HomeMy Public PortalAbout10/05/04 CCM279
MEDINA CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF OCTOBER 5, 2004
The City Council of Medina, Minnesota met in regular session on October 5, 2004 at
7:30 p.m. in the City Hall Chambers. Mayor Zietlow presided.
I. ROLL CALL
Members present: Workman (arrived at 7:31 p.m.), Lane, Brinkman, Zietlow and
Smith (arrived at 7:38 p.m.).
Members absent: None.
Also present: City Attorney Ron Batty, City Engineer Tom Kellogg, Public Works
Director Jim Dillman, City Administrator Chad Adams, City Planning Consultant Sarah
Schield, Police Chief Ed Belland, and Recording Secretary Liza Weniger.
II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
III. ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA
Moved by Lane, seconded by Brinkman, to approve the agenda as presented. Motion
passed unanimously.
Workman arrived at 7:31 p.m.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Approval of the September 21, 2004 Regular Council Meeting Minutes
It was noted on page 2, the last line of the last paragraph should state: "Zietlow
explained that several years ago chemicals were used to kill..."
It was noted on page 3, the first line of the first paragraph should state: "...weeds_
Costs were very high and made little impact
small impact on weed control, and..."
It was noted on page 3, the second line of the first paragraph should state: "wh4e# may
possibly cause more harm than good. Zietlow stated that the City now mows the..."
It was noted on page 3, the first line of the second paragraph should state: "Zietlow
stated that most the Dutch Elm trees are a private property issue,..."
It was noted on page 3, the second line of the second paragraph should state: "...many
Dutch Elm on its..."
It was noted on page 3, the fourth line of the second paragraph should state: "...is to
treat trees every year day."
It was noted on page 3, the first line of the seventh paragraph should state: "Zietlow
stated that a laig meeting was held..."
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
280
It was noted on page 3, the second line of the seventh paragraph should state: "...has
had a lot tog of issues request:, resulting in..."
It was noted on page 3, the final line of the seventh paragraph should state: "...the
developer was conforming to the development agreement granted the bonus lot:,."
It was noted on page 4, the last line of the second paragraph should state: "...training
on the care of prairie yards. Meldrum..."
It was noted on page 4, the first and second lines of the fourth paragraph should state:
"Last year, the developer is trying to addressed the issues related to the mud coming
over the roads."
It was noted on page 5, the last line of the last paragraph should state: "...Gramercy
met Medina's ordinance on building heights was grantcd a variance."
It was noted on page 8, the final line of the fourth paragraph should state: "to be made
in 2008 2000."
It was noted on page 12, the first line of the eighth paragraph should state: "...two
different developments zones butting up..."
It was noted on page 15, it was noted that a separate heading should be added between
the sixth and seventh paragraphs that should state: "2. Hamel Fire Protection".
Moved by Lane, seconded by Workman, to approve the September 21, 2004 Regular
City Council meeting minutes as amended. Motion passed unanimously.
V. CONSENT AGENDA
A. Resolution Granting Final Approval to the Plat of Rolling Green Business
Center Office Condominiums
B. Resolution Approving Preliminary Plans for Trunk Highway 55 and CSAH
19 Intersection
C. Reschedule November 2, 2004 Regular Council Meeting to November 3,
2004 at 7:30 p.m.
D. Approve Appointment of General Election Judges for November 2, 2004
Moved by Workman, seconded by Brinkman, to approve the amended Consent Agenda.
Motion passed unanimously.
Smith arrived at 7:38 p.m.
VI. COMMENTS
A. Comments from Citizens on Items Not on the Agenda
Elizabeth Weir, Planning Commissioner, stated that while on her commute into Medina,
she stopped west of Uptown Hamel, and noted the prominent amount of drainage going
into the creek. She stated she believes there is a considerable amount of hardcover
causing excessive drainage. She asked Dillman if current drainage meets standards.
Dillman stated drainage west of Uptown Hamel has always been this way.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
281
Weir stated that she had hoped that the drainage would improve.
Sue Van Cleaf, reporter for the South Crow River News, stated that she would like to
remind all candidates to submit their pictures and bios to the newspaper office. Posting
bios and photos is the best way for South Crow River News to remain impartial and yet
educate the public on the candidacy race.
B. Park Commission
Dillman stated that Park Commission meeting was short. After touring the Community
Building and Donor Wall, the group returned to City Hall at 7 p.m. to meet.
Lane asked when openings for Park Commission positions would be reappointed.
Adams stated there may be an appointment on October 19, 2004.
Smith requested a discussion to clarify why the Park Commission does not abide by the
nine-year maximum service term as the Planning and Zoning Commission does.
Zietlow proposed that the discussion be brought back to the Park Commission in order
to have them make a recommendation on the rule. Brinkman and Smith both stated
that the Park Commission has already discussed the ruling, and both Brinkman and
Smith don't think it is right for the Park Commission to make a recommendation.
Workman stated that a couple of committee members have been known to retire after a
nine-year maximum term period, and return a few years later to re -serve on the board.
Adams suggested the term discussion of each commission be placed on next agenda.
C. Planning Commission
Schield stated the 3000 Hamel Road for Bradley subdivision of 200 plus acres into 9 lots
was on the Planning Commission agenda for October 12, 2004.
Smith stated that when Josh Doty was acting as City Planner, he was requested to
research if there were any restrictions on the development addition due to ponding on
the property. Schield stated that staff is looking into the matter with Hennepin County.
VII. OLD BUSINESS
A. Water Treatment Plant — Hamel Water System
Adams stated that there are a number of agenda items to be addressed tonight on the
project. A preview of each of the items was discussed. The Federal Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) and MN Department of Health Guidelines have caused the
City to perform a water study to review options of reducing levels of radium and gross
alpha from the Hamel Water System. Upon reviewing options and holding public
meetings, a feasibility report was prepared for a conventional water treatment plant
which will also reduce aesthetic contaminant levels of iron and manganese.
1. Water Rate Study
Adams reviewed the memo and rate analysis from Ehlers & Associates. The study
includes an analysis of expected rates and fees for the Hamel Water System, through
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
282
future capital improvements such as the Water Treatment Plant, wells, supply lines, etc.
There are two growth scenarios' to review: current and alternate growth. Based on the
analysis and assumptions, staff is recommending a Trunk Connection rate increase of
100% effectively immediately. The increase would raise the rate for new development
connections from $1,790/unit to $3,580/unit. The increase is being proposed by
ordinance under Agenda Item VII A4.
Jessica Cook of Ehlers & Associates made a presentation to summarize and clarify the
rate analysis report. She commended Adams and staff for their diligence and analysis
of the rate study. She explained that the water system consists of two parts financially:
The operating fund where user fees are responsible for bringing in the revenues, and
the connection/trunk fund where its revenue draws from a one time fee that developers
pay as they pull a building permit. The fees are used over time to expand the system,
drill new wells and etc. Cook explained that the role of the City is to decide how to
allocate those costs between the two funds.
Cook further clarified the two growth scenarios mentioned in the introduction of the
agenda item, which were used to measure the impact of the study. Cook explained that
all assumptions were put into a model and were used to measure impacts of the rates.
She also stated that smaller improvements would be most efficient if paid in cash,
leaving large improvements, such as the water treatment plant, to be financed.
Cook stated that the study found that the connection fee tends to be less in Medina than
surrounding communities; and Medina does not charge an area fee.
Cook explained that user fees will necessitate an increase, and how raising the increase
is arbitrary. As a Council, there are some policy decisions about funding that need to be
weighed in. The study makes a recommendation that the City maintains a prudent level
in both user and connectivity funds. The Council would need to determine the "prudent
level"; however the goal would be to fund 50% of depreciation.
Cook stated that another role for Council is to make sure that connection fees are used
under law for appropriate purposes. The third important role is to get the consultant
fees back. The fourth duty would entail that Council set rates annually. Now that a
model is built, it should be updated annually and rate increases set accordingly.
Zietlow proposed that Council first set the rates conservatively, and then assess the
fees after monitoring the growth.
Adams stated that design and construction costs were all factored into the water study.
Lane asked Adams how the numbers were arrived at with respect to the accelerated
growth scenario. Adams stated that conversations with staff and expressed interest in
development from potential developers were all considered as part of the assumption.
The numbers do not assume a lot of commercial growth, and staff was very
conservative in the growth of the commercial district. Adams explained that whatever
growth there is commercially will help with the connection fees.
Lane stated that it is his opinion that the growth numbers prior to 2020 seem very
aggressive and recommends modeling off the conservative or current growth model.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
283
Adams stated that it had been staff's intention to underestimate the growth scenarios,
and referenced the conservative number for units in Uptown Hamel which may only be
about a third of what could be developed.
Adams stated that to keep with the schedule, an adoption of connection fees will need to
be approved tonight, and would then return in December for review of the user fees.
Lane asked Council Members how they felt about the rate increases currently proposed
versus what was discussed back at the public hearings in June of 2004. Lane asked
Adams if there should there be a discussion, or an informational newsletter sent out to
the public, informing them of the increased proposed rates. Adams stated that he would
put together a newsletter informing residents of the proposed user fees.
Workman asked if the connection fee would be per unit. Adams stated yes, per living
unit for residential and equivalent residential unit for commercial.
Adams stated that typically when the City raises the user fees, it also raises the sewer
fees. The City will not be doing that here because the City has a strong fund balance
already in the sewer fund.
Zietlow commended Cook for her report stating it was easy to read and understand.
2. Resolution Authorizing and Directing the Use of the Power of Eminent
Domain to Acquire Certain Property for the Purpose of Constructing a
Water Treatment Facility
Adams stated that at the last Council Meeting, staff was advised to send an offer letter
to John and Jack Day for acquisition of their parcel. They responded promptly by
declining to sell the property. Therefore, the next step for the City is to consider is
condemnation.
Adams identified a parcel of land at 780 Tower Drive as the piece of property to be
acquired through the Power of Eminent Domain.
Jack Day introduced himself to the Council.
Batty stated that the resolution in packet is straight forward and authorizes City to
acquire the property though condemnation using April 1, 2005 as the goal date for
acquisition. This resolution allows City to legally acquire the land under "quick -take".
Day asked Council how the City arrived at selecting his lot for acquisition.
Adams stated that obviously the City wanted a location that was close to the water
tower, wells, and existing supply lines. Since the City intends to have a Water
Treatment Facility, and there are not very many vacant lots in the area, the Days
property was found to best fit the water treatment plant.
Adams stated that the City did look at other properties but the selection was very limited.
With the cost of purchasing or condemning properties, especially properties that already
house buildings, the City had to be concerned for the budget as the project has
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
284
increased considerably over the last year due to the price of steel and other materials in
the project.
Smith stated that the City does not own any land anywhere, with the exception of parks,
and is not able to offer land in exchange for the quick -take.
Lane stated that it is not the City's interest to invest in commercial property in
anticipation of projects such as the Water Treatment Facility.
Zietlow informed Day that Council needed to move forward as both the Federal EPA and
MN Department of Health Guidelines requires the City reduce contaminant levels of
radium and gross alpha in the immediate future.
Smith stated she wishes City had an alternative plan and had done some long term
planning to have seen the current circumstance. She stated that for the sake of the
City, the condemnation will have to occur. She stated that she felt empathy for Day as
the City has removed his ability to make a choice on what to do with his land.
Moved by Smith, seconded by Lane, to approve Resolution No. 04-54 Authorizing and
Directing the Use of the Power of Eminent Domain to Acquire Certain Property identified
at 780 Tower Drive for the Purpose of Constructing a Water Treatment Facility. Motion
passed unanimously.
3. Authorize Preparation of Plans and Specifications
Adams reviewed BRAA's memo explaining the recommendation of the Steel Gravity
Plant Option. Adams also stated that staff recommends that Council authorize
preparation of plans and specs for the Steel Gravity Plant option. By taking action
tonight, City will keep on schedule with the timeline outlined in the Feasibility Report.
Adams presented the schedule via overhead.
Miles Jensen of BRAA stated that he would be happy to answer any questions that
Council may have.
Zietlow stated he recalled at the last meeting, there was discussion in an attempt to
negotiate the engineering costs. Jensen stated that there is not a standard design, and
unfortunately the engineering costs reflect the time and detail that go into each design.
Moved by Workman, seconded by Smith, to authorize preparation of plans and
specifications of the Steel Gravity Plant. Motion passed unanimously.
4. Ordinance Amending City Fee Schedule — Hamel Water System Truck
Connection Rates
As discussed earlier in the introduction of this agenda item, staff is recommending
approval of the connection rate increase from $1,790 to $3,580 per unit. Adams stated
that staff is not seeking approval of the proposed user rate increase until its effective
date of January 1, 2005.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
285
Moved by Smith, seconded by Workman, to approve the Ordinance No. 375 Adopting
an Amended Fee Schedule. Motion passed unanimously.
B. Preliminary Plat to Allow a 21-lot Subdivision to be know as Keller Estates
for Property Located at 1255 Willow drive and the Adjacent Property to the
West — Dean Johnson Homes
Schield stated that this item was tabled from the September 7, 2004 meeting. Schield
reviewed the revised staff report that addresses conditions of the plat and project.
Following the September 7, 2004 meeting, staff advised the applicant to consider
working on conditions of the plat and other items.
Schield presented a site plan via overhead.
Dean Johnson, applicant from Dean Johnson Homes, stated that he had been hoping to
meet with staff prior to tonight's City Council Meeting but was unable to due to
unavailabilities, however he has received a voicemail since the last City Council meeting
that detailed items to be working on. Johnson inquired as to staff's decision on the road
extension to the west.
Adams stated that staff has not come to a conclusion and would refer to Council's
interpretation to how this matter should be treated. A unique concern is that the three
properties are already served by a cul-de-sac; if they were landlocked, then the City
would require a road access.
Smith stated that if this was subdivided, the three properties would have to obtain sewer.
The adjacent homeowners are not paying money to acquire sewer from Orono,
therefore Medina should not require the developer to construct a road extension.
Adams proposed a trail easement to the trail system in Orono, if a road is not required.
Steve Bohl, of Bohland Development, stated that he has aerial photos of the land as it
shows that there are lowlands in the discussed area, therefore it does not appear to
make sense or necessary to bring in a road to the three homes along the westerly area.
Johnson stated that easement splits through the low spots and drains off to the west.
Bohl stated that they are building houses along existing drainage. Workman asked if he
has talked to the three homeowners. Bohl stated that he did not think that it would
make sense to ask the three homeowners if they would sell the back half of their lots.
Dillman stated that because of the elevation, it would be difficult to have the lots
subdivided in order to get a road through there from the existing cul-de-sac.
Smith asked if the three homeowners would have to have sewer and water. Dillman
stated that the City would have to draw up the agreements.
Smith stated the landowner to west of these three parcels would be taking the property
out of Agricultural Preserve. Smith stated that if the three homeowners would want to
share in the $200,000 to get the road and sewer and water connection fees, then it
would make sense.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
286
Zietlow stated that if the three property owners were interested in dividing their property,
they would have been present at tonight's meeting.
Lane asked if the City would at least need an easement. Dillman stated yes. Lane
stated that he is in favor of an easement, but the road does not seem fair. Protecting
the access in the form of an easement would be appropriate.
Workman stated that the City should ask for an easement in order to protect the City's
future planning.
Bohl stated that he foresees a compromise. If there was an easement, the developer
could use the easement to create a wetland within.
Batty listed two options for defining the easement area: the definition could include
dedicating Right -Of -Way (ROW), or the City could allow some part of the dedicated or
unbuilt ROW to be dedicated to the pond.
Bohl presented the aerial photos to Smith and Zietlow.
Johnson stated that he would like Council to consider thinking about possibly allowing
for a retaining wall to the wall (only one wall) instead of around the pond. He stated that
these are things he could bring back to his engineer to work on.
Batty stated that instead of having a sixty -foot ROW, there would be a piece of the
ROW for either a pond or a slope that precludes the ability to use the road. He stated
that it would be unknown how much of an incursion this would be.
Dillman stated that the three homes are zoned SR. The Park Commission has been
discussing a trail to Old Crystal Bay Road, and one of the things discussed with the
homeowners was an exchange for a trail easement.
Workman stated that he is okay with the easement. He stated that he feels that
everything has to be self-contained in the development and is still concerned that the
development is too dense. Zietlow stated that density does meet zoning requirements.
Smith referenced rules from City of Plymouth that would not allow water to run-off and
has to be self-contained.
Kellogg stated that the purpose of the pond is to hold the run-off, and referenced the
self -containment of run-off on site has always been the philosophy in Medina.
Smith asked the developer how they were solving the wetland mitigation.
Bohl stated that his firm has done some investigation of their own on how to mitigate
land within the community. There are a couple of parcels in the community; however
the mitigation will have to take place offsite.
Smith stated that if the City was to have a policy to mitigate within the City, then Council
would need to have a discussion and create a policy.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
287
Lane stated that he remembers that Zietlow required mitigation within the watershed in
the City of Medina, and if not in Medina, than within the same watershed district. Lane
stated that although it is not the law, it is Medina's policy.
Lane asked Bohl if the mitigation will be done within the same watershed. Bohl stated
yes, but this is part of the negotiation. His firm would propose a boundary around
Medina, or within the watershed that serves Medina.
Lane asked how the other Council Members would feel about exhausting the efforts
within the remaining parts of Medina before going elsewhere in the Watershed district.
Workman stated that he would like it identified before approval.
Lane asked Batty for his clarification on the minutes from September 21, 2004 and a
reference that was made to an old agreement with the City of Medina. Batty stated that
a 1997 agreement, which he has reviewed, was an agreement entered into when the
City was trying to fix some drainage issues along the part of the development along the
west. In regard to parcel A, it was the area that the City was taking material out of in
order to have material to work with on the property to the west. The City, in the
agreement, stated that it would improve the wetland and make it a wetland. As far as
the City is concerned, the City could use it as storm water retention, have a dual use of
wetlands and storm water retention. If the two uses do not work together, than the
property owner would get to choose which method they would prefer and then would
have to be mitigated at the City's cost and effort.
Lane asked Batty with whom the 1997 agreement was between. Batty responded that
agreement was held between the City and the landowner.
Fred Keller expressed his frustration with the property along the north side of County
Road 6, as it was a property that was created for the purpose of being filled in with
mound systems. The process has taken thirty-five years. He stated that in his opinion,
the residents along the proposed development have been held "hostage" as the City of
Orono has taken its time in filling in the area.
Doug Sorenson, resident on Morningside Road, stated that Medina issued a permit for a
landowner to build a house back in the development. In result, the ditch was narrowed
and the water has washed away a lot more soil. He stated that the three lots in question
are not Medina Morningside lots, they are Beasley Bluffs.
Keller stated that past city engineer designed this development to hold forty houses.
Smith asked why the City would not consider looping the easement around so that it did
not end in a dead end road. Zietlow stated that someday when the area is developed
into five additional lots; it would make sense to have an easement for a future road.
Zietlow stated that Council needs to figure out how to mitigate the land for easement.
Lane asked how the drainage issues would be addressed if the City was to create a
road easement. Zietlow stated that if the City had an easement, the pond could be
lowered, and the pond could be reduced with a larger slope so that it gradually slopes
onto the easement.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
288
Batty suggested that the plat be dedicated to the easement. The easement would be an
encroaching drainage easement which would provide the City a provisionary mechanism
of corrective action if the road would go through.
Lane stated that would be a condition for a development in the future.
Zietlow stated that he senses a compromise. Bohl agreed.
Zietlow stated that City would like more information on how the rain gardens and pond
(both located on somebody else's land) were going to be maintained.
Batty stated that in order to create a special taxing district, an adoption of an ordinance
(2/3 vote) and a public hearing would need to occur. The City would establish a district
for as small, or as large, as deemed necessary and only of which would be used as a
last minute measure to tax those benefited, and if the pond was not being maintained.
Bohl stated that his firm would have the homeowners association agreement as part of
the final documents submitted for approval.
Zietlow stated Medina would need documentation or proof of developer's agreement
with Orono for sewer and water. Bohl stated that agreement has already been through
Orono's Council and the proper documentation will be presented to Medina.
Smith asked if the City was going to use term "storm water retention pond" instead of
"wetland". Kellogg stated yes.
Smith asked if City would have to pay to mitigate the wetland. Kellogg stated that is
what he had understood Batty to say. Bohl re -instated his firm will work with City.
Zietlow asked for clarification on the wording of the seventeen conditions and whether
the only noted change was the request for an easement for a road.
Smith asked if the change would require an added condition number eighteen for an
addition of an easement. Adams stated staff would work on wording of condition.
Brinkman stated that after hearing the history from Keller and despite the fact that there
will be fewer lots, if the City could get the land mitigated and worked out, than he would
be willing to change his original vote. He acknowledged that the developer has been
working hard on making the development work.
Zietlow asked for clarification from Brinkman on whether he was willing to change his
vote with an additional condition for the easement for the road. Brinkman stated yes.
Lane asked where the condition discussing the special 444 district was. Batty stated
that the tax district was not a condition for approval, however is a condition of control for
the City.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
289
Lane proposed changing condition number seventeen to include City authorization of
setting up a district 444 tax district.
Bohl asked if the tax district condition would be a fail-safe method that would be set up
in addition to the homeowners' agreement. Zietlow stated yes.
Zietlow asked Council if the members felt comfortable approving the preliminary plat
with the conditions as is, or if they wanted to take additional time to solidify the wording.
Workman stated that he would like to see everything ironed and written out.
Zietlow stated that the developer is going to need some type of a guarantee from the
City that it is okay to precede with the next step.
Adams stated that the process would simply authorize staff to prepare a resolution.
Moved by Smith, seconded by Brinkman, to authorize staff to prepare a resolution for
the preliminary plat with conditions 1-17 with the modifying of condition 17 to set up
district 444 tax district and creating a new condition #18 for the addition of a road
easement.
Motion passed 3 — 2 (Workman and Lane opposed).
VIII. NEW BUSINESS
A. Conditional Use Permit Amendment and Site Plan Amendment to Allow a
42,080-square foot Building Expansion for Walter G. Anderson located at
4535 Willow Drive — Olson General Contractors
Schield reviewed the memo from staff, which provides an overview of the request and
recommended conditions. Olson General Contractors is requesting approval of a
conditional use permit amendment and a site plan amendment to allow a 42,080-square
foot building expansion for Walter G. Anderson. The expansion would include a 38,400-
square foot manufacturing/warehouse addition on the west side of the existing building.
The expansion would also include a 3,680-square foot office addition on the south side
of the existing building. Walter G. Anderson is requesting the building expansion due to
the growth of their business. The Planning Commission, with noted conditions, has
approved the CUP and Site Plan.
Schield stated staff recommends approval of the conditional use permit amendment and
site plan amendment to allow the expansion subject to conditions of approval.
Zietlow asked if Council had any questions. Workman stated that he has a question
pertaining to the condition of approval on the new overhead door and why the Planning
Commission had removed the condition.
Schield stated removal of the condition had to do with the interior layout and ease of
movement. Schield stated that applicant clarified the reason was due to production
layout and ease of moving in large pieces of equipment
Smith stated that the addition and the windows are a great improvement.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
290
Wally Gervais, representing Walter G. Anderson, stated that he is concerned about the
amount of glass proposed for the addition. He stated that the ordinance does allow for
stucco panels and yet the Planning Commission would not allow for the stucco panels
without providing reasons for denial. He stated that glass is a safety hazard along west
side of building, which is the manufacturing side. He stated that approximately thirty-five
people work in that area, ten thousand dollars worth of equipment is in that area, and
with weather as a concern, the glass along the southwestern side of the land does not
seem to make sense. He stated that if City will not allow for stucco panels, then he
would go with glass. He stated that he would like it noted that he would prefer stucco.
Smith stated that natural light creates a healthier work environment. Gervais stated that
the windows will increase his heating and air conditioning costs.
Brinkman stated he was part of the Planning Commission when the application was first
looked at. He stated that the applicant was barely meeting the current code. Brinkman
stated that the glass makes the building look good and smart. He stated that he wants
to see the addition and improvements as presented before Council today.
Zietlow stated that his addition makes for a classy looking building which will attract
other classy businesses.
Gervais stated his building is a manufacturing business, and glass will be raising the
cost of manufacturing and will jeopardize jobs.
Gervais stated that he will build the addition as required, however, as a manufacturer, it
does not make sense and feels that he will be wasting money.
Moved by Workman, seconded by Smith, to authorize staff to prepare resolution
approving the conditional use permit amendment and site plan amendment to allow a
42,080-square foot building expansion for Walter G. Anderson located at 4535 Willow
Drive, subject to conditions of approval. Motion passed unanimously.
B. Conditional Use Permit Amendment and a Variance to Allow Construction
up to a 700-spare foot Chemical Storage Building at the baker National Golf
course located at 2935 Parkview drive — Three Rivers Park District.
Schield reviewed memo from staff that provides detail on application with conditions.
Three Rivers Park District is requesting approval of a conditional use permit amendment
and a variance to allow up to a 700-square foot accessory building. The accessory
building would be used to store and mix chemicals used by golf course. Three Rivers
Park District currently has a 144-square foot wood -frame building that is used for
storage of chemicals. The mixing of chemicals is currently performed on an existing
concrete pad adjacent to existing accessory building. The applicant is proposing to
remove existing wood -frame building and replace it with up to a 700-square foot building
in same location. Since building is larger in size, building would be located on footprint
of existing building and over current outside mixing area. The Planning Commission
has approved and forwarded the application to the City Council.
Schield presented plans and photos of the proposed project. Schield stated that staff
recommends approval of the conditional use permit amendment and variance.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
291
Gary Klingelhoets, Maintenance Supervisor at Baker National Golf Course, stated that
the chemicals are mainly fungicides. The golf course does not hardly use any
pesticides. Baker also stores chemicals for Glen Lake and Eagle Lake who store their
remaining chemicals over the winter.
Zietlow asked if fertilizers were stored in building. Klingelhoets stated he is required to
hold two hundred pounds of weed and feed fertilizers, as well as a three hundred pound
sprayer. The fertilizers will be mixed inside building which will be able to contain up to
1,500 gallons, which is way more than Golf Course needs. He stated that in his history
of employment, he has never had a spill of over five gallons. Klingelhoets stated that
during the 2004 season, the Golf Course did not have any insecticides.
Klingelhoets stated building size will not change amount of chemicals golf course plans
to store.
Loren Kohnen, City Fire Marshal, will need to be provided with chemical data sheets of
all chemicals used and stored within the building.
Klingelhoets stated there will be an eye wash and shower located in building. He stated
this building is state of the art modeled after State of Illinois guidelines for chemical
containment. Klingelhoets stated building will be protected with alarm system.
Brinkman stated he would like building painted brown or green. He stated he has
concerns with other businesses storing their chemicals in this building. Brinkman stated
he is concerned there will be a lot of traffic coming in and out of property.
Marjorie Walz, Director of Park Operations Services, stated there is a small percentage
of chemicals from other companies, as they only bring over what has not been used
upon the end of the Fall season.
Brinkman asked for clarification on whether 80% of the chemicals being stored in the
building are used strictly for Baker Park. Klingelhoets stated yes.
Brinkman asked for clarification as to why the chemicals are brought to the building.
Walz stated that this building is heated and therefore the chemicals will not freeze. The
other facilities do not have heated storage.
Klingelhoets stated a lot of the stored chemicals are wettable powders versus liquids.
Klingelhoets stated they would like to paint the building white to match their other
buildings and shop. He clarified golfers will not see the building from the course.
Brinkman asked that material data sheets be forwarded to the Fire Marshal, including
those from the other two facilities as well. Brinkman also requested that the Golf
Course clearly post signage on the building indicating that it is for chemical storage.
Workman stated that it is his opinion that the building is a great improvement and
commended the applicant for moving forward with the project.
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
292
Moved by Workman, seconded by Brinkman, to authorize staff to prepare the resolution
to a approve the conditional use permit amendment and variance to allow construction
up to a 700-square foot chemical storage building at the Baker National Golf Course
located at 2935 Parkview Drive. Motion passed unanimously.
C. Uptown Hamel Public Improvements
Adams stated that after accepting the Feasibility reports at the last meeting, the next
step is to move forward with calling for a public hearing on the public improvements.
Staff is suggesting November 16, 2004 for the public hearing. Prior to that date, staff
will need to make a recommendation on the storm water design options of which staff
will be doing in coming weeks. Another item to be addressed will be how much to
assess and against whom for the public improvements; all of which can be discussed at
an upcoming meeting as well as prior to the public hearing date.
Kellogg stated that he had nothing to add.
Lane asked Batty for at what point does City determine assessment of these projects.
Batty stated assessment hearings would not be until a year from now in keeping with
schedule. The notices that have to go out with these hearings have to be accompanied
with estimates of the cost of improvement. The notice must describe the methodology
in determining the most suitable option, which will be presented at the public hearing.
Council will have to have thought it out thoroughly enough so that people have a
reasonable guess as to how much improvement will cost. If any additional questions or
issues are raised, Council will have two more meetings to address those. Batty stated
Council had special meeting in June and staff will review notes to prepare something
that will be in agreement with what was discussed back then.
1. Resolution Calling for Public Hearing on the Improvement of Mill Drive
Moved by Lane, seconded by Workman, to approve Resolution No. 04-55 Calling for
Public Hearing on November 16, 2004 the Improvement of Mill Drive. Motion passed
unanimously.
2. Resolution calling for Public Hearing on Roadway and Sidewalk
Improvements on Sioux Drive from Hamel Road to Vicinity of the Railroad
Tracks south of T.H. 55
Moved by Lane, seconded by Brinkman, to approve Resolution No. 04-56 calling for
Public Hearing on Roadway and Sidewalk Improvements on Sioux Drive from Hamel
Road to Vicinity of the Railroad Tracks south of T.H. 55. Motion passed unanimously.
3. Resolution Calling for Public Hearing on Uptown Hamel Storm Water and
Drainage Improvement Project
Moved by Smith, seconded by Brinkman, to approve Resolution No. 04-57 Calling for
Public Hearing on Uptown Hamel Storm Water and Drainage Improvement Project.
Motion passed unanimously.
Zietlow asked Batty whether City would have option of choosing option number two in
future for storm water. Kellogg stated that even though option number one is more
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
293
expensive, for purposes of the public hearing, it would be better to indicate the highest
cost option. The City can change its mind; and if the options do change, then it will
appear to be good news for the public.
Batty stated that an option would need to be decided upon in order for staff to order
specs and plans.
D. Brady Wetland Mitigation — Approval of Agreement
Dillman reviewed his report on the Brady wetland mitigation project and agreement. The
agreement outlines the process and responsibility of Brady's to create a new wetland for
mitigation purposes. Staff is seeking Council approval of the agreement.
Smith asked if the manure being used to enrich the soil around the pond would be
composted or raw. Dillman stated the manure would be composted.
Zietlow stated that the key here is to approve mitigation of wetlands. Smith stated she
agreed and simply wanted to express her opinion against using raw manure.
Zietlow stated City would be providing most of the front work which would consist mostly
of engineering costs in which landowners would have two years to pay it back.
Moved by Workman, seconded by Smith, to proceed with the process to create a new
wetland for mitigation purposes for Patrick and Diane Brady at 4700 Covey Trail.
Motion passed unanimously.
E. Lakeshore Park Boat Ramp to Lake Independence
Adams stated that upon receiving two quotes, staff is seeking a recommendation to
proceed with the project. The quote is for $18,200 for a ramp going into the water. The
project was budgeted for $15,000. Even though project will be over budget, the
playground equipment project came $10,000 under the budget. This item is a capital
improvement project planned and budgeted for 2004. The Park Commission has been
reviewing and discussing options for Council approval over the past several months.
Dillman explained layout of boat ramp as it slopes into the water focusing on possible
problems with the design and consumer misuse. Due to slope of hill, these boat ramps
can last anywhere from a year to a couple of years depending on abuse and use.
Moved by Workman, seconded by Brinkman, to approve the project and funding for the
Boat Ramp. Motion passed unanimously.
F. Open Candidate's Forum
Adams stated that Smith had asked for this item to be added to the September 21, 2004
Council meeting agenda, which it was, but then was forgotten.
Smith stated she has a belief that best way to know one's candidates is to allow them to
speak. She stated she did call the Minnesota League of Women Voters to ask for their
assistance in moderating; however they are very busy at this time.
Smith stated general rule of a forum requires that moderator not be a person from the
City, or from a business within the City. Smith stated there would be an allotted time
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
294
period for a presentation by the candidates. She stated she would be willing to find a
moderator as she knows of a person who was part of MN League of Women Voters.
Zietlow stated he would be concerned that nobody would show up and does not want to
see this forum as a waste of time.
Smith stated that nobody would show up if the City did not allow the candidates or
residents an opportunity to appear. Lane stated that he too would be concerned that
nobody would show up, but is willing to give the forum a try anyway.
Zietlow asked the four present candidates for their opinion.
Doug Meldrum stated that he is okay with the forum but also agrees that he does not
think many people would be present.
Batty stated that the City should not be involved in the forum other than providing the
space. The forum is not an official City event. He stated that involving a member of the
League of Voters is perfect, as another entity should organize the event.
Zietlow asked if a motion should be made. Batty stated no, as the City would not be
providing any money or assistance in the event. He proposed however that a motion be
made in order to allow Smith to proceed with contacting a forum moderator.
Zietlow proposed targeting Tuesday, October 26, 2004 as the date for the forum.
Batty stated that the Council might need to have a special meeting on October 26, 2004
anyway (as discussed under the Administrator Report).
Motion by Brinkman, seconded by Smith, to authorize Councilor Smith to find a
moderator for the forum to take place in late October of 2004. Motion passed
unanimously.
IX. ADMINISTRATION
A. City Administrator Report
Adams provided updates on the following:
1. Hamel Community Building
Adams stated that there will be a progress meeting on October 6, 2004. He stated that
there are two agents that are interested in operating the building. Staff has just sent out
the RFP and neither one of the agents provided a complete proposal. The RFPs will
need to be clarified a little more.
2. City Hall improvements
Adams stated that he has met with the consultant today and received a draft plan of
three improvement options. Staff is focusing on the middle approach and wants to take
it to staff first for comments before forwarding it to Council.
3. Met Council discussions for Bridgewater Amendment
Adams stated he and Dillman met with staff to clarify some of the conditions of the
amendment. The Met Council Community Development Committee (CDC) met Monday
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
295
and discussed general policies for urban development using Medina as examples for the
discussion. The conversation with Met Council staff following the CDC meeting included
a discussion of wanting to take these policy guidelines to full Met Council October 13,
2004 for approval nd for the City of Medina to defer the Bridgewater discussion to
October 27, 2004 as to not confuse the policy discussion. They talked about dropping
the fourth condition. Staff also talked with the Cudd Development, and Cudd is
acceptable with putting it off upon receipt of an extension.
Adams stated that Medina's letter was effective in demonstrating its standing and
believes it may have made an impact on Met Council.
Lane stated that in his opinion, it sounded as if Met Council is trying to establish their
policy framework before addressing Medina's amendment. There is room or opportunity
to work with the Met Council in regard to the amendment before Met Council finalizes
their decision.
Lane asked Batty if it was inappropriate to work out a stipulation ahead of time with Met
Council. Batty stated that it may not be necessary for Medina to formalize the process
of making provisions with Met Council as Adams is doing all that he can to predetermine
what the committee is thinking.
4. Special Meeting
Adams stated that a number of deadlines are approaching that may warrant a special
meeting due to their timeliness, namely the City Planner search, Uptown Hamel special
assessments, Cudd project, Hamel Community Building operational agreement, and
space planning for City Hall.
X. APPROVAL TO PAY THE BILLS
Moved by Workman, seconded by Smith, to approve the bills, order check numbers
027034-027075 for $48,091.05 and payroll check numbers 018887-018909 for
$23,973.04. Motion passed unanimously.
XI. ADJOURN
Moved by Workman, seconded by Smith, to adjourn the meeting at 10:31 p.m. Motion
passed unanimously. n
ilip K. Zietlow, Mayor
Attest:
Chad M. Adams, City Administrator
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
296
(THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK INTENTIONALLY)
Medina City Council Meeting Minutes
October 5, 2004
297
ORDER CHECKS - OCTOBER 5, 2004
027034 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION $75.00
027035 AMERICAN SUPPLY GROUP $82.58
027036 BARCO MUNICIPAL PRODUCTS $452.42
027037 BEST WESTERN KELLY INN $80.64
027038 BONESTROO, ROSENE, ANDERLIK $9,124.24
027039 BUDGET PRINTING $225.58
027040 BUFFALO BITUMINOUS $1,645.36
027041 CENTERPOINT ENERGY $33.55
027042 CLASSIC CLEANING $399.38
027043 EHLERS & ASSOC. $1,400.00
027044 ERICKSON, ROLF ENT., INC $4,900.15
027045 FISCHER, CHRIS $25.00
027046 FORTIS BENEFITS $322.46
027047 HENNEPIN CO.TREAS.(JAIL SVC.) $459.00
027048 HENNEPIN COUNTY SHERIFF$253.86
027049 HIGHWAY 55 RENTAL $80.80
027050 INN, THE ON LAKE SUPERIOR $89.27
027051 KATOLIGHT CORPORATION $395.32
027052 KEN'S SNOWPLOWING & BOBCAT $2,000.00
027053 LAKE BUSINESS SUPPLY $114.44
027054 LAW ENFORCEMENT LABOR SERVICES $222.00
027055 LAWSON PRODUCTS, INC $304.30
027056 MARSHALL CONCRETE PRODUCTS $4,850.02
027057 MCGILL, CHRISTOPHER $50.00
027058 MEDICA CHOICE $12,382.89
027059 METROCALL $21.07
027060 NATIONAL WATERWORKS $863.06
027061 NEXTEL COMMUNICATIONS $673.29
027062 PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE CO. OF AM $224.25
027063 QWEST $467.51
027064 RANDY'S SANITATION $109.62
027065 STREICHER'S $411.78
027066 SUPERIOR WIRELESS $184.20
027067 TIME SAVER OFF SUE SEC. $282.45
027068 TRUGREEN CHEMLAWN (OSSEO) $1,919.16
027069 TWIN CITY WATER CLINIC $45.00
027070 VALVOLINE FLEET SERVICES $120.39
027071 WEETMAN, DAVID & MARIA $40.00
027072 WEST SIDE REDI MIX $368.76
027073 WESTSIDE WHOLESALE TIRE $359.47
027074 WRIGHT-HENNEPIN ELECTRIC $2,295.96
027075 XCEL ENERGY $36.82
$48,091.05
298 PAYROLL CHECKS - OCTOBER 4, 2004
018887 WORKMAN, BRUCE $138.52
018888 SMITH, CAROLYN A. $138.52
018889 BRINKMAN, RANDY $138.52
018890 ZIETLOW, PHILIP K. $207.79
018891 CHAFFINS, GARY S $793.39
018892 ADAMS, CHAD M. $1,786.96
018893 SCHERER, STEVEN T $1,218.75
018894 MCGILL, CHRISTOPHER R. $1,744.34
018895 HALL, DAVID M. $1,297.43
018896 DILLMAN, JAMES D $1,790.18
018897 DRESSEL, ROBERT P. $1,069.28
018898 BELLAND, EDGAR J $2,189.87
018899 CONVERSE, KEITH A $1,024.70
018900 VIEAU, CECILIA M. $1,037.11
018901 DINGMANN, IVAN W $1,102.26
018902 SULANDER, LAURA L. $1,155.21
018903 LARSON, SANDRA L $945.47
018904 BOECKER, KEVIN D $1,291.16
018905 GREGORY, THOMAS $1,394.78
018906 GRASSMAN, MICHELLE L $422.58
018907 LANE, JAMES S. $138.52
018908 NELSON, JASON $1,576.75
018909 THUL, JEFFREY P. $1,370.95
$23,973.04