The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My Public Portal About20200615plCC5 701-32 DOCUMENTS IN THIS PACKET INCLUDE: LETTERS FROM CITIZENS TO THE MAYOR OR CITY COUNCIL RESPONSES FROM STAFF TO LETTERS FROM CITIZENS ITEMS FROM MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS ITEMS FROM OTHER COMMITTEES AND AGENCIES ITEMS FROM CITY, COUNTY, STATE, AND REGIONAL AGENCIES Prepared for: 06/15/2020 Document dates: 5/27/2020 – 6/3/2020 Set 5 of 6 Note: Documents for every category may not have been received for packet reproduction in a given week. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. To whom it may concern, I would be thrilled if Palo Alto were to follow the trend of Menlo Park and Mountain View to include Parklets as a part of the downtown experience. Honestly, I know for my family and myself, we actively seek out communities where we feel safe walking around, get to enjoy our incredible weather as well as get some great food. We go to other communities to achieve this. It would be wonderful for us to be able to walk / bike downtown and dine outdoors. Given the Covid 19 restrictions, I would be far more encouraged to dine outdoors and would hope that Palo Alto would make this possible for both the businesses as well as customers looking to get out. Thank you for your consideration. If you have any questions or would like to follow up my contact information is: Shealan Singh (teacher in PAUSD) shea@blueacre.com Best, Shealan 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Marc A. Bienaimé | | @marcbienaime6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Palo Alto City Council: I urge you accept the proposal from the Palo Alto city staff to exempt stores like Mac's Smoke Shop from the proposed flavored tobacco ban. Small retail stores are all suffering from the Covid-19 pandemic. Why would you want to drive Mac's Smoke Shop out of business? Or any other store out of business? Moreover, Mac's Smoke Shop is a Palo Alto icon. Shutting down Mac's Smoke Shop would be a terrible mistake. I hope you can find a way to keep Mac's Smoke Shop open. Sincerely yours, Peter Enemark Peter Enemark P. O. Box 20364 Palo Alto, CA 94309 CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 6IHEGXIH CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Dear Members of the Palo Alto City Council, I am writing this to appeal to you to reconsider your ban on vaping as regards Macs Smoke Shop, and to request that you exempt that shop from the ban. Macs is, after all, more than just a smoke shop. Its a newsstand, too. And they sell lottery tickets. My husband has been buying a copy of the Saturday New York Times and a lottery ticket from Macs every Saturday, without fail, for the past 30 years. Macs is an institution in Palo Alto. Part of Palo Altos commercial history. Id hate for our city to lose this resource. My husband would join me in this appeal, but for the fact that he now has dementia, and while he still wants his Saturday New York Times and the lottery ticket, doesnt quite understand why Macs would be closing. He thinks that would be impossible. It would be something Id have to explain to him over and over again. Thank you for your consideration of my request. Regards, Kristina P. Smith (Mrs. Robert Johnstone) 1144 Cedar Street CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. From: Iris Zhang <ihzhang@stanford.edu> Sent: Tuesday, June 2, 2020 6:57 PM To: Council, City <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Concerns about curfew For consideration for the next city council meeting agenda packet: Dear city council members: In implementation of the curfew, the city says that it is out of concern for keeping this town safe. Let me assure you, the blatant racism is dripping out from between the lines. Curfews are about protecting the Apple Store and Stanford Shopping Center, based on baseless racist fearmongering, not about protecting everyday people like myself. Mayor Fine, am I more important, or is the latest Macbook Pro more important? How do I know for a fact that you value that latest Macbook Pro more than you value me? 1. You couldn’t stop people standing in the line waiting to get into Ramen Nagi, standing shoulder to shoulder, under shelter in place officially came down, at the height of COVID spreading. 2. Not even in the face of the COVID and white nationalists showing up to the state house with military-grade weapons, did you institute a curfew, which would have legitimately protected many of the vulnerable population in this town, and gasp: maybe even the latest Macbook Pro. And yet, a few people gather in support of black lives, and all of a sudden, you’re telling us we should all be afraid lest you see a black man walking down the streets after 8:30pm. 3. How about when people were biking around, terrorizing Asian-looking people when COVID panic was settling? These were credible, actual, real, events that happened. They actually happened. Even then, there was no curfew in the name of protecting people who look like me. Before looting actually happens—because it hasn’t happened, you decided that it was necessary to have a curfew. What is it about supporting black rights that inspires so much panic before anything has even happened, that we take such extreme measures as a curfew for 10 days? You reiterate that it’s about safety concerns. Please examine how your perception of what is unsafe is deeply shaped by racism. In one of the richest and most privileged neighborhoods in the entire country, with ADT alarm signs littering the front lawns of every single household, we are willing to give up fundamental liberties and rights because white people are afraid? Not me, but it seems clear that my opinion or my safety doesn’t matter because I’m not white. The racist reactions of my neighbors, and this entire city council, disgust and anger me. I hope you appreciate that all you have done is validate irrational, racist perceptions of black people. I feel more unsafe than ever. Imagine living in a community that hoards wealth and resources through exclusive zoning and building no new housing, and the only concern you have is that someone might come and take some, after the government killed a man in broad daylight for no other reason than that he is black. You imposing a curfew because of the threat of riots, before anything has actually happened, is just like justifying the use of a chokehold against the “threat" that a black man imposes when he is already on the ground, hands cuffed behind his back. Iris -- Iris Zhang | Stanford Sociology ihzhang@stanford.edu CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Via Email May 31, 2020 Palo Alto City Council Honorable Mayor Fine and City Council members, The Palo Alto Chamber of Commerce enthusiastically supports creating pedestrian/bikeonly, pilot street closure projects on University and California Avenues to allow for outdoor retail and restaurant use. To gauge business sentiment and willingness to experiment with street closures, we conducted surveys with businesses in the two commercial zones over the past two weeks. The results show an extraordinarily high percentage of support for partial street closures on both streets, by both restaurants and other business owners, and for all weekdays. The response from University Avenue businesses 83% in favor The response from California Avenue 93% in favor In addition, 63% of University Ave respondents and 79% of Cal Ave respondents agreed that, to avoid confusion, the street closures should be all days of the week to better judge the success of the pilot encourage longer shopping periods and accommodate pedestrian walktime, [the City should] extend weekday parking hours We believe concerns about adequate parking nearby, access for trash pickup and delivery trucks, and ability to locate businesses can be met with simple solutions, such as signage and shopping time restrictions. The Chamber proposes that the City consider the following strategies, some being longer term: time, change 1 to 2 floors of underutilized permit parking garage spaces to regular parking, made more feasible given the predicted reduction in onsite office workers going forward, change permit to regular parking on the west side of Alma Street from Everett to Palo Alto Avenue, create specially designated, shortterm parking zones at side streets for pickup/delivery, car share/taxi services and bike racks, and evaluate the program monthly for modifications as needed, and conduct an in depth review of 56 months. These changes alone would add nearby, accessible parking spaces in both commercial zones, dozens more than the ones being lost by street closures or parklets, within a short walk of the businesses while mitigating any increase in adjacent neighborhood parking. We reviewed the survey results with City Manager Ed Shikada on Friday and are gratified that he then reached out to businesses in these two areas to begin working with them on plans for sharing the streets. Palo Alto City Council Page Two Restauranteurs have warned that when reopening is permitted, safe table distancing rules will render them financially unable to succeed with only inside dining unless they are may add outdoor seating. Acknowledging this situation, Gov. Newsom has stated that restaurants should "prioritize" outdoor seating when their local jurisdictions meet the criteria for reopening. Palo Alto already has experience with successful pedestrianonly shopping, such as the California Avenue Farmers Market, the Palo Alto Art Festival and Stanford Shopping Center. Pedestrian/bikeonly shopping areas in commercial zones are currently being considered or already being created in other Bay Area cities, such as Redwood City, San Carlos, Burlingame and Berkeley, and highly successful pedestrian only commercial zones exist in such cities as Boulder and Santa Monica. Pedestrian and bike only street malls are popular throughout Europe, and parklets using street parking spaces are already allowed in such local cities as Menlo Park and Santa Cruz. We believe the survey results strongly reinforce the calls by both residents and businesses for the City to help commercial districts recover from the Covid19 closures by partially closing these two commercial streets to cars and allowing businesses to safely serve customers outdoors. With the decrease in car usage and parking demand, and the need for restaurants, the linchpins of our commercial districts, to be able to reopen in a financially sustainable way, the timing is perfect to conduct these pilot programs and see if it works for our community and our businesses. We respectfully urge the City Council to expedite the approval of these street sharing proposals. Sincerely, Judy Kleinberg President Charlie Weidanz CEO CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Snapshot of the item below: Café Venetia 419 University Ave Palo Alto, California 94301 www.cafevenetia.com all and real Cafe Venetia 419 University Ave 95 University Ave Palo Alto, California 94301 Preserving tradition… CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. 26 May 25, 2020 Palo Alto City Council Dear Council Members, I am writing as a concerned citizen to request that certain standards regarding the placement and operation of new 5G cell towers in our city. There must be a balance between the needs of cell service and the safety and other public welfare needs of all of our residents. Specifically: Any new cell tower or other wireless communication facility must adhere to the 100 foot setback from residential homes. There must be no exception to the 1500 foot setback from schools, and no exceptions to the 1500 foot distance between cell service devices along residential streets. Any installed cell tower/device must adhere to a maximum 45 decibel noise level output. Thank you for your concern and responsiveness to these important safety and quality of life issues. Sincerely Howard Belfer & Laurie LeventhalBelfer GreenAcres I residents since 1989 CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Build smart for flexible living. 92()60=-2+>32)78%2(%6(7%6)¬ *VSQ2MGOPIWW+VIK$,'(+VIK2MGOPIWW$LGHGEKSZ 7YFNIGX6)%(9PSXPMRIWIXFEGOW (EXI1E]EX41 8S.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ +VIK2MGOPIWW ,SYWMRK4SPMG]7TIGMEPMWX ,SYWMRK 'SQQYRMX](IZIPSTQIRX ;)P'EQMRS%ZIRYI7YMXI`7EGVEQIRXS'% 4LSRI .IWWMGE %PSGEPEKIRG]WLEPPRSXVIUYMVI%(9WMHISVVIEVTVSTIVX]PMRIWIXFEGOWSJQSVIXLER¬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`'SPPIGXMZI &YMPHWQEVXJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR?PMROIHMRGSQA CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC .IWWMGE % PSGEP EKIRG] QE] RSX VIUYMVI E WMHI SV VIEV PSX PMRI WIXFEGO SJ QSVI XLER JSYV¬ [LIXLIV XLI +VIK2MGOPIWW ,SYWMRK4SPMG]7TIGMEPMWX ,SYWMRK 'SQQYRMX](IZIPSTQIRX ;)P'EQMRS%ZIRYI7YMXI`7EGVEQIRXS'% 4LSRI %PSGEPEKIRG]QE]RSXVIUYMVIEWMHISVVIEVPSXPMRIWIXFEGOSJQSVIXLERJSYV [LIXLIVXLI %(9MWEXXEGLIHSVHIXEGLIH +VIK %(9`'SPPIGXMZI &YMPHWQEVXJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR ?PMROIHMRGSQA 3R1E]EX41*VIRGL%Q] %Q]*VIRGL$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXSSVK"[VSXI 8LIVIUYMVIHWIXFEGOHITIRHWSR[LIXLIV]SYVGPMIRXMWVIP]MRKSR+SZ'SHII % 4%1'E 8LMW[SYPHQIERXLI]EVIPSSOMRKXSMKRSVIXLIVIUYMVIQIRXW SJ4%1'E E E ERHE MRFYMPHMRKXLIEXXEGLIH%(9-JWSXLIR XLI]QYWXGSQTP][MXLFEWI^SRIWIXFEGOW -JRSXMIXLI][MPPGSQTP]4%1'E E ERHE XLIRXLI]GERFYMPHXS EJSSXWIXFEGO %Q]*VIRGL`'LMIJ4PERRMRK3J´GMEP ,EQMPXSR%ZIRYI`4EPS%PXS'% (`)EQ]JVIRGL$GMX]SJTEPSEPXSSVK 4PIEWIXLMROSJXLIIRZMVSRQIRXFIJSVITVMRXMRKXLMWIQEMP§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¬XLIEVHGSR´VQEXMSRSRXLMW%R]YTHEXI#''MRKXLIGPMIRXLIVIWSLIGEROIITXEFW SRXMQIPMRI8LI]EVIVIEH]XSQSZIJSV[EVH %WWYQMRKXLIWXEXIPE[MW[LEX[IWLSYPHJSPPS[ERHXLEXER%(9QE]FI¬JVSQXLI TVSTIVX]PMRIRSQEXXIVMJMX¬WEXXEGLIHHIXEGLIHFYX[ERXXSFIMRGSQQYRMGEXMSREFSYXER] UYIWXMSRW 8LEROW .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZI &YMPHWQEVXJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR?PMROIHMRGSQA 3R1E]EX416IMGL6YWW 6YWW6IMGL$GMX]SJTEPSEPXSSVK" [VSXI ,IPPS.IWWMGE 8LERO]SYJSVXLI,'(TIVWTIGXMZI;I[MPPGSVVIWTSRH[MXLSYV%XXSVRI]ERH KIXFEGOXS]SY%PPXLIWI%(9VIKYPEXMSRWEVIWSQYGLJYR-GER¬X[EMXXSWII LS[XLMRKWGSQIHS[RSRXLMWSRI 8LEROW MQEKITRK"6YWW6IMGL 4PERRMRK1EREKIV 4PERRMRKERH(IZIPSTQIRX7IVZMGIW `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`'SPPIGXMZI +VIK2MGOPIWW ,SYWMRK4SPMG]7TIGMEPMWX ,SYWMRK 'SQQYRMX](IZIPSTQIRX ;)P'EQMRS%ZIRYI7YMXI `7EGVEQIRXS'% 4LSRI 7QEVXFYMPHMRKJSVJPI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR?PMROIHMRGSQA &IKMRJSV[EVHIHQIWWEKI *VSQ2MGOPIWW+VIK$,'( +VIK2MGOPIWW$LGHGEKSZ" (EXI1E]EX414(8 8S.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ" 7YFNIGX %(9PSXPMRIWIXFEGOW .IWWMGE %PSGEPEKIRG]QE]RSXVIUYMVIEWMHISVVIEVPSXPMRIWIXFEGOSJ QSVIXLERJSYV¬ [LIXLIVXLI%(9MWEXXEGLIHSVHIXEGLIH +VIK *VSQ.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ" 7IRX1SRHE]1E]41 8S6IMGL6YWW 6YWW6IMGL$GMX]SJTEPSEPXSSVK"2MGOPIWW +VIK$,'( +VIK2MGOPIWW$LGHGEKSZ" 'G*VIRGL%Q] %Q]*VIRGL$GMX]SJTEPSEPXSSVK"7EYPW+EVVIXX +EVVIXX7EYPW$GMX]SJTEPSEPXSSVK" 7YFNIGX6I0SMW0ERI ,M6YWW 8LMWMWEPPSZIVQ]LIEH-¬QPSSTMRK+VIK2MGOPIWW[MXL,'(MR 4IVQ]YRHIVWXERHMRKSJXLIWXEXIPE[EVIUYMVIHWMHISVVIEVWIXFEGO SJSZIV¬MWRSXMRGSQTPMERGI[MXLWXEXYI%(9PE[+SZ'SHI 7IGXMSRE ( ZMM G ' SVI & VIKEVHPIWWSJMJ MX¬WEXXEGLIHSVHIXEGLIH .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZI 7QEVXFYMPHMRKJSVJPI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR?PMROIHMRGSQA 3R1E]EX%16IMGL6YWW 6YWW6IMGL$GMX]SJTEPSEPXSSVK"[VSXI ,IPPS.IWWMGE -XMWQ]YRHIVWXERHMRKXLEXEREXXEGLIH%(9MWVIUYMVIH XSJSPPS[XLIWEQIWIXFEGOWEWXLIVIWMHIRGIXLEXMXMW EXXEGLIHXS8LMW[SYPHVIWYPXMREWM\SVIMKLXJSSXWMHI ]EVHWIXFEGOHITIRHMRKSRXLI^SRMRKSJXLITVSTIVX] -J]SYFIPMIZIXLEX4EPS%PXS¬WQYRMGMTEPGSHIMWMR GSRµMGX[MXL7XEXIPE[TPIEWITVSZMHIXLITEVXMGYPEV 7XEXIGSHIWIGXMSRMRUYIWXMSRERH-[SYPHFILETT]XS JSV[EVHMXXSSYV'MX]%XXSVRI]JSVVIZMI[ &IWX MQEKITRK" 6YWW6IMGL 4PERRMRK1EREKIV 4PERRMRK ERH (IZIPSTQIRX 7IVZMGIW 4PERRMRKERH(IZIPSTQIRX7IVZMGIW `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¬Q[SRHIVMRK[LS QMKLXFIEFPIXSPSSOMRXSXLIFIPS[UYIWXMSR1] YRHIVWXERHMRKJVSQXLIWXEXIPE[WMWXLEXEREXXEGLIHSV HIXEGLIH%(9GERLEZIE¬WIXFEGO-¬Q[SVOMRKSRE TVSNIGX[LIVIXLIGPMIRXMWTVSTSWMRKEREXXEGLIH%(9 FYX[ERXXSFIEFPIXSKMZIXLIQKSSHHMVIGXMSR'SYPH ]SYTSMRXQIMRXLIVMKLXHMVIGXMSRSJ[LSXSXEPOXS# 8LEROW .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZI &YMPHWQEVXJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR ?PMROIHMRGSQA 3R%TVEX%1.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ"[VSXI ,M%Q]ERH+EVVIXX 8LIWIEVIGVE^]XMQIW-LSTI]SYFSXLEVIHSMRKSOE]5YIWXMSRJSV ]SYEFSYXEXXEGLIH%(9W 6)7IXFEGOWJSVEXXEGLIH%(9#7GSXXQIRXMSRIH4EPS%PXSMW VIUYMVMRKE¬WIXFEGOJSVEXXEGLIH%(9W 'ER]SYHSYFPIGLIGOXLIWIXFEGOVIUYMVIQIRXJSVEXXEGLIH%(9# 4IVQ]YRHIVWXERHMRKSJXLIWXEXIPE[EVIUYMVIHWMHISVVIEV WIXFEGOSJQSVIXLER¬MWRSXMRGSQTPMERGI[MXLWXEXYI%(9PE[ +SZ'SHI7IGXMSRE ( ZMM G ' SVI & ERHE WMHISVVIEVWIXFEGOSJ¬WLEPPRSXFIVIUYMVIHF]EPSGEPEKIRG]8LI WXEXIHSIWRSXHMJJIVIRXMEXIFIX[IIREXXEGLIHSVHIXEGLIH4PIEWI VIJIVXSXLIWIWIGXMSRWEWJSYRHMRXLI%(98%1IQSEXXEGLQIRX HEXIH.ERYEV]0IXQIORS[[LEX-¬QQMWWMRK# .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZI 7QEVXFYMPHMRKJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR?PMROIHMRGSQA &IKMRJSV[EVHIHQIWWEKI *VSQ1G/E]7GSXX 7GSXX1G/E]$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXSSVK" (EXI%TVMPEX414(8 8S.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ" 7YFNIGX 6)0SMW0ERI ,M.IWWMGE 8LI4PERRMRK-QTEGX*IIWEVI YWYEPP]EVSYRHERHEVIHYITVMSV XSFYMPHMRKTIVQMXMWWYERGI8LII\EGX EQSYRXMWR¬XGEPGYPEXIHYRXMPXLIETTPMGEXMSR MWWYFQMXXIH%PPXLIEXXEGLIH%(9W-LEZI VIZMI[IHLEHLEHXSQIIXXLIWEQI WIXFEGOWEWXLITVMQEV]VIWMHIRGI-[SYPH VIGSQQIRHVIEGLMRKSYXXS%Q]*VIRGLMJ ]SY[ERXIHXSLEZILIVXEOIEPSSOEXXLI GSHI MQEKITRK" 7GSXX1G/E]%-'4`4PERRIV`' ((IFVMW(MZIVWMSR 4VSKVEQ'SSVHMREXSV -7%'IVXM´IH%VFSVMWX`4PERRMRK (IZIPSTQIRX 7IVZMGIW ,EQMPXSR%ZIRYI`4EPS%PXS'% 8`)7GSXX1G/E]$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXSSVK 4PIEWIXLMROSJXLIIRZMVSRQIRXFIJSVITVMRXMRKXLMW IQEMP§8LERO]SY *VSQ.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ" 7IRX8LYVWHE]%TVMP41 8S1G/E]7GSXX 7GSXX1G/E]$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXSSVK" 7YFNIGX6I0SMW0ERI '%98-328LMWIQEMPSVMKMREXIHJVSQ SYXWMHISJXLISVKERM^EXMSR&I GEYXMSYWSJSTIRMRKEXXEGLQIRXWERH GPMGOMRKSRPMROW ,M7GSXX 8LEROWJSVXLIGEPP8LIWIEVIGVE^]XMQIW 'SR´VQMRKSYVHMWGYWWMSRFIPS[ 6IKEVHMRKXLIHVMZI[E] 'SSVHMREXI[MXL9VFERJSVIWXV]MRVIKEVHW XSXLIWXVIIXXVII)RKEKI%VFSVMWX 'SSVHMREXI[MXL4YFPMG [SVOW9XMPMXMIW)RKMRIIVMRKVIKEVHMRK TVS\MQMX]XS´VIL]HVERX -RVIKEVHWXSTEVOMRK ;LIRGSRZIVXMRKJVSQGEVKEVEKIXS GEVKEVEKIIRWYVIXLIVIMWSRITEVOMRK WTEGITVSZMHIHSYXWMHISJJVSRX]EVH WIXFEGO -RVIKEVHWXS%XXEGLIHWJFIHVSSQ %(9 -QTEGXJIIW[MPPETTP]SZIVWJ 'ER ]SYWIRHYTHEXIHMQTEGXJIIEQSYRX# 'LIGOWIXFEGOWJSVEXXEGLIH%(9¬SV¬# 'ER]SYHSYFPIGLIGOXLIWIXFEGO VIUYMVIQIRXJSVEXXEGLIH%(9#4IVQ] YRHIVWXERHMRKSJXLIWXEXIPE[EVIUYMVIH WMHISVVIEVWIXFEGOMWRSXMRGSQTPMERGI [MXLWXEXYI%(9PE[+SZ'SHI7IGXMSR E ( ZMM G ' SVI & FEWIHSRXLIWMXYEXMSR%WMHISVVIEV WIXFEGOSJ¬WLEPPRSXFIVIUYMVIHF]E PSGEPEKIRG]0IXQIORS[[LEX-¬Q QMWWMRK# 8LERO]SY .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZI &YMPHWQEVXJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI ?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR ?PMROIHMRGS QA 3R%TVEX41 1G/E]7GSXX 7GSXX1G/E]$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXS SVK"[VSXI 1IWWEKIVIGIMZIH-[MPPXV] GEPPMRK MQEKITRK" 7GSXX1G/E]%-'4`4PERRIV`' ((IFVMW(MZIVWMSR 4VSKVEQ'SSVHMREXSV -7%'IVXM´IH%VFSVMWX`4PERRMRK (IZIPSTQIRX 7IVZMGIW ,EQMPXSR%ZIRYI`4EPS%PXS'% 8`)7GSXX1G/E]$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXSSVK 4PIEWIXLMROSJXLIIRZMVSRQIRXFIJSVITVMRXMRKXLMW IQEMP§8LERO]SY *VSQ.IWWMGE6IWQMRM NIWWMGE$EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQ" 7IRX8YIWHE]%TVMP 41 8S1G/E]7GSXX 7GSXX1G/E]$'MX]SJ4EPS%PXS SVK" 7YFNIGX6I0SMW0ERI ,M7GSXX -LSTI]SYEVIHSMRKSOE]- LEZIETVSTSWIH%(9TVSNIGX -¬QLSTMRKXSVIZMI[[MXL]SY ZME^SSQFIJSVI-QSZI JSV[EVH[MXLXLIGPMIRX-WXLIVI EXMQIXLEXQMKLX[SVOJSV]SY# -¬ZIEXXEGLIHEGSRGITXYEPTPER XL X M P H P XM XL XLEXMRGPYHIWVIPSGEXMRKXLI HVMZI[E]PSGEXMSREPSRKE VSPPIHGYVFWXVIIXJVSRXXSXLI RSVXLERHVIPSGEXMRKXLIKEVEKI HSSV0IXQIORS[ 8LEROW .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZI &YMPHWQEVXJSVµI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))(%4 1SFMPI 'SQTER]7MXI ?EHYGSPPIGXMZIGSQA`0MROIHMR ?PMROIHMRGSQA 3R%TVEX %16IMGL 6YWW 6YWW6IMGL$GMX] SJTEPSEPXSSVK" [VSXI ,IPPS.IWWMGE -[SYPH VIGSQQIRH WIRHMRKXLITPERW XSXLITPERRIV´VWX ERHKMZIXLIQE GLERGIXS JEQMPMEVM^I XLIQWIPZIW[MXL XLITVSTSWEPWSXLI ^SSQQIIXMRKGER FIQSVIIJJIGXMZI =SYEVIJVIIXS VIEGLSYXXSER]SJ XLIWXEJJXLEX[SVO SR%(9 ETTPMGEXMSRWFYX XLMW[SYPHX]TMGEPP] FI:EP'EVPSWERH 7GSXX4PIEWI OIITMRQMRHXLEX SYXWMHISJEJSVQEP FYMPHMRKTIVQMX TPERWYFQMXXEPER] GSYVXIW]VIZMI[MW RSXKSMRKXSFIE GSQTPIXIERH GSQTVILIRWMZI TPERVIZMI[ERH XLIVIQE]FIMXIQW XLEXEVIQMWWIH &IWX &IWX MQEKITRK"6 YWW6IMGL 4PERRMRK 1EREKIV 4PERRMRKERH (IZIPSTQIRX 7IVZMGIW `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¬Q [SRHIVMRKMJ-GER WGLIHYPIE>SSQ QIIXMRK[MXLE TPERRIVXSVIZMI[E TVSTSWIH%(9 TVSNIGXEX0SMW 0ERIFIJSVI- JMREPM^IXLMRKW[MXL XLIS[RIV-WXLIVI ETEVXMGYPEVTPERRIV -WLSYPHVIEGLSYX XS# 8LEROW .IWW %(9`'SPPIGXMZ I &YMPHWQEVXJSV µI\MFPIPMZMRK .IWWMGE6IWQMRM %VGLMXIGX0))( %4 1SFMPI 'SQTER] 7MXI ?EHYGSPPIGXMZI GSQA`0MROIHMR ?PMR OIHMRGSQA