HomeMy Public PortalAbout2012.09.13 Regular Minutes
MINUTES
McCall City Council
Regular Meeting
Legion Hall (McCall City Hall - Lower Level)
September 13, 2012
Agenda
Call to Order and Roll Call
Approve the Agenda
Reports
Pledge of Allegiance
Public Comment
Business Agenda
Consent Agenda
Executive Session
Open Session
Adjournment
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Mayor Bailey called the regular meeting of the McCall City Council to order at 5:35 p.m.
Council Member Aymon, Mayor Bailey, Council Member Scott, Council Member
Swanson, and Council Member Witte all answered roll call.
City staff present was Gene Drabinski, Interim City Manager, Bill Punkoney, City Attorney;
Linda Stokes, City Treasurer; Dennis Coyle, Parks and Recreation Director; Eric McCormick,
Golf Course Superintendent; Jerry Summers, Police Chief; Peter Borner, Public Works Director;
Michelle Groenevelt, Community Development Director; David Simmonds, Information
Systems Manager; Carol Coyle, Grant Coordinator; Barbara Sivey, Human Resources Manager;
and BessieJo Wagner, City Clerk.
APPROVE THE AGENDA
Mayor Bailey moved to amend the City Council Agenda to add to the Consent Agenda the
Warrant Register printed on September 12, 2012 to ensure timely payment of City bills.
Council Member Aymon seconded the motion. In a roll call vote, Mayor Bailey, Council
Member Aymon, Council Member Scott, Council Member Swanson, and Council Member
Witte all voted aye and the motion carried.
REPORTS
Gene Drabinski, Interim City Manager, gave a report on the tasks assigned to him from Council
to achieve in his 90 day tenure. The following explains each task and the result:
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 1 of 9
September 13, 2012
1.Task: To complete the budget per state and City Code.
Result: Budget adopted and completed per state and City code on August 23, 2012.
2.Task: To improve public relations with the McCall Police Department and to evaluate
and establish a matrix on the performance of the McCall Police Department
Result: A police task force was established. The task force then developed a survey that
was placed on the City website. The task force will analyze the data received from the
survey and identify areas of opportunity for improvement.
3.Task: Improve Community Involvement the balance between the City and the
Community, and improve the perception that the City was unfriendly to businesses.
Result: Mr. Drabinski had spent time with various civic groups throughout the
community. He had also visited 12 businesses that need to comply with the trash
enclosure code. At the Department Head level, Mr. Drabinski had identified many of the
civic groups in town and had asked for the leader of each group to attend a Department
Head meeting, which occurs every other week. He had encouraged the Department Heads
to get involved in some way in one of the community groups.
Council requested that at the conclusion of the meetings with the various groups, to
schedule a work session with Council and have Mr. Drabinski summarize what
information had been learned from those meetings.
4.Task: Improve the accuracy of the information the Star-News reports on.
Result: Mr. Drabinski stated that the articles had been more accurate since he had been in
the City Manager role.
5.Task: Transition of the new City Manager.
Result: Mr. Drabinski felt that he had been working toward that goal. He stated that he
had been working toward ensuring that he provides the full picture to the Council,
showing both the pros and cons of each issue as they come up.
6.Task: Mr. Drabinski stated that he added this task – to improve the working relationship
between the City and Payette Lakes Recreational Water and Sewer District (PLRWSD).
Result: Mr. Drabinski stated that he and two of the Council members had met with the
irrigators. Mr. Drabinski also stated that he had met with each of the PLRWSD Board
members separately. He also stated that he would be attending their October Board
Meeting.
Council reviewed the department reports.
Council commented on the number building permits issued to date for FY12.
Mayor Bailey commented on the new Airport snow equipment storage building, stating that it
was a nice facility and would improve working conditions for the airport staff. Council Member
Witte asked what the procedure would be to track aircraft arrival. Dennis Coyle, Interim Airport
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 2 of 9
September 13, 2012
Manager stated that John Anderson, the Airport Consultant, was working on a method to track
aircraft arrivals.
Mayor Bailey asked how the year finished up for the Golf Course. Eric McCormick, Golf Course
Superintendent, commented that they had seen an increase in overall rounds played.
Gene Drabinski, Interim City Manager, showed the Council the Golden Gnome Award that the
Library received as part of the McCall in Bloom competition. Council also commented on the
new exterior paint the Library had and how good it looked.
Council Member Aymon asked the status of the protection net for the volleyball court in Legacy
Park. Mr. Coyle commented that the net had been ordered. Mayor Bailey asked for clarification
on the maintenance agreement mentioned in conjunction with the boat trailer parking lot. Mr.
Coyle clarified that is was in relation to the landscaping and the warrantees that came with the
new landscaping.
In response to Council Member Witte, Mr. Coyle explained the process for spraying for noxious
weeds, stating that the Parks crew was still spraying rights of ways. The City does not spray for
noxious weeds on private property. If the Parks crew identifies noxious weeds on private
property then a notice is left for the property owners.
Peter Borner, Public Works Director, introduced two new members of his crew: Cris Malvich
Street Superintendent and Kraig Newcomb Street Supervisor.
Mayor Bailey requested that Mr. Borner give the Council an update on the Davis Beach
generator. Mr. Borner stated that a neighborhood meeting was held and some concerns were
brought up related to the back-up generator building. He also stated that Public Works would be
taking an additional look at the entire project to include parking issues and traffic in and out of
the area.
rd
Mayor Bailey asked about the ICDBG Grant for the 3 Street project. Mr. Borner stated that
Horrocks Engineers were working on the design for the underground water infrastructure. He
stated that the plan was to complete all the undergrounding of utilities in the fall so that the
streetscape improvements could be done in the spring. Carole Coyle, Grant Coordinator,
commented that the Department of Commerce had stated that the City could not move forward
rd
on the 3 Street project until the City had received the environmental release, which was
anticipated to be received on September 25. Mrs. Coyle also stated that she anticipated that the
Department of Commerce contract would be ready for the September 27, 2012 City Council
Meeting.
rd
Mayor Bailey requested that staff provide the plans for the 3 Street project at the next Council
Work Session.
Peter Borner gave a brief update on the leak test done on the storage ponds, stating that lagoon
#3 showed some leakage and the plan was to repair the valves in the spring. Lagoon #2 looked
good and they were in the process of testing lagoon #1.
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 3 of 9
September 13, 2012
The Council received copies of the following:
1.McCall Environmental Advisory Committee – May 16, 2012
2.McCall Environmental Advisory Committee – June 19, 2012
3.McCall Environmental Advisory Committee – July 17, 2012
4.McCall Improvement Committee – July 12, 2012
5.McCall Redevelopment Agency – July 17, 2012
6.Planning and Zoning Commission – July 10, 2012
Mayor Bailey led the audience in the Pledge of Allegiance at 6:10 p.m.
PUBLIC COMMENT
Mayor Bailey called for public comment at 6:11 p.m.
Jessica Travis, Program Administrator for MYST, invited the Council to the new Teen Center
opening on Saturday September 15, 2012.
Tuck Miller, city resident addressed the Council giving his perspective on the Police
Department. He stated that he was in favor of a substantial police force in McCall. Mr. Miller
wanted to publicly thank Jerry Summers, Police Chief, and his officers for their diligence and
professionalism.
Hearing no further comments, Mayor Bailey closed the public comment.
BUSINESS AGENDA
AB 12-172 Appeal of Clerk’s Denial of a Business Application for a Taxi Service
BessieJo Wagner, City Clerk presented the Clerk’s Denial of a Business Application for a Taxi
Service to Council. This request was denied based on the opinion that a Taxi Service should
provide a safe and suitable service to the community. The fact that the owner of this service has
on record excessive traffic violations, failure to register vehicles, and failure to maintain vehicle
insurance does not reflect a safe and suitable service.
Anthony Benallo has requested an appeal of the Clerk’s denial of a business application for a
Taxi Service. He requests that the Council approve his application to provide a Taxi Service
business to McCall.
Mayor Bailey stated that the McCall City code needed to be updated and in an effort to avoid any
lawsuit, he also recommended that Mr. Benallo’s request for a business licence to provide a Taxi
Service in McCall be approved. Mayor Bailey acknowledged that Mr. Benallo had had a history
of poor driving performance. However without the authority in the City Code, Mayor Bailey felt
that the Council should proceed with caution.
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 4 of 9
September 13, 2012
Council Member Aymon stated that she understood being wary of lawsuits; however she also
stated that that the health and safety of the citizens of McCall was paramount. She expressed her
concern with the number of traffic violations that Mr. Benallo had and the fact that he now
wanted to provide a taxi service to the City of McCall.
Council Member Witte requested that Bill Punkoney, City Attorney, brief the City Council on
their options. Mr. Punkoney stated that the City has the authority to regulate the public sidewalks
and the streets. He stated that regulation could be done through granting or choosing not to grant
business licenses to businesses that operate in the public streets. Mr. Punkoney clarified that this
authority falls under the Police Power of the City to protect the public welfare, safety and health.
He cautioned however that if the Council should take action based on the Police power those
decisions cannot be arbitrary or capricious. He clarified that the Council needs to have a standard
by which to make decisions. Mr. Punkoney continued stating that the McCall City Code does not
provide a standard for granting or not granting a taxi service license. He stated in order for the
Council to set a standard since it was not set out in the City’s code was to do Findings of Facts
and Conclusions of Law with the outcome the Council would decide. Mr. Punkoney further
clarified stating that if the Council chose not to grant the license, the Council would come up
with findings of facts that would support their decision.
Mr. Punkoney also addressed the question of whether the decision could be postponed until the
code could be updated to address the issue. He stated that the Council could not unreasonably
delay the decision but if the code section would be updated in the near future, the Council had
the option to wait. With the updating of the code it would give the Council a standard by which
to make their decision on this license as well as future licenses. Mr. Punkoney also clarified the
question of what a review hearing would be for the applicant. He stated that if the Council
wanted to make a decision at this meeting then they would want to give the applicant some sort
of due process that would include giving the applicant a chance to be heard, as well as hearing
the position of the City administrators. After hearing all the information the Council could then
make a finding of facts and conclusion of law of which to make their decision of whether to
grant or deny the application.
Council Member Witte stated that she thought it best to amend the code to set a standard that
could then be applied universally going forward. Generally the Council agreed that a standard
needed to be set by the code.
Council Member Scott asked if there was any state code that addressed the taxi licensing issue or
commercial drivers licensing. Mr. Punkoney stated that municipalities deal with the
qualifications of taxi drivers as they typically drive standard vehicles.
Jerry Summers, Police Chief, stated that there were state codes for chauffeurs but nothing
specific for taxi drivers. Chief Summers also stated that the applicant was present at the meeting.
He also stated that the applicant had been operating his taxi service even without the license.
Chief Summers requested that if the Council chose to post pone their decision, then whether or
not the applicant could continue to operate, without a license, until the decision is made.
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 5 of 9
September 13, 2012
Council Member Scott asked that if through police presence if the safe operation of this service
could be monitored. Chief Summers replied stating that the service would be subject to traffic
stops like any other vehicle. Chief Summers also stated that in the seven plus years as the Police
Chief he has never denied a business license and this is one that he felt very strongly about.
Anthony Benallo addressed the Council, stating that he has been in the taxi business for the last
three or four years with another company and then for the last few months on his own. He stated
that he had a few regular clients that he provided services for on a regular basis. Mr. Benallo
stated that the service he provided included the delivery of groceries and pharmaceuticals for the
elderly. His desire was to provide a good service to the community. He also stated that he had
invested in a van to provide the service.
Mayor Bailey questioned the applicant on whether he planned to obey the traffic laws of the City
of McCall. Mr. Benallo responded that he would. Council Member Aymon asked if any of the
applicant’s traffic violations had occurred while operating his taxi. Mr. Benallo responded that
they had not.
Mayor Bailey also asked the applicant if he was only driving while sober. Mr. Benallo assured
the Mayor that he would only drive sober. Mayor Bailey reiterated the concerns of the Council
and staff regarding Mr. Benallo’s poor driving record.
Council Member Swanson stated that the service an additional taxi service in town was worth
considering. Council member Aymon stated that she did not disagree that the service would be
great to have in town; however her concern was the quality of service that may be provided.
Council members Witte and Scott agreed that a standard needed to be set.
There was some discussion as to what the best course of action would be.
Council Member Witte moved to table until first meeting in October the Clerk’s denial of
the business application for a taxi service by Anthony Benallo. Council Member Swanson
seconded the motion. In a roll call vote, Council Member Witte, Council Member Swanson,
Council Member Aymon, and Mayor Bailey all voted aye; Council Member Scott voted no;
and the motion carried.
After further discussion Council Member Swanson felt that Mr. Benallo had a right to operate a
business.
Council Member Swanson moved to reconsider the denial of the business application for a
taxi service by Anthony Benallo. Mayor Bailey seconded the motion. In a roll call vote
Council Member Swanson, Mayor Bailey, Council Member Aymon and Council Member
Scott all voted aye; Council Member Witte voted no; and the motion carried
.
Council Member Swanson moved to grant the business license for a taxi service by
Anthony Benallo. Council Member Scott seconded the motion.In a roll call vote Council
Member Swanson, Council Member Scott, Mayor Bailey, and all voted aye; Council
Member Aymon and Council Member Witte voted no; and the motion carried
.
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 6 of 9
September 13, 2012
AB 12-166 Centennial Committee recommendation for historical events for Centennial
Plaza “Art Wall”
Carol Coyle, Grant Coordinator and staff liaison to the Centennial Committee, presented the
Centennial Committee recommendation for historical events for Centennial Plaza “Art Wall” to
Council. Lyle Nelson and Deb Facchin addressed the Council stating that the Centennial
Committee had been actively raising funds for the completion of Centennial Plaza. One
component of the Plaza was the “art wall”- a serpentine rock wall that would include
approximately 22 dates of local and national historic significance. Artists would interpret the
historic events through the use of mosaic tiles and glass. The events would also be listed at
various locations along the 100 foot wall.
A list of historic events was suggested to the Centennial Committee by David Armstrong in June,
2012. The events were gleaned from records compiled by the McCall Historic Preservation
Commission and from events listed on the interpretive panels at Legacy Park. Events of national
significance were added to the list. The list was then presented to a number of local long-time
residents to obtain input for dates and events of local interest.
There was much discussion regarding the suggested dates, including removal of some dates and
addition of other dates for the art wall in Centennial Plaza. There was also some explanation
from the artist, Deb Facchin as to how the dates may be interpreted throughout the art wall.
There was general consensus from the Council to give suggestions and corrections to Carol
Coyle for further review. Council agreed that a revised list should come back to Council for a
formal approval.
AB 12-169 Winter Snow Removal Equipment Lease Resolution 12-19
Peter Borner, Public Works Director, presented the Winter Snow Removal Equipment Lease and
Resolution 12-19 to Council. Mr. Borner requested that the Council table this item until the
September 27, 2012 City Council Meeting giving the City’s attorney an opportunity to review all
documents.
Council Member Mayor Bailey moved to table until September 27, 2012 Resolution No. 12-
19 authorizing the Mayor to enter into, on behalf of the City of McCall, a “Governmental
Equipment Lease-Purchase Agreement” and a “Non-Appropriation Addendum” between
the City of McCall and Caterpillar Financial Services Corporation. Council Member
Aymon seconded the motion. In a roll call vote, Mayor Bailey, Council Member Aymon,
Council Member Scott, Council Member Swanson, and Council Member Witte all voted
aye and the motion carried.
AB 12-168 Dissolution of the Transportation Advisory Committee and Formation of a New
Public Works Advisory Committee
Peter Borner, Public Works Director, presented the dissolution of the Transportation Advisory
Committee and formation of a new Public Works Advisory Committee to Council. Mr. Borner
explained that the Transportation Advisory Committee (TAC) had been in existence since 2001.
In the last two years, there had been only one meeting. He stated that unfortunately, the focus of
the TAC had been limited in scope to solely transportation related issues. Mr. Borner stated that
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 7 of 9
September 13, 2012
the Public Works Department dealt with a number of issues not only in areas of transportation,
but also in water, wastewater, stormwater, etc., and these areas would benefit from public
involvement in the form of a new Public Works Advisory Committee (PWAC).
Council Member Scott moved to dissolve of the Transportation Advisory Committee
(TAC) and create a Public Works Advisory Committee (PWAC). Council Member
Swanson seconded the motion. In a roll call vote, Council Member Scott, Council Member
Swanson, Council Member Aymon, Mayor Bailey, and Council Member Witte all voted
aye and the motion carried.
AB 12-173 City Manager Recruitment
Barbara Sivey, Human Resources Manager, requested that the Council move AB 12-173 City
Manager Recruitment until after the Executive Session.
Mayor Bailey moved to revise the agenda to move AB 12-173 City Manager Recruitment to
after the executive session. Council Member Aymon seconded the motion. In a voice vote
all members voted aye and the motion carried.
CONSENT AGENDA
Staff recommended approval of the following items:
1.Council Special Minutes – August 13, 2012
2.Council Special Minutes – August 14, 2012
3.Council Special Minutes – August 20, 2012
4.Warrant Registers Dated September 7, 2012
5.Payroll Report for Period ending August 17, 2012
6.Payroll Report for Period ending August 31, 2012
7.AB 12-170 Authorization for the Destruction of Records – Resolution 12-18
8.AB 12-167 Memorandum of Understanding Between the City of McCall, Payette
National Forest and Valley County Concerning Noxious Weed Management
9.AB 12-174 Terrorism Insurance Waiver FY13 (added 9/13/12)
A brief discussion took place regarding items on the Warrant Register.
Council Member Scott moved to approve the Consent Agenda. Council Member Swanson
seconded the motion. In a roll call vote, Council Member Scott, Council Member Swanson,
Mayor Bailey, Council Member Aymon, and Council Member Witte all voted aye and the
motion carried.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
At 7:58 p.m., Mayor Bailey moved to go into Executive Session for:
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 8 of 9
September 13, 2012
• Hiring - Pursuant to Idaho Code §67-2345(1)(a): to consider hiring a public officer,
employee, staff member or individual agent, wherein the respective qualities of
individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need. This
paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or deliberations
about staffing needs in general; and
• Litigation — Pursuant to Idaho Code §67-2345(1)(f): to communicate with legal
counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options
for pending litigation, or controversies not yet being litigated but imminently likely
to be litigated;
Council Member Swanson seconded the motion. In a roll call vote, Mayor Bailey, Council
Member Swanson, Council Member Aymon, Council Member Scott and Council Member
Witte all voted aye and the motion carried.
Council discussed candidates for the City Manager position and litigation issues.
RETURN TO OPEN SESSION
At 9:55 p.m., Mayor Bailey moved to return to Open Session. Council Member Swanson
seconded the motion. In a voice call vote, all voted aye and the motion carried.
AB 12-173 City Manager Recruitment
Council Member Swanson moved to invite candidate G for an in-person interview on September
24, 2012 for the position of City Manager and directed City staff to make the arrangements.
ADJOURNMENT
Without further business, the Mayor adjourned the meeting at 10:00 p.m.
``1111111111/1//''
o`I M c CA '0.
i
dZ
414 )0
f jr,
1„ "No.. 0 Donald C. Bailey, Mayor
ATTEST:%te '
* •
al', IDt►��`,`,�
if MIL ��ai„uu0.0
BessieJo jgner, Cit 'lerk
McCall City Council Regular Meeting Page 9 of 9
September 13, 2012