HomeMy Public PortalAboutPRR 15-2072Kelly Avery
From: Record Requestor <publicrecordrequester@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, December 11, 2015 11:07 AM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15
Attachments: Ward Report on Hanna from O'Connor..pdf
Mr. Thrasher,
Please forward this email to the Custodian of Records for the Town of Gulf Stream,
Custodian,
Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the attached document?
The records I wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or anything created
in the preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly about, the attached document.
Respond to: publicrecordrequester(@,,email.com
On Friday, November 13, 2015, I attended the scheduled monthly Town
Commission Meeting at Gulf Stream Town Hall at 9:00 A.M. In
attendance were Martin O'Boyle, Christopher O'Hare, Attorney Jonathan
O'Boyle and Attorney Mark Hanna, along with a number of town
residents and persons conducting business with the town.
For much of the meeting I observed Jonathan O'Boyle and Mark Hanna
conversing in the lobby of Town Hall. Towards the end of the meeting
the Commission presented changes to a number of Town Ordinances.
Martin O'Boyle rose to the podium to speak on the Ordinance changes
but deviated from the topic and, when his allotted time of three minutes
expired, he refused to take his seat until so directed by a Gulf Stream
Police Officer.
Mark Hanna then rose to the podium and shortly became embroiled in
harsh words with the Chair and in defense of Martin O'Boyle and
Christopher O'Hare. He too was directed to his seat by a p9lice officer.
After the meeting I was approached and engaged in conversation by Mark
Hanna. I knew Mr. Hanna as he had deposed me as Christopher
O'Hare's attorney in a lawsuit Mr. O'Hare had filed against the Town.
Mr. Hanna told me that he was no longer associated with O'Hare and
O'Boyle. He said that as O'Hare's attorney he attended a meeting with
O'Hare and the O'Boyles, the purpose of which was to develop
hypothetical strategies for targeting individuals. He said he participated
and provided some input and the meeting ended. Afterwards he was
provided a list of individuals that were to be targeted utilizing the
strategies discussed at the meeting. Mr. Hanna said he would not do
that because he felt it was unethical. He was then directed to assist
other members of the O'Boyle law firm in implementing the targeting
strategies and he refused to do that as well and he was fired.
Mr. Hanna said his firing was the best thing that could have happened to
him. He is now involved in work that he enjoys and he is glad that he
doesn't have anything to do with those people any longer.
Mr. Hanna did not say why he attended the meeting. Our conversation
ended shortly thereafter and Mr. Hanna went on his way.
iA:
O BTS Number PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT t.Anasl 3. Raquastforwement Juvenile
2. N.TA. 1, Requeslfor Ceplaa 3
o ABFLOency RIN 5 0 1 3 0 0 mber Aaerry Name Aaeroy Report Number
G GULFSTREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT 1
Charge Type. f. Felon
Check a many y 3. Misdemeanor 5. Ordinance Spedal Ndee:
as apply. ❑ 2. Traffic Felony D 4. Traffic Misdemeanor ❑ B. Other
Name OLost, First, Middle) Ie,Martin,E viae Race Se: Delsa Binh
rn
Charge Deacnption 10/12/51 W M 10/12/51
Ch rip Description
C Disorderly Conduct
< charge Omcnptian Charas Deeclphon
Resisting Officer Without Violence
Victim's Name (Last Fist Middle)
Race Sex Dets of ehih
FLoral
cp
Address atreot Apt Number) (cb) (State) lap) Pnone Addreae Duma
Business Address (Name, Street) (Oily) ISmtel (act!) Phone Ocapalion
TIN understoned contains and swears that 11I has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that as above nemetl Dalanda0t committed the folbwhq violation d law.
The Person taken into custody
® cemmihed the below acts In my presence. ❑ was observed by
__who told
❑ mnkaaetl to that he/she saw the arrested person commit the below acts.
admitting to bre 6e1ow fads, ❑was
found to have committed the below acts, resuRing from my (described) Investigatton.
On the 22 day of September yg 15 at 5:50 CIA -M- ® PA. (Specifically include facts consliluling cause for arrest.)
At the end of a public Town Hall Meeting at Gulf Stream Town Hall 100 Sea Rd Gulf Stream Florida
33483, county of Palm Beach. Mr. Martin O'Boyle a Town Of Gulf Stream resident was acting disorderly
by engaging in such conduct as to constitute a breach of peace. Mr. O'Boyle attempted to deface public
property by writing with a marker on a poster displayed at Town Hall. When I directed Mr. O'Boyle to
refrain from his attempt to deface the poster, He asked, "What are you going to do about it"?" I Then
directed Mr. O'Boyle to move away from the poster and he loudly replied "Fuck you". I then directed Mr.
O"Boyle to leave the building and his loud response was , "Go Fuck Yourself'. At that point Chief Ward
engaged Mr. O'Boyle in an attempt to have him comply with my direction to leave the building. He loudly
responded to the Chief, "Fuck You, Go Fuck Yourself you Fucking asshole". Mr. O'Boyle then moved
directly in front of Chief Ward at a very close distance from him, puffed up his chest and shoulders and
w
glared at the Chief in a threatening manner. Chief Ward asked O'Boyle, "What is that a combat stance?".
Mr. O'Boyle responded, "Yeah its a combat stance." I then attempted to escort Mr. O'Boyle from the
building. He moved to the exit door which I had put in an open position, Mr. O"Boyle then stopped and
va
pulled his arm free of my hand, stating "I'm not going anywhere." He then grabbed the door frame and
`
gingerly lowered himself to his knees. Chief Ward and I attempted to raise him to his feet but he refused to
cooperate. This incident occurred in the Gulf Stream Town Hall Lobby when meeting attendees were
m
passing through the Lobby and were subject to Mr. O'Boyles Tirade of obscenities and his disruptive and
a
disorderly conduct. Probable cause exists to charge Mr. O'Boyle in that he acted in a disorderly manner,
obstructed justice and resisted an officer without violence. Mr. O'Boyle did not comply with a lawful order
to leave Town Hall on several occasions.
SWORN AND SUBSC IB ED BEFORE ME
w
~ L \,rr(M
SIGNATURE Oq AFtgESTINGIINVEBTiGAT�I GO
yQ CES
NOT RY PU IC! CL RI ' F COU OFFICER IF .9. 11210) VV
= S John Passe iats
M923/15
NAME OF OFFICER (PLEASE PRINT)
DATE
9/23/15 PAGE
DATE I OF
OBTSNumber ARREST/ NOTICE TO APPEAR
1 Areal
Juvenile Refrerral Report 2. N.T.A. a_ Reeueel far Wa Juvenile
4. Request (or Caples 3
Agency Num oar as
A enc Name
?
F FLO 50 1 3 00 B GULFSTREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT Agency Report Number IN.T.A.'e only)
z Charge Type y ❑ 1 Felony ® 3. Misdemeanor ❑ 5. Ordinance Weapon 9el'el I Type
I- Check ee men
Muni e
_m ea e I . El2. Traffic Felon ❑ 4. Traffic Misdemeanor E]6. Other 2 i Nos Cluae�anca
? LowlA
llon omet including Nerre of ouaness) Inclicanor
GLceentibn of Offeree (Business Name, AddhoI
a
4te dArre9 Tore olM
9nns meet among Owe Bbn. Tine Jaa Cale Jed Times Location I vaniNa
3
Name (Last, Fast. Meadia)
Albs (Name. DOB, Soe Sec #. Etcj
cannel• Sax RIO 10/12/51,
W Ha;
American Indian ght Wight Eye color He'r Color Campli Buy
e - eleckg- Onentalualen W M 10/12/51
6'2" 250 BrDwn Gre LI ht Lar e
Sears, Mark', T111008, Unique Physical Feature, (Locatian, Type, 011"A
tion) Markel Steals Religion Indication of Y nk
Alcohol Influence ❑
Married
F revs beat, umber (City) D Influence ❑ ❑ ❑
(710 one Rescan Type:
0 23 N Hidden Harbour Dr GULF STREAM FL Cllr
33483 561 2725468 3 Fbroe
Permanent Addnse (Street Apl. Number) 2 CounlY 4. Out of 91e1e 3
(Shia)
0
wvt Phone pydr,a arm
23 N Hidden Harbour Dr GULF STREAM FL 33483
561 2725468
Bmirnes Atltlrea (Name, Sinai) (CAI a
(ap) DOW on
DIL Number, anal. Soo. Sae. Number IN um
0140-565-51-372-0 149-42-5865 P!xeo/BiM (City,9Mle) ens p
Ca-Oeferdanl Name (Leet, Firet praI New Jerse USA
LL
ear
Raee Dale of BiM ❑ 1 Artested ❑ 3. Felony
❑
Nems Ca Defen11 2. Al Lags 4. Misdemeanor
dant (Last, Fire Midrib)
Raw Date d HIM 6 Juvaoib
❑ 1. Aansaf 3. Felony
❑ 4. Misdemeanor
Neme(WD ❑ 2 A lupe S. Juvenile
LegalsCusladan ( a
Omer ftaskarrca none
reea( treat, Apt. umbar) (City)
e (➢pl venue one
a ed by:( ams
Deb
Time
Ju till D yyalaon
1. withn
?s
Relesaa To: INsms)
Door. ad/pnwaed 2. TOarwroa Y6
Dept. era Released. 3. Incercenled
'
Reblbnahip
Date Time
Tha ,bove eddroeaDymvitlad by debntlent enp/a sen enu enema a an ear parent was o
to keep ma Juvenile Court Clerk (Phone ]55.2528) Inform ed p1 any ooi Attended
eRenge of addres$. Grade
❑ Yu, ay: (Name) ❑ No. (Reuan)
ryperryrrpe• eaenp ono roper
LI You
LI No VI of Property
c
p
Dry Actlrily 9. Sell R. Smuggle K. Oieyyensel an.., ora then prop yPa aMlNnb H. NalWcnagen P.
N. 1P/A e. Buy 0. Deliver DiaWbute Produced op
o
N. IA eme rel Unlike on
P. Passau T. TnRc E. Use CuWvab A C. Cocaina M. Mariluarn EgbllanA_ 2.Omar
AmpMteMro E. Heroin
&W
O. OpIumlDetiv. 6 e
hero, Description ynlhetics
Counts statute Violation Number
isorderl Conduct Vlalelipn of ORO i
M°°®N
877 03
OmgNlvity DrugN AmourdI nd OtbnseAl
csi
Warrant l Capias Number Bcd
1
Charge Deaciption Counb a 6btWe VIOare nNunber
esistin Officer Without Violence Nobtlano 0ft0#
1 -Loy-N 843.02
OmgN ivlly ors" Amorar"UNI Oaena.#
Warrent/Caplan Numbar
as
2 Bantl
W
C.,a. Descipum Courts Damesuc 6talule Vialellon Number
re
Vobnca Violation of ORD #
Y
❑ [IN
ch
Drug AmNI rug Type Amount I Untt ea# Wananty spree Number
Bwd
ou
Charge Distripvon Count. Domestic 6latula Violation Numbar
pp
s
Vbbr¢e Violation of ORO #
I.,
Drug PUNdy Drug Type Pnwrra/Una Offers. Y N
Warteni! Capin Number
w
Bow
❑ Instruction No. 1
Lotion (COnrt Room Number, Addrea)
Nary Appearance In court
❑ InstructionNo. 2 N/AMISDEMEA FILING WITH STATE ATTORNEYS OFFICE
a
pd
YouNOR
w neenot appaer in Corot bol must Court Date and 7Me
ccaFb winstructionsithinstructionsve
ns on ftera eBide.
O
w I
Asendin Day Year Time
AGREE TO APPEAR AT THE TIME AND PLACE DESIGNATED
F FAIL
TO ANSWER THE OFFENSE CHARGED OR TO PAY THE FINE SUBSCRIBED. 1 UNDERSTAND THAT SHOULD I WILLFULLY
TO APPEAR BEFORE THE COURT AS REQUIRED BY THIS NOTICE TO APPEAR, THAT I MAY BE HELD IN CONTEMPT OF COURT AND
o
X A WARRANT FOR MY ARREST SHALL BE ISSUED
9/23/15
Slprnlme of Oefenpanl (or Juvenile antl Pwent /Cuslodlan)
HOLO
Dela Signed
for olhor Agency 91 tun blAmatinp qmE')
Nems
Namevery ian(PriNatl ..W)
V by Ar
\
❑
Oangamra Resisbd Anent Neme a Inp 0llcer(Prnt) 1.0 # (PRINT)
❑ Subbed ❑ Omer: S
,Jahn Passe lata 748
IMehe
Deputy I'D is PouMr# Truspbrting Officer ID pperry PACE
Y an.. hen N --bled signed wish AI 1
OF
DBTS Number ARREST I NOTICE TO APPEAR
I. Arrest
3. Juvenile Referral Report 2. N.TA Juvenile
4. Requertfor Capiaet
Agency I umber
w 3
Agency Name
FLO 5 0 13 00 g GULFSTREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT Agency Report Number (N.T,A.'e only)
IGhupe Type: ❑ 1. Felon
I Chae ee many Y ®3. Misdemeanor ❑ S. Ordinance Weapon
Seized /Type
age I . ❑ 2 Traffic Felon ❑ 4. Traffic Misdemeanor ❑ 6. Other 1. Yea
2 Clearelnca
L®tian rAmn (Intlldlnp Nana of Buainees) 2 No
c Lomgon r Offense (S s. Name. PGtlnv)
OeleafAmsl Tare ofA hear Stool pate Baskin Tore
9/23/15 D Jell gra Jdl Tan. Location a Vehicle
Name (Last, Flat, Middle)
Arias (tarns. DOS, So-- Sea i, Eta)
10/12/51,
Rasa hex ata al Bath Haight 1"Ai
W -White[ -American In d tan gro Eye Coro'
HeirColor Cwnple4on Bund
B -Bleck D- Orlsnlal/Asian W M 10/12/51 6'2"
250 Brown Gre
Scab, Marks, Tetoo,. Unlqus Physical Features (Location, Type, Description) LI ht Lar e
Marital Steals RanplonIndksGan of: Y Unk.
W. qd au Vest, unber) Maarried o hloouerYeva� 0 O 0
(rIp)
N Hidden Harbour Dr GULF STREAM cuy
'�
IV
3. Flake
33483 561 2725468 2. Coum
Pamlananl Address (Street, APO. Number (Cly) (Sire) Y 4. Out of Sbte 3
0
(2iP) Phone
23 in Hidden Harbour Dr GULF STREAM Addreaa Ounce
FL
33483 561 2725468
Business Address (Name, SVeeD
%—Y)e )
pe n
OIL Number. State Sec. Sec. Number
0140-56551-372-0 I um r Plaubofaso(CIty,Sleb) m p
149-02-5865
Cokam �peferNeme(Last, Flnl Mgdb) New Jerse USA
VCo-Drflderd
ale firth 13 1. Armadea 3. Felony
Name (Leat,'.. More) ❑ 2 Al large 13
4. Misd^
leanor
D js
Race pre of arta
❑ 1, Arai 3. Fa"
Parer Name (Ler) ❑ 2 A Large 4. Mi., maemr
Lepel Curatlion a ❑ 5. J.. IW
Other Rudenu ne
Address ( 'reel, Ap ....... (city)
ZP) vamus one
o lied bY:( ems)
4
Onto Time Ju nu povitlan
1. i�an5led}preusaed
iO
>
Within 2. TOT HRS /DYB
Released Ta: Name Dept end Released.
( ) 3. Incanantad
Reielionship
Dole Time
The aboveyy
the Juvenla Ceufi Cle„yPhono X552 njlo� eenen spabns eci an "'Fenn was v�. caval
f 25e28 In
armed ��a(( any crunpa of address. sanies Grads
LLII Yee, by: IName) L7 No:
(Reason)
,._n fry ni�pp.s,, asap no reps
LJ Yes
LIN, Value of Pnpany
M
NnlilA ihhy S. Sail K Smuggle X. Ohsnnems/ eau acture/ mer B. aNitunta
B. Buy p. Daher Distribute
'5A
P Post... Pnduu/ N'IIp/AYps H. HaIMciMpen eraphamalm U Unkn"vm
T. Traffic E. Uu Cueivra A IAXeoruoln e M Mfi)usna Equpmant Z. Other
E. O.OpIum10edv. 9. Synlhatlm
Charge Description
w
Counb mss is SteMta Vwletlen Number
Vwlanu
Violation of ORD a
Ely [INy4
Onp AcnWfy Onp Type gmaunt/Unit others.i Warrant l Copies Humpar
Berea
u
CAvrge paeatlpgon Counb omealm Statute Vlolagan Number
Vlolmu Violation of ORD a
Y
❑ ❑N
s
v
Drug Activity Onp Type Amountl Unit Offense Warrant I Caples Number
Band
w
Chergo Deecripnon
Counts Domestic Statute VII Number
Statute
m
Violence of ORD e
❑Y ON3mg Acfivily Ong Type ee
tlnIi
Wemnt I Capbe Number
Sono
Charge
DsacnptlonCvunb
e Statute Violation Number
e
qy
Moan.
Vlobnu Notation of ORO i
Y N
Ong
Activity Opp Type Amount/Unit Oaensei Warrant /Capin Numbf
Bond
❑ ]MIM mn No. 1 Location iCourt Room Number, Adi
albn No. 2
❑ MandandMandalay,Appeanm k rCaul N/A ]VIiSDEMEANOR FIi',ING WTCH STATE ATTORNEYS
o-
OFFICE
You need not appear in Coot but must Court Date and Time
comply with lhad r kms on Power, Side.
O
W
Morsh Dry Year Time
AGREE TO APPEAR ATT HETIMEANOPLACEIRED
F FAIL
TO APPEAR BEFORE THE COURT REQUIRED BY THIS NOTICETO APPEAR, THATI MAY BE HELO IN CONTEMPT OF COURT
B THISTED TO ANSWER THE OFFENSE CHAR GED OR TOPAYTHE FINESUBSCRIBED. IUNDERSTAND THAT SHOULD I WILLFULLY
i
AND A WARRANT FOR MY ARREST SHALL BE ISSUED
Slgretun aloolendar4 (or Juvenile and Parent /Custodian) 9/23/15
Door Sipped
OLD for Omar Agency
sta
Sip re ofAmalinp Om"er�
Nems:
1S/
Name '101171 Mi (Famed pygrreree)
❑ Dangerous Resisted ARed
p s'e`pia' ❑ Other
X
Nem of sting Officer (Print) _ID.
(PRINT)
S t. John Passe iata 748
PAGE
retake OepulY I.O.a PourAa
Tranvponin9Ogmr lot Agency
4t51neet mere if eublea alpmtl whh en -X'
2
OF
OBTS Number PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT i. Amest 3. Request for Warrant
Juvenile
Z ]. N.T.A. A. Request for Caplan 3
Agency ORI Number Agency Name Agar spat Number
FLO b 0 1 3 0 0 Age,
POLICE DEPARTMENT 1
Cherie Type: 1. Felon
Check as many y 3. Misdemeanor S. Ordinance Spatial Notes:
ea apply. ❑
2. Tratric Felony 4. Traffic Misdemeanor 6. Other
u Name (Last, First, Middle) Rau Sex Data pl Binh
o 'Bo Ie,rlpti n,E Alias10112/51
rn
Change DeaWplbn W M 10/12/51
w Disorderly Conduct Cne ga Msalptbn
Cnarne Desatptlan Charge Deealpoon
esistin Officer Without Violence
Victim's Name (Leet, First, Middle)
Raw Sex Dave of Birth
ULowlAtltlrese
(Street, Apt Number (City)
(State) (zip) PnoneAddress
5
Busheea Atltlreee.name. Streat) (Cay) (BleteJ (sip) Phone
Osupallon
The undenlpned n Into canto ewean that helehe has rust and reaeaebie grounds b believe, and dose ulleve Nal the above named Defendant communed the fdbwing vlaatbn of law.
The Parson ishan Into custody
❑ commlited the below acts In my presence. ❑ was observed by
13 confessed to who told
that he/she saw, the arrested person commit the below acts.
atlmitling to the below facts' ❑ was found to have Committed the below acts, resulting from my (described) Invaetlpatlon.
On the day of 20_ei Elk M- ❑P.M.(SpeeJRceily Include (acts
constituting cause for arrest.)
z
w
a
w
a
N
6
J
SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME
F=
SIGNATURE OF ARFU:STING
/ INYEsnGAnNG OFFICER
m NDTARY PUBLIC/CLERK OU T/OFFICEfi (F.S.5. 11 .10)
g 9/23/15 S .John Passe iate
DATE NAME OF OFFICER(PLEASEPRINT)
9/23/15 PAGE
DATE _Lo,_
FILING RECEIPT
Case No:
Arrest Date: 9/23/15
Received with reference to Defendant: O'Boyle,Martin,E
(NAME)
The following in the above style case ( CHECK )
®
I.)
Police Reports
®
2.)
Witness Lists
❑
3.)
Evidence List
®
4.)
Probable Cause
®
5.)
Rough Arrest
®
6.)
Criminal History
❑
7.)
❑
E.)
❑
9.)
❑
10.)
Charged by officer with Disorderly Conduct -Resisting Officer WitLoutViolence—
Charges filed by A/S/A
Officer's Name: SgL John Passeggiata
THIS 23
By
DAY OF September , 20 15
Assistant State Attorney
GOLF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT
STATE ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
FILING INFORMATION FORM
DEFENDANT O'Boyle,Martin,E
A/R/A: 10/12/51,
CO-DEFENDANTS (if any)
VICTIM RELATED/ACQUAINTED WITH DEFENDANT? YES-__ NO x N/A _
ARREST DATE: 923/15 AGENCY CASE NO.: 1
ARRESTING/LEAD OFFICER: S8t John Passe2Riata
AGENCY GULF STREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT PHONE NO.: 561-278-8611
CURRENT SHIFT HOURS: 0700 TO 1900 DAYS OFF:
LEAVE/SHIFT CHANGE INFO:
WAS ARREST MADE FOR, OR IN CONJUNCTION WITH ANOTHER AGENCY AND IF SO
WHAT AGENCY?
SENTENCING RECOMMENDATIONS:
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS, IF ANY:
».«.«««»««......«« «»« .......»«»«»«»«.«»»»«»«»».»»»
FILING DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:
ROUGH ARREST
P.C. AFFIDAVIT (SWORN ORIGINAL)
SWORN STATEMENT OF MATERIAL WITNESSES
WITNESS/EVIDENCE LIST
OFFENSE REPORTS (ALL)
ACCIDENT REPORTS (ALL)
WITNESS STATEMENTS (ALL)
FCIC/NCIC CRIMINAL HISTORY
OTHER ATTACHMENTS INCLUDE:
** PLEASE NOTE REQUIREMENT OF SWORN STATEMENT(S) OF MATERIAL WITNESSES;
REQUIRED BY SUPREME COURT FOR FILING (RULE 3 140(g) RCrP)
DEFENDANT:
Arres
D E FENDANT / EV2 DENCE L 2 S T
Officer
Filing Officer: Sgt. John Passeggista
PAG, 1 OF—PAGES
Circuit Court Case
I
Police Dept. Case #
A. NAMES, ADDRESSES AND PHONE NUMBERS OF ALL PERSONS WHO MAY
HAVE INFORMATION WHICH MAY BE RELEVANT TO THE OFFENSE
CHARGED OR ANY DEFENSE THERETO, ARE PROVIDED ON PAGE 3.
B. ARE THERE ANY STATEMENTS OF PERSONS LISTED IN PARAGRAPH 1?
❑ Yea ® NO ❑ Written ❑ Taped
❑ Oral (Check only if statement was written down when
person said it)
Copy of transcript provided ❑ Yes ❑ No
C. WRITTEN RECORDED, AND/OR ORAL STATEMENTS OF DEFENDANT (USE
additional pages if necessary)
1 ) Person to whom made:
Date of Statement: Written ❑ Taped ❑
Oral ❑ IF ORAL WHAT DID HE/SHE SAY?
Person to whom made:
Date of Statement Written
Oral ❑ IF ORAL WHAT DID HE/SHE SAYS
❑ Taped ❑
PAGE 2 OF_ PAGES
D. WRITTEN, RECORDED AND/OR ORAL STATEMENTS OF CO-DEFENDANT.
(use additional pages if necessary)
1) Person to whom made:
Date of Statement: —_ Written ❑ Taped
Oral ❑ IF ORAL WHAT DID HE/SHE SAY?
J. PAPERS OR OBJECTS BELONGING TO OR OBTAINED FROM DEFENDANT.
(use additional pages if necessary)
ITEMS CUSTODIAN CHAIN OF CUSTODY
1)
2) —
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
12)
Gulf Stream Police Department
2 ) Person to whom made:
Date of Statement: _
Oral ❑ IF ORAL WHAT
DID
Written
HE/SHE SAY?
❑
Taped ❑
E.
F.
G.
H.
GRAND JURY TESTIMONY
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMANT
ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE
SEARCH AND/OR SEIZURE
REPORTS OF EXPERTS
Name of Expert:
Nature of Testimony:
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
YES
YES
YES
YES
YES
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
J. PAPERS OR OBJECTS BELONGING TO OR OBTAINED FROM DEFENDANT.
(use additional pages if necessary)
ITEMS CUSTODIAN CHAIN OF CUSTODY
1)
2) —
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
12)
Gulf Stream Police Department
K. OTHER EVIDENCE
ITEMS
1 )
2)
3 )
4 )
5)
6 )
7 )
8 )
9 )
10 )
11 )
12 )
PAGE 3 OF _PAGES
(use additional pages if necessary)
CUSTODIAN CHAIN OF CUSTODY
L. ANYTHING SHOWING THE DEFENDANT MAY NOT BE GUILTY: ❑ YES ® NO
Source:
Describe Information:
M. INFORMATION OR EVIDENCE TO BE SUPPLIED LATER
additional pages if necessary)
Item•
Date will be furnished: _
Why not supplied at filing:
(use
NOTE: IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE OFFICER FILING THE CASE TO INSURE THE FOREGOING LIST IE CONFUTE An
CORRECT.
9/23/15
SIGNATURE OF FILING OFFICER DATE
Gulf Stream Police Department
VICTIM/WITNESS LIST PAGE 4 OF _-pAGES
VICTIM:
ADDRESS: (W)
(H)
PHONE: (W) (H)
IF NO PHONE, THEN NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER OF PERSON WHO MAYBE CONTACTED TO ACCEPT MESSAGE:
CAN TESTIFY TO:
w X '
ARRESTING OFFICER: Sgt JohnPassegmeta ID# 748
DEPARTMENT: GULFSTREAM POLICE DEPARTMENT
ADDRESS: 246 SEA ROAD, GULFSTREAM, FL 33483
PHONE: (W) 561-278-8611 (H) 561-278-8611 _
CAN TESTIFY TO: The information contained within the police reports.
NAME: Mr. Serge Delaville ID#
ADDRESS: (W)
(E) 4225 County Rd Gulf Stream F133483
PHONE: (W) (H) cell 561-573-7150
IF NO PHONE, THEN NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NOMBER OP PERSON WHO MAY BH CONTAMM TO ACCEPT MESSAGE:
CAN TESTIFY TO: Mr. O'Boyle acting disorderly in the Town Hall Lobby, and resisting arrest
without violence.
NOTE: CIVILIAN WITNESS GIVE HOME AND BUSINESS ADDRESS AND PHONE N0. OFFICBRS-BUSINESS ADDRESS AND PROVE ONLY y
Gulf Stream Pollee Department
" . . . " " " " . " . . . . " . " . . . . " . . . " " . . . . : . . " " . . . . " . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " . . . " . . " " . . . . . P a g e 5 O F P a g e s
N A M E : W i l l i a m T h r a s h e r ( T o w n M a n a g e r ) I D #
A D D R E S S ( W ) : 1 0 0 S e a R d G u l f S t r e a m T o w n H a l l
( H ) :
P H O N E ( W ) : 5 6 1 2 7 8 - 8 6 1 1 ( H )
F N O P H O N E , T H E N N A M E , A D D R E S S A N D P H O N E N U M B E R O F P E R S O N W H O M A Y B E C O N T A C T E D T O A C C E P T M E S S A G E :
C A N T E S T I F Y T O : M r . O ' B o y l e a c t i n g d i l o r d _ e r l y I n t h e T o w n H a l l L o b b y , a n d r e s i s t i n g a r r e s t
w i t h o u t v i o l e n c e .
N A M E I D #
A D D R E S S ( W ) :
( H Y
P H O N E ( W ) : t H ) :
F T C R A 3 1 9 ' F E N N I M
C A N T E S T I F Y T O :
. . . . a . . . e " " u u " " " " " . . . . . . " . . . . " . . . . . " " " . . . . " . " . " " . " . " . " " . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " . . . " . . "
N A M E : I D #
A D D R E S S ( W ) :
(
H ) :
P H O N E ( W ) :
H
I F N O P H O N E , T H E N N A M E , A D D R E S S A N D P H O N E N U M B E R O F P E R S O N W H O M A Y B E C O N T A C T E D T O A C C E P T M E S S A G E :
C A N T E S T I F Y T O :
^ F
N O T E : C I V I L I A N N I T H E S S G I V E H O N E A N D B U S I N E S S A D D R E S S A N D P H O N E N O . O F F I C E R S - B D S I N N I S S S S A D D R E S S A N D P H O N E O N L Y
G u l f S t r e a m P o l i c e D e p a r t m e n t
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
December 16, 2015
Record Requestor [mail to: publicrecordrequester@gmail.com]
Re: GS #2072 (Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15)
Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the attached document? The
records I wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or
anything created in the preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly
about, the attached document.
Dear Record Requestor [mail to: nublicrecordrequester(a gmail.coml,
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records requests dated December 11, 2015.
The original public record request can be found at the following link: http://www2.gulf-
stream.ore/WebLink/DocView.aWx?dbid=0&id=75064&naee=l&ci=1. Please refer to the
referenced number above with any future correspondence.
The Town of Gulf Stream is currently working on a large number of incoming public records
requests. The Town will use its very best efforts to respond to you in a reasonable amount of time
with the appropriate response or an estimated cost to respond.
Sincerely, Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
December 30, 2015
Record Requestor [mail to: publicrecordrequester@gmail.com]
Re: GS #2072 (ward statement of 11-17-15)
Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the attached document? The records I
wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or anything created
in the preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly about, the attached
document.
Dear Record Requestor [mail to: i)ublicrecordreeuester(a,email.coml,
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your public records request dated December 11, 2015.
Your original public records request can be found at the following link htto://www2.gulf-
stream.org/weblink/O/doc/75064/Pagel.aspxx. Please refer to the referenced number above with
any future correspondence.
It appears you have inadvertently provided two different documents. The Town is under the
assumption from the subject line that you are referring to the statement from Chief Ward. Please
be advised that there are no other records related to that statement.
We consider this matter closed.
Sincerely,
Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records
From: Record Requestor [mailto:publicrecordrequester@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, December 30, 2015 4:49 PM
To: Bill Thrasher <bthrasher@gulf-stream.org>
Subject: Follow up to GS #2072 + Fwd: FW: Public Record Request to Jones Foster - 5.00077 reports
hanna - widboom
Dear Custodian of Records,
On December 30, 2015 you responded to my record request copied here for your reference:
Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the attached document? The records
I wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or anything
created in the preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly about, the
attached document
You labeled your response as follows: Re: GS #2072 (ward statement of 11-17-15)
You stated in your response:
It appears you have inadvertently provided two different documents. The Town is under the
assumption from the subject line that you are referring to the statement from Chief Ward. Please
be advised that there are no other records related to that statement.
We consider this matter closed.
Unfortunately your assumption is wrong. The abbreviated caption in the subject line is a short
hand reference and not a limiting description. Also note that I did NOT inadvertently provide
two different documents. The attached document which is the subject of this record request was
provided to me in its entirety by Ms. Joanne O'Connor in response to another public record
request I made to the firm of Jones Foster Johnston & Stubbs P.A. I have forwarded Ms.
O'Connors email with the document attached for your reference.
May I soon be allowed to inspect any records responsive to this request?
i3ublicrecordreciuester(@,jzmail.com
SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
January 8, 2016
Record Requestor [mail to: publicrecordrequester@gmail.com]
Re: GS # 2072 (Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15)
Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the attached document? The records I
wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or anything created
in the preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly about, the attached
document.
Dear Record Requestor [mail to: publicrecordreauester(a)email.coml,
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your record request dated December 11, 2015. Your
original public records request and clarification can be found at the following link
htta://www2.gulf-stream.ore/weblink/O/doc/75064/Pagel.asi)x. Please refer to the referenced
number above with any future correspondence.
The Town understands that an email from 11/24/15 was produced to you on 12/21/15 in response
to your request, JF206, directed to Jones, Foster, Johnston & Stubbs, P.A. The Town does not
concede that the record is a public record of Gulf Stream. There are no public records responsive
to your request.
We consider this matter closed.
Sincerely,
Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records
From: Record Requestor <publicrecordrequester@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, January 13, 2016 8:04 PM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: Fwd: GS # 2072 (Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15)_supplemental
Attachments: GS # 2072 (Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15)_supp.pdf; document -
ward-oboyle.pdf
Dear custodian of Records,
Thank you for your supplemental response to my request for public records of Nov 17, and Dec 11, 2015
(response forwarded below).
You claim to not concede that the record is a public record of Gulf Stream. And you further claim there are no
public records responsive to my request.
I feel there is a strong possibility that public records responsive to my request do indeed exist or once existed. If
the records once existed but no longer exist then please provide for my inspection the disposition record for any
records that no longer exist. If you claim records responsive to my request never existed because you can't find
them then please look again. I make this request as a courtesy to you to give you one more opportunity to
provide these records for my inspection.
Here again is the request; attached are the referenced documents titled document - ward-obovle.pdf
Can you provide far my inspection any records related to the attached document (attached)? The records I
wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or anything created in the
preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly about, the attached document.
Best regards,
publicrecordrequester(a�gmail.com
Forwarded message
From: Bill Thrasher <bthrasher(a)gulf-stream.orj,>
Date: Fri, Jan 8, 2016 at 2:08 PM
Subject: GS # 2072 (Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15)_supplemental
To: "publicrecordreouester(a,email.com" <publicrecordrectuesterCa pnail.com>
Confidentiality Notice: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended
recipient(s). If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all
copies of the original message. Florida has a very broad public records law. Written communications regarding
Town of Gulf Stream business are public records available to the public upon request. Your e-mail
communications are therefore subject to public disclosure. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public
records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send
electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing.
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
January 19, 2016
Record Requestor [mail to: publicrecordrequester@gmail.com]
Re: GS # 2072 (Public Record Request ward statement of 11-17-15)
Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the attached document? The records I
wish to inspect would include things like drafts, notes, memos, emails, letters or anything created
in the preparation of, or at least partly a consequence of, or at least partly about, the attached
document. (amended 1/13116 - Can you provide for my inspection any records related to the
attached document (attached)? The records I wish to inspect would include things like drafts,
notes, memos, emails, letters or anything created in the preparation of, or at least partly a
consequence of, or at least partly about, the attached document. )
Dear Record Requestor [mail to: publicrecordreeuester(a)email.coml,
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your record request dated January 11, 2015. Your
original public records request can be found at the following link http://www2.gulf-
stream.ore/weblink/O/doc/75064/Pastel.asox. Please refer to the referenced number above with
any future correspondence.
The Town is aware that an identical follow-up request was made by you to the Town's outside
counsel, Joanne O'Connor, on 12/11/15. The Town further understands that an email dated
11/24/15 was provided in response to that request. The Town does not concede that that email is
a public record of Gulf Stream. In any event, there are not and never have been any records
responsive to your request.
We consider this matter closed.
Sincerely,
Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records