yes ✓ No Unknown e. An example of cultural, political, economic, social or historic heritage of the city? Yes ✓ No Unknown f. Contains elements of design, detail, material or craftsmanship which represent a significant construction innovation. Yes ✓ No Unknown g. It is part of or related to a square, park or other distinctive area that was or should be developed or preserved according to a plan based on a historic or architectural motif. Yes ✓ No Note: Here is an example of architectural motif h. It is an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood or of the entire community. Yes ✓ No Unknown I. It has yielded, or is likely to yield archeological artifacts and/or information. Yes ✓ No 2. Will the demolition be detrimental to: a. The visual or spatial relationships to designated landmarks, National Register Sites, or the streetscape of a local historic district or National Register District. Yes ✓ No Unknown b. The architectural, cultural, historic or contextual character of property designated as a local historic landmark, local historic district, or building or area listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Yes ✓ No Unknown 3. Why can't the property be rehabilitated or restored with reasonable economical return? Attach additional pages if necessary. TOFRade damage. CERTIFICATION: I hereby certify that I am the owner of the named property, or that the requested Demolition Review/Clearance is authorized by the owner of record and I have been authorized by the owner to make this application as his/her agent. Signature: Please check: Property Owner Authorized Agent Licensed Contractor Other DEMOLITION PROCEDURES: Chapter 8, Article IV, Section 8-43 Applications to demolish or remove a structure that meet one or more of the following criteria are subject to application requirements, regulations and review by the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Review: • Structures greater than 50 years old. • Structures designated as a Local Landmark. • Structures listed on the National Register or located within a National Register District. The Building Regulations Division will not issue a demolition permit until the Historic Preservation Commission has approved the Demolition Review Application or the expiration of the 75 day review period, whichever occurs first. The approval of application is valid for one year from date of approval by the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Clearance: • Structure greater than 100 years old. • Structure located within a Local Historic District. Demolition Clearance applications requires a public hearing in accordance with Section 8-47 of the City Code; which is determined by the date of submittal of completed application. Approximately 10-15 days prior to the public hearing, the property will be posted with sign in the yard notifying the public of the date and time of the public hearing. The Historic Preservation Commission may request information regarding the state of deterioration or disrepair or structural unsoundness of the structure, and the practicability of rehabilitation. In addition, plans for the preservation or salvage of notable historic or architectural features and historic fixtures. Appeal. Demolition Clearance Applications denied by the Historic Preservation Commission may be appealed to the City Council. A written request for appeal to the City Council must be submitted to the Neighborhood Services Division within 30 days of notice to applicant of the Historic Preservation Commission decision. Conditions. The Historic Preservation Commission or City Council may impose conditions on the approval of a Demolition Clearance Application that may include, but not limited to: a. Salvage or preserve notable historic or architectural features or historic fixtures that contributed to the finding of a notable structure. b. Structure found to be a notable structure and approved for demolition clearance is properly documented for posterity. c. Partial demolition of a structure found to be notable structure does not result in establishment of an exterior finish that is out of character with the structure. d. Other conditions that the Historic Preservation Commission or City Council may deem appropriate to reduce the impact of the demolition with respect to the applicable review criteria. The Building Regulations Division will not issue a demolition permit until the Historic Preservation Commission has approved the Demolition Clearance Application. The approval of application is valid for one year from date of approval by the Historic Preservation Commission or by City Council, as applicable. Demolition Application Tips: 1. Photos —Digital photos are required to be submitted as part of the application. Photos must have been taken within the past 90 days at the time of the application. a. Photos must include all exterior sides, interior rooms and stairwells. b. Photos must show all areas and characteristics of the structure, not just those areas in disrepair. c. If multiple structures or addresses, the photos must be labeled to distinguish between structures. 2. Research —Simple check of the following websites and documents will aid answering questions within the demolition application regarding the structure. a. National Resister Listings - https://dnr.mo.gov/shoo/cole.htm b. Landmark Designation Listings - www.ieffersoncitymo.gov/live play/history heritage/landmark awards.php c. Land and property records —original abstracts for the property holds information on construction date, designer or architect, who originally owned the property, profession, and associated information. If the original abstract is not available a simple deed or title search can tell you who previously owned the property. d. Look up local census data — Census records can provide information about the lives of the previous owners, like the number of children, cost of home, and more. e. City Directory —A precursor to the modern phone book, offers more details on previous occupants. Missouri River Regional Library has City Directories for Jefferson City in the Genealogy Section. f. Sanborn Map —The Sanborn Map Company was a publisher of detailed maps of US cities. Maps were originally created for fire insurance companies. https•//dl rnospace umsystem.edu/mu/islandora/object/mu%3Al38834 3. Attendance - It's strongly encouraged to attend the Historic Preservation Commission meeting for when the demolition application is reviewed. The Commission may have questions regarding the application. A staff report will be presented based on Review Criteria as outlined in Section 8-43 (F) of City Code. 4. Public Hearing —As part of a Demolition Clearance Application process includes a public hearing before the Historic Preservation Commission. The format of the hearing is as follows: • After introduction of the application (request) by city staff, the applicant or their consultants will provide information on the request. The opening presentation by the applicant is limited to 10 minutes unless additional time is granted by the Commission. • The Commission will then ask to hear from supporters of the request. • The Commission will then ask to hear from opponents of the request. • The Commission will then ask to hear from anyone else who wishes to speak on the request. • Testimony is limited to 3 minutes each unless additional time is granted by the Commission. • City staff will then make their recommendations on the request. In order to reduce the time necessary to hear an application, reference to printed material, including staff reports and applicable findings, is not be read into the record unless directed by the Commission. • The Commission will close testimony from the floor. • The Commission will then discuss the proposal, and then publicly make its determination with reasons. Print Preview Page 1 of 1 MONl GIS, MO Parcel IC`. 1104180002009013 Soak -Page Date 671-733 12/1/2016 Owner Name JEFFERSON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT See/Twn/Rng 18/44/11 Mailing Address 315 E DUNKLIN ST Square Feet (Above Grade) 1,096 Cite State ZIP JEFFERSON CITY, MO 65101 Basement Type Part Property Address 411 Case Ave Finished Bsrnnt, Size (Sq. Ft.) 320 Subdivision MORRIS Year Built 1945 Subdivision Image M0PIRIS Gate Certified 1/1/2019 LOTS 85 & 8b & PT LOT 87; BEG SE Comm: $0 Property Description COR LOT 85 NE 130.46: MA) 60.33.: Property Value, (Land) Ag: $0 SW 80.46; SW 25 (S); Ries: $7,000 Book -Page Date 706-028 1/14/2020 Book -Page Date 679-663 8/2312017 Property Values (Improv.) Appraised Value Uomrn: �Fu Ag: 0 Res: $325700 $39,700 Disclaimer. Map .and parcel data are believed to beaccurate, but accuracy is arotguaranteed. This is not Map Scale legal document and should not be substituted fora title sear h appraisal, survey, or for zoning 1 inich = 293 feet vevi trorR. 2/13/2020 http://www.midmogis.org/colesI/WebForms/Print.aspx?img=http://www.midmogis.org/arc... 2/ 13/2020 STAFF REPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION — CITY OF JEFFERSON, MISSOURI March 10, 2020 Demolition Application. Application for demolition of one residential structure located at 411 Case Avenue NATURE OF REWEST The purpose of the request is to demolish a single family residential structure located at 411 Case Avenue. According to MidMOGIS the structure located at 411 Case Avenue was constructed in 1945. This property is owned by the Jefferson City School District. The Historic Southside/Cld Munichburg District & Neighborhood Plan identifies this are to be redeveloped as institutional land use. STAFF ANALYSIS Historic Preservation Review Yes No Conyna its Property listed on the National Register? X See map on pg. 2 of this document. Property awarded landmark Designation? X Is the property character, interest, or value as part of the X These properties are not individually listed on the development, heritage or cultural characteristics of the commnity, National Register, local landmark or local historic county, state or nation? district. Is the property location a site of a significant local, county, state or X No known significant events have transpired on the national event? properties. Is the property identification with a person or persons who X significantly oontdbuted to the development of the community, county, state or nation? Is the property embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style valuable for the study of a period, type, method of X Reconnaissance or intensive level of survey has not been completed for this area of town. construction or use of indigenous materials? Is the property identified as a work of a master builder, designer, X Infomnation on designer or architect is unWoAn. architect, or landscape architect whose individual work has influenced the development of the community, county, state or nation? Is the property embodiment of elements of design, detailing, X These properties are not architecturally significant. raterials, or craftsmanship that render it architecturally significant? Is the property unique location or singular physical characteristics X that make it an established or familiar visual feature? Is the property character as a particularly fine or unique example of X a utilitarian structure, including, but not limited to, farrThouses, gas stations, or other commercial structures, with a high level of integrity or architectural significance? In reviewing Section 8-44 C, Criteria for Nomination (as outlined above), the structure does not appear to hold sufficient historical significance in terms of heritage, cultural or architecturally. 411 Case Avenue was constructed in 1945 and was utilized as a residential structure. FORM OF MOTION Motion that the Demolition Review Application for 411 Case Avenue is recommended for approval by this commission. Demolition Application — 403 Union Street Historic Preservation Commission Layers = x Filter Layers..+ civilian * Veteran ❑ Longview Cemetery Lots ® Graves © Unavailable ® Historic Sites ® Landmark Properties . National Register Sites ® National Register Districts Filter Page 2 411 Case 44 1-k a r I - ,} map • � _._ � '"�' Jac ��_ � 411 Case 411 Case City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Application for Nomination Landmark Designation Award We invite you to nominate your building/structure to be reviewed by the Historic Preservation Commission and designated as a local Landmark. See attached page for information about this award. This form must be completed by the owner of the property nominated and returned no later than February 28 annually. Please fill out the below information in complete detail. Please submit a current photo(s) of the property being nominated. If applicable, older photos may also be submitted. Return the application to: City of Jefferson, Landmark Designation Award, c/o Rachel Senzee, 320 E. McCarty Street, Jefferson City, MO 65101 or email to rsenzee@ieffcitvmo.ore. If you have questions please call 573-634-6410. Contact Information: Owner: Levi and Amanda Burke Williams Address: 103 Jackson St, Jefferson City, MO Contact Person: Amanda Phone No. 3184716931 Email Address: blueoctavia@yahoo.com Will the owner display the plaque on the building? ® Yes O No (if no please explain) Property Information: Historic Name (if known) Standish House Year Built C.1880 History & Significance, include details such as builder, unique facts of previous owners Attach additional pages if necessary: I am the owner of this property and am aware of this application for Landmark Award and agree to accept the award if no ina d bythe City fJefferson Historic Preservation Commission: 'Owner's - Signature Date Indmzduals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573)634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. The Standish House was constructed c.1880 and is a good example of the Queen Anne Eastlake style. It is characterized by its keyhole entry and U-shaped stairs. The house is two -stories with an asymmetrical fagade, paired Tuscan columns flanking the brick keyhole entry, flared second story clad in decorative shingles, and sunburst brackets on the cutaway bays. The house was originally constructed for Mildred Standish, the widow of Lt. Col. Austin Standish, with money she received in a suit against the Mexican government for the murder of her husband while traveling in the country after the Civil War. The house was converted into a law office by Robert Hawkins III in the 1980s. Subsequent owners abandoned the property and allowed it to fall into disrepair. The property was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 2005 as a contributing building in the Capital Avenue Historic District. The house came under the ownership of the Jefferson City Housing authority in 2018 and was purchased in 2019 by the current owners Levi and Amanda Burke Williams to be restored into their family home. The property is currently under restoration and should be complete later this year. To learn more about their restoration efforts visit https://outstandishpreservation.weebly.com/. of al 4.4 C IRA; 2. ISA I - sit tj 1§011 Al;t :7V MR] —11�ililillii mil 7 Are.,44 W11 AP V 4a; t. xr� -!i .,U. 99 W, RAI _Aw i7 lee AO-0- �� - iA �� � �< 0 City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Application for Nomination Landmark Designation Award if 1 _--=_� FEB 1 8 2020 ,,,,__PLANNING & We invite you to nominate your building/structure to be reviewed by the Historic Preservation Commission and designated as a local Landmark. See attached page for information about this award. This form must be completed by the owner of the property nominated and returned no later than February 28 annually. Please fill out the below information in complete detail. Please submit a current photo(s) of the property being nominated. If applicable, older photos may also be submitted. Return the application to: City of Jefferson, Landmark Designation Award, c/o Rachel Senzee, 320 E. McCarty Street, Jefferson City, MO 65101 or email to rsenzeeP!effcitvmo.org. If you have questions please call 573-634-6410. Contact Information: Owner: ► IJt-0RIC- ( L 4 k I o-)� jlet�'e ,son Address:_ _ /a b/ E 14 t o ti Sd- Contact Person: �00 n n_4-- Phone No. Email Address: 1CC I ID re-7 on a n t eoM Will the owner display the plaque on the building? JYes ❑ No (if no please explain) Property Information: Historic Name (if known) --rW c,�A le. J)oUSe Year Built_ 15" 1590 History & Significance, include details such as builder, unique facts of previous owners Attach additional pages if necessary: See- aA4� I am the owner of this property and am aware of this application for Landmark Award and agree to accept the award if nominated by the City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission: 1b mul0. i in�S£ Pr-"(80,44 HCJ 2 tq —ZO Owner's Signature Date Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573)634-6570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required tinder the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. A year ago, HCJ Purchased the historic Tweedie House (601 East High Street) for office space. The story of this building started just over 50 years after the founding and incorporation of our city. The Tweedle connection to the city started a over 1 5years ago and carried on for four generations. John Tweedie was born in 1838 in Scotland, where he learned shoemaldng from his father. John immigrated to the United States in 1856 and enlisted in the Union army. After the Civil War, he was married May 1, 1867, to Anna De Bemff In 1869, Tweedie moved to SL Louis to become foreman of a shoe company, then joined the A. Priesmeyer Shoe Company as a foreman in 1872. He moved to Jefferson City in 1874 to manage a new Priesmeyer factory inside the Missouri State Penitentiary(MSP). In the 1870s, the state constructed factory buildings inside MSP, then negotiated for the use of prison labor. Shoe manufacturer George Coming testified in 1873 that his operation employed 70 inmates at a cost of $0.40 each per day, generating an annual profit of $51 OOO. Such testimony may have been what attracted the A. Priesmeyer Shoe Company to Jefferson City. 14 CONTINUED ON PAGE 15 The A. Priesmeyer company enlarged its Operation in 1889 and built a new factory just south of Lohman's Landing in 19o5.'Ihe four- story building with a basement employed over 400 penple. In 1917 the company became known as the'hveedie Footwear Corporation. The business grew and thrived through World War 11 until manufacturing stopped in 1964. In the 1880s, John and Anna Tweedie lived on the 700 block of E. High Street, just west of today's High Street Retreat. Tweethe hired well-known architect Charles Opel to design his home at 601 East High Street. Opel would later design nearby Ivy Terrace for Governor Lawrence V. Stephens in 1893, and part of MSp as well. Although Opel was the architect, Tweedie in many of his own touches into the design of the building. Several of these features still exist today. You ran still see the thistles carved in the stone above the first floor windows which would have perhaps reminded Tweedie of Scotland and his youth, The unique curved stonework around the front entry features a lizard and displays the Scottish affinity for stone masonry. Due to the intricate designs throughout, the Victorian house Is classified as being in the Queen Anne style which was popular from 18W-1910. The house was perfect for a local businessman wanting to exhibit his wealth and Position within the community. of John Tweedie in 1908, his family continued to live at the home for a number of years. 1n the 1950s, the building was converted into the Dune Funeral Home. It served as ✓ohn Tweedie a hospice home in the 90s then in the 2 the building housed Cole County Residential Services. Bach new business changed the historic building In some way. When HCJ purchased the building last year, the goal was not a full restoration. Instead, HCJ implanted the tactic of adaptive reuse. Adaptive reuse is the process of repurposing buildings that have outlived their original Purposes for different uses Or functions while at the same time retaining their historic features. HCJ supports adaptive reuse as a way to save neglected buildings that might otherwise be demolished or left vacant. Benefit of adaptive arch include: itecture reuse Utilization of Quality Materials: Seasoned building materials are generally not available today. Close -grained, first -growth lumber that was used +75 years ago is naturally stronger than wood grown quickly today. pt> bi �e,S 6y C�(L� Comw Lori tcr*1lo�s Increasing Sustainability: Adaptive reuse in inherentlygreen. Preserving the Culture: These buildings are Part of our commturity s history and memory. As the state capitol, they are also part of our State's story. HCJ has focused on rehabbing the original historic portion of the property which had not been utilized for some time. The front parlor has been revitalized and now houses the OOOs contents of the 1904 St. Marys Time Capsule for the public to view, The middle segment of the house which was once joined with the parlor to make one large room, will soon hold a public research library focused on historic buildings and properties in Jefferson City. The annex, which was added in the rnld- 1900s when the property served as a funeral home, has been painted to better highlight the historic portion of the property. The first floor of the annex is available to rent as a community room for meetings or events with 30-4p people. The second floor of the annex nur. 40tly houses architectural salvage, much ofwhichwm saved from buildings that were demolished as a result Of the May 2019 tornado. Through adaptive reuse, HCl has been able to rehab and mPurpose this beautiful historic building to serve our community today. The building and it's historic architectural features remind of us of the people that once lived in our community and their story. Historic buildings Bke the TZedie House help communicate our understanding of the past to future generation, ---- - --•••• • ••-�-•� •��or, ane wa nawnome or Hisronc tarty ofieHerson. _ - __..._ ..__. _...... ....,, �� my .vuw• y. h r Le .R Lr� n'•-x.y Jefferson City BUZ • January 2020 City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission Application for Nomination Landmark Designation Award We invite you to nominate your building/structure to be reviewed by the Historic Preservation Commission and designated as a local Landmark. See attached page for information about this award. This form must be completed by the owner of the property nominated and returned no later than February 28 annually. Please fill out the below information in complete detail. Please submit a current photo(s) of the property being nominated. If applicable, older photos may also be submitted. Return the application to: City of Jefferson, Landmark Designation Award, c/o Rachel Senzee, 320 E. McCarty Street, Jefferson City, MO 65101 or email to rsenzee(a)ieffcitymo.org. If you have questions please call 573-634-6410. Contact Information: Owner: ADk>/E/VNE' Address: Contact Email Ac Will the owner display the plaque on the building?)(Yes ❑ No (if no please explain) Property Information: Historic Name (if known) Ty4rllelw llea-lE- Year Built 1�51O History & Significance, include details such as builder, unique facts of previous owners Attach additional pages if necessary: This application is a request for The Hoard Home at 815 East Dunklin Street to be designated as a City of Jefferson Historic Landmark, because of its cultural significance and meaningful historical context to the area. SEX'ATFAC446D PPr66-r- I am the owner of this property and am aware of this application for Landmark Award and agree to accept the award if nominated by the City of Jefferson Historic Preservation Commission: Owner's Signature Date Individuals should contact the ADA Coordinator at (573)6346570 to request accommodations or alternative formats as required under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please allow three business days to process the request. 815 East Dunklin Street The Charles M. and Yvonne W. Hoard House Adrienne W. Hoard, owner CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE This application is a request for The Charles M. and Yvonne W. Hoard House at 815 East Dunklin Street to be designated as a City of Jefferson Historic Landmark, because of its cultural significance and meaningful historical context to the area. Since 1956, the brick ranch home has been in prominent view of students and faculty from the Lincoln University campus. Major Brothers Construction Company built the home at the corner of Chestnut and Dunklin streets. Over the years university events list "the Hoard House", as a pivotal map marker for school activities, particularly annual parades. The house retains its original function, as it remains a single-family dwelling. The Charles M. and Yvonne W. Hoard House remains intact, both inside and out, and retains its integrity in location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association. During the early 1950s this corner was occupied by a wooden billboard, which advertised to the "colored" neighborhoods. Coupled with the gasoline filling station on the parallel corner, this intersection provided a substantial social and commercial hub for the local Black residents and for the university. Within this historic neighborhood, the Hoard House reflects an era when HOARD —Landmark Designation Award 2020 university professors were only able to purchase land and/or homes on the streets which ringed the university, such as Dunklin and Lafayette streets. In 1982, the Missouri Office of Historic Preservation included this property in its Architectural/Historic Inventory survey, along with neighboring homes along Dunklin and Lafayette streets and adjacent side streets. Although this home is well -maintained by the Hoard's daughter, Adrienne, and not in jeopardy; many of the other properties noted in that 1982 survey have come down. As an education -focused couple, Dr. Charles M. Hoard and Mrs. Yvonne Walker Hoard provided over four decades of support and guidance for students, faculty and staff at Lincoln University. Their combined service contributions had impact on the City of Jefferson as well. Dr. Charles M. Hoard served in many academic capacities on the campus from coach to professor during his decades of working at Lincoln University. One of his greatest contributions was serving as a moral compass for generations of young black men and women, who were finding their way through the Civil Rights era and into the work force beyond. Growing up in St. Louis, gave him knowledge of and respect for the diverse lives of his students. He was Dean of Men, professor of Physical Education, Dean of Students, Director of Health Services, professor of Psychology, professor of Education, and Chairman of the Education and Psychology departments. He retired in 1979 after more than 38 years at the university. He was invited to return to the university to serve as Provost for the 1983-84 academic year. His education included his master's degree from the University of Wisconsin and his doctorate in education from Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana. After receiving his bachelor's degree from Bishop College is Marshal Texas in 1938, Dr. Hoard returned to Missouri to teach in Brunswick, Missouri. In 1941, Hoard came to Lincoln as coach and dorm monitor for one year, before enlisting in the US Army Air Corps and being assigned as an instructor at the Tuskegee Army Air Field. He was commissioned a lieutenant in 1944. In 1945, he entered OCS (Officer Candidate School) and became a captain. He remained in the US Air Force Reserve for almost 30 years, assigned to the Jefferson City local squadron and reaching the rank of major. He enjoyed relating his stories of friendships as well as personal losses among competent pilots during a unique war experience. Off campus, he was a motivational speaker, social science consultant and leadership instructor. He was a member of the local Optimist International Club. His subtle activism in Jefferson City during the early 1960s supported the negotiated opening of the local theater for Lincoln University students and other Black citizens to be able to sit on the first floor and not only in the balcony of the theater building. For the Jefferson City community, Hoard was an original member appointed to the city's Human Rights Commission in April 1964. In February 1966, he was the first Black resident to be named to a public -school committee. He was the first Black person to be placed on a bank HOARD —Landmark Designation Award 2020 3 board of directors for the local UMB. Dr. Hoard also was a deacon at Second Baptist Church and volunteered with the Boy Scouts. In 1947, Hoard married Yvonne Walker. They reared three children at their home at 815 E. Dunklin Street —Adrienne, Andrea and Charles Jr. Mrs. Yvonne Walker Hoard's education includes a bachelor's degree in physical education from Howard University, a master's degree of education from the University of Michigan and she was a doctoral candidate at the University of Wisconsin. In 1946, she arrived at Lincoln as a professor Physical Education, after serving as Head of women's Physical Education at Florida A&M University, Tallahassee, Florida. Mrs. Hoard was named Associate Director of athletics in 1974, when Lincoln began intercollegiate competition in women's volleyball and track. She was an officer with the Missouri Association of Intercollegiate Athletics for Women. In 1987, she became the first female vice president of the Missouri Intercollegiate Athletic Association. From 1983 through 1990, the Lincoln University women's tennis team won the MIAA championship, making Mrs. Hoard, the coach with the most winning seasons in the history of the league. Following her tragic death in a car accident while adjudicating an MIAA case at the School of the Ozarks in 1990, the Lincoln University tennis courts were named in her honor. In her service to the community, Mrs. Yvonne W. Hoard was an original organizer of the Jefferson City Women's Bowling Association, she served on the YMCA board of directors and on the Jefferson City Hospice board of directors. Frequently, she worked with the first female Mayor of Jefferson City to facilitate joint programs and projects for Jefferson City and Lincoln University. The family legacy of education and service to the community continues through the Hoard's eldest daughter, Dr. Adrienne W. Hoard, current owner and resident of the 815 East Dunklin Street house. She is a retired professor of art from the University of Missouri system. She works with local arts organizations to jury art exhibition and shows. She has served on the Girl Scouts of American board of directors in Jefferson City. Her focus remains her service to a greater Jefferson City. Thank you for your consideration of the application for the Landmark Designation Award for the Charles M. and Yvonne W. Hoard House at 815 East Dunklin St. This property remains a symbolic home of cultural heritage and historical importance for generations of Jefferson City residents. May 22, 2019 EF3 Tornado Dangerous Building Determinations June 1. 421 Stadium July 1. 510 E Dunklin St 2. 516 E Dunklin St 3. 607 E McCarty St 4. 816 Jackson St 5. 916 Jackson St 6. 502 E McCarty St 7. 427 Case Avenue 8. 517 E McCarty St 9. 1937 Christy Pool House - Under 50 years old August 1. 1218 Jackson St 2. 600 E Capitol 3. 621 E Capitol 4. 623 E Capitol September 1. 701 Jackson 2. 210 Marshall 3. 508 E Dunklin — Need Building Official Write Up 4. 514-516 E Capitol Ave October 1. 527 E High St 2. 511 E McCarty St 3. 505 Ellis (8 buildings) — Apartment complexes under 50 years old November 1. 507 Holiday — Under 50 years old December 1. 415 Stadium 2. 425 Union 3. 425 Case 4. 421 Union 5. 420 Union 6. 914 Jackson 7. 902 Jackson 8. 415 E Ashley May 22, 2019 EF3 Tornado Dangerous Building Determinations January 2020 1. 430 E Dunklin — Need Building Official Write Up 2. 516 E Dunklin — Need Building Official Write Up February 2020 1. 426 Case Avenue 2. 411 Case Avenue