Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 15-2043From: Chris O'Hare[mailto:chrisoharegulfstream@gmail.comj Sent: Thursday, November 05, 2015 9:46 PM To: Bill Thrasher <bthrasher@gulf-stream.org> Subject: Public Record Request- Alexander, Watkins allegations Dear Custodian of Records, This email is a singular request for a public record. Please respond to this public record request in a singular manner and do not combine this public record request with any other public record requests when responding. Before making this public record request, I first searched the public records portion of your agency's website hoping I could locate the public record I seek without having to trouble you for it. Unfortunately 1 can not find the records I wish to examine. Attached is the title page of the published Code of Ordinances for the Town of Gulf Stream Florida (copied from the Town's web site). Please note that this title page contains a section labeled CURRENT OFFICIALS of the TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, and under this heading John C. Randolph is identified as Town Attorney. Please provide any public record documenting where the Town Commission by a majority vote, or anyone officially designated by the Town Commission to act on their behalf, has authorized the entire law firm of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, as an entity, to be the Town Attorney instead of the individual John C. Randolph as claimed on the attached Town's published code of ordinances. Any public record, other than billing records and notices of billing rate increases, that would document, substantiate, support or in any way be related to the statement by Larry Alexander, Chairman and President of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, made to the Florida COMMISSION ON ETHICS regarding complaint no. 15-001 that his entire law firm (Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs), and not the respondent individually (John C. Randolph), serves as the Town Attorney for the Town of Gulf Stream. Any public record that would document, substantiate, support or in any way be related to the statement made by Scott Watkins, of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, to the Florida COMMISSION ON ETHICS during the hearing of complaint no. 15-001, that there is a contract between the Town and the entire law firm of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, other than billing records and notices of billing rate increases, to serve as Town Attorney. Any contract THAT INCLUDES PROVISIONS that anyone or everyone at Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs is authorized or mandated to complete legal services for the Town of Gulf Stream. I make this request pursuant to Article 1. Section 24 of the Florida Constitution and Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes. If you contend that any of the records I am seeking, or any portion thereof, are exempt from inspection or disclosure please cite the specific exemption as required by § I19.07(1)(e) of the Florida Statutes and state in writing and with particularity the basis for your conclusions as required by § 119.07(1)(f) of the Florida Statutes. Please take note of 4119.07(1)(c) Florida Statues and your affirmative obligation to (1) promptly acknowledge receipt of this public records request and (2) make a good faith effort which "includes making reasonable efforts to determine from other officers or employees within the agency whether such a record exists and, ifso, the location at which the record can be accessed." I am, therefore, requesting that you notify every individual in possession of records that may be responsive to this public records request to preserve all such records on an immediate basis. If the public records being sought are maintained by your agency in an electronic format please produce the records in the original electronic format in which they were created or received. See §119.01(2)(fl. Florida Statutes. Please provide only those records for inspection that do not require extensive use of information technologies or extensive staff time or both in excess of 15 minutes. Please take note of § 119.07(4)(a)3.(d) Florida Statues and if you anticipate that any records exist, the production for inspection of which will require extensive use of information technologies or extensive staff time or both in excess of 15 minutes, then please advise me of the cost you anticipate to be incurred by your agency prior to incurring this cost. Please do not incur any costs on my behalf without fust obtaining my written authorization to proceed. If you anticipate the need to incur any costs that I would be statutorily required to pay in order to inspect these public records which would exceed $1.00 please notify me in advance of your incurring that cost with a written estimate of the total cost. Please be sure to itemize any estimates so as to indicate the total number of pages and/or records, as well as to distinguish the cost of labor and materials. Again, please do not incur any costs on my behalf without first obtaining my written authorization to proceed. I hereby reserve all rights granted to me under the Florida Constitution and Florida Statutes. Please provide for my inspection the requested records within ten (10) days of your receipt of this request. All responses to this public records request should be made in writing to the following email address: chrisohareaulfstream(a) email.com 11/5/2015 CODE OF ORDINANCES TOM OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA i Code of Ordinances I Gulf Stream, FL i Municode Library CODE OF ORDINANCES TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Republished by Order of the Town Commission Adopted: June 4, 1999 Effective: June 4, 1999 i, muncode \ Municipal Code Corporation • PO Box 2235 Tallahassee, FL 32316 info@municode.com • 800.262.2633 fax850.575.8852 • www.municode.com CURRENT OFFICIALS of the TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA Joan K. Orthwein Mayor Muriel J. Anderson W. Garrett Dering Robert W. Ganger Thomas M. Stanley Town Commission William H. Thrasher Town Mana1?er Mips:/Aw .municode.conVIibrarp'A/gulf streamtcodes/code_of ordinances?nodeld=CD_ORD_TOwN_GULF_STREAM_FLORIDA 2110 11/5/2015 CODE OF ORDINANCES TOVMJ OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA I Code of Ordinances I Gulf Stream, FL I Municode Library John C. Randolph Town Attorney Rita L. Taylor Town Clerk GarrettJ. Ward Police Chief PREFACE This Code constitutes a complete republication of the general and permanent ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida. Source materials used in the preparation of the Code were the 1978 Code, as supplemented through March 10, 2000, and ordinances subsequently adopted by the town commission through September 5, 2008. The source of each section is included in the history note appearing in parentheses at the end thereof. The absence of such a note indicates that the section is new and was adopted for the first time with the adoption of the Code. By use of the comparative tables appearing in the back of this Code, the reader can locate any section of the 1978 Code, as supplemented, and any subsequent ordinance included herein. The chapters of the Code have been conveniently arranged in alphabetical order, and the various sections within each chapter have been catchlined to facilitate usage. Notes which tie related sections of the Code together and which refer to relevant state law have been included. A table listing the state law citations and setting forth their location within the Code is included at the back of this Code. Chapter and Section Numbering System The chapter and section numbering system used in this Code is the same system used in many state and local government codes. Each section number consists of two parts separated by a dash. The figure before the dash refers to the chapter number, and the figure after the dash refers to the position of the section within the chapter. Thus, the second section of chapter 1 is numbered 1-2, and the first section of chapter 4 is 4-1. Under this system, each section is identified with its chapter, and at the same time new sections or even whole chapters can be inserted in their proper place by using the decimal system for amendments. For example, if new material consisting of one section that would logically come between sections 3-1 and 3-2 is desired to be added, such new section would be numbered 3-1.5. New chapters may be included by using one of the reserved chapter numbers. Care should be taken that the alphabetical �rr�nncment of rh mento rr ie nn,A, Kln,s, nnrl Mtps:/Mww.nwdcode.comlibrarVR/g Jf streanVcocles/code_of acinances?nodeld=CD_0RD TONTI GULF STREAM_FLORIDA 3110 STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION MICHAEL O, O'NEIL, Swr"vy Post Office Box 22838 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33315 July P9, 1969 Section 93060 - State .Road AlA Resolutions - Palm Beach County Secondary Mr. Henry F. Lilienthal, Attorney Johnston, Lilienthal & Johnston Post Office Box 48 West Palm Beach,Florida 33402 Dear Mr. Lilienthal: We wish to thank you for submitting &.copy of a resolution as adopted by the Town of Gulf Stream, in regard to their desire that State Road AlA not be widened in the area of their muni- cipality. 7 ' As you are probably aware, an ever-increasing population growth in the State of Florida requires the,construction of additional highways, and the upgrading of existing.facilities. We can certainly agree that considerable study should be made prior to serious consideration of four-laning State Road AIA in the area of Cuff Stream. We have no plans at the present time to four -.lane this section of State Road AlA in our current Five -Year Primary Road Program. However, in a recent study prepared by the Department, the fovr- laning of State Road AIA throughout Palm.Beach County has been recommended. This 16 -year program (1969-1985) was presented to the last session of the Legislature, but was not adopted or fends provided. COMMISSION MEETING March 13, 1970 Present: Mayor William F. Koch, Jr. Vice -Mayor Stewart S. Iglehart Commissioner John G. Hart Commissioner J. Phil Hoyle Also attending: Richard F. Ward, Marry Johnston, Roy Cowart and Kathleen Kirton. Mayor Koch called the meeting to order. Mr. Hart moved that the minutes of the meeting held on February 13, 1970 be approved as written and the reading of these minutes be waived. Mr. Iglehart seconded the motion. Motion passed. Mr. Hart moved that the Financial Report for February, 1970 be approved as written and all expenses included in the report be approved. :Mr. Iglehart seconded the motion. Motion passed. Police reports for February were read. Mayor Koch reported receiving complaints concerning drainage in the Town. It was agreed that the Town's policy remain that the Town will have no financial responsibility .in regard to drainage. The Town. Clerk reported that Police Sgt. G.M. Partin was retiring as of .March 15, 1970 and had served approximately 14 years with the Town. There was discussion concerning financial consideration to be given Sgt. Partin in recognition of his faithful and loyal service to the Town. Mr. Iglehart suggested $500.00 a year for three years. After further discussion, Mr. Hart moved that Sgt. Partin be paid s2f000.00 with payments to be in sums of $500.00 yearly. Mr. Iglehart seconded the motion. Motion passed. There being no further business the meeting was adjourned. ATTEST: to come before the Commission, Present: Also attending: CONKISSION h<EGTING I;ay 8, 1970 Mayor Commissioner Commissioner Commissioner William F. Koch, Jr. John G. Hart J. Phil Hoyle William S. LaPorte Richard F. Ward, Harry Johnston, Gordon Nagle and Kathleen Kirton. Mayor Koch called the meeting to order and announced the Commission would deviate from the regular order of business in order to hear Mr. Gordon Nagle, architect for Hillside House, present plans for apartments to be built on land to the East of the Little Club. After looking over the plans and discussing them, it was agreed that they met all Town requirements as to setbacks, etc. and that a permit could be issued after the. Health Department and any other necessary agency -approved the plans. Mr. Hart moved that the minutes of the meeting held on April 10, 1970 be approved with the correction of Paul Grady attending rather than Paul Gerot and that the reading of these minutes be waived. I•Ir. Hoyle seconded the motion. I -lotion passed. Mr. Hart moved that the Financial Report for April, 1970 be approved as written and all expenses included in the report be approved. Mr. Hoyle seconded the motion. Motion passed: Letter of resignation from the Commission from Mr. Iglehart was read. Mr. LaPorte moved that the resignation be accepted with regret. Mr. Hart seconded the motion. Motion passed. Resolution No. 2-70, commending Mr. Iglehart for his service as a Commissioner, was read. AIr. Hart moved that this resolution be passed and adopted. Mr. LaPorte seconded the motion. Motion passed. A letter from Mrs.. Henry V. Pope requesting a Northerly extension of the no passing zone on,AlA was read. Since this is a State road it was agreed that the Town could do little in this regard and Mrs. Pope Would be so advised... Police reports for April were read. Resolution No: 3-70, vacating and; abandoning an easement over. the North five feet of Lot. 21, Gulf Stream Cove, was read. Mr. LaPorte moved that this resolution be. passed and adopted. Mr. Hart seconded the motion. Motion passed. Ordinance No. 70-1, granting a franchise to Teleprompter Florida CATV Corporation, was read. Mr. Hart moved that this ordinance be approved and placed on first reading. Mr. Hoyle seconded the motion. I -lotion passed. There was discussion as to the vacancy on the Commission and it was agreed that the Commissioners would discuss the matter between them- selves prior to the June 12, 1970 Commission meeting. It was pointed. out that the charter calls for a replacement to be made,in thirty days. Ll�Y, 1 ut� 1.H11.e5 PLORIOA 'ZCnifeb Zfafez Zenafe WASHINGTON, Mc, 201S1U January 15, 1971 Hr. Henry F. Lilienthal Johnston, Lilienthal 6 Johnston' Attorneys and Counselors at Law Harvey Building Hest Palm teach, Florida 33402 Dear Mr. Lilienthal: Upon my arrival here in Washington I was pleased to find your letter and the attached. copy of the Town of Gulf Stream Resolu- tion with respect to the Navy's Atlantic Undersea Test and Evaluation Center, awaiting my attention. There is every reason for this facility to be left where it is and you may be sure of my full support of such action by the Navy. Looking forward to working with you in any and all matters_af- fecting your City and Palm Beach County, and with kindest regards, I am Most ^ osincerely,, LAWTON CHILES LC/wbb  2  ::rb1n e_ /q?) The, proposed revised 'Rate Schedule', stated by County Sanitation to he necessary due to extreme escalation, in recent years, of all cost factors relating to Garbage Collection and Disposal operation, was considered excessive; and unreasonable by the Town Manager. Competi- tive costs were obtained, found to be more excessive and negotiation was 'then effected with said County Sanitation which resulted. in an appreciable reduction in their proposed increase over the current cost of these services, as shown below: CURRE14T COST - - -.per existing Contract $ 7,800. per yr. Proposed NEW Contract as submitted S 12,000. IT plus a graduated 'Fee' for NEW Dwelling Units within the Town to he served; Adjustment resulting from negotiations reflect an annual cost of $10,800. Plus a graduated additional FEE for each NEW Dwelling Unit. within any fiscal year period - Collection 'Service Cost for which shall NOT commence until the beginning of the next Fiscal Year. Mr. Hart moved to accept the recommendation of the Manager and enter into a. NEW AGREEMENT with County Sanitation, authorizing execution of such document, effective October 1, 1971) and which is for a five (5) year period with o,," tion of renewal for a similar period at the same terms: as set forth and contained therein. Motion was seconded by Tar. Walker and ?,Unanimously approved. 7. A Resolution, numbered 7-71, created and submitted by the Palm Beach County Transportation Committee, was forwarded to the Town. of Gulf Stream, by County Commissioner. Lake Lytal, who, under date of May 24th, r.egUested Gulf Stream Commission's consirleration thereof, RSSOLUT_CN NO. 7-71. 1 RESOLUTION !az THE TOV7V COi`tP185ION FOR THE TC -!,!N CF GULF STgEA41 PASN BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AGREE- lNi4i 1N PRINCIPLE To THE CREATION OF A COUNTY TRj.rrS- ECRTATION AUTHORITY. The original copy of this Resolution is attached to the official copy of the Rr%,inutes" covering the Town Commission Trieeting held on June 40 1971. Following general discussion of said proposed Resolution, and being informed ba "he y e Tor:n'S leg counsel, Att'. Fenl'y F. Lili.vithal, of no apparent reason, for objection to its adoption SUBJECT, however, to deletion_ of reference to the Town Attorney as appears in sub -paragraph SECTION 4. of the original resolution submitted by the Transportation, Committee, Mr. Hart moved for ADOPTION of Resolution No. 7-71 amended. Motion was seconded by t" ir. Walker and unanimously approved by the Com- mission. C0131118SION MEETING May 12, 1972, Present: GEORGE W, WALKER Mayor WILLIAM P. KOCH, JR. Vice -mayor WILLIAM 5. LaPORTE commissioner Also attending: n. D. Worthing• Att#y, John C, Randolph and Kathleen K;ston0s Assistant, 1, The Heating was called to order by mayor [•talker. 2, On motion of Mr. LaPorte, seconded by Mr, Koch, the Minutes of the April 14th Meeting ;are unanimously approved. 3, The Financial Report for the Month of April - 1972, an submitted by the sown Manager, was accepted, 4. The following "SUMMARY" of Police Reports for the Hoath of April was presented and accepted by the COMLisaioni COWART BROWN CORBETT MqQUADE HUNKA Mileage 1453 1650 1609 1716 1804 Days 20 22 21 20 22 Hours 160 176 168 160 179 CALLS 10 8 2 5 7 It was further reported that there had not been any B & 5 or other major law violations during the Month of April, 5. The Planning Board submitted its •Report° to the Commission Can_ corning the Board's meeting with Mrs. LeRoy W. Caddell and her representative Mr. Robert Grauch relative to the proposed devel- opment of the 12.8 acres tract of land recently acquired by Mrs, Caddell and her son Mr. Jahn B. Caddell II. Planning Board "Re- port" is as follows, "R8: Recommendations of the Town Planning Board in reference to the proposed CADDP.LL Subdivision. The Planning Board wishes to call to the Commiaaion0a atten- tion x portion of the Town zoning Ordinance No, 108, approved in May, 1952, as not forth on Page 23, Section X. sub -Section "A" which reads as followas 'Ali plans, and re -plans, plate or CO -Plats of land herein- after laid out in building lots or streets, alleys or other por- tions of the same intended to be dedicated to the public use, or for the use of purchasers or owners of lots fronting thereon, or adjacent thereto, and located within the Town, shall be submitted to the Town Commission, or a Committee thereof designated for such purpose, for its approval or rejection, and it shall be unlawful to receive or record such plans, re -plans, plats or re -plate, in cont. -G - ITEM 5 conts any public office unlesa the sane shall bear thereon, by endorse- ment or otherwise, the approval of the Town Mayor and Clork upon authority of the Town Commisnion, and the corporate Seal of the Toi-in. The disapproval of such plans, re -plana, plats or re -plats by the Town Commission shall be doomed a refusal by the Town of the proposed dedication shown thereon. The approval by the Town Cowdaeion shall be deemed an acceptance by the Town of such pro- posed dedication, but shall not impose any duty upon the Town con- cerning the maintenance or improvement of any such dedication or dedicated parts until the proper authorities of the Town shall have made actual appropriations of the same by entry, use or im- provements. All plana, re -plans, plata or re -plats of lands hereafter laid out within any area of the Town, located in Residence District "A", or in Apartment or ?residence District "C", shall provide for lots or tracts of land having a frontage of at least one hundred (100) foot on a dedicated street road or avenue, and a land area of at least ten thousand (10,00f square feet, for each lot or tract shown on maid plat." Possible exception to the above should be noted on the McLOUTH Subdivision Plat, approved in July, 1954, )rE-PLATTED and approved in May, 1957, which may not conform to the above section X, sub- section "A", in regard to dedicated roads. it is the recommendation of thin Board that access roads should be paved at least twenty (20) feet in width and provided with swalea on both sides of said roads, each swale to be at least five (5) feat wide. Catch Basins and drainage layout should be provided on a form to be approved by the Town'■ Engineer. The North Road in the Caddell Subdivision should be laid out in a manner so that it does not intersect with AIA adjacent to the South Road of the McLOUTB Subdivision, for safety reasons. The Planning Board further recommends that no approval of the Caddell subdivision Plans be given until complete engineering draw- ings and specifications, showing the layout of access roads and a drainage system, have been examined and approved by the Townes En— gineer, all being subject to necessary survey. It should be further noted that the Planning Board feels that the general layout of this project is very attractive and if the matter of the access roads, and properly designed drainage, can be straightened out, there would be no objection to such proposed de- velopment of the subdivision. Following general discussion of the Planning Board's recommend- ations between the Commission, Planning Board Member Mr. L. He Ball and Mr. Robert Grauch, representing the owners of the proposed Sub- division, during which discussions Mr. Koch, Vice -Mayor of the Com- mission, cited the advisability of providing swales of ten (10) ft in width, instead of five (5) ft., Hayor Walker informed Mr. Grauch that engineering plana and specifications, for such proposed devel- opment, reflecting suggestions as made by the Commission and there should also be reflected the recommendations of the Planning Hoard, be provided for re -submission to the Town Commission for further consideration. -3 - ITEM 5 cont. The commission, on motion of Mr. Koch, seconded by Hr. LaPorte, unanimously approved acceptance of the Planning Board's Report, together with the understanding that Hr. Grauch proceed with providing for engineering design plane and specifications for possible development of the Caddell property to reflect the rec- emendations of the Planning Hoard and the commission, as well as the intent of Mr. Grauch relative to possible sewage facili- ties. 6. Ordinance No. 72-3, providing a basis for local Police control over LOITERRRS aid/or PROWLERS was submitted for Commission con- sideration, much ordinance being deemed necessary in the beat interest of the Town in view of the fact that the United States Supreme court recently declared the State Vagrancy Law being un- constitutional. On motion of Mr. Koch, seconded by Mr. LaPorte, the Commis- sion unanimously approved placing ordinance No. 72-3 on FIRST reading. 7. The Commission was informed that satisfactory arrangements with the City of Delray Beach for use of its jail facilities, by the Town of Gulf Stream, for detention of prisoners, when necessary, have been concluded. on motion of Mr. Koch, seconded by Mr. LaPorte who further expressed his appreciation for the coopera- tion extended by the City of Delray Beach, the Commission unani- mously approved execution of a prepared "Agreement", by the pro- per Town officials, whereby the City of Delray Beach will provide jail facilities for detention of prisoners from the Town of Gulf Stream, when such service is needed. B. The Commission directed the Town's legal counsel (Johnston, Lil- ienthal & Johnston), represented at the meeting by Att'y. John C. Randolph, to initiate legal procedure for amending Paragraph 2, Section 5, of Article IV, chapter 22306, Laws of Florida, Special Acts of 1943, being the charter Act for the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida, in order to provide an "AMENDMENT" thereto, when so amended, to read as follows; "All public moneys shall be deposited in the name of the Town of Gulf Stream, in a bank or banks in Palm Beach County, to be designated by the Town commission, and all public moneys shall be disbursed only on check to be signed by either one of the followings (a) The Town Manager and any one (1) Commissioner; or (b) Any Two (2) members of the commission. Any person performing any duties in which he or she collects, receives or handles any public funds shall give bond to faithfully account for mama." Upon motion of kr. Koch, seconded by Mr. LaPorte, the Commission unanimously approved directing the Town legal counsel to proceed with effecting such Charter Change. Z 1'!3 COMMISSION MEETING FEBRUARY 9. 1973. PRESENT: WILLIAM F. KOCH, JR. Mayor WILLIAM S. LaPORTE Vice -Mayor GEORGE W. WALKER Commissioner HENRY N. WHITNEY Commissioner JOHN K. WHITTEMORE Commissioner Also attending: R. D. Worthing; Att'y. John C. Randolph. r 1. The meeting was called to order by Mayor Koch. 2. On motion by Mr. LaPorte and seconded by Mr. Walker, the Com- mission unanimously approved the 'Minutes' for the regular meeting held on January 12, 1973. . 3. The FINANCIAL REPORT for the Month of January was accepted as submitted. 4, The following "SUMMARY" of Police Reports for the Month of January was presented to the Commission: COWART BROWN CORBETT McQUADE MUMIdA Mileage 1516 1754 1802 2031 Days 24 23 22 24 Hours 192 184 176 192 CALLS 23 10 9 9 During the Month - Chief Cowart attended TWO First -Aid Calls; Both being sent to the Hospital. No. 1 Party was overcome by GAS from an Air Conditioner No. 2 " " a Heart attack Victim. 5. The Commission was then informed that owners of properties a- butting on portions of oleander Way, Banyan and Gulf Stream Roads involved in a proposed Drainage Improvement Project previously discussed at the January 12th Commission Meeting, have again been requested to be present at this Meeting for further consideration of such proposed improvement and possible sharing of costs there- of. The Commission was further informed that three (3) of said property owners, namely, Mrs. Lake, Mr. & Mrs. G. P. Bissell and Mr. & Mrs. A. N. Lilley, not being able to be present, have ad- vised the administration of their willingness to join in the de- cision of the majority. COMMISSION MEETING JANUARY 10, 1975 PRESENT: MAYOR,WILLIAM F. KOCH, JR. MAYOR GEORGE W. WALKER VICE MAYOR JOAN S. LAPORTE COMMISSIONER JOHN K. WHITTEMORE COMMISSIONER HENRY N, WHITNEY COMMISSIONER Also attending: Att'y H. Adams Weaver, Town Manager, William E. Gwynn Deputy Town Clerk, Barbara Gwynn, Police Chief, Roy Cowart, and Franklin B. O'Brien. The Meeting was called to order at 9:00 A,M, by Mayor Koch, Upon motion by Mr. Whitney and seconded by Mr. Walker the Commission approved the "Minutes" of the December 13th, 1974 Commission Meeting. Financial Report for the Month of December was submitted and accepted by the Commission. b—IM Financial Report for the Quarter ending December 1974 was submitted. L-AAW The following summarization of Police Reports for the Mouth of December 1974 was submitted to the Commission. MILEAGE DAYS HOURS CALLS WARNINGS Roy Cowart 1195 22 237 11 -0- Sgt. Wm. McQuade 1674 22 183 22 2 James F. Brown 1452 21 168 16 2 Ron Pabor 1601 23 184 15 4 H. B. Simpson 1314 22 176 27 -0- Wm. Reardon 1222 22 176 20 -0- J. L. Brown 1234 22 176 23 5 David Burns 998 22 186 7 -0- Five B & E's - One Conviction. Mr. Hull from the Palm Beach County Agricultural Department gave a talk on the Lethal Yellowing Disease. Deputy Town Clerk Gwynn gave a progress report on the innoculation program to date. Mr. Franklin O'Brien gave a report on the joint efforts by the Gulf Stream Civic Association and the Town in helping to alert the citizens of the importance of this project. Mr. O'Brien further noted that the Civic Association had adopted a resolution requesting that the Town pass an Ordinance making it mandatory for removal of diseased trees and require a compulsory program for all property owners to treat all trees ausceptable to this disease. Mayor Koch said the Townwould consider this reco®endation and instructed the Town Attorney to review the legal aspects and advise if such an Ordiance could be pre- pared. 1�� =iMISSION.MEETING MAY 9, 1975 PRESENT: WILLIAM F, KOCH, JR. MAYOR GEORGE W. WALKER VICE MAYOR. JOAN S. LAPORTE COMMISSIONER JOHN K. WHITTEMORE COMMISSIONER LINDLEY S. DETTISON COMPIISSIONER, ALSO ATTENDING; Attorney John Randolph, William Gwynn, Manager, Barbara Gwynn, Deputy Town Cleric, Roy Cowart Police Chief, Larry M. Ball, Chairman. of the Planning Board. The Meeting was called to order at 9:00 A.M. by Mayor Koch. Upon motion by Mr. Whittemore and seconded by Mrs. LaPorte the Commission approved the Minutes of the Regular Meeting April 11, 1975. Financial Report for Month of April, 1975 was submitted and accepted by the Commission. The following summarization of the Police Reportfor the Month of April, 1975 was submitted to the Commission. MILEAGE DAYS HOURS CALLS- WARNINGS Roy Cowart 1040 20 182 11 0 Sgt. McQuade 1528 19 156 13 2 David Burns 1085 21 168 11 1 Jerry Brown 1544 20 160 15 3 Simpson 1652 22 1.76 13 0 James Brown 1462 22 176 28 0 Ron Pabor 1.106 20 160 13 0 Reardon 1102 22 176 12 2 Twenty three aaests, one accident report - Fines for April $265..00 Second and final •reading of Ordinance 75.4 was read. AN. ORDINANCE OF THE. TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, ASSESSING A FEE FOR THE FILING OF PETITIONS OR REQUESTS FOR VARIANCES OR SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS FROMTHEOFFICIAL ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, Upon motion by lir. Walker and seconded by Mrs. LaPorte, Ordinance 75-4 was unanimously approved by the Commission. COMMISSION MEETING x} JUNE 13, 1975 VICE MAYOR PRESENT: GEORGE M. WALKER COMMISSIONER JOAN S. LAPORTE COMMISSIONER JOHN K. WHITTEMORE COMMISSIONER LINDLEY S. BETTISON ABSENT: WILLIAM F. KOCH, JR. MAYOR Also attending, Attorney Weaver, C aver,William Gwynn, Manager, Barbara Gwynn, Deputy Town Roy hief The Meeting was called to order at 9 A.M. by Vice Mayor George M. Walker. Upon motion by Mrs. LaPorte and seconded by Mr. Whittemore the Commission approved the Minutes of the Regular Meeting May 9, 1975. Financial Report for Month of May, 1975 was submitted and accepted by the Commission. The following summarization of the Police Report for the month of May, 1975 was submitted to the Commission. MILEAGE DAYS HOURS CALLS WARNINGS Roy Cowart 710 15 120 10 0 Part of vacation Stg. McQuade 1216 23 184 23 2 H. B. Simpson 1471 21 163 10 1 Ron Pabor 1138 21 168 B 0 J, L. Brown 1214 20 160 6 4 James Brown 1558 23 184 19 0 Wm. Reardon 1171 21 168 15 1 David Burns 1040 20 160 2 0 Judge Martin held traffic court May 29, 1975. There were 30 traffic cases. 27 convictions and 3 not guilty. he Court also found 2 young men guilty of trespassing on Mr. Evans property, located at 1357 No. Ocean Blvd. Fines and T forfeitures amounted to $928.00. The Police Department also handled 2 traffic accidents and 3 D.W.I's. Resolution No. 75.8 was read to the Commission A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IX, SECTION �, OF THE TOWN CHARTER, FINDING AND DETERMINING IT NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT FOR THE PRESERVATION OF THE HEALTH, SAFETY AND GENERAL WELFARE OF THE RESIDENTS OF THE TOWN TO REQUIRE THE OWNERS OF CERTAIN PROPERTIES TO REMOVE THEREFROM ALL DEAD AND/OR DYING TREES. Upon motion by Mrs. LaPorte and seconded by Mr. Whittemore Resolution 75-8 was unanimously approved by the Commission. JOHN STON,L.ILI ENTHAL & JOHNSTON ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW HARVEY OYILOINO WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 3340E HARRY ALLISON JOHNSTON NEN R4 F LILIENTHAL HARRY A. JOHNSTON n July 3, 1972 Town Commissioners Town of Gulf Stream P.O. Box 255 Delray Beach, FL 33444 Gentlemen: 655.0100 D05NzSffiuHIRgW P. o. Box 4a Some time ago I informed Mr. Worthing of the necessity for our firm to increase the fee which is now being charged the Town of Gulf Stream for legal services. I now relate this information to you for your consideration. For several years this firm has represented the Town of Gulf Stream for a retainer of $50.00 per month, with an additional charge for work done over and above the regular course of the Town's business. We. have found; due to inflation and the increase /�01 in time and effortexpended toward the legal p-roblems of the Town, that it is economically unfeasible for :our firm to continue representation on such a basis. Thus, we submit the following proposal: Representation would continue on the basis of $75.00 per month as a retainer fee, This would include such services as attending meetings, rendering legal advice and opinions, time expended on telephone calls, ordinary communications, etc. The prepartaion of ordinances, resulutions, extraordinary legal research, litigation and any other matter outside the ordinary course of business would not be included in the retainer fee. Fees for those services would necessarily have to be computed on an hourly basis of $30.00 per hour. This firm has enjoyed representing the Town of Gulf Stream for the past several years and would like to continue in that capacity. We hope that the terms set out herein meet with your approval. Please feel free to ca.il if you have any questions in regard to this matter. Thank you.. Very truly yours, >JOHNSTON, LILIENTHAL & JOHNSTON By JCR/ml JONES FOSTER JOHNSTON & STUBBS, P.A. Attor,nays and Counselors John C. Randolph, Esquire Direct Dial: 561-650-0458 Direct Fax: 561-650-0435 E -Mail: jrandolph@Jones-fostercom May 31, 2006' Mr. William H. Thrasher Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea.Road Gulf Stream, Florida 33483 Re: Town of Gulf Stream Our File No, 13147.1 Dear Bill: Hagler CenterTmer, Suite 1100 505 South Rader flrtye West Palin Beach, Florida 33401 Telephone(561)659.3000 Aloi/ingAddress Post Office Box 3475 Nest Palm Beach,,Flodda 33402-3475 Please be advised that the firm is proposing to modify my hourly rate to $210.00 per hour beginning September 1, 2006. As you know my hourly rate has been $190.00 per hour since September 1, 2001, with no increases since that date. Thank you for your consideration of this matter. Sincerely,. JONES, FOSTER, JOHNSTON & STUBBS, P.A. John C. Randolph JCR/ssm zoww.jon es fosl er. cont John C. Randolph, Esquire . Direct Dial: 561-650-0458 Direct Fax: 561-650-0435 E -Mail: jandolph@jones-foster.com July 14, 2008 Mr. William H. Thrasher, Town Manager Town of Gulf Stream 100 Sea Road Gulf Stream Florida 33483 Re: Town of Gulf Stream Our File No. 13147.1 Dear Bill: Pursuant to our recent discussion, please be advised that I propose to increase my hourly rate for the Town of Gulf Stream, effective August 1, 2008, to $235.00 per hour. Thank you. Sincerely, JONES, FOSTER, JOHNSTON & STUBBS, P.A. John C. Randolph JCR/ssm Gulf Stream, FL Code of Ordinances Page 1 of 4 PARTI- CHARTER TOWN OF GULF STREAM FOOTNOTE(S); — (1) -•- Editor's note— printed herein is the Charter for the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida, ordinance number 80-1, enacted on February 8, 1980, and adopted by referendum held on March 11, 1980. Obviously misspelled words have been corrected without notation.Words added for clarification have been added In brackets 0. Amendments, have been included and are Indicated by a history note immediately following the amended section. ARTICLE I. CREATION AND POWERS Section 1.01..• Creation and powers. The Town of Gulf Stream is created, which shall have all governmental, corporate and proprietary powers to enable It to conduct municipal government, perform municipal functions and render municipal services, and may exercise any powerfor municipal purposes except as otherwise provided by law. ARTICLE II. - CORPORATE LIMITS Section 2.01. - Description of corporate limits,. The following areas shall constitute the corporate limits of the Town of Gulf Stream; (The boundary description is not printed herein, but is on file in the city clerk's office,] ARTICLE III. - LEGISLATIVE Section 3.01. -Town Commission; powers, composition. There shall be a. Town Commission with all legislative powers of the Town vested therein, consisting of five (S) members who shall be electors of the Town, electedat large bythe electors of the Town in the manner hereinafter provided. Section 3.02. —Qualifications. Any elector of'the Town shall be eligible to hold the office of Town Commissioner. The Commission shall be thejudge of the election and qualifications of its members and of the grounds for forfeiture of their office. A member charged with conduct constituting grounds for forfeiture of his office shall be entitled to a public hearing on demand, and notice of such hearing shall be published in one or more newspapers ofgeneral circulation in the Town at least one. (1) week in advance of the hearing. Section 3.03. - Election and terms. The Commissioners shall hold office for a term of three (3) years beginning at noon of the third day after their election and shall continue in office until their term expires and until their successors. are elected and qualified. There Shall be an election of a Commissioner or Commissioners in the manner prescribed in Article V of this Charter, on the second Tuesday in March on any yearin which a vacancy or vacancies are occasioned by the expiration or early termination (voluntary or involuntary) of the terms ofthe office of Commissioners. aboutlblanlc. 2/19/201.5 Gulf Stream, FL Code of Ordinances Page 2 of 4 Section 3.04. - Compensation and expenses. Commissioners shall serve without compensation but they shall receive their actual and necessary expenses Incurred in the performance of their dudes of office as provided by law. Section 3.05. - Mayor and Vice Mayor. The Commission shall select from among Its members a Mayor and a Vice Mayor. Such selection shall be done at the first regular Commission meeting after the Town election. The Mayor shall preside at meetings of the Commission, shall be recognized as head of Town government for all ceremonial purposes, by the Governor for purposes.of military law, for services of process execution of contracts, deeds and other documents, and as the Town official designated to represent the Town in all agreements with other governmental entitles or certifications to other governmental entities, but shall have no administrative duties except as required to carry out the responsibilities herein. The Vice Mayor shall act as Mayor during absence or disability of the Mayor. Section 3.06. - Vacancies; forfeitures of office; filling of vacancies. (a) Vacancies. The office of a Commissioner shall become vacant upon his death, resignation, removal from office in any manner authorized by law or forfeiture of his office. (b) Forfeiture of Office. A Commissioner shall forfeit his office if he: (1) Lacks at anytime during his term of office any qualification for the office prescribed by this Charter or by law, or (2) Violates any standard conduct or code of ethics established by law for public officials, such violation to be determined by remaining members of the Commission. (c) Filling of Vacancies. A vacancy on the Commission shall be filled by a majority vote of the remaining members of the Commission for the period of time until the next election, when a Commissioner shall be elected for the remainder of the term vacated. (d) Extraordinary Vacancies. In the event that all members of the Commission are removed by death, disability of forfeiture of office, the Governor shall appoint an Interim Commission that shall call a special election. Section 3.07. - Procedure. (a) Meetings. The Commission shall meet regularly at least once in every month at the Town Hall or at such time and place as the Commission may prescribe. Special meetings may be held on the call of the Mayor or of a majority of the members and, whenever practicable, upon no less than twelve (12) hours' notice to each member and the public. All meetings shall be public. (b) Rules and Minutes. The Commission shall determine Its own rules and order of business. The Commission shall keep minutes of its meetings. (c) Voting. Voting, on ordinances and resolutions, shall be by majority vote, or If requested by a Commissioner, by a roll call, and shall be recorded in the minutes. A majority of the Commission shall constitute a quorum; but a smaller number may adjourn from time to time and may compel the attendance of absent members in the manner and subject to the penalties prescribed by the rules of the Commission. No action of the Commission except as otherwise provided in the preceding sentence shall be valid or binding unless adopted by the affirmative vote of the majority of a quorum present. about:blanlc 2/19/2015 Gulf Stream, FL Code of Ordinances Page 3 of 4 (d) Annual Audit At the end of each fiscal year the Commission shall select and employ competent Independent auditors to review the Town's financial activities and condition for the year and to express their opinion thereof. ARTICLE IV. -ADMINISTRATIVE Section 4.01. - Town officers. The Commission shall appoint a Town Manager, Town Clerk, and a Chief of Police who shall serve at the pleasure of the Commission and perform such duties as may be specified by law or the Commission. The Commission may appoint such other officers, consultants and employees as may be needful. Section 4.02. - Compensation. The Commission shall determine for each officer, consultant or employee his kind and amount of compensation and his employee benefit status. ARTICLE V. - NOMINATIONS AND ELECTIONS Section 5.01. - Electors. Any person who is a resident of the Town who has qualified as an elector of this state, and who registers in the procedural manner prescribed by general law and ordinance of the Town, shall be an elector of the Town. Section 5.02. - Nonpartisan elections. All nominations and elections for the office of Town Commissioner shall be conducted on a nonpartisan basis without regard for or designation of political party affiliation of any nominee on any nomination petition or ballot. Section 5.03. - Nominations. Candidates for the office of Town Commissioner shall be nominated for such office(s) by the filing of a written notice of candidacy with the designated Town official at such time and in such manner as may be prescribed by ordinance. Section 5.04. - Form of ballots. The Commission by ordinance shall prescribe the form of the ballot or method of balloting including the method of listing candidates for Town Commission elections, and any other Town election. A Charter amendment to be voted on by the Town shall be presented for voting by ballot title. The ballot title of a measure may differ from its legal title and shall be a clear, concise statement describing the substance of the measure without argument or prejudice. Section 5.05. - Elections. Town elections shall be held on the second Tuesday in March. The election of candidates for the office of Commissioner shall be determined solely on the basis of a plurality of votes cast at the election and shall not be a run-off system of voting. If for any reason an elected candidate refuses to acknowledge or accept the campaign seat or term of office which he has been elected to, then that Commission seat and term of office shall be awarded to the candidate who received the next largest number of votes cast at the election. In case all vacancies on the Commission cannot be filled In this manner, the Commission shall elect a person or persons to fill such vacancies. about:blank 2/19/2015 Gulf Stream, FL Code of Ordinances Page 4 of 4 ARTICLE VI. -TRANSITION SCHEDULE Section 6.01. - Ordinances preserved. All ordinances in effect upon the adoption of this Charter, to the extent not Inconsistent with it, shall remain in force until repealed or changed as provided herein. Section 6.02. - Rights of officers and employees. Nothing in this Charter except as otherwise specifically provided shall affect or impairthe rights or privileges of persons who are Town officers or employees at the time of adoption. Elected officers shall continue to hold their offices and discharge the duties thereof until successors are elected. Section 6.03. - Pending matters. All rights, claims, actions, orders, contracts and legal or administrative proceedings Involving the Town shall continue except as modified pursuant to the provisions of this Charter. CHARTER COMPARATIVE TABLE ORDINANCES This table shows the location of the sections of the basic Charter and any amendments thereto, Ordinance Date Referendum Number Date 80-1 2- 8-80 3-11-80 Section 1.01-6.03 Section this Charter 1.01-6.03 about: blank 2/19/2015 TOWN OF GULF STREAM PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Delivered via e-mail November 19, 2015 Chris O'Hare [mail to: chrisoharegulfstream@gmail.comj Re: GS #2043 (Alexander, Watkins allegations) Attached is the title page of the published Code of Ordinances for the Town of Gulf Stream Florida (copied from the Town's web site). Please note that this title page contains a section labeled CURRENT OFFICIALS of the TOWN OF GULF STREAM, FLORIDA, and under this heading John C. Randolph is identified as Town Attorney. (1) Please provide any public record documenting where the Town Commission by a majority vote, or anyone officially designated by the Town Commission to act on their behalf, has authorized the entire law firm of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, as an entity, to be the Town Attorney instead of the individual John C. Randolph as claimed on the attached Town's published code of ordinances. (2) Any public record, other than billing records and notices of billing rate increases, that would document, substantiate, support or in any way be related to the statement by Larry Alexander, Chairman and President of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, made to the Florida COMMISSION ON ETHICS regarding complaint no. 15-001 that his entire law firm (Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs), and not the respondent individually (John C. Randolph), serves as the Town Attorney for the Town of Gulf Stream. (3) Any public record that would document, substantiate, support or in any way be related to the statement made by Scott Watkins, of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, to the Florida COMMISSION ON ETHICS during the hearing of complaint no. 15-001, that there is a contract between the Town and the entire law firm of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, other than billing records and notices of billing rate increases, to serve as Town Attorney. (4) Any contract THAT INCLUDES PROVISIONS that anyone or everyone at Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs is authorized or mandated to complete legal services for the Town of Cruj( Stream. Dear Chris O'Hare [mail to: chrisoharet,ulfstream(,cmail.coml, The Town of Gulf Stream received your public records request on November 5, 2015. You should be able to view your request at the following link httn://www2.gulf- stream.ore/weblink/O/doc/70190/Pagel.asnx. In future correspondence, please refer to this public records request by the above referenced numbers. For parts 1 & 4, please be advised that there are no responsive records. For parts 2 & 3 of your request, the Town disputes that you have identified those portions of the public records that you seek with sufficient specificity to permit the Town's records custodian to identify the records as is required under the Public Records Act. Your request is vague, ambiguous and overly broad. Without conceding the propriety of your request, the Town responds that public records responsive to part 2 of your request include the Town meeting minutes dated 5/12/72, 2/19/73, 1/10/75, 5/9/75 and 6/13/75 and the correspondences dated 7/29/69 and 1/15/71, which are available at the same above link. The Town construes part 3 of your request to refer to "Scott Hawkins", a partner at Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. and responds that all of the documents available at the above link are partially responsive to your request. The Town believes that there may be additional records requests made to it or its records custodians that would be responsive to parts 2 and 3 of your request. However, to review Town records going back to the 1970s to determine whether there are any other records responsive to your request and produce those records will require extensive clerical or supervisory assistance. The Town estimates that it will require at least 8 hours of administrative support at $40.51 per hour, 4 hours of administrative support from the office of Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. at $50.00 per hour and 4 hours of attorney time by an attorney at Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. at $235.00 per hours, the labor costs of the personnel providing the service, per Fla. Stat. § 119.07(4)(d). In light of the foregoing estimates of the extensive clerical or supervisory assistance required to fulfill your records request, before producing documents, the Town will therefore require a deposit from you calculated as follows% (8 hours @ 40.51 = 648.16) — (.25 hours @ 40.51 = 10.13) + (4 hours @ 50.00 = $200) + (4 hours @ 235 = 940) = Deposit Due: $1,778.03 in cash or check. If the costs of producing these documents will exceed your deposit, the Town will provide you with an initial production of responsive records and an estimate for the production of any additional responsive records. If the costs of production are less than the deposit, the Town will provide you with the responsive records and a refund. Upon receipt of your deposit, the Town will use its very best efforts to further respond to your public records request in a reasonable amount of time. Sincerely, Town Clerk