HomeMy Public PortalAboutHISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE DETERMINATION LETTERS - 4420 PALMARITO ST -
Historical Resources ev
Cultural Arts
2327 SALZEDO STREET
CORAL GABLES
FLORIDA 33134
@) 305-460-5093
@® hist@coralgables.com
August 18, 2023
Gustavo and Susana Cisneros
4420 Palmarito Street
Coral Gables, FL 33146
Re: 4420 Palmarito Street, legally described as Lots 13 & 14, Block 12, Coral
Gables Riviera Section Part 1 REV PL, according to the plat thereof as
recorded in Plat Book 28 Page 31 of the public records of Miami-Dade
County, Florida
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Cisneros:
Section 8-107(G) of the Coral Gables Zoning Code states that “All demolition permits
for non-designated buildings and/or structures must be approved by the Historic
Preservation Officer or designee. The approval is valid for eighteen (18) months from
issuance and shall thereafter expire and the approval is deemed void unless the
demolition permit has been issued by the Development Services Department. The
Historic Preservation Officer may require review by the Historic Preservation Board
if the building and/or structure to be demolished is eligible for designation as a local
historic landmark or as a contributing building, structure or property within an
existing local historic landmark district. This determination of eligibility is
preliminary in nature and the final public hearing before the Historic Preservation
Board on Local Historic Designation shall be within sixty (60) days from the Historic
Preservation Officer determination of “eligibility.” Consideration by the Board may
be deferred by mutual agreement by the property owner and the Historic Preservation
Officer. The Historic Preservation Officer may require the filing of a written
application on the forms prepared by the Department and may request additional
background information to assist the Board in its consideration of eligibility.
Independent analysis by a consultant selected by the City may be required to assist in
the review of the application. All fees associated with the analysis shall be the
responsibility of the applicant. The types of reviews that could be conducted may
include but are not limited to the following: property appraisals; archeological
assessments; and historic assessments.”
Therefore, please be advised that after careful research and study of our records and
the information you presented the following information has been determined:
4420 Palmarito Street, legally described as Lots 13 & 14, Block 12, Coral
Gables Riviera Section Part 1 REV PL, according to the plat thereof as
recorded in Plat Book 28 Page 31 of the Public Records of Miami-Dade
County, Florida, does not meet the minimum eligibility criteria for
designation as a local historic landmark. Therefore, the Historical
Resources staff will not require review by the Historic Preservation Board
if an application is made for a demolition permit.
This letter is a reissue of the previous letter dated July 19, 2018. Please note that,
pursuant to Section 14-107.5(b)(15) of the Coral Gables Zoning Code, this
determination does not constitute a development order and is valid for a period of
eighteen (18) months. In the case where the Historic Preservation Officer or designee
determines that the property does not meet the minimum eligibility criteria for
designation, a permit for the demolition of the property must be issued within the
eighteen-month period.
Upon expiration of the eighteen-month period, you will be required to file a new
application. Any change from the foregoing may be made upon a demonstration of a
change in the material facts upon which this determination was made.
If you have any further questions concerning this matter, please do not hesitate to
contact this office.
Sincerely,
wen
Anna C. Pernas
Historic Preservation Officer
cc: Monica Loredo, 8775 SW 28 Street, Miami, FL 33165
Albert Menendez, Chair, Historic Preservation Board
Cristina M. Suarez, City Attorney
Stephanie Throckmorton, Deputy City Attorney
Gustavo Ceballos, Assistant City Attorney
Douglas Ramirez, Development Services Assistant Director
Jennifer Garcia, City Planner
Analyn Hernandez, Interim Plans Processor, Lead
Historical Significance Request Property File
CITY OF CORAL GABLES
HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE REQUEST
OF ANY STRUCTURE
PROPERTY INFORMATION:
Folio Number: 03-- 4l O- o a.q- f s o
XRe -Issue
Property Address: / C P4 L/ 74 f' Th sr. • C oM L 45L s .
Legal Description: j_O ! 3t 14 I✓,L OC / 2 P Y/ SE j r L7t 6 p•
CoR. L g7'481- R v(&S,d S c-(-jDN /4kt i ene 2 i)
PAGE 3. Cr 8 Original Date of Construction:
Original Architect(s):
OWNER INFORMATION:
Owner: GU STA vo 4.jG / S N R o S S US74Ah4 C 0/ NERD S
Mailing Address: f4 0 - 4 L- MA - J DC Sr. CC R 4 L+ G74 B L. s
(Please be sure to Include City and Zip Code)
Phone number(s): 305.— 601 4 6 a 7.
E-mail: Gus ctSN ROs @, /-(i . GOf(
CONTACT INFORMATION: L r
1 `"I
Applicant Name: o `� I c4 �) o R b C
Mailing Address: F715 s V V .28 sr- 1-(1,41,41. L,33165.
q / (Pleasebesure to include City and Zip Code)
Phone number(s): -186- 6 S W -I & 13
E-mail:
1ah�Qy_ �esi�n � covncas4. net
-Stag-Use Only -
EDEN SYSTEM PERMIT #:
Determination: The property ❑ does not meet ❑ does meet the minimum eligibility criteria for
designation as a local historic landmark at the present time.
Note: The Historical Resources staff will require review by the Historic Preservation Board iftbe building to be demolished is considered eligible forlocal designation.
Any change from the foregoing may only be made upon a demonstration of a change in the material facts upon which this determination was made.
Please be advised that this determination does not constitute a development order.
'''''PLEASE NO TE: Section 3-1107(g) of the Coral Gables Zoning Code states that "All demolition permits for non -designated buildings and/or structures
must be approved by the Historic Preservation Officer or designee. The approval is valid for eighteen (18) months from issuance and shall thereafter expire and the
approval is deemed void unless the demolition permit has been issued by the Development Services Department. The Historic Preservation Officer may require
review by the Historic Preservation Board if the building and/or structure to be demolished is eligible for designation as a local historic landmark or as a
contributing building, structure or property within an existing local historic landmark district. This determination of eligibility is preliminary in nature and the final
public hearing before the Historic Preservation Board on Local Historic Designation shall be within sixty (60) days from the Historic Preservation Officer
determination of "eligibility."Consideration by the Board may be deferred by mutual agreement by the property owner and the Historic Preservation Officer. The
Historic Preservation Officer may require the filing of a written application on the forms prepared by the Department and may request additional background
information to assist the Board in its consideration of eligibility. Independent analysis by a consultant selected by the City may be required to assist in the
review of the application. All fees associated with the analysis shall be the responsibility of the applicant. The types of reviews that could be conducted may
include but are not limited to the f ollowing: property appraisals; archeological assessments; and historic assessments."
HISTORICAL RESOURCES & CULTURAL ARTS DEPARTMENT —HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION -2327 SALZEDO STREET, CORAL GABLES, FLORIDA 33134
X\ Forms \Hiss-Sig-Req\Hiss-Sig-App.doc Page 2 of 2 Revised: 8/18/2015
Date: July 18, 2023.
From: Monica Loredo, Applicant
L and G Design, Inc.
To: The City of Coral Gables
Historical Resources Department
2327 Salzedo Street, 2nd Floor
Coral Gables, FL 33134.
Reference: Historical Significance Request for
4420 Palmarito St. Coral Gables. Fl.
To whom it may concern:
I would like to know if 4420 Palmarito St. (Lot 13 and 14, Block 12, Coral Gables Riviera Part I) is
historically significant.
Sincerely,
Monica Loredo
JOH N IBARRA & ASS OCIATES , IN C.
Professional Land Surveyors & Mappers
W W W.IB ARR ALANDSUR VEYOR S.COM
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
LOTS 13 AND 14, BLOCK 1 2, REVISED PLAT OF
CORAL GABLES RIVIERA SECTION PART I ,
ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS
RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 28, PAGE 3 1 , OF THE
PUBLIC RECORDS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY,
FLORIDA.
5-
0
0
F,I,P. 1/2"
NO CAP
CL
I-:'
lI
ry
LOT - 1 / ^ I
BLOCK - 1 G
ZI
3. 20' CL
/
TREE TABLE
No.
N ame
Diameter
(Ft.)
Height
(Ft.)
Spread
(Ft.)
1
UNKNOWN
0: 80
25
15
2
ARECA PALMS
2.00
17
I 0
3
ARECA
2. 50
12
8
4
OAK
2.00
35
25
5
ARECA
4.00
12
I5
0
85H TAIL
2.00
12
7
7
ARECA
3. 00
17
17
5
OAK
2.00
35
45
9
ROYAL PALM
1.00
50
10
10
OAK
2.00
30
40
1I
UNKNOWN
0. 70
20
10
12
COCONUT
0. 80
12
8
13
COCONUT
0. 890
12
8
14
CAPPETERIA
1.50
25
12
15
CAPPETERIA
.2.00
25
10
10
OAK
3.00
45
45
17
COCONUT
0. 80
15
10
LOT - 12
BLOCK - 12
N83°50'17"E 137.58'
\
_ Q
CJ
0
o "Q
G\•
u
0
3.50'
L.
02
LV
0
O
3.42'
LOT - 13
m BLOCK - 1 2
ONE STORY N
RES. # 4420
F.F:E = 17. 22
13.31 L,F.E. = 16.69'
0 0 0
\ (D .
co
N
24.21 1.20
.G
4' C.B.W
14.05 0
21.59'
7
30.
Q
0
0'
Nh0
MAP OF BOUNDARY SURVEY
4420 PALMARITO STREET. CORAL GABLES, FL 33 146
GRAPHIC SCALE
-30 0 15 30
(IN FEET)
1 INCH = 30 FEET
SET T.B.M.
NA/L & D ISK
ELEV. = 13.00'
L=99.57'
R=6603. 40'
T=49.78
A=000°51'50"
CH=99. 57'
CHB=S10°36'38"E
:4
11
+tG
Gary'R=20. 00'
L=21.42'
o>�-tFT=11.87'
H=20. 411. ^y%
CHB N19°38'24"E h
,A
t= 1°71'53" +"
T. B.M. SET T. B.M.
F.N.D NAIL &D/SK
\ELEV. = 16.77
NO ID.
CL BY CL
TREE TABLE
18
ROYAL PALM
1 .50
50
I5
I9
ROYAL PALM
1 .50
50
I5
20
ROYAL PALM
1.50
50
I5
2I
MAMEY
0.70
20
15
22
MAMEY
0 .40
17
I2
23
ROYAL PALM
1.00
50
10
24
ARECA
3.00
20
I0
25
FISH TAIL
3:00
17
8
20
FISH TAIL
3.00
17
8
27
5150 TAIL
3 .00
17
8
28
FISH TAIL
2.00
15
5
i
LEGEND
ABBREVIATIONS AND M EANINGS
A = ARC
NC = AIR CONDITIONER PAD.
A.E.= ANCHO R EASEMENT.
NR = ALUMINUM ROO F.
A5 = ALUMINUM SHED.
A551.= ASPHALT.
5. C. BLO CK CORNER.
B. G.R.= BROWARD COUNTY RECORDS
BLDG.= BUILDING.
B.M. = BENCH MARK
B.O .B. = BASIS OF BEARINGS.
B.S.L. = BUILDING SETBACK UNE
C = CALCULATED
C. 1= CATCH BASIN.
C.5.5 = CONCRETE BLO CK STRUCTURE.
CBW = CONCRETE BLOCK WALL.
CH.= CHORD.
CH.B.= CHO RD BEARING.
CL = CLEAR
C. L.F.= CHAIN LINK FENCE.
C. M. E.- CANAL MAINTENANCE EASEMENTS.
CO NC.= CO NCRETE.
G.P. = CONG. PORCH.
C.5.= CONCRETE SLAB.
C. U.P.= CONC. UTILITY POLE
C.W.= CONCRETE WALK
D. E. = DRAINAGE EASEMENT .
D.M. E.= DRAINAGE MAINTENANCE EASEMENTS
DRIVE = DRIVEW AY
= DEGREES.
E = EAST.
EB = ELECTRIC BOX
E.T.P: ELECTRIC TRANSFORMER PAD.
ELEV. = ELEVATION.
ENCR.= ENCROACHMENT.
F.H.= FIRE HYDRANT.
F.I.P.= FOUND IRON PIPE.
F.I.R.= FOUND IRON ROD.
FEE. = FINISHED FLOOR ELEVATION.
F N.D.= FOUND NAIL E DISK.
FR = FRAME.
FT = FEET.
FNIP.= FEDERAL NATIONAL INSURANCE
F.N.= FOUND NAIL.
H. = HIGH (HEIGHT1
!C. V.= IRRIGATIO N CONTRO L VALVE
I.F.= IRO N FENCE
IN.E. EG.= INGRESS AND EGRESS EASE MENT.
L.B. = Ce rtf,wte of A,thonzabon L.5.07805
L.P. = LIGHT PO LE.
LEE. LOWEST FLOOR ELEVATI ON.
L.M. E. = LAKE MAINTENANCE EASE MENT.
' = MINUTES.
M. = MEASURED DISTANCE.
MB = MAIL BOX
M. D.C. R.= MIAMI DADE COUNTY RECORDS
M.E. = MAINTENANCE EASEMENTS
MON. = MONUMENT LINE.
MH = MANHOLE.
MIL = MONUMENT LINE.
N.A.P. = N OT A PART OF.
NGVD = NATONAL GEODETIC VERTICAL DATUM.
N. = NORTH.
N.T.S. = NOT TO SCALE.
0 -NO. = NUMBER.
0/5 = OFFSET.
0.H . = OVE RHEAD
0.H.L.= OVERHEAD UTILITY LINES
O .R.B. = OFFICIAL RECORDS B OOK
OVH = OVERHANG
PVMT.= PAVEMENT .
PL= PL ANTER.
P)L = PR OPERTY UNE.
P.C.C.= POINT OF COMPOUND CURVE.
P.C.= POINT OF CURVE.
PT.= POINT OF TANGENC Y.
HOC .= POINT OF COM MENCEMENT.
705 .= POINT OF BEGINNING .
P.R.C.= POINT OF REVERSE CURVE
P.B.= PLAT BOOK.
PG.= PAGE.
PWY .= PARK WAY.
P0M, = PERMANENT REFERENCE MONUMENT.
PLS.- PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR,
R - RECORDED DISTANCE.
RR .= RAIL ROAD.
RE5.= RESIDENCE.
PROP . CDR .= PROPERTY CORNER
R/W = RIGHT-OF-WAY.
R.P.= RADIUS POINT.
RGE .= RANGE.
SE C= 5ECTION .
51Y.= STORY .
5WK,= SIDEWALK.
S.I.5. 5E IRON PIPE LB. 07800.
5.7. = SCREENED PORCH
5.= SOUTH .
^ = SECONDS
T = TANGENT
TB = TELEPHONE BOOTH
T.U.E.= TECHNOLOGY UTILITY EASEMENT
TSB = TRAFFIC SIGNAL BOX
T.5.P. = TRAFFIC SIGNAL POLE
1/71' = TOWNSHIP.
UTIL= UTILITY.
U.0.= UTILITY POLE.
W M.= WATER METER
W.F.- WOOD FENCE.
W R.= WOOD ROOF.
W M.= WATER METER.
W.F.= W OOD FENCE .
W .12 .= WO OD ROOF .
W.5.= WOOD 5HED.
W = WEST.
9 = CENTER LINE .
p. = CENTRAL ANGLE.
= ANGLE .
o -I1 = OVERHEAD UTILITY LINES
= CONCRETE BLOCK WALL
X X X - CHAIN LINK FENCE
0 0 0 - IRON FENCE
1/ // - WOOD FENCE
= BUILDING SETBACK LINE
- UTILITY EASE MENT
/1/ /1/ = LI MITED ACCESS RAN
/ / = NON -VEHICULAR ACCESS R/W
= EXISTING ELEVATIONS
x 0.00
LOC ATI ON SKETCH
SCALE =N .T .S.
LEGAL NOTES TO ACCOMPANY S KETCH OF SURVEY :
• THERE M AY BE EASEMENTS RECORDED IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS NOT SHO WN ON THIS
SURVEY.
• EXAMINATIONS OF THE ABSTRACT OF TITLE WILL HAVE TO BE MADE TO DETERMINE
RECORDED INSTRU MENTS, 17 ANY, AFFECTING THE PROPERTY.
• TH15 SURVEY 5 SUBJECT TO DEDICATIONS. LIMITATIONS, RESTRICTIONS, RESERVATIONS OR
EASEMENTS OF RECORD.
• LEGAL DESCRIPTIONS PROVIDED BY CLIENT OR ATTESTING TITLE COMPANY.
• B OUNDARY SURVEY MEANS A DRAWING AND/ OR A GRAPHIC REPRESENTATI ON OF THE SURVEY WORK
PERFORMED IN THE FIELD, COULD BE DR AWN AT A SHOWN SCALE AND/OR NOT TO SCALE; THE WALLS OR
FENCES MAY BE EXAGGERATED FOR CLARITY PURPOSES.
• EASEMENTS A5 SHOWN ARE PER PLAT BO OK. UNLESS DEPICTED OTHER WISE.
• THE TERM "ENCROACHMENT" MEANS VISIBLE AND ABOVE GROUND ENCROACHMENTS.
• ARCHITECTS SHALL VERIFY ZONING REGULATIONS, RESTRICTI ONS, SETBACKS AND WILL BE
RESPONSIBLE FOR SUBMITTING
• PLOT PLANS WITH CORRECT INFOR MATION FOR "APPROVAL FOR. AUTHORIZATION" TO THE
PROPER AUTHORITIES IN NEW CONSTRUCTI ON.
• UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED. THIS FIRM HAS NOT ATTEMPTED TO LOCATE FOOTING AND/OR
FOUNDATIONS.
• FENCE OWNERSHIP NOT DETERMINED.
• THIS PLAN OF SURVEY, HAS BEEN PREPARED FOR THE EXCLUSIVE 05E OF THE ENTITIES
NAMED HEREON, THE CERTIFICATE
• DOES NOT EXTEND TO ANY UNNAMED PARTY .
FLOOD ZONE INFORMATION:
THE NFIP FLOOD MAPS HAVE DESIGNATED THE HEREIN DESCRIBED LAND TO BE SITUATED IN:
FLOOD ZONE: X"
BASE FLOOD ELEVATION: N/A .
CO MMUNITY .' 120639
PANE L 0457
SUFFI X: L
DATE OF FIR M: 09/11/2009
THE SUBJECT PROPERTY DOES NOT LIE IN A SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA.
SURVEYOR'S NOTES:
I . 1E SHOWN, BEARINGS ARE REFERRED TO AN ASSUMED MERIDIAN, BY SAID PLAT IN THE DESCRIPTION OF
THE PROPERTY . 10 NOT, BEARINGS ARE THEN REFERRED TO COUNTY, TO WNSHIP MAPS.
2. THE CLOSURE IN THE BOUNDARY SURVEY 15 AB OVE 1 :7500 FT.
3. CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION LB # 7506.
4. ALL ELEVATIONS SHOWN ARE REFERRED TO NATIONAL GEODETIC VERTICAL DATUM OF 1929 MIA MI-DADE
COUNTY BENCH MARK #P-71 14. LOCATOR N0 . 4 152 E; ELEVATION 5 12.27 FEET OF N.G .V .D . OF
1929
SURVEYOR'S CERTIFICATION:
1 HEREBY CERTIFY: TH15 "BOUNDARY SURVEY' OF THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED HEREON, HA5 RECENTLY BEEN
SURVEYED AND DRA WN UNDER MY SUPERVISION, AND COMPLIES WITH THE STANDARDS OF PRACTICE
A5 SET FORTH BY THE FLORIDA BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYORS IN CHAPTER 5J- 1 7. FLORIDA
ADMINISTRATIVE CODE PURSUAIN0TO 472 .027, FLORIDA STATUTES.
BY
09/26/2018
CARLOS IBARRA (DATE of FIELD WORE/
PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR NO.: 0770 STATE OF FLORIDA
(NOT VAUD WITHOUT THE SIGNATURE AND THE ORIGINAL RAISED SEAL OF A FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR
AND MAPPER).
REVISED ON ' ADDED CONSTRUCTION ELEV AND TREES 06/05/2018
REVISED ON: SPOT ELEV AND TREES 09/26/2018
DRAW N BY:
L.L.
FIELD DATE: 09/26/2018
SU RVEY NO:
18-001489-3
S HEET:
1 OF 1
L.B .# 7806 SEAL
NO. 0770
STATE OF