Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutHISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE DETERMINATION LETTER - 314 MANOR PL - Historical Resources e Cultural Arts 2327 SALZEDO STREET CORAL GABLES FLORIDA 33134 @) 305-460-5093 ©) hist@coralgables.com July 6, 2023 Guillermo Alvarez Cynthia Lopez 314 Manor Place Coral Gables, FL 33133 Re: 314 Manor Place, legally described as Lots 4 & 5, Block 4, Coconut Grove Manor, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 17, at Page 19, of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida. Dear Mr. Alvarez and Ms. Lopez, Section 8-107(G) of the Coral Gables Zoning Code states that “All demolition permits for non-designated buildings and/or structures must be approved by the Historic Preservation Officer or designee. The approval is valid for eighteen (18) months from issuance and shall thereafter expire and the approval is deemed void unless the demolition permit has been issued by the Development Services Department. The Historic Preservation Officer may require review by the Historic Preservation Board if the building and/or structure to be demolished is eligible for designation as a local historic landmark or as a contributing building, structure, or property within an existing local historic landmark district. This determination of eligibility is preliminary in nature and the final public hearing before the Historic Preservation Board on Local Historic Designation shall be within sixty (60) days from the Historic Preservation Officer determination of “eligibility.” Consideration by the Board may be deferred by mutual agreement by the property owner and the Historic Preservation Officer. The Historic Preservation Officer may require the filing of a written application on the forms prepared by the Department and may request additional background information to assist the Board in its consideration of eligibility. Independent analysis by a consultant selected by the City may be required to assist in the review of the application. All fees associated with the analysis shall be the responsibility of the applicant. The types of reviews that could be conducted may include but are not limited to the following: property appraisals; archeological assessments; and historic assessments.” Therefore, please be advised that after careful research and study of our records and the information you presented the following information has been determined: 314 Manor Place, legally described as Lots 4 & 5, Block 4, Coconut Grove Manor, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 17, at Page 19, of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida, does not meet the minimum eligibility criteria for designation as a local historic landmark. Therefore, the Historical Resources staff will not require review by the Historic Preservation Board if an application is made at this time for a demolition permit. Please note that, pursuant to Section 14-107.5(b)(15) of the Coral Gables Zoning Code, this determination does not constitute a development order and is valid for a period of eighteen (18) months. In the case where the Historic Preservation Officer or designee determines that the property does not meet the minimum eligibility criteria for designation, a permit for the demolition of the property must be issued within the eighteen-month period. Upon expiration of the eighteen-month period, you will be required to file a new application. Any change from the foregoing may be made upon a demonstration of a change in the material facts upon which this determination was made. If you have any further questions concerning this matter, please do not hesitate to contact this office. Sincerely, Dr Anna Pernas Historic Preservation Officer cc: Albert Menendez, Chair, Historic Preservation Board Cristina M. Suarez, City Attorney Stephanie Throckmorton, Deputy City Attorney Gustavo Ceballos, Assistant City Attorney Suramy Cabrera, Development Services Director Jennifer Garcia, City Planner Analyn Hernandez, P/T, Plans Coordinator Assistant Historical Significance Request Property File City of Coral Gables Historical Resources Department PLANS & DOCUMENT DROP OFF FORM PLEASE COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION SO THAT WE MAY PROCESS YOUR REQUEST ACCORDINGLY: ** PLANS AND DOCUMENTS ARE BEING PLACED IN QUARENTINE FOR 48 HRS.** ***PLEASE WRITE LEGIBLY*** DATE DROPPED OFF: S US | ‘23 PERMIT OR BOARD NO.: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 29 44 YY) uo C e | CONTACT NAME: © &})1 87716 (Aw ACR PHONE NUMBER: 7% G29) —G UO ema: G a\wacez @ ) DG&oo e¥d com Briefly describe the submittal & check where applicable: [ ] New Board of Architects [ ] Local Historic Designation [ ] Board of Architects Re-submittal BY Historical Significance Request (New) [ ] Color Palette Review [ | Historical Significance Request (Reissue) [| Shop Drawings [ ] Certificate of Appropriateness LJ Revisions *Job Site Set Required L Cottage Application [ Other (please describe below) NY Check submitted with Application COMMENTS NEW SHEETS ADDED (Site Plan/Elevation sheets added, must be submitted to the Board of Architects for approval) [| DID NOT ADD NEW SHEETS 06/17/2020 CITY OF CORAL GABLES HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE REQUEST C1 Re-Issue OF ANY STRUCTURE PROPERTY INFORMATION: Folio Number: 03-4129-024-0390 Property Address: 314 Manor Pl, Coral Gables, FL 33133 Legal Description: Lot 4 & 5, Block 4, COCONUT GROVE MANOR, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 17, Page 19, of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida. Original Date of Construction; 1948 Original Architect(s); Unknown OWNER INFORMATION: Owner: Guillermo Alvarez & Cynthia Lopez Mailing Address: 314 Manor Pl, Coral Gables, FL 33133 (Please be sure to include City and_Zip Code) Phone number(s): /86-390-4702 & 305-790-5250 E-mail: Galvarez@TDGroupFL.com CONTACT INFORMATION: Applicant Name: Guillermo Alvarez Mailing Address; 314 Manor Pl, Coral Gables, FL 33133 (Please be sure to include City and Zip Code) OE :O1W Y | SZI A V H E602 Phone number(s): 786-390-4702 E-mail: Galvarez@TDGroupFL.com -Staff Use Only- EDEN SYSTEM PERMIT #: Determination: The property [_]does not meet []does meet the minimum eligibility criteria for designation as a local historic landmark at the present time. Note: The Historical Resources staff will require review by the Historic Preservation Board if the building to be demolished is considered eligible for local designation. Any change from the foregoing may only be made upon a demonstration of a change in the material facts upon which this determination was made. Please be advised that this determination does not constitute a development order. **PLEASE NO TE: Section 3-1107@) of the Coral Gables Zoning Code states that “All demolition permits for non-designated buildings and/or structures must be approved by the Historic Preservation Officer or designee. The approval is valid for eighteen (18) months from issuance and shall thereafter expice and the approval is deemed void unless the demolition permit has been issued by the Development Services Department. The Historic Preservation Officer may require review by the Historic Preservation Board if the building and/or structure to be demolished is eligible for designation as a local historic landmark or as a contributing building, stcucture or property within an existing local historic landmark district. This determination of eligibility is preliminary in nature and the final public hearing before the Historic Preservation Board on Local Historic Designation shall be within sixty (60) days from the Historic Preservation Officer determination of “eligibility.” Consideration by the Board may be deferred by mutual agreement by the property owner and the Historic Preservation Officer. The Historic Preservation Officer may require the filing of a written application on the forms prepared by the Department and may request additional background information to assist the Board in its consideration of eligibility. Independent analysis by a consultant selected by the City may be required to assist in the review of the application. All fees associated with the analysis shall be the responsibility of the applicant. The types of reviews that could be conducted may include but ace not limited to the f ollowing: property appraisals, archeological assessments; and historic assessments.” HISTORICAL RESOURCES & CULTURAL ARTS DEPARTMENT -HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION-2327 SALZEDO STREET, CORAL GABLES, FLORIDA 33134 X:\Forms\Hist-Sig-Req\Hist-Sig-App.doc Page 2 of 2 Revised: 8/17/17 Fro n t of Ho u s e LE G E N D A 2 AC ASP H = Agp h a k BM_ = Ben c h Mar k BRG = B e e r n g CAT V = Cat c h Des i n CB = Cat c h bas i n CBS = Con c r e t e Bloc k Stru c t u r e CH == Cho r d Cha t t a = Cha t t s h o o c h e s € = Cont e r Line GF = Che n Lnk F e n c e CL. = Clea r CON C . = Con c r e t e D = Dett e 9 2 Die m e t e r DH = Dril l Hol e OM E = Cra i n e g e & Mam t e n a n c e . Eas e m e n t EB. = Elec t r i c Box Enc. = Enc r o a c h m e n t FF. = Fins h Floo r FH. = Fre Hydr e n t FR. 5 Fou n d iron Reb e r FPL 2 Flo n d a Pow e r & Lig h t FP . = Fou n d tro n Pip e FD. = Fou n d LP. = Ligh t Pol e M = Mee s u r e d MF. = Meta l Fen c e MH, = Man h o l e Mo = Mon u m e n t Line MON . = Mon u m e n t NIA = Not App l i c a b l e Thi s des c r i b e d as: Lots 4 and 5, Blo c k 4, 3 CO C O N U T GR O V E MA N O R , acc o r d i n g to the Plat 3 N the r e o f as rec o r d e d in Plat Boo k 17, Pag e 19, of the Pub l i c Rec o r d s of Mia m i - D a d e Cou n t y , Flo r i d a . FLP. 1/2 " f- L L Cer t i f i e d to: S . Gui l l e r m o Alv a r e z and Cyn t h i a Lop e z fo } se o Unit e d Who l e s a l e Mor t g a g e , Was h ISA O A / A T I M A & Law Off i c e s of Men d e z & Men d e z , P.A, , 3C. B . S . Old Rep u b l i c Nat i o n a l Titl e Ins u r a n c e Com p a n y WAL L , 1 / 3° (rye ) Add r e s s : 1O COL U N N 314 Man o r Plac e , Cora l Gab l e s , FL 331 3 3 Lo __9 g . 4 5 ' 1.8° x 1 . 8 ° 9 <o ) 15, On PL NOTE S : ‘ ’ Ele v a t i o n s Sho w refe r to NG V D 192 9 NID = Nek & Di X aby, (Miam i D a d e ) a teat . mY . : iami - = Oftset zB 8 ie ON E ST O R Y ; LOT ~ 4 a oe cs O U L L . = Over h e a d Utilt y Lines : Ht . ‘OH — = Ove r h a n : 5 _ 19- 3 , TREE CHA R T are a — 4 — - — — BLO C K > COR N E R j 4 r Ov 27.68 F.LP . 1/2 " @ “PeloU SSWUELAO SsE{UN SiGWIOD Avedold UO PUN; ded Pelou eswuergo Ssejun pemnseelu pus Pores om ANepUnoY OuoR euEriQ [! ANNGAISG LWHOSY 00°00} 9.1 0 ° C L PeodKe 0} PUN; Sem eUNHY 2UjEWW0eS Peso) @ JO UONE/ND|G> pus jVoWesNSBeW Aq peueKD A2e/1DI0 eu, BO; 208d pequssep Lee s8y 6y] UO UOQEABXe 20 4J0m UBisep Aue 0) 000d SeqUOYING eRUdoxdde ey] DeENOD (tT qwoweunber sii 3°C. B . S . . BIBP PoEDs Guu UE YA PorEpYSUOD eq PINoYs “WONs Se pue SuCTDNpOKes UM pereAs eq Asw) OBIS PES $99) OOS'Z U8 1003 4 51 Aavuns Alepunog jo ed] eu J0) Ao92NI9e @2UEISIP SAde}Os WMRUIUI, @4y "UeQUngnS, SCOVI-LUCS) SPSpUS P2UYe! WNUNUT O19 Ul PerZsSED SB PUB] jo Bsn pebedxe ey, AdeNDIy (4 Vone20] SeMsIN Pue VoReUWO;UI BulvoZ ‘Gupyng Pel adep se Seye7s eweLy2IYdesS OY) Fe PeARICSD 6q 01 PepLEIUI 67 IUELUNDOp S1Ig SuOgId DudeKeuL (I ‘POl0U Ss UELIO SsEjUN 3NGNd Om UOeIeY UMOYS Speo AY [6 On (yu posse ke Ub LN Poa . FENC E ae RES I D E N C E 50O % - * “Ey tors , #3 4 4 , . BLO C K ~4 a PB = Pilar Boo k PC = Poin t of Curv a t u r e PCC . = Poin t of Com p o u n d Curv a t u r e PCP = Per m a n e n t Cont r o l Pomt PG = Pag e Pi, = Poin t of Inte r s e c t i o n fe == Prop e r t y Line PL = Plon t e r P.O. B . = Pom t of Beg i n n n g P.0 . C . = Pom t of Com m e n c e m e n t PP, =Po w e r P o l e PR M.= Per m a n e n t Ref e r e n c e Mon u m e n t PR. C . 2 Pomt of Rev e r s e Curv e t u r e PT = Pom t of Ten g e n c y R = Red u s RR =Ra l r o e d PSM = Pro f e s s i o n a l Sur v e y o r Map p e r RM = Righ t - o t Way SW K = Sid e w a k Sec. = Sect i o n (TY P ) = Typ i c a l T = Tan g e n t UE. = Utilt y Eas e m e n t W.F. = Woo d Fen c e WIM. = Wete r Mete r WAY , = Wat e r Val v e WS. = Wete r Sen c o 7 oy t e s sn Elev a t i o n s Tak e n DES C R I P T I O N @ |ner c u T | c a n o p y MUSA BASJ O O BAN A N A la" | 15° ’ PALM | 3s] 8 PALM ae |_| @ PALM 26] is | iz ROYA L PALM er { za] 2 COC O N U T hot so | ot COC O N U T hoy so | ie PALM se | z | + PALM «| | & PALM iz] 30 | 20 PALM 7] 2 | os BUR M E S E FISH T A L PALI N [s”| zo | 8 6 ES PALM sl el 6 ihe JAP A N E S E SPI N D L E si z ] 6 SS mee e Me = == —— -F o u l ~~ =; = TS[M U S A BASJ O O BAN A N A |1I"| 30° | 16° i ’ 1 NCee. 126 16[ MAN G O a | is | 1s :{ , | Sea s 0.3 0 ° E N C R . — — F - wo ' 8 ee ee ee ee a a ae i eae eee ae we qu aNnar a1 «n0Z.2£,06 al — [fof + [fo [re [olo[S [ES]? [2 s ty tn at! SITING; 6 OMe MT FAP. 1/2 8 ws ye Gy wan e Dy 550 LOT - 1 1 BLO C K — 4 BLO C K — 4 BLO C K — 4 = I I | | LOT= 1 3 | LoT= 1 4 I 1 eGewep Aya 20) "oszey) 89 Ao;due 20 wt BLN JO Ld OU UO Artiqe!] 68.0 10U SeOp puB eGeuRp J Gupooy 0158 SUBD OU PUR wel AQ Papiacid UONdUR<Ep Ebel Jed PeABAINS eres UOaIEY PePIdep Spuey () VONPULIOIU PIES UO e>UBKE) WO 53N390 16 “peRdua 10 epeL 68 0/91 / SJANEW 20 GySIBUMO uk SUOANYTSUI JO Soca ‘SU0SsOd 85012 JO @SN 3193005 PUB EANSNPXE GYT 10) AUO $1 AdAins Sip ;0 eNss1 ONL (q pouRuworep wou AGAINS SiQ Us POTDSYS. JOU IDATOS OFF PUG SUOMDURSE) EPOD (3 woe ye? OUT Plat Mer i d i a n (re f e r e n c e ) WA WOI] 664 OQ JOU gu4 20 Ip AUedoud IDeIQNS EYL WUD ACUI JOU SeOp UOSIAY WADYS VONBUUE]UI Poo oy t (o RG 6200) ‘eSN wos Aud UElEdde OY JO O28 UOeJ8Y UMOUS SIUCWIPGO NUE syPLe Se UaZeEP Ty (F Peye20} jou Aue p 's|uoUNpeaIUe pue sHuNCD) ‘Sivewesordus “saan puNnoMsepun (Pp -JLON Dig i t a l l y sig n e d by Re n e Bea r i n g , if any , sho w n bas e d on. Re n e Ai g u e s v i v e s Aig u e s v i v e s PSM 4 3 2 7 REVI S I O N S : sun g y an Upda t e Z7f TOP O G R A P H I C SURV E Y . Alv a r e z , Aig u e s v i v e s and Ass o c i a t e s , Inc. l 'Y CER T I F Y : that this surve y mee t s the PS M 4 3 2 7 Dat e : 202 3 . 0 5 . 1 7 05/1 6 / 2 0 2 3 Upda t e Me anda r d s of pract i c e as set ferh byth e Surv e y o r s , Map p e r s and Land Plan n e r s 15: 4 2 : 0 0 -04 ' 0 0 ' 978 9 Sun s e t Driv e , Mia m i , FL 331 7 3 Pho n e 305 . 2 2 0 . 2 4 2 4 Fax 305 . 5 5 2 . 8 1 8 1 L.B. No. 686 7 / E-ma i l : aaa s u r v e y @ a o l . c o m TNo t vali d unl e s s |No. |PANE L N o | SUFF I X ! ’ “TH I S SUR V E Y DEC L A R A T I O N IS MAD E ON THE FIEL D FLOO D ZONE ] COMM . No a it beers the Xx 126 6 3 9 04 5 9 L sig n a t u r e and the DAT E IND I C A T E D , TO THE OWN E R ( S ) LIS T E D . IT [S NOT ona l eals e d cea! TR A N S F E R A B L E TO ADD I T I O N A L INS T I T U T I O N S OR AM FIR M N D E X T BASE EL riginal ras ab a SUB S E Q U E N T OWN E R S . ” F.LR . M . D A T E | F.1.R. M . € ELEV. of Foi e \ice n s e d Date Scal e : | Draw n b y : | Drwg . No. Mapp e r . MAP P E R No. 4327 . Stat e of Flori d a . 02/ 0 3 / 2 1 1"=2 0 ' | RS. 21- 2 2 5 6 1 09 / 1 1 / 0 9 0 9 / 1 1 / 0 9 +N A NG N D . SQUARE FOOTAGE PERMIT No. DATE BUILT .: SQ.-FT: hh COCONUT -GROVE -MA -NOR LOTS 4 & 5 BLK 4 Me/trnA. ur nr I 414 ENTRY _ _ GARAGE - CARPORTE - _ i BREEZE WAYS - i OPEN PORCHES - 1 SCREEN ,c _ 1 SERVANT:QTS.- FULL GARAGE ' OTHERS. FULL 8116_..-_,-'_I_! 12526....-.... _ 17289 3 1948------ -- 1955__- 196L_ I ----1-51,1 r2 - SCF_ENC i Bc.--tJL 17- 4 j3 t 4 gl /. 5 5 6 6 7 TOTAL 7 r11307)-353' rsC Errs. 11961 ...1_ 1338. ;1955: 1 T I I I,_ t I i } I E- 7 I L t - ITT' t r t _ i t t t t { i It , Ir. I IVr,/j/ r l/.. 4,/ //J/ J W.; /4 /f 1. J _ 4 L e.r IJ 7 ,. 1 I t 1 1 I I 1 I. 77- io. @ hr' /. iV .P r o' a ry r _ T_'' , i 7 1 ; _ L •_ i , f 33 i t L I- I i' 1"- 6_E9 I i b { r . ' v G7f 1.r/. f2zI # F F`/ G 1 i .,_ 1 _ 1 1 i-. " ,.. ! -4 i .. I ' 1• .7 I 1 -'. L r r ^— c a { t — 1- ; i ! I :-_+ c, J .: 1 I t 1 r r hl t off I I L I f i- 7f- t 1 o 1t 1.:-.!..'....: i. r l r 7 S{• r. t J S - I. _ JI d i I/S ii 1 t1 if I r 1 x c - - -, �-. -- ;1 -.‘69t9-kH Price —3Iqp. Furn Unf PL— 61 B-3589 4—13-61 M&L ML expired (Neid.U.riger)remove sh KSM 11 Owner:£1et-P-K4.p-&w,-4G5 1—46 wD:Lee M.Meidlinger &w Gertha L 118 Menores 1.40 2-14-47 .• —- . —.._,—.4’ COC)NUTRO1tFV4NOR.--...Lts 145 F1k 4 1OOxi ,taxes over &POOL RS:31)4 Manor Place permit:)—48,14,0O0 —1 sty Arch:Vahe Balikjian Owner:Lee Neidlinger 3/2,wb.fp,1—c,wail,ige scrnd patio w/fish pond;part (divided)of pati.roofed w/diriing area,util rn POOL &GARAGE ADDN:pmt #17289B,11—16—61 O/Neidlinger 450O: SCRN ENCL:ç #17593B,7—13—62 Climatrol 2556(Neid1inger) — cot’d fr ovez:&&L-69k9 3..-4G taxes W0111,City 145.94 Co 380.37;extg mtg apx U1L Chase Fed,MI;terms rrgd RE2AOVED —over The Miami News (Miami, Florida) · S at, S ep 23, 1978 · Page 4 https ://www.news papers .com/image/302391445 Downloaded on Jun 28, 2023 Copyright © 2023 News papers .com. All Rights Res erved. The Miami Herald (Miam i, Flo rida) · S un, S ep 24, 1978 · Page 106 https ://www.news papers .com/image/627770228 Downloaded on Jun 28, 2023 Copyright © 2023 News papers .com. All Rights Res erved.