Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAboutPKT-CC-2022-03-22MARCH 22, 2022 PRE -COUNCIL WORKSHOP 5:30 P.M. REGULAR MEETING 6:00 P.M. Consistent with provisions of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, Utah Code Ann. § 54 -2 - 207(4), the Moab City Council Chair has issued written determinations supporting the decision to convene electronic meetings of the Council without a physical anchor location. Due to the health and safety risks related to the ongoing COVID -19 pandemic, the Moab City Council will continue to hold meetings by electronic means. The public is invited and encouraged to view and participate in the Council ’s electronic meetings by viewing the City ’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/MoabCityGovernment Pre -Council Workshop - 5:30 p.m. Regional Haze Conversation with the EPA Region 8 Conversation. regional haze conversation agenda summary sheet.docx.pdf regional haze memo - draft nov 2021.pdf city of moab regional haze letter 2 -1 -2022.pdf Regular City Council Meeting - 6:00 p.m. Call to Order and Roll Call Attendance Citizens to Be Heard (Electronic Participation) Citizens to be heard comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963? pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09 Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/citizenstobeheard . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words. Public Hearing Proposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023 Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the City Public comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963? pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09 Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/publiccommentform . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words . ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdf ordinance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf Presentations Moab Solutions Presentation (5 minutes) Lions Park River Access Consent Agenda Approval of Minutes March 8, 2022, Regular Meeting min -cc -2022 -03 -08 draft.pdf Approval of Bills Against the City of Moab in the Amount of $596,805.93 check register council consent 3 -14 -22.pdf Old Business Draft Landscaping Requirements Discussion and direction. landscape regulations discussion - agenda summary.docx.pdf 2022.02.16_memo_ city of moab water efficient landscaping standards draft recommendations.pdf Staff Update on Draft Ordinance 2022 -05: An Ordinance Amending the Moab Municipal Code R3/R4 Zones with an Active Employment Household Requirement Briefing and discussion aeh draft ordinance 2022 -05 agenda summary 032222.pdf exhibit 1 draft aeh ordinance 2022 -05 031722 redline cps.pdf New Business Proposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023 Briefing and possible action agenda summary ordinance 2022 -03.pdf ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdf Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the City Briefing and possible action agenda summary - ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf chapter 3.50 code - master fee schedule revisions - redline.pdf Proposed Resolution 08 -2022: A Resolution Approving the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision of Property Located at 458 West 200 South, Moab UT 84532 Briefing and possible action mclaughlin minor subdivision cc agenda summary 032222.pdf exhibit 1 resolution 08 -2022 mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 2 vicinity map mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 3 recorded county plat mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 4 draft plat final mclaughlin minor subdivision 032222.pdf Maximum Adult Residential Occupancy Discussion Discussion moab city council agenda item.pdf Administrative Reports Acting City Manager Updates Mayor and Council Reports Adjournment Special Accommodations: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, individuals needing special accommodations during this meeting should notify the Recorder ’s Office at 217 East Center Street, Moab, Utah 84532; or phone (435) 259 -5121 at least three (3) working days prior to the meeting. Check our website for updates at: www.moabcity.org 1. 1.1. Documents: 2. 2.1. 3. 4. Documents: 5. 5.1. 5.2. 6. 6.1. Documents: 6.2. Documents: 7. 7.1. Documents: 7.2. Documents: 8. 8.1. Documents: 8.2. Documents: 8.3. Documents: 8.4. Documents: 9. 9.1. 10. 11. MARCH 22, 2022PRE-COUNCIL WORKSHOP 5:30 P.M. REGULAR MEETING 6:00 P.M.Consistent with provisions of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, Utah Code Ann. § 54 -2 -207(4), the Moab City Council Chair has issued written determinations supporting the decision to convene electronic meetings of the Council without a physical anchor location. Due to the health and safety risks related to the ongoing COVID -19 pandemic, the Moab City Council will continue to hold meetings by electronic means. The public is invited and encouraged to view and participate in the Council ’s electronic meetings by viewing the City ’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/MoabCityGovernmentPre-Council Workshop - 5:30 p.m.Regional Haze Conversation with the EPA Region 8Conversation.regional haze conversation agenda summary sheet.docx.pdfregional haze memo - draft nov 2021.pdfcity of moab regional haze letter 2 -1 -2022.pdfRegular City Council Meeting - 6:00 p.m. Call to Order and Roll Call AttendanceCitizens to Be Heard (Electronic Participation)Citizens to be heard comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963?pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/citizenstobeheard . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words. Public Hearing Proposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023 Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the City Public comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963? pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09 Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/publiccommentform . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words . ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdf ordinance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf Presentations Moab Solutions Presentation (5 minutes) Lions Park River Access Consent Agenda Approval of Minutes March 8, 2022, Regular Meeting min -cc -2022 -03 -08 draft.pdf Approval of Bills Against the City of Moab in the Amount of $596,805.93 check register council consent 3 -14 -22.pdf Old Business Draft Landscaping Requirements Discussion and direction. landscape regulations discussion - agenda summary.docx.pdf 2022.02.16_memo_ city of moab water efficient landscaping standards draft recommendations.pdf Staff Update on Draft Ordinance 2022 -05: An Ordinance Amending the Moab Municipal Code R3/R4 Zones with an Active Employment Household Requirement Briefing and discussion aeh draft ordinance 2022 -05 agenda summary 032222.pdf exhibit 1 draft aeh ordinance 2022 -05 031722 redline cps.pdf New Business Proposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023 Briefing and possible action agenda summary ordinance 2022 -03.pdf ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdf Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the City Briefing and possible action agenda summary - ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf chapter 3.50 code - master fee schedule revisions - redline.pdf Proposed Resolution 08 -2022: A Resolution Approving the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision of Property Located at 458 West 200 South, Moab UT 84532 Briefing and possible action mclaughlin minor subdivision cc agenda summary 032222.pdf exhibit 1 resolution 08 -2022 mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 2 vicinity map mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 3 recorded county plat mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 4 draft plat final mclaughlin minor subdivision 032222.pdf Maximum Adult Residential Occupancy Discussion Discussion moab city council agenda item.pdf Administrative Reports Acting City Manager Updates Mayor and Council Reports Adjournment Special Accommodations: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, individuals needing special accommodations during this meeting should notify the Recorder ’s Office at 217 East Center Street, Moab, Utah 84532; or phone (435) 259 -5121 at least three (3) working days prior to the meeting. Check our website for updates at: www.moabcity.org 1.1.1.Documents:2.2.1.3. 4. Documents: 5. 5.1. 5.2. 6. 6.1. Documents: 6.2. Documents: 7. 7.1. Documents: 7.2. Documents: 8. 8.1. Documents: 8.2. Documents: 8.3. Documents: 8.4. Documents: 9. 9.1. 10. 11. MARCH 22, 2022PRE-COUNCIL WORKSHOP 5:30 P.M. REGULAR MEETING 6:00 P.M.Consistent with provisions of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, Utah Code Ann. § 54 -2 -207(4), the Moab City Council Chair has issued written determinations supporting the decision to convene electronic meetings of the Council without a physical anchor location. Due to the health and safety risks related to the ongoing COVID -19 pandemic, the Moab City Council will continue to hold meetings by electronic means. The public is invited and encouraged to view and participate in the Council ’s electronic meetings by viewing the City ’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/MoabCityGovernmentPre-Council Workshop - 5:30 p.m.Regional Haze Conversation with the EPA Region 8Conversation.regional haze conversation agenda summary sheet.docx.pdfregional haze memo - draft nov 2021.pdfcity of moab regional haze letter 2 -1 -2022.pdfRegular City Council Meeting - 6:00 p.m. Call to Order and Roll Call AttendanceCitizens to Be Heard (Electronic Participation)Citizens to be heard comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963?pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/citizenstobeheard . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words.Public HearingProposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the CityPublic comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963?pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/publiccommentform . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words .ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdfordinance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdfPresentations Moab Solutions Presentation (5 minutes)Lions Park River AccessConsent AgendaApproval of MinutesMarch 8, 2022, Regular Meetingmin-cc -2022 -03 -08 draft.pdfApproval of Bills Against the City of Moab in the Amount of $596,805.93check register council consent 3 -14 -22.pdfOld BusinessDraft Landscaping RequirementsDiscussion and direction. landscape regulations discussion - agenda summary.docx.pdf 2022.02.16_memo_ city of moab water efficient landscaping standards draft recommendations.pdf Staff Update on Draft Ordinance 2022 -05: An Ordinance Amending the Moab Municipal Code R3/R4 Zones with an Active Employment Household Requirement Briefing and discussion aeh draft ordinance 2022 -05 agenda summary 032222.pdf exhibit 1 draft aeh ordinance 2022 -05 031722 redline cps.pdf New Business Proposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023 Briefing and possible action agenda summary ordinance 2022 -03.pdf ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdf Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the City Briefing and possible action agenda summary - ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdf chapter 3.50 code - master fee schedule revisions - redline.pdf Proposed Resolution 08 -2022: A Resolution Approving the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision of Property Located at 458 West 200 South, Moab UT 84532 Briefing and possible action mclaughlin minor subdivision cc agenda summary 032222.pdf exhibit 1 resolution 08 -2022 mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 2 vicinity map mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 3 recorded county plat mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdf exhibit 4 draft plat final mclaughlin minor subdivision 032222.pdf Maximum Adult Residential Occupancy Discussion Discussion moab city council agenda item.pdf Administrative Reports Acting City Manager Updates Mayor and Council Reports Adjournment Special Accommodations: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, individuals needing special accommodations during this meeting should notify the Recorder ’s Office at 217 East Center Street, Moab, Utah 84532; or phone (435) 259 -5121 at least three (3) working days prior to the meeting. Check our website for updates at: www.moabcity.org 1.1.1.Documents:2.2.1.3.4.Documents:5.5.1.5.2.6.6.1.Documents:6.2.Documents:7.7.1.Documents: 7.2. Documents: 8. 8.1. Documents: 8.2. Documents: 8.3. Documents: 8.4. Documents: 9. 9.1. 10. 11. MARCH 22, 2022PRE-COUNCIL WORKSHOP 5:30 P.M. REGULAR MEETING 6:00 P.M.Consistent with provisions of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, Utah Code Ann. § 54 -2 -207(4), the Moab City Council Chair has issued written determinations supporting the decision to convene electronic meetings of the Council without a physical anchor location. Due to the health and safety risks related to the ongoing COVID -19 pandemic, the Moab City Council will continue to hold meetings by electronic means. The public is invited and encouraged to view and participate in the Council ’s electronic meetings by viewing the City ’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/MoabCityGovernmentPre-Council Workshop - 5:30 p.m.Regional Haze Conversation with the EPA Region 8Conversation.regional haze conversation agenda summary sheet.docx.pdfregional haze memo - draft nov 2021.pdfcity of moab regional haze letter 2 -1 -2022.pdfRegular City Council Meeting - 6:00 p.m. Call to Order and Roll Call AttendanceCitizens to Be Heard (Electronic Participation)Citizens to be heard comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963?pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/citizenstobeheard . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words.Public HearingProposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023Proposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the CityPublic comments may be made by phone or online through Zoom. Citizens are limited to two (2) minutes for comments.To participate by phone or online through Zoom, please use the following links: Dial: 669 -900 -9128 Meeting ID: 841 2070 0963 Passcode (if needed): 289387 Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84120700963?pwd=z1vqefpcohovajfidstxaxpetgjkut09Please note that when joining the meeting, you will be placed in a waiting room and will be added to the meeting by the moderator. Your comments will be recorded and on YouTube. To have your written comments considered for the Citizens to Be Heard portion of the electronic meeting, please fill out the form found here: https://bit.ly/publiccommentform . You must submit your comments by 6:00 PM on the date of the meeting. Please limit your comments to 400 words .ordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdfordinance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdfPresentations Moab Solutions Presentation (5 minutes)Lions Park River AccessConsent AgendaApproval of MinutesMarch 8, 2022, Regular Meetingmin-cc -2022 -03 -08 draft.pdfApproval of Bills Against the City of Moab in the Amount of $596,805.93check register council consent 3 -14 -22.pdfOld BusinessDraft Landscaping RequirementsDiscussion and direction.landscape regulations discussion - agenda summary.docx.pdf2022.02.16_memo_ city of moab water efficient landscaping standards draft recommendations.pdfStaff Update on Draft Ordinance 2022 -05: An Ordinance Amending the Moab Municipal Code R3/R4 Zones with an Active Employment Household RequirementBriefing and discussionaeh draft ordinance 2022 -05 agenda summary 032222.pdfexhibit 1 draft aeh ordinance 2022 -05 031722 redline cps.pdfNew BusinessProposed Ordinance 2022 -03: An Ordinance Adopting the City of Moab Pay Plan Schedule and Adopting the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries for Fiscal Year 2022 -2023Briefing and possible actionagenda summary ordinance 2022 -03.pdfordinance no 2022 -03 with attachments.pdfProposed Ordinance 2022 -06: An Ordinance Amending Title 3 of the Moab Municipal Code to Update Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule and Modifying Certain Fees and Rates Charged by the CityBriefing and possible actionagenda summary - ordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdfordiance 2022 -06 - master fee schedule revision.pdfchapter 3.50 code - master fee schedule revisions - redline.pdfProposed Resolution 08 -2022: A Resolution Approving the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision of Property Located at 458 West 200 South, Moab UT 84532Briefing and possible actionmclaughlin minor subdivision cc agenda summary 032222.pdfexhibit 1 resolution 08 -2022 mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdfexhibit 2 vicinity map mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdfexhibit 3 recorded county plat mclaughlin minor subdivision 031022.pdfexhibit 4 draft plat final mclaughlin minor subdivision 032222.pdfMaximum Adult Residential Occupancy DiscussionDiscussion moab city council agenda item.pdf Administrative Reports Acting City Manager Updates Mayor and Council Reports Adjournment Special Accommodations: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, individuals needing special accommodations during this meeting should notify the Recorder ’s Office at 217 East Center Street, Moab, Utah 84532; or phone (435) 259 -5121 at least three (3) working days prior to the meeting. Check our website for updates at: www.moabcity.org 1.1.1.Documents:2.2.1.3.4.Documents:5.5.1.5.2.6.6.1.Documents:6.2.Documents:7.7.1.Documents:7.2.Documents:8.8.1.Documents:8.2.Documents:8.3.Documents:8.4. Documents: 9. 9.1. 10. 11. Moab City Council Agenda Item Meeting Date: March 22, 2022 Title:Regional Haze Conversation with the EPA Region 8 Presenter:None Attachment(s):Draft letter, Sierra Club memo Recommended Motion:N/A - Conversation Background/Summary:This item was heard at the February 8th, 2022 regular City Council meeting, at which time the Council approved a letter (attached) to send to the EPA discussing the importance of pollution controls for our nearby coal power plants. The EPA responded to that letter and asked to have a conversation with the Mayor and City Council. This is an opportunity for Council members and the Mayor to discuss these issues with KC Becker, the Region 8 Administrator for the EPA. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From the previous agenda summary: There are two remaining large coal-fired power plants in Utah - Hunter and Huntington - which are required to comply with clean air regulations. Part of these regulations are in regards to haze-producing pollutants in national parks. This aspect of the Clean Air Act is called “Regional Haze.” In 2016, Moab played a pivotal role in engaging the EPA and producing a strong haze rule, which was incorporated into the Federal Implementation Plan for pollution control at both plants in 2016. This plan was never adopted and implemented, due to rule rollbacks after the federal administration changed. With the new administration, and new Region 8 EPA Administrator, KC Becker, there is an opportunity to engage the EPA anew and encourage them to reinstate the pollution-control requirements from 2016, which would reduce haze-causing pollutants by 76% from Hunter and Huntington power plants. Retrofit technology has only become more available, and the parks continue to be impacted by anthropogenic haze. The intention of this letter is to voice support at the local level for Regional Haze controls and introduce Moab to the new EPA administrator. The climate change and clean energy goals of the current administration align well with pollution-controls, and the Hunter and Huntington plants directly impact our region’s skies. Enforcing the regulations agreed upon in 2016 would benefit the health and economy of Moab and our neighboring communities. MEMO TO:White House Climate Policy Office FROM:Sierra Club and National Parks Conservation Association SUBJECT:Action on Regional Haze Will Deliver Significant Climate and Health Co-benefits DATE:December 7, 2021 ==================================================================== This memo discusses actions necessary from the administration to reduce haze-causing pollution from coal-fired plants under the Regional Haze Rule. Significant opportunities exist to codify emission reductions under both the outstanding round 1 plans for five states as well round 2 plans that are currently in process for all states around the nation. Final Regional Haze action is required now on outstanding round 1 plans. Significant emissions reductions can be secured that would not otherwise be achieved under any other existing rulemaking. The 1990 Clean Air Act amendments require states and EPA to remedy the degraded visibility caused by human-made air pollution -- primarily sulfur dioxide (“SO2”), nitrogen oxide (“NOx”), and particulate matter from industrial sources -- at treasured national parks and wilderness areas designated as “Class I” areas. EPA subsequently issued the Regional Haze Rule, which required states to submit state implementation plans by 2007, and then every 10 years after. The plans outline compliance schedules and measures, and emissions limits for polluting facilities that will make reasonable progress toward the goal of correcting visibility issues in Class I areas. The first round of plans required the oldest and dirtiest polluters to install the best available retrofit technology, or “BART”, to reduce pollution from some of the worst offenders. More than 13 years later, several states’ plans have yet to fully comply with round 1 BART requirements. In June 2021, Sierra Club and National Parks Conservation Association along with four other conservation organizations submitted a request1 to EPA Administrator Michael Regan highlighting the need for complete and rigorous implementation of BART requirements, highlighting a range of state plan deficiencies or a lack of final action state implementation plans for Texas, Utah, Wyoming, Nebraska and Pennsylvania. 1 The coal units described in this letter (excluding those with firm retirement dates) are: Gerald Gentleman 1-2 (NE), Hunter 1-3 (UT), Huntington 1-2 (UT), Jim Bridger 1-2 (WY), Limestone 1-2 (TX), Martin Lake 1-3 (TX), Naughton 1-2 (WY), Tolk 1-2 (TX), WA Parish 5-6 (TX), Wyodak 1 (WY). Sierra Club, Environmental Defense Fund, Powder River Basin Resource Council, Earthjustice, National Parks Conservation Association and HEAL Utah, “Re: Regional Haze: Outstanding Obligations from the First Planning Period,” Letter to EPA Administrator Regan, June 8, 2021. 1 Full compliance with the BART program and final round 1 actions will lead to long overdue, significant improvement to air quality and visibility in places like (but not limited to) Big Bend, Zion, Grand Canyon, Bryce Canyon, Arches, Rocky Mountain and Shenandoah National Parks. In addition, this action will have substantial co-benefits of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving public health. This memo highlights these important co-benefits and the need for prompt action by EPA. Climate and health impacts of coal plants subject to Regional Haze action The Conservation Organizations’ letter highlighted 21 units at coal-fired power plants2 in these five states which would be required to make significant capital expenditures in pollution controls like selective catalytic reduction (“SCR”) or flue gas desulfurization (“FGD”) to meet BART requirements at aging, polluting coal plants. Many of these plants, however, are expensive to continue operating and increasingly uneconomic relative to renewable energy like wind and solar, energy storage, and customer energy efficiency programs that avoid the need for expensive power plants. While modern pollution controls would reduce air pollution from these plants, in many cases it is more cost effective to simply replace these polluting power plants with clean energy resources. These 21 coal units consist of 12,579 MW of generating capacity. In 2019, they collectively emitted 63 million metric tons of CO2, nearly 4% of total U.S. electric sector emissions. While modern air pollution controls on their own may not reduce this climate pollution, many of these units are already uneconomic, and additional capital expenditures on aging and expensive power plants may not be economically rational in the face of lower cost clean energy options. The 21 coal units described in this letter collectively emitted 233 million pounds of SO2 and 112 million pounds of NOx in 2019. This includes some of the largest sources of pollution in the country. For example, the Martin Lake power plant in Texas was the single largest source of SO2 emissions nationwide in the power sector in 2019, and was also the 7th largest power sector source of NOx pollution. W.A. Parish, outside of Houston, Texas was the third largest source of SO2 in the U.S. power sector in 2019, polluting communities that are already burdened with particulate matter pollution worse than three-quarters of the country. Gerald Gentleman in Nebraska was the 5th largest SO2 emitter in the power sector in 2019. The Hunter power plant in Utah is 5th in the nation for NOx pollution, and due to its proximity to several iconic national parks, is the second largest contributor to pollution in national parks.3 3 NPCA, as referenced in Sierra Club et al letter to EPA Administrator Regan. 2 These totals exclude four Texas electricity generating units that have proposed retirement / gas conversion dates, as well as two cement plants in Pennsylvania which are identified in the letter for which the state implementation plan has significant deficiencies. 2 Reducing SO2 and NOx emissions from these coal units to the level of plants with modern, fully functional pollution controls would reduce NOx emissions by 41 million pounds and SO2 by 180 million pounds.4 Shuttering these plants and replacing the electricity and grid services with clean energy resources could eliminate this pollution altogether. The air pollution from these coal units does not just impair visibility in national parks. SO2 and NOx are dangerous pollutants, both directly and through the formation of particulate matter and ozone in the atmosphere. The pollution from these 21 coal units contributes to at least 435 premature deaths from air pollution each year. In addition, dirty emissions from these plants contribute to an estimated 5,400 asthma attacks and 173 heart attacks per year.5 Reducing air pollution from these plants will significantly reduce the health burden they place on surrounding communities, many already overburdened by pollution, and regions. Replacing these coal plants with clean energy will drive over $45 billion in clean energy investment and deliver jobs These aging coal plants are increasingly uneconomic compared to renewable energy resources, which have seen significant and sustained cost reductions in recent years. In many cases, clean energy portfolios that provide the same electricity output and capacity value as a coal plant may be less costly than the cost of necessary retrofits and continued operations of those coal plants. In fact, our preliminary, internal analyses indicate that for most of the coal units at issue, retiring and replacing these plants with clean energy resources would lower costs and emissions, relative to investing additional capital in these aging and already expensive fossil generation resources. Finally, replacing the 21 coal units with cost-saving portfolios of clean energy resources would result in over $45 billion in investment, including approximately 22 GW of solar, 10 GW of wind, and 11 GW of energy storage. These investments can deliver economic benefits to rural communities6, including local tax revenues, income for landholders, and an estimated 300,000 cumulative job-years over a 15 year time horizon.7 These much needed economic development benefits will support communities as they transition away from coal. 7 Calculation based on average job-years per MW and investment per MW for solar, wind and storage from the UC Berkeley, Energy Innovation and Gridlab “2035 Report”. 6 For more on the rural economic development benefits of renewable energy projects, see RMI, “Seeds of Opportunity”, 2021, https://rmi.org/insight/seeds-of-opportunity/ 5 Based on analysis of 2019 emissions data by Clean Air Task Force, published at https://www.tollfromcoal.org/#/map/(title:none//detail:none//map:none/US).Pro-rated from plant-level to unit-level proportionally using total NOx and SO2 emissions. 4 Based on 2019 NOx and SO2 emissions rates per MMBtu. Assuming fully controlled units have a NOx emissions rate of 0.05 lbs/MMBtu and SO2 emissions rate of 0.06 lbs/MMBtu, and that units in Texas and Nebraska control SO2 emissions while plants in Utah and Wyoming control NOx emissions. 3 Public Engagement Public engagement on regional haze has been robust and longstanding. Since 2016, Sierra Club members and supporters have submitted more than 108,000 individual comments to state and federal agencies requesting stronger NOx pollution controls be installed on the coal plants listed in this memo. The National Parks Conservation Association has extensively worked on and led regional haze advocacy to engage tens of thousands of residents calling for strong action to address Utah’s haze pollution since the beginning of Round 1 planning. Together, our groups formed a coalition of more than 200 businesses from Utah, Colorado, and Arizona that raised their voices to decry the effects of uncontrolled NOx emissions from regional sources, like Hunter and Huntington, and called on EPA to ensure pollution reduction. In 2015, the National Park Service, including Superintendents from Arches, Canyonlands, Zion, Bryce Canyon and Capitol Reef National Parks, identified these coal plants as the largest contributors to visibility impairment in regional Class I areas and called on EPA to require NOx reductions. Over the years, local municipal and county elected officials from National Park gateway communities have made personal appeals to EPA leadership to require pollution controls and clean up the skies and views their communities rely on for economic development. As recent as last month, a County Commissioner in Utah renewed those calls8. And still, these coal plants remain uncontrolled. Recommendations The Regional Haze Rule’s BART requirement for Texas, Utah, Wyoming, Nebraska, and Pennsylvania is nearly fifteen years overdue. Because those states have refused to comply with the Clean Air Act’s mandate, EPA must finally complete the BART process from the first planning period and put these important obligations to rest. In our letter, we proposed a nationwide rulemaking to be completed as expeditiously as possible that would fully correct all deficiencies and satisfy the remaining first round regional haze obligations in the five states. We are also open to other options that would quickly achieve the same goal. Either way,EPA must finally ensure that all states have fully complied with the Clean Air Act’s Regional Haze Rule’s BART requirements for the first round and require emission reductions to achieve reasonable progress towards the national goal of restoring natural visibility to America’s treasured Class I national parks and wilderness areas. The actions of the Biden Administration on these five outstanding state regional haze requirements are of consequence even beyond the sharp reductions they must produce. With 8 “Sarah Stock: Regional Haze Rule is important for our community and must be enforced to do the most good,” Salt Lake Tribune, October 21, 2021. https://www.sltrib.com/opinion/commentary/2021/10/21/sarah-stock-regional-haze/ 4 all state regional haze plans in the midst of the planning and implementation process for the second round, actions on these outstanding obligations will inform the Administration’s regard and approach for standards to ensure reasonable progress for emission reductions in all states. EPA, in its July 2021 Clarification Memo on Regional Haze made plain that it expects states' haze plans for the second planning period to result in meaningful, additive reductions in SO2 and NOx pollution by 2028. Thousands upon thousands of tons of haze pollution remain unchecked at facilities of all kinds, and at coal-fired power plants in particular. We urge the Biden Administration to act swiftly on our request to resolve the five state round 1 BART obligations once and for all and send a clear signal to all states that the agency is taking the mandate of this Clean Air Act program seriously. 5 Appendix: Coal power plants subject to Regional Haze action State Plant Unit Nameplat e Capacity (MW) 2019 Capacity Factor (%) 2019 CO2 (MMT) 2019 SO2 (million lbs) 2019 NOx (million lbs) NE Gerald Gentleman 1 681 67%3.59 20.93 7.76 NE Gerald Gentleman 2 681 73%4.34 25.89 7.19 TX Limestone 1 910 54%3.90 5.08 6.26 TX Limestone 2 957 64%5.06 6.29 8.68 TX Martin Lake 1 793 54%4.06 27.90 6.24 TX Martin Lake 2 793 54%4.00 30.19 6.22 TX Martin Lake 3 793 62%4.54 35.01 6.52 TX Tolk 1 568 24%1.14 5.73 1.98 TX Tolk 2 568 35%1.76 8.72 2.99 TX W A Parish 5 734 50%2.78 16.00 1.88 TX W A Parish 6 734 57%3.60 22.15 2.15 UT Hunter 1 488 72%2.88 2.35 6.38 UT Hunter 2 488 75%2.76 2.34 5.96 UT Hunter 3 496 72%2.82 2.41 8.69 UT Huntington 1 498 71%2.79 2.75 6.03 UT Huntington 2 498 52%2.07 1.54 4.39 WY Jim Bridger 1 578 58%2.75 4.14 5.59 WY Jim Bridger 2 578 61%2.90 4.87 5.38 WY Naughton 1 163 87%1.31 2.21 2.92 WY Naughton 2 218 84%1.56 2.53 3.58 WY Wyodak 1 362 62%2.22 3.50 5.28 Total 12,579 62.83 232.52 112.06 Source: Sierra Club Analysis of EIA and EPA data. Note: Excludes Coleto Creek, Harrington 1-2, Welsh 1 in TX, which have proposed retirement dates. In addition, Conservation Organizations’ letter from June 8, 2021 identifies two cement plants in PA (Lafarge Whitehall and Lehigh Evansville) as facilities with significant deficiencies in the 2019 state BART plan. 6 To: KC Becker, Region 8 Administrator, EPA From:City of Moab Subject:Clean Air Act Regional Haze Program Date:February 8, 2022 The City of Moab requests the EPA require the Hunter and Huntington coal power plants to comply with emissions reductions consistent with the best-available retrofit technology determined by the 2016 Federal Implementation Plan as per the Clean Air Act’s Regional Haze Program Round 1 requirements. This plan would cut haze-causing nitrogen-oxide emissions by 76% from Utah’s two major coal plants, and would support the Biden administration’s stated interests in climate change action and clean energy development, and in addition to cleaning up the air for our community, our visitors, and our national parks. Moab is the gateway community to Arches and Canyonlands National Parks, in addition to miles of world-renowned trails providing recreation opportunities for over three million national and international visitors per year. We have unparalleled desert vistas which are a national treasure. The eye can only see as far as the air is clear, however, and haze from air pollution has detrimental effects on not only the views, but our community’s health and safety as well. There is an opportunity already in place to prevent a majority of this air pollution, the EPA only needs to support it. The 2016 Federal Implementation Plan lays out a cost-effective route to decrease pollution from the two large coal plants in our region, and over 106,600 people have already submitted comments in support of pollution controls as per this plan. The City of Moab supports the enforcement of the Clean Air Act’s provisions and the installation of nitrogen oxide pollution controls on the Hunter and Huntington coal plants to protect our clean air. The Regional Haze Program is designed to return our national parks to natural visibility by 2064. If coal-powered air pollution is allowed to continue unabated, this goal will never be met. Pacificorp’s 2021 Integrated Resource Plan states that they plan to keep the Huntington plant open until 2036 and the Hunter plant burning until 2042. This is 14 and 20 years, respectively, of haze-causing air pollution that could be avoided with the implementation of the 2016 FIP requirements. Our city was proud to host Region 8 Administrator Sean McGrath in 2015, as the EPA deliberated the initial Utah round 1 FIP designation. We would like to invite the current Region 8 Administrator, KC Becker, to visit and listen to the concerns of our community, as this issue deserves careful consideration. Our City’s economic and public health depend on clean air and clear skies. The EPA has the opportunity to keep them that way. Sincerely, _________________________________ Joette Langianese, Mayor ORDINANCE NO. 2022-03 AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING THE CITY OF MOAB PAY PLAN SCHEDULE AND ADOPTING THE EXEMPT AND ELECTED OFFICIALS SALARIES FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022-2023 WHEREAS, the Moab City Policies Manual allows that pay ranges may be adjusted periodically for comparable work in other municipalities; and WHEREAS, the Moab City Polices Manual calls for annual surveys of salaries; and WHEREAS, in 2021 the City conducted a comprehensive salary survey through the utilization of Personnel Systems Inc. and has presented the survey results to the Governing Body; and WHEREAS, positions within the City are rated and ranked according to four factors: Job Knowledge, Responsibility, Difficulty, and Work Environment and salaries are calculated based on those ratings and rankings and incorporated into the pay plan schedule; and WHEREAS, the proposed “City of Moab 2022-2023 Pay Plan” is attached to this Ordinance as Attachment A, respectively; and WHEREAS, the proposed “Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries” is attached to this ordinance as Attachment B, respectively; and WHEREAS, Moab Municipal Code Section 2.44.010 states that all salaries of the elective and appointive officers of the City and the other employees of the City shall be fixed by a motion or resolution of the City Council as in accordance with existing law. NOW, THEREFORE, WE, THE GOVERNING BODY OF THE CITY OF MOAB RESOLVE TO ADOPT The City of Moab 2022-2023 Pay Plan (Attachment A) and the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries (Attachment B) as referred herein. DATED this 22nd day of March 2022. SIGNED ___________________________________________ Joette Langianese Mayor ATTEST: ____________________________________ Sommar Johnson City Recorder Ordinance #2022-03 March 22, 2022 ATTACHMENT B Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries Section 1. The following are exempt positions: City Engineer……………………………………….. See approved pay plan City Manager……………………………………….. See approved pay plan City Recorder……………………………………….. See approved pay plan City Treasurer………………………………………. See approved pay plan Deputy City Manager…………………………… See approved pay plan Finance Director………………………………….. See approved pay plan Human Resource Director……………………. See approved pay plan Park, Recreation & Trails Director………… See approved pay plan Planning Director…………………………………. See approved pay plan Police Chief………………………………………….. See approved pay plan Public Works Director………………………….. See approved pay plan Section 2. Yearly salary rates for the following elected official positions: Mayor………………………………………………….. $41,057 Councilmembers………………………………….. $33,817 Planning Commission Members…………… $75 per meeting Information about all Moab City financial transactions can be found at: http://www.utah.gov/transparency Ordinance #2022-03 – Attachment B JOB TITLE Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum Administrative Assistant - Admin $20.96 $26.20 $31.44 $43,593 $54,491 $65,389 Administrative Assistant - Planning $20.96 $26.20 $31.44 $43,593 $54,491 $65,389 Administrative Assistant - Public Works $20.96 $26.20 $31.44 $43,593 $54,491 $65,389 Administrative Assistant II - Evidence $23.27 $29.09 $34.91 $48,403 $60,503 $72,604 Administrative Assistant II - FATPOT $22.85 $28.57 $34.28 $47,535 $59,418 $71,302 Animal Shelter Manager $25.80 $32.25 $38.71 $53,672 $67,090 $80,508 Aquatic Mechanical Manager $26.81 $33.52 $40.22 $55,774 $69,718 $83,661 Aquatics Manager $27.18 $33.97 $40.77 $56,533 $70,666 $84,800 Arts Director $29.00 $36.26 $43.51 $60,330 $75,413 $90,495 Assistant City Engineer $29.18 $36.48 $43.78 $60,702 $75,878 $91,054 Assistant City Engineer - GIS $27.86 $34.83 $41.79 $57,951 $72,438 $86,926 Assistant City Planner $25.54 $31.92 $38.31 $53,118 $66,397 $79,676 Associate Arts Director $22.32 $27.90 $33.48 $46,419 $58,024 $69,629 Associate Sports Director $23.47 $29.34 $35.21 $48,822 $61,027 $73,233 Building Official $35.74 $44.68 $53.62 $74,349 $92,937 $111,524 City Attorney $54.11 $67.63 $81.16 $112,540 $140,675 $168,810 City Engineer $44.12 $55.15 $66.18 $91,766 $114,707 $137,648 City Manager $65.29 $79.98 $94.67 $135,802 $166,358 $196,913 City Recorder $37.26 $46.57 $55.89 $77,499 $96,873 $116,248 City Treasurer $36.31 $45.39 $54.47 $75,535 $94,419 $113,303 Code Compliance $27.38 $34.23 $41.08 $56,958 $71,198 $85,438 Code Enforcement I/Animal Control $19.78 $24.72 $29.67 $41,141 $51,426 $61,711 Code Enforcement II/Animal Control $22.48 $28.11 $33.73 $46,767 $58,459 $70,151 Code Enforcement Supervisor/Animal Control $27.72 $34.65 $41.58 $57,660 $72,075 $86,490 Communications and Engagement $35.51 $44.38 $53.26 $73,851 $92,313 $110,776 Construction Inspector $31.86 $39.83 $47.80 $66,277 $82,847 $99,416 Deputy City Manager $55.03 $68.79 $82.54 $114,460 $143,075 $171,690 Deputy Recorder I $21.18 $26.48 $31.77 $44,056 $55,070 $66,084 Deputy Recorder II $25.23 $31.54 $37.84 $52,478 $65,597 $78,717 Deputy Treasurer I $21.07 $26.34 $31.61 $43,834 $54,792 $65,750 Deputy Treasurer II $24.23 $30.28 $36.34 $50,391 $62,989 $75,587 Finance Director $53.33 $66.66 $80.00 $110,930 $138,662 $166,395 Human Resource Assistant $25.71 $32.14 $38.56 $53,474 $66,842 $80,211 Human Resource Director $49.57 $61.97 $74.36 $103,114 $128,892 $154,671 Moab Arts Assistant (part time) $19.37 $24.21 $29.05 $40,283 $50,354 $60,425 Parks, Recreation & Trails Director $38.30 $47.88 $57.46 $79,673 $99,591 $119,510 Permit Technician $21.55 $26.94 $32.33 $44,833 $56,041 $67,249 Planning Director $43.49 $54.36 $65.23 $90,457 $113,072 $135,686 Police Office Manager $25.62 $32.03 $38.44 $53,298 $66,623 $79,947 Safety Specialist $26.02 $32.52 $39.03 $54,121 $67,651 $81,181 Senior Projects Manager $26.41 $33.01 $39.62 $54,937 $68,671 $82,405 Sports Director $29.15 $36.44 $43.72 $60,631 $75,788 $90,946 Sustainability Director $29.38 $36.73 $44.07 $61,116 $76,395 $91,674 Victim Assistance Unit Manager $26.74 $33.42 $40.11 $55,614 $69,518 $83,421 Zoning Administrator $27.17 $33.96 $40.76 $56,516 $70,645 $84,774 Annual Pay Rates Pay Range Pay Range City of Moab General Proposed Pay Plan 2022-2023 (5.9% COLA) Hourly Pay Rates JOB TITLE Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum Detective $31.51 $39.39 $47.27 $65,550 $81,938 $98,325 Investigations Sergeant $37.42 $46.77 $56.12 $77,827 $97,283 $116,740 Police Assistant Chief $42.32 $52.90 $63.48 $88,026 $110,032 $132,039 Police Chief $54.91 $68.64 $82.37 $114,216 $142,770 $171,324 Police Officer I $27.58 $34.48 $41.37 $57,368 $71,709 $86,051 Police Officer II $28.84 $36.05 $43.26 $59,990 $74,987 $89,985 Police Officer III $32.55 $40.69 $48.82 $67,700 $84,625 $101,550 Police Sergeant $36.97 $46.22 $55.46 $76,903 $96,129 $115,355 School Resource Officer $29.37 $36.71 $44.06 $61,090 $76,363 $91,636 Pay Range Pay Range City of Moab Police Proposed Pay Plan 22-23 (5.9% COLA) Hourly Pay Rates Annual Pay Rates JOB TITLE Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum Facilities Lead $34.81 $43.52 $52.22 $72,412 $90,515 $108,617 Facilities Mechanical Technician $24.73 $30.91 $37.09 $51,430 $64,287 $77,145 Facilities Worker I $20.77 $25.96 $31.15 $43,195 $53,994 $64,793 Facilities Worker II $21.15 $26.44 $31.72 $43,992 $54,989 $65,987 Facilities Worker III $25.02 $31.28 $37.53 $52,044 $65,055 $78,066 Fleet Mechanic II $25.13 $31.41 $37.69 $52,265 $65,331 $78,397 Fleet Mechanic III $30.11 $37.64 $45.17 $62,638 $78,298 $93,957 Parks Lead $38.07 $47.58 $57.10 $79,178 $98,973 $118,768 Parks Worker I $22.18 $27.72 $33.27 $46,132 $57,665 $69,198 Parks Worker II $23.38 $29.23 $35.08 $48,639 $60,798 $72,958 Parks Worker III $27.87 $34.83 $41.80 $57,960 $72,450 $86,941 Public Works Director $47.47 $59.33 $71.20 $98,729 $123,411 $148,093 Sewer Collections I $23.20 $29.00 $34.81 $48,264 $60,330 $72,396 Sewer Collections II $25.10 $31.38 $37.65 $52,214 $65,268 $78,322 Sewer Collections III $28.86 $36.08 $43.29 $60,034 $75,042 $90,050 Streets Lead $37.72 $47.15 $56.58 $78,456 $98,070 $117,684 Streets Worker I $22.50 $28.13 $33.75 $46,806 $58,507 $70,209 Streets Worker II $25.03 $31.29 $37.55 $52,068 $65,085 $78,102 Streets Worker III $28.94 $36.18 $43.42 $60,204 $75,256 $90,307 Water Lead $40.00 $50.00 $60.00 $83,205 $104,006 $124,807 Water Worker I $23.66 $29.57 $35.48 $49,204 $61,505 $73,806 Water Worker II $25.32 $31.65 $37.98 $52,666 $65,832 $78,999 Water Worker III $29.11 $36.39 $43.67 $60,555 $75,693 $90,832 WRF Superintendent $41.60 $52.00 $62.40 $86,524 $108,155 $129,786 WRF Worker II $25.40 $31.75 $38.10 $52,833 $66,041 $79,249 Pay Range Pay Range City of Moab Public Works Proposed Pay Plan 22-23 (5.9% COLA) Hourly Pay Rates Annual Pay Rates PUBLIC HEARING DOCUMENT ORDINANCE #2022-06 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 3 OF THE MOAB MUNICIPAL CODE TO INCLUDE CHAPTER 3.50, MASTER FEE SCHEDULE AND MODIFYING CERTAIN FEES AND RATES CHARGED BY THE CITY The following entries describe the intent and purpose of the City of Moab (“City”) of this ordinance: a. The City desires to update or create new fees for the following items (see Master Fee schedule attachment A for current and proposed fees): • Add -Business Licenses - Administration fee for business change of address applications (excluding home occupations) • Remove – Business Licenses - Retail beer licenses • Update – Record Request - Break out color copies • Update – Deposits required for city-provided utilities • Update – Culinary water rates • Update – Other culinary water fees • Add – Sewer rates - After hour service fee for septage dumps • Update – Business license – conducting business prior to obtaining the proper license • Update - Police services fees – Police report, copy of • Update - Parks and facilities rentals fees – Private use • Update - Parks and facilities rentals fees –Day camp rates • Update/remove – Moab Arts and Recreation center fees • Update – Dogs and cats – Replacement tag for dogs and cats, Impound fees, and adoption fees • Update/Add - Miscellaneous fees – penalty charge for AR and rental fee for conference room and council chambers. b. The City Council held a duly advertised public hearing during a regularly scheduled meeting on March 22, 2022, to hear evidence and public comment, and to review the Master Fee schedule. NOW, THEREFORE, the Council hereby ordains that the following amendments to the Moab Municipal Code 3.50, Master Fee Schedule, are adopted as noted in Attachment A PASSED AND APPROVED by majority of the City of Moab City Council. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage. SIGNED: _______________________________ ____________________________ Joette Langianese, Mayor Date ATTEST: ________________________________ Sommar Johnson, Recorder Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 1 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Chapter 3.50 MASTER FEE SCHEDULE Sections: 3.50.050 Business licenses. 3.50.060 Special event and street performer permits. 3.50.070 Records requests. 3.50.080 Deposit required for City-provided utilities. 3.50.090 Culinary water rates. 3.50.100 Sanitary sewer rates. 3.50.110 Storm water rates. 3.50.120 Trash and recycling rates. 3.50.130 Culinary water connection fees. 3.50.140 Culinary water impact fees. 3.50.150 Sanitary Sewer Connection Fees. 3.50.160 Sanitary sewer impact fees. 3.50.165 Building Service Fees. 3.50.170 Planning and engineering service fees. 3.50.180 Civil code violation penalties (maximum fines noted). 3.50.190 Police services fees. 3.50.200 Public Works staff and equipment fees. 3.50.210 Parks and facilities rental fees. 3.50.220 Moab Arts and Recreation Center fees. 3.50.230 Moab Recreation and Aquatic Center fees. 3.50.240 City sports fees. 3.50.250 Dogs and cats. 3.50.260 Miscellaneous fees. Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 2 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.050 Business licenses. Initial Renewal General business $99.00 $26.00 Vendor $214.00 $52.00 Vendor – ice cream truck $222.00 $52.00 Solicitor, peddler, merchant $111.00 $52.00 Nightly rentals, 3 units or less $116.00 $26.00 Nightly rental, more than 3 units $145.00 $26.00 Home occupation $0 $0 Administration fee for business change of address application (excluding home occupation) $25.00 each request Retail beer licenses Bar establishment $500.00 $500.00 Beer, recreational $200.00 $200.00 Hotel $500.00 $500.00 Off-premises sales $90.00 $90.00 Restaurant $200.00 $200.00 Tavern $500.00 $500.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 20-05 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.060 Special event and street performer permits. Event application fee $50.00 Commented [MM1]: We currently do not charge for  changes that require documentation to be updated and  signatures be obtained for change of address. The process is  the same as if they were applying for a new license.   Commented [MM2]: We no longer issue retail beer  license per ordinance 2020‐05.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 3 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Special event, Level 1* $466.00 Special event, Level 2* City may require a cash deposit or performance bond for Level II special events to cover estimated costs for damages, cleanup, or loss to public property. Unexpended balance will be returned to event sponsor. $820.00 Street performance permit fee $106.00 Filming permit $149.00 * City may waive fees only for a free speech event (Section 4.13.050). (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.070 Records requests. Record location, retrieval, research, and compilation $25.00/hr B&W photocopies for 8.5" x 11" $0.15 B&W photocopies for 8.5" x 11" double-sided $0.30 B&W photocopies for 11" x 14" $0.20 B&W photocopies for 11" x 14" double-sided $0.45 B&W photocopies for 11" x 17" $0.30 B&W photocopies for 11" x 17" double-sided $0.60 Color photocopies for 8.5" x 11" $0.50 Color photocopies for 8.5" x 11" double-sided $1.00 Color photocopies for 11" x 14" $0.75 Color photocopies for 11" x 14" double-sided $1.50 Color photocopies for 11" x 17" $1.00 Color photocopies for 11" x 17" double-sided $2.00 Commented [MM3]: Finance Director asked fees be  updated to breakout color copies.   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 4 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Citizens requesting personal copies are to be charged at rate listed above Color copies are double the costs above (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.080 Deposit required for City-provided utilities. This section applies to City water, sewer, garbage services. A deposit may be required from any customer at any time if payment record requires one. All deposits made with the City are noninterest bearing. After one year the account will be reviewed and the deposit refunded if payment history shows twelve current consecutive payments. Deposit may be waived for existing customers in good-standing payment status at the discretion of the City Treasurer. Owners of single-family residential dwelling $25.00100.00 Small business and retail establishments having an average monthly service charge $50.00200.00 Large commercial and industrial users 2 times the highest water bill for service location New Large commercial and industrial users $2,000 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 5 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.090 Culinary water rates. 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Residential, within the City - minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gallons) $13.00 minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gal.) $13.65 $14.33 $15.05 $15.80 $16.59 $17.42 $18.29 $19.21 $20.17 Per thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gallons $1.13/thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gal. $1.18 $1.24 $1.30 $1.37 $1.44 $1.51 $1.58 $1.66 $1.75 Per thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gallons $1.50/thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gal. $1.58 $1.65 $1.74 $1.82 $1.91 $2.01 $2.11 $2.22 $2.33 Per thousand for 60,001 or more gallons $1.88/thousand for 60,001 or more gal. $1.97 $2.07 $2.17 $2.28 $2.39 $2.51 $2.64 $2.77 $2.91 Residential, outside the City - minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gallons) $18.85 minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gal.) $19.79 $20.78 $21.82 $22.91 $24.06 $25.26 $26.52 $27.85 $29.24 Per thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gallons $1.50/thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gal. $1.58 $1.65 $1.74 $1.82 $1.91 $2.01 $2.11 $2.22 $2.33 Per thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gallons $2.25/thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gal. $2.36 $2.48 $2.60 $2.73 $2.87 $3.02 $3.17 $3.32 $3.49 Per thousand for 60,001 or more gallons $2.63/thousand for 60,001 or more gal. $2.76 $2.89 $3.04 $3.19 $3.35 $3.52 $3.69 $3.88 $4.07 Commercial, within $37.50 $39.38 $41.34 $43.41 $45.58 $47.86 $50.25 $52.77 $55.40 $58.17 Commented [MM4]: Updated to include Water rates  from 2022 through 2030 that were accepted on June 9,  2020, Agenda item 8.3, Option C. (Ordnance Number  2020‐07)   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 6 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. the City - minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gallons) minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gal.) Per thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gallons $1.50/thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gal. $1.58 $1.65 $1.74 $1.82 $1.91 $2.01 $2.11 $2.22 $2.33 Per thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gallons $2.25/thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gal. $2.36 $2.48 $2.60 $2.73 $2.87 $3.02 $3.17 $3.32 $3.49 Per thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gallons $3.40/thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gal. $3.57 $3.75 $3.94 $4.13 $4.34 $4.56 $4.78 $5.02 $5.27 Per thousand for 50,001 or more gallons $4.25/thousand for 50,001 or more gal. $4.46 $4.69 $4.92 $5.17 $5.42 $5.70 $5.98 $6.28 $6.59 Commercial, outside the City – minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gallons) $44.25 minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gal.) $46.46 $48.79 $51.22 $53.79 $56.48 $59.30 $62.26 $65.38 $68.65 Per thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gallons $3.00/thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gal. $3.15 $3.31 $3.47 $3.65 $3.83 $4.02 $4.22 $4.43 $4.65 Per thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gallons $3.38/thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gal. $3.54 $3.72 $3.91 $4.10 $4.31 $4.52 $4.75 $4.99 $5.24 Per thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gallons $4.25/thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gal. $4.46 $4.69 $4.92 $5.17 $5.42 $5.70 $5.98 $6.28 $6.59 Per thousand for 50,001 or more $4.68/thousand for 50,001 or $4.91 $5.15 $5.41 $5.68 $5.97 $6.26 $6.58 $6.91 $7.25 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 7 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. gallons more gal. Shop water retail fee (City Public Works Yard) – Includes the first 2,000 gallons $32.50 for first 2,000 gallons, $12.75/1,000 gal. $34.13 $35.83 $37.62 $39.50 $41.48 $43.55 $45.73 $48.02 $50.42 Per 1,000 gallons for 2,001 or more gallons $12.75 $13.39 $14.06 $14.76 $15.50 $16.27 $17.09 $17.94 $18.84 $19.78 Shop water government fee (City Public Works Yard) – Includes the first 2,000 gallons $26.00 for first 2,000 gallons, $9.38/1,000 gal. $27.30 $28.67 $30.10 $31.60 $33.18 $34.84 $36.58 $38.41 $40.33 Per thousand for 2,001 or more gallons $9.38 $9.84 $10.34 $10.85 $11.40 $11.97 $12.56 $13.19 $13.85 $14.54 Construction fire hydrant fee – Includes the first 2,000 gallons $32.50 for first 2,000 gallons, $12.75/1,000 gal. $34.13 $35.83 $37.62 $39.50 $41.48 $43.55 $45.73 $48.02 $50.42 Per thousand for 2,001 or more gallons $12.75 $13.39 $14.06 $14.76 $15.50 $16.27 $17.09 $17.94 $18.84 $19.78 Construction fire hydrant rental fee per day $15.00 per day $15.75 $16.54 $17.36 $18.23 $19.14 $20.10 $21.11 $22.16 $23.27 City parks & cemeteries per 1,000 gallons $0.81/1,000 gal. $0.85 $0.89 $0.94 $0.98 $1.03 $1.09 $1.14 $1.20 $1.26 Moab Golf Course Well #7 Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Other Culinary Water Fees Commented [MM5]: Made its own table for formating  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 8 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Water turn-on fee, after failure to pay City water/sewer charges $40.00 during normal working hours; $80.00 after normal working hours Water meter re-read charges The City crew will re-read the customer’s meter. $49.00 The City crew will test a customer’s meter. $49.00 The City crew will change a tested customer’s meter, at the customer’s request. Actual labor costs with a 1-hour minimum The costs incurred for these requests will be paid within 30 days. If that bill is not paid, the water will be turned off until the debt is satisfied, and a reconnect charge (½-hour minimum) during regular hours, or reconnect charge (2-hour minimum) after hours, will be applicable. During regular working hours, actual labor costs with a ½-hour minimum After hours, actual labor costs with a 2-hour minimum If the problem proves to be the City’s responsibility, there will be no charge to the customer. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.100 Sanitary sewer rates. Rates shall be effective on the first full billing cycle of each calendar year. Base Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Single-Family $21.60 $27.00 $29.70 $32.67 $35.94 $38.81 $40.75 $42.79 Multifamily + Overnight Accommodations (1st $19.65 $24.56 $27.02 $29.72 $32.69 $35.31 $37.07 $38.93 Commented [MM6]: Levi requested this be increased to  $40.00 from $25 to cover man hours and cost of vehicle to  drive out to location  Commented [MM7]: Comments from Levi Jones:  Increase fee to $80.00 from $50.00 to cover after hour call  outs and vehicle fee.   Commented [MM8]: Comments from Levi: Update fee  from $10.00 to $49.00 to reflect current fees associated to  vehicle and employee   Commented [MM9]: Comments from Levi: Update fee  from $10.00 to $49.00 to reflect current fees associated to  vehicle and employee  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 9 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Base Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Unit) Charge per Additional Unit $9.45 $11.81 $12.99 $14.29 $15.72 $16.98 $17.83 $18.72 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 1" $21.60 $27.00 $29.70 $32.67 $35.94 $38.81 $40.75 $42.79 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 1.5" $24.85 $31.06 $34.17 $37.59 $41.34 $44.65 $46.88 $49.23 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 2" $33.80 $42.25 $46.48 $51.12 $56.23 $60.73 $63.77 $66.96 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 3" $99.75 $124.69 $137.16 $150.87 $165.96 $179.24 $188.20 $197.61 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 4" $124.20 $155.25 $170.78 $187.85 $206.64 $223.17 $234.33 $246.04 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 5" $181.20 $226.50 $249.15 $274.07 $301.47 $325.59 $341.87 $358.96 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 6" $246.35 $307.94 $338.73 $372.60 $409.86 $442.65 $464.79 $488.03 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 8" $336.25 $420.31 $462.34 $508.58 $559.44 $604.19 $634.40 $666.12 Volume Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Single-Family $1.90 $2.38 $2.61 $2.87 $3.16 $3.41 $3.58 $3.76 Multifamily $2.22 $2.78 $3.05 $3.36 $3.69 $3.99 $4.19 $4.40 Overnight Accommodations $2.22 $2.78 $3.05 $3.36 $3.69 $3.99 $4.19 $4.40 Restaurant/Fast Food $3.41 $4.26 $4.69 $5.16 $5.67 $6.13 $6.43 $6.76 Other Nonresidential $2.22 $2.78 $3.05 $3.36 $3.69 $3.99 $4.19 $4.40 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 10 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Base Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Wastewater and septage discharge into municipal treatment works $180.00/1,000 gallons After our service fee for septage dumps $150.00 (Ord. 21-19 Exh. A (Option A), 2021; Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.110 Storm water rates. Residential, month for single- and two-household homes on a single lot $4.50 All other uses (commercial or residential)/month/storm water ERU.* One (1) ERU minimum. $4.50 * Every 3,000 ft2 of impervious surface =1 ERU; every 6,000 ft2 of semi-impervious surface area = 1 ERU (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.120 Trash and recycling rates. Residential Service (monthly) Trash cart size Frequency 65 gal. Every other week $12.00 95 gal. Every other week $14.00 65 gal. Weekly $16.00 95 gal. Weekly $18.00 Commented [MM10]: Was on Master fee schedule  approved on 07/2020. Was not showing on the code side of  the master fee schedule. Adding back in to ensure it is  captured back on the master fee schedule posted under the  codes on the website.     Commented [MM11]: Comments from Obe Tejada:  Include an after‐hour service fee for septage dump calls to  open gate up. This fee covers the cost to have an employee  dispatched out to open the gate for the hauler.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 11 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Extra 95 gal. Weekly only $18.00 Recycling cart size Frequency 95 gal. Every other week $12.00 Extra 95 gal. Every other week $12.00 Commercial Service (monthly) Trash cart size Frequency Base rate Extra bin 2 yd. Every other week $40.00 $34.00 1 x a week $64.00 $54.00 2 x a week $120.00 $102.00 3 x a week $182.00 $154.00 4 x a week $243.00 $207.00 5 x a week $307.00 $261.00 6 x a week $387.00 $329.00 7 x a week $482.00 $410.00 3 yd. Every other week $47.00 $40.00 1 x a week $79.00 $67.00 2 x a week $149.00 $126.00 3 x a week $223.00 $189.00 4 x a week $296.00 $252.00 5 x a week $370.00 $315.00 6 x a week $460.00 $391.00 7 x a week $566.00 $481.00 4 yd. Every other week $56.00 $48.00 1 x a week $94.00 $80.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 12 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 2 x a week $177.00 $150.00 3 x a week $262.00 $222.00 4 x a week $348.00 $296.00 5 x a week $435.00 $370.00 6 x a week $537.00 $457.00 7 x a week $656.00 $557.00 6 yd. Every other week $74.00 $63.00 1 x a week $124.00 $105.00 2 x a week $233.00 $198.00 3 x a week $343.00 $291.00 4 x a week $454.00 $386.00 5 x a week $565.00 $481.00 6 x a week $692.00 $589.00 7 x a week $836.00 $710.00 8 yd. Every other week $92.00 $79.00 1 x a week $154.00 $131.00 2 x a week $290.00 $246.00 3 x a week $427.00 $363.00 4 x a week $566.00 $481.00 5 x a week $704.00 $599.00 6 x a week $859.00 $731.00 7 x a week $1,030.00 $876.00 Misc. Services Trash or recycling cart servicing Reload Special pick-up Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 13 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 65 gal. $5.00 $10.00 95 gal. $5.00 $10.00 2 yd. $20.00 $30.00 3 yd. $30.00 $40.00 4 yd. $40.00 $50.00 6 yd. $60.00 $70.00 8 yd. $80.00 $90.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.130 Culinary water connection fees. Connection fees do not include the labor and materials required to complete any asphalt repairs. Owner/requester is responsible for completing this work in accordance with City standards and is subject to final inspection by the City. Within the City (meter size/ERU capacity) Meter provided by City Meter provided by customer 5/8" x 3/4" $1,746.60 $1,114.00 1" $1,932.50 $1,114.00 1½" $2,339.20 $1,212.00 2" $2,577.40 $1,212.00 3" $4,828.80 $1,506.00 4" $5,500.90 $1,506.00 6" $7,501.60 $1,506.00 Outside City Limit – additional 5% (meter size/ERU capacity) Meter provided by City Meter provided by customer Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 14 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 5/8" x 3/4" $1,833.93 $1,169.70 1" $2,029.13 $1,169.70 1½" $2,456.16 $1,272.60 2" $2,706.27 $1,272.60 3" $5,070.24 $1,581.30 4" $5,775.95 $1,581.30 6" (includes the meter) $7,876.68 $1,581.30 Fire sprinkler system connection fee Actual cost to perform the connection Fire hydrant connection fee Actual cost of installation Fire hydrant meter deposit $2,000.00 $2,000.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.140 Culinary water impact fees. Within the City (meter size/ERU capacity) 5/8" x 3/4"/1.0 $478.00 1"/3.7 $1,769.00 1½"/11.0 $5,528.00 2"/22.9 $10,946.00 4"/n-a Calculated under lodging rate, see below Outside City Limit (meter size/ERU capacity) 5/8" x 3/4"/1.0 $478.00 1"/3.7 $1,769.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 15 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 1½"/11.0 $5,528.00 2"/22.9 $10,946.00 4"/n-a Calculated under lodging rate, see below Water impact fees for overnight lodging including motels, inns, bed and breakfast establishments, and hotels shall be calculated pursuant to the following schedule: Impact fee/room for lodging without a restaurant: Number of rooms x $229.00 Impact fee/room for lodging with a restaurant: Number of rooms x $330.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.150 Sanitary Sewer Connection Fees. Within the City: 4" line $680.00 6" line $844.00 Outside the City: 4" line $714.00 6" line $886.20 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.160 Sanitary sewer impact fees. Within City Limits Outside of City Limits Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 16 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Allowable units under minimum fee Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum Residential dwellings Single-family (residence) 1 residence $1,566.00 $1,566.00/ residence $1,361.00 $1,361.00/ residence Multifamily, 2 bedrooms or larger (residential unit) 2 units $3,132.00 $1,566.00/unit $2,721.00 $1,361.00/unit Multifamily, 1 bedroom or smaller (residential unit) 2 units $1,754.00 $877.00/unit $1,524.00 $762.00/unit Nightly rental dwellings 2 bedrooms or larger with kitchen (residential unit) 1 unit $1,879.00 $1,879.00/unit $1,633.00 $1,633.00/unit 1 bedroom or smaller with kitchen (residential unit) 1 unit $1,566.00 $1,566.00/unit $1,361.00 $1,361.00/unit Hotel/motel, no kitchen (residential unit) 2 units $2,452.00 $1,226.00/unit $2,130.00 $1,065.00/unit Auto repair (1,000 ft2) 7,000 ft2 $1,768.00 $253.00/ 1,000 ft2 $1,536.00 $219.00/ 1,000 ft2 Bakery (1,000 ft2) 500 ft2 $1,793.00 $3,585.00/ 1,000 ft2 $2,190.00 $4,380.00/ 1,000 ft2 Bank (1,000 ft2) 2,000 ft2 $1,566.00 $783.00/1,000 ft2 $1,361.00 $680.00/1,000 ft2 Beauty/barber shop (chair) 4 chairs $1,566.00 $392.00/chair $1,361.00 $340.00/chair Campground (campsite) 2 campsites $2,463.00 $1,231.00/ campsite $2,139.00 $1,070.00/ campsite Car wash – automatic (each) 1 each $12,575.00 $12,575.00/ each $9,510.00 $9,510.00/each Car wash – wand (wands) 1 wand $6,288.00 $6,288.00/ $4,755.00 $4,755.00/ Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 17 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Within City Limits Outside of City Limits Allowable units under minimum fee Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum wand wand Commercial (1,000 ft2) 7,000 ft2 $1,687.00 $241.00/1,000 ft2 $1,465.00 $209.00/1,000 ft2 Dry cleaner (1,000 ft2) 2,000 ft2 $1,574.00 $787.00/1,000 ft2 $1,866.00 $622.00/1,000 ft2 Fast food (1,000 ft2) 500 ft2 $2,825.00 $5,650.00/ 1,000 ft2 $2,724.00 $5,447.00/ 1,000 ft2 Gas station/convenience store (1,000 ft2) 4,000 ft2 $1,740.00 $435.00/1,000 ft2 $1,512.00 $378.00/1,000 ft2 Grocery store (1,000 ft2) 4,000 ft2 $2,021.00 $505.00/1,000 ft2 $1,756.00 $439.00/1,000 ft2 Laundromat (washers) 2 washers $1,767.00 $884.00/washer $1,320.00 $660.00/washer Office (1,000 ft2) 4,000 ft2 $1,566.00 $392.00/1,000 ft2 $1,361.00 $340.00/1,000 ft2 Restaurant (seats) 12 seats $2,650.00 $221.00/seat $2,704.00 $225.00/seat Retail (1,000 ft2) 7,000 ft2 $1,687.00 $241.00/1,000 ft2 $1,465.00 $209.00/1,000 ft2 School (students) 15 students $1,566.00 $104.00/student $1,361.00 $91.00/student Theater (seats) 150 seats $1,620.00 $11.00/seat $1,407.00 $9.00/seat Warehouse (1,000 ft2) 10,000 ft2 $1,649.00 $165.00/1,000 ft2 $1,432.00 $143.00/1,000 ft2 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.165 Building Service Fees. Building, temporary, during construction on a lot – bond RV: $200.00 Mobile home: $500.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 18 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Building permit (by total valuation) $1.00 to $500.00 $65.00 $501.00 to $2,000.00 $65.00 for the first $500.00 plus $3.66 for each additional $100.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $2,000.00 $2,001.00 to $25,000.00 $119.90 for the first $2,000.00 plus $16.80 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $25,000.00 $25,001.00 to $50,000.00 $506.30 for the first $25,000.00 plus $12.12 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $50,000.00 $50,001.00 to $100,000.00 $809.30 for the first $50,000.00 plus $8.40 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $100,000.00 $100,001.00 to $500,000.00 $1,229.30 for the first $100,000.00 plus $6.72 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $500,000.00 $500,001.00 to $1,000,000.00 $3,917.30 for the first $500,000.00 plus $6.72 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $1,000,000.00 $1,000,001.00 and up $7,277.30 for the first $1,000,000.00 plus $6.72 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof Building permit, miscellaneous Demo permit $25.00/unit Garage up to 600 sq feet (plus plan review) $195.00/permit Manufactured or mobile home into park $195.00/unit Manufactured home on private property (not into park) $260.00/unit Modular home (plus plan review; requires third-party ICC inspections to be performed at factory) $455.00/unit Residential swimming pool (plus plan review) $260.00/permit Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 19 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Roofing permit $1.00 per 100 sq feet with $65.00 minimum fee RV park infrastructure $195.00/5 sites Separate mechanical, electrical, and/or plumbing permits $65.00/inspection Solar – roof mount (plus plan review) $130.00/permit Solar – ground mount (plus plan review) $195.00/permit Inspections Inspections for which no fee is specifically listed $65.00/inspection Inspections outside of normal business hours Actual costs plus 10% Re-inspection fees assessed under provisions of Section 305.8 due prior to the re-inspection Actual costs plus 10% Plan review – commercial Nonrefundable commercial plan deposit for initial plan review only for new construction, tenant finish, and/or major remodel 10% building permit fee; $260.00 minimum Commercial plan review and additional plan review(s) required due to changes, corrections, additions, and/or revisions to plans $65.00/hr; 1-hour minimum charge Deferred submittal (prior approval by the Building Official required) $130.00/submittal Outside consultants (plan review and/or inspections) Actual costs plus 10% Plan review – residential Nonrefundable residential plan review deposit (new construction only) $130.00/permit Residential plan review and additional plan review required for changes, corrections, additions, change of contractor, owner or other information, and/or revisions to plans $65.00/hr; 1-hour minimum Actual costs calculated by including 10% administrative and overhead costs. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 20 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.170 Planning and engineering service fees. Administrative costs (research) $50.00/hr Amended plats (boundary adjustment) $250.00 plus $25.00/amended lot or unit Annexation $600.00 (flat rate) Appeal authority submittal $450.00 Application withdrawal fee 50% of collected fee if prior to advertising Cemetery application fee $100.00 Cemetery bond 150% of total cost of improvements Condominiums and condominium conversions $350.00 plus $50.00/unit Code amendment application $350.00 Construction bond In every construction contract where there is a modification of bonding requirements, or where no bonding is required (e.g., contracts under $50,000.00 in value), the construction contract shall contain one or more alternative security mechanisms to secure performance by the contractor and/or payment to subcontractors, laborers, and material suppliers. Alternative security mechanisms may include: (1) an irrevocable letter of credit payable to the City; (2) a first position deed of trust on real property; (3) a cash deposit to be held by the City; or (4) other collateral, contract, or security instruments as approved by the City Attorney. Floodplain development permits and elevation certificates $90.00 Floodplain reviews – for floodway and floodplain interpretations, delineations and reviews that exceed 1 hour. $50.00/hr Grading/excavation permit Required for >50 cubic yards or cuts or fills exceeding 10' deep or height $50.00/each 100 cubic yards Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 21 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. General plan amendment $350.00 Hillside development permits $300.00 + $50.00/hr of staff review time that exceeds 10 hours Hillside development – improvements and restoration bond Amount reasonably calculated to cover anticipated costs for improvements, as determined by City Planning Director Improvements agreement Financial assurance 110% of the approved construction costs Warranty deposit 10% of the approved construction costs Landscaping – bond for new developments in summer and winter months Amount reasonably calculated to cover anticipated costs for improvements, as determined by City Planning Director Large-scale projects – dee structure for developers to underwrite City staff expenses Amount reasonably calculated to cover anticipated costs for improvements, as determined by City Planning Director Large-scale projects – over 30,000 ft2 – landscaping deposit For completion of landscaping, in the event corrections cannot be made or installation cannot be completed prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy. 1½ the cost of the landscaping project Maps D or E size (>2’): $25.00 Digital files: $20.00 Master planned developments and planned unit development – application (A separate fee is to be collected for preliminary and final plats) $200.00 plus $25.00/dwelling unit or $25.00/ 3,000 ft2 of floor area for commercial buildings Master planned developments and planned unit development – bond As required on a case by case basis by the City Planning Director Mobile, manufactured or modular home parks and/or subdivisions – application $200.00 plus $25.00/unit or lot Mobile home parks – bond Amount equal to the estimated cost, plus 50% of constructing all landscaping, roads, lighting, pedestrian ways, Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 22 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. hard-surfacing, water and sewer lines, storage enclosures and common facilities as shown on the final plan. Occupancy – cash-only bond if given permission by City Planner or designee to occupy prior to completion of building 150% of the cost of completing all required work, plus all administrative costs as determined by the governing body. Parking, fee-in-lieu. Due prior to issuance of a building permit. $8,500.00/parking space Plan check fee 65% of the building permit fee for plans that are sent out to a professional plan checker; or $30.00/hour for plans that are checked by staff, with a $30.00 minimum. Planned affordable development (PAD) $50.00/1,000 ft2 of building floor area Planning applications – miscellaneous $100.00 Pre-application conference (sketch plan reviews) $100.00 to be credited toward application fee Professional services Actual costs plus 10% Reapplication fee $300.00 plus appropriate subdivision plat fees Recording fee Actual costs Recreational vehicle court $200.00 plus $25.00/RV space Right-of-way construction permit $50.00 Sidewalks, curbs, gutters, and street paving, fee-in-lieu. The City Engineer shall calculate by consulting licensed contractors. 110% of the estimated cost of constructing 200 lineal feet of the required improvements. Sign permit $25.00 plus $0.50 for each ft2 above 30 ft2 Sign, temporary – Political campaign signs $15.00 permit Site plan review $50.00/1,000 ft2 of building floor area Site plan review appeal If the record is voluminous, appellant must pay the reasonable costs of assembly and copying of the record. Special exception $100.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 23 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Street numbers, if City has to install $20.00 Subdivisions (A separate fee is to be collected for preliminary and final plats.) $200.00 plus $25.00/lot Subdivisions – bond 1½ times the cost of improvements not previously installed. Trees – removing or damaging City-owned trees without permission The basal area formula and the cost to buy, plant and water replacement trees shall be the basis for the urban forester to determine the replacement cost of the removed or damaged trees. Water & sewer master plan mains extensions – deposit Amount equal to the estimated cost of construction Wireless telecommunications facility – application fee (for each separate monopole, lattice tower, or antenna) $350.00 Zone change application $500.00 Zoning confirmation letter $100.00 *Square foot construction costs are established using the International Code Council’s Building Valuation Data which is updated at 6-month intervals (February and August). Refunds for building permits issued will be limited to 80% of the permit costs, not later than 90 days after the date of fee payment. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.180 Civil code violation penalties (maximum fines noted). Building code violation $500.00/infraction Illegal use of vehicle as dwelling $650.00/day/infraction Nuisances – generally $500.00/day/infraction Solid waste $500.00/infraction and all costs associated with legal fees and cleanup Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 24 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Weed abatement $500.00/day/infraction Unlawful parking, idling, or camping $120.00/infraction or 24-hour period Illegal storm water system dumping $1,000.00/day/Class B misdemeanor Grease trap – installation and/or maintenance compliance $500.00/day/Class B misdemeanor Violation – building code $1,000.00/day/Class B misdemeanor Signs – number of freestanding signs/lot $250.00/infraction Signs – setbacks $350.00/infraction Signs – prohibited signs $250.00/infraction Signs – temporary signs $250.00/infraction Signs – Permit $250.00/infraction Illegal subdivision $650.00/infraction Debris abatement $500.00/infraction Chickens – prohibited uses $250/infraction Chickens – application for permit $15.00 Construction without permit, investigation fee $500/infraction Storage of junk and debris $650.00/day/infraction Mobile home parks – failure to maintain common areas, landscaping, and/or improvements City and its contractors may complete this work and charge all costs (plus 10% administration) to property owner including, but not limited to, labor costs and attorney’s fees Land use violations $650.00/day/infraction Noise $650.00/day/infraction Residential area regulations $650.00/day/infraction Zoning violations generally Class B misdemeanor Business license – conducting business prior to obtaing the proper licensing; $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Commented [MM12]: Updating back to old fee schedule.  We are unsure how this was updated to $650.00 a day last  fee schedule.   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 25 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Business license – operating long-term rental prior to obtaining the proper licensing $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Business license – operating short-term rental prior to obtaining the proper licensing $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Business license – conducting home occupation prior to obtaining the proper licensing $650.00/day/infraction$50 fee Business license – expired or changed name and/or address $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Illegal short-term rental $750.00/day/infraction Signs – off premises $250.00/infraction Burning prohibited $500.00/infraction Nuisance – abate City and its contractors may abate the nuisance and charge all costs (plus 10% administration) to property owner including, but not limited to, labor costs and attorney’s fees Miscellaneous fines and/or penalties As directed in specific code sections (to be used until code revision is completed and adopted) (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.190 Police services fees. Fingerprinting $10.00 Police report, copy of $5.007.50 Driver privilege card digital fingerprints and background check $30.00 Police officers (Time charged begins when the officer leaves his/her residence and ends when he/she returns to his/her residence. If 12-hour notice is not given for cancellation, there is a minimum charge of four hours for each officer requested, plus police $65.00/hr; 4-hour minimum/day Commented [MM13]: Police Chief requested this be  increased to come in line with the county rates they  currently charge.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 26 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. vehicle time.) Police vehicles $100.00/day Evidence disposal $100.00/hour w/ 4-hour minimum (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.200 Public Works staff and equipment fees. Public Works Superintendent $56.00/hr Parks worker $46.00/hr Sewer service worker $47.00/hr Water worker $49.00/hr Street/storm water worker $47.00/hr Other Public Works staff. Includes the time for loading or unloading prior to and after an event Actual cost Overtime service fee 1½ times hourly rate Traffic control and safety equipment 36" cone $0.40/day Vertical flats $0.60/day Signs w/ stand $2.50/day Barrels $0.60/day Candle stick $0.50/day Slide top $5.50/day Barricades $3.00/day Other items and equipment Assessed as needed Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 27 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.210 Parks and facilities rental fees. Rotary Park Pavilion reservation, 4 hours or less $35.00 Pavilion reservation, more than 4 hours $85.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 Old City Park Reservation, 4 hours or less $35.00 Reservation, more than 4 hours $85.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 Amplified music $30.00 Lions Park Pavilion reservation, 4 hours or less $35.00 Pavilion reservation, more than 4 hours $85.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 Amplified music $30.00 Swanny Park (via special event permit only) Grand County Resident Nonresident Less than 25% of park, 4 hours or less $35.00 $55.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 28 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Less than 25% of park, more than 4 hours $85.00 $125.00 Use of more than 25% of park, less than 4 hours $60.00 $75.00 Use of more than 25% of park, 4-8 hours $105.00 $155.00 All day use of entire park $475.00 $600.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 $200.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 $400.00 Center Street Ballfield Nonprofit/resident use (no admission fees) $15.00/hr or $100.00/day Nonprofit/resident use (admission and/or participation fees) $25.00/hr or $150.00/day Commercial use w/no fees $250.00/day Commercial use w/fees $500.00/day Day camp rates $50.00/day Damage and cleanup deposit $150.00 Use of lights $15.00/hr Center Street Gym Private use $250.00/hr Commercial use w/no fees $250.00/day Commercial use w/fees $500.00/day Day camp rates $50.00/day Recurring gym groups (No damage and cleanup deposit required) $10.00/use, capped $100.00/month Damage and cleanup deposit $200.00 Sun Court Reservations 3 hours or less $40.00 Commented [MM14]: Comment from Annie McVay:  Center Street Gym:  Change use to $25/hour (to be  consistent with MARC and MRAC rentals)  Commented [MM15]: Comment from Annie McVay: Add  Day camp rate of $50/day to the gym to be consistent with  ball fields.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 29 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Reservations more than 3 hours $75.00 Other areas not listed $25.00/day (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.220 Moab Arts and Recreation Center fees. Room rentals (art events, classes, programs, workshops, public meetings, etc.; one-time or ongoing) Dance room upstairs $25.00/hr, $19200.00/day Stage room upstairs $25.00/hr, $19200.00/day Foyer upstairs $25.00/hr, $19200.00/day Side yard $250.00/hr, $15200.00/day Downstairs studio/kitchen $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Downstairs conference room $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Entire facility $100.00/hr, $700.00/day Artillery (community art room) $20.00/hr or $140.00/day Private parties (weddings, receptions, birthdays, etc.) Dance room upstairs $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Stage room upstairs $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Foyer upstairs $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Side yard $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Downstairs studio/kitchen $20.00/hr, $150.00/day Downstairs meeting room $20.00/hr, $150.00/day Entire facility $125.00/hr, $980.00/day Commented [MM16]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Change day rentals from Dance Room to Sideyard to  $200.  (It seemed cleaner than $190)  Commented [MM17]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Change Sideyard to $25 hr/$200 day to be consistent.  Commented [MM18]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Delete ‘Entire Facility’ ‐we no longer want this as an option.  Commented [MM19]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Eliminate the second category of rates for ‘private parties’  the one that is $35/hour, we don’t utilize it and it’s  confusing.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 30 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Private party deposit (refundable/excludes weddings) $500.00 Wedding fee (includes rental and planning services) $2,000.00 Private party room rental $25.00/hr or $190.00/day Any event with alcohol $75.00/event additional Coworking fees Daily membership $15.00 Monthly membership $75.00 ARTillery studio monthly membership $75.00 Discounts available (one/agreement) Local nonprofit (501(c)3, church, school, etc.) 50% discount Moab-area local multi-day rentals 20% discount Moab-area local private party 10% discount Moab City employee 20% discount Equipment rentals PA/sound system $75.00/day Digital projector $25.00/day Screen $20.00/day Tables (included if renting space) $10.00/day/table Chairs (included if renting space) $2.00/day/chair Easels (included if renting space) $2.00/day/easel Yoga mats and blocks $1.00/piece/day (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) Commented [MM20]: Comments from Annie McVay:  delete ‘excludes weddings’  a deposit is appropriate for  weddings  Commented [MM21]: Comments from Annie McVay:  delete planning services as they are not offered.  Commented [MM22]: Kelley requested these be added  as they are current fees charged at the MARC.   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 31 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.230 Moab Recreation and Aquatic Center fees. Aquatic Only or Fitness Only Daily admission Resident Nonresident 3 and under Free $1.00 Youth 4-17 individual (aquatic) $3.00 $5.00 Youth 14-17 individual (fitness) $3.00 $5.00 Adult 18+ individual $5.00 $10.00 Senior 55+ individual $3.00 $5.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $15.00 $30.00 Annual pass Youth 4-17 individual $115.00 Adult 18+ individual $170.00 Senior 55+ individual $125.00 Adult couple $250.00 Senior couple $200.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $320.00 Additional family member $50.00 Summer season pass Youth 4-17 individual $75.00 Adult 18+ individual $100.00 Senior 55+ individual $75.00 Adult couple $150.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 32 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior couple $115.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $200.00 Additional family member $40.00 6-month pass Youth 4-17 individual $90.00 Adult 18+ individual $120.00 Senior 55+ individual $90.00 Adult couple $170.00 Senior couple $130.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $210.00 Additional family member $40.00 3-month pass Youth 4-17 individual $70.00 Adult 18+ individual $85.00 Senior 55+ individual $70.00 Adult couple $135.00 Senior couple $110.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $165.00 Additional family member $30.00 Monthly Youth 4-17 individual $35.00 Adult 18+ individual $45.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 33 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior 55+ individual $35.00 Adult couple $70.00 Senior couple $50.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $85.00 Additional family member $10.00 25-punch card Youth 4-17 individual $60.00 Adult 18+ individual $100.00 Senior 55+ individual $60.00 1-week family aquatic only pass $100.00 Aquatic and Fitness Combined Daily admission Resident Nonresident 3 and under N/A N/A Student 14-17 individual $5.00 $7.00 Adult 18+ individual $7.00 $15.00 Senior 55+ individual $5.00 $7.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $20.00 $40.00 Annual pass Youth 14-17 individual (fitness) $185.00 Adult 18+ individual $275.00 Senior 55+ individual $200.00 Adult couple $410.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 34 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior couple $320.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $500.00 Additional family member $65.00 Summer season pass Youth 14-17 individual $115.00 Adult 18+ individual $145.00 Senior 55+ individual $115.00 Adult couple $225.00 Senior couple $180.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $300.00 Additional family member $50.00 6-month pass Youth 14-17 individual $125.00 Adult 18+ individual $175.00 Senior 55+ individual $125.00 Adult couple $265.00 Senior couple $210.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $325.00 Additional family member $55.00 3-month pass Youth 14-17 individual $100.00 Adult 18+ individual $135.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 35 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior 55+ individual $100.00 Adult couple $210.00 Senior couple $165.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $265.00 Additional family member $45.00 Monthly Youth 14-17 individual $50.00 Adult 18+ individual $65.00 Senior 55+ individual $50.00 Adult couple $105.00 Senior couple $85.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $135.00 Additional family member $15.00 25-punch card Youth 14-17 individual $100.00 Adult 18+ individual $135.00 Senior 55+ individual $100.00 Annual corporate membership Regular Org. size 4-9 Org. size 10+ Adult 18+ individual $275.00 $250.00 $235.00 Senior 55+ individual $200.00 $175.00 $160.00 Adult couple $410.00 $365.00 $350.00 Senior couple $320.00 $265.00 $250.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 36 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $500.00 $440.00 $415.00 Additional family members $65.00 $65.00 $65.00 MRAC classes Resident Nonresident Swim lessons $40.00 $40.00 Jr. lifeguard course $25.00 $30.00 Class 20-punch pass – members $45.00 $45.00 Class 20-punch pass – nonmembers $75.00 $75.00 Drop-in fee – members $3.00 $3.00 Drop-in fee – nonmembers $5.00 $5.00 Other fees Shower fee $7.00 Child careChildcare – individual $5.00 Swim club registration fee $60.00 Locker rentals $10.00/mo $25.00/3 mo $100.00/yr Room rental fee $25.00/hr Wibit rental fee $25.00/rental (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.240 City sports fees. First Kicks 3-4 yrs old $20.00 Spring soccer 5 yrs old-4th grade $40.00 + $10.00 uniform Spring soccer 5th grade-8th grade $60.00 (uniform included) Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 37 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Spring youth volleyball 3rd-8th grade $50.00 reg + $30.00 uniform Li’l Tykes T-ball 3-4 yrs old $20.00 T-ball kindergarten $40.00 Coach pitch boys 1st + 2nd grade $45.00 Coach pitch girls 1st + 2nd grade $45.00 Baseball/softball 3rd-8th grade $80.00 Adult soccer 15+ $25.00 Frisbee golf tournament 15+ $25.00/person, $40.00/team Adult softball league 15+ $275.00/team Adult pickleball tournament 15+ $50.00/individual, $75.00/team Fall youth soccer 5 yrs old – 3rd grade $40.00 Tackle football 4th – 7th grade $85.00 NFL flag football 1st – 4th grade $50.00 Fall youth volleyball 3rd – 6th grades $45.00 Adult flag football 15+ $150.00/team Adult volleyball 15+ (winter/summer) $30.00/season (drop-in) Adult volleyball league 15+ $150.00/team Adult basketball league 15+ $100.00/team Adult spring basketball tournament 15+ $100.00/team (discount with item above to $175.00/team) Jr. Jazz basketball 3rd – 6th grades $65.00 (includes full uniform) Youth indoor soccer 7th – 12th grades $45.00 Adult indoor soccer 15+ $30.00/season (drop-in) Ultimate frisbee 15+ $10.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 38 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Ultimate frisbee tournament 15+ $75.00/team (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.250 Dogs and cats. Annual license fee for unneutered or unspayed dogs and cats (May be waived for in-service or assistant dogs) $25.00 No fee for lifetime license of neutered dogs and cats. $0 Replacement tag for dogs and cats $25.0010.00 Breeder $100.00 annually Guard dog permit Expires in 1 year. Not transferable to any other location. $100.00 plus applicable registration fee Impoundment fees for dogs and cats; fines for no tag. May be applied to the cost of spaying or neutering the dog or cat. Cats: $430.00 + $5.00/day of impoundment Dogs: $430.00 + $10.00/day of impoundment Impounded, registered, unspayed or unneutered dog or cat, taken 2 times in 12 months. Owner must pay spay or neuter deposit. Fee refunded if owner spays or neuters within 30 days of release. $50.00 refundable deposit, if animal is spayed or neutered within 30 days of release Shelter relinquishment fees Cats if altered and current on rabies vaccination $25.00 Cats if unaltered and not current on rabies vaccination $50.00 Cats if altered and not current on rabies vaccination $35.00 Dogs if altered and current on rabies vaccination $35.00 Dogs if altered and not current on rabies vaccination $45.00 Commented [MM23]: Police Chief and Code  enforcement: We are requesting these fee increases to account for inflation and to better compensate the City for services. The current fees were implemented 15 years ago and have not since been adjusted. Adoption Fee - $50 (increase of $15 from current) Impound Fee - $40 (increase of $10 from current) Replacement Tag - $10 (decrease of $15 from current)   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 39 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Dogs if unaltered and not current on rabies vaccination $45.00 Presentation of strays at shelter (One mother dog with puppies or one mother cat with kittens counts as one stray.) First two presentations of strays: $0 Presentation of strays after first two: $25.00/stray Adoption fees (Deposit is refundable upon presentation of proof of spay/neuter and rabies vaccination within 30 days of adoption if animal is over six months of age, and within 6 months if animal is under 6 months of age.) Altered and current on rabies vaccination $35.0050.00 Unaltered and not current on rabies vaccination $35.0050.00 + $50.00 deposit Altered and not current on rabies vaccination $35.0050.00 + $25.00 deposit Rabies quarantine at shelter $15.00/day of quarantine Rabies deposit at shelter. For all animals released without current rabies vaccination. Deposit is refundable if proof of rabies vaccination is provided within 30 days of release. $25.00 Rabies vaccination performed at shelter $25.00 Veterinary fees for reclaimed animals Owners of reclaimed animals shall be charged the actual cost of any veterinary services needed during the impoundment plus 5%. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.260 Miscellaneous fees. Check given as payment to City that is returned for insufficient funds $25.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 40 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Late payment penalty – assessed 10 days after payment due date Commercial accounts – greater of 3% of billing or $25.00; Residential accounts – $15.00 Finance charge on accounts receivable that are over 30 days past due 35% or $25.00/month, whichever is higher Designation of historic structure $75.00 + public notice expenses and recording fees associated with the designation. Conference room rental $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Council Chambers room rental $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Conference room and Council Chambers rental (open wall) $25.00/hr, $200.00/day (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Disclaimer: The City Recorder's Office has the official version of the Moab Municipal Code. Users should contact the City Recorder's Office for ordinances passed subsequent to the ordinance cited above. Note: This site does not support Internet Explorer. To view this site, Code Publishing Company recommends using one of the following browsers: Google Chrome, Firefox, or Safari. City Website: moabcity.org City Telephone: (435) 259-5121 Code Publishing Company Commented [MM24]: Bring in line with the Commercial  account late payment penalty.   Commented [MM25]: Finance director requested fees be  put into place for rental of our Conference room and  Chambers room. Used fees lined out for the MARC to stay  consistent.  Page 1 of 4 March 8, 2022 MOAB CITY COUNCIL MINUTES--DRAFT REGULAR MEETING March 8, 2022 Moab City Council held its Regular Meeting on the above date. Consistent with provisions of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, the meeting was held electronically. Audio is archived at www.utah.gov/pmn. Pre-Council Workshop: Mayor Joette Langianese called the workshop to order at 4:07 p.m. Video is archived at www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvIekssUTGc. Councilmembers Rani Derasary, Kalen Jones, Luke Wojciechowski and Jason Taylor attended remotely. City staff participating included Acting City Manager Carly Castle, Finance Director and Acting Deputy Manager Ben Billingsley, Planning Director Cory Shurtleff and Recorder Sommar Johnson. Active Employment Households (AEH)—Discussion Planner Shurtleff opened the workshop on Draft Ordinance 2022-05: an Ordinance Amending the Moab Municipal Code R3/R4 Zones with AEH requirements. Shurtleff addressed Council questions regarding Resolution 33-2021. Councilmember Derasary asked about considerations for the R2 zone. Councilmember Jones asked if the ordinance would apply to subdivisions and Planned Unit Developments (PUDs). The timeline was discussed, including public notice and public hearings. Shurtleff described ordinance amendments including Chapter 17.64 which deals with AEH definitions, permitting and enforcement; he reviewed details of multi-household dwellings and AEH occupancy requirements. Robert Keller of Snow Christensen & Martineau brought up legal issues regarding enforcement provisions. Aaron Nousaine of BAE Urban Economics presented data to be considered when determining the required share of housing for workforce needs, both Citywide and in the R3/R4 zones. Councilmember Jones brought up the Assured Housing Study (AHS) of 2017 and questioned the “commuter share” that implied workers camping on public lands and noted the City goal to ensure safe and decent housing for the workforce. Councilmember Derasary asked about the scope of work and rates for BAE’s contract and about updating the AHS. Planner Shurtleff suggested removing enforcement from the pending ordinance. He was asked about the costs of implementing the ordinance. Councilmember Jones brought up exaction and financial feasibility for individual developers, including the challenge of determining if the impact on developers was commensurate with the development’s impact on the City. The characteristics of the R3 and R4 zones were discussed in terms of the intention for full time residents to populate the zones. Parking changes were discussed along with developments with more than seven units rather than more than three. Councilmember Taylor asked about the exclusion of garages in front of the dwelling units and Councilmember Derasary brought up the scope of safety considerations being addressed by the ordinance. Discussion of potential litigation ensued. Regular Meeting Attendance and Call to Order: Mayor Langianese called the meeting to order at 6:04 p.m. Councilmembers Tawny Knuteson- Boyd, Derasary, Jones, Wojciechowski and Taylor attended remotely. City staff in attendance included Acting City Manager Castle, Finance Director and Acting Deputy Manager Billingsley, Human Resource Director Dani Guerrero, Engineer Chuck Williams, City Attorney Nathan Bracken and Recorder Johnson. Video is archived at www.youtube.com/watch?v=lEpvl8F-l1o. Citizens To Be Heard: Travis Clark spoke about a residence on Arches Drive that housed 28 people. He said it was a catastrophe. He said it was a commercial-type operation and not a bed and breakfast. He Page 2 of 4 March 8, 2022 acknowledged the need for employee housing but expressed outrage that this has happened. He indicated his home value depreciated and parking was an issue. Jack Wynn concurred with Mr. Clark regarding the residence on Arches Drive. He said it was the wrong place for a large employee housing development. He called it a corporate bunkhouse, and stated it sanctioned discrimination and should be in the commercial zone. Consent Agenda—Approved Motions and Votes: Councilmember Derasary moved to approve the minutes of the February 22, 2022 Regular City Council Meeting and to approve bills against the City of Moab in the amount of $360,367.31. Councilmember Jones seconded the motion. Councilmember Derasary stated she sent corrections to the Recorder. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Wojciechowski and Knuteson-Boyd voting aye. New Business: Salary Survey—Presentation Human Resource Director Guerrero answered questions regarding communities used for comparisons, salary compression and adjustments made since the last salary survey was completed in 2016. Discussion followed regarding minimum and maximum ranges, longevity versus performance, and the pay plan versus a Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA). Disposal of Real Property Procedures—Approved Discussion: Finance Director and Acting Deputy Manager Billingsley described the need to codify procedures for the disposal of small parcels of land owned by the City. He said the proposed ordinance was recommended by the City’s attorney and was in the public interest. Councilmember Derasary asked how the Council could know the significance of a parcel and Billingsley brought up the threshold for parcels deemed significant. Councilmember Knuteson- Boyd said it was reasonable and defensible and she was fine with it. Motion and Vote: Councilmember Jones moved to approve Ordinance 2022-04, which defines a significant parcel of real property as a property that exceeds ($100,000) in fair market value, is (1) acre or larger, or is set aside for, or used as, a public recreation area. Councilmember Derasary seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Knuteson-Boyd and Wojciechowski voting aye. Authorization of Sale of Remnant Parcel of Real Property—Approved Discussion: Finance Director and Acting Deputy Manager Billingsley addressed questions regarding the sale of a parcel adjacent to residential property at 388 East 100 South. He said the site plan process should have identified the 0.04-acre parcel belonging to the City. The adjacent property owner was selling his residence and hoped for a quitclaim at closing. Motion and Vote: Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd moved to approve Proposed Resolution 09-2022: a Resolution Authorizing the Sale of a Remnant Parcel of Real Property. Councilmember Jones seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Knuteson-Boyd and Wojciechowski voting aye. Old Business: Lot Consolidation of Properties Located at 241 East 100 North—Approved Motion and Vote: Councilmember Wojciechowski moved to approve Proposed Resolution 06-2022: a Resolution Approving the Lot Consolidation of Properties Located at 241 East 100 North, Moab UT. Councilmember Taylor seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Knuteson-Boyd and Wojciechowski voting aye. Page 3 of 4 March 8, 2022 Lot Consolidation of Properties located at 196 N 200 E & 110 N 200 E—Approved Motion and Vote: Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd moved to approve Proposed Resolution 07-2022: a Resolution Approving the Lot Consolidation of Properties located at 200 East 196 North & 200 East 110 North, Moab, Utah 84532. Councilmember Wojciechowski seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Knuteson- Boyd and Wojciechowski voting aye. Five-Year Transit Pilot Project Budget—Approved Discussion: Engineer Williams presented background on the transit pilot project which includes funding from the Federal Transportation Administration and the American Rescue Plan Act (FTA ARPA) and presented a proposed alternative budget that would include a fixed route as well as micro-transit van service. Williams stated the City would hire a part-time employee to coordinate the program and a vendor would provide the service. The proposed fixed route was described as running along Highway 191 from the north side of the Colorado River Bridge to the Old Spanish Trail Arena. Hours and overlap of the two services were discussed. Councilmember Taylor asked about storage for fleet vehicles. Councilmember Derasary asked about the preparation of the Request for Proposals. Mayor Langianese asked about onboard advertising. Motion and Vote: Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd moved to approve a Proposed Alternative Budget dated March 8, 2022, including FTA ARPA Funds and Authorize the Mayor to sign appropriate Contract Documentation as needed. Councilmember Taylor seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Knuteson-Boyd and Wojciechowski voting aye. Walnut Lane Public-Private Partnership Request for Proposals (RFP)—Approved Discussion: Acting City Manager Castle reviewed alternatives regarding the Walnut Lane affordable housing project, including issuance of an RFP to engage a developer for a public- private partnership (PPP) as the possible next step. Councilmember Jones brought up the specter of required staffing and the difficulty of competing with private sector employers. Finance Director and Acting Deputy Manager Billingsley described staff involvement. Selling the property was discussed as an alternative. Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd suggested that issuance of an RFP would not commit the City and the property could still be sold with deed restrictions in the future. Councilmember Taylor concurred that the PPP option could be explored before moving on. Councilmember Jones stated his skepticism regarding the PPP option and suggested selling the property because of the lengthy process and lack of staff resources. Councilmember Derasary requested staff to inform residents of the process. She also asked about the cost of issuance of an RFP and expressed appreciation of Councilmember Jones’ point of view. Councilmember Wojciechowski stated that selling the property was the least palatable option and displacement of residents is a problem. He cited human costs and the impact on the community because there was no re-housing option. He said he was open to developing partnerships with local nonprofits. Motion and Vote: Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd moved to direct staff to publish an RFP to solicit developers for proposals to enter into a public private partnership for the development of the Walnut Lane Apartments. Councilmember Taylor seconded the motion. The motion passed 4-1 aye with Councilmembers Derasary, Taylor, Knuteson-Boyd and Wojciechowski voting aye and Councilmember Jones voting nay. Administrative Reports: Acting City Manager Castle reported on hiring a new City Attorney, Nathan Bracken. She noted staffing changes in the Public Works department and the hiring of a Safety Coordinator. She mentioned the March 18 and 19 strategic planning session. Page 4 of 4 March 8, 2022 Mayor and Council Reports: Councilmember Wojciechowski reported on a Planning Commission meeting and his site visit to the new Utah State University-Moab (USU) campus. Councilmember Derasary mentioned her appreciation of the Moab Valley Multicultural Center (MVMC). She noted the strategic planning test survey and reported she attended meetings with the Grand Water and Sewer Services Agency, the City’s attorney, and an affordable housing expert. She brought up the legislative recap as well as City representation in the Mill Creek Community Collaborative. Derasary aired concern regarding the bunkhouse on Arches Drive. Councilmember Jones stated he attended the final meeting of the Dark Skies alliance. He also reported on meetings of the solid waste district, the Housing Task Force, the Community Renewable Energy Agency and the Travel Council. He said he attended the USU site visit. Councilmember Taylor reported on the Chamber of Commerce retreat and noted their scholarship program and July Fourth activities. He stated he attended an airport board meeting. Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd said she met with the visioning team. Mayor Langianese said she attended the USU event and announced the April 1 ribbon cutting at the new campus. She mentioned the Moab Free Health Clinic and the health department had purchased the existing USU building. She suggested Parks, Recreation and Trails Director Annie McVay to represent the City in the Mill Creek Community Collaborative. The Mayor mentioned that USU is looking for an advisory board member and brought up a suggestion from Senator Mike Lee’s staff, referring to Senator Lee’s “housing act” which would allow local governments to purchase federal public lands for housing projects. She also brought up how to proceed with the many letters she is asked to sign on behalf of the City. City Attorney Report: Attorney Bracken recapped the legislative session and answered Council questions regarding specific bills. Executive (Closed) Session: Motions and Votes: Councilmember Jones moved to enter an Executive Session to Discuss Reasonably Imminent and/or Pending Litigation. Councilmember Wojciechowski seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Wojciechowski and Knuteson-Boyd voting aye. Mayor Langianese convened the closed session at 8:13 p.m. Councilmember Knuteson-Boyd moved to close the Executive Session. Councilmember Derasary seconded the motion. The motion to end the closed session passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Wojciechowski and Knuteson-Boyd voting aye. Mayor Langianese ended the session at 9:34 p.m. Adjournment: Councilmember Derasary moved to adjourn the meeting. Councilmember Jones seconded the motion. The motion passed 5-0 aye with Councilmembers Jones, Derasary, Taylor, Wojciechowski and Knuteson-Boyd voting aye. Mayor Langianese adjourned the meeting at 9:34 p.m. APPROVED: __________________ ATTEST: ___________________ Joette Langianese, Mayor Sommar Johnson, City Recorder City of Moab City of Moab Bills for Approval Page: 1 Live 5.10.2021 Hosted Check Issue Dates: 3/1/2022 - 3/14/2022 Mar 10, 2022 11:43AM Payee Check Issue Date Check Number Invoice Date GL Period Invoice Number Check Amount AARON P. WISE ATTORNEY AT LAW 03/10/2022 270254 03/01/2022 03/22 1110 2,000.00 AD-VERTISER 03/10/2022 270255 02/23/2022 03/22 Multiple 636.00 AMAZON 03/10/2022 270332 03/07/2022 03/22 Multiple 6,548.72 AMERIGAS 03/10/2022 270333 02/18/2022 03/22 805298475 75.86 ANN WALTERS-COOL 03/10/2022 270334 03/04/2022 03/22 REFUND:3-4-22 61.50 BLUE STAKES OF UTAH 811 03/10/2022 270335 02/28/2022 03/22 UT202200381 107.10 BOWEN COLLINS & ASSOCIATES INC. 03/10/2022 270260 02/14/2022 03/22 27720 1,289.25 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT DAILY OR INVESTING 03/10/2022 270261 02/14/2022 03/22 LT0335 199.00 C AND T DRIVE TRAIN SYSTEMS AUTO BODY 03/10/2022 270262 02/07/2022 03/22 Multiple 738.00 CANYONLANDS AUTO & MINING SUPPLY INC. 03/10/2022 270263 03/03/2022 03/22 Multiple 138.47 CANYONLANDS COPY CENTER 03/10/2022 270264 02/23/2022 03/22 36261 45.00 CASELLE INC 03/10/2022 270265 03/01/2022 03/22 115346 3,721.00 CERTIFIED LABORATORIES DIVISION 03/10/2022 270266 03/01/2022 03/22 706601 723.95 CHEMTECH-FORD INC.03/10/2022 270267 03/07/2022 03/22 Multiple 800.00 CITY OF MOAB 03/10/2022 270268 03/01/2022 03/22 2/2022 8,372.22 CLARK, NATHANIEL 03/10/2022 270269 02/19/2022 03/22 019481 20.58 CODALE ELECTRIC SUPPLY 03/10/2022 270270 02/25/2022 03/22 S7688600.001 238.83 COLBY MEANS 03/02/2022 270250 03/02/2022 03/22 PER DIEM: 3/2/22 30.00 COLORADO ASSOCIATION OF SKI TOWNS 03/10/2022 270271 03/01/2022 03/22 1533 630.00 COSY SHERIDAN 03/10/2022 270272 03/07/2022 03/22 REFUND:PARK RESERVA 70.00 COWDELL & WOOLLEY PC 03/10/2022 270273 02/17/2022 03/22 M1087 3,379.50 CURTIS BLUE LINE 03/10/2022 270274 02/17/2022 03/22 INV570095 305.35 DESERT WEST OFFICE SUPPLY 03/10/2022 270275 03/07/2022 03/22 Multiple 664.95 DUFFORD,WALDECK, MILBURN & KROHN LLP 03/10/2022 270276 03/01/2022 03/22 Multiple 16,815.39 ELWOOD STAFFING SERVICES 03/10/2022 270277 03/08/2022 03/22 Multiple 2,831.83 EMERY TELCOM 03/10/2022 270278 03/01/2022 03/22 Multiple 2,073.17 ERIC PRATT 03/10/2022 270279 03/10/2022 03/22 PER DIEM:3/15/22-3/19/22 210.00 FRONTIER 03/10/2022 270280 02/25/2022 03/22 Multiple 1,357.60 GLORIA TOPLISS 03/10/2022 270281 03/04/2022 03/22 REFUND: BASKET WEAVI 61.50 GRAINGER 03/10/2022 270282 02/24/2022 03/22 Multiple 1,485.44 GRAND COUNTY SOLID WASTE SSD 03/02/2022 270249 03/01/2022 03/22 2/2022 98,071.84 GRAND COUNTY SOLID WASTE SSD 03/10/2022 270283 02/28/2022 03/22 Multiple 7,213.66 GRAND TIRE PROS 03/10/2022 270284 03/03/2022 03/22 111751 411.39 GRAND WATER & SEWER AGENCY 03/10/2022 270285 02/28/2022 03/22 Multiple 476.15 INTERMOUNTAIN BOBCAT 03/10/2022 270286 02/22/2022 03/22 P04550 151.91 INTERMOUNTAIN FARMERS ASSOCIATION 03/10/2022 270287 02/22/2022 03/22 1016670038 2,622.00 INTERMOUNTAIN SALES OF DENVER 03/10/2022 270288 02/23/2022 03/22 29487 549.90 JACE WOODARD 03/02/2022 270251 03/01/2022 03/22 PER DIEM 3/2/2022 30.00 JB PLUMBING LLC 03/10/2022 270289 02/23/2022 03/22 Multiple 686.00 JEAN TAGGART 03/10/2022 270290 03/04/2022 03/22 REFUND:BASKET WEAVI 12.30 JOHNSTONE SUPPLY 03/10/2022 270291 02/28/2022 03/22 9033294 137.52 City of Moab City of Moab Bills for Approval Page: 2 Live 5.10.2021 Hosted Check Issue Dates: 3/1/2022 - 3/14/2022 Mar 10, 2022 11:43AM Payee Check Issue Date Check Number Invoice Date GL Period Invoice Number Check Amount KELLIE WOOD 03/10/2022 270292 03/06/2022 03/22 REFUND: CYANOTYPES 61.50 KILGORE COMPANIES LLC 03/10/2022 270293 02/24/2022 03/22 992988 2,315.74 LANE GILSON 03/02/2022 270252 03/02/2022 03/22 PER DIEM: 3/7/22-3/8/22 229.44 LEXISNEXIS 03/10/2022 270294 02/28/2022 03/22 3093727845 338.00 LONG BUILDING TECHNOLOGIES INC 03/10/2022 270295 03/07/2022 03/22 000135541 203.04 LOVE COMMUNICATIONS 03/10/2022 270296 02/25/2022 03/22 060344 1,050.00 METERWORKS INC.03/10/2022 270297 03/08/2022 03/22 Multiple 6,831.16 MIRIAM GRAHAM 03/10/2022 270298 03/03/2022 03/22 03/03/2022 140.00 MOAB MAILING CENTER 03/10/2022 270299 03/01/2022 03/22 24498 17.12 MOAB SUN NEWS 03/10/2022 270300 03/04/2022 03/22 Multiple 830.00 MOUNTAIN ALARM FIRE 03/10/2022 270301 01/28/2022 03/22 2694462 585.00 NATHAN TUHY 03/10/2022 270302 03/08/2022 03/22 112-6990747-4461833 102.73 OFFICE DEPOT INC.03/08/2022 270060 01/06/2022 03/22 216431204001 17.09- OFFICE DEPOT INC.03/08/2022 270166 02/02/2022 03/22 Multiple 141.34- OFFICE DEPOT INC.03/08/2022 270253 02/02/2022 03/22 Multiple 158.43 OFFICE DEPOT INC.03/10/2022 270303 03/02/2022 03/22 Multiple 279.01 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS 03/10/2022 270304 03/07/2022 03/22 3792-192559 26.99 PACKARD WHOLESALE 03/10/2022 270305 03/01/2022 03/22 Multiple 452.23 PARR BROWN GEE & LOVELESS 03/10/2022 270306 02/28/2022 03/22 904955 3,779.75 PELORUS METHODS INC 03/10/2022 270307 03/01/2022 03/22 220401 500.00 PITNEY BOWES INC - PURCHASE POWER 03/10/2022 270308 03/08/2022 03/22 3/4/22-29213089-ACCT 500.00 POSITIVE CONCEPTS INC.03/10/2022 270309 02/16/2022 03/22 0233962-IN 240.00 POWERDMS INC 03/10/2022 270310 02/28/2022 03/22 INV-16925 1,197.00 PROVELOCITY 03/10/2022 270311 03/01/2022 03/22 33937 10,555.00 RELINER/DURAN INC 03/10/2022 270312 03/03/2022 03/22 42722 333.58 REVCO LEASING COMPANY LLC 03/10/2022 270313 02/28/2022 03/22 Multiple 1,048.15 RHINEHART OIL CO. , LLC 03/10/2022 270314 03/01/2022 03/22 IN-424201-21A 114.64 RIVER CANYON WIRELESS 03/10/2022 270315 03/04/2022 03/22 73684 84.99 SAFETY SUPPLY & SIGN CO. INC 03/10/2022 270316 02/21/2022 03/22 179984 2,055.70 SANDY HINCK 03/10/2022 270317 03/04/2022 03/22 REFUND:03/4/2022 61.50 SARAH COOK 03/10/2022 270318 03/04/2022 03/22 REFUND:3/4/22 12.30 SIRCHIE FINGER PRINT LABS 03/10/2022 270319 02/26/2022 03/22 0532865-IN 503.52 STANDARD PLUMBING SUPPLY CO.03/10/2022 270320 03/04/2022 03/22 Multiple 172.05 THE LIFEGUARD STORE 03/10/2022 270321 03/04/2022 03/22 Multiple 2,939.00 TIMES-INDEPENDENT 03/10/2022 270322 02/24/2022 03/22 29516 1,547.41 TRASHCANS UNLIMITED 03/10/2022 270323 02/17/2022 03/22 13933 13,109.14 U.S. POSTMASTER 03/01/2022 270248 03/01/2022 03/22 MARCH 2022 511.85 USABLUEBOOK 03/10/2022 270324 03/04/2022 03/22 899359 219.04 VERIZON WIRELESS 03/10/2022 270325 02/26/2022 03/22 9900480944 1,325.03 WALKER DRUG 03/10/2022 270326 03/08/2022 03/22 Multiple 94.78 WALKER'S TRUE VALUE HARDWARE 03/10/2022 270327 03/07/2022 03/22 Multiple 777.66 City of Moab City of Moab Bills for Approval Page: 3 Live 5.10.2021 Hosted Check Issue Dates: 3/1/2022 - 3/14/2022 Mar 10, 2022 11:43AM Payee Check Issue Date Check Number Invoice Date GL Period Invoice Number Check Amount WASH-IT EXPRESS 03/10/2022 270328 03/01/2022 03/22 STMT2022-MAR-01 141.21 WRIGHT EXPRESS FSC 03/14/2022 202230103 03/01/2022 03/22 2/2022 7,707.23 XEROX CORPORATION 03/10/2022 270329 03/04/2022 03/22 Multiple 959.65 ZEN COMMUNICATIONS 03/10/2022 270330 03/01/2022 03/22 IN9612 1,311.00 ZIONS BANK PUBLIC FINANCIAL SERVICES 03/10/2022 270331 02/25/2022 03/22 9040 365,549.91 Moab City Council Agenda Item Meeting Date: March 22nd, 2022 Title:Landscaping Code Updates Presenter:Mila Dunbar-Irwin Attachment(s):Memo from Western Resource Advocates Recommended Motion: N/A, Discussion and Direction Background/Summary: The Council has seen a presentation on the possible landscaping code updates from WaterNOW and Western Resource Advocates. These have since been presented and discussed by Planning Commission and the Water Conservation and Drought Management Board. At this time, staff requests direction from Council in choosing which approach to take forward. The main questions are as follows: 1)Which approach do you like best – Water Budget? Standards? A combination of the two? 2)Are there any standards you are wholeheartedly in favor of and would like to see move forward? 3)Are there any standards you are wholeheartedly against and would like to see struck from the list? The Planning Commission discussion ended with a general agreement (not unanimous) around the water budget approach (#7), with the addition of hydrozones, a plant list as a guideline, irrigation system requirements, and some kind of turf limits. They felt the minimum plant material requirement would be too high and advised to strike it. Mulch was considered likely too expensive and unnecessary. The Water Board concluded that they were also in favor of the water budget approach, with the addition of a maintenance requirement, hydrozones, and a plant list (including known problematic and prohibited plants as well as recommended). They did not find any particularly problematic from a cost perspective and also recommended lowering the minimum living plant material requirement and allowing any amount of turf as long as it fit within the water budget for residential, but keeping a 200sf maximum for commercial. The Water Board also recommended striking a requirement for ground cover for residential properties, but keeping it for commercial. They were, as a whole, in favor of strict requirements for commercial properties and none / minimal requirements for residential. They also wanted to note that they felt it would be more prudent to wait to adopt anything until the County is aligned and ready to adopt their own ordinance via the proposed discussion with the management group. Staff is supportive of the recommendations from the Water Board and Planning Commission, and propose a tiered approach according to levels of development. For developments under 2,000sf, staff recommend easy-to-design requirements such as turf limits, waterwise plants, and hydrozones, with any of those being allowed to change if the applicant chooses the water budget approach instead to allow for more flexibility. For developments between 2,000sf and 8,000sf staff recommend the water budget approach in combination with the other recommended requirements. For developments over 8,000sf staff recommend requiring a robust water budget analysis, decreasing allowable turf, and including the recommended requirements from the other two categories. These development levels correspond to current Planning Department requirements for various permits. It is staffs’ opinion that this approach would not create an overly onerous demand on staff time and the added burden could be shared between the Sustainability Department and Planning / Building / Engineering. The Water Budget approach with some additional requirements seems to be the most streamlined for review purposes, while still achieving water conservation goals. However, any of the recommendations are well-founded in science, practical examples from other communities, and best practices in Moab, and any combination of the recommended standards would be a benefit to the landscape regulations currently in place. 1 MEMO: City of Moab Water Efficient Landscaping Standards Draft Recommendations TO: Moab City Council & Planning Commission FROM: Lindsay Rogers & John Berggren, Western Resource Advocates & Victoria Arling, WaterNow Alliance DATE: February 16, 2022 Executive Summary In August 2021, WaterNow Alliance (WaterNow) and Western Resource Advocates (WRA) launched a Project Accelerator with the City of Moab to provide pro-bono support in updating the City’s zoning code to include water wise landscaping and irrigation efficient standards. This memo presents 11 potential recommendations for updating Moab’s landscaping standards in the City’s zoning code that we feel would be reasonable for developers and landscapers to undertake and feasible for City staff to implement. These proposed recommendations would apply to some (or all) types of new development and redevelopment. The recommendations are based on research conducted by WaterNow and WRA on water wise landscaping standards implemented in 10 communities throughout the West. This research – which included a number of options for updating landscaping standards to prioritize water efficiency - was vetted through a variety of avenues, including a presentation and discussion with Moab’s Water Conservation & Drought Management Board, conversations with City staff, and interviews with key local stakeholders. Local stakeholders included: Jeffrey Adams with Terra Sophia; Eric Floor and Tara Stoner with EcoLogic; Kara Dohrenwend with Wildland Scapes; Roslynn Brain McCann with Utah State University Extension; Rikki Epperson with Community Rebuilds; and Orion Rogers with Southeast Utah Health Department. Stakeholders were asked to consider, in particular, any financial, capacity, material availability, or other barriers that could arise from a given recommendation. Based on this feedback, and additional research into other western community’s landscape regulations, these 11 potential recommendations were drafted. Each recommendation outlined below includes a justification (with stakeholder feedback), current City standards, recommended code update, supporting code language/examples of potential modifications, and any related supporting resources. In addition, there are 3 recommendations for educational or best management practices the City could pursue. The 11 recommendations include: 1. Living Plant Material: Require 25% living plant material at maturity in the landscaped area for all development types and require 50% living plant material in high-visibility, commercial development 2. Non-Living Permeable Groundcover: Allow up to 75% of landscaped area to be non-living, permeable materials (e.g., organic mulches, gravel, decorative pavement); for high visibility, commercial areas, allow up to 50% of landscaped areas to be non-living permeable groundcover. 3. Turf Limits: For all residential development, require that turf areas shall: (a) be limited to areas with suitable shade; (b) not be allowed in spaces narrower than 10 feet wide; (c) not be used in more than 10% of total landscaped area or a maximum of 200 square feet of turf; (d) not be 2 allowed on slopes greater than 33%; and HOAs may not mandate the installation of turf on residential properties. For commercial properties, retain current standards. 4. Plant List: All plant materials must be selected from the City’s approved Plant List, which is organized by non-irrigated/very low, low, medium and high water use plants. 5. WaterWise Plants Requirement: A minimum of 50% of living plant material must be selected from the non-irrigated/very low or low water use category of the City’s Approved Plant List. 6. Hydrozones: Plants are to be hydrozoned with plants of a similar hydrozone. Plants with a very low hydrozone are not to be planted in a moderate to high hydrozone. Irrigation shall be hydrozoned, grouping similar water demands by irrigation zone. 7. Landscape Water Budget: The total irrigation water need for all hydrozones cannot exceed a Maximum Applied Water Budget of 15 gallons/season/sq-ft (24in/season) of irrigated landscape area unless special features are included. Special features include: protected native vegetation areas, ecological restoration areas, bioretention areas, non-irrigated permeable areas, stormwater conveyance infrastructure, and graywater systems. 8. Mulch: Organic mulch must be applied at a depth of 4 inches, 1 cubic yard per 80 sq ft; inorganic mulch including gravel, river rock, and crushed rock must be applied at a depth of 2 inches. Because mulching can limit the successful propagation of some native plants, native plants are exempt from these mulching requirements. 9. Irrigation System Criteria: For commercial and large-scale developments: (a) smart irrigation controllers are required; (b) dedicated landscape water meters/submeters must be installed for all non-residential landscapes greater than 5,000 sq-ft; (c) the irrigation system must be designed to prevent runoff, low head drainage, overspray and other similar conditions; (d) minimum pop-up height for sprinklers in turf grass shall be 6 inches; (e) check valves or anti- drain valves are required on all sprinkler heads; (f) operating pressure at each emission device must be within the manufacturer’s recommended pressure range; (g) sprinklers within a zone must have matched precipitation rates; (h) a pressure regulation valve shall be installed and maintained by the consumers; (i) overhead irrigation shall not be permitted within 24 inches of any non-permeable surface. 10. Fire Wise Landscaping: For all developments in the wildland urban interface: Avoid fire prone plant materials and highly flammable mulches; plant widely-spaced, low growing, non-resinous shrubs 2-3 feet away from the house; if planting new trees, plant small maturing ones at least 15 feet away from structures. 11. Maintenance: All irrigation systems must be maintained including backflow assembly testing, leak repair, head adjustment, etc.; all replacement plants shall conform to the city’s plant list and landscaping standards; recommended turf mowing height is 3 ½ inches. It is important to note that this list of 11 potential recommendations is not intended to be adopted in whole; that is, this is a menu of options from which the City could select certain recommendations to explore. Most notably, there are two broad categories to consider when making those selections, driven primarily by the selection of a water budget allowance approach or not. If the #7: Water Budget Allowance approach is selected, that would impact which of the other recommendations are still applicable. A water budget approach would NOT include #5: Low Water Plant Requirements or #3: Turf Limits residential limitation of 10% or 200 square feet. If a water budget approach were not selected, those recommendations could still be considered. 3 Finally, Attachment A is a Landscape Water Budget Allowance Worksheet, which presents how the #7: Water Budget Allowance recommendation (Maximum Applied Water Budget of 15 gallons/season/sq-ft (24in/season) of irrigated landscape area) was developed. Draft Recommendations for Updating Landscape Standards 1. Living Plant Material a. Justification i. While requiring living plants doesn’t necessarily help reduce landscape water demand, a living plant material minimum standard can be important for landscaping aesthetics, reduced heat island effect, and pollinator habitat, among other benefits. Stakeholders expressed support for a living plant minimum, though they noted the example code language from other communities (50% or 75%) was likely too high for Moab’s desert landscaping aesthetic. b. Current Standards i. Residential: No living plant material requirement. At least seventy percent of the area contained within a required front or side yard adjacent to a street in any residential or residential-agricultural zone shall be landscaped. ii. Developments over 30,000 sq ft: At least 5% living plant material other than groundcover or natural vegetation; no more than 80% living ground cover. c. Recommended Code Update i. Require 25% minimum living plant material at maturity in the landscaped area including shrubs, perennials, ornamental grasses, groundcover plants, and turf grasses in all development types. ii. Require 50% minimum living plant material at maturity in the landscaped area for high-visibility, commercial areas including - but not limited to - street frontage landscapes, buffers, and parking lot perimeter landscapes. iii. Artificial trees, shrubs, plants, and artificial turf are prohibited. d. Supporting Code Language i. 50% minimum living materials including shrubs, perennials, ornamental grasses, groundcover plants, and turf grasses. (Aurora, CO) ii. For Street frontage landscapes, buffers, and parking lot perimeter landscapes – 75% of the area must be live vegetation. (Grand Junction, CO) 2. Non-living Permeable Groundcover a. Justification i. It’s important to strike a balance between non-living groundcover and living plant material. Allowing for a greater percentage of non-living ground cover could have the effect of reducing landscape water demand. Stakeholders were generally supportive of this recommendation and wanted to see the living and non-living percentages add up to 100% for clarity. b. Current Standards i. Residential: None 4 ii. Developments over 30,000 sq ft: Permeable non-living ground cover shall have a maximum coverage of 20%. c. Recommended Code Update i. For all development types except high visibility, commercial areas: Allow up to 75% of landscaped area to be non-living, permeable materials including river rock, crushed rock, organic mulches such as shredded bark, gravel, cobbles, walks, decorative pavement, or other non-living materials for all development types. ii. For high visibility, commercial areas: Allow up to 50% of landscaped areas to be non-living permeable groundcover. d. Supporting Code Language i. Allows up to 50% non-living materials including river rock, crushed rock, organic mulches such as shredded bark, gravel, cobbles, walks, decorative pavement, and artificial turf or other non-living materials. (Aurora, CO) ii. Allows up to 25 percent of the area required to be landscaped may be covered with mulch, pavers, decorative concrete (Thornton, CO) 3. Turf Limits a. Justification i. High water use, non-essential turf limitations are potentially the most important standard we can implement to reduce landscape water demand. Given Moab’s desert climate, the irrigation demands for turf are significant, so any reductions in the amount of new turf being installed will have large water savings. Currently, there are no limits on turf for residential development. Some form of turf limits were strongly supported by all stakeholders interviewed for this project. b. Current Standards i. Residential: None ii. Developments over 30,000 sq ft: ● Turf areas shall be limited to areas with suitable shade and shall not be allowed in spaces narrower than ten feet wide. ● Turf shall not be used in more than ten percent of total landscape area, and should be located in places where people will use it. ● Areas with a slope greater than thirty-three percent shall be landscaped with deep rooting, water conserving plants for erosion control and soil stabilization. (Ch. 17.80.070) c. Recommended Code Update i. Retain existing standards for large developments ii. For all residential development, adopt the standards below: ● Turf areas shall be limited to areas with suitable shade from buildings or trees and shrubs at maturity. ● Shall not be allowed in spaces narrower than ten feet wide. 5 ● Shall not be used in more than 10% of total landscaped area or a maximum of 200 square feet of turf, whichever is greater. (Note: this requirement could be removed if water budget approach is adopted) ● Turf is not allowed on slopes greater than 33%. ● Homeowners Associations may not mandate the installation of turf on residential properties. d. Supporting Code Language i. Lawn or turf area shall not exceed 10 percent of the overall landscape area of a project site (Sedona, AZ) ii. The installation of new turf in residential front yards is prohibited; Turf is not an allowable plant material within public or private common open space unless it meets the definition of “usable”. (For example, they’re defined as non-usable as medians, streetscapes, parking lots, entryways, and perimeter landscaping). (Henderson, NV) iii. Turf is not allowed on slopes greater than 25% when oriented towards hardscape (Sacramento, CA) iv. Any HOA governing documents… are void and unenforceable if they: Require the use of turf in landscape areas less than 8 feet wide or require turf in other areas that exceed 35% of the landscaped area; or prohibit the use of water- conserving plants as a group. (Jordan Valley WCD, UT) e. Supporting Resources i. Utah State University Cooperative Extension “Water-Wise Landscaping: Practical Turfgrass Areas” ii. Jordan Valley Water Conservancy District, Flip Your Strip-Park Strip Designs 4. Plant List a. Justification i. There is an increasingly critical need to conserve water in the arid west, provide habitat for local animals within the urban environment, and create a more sustainable landscape system through the use of adapted plant materials. A plant list can be used to address these environmental concerns by encouraging or requiring certain low water, native plant species and to categorize plant species by their water use. The stakeholders interviewed expressed general interest and support of the City of Moab developing and maintaining a comprehensive plant list, as it would include plants appropriate to Moab’s unique climate and would give landscapers the flexibility to select a variety of plants based on what is available in the list. b. Current Standards i. Residential: None ii. Large Scale Developments over 30,000 sq ft: None. iii. RC Resort Commercial Zone: Screening Plant List: Plants used to satisfy any required screening standards shall be limited plants with a mature height of between six and fifteen feet and foliage. For reference to appropriate plants and 6 trees see the publication Urban & Community Forest: A Guide for interior Western United States, Department of Agriculture, 1990. (Ch. 17.31.050) c. Recommended Code Update i. For All Development Types: All plant material must be selected from the City’s Approved Plant List. The plant list is categorized by non-irrigated/very-low, low, medium, and high water use plants. ii. Installation of plants that are not on the approved list must be pre-approved by the City and are up to the discretion of the Planning Director. iii. Pursuant to the Utah Noxious Weed Act, Section 7, no plants shall be planted from the Grand County Noxious Weeds List (Available here: https://www.grandcountyutah.net/168/Noxious-Weeds) iv. Note: The City could either adopt and maintain its own plant list or borrow from other communities or potentially a state-maintained list. d. Examples of Potential Modifications i. The required plant list features plants that are considered water-wise or low water use plants, unless listed as riparian; includes three categories: native, adaptive, and riparian plants. (Sedona, AZ) ii. Plant material must be selected from Town’s approved plant list; plant materials meet or exceed the plant quality and species standards of the American Standard for Nursery Stock. (Castle Rock, CO) e. Supporting Resources i. Native Plants for the Intermountain West: https://cwelwnp.usu.edu/westernnativeplants/index.php ii. USU - Waterwise plants for Utah Landscapes: https://extension.usu.edu/cwel/water-wise-plants iii. Wildland Scapes, LLC ● Native: https://www.revegmoab.com/native-plants ● Pollinator: https://www.revegmoab.com/pollinator-plantings-and- moab-big ● Shade trees, fruit trees, evergreens: https://www.revegmoab.com/general-plant-lists ● Shrubs and herbaceous perennials: https://www.revegmoab.com/shrubs-and-herbaceous-perennials 5. Water Wise Plants Requirements a. Justification i. Water wise and native plants typically have significantly lower water demand than turfgrass and other high water use plants. There are also many associated benefits to using water wise and native plants such as providing pollinator habitat, being fire resistant, being lower maintenance, and providing functional, attractive landscapes. Stakeholders interviewed generally agree that landscaping code updates should include requirements for water wise plants and not native plants. It would be disadvantageous to require a standard for native plants as many plants native to Moab (i.e., cottonwood trees) are not low 7 water use. Additionally, there are many non-native, low water use plants that are well suited to Moab’s climate that would otherwise be restricted in this native plant requirement. b. Current Standards i. Residential: None ii. Large Scale Developments over 30,000 sqft: Plant Materials and Landscape Design Standards. 1. Plants selected for landscape areas shall consist of plants that are well suited to the microclimate and soil conditions at the project site. (Ch 17.80.070) iii. RC Resort Commercial Zone: i. Use of locally appropriate shrubs, trees and grasses or plants with low-water demand characteristics is encouraged, but not required, in all cases in order to minimize the consumption of water. (Ch 17.31.050) c. Recommended Code Update i. For All Development Types: A minimum of 50% of living plant material must be selected from the non-irrigated/very low or low water use category of the City’s Approved Plant List. ii. Remove RC Resort language above from code as it would be contradictory to the recommended code update. d. Supporting Code Language i. Adopt current standards for all development types in WUI ii. A minimum of 50 percent of the plants on a development site shall be native species identified in the Administrative Manual (Sedona, AZ) iii. Minimum three tree varieties and five shrub varieties shall be provided for each project selected from the plant list. (Henderson, NV) iv. Water-wise landscaping is required on all development, private or public, in recognition of our semi-arid climate and limited amount of water available for outdoor uses. (Thornton, CO) 6. Hydrozones a. Justification i. Hydrozones allow for proper, efficient irrigation. Hydrozones means grouping plants in the landscape according to categories based on their water usage (ex. non-irrigated, water-conserving, and non-water conserving); and these plants are served by a valve or set of valves with the same irrigation schedule. Stakeholders interviewed were generally interested and supportive of integrating hydrozone standards into the landscape code in conjunction with the water budget approach and plant list. Local nurseries in Moab already categorize plants by very low, low, medium, and high water use and which complements this code requirement. b. Current Standards i. Residential: None 8 ii. Large Developments Over 30,000 sqft: Plant Materials and Landscape Design Standards. Plants with similar water needs shall be grouped together as much as possible. (Ch 17.80.070) c. Recommended Code Update i. For All Development Types: Plants are to be hydrozoned with plants of a similar hydrozone (for example, low with low; very low with very low). Plants with a very low hydrozone are not to be planted in a moderate to high hydrozone. ii. Irrigation shall be hydrozoned, grouping similar water demands by irrigation zone. d. Supporting Code Language i. Plants are to be hydrozoned with plants of a similar hydrozone (for example, low with low; very low with very low). Plants of a very low hydrozone are not to be planted in a moderate to high hydrozone. (Castle Rock, CO) ii. All non-single-family landscapes must be divided into water conserving (non- turf), non-water conserving (turf), and non-irrigated areas (e.g., pavement). A separate hydrozone plan is required for submittal with the landscape plan. (Aurora, CO) iii. Each valve shall irrigate a landscape with similar site, slope and soil conditions and plant materials with similar watering needs. Turf and non-turf areas shall be irrigated on separate valves. Drip emitters and sprinklers shall be placed on separate valves. (JVWCD, UT) e. Supporting Resources i. Definitions: ● Hydrozone: A group of plants with the same water use classification and microclimate assigned to a single irrigation valve. Plants should be grouped and planted in separate hydrozones due to factors such as: Plant water use classification; root depth; microclimate (sun, shade, wind, heat); slope and elevation; soil type; irrigation emission devices with different application rates; summer-dry adapted plants should be on a different hydrozone to those that require more summer moisture (QWEL Reference Manual). Hydrozone example / design template Qualified Water Efficient Landscaper Reference Manual) 9 7. Landscape Water Budget a. Justification: i. A landscape water budget limits the overall amount of water that can be applied to a given landscape during the irrigation season. Stakeholders have been overwhelmingly supportive of this recommendation as a way to reduce landscape water demand while allowing for flexibility in what can be installed in the landscape. b. Current Standards: None c. Recommended Code Update i. All irrigated landscaped areas must be included in the water budget calculation. See Appendix for details regarding the Maximum Applied Water Budget calculation. ii. The total irrigation water need for all hydrozones cannot exceed a Maximum Applied Water Budget of 15 gallons/season/sq-ft (24in/season) of irrigated landscape area unless special features are included. iii. Special features include: ● Non-irrigated protected native vegetation areas ● Ecological restoration projects ● Bioretention areas ● Non-irrigated permeable areas ● Stormwater conveyance infrastructure (vegetated swales) ● Graywater applied to the landscape (% based on % living plant material primarily watered with graywater) iv. If any combination of the special feature areas totals to at least 5% of the total irrigated hydrozone area, then the Maximum Applied Water Budget increases to 16 gallons/season/sq-ft. If any combination of the special feature areas totals to at least 10% of the total irrigated hydrozone area, then the Maximum Applied Water Budget increases to 17 gallons/season/sqft. v. Active rainwater catchment systems, including rain barrels or cisterns, are also incentivized in the calculation through a reduced overall irrigation water need. d. Examples of Potential Modifications i. Require all proposals to calculate water demand of all landscapable areas according to a water usage table; no water budget limit (Aurora, CO) ii. Require water budget calculations that include an estimated total water use that does not exceed the calculation for the site’s maximum applied water allowance (Sacramento, CA) iii. The total irrigation water need for all hydrozones cannot exceed a Maximum Applied Water Budget of 7.5 gallons/season/sq-ft of irrigated landscape area unless special features are included (e.g. green stormwater infrastructure, graywater) (Aspen, CO) e. Supporting Resources i. EPA Water Budget Calculation Tool: https://www.epa.gov/watersense/water- budget-tool 10 ii. USBR Agrimet Castle Valley Station: https://www.usbr.gov/pn/agrimet/etsummary.html?station=csvu&year=2021 iii. City of Moab Precipitation Date: https://wrcc.dri.edu/cgi-bin/cliMAIN.pl?ut5733 8. Mulch a. Justification: i. Proper mulching provides many benefits to landscapes, including reducing soil evaporation and moisture loss, moderating soil temperatures, providing weed control, and improving landscape aesthetics. Some of the stakeholders interviewed expressed concern about the availability of organic mulch in Moab, but also noted that any requirements would create market demand. One stakeholder described organic mulch from arborists as relatively easy to acquire. b. Current standards: None c. Recommended Code Update i. For all development types, require organic mulch be applied at a depth of 4 inches, 1 cubic yard per 80 sq ft; inorganic mulch including gravel, river rock, and crushed rock must be applied at a depth of 2 inches. ii. Because mulching can limit the successful propagation of some native plants, it is recommended that native plants be exempt from these mulching requirements. d. Examples of Potential Modifications i. Rock mulch shall be installed and maintained at a minimum depth of 2 inches and a maximum depth of 4 inches on all planted areas except where groundcover plants are fully established. (Henderson, NV) ii. Organic mulch applied at depth of 4 inches, 1 cubic yard per 80 sq ft; inorganic mulch applied at a depth of 2 inches. (Castle Rock, CO) e. Supporting Resources i. Utah State University Cooperative Extension, Using Mulches in Utah Landscapes and Gardens ii. Utah State University Cooperative Extension, Water-Wise Landscaping: Mulch 9. Irrigation System Criteria a. Justification i. Irrigation system design and installation is critical because even the most water wise landscaping won’t save water if it’s not being irrigated efficiently and effectively. For example, MP rotator nozzle heads are significantly more efficient in applying water to the landscape compared to more traditional spray nozzles, especially in windy areas like Moab. The stakeholders interviewed expressed interest in irrigation system criteria requirements, but were concerned about having requirements for residential properties. b. Current standards: i. Residential: None ii. Large developments over 30,000 sq-ft: ● A detailed irrigation plan shall be drawn to the same scale as the landscape plan and shall contain the following information: 11 a. Layout of irrigation system and summary legend outlining the type and size of all components of the system, including manufacture name and model number with approved equals; and b. Flow rate in gallons per minute and design operating pressure in pounds per square inch for each valve and precipitation rate in inches per hour for each valve with sprinklers. (Ch. 17.80.070) iii. RC Resort Commercial Zone: ● Irrigation. All required landscaped areas shall include a permanent, underground irrigation system as defined herein to insure the long-term health and growth of the landscape. Where possible, irrigation systems shall utilize untreated, irrigation water instead of treated water. Irrigation system design shall take into consideration the xeriscape characteristics of plant materials used. (Ch. 17.31.050) iv. Recommended Code Update: ● For residential developments: All requirements below are recommendations. ● For commercial and large-scale developments: ● Smart irrigation controllers labeled by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s WaterSense Program or with published reports posted on the Smart Water Application Technologies website are required. ● Dedicated landscape water meters/sub-meters shall be installed for all non-residential irrigated landscapes of 5,000 sq-ft or more. ● The irrigation system shall be designed to prevent runoff, low head drainage, overspray, or other similar conditions where irrigation water flows onto non-targeted areas, such as adjacent property, non-irrigated areas, hardscapes, roadways, or structures. ● Minimum pop-up height for sprinklers in turfgrass areas shall be six inches (6”). ● Check valves or anti-drain valves are required on all sprinkler heads. ● The irrigation system shall be designed to ensure that the operating pressure at each emission device is within the manufacturer’s recommended pressure range for optimal performance. ● Sprinklers within a zone shall have matched precipitation rates, unless otherwise directed by the manufacturer’s recommendations. Sprinkler spacing shall be designed to achieve the highest possible distribution uniformity using the manufacturer’s recommendations. Spacing must achieve head-to-head coverage. ● A pressure regulating valve shall be installed and maintained by the consumer if the static service pressure exceeds 80 pounds per square inch (psi). The pressure-regulating valve shall be located between the meter and the first point of water use, or first point of division in the pipe, and shall be set at the manufacturer's recommended pressure for the sprinklers. 12 ● Overhead irrigation shall not be permitted within 24 inches of any non- permeable surface. Allowable irrigation within the setback from non- permeable surfaces may include drip, drip line, or other low flow non- spray technology. The setback area may be planted or unplanted. The surfacing of the setback may be mulch, gravel, or other porous material. c. Examples of Potential Modifications i. An irrigation construction plan shall graphically depict, and describe through appropriate notes, an efficient irrigation design; each irrigation zone on the irrigation construction plan should be designed to water plants with similar water and environmental requirements. (Thornton, CO) ii. Specific requirements for irrigation systems including backflow prevention, pressure regulators, highest possible distribution uniformity, and not permitting overhead irrigation within 24 inches of non-permeable surfaces. (Sacramento, CA) iii. Landscaped areas shall be provided with a WaterSense labeled smart irrigation controller which automatically adjusts … in response to changing weather conditions. (JVWCD, UT) d. Supporting Resources i. Washington County Water Conservancy District, Installation and Maintenance ii. EPA WaterSense, Water Efficiency Management Guide: Landscaping and Irrigation iii. South Metro Water Supply Authority, Model Regional Water Efficient Landscape and Irrigation Ordinance 10. FireWise Landscaping Standards a. Justification: i. Wildfires present a serious and growing threat to Western communities, particularly properties at the interface between urban areas and natural open space. In conversation with stakeholder, it was recommended that Moab expand firewise landscape regulation for properties in the WUI. b. Current Standards: i. Residential: None ii. Developments over 30,000 sq ft: For projects located at the interface between urban areas and natural open space non-irrigated, highly drought tolerant plants shall be selected that will blend with the native vegetation and are fire resistant or retardant. Plants with low level fuel volume or high moisture content shall be emphasized. Plants which tend to accumulate excessive amounts of dead wood or debris shall be avoided. c. Recommended Code Update: i. Expand current large development standards to all development types at the interface between urban areas and natural open space. ii. For all development in the WUI: ● Avoid fire-prone plant materials and highly flammable mulches. See appendix for a recommended list of plants. 13 ● Plant widely-spaced, low-growing, non-resinous shrubs, 2-3 feet away from the house. Do not plant directly under windows, vents, or decks. Do not plant under tree crowns, or use shrubs to screen propane tanks or firewood piles. ● If planting new trees, plant small-maturing ones, at least 15 feet away from structures. d. Supporting Resources i. Utah State University Forestry FireWise Plants List (for appendix): https://forestry.usu.edu/news/utah-forest-facts/firewise-plants-for-utah- landscapes ii. Utah State University Forestry Firewise Landscaping Guide: https://forestry.usu.edu/files/firewise-landscaping-updated-2018.pdf 11. Maintenance a. Justification: Effectively maintaining landscapes and irrigation systems is critical to plant health and water demand management. b. Current Standards: i. For residential developments: Required landscaped areas shall be maintained in a neat, clean, orderly and healthful condition. This is meant to include proper pruning, mowing lawns, weeding, removal of litter, fertilizing, replacement of dead plants and the regular watering of all plantings. (Prior code § 27-3-24(B)) ii. For commercial developments: Maintenance Requirements. Landscaped areas shall be reasonably maintained by the owner or the lessee of the property, including pruning, trimming, watering, and other requirements necessary to create an attractive appearance for the development. Lack of maintenance of required landscaping material shall constitute a violation of this code. c. Recommended Code Update: i. Include the replacement and maintenance of irrigation systems including backflow assembly testing, leak repair, head adjustment, etc. ii. Include language to specify that all replacement plants shall conform to the city's current plant list and landscaping standards. iii. Include a recommended turf mowing height of 3 ½ inches. d. Supporting Code Language i. Required maintenance shall include regular watering, pruning, mowing, fertilizing, clearing of debris and weeds, removal and replacement of dead plants and repair and replacement of irrigation systems and architectural features. (Sedona, AZ) ii. All replacement plants shall conform to the city's current landscaping standards. (Aurora, CO) iii. Maintenance requirements must be noted in landscape and irrigation plans. Irrigation system maintenance includes back flow assembly testing, leak repair, head adjustment, etc. Turf preferred mowing height is 3 ½ inches. (Castle Rock, CO) 14 Educational, Best Management Practice Opportunities 1. Soil Amendment a. Justification i. Incorporating compost and other soil amendments into a landscape has important benefits including: up to 20% water savings, improved plant growth and increased stormwater retention for the soil, pest suppression and reduced need for fertilizers. However, stakeholders agreed that a requirement for soil amendment – which can be difficult to come by in Moab – would present a financial burden and an enforcement challenge for the City at this time. b. Current standards: None c. Examples of Potential Modifications i. Min. 4 cubic yards of organic matter soil amendment required for turf, trees, shrubs, perennials and annuals; Soil amendment tilled to min. depth of 6 inches (Thornton, CO) ii. Develop exception for native seeds/plants to use 2 cubic yards per 1,000 square feet (based on research from City of Centennial, CO) 2. Graywater Reuse a. Justification: Graywater reduces potable water demand by reusing water from showerheads or washing machines or bathroom sinks in the landscape. While graywater systems have been incentivized through the water budget allowance, stakeholders shared that requirements for installing graywater stub-outs would likely be ineffective since most homeowners would not then install the full system and graywater stubouts are challenging from a regulatory perspective for Grand County Public Health. Fully installed graywater systems were considered potentially overly prescriptive as a mandate. b. Current standard: No requirements, graywater systems allowed in Grand County per state statute (R317) c. Examples of Potential Modifications i. Incentivize or require graywater in all/some types of new development: ● Graywater included in a landscape water budget allowance ● Graywater stub-out requirement ● Fully installed graywater system required ii. Landscape Standards Best Practices ● Soil characteristics ● Subsurface irrigation system design ● Mulch basin design 3. Rainwater Capture a. Justification: Rainwater can also be used to reduce potable water demand by capturing, holding and releasing collected water to the landscape. While active and passive rainwater capture is incentivized through the water budget, some stakeholders shared 15 that mandating rainwater capture could be financially burdensome and would potentially not make a significant difference given Moab’s arid climate. b. Current standards: No local standards, state statute (73-3-1.5) allows for rain catchment storage up to 2,500 gallons or up to 100 gallons without registering. c. Examples of Potential Modifications i. Incentivize and/or require passive or active rainwater harvesting ● Landscape water budget allowance ● Requiring specific forms of rainwater harvesting on some properties ii. Landscape Standards Best Practices ● Rain garden / bioswale design ● Rain barrel installation 16 ATTACHMENT A: Maximum Allowed Landscape Water Budget Effective Precipitation: Effective Precipitation (25 – 75% total rainfall) = 1.6 – 4.7 gal/sf/season o Precipitation during irrigation season = 6.27 in (Mar – Oct) ▪ Per Desert Research Institute1 Reference Evapotranspiration: • ETo = 57.38 inches/season (Mar – Oct) o Per AgriMet Castle Valley UT station2 Irrigated Area • Irrigated Area = hydrozone area in sq-ft Water Use Category Plant Factor3 High (including Cool Season Turf & Water Features) 0.8 Medium 0.5 Low 0.2 Very Low / Non-Irrigated 0 Irrigation Method Default Efficiency Overhead 70% Drip 90% Water Feature 75% Special Features to Incentivize Healthy Landscapes (% of irrigated landscape) Maximum Applied Water Budget (gal/sf/season) At least 15% +3 gal / sf / season At least 10% +2 gal / sf / season At least 5% + 1 gal / sf / season 1 Annual rainfall during irrigation season from Moab, Desert Research Institute https://wrcc.dri.edu/cgi- bin/cliMAIN.pl?ut5733); Effective precipitation ranges from 25 – 75% based on local climate factors. 2 Average tall reference ETo from 2015 – 2021; https://www.usbr.gov/pn/agrimet/etsummary.html?station=csvu&year=2021. Additional supporting information: Peak monthly ETo for Moab in June is 9.55 (EPA WaterSense Water Budget); Fruita, Colorado – CoAgMet station captured an ETo of 59.55 for irrigation season. 3 This table is based on EPA WaterSense Water Budget tool designations, plus an additional VL/Non -Irrigated category to incentivize VL hydrozone plants. 17 Special Features include: • Non-irrigated protected native vegetation areas • Ecological restoration projects • Bioretention areas • Non-irrigated permeable areas • stormwater conveyance infrastructure (vegetated swales) • Graywater applied to the landscape (% based on % living plant material primarily watered with graywater) Active Rainwater Catchment Amount of Rainwater Catchment Capacity Reduction in Calculated Irrigation Water Need (gallons) 1 x 50 gallon rain barrel 100 2 x 50 gallon rain barrel (100 gal) 200 101 - 500 gallon-cistern 1,000 501 - 1000 gallon-cistern 2,000 1,001 – 1,500-gallon cistern 3,000 1,501 – 2,000 gallon cistern 3,750 2,001 – 2,500 gallon cistern 4,500 Sample Hydrozone Tables Irrigation Water Budget = [(ETo × Plant Factor) – Re] × Irrigated Area ÷ Irrigation Efficiency × 0.623 Example 1: 1/3 of each High, Medium and Low Water Hydrozones (w/ 75% Effective Precip) Hydrozone ETo Plant Water Use Category Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq ft) Irrigation Water Need (gal/season) Zone 1 57.4 H 0.8 4.7 Overhead 0.7 1,000 36,6854 Zone 2 57.4 M 0.5 4.7 Drip 0.9 1,000 16,613 Zone 3 57.4 L 0.2 4.7 Drip 0.9 1,000 4,693 TOTAL (c) 3,000 (d) 57,991 Avg. irrigation water need all zones = (d / c) = 19.33 gal/sf/season Example 1B: 1/3 of H,M, L Hydrozones (w/ 25% Effective Precip) Hydrozone ETo Plant Water Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq ft) Irrigation Water Need (gal/season) 4 Note: If the entire area was high water use (turf), landscape water use per square foot would be 36.6 gal/sf/season 18 Use Category Zone 1 57.4 H 0.8 1.6 Overhead 0.7 1,000 39,445 Zone 2 57.4 M 0.5 1.6 Drip 0.9 1,000 18,759 Zone 3 57.4 L 0.2 1.6 Drip 0.9 1,000 6,839 TOTAL (c) 3,000 (d) 65,043 Avg. irrigation water need all zones = (d / c) = 21.7 gal/sf/season Example 2: 1/4 H and M, 1/2 Low Water Hydrozones Hydrozone ETo Plant Water Use Category Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq ft) Irrigation Water Need (gal/season) Zone 1 57.4 H 0.8 4.7 Overhead 0.7 1,500 55,029 Zone 2 57.4 M 0.5 4.7 Drip 0.9 1,500 24,920 Zone 3 57.4 L 0.2 4.7 Drip 0.9 3,000 14,080 TOTAL (c) 6,000 (d) 93,729 Average irrigation water needs = 15.62 gal/sf/season Example 2: 1/4 H, M, L, VL/Non-irrigated Hydrozone ETo Plant Water Use Category Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq ft) Irrigation Water Need (gal/season) Zone 1 57.4 H 0.8 4.7 Overhead 0.7 1,000 36,685 Zone 2 57.4 M 0.5 4.7 Drip 0.9 1,000 16,613 Zone 3 57.4 L 0.2 4.7 Drip 0.9 1,000 4,693 Zone 4 VL 0 1,000 TOTAL (c) 4,000 (d) 57,991 Average irrigation water needs = 14.5 gal/sf/season Example 4: 10% H and, 1/4 M, 1/2 L, 15% VL w/ a 2,500 gallon cistern Hydrozone ETo Plant Water Use Category Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq ft) Irrigation Water Need (gal/season) Zone 1 57.4 H 0.8 4.7 Overhead 0.7 600 22,011 Zone 2 57.4 M 0.5 4.7 Drip 0.9 1,500 24,920 Zone 3 57.4 L 0.2 4.7 Drip 0.9 3,000 14,080 Zone 4 VL 0 900 0 Subtotal (c) 6,000 (d) 61,011 19 Rainwater Capture - 4,500 TOTAL 6,000 56,511 Average irrigation water needs w/out cistern = 10.16 gal/sf/season Average irrigation water needs w/ cistern = 9.42 gal/sf/season Special Features Special Feature Special Feature Response Total area of Special Features (sq-ft) 600 Total percent of Special Features 10% Maximum Applied Water Budget (gal/sf/seaon) + 2 gal/sf/season Recommended water budget allowance = 15 gal/sf/season Moab City Council Agenda Item Draft Ordinance 2022-05: Active Employment Household Requirement Meeting Date: March 22, 2022 Title: Briefing and Discussion on Moab City Draft Ordinance #2022-05, An Ordinance Amending the Moab Municipal Code R-3 Multi-Household Residential Zone, and R-4 Manufactured Housing Residential Zone with an Active Employment Household Requirement. Disposition: Briefing and Discussion Staff Presenter: Cory P. Shurtleff, Planning Director Attachment(s): - Exhibit 1: Draft AEH Ordinance #2022-05 031722 redline cps Background: Staff Update on Draft Ordinance #2022-05. Presentation from BAE Urban Economics on progress with formulation of data, establishing a rational basis for percentage requirement of Active Employment Units designated by Multi-Household Dwelling projects. Available consultation by Snow Christensen & Martineau for legal land use questions and concerns. Narrative Summary: City initiated Ordinance #2022-05, an Ordinance amending the text of the Moab Municipal Code (MMC) Sections 17.48 R-3 Multi-Household Residential Zone, and R-4 Manufactured Housing Residential Zone, to add a use parameter requirement to the Multi-Household permitted use, such that a percentage of units be designated as Active Employment Units (AEU) to qualified Active Employment Households (AEH). This Ordinance is in response to City Resolution #33-2021, initiating the Pending Ordinance Doctrine drafting period. Objective: Update City Council on progress made in the drafting and data formulation for Draft Ordinance #2022-05. Discussion and questions by Council to advance direction of Staff and Consultants to complete final draft ordinance. CITY OF MOAB, UTAH ORDINANCE NO. 2022-05 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE TEXT OF THE MOAB MUNICIPAL CODE (MMC) SECTIONS 17.48 R-3 MULTI- HOUSEHOLD RESIDENTIAL ZONE, AND 17.51 R-4 MANUFACTURED HOUSING RESIDENTIAL ZONE, TO ADD A USE PARAMETER REQUIREMENT TO THE MULTI-HOUSEHOLD PERMITTED USE, SUCH THAT 00% OF UNITS BE DESIGNATED AS ACTIVE EMPLOYMENT UNITS (AEU) TO QUALIFIED ACTIVE EMPLOYMENT HOUSEDHOLDS (AEH) WHEREAS, the stock of workforce housing in Moab is being replaced by new townhomes and condominiums that are not affordable for workers employed in and around Moab who need housing, often because these new homes are being built for the second home market; and WHEREAS, persons employed in and around Moab are unable to afford housing given current wage and housing trends; and WHEREAS, the cost of housing has risen with median home prices having increased 22% from last year, from $400,000 to $490,000, which is unaffordable to most workers given the annual household median income of $52,000; and WHEREAS, the lack of affordable housing can result in crowding, undesirable living conditions, lack of funds available for other basic needs, and a decrease in the quality of life for Moab workers and their families; and WHEREAS, the supply of rental units available for workforce housing are at an all- time low; and WHEREAS, the Moab City Planning Department has received application or inquiries for numerous multi-household projects on parcels that currently contain attainable workforce housing that will be removed and replaced by higher-priced market-rate units that are unaffordable for the Moab area workforce; and WHEREAS, there are many parcels in Moab that are underutilized and property owners are selling the properties to developers who intend to remove existing workforce housing units and replace them with units that are not affordable for workforce housing; and WHEREAS, employers in and around Moab are unable to hire employees because of this lack of affordable workforce housing; and WHEREAS, the City has adopted the 2016 Moab Area Affordable Housing Plan, the City and other agencies have implemented many of the Plan's recommendations, and the City is in the process of reviewing additional barriers to the construction of housing in the community; and WHEREAS, the City Council is in support of eliminating barriers to increasing the inventory of workforce housing; and WHEREAS, from time to time the City undertakes revisions in its zoning ordinances to improve the quality of land development and align the Code with state law and contemporary planning concepts; and WHEREAS, the Moab Municipal Code Chapter 17.04, Zoning Map Amendments and Text Amendments, permits the Zoning Text Amendment process to allow amendments to the use requirements within zoning districts; and WHEREAS, in order to address the lack of affordable workforce housing, the Moab City Council formally initiated proceedings to amend the Moab Municipal Code Section 17.48 R-3 Multi-Household Residential Zone, and 17.51 R-4 Multi- Household Residential Zone, through Resolution #33-2021, approved October 12, 2021, to specifically evaluate the need for and the use parameters for requiring a percentage of Active Employment Household Unit occupancy in Multi- Household Developments; and WHEREAS, the City has also coordinated and contracted for research by BAE Urban Economics to analyze and determine the need for a particular percentage of designated Active Employment Units to be required as a permitted use parameter in the identified zoning districts in order to address the lack of affordable workforce housing; and WHEREAS, the City finds that there is a compelling need for and public purpose for adopting this Ordinance due to the market conditions and other factors that are not supplying the needed numbers of affordable housing units for Moab; and WHEREAS, this process is one of many strategies that have and are being considered by the City of Moab to address Moab’s workforce housing need; and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED that the Moab City Council hereby approves the Text Amendments as follows: PASSED AND APPROVED in open Council by a majority vote of the Governing Body of Moab City Council this 00th day of March 2022. SECTION 1. AMENDMENTS TO MMC CHAPTER 17.06 DEFINITIONS ADDING OR MODIFYING DEFINITIONS OF: A. “Active employment household” or “actively employed household” or “AEH”, means a household with at least one adult who meets one of the following criteria; provided, however, where there are unrelated individuals living together in one household, at least 50 percent of all the adults comprising the household shall meet one of the following criteria: 1. A full-time (aggregate of at least 30 hours of employment per week for a minimum of nine months per calendar year) employee of a business, or entity, or entities located within Grand County; or 2. An owner or owner’s representative of a business or entity with a primary place of business within Grand County; or 3. A full-time (aggregate of 30 hours of employment per week for a minimum of nine months out of each calendar year) worker who is self- employed or works out of their home must provide their entire list of clients/workload so that it can be verified that a minimum of 75 percent of their work/billable hours are for clients or projects are based located within Grand County. 4. A person who is unable to work or does not have a work history required under subsections F.1 through F.3 of this section due to a disability as defined by the state and federal Fair Housing Acts; 5. A family member of the owner of the property 6. A retiree with a work history required under subsection 1 through 4 of this section for the five years prior to retirement. B. “Active Employment Unit” or “AEU”, means a dwelling unit that is required to be occupied by a qualified Active Employment Household. SECTION 2. AMEND CHAPTER 17.48 R-3 MULTI-HOUSEHOLD RESIDENTIAL ZONE SECTION 17.48.020. PERMITTED USES AND REGULATIONS, AS FOLLOWS: 17.48.010. Objectives and characteristics The objective in establishing the R-3 residential zone is to provide appropriate locations within the City for high density development, primarily occupied by full-time residents, and employees and owners of local businesses. In general, this zone is located in the central part of the City, adjacent to commercial areas where the impact of vehicular travel and parking is consonant with adjacent use of land, and where multiple dwellings can best be supplied with necessary public facilities. This zone is characterized by more compact development and somewhat higher volumes of traffic than is characteristic of the R-1 and R-2 zones. 17.48.020. 7. Multi-Household Dwellings. a. Developments consisting of three or more multi-household units shall be subject to the following requirements: i. Access. Vehicular access shall be provided to the property in such a way that it does not impede traffic patterns on adjacent streets. ii.i. Parking. Off-street parking shall be designed in such a way as to allow vehicles to pull forward into the on-street traffic flow. iii.i. 00% of the units in a multi-household development shall be designated as Active Employment Units, as defined by MMC Chapter 17.06. definitions, and regulated per MMC Chapter 17.64. Active Employment Households b. Developments consisting of seven or more multi-household units shall be subject to the following additional requirements: i. Access. Vehicular access shall be provided to the property in such a way that it does not impede traffic patterns on adjacent streets. ii. Parking. Off-street parking shall be designed in such a way as to allow vehicles to pull forward into the on-street traffic flow. i.iii. Garages or Carports. If provided, garages and carports shall not be located in the front yard and shall be set back from the front wall of the principal structure at least fifteen feet or be accessed from the rear or side of the property. Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.75", No bullets ornumbering Formatted: Indent: Left: 1", No bullets or numbering ii.iv. Landscaping. All off-street parking shall be landscaped and buffered from adjacent uses. A minimum of fifteen percent of the interior of the parking area shall be landscaped to provide shade and break up the expanse of asphalt. iii.v. Buffering. All adjacent uses shall be buffered by a distance of not less than fifteen feet and contain berms, shrubs, and other plantings. Buffering may be combined with screens, fences and hedges. iv.vi. Apartments and court apartments shall designate an open space/recreation area that is a minimum of two hundred square feet in size to be developed into recreation, play or landscaped areas. The requirement can be met with the construction of a recreation room (“rec room”) or club house of a similarly sized area that can be used for residents and their guests for recreation/social activities and/or relaxation. v.vii. The allowed number of multi-household units shall be determined by Section 17.48.030. SECTION 3. AMEND CHAPTER 17.51 R-4 MANUFACTURED HOUSING RESIDENTIAL ZONE SECTION 17.51.020. PERMITTED USES AND REGULATIONS, AS FOLLOWS: 17.51.010 Objectives and characteristics. The objective in establishing the R-4 residential zone is to provide the most appropriate locations for mobile home parks, and mobile home subdivisions, along with and conventional dwellings of other construction. The zone is characterized by open fields interspersed by well-maintained mobile home parks, mobile home subdivisions, and other types of dwellings,. all primarily occupied by full-time residents, and employees and owners of local businesses. 17.70.020. 8. Multi-Household Dwellings. a. Developments consisting of three or more multi-household units shall be subject to the following requirements: i. Access. Vehicular access shall be provided to the property in such a way that it does not impede traffic patterns on adjacent streets. ii.i. Parking. Off-street parking shall be designed in such a way as to allow vehicles to pull forward into the on-street traffic flow. iii.i. 00% of the units in a multi-household development shall be designated as Active Employment Units, as defined by MMC Chapter 17.06. definitions, and regulated per MMC Chapter 17.64. Active Employment Households b. Developments consisting of seven or more multi-household units shall be subject to the following additional requirements: i. Access. Vehicular access shall be provided to the property in such a way that it does not impede traffic patterns on adjacent streets. ii. Parking. Off-street parking shall be designed in such a way as to allow vehicles to pull forward into the on-street traffic flow. i.iii. Garages or Carports. If provided, garages and carports shall not be located in the front yard and shall be set back from the front wall of the principal structure at least fifteen feet or be accessed from the rear or side of the property. ii.iv. Landscaping. All off-street parking shall be landscaped and buffered from adjacent uses. A minimum of fifteen percent of the interior of the parking area shall be landscaped to provide shade and break up the expanse of asphalt. iii.v. Buffering. All adjacent uses shall be buffered by a distance of not less than fifteen feet and contain berms, shrubs, and other plantings. Buffering may be combined with screens, fences and hedges. Formatted: Indent: Left: 1.5", No bullets or Formatted: Indent: Left: 1.5", No bullets or iv.vi. Apartments and court apartments shall designate an open space/recreation area that is a minimum of two hundred square feet in size to be developed into recreation, play or landscaped areas. The requirement can be met with the construction of a recreation room (“rec room”) or club house of a similarly sized area that can be used for residents and their guests for recreation/social activities and/or relaxation. v.vii. The allowed number of multi-household units shall be determined by Section 17.51.030. SECTION 4. ADD CHAPTER 17.64 ACTIVE EMPLOYMENT HOUSEHOLDS, AS FOLLOWS: 17.64.010. Purpose. Active Employment Household is a defined use parameter, meant to identify qualified workforce residents, whereby the permitted uses in zoning districts may include a required designation for Active Employment Units as a part of a development or qualified occupancy of dwelling property. 17.64.020. General Standards. 1) Active Employment Households shall be regulated by this Chapter 17.64, in addition to the requirements defined in MMC Chapter 17.06 Definitions, for “Accessory Dwelling Unit, Type 1”, and “Accessory Dwelling Unit, Type 2”. 2) Active Employment Households and Active Employment Units required as a use parameter for the permitted use of Multi-Household Dwelling developments shall be regulated as follows: a) Not less than zerozero percent (00%) of the number of dwellings approved for multi-household dwelling developments in the R-3 Multi-Household Residential Zone and R-4 Manufactured Housing Residential Zone shall be designated or deed restricted to be Active Employment Units. b) Active Employment Units shall be: i) Roughly proportional by number in type (e.g. studio, one bedroom, two bedroom…) and size (square footage) to the free market units; and ii) Of a quality, both aesthetically and with respect to the standard construction, that is not materially different from the free market units. c) The Active Employment Units shall be ready for occupancy no later than the date of the initial, or temporary occupancy of any free market units with the project or applicable phase thereof. If the free-market units are developed in phases, then the Active Employment Units may be developed in proportion to the phasing of the free market units (e.g. not less than 00% of the units developed for occupancy in any phase shall be Active Employment Units). d) Active Employment Units shall only be occupied by households who qualify as Active Employment Households. e) Active Employment Units shall be occupied by Active Employment Households a minimum of nine (9) months per calendar year in total. f) Active Employment Units shall not be occupied, rented, leased by Active Employment Households for less than ninety (90) consecutive days. 17.64.030 Submittal requirements and approval criteria. 1. Active Employment Unit Designation a. Active Employment Units shall be designated through one or more of the following: i. AEUs shall be designated on Townhome or Condominium Plat for Multi-Household Developments in the R3 Multi-Household Residential Zone and R4 Manufactured Housing Residential Zone that require Townhome or Condominium Plat Approval. ii. AEUs shall be designation on Site Plan Approval materials for Multi- Household Developments in the R3 Multi-Household Residential Zone and R4 Manufactured Housing Residential Zone that require Site Plan Approval. iii. AEUs shall be designated on Building Permit Plan Approval for Multi- Household Developments in the R3 Multi-Household Residential Zone and R4 Manufactured Housing Residential Zone that require Building Permit Plan Approval. iv. AEUs shall be designated by Deed Restriction for Type 1 and Type 2 ADUs per MMC Chapter 17.70 Accessory Dwelling Units. b. Deed Restriction i. A deed restriction must be filed with the Grand County Recorder’s Office, which states: 1. “An approval for an Active Employment Unit was issued to______________, the current owner of this property on_____________. The owner shall strictly adhere to the prohibition of the use of the Active Employment Unit as nightly or short-term rental. The lease period for an Active Employment Unit shall be a minimum of ninety (90) days.” Modified deed restriction language may be proposed by the City. In the occurrence that the MMC requirements and regulations change regarding this restriction, a Release of Deed Restriction, signed by the City, may remove this restriction. 2. “An approval for an Active Employment Unit was issued to______________, the current owner of this property on_____________. The owner, and or, occupant, shall strictly adhere to the Moab Municipal Code requirements and regulations for Active Employment Units and Active Employment Households” Modified deed restriction language may be proposed by the City. In the occurrence that the MMC requirements and regulations change regarding this restriction, a Release of Deed Restriction, signed by the City, may remove this restriction. 2. Active Employment Household Qualification a. Active Employment Households shall meet one of the following criteria: i. A full-time (aggregate of 30 hours of employment per week) employee of a business, or entity, or entities located within Grand County; or ii. An owner or owner’s representative of a business or entity with a primary place of business within Grand County; or iii. A full-time (aggregate of 30 hours of employment per week for nine months out of each calendar year) worker who is self-employed or works out of their home must provide their entire list of clients/workload so that it can be verified that a minimum of 75 percent of their work/clients are based within Grand County. iv. A person who is unable to work or does not have a work history required under subsections 2.a.i through 2.a.iii of this section due to a disability as defined by the state and federal Fair Housing Acts; v. A family member of the owner of the property vi. A retiree with a work history required under subsection 2.a.i through 2.a.iv of this section for the five years prior to retirement. b. Active Employment Households shall verify qualifications through staff review and approval as part of applicable approval process; verification submittals may include: i. Verification of Occupancy 1. Grand County Tax Roll Master Record of Ownership and Primary Residency 2. Occupant Rent/Lease Agreement of not less than ninety (90) days. ii. Verification of qualified Active Employment Household 1. Employee Verification Form 2. Home Occupation Business License 17.64.040. Review procedures. 1. The Land Use Authority responsible for the type and process of development (e.g. Building Permit Approval, Site Plan Approval, Townhome Plat or Condominium Plat Approval), shall review and approval the proportionality requirement for Active Employment Units referenced in MMC 17.64.020.2.b. 2. Prior to the preliminary or final plan or plat approvals for any project or phase of project, the Active Employment Units shall be identified and designated on the preliminary and final plan or plat for such projects or phases. 17.70.050 Enforcement. In addition to any other legal or equitable remedies available to a municipality, the City may pursue enforcement and compliance for a municipality may foreclose or hold a lien against a property that contains designated Active Employment Household Units in violation, or if the owner of the property violates any of the provisions of this section. 1. Violation a. The requirements and regulations set forth herein regulating the use and occupancy of the Active Employment Units shall run with the portion of land or designation of units constituting the required percentage or dedication of Active Employment Units of a Multi-Household development or Accessory Dwelling Unit: i. The required designation of Active Employment Units shall extend for as long as the use parameter remains a requirement of the permitted use for compliance within the zone. The following conditions of violation will impose the following penalty: (1) The designated property or property containing the Active Employment Unit will be in violation if the Active Employment Unit is occupied by any household that is not a qualified AEH, if, 30 days after written notice from the City, the AEU is not occupied by and AEH. (2) The designated property or property containing the Active Employment Unit will be in violation if the AEU is not occupied by an AEH for a minimum of nine (9) months in any calendar year, allowing the AEU to be unoccupied for ninety (90) days, if, 30 days after notice from the City, the AEU is not occupied by an AEH. (3) The designated property or property containing the Active Employment Unit will be in violation if the AEU is occupied, rented or leased, by an AEH, less than ninety (90) consecutive days, if, 30 days after notice from the City, the AEU is not occupied by an AEH. (4) In the event of violation, penalties may be assessed by the City against the Active Employment Unit owner, as determined by the Moab Municipal Code Chapter 17.78. Zoning Violations--Penalties. in the case of an amount, it may be equal to the number of days that the AEU is not occupied by an AEH multiplied by an approved rate by the City Council, commencing on the date of the City’s written notice of default and continuing thereafter until the date that the default is cured. The City reserves the right to seek specific performance of the municipal code and judicial enforcement of the foregoing penalties, including seeking a judgement lien and foreclosure. 1) Process of Violation a) If the owner of the property violates any of the provisions of this Chapter, the City may peruse the violation for noncompliance in accordance with established processes outlined by Moab Municipal Code Chapter 17.78. Zoning Violations-- Penalties. In addition to any other legal or equitable remedies, Moab City may hold a lien against a property that contains the Active Employment Unit if: as follows: 1. The City provides a written notice of violation 2. The City holds a hearing and determines that the violation has occurred. if the owner files a timely written objection 3. The owner fails to cure the violation within the time period prescribed in the written notice of violation 4. The City provides a written notice of lien with the county recorder of the county in which the property is located. The written notice of violation shall a. Describe the specific violation b. Provide the owner of the Active Employment Unit a reasonable opportunity to cure the violation no less than 14 days after the day on which the City sends notice of violation, if the violation results from the owner renting or offering to rent the Active Employment Unit for a period of less than 30 consecutive days or no less than 30 days after the day on which the City sends the written notice of violation, for any other violation c. State that if the owner of the property fails to cure the violation within the relevant time period, the City may hold a lien against the property in an amount of up to $100 for each day of violation after the day on which the opportunity to cure the violation expires d. Notify the owner of the property that the owner may file a written objection to the violation within 14 days after the day on which the written notice of violation is post-marked or posted on the property; and of the name and address of the municipal office where the owner may file the written objection to be mailed to the property’s owner of record; any other individuals designated to receive notice in the owner’s license or permit records e. Posted on the property f. The written notice of lien shall state that the property is subject to a lien, specify the lien amount, in an amount of up to $100 for each day of violation after the day on which the property's owner of record; and any other individual designated to receive notice in the owner's license or permit record and be posted on the property. Formatted: List Paragraph, Outline numbered + Level:2 + Numbering Style: a, b, c, … + Start at: 1 +Alignment: Left + Aligned at: 0.25" + Indent at: 0.5" 5. If an owner of property files a written objection in accordance with Subsection the City shall: a. hold a hearing in accordance with Title 52, Chapter 4, Open and Public Meetings Act, to conduct a review and determine whether the specific violation described in the written notice of violation under has occurred; and b. notify the owner in writing of the date, time, and location of the hearing. The hearing notice shall be sent no less than 14 days before the day on which the hearing is held. 6. If an owner of property files a written objection the City may not record a lien until the City holds a hearing and determines that the specific violation has occurred. 7. If the City determines at the hearing that the specific violation has occurred, the City may impose a lien in an amount of up to $100 for each day of violation after the day on which the opportunity to cure the violation expires, regardless of whether the hearing is held after the day on which the opportunity to cure the violation has expired. 8. If an owner cures a violation within the time period prescribed in the written notice of violation the City may not hold a lien against the property, or impose any penalty or fee on the owner, in relation to the specific violation described in the written notice of violation. 9. A municipality that issues a permit or license to an owner of an Active Employment Unit to rent the unit to an Active Employment Household, or a building permit to an owner of a qualifying Active Employment Household development to create Active Employment Units, may record a notice in the office of the Grand County recorder. The notice shall include a. A description of the AEU dwellings; and b. A statement that the development contains designated AEU dwellings; and c. A statement that the AEU dwellings may only be used in accordance with the municipality’s land use regulations. d. The municipality/jurisdiction shall, upon recording the notice described, deliver a copy of the notice to the owner of the AEU dwelling. PASSED by the City Council in a public meeting on _____________ by the following vote: MOAB CITY COUNCIL: Those voting aye:_____________________________________ Those voting nay:____________________________________ Those abstaining: ___________________________________ Those absent:_______________________________________ __________________________________________________________ Joette Langianese, Mayor Date ATTEST:______________________________________________________ Sommar Johnson, Clerk/Recorder 6-1 Public Hearing Moab City Council Agenda Item Meeting Date: March 22, 2022 Title: Briefing and Possible Adoption of Proposed Ordinance #2022-03 – Adopting the Pay Plan Schedule and Appointed/Exempt and Elected Salaries Presenter: Dani Guerrero – HR Director Attachment(s): - Proposed Ordinance #2022-03 - Attachment A: Proposed FY 2022-23 Pay Plans - Attachment B: Exempt and Elected Salaries Background/Summary: This is the next procedural step to meet the requirement that compensation ranges be adopted annually by Ordinance after a Public Hearing. The public hearing was held on March 22, 2022. Attached are the proposed pay ranges for fiscal year 2022- 2023. These ranges have been adjusted by a 5.9% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA). ORDINANCE NO. 2022-03 AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING THE CITY OF MOAB PAY PLAN SCHEDULE AND ADOPTING THE EXEMPT AND ELECTED OFFICIALS SALARIES FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022-2023 WHEREAS, the Moab City Policies Manual allows that pay ranges may be adjusted periodically for comparable work in other municipalities; and WHEREAS, the Moab City Polices Manual calls for annual surveys of salaries; and WHEREAS, in 2021 the City conducted a comprehensive salary survey through the utilization of Personnel Systems Inc. and has presented the survey results to the Governing Body; and WHEREAS, positions within the City are rated and ranked according to four factors: Job Knowledge, Responsibility, Difficulty, and Work Environment and salaries are calculated based on those ratings and rankings and incorporated into the pay plan schedule; and WHEREAS, the proposed “City of Moab 2022-2023 Pay Plan” is attached to this Ordinance as Attachment A, respectively; and WHEREAS, the proposed “Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries” is attached to this ordinance as Attachment B, respectively; and WHEREAS, Moab Municipal Code Section 2.44.010 states that all salaries of the elective and appointive officers of the City and the other employees of the City shall be fixed by a motion or resolution of the City Council as in accordance with existing law. NOW, THEREFORE, WE, THE GOVERNING BODY OF THE CITY OF MOAB RESOLVE TO ADOPT The City of Moab 2022-2023 Pay Plan (Attachment A) and the Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries (Attachment B) as referred herein. DATED this 22nd day of March 2022. SIGNED ___________________________________________ Joette Langianese Mayor ATTEST: ____________________________________ Sommar Johnson City Recorder Ordinance #2022-03 March 22, 2022 ATTACHMENT B Exempt and Elected Officials Salaries Section 1. The following are exempt positions: City Engineer……………………………………….. See approved pay plan City Manager……………………………………….. See approved pay plan City Recorder……………………………………….. See approved pay plan City Treasurer………………………………………. See approved pay plan Deputy City Manager…………………………… See approved pay plan Finance Director………………………………….. See approved pay plan Human Resource Director……………………. See approved pay plan Park, Recreation & Trails Director………… See approved pay plan Planning Director…………………………………. See approved pay plan Police Chief………………………………………….. See approved pay plan Public Works Director………………………….. See approved pay plan Section 2. Yearly salary rates for the following elected official positions: Mayor………………………………………………….. $41,057 Councilmembers………………………………….. $33,817 Planning Commission Members…………… $75 per meeting Information about all Moab City financial transactions can be found at: https://transparent.utah.gov/ Ordinance #2022-03 – Attachment B JOB TITLE Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum Administrative Assistant - Admin $20.96 $26.20 $31.44 $43,593 $54,491 $65,389 Administrative Assistant - Planning $20.96 $26.20 $31.44 $43,593 $54,491 $65,389 Administrative Assistant - Public Works $20.96 $26.20 $31.44 $43,593 $54,491 $65,389 Administrative Assistant II - Evidence $23.27 $29.09 $34.91 $48,403 $60,503 $72,604 Administrative Assistant II - FATPOT $22.85 $28.57 $34.28 $47,535 $59,418 $71,302 Animal Shelter Manager $25.80 $32.25 $38.71 $53,672 $67,090 $80,508 Aquatic Mechanical Manager $26.81 $33.52 $40.22 $55,774 $69,718 $83,661 Aquatics Manager $27.18 $33.97 $40.77 $56,533 $70,666 $84,800 Arts Director $29.00 $36.26 $43.51 $60,330 $75,413 $90,495 Assistant City Engineer $29.18 $36.48 $43.78 $60,702 $75,878 $91,054 Assistant City Engineer - GIS $27.86 $34.83 $41.79 $57,951 $72,438 $86,926 Assistant City Planner $25.54 $31.92 $38.31 $53,118 $66,397 $79,676 Associate Arts Director $22.32 $27.90 $33.48 $46,419 $58,024 $69,629 Associate Sports Director $23.47 $29.34 $35.21 $48,822 $61,027 $73,233 Building Official $35.74 $44.68 $53.62 $74,349 $92,937 $111,524 City Attorney $54.11 $67.63 $81.16 $112,540 $140,675 $168,810 City Engineer $44.12 $55.15 $66.18 $91,766 $114,707 $137,648 City Manager $65.29 $79.98 $94.67 $135,802 $166,358 $196,913 City Recorder $37.26 $46.57 $55.89 $77,499 $96,873 $116,248 City Treasurer $36.31 $45.39 $54.47 $75,535 $94,419 $113,303 Code Compliance $27.38 $34.23 $41.08 $56,958 $71,198 $85,438 Code Enforcement I/Animal Control $19.78 $24.72 $29.67 $41,141 $51,426 $61,711 Code Enforcement II/Animal Control $22.48 $28.11 $33.73 $46,767 $58,459 $70,151 Code Enforcement Supervisor/Animal Control $27.72 $34.65 $41.58 $57,660 $72,075 $86,490 Communications and Engagement $35.51 $44.38 $53.26 $73,851 $92,313 $110,776 Construction Inspector $31.86 $39.83 $47.80 $66,277 $82,847 $99,416 Deputy City Manager $55.03 $68.79 $82.54 $114,460 $143,075 $171,690 Deputy Recorder I $21.18 $26.48 $31.77 $44,056 $55,070 $66,084 Deputy Recorder II $25.23 $31.54 $37.84 $52,478 $65,597 $78,717 Deputy Treasurer I $21.07 $26.34 $31.61 $43,834 $54,792 $65,750 Deputy Treasurer II $24.23 $30.28 $36.34 $50,391 $62,989 $75,587 Finance Director $53.33 $66.66 $80.00 $110,930 $138,662 $166,395 Human Resource Assistant $25.71 $32.14 $38.56 $53,474 $66,842 $80,211 Human Resource Director $49.57 $61.97 $74.36 $103,114 $128,892 $154,671 Moab Arts Assistant (part time) $19.37 $24.21 $29.05 $40,283 $50,354 $60,425 Parks, Recreation & Trails Director $38.30 $47.88 $57.46 $79,673 $99,591 $119,510 Permit Technician $21.55 $26.94 $32.33 $44,833 $56,041 $67,249 Planning Director $43.49 $54.36 $65.23 $90,457 $113,072 $135,686 Police Office Manager $25.62 $32.03 $38.44 $53,298 $66,623 $79,947 Safety Specialist $26.02 $32.52 $39.03 $54,121 $67,651 $81,181 Senior Projects Manager $26.41 $33.01 $39.62 $54,937 $68,671 $82,405 Sports Director $29.15 $36.44 $43.72 $60,631 $75,788 $90,946 Sustainability Director $29.38 $36.73 $44.07 $61,116 $76,395 $91,674 Victim Assistance Unit Manager $26.74 $33.42 $40.11 $55,614 $69,518 $83,421 Zoning Administrator $27.17 $33.96 $40.76 $56,516 $70,645 $84,774 Annual Pay Rates Pay Range Pay Range City of Moab General Proposed Pay Plan 2022-2023 (5.9% COLA) Hourly Pay Rates JOB TITLE Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum Detective $31.51 $39.39 $47.27 $65,550 $81,938 $98,325 Investigations Sergeant $37.42 $46.77 $56.12 $77,827 $97,283 $116,740 Police Assistant Chief $42.32 $52.90 $63.48 $88,026 $110,032 $132,039 Police Chief $54.91 $68.64 $82.37 $114,216 $142,770 $171,324 Police Officer I $27.58 $34.48 $41.37 $57,368 $71,709 $86,051 Police Officer II $28.84 $36.05 $43.26 $59,990 $74,987 $89,985 Police Officer III $32.55 $40.69 $48.82 $67,700 $84,625 $101,550 Police Sergeant $36.97 $46.22 $55.46 $76,903 $96,129 $115,355 School Resource Officer $29.37 $36.71 $44.06 $61,090 $76,363 $91,636 Pay Range Pay Range City of Moab Police Proposed Pay Plan 22-23 (5.9% COLA) Hourly Pay Rates Annual Pay Rates JOB TITLE Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum Facilities Lead $34.81 $43.52 $52.22 $72,412 $90,515 $108,617 Facilities Mechanical Technician $24.73 $30.91 $37.09 $51,430 $64,287 $77,145 Facilities Worker I $20.77 $25.96 $31.15 $43,195 $53,994 $64,793 Facilities Worker II $21.15 $26.44 $31.72 $43,992 $54,989 $65,987 Facilities Worker III $25.02 $31.28 $37.53 $52,044 $65,055 $78,066 Fleet Mechanic II $25.13 $31.41 $37.69 $52,265 $65,331 $78,397 Fleet Mechanic III $30.11 $37.64 $45.17 $62,638 $78,298 $93,957 Parks Lead $38.07 $47.58 $57.10 $79,178 $98,973 $118,768 Parks Worker I $22.18 $27.72 $33.27 $46,132 $57,665 $69,198 Parks Worker II $23.38 $29.23 $35.08 $48,639 $60,798 $72,958 Parks Worker III $27.87 $34.83 $41.80 $57,960 $72,450 $86,941 Public Works Director $47.47 $59.33 $71.20 $98,729 $123,411 $148,093 Sewer Collections I $23.20 $29.00 $34.81 $48,264 $60,330 $72,396 Sewer Collections II $25.10 $31.38 $37.65 $52,214 $65,268 $78,322 Sewer Collections III $28.86 $36.08 $43.29 $60,034 $75,042 $90,050 Streets Lead $37.72 $47.15 $56.58 $78,456 $98,070 $117,684 Streets Worker I $22.50 $28.13 $33.75 $46,806 $58,507 $70,209 Streets Worker II $25.03 $31.29 $37.55 $52,068 $65,085 $78,102 Streets Worker III $28.94 $36.18 $43.42 $60,204 $75,256 $90,307 Water Lead $40.00 $50.00 $60.00 $83,205 $104,006 $124,807 Water Worker I $23.66 $29.57 $35.48 $49,204 $61,505 $73,806 Water Worker II $25.32 $31.65 $37.98 $52,666 $65,832 $78,999 Water Worker III $29.11 $36.39 $43.67 $60,555 $75,693 $90,832 WRF Superintendent $41.60 $52.00 $62.40 $86,524 $108,155 $129,786 WRF Worker II $25.40 $31.75 $38.10 $52,833 $66,041 $79,249 Pay Range Pay Range City of Moab Public Works Proposed Pay Plan 22-23 (5.9% COLA) Hourly Pay Rates Annual Pay Rates Moab City Council Agenda Item Meeting Date: March 22, 2022 Title: Ordinance 2022-06 - Master Fee Schedule Presenter: Marcy Mason Attachment(s):  Ordinance 2022-06 - Master Fee Schedule revisions (redline) Recommended Motion: I move to adopt Ordinance 2022-06, an Ordinance to Remove, Add, or Amend fees in the Moab Municipal Code Chapter 3.50, Master Fee Schedule. Background/Summary: Master fee scheduled (attached) to the proposed ordinance titled “Chapter 3.50 - Master Fee Schedule (revisions)” enumerates current fees, what changes are proposed, and the source of that fee in code, by resolution, or other means. Proposed Changes to some fee amounts: While the majority of fees are to remain unchanged, some are in need of an update, addition, or removal per previous Council direction or staff suggestion. The proposed changes are listed below for ease of reference. 3.50.050 Business Licenses 3.50.070 Records Requests 3.50.080 Deposit required for City-provided utilities 3.50.090 – Culinary water rates 3.50.100 Sanitary sewer rates 3.50.180 Civil code violations penalties (maximum fines noted) 3.50.190 Police services fees 3.50.210 Parks and facilities rental fees 3.50.220 Moab Arts and Recreation Center fees 3.50.250 Dogs and cats 3.50.260 Miscellaneous fees ORDINANCE #2022-06 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 3 OF THE MOAB MUNICIPAL CODE TO UPDATE CHAPTER 3.50, MASTER FEE SCHEDULE AND MODIFYING CERTAIN FEES AND RATES CHARGED BY THE CITY The following entries describe the intent and purpose of the City of Moab (“City”) of this ordinance: a. The City desires to update or create new fees for the following items (see Master Fee schedule attachment A for current and proposed fees):  Add -Business Licenses - Administration fee for business change of address applications (excluding home occupations)  Remove – Business Licenses - Retail beer licenses  Update – Record Request - Break out color copies  Update – Deposits required for city-provided utilities  Update – Culinary water rates  Update – Other culinary water fees  Add – Sewer rates - After hour service fee for septage dumps  Update – Business license – conducting business prior to obtaining the proper license  Update - Police services fees – Police report, copy of  Update - Parks and facilities rentals fees – Private use  Update - Parks and facilities rentals fees –Day camp rates  Update/remove – Moab Arts and Recreation center fees  Update – Dogs and cats – Replacement tag for dogs and cats, Impound fees, and adoption fees  Update/Add - Miscellaneous fees – penalty charge for AR and rental fee for conference room and council chambers. b. The City Council held a duly advertised public hearing during a regularly scheduled meeting on March 22, 2022, to hear evidence and public comment, and to review the Master Fee schedule. NOW, THEREFORE, the Council hereby ordains that the following amendments to the Moab Municipal Code 3.50, Master Fee Schedule, are adopted as noted in Attachment A PASSED AND APPROVED by majority of the City of Moab City Council. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage. SIGNED: _______________________________ ____________________________ Joette Langianese, Mayor Date ATTEST: ________________________________ Sommar Johnson, Recorder Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 1 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Chapter 3.50 MASTER FEE SCHEDULE Sections: 3.50.050 Business licenses. 3.50.060 Special event and street performer permits. 3.50.070 Records requests. 3.50.080 Deposit required for City-provided utilities. 3.50.090 Culinary water rates. 3.50.100 Sanitary sewer rates. 3.50.110 Storm water rates. 3.50.120 Trash and recycling rates. 3.50.130 Culinary water connection fees. 3.50.140 Culinary water impact fees. 3.50.150 Sanitary Sewer Connection Fees. 3.50.160 Sanitary sewer impact fees. 3.50.165 Building Service Fees. 3.50.170 Planning and engineering service fees. 3.50.180 Civil code violation penalties (maximum fines noted). 3.50.190 Police services fees. 3.50.200 Public Works staff and equipment fees. 3.50.210 Parks and facilities rental fees. 3.50.220 Moab Arts and Recreation Center fees. 3.50.230 Moab Recreation and Aquatic Center fees. 3.50.240 City sports fees. 3.50.250 Dogs and cats. 3.50.260 Miscellaneous fees. Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 2 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.050 Business licenses. Initial Renewal General business $99.00 $26.00 Vendor $214.00 $52.00 Vendor – ice cream truck $222.00 $52.00 Solicitor, peddler, merchant $111.00 $52.00 Nightly rentals, 3 units or less $116.00 $26.00 Nightly rental, more than 3 units $145.00 $26.00 Home occupation $0 $0 Administration fee for business change of address application (excluding home occupation) $25.00 each request Retail beer licenses Bar establishment $500.00 $500.00 Beer, recreational $200.00 $200.00 Hotel $500.00 $500.00 Off-premises sales $90.00 $90.00 Restaurant $200.00 $200.00 Tavern $500.00 $500.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 20-05 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.060 Special event and street performer permits. Event application fee $50.00 Commented [MM1]: We currently do not charge for  changes that require documentation to be updated and  signatures be obtained for change of address. The process is  the same as if they were applying for a new license.   Commented [MM2]: We no longer issue retail beer  license per ordinance 2020‐05.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 3 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Special event, Level 1* $466.00 Special event, Level 2* City may require a cash deposit or performance bond for Level II special events to cover estimated costs for damages, cleanup, or loss to public property. Unexpended balance will be returned to event sponsor. $820.00 Street performance permit fee $106.00 Filming permit $149.00 * City may waive fees only for a free speech event (Section 4.13.050). (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.070 Records requests. Record location, retrieval, research, and compilation $25.00/hr B&W photocopies for 8.5" x 11" $0.15 B&W photocopies for 8.5" x 11" double-sided $0.30 B&W photocopies for 11" x 14" $0.20 B&W photocopies for 11" x 14" double-sided $0.45 B&W photocopies for 11" x 17" $0.30 B&W photocopies for 11" x 17" double-sided $0.60 Color photocopies for 8.5" x 11" $0.50 Color photocopies for 8.5" x 11" double-sided $1.00 Color photocopies for 11" x 14" $0.75 Color photocopies for 11" x 14" double-sided $1.50 Color photocopies for 11" x 17" $1.00 Color photocopies for 11" x 17" double-sided $2.00 Commented [MM3]: Finance Director asked fees be  updated to breakout color copies.   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 4 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Citizens requesting personal copies are to be charged at rate listed above Color copies are double the costs above (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.080 Deposit required for City-provided utilities. This section applies to City water, sewer, garbage services. A deposit may be required from any customer at any time if payment record requires one. All deposits made with the City are noninterest bearing. After one year the account will be reviewed and the deposit refunded if payment history shows twelve current consecutive payments. Deposit may be waived for existing customers in good-standing payment status at the discretion of the City Treasurer. Owners of single-family residential dwelling $25.00100.00 Small business and retail establishments having an average monthly service charge $50.00200.00 Large commercial and industrial users 2 times the highest water bill for service location New Large commercial and industrial users $2,000 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 5 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.090 Culinary water rates. 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Residential, within the City - minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gallons) $13.00 minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gal.) $13.65 $14.33 $15.05 $15.80 $16.59 $17.42 $18.29 $19.21 $20.17 Per thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gallons $1.13/thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gal. $1.18 $1.24 $1.30 $1.37 $1.44 $1.51 $1.58 $1.66 $1.75 Per thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gallons $1.50/thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gal. $1.58 $1.65 $1.74 $1.82 $1.91 $2.01 $2.11 $2.22 $2.33 Per thousand for 60,001 or more gallons $1.88/thousand for 60,001 or more gal. $1.97 $2.07 $2.17 $2.28 $2.39 $2.51 $2.64 $2.77 $2.91 Residential, outside the City - minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gallons) $18.85 minimum charge (includes the first 3,000 gal.) $19.79 $20.78 $21.82 $22.91 $24.06 $25.26 $26.52 $27.85 $29.24 Per thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gallons $1.50/thousand for 3,001 to 10,000 gal. $1.58 $1.65 $1.74 $1.82 $1.91 $2.01 $2.11 $2.22 $2.33 Per thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gallons $2.25/thousand for 10,001 to 60,000 gal. $2.36 $2.48 $2.60 $2.73 $2.87 $3.02 $3.17 $3.32 $3.49 Per thousand for 60,001 or more gallons $2.63/thousand for 60,001 or more gal. $2.76 $2.89 $3.04 $3.19 $3.35 $3.52 $3.69 $3.88 $4.07 Commercial, within $37.50 $39.38 $41.34 $43.41 $45.58 $47.86 $50.25 $52.77 $55.40 $58.17 Commented [MM4]: Updated to include Water rates  from 2022 through 2030 that were accepted on June 9,  2020, Agenda item 8.3, Option C. (Ordnance Number  2020‐07)   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 6 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. the City - minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gallons) minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gal.) Per thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gallons $1.50/thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gal. $1.58 $1.65 $1.74 $1.82 $1.91 $2.01 $2.11 $2.22 $2.33 Per thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gallons $2.25/thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gal. $2.36 $2.48 $2.60 $2.73 $2.87 $3.02 $3.17 $3.32 $3.49 Per thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gallons $3.40/thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gal. $3.57 $3.75 $3.94 $4.13 $4.34 $4.56 $4.78 $5.02 $5.27 Per thousand for 50,001 or more gallons $4.25/thousand for 50,001 or more gal. $4.46 $4.69 $4.92 $5.17 $5.42 $5.70 $5.98 $6.28 $6.59 Commercial, outside the City – minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gallons) $44.25 minimum charge (includes the first 2,000 gal.) $46.46 $48.79 $51.22 $53.79 $56.48 $59.30 $62.26 $65.38 $68.65 Per thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gallons $3.00/thousand for 2,001 to 5,000 gal. $3.15 $3.31 $3.47 $3.65 $3.83 $4.02 $4.22 $4.43 $4.65 Per thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gallons $3.38/thousand for 5,001 to 10,000 gal. $3.54 $3.72 $3.91 $4.10 $4.31 $4.52 $4.75 $4.99 $5.24 Per thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gallons $4.25/thousand for 10,001 to 50,000 gal. $4.46 $4.69 $4.92 $5.17 $5.42 $5.70 $5.98 $6.28 $6.59 Per thousand for 50,001 or more $4.68/thousand for 50,001 or $4.91 $5.15 $5.41 $5.68 $5.97 $6.26 $6.58 $6.91 $7.25 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 7 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. gallons more gal. Shop water retail fee (City Public Works Yard) – Includes the first 2,000 gallons $32.50 for first 2,000 gallons, $12.75/1,000 gal. $34.13 $35.83 $37.62 $39.50 $41.48 $43.55 $45.73 $48.02 $50.42 Per 1,000 gallons for 2,001 or more gallons $12.75 $13.39 $14.06 $14.76 $15.50 $16.27 $17.09 $17.94 $18.84 $19.78 Shop water government fee (City Public Works Yard) – Includes the first 2,000 gallons $26.00 for first 2,000 gallons, $9.38/1,000 gal. $27.30 $28.67 $30.10 $31.60 $33.18 $34.84 $36.58 $38.41 $40.33 Per thousand for 2,001 or more gallons $9.38 $9.84 $10.34 $10.85 $11.40 $11.97 $12.56 $13.19 $13.85 $14.54 Construction fire hydrant fee – Includes the first 2,000 gallons $32.50 for first 2,000 gallons, $12.75/1,000 gal. $34.13 $35.83 $37.62 $39.50 $41.48 $43.55 $45.73 $48.02 $50.42 Per thousand for 2,001 or more gallons $12.75 $13.39 $14.06 $14.76 $15.50 $16.27 $17.09 $17.94 $18.84 $19.78 Construction fire hydrant rental fee per day $15.00 per day $15.75 $16.54 $17.36 $18.23 $19.14 $20.10 $21.11 $22.16 $23.27 City parks & cemeteries per 1,000 gallons $0.81/1,000 gal. $0.85 $0.89 $0.94 $0.98 $1.03 $1.09 $1.14 $1.20 $1.26 Moab Golf Course Well #7 Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Current commercial rate Other Culinary Water Fees Commented [MM5]: Made its own table for formating  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 8 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Water turn-on fee, after failure to pay City water/sewer charges $40.00 during normal working hours; $80.00 after normal working hours Water meter re-read charges The City crew will re-read the customer’s meter. $49.00 The City crew will test a customer’s meter. $49.00 The City crew will change a tested customer’s meter, at the customer’s request. Actual labor costs with a 1-hour minimum The costs incurred for these requests will be paid within 30 days. If that bill is not paid, the water will be turned off until the debt is satisfied, and a reconnect charge (½-hour minimum) during regular hours, or reconnect charge (2-hour minimum) after hours, will be applicable. During regular working hours, actual labor costs with a ½-hour minimum After hours, actual labor costs with a 2-hour minimum If the problem proves to be the City’s responsibility, there will be no charge to the customer. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.100 Sanitary sewer rates. Rates shall be effective on the first full billing cycle of each calendar year. Base Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Single-Family $21.60 $27.00 $29.70 $32.67 $35.94 $38.81 $40.75 $42.79 Multifamily + Overnight Accommodations (1st $19.65 $24.56 $27.02 $29.72 $32.69 $35.31 $37.07 $38.93 Commented [MM6]: Levi requested this be increased to  $40.00 from $25 to cover man hours and cost of vehicle to  drive out to location  Commented [MM7]: Comments from Levi Jones:  Increase fee to $80.00 from $50.00 to cover after hour call  outs and vehicle fee.   Commented [MM8]: Comments from Levi: Update fee  from $10.00 to $49.00 to reflect current fees associated to  vehicle and employee   Commented [MM9]: Comments from Levi: Update fee  from $10.00 to $49.00 to reflect current fees associated to  vehicle and employee  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 9 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Base Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Unit) Charge per Additional Unit $9.45 $11.81 $12.99 $14.29 $15.72 $16.98 $17.83 $18.72 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 1" $21.60 $27.00 $29.70 $32.67 $35.94 $38.81 $40.75 $42.79 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 1.5" $24.85 $31.06 $34.17 $37.59 $41.34 $44.65 $46.88 $49.23 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 2" $33.80 $42.25 $46.48 $51.12 $56.23 $60.73 $63.77 $66.96 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 3" $99.75 $124.69 $137.16 $150.87 $165.96 $179.24 $188.20 $197.61 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 4" $124.20 $155.25 $170.78 $187.85 $206.64 $223.17 $234.33 $246.04 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 5" $181.20 $226.50 $249.15 $274.07 $301.47 $325.59 $341.87 $358.96 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 6" $246.35 $307.94 $338.73 $372.60 $409.86 $442.65 $464.79 $488.03 Restaurant/Fast Food and Other Nonresidential 8" $336.25 $420.31 $462.34 $508.58 $559.44 $604.19 $634.40 $666.12 Volume Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Single-Family $1.90 $2.38 $2.61 $2.87 $3.16 $3.41 $3.58 $3.76 Multifamily $2.22 $2.78 $3.05 $3.36 $3.69 $3.99 $4.19 $4.40 Overnight Accommodations $2.22 $2.78 $3.05 $3.36 $3.69 $3.99 $4.19 $4.40 Restaurant/Fast Food $3.41 $4.26 $4.69 $5.16 $5.67 $6.13 $6.43 $6.76 Other Nonresidential $2.22 $2.78 $3.05 $3.36 $3.69 $3.99 $4.19 $4.40 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 10 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Base Rate 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Wastewater and septage discharge into municipal treatment works $180.00/1,000 gallons After our service fee for septage dumps $150.00 (Ord. 21-19 Exh. A (Option A), 2021; Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.110 Storm water rates. Residential, month for single- and two-household homes on a single lot $4.50 All other uses (commercial or residential)/month/storm water ERU.* One (1) ERU minimum. $4.50 * Every 3,000 ft2 of impervious surface =1 ERU; every 6,000 ft2 of semi-impervious surface area = 1 ERU (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.120 Trash and recycling rates. Residential Service (monthly) Trash cart size Frequency 65 gal. Every other week $12.00 95 gal. Every other week $14.00 65 gal. Weekly $16.00 95 gal. Weekly $18.00 Commented [MM10]: Was on Master fee schedule  approved on 07/2020. Was not showing on the code side of  the master fee schedule. Adding back in to ensure it is  captured back on the master fee schedule posted under the  codes on the website.     Commented [MM11]: Comments from Obe Tejada:  Include an after‐hour service fee for septage dump calls to  open gate up. This fee covers the cost to have an employee  dispatched out to open the gate for the hauler.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 11 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Extra 95 gal. Weekly only $18.00 Recycling cart size Frequency 95 gal. Every other week $12.00 Extra 95 gal. Every other week $12.00 Commercial Service (monthly) Trash cart size Frequency Base rate Extra bin 2 yd. Every other week $40.00 $34.00 1 x a week $64.00 $54.00 2 x a week $120.00 $102.00 3 x a week $182.00 $154.00 4 x a week $243.00 $207.00 5 x a week $307.00 $261.00 6 x a week $387.00 $329.00 7 x a week $482.00 $410.00 3 yd. Every other week $47.00 $40.00 1 x a week $79.00 $67.00 2 x a week $149.00 $126.00 3 x a week $223.00 $189.00 4 x a week $296.00 $252.00 5 x a week $370.00 $315.00 6 x a week $460.00 $391.00 7 x a week $566.00 $481.00 4 yd. Every other week $56.00 $48.00 1 x a week $94.00 $80.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 12 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 2 x a week $177.00 $150.00 3 x a week $262.00 $222.00 4 x a week $348.00 $296.00 5 x a week $435.00 $370.00 6 x a week $537.00 $457.00 7 x a week $656.00 $557.00 6 yd. Every other week $74.00 $63.00 1 x a week $124.00 $105.00 2 x a week $233.00 $198.00 3 x a week $343.00 $291.00 4 x a week $454.00 $386.00 5 x a week $565.00 $481.00 6 x a week $692.00 $589.00 7 x a week $836.00 $710.00 8 yd. Every other week $92.00 $79.00 1 x a week $154.00 $131.00 2 x a week $290.00 $246.00 3 x a week $427.00 $363.00 4 x a week $566.00 $481.00 5 x a week $704.00 $599.00 6 x a week $859.00 $731.00 7 x a week $1,030.00 $876.00 Misc. Services Trash or recycling cart servicing Reload Special pick-up Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 13 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 65 gal. $5.00 $10.00 95 gal. $5.00 $10.00 2 yd. $20.00 $30.00 3 yd. $30.00 $40.00 4 yd. $40.00 $50.00 6 yd. $60.00 $70.00 8 yd. $80.00 $90.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.130 Culinary water connection fees. Connection fees do not include the labor and materials required to complete any asphalt repairs. Owner/requester is responsible for completing this work in accordance with City standards and is subject to final inspection by the City. Within the City (meter size/ERU capacity) Meter provided by City Meter provided by customer 5/8" x 3/4" $1,746.60 $1,114.00 1" $1,932.50 $1,114.00 1½" $2,339.20 $1,212.00 2" $2,577.40 $1,212.00 3" $4,828.80 $1,506.00 4" $5,500.90 $1,506.00 6" $7,501.60 $1,506.00 Outside City Limit – additional 5% (meter size/ERU capacity) Meter provided by City Meter provided by customer Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 14 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 5/8" x 3/4" $1,833.93 $1,169.70 1" $2,029.13 $1,169.70 1½" $2,456.16 $1,272.60 2" $2,706.27 $1,272.60 3" $5,070.24 $1,581.30 4" $5,775.95 $1,581.30 6" (includes the meter) $7,876.68 $1,581.30 Fire sprinkler system connection fee Actual cost to perform the connection Fire hydrant connection fee Actual cost of installation Fire hydrant meter deposit $2,000.00 $2,000.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.140 Culinary water impact fees. Within the City (meter size/ERU capacity) 5/8" x 3/4"/1.0 $478.00 1"/3.7 $1,769.00 1½"/11.0 $5,528.00 2"/22.9 $10,946.00 4"/n-a Calculated under lodging rate, see below Outside City Limit (meter size/ERU capacity) 5/8" x 3/4"/1.0 $478.00 1"/3.7 $1,769.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 15 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 1½"/11.0 $5,528.00 2"/22.9 $10,946.00 4"/n-a Calculated under lodging rate, see below Water impact fees for overnight lodging including motels, inns, bed and breakfast establishments, and hotels shall be calculated pursuant to the following schedule: Impact fee/room for lodging without a restaurant: Number of rooms x $229.00 Impact fee/room for lodging with a restaurant: Number of rooms x $330.00 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.150 Sanitary Sewer Connection Fees. Within the City: 4" line $680.00 6" line $844.00 Outside the City: 4" line $714.00 6" line $886.20 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.160 Sanitary sewer impact fees. Within City Limits Outside of City Limits Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 16 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Allowable units under minimum fee Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum Residential dwellings Single-family (residence) 1 residence $1,566.00 $1,566.00/ residence $1,361.00 $1,361.00/ residence Multifamily, 2 bedrooms or larger (residential unit) 2 units $3,132.00 $1,566.00/unit $2,721.00 $1,361.00/unit Multifamily, 1 bedroom or smaller (residential unit) 2 units $1,754.00 $877.00/unit $1,524.00 $762.00/unit Nightly rental dwellings 2 bedrooms or larger with kitchen (residential unit) 1 unit $1,879.00 $1,879.00/unit $1,633.00 $1,633.00/unit 1 bedroom or smaller with kitchen (residential unit) 1 unit $1,566.00 $1,566.00/unit $1,361.00 $1,361.00/unit Hotel/motel, no kitchen (residential unit) 2 units $2,452.00 $1,226.00/unit $2,130.00 $1,065.00/unit Auto repair (1,000 ft2) 7,000 ft2 $1,768.00 $253.00/ 1,000 ft2 $1,536.00 $219.00/ 1,000 ft2 Bakery (1,000 ft2) 500 ft2 $1,793.00 $3,585.00/ 1,000 ft2 $2,190.00 $4,380.00/ 1,000 ft2 Bank (1,000 ft2) 2,000 ft2 $1,566.00 $783.00/1,000 ft2 $1,361.00 $680.00/1,000 ft2 Beauty/barber shop (chair) 4 chairs $1,566.00 $392.00/chair $1,361.00 $340.00/chair Campground (campsite) 2 campsites $2,463.00 $1,231.00/ campsite $2,139.00 $1,070.00/ campsite Car wash – automatic (each) 1 each $12,575.00 $12,575.00/ each $9,510.00 $9,510.00/each Car wash – wand (wands) 1 wand $6,288.00 $6,288.00/ $4,755.00 $4,755.00/ Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 17 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Within City Limits Outside of City Limits Allowable units under minimum fee Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum Minimum fee Fee/additional unit above minimum wand wand Commercial (1,000 ft2) 7,000 ft2 $1,687.00 $241.00/1,000 ft2 $1,465.00 $209.00/1,000 ft2 Dry cleaner (1,000 ft2) 2,000 ft2 $1,574.00 $787.00/1,000 ft2 $1,866.00 $622.00/1,000 ft2 Fast food (1,000 ft2) 500 ft2 $2,825.00 $5,650.00/ 1,000 ft2 $2,724.00 $5,447.00/ 1,000 ft2 Gas station/convenience store (1,000 ft2) 4,000 ft2 $1,740.00 $435.00/1,000 ft2 $1,512.00 $378.00/1,000 ft2 Grocery store (1,000 ft2) 4,000 ft2 $2,021.00 $505.00/1,000 ft2 $1,756.00 $439.00/1,000 ft2 Laundromat (washers) 2 washers $1,767.00 $884.00/washer $1,320.00 $660.00/washer Office (1,000 ft2) 4,000 ft2 $1,566.00 $392.00/1,000 ft2 $1,361.00 $340.00/1,000 ft2 Restaurant (seats) 12 seats $2,650.00 $221.00/seat $2,704.00 $225.00/seat Retail (1,000 ft2) 7,000 ft2 $1,687.00 $241.00/1,000 ft2 $1,465.00 $209.00/1,000 ft2 School (students) 15 students $1,566.00 $104.00/student $1,361.00 $91.00/student Theater (seats) 150 seats $1,620.00 $11.00/seat $1,407.00 $9.00/seat Warehouse (1,000 ft2) 10,000 ft2 $1,649.00 $165.00/1,000 ft2 $1,432.00 $143.00/1,000 ft2 (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.165 Building Service Fees. Building, temporary, during construction on a lot – bond RV: $200.00 Mobile home: $500.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 18 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Building permit (by total valuation) $1.00 to $500.00 $65.00 $501.00 to $2,000.00 $65.00 for the first $500.00 plus $3.66 for each additional $100.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $2,000.00 $2,001.00 to $25,000.00 $119.90 for the first $2,000.00 plus $16.80 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $25,000.00 $25,001.00 to $50,000.00 $506.30 for the first $25,000.00 plus $12.12 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $50,000.00 $50,001.00 to $100,000.00 $809.30 for the first $50,000.00 plus $8.40 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $100,000.00 $100,001.00 to $500,000.00 $1,229.30 for the first $100,000.00 plus $6.72 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $500,000.00 $500,001.00 to $1,000,000.00 $3,917.30 for the first $500,000.00 plus $6.72 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof, to and including $1,000,000.00 $1,000,001.00 and up $7,277.30 for the first $1,000,000.00 plus $6.72 for each additional $1,000.00, or fraction thereof Building permit, miscellaneous Demo permit $25.00/unit Garage up to 600 sq feet (plus plan review) $195.00/permit Manufactured or mobile home into park $195.00/unit Manufactured home on private property (not into park) $260.00/unit Modular home (plus plan review; requires third-party ICC inspections to be performed at factory) $455.00/unit Residential swimming pool (plus plan review) $260.00/permit Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 19 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Roofing permit $1.00 per 100 sq feet with $65.00 minimum fee RV park infrastructure $195.00/5 sites Separate mechanical, electrical, and/or plumbing permits $65.00/inspection Solar – roof mount (plus plan review) $130.00/permit Solar – ground mount (plus plan review) $195.00/permit Inspections Inspections for which no fee is specifically listed $65.00/inspection Inspections outside of normal business hours Actual costs plus 10% Re-inspection fees assessed under provisions of Section 305.8 due prior to the re-inspection Actual costs plus 10% Plan review – commercial Nonrefundable commercial plan deposit for initial plan review only for new construction, tenant finish, and/or major remodel 10% building permit fee; $260.00 minimum Commercial plan review and additional plan review(s) required due to changes, corrections, additions, and/or revisions to plans $65.00/hr; 1-hour minimum charge Deferred submittal (prior approval by the Building Official required) $130.00/submittal Outside consultants (plan review and/or inspections) Actual costs plus 10% Plan review – residential Nonrefundable residential plan review deposit (new construction only) $130.00/permit Residential plan review and additional plan review required for changes, corrections, additions, change of contractor, owner or other information, and/or revisions to plans $65.00/hr; 1-hour minimum Actual costs calculated by including 10% administrative and overhead costs. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 20 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.170 Planning and engineering service fees. Administrative costs (research) $50.00/hr Amended plats (boundary adjustment) $250.00 plus $25.00/amended lot or unit Annexation $600.00 (flat rate) Appeal authority submittal $450.00 Application withdrawal fee 50% of collected fee if prior to advertising Cemetery application fee $100.00 Cemetery bond 150% of total cost of improvements Condominiums and condominium conversions $350.00 plus $50.00/unit Code amendment application $350.00 Construction bond In every construction contract where there is a modification of bonding requirements, or where no bonding is required (e.g., contracts under $50,000.00 in value), the construction contract shall contain one or more alternative security mechanisms to secure performance by the contractor and/or payment to subcontractors, laborers, and material suppliers. Alternative security mechanisms may include: (1) an irrevocable letter of credit payable to the City; (2) a first position deed of trust on real property; (3) a cash deposit to be held by the City; or (4) other collateral, contract, or security instruments as approved by the City Attorney. Floodplain development permits and elevation certificates $90.00 Floodplain reviews – for floodway and floodplain interpretations, delineations and reviews that exceed 1 hour. $50.00/hr Grading/excavation permit Required for >50 cubic yards or cuts or fills exceeding 10' deep or height $50.00/each 100 cubic yards Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 21 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. General plan amendment $350.00 Hillside development permits $300.00 + $50.00/hr of staff review time that exceeds 10 hours Hillside development – improvements and restoration bond Amount reasonably calculated to cover anticipated costs for improvements, as determined by City Planning Director Improvements agreement Financial assurance 110% of the approved construction costs Warranty deposit 10% of the approved construction costs Landscaping – bond for new developments in summer and winter months Amount reasonably calculated to cover anticipated costs for improvements, as determined by City Planning Director Large-scale projects – dee structure for developers to underwrite City staff expenses Amount reasonably calculated to cover anticipated costs for improvements, as determined by City Planning Director Large-scale projects – over 30,000 ft2 – landscaping deposit For completion of landscaping, in the event corrections cannot be made or installation cannot be completed prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy. 1½ the cost of the landscaping project Maps D or E size (>2’): $25.00 Digital files: $20.00 Master planned developments and planned unit development – application (A separate fee is to be collected for preliminary and final plats) $200.00 plus $25.00/dwelling unit or $25.00/ 3,000 ft2 of floor area for commercial buildings Master planned developments and planned unit development – bond As required on a case by case basis by the City Planning Director Mobile, manufactured or modular home parks and/or subdivisions – application $200.00 plus $25.00/unit or lot Mobile home parks – bond Amount equal to the estimated cost, plus 50% of constructing all landscaping, roads, lighting, pedestrian ways, Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 22 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. hard-surfacing, water and sewer lines, storage enclosures and common facilities as shown on the final plan. Occupancy – cash-only bond if given permission by City Planner or designee to occupy prior to completion of building 150% of the cost of completing all required work, plus all administrative costs as determined by the governing body. Parking, fee-in-lieu. Due prior to issuance of a building permit. $8,500.00/parking space Plan check fee 65% of the building permit fee for plans that are sent out to a professional plan checker; or $30.00/hour for plans that are checked by staff, with a $30.00 minimum. Planned affordable development (PAD) $50.00/1,000 ft2 of building floor area Planning applications – miscellaneous $100.00 Pre-application conference (sketch plan reviews) $100.00 to be credited toward application fee Professional services Actual costs plus 10% Reapplication fee $300.00 plus appropriate subdivision plat fees Recording fee Actual costs Recreational vehicle court $200.00 plus $25.00/RV space Right-of-way construction permit $50.00 Sidewalks, curbs, gutters, and street paving, fee-in-lieu. The City Engineer shall calculate by consulting licensed contractors. 110% of the estimated cost of constructing 200 lineal feet of the required improvements. Sign permit $25.00 plus $0.50 for each ft2 above 30 ft2 Sign, temporary – Political campaign signs $15.00 permit Site plan review $50.00/1,000 ft2 of building floor area Site plan review appeal If the record is voluminous, appellant must pay the reasonable costs of assembly and copying of the record. Special exception $100.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 23 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Street numbers, if City has to install $20.00 Subdivisions (A separate fee is to be collected for preliminary and final plats.) $200.00 plus $25.00/lot Subdivisions – bond 1½ times the cost of improvements not previously installed. Trees – removing or damaging City-owned trees without permission The basal area formula and the cost to buy, plant and water replacement trees shall be the basis for the urban forester to determine the replacement cost of the removed or damaged trees. Water & sewer master plan mains extensions – deposit Amount equal to the estimated cost of construction Wireless telecommunications facility – application fee (for each separate monopole, lattice tower, or antenna) $350.00 Zone change application $500.00 Zoning confirmation letter $100.00 *Square foot construction costs are established using the International Code Council’s Building Valuation Data which is updated at 6-month intervals (February and August). Refunds for building permits issued will be limited to 80% of the permit costs, not later than 90 days after the date of fee payment. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.180 Civil code violation penalties (maximum fines noted). Building code violation $500.00/infraction Illegal use of vehicle as dwelling $650.00/day/infraction Nuisances – generally $500.00/day/infraction Solid waste $500.00/infraction and all costs associated with legal fees and cleanup Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 24 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Weed abatement $500.00/day/infraction Unlawful parking, idling, or camping $120.00/infraction or 24-hour period Illegal storm water system dumping $1,000.00/day/Class B misdemeanor Grease trap – installation and/or maintenance compliance $500.00/day/Class B misdemeanor Violation – building code $1,000.00/day/Class B misdemeanor Signs – number of freestanding signs/lot $250.00/infraction Signs – setbacks $350.00/infraction Signs – prohibited signs $250.00/infraction Signs – temporary signs $250.00/infraction Signs – Permit $250.00/infraction Illegal subdivision $650.00/infraction Debris abatement $500.00/infraction Chickens – prohibited uses $250/infraction Chickens – application for permit $15.00 Construction without permit, investigation fee $500/infraction Storage of junk and debris $650.00/day/infraction Mobile home parks – failure to maintain common areas, landscaping, and/or improvements City and its contractors may complete this work and charge all costs (plus 10% administration) to property owner including, but not limited to, labor costs and attorney’s fees Land use violations $650.00/day/infraction Noise $650.00/day/infraction Residential area regulations $650.00/day/infraction Zoning violations generally Class B misdemeanor Business license – conducting business prior to obtaing the proper licensing; $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Commented [MM12]: Updating back to old fee schedule.  We are unsure how this was updated to $650.00 a day last  fee schedule.   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 25 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Business license – operating long-term rental prior to obtaining the proper licensing $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Business license – operating short-term rental prior to obtaining the proper licensing $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Business license – conducting home occupation prior to obtaining the proper licensing $650.00/day/infraction$50 fee Business license – expired or changed name and/or address $650.00/day/infraction200% of license fee Illegal short-term rental $750.00/day/infraction Signs – off premises $250.00/infraction Burning prohibited $500.00/infraction Nuisance – abate City and its contractors may abate the nuisance and charge all costs (plus 10% administration) to property owner including, but not limited to, labor costs and attorney’s fees Miscellaneous fines and/or penalties As directed in specific code sections (to be used until code revision is completed and adopted) (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.190 Police services fees. Fingerprinting $10.00 Police report, copy of $5.007.50 Driver privilege card digital fingerprints and background check $30.00 Police officers (Time charged begins when the officer leaves his/her residence and ends when he/she returns to his/her residence. If 12-hour notice is not given for cancellation, there is a minimum charge of four hours for each officer requested, plus police $65.00/hr; 4-hour minimum/day Commented [MM13]: Police Chief requested this be  increased to come in line with the county rates they  currently charge.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 26 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. vehicle time.) Police vehicles $100.00/day Evidence disposal $100.00/hour w/ 4-hour minimum (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.200 Public Works staff and equipment fees. Public Works Superintendent $56.00/hr Parks worker $46.00/hr Sewer service worker $47.00/hr Water worker $49.00/hr Street/storm water worker $47.00/hr Other Public Works staff. Includes the time for loading or unloading prior to and after an event Actual cost Overtime service fee 1½ times hourly rate Traffic control and safety equipment 36" cone $0.40/day Vertical flats $0.60/day Signs w/ stand $2.50/day Barrels $0.60/day Candle stick $0.50/day Slide top $5.50/day Barricades $3.00/day Other items and equipment Assessed as needed Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 27 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.210 Parks and facilities rental fees. Rotary Park Pavilion reservation, 4 hours or less $35.00 Pavilion reservation, more than 4 hours $85.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 Old City Park Reservation, 4 hours or less $35.00 Reservation, more than 4 hours $85.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 Amplified music $30.00 Lions Park Pavilion reservation, 4 hours or less $35.00 Pavilion reservation, more than 4 hours $85.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 Amplified music $30.00 Swanny Park (via special event permit only) Grand County Resident Nonresident Less than 25% of park, 4 hours or less $35.00 $55.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 28 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Less than 25% of park, more than 4 hours $85.00 $125.00 Use of more than 25% of park, less than 4 hours $60.00 $75.00 Use of more than 25% of park, 4-8 hours $105.00 $155.00 All day use of entire park $475.00 $600.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (100-300 people) $150.00 $200.00 Damage and cleanup deposit (300+ people) $300.00 $400.00 Center Street Ballfield Nonprofit/resident use (no admission fees) $15.00/hr or $100.00/day Nonprofit/resident use (admission and/or participation fees) $25.00/hr or $150.00/day Commercial use w/no fees $250.00/day Commercial use w/fees $500.00/day Day camp rates $50.00/day Damage and cleanup deposit $150.00 Use of lights $15.00/hr Center Street Gym Private use $250.00/hr Commercial use w/no fees $250.00/day Commercial use w/fees $500.00/day Day camp rates $50.00/day Recurring gym groups (No damage and cleanup deposit required) $10.00/use, capped $100.00/month Damage and cleanup deposit $200.00 Sun Court Reservations 3 hours or less $40.00 Commented [MM14]: Comment from Annie McVay:  Center Street Gym:  Change use to $25/hour (to be  consistent with MARC and MRAC rentals)  Commented [MM15]: Comment from Annie McVay: Add  Day camp rate of $50/day to the gym to be consistent with  ball fields.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 29 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Reservations more than 3 hours $75.00 Other areas not listed $25.00/day (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.220 Moab Arts and Recreation Center fees. Room rentals (art events, classes, programs, workshops, public meetings, etc.; one-time or ongoing) Dance room upstairs $25.00/hr, $19200.00/day Stage room upstairs $25.00/hr, $19200.00/day Foyer upstairs $25.00/hr, $19200.00/day Side yard $250.00/hr, $15200.00/day Downstairs studio/kitchen $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Downstairs conference room $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Entire facility $100.00/hr, $700.00/day Artillery (community art room) $20.00/hr or $140.00/day Private parties (weddings, receptions, birthdays, etc.) Dance room upstairs $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Stage room upstairs $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Foyer upstairs $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Side yard $35.00/hr, $270.00/day Downstairs studio/kitchen $20.00/hr, $150.00/day Downstairs meeting room $20.00/hr, $150.00/day Entire facility $125.00/hr, $980.00/day Commented [MM16]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Change day rentals from Dance Room to Sideyard to  $200.  (It seemed cleaner than $190)  Commented [MM17]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Change Sideyard to $25 hr/$200 day to be consistent.  Commented [MM18]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Delete ‘Entire Facility’ ‐we no longer want this as an option.  Commented [MM19]: Comments from Annie McVay:  Eliminate the second category of rates for ‘private parties’  the one that is $35/hour, we don’t utilize it and it’s  confusing.  Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 30 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Private party deposit (refundable/excludes weddings) $500.00 Wedding fee (includes rental and planning services) $2,000.00 Private party room rental $25.00/hr or $190.00/day Any event with alcohol $75.00/event additional Coworking fees Daily membership $15.00 Monthly membership $75.00 ARTillery studio monthly membership $75.00 Discounts available (one/agreement) Local nonprofit (501(c)3, church, school, etc.) 50% discount Moab-area local multi-day rentals 20% discount Moab-area local private party 10% discount Moab City employee 20% discount Equipment rentals PA/sound system $75.00/day Digital projector $25.00/day Screen $20.00/day Tables (included if renting space) $10.00/day/table Chairs (included if renting space) $2.00/day/chair Easels (included if renting space) $2.00/day/easel Yoga mats and blocks $1.00/piece/day (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) Commented [MM20]: Comments from Annie McVay:  delete ‘excludes weddings’  a deposit is appropriate for  weddings  Commented [MM21]: Comments from Annie McVay:  delete planning services as they are not offered.  Commented [MM22]: Kelley requested these be added  as they are current fees charged at the MARC.   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 31 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. 3.50.230 Moab Recreation and Aquatic Center fees. Aquatic Only or Fitness Only Daily admission Resident Nonresident 3 and under Free $1.00 Youth 4-17 individual (aquatic) $3.00 $5.00 Youth 14-17 individual (fitness) $3.00 $5.00 Adult 18+ individual $5.00 $10.00 Senior 55+ individual $3.00 $5.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $15.00 $30.00 Annual pass Youth 4-17 individual $115.00 Adult 18+ individual $170.00 Senior 55+ individual $125.00 Adult couple $250.00 Senior couple $200.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $320.00 Additional family member $50.00 Summer season pass Youth 4-17 individual $75.00 Adult 18+ individual $100.00 Senior 55+ individual $75.00 Adult couple $150.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 32 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior couple $115.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $200.00 Additional family member $40.00 6-month pass Youth 4-17 individual $90.00 Adult 18+ individual $120.00 Senior 55+ individual $90.00 Adult couple $170.00 Senior couple $130.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $210.00 Additional family member $40.00 3-month pass Youth 4-17 individual $70.00 Adult 18+ individual $85.00 Senior 55+ individual $70.00 Adult couple $135.00 Senior couple $110.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $165.00 Additional family member $30.00 Monthly Youth 4-17 individual $35.00 Adult 18+ individual $45.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 33 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior 55+ individual $35.00 Adult couple $70.00 Senior couple $50.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $85.00 Additional family member $10.00 25-punch card Youth 4-17 individual $60.00 Adult 18+ individual $100.00 Senior 55+ individual $60.00 1-week family aquatic only pass $100.00 Aquatic and Fitness Combined Daily admission Resident Nonresident 3 and under N/A N/A Student 14-17 individual $5.00 $7.00 Adult 18+ individual $7.00 $15.00 Senior 55+ individual $5.00 $7.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $20.00 $40.00 Annual pass Youth 14-17 individual (fitness) $185.00 Adult 18+ individual $275.00 Senior 55+ individual $200.00 Adult couple $410.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 34 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior couple $320.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $500.00 Additional family member $65.00 Summer season pass Youth 14-17 individual $115.00 Adult 18+ individual $145.00 Senior 55+ individual $115.00 Adult couple $225.00 Senior couple $180.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $300.00 Additional family member $50.00 6-month pass Youth 14-17 individual $125.00 Adult 18+ individual $175.00 Senior 55+ individual $125.00 Adult couple $265.00 Senior couple $210.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $325.00 Additional family member $55.00 3-month pass Youth 14-17 individual $100.00 Adult 18+ individual $135.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 35 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Senior 55+ individual $100.00 Adult couple $210.00 Senior couple $165.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $265.00 Additional family member $45.00 Monthly Youth 14-17 individual $50.00 Adult 18+ individual $65.00 Senior 55+ individual $50.00 Adult couple $105.00 Senior couple $85.00 Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $135.00 Additional family member $15.00 25-punch card Youth 14-17 individual $100.00 Adult 18+ individual $135.00 Senior 55+ individual $100.00 Annual corporate membership Regular Org. size 4-9 Org. size 10+ Adult 18+ individual $275.00 $250.00 $235.00 Senior 55+ individual $200.00 $175.00 $160.00 Adult couple $410.00 $365.00 $350.00 Senior couple $320.00 $265.00 $250.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 36 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Family up to 6 (14+ allowed in fitness) $500.00 $440.00 $415.00 Additional family members $65.00 $65.00 $65.00 MRAC classes Resident Nonresident Swim lessons $40.00 $40.00 Jr. lifeguard course $25.00 $30.00 Class 20-punch pass – members $45.00 $45.00 Class 20-punch pass – nonmembers $75.00 $75.00 Drop-in fee – members $3.00 $3.00 Drop-in fee – nonmembers $5.00 $5.00 Other fees Shower fee $7.00 Child careChildcare – individual $5.00 Swim club registration fee $60.00 Locker rentals $10.00/mo $25.00/3 mo $100.00/yr Room rental fee $25.00/hr Wibit rental fee $25.00/rental (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.240 City sports fees. First Kicks 3-4 yrs old $20.00 Spring soccer 5 yrs old-4th grade $40.00 + $10.00 uniform Spring soccer 5th grade-8th grade $60.00 (uniform included) Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 37 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Spring youth volleyball 3rd-8th grade $50.00 reg + $30.00 uniform Li’l Tykes T-ball 3-4 yrs old $20.00 T-ball kindergarten $40.00 Coach pitch boys 1st + 2nd grade $45.00 Coach pitch girls 1st + 2nd grade $45.00 Baseball/softball 3rd-8th grade $80.00 Adult soccer 15+ $25.00 Frisbee golf tournament 15+ $25.00/person, $40.00/team Adult softball league 15+ $275.00/team Adult pickleball tournament 15+ $50.00/individual, $75.00/team Fall youth soccer 5 yrs old – 3rd grade $40.00 Tackle football 4th – 7th grade $85.00 NFL flag football 1st – 4th grade $50.00 Fall youth volleyball 3rd – 6th grades $45.00 Adult flag football 15+ $150.00/team Adult volleyball 15+ (winter/summer) $30.00/season (drop-in) Adult volleyball league 15+ $150.00/team Adult basketball league 15+ $100.00/team Adult spring basketball tournament 15+ $100.00/team (discount with item above to $175.00/team) Jr. Jazz basketball 3rd – 6th grades $65.00 (includes full uniform) Youth indoor soccer 7th – 12th grades $45.00 Adult indoor soccer 15+ $30.00/season (drop-in) Ultimate frisbee 15+ $10.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 38 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Ultimate frisbee tournament 15+ $75.00/team (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.250 Dogs and cats. Annual license fee for unneutered or unspayed dogs and cats (May be waived for in-service or assistant dogs) $25.00 No fee for lifetime license of neutered dogs and cats. $0 Replacement tag for dogs and cats $25.0010.00 Breeder $100.00 annually Guard dog permit Expires in 1 year. Not transferable to any other location. $100.00 plus applicable registration fee Impoundment fees for dogs and cats; fines for no tag. May be applied to the cost of spaying or neutering the dog or cat. Cats: $430.00 + $5.00/day of impoundment Dogs: $430.00 + $10.00/day of impoundment Impounded, registered, unspayed or unneutered dog or cat, taken 2 times in 12 months. Owner must pay spay or neuter deposit. Fee refunded if owner spays or neuters within 30 days of release. $50.00 refundable deposit, if animal is spayed or neutered within 30 days of release Shelter relinquishment fees Cats if altered and current on rabies vaccination $25.00 Cats if unaltered and not current on rabies vaccination $50.00 Cats if altered and not current on rabies vaccination $35.00 Dogs if altered and current on rabies vaccination $35.00 Dogs if altered and not current on rabies vaccination $45.00 Commented [MM23]: Police Chief and Code  enforcement: We are requesting these fee increases to account for inflation and to better compensate the City for services. The current fees were implemented 15 years ago and have not since been adjusted. Adoption Fee - $50 (increase of $15 from current) Impound Fee - $40 (increase of $10 from current) Replacement Tag - $10 (decrease of $15 from current)   Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 39 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Dogs if unaltered and not current on rabies vaccination $45.00 Presentation of strays at shelter (One mother dog with puppies or one mother cat with kittens counts as one stray.) First two presentations of strays: $0 Presentation of strays after first two: $25.00/stray Adoption fees (Deposit is refundable upon presentation of proof of spay/neuter and rabies vaccination within 30 days of adoption if animal is over six months of age, and within 6 months if animal is under 6 months of age.) Altered and current on rabies vaccination $35.0050.00 Unaltered and not current on rabies vaccination $35.0050.00 + $50.00 deposit Altered and not current on rabies vaccination $35.0050.00 + $25.00 deposit Rabies quarantine at shelter $15.00/day of quarantine Rabies deposit at shelter. For all animals released without current rabies vaccination. Deposit is refundable if proof of rabies vaccination is provided within 30 days of release. $25.00 Rabies vaccination performed at shelter $25.00 Veterinary fees for reclaimed animals Owners of reclaimed animals shall be charged the actual cost of any veterinary services needed during the impoundment plus 5%. (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) 3.50.260 Miscellaneous fees. Check given as payment to City that is returned for insufficient funds $25.00 Ch. 3.50 Master Fee Schedule | Moab Municipal Code Page 40 of 40 The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Late payment penalty – assessed 10 days after payment due date Commercial accounts – greater of 3% of billing or $25.00; Residential accounts – $15.00 Finance charge on accounts receivable that are over 30 days past due 35% or $25.00/month, whichever is higher Designation of historic structure $75.00 + public notice expenses and recording fees associated with the designation. Conference room rental $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Council Chambers room rental $15.00/hr, $120.00/day Conference room and Council Chambers rental (open wall) $25.00/hr, $200.00/day (Ord. 20-07 Att. A (part), 2020; Ord. 19-24 Att. A (part), 2019) The Moab Municipal Code is current through Ordinance 21-19, passed November 9, 2021. Disclaimer: The City Recorder's Office has the official version of the Moab Municipal Code. Users should contact the City Recorder's Office for ordinances passed subsequent to the ordinance cited above. Note: This site does not support Internet Explorer. To view this site, Code Publishing Company recommends using one of the following browsers: Google Chrome, Firefox, or Safari. City Website: moabcity.org City Telephone: (435) 259-5121 Code Publishing Company Commented [MM24]: Bring in line with the Commercial  account late payment penalty.   Commented [MM25]: Finance director requested fees be  put into place for rental of our Conference room and  Chambers room. Used fees lined out for the MARC to stay  consistent.  Moab City Council Agenda Item McLaughlin Minor Subdivision Meeting Date: March 22, 2022 Title: Consideration and Possible Approval of Moab City Resolution #08-2022 – A Resolution Approving the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision of Property Located at 458 West 200 South, Moab, Utah 84532. Disposition: Discussion and Possible Action Staff Presenter: Cory P. Shurtleff, Planning Director Attachment(s): - Exhibit 1: Draft Moab City Resolution #08-2022 - Exhibit 2: Vicinity Map - Exhibit 3: Recorded County Plat - Exhibit 4: Draft Plat Options: 1. Approve Resolution #08-2022, with or without modifications; or 2. Continue or table item and give specific direction to the applicant and City Staff as to additional information needed to make a decision; or 3. Deny, giving specific findings for the decision. Recommended Motion: I move that the City Council Approve Moab City Resolution #08-2022, A Resolution Approving the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision of property located at 458 West 200 South, Moab, UT, 84532 Applicant: Shellie Blake, Applicant; Douglas S. McLaughlin, Owner Background: Applicant, Shellie Blake, and property owner, Douglas S. McLaughlin, submitted the City of Moab Minor Subdivision Application on January 19, 2022, for the two-lot subdivision of property located at 458 West 200 South, Moab UT. On February 2, 2022, the application and submittal materials were reviewed for completeness by staff; with updated materials submitted February 16, 2022. Additional clarification was needed prior to the Minor Subdivision being submitted to Planning Commission. City Staff and the Applicant have coordinated to rectify outstanding information needed for approval. The Minor Subdivision has been submitted for review and conditional recommendation by the Moab Planning Commission on March 10, 2022. Sufficient materials to address the condition of approval were submitted and approved by staff. The Minor Subdivision was submitted for review and approval by the City Council on March 22, 2022. Project Summary: Location: 458 West 200 South, Moab UT 84532 Property Owner: Douglas S. McLaughlin Applicant: Shellie Blake Parcel Size: 195,377.7 sf (4.48 acres) Excluding Private Drive Easement Proposed Lot 1: 105,356 sf (2.42 acres) Including Private Drive Easement Proposed Lot 2: 114,838 sf (2.64 acres) Including Private Drive Easement Zoning: RA-1 Residential- Agricultural Zone Narrative Summary: The property owner is proposing to subdivide the existing property, currently used for single-household residential. Private Access Easement has been established and existing, providing access for the subject property and adjacent properties; this private access easement will maintain and continue as is, not as City Right-of-Way. Process: MMC Section 16.08.020 allows for exceptions to the final plat hearing process for minor subdivisions of five lots or less. These applications must be reviewed by the Planning Commission and referred to Council with a recommendation, as noted below. “MMC Section 16.08.020, Exceptions--Final plat, discusses the process and required documents In subdivisions of less than five lots, land may be sold after recording of a plat, if all the following conditions are met: A. The subdivision plan shall have been approved by the planning commission, the planning coordinator, the city engineer, the city attorney, other agencies the zoning administrator deems necessary, and the city council; B. The subdivision is not traversed by lines of a proposed street, and does not require the dedication of any land for street or other purposes; C. Each lot within the subdivision meets the frontage width and area requirements of the zoning title or has been granted a variance from such requirements by the appeal authority; D. All final plat requirements shall be complied with; E. All provisions of Chapter 16.20 of this title shall be complied with; and F. The water supply and sewage disposal shall have been approved by the utility supervisor CITY OF MOAB RESOLUTION NO. 08-2022 A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE MCLAUGHLIN MINOR SUBDIVISION AT 458 WEST 200 SOUTH, MOAB, UT 84532, AS REFERRED TO COUNCIL BY THE MOAB PLANNING COMMISSION WHEREAS, The following describes the intent and purpose of this resolution: a. Shellie Blake, (Applicant), has applied for a Minor Subdivision of the property located at 458 West 200 South, Moab, Utah; and b. Applicant submitted to the City of Moab the appropriate application and documents for review and approval of the proposed two-lot minor subdivision as required in MMC Chapter 16.08.020; and c. The property is in the RA-1 Residential-Agricultural Zone and the existing use is permitted; and d. Owner (Douglas S. McLaughlin) desires to subdivide the existing Parcel #01-0001-0166, of 195377.7 sf, 4.48 acres, into Lot 1 (105,356 sf, 2.42 acres), and Lot 2 (114838 sf, 2.64 acres); and e. The proposed lots satisfy the dimensional requirements of the RA-1 Zone; and f. The Moab Planning Commission reviewed the application for the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision in a regularly scheduled meeting held on February 24, 2022, and subsequently recommended approval to the Moab City Council in accordance with MMC Chapter 16.08.020 that allows a minor subdivision of less than five (5) lots to be reviewed without a public hearing; and g. The Moab City Council reviewed the application and considered the Planning Commission and Staff recommendations in a public meeting held on March 8, 2022; and h. Following the consideration of the technical aspects of the pertinent code sections, the Moab City Council, pursuant to Resolution #08-2022, hereby finds, that the subdivision can meet or exceeds the pertinent code requirements. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MOAB CITY COUNCIL, the application for the McLaughlin Minor Subdivision is hereby APPROVED. PASSED AND APPROVED in open Council by a majority vote of the Governing Body of Moab City Council on March 22, 2022. SIGNED: ________________________________ Joette Langianese , Mayor ATTEST: ________________________________ Sommar Johnson, Recorder Moab City Council Agenda Item Meeting Date: 3/22/22 Title: Maximum Adult Residential Occupancy Discussion Presenter: Councilmembers Derasary and Jones, staff Budget Impact: None at this time Attachment(s): None Recommended Motion: None – Discussion only Background/Summary: The housing market in Moab is highly competitive. Houses, neighborhoods, and city codes have developed in response to assumptions about household composition which may not be as accurate in the future. For example, heretofore unusually large numbers of adults living in one house, each possibly with their own car. This has been observed or is feared by some members of the community to have negative impacts related to noise, nuisances, landscaping, and on-street parking availability. This agenda item is an opportunity to further assess councilmembers’ desire to manage these impacts, staff to clarify existing tools, and the practical limitations in using them with current City resources.