HomeMy Public PortalAboutRespondent's ExhibitsCOMMISSIONERS
SCOTT W. MORGAN, Mayor
ROBERT W. GANGER, Vice -Mayor
JOAN N. ORTHWEIN
THOMAS M. STANLEY
DONNA S. WHITE
August 4, 2015
Christopher
2520 Avenue
Gulf Stream,
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
O'Hare
Au Soleil
Florida 33483
Dear Mr. O'Hare:
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Telephone
(561)276-5116
Fax
(561)777.0166
Town Manager
WILLIAM H. THRASHER
Hand Delivery
Article $198
Town Clerk
RITA L. TAYLOR
On August 29, 2011 the Town of Gulf Stream issued zoning approval
for the replacement of the roof on the home you own at 2520 Avenue
Au Soleil and issued Receipt Number 5777 to your contractor, Rooftec
Corporation. On August 30, 2011, the City of Delray Beach issued the
re -roofing Permit Number 11-135146 to Rooftec Corporation. The approved
permit covered re -roofing the structure with white, thru and thru,
flat cement tile with no slurry coating or paint. This work was started
but has, to date, not been completed in conformity with the permit
that was issued.
Section 42-29 CONSTRUCTION ABANDONMENT states that failure of the
permit holder or the property owner to complete construction once it
has been initiated within the timeframe of the building permit is
a violation.
Section 70-238 ROOFS requires that roofs on homes that are predominately
with Bermuda influences have flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated
tile. The roof is in violation as there is no tile in place.
Section 70-99 ROOF DESIGN, SLOPE AND MATERIALS (3) Prohibited lists
inconsistent roofing materials visible from the exterior o t e property,
except approved accent materials. The material that has been applied is
inconsistent with roofing materials visible from the exterior of the
property or with any other house in town and thus is in violation
of this section of the Code.
100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 33483
Cil
Renye
I
CITY OF DELRAY BEA_ CH
"FAILURE
TO COMPLY WITH THE
.-rWw
----
Plat/Are
MECHANICS' LIEN LAW CAN
COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPT.
RESULT
IN THE PROPERTY
540.00
OWNER
PAYING TWICE FOR
001-0000-329.22-':1;
BUILDING
IMPROVEMENTS" ��
L (561) 243-7218
E:13lPrepared
Zoning
e
Revievved by
DateApplied:
4NSPECN
001-0000-329.32-010
by: TF POMC0
5.10
7-'5c0 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
.00
r, AgentDate
UK
8.10
Subdivision Name
.00
Issued:Pemype:RMIT
Permit Phone Access #: 1455021
.-' x...., ..
it m
1 Z -PrSriY_9: 146 000 i;c:I:,,
Owner's Name/Address/Telephone
e I -
Cil
Renye
7wnhp.s
section
sn
sub Dv. Block
Lot
.-rWw
----
Plat/Are
J
PERMIT FEES
540.00
540.00
.00
001-0000-329.22-':1;
)THER FEES:
F O T
co T
Pmrwrty Address
Zoning
e
Revievved by
100.00
1UU. DO
001-0000-329.32-010
BLDG SURCHARGE -DCA
5.10
7-'5c0 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
.00
001-0000-209.05--0�I
UK
8.10
Subdivision Name
.00
Improvements
.-' x...., ..
(3.. . .
Owner's Name/Address/Telephone
Contractor's Name/Address/License/Telephone
... J _
_,
2!,20 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
190 SE 2ND AVE
:'ELRAY BEACH FL 3348361.01'
DELRAY BEACH
FL. 334,,';'
Additional Comments
uonstruCtlon
tPl/EEH
Fl -b:
FLL
occupancy
Sq. Ft.
Valuatbn
-L'
Jf.`rIGaUle of Fees ano A00itional Information
i
J
PERMIT FEES
540.00
540.00
.00
001-0000-329.22-':1;
)THER FEES:
NO FINAL INSPECTION
x00.00
100.00
1UU. DO
001-0000-329.32-010
BLDG SURCHARGE -DCA
5.10
9.10
.00
001-0000-209.05--0�I
BLDG SURCHARGE-DBPR
8.10
8.10
.00
001 -0000 -208.06 --OC,
GRAND TOTAL 756.20
iPECIAL NOTES 3, RESTRICTIONS:
"EROOF SLOPED 5:12 ENTEGR.A 11-0414.09
'LAT TAMKO 09-0920.11
-HE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH ENCOURAGES THE
ISE OF ENERGY STAR PRODUCTS.
656.20 100.00
oAny change in building plans or specificatioro must be recorded with this office. Amy work not covered above, must have a valid permit prior to starting. In consideration
granting of this permfl, the owner and builder agree to erect this structure in lull compliance wah me ucce of Ordinances of the City of Delray Beach,
Florida.
C City of Del�r__aYY Reach Florida
ate CUSTOW RECEIPT aaa
Dper: SALVID Type: DC Drawer: 1
Date: 6/24/13 BI Receipt no: 222631
Year Number Amount
2811 135146
2528 AVENUE AU SDLEIL
DELRAY REACH FL 33483
DP kILDIHR PERMITS
$188.88
Tender detail
CK CHECK 3555 5188.88
Total tendered $188.88
Total payment $188.88
Trans date: 6/21/13 Time: 14:18:42
CHRISTOPHER F. OHARE /SHELLEY CHILDERS OHARE
CHRISTOPHER F. OHARE / SHELLEY CMLOERS OHARE
Mlles (M lw
3555
3555
J
122PM5
PemitVarlBcdon
r�
Building Permits Self Service
,¢ OShould you require assistance, please call 561-243-7700.
When Permit Is Ready, You Will Be Called With Tocol Fee Due. Permits are not ready for pickup until the
Building Dept status is'Approved'.
Permit Verification Info
Permit Address: 2520 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
Permit Description
Permit SbFIMM
Status Data
ALTERATION - INTERIOR & EXTERIOR-RESMENTIAL
CLOSED
8/17/2015
RE -ROOF OF EJOSTM STRUCTURE
APPROVED
612112013
AIR CONDITIONING REPLACEMENT
APPROVED
12/2/2011
DOOR REPLACEMENTIOIANGE OUT
CO. ISSUED
5/17/2011
® Selectron
MPJ/egw.mydelreybm&.mm/wehpwmitsJpermltbngVPermWaificatm. px 1M
Gmaii
ac7u, �;k
Gmdl - Delray Bench pemtH erten maedrrp 1 I-
Delray Beach permit status meaning
Loula Roeder Mou.maderegmail.aom>
a a <pinegdggmaiLcom> VVGC Dec Y. 2015 at 4:46 PIA
To: Louis PAsder<lou.rosd&@gmall.ccm>
Lou,
I Just spoke to Mary (dldnt got her last Warne) at the Dekay Beech Building Departmant She Identfflad wfmt the fdlaMng
words mean that aro posted on the Penult Verification Tom found at:
http:Ilagov_myddrayhmch.cmUwehparmlbdpennitfingf PeunUVerfflcMW.aspx
Here Is a sample. This Happens to Be the oNlne Permit Vedrlcation for Mayor Morgan's home.
=.] Building Permits Self Service
Should you requlfrre asalntance, plesse call 011443-7200.
as
When Permit Is Rady, You Will Be Cased Wkb Total Fee Due. Permits are not rowdy for pldcup until the
nuRdng Dept status In'wpprvved'.
Permit VerlflcaUsn Into
Permit Addrasa: 1140 N OCEAN BLVD
PsmRDescriptlon
PennRStatus
statusoutsr
HiDMS - REPLAOEAfEW
CLO5ED
9/9/2015
GENERATOR - BACKUP
CO. 335UED
9/9/2015
WATER HEATER REPLACEMENT
APPROVED
8/16/2012
POOL OR SPA - RESIDENTIAL
CO. E35UED
3/4/2011
According to Mary,
CLOSED means the permit is expired, abarldorrsd, or the owner changed their mind and didn't do the work
C.O. ISSUED means the work was completed and a Carttflcale ofCompletion was Issued.
APPROVED means the permlt Is mad y for pick up or the work Is actively In progress.
PLAN CHECK meens the application Is still In review.
Why dont you call hertomonow and pat her last name and verify what she told me.
reP.L'mrr.sow.�,t.„+nron��asrk-mmrema�n.w-pracrpr�xwsrrri.��ksop.mnsrrtrr.so.ma*y�rarna�isrs�sl�a.�eserrml.. tM
SCOPE AND ADMINISTRATION
10533 An enforcing authority may not issue a building
permit for any building construction, erection, alteration,
modification, repair or addition unless the permit either
includes on its face or there is attached to the permit the fol-
lowing statement: "NOTICE: In addition to the require-
ments of this permit, there may be additional restrictions
applicable to this property that may be found in the public
records of this county, and there may be additional permits
required from other governmental entities such as water
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.'
1053.4 A building permit for a single-family residential
dwelling must be issued within 30 working days of applica-
tion therefor unless unusual circumstances require a longer
time for processing the application or unless the permit
application fails to satisfy the Florida Building Code or the
enforcing agency's laws or ordinances.
105.3.5 Identification of minimum premium policy.
Except as otherwise provided in Chapter 440, Florida Stat-
utes, Workers' Compensation, every employer shall, as a
condition to receiving a building permit, show proof that it
has secured compensation for its employees as provided in
Section 440.10 and 440.38, Florida Statutes.
1053.6 Asbestos removal. Moving, removal or disposal of
asbestos -containing materials on a residential building
where the owner occupies the building, the building is not
for sale or lease, and the work is performed according to the
owner -builder limitations provided in this paragraph. To
qualify for exemption under this paragraph, an owner must
personally appear and sign the building permit application.
The permitting agency shall provide the person with a dis-
closure statement in substantially the following form:
Disclosure Statement: State law requires asbestos abate-
ment to be done by licensed contractors. You have applied
for a permit under an exemption to that law. The exemption
allows you, as the ownerof your property, to act as your own
asbestos abatement contractor even though you do not have
a license. You must supervise the construction yourself. You
may move, remove or dispose of asbestos -containing mate-
rials on a residential building where you occupy the build-
ing and the building is not for sale or lease, or the building is
a farm outbuilding on your property. If you sell or lease
such building within I year after the asbestos abatement is
complete, the law will presume that you intended to sell or
lease the property at the time the work was done, which is a
violation of this exemption. You may not hire an unlicensed
personas your contractor. Your work must be done accord-
ing to all local, state and federal laws and regulations which
apply to asbestos abatement projects. It is your responsibil-
ity to make sure that people employed by you have licenses
required by state law and by county or municipal licensing
ordinances.
1053.7 Applicable Code for Manufactured Buildings.
Manufacturers should be permitted to complete all build-
ings designed and approved prior to the effective date of a
new code edition, provided a clear signed contract is in
place. The contract shall provide specific data mirroring that
required by an application for permit, specifically, without
limitation, date of execution, building owner or dealer, and
anticipated date of completion. However, the construction
activity must commence within 6 months of the contract's
execution. The contract is subject to verification by the
Department of Community Affairs.
105.4 Conditions of the permit.
105.4.1 Permit intent. A permit issued shall be construed
to be a license to proceed with the work and not as authority
to violate, cancel, alter or set aside any of the provisions of
the technical codes, nor shall issuance of a permit prevent
the building official from thereafterrequiring acorrection of
errors in plans, construction or violations of this code.
Every permit issued shall become invalid unless the work
authorized by such permit is commenced within six months
after its issuance, or if the work authorized by such permit is
suspended or abandoned for a period of six months after the
time the work is commenced.
105.4.1.1 If work has commenced and the permit is
revoked, becomes null and void, or expires because of
lack of progress or abandonment, a new permit covering
the proposed construction shall be obtained before pro-
ceeding with the work.
105.4.1.2 If a new permit is not obtained within 180 days
from the date the initial permit became null and void, the :
building official is authorized to require that any work
which has been commenced or completed be removed
from the building site. Alternately, a new permit may be
issued on application, providing the work in place and :
required to complete the structure meets all applicable E
regulations in effect at the time the initial permit became E
null and void and any regulations which may have
become effective between the date of expiration and the :
date of issuance of the new permit.
105.4.13 Work shall be considered to be in active prog-
ress when the permit has received an approved inspec-
tion within 180 days. This provision shall not be
applicable in case of civil commotion or strike or when
the building work is baited due directly tojudicialinjunc- t
tion, order or similar process.
105.4.1.4 The fee for renewal reissuance and extension
of a permit shall be set forth by the administrative author-
ity.
1055 Expiration. Reserved.
105.6 Suspension or revocation. Reserved.
105.7 Placement of permit. The building permit or copy shall
be kept on the site of the work until the completion of the pro-
ject.
105.8 Notice of commencement. As per Section 713.135,
Florida Statutes, when any person applies for a building per-
mit, the authority issuing such permit shall print on the face of
each permit card in no less than 14 -point, capitalized, bold-
faced type: "WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO
RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY
RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVE-
MENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO
OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER
1.6 2010 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE — BUILDING
COMMISSIONERS
IQAN R. DRTHWEIH. W"I
iHOMASM STANLEY. VR MRTRr
MURIELI ANDERSON
W GARRETT DIKING
ROURT W. GANGER
November 5, 2012
TOWN OF GULF STREAM CR -Z
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLVFiiDA
NOTICE OF VIOLATIONS
T." "r
156112/6-5116
Fax
15611 777-0188
To" Manager
WTLLIANIH THRASHER
7o+ Clert
RITA L TAYLOR
Christopher 5 Shelly O'Hare
2520 and/or 2516 Avenue Au Soleil Hand Deliver Article 11165
Gulf Stream, Florida 33483
Dear Mr. S Mrs. O'Hare:
There are several code violations on the property owned by you
located at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil. These violations are as follows:
1. Expired Re -roofing Permit 511-135146. Section 42-29 of the
Gulf Stream Code of Ordinances states that all authorized
construction shall be completed prior to exoiration of the
permit. Florida Building Code Section 105.4,1.3 states that work
shall be considered to be in active progress when the permit
has received an approved inspection within 180 days. The last
roof inspection was April 26, 2012.
2. No overlay material in place on roof. Section 22-32(5) states
the roof shall be constructed 5 maintained so as not to leak
and they shall be kept clean and painted.
3. Removal of a portion of driveway without obtaining a permit.
This is a violation of Section 58-138(b).
4. Installation of landscape material that does not reinforce the
identy of the applicable zoning district as stated in Section
70-146 and further is in violation of Section 70-32(a)that states
this district is characterized as havinq "oven front lawns'.'.
5. Some of the plants in the landscaping pallet are not listed
within the Code at Section 70-150 ie. the Lady Palms and the
plantings also include species not listed as appropriate or
typical for Gulf Stream or Place Au Soleil
100 SEA ROAD. GUI F STREAM, FLORIDA 33483
November 5, 2012
Page 2
Mr. 6 Mrs. O'Hare
This is to be considered official notice to correct these violations
within 30 days. Failing to comply with this order shall result in
future action as provided in Chapter 2, Article III, Division 2
of the Code of Ordinances, a copy of which is enclosed along with
conies of other sections mentioned herein.
Very truly yours,
;Jilliam H. Thrasher
Town Manager
Encls.
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
December 4, 2015
Chris O'Hare [mail to: chrisoharegulfstream@gmail.com] & Hand delivered 12/4/15
Re: GS #2069 (complaints)
Nat complaints have been received by the Town in regard to the roof currently under
construction at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil? May I have this record to present to the Special
Magistrate at hearing in progress?
Dear Chris O'Hare [mail to: chrisohareeulfstream(a),gmail.coml,
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your a public records request dated December 4, 2015.
Your original public records request can be found at the following link httn://www2.eulf-
stream.ore/weblink/O/doc/73580/Paeel.aspxx. Please refer to the referenced number above with
any future correspondence.
Please be advised that there are no such records. All complaints were verbal.
We consider this matter closed.
Sincerely,
Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records
t DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE 8
3lepbacks, smaller second story, single story garage, and a balcony help to
articulate and give appropriate scale to this house (preferred).
(c) Preferred.
Balconies
Simple rectangular configurations
Single story garages
Smaller second story configurations
Stepbacks to second story
(d) Discouraged.
Angular wells
Complex facade treatment (excessive multi -layer stepbacks)
Sec. 70-238. Roofs.
(a) Required. Flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated the and gray slate file may be permitted on
homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda Influences. Flat, gray thru
and thru, un -coated file or slaW41ke the may be permitted at the discretion of architectural review and
planning board and town commission through the Level III review process, subject to the
architectural review and planning board and the town commission making a determination that such
alternatives are appropriate for the neighborhood.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 433
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Gulf Stream- Bermuda style while file roof (required)
(b) Proferred.
Combination hip/gable roofs
Decorative capped chimney
Exposed rafter tails
Flashing, vent stacks, and pipes painted to match adjacent building surface
Hip roof
Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes)
Roof overhang (2-21h feet)
Simple roof geometry emphasizing long horizontal fines
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 434
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
White flat untextured the
Roof delail showing exposed rafter lails and decorative capped chimney
(preferred)
(c) Discouraged.
Dormers on single story houses
Gable
Pyramidal hip (often has too steep of slope)
Very low pitched roofs (slope less than 5:12)
(d) Prohibited.
Banal tiles
Front gable except for entry features
Gambrel
Mansard
Monolithic roof design where Inadequate measures were taken to reduce massing and height of
roof design
Pan tiles
Shed
Shingles
Tiles other than white flat untextured tiles or gray slate tiles
Unnecessarily complex roof geometry
(Ord. No. 00.1, §§ 56, 57, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 12-4, § 6, 7-13-12)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 435
ARTICLE VI I. PRE DOM INA NT ARCH ITECTURALSTYLES /
ARTICLE VII. PREDOMINANT ARCHITECTURAL STYLES
DIVISION 1. - GENERALLY
DIVISION 2. - SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLEARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
DIVISION 3. - GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 418
DIVISION 1. GENERALLY
DIVISION 1. GENERALLY
Sec. 70-206. Purpose.
Sec. 70-207. Styles unioue to the town.
Sec. 70-208. Prooertv survey.
Secs. 70-209-70-215. Reserved.
Sec. 70-206. Purpose.
Two styles of architecture have historically dominated the character of Gulf Stream homes: Spanish
Mediterranean Revival style and Gulf Stream -Bermuda style. While the use of these two styles is
therefore encouraged, it is not required. The provisions of this article are Intended for those choosing one
of these styles and are intended to guide the process of design for new construction as well as
remodeling and renovation.
Sec. 70-207. Styles unique to the town.
The style definitions contained in this article are unique to the town. Although these architectural
styles are used throughout South Florida and in other parts of the country, there are certain adaptations
of them that are unique to the town. Chief among these adaptations is a more formal and uncomplicated
use of form and materials than is typically associated with these styles, particularly Spanish
Mediterranean Revival. Users of this chapter are therefore advised to closely study the standards
provided in this article and not rely solely on outside reference books or existing structures in other
communities for guidance on how to use these styles.
Sec. 70-208. Property survey.
A property by property survey was conducted in March of 1997 to identify existing homes designed
In the Spanish Mediterranean or Gulf Stream -Bermuda styles as defined in this article. This survey was
updated in October of 1999 to reflect architectural approvals granted in the proceeding 2'% years. The
locations of these homes are shown on the map on the following page. These homes, as well as those
constructed after the date of the survey and classified as having one of these styles, will be subject to the
standards contained in this article when additions or rehabilitations are proposed.
(Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 52, 53, 3-10-00)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 419
Secs. 70-209-70-215. Reserved.
ARCffiTEC
STYLE AN
DIVISION 1. GENERALLY
1MMM
4 N RMI STYLE
E6
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 420
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE
ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Sec. 70-216. Generally.
Sec. 70-217. Building form.
Sec. 70-218. Roofs.
Sec. 70-219. Windows.
Sec. 70-220. Entrances.
Sec. 70-221. Exterior materials: colors.
Sec. 70-222. Garages: accessory buildings.
Secs. 70-223-70-235. Reserved.
Sec. 70-216. Generally.
Many beachfront houses exhibit Spanish Mediterranean Revival style architecture. Strong unifying
characteristics include barrel tile roofs, pale washed walls, simple uncluttered detailing, and the
appearance of thick walls. The emphasis on open architecture such as balconies, courtyards, and
verandas, is suited for the town's subtropical climate. The selected architectural styles, Spanish and
Mediterranean Revival, will be described through a series of graphics and the use of explicit architectural
vocabulary. Appropriate variations or interpretations of this style are permitted.
Mediterranean Revival Style
Sec. 70-217. Building form.
(a) Characteristics. Distinguished by simple and strong configurations, Spanish and Mediterranean style
homes are typically either one or two stories. These structures often exhibit an asymmetrical facade
with varying roofs. Wall planes predominate over openings on primary surfaces (windows, doors,
etc.). Usually one or more predominant arches are incorporated above the main entrance or principal
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 421
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
window. Arches are also used below porches and verandas. They are typically semicircular and in
regular series with columns as supports or walls. Stucco columns should be square, rectangular, or
round and appear massive in thickness. The column height should be four to five times the width of
the column. Balconies or porches should be Integrated Into the building form to add articulation.
(b) Preferred.
Appearance of "thick walls"
Asymmetrical facade
Balconies, porches, verandas, courtyards
Capitals and column bands
Column height four to five times column width
Limited use of decorative elements such as wall tile, wall fountains, non-standard windows,
varied eave finishes, etc.
Semicircular arches
Simple, strong rectilinear forms
Wall planes predominate over openings
Wrought iron or wood railings
(c) Discouraged.
Complex or angular building forms
Excessive large windows
Excessive ornamentation or use of decorative elements
Flat or parabolic arches
Sec. 70-218. Roofs.
(a) Characteristics. Spanish and Mediterranean Revival roofs often exhibit a combination of gable and
hip roofs.
(b) Preferred.
Decorative chimney or bell tower
Exposed gutters and downspouts painted to match adjacent roof or wall material
Exposed rafter tails
Flashing, vent stacks, and pipes painted to match adjacent building surface
Gutters and downspouts designed as a continuous architectural feature
Hip or gable roofs
Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes or less)
Simple short overhangs
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 422
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Traditional red barrel tiles
(c) Discouraged.
"S" -shaped tile
Skylights
Very low pitched roofs (slopes less than 4:12)
t
:, t
Gable Roof !r.
6:12 Slopes or less preferred
•�` �:� FF:_`
Hip Roof
12
Slopes less than 4:12 is discouraged
(d) Prohibited.
Flat roofs visible over ten percent of total roof
Gambrel roofs
Glazed skylights on the streetside
Mansard roofs
Non-earthtone colored tile
Shingles
Solar panels on the streetside
Traditional red barrel tile roof with simple, short
overhangs and exposed rafter tails (preferred)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 423
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
j
G0�
American -Spanish Tile
Spanish Tile
"Pan Tile"
"S -Tile"
Straight Darrel Tile
(Preferred)
Tapered
(Preferred)
(Neither Preferred nor
Discouraged)
(Discouraged)
Toever element (optional)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 424
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Chimneys are a decorative, Integral part of Mediterranean Revival roofs.
Roof and column detail
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 425
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Ilk-
` .`.�..
ri
i
now
Roof and entry detail
Sec. 70-219. Windows.
(a) Characteristics. Windows typically exhibit rectangular or round -headed openings. They have several
small panes in each window rather than one large pane of glass.
Smart, multi -paned
reroared Ca=nent
windo%Y (preferred)
(b) Preferred.
Casement windows
Recessed openings
Round -headed
Small multi -paned
[found -headed windows
(preferred)
(c) Discouraged.
Metal or aluminum awnings
Shutters on more than half of the windows
Windows as a dominant element
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 426
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
(d) Prohibited.
Floor to ceiling windows greater than one story
Glass block visible from street
Jalousie windows visible from street
More than 50 percent window openings on an elevation (there must be a higher percentage of
wall area than window area)
Picture windows over three feet in length visible from street
Reflective glass visible from
Sec. 70-220. Entrances.
street
(a) Characteristics. Like windows, doors in Spanish and Mediterranean Revival architecture are typically
rectangular or round -headed. The doorway should be fully recessed in order to convey the
appearance of thick, protective exterior walls. Doors are traditionally made of wood with a heavy
look, as well as being highly detailed.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 427
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Recessed French door with fan light preferred
(b) Preferred.
Appropriate scale and proportion
Fan light
Recessed
Wood
Wood/glass combination
(c) Discouraged.
Solid, unarticulated doors
Stained glass sidelights
(d) Prohibited.
Two-story porte-cochere
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 428
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Sec. 70.221. Exterior materials; colors.
(a) Characteristics.
(1) Stucco is the primary Spanish and Mediterranean type wall surface material utilized throughout
the town. A smooth stucco finish with a hand -troweled, modeled look is typical. Accent materials
and colors used to complement the stucco are encouraged in moderation. The use of tile, wood,
brick, and finished concrete should be used as design accents only. Buildings are encouraged
to have up to three colors, one base color and two trim colors. The trim colors would typically be
used on the cornice bands and window articulation.
(2) Unlike some Spanish and Mediterranean homes found elsewhere, the Spanish and
Mediterranean homes in the town have a relatively simple and unadorned design with a limited
use of decorative elements such as wall tile, wall fountains, non-standard windows (e.g.
hydrafoils) and varied eave finishes.
(b) Required.
Principal building color selected from the approved color list (with the exception of blues and
greens #365 through 840)
(c) Preferred.
Hand -troweled stucco finish (smooth surface rather than rough finish preferred)
Light pastel window trim to be compatible with principal building color
Limited use of decorative elements
Tile, wood, brick, or finished concrete as accent material
Warm, light pastel or off-white principal color
(d) Discouraged.
More than three colors (principal building and trim)
Over -use of decorative elements
Principal building color not representative of architectural style
Trim colon(s) not compatible with principal building color
Trim color(s) not compatible with architectural style
(e) Prohibited.
Any material other than stucco as primary building material
Blues, greens, as principal building color (#365 through 840)
Non -approved colors for principal building and trim
Shades of purples, red (excluding doors), bright yellow, bright pink and fluorescent or other
extremely bright colors as trim or accent
Stain as principal building color
(Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 54, 55, 3-10-00)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 429
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
Sec. 70-222. Garages; accessory buildings.
(a) Generally. Garages, storage sheds, decks, and other ancillary structures are elements which should
be integrated with the principal building in color and architectural style.
(b) Preferred.
Same color and materials as principal building
Spanish Mediterranean Revival style architecture
(c) Discouraged.
Different color or material than principal building
(d) Prohibited.
All garages facing street on lots over 20,000 square feet not adequately screened or buffered from
roadways
Carports
Metal storage sheds
Three -stall or larger garages on any lot not adequately screened or buffered from roadways
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 430
DIVISION 2. SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS
r
M
1
�rC}
, r
C
Typical Spanish -Mediterranean Revival style garage exemplifying matching
colors and materials as principal building (preferred).
Secs. 70-223-70-235. Reserved.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 431
Irl]ckulllm,REM
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Sec. 70-236. Generally.
Sec. 70-237. Building form.
Sec. 70-238. Roofs.
Sec. 70-239. Windows.
Sec. 70-240. Shutters.
Sec. 70-241. Entrances.
Sec. 70-242. Exterior materials: colors.
Sec. 70-243. Other features.
Sec. 70-244. Garages: accessory buildings.
Secs. 70-245-20-265. Reserved.
Sec. 70-236. Generally.
Gulf Stream -Bermuda style architecture refers to the majority of houses in the town that exhibit a
combination of Bermuda, British Colonial, or Georgian characteristics. Gulf Stream -Bermuda style
architecture places emphasis on simple, straightforward design. Roofs are a predominant and Identifiable
feature. Gulf Stream -Bermuda style roofs do not recycle rain water as Bermuda roofs do, but the white
tiles do reflect the heat of the sun and the extended overhangs provide shade and shelter from our rainy
climate. Decorative chimneys adorn most roofs, while contrasting details such as shutters and doors add
interest and charm to this style.
Sec. 70-237. Building form.
(a) Characteristics. Most Gulf Stream -Bermuda style houses are patterned after simple rectilinear forms.
Although the majority are rectangles, many houses have L- and U-shaped layouts. Most Gulf
Stream -Bermuda style houses are one story and often exhibit a central peak flanked by peaks over
projecting wings. Two-story houses should pay particular attention to reducing the size of the second
floor and applying articulation such as balconies, setbacks, and other design techniques to avoid
box -like massive buildings.
(b) Stepbacks. The use of stepbacks is appropriate to reduce excessive bulkiness and provide a
transition between first and second stories. A few critical stepbacks on a building are better than
several minor stepbacks that only complicate the facade and create busy architecture.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 432
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
, ;Ile
.� .•,, �`' a; , .�. � � if °' � III ,
�JLA. `J
Stepbacks, smaller second story, single story garage, and a balcony help to
articulate and give appropriate scale to this house (preferred).
(c) Preferred.
Balconies
Simple rectangular configurations
Single story garages
Smaller second story configurations
Stepbacks to second story
(d) Discouraged.
Angular walls
Complex facade treatment (excessive multi -layer Stepbacks)
Sec. 70-238. Roofs.
(a) Required. Flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated tile and gray slate tile may be permitted on
homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda influences. Flat, gray thru
and thru, un -coated tile or slate -like tile may be permitted at the discretion of architectural review and
planning board and town commission through the Level III review process, subject to the
architectural review and planning board and the town commission making a determination that such
alternatives are appropriate for the neighborhood.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 433
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Gulf Stream- Bermuda style white Tile roof (required)
(b) Preferred.
Combination hip/gable roofs
Decorative capped chimney
Exposed rafter tails
Flashing, vent stacks, and pipes painted to match adjacent building surface
Hip roof
Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes)
Roof overhang (2-21/2feet)
Simple roof geometry emphasizing long horizontal lines
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 434
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
White Flat untextured tile
Roof detail showing exposed rafter faits and decorative capped chimney
(preferred)
(c) Discouraged.
Dormers on single story houses
Gable
Pyramidal hip (often has too steep of slope)
Very low pitched roofs (slope less than 5:12)
(d) Prohibited.
Barrel tiles
Front gable except for entry features
Gambrel
Mansard
Monolithic roof design where inadequate measures were taken to reduce massing and height of
roof design
Pan tiles
Shed
Shingles
Tiles other than white flat untextured tiles or gray slate tiles
Unnecessarily complex roof geometry
(Ord. No. 00-1, §§ 56, 57, 3-10-00; Ord. No. 124, § 6, 7-13-12)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 435
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Sec. 70-239. Windows.
(a) Characteristics. Gulf Stream -Bermuda windows are typically small in scale and proportioned to wall
coverage. Rectilinear in form, these windows have several small panes in each window rather than
one large pane of glass.
Mulli-panel window, contrasting shutters
Palladian windows wiscollrazedl
(b) Preferred.
Casement to reflect color of building
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 436
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Keystone over lintel
Pronounced sill and/or lintel
Rectilinear form
Small multi -paned
(c) Discouraged.
Bay and bow windows as prominent feature
Paired and triple windows
Palladian window
Sliding window
Windows as dominant element
(d) Prohibited.
Floor to ceiling windows greater than one story
Glass block visible from street
Jalousie windows visible from street or waterway
More than 50 percent window openings on an elevation (there must be a higher percentage of
wall area than window area)
Picture windows over three feet in width visible from street
Reflective glass
Bronze colored window frames
(Ord. No. 00-1, § 58, 3-10-00)
Sec. 70-240. Shutters.
(a) Characteristics. Shutters are important elements of Gulf Stream -Bermuda style houses. They should
contrast with the primary building color and be proportioned to the window.
(b) Preferred.
Contrasting color
Functional
Shutters should measure the full height and half the width of the window
Traditional horizontal slat or panel type
Traditional shutter color (for example: white, black, dark green, dark slate blue, dark taupe,
stained mahogany, dark or slate gray)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 437
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Contrasting, well proportioned shutters (preferred)
Preferred shutters for Gulf Stream -Bermuda style
architecture
(c) Discouraged.
Board and batten
Commercial type
Metal or aluminum awnings
No shutters
Non-traditional colors for Bermuda style architecture, (for example: painted chocolate brown)
Shutters painted in same color as principal building
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 438
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Metal or aluminum awnings discouraged
(d) Prohibited.
Colors inappropriate to the architectural style (for example: reds, purples)
Fluorescent colors and extremely bright colors (for example: magenta, lime green, traffic -sign
orange, chartreuse, fuchsia, bright aqua blue)
(Ord. No. 00-1, § 59, 3-10-00)
Sec. 70-241. Entrances.
(a) Characteristics. Gulf Stream -Bermuda houses offer a variety of entry features. Doors are often
detailed with a combination of glazing and panels. Transom lights are a character borrowed from
Georgian styles. Although not typical, porte-cocheres and columns are sometimes evident.
(b) Preferred.
Contrasting shutters or side lights
Multi -paneled doors (six to eight)
Simple pediment
Transom lights
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 439
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Panel door with built-in fan light, pilasters, and
enlablilure (preferred)
Wood panel door with contrasting shutters
(preferred)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 440
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Wood panel door with overhead light and keystone
detailing (preferred)
(c) Discouraged
Aluminum/metal doors, unpainted
Board and batten door
Over -bearing entablature or pediment
Solid, flush door
(d) Prohibited.
Etched glass design in door
Leaded glass panels in door
Two-story columns
Two-story porte-cochere
(Ord. No. 00-1, § 60, 3-10-00)
Sec. 70-242. Exterior materials; colors.
(a) Generally. Traditional Gulf Stream -Bermuda building materials consist of concrete block construction
with smooth stucco finishes. Colors are typically exemplified by various soft pastel colors and off-
whites.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 441
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Typical Gulf Stream -Bermuda house
Ty
pical Gulf Stream Bermuda House
(b) Required.
Principal building color from approved color list
(c) Preferred.
Contrasting trim
Smooth stucco finish
White and soft pastel colors
White or neutral color quoins and keystones
Wood trim
(d) Discouraged.
Brick (other than white)
More than three colors (principal building and trim)
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 442
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Principal building color not representative of architectural style
Trim color(s) not compatible with architectural style
Trim color(s) not compatible with principal building color
(e) Prohibited.
Faux stone siding
Metal and aluminum siding
Mid -elevation stucco banding, except foundation banding at or below finished floor elevation
Non -approved colors for principal building and trim colors
Shades of purples, red (excluding doors), and fluorescent or extremely bright colors as trim or
accent
Stain as principal building color
Unfinished, exposed concrete block
Veneer applications
Vinyl
Wood as primary material
(Ord. No. 00-1, § 61, 3-10-00)
Sec. 70-243. Other features.
(a) Generally. Other important elements contribute to the character of Gulf Stream -Bermuda style.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 443
Deenrxlive capped chimney
(preferred)
(b) Preferred.
Decorative capped chimneys
Keystone detailing
Quoins
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 444
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Corner quoins, contrasting shutters, pastel calor (preferred)
Single story garage with double bays, keystone detailing (preferred)
(c) Prohibited.
Exposed metal spark arrestors
Exposed metal capped chimneys
(Ord. No. 00-1, § 62, 3-10-00)
Sec. 70-244. Garages; accessory buildings.
(a) Generally. Garages, storage sheds, decks, and other ancillary structures are elements which should
be integrated with the principal building in color and architectural style.
(b) Preferred.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 445
DIVISION 3. GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Reflective of Gulf Stream -Bermuda architecture
Same color and materials as principal building
(c) Discouraged.
Different color or material than principal building
(d) Prohibited.
All garages facing street on lots over 20,000 square feet not adequately screened or buffered
from roadways
Carports
Metal storage sheds
Three -stall or larger garages not adequately screened or buffered from roadways
Offsels in the building articulate the facade and add interst (preferred)
Gul[Strenm-Bermuda style garage with double bay doors and detailing
Secs. 70-245-20-265. Reserved.
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances Page 446
Secs. 70-209-70-215. Reserved.
ARCHITECTURAL
STYLE ANALYSIS
DIVISION 1. GENERALLY
� GNF $iflENA8FJUIWA$ME
lS SW1N1$f4LEOREANIIXFAN PEVNNI$IYIE
� OfXEM91ROlA $TYLE$
Gulf Stream, Florida, Code of Ordinances
Page 420
X61
GULF, STREAM ARCHIT;�CTURAL STYLE ANALYSIS
Address:
Districe.
Comments:
2520 Ave Au Soleil 11/22/95
Building Form:
❑
❑
❑
❑
1 (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 (0 pts.)
Roofs:
❑
❑
❑
❑
1 (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 (0 pts.)
Windows:
❑
❑
❑
❑
I (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 ( 0 pts.)
Shutters:
❑
❑
❑
❑
1 (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 (0 pts.)
Entrances:
❑
❑
❑
❑
1 (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 (0 pts.)
Exterior Materials(Colors:
'
❑ 1❑
❑
❑
t (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 (0 pts.)
Other Features:
❑
❑
❑
❑
1 (20 pts.)
2 (15 pts.)
3 (10 pts.)
4 (0 pts.)
1 = Most Major end Minor Characteristics 3 = Only Minor Characteristics
2 = Some Major and Minor Characteristics 4 = None or Trace Only
0
5.
tJ
sr�
CJI
��Z
0
-❑O
-❑x
-0 I
-0 c
-❑�
-❑a
-❑m
O
n
Off.
O
a
ro
ro o
ro
Li
a
ro
a
a
g.
3
m
A
v
(D
N
v
a. a
N ❑
y
N ❑ �'
N ❑
N ❑
N �
N ❑
^ ❑
�.
—
�'o
ro
b o
ro
b
ro
ro
ro
S S
d m
fA
Cl �
N
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
!A
II If
v
N
fA
4!
v
ILIN
0 3
rt `�
o �
A.❑
A❑
A❑
A❑
A ❑
t' ❑
A❑
p
�
O
O
O
O
p
O
'fl
O
A S
ro
ro
Li
ro
ro
ro
H
ro
V
ILI
L
V
v
"9 6
� n
n
n
N
7.3
I!4twt
.-t,.
,w
4�R
... �1Z� ��.'aa•_. aim
A ;
Q f it
6'
FAX Cot er Sheet
TO:
Louis Roeder
Phone:
Fax Phone: 866-610-6090
Date: 10-23-12
Number of pages including cover sheet
Wm. Thrasher
(FROM: Town of Gulf Stream
100 Sea Road
Gulf Stream, FL 33483
Phone: 561-276-5116
Fax Phone: 561-737-0188
REMARKS: o As Requested o Urgent o FYI o For Your Review n Reply ASAP
I'm sorry, I thought I had sent this information to you.
In response to your email, please be advised as follows: The
name of our consultant is Marty Minor of Urban Design Kilday
Studios. There was no formal report requested or provided.
ML-. Minur simply curifirmed L1tnL Llre aLc1iiLeclurct1 sLyle of Lhe home
at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil is Gulf Stream -Bermuda.
Aly decision to decline was accompanied by an example from the code
of a raised panel garage door. I thought it would be helpful to
illustrate what your client could do under the design guidelines.
As you know, your client has available the option to challenge my
decision to the full Commission or take his request to the ARPB
for their review. The Commission meets November 9, 2012 and the
wPg*Ndvmo)UX34k=dxycivlasp[xitmxxxxxxxxxxxxxNaxxxxxx ARPB on November 15, 2012.
CC:
Fax Phone:
Bill Thrasher
From: Marty F.1 nor <MMinorgudkstudics com>
Sent: Wednesday. Septemhor 14, 9017 915 NO
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: RE. 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
reef tt;at c: ,i her! of a different color. Yes, I did unfortunately rely on Google for this. Here is my description for your use
Z'S?fi 4,1 nue Au solof mcerporates various architectural styles, but the predominant style is Gulf Stream r+u,l Cenststent taxth the description found in Sections 70-236 thrcugh 70-244, the heme's simple: �ectaneuiar layc.t.t.
mcot � %tat cc e,taner and rectilinear windows help identify its style. Although the existing barrel Cie •onf uses nor. -
ow pitch, comhinaticn h,p and gable style roof is a strong characteristic of the Gulf Stream
Marty RA Minor, AICP
Uraan Dcsign Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place No; th
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Pa m Beach. Florida 33401-5758
551-366-1100
From: Will Thrasher fmailto:bthrashert@qulf-stream.orgl
Sent Wednesday, September 19, 2012 1:08 PM
To: Marty Minor
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Perhaps you used Google as I did. The house that had the identifier on it is not the house in question. It is the inside comer
o,:e with red terra cotta roof.
am atiaLlrng a sheet for your review that will indicate which is 2520. Also, if you have to ride by, please do.
$ah `9 rriii5 'diiiidiN's'F%5:`
From: Marty Minor fmailto:MMinoraudkstudios.coml
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 11:58 AM
1"0: Bill Thrasher
Subject: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Importance: High
Bill.
This email is to confirm the findings of the Single Family Home architectural survey for the home at 2520 Avenue Au
Soleil. The architectural style for the home is Gulf Stream Bermuda.
As described in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the predominant and most identifiable feature of Gulf Stream -Bermuda
homes is the `last, white tile hip roof. In addition, a simple building configuration and consistent cave lines are also features
Of the Gulf Stream -Bermuda style. The home at 2520 Avenue Au 5olell share all of these characteristics. As such, the
architectural style for 2520 Avenue Au Soleil is Gulf Streartl-Bemtuda.
Should you have any questions regarding this confirmation, please let me know.
Thank you,
rnartY
Marty R.A. Minor. AICP
Urban Design Kdday Studios
Thp Offires nt ('itv Plare North
COMPARISON OF CRITERIA
AS STATED IN MINOR'S E-MAIL OF 9/291Xvs THE TOWN CODE:
Dec 4, 2015 `l
* USING PGS 418.446 OF THE GULF STREAM TOWN CODE -ARCHITECTURAL STYLES
PLUS:
shutters no no ✓
doors (pediment) no no
exposed rafter tails no yes ✓
multi -paned windows no yes ✓
TOTALS 5 9
CONCLUSION:
So, according to this chart, 2520 AAS has how many more "Spanish"
characteristics than "Bermuda?"
Bermuda
Spanish
"simple, rectangular layout"
yes ✓
yes ✓
"smooth stucco exterior"
yes ✓
yes ✓
"rectilinear windows"
yes ✓
yes ✓
"existing" barrel tile roof
no
yes ✓
"low pitch" roof
6:12 ✓
6:12 ✓
"hip & gable style roof'
yes ✓
yes ✓ _
SUB -TOTAL
5
6
PLUS:
shutters no no ✓
doors (pediment) no no
exposed rafter tails no yes ✓
multi -paned windows no yes ✓
TOTALS 5 9
CONCLUSION:
So, according to this chart, 2520 AAS has how many more "Spanish"
characteristics than "Bermuda?"
COMM1551e11ERS
leM1LORTHWFRt.Meyor
TMURIZU HOMAS M. fTAN HVw MaYat
W.OAAAFROERRIR
P116ERFW OaHOER
December 27, 2012
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH Comm FLORIDA
p 1 Telephone
_
(Sal;276-5116
F"
,. (561)777-01g6
e Town Manger
YALLIAM H Tra1A5HER
T."Cluk
RRA L TAYLOR
Mr. Louis L. Roeder, Esquire
7414 Sparkling Lake Road Via Fax 866-610-6090
Orlando, Florida 32819
Re: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil, Gulf Sueam, FL 33483
Subject: Code Violation Letter, dated November 5, 2012
Dear Mr. Roeder,
I am receipt of your email dated December 10, 2012 concerning the above referenced
property address and subject. The following is the Town's response.
I. "Expired re -roofing permlt Rl1-135146. On November 5, 2012 a "Notice of
Violations" was prepared for delivery to Mr. O'Hare. On November 10, 2012
that "Notice of Violations" was hand delivered and received by Mr. O'Hare.
According to a written document received by the Town on December 11, 2012,
from the Delray Beach Pcrt it Department the subject expired permit was
renewed an November 14, 2012 which is shortly after Mr. O'Hare was in receipt
of the Town's "Notice of Violations". Therefore, the violation of an expired re-
roofing permit no longer exists.
2. This item, as directly related to item 1, is therefore no longer in violation of the
Town's Code.
All other items listed on the November 5, 2012 "Notice of Violations" remain
outstanding. The remaining outstanding violations am requested to be corrected by
January 17, 2013.
Sine rely,
William H. Thrasher
Town Manager
100 SEA ROAD, GULF STREAM, FLORIDA 33483
COMMISSIONERS
SLOTT IV ArORGAN, Mayor
ROBERT W GANGER, Vice Mayor
JOAN ORTHWEIN
THOMAS M. STANLEV
DONNA S. WHITE
September 18, 2015
Christopher F. O'Hare
2520 Avenue Au Soled
Gulf Stream, Florida 33481
Re Roofing Permit No 11 135146
Dear Mr. O'Hare
TOWN OF GULF STREAM J ��
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Telephon.•
' IS6p270-61 I6
Fay
- 1661 p7T-0188
Tnwn Manager
WILLIAM THRASHER
Town Clerk
RITA L rA TLOH
I am responding to your hand delivered letter to me by one of your attorneys, Mr Lou Raider, esquire. With the letter
was a request for a permit revision, also dated September 16, 2016 and a sample of a roof the "Ludo Slate Ceramic
Roof Tile" that you would like approved.
The original permit 11135146 Is Inactive and may not be renewed or revised. The last inspection on this permit was
4/26/12 A new permit application for a re -roof on your structure Is required.
In your letter you have made several claims and statements In an attempt for you to better understand the Town's
position on this matter and also expedite the permit application process, the following information Is provided
As previously explained to you and also answered by me in my deposition held by another one of your
attorneys, Mr. Mark Hanna, esquire, the predominant architectural style of your horne Is, by code
definition, Gulf Stream Bermuda Although your letter states that you disagree, the Town's consultant
and the Town stand by this determination and c-oncluslon.
The Town agrees that the map you refer to does indicate the style of your home is"Other various
Although that designation is Inaccurate the map is not the determining factor of the architectural style
of a home, but rather and more importantly, the architectural style is determined by the architectural
elements that exist on the structure.
The sample of the the you have provided Is a flat red clay lite with a "fired" top finish applikd. This
type of roof tele Is prohibited for the architectural style of your home. Approval of this roof tile
exceeds my level of authority Your options are to apply for a variance and/or challenge my decision
on this matter The forms necessary for these options are available at Town Hall,
To assist you further, I refer you to the Town's Code, Division 3 "Gulf Stream Bermuda Style", Section 70-238 "Roofs"
which is on the Town's website at www.gull_stream ore.
William H. Thrasher, Town Manager
100 SEA ROAD GULF .STREAM, FLORIDA 33483
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Delivered via e-mail
November 30, 2015
Chris O'Hare [mail to: chrisoharegulfstream@gmail.com]
Re: GS #2056 (violations of 42-29)
The most recent record of any Notice of Violation or Notice of Hearing sent to a property owner
which cited any alleged violation of Town Code Section 42-29, Construction Abandonment ,
(formerly codified as Section 42-30) other than sent to the property located at 2520 Avenue Au
Soleil. (amended 11/25/15 - The most recent record o/' anv Notice of Violation or Notice of
Hearing sent to a resident of an occupied property which cited any alleged violation of Town
Code Section 42-29, Construction Abandonment , (formerly codified as Section 42-30) other
than sent to the property located at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil)
Dear Chris O'Hare [mail to: chrisoharegulfstreamCgmail.coml,
The Town of Gulf Stream has received your amended public records request dated November
25, 2015. Your original public records request and the amended request can be found at the
following link htty://www2.gulf-stream.org/weblink/O/doc/70392/Page Lasox. Please refer to the
referenced number above with any future correspondence.
Please be advised that no such records exist.
We consider this matter closed.
Sincerely,
Town Clerk, Custodian of the Records
C
r
0
J
}
j
��
liil ii G! ii lit II III II ill IE III b ill li III illi 1. iii I Iii.
INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN
THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH AND
THE TOWN OF GULF STREAM
THIS AGREEMENT entered into on this �)e day of bLY
2009 by and between the CITY OF DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA, A Florida municipal
corporation, hereinafter referred to as "the CITY" and the TOWN OF GULF STREAM,
FLORIDA, a Florida municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as "the TOWN".
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the health, safety and welfare of the residents of both TOWN and
CITY will best be served by the CITY inspecting certain structures lying within the
TOWN'S limits; and,
WHEREAS, this Agreement evidences the intentions of the respective parties to
cooperate with each other in the furtherance of the public's interest.
NOW THEREFORE, it is hereby agreed by and between the parties hereto as
follows:
Section 1. Definitions:
Code: When used herein, the term "Code" shall mean the Florida Building Code
as amended.
Department When used herein, the term "Department" shall mean the City of
Delray Beach Community Improvement Department.
Building Official: Where used hereln, the term "Building Official" shall mean the
Chief Building Official for the City of Delray Beach.
Feels): When used herein, the term "fee" or "fees" shall mean the fee(s) charged
as a condition for plan review, building, electrical, or plumbing permit and/or the
inspection fee charged for inspection of work; both made a part hereof.
Inspector. When used herein, the term "inspector" shall mean any Building
Inspector in the employ of the CI'T'Y.
Permit: When used herein, the term "permit" shall mean permit issued by the
CITY for any construction work.
Permittee: When used herein, the term "permittee" shall mean any Individual,
corporation or other business entity applying for and/or holding a valid permit.
01 0
S r=
� m
r.s
ry W
C,
c; a
rrr; `XT-'
� n
m
G
hi
iF
P4 9a
Structures: When used herein, the term "structures' shall mean any and all
above -ground, in -ground, and/or underground structures, and any and all construction,
mechanical, electrical and/or plumbing work for which a permit must be obtained.
Section 2. The CITY and TOWN, in consideration of the mutual promises and
benefits hereinafter set forth, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, do hereby agree
as follows:
A. The purpose of this Agreement is to provide the TOWN with the expertise
and assistance of the CITY'S Department for the inspection and permitting of certain
construction projects within the TOWN'S limits for compliance with the Florida Building
Code.
B. The method by which this purpose will be accomplished is as follows:
The TOWN shall adopt an ordinance which:
a. incorporates by reference the provisions of the Code as
presently in force and effect in the CITY;
b. vests the responsibility for reviewing plans for compliance
With the Code, issuing permits, and inspecting structures
with the TOWN In the CITY S Department; and
C. upon adoption by the CITY of any amendments to said
Code, the TOWN shall immediately, upon notice by the CITY
amend its ordinance to accurately reflect such changes.
2. a. Plans for construction shall be submitted to the TOWN in
triplicate by the applicant and shall be reviewed by TOWN
for compliance with TOWN'S Zoning Code and other non -
construction compliance. The three (3) plans shall be
stamped and submitted to CITY by contractor or owner with
the attendant permit applicant and fees.
b. The Department shall review and process all plans,
submitted in triplicate, checking the same for compliance
with the Code; and determine the subsidiary permits
necessary and the amount of fees. For processing and the
inspection service, CITY shall receive one hundred percent
(100%) of the permit fee. Said fees shall be collected by
CITY. After reviewing and processing said construction
plans, CITY shall forward one set of said plans to the
contractor/owner with the permit and another set to the
TOWN with a copy of the permit. CITY shall not forward any
plans to TOWN without the attendant permit.
3. Applications for all permits shall be submitted to CITY on CITY
approved forms. The CITY shall process and prepare all permits for construction within
the TOWN. Any authorized individual may request the Department to inspect a project
on a given time and date. The permit inspection card and plans shall be on the
construction site at all times and the inspector, upon the completion of his inspection,
will mark the card either as to acceptance and the date thereof, or will note reason for
rejection and the date thereof. Upon satisfactory completion of the project and final
inspection, the Building Official will prepare the Certificate of Occupancy and will
forward said Certificate of Occupancy to TOWN which will issue the Certificate of
Occupancy to the permitee, or authorized agent thereof, with a copy to the CITY.
4. The TOWN shall be solely responsible for the enforcement of
violations of the provisions of said Code by persons, firms or corporations engaged in
construction within the TOWN.
5. The TOWN shall assume responsibility for the administration of all
consumer inquires. The TOWN shall forward to the Building Official only those inquires
concerning the plan review and inspection process, set forth above, and all others shall
be the responsibility of the TOWN_
6. The Building Official shall have the right to refuse to Inspect any
structure within TOWN should he/she deem It in the best interest of CITY. All such
determinations not to Inspect a structure shall be made in writing to TOWN.
7. Subject to the limitations of Florida Statute 768.28, the TOWN shall
hold harmless and indemnify CITY against any and all claims for damages of every kind
and nature including, but not limited to claims for property damage, personal injury or
death, arising out of the plan review and inspection process.
8. The TOWN shall annually supply CITY with a Certificate of
Insurance from the TOWN'S insurance carrier evidencing all the necessary insurance
coverage for CITY and the Bullding Official or any authorized agent of the Department
reviewing plans for construction within the Town and/or making inspections within the
TOWN. Said insurance certificates and coverage shall be satisfactory to the CITY'S
Risk Manager. The CITY is not obligated to undertake any action under this Agreement
until the CITY'S Risk Manager has approved said insurance certificate and coverage.
The approval by the CITY'S Risk Manager shall not be unreasonable withheld.
Section 3. Duration.
This Agreement shall be a continuing nature unless cancelled by either party for
any reason and without penalty, on not less than sixty (60) days written notice. Any
fees paid to CITY where inspection services are not completed shall be prorated in
accordance with the percentage of inspection completed and any excess shall be
refunded to TOWN.
Section 4. Miscellaneous
A. This Interiocal Agreement shall be filed pursuant to the requirements of
Section 163.01(11) of the Florida Statutes.
B. This Agreement shall be governed by and in accordance with the Laws of
Florida. The venue for any action arising from this Agreement shall be in Palm Beach
County, Florida.
C. Neither party shall assign or transfer any rights or interest in this
Agreement without the written consent of the other party.
D. This Agreement shall not be valid until signed by the Mayor and the City
Clerk of each party.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused these to be
signed by their duly authorized officers on the date set forth above.
ATTEST.
a,
City Clerk
Approved as to forint • ,
X !
By:
ity Attorney cri
ATTEST:
By: /C/
City Clerk
Approved
By:
Ch Attorney
4
Y
Mayor
TOWN OF GULF jl STREAM; FLORIDA
y�X� 'r 1 2Xt
Mayor
I 11
To: Lula Butler, Director of Community Improvement
CC: Terrill Pybum, Assistant City Attorney
Milena Walinski, Assistant Finance Director
File
From: Kimberly Wynn, Executive Assistant/Agenda Coordlnatoro
Date: 10/02009
Re: Interlocal Agreementrfown of Gulf Stream/Bullding Permit and Inspection
Services
For your record and disbursement, attached please find one (1) fully executed
original Interlocal Agreement with the Town of Gulf Stream to provide Building
Permit and Inspection services. The agreement was approved at the August 18,
2009 Regular Commission Meeting; Item B.Q.
An original agreement will be maintained In the Clerk's office for Its file and a copy
sent to Finance and the City Attorney's Office.
Please call me at 243-7059 if you have any questions.
Thank you.
KW/kw
Attachments
CITY CLERK DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
F"', 7tr.- Terrill Pyburn, Assistant City Attorney
-TD , fit: Kimberly Wynn, Executive Assistant/Agenda Coordinator;eo)
Date: 4A2942009 q j: oO Dq
Re: Interlocal Agreement/Town of Gulf Stream/Building Permit and
Inspection Services
Attached please find two (2) original Interlocal Agreements with the Town of
Gulf Stream to provide Building Permit and Inspection services. The item was
approved at the August 18, 2009 Regular Commission Meeting; Item B.Q.
Plc&w approve for legal sufficiency and return to the Clerk's depar*nwt tar
Irutherprocemir{.
Call me at 243-7059 if you have any questions.
Thank you.
KW/kw
Attachment
CITY CLERK DEPARTMENT
RECEIVED
SEP 2 9 Mpg
CITY ATTORNEY
DIVISION 2. - SPANISH MEDITERRANEAN REVIVAL STYLE ARCHITECTURAL
STANDARDS
See. 70-218. - Roofs.
(a) Characteristics. Spanish and Mediterranean Revival roofs often exhibit a combination of
gable and hip roofs.
(b) Preferred.
Exposed rafter tails
Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes or less)
Simple short overhangs
Traditional red barrel tiles
(c) Discouraged.
Very low pitched roofs (slopes less than 4:12)
See. 70-219. - Windows.
(a) Characteristics. Windows typically exhibit rectangular or round -headed openings. They have
several small panes in each window rather than one large pane of glass.
(b) Preferred.
Casement windows
Small multi -paned
Sec. 70-221. - Exterior materials; colors.
(a) Characteristics.
(1) Stucco is the primary Spanish and Mediterranean type wall surface material utilized
throughout the town. A smooth stucco finish with a hand -troweled, modeled look is typical. (2)
(c) Preferred.
Hand -troweled stucco finish (smooth surface rather than rough finish preferred)
Warm, light pastel or off-white principal color
DIVISION 3. - GULF STREAM -BERMUDA STYLE
Sec. 70-238. - Roofs.
(a) Required. Flat, white thru and thru, smooth, un -coated tile and gray slate tile may be
permitted on homes that are predominately Georgian or British Colonial with Bermuda
influences. Flat, gray thru and thru, un -coated tile or slate -like tile may be permitted at
the discretion of architectural review and planning board and town commission through
the Level III review process, subject to the architectural review and planning board and
the town commission making a determination that such alternatives are appropriate for
the neighborhood.
(b) Preferred.
Combination hip/gable roofs
Exposed rafter tails
Hip roof
Low pitched roofs (6:12 slopes)
Roof overhang (2-2V2 feet)
(c) Discouraged.
Gable
Very low pitched roofs (slope less than 5:12)
Sec. 70-239. - Windows.
(a) Characteristics. Gulf Stream -Bermuda windows are typically small in scale and
proportioned to wall coverage. Rectilinear in form, these windows have several small
panes in each window rather than one large pane of glass.
(b) Preferred.
Casement to reflect color of building
Keystone over lintel
Pronounced sill and/or lintel
Rectilinear form
Small multi -paned
(c)
Discouraged.
Bay and bow windows as prominent feature
Paired and triple windows
Sec. 70-240. - Shutters.
(a) Characteristics. Shutters are important elements of Gulf Stream -Bermuda style houses. They
should contrast with the primary building color and be proportioned to the window.
(b) Preferred.
Contrasting color
Functional
Shutters should measure the full height and half the width of the window
Traditional horizontal slat or panel type
Traditional shutter color (for example: white, black, dark green, dark slate blue, dark taupe,
stained mahogany, dark or slate gray) _
(c)
Discouraged
No shutters
Sec. 70-241. - Entrances.
(c) Preferred.
Contrasting shutters or side lights
Multi -paneled doors (six to eight)
Simple pediment
Transom lights
Sec. 70-242. - Exterior materials; colors.
(a) Generally. Traditional Gulf Stream -Bermuda building materials consist of concrete block
construction with smooth stucco finishes. Colors are typically exemplified by various soft
pastel colors and off-whites.
(c)Preferred.
Contrasting trim
Smooth stucco finish
White or neutral color quoins and keystones
Wood trim
See. 70-243. - Other features.
(a) Generally. Other important elements contribute to the character of Gulf Stream -Bermuda
style.
(b) Preferred.
Decorative capped chimneys
Keystone detailing
Quoins
ROOFTEC CORPORATION
180 S.E. 2ND AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FL. 33444
561-243-0705
FAX 561-243-6030
BILL TO:
Gulfstream Town Hall
100 Sea Road
Gulfstream, Fl. 33483
WEBSITE:
W W W.ROOMCCORP.COM
STATEMENT
STATEMENT
4/5/10 Gulfstream Police Dept
TERMS
DESCRIPTION: NE Valley repair above rear QTY RATE AMOUNT:
entry 1$3,601.98
Materials: $398.23
Labor: 3/18 15 hrs (a3 $95.00= $14250
3/19 (2 men) 9.75 hrs. @ $95.00= $926.75
325 (2 men) 4 hrs ® $95.00= $380.00
326 (2 men)
THANK YOU FOR
Gulftream Police Dept.
246 Sea Road
Gulfstream
9 hrs. ® $95.00= $855.00
AMOUNT DUE: $3,601.98
T0`- N LSF GLt1,F _i1 REArul
FAYfviEtAT/APPROVED
77 W .._ ._ I0,TC_ /V _.._
Rooltec Corp.
160 S E. 2nd Ave.
Delray Beach, Florida 33444
License #CCC032457
Date: 3/n//t7
(SUBMITTED TO)
ESTIMATE
Name:C(/TOWiJ fj�i9LG
Address:/1,9Q sle54 /2,9A0
City: G7lJL�ST%2�lL! �LO/�/�i9
Zip: PH:
~ (DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING)
Name: Abar- p&a, i2T/' &,L,T
Address: _09916 SCfI 12aw
City: 6ULFST6f-5-n�
PH:
(561) 243-0705
FAX (561) 243-6030
Licensed & Insured
DESCRIPTION OF WORK: VE l�/`i!1 �y i�fiSE /GETU%?� � (ifI//Z 1/E l %d�0 4k/j/2Y
(" A) Remove existing roof tile to allow for proper repair of roof system and replacement of new cement tile to match / '
existing. New tile color may vary due to natural aging of existing roof.
() B) Remove existing embedded gravel to allow for proper repair of the flat roof membrane system.
() C) Remove damaged shingles to allow for proper repair and replacement of new shingles to match
existing. New shingle color may vary due to natural aging of existing roof.
(-I' D) Rebuild existing membrane damage using fibered roof cement and reinforcement membrane.
(✓' E) Install 901b. roll roofing membrane with new to match existing using fibered roof cement.
() F) Install 30/43 Ib, underlayment with new to match existing using mechanical fasteners.
() G) Replace necessary metal flashing with new to match existing.
H) Replace damaged wood decking rf any, with new to match existing.rntr/`/7Fi2/s9L S f a2o5o
(tY 1) Replace damaged wood facia if a with new to match existing. w �5 00 lOfi2 (�Ot712 .
(vY J) Clean up and haul away all debris.
O 1
All workmanship and materials guaranteed for-0year(s). DIIE TO A60 0,1'/10df
We propose to supply all workmanship and materials for: $ %�0 7• So
(50% upon commencement, huponomplet on)Estimator/Mechanic:1 re
Print)
Accepted, Owner/Agent: pate:
i
k
al
7
D
N N
ao
m�
O
N
... ... d�00 _.
In
cc
cc
S.
m
mz
•2
v O
Q
+
f
#
#
+
iIl
#
i
I
m
#
i
Y �
2 m
m
LL
O
O r +
Q
FJF UW'
v U
O
a1
b
C
m
N
N
ro
.ti
'I
O
Q
m
G
O
m
=I
^L
G
S
LU v
k
r
W9 00
D
Ui Qn:-
- LL 0
m
Q
OLL
rD.
El
❑ W N
q
z O LL
d
H
0
#
... ... d�00 _.
In
cc
cc
S.
m
nl/07/2009 14:14 5612436030
ROOFTEC CORPORATION
180 SE 2ND AVENUE
DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33444
561-243-0705
FAX 561-243-6030
-4zz
RE)OFTEC PAGE 01
�3 1-v1eF
W F.B.RITF.:
W W W_ROOFECCORP.COM
STATEMENT
ATEMENT
4/07/09 1 Gulfstream Tmva Hall
BILL TO:
Gulfsh+eam Town Hall
100 Sea Road
Oulfsnoam. FI. 33483
TERMS PROJECT
Due Upon Receipt $36,952.00
DESCRrnTroN: Rs root
QTV
RATE AMOUNT
511085.60
30% spoil hot mop: 511,085.60
THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESSS:
AMOUNT DUE: $11,085.60
JOB ADDRESS:
100 Sea Road
TOWN OF GULF STREAM
Gullstrcam
PAYMENT APPROVED
.4fdT_
BY _T
Q9lIGi
CK
I
khm
%7r
1 4r
ROOFTEC CORPORATION
180 SE 2 u Avenue, Delray Beach, Florida 33444
(561) 243-0705
(561) 243-6030 (FAX)
Gulfstream Town Hall
100 Sea Road
Gulfstream, Florida 33483
DATE I STATEMENT
April 8, 2009 1 Gulfstream Town Hall
Scope of work to date: Due Upon Receipt
Plywood decking used: 200 s.f. —100 s.f. =100 s.t @ $2.85 = $285.00
Rafter (Re -Used) Labor only: 4 hrs @ $95.00 = $380.00
Additional SYP 2X4 sleepers at all cupola hips as
required by Palm Beach County Building Inspector.
2X4 SYP: 274 ft @ .5111 $139.74
10-D ring shank nails: $17.80
3" deck screws: $36.09
Labor. 3 furs. @ $95 = +$285.00
Total amount due: $1,143.63
THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS!
Gulfstream Town Hall
100 Sea Road
Gulfstream, Florida
J TMAM OF GULF STREAM
PP.':'dr.Ec TT APPROVED
BY DATE�i?__.
OBLICA T V4 — . / z q1
TERMS
PROJECT
Amount Due
$1,143.63
Town Hall
Roof
Scope of work to date: Due Upon Receipt
Plywood decking used: 200 s.f. —100 s.f. =100 s.t @ $2.85 = $285.00
Rafter (Re -Used) Labor only: 4 hrs @ $95.00 = $380.00
Additional SYP 2X4 sleepers at all cupola hips as
required by Palm Beach County Building Inspector.
2X4 SYP: 274 ft @ .5111 $139.74
10-D ring shank nails: $17.80
3" deck screws: $36.09
Labor. 3 furs. @ $95 = +$285.00
Total amount due: $1,143.63
THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS!
Gulfstream Town Hall
100 Sea Road
Gulfstream, Florida
J TMAM OF GULF STREAM
PP.':'dr.Ec TT APPROVED
BY DATE�i?__.
OBLICA T V4 — . / z q1
E
m
N
ri
N
O
V
a
u
Q
w
0
a
W
I=
I. -
U) N
LL
J
7
a
LL
0.
2
0
Y I O m m
C I mtoN
U i
I
m W P I m
I N
I O N N
I
N
H N
-1 N
k
m
N
t -i
�7
0
0
U
a
U'
a
a
0
a
W
cc
LL
J
M
a
LL
0
Z
3.0
m
N h
MZ
m=
NO
N �
N a
N
t
t
f
t
+ f
m
f fi
+
I
i tl
N
4 L~
2m M
U
a
rn
WJ
1L N
o W m
O 1- N
U Z
11U1
O H
�
�
O
N
O
m
C
H
Z
T
N
C
W
E
•O
P
P
0/
H
P
m
UC
m
�
x
WCC a
F
C
F k m
ul oo�ge
m
my
vamN
m
C
J ¢ ¢
oo
P
C=7og�
F
ad v
F
LL sS¢vR
C W
0 W N
m
U
N w
m
mwa
zo
3
v m
0 W
F
OOr-HI
F
+
om m
k
m
N
t -i
�7
0
0
U
a
U'
a
a
0
a
W
cc
LL
J
M
a
LL
0
Z
3.0
City
FtWW TwnWV. Section
> / `'2 -
Block
crrY of DELRAY BEACH
"FAILURE
TO COMPLY WITH THF
4en
-
MECHANICS' LIEN LAW CAN
PERMIT FEES
COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPT.
RESULT
IN THE PROPERTY
001-0000-329.22-00
(561)243-7200
OWNER
PAYING TWICE FOR
_ - AVENUE AU SOLEIL
INASPEC-
BULGING
IMPROVEMENTS"
PAI..
ALL (561) 243-7218
001-0000-329.32-00
InVnxemerlt8
8.10
8.10
.00
Date Applied:
BLDG SURCHARGE---DPPR
I
8.10
Prepared by: THOMC
Y
_
-�
2520 AVENUE AU SOL.EIL
DELROY BEACH FL 334836102
n
or, O , Agent
FL 33447
Date Issued P /30.'
E:
PE --R F PERMITp�
Permit Type:
Parmh Phone Access #: 1455021
Construction
d No
1 1-0135146 00 0
REPO
Fu
ocatitiancy
Sq. Ft.
City
FtWW TwnWV. Section
SubDvsn.
Block
Lot
Platt 01.111111 As - -
CINKU
4en
:4
PERMIT FEES
540.00
540.00
PriNvirly Address
001-0000-329.22-00
LTHER Fc.�ES.
Zoning
RiVmwl
_ - AVENUE AU SOLEIL
NO FINAL _TNSPECTICN
U!:
PAI..
Subdlvlsion Nemo
001-0000-329.32-00
InVnxemerlt8
8.10
8.10
.00
001-0000-208.05-0Q
BLDG SURCHARGE---DPPR
8.10
8.10
Owner's Neme/Addreea/Telephone
001-0000-208.06--00
Contractor's Name/Address/License/Telephone
-�
2520 AVENUE AU SOL.EIL
DELROY BEACH FL 334836102
100.00
180 SE 2ND AVE
DELRAY BEACH
FL 33447
Additional Comments
Ht:,NIzwC Y. ..
Construction
EPPEER
FFE
Fu
ocatitiancy
Sq. Ft.
valuation
...
..
� r
.. _ ...
Scinil of Facts and Additional Information
CINKU
1
:4
PERMIT FEES
540.00
540.00
.00
001-0000-329.22-00
LTHER Fc.�ES.
NO FINAL _TNSPECTICN
?00.00
100.00
100.00
001-0000-329.32-00
BLDG SURCHARGE -DCA
8.10
8.10
.00
001-0000-208.05-0Q
BLDG SURCHARGE---DPPR
8.10
8.10
.00
001-0000-208.06--00
GRAND TOTAL
756.20
656.20
100.00
SPECIAL NOTES I RESTRICTIONS:
PEROOF SLOPED 5.12 ENTEGRA 11-0414.0?-
F--AT
1-0414.09F--AT TAMKO 09-0820.11
THE CITY OF DELRAY BEACH ENCOURAGES THE
USE OF ENERGY STAR PRODUCTS.
Any change in bunding plans or spedlicatlohs mug be recorded with NO office. Arty work not covered shove, mw have a valid permit prior to starting. In consideration
of ine gramxg of this planta. the owner and Wiser agree to erect this amu ne In fun complance with ftte Cope of Ominances V this tatty of Way Beach,
Fonow
'ieh# ddiWiWd>.i k'::.,.,: siAN:At
City o&Del Deac6 Florida
aaa CUSIBIER RECEIPT aaa
Oper: SKVIO Type: OC Drawer: 1
Date: 6/24/13 81 Receipt no: 222631
Year Nw&r Aeount
2911 135146
2529 RUM RU SOLEIL
DELRAY PM FL 334933
DP kILDIN9 PERMITS
$199.88
Tender detail
3555
Totaltenderedtendered
{18008..88
Total paywent
$188.88
Trans date: 6/21/13
Tice: 14:18:42
W-261
ORDINANCE NO. 04/4
AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE
TOWN OF GULF STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY,
FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 22, OF THE CODE OF
ORDINANCES, NUISANCES, AT ARTICLE I TO INCLUDE
A NEW SECTION 22-3 RELATING TO OBSTACLES TO
TRAFFIC AND PARKING; RESCINDING ARTICLE II,
RELATING TO DEBRIS, RUBBISH, WEEDS AND WILD
GROWTH IN ITS ENTIRETY AND PROVIDING FOR A
NEW ARTICLE 11 RELATING TO UNSIGHTLY, UNSAFE
OR UNSANITARY CONDITIONS; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF
ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR
CODIFICATION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COMMISSION OF THE TOWN OF GULF
STREAM, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS
Section 1. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby
amended at Chapter 22, Nuisances, Article I, In General, to include a new Section 22-3,
to read as follows:
"Sec. 22-3. Obstacles to traffic and parking
(a) It shall be unlawful for any person to place and/or maintain
any obstructions within the public right-of-way of the Town without first
being given authority in writing by the Town to place said obstructions.
Obstructions shall include, but shall not be limited to, hedges, trees, walls,
fences, traffic triangles, or other obstacles intended to impede traffic or
parking or structures of any kind not previously approved in writing by the
Town.
(b) Any obstacles placed in the Town right-of-way in violation of
this section may be immediately and summarily removed by the Town and
shall be removed at the expense of the property owner.
(c) Any person found to be in violation of this section shall be
subject to the general penalty section of this code or, alternatively, shall be
subject to the jurisdiction of the Town's code enforcement process."
Section 2. The Code of Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream is hereby
amended at Chapter 22, Nuisances, by deleting Article Il, Debris, Rubbish, Weeds and
Wild Growth, Sections 22-31 through 22-34 inclusive, in its entirety, and substituting
therefore the following new Article II entitled Unsightly, Unsafe or Unsanitary Conditions
to read as follows.
"ARTICLE II. UNSIGHTLY, UNSAFE OR
UNSANITARY CONDITIONS
See. 22-31. Prohibited.
It shall be unlawful and shall constitute a nuisance for any owner of
land within the Town to have or permit thereon any:
(1) Conditions in violation of any of the provisions in this
chapter.
(2) Rank vegetational growth that exudes unpleasant or noxious
odors, high or rank vegetational growth that may conceal
pools of water, trash or filth, or any other de -posits that may
be detrimental to health.
(3) Brush, weeds or grass that shall be greater than eight inches
in height above the ground.
(4) Dead or dying trees, grass, shrubs, stumps, roots or
obnoxious growth.
(5) Sand, soil or other fill material used in connection with or
resulting from construction projects.
(6) Filth, garbage, trash or debris.
(7) Decayed or decaying buildings or structures, ruins of any
kind or buildings, docks, walls or other structures in a failing
or dangerous condition.
(8) Any condition which provides harborage for rats, mice,
snakes, or other vermin.
(9) Any building or other structure which is in such a dilapidated
condition that is unfit for human habitation, or kept in such an
unsanitary condition that it is a menace to the health of
people residing in the vicinity thereof, or presents a more
than ordinary dangerous fire hazard in the vicinity where it is
located.
(10) All unnecessary or unauthorized noises and annoying
vibrations, including animal noises.
(11) All disagreeable or obnoxious odors and stenches, as well
as the conditions, sub -stances, or other causes which give
rise to the emission or generation of such odors and
stenches.
(12) The carcasses of animals or fowl not disposed of within a
reasonable time after death.
(13) The pollution of any public well or cistern, stream, lake,
canal, or body of water by sewage, dead animals,
commercial wastes, or other substances.
(14) Any building, structure, or other place or location where any
activity which is in violation of local, state, or federal law is
conducted, performed or maintained.
(15) Any accumulation of stagnant water permitted or maintained
on any lot or piece of ground.
(16) Dense smoke, noxious or lethal fumes, lethal gas, soot, or
cinders, in unreasonable quantities.
2
(17) Any condition constituting a fire hazard
(18) Any worn-out, scrapped, partially dismantled, nonoperative,
unusable, or discarded materials or objects, such as
automobiles or parts thereof, building materials, machinery,
metal, wastepaper, rags, glass -ware, tinware, vehicles,
boats or parts thereof, or other items of junk. Failure of any
vehicle, or parts thereof, to have a valid license plate or
other registration certificate specifically attached to the
vehicle or part thereof, shall be prima facie evidence that
such property is worn out, scrapped, nonoperative, unusable
or discarded.
(19) Failure of any person who has cleared land pursuant to a
land clearing permit to resod, replant or periodically sprinkle
the cleared area to prevent creation of wind-blown dust or
dirt.
(20) A seawall or bulkhead which falls into a state of disrepair or
ruin so as to allow erosion to land adjacent thereto.
Sec. 22-32. Foundations, structural members and exterior surfaces.
Foundations and structural members located upon any lot, parcel of
land or premises in the Town shall provide a safe, firm and substantial
base and support for the structure, and shall meet the following conditions,
in addition to those set forth by the Town's building code.
(1)
No floor, ceiling, roof, beam or essential horizontal
component of a building shall sag in excess of 31/2 percent
of its span.
(2)
Exterior walls shall be reasonably free of cracks or holes
through which weather elements can enter the building or
structure, and all exterior surfacing material shall be kept
painted and in good repair.
(3)
Interior walls and ceilings shall be structurally sound.
(4)
All windows and doors to the outside shall be constructed
and maintained in such a condition as to exclude weather
elements or insects entering.
(5)
The roof shall be constructed and maintained so as not to
leak. Roofs shall be kept clean and painted.
(6)
Every inside and outside stair, every porch and
appurtenance thereto shall be constructed so as to be safe
to use and capable of supporting the load that normal use
may cause to be placed thereon, and in conformance with
the building code, and shall be kept in sound condition and
good repair.
(7)
Accessory buildings and other appurtenances such as
swimming pools, tennis courts, walls, gates and fences
situated on the premises shall be kept in a safe and good
state of repair.
Sec. 22-33.
Notice to abate; content.
Whenever it is made to appear to the Town Manager, or the Town's
designee, after investigation that a nuisance exists within the Town
pursuant to the provisions of this chapter, the Town Manager or the Town
Manager's designee shall forthwith prepare an estimate of the total cost of
removing, suppressing or abating the nuisance and cause to be served
upon the person owning, occupying or having the care or custody of any
lot or parcel of land upon or in connection with such nuisance a written
notice to remove, suppress or abate the nuisance.
The notice shall:
(1) Describe the prohibited act, occurrence or condition, in
sufficient detail to plainly identify same.
(2) State the legal description of the property on which the same
exists or is maintained.
(3) State the estimated total cost which will in the opinion of the
Town Manager cover the total cost of removing, suppressing
or abating same.
(4) The proportion of such cost proposed to be bome by the
Town, if any.
(5) The proportion of such estimated amount which shall be
bome by the owner or occupant of the premises involved.
(6) State that unless such prohibited act, occurrence or
condition has been effectively removed, suppressed or
abated on or before the time stated in the notice, to be not
less than 15 days after service of the notice, the Town will
remove, suppress or abate the same and assess the cost of
so doing, or such proportion thereof as it may deem
equitable and just, against the owner or occupant of the
premises involved, provided such assessment shall in no
event exceed the proportion of the estimated amount set
forth in the aforementioned notice to be bome by the owner
or occupant of the premises involved;
(7) That such notice shall be served upon the owner, occupant
or person having the care or custody of the particular
property Involved, if he or she be found upon the premises or
within the Town. In the event the owner, occupant or
custodian cannot be found within the Town after reasonable
and diligent inquiry, such notice shall be posted in a
conspicuous place upon the premises and a copy thereof
mailed by certified mall, return receipt requested, and by
regular mail, to the last known address of such owner,
occupant or person having the care or custody of the land
involved.
Sec. 22-34. Hearing.
Any person owning or occupying the property removed or otherwise
interested, who objects to the proposed removal, suppression or
abatement or levy of a special assessment under this subchapter, must
present in writing to the Town Manager, his or her objections, within ten
days of the mailing or posting of the notice and must request a hearing
before the Town commission, or the person shall have deemed to have
consented thereto. The hearing shall be on the first regularly scheduled
meeting following the request for the hearing. After the hearing, the Town
commission, in the exercise of its discretion, may approve, revise, modify
or abandon the proposed action.
Sec. 22-35. Abatement by Town.
If at the time specified in the notice as provided in section 42-91,
the nuisance has not been removed, suppressed or abated, or in the
event a hearing is held by the Town Commission and the notice is upheld
in whole or in part, the Town Manager shall cause to be removed,
suppressed or abated the nuisance referred to in the notice according to
the terms set forth in the notice or, in the event of a hearing, in the manner
approved by the Town Commission.
Sec. 22-36. Levy of special assessment lien against property.
(a) The Town Manager shall, as soon as practicable and within 30
days after the completion of work as authorized in this subchapter,
ascertain and determine the actual cost thereof and the respective
portions to be borne by the Town if any, and the owners or occupants of
the property involved and, thereupon shall notify the owner or occupant, in
writing, of the amount required to be borne by the owner or occupant. In
the event said amount is not paid to the Town within thirty days of the date
of said notice in writing, the Town Commission, by resolution, fix, levy and
impose a special assessment against the property involved in an amount
not exceeding either the actual cost of the work, or the estimated special
assessment stated in the notice.
(b) The resolution shall specify the following:
(1) Description of the work performed.
(2) Date of completion.
(3) Total cost
(4) The proportion of such cost to be financed and defrayed by
special assessment.
(5) The unit or basis for distributing the amount to be specially
assessed among the several parcels of property where more
than one parcel is liable for assessment.
(6) The fact that a lien has been assessed by the Town with a
complete schedule or breakdown of the specific amount of
special assessment levied and imposed against and upon
each respective particular parcel of property involved,
showing in detail the description of the property, name of
owner and amount of assessment as severally and
respectively levied and imposed.
(7) That such liens shall bear interest at a rate of eight percent
per annum compounded unless paid within 30 days after
publication of such resolution.
(8) That the Town clerk shall forthwith have prepared and filed
of record, the amount of such lien assessed against each
parcel of property, the date of completion of such work and
such other information as may be deemed appropriate.
(9) That the Town clerk shall cause the resolution to be
published by posting, or publication in a newspaper, as
required by law.
(10) That the Town shall have, assert and possess a lien,
superior to all other claims, except taxes, against and upon
the property as therein described for the respective amounts
of such special assessments as indicated above, together
with interest and costs of collection.
(11) Commanding the Town Manager to enforce collection thereof
Sec. 22-37. Civil actions.
In addition to the other remedies and charges provided in this
article, the Town attorney is authorized to file appropriate civil actions for a
temporary restraining order, temporary injunction, permanent injunction, or
for damages, against any person violating this article.
Sec. 22-38. Emergency action.
Nothing in this article shall be construed to limit the Town's
authority to immediately abate any nuisance existing on public or private
property should an emergency exist.
Sec. 22-39. Penalty.
In addition to the penalties prescribed herein, the violation of this
article may, upon conviction, be punished pursuant to Section 1-15 of the
Town's Code of Ordinances. Additionally, a violation of any of the
provisions of this article may be referred to code enforcement which has
jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 2, Article II, Section 2-68."
Section 3. Severability.
If any provision of this Ordinance or the application thereof is held invalid, such
invalidity shall not affect the other provisions or applications of this Ordinance which can
be given effect without the invalid provisions or applications, and to this end the
provisions of this Ordinance are hereby declared severable.
Section 4. Repeal of Ordinances in Conflict.
All other ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream, Florida, or parts thereof which
conflict with this or any part of this Ordinance are hereby repealed.
Section 5. Codification.
This Ordinance shall be codified and made a part of the official Code of
Ordinances of the Town of Gulf Stream.
Section 6. Effective Date.
0
This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon Its passage and approval, as
provided by law.
PASSED AND ADOPTED in a regular, adjourned session on first reading this
j 7ti; day of September , 2004, and for a second and final reading on this 8th
day of October , 2004.
ATTEST:
,Gv
Clerk
N: VCFV 3147-0"Ord Chapter 22 Ad 1& 11, DOC
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 1 of it
14 -UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO.: 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
MARTIN E. O'BOYLE,
Plaintiff,
V.
ROBERTA. SWEETAPPLE and
TOWN OF GULF STREAM,
Defendants.
Defendant, ROBERT A. SWEETAPPLE (hereinafter "Defendant"), by and through the
undersigned counsel, and pursuant to Rule 11, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, respectfully
serves the following Motion for Rule I 1 Sanctions and Incorporate Memorandum of Law, and as
grounds therefore, would state as follows:
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The above -captioned matter involves a meritless and frivolous claim, as set forth
in the Plaintiff MARTIN E. O'BOYLE's ("Plaintiff' or "O'Boyle") Second Amended
Complaint; for slander pease against Defendant.
2. Plaintiff is a long time resident of the Town of Gulfstream ("Town"), a small
municipality with only 1,000 residents. [D.E. 411 at lr�¶ 5, 8. Moreover, Plaintiff is a self-
proclaimed "avid supporter" of Florida's Public Records Law and has by his own admission
submitted numerous public records requests to the Town as well as other municipalities and
agencies over the years. Id. at 19. Moreover, Plaintiff is no stranger to conflict with Town or the
legal system. Id. at j;¶ 10-17. Plaintiff has admittedly filed approximately twenty-nine (29)
J
P
COLE, SC07T d KTSSANE, P.A.
137 LAI:CVIEW AYDIU^.-SURE IN-%TST PA!Mt3 401. rU)MA 114011561)517.9300-(561) 617.39719AX
a
1
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 2 of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
lawsuits against the Town for alleged violations of the Public Records Law, including, but not
limited to approximately twelve (12) pending legal actions against the Town regarding alleged
violations of the Public Records Law, at the time this action was filed. Id, at ¶ 11.
3. Due to these pending lawsuits, the Town elected to "step up its defense of the
lawsuits", wherein the Town proceeded to hire Sweetapple as special counsel to assist its other
attorneys with respect to the defense of Plaintiff's numerous lawsuits against the Town. Id, at ¶¶
24-25.
4. O'Boyle further alleges that Defendant along with the Town of Gulf Stream's
Mayor, Scott Morgan, devised a plan to "defame, harass, intimidate, and antagonize" Plaintiff at
"private" meetings held between April 3, 2014 and June 10, 2014. Id. at ¶ 29. Specifically,
Plaintiff further asserts that Morgan and Sweetapple decided on a course of action to "falsely and
maliciously publish to others that Plaintiff is violating the civil and criminal provisions of the
federal and Florida RICO Acts by his filing and pursuit of public records cases," "falsely and
maliciously publish to others that Plaintiff's pursuit of public records cases against the Town is a
`scheme' devised by Plaintiff to `line his pockets' with profit," and "putting pressure on
Plaintiff's son and business associates in an effort to gain an undue advantage over Plaintiff in
[his) lawsuits against the Town" Id, at 130.
5. In this regard, Plaintiff alleges that "on several occasions over the last four
months, Sweetapple has spoken to friends, colleagues, business associates, and attorneys for
Plaintiff and conveyed the same message to each — Plaintiff is a criminal, he has violated the
federal and Florida RICO Acts, and that he is engaging in a for-profit scheme by having the
audacity to file public records requests and the will power to enforce them through lawsuits..."
-1)-
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
7:7 LAKEVIEW AVOWt-SUITE- IID- WEST PALM OGCIL FLOWDA 77{01 �7611JA7-9100 ISSiIbn NT1 PA%
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 3 of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
and that a lawsuit would be filed soon against the Plaintiff for the alleged RICO violations. Id. at
¶¶ 32-33, 45-46.
6. In response to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories, in particular Number 3,
which requested information related to the alleged defamatory statements made by Sweetapple,
Plaintiff was only able to specifically identify two instances: (1) July 2014 — settlement
discussions between Defendant as counsel for the Town of Gulf Stream, and Mark Hanna, an
attorney representing another town resident, Chris O'Hare, who has filed similar public records
suits against the Town, stating that the suits should be dismissed or Mr. O'Hare ran the risk of
being named in a RICO suit against O'Boyle; and (2) during a confidential settlement conference
between Defendant, as counsel for the Town of Gulf Stream, and Mark Hanna and Lou Roeder,
acting as counsel for Chris O'Hare and Mr. O'Hare himself, Defendant purportedly made the
statements alleged in paragraphs 30 and 32 of the Second Amended Complaint.
7. In fact, in or around February 12, 2015, the Town of Gulf Stream as well as the
Wantman Group, Inc. filed a Federal RICO Class Action suit against O'Boyle, Mr. O'Hare and
others, in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Case No.: 9:15-cv-
80182.
8. There is no Factual or legal basis to support O'Boyle's claims under federal or
slate law against Sweetapple.
9. The doctrines of Florida's absolute litigation immunity privilege, qualified
privileges as well as absolute immunity privilege as counsel/agent for the Town of Gulf Stream
clearly bars Plaintiff's claims. Moreover, the evidence in this matter establishes the truth of
Sweetapple's alleged statements which likewise serve as a complete bar to Plaintiffs claims.
-3-
COLI, SCOTT E KISSANE, P.A.
xn"MVJE AVENUC-SUIT ISU- ATST PALM MCAp4M0Ri0A 3 WI)u I)7j}M-JM I)UMMiA%
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 4 of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAb9
10. The absence of a viable claim is se readily apparent that it amounts to a Rule 11,
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, violation. As a result, Sweetapple, asks this Court for entry of
an Order imposing sanctions against O'Boyle and his attorneys.
11. In accordance with Rule 11(c)(2), this Motion for Rule I1 Sanctions will be
served upon O'Boyle, but will not be Bled with the Court until after the expiration of the safe
harbor period. If O'Boyle withdraws the Second Amended Complaint before then, this Motion
for Rule 11 Sanctions will not be filed with the Court, and Sweetapple will not seek sanctions
against O'Boyle or his attorneys.
MEMORANDUM OF LAW
It is axiomatic that a party who files a suit that is legally baseless and made without
reasonable and competent inquiry, is subject to sanctions under Rule 11. See, In re: BankAtlantic
Bancorp, Inc. Sec. Litie., 851 F. Supp, 2d 1299, 1308 (S.D. Fla. 2011) affdsub nom. Hubbard v.
BankAdantic Bancorp, Inc.. 503 F. Apple 671 (11th Cir. 2012); see also, Thompson v.
RelationServe Media, Inc.. 610 F.3d 628, 665 (11th Cir. 2010). In other words, a legal claim is
frivolous if no reasonably competent attorney could conclude that it has any reasonable chance
of success or is a reasonable argument to change existing law. Worldwide Primates. Inc. v.
Mc real 87 F.3d 1252, 1254 (11th Cir. 1996) citing Jones v. Int'I Riding Helmets. Ltd. 49 F.3d
692, 695 (11th Cir. 1995)); see also Davis v. Carl 906 F.2d 533, 538 (11th Cir. 1990) (noting
that legal claims are objectively frivolous when they ignore clearly established law). Further,
suits that are intended to harass a party are subject to Rule I I sanctions.' In re: Flinn 139 F.R.D.
1 Courts in the Eleventh Circuit have sanctioned pro se parties under Rule 11 for frivolous, harassing, and delaying
litigation behavior, including nonmeritarlous claims, defenses, and motions. Sloccklin v. United Staten 89 -182 -
CIV -0C-16, 1997 WL 1039239 (M. D. Fla. 1997) tiling Unitcd States v. Milam 855 F.2d 739. 740 (11th Cir 1988);
Schmmek v ]ones 161 F.RD. 119, 120 (M D.Fla.1995); Dean v ARA Environmental Svcs,. Inc . 124 F.R D 224,
226 (N.D.Ga.1988), affd 890 F.2d 1166 (1 Ith Cir. 1989),
-4-
COLE, SC07T & KISS,WE, Pt
737 "REVIrW AVENUL-Sana 120 • WEST PAW aLSC1l.&ORMA 37401(5 61) 311-920 -JS61)6934MFAX
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 5 of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
698, 699 (S.D. Fla. 1991) affd, 22 F.3d 1097 (11th Cir. 1994) and affd, 22 F.3d 1097 (11th Cir.
1994).
In this regard, Rule 11(b), Federal Rule of Civil Procedure I I(b) provides that,
[b]y presenting to the court a pleading, written motion, or other paper—whether
by signing, filing, submitting, or later advocating it—an attorney certifies that to
the best of the person's knowledge, information, and belief, formed after an
inquiry reasonable under the circumstances:
(1) it is not being presented for any improper purpose, such as to harass, cause
unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of litigation;
(2) the claims, defenses, and other legal contentions are warranted by existing law
or by a non -frivolous argument for extending, modifying, or reversing existing
law or for establishing new law;
(3) the factual contentions have evidentiary support or, if specifically so
identified, will likely have evidentiary support after a reasonable opportunity for
further investigation or discovery; ..."
Fed. R. Civ. P. 1 I(b). Thus, under Rule 11, an attorney must make some reasonable inquiry into
the facts and the law. Worldwide Primates 87 F.3d at 1254, The reasonableness of the inquiry is
a fact -based question, dependent on the circumstances of the case at hand. Id.
A court confronted with a motion for Rule I I sanctions premised on the alleged frivolity
of a claim must first determine whether the party's claims or assertions are objectively frivolous
in view of the facts or law; if they are, the court must then determine whether the person who
signed the pleadings would have been aware they were frivolous had he made a reasonable
inquiry. Id An objective standard of reasonableness governs this inquiry. Baker v. Alderman.
158 Fad 516 (11th Cir. 1998); Donaldson v. Clark 819 F 2d 1551, 1556 (11th Cir. 1987) (en
Banc ). A legal claim is frivolous if no reasonably competent attorney could conclude that it has
any reasonable chance of success or is a reasonable argument to change existing law.
Worldwide Primates 87 F.3d at 1254 citing Tones, 49 F.3d at 695; see also Dgyis 906 F.2d at
538. As explained in detail below, Plaintiff's claims against Defendant fall squarely within the
-5-
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
3M "KCVICW AVENUE -S= I70-NLiT MM EEACII. FLOftif1A ASPI IMi)11Y91fA- rMJ)6u nr rut
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 6 of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
purview of Rule 1 I and as such, Plaintiff and his attorneys should be sanctioned. Plaintiff's
claims set forth in the Second Amended Complaint are objectively frivolous and are clearly
barred under federal and state law. O'Boyle's counsel either knew or should have known that
the Second Amended Complaint was objectively frivolous. The entry of Rule 11 sanctions
against O'Boyle and his attorney are the property remedy for O'Boyle's improper conduct.
A. PLAINTIFF'S CLAIM FOR SLANDER PER SE
In order to prove a valid claim of slander per se, O'Boyle must establish that (1) the
defendant published a false statement; (2) about the plaintiff, (3) to a third party; and (4) the
party suffered damages as a result of the publication. Valencia v. Citibank Int'I 728 So.2d 330,
330 (-la. 3d DCA 1999); Fun Spot of Florida. Inc. v. Magical Midway of Cent. Florida. Ltd.,
242 F. Supp. 2d 1183, 1187 (M.D. Fla. 2002). Further, an actionable claim of slander per Se
must show that the purported slander impute to another (a) a criminal offense amounting to a
felony; (b) a presently existing venereal or other loathsome and communicable disease; (c)
conduct, characteristics, or a condition incompatible with the proper exercise of his lawful
business, trade, profession, or office; or (d) acts of unchasti[t]y. Campbell v. Jacksonville Kennel
Club, 66 So.2d 495, 497 (Fla. 1953).
1. Plaintiffs Claim for Slander per se is barred by the absolute litiaation immunity
orivileae
It is well established under Florida law that counsel involved in a judicial proceeding
enjoys an absolute privilege from civil liability for any act taken in relation to such proceedings.
Levin. Middlebrooks, Mabie, Thomas. Moves &. Mitchell- P.A. v. U.S. Fire Ins. Co 639 So.2d
606, 609 (Fla. 1994). In this case, Counts I of Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint against
Sweetapple are based entirely on Defendant's alleged conduct preliminary to, in the course of,
and otherwise related to Defendant's defense of 30 plus, various law suits filed by Plaintiff
-6-
COLE, SCOTr & HISSANE, PA
a:urMVMWAVa t -sung 13 -WEST PAW 3aAoi.n MDA u+oi csetl�u-nm-�sailau�an rnx
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08124/2015 Page 7 of it
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
against the Town. In a recent decision, Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal, in a matter
similar to the facts in this case, affirmed the trial court's dismissal with prejudice of the
plaintiffs defamation claim. McCullough v. Kubiak, 158 So.3d 739, 740 (Fla. 4th DCA 2015).
Specifically, the Court affirmed the trial court's opinion that alleged disparaging
statement(s) which were made during the course of a deposition of a non-party witness in an
attempt to scare the insurance company into a settlement were absolutely privileged.
McCullough v. Kubiak 158 So.3d 739, 740 (Fla. 4th DCA 2015). In this regard the Court
recognized that the privilege extended to conversations between opposing counsel in a pending
civil action in which the attorneys represented one of the parties involved. Id. citing Sussman v.
Damian. 355 So?d 809, 811 (Fla. 3d DCA 1977). In addition the Court relied on the holding in
Jackson v. BellSouth Telecomms. 372 F.3d 1250, 1276 (11th Cir. 2004) which noted that
"events taking place outside the courtroom during discovery or settlement discussions are no less
an integral part of the judicial process, and thus deserving of the protection of the [litigation]
privilege, than in -court proceedings." Id, citing Jackson v. BellSouth Telecomms., 372 F.3d
1250, 1276 (11th Cir. 2004)(internal citations omitted). Lastly, the McCullough Court
distinguished the facts in that matter from DelMonico v. Traynor, 116 So.3d 1205 (Fla. 2013),
noting that the facts in McCulloughlike those in this matter, do not fall within the narrow
scenario and concern presented in Delmonico. Id.
Notwithstanding the broad sweeping and bare bones allegations in the Second Amended
Complaint Plaintiff cannot maintain his claim for slander per se. Specifically, a review of
Plaintiff's interrogatory responses reveals that any purported statements by Mr. Sweetapple were
made during the course of confidential settlement discussions between Mr. Sweetapple on behalf
of his client, the Town of Gulf Stream and Mark Hana, Esq., Lou Roeder, Esq. as counsel for
-7-
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
MLAFEV AVENUE—SURE 130-N:STPAUI REACT I, r1ARIVA3343I ISbi)3M9300-(S61)613431 FAX
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/2412015 Page 8 of 11
CASE N0. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
Chris O'Hare as well as Mr. O'Hare. Notwithstanding, Plaintiffs inability to articulate and/or
establish two occasions where the alleged statements were made, it clear from the record that the
alleged statements of Mr. Sweetapple, fall with the absolute litigation immunity privilege as they
were done between counsel of represented parties, and during the course of settlement
discussions. As such, Plaintiffs claims for slander per se are clearly barred by the absolute
litigation immunity privilege.
2. Plaintiffs Claims are barred based upon the qualified privilege
Moreover, based upon the facts and evidence in this matter Plaintiffs claims are also
barred pursuant to a qualified privilege as recognized by the DelMonico Court precluding
Plaintiff's claim for slander per se DelMonico 116 So.3d at 1219. Specifically, the qualified
privilege applies where the statements are made out of court and are relevant to the underlying
suit. Id. Here the alleged statements were all made during the course of confidential settlement
discussions. Where as in this matter the qualified privilege applies, Plaintiff must then establish
express malice of Sweetapple. Id. Plaintiff has not and cannot establish the requisite malice
requirement to defeat the qualified privilege. As such, Plaintiffs slander per se fails as a matter
orlaw.
3. Plaintiffs Claims are barred by the absolute immunity privilege
In this matter all the alleged statements of Mr. Sweetapple, are barred by the absolute
immunity privilege. Casell v. India 964 So.2d 190, 193-94 (ila. 4th DCA 2007); Fla. State.
Univ. Bd. of Trustees v. Monk 68 So 3d 316, 318-19 (Fla, 1st DCA 2011); McNavr v. Kelly.
184 So.2d 428,429-31 (Fla. 1966); M.S. v. Nova Southeastern Univ. 81 So.2d 614, 617-19 (Fla.
4th DCA 2004); Fla. Stat. § 768.28; see e.g. Andrew H. Boros. P.A. v. Arnold P Carter M.D.,
P.A. 537 So.2d 1134, 1135 (Fla. 3d DCA 1989). Specifically, Florida's executive immunity
-8-
COLE, SCOTT & h7SSANH, P.A.
000LAXEVIL AVeN11E-SORE e0.WrSTPALM SEACN. nOMM 0110115611113.M -061I 6IN9flfAX
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 9 of 11
CASE N0. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
privilege extends to certain private parties who are in a contractual relationship with the Stale.
M.S.. 81 So.2d at 618-19; Fla. Stat. § 768.26. In this matter, all of Defendant's alleged
defamatory statements, even if true, were made during and in the scope of Defendant's role as
special counsel for the Town or Gulf Stream and are therefore based upon his contractual
relationship with the Town of Gulf Stream are absolutely immune from liability. Id.
4. Defendant's purported statements were of nure opinion
Further, the alleged statements by Mr. Sweetapple were of pure opinion precluding them
from being actionable as a matter of law. Colondy v. Iverson. Yoakum. Papiano & Hatch, 936
F.Supp. 917, 923 (M.D.Fla. 1996); Hay v. Independent Newspapers, Inc.- 450 So.2d 293, 295
(Fla. 2d DCA 1984). To be sure, to date the only individuals Plaintiff can identify that Mr.
Sweetapple made any of the alleged statements to, are Mark Hannah and Lou Roeder both of
whom are experienced attorney's practicing in Florida and Chris O'Hare, another resident of the
Gulf Stream engaged in public records requests and a party to the RICO action. Mr, Hannah hus
already testified in deposition in other matters that the alleged statements of Mr. Sweetapple
were merely his opinion based upon facts generally known and previously admitted by Plaintiff.
Under the totality of the circumstances, it is clear that any of Sweetapple' s alleged statements
were no more than his opinion with respect to Plaintiff's admittedly litigious conduct over the
last eighteen (18) months. As such, any of Sweetapple's alleged statements are not actionable as
a matter of law as they are of pure opinion and Plaintiff' has not and cannot establish that Mr.
Sweetapple acted with the requisite malice. See e.g. Estoril Inc, v. Villarreal 2009 WL 2876229,
"4 (S.D. Fla. Sept. 8, 2009).
5. Defendant's purported statements were in fact true
-9-
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
111I.U9CVICW AVENUE -SUIT[ 110' WTSTPAW WCI I. FLORIDA 33401 (Idll)t1-9100-il6U 6i}I9TIFAX
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page 10 of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-KAM
It is an absolute defense to any claim for defamation/slander that the offending statements
were in fact true. See e.g. Rosenberg v. American Bowline Congress 589 F.Supp. 547, 551
(M D.Fla. 1984). In this matter, there can be no doubt that the alleged statements made by Mr.
Sweetapple were in fact true. Specifically, Plaintiff has alleged that Sweetapple stated that
O'Boyle has violated the federal and Florida RTCO Acts, that he believes O'Boyle's public
records requests and law suits are a scheme to make profit and that RICO suit was forth coming.
In or around February 12, 2015, the Town of Gulf Stream as well as the Wantman Group, Inc.
filed a Federal RICO Class Action suit against O'Boyle, Mr. O'Hare and others, in the United
States District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Case No.: 9:15-cv-80182, establishing
the Sweetapple's statements were in fact true and accurate. It follows that Plaintiffs slander per
se claim is completely unsupported by the facts and law and is grossly frivolous as the truth
serves as a complete bar to same.
WHEREFORE, and for the reasons detailed above, Defendant, ROBERT A.
SWEETAPPLE, respectfully requests that this Court enter an Order granting this Motion for
Rule I1 Sanctions against, Plaintiff, MARTIN O'BOYLE, and Plaintiffs counsel, DANIEL
DESOUZA, and award Defendant his attorneys' fees and costs incurred directly from these Rule
11 violations, and to take such further action as it deems just and proper.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
WE HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed with
the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system, this 24h day of August, 2015 which will, in
tum, send a notice of electronic filing to: DANIEL DESOUZA, ESQ., DeSouza Law, P.A.,
1515 N. University Drive, Suite 209, Coral Springs, Florida 33071 and JEFFREY L.
-10-
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
3L`I XZVICWAVENLIE.S IL 130-WTST PALM DWILnAIUUA 0N01(M II II}g300.1N1)60-M FAX
Case 9:14-cv-81250-KAM Document 52 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/24/2015 Page it of 11
CASE NO. 9:14-CV-81250-K4M
HOCHMAN, ESQ., HUDSON C. GILL, Johnson, Anselmo, Murdoch, Burke, Piper &
Hochman, P.A., 2455 E. Sunrise Blvd., Suite 1000, Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33304.
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
Attomeys for Defendant Sweetapple
222 Lakeview Avenue, Suite 120
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Telephone: (561) 383-9200
Facsimile: (561) 683-8977
By: IS/JOSHUA A. GOLDSTEIN
BARRY A. POSTMAN
FBN: 991856
JOSHUA GOLDSTEIN
FBN: 064834
I \1601-0062-001pleadinglmotimnnotion far rule I I sections- second emended complaint -riled docz
_11 -
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
322 "UV1EW AVL4U[—SUrrr. IW • WEST PALM Y.'vKil. rIDmUA ]Nal 134111a}9laa•1141) bU IS'Ti PAX
T _2,6
Chapter 22 - NUISANCES
ARTICLE If. - UNSIGHTLY, UNSAFE OR UNSANITARY
CONDITIONS
Sec. 22-32. - Foundations, structural members and exterior surfaces.
Foundations and structural members located upon any lot, parcel of land or premises in the
town shall provide a safe, firm and substantial base and support for the structure, and shall
meet the following conditions, in addition to those set forth by the town's building code.
(5) The roof shall be constructed and maintained so as not to leak. Roofs shall be kept
clean and painted.
(Ord. No. 04-4, § 2, 10-8-04)
&=015 E -Codes
Chapter 1, Part 2, Section 105, (4)(1) C/
105.4.1 Permit intent.
A permit issued shall be construed to be a license to proceed with the work and not as authority to violate,
cancel, alter or set aside any of the provisions of the technical codes, nor shall issuance of a permit prevent
the building official from thereafter requiring a correction of errors in plans, construction or violations of
this code. Every permit issued shall become invalid unless the work authorized by such permit is
commenced within six months after its issuance, or if the work authorized by such permit is suspended or
abandoned for a period of six months after the time the work is commenced.
105.4.1.1
If work has commenced and the permit is revoked, becomes null and void, or expires because of
lack of progress or abandonment, a new permit covering the proposed construction shall be obtained
before proceeding with the work.
105.4.1.2
If a new permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date the initial permit became null and
void, the building official is authorized to require that any work which has been commenced or
completed be removed from the building site. Alternately, a new permit may be issued on
application, providing the work in place and required to complete the structure meets all applicable
regulations in effect at the time the initial permit became null and void and any regulations which
may have become effective between the date of expiration and the date of issuance of the new
permit.
105.4.1.31
,•
Work shall be considered to be in active progress when the permit has received an approved`;
inspection within 180 days. This provision shall not be applicable in case of civil commotion or
strike or whenthe building work is halt eJ due directly to judicial injunction, order or similar;
process.
.._ .
105.4.1.4
The fee for renewal reissuance and extension of a permit shall be set forth by the administrative
authority.
Privacy policy
Click here for copyright U Information.
http:llecodes.cyberregs.c=lco-ezelcpage.dll7pg=cuy,bdm&p=d:%5Cv,ebr rr.csri955Ccrdlns2-A5Cindx%5CST%5Cfl%5CstA5CbZ00v10°,55CsLiLsLb20o... ill
(S ' cs
BP500U04 City of Delray Beach Florida 7/09/13
Request For Inspection - Inspection History 10:06:42
Application number 11 00135146 000 000
Application type RE -ROOF OF EXISTING STRUCTURE
Tenant number, name :
Permit type/seq/VRU : RERO 00 001455021 RE -ROOF PERMIT 9/07
Property address . • 2520 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
Type options, press Enter.
2=Change
4=Delete 5=View
Status
Inspector
Request
Results
Opt Date
Inspection Description
ID
Date Time
Stat
Date
6/21/13
PERMIT RENEWED
LT
6/24/13
AP
6/21/13
_
12/10/12
PERMIT RENEWED
KEB
11/14/12
AP
11/14/12
_
4/26/12
ROOF TIN TAG/METAL
BK
4/26/12
AP
4/26/12
_
11/30/11
ROOF SHINGLE/TILE IN PROG
BK
11/30/11
AP
11/30/11
_ 9/06/11
ROOF SHEATHING
ETG
9/06/11
AP
9/06/11
Bottom
F3=Exit F6=Add inspection F12=Cancel F15=Override
-29(
Gmail-
Louis Roeder <1ou.roeder@gmail.com>
byGXkNIC
Public Records Case - CC000556
Spritz, Stephanie <spdtzs@mydelraybeach.com> Fri, Feb 26, 2016 at 9:04 AM
To: Lou Roeder <lou@louroeder.com>
Cc: "Bustin, Janice" <rustin@mydelraybeach.com>
Mr. Roeder,
The City conducted an extensive review of the records pertaining to 2520 Avenue Au Soleil. In our
review, we found one additional document that I am attaching to this email.
Sincerely,
Stephanie
4 Staffr.Attorney
MV of Delray Beach
2DO NW 11"Ave, Delray Beach, FL 33444
i" f
July 3, 2013
Rooftec Corporation
180 SE 2°d Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33447
RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil, Permit #11-135146
Dear Mr. Mulleavy,
Per our conversation on July 3, 2013 regarding the above permit, this permit is not eligible for renewal.
Too much time has passed and a new application and supporting documents will need to be submitted for
the re -roof.
If you have any questions, you may contact me at (561) 243-7200.
Regards,
Steve Tobias
Chief Building Official
7013
Paint Verificadw 1 1 z3
ABuilding Permits Self Service
Should you require assistance, please call 561-243-7200.
Permits are not ready for pickup until the Building Dept status is 'Approved'.
Permit Verification Info
Permit Address: 2520 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
:-ROOF OF EXISTING STRUCTURE
.TERATION - INTERIOR & EXTERIOR -RESIDENTIAL
R CONDITIONING REPLACEMENT
)OR REPLACEMENT/CHANGE OUT
New Search
City Home Contact Us
0 Selectron
[c.uo[oc�[[ c
APPROVED
6/21/2013
APPROVED
4/3/2013
APPROVED
12/2/2011
C.O. ISSUED
5/17/2011
More Information Privacy Policy
egw.mKldraybwchcaMN bpem Wparrittlrg/ParritVaifimdc)n.mpx 1/1
111172015
Pemit Verification
Building Permits Self Service
Should you require assistance, please call 561-243-7200.
When Permit is Ready, You Will Be Called With Total Fee Due. Permits are not ready for pickup until the
Building Dept status is 'Approved'.
Permit Verification Info
Permit Address: 2520 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
Permit Description
Permit Status
Status Date
ALTERATION -INTERIOR & EXTERIOR -RESIDENTIAL
RE -ROOF OF EXISTING STRUCTURE
CLOSED
APPROVED
8/17/2015
6/21/2013
AIR CONDITIONING REPLACEMENT
APPROVED
12/2/2011
DOOR REPLACEMENT/CHANGE OUT
C.O. ISSUED
5/17/2011
New Search
City Home Contact Us More Information Privacy Policy
Selectron
htlp://egoynriddrelbeach.cmAvebpelmts/Pe mtbrglPermtVwificadm.wpx
1/1
3$2016
Permit Verification
Building Permits Self Service
Should you require assistance, please call 561-243-7200.
When Permit is Ready, You Will Be Called With Total Fee Due. Permits are not ready for pickup until the
Building Dept status is'Approved'.
Permit Verification Info
Permit Address: 2520 AVENUE AU SOLEIL
Permit Description
Permit Status
Status Date
ALTERATION -INTERIOR & EXTERIOR -RESIDENTIAL
CLOSED
8/17/2015
RE -ROOF OF EXISTING STRUCTURE
APPROVED
6/21/2013
AIR CONDITIONING REPLACEMENT
APPROVED
12/2/2011
DOOR REPLACEMENT/CHANGE OUT
C.O. ISSUED
5/17/2011
New Search
City Home Contact Us More Information Privacy Pollcv
Selectron
cnua. oaua. inc
http:I/egm.mydeiraybeach.com/wepparmits/PsmittinglPermltVerificatm.aspx �/�
}U
L14M'elep lseq a41 se4 ugpaN
SIW S940POS
awno6
tlLLtlIfLLVIa"•�4lGtlVLL"1!�I"J„OT"u�^e VLSG wco�g91'r0/ Itll�� vyNaa rnnvr�/.a..H4
smelneo lua110 6 smelnw ju"a C smelnw Wells 9l
lu86V 611453 leag ® lue6b wels3leaa 1u06y alels3leap EMM
01SAOS )JOIN e10jee xaltl !(ue4a IV
'away siql Inoge alou alenud a Ke aseald
Lwolgwd
6ugs1151411upd sawoH 6q/eeH dela
a 6 slea6 Z :palepdn Ise'I l o6e salnww 6 :pelloa4O lsel ugpeN
dnwE) uwowoo e41 'Ilauuag uuV
lueBV s,sa6ng
dnwO uwowoo 941 •Ilauuee uuy
to Ilssl+noo pepinwd 6ups1-1
99006IE-X-d #Slut
40¢913 wled /qunoo IlaloS nyaoeld Rl!unwwoo
pagoela0 6pwed el6wS ad61f4isdoid 4luowiS lS son(3VOH
'spunw6 pue food alp s>loopeno 1941 wow epuold 6uol Io(4-Ajol a of
Suluado ua431IN )euuno6 pue leq ism -wow 6ululp lewlol e'swow 6gwel pue 6wn11 6ug1nul 4pm 6ululepaluelol leap) $l awo4 6uluue40 5141 w9110 Bele a4I1e41 Ile o) e9l01USAUGD
SU Ilam se 6oenud 6ulp!nwd'poo41og461au papnloes s141 w slol Isafuel stplo BOB uo peleool 8w04 wea4Sllne) 96we6 suo-om4'4leq lleq-auo pue oml'wowpeq sw4
CoV 1
+e AR
"OZ'Ll unr :ua Plos 6d6I gllne
'lj'bsRABs spas IIOZ'L1. unf ROS
e99'Z I S'Z E I 000,991pS
stool Sluafy alelS3 leaf Ilas 9 Ans
rase -snims
[seEE ld'wewls llnE1
Ilalog ny anuantl 0ZSZ
N130321
uuo m I ccn/ul c -vv aelml I coir 14 wean¢ nn� halo¢ nw anu Aw n7C7 01 n71n7/l
Al,
I
;Aj
61I9Z # -Sa-d 13
,DJ 'dd'mm1 •H aauazzal,
J11 'Hd'uun1 'H•• ,
'6lazaatnS
•Ilea aseald aauuas zaq}mI 3o aq um I II
•iTzons papluuad ail}';o
uopez}S;UTUIpE puE 'nano uot;o}psunf 5ulnEq AaUaSP ay} o} Su}pze.Hzo; zol not o} papTnozd sr zapal snit,
•papuaunuooaz s} zTedaz pue pagewep
szuadde joap jigjo a`dpa }sans uo Te}aut aapa duQ •uo}srulu} za}um;uanazd o} }uaotgns ale pup apo:)
algeolldde gjjm aouellduzoo ul aq o; puno; puE pa}aadsul sen+ XalTun HN }u;aags deo o} a2rurep zledaz
o} sleua}etu panozddE Io uopEo.Tdde pue sampaaozd anl}aauo' }aags dpa snou}wM pagTpout uo
paddoui u q;lm pane}sin }aags aseq u pur palle;sm uaaq sEq Team au •ZIOZ;sang punozu peaeldea
pue panoutaz azam pup pa}uzoua}ap peq sTuua}eui asogZ autp;eq; it, panu;suc uaaq peq }sags
dm pue ';aags aseq a 'Maui mou pue I IOZ zago}ao punozu panoutaz sung jooz plo aq; pue}szapun I
•6upo4 pa}aadsm sung anoqu par�uapl HulpTmq aq; jo Iooz aq} uo �Tzom ssazSozd aq} }sanbaz mo C;d
:azuH2O 'XW zu9G
9f,19E T # 3}utzad
•13 'utEa% ITnJ 'ITaloS ny anuanV OZgZ }u aauapTsag azeH O :ag
£SKE 1d 'uteaz}S ITnO
Halog nV anuany OZSZ
azuH2O sutD
£IOZ '0£ Azenue j
woa uunlaia7:Fmn-a
S%z-su (SWmed
%W -M (19S) :auow
STM 'Id'suap"D gM99 U"d
aue l wZZ £IZZ
���� �l�II2IH�AiI9NH
6T19Z" •gaX-H
.Lnl •g aouaiaay
'dLj'uunl g•Z
'Alazaouis
•lien aseald az)puas iaLllzry;o aq ueo I jj
xao v, pa}}juuad aLl} 'jo uoj;es}sn nuipe pue 'nano uo;}otpsun[ dulnell
n-.)uaSe atl} o} Sujpzenuo.j aoI noX o} papinoid aae 'riue Tl 'so4oLid SLnALTedLuoaae pue ia}}al snli•
•apoo algeocldde iljcm
aouetlduioo ul aq o} punoj pue pa}oadsuc a.Ta ti suogeool aldpinui }e uojsru}uj ialLIA }uanazd pue
}aaLls deo o} a2eump rledai o} sleualum panoadde jo uopeojldde pue saLnpaooid anj}oauoJ }aags
deo snoucuin}Lq payjpoLu uo paddow e tjj!m palle}sui }aaLls aseq a pue palle}sul uaaq sell le}atu aqj,
repo} pa}oadsul sena anoge pat
guapL atnplinq atp jo jooi aqj uo 31aom ssaa2ozd aLp }sanbaz mo C }y
:a'LH,O •.Lyq ieaQ
9ti'IS£I-LI s }luuad
•Zd 'Ineai}S jinJ 'lcaloS ny anuany OZgZ }e aouapjs@U amH2O :all
£Si%££ 13 'Luea4S ITnJ
lcaloS ny anuany OZcZ
amH2O sul-D
tIOZ'9T f"enuej
urii[;�aMIuun�<tr=»a.ua� atew-a
SLS -88L X888) �x'e3
S5K-C--(g(L9S):auogd
BLKE'Id'suapaeD q:)PN Luted
auel wic £LU
�MI2IH311II9Nfl
;, . �f
y _�
,% �
,. � � Y
d ,`
.+
r�'�.
i�
��i
:� �`
.�
' o a
u.
��,
yy/
N
r
1•
y` Y
}
+C �
C '',.
rt
y
I
,g ..
u ,�:': .
',
,`f
!r
r
}'YO•""i
Oil -L
6iT9Z = '$a2T 13
.. D 'ISDJ 'dd 'uunl •g aauallay
z2A_ UM G
J71 'dd 'Llunl •g•y
'6lazaourS
'Ilea aseald aavuas Iaq}zn3 Io aq uza I II
Asona pa}}cuuad ail; '3o uoi;el}sjujujpu pue'Iano uorpcpsunl $u}nutl
foua9e atp o} 2ujprnnuol zoI no S o} pap}nozd am Xuo }I'so}ogd 2upSuudwo»e pue za}}al slgy
•apoz) alqu-)lldde
tl}Ina aauulldujoa u} aq o} punol puu pa}nadsu} sena Mallen MI\T alp pue -5pap }ug aqj to uopaasza}ul ag}
}u uoisru}ul za}ena }uanazd pue }aags dui o} adetuep zludaz of sleua}eul panozddu �o uoI}e:)gdde pue
sampaaozd anl}aazzoD •}aags du:) snounun}Iq paglpotu uo paddotu e q}Ina pallu}stn }aags aseq u puu
pallu}sut uaaq seq le}aur agy •}Isln }seI btu Stnznp sura }c se uoplpuo: WITMIS a to Al}sotu st Iooz agy
Sepo} pa}aadsuT sunt anoqu pagl}uapl oulpllnq aq} to }ooz aq} uo >Iiom ssaz2ozd aq} }sanbaz InoX 4V
:aIuH2O '-'W IuaCl
9tIS£I-I1 }IUUad
•13 'tueaz}S IInO 'IlaloS nV anuand OZg }u aauapjsag azeH2O :aX
£SK£ 13 'ujeaz}S ?InJ
I]aloS nV anuaAV oZSZ
azuH2O su D
T'IOZ `ZI AIrLf
uo"raau`uiy�ai u tii�>f :jjuw-a
s:xL3
ccbg-sZ9(195):auogd
8IK£ -o `suapluo Sae% luIpd
aur ] ;+wZ £IGG
�rII2IHHI�tI�Ai�
N
d'
O
►N
6II9Z w '$ad 13
S�7 `IS�3 `3d'uLm I •g a,)uaizay
D11'3d `uun-I •g•y
,ilaia,)urS
'ITUD aseald a,)in zas iaq}jn;;o aq ue,) l;I
x1011%11 pa tuuad aq; ';o uopei;srutuipe pue 'IaAo uoipipsun[ 9uineq
I�JUagD atp m BuipxeAUo; zo; no,S o; p9pinoad aze ',iue;i 'so;ogd SuuiuedLuoaae pue .Ia:gal snly
•2uuanoo;ooz Ieug;o
uo[;e,)ildde of zoud panouiaz aq o; paau 111m sui;eo,) snly -apo,) ugisap Ie,)ol q;tni ,ildwoo PUL,ui
aseep
nn a,)npai XIueioduia; oa ;aaLls de,) aqI of piridde-ei Supq paniasgo sent gupeoo;ooi ajjq A y
.apo:) alge,)tldde q;jm ammildwoo u[ aq o; puno; pue papadsui semi uoisni;ui ia;em;uanaad o;
K,)ap;ep pue;oox padols;o uoipasza;ut le ;aags deo o; a9euzep atedax o; sampaooid pup sleuaptu
E.anoxdde;o
uoe,)gdd�;aas ,) snoutuiniq paugipow uo paddoue 1111m palle;sui ;aags aseq a pue
pane;suiuaaqseqIr;auiaqy ;isin;selipsen;iseuopipuoo
.mltuns e ui ,Cpsoui si;ooi aqy
repo; pa;oadsui sena anoge paypuap[ Sinplmq aq;;o;ooi aq; uo �Iiom ssai?ozd aq;;sanbaz mo,(;y
:azeH2O '-IN zeaQ
9�L£I-ii t ;tuuacl
'"13 'umaj4S 3[nJ 'IlaloS ny anua,�V OZSZ;e a,)uapisag azeH2O :aH
£sig££ 13 'uieailS JMD
IlaloS ny anuany OZgZ
aieH2O sizq'
5IOZ 'L ,faenue j
7Uo,T3 Uc� Un�aI�y; jJI :Puw-a
5Lsz-88L(8%) :xLd
9569<Z9 (m) :auoq�I
Ru-cuId'Suapmo weag �d
aue-I � £IZZ
9NIH3aNI0N�
I
ell
6119Z # '$aU -ld
J 'ISDd 'ad 'uun7 'g aouazzal
D-IVRd'uun,j •g•S
'6lazaouls
•ijea aseald a:)Luas jail}inj jo aq ueo I jj
•lion+ papluuad ail} ';o uor4sRnuipL, pue 'nano uorTpsun[ gucne4
douaSe all} o} Bu}pze,rouoj zoj nob of pap}nozd azr'XuL jl'so}ogd SULe Uedtu000r pue za}}al snlj,
.apo-.) ajgeoljdde Ljjjm aourllduioo uI aq o} punoj pue pa}oadsu} sem uoismqu! za}ent
}uanazd pue )pap }elj;o a2pa dup Ie}aur }e }aatls dra o} a�euiep zlydaz o} saznpao}e
ozd pue slelzatu
panozdde jo uol}eoilddy •}aags deo snounun}Iq pagipotu uo paddotu e Tim palle}sul }sags aseq r pue
pane}su} uaaq sett Ie}aui Dqj. •}}s}n }srI btu $uunp sect }} se uo}}}puoo zelltu}s a Ln Sl}souz s} jooz atlj
fepo} pa}oadstn sent anogr pacjyuapc Surpllnq aLp jo jooz ail} uo xzom ssai2ozd ail} }sanbaz znoA }y
:azeH2O •zjnl zeaCl
9i'iS£i-11 # }}uuad
'1d 'urnaz}S jlnO 'IcaloS ny anuany oZcZ }e aouaplsad azrH2O :aY
£S%££ 7d 'tuua4s Eng
IialoS ny anuany OZSZ
azeH2O suit'
SIOZ'9 SInf
ILO:`: uall!11� ie.^a1i?! :jletu-a
Sir 88L (888) :mei
cct9-<Z9 (199) :auoqd
SME -13 'suapzro goeag tined
aur? PZZ ila
ONI2 a3NIDN9)o
O
Lid
O
N
O
ti
0
4
6119Z 'IIad -Id
'Uun-I 'g aauazia,I,
11 'dd 'uunZ 'g'y
'AlazannS
Ilea aseaid aatAzas .Taq-jjnl Io aq up-.) I II
'xzO,ti pa}}TUTzad aLl; 'JO UOT4V gSTU"ne pue '.iano uopaipsimf $uinELi
AJua&E all; o; SuipmM.ToI zo; noA o; papino.Td ale 'Aur j! 'so;ogd guiAueduzoaaE pm zapaI silly
'apo-, alquxidde
Lpp,i aauuifduio-, ui aq o; punol pup pa;aadsui sem uoisn;ui za;e.vL aua,Lazd o; Iaap;ooz
padols puE ITEM aigE4lo uoi uoeuiep
zTEdaz o; sainpaaozd puE Sleiia;ELU
paAOzddE IO UO[}eaTiddy';aaliS dEa SnOURTIrijiq payipOlu LTO paddOlU E Lf;iM paliE;SLIT }aaLIS aSEq E puE
palle;sui uaaq smi IE;aui ai.0 ';IsiA ISE1 ALU 'uunp SPM II Se uopipuOa zelluns PUT fpsoui si Iooz ally
fEpo; pa;-,adSui Ur se,ti aAOge paypuapi 3uipfinq
ailjo Iooz alp uo )IzoAL ssazdozd all ;sanbaz znoA zad 'SLOZ '£ zaquiaaaCI pa;Ep osle aauapisaz
paauazalaz anoqu znoA SLnpzeaai noA o; zapal snoiAazd ALu o; do mollol E sE avzas flim .Tapal snly
:azEH,O 'IN zeaCI
9N4£I-11 s I!uuad
'Zd 'Lueaz;S 3fnJ 'I?aloS ny anua,LV OZSZ;e aauapisag azEH,O :aU
£sfi££ id 'uTeaz;S IInO
fialoS nV anuany OZSZ
amH2O SULD
6I OZ '£ zaquiaaaQ
l;i r,r00, I U t'! I d1 : jIELu-a
5LSZ-m (888) :xed
55 9 (IW) :auogJ
8 Li££ -L3 'suapTEo yaeag Lulea
aue'i MZL- £Ic:c
ONIH3,3NION9" 14`
ZIOZ `VI zaqtu,-moNjS6£V9 Id 'M as;.1r.M uagda;S
�1
suol;sanb
due angq pinogs noi(j! pea asuald •opo0 algeallddu pug LOOZ 3H3 0; 2ulpa033g
auop sem anoqu pagp3sap ilaom aq; ;gq; swaguoa uol;aadsul plag Pug'aa4aj slgy
•saSpo oq;;e naq; paalq dq aauapina sg;uawAH1.1apun
aq; o; paaagpg Mani sum ;legse;oq aql, •a•o sagaul ZI sligu xaldwlS q;lm palleu llagq
sum ql 06 aqL •auop osle sem ssajBoad ul dow;oq paw,Sgl lopun alljooi V •plag
aq; ul •a•o•ul ZT gn smog ow pug del puaq aq; ;e •a•o •ul 9 @v paauds aaam s2c;-up aq,I,
•apo0 alggalldde aad auop aaam sft-ul; waguoa o; ZTOZ `SZ;sn;InV uo pawaolaad
sum 'Jul maulgua •M •S Xq'ssoappu anoqu aq; ;e Soo i aq; )o uol;aadsul uV
ZTOZ `VT aagwanoN
�q-a
SOLO £VZ I9S
VVV££ UPl.1013'g3V0ff Sg.alaQ
anis p„ Z as OST
uol;r.lod.lo0 aagoog uopv quoD
9VTS£T-1T # Mulad
13 `wgaa;S SInJ
IIa0S nV aAV 09SZ :uoyeaorl qof
uol;aadsul doW;og'29; -ulZ :ag
lopuj0 Omppng :oLL
T9£6 OSV 195:aag30
£OV££ um -1013 'uo;eg eaog
ZTZ# •Pnlg smalPUV •;S SIZTZ
•ONI ONRIadNIONd •M •S
'DNI JNRI33NIJN3 'M 'S
£IOZ'OZ Slni S6£VS ad'Id aa;aum uayda;S
Kccr.;., �lk
•suol;sanb SUE ansq p!nogs noSj! pea asuald
•sopoD algsa!Iddu puu OIOZ Dg3 o; 3ulpaoaas auop SEM anoqu pa%osap ilaom agjL
';! aano
paddow;oy sum uawn;!q qI 06 ay; aao;aq'pawud uaq; pup •a•o „ b sI!eu jusys Su!a
V,, I y;!n+ pal!uu ssm aauap!saa anoqu ay;;u,Iooa;u!I ay; uo Is;aW a2pa di -la aqy
SOLO £1'Z 195
hhb££ up!.ao!g'yasag Ssala(l
aAV puZ as 08I
uo!;u.aodaoa 3a;3ooH :ao;aua4uo3
13 `wnaa;S31nO
I!a!oS nV anV OZSZ :uol;u3o7 qof
uoyaadsul Iu;aW 3oog :ag
Iu!a!IIO 2u!pI!ng :od,
19£6 OSB 19S :a39J0
£Oti££ epuo13 'uo;s2l sang
ZIZ# 'pn!g senaapuV 'aS 81ZIZ
£IOZ `OZ Slur *aKi OmivaaAI oma 'M 's
'ONI JNN33NI9N3 'M'S
£IOZ `iZ "Int
OOI$......................• uo!;aadsul lupw joog 1913
13 `wean;S 31n0
ItaoS nV aAV 099Z :uo!;saoZ Qof
uopaadsul Iu;aye ;ooll :all
SOLO £hZ I95
hhh££ up!aoIA `gauag sua!aQ
aAV pj IIS 081
uol;smodao0 aa;3oog :0j,
I9£6 OSP 199 :93330
££h££ up!ao13 'uo;ug sang
ZIZ# 'PAIS sAaapUV IS 81ZIZ
'DTII f)NrHaaNlIf)Na'M'S :W0213
£IIZLO # aaionul
IIDIOAKII
ONI 9NR133NIDN3
£TOZ `TZ finf .layl uagdalS
OOi$....................... uollaadsulIRON PON 1131A
13 `wua.>i1S 3in0
llaoS nV 3AV 09SZ :uollaaorl qor
uolloadsul JuPl i PON -ag
SOLO £bZ 19S
thD££ 13PPOIA gaE39 "alaQ
OAV p,z AS 081
uoilsaodao0 aalioog :O.L
TM OSB T99 :93li3O
££b££ UP11013 'uoleg sang
ZTZ# 'PMS sA+a.lpuY •1S 8TZTZ
DISI Ol\luaaNIIOAia'M'S :L ONA
£iiZLO # a310Aul
33I0ANI
'SNI 9NN33NI9N3
3HVHo SH30'lIHO A3-i-i3HS / 3HVH0 'd H3Hd0lSlblH3
- 121:1900490:1 .1106SE00.11
0 SHV -1100
v
GbCoj $ -2NII�IV��I 3H0
L 1, %"
OL9B49-E9
0690 VN'NNVB VIAOHOVM
£84££ 1=i 'WvBuis =nno
Oki 31001W 0£S
28VHO SH3allHO A3-11
31iVH0 'rl li3Hd0lSWl
woo lasannnnnnp:dllq
AllJnoaS lJewS 13S3 Aq pa�oayo seen a6essaw a41
(OZLO l l OZ)
L LEg asegelep aJnleu6ls snJln to uOISJaA '/lunoaS lJewS 13S3 woJl uopewJolul
a3d00a-6-LL9 :89JA Ilol OE09-EbZ-L99 :d 90LO-EtiZ-L99:0
SJNIAVS lOH SdOOU 1000 011 'oaUooa Rq looa lJewS
oul 'luawa6euelN R 6ulllnsuo0 oallooa
9LVZE0000 'ON 95U9011 'uolleJodJoO oe400a
Aaneallnw .r ugor 'spJe6aa
LZOL-9LZ-ZLL :1190 -suollsenb (ue aneq no/ b! aw IleO
luawAelJapun alp uawnllq paglpow aql Jol luawgoelle loeJluoO o1 wnpueppV aes aseald
WV 9L:91e LLOZ'LZ Inf 'n41
<woo•llew6@o p6auld> o o
'su40 6ulwoW poo0
woo-llew60p6auld :o1
woo dJ000allooJ@o ugor :o1-lldaa
<woo,dJ000allooJ@ugol> ugol
weeilsllnE) OZBZ - loo21
Azll
aop•aJeH2O s1J4O - lOVH.LNOO Ol Wn4N34OV
woO lasaMMMp:dllq
(lunoaS liewS 1353 Aq papap seen e6essaw a41
ZlE9 asegelep ainleu6ls snjln;o uolsJan 'AilmoeS IJewS 1353 wog; uollewJoJul
Wb' OZ:B le 6loz ' LZ Inf 'n41
<woo•Ifew6@o p6aufd> o o
(2L06LOZ)
AaneallnW ugof
luaw4oe6e 9ql s,alaH '1e43 inoge tijoS
'su4O
woo llew6@@p6auld :01
woo -dj000alyooj@@ugof ol-Llda2j
<woo,dj000e400a@@ugo6 u4of
(joa)gns ou)
woo;asam mm//:duq
L;unoaS jjewS 1353 Lq peNoago seen e6essaw aql
(9Z8o l wz)
8oti9 asege;ep ain;eu6!s snj!n Jo uo!sJan 'l;unoaS PewS 1353 w01; uo!;ewJOJul
FaneallnW -r ugor 'spie6am
's;soo apes o; Aenm jaq;oue ap!nad ll!M s!ql ;oa ay; 6u!;u!ed 6uuap!suoo aje no ( aou!s el!;;uawao
a;!qM g6naq;aoloo sq; }o nail u! al!; /,eA lem;eu jo;;soo a;ewa;le ue ap!noid o; Bu loo osle we 1
-Repo; sa6pu pue sd!q paja;!w
pue alp jape;s unq No!y; q;!nm alg P199 .6 leuol;!peJ; a Jo; uo!s!naJ nmau a no/ puas II!M I sal!l looH
„6 'An8 Nolgl Ilb„ jo; s! lesodad pas!naJ q;9�;sn6nV aq; uo q'8 S sjagwnu a;ewa;lV 6uojm seen I
WV L0:6 ]e L 60Z '9Z 6nV 'nql
sugO !H
woo-pew6@7pbau!d :ol
woo,dj000auooj@@ugor :ol-Fldaa
<woo,dj000auooj@ugol> ugol
leiognd and OZBZ
'leaµ]', IQ
<wo3•llew6@n p6awd> o o
Noti
ooP'=IHN PazIuenle6-E)HS
woo'las@r mm//:dllg
llunoes >JewS 13S3 Aq p@Noago sero a6essaw ag1
(9Z80660Z)
£ l49 esegelep amleubs sniln;o uoisJan 'AlunoaS 3JewS 13S3 wa; uoilewJo;ul
Nd LEZle IIOZ'9Z 6ny'ud
<woo•llew6@@p6auld> o o
AaneapnLq pugop'spje6eH
luawgoeue 'lesodojd;ooi laajlS sel6noa aas aseald
'sugo
woo,pew6@o p6auld :o1
woo-dj000auoo. @@ugop :o1-(ldaa
<woo'dj000agooj ugof> uyof
=100M -;aaj;S sei6nod SZ
Hr_WIL-1-1
woo;asanvnnn//:d;;y
A;unoeS pewS 1353 Aq peNoego seen a6essew ayl
i9Z90LLOZ)
E lb9 asege;ep ain;eu6is sniin;o uoisJan '/;unoeS uewS 13S3 woj; uogewjo;ul
Rane911n!n! ugor'spje6aa
-sai;!unpoddo
piq iay;o asay; pue;ooi inoR uo sanIesmo anad o; Apnlioddo ay; jo; yonw tian noF sNueyl
-suoi;senb
Aue aney nog(;i aw Ileo pue;uawpe;;e lesodoid;oa '-pne-! 13 'anuany 41g; 3N aas aseald
Wd LO:E le IIOZ'9Z6nH'p3
<woo•!!ew6@@p6awd> o a
'sugC) !H
woo-j!ew6@o p6auid :ol
woo'di000auoa@@ugo!' :ol-lIdaa
<woo-dj000auoa@@ugo!> uyo!
X00N - alepjapne'lpo.1 °anuand 9� 3N
00'E96'£l$ ppH :a;!qm y6nojy;-joloo (ung �ol41 IIH) si;uellb' „1X,.6 'lejog <O
00'ZOZ'£ l$ ppb' :a;!qm y6na4l-joloo (line Nol41 Ilb') epnwj@G „ti/£X„6 'eJ6a;u3 <g
00'OL6'9Z$ :@NM Ass016 JIb' lag ,£ l 'ai6e3 <y
.uolsloap
moA o; 6uipj000e;oej;uoo ay; aun; aug il!M ! passnosip suoi;do;ooi lie }o Ajewwns a sl aJaH
'SPLIO 0118H
tiewwnS;so33oob ::pafgnS
,woo llewOi p6auld, :ol
Wd 9T:g TTOZ 19Z4sn6ny'Aepuj quaS
[woo dj000auoo guyof:o;!!ew] uyof :wojd
NHOf
'MO -139 33S 'Mgil d0 31dnoo d lOJaOd I isd000
'SlHHO IH
woo•pew6@')p6auid :ol
woo*dj000auooj uyor :ol-Aidan
INV £4 9 le 6I OZ '9Z 6ny 'u3 <woo dj000auoojguyof> ugof
NOISIA3N - tiewwnS;so3;oob :M.1
a;,Kxr�!a
<woo•pew6@@p6aufd> o o I
•
woo 'lase -Mnnnn//: dl}q
,1!.mooS veU1S IFISg Xq pgoago sung a8essaw aq L
(9Z80I IOZ) ZIb9
asege;ep am;eu;9is sniin30 uois13n `XI!JnoaS 11GUJS LESS Ln04 u0i;euuo3ul
SEJNIAVS -LOH SgOOa 1000 oauoob tq Iooa uewS
-oul ';uawa6eueyq g 6ul;lnsuoo oauooa
uopiodJoO oauooa
IZOI-92-ZLL :O
(aneallnyq -r ugor 'spJe6aa
uogdo Jag;oue;o A uiq; no/;I Jo suoi;senb AUe aneq no ( lI aw ileo 01994 lea; aseald
6ulgsel; Jaddoo eouno 94 Jo) 00'L00'Z +
1aagS
de0puaw felJapuN au jooa aueJgwaW uawn;18 pag poIN SW0 pea;ulelia0 Jo} 00'L£0'Z$ +
al!1 a6pla S dIH 1n3-J9;!W Jo) 00'009$ +
(00' L6Z'8Z$ :AeJEJ) 00'9L9'8Z$ :a;lgnn g6naq;-Joloo sl;ueIIV „lX„6 'IeJoB <88
(00'£6£'LZ$ :/eJEJ) 00'9WLZ$ :a;lgnn g6naq;-Joloo epnwa8 „til£X„6 'eJ6a;u3 <yy
NNE �4
;pd•!esodoJd aJeH2O
woo lasammm//:dl;y
'Alunoas liewS 1353 A9 peNoayo sero a6essaw ayl
(9Z90660Z)
£ 449 asegelep amleu6is snu!n;o uo!sJan ' (lunoaS )rewS 1353 wog} uo!lewjo;ul
Wd 91.:Zi le IIOZ'9Z 6nH'!jd
<woo•pew6@p69wd> o o
Raneal!nyy uyor'spie6aa
luawyoelle ayl lab lou p!p no (l! mouN aw lal aseald
's!j4O !H
woo-l!ew6@@p6au!d :ol
woo dj0009400j uyor :ol-/idaa
<W03-dj000a)jooj@@ugo.[> uyof
3agooa - IesodoJd PON
BIZ£
oop•Z abed - aJeH.O
woo lasammm//:dlly
/lunoeS liewS 13S3 Aq pa�oayo sem a6essaw ayl
6149 asegelep ainleu6ls snnn to uolsJan '/lunoaS liewS 1353 wal uogewjolul
VW K:L le l M '6Z 6ny 'uoW
<woo•pew6@o p6auld> o o
(6Z90LLOZ)
IZOI-91Z-ZLL ugof
aw IleO
luawgoelle aes
LOZ-9£-9Z-OZ lnoge moH
suyo 6ulwon pooO
woo Ilew6@7p6auld :ol
woo-dj000auooj@o uyof :ol-XIdaa
<woo*dj000auooj@o uyof> uyof
(;oafgns ou)
[nppiy Ixol palono]
slJgz)
Z asegd pus 6 asegd uaanµaq polled
owl; aq; Jo; uol;ej;igw Ja;enn Joulw Niue g;Inn pawaouoo;ou we I
uol;aldwoo;e %OZ
;oa uo 6ulpeol lepa;ew;e %9Z
dow;oy;e %OZ
Z asegd
ja;el sNaaM y
;sags dlls q;!M u! -tip is %SZ
;uawaouawwoo Is %06
I asegd
:alnpagos;uawAed bulMollo; ag;;noge MOH
'saM g31M
;ooi aq; peol pus dow;oq ueo nog( ja;el sNaem q;nogy -/luo 6e; up
pus q10£ qi!M ul tip pue;oa 6ul;slxa ag; anowaJ I!IM no ( 'alnpagos
eq; eas I /em, agl dow;oq pus lenow91;oa eq; q;IM saseqd ON aq;
seuigwoo alnpagos pasodad moR;nq sesegd Z ul aq II!M qof eq; ;eq;
S! waouoo AIW elnpegos;uawAsd alge;lnba us Ino NJoM ueo am Sins we I
Wd £4:6;e L WZ '6Z 6ny 'uoW
'ugof
woodi000auoa@')ugor :ol
<woo,llew6@o p6auld> o o
(pefgns ou)
FWD<woo•llew6@o p6auld> o o
woo Iasammm//:dlly
(IunoaS liewS 1353 Lq papap sem a6essaw a41
(L0604 wz)
g77g aseqelep ainleu6ls sniln to uolsJan ' (lunoaS lJewS 13S3 woal uo!lewio;u!
/aneallnW u4of
spiebad
'wJguoo aseald
-> oeq 6ulpls jo/pue poom mau a4I Ind (94I alolaq seaie aso4l 4seg-aa ueo am le4l os Ino sl l! ua4m
aw fl!lou aneal I!94I Ie4I 6ulpls pua-elge6 pue elosel a4I a6ue4o aldoad jno ( ua4m le4l puawwooaj
I •ooI peAeoep si elosel alge6 a41 •asn-ai puoAeq palejoualep se4 lelaw pezluenle6 041 1841 pue
lelaw p9zluenle6 pue jaddoo;o ajnlxlw a s! 6u!4seg llem, pue-alge6 94I legl peu!wialep uaaq se4 Il
Wd 87 Z le l WZ 'L daS 'paM
's1J40 !H
woo•llew6Op69uld :ol
woo•dj0009400j@u4op :ol-(ldaa
<woo•dj000agooj@o u4of> u401
OZSZ-1008
<woo•pew6@o p6au!d> o o
n
woo jasanvmy:d;34
RlunoaS )JEWS 1353 Aq peHoago seen 96essaw a41
(uO L L LOZ)
6£99 asege;ep ainaeu6ls snjln;o uolsJan ' jpnoaS )JewS 1983 wa; uolaewjo;ul
oa1Joo8
AaneallnW ugof
Zsn jol (peaj noA ajV
's!J40 0119H
<w03'llew5@@pB9uld> o o :01
woo-dJ033aUow@7uyop :o1-/ld98
WV 9q:L le L LOZ'EL 30O 'nql <woo-dj000auoa�o ugof> uyot
1OOJ
<woo•l!ew6@@p6euld> o 0
Iuappl4 lxal polonp]
ML -05£
aJeH.O su40
-9ou9ja.4]p eoud a41 mous] aw lal aseald 'lejew of 9111
a]aJouoo woJ1 aouep 01 luem pue sanss] lemlonils awns 9ne4 9M •;oa
jell 941 dow 1o4 pue ul tip of Apew 6ulaq of asolo 6ullla6 aie aM
'u4of
woo di0009Uooi@u4or :ol
INVvv: L L 1e 1 wz '9Z 100 'Pam <woo llew6@@p6auld> o o
J00M
ms(xxvv)Aq
<woo•11ew6@o p6au]d> o o Ria
r 0
[uappiq jxa) palonp]
sug0
Z;uawAeliapun awes ay; asn am ue0 Z;ow lelaw /lpenb
g61q a o; qo;loos of aq lsoo ejlxe ay; pinom legm 'a114mue9lnl 11 le Tool of aJadxa ue;96 of 6u1o6 we I
-paluem
11egl Mool alRls plo aq; 9�]1 alp gnq No]gl agl gllM 06 1 l] WOW uana — aienbs jad sq1 OOZ 4 lnoge
si Ile;sul of;uem I all; a;ajouoo aql an6llel to su6ls 6ulmogs sem awed loos aql sieedde;I lg6lam ley;
le uana 'ajenbs jad sq1 OB4lnoge sg6lam ll alelnoleo 1 pue eoa]d a pag6lam I -alp pedegs iajjeq Belo
idyl sem loa eql llo uaNe; sem;eg; alp agl loa aql to A;loedeo 6uueaq peol agl jol pawaouoo we 1
'ugof
woo dj000allooj ugor :ol
WV 9V 61e 6 WZ 'LZ 100 'ngl <woo-llew6@@p69uld> o o
loom
�lt�.K,baa
<woo•11ew6@@p6auld> o o
woo lasammm//:dllg
Al!jnoeS liewS 13S3 Aq pa�oago seen abessew a41
(8Z011l z)
y899 asegelep ainleu6ls snnn to uoiSJan 'RlimoeS liewS 13S3 wwl uo!lewolul
taneallnW ugof
• (epuofry uo ql!M Xoeq pago 11,1 'PUS �aann 801u a aneH
WOO'OUI}J2j6U8'MMM Ino Moeg0 -4uejjeM a gl!nn sawoo legl auo pue laued loos wnu!wnle
Ile a yl!m o6 am legl puawwooai 1 •6ullsnu aie Fay1,ueaoo aql pue Aervualenn lelseooeip eql of
fi4!w!xojd asolo inoA of anp sauaS uews4ej0 / !eels (ue wou Aenne Aels pinonn 1 IgBnogl puooas u0
Ad VE Z Ie L lOZ '8Z 300 '!1d
'su40 !H
<woo*l!ew6@p69uld> o o :o1
woo•dj000auoou@ugop :ol-Fldaa
<woo•di000auooi@o ugof> uyof
Sloom f ejaw
a! woe
<wo0•l!ew6@n p6au!d> o a I' a�
Nd L9:Z le 4 WZ '8Z 100 '!Jd
<woo•[[ew6@@p6awd> o 0
[Uapp!41xa1 palon0l
ssan6 ! sgof;ooi onl jay;o ay; uo;! asn p!nn ! a6pa dup jaddoo
ay; jo; Aed o; aney !;! 6;uawAspapun ay; japun 6u!ysep Ra!!eA
jaddoo asn no/;,up!nonn;nq s!e;aw jepw!s-sip u!of;,ueo no/ MouX !
a!gel!ene jaweq !ewjay; Aue pue adA;;uawAepapun ay; 'a!ge!!ene
a6ne6;sa!neaq ay; gojeasaj o; peau ! -a;!qm pa;u!ed squ 6wuag!;s
pue s!aued ap!M „8; y;!M weas 6u!pue;s „g,; jo; 6u!�oo! we !
'u4of
woo-dj000a800j@o ugop :ol
<woo-!!ew6@@p69u!d> o o
1OON
woo•;as9mmm//:dg4
l!jnoeS liewS 1353 Aq peNoago sem e6essew a41
HOZ moz)
ZW9 asege;ep ain;eu6!s snjm;o uoisJan 'AunoeS }jewS 1363 woj; uo!;ewjo;u!
/aneGlInW uyop 'spie6ay
Lweal;s;jnE) pue;oa o; 4;im;se;el a4; s!;e4M
's!J40 !H
<woo iewb@Dp6eu!d> o o :01
Ad ho Zl ae ZIOZ 'OZ uer 'ud <woo dj000e400j�u4o.6 AaneapnW uyop
031=Iooa
<woo•!!ew6@')p6au!d> o 3'
[uappiy pal palonp]
ajeH 0 su40
loos je;aw ay; jo} saiinbai weaj;s}ln0;ey; jaual
s,Jaaui6u9 ay; aneq I -NaaM;xau Aq Nionn;p;os /w y;inn auop aq osle pini ;ey; m4e;iwjad;ooi je;aw
pasinaJ ay; jo; Aldde o; aNp p1nonn Naam;xau;iwiad mopuinn a pue Aennanup a jop 6uiAldde we ]
Wd X17 le UOZ'OZ uep'ud
'u4of
<woo dj000auooj uyof> AaneallnW uyop :ol
<woo-jiew6@o p6awd> o o
03130021
<wo3•pew6@n p6au]d> o o�
_ y
woo lasemmm//:dllq
'A}unaaS laewS i 3S3 Aq pa: oep send a6essew eqi
g Lgg aseggep ain;eu6is sniin Jo uoisJan 'A#unoaS pwuS 1353 wojl uogewjojul
Ad Lb:V Ie ZLOZ 'OZ uef 'p j
<woo•llew6@o p6auid> o o
(OZLOZLOZ)
juapplq 1%al palonol
J31400,d :aa :}oafgng
AanealinW ugor :ol
Wd LE:b ZTOZ'OZ Menue['Aepu3 quag
[woo jiew6@Dp69uid:oapew] o u :woa3
uqor
pua>t99h%JeaJ6 a aneH do-speaq aqj job quagj
'su40
<woo jiew6po p6auid> o o :ol
<woo'dj000auooj uyof> AaneallnW ugop
031-AOON
suyo
sseoaad jenadde ay; uo palepdn noR da@N Ipm
6 -6Z-L� uo uoiloadsui
>loap leg pue 6 �-9-6 uo uogoadsui 6uiyleags a .ioj ldiaoaj a sweluoo;I adolanua liwjad aql aneq
WV 96 L le Z6OZ '9Z qac 'leS
'ugop
weailS linE) ui 1!elos nV anuanV OZ9Z :aa
<woo dj000al}ow@@ugop> AaAealinvy uyop :ol
<woo jiew6@7p6auid> o o
100J BJeLIO
<wo3•pew6@@p6awd> o o
s
woo';asammml/:d;;y
LwnoeS uewS i2S9 Lq p@Aoayo sem 96essaw ayl
(LZZOZLOZ)
6 L69 esege;ep ain;eu6is sniin;o uoisJan 'RfunoeS ;uewS 1SS3 wa; uogewo;ul
hiopp!4 Jxai pa:onol
joa ajego ::pafgng
AaneallnW uyof :ol
WV LI:L ZTOZ 'SZ tienjga� 'Aepm;eS :;ua5
[woo pew6@o p6auid:oajiew] o o :woij
uyor
s�uegj
<woo liew6@o p6auid> o o :ol
WH L9:O L le ZLOZ 'LZ qaj 'uoW <woo,dj000a;}oa@o ugof> tanealinW uyop
1001 aleyo
<woo•ffew6@o p6auid> o o P
ajeH2O su4O
'spjebaj;sag
wly o; Meads o; peau I 'lleq;oo;
e6alloo 6ulleld s1 uos asoyM Anb ay; 'josiniadns plag ino f;o aweu ay; aw Iia; no/ p1noo 'osly
Ganey Aew Aay;
ain;eja;Il /ue pue saldwes asay; jo; Al;oajlp IJai6u3;0e;uoo I pinoyS 'lulys 6uiy; (ue joyge tay; plo;
uaaq aney I se 6w;9aw ay; o; Loud a;IyM;eg a;l;uled o; peau Aew I -uogenlena Jiay; Jo; uolsslwwoo
ay; o;;uasajd ueo I;ey; lelja;ew;ooi paw ay;;o eoald a y;IM aw apinad ueo no/ alglssod;l sl
6uly;li9n940 saldoo aldl;lnw apinoid o; pa;oni;sul uaaq aney I pue
y;uow;xeu eq ll!m leadde ayl uolsslwwoo ay; o; uolsloap siaysejyl 'jW 6ulleadde we 1 'pa;aldwoo
;snf noA;ooi asoyM Ja;ad jogy6lau (w;o aolnpe ay; uo paseg le;aw o; leua;ew bugooi ino eOueyo
o;;senbai mo pa;oafai sey jaysejyl j6w uMol;ey; sl;se;el ayl qof sly; uo eoual;ed Ino ( jo; sNueyl
Wd 90 l L ae Z IOZ '£ l 12W 'anl
<wo3•pew6@o p6auld> o 3
'u4of
<woo -dj000@400j@ uyor> /aneallnIN uyor :ol
<woo llew6@o p6auld> o o
wean;s;jn6 `jow ajeyp
(uaPP:P axil P?IPnpf
:alarm <woo dj000el}oa§o ugof> ugof 'Nd 90:£ le l lOZ '96 AoN 'ani uO
suy0
64191 jagwanoN uo no!
of esuodsai si4 uMop alpm jo /peqJan no ( pal jagsejgl jN pia 6molaq Iiewe aql jagwewal not op
loa jelaw aql to aldwes eql 9ne4 not ua4M mou> aw la'i aw papewe noR olui eql jol sNue41
'u4of,
woo dj000e4oa@o ugor :ol
Nd £Z4 le MZ 146 JeN 'paM <woo-jiew6@n p6auid> o o
i131OS nv 3nN3AV - 30021
<woo•pew6@o p6aufd> o o
a �""
aJeH2O su4O
spieftjsag
Ljagwnu euogd sly aneq I ueO ';eq;
3noge ajow awos wlq of Nlel oa ajll pinoM I u1 396 of 6ul;uem uew pew a aNll joop Aw uo 6ui6ueq
seen pue asnoq Aw Aq awed (ablj /aweg joj cogs) Aaweg Ileo (aql uewaollod aq; aw plo; pue (;@ails
eq3 ssaoe jooi llauuag eql uo 6uhlioM seen aq) awoq tw le eq; aw pegoeoidde joslniadns mo k
'ugof
<woo dj000a)jooj@o ugOr> Aaneallnw ugop :ol
WV [O:L le Z WZ 14 JeW 'an 1 <woo-pew6@o p6auld> o o
we9n;s;jn6 `;ow ajeyp
<woo•Ilew6r]o p6auld> o o�
woo lasammm//:dlly
tlunoaS IJewS 1353 Lq palloayo sem e6essaw ay1
(4l£OZIOZ)
9969 esegelep ainleu6ls sni!n Jo uo!sJan 'AlunoeS liewS 13S3 wojl uollewio;ul
WV OIL le ZIOZ 14I JeW 'PGM
[uappiy jxaj paiono]
weaalsj[n6'jooi ajeyp ::pafgng
AaneallnW uyor :ol
Wd 90:TT ZTOZ'£T 4»eW 'Aepsanl quag
[woo pew6io p6awd:oa]]ew] o o :wou.1
/aneallnW ugof
6ZOI-S IZ-ZLL 'luapualuuadns play Aw si sweH weS
laued boa }ja16u3 ayl jo aldwes no ( la6 !l,l
'su43 !H
<woo l!ew6@@p6auld> o o :o1
<woo dj000a0oojpo uyof> Aanea[lnw uyor
weeilslin6 `;ow ejeyo
<woo ]lew6@p6auld> o a v
woo•;asammm//:duy
'A;unoes 11ewS 13S3 Aq paMoago sem a6essaw e41
(L1ti0Z10Z)
190L asege;ep am;eu6ls snJ!n;o uo!sJan 'A;unoaS pews 13S3 wa} uopewio;u!
AanealInn ugop'spje6ay
'aslnpe aseald
(•ule6e uol;oadsul le;aw
;ow a lleo-91 o; aneq;ou pue uoyoadsui ay; ssed p!m am ;eq; Ala�!I osle s! ;I (00'091$ eq
ll!m le;ew Aalien pue le;aw anea p9zluenle6 ay; 6wpieoslp jo; ssol;o enlen rook) -wa;sAs;oa
uasogo a q;lm payloads se eoeldaj pue le;aw Aallen pue le;ew anea p9zluenle6 ay; pjeoslp
ll!m am wa;sAs;oa jaq;oue q;lm paeoad o; aneq pue;oa le;aw ay; papieme;ou aie noA;I
•le;aw
anea pue u!-Aap 6ul;slx9 9y;19no;g6u le;aw anea pue;uawAeljapun paiagpe;las lia16u3 ay;
6u!lle1sul Aq peaoad ueo am peagy-oE) wa;sAS;ooa le;aW yal6u3 ay; pepieme aie noA dl
(LZE'Z$ :enlLA) uwjed moA uo os jo sq;uow 9 iaq;oue ule6 pue uoylpuoo jg61l-ja;em
e o; jasolo noA;a6 o; le;aw pezluenie6 q;lm jooj ay; lelaw pue 6ul;slxa ay; ;o do; uo 'ql 06 jay;oue
ul-k(i o; s! uo!lepuawwooai AW-(sq;uow L) do peup Auaid s400l;! pue Aepia;seA I= ay; peNlem I
WH" 11 le Z10Z'L1 jdv'enl
<woo•l!ew6@@p6au!d> o o
's1Jg0 ollaH
<woo pew6@7p6ewd> o o :o1
<woo-dj000auoa@ugof> AaneallnW ugop
uoi;oadsul ul fu(]
41oN}I flOA 131
Ill '31fIQ3HJS SX33M .LY3N 01M C)D 71L 11.LfIS AVC[ .LVHM MIS .LOFT
INV l aur zo; pooS sl �aam lxau atop CuV -ltcm snp Sulop Pq JJL'n no,C ,Cep agl mou)l oui la -1
'NOJ1.J31ANd'IV OI.LIQQV GOOD 78 Q'If10,`\ CIN3 31SVD IIOV3 2H3AO
dZIVI V *DNIHSV'Id AIMIOJIAE i. S V (JNhgOO1Id2I3.LVM 011IV L3Q 32IOW
H.LIM) 32I3HL NI TILLS SI .LVH1, DNIHSV'IJ C10 714.E 7Sf1 O'L NV1d 3M •PPAOU aS
,Cltsuo sI sip;m olqug oql uo poom,Cld P T 1,sllen+ alquS Pip aapun Butgsep aq osle noX II?M
"IV1.31l 3AV3 .L2I7'10N3
71-I1 AS Q31V70NOJ A13..L31GHNOJ 3f11 IIM QNV ZxZ 3S 11IM 1V.L3W
3AV3 3H.L •POo2 ,itan yool of 2utoS sl o2pa dup lqp aql ams lou um I •lulaut AS agl
oplg of aoRmI XIJulluelsgns aq 1pm anus laal2ug agl pue „£ �q „£ sJ Iulaui anea n2 agl aumsse
I ;loot atp Ielaw pue ut-fap of Iesodotd mo,C tpIm paaooid aseald •aleunlsa agl JOJ S*ME L
WV 09:L12 ZIOZ'9l jdy'paM
`ugof
uopoadsuI uT /j(] :aa ::paCgng
daneallnW ugoc :o.L
Wd bE:6 ZTOZ'LT lljdV'Aepsanl:Iuag
[woo-ilew6@@p69uid:o4pew] o o :woad
<woo jlew6q p6auid> o o :ol
<woo•dj000e400j@ugof> (aneallnW ugor
uoll3odsul ul /Cad
<woa•llew6@n p6auld> o o ��
woo'jasanwwy/:dUq
/gijnoaS jjewS 1353 Lq paXoego seen 96essaw eql
(n9moZ)
6ZZL asegeaep am;eu6is snjln 10 uolsJan '7qunoeS pewS 13S3 woj; uogewjolul
/,snjeas gof;salel ag; sl aegM
'spg3 ollaH
<woo-jlew6@p69uld> o o :ol
WH Lh 6 le ZLoZ '9L ung 'uolN <woo•dj000agooj@ugof> 6aneapnW uyop
0310021
<woo•jlew6@@p6auld> o o
woo-;asem vin//:duq
!I maaS uniuS .L3Sj Xq paxaaga sena agussam atU
(LltOZIOZ) I9OL
asuqulup a.mleu9is snits JO uo[saaA `rilianaaS ;leuiS ZgSg woij uopmuojul
Al IA '3lim NHOf '1S�19
*DMHI WAO OC HAl2IgLIV AVQ'Ifll NO[IJ7dSN1 NV Wd 11V311M I ZI-6
-s lnoge sI (uozleirdxa ltuuad) jalul SX19P 08I 081 -11 -OC -1 I uo sans qof snp uo uotloodsul lsel ag,l,
luoppl4 lzal pa3onD)
SIJU3
„mou jol 06 ou„ si snlels 'umol a43 AR ueay jo e6ueyo a jo leedde leyl 6uipued
-slJnoo ayl ylwn leadde ue p91il aney I pus tool ie12w a jo} leadde Aw peloafai Allewiol sey uMol
u4of
<woo'dj000auooj@o uyof> AaneapnW uyop :ol
Wd 9VZIs Z60Z'6L unr'enl <woo-jiew6&6auid> o o
331-AOON
/ -j�w
)
<woo•jiew61p6auid> o 9 1 [at)
•
aieH2O su4O
spJe6aj;sag
-dla4 penuiluoo inoR jol sNue4l
WOO s,umo,i 941 ui 96en6uel piemiol;46leils a4l u9n16 euilna
uaaq 9ne4 pinogs;e416ui4;awos jol jjonn 1euoi;ippe s1gl Ile 46na4; 06 of pe4 an,no I tijos we I
junoo a;elladdy a4; Aq 6uipug algeJone; a 6uipued
Aejlaa o; uo ssed o; umol a4l jol Apeai Aleleipawwt aq pim a6eNoed uoismM liuuad a4l os loos
000Z S pal6u3 eql jol ;uawnoop „Ienoiddy lonpoid„ i94;oue aw;a6 pinoo nob;i;1 a;eloaidde pinom 1
'uopeoiidde si4l sseoad o; 4oeae Rejlap jol pa.nnbaa
;uawnoop „Ienaddy lonpad„ epuoid to ale;S a4l 4lim sn apinoid lou pip Aeqj;nq 'peu6is noR
luawnoop Janoo 941 4lim sn paidoo se4 umol a4l •/doo a 9ne4 lou op no ( '4ons se pue 'sluawnoop
uoileoildde aq Ile lde� uagl umol aql le4l puelsiapun I moN -weeds jInO ui pamolle aiam s;ooi
lelaw ou ley; eueid 6uillal ui wJq ja4lej sem gels umol a4l ley; not wa; jea4 of pasudms lou we 1
•le;aw of alil alaouoo woll liwad;oa Aw 6uisin9J jol jagwanoN lseI
weai3S IInJ to umol a4; o; pal;iwgns eueip uoileoildde 94; 6uipje6ai Aepol aw 6uiileo jol sNue4l
u4or
INd OZ:C le Z lOZ 'Z 6nH 'n41
<woo dj000auooj u4or> taneallnW u4or :ol
<woo•Iiew6ap69uid> o o
weal;g;jn!D-}ooj ejeyo
<wo3•11ew6@o p6auid> o o
:a;aM <woo-dj000auooj�ugof> RaneellnW u4of 'INV L4:6 le Z60Z '8l unf 'uoW uO
su4O
,quegj
Ienadde s,uMo; ay; jol uol;eiedaid w slinoo
ay; o; uol;eolldde 4L jagwanoN ay;;o Adoo e;lwgns use I os soads pue VON ay; se yons;sanbai
uolslnaj sly; q;IM;Iwgns Allewjou pinoM no ( uol;e;uawnoop J9n91e4M aw;a6 aseeld no/ pinoO
'way; w04 algellene eq jebuol ou
Aew;l pawaouoo we I;nq uol;ewjo;ul sly; seq uMo; ayl 'a;IgAA euoe uI wa;s fs }oa OOOZ-S ual6u3
ay; Jo; aw ane6 no/ soads ay; y;IM ; L OZ 8 L noN apew uol;eolldde moR;o (doo a no/ pexe;;snf I
WV 64: L L 1e Z60Z 'Z 6nV 'n41
'u4of
<woo dj000e400i@7ugof> A9AL9jjnVV uyof• :ol
<woo•llew6@o p6auld> o o
03130021
<woo•I;ew6@p6auld> o o I I
AaneallnW -p ugop
'Alajaoulg
:ale( — : pa}daooy
00'006'C$
-sugap Ile Aeme Ine4 pue do ueelo '9 '9
;aa; ajenbs 00 L jad -sql 9Z -OZ bo a;ej a;e
;legdse apej6 daa;s 6ulsn;oa pedols o; (.iaweg ja;eM tiejodwal);aags eseq ql eq -L dow;oH -y
:ol jogel pue slepa;ew Ile Alddns of sasodad uol;ejodjo0 oal}oob
'aJeH2O su4O
<woo llew6op6auld> o o :ol
Wd 9L:L le ZLOZ'ZZ 6ny'paM <woo'dj000eUooj uyof> AanealfnW uyor
eppof_q `weaj4sjlnE) `l!eognd and OZSZ =Iddtf
<woo•pew6@n p6ould> o o
•
ajeH O su40
'sNueyl
idlaoaj sioloadsul ayl yl!m ew Adoo aseeld
'eoueyo a lab nog( uayM -awoy Aw jo �oap leld ay:, uo ,penisul 96pe dup lelaw ayl 6ul11a6 jol sNueyl
Ad ":U le £WZ'9L Inf'uoW
<woo•llew6@@p6auld> o 3
uyor
woo dj000a400jguyor :ol
<woo-pew6pp6euld> o 0
JOOJ aJBH,O
C6/q!-//o :ale(] aseala?
luapoi41xe1 Palond
SINO
awl;;sel @>!j isnf uol;oadsul sly jo; jaaul6ua ay; Aed Ipm 1 ;ool sly; uo 6ulssai6oid paapul
si Niom;et'; lelol};o 6uipllnq ay; mot's ueo I /gem slyl Z (epuow uo joa;elj ay; uo Ile;sul noA mes ay
a6pe 1e;aw ay; L41aJao osle o; ssai6ad ul dow lop ay; pa;oadsul;sel oqm jaeul6ue ay; Nse noR pinoo
'ugof
<woo dj0009400j@a ugof> taneallnW ugop :ol
WV h£ L L le £LOZ 'LL Inf 'paM <woo 11ew6Oa p6auld> o 0
;ooJ a-IeH2O
<woo•llew6@o p6auld> o o�
0
pu.3rpl ! ixa: Palori,:)J
s1Jyc)
luawliedep 6uIpllnq ayl of pie6ai
ui „Ieloljjo„ @pew jo paloadsui ueaq lou seq leul;oa sigl uo auop > joM Aue lueM lou op I 'sNueyl
Wd 9Z L le E LOZ '9L Inp 'n41
'ugop
<woo dj000el;ooj@@UgO,> (aneallnW ugop :ol
<woo IIew6@o p6awd> o a
;ooa aJBH.O
<wo3•IIew6@@p6auid> o no Leo
a r
£lIL6ILO :a]el] esealaa - 83b9/170ZE :asege]ea snjin 16ti££'0TWZ :uolsJan
luappw ixai mon0l
luepplU pal palono]
Napp!41xa! paJonol
WV 9Z:L ETOZ '8T Alnr'Aepsmyl quag
[woo jiew6@@p6awd:oallew] o o :wo.ij
eyoJoE)
<woo jiew6@p6auid> o o :ol
WV EC:L ]e £60Z '8L Inf 'nqi <woo'dj000e4oai@ugof> AaneallnW uyop
}ooJ aJLH,O
<wo3•l]ew6r]o p6auld> o o
�� Z 0 6 - 9 2 - Z L L : 0
9 0 L O - � t 7 Z - 4 g g : 0
A a n e a l l n W ' p u y o p
' s s a a p p e a n o g e
a u ; ; e u o l ; o a d s u l l e ; G W J O O J e 6 u l L u a o u e d o u l p J e 6 9 a @ w I l e o a s e a l d
W d 9 6 : E l e C W Z ' S 6 I n f ' n 4 1
< w o o " l l e w 6 @ 7 p 6 a u l d > o o
e p p o j d ' w e a j ; s ; I n O
I a l l o S n y a n b ' O Z S Z
a o u a p ! s a ��l a J e H 2 O s u 4 O - @ ��]
' a n a ; S
< w o o p e w 5 p p 6 a u i d > o o : o o
< l a u l s e o w o o @ ' D J 9 j J e n n a n 9 l s > J a u e M a n a l g : o l
< w o o d j 0 0 0 a u o a @ u y o ( > 6 a n e a l l n w u y o p
3 a l l O O N - " s a N a a e H 2 O s I J y O
- 1 ' ����
W'd oo: L L 1e E Loi '9 Bny 'ani
<woo•jiew6@o p6auid> o o
suyO
'queyi
Law jol Luaw}jedap 6uippnq aye 01 rano J91191 s,jaaui6ua leya;a6 no ( ueo
'ugof
<woo-dj0009uooj@7uyo6 /anealinw ugof :oi
<woo,pew6@@p6awd> o a
3ai300H
WH L£: l l le E LOZ '9 6ny 'ani
uyor
-auop (peaJIy
'su4o
<woo•jiew6@o p6awd> o o :ol
<woo-dj000agoa@o uyof> 6aneapnw uyop
3allooH
<wo3•jiew6@o p6awd> o 3 ''
suy0
'sAue41
,auop sl 31 se MioM 6ulo6uo a43loadsul
pue Moeq awoo of tienuer isel nedai Hallen a43 10 uolloodsul a43 plp 1e43 iaeul6ue (w rise of 6=6
we I -lepejew loos leug 941 jnoge pnoo a43 wa; uolsloap a lab AIleug am Illun paloadsul eq of peau
@M 1843 sjledaj 6u1o6 uo 8ne4 I -ja4 of 6ulpj000e auo ja43oue japuo peo no ( panadde sl uogoadsul
dow loo jo Bel up a eouo eldwexa jol og •aolMl uol3oadsul to adA awes a4l jalue of wa43 Molle
lou scop wels(s jalndwoo rayl1e43 pewiguoo aja4l IiI6 a43 pue luawlredad 6ulpling Aejlap palleo 1
'u4of
<woo•dj000auoojougof> AaneallnIN u4op :ol
WH tiZ:ol le £6oi'S dag'n41 <woo•llew6@@p6auld> o o
3 L I00H
ZISbODw
<woo•11ew6@7p6awd> o 0
Martv Minor
From: Chris O'Hare <chrisoharegulfstream@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, December 10, 2015 5:57 PM
To: Marty Minor
Subject: follow up request - Re: Public Record Request - recent design analysis - 2520 AAS - Gulf
Stream
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Flagged
Dear Mr. Minor,
Thank you for responding to my recent public record request.
I asked your Custodian of Records for public records in the custody of your firm which I described as:
Records of the field investigation, photo documentation, evaluation and tabulation, point system of 100, review of
historic literature and any other record in the custody of UDKSTUD/OS created in the process of determining the
architectural style of the home located at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil in the Town of Gulf Stream during the time period from
Jan 1. 2012 to the present.
You provided me with a brief three email exchange between you and Mr. Thrasher. In that exchange Mr Thrasher asked you to
identify all such GS Bermuda characteristics of 2520 Avenue An Soleil. Mr. Thrasher, apparently referring to
another document explains to you that the house that had the idenlifrer on it is not the house in question.
Please provide the public record of that document.
Please provide the public record of any other communications between you and Mr. Thrasher related to
` the three email exchange reference above.
Please confirm that no other record exists in your firms custody that is responsive to the original request.
Please provide the disposition record for any responsive record that may have previously existed but no
longer exists.
I make these requests under the same terms, conditions and references as the original public record
request.
I hereby reserve all rights granted to me under the Florida Constitution and Florida Statutes.
All responses to this public records request should be made in writing to the following email address:
chrisoharegulfstream(rdgmail.com
On Thu, Dec 10, 2015 at 3:22 PM, Marty Minor <MMinorla7e udkstudios.com> wrote:
Mr. O'Hare,
Tl-qO
Attached are the documents from UDKS in response to your request below.
Thank you,
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
610 Clematis Street
Suite CU -02
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)366-1100
From: Chris O'Hare[mailto:chrisoharezulfstream@gmail.coml
Sent: Monday, December 07, 2015 8:05 AM
To: Ken Tuma <KTuma@udkstudios.com>; Ken Tuma <KTuma@udkstudios.com>; Anne Booth
<ABooth@udkstudios.com>
Subject: Public Record Request - recent design analysis - 2520 AAS - Gulf Stream
Dear Kerry, Ken and Anne
I wish to inspect public records in the custody of UDKSTUDIOS. If none of you are the Custodian of Records
for UDKSTUDIOS, please immediately forward this email to the individual who is Custodian of Records for UDKSTUDIOS.
This request is being made for records required in the defense of an existing and ongoing code enforcement prosecution. Your
IMMEDIATE attention and response to this matter is required. Production of these records within the next ten (10) days will be
considered a reasonable production schedule.
This email is a singular request for a public record. Please respond to this public record request in a singular manner and do
not combine this public record request with any other public record requests when responding to this request.
As background to this request I refer you to a portion of the Town of Gulf Stream Land Regulation Code known as the Design
Manual. Please reference these sections when searching for the public records which are the subject of this email.
Results of single-family development survey.
Sec. 70-299(b)(2)b....Based on the categories established in article VII, Predominant Architectural Styles, a
point system of 100 was assigned to each style that evaluated all the characteristic elements. In tum, this
ultimately determined, if a particular house was classified under one of the two styles or not.
Sec. 70-299(b)(2)c Field investigation and photo documentation were conducted and recorded. After all
properties were evaluated and tabulated, a cut off point was established for each architectural style. Spanish
Mediterranean style homes receiving 60 points or above or Gulf Stream -Bermuda style homes receiving 70
points or above, were classified as their respective style.
Please make available the following records for my inspection:
Records of the field investigation, photo documentation, evaluation and tabulation, point
system of 100, review of historic literature and any other record in the custody of
UDKSTUDIOS created in the process of determining the architectural style of the home
located at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil in the Town of Gulf Stream during the time period from Jan
1. 2012 to the present.
I make this request pursuant to Article 1. Section 24 of the Florida Constitution and Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes.
If you contend that any of the records I am seeking, or any portion thereof, are exempt from inspection or disclosure please cite
the specific exemption as required by &119.07(1)(e) of the Florida Statutes and state in writing and with particularity the basis
for your conclusions as required by 6I 19.07(1)(f) of the Florida Statutes.
Please take note of 4119.07(1)(c) Florida Statues and your affirmative obligation to (1) promptly acknowledge receipt of this
public records request and (2) make a good faith effort which "includes making reasonable efforts to determine from other
officers or employees within the agency whether such a record exists and, if so, the location at which the record can be
accessed." I am, therefore, requesting that you notify every individual in possession of records that may be responsive to this
public records request to preserve all such records on an immediate basis.
If the public records being sought are maintained by your agency in an electronic format please produce the records in
the original electronic format in which they were created or received. See 5119.01(2)(f). Florida Statutes.
Please provide only those records for inspection that do not require extensive use of information technologies or extensive staff
time or both in excess of 15 minutes. Take note of it 19.07(4)(a)3.(d) Florida Statues and if you anticipate that any records
exist, the production for inspection of which will require extensive use of information technologies or extensive staff time or
both in excess of 15 minutes, then please provide those records that can be produced within the first 15 minutes and advise me
of the cost you anticipate to be incurred by your agency for the remaining records prior to incurring this cost. Please do not
incur any costs on my behalf without first obtaining my written authorization to proceed.
If you anticipate the need to incur any costs that I would be statutorily required to pay in order to inspect these public records
which would exceed $1.00 please notify me in advance of your incurring that cost with a written estimate of the total cost.
Please be sure to itemize any estimates so as to indicate the total number of pages and/or records, as well as to distinguish the
cost of labor and materials. Again, please do not incur any costs on my behalf without first obtaining my written authorization to
proceed.
I hereby reserve all rights granted to me under the Florida Constitution and Florida Statutes.
All responses to this public records request should be made in writing to the following email address:
c h ri s o h a re g u l fs trea m fa) g m a i I. c o rn
--------- Forwarded message --------
From: Bill Thrasher <bthrasher(a gulf-stream.org>
To: Marty Minor <MMinoraa,udkstudios.com>
Cc:
Date: Wed, 19 Sep 2012 18:24:11 +0000
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
i Thanks.
From: Marty Minor [mallto:MMinor(&udkstudios.coml
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 2:15 PM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Well, that is a horse of a different color. Yes, I did unfortunately rely on Google for this. Here is my
description for your use:
2520 Avenue Au Soleil incorporates various architectural styles, but the predominant style is Gulf Stream -
Bermuda. Consistent with the description found in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the home's simple,
rectangular layout, smooth stucco exterior and rectilinear windows help identify its style. Although the
existing barrel tile roof uses non -preferred materials, the low -pitch, combination hip and gable style roof is a
strong characteristic of the Gulf Stream -Bermuda style.
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place North
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758
561-366-1100
From: Bill Thrasher rmailto:bthrasherCaloulr-stream.oro]
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 1:08 PM
To: Marty Minor
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Perhaps you used Google as I did. The house that had the identifier on it is not the house in question. It is the
inside corner one with red terra cotta roof.
i I am attaching a sheet for your review that will indicate which is 2520. Also, if you have to ride by, please
do. Please identify all elements that can be associated with GS Bermuda such as rectilinear features that may
be present. I need a listing of all such GS Bermuda characteristics.
From: Marty Minor rmailto:MMinor@udkstudios.coml
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 11:58 AM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Importance: High
This email is to confirm the findings of the Single Family Home architectural survey for the home at 2520
Avenue Au Soleil. The architectural style for the home is Gulf Stream -Bermuda.
As described in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the predominant and most identifiable feature of Gulf
Stream -Bermuda homes is the flat, white tile hip roof. In addition, a simple building configuration and
consistent eave lines are also features of the Gulf Stream -Bermuda style. The home at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
share all of these characteristics. As such, the architectural style for 2520 Avenue Au Soleil is Gulf Stream -
Bermuda.
Should you have any questions regarding this confirmation, please let me know.
Thank you,
marty
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place North
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758
561-366-1100
Marty Minor
From:
Bill Thrasher <bthrasher@gulf-stream.org>
Sent:
Wednesday, September 19, 2012 2:24 PM
To:
Marty Minor
Subject:
RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Thanks.
From: Marty Minor [mailto:MMinor@udkstudios.com]
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 2:15 PM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Well, that is a horse of a different color. Yes, I did unfortunately rely on Google for this. Here is my description for your
use:
2520 Avenue Au Soleil incorporates various architectural styles, but the predominant style is Gulf Stream -
Bermuda. Consistent with the description found in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the home's simple, rectangular
layout, smooth stucco exterior and rectilinear windows help identify its style. Although the existing barrel tile roof uses
non -preferred materials, the low -pitch, combination hip and gable style roof is a strong characteristic of the Gulf
Stream -Bermuda style.
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place North
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758
561-366-1100
From: Bill Thrasher rmailto:bthrasher(abgulf-stream.orol
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 1:08 PM
To: Marty Minor
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Perhaps you used Google as I did. The house that had the identifier on it is not the house in question. It is the inside
corner one with red terra cotta roof.
I am attaching a sheet for your review that will indicate which is 2520. Also, if you have to ride by, please do. Please
identify all elements that can be associated with GS Bermuda such as rectilinear features that may be present. I need a
listing of all such GS Bermuda characteristics.
From: Marty Minor rmailto:MMinorCaludkstudios.coml
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 11:58 AM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Importance: High
Bill,
This email is to confirm the findings of the Single Family Home architectural survey for the home at 2520 Avenue Au
Soleil. The architectural style for the home is Gulf Stream -Bermuda.
R -II
As described in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the predominant and most identifiable feature of Gulf Stream -Bermuda
homes is the flat, white tile hip roof. In addition, a simple building configuration and consistent eave lines are also
features of the Gulf Stream -Bermuda style. The home at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil share all of these characteristics. As
such, the architectural style for 2520 Avenue Au Soleil is Gulf Stream -Bermuda.
Should you have any questions regarding this confirmation, please let me know.
Thank you,
Marty
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place North
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758
561-366-1100
��: I l i
. . '
I f y o u c o n t e n d t h a t a n y o f t h e r e c o r d s I a m s e e k i n g , o r a n y p o r t i o n t h e r e o f , a r e e x e m p t f r o m
i n s p e c t i o n o r d i s c l o s u r e p l e a s e c i t e t h e s p e c i f i c e x e m p t i o n a s r e q u i r e d b y 4 1 1 9 . 0 7 0 ) ( e ) o f t h e
F l o r i d a S t a t u t e s a n d s t a t e i n w r i t i n g a n d w i t h p a r t i c u l a r i t y t h e b a s i s f o r y o u r c o n c l u s i o n s a s r e q u i r e d
b y � 1 1 9 . 0 7 0 ) ( f ) o f t h e F l o r i d a S t a t u t e s .
P l e a s e t a k e n o t e o f 4 1 1 9 . 0 7 ( 1 ) ( c ) F l o r i d a S t a t u e s a n d y o u r a f f i r m a t i v e o b l i g a t i o n t o ( 1 )
p r o m p t l y a c k n o w l e d g e r e c e i p t o f t h i s p u b l i c r e c o r d s r e q u e s t a n d ( 2 ) m a k e a g o o d f a i t h e f f o r t w h i c h
" i n c l u d e s m a k i n g r e a s o n a b l e e f f o r t s t o d e t e r m i n e f r o m o t h e r o f f i c e r s o r e m p l o y e e s w i t h i n t h e a g e n c y
w h e t h e r s u c h a r e c o r d e x i s t s a n d , i f s o , t h e l o c a t i o n a t w h i c h t h e r e c o r d c a n b e a c c e s s e d . " I a m ,
t h e r e f o r e , r e q u e s t i n g t h a t y o u n o t i f y e v e r y i n d i v i d u a l i n p o s s e s s i o n o f r e c o r d s t h a t m a y b e r e s p o n s i v e
t o t h i s p u b l i c r e c o r d s r e q u e s t t o p r e s e r v e a l l s u c h r e c o r d s o n a n i m m e d i a t e b a s i s .
I f t h e p u b l i c r e c o r d s b e i n g s o u g h t a r e m a i n t a i n e d b y y o u r a g e n c y i n a n e l e c t r o n i c f o r m a t p l e a s e
p r o d u c e t h e r e c o r d s i n t h e o r i g i n a l e l e c t r o n i c f o r m a t i n w h i c h t h e y w e r e c r e a t e d o r
r e c e i v e d . S e e � 1 1 9 . 0 1 ( 2 ) ( f ) , F l o r i d a S t a t u t e s .
P l e a s e p r o v i d e o n l y t h o s e r e c o r d s f o r i n s p e c t i o n t h a t d o n o t r e q u i r e e x t e n s i v e u s e o f i n f o r m a t i o n
t e c h n o l o g i e s o r e x t e n s i v e s t a f f t i m e o r b o t h i n e x c e s s o f 1 5 m i n u t e s . T a k e n o t e o f 4 1 1 9 . 0 7 ( 4 ) ( a ) 3 . ( d )
F l o r i d a S t a t u e s a n d i f y o u a n t i c i p a t e t h a t a n y r e c o r d s e x i s t , t h e p r o d u c t i o n f o r i n s p e c t i o n o f w h i c h w i l l
r e q u i r e e x t e n s i v e u s e o f i n f o r m a t i o n t e c h n o l o g i e s o r e x t e n s i v e s t a f f t i m e o r b o t h i n e x c e s s o f 1 5
m i n u t e s , t h e n p l e a s e p r o v i d e t h o s e r e c o r d s t h a t c a n b e p r o d u c e d w i t h i n t h e f i r s t 1 5 m i n u t e s
a n d a d v i s e m e o f t h e c o s t y o u a n t i c i p a t e t o b e i n c u r r e d b y y o u r a g e n c y f o r t h e r e m a i n i n g r e c o r d s
p r i o r t o i n c u r r i n g t h i s c o s t . P l e a s e d o n o t i n c u r a n y c o s t s o n m y b e h a l f w i t h o u t f i r s t o b t a i n i n g m y
w r i t t e n a u t h o r i z a t i o n t o p r o c e e d .
I f y o u a n t i c i p a t e t h e n e e d t o i n c u r a n y c o s t s t h a t I w o u l d b e s t a t u t o r i l y r e q u i r e d t o p a y i n o r d e r t o
i n s p e c t t h e s e p u b l i c r e c o r d s w h i c h w o u l d e x c e e d $ 1 . 0 0 p l e a s e n o t i f y m e i n a d v a n c e o f y o u r i n c u r r i n g
t h a t c o s t w i t h a w r i t t e n e s t i m a t e o f t h e t o t a l c o s t . P l e a s e b e s u r e t o i t e m i z e a n y e s t i m a t e s s o a s t o
i n d i c a t e t h e t o t a l n u m b e r o f p a g e s a n d / o r r e c o r d s , a s w e l l a s t o d i s t i n g u i s h t h e c o s t o f l a b o r a n d
m a t e r i a l s . A g a i n , p l e a s e d o n o t i n c u r a n y c o s t s o n m y b e h a l f w i t h o u t f i r s t o b t a i n i n g m y w r i t t e n
a u t h o r i z a t i o n t o p r o c e e d .
I h e r e b y r e s e r v e a l l r i g h t s g r a n t e d t o m e u n d e r t h e F l o r i d a C o n s t i t u t i o n a n d F l o r i d a S t a t u t e s .
A l l r e s p o n s e s t o t h i s p u b l i c r e c o r d s r e q u e s t s h o u l d b e m a d e i n w r i t i n g t o t h e f o l l o w i n g e m a i l
a d d r e s s :
c h r i s o h a r e g u l f s t r e a m ( c D g m a i l . c o m
- - - - - - - - - - F o r w a r d e d m e s s a g e - - - - - - - - - -
F r o m : B i l l T h r a s h e r < b t h r a s h e r ( 2 g u l f - s t r e a m . o r g >
T o : M a r t y M i n o r < M M i n o r a u d k s t u d i o s . c o m >
C c :
D a t e : W e d , 1 9 S e p 2 0 1 2 1 8 : 2 4 : 1 1 + 0 0 0 0
S u b j e c t : R E : 2 5 2 0 A v e n u e A u S o l e i l
T h a n k s .
3
From: Marty Minor[mailto:MMinorCaludkstudios.coml
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 2:15 PM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Well. that is a horse of a different color. Yes, I did unfortunately rely on Google for this. Here is my
description for your use:
2520 Avenue Au Soleil incorporates various architectural styles, but the predominant style is Gulf Stream-
Bennuda. Consistent with the description found in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the home's simple,
rectangular layout, smooth stucco exterior and rectilinear windows help identity its style. Although the
existing barrel tile roof uses non -preferred materials, the low -pitch, combination hip and gable style roof is a
strong characteristic of the Gulf Stream -Bermuda style.
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place North
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758
561-366-1100
From: Bill Thrasher rmailto:bthrasher(c' oulf-stream.orol
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 1:08 PM
To: Marty Minor
Subject: RE: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Perhaps you used Google as I did. The house that had the identifier on it is not the house in question. It is the
inside corer one with red terra cotta roof.
I am attaching a sheet for your review that will indicate which is 2520. Also, if you have to ride by, please
do. Please identify all elements that can be associated with GS Bermuda such as rectilinear features that may
be present. I need a listing of all such GS Bermuda characteristics.
From: Marty Minor rmailto:MMinorCaludkstudios.com]
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 11:58 AM
To: Bill Thrasher
Subject: 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
Importance: High
This email is to confirm the findings of the Single Family Home architectural survey for the home at 2520
Avenue Au Soleil. The architectural style for the home is Gulf Stream -Bermuda.
As described in Sections 70-236 through 70-244, the predominant and most identifiable feature of Gulf
Stream -Bermuda homes is the flat, white tile hip roof. In addition, a simple building configuration and
consistent eave lines are also features of the Gulf Stream -Bermuda style. The home at 2520 Avenue Au Soleil
share all of these characteristics. As such, the architectural style for 2520 Avenue Au Soleil is Gulf Stream -
Bermuda.
Should you have any questions regarding this confirmation, please let me know.
Thank you,
marty
Marty R.A. Minor, AICP
Urban Design Kilday Studios
The Offices at City Place North
477 South Rosemary Avenue, Suite 225
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5758
561-366-1100