Loading...
HomeMy Public PortalAbout050_010_City Council Minutes May 23 2013 City Council Minutes 20130523 Consideration of Items for Cons-nt Agenda Mayor Buelterman called the consent agenda to order at 6:30PM on May 23, 2013. Those present were Mayor pro tern Wanda Doyle, Paul Wolff, Tom Groover, Jan Fox, Barry Brown and Bill Garbett. Also attending were Diane Schleicher, City Manager; Bubba Hughes, City Attorney; Tommy Branch, Callaway, Braun, Riddle and Hughes, PC; Dianne Otto, Manager, Planning and Zoning Department; and Janet LeViner, Clerk of Council. Mayor Buelterman listed the following items on the consent agenda: • Emergency City Council Meeting Minutes, May 3, 2013 • City Council Minutes, May 9, 2013 as amended • Tom Borkowski, Planning Commission Appointment • Additional Costs for WWII Memorial Restoration and Re-Conditioning of Bronze Plaque. Requires budget adjustment of $505 from 100-9000-61-1000 (Contingency) to 100-6110-54-1200 • Recommend Thomas & Hutton for engineering services of $45,000 for Jones Avenue Water Line Project Budget Line Item Number: TBD for FY 14 Budget. DISCUSSION: Ms. Schleicher stated that Thomas & Hutton is the recommended engineering firm by the Infrastructure Committee and she would request mayor and council approve the engineering firm contingent on budgeting for the project in the upcoming fiscal year. • Engineering Consulting Independent Contractors Agreement, Downer Davis. Mayor Buelterman called the regular meeting to order at 7:00PM. All those present for the consent agenda were present. Opening Ceremonies • Call to Order • Invocation: Jan LeViner • Pledge of Allegiance Report of Staff, Boards, Standing Committees and/or Invited Guests • Chief Sasser, Tybee Island Fire Department • Chief Bryson, Tybee Island Police Department • George Reese, Water/Sewer Department • Joe Wilson, Department of Public Works • Dianne Otto, Planning and Zoning Department • Woody Hemphill, River's End Campground • Angela Hudson, Finance Department Mr. Chambers, Historic Preservation Advisor to ne F''istoric Preservator Commission approached mayor and council stating May is Historic Preservation Month and he would like to discuss historic preservation in general. He would also like to discuss the recommended changes to Article 14. He discussed his presentation entitled Preserving the Future of Tybee Island as was included in the packet. Monty Parks, Better Hometown Program. Mr. Parks, Chairman of the Board, Better Hometown Program, approached mayor and council giving an update for the program in regards to the upcoming budget cycle. He would ask for the continued support of mayor and council with the program. Chantel Morton approached mayor and council to discuss signage recommendations for the standardization of city signage. These recommendations would be for consistence standardized, non-cluttered sign postings for future signs when they need to be revised. The committee recommended a kiosk with a corrugated tin roof and posts with a six inch overhang on both sides. Mayor and council thanked Ms. Morton for a job well done as they liked the concept, color scheme and the recommendation would be cost effective to the City. Harvey Ferrelle and Mike Foran, Beach Task Force approached mayor and council with recommendations from the Beach Task Force. Mr. Ferrelle explained that it cost the City $10.5M for the re-nourishment 2008. $2.9M is what the state of Georgia gave the City and $6.1M is what was received from the federal government. The next re- nourishment in 2015 will cost approximately $18.5M. The State has agreed to give the City approximately $4M and the task is to get support from the federal government to assist the City with the re-nourishment. The Beach Task Force would recommend the hotel/motel tax be raised and the additional tax be set aside for future beach re- nourishments as the City needs to be self-sufficient. Mr. Ferrelle would ask mayor and council to get behind the local representatives for their support with future re- nourishments regarding funding from the State. Mayor Buelterman explained that the City has set aside additional funds for the upcoming 2015 re-nourishment. A short discussion ensued regarding the process of raising the hotel/motel tax. Bill O'Brien, Chair, CRC, approached mayor and council to do a presentation on sustainability and cost saving ways for the community in particular with the Tybee Island Police Department vehicles. He discussed the two case studies that were included in the packet: the VW Passat Diesel and the Toyota Prius Hybrid (attached). Mr. O'Brien discussed the concerns regarding alternative vehicles: cost of ownership; maintenance and warranty information; safety; and comfort recommendations. Chief Mike Holman, White Bluff, Tennessee Police Department, approached mayor and council to report on the cost, maintenance and warranty on the Prius. Chief Holman also discussed retrofitting the Prius and cost thereof. A short question and answer period followed. Mayor Buelterman asked for recommendations from mayor and council in regards to the police vehicles. It was decided that they would like more information and to actually see the VW Passat. Ms. Doyle stated she is against obtaining a loan to purchase new vehicles but is not against starting the process to purchase these vehicles. Ms. Fox stated she is not adverse to evaluating two different vehicles for a year and seeing how they perform. Mayor Buelterman stated that this should be discussed during the budget cycle. Citizens to be Heard Jack Rosenberg, Private Parking Lot, 203 14th Street, Tybee Island — Request for more operating days during the tourist season. Mr. Rosenberg approached mayor and council requesting additional days of operation which would include weekends during the summer (Memorial Day to Labor Day weekends). He also distributed a petition showing support for his private parking lot (attached). Mayor Buelterman asked Mr. Hughes if a motion was in order° Mr. Hughes stated that if mayor and council wanted to consider allowing additional days, there would have to be another public hearing which would have to be advertised. Mayor Buelterman suggested that next year, at the time of application and review of the private parking lots, mayor and council consider the application fees. Rich Hammons, approached mayor and council recommending mayor and council afford the local business owners time to work out the logistical and planning issues with the Tybee Island Tourism Council in regards to Pirate Fest. He also asked mayor and council to work with the business owner to make the festival a success. John Yarbrough, Spanky's Restaurant, approached mayor and council to voice his concerns with the current plan for Pirates Festive. He is concerned with the current layout as presented by the Tybee Island Tourism Council and would ask there be no vote taken until such time as the business owners have more time to speak with the tourism council. He along with the other business owners are not in agreement with the current site plan. Mayor Buelterman stated that it is mayor and council's goal to have the event go forward, to be successful and would like the business community to unite and bring their recommendations back to mayor and council. Ms. Fox agreed and recommended the agenda item be tabled until a future date. Mr. Garbett confirmed that the Tybee Island Tourism Council submitted the application for this event and would like to have a recommendation on who is going to be responsible for working with the tourism council to resolve all the issues at hand. Mr. Yarbrough stated that he is more than willing to work with the tourism council for a successful event but there is a lack of communication. Mayor Buelterman stated there is currently an impasse and based on the conversations with mayor and council, they are not willing to vote on this agenda item. Cullen Chambers, t©ard Member, Tybee Tourism Csuncil, approached mayor and council as board member of the Tybee Island Tourism Council. He stated that the tourism council assumed the responsibility for the festival as others were not willing to accept the challenge. He further stated that they were at an impasse with negotiations with the business owners and would ask mayor and council not to table this request but to proceed with the merits of the proposal. Jenny Orr, Marlin's and Fanny's on the Beach, approached mayor and council to recommend that mayor and council not vote on this agenda item as she and other business owners on the south end are not in agreement with the site plan as presented. She would also ask that mayor and council not change the nature of the event, Pirates Festival, to keep it as a festival, Tybee Island Pirates Festival which represents the uniqueness of Tybee Island. Keith Gay, approached mayor and council stating that the board of directors, Tybee Island Tourism Council voted unanimously for the proposed site plan. This plan only has few changes from previously years: (1) to change the basic stage from the round- about to the other end of the parking lot (2) to create a bigger area for the children (3) to create an area for the pirates as an entertainment area and (4) traffic the people down Tybrisa as a way to ensure all the business were included. Mr. Gay does not feel these changes will affect the business owners financially and he would encourage a vote in the positive. Anna Butler, 1212 Butler Adenue, approached mayor and council to speak on the Alley 3 proposed parking plan. She v,.iould ask mayor and council to consider increasing the width of the parking spaces to 10', angled parking, bicycle parking, and a secured area for boat trailers. Mr. Garbett stated there is an area for bicycle parking as did Mr. Wolff. JR Roseberry, approached mayor and council stating he was impressed with the CRC's presentation regarding the police cars. Karen Penick approached mayor and council to speak in favor of the historic preservation ordinance that is on the agenda. She agreed with previous comments on the uniqueness of the Island, how special it is and we need to preserve our Island. Ms. Penick further stated that mayor and council are the guardians and stewards of Tybee Island and they need to protect our Island. Keith Gay approached mayor and council to comment on the trash cans that are on the curb. He would support side door pickup to eliminate trash and recycle containers on the curb. Mr. Gay stated the dump policy for trash is an interesting transition as it deserves consideration and would hope it would be reviewed. Olga Hatjusina approached mayor and council to speak on the Tybee Island Pirates Festival. She agreed there have been communication issues and feels the new site plan will not give any negative impact to the businesses. This is a major event for Tybee Island and the festival needs to be maintained. Lindsay Fruchtl and Heather Gordon, Tybee Tourism Council, approached mayor and council to speak on Tybee Island Pirate Festival. Ms. Fruchtl asked mayor and council if they are planning on tabling this agenda request. Mayor Buelterman responded that a vote has not been taken but based on the sentiment from mayor and council is that there will not be a vote on the request. Mr. Wolff stated he would like to hear the justification for the changes in the site plan. Ms. Fruchtl read a statement regarding Privates Festival and the site plan as presented (attached). Heather Gordon approached mayor and council to further explain the changes in the festival. She explained that the changes came from surveys and feedback received from the business owners and visitors. This information is included in the packet that is before mayor and council tonight. Mr. Wolff thanked both Ms. Fruchtl and Ms. Gordon for aii their hard work with working with the business district to make this festival a success but feels there still are unresolved issues. Mr. Brown asked for clarification of the parking station at the 15th Street parking lot. Ms. Gordon stated that area will be left open for emergency vehicles. Ms. Doyle asked if they have considered where the vendor trucks will be parked. These are very large trucks and will need ample space to park in. Ms. Gordon responded there are staging areas as well as areas at Ocean Plaza where these vehicles can park. Mr. Groover stated that the tourism council is anticipating 5,000 visitors to the festival and do they have a parking plan for that amount of vehicles as north beach parking lot is closed for parade staging. Ms. Gordon stated that back parking spaces have been added from previous years. There will also be a trolley to shuttle people from other parking areas. Ms. Fruchtl again asked mayor and council if their intention is to table this item. Mayor Buelterman responded that yes that is the censuses. Ms. Fruchtl stated that if this item is to be tabled, they would like to withdraw their application. Consideration Local Requests and Applications — Funding, Special Events, Alcohol License Tybee Island Pirate Fest (October 11 — 13): Festival grounds @ 16th Street Lot; Pirate Encampment on beach @16th Street Crossover; Beach Derby from North Beach to 18th Street; Parade from NB lot to Tybrisa Street. Tabled by censuses. Application withdrawn. Consideration of Bids, Contracts, Agreements and Expenditures WastePro proposal for change in service levels and costs — switching from twice weekly garbage pickup to once weekly and/or side door garbage and recycling service. Staff recommends city council approval of a rate change depending of o rvice UoveU decision to reflect recant LO(30© ITEVa contractual increase and a $1.94 charge per customer garbage c rt to recover administrative solid waste fund c•into end complementary senior recycling expense. Mayor Buelterman asked Ms. Schleicher to confirm that a 1.6% rate increase is already in the contract. She confirmed and further explained that the $1.95 charge would cover the administrative costs that have not been covered in the past and also the complimentary recycling for seniors that the City offers. Ms. Fox asked why the administrative costs increased to the level it did. Ms. Schleicher stated that it includes the salary that is attributed to billing and collecting which is approximately $38,000. Mayor Buelterman stated it will be hard to look at an increase for other services when the City is looking at a 1.6% increase plus $1.94. Ms. Fox stated that there might be another consideration if the City were to go to once a week collection on the garbage then the rates for the commercial accounts will increase by $7.00. Fran Plyler, SC Market Development Manager, WastePro, approached mayor and council to answer any questions or concerns. Ms. Fox asked Ms. Plyler to explain the increase, i.e., if residential pickup goes to once a week for garbage then the commercial accounts will increase to $30.00 per unit, per cart, per month from $23.:3. Ms. Plyler responded the increase is only if you include side door service for everyone. The impact if side door pick up is not included would be $26.05 for commercial accounts. Mayor Buelterman asked if recycling was once a week currently. Ms. Plyler stated that two weeks ago once a week recycling pickup started. She did apologize for the misunderstanding with the pickup schedule. Ms. Schleicher stated that the cost of the senior program is $2,000 per month and that is passed on to the non-senior residents. Also, the administrative costs are $3,000 per month which is also being passed on the residents. She would further recommend that the sir charged be passed on to the residents that have garbage pickup as an incentive to recycle. Ms. Fox asked Ms. Schleicher how much money the City receives from recycling. Ms. Plyler responded $10.00 per ton per recycling rebate. Mr. Groover asked Ms. Plyler to explain what side door pickup includes, i.e., how far out from the house does he containers have to be. She responded that it is not common practices for WastePro employees go into the residents' personal area and that the containers will still have to be moved. Co00 Garbett made a motion to approve the 1.6% rate contractual increase. Wan Cloyle seconded. Vote was unanimous. Jan Fox made a motion to add $1.00 administrative charge per customer per garbage cart and re-evaluate rate in six months. Paul Wolff seconded. Vote was unanimous. Paul Wolff made a motion to leave side door pickup optional. Tom Groover seconded. Discussion: Mr. Groover asked for the results of the recent survey. Mayor Buelterman stated it was inconclusive. Ms. Fox remarked that in the comments section there was strong anti- side door pickup opinion. Ms. Doyle explained that in neighboring communities there were issues with placement of the containers after they were emptied along with vandalism under the carports due to the location of their container. Mr. Brown asked Ms. Plyler how long it takes their employees to cover pick-up for all the residents. She stated that the trucks should be off the Island by 5:00PM but in the peak season it might be later. There was a discussion regarding the time frame in which the containers are taken and removed from the curb. Ms. Doyle reminded eve y one there is an ordinance that outlines the procedure. Voting in favor were Paul Wolff, Jan Fox, Tom Groover, Wanda Doyle and Bill Garbett. Voting against was Barry Brown. Motion carried 5-1. Jan Fox made a motion to keep twice a week pick-up for garbage. Barry Brown seconded. '''iscussion: Mr. Brown stated his concerns regarding the odor during the summer months with one a week pick-up. Ms. Fox stated that is her concern also and that is why she made the motion as stated. Mr. Wolff asked Ms. Plyler is recycling continues to increase will WastePro provide adequate service. She replied yes. Voting in favor were Tom Groover, Jan Fox, Barry Brown and Bill Garbett. Voting against was Paul Wolff and Wanda Doyle. Motion carried 4-2. Discussion: Ms. Schleicher added she would like to address Mr. Gay's concerns regarding pick-up of bulky items by WastePro. She stated that residents can take these items to the transition area on a complimentary basis but businesses may not. Mr. Brown asked Mr. Hughes if the City could refuse to let businesses use the transition area. Mr. Hughes confirmed and further stated the City could draw a distinction between residential use for residential only purposes, residential use for commercial and is a legitimate distinction. Alley 3: Proposed improvement by DPW of road surgace ETSEu parking spaces in city rights of way and creation of a turnaround area. Estimated cost is $70,000. Parking Committee recommended plan 2-1. Budget Line Item: TBD in FY14 budget. Mayor Buelterman asked Ms. Schleicher what mayor and council would actually be approving. Ms. Schleicher stated she would like mayor and council to review the parking layout and in turn it would then be included in the budget cycle. Ms. Doyle stated she is in agreement with widening the parking spaces to 10' x 20'. Mr. Garbett would disagree. Paul Wolff made a motion to approve with the exception of widening the 90° parking spaces to 10'. Wanda Doyle seconded. Discussion: Mr. Wolff stated he has spoken too many of the individuals that use this area so as to ease their concerns. Mr. Groover stated that the parallel parking on the west side is a hazard. He would recommend that the parallel parking spaces be removed and have DPW install something that will protect the planters on that side of the street. Ms. Schleicher reminded mayor and council that this project is contingent upon budgeting. Voting in favor were Paul Wolff, Jan Fox, Wanda Doyle and Bill Garbett. Voting against were Barry Brown and Tom Groover. Motion carried 4-2. Paul Wolff made a motion to approve the consent agenda. Tom ero©ver seconded. Vote was unanimous. Consideration of Ordinances and Resolutions Second Reading, 16-2013, Historic Preservation. Paul Wolff made a motion to approve. Bill Garbett seconded. Discussion: Ms. Fox stated that she had been in contact with Cullen Chambers in order to include the proper language. She would ask that this not be voted on until she has had time to include Mr. Chambers Language in the ordinance. Ms. Doyle recommended that Ms. Fox be given the time to rework the language and would like it moved to the June 3rd meeting. Mr. Brown agreed. Paul Wolff withdrew his motion. Bill Garbett withdrew his second. Paul Wolff made a motion to continue until the city council meeting on June 3, 2013. Bill Garbett seconded. Vote was unanimous. Discussion: Mr. Chambers approached mayor and council stating his concerns regarding individuals who apply for a permit as once approved, change the scope entirely from the approved permit. He would ask that individuals respect the rules as intended and as written. Second Reading, 17-2013, Footings. Wanda DoyUa made a motion to approve. Paul Wolff seconded. Vote was unanimous. Second Reading, 18, Angled Parking. Wanda Doyle made a motion to approve. Tom Groover seconded. Vote was unanimous. Second Reading, 19-2013, Kitchen. Paul Wolff made a motion to approve. Tom Groover seconded. Vote was unanimous. Council, Officials and City Attorney Considerations and Comments Jason Buelterman Use of SPLOST fund for beach bathhouse. Mayor Buelterman stated he would like to seriously think about 2008 SPLOST funds for a beach bathhouse at north beach as he feels the City needs to improve the bathhouse situation on the Island. He recommended this bathhouse be full size and fully equipped with children's changing tables and such amenities as other beach communities. Mr. Brown suggested that the new Marine Science Building might incorporate a bathhouse with their design. Ms. Fox recommended this be forwarded to the Infrastructure Committee for their recommendations. Mr. Wolff requested Ms. Schleicher approach the engineers for the Marine Science Building and get their recommendations as well. She agreed. Wanda Doyle Status of 142 Lewis. Ms. Schleicher explained the RFP's are due Friday, May 24, 2013 and once reviewed she will bring to the June 13, 2013 city council meeting for their recommendation. Public Safety Building. Ms. Doyle reported the Public Safety Committee met and there are three items she would like to bring to mayor and council's attention: (1) recommend the shooting range be eliminated from the plan; (2) the RPF for the Construction Manager at Risk position will be posted; and (3) issues with the survey and an update to reflect the proper elevations. Review of Section 66-148. Ms. Doyle requested Mr. Hughes review the ordnance as it outdated. She discussed her recommendations with mayor and council and Mr. Hughes agreed he would review. Ms. Fox stated she would like the internal controls reviewed as well as updating for the pay and display meters. Tom Groover Purchase of a mat at 7th, Street crossover. Mr. Groover stated that the residents on 7th Street approached him regarding access to the beach. The soft sand makes it difficult to them to get to the beach. Mr. Groover did discuss matting with Ms. Schleicher and she was able to find an economical solution. He would ask mayor and council to approve the $393.00 purchase. This matting is DNR approved as it is permeable and they are willing to give the City a Letter of Permission (LOP) for this matting. Mr. Brown asked Ms. Schleicher is this something that could be used at other crossovers on the beach. She confirmed and explained the City would be required to get a LOP from DNR for each instance. Jan Fox A city council committee to consider financial policy issues facing the My and make recommendation. Withdrawn Audit. Ms. Fox stated that in 2011 when the audit report was sent to the State, it was originally rejected and the correspondence was sent to the City of Tybee Island. These letters were also sent to the auditors at which time they made corrections. She further stated that the audit the City has been working from is not the corrected audit. She would like everyone to be aware that there was an audit committee at that time and they should have been given copies of that correspondence so they could have followed up as it is their responsibility. Mr. Groover stated that a correction that was made on April 24th by Resnick was disapproved by the State. Ms. Fox requested of Mr. Groover that the Audit Committee meet more than once a quarter. Mr. Groover responded that the Audit Committee will meet anytime and they are waiting on guidance from mayor and council. Ms. Doyle added that mayor and council directed the Audit Committee to review the internal control policy and procedures for the Finance Department. Mr. Groover would recommend that mayor and council formally outline the duties of the Audit Committee. He also feels they are a valuable asset to the City and they are not being utilized. Mr. Garbett asked Ms. Fox what would be her recommendations to the Audit Committee. She responded that mayor and council request the Audit Committee to review policies and procedures, internal controls and to meet more frequently, possibly monthly. Mr. Wolff agreed. Jan Fox made a motion that the Audit Committee review policies and procedures, internal controls and to meet more at least once a month. Barry Brown seconded. Vote was unanimous. Bubba Hughes Southeast Corrections contract. Mr. Hughes stated this was before mayor and council for ratification as it was previously approved but not fully executed. The Clerk will need to execute the contract. Supplement to the contract with Alton Brown, Sat Meadows. Mr. Hughes stated this will update Mr. Brown's consulting contract. City Managers Report • Action Item List • Short Term Work Program Paul Wolff made a motion to adjourn to Executive Session to discuss litigation and personnel. Tom Groover seconded. Vote was unanimous Paul Wolff made a motion to return to regular session. Tom Groover seconded. Vote was unanimous. Paul Wolff made a motion to adjourn. Tom Groover seconded. Vote was unanimous. Meeting adjourned at 10:50PM We realize there have been many discussions around the island regarding the planning and management of Pirate Fest. We are here to help answer any questions and correct any misconceptions. We understand that Pirate Fest has a significant economic impact to the island during the shoulder season. In fact, it has been determined to represent more than $2.3 million being brought onto the island over that weekend. From a management perspective, Pirate Fest is not currently sustainable. It is imperative that we evaluate how to grow the festival and attract more visitors. In response to this need, the Tourism Council has reviewed feedback from visitors and Tybee businesses to design what we strongly believe will be an improved site plan leading to a more successful event. We have listened to the concerns shared with us from the business community and have made a number of adjustments to our plans in response to those concerns. We have also met with event sponsor, Southern Eagle, and implemented some of their recommendations. Ultimately, the TITC board, made of Tybee business owners, believes that the proposed layout will be the most beneficial to the continued success of the festival. Our ultimate goal is to provide an improved visitor experience so that the festival can continue to be a major stimulus to Tybee businesses. Lindsay Fruchtl Marketing Director Visit Tybee P: 912.644.6470 F: 912.786.5895 M: 912.220.3428 VisitTybee.com Jack Rosenberg, File No. 851 Jack Rosenberg <jackrosenberg2©gmail.com> t-0-0. �e,2 Thu, May 23, 2013 at 2:36 PM To: Bubba Hughes <bhughes©cbrhlaw.com> C) f Zoi� v4�l s j) Bubba, As you may know I am speaking at the Council meeting tonight regarding the parking issue at Tybee. I hope that this can be worked out like the off site advertising issue. This has to do with me/us being restricted to$ ays of parking while others are not. It DOES raise equal protection and failing to folio the ordinance and many issues in a big way. 1. We are being charged a fee of g g $200 for 45.days of parking, while others have the same fee and unlimited days of parking. This"fee"then becomes an improper"tax" meant not for services but to treat us differently. 2. The ordinance specifies that the Council has the right to put "reasonable" conditions on parking. You opined at the meeting that included days of operation. You may or may not be right, as "days" are not specified in the ordinance. Once we are approved and we are legal, we are good to go and days may or may not be an appropriate condition. My lot is on 14th St., ground zero for traffic in a semi-commercial area. Apartments abound and landlords are allowed to have their tenants park on City ROW. People parking on my property, I call the city and they say to call towing, I call towing and they say they can't tow on private property. During orange crush my property was covered with cars. Yet I was treated like the others who may be in more residential areas. It is only fair that I have parking to make up_for all these headaches. However, in my case, I had/ neighbors sign a petition AND my two abutting neighbors (including one that came to the hearing and was recognized) who said they had NO problem with our lot. Therefore, clearly in my case I was not treated separately and "the baby thrown out with the bath water." 3. The city is allowing paid private parking lots in residential areas ALREADY in violation of the ordinance. Landlords are allowed to have their parking on City ROW unsubsidized and with no restrictions. On weekends, the house across from me has 10 (ten) vehicles parking in front AND in city ROW. Further, countless homes and their owners are parking on city ROW FREE and in violation of ordinances, but this is NOT being enforced. This is an equal protection issue. Therefore, clearly I could start renting my house for"day changing/day rental" and give "free parking". This is only going to cause more issues. The city will have to deal with hundreds of landlords/homes who are parking illegally in the ROW. For the good of all, we just need one council member/mayor to see the contradictions in the code, and realize that the way to settle this is to compromise. Simply allow us weekends between Memorial Day and Labor Day. That is all we want. We are not asking for the world, and we don't want a fight. This does not have to be a federal case. Please talk to your client and let's work this out reasonably. With best regards, Jack Rosenberg Attorney-Mediator Labor& Employment/Discrimination Law Overtime/FLSA, Unemployment Appeals Suite 53 --., 4:. . , . .. • ,, ;',..,.. . ... ,-,t... w Apt- -- ' 't'''''-'*,4'.;•!'--"-::::::'4;Af-'-'4.: - Ai,. ' 1,-- - -_, AA - a , a , '',:t.. k - 4 i I.• , . 4 .. ,r_ ' :* . -..,,,,,,,,•••,,,,,,,,.5,..f.,,,...;,,A,,,,,,,..011.,,, „...,- . ,........„... ..",." 1 ,. , „ ‘ t..., fi.,.>".-!:, _AW:,1.5.",";;-: t',"-'4.-..„-`4"!;'''''''-',- , - '''',ot''' °-= 'N•,' i' 1°, 4!'"' ‘I ', A I :' '-•, . _ ,• 1. t , ,A "ct*...4't'/:,'' •''',:"..`:;A:4'."-.‘"44''',1;;":„.-. :-'i,14,',-;t..:,,et,".. ' , I . ^-ty,-.,`,--i-ig•.11- .-.;„$2,,,,,,i,ir:„i,:ii..‘$'.,..??,':..‘',.'..'''' .... -,-.I ' t i 1 , ' 1 -(';''l'''''''''-:"',„.;-',-(',',4'.:','-,,',,f, ,„, - - - . , i 'r ,,,,,,, ' •I'l ,."'" '. -** ' ' t .. s la' I ; -.,,,,V.'"'"'V'lli,,,:4;g:;,','....7 ,' ' •' 41 ' ,..."... ..7-t..f,t?",,,,4,■..:',.....,,,..,,, ,., ,; ' ., ' i ::.,..1.0,1Ste;:--k ,., ; 41ip , [ -, '-'-‘,:•.4.1.„,:i.- „, 41 .. „.',.. ....".,-,...)--4:-•,,,,.:. 4,-,,T... ., , , ''fi''' ''''' ' „, - 1 ..,I” ''''':,, - ',,-, ,''' ' "A-t5';'' '" - ' '• \ , , , -,,,, -,;.•Al•-',. :4-.-•.!;,?. 1 - .•-•,,,"..,-.:,..,.izt• . III, - ,, 1 -41,, ...,....-z.... ,,,, ,,i,,,,-",,-..! • -. •,...,,,,n,,,..:f.,..„,,,„ ,,, i., 1 ,.. : ; •:.,=•...., I •-• .,4 .‘• 4 - . _ • - 4 ..,„,,,mw„, , :, ` • ' ..... , U...,..„. ,,, .„ •,..„ ... , . , .. .- , \ ,„„,. •i :i ,- ,14 ''''- '-, 1 . I 4/ ' .,-'•:'''''''; . *'.' . ■ ' . 44, ,' -7: * -4„, ,„ 77 T , 1 ,,,,- 1- .„,„ ' -4 - ,... , . - ,..... ....„,„:„.....„ . __„ , , M. .. - -----!, i„, . ,. ..'., , 1 -1 y(` 8 :r y :i a 1 et.0 � , J t - i . ,ce IL i b ': .� x. /7--- Mq� f hear m.k t� 1 ER j t yy aL " .:. i 1 .,1:1:':. _..• ' 'r I ;7i.---n Ywy r 4 Ti . .�. Fri � A r.., 0 -.1;, w 1A+r '-.=_'.'',-:;,'-:''-;,f'::,7q:ift''...*'ttk&je.Mi,?.i14*,iiAiv'tAttoffXi,te:4itio,,t-ue m�°i; - alp '.- is" .3,' .K Its 'j■ 1 .mss" 'x"x °B µay: February, 2013 To: City Council of the City of Tybee Island, Georgia Re: Rosenberg Private Parking Lot at 203 14th Street, Tybee Island, Georgia We support the Rosenberg's and the renewal of their license for their private parking lot at 203 14th Street. SIGNATURE NAME(PRINT) ADDRESS ,V,/lx-je 0 6asireir 2)161 To iogc i gout/td J i L -- t'rit ,----) ,-cy ----( -_-. -"KCA-rKe 0,1■1.-rYeej /_____/\(, t i vtlk-, noraiL2t) , m 7 5/- _ ,./- '--/ -col ..2 -ra- 'Y'Y -.6) (s2j --u 4.(AC- Shoomoo '%oci/ill&-,o._ /L/0 5 (-- . t/i(VjavviC 7_,104 - t_LA-e- IOD3 I 'Al .117:51cduil (--- I FD U ;I ler:- L *---_b i . WA COOV IA ( }( 1 iCA (1 frOALL--- 0-1 i COttnion N i _ iri'( -7"kci'D* (ji,opcif: e._ 2J: W a vyLs ) k)--oHl lir)Nies I.Je- 0 1 I au.?, 1,40 Froyeo ii.) iit, ,1- vd -I fk W i i d- 41 - c,ok ....-3-, we----1- Cock .,,,w I 1 0 / ../ i # ;4 3-0a 7 /71/'/a,cty i4/1)(A/j/(2.//7 4/;Ce X /7/J7L5CA _d-- itg".C.,'' , , ----- /AA 4 1 1 I S • 'N\\k M f L)(\ L e-.e._ ,1 \.-(Rsdi i 601. 1,va Aue . February, 2013 To: City Council of the City of Tybee Island, Georgia Re: Rosenberg Private Parking Lot at 203 14th Street, Tybee Island, Georgia We support the Rosenberg's and the renewal of their license for their private parking lot at 203 14th Street. SIGNATURE NAME(PRINT) ADDRESS (A) j---,—c A6ut,- 1,--P) aN - rz- , w\ \ -tot < k ce\- \N &J- \r----------- \-1WASA*AJkkAki 1./1 1A-c-V■ <1'.(A-S e-- 613c0-A-:k-e-14-in-A-S__ &^-- , c'd.fZe R id 61 111 1A13 ..)-1W11-- (Zen. ksdev '72occA, ugsd /3/3 a eve l--)rcsz_ Ceii\FI' �� 'tip` '"1-: -(2t 2- 643gy L, QI)/Ok' -:\ 'j 0 go 3- 1, 1--)- IDA1 ..>Z7-7 / 7, U 0 1\ -4q- PV('- / 1-06 ✓ - ,0 ) t4 �� � �° 1%1/4,d ,,A, V erVii" 7 /ft S1 fie€ C , e/;__) _7----- - 4:1;c; ; C Z/ - / i) I i "/ ' 11''L-45 / ( / 2' A eiJA, e-06--E i i 1l X.U.)-ZV - o lJ v u3 E 5 1Lk.oa, 2, A ve ..2-4 /9z__- .-k>/-(- P,A4144-6vvs (,)„,04- ifio e rr -,l-ti 1)(;)40irCI-esk. e (- k b)k- lj 7,06 A (J t MAIN February, 2013 To: City Council of the City of Tybee Island, Georgia Re: Rosenberg Private Parking Lot at 203 14th Street, Tybee Island, Georgia We are next door neighbors to the Rosenberg's and their private parking lot at 203 14th Street. They have always been good neighbors,respectful in their operation of the parking lot, and we support their annual renewal for a business license. Sincerely, Irene and Ronnie Brown 6ira Hoy 2 /c , 5 Year Ownership Cost Breakdown Dodge Charger V6 3.6L SE Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 5 YEAR TOTAL£ Maintenance $97 $321 $466 $1,044 $362 $2,290 Repairs $0 $0 $114 $247 $273 $634 Fuel $2,246 $2,311 $2,378 $2,447 $2,518 $11,900 Depreciation $9,042 $2,436 $2,312 $2,129 $1,701 $17,620 g $1,019 $807 $587 $367 $131 $2,9 in $1,872 $1,872 $1,872 $1,872 $1,872 $9,360 ,State Fees $128 $86 $85 $79 $79 $457 Yearly otals Y $14,404 $7,833 $7,814 $8,185 $6,936 $45,172 1 5-Year Cost of Similar Vehicles $43,146 Difference $2,026 Click here to check rebates/incentives that also affect overall ownership costs. Poor 'Value Rating Read more: http://www.motortrend.com/cars/2013/dodge/charger/cost_of ownership/#ixzz2U9huv6za FUELLY All Cars It Dodge )9 Charger :1 MIS:US 1 tiK uTOOkrolkyvt. Dr,--it,c-,,, ,----r, 1.,,,,.--1c,.,.., - __., , ::-. c„,.,,T .... - ... „ : , , , ,:,, FAR ! There are 99 Dodge Chargers(Gas V8 Sedan)with reported gas mileage parked at Fuelly. 'show at About ; Fiter:3. I Gas V8(104) :1 -N.:- I Sedan(200) LI applyllter FAQ I 25 i . 7 41' 20 Browse Vehicles Tips , , (13_71i 21 Forum , E 'r. , = 5 . h 0 num wawa dam 11111 111 ,.,.. .: ONWP OWN Sign Up 6 7 12 IS' 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 30 * (211 Tacon kierage MPG Log in (19_911 v..,. ,..-.•— ....— -,-----,“%r -....-;-- ;VENT ,:.k,•.6----,,J,.: '4 - - '''-"I;^- 8701 Pbercom StSavannah GA31406 i::: 414 :.- , 1 A. '?l° ' Tacon The New 2013 Dodge Charger 17 . 7 3 Cars 33 Fuel-Ups 9,429 1 Mites Tracked VIE,°, 41 A:..tg ICPG VIEW ALL -_, --' "-_" 17_ ..;. r. ,,,,°-'-..--..,-'' .. "-,,,, . J11 .1 I '''; 'l''''''. .Z.„ •' . - P C- .5e:-. ■I;t ' •• . e---; = 6,1 Save ......--- „, WI Oper 16 . 8 10 277 67,306 Cars Fuel-Ups mi , te s Tracked Li Copy ,,, Send Thursday, May 23, 2013 6:10:53 PM - Buying or Leasing a New Car? PRIC d. IEQUOTES.COM Find the Dealer in Your Area with the Lowest Price. wept.' IIIMIIIIIIIIIpplo. Soled a Make: Select v Select a Model:I Select ■ j npcode: i Continue 4111% FUELLY All Cars a Dodge x.Charger t TOYOTA CNA ' 7 Pa Of Comte anks US,k,' ' *"''''' '- ..- '''... -..‘ - The New 2013 Toy There are 68 Dodge Chargers (Gas V6 Sedan)with reported as mileage parked at Fuelly About i :..,1 Gas V6(68) 1.1 --,- I Sedan(200) ] applyfilter I , 12 ,...44., -,0i......;:i....r., FAQ 7.7. . Browse Vehicles 2 8 Tips ,... 6 o I I Forum .,.... __ ,, ,,......,, o I z 4 Visit website or ce E - a I = SOO W Mtle ' aim Sign Up 14 15 16 17 1-0 19 20 21 22 25 24 25 2€ 27 Average MPG Log In iOV - , tOER ION' (13.7 MPG) --- ; ENT , „.. fire - t. - , ,. 8701 Abeream at Savannah GA314015 (21.1 MPG) The New 2013 Dodge Charger 21 2 5 58 Cars ' Fuel-Ups 17 997 al Miles Tracked (19.9 MPG) ' A t.=P,...; ViEW ALL fueled-u ---I---\ "--'-':--:- - 1 ar•-:.)wta. ' -- , 2012 „ ,„, -_,, _ , .____. .,„, . .- -__'. -:--- (29.2 MPG) npf..."14- ,,. - , .:-.-::..-...„ .,:1-4' F.,,,84,SI tC'81 1 ' 1 frai I 1--4, i Thursday, May 23, 2013 6:09:45 PM - Untitled 1 - LibreOffice Writer _,... + , •<.s 'aptr,,:,:-snet-nese -.2,---.A- ____ 7zr, --;:,-,7 *Atitt* _ ip. C a_iii s• rMax is now open in Savannah! SIX° -/ , On Abercorn S.at Montgomery Cross Rd. FUELLY _ ...... _..... Ali Cars))Voks,hager,))Passat Nivat TOYOTA CHA ., 7 Park of Comm -...., The New 2013 To There are 630 Volkswagen Passats(Diesel L4 Sedan)with reported gas mileage parked at Fuelly. Fgt.c e„,sir, About Diesel L4(758) z.1 ,,,: I Sedan(913) :_l apply filter I .oitri 'A , ^ FAQ so 3 7— c)-- fvri°(1- —=—.• `-,t'cr Browse Vehicles 2 ...' '',.''''', •`4' b`u ., r _c ill retYV --Z.1 b AI) , Tips 31 r- -.,- :, .41' ., -1 t4.0 ' t ''', •.^.',,ii ''''.' Forum visit website or c, 82: •,n :cl, Sign Up ---- ,C1 —2; 5'0' 31 32 33 34 3S 36 37 33 39 40 41 42 43, 44 45 46 47 45 45 53 3' 52 55 58 Log In Average MPG -:. fueled-up DOVER =fa/ENT , . ..,...y.'";7- - ' ,,T; add' 8701 Abercorn St Savannah GA 3142'6 ~4,....---z._- ...:_i7.-..i,. .- .: ... taio .s._ his garage. • Used 2010 11:111 1 .. ,ti...*' -.. — -- ''' , Honda Accord • (28.5 MPG) `1:'-iw;i'-'', --;•,le",'t,t,!! 7_3 MPG) .__.,.,....,...,,...„.... „,., o.„--,„ 40 . 257 3 Cars ! , )594 1 ,941 ,75 (2 Fuel-Ups Mites Tracked -, ----.added garage. ■ .1 i p.......ot tfr.4.1341 ,, ......_ ,_ . .1,,i, ,-- -,,,,: 4.7+,..-40.. --';'-' -• -- -4,1,- - ..,.4'.. .7,7-71"-7 '- -,.fueled--1 1 0°4 )4°' - '-t— ,-.4-4, 4-, ' . '''-1155.-L. -• - '' ":m",,, ,V.,'.4-,-,‘,--''''',- : ;` ,:..; kj2''"'"'-'7-77 C r -11 .--:'-- 21 ''' 7.4 -.-- •--,z— ' , -. ...alabigie (44A MPG) 11 .,-'----- Thursday, May 23, 2013 5:24:34 PM - Program Manager tittitt* di& acrt a-- Car Max is now open in Savannah! f, Or,Abercorri St. at Montgomery Cross Rd_ Search Now FUELLY All Cars 0 Toyota o Prius u:T-.,-,.. us „Ig :5114 There are 680 Toyota Prii(Hybrid H4 Hatchback)with reported gas mileage parked at Fuelly ,stic-v.g ail About I Hybrid H4(685) zi -!..:: I Hatchback(1957)..11 apply filter I SO FAQ 6,5 q 14— ,c-O PI Of .f. ID . . , 60 Browse Vehicles i 1 INIC_Cf" --1 ti Tips 1 40 .- VV i .In Forum . 20 --, Z . , (30 , Sign Up 33 39 43 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 43 49 53 51 -52 53 54 55 56 57 56 59 60 F..' 62 _ Average MPG Log In AdChoices CI> Fusion vs. Civic , i• ', 7: '''''"‘" , Z-',-r: -,-.;.1..-- --- 6 - dor,- - „... .... 1-c-ict a c o ni ford_fus -- ■''`- ‘ '' Ai ,-.._ 1 V 0,...' ,-4,..,;t1204 (40 Compare the Civic Hybridto a Fusion.View Prices& . Photos Today! 56 425 154 551 (32 Toyota Prius si Cars Fuel-Ups Miles Tracked Clearance A,,A,g m PG VIE,V ALL Tc:ota-0e3r3loe. utosit Massive Prius Sale Going on Now.—Internet Price ,....077-..,.j;- -;..z.,:.; ; i,.,. ,..,.;-,. ,a, .J,771. .:r,.;..7.7 ',--1,-,1,-,-:`,‘ --r, ,, ; - 4 , .o.4N.--;,.'. Cuts WI our Site r.:;:: __,,„0 '" nom. ::-'7‘; ,-Altr" ' New Toyota Prius C 4:. 7 12; Prir.ec Thursday, May 23, 2013 5:28:05 PM -Toyota Prius MPG Reports I Fuelly