HomeMy Public PortalAbout12-8449 Contract with F.R. Aleman for Preparation of Water and Sewer System Sponsored by: City Manager
Resolution No. 12-8449
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
OPA LOCKA,FLORIDA,TO AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER
TO NEGOTIATE AND EXECUTE THE CONTRACT WITH F. R.
ALEMAN FOR COST SOLICITATION FOR THE PREPARATION
OF WATER AND SEWER SYSTEM ATLASES; PROVIDING FOR
INCORPORATION OF RECITALS; PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS,pursuant to Resolution 12-8396,the City of Opa-locka(City)issued Request for
Proposal # 12-2106100 (RFP) for the preparation of Water and Sewer System Atlases; and
WHEREAS,seven bidders responded to the RFP,and the Evaluation Committee ranked the
top three most responsive bidders, 1) F. R. Aleman, 2) Robayna & Associates, 3) Corzo Castella,
respectively; and
WHEREAS,both Water and Sewer Atlases(Atlases)are funded in Fiscal Year 2012 under
the Capital Projects and will have no adverse financial impact to the current budget; and
WHEREAS,the Atlases will provide accurate locations of the Water and Sewer Systems and
are critical for the Public Works and Utilities Department for maintenance and prevention of
problems such as leaks and breakages within the Water and Sewer systems; and
WHEREAS, staff recommends the awarding the contract to the most responsive and
responsible bidders, F. R. Aleman; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Opa-locka desires to authorize the City
Manager to negotiate and execute the contract with F. R. Aleman for the preparation of Water and
Sewer System Atlases for the City of Opa-locka.
NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF
Resolution No. 12-8449
THE CITY OF OPA-LOCKA, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The recitals to the preamble herein are incorporated by reference.
Section 2. The City Commission of the City of Opa-locka hereby authorizes and
directs the City Manager to negotiate and execute the contract with F. R. Aleman for cost in
preparation of Water and Sewer Atlases.
Section 3. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 12th day of September, 2012.
MY' • AYLOR
MAYOR
Attest to:
•
J.4 nna Flores
In -rim City Clerk
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
,11/1
Ai
J eph 7.. Geller
It)/At orney
Moved by: VICE MAYOR JOHNSO
Seconded by: COMMISSIONER MILLER
Commission Vote: 5-0
Commissioner Holmes: YES
Commissioner Miller: YES
Commissioner Tydus: YES
Vice-Mayor Johnson: YES
Mayor Taylor: YES
10327484 vl
pn-LOCk
,'FOI \\..
lU' ni
ry
"/Jg
'0 R
pt
City of Opa-Locka
Agenda Cover Memo
Commission Meeting 9/12/2012 Item Type: Resolution Ordinance Other
Date: X
(EnterXin box)
Fiscal Impact: Ordinance Reading: 1st Reading 2nd Reading
(EnterXin box) Yes No (EnterXin box)
x Public Hearing: Yes No Yes No
(EnterXin box) X X
Funding Source: (Enter Fund&Dept) Advertising Requirement: Yes No
Ex: (EnterXin box)
Account#64-533630 X
Contract/P.O.Required: Yes No RFP/RFQ/Bid#:
(EnterXin box) RFP#12-2106100
Strategic Plan Related Yes No Strategic Plan Priority Area: Strategic Plan Obj./Strategy: (list the
(Enter X in box) specific objective/strategy this item will address)
X Enhance Organizational p
Bus.&Economic Dev - 1. Will help reduce man-hours
Public Safety - water and sewer system
Quality of Education repair and maintenance.
Qual.of Life&City Image - 2. Is required per Consent
Communication D Agreement with Miami-Dade
County.
Sponsor Name City Manager Department: Public Works
Short Title:
Authorization for the City Manager for the price negotiation to prepare Water and Sewer Systems Atlas
Staff Summary:
The purpose of this resolution is to negotiate price to seek service from FR Aleman for the Preparation of
Water and Sewer Systems Atlas in the City of Opa-Locka.
Proposed Action:
Staff recommends approval in order to prepare Water and Sewer Atlas to comply with Consent Agreement with
Miami-Dade County.
1
Attachment:
1. Agenda
2. Evaluation Summary Sheets
3. Panel Member's evaluation sheet
4. Copy of Resolution# 12-8396
2
c,Lopk
O
a AEI
/
Z.
teo/
Memorandum
TO: Mayor Myra L.Taylor
Vice-Mayor Dorothy Johnson
Commissioner Ti oth olmes
Commissioner R .e Ty► s
Commissioner Ga 1 Mi e
FROM: Kelvin L.Baker,Sr.,City Mana • '
DATE: September 12,2012
RE: Authorization for the City Manager for the price negotiation to prepare Water
and Sewer Systems Atlas
Request: A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF OPA-
LOCKA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
NEGOTIATE WITH THE TOP RANKED BIDDER F.R. ALEMAN
SOLICITED UNDER RFP 12-2106100 FOR COST SOLICITATION FOR THE
PREPARATION OF WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS.
Description: The City of Opa-locka requested and received proposals from seven bidders for
the preparation of Water and Sewer Systems Atlas. The evaluation committee ranked the three
top most responsive bidders as listed below:
BIDDER SCORE RANK
F. R. ALEMAN 472 1ST
ROBAYNA&
ASSOCIATES 442 2ND
CORZO CASTELLA 440 3RD
The Water and Sewer Atlases in the City of Opa-locka are over thirty (30) years old. The old age of the
atlases causes inaccuracy. As a result, the Public Works and Utilities Department has to rely on human
memory and staff familiarity with the City's system in order to service some areas of the City utilities.
Also, the Utility Crew has to react to problems such as leaks and breakages, etc. rather than monitoring
and preventing them. Due to the City's ongoing aggressive Capital Projects Program, it has become
critical to have accurate locations of all underground utilities; including size and depth of sewer and water
mains; location of hydrants, valves, manholes, etc. to facilitate design and limit construction costs.
Ultimately, this information will become part of a Citywide Geographic Information System (GIS). This
will provide a visual tool for the location of a water meter, shut off valve, and sewer lateral in relation to a
service address. The Water and Sewer Atlas will increase operational efficiencies, safety of staff and
citizens and saving costs,as well as an overall savings over a long term outlook.
1
Financial Impact: Both Water and Sewer Atlases are funded in Fiscal Year(FY) 2012 under the capital
projects section and therefore will have no adverse financial impact. Rather, the operational costs savings
with the capacity for new residences and businesses to connect to the wastewater collection system. There
will be cost savings in performing maintenance and repairs which will have a great economic impact for
the entire community.
Account Number: 64-533630- Water Division-Improvements Other Than Buildings
Implementation Time Line: As soon as possible.
Legislative History: Resolution#12-8396
Recommendation(s): Staff recommends negotiating the price with the top ranked bidder F.R. Aleman.
Analysis: This recommendation is based on the City's inaccurate existing Water and Sewer Atlas, which
is over thirty (30)years old. Also, a new atlas will save man-hours in performing maintenance and repairs
and the Geographic Information System (GIS) will have a positive economic impact on the entire
community.
ATTACHMENT(S):
1.Evaluation Summary Sheets
2. Panel Member's evaluation sheet
3. Copy of Resolution# 12-8396
PREPARED BY: Mohammad Nasir,PE,Interim Public Works Director
Arshad Vigar, PE, Project Utilities Engineer
END OF MEMORANDUM
2
Sponsored by: City Manager
Resolution No. 12-8396
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
OPA-LOCKA,FLORIDA,TO AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER
TO ISSUE REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS (RFP) FOR QUALIFIED
CONSULTANTS FOR THE PREPARATION OF WATER AND
SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS,PAYABLE FROM ACCOUNT NUMBER
64-533630; PROVIDING FOR INCORPORATION OF RECITALS;
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS,the Public Works and Utilities Department rely on human memory and staff
familiarity with the City's Water and Sewer system to maintain some areas of the system,since the
Water and Sewer Atlas in the City of Opa-locka is antiquated and is in need of an update; and
WHEREAS,the City needs to have accurate locations of the system in order to monitor and
prevent leaks and breakages,within the system; and
WHEREAS, as the City of Opa-locka considers major improvement projects to its
underground infrastructure, the accurate location of its physical assets will assist in sustainable
managements and will bring the system into line with the current technology; and
WHEREAS, the water and sewer Atlases are both funded in FY 2012, and the City
Commission of the City of Opa-locka desires to authorize the City Manager to issue Request for
Proposals(RFP)to qualified consultants for preparation of Water and Sewer Systems Atlases for the
City of Opa-locka.
NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT DULY RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF OPA-LOCKA, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The recitals to the preamble herein are incorporated by reference.
Section 2. The City Commission of the City of Opa-locka hereby authorizes the City
Resolution No. 12-8396
Manager to issue Request for Proposals(RFP) for qualified consultants for the preparation of
Water and Sewer System Atlases, to be funded from Account 64-533630,Water Division-
Improvements other than Buildings.
Section 3. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 25th day of April,2012.
•
MY TAYLOR
MAYOR
ttest to: (4k.,
A.anna Flores
terim City Clerk
Appr.ved as to form and legal suit ci-ncy:
ti' 1
1 �
Jos . "G; er
Ci a •ttorne
Moved by: COMMISSIONER MIL ER
Seconded by: VICE MAYOR JOHNSON
Commission Vote: 4-1
Commissioner Holmes: NO
Commissioner Miller: YES
Commissioner Tydus: YES
Vice-Mayor Johnson: YES
Mayor Taylor: YES
•
CITY OF OPA LOCKA
EVALUATION FORM
WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS
RFP 12-2106100
COMPANY EXPERIENCE REFERENCES LETTER OF TOTALS
Max pts 75 Max pts 15 INTRODUCTION
Max pts 10
WOOLPERT, INC.
Zeke 65 14 9
Howard 70 15 8
Arshad 45 8 5
Mohammad 40 7 5
Shirley 43 6 6
TOTALS 263 50 33 346
CARDNO TBE
Zeke 65 14 8
Howard 70 15 10
Arshad 42 7 5
Mohammad 45 8 6
Shirley 46 7 6
TOTALS 268 51 35 354
CALVIN,GIORDANO
Zeke 70 15 9
Howard 75 15 10 _
Arshad 50 10 5
Mohammad 50 7 5
Shirley 48 9 5
TOTALS 293 56 34 383
CSA GROUP
Zeke 73 14 10
1 Howard 70 15 10
Arshad 45 9 7
Mohammad 40 8 5
Shirley 43 7 5
TOTALS 271 53 37 361
ROBAYNA AND
ASSOCIATES
Zeke 75 14 10
Howard _70 15 10
Arshad 67 13 8
Mohammad 60 12 7 _
Shirley 65 10 6
TOTAL 37 64 41 442
CORZO CASTELLA
Zeke 75 14 9
Howard 75 15 10
Arshad 65 14 9
Mohammad 55 11 8
Shirley 60 12 8
TOTAL 330 66 44 440 1
F. R.ALEMAN
Zeke 74 13 10 _
Howard 65 15 10
Arshad 70 15 9
Mohammad 73 14 9
Shirley 72 15 8
TOTALS 354 72 46 472
SUMMARY
1. F. R.ALEMAN 472
2. ROBAYNA&ASSOCIATES 442
3. CORZO CASTELLA 440
4. CALVIN GIORDANO 383
5. CSA GROUP 361
6. CARDNO TBE 354
7. WOOLPERT, INC. 346
CITY OF OPA LOCKA
EVALUATION FORM
WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS
RFP 12-2106100
COMPANY EXPERIENCE REFERENCES LETTER OF
Max pts 75 Max pts 15 INTRODUCTION
Max pts 10
WOOLPERT, INC.
CARDNO TBE 6,5 Jf-
CALVIN,GIORDANO
_ qt
CSA GROUP
7 3 1
ROBAYNA AND ASSOCIATES
75 /4 lu qq
CORZO CASTELLA
y (/- 9g
F.R.ALEMAN 74 , rl q I ��
(ea II
ommittee M-tuber •,:nature
Date:
/
CITY OF OPA LOCKA
EVALUATION FORM
WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS
RFP 12-2106100
COMPANY EXPERIENCE REFERENCES LETTER OF
Max pts 75 Max pts 15 INTRODUCTION
Max pts 10
WOOLPERT, INC. '7v / 8
CARDNO TBE
70 /c /o
CALVIN,GIORDANO 75 / 5 l6
CSA GROUP 70 / 5- //)
ROBAYNA AND ASSOCIATES •-7/, l 5 /i)vv I
CORZO CASTELLA 75 16 Jo
F. R.ALEMAN ‘ S l S JO
t,‹ce,iti, /_i i ci/to,n, (6,2,Ac&)
Committee Member ignatur
Date: 7-so i Z
.Y'
p
7'../
k
CITY OF OPA LOCKA
EVALUATION FORM
WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS
RFP 12-2106100
COMPANY EXPERIENCE REFERENCES LETTER OF
Max pts 75 Max pts 15 INTRODUCTION
Max pts 10
WOOLPERT, INC.
tis� 8 s'
CARDNO TBE It Z - c
CALVIN,GIORDANO S d 10
CSA GROUP y S `I 7
ROBAYNA AND ASSOCIATES 67 /3
CORZO CASTELLA 6 5- ) L q
F. R.ALEMAN 70
Committee Member Signature
Date: 7 3 - /2
•
�� J
CITY OF OPA LOCKA
EVALUATION FORM
WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS
RFP 12-2106100
COMPANY EXPERIENCE REFERENCES LETTER OF
Max pts 75 Max pts 15 INTRODUCTION
Max pts 10
WOOLPERT, INC. cc d 7
CARDNO TBE "C
CALVIN,GIORDANO 7
CSA GROUP If 6 '� c
ROBAYNA AND ASSOCIATES 6 O ! 2_ 7
CORZO CASTELLA Sc //
F. R.ALEMAN 7 3 ( 7
dal
Comm' t re Member Signature
Date: .)7V/2"--
' .r-?
( )
CITY OF OPA LOCKA
EVALUATION FORM
WATER AND SEWER SYSTEMS ATLAS
RFP 12-2106100
COMPANY EXPERIENCE REFERENCES LETTER OF
Max pts 75 Max pts 15 INTRODUCTION
Max pts 10
WOOLPERT, INC.
CARDNO TBE
-Y6
CALVIN,GIORDANO
9 5
CSA GROUP
213 `7
ROBAYNA AND ASSOCIATES
Crr l 6 (c,
CORZO CASTELLA
2
F. R.ALEMAN
. g
Corn ittee Member Signature
Date: /1/3/(ot›
o--- ,./sn
l /
(2)